text
string
source
string
embeddings
list
Given the recent advances with image-generating algorithms, deep image completion methods have made significant progress. However, state-of-art methods typically provide poor cross-scene generalization, and generated masked areas often contain blurry artifacts. Predictive filtering is a method for restoring images, which predicts the most effective kernels based on the input scene. Motivated by this approach, we address image completion as a filtering problem. Deep feature-level semantic filtering is introduced to fill in missing information, while preserving local structure and generating visually realistic content. In particular, a Dual-path Cooperative Filtering (DCF) model is proposed, where one path predicts dynamic kernels, and the other path extracts multi-level features by using Fast Fourier Convolution to yield semantically coherent reconstructions. Experiments on three challenging image completion datasets show that our proposed DCF outperforms state-of-art methods.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00379v1
[ -0.027834158390760422, -0.03914050757884979, 0.0007650286424905062, 0.01694560796022415, -0.026546601206064224, -0.04290138557553291, 0.021735312417149544, 0.01713099144399166, -0.0017801346257328987, -0.01758136972784996, -0.025996629148721695, 0.0017725637881085277, 0.007472196128219366, 0.01100852619856596, -0.03871499001979828, -0.008456162177026272, 0.07630366832017899, -0.03965399041771889, -0.033605292439460754, 0.07486435025930405, -0.0013567779678851366, 0.017943765968084335, -0.0279938206076622, 0.046779707074165344, 0.04227554798126221, 0.009307860396802425, -0.08292590081691742, 0.03962717577815056, -0.0456017442047596, -0.02476481907069683, 0.061929766088724136, -0.01557070016860962, -0.007128676865249872, -0.05188530310988426, -0.0269708763808012, 0.012538307346403599, -0.015700984746217728, 0.02580183371901512, 0.009482288733124733, -0.05461293086409569, 0.05266846343874931, -0.04096599295735359, -0.06524164974689484, -0.016575200483202934, -0.04200631380081177, -0.0008419275982305408, -0.00723801925778389, 0.0047381240874528885, -0.06660888344049454, -0.026583537459373474, 0.03236152604222298, -0.03390742838382721, -0.0401727557182312, 0.02558792755007744, -0.023305797949433327, -0.02722230553627014, -0.031487513333559036, 0.008752843365073204, -0.0529952235519886, -0.011551490053534508, 0.006617649924010038, -0.013362518511712551, -0.02050698734819889, -0.04402606934309006, 0.007068725768476725, 0.056822340935468674, 0.01044820062816143, -0.07021496444940567, -0.0465591624379158, -0.02860957756638527, 0.04409557580947876, -0.05511065945029259, 0.02279539592564106, 0.03422235697507858, -0.05289812386035919, -0.01871112734079361, -0.024914700537919998, -0.0024292576126754284, 0.0018071490339934826, -0.004578080493956804, 0.004423969890922308, 0.03493262827396393, 0.012312452308833599, 0.03683938458561897, -0.038490597158670425, 0.01253552921116352, 0.06677917391061783, -0.025631800293922424, 0.018785415217280388, -0.05731027573347092, 0.016448097303509712, -0.045318085700273514, -0.0401647575199604, 0.00980015005916357, 0.023119114339351654, -0.04580974206328392, 0.06516671925783157, 0.0327245257794857, 0.02165893092751503, 0.019757971167564392, -0.019532812759280205, -0.038516413420438766, -0.050347767770290375, 0.0024097952991724014, 0.02008306235074997, -0.011395874433219433, -0.0029665902256965637, -0.003863486461341381, -0.02117440290749073, -0.0019439613679423928, -0.01664121448993683, 0.008980895392596722, -0.028325164690613747, -0.044938646256923676, -0.008266616612672806, -0.02200615033507347, 0.06393255293369293, -0.006309250369668007, 0.015244021080434322, 0.01084968727082014, 0.0033614286221563816, 0.023148804903030396, 0.05060902610421181, -0.04917874559760094, -0.03929158300161362, -0.041193537414073944, 0.05574772506952286, 0.003508908674120903, 0.0021007598843425512, -0.04009367898106575, -0.034095462411642075, 0.0350705049932003, -0.011426184326410294, -0.03166908398270607, 0.07012780755758286, 0.024585416540503502, -0.009541267529129982, -0.04737125709652901, -0.007093881256878376, 0.020642930641770363, -0.004080081358551979, -0.06337178498506546, 0.027511008083820343, -0.030209947377443314, 0.000734717701561749, 0.06145195662975311, -0.0474831648170948, -0.04209843650460243, 0.012491492554545403, 0.021925846114754677, -0.0037772494833916426, 0.020791124552488327, 0.030290232971310616, 0.010667771100997925, -0.027798498049378395, -0.004920689854770899, 0.0611317977309227, 0.005061047617346048, -0.04470382258296013, 0.030994921922683716, -0.02027747966349125, -0.06229810044169426, 0.04087401553988457, 0.004601480904966593, 0.016371475532650948, -0.003977709915488958, 0.012930560857057571, 0.00559630012139678, 0.02521429769694805, 0.022075504064559937, -0.026454610750079155, -0.034571096301078796, -0.016412585973739624, -0.040493447333574295, -0.022845087572932243, -0.020245041698217392, -0.024575909599661827, -0.07021581381559372, -0.047194380313158035, -0.0150900324806571, -0.029661111533641815, 0.027409104630351067, -0.015269476920366287, -0.04885539039969444, -0.05673831328749657, -0.03858035057783127, -0.0886988416314125, -0.01952565461397171, 0.03341370075941086, 0.020826751366257668, -0.0632597953081131, -0.009208455681800842, 0.007611165288835764, 0.020420318469405174, -0.05837610363960266, -0.05324488878250122, 0.003059397917240858, -0.05216914787888527, -0.014835720881819725, 0.03683876246213913, -0.09052419662475586, -0.061311736702919006, -0.0627216100692749, 0.036354757845401764, 0.014521312899887562, -0.03387947380542755, 0.005620686803013086, 0.03848324716091156, -0.06001387536525726, 0.010926583781838417, 0.06360404938459396, 0.0497736781835556, 0.07829886674880981, -0.017099177464842796, 0.046714331954717636, 0.033813685178756714, -0.09344718605279922, 0.0035170174669474363, 0.004556199070066214, 0.0003642764640972018, 0.009353638626635075, 0.018042540177702904, -0.02849963866174221, -0.06672094017267227, -0.04755467548966408, 0.04759214445948601, 0.06737375259399414, -0.022776657715439796, -0.045711468905210495, -0.022197309881448746, -0.011018456891179085, -0.05073227733373642, -0.009910579770803452, -0.06741165369749069, -0.03416859731078148, -0.014631611295044422, -0.031017014756798744, 0.05619559437036514, 0.00821258407086134, -0.043685995042324066, -0.04695427045226097, 0.024883218109607697, 0.04294198006391525, -0.02079424075782299, -0.020356157794594765, -0.007181928027421236, 0.018485700711607933, 0.026954639703035355, -0.0018186738016083837, -0.02797248773276806, -0.04597529023885727, -0.06539382040500641, -0.01671196147799492, 0.02980511263012886, 0.018623240292072296, 0.055512942373752594, -0.010046493262052536, 0.014542892575263977, -0.045356955379247665, 0.06193770095705986, 0.03171524032950401, 0.008845949545502663, -0.03063121810555458, 0.04699161276221275, 0.014223678968846798, 0.026549343019723892, 0.025398390367627144, -0.005817898083478212, 0.007827211171388626, -0.04074632003903389, -0.04245823621749878, 0.054871074855327606, -0.007923249155282974, 0.03203345462679863, 0.022180574014782906, -0.04040038585662842, -0.029460027813911438, -0.01964244432747364, 0.031819019466638565, 0.049805622547864914, -0.00022733263904228806, 0.005558484699577093, -0.02678276225924492, -0.0584464967250824, 0.04418906942009926, -0.03613144904375076, 0.007299812510609627, -0.06036936119198799, -0.0662059336900711, -0.0394866019487381, -0.07661900669336319, -0.042414020746946335, -0.06044437736272812, -0.049355991184711456, 0.006922955624759197, -0.012951659969985485, -0.04884372279047966, -0.023011624813079834, 0.031117895618081093, 0.0053518894128501415, -0.04016783460974693, -0.06496372073888779, 0.048793502151966095, 0.019265631213784218, -0.0034279655665159225, -0.057751357555389404, -0.07797576487064362, 0.0021443881560117006, -0.00746455043554306, -0.0515698678791523, -0.026541534811258316, 0.036169733852148056, -0.01510422769933939, 0.05778418481349945, 0.03546084091067314, 0.03605418652296066, 0.021160252392292023, 0.008422065526247025, -0.001237370539456606, 0.02562543749809265, 0.0006832782528363168, 0.0015325159765779972, -0.0028691329061985016, -0.04778061434626579, -0.01868295483291149, -0.03668345510959625, 0.04639821499586105, -0.028978334739804268, -0.060053154826164246, -0.017126310616731644, 0.022005105391144753, 0.00723031023517251, 0.012200793251395226, -0.012446398846805096, 0.030471524223685265, 0.056373585015535355, -0.04049212485551834, -0.03738049790263176, -0.0001235311501659453, -0.015948863700032234, 0.019516101107001305, 0.013168016448616982, -0.011288712732493877, 0.011987005360424519, 0.03803578019142151, -0.09078852087259293, 0.01800580509006977, 0.0448712557554245, 0.07673376053571701, -0.023105181753635406, -0.003805868560448289, -0.028124921023845673, 0.02342560701072216, -0.03471550717949867, 0.002133346861228347, -0.033791761845350266, -0.01741310954093933, 0.07543251663446426, -0.03549440950155258, -0.05523493513464928, -0.005144571885466576, -0.055134233087301254, -0.05890929698944092, 0.00465953815728426, 0.036110445857048035, 0.010054408572614193, -0.015506543219089508, -0.04769670590758324, 0.01990371383726597, -0.06310935318470001, 0.057432059198617935, -0.006183986086398363, -0.03283095359802246, 0.04983799532055855, -0.04951595515012741, 0.00022922662901692092, 0.012082087807357311, -0.03662578761577606, 0.04204801470041275, -0.04669071361422539, 0.02917725406587124, -0.0693364068865776, 0.045102931559085846, 0.013671663589775562, -0.005132706835865974, 0.03850521892309189, 0.061066556721925735, -0.0270242802798748, 0.06512416899204254, -0.012922663241624832, 0.006049288436770439, -0.004542285576462746, 0.038606345653533936, 0.029591361060738564, 0.014607531018555164, -0.06307610124349594, -0.01695050299167633, 0.02744838036596775, -0.016210034489631653, -0.03504566103219986, 0.02544395439326763, -0.02030562050640583, -0.03251224383711815, -0.07365132868289948, 0.019403332844376564, -0.05597562715411186, 0.04359003156423569, -0.029507149010896683, -0.05462295189499855, 0.053974684327840805, -0.034363098442554474, 0.006182762794196606, -0.02956153266131878, -0.025800757110118866, -0.024943998083472252, -0.030554741621017456, 0.02282469905912876, -0.08221285045146942, 0.03153271600604057, -0.021424168720841408, 0.067867711186409, 0.03549978882074356, -0.004323939792811871, -0.029232952743768692, -0.04902374744415283, 0.0068299006670713425, -0.0094713494181633, 0.05015958845615387, -0.02421470917761326, -0.025027284398674965, 0.014845049008727074, 0.024199357256293297, -0.01141790859401226, -0.013610349968075752, -0.0128417843952775, -0.04021621122956276, 0.034137796610593796, -0.02312571369111538, -0.048134755343198776, -0.04168805107474327, 0.02474816143512726, 0.04779204726219177, -0.06972404569387436, -0.03208636865019798, 0.020502878352999687, 0.0023699419107288122, -0.030034806579351425, -0.02838977985084057, -0.04439219459891319, -0.0012939381413161755, -0.01661902666091919, -0.00945833045989275, 0.0017801070353016257, 0.04720351845026016, 0.052315905690193176, 0.003472852287814021, 0.0006701101083308458, -0.013784574344754219, -0.020964568480849266, 0.025083377957344055, 0.055106021463871, 0.016404947265982628, -0.03664097189903259, -0.058614376932382584, -0.07512585818767548, 0.03318580985069275, -0.02621416002511978, -0.016437362879514694, 0.006419687531888485, -0.001591247390024364, 0.014560346491634846, 0.05754639208316803, -0.07918272167444229, -0.01226753182709217, 0.0550110787153244, -0.041456446051597595, -0.02449560910463333, 0.06549106538295746, 0.0011672945693135262, 0.04323602467775345, -0.03758595138788223, -0.0004132838221266866, 0.0026960845571011305, -0.051420632749795914, -0.0022326004691421986, -0.0057609970681369305, -0.015599719248712063, -0.007034048903733492, 0.05035245046019554, 0.015607968904078007, -0.034931596368551254, -0.02004271000623703, -0.0063899788074195385, -0.004562882706522942, -0.03831310570240021, 0.02321736328303814, -0.009340988472104073, -0.005993955302983522, -0.03524329513311386, 0.03566505014896393, -0.00838793907314539, -0.00473026093095541, 0.025002624839544296, -0.038741130381822586, -0.012595889158546925, 0.05821835622191429, -0.03684147819876671, 0.009923364035785198, -0.005196733400225639, -0.013371534645557404, -0.017690502107143402, -0.04212140291929245, -0.022714752703905106, -0.01970694214105606, -0.0202937088906765, -0.01929911971092224, 0.024464961141347885, 0.020053965970873833, 0.0319981575012207, -0.0328279472887516, 0.03081442043185234, -0.047580841928720474, 0.010054731741547585, -0.017157113179564476, -0.024673808366060257, 0.02585555426776409, 0.0014802968362346292, 0.05607440695166588, 0.0014281008625403047, 0.03242116793990135, -0.0038031761068850756, 0.041948478668928146, -0.022461596876382828, 0.005442869383841753, 0.007079632952809334, -0.022917676717042923, 0.04146061837673187, -0.034956902265548706, -0.057325124740600586, 0.008746781386435032, 0.03546779602766037, -0.04477910324931145, 0.009828055277466774, 0.039293307811021805, -0.06709291785955429, -0.014296690002083778, -0.030659746378660202, -0.04107354208827019, -0.05128045007586479, -0.005000539589673281, 0.04944125562906265, -0.07360904663801193, -0.021297559142112732, -0.011348957195878029, 0.004882362671196461, -0.01096517313271761, -0.043888457119464874, 0.04974471777677536, 0.006682182662189007, -0.030802978202700615, -0.058452121913433075, 0.03573385626077652, -0.001835295814089477, -0.06266829371452332, 0.010543525218963623, 0.019086843356490135, -0.06310415267944336, -0.012436602264642715, -0.014011120423674583, 0.038654983043670654, -0.027503477409482002, 0.00843930896371603, 0.008835007436573505, -0.0026362391654402018, -0.06374859064817429, 0.07625412195920944, 0.08097299188375473, -0.005198716651648283, -0.0038042496889829636, 0.04046061262488365, -0.03192610666155815, 0.01108161173760891, -0.05322159081697464, 0.014225882478058338, -0.05006802827119827, 0.02214025892317295, -0.007301983889192343, -0.05670560151338577, -0.06160968169569969, 0.06858761608600616, -0.017801223322749138, -0.0033245128579437733, 0.04523821920156479, -0.000019286359020043164, 0.036250557750463486, -0.03224064037203789, -0.047770533710718155, 0.03117549978196621, -0.019021349027752876, -0.005573133006691933, -0.023097973316907883, 0.012511830776929855, -0.036051902920007706, -0.0037345332093536854, -0.008020609617233276, -0.06897240877151489, 0.02229662612080574, -0.017072120681405067, -0.05119971185922623, 0.007294117473065853, -0.0645843893289566, -0.03187262639403343, -0.005115023348480463, 0.036831680685281754, 0.04904218018054962, 0.04677668213844299, -0.0441533625125885, -0.021183855831623077, 0.041993241757154465, 0.030070427805185318, -0.03576481342315674, -0.01772686466574669, 0.002691724104806781, -0.05640377476811409, 0.04215843603014946, -0.05248887836933136, 0.006425260566174984, -0.05108672007918358, -0.006640226114541292, 0.007551432587206364, 0.030720846727490425, -0.0674886554479599, -0.02263825573027134, 0.020676400512456894, -0.033954501152038574, -0.0071490113623440266, 0.01664040982723236, -0.04909451678395271, -0.07612916827201843, 0.012301832437515259, -0.022602982819080353, 0.029942696914076805, 0.03587310388684273, 0.06174956262111664, 0.052539803087711334, -0.042831189930438995, 0.044001828879117966, 0.03109409660100937, 0.016229409724473953, 0.022525640204548836, -0.04518997296690941, -0.008808791637420654, -0.008863567374646664, 0.029374871402978897, -0.042797163128852844, -0.009282038547098637, -0.004004518501460552, -0.07838822901248932, 0.04365461692214012, 0.025743603706359863, 0.018619218841195107, -0.023117126896977425, -0.06803907454013824, -0.006020551081746817, -0.008436894044280052, -0.0436687096953392, -0.07088816910982132, 0.01988060586154461, 0.027147971093654633, 0.010926096700131893, -0.022491956129670143, -0.009080278687179089, -0.03637249395251274, -0.053328853100538254, -0.07342150062322617, 0.004571795463562012, 0.002020325744524598, 0.0767396092414856, 0.00024159587337635458, -0.05677962303161621, -0.0027785946149379015, -0.01689184084534645, -0.04291409254074097, 0.021609701216220856, 0.015512049198150635, -0.03958060219883919, 0.021146997809410095, -0.01387724932283163, -0.05777986720204353, -0.036921076476573944, 0.00021623187058139592, -0.019223559647798538, 0.017882082611322403, 0.02635425142943859, 0.025529179722070694, 0.02411598525941372, 0.037941157817840576, 0.06296417117118835, 0.01570069044828415, 0.03383002430200577, -0.05579201877117157, -0.010835445486009121, -0.011539955623447895, -0.0519423633813858, 0.04254002496600151, -0.032476071268320084, -0.0018907833145931363, 0.02159912697970867, 0.01506341714411974, 0.007163462229073048, 0.006463042460381985, -0.0633985623717308, 0.002516109263524413, -0.023106710985302925, 0.003255852498114109, 0.005132749676704407, -0.0719279795885086, 0.04782920330762863, -0.01812637411057949, 0.010070914402604103, -0.04274597018957138, 0.0006050757947377861, 0.042094551026821136, -0.0032947096042335033, 0.011983762495219707, -0.06925760209560394, 0.005832481663674116, -0.007618215400725603, -0.03447134420275688, -0.023650046437978745, 0.057539522647857666, -0.015124152414500713, 0.005941644310951233, -0.007831834256649017, -0.005826893262565136, -0.02992548793554306, -0.06427012383937836, -0.03794465586543083, -0.026635773479938507, 0.02894521690905094, -0.01222627330571413, 0.030566515401005745, -0.03502872586250305, 0.0514051727950573, 0.0354246087372303, 0.017291616648435593, 0.02409486286342144, -0.018561528995633125, -0.05946730077266693, 0.06487869471311569, 0.0015820375410839915, 0.01258914079517126, -0.035907573997974396, -0.0035942501854151487, -0.02665204554796219, -0.03207385912537575, -0.0023163766600191593, -0.015559590421617031, 0.002663286402821541, -0.06687618046998978, 0.01677350141108036, 0.0001389156823279336, -0.03704403340816498, -0.0411522276699543, -0.018205469474196434, -0.012197903357446194, -0.01972227916121483, -0.03675069659948349 ]
We analyzed four epochs of beamformed EVN data of the Crab Pulsar at 1658.49 MHz. With the high sensitivity resulting from resolving out the Crab Nebula, we are able to detect even the faint high-frequency components in the folded profile. We also detect a total of 65951 giant pulses, which we use to investigate the rates, fluence, phase, and arrival time distributions. We find that for the main pulse component, our giant pulses represent about 80% of the total flux. This suggests we have a nearly complete giant pulse energy distribution, although it is not obvious how the observed distribution could be extended to cover the remaining 20% of the flux without invoking large numbers of faint bursts for every rotation. Looking at the difference in arrival time between subsequent bursts in single rotations, we confirm that the likelihood of finding giant pulses close to each other is increased beyond that expected for randomly occurring bursts - some giant pulses consist of causally related microbursts, with typical separations of $\sim\!30{\rm\;\mu s}$ - but also find evidence that at separations $\gtrsim\!100{\rm\;\mu s}$ the likelihood of finding another giant pulse is suppressed. In addition, our high sensitivity enabled us to detect weak echo features in the brightest pulses (at $\sim\!0.4\%$ of the peak giant pulse flux), which are delayed by up to $\sim\!300{\rm\;\mu s}$.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16362v2
[ -0.00516589917242527, 0.028823602944612503, 0.014131853356957436, 0.01897905394434929, 0.017657045274972916, 0.033469028770923615, -0.0013439367758110166, 0.0555381253361702, -0.022855674847960472, -0.013231197372078896, 0.010254589840769768, -0.039916373789310455, -0.04593351483345032, -0.07314100116491318, -0.027222810313105583, 0.011553335003554821, 0.07417954504489899, 0.03721857815980911, -0.06751353293657303, 0.06825307756662369, 0.02126290090382099, 0.0059870644472539425, -0.033846355974674225, 0.05133252218365669, 0.028973115608096123, -0.06449050456285477, 0.00007289538916666061, 0.03610577806830406, -0.034220948815345764, -0.04054723307490349, 0.07662706822156906, -0.022671736776828766, -0.03369421511888504, -0.019338330253958702, -0.036382533609867096, 0.013326347805559635, -0.022326288744807243, 0.0718005895614624, 0.03605378791689873, -0.006419303826987743, -0.014798836782574654, -0.08318693190813065, -0.016373248770833015, -0.007715517655014992, -0.037534404546022415, -0.02139139734208584, -0.001999165629968047, 0.005870521534234285, 0.020637063309550285, -0.04814928397536278, -0.012566635385155678, -0.020265037193894386, 0.015351297333836555, 0.0496022030711174, -0.018354007974267006, -0.05936861038208008, 0.011701294220983982, 0.046751488000154495, -0.025877777487039566, -0.007987774908542633, -0.01863827370107174, -0.007229793816804886, -0.03956253081560135, -0.020273640751838684, -0.02842569537460804, 0.044458501040935516, 0.0015341750113293529, -0.030306560918688774, -0.012438636273145676, -0.034387342631816864, 0.0409277081489563, -0.055427391082048416, 0.028844669461250305, 0.031007058918476105, -0.0630943551659584, 0.012141927145421505, -0.01578337512910366, -0.006346256472170353, 0.01981370337307453, 0.020586000755429268, -0.03133324161171913, -0.02573487162590027, 0.02406931295990944, 0.019113343209028244, -0.03346087783575058, -0.0029813377186656, 0.07386505603790283, -0.009075119160115719, -0.02280908264219761, -0.055734872817993164, 0.04293232783675194, -0.04418424889445305, -0.05222569406032562, -0.05060204863548279, 0.0709492638707161, -0.040716320276260376, 0.07217499613761902, 0.012883739545941353, 0.023733654990792274, -0.012205508537590504, 0.001097781816497445, -0.008473329246044159, -0.018012825399637222, 0.00250979489646852, 0.020115120336413383, -0.001969501143321395, 0.006651327945291996, -0.04470456764101982, -0.04745448753237724, 0.051048409193754196, -0.013876046054065228, 0.004287568386644125, -0.005034358240664005, -0.017932739108800888, -0.07847920060157776, -0.03771588206291199, 0.07092303037643433, 0.012733121402561665, 0.006917942315340042, -0.011358670890331268, -0.015716759487986565, 0.02806469239294529, 0.027794837951660156, 0.04637013003230095, 0.03668207302689552, 0.039465900510549545, 0.06269343942403793, -0.030153024941682816, 0.028799841180443764, -0.014430501498281956, -0.01763736642897129, 0.0023853140883147717, 0.02359793521463871, 0.009267225861549377, 0.039381083101034164, 0.0011816041078418493, 0.03329058364033699, 0.01687631383538246, 0.019287416711449623, -0.007630078122019768, 0.02205435186624527, -0.027843698859214783, 0.028920404613018036, 0.030213458463549614, 0.027176739647984505, 0.016293533146381378, -0.09397675842046738, 0.010013489052653313, 0.08093465864658356, 0.027145592495799065, -0.028070196509361267, 0.05456561967730522, -0.024681774899363518, 0.016861556097865105, -0.005193403922021389, 0.025800764560699463, 0.05161301791667938, 0.012686904519796371, -0.00911889597773552, -0.016652679070830345, -0.027107546105980873, -0.04061576724052429, 0.004517791792750359, 0.04078994691371918, 0.002152390079572797, -0.01405832078307867, 0.007188898511230946, -0.029199596494436264, 0.0066818357445299625, 0.026751331984996796, -0.04896983504295349, 0.023521356284618378, 0.002671807073056698, -0.03061782754957676, -0.03247300535440445, -0.033908482640981674, 0.003907382488250732, -0.030796799808740616, -0.010900835506618023, 0.014692775905132294, 0.05846284329891205, 0.013669352047145367, -0.06379906088113785, -0.00009297353244619444, -0.013274505734443665, 0.007990485988557339, -0.08503463119268417, 0.02457449957728386, 0.06803147494792938, -0.0014895693166181445, 0.00022689309844281524, -0.0293413233011961, 0.026958419010043144, -0.028156183660030365, 0.02546115778386593, -0.018359016627073288, 0.021601956337690353, -0.0212933961302042, 0.013626521453261375, 0.01636662892997265, -0.08246402442455292, -0.033320751041173935, -0.05691951885819435, 0.009197568520903587, 0.026652155444025993, -0.07139426469802856, 0.039282120764255524, -0.03980816900730133, -0.046792931854724884, -0.043382395058870316, 0.0699385330080986, 0.047774408012628555, 0.015793392434716225, 0.020654890686273575, -0.04373451694846153, -0.04080740362405777, -0.11418034136295319, 0.04133852571249008, 0.009411027655005455, -0.01602010428905487, 0.018300099298357964, 0.03311818465590477, -0.03076898492872715, -0.01747753471136093, -0.032151155173778534, 0.061404693871736526, 0.046925436705350876, -0.032363586127758026, -0.03220684081315994, 0.0009793142089620233, -0.009319186210632324, -0.03281093016266823, -0.024633800610899925, -0.06977594643831253, 0.00963953509926796, 0.02858886681497097, -0.03745156526565552, 0.03354843705892563, 0.04505495727062225, -0.03311888128519058, -0.04037057235836983, 0.0047100381925702095, 0.028093650937080383, 0.0010172311449423432, -0.044084109365940094, 0.022070033475756645, -0.03758982941508293, 0.050343841314315796, -0.010333767160773277, -0.022913258522748947, -0.010971225798130035, -0.03677653521299362, -0.00835046824067831, 0.034341201186180115, 0.0039001114200800657, 0.052174217998981476, -0.02697019651532173, -0.0009966687066480517, -0.03586168214678764, 0.03351791948080063, -0.02507867105305195, -0.003964404575526714, -0.018502864986658096, 0.003539504949003458, 0.03949958458542824, 0.01983601786196232, -0.06067000702023506, 0.02355312556028366, 0.0449301153421402, 0.023410258814692497, -0.004961706232279539, 0.04200766980648041, 0.05508238822221756, -0.003047400387004018, -0.0011578701669350266, -0.04680347815155983, -0.03988022729754448, -0.033964794129133224, 0.03471372276544571, -0.011127980425953865, 0.04926614090800285, 0.010520952753722668, 0.025414133444428444, -0.06019749864935875, -0.007334854919463396, -0.03359200805425644, 0.00964124221354723, -0.06056857481598854, -0.05173836648464203, 0.0005851208698004484, -0.07492479681968689, 0.014500916004180908, -0.03777219355106354, -0.02703298255801201, -0.026650894433259964, -0.046869754791259766, 0.0026753051206469536, -0.04858784377574921, 0.002687052357941866, -0.05988016724586487, -0.05668693780899048, -0.004608522169291973, 0.06529903411865234, 0.03125729784369469, -0.04323407635092735, -0.05389353632926941, -0.01422115694731474, 0.021029993891716003, 0.029768727719783783, 0.02960168942809105, -0.027366401627659798, -0.021996665745973587, -0.06320890784263611, 0.021580174565315247, -0.02218746393918991, 0.05507802590727806, 0.036445826292037964, -0.05309833586215973, -0.005063261371105909, -0.041739918291568756, -0.037668485194444656, -0.032374169677495956, 0.03825533762574196, -0.03419673815369606, -0.06250953674316406, -0.02947288192808628, 0.04617119953036308, 0.058027952909469604, 0.042377226054668427, -0.06745240092277527, -0.03841505944728851, -0.02393392100930214, 0.016110174357891083, 0.002941792830824852, 0.04394642263650894, 0.04328587278723717, -0.058465760201215744, 0.00018361012917011976, -0.054230641573667526, 0.057256896048784256, 0.007659968454390764, 0.013871703296899796, -0.054090261459350586, 0.019595857709646225, 0.015323116444051266, -0.05764232948422432, 0.0008639530860818923, 0.057183440774679184, 0.013286293484270573, -0.015838153660297394, 0.019691506400704384, 0.02634492702782154, 0.023476310074329376, 0.047097478061914444, 0.0006254204199649394, 0.0006576317246071994, 0.03265433385968208, 0.04405585303902626, -0.0189072098582983, -0.013240850530564785, 0.013520979322493076, -0.057857561856508255, -0.03093159757554531, 0.026950426399707794, -0.005178019404411316, 0.06682340055704117, 0.03770881146192551, 0.044361695647239685, -0.021223703399300575, -0.02360668033361435, 0.07281985878944397, 0.005157823674380779, -0.03771944344043732, 0.0020980010740458965, 0.009858492761850357, 0.03236962482333183, -0.01144363172352314, 0.004054312128573656, 0.009549178183078766, -0.06314492970705032, -0.0004628199094440788, -0.05465307831764221, -0.0015213304432108998, 0.01863175816833973, 0.00039175001438707113, 0.027794459834694862, 0.019500181078910828, 0.02057211846113205, 0.07641905546188354, 0.00948266126215458, -0.04455704241991043, -0.01024473737925291, 0.007407931610941887, 0.04610341414809227, 0.03756176307797432, 0.0036757970228791237, 0.006510999519377947, 0.03794194012880325, -0.016099728643894196, 0.0306447371840477, -0.02819204516708851, -0.020691927522420883, -0.022694412618875504, -0.09879905730485916, 0.008165363222360611, -0.05001237243413925, 0.046425119042396545, -0.029194502159953117, -0.0027849602047353983, 0.048099637031555176, 0.0004778976726811379, 0.006291956175118685, -0.020500371232628822, -0.02545986883342266, -0.040575649589300156, -0.022577915340662003, 0.028681237250566483, -0.02750120870769024, 0.05859744921326637, -0.02736804261803627, 0.04469727352261543, 0.01518404483795166, -0.01522169541567564, -0.04625864699482918, 0.008231802843511105, -0.04105415567755699, -0.011252759024500847, 0.010513583198189735, 0.028525467962026596, 0.01963167078793049, -0.01043633371591568, -0.008447516709566116, 0.013821334578096867, 0.030257152393460274, 0.0187802966684103, -0.032154880464076996, 0.025785567238926888, -0.04037497192621231, -0.06297384947538376, -0.049423329532146454, -0.01613455079495907, 0.028086477890610695, -0.08205012232065201, -0.047673098742961884, 0.012711405754089355, 0.04685058817267418, -0.06423391401767731, -0.0344056636095047, -0.026473836973309517, -0.059566959738731384, -0.05320296064019203, -0.028916412964463234, 0.016113510355353355, 0.00026837651967070997, 0.011260797269642353, 0.05884546786546707, -0.007882167585194111, 0.03523675352334976, -0.02664022520184517, 0.04364967718720436, 0.03418093919754028, 0.03766198456287384, -0.00219652964733541, -0.01669348031282425, -0.032110705971717834, -0.023048197850584984, 0.024821683764457703, -0.06325729191303253, -0.012486052699387074, 0.043907951563596725, 0.01576274447143078, -0.00023120181867852807, -0.07846946269273758, 0.03766762465238571, 0.022921660915017128, -0.04311259835958481, 0.010269916616380215, 0.02572023682296276, 0.006194125860929489, 0.05083999037742615, -0.023947393521666527, -0.013215643353760242, -0.006149436812847853, 0.017183855175971985, -0.027001596987247467, 0.009512819349765778, -0.03324171155691147, -0.011369257234036922, -0.01199882198125124, 0.008477149531245232, -0.07298075407743454, 0.013958116061985493, 0.016139283776283264, 0.0018055137479677796, -0.010299280285835266, 0.03637807443737984, 0.01508573442697525, -0.01242469809949398, -0.05771884322166443, -0.012581892311573029, 0.030500885099172592, -0.03119218721985817, 0.07708539813756943, -0.058352984488010406, -0.03851018100976944, 0.05288056656718254, -0.00975573156028986, 0.03560427203774452, 0.030248545110225677, 0.020502537488937378, -0.009690302424132824, 0.04214584827423096, 0.034542832523584366, -0.06549708545207977, 0.00011180104775121436, -0.036742694675922394, 0.021701447665691376, -0.003081487724557519, 0.038505472242832184, 0.01729351282119751, 0.056390389800071716, 0.03727636858820915, -0.07561907917261124, -0.029053255915641785, 0.0015763482078909874, 0.054860472679138184, -0.03424777463078499, 0.014315802603960037, 0.0011686815414577723, 0.04830598458647728, 0.010000201873481274, 0.010304739698767662, -0.03070393204689026, -0.031465865671634674, -0.014424332417547703, 0.016557184979319572, 0.01151321455836296, 0.013897471129894257, -0.04915096238255501, -0.020621564239263535, 0.04204672947525978, -0.013779211789369583, 0.057167623192071915, 0.010867683216929436, -0.0042382534593343735, 0.015230974182486534, 0.010110334493219852, -0.024801528081297874, -0.036769505590200424, 0.01831533946096897, 0.08525415509939194, -0.04129169508814812, 0.005370088387280703, 0.015756018459796906, -0.011036868207156658, 0.009747246280312538, -0.015204272232949734, 0.012196056544780731, 0.030667243525385857, -0.0064392792992293835, -0.04661118611693382, 0.02848709188401699, -0.02132035233080387, -0.05325155705213547, 0.015369032509624958, -0.005890654865652323, -0.08479773998260498, -0.014021841809153557, 0.009345367550849915, 0.006333172786980867, -0.06782688200473785, -0.01529639307409525, -0.034623611718416214, -0.05962019041180611, -0.038001321256160736, 0.05731198191642761, 0.05556225776672363, -0.04284479469060898, -0.023515256121754646, 0.02606530301272869, 0.02525230124592781, 0.04637094959616661, -0.047424085438251495, 0.0040914216078817844, -0.035955846309661865, 0.035124272108078, -0.01563977263867855, -0.03354980796575546, 0.006971121300011873, 0.06088510528206825, -0.06627076119184494, 0.04677653685212135, -0.012442021630704403, -0.01752115786075592, 0.00801644567400217, -0.06548060476779938, -0.048209961503744125, 0.025884825736284256, -0.017225291579961777, 0.024209434166550636, -0.024524949491024017, -0.017116865143179893, -0.0009600864141248167, 0.07408124208450317, 0.012957527302205563, -0.009417789988219738, 0.02215930074453354, -0.02527284249663353, -0.003526390064507723, 0.034117162227630615, -0.06571845710277557, 0.020560862496495247, 0.03973913937807083, 0.04494631290435791, -0.005065354984253645, 0.050817571580410004, -0.026635529473423958, -0.046100493520498276, -0.028045987710356712, -0.0011951647466048598, 0.050017017871141434, -0.0037728757597506046, 0.027436034753918648, -0.044049300253391266, 0.042746711522340775, -0.03380925580859184, 0.0026184162124991417, 0.008879630826413631, -0.05327726900577545, 0.06363467127084732, 0.0053241066634655, -0.050134822726249695, -0.03573552519083023, -0.003536945441737771, -0.045718349516391754, 0.029841633513569832, 0.034174591302871704, -0.04180300235748291, -0.06130551919341087, -0.019648395478725433, -0.009577962569892406, -0.025620747357606888, 0.04572034999728203, 0.002462514443323016, 0.04714087396860123, -0.03879023343324661, 0.030269721522927284, 0.060138773173093796, -0.0007769236108288169, -0.005734187085181475, -0.03495757281780243, 0.01713901199400425, 0.040979430079460144, 0.015759043395519257, -0.022687608376145363, -0.0009081789175979793, -0.04097158834338188, -0.06008525565266609, -0.028572190552949905, -0.032524462789297104, -0.01288635190576315, -0.008449063636362553, -0.06252428889274597, 0.026016388088464737, 0.044406820088624954, -0.0274239182472229, -0.09244494885206223, 0.0009994922438636422, -0.0026603550650179386, 0.013547577895224094, 0.018752947449684143, -0.0027076785918325186, -0.0328780822455883, 0.02998155541718006, -0.09322672337293625, -0.002752891043201089, -0.05197390913963318, 0.026836292818188667, -0.015599217265844345, 0.005798617377877235, -0.034123435616493225, -0.01868250034749508, 0.005021409131586552, 0.04843604564666748, -0.032191529870033264, 0.021248482167720795, -0.014836344867944717, -0.008777125738561153, -0.05627686530351639, 0.00659939693287015, 0.017271921038627625, -0.0484628900885582, 0.003735202830284834, 0.03017822653055191, 0.028016483411192894, -0.019688373431563377, 0.0070168329402804375, 0.04588625580072403, -0.026923788711428642, -0.03643456846475601, -0.04328492656350136, 0.0019497056491672993, -0.043278973549604416, 0.004824713803827763, 0.027360854670405388, -0.04103292152285576, 0.02831188403069973, 0.01925170049071312, 0.004792146850377321, -0.00048249904648400843, -0.05051141604781151, 0.011989106424152851, 0.03140215948224068, 0.040442440658807755, 0.03957182168960571, 0.08844492584466934, -0.04847455769777298, -0.01925066113471985, 0.011691092513501644, 0.0037379285786300898, -0.07837654650211334, 0.037874605506658554, 0.010407326743006706, -0.06950148195028305, 0.007433619350194931, -0.07736802846193314, 0.03654085099697113, -0.024342847988009453, -0.014219856821000576, 0.03713974729180336, 0.02404373325407505, -0.03175780177116394, -0.0336047038435936, -0.016845565289258957, -0.0381711982190609, -0.018005283549427986, -0.0302733201533556, 0.0021861603017896414, 0.06298769265413284, 0.014086883515119553, 0.04346451535820961, 0.0526602640748024, -0.017097128555178642, 0.022330431267619133, -0.0024270943831652403, 0.03833991661667824, -0.03458947688341141, 0.0020223238971084356, -0.03506384417414665, 0.07328309118747711, -0.04910305142402649, 0.016503125429153442, -0.054006267338991165, 0.031197793781757355, 0.02873212844133377, 0.01872008666396141, -0.015352199785411358, 0.008724423125386238, -0.03467647358775139, -0.0882839784026146, -0.06378968060016632, 0.02255404368042946, 0.020737743005156517, -0.010702290572226048, 0.03314472362399101, 0.012891345657408237, -0.00567576615139842, -0.0688231885433197 ]
Understanding and evaluating uncertainty play a key role in decision-making. When a viewer studies a visualization that demands inference, it is necessary that uncertainty is portrayed in it. This paper showcases the importance of representing uncertainty in visualizations. It provides an overview of uncertainty visualization and the challenges authors and viewers face when working with such charts. I divide the visualization pipeline into four parts, namely data collection, preprocessing, visualization, and inference, to evaluate how uncertainty impacts them. Next, I investigate the authors' methodologies to process and design uncertainty. Finally, I contribute by exploring future paths for uncertainty visualization.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.07687v1
[ -0.042537085711956024, -0.02596546895802021, 0.02493957430124283, -0.037278592586517334, -0.007876602001488209, -0.007870716974139214, -0.014466614462435246, 0.013170160353183746, -0.024754155427217484, 0.020156247541308403, -0.061355624347925186, -0.03396644443273544, 0.024186093360185623, -0.034225933253765106, -0.011822287924587727, -0.024536948651075363, 0.06546637415885925, 0.02549489587545395, -0.06548422574996948, 0.04931597784161568, -0.024094074964523315, -0.006303572095930576, 0.01637938618659973, 0.009681472554802895, 0.04736437276005745, -0.028999676927924156, -0.0010866571683436632, 0.012304709292948246, -0.03398227319121361, 0.01450665295124054, 0.024132832884788513, -0.034569837152957916, -0.04696255177259445, -0.04591679200530052, -0.006428930908441544, -0.002998816780745983, 0.01147864293307066, -0.009779785759747028, -0.04375961795449257, -0.01711582951247692, 0.048085056245326996, -0.02672405354678631, -0.05923082306981087, -0.014886676333844662, -0.05107475444674492, 0.003596584778279066, -0.03602205216884613, 0.01987379603087902, -0.08926806598901749, 0.007343414705246687, 0.030339280143380165, -0.012899599969387054, -0.006497498601675034, 0.04977185279130936, -0.02713088132441044, -0.028971625491976738, 0.02752246893942356, 0.008003270253539085, -0.017443479970097542, 0.03246055170893669, 0.03440374881029129, 0.025980155915021896, 0.012279939837753773, 0.020127203315496445, 0.020175468176603317, 0.017742788419127464, -0.006474337540566921, -0.017558783292770386, 0.0006346581503748894, -0.03537615388631821, 0.05309942737221718, -0.058291543275117874, 0.01622053049504757, -0.0019777517300099134, -0.04260795935988426, 0.01838815025985241, -0.017552483826875687, -0.0580621138215065, -0.016742877662181854, 0.06139230355620384, -0.028936978429555893, -0.01384679600596428, 0.020855937153100967, 0.01506031583994627, 0.027277503162622452, -0.032084569334983826, -0.012010516598820686, 0.03439826890826225, 0.020062118768692017, -0.04126105085015297, 0.011168479919433594, -0.048768799751996994, -0.045117203146219254, -0.012075353413820267, -0.007149470038712025, 0.032776229083538055, 0.07162162661552429, -0.009691447019577026, -0.02216743491590023, -0.05542217567563057, -0.058304622769355774, 0.018304426223039627, -0.030791951343417168, 0.005770422052592039, 0.056056588888168335, -0.05216005817055702, -0.006241002585738897, 0.013517721556127071, -0.009767713956534863, -0.04127558320760727, 0.018620552495121956, -0.0027628291863948107, 0.013242971152067184, -0.08582442998886108, 0.004699365701526403, -0.011122701689600945, 0.029554758220911026, 0.0017628889763727784, 0.022881286218762398, -0.005691456608474255, -0.05571646988391876, 0.027651049196720123, 0.00699692964553833, -0.035724297165870667, -0.05809968709945679, -0.0003030321968253702, 0.050943680107593536, 0.010385186411440372, 0.02882849983870983, -0.011934073641896248, -0.06352259963750839, -0.008933856151998043, -0.04019996151328087, -0.030016975477337837, 0.01796739548444748, -0.02258288487792015, -0.02825063094496727, -0.06063605844974518, 0.006848200224339962, -0.02742532640695572, -0.04169824719429016, -0.05814439430832863, 0.0009205946698784828, -0.019735634326934814, 0.010175301693379879, 0.03150440752506256, 0.006312476471066475, -0.01806236058473587, 0.018761906772851944, 0.04559045657515526, 0.031519729644060135, -0.045279212296009064, 0.0593462735414505, 0.018123548477888107, 0.00598210608586669, -0.048631973564624786, 0.03269189968705177, 0.006446044892072678, -0.027419736608862877, 0.02819507196545601, 0.035586319863796234, -0.03997436910867691, 0.02787659503519535, -0.037903353571891785, -0.02558007650077343, -0.016529755666851997, 0.03765224292874336, -0.024342156946659088, 0.005971609149128199, -0.005208179820328951, -0.06317473948001862, 0.05269411951303482, -0.014483836479485035, -0.02639971487224102, -0.07593930512666702, -0.013785825110971928, 0.011277339421212673, -0.062000419944524765, -0.009199084714055061, 0.011553619988262653, -0.03884348273277283, -0.032771140336990356, -0.0087811890989542, -0.0062890127301216125, 0.01853809505701065, 0.05629046633839607, -0.0575384795665741, -0.005811786279082298, 0.001040721544995904, 0.013594835996627808, -0.03728688508272171, -0.05367640033364296, -0.04173142462968826, -0.02272595651447773, -0.05234094336628914, -0.011065484955906868, 0.032954998314380646, 0.015964778140187263, 0.000622520106844604, 0.028059301897883415, -0.08185403048992157, -0.013179830275475979, -0.05860016122460365, 0.03505740687251091, -0.06141526624560356, -0.07752442359924316, -0.055671367794275284, -0.009545765817165375, -0.016009874641895294, -0.02170444093644619, -0.004679618403315544, 0.03390570357441902, 0.05207483097910881, 0.004830058664083481, 0.013110938481986523, 0.02228403091430664, -0.09667632728815079, 0.015933340415358543, 0.021189669147133827, 0.011100349016487598, 0.016436882317066193, 0.0526573583483696, 0.059840794652700424, -0.032412536442279816, 0.005966558121144772, 0.052838582545518875, 0.013988778926432133, -0.006172872148454189, -0.04744786024093628, -0.05986050143837929, -0.0510266050696373, -0.06535859405994415, 0.014198899269104004, -0.05886543169617653, -0.003605644218623638, 0.0002584087196737528, -0.05639530345797539, 0.001031728694215417, -0.04033597931265831, 0.010158480145037174, -0.05168359354138374, -0.06077073514461517, 0.05407743528485298, 0.013075272552669048, -0.011009923182427883, 0.013966280035674572, -0.05753659829497337, -0.014031518250703812, -0.004281799308955669, 0.038517218083143234, -0.019410723820328712, -0.06810613721609116, 0.022218236699700356, -0.03357543796300888, 0.05235375836491585, 0.010414804331958294, -0.028630496934056282, 0.03074134700000286, 0.0006185472593642771, -0.005227675195783377, 0.03354119509458542, 0.043144743889570236, -0.019764119759202003, 0.02795356698334217, 0.017986606806516647, 0.010435824282467365, 0.022142190486192703, -0.03221690654754639, 0.03128494694828987, -0.07818405330181122, 0.02221478894352913, -0.024844583123922348, -0.023952431976795197, 0.023259375244379044, -0.03245142474770546, -0.04899981990456581, -0.0030071004293859005, -0.04393339902162552, 0.04510333016514778, 0.04633186012506485, 0.019560186192393303, 0.0026232225354760885, -0.05269375070929527, -0.056060753762722015, 0.04646708071231842, -0.022292815148830414, -0.021869715303182602, -0.07413866370916367, -0.052224427461624146, -0.017508286982774734, -0.06518339365720749, -0.017783286049962044, 0.013564225286245346, -0.07926736027002335, -0.035812314599752426, -0.06521440297365189, -0.029182251542806625, 0.014477705582976341, 0.07283318787813187, 0.014287956990301609, -0.03326975554227829, -0.05179012566804886, -0.016927944496273994, 0.007500901818275452, 0.017362944781780243, -0.06942065060138702, -0.06457771360874176, -0.0020266592036932707, 0.0073910970240831375, -0.04319257289171219, 0.028704501688480377, 0.02617563307285309, -0.04307456687092781, 0.007720484863966703, -0.025614719837903976, -0.016088061034679413, -0.03727405145764351, -0.015063281171023846, -0.02518775500357151, 0.04356959089636803, -0.015895476564764977, 0.035200126469135284, 0.0244117621332407, -0.03258972242474556, -0.04751571640372276, -0.013986976817250252, 0.05265795439481735, -0.06651924550533295, 0.020145084708929062, -0.07694732397794724, -0.007097371853888035, 0.04139823466539383, 0.014374425634741783, -0.019076421856880188, 0.03156271576881409, 0.006379151716828346, -0.04433388262987137, -0.06541477143764496, 0.0017512260237708688, -0.02581699565052986, 0.017547553405165672, 0.008358766324818134, -0.0817076563835144, 0.012661824002861977, 0.02225634641945362, -0.09436739981174469, 0.0440681055188179, 0.02219141274690628, 0.07600083947181702, 0.025738844648003578, 0.03396939858794212, 0.01599965989589691, 0.009070678614079952, -0.0476938933134079, 0.027973609045147896, 0.04000428318977356, 0.06503605842590332, 0.05548196658492088, -0.02597154676914215, -0.05664534121751785, 0.004768743645399809, -0.06665606796741486, -0.05994844809174538, 0.0029856415931135416, 0.07251570373773575, 0.02699253521859646, 0.011509139090776443, -0.03311539068818092, -0.008985326625406742, -0.02254599891602993, 0.06533530354499817, 0.06384450942277908, 0.039574701339006424, 0.013024491257965565, -0.07946368306875229, 0.059743911027908325, 0.02386469393968582, 0.06207336485385895, 0.007023302838206291, -0.05906461551785469, 0.0262598879635334, -0.025536317378282547, 0.06916487216949463, 0.005394280422478914, -0.020467204973101616, 0.010866979137063026, -0.02726634033024311, 0.010684900917112827, 0.05415957048535347, -0.033120978623628616, 0.014137011021375656, 0.010634396225214005, 0.011373687535524368, -0.013976230286061764, -0.02133876271545887, -0.05888711288571358, -0.00934571586549282, 0.000308511545881629, -0.03886072337627411, -0.022816097363829613, -0.031227972358465195, -0.01071651466190815, 0.01602780632674694, -0.04719246178865433, -0.00048269014223478734, 0.0319201834499836, -0.003417536849156022, -0.024576665833592415, -0.01807144097983837, 0.0614934004843235, -0.049120981246232986, -0.022328926250338554, -0.027594491839408875, -0.033835213631391525, -0.03519745171070099, -0.03614528849720955, -0.019310347735881805, -0.05608728900551796, -0.021952874958515167, -0.04603717103600502, -0.011110063642263412, 0.026478609070181847, 0.03330539911985397, 0.013356991112232208, -0.007605127524584532, 0.0036103741731494665, -0.011378005146980286, 0.07008659094572067, -0.007163304835557938, -0.030864708125591278, -0.03178456053137779, 0.055272769182920456, 0.016053536906838417, 0.012212011963129044, -0.028230341151356697, 0.00398681266233325, -0.005692126229405403, 0.011529281735420227, 0.037186626344919205, -0.02503756806254387, -0.05425386130809784, 0.04016124829649925, 0.02319917641580105, -0.04314705729484558, 0.03776530548930168, -0.0038085603155195713, -0.060721445828676224, -0.06576958298683167, -0.0053689503110945225, -0.0034267716109752655, -0.054681774228811264, -0.011398849077522755, 0.0051292735151946545, -0.004454032517969608, -0.0326240248978138, -0.014146309345960617, 0.0025951042771339417, 0.046522967517375946, 0.048732202500104904, 0.015645135194063187, -0.020411625504493713, 0.010568047873675823, -0.01716938242316246, -0.025501634925603867, -0.06727879494428635, 0.01804906316101551, -0.021058786660432816, -0.00971996784210205, -0.016503600403666496, 0.054922379553318024, 0.041488923132419586, 0.056224334985017776, -0.05877682566642761, 0.0348062589764595, 0.039447151124477386, -0.04313557967543602, 0.013452136889100075, 0.0610755980014801, 0.02474098466336727, -0.011164139956235886, -0.021116208285093307, 0.03421982750296593, 0.0503755621612072, -0.034584417939186096, 0.036247581243515015, -0.021007731556892395, 0.01932946965098381, -0.017962196841835976, 0.02038213051855564, -0.026640327647328377, 0.009410946629941463, -0.008166260085999966, 0.02033725380897522, 0.023777807131409645, 0.01854393258690834, -0.01793171837925911, 0.019782304763793945, -0.026977483183145523, -0.022711001336574554, 0.0021835286170244217, -0.021408477798104286, -0.031386882066726685, 0.025236360728740692, 0.027002153918147087, -0.003048294223845005, -0.009135669097304344, 0.02267870493233204, 0.03157574683427811, 0.003354752669110894, 0.03993845358490944, -0.022964151576161385, -0.04659418389201164, 0.03374042734503746, -0.041048385202884674, 0.005623906850814819, -0.006296487525105476, 0.05407451093196869, 0.06368449330329895, 0.03847088664770126, -0.02950892597436905, -0.010430142283439636, -0.037504225969314575, -0.027315275743603706, 0.03115125186741352, -0.01269881147891283, 0.011913023889064789, -0.015607473440468311, 0.008447166532278061, 0.015228234231472015, 0.05943599343299866, -0.0017632553353905678, 0.03421899303793907, 0.022145500406622887, 0.01031991932541132, -0.03187856078147888, -0.04203290119767189, 0.06155014783143997, -0.043212614953517914, -0.020876556634902954, -0.022468747571110725, 0.03546007350087166, -0.020465200766921043, 0.04245408996939659, -0.006852203514426947, -0.04882439970970154, 0.006320952903479338, 0.005549200344830751, -0.010764257982373238, -0.04596357420086861, 0.052555572241544724, 0.02784637175500393, -0.02613389678299427, 0.011402655392885208, 0.02827664278447628, -0.06243113800883293, 0.01097030472010374, -0.023816874250769615, 0.02315646782517433, -0.03915215656161308, -0.018590165302157402, -0.04190387949347496, 0.016520269215106964, -0.022885022684931755, -0.06118672713637352, -0.0012613085564225912, -0.012278016656637192, -0.04200819507241249, 0.03257595747709274, 0.004323655739426613, 0.047660574316978455, 0.02344331331551075, 0.023339638486504555, 0.006761827971786261, -0.029627371579408646, -0.07480903714895248, 0.06257489323616028, 0.07713478058576584, -0.046221133321523666, -0.01832999847829342, -0.013274336233735085, -0.05127652734518051, 0.011681443080306053, 0.014305772259831429, 0.039020195603370667, -0.007059786468744278, 0.010857006534934044, 0.0367908850312233, 0.016665585339069366, -0.05707256495952606, 0.06313607096672058, -0.014340878464281559, -0.05614212527871132, -0.008240803144872189, -0.04571492224931717, 0.05011887848377228, -0.03424010053277016, -0.06375796347856522, -0.03248526155948639, -0.04541097953915596, -0.026862306520342827, -0.07167171686887741, -0.0023732036352157593, -0.02673749439418316, -0.021662507206201553, 0.012367693707346916, -0.08347389101982117, 0.01497307326644659, -0.02812962234020233, -0.029442891478538513, -0.004104955587536097, -0.06608511507511139, -0.036800891160964966, -0.0024380411487072706, 0.005723028909415007, 0.0511440634727478, 0.05986049026250839, -0.0481911301612854, 0.017619777470827103, -0.006061718799173832, -0.011752372607588768, -0.009503785520792007, 0.026449143886566162, -0.0051275440491735935, 0.03320837765932083, 0.023291759192943573, -0.020601823925971985, 0.02439151704311371, -0.0468360111117363, 0.03287012130022049, 0.04386759549379349, -0.017539791762828827, -0.04683529585599899, -0.0627768263220787, -0.008793620392680168, -0.03174339234828949, -0.044040877372026443, 0.04768424108624458, -0.056940969079732895, -0.0766318216919899, 0.004846947267651558, 0.0027480628341436386, 0.017576657235622406, 0.03608378395438194, 0.07433852553367615, 0.05811501294374466, -0.011969974264502525, -0.02085137367248535, 0.03734417259693146, 0.03356342017650604, 0.013696758076548576, -0.017430778592824936, 0.016635913401842117, 0.006138046737760305, -0.03874697908759117, -0.02515108324587345, -0.024001983925700188, 0.007819343358278275, -0.05416570603847504, -0.009391441941261292, 0.04125567525625229, -0.059960950165987015, -0.006007271818816662, -0.07044550776481628, 0.01590983010828495, 0.0012552841799333692, 0.00919436290860176, -0.03637702018022537, 0.04335876554250717, -0.025703709572553635, -0.022374948486685753, -0.0036620781756937504, -0.017732204869389534, -0.013094245456159115, 0.04481922462582588, -0.041679080575704575, 0.003156802384182811, 0.0010888720862567425, 0.059566471725702286, -0.03866203501820564, 0.0005004382110200822, 0.03016679733991623, 0.0024737128987908363, -0.005351483356207609, -0.026119066402316093, -0.027177076786756516, 0.02689029462635517, -0.01464159321039915, 0.0007588444859720767, -0.05043187364935875, 0.020920809358358383, 0.039049845188856125, 0.019885603338479996, 0.014383458532392979, 0.05237778648734093, 0.04782763868570328, 0.010678458027541637, -0.03128412738442421, 0.01938873529434204, -0.006020770408213139, 0.004551406484097242, -0.05686207860708237, 0.06385686993598938, 0.024458827450871468, -0.05512131750583649, 0.0562877431511879, 0.03245488181710243, -0.01630326732993126, -0.029771974310278893, -0.03417935222387314, 0.00863313302397728, -0.023278674110770226, -0.054154589772224426, 0.0498996376991272, -0.03992181643843651, 0.0020960900001227856, 0.06272149831056595, -0.01029117126017809, -0.003627766389399767, -0.00595011655241251, 0.004117319360375404, -0.045544594526290894, -0.013731946237385273, -0.010571639984846115, -0.06509440392255783, 0.03678528591990471, -0.07750861346721649, 0.00524446927011013, -0.0036311654839664698, -0.023876070976257324, -0.04369867965579033, 0.061892084777355194, -0.01438921969383955, -0.06605245918035507, -0.025920141488313675, 0.0018438304541632533, -0.03283434733748436, -0.07586093991994858, -0.06807998567819595, -0.05225346237421036, 0.06743820756673813, -0.035125717520713806, -0.035862669348716736, 0.005360583774745464, 0.05053464323282242, 0.01544572226703167, 0.026924055069684982, -0.004362062085419893, -0.04415386542677879, -0.02076190710067749, 0.045439016073942184, 0.06427174806594849, -0.01169289369136095, -0.011279089376330376, -0.022059274837374687, -0.005936001893132925, -0.004365428350865841, 0.054550621658563614, 0.018178345635533333, -0.008249843493103981, -0.06377673894166946, -0.0020768947433680296, 0.03693116083741188, -0.049466028809547424, -0.001219371217302978, -0.05054770037531853, 0.006840930785983801, -0.05496789887547493, -0.045054491609334946 ]
Vocoder models have recently achieved substantial progress in generating authentic audio comparable to human quality while significantly reducing memory requirement and inference time. However, these data-hungry generative models require large-scale audio data for learning good representations. In this paper, we apply contrastive learning methods in training the vocoder to improve the perceptual quality of the vocoder without modifying its architecture or adding more data. We design an auxiliary task with mel-spectrogram contrastive learning to enhance the utterance-level quality of the vocoder model under data-limited conditions. We also extend the task to include waveforms to improve the multi-modality comprehension of the model and address the discriminator overfitting problem. We optimize the additional task simultaneously with GAN training objectives. Our results show that the tasks improve model performance substantially in data-limited settings.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09088v2
[ -0.03753101825714111, -0.017209449782967567, 0.009174360893666744, 0.0014714315766468644, -0.040026210248470306, 0.005680386442691088, 0.01824381574988365, -0.011872976087033749, -0.015502014197409153, -0.018849026411771774, -0.0408158041536808, 0.02819795161485672, -0.0661451444029808, -0.013581480830907822, -0.0444435253739357, 0.00847808737307787, 0.07656941562891006, -0.01358124054968357, -0.02693253755569458, 0.05767780914902687, 0.007046388927847147, 0.026266854256391525, -0.045715488493442535, 0.008487249724566936, 0.024066561833024025, 0.021696802228689194, -0.03903361037373543, 0.005608665756881237, 0.036736857146024704, -0.007516296114772558, 0.062080491334199905, -0.010743225924670696, -0.017754236236214638, -0.02012207731604576, -0.04874312877655029, -0.04103732854127884, -0.04598842188715935, 0.03429863601922989, 0.03530362993478775, -0.05142659321427345, 0.05519124120473862, -0.06408561766147614, -0.07272395491600037, 0.008121869526803493, -0.04210209473967552, -0.01487431675195694, -0.03853515908122063, 0.019393423572182655, -0.07607683539390564, -0.0599757619202137, 0.023719407618045807, 0.028490951284766197, 0.008589746430516243, 0.026387764140963554, -0.009982235729694366, 0.03256003558635712, -0.0506962426006794, 0.002946096006780863, -0.06629126518964767, -0.014508133754134178, 0.020057369023561478, -0.010811767540872097, -0.018986672163009644, -0.0023232069797813892, -0.010871358215808868, 0.036003854125738144, 0.006299168802797794, -0.05893305316567421, -0.042580004781484604, -0.03149060904979706, 0.051209740340709686, -0.06970065832138062, -0.017080429941415787, -0.01161283440887928, -0.0031425263732671738, -0.001462524407543242, -0.0474654883146286, -0.04393080249428749, -0.03619550168514252, 0.009879667311906815, -0.029561256989836693, 0.03697437793016434, 0.03527176380157471, 0.03348070755600929, -0.032116133719682693, -0.022915927693247795, 0.004480005707591772, 0.013052304275333881, -0.024916892871260643, -0.04739747568964958, 0.06226096674799919, -0.032064780592918396, -0.08304000645875931, 0.05351879820227623, 0.05441920831799507, -0.016458719968795776, 0.043624382466077805, 0.05092403665184975, -0.016977518796920776, -0.0007811238756403327, -0.03536812588572502, -0.01502907369285822, 0.0015474888496100903, 0.02085569128394127, 0.01214046310633421, -0.04579143598675728, -0.0007008689572103322, -0.026142071932554245, -0.06224816292524338, -0.014503913931548595, -0.0030566290952265263, -0.020222963765263557, 0.016442470252513885, -0.05335811525583267, -0.05238066241145134, -0.03521356359124184, 0.023462846875190735, 0.006133481860160828, -0.044992949813604355, -0.02700953371822834, 0.015356884337961674, 0.06909491866827011, 0.009787730872631073, -0.008128157816827297, -0.017875971272587776, -0.025630110874772072, 0.04881870374083519, 0.028510864824056625, -0.037453584372997284, -0.0518898069858551, -0.05452222377061844, 0.008703650906682014, -0.040626756846904755, -0.030083442106842995, 0.055471595376729965, -0.009648974984884262, -0.004773860797286034, -0.053195055574178696, 0.015483084134757519, -0.013044893741607666, -0.03432824835181236, -0.08013810217380524, 0.046819258481264114, -0.01324356347322464, 0.002735034329816699, 0.039253804832696915, -0.02752409316599369, -0.0072081442922353745, 0.042110148817300797, 0.021294167265295982, 0.030534448102116585, -0.0058350577019155025, 0.030037933960556984, 0.04162956401705742, 0.010353350080549717, -0.002301956992596388, 0.03544774651527405, 0.012087250128388405, -0.054537348449230194, 0.028736479580402374, -0.04648052901029587, -0.027680132538080215, -0.008228444494307041, -0.03748583048582077, 0.05270310863852501, -0.05074857920408249, 0.04431474581360817, -0.034191668033599854, -0.03267630934715271, 0.03495252877473831, -0.03423457220196724, -0.03538983315229416, 0.004642575979232788, 0.01416311226785183, -0.022677086293697357, 0.020627211779356003, -0.010322818532586098, -0.014965985901653767, -0.06328275054693222, -0.005867376923561096, 0.021204983815550804, 0.023831987753510475, -0.03454842045903206, -0.02636449597775936, -0.013946719467639923, -0.017067985609173775, -0.0814678743481636, -0.035076405853033066, 0.07040565460920334, -0.02217620052397251, -0.031070111319422722, -0.014423073269426823, 0.010433662682771683, 0.036324962973594666, -0.03776516765356064, -0.030762840062379837, 0.006949509959667921, 0.00040515896398574114, 0.027125105261802673, 0.05188724398612976, -0.08109033107757568, -0.03198820725083351, -0.05392662063241005, -0.032957468181848526, -0.01790090650320053, -0.05731897056102753, -0.04222859442234039, 0.030735136941075325, -0.06228365749120712, 0.03326960280537605, 0.05023660510778427, 0.04795684292912483, 0.0411907397210598, 0.0026962952688336372, 0.027381451800465584, 0.006188696250319481, -0.0896405577659607, 0.07367447763681412, 0.017179783433675766, -0.0050315773114562035, 0.018146377056837082, 0.01594044826924801, -0.005513565614819527, -0.03747202455997467, 0.0031650702003389597, 0.04709267616271973, 0.04884207621216774, -0.006230924744158983, -0.027920518070459366, -0.01567188650369644, 0.012462443672120571, -0.020942775532603264, -0.0033932572696357965, -0.07155223190784454, 0.0006951917894184589, 0.02498658001422882, 0.020745011046528816, 0.01181570254266262, 0.014862405136227608, -0.021549629047513008, -0.034800175577402115, -0.04369369521737099, 0.038974516093730927, -0.003165536792948842, -0.05365057289600372, -0.027275988832116127, 0.005761284846812487, 0.04937932267785072, -0.02424888126552105, 0.005779751110821962, -0.03123210370540619, -0.04461241886019707, -0.018007967621088028, -0.017248719930648804, 0.04949866235256195, 0.0047788494266569614, -0.05529981479048729, 0.026522619649767876, -0.0110490582883358, 0.04427232965826988, -0.018988430500030518, 0.03950560837984085, -0.05776604264974594, 0.02648937702178955, 0.054263267666101456, -0.023084966465830803, -0.023130206391215324, -0.04143976792693138, -0.004519794136285782, -0.037586238235235214, 0.006706508342176676, 0.04671705141663551, 0.04388143867254257, -0.0013015002477914095, -0.008602414280176163, -0.04468211904168129, -0.01618671976029873, -0.019895704463124275, 0.008791133761405945, 0.05678267031908035, 0.0019744865130633116, 0.020321615040302277, 0.006603432819247246, -0.0690309926867485, -0.051810380071401596, -0.06914350390434265, -0.0469646155834198, -0.06377647817134857, -0.03941342979669571, -0.0344281829893589, -0.07447707653045654, -0.05742286890745163, -0.04346827417612076, -0.04629712924361229, -0.0010917194886133075, -0.03950353339314461, -0.013527559116482735, -0.017142875120043755, 0.032755136489868164, 0.00013469641271512955, -0.01373559981584549, 0.004791135434061289, 0.006759068462997675, -0.021443309262394905, 0.011454730294644833, -0.058192748576402664, -0.017613615840673447, -0.012284084223210812, 0.028527921065688133, 0.00722992280498147, 0.010500375181436539, 0.05271974951028824, -0.03713749721646309, -0.009735547006130219, -0.020620133727788925, 0.060012008994817734, -0.018898088485002518, 0.056179068982601166, -0.040776047855615616, -0.04450918361544609, 0.023457501083612442, 0.011541360057890415, 0.004401151090860367, -0.014650668017566204, -0.04509684816002846, -0.047929007560014725, 0.06638560444116592, -0.0008053959463723004, -0.05850127339363098, -0.02344634011387825, -0.05437232926487923, 0.011112038046121597, 0.03013393096625805, -0.020496414974331856, 0.015596816316246986, 0.058443598449230194, -0.021091099828481674, -0.04013535752892494, -0.05627364665269852, -0.02682965248823166, -0.011092212982475758, 0.02026723511517048, -0.06270431727170944, 0.0184913482517004, 0.03734130412340164, -0.08563355356454849, 0.027923952788114548, 0.010618331842124462, 0.0538599006831646, 0.016466794535517693, 0.018316440284252167, -0.013355802744626999, 0.017795072868466377, 0.050501253455877304, 0.009117219597101212, 0.0008013314800336957, -0.012104541063308716, 0.04875130578875542, -0.0058778030797839165, -0.06000606343150139, 0.01220434159040451, -0.07088874280452728, -0.036273449659347534, 0.006097330711781979, 0.03516507148742676, 0.0253891721367836, 0.017302243039011955, -0.0778878778219223, -0.0110411886125803, -0.025340337306261063, 0.029924534261226654, -0.01948227733373642, -0.06171640753746033, 0.025782648473978043, -0.059571485966444016, 0.01469431258738041, -0.02749723196029663, -0.009740336798131466, -0.03872842714190483, -0.01171149779111147, 0.023069215938448906, -0.05366837978363037, 0.06049533560872078, 0.010769207961857319, -0.048062440007925034, 0.04016980528831482, 0.0575236938893795, -0.0008277908200398088, 0.04148413613438606, -0.05893049016594887, -0.03395872190594673, 0.01670646108686924, -0.03629341349005699, -0.04887106642127037, 0.03340475633740425, -0.06519696861505508, -0.005114249885082245, 0.00025707579334266484, -0.0440603643655777, 0.0010930027347058058, 0.024851003661751747, 0.030163366347551346, -0.02671884372830391, -0.08243837207555771, 0.000017646612832322717, -0.04500759020447731, 0.05672646686434746, 0.01309258583933115, -0.044941484928131104, 0.04989597201347351, -0.03252387046813965, -0.016200890764594078, -0.03305238485336304, -0.015838056802749634, -0.029521983116865158, -0.04623007774353027, -0.009544889442622662, -0.07163984328508377, 0.040675655007362366, -0.04336368292570114, 0.033661119639873505, -0.00035187159664928913, -0.003176001599058509, -0.029460081830620766, -0.015888875350356102, -0.01997116580605507, 0.039465345442295074, 0.06751102209091187, -0.007772374898195267, -0.04510396718978882, -0.01722143404185772, -0.01707359030842781, 0.016047371551394463, 0.00650078896433115, 0.0271725133061409, -0.027482878416776657, 0.04114452376961708, -0.025953413918614388, 0.01859414018690586, -0.005755661986768246, -0.006774814333766699, 0.053714048117399216, -0.009282338432967663, -0.0698394775390625, -0.0350768156349659, 0.028745658695697784, 0.0273620393127203, -0.034868452697992325, 0.006371190305799246, -0.021584970876574516, -0.03851274773478508, -0.039525106549263, 0.03137356787919998, 0.013820555992424488, -0.02836485020816326, -0.00824629608541727, 0.02639024332165718, 0.002007922623306513, -0.018716657534241676, -0.006490679457783699, 0.06148063391447067, -0.040498435497283936, -0.02676250971853733, -0.056732770055532455, -0.08043453097343445, 0.012733480893075466, -0.041438523679971695, -0.027190648019313812, -0.022244900465011597, -0.010956206358969212, 0.00511644221842289, 0.05444777384400368, -0.059975557029247284, -0.00295400433242321, 0.06693898886442184, -0.029192645102739334, 0.04304042086005211, 0.06915667653083801, -0.029844438657164574, 0.05700105056166649, -0.017035067081451416, -0.014872283674776554, -0.004703459795564413, -0.037943035364151, -0.02970387041568756, 0.013118956238031387, -0.04662837088108063, 0.00008685085049364716, 0.025315046310424805, 0.030753353610634804, -0.0589248426258564, 0.0001714612590149045, 0.045543789863586426, 0.04035095125436783, -0.02120189368724823, 0.024507157504558563, 0.046127185225486755, -0.020072951912879944, -0.049284014850854874, 0.005535244941711426, -0.02754894271492958, -0.037189483642578125, 0.03728258237242699, -0.049873288720846176, -0.027611015364527702, 0.04330422356724739, 0.019819064065814018, -0.005319742951542139, 0.014069017954170704, -0.0007227310561574996, -0.01135497447103262, -0.056629568338394165, -0.026131797581911087, -0.009370616637170315, -0.0562908872961998, -0.024638978764414787, 0.028819411993026733, 0.05015949159860611, 0.014660212211310863, 0.031741224229335785, 0.03157595545053482, -0.006987134460359812, 0.027064146474003792, -0.011346503160893917, 0.027435706928372383, 0.013265853747725487, -0.020503101870417595, 0.017862478271126747, -0.044460996985435486, 0.017049739137291908, 0.0130129624158144, 0.058838892728090286, -0.03105807676911354, 0.023832958191633224, -0.026208052411675453, -0.001184763852506876, 0.0019302483415231109, -0.03742745518684387, -0.04395279288291931, 0.003625367069616914, 0.03894186019897461, -0.002001475775614381, 0.010645993985235691, 0.017417090013623238, 0.005740318913012743, 0.022217998281121254, -0.008634581230580807, -0.04940628260374069, -0.01822163164615631, 0.03299766778945923, 0.06626304239034653, -0.0564146488904953, 0.00481488136574626, -0.04294094815850258, -0.03253643959760666, 0.02444702945649624, -0.06336069107055664, 0.025834156200289726, 0.00415807543322444, 0.009287501685321331, -0.021284399554133415, 0.06465189903974533, 0.015151700004935265, -0.06743941456079483, 0.03986364230513573, -0.0038282908499240875, -0.07850596308708191, -0.022888094186782837, -0.012010362930595875, -0.011057860217988491, -0.05819028243422508, 0.04081167280673981, 0.03514872118830681, -0.006931459065526724, -0.035097215324640274, 0.06888557225465775, 0.07744184881448746, -0.04430028423666954, 0.0016931368736550212, 0.026223083958029747, -0.06825505942106247, -0.017777299508452415, 0.012650000862777233, -0.010519789531826973, 0.02108476683497429, -0.0003329355677124113, 0.03613705560564995, -0.04531491547822952, -0.042625151574611664, 0.043647587299346924, -0.06465420871973038, -0.006283327005803585, 0.022942375391721725, 0.034018248319625854, 0.049231015145778656, -0.014035450294613838, -0.023550407961010933, 0.0209994874894619, 0.014217572286725044, 0.016364753246307373, -0.06609491258859634, -0.008608194999396801, 0.01842728815972805, 0.03559885174036026, -0.004198905546218157, -0.07596413046121597, -0.031948648393154144, -0.03153594583272934, -0.07985249161720276, 0.023827794939279556, -0.07396570593118668, 0.023215411230921745, 0.012925151735544205, 0.020401006564497948, 0.007440278772264719, 0.053245846182107925, -0.012960589490830898, -0.030268553644418716, 0.03460873290896416, 0.015265798196196556, 0.0056566414423286915, -0.03215310722589493, -0.00393719645217061, -0.05353834852576256, 0.03227299824357033, -0.035234034061431885, -0.026876550167798996, 0.02520854026079178, -0.05996554344892502, -0.01942971535027027, 0.034927573055028915, -0.0120015237480402, -0.050830524414777756, 0.018892137333750725, -0.03892022371292114, -0.01121379341930151, 0.029144514352083206, -0.05512973293662071, -0.06827687472105026, -0.034068141132593155, 0.021030358970165253, -0.008104359731078148, 0.024025211110711098, 0.025926969945430756, 0.008466887287795544, -0.04037374630570412, 0.023247968405485153, 0.012125380337238312, -0.012756514362990856, 0.013163428753614426, -0.05272766575217247, -0.0325808972120285, -0.016139818355441093, -0.04443921893835068, -0.026359833776950836, 0.01779906451702118, 0.04079601541161537, -0.06493517756462097, 0.0005354928434826434, 0.05760723352432251, 0.03127346932888031, 0.005920105148106813, -0.05023747310042381, 0.03840295225381851, 0.005754383280873299, -0.06658108532428741, -0.04821149259805679, 0.040118396282196045, -0.0031679074745625257, -0.051961854100227356, -0.033125899732112885, -0.031613901257514954, -0.007158495020121336, -0.022271279245615005, -0.07528595626354218, 0.0064822714775800705, 0.01303386315703392, 0.005896939896047115, -0.0080893374979496, -0.04503770172595978, 0.01994437538087368, -0.054928310215473175, 0.0334804505109787, -0.021418042480945587, 0.026611892506480217, 0.028415590524673462, 0.028925051912665367, -0.03426866605877876, -0.06888027489185333, -0.015326138585805893, 0.051137518137693405, -0.03234825283288956, -0.0009908187203109264, -0.031912803649902344, 0.022859865799546242, 0.020851487293839455, 0.005012182053178549, 0.058850985020399094, -0.05531490221619606, 0.043478164821863174, -0.05798177421092987, 0.017900418490171432, 0.0007705299649387598, -0.029490981251001358, 0.035711005330085754, 0.004474091809242964, -0.03715577721595764, 0.01600983552634716, 0.0018707722192630172, 0.01055655162781477, -0.030523572117090225, -0.03632515296339989, -0.017789525911211967, 0.001031244290061295, -0.04257204383611679, 0.04736540466547012, 0.018391110002994537, -0.04227618873119354, -0.017642855644226074, -0.011022309772670269, -0.04416542127728462, 0.06724746525287628, 0.03246140852570534, -0.030903855338692665, -0.014361453242599964, -0.05145813524723053, 0.0021528592333197594, -0.020235266536474228, -0.007598890457302332, -0.026253482326865196, 0.07143741101026535, -0.01575375534594059, -0.027384525164961815, -0.049118660390377045, -0.026713475584983826, -0.0418316088616848, -0.07243800908327103, -0.021511970087885857, -0.03481597825884819, -0.01752534694969654, 0.0016306096222251654, -0.024392805993556976, -0.03355323523283005, 0.03655773028731346, 0.00048197765136137605, 0.0037650892045348883, -0.03383330628275871, 0.0249240230768919, -0.05301468074321747, 0.05362096428871155, 0.003652309998869896, 0.0188785158097744, -0.03951536491513252, 0.024271942675113678, 0.006315430160611868, -0.03195711597800255, 0.019503911957144737, -0.022272031754255295, 0.02828208915889263, -0.05748354271054268, 0.01720103807747364, 0.02938006818294525, -0.011490092612802982, -0.07759831100702286, -0.009712918661534786, -0.02721025049686432, -0.05431782081723213, -0.06087251007556915 ]
Ongoing research explores thermal switching materials to control heat flow. Specifically, there has been interest in magneto-thermal switching (MTS) materials based on superconductors, which only exhibited switching behavior when a magnetic field was applied. However, a recent report highlighted nonvolatile MTS in commercial Sn-Pb solders, attributed to magnetic flux trapping. In this study, we focused on flux trapping in a type-II superconductor MgB2. Magnetization and thermal conductivity measurements under magnetic fields were conducted on polycrystalline MgB2. We confirmed that magnetic flux was indeed trapped in MgB2 even after demagnetization. Additionally, we observed nonvolatile MTS in MgB2 as well as Sn-Pb solders. These results suggest that the nonvolatile MTS may be a widespread characteristic of superconducting materials with flux trapping.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16404v1
[ -0.02036316692829132, -0.011860113590955734, 0.050075288861989975, -0.009352781809866428, 0.022641224786639214, -0.0017555714584887028, 0.021829649806022644, 0.005529165733605623, -0.024944331496953964, 0.0018546521896496415, -0.015032513067126274, 0.0014992442447692156, -0.010489951819181442, -0.04145156964659691, -0.011755219660699368, 0.03663837909698486, 0.051261648535728455, 0.029377929866313934, 0.011689340695738792, 0.03732739016413689, -0.010327132418751717, -0.021621210500597954, -0.034110866487026215, 0.05709563568234444, -0.0036167048383504152, -0.011409296654164791, -0.037490539252758026, -0.014457086101174355, -0.05339793115854263, -0.039087049663066864, -0.01137609127908945, -0.04323428496718407, -0.026124518364667892, 0.0073573775589466095, 0.0167445857077837, 0.016393303871154785, -0.0073226396925747395, -0.015407664701342583, 0.008892917074263096, -0.056630633771419525, -0.009607498534023762, 0.012395584024488926, -0.03939378634095192, -0.0515260323882103, -0.024298200383782387, -0.03502252697944641, -0.04042978957295418, 0.023912591859698296, -0.035750847309827805, -0.03293093293905258, 0.014924315735697746, 0.03153662756085396, 0.0026624049060046673, 0.0243768859654665, -0.04482398182153702, -0.030716102570295334, -0.02043052949011326, -0.022011831402778625, -0.06941285729408264, 0.010736601427197456, 0.019070900976657867, -0.0032822429202497005, 0.024107497185468674, -0.048921484500169754, -0.08446234464645386, 0.002815834479406476, -0.04891696199774742, -0.03505066782236099, -0.04261815920472145, -0.09282733500003815, 0.016924124211072922, -0.05239906162023544, 0.025195883587002754, 0.0033619997557252645, -0.014521264471113682, -0.03304274007678032, -0.06617183238267899, 0.03168095648288727, -0.051205024123191833, -0.007998396642506123, -0.03517074137926102, 0.022386180236935616, 0.004868522752076387, -0.0254850871860981, 0.02931683138012886, -0.011950911954045296, 0.006020015105605125, -0.061129942536354065, 0.01350521668791771, -0.037217818200588226, -0.013047095388174057, -0.03029095195233822, -0.04781493917107582, 0.011628961190581322, 0.0597764290869236, -0.043800290673971176, 0.04311612993478775, 0.03161241486668587, 0.0440746508538723, -0.00020084688731003553, 0.010391280986368656, -0.009811856783926487, -0.052703987807035446, 0.04307261109352112, -0.060057077556848526, -0.031395796686410904, 0.016809893772006035, 0.005170261487364769, 0.005422197747975588, -0.04075836390256882, -0.018456069752573967, -0.013165689073503017, 0.018256668001413345, -0.027495788410305977, -0.009900955483317375, -0.028879346325993538, 0.039778731763362885, -0.010298452340066433, -0.0009756363579072058, 0.03453269600868225, -0.031549300998449326, 0.029138479381799698, 0.03721552714705467, 0.02344834804534912, -0.004294207319617271, -0.003654027823358774, 0.04718474671244621, -0.019963983446359634, -0.04487420991063118, -0.06066623330116272, -0.046948548406362534, 0.013575450517237186, 0.047546904534101486, -0.04542670398950577, 0.07455107569694519, 0.010601602494716644, 0.011297198012471199, 0.010555817745625973, -0.016658561304211617, -0.05397231876850128, -0.02212897315621376, 0.003904498415067792, 0.022156383842229843, -0.022617463022470474, 0.03542592003941536, -0.003202425315976143, -0.056701622903347015, 0.040267620235681534, -0.018536342307925224, 0.016536442562937737, 0.021548911929130554, 0.006806075572967529, -0.020889047533273697, 0.03442688658833504, -0.000100268742244225, -0.0019512467551976442, 0.036321889609098434, -0.0007312522502616048, -0.011440813541412354, 0.020190829411149025, 0.024352317675948143, -0.01003542635589838, 0.03394756093621254, -0.06706391274929047, 0.03558944910764694, -0.041738953441381454, 0.0050763776525855064, 0.0028363815508782864, -0.0316111296415329, -0.009476696141064167, 0.039390336722135544, -0.02576454170048237, 0.022439638152718544, -0.04408828541636467, -0.068293496966362, -0.016048049554228783, -0.008569713681936264, -0.06685744225978851, -0.023740755394101143, -0.008578156121075153, 0.03130773827433586, 0.01698058657348156, -0.04218992963433266, -0.06981249898672104, -0.051198091357946396, 0.041522812098264694, -0.08663394302129745, -0.0028383482713252306, 0.02658362127840519, -0.03447236493229866, -0.0036484026350080967, 0.04321105778217316, 0.024371366947889328, -0.043979573994874954, -0.009109877981245518, 0.004477363545447588, -0.007320965640246868, 0.02488047629594803, 0.008647065609693527, 0.0014344686642289162, -0.08026938885450363, -0.033855002373456955, -0.05011243373155594, 0.011918816715478897, -0.03677653893828392, -0.07079765200614929, 0.00879778154194355, -0.008658663369715214, -0.03321385756134987, -0.03857380896806717, 0.045414477586746216, 0.010504879988729954, -0.033771902322769165, 0.016581077128648758, 0.01846095360815525, -0.022049009799957275, -0.09668505936861038, -0.0173308365046978, 0.0032723143231123686, 0.019098564982414246, 0.028561143204569817, -0.022352231666445732, -0.03581550344824791, -0.03920436277985573, -0.006449109874665737, 0.05508534237742424, 0.05720335617661476, 0.04805269464850426, -0.0016506542451679707, 0.055675677955150604, 0.06437183171510696, -0.042772382497787476, -0.06450711190700531, -0.03804014250636101, 0.003681025467813015, -0.03029806539416313, -0.070423424243927, 0.0348333865404129, -0.014955149032175541, -0.0525103360414505, 0.005351331550627947, -0.023707598447799683, 0.058096759021282196, -0.020903609693050385, -0.009362101554870605, -0.004881975706666708, -0.03052050806581974, 0.03920849412679672, -0.05161665007472038, 0.02181585691869259, -0.02481180615723133, -0.05091799795627594, -0.030962981283664703, -0.030757661908864975, 0.04772757738828659, 0.036328721791505814, -0.05538661777973175, -0.018458368256688118, 0.019061477854847908, 0.002060076454654336, 0.012122909538447857, 0.05630412697792053, -0.03590354695916176, 0.02971365861594677, 0.010624254122376442, -0.024851525202393532, -0.054774168878793716, 0.009448358789086342, -0.004014004487544298, -0.034837719053030014, 0.057641200721263885, 0.0206596776843071, 0.03589208796620369, -0.016744794324040413, -0.006617482285946608, -0.05052554979920387, -0.020678406581282616, -0.050613366067409515, -0.008320662193000317, 0.031408365815877914, 0.07363396137952805, 0.040795039385557175, 0.0250225979834795, -0.06217607483267784, -0.014949221163988113, -0.057252585887908936, -0.0009176678140647709, -0.05460410192608833, -0.03709213435649872, -0.023508664220571518, -0.043324001133441925, -0.0322016179561615, -0.019990619271993637, 0.03679128363728523, -0.012798509560525417, -0.05490030348300934, -0.02402961067855358, 0.023279137909412384, 0.011065555736422539, -0.020946228876709938, -0.025712110102176666, 0.03726472333073616, -0.014542545191943645, -0.01952279731631279, -0.0011508086463436484, -0.015233594924211502, -0.01131182536482811, -0.000034266333386767656, -0.0013753861421719193, 0.00844531413167715, -0.012546559795737267, 0.016651371493935585, -0.0597686842083931, 0.013139958493411541, -0.04949997365474701, 0.06744138896465302, 0.04285493865609169, -0.012343527749180794, 0.006463220342993736, -0.03982825204730034, 0.029527856037020683, -0.03242390230298042, -0.05382192134857178, -0.008122896775603294, -0.05482237786054611, -0.03598136827349663, 0.07276280969381332, 0.07059308141469955, -0.009155606850981712, -0.0340120792388916, -0.05692402273416519, -0.0021128091029822826, -0.040494538843631744, 0.018873367458581924, 0.07229738682508469, -0.0404580719769001, -0.0315612256526947, 0.009397406131029129, -0.045672062784433365, 0.010090900585055351, -0.02374786138534546, -0.042480550706386566, 0.013637654483318329, -0.016030671074986458, -0.02437465824186802, 0.01144331879913807, -0.033785268664360046, 0.06669057905673981, 0.03359794616699219, -0.03235854208469391, -0.023967666551470757, 0.01445738784968853, 0.005701852031052113, 0.061433762311935425, 0.043428752571344376, 0.0029460962396115065, 0.023923611268401146, 0.03682224825024605, -0.08524174243211746, 0.026591707020998, 0.0009628957486711442, 0.015537314116954803, -0.04779370129108429, 0.02381831407546997, 0.03563666716217995, 0.013336761854588985, 0.0450344979763031, -0.04176760092377663, 0.0073897517286241055, -0.028667375445365906, 0.04605856165289879, -0.05718502029776573, -0.06234480068087578, -0.019245730713009834, -0.027642078697681427, -0.007469823118299246, 0.023588666692376137, -0.053997207432985306, -0.06642744690179825, -0.032321035861968994, -0.010055724531412125, -0.042696643620729446, 0.045696403831243515, 0.05216614156961441, 0.05168243125081062, 0.032072003930807114, 0.05416467785835266, 0.03699579834938049, -0.035629577934741974, -0.03254023194313049, -0.021051323041319847, -0.04267510399222374, -0.029023684561252594, 0.056089650839567184, -0.008505175821483135, -0.06603146344423294, 0.0011902956757694483, 0.05478606000542641, -0.026626907289028168, 0.060077715665102005, 0.03698333725333214, 0.004175808280706406, -0.007000769022852182, -0.08770832419395447, -0.04449334740638733, -0.05616633594036102, 0.046036843210458755, 0.028547223657369614, -0.029400048777461052, 0.05608643218874931, -0.006836295127868652, 0.022557247430086136, -0.012221653014421463, -0.008924741297960281, -0.052864812314510345, -0.04748363420367241, -0.007523548323661089, -0.036886341869831085, 0.022802656516432762, -0.0298679880797863, 0.037606336176395416, -0.04325586184859276, -0.025787431746721268, -0.07467196136713028, -0.028782999143004417, 0.01614140346646309, -0.008405727334320545, 0.0538778081536293, 0.015016254968941212, -0.006953881122171879, -0.0024696963373571634, -0.03681167960166931, -0.0424882173538208, -0.018876170739531517, 0.0431184247136116, -0.021577512845396996, 0.014476457610726357, -0.03294914588332176, -0.03003525547683239, -0.04703269153833389, -0.014255532063543797, 0.06258291751146317, -0.02234230749309063, 0.005251502152532339, -0.021520713344216347, -0.00007358120637945831, 0.04203672334551811, -0.05636345222592354, 0.0010011224076151848, -0.037185993045568466, -0.04857150837779045, 0.02370375022292137, 0.013582163490355015, -0.01634335145354271, 0.0156845860183239, -0.04115164652466774, 0.015165500342845917, 0.011532803997397423, -0.026644622907042503, -0.027100801467895508, 0.023063046857714653, -0.02813039720058441, -0.032566770911216736, -0.011229555122554302, -0.03415052592754364, -0.014466283842921257, 0.023716555908322334, 0.029014814645051956, 0.029195331037044525, 0.008719880133867264, -0.025237886235117912, 0.03040597401559353, -0.05509212240576744, 0.01662682555615902, 0.05610687658190727, -0.023822970688343048, -0.046783287078142166, 0.015343626961112022, -0.01360352709889412, 0.014886239543557167, -0.018592210486531258, 0.02142384462058544, 0.0024168987292796373, -0.028139520436525345, 0.01134782936424017, 0.008130365051329136, 0.014745312742888927, -0.039892252534627914, -0.026805192232131958, 0.021314075216650963, -0.0716848224401474, 0.07105784863233566, 0.0359957329928875, -0.02788664773106575, -0.022250885143876076, -0.0039536841213703156, 0.03334842994809151, -0.025917090475559235, -0.05369286984205246, -0.03436009958386421, 0.011272161267697811, 0.006643056403845549, 0.05130409076809883, -0.06551893055438995, 0.0009825269225984812, -0.048719000071287155, -0.022224940359592438, 0.06663412600755692, 0.03837160766124725, -0.02728932537138462, 0.01586962305009365, 0.047110483050346375, -0.015267997048795223, -0.06715455651283264, -0.000330804759869352, -0.09211722761392593, -0.02421913482248783, 0.00874344166368246, 0.05866676941514015, 0.07188962399959564, 0.058211714029312134, 0.0033089234493672848, -0.03340499475598335, -0.012338345870375633, -0.07273757457733154, 0.036259058862924576, -0.029554272070527077, 0.016636740416288376, -0.02577608823776245, 0.04231033846735954, 0.018205778673291206, -0.009700569324195385, -0.030251240357756615, 0.0400376096367836, -0.056116387248039246, -0.01097993552684784, -0.049042824655771255, -0.03870443254709244, -0.05968490615487099, 0.027441442012786865, 0.040349818766117096, -0.05862099304795265, 0.025270922109484673, -0.0008896776707842946, 0.002981619443744421, -0.004475359804928303, 0.0220187921077013, 0.00244294130243361, -0.04958665743470192, 0.01542265061289072, 0.06765672564506531, -0.08412783592939377, -0.03404499590396881, -0.049821995198726654, -0.03441357985138893, -0.009304000996053219, -0.04073510318994522, 0.0010860869660973549, 0.07015037536621094, 0.01609334722161293, -0.030145877972245216, -0.017793960869312286, 0.003987573087215424, -0.08096315711736679, -0.01433313824236393, -0.024963442236185074, -0.06794606149196625, -0.030741116032004356, 0.012845204211771488, -0.011144175194203854, -0.045427463948726654, 0.02436906099319458, -0.010683240368962288, -0.05400380492210388, -0.059357915073633194, 0.04828691482543945, 0.0361962653696537, -0.005051536485552788, -0.03792537748813629, 0.00839234609156847, -0.040032267570495605, -0.02731969766318798, -0.03673234581947327, 0.010786401107907295, 0.020561059936881065, 0.04969377443194389, 0.05760224908590317, -0.020892420783638954, -0.006092321593314409, 0.02238839864730835, 0.0232898760586977, -0.0030851303599774837, 0.050090108066797256, 0.047733042389154434, 0.031966857612133026, -0.031111806631088257, -0.017268111929297447, 0.03699110448360443, -0.0030878009274601936, 0.009656364098191261, -0.01677178591489792, -0.026364751160144806, -0.012228161096572876, 0.026938948780298233, 0.04737132787704468, -0.041748955845832825, 0.010942739434540272, -0.017918607220053673, -0.08069398254156113, 0.002123673912137747, 0.02137860842049122, 0.006447196006774902, -0.012136456556618214, 0.02022884599864483, 0.0019331539515405893, 0.04599618539214134, -0.05371154472231865, -0.026759393513202667, -0.04290101304650307, -0.05696764215826988, 0.031286392360925674, -0.01172652468085289, 0.04174673929810524, -0.001004083314910531, 0.03380172327160835, -0.046846915036439896, -0.0113012520596385, 0.0010890510166063905, -0.06854362040758133, 0.01878923736512661, -0.005412455182522535, -0.011421330273151398, 0.02185227908194065, -0.000557499413844198, 0.004027789458632469, 0.031100861728191376, -0.01681840419769287, -0.026121411472558975, -0.011225773021578789, -0.02397645264863968, -0.03024217300117016, 0.0097737405449152, 0.019865065813064575, -0.025644879788160324, 0.040503937751054764, -0.040505316108465195, -0.01955595798790455, -0.02210913971066475, -0.009648403152823448, 0.04118645191192627, -0.05602773278951645, 0.0008698838064447045, 0.041097234934568405, 0.011237404309213161, 0.0007505636312998831, 0.0002950083289761096, -0.017443565651774406, -0.06940015405416489, -0.03853443264961243, 0.04978548735380173, -0.028312191367149353, -0.03806544467806816, -0.04163963347673416, -0.0005430462770164013, 0.04875902831554413, -0.0307078305631876, -0.07486335933208466, 0.011525598354637623, -0.027029383927583694, -0.05542607605457306, 0.005115833133459091, -0.010658426210284233, -0.03716858848929405, 0.022586654871702194, -0.0822756290435791, -0.04879405349493027, -0.010085901245474815, 0.05863900110125542, 0.0233872439712286, -0.042870670557022095, 0.015842726454138756, -0.04963373765349388, 0.03532842919230461, 0.06966864317655563, -0.017413422465324402, 0.006065597292035818, -0.05226987600326538, 0.04020753130316734, -0.044037993997335434, -0.012231023982167244, 0.0060851420275866985, 0.005633540917187929, 0.001123993075452745, 0.000494492007419467, 0.0488644614815712, -0.04955345019698143, -0.017225194722414017, 0.03959318622946739, -0.013441856950521469, 0.02145288698375225, -0.0062219370156526566, -0.009761007502675056, -0.04417355731129646, -0.08106350153684616, 0.007432679645717144, -0.03594035655260086, 0.033979859203100204, 0.05361286178231239, 0.003687927732244134, 0.01760968193411827, -0.08010885864496231, -0.024930723011493683, -0.012551971711218357, 0.03156866878271103, -0.007901265285909176, 0.08014564216136932, -0.03411665931344032, -0.031191039830446243, -0.0003097756998613477, -0.030135422945022583, -0.04608361795544624, -0.019380314275622368, 0.03140620142221451, -0.05979456007480621, 0.03362736105918884, -0.07721032202243805, 0.06698069721460342, -0.020137151703238487, 0.01606333814561367, 0.01183166354894638, 0.04018121212720871, -0.0775698721408844, 0.030392197892069817, -0.051639165729284286, 0.006346606649458408, 0.0071690925396978855, -0.009099632501602173, -0.038843851536512375, 0.030389100313186646, -0.031836386770009995, -0.011860093101859093, -0.007377958856523037, 0.033558279275894165, 0.034253545105457306, -0.027016526088118553, -0.026723163202404976, 0.009791816584765911, -0.047034021466970444, -0.0036882441490888596, 0.06746167689561844, -0.03493792563676834, -0.0030167128425091505, -0.05069621652364731, 0.041872359812259674, 0.006305806338787079, -0.002019868465140462, 0.04211897775530815, 0.01775495894253254, -0.021258609369397163, -0.000723628792911768, -0.047194916754961014, 0.06678703427314758, 0.014126159250736237, -0.013847061432898045, -0.05911664664745331, 0.04399890452623367, -0.024981066584587097, -0.06349582225084305 ]
Scene text image super-resolution (STISR) is an important pre-processing technique for text recognition from low-resolution scene images. Nowadays, various methods have been proposed to extract text-specific information from high-resolution (HR) images to supervise STISR model training. However, due to uncontrollable factors (e.g. shooting equipment, focus, and environment) in manually photographing HR images, the quality of HR images cannot be guaranteed, which unavoidably impacts STISR performance. Observing the quality issue of HR images, in this paper we propose a novel idea to boost STISR by first enhancing the quality of HR images and then using the enhanced HR images as supervision to do STISR. Concretely, we develop a new STISR framework, called High-Resolution ENhancement (HiREN) that consists of two branches and a quality estimation module. The first branch is developed to recover the low-resolution (LR) images, and the other is an HR quality enhancement branch aiming at generating high-quality (HQ) text images based on the HR images to provide more accurate supervision to the LR images. As the degradation from HQ to HR may be diverse, and there is no pixel-level supervision for HQ image generation, we design a kernel-guided enhancement network to handle various degradation, and exploit the feedback from a recognizer and text-level annotations as weak supervision signal to train the HR enhancement branch. Then, a quality estimation module is employed to evaluate the qualities of HQ images, which are used to suppress the erroneous supervision information by weighting the loss of each image. Extensive experiments on TextZoom show that HiREN can work well with most existing STISR methods and significantly boost their performances.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16410v1
[ -0.022042518481612206, -0.0198346134275198, -0.020348338410258293, -0.023499300703406334, -0.028650235384702682, -0.05236806720495224, -0.05079814791679382, -0.001938299392350018, -0.015187173150479794, -0.06590205430984497, -0.05733916908502579, -0.00013560162915382534, -0.042284466326236725, -0.0022109963465481997, -0.030889060348272324, 0.02443729154765606, 0.07866779714822769, 0.0010112235322594643, -0.058521151542663574, 0.046764787286520004, -0.016193043440580368, -0.016237029805779457, -0.05771411955356598, -0.004128084052354097, 0.02991422824561596, -0.0421048067510128, -0.0623428076505661, -0.01655220054090023, -0.06458085775375366, 0.02230098471045494, 0.060200177133083344, -0.015294808894395828, -0.040083449333906174, -0.02608632855117321, -0.011947917751967907, -0.005982111673802137, -0.00909468438476324, 0.03599681705236435, 0.011566651053726673, -0.06524793058633804, 0.017842350527644157, -0.05338927358388901, -0.02138288877904415, -0.04035520553588867, -0.00539506645873189, 0.010251196101307869, -0.057586200535297394, 0.03359590470790863, -0.08822771906852722, -0.012053359299898148, 0.04035955294966698, 0.002123225713148713, 0.003902389667928219, 0.041966475546360016, -0.009092038497328758, -0.03352470323443413, 0.025664623826742172, -0.011292570270597935, -0.07017579674720764, -0.027577314525842667, 0.032083407044410706, -0.028116511180996895, -0.011766373179852962, -0.04863723739981651, -0.005535027477890253, 0.028875112533569336, -0.06690246611833572, -0.06624278426170349, -0.022257981821894646, -0.03884325549006462, 0.04912949353456497, -0.06283149123191833, 0.05437782406806946, 0.002575433114543557, -0.0073538413271307945, -0.0362573005259037, -0.054862335324287415, -0.05737226456403732, 0.007812938652932644, -0.028434066101908684, -0.0647231787443161, 0.08040783554315567, 0.028519634157419205, 0.038157716393470764, -0.009270691312849522, -0.036698319017887115, 0.02561626024544239, -0.00809702929109335, 0.00006876452243886888, -0.06008712202310562, 0.041746314615011215, -0.030843278393149376, -0.05726340413093567, -0.0063284020870924, -0.026800014078617096, 0.017055463045835495, 0.07053923606872559, -0.016354480758309364, 0.03542930260300636, -0.026558073237538338, 0.00824277475476265, 0.018121588975191116, -0.018683386966586113, 0.07961812615394592, 0.021349959075450897, -0.03640511631965637, -0.02622637152671814, 0.038805246353149414, -0.04140886664390564, -0.036237262189388275, -0.03972037136554718, -0.05004056170582771, 0.0340055450797081, -0.0695178285241127, -0.017281757667660713, -0.025435058400034904, 0.060405731201171875, 0.015679800882935524, -0.027695883065462112, -0.02657032012939453, -0.0526735782623291, 0.05033695325255394, 0.05525756627321243, -0.05946820229291916, -0.06492026150226593, -0.04113064333796501, 0.03260265290737152, 0.02969042770564556, 0.02807680144906044, 0.005949013400822878, -0.006584453862160444, 0.018839474767446518, -0.019506661221385002, 0.001966974465176463, 0.012019836343824863, -0.029349202290177345, 0.0014799749478697777, -0.06393267214298248, 0.018054522573947906, -0.00836491771042347, -0.008853556588292122, -0.05721701309084892, -0.0069987038150429726, -0.028443682938814163, 0.013812092132866383, 0.053619422018527985, 0.028655413538217545, -0.04221836104989052, -0.010568595491349697, 0.03959321975708008, 0.01945260539650917, -0.048101022839546204, 0.05854008346796036, 0.030688436701893806, -0.003890639403834939, -0.040234822779893875, 0.04548701271414757, -0.0354117788374424, -0.041855692863464355, 0.007175769191235304, 0.01531402301043272, -0.004504920914769173, 0.04315897077322006, -0.02837466076016426, 0.03337368369102478, -0.003250342793762684, 0.045028600841760635, -0.00610716175287962, 0.03165370970964432, 0.05009758844971657, -0.00807105004787445, -0.025265581905841827, 0.004227291792631149, 0.008168736472725868, -0.07913841307163239, 0.010251643136143684, 0.016196656972169876, -0.039449986070394516, -0.017585763707756996, -0.028382178395986557, -0.06267400085926056, 0.025664083659648895, 0.012864085845649242, -0.01248746458441019, -0.008778797462582588, -0.006774314679205418, -0.0834994912147522, -0.05238024517893791, 0.047980938106775284, 0.017675166949629784, -0.020522667095065117, -0.011571190319955349, 0.012114077806472778, -0.028918961063027382, -0.014656657353043556, -0.024905873462557793, -0.019605642184615135, -0.03430119529366493, 0.040930576622486115, 0.021334568038582802, -0.08955525606870651, -0.01938951201736927, -0.04347362369298935, 0.014049532823264599, -0.01185411773622036, -0.06979911774396896, -0.05236707255244255, 0.043178725987672806, -0.04346843436360359, 0.03287474066019058, 0.006166499573737383, 0.05298145115375519, 0.03979739174246788, -0.019759854301810265, 0.06175309419631958, -0.010743275284767151, -0.09195398539304733, 0.013774271123111248, -0.061799611896276474, -0.026633037254214287, -0.011045567691326141, 0.01236253697425127, 0.014062954112887383, -0.0023223995231091976, -0.014583473093807697, -0.00794204045087099, 0.05853360518813133, -0.030708936974406242, -0.06134825572371483, -0.004265109542757273, -0.046636614948511124, -0.05101003870368004, 0.0009657132322899997, -0.06035111844539642, -0.006426852196455002, -0.009355077520012856, -0.01622270606458187, 0.025597678497433662, -0.0497610867023468, 0.0057435850612819195, -0.037783458828926086, 0.010502215474843979, 0.02197386510670185, 0.017956189811229706, -0.04781967028975487, -0.049189046025276184, 0.023080522194504738, -0.010279206559062004, -0.01879807747900486, 0.005611875560134649, -0.047380223870277405, -0.044513020664453506, -0.0006038442370481789, 0.015606464818120003, 0.0474531389772892, 0.011067254468798637, -0.03734111040830612, 0.03142842277884483, -0.0590193048119545, 0.03958506882190704, 0.03553323820233345, 0.03613881766796112, -0.08021687716245651, 0.009091987274587154, -0.038565706461668015, -0.022392818704247475, -0.017350703477859497, -0.02568937838077545, -0.00876432191580534, -0.04064489156007767, -0.028124088421463966, 0.032307788729667664, 0.01014011912047863, -0.006202430929988623, -0.01506126020103693, -0.04462491720914841, 0.027606826275587082, 0.02111414261162281, 0.040080808103084564, 0.015359670855104923, 0.022951161488890648, 0.022231142967939377, -0.04018668830394745, -0.06106729805469513, 0.03646928444504738, -0.06386352330446243, -0.03914598003029823, -0.0662861093878746, -0.0660059005022049, -0.02439742721617222, -0.06757339090108871, -0.0021258494816720486, -0.005967150907963514, -0.05035931617021561, -0.02450128272175789, -0.041683245450258255, -0.0511385016143322, 0.027027253061532974, 0.05337334796786308, -0.0028196643106639385, -0.009410712867975235, -0.0037796315737068653, 0.04310644790530205, -0.0071781291626393795, -0.04044286534190178, -0.042602669447660446, -0.05990701541304588, -0.05356748029589653, 0.018524542450904846, -0.03722676634788513, -0.06286831945180893, -0.002706648549064994, -0.006255874410271645, 0.004408946260809898, -0.0007459582411684096, 0.046495258808135986, 0.03263205289840698, 0.045834239572286606, -0.01694575510919094, -0.01932632550597191, -0.013827737420797348, -0.04094499349594116, -0.028436336666345596, -0.05691446736454964, -0.030298545956611633, -0.03746078163385391, 0.04347002133727074, -0.004594137892127037, 0.011213255114853382, -0.044394515454769135, 0.025141261518001556, -0.008820310235023499, -0.06441585719585419, 0.00780855817720294, 0.018466979265213013, -0.03565173223614693, -0.032439228147268295, -0.04077112674713135, 0.007814149372279644, -0.0034697353839874268, 0.023179547861218452, -0.0030898370314389467, -0.04901200905442238, 0.02411964163184166, -0.011983664706349373, -0.09105415642261505, 0.045224495232105255, 0.025278931483626366, 0.08627250790596008, 0.004456551745533943, -0.009479966945946217, 0.006201586686074734, -0.022123171016573906, -0.013879728503525257, -0.045489806681871414, -0.024449286982417107, 0.028461482375860214, 0.033210963010787964, -0.02825714834034443, -0.027269020676612854, -0.024412164464592934, -0.022612666711211205, -0.00726355891674757, -0.017808305099606514, 0.04473317041993141, -0.00260588969103992, 0.030170980840921402, -0.0593351349234581, 0.009074178524315357, -0.021711083129048347, 0.03992026671767235, -0.001310507650487125, -0.04007463902235031, 0.04338441789150238, -0.04145321249961853, 0.05198417603969574, 0.0012565201614052057, 0.006083531305193901, 0.024208514019846916, -0.0589006245136261, 0.0014876952627673745, -0.0355740450322628, 0.04270860552787781, 0.017522135749459267, 0.00245665037073195, 0.039995744824409485, 0.051001280546188354, 0.011508438736200333, 0.0390462800860405, -0.0159130971878767, 0.006864132825285196, -0.023990508168935776, -0.021767636761069298, -0.011441854760050774, 0.034281399101018906, -0.05730602517724037, -0.015180227346718311, 0.012351860292255878, 0.020796462893486023, 0.011273065581917763, -0.007446300238370895, -0.025662820786237717, -0.02611479163169861, -0.06254255771636963, -0.0014157325495034456, -0.028491608798503876, 0.059024687856435776, -0.0007781093008816242, -0.04976766183972359, 0.04308528080582619, -0.07147815078496933, -0.03561944514513016, -0.06550566107034683, 0.0026816846802830696, -0.04310128092765808, -0.010856946930289268, -0.008550609461963177, -0.07924992591142654, -0.008538064546883106, -0.05901115760207176, 0.017792867496609688, 0.02867324836552143, 0.02150692045688629, -0.010346888564527035, -0.062363553792238235, -0.027970239520072937, 0.021416427567601204, 0.05700089782476425, -0.023786034435033798, -0.04530590400099754, 0.030344590544700623, -0.015077117830514908, 0.01732652820646763, 0.029421312734484673, 0.020639142021536827, -0.0001644919830141589, 0.03315306454896927, 0.0029200438875705004, 0.021075697615742683, -0.0278903990983963, 0.04216349869966507, 0.05186742544174194, -0.02173631824553013, -0.006207945290952921, 0.026743054389953613, 0.040526196360588074, 0.027733396738767624, -0.0564533993601799, -0.01642606593668461, -0.022182758897542953, -0.03345296159386635, -0.03513854369521141, 0.04551123455166817, 0.022138042375445366, -0.018938282504677773, -0.01370076835155487, 0.0482148602604866, -0.04148925468325615, 0.004411208443343639, -0.012674087658524513, 0.03262730687856674, -0.008489598520100117, -0.04741916060447693, 0.0009182141511701047, -0.06915528327226639, 0.036039866507053375, -0.02482011541724205, -0.032460588961839676, -0.0008672224939800799, -0.025535693392157555, -0.006834452506154776, 0.033143043518066406, -0.0761529728770256, 0.024685153737664223, 0.010371294803917408, -0.0034101458732038736, 0.025333812460303307, 0.07541526854038239, 0.02333962544798851, 0.07003654539585114, -0.008404609747231007, -0.002053671283647418, 0.03879719227552414, -0.0578608438372612, -0.035736631602048874, 0.012603780254721642, -0.03789327293634415, 0.008785250596702099, 0.04017065465450287, 0.032227396965026855, -0.047728557139635086, -0.004146107938140631, 0.033648476004600525, 0.025932468473911285, -0.01955491490662098, 0.03066440112888813, 0.026897303760051727, -0.024170206859707832, -0.05101783201098442, 0.0156867653131485, -0.01077602431178093, 0.010462907142937183, 0.02946331910789013, -0.01547645777463913, -0.022767990827560425, 0.002978598466143012, 0.0072069852612912655, -0.012930666096508503, 0.01284973043948412, -0.011868423782289028, 0.006645927671343088, -0.0015611064154654741, 0.03402397036552429, -0.001720324857160449, -0.04473883658647537, -0.039155468344688416, 0.06018142029643059, 0.028210483491420746, -0.002245145384222269, 0.02373882755637169, 0.02832547202706337, -0.0718505010008812, -0.012804465368390083, -0.011922321282327175, 0.017910508438944817, 0.018879054114222527, -0.0381045825779438, 0.03629103675484657, -0.045329153537750244, 0.03434072807431221, -0.03505009785294533, 0.03131141513586044, 0.049484241753816605, 0.03196154907345772, -0.03787815570831299, 0.027955543249845505, 0.038791656494140625, -0.030036723241209984, -0.061234015971422195, 0.026855820789933205, -0.03077014535665512, -0.03479595109820366, 0.05182528868317604, 0.01630055345594883, -0.003060496412217617, 0.03103463165462017, 0.009000391699373722, 0.015078062191605568, -0.05582090839743614, 0.007714778184890747, 0.04882914200425148, -0.05836695805191994, -0.02221924252808094, -0.013432316482067108, -0.016349025070667267, 0.03449162840843201, -0.05511412024497986, 0.03256849944591522, -0.020150262862443924, 0.0037267531733959913, -0.06778022646903992, 0.060069989413022995, -0.017297834157943726, -0.06397655606269836, 0.02755093201994896, -0.0015160037437453866, -0.04503171518445015, -0.010572881437838078, 0.012437117286026478, -0.027321187779307365, 0.008669719099998474, 0.03161478042602539, -0.03136793524026871, -0.022889913991093636, -0.03585471585392952, 0.07380777597427368, 0.08229658007621765, 0.0015484244795516133, 0.008858023211359978, -0.0070130228996276855, -0.060408562421798706, -0.06584989279508591, 0.05720120295882225, -0.021574659273028374, 0.025477532297372818, 0.012763360515236855, 0.026479056105017662, -0.01990405097603798, -0.016886012628674507, 0.04921198636293411, -0.03707969933748245, -0.059363991022109985, 0.004486964549869299, -0.008072799071669579, 0.06568824499845505, -0.04620625451207161, -0.029424268752336502, -0.038127921521663666, -0.01871601678431034, 0.021904543042182922, -0.04643513262271881, 0.0028995214961469173, 0.0057110595516860485, 0.04411680996417999, 0.0007006396190263331, -0.06360512226819992, 0.011807499453425407, -0.028734084218740463, -0.04935738444328308, -0.0019225541036576033, -0.06516901403665543, 0.012144643813371658, -0.04843505471944809, 0.00975083839148283, 0.026976214721798897, 0.047790516167879105, -0.03937540948390961, -0.031179247424006462, 0.005210520699620247, 0.003150095697492361, 0.03343234583735466, -0.010882573202252388, 0.0682378038764, 0.0025865735951811075, 0.01719031110405922, -0.07069415599107742, -0.04877128079533577, -0.012677891179919243, 0.0025612032040953636, 0.005164561327546835, 0.024560272693634033, -0.003107281168922782, -0.029286149889230728, 0.009718307293951511, -0.04030952602624893, 0.008965890854597092, 0.001989621901884675, -0.05560498312115669, -0.06931709498167038, -0.027796229347586632, 0.012593863531947136, -0.05203138664364815, 0.02640298195183277, 0.020679522305727005, 0.028455214574933052, -0.013047512620687485, 0.01303486805409193, -0.007842821069061756, 0.0036696535535156727, 0.043300189077854156, -0.06394597142934799, -0.004992150701582432, -0.03208858519792557, -0.03303109481930733, -0.03478914499282837, 0.05206643044948578, 0.0030837617814540863, -0.0638013482093811, -0.01762400195002556, 0.04608700051903725, 0.02066819556057453, -0.04033837094902992, -0.07614406943321228, 0.010642779059708118, 0.009733031503856182, -0.03530333936214447, -0.01565471664071083, 0.00028875231510028243, 0.0023492351174354553, -0.06405150890350342, -0.05430813133716583, -0.019910773262381554, -0.0198063887655735, 0.032560259103775024, -0.08175989985466003, 0.05304892361164093, 0.002729441039264202, 0.0747610554099083, -0.01893722638487816, -0.002822049893438816, -0.026829062029719353, 0.00007312214438570663, 0.0065130311995744705, 0.028749840334057808, 0.007682251278311014, 0.03108319826424122, 0.03838683292269707, -0.028667796403169632, -0.03279596194624901, -0.03605414181947708, -0.006672285031527281, 0.0024254838936030865, 0.007148270960897207, 0.04766242206096649, 0.03764338791370392, -0.006160545162856579, 0.0012511092936620116, 0.06340649724006653, 0.01558531541377306, 0.05818143114447594, -0.03078985959291458, 0.026153065264225006, -0.035887785255908966, -0.02472817339003086, 0.00654462818056345, -0.034312471747398376, -0.03892795741558075, 0.014579069800674915, -0.03806773200631142, 0.00931741762906313, -0.009728758595883846, -0.041782014071941376, -0.005030769854784012, -0.05110090225934982, 0.04550459235906601, -0.009903484024107456, -0.05973571911454201, 0.04035571217536926, -0.035216074436903, -0.009174133650958538, -0.02632720395922661, -0.012813243083655834, 0.003781599225476384, -0.0215577594935894, 0.010163421742618084, -0.06631000339984894, -0.04251677542924881, -0.058615971356630325, -0.014255828224122524, -0.00682477792724967, 0.05913543701171875, 0.0009985376382246614, -0.007869500666856766, -0.027407947927713394, -0.05029745772480965, -0.009414051659405231, -0.0597718320786953, -0.046448223292827606, -0.06087411567568779, 0.053101081401109695, -0.005920772440731525, -0.031122246757149696, -0.0005781391519121826, 0.03737003728747368, 0.03180134668946266, 0.013706734403967857, -0.004584867041558027, -0.004663615021854639, 0.003872005036100745, 0.05447175353765488, 0.04334765300154686, 0.014597519300878048, -0.01883704774081707, 0.030359745025634766, -0.0035457112826406956, -0.05509022995829582, -0.01884620450437069, 0.007914328947663307, 0.02275841496884823, -0.06334200501441956, -0.013866020366549492, -0.012328977696597576, -0.03133305162191391, -0.06562796235084534, -0.04842081293463707, 0.03318772837519646, 0.022590668871998787, -0.04222669452428818 ]
Synchrotron and inverse Compton emission successfully explain the observed spectra of gamma-ray burst (GRB) afterglows. It is thought that most GRBs are products of extremely relativistic outflows and the afterglow marks the interaction of that ejecta with the surrounding matter. Faster decay of afterglow light curves at late times is indicative of non-spherical geometries, and are usually interpreted as evidence for jet geometry. Recent numerical simulations have shown that ring-like geometries are also permissible for relativistic outflows. We therefore extend the standard theory of afterglow evolution to ring geometries. An analytic prescription for the light curves and spectra produced by relativistic toroidal blast waves is presented. We compare these to their spherical and jet-like counterparts, and show that ring afterglows decay faster than spherical outflows but not as fast as jets.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00044v1
[ 0.004048449452966452, -0.024256819859147072, -0.003772745607420802, 0.012811326421797276, 0.02289213426411152, -0.026814039796590805, -0.029088325798511505, 0.04147737845778465, -0.029465623199939728, -0.01898939535021782, -0.014254821464419365, -0.03250038996338844, -0.032889530062675476, -0.06621602922677994, -0.01974935084581375, 0.03930651769042015, 0.060829948633909225, 0.03354312479496002, -0.06544490158557892, 0.06708593666553497, 0.05450909957289696, 0.06587062776088715, -0.02984001487493515, 0.05386282131075859, -0.012399529106914997, -0.021488718688488007, 0.006825154647231102, 0.044904861599206924, -0.04870011284947395, -0.02724238857626915, 0.07195933908224106, -0.03927040472626686, 0.018013164401054382, -0.03718001767992973, -0.015857093036174774, 0.05931328982114792, 0.005341224372386932, 0.029606817290186882, 0.06401291489601135, -0.038200266659259796, -0.011168545112013817, -0.043375615030527115, -0.022958090528845787, -0.03032347373664379, -0.054463692009449005, -0.04952918365597725, -0.05156618356704712, 0.04266003891825676, -0.041991207748651505, -0.0484272763133049, 0.011260365135967731, 0.02237178571522236, 0.03723187744617462, 0.023768916726112366, -0.07111532986164093, -0.03178010508418083, 0.056499939411878586, -0.006790409795939922, -0.022281445562839508, -0.006046677939593792, -0.06904286891222, 0.039952442049980164, 0.028585605323314667, -0.044405482709407806, -0.03564946725964546, 0.038962867110967636, -0.021114252507686615, -0.016369091346859932, -0.00994481984525919, -0.05082216486334801, 0.008236241526901722, -0.06527779996395111, 0.025100424885749817, 0.019959095865488052, -0.06433457136154175, 0.017694374546408653, -0.023221455514431, -0.0029444098472595215, 0.0479871965944767, 0.06147387996315956, -0.05356256663799286, -0.005088059231638908, 0.03218187764286995, 0.028591366484761238, -0.03222139552235603, 0.059379708021879196, 0.06012815237045288, -0.01675245352089405, -0.004114391747862101, -0.03644852340221405, 0.07650065422058105, -0.039348118007183075, -0.01908768154680729, -0.003373526269569993, 0.06768345087766647, -0.025702262297272682, 0.0651329755783081, 0.022016646340489388, 0.03938155621290207, -0.021159878000617027, -0.007986931130290031, -0.040224310010671616, -0.05836459621787071, 0.04978637769818306, 0.019645007327198982, -0.02904624305665493, 0.021309519186615944, -0.030279750004410744, -0.037532296031713486, 0.017741788178682327, -0.04411257430911064, -0.027671227231621742, 0.03323593735694885, -0.039919544011354446, -0.02843538671731949, -0.04448828101158142, 0.04960997775197029, -0.04057617858052254, 0.04031916335225105, 0.014070636592805386, -0.05782490223646164, 0.03594130277633667, 0.01681952364742756, 0.018032997846603394, -0.020103484392166138, -0.016690367832779884, 0.040220409631729126, 0.041341472417116165, 0.018353929743170738, -0.013844287022948265, -0.012611557729542255, 0.029461143538355827, -0.00018179773178417236, -0.04178537800908089, 0.055831585079431534, 0.0016503885854035616, 0.04921858757734299, 0.0013664468424394727, 0.001794822746887803, -0.007515132427215576, -0.011152639985084534, -0.019132373854517937, 0.026423992589116096, 0.016174770891666412, -0.02433401718735695, 0.040075019001960754, -0.05458995699882507, 0.0174406748265028, 0.017261631786823273, -0.024366531521081924, -0.010939530096948147, -0.015477105043828487, 0.03284405544400215, 0.022083664312958717, 0.0067998492158949375, -0.050052233040332794, 0.06313184648752213, 0.03771202266216278, 0.012070324271917343, 0.002077616984024644, -0.0016951985890045762, -0.021896809339523315, 0.006636435631662607, 0.03961939364671707, 0.03804662823677063, 0.004392927046865225, 0.005894591100513935, -0.05151547119021416, -0.026865391060709953, 0.043420761823654175, -0.048845324665308, 0.04702916741371155, -0.004439790267497301, -0.04896707832813263, -0.04206809028983116, -0.017877046018838882, -0.01750708930194378, -0.06150834262371063, -0.009401827119290829, 0.006141378544270992, 0.00368886673822999, 0.010609081946313381, -0.022588878870010376, 0.004542415961623192, -0.028327403590083122, 0.009157691150903702, -0.08913030475378036, -0.011012192815542221, 0.004334685392677784, 0.016849827021360397, 0.013297338970005512, -0.06268288940191269, 0.02960953675210476, -0.015507229603827, -0.039818182587623596, -0.0029454706236720085, 0.008490249514579773, -0.05187009647488594, -0.05215160548686981, 0.04261089488863945, -0.06544174253940582, -0.016468023881316185, -0.020804286003112793, -0.00011653919500531629, 0.0018768382724374533, -0.06941165775060654, 0.03142857924103737, -0.010661317966878414, -0.021632127463817596, -0.012695299461483955, -0.024499662220478058, 0.021162716671824455, 0.05301143601536751, 0.025076156482100487, -0.0001986566639970988, -0.009914403781294823, -0.09808262437582016, 0.014423130080103874, -0.03768037632107735, -0.03450480476021767, 0.009263292886316776, -0.031506072729825974, -0.037515319883823395, -0.042072128504514694, -0.03841693699359894, 0.06015974283218384, 0.04014519602060318, -0.019152609631419182, -0.06609022617340088, -0.03233520686626434, 0.017708638682961464, -0.012931649573147297, -0.0529574453830719, -0.04953202232718468, -0.01730056293308735, 0.01414464320987463, -0.03534902259707451, 0.039151955395936966, -0.013052837923169136, -0.033252693712711334, -0.04269186034798622, 0.017496922984719276, 0.01751272939145565, -0.01888664998114109, -0.008396223187446594, -0.05260992795228958, -0.035264868289232254, 0.031187450513243675, -0.054456375539302826, 0.02949216030538082, -0.0022489808034151793, -0.03465161845088005, -0.038551684468984604, 0.030502744019031525, 0.0472918376326561, 0.04446778818964958, -0.053081266582012177, 0.035413675010204315, 0.0069944486021995544, 0.04133840650320053, -0.032456766813993454, -0.036811839789152145, -0.06276729702949524, -0.03801104426383972, 0.004432729445397854, 0.018420493230223656, -0.03801567852497101, 0.026549536734819412, 0.04683685675263405, 0.001569174462929368, 0.029728617519140244, 0.03411488234996796, 0.04299869388341904, -0.035730037838220596, -0.009989713318645954, 0.014967141672968864, -0.0574503131210804, -0.04567159339785576, 0.02137071080505848, 0.0073542469181120396, 0.06355012208223343, 0.021598389372229576, 0.003725735004991293, -0.05748593062162399, -0.009638708084821701, -0.01871873438358307, -0.042931050062179565, -0.017686855047941208, -0.02647683024406433, 0.013382467441260815, -0.08638745546340942, 0.016670100390911102, -0.03519408777356148, -0.021702824160456657, -0.03346504643559456, -0.00040752036147750914, 0.0034066084772348404, 0.020944857969880104, 0.014037245884537697, -0.014779780991375446, -0.070962093770504, 0.05203324183821678, 0.05790802091360092, -0.004945269785821438, -0.048901721835136414, -0.02832953818142414, -0.042512983083724976, 0.0340825580060482, 0.019748954102396965, 0.015118025243282318, -0.05585632100701332, 0.03337772563099861, -0.0439659059047699, -0.00048247736413031816, 0.004567679483443499, 0.05238587409257889, 0.05681813508272171, -0.055384233593940735, -0.030286194756627083, -0.048962950706481934, -0.06497188657522202, -0.005294575821608305, -0.00797135941684246, -0.0068311747163534164, -0.06991977989673615, -0.03195033594965935, 0.030628882348537445, 0.040542252361774445, -0.025054434314370155, -0.037691324949264526, -0.012640147469937801, 0.013318230397999287, -0.000887160247657448, 0.023253392428159714, 0.006758794654160738, 0.04791545122861862, -0.03611084073781967, -0.040988072752952576, -0.046579331159591675, 0.00737439189106226, 0.013650383800268173, 0.04066004976630211, -0.013164916075766087, -0.018784938380122185, 0.03510645031929016, -0.07510486990213394, -0.03309708461165428, 0.021695969626307487, 0.034303780645132065, -0.03136078640818596, -0.0027968555223196745, 0.05084354802966118, 0.007646697107702494, 0.06031108647584915, 0.017516285181045532, -0.007363150827586651, -0.019377877935767174, 0.044865842908620834, -0.038785070180892944, 0.015734976157546043, -0.03687765821814537, -0.05567140132188797, -0.026184462010860443, 0.010198349133133888, -0.0011317622847855091, 0.05846218392252922, 0.05201447755098343, -0.02106531709432602, -0.014000185765326023, -0.03337062895298004, 0.04825306311249733, -0.047489020973443985, -0.0401831790804863, -0.02288741245865822, -0.036494605243206024, 0.031213119626045227, -0.023627299815416336, 0.03391527384519577, 0.01119233388453722, -0.05257139727473259, -0.02271268330514431, -0.06844007968902588, 0.03765527531504631, 0.050952646881341934, 0.0009581675985828042, 0.010468244552612305, 0.0230531245470047, -0.01857740618288517, 0.04279756546020508, 0.009076998569071293, -0.027210494503378868, -0.03222111240029335, 0.0020347279496490955, 0.00470907986164093, 0.029798541218042374, 0.006815527565777302, 0.023821935057640076, 0.0402921624481678, -0.046877145767211914, 0.03259294480085373, -0.009871980175375938, -0.012819594703614712, -0.0642087385058403, -0.08449620753526688, -0.015494699589908123, -0.04215160012245178, 0.03753936290740967, -0.04951091110706329, -0.023916905745863914, 0.0795946791768074, -0.013053935021162033, 0.03617730364203453, -0.02825009450316429, -0.028679778799414635, -0.0677361860871315, 0.0012640327913686633, -0.005596240051090717, -0.024566838517785072, 0.039232660084962845, 0.002437674207612872, -0.004529131110757589, 0.03924183174967766, 0.01244367752224207, -0.051076073199510574, 0.028291882947087288, 0.01974136009812355, 0.026360753923654556, 0.04531344026327133, -0.0070069278590381145, -0.009919503703713417, -0.0014445666456595063, -0.04426809027791023, 0.00789937749505043, -0.01666335016489029, -0.03329222649335861, -0.04675678536295891, 0.02594454400241375, -0.05563846975564957, -0.044947393238544464, -0.05747910216450691, -0.004407963715493679, 0.036071453243494034, -0.06731464713811874, -0.0439237505197525, -0.008005491457879543, 0.011846981011331081, -0.010810298845171928, -0.07156124711036682, -0.013750354759395123, -0.016608519479632378, -0.07111487537622452, 0.024493228644132614, -0.008435385301709175, -0.030302856117486954, -0.015462414361536503, -0.007154385093599558, -0.024764809757471085, 0.0026110794860869646, -0.0304716769605875, 0.03338509798049927, 0.012132078409194946, -0.0003965198702644557, -0.004048080183565617, -0.024788284674286842, -0.04296090081334114, 0.02188669703900814, -0.026233451440930367, -0.0305216945707798, -0.0177211444824934, 0.005445610731840134, -0.03970969095826149, 0.044802576303482056, -0.06906360387802124, 0.02605397067964077, 0.04893791675567627, -0.031084658578038216, 0.028233418241143227, 0.05289260670542717, -0.026683786883950233, 0.03670242428779602, -0.0001483000087318942, 0.026961831375956535, -0.009418378584086895, -0.02661634050309658, -0.03883260488510132, -0.015727873891592026, -0.020665552467107773, -0.01027795672416687, 0.010110180824995041, 0.0018957445863634348, -0.05201772600412369, 0.009086755104362965, 0.00927961990237236, -0.04971376433968544, -0.0451938770711422, 0.033019859343767166, 0.0052528949454426765, -0.0008364571840502322, -0.01605302095413208, -0.024371203035116196, -0.032124172896146774, 0.006424273364245892, 0.07075196504592896, -0.030697142705321312, -0.03402113541960716, 0.00828222744166851, 0.010260693728923798, -0.0100310780107975, -0.0061956108547747135, -0.012197649106383324, 0.014769249595701694, 0.016510365530848503, -0.009020757861435413, -0.07241379469633102, 0.006679647136479616, -0.07796695083379745, 0.006129878107458353, 0.023454653099179268, 0.0415993258357048, 0.015192602761089802, 0.03512975201010704, -0.010720813646912575, -0.062680684030056, -0.04573022946715355, -0.03436627611517906, 0.043005332350730896, -0.042501576244831085, 0.048163242638111115, 0.014639667235314846, 0.000021452922737807967, -0.05136682093143463, -0.008822119794785976, 0.024056125432252884, -0.022362973541021347, -0.014933731406927109, 0.003802211955189705, -0.009992845356464386, 0.01668187975883484, -0.04285190626978874, 0.014605064876377583, 0.027417343109846115, 0.010005595162510872, 0.06693165749311447, 0.03524833917617798, 0.025493931025266647, -0.03914502263069153, -0.0010536143090575933, 0.015221581794321537, 0.008850554004311562, -0.011004100553691387, 0.0656859278678894, -0.07264900952577591, -0.06042631343007088, -0.023374328389763832, -0.04107041284441948, -0.008648354560136795, -0.027965106070041656, 0.02177894487977028, 0.0038374036084860563, -0.016318922862410545, -0.07923706620931625, 0.03502509370446205, 0.03043386898934841, -0.0559672974050045, -0.005554807372391224, -0.008217960596084595, -0.07229162007570267, -0.036921028047800064, 0.04921432584524155, 0.032187703996896744, -0.05310451611876488, 0.030268318951129913, -0.05378815531730652, -0.03709013760089874, -0.0686829462647438, 0.07407120615243912, 0.0698830708861351, -0.07771103829145432, -0.029581423848867416, 0.031755439937114716, -0.001776841701939702, 0.03312451019883156, -0.014558153226971626, -0.014321299269795418, -0.02012261003255844, 0.00895246397703886, -0.0001352470280835405, -0.03643086552619934, -0.04063291475176811, 0.02158362977206707, -0.03386932611465454, 0.009900739416480064, -0.004484411794692278, 0.0067090606316924095, 0.02882985956966877, -0.048401594161987305, -0.0039789192378520966, -0.010867307893931866, 0.009690702892839909, 0.018095675855875015, -0.0001966338895726949, -0.019798459485173225, 0.0003323840210214257, 0.026148319244384766, 0.016167964786291122, -0.035702407360076904, 0.0032900883816182613, -0.0028865693602710962, -0.0244793351739645, 0.04884779825806618, -0.018431026488542557, 0.031599316745996475, 0.04402821511030197, 0.009209100157022476, 0.0006945834611542523, 0.051815979182720184, -0.022929444909095764, -0.044874947518110275, -0.009848441928625107, -0.023283278569579124, 0.02982298471033573, 0.007712833117693663, 0.08134489506483078, 0.04445110633969307, 0.06423500180244446, -0.03666551038622856, -0.052533503621816635, -0.0440233014523983, -0.041901279240846634, 0.025422442704439163, -0.016546832397580147, -0.025534208863973618, 0.0407160222530365, 0.021239330992102623, -0.03287764638662338, -0.02600148692727089, 0.028226207941770554, 0.02120545133948326, -0.06641588360071182, 0.015098045580089092, -0.016065631061792374, -0.048431530594825745, 0.01656067930161953, 0.02939717285335064, 0.018871836364269257, -0.054320286959409714, 0.03951312229037285, 0.011376614682376385, 0.030265653505921364, -0.04910428449511528, -0.014466719701886177, -0.0693507045507431, -0.017416970804333687, 0.014423786662518978, -0.043232642114162445, 0.03498142585158348, -0.06916411221027374, -0.0807436928153038, 0.027628496289253235, 0.014435267075896263, -0.013655588030815125, -0.05168035626411438, -0.060412436723709106, 0.02804652228951454, 0.04155061021447182, -0.04601041227579117, -0.0660172775387764, -0.0028273097705096006, 0.010687584057450294, -0.01883738301694393, -0.012867793440818787, 0.021510709077119827, -0.06190086156129837, 0.015523859299719334, -0.08700430393218994, 0.03235907107591629, -0.04117486998438835, 0.06906876713037491, -0.02895945869386196, -0.007806210312992334, -0.037988271564245224, -0.040203679352998734, 0.033389732241630554, 0.05410289391875267, -0.021373482421040535, 0.04869607463479042, 0.011361351236701012, -0.0018594827270135283, -0.051013633608818054, -0.03392958641052246, 0.005533609073609114, -0.005489485803991556, 0.013111403211951256, -0.047377895563840866, 0.03611869364976883, 0.019874397665262222, 0.00756785087287426, 0.033359821885824203, -0.020433874800801277, -0.00852734874933958, -0.044783636927604675, 0.01424834132194519, -0.052959226071834564, -0.008274388499557972, 0.007379316259175539, -0.019143685698509216, 0.02379915863275528, 0.04949011281132698, -0.01319711934775114, -0.0351821593940258, -0.04840127006173134, -0.051692087203264236, 0.055741846561431885, 0.02021011896431446, 0.026904329657554626, 0.050781358033418655, -0.05953545123338699, -0.022345321252942085, -0.005232992582023144, 0.029167581349611282, -0.045005325227975845, 0.012014731764793396, -0.0027965877670794725, -0.053796250373125076, 0.017716815695166588, -0.0786651000380516, 0.03379601240158081, -0.039511751383543015, 0.0020017900969833136, 0.02876424230635166, -0.0030856698285788298, -0.06916781514883041, 0.03514724224805832, -0.025266746059060097, -0.018272697925567627, -0.02782771736383438, 0.015315989963710308, 0.015130234882235527, 0.017548317089676857, 0.021051643416285515, 0.03703654557466507, 0.046751346439123154, -0.022548425942659378, 0.043392833322286606, -0.0062364633195102215, 0.005833338014781475, -0.004024876747280359, -0.024831188842654228, -0.049361616373062134, 0.0344550646841526, -0.0013713691150769591, -0.07138440757989883, -0.04785587638616562, 0.049183934926986694, 0.023729654029011726, 0.0038075370248407125, -0.014834633097052574, 0.00913373101502657, -0.018671348690986633, -0.06271076947450638, -0.055316124111413956, 0.02833167463541031, 0.026557691395282745, -0.021261831745505333, 0.021405531093478203, 0.011562595143914223, -0.01774711161851883, -0.06600897014141083 ]
Recent studies in active learning, particularly in uncertainty sampling, have focused on the decomposition of model uncertainty into reducible and irreducible uncertainties. In this paper, the aim is to simplify the computational process while eliminating the dependence on observations. Crucially, the inherent uncertainty in the labels is considered, the uncertainty of the oracles. Two strategies are proposed, sampling by Klir uncertainty, which tackles the exploration-exploitation dilemma, and sampling by evidential epistemic uncertainty, which extends the concept of reducible uncertainty within the evidential framework, both using the theory of belief functions. Experimental results in active learning demonstrate that our proposed method can outperform uncertainty sampling.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12494v2
[ -0.002488079247996211, -0.020085355266928673, 0.033308397978544235, -0.032278671860694885, 0.01273675449192524, 0.01232585683465004, -0.0340689942240715, -0.031244706362485886, 0.01639264076948166, -0.0010828889207914472, -0.051501985639333725, -0.0470631942152977, -0.020471228286623955, -0.03611442819237709, -0.007742918096482754, -0.0003674798063002527, 0.07460606098175049, 0.028241723775863647, -0.05594359338283539, 0.05835900083184242, 0.014687744900584221, -0.04843819886445999, -0.03488282114267349, 0.039023492485284805, 0.026618968695402145, -0.02584240213036537, -0.04087410122156143, -0.0451836921274662, -0.044551145285367966, -0.0221419595181942, 0.03463940694928169, -0.021762404590845108, -0.00654329638928175, -0.04661709442734718, -0.02162286452949047, -0.03785185515880585, -0.003849910805001855, -0.02627960592508316, 0.013301811181008816, -0.023271039128303528, 0.03572482615709305, -0.03457650542259216, -0.062404993921518326, -0.0039990744553506374, -0.018626058474183083, -0.007207418791949749, 0.015077591873705387, 0.02620702050626278, -0.09100399911403656, -0.016864977777004242, 0.04187940061092377, 0.012564148753881454, -0.024397792294621468, 0.02806944213807583, -0.06860858201980591, -0.006355899851769209, -0.016394564881920815, 0.012870022095739841, -0.07467853277921677, -0.03237304091453552, 0.03478877618908882, 0.021666493266820908, 0.016086982563138008, -0.011559068225324154, 0.012979886494576931, 0.019669678062200546, 0.03968903794884682, -0.03941873461008072, -0.05445865914225578, -0.0630330890417099, 0.051436178386211395, -0.04373681917786598, 0.01911749877035618, -0.0074563524685800076, -0.042019400745630264, 0.00205725384876132, -0.026030192151665688, -0.03885064274072647, 0.025074532255530357, 0.026078304275870323, -0.024980800226330757, 0.06826946884393692, 0.019362157210707664, -0.017872728407382965, 0.01305086724460125, -0.036062609404325485, 0.0023652520030736923, -0.014673858880996704, 0.0077454266138374805, -0.00639443239197135, 0.03274606168270111, -0.014938685111701488, -0.028406595811247826, 0.024701083078980446, 0.03205077350139618, -0.039981380105018616, 0.05212908238172531, 0.036835942417383194, 0.040877729654312134, 0.014045268297195435, 0.016858790069818497, -0.04085488244891167, -0.044363439083099365, 0.0684221163392067, 0.024263955652713776, -0.024279486387968063, 0.019798003137111664, 0.009621234610676765, -0.018127338960766792, 0.046659208834171295, 0.0037397996056824923, -0.0053269765339791775, 0.012451580725610256, -0.051556456834077835, -0.009374014101922512, -0.051561374217271805, 0.07150484621524811, 0.024987556040287018, 0.051338616758584976, -0.04155970737338066, -0.045437902212142944, 0.06440390646457672, 0.013224303722381592, -0.016939014196395874, -0.008060949854552746, -0.0042073093354702, 0.0409427247941494, 0.042955540120601654, -0.030583413317799568, 0.027597784996032715, -0.012089073657989502, 0.011270398274064064, 0.017846813425421715, -0.0008098009857349098, 0.020514268428087234, -0.025446169078350067, -0.036661066114902496, -0.06460817158222198, 0.02263486571609974, -0.028724079951643944, -0.0513324961066246, -0.07194001227617264, 0.06572248041629791, -0.043960608541965485, -0.008130728267133236, 0.031116697937250137, -0.044080086052417755, -0.04736530780792236, 0.021176982671022415, 0.028649184852838516, 0.04183204099535942, -0.03924834355711937, 0.023870158940553665, -0.010587876662611961, 0.024835849180817604, -0.016186228021979332, 0.039437130093574524, -0.025897346436977386, -0.03255997598171234, -0.008002069778740406, 0.05616019293665886, -0.0074666035361588, 0.046683602035045624, -0.04641011357307434, 0.023809000849723816, -0.006857210770249367, 0.04142090678215027, 0.020791513845324516, -0.04708298668265343, -0.016472050920128822, -0.07613181322813034, 0.07372631132602692, 0.013833916746079922, -0.006810765713453293, -0.08010470122098923, -0.011329793371260166, -0.02626655250787735, -0.04533899202942848, -0.05900382623076439, 0.015405614860355854, -0.002513439394533634, -0.0031564957462251186, -0.013224177062511444, -0.01205030083656311, 0.00006592140562133864, 0.046463824808597565, -0.07426317036151886, -0.003679063869640231, 0.02289421111345291, 0.026892777532339096, -0.037125568836927414, -0.021906062960624695, 0.013769000768661499, 0.010404800996184349, -0.03170420974493027, -0.0558076873421669, 0.0007484886446036398, 0.032625142484903336, -0.012663879431784153, 0.03620826452970505, -0.08907407522201538, -0.0041477070190012455, -0.028040634468197823, 0.025877511128783226, -0.02813519909977913, -0.050295423716306686, -0.02095337212085724, 0.024510525166988373, -0.03397255018353462, -0.019109491258859634, 0.01819225214421749, 0.037086375057697296, 0.0293586365878582, 0.011644170619547367, 0.020691579207777977, 0.010222000069916248, -0.0969771295785904, 0.0381971076130867, 0.032382622361183167, 0.0386686846613884, 0.015855854377150536, 0.017720388248562813, 0.04542503133416176, -0.03320462256669998, 0.009762675501406193, 0.05664411932229996, 0.058564405888319016, -0.03566759452223778, -0.007394922897219658, -0.046702656894922256, -0.011400432325899601, -0.0540655143558979, -0.041705816984176636, -0.04528976231813431, -0.0406164675951004, -0.044516365975141525, 0.016409244388341904, 0.06460894644260406, -0.016590144485235214, -0.06066805496811867, -0.06762409955263138, -0.031552139669656754, 0.036634378135204315, -0.008782408200204372, 0.011256195604801178, -0.050824765115976334, -0.012483459897339344, 0.003459108527749777, -0.007225590292364359, 0.03568282723426819, -0.022074760869145393, -0.06451861560344696, -0.0024081142619252205, -0.06804899126291275, 0.009302323684096336, 0.051027920097112656, -0.041107431054115295, 0.029106546193361282, 0.021195093169808388, 0.038055382668972015, 0.04019725322723389, 0.0470321923494339, -0.043890420347452164, -0.006911716889590025, 0.038555536419153214, -0.004525029566138983, -0.01167755015194416, -0.03469925373792648, -0.027195656672120094, -0.06147643178701401, 0.030012791976332664, -0.01817469485104084, 0.008420146070420742, 0.02823611907660961, -0.04902518540620804, -0.020415524020791054, 0.013218681327998638, -0.048894841223955154, -0.000024453031073790044, 0.0251188762485981, 0.018437102437019348, 0.012319359928369522, 0.00009127493103733286, -0.07756174355745316, -0.007123639341443777, -0.04570350795984268, -0.035817235708236694, -0.06563377380371094, -0.05864774435758591, -0.01659589260816574, -0.08435846865177155, -0.03689177334308624, 0.03072299249470234, -0.03041815385222435, -0.0430874340236187, -0.05948314815759659, -0.06001833453774452, 0.012531440705060959, 0.06616702675819397, -0.032227806746959686, -0.007527793757617474, -0.044492196291685104, -0.011856382712721825, 0.03273078426718712, 0.024411840364336967, -0.036907490342855453, -0.06069248169660568, -0.03256014734506607, 0.03251441568136215, 0.01217239536345005, 0.034315068274736404, 0.013278326950967312, -0.005221506580710411, 0.022254573181271553, -0.0520775280892849, 0.03144236281514168, 0.0005351359723135829, -0.0010769664077088237, 0.00523292226716876, -0.028675708919763565, 0.010160860605537891, 0.017457766458392143, -0.036098700016736984, -0.013017909601330757, -0.020119277760386467, 0.013252713717520237, 0.07588697969913483, -0.03913566842675209, -0.03720667585730553, -0.03911908343434334, -0.044965390115976334, 0.013466062024235725, -0.003058198606595397, -0.03184319660067558, 0.046602293848991394, 0.022785061970353127, -0.035816740244627, -0.030029267072677612, -0.017709434032440186, -0.006714412942528725, -0.006612914148718119, 0.028509240597486496, -0.03671226650476456, 0.01437523402273655, 0.030635900795459747, -0.08552411198616028, 0.023806704208254814, 0.05081949383020401, 0.07848921418190002, 0.0005536709213629365, -0.020346026867628098, 0.022283343598246574, 0.017642976716160774, -0.015144464559853077, 0.031505290418863297, 0.02537580020725727, 0.05890774354338646, 0.03115910105407238, -0.03292464837431908, -0.025526247918605804, 0.035664744675159454, -0.07632521539926529, -0.05514109879732132, -0.005694064777344465, 0.057636234909296036, -0.017967602238059044, 0.05042653530836105, -0.052352726459503174, 0.0514770932495594, -0.0048375618644058704, 0.02488676831126213, 0.02513728477060795, -0.048238471150398254, 0.037773095071315765, -0.056253284215927124, 0.06217730790376663, 0.02054094895720482, 0.02713031694293022, 0.02651659958064556, -0.05343128740787506, 0.055507440119981766, -0.029943466186523438, 0.04635629802942276, 0.01641659438610077, -0.02936718799173832, 0.03287067264318466, -0.012678208760917187, -0.004386280197650194, 0.053391098976135254, -0.029888294637203217, -0.004502808675169945, -0.024069426581263542, -0.014924663119018078, 0.020173395052552223, -0.02900194562971592, -0.06992019712924957, -0.0010850524995476007, 0.0322301872074604, -0.04661159589886665, -0.024250075221061707, -0.009263555519282818, 0.009604029357433319, 0.010738618671894073, -0.06086544319987297, -0.0017889364389702678, -0.044883135706186295, 0.020706413313746452, -0.022700686007738113, -0.054314855486154556, 0.07070433348417282, -0.020523514598608017, 0.04198228940367699, -0.023471998050808907, 0.0037513950373977423, -0.0479007326066494, -0.03720421716570854, -0.046998120844364166, -0.07400209456682205, 0.036048103123903275, -0.05803350731730461, 0.021612806245684624, -0.01587848737835884, 0.012322326190769672, -0.0484459362924099, 0.023792188614606857, -0.0016326638869941235, 0.026810314506292343, 0.04418058320879936, 0.029036762192845345, 0.0015015766257420182, -0.03219019994139671, 0.03200284019112587, -0.004795369226485491, -0.014716214500367641, -0.031592052429914474, -0.04915992543101311, 0.050127122551202774, -0.012942034751176834, -0.02882268652319908, -0.03546403720974922, -0.03273754566907883, 0.07543522864580154, 0.005619518458843231, -0.004390299320220947, -0.009512539021670818, 0.011233947239816189, -0.061594344675540924, -0.07817169278860092, -0.0030197761952877045, 0.014275796711444855, -0.015112648718059063, 0.003139600157737732, 0.040650952607393265, 0.05579677224159241, -0.0034153179731220007, -0.03578678518533707, 0.008616017177700996, 0.027458222582936287, 0.039607733488082886, -0.01631927862763405, 0.014599914662539959, 0.001149370800703764, -0.011078548617661, -0.017381273210048676, -0.07874879240989685, 0.0008689399110153317, 0.008473261259496212, 0.02120272070169449, -0.004296333994716406, 0.07735607028007507, -0.029488462954759598, 0.028595319017767906, -0.08482174575328827, -0.013606365770101547, 0.017971718683838844, 0.017100738361477852, -0.004701205529272556, 0.05075298994779587, 0.002952869050204754, -0.012976194731891155, -0.05889714136719704, 0.0250631682574749, -0.0057398113422095776, -0.023821400478482246, 0.019457224756479263, -0.026151899248361588, -0.016516171395778656, -0.04931577295064926, 0.07106100022792816, -0.001840072451159358, -0.04517488554120064, 0.027100086212158203, -0.0024644879158586264, 0.0022369835060089827, 0.00956688728183508, 0.02575950138270855, 0.04365307092666626, -0.032692618668079376, -0.04247409850358963, -0.03357978165149689, -0.019034158438444138, 0.036181703209877014, 0.054263729602098465, -0.028049157932400703, -0.03327774628996849, 0.015597752295434475, 0.005850486923009157, -0.027761930599808693, 0.0471501350402832, -0.008014115504920483, 0.006231315899640322, -0.049327388405799866, 0.02235887385904789, -0.043286241590976715, 0.00009762075205799192, -0.0358368381857872, 0.028540262952446938, 0.01984318159520626, 0.026440927758812904, 0.006096380762755871, -0.010392831638455391, -0.03351490572094917, -0.01716696284711361, -0.007524432614445686, 0.00045842822873964906, 0.028291849419474602, -0.028035607188940048, -0.005633413325995207, 0.011768350377678871, 0.03633907437324524, 0.004094731993973255, -0.01159735955297947, 0.0030047965701669455, 0.014804393984377384, -0.011210200376808643, -0.003573124762624502, 0.05671284720301628, -0.03384070098400116, -0.02371293492615223, -0.003916980233043432, 0.04032348468899727, 0.006098244804888964, 0.032708097249269485, 0.033361662179231644, -0.04949921369552612, 0.0016617889050394297, -0.029697829857468605, -0.0508006326854229, -0.047055695205926895, 0.03654204681515694, 0.0705161914229393, -0.03316390514373779, -0.01522183045744896, -0.044196538627147675, -0.06740567088127136, -0.014466619119048119, -0.06220489740371704, -0.01653313636779785, 0.027382729575037956, 0.05363600701093674, -0.045349396765232086, 0.04960199445486069, -0.029657190665602684, -0.08186938613653183, -0.006745850667357445, 0.02247711643576622, -0.047888532280921936, 0.01183632854372263, 0.021361326798796654, 0.007691350299865007, -0.0023499848321080208, 0.04085375368595123, 0.008899311535060406, -0.030978087335824966, -0.059722498059272766, 0.07662836462259293, 0.08454249799251556, -0.022335246205329895, 0.014823449775576591, -0.022714877501130104, -0.03364524245262146, -0.027169520035386086, -0.050080690532922745, -0.016971416771411896, -0.036945611238479614, 0.02723315730690956, 0.019722189754247665, -0.03589466214179993, -0.04503769055008888, 0.054396435618400574, -0.043600622564554214, 0.004578510764986277, 0.01384969986975193, 0.006139937788248062, 0.027939448133111, -0.003177736420184374, -0.001260171178728342, -0.043155647814273834, 0.016687976196408272, -0.03539741039276123, -0.05469871684908867, 0.010275882668793201, -0.021980322897434235, 0.03136233240365982, -0.014206494204699993, -0.07659357786178589, -0.006135676056146622, 0.006107706110924482, -0.02565455064177513, -0.009501460939645767, -0.05947963520884514, 0.03765746206045151, -0.019020771607756615, 0.02110292576253414, -0.013553167693316936, 0.0746699646115303, -0.03395841270685196, -0.019514840096235275, -0.036094505339860916, -0.014174427837133408, -0.021703772246837616, 0.060111794620752335, 0.001385337789542973, 0.020181726664304733, 0.04509463533759117, -0.020240196958184242, 0.052027296274900436, 0.0007979024085216224, -0.0375630185008049, 0.02177417278289795, 0.031305987387895584, -0.030170636251568794, -0.07245555520057678, 0.02609342336654663, -0.05256189778447151, 0.00656855059787631, 0.02301032654941082, -0.024145307019352913, -0.06011096015572548, -0.004197780974209309, 0.006998042576014996, -0.00826981756836176, 0.04411650076508522, 0.039066825062036514, 0.010246126912534237, -0.006976292934268713, -0.02448064647614956, 0.010753422044217587, 0.016586119309067726, 0.026893116533756256, -0.06296573579311371, -0.06650238484144211, 0.004563663620501757, -0.019353356212377548, -0.03888415917754173, -0.016543032601475716, -0.023688368499279022, -0.07353959232568741, 0.011780795641243458, 0.06269930303096771, 0.02328180894255638, -0.00015766704746056348, -0.04397188127040863, 0.03560721129179001, -0.001990663819015026, -0.039957646280527115, -0.040331389755010605, 0.018299080431461334, -0.02163342386484146, 0.017193781211972237, -0.013240858912467957, -0.024239718914031982, -0.06029484421014786, 0.011701145209372044, -0.08692219108343124, -0.01598856784403324, 0.04312308877706528, 0.047028496861457825, 0.020120806992053986, -0.035481058061122894, 0.04375578835606575, 0.014699322171509266, 0.03647686541080475, 0.006719857454299927, 0.009512821212410927, 0.015167320147156715, 0.04788782820105553, 0.014454256743192673, -0.043755825608968735, -0.040494404733181, 0.07032003998756409, 0.02283981628715992, -0.029588110744953156, 0.051427844911813736, 0.05283498391509056, -0.021273842081427574, -0.0050349486991763115, 0.0426209531724453, 0.03404487296938896, 0.045224275439977646, -0.014207610860466957, 0.0029744410421699286, -0.0027150921523571014, -0.04326406866312027, 0.04416713863611221, -0.014030629768967628, -0.029134858399629593, -0.018157295882701874, -0.04558763653039932, -0.005420206114649773, -0.03428984433412552, -0.04520825669169426, 0.004670714493840933, -0.016751937568187714, -0.008977591060101986, 0.046842388808727264, -0.0474562868475914, -0.0012983246706426144, -0.005587887484580278, 0.043617621064186096, -0.06202445924282074, 0.000011740822628780734, 0.010136475786566734, -0.04248447343707085, 0.010299520567059517, -0.07624073326587677, -0.01680784858763218, -0.018290521577000618, -0.001958640292286873, -0.028897052630782127, 0.05200860649347305, 0.027037488296628, -0.01965886726975441, -0.027021171525120735, -0.0006619457853958011, -0.021177401766180992, -0.07506734132766724, -0.05300547927618027, -0.06913253664970398, 0.05613099783658981, -0.0008185135084204376, -0.012505676597356796, 0.012471767142415047, 0.07626605033874512, 0.03826548531651497, 0.03479137644171715, 0.014599301852285862, -0.028029460459947586, -0.042430028319358826, 0.07288241386413574, 0.03287259861826897, 0.007764674723148346, -0.03429815173149109, 0.020973818376660347, -0.02269592136144638, 0.005716776009649038, 0.0571676567196846, -0.03620986267924309, -0.0016100768698379397, -0.05101855844259262, -0.014195884577929974, 0.027147499844431877, -0.0034172215964645147, -0.0398935042321682, 0.011279391124844551, 0.023246828466653824, -0.04283375293016434, -0.03831613063812256 ]
Recent advancements in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems, exemplified by Whisper, have demonstrated the potential of these systems to approach human-level performance given sufficient data. However, this progress doesn't readily extend to ASR for children due to the limited availability of suitable child-specific databases and the distinct characteristics of children's speech. A recent study investigated leveraging the My Science Tutor (MyST) children's speech corpus to enhance Whisper's performance in recognizing children's speech. They were able to demonstrate some improvement on a limited testset. This paper builds on these findings by enhancing the utility of the MyST dataset through more efficient data preprocessing. We reduce the Word Error Rate (WER) on the MyST testset 13.93% to 9.11% with Whisper-Small and from 13.23% to 8.61% with Whisper-Medium and show that this improvement can be generalized to unseen datasets. We also highlight important challenges towards improving children's ASR performance. The results showcase the viable and efficient integration of Whisper for effective children's speech recognition.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07927v3
[ -0.03682374581694603, -0.03459588438272476, 0.027981415390968323, -0.016913166269659996, -0.04354235157370567, 0.057468872517347336, 0.00962082576006651, -0.00686584273353219, -0.020327892154455185, -0.07169643044471741, -0.05711885914206505, -0.011599739082157612, -0.03343323990702629, -0.02072571963071823, -0.059518080204725266, -0.012748283334076405, 0.07351546734571457, 0.023773053660988808, -0.003129037097096443, 0.05922350287437439, 0.025946183130145073, -0.0006818969268351793, -0.07747873663902283, 0.006081589963287115, 0.052637480199337006, -0.03423771262168884, -0.04655081033706665, 0.03507417067885399, 0.013603905215859413, 0.009380960837006569, 0.06253065168857574, -0.03078344836831093, -0.044361572712659836, -0.033554207533597946, -0.04818331077694893, -0.022152183577418327, -0.03880006819963455, 0.02503581903874874, -0.039601974189281464, -0.02121978998184204, 0.05481213703751564, -0.05722948908805847, -0.04457510635256767, -0.0403575524687767, -0.011991853825747967, 0.007998248562216759, -0.007211316842585802, 0.009447980672121048, -0.06871213018894196, -0.019621673971414566, 0.046067703515291214, -0.004151545464992523, -0.024545324966311455, 0.020979294553399086, -0.020115559920668602, 0.010641229338943958, -0.029133731499314308, -0.021633561700582504, -0.012676646932959557, -0.012921900488436222, 0.03693801537156105, -0.012382132932543755, 0.006895164959132671, 0.020729027688503265, 0.01829678937792778, 0.016002023592591286, -0.04498216137290001, -0.038776278495788574, -0.05061850696802139, -0.04652981460094452, 0.011798817664384842, -0.05100053548812866, -0.01016688346862793, -0.015278692357242107, -0.036766186356544495, -0.0017434373730793595, -0.018189288675785065, -0.033783912658691406, -0.018677884712815285, -0.008886219933629036, -0.018170218914747238, 0.06736378371715546, 0.03278413042426109, 0.018060162663459778, -0.00543752359226346, -0.05702846124768257, 0.06827943027019501, 0.013654716312885284, 0.002763774013146758, -0.019479691982269287, 0.05828500911593437, -0.01825181394815445, -0.07542891800403595, 0.006931761745363474, 0.07371994853019714, -0.012119772844016552, 0.01157066784799099, 0.023888928815722466, 0.025776561349630356, -0.018936216831207275, -0.04200150817632675, -0.0200409684330225, 0.006587987300008535, 0.07069461047649384, -0.021273130550980568, -0.04213273897767067, -0.012990599498152733, 0.030782800167798996, -0.03444872051477432, -0.0022829477675259113, -0.008544397540390491, -0.011754628270864487, -0.01668482832610607, -0.07228442281484604, -0.057827841490507126, -0.02592363767325878, 0.054952528327703476, 0.04083365947008133, -0.008883235976099968, -0.02859548293054104, -0.02574792318046093, 0.06635494530200958, 0.01988082565367222, -0.0649075135588646, -0.03900020942091942, -0.02410951629281044, 0.0023933376651257277, 0.021876409649848938, -0.04195772856473923, -0.016855619847774506, -0.03859278932213783, 0.04050248861312866, -0.0297809187322855, 0.013778004795312881, 0.07998961955308914, 0.0029124023858457804, 0.00987121369689703, -0.02619440294802189, 0.022148502990603447, 0.002496920060366392, -0.01764928735792637, -0.05898258462548256, 0.03910244628787041, -0.02423107624053955, -0.0006262503447942436, 0.04096776992082596, 0.0338527075946331, -0.05080932006239891, 0.03591315075755119, 0.005568325985223055, 0.032588664442300797, -0.007570752874016762, 0.03155914321541786, 0.044489145278930664, 0.0028259195387363434, 0.028551800176501274, 0.04963359236717224, 0.011298390105366707, -0.07912006974220276, 0.028586365282535553, 0.02324701100587845, -0.0017097648233175278, 0.029565684497356415, -0.01877007819712162, 0.04343688115477562, -0.0315176323056221, 0.058273982256650925, 0.006403401028364897, -0.033759716898202896, 0.032548483461141586, -0.04438454657793045, 0.03625680133700371, -0.03301100432872772, 0.028965704143047333, -0.07590936124324799, 0.013321122154593468, 0.03217334300279617, -0.023420335724949837, -0.06940847635269165, 0.0016192522598430514, -0.0017415600595995784, 0.054641470313072205, -0.02086200751364231, -0.012508345767855644, 0.01689899154007435, -0.00426899129524827, -0.07352423667907715, -0.040948618203401566, 0.05547520890831947, 0.0021057971753180027, -0.024942073971033096, -0.06388524919748306, 0.02329450100660324, 0.011101948097348213, 0.015274693258106709, -0.011808604933321476, 0.0033281194046139717, -0.003247995162382722, -0.004707932006567717, 0.02702001854777336, -0.08383152633905411, -0.029472576454281807, -0.05938676744699478, -0.005761487875133753, 0.010204979218542576, -0.08234825730323792, 0.031176278367638588, 0.034074507653713226, -0.027495499700307846, -0.0014640005538240075, 0.02692084200680256, 0.031592924147844315, 0.040931303054094315, 0.03418656066060066, 0.03088708594441414, -0.01814468950033188, -0.09658144414424896, 0.06879572570323944, -0.03152290731668472, -0.001864651800133288, -0.010425647720694542, 0.031612422317266464, -0.018334750086069107, -0.022567186504602432, -0.027071230113506317, 0.016539640724658966, 0.042295053601264954, -0.03619493544101715, -0.05577429383993149, -0.04589907079935074, -0.008167792111635208, -0.01485393475741148, -0.05783843621611595, -0.07208318263292313, -0.0010801159078255296, 0.015214036218822002, 0.02159247174859047, 0.020394714549183846, -0.012068789452314377, -0.010354015044867992, -0.01920352876186371, -0.013353916816413403, 0.03498034179210663, 0.029163334518671036, -0.056644804775714874, -0.02822115086019039, -0.0006818801048211753, 0.013203606940805912, -0.02616089954972267, 0.0015178890898823738, -0.03870042413473129, -0.009574832394719124, -0.011656535789370537, -0.04172142595052719, 0.05795826017856598, -0.010199587792158127, -0.043556228280067444, 0.04978916421532631, -0.031775228679180145, 0.043856993317604065, 0.01283900998532772, 0.011691107414662838, -0.0693892240524292, 0.024117816239595413, 0.022187095135450363, -0.021705754101276398, -0.0034726588055491447, -0.03974594175815582, 0.0022594640031456947, 0.003215986071154475, 0.057300057262182236, 0.03216864913702011, 0.03998264670372009, -0.04555211588740349, -0.025862781330943108, -0.0355176217854023, 0.028610097244381905, 0.020101400092244148, 0.025825539603829384, 0.008556731045246124, 0.06313736736774445, 0.005586008541285992, 0.056027837097644806, -0.05936793237924576, -0.017763745039701462, -0.032520510256290436, -0.05615822598338127, -0.06144122779369354, -0.04530949518084526, -0.002686145482584834, -0.06241153925657272, -0.04135362431406975, -0.013038736768066883, -0.02320476993918419, -0.027318870648741722, -0.029742376878857613, -0.04332912713289261, 0.012717124074697495, 0.050984933972358704, -0.015276570804417133, -0.004186841193586588, 0.012327452190220356, 0.011082356795668602, -0.010209820233285427, 0.007273846305906773, -0.03414417803287506, -0.02254001423716545, -0.038468364626169205, 0.03274717926979065, 0.004034337121993303, 0.007299537770450115, 0.05692163109779358, 0.007588567212224007, 0.025269413366913795, -0.04937022924423218, 0.051576245576143265, 0.04430246725678444, 0.040693409740924835, -0.03303641453385353, -0.06776691228151321, 0.026568114757537842, -0.018176982179284096, -0.020259905606508255, -0.02780798077583313, -0.06815984845161438, -0.0037969190161675215, 0.05810843035578728, -0.00016873999265953898, 0.002787681296467781, -0.04598822817206383, -0.024298954755067825, 0.045696478337049484, -0.02446169964969158, 0.00830923393368721, 0.034627970308065414, 0.04724723473191261, -0.05161849781870842, -0.03495676442980766, 0.018539831042289734, 0.028062690049409866, -0.01195482350885868, 0.037124697118997574, -0.05293368920683861, 0.00429691793397069, 0.03709842264652252, -0.08536317199468613, 0.010593566112220287, 0.05094126984477043, 0.07547832280397415, -0.004061751998960972, 0.009051606059074402, 0.046368926763534546, 0.030194371938705444, 0.03510301932692528, -0.042330820113420486, -0.014495170675218105, 0.03280648961663246, 0.04110167920589447, -0.03735792636871338, -0.04228675365447998, 0.04205525293946266, -0.04316252842545509, -0.03789326548576355, -0.014702904969453812, 0.00818780716508627, 0.038268495351076126, 0.02526228502392769, -0.06301258504390717, 0.022227425128221512, 0.034033358097076416, 0.0318293496966362, -0.0030692648142576218, -0.027263741940259933, 0.03923467919230461, -0.044346652925014496, 0.03676949813961983, -0.012444261461496353, -0.015717756003141403, -0.029375635087490082, -0.03418983891606331, 0.043584756553173065, -0.05402246117591858, 0.02623268961906433, 0.03873087093234062, -0.05480918660759926, 0.035797666758298874, 0.060773927718400955, -0.04452173039317131, 0.025711040943861008, -0.016966935247182846, -0.026292333379387856, -0.03148042783141136, -0.04464676231145859, -0.040862489491701126, -0.0034716941881924868, -0.06059033051133156, -0.023809146136045456, -0.019557438790798187, -0.00847140233963728, 0.023941900581121445, -0.010852927342057228, 0.00031041709007695317, -0.006298987194895744, -0.0849638357758522, 0.012976075522601604, -0.04086592048406601, 0.04498927295207977, 0.03131476789712906, -0.032512396574020386, 0.040070630609989166, -0.03130926936864853, -0.013070376589894295, -0.04102333262562752, 0.033875398337841034, -0.0193187203258276, -0.04889361560344696, -0.029671430587768555, -0.06913222372531891, 0.011814949102699757, -0.06918928772211075, 0.025220641866326332, -0.02176172100007534, 0.006899588741362095, -0.028357312083244324, -0.02035141922533512, -0.031145606189966202, 0.04070266708731651, 0.05801146477460861, -0.004073639865964651, 0.014769278466701508, 0.0037122752983123064, -0.007383036892861128, -0.03844701126217842, 0.016754809767007828, 0.013224964961409569, -0.05402803421020508, 0.021437155082821846, -0.006173671688884497, -0.003440441796556115, -0.03994016349315643, -0.005726643372327089, 0.07977862656116486, -0.04215378314256668, -0.05713656544685364, 0.002315634861588478, 0.018176568672060966, -0.028975676745176315, -0.04549724608659744, -0.043839674443006516, -0.05402364581823349, -0.06813975423574448, -0.030809516087174416, 0.03658664971590042, 0.02820909582078457, -0.06367584317922592, 0.017139596864581108, 0.06991484016180038, 0.019930154085159302, 0.003505667205899954, 0.006790448445826769, 0.05312308669090271, 0.01880243420600891, -0.006993724033236504, -0.04628593102097511, -0.06006670370697975, 0.023490464314818382, -0.03647063672542572, -0.0266397837549448, -0.030528100207448006, 0.022458922117948532, -0.023619813844561577, 0.03596526011824608, -0.06757863610982895, 0.03049086034297943, 0.053860053420066833, 0.011114120483398438, 0.035795461386442184, 0.07202869653701782, -0.01613422855734825, 0.06446399539709091, -0.03068864904344082, -0.002681227633729577, 0.019512616097927094, -0.03235573321580887, 0.008989624679088593, 0.028674336150288582, -0.020001038908958435, -0.04418695718050003, 0.019019510596990585, -0.04472574219107628, -0.04459549859166145, 0.0037322030402719975, 0.03154145926237106, 0.058210860937833786, -0.0149126211181283, 0.014267073012888432, 0.04194505140185356, -0.01807936280965805, -0.07152575999498367, -0.027425654232501984, -0.03887706249952316, -0.028471678495407104, 0.06724867224693298, -0.07132957875728607, -0.024489235132932663, 0.05390528589487076, 0.028654662892222404, -0.02811593934893608, 0.015511849895119667, -0.012883980758488178, -0.0008806605474092066, -0.01301465556025505, -0.0252082422375679, -0.027172978967428207, -0.06197136268019676, -0.03708276152610779, 0.04969533905386925, 0.026467932388186455, 0.01625116914510727, 0.04789941757917404, 0.0014904659474268556, -0.06493989378213882, -0.04490488022565842, 0.005176824983209372, -0.05292496457695961, 0.019304875284433365, -0.01100581232458353, 0.039144549518823624, 0.024494262412190437, 0.055359650403261185, 0.04262123256921768, 0.017088552936911583, -0.04329023137688637, 0.016864798963069916, -0.019026270136237144, -0.017431022599339485, 0.008441329002380371, -0.06710300594568253, -0.041273895651102066, 0.03842135891318321, -0.01641814596951008, -0.025534776970744133, 0.045419253408908844, -0.020712241530418396, -0.0073860096745193005, 0.037869203835725784, 0.013102643191814423, -0.04032452031970024, -0.04316478595137596, 0.030382124707102776, 0.05952977389097214, -0.0339290015399456, -0.024696573615074158, -0.007536783814430237, -0.014036226086318493, 0.02431417442858219, -0.06500966846942902, 0.030253378674387932, 0.010080205276608467, 0.042849358171224594, -0.023880427703261375, 0.0709606483578682, 0.0017467924626544118, -0.07866562157869339, 0.031571339815855026, 0.011914699338376522, -0.08586455881595612, 0.015370740555226803, 0.023343795910477638, -0.021394655108451843, -0.06952156126499176, 0.04246115684509277, 0.03149053081870079, -0.028375882655382156, -0.0006712245522066951, 0.04492325335741043, 0.07432941347360611, -0.024569641798734665, -0.010077296756207943, 0.012482942081987858, -0.06647925078868866, -0.0042302412912249565, 0.013260737992823124, -0.0062925745733082294, -0.002950497204437852, 0.014895760454237461, 0.002240573987364769, 0.005395571701228619, -0.035249076783657074, 0.05757194384932518, -0.051904525607824326, 0.0332716703414917, -0.00046634377213194966, 0.030534381046891212, 0.049200549721717834, 0.002994855400174856, 0.002238292247056961, -0.02388354018330574, -0.014489246532320976, 0.02125505544245243, -0.030818866565823555, -0.0005199927254579961, 0.007917703129351139, 0.0464983694255352, 0.01678517833352089, -0.06319762766361237, 0.012959809973835945, 0.03101799450814724, -0.06987041234970093, 0.062453027814626694, -0.035840921103954315, 0.00764796556904912, -0.017084801569581032, 0.0032100677490234375, 0.005510127637535334, 0.029138047248125076, -0.054241400212049484, -0.034721050411462784, -0.019036976620554924, 0.037391211837530136, 0.012566936202347279, -0.011721976101398468, -0.0015571684343740344, -0.0036795882042497396, 0.06482744216918945, -0.048146802932024, -0.02340250089764595, -0.026898961514234543, -0.042382702231407166, -0.0074943252839148045, 0.029720930382609367, -0.029091965407133102, -0.04614147171378136, 0.016827302053570747, -0.03434643894433975, 0.028788963332772255, 0.02897465229034424, -0.04489791765809059, -0.07886343449354172, -0.013733620755374432, 0.04109806567430496, -0.06350645422935486, 0.05216313526034355, -0.016109559684991837, 0.030676234513521194, -0.03367002308368683, 0.022228196263313293, 0.005927500315010548, -0.004485397133976221, 0.01188707910478115, -0.04483463987708092, -0.019464068114757538, -0.002702502766624093, -0.020915433764457703, -0.017713595181703568, 0.030154496431350708, 0.015774955973029137, -0.04377265274524689, 0.004257694352418184, 0.04588095098733902, 0.05324156954884529, 0.018085774034261703, -0.04264886677265167, 0.037057630717754364, 0.005793226882815361, -0.06158432364463806, -0.003491040552034974, 0.006549360230565071, 0.023125559091567993, -0.07307711988687515, -0.015330662950873375, 0.03242504969239235, -0.037961695343256, -0.0009571991977281868, -0.07707574218511581, 0.014256095513701439, 0.00952942669391632, 0.01495056226849556, -0.0066178361885249615, 0.03787040337920189, -0.018276095390319824, -0.03843871131539345, 0.013240503147244453, -0.004680824466049671, -0.0184742733836174, 0.016249965876340866, 0.06221853196620941, -0.030565321445465088, -0.06811859458684921, -0.02514824829995632, 0.029731547459959984, -0.06410331279039383, 0.001316984067671001, 0.004978668875992298, 0.020499246194958687, -0.004267860669642687, -0.016367925330996513, 0.05170287936925888, 0.006183740217238665, 0.039920032024383545, -0.02420903369784355, 0.021694499999284744, -0.024434147402644157, -0.017360670492053032, 0.04499931260943413, -0.03615080565214157, -0.027813153341412544, 0.05450241640210152, -0.01133410632610321, 0.007463798392564058, -0.03102584183216095, -0.02537704072892666, -0.01790371909737587, -0.022903211414813995, -0.03463450074195862, 0.05004286393523216, 0.0060324762016534805, -0.059940405189991, -0.04334617406129837, -0.020910918712615967, -0.03996977210044861, 0.023791490122675896, 0.007899031043052673, -0.03927713632583618, -0.03389899805188179, -0.05222837254405022, -0.03600669279694557, -0.01196211762726307, 0.017619788646697998, -0.015967901796102524, 0.06557705253362656, -0.011848581954836845, -0.00039493630174547434, -0.02587966062128544, -0.01594468764960766, -0.021726321429014206, -0.07112275809049606, -0.05835053324699402, -0.02038724161684513, -0.004982271697372198, 0.052013497799634933, 0.0014005735283717513, 0.01159867737442255, 0.033503543585538864, 0.004162806551903486, 0.026665272191166878, 0.0025308914482593536, -0.010381493717432022, -0.01449580304324627, 0.0673568844795227, 0.01670195907354355, 0.03778542950749397, -0.014984880574047565, 0.02777457796037197, -0.007612196262925863, 0.002755971858277917, 0.022617261856794357, -0.018152618780732155, 0.019087066873908043, -0.049964066594839096, 0.048001475632190704, 0.043912798166275024, 0.005060689523816109, -0.05334603041410446, 0.009153977036476135, 0.01517192367464304, -0.02498740702867508, -0.01848728395998478 ]
In the literature, Benford's Law is considered for base-b expansions where b>1 is an integer. In this paper, we investigate the distribution of leading "digits" of a sequence of positive integers under other expansions such as Zeckendorf expansion, and declare what Benford's Law should be under generalized Zeckendorf expansion.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.00090v1
[ -0.011084306053817272, 0.015460952185094357, -0.01186279021203518, 0.027701163664460182, 0.03229867294430733, -0.04821443557739258, -0.052252039313316345, -0.041546665132045746, -0.05288330093026161, 0.028615357354283333, -0.03190081566572189, -0.013608469627797604, -0.017168281599879265, -0.0036117935087531805, -0.045718152076005936, -0.020315801724791527, -0.03555553779006004, 0.056542329490184784, -0.042222779244184494, 0.04843765124678612, -0.030033865943551064, -0.01801893301308155, -0.03194771334528923, 0.0488944947719574, -0.004819472786039114, 0.037669554352760315, 0.03691279888153076, -0.046230923384428024, -0.015385352075099945, -0.02132040075957775, 0.00826216209679842, -0.04524771496653557, 0.03754616528749466, 0.041291557252407074, -0.04127555713057518, -0.001515488955192268, -0.022427648305892944, -0.056960638612508774, -0.030969230458140373, -0.056900788098573685, -0.03436417132616043, 0.01957734115421772, -0.030970079824328423, -0.014474880881607533, -0.041882045567035675, -0.02339731901884079, -0.06988046318292618, 0.03287402540445328, -0.034244511276483536, -0.0619402751326561, 0.028836354613304138, 0.014520915225148201, 0.007397075183689594, 0.0178774893283844, -0.055027831345796585, -0.05225248634815216, 0.031385552138090134, -0.037965476512908936, -0.07345059514045715, -0.014506679959595203, 0.009902650490403175, -0.00936809554696083, -0.012034114450216293, -0.05486118048429489, -0.03826728090643883, -0.010948831215500832, -0.007621365133672953, -0.06521131098270416, -0.021962624043226242, -0.023754121735692024, 0.0012949812225997448, -0.052190300077199936, 0.008872748352587223, 0.051647961139678955, -0.04406177997589111, -0.02217242494225502, -0.041795551776885986, -0.020765161141753197, 0.0012757837539538741, 0.06425628811120987, -0.01670175977051258, -0.0344339944422245, -0.019329626113176346, -0.06869591772556305, 0.017148345708847046, -0.037676021456718445, 0.014903818257153034, -0.02354634739458561, -0.03799121454358101, -0.05690509080886841, -0.01617627777159214, -0.020040301606059074, -0.07632027566432953, 0.013510352931916714, -0.043681543320417404, -0.017448216676712036, 0.034381166100502014, 0.03040442056953907, -0.057170286774635315, -0.05372011661529541, -0.009455357678234577, -0.06105035915970802, 0.038628123700618744, -0.017889225855469704, -0.0126577103510499, -0.008613974787294865, -0.03720680996775627, -0.04179256781935692, -0.030062071979045868, 0.03415405750274658, -0.02033761516213417, 0.03243616595864296, -0.0674297958612442, -0.05842609703540802, -0.016041917726397514, 0.01732337847352028, 0.027961818501353264, -0.024542275816202164, -0.01679486595094204, -0.03173545375466347, -0.015497375279664993, -0.026515880599617958, -0.0011660857126116753, 0.04384039714932442, -0.017407812178134918, 0.011352811008691788, 0.014316939748823643, 0.05481347814202309, -0.053441017866134644, 0.013264093548059464, -0.02859984152019024, -0.0627712830901146, -0.028379416093230247, 0.014006235636770725, 0.02789445035159588, -0.013019452802836895, -0.012353057973086834, -0.05482729151844978, 0.017794188112020493, 0.0009856420801952481, -0.015858551487326622, -0.05173342674970627, 0.008099157363176346, 0.005514401942491531, 0.01312319003045559, 0.063847117125988, -0.07230367511510849, 0.057771652936935425, 0.02849351055920124, 0.015652043744921684, -0.024029619991779327, -0.010647589340806007, -0.024287622421979904, -0.05315544828772545, -0.017700664699077606, -0.04146358370780945, 0.0366070456802845, -0.013598141260445118, 0.026090513914823532, -0.015850909054279327, 0.05409576743841171, -0.030882997438311577, -0.06283386051654816, -0.03978943079710007, -0.006748102139681578, -0.059624072164297104, 0.0001520546938991174, -0.019954154267907143, -0.034792665392160416, 0.051195353269577026, -0.06738927960395813, -0.02170398086309433, 0.032076362520456314, -0.0505518913269043, -0.032086070626974106, -0.03304729983210564, -0.04779060557484627, -0.06890729069709778, -0.017866546288132668, 0.01637129671871662, -0.005007415544241667, -0.02580769546329975, 0.0067192018032073975, 0.014559725299477577, -0.023315034806728363, -0.010329896584153175, -0.04875945299863815, 0.0355166457593441, -0.01432329323142767, 0.007175383158028126, 0.012156285345554352, -0.02561519481241703, -0.0061464495956897736, -0.01852559857070446, -0.027303341776132584, -0.05063913017511368, 0.019979972392320633, -0.04702117666602135, -0.04872174188494682, -0.01244802214205265, -0.07089447975158691, -0.07290440052747726, -0.039305876940488815, 0.011862954124808311, -0.045254576951265335, -0.048950519412755966, 0.006194899324327707, 0.03268057480454445, -0.03250260278582573, -0.016471751034259796, 0.04345295578241348, -0.03801091015338898, 0.047411300241947174, -0.011836903169751167, 0.02207150124013424, -0.022297007963061333, -0.08375483006238937, 0.026622284203767776, -0.025226090103387833, -0.028476431965827942, 0.0138557069003582, 0.008253281004726887, -0.043022993952035904, -0.012116774916648865, -0.06247878447175026, 0.05017103627324104, 0.003509714500978589, 0.03505987673997879, -0.0519506111741066, -0.008213654160499573, -0.02827531285583973, -0.04215900972485542, -0.06867292523384094, -0.01040873397141695, -0.05322830379009247, -0.03669671714305878, -0.027754100039601326, -0.007055735681205988, 0.04978835955262184, -0.039471231400966644, -0.031883735209703445, -0.005146567244082689, 0.04652309790253639, 0.01381337083876133, -0.006535372696816921, -0.05205436423420906, -0.06813572347164154, -0.04510882496833801, -0.03550682216882706, -0.019881604239344597, 0.0561942420899868, -0.01781427301466465, 0.004179659299552441, -0.014568145386874676, -0.017123470082879066, 0.005019843578338623, -0.033623598515987396, 0.02630053460597992, -0.03482422977685928, -0.017339950427412987, 0.027747858315706253, 0.034075718373060226, 0.013107208535075188, -0.03439459204673767, 0.023242084309458733, -0.0008875444182194769, -0.04560571908950806, -0.0014367711264640093, 0.016209831461310387, 0.019951127469539642, 0.016381168738007545, 0.025170404464006424, 0.03280247375369072, -0.05740532651543617, -0.028343617916107178, -0.040361810475587845, -0.00423514423891902, -0.019543567672371864, 0.03437848761677742, 0.003825194900855422, 0.040550969541072845, 0.05234156548976898, -0.02589448355138302, -0.054776906967163086, -0.013121314346790314, -0.002273843390867114, -0.02895236760377884, -0.055133040994405746, 0.008806037716567516, -0.05537297576665878, -0.04878072440624237, -0.0008954113000072539, 0.03909315913915634, -0.05363460257649422, -0.06940551847219467, -0.0657300129532814, -0.026564156636595726, 0.010298606008291245, -0.033613789826631546, -0.06969325989484787, -0.00004635758887161501, 0.02217521332204342, 0.014615853317081928, -0.03414835408329964, 0.015101377852261066, -0.07199668139219284, 0.0022428100928664207, 0.007712618913501501, -0.06281483173370361, 0.011545353569090366, -0.04750308766961098, -0.005835844669491053, 0.03305331990122795, -0.025709407404065132, 0.007305249571800232, 0.03323137387633324, -0.04491068050265312, 0.009005194529891014, 0.05461250990629196, -0.05257706344127655, -0.03253072127699852, -0.02942521497607231, 0.024743137881159782, 0.03710026293992996, -0.04867218807339668, -0.02351965941488743, 0.03152571618556976, -0.015893638134002686, -0.0434294119477272, 0.01066273357719183, -0.037273015826940536, 0.03689691796898842, 0.03595175966620445, -0.03753681480884552, -0.02569788135588169, 0.035780806094408035, 0.015055140480399132, -0.03197221830487251, -0.029326947405934334, 0.01214873418211937, 0.028639910742640495, -0.011392833665013313, -0.05957277864217758, -0.028685783967375755, 0.01874253898859024, -0.055418163537979126, 0.04008688032627106, -0.004025869071483612, 0.029858628287911415, -0.05173582583665848, -0.046064190566539764, 0.015588955953717232, 0.00037822365993633866, -0.022974520921707153, 0.05061321705579758, 0.008850036188960075, 0.04227187857031822, 0.027864970266819, -0.024954430758953094, -0.05500689893960953, -0.04541994258761406, -0.026282628998160362, -0.025914521887898445, -0.02986149489879608, 0.0473899319767952, -0.015497767366468906, 0.012852192856371403, -0.03604121133685112, -0.01522301509976387, -0.04699093475937843, 0.07463974505662918, -0.05521629750728607, -0.06544157862663269, -0.015013298019766808, -0.005233414005488157, -0.024973690509796143, -0.0032011475414037704, -0.019695574417710304, 0.021636122837662697, 0.02707519195973873, 0.007703003007918596, -0.011186489835381508, 0.03961370140314102, -0.01608242839574814, 0.015995318070054054, -0.04030295088887215, -0.04199550300836563, 0.010273698717355728, 0.004261443857103586, -0.06722436100244522, -0.022522620856761932, 0.04001631215214729, -0.00018413763609714806, 0.02288062497973442, -0.018482042476534843, -0.02048552967607975, 0.008356506004929543, 0.006697503384202719, -0.06884688138961792, -0.013934988528490067, 0.027437524870038033, 0.020502392202615738, -0.07252944260835648, -0.06114575266838074, -0.020951954647898674, -0.005193160846829414, -0.00906014908105135, -0.061419423669576645, -0.07948795706033707, 0.04441927745938301, 0.027228329330682755, -0.01563085988163948, 0.013694210909307003, -0.00042037502862513065, -0.007893531583249569, 0.04516009986400604, -0.04010961204767227, -0.03129754215478897, -0.02366884984076023, -0.05829652026295662, 0.027835041284561157, -0.006474278401583433, -0.06827100366353989, -0.058755338191986084, 0.0018757566576823592, -0.0259442999958992, -0.05745622143149376, 0.011751298792660236, 0.018340202048420906, -0.007739933207631111, -0.019467562437057495, -0.03906434401869774, 0.0605040118098259, -0.03793546184897423, -0.03503352403640747, 0.043857865035533905, -0.03341178223490715, -0.008482259698212147, -0.032357607036828995, -0.013831748627126217, -0.011319081299006939, 0.02569320797920227, -0.009899667464196682, -0.03352811560034752, -0.04142497107386589, 0.010681316256523132, -0.031419530510902405, -0.04843932017683983, 0.032817594707012177, -0.025131555274128914, -0.06332079321146011, -0.053040917962789536, 0.016588691622018814, -0.060343869030475616, -0.010460599325597286, 0.003919168375432491, -0.06305930018424988, 0.06107738986611366, 0.0035682583693414927, 0.012317048385739326, 0.04294878616929054, -0.02263662964105606, -0.03773242235183716, -0.01712815836071968, 0.01787520758807659, 0.004206020385026932, 0.01495867595076561, -0.036815498024225235, 0.034219227731227875, 0.00919319037348032, 0.02445247396826744, 0.0486392006278038, -0.03831227123737335, 0.050750236958265305, -0.005738537292927504, -0.03350701928138733, -0.016927124932408333, -0.022216742858290672, -0.06989213824272156, -0.027153218165040016, -0.05379803106188774, 0.013295349664986134, 0.019016556441783905, 0.05802463740110397, 0.017354026436805725, -0.030066510662436485, 0.0390746146440506, 0.0069442917592823505, -0.005079309456050396, -0.04055170342326164, -0.02779318019747734, -0.034097813069820404, 0.0568108931183815, -0.014485160820186138, -0.048186250030994415, -0.04293880611658096, 0.035681918263435364, -0.04815850779414177, -0.04035847261548042, -0.005698082502931356, 0.0160469152033329, -0.04062270373106003, -0.017345832660794258, 0.007538286969065666, 0.02297111414372921, 0.011372273787856102, -0.06449825316667557, 0.008912032470107079, 0.04227505996823311, -0.012907569296658039, 0.02277057059109211, 0.006222372408956289, 0.00010344075417378917, -0.01739325560629368, -0.010634835809469223, -0.0143100181594491, 0.0034166560508310795, -0.005420299246907234, -0.002319860504940152, 0.056285690516233444, 0.03333079814910889, -0.024840867146849632, -0.027081148698925972, -0.02192040905356407, -0.02995128743350506, 0.04546329006552696, -0.009179300628602505, -0.0715750902891159, -0.02151278406381607, 0.054888058453798294, 0.034397196024656296, -0.013826975598931313, -0.002464229939505458, 0.05601324886083603, -0.007430576719343662, -0.0397736132144928, 0.02015409804880619, -0.02286023646593094, -0.02208087593317032, -0.058746401220560074, -0.013664555735886097, -0.05818362534046173, 0.011296221055090427, 0.02370036020874977, 0.0303493719547987, 0.032861582934856415, 0.0012451151851564646, 0.010935778729617596, -0.048804983496665955, -0.06939355283975601, 0.06358984857797623, -0.030856790021061897, -0.010307266376912594, -0.008167591877281666, 0.010037471540272236, -0.04325489327311516, -0.027502039447426796, 0.022808661684393883, 0.04488131403923035, -0.01116611622273922, -0.022505685687065125, 0.06278415024280548, 0.05761341750621796, -0.06116965040564537, -0.026447052136063576, 0.04367687180638313, -0.05279800668358803, 0.010730099864304066, -0.003991360776126385, 0.020114585757255554, -0.042703915387392044, -0.0011316670570522547, -0.06465056538581848, -0.04732438549399376, -0.03520815819501877, 0.01253485307097435, 0.06609183549880981, -0.009536859579384327, 0.021410327404737473, -0.045675937086343765, -0.021563638001680374, 0.003758682170882821, -0.04198858514428139, -0.05430048704147339, -0.05944538488984108, -0.044330377131700516, -0.020871683955192566, -0.009467513300478458, -0.02993345446884632, 0.023450689390301704, -0.010579383932054043, -0.056311167776584625, -0.01499971840530634, -0.013933598063886166, -0.015089544467628002, -0.0362420417368412, -0.0530041866004467, -0.0020688131917268038, 0.017025219276547432, -0.02674042619764805, -0.0350523479282856, -0.02124163880944252, -0.07565797120332718, -0.011123276315629482, 0.010968608781695366, -0.07132957875728607, -0.03657595068216324, 0.030410902574658394, -0.03981248661875725, -0.015824027359485626, -0.025594748556613922, -0.01871470920741558, -0.03459814935922623, 0.025118736550211906, 0.011528745293617249, 0.03773864731192589, 0.012704387307167053, -0.06703641265630722, -0.024617401883006096, -0.025034291669726372, 0.0037137558683753014, -0.009073755703866482, 0.010944690555334091, -0.012986639514565468, 0.04285441339015961, -0.07309853285551071, 0.03214186057448387, 0.029413074254989624, -0.04068262502551079, -0.017082298174500465, 0.008857819251716137, -0.04838204383850098, 0.017754442989826202, -0.0035295893903821707, -0.06836799532175064, -0.05487362667918205, 0.041594911366701126, -0.06205182895064354, -0.028784748166799545, -0.014155576936900616, -0.01631835475564003, 0.016563475131988525, -0.025739051401615143, 0.025213323533535004, 0.014981782995164394, 0.0000495304811920505, -0.04745619371533394, 0.017917949706315994, 0.0529598593711853, 0.0038499971851706505, -0.0485994890332222, 0.010681319050490856, -0.03597185015678406, -0.03029133938252926, 0.008719201199710369, -0.0247269868850708, -0.06942393630743027, -0.016695721074938774, 0.0016457962337881327, -0.009332125075161457, -0.05901741981506348, -0.03240509703755379, -0.07284214347600937, 0.04824471473693848, -0.008829602040350437, 0.007227543741464615, -0.06608573347330093, 0.012303043156862259, -0.05841144174337387, -0.011827100068330765, 0.002695650327950716, -0.06396159529685974, 0.003389095887541771, 0.040287453681230545, -0.0763002336025238, -0.05725586414337158, 0.05001792311668396, 0.03863002359867096, -0.02876596711575985, -0.01846589334309101, -0.03892068564891815, -0.06613974273204803, -0.033627793192863464, -0.03271500766277313, -0.05079048126935959, 0.0066068172454833984, -0.021541979163885117, 0.03337743505835533, -0.06763296574354172, 0.04339092597365379, 0.04527437314391136, -0.033516205847263336, 0.007910790853202343, 0.018361389636993408, -0.003852455411106348, -0.017195146530866623, 0.03938669338822365, 0.04221973940730095, -0.05178287625312805, -0.02353980951011181, -0.03397127613425255, -0.03342104330658913, -0.04121113568544388, -0.05655236169695854, 0.04891303926706314, -0.06085842475295067, 0.006895959842950106, -0.003046377096325159, -0.016921795904636383, -0.046174388378858566, -0.07193843275308609, -0.026496034115552902, 0.03199392557144165, 0.01830323413014412, -0.05419860780239105, 0.033973220735788345, -0.00535953463986516, -0.06118512898683548, 0.06047229468822479, -0.0029246737249195576, -0.048281099647283554, -0.06644665449857712, -0.014885206706821918, -0.06896743178367615, 0.017734304070472717, -0.06218152493238449, -0.027736302465200424, -0.035037048161029816, 0.024507367983460426, 0.04608523100614548, 0.022549865767359734, -0.030932798981666565, 0.0396156944334507, -0.046072788536548615, -0.0452871210873127, 0.03666350990533829, -0.01966111920773983, -0.00985917542129755, -0.03514347970485687, 0.03207217529416084, -0.02780078537762165, -0.015393145382404327, -0.02709614485502243, 0.0036003421992063522, -0.004972558468580246, -0.04438716918230057, 0.0034754860680550337, -0.0026486385613679886, -0.005884027108550072, 0.02279369719326496, -0.03497397154569626, -0.016793305054306984, -0.042381830513477325, 0.017474060878157616, -0.03140359744429588, -0.007268581073731184, 0.052535802125930786, -0.00952523946762085, 0.05916920304298401, -0.054358113557100296, -0.02462559938430786, 0.0016616919310763478, 0.008977646008133888, -0.06144171953201294, 0.015098358504474163, 0.008320976048707962, -0.023648438975214958, -0.051583267748355865 ]
General Relativity predicts that black holes do not possess an internal structure and consequently cannot be excited. This leads to a specific prediction about the waveform of gravitational waves, which they emit during a binary black hole inspiral and to the vanishing of their Love numbers. However, if astrophysical black holes do possess an internal structure, their Love numbers would no longer vanish, and they could be excited during an inspiral by the transfer of orbital energy. This would affect the orbital period and lead to an observable imprint on the emitted gravitational waves waveform. The effect is enhanced if one of the binary companions is resonantly excited. We discuss the conditions for resonant excitation of a hypothetical internal structure of black holes and calculate the phase change of the gravitational waves waveform that is induced due to such resonant excitation during intermediate- and extreme-mass-ratio inspirals. We then relate the phase change to the electric quadrupolar Love number of the larger companion, which is resonantly excited by its smaller companion. We discuss the statistical error on measuring the Love number by LISA and show that, because of this phase change, the statistical error is small even for small values of the Love number. Our results provide a strong indication that the Love number could be detected by LISA with remarkable accuracy, much higher than what can be achieved via tidal deformation effects. Our results further indicate that resonant excitation of the central black hole during an extreme- or intermediate-mass-ratio inspirals is the most promising effect for putting bounds on, or detecting, non-vanishing tidal Love numbers of black holes.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.00173v1
[ -0.052756983786821365, -0.0242234505712986, 0.01084925513714552, 0.012043062597513199, 0.05807725712656975, 0.03788754716515541, -0.0475597120821476, 0.058530740439891815, -0.018443260341882706, -0.00818455871194601, -0.022873973473906517, -0.07564037293195724, -0.016277983784675598, -0.06828830391168594, -0.018171193078160286, 0.019883980974555016, 0.05759657919406891, 0.054813798516988754, -0.04428468272089958, 0.05612395703792572, 0.030048489570617676, 0.022574815899133682, -0.006310096941888332, 0.01760234497487545, 0.015641462057828903, -0.031245937570929527, -0.01684539020061493, 0.028549987822771072, -0.0633154809474945, -0.018865324556827545, 0.060693107545375824, -0.0312502458691597, -0.004636961035430431, -0.05798518285155296, -0.04713447764515877, 0.0049821496941149235, 0.021724339574575424, 0.049744538962841034, -0.002189092570915818, -0.0427163727581501, -0.0038657502736896276, -0.026910308748483658, -0.01129575539380312, 0.014638906344771385, -0.05967431142926216, -0.02779497019946575, -0.021844226866960526, 0.03138218820095062, -0.05056674778461456, -0.057294681668281555, 0.014533991925418377, 0.024790924042463303, 0.021300626918673515, 0.06333918124437332, -0.0527753122150898, -0.02210790477693081, 0.00547036062926054, -0.020584633573889732, -0.030507557094097137, 0.014022291637957096, -0.02880360186100006, -0.006622386164963245, 0.032605208456516266, -0.03007601574063301, -0.01056520827114582, 0.02958621084690094, -0.04298809543251991, -0.030294334515929222, -0.03882830962538719, -0.05857737362384796, 0.04452772065997124, -0.07631783187389374, 0.03853427618741989, 0.025570640340447426, -0.05929990112781525, 0.023492272943258286, 0.005157082807272673, -0.012370966374874115, -0.020031513646245003, 0.038077134639024734, -0.030846962705254555, 0.011022603139281273, 0.01676207408308983, 0.04279246926307678, 0.015465077944099903, 0.02565981261432171, 0.06617573648691177, 0.0016216491349041462, 0.01790602318942547, -0.06724041700363159, 0.03699308633804321, -0.042408619076013565, -0.038718417286872864, -0.0590217150747776, 0.020159687846899033, -0.044794268906116486, 0.06608306616544724, 0.03725869953632355, 0.018819250166416168, -0.006242127623409033, 0.007533713709563017, -0.030378738418221474, -0.019251232966780663, 0.03357299044728279, -0.01684492453932762, -0.06809253245592117, -0.015997031703591347, 0.006780881434679031, -0.05700463056564331, 0.045606452971696854, -0.023863092064857483, -0.011733224615454674, 0.01780891977250576, -0.04801138490438461, -0.03260582312941551, -0.03309525176882744, 0.07494877278804779, 0.020317764952778816, 0.035784151405096054, 0.008242701180279255, -0.054843686521053314, 0.05943768844008446, -0.017591942101716995, -0.022390248253941536, 0.0040407972410321236, 0.02403949573636055, 0.06187121197581291, 0.02615288458764553, -0.006190360523760319, -0.004442399367690086, -0.038508858531713486, 0.014446594752371311, 0.01717921905219555, -0.013864469714462757, 0.017939697951078415, 0.011825312860310078, 0.045487482100725174, 0.013030421920120716, 0.0020307907834649086, 0.029812078922986984, 0.019554944708943367, -0.005489942152053118, 0.03782319650053978, 0.029998868703842163, 0.013731826096773148, 0.01925109326839447, -0.06020158529281616, 0.008114061318337917, 0.05600248649716377, 0.020671723410487175, 0.02089577168226242, -0.005761174019426107, 0.007627605460584164, -0.007388260681182146, 0.03972410783171654, -0.004127925727516413, 0.03968700021505356, 0.01611461117863655, 0.005227551329880953, 0.001661796704865992, 0.012682825326919556, -0.030164606869220734, -0.0009341883705928922, 0.025438766926527023, 0.03415394201874733, 0.006079046055674553, 0.06900673359632492, -0.02346920594573021, -0.023425113409757614, -0.018812527880072594, -0.038509801030159, 0.06288605183362961, 0.020982112735509872, -0.04483317583799362, -0.03249627351760864, -0.03528065234422684, -0.014620058238506317, -0.02872290089726448, 0.028438376262784004, 0.013630066066980362, 0.008086222223937511, 0.013411350548267365, -0.04302671551704407, 0.007480822969228029, -0.03455601632595062, -0.021754935383796692, -0.075914666056633, 0.0027292645536363125, 0.021092668175697327, 0.01216589193791151, -0.015561826527118683, -0.052077773958444595, 0.03341121971607208, 0.02073063515126705, -0.001882483484223485, -0.019184540957212448, 0.011476323939859867, -0.014241437427699566, -0.01780370995402336, 0.04041551053524017, -0.06510089337825775, -0.0295037180185318, -0.02869511768221855, -0.003287562634795904, -0.01738038659095764, -0.06550908088684082, 0.017516743391752243, 0.00012552697444334626, -0.029262294992804527, -0.032860588282346725, 0.06078885495662689, 0.019678756594657898, 0.042147982865571976, 0.017706621438264847, 0.011814326979219913, -0.03260853514075279, -0.10679459571838379, 0.04286281764507294, 0.011147753335535526, 0.021026840433478355, 0.022961976006627083, -0.006461414974182844, -0.001498621073551476, -0.037113528698682785, -0.02294735796749592, 0.036023739725351334, 0.036981433629989624, -0.023958539590239525, -0.06587475538253784, -0.03869713470339775, -0.031243568286299706, -0.07019222527742386, -0.05680418387055397, -0.05667600780725479, -0.023152291774749756, 0.008652368560433388, -0.026199953630566597, 0.01318341214209795, 0.00918339192867279, 0.00944915134459734, -0.05287330970168114, 0.03554496169090271, 0.0164013784378767, 0.011925293132662773, -0.025598300620913506, -0.00786842592060566, -0.03151093050837517, 0.04611256718635559, -0.05142437294125557, 0.005007150117307901, -0.01617283932864666, -0.02463417313992977, -0.026200145483016968, -0.014372688718140125, 0.01611892692744732, 0.03954635187983513, -0.06567607820034027, 0.013048413209617138, 0.031949009746313095, 0.03229638561606407, -0.03603396564722061, 0.04720870777964592, -0.04326319694519043, 0.02549293078482151, 0.02624564617872238, 0.00981952901929617, -0.06751399487257004, 0.0033218555618077517, 0.03574347496032715, -0.022900884971022606, 0.025911914184689522, 0.011190351098775864, 0.05358147993683815, -0.014701097272336483, 0.0075162723660469055, -0.04071470722556114, -0.045322615653276443, -0.00599675765261054, 0.04004790633916855, 0.024894878268241882, 0.07523974776268005, 0.061355382204055786, -0.019881192594766617, -0.06982260942459106, 0.005319566000252962, -0.045862969011068344, 0.008344498462975025, -0.059005122631788254, -0.03610209748148918, -0.01731962151825428, -0.08308462053537369, 0.027728334069252014, -0.050874028354883194, 0.0078118122182786465, -0.034794870764017105, -0.02207520231604576, -0.008517295122146606, -0.021064210683107376, 0.0467701219022274, -0.07491157948970795, -0.060543593019247055, 0.05238061398267746, 0.07466204464435577, 0.01156625710427761, -0.033627014607191086, -0.023430954664945602, -0.016251152381300926, -0.018635772168636322, 0.024579618126153946, -0.007829401642084122, -0.03527242690324783, -0.027936480939388275, -0.07482566684484482, -0.0025482249911874533, -0.010432724840939045, 0.03644904866814613, -0.010426616296172142, -0.08173534274101257, -0.014717279933393002, -0.027089722454547882, -0.010038831271231174, -0.04123213514685631, 0.012249418534338474, -0.007870115339756012, -0.06819912046194077, -0.04128147289156914, 0.0489339642226696, 0.07444498687982559, 0.015045233070850372, -0.038825422525405884, -0.05298467352986336, -0.02422037161886692, 0.005669762380421162, -0.009285353124141693, 0.04815446212887764, 0.0401364304125309, -0.04737020283937454, -0.025383032858371735, -0.04057513177394867, 0.024060795083642006, 0.003419377375394106, 0.014847012236714363, -0.02179497480392456, 0.01926345005631447, 0.0074817100539803505, -0.04199130833148956, -0.008509845472872257, 0.052920449525117874, 0.06799635291099548, -0.047921862453222275, -0.004766194149851799, 0.043042272329330444, 0.015834154561161995, 0.041666410863399506, 0.0019683009013533592, 0.01712949387729168, 0.01820231042802334, 0.0699935108423233, -0.045967042446136475, -0.021393151953816414, -0.03583362698554993, -0.06300128996372223, -0.05594485253095627, 0.01675289124250412, 0.04258895665407181, 0.04632246494293213, 0.06584467738866806, 0.03995075076818466, 0.020949354395270348, -0.01963033527135849, 0.04139223322272301, -0.006533872336149216, -0.012221312150359154, 0.04611813649535179, -0.02166046015918255, 0.006525090429931879, 0.013971836306154728, 0.025783000513911247, -0.033176861703395844, -0.05012386292219162, 0.0014823025558143854, -0.053352002054452896, 0.02414337918162346, -0.005308710504323244, 0.012684179469943047, 0.023544207215309143, 0.004665829241275787, -0.022005686536431313, 0.05321721360087395, 0.032521627843379974, 0.009694382548332214, -0.03420375660061836, -0.025151196867227554, 0.01930774748325348, 0.013806594535708427, -0.024989603087306023, 0.0022155262995511293, -0.0013368881773203611, -0.04141167178750038, 0.03966642916202545, -0.025247355923056602, -0.026425829157233238, -0.04742500185966492, -0.08427189290523529, -0.04399295523762703, -0.029307961463928223, 0.01581566222012043, 0.004144040867686272, -0.042448289692401886, 0.06275574117898941, 0.0024089240469038486, 0.009318871423602104, -0.030412018299102783, -0.040804192423820496, -0.04496923089027405, -0.031249430030584335, -0.0036786666605621576, -0.019236663356423378, 0.04946446046233177, -0.06313812732696533, 0.019807884469628334, -0.020818954333662987, 0.030838308855891228, -0.04667146876454353, 0.008200620301067829, -0.02055070362985134, 0.03713720291852951, 0.03784345090389252, 0.031257737427949905, 0.0065341913141310215, 0.002387329703196883, -0.05896619334816933, 0.008890540339052677, 0.031198199838399887, -0.006844540126621723, -0.02196630649268627, 0.042594097554683685, -0.05573354661464691, -0.043299607932567596, -0.06557597219944, 0.007387046702206135, 0.025997204706072807, -0.043660279363393784, -0.042919084429740906, 0.012358230538666248, 0.030593011528253555, -0.03924926742911339, -0.04178212955594063, -0.06354095041751862, -0.044407203793525696, -0.07057353854179382, 0.02000250667333603, -0.023637963458895683, -0.02801627665758133, -0.02181917428970337, 0.060595255345106125, 0.020934952422976494, 0.046418022364377975, -0.008009480312466621, 0.026265498250722885, 0.03578728809952736, 0.030176613479852676, 0.013397288508713245, -0.04169696569442749, -0.03520791605114937, 0.02441105991601944, 0.0058875614777207375, -0.038102712482213974, -0.030460909008979797, 0.025943782180547714, -0.020308872684836388, 0.05192848667502403, -0.08746039867401123, 0.018548481166362762, 0.06249365210533142, -0.010549874044954777, -0.008948207832872868, 0.02230783924460411, -0.05568752437829971, 0.02379569783806801, -0.017153475433588028, 0.049924105405807495, 0.003547531319782138, -0.012287542223930359, 0.0325658954679966, 0.024630671367049217, -0.03810817748308182, 0.00025534583255648613, 0.03786575049161911, -0.025833742693066597, -0.04790199175477028, 0.026402616873383522, 0.03192667290568352, -0.011756670661270618, -0.03770110756158829, 0.025034984573721886, 0.06059632450342178, -0.0014966904418542981, -0.04876513406634331, -0.006786041427403688, -0.00030857467208988965, -0.011063328944146633, 0.05121549963951111, -0.06824459135532379, 0.006076313555240631, -0.011890487745404243, -0.0054166680201888084, -0.00950222834944725, 0.04787822812795639, 0.034463342279195786, 0.013305003754794598, 0.016734110191464424, 0.015562636777758598, -0.06540906429290771, 0.008319901302456856, -0.06173425167798996, 0.05145811662077904, 0.02761286310851574, 0.03924904391169548, 0.01916310377418995, 0.04644457623362541, -0.021490348502993584, -0.06992192566394806, 0.00820219423621893, -0.0013412903062999249, 0.0502980574965477, -0.06334629654884338, 0.013324208557605743, 0.03230702877044678, 0.05268087238073349, -0.014993417076766491, -0.00853982288390398, -0.003114856779575348, -0.04054106026887894, -0.02884618379175663, -0.0196327343583107, 0.00891065038740635, 0.012041902169585228, -0.019125884398818016, -0.018888099119067192, 0.02225453406572342, -0.005251651164144278, 0.044018592685461044, 0.04518570005893707, 0.005415699444711208, 0.038045380264520645, -0.030429311096668243, 0.021005447953939438, -0.04067515209317207, 0.010263307951390743, 0.08553502708673477, -0.050600118935108185, 0.036282286047935486, 0.0064280349761247635, -0.032016634941101074, 0.00736552057787776, 0.009469074197113514, -0.018849344924092293, -0.015688207000494003, 0.0117561724036932, -0.07125475257635117, 0.016520388424396515, 0.013019104488193989, -0.0803263857960701, -0.024635836482048035, 0.03556562587618828, -0.06600634008646011, -0.005627599079161882, 0.016081299632787704, -0.01304601226001978, -0.063288614153862, -0.011479140259325504, -0.031136147677898407, -0.0724613294005394, -0.04837147518992424, 0.07489940524101257, 0.057944439351558685, -0.07601504772901535, 0.011535132303833961, 0.053750649094581604, -0.043449994176626205, 0.04154803603887558, -0.01919304020702839, 0.012750268913805485, -0.004922498483210802, 0.03897248953580856, 0.02516494318842888, -0.0035403489600867033, 0.017773998901247978, 0.03852575644850731, -0.051044441759586334, 0.034915219992399216, 0.002525251591578126, 0.005966643337160349, 0.023292474448680878, -0.04138260707259178, -0.05106915161013603, 0.03657611832022667, -0.03111027553677559, 0.03655627369880676, -0.004836962092667818, -0.01482783630490303, 0.023875363171100616, 0.03152083232998848, 0.002818211680278182, -0.040610093623399734, 0.001312343287281692, 0.004407087806612253, -0.04013265669345856, 0.04372275993227959, -0.029111547395586967, -0.012701435014605522, 0.01979338750243187, 0.013945420272648335, 0.019487636163830757, 0.04111890122294426, -0.062422651797533035, 0.005486772861331701, -0.004200827796012163, 0.025632133707404137, 0.04036298394203186, 0.019471999257802963, 0.028228148818016052, -0.021140139549970627, 0.03500552475452423, -0.027624545618891716, 0.0004596820508595556, 0.0013236121740192175, -0.03317626938223839, 0.05326525494456291, -0.014938325621187687, -0.012786324135959148, -0.0274729635566473, -0.0075224158354103565, -0.0781375914812088, 0.001274681300856173, 0.0333012118935585, -0.02043052762746811, -0.0600394532084465, 0.030294135212898254, -0.004651428200304508, -0.02536836452782154, 0.02660941891372204, -0.017329124733805656, 0.060967765748500824, -0.044334303587675095, 0.0349428690969944, 0.07894960790872574, -0.019607312977313995, -0.015018977224826813, -0.04977079853415489, -0.022443637251853943, 0.04732027277350426, -0.0018758841324597597, 0.0015859260456636548, 0.020232804119586945, -0.03618791699409485, -0.054408419877290726, 0.008048785850405693, 0.026028629392385483, -0.027845127508044243, -0.012567060999572277, -0.03079529106616974, 0.03907770663499832, 0.030168119817972183, -0.0648229569196701, -0.07992082834243774, 0.016112729907035828, 0.003502288833260536, 0.00020676256099250168, -0.006432902067899704, 0.0031524263322353363, -0.04834705963730812, 0.016456466168165207, -0.09187696129083633, -0.014977390877902508, -0.04286295175552368, 0.013168331235647202, -0.031087439507246017, -0.02099430561065674, -0.040185049176216125, -0.03158411383628845, 0.03378402441740036, 0.011272773146629333, -0.052941951900720596, 0.038935720920562744, 0.04865472391247749, 0.05189681425690651, -0.053954944014549255, -0.0069696493446826935, 0.039259180426597595, -0.02546200156211853, -0.01783931627869606, 0.058023784309625626, 0.0217194352298975, -0.03214721381664276, -0.009422238916158676, 0.032321278005838394, -0.008707134984433651, -0.011806901544332504, -0.039648693054914474, 0.020182816311717033, -0.009393041022121906, -0.04166392609477043, 0.02562628872692585, -0.03617599979043007, 0.021608633920550346, 0.038682498037815094, -0.014921193942427635, -0.06568466871976852, -0.04686635360121727, -0.03300546482205391, 0.041463885456323624, 0.015014037489891052, -0.0009186490206047893, 0.06435113400220871, -0.05798393487930298, 0.023015130311250687, 0.004918854217976332, -0.028137782588601112, -0.03529559448361397, 0.01777542568743229, -0.007470219396054745, -0.07959412783384323, 0.004388780798763037, -0.08608996123075485, 0.043148286640644073, -0.03053179942071438, -0.0154638160020113, 0.03218422085046768, 0.023272786289453506, -0.057380057871341705, -0.013572407886385918, -0.03174646571278572, -0.04764123260974884, 0.020618880167603493, -0.0668572336435318, -0.02534034289419651, 0.024169201031327248, 0.04464815557003021, -0.008330674842000008, 0.027795976027846336, -0.008421373553574085, 0.012780634686350822, 0.035732612013816833, -0.023966500535607338, -0.014959637075662613, -0.020508600398898125, -0.026909183710813522, 0.019427217543125153, 0.015425590798258781, -0.0022175258491188288, -0.05993758887052536, 0.0031474123243242502, 0.008797268383204937, 0.04327872022986412, -0.0061157094314694405, 0.026663707569241524, -0.045603834092617035, -0.07257780432701111, -0.042589347809553146, 0.035198140889406204, -0.013634827919304371, 0.0009710239828564227, 0.05110256001353264, 0.02019720897078514, -0.012407264672219753, -0.07339930534362793 ]
We describe the tropical mirror for complex toric surfaces. In particular we provide an explicit expression for the mirror states and show that they can be written in enumerative form. Their holomorphic germs give an explicit form of good section for Landau-Ginzburg-Saito theory. We use an explicit form of holomorphic germs to derive the divisor relation for tropical Gromov-Witten invariants. We interpret the deformation of the theory by a point observable as a blow up of a point on the toric surface. We describe the implication of such interpretation for the tropical Gromov-Witten invariants.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00423v2
[ 0.009431220591068268, -0.027422461658716202, 0.023822829127311707, -0.005249774549156427, 0.02375633269548416, -0.03287554532289505, -0.006959736347198486, 0.0002096487005474046, -0.04869668930768967, 0.024820035323500633, -0.053591322153806686, -0.026797480881214142, -0.017049850896000862, -0.04332871362566948, -0.060610707849264145, 0.060024771839380264, 0.06650444865226746, 0.017648939043283463, -0.060389094054698944, 0.07774356007575989, 0.006785740610212088, 0.05262243002653122, -0.043367963284254074, 0.08282018452882767, -0.01137171033769846, 0.008452413603663445, 0.04333155229687691, 0.04595527425408363, -0.03760218247771263, -0.04321201890707016, 0.07789874821901321, 0.004533188417553902, 0.013619150035083294, 0.028502468019723892, 0.03602970391511917, 0.012922002002596855, 0.05405683070421219, 0.03412353992462158, 0.027153173461556435, -0.010009358637034893, -0.007169388234615326, -0.018174367025494576, -0.018262183293700218, -0.0026960663963109255, -0.01317160576581955, 0.0024384402204304934, -0.008974320255219936, 0.017697205767035484, -0.042439140379428864, -0.03982757776975632, 0.04790825769305229, 0.011465296149253845, 0.014026327058672905, 0.05908309668302536, -0.06376078724861145, 0.0005410388112068176, 0.03176601231098175, -0.0031667945440858603, 0.0070248814299702644, 0.022476350888609886, 0.00029744775383733213, 0.009086345322430134, -0.0060189468786120415, -0.035320281982421875, -0.025634748861193657, 0.02182672917842865, -0.07466292381286621, -0.018871301785111427, 0.010962161235511303, -0.04551805928349495, 0.005586287472397089, -0.06287878751754761, 0.02399211935698986, -0.009012429043650627, -0.07999102026224136, 0.03494434431195259, -0.0387333445250988, -0.004028587136417627, 0.022620219737291336, 0.05797132849693298, -0.02919694595038891, -0.04704616591334343, 0.04018368199467659, 0.051887147128582, 0.020879002287983894, 0.034157756716012955, -0.003084352472797036, 0.03177522495388985, 0.021747414022684097, -0.04221043363213539, 0.04874850809574127, 0.0015853454824537039, -0.03834055736660957, -0.01604544185101986, 0.015065940096974373, -0.040430523455142975, 0.07633006572723389, -0.0015213961014524102, -0.01456484291702509, 0.02057904750108719, -0.036092545837163925, -0.03784885257482529, 0.022947948426008224, 0.017140518873929977, 0.01817857287824154, -0.04324369132518768, 0.05278777703642845, 0.015114941634237766, -0.021908629685640335, 0.01650778204202652, -0.021895824000239372, -0.004259511828422546, 0.03217937424778938, -0.05170859023928642, 0.027783330529928207, -0.052003707736730576, 0.05431073158979416, -0.031950101256370544, 0.05256267264485359, -0.01915745437145233, -0.06647463887929916, 0.03280983120203018, 0.0238551776856184, -0.01048749964684248, -0.05383424088358879, -0.07110171765089035, 0.048743732273578644, 0.05973074212670326, -0.020219169557094574, -0.061019882559776306, -0.0037442389875650406, -0.01942911185324192, 0.008342616260051727, -0.0225356612354517, 0.04485813528299332, -0.05325295403599739, 0.05226391181349754, -0.0104031627997756, -0.035685449838638306, 0.04609055072069168, -0.0376327708363533, -0.06802957504987717, 0.00017397917690686882, -0.043434660881757736, 0.0013145849807187915, 0.044646717607975006, -0.05088982731103897, 0.06231401488184929, 0.004241022281348705, -0.01575871743261814, 0.011163167655467987, -0.025667866691946983, 0.03200886771082878, 0.03741518408060074, -0.00782015547156334, -0.03820985183119774, 0.051237914711236954, 0.00721458625048399, 0.000009866372238320764, 0.03436851128935814, 0.00291165872476995, -0.012082509696483612, 0.011906246654689312, 0.003772100666537881, 0.013021139428019524, -0.021479226648807526, 0.005878892261534929, -0.0698503702878952, -0.012143051251769066, 0.01655629649758339, -0.030136484652757645, 0.030577659606933594, 0.016458528116345406, -0.03298009932041168, -0.059728968888521194, -0.06115409731864929, -0.05458210036158562, -0.05615328997373581, -0.010649513453245163, 0.0030286128167062998, -0.03462052717804909, -0.02658325433731079, 0.011298642493784428, -0.017293639481067657, -0.016472363844513893, -0.004234973341226578, -0.062130287289619446, 0.04490023851394653, -0.00975275319069624, -0.0007703214068897069, 0.03024369664490223, -0.0756216049194336, 0.0006655518081970513, 0.017818385735154152, -0.0578409843146801, -0.007341750897467136, 0.043578311800956726, 0.013045340776443481, -0.0322803258895874, 0.029608601704239845, -0.056155726313591, 0.00018427448230795562, 0.01982712186872959, 0.018412427976727486, -0.015839818865060806, -0.08441312611103058, -0.027365904301404953, 0.06097226217389107, -0.050786323845386505, -0.04389526695013046, 0.047876063734292984, -0.010029765777289867, 0.04521699249744415, -0.026572678238153458, 0.007978093810379505, -0.01785765029489994, -0.12284927815198898, 0.00576051976531744, 0.007913708686828613, 0.005330578424036503, -0.009197844192385674, -0.00688391225412488, -0.01975381188094616, -0.0282269399613142, -0.03622254729270935, 0.06674202531576157, 0.06700312346220016, 0.027642929926514626, -0.03346678242087364, -0.04734126850962639, -0.0005762254586443305, -0.002553889760747552, -0.038998719304800034, -0.04240048676729202, -0.032326120883226395, 0.03527459129691124, -0.04684387892484665, 0.030450426042079926, -0.02722468599677086, -0.06286587566137314, -0.04742739349603653, -0.0013114579487591982, 0.04066450148820877, -0.04470427706837654, 0.01187132392078638, -0.03725273162126541, -0.06278441101312637, 0.006476878188550472, -0.028193872421979904, -0.007245734333992004, 0.03983328491449356, -0.05892355367541313, -0.008510065264999866, -0.0029601131100207567, 0.06312792748212814, 0.02976430580019951, -0.031071554869413376, 0.05257023498415947, -0.004452197812497616, 0.06449036300182343, 0.019283194094896317, -0.0046019828878343105, -0.005337765906006098, 0.00963749922811985, -0.001787466579116881, 0.03805486857891083, -0.04943244904279709, -0.0469326376914978, 0.038357924669981, -0.02299019880592823, 0.04423822835087776, -0.008778817020356655, 0.048986468464136124, -0.03646044433116913, -0.03848683461546898, 0.0271634329110384, 0.001448154216632247, -0.060001060366630554, 0.04672439768910408, 0.02570566162467003, 0.045787785202264786, 0.010453842580318451, -0.04969452694058418, -0.06490292400121689, 0.025075022131204605, -0.03758758306503296, -0.04129885137081146, -0.05852331221103668, -0.038282331079244614, -0.013977901078760624, -0.07747408002614975, 0.0022584572434425354, -0.005026103463023901, -0.02927708998322487, -0.06196491792798042, -0.0796075090765953, -0.022788478061556816, 0.030893798917531967, -0.010411122813820839, -0.05487509444355965, -0.07025553286075592, 0.06685025244951248, 0.04408976063132286, -0.01822148635983467, -0.031886231154203415, -0.039538267999887466, 0.00003627770274761133, 0.06208121031522751, -0.00994621217250824, -0.007044669706374407, -0.020118260756134987, 0.01538543775677681, 0.008040337823331356, -0.03257683664560318, 0.04100313037633896, 0.009850126691162586, 0.013766697607934475, -0.010180681943893433, 0.02481822855770588, -0.014309754595160484, -0.04886344075202942, 0.01353826280683279, 0.012089311145246029, 0.03944435343146324, -0.052249595522880554, 0.027469398453831673, 0.01037120632827282, 0.03063141368329525, -0.007650582119822502, -0.00477107847109437, -0.046653203666210175, -0.02208687551319599, 0.0256811510771513, -0.008719836361706257, 0.050979577004909515, 0.060015760362148285, -0.021423382684588432, -0.025464309379458427, -0.034094713628292084, -0.018744636327028275, 0.0006139108445495367, 0.05957348644733429, -0.04804152250289917, -0.044451307505369186, 0.008426029235124588, -0.10143358260393143, 0.04746607691049576, 0.022541405633091927, 0.005671804305166006, -0.022614367306232452, 0.005825441796332598, -0.02805372141301632, 0.05060182139277458, 0.006194360554218292, 0.04647934436798096, -0.016112424433231354, 0.011457519605755806, 0.061341386288404465, -0.04601949080824852, -0.006868772674351931, -0.02817169763147831, -0.053419895470142365, 0.002120384480804205, 0.01649571768939495, 0.03042432852089405, 0.0749220922589302, 0.05717221274971962, -0.012520505115389824, -0.008249526843428612, -0.012952486984431744, 0.03889439254999161, 0.020598234608769417, 0.003436195896938443, -0.043932631611824036, -0.028039459139108658, 0.04217011481523514, -0.009371555410325527, 0.029893718659877777, -0.0428188219666481, -0.042928099632263184, -0.0029916376806795597, -0.013105778023600578, 0.01950574666261673, 0.04175467789173126, 0.010886558331549168, 0.00014449600712396204, -0.04364321753382683, 0.011181331239640713, 0.02016475982964039, -0.013171084225177765, 0.035250626504421234, 0.0053936210460960865, 0.04071361571550369, 0.039337120950222015, -0.037963252514600754, -0.029884543269872665, 0.01188073679804802, -0.014310852624475956, -0.05102155730128288, -0.0037590109277516603, -0.0244480911642313, 0.01679624430835247, -0.05593261122703552, -0.04476502910256386, -0.045164499431848526, -0.00945389922708273, 0.0005153495585545897, -0.034199122339487076, -0.06795217841863632, 0.04837526008486748, -0.016794098541140556, 0.022154122591018677, 0.014260342344641685, -0.01731397770345211, -0.05402471125125885, 0.002084134379401803, -0.026577100157737732, -0.04920050874352455, 0.012890193611383438, -0.03479565680027008, -0.006133025977760553, -0.016581419855356216, 0.006652603391557932, -0.025560500100255013, 0.026743624359369278, -0.016774876043200493, 0.0158047117292881, 0.04194587841629982, -0.031422458589076996, 0.036125145852565765, 0.028724923729896545, 0.008386149071156979, 0.016506679356098175, 0.0021568704396486282, -0.03153226524591446, -0.028565211221575737, 0.006288377568125725, -0.04230108857154846, -0.0197292547672987, -0.023832639679312706, 0.012734416872262955, 0.031739573925733566, -0.059720057994127274, -0.039719268679618835, -0.009469960816204548, 0.03998382389545441, -0.05046716704964638, -0.045233387500047684, -0.0044190664775669575, 0.0032315326388925314, -0.030038982629776, 0.04039843752980232, 0.0022312263026833534, -0.037832554429769516, -0.04719032719731331, 0.012710880488157272, 0.0002449746825732291, 0.021633870899677277, 0.02741227112710476, -0.012164083309471607, 0.044707052409648895, 0.037791911512613297, 0.008462109602987766, -0.00917515717446804, -0.03147745132446289, 0.015177355147898197, -0.00580631336197257, 0.022368203848600388, 0.018829165026545525, 0.0720815360546112, -0.005437575280666351, 0.06054457277059555, -0.056106869131326675, 0.05152236670255661, 0.055214766412973404, 0.0043017989955842495, -0.002417404903098941, 0.02896157093346119, 0.021291038021445274, 0.015087166801095009, 0.042630311101675034, -0.014212884940207005, -0.002325060311704874, 0.004499934148043394, 0.00438704714179039, 0.028953755274415016, 0.007060734089463949, -0.0060377647168934345, 0.011284521780908108, 0.04239767789840698, -0.002434334484860301, 0.016872240230441093, -0.01608617790043354, -0.0032624336890876293, -0.043479617685079575, 0.0032408847473561764, 0.025697793811559677, -0.037620190531015396, 0.007232474163174629, 0.027628201991319656, -0.016075780615210533, 0.004350801929831505, 0.017060965299606323, -0.04326535761356354, 0.012507680803537369, 0.01017821952700615, -0.008398608304560184, 0.010430771857500076, -0.0009631378343328834, 0.023374710232019424, 0.007725754752755165, 0.07003748416900635, -0.010225478559732437, -0.06714248657226562, 0.008523605763912201, -0.010493254289031029, 0.03964304178953171, 0.047548212110996246, 0.06895671784877777, 0.07128188014030457, 0.03572683408856392, 0.025001609697937965, 0.005025444086641073, -0.02240334078669548, 0.007294000126421452, 0.04190218821167946, -0.046009160578250885, 0.019709331914782524, 0.02595263533294201, 0.048208437860012054, -0.01747378520667553, 0.014367187395691872, -0.020892975851893425, -0.004802720621228218, -0.050007108598947525, -0.028878983110189438, 0.0001932172162923962, 0.030896425247192383, -0.02394775301218033, -0.015283253975212574, 0.035077907145023346, -0.017194846644997597, 0.03913521394133568, 0.04797796159982681, 0.026183143258094788, -0.01164552103728056, 0.008902998641133308, 0.04978878051042557, -0.06365973502397537, -0.03469033166766167, 0.08058974891901016, -0.019380897283554077, -0.018502842634916306, 0.04473766312003136, -0.08544699847698212, -0.005567298270761967, -0.028986217454075813, 0.041463326662778854, 0.024425148963928223, -0.03522603586316109, -0.0626058354973793, 0.040356360375881195, 0.011178913526237011, -0.062485288828611374, -0.0017738551832735538, 0.014341054484248161, -0.07019008696079254, -0.012424464337527752, 0.02353242225944996, -0.015337754972279072, 0.0040522473864257336, 0.048735279589891434, -0.06794029474258423, -0.030047321692109108, -0.02763623557984829, 0.025755412876605988, 0.07196963578462601, -0.039666324853897095, 0.043155912309885025, 0.0028311097994446754, -0.018683547154068947, 0.031508252024650574, -0.013120985589921474, 0.028570514172315598, -0.0069252122193574905, 0.0011731163831427693, -0.018213650211691856, -0.038036320358514786, 0.0017192671075463295, 0.010915503837168217, -0.031685732305049896, -0.042205896228551865, 0.0027010818012058735, 0.037253350019454956, 0.03175467625260353, -0.03727114573121071, -0.030426857993006706, -0.02941531501710415, 0.01089285034686327, -0.02085931971669197, -0.03997267037630081, -0.017426766455173492, -0.0029511614702641964, 0.020967666059732437, 0.021687209606170654, -0.003738791448995471, -0.056261420249938965, 0.022923238575458527, -0.005603175610303879, -0.002567425137385726, -0.08364327251911163, 0.007306011393666267, 0.005691301077604294, 0.07590385526418686, 0.020272061228752136, -0.00492125004529953, -0.03454993665218353, -0.0007971874438226223, 0.03916739672422409, 0.001920577371492982, -0.002116848947480321, 0.029045235365629196, 0.05213650315999985, 0.038873739540576935, 0.036632660776376724, -0.042918045073747635, 0.05803711712360382, -0.010003790259361267, -0.05336214229464531, -0.01299993135035038, -0.011320238001644611, -0.032572194933891296, 0.0150351133197546, -0.03031613864004612, -0.018974844366312027, -0.037642672657966614, 0.03325812891125679, 0.00678773270919919, -0.07765327394008636, 0.06089385971426964, 0.017336532473564148, -0.006470362190157175, 0.026129979640245438, 0.004604530055075884, 0.0278275515884161, 0.011305064894258976, 0.04300281032919884, 0.039461731910705566, 0.003441737499088049, -0.016889868304133415, -0.039744872599840164, -0.0214390829205513, -0.042219556868076324, 0.018271945416927338, -0.019427932798862457, 0.024005582556128502, -0.05556199699640274, -0.08135928958654404, 0.023691149428486824, -0.028558703139424324, -0.0547434538602829, -0.033718597143888474, -0.031917791813611984, 0.010540686547756195, 0.0420985147356987, -0.043303679674863815, -0.08484769612550735, 0.005309392232447863, 0.023504750803112984, -0.014026672579348087, -0.01972990669310093, -0.00798787735402584, -0.05318242684006691, 0.011657750234007835, -0.08848609775304794, -0.003612956963479519, 0.05442104861140251, 0.020912766456604004, 0.008030788972973824, -0.019899573177099228, 0.03858006373047829, -0.04325916990637779, -0.02451440505683422, 0.006405186839401722, -0.022287512198090553, 0.027232544496655464, -0.024851294234395027, 0.01564251258969307, -0.0350886769592762, 0.0016216253861784935, 0.05805754289031029, 0.02678200975060463, -0.014584916643798351, -0.007543260231614113, 0.022497843950986862, -0.013665612787008286, 0.027098815888166428, 0.06507102400064468, 0.006906285881996155, 0.023600684478878975, -0.04650311917066574, 0.008184039033949375, -0.028841283172369003, -0.05225064605474472, 0.040239784866571426, -0.0326644666492939, 0.011238169856369495, 0.018484016880393028, -0.019170023500919342, -0.01229471992701292, -0.05146848410367966, -0.07053995877504349, 0.05413861200213432, 0.01024734228849411, -0.01457400806248188, 0.04181893169879913, -0.030254676938056946, 0.0291970856487751, 0.018976612016558647, 0.024094901978969574, -0.03172207251191139, -0.0249038003385067, 0.009620284661650658, -0.037738408893346786, 0.059997644275426865, -0.07682845741510391, 0.0346611924469471, -0.020785214379429817, -0.004265174735337496, 0.05518171936273575, 0.07156640291213989, -0.023889761418104172, 0.0565914586186409, -0.0846673771739006, -0.006707873195409775, 0.05247730761766434, -0.04292040690779686, 0.022319545969367027, 0.05427708476781845, 0.014800110831856728, 0.04620678722858429, 0.024846794083714485, -0.03523589298129082, 0.07602453976869583, -0.033559657633304596, 0.025728214532136917, 0.010735411196947098, 0.02115792967379093, -0.0031635737977921963, 0.01836714893579483, 0.005562200676649809, -0.07134509831666946, -0.0020077680237591267, -0.006688244640827179, 0.03862271457910538, -0.0026733672711998224, -0.0062374877743422985, 0.07398635149002075, 0.0013705019373446703, -0.023897267878055573, -0.0369984433054924, 0.05963071063160896, -0.035461246967315674, -0.05171741917729378, 0.04903542622923851, 0.02800319530069828, -0.06808583438396454, -0.05436394736170769 ]
The magnetotail current sheet's spatial configuration and stability control the onset of magnetic reconnection - the driving process for magnetospheric substorms. The near-Earth current sheet has been thoroughly investigated by numerous missions, whereas the midtail current sheet has not been adequately explored. This is especially the case for the long-term variation of its configuration in response to the solar wind. We present a statistical analysis of 1261 magnetotail current sheet crossings by the Acceleration, Reconnection, Turbulence and Electrodynamics of Moon's Interaction with the Sun (ARTEMIS) mission orbiting the moon (X~-60 RE), collected during the entirety of Solar Cycle 24. We demonstrate that the magnetotail current sheet typically remains extremely thin, with a characteristic thickness comparable to the thermal ion gyroradius, even at such large distances from Earth's dipole. We also find that a substantial fraction (~one quarter) of the observed current sheets have a partially force-free magnetic field configuration, with a negligible contribution of the thermal pressure and a significant contribution of the magnetic field shear component to the pressure balance. Further, we quantify the impact of the changing solar wind driving conditions on the properties of the midtail around the lunar orbit. During active solar wind driving conditions, we observe an increase in the occurrence rate of thin current sheets, whereas quiet solar wind driving conditions seem to favor the formation of partially force-free current sheets.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16194v1
[ -0.05598924681544304, -0.045447446405887604, 0.026708876714110374, -0.026968160644173622, -0.02209123969078064, -0.01464610081166029, -0.006740770768374205, 0.040643077343702316, -0.013776290230453014, 0.009157375432550907, 0.03724329546093941, -0.06231962889432907, -0.003090203506872058, -0.012936867773532867, -0.03367409482598305, 0.05652306228876114, 0.03347368165850639, 0.031028946861624718, -0.0021755655761808157, 0.05094034597277641, 0.019291551783680916, -0.022490469738841057, 0.00407365383580327, 0.02907501719892025, 0.013692845590412617, -0.03418871387839317, -0.04420740157365799, 0.03272208198904991, -0.042666804045438766, 0.0011928615858778358, 0.05310395732522011, -0.05321672931313515, -0.01913989894092083, -0.0055887121707201, -0.022538315504789352, 0.0332646481692791, -0.023809006437659264, 0.03561906889081001, 0.03649643808603287, -0.004047020338475704, -0.018889598548412323, -0.06154249981045723, 0.006990024354308844, -0.00680007366463542, -0.031477075070142746, -0.06314969062805176, 0.004337741527706385, -0.009870052337646484, -0.013517143204808235, -0.04758839309215546, 0.036622412502765656, 0.004473618697375059, 0.019880279898643494, 0.013061756268143654, -0.02126953937113285, -0.02301008068025112, 0.033190224319696426, -0.0375504307448864, -0.030171824619174004, -0.019817348569631577, -0.041368257254362106, -0.0418827161192894, 0.04890519008040428, -0.011814195662736893, -0.049992699176073074, 0.05330050736665726, -0.041468143463134766, -0.060936395078897476, -0.0029333801940083504, -0.057774003595113754, 0.007336695212870836, -0.06093176081776619, 0.012879506684839725, 0.0007040711352601647, -0.05304950475692749, 0.03943290561437607, -0.03125423938035965, -0.03076402097940445, -0.010767849162220955, 0.027293290942907333, -0.04791224002838135, -0.007021708879619837, 0.025685356929898262, 0.027016310021281242, 0.04181128367781639, 0.00031024368945509195, 0.04266323894262314, 0.0004951820592395961, -0.021355342119932175, -0.03790394961833954, -0.002377592958509922, -0.04874243959784508, -0.02232687547802925, -0.0623474158346653, 0.049117960035800934, -0.03669055923819542, 0.06067032366991043, 0.01426541805267334, 0.0258634015917778, -0.03879183158278465, 0.012047297321259975, -0.03891543298959732, -0.030087169259786606, 0.04329263046383858, 0.0430644191801548, -0.06668485701084137, -0.01100866962224245, -0.037565261125564575, -0.03391021117568016, 0.040528472512960434, -0.0020215758122503757, -0.01706315577030182, 0.018421607092022896, -0.03812311962246895, -0.03542754054069519, -0.07460917532444, 0.06694871932268143, 0.01086780522018671, -0.009447423741221428, -0.03082241863012314, -0.030925432220101357, 0.04662644863128662, -0.004135428462177515, -0.0077659450471401215, 0.014062182046473026, 0.005577237345278263, 0.07477480918169022, 0.003041510470211506, 0.02424732968211174, -0.03919330611824989, -0.03372938930988312, -0.018163364380598068, 0.046346619725227356, -0.010483323596417904, 0.03900875896215439, 0.006173951551318169, 0.002294495701789856, 0.013204534538090229, 0.010969933122396469, 0.013090677559375763, -0.020555494353175163, 0.016107935458421707, 0.014595716260373592, 0.01632397249341011, -0.02176091820001602, -0.01620575040578842, -0.0678909495472908, -0.006673632189631462, 0.05298647657036781, 0.022753961384296417, -0.01744825951755047, -0.011736825108528137, 0.00930330902338028, 0.036427248269319534, 0.05776549503207207, -0.02332964912056923, 0.04443741217255592, 0.005947963334619999, -0.03542271628975868, 0.015985563397407532, 0.03151519596576691, -0.048336971551179886, 0.0290974173694849, -0.005754176992923021, -0.02100439742207527, 0.040580883622169495, 0.05688706785440445, -0.04940551146864891, -0.03451140969991684, 0.011750221252441406, 0.008351667784154415, 0.0379374660551548, 0.0012357907835394144, -0.04329247027635574, -0.06081171706318855, -0.06833460927009583, 0.021433208137750626, -0.036956775933504105, 0.027839483693242073, 0.054858360439538956, 0.013235513120889664, 0.00770147331058979, -0.04292592778801918, -0.02592315897345543, -0.025289801880717278, 0.003689604578539729, -0.08571354299783707, 0.02825166843831539, -0.002908282680436969, -0.015266137197613716, -0.03967176750302315, -0.04584050923585892, 0.04221533238887787, -0.004487975966185331, -0.024345532059669495, 0.010095829144120216, 0.0139217684045434, 0.008452390320599079, 0.007433359976857901, -0.0044018859043717384, -0.042685382068157196, 0.003773644333705306, -0.018108464777469635, -0.021743888035416603, -0.02325599268078804, -0.08386985957622528, 0.05052276328206062, 0.02078717015683651, 0.0011328522814437747, -0.00955776497721672, 0.032570190727710724, 0.018597116693854332, -0.006728764157742262, -0.0065653035417199135, 0.006194768473505974, -0.0325322262942791, -0.0904783234000206, 0.0050949170254170895, -0.013586197979748249, -0.028482066467404366, 0.0028910632245242596, -0.022434096783399582, -0.026572298258543015, -0.024418581277132034, -0.0066110510379076, 0.054649267345666885, 0.049590304493904114, -0.017086051404476166, -0.06875485181808472, 0.03772764652967453, -0.005339817143976688, -0.07554326951503754, -0.06067157909274101, -0.06271246075630188, -0.03726648911833763, 0.05863291397690773, -0.06144234165549278, 0.047162316739559174, -0.03537169471383095, -0.0019470214610919356, -0.012804048135876656, 0.02859979309141636, 0.02036207728087902, -0.03281731158494949, -0.07422090321779251, -0.03329746052622795, -0.07052205502986908, 0.01629248820245266, -0.02473589777946472, -0.02997550740838051, -0.027311500161886215, -0.04166734963655472, -0.010222640819847584, 0.0031152672600001097, 0.004555988125503063, 0.07316896319389343, -0.020743245258927345, 0.03655243664979935, 0.021105369552969933, 0.006339939311146736, -0.027157394215464592, 0.040565863251686096, -0.061894867569208145, 0.01015452016144991, -0.025162428617477417, 0.02514917589724064, -0.0686703473329544, -0.006289548706263304, -0.054626427590847015, -0.030840545892715454, 0.03608350083231926, 0.001480795443058014, 0.04050089418888092, -0.0003455805126577616, -0.036411236971616745, -0.06601757556200027, 0.012676388025283813, -0.05927278473973274, 0.0015813133213669062, 0.026897229254245758, 0.03680970519781113, 0.04112491384148598, 0.020827967673540115, -0.07750027626752853, -0.009132002480328083, -0.033574700355529785, -0.0075383298099040985, -0.032016512006521225, -0.057369641959667206, 0.029567690566182137, -0.04212716221809387, -0.019992806017398834, -0.0303039588034153, 0.009759936481714249, -0.03705922141671181, -0.04222552850842476, -0.001977992244064808, 0.007244308013468981, 0.0009446125477552414, -0.03667877987027168, -0.02455466240644455, 0.022937482222914696, 0.009745855815708637, 0.050509415566921234, -0.04183686152100563, 0.007926124148070812, -0.044506534934043884, 0.013272913172841072, -0.022424964234232903, 0.005978549364954233, -0.060764413326978683, 0.003097525564953685, -0.05243413522839546, -0.001311328960582614, -0.025539755821228027, 0.06130136176943779, 0.032352421432733536, -0.07365988940000534, -0.030049744993448257, -0.019843896850943565, -0.03972058743238449, -0.03169737011194229, 0.039730459451675415, 0.005395349580794573, -0.07189100235700607, -0.026083992794156075, 0.06783416122198105, 0.07047945261001587, 0.05013890564441681, -0.044851068407297134, -0.05700983479619026, 0.021752476692199707, -0.041606027632951736, 0.01258025411516428, 0.06990107893943787, 0.01562490314245224, -0.05720473453402519, 0.06380288302898407, -0.013349764980375767, 0.060164835304021835, -0.02738691121339798, -0.005809738300740719, -0.011128459125757217, 0.004125051666051149, -0.0012075693812221289, -0.0295964814722538, 0.011710947379469872, 0.0274953655898571, 0.04318281263113022, -0.007756034377962351, 0.014390146359801292, 0.05307063087821007, 0.005219439044594765, 0.031166192144155502, -0.05064314603805542, -0.0024730898439884186, 0.02953276038169861, 0.042235661298036575, -0.022225964814424515, 0.009613754227757454, -0.010062620975077152, -0.06432303041219711, -0.04469681903719902, 0.008329266682267189, 0.034809648990631104, 0.03354039415717125, 0.046521030366420746, -0.019888944923877716, 0.02260942943394184, -0.022169318050146103, 0.06437855958938599, -0.02501988224685192, -0.04394084960222244, 0.0057307216338813305, -0.025878770276904106, 0.0077308425679802895, -0.02512345463037491, 0.01889932155609131, -0.02255217917263508, -0.06914912164211273, 0.02762332558631897, -0.051586054265499115, -0.049400731921195984, 0.0031075202859938145, 0.0557347908616066, 0.04565765708684921, 0.029346611350774765, -0.012096386402845383, 0.005426015704870224, -0.0025489432737231255, -0.011865532957017422, -0.007963160052895546, -0.0400250107049942, 0.04144622012972832, -0.03300737962126732, -0.012883477844297886, -0.025728272274136543, 0.026589220389723778, 0.0012453811941668391, 0.006834348663687706, -0.028244229033589363, -0.01717933639883995, -0.0528796911239624, -0.08213310688734055, -0.03396255150437355, -0.04655466601252556, 0.05901971459388733, 0.0025264902506023645, 0.016224725171923637, 0.06359611451625824, -0.019533026963472366, -0.04554830864071846, -0.01864723488688469, 0.019656745716929436, -0.049649421125650406, -0.044820237904787064, 0.009244242683053017, 0.008434443734586239, 0.039277251809835434, -0.044495590031147, 0.03386220708489418, -0.03879602253437042, 0.02117765322327614, -0.07963163405656815, 0.036360640078783035, -0.039340194314718246, 0.02146046794950962, 0.017580388113856316, 0.017301497980952263, 0.04525677114725113, 0.009480280801653862, -0.016219880431890488, 0.021795956417918205, 0.016682755202054977, 0.020180704072117805, -0.030729221180081367, 0.03859931230545044, -0.06502953171730042, -0.06412552297115326, -0.034610796719789505, 0.013424953445792198, 0.06207949295639992, -0.039093855768442154, -0.03349786624312401, 0.048601385205984116, 0.05856282636523247, -0.04550148546695709, -0.060696590691804886, -0.03140611946582794, -0.05431334674358368, -0.06393501162528992, -0.0035995279904454947, -0.022346025332808495, -0.005110207945108414, -0.034927502274513245, 0.06433746218681335, 0.04180512577295303, 0.01364967692643404, -0.060087189078330994, 0.06434263288974762, -0.023481925949454308, 0.0006127107189968228, -0.0071364641189575195, -0.018790900707244873, -0.06597980111837387, 0.016055718064308167, 0.05372309312224388, -0.03204866498708725, 0.021883094683289528, 0.026038777083158493, -0.027463432401418686, 0.012912135571241379, -0.07786569744348526, 0.026164960116147995, 0.023522166535258293, -0.06703300029039383, 0.030610473826527596, -0.011919979937374592, -0.02126438543200493, 0.012291576713323593, 0.004613771568983793, -0.012593397870659828, -0.00007509897841373459, -0.023807872086763382, 0.009245403110980988, 0.04456520080566406, -0.06614069640636444, -0.0025436822324991226, -0.02256941795349121, 0.0014977415557950735, -0.07737011462450027, 0.032387565821409225, 0.0039021773263812065, -0.03417601063847542, -0.05917079746723175, 0.011389479041099548, 0.05063039809465408, -0.010311208665370941, -0.05994700267910957, -0.014392060227692127, 0.011492030695080757, -0.02015162818133831, 0.032624777406454086, -0.06417007744312286, -0.04177413508296013, -0.0049002752639353275, 0.018189702183008194, 0.03356444463133812, 0.06464994698762894, -0.02511652372777462, -0.03651570901274681, 0.04263026639819145, -0.023902593180537224, -0.07367369532585144, 0.0067322091199457645, -0.06839941442012787, 0.041507307440042496, 0.041308384388685226, 0.020430268719792366, 0.06855931878089905, 0.057921264320611954, 0.008194828405976295, -0.07159844785928726, 0.005019188392907381, -0.025407761335372925, 0.04252946376800537, -0.018125345930457115, 0.023388326168060303, 0.012238584458827972, 0.028120242059230804, -0.013869664631783962, -0.019671669229865074, 0.01125989481806755, -0.018792135640978813, -0.030176391825079918, 0.02868962660431862, -0.023345259949564934, 0.008988836780190468, -0.06314700096845627, -0.001199035788886249, 0.058303263038396835, -0.006162631791085005, 0.06790290027856827, 0.005721915513277054, 0.019990183413028717, 0.029843177646398544, -0.011623915284872055, -0.006614516489207745, -0.08204764872789383, -0.016041019931435585, 0.0714338943362236, -0.06630326062440872, -0.011731655336916447, 0.0169437974691391, 0.005176790524274111, 0.013131332583725452, -0.03567954897880554, 0.007799656596034765, 0.029286667704582214, -0.03487670049071312, -0.06396757066249847, -0.0028954206500202417, -0.03099297545850277, -0.04135994613170624, -0.008457380346953869, 0.010863116011023521, -0.07068102061748505, 0.004097718745470047, -0.03053753636777401, -0.012312863022089005, -0.029838765040040016, 0.0025578162167221308, -0.06853161007165909, -0.06532886624336243, 0.003493559081107378, 0.01175019796937704, 0.06926167756319046, -0.03644818812608719, -0.01222721766680479, 0.004438373260200024, 0.002047566929832101, -0.020661743357777596, -0.0386829748749733, -0.003977152984589338, -0.018080072477459908, 0.07022394984960556, -0.028646929189562798, 0.0067167337983846664, -0.012127207592129707, 0.04479045048356056, -0.04553645849227905, -0.004470308311283588, 0.032401565462350845, -0.0014770642155781388, 0.04140337556600571, -0.03094898723065853, -0.046782154589891434, 0.016468897461891174, 0.014009259641170502, 0.017067454755306244, -0.03006628528237343, -0.01236011739820242, 0.01838071271777153, 0.06624611467123032, 0.03357734531164169, -0.01738681271672249, 0.03193509951233864, -0.03470573574304581, -0.0590120330452919, 0.018417702987790108, -0.0493762232363224, -0.02211509644985199, -0.016781436279416084, 0.021396268159151077, -0.010064725764095783, 0.030208749696612358, -0.03390062227845192, 0.00855176243931055, -0.051483288407325745, 0.007304857484996319, 0.027285266667604446, 0.007391619496047497, 0.009629573673009872, 0.011809172108769417, 0.052668459713459015, -0.044636111706495285, -0.04377669468522072, -0.05424649640917778, -0.0381300188601017, 0.04174492880702019, -0.04145937040448189, -0.021831674501299858, -0.017750242725014687, 0.020255932584404945, -0.03343935310840607, 0.0182949285954237, 0.03189019113779068, -0.01408276055008173, -0.06687966734170914, -0.029492245987057686, 0.033309489488601685, 0.007516379002481699, 0.012195848859846592, -0.040105607360601425, 0.029082460328936577, -0.0019660007674247026, -0.0017647636123001575, 0.06029011309146881, -0.0032076851930469275, -0.0030644601210951805, -0.04766895994544029, 0.0065751345828175545, 0.0426635667681694, -0.0034533755388110876, -0.05437003821134567, -0.009767673909664154, -0.04485515505075455, -0.06253223866224289, 0.03029484674334526, 0.03946644067764282, 0.04717644304037094, -0.01184756774455309, -0.020336883142590523, 0.04759389907121658, 0.055297743529081345, 0.007735807914286852, -0.07966508716344833, -0.00898919627070427, -0.00927964597940445, -0.01830669865012169, 0.004987012594938278, 0.011552517302334309, -0.06101492419838905, -0.012207997031509876, -0.07690113037824631, 0.015502970665693283, -0.06014714017510414, 0.0552392303943634, -0.021975846961140633, -0.013131240382790565, -0.01841810531914234, -0.04441556707024574, 0.04364924505352974, 0.04570513218641281, 0.03639502823352814, 0.04280516505241394, 0.009450952522456646, -0.00781698152422905, -0.028840795159339905, -0.003408552147448063, 0.014209885150194168, -0.05094190686941147, 0.01647273264825344, 0.02896973490715027, 0.05132570490241051, -0.030639277771115303, 0.01708957552909851, 0.005852123722434044, -0.03715813532471657, -0.00496445270255208, 0.0018137791194021702, -0.028110463172197342, -0.030272841453552246, -0.056748583912849426, -0.023413630202412605, -0.01767336204648018, 0.01591874286532402, 0.03717547655105591, -0.0007737225387245417, -0.03156430274248123, -0.028645439073443413, -0.03174002468585968, 0.0038443247321993113, 0.03003140352666378, -0.010674168355762959, 0.06666424870491028, -0.06499559432268143, 0.0028185753617435694, 0.023545168340206146, -0.051365308463573456, -0.053870029747486115, 0.02948693558573723, 0.03215542063117027, -0.029108315706253052, 0.012977558188140392, -0.06672777980566025, 0.043725915253162384, -0.027481241151690483, 0.011772175319492817, -0.015738967806100845, 0.024553213268518448, -0.05895596370100975, -0.03914928436279297, -0.0464756116271019, -0.05346205458045006, 0.004455822054296732, -0.024455735459923744, -0.030328379943966866, -0.01684308424592018, 0.0055002435110509396, 0.011657333932816982, 0.027568280696868896, 0.011906889267265797, 0.04489952698349953, 0.016667630523443222, -0.009935217909514904, -0.04056178033351898, -0.02749665267765522, -0.02079661563038826, 0.03946685418486595, 0.015972016379237175, -0.041742559522390366, -0.07612761110067368, -0.015401494689285755, -0.0331353023648262, -0.020697832107543945, -0.03613697737455368, 0.03370538726449013, -0.03827711567282677, -0.04885444790124893, -0.05140523239970207, -0.0022916996385902166, 0.016676360741257668, 0.004252603743225336, -0.004188825376331806, 0.043597981333732605, -0.00966909434646368, -0.05598248541355133 ]
The utilization of programming language (PL) models, pre-trained on large-scale code corpora, as a means of automating software engineering processes has demonstrated considerable potential in streamlining various code generation tasks such as code completion, code translation, and program synthesis. However, current approaches mainly rely on supervised fine-tuning objectives borrowed from text generation, neglecting unique sequence-level characteristics of code, including but not limited to compilability as well as syntactic and functional correctness. To address this limitation, we propose PPOCoder, a new framework for code generation that synergistically combines pre-trained PL models with Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) which is a widely used deep reinforcement learning technique. By utilizing non-differentiable feedback from code execution and structure alignment, PPOCoder seamlessly integrates external code-specific knowledge into the model optimization process. It's important to note that PPOCoder is a task-agnostic and model-agnostic framework that can be used across different code generation tasks and PLs. Extensive experiments on three code generation tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed approach compared to SOTA methods, achieving significant improvements in compilation success rates and functional correctness across different PLs.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13816v4
[ -0.023754503577947617, -0.05591191351413727, 0.0009241397492587566, -0.02607167698442936, -0.04017899930477142, -0.02044611983001232, -0.003447928000241518, 0.002392915077507496, 0.044187989085912704, -0.0004973767208866775, -0.04638642817735672, 0.04425125941634178, -0.02611522004008293, -0.019131401553750038, -0.039034999907016754, -0.04649770259857178, 0.07132993638515472, 0.0505170039832592, -0.05802387744188309, 0.06278369575738907, -0.020388305187225342, -0.0008726806263439357, -0.03885597735643387, 0.03686065226793289, -0.0009595084120519459, 0.01426213514059782, -0.053456082940101624, -0.023697245866060257, -0.02430822141468525, -0.01566222682595253, 0.05214407294988632, -0.0019503869116306305, -0.04041343554854393, -0.042312901467084885, -0.04822586476802826, -0.04008793458342552, -0.04958144947886467, 0.031054187566041946, 0.07037204504013062, -0.06068495288491249, 0.032365813851356506, -0.058524008840322495, -0.06731710582971573, 0.02312195487320423, 0.01040845550596714, -0.030789632350206375, -0.06606095284223557, 0.029222242534160614, -0.03201369568705559, -0.061945244669914246, 0.01663976162672043, 0.00325993774458766, -0.015921762213110924, 0.051105063408613205, -0.06485669314861298, 0.028758252039551735, -0.0034744804725050926, 0.018908366560935974, -0.06584595143795013, -0.007161584682762623, 0.032409146428108215, 0.01680712401866913, -0.06128912791609764, 0.032656479626894, 0.004873083904385567, 0.05000316724181175, 0.006220798473805189, -0.07024578005075455, -0.06065671890974045, -0.031316161155700684, 0.033650778234004974, -0.06254526972770691, -0.03058561496436596, 0.023538650944828987, -0.035062115639448166, -0.03296594321727753, -0.058995649218559265, -0.01920708268880844, 0.010104498825967312, -0.03452786058187485, -0.05821709334850311, 0.020318737253546715, -0.0058362181298434734, 0.018020739778876305, -0.01518994476646185, -0.029698096215724945, -0.005516135133802891, 0.016910851001739502, -0.02194172516465187, -0.03458421677350998, 0.0353592224419117, -0.010874977335333824, -0.08126049488782883, 0.04352307692170143, 0.059909090399742126, 0.004055559169501066, 0.04236667975783348, 0.03668619692325592, 0.014916663989424706, -0.023881396278738976, -0.038903310894966125, 0.007743820082396269, -0.03481004014611244, 0.034108538180589676, 0.03983822092413902, -0.026196351274847984, 0.04747233912348747, 0.002480686642229557, -0.04564088582992554, -0.045582447201013565, -0.03010491281747818, -0.03187307342886925, -0.03361305594444275, -0.06829819828271866, -0.05468194559216499, -0.03338727355003357, 0.05256762355566025, -0.011948979459702969, -0.013546964153647423, -0.0016727468464523554, -0.044743940234184265, 0.03828245401382446, 0.024142051115632057, -0.013406851328909397, -0.046492211520671844, -0.03156258538365364, 0.06875638663768768, -0.036523837596178055, -0.021720781922340393, -0.035358257591724396, -0.019370947033166885, 0.010204237885773182, 0.00499762175604701, -0.03903046250343323, 0.07464198768138885, -0.009578594006597996, 0.005372283980250359, -0.0518563948571682, 0.04938999563455582, -0.05311499536037445, -0.0574035607278347, -0.08245658874511719, -0.0004473722947295755, -0.06305035948753357, 0.041998349130153656, 0.06572478264570236, -0.01843300648033619, 0.02303212694823742, 0.023223968222737312, 0.0094453739002347, 0.012755398638546467, -0.020430030301213264, 0.02894122526049614, 0.022816244512796402, 0.038964297622442245, 0.01215323992073536, 0.023639487102627754, -0.02875329926609993, -0.07027659565210342, -0.011175906285643578, 0.0035334841813892126, 0.0016301660798490047, 0.03215060755610466, -0.013706348836421967, -0.02487165294587612, -0.0017161297146230936, 0.05281419679522514, -0.014890278689563274, -0.002290277974680066, 0.0506431870162487, -0.040114626288414, -0.00867713987827301, -0.009681988507509232, -0.01441025361418724, -0.046542998403310776, -0.02797478251159191, 0.03817570582032204, -0.03519314154982567, -0.04899085313081741, 0.017787238582968712, -0.004150237422436476, 0.02800552174448967, -0.03879665210843086, -0.04842650517821312, -0.029296837747097015, 0.0023253976833075285, -0.07367997616529465, -0.0003782157727982849, 0.04312131181359291, 0.0305167343467474, -0.028702547773718834, -0.013023743405938148, 0.02359769679605961, 0.020824622362852097, -0.01504428405314684, -0.043524980545043945, 0.005554153583943844, -0.0403754860162735, 0.03229604661464691, 0.050573691725730896, -0.08170752972364426, 0.002682775491848588, -0.06624315679073334, 0.00869590975344181, 0.007339891511946917, -0.05327729508280754, -0.0027603181079030037, 0.05627664178609848, -0.06861896812915802, -0.006302675232291222, 0.011183326132595539, 0.05303001031279564, 0.059867363423109055, 0.027110429480671883, 0.03155425935983658, 0.018002869561314583, -0.08720957487821579, 0.060409191995859146, 0.02489103190600872, -0.01800716295838356, 0.015797864645719528, -0.022887568920850754, -0.016359882429242134, -0.04779563471674919, -0.038738101720809937, 0.046936120837926865, 0.05866216868162155, 0.005158258136361837, -0.04555884748697281, -0.009950065985321999, 0.0008924160501919687, -0.016563259065151215, -0.0001777961297193542, -0.06499496102333069, 0.001814087969250977, -0.028212806209921837, -0.010836734436452389, 0.040692880749702454, -0.005922851152718067, -0.02950223907828331, -0.03805747628211975, -0.03243511542677879, 0.020339032635092735, -0.016136398538947105, -0.05107872933149338, -0.057525597512722015, -0.023984631523489952, 0.0218715351074934, -0.020160702988505363, -0.0014128809561952949, -0.03843128681182861, -0.020927947014570236, 0.005767191760241985, 0.0032057235948741436, 0.017604241147637367, 0.03679606318473816, -0.01825423538684845, 0.029354404658079147, 0.0010435993317514658, 0.0018221336649730802, 0.023076191544532776, 0.030263256281614304, -0.03948097303509712, 0.029716402292251587, 0.042299412190914154, -0.01049800869077444, 0.007892073132097721, 0.015219304710626602, 0.013323736377060413, -0.04316617175936699, -0.015577202662825584, 0.045695528388023376, 0.042365167289972305, -0.007370375096797943, -0.010592853650450706, -0.013052772730588913, 0.006947701796889305, 0.008476372808218002, 0.01976892724633217, 0.06345141679048538, 0.009399010799825191, 0.022854654118418694, 0.016462896019220352, -0.07823899388313293, -0.012661476619541645, -0.03483147174119949, -0.023361817002296448, -0.03896300867199898, -0.008293483406305313, -0.06756015866994858, -0.045581333339214325, -0.050511617213487625, -0.03676045686006546, -0.02068280428647995, 0.003718327498063445, -0.05018160119652748, -0.025854669511318207, -0.0028821423184126616, -0.016200220212340355, 0.001397492247633636, -0.047746509313583374, -0.0635576918721199, 0.008124050684273243, -0.030578365549445152, -0.02227269671857357, -0.05416925996541977, -0.03438742458820343, -0.014742108061909676, 0.006316651590168476, 0.0076661561615765095, -0.02010369300842285, 0.034323666244745255, -0.022812385112047195, 0.0032436747569590807, -0.012843628413975239, 0.039677828550338745, 0.010241185314953327, 0.05841643363237381, -0.03270278498530388, -0.007576779928058386, 0.0008338253246620297, 0.014929980970919132, -0.0021787728182971478, -0.03218986839056015, -0.03650907427072525, 0.012875725515186787, 0.05111496150493622, -0.027434218674898148, -0.061663445085287094, -0.04900349676609039, -0.013942783698439598, 0.038908421993255615, 0.027239009737968445, -0.030764557421207428, -0.012925099581480026, 0.05574342980980873, -0.029724203050136566, -0.05471111834049225, -0.002077203243970871, 0.0005394459003582597, 0.015013562515377998, 0.020339958369731903, 0.018575120717287064, -0.04946831613779068, 0.05973149091005325, -0.06872271746397018, 0.0022904048673808575, 0.06082986667752266, 0.052674464881420135, -0.03126024454832077, 0.0032309270463883877, -0.044207870960235596, 0.04572301357984543, 0.005717235151678324, -0.00036054785596206784, 0.04757650941610336, 0.035977691411972046, 0.0342954657971859, -0.010688494890928268, -0.03467941656708717, -0.008646827191114426, -0.06525053083896637, -0.024236518889665604, -0.009290696121752262, -0.0012631557183340192, -0.03161342814564705, -0.028711454942822456, -0.060180217027664185, -0.010487912222743034, -0.02806306630373001, 0.019900621846318245, 0.030663589015603065, -0.05590508505702019, -0.00044124829582870007, -0.05981016531586647, 0.02091403864324093, -0.015265149995684624, 0.016905751079320908, -0.0003236386692151427, -0.03156261146068573, 0.04076128080487251, -0.06983613222837448, 0.025258567184209824, 0.030270347371697426, -0.01775914430618286, 0.02149062603712082, 0.05682571604847908, -0.004315252415835857, 0.06021919846534729, -0.022328274324536324, -0.030685078352689743, 0.03483125939965248, 0.03726067766547203, -0.033008091151714325, -0.04355153068900108, -0.05731803551316261, -0.047760531306266785, 0.045325085520744324, -0.020526062697172165, -0.003585526719689369, 0.009571125730872154, -0.0014948999742045999, -0.012310091406106949, -0.06779808551073074, 0.030762843787670135, -0.05761025846004486, 0.05853778496384621, 0.0003893526445608586, -0.04984314367175102, 0.04008921608328819, -0.0401497557759285, 0.006560004781931639, -0.029588906094431877, 0.008051290176808834, -0.026084033772349358, -0.03704824298620224, -0.02959871105849743, -0.06403759121894836, 0.03334866836667061, -0.03312765434384346, 0.05688555911183357, 0.016408905386924744, -0.008474656380712986, -0.018311575055122375, 0.02543346770107746, -0.010290777310729027, 0.014359519816935062, 0.07008010894060135, -0.005694061517715454, -0.043718237429857254, -0.04244161397218704, 0.016289884224534035, 0.028866944834589958, -0.017322488129138947, 0.028936337679624557, -0.04611285775899887, 0.019618934020400047, -0.00687041599303484, -0.011349956505000591, 0.017021415755152702, -0.02601064369082451, 0.05456310883164406, -0.02652248740196228, -0.03410400077700615, -0.052192848175764084, 0.027191409841179848, -0.044827722012996674, -0.06050597131252289, -0.03013647347688675, -0.03403621166944504, -0.055643852800130844, -0.036723751574754715, 0.045730963349342346, 0.060653988271951675, -0.03566346690058708, -0.016352955251932144, 0.020060880109667778, -0.009393008425831795, 0.0024105063639581203, 0.020231349393725395, 0.04952645301818848, -0.03739876300096512, -0.006957215256989002, 0.010928298346698284, -0.07667849212884903, 0.018134715035557747, -0.03039463423192501, -0.005088682286441326, -0.004935640841722488, -0.017009256407618523, 0.03034370020031929, 0.05096384137868881, -0.08193030953407288, -0.013673597015440464, 0.001357564702630043, -0.0634913519024849, 0.016404228284955025, 0.036460671573877335, -0.02764633484184742, 0.042890552431344986, -0.03319527581334114, -0.01890844665467739, 0.017148293554782867, -0.05093485116958618, -0.024050021544098854, -0.003591978456825018, -0.014402673579752445, 0.016113173216581345, 0.05523436516523361, 0.037990275770425797, -0.05938338860869408, 0.004124680068343878, 0.05716816335916519, 0.01004274096339941, -0.046647440642118454, 0.05599072203040123, 0.02261047251522541, -0.0423162542283535, -0.057004913687705994, -0.026950418949127197, 0.005266750231385231, -0.05497710034251213, -0.01979542151093483, -0.015224427916109562, -0.005897774361073971, 0.02016214095056057, 0.030222197994589806, -0.008721156045794487, 0.021173957735300064, 0.04099265858530998, -0.007186748553067446, -0.053520288318395615, -0.0026544162537902594, -0.039056919515132904, 0.002190419938415289, 0.008050665259361267, 0.011729172430932522, 0.04025431349873543, -0.04525819420814514, 0.0345926433801651, 0.033798947930336, -0.029855137690901756, -0.020673435181379318, -0.00826937798410654, -0.013657511211931705, -0.006684085354208946, -0.042143192142248154, -0.019600484520196915, -0.008151271380484104, -0.0018469482893124223, 0.008845980279147625, 0.0339498408138752, -0.02916182577610016, -0.004692632704973221, -0.019507478922605515, 0.045081350952386856, 0.010518561117351055, -0.06735441088676453, -0.029963282868266106, 0.04628366231918335, 0.01141448225826025, -0.036460813134908676, 0.027396628633141518, 0.04196156933903694, -0.0287331435829401, 0.04542035609483719, 0.04678894579410553, -0.03984121233224869, -0.03201620280742645, 0.02027282677590847, 0.054730676114559174, -0.07199729233980179, -0.020310835912823677, -0.03486410155892372, -0.023275939747691154, 0.02900039218366146, -0.028721440583467484, -0.022669073194265366, 0.05722002312541008, -0.010620271787047386, -0.06167587637901306, 0.05320213735103607, 0.019807325676083565, -0.06807433068752289, 0.038351744413375854, 0.022973250597715378, -0.06787878274917603, -0.023603985086083412, 0.020627334713935852, 0.014908739365637302, -0.050309907644987106, 0.05774083733558655, 0.06417330354452133, -0.047131724655628204, -0.02119966596364975, 0.020290378481149673, 0.07334063947200775, -0.031511735171079636, -0.022216813638806343, 0.024517197161912918, -0.05988622084259987, 0.02819100394845009, -0.015192913822829723, -0.044435810297727585, 0.033125363290309906, -0.004214588552713394, 0.01911286450922489, -0.03061072714626789, 0.020951034501194954, 0.04604518041014671, -0.015910543501377106, 0.011563313193619251, 0.012024099007248878, -0.024599574506282806, 0.01768808253109455, -0.0572734996676445, -0.012701719999313354, 0.020701944828033447, -0.008937620557844639, -0.00562676414847374, -0.07587606459856033, 0.0022533154115080833, -0.012954894453287125, 0.011739853769540787, 0.020599117502570152, -0.07357554882764816, -0.01590280793607235, -0.04370627552270889, -0.08416518568992615, 0.0020198854617774487, -0.054256655275821686, 0.02099972777068615, 0.04150600731372833, -0.024649078026413918, -0.026188697665929794, 0.07319781184196472, -0.013628281652927399, -0.03281015530228615, 0.044586457312107086, -0.005775435362011194, 0.019087791442871094, 0.012484649196267128, -0.012825342826545238, -0.014491857960820198, 0.04668624699115753, -0.03585425764322281, -0.027754412963986397, 0.0018535553244873881, -0.03929832577705383, 0.03648298606276512, 0.017335427924990654, -0.009359206072986126, -0.015140089206397533, -0.011659420095384121, -0.024960745126008987, -0.005411533638834953, -0.03731129318475723, -0.05540168657898903, -0.07526043057441711, -0.02529890462756157, -0.0072370353154838085, 0.007837923243641853, -0.0006748930318281054, 0.0418514683842659, 0.03212848678231239, -0.007271158508956432, 0.037746794521808624, -0.027643993496894836, 0.04415721073746681, 0.012124244123697281, -0.058648671954870224, -0.022623328492045403, 0.029776282608509064, -0.03796269744634628, -0.026542283594608307, -0.016096528619527817, 0.004777057096362114, -0.0685783103108406, -0.019685570150613785, 0.02411278337240219, 0.0030212667770683765, -0.00853437278419733, -0.06627583503723145, 0.018797611817717552, -0.0015238634077832103, -0.06369365006685257, -0.044682685285806656, -0.005041923373937607, 0.023747706785798073, -0.041241638362407684, 0.03156612068414688, -0.059575967490673065, -0.035508155822753906, -0.01268556248396635, -0.060145847499370575, -0.011078783310949802, -0.0006004856550134718, 0.010042320005595684, 0.030448291450738907, -0.040542278438806534, 0.038605548441410065, -0.06459352374076843, 0.013930508866906166, -0.010236235335469246, 0.0029022409580647945, -0.0014021985698491335, 0.008158746175467968, 0.037934619933366776, -0.02992015890777111, -0.011517232283949852, 0.0611523762345314, -0.0007006279774941504, -0.03577570617198944, -0.006599102169275284, -0.03612832352519035, 0.04763047769665718, 0.01239769347012043, 0.040336448699235916, -0.05683213099837303, 0.020997369661927223, -0.054316796362400055, -0.010658814571797848, -0.05355070158839226, -0.04652829095721245, 0.010280988179147243, -0.03651833161711693, -0.017231881618499756, 0.04945716634392738, -0.005671119783073664, 0.015127536840736866, -0.03071967326104641, -0.042036738246679306, 0.036535345017910004, -0.046452105045318604, -0.05724791809916496, 0.06283360719680786, -0.01894320547580719, -0.01370132714509964, -0.037997011095285416, -0.03295453265309334, 0.009148923680186272, 0.05658880993723869, 0.06853320449590683, -0.025092901661992073, -0.0030221922788769007, -0.034255191683769226, 0.002443166682496667, 0.03666076436638832, 0.020928476005792618, -0.037773847579956055, 0.07358838617801666, 0.0010645592119544744, -0.020367974415421486, -0.013809642754495144, -0.031800705939531326, -0.046826787292957306, -0.06975071132183075, -0.036272309720516205, -0.06733237951993942, -0.005660326685756445, 0.004323145840317011, -0.034047793596982956, -0.01006521750241518, 0.04117726907134056, 0.04338373988866806, -0.015569406561553478, 0.009056437760591507, 0.052200354635715485, -0.03394276648759842, 0.04927681013941765, -0.0007608048617839813, 0.009283882565796375, -0.01819237694144249, 0.038079939782619476, 0.007696127984672785, -0.028555093333125114, 0.012982412241399288, -0.04928278923034668, -0.004143975675106049, -0.002790003316476941, -0.007970846258103848, 0.027674518525600433, 0.021959912031888962, -0.06044783070683479, -0.03696968033909798, -0.019078366458415985, -0.047072287648916245, -0.062046051025390625 ]
In manufacturing processes, surface inspection is a key requirement for quality assessment and damage localization. Due to this, automated surface anomaly detection has become a promising area of research in various industrial inspection systems. A particular challenge in industries with large-scale components, like aircraft and heavy machinery, is inspecting large parts with very small defect dimensions. Moreover, these parts can be of curved shapes. To address this challenge, we present a 2-stage multi-modal inspection pipeline with visual and tactile sensing. Our approach combines the best of both visual and tactile sensing by identifying and localizing defects using a global view (vision) and using the localized area for tactile scanning for identifying remaining defects. To benchmark our approach, we propose a novel real-world dataset with multiple metallic defect types per image, collected in the production environments on real aerospace manufacturing parts, as well as online robot experiments in two environments. Our approach is able to identify 85% defects using Stage I and identify 100% defects after Stage II. The dataset is publicly available at https://zenodo.org/record/8327713
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04590v1
[ -0.04337914288043976, -0.03392088785767555, 0.025774525478482246, -0.020812414586544037, 0.008970905095338821, -0.01454290933907032, 0.0279688760638237, 0.018681267276406288, 0.01270533911883831, -0.03237999603152275, -0.0289374440908432, 0.020942794159054756, -0.05792146548628807, -0.0708191841840744, -0.030420364812016487, 0.03851155564188957, 0.07151207327842712, -0.04374665394425392, -0.0216080229729414, 0.05037246271967888, 0.023656126111745834, -0.022099139168858528, 0.024316858500242233, 0.02885577641427517, -0.016980012878775597, 0.0007450252305716276, -0.032726041972637177, 0.01677892729640007, -0.04240794852375984, 0.012501329183578491, 0.06731466203927994, 0.0074648079462349415, -0.04864766448736191, -0.03384954109787941, 0.008534101769328117, 0.021245138719677925, -0.03199520707130432, 0.01748165674507618, -0.007217623759061098, -0.05699092522263527, 0.016416223719716072, -0.00928072165697813, -0.04360952973365784, -0.008553970605134964, -0.014117158018052578, -0.011465628631412983, 0.0001662424037931487, -0.0021696528419852257, -0.06810998916625977, -0.013455646112561226, 0.03869091346859932, -0.024159761145710945, -0.0260743647813797, 0.058985427021980286, 0.016367608681321144, -0.0633486956357956, -0.02338716760277748, 0.017863187938928604, -0.0407126285135746, 0.004376939032226801, 0.05422849953174591, -0.05180365592241287, -0.055983033031225204, 0.00579191604629159, 0.007143394555896521, 0.055902477353811264, -0.01635737344622612, -0.05676550045609474, -0.027224887162446976, -0.07121171802282333, -0.011053063906729221, -0.04995954781770706, -0.025179391726851463, 0.060004305094480515, -0.018978439271450043, -0.06510331481695175, -0.04806431755423546, 0.0026460408698767424, 0.013436698354780674, -0.028720468282699585, -0.02750873938202858, 0.03098561428487301, 0.05148489028215408, 0.04578697308897972, 0.020381975919008255, 0.0069077941589057446, 0.03253038972616196, 0.00421714736148715, 0.02677301876246929, -0.01806974783539772, 0.04270797222852707, -0.07129550725221634, -0.07810791581869125, -0.026194287464022636, 0.05780721828341484, -0.017876990139484406, 0.0580010749399662, 0.0034313444048166275, 0.045311108231544495, 0.009480240754783154, -0.018102161586284637, -0.047983478754758835, -0.04584075137972832, 0.037870243191719055, 0.029069140553474426, -0.0440467968583107, 0.03036918118596077, -0.0047063883394002914, -0.02693326584994793, 0.013052287511527538, -0.027916517108678818, -0.009404350072145462, 0.0382629856467247, -0.06916652619838715, -0.05787300318479538, -0.022461948916316032, 0.06174582242965698, -0.0003109142417088151, 0.036084406077861786, 0.002854364225640893, -0.036869488656520844, 0.02356726862490177, 0.07701460272073746, 0.004971130285412073, -0.016642699018120766, 0.0024657552130520344, 0.042454272508621216, 0.013651201501488686, 0.02697451040148735, -0.05145750567317009, 0.008651557378470898, 0.008879410102963448, 0.008596961386501789, -0.00495575787499547, 0.029934557154774666, 0.018900563940405846, 0.007458665873855352, 0.00707771023735404, 0.015941567718982697, -0.003995121456682682, -0.05824293941259384, -0.0550197958946228, 0.03102816455066204, -0.0006654458702541888, -0.017055196687579155, 0.05100968852639198, -0.062494732439517975, -0.03520004823803902, 0.033732447773218155, 0.0375092439353466, 0.016307620331645012, -0.03751029446721077, 0.017539629712700844, -0.0015446677571162581, 0.02014264278113842, -0.05158931389451027, 0.052066922187805176, -0.06577909737825394, -0.01576785370707512, -0.002965597901493311, -0.019579268991947174, 0.0022012183908373117, 0.05109782516956329, -0.0370590016245842, -0.00403415784239769, 0.001890247338451445, -0.0009604835067875683, -0.013787245377898216, 0.004250876605510712, 0.038421377539634705, -0.0011450093006715178, -0.034172456711530685, -0.03996764123439789, -0.056791920214891434, -0.04585069417953491, -0.034774299710989, 0.022097060456871986, -0.0608844980597496, -0.04338804632425308, -0.02851114608347416, -0.003912614192813635, -0.007054806686937809, -0.005884450860321522, 0.010687601752579212, -0.054982688277959824, -0.015376068651676178, -0.07957655936479568, 0.0061753615736961365, 0.0002838994550984353, 0.029163507744669914, -0.014547147788107395, -0.008363757282495499, 0.01616622321307659, -0.010599707253277302, -0.028701934963464737, -0.004110819194465876, 0.0044064270332455635, -0.04791051521897316, 0.03429124131798744, 0.036494314670562744, -0.08346980810165405, 0.03684529662132263, -0.052536170929670334, -0.0019586565904319286, -0.012759446166455746, -0.06956254690885544, -0.01717641018331051, 0.03394116088747978, -0.044064998626708984, 0.02909374050796032, 0.060120970010757446, 0.0409105159342289, 0.06085468456149101, -0.0047438484616577625, -0.021515456959605217, 0.0020259071607142687, -0.09583732485771179, -0.0219291839748621, -0.026281433179974556, 0.05523976311087608, 0.045497678220272064, 0.03318966552615166, -0.007447064854204655, -0.01770075596868992, -0.03415994346141815, 0.03785642981529236, 0.07449868321418762, -0.04768015816807747, -0.05158399045467377, -0.0026605878956615925, -0.04017709568142891, -0.07420986145734787, -0.024620378389954567, -0.05639171227812767, -0.054956573992967606, -0.018573960289359093, -0.04185052961111069, 0.05317006632685661, -0.03605874255299568, -0.01391180045902729, -0.04267216846346855, -0.04167250916361809, 0.04659384489059448, 0.004570009186863899, -0.04313264414668083, -0.03661424294114113, -0.05205196887254715, 0.052802205085754395, -0.006170180626213551, -0.0007072788430377841, -0.0523131899535656, -0.032536622136831284, 0.03614514321088791, 0.003301692195236683, 0.020476708188652992, 0.04155144840478897, -0.027533017098903656, -0.019337162375450134, -0.027175670489668846, 0.05250225216150284, 0.03232554718852043, -0.036744583398103714, -0.04928820952773094, 0.018660809844732285, 0.06834100931882858, 0.008024967275559902, -0.0025507137179374695, -0.013305345550179482, -0.0014076586812734604, -0.014590570703148842, -0.04044673964381218, -0.011062830686569214, 0.054417598992586136, 0.02931809611618519, -0.03363456204533577, -0.04880407452583313, -0.0005406450945883989, -0.006786393001675606, 0.0340903215110302, 0.05234270542860031, 0.031035132706165314, -0.006596941966563463, 0.0014779561897739768, -0.04806841164827347, 0.022623198106884956, -0.059505313634872437, 0.047476764768362045, -0.06744849681854248, -0.03339759632945061, 0.0007336687995120883, -0.049666326493024826, -0.05766564607620239, -0.040695153176784515, -0.028957009315490723, -0.03432077914476395, -0.07633563131093979, -0.04586615413427353, 0.01480337604880333, 0.0634739026427269, 0.009549800306558609, -0.03784661367535591, -0.03960877284407616, 0.056610848754644394, 0.06249067932367325, 0.019929351285099983, -0.008362614549696445, -0.039257410913705826, -0.012666884809732437, 0.021617917343974113, -0.013940849341452122, -0.03848390281200409, 0.005454217083752155, -0.017625069245696068, 0.03439222276210785, 0.0006032173405401409, -0.004352710675448179, 0.004824105650186539, -0.009948338381946087, 0.030621031299233437, 0.03227001428604126, 0.0020098541863262653, -0.0458965003490448, 0.023715637624263763, -0.02660541981458664, 0.004653343930840492, -0.003946978133171797, 0.04602281376719475, 0.011532064527273178, -0.03646698221564293, 0.009512579068541527, -0.020430995151400566, 0.035812024027109146, 0.039953723549842834, -0.015478638000786304, 0.0246345866471529, 0.010980441235005856, -0.05297853797674179, -0.018343983218073845, -0.038803331553936005, -0.00819050520658493, 0.01981401816010475, 0.027950206771492958, -0.02056066133081913, 0.01442294754087925, 0.01244206354022026, -0.08657151460647583, -0.01243402436375618, 0.050629872828722, 0.0809905081987381, 0.0071220663376152515, 0.007075323723256588, -0.024076471105217934, 0.01915154792368412, 0.027663208544254303, -0.013697708956897259, 0.05210346728563309, 0.044839076697826385, 0.04695277288556099, -0.02992379106581211, -0.06968490034341812, -0.020228631794452667, -0.03855382651090622, -0.07247795164585114, 0.001657696207985282, 0.031023161485791206, 0.013883969746530056, 0.05869169905781746, -0.04987964406609535, -0.001953895203769207, 0.025238892063498497, 0.04870900139212608, 0.036577604711055756, -0.020655328407883644, 0.009959184564650059, -0.029969606548547745, 0.023658480495214462, 0.040565162897109985, -0.038929328322410583, -0.02522084303200245, -0.07125160843133926, 0.011741490103304386, -0.05597038194537163, 0.031100299209356308, 0.05090833082795143, 0.018917879089713097, 0.0466170497238636, 0.03659200295805931, 0.016183054074645042, 0.037431176751852036, 0.039967045187950134, -0.012736269272863865, 0.014092528261244297, 0.013841112144291401, 0.015152906067669392, -0.014229430817067623, 0.02008255571126938, -0.012890040874481201, -0.017707880586385727, -0.05292343720793724, -0.01427424792200327, -0.05127830430865288, -0.02763008512556553, 0.02079135552048683, -0.04866921529173851, -0.01184022892266512, -0.01925133541226387, 0.044725045561790466, -0.016763510182499886, 0.025651760399341583, 0.024497319012880325, -0.06302124261856079, 0.007375409826636314, -0.029019197449088097, -0.004145434126257896, -0.0353824757039547, -0.052972037345170975, -0.0063778106123209, -0.07592806965112686, -0.021573185920715332, -0.03521943837404251, 0.047886788845062256, 0.03525497019290924, 0.0292047206312418, -0.04055396467447281, -0.04855399951338768, -0.026900460943579674, -0.0017069174209609628, 0.024551205337047577, -0.014780721627175808, -0.0024166563525795937, -0.018284691497683525, 0.02595837228000164, -0.0007708270568400621, 0.011385676451027393, 0.029715245589613914, -0.028947653248906136, 0.03842492774128914, 0.014069709926843643, -0.02628028765320778, -0.0050628576427698135, -0.004527402576059103, 0.03979459032416344, -0.05695537105202675, -0.02661445550620556, 0.03841320052742958, 0.022884182631969452, -0.05499700829386711, -0.04754851013422012, -0.04960842430591583, -0.04869833588600159, -0.04561207816004753, -0.043134212493896484, 0.03395367041230202, 0.011956737376749516, 0.0014949770411476493, 0.021480942144989967, 0.011852829717099667, -0.016790514811873436, -0.021262450143694878, -0.00356200709939003, 0.017847061157226562, 0.03817197307944298, -0.00017008847498800606, -0.0479218028485775, -0.06779570877552032, 0.042221058160066605, 0.01629127934575081, 0.0029025825206190348, -0.002601591870188713, 0.0428641214966774, 0.035422611981630325, 0.03655398264527321, -0.07456766068935394, 0.06939953565597534, 0.06606467068195343, -0.0393497571349144, -0.03603309020400047, 0.036283884197473526, 0.027709662914276123, 0.051946546882390976, -0.024828564375638962, 0.007235488388687372, 0.012034766376018524, -0.02776213176548481, -0.005271634086966515, 0.007959320209920406, -0.029689328745007515, -0.0032769180834293365, 0.04390021413564682, 0.0003839305427391082, -0.07886728644371033, -0.009103810414671898, 0.025718877092003822, 0.0014356328174471855, 0.0025461814366281033, 0.0189819373190403, 0.019025476649403572, -0.0290583074092865, -0.02915133722126484, 0.0005650262464769185, 0.01744881644845009, 0.010339559987187386, -0.015237154439091682, -0.06468571722507477, -0.030948355793952942, 0.006657595746219158, -0.0030516665428876877, 0.0012439304264262319, -0.009939571842551231, -0.015265289694070816, -0.016655726358294487, -0.023271847516298294, -0.015897030010819435, -0.05309582129120827, -0.040421344339847565, -0.03253520652651787, 0.03690943494439125, 0.06970319896936417, 0.028055356815457344, 0.04026368260383606, 0.0038236710242927074, -0.04271799325942993, -0.020083840936422348, -0.006365158595144749, -0.0016630939207971096, 0.01920256018638611, -0.053276754915714264, 0.07075745612382889, 0.024553094059228897, 0.02659052610397339, 0.025994857773184776, 0.01087784394621849, 0.018491433933377266, 0.0064956932328641415, -0.06055203825235367, -0.017058691009879112, 0.04425148293375969, -0.03919709846377373, -0.048991598188877106, 0.021416939795017242, 0.045084625482559204, -0.04873192682862282, 0.01486483495682478, 0.03590353950858116, -0.0404338538646698, 0.016352280974388123, 0.013226903975009918, -0.039624374359846115, -0.07136277109384537, 0.008163277059793472, 0.028182312846183777, -0.06478051841259003, -0.027476569637656212, 0.03751524165272713, -0.006168968975543976, 0.03132060542702675, -0.049629710614681244, 0.045292627066373825, 0.04453218728303909, -0.006826760713011026, -0.06026030331850052, 0.031026653945446014, -0.043222811073064804, -0.04006267338991165, 0.020222870633006096, -0.035223811864852905, -0.05741945281624794, 0.02436024323105812, 0.024950897321105003, 0.018606793135404587, -0.002970597008243203, 0.04624500498175621, -0.015578473918139935, -0.023693770170211792, -0.03819027543067932, 0.04024535417556763, 0.06272852420806885, 0.019521502777934074, 0.0008763018995523453, 0.0007311184308491647, -0.0004639415128622204, 0.023182787001132965, -0.009531345218420029, 0.012924599461257458, 0.03867107629776001, 0.02596345916390419, 0.04455506056547165, -0.03127535805106163, 0.0010446837404742837, 0.07096134126186371, -0.04798838868737221, -0.027924489229917526, 0.002197856083512306, -0.006767609156668186, 0.04916269704699516, -0.014501596800982952, -0.06422977149486542, 0.012044845148921013, -0.04259558394551277, 0.0038373505230993032, -0.06731332093477249, -0.0019692599307745695, -0.0514078214764595, 0.03805243968963623, 0.017063254490494728, -0.03393523767590523, 0.015673860907554626, -0.028857877478003502, -0.04438221454620361, 0.008625608868896961, -0.0780961886048317, -0.015246206894516945, -0.0030267592519521713, 0.02439003996551037, 0.06946825981140137, 0.037690795958042145, -0.02425137162208557, -0.05854540318250656, 0.01567225344479084, -0.0016963313100859523, 0.0046429019421339035, 0.03418871387839317, 0.04351334646344185, -0.009527789428830147, 0.03366868197917938, 0.01461061928421259, -0.04096269980072975, -0.022492753341794014, -0.009646691381931305, 0.029396452009677887, -0.05286380276083946, -0.04902094602584839, -0.019485142081975937, 0.02409917674958706, 0.014278137125074863, 0.05098974332213402, -0.003050690283998847, -0.055564820766448975, -0.05889960005879402, 0.04454966261982918, -0.025548575446009636, -0.006029366981238127, 0.00888036284595728, 0.044302698224782944, 0.042457398027181625, 0.004789972212165594, 0.026898805052042007, 0.04841775447130203, -0.036563798785209656, 0.03339145705103874, -0.06385093927383423, 0.008282952941954136, 0.019825616851449013, 0.03904718533158302, -0.06492539495229721, -0.020985251292586327, -0.056552160531282425, -0.017296450212597847, 0.03901221603155136, 0.03263385593891144, -0.012054108083248138, -0.024742284789681435, -0.036541976034641266, 0.0071168565191328526, 0.029377106577157974, -0.03677807003259659, -0.05599649250507355, -0.028834335505962372, -0.0008899117237888277, 0.010543313808739185, -0.027390148490667343, 0.022350823506712914, -0.03958921507000923, 0.029932409524917603, -0.07946041971445084, 0.016678640618920326, 0.04021918401122093, 0.05530843138694763, -0.014444857835769653, -0.07710160315036774, -0.006518698297441006, -0.024396132677793503, -0.03252701461315155, 0.01525600254535675, -0.014205406419932842, -0.0018862670985981822, -0.018696026876568794, -0.01178970281034708, -0.06033572554588318, -0.02889062464237213, 0.025902755558490753, 0.012653092853724957, -0.033723484724760056, 0.030002735555171967, 0.02321101352572441, 0.029771262779831886, -0.005253207869827747, 0.03918106481432915, -0.030079780146479607, 0.06482946872711182, -0.08186423033475876, 0.05703035742044449, -0.050165288150310516, -0.0635349228978157, -0.0071724350564181805, -0.0492410846054554, -0.007921498268842697, 0.018643829971551895, -0.003972627688199282, 0.0341559536755085, -0.04723326116800308, -0.0632859617471695, 0.01508566364645958, -0.020646797493100166, -0.011483845300972462, 0.07215287536382675, -0.05662577599287033, 0.006467889528721571, -0.04901619255542755, 0.008221217431128025, -0.035912416875362396, -0.019007939845323563, 0.02475416660308838, -0.05838564410805702, 0.015172561630606651, -0.0662836879491806, -0.00741606904193759, 0.025994010269641876, 0.02259070985019207, 0.029962440952658653, 0.06578947603702545, -0.017225680872797966, -0.020268645137548447, -0.07373204082250595, -0.05322965979576111, 0.0010546797420829535, -0.05026676878333092, -0.06792707741260529, -0.00110487116035074, 0.015853136777877808, -0.008857627399265766, -0.031362295150756836, -0.023432550951838493, 0.040637873113155365, -0.015978947281837463, 0.0032346544321626425, -0.027673358097672462, -0.0013295498210936785, -0.05608643591403961, 0.06756561994552612, 0.027277428656816483, 0.021224606782197952, -0.031213996931910515, -0.007470868993550539, -0.0035776877775788307, -0.023826221004128456, -0.01716318354010582, 0.0192238949239254, -0.019711121916770935, -0.0569440983235836, -0.01099760178476572, -0.008826201781630516, -0.026231633499264717, 0.014970139600336552, -0.04390973225235939, 0.051806043833494186, -0.022395405918359756, -0.043748319149017334 ]
The design dataset is the backbone of data-driven design. Ideally, the dataset should be fairly distributed in both shape and property spaces to efficiently explore the underlying relationship. However, the classical experimental design focuses on shape diversity and thus yields biased exploration in the property space. Recently developed methods either conduct subset selection from a large dataset or employ assumptions with severe limitations. In this paper, fairness- and uncertainty-aware data generation (FairGen) is proposed to actively detect and generate missing properties starting from a small dataset. At each iteration, its coverage module computes the data coverage to guide the selection of the target properties. The uncertainty module ensures that the generative model can make certain and thus accurate shape predictions. Integrating the two modules, Bayesian optimization determines the target properties, which are thereafter fed into the generative model to predict the associated shapes. The new designs, whose properties are analyzed by simulation, are added to the design dataset. An S-slot design dataset case study was implemented to demonstrate the efficiency of FairGen in auxetic structural design. Compared with grid and randomized sampling, FairGen increased the coverage score at twice the speed and significantly expanded the sampled region in the property space. As a result, the generative models trained with FairGen-generated datasets showed consistent and significant reductions in mean absolute errors.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05842v1
[ -0.017760518938302994, -0.028722576797008514, 0.04818147048354149, 0.032480388879776, 0.0018984698690474033, -0.0018820727709680796, -0.02223309874534607, 0.01065319124609232, -0.006435413844883442, -0.024920441210269928, -0.055895283818244934, -0.0038675807882100344, -0.03661058098077774, -0.05493360757827759, -0.0391683429479599, -0.0086196418851614, 0.06237158179283142, 0.024306826293468475, -0.05673840641975403, 0.073904849588871, -0.031314071267843246, -0.00008637470455141738, -0.011985476128757, 0.026743942871689796, 0.024028703570365906, 0.0043137166649103165, -0.02988186478614807, 0.0013144838158041239, -0.028566844761371613, 0.02565615437924862, 0.04639531299471855, -0.050102900713682175, 0.013915837742388248, -0.044847048819065094, -0.05287276208400726, -0.0012031962396577, -0.057644590735435486, -0.0032055058982223272, 0.03607679158449173, -0.0515957847237587, 0.029039988294243813, -0.027194535359740257, -0.05477316305041313, -0.0225602425634861, -0.04924099147319794, 0.004802756942808628, -0.04048237204551697, 0.016098573803901672, -0.059636082500219345, -0.05059884116053581, 0.026723532006144524, -0.02414531633257866, 0.029970908537507057, 0.045788802206516266, -0.020765049383044243, 0.0339706651866436, -0.027035344392061234, 0.012990374118089676, -0.06649629026651382, 0.004313384182751179, 0.0294401366263628, -0.06287039071321487, 0.018837401643395424, -0.00542102474719286, 0.010318897664546967, 0.047614436596632004, -0.013216353952884674, -0.06938734650611877, -0.016705643385648727, -0.01756218448281288, 0.05744098126888275, -0.07979797571897507, -0.014640982262790203, 0.06038146838545799, -0.06802760809659958, 0.0014968733303248882, 0.008542122319340706, -0.020154625177383423, 0.0028707003220915794, 0.018946684896945953, -0.0146767757833004, 0.018334101885557175, 0.02276543714106083, 0.043383125215768814, -0.003672283375635743, 0.000012640568456845358, 0.061234019696712494, -0.011381138116121292, 0.019701967015862465, -0.03366021811962128, 0.011111044324934483, -0.010328400880098343, -0.08033259212970734, 0.006611297372728586, 0.07689723372459412, -0.012586813420057297, 0.05071692168712616, 0.03448168560862541, 0.022935763001441956, -0.015140105970203876, -0.0386582687497139, -0.04593641683459282, -0.012202458456158638, 0.04678408056497574, 0.020551685243844986, -0.01953846588730812, 0.006212889216840267, 0.003414439968764782, -0.027624012902379036, 0.02383182756602764, -0.002853784244507551, 0.03219674155116081, -0.009438758715987206, -0.03804313763976097, -0.03837975487112999, -0.04399099200963974, 0.07109647989273071, 0.026671236380934715, 0.04547746852040291, 0.03504315763711929, -0.006446394138038158, 0.022517316043376923, 0.04591628164052963, 0.007277252618223429, -0.04360198602080345, -0.0020304725039750338, 0.06086791679263115, 0.006316825281828642, -0.006393398158252239, -0.0035422896035015583, -0.027475256472826004, 0.006879006512463093, -0.017512720078229904, -0.012412315234541893, 0.06146389618515968, -0.006855086423456669, -0.002105384599417448, -0.0730605497956276, 0.00008734605216886848, -0.011855068616569042, -0.03852013126015663, -0.08580515533685684, 0.01913594827055931, -0.0035632040817290545, 0.0408916212618351, 0.04967591539025307, -0.04757707566022873, -0.03458132594823837, 0.020838238298892975, 0.01599789597094059, 0.0021680076606571674, -0.021859806030988693, 0.04270262271165848, 0.013556724414229393, -0.01902131922543049, -0.03857225924730301, 0.03809041157364845, -0.03580564633011818, -0.008515812456607819, 0.019433045759797096, 0.042440399527549744, -0.014690031297504902, 0.0065865362994372845, -0.05271873250603676, -0.024052221328020096, -0.03667744621634483, 0.02285022661089897, -0.00985624548047781, -0.01822107471525669, 0.0016312883235514164, -0.026932351291179657, 0.04028947651386261, -0.040690019726753235, -0.050318408757448196, -0.04065905138850212, 0.025225704535841942, 0.002966279396787286, -0.05420040339231491, -0.02431955188512802, 0.031776174902915955, 0.0168597549200058, -0.01452706754207611, -0.024740034714341164, 0.027352968230843544, -0.020600860938429832, -0.03323119878768921, -0.08177271485328674, -0.017538832500576973, 0.012523289769887924, 0.030885232612490654, -0.03875841572880745, -0.04344699904322624, -0.003639285685494542, 0.011321308091282845, -0.04386072978377342, -0.01819150522351265, 0.0220625139772892, -0.03847994655370712, 0.0027417452074587345, -0.0017127079190686345, -0.08222084492444992, -0.051216110587120056, -0.065314382314682, 0.02363700047135353, 0.01876647397875786, -0.041791245341300964, -0.014405911788344383, 0.04589065536856651, -0.016024533659219742, 0.01272680051624775, 0.0632040947675705, 0.05064072087407112, 0.06173982471227646, 0.0010763482423499227, -0.001684663351625204, 0.004948771093040705, -0.09562502801418304, 0.027333632111549377, -0.022246260195970535, 0.0345991812646389, 0.03718457370996475, 0.05299629643559456, -0.0018739248625934124, -0.033812299370765686, -0.007837074808776379, 0.03283821418881416, 0.06771018356084824, 0.0026375632733106613, -0.03465380519628525, -0.025705356150865555, -0.03498578071594238, -0.06144480034708977, -0.023099685087800026, -0.05938134342432022, -0.03507106006145477, -0.007376313209533691, -0.0014264468336477876, 0.07573435455560684, 0.03313342481851578, -0.03168133646249771, -0.040316421538591385, -0.03195341303944588, 0.04836547374725342, 0.0004277339030522853, -0.03610505163669586, -0.05811072140932083, -0.04120743274688721, 0.03795440122485161, -0.008303254842758179, -0.015124878846108913, 0.007075182162225246, -0.07225017994642258, -0.02180839702486992, -0.012752130627632141, 0.03436357527971268, 0.038981545716524124, -0.05074595659971237, 0.012878921814262867, -0.03964012488722801, 0.04800625145435333, 0.033915020525455475, 0.013100903481245041, -0.050846826285123825, 0.016215583309531212, 0.05629560723900795, -0.0239704679697752, -0.01545214094221592, -0.03755202889442444, 0.02285178191959858, -0.0330854207277298, 0.010914783924818039, -0.008760804310441017, 0.05333520844578743, 0.014300839975476265, -0.021779468283057213, -0.016728250309824944, -0.0324455127120018, -0.011750346049666405, 0.010580114088952541, 0.03674359619617462, 0.05006453022360802, 0.05437785014510155, 0.004002850502729416, -0.05943632498383522, 0.02971167303621769, -0.052335433661937714, 0.020994538441300392, -0.07623438537120819, -0.07116232067346573, -0.0364513136446476, -0.07008188217878342, -0.05584239214658737, -0.024074088782072067, -0.0512077771127224, -0.030652618035674095, -0.04191640391945839, 0.0036096752155572176, 0.020729389041662216, 0.007378577720373869, -0.02393270842730999, 0.005633848253637552, -0.013145484030246735, 0.019358346238732338, 0.022153135389089584, -0.01402684859931469, -0.06204431504011154, -0.05707094818353653, -0.01253944169729948, 0.04836796596646309, -0.036199431866407394, -0.038436293601989746, 0.023830344900488853, -0.02475019171833992, -0.028086643666028976, -0.02827000990509987, 0.008711650036275387, 0.03291601687669754, 0.008106532506644726, 0.049167077988386154, 0.022459791973233223, 0.014550266787409782, 0.019031038507819176, 0.02019599638879299, -0.06273078918457031, -0.03146428242325783, -0.03191962093114853, 0.009211850352585316, -0.014279607683420181, -0.0679386630654335, 0.007892344146966934, -0.032332781702280045, 0.04295886307954788, 0.0013394795823842287, -0.015865804627537727, 0.012081942521035671, 0.0611778199672699, -0.00645895441994071, -0.030069474130868912, 0.0027721854858100414, 0.0065559446811676025, 0.010060569271445274, 0.054550621658563614, -0.018698453903198242, -0.02715863659977913, 0.07204046100378036, -0.08525070548057556, 0.006341524422168732, 0.026000024750828743, 0.07619323581457138, -0.023872174322605133, 0.0016424634959548712, 0.005530469119548798, -0.016092712059617043, 0.05232730880379677, -0.019990649074316025, 0.0009737022337503731, 0.04749644175171852, 0.05297159031033516, -0.04437026381492615, -0.07157811522483826, -0.04578423127532005, -0.06376394629478455, -0.018934480845928192, 0.004111265763640404, 0.05994649976491928, 0.017543423920869827, 0.03419768810272217, -0.02135937102138996, 0.06333097070455551, -0.0050988164730370045, 0.061943795531988144, -0.000718564260751009, -0.04169890284538269, 0.060340989381074905, -0.06734122335910797, 0.027150815352797508, 0.025841765105724335, -0.037752434611320496, 0.008976014330983162, -0.034384675323963165, 0.02992827817797661, -0.046448882669210434, 0.04822807386517525, 0.01782720908522606, -0.015543518587946892, 0.06813757866621017, 0.03971782699227333, -0.036477819085121155, 0.062069930136203766, -0.016818828880786896, 0.02192818373441696, -0.008520957082509995, -0.0024892420042306185, -0.01321084052324295, 0.007191918324679136, -0.04740781709551811, 0.013201668858528137, 0.0015720780938863754, -0.034812454134225845, -0.02394421584904194, -0.01666112057864666, -0.0369504913687706, -0.022604331374168396, -0.0641472116112709, 0.03689533472061157, 0.001007967395707965, 0.052229803055524826, 0.0020737089216709137, -0.046152833849191666, 0.058922816067934036, -0.010317793115973473, -0.021732613444328308, -0.025930512696504593, -0.008609162643551826, -0.047711726278066635, -0.04170297831296921, -0.02024068310856819, -0.07034876197576523, 0.016704468056559563, -0.05607234686613083, 0.06836667656898499, 0.01943318173289299, -0.005214546341449022, -0.0033730443101376295, -0.025363251566886902, 0.0031201019883155823, 0.02878841757774353, 0.05528051778674126, 0.038174472749233246, -0.015020365826785564, -0.006714219693094492, -0.00863034650683403, 0.024394745007157326, 0.012505018152296543, 0.01332494243979454, -0.03585623949766159, 0.022254042327404022, -0.026988321915268898, -0.03464379906654358, -0.017408274114131927, -0.019697120413184166, 0.0319751612842083, -0.04600324109196663, -0.008212600834667683, -0.033668868243694305, 0.045979831367731094, -0.06119906157255173, -0.06003771349787712, -0.009254131466150284, -0.027595609426498413, -0.05883634090423584, -0.02960612252354622, 0.01411878876388073, 0.01909320056438446, 0.05659707263112068, 0.029303954914212227, -0.017827538773417473, -0.002403180580586195, -0.03609064221382141, 0.03440342843532562, 0.037481654435396194, -0.023427443578839302, -0.016383325681090355, -0.057091258466243744, -0.07005196809768677, -0.007923786528408527, -0.05169782042503357, -0.024267729371786118, 0.032182592898607254, 0.026419714093208313, 0.0055227517150342464, 0.05340675264596939, -0.08573171496391296, 0.04228978231549263, 0.04074382781982422, -0.01873355731368065, -0.002375819953158498, 0.04009433090686798, 0.005633722525089979, 0.027044732123613358, -0.05721360072493553, 0.01796955242753029, 0.020489003509283066, -0.03675651550292969, -0.0014740187907591462, 0.04244903847575188, -0.018911801278591156, -0.01643841713666916, 0.07281676679849625, -0.016486164182424545, -0.07125306129455566, 0.01836717501282692, 0.018683435395359993, 0.02400730736553669, -0.009386656805872917, 0.030760979279875755, 0.017857328057289124, -0.0032955307979136705, -0.022942671552300453, -0.04568369686603546, -0.02518981322646141, 0.014079445041716099, 0.005236107390373945, -0.02345232106745243, 0.00790385715663433, 0.04369613155722618, -0.0038864132948219776, 0.033292148262262344, 0.0016996144549921155, -0.016152720898389816, -0.006371801253408194, -0.022245001047849655, -0.007721917703747749, -0.043087296187877655, -0.018275784328579903, -0.007026996463537216, 0.020256424322724342, 0.0610421821475029, 0.05222615227103233, 0.011590310372412205, 0.029886936768889427, -0.059040918946266174, -0.02692195028066635, 0.012761782854795456, 0.04060506820678711, 0.019297011196613312, -0.03333146870136261, 0.041164860129356384, 0.000010967141861328855, 0.042551204562187195, 0.013168754056096077, 0.0496576651930809, 0.013567125424742699, 0.009685102850198746, -0.016886992380023003, -0.04037646949291229, 0.051287028938531876, -0.00489406380802393, -0.0341363400220871, -0.007468549069017172, 0.059095825999975204, -0.03330490365624428, 0.038292061537504196, 0.043149638921022415, -0.03149806708097458, 0.03165223449468613, 0.0027001581620424986, 0.006355423014611006, -0.055225152522325516, -0.05142098292708397, 0.06895586848258972, -0.0606374628841877, -0.002758896443992853, -0.029156483709812164, -0.03646775707602501, -0.02315695956349373, -0.04992201551795006, 0.03822686895728111, 0.04155284911394119, -0.013709968887269497, -0.030405020341277122, 0.03831654042005539, 0.030959632247686386, -0.05116155743598938, 0.044220905750989914, 0.04229286313056946, -0.08450956642627716, -0.005915672983974218, -0.003295853268355131, 0.01091312151402235, -0.028712034225463867, 0.030375726521015167, -0.035458534955978394, -0.012861545197665691, -0.06325286626815796, 0.07384157925844193, 0.0754208043217659, -0.008508751168847084, 0.00604608841240406, -0.00021822380949743092, -0.04829872027039528, -0.010164524428546429, -0.039171185344457626, -0.030550390481948853, -0.035931918770074844, 0.0211099274456501, 0.002287205308675766, -0.03171294555068016, -0.0010083301458507776, 0.06758253276348114, 0.00036145892227068543, -0.015104790218174458, 0.04122874140739441, 0.0068106818944215775, 0.002450731350108981, -0.05627861246466637, -0.05248096212744713, 0.000177555630216375, 0.019510461017489433, 0.005652216263115406, -0.05211188644170761, 0.0345785953104496, -0.042282748967409134, 0.052664779126644135, -0.024945029988884926, -0.06842239201068878, -0.0008722619968466461, -0.03234797716140747, -0.02934451773762703, 0.01957869343459606, -0.05977282300591469, 0.021103618666529655, -0.0006702314130961895, 0.04575641080737114, 0.05343935638666153, 0.04848238453269005, -0.049204714596271515, -0.009651722386479378, 0.01864638738334179, 0.0060620359145104885, 0.008496708236634731, -0.010553194209933281, 0.012725958600640297, -0.026924248784780502, 0.046197470277547836, -0.04957468807697296, -0.013308601453900337, -0.03379566967487335, -0.023092681542038918, 0.003406622214242816, -0.010350740514695644, -0.04904625937342644, -0.040173839777708054, 0.021893925964832306, -0.04599195718765259, 0.010075126774609089, 0.033290039747953415, -0.06303325295448303, -0.06267841160297394, 0.0022440929897129536, -0.02113800309598446, -0.045896321535110474, 0.04232227802276611, 0.03731219470500946, 0.06552937626838684, -0.0060778530314564705, 0.01670061983168125, 0.04918581247329712, 0.018800163641572, 0.03868383169174194, -0.04637541621923447, -0.025126086547970772, 0.02625676430761814, 0.008120875805616379, -0.015437501482665539, -0.03387586027383804, -0.007379019632935524, -0.05970228463411331, 0.014562888070940971, 0.06090717017650604, -0.01779300346970558, -0.02090160921216011, -0.038526032119989395, 0.009263298474252224, -0.03008277714252472, -0.016286533325910568, -0.08013651520013809, 0.0038180085830390453, 0.01958313398063183, 0.0010645908769220114, 0.004986082203686237, -0.0078385965898633, -0.025599878281354904, 0.005521160550415516, -0.08786231279373169, 0.022526545450091362, 0.010556282475590706, 0.06443116068840027, -0.007228562142699957, -0.033388543874025345, -0.016672417521476746, -0.026416422799229622, -0.03043418750166893, -0.022337866947054863, 0.03582087159156799, 0.00708279013633728, 0.019947243854403496, 0.0007805356872268021, -0.058487407863140106, -0.0008662217878736556, 0.0588352270424366, 0.003129592863842845, -0.023278135806322098, -0.006872889120131731, 0.0034562989603728056, 0.009962794370949268, 0.0008963481523096561, 0.060831744223833084, -0.00973580963909626, 0.06275968998670578, 0.010343173518776894, -0.008350448682904243, -0.030974628403782845, -0.06822824478149414, 0.03189283609390259, -0.04021768644452095, -0.04590914025902748, 0.005313146393746138, 0.007941627874970436, -0.021533343940973282, -0.024467693641781807, -0.054449018090963364, 0.05511077865958214, 0.0027068357449024916, -0.03241740167140961, 0.058096081018447876, -0.03714359179139137, -0.03839503228664398, -0.01088867336511612, 0.026352060958743095, -0.04030575603246689, -0.032624196261167526, 0.0314314067363739, -0.06414555758237839, -0.0016889171674847603, -0.044089145958423615, -0.009902145713567734, -0.01378148328512907, 0.00493023544549942, -0.017298463732004166, 0.06973344087600708, -0.049938950687646866, -0.0031957393512129784, -0.024001888930797577, -0.04768736660480499, 0.0011733233695849776, -0.0845344066619873, -0.0630679503083229, -0.05137833207845688, 0.042334891855716705, -0.02786099724471569, -0.01808558776974678, -0.03104311227798462, 0.06354755163192749, 0.000738050730433315, 0.012627169489860535, 0.005589226260781288, -0.004688157234340906, -0.05791139602661133, 0.048941951245069504, 0.02262849546968937, -0.013029282912611961, 0.01263912208378315, 0.03497278317809105, 0.007836565375328064, -0.02404008060693741, 0.0020769252441823483, 0.004381790291517973, 0.007654255721718073, -0.06077541783452034, 0.014776000753045082, 0.02608872763812542, 0.025652920827269554, -0.02798103541135788, 0.014623316936194897, 0.004089151043444872, -0.01021112035959959, -0.048138074576854706 ]
Model-based diagnosis has been an active research topic in different communities including artificial intelligence, formal methods, and control. This has led to a set of disparate approaches addressing different classes of systems and seeking different forms of diagnoses. In this paper, we resolve such disparities by generalising Reiter's theory to be agnostic to the types of systems and diagnoses considered. This more general theory of diagnosis from first principles defines the minimal diagnosis as the set of preferred diagnosis candidates in a search space of hypotheses. Computing the minimal diagnosis is achieved by exploring the space of diagnosis hypotheses, testing sets of hypotheses for consistency with the system's model and the observation, and generating conflicts that rule out successors and other portions of the search space. Under relatively mild assumptions, our algorithms correctly compute the set of preferred diagnosis candidates. The main difficulty here is that the search space is no longer a powerset as in Reiter's theory, and that, as consequence, many of the implicit properties (such as finiteness of the search space) no longer hold. The notion of conflict also needs to be generalised and we present such a more general notion. We present two implementations of these algorithms, using test solvers based on satisfiability and heuristic search, respectively, which we evaluate on instances from two real world discrete event problems. Despite the greater generality of our theory, these implementations surpass the special purpose algorithms designed for discrete event systems, and enable solving instances that were out of reach of existing diagnosis approaches.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16180v1
[ 0.0008523227879777551, -0.0346052460372448, 0.044025689363479614, 0.010951034724712372, 0.005757499020546675, -0.04052220284938812, -0.055010851472616196, -0.01804165169596672, -0.009275243617594242, 0.010903595946729183, -0.046571891754865646, -0.007203603629022837, -0.05226462706923485, -0.044847775250673294, -0.05461939424276352, 0.001282261684536934, 0.07370790839195251, 0.035542700439691544, -0.05099686235189438, 0.06501194834709167, -0.010201138444244862, -0.013154033571481705, -0.037028923630714417, 0.040587443858385086, 0.03080301359295845, -0.017299579456448555, 0.004814333748072386, -0.04565456137061119, 0.0017695362912490964, 0.02379242330789566, 0.04619285464286804, -0.01576518453657627, -0.03201913461089134, -0.03389989584684372, -0.018436579033732414, -0.023901265114545822, 0.011582198552787304, -0.016404325142502785, 0.03588639944791794, -0.04918244481086731, 0.0010037452448159456, -0.03307551518082619, -0.07521776109933853, 0.008553117513656616, -0.029208054766058922, -0.020713258534669876, -0.036685701459646225, -0.008503581397235394, -0.08140626549720764, -0.037746451795101166, 0.018934646621346474, -0.005276205949485302, -0.041182518005371094, 0.03652207553386688, -0.0369490385055542, -0.005976579152047634, -0.005566901061683893, 0.029611928388476372, -0.07077576965093613, 0.0028668034356087446, 0.01807020604610443, -0.015482180751860142, 0.014532807283103466, 0.010183064267039299, 0.027094366028904915, 0.025702698156237602, -0.0162061657756567, -0.06518802791833878, -0.051293618977069855, -0.0031126069370657206, 0.05746655538678169, -0.05297578126192093, -0.0029994237702339888, 0.0029918404761701822, -0.06543294340372086, -0.029560856521129608, -0.010134653188288212, -0.031638313084840775, 0.03497680649161339, 0.03195589408278465, -0.004094778560101986, 0.03236757591366768, 0.01296693179756403, -0.016506176441907883, -0.0007399693131446838, -0.03386606276035309, 0.038503747433423996, -0.029532724991440773, 0.027174480259418488, -0.04954507574439049, 0.027915457263588905, -0.04039737954735756, -0.0777946189045906, 0.022643472999334335, 0.06433556228876114, -0.06457985192537308, 0.021431615576148033, 0.05165551230311394, 0.032520800828933716, -0.008987046778202057, -0.027979234233498573, -0.03018515184521675, -0.05752076581120491, 0.04103167727589607, 0.02556001953780651, -0.02901376411318779, 0.00638585677370429, 0.0005651604733429849, -0.01695616915822029, 0.02767934463918209, -0.022646663710474968, -0.01874030940234661, 0.012574896216392517, -0.07031087577342987, -0.04136005416512489, -0.01603250578045845, 0.06987205892801285, 0.010184964165091515, 0.014039467088878155, 0.013530227355659008, -0.03767358511686325, 0.018050754442811012, 0.011626910418272018, -0.014487599022686481, -0.07867864519357681, -0.01788308098912239, 0.02865229733288288, 0.04647813364863396, 0.004210529383271933, 0.014627654105424881, -0.04240557178854942, 0.0037077164743095636, 0.006350050214678049, -0.0033373539336025715, 0.04482581838965416, 0.01092931441962719, -0.0005031005712226033, -0.06919456273317337, 0.05459245294332504, -0.0001613328786334023, -0.01890680566430092, -0.07241964340209961, 0.012513590045273304, -0.043351270258426666, 0.029652230441570282, 0.055375102907419205, -0.06427980214357376, -0.029084021225571632, 0.02849331684410572, 0.062469612807035446, 0.015205621719360352, 0.010341469198465347, -0.013604746200144291, 0.004510347731411457, 0.028311075642704964, -0.023672018200159073, 0.042091578245162964, -0.04401983320713043, -0.04287716746330261, 0.017934927716851234, 0.0037810637149959803, -0.008946222253143787, -0.031140048056840897, -0.006133229937404394, -0.04304933547973633, 0.02027270942926407, 0.011739572510123253, 0.0014808950945734978, -0.014288120903074741, 0.01678827777504921, -0.017695987597107887, 0.04404648393392563, 0.016125891357660294, -0.05329297482967377, -0.06131935492157936, -0.020151391625404358, -0.011152553372085094, -0.03537898138165474, -0.0640840157866478, 0.013787462376058102, 0.00561321759596467, -0.014102015644311905, -0.049890484660863876, 0.014332366175949574, -0.009679523296654224, 0.03975732624530792, -0.07521441578865051, -0.017073094844818115, 0.033806249499320984, 0.005672763101756573, -0.007943803444504738, -0.027015911415219307, 0.026075027883052826, -0.0035144358407706022, -0.05938537046313286, -0.03543296083807945, 0.006830817554146051, -0.012066776864230633, 0.00018824174185283482, 0.048052627593278885, -0.08626709878444672, -0.024852925911545753, -0.0658874586224556, -0.0154534000903368, -0.05714573711156845, -0.055107686668634415, 0.015849871560931206, 0.03894496709108353, 0.0009527004440315068, -0.025879262015223503, 0.059382230043411255, 0.024694714695215225, 0.08190255612134933, -0.01345466636121273, -0.009526904672384262, 0.06077973172068596, -0.0991673395037651, 0.046034567058086395, -0.011045239865779877, 0.01662636548280716, 0.027334697544574738, 0.029869936406612396, 0.00034286201116628945, -0.013877717778086662, -0.008771688677370548, 0.057025086134672165, -0.003064157208427787, -0.011038929224014282, -0.045195072889328, -0.007885993458330631, -0.045168329030275345, -0.07536683231592178, -0.012719197198748589, -0.06070687994360924, -0.03485674783587456, -0.01490516122430563, -0.0006216899491846561, 0.05758737027645111, -0.011793363839387894, -0.060390159487724304, -0.07782307267189026, -0.01791771873831749, 0.05130825936794281, -0.0013077124021947384, -0.027872389182448387, -0.06334946304559708, -0.03719751536846161, -0.015858570113778114, 0.009554523974657059, 0.026134073734283447, -0.006103071384131908, -0.021561050787568092, -0.02663920633494854, -0.022226613014936447, 0.004101525526493788, -0.0031249544117599726, -0.03189852088689804, 0.03127594292163849, -0.0015480801230296493, 0.03619392588734627, 0.06909599155187607, 0.03526145592331886, -0.05818741023540497, -0.010602454654872417, 0.05871277302503586, -0.013158530928194523, -0.026595402508974075, 0.03679059445858002, 0.035623304545879364, -0.05287184193730354, 0.025888781994581223, -0.0016331265214830637, 0.02534429170191288, 0.025184065103530884, -0.012824160978198051, -0.05036032572388649, 0.015860654413700104, -0.017688514664769173, 0.04281741753220558, 0.06508627533912659, 0.05250447243452072, 0.011549806222319603, -0.02197285369038582, -0.07285227626562119, -0.010957884602248669, -0.01539552491158247, 0.02931910939514637, -0.04567596688866615, -0.05759887769818306, -0.026570046320557594, -0.08634003251791, 0.004724143072962761, 0.005792182870209217, -0.04693037271499634, -0.055008310824632645, -0.08143673092126846, -0.052473217248916626, -0.004676140379160643, 0.04032960161566734, -0.0338580422103405, -0.06688813865184784, -0.06626817584037781, 0.014741064049303532, 0.022051246836781502, 0.018288837745785713, -0.06277099996805191, -0.04840087890625, -0.019077597185969353, 0.0044332644902169704, -0.024173688143491745, -0.03173380345106125, 0.0020682946778833866, -0.000942621030844748, 0.01639472134411335, -0.005667794030159712, -0.03178756311535835, 0.014433600008487701, 0.012000133283436298, 0.03458414971828461, 0.04803064838051796, -0.014855599962174892, 0.005927448160946369, 0.028216872364282608, -0.06595242768526077, -0.008969846181571484, -0.016610322520136833, 0.06507066637277603, -0.011119108647108078, -0.034016434103250504, -0.035326432436704636, 0.02085408940911293, 0.004445225931704044, 0.024318315088748932, -0.0010070264106616378, 0.0009335171198472381, 0.04538422077894211, -0.03852720931172371, -0.03988204896450043, 0.015582803636789322, 0.02311648614704609, -0.0000778401517891325, 0.03960643336176872, -0.05385655164718628, -0.004568010568618774, 0.057714592665433884, -0.0939013734459877, 0.008581985719501972, 0.034691136330366135, 0.0802541971206665, -0.031044770032167435, -0.0010358812287449837, 0.014914389699697495, -0.019394157454371452, -0.01381686981767416, -0.02430897019803524, 0.016344616189599037, 0.006034496705979109, 0.031498443335294724, -0.06467831134796143, -0.04398627206683159, -0.030774055048823357, -0.06494360417127609, -0.06934919953346252, 0.012109003029763699, 0.05007006227970123, -0.035343237221241, 0.011570237576961517, -0.05059678852558136, 0.015485137701034546, -0.013753351755440235, 0.04213137924671173, 0.052786730229854584, -0.014331326819956303, 0.023467831313610077, -0.04384808614850044, 0.018026202917099, 0.031060095876455307, -0.0067749423906207085, 0.009139647707343102, -0.01614442653954029, 0.02137131430208683, -0.05684364214539528, 0.064503513276577, 0.025166288018226624, -0.007752162870019674, 0.011945059522986412, 0.001409884775057435, -0.01851779781281948, 0.04564812406897545, 0.019943462684750557, 0.0202544666826725, -0.03502507507801056, 0.03765163570642471, 0.017366789281368256, -0.043048880994319916, -0.05383973568677902, -0.00037016801070421934, 0.007504423148930073, -0.03362816572189331, -0.03017629124224186, -0.01902177557349205, -0.014733684249222279, -0.042543746531009674, -0.08472105115652084, 0.004631918389350176, -0.02385680191218853, 0.03935127332806587, -0.010110556147992611, -0.05760634317994118, 0.05285939574241638, -0.05453849211335182, 0.006974091287702322, -0.0470963716506958, 0.01486259512603283, 0.014184712432324886, -0.025698980316519737, -0.035087864845991135, -0.07201482355594635, 0.026589471846818924, -0.059485990554094315, 0.042938098311424255, 0.0010884212097153068, 0.007120726630091667, -0.044626642018556595, -0.007341331336647272, -0.007780061569064856, 0.031110933050513268, 0.060073819011449814, 0.04828739911317825, 0.03492012992501259, -0.02011163718998432, 0.0308479443192482, -0.01105837058275938, 0.02665691263973713, -0.04385402798652649, -0.0009757602238096297, 0.045402877032756805, -0.010665034875273705, -0.027438649907708168, -0.048952240496873856, -0.020862042903900146, 0.04816627874970436, -0.04766446724534035, -0.015994740650057793, -0.032741058617830276, 0.0430641807615757, -0.06532975286245346, -0.07975886017084122, -0.02974225953221321, -0.02027122676372528, -0.06227144971489906, -0.018192801624536514, 0.04317585751414299, 0.017843764275312424, -0.035193394869565964, -0.00975510012358427, 0.007985086180269718, 0.008721766993403435, 0.008072768338024616, 0.02242126874625683, 0.04754932224750519, 0.011770235374569893, -0.016139423474669456, 0.009811537340283394, -0.06404527276754379, 0.00036989658838137984, -0.01467935647815466, 0.018365826457738876, 0.001128088217228651, 0.06953495740890503, 0.03502336144447327, 0.05479743704199791, -0.09150068461894989, 0.056394509971141815, 0.02912956103682518, -0.004805914591997862, 0.04192269593477249, 0.07499455660581589, 0.001451674965210259, -0.0031953768339008093, -0.035979434847831726, 0.018992718309164047, 0.03782793506979942, -0.02332049049437046, 0.03337489813566208, -0.027469933032989502, -0.017180347815155983, -0.007704106625169516, 0.07556017488241196, -0.02143300510942936, -0.05680352821946144, 0.046456560492515564, 0.02661737985908985, -0.02056022360920906, -0.025385191664099693, 0.03867259994149208, 0.032576195895671844, -0.01704929582774639, -0.029476765543222427, 0.00373810320161283, -0.056544285267591476, 0.023698590695858, -0.011424515396356583, -0.03452986851334572, 0.017631156370043755, 0.032777346670627594, -0.010617194697260857, -0.012901941314339638, 0.01654827781021595, -0.03556908667087555, 0.019402066245675087, -0.011289490386843681, 0.004514889791607857, -0.05465663596987724, -0.00048813241301104426, -0.04011395946145058, 0.02219429798424244, 0.05917428433895111, -0.011532964184880257, 0.01118112076073885, -0.01697029359638691, -0.03708627447485924, -0.01400196272879839, -0.0165642611682415, 0.006557741202414036, 0.02752353996038437, -0.045339059084653854, 0.04949666187167168, 0.03252546116709709, 0.0573522187769413, 0.05040198564529419, -0.022731399163603783, 0.0028852918185293674, -0.0016466344241052866, -0.02967819944024086, 0.020712845027446747, 0.027687648311257362, -0.023745790123939514, -0.0487217977643013, 0.022895220667123795, 0.0167766772210598, -0.020876264199614525, 0.038399700075387955, 0.006421240512281656, 0.004976125434041023, -0.0016804279293864965, 0.003719549858942628, -0.03159270063042641, -0.04251176863908768, -0.0014466015854850411, 0.07442652434110641, -0.041783127933740616, -0.004760829731822014, -0.058826934546232224, -0.026300018653273582, -0.0003433742967899889, -0.03338718041777611, 0.011849622242152691, 0.042142193764448166, 0.02961495704948902, -0.0434245765209198, 0.025373902171850204, -0.021660976111888885, -0.06203765794634819, -0.011326403357088566, -0.007111085578799248, -0.07600230723619461, -0.01289814431220293, 0.0242867823690176, 0.021615229547023773, 0.03795510530471802, 0.07124041765928268, -0.017197826877236366, -0.016059959307312965, -0.03466453030705452, 0.05620761960744858, 0.08592349290847778, -0.01523081585764885, 0.04160383343696594, -0.01243440993130207, -0.01100186537951231, -0.009337433613836765, -0.0008136720862239599, -0.019115697592496872, -0.026767926290631294, 0.00022058005561120808, -0.03769080713391304, -0.020215345546603203, -0.008385936729609966, 0.061580780893564224, -0.017019100487232208, 0.010224556550383568, -0.017219385132193565, -0.023752598091959953, 0.026671255007386208, -0.029134897515177727, -0.05443793535232544, -0.010964027605950832, 0.0047068833373487, -0.008386283181607723, -0.03309658542275429, -0.030282095074653625, -0.03880153223872185, 0.004699445329606533, -0.03240581601858139, -0.04210679605603218, 0.010710506699979305, -0.009978973306715488, -0.04158627614378929, 0.010204488411545753, -0.05727770924568176, 0.020489254966378212, -0.01992275007069111, 0.018243804574012756, 0.016668682917952538, 0.07367163151502609, -0.014708061702549458, -0.04001758620142937, 0.025819508358836174, -0.003935420420020819, 0.01435499545186758, 0.004755621310323477, 0.012261071242392063, 0.01619109697639942, 0.012085752561688423, -0.03218992426991463, -0.01078716665506363, -0.03321083262562752, -0.0249488465487957, 0.05172472074627876, 0.010991217568516731, -0.011545881628990173, -0.05168808251619339, 0.004401191603392363, 0.004458974115550518, -0.011155025102198124, 0.03310847282409668, -0.03073440119624138, -0.06582697480916977, -0.0014158796984702349, 0.007687408942729235, -0.013916931115090847, -0.02539755590260029, 0.06381116062402725, 0.040411096066236496, 0.023418692871928215, 0.03378940001130104, 0.01373029313981533, 0.05615301430225372, 0.002217154251411557, -0.06518281251192093, -0.017599839717149734, 0.030442947521805763, -0.03209356218576431, -0.04696541652083397, -0.03205609321594238, -0.027423188090324402, -0.05569322779774666, 0.025694463402032852, 0.05528216063976288, 0.01786867529153824, 0.013870648108422756, -0.048583127558231354, 0.0114233223721385, 0.01470209751278162, -0.04007888585329056, -0.050793424248695374, -0.036793988198041916, -0.011383249424397945, -0.005075570661574602, -0.013339958153665066, -0.04423917084932327, -0.06508863717317581, 0.015360260382294655, -0.08778240531682968, 0.026217522099614143, 0.029666906222701073, 0.07386867702007294, -0.004687253851443529, -0.037217967212200165, -0.029850387945771217, -0.006571160163730383, -0.0022893352434039116, -0.024323206394910812, 0.011183944530785084, 0.04718109965324402, 0.02315646968781948, 0.046763282269239426, -0.05306253582239151, -0.009817980229854584, 0.04232614114880562, -0.0463283471763134, 0.01241996232420206, 0.0182719137519598, 0.03796051815152168, -0.02093561738729477, 0.03406555950641632, 0.03344787657260895, -0.008129834197461605, 0.0338783785700798, -0.036381591111421585, 0.006669879890978336, -0.07374483346939087, -0.06457094103097916, 0.021084260195493698, -0.07002339512109756, -0.012692746706306934, 0.036942534148693085, -0.015396712347865105, -0.03419189900159836, -0.01777588576078415, -0.06869176030158997, 0.05263695865869522, 0.0037464527413249016, -0.03471742570400238, 0.04851241782307625, -0.044189587235450745, 0.018309643492102623, -0.020435582846403122, 0.016932658851146698, -0.035839684307575226, 0.010814350098371506, 0.026307187974452972, -0.06149667873978615, 0.021918676793575287, -0.06254246830940247, -0.011208603158593178, -0.010288650169968605, 0.009957988746464252, -0.017966369166970253, 0.0454699769616127, 0.009894320741295815, -0.041203372180461884, -0.006400803569704294, -0.03807290270924568, -0.00330373365432024, -0.07629892230033875, -0.06225564330816269, -0.046589549630880356, 0.04401077330112457, -0.03317505866289139, 0.02741292677819729, 0.026419108733534813, 0.05586559325456619, 0.04015863314270973, 0.011225431226193905, 0.007900606840848923, 0.04788117855787277, -0.06803139299154282, 0.08660958707332611, 0.04109705239534378, -0.00032079743687063456, -0.0026750555261969566, -0.01410878635942936, -0.010034209117293358, -0.03023999184370041, 0.006315730977803469, 0.018400711938738823, 0.0026472890749573708, -0.0420781746506691, -0.005370748229324818, 0.000736276968382299, -0.022063184529542923, -0.000992950750514865, -0.002357594668865204, 0.03610265254974365, 0.0003169066330883652, -0.03046519309282303 ]
A dry frictional interface loaded in shear often displays stick-slip. The amplitude of this cycle depends on the probability that a slip event nucleates into a rupture, and on the rate at which slip events are triggered. This rate is determined by the distribution $P(x)$ of soft spots which yields if the shear stress is increased by some amount $x$. In minimal models of a frictional interface that include disorder, inertia and long-range elasticity, we discovered an 'armouring' mechanism, by which the interface is greatly stabilised after a large slip event: $P(x)$ then vanishes at small arguments, as $P(x)\sim x^\theta$ [1]. The exponent $\theta>0$, which exists only in the presence of inertia (otherwise $\theta=0$), was found to depend on the statistics of the disorder in the model, a phenomenon that was not explained. Here, we show that a single-particle toy model with inertia and disorder captures the existence of a non-trivial exponent $\theta>0$, which we can analytically relate to the statistics of the disorder.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13802v1
[ -0.04599225893616676, -0.044730693101882935, 0.03257320448756218, -0.039983250200748444, 0.01499794889241457, 0.03514549508690834, 0.0009141644113697112, 0.01528659462928772, -0.007350245490670204, -0.021946316584944725, -0.00253039482049644, -0.056623004376888275, -0.012343264184892178, -0.03491061553359032, -0.022520147264003754, -0.04596149921417236, 0.07411312311887741, 0.05264383926987648, -0.038705769926309586, 0.055855244398117065, -0.04927448183298111, -0.028972622007131577, 0.0016205731080844998, 0.04149646684527397, -0.017345022410154343, -0.04976239427924156, -0.04191110283136368, 0.04849453270435333, -0.05757080391049385, 0.001966851996257901, 0.0711723119020462, -0.011825419031083584, -0.019423773512244225, -0.057134535163640976, 0.00799119658768177, 0.0032479078508913517, -0.03279171139001846, 0.015462632291018963, 0.023495681583881378, -0.013265818357467651, 0.006640313193202019, -0.03347228094935417, -0.019848279654979706, -0.01851634867489338, -0.006056062877178192, 0.01613231562077999, -0.02220754139125347, 0.0012446851469576359, -0.016141081228852272, -0.04028923064470291, 0.03610828146338463, 0.009099590592086315, -0.017759287729859352, 0.05611139535903931, -0.030917027965188026, -0.008192094042897224, -0.013466492295265198, -0.012100059539079666, -0.012162971310317516, -0.05034217610955238, -0.018353328108787537, -0.039499085396528244, -0.02868625894188881, -0.04635687172412872, -0.0324159599840641, 0.03336029872298241, -0.006978911347687244, -0.05398692935705185, 0.0054418109357357025, -0.06530603021383286, 0.006394984200596809, -0.06916002929210663, 0.03933965787291527, 0.0314851850271225, -0.06655178964138031, 0.01584279164671898, -0.029545269906520844, -0.0024872408248484135, -0.017701946198940277, 0.021109797060489655, 0.0019292942015454173, 0.028411703184247017, 0.02851106971502304, -0.04341054707765579, 0.05469990894198418, 0.0035178468097001314, 0.07150272279977798, -0.06347662955522537, 0.019374923780560493, -0.07029721140861511, -0.0012253490276634693, -0.0423487089574337, -0.07321653515100479, -0.05583670735359192, 0.04904983565211296, -0.04336891695857048, 0.07152575999498367, -0.0006245321710593998, 0.050020210444927216, -0.0074492162093520164, -0.054610833525657654, -0.06014355272054672, -0.029449285939335823, -0.00945967435836792, 0.02700374275445938, -0.04547520726919174, -0.019828949123620987, -0.011507922783493996, -0.041518982499837875, 0.04983198270201683, -0.01343085803091526, 0.014264843426644802, 0.005217471159994602, -0.04761560633778572, -0.03410027548670769, -0.06114119291305542, 0.049451202154159546, 0.003741319291293621, 0.022534150630235672, -0.005639899522066116, -0.029504360631108284, 0.05379354953765869, 0.012356226332485676, 0.015770338475704193, -0.031206471845507622, -0.017926475033164024, 0.05593124032020569, -0.043031319975852966, 0.007863671518862247, 0.02069157548248768, -0.04789182171225548, -0.017351754009723663, 0.03225314989686012, 0.009137231856584549, 0.04690830409526825, -0.010992917232215405, 0.02295084297657013, -0.020726371556520462, 0.044472504407167435, 0.030685171484947205, -0.0148087739944458, -0.029123468324542046, 0.011446631513535976, 0.04820571839809418, -0.0069481017999351025, 0.009278937242925167, -0.05247785896062851, 0.004067715723067522, 0.04521360620856285, 0.010048236697912216, -0.010107881389558315, -0.023287184536457062, -0.0015610193368047476, 0.018663881346583366, 0.021816106513142586, -0.006654472090303898, 0.018658224493265152, 0.04994256794452667, -0.0562644861638546, -0.01031104288995266, 0.019190119579434395, -0.026831818744540215, 0.0013052168069407344, 0.018255434930324554, 0.042872104793787, 0.027157073840498924, 0.019218817353248596, -0.02230718359351158, 0.02826102450489998, 0.0028467001393437386, -0.0561692975461483, 0.026791980490088463, -0.024208014830946922, -0.05319114401936531, -0.06603146344423294, -0.015869151800870895, -0.0034289127215743065, -0.050448667258024216, -0.002972533693537116, 0.0033694086596369743, 0.038768090307712555, 0.013187289237976074, -0.020599747076630592, 0.00012349776807241142, -0.048482440412044525, -0.0002998870622832328, -0.07009391486644745, -0.00490986043587327, 0.04487161338329315, 0.027431249618530273, -0.020636916160583496, -0.0331815630197525, 0.0028292452916502953, 0.003548749489709735, 0.05836709588766098, -0.0017667148495092988, -0.01831238530576229, -0.040036484599113464, -0.03990678861737251, 0.044406019151210785, -0.056457918137311935, -0.00766996992751956, -0.06583167612552643, 0.030854856595396996, -0.018064571544528008, -0.0513821505010128, 0.010742579586803913, 0.028749873861670494, -0.0413648821413517, -0.07844424992799759, 0.03610069304704666, 0.013745437376201153, 0.04451511800289154, 0.02472812309861183, -0.026012316346168518, -0.03138025104999542, -0.09132788330316544, 0.03477729856967926, 0.0370248481631279, -0.026813087984919548, 0.013773159123957157, -0.005410661920905113, 0.0042404052801430225, -0.053583789616823196, -0.07933081686496735, 0.05088036134839058, 0.051154788583517075, -0.004289817530661821, -0.024438880383968353, 0.002174920868128538, -0.001610076054930687, -0.05615318939089775, -0.0258462093770504, -0.0571860745549202, -0.02989373914897442, -0.03900885581970215, -0.029224073514342308, 0.0560150183737278, 0.004937333520501852, 0.013196438550949097, -0.03792755678296089, -0.0536213144659996, 0.04943886026740074, 0.016484569758176804, -0.06801171600818634, -0.05306999757885933, -0.04861969128251076, 0.008086482994258404, -0.033718518912792206, 0.0016938538756221533, -0.011625480838119984, -0.06993025541305542, -0.005885105114430189, -0.047417834401130676, 0.021612705662846565, 0.07031478732824326, -0.028777102008461952, 0.010756327770650387, -0.0005776399048045278, 0.04237633943557739, -0.004547498654574156, 0.027936028316617012, -0.037920307368040085, -0.004484530538320541, -0.0023299914319068193, -0.009941237978637218, -0.03230065479874611, -0.025191467255353928, -0.01116210874170065, -0.0038287292700260878, 0.018447963520884514, 0.0005986611358821392, 0.025411956012248993, 0.03658835217356682, -0.005903072189539671, -0.06243833899497986, -0.035536959767341614, -0.01953793317079544, 0.010832631960511208, -0.03926548734307289, 0.05958251655101776, 0.0008634575642645359, -0.04288278892636299, -0.07721743732690811, -0.011513153091073036, 0.009424095042049885, -0.024038702249526978, -0.08058585971593857, -0.04452259838581085, 0.013136441819369793, -0.0734490379691124, 0.007491703145205975, -0.026935001835227013, 0.0067852153442800045, -0.05609723925590515, -0.06170596182346344, -0.05065315589308739, 0.025724945589900017, 0.03964588791131973, -0.06483075022697449, -0.05666137859225273, -0.009333230555057526, 0.036498166620731354, 0.04220704361796379, -0.013545255176723003, -0.03550788387656212, -0.03579644486308098, -0.015336270444095135, -0.005320915952324867, -0.028775231912732124, -0.03262920677661896, 0.012714754790067673, -0.04555148258805275, -0.021535536274313927, -0.039889100939035416, 0.034584514796733856, 0.015972843393683434, -0.04711788520216942, 0.013416946865618229, -0.05226635932922363, 0.017146160826086998, -0.049866076558828354, -0.00708765210583806, -0.05351566523313522, -0.050645533949136734, -0.020339256152510643, 0.06355281919240952, 0.04396049305796623, 0.009095459245145321, -0.0487997904419899, -0.059096869081258774, 0.03145737200975418, -0.033019065856933594, -0.028318580240011215, 0.04528307542204857, 0.02029600366950035, -0.026531212031841278, -0.0024147445801645517, -0.05637087672948837, 0.04792340099811554, -0.010493723675608635, 0.025354165583848953, 0.0036553198006004095, 0.008021220564842224, -0.016356533393263817, -0.08056645095348358, 0.05919552966952324, 0.06680107116699219, 0.049783214926719666, -0.0016134621109813452, -0.0010998889338225126, 0.04905727505683899, 0.001760537619702518, 0.03638220950961113, -0.019468847662210464, -0.01466917060315609, 0.06253167241811752, 0.05912666767835617, -0.015670062974095345, -0.07680950313806534, 0.025634920224547386, -0.07632416486740112, -0.004339409060776234, 0.00039027552702464163, -0.04412226751446724, 0.019005082547664642, 0.010587088763713837, 0.044312603771686554, 0.05795155093073845, 0.014651685953140259, 0.06497271358966827, -0.02898242697119713, -0.0014682308537885547, 0.013918201439082623, -0.00704016350209713, -0.011590295471251011, -0.02188016287982464, 0.01500086858868599, -0.02681506611406803, -0.0443122498691082, 0.045713335275650024, -0.024447979405522346, 0.018737275153398514, 0.051168520003557205, 0.010887488722801208, 0.0028980455826967955, 0.007131714373826981, -0.0370502732694149, 0.04976912587881088, 0.012328588403761387, 0.027112489566206932, 0.004087118897587061, -0.028942037373781204, 0.04839906096458435, -0.01690266840159893, -0.0015600662445649505, -0.01134458463639021, 0.003013696987181902, -0.04637661576271057, 0.015582901425659657, 0.010469108819961548, -0.013079704716801643, 0.002469839761033654, -0.08522774279117584, 0.00755973719060421, -0.06552745401859283, 0.031922660768032074, 0.004175160080194473, -0.0026166175957769156, 0.05722034350037575, -0.00642931554466486, -0.02518567256629467, -0.021551914513111115, -0.018394730985164642, -0.012972836382687092, -0.005546931177377701, -0.059796180576086044, -0.03331013396382332, 0.014681029133498669, -0.06066819280385971, 0.026041438803076744, 0.00043408648343756795, 0.0015102409524843097, -0.02909601479768753, 0.05163099989295006, -0.010209945030510426, 0.02697804942727089, 0.0658593699336052, 0.05198600888252258, 0.030918369069695473, -0.024948373436927795, -0.01602409966289997, -0.031694427132606506, -0.0022479339968413115, 0.018639856949448586, -0.03885307535529137, 0.024853480979800224, -0.042003728449344635, -0.04452907666563988, -0.010587990283966064, 0.02306331694126129, 0.07002376765012741, -0.003424270311370492, -0.008325250819325447, 0.03568526729941368, 0.034489624202251434, -0.07662416249513626, -0.06676843017339706, -0.002864130539819598, -0.06095690652728081, -0.060298722237348557, 0.012461388483643532, -0.04098637402057648, 0.015164963901042938, 0.025046078488230705, 0.050660062581300735, -0.04629644379019737, 0.03740929812192917, -0.009686817415058613, -0.02688302844762802, 0.03335600346326828, 0.011003769002854824, -0.016920145601034164, -0.024987243115901947, -0.06347400695085526, 0.027921132743358612, 0.015802975744009018, -0.04269272834062576, 0.0025880474131554365, 0.07373680919408798, -0.03973259776830673, 0.0076772961765527725, -0.07676602154970169, 0.04161503538489342, -0.015110977925360203, -0.025870580226182938, -0.0032617375254631042, 0.014329221099615097, -0.048394620418548584, 0.02817067690193653, -0.04722708836197853, 0.00425741309300065, -0.015079219825565815, 0.026480576023459435, -0.012789432890713215, 0.01938687078654766, -0.036652009934186935, -0.021845359355211258, 0.0013454965082928538, -0.04008006677031517, -0.04369582235813141, -0.01777726784348488, -0.004307062830775976, -0.02230064943432808, -0.029964135959744453, 0.025509128347039223, -0.005858375690877438, -0.04297203943133354, -0.04583980143070221, -0.004613266792148352, 0.023549243807792664, 0.040729522705078125, 0.033877693116664886, -0.07447677105665207, -0.01173930149525404, 0.0067497193813323975, 0.0055920896120369434, 0.011654582805931568, 0.0064741382375359535, 0.029442884027957916, -0.015858108177781105, -0.0017490633763372898, 0.0087134325876832, -0.06121370196342468, 0.003084191819652915, -0.002842789515852928, 0.026592882350087166, 0.006997518707066774, -0.02832026220858097, 0.042980700731277466, 0.025267377495765686, -0.022882990539073944, -0.06438548862934113, -0.028181113302707672, -0.041413649916648865, 0.025814970955252647, -0.0030097351409494877, -0.032127510756254196, 0.014174560084939003, 0.026399262249469757, 0.04122040793299675, -0.01607801765203476, -0.023261407390236855, -0.026532521471381187, -0.03359856456518173, -0.02556224912405014, 0.024909771978855133, -0.011008324101567268, -0.06432391703128815, -0.04183576628565788, 0.033001650124788284, -0.029880771413445473, 0.0317988395690918, -0.004406587686389685, 0.006103166379034519, -0.010743881575763226, 0.023429151624441147, 0.05091079697012901, -0.06802379339933395, -0.0002276578888995573, 0.06758968532085419, -0.051364630460739136, 0.015858547762036324, -0.05073849484324455, -0.020629165694117546, -0.03556731343269348, -0.037637293338775635, -0.032974448055028915, 0.007391443941742182, -0.00906689465045929, -0.024390140548348427, 0.04718580096960068, -0.02038438245654106, -0.05591040849685669, -0.012838773429393768, 0.025621093809604645, -0.06311125308275223, 0.03172306343913078, 0.013830947689712048, -0.024834351614117622, -0.018460910767316818, 0.03496742621064186, -0.06656619161367416, -0.07363313436508179, -0.025181056931614876, 0.0540539026260376, 0.03876132518053055, 0.02336498722434044, 0.02575385570526123, -0.020921437069773674, -0.05017498880624771, 0.00673001678660512, -0.05435136705636978, -0.028479576110839844, -0.013434079475700855, 0.012476643547415733, -0.05170218646526337, -0.0011090381303802133, 0.0010195233626291156, 0.032891903072595596, -0.02915392629802227, -0.014248254708945751, -0.012430848553776741, 0.017895875498652458, 0.05884391814470291, -0.030591284856200218, -0.04686493054032326, 0.002447784412652254, 0.020119495689868927, 0.0036732067819684744, -0.013442291878163815, 0.03914150595664978, 0.022194255143404007, 0.01945674978196621, 0.032864443957805634, -0.06264965236186981, -0.01106980536133051, -0.022492999210953712, -0.037851374596357346, -0.006229204125702381, -0.032521821558475494, 0.006193676497787237, 0.01933962292969227, 0.04920711740851402, 0.019675014540553093, 0.025543415918946266, -0.02140875905752182, 0.025393690913915634, -0.04214967042207718, 0.026963304728269577, -0.007075542118400335, 0.04971751943230629, 0.0031287441961467266, -0.01617615669965744, 0.06256170570850372, -0.039339739829301834, -0.010464142076671124, -0.04182419925928116, -0.035531263798475266, 0.02421996183693409, -0.020357875153422356, -0.02978178672492504, -0.041152745485305786, -0.0014470502501353621, -0.06762135028839111, 0.057247769087553024, -0.010263683274388313, -0.021890340372920036, -0.05356089025735855, 0.037049368023872375, 0.00953444093465805, -0.01359670888632536, 0.03706071153283119, 0.034270498901605606, -0.013944093137979507, 0.028589393943548203, 0.07090025395154953, 0.060562629252672195, 0.06038743257522583, 0.021218497306108475, -0.07039586454629898, 0.01641925983130932, 0.04099103808403015, -0.018793020397424698, -0.04639836400747299, 0.0016441906336694956, -0.07669788599014282, -0.0504627600312233, 0.019405348226428032, 0.015801476314663887, 0.001295675989240408, -0.04217636585235596, -0.041628725826740265, 0.06296905130147934, 0.02392200566828251, 0.017163144424557686, -0.08165903389453888, 0.011528248898684978, 0.020175417885184288, -0.021550631150603294, 0.020963070914149284, -0.011219881474971771, -0.07812099158763885, 0.010077081620693207, -0.08587531745433807, 0.010433505289256573, -0.027606086805462837, 0.03877928480505943, 0.028169145807623863, 0.01946280524134636, -0.05415315926074982, 0.005900620482861996, 0.04219387471675873, 0.05070017650723457, 0.0026250125374644995, 0.0534001924097538, 0.022032691165804863, -0.035701509565114975, -0.010317478328943253, 0.0055803339928388596, 0.07142314314842224, -0.016238752752542496, -0.009637155570089817, 0.06344092637300491, 0.007864939980208874, -0.04906507208943367, 0.005231573712080717, -0.025763582438230515, 0.0043426696211099625, 0.013597414828836918, 0.02637309394776821, 0.00997033528983593, -0.04713792726397514, -0.0518377348780632, 0.051547277718782425, -0.05811101570725441, -0.020338496193289757, -0.03219355642795563, 0.023521829396486282, -0.009440908208489418, -0.02717020735144615, -0.0030980692245066166, 0.050544340163469315, 0.049958616495132446, 0.019401567056775093, 0.04020451381802559, -0.038608673959970474, -0.0006523341289721429, 0.004755996633321047, -0.0011112494394183159, -0.03344679996371269, 0.04042493924498558, 0.048003096133470535, -0.022413045167922974, -0.007317372132092714, -0.05700090527534485, 0.012974909506738186, -0.019830109551548958, 0.04182823374867439, 0.0267877746373415, 0.04543156549334526, -0.04289276525378227, 0.003621714888140559, -0.047447819262742996, -0.0637088194489479, -0.030222145840525627, -0.05603497102856636, 0.031034991145133972, -0.021722955629229546, -0.0174575112760067, 0.02351558208465576, 0.06515613198280334, -0.03505869209766388, 0.02933516539633274, 0.024983741343021393, 0.035829126834869385, -0.025742797181010246, -0.004637355916202068, -0.06535745412111282, 0.030926333740353584, 0.03943596035242081, -0.012706202454864979, -0.025384295731782913, -0.0011965094599872828, 0.003021174343302846, -0.024077801033854485, 0.0064756302163004875, -0.038027312606573105, -0.014705508016049862, -0.07051540166139603, -0.04636766389012337, 0.026821792125701904, 0.043422672897577286, -0.029482191428542137, 0.026529671624302864, 0.04330938681960106, 0.022067904472351074, -0.05038924515247345 ]
Enabling preserving bisimilarity is a refinement of strong bisimilarity that preserves safety as well as liveness properties. To define it properly, labelled transition systems needed to be upgraded with a successor relation, capturing concurrency between transitions enabled in the same state. We enrich the well-known De Simone format to handle inductive definitions of this successor relation. We then establish that ep-bisimilarity is a congruence for the operators, as well as lean congruence for recursion, for all (enriched) De Simone languages.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07933v1
[ -0.01715102605521679, -0.0016233581118285656, 0.0574050098657608, 0.053666938096284866, 0.014709025621414185, -0.0003076677385251969, -0.01666100136935711, 0.031052613630890846, -0.005832132883369923, -0.005249419715255499, -0.0017713349079713225, 0.009315066039562225, -0.048907842487096786, -0.03894597291946411, -0.015920212492346764, 0.00026070987223647535, 0.016369104385375977, -0.002266403753310442, -0.036488551646471024, 0.054671477526426315, -0.04093829169869423, 0.008693153969943523, -0.0380532331764698, 0.03827715292572975, -0.008811230771243572, -0.06696899235248566, -0.007360145915299654, 0.044882968068122864, -0.04217907413840294, -0.015583702363073826, 0.04279385134577751, -0.01580897346138954, 0.00495788361877203, -0.019418710842728615, -0.02948819100856781, -0.030567411333322525, -0.07114020735025406, 0.0001411019911756739, 0.015507007017731667, -0.004269680008292198, 0.030359191820025444, -0.02532515674829483, -0.028246674686670303, -0.022286614403128624, -0.011381315998733044, 0.02733708545565605, -0.03510493412613869, -0.006787309888750315, -0.05845533311367035, -0.01848071813583374, 0.0428742989897728, 0.003989893011748791, 0.004881555680185556, 0.028397878631949425, -0.01222783513367176, 0.022649837657809258, -0.00735078752040863, -0.010929491370916367, -0.07949721068143845, -0.04129929840564728, -0.0618271678686142, -0.002510418649762869, -0.029832249507308006, -0.039558522403240204, 0.02573518082499504, 0.07458662986755371, -0.0319167897105217, -0.03887774050235748, -0.02917734533548355, 0.04120683670043945, 0.05775768309831619, -0.07554725557565689, -0.02094143256545067, 0.014908920042216778, -0.03279730677604675, 0.018232159316539764, 0.014438945800065994, -0.06329850107431412, -0.012741316109895706, 0.024766799062490463, -0.031649746000766754, 0.023279331624507904, 0.0077029746025800705, 0.035995978862047195, 0.015067030675709248, 0.025817109271883965, 0.05707932263612747, 0.01067026425153017, 0.011927414685487747, -0.02616223506629467, -0.007592133246362209, -0.0018793678609654307, -0.09260327368974686, -0.022692689672112465, 0.05201994255185127, -0.03164047747850418, 0.0537450946867466, 0.042222511023283005, -0.020793689414858818, -0.0250962283462286, -0.05044533312320709, 0.003291929606348276, -0.014040558598935604, 0.06168566271662712, 0.024587145075201988, -0.03227989003062248, 0.004348582588136196, 0.038434457033872604, -0.043314795941114426, 0.01997370645403862, -0.004218575078994036, -0.05325036868453026, -0.0391414575278759, -0.06296226382255554, -0.008597680367529392, 0.007596070412546396, 0.04472022503614426, -0.03703276813030243, 0.02355596236884594, 0.012391388416290283, -0.06250926852226257, 0.03456637263298035, 0.037971653044223785, -0.010102206841111183, 0.011097186245024204, -0.008750741370022297, 0.05291799455881119, 0.041251711547374725, -0.02444296143949032, 0.013161219656467438, -0.012062537483870983, -0.013799594715237617, -0.001960545079782605, -0.05884155258536339, 0.07475820183753967, -0.005094487220048904, 0.056419454514980316, -0.035605669021606445, -0.029608823359012604, -0.026358192786574364, -0.01450808160007, -0.04979442059993744, -0.0033389225136488676, -0.009163892827928066, 0.04942611977458, 0.028331521898508072, -0.029089609161019325, 0.043711524456739426, 0.0182169359177351, 0.00845413189381361, -0.011977043934166431, 0.011454245075583458, 0.05673692747950554, 0.01186116598546505, -0.030525971204042435, -0.05076069384813309, 0.09121537208557129, 0.005030598025768995, -0.08287309855222702, 0.02450402081012726, 0.01341363973915577, -0.008808035403490067, -0.02580895647406578, -0.016065070405602455, 0.00012239461648277938, 0.03679482266306877, -0.010087951086461544, -0.004181837663054466, -0.011752935126423836, -0.013966712169349194, -0.0325678251683712, 0.044143255800008774, -0.0018956232815980911, -0.028947602957487106, -0.06426414847373962, -0.02921520546078682, -0.028965622186660767, -0.05916071683168411, 0.004006591625511646, 0.053817056119441986, 0.016316769644618034, 0.045764271169900894, -0.019500592723488808, -0.011337189003825188, -0.03126220777630806, -0.00008300817717099562, -0.08636093884706497, 0.009785511530935764, 0.07136348634958267, -0.00459497282281518, -0.05659351497888565, -0.08946619927883148, -0.04304823279380798, -0.0243112500756979, -0.062080755829811096, -0.05819312483072281, -0.005265001207590103, -0.045424290001392365, 0.017817853018641472, 0.022267064079642296, -0.0846777930855751, -0.001918417983688414, -0.06476948410272598, 0.03666474670171738, -0.01247278694063425, -0.03692879155278206, 0.011003575287759304, 0.03802906349301338, -0.06769175082445145, -0.02283037081360817, 0.057738158851861954, -0.00023523181152995676, 0.054054584354162216, -0.03595077991485596, 0.05720138922333717, 0.007180188316851854, -0.12261104583740234, 0.03246774896979332, 0.012590063735842705, 0.01716601476073265, 0.03312426805496216, -0.0034351993817836046, -0.03970934823155403, -0.007711518090218306, -0.03809095174074173, 0.05205926299095154, 0.07526570558547974, -0.012049798853695393, -0.026395590975880623, -0.036020033061504364, -0.00459245964884758, -0.02228015661239624, -0.035640109330415726, -0.06845834851264954, -0.016036488115787506, -0.010119185782968998, -0.036135926842689514, -0.000849022704642266, -0.03335331007838249, -0.04859912395477295, -0.07317928969860077, -0.05458840727806091, 0.0497150719165802, -0.04974134638905525, -0.009054313413798809, -0.007384876720607281, -0.03728562965989113, -0.0067302510142326355, -0.03479588404297829, -0.003036245470866561, 0.05757192522287369, -0.05052851885557175, -0.015618768520653248, -0.022573111578822136, 0.025128468871116638, 0.06851319968700409, -0.05293702334165573, 0.046597376465797424, 0.006161267403513193, 0.00355584267526865, -0.013274019584059715, 0.020087236538529396, -0.04750370606780052, -0.031133027747273445, -0.004728040657937527, 0.0016824364429339767, -0.00907236896455288, -0.016423750668764114, -0.015492944978177547, 0.009127975441515446, 0.01773870177567005, 0.012870890088379383, 0.050291456282138824, -0.0019724289886653423, 0.027166422456502914, 0.05037664994597435, 0.05694282054901123, -0.003672286868095398, 0.023227808997035027, -0.023395732045173645, 0.02450614981353283, -0.007462338078767061, 0.000812023296020925, -0.04882879555225372, 0.018986059352755547, 0.056921422481536865, 0.010107772424817085, -0.034804318100214005, -0.050684086978435516, -0.005234793294221163, -0.027781972661614418, -0.018817810341715813, -0.004535417538136244, 0.004433140624314547, -0.04888056591153145, -0.03400440141558647, 0.007862868718802929, -0.018951229751110077, 0.004831135272979736, -0.053574953228235245, -0.040270667523145676, -0.024516286328434944, 0.029944967478513718, 0.014720536768436432, -0.02653818391263485, -0.08586104959249496, -0.019236596301198006, -0.023252271115779877, -0.016762034967541695, -0.042140837758779526, -0.028272980824112892, 0.0010607766453176737, 0.04022212699055672, -0.0362696535885334, -0.02091413363814354, 0.0072382232174277306, 0.03090905211865902, 0.03803618624806404, -0.017540208995342255, -0.014586074277758598, 0.012286418117582798, -0.006310618482530117, -0.021423542872071266, 0.022296199575066566, -0.02977338805794716, -0.02052837610244751, 0.06866386532783508, -0.022649528458714485, -0.01572403870522976, -0.023025618866086006, -0.015375140123069286, -0.00406474806368351, -0.0339917354285717, -0.05622562766075134, -0.0016265964368358254, 0.059937164187431335, 0.07181668281555176, -0.01946650817990303, 0.010531633161008358, -0.0012003692099824548, -0.007308924570679665, 0.04842472821474075, -0.01263140793889761, -0.0633852407336235, 0.015384760685265064, -0.08328953385353088, 0.01959090307354927, 0.02165592461824417, 0.05108265578746796, -0.0168877262622118, 0.011082766577601433, -0.03167276456952095, -0.02725713886320591, -0.0038946704007685184, 0.025420764461159706, 0.002891266020014882, 0.029634980484843254, 0.041189391165971756, -0.0035584992729127407, 0.04353022575378418, -0.04473801702260971, -0.06160368397831917, 0.003290985943749547, 0.03297742083668709, 0.03519522026181221, 0.027565790340304375, -0.00035765927168540657, -0.04340237006545067, -0.0005980824935249984, -0.05894680321216583, 0.09162821620702744, 0.023440254852175713, -0.021661866456270218, 0.04613180458545685, 0.004974390380084515, -0.001000531599856913, -0.014411679469048977, 0.0454198457300663, 0.030632244423031807, -0.031574442982673645, 0.05077899247407913, -0.046057503670454025, 0.013701383955776691, -0.020091209560632706, -0.07612046599388123, 0.028080491349101067, 0.052162449806928635, -0.005265399347990751, 0.027621597051620483, -0.06468606740236282, -0.01042037084698677, 0.001930256374180317, -0.048067376017570496, -0.00034884799970313907, -0.06440198421478271, -0.06310958415269852, 0.02238689921796322, 0.005820279475301504, 0.022464219480752945, 0.008072053082287312, 0.031762801110744476, -0.01122998632490635, -0.019793353974819183, -0.06304227560758591, -0.002069099573418498, -0.03034202940762043, 0.0036228089593350887, -0.02300419844686985, -0.06264417618513107, 0.0643387958407402, -0.03838010132312775, -0.003465926507487893, -0.03877914696931839, -0.033004216849803925, 0.006964018102735281, -0.030984317883849144, 0.024422721937298775, -0.03794341906905174, 0.01996702142059803, -0.08583755046129227, 0.0320931114256382, -0.05114531144499779, 0.025754060596227646, -0.0342542789876461, -0.00506705092266202, -0.02886711247265339, 0.02668355219066143, 0.05229124799370766, 0.028863966464996338, -0.0033991949167102575, -0.02591235749423504, 0.014487704262137413, 0.051923274993896484, 0.012478532269597054, 0.02449696511030197, 0.014155480079352856, 0.009966288693249226, -0.0019644598942250013, -0.04676111415028572, 0.030441878363490105, -0.013359319418668747, 0.05101894959807396, -0.047230299562215805, -0.021237686276435852, -0.026011226698756218, 0.04937531426548958, -0.049463529139757156, -0.024473996832966805, 0.03484538570046425, 0.0013392092660069466, -0.029264234006404877, -0.02517949976027012, -0.015019177459180355, 0.004149134736508131, -0.021019984036684036, 0.00040339212864637375, 0.03591302037239075, -0.042502302676439285, 0.054724860936403275, -0.005078500602394342, 0.060466039925813675, -0.0011009506415575743, -0.02132372371852398, -0.007181480061262846, -0.02099495381116867, 0.016143037006258965, -0.03775189071893692, 0.03027837909758091, -0.0026342691853642464, 0.06845707446336746, 0.015690868720412254, 0.00567166693508625, -0.08935960382223129, 0.018352651968598366, 0.023935968056321144, -0.040069062262773514, 0.04113943874835968, 0.0391806922852993, -0.008105849847197533, 0.04999036714434624, -0.050648629665374756, -0.040282487869262695, 0.026981711387634277, 0.02823689952492714, 0.018207380548119545, 0.014731144532561302, 0.00234596966765821, 0.024095896631479263, 0.0342421792447567, 0.020021826028823853, -0.007011563051491976, -0.04134879261255264, 0.012430986389517784, -0.013410796411335468, -0.07334855943918228, 0.0006505128112621605, 0.042142245918512344, -0.01602182537317276, 0.013165781274437904, 0.07146108150482178, -0.027840226888656616, -0.011038962751626968, 0.04471122846007347, -0.010876936838030815, 0.02253136597573757, 0.04260629788041115, -0.038282088935375214, -0.016733884811401367, 0.09042581170797348, 0.03382690250873566, -0.008315837942063808, 0.006241460330784321, 0.0430079847574234, -0.043219566345214844, 0.02065294049680233, -0.03350415080785751, -0.0163588747382164, 0.015048819594085217, 0.042735543102025986, 0.028307493776082993, 0.008855011314153671, -0.040464453399181366, 0.013256048783659935, -0.03177012503147125, 0.0027908477932214737, -0.011917712166905403, -0.02792707271873951, 0.024829687550663948, -0.029732631519436836, 0.03850076347589493, 0.011619149707257748, 0.041548747569322586, -0.04787718132138252, 0.05890873447060585, -0.02667827531695366, -0.002933918498456478, 0.024515442550182343, -0.05491901561617851, -0.011325578205287457, 0.013167010620236397, 0.00784645788371563, -0.04507855698466301, 0.042684879153966904, 0.007339598145335913, -0.022158440202474594, 0.033310115337371826, -0.03835522010922432, -0.037259865552186966, -0.05331960320472717, -0.06142616271972656, 0.10133063048124313, -0.03886961564421654, 0.044035475701093674, -0.049468252807855606, -0.026769911870360374, -0.018650680780410767, -0.05409364402294159, -0.0002860606473404914, 0.060449838638305664, -0.04768715053796768, -0.03122691623866558, 0.04238344728946686, -0.02253461815416813, -0.06484922766685486, -0.018702475354075432, 0.01196335256099701, -0.060244370251894, 0.011123958975076675, 0.010313844308257103, -0.01946897991001606, 0.005109528079628944, 0.03807525336742401, 0.050025053322315216, 0.013717692345380783, -0.02186502330005169, 0.0767500251531601, 0.07433004677295685, 0.0012174197472631931, -0.011728351935744286, -0.006848582532256842, -0.027215350419282913, -0.00451680039986968, -0.023899633437395096, -0.04001515731215477, 0.00426635704934597, 0.00673168757930398, 0.005131435114890337, -0.0009117720765061677, -0.001920578652061522, 0.07827792316675186, -0.04230789467692375, 0.029264770448207855, 0.0024797709193080664, -0.03202810510993004, 0.01432786788791418, -0.036862876266241074, -0.019993513822555542, -0.02039129100739956, -0.02550719492137432, -0.01903628557920456, -0.005275505594909191, -0.04022558405995369, -0.03361378237605095, 0.0017689429223537445, 0.023385630920529366, -0.02167617715895176, 0.00714260246604681, 0.031053295359015465, -0.031722377985715866, -0.026273872703313828, -0.023941658437252045, -0.019923698157072067, 0.00933234766125679, -0.027280956506729126, 0.019172584637999535, 0.06615251302719116, -0.0038196712266653776, 0.00947557669132948, 0.01842828094959259, 0.02383146621286869, 0.02600342035293579, -0.022340787574648857, -0.03836553543806076, 0.022495880722999573, 0.030725883319973946, -0.059938833117485046, 0.0282872524112463, 0.03145963326096535, -0.005253299605101347, 0.03419186547398567, -0.006891663186252117, -0.04824824631214142, -0.010819921270012856, -0.002642157720401883, -0.03836509585380554, 0.019342796877026558, 0.016645165160298347, -0.034857675433158875, -0.04301584139466286, 0.020782340317964554, 0.008749239146709442, 0.020797686651349068, 0.014770892448723316, 0.007724950090050697, 0.006567928474396467, -0.03904949128627777, 0.045319583266973495, 0.01318549457937479, 0.0015479687135666609, -0.00960273016244173, -0.050401296466588974, -0.0014602538431063294, 0.00041394116124138236, 0.0006233751773834229, -0.01879069022834301, 0.028983483090996742, -0.03277475759387016, -0.01493089459836483, 0.0042555853724479675, -0.005044156219810247, -0.0016577474307268858, -0.02309737727046013, -0.0568663515150547, 0.031762927770614624, -0.049011245369911194, -0.039479851722717285, -0.08724448084831238, 0.048383746296167374, 0.0071815368719398975, -0.00984328705817461, -0.01065565925091505, 0.006471996661275625, -0.04997728765010834, -0.02056344784796238, -0.0663059651851654, 0.02708980068564415, -0.035248253494501114, 0.05493193119764328, -0.01913181133568287, 0.004699222277849913, 0.045963939279317856, -0.05014285817742348, 0.031592246145009995, 0.030752699822187424, -0.011426196433603764, -0.02777118608355522, 0.035659272223711014, -0.01401518378406763, -0.04019572213292122, -0.016885550692677498, 0.08740764856338501, -0.008226464502513409, 0.03264886513352394, 0.07177960872650146, -0.0006199263734742999, -0.02172461897134781, 0.0483667254447937, -0.0005383052630349994, -0.0003986503870692104, 0.062013179063797, -0.06244192644953728, -0.031046414747834206, -0.07024727761745453, -0.06908845156431198, -0.015925418585538864, -0.06592576950788498, 0.03167608752846718, 0.054743193089962006, 0.02710757404565811, -0.011833444237709045, -0.02441730536520481, -0.02555936761200428, 0.018826089799404144, -0.0628916397690773, -0.06040550395846367, 0.050637491047382355, -0.042366255074739456, -0.006236061453819275, 0.012443268671631813, 0.016031639650464058, -0.05337831377983093, -0.0029777330346405506, 0.06642881035804749, -0.021520361304283142, 0.03443590924143791, -0.037305284291505814, 0.043988581746816635, -0.0506252720952034, 0.02628319524228573, -0.037862516939640045, 0.06054970249533653, -0.03198947012424469, -0.006129880901426077, -0.07483414560556412, -0.028364147990942, -0.0022710594348609447, -0.0966596007347107, -0.004636306315660477, -0.005320372525602579, 0.04370645433664322, 0.01588791236281395, 0.01724565401673317, -0.004031200427561998, -0.006597692146897316, 0.04310983046889305, 0.0731649175286293, 0.006015565246343613, -0.0171361044049263, -0.06657937914133072, 0.002875256584957242, -0.02098446525633335, -0.00010023149661719799, -0.005923831835389137, 0.04548078030347824, -0.030769357457756996, 0.024103883653879166, -0.053347114473581314, 0.004032769240438938, -0.006747748702764511, -0.0383106954395771, 0.015800723806023598, 0.03756486251950264, -0.04751916229724884, -0.06064348667860031, -0.0008465712890028954, 0.006927774287760258, -0.004656694829463959, -0.04750895872712135 ]
Most modern ticketing systems rely on a first-come-first-serve or randomized allocation system to determine the allocation of tickets. Such systems has received considerable backlash in recent years due to its inequitable allotment and allocative inefficiency. We analyze a ticketing protocol based on a variation of the marginal price auction system. Users submit bids to the protocol based on their own utilities. The protocol awards tickets to the highest bidders and determines the final ticket price paid by all bidders using the lowest winning submitted bid. Game theoretic proof is provided to ensure the protocol more efficiently allocates the tickets to the bidders with the highest utilities. We also prove that the protocol extracts more economic rents for the event organizers and the non-optimality of ticket scalping under time-invariant bidder utilities.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11189v1
[ -0.03437270596623421, -0.045327190309762955, 0.014077947475016117, 0.06473876535892487, 0.01830580085515976, -0.0428008958697319, 0.0027114623226225376, -0.001720610773190856, 0.013038672506809235, -0.01102111954241991, -0.028065275400877, 0.02885301411151886, -0.033070407807826996, -0.05201615020632744, -0.0519368015229702, 0.020805418491363525, 0.09069081395864487, 0.019419459626078606, -0.03008204512298107, 0.04220108315348625, -0.01695692166686058, 0.008357641287147999, 0.0374114066362381, 0.051326509565114975, 0.0025702156126499176, -0.0039012464694678783, -0.046621132642030716, -0.016266757622361183, -0.06477668136358261, 0.00794911477714777, 0.037701480090618134, -0.0462857261300087, -0.02714722603559494, -0.029577359557151794, -0.010627279058098793, -0.0010344742331653833, 0.012519468553364277, -0.011989696882665157, -0.034104734659194946, -0.028218580409884453, 0.0337977260351181, -0.079470194876194, -0.05628348886966705, -0.015113315545022488, 0.024486379697918892, -0.010435285046696663, -0.07508357614278793, 0.028793146833777428, -0.06336832046508789, 0.004795838613063097, 0.010246622376143932, -0.04448191821575165, -0.002409011824056506, -0.0026659013237804174, -0.011023260653018951, -0.029839446768164635, -0.0004443603102117777, 0.05545710399746895, -0.05505593866109848, -0.01688423566520214, -0.036411162465810776, 0.026446348056197166, 0.019026337191462517, -0.021536029875278473, -0.0194950420409441, 0.05725885555148125, -0.02423490583896637, -0.06373515725135803, -0.05485345795750618, -0.017507631331682205, 0.053148914128541946, -0.037513989955186844, 0.012743466533720493, 0.013206996023654938, -0.03373435139656067, -0.034294258803129196, -0.006814010441303253, 0.01839454472064972, 0.03382390737533569, -0.004649302456527948, -0.031341202557086945, 0.029936600476503372, -0.032743219286203384, 0.019242942333221436, -0.026099009439349174, 0.04003714397549629, 0.06665392965078354, -0.005687958560883999, 0.06246500462293625, -0.03663041815161705, 0.016401654109358788, -0.03464871644973755, -0.0642373189330101, -0.007313238922506571, 0.04476876184344292, -0.05529237166047096, 0.06396672874689102, 0.06648086756467819, 0.01056811586022377, 0.01696774922311306, -0.010076044127345085, 0.017528865486383438, -0.051584791392087936, 0.03429768607020378, 0.006541933864355087, -0.005365579389035702, 0.03623771294951439, 0.00844044890254736, -0.003949563950300217, 0.02387825958430767, -0.01882447674870491, -0.05937787517905235, 0.04679833725094795, -0.051550496369600296, -0.044483285397291183, 0.020884377881884575, 0.04152403399348259, -0.028697336092591286, 0.05858490243554115, 0.0003940888855140656, -0.014012826606631279, -0.002877461723983288, 0.03801318630576134, -0.02613949403166771, -0.0534772090613842, -0.025777986273169518, -0.0013487973483279347, 0.019538214430212975, -0.019511952996253967, 0.02346036396920681, -0.007468888536095619, 0.03663289546966553, 0.014976881444454193, -0.029082566499710083, 0.04861423373222351, 0.04082082211971283, 0.013382275588810444, -0.04602164775133133, 0.03203776106238365, -0.03537517413496971, -0.060763511806726456, -0.02399149164557457, 0.029578683897852898, 0.026775259524583817, 0.013786586932837963, 0.05706709995865822, 0.02680402621626854, 0.006032487843185663, -0.03931088373064995, 0.0005750463460572064, 0.03985779359936714, 0.03748112544417381, 0.0035147415474057198, -0.002997470321133733, 0.027402248233556747, 0.004970667418092489, 0.06223323568701744, -0.02085677534341812, -0.06411708891391754, 0.05999742075800896, 0.0008606454939581454, -0.0021913766395300627, -0.005425752140581608, -0.043953269720077515, 0.014203041791915894, 0.030302338302135468, 0.07114472985267639, 0.01143447495996952, 0.003087694523856044, -0.02192569710314274, -0.016603775322437286, 0.05836942419409752, 0.0067643066868186, -0.03592779487371445, -0.05834121257066727, -0.03608742356300354, -0.007657266687601805, -0.04165266454219818, -0.02102944441139698, -0.05613647773861885, -0.023072008043527603, 0.049326516687870026, -0.05836012214422226, 0.032195959240198135, -0.019755948334932327, 0.015451176092028618, -0.08148601651191711, 0.027328994125127792, 0.013727941550314426, 0.02428160421550274, -0.026239942759275436, -0.03538782149553299, -0.03005543164908886, -0.0023468537256121635, -0.013855457305908203, -0.042640890926122665, 0.012311005964875221, -0.001783061889000237, -0.015118089504539967, 0.005511333234608173, -0.05954715237021446, 0.0066252355463802814, -0.07767891883850098, 0.0027819571550935507, -0.04455499351024628, -0.0404626689851284, 0.0173769723623991, 0.026942167431116104, -0.06087176129221916, 0.006941443774849176, -0.02604909986257553, 0.07174327969551086, 0.026461323723196983, -0.0038614217191934586, 0.016838418319821358, -0.0020552058704197407, -0.10186026990413666, 0.030971160158514977, -0.0030116180423647165, 0.02416439726948738, 0.0020310652907937765, 0.007079864852130413, -0.0629057064652443, 0.016940776258707047, -0.01883362978696823, 0.04148351028561592, 0.00946817733347416, -0.05680606886744499, -0.04016370698809624, 0.0013663643039762974, -0.0007209189934656024, -0.021768413484096527, -0.003286511404439807, -0.0746845155954361, 0.02965405210852623, 0.03658641502261162, 0.020607907325029373, 0.010545004159212112, 0.021525191143155098, -0.013807143084704876, -0.060611847788095474, -0.056972306221723557, 0.057104501873254776, -0.018464449793100357, -0.018977588042616844, -0.06815086305141449, -0.04104416072368622, -0.043865881860256195, -0.008840839378535748, 0.049468331038951874, -0.002278228523209691, 0.02343236841261387, -0.011131935752928257, -0.03942233696579933, 0.015765110030770302, -0.0026261203456670046, 0.014419985935091972, 0.03056545928120613, -0.005650101229548454, 0.010240796953439713, 0.005542292259633541, 0.01464951504021883, -0.05224241316318512, 0.02973363921046257, 0.06750010699033737, -0.017962686717510223, 0.020718611776828766, -0.0029430054128170013, 0.0485917404294014, -0.04304696246981621, 0.005516916047781706, 0.004084727261215448, 0.024697164073586464, -0.04806302487850189, 0.05537322536110878, -0.04547471925616264, -0.007235209923237562, -0.01797320507466793, 0.010300378315150738, 0.02497391775250435, 0.054021477699279785, 0.03196239471435547, 0.07301778346300125, -0.07567620277404785, 0.030740078538656235, -0.029881693422794342, 0.01172531396150589, -0.07084506005048752, -0.07121822237968445, -0.04069144278764725, -0.060772448778152466, 0.02235334925353527, -0.054067108780145645, 0.011457179673016071, -0.043029963970184326, -0.014891580678522587, -0.03975759074091911, 0.004219334572553635, -0.017501596361398697, 0.012722142040729523, -0.08219743520021439, -0.059416431933641434, 0.04610598459839821, 0.009220287203788757, -0.0012308239238336682, -0.024599479511380196, -0.001023836899548769, -0.037554383277893066, 0.029803503304719925, -0.02694079838693142, 0.008341057226061821, -0.015674356371164322, 0.0032484987750649452, 0.04124169424176216, -0.02472694404423237, -0.05914827808737755, 0.03299069404602051, 0.004644246771931648, -0.059390272945165634, -0.015425159595906734, 0.006946135312318802, 0.02301613800227642, -0.016283979639410973, -0.028936313465237617, -0.05686957761645317, -0.059983186423778534, 0.024860074743628502, -0.016402672976255417, -0.02200743556022644, -0.07763516902923584, 0.018696242943406105, -0.02531563676893711, 0.004799090791493654, -0.0390826091170311, 0.04127549007534981, 0.026249030604958534, -0.007372882682830095, -0.05662134662270546, -0.026042841374874115, -0.013300897553563118, -0.060500260442495346, 0.0778120681643486, -0.0002638415026012808, 0.055574383586645126, 0.05344593524932861, -0.0734318271279335, 0.04579727724194527, 0.017825322225689888, 0.0718875527381897, -0.03825822100043297, 0.011859427206218243, 0.004818797577172518, -0.05078557878732681, -0.005375644192099571, 0.0585525706410408, -0.01735076680779457, 0.062388159334659576, 0.04091319441795349, -0.02500353939831257, -0.06566257774829865, -0.0011709985556080937, -0.05936112627387047, -0.0398792140185833, -0.002775344764813781, -0.004357052035629749, 0.033249858766794205, -0.00551261380314827, -0.0067175631411373615, 0.01727943681180477, -0.0384313240647316, 0.03323621675372124, 0.008057964034378529, -0.014875526539981365, 0.028934888541698456, -0.02399682067334652, 0.029381297528743744, 0.0415571928024292, 0.008680297061800957, 0.04338939115405083, -0.023161286488175392, -0.0007447567186318338, -0.0720386952161789, -0.0020744323264807463, -0.02108747698366642, -0.04876809939742088, -0.04082346335053444, 0.060615286231040955, -0.01725964993238449, 0.048155032098293304, -0.026890328153967857, -0.0028507192619144917, -0.047516174614429474, 0.014117300510406494, -0.008555618114769459, -0.028261633589863777, -0.0016925572417676449, 0.015472779050469398, 0.0204215906560421, -0.01335563138127327, -0.031686339527368546, -0.022111840546131134, 0.019026614725589752, -0.019244281575083733, -0.07751739770174026, 0.07887284457683563, -0.004860876593738794, 0.03128455951809883, 0.048355501145124435, -0.030795231461524963, 0.07222786545753479, -0.013588418252766132, 0.007437820080667734, -0.09122338145971298, -0.04884004592895508, -0.009079355746507645, -0.05803363025188446, -0.01425107941031456, -0.02907680906355381, 0.046944182366132736, 0.008635133504867554, 0.011203558184206486, -0.02195676788687706, 0.031175723299384117, -0.06793319433927536, -0.06291969865560532, 0.01762017048895359, 0.04876524955034256, 0.055472612380981445, 0.03914046660065651, -0.005113193765282631, -0.022207491099834442, 0.0058534713461995125, -0.005835267249494791, -0.007894464768469334, -0.07309402525424957, -0.06553183495998383, 0.05182163417339325, -0.03703170642256737, 0.023807695135474205, 0.032622259110212326, -0.010202627629041672, 0.07386953383684158, -0.040738094598054886, -0.03997974842786789, -0.058755964040756226, 0.011205757036805153, -0.055726055055856705, -0.0693923830986023, -0.04818986356258392, -0.05042702332139015, -0.00038538320222869515, -0.005577226169407368, -0.03066411428153515, 0.02196813002228737, 0.01395520567893982, 0.014477623626589775, 0.04515867680311203, 0.010091925039887428, -0.016133787110447884, 0.005632030311971903, 0.012265056371688843, -0.0019399533048272133, -0.06328718364238739, -0.0002938725519925356, -0.02308559976518154, -0.015235071070492268, -0.02534439042210579, 0.012007142417132854, -0.04824184253811836, 0.06425151973962784, -0.035370729863643646, 0.01606977917253971, -0.08583958446979523, -0.008158482611179352, 0.05779261142015457, 0.014267410151660442, 0.0445825569331646, 0.04970010742545128, -0.02426777221262455, -0.002981289755553007, -0.03753232955932617, 0.017531905323266983, 0.05042973905801773, -0.01866486296057701, 0.0019563655368983746, 0.0032993946224451065, -0.030800294131040573, 0.026061084121465683, 0.06487543880939484, -0.016467344015836716, -0.05628632381558418, -0.01809580810368061, 0.04000338539481163, -0.044785019010305405, -0.04113692790269852, 0.013518108054995537, -0.004407265689224005, -0.07469936460256577, 0.013854575343430042, 0.023389287292957306, -0.028704265132546425, -0.010166713036596775, 0.032480183988809586, -0.023936057463288307, -0.0034931483678519726, 0.037581007927656174, -0.006115269381552935, -0.009840589016675949, 0.054437171667814255, -0.02854401245713234, 0.009904141537845135, 0.025173749774694443, 0.012563210912048817, -0.04937301203608513, 0.03812243416905403, 0.03214537724852562, 0.03744784742593765, 0.014932333491742611, 0.03724716231226921, -0.013652932830154896, -0.05664047226309776, -0.02693309262394905, -0.044967908412218094, -0.015218011103570461, -0.017778821289539337, 0.018451770767569542, -0.00469125434756279, 0.021025484427809715, -0.009414739906787872, 0.004573489539325237, 0.008861090987920761, -0.02735568955540657, 0.01734744757413864, -0.011795353144407272, -0.036270253360271454, 0.02409529872238636, 0.04768584296107292, -0.0038599318359047174, -0.044731397181749344, 0.024090096354484558, 0.05335191637277603, -0.06388014554977417, 0.029142707586288452, 0.05130535736680031, -0.004232076462358236, -0.04367789253592491, -0.01475390326231718, 0.03279599919915199, 0.018040960654616356, 0.029239065945148468, 0.03054443746805191, -0.05149325728416443, 0.007799013052135706, -0.06416885554790497, -0.014523232355713844, -0.04073378071188927, -0.012511364184319973, -0.009236953221261501, 0.0382644459605217, -0.04085052013397217, -0.0669918805360794, 0.024112774059176445, 0.01583469845354557, -0.04479670524597168, -0.025733163580298424, 0.041667740792036057, -0.06441148370504379, 0.004152493551373482, 0.04118282347917557, 0.012419271282851696, 0.0037071211263537407, 0.03133878856897354, -0.022439267486333847, -0.0009192536235786974, -0.03623539209365845, 0.02709181234240532, 0.07801363617181778, -0.022208435460925102, -0.01329157967120409, 0.04331304505467415, -0.06893149763345718, 0.02882523462176323, 0.012681812979280949, 0.04622118920087814, 0.000007337532224482857, 0.03795551136136055, -0.012796025723218918, -0.02782505936920643, -0.050281740725040436, 0.07164798676967621, -0.043245621025562286, -0.027807218953967094, -0.03502826765179634, -0.03081277199089527, 0.03478884696960449, -0.014379636384546757, -0.035323724150657654, -0.04109521955251694, 0.02069348469376564, -0.039588067680597305, -0.022195763885974884, 0.0038798723835498095, -0.018878361210227013, -0.016764359548687935, 0.031455326825380325, -0.03862645849585533, 0.031041720882058144, -0.003805257147178054, -0.02333010733127594, -0.00536224665120244, -0.043035466223955154, -0.0008910781471058726, -0.01345848385244608, 0.03449397534132004, 0.00894775241613388, 0.06449317932128906, -0.020158857107162476, 0.0513254776597023, 0.030304573476314545, -0.03191941976547241, -0.002659675432369113, 0.013668766245245934, -0.011431243270635605, 0.03228366747498512, 0.048998039215803146, 0.0025123553350567818, 0.0011803422821685672, -0.012181167490780354, -0.011304675601422787, 0.0276890117675066, -0.011415384709835052, -0.02798302099108696, -0.02332725003361702, 0.034318916499614716, -0.018302639946341515, -0.029018666595220566, 0.018475431948900223, 0.05761119723320007, -0.06547920405864716, 0.0006731937173753977, -0.023772023618221283, 0.013492903672158718, -0.013220502994954586, 0.0634080097079277, 0.01999855414032936, -0.0021176973823457956, 0.033991213887929916, 0.022273937240242958, 0.04868502914905548, 0.011647909879684448, -0.03432975709438324, -0.06069329380989075, -0.017889611423015594, -0.00926318857818842, -0.04802773892879486, -0.04524373635649681, -0.06306270509958267, -0.06467687338590622, 0.0651295855641365, 0.04928193613886833, -0.058829598128795624, -0.018874501809477806, -0.07561857253313065, 0.028088470920920372, -0.00746541004627943, -0.023990130051970482, -0.029998455196619034, 0.01445511169731617, 0.05059269815683365, -0.02572917938232422, -0.026181379333138466, -0.002143119927495718, -0.045902613550424576, -0.058852843940258026, -0.08191897720098495, 0.02862892672419548, 0.02829161286354065, 0.029997963458299637, -0.01911744847893715, 0.01511515025049448, -0.03862232714891434, -0.0409444160759449, 0.02968035638332367, 0.009404229931533337, -0.027987614274024963, -0.00044665188761428, 0.025190098211169243, 0.000389611697755754, -0.05010635405778885, -0.025429164990782738, 0.0390719436109066, -0.011262563988566399, 0.03856434300541878, 0.018634594976902008, 0.02983992174267769, 0.05060984939336777, -0.01121619064360857, 0.006428879220038652, 0.017199736088514328, 0.039221763610839844, -0.05101129412651062, 0.004325993824750185, -0.02122267708182335, -0.023421309888362885, 0.014189108274877071, -0.06220090016722679, -0.00373154878616333, 0.01565781608223915, 0.001256802468560636, 0.01816612295806408, -0.014801098965108395, -0.04891581833362579, 0.04169589281082153, -0.03776615858078003, 0.02165188081562519, -0.001066615805029869, 0.0038545008283108473, 0.007907029241323471, -0.030050991103053093, -0.014747418463230133, 0.001473316689953208, 0.05971042066812515, 0.0056265052407979965, -0.03135392442345619, 0.010060827247798443, -0.03609304502606392, -0.010564910247921944, -0.026313994079828262, 0.0374995581805706, -0.02653883583843708, 0.05066521093249321, -0.002259459113702178, -0.006316193379461765, 0.0036836559884250164, -0.04924614727497101, -0.04927720129489899, -0.07730819284915924, -0.045055437833070755, -0.018780510872602463, 0.015799613669514656, 0.019791191443800926, 0.07566370069980621, 0.03211744874715805, -0.012240349315106869, -0.0019126269035041332, 0.01991092972457409, -0.018397176638245583, -0.0030012622009962797, -0.05817102640867233, 0.07522615790367126, -0.026171116158366203, 0.004626493435353041, -0.004909188952296972, 0.013726511970162392, 0.0038623318541795015, 0.038788340985774994, -0.03057526797056198, 0.00114259694237262, 0.019573817029595375, -0.01346814725548029, 0.024710867553949356, 0.06615499407052994, -0.016305776312947273, -0.04574805125594139, -0.0162107702344656, 0.021329179406166077, -0.03516165912151337, 0.007170527707785368 ]
We show that for $1\leq p, q<\infty$ with $p/q \notin \mathbb{N}$, the doubly atomless separable $L_pL_q$ Banach lattice $L_p(L_q)$ is approximately ultrahomogeneous (AUH) over the class of its finitely generated sublattices. The above is not true when $p/q \in \mathbb{N}$. However, for any $p\neq q$, $L_p(L_q)$ is AUH over the finitely generated lattices in the class $BL_pL_q$ of bands of $L_pL_q$ lattices.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10297v1
[ -0.06524873524904251, -0.021462149918079376, 0.014147921465337276, -0.016091903671622276, 0.035565588623285294, -0.04292957857251167, -0.06083044409751892, -0.004937730263918638, -0.049001727253198624, -0.05540209263563156, -0.006768462713807821, -0.05256308615207672, -0.011956362053751945, -0.061792075634002686, -0.030279170721769333, -0.024472814053297043, 0.006739381700754166, 0.04636054113507271, -0.02429893985390663, 0.05927495285868645, -0.01668577827513218, -0.05911370366811752, -0.04590732976794243, 0.035860732197761536, -0.013011405244469643, -0.03430795669555664, -0.03441745787858963, -0.04007435590028763, -0.05549613758921623, -0.046891167759895325, 0.0562778078019619, -0.028686784207820892, -0.03208304941654205, -0.05653238296508789, -0.01675247587263584, 0.03858185186982155, 0.02269495651125908, 0.03651141747832298, 0.003109895158559084, -0.01652531512081623, 0.022369567304849625, -0.07017868757247925, 0.003955231048166752, -0.06749411672353745, -0.0037700466345995665, -0.018184596672654152, -0.05166823789477348, 0.024477943778038025, -0.03589647635817528, -0.032145217061042786, 0.013793610967695713, -0.019728979095816612, 0.007109655532985926, -0.002107098000124097, -0.049965646117925644, -0.03755990043282509, 0.012400573119521141, 0.02527552843093872, -0.05221458896994591, -0.023106951266527176, -0.026164527982473373, -0.037324633449316025, -0.037225790321826935, -0.02896895259618759, -0.047331303358078, 0.013314938172698021, -0.03125550225377083, -0.05991321802139282, 0.05381388962268829, -0.029890073463320732, 0.008066615089774132, -0.025579437613487244, -0.022784259170293808, -0.007369943428784609, -0.057676177471876144, 0.03233569860458374, 0.0054467953741550446, 0.029510999098420143, 0.03904223069548607, 0.03893272578716278, -0.059176504611968994, -0.03559726104140282, -0.03001483716070652, -0.02421259693801403, 0.004107648506760597, -0.04403156414628029, 0.028161602094769478, -0.04764877259731293, -0.002833860693499446, -0.04802202060818672, 0.002927236258983612, -0.05277380347251892, -0.036322131752967834, -0.010761285200715065, 0.046166595071554184, -0.06076793745160103, -0.00040402202284894884, 0.030644431710243225, 0.023849403485655785, -0.0027074881363660097, 0.028743861243128777, -0.05911322683095932, -0.04684623330831528, 0.018462935462594032, -0.013090018182992935, -0.0010381728643551469, 0.006610667798668146, 0.023793112486600876, -0.052256111055612564, 0.04631777107715607, -0.01937766559422016, 0.003407815471291542, -0.05554302781820297, -0.03984791040420532, -0.05516218766570091, -0.05728452280163765, 0.05264882743358612, 0.027049578726291656, 0.030188558623194695, -0.015115358866751194, 0.050608791410923004, -0.007915537804365158, 0.017558962106704712, 0.02475489117205143, -0.029110709205269814, -0.03945513069629669, 0.0020832831505686045, -0.0253261998295784, 0.049988653510808945, 0.007385874167084694, -0.039921969175338745, -0.010329918935894966, 0.06632737070322037, 0.01048021949827671, 0.03236060589551926, -0.028807267546653748, 0.04812658578157425, -0.02980753406882286, 0.011826814152300358, 0.017898399382829666, -0.035377103835344315, -0.042446088045835495, 0.023029852658510208, 0.022154705598950386, 0.03478022664785385, 0.03909462317824364, -0.06733113527297974, 0.0523473285138607, -0.0026769109535962343, 0.03998180851340294, -0.015387814491987228, 0.06328646838665009, -0.01248516608029604, -0.03151638060808182, 0.006832823622971773, 0.025302771478891373, 0.0314134880900383, 0.01240491308271885, -0.012614469043910503, 0.005754441954195499, -0.005241459235548973, -0.0067605008371174335, -0.0587664395570755, 0.019323835149407387, 0.026555903255939484, 0.04113025218248367, -0.00854492373764515, 0.0017901974497362971, 0.03154507651925087, 0.004704292863607407, -0.021802259609103203, -0.02850702404975891, -0.031030191108584404, -0.06286487728357315, -0.05565141141414642, -0.036289531737565994, 0.008609490469098091, -0.0513087697327137, -0.010950773023068905, -0.039955418556928635, -0.011084535159170628, -0.0459786057472229, -0.034487828612327576, -0.022407615557312965, -0.05029970034956932, 0.031968265771865845, -0.020291490480303764, 0.05917127802968025, 0.0065381950698792934, 0.01800377480685711, 0.04186554625630379, -0.030994746834039688, 0.05476457253098488, -0.009295616298913956, -0.026409445330500603, -0.019162165001034737, -0.01913650520145893, -0.036743879318237305, -0.024937614798545837, 0.006585545372217894, -0.05035123974084854, -0.035747211426496506, -0.04788082465529442, 0.03377430886030197, -0.0030393211636692286, -0.0518779456615448, 0.025991708040237427, 0.049801263958215714, -0.005188758950680494, -0.06378160417079926, 0.05547643080353737, 0.04007613658905029, 0.02808482013642788, -0.03136943280696869, -0.05586983263492584, -0.04628482833504677, -0.07520494610071182, 0.05682466924190521, -0.049699511379003525, -0.01749798282980919, 0.037643998861312866, -0.018798887729644775, -0.05429556593298912, -0.027491459622979164, -0.06640858203172684, 0.020331881940364838, -0.024604855105280876, -0.00034721376141533256, -0.02428293600678444, -0.038356926292181015, 0.00625061709433794, -0.05493795871734619, -0.008588075637817383, -0.058600980788469315, -0.025448108091950417, -0.030659208074212074, -0.008151282556355, 0.050940923392772675, 0.013237562961876392, -0.004821859300136566, -0.05168408900499344, 0.04456440359354019, 0.033684585243463516, 0.020043885335326195, -0.06159621477127075, -0.018570223823189735, -0.03639483079314232, -0.00521637499332428, 0.036393772810697556, -0.0041232178919017315, -0.017805401235818863, -0.006054547615349293, -0.04416147992014885, -0.0031625728588551283, 0.016418052837252617, 0.003811958245933056, -0.03168492019176483, -0.019475962966680527, -0.06049846485257149, 0.02860095538198948, 0.01757141575217247, 0.00903454888612032, -0.012854115106165409, -0.056621890515089035, -0.03161873295903206, 0.030439449474215508, -0.04707285761833191, 0.02285332791507244, -0.010288246907293797, -0.02477911114692688, 0.023883789777755737, 0.027079012244939804, 0.03725897893309593, -0.009586426429450512, -0.03877551481127739, -0.02371331676840782, -0.018730228766798973, 0.01745583303272724, 0.04824099317193031, -0.03555383160710335, 0.04812414199113846, 0.028185755014419556, 0.018256213515996933, -0.07009820640087128, -0.02556314691901207, 0.018560316413640976, -0.04007526487112045, -0.04750734567642212, -0.03476092219352722, -0.056340571492910385, -0.0614558570086956, 0.031341422349214554, -0.04880347102880478, -0.01838303543627262, -0.05047743767499924, -0.060952406376600266, -0.017648635432124138, -0.019268834963440895, -0.006413224618881941, -0.06825071573257446, -0.04040290415287018, -0.042090896517038345, 0.01802114211022854, 0.027909917756915092, 0.009933296591043472, -0.04363717883825302, -0.00478651188313961, -0.02929246984422207, 0.009586104191839695, 0.050408586859703064, -0.053356144577264786, -0.045387644320726395, -0.04734932631254196, 0.011267031542956829, 0.02745724283158779, 0.04691639170050621, 0.0379277803003788, -0.060757365077733994, 0.02870078571140766, -0.014654048718512058, -0.054183218628168106, -0.052596479654312134, -0.021867785602808, -0.0624910444021225, -0.039278458803892136, -0.05813867598772049, -0.006703055929392576, 0.06311547011137009, 0.0011668195948004723, -0.03356925770640373, -0.053210679441690445, -0.02188846468925476, 0.04865867644548416, -0.03892495855689049, 0.05197131633758545, 0.031972844153642654, -0.0455961748957634, 0.02399960346519947, -0.05521902069449425, 0.01937408745288849, 0.004638171289116144, 0.009503883309662342, -0.0026646051555871964, 0.04027314484119415, -0.026698103174567223, -0.06738405674695969, 0.042063482105731964, 0.05799199640750885, 0.03648267313838005, -0.055000871419906616, -0.05587432533502579, 0.046538762748241425, 0.02508143149316311, 0.00011222711327718571, -0.04915238171815872, 0.020867692306637764, 0.054288629442453384, -0.02036438323557377, -0.008344330824911594, -0.0317281074821949, 0.0367182232439518, -0.003673793049529195, 0.009766834788024426, 0.032354552298784256, -0.011190947145223618, 0.04813064634799957, -0.050573963671922684, -0.0021092586684972048, 0.002216687658801675, 0.019055048003792763, 0.03937516734004021, -0.0644928440451622, -0.045346908271312714, -0.046668171882629395, -0.02309158444404602, -0.024965373799204826, 0.029647188261151314, -0.040959205478429794, -0.03252887353301048, -0.05605003610253334, -0.033574800938367844, -0.05422014370560646, -0.037693969905376434, -0.024730922654271126, 0.005367185454815626, -0.01924366131424904, 0.029805805534124374, 0.021767979487776756, 0.0001456436439184472, -0.04123707488179207, 0.0017571222269907594, -0.001904416480101645, 0.014734049327671528, 0.01760624162852764, -0.00944722443819046, 0.03677944466471672, 0.0048057627864181995, -0.0015438826521858573, -0.060448016971349716, -0.04402325674891472, 0.006375337019562721, -0.03560493886470795, 0.006747185718268156, -0.06956226378679276, -0.04337281733751297, -0.04374074190855026, -0.014622219838202, -0.00793816614896059, -0.02040501870214939, 0.02642090618610382, 0.007335331756621599, -0.04679379612207413, -0.0005719672190025449, -0.034682244062423706, 0.00569329597055912, -0.041077107191085815, -0.04937879368662834, -0.005859347991645336, 0.015407947823405266, -0.012476000003516674, -0.000015779067325638607, 0.030954843387007713, -0.012533814646303654, -0.0623052753508091, 0.006285695359110832, 0.0040777320973575115, -0.002850630786269903, 0.014322353526949883, 0.05551135912537575, 0.03218451142311096, 0.01959613338112831, -0.050069257616996765, -0.023673780262470245, -0.04331609234213829, -0.035387102514505386, -0.06736687570810318, 0.048138123005628586, -0.04308567941188812, -0.059099745005369186, -0.0593399703502655, 0.02867932990193367, -0.023840399459004402, -0.05583381652832031, 0.008087261579930782, 0.007910200394690037, -0.01567751169204712, -0.049915991723537445, -0.060219522565603256, -0.002098878612741828, -0.024799345061182976, -0.05635811388492584, -0.026520980522036552, 0.016621366143226624, 0.021021349355578423, -0.02465134672820568, 0.012574898079037666, -0.04852022975683212, 0.02310623787343502, -0.055702026933431625, 0.006609245203435421, 0.009913666173815727, -0.007775132544338703, -0.024920444935560226, 0.03790780156850815, -0.058576710522174835, -0.02902170456945896, -0.05338103324174881, -0.005481458734720945, -0.013673560693860054, -0.0002497251844033599, -0.005155691411346197, 0.04437438026070595, -0.07059717923402786, -0.002687595086172223, 0.022169681265950203, -0.029433540999889374, -0.016174204647541046, -0.04841160774230957, -0.0428587831556797, 0.022284753620624542, 0.007118640933185816, 0.006327937822788954, 0.006373637821525335, 0.015467805787920952, -0.032200977206230164, -0.014733265154063702, -0.03044068068265915, -0.04124157875776291, -0.008618984371423721, 0.0024882755242288113, -0.034803345799446106, -0.0444449707865715, 0.02164832316339016, -0.015896989032626152, -0.043827615678310394, 0.05559385195374489, 0.021673187613487244, -0.03185409680008888, -0.04479029402136803, -0.05738392099738121, 0.043461836874485016, -0.0239234771579504, 0.02573639340698719, -0.040530189871788025, -0.029757384210824966, 0.021905308589339256, -0.054494358599185944, 0.0006776234367862344, 0.0022716557141393423, 0.05851200222969055, -0.03175012022256851, -0.010518789291381836, -0.040423281490802765, -0.03705337643623352, -0.018856145441532135, -0.041503749787807465, 0.03982961177825928, 0.022298641502857208, -0.04274812340736389, -0.014591272920370102, 0.012612233869731426, 0.01028480101376772, -0.05646092817187309, 0.006191008724272251, -0.06306540966033936, 0.05720512196421623, -0.008422317914664745, -0.017471235245466232, -0.015241122804582119, 0.002343037398532033, -0.005431502591818571, 0.008557451888918877, 0.02172256074845791, -0.011970131658017635, -0.013365647755563259, 0.04483050853013992, 0.007015905808657408, -0.02820189855992794, -0.011882806196808815, -0.01150573045015335, 0.025063902139663696, -0.0564042404294014, 0.047616831958293915, -0.02592247724533081, 0.06605429947376251, 0.046196598559617996, 0.03918105736374855, 0.02912299335002899, -0.06453695893287659, -0.04972134530544281, 0.016258057206869125, -0.04385939985513687, 0.019590528681874275, -0.05707712471485138, -0.038853950798511505, 0.019703084602952003, -0.034367892891168594, -0.006936074700206518, 0.052182648330926895, 0.004807016346603632, -0.032670579850673676, 0.013241203501820564, 0.00033621370675973594, -0.057348039001226425, -0.05894031748175621, 0.045020218938589096, -0.0655982494354248, 0.00904329214245081, -0.0022488681133836508, -0.04499734193086624, -0.05693432688713074, 0.014442733488976955, -0.005781135056167841, -0.06306373327970505, -0.018035534769296646, 0.051371678709983826, 0.014005204662680626, -0.06381666660308838, 0.020302213728427887, 0.02072969637811184, 0.006068598944693804, 0.036539994180202484, -0.06839558482170105, -0.05484398826956749, -0.013821189291775227, 0.067848339676857, -0.04313713684678078, -0.026801280677318573, 0.0019782993476837873, -0.018604883924126625, -0.003866666927933693, -0.009940555319190025, 0.03783994913101196, 0.003958825953304768, 0.05162555351853371, -0.04924754053354263, -0.028009360656142235, -0.03760688751935959, -0.041518837213516235, -0.028751190751791, -0.03398454561829567, 0.013290316797792912, -0.041231852024793625, -0.003959354478865862, 0.017107447609305382, -0.04776213690638542, -0.0002884700079448521, -0.026068802922964096, -0.0658210888504982, -0.018800754100084305, -0.0464155375957489, -0.015284747816622257, -0.019055256620049477, 0.04099767655134201, -0.014723300002515316, -0.015492582693696022, -0.04014306887984276, -0.02883230708539486, -0.04481000453233719, -0.007298255804926157, -0.01381515059620142, -0.032013215124607086, 0.025887615978717804, -0.03958595544099808, 0.04897119849920273, -0.05636746808886528, 0.043086353689432144, -0.02227252908051014, -0.03700428083539009, 0.009333751164376736, -0.015080590732395649, -0.060647137463092804, -0.017595291137695312, 0.023282237350940704, -0.036905765533447266, 0.029866736382246017, -0.028924861922860146, -0.022221848368644714, -0.05008081719279289, 0.020327335223555565, -0.01603582315146923, -0.04034506157040596, -0.036929063498973846, -0.05142829939723015, 0.0224818903952837, 0.020352760329842567, 0.0021048439666628838, 0.01241513155400753, 0.04084157943725586, -0.00456282589584589, -0.003221303690224886, -0.01864587888121605, 0.008395861834287643, -0.03059624508023262, -0.05389733985066414, -0.0339321568608284, -0.06829599291086197, -0.026881981641054153, 0.007059019524604082, -0.0277458056807518, 0.02025737427175045, -0.055611658841371536, -0.034038495272397995, 0.03823190927505493, 0.020979251712560654, 0.0067640081979334354, -0.06748458743095398, -0.05397050827741623, -0.026383213698863983, -0.03472604975104332, 0.03833914175629616, -0.02811518684029579, -0.059926923364400864, -0.013637799769639969, -0.07413817942142487, -0.059141501784324646, -0.052494920790195465, -0.007810456212610006, 0.002805630210787058, 0.028346145525574684, -0.060354094952344894, -0.05768923461437225, -0.018905378878116608, -0.02664114721119404, -0.04641905799508095, 0.057096339762210846, 0.04294503852725029, -0.04022325575351715, 0.03237701952457428, 0.004416629206389189, -0.03490153327584267, -0.027073673903942108, -0.007082088850438595, 0.04676377400755882, 0.02276785485446453, -0.04166579991579056, 0.021079113706946373, 0.056632887572050095, -0.03687227517366409, 0.015095124021172523, 0.0008402118692174554, -0.028978470712900162, -0.06064877659082413, -0.027769947424530983, 0.021184157580137253, -0.07249078154563904, -0.008297145366668701, -0.023722918704152107, 0.002029657131060958, -0.06618482619524002, -0.03353428840637207, -0.013789464719593525, -0.036046069115400314, 0.0026238856371492147, 0.02326156012713909, -0.02419104240834713, -0.05926121026277542, -0.010819786228239536, 0.010756990872323513, -0.017650827765464783, -0.041502200067043304, 0.002261935267597437, 0.021887462586164474, -0.004549485631287098, -0.04825272038578987, -0.06881193071603775, 0.03462410345673561, -0.06186255067586899, -0.015932662412524223, 0.05758097022771835, 0.042245808988809586, -0.04381893202662468, 0.0162209440022707, -0.0007923146476969123, -0.052239589393138885, -0.007273560389876366, -0.05477815493941307, -0.01871975138783455, 0.01942928321659565, 0.026678573340177536, 0.04010254517197609, 0.06687688827514648, -0.0420566163957119, 0.009938517585396767, -0.045404259115457535, -0.02913963980972767, 0.03864887356758118, 0.02840517647564411, 0.0024738966021686792, -0.008310200646519661, -0.03307921066880226, -0.047329239547252655, -0.0487026609480381, 0.024019315838813782, 0.018965180963277817, -0.0243091844022274, -0.04355667531490326, -0.05723493918776512, 0.027055127546191216, -0.06574203819036484, -0.012748362496495247, -0.034532032907009125, 0.05982258915901184, -0.016186464577913284, 0.04758395254611969, -0.03845828399062157, -0.014069286175072193, -0.02372206561267376 ]
We place observational constraints on a dark energy (DE) model in which a quintessence scalar field $\phi$ is coupled to dark matter (DM) through momentum and energy exchanges.The momentum transfer is weighed by an interaction between the field derivative and DM four velocity with a coupling constant $\beta$, whereas the energy exchange is characterized by an exponential scalar-field coupling to the DM density with a coupling constant $Q$. A positive coupling $\beta$ leads to the suppression for the growth of DM density perturbations at low redshifts, whose property offers a possibility for resolving the $\sigma_8$ tension problem. A negative coupling $Q$ gives rise to a $\phi$-matter-dominated epoch, whose presence can reduce the sound horizon around the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) decoupling epoch. Using the data of Planck 2018, 12-th Sloan Digital Sky Survey, Phantheon supernovae samples, and 1-year dark energy survey, we find that the two couplings are constrained to be $\beta=0.332^{+1.246}_{-0.237}$ and $Q =-0.0312^{+0.0312}_{-0.0085}$ at 68\,\% confidence level (CL). Thus, there is an interesting observational signature of the momentum exchange ($\beta \neq 0$) between DE and DM, with a peak of the probability distribution of the energy transfer coupling at $Q<0$.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13946v2
[ -0.05815819650888443, -0.03941484913229942, 0.032734036445617676, -0.013542862609028816, -0.007708746008574963, 0.05305733531713486, 0.02819223888218403, 0.012541724368929863, -0.03977708891034126, -0.005520150065422058, 0.02557588368654251, -0.051198095083236694, -0.015068813227117062, -0.03428502008318901, -0.03513777628540993, 0.014795503579080105, 0.04791310057044029, 0.030818311497569084, 0.01309913583099842, 0.052993498742580414, 0.026094883680343628, -0.010119548998773098, -0.012548428028821945, 0.048223916441202164, 0.01261987816542387, -0.020736385136842728, -0.05679823085665703, 0.02524494007229805, -0.025574078783392906, -0.04910171777009964, 0.06563494354486465, -0.036080002784729004, 0.0059792096726596355, -0.03772776201367378, -0.014327389188110828, 0.006824857089668512, -0.025750145316123962, 0.043506018817424774, 0.03083331696689129, -0.04216676205396652, 0.007315941620618105, -0.040193893015384674, -0.04675932228565216, -0.06753729283809662, -0.022105298936367035, -0.027410950511693954, -0.02052312158048153, -0.005039433483034372, -0.02297978475689888, -0.05905523523688316, 0.026837769895792007, 0.001770108356140554, 0.039708249270915985, 0.03692755848169327, -0.03454592451453209, 0.019618170335888863, -0.010345940478146076, -0.025699062272906303, -0.04828650876879692, -0.021107781678438187, 0.022411344572901726, -0.029140865430235863, 0.02823365479707718, -0.03380092605948448, -0.04578553885221481, 0.03233123570680618, -0.04642981290817261, -0.05524282902479172, -0.02161148190498352, -0.05946356803178787, 0.019970271736383438, -0.06773549318313599, 0.037908438593149185, 0.028511475771665573, -0.048145730048418045, 0.034975096583366394, -0.008662362582981586, -0.024208787828683853, -0.042822930961847305, 0.011776904575526714, -0.0023686299100518227, -0.030254758894443512, -0.0002089760237140581, 0.03426950052380562, 0.028670087456703186, 0.017015798017382622, 0.02718919888138771, -0.012516713701188564, 0.010821830481290817, -0.05130688101053238, 0.04832249507308006, -0.061760567128658295, -0.04025967791676521, -0.04665587097406387, 0.07146187871694565, -0.060957495123147964, 0.03692568093538284, 0.03955801948904991, 0.011727618053555489, -0.016815345734357834, 0.0031697957310825586, -0.055807482451200485, -0.03890125826001167, 0.010505509562790394, 0.0005590767250396311, -0.034233786165714264, 0.010486544109880924, -0.03606151416897774, -0.0421588271856308, 0.06040347367525101, 0.02692067064344883, 0.03793838992714882, -0.060488756746053696, -0.029662776738405228, -0.0454443022608757, -0.05905378982424736, 0.05373337119817734, 0.040082912892103195, 0.030517539009451866, -0.021001018583774567, -0.03684767708182335, 0.060123518109321594, 0.02123301662504673, 0.025827810168266296, -0.0011622733436524868, 0.037588223814964294, 0.057558272033929825, -0.01512750145047903, 0.004499529954046011, -0.04610661417245865, -0.05309002846479416, 0.012790552340447903, 0.0028826065827161074, -0.0423257052898407, 0.01992087811231613, 0.013014625757932663, -0.0017570556374266744, -0.01922733150422573, -0.006772725842893124, 0.026349902153015137, -0.03294074907898903, -0.04071803390979767, 0.010272510349750519, 0.03248298168182373, -0.023594798520207405, -0.017443886026740074, -0.039278868585824966, 0.00622220104560256, 0.017560051754117012, 0.020906412973999977, 0.00968840066343546, 0.0326530747115612, 0.023559758439660072, -0.010533387772738934, 0.00853201188147068, -0.007514791563153267, 0.05229513347148895, -0.0023133857175707817, -0.0462617427110672, 0.036043088883161545, 0.001551779336296022, -0.04082609340548515, 0.028284411877393723, -0.017172694206237793, -0.015064171515405178, 0.017618343234062195, -0.005774505436420441, -0.0255954097956419, 0.02676849626004696, -0.013249678537249565, -0.012483211234211922, -0.026953885331749916, 0.010596313513815403, -0.049359194934368134, -0.05429528281092644, -0.0038049183785915375, -0.05562639608979225, -0.05015842616558075, -0.021411791443824768, 0.018868103623390198, 0.031007280573248863, 0.0364653654396534, -0.04891738295555115, -0.028699014335870743, -0.051118381321430206, 0.01502486877143383, -0.07406523078680038, -0.007775314152240753, 0.021052319556474686, 0.005103640258312225, -0.05300576984882355, -0.0470554418861866, 0.006653905846178532, -0.00739308400079608, -0.034915581345558167, -0.027373695746064186, 0.022025061771273613, -0.028312595561146736, -0.007108495105057955, 0.019245553761720657, -0.05868484824895859, -0.007240519858896732, -0.058000873774290085, 0.019534019753336906, 0.02352035418152809, -0.06459619104862213, 0.01515815407037735, 0.05027586594223976, -0.011625934392213821, -0.050514791160821915, 0.06234902888536453, 0.03673119470477104, 0.035304270684719086, -0.007406627293676138, 0.014153392054140568, -0.0038701039738953114, -0.08836936205625534, 0.0499291867017746, 0.03791721537709236, 0.03287723660469055, 0.007025681436061859, -0.0269040334969759, 0.02178180031478405, -0.04135361686348915, -0.018362998962402344, 0.018913840875029564, 0.037192076444625854, 0.019163107499480247, -0.03870922327041626, -0.026462916284799576, 0.008088760077953339, -0.06667390465736389, -0.05769263207912445, -0.05695055052638054, -0.03885960951447487, -0.001153461285866797, -0.05787280574440956, 0.06249777227640152, -0.024400955066084862, -0.03486103564500809, -0.01715906895697117, -0.0003844826715067029, 0.04106755182147026, -0.03420690819621086, -0.045892130583524704, 0.00037534371949732304, -0.022969460114836693, 0.017872661352157593, -0.05463767424225807, -0.039714109152555466, 0.029051510617136955, -0.04686633124947548, -0.05159255117177963, -0.044914040714502335, 0.041123948991298676, 0.04543667659163475, -0.05362585932016373, -0.00678509846329689, -0.032064370810985565, 0.04883255064487457, 0.0007470741402357817, 0.03854755312204361, -0.04795052856206894, 0.03150426223874092, 0.015740307047963142, 0.02530922368168831, -0.04733172804117203, -0.030310306698083878, -0.030929353088140488, -0.0008963451837189496, -0.020691270008683205, 0.0268788430839777, 0.041972484439611435, 0.043638959527015686, 0.00975965429097414, 0.03408978134393692, -0.06847038865089417, -0.0022805710323154926, -0.013813897967338562, -0.0002235508873127401, 0.06201489642262459, 0.03145076334476471, 0.003988330252468586, -0.05913249030709267, -0.0312514454126358, -0.03622676432132721, -0.0244169682264328, -0.06020289659500122, -0.04981926456093788, 0.013057426549494267, -0.07512256503105164, -0.007448381278663874, -0.044667795300483704, -0.006947224494069815, -0.046811897307634354, -0.014305267482995987, -0.024132519960403442, -0.023569943383336067, 0.0015371281187981367, -0.0819651335477829, -0.014889426529407501, 0.04198755696415901, -0.04583486169576645, 0.05343185365200043, -0.04053984954953194, -0.0165692288428545, -0.024568581953644753, -0.007888938300311565, -0.02585708349943161, 0.009195763617753983, -0.04286131262779236, 0.003686740528792143, -0.057678237557411194, -0.0047774226404726505, 0.0034614945761859417, 0.040708277374506, 0.010791635140776634, -0.047187820076942444, -0.018648438155651093, -0.04165055602788925, -0.011336950585246086, -0.023347456008195877, 0.010159877128899097, -0.01487562246620655, -0.043952420353889465, -0.06497452408075333, 0.06009432673454285, 0.07371044158935547, 0.010871656239032745, -0.04060352221131325, -0.05546609312295914, 0.013006570748984814, 0.03121110424399376, -0.001316757989116013, 0.06467603147029877, 0.058798063546419144, -0.01284186914563179, -0.012554759159684181, -0.03738243505358696, 0.05169227719306946, -0.0038287844508886337, -0.018752126023173332, 0.020575350150465965, 0.03640340268611908, 0.004145200364291668, -0.07097745686769485, 0.039901506155729294, 0.049125563353300095, 0.0413222461938858, 0.015685081481933594, 0.01768963411450386, 0.011715107597410679, 0.011386743746697903, 0.03778645023703575, -0.0013921513454988599, 0.0309899989515543, 0.046050600707530975, 0.030696654692292213, -0.03857175633311272, -0.007094762288033962, -0.007664382923394442, -0.04946020618081093, -0.0335075668990612, 0.06804487109184265, -0.01598445139825344, 0.03416503220796585, 0.04203326627612114, -0.03387610614299774, 0.0351749062538147, -0.021994158625602722, 0.054514434188604355, -0.04725254327058792, -0.05955976992845535, 0.044395625591278076, 0.018736908212304115, -0.014201690442860126, -0.036454152315855026, -0.015958981588482857, -0.01813317835330963, -0.022222358733415604, 0.014776729047298431, -0.06983109563589096, 0.015735093504190445, 0.015227008610963821, 0.04022107645869255, 0.014869768172502518, 0.04689626395702362, 0.01724909245967865, 0.010547507554292679, -0.04797783121466637, 0.005939725786447525, -0.04517071694135666, -0.009570024907588959, -0.01901155337691307, 0.02160288766026497, -0.011368530802428722, -0.009092588908970356, 0.04254842549562454, -0.04586515575647354, -0.050019122660160065, 0.058205440640449524, 0.002573946723714471, 0.0036910707131028175, -0.07717698067426682, -0.047917116433382034, -0.07263417541980743, 0.02515820786356926, 0.01400487869977951, -0.0085862772539258, 0.06543589383363724, 0.02152649313211441, -0.027072841301560402, -0.005859800614416599, -0.047961436212062836, -0.007791638374328613, -0.0484495535492897, -0.020348023623228073, -0.012718122452497482, 0.03414778783917427, -0.023154841735959053, 0.043949585407972336, -0.01426215935498476, 0.014466666616499424, -0.06696931272745132, -0.002259633969515562, -0.01629159227013588, 0.009645507670938969, 0.005149765871465206, -0.019499104470014572, 0.023761490359902382, 0.03539104759693146, -0.03635939955711365, 0.006873449310660362, 0.024097822606563568, 0.04810670018196106, -0.0630984753370285, 0.034225624054670334, -0.036362383514642715, -0.037254102528095245, 0.006054780445992947, -0.01464733574539423, 0.05625525116920471, -0.04283057153224945, -0.012077227234840393, 0.0019756818655878305, 0.033317312598228455, -0.033010512590408325, -0.03628934547305107, -0.03935744985938072, -0.04967015981674194, -0.06278417259454727, -0.022579656913876534, -0.020502878352999687, -0.027186118066310883, 0.03699513152241707, 0.043630003929138184, -0.012224473990499973, 0.041208699345588684, -0.06247303634881973, 0.022082138806581497, 0.010242562741041183, -0.0017740253824740648, -0.0269224364310503, -0.020146002992987633, -0.0758613869547844, 0.0321914404630661, -0.02031310647726059, -0.03200531005859375, 0.04449158534407616, 0.015355373732745647, -0.02389364317059517, 0.04457157105207443, -0.07507102191448212, 0.024458590894937515, 0.054081011563539505, -0.04398370161652565, 0.018736371770501137, -0.011500904336571693, -0.057123105973005295, 0.0029007233679294586, 0.0029772529378533363, 0.008809814229607582, -0.018869856372475624, -0.012816247530281544, 0.02410450018942356, 0.0063889822922647, -0.05315159261226654, -0.026012934744358063, 0.03229107707738876, 0.03610823303461075, -0.06119881570339203, -0.0021910539362579584, -0.0001385350915370509, -0.001487922272644937, -0.06254346668720245, 0.029254360124468803, 0.052012089639902115, -0.06323312968015671, -0.061824217438697815, -0.023290038108825684, -0.0031141084618866444, 0.02733147144317627, 0.04094180464744568, -0.06970090419054031, -0.008748448453843594, -0.011253053322434425, 0.014682726003229618, -0.0069552138447761536, 0.031815167516469955, -0.0046455347910523415, 0.014262082986533642, -0.0028832117095589638, -0.017614711076021194, -0.07061312347650528, 0.012963310815393925, -0.05777234584093094, 0.0121341897174716, 0.0030664552468806505, 0.06010543555021286, 0.016559958457946777, 0.028945716097950935, -0.010937606915831566, -0.043600887060165405, -0.01801261119544506, -0.027456369251012802, 0.05473436042666435, 0.029513219371438026, -0.04075762256979942, 0.02596632018685341, 0.0012558290036395192, -0.003243702929466963, 0.01734623685479164, -0.013594923540949821, -0.038820475339889526, -0.02078660950064659, -0.019303666427731514, 0.02647988684475422, -0.030852846801280975, -0.03826931118965149, -0.010600373148918152, 0.05567427724599838, -0.040393684059381485, 0.06349308043718338, -0.027113281190395355, -0.018110454082489014, 0.033583901822566986, -0.006352762226015329, 0.03700771555304527, -0.06730516999959946, -0.010920610278844833, 0.07140588760375977, -0.07250892370939255, 0.01847611367702484, -0.017050985246896744, -0.028513014316558838, -0.026970602571964264, -0.059110790491104126, -0.04364641755819321, 0.004232460632920265, -0.0024113901890814304, -0.04173778370022774, 0.0651484951376915, -0.03275125101208687, -0.06959805637598038, -0.016285542398691177, 0.04144641384482384, -0.0841478556394577, 0.011020451784133911, 0.002499336376786232, -0.025353970006108284, -0.06216823682188988, 0.0029477591160684824, -0.04573482647538185, -0.028059128671884537, -0.05234069004654884, 0.07306961715221405, 0.033932629972696304, -0.043904319405555725, 0.02764386124908924, 0.009246839210391045, -0.057546455413103104, 0.013153753243386745, -0.0728452056646347, -0.06472893804311752, -0.039846938103437424, 0.05500765144824982, 0.0011309622786939144, 0.012840371578931808, -0.05004611611366272, -0.00022822024766355753, -0.00604602787643671, -0.014918963424861431, 0.017773006111383438, 0.006674197036772966, 0.06514764577150345, 0.0033033397048711777, -0.05473540350794792, 0.035017840564250946, -0.04240935295820236, 0.006350985262542963, -0.014501618221402168, 0.05103495344519615, 0.02998322620987892, 0.02328948862850666, -0.02797851338982582, -0.052046723663806915, 0.023543406277894974, -0.033145494759082794, -0.049696698784828186, 0.04578861594200134, -0.05359817296266556, -0.035623956471681595, 0.020688116550445557, 0.018033696338534355, 0.028265822678804398, 0.01414884440600872, -0.014630263671278954, 0.03376547619700432, -0.04168323799967766, -0.002920652274042368, 0.016896309331059456, 0.005627669859677553, 0.0362032875418663, -0.05444733053445816, 0.05989430099725723, -0.0606229193508625, 0.01361926645040512, -0.02886876091361046, -0.021117903292179108, 0.027525657787919044, 0.021540826186537743, -0.05526601895689964, 0.004931866656988859, 0.032610539346933365, -0.04323064535856247, -0.0017720730975270271, -0.014272146858274937, -0.016551606357097626, -0.06967806071043015, -0.0031315330415964127, -0.005339610856026411, 0.027348952367901802, 0.043482206761837006, -0.04718167334794998, 0.047253090888261795, -0.004318131599575281, 0.03779386356472969, 0.03394421562552452, 0.008854713290929794, -0.008727764710783958, -0.06694285571575165, -0.009301307611167431, -0.007031393703073263, 0.014502924866974354, -0.04087807983160019, -0.03760599344968796, -0.017944779247045517, -0.07369030267000198, 0.0064079975709319115, -0.020601531490683556, 0.021614648401737213, -0.03622619807720184, -0.03849227726459503, 0.04160206764936447, 0.023382999002933502, 0.012532400898635387, -0.07653510570526123, -0.00854749046266079, -0.006443056743592024, 0.021624721586704254, 0.029812518507242203, -0.023777995258569717, -0.051688846200704575, -0.023810293525457382, -0.07305740565061569, -0.026109589263796806, -0.03768093138933182, 0.04940883815288544, 0.018295489251613617, -0.0017919408855959773, -0.011900625191628933, -0.046526577323675156, 0.011923774145543575, 0.03446086496114731, 0.007275893818587065, -0.00166726962197572, 0.014361042529344559, -0.016201794147491455, -0.030640101060271263, 0.008589931763708591, 0.017195673659443855, -0.03571709990501404, -0.039288993924856186, 0.043307214975357056, 0.0485958568751812, -0.04170927032828331, -0.012171885930001736, 0.02141920104622841, -0.032244257628917694, 0.0315682627260685, -0.03862990066409111, -0.03091847337782383, -0.028695935383439064, -0.05796578899025917, 0.04377472400665283, -0.03880000114440918, 0.011657691560685635, -0.01772495172917843, -0.011341222561895847, -0.060082681477069855, -0.05018278956413269, -0.05173869431018829, 0.005046776495873928, 0.03721971809864044, -0.010813438333570957, 0.0611063688993454, -0.06976491212844849, -0.0037527475506067276, -0.004544357303529978, 0.01296919398009777, -0.05847370624542236, -0.03060312755405903, 0.028094494715332985, -0.05497181415557861, -0.031063131988048553, -0.053434912115335464, 0.06020968034863472, -0.05127045512199402, -0.04160725325345993, -0.01982509158551693, 0.04854206368327141, -0.010513382963836193, 0.0015420867130160332, -0.025614868849515915, -0.006624116096645594, 0.009041430428624153, -0.06579185277223587, 0.019863812252879143, -0.01976604387164116, 0.021410884335637093, 0.03484180197119713, 0.05267830193042755, -0.023702841252088547, 0.054414182901382446, 0.030990533530712128, 0.02812926098704338, -0.02688160166144371, -0.02027379348874092, -0.032864075154066086, 0.029669541865587234, 0.016660792753100395, -0.02626989036798477, -0.03184563294053078, 0.05757197365164757, -0.007645332254469395, 0.011116141453385353, 0.012725037522614002, 0.01028102170675993, 0.017716404050588608, -0.048065658658742905, -0.046714939177036285, 0.03425096720457077, 0.011088017374277115, -0.03014601208269596, 0.05644923076033592, 0.011633913964033127, -0.02415456436574459, -0.04985516890883446 ]
Discovery of mathematical descriptors of physical phenomena from observational and simulated data, as opposed to from the first principles, is a rapidly evolving research area. Two factors, time-dependence of the inputs and hidden translation invariance, are known to complicate this task. To ameliorate these challenges, we combine Lagrangian dynamic mode decomposition with a locally time-invariant approximation of the Koopman operator. The former component of our method yields the best linear estimator of the system's dynamics, while the latter deals with the system's nonlinearity and non-autonomous behavior. We provide theoretical estimators (bounds) of prediction accuracy and perturbation error to guide the selection of both rank truncation and temporal discretization. We demonstrate the performance of our approach on several non-autonomous problems, including two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05117v2
[ -0.01689535565674305, -0.03757765516638756, 0.0461055152118206, 0.020314550027251244, 0.0072874040342867374, -0.04298501834273338, -0.01095874235033989, 0.020530756562948227, 0.000773697451222688, 0.003112879116088152, -0.06186491623520851, -0.02888122759759426, -0.052561089396476746, -0.052042629569768906, -0.023454269394278526, -0.002080541104078293, 0.08002141118049622, 0.006000517401844263, -0.0478484109044075, 0.07429814338684082, 0.009912022389471531, -0.016088947653770447, 0.0025755902752280235, 0.048599209636449814, -0.01300832536071539, -0.01757148839533329, -0.010723785497248173, -0.00449390010908246, 0.002079698024317622, 0.00044827122474089265, 0.04913013428449631, -0.04059401527047157, 0.028317831456661224, -0.043715137988328934, -0.02041700668632984, -0.0278639979660511, 0.004642688203603029, 0.03274375572800636, 0.05334868282079697, 0.00494431285187602, -0.021381845697760582, -0.04578114300966263, -0.0335562527179718, 0.02059170790016651, -0.03065323270857334, -0.019163910299539566, -0.003655280452221632, 0.017139969393610954, -0.038321301341056824, -0.06365091353654861, 0.03603184223175049, -0.00007570106390630826, -0.035860735923051834, 0.029692431911826134, -0.034460023045539856, 0.004424353130161762, 0.0004904168890789151, 0.00944130402058363, -0.03197133168578148, -0.029185840860009193, 0.006925074849277735, -0.02963000163435936, 0.030880948528647423, -0.009994026273488998, 0.034529272466897964, 0.05003567412495613, -0.02226831018924713, -0.061513375490903854, -0.02094120904803276, -0.05647224560379982, 0.019378364086151123, -0.061041951179504395, 0.03417046368122101, -0.018478062003850937, -0.047694750130176544, -0.009389571845531464, -0.01723528653383255, 0.008555490523576736, 0.00733403442427516, 0.05266770347952843, 0.0015057037817314267, 0.03860488161444664, 0.04355504363775253, 0.04001999646425247, 0.03321573883295059, -0.026643570512533188, 0.05275804549455643, -0.016098234802484512, 0.001709380536340177, -0.04618651792407036, 0.03593488410115242, -0.07019621878862381, -0.037365831434726715, -0.02584007941186428, 0.0406898595392704, -0.027048008516430855, 0.05873586982488632, 0.06498045474290848, 0.034843526780605316, -0.011783191002905369, -0.02382044680416584, -0.03489290550351143, -0.05110745504498482, 0.06900552660226822, 0.01601559668779373, -0.03989490121603012, -0.016559341922402382, -0.02494686096906662, -0.039030201733112335, 0.017185769975185394, -0.017262399196624756, -0.006055078469216824, -0.01296789851039648, -0.06768982112407684, -0.058431226760149, -0.05117205157876015, 0.06396155804395676, 0.020699838176369667, 0.05278296768665314, -0.016020460054278374, -0.03270312026143074, 0.03742390125989914, 0.0009295580675825477, 0.019997110590338707, -0.04389185830950737, -0.004604046698659658, 0.05668528005480766, 0.039862897247076035, 0.0035290231462568045, -0.018625540658831596, -0.007946880534291267, 0.02237517200410366, 0.02920583263039589, -0.025262709707021713, 0.045136161148548126, -0.00454443646594882, -0.018152793869376183, -0.04900173097848892, 0.02456028014421463, 0.021590987220406532, -0.06181371957063675, -0.06378725916147232, 0.017194882035255432, -0.014036926440894604, -0.006534800864756107, 0.028325986117124557, -0.07320608198642731, -0.023342274129390717, 0.03327896445989609, 0.03851241245865822, 0.006546440068632364, -0.024232827126979828, 0.03289613127708435, 0.019448384642601013, 0.03795767202973366, -0.007309246342629194, 0.04104246944189072, -0.04199400544166565, -0.05566314607858658, 0.015845676884055138, 0.05560369789600372, -0.02441590093076229, 0.020892418920993805, -0.010950224474072456, 0.030324021354317665, 0.05206998065114021, 0.04092154651880264, -0.03163423389196396, 0.008948914706707, 0.014946581795811653, -0.014740554615855217, -0.00495482049882412, 0.0171352569013834, -0.061780549585819244, -0.052892353385686874, -0.02532048523426056, -0.03381294012069702, -0.043421629816293716, -0.04393771290779114, -0.0071558877825737, -0.003383859759196639, 0.009353877045214176, -0.03099300153553486, 0.020529044792056084, -0.02990581840276718, 0.03757375851273537, -0.08414693921804428, 0.0017287820810452104, 0.04892973601818085, 0.02747669443488121, -0.012899721972644329, -0.0615229532122612, -0.020373808220028877, 0.012480986304581165, -0.06346000730991364, -0.02858484722673893, 0.038375113159418106, -0.02518177218735218, -0.0029520727694034576, 0.03995377942919731, -0.08778580278158188, -0.02714674547314644, -0.01934828609228134, -0.025536054745316505, -0.05002126470208168, -0.05838838964700699, 0.030772633850574493, 0.042731162160634995, -0.010195053182542324, 0.020431580021977425, 0.06718692928552628, 0.031149592250585556, 0.053964998573064804, 0.000038399335608119145, 0.0009405779419466853, -0.0008468125597573817, -0.0991281047463417, 0.026525776833295822, -0.02833505906164646, 0.02674323134124279, -0.009144578129053116, 0.027240527793765068, -0.018139254301786423, -0.04250994324684143, -0.007881203666329384, 0.05955680087208748, 0.021574821323156357, 0.032320406287908554, -0.07127594947814941, -0.03208565711975098, -0.017990635707974434, -0.0622735321521759, -0.053167618811130524, -0.06937140226364136, -0.03113858588039875, 0.03951653838157654, -0.022627413272857666, 0.05128222703933716, -0.035810403525829315, -0.04266421124339104, -0.06831717491149902, -0.03125162795186043, 0.05834071338176727, -0.04226000979542732, -0.013727229088544846, -0.04436712712049484, -0.01698955148458481, 0.02408738248050213, -0.0057951887138187885, -0.015571556985378265, 0.00758602237328887, -0.08005940169095993, -0.029944516718387604, -0.04569318890571594, -0.007284979801625013, 0.06620292365550995, -0.038123127073049545, 0.048471078276634216, 0.02275105006992817, 0.07617481052875519, 0.015599031001329422, 0.009393282234668732, -0.016872188076376915, -0.00025068651302717626, 0.021621843799948692, 0.01911577768623829, 0.006186165846884251, 0.012213495559990406, -0.027798309922218323, -0.055659499019384384, 0.005230065435171127, -0.017555607482790947, 0.03889501467347145, 0.008186493068933487, -0.01615232415497303, -0.023135391995310783, -0.02557223290205002, -0.046215809881687164, 0.03916827589273453, 0.06549087911844254, 0.043064385652542114, 0.0030309753492474556, -0.010971284471452236, -0.07628791779279709, -0.003351901425048709, -0.002395608928054571, -0.04634431377053261, -0.03192058950662613, -0.05681426823139191, -0.0017609315691515803, -0.07863988727331161, 0.004104214254766703, -0.014668865129351616, -0.05838383361697197, -0.05272243171930313, -0.0555843859910965, -0.0485348217189312, -0.004809101577848196, 0.022600827738642693, -0.016047142446041107, -0.0622580461204052, -0.03353003039956093, 0.037579987198114395, 0.03294863924384117, 0.017368197441101074, -0.044990651309490204, -0.06643467396497726, 0.030084431171417236, 0.034583572298288345, 0.0068006254732608795, -0.019826332107186317, 0.008774657733738422, -0.013926530256867409, 0.035861484706401825, 0.026516925543546677, -0.0013955774484202266, 0.03694169223308563, -0.017942750826478004, -0.004597645718604326, 0.016266629099845886, 0.022778339684009552, 0.008618228137493134, 0.021711556240916252, -0.0038260240107774734, -0.048130691051483154, -0.029616083949804306, 0.05195518955588341, 0.02419622242450714, 0.016825612634420395, -0.057286303490400314, -0.024983610957860947, -0.003593798726797104, 0.002573547884821892, -0.025047151371836662, 0.06011984497308731, 0.016064120456576347, 0.010058860294520855, -0.03937693312764168, -0.020992839708924294, 0.021844474598765373, 0.0021461984142661095, 0.047677017748355865, -0.023914337158203125, -0.021380452439188957, 0.03772451728582382, -0.08175002783536911, 0.01366881188005209, 0.03479428216814995, 0.03635299578309059, -0.0239054337143898, 0.0076487404294312, 0.007849080488085747, -0.00042185880010947585, -0.012870716862380505, 0.016212470829486847, 0.037840258330106735, 0.027643444016575813, 0.0502084419131279, 0.0088193966075778, -0.04192613810300827, 0.034300606697797775, -0.0772550106048584, -0.0632171630859375, 0.013143034651875496, 0.015561159700155258, 0.006479553412646055, 0.03484557196497917, -0.054423149675130844, 0.008211401291191578, -0.05392741784453392, 0.03654085472226143, 0.012205686420202255, -0.01894659735262394, 0.03390733152627945, -0.02642727456986904, -0.014645337127149105, -0.0003017880371771753, 0.010971258394420147, 0.025560345500707626, -0.06236400827765465, -0.021122649312019348, -0.06830789893865585, 0.03282936289906502, -0.014715972356498241, -0.03232135996222496, 0.04335509240627289, 0.01840105839073658, -0.039799172431230545, 0.056941479444503784, -0.009266814216971397, 0.018024848774075508, 0.008538328111171722, -0.017325351014733315, 0.019245363771915436, -0.013729033060371876, -0.05638052150607109, 0.016614029183983803, 0.01695421151816845, -0.025319987908005714, -0.04375108703970909, -0.010471532121300697, -0.037110552191734314, 0.016663050279021263, -0.07291276752948761, -0.010638521052896976, -0.060244083404541016, 0.004893813282251358, -0.06876267492771149, -0.05732492730021477, 0.08050478994846344, -0.0342436358332634, -0.00952595192939043, -0.03769156336784363, -0.017567966133356094, -0.017061777412891388, -0.005300361663103104, -0.0030099477153271437, -0.05339491367340088, 0.021614741533994675, -0.030478062108159065, 0.03611525148153305, -0.018260477110743523, 0.007025060243904591, -0.034869663417339325, 0.005162087734788656, -0.010886081494390965, 0.06686272472143173, 0.0498121902346611, 0.0060893213376402855, 0.007058215793222189, -0.006830401718616486, -0.02084246650338173, 0.018408766016364098, -0.024603670462965965, -0.007308377884328365, -0.04638278856873512, 0.013621337711811066, -0.03987564519047737, -0.018514318391680717, -0.006249529775232077, -0.016359452158212662, 0.0782909169793129, -0.023275379091501236, -0.04640064015984535, 0.012656423263251781, 0.03642163798213005, -0.03952741250395775, -0.04576472193002701, -0.033465124666690826, -0.003968171775341034, -0.056371692568063736, 0.01026983093470335, 0.0021897826809436083, -0.002699196571484208, -0.03140878677368164, 0.044576819986104965, -0.00041569178574718535, 0.03622155264019966, -0.029462803155183792, -0.013365847989916801, 0.03185465931892395, 0.0413985438644886, 0.015785379335284233, 0.01030562911182642, -0.08831067383289337, 0.01801697351038456, -0.043968163430690765, -0.04332456365227699, -0.03370243310928345, 0.05742013081908226, 0.029343467205762863, 0.060827068984508514, -0.07709100842475891, 0.018145650625228882, 0.03698352351784706, -0.011515287682414055, -0.01297853235155344, 0.04257042706012726, -0.023986807093024254, -0.031918399035930634, -0.02451036311686039, -0.030772607773542404, 0.03601157292723656, 0.02106553129851818, -0.008539411239326, -0.026455268263816833, -0.03692258521914482, -0.041515011340379715, 0.06257104128599167, -0.007934562861919403, -0.03631189092993736, -0.016534829512238503, -0.03478279337286949, 0.025313904508948326, -0.061094123870134354, 0.05907581374049187, 0.059809114784002304, -0.05391829088330269, -0.04339908808469772, -0.020831333473324776, -0.01932358741760254, 0.027241159230470657, 0.02415226586163044, -0.05106382817029953, -0.008704871870577335, 0.008813629858195782, 0.021944038569927216, 0.007672654930502176, 0.0238459762185812, -0.01079520583152771, -0.019473139196634293, 0.001562429708428681, 0.00605492340400815, -0.07495038956403732, 0.011846737004816532, -0.025051863864064217, -0.0004419424512889236, 0.041506264358758926, 0.023746641352772713, -0.0008214703993871808, 0.036782100796699524, 0.00390412425622344, 0.007406644057482481, -0.02481800504028797, -0.019155656918883324, 0.0547538697719574, -0.037129178643226624, 0.014951295219361782, 0.011057417839765549, 0.052122242748737335, 0.009014153853058815, 0.018646638840436935, 0.004482120741158724, -0.03072376735508442, -0.05476962774991989, 0.0007266023894771934, 0.013157759793102741, -0.06179478019475937, -0.06382015347480774, 0.007183013949543238, 0.04867994040250778, -0.002781818388029933, 0.03283057361841202, -0.02660481445491314, 0.01795046590268612, -0.0032329370733350515, 0.02008427307009697, -0.012897844426333904, -0.04919072240591049, 0.028454460203647614, 0.08838621526956558, -0.037938524037599564, -0.030245579779148102, -0.029567917808890343, -0.052021998912096024, -0.009811400435864925, -0.055310916155576706, 0.038177475333213806, 0.002551075303927064, -0.013089116662740707, -0.06888848543167114, 0.035028744488954544, 0.0011498772073537111, -0.06891956180334091, -0.028895260766148567, 0.017635241150856018, -0.0626400038599968, 0.013287132605910301, 0.00020958388631697744, -0.013670478016138077, -0.0022338125854730606, 0.0406828448176384, 0.012254890985786915, -0.04393713176250458, -0.0442887544631958, 0.05091505125164986, 0.08243680000305176, -0.010492954403162003, 0.02465178444981575, -0.006915563717484474, -0.027539625763893127, 0.021851690486073494, -0.049684155732393265, 0.007931294851005077, -0.02500249072909355, 0.01950124278664589, 0.0010210196487605572, -0.021375484764575958, -0.04418395087122917, 0.04885829985141754, -0.02572227641940117, 0.01279731560498476, 0.004851154983043671, 0.019763430580496788, 0.019544409587979317, -0.03936005011200905, -0.05283743143081665, -0.03372950851917267, 0.0018404306611046195, -0.041647572070360184, -0.04920431971549988, 0.010692646726965904, -0.038405004888772964, 0.029275257140398026, -0.03753717988729477, -0.03450574725866318, 0.0395737886428833, -0.02943410910665989, -0.04642995074391365, -0.00043428572826087475, -0.07020798325538635, -0.012477528303861618, 0.01159550528973341, -0.0048635173588991165, -0.01090739294886589, 0.023384734988212585, -0.03667355328798294, 0.037760961800813675, -0.018440382555127144, 0.008347918279469013, -0.027305083349347115, 0.016460822895169258, 0.012044176459312439, 0.0237391646951437, 0.0366937629878521, 0.0008393821190111339, 0.037972018122673035, -0.009620998054742813, -0.06041615828871727, 0.030481215566396713, 0.04220159724354744, -0.02712407521903515, -0.027654169127345085, 0.014751732349395752, -0.04119563475251198, -0.028226500377058983, 0.06559622287750244, -0.03517945855855942, -0.04209483787417412, -0.007256979122757912, 0.00985824503004551, 0.022673964500427246, -0.0058998167514801025, 0.043031491339206696, 0.032559413462877274, -0.02750919945538044, 0.03448709100484848, 0.05145486071705818, 0.014550468884408474, -0.012578287161886692, -0.07163075357675552, -0.050622645765542984, -0.01021034549921751, -0.035570405423641205, -0.027781596407294273, 0.00525056105107069, 0.0015614748699590564, -0.07913488894701004, 0.006881908513605595, 0.05803811550140381, 0.003989046439528465, -0.007750682532787323, -0.06476476788520813, 0.017333216965198517, -0.017344549298286438, -0.06297658383846283, -0.06919100880622864, 0.04082620143890381, -0.035681650042533875, 0.03259086236357689, 0.0016678136307746172, -0.01064603216946125, -0.05665477737784386, 0.010867755860090256, -0.08723378926515579, 0.0033870369661599398, -0.03345455601811409, 0.06908483803272247, 0.05666161701083183, 0.008134179748594761, 0.017065050080418587, -0.004753846675157547, 0.006833194755017757, 0.01900303177535534, 0.030045263469219208, 0.021335233002901077, 0.02104983851313591, 0.045751046389341354, -0.05492953583598137, -0.05256495997309685, 0.05275784060359001, -0.0035769608803093433, 0.00023474846966564655, 0.039279505610466, 0.04310904070734978, -0.022370293736457825, 0.02054087072610855, 0.0511455237865448, 0.011628582142293453, 0.030857570469379425, -0.059466402977705, 0.03680219128727913, -0.02606959082186222, -0.06428150832653046, 0.007014624774456024, -0.03995825722813606, 0.01628643088042736, -0.001149453455582261, -0.04994535818696022, -0.029659468680620193, -0.02947324328124523, -0.06412654370069504, 0.039779938757419586, -0.0071766492910683155, -0.01757936179637909, 0.06970033794641495, -0.0315982960164547, 0.019837142899632454, 0.02582736313343048, -0.001254958100616932, -0.05570140853524208, 0.03991750255227089, 0.032011136412620544, -0.019862310960888863, 0.030055105686187744, -0.08459608256816864, 0.05257560685276985, -0.02720090001821518, 0.0007306294282898307, -0.04162270203232765, 0.07268320769071579, 0.00090592767810449, -0.007929598912596703, -0.017757736146450043, 0.02089964970946312, -0.04178294539451599, -0.06589577347040176, -0.024879086762666702, -0.031788598746061325, 0.03251490369439125, 0.020145423710346222, 0.047504112124443054, 0.010971534997224808, 0.07341806590557098, 0.035723451524972916, 0.0312512181699276, -0.015502567403018475, 0.01496462244540453, -0.05409867689013481, 0.05209321901202202, -0.015484008938074112, -0.01878221519291401, -0.039767444133758545, -0.01954454928636551, 0.02445562183856964, -0.03078882396221161, 0.026755083352327347, -0.0009494342375546694, -0.02593233808875084, -0.04773786664009094, 0.01709030196070671, 0.030066976323723793, 0.007366332225501537, -0.038501545786857605, 0.02011844702064991, 0.00685666361823678, -0.026088569313287735, -0.03646028786897659 ]
Software-Defined Networking (SDN) significantly simplifies programming, reconfiguring, and optimizing network devices, such as switches and routers. The de facto standard for programmming SDN devices is the P4 language. However, the flexibility and power of P4, and SDN more generally, gives rise to important risks. As a number of incidents at major cloud providers have shown, errors in SDN programs can compromise the availability of networks, leaving them in a non-functional state. The focus of this paper are errors in control-plane programs that interact with P4-enabled network devices via the standardized P4Runtime API. For clients of the P4Runtime API it is easy to make mistakes that lead to catastrophic failures, despite the use of Google's Protocol Buffers as an interface definition language. This paper proposes P4R-Type, a novel verified P4Runtime API for Scala that performs static checks for P4 control plane operations, ruling out mismatches between P4 tables, allowed actions, and action parameters. As a formal foundation of P4R-Type, we present the $F_{\text{P4R}}$ calculus and its typing system, which ensure that well-typed programs never get stuck by issuing invalid P4Runtime operations. We evaluate the safety and flexibility of P4R-Type with 3 case studies. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work that formalises P4Runtime control plane applications, and a typing discipline ensuring the correctness of P4Runtime operations.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03566v1
[ -0.05249204486608505, -0.03542516008019447, 0.031206276267766953, -0.03483683243393898, 0.03255006670951843, -0.035868339240550995, 0.001336804823949933, -0.007208301220089197, 0.013125482015311718, -0.014631181955337524, -0.014774953946471214, 0.030454790219664574, -0.062000442296266556, -0.046173159033060074, -0.030645960941910744, -0.005160334520041943, 0.08052045106887817, 0.047060392796993256, -0.04138221591711044, 0.06831872463226318, -0.017321351915597916, -0.06243829056620598, -0.05699571967124939, 0.023056091740727425, 0.01817978173494339, -0.024139052256941795, -0.0522797554731369, -0.038357075303792953, -0.030306944623589516, -0.026472171768546104, 0.04630173742771149, -0.02750050090253353, -0.02391611784696579, 0.015303561463952065, -0.053310979157686234, -0.015864254906773567, -0.03604310005903244, 0.05553150922060013, 0.06930616497993469, -0.01981695368885994, 0.03352288529276848, -0.02760469540953636, -0.02045784704387188, -0.038987867534160614, -0.015159727074205875, -0.019508594647049904, -0.06319882720708847, 0.0010391742689535022, 0.027069851756095886, -0.04188431799411774, 0.034493446350097656, 0.004953993018716574, 0.01527722179889679, 0.04269978031516075, -0.06313704699277878, -0.021120304241776466, 0.025625089183449745, 0.002522008493542671, -0.04824959114193916, -0.004607697948813438, 0.016547368839383125, -0.00992724858224392, -0.04417027160525322, -0.012123296037316322, -0.03435760363936424, 0.01620490476489067, -0.025110991671681404, -0.04637659341096878, -0.010855603963136673, -0.0017971012275665998, 0.013173965737223625, -0.06530559062957764, 0.02191997319459915, 0.04956147447228432, -0.0260014608502388, 0.024120070040225983, -0.03673705831170082, 0.01647658832371235, 0.014783840626478195, -0.03571661189198494, -0.012376636266708374, -0.024843517690896988, -0.008609072305262089, -0.0077899303287267685, 0.0029586153104901314, -0.056098245084285736, 0.036301057785749435, 0.03565226122736931, 0.005656293593347073, -0.027445059269666672, 0.036802567541599274, -0.03917473927140236, -0.0920010507106781, -0.020509546622633934, 0.0664786696434021, -0.007552210707217455, 0.04404359310865402, -0.011275541968643665, -0.020862668752670288, -0.047342464327812195, -0.0305178165435791, 0.03591511771082878, -0.0675077885389328, 0.03011409379541874, 0.009477588348090649, 0.015469123609364033, 0.02026701532304287, 0.04679591581225395, -0.060335926711559296, -0.014123249799013138, -0.041900355368852615, 0.0012563940836116672, -0.046686578541994095, -0.07373805344104767, -0.037171754986047745, -0.012910163030028343, 0.04692293331027031, -0.0019484448712319136, 0.03679376095533371, 0.00386541779153049, -0.06175273656845093, 0.01498605776578188, 0.03435400500893593, -0.027282264083623886, -0.06153997778892517, -0.004345025401562452, 0.07060492783784866, -0.028858039528131485, 0.02685263752937317, 0.002297049853950739, -0.01717389188706875, 0.060365933924913406, 0.007905010133981705, -0.0220327265560627, 0.07650991529226303, 0.007136364933103323, 0.00720098614692688, -0.044110674411058426, 0.021122481673955917, -0.04047409072518349, -0.025461075827479362, -0.04695212468504906, -0.004042773507535458, -0.00929963868111372, 0.05092453956604004, 0.06756479293107986, -0.005242085549980402, -0.016658080741763115, -0.004789934027940035, 0.0416950024664402, -0.02047135680913925, -0.00046760900295339525, 0.042663414031267166, 0.023306604474782944, 0.0020479774102568626, 0.008040245622396469, 0.047542087733745575, -0.030351903289556503, -0.06886379420757294, 0.01140958908945322, 0.017800820991396904, 0.01895403116941452, 0.030827339738607407, 0.005099829286336899, 0.00507504865527153, 0.03133537247776985, 0.011110171675682068, 0.007163391914218664, 0.03835911303758621, 0.01049539539963007, -0.06455855071544647, -0.006842201109975576, -0.05494479089975357, -0.024744611233472824, -0.07042789459228516, 0.01969468593597412, 0.03849007189273834, -0.051815178245306015, 0.042911168187856674, 0.012675161473453045, -0.023784637451171875, 0.06384778767824173, -0.033024534583091736, -0.014463135972619057, -0.05844179168343544, -0.015341970138251781, -0.09049475193023682, 0.0005473780911415815, 0.032952528446912766, 0.019071700051426888, -0.03906596079468727, -0.04949118569493294, 0.03490658104419708, -0.03646286576986313, -0.0005015952046960592, -0.010270628146827221, -0.0020700362510979176, -0.0666295662522316, 0.016222724691033363, 0.027576465159654617, -0.07882807403802872, 0.02022368088364601, -0.08124575763940811, 0.023444997146725655, 0.009013279341161251, -0.06318173557519913, 0.014610104262828827, 0.04892498254776001, -0.0399760864675045, -0.008710576221346855, 0.021760428324341774, 0.04618813842535019, 0.08248570561408997, 0.014162762090563774, 0.029159927740693092, 0.011111107654869556, -0.1063074842095375, 0.0530935674905777, 0.01642329804599285, 0.006993430200964212, 0.026847191154956818, -0.03569158539175987, 0.0036071224603801966, -0.021687325090169907, -0.009461027570068836, 0.006638057995587587, 0.0317445807158947, -0.0020072690676897764, -0.03991040214896202, -0.014156211167573929, 0.024640411138534546, -0.0320991687476635, -0.009611068293452263, -0.08704540133476257, 0.028100155293941498, -0.029432643204927444, -0.03053504414856434, 0.02299688570201397, 0.001458035665564239, 0.022866085171699524, -0.06387181580066681, -0.05867390334606171, 0.045231230556964874, -0.01671072095632553, -0.032896533608436584, -0.004707007668912411, -0.03025861829519272, -0.006654105614870787, -0.022111250087618828, 0.007702285889536142, -0.025504471734166145, -0.02811567671597004, -0.02589070238173008, -0.04264514893293381, 0.015795249491930008, 0.04628370702266693, -0.02456383965909481, 0.035750340670347214, -0.017930511385202408, 0.04599806293845177, 0.035753753036260605, 0.04119471088051796, -0.007248517591506243, 0.005155893508344889, 0.008464974351227283, -0.03268137201666832, 0.022617487236857414, 0.03394053503870964, -0.0016049474943429232, -0.011959881521761417, -0.005304647143930197, 0.03474777191877365, 0.021424874663352966, -0.05609166994690895, -0.015534370206296444, 0.007887124083936214, 0.002966874046251178, 0.022372832521796227, -0.0066998484544456005, 0.06797357648611069, 0.044069983065128326, -0.014964287169277668, 0.018633060157299042, -0.08566738665103912, 0.020507028326392174, -0.02828514389693737, -0.000676711555570364, -0.06292255222797394, 0.017900336533784866, -0.07602758705615997, -0.0353657603263855, 0.0022948291152715683, 0.014300696551799774, 0.02813115157186985, 0.018331781029701233, -0.03510650247335434, -0.046410128474235535, -0.014349095523357391, 0.022608956322073936, -0.03939240053296089, -0.05981780216097832, -0.06573118269443512, -0.019692547619342804, 0.04969615116715431, 0.015372365713119507, -0.05336116999387741, -0.011495962738990784, -0.012080758810043335, -0.02184908650815487, 0.05333933234214783, -0.016511114314198494, 0.04593043401837349, -0.05081599950790405, 0.009025933220982552, -0.010673685930669308, -0.023710619658231735, 0.004081161227077246, 0.01368061825633049, -0.024360205978155136, -0.01684105023741722, 0.0178587194532156, -0.006086552049964666, -0.014518987387418747, -0.06914528459310532, -0.017634456977248192, -0.02657477743923664, 0.048387281596660614, -0.01596922241151333, -0.002582239918410778, -0.030763428658246994, 0.03398618847131729, 0.019320908933877945, -0.024898270145058632, -0.014449129812419415, 0.01769995130598545, 0.044104911386966705, -0.02762318216264248, -0.03227222338318825, 0.015076977200806141, 0.017415279522538185, 0.015709765255451202, 0.03787820786237717, 0.01526289526373148, -0.028684522956609726, 0.013671331107616425, -0.07118332386016846, -0.009348176419734955, 0.07079966366291046, 0.0485449843108654, -0.04678835719823837, 0.009021314792335033, -0.016484946012496948, 0.03163802623748779, 0.033493027091026306, -0.048273734748363495, 0.03654789552092552, 0.07732418924570084, 0.028620699420571327, -0.037356119602918625, -0.053905192762613297, 0.010394963435828686, -0.035929713398218155, -0.013895268552005291, 0.0475570447742939, -0.008081240579485893, -0.009634551592171192, -0.034720342606306076, -0.028711823746562004, 0.022661924362182617, -0.006473636254668236, 0.073422871530056, 0.040777742862701416, 0.0013465513475239277, 0.03650812804698944, -0.009839871898293495, 0.025054089725017548, -0.026412082836031914, 0.04359831288456917, 0.012637135572731495, -0.05387267842888832, 0.024830713868141174, -0.0843350887298584, -0.031719524413347244, 0.03086656890809536, -0.017483554780483246, 0.01069599948823452, 0.027168521657586098, -0.00008966186578618363, 0.050215378403663635, 0.013817371800541878, 0.01483331061899662, 0.03660997375845909, 0.018429143354296684, 0.005304532125592232, -0.034056488424539566, -0.048623062670230865, -0.03915300965309143, 0.057622261345386505, -0.01397061999887228, -0.00694319186732173, 0.05304442346096039, -0.022360505536198616, 0.04456374794244766, -0.05731380730867386, 0.02045818604528904, -0.07896684855222702, 0.030285393819212914, -0.007032434456050396, -0.0294062290340662, 0.049946755170822144, -0.026944266632199287, -0.03374572470784187, -0.04473584517836571, -0.055460620671510696, -0.03538183867931366, -0.012845746241509914, -0.0009185946546494961, -0.04595519229769707, -0.02272014133632183, -0.03164020925760269, 0.04718181863427162, 0.024676673114299774, 0.005180935375392437, -0.006075583398342133, 0.015526213683187962, 0.021325629204511642, 0.02601710706949234, 0.050897277891635895, 0.01934744231402874, -0.010190312750637531, 0.008793179877102375, 0.0033326621633023024, 0.03281934931874275, 0.005289882887154818, -0.004051926080137491, -0.03436317294836044, 0.0037233184557408094, -0.004757110495120287, -0.0021912462543696165, 0.019264722242951393, -0.0025423653423786163, 0.04333678260445595, -0.02630990743637085, -0.019493289291858673, 0.026697825640439987, 0.035999398678541183, -0.04412441700696945, -0.06017622724175453, -0.006049318704754114, -0.057583507150411606, -0.07283395528793335, -0.054971810430288315, 0.02404709905385971, 0.0228218212723732, -0.036505114287137985, 0.054562877863645554, 0.016927490010857582, 0.014299080707132816, -0.02528427168726921, 0.0021728980354964733, 0.03467021510004997, -0.020522458478808403, 0.014397988095879555, 0.03152680769562721, -0.05748506262898445, 0.04225531965494156, -0.06807005405426025, 0.01835663616657257, -0.04058350622653961, -0.017145559191703796, -0.002329486422240734, 0.021121229976415634, -0.07034359872341156, 0.02438877709209919, 0.03105769120156765, -0.07209105044603348, 0.005154214799404144, 0.013248896226286888, -0.002913582604378462, 0.04855482652783394, -0.04404764622449875, 0.0058593773283064365, 0.04553451016545296, -0.0076561723835766315, 0.028477059677243233, 0.023857543244957924, -0.04950316622853279, -0.011988695710897446, 0.012345685623586178, 0.030297134071588516, -0.02521623857319355, -0.013414709828794003, 0.06558031588792801, 0.014379024505615234, -0.04529457539319992, 0.03499769791960716, 0.03753507137298584, -0.048638541251420975, 0.022220879793167114, -0.037701524794101715, 0.021300846710801125, 0.0025540594942867756, 0.011808404698967934, -0.019255725666880608, -0.021292855963110924, -0.031485531479120255, 0.006772598717361689, -0.02647753618657589, 0.02112787961959839, 0.015462175942957401, 0.0058906045742332935, -0.034999728202819824, -0.011331476271152496, -0.0424642488360405, 0.015866562724113464, -0.015660012140870094, 0.02392302080988884, 0.0467848964035511, 0.007773745805025101, 0.01992177404463291, -0.0289546437561512, -0.05088182911276817, -0.04250773787498474, -0.018112903460860252, -0.042737215757369995, 0.04618509113788605, 0.022055841982364655, -0.007595736067742109, -0.01953374408185482, 0.042263489216566086, 0.02659641019999981, 0.02525932900607586, -0.033829160034656525, -0.010348130948841572, -0.050196267664432526, 0.026517020538449287, 0.04139889404177666, -0.07927505671977997, -0.044902902096509933, 0.009920407086610794, -0.0067405616864562035, -0.041833147406578064, 0.04314970225095749, 0.0359698049724102, -0.026077711954712868, 0.07164757698774338, 0.055782102048397064, -0.01927763596177101, -0.013521368615329266, 0.0242573581635952, 0.045822933316230774, -0.07104694098234177, 0.021876012906432152, -0.03255621716380119, -0.015918804332613945, 0.04541431739926338, -0.007530864793807268, 0.011066874489188194, 0.03262464329600334, -0.010812852531671524, -0.05271689593791962, 0.006470753811299801, -0.02402610145509243, -0.07985986769199371, 0.015831099823117256, 0.011518058367073536, -0.0663788840174675, 0.03520146757364273, 0.04195502772927284, 0.02400314062833786, -0.04435374215245247, 0.06274723261594772, 0.039550263434648514, -0.03974921628832817, -0.03826255351305008, 0.06472844630479813, 0.05914951115846634, -0.015346251428127289, -0.006794122513383627, 0.021597370505332947, -0.05502685159444809, 0.008962363936007023, -0.036727175116539, -0.034823495894670486, -0.043199729174375534, -0.0014880322851240635, 0.022488662973046303, 0.03219953179359436, -0.02398483082652092, 0.04855424165725708, -0.0022564136888831854, -0.017895007506012917, 0.03814731165766716, -0.04807703197002411, 0.022936558350920677, -0.054901160299777985, -0.0464901365339756, -0.025738097727298737, -0.02325245924293995, 0.028991643339395523, -0.05802610144019127, 0.021619116887450218, -0.029976215213537216, 0.010049317963421345, -0.0007379198214039207, -0.076918825507164, 0.008053014986217022, -0.043786078691482544, -0.08256834000349045, 0.005923181306570768, -0.04940593242645264, -0.030428558588027954, 0.033678699284791946, -0.03527747094631195, -0.026128841564059258, 0.0641402006149292, -0.041095975786447525, 0.00043961292249150574, -0.015584994107484818, -0.016691317781805992, 0.01801767200231552, -0.018830539658665657, -0.04011117294430733, -0.0011533719953149557, 0.03559207171201706, -0.05766081437468529, -0.06563125550746918, -0.0064146206714212894, -0.012637182138860226, 0.03379422798752785, -0.030124692246317863, -0.04656726494431496, -0.008578958921134472, -0.002403625752776861, -0.035315461456775665, 0.026408853009343147, -0.02898157201707363, -0.026400823146104813, -0.09487131983041763, -0.040424101054668427, 0.023067764937877655, 0.04878902807831764, 0.03720271959900856, 0.048193566501140594, 0.029334688559174538, -0.0314197838306427, 0.07583945989608765, -0.010764829814434052, 0.04427962377667427, 0.022022737190127373, -0.07166711241006851, -0.008480123244225979, 0.020586462691426277, -0.012442388571798801, -0.019871462136507034, -0.03548423945903778, 0.00503444392234087, -0.0602661594748497, -0.009664727374911308, 0.03183162212371826, 0.005283658858388662, -0.05174556002020836, -0.07401303201913834, 0.04422875866293907, 0.005311968736350536, -0.026374278590083122, -0.022007551044225693, -0.0075307381339371204, 0.038686592131853104, -0.06987841427326202, 0.03846658021211624, -0.006986597552895546, -0.014101683162152767, 0.01912795752286911, -0.0790482759475708, -0.030881118029356003, 0.018503563478589058, 0.048286691308021545, 0.04327419400215149, -0.016176952049136162, -0.033528827130794525, -0.05253324657678604, -0.007365760859102011, -0.010385625064373016, 0.0015951477689668536, -0.01182033121585846, 0.020466776564717293, -0.00986209511756897, -0.01185702346265316, -0.005089253187179565, 0.032696682959795, -0.0026124450378119946, -0.054165229201316833, 0.0625700056552887, 0.015662645921111107, 0.02448093518614769, -0.004268178250640631, 0.032976310700178146, -0.047860316932201385, 0.02494245395064354, -0.047035057097673416, 0.012014259584248066, -0.05297865718603134, -0.05766056478023529, 0.026420895010232925, -0.07561073452234268, -0.04676815867424011, 0.04952164366841316, -0.014983083121478558, 0.0018155976431444287, -0.031150298193097115, -0.0543951615691185, 0.048322368413209915, -0.0267519261687994, -0.013322088867425919, 0.037516966462135315, -0.055631428956985474, -0.03335622698068619, -0.02045876905322075, -0.022067571058869362, -0.0018977608997374773, 0.03527181223034859, 0.04074724763631821, -0.047905005514621735, -0.002572821220383048, -0.030968446284532547, 0.018743079155683517, 0.02766813524067402, 0.005061128176748753, -0.033592432737350464, 0.07193981111049652, 0.05290508642792702, 0.0033147556241601706, -0.034038711339235306, -0.016039229929447174, -0.0362139530479908, -0.08504347503185272, -0.04569390416145325, -0.03922691568732262, 0.004628798458725214, 0.026150448247790337, -0.011701233685016632, 0.020585887134075165, 0.01425232831388712, 0.028348024934530258, 0.029311537742614746, 0.023993849754333496, 0.04417623206973076, -0.03678785264492035, 0.05512690544128418, 0.012806539423763752, 0.04094231128692627, -0.02872464805841446, 0.03366200998425484, -0.02498549409210682, 0.038528647273778915, -0.0033842716366052628, -0.015741726383566856, 0.027351979166269302, -0.012059882283210754, 0.0057745566591620445, -0.006040021311491728, 0.00039974547689780593, -0.024844035506248474, 0.000023255071937455796, 0.017901169136166573, 0.00046587319229729474, -0.03844437748193741 ]
Let $f:[0,1]^d\to\mathbb{R}$ be a completely monotone integrand as defined by Aistleitner and Dick (2015) and let points $\boldsymbol{x}_0,\dots,\boldsymbol{x}_{n-1}\in[0,1]^d$ have a non-negative local discrepancy (NNLD) everywhere in $[0,1]^d$. We show how to use these properties to get a non-asymptotic and computable upper bound for the integral of $f$ over $[0,1]^d$. An analogous non-positive local discrepancy (NPLD) property provides a computable lower bound. It has been known since Gabai (1967) that the two dimensional Hammersley points in any base $b\ge2$ have non-negative local discrepancy. Using the probabilistic notion of associated random variables, we generalize Gabai's finding to digital nets in any base $b\ge2$ and any dimension $d\ge1$ when the generator matrices are permutation matrices. We show that permutation matrices cannot attain the best values of the digital net quality parameter when $d\ge3$. As a consequence the computable absolutely sure bounds we provide come with less accurate estimates than the usual digital net estimates do in high dimensions. We are also able to construct high dimensional rank one lattice rules that are NNLD. We show that those lattices do not have good discrepancy properties: any lattice rule with the NNLD property in dimension $d\ge2$ either fails to be projection regular or has all its points on the main diagonal. Complete monotonicity is a very strict requirement that for some integrands can be mitigated via a control variate.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04209v2
[ -0.04771120846271515, -0.050154849886894226, 0.03471389412879944, -0.02897275611758232, 0.020429261028766632, 0.0341830849647522, -0.03390831872820854, 0.012242797762155533, -0.041921935975551605, -0.02696773037314415, -0.01594139263033867, -0.05531641095876694, -0.03985952213406563, -0.052985310554504395, -0.04839636757969856, -0.028800977393984795, 0.04227093979716301, -0.007301780395209789, -0.025213856250047684, 0.039352383464574814, -0.030661042779684067, -0.04453396424651146, -0.03490738943219185, 0.050995610654354095, -0.042574431747198105, -0.044852498918771744, -0.0021774049382656813, -0.03449084982275963, -0.03434184566140175, -0.022342130541801453, 0.05384109914302826, -0.008945152163505554, 0.017622290179133415, -0.03803304210305214, -0.028528958559036255, 0.04802292212843895, -0.019382117316126823, -0.0029391467105597258, -0.01698971539735794, -0.06555446982383728, 0.004990255925804377, -0.03341733664274216, -0.044927436858415604, -0.05674639716744423, 0.006183600518852472, -0.00585729256272316, -0.023809462785720825, -0.027827899903059006, -0.030726855620741844, -0.04089609906077385, 0.03888942301273346, -0.010184135288000107, -0.018430184572935104, 0.027376437559723854, -0.021008145064115524, -0.01761477068066597, 0.006241912953555584, -0.006148230284452438, -0.05939023941755295, -0.017993565648794174, 0.040874186903238297, -0.05238964036107063, -0.025825532153248787, -0.02800898253917694, -0.038891710340976715, 0.02102835103869438, -0.049347829073667526, -0.05590825155377388, -0.016013149172067642, -0.036679334938526154, -0.022888580337166786, -0.05312751606106758, -0.012259041890501976, -0.018224522471427917, -0.06567136943340302, 0.03460186347365379, -0.026039548218250275, -0.0007871293346397579, -0.041589055210351944, 0.022163186222314835, -0.044871143996715546, 0.002523831557482481, 0.0045537808910012245, 0.010362746194005013, 0.030337898060679436, 0.0072989859618246555, 0.057149745523929596, -0.04073769599199295, 0.03309387341141701, -0.03737296536564827, -0.03551953658461571, -0.057367466390132904, -0.06688235700130463, -0.04301263019442558, 0.057581815868616104, -0.05697425454854965, 0.04182489588856697, -0.004980136640369892, 0.0295404139906168, 0.014402173459529877, -0.0108953220769763, -0.053445179015398026, -0.013765200972557068, 0.008435171097517014, -0.02558208256959915, -0.04377859830856323, -0.03740473836660385, -0.0307044368237257, -0.056848037987947464, 0.04166373237967491, 0.013576079159975052, 0.009309977293014526, -0.0449993759393692, -0.03439551219344139, -0.040682923048734665, -0.05735442787408829, 0.028292885050177574, 0.004627856891602278, 0.04410938546061516, 0.016558676958084106, 0.006261591333895922, -0.01119970716536045, 0.043936822563409805, -0.051978014409542084, -0.01637854427099228, -0.03534392639994621, 0.04399276524782181, -0.014143146574497223, 0.045087553560733795, 0.039712388068437576, -0.032344572246074677, -0.031469278037548065, 0.05549506098031998, -0.02657347545027733, 0.044012315571308136, 0.01224873960018158, -0.030520247295498848, -0.03883364424109459, -0.0353543721139431, 0.05412885546684265, -0.03909873962402344, -0.05188994109630585, -0.01079939678311348, 0.005578732118010521, 0.022758368402719498, 0.019561562687158585, -0.06162815913558006, 0.0164970513433218, 0.039347920566797256, 0.023929037153720856, 0.004548619966953993, -0.0031801192089915276, 0.02381271682679653, 0.02509802207350731, 0.0014170726062729955, -0.02677498385310173, 0.030763980001211166, -0.03370779752731323, -0.05423135310411453, -0.003943422343581915, 0.043850865215063095, 0.01614665798842907, -0.022793691605329514, -0.012930304743349552, 0.005251748021692038, 0.040006767958402634, 0.019895190373063087, -0.03205886483192444, 0.005171761382371187, 0.030740248039364815, -0.020377667620778084, -0.028478950262069702, 0.019775638356804848, -0.05415438115596771, -0.04190913215279579, -0.030023232102394104, -0.0020912697073072195, -0.057065192610025406, -0.03400620445609093, -0.0058177197352051735, 0.020330434665083885, -0.008920203894376755, -0.0293379258364439, 0.017059005796909332, -0.052240584045648575, 0.014340871013700962, -0.059434644877910614, -0.023201093077659607, -0.008070318028330803, 0.031409651041030884, -0.009306322783231735, -0.046148039400577545, 0.0056887902319431305, 0.013914347626268864, -0.03738009184598923, -0.032704729586839676, 0.0035079922527074814, -0.051172543317079544, -0.04786008596420288, -0.009357364848256111, -0.0645684078335762, -0.058848749846220016, -0.051928263157606125, 0.03952211141586304, -0.03263091295957565, -0.05511467158794403, -0.0036449155304580927, 0.03456830978393555, 0.0001702810695860535, -0.029709627851843834, 0.06317800283432007, -0.01183264795690775, 0.04773494973778725, -0.025046641007065773, -0.01568092219531536, -0.02098245732486248, -0.07088270038366318, 0.059296105057001114, -0.022899502888321877, 0.0061365594156086445, -0.01198991946876049, 0.0032562853302806616, -0.025411877781152725, -0.055511195212602615, -0.04305484890937805, 0.05658990517258644, 0.05872366204857826, 0.033451467752456665, -0.04699065908789635, -0.045219626277685165, -0.03452208638191223, -0.06405983865261078, -0.03765784949064255, -0.0413610078394413, 0.0011549582704901695, -0.00903793703764677, -0.05154355242848396, 0.04343905299901962, -0.006796319968998432, -0.0028169492725282907, -0.040193669497966766, 0.030573587864637375, 0.04902789369225502, -0.019975265488028526, -0.0386931337416172, 0.003873562440276146, -0.010026401840150356, 0.047582801431417465, -0.053311966359615326, 0.01145735289901495, -0.006746015045791864, -0.059723153710365295, 0.0016859272727742791, -0.05161021649837494, 0.031207013875246048, 0.0014989553019404411, -0.03497132286429405, 0.03573254123330116, -0.0005040827090851963, 0.04466070979833603, -0.01174950785934925, 0.010305412113666534, -0.05104201287031174, -0.051360953599214554, 0.039204422384500504, -0.0023432110901921988, -0.06044234335422516, -0.013210805132985115, 0.02004777081310749, 0.00166172010358423, 0.02143797092139721, -0.03091180883347988, 0.06045021489262581, -0.0065171862952411175, -0.011410103179514408, 0.03485643118619919, -0.04222920536994934, 0.006147690583020449, 0.0487963929772377, -0.03545241430401802, 0.057139020413160324, 0.034286484122276306, -0.020292920991778374, -0.06657402217388153, -0.05386234074831009, -0.0005234585260041058, -0.015042564831674099, -0.06008436158299446, -0.065821573138237, -0.0469525009393692, -0.06685259193181992, 0.00758141465485096, -0.05842770263552666, -0.052884794771671295, -0.05710065737366676, -0.06562692672014236, -0.02780339866876602, -0.027936233207583427, -0.014392703771591187, -0.06149349734187126, -0.02068658359348774, 0.013597792945802212, -0.017501799389719963, 0.01896500401198864, -0.019575191661715508, -0.05213236063718796, -0.04546643793582916, -0.017900336533784866, -0.030072864145040512, 0.007562489714473486, -0.025337740778923035, -0.009193764068186283, -0.05581054836511612, -0.011644609272480011, 0.008882362395524979, 0.021461186930537224, -0.03479292243719101, -0.011301187798380852, 0.045542456209659576, -0.027832111343741417, -0.00440725265070796, -0.011260376311838627, 0.028120430186390877, -0.03569108992815018, -0.06520146876573563, -0.05297860503196716, 0.03868989273905754, 0.050755832344293594, -0.04866085574030876, -0.022211354225873947, -0.018113957718014717, -0.03850976377725601, 0.03150216490030289, -0.022471556439995766, 0.031015265733003616, -0.0038657723926007748, -0.025273233652114868, -0.029605483636260033, -0.029844578355550766, 0.00788489356637001, 0.02792993374168873, 0.006471601314842701, -0.02937881276011467, -0.0265011228621006, 0.006175569724291563, -0.06777834892272949, 0.03278401121497154, 0.04939271882176399, 0.04584365338087082, -0.02134401723742485, -0.029724160209298134, 0.04127953574061394, -0.01625756174325943, 0.015427760779857635, -0.04054807499051094, 0.0009978854795917869, 0.03817184269428253, 0.04125382378697395, -0.03582148998975754, -0.04468443989753723, -0.033510901033878326, -0.03371184691786766, 0.025370696559548378, 0.057155150920152664, -0.01407942920923233, 0.03157152608036995, 0.028979994356632233, -0.0015606788219884038, 0.029897820204496384, -0.022224055603146553, 0.0572507344186306, -0.04276159778237343, -0.009066405706107616, 0.04418100789189339, -0.004621194675564766, -0.030802538618445396, 0.010324392467737198, -0.02285727672278881, -0.005871076136827469, -0.05242359638214111, 0.02342567779123783, -0.05737203732132912, 0.004306603688746691, 0.03701737895607948, 0.012683600187301636, -0.012275919318199158, -0.005315185058861971, -0.02620430290699005, 0.055061522871255875, -0.03375563025474548, -0.03514425456523895, 0.02649562992155552, 0.00960049033164978, -0.006970144808292389, -0.006304670125246048, -0.052103910595178604, 0.013401193544268608, 0.013692193664610386, -0.037229325622320175, -0.011454788967967033, 0.03661017864942551, -0.04783686250448227, -0.009561274200677872, -0.0681772530078888, -0.025637611746788025, -0.04587734863162041, -0.017513206228613853, -0.03022664040327072, -0.05543537810444832, 0.03490835428237915, 0.0026774799916893244, -0.03947838395833969, 0.010135610587894917, -0.04264184087514877, -0.04117944836616516, 0.010095725767314434, -0.04021386802196503, -0.05605662241578102, -0.035278454422950745, -0.04945136979222298, 0.04607105627655983, 0.012966725043952465, -0.03238745033740997, -0.055571358650922775, -0.014500999823212624, -0.030780266970396042, -0.010538420639932156, 0.03309740126132965, 0.05101354792714119, 0.05979832261800766, -0.01956993341445923, -0.029209595173597336, -0.02075044997036457, -0.03388186916708946, -0.027211889624595642, -0.019489331170916557, 0.014679981395602226, -0.03811955824494362, -0.034775689244270325, -0.044818710535764694, -0.026749635115265846, 0.0014731739647686481, -0.045890726149082184, -0.026067307218909264, -0.005479127634316683, 0.008411160670220852, -0.06416185200214386, -0.04656204953789711, -0.015621090307831764, -0.020651109516620636, -0.06091458722949028, -0.006754837930202484, -0.0102913286536932, 0.038977984338998795, 0.02282651513814926, 0.033713649958372116, -0.05329889431595802, 0.007922003045678139, -0.039896514266729355, -0.0013265354791656137, 0.04531186819076538, 0.02141266129910946, -0.023453768342733383, -0.027178123593330383, -0.04225838929414749, -0.03347841650247574, -0.06484109908342361, -0.02089613862335682, 0.038331422954797745, 0.012792141176760197, 0.021355729550123215, 0.05243834853172302, -0.06735839694738388, 0.03467395156621933, 0.035848136991262436, -0.015676727518439293, -0.03573611006140709, 0.030234284698963165, -0.030310971662402153, -0.0385158509016037, -0.03770160302519798, -0.0018178350292146206, -0.008991626091301441, -0.000023493108528782614, -0.03582312539219856, -0.04838601127266884, -0.04044507071375847, -0.045252032577991486, 0.04946514591574669, -0.008396279998123646, -0.05919800326228142, -0.021922588348388672, -0.01527880784124136, 0.0013000835897400975, -0.05022837966680527, 0.041645947843790054, 0.006932100746780634, -0.06440939754247665, -0.06636658310890198, -0.02645212784409523, -0.0069078016094863415, 0.005541379097849131, 0.01998254284262657, -0.03433740884065628, 0.0296658743172884, 0.048527706414461136, -0.06418687850236893, 0.0227721706032753, -0.008382880128920078, 0.0013857233570888638, 0.024847116321325302, -0.021386148408055305, 0.009521699510514736, -0.04092220962047577, -0.01600126177072525, -0.018055368214845657, 0.03785797581076622, 0.054229285567998886, -0.020368989557027817, -0.027742581441998482, 0.05198623239994049, -0.02314899116754532, -0.018843499943614006, -0.012209349311888218, -0.028388556092977524, 0.0346161313354969, -0.03843865171074867, 0.03376927599310875, -0.0027146239299327135, 0.04723113030195236, -0.04485342279076576, -0.04789460822939873, 0.003586238482967019, -0.022514065727591515, -0.028659850358963013, 0.014285709708929062, 0.02617345005273819, 0.02382180094718933, -0.030472595244646072, -0.019779186695814133, 0.0036928874906152487, -0.052998241037130356, 0.048855312168598175, 0.04400259256362915, 0.024321258068084717, 0.03363143652677536, -0.00010634453792590648, 0.053662970662117004, -0.04988357424736023, -0.036379896104335785, 0.05470375344157219, -0.020820166915655136, 0.02372322604060173, -0.031033894047141075, -0.05670860409736633, -0.032114334404468536, -0.036385368555784225, -0.01286196056753397, 0.0185987651348114, -0.007092134561389685, -0.057836394757032394, 0.054188694804906845, 0.0025398677680641413, -0.06016618385910988, -0.045153651386499405, 0.002662925748154521, -0.062030233442783356, 0.010622802190482616, -0.0367392860352993, -0.04967401176691055, -0.02901533618569374, -0.013536537066102028, -0.05521933361887932, -0.04593103379011154, -0.05660863220691681, 0.059200286865234375, 0.06366652995347977, -0.04811976104974747, 0.057958655059337616, 0.03855030611157417, -0.02073044888675213, 0.03261781111359596, -0.061393074691295624, -0.013642842881381512, -0.030326947569847107, 0.00670936843380332, -0.025089869275689125, -0.01879505068063736, -0.03498296067118645, 0.03916643187403679, -0.03431978076696396, -0.009079774841666222, 0.038169749081134796, 0.018321439623832703, 0.020812584087252617, -0.025752250105142593, -0.057285748422145844, 0.022542569786310196, -0.021563615649938583, -0.04891825467348099, -0.053269289433956146, 0.046147529035806656, -0.03275405988097191, -0.002948879962787032, -0.019298486411571503, -0.015531645156443119, -0.017390286549925804, 0.015982290729880333, -0.04240928217768669, -0.049354489892721176, -0.062231000512838364, 0.018871968612074852, -0.02408197894692421, 0.040315017104148865, 0.034373506903648376, 0.03666361793875694, -0.042126160115003586, -0.0219173151999712, -0.04256824776530266, 0.005666595418006182, -0.02782348357141018, 0.002872059354558587, 0.007397742476314306, -0.037074536085128784, 0.06563878059387207, -0.0599428191781044, 0.047303877770900726, -0.041911110281944275, -0.04909640923142433, 0.051972463726997375, -0.03496195003390312, -0.05010798200964928, -0.004843600559979677, 0.049860671162605286, -0.06538624316453934, 0.025325575843453407, 0.004352390766143799, -0.05934460088610649, -0.060981635004282, 0.0024686723481863737, -0.04115377739071846, -0.015334353782236576, -0.005629411432892084, -0.014279552735388279, 0.0399337038397789, 0.012318248860538006, 0.03270120918750763, 0.02604489028453827, 0.01627255603671074, -0.0042092036455869675, -0.058101654052734375, 0.01867554523050785, -0.01821480132639408, 0.011875683441758156, -0.0328519344329834, -0.046762362122535706, -0.05961361527442932, -0.03641722351312637, 0.03318478539586067, -0.04056933894753456, 0.02452423796057701, -0.04149521142244339, -0.055597707629203796, 0.03132642060518265, 0.022462857887148857, 0.0280762892216444, -0.06720870733261108, -0.020949378609657288, 0.005533791612833738, 0.044883958995342255, 0.019505470991134644, -0.028445091098546982, -0.029777048155665398, 0.05037927255034447, -0.07005134224891663, -0.02334282547235489, 0.020154684782028198, 0.030545178800821304, 0.0031321931164711714, 0.007370715029537678, -0.039310310035943985, -0.0368039570748806, -0.04924371466040611, 0.003676133695989847, -0.044731736183166504, 0.02770160883665085, 0.020952394232153893, -0.03798902407288551, -0.002300058724358678, -0.021735407412052155, 0.033899273723363876, -0.025922676548361778, -0.05716374143958092, 0.04751511663198471, -0.0010989062720909715, -0.03753940016031265, -0.026528360322117805, 0.06612017750740051, -0.029282161965966225, 0.03911508992314339, -0.02094559371471405, -0.04113974794745445, -0.05323289707303047, -0.06278303265571594, 0.03321909159421921, -0.06495491415262222, 0.0037311064079403877, -0.03809521347284317, -0.04791105538606644, -0.06537275016307831, -0.0607123076915741, -0.04195471480488777, -0.030066121369600296, 0.05233413726091385, -0.02331753820180893, -0.013282565400004387, -0.044825516641139984, -0.049111876636743546, -0.004633266478776932, -0.0017913210904225707, -0.041495148092508316, -0.06101340427994728, 0.026627443730831146, -0.037413809448480606, 0.0016798509750515223, -0.05788138881325722, 0.032852862030267715, -0.02491454966366291, -0.008315284736454487, 0.05312599986791611, 0.03406215086579323, 0.001264926278963685, 0.03397933766245842, -0.03193148598074913, -0.03126552700996399, 0.02229941263794899, -0.06364931911230087, 0.0180666521191597, -0.012806706130504608, 0.04546257480978966, 0.051501210778951645, 0.0433850958943367, -0.03879283741116524, 0.04437856748700142, -0.01969330385327339, -0.019993973895907402, 0.06305931508541107, 0.019037572667002678, 0.02300712652504444, 0.013570545241236687, -0.012207278981804848, -0.04775397107005119, -0.055676743388175964, 0.04294663295149803, -0.021407248452305794, -0.03563990071415901, -0.026971343904733658, 0.0031044359784573317, 0.039137572050094604, -0.05837630480527878, 0.03379649668931961, 0.02344261109828949, 0.021038049831986427, -0.040185295045375824, 0.04179742932319641, 0.01969589665532112, -0.03621731698513031, -0.06320910155773163 ]
As Diffusion Models have shown promising performance, a lot of efforts have been made to improve the controllability of Diffusion Models. However, how to train Diffusion Models to have the disentangled latent spaces and how to naturally incorporate the disentangled conditions during the sampling process have been underexplored. In this paper, we present a training framework for feature disentanglement of Diffusion Models (FDiff). We further propose two sampling methods that can boost the realism of our Diffusion Models and also enhance the controllability. Concisely, we train Diffusion Models conditioned on two latent features, a spatial content mask, and a flattened style embedding. We rely on the inductive bias of the denoising process of Diffusion Models to encode pose/layout information in the content feature and semantic/style information in the style feature. Regarding the sampling methods, we first generalize Composable Diffusion Models (GCDM) by breaking the conditional independence assumption to allow for some dependence between conditional inputs, which is shown to be effective in realistic generation in our experiments. Second, we propose timestep-dependent weight scheduling for content and style features to further improve the performance. We also observe better controllability of our proposed methods compared to existing methods in image manipulation and image translation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14368v3
[ -0.03022148087620735, -0.00805420521646738, 0.027099017053842545, 0.00379828829318285, -0.010659907944500446, 0.0006394123192876577, -0.01262105256319046, 0.016921715810894966, -0.005055603105574846, 0.0035375794395804405, -0.051356006413698196, -0.026393499225378036, -0.04949337989091873, -0.03862611949443817, -0.018475208431482315, 0.006717773620039225, 0.0732116550207138, -0.024988770484924316, -0.03675348684191704, 0.05944352596998215, -0.019985947757959366, -0.01349057536572218, -0.06208058074116707, 0.05042723938822746, 0.018863623961806297, 0.02509971708059311, -0.023496203124523163, -0.02457435429096222, -0.043119706213474274, -0.02118927612900734, 0.053045157343149185, 0.004165598191320896, 0.02895878441631794, -0.03940583020448685, -0.05782870948314667, -0.002435536589473486, -0.040831733494997025, -0.01460259035229683, 0.05517404526472092, -0.06198691204190254, 0.0400000661611557, -0.052705563604831696, -0.0621783547103405, 0.013242191635072231, -0.03808394446969032, 0.03710436448454857, 0.013725550845265388, 0.02448924072086811, -0.06671632826328278, -0.035046808421611786, 0.000574843434151262, -0.015208574943244457, -0.01045092660933733, 0.0284977238625288, -0.04756612330675125, 0.021059367805719376, -0.0346987247467041, 0.007948312908411026, -0.07237744331359863, -0.05150137096643448, 0.025323932990431786, -0.0309307724237442, 0.02439410239458084, 0.0018025839235633612, 0.023361410945653915, -0.0025681869592517614, -0.029231777414679527, -0.046049389988183975, -0.02823113277554512, -0.06390219926834106, 0.04246353358030319, -0.04909129813313484, 0.0017898895312100649, 0.04303664714097977, -0.04492645338177681, -0.004258796107023954, -0.05790457874536514, -0.030493414029479027, -0.00838942639529705, -0.0011090736370533705, -0.021609174087643623, 0.034216418862342834, 0.03130212798714638, 0.01214707549661398, 0.0004463205114006996, -0.018618140369653702, 0.006229864899069071, -0.01609126478433609, 0.01268317922949791, -0.0272369347512722, 0.01604745164513588, -0.03504525497555733, -0.06498614698648453, 0.014149977825582027, 0.06635202467441559, -0.0330021046102047, 0.06764541566371918, 0.014400016516447067, 0.03262331709265709, -0.03823695331811905, 0.004652750212699175, -0.0030199084430933, -0.0373222790658474, 0.024191200733184814, 0.027498943731188774, -0.03888808563351631, 0.03516124561429024, 0.011862928979098797, -0.03335651010274887, 0.009710860438644886, -0.02325541153550148, 0.0006982652703300118, 0.022340666502714157, -0.05803922563791275, -0.03731829673051834, -0.025240564718842506, 0.03190995007753372, -0.027235103771090508, 0.031865477561950684, 0.03817211464047432, -0.0014487782027572393, 0.03114275634288788, -0.018993515521287918, -0.009608565829694271, -0.033829111605882645, -0.02046678029000759, 0.06517838686704636, 0.013236716389656067, -0.03221111744642258, -0.005459411069750786, -0.045549552887678146, -0.042667753994464874, 0.016137810423970222, -0.04340432956814766, 0.06715867668390274, -0.04942343384027481, 0.008487901650369167, -0.05415353178977966, 0.011922325007617474, 0.010569737292826176, -0.0411728136241436, -0.0811963602900505, 0.027432503178715706, -0.004831437952816486, 0.02301287092268467, 0.05643773078918457, -0.054096661508083344, -0.01220909133553505, 0.022751005366444588, 0.023170704022049904, 0.047327931970357895, -0.01896616257727146, 0.03509998321533203, 0.025514649227261543, -0.016042150557041168, -0.04569458216428757, 0.06322778016328812, -0.003764142980799079, -0.0238907840102911, 0.011160803958773613, 0.009180475026369095, -0.052438415586948395, 0.0615045540034771, -0.024892868474125862, 0.04521333798766136, -0.034819573163986206, 0.024055127054452896, 0.0070833503268659115, -0.04027406871318817, 0.010196318849921227, -0.027071556076407433, 0.007461237721145153, 0.008825423195958138, -0.004576548468321562, -0.05812913179397583, -0.02199467457830906, -0.0027825485449284315, -0.03478914499282837, -0.045891083776950836, -0.005637633614242077, 0.012235111556947231, 0.018654586747288704, -0.07571770995855331, -0.03380289301276207, -0.05191788449883461, -0.005780304782092571, -0.08532392233610153, -0.03835225850343704, 0.028525792062282562, 0.010896597988903522, -0.05990856885910034, -0.028583737090229988, 0.007409941870719194, 0.026500707492232323, -0.054806750267744064, -0.026377541944384575, 0.03125626966357231, 0.004234340973198414, 0.022993765771389008, 0.021038588136434555, -0.08626426011323929, -0.025779562070965767, -0.0639977753162384, 0.01449474599212408, -0.004243647214025259, -0.025530602782964706, -0.04007011279463768, 0.02755128964781761, -0.06490512192249298, 0.0051061129197478294, 0.028082536533474922, 0.0363864004611969, 0.04398532211780548, -0.0006356840603984892, 0.02599688433110714, 0.008090152405202389, -0.09722038358449936, 0.015097230672836304, 0.0035364790819585323, -0.0009026821353472769, 0.02388758771121502, 0.05686735361814499, 0.011301151476800442, -0.03545662388205528, 0.0031640571542084217, 0.020143305882811546, 0.07166074961423874, -0.047507308423519135, -0.03815588727593422, 0.0005670502432622015, -0.009400377050042152, -0.0339798703789711, -0.020554758608341217, -0.05144171789288521, -0.04429146647453308, -0.02261413261294365, 0.01851833425462246, 0.043941155076026917, 0.03529876098036766, -0.0264433603733778, -0.028414437547326088, -0.017738373950123787, 0.0559946671128273, -0.013796508312225342, -0.03543253615498543, -0.048914048820734024, -0.019405191764235497, 0.03253953903913498, -0.014892692677676678, 0.021354075521230698, -0.030810292810201645, -0.05731362849473953, -0.028035804629325867, 0.013908740133047104, 0.046603646129369736, 0.06047927215695381, -0.050079166889190674, -0.0032113667111843824, -0.0018200628692284226, 0.06347502022981644, 0.015049939975142479, 0.04016890749335289, -0.042761534452438354, 0.01282120868563652, 0.032336339354515076, 0.02033262327313423, -0.03990679606795311, -0.05788201838731766, -0.023829754441976547, -0.04177464544773102, 0.011468704789876938, 0.012856939807534218, 0.053753480315208435, 0.0183988269418478, 0.02321603149175644, -0.0029246751219034195, -0.018506424501538277, -0.031489048153162, 0.025584829971194267, 0.03620011359453201, 0.035114727914333344, 0.01716638170182705, 0.012010137550532818, -0.058532360941171646, 0.0014035298954695463, -0.056162599474191666, -0.0065137227065861225, -0.06446302682161331, -0.06659489125013351, -0.04532421752810478, -0.06133999302983284, -0.05230217054486275, -0.015125004574656487, 0.004992738366127014, -0.019780069589614868, -0.053664080798625946, -0.005465639755129814, -0.0075428723357617855, 0.03804657980799675, -0.011241179890930653, -0.04394109919667244, -0.026277178898453712, -0.01987786777317524, 0.030376892536878586, 0.01812048628926277, -0.04157678782939911, -0.06764522939920425, -0.03144678846001625, 0.016131620854139328, -0.01636471599340439, -0.04539383947849274, 0.03891630098223686, -0.009713849984109402, -0.01681329496204853, -0.02547365054488182, 0.06051110476255417, 0.0331561453640461, 0.043084267526865005, -0.006999656092375517, -0.01672394573688507, 0.024117927998304367, 0.02279778942465782, 0.008151176385581493, -0.009674636647105217, -0.05151428282260895, -0.035822875797748566, 0.04965365305542946, -0.010403625667095184, -0.02965250238776207, -0.0007932016742415726, -0.035385601222515106, -0.0001889664272312075, 0.003340421011671424, -0.018821781501173973, 0.06638718396425247, 0.06012529507279396, 0.0013528922572731972, -0.049604207277297974, 0.002002290915697813, -0.011531716212630272, -0.030469343066215515, 0.014526696875691414, -0.0631534606218338, -0.0025675164069980383, 0.035792600363492966, -0.08541823923587799, 0.04300551116466522, 0.047264400869607925, 0.06382125616073608, -0.01133653987199068, -0.004584016744047403, -0.046804338693618774, 0.006887536495923996, 0.015945062041282654, 0.03641395643353462, 0.04727146402001381, 0.02379722148180008, 0.015871789306402206, -0.023799089714884758, -0.06696528941392899, 0.007207746151834726, -0.06784295290708542, -0.052795182913541794, 0.05183388292789459, 0.02930004708468914, -0.008862996473908424, 0.013891716487705708, -0.06670655310153961, 0.06263323873281479, -0.031241079792380333, 0.05468550696969032, -0.02042962796986103, -0.06709504127502441, 0.03640167415142059, -0.06198754534125328, 0.03817084804177284, 0.021791569888591766, -0.015949146822094917, -0.011116483248770237, -0.05574176460504532, 0.042340513318777084, -0.02366161160171032, 0.04956621304154396, 0.034687142819166183, 0.012983792461454868, 0.035823337733745575, 0.044948652386665344, 0.02404388040304184, 0.05498846247792244, -0.03115564025938511, -0.045213621109724045, 0.016125503927469254, 0.0009175598388537765, -0.015052895992994308, -0.019859813153743744, -0.07457991689443588, -0.007644386496394873, 0.027270162478089333, 0.003605248173698783, -0.024761144071817398, 0.035895492881536484, -0.049553580582141876, -0.01879289001226425, -0.07995439320802689, -0.020327361300587654, -0.04555048048496246, 0.050736360251903534, 0.018337266519665718, -0.05985752493143082, 0.048433877527713776, -0.02227061428129673, 0.010951319709420204, 0.024106061086058617, 0.0037105379160493612, -0.048116832971572876, -0.03441854193806648, -0.02071847766637802, -0.0670485645532608, 0.05862075090408325, -0.0700412318110466, 0.03989090025424957, 0.020840641111135483, -0.024112872779369354, -0.030231859534978867, 0.012715104036033154, -0.02552657388150692, 0.024972381070256233, 0.048118993639945984, 0.00008862715912982821, -0.014820742420852184, -0.013349159620702267, -0.010837185196578503, 0.01742834597826004, -0.02758566290140152, 0.008796392008662224, -0.03504413366317749, 0.049452044069767, -0.03511224687099457, -0.019793273881077766, -0.02825084514915943, 0.006197473034262657, 0.059175293892621994, -0.045596495270729065, -0.03690218925476074, -0.034510985016822815, 0.048442017287015915, -0.044037073850631714, -0.06327235698699951, 0.014552227221429348, 0.012309886515140533, -0.056077685207128525, -0.05053354799747467, 0.025989847257733345, 0.04467787966132164, 0.03621342033147812, -0.01923402026295662, 0.013501579873263836, -0.00007427560194628313, 0.012537132948637009, 0.012117194943130016, 0.03414224833250046, -0.020798133686184883, -0.010836899280548096, -0.039647579193115234, -0.08223000168800354, 0.006225693039596081, -0.01478132326155901, -0.0015687242848798633, -0.02673535794019699, 0.05094781890511513, -0.004390071611851454, 0.03980544954538345, -0.08742683380842209, -0.0031736623495817184, 0.03812333941459656, -0.020569905638694763, 0.033326003700494766, 0.0490814670920372, -0.010869566351175308, 0.028735438361763954, -0.0504947230219841, 0.050056952983140945, -0.021731460466980934, -0.018461884930729866, -0.018857331946492195, 0.02246338129043579, -0.017436768859624863, -0.026082031428813934, 0.06266371160745621, 0.016856137663125992, -0.048241667449474335, 0.03133546933531761, 0.0027280007489025593, 0.02245209366083145, -0.04136969894170761, 0.011998251080513, 0.05353482812643051, -0.025400256738066673, -0.009677866473793983, 0.011654752306640148, -0.009101375937461853, 0.005321537610143423, 0.04665235057473183, -0.03382158651947975, -0.004585868678987026, 0.035439737141132355, -0.009292300790548325, 0.023964593186974525, 0.03611551597714424, -0.005942396353930235, 0.008218989707529545, -0.030479924753308296, 0.007527267560362816, -0.033708635717630386, 0.004126835614442825, -0.04910055547952652, 0.013006700202822685, 0.04021628201007843, 0.047504935413599014, 0.008382265456020832, 0.022084305062890053, -0.030225159600377083, -0.007349445018917322, -0.028919467702507973, -0.005443175323307514, 0.03471076115965843, -0.024227995425462723, 0.020706605166196823, -0.0039785634726285934, 0.039908215403556824, -0.00038038924685679376, 0.011670985259115696, 0.007628130726516247, 0.02028089202940464, -0.028456494212150574, -0.040108561515808105, 0.03397483751177788, 0.005804221145808697, -0.051964763551950455, -0.0035457953345030546, 0.06473753601312637, -0.05353674665093422, 0.021192314103245735, 0.04275034740567207, -0.027681643143296242, -0.004264392890036106, -0.02439579740166664, -0.027912408113479614, -0.06016252934932709, 0.02297075279057026, 0.08074585348367691, -0.06121806800365448, 0.042787376791238785, -0.032087430357933044, -0.033339712768793106, -0.03336920216679573, -0.04963458701968193, 0.017246747389435768, 0.04078041762113571, 0.018147582188248634, -0.047720540314912796, 0.05378512665629387, -0.020120015367865562, -0.05811724066734314, 0.009165973402559757, -0.008090473711490631, -0.07066331803798676, -0.021433085203170776, -0.02381790429353714, -0.0237170048058033, -0.01598880998790264, 0.032155826687812805, -0.005676755681633949, -0.02313866652548313, -0.07167024165391922, 0.0818386897444725, 0.08402157574892044, -0.0032317182049155235, 0.01301237940788269, 0.0026318493764847517, -0.047302186489105225, -0.00045329006388783455, -0.04001995548605919, -0.027537161484360695, 0.03262942284345627, 0.00250117015093565, 0.04059109091758728, -0.04404716566205025, -0.05460396036505699, 0.06627026945352554, -0.025747643783688545, 0.009556123055517673, 0.04499426484107971, 0.017046168446540833, 0.030373821035027504, -0.0069916946813464165, -0.00330911367200315, -0.00995588954538107, -0.008930236101150513, -0.025877078995108604, -0.03982686623930931, 0.00694614602252841, -0.02158033289015293, 0.011273687705397606, 0.03082258068025112, -0.08082058280706406, 0.012171846814453602, -0.03579659387469292, -0.04952099919319153, -0.009740489535033703, -0.05193507671356201, 0.04506371170282364, -0.012095690704882145, 0.021855320781469345, 0.01406046375632286, 0.06310116499662399, -0.05210672691464424, -0.025261472910642624, 0.011383920907974243, 0.007384312804788351, -0.02647647261619568, 0.02787718176841736, -0.00934165995568037, -0.008843973278999329, 0.020671086385846138, -0.0356576144695282, -0.004082375671714544, -0.03560082986950874, -0.05884306877851486, 0.01933347061276436, 0.010135545395314693, -0.05376569926738739, -0.05097664147615433, 0.05945972725749016, -0.05081979185342789, 0.0220419242978096, 0.040131181478500366, -0.06144912168383598, -0.06608054786920547, 0.021028462797403336, -0.009847380220890045, 0.002259589498862624, 0.03514403477311134, 0.05190795660018921, 0.035993125289678574, -0.026572320610284805, 0.023975195363163948, -0.002537607215344906, -0.011932657100260258, 0.05463522672653198, -0.07261236011981964, -0.03747161850333214, 0.02082536555826664, -0.0018965790513902903, -0.05190843343734741, 0.005665493663400412, -0.013209179975092411, -0.0733669325709343, 0.008692126721143723, 0.04206085950136185, 0.010717923752963543, -0.0389995351433754, -0.023870840668678284, 0.03531381115317345, -0.00820178259164095, -0.049509432166814804, -0.08026478439569473, 0.04441509023308754, 0.016207532957196236, -0.01575157232582569, -0.04617711529135704, -0.02565179392695427, -0.03473449498414993, -0.021708812564611435, -0.092388816177845, 0.013070969842374325, 0.011432149447500706, 0.06360004842281342, 0.001263136975467205, -0.04661490023136139, 0.016021333634853363, -0.05110861361026764, 0.023339848965406418, 0.01062588021159172, 0.021139075979590416, 0.011042078956961632, 0.045844916254282, 0.00035123765701428056, -0.05721975862979889, -0.022286443039774895, 0.07029082626104355, 0.00174724159296602, -0.029946668073534966, 0.007799028418958187, 0.03336557745933533, 0.019530262798070908, 0.010609137825667858, 0.05730677396059036, 0.013087659142911434, 0.04113477095961571, -0.007693755906075239, 0.014369911514222622, 0.0015089850639924407, -0.05646592006087303, 0.033552125096321106, -0.038335587829351425, 0.012004533782601357, 0.01596168801188469, 0.008972255513072014, -0.019834749400615692, -0.03086482733488083, -0.04469195380806923, 0.00923009030520916, -0.003068600781261921, -0.01928127370774746, 0.05436128377914429, -0.027622027322649956, 0.001794556388631463, 0.013490637764334679, 0.03922204673290253, -0.046790167689323425, 0.024935802444815636, 0.032350506633520126, -0.02626188099384308, 0.039661552757024765, -0.07049486041069031, 0.01548996102064848, -0.025990869849920273, -0.01953788287937641, -0.044192153960466385, 0.07940685003995895, -0.03217396140098572, -0.006789614912122488, -0.014469844289124012, -0.020445028319954872, -0.009884814731776714, -0.08225242793560028, -0.05549641698598862, -0.010317052714526653, 0.033475086092948914, -0.003056929213926196, -0.02442372776567936, -0.04281165450811386, 0.06556645035743713, -0.0008289362885989249, 0.04531335085630417, 0.0338389053940773, -0.011448186822235584, -0.018289055675268173, 0.05408279970288277, 0.03660881146788597, 0.007738852873444557, -0.018550029024481773, 0.042013928294181824, -0.00573153467848897, 0.007839149795472622, 0.037394117563962936, 0.009763137437403202, -0.010811606422066689, -0.06022919341921806, -0.017220983281731606, 0.028067365288734436, -0.006315723527222872, -0.01899600774049759, 0.005416969768702984, 0.001993796555325389, -0.029355043545365334, -0.03345201537013054 ]
Good teachers always tailor their explanations to the learners. Cognitive scientists model this process under the rationality principle: teachers try to maximise the learner's utility while minimising teaching costs. To this end, human teachers seem to build mental models of the learner's internal state, a capacity known as Theory of Mind (ToM). Inspired by cognitive science, we build on Bayesian ToM mechanisms to design teacher agents that, like humans, tailor their teaching strategies to the learners. Our ToM-equipped teachers construct models of learners' internal states from observations and leverage them to select demonstrations that maximise the learners' rewards while minimising teaching costs. Our experiments in simulated environments demonstrate that learners taught this way are more efficient than those taught in a learner-agnostic way. This effect gets stronger when the teacher's model of the learner better aligns with the actual learner's state, either using a more accurate prior or after accumulating observations of the learner's behaviour. This work is a first step towards social machines that teach us and each other, see https://teacher-with-tom.github.io.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17275v1
[ -0.02558048814535141, -0.03519687056541443, 0.03617255389690399, -0.005558472126722336, -0.026714297011494637, -0.023157523944973946, 0.023729834705591202, -0.015885930508375168, -0.06484004855155945, -0.02838745154440403, -0.022501952946186066, 0.0014440515078604221, -0.020311247557401657, -0.04752917215228081, -0.039107777178287506, 0.014002235606312752, 0.08356381952762604, -0.006487157661467791, -0.044728200882673264, 0.03882093355059624, -0.020308690145611763, 0.03377183899283409, -0.008386039175093174, 0.04094928503036499, -0.01849716156721115, -0.0375295951962471, -0.033808641135692596, 0.0006692769238725305, -0.03587764874100685, -0.029340317472815514, 0.08108057081699371, -0.020122788846492767, -0.015646882355213165, -0.06998386979103088, -0.01766381226480007, -0.017033934593200684, 0.005594250746071339, -0.028478508815169334, 0.03179420158267021, 0.006526881363242865, 0.04043924808502197, -0.06475421041250229, -0.07558097690343857, -0.046054914593696594, -0.014824903570115566, 0.015331769362092018, -0.06946434825658798, 0.03495872765779495, -0.08829143643379211, -0.07416996359825134, 0.020137658342719078, 0.00962301716208458, 0.02247726172208786, 0.049364134669303894, -0.005869879387319088, 0.042332667857408524, -0.00505613349378109, 0.033253710716962814, -0.041505806148052216, -0.010113619267940521, -0.015577335841953754, -0.045646630227565765, 0.011888742446899414, -0.0024847202003002167, 0.04291743412613869, 0.03020351193845272, -0.029812851920723915, -0.0720895454287529, -0.027100492268800735, -0.01817086525261402, 0.0665983334183693, -0.06448162347078323, -0.005444043315947056, -0.024693911895155907, -0.02904677949845791, -0.01604241319000721, -0.037282489240169525, -0.05561704561114311, -0.019487326964735985, 0.025781456381082535, -0.05600344389677048, 0.030913159251213074, 0.050984252244234085, 0.002944291103631258, -0.004257525317370892, -0.06629638373851776, 0.003331061452627182, 0.001384005998261273, 0.04754369705915451, -0.042394284158945084, 0.0356728732585907, -0.019720811396837234, -0.07561884820461273, 0.01836421526968479, 0.0591866597533226, -0.0641106367111206, 0.010279913432896137, 0.0376189649105072, 0.018767083063721657, -0.021909870207309723, -0.0053619262762367725, -0.0064467741176486015, 0.0005440672393888235, 0.00894833728671074, 0.025706322863698006, -0.06831953674554825, 0.010777286253869534, 0.010006780736148357, -0.044607289135456085, -0.030743062496185303, -0.03126329183578491, -0.03282826766371727, 0.05031191185116768, -0.05807086080312729, -0.019287342205643654, -0.020324576646089554, -0.007708101067692041, 0.016902893781661987, 0.011692100204527378, 0.014893939718604088, -0.06388680636882782, 0.047389913350343704, 0.0039047012105584145, -0.06332655251026154, 0.0023858656641095877, -0.04759988188743591, 0.03146936744451523, 0.024233341217041016, -0.05386815220117569, 0.002665915060788393, -0.049760814756155014, 0.061558306217193604, -0.0314052440226078, -0.0380081832408905, 0.06131383404135704, -0.032185282558202744, -0.008265562355518341, -0.06892048567533493, -0.006460350006818771, 0.002865340793505311, -0.033431921154260635, -0.07386929541826248, 0.011728160083293915, -0.030000247061252594, 0.0022480140905827284, 0.0457262247800827, 0.002995664719492197, -0.003444514237344265, 0.01250024139881134, 0.0166237223893404, 0.051060792058706284, -0.006282676476985216, 0.024893783032894135, 0.019489187747240067, -0.0017083476996049285, -0.04905011132359505, 0.028767544776201248, 0.010652330704033375, -0.07175097614526749, 0.02010836824774742, -0.023386569693684578, -0.024912990629673004, 0.008124043233692646, -0.04659954085946083, 0.04820358753204346, -0.013633685186505318, 0.06034821271896362, -0.02291272021830082, -0.016238665208220482, -0.008196132257580757, -0.019068706780672073, 0.006416857708245516, -0.019045427441596985, 0.023601077497005463, -0.061853766441345215, -0.016742222011089325, 0.00041434061131440103, -0.007249313872307539, -0.04434671998023987, 0.0161778274923563, 0.007591630332171917, 0.007547608111053705, -0.06916294991970062, 0.005481076426804066, -0.04889973625540733, 0.021916203200817108, -0.0663086473941803, -0.06355985999107361, 0.028757771477103233, 0.022845134139060974, -0.05447550117969513, -0.043371494859457016, -0.011343983002007008, 0.009055670350790024, -0.0542747937142849, 0.017279649153351784, 0.048220131546258926, -0.015591924078762531, 0.036185912787914276, 0.05705471709370613, -0.07454285025596619, 0.01068432442843914, -0.059858374297618866, -0.026880616322159767, -0.03596248850226402, -0.06447750329971313, -0.013931079767644405, 0.06720272451639175, -0.018188906833529472, -0.010464241728186607, -0.011113313026726246, 0.0034565352834761143, 0.019113631919026375, 0.0010069789132103324, 0.030924424529075623, -0.01313410047441721, -0.09763532131910324, 0.06939570605754852, 0.043545857071876526, 0.021774351596832275, 0.01584664359688759, 0.039998460561037064, 0.0039377035573124886, 0.005790716968476772, -0.004486775491386652, 0.00994699914008379, 0.0031763005536049604, -0.016255218535661697, -0.0016809470253065228, -0.021855689585208893, -0.005555200856178999, -0.05815443396568298, -0.01787668466567993, -0.06729045510292053, 0.011785807088017464, 0.013657597824931145, -0.009926700964570045, 0.05888684466481209, -0.026948679238557816, -0.019476991146802902, -0.04372663050889969, -0.03568294271826744, 0.02704790234565735, -0.010608872398734093, -0.047464217990636826, -0.03654596209526062, -0.01968807727098465, 0.034994982182979584, -0.04251425713300705, -0.0364120677113533, 0.00266880146227777, -0.0548277348279953, 0.02118460088968277, -0.024848220869898796, 0.06679096072912216, -0.057828012853860855, -0.0039640809409320354, 0.0024768677540123463, -0.01821221224963665, 0.0638362392783165, 0.024777894839644432, 0.025862030684947968, -0.02643449977040291, -0.002701509278267622, 0.010536468587815762, -0.021891530603170395, 0.004482492338865995, -0.060993291437625885, -0.00970433559268713, -0.03408432751893997, 0.05500306934118271, 0.03139417618513107, 0.031828638166189194, 0.0436842143535614, -0.03404722362756729, -0.05727434530854225, -0.015271120704710484, -0.045327797532081604, 0.031964126974344254, 0.04509059339761734, 0.054605673998594284, -0.030330559238791466, -0.02822522073984146, -0.07022503018379211, -0.026358801871538162, -0.033043112605810165, -0.06868495047092438, -0.05253352224826813, -0.06153084337711334, -0.0003349142207298428, -0.05995187908411026, -0.01181513350456953, -0.0533965639770031, -0.03491460904479027, -0.03097301907837391, -0.02183395065367222, 0.005669512320309877, -0.009054457768797874, -0.018599728122353554, -0.016682393848896027, -0.052701860666275024, -0.0034089351538568735, -0.0068119484931230545, -0.014401312917470932, 0.014233351685106754, -0.04340605437755585, -0.011065163649618626, -0.012258484959602356, 0.0499069020152092, 0.007274558302015066, -0.02493390627205372, 0.04937513917684555, -0.020036982372403145, -0.011872656643390656, 0.012909471988677979, -0.016650734469294548, -0.015141505748033524, 0.05119943991303444, -0.015336843207478523, -0.031972743570804596, 0.014926961623132229, -0.0228677187114954, -0.008640085346996784, -0.01908215880393982, -0.04001633822917938, -0.06546511501073837, 0.04774660989642143, -0.05071365088224411, -0.046686481684446335, -0.08379743248224258, -0.03408167138695717, -0.01810281164944172, 0.02854372374713421, -0.028286142274737358, -0.007190926931798458, 0.015150586143136024, -0.0033122554887086153, -0.025656532496213913, -0.06795400381088257, -0.018625736236572266, -0.04696253687143326, -0.009645150974392891, -0.04451838135719299, 0.013006986118853092, 0.06484699249267578, -0.09053869545459747, 0.020024387165904045, 0.032923564314842224, 0.06575429439544678, 0.01990644261240959, 0.02869136445224285, 0.017498435452580452, -0.030900130048394203, 0.024855222553014755, 0.02606750652194023, 0.025391794741153717, 0.008039448410272598, 0.00992076937109232, -0.03691347315907478, -0.006155247800052166, 0.03376251459121704, -0.029505398124456406, -0.03443228080868721, -0.0176447294652462, -0.005933835636824369, 0.05636872351169586, 0.025718102231621742, -0.05392703786492348, 0.011414898559451103, -0.028442926704883575, -0.004250410012900829, -0.052064668387174606, 0.015066334046423435, 0.034643836319446564, -0.07027024775743484, -0.016354965046048164, -0.01887216791510582, 0.021414123475551605, -0.061183903366327286, -0.009915733709931374, -0.009854067116975784, -0.01395939290523529, 0.0027476693503558636, -0.032239045947790146, -0.05162009596824646, -0.004209315404295921, -0.001472253818064928, -0.02558126673102379, 0.03940759226679802, -0.03934680297970772, -0.019952209666371346, -0.052822843194007874, -0.04619668051600456, -0.04176449030637741, -0.012003260664641857, -0.07621803134679794, -0.00709965405985713, 0.01892801746726036, 0.029709510505199432, 0.0020500554237514734, 0.015794632956385612, -0.006119489669799805, 0.012400684878230095, -0.08211003243923187, 0.01669112965464592, -0.020641949027776718, 0.03448890522122383, 0.03727034851908684, -0.039814069867134094, 0.06401917338371277, -0.02939329296350479, -0.01189710758626461, -0.06203467771410942, -0.021891064941883087, -0.04069061577320099, 0.00013194806524552405, -0.007416241802275181, -0.07297524809837341, -0.006794464308768511, -0.07885244488716125, -0.011958510614931583, -0.037310048937797546, -0.0004508319834712893, -0.01793741062283516, -0.013470802456140518, -0.03335181251168251, 0.040388740599155426, 0.05412711575627327, 0.02709769830107689, 0.009700185619294643, -0.036505285650491714, 0.03290648013353348, -0.018324825912714005, -0.004818365443497896, -0.0033776594791561365, -0.017154650762677193, -0.02327815815806389, -0.02124343067407608, 0.019348543137311935, -0.011255836114287376, -0.03133297339081764, 0.05386431887745857, -0.0004764320910908282, -0.05034714937210083, -0.04807082191109657, 0.060441672801971436, -0.04839136451482773, -0.0831247866153717, -0.03801628202199936, 0.016874628141522408, -0.047363825142383575, 0.04573790356516838, 0.01969592273235321, 0.04614757373929024, 0.002618941245600581, -0.044756267219781876, 0.017654715105891228, 0.013279160484671593, 0.008681107312440872, 0.00226394715718925, -0.01933424174785614, -0.014516209252178669, -0.023584241047501564, -0.011281617917120457, -0.0736624076962471, 0.005096407141536474, -0.0795530378818512, -0.009907539002597332, -0.010533236898481846, 0.0739942342042923, -0.013223814778029919, 0.05056600272655487, -0.09041380882263184, -0.006763444747775793, 0.0006115849828347564, 0.038390133529901505, 0.03874504193663597, 0.07731787860393524, -0.030253736302256584, -0.0018833533395081758, -0.005915715824812651, -0.0037675455678254366, 0.006090246140956879, -0.001817852957174182, 0.004815378226339817, 0.0068113491870462894, -0.017145073041319847, -0.0196039080619812, 0.0664556622505188, -0.016153642907738686, -0.05240783840417862, 0.00462263822555542, 0.030732521787285805, 0.0236690491437912, -0.03356160223484039, 0.030458318069577217, 0.046471934765577316, -0.055392514914274216, -0.039212655276060104, 0.0250815711915493, -0.035149723291397095, -0.02055007964372635, 0.041464101523160934, -0.028607536107301712, 0.03927530348300934, 0.009016030468046665, 0.021369677037000656, 0.04690614342689514, 0.003302980912849307, 0.02757435105741024, -0.00012316678476054221, 0.02943018451333046, 0.04951002448797226, -0.05571018159389496, -0.009688327088952065, -0.027807872742414474, 0.03998073935508728, 0.027485555037856102, 0.04290684685111046, 0.019606608897447586, 0.030593594536185265, -0.013774852268397808, -0.002430511638522148, 0.0017446124693378806, 0.0051879603415727615, -0.005676968023180962, -0.025386597961187363, -0.020577337592840195, -0.018525952473282814, 0.020092226564884186, -0.007342980243265629, 0.030881259590387344, 0.0604485347867012, -0.003759471233934164, -0.017332877963781357, -0.05663337931036949, 0.054527297616004944, -0.042151983827352524, -0.06583942472934723, 0.011704603210091591, -0.0015488015487790108, -0.03514030575752258, 0.040925417095422745, 0.04308285564184189, 0.012013726867735386, -0.022792693227529526, -0.014562071301043034, 0.03682778775691986, -0.010258330032229424, 0.005371929612010717, 0.06198212131857872, -0.022579727694392204, 0.04356655105948448, -0.05304134637117386, -0.042597852647304535, -0.0020235690753906965, -0.04296208545565605, 0.00028843540349043906, 0.0095891198143363, 0.005081449635326862, -0.04816444218158722, 0.04165913909673691, -0.011059525422751904, -0.07787760347127914, -0.0054318662732839584, -0.011112610809504986, -0.08520014584064484, -0.028748951852321625, -0.0031760078854858875, -0.022673198953270912, -0.024251164868474007, 0.0343439020216465, -0.017939439043402672, 0.030166776850819588, -0.023098252713680267, 0.060580965131521225, 0.08652958273887634, -0.021336786448955536, 0.04569082334637642, 0.03774474933743477, -0.05712020769715309, 0.009279581718146801, 0.005247738212347031, 0.023891491815447807, 0.012811479158699512, 0.060564879328012466, 0.021662898361682892, -0.05029192939400673, 0.013934388756752014, 0.03841698542237282, -0.036079052835702896, -0.022999534383416176, -0.007279228884726763, -0.002924471627920866, 0.05986778438091278, -0.01945989765226841, -0.043713394552469254, -0.03826696425676346, 0.04945626109838486, -0.06540977954864502, -0.045138899236917496, -0.015548208728432655, 0.013580887578427792, -0.005734378471970558, -0.02566426433622837, -0.06566121429204941, 0.03312957286834717, -0.007720074616372585, -0.06876622140407562, 0.03551005944609642, -0.008200653828680515, 0.018856022506952286, -0.029582660645246506, 0.03454936295747757, 0.03400062397122383, 0.011424564756453037, -0.024539267644286156, -0.02218007668852806, 0.008618115447461605, 0.012151375412940979, 0.008614771999418736, -0.020722588524222374, 0.011424606665968895, -0.0011657833820208907, -0.02217535488307476, 0.007864682003855705, 0.011685965582728386, -0.010867688804864883, -0.021955668926239014, 0.03432157635688782, 0.016854282468557358, 0.00936631578952074, -0.05225653946399689, -0.00885713566094637, -0.0280259158462286, 0.002708407351747155, 0.06006952375173569, 0.01298474706709385, -0.04858717694878578, 0.003048970364034176, -0.009899643249809742, -0.007805611006915569, -0.010608595795929432, 0.05405668541789055, -0.006237895227968693, -0.00021390563051681966, 0.01184160728007555, 0.025131957605481148, -0.03756648302078247, 0.007897263392806053, -0.06620610505342484, -0.041711170226335526, 0.0071473438292741776, -0.04819650202989578, -0.019728900864720345, -0.024798650294542313, -0.01698499172925949, -0.06703603267669678, -0.010705148801207542, 0.05379262566566467, -0.01622719131410122, 0.009155234321951866, -0.04924444109201431, 0.025722451508045197, 0.015653612092137337, -0.060059141367673874, -0.06079092621803284, -0.005190541036427021, 0.00405857153236866, -0.03379254415631294, 0.012156032957136631, -0.010828337632119656, -0.005832388531416655, -0.02036971226334572, -0.08909031748771667, 0.020016266033053398, -0.009845399297773838, 0.015106904320418835, -0.01764514297246933, -0.005955027416348457, -0.0221785306930542, -0.05865507572889328, 0.022399790585041046, -0.016184436157345772, 0.03448082134127617, 0.03873828426003456, 0.05502299219369888, 0.012768348678946495, -0.049881577491760254, -0.012261583469808102, 0.06634704023599625, -0.03795117884874344, 0.01500573568046093, -0.0138554023578763, 0.013397282920777798, 0.026519060134887695, -0.04931916296482086, 0.03651854768395424, 0.011706101708114147, 0.05671699345111847, 0.01584644988179207, -0.011607129126787186, -0.029607994481921196, -0.0531814843416214, 0.04704572260379791, -0.0030097784474492073, 0.01931512914597988, 0.04001918435096741, 0.008691828697919846, -0.027888920158147812, -0.0052701509557664394, -0.049669697880744934, 0.02699051797389984, -0.03512073680758476, -0.017400624230504036, 0.05675206333398819, -0.004220134578645229, -0.011471960693597794, -0.059123966842889786, -0.02149377204477787, -0.007635101210325956, 0.016420627012848854, 0.03745799884200096, -0.04943089932203293, 0.032482270151376724, -0.06460381299257278, 0.019122496247291565, -0.04779981076717377, 0.046929731965065, -0.024063661694526672, 0.07562023401260376, 0.008681540377438068, -0.007040103897452354, -0.002909061498939991, -0.05591524764895439, -0.048594020307064056, -0.07975172996520996, -0.014449721202254295, 0.009251548908650875, 0.024128209799528122, 0.0421556681394577, 0.011264396831393242, 0.038776595145463943, 0.043735235929489136, 0.03571625053882599, 0.03730998933315277, -0.015009589493274689, -0.017294296994805336, -0.03700432553887367, 0.06515077501535416, 0.0186559297144413, -0.038050126284360886, -0.043040163815021515, 0.027768421918153763, 0.026434430852532387, 0.01881624571979046, -0.001756772631779313, -0.026760432869195938, 0.014650000259280205, -0.028170695528388023, -0.005128919146955013, 0.05030374974012375, -0.052576903253793716, -0.06495355069637299, 0.011542964726686478, 0.014970955438911915, -0.014137093909084797, -0.009387490339577198 ]
Extracting precise geographical information from textual contents is crucial in a plethora of applications. For example, during hazardous events, a robust and unbiased toponym extraction framework can provide an avenue to tie the location concerned to the topic discussed by news media posts and pinpoint humanitarian help requests or damage reports from social media. Early studies have leveraged rule-based, gazetteer-based, deep learning, and hybrid approaches to address this problem. However, the performance of existing tools is deficient in supporting operations like emergency rescue, which relies on fine-grained, accurate geographic information. The emerging pretrained language models can better capture the underlying characteristics of text information, including place names, offering a promising pathway to optimize toponym recognition to underpin practical applications. In this paper, TopoBERT, a toponym recognition module based on a one dimensional Convolutional Neural Network (CNN1D) and Bidirectional Encoder Representation from Transformers (BERT), is proposed and fine-tuned. Three datasets (CoNLL2003-Train, Wikipedia3000, WNUT2017) are leveraged to tune the hyperparameters, discover the best training strategy, and train the model. Another two datasets (CoNLL2003-Test and Harvey2017) are used to evaluate the performance. Three distinguished classifiers, linear, multi-layer perceptron, and CNN1D, are benchmarked to determine the optimal model architecture. TopoBERT achieves state-of-the-art performance (f1-score=0.865) compared to the other five baseline models and can be applied to diverse toponym recognition tasks without additional training.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13631v2
[ -0.007182084955275059, -0.065804623067379, 0.061374813318252563, 0.02760169468820095, -0.047392070293426514, 0.01943775825202465, 0.0269904937595129, 0.03146388381719589, 0.0013291428331285715, -0.028738997876644135, -0.030882716178894043, 0.03155006468296051, -0.058283280581235886, 0.015505862422287464, -0.021595362573862076, 0.040207523852586746, 0.07047709077596664, 0.022480344399809837, -0.06826669722795486, 0.04588206857442856, 0.008457469753921032, 0.019615797325968742, -0.04229304939508438, 0.029792020097374916, 0.0060212574899196625, 0.003624431788921356, -0.05223490297794342, -0.01849677413702011, -0.0004620253457687795, -0.018010860309004784, 0.03588109835982323, -0.02871314063668251, -0.018293851986527443, -0.01697799190878868, -0.04812946915626526, -0.05729537457227707, 0.0010074827587231994, 0.0139927938580513, 0.02393418364226818, -0.05905861407518387, 0.03435635194182396, -0.04066452756524086, -0.038665108382701874, -0.025883113965392113, -0.039860378950834274, -0.00399464275687933, -0.05631570145487785, -0.021969640627503395, -0.0554368682205677, -0.046092621982097626, 0.03941532224416733, 0.014934633858501911, -0.025043200701475143, 0.04329543188214302, -0.019013144075870514, -0.004970308393239975, -0.009668007493019104, 0.017838744446635246, -0.06419853866100311, 0.021043088287115097, 0.03757253289222717, -0.01598711498081684, -0.018622465431690216, 0.002603519009426236, 0.0027660434134304523, 0.04756641015410423, -0.023609405383467674, -0.05182715877890587, -0.0278729610145092, -0.019830023869872093, 0.03155581280589104, -0.0738394483923912, 0.029555339366197586, 0.003947662189602852, -0.011378980241715908, -0.03325692564249039, -0.02385604940354824, -0.00687301903963089, -0.032098911702632904, -0.022762522101402283, -0.054049551486968994, 0.03366079181432724, 0.06358293443918228, 0.009110597893595695, 0.019789105281233788, -0.05716206133365631, 0.018680233508348465, -0.016552500426769257, 0.01070784218609333, -0.05819137021899223, 0.04156443476676941, -0.04103156179189682, -0.07847487181425095, -0.028716102242469788, 0.0691773071885109, 0.010548315942287445, 0.03938162326812744, -0.03010808490216732, -0.0023810015991330147, -0.02912580408155918, -0.05153230205178261, 0.03339558094739914, 0.008782398886978626, 0.065620057284832, 0.022298742085695267, -0.047019779682159424, 0.0070015727542340755, -0.026303555816411972, -0.037769101560115814, -0.029736803844571114, -0.024146482348442078, -0.01759529486298561, -0.009026202373206615, -0.057633813470602036, 0.018770795315504074, -0.025079194456338882, 0.046479232609272, 0.01070389710366726, 0.006130622234195471, 0.001477660029195249, -0.010768692940473557, 0.03124222718179226, 0.0686178207397461, -0.01251918449997902, -0.04633081704378128, -0.017493829131126404, 0.06067924201488495, -0.0013326224870979786, -0.022293448448181152, -0.005141055677086115, -0.018563197925686836, 0.0068656522780656815, -0.04609515890479088, -0.02033804915845394, 0.05629557743668556, -0.012413699179887772, -0.0062145451083779335, -0.06762202829122543, 0.01891574263572693, -0.026179980486631393, -0.027798142284154892, -0.08285151422023773, -0.0025609037838876247, -0.056655194610357285, 0.012092656455934048, 0.04183506593108177, -0.06065140664577484, -0.04432094469666481, 0.00030395612702704966, 0.010631518438458443, 0.010484280064702034, -0.05488097667694092, 0.040665723383426666, 0.056246232241392136, 0.0075788418762385845, -0.035937320441007614, 0.013650888577103615, -0.03597412258386612, -0.03512168675661087, 0.01883769780397415, 0.03549869731068611, 0.00989510677754879, 0.004154101479798555, -0.0022258914541453123, -0.034189920872449875, 0.016084546223282814, 0.026600776240229607, -0.0265462938696146, 0.008157026953995228, 0.03946581855416298, -0.016922201961278915, -0.007051228079944849, 0.0035565218422561884, -0.022829707711935043, -0.028613857924938202, -0.014914860017597675, 0.030806399881839752, -0.024333955720067024, -0.027917606756091118, -0.006234619300812483, -0.012815470807254314, 0.06410465389490128, -0.021325042471289635, 0.0005793993477709591, -0.023995153605937958, 0.016135506331920624, -0.0893850326538086, -0.025716101750731468, 0.023934679105877876, 0.008124475367367268, -0.04205333814024925, -0.00027981592575088143, 0.014936305582523346, -0.017865996807813644, -0.03807081654667854, -0.06512491405010223, 0.020935146138072014, -0.03767113387584686, 0.035711441189050674, 0.01868070475757122, -0.09372931718826294, -0.03396907448768616, -0.07521118223667145, 0.024968132376670837, 0.028172213584184647, -0.07408539950847626, -0.021482151001691818, 0.05030971020460129, -0.03745880722999573, -0.0023611891083419323, 0.03565022721886635, 0.035597506910562515, 0.04039009287953377, 0.0359715074300766, 0.0541214719414711, -0.0034698103554546833, -0.10639950633049011, 0.05390986427664757, 0.0027925928588956594, -0.01986730471253395, 0.04745197296142578, -0.006644504144787788, 0.022780397906899452, -0.03410474583506584, 0.016489177942276, 0.022736577317118645, 0.06898526102304459, -0.00241747684776783, -0.03278595581650734, -0.045282430946826935, -0.021905066445469856, -0.04759891703724861, -0.04283791407942772, -0.04715820029377937, -0.027748312801122665, -0.0567670539021492, -0.05832858011126518, 0.017369497567415237, 0.008097975514829159, -0.03790460526943207, -0.003344486700370908, -0.01610267348587513, 0.0213644839823246, -0.021362505853176117, -0.04936911538243294, -0.03455829247832298, -0.03821376711130142, 0.036116164177656174, -0.023851018399000168, -0.03494374081492424, 0.013080867938697338, -0.06711839884519577, 0.010461749508976936, 0.00384268956258893, 0.019439173862338066, 0.04136703535914421, -0.05183637887239456, 0.030993133783340454, -0.008486014790832996, 0.04818722978234291, 0.020072221755981445, 0.018163757398724556, -0.047771234065294266, 0.023617573082447052, 0.04351695626974106, -0.01749289408326149, 0.011569497175514698, 0.0011945338919758797, 0.020285826176404953, -0.040330950170755386, 0.0009687988786026835, 0.04756265878677368, 0.056086216121912, -0.03160729259252548, -0.0365152582526207, -0.036926742643117905, 0.0006478283903561532, -0.043791528791189194, 0.02366863191127777, 0.06046905741095543, 0.06108383461833, 0.03362599387764931, -0.01532887201756239, -0.050675760954618454, -0.0284220390021801, -0.06568274646997452, -0.026127345860004425, -0.08061365783214569, -0.019797075539827347, -0.031074047088623047, -0.06317038089036942, -0.014726717956364155, -0.0300854854285717, -0.07382641732692719, -0.032299868762493134, -0.061694178730249405, -0.047214627265930176, 0.01075729914009571, 0.0009388357866555452, 0.005712696351110935, -0.006341123953461647, -0.010718370787799358, 0.0023159347474575043, -0.013935479335486889, 0.017761923372745514, -0.05048902705311775, -0.06178964301943779, 0.009172958321869373, -0.002366174478083849, 0.0152641162276268, -0.020221348851919174, 0.0067360312677919865, -0.038774654269218445, 0.06497563421726227, 0.026565952226519585, 0.007492168806493282, -0.007519291248172522, 0.0536753311753273, 0.027715420350432396, -0.03226529061794281, 0.045326393097639084, 0.011996817775070667, -0.0076296511106193066, 0.0000629982678219676, -0.05758799612522125, -0.028324540704488754, 0.03919593244791031, -0.004725493025034666, -0.02852056175470352, -0.005487428046762943, 0.027885809540748596, 0.0283326618373394, 0.009438438341021538, 0.019345784559845924, 0.018484463915228844, 0.056968510150909424, -0.04340746998786926, -0.05401651933789253, 0.03859521448612213, -0.013014501892030239, 0.04153266176581383, -0.018325725570321083, -0.04270545765757561, -0.025992853567004204, 0.048004746437072754, -0.09109415113925934, 0.03377808257937431, 0.03603222221136093, 0.08101677894592285, 0.05174631625413895, 0.001700595486909151, 0.010628719814121723, 0.035040680319070816, 0.025925541296601295, 0.00030219220207072794, 0.018202684819698334, -0.001656590262427926, 0.06415380537509918, -0.055731698870658875, -0.033947158604860306, -0.0031657926738262177, -0.05776989832520485, -0.027508445084095, 0.03172817453742027, 0.008033382706344128, 0.05463277921080589, 0.01630905456840992, -0.04451890289783478, 0.036261074244976044, 0.0014258292503654957, 0.027246983721852303, 0.022788958624005318, -0.05004106089472771, 0.047583404928445816, -0.007805841974914074, 0.025467583909630775, 0.0016056132735684514, -0.020556028932332993, 0.04571310058236122, -0.04161055386066437, 0.03761332482099533, -0.0669512078166008, 0.06306583434343338, 0.03783515468239784, -0.011933060362935066, 0.030290953814983368, 0.0529981330037117, -0.011022604070603848, 0.05198284983634949, -0.018088437616825104, -0.014000634662806988, 0.013964901678264141, 0.004986392334103584, -0.04019886255264282, -0.008068624883890152, -0.06952762603759766, -0.016425639390945435, 0.054018307477235794, 0.035598982125520706, 0.02042684517800808, 0.008146497420966625, 0.032319698482751846, 0.0070593939162790775, -0.0797620564699173, 0.008280884474515915, -0.016720276325941086, 0.007774889934808016, -0.04369254782795906, -0.04195081442594528, 0.07263463735580444, -0.05228959023952484, -0.029807010665535927, -0.010052891448140144, -0.01557833794504404, -0.057042449712753296, -0.03476519510149956, -0.013263697735965252, -0.0886855199933052, 0.013696427457034588, -0.06704075634479523, 0.062238164246082306, 0.030677691102027893, -0.014667159877717495, -0.028638308867812157, -0.009718168526887894, -0.003953213803470135, 0.015686774626374245, 0.03810640424489975, 0.008237263187766075, 0.006006891373544931, 0.01908528059720993, 0.006131100468337536, -0.013460586778819561, -0.014768879860639572, 0.01068933680653572, 0.01348007470369339, -0.0028568916022777557, -0.006316937040537596, -0.006473070476204157, -0.007387590128928423, 0.009420438669621944, 0.07129483669996262, -0.022245164960622787, 0.000986691564321518, -0.0029711395036429167, 0.04775945469737053, -0.03803122043609619, -0.058625850826501846, -0.02369575761258602, -0.03255223482847214, -0.06105218082666397, -0.045930907130241394, 0.0316324383020401, 0.0529635064303875, 0.0070154075510799885, -0.005161629989743233, 0.021241728216409683, 0.01991303078830242, 0.025922385975718498, 0.0019650913309305906, 0.015910612419247627, 0.01522018387913704, 0.003137393621727824, -0.04457641765475273, -0.06636641919612885, -0.006775110960006714, -0.008037138730287552, 0.021882282570004463, 0.018997715786099434, 0.02642257697880268, 0.0493500754237175, 0.06912054866552353, -0.06633395701646805, 0.03817800059914589, 0.03238746151328087, -0.017629526555538177, 0.025370139628648758, 0.05537767708301544, 0.02144002914428711, 0.021581582725048065, -0.045613594353199005, 0.012657533399760723, -0.005660753697156906, -0.04979349300265312, 0.030823811888694763, -0.01157760713249445, -0.006103167310357094, 0.032088421285152435, 0.07557977735996246, 0.025151997804641724, -0.03883044794201851, 0.013052244670689106, 0.03463442251086235, -0.01872258447110653, -0.0503956601023674, 0.02255484275519848, 0.03532158210873604, -0.01977493055164814, 0.0013839337043464184, -0.023388855159282684, 0.00480349175632, 0.022046664729714394, -0.010479820892214775, -0.023668836802244186, -0.02143034152686596, 0.020713169127702713, 0.017616715282201767, 0.03435363247990608, -0.0029389599803835154, -0.00024524593027308583, 0.0016441126354038715, 0.016787072643637657, 0.001674139522947371, -0.06934475153684616, -0.009753403253853321, -0.03908654302358627, 0.05150611698627472, 0.06347471475601196, 0.05257300287485123, 0.023732837289571762, 0.048164647072553635, -0.05204309523105621, 0.036770615726709366, 0.02434636652469635, -0.0268626157194376, 0.0194492656737566, -0.02337229624390602, 0.0641554519534111, -0.029748467728495598, 0.023137906566262245, 0.019392235204577446, 0.0132959745824337, 0.005866138264536858, -0.005259460769593716, -0.03888978809118271, 0.0005044225254096091, 0.005373953375965357, 0.003789628855884075, -0.045468732714653015, 0.04687369614839554, 0.0015056189149618149, -0.040714457631111145, -0.01061098650097847, 0.03546622768044472, -0.007827702909708023, 0.06928450614213943, -0.005458985920995474, -0.011241838335990906, -0.007951445877552032, 0.015327061526477337, 0.08535856753587723, -0.0005808571586385369, 0.0012100990861654282, 0.007493683136999607, -0.003190550021827221, 0.03698655590415001, -0.03310605138540268, 0.046878986060619354, 0.026863867416977882, 0.006076660007238388, -0.04252501204609871, 0.056164130568504333, 0.006133805029094219, -0.06491836905479431, 0.037759676575660706, -0.029876818880438805, -0.09462425112724304, -0.0302448570728302, 0.003118279157206416, 0.00017532077617943287, -0.03849412128329277, 0.06274835765361786, -0.013670867308974266, 0.030358795076608658, -0.03771776333451271, 0.05986548215150833, 0.0849042758345604, 0.04022110998630524, 0.0015677408082410693, -0.008661220781505108, -0.0029232357628643513, -0.0035503378603607416, -0.014962144196033478, -0.0013453435385599732, 0.04795992374420166, 0.042658738791942596, 0.03516753762960434, -0.014707908034324646, -0.030489791184663773, 0.06519144028425217, -0.02989453449845314, -0.02244981937110424, 0.00551310321316123, -0.0437241867184639, 0.0651223435997963, -0.018036048859357834, -0.036990586668252945, 0.02470351941883564, 0.02442798763513565, -0.003854138310998678, -0.016529250890016556, -0.023799767717719078, 0.009781568311154842, 0.015365141443908215, -0.013968794606626034, -0.0618194155395031, 0.006290957797318697, -0.017577987164258957, -0.07951967418193817, 0.019977830350399017, -0.07198602706193924, -0.0015284193214029074, -0.0028725506272166967, 0.041382282972335815, 0.02794359065592289, 0.05002265423536301, -0.06877785176038742, -0.05083613097667694, 0.020663555711507797, 0.03704095259308815, -0.0009190855780616403, -0.03612891584634781, 0.023734454065561295, -0.05165455862879753, 0.005554147530347109, -0.03290808945894241, -0.02734532579779625, -0.01946939527988434, -0.026820586994290352, 0.012136665172874928, 0.03169539198279381, -0.015350726433098316, 0.002733561908826232, 0.03314966335892677, 0.01264284923672676, -0.007044553756713867, 0.029806848615407944, -0.04805811122059822, -0.07610830664634705, -0.009538952261209488, -0.023111756891012192, 0.005288850981742144, 0.004696519114077091, 0.04398190230131149, 0.058239180594682693, -0.02394147403538227, 0.03263493627309799, -0.016698457300662994, 0.019079623743891716, 0.007778756320476532, -0.05746297538280487, 0.023970672860741615, 0.00759115070104599, 0.02458581142127514, -0.056622106581926346, 0.021291259676218033, -0.01483664195984602, -0.06532527506351471, -0.05046512186527252, 0.04583454132080078, 0.0003704576811287552, 0.008332031778991222, -0.08106105029582977, -0.0003831485810223967, -0.016704799607396126, -0.018493397161364555, -0.05135573074221611, 0.02179061807692051, -0.020735587924718857, -0.03733903169631958, -0.028319964185357094, -0.050701625645160675, -0.04463086277246475, 0.01580820418894291, -0.07816348969936371, 0.01951354742050171, 0.010113357566297054, 0.010327768512070179, -0.018092382699251175, -0.026721175760030746, 0.006518227513879538, -0.028057293966412544, -0.014652656391263008, -0.013744940049946308, 0.0102371321991086, -0.009189334698021412, 0.016868408769369125, 0.01645817421376705, -0.05975201353430748, -0.05281524732708931, 0.01864273101091385, -0.00012507692736107856, -0.018801294267177582, -0.006449373904615641, 0.038343582302331924, -0.0029389590490609407, 0.024391284212470055, 0.07763132452964783, -0.045968037098646164, 0.03509058058261871, -0.04085161164402962, -0.0030515212565660477, -0.01638079807162285, -0.07305698841810226, 0.01539637055248022, -0.0076957764104008675, 0.01964721828699112, 0.03522767499089241, -0.030761217698454857, -0.016743609681725502, -0.039020370692014694, -0.049363505095243454, 0.03406183049082756, -0.04086516052484512, -0.0221692007035017, 0.04652310907840729, -0.007027325686067343, -0.023073557764291763, -0.034370556473731995, -0.007770839147269726, -0.0015558162704110146, -0.0036970849614590406, 0.03601976856589317, -0.04058263450860977, -0.00621792720630765, -0.05070008337497711, 0.027883516624569893, -0.011464879848062992, 0.009676561690866947, -0.0678861141204834, 0.07511378079652786, 0.025043167173862457, -0.004246578086167574, -0.03436204046010971, -0.0240690428763628, -0.05201931297779083, -0.0624263621866703, -0.05052027851343155, -0.04469503089785576, 0.06406337767839432, 0.019586317241191864, -0.02767016738653183, 0.03369101136922836, 0.0766928568482399, 0.011142277158796787, 0.03220415487885475, -0.006879145745187998, 0.03675053268671036, -0.003996529150754213, 0.08636873960494995, -0.03183501586318016, -0.004788931459188461, -0.030614228919148445, 0.012882641516625881, 0.008200780488550663, -0.05965881049633026, 0.00036974321119487286, -0.026184113696217537, 0.0006517207948490977, -0.037358712404966354, 0.0031069291289895773, 0.021800752729177475, -0.026419315487146378, -0.0459512434899807, -0.0024538200814276934, 0.01656864397227764, -0.051878489553928375, -0.04958334565162659 ]
Human motion prediction is important for mobile service robots and intelligent vehicles to operate safely and smoothly around people. The more accurate predictions are, particularly over extended periods of time, the better a system can, e.g., assess collision risks and plan ahead. In this paper, we propose to exploit maps of dynamics (MoDs, a class of general representations of place-dependent spatial motion patterns, learned from prior observations) for long-term human motion prediction (LHMP). We present a new MoD-informed human motion prediction approach, named CLiFF-LHMP, which is data efficient, explainable, and insensitive to errors from an upstream tracking system. Our approach uses CLiFF-map, a specific MoD trained with human motion data recorded in the same environment. We bias a constant velocity prediction with samples from the CLiFF-map to generate multi-modal trajectory predictions. In two public datasets we show that this algorithm outperforms the state of the art for predictions over very extended periods of time, achieving 45% more accurate prediction performance at 50s compared to the baseline.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07066v1
[ -0.030932700261473656, 0.002751853782683611, 0.046410247683525085, 0.040297847241163254, -0.025113508105278015, 0.02291734516620636, 0.030432460829615593, -0.022471284493803978, -0.02877245470881462, -0.039099086076021194, -0.058068811893463135, 0.03392091393470764, -0.0039022003766149282, -0.013331838883459568, -0.038957420736551285, 0.019808469340205193, 0.0682588517665863, 0.02012960985302925, -0.04970385506749153, 0.05498874932527542, 0.028496969491243362, 0.012161767110228539, -0.03605424240231514, 0.030016399919986725, -0.007484490051865578, -0.029842646792531013, -0.023469313979148865, 0.036202989518642426, -0.03951083496212959, -0.026404280215501785, 0.07183058559894562, -0.009271059185266495, -0.019708797335624695, -0.06129175424575806, -0.05621111020445824, -0.014699827879667282, 0.00455088447779417, 0.04352904111146927, 0.015735166147351265, -0.008963648229837418, 0.03733645752072334, -0.05518797039985657, -0.007716389838606119, -0.021637558937072754, -0.031940314918756485, 0.004170447587966919, -0.06782904267311096, 0.046149931848049164, -0.05479918792843819, -0.03758150711655617, 0.04532702639698982, -0.06318753212690353, 0.011366491205990314, 0.06350662559270859, -0.037594422698020935, 0.00024603164638392627, -0.002672258298844099, 0.052281614392995834, -0.04369937255978584, -0.0021714852191507816, 0.03302869200706482, -0.0003280756645835936, -0.02048240415751934, 0.002615910954773426, 0.059657346457242966, 0.06218908354640007, -0.013885256834328175, -0.05767260491847992, 0.009335263632237911, -0.055703964084386826, 0.04836351424455643, -0.05880942940711975, -0.007862791419029236, -0.002532495418563485, -0.037208203226327896, -0.005580981727689505, 0.007872260175645351, -0.026203207671642303, -0.00041068854625336826, 0.00016641161346342415, -0.025361469015479088, 0.020212236791849136, 0.057812560349702835, 0.03509384021162987, -0.040196701884269714, -0.03438649699091911, 0.06543643772602081, -0.041938040405511856, -0.013168597593903542, -0.047088973224163055, 0.032821159809827805, -0.02905954048037529, -0.0656600072979927, -0.0019030584953725338, 0.017500154674053192, -0.015041708014905453, 0.07155849039554596, 0.031383808702230453, -0.005159525200724602, 0.002964276820421219, -0.05834328383207321, 0.030862390995025635, 0.0024068192578852177, 0.048794638365507126, 0.04864459112286568, -0.06417517364025116, 0.0416857935488224, -0.038809966295957565, -0.03311823308467865, -0.015650635585188866, -0.048745524138212204, -0.06402601301670074, -0.01807670295238495, -0.0374479740858078, -0.06931015849113464, -0.06063327193260193, 0.024482818320393562, -0.04233207926154137, 0.04164888337254524, 0.03529345989227295, -0.03810068219900131, 0.02429310232400894, 0.051173094660043716, -0.0007031324785202742, 0.021549813449382782, -0.006886822171509266, 0.06715302169322968, -0.0020787399262189865, -0.050295740365982056, -0.035327501595020294, -0.02047792263329029, 0.04027935862541199, -0.04189804196357727, -0.06698135286569595, 0.030034104362130165, 0.00857958197593689, -0.012427786365151405, -0.05012567341327667, 0.042791541665792465, 0.009642688557505608, -0.030736535787582397, -0.06714018434286118, 0.0005397612112574279, -0.03590591624379158, -0.04117792472243309, 0.04412604868412018, -0.06850030273199081, 0.015389863401651382, 0.03941560909152031, 0.012722387909889221, 0.009024197235703468, 0.021815963089466095, 0.004381658975034952, 0.022145651280879974, 0.02297668345272541, -0.0026501838583499193, 0.054135244339704514, -0.012909863144159317, -0.05600200966000557, 0.02539554238319397, 0.014500334858894348, -0.061016105115413666, 0.026276633143424988, -0.002850561635568738, 0.016700634732842445, 0.021987540647387505, 0.0479721762239933, 0.0231083445250988, -0.009896887466311455, 0.014161786995828152, -0.008384334854781628, -0.02440144307911396, -0.032139603048563004, -0.054599881172180176, -0.046028245240449905, -0.035425055772066116, -0.006824834737926722, -0.04687535762786865, -0.0104000773280859, -0.031304776668548584, -0.04167262092232704, 0.03509652242064476, -0.05090881139039993, 0.02120930701494217, -0.05360784754157066, -0.013688174076378345, -0.07970435172319412, -0.03899992257356644, -0.011854942888021469, 0.045499563217163086, -0.06312413513660431, -0.03497106954455376, -0.009745942428708076, 0.003936617635190487, -0.016721129417419434, -0.06117461621761322, 0.007681894116103649, -0.046145930886268616, -0.0038767519872635603, 0.02487936243414879, -0.08245113492012024, -0.04899369180202484, -0.05288771912455559, -0.00954138208180666, 0.028406010940670967, -0.06636657565832138, 0.001546799554489553, 0.03798539191484451, -0.056704968214035034, 0.017559759318828583, 0.023079000413417816, 0.05002978816628456, 0.0554819293320179, 0.008360788226127625, 0.009942135773599148, 0.03645328804850578, -0.0932006686925888, 0.05777054652571678, -0.00993152242153883, 0.0034529061522334814, 0.038157545030117035, 0.0007421949994750321, -0.0030629700049757957, 0.008578740991652012, -0.04781489446759224, 0.03483046963810921, 0.048299890011548996, -0.02736450545489788, -0.043355681002140045, -0.05186115577816963, -0.06160219386219978, -0.07049136608839035, -0.05644088611006737, -0.06530702859163284, -0.027148040011525154, -0.007844222709536552, -0.04563754051923752, 0.031128358095884323, 0.007598359137773514, -0.016497556120157242, -0.014935268089175224, -0.021525997668504715, 0.02185220830142498, -0.061364687979221344, -0.054983798414468765, -0.009504072368144989, -0.03304878622293472, 0.025978200137615204, -0.0014419970102608204, -0.03638365492224693, 0.0016464211512356997, -0.0374281220138073, 0.015561127103865147, -0.023353466764092445, 0.01679815724492073, 0.066771499812603, 0.028091110289096832, 0.008649676106870174, -0.047305744141340256, 0.04344990849494934, -0.021880781278014183, 0.03044336661696434, -0.057811327278614044, 0.03791021928191185, 0.0273478664457798, 0.0032736235298216343, 0.011777288280427456, 0.01977020688354969, 0.03152943775057793, 0.011148256249725819, 0.023820729926228523, 0.004837204702198505, 0.04378165677189827, -0.04143858328461647, -0.011944319121539593, -0.015517533756792545, 0.020298844203352928, -0.026399826630949974, -0.0053773862309753895, 0.02347886934876442, 0.039474841207265854, 0.0020687468349933624, 0.05547763407230377, -0.044885870069265366, 0.002872239565476775, -0.04262564703822136, -0.021817857399582863, -0.07341191917657852, -0.033102281391620636, -0.006393428426235914, -0.06034968048334122, 0.030576657503843307, 0.0023730939719825983, -0.021971626207232475, 0.009735669009387493, -0.048731472343206406, -0.031003952026367188, 0.006230544298887253, 0.024300167337059975, -0.007203178945928812, -0.034812722355127335, -0.06749950349330902, 0.023633606731891632, 0.015997586771845818, -0.002205031691119075, -0.06815017014741898, -0.05862804129719734, -0.03651411086320877, -0.0014170771464705467, -0.01838657446205616, -0.06465289741754532, 0.054265644401311874, 0.009288833476603031, -0.0021259814966470003, 0.04275112599134445, 0.013087600469589233, 0.00795181468129158, -0.01588890515267849, -0.002798968693241477, 0.0045846677385270596, 0.05439559370279312, -0.0005505816079676151, 0.03628147765994072, 0.007329154293984175, -0.06110476329922676, -0.0327286534011364, 0.044079359620809555, 0.017417658120393753, 0.014839250594377518, -0.0305961724370718, 0.020320270210504532, 0.004502248018980026, 0.02685358002781868, 0.023715196177363396, 0.04423176869750023, 0.012194394133985043, -0.059089481830596924, 0.007994743064045906, -0.028899630531668663, -0.01675083301961422, -0.046595364809036255, -0.007052442524582148, -0.0584537610411644, -0.02432124689221382, 0.02508951537311077, -0.07736387103796005, -0.005639698356389999, 0.032283902168273926, 0.058395467698574066, 0.016567489132285118, 0.042788174003362656, 0.013228591531515121, 0.0433606319129467, -0.017346281558275223, 0.013174832798540592, 0.041810378432273865, 0.04497190937399864, 0.06364557147026062, 0.012867486104369164, -0.059129197150468826, 0.03929157182574272, -0.06898710131645203, -0.03284807875752449, 0.0014099417021498084, 0.008145459927618504, -0.0020797725301235914, 0.03428252041339874, -0.054434288293123245, 0.036980558186769485, -0.017926957458257675, 0.025441160425543785, -0.0036614928394556046, -0.022346794605255127, 0.04651256278157234, -0.02274499461054802, -0.023711789399385452, 0.029880465939641, 0.034522414207458496, 0.0368192084133625, -0.04048170521855354, 0.01781965047121048, -0.06397993117570877, 0.0039907037280499935, -0.0033239584881812334, -0.00027490401407703757, 0.02035902626812458, 0.059419192373752594, -0.007573641370981932, 0.05690480396151543, -0.017203573137521744, -0.03535096347332001, -0.01987195946276188, -0.002856231527402997, -0.006563558243215084, 0.01146306935697794, -0.03730260580778122, -0.010353614576160908, 0.018994003534317017, -0.010875627398490906, -0.03383781015872955, -0.014002600684762001, -0.01579422317445278, -0.015501171350479126, -0.07642301917076111, 0.024169860407710075, -0.04600315913558006, 0.03507958725094795, -0.06657302379608154, -0.02216739021241665, 0.05827371031045914, -0.055095769464969635, -0.006587008014321327, -0.017932724207639694, -0.028576673939824104, -0.04586883634328842, -0.01326513011008501, 0.0038630161434412003, -0.0636104941368103, 0.04953679442405701, -0.050747208297252655, 0.03213852271437645, -0.011745894327759743, 0.025751706212759018, -0.023725226521492004, -0.05049237608909607, 0.021737324073910713, 0.04698030278086662, 0.042785126715898514, -0.018756117671728134, -0.041419632732868195, -0.006405106279999018, -0.020777713507413864, -0.0013706879690289497, 0.005962330382317305, -0.03181828185915947, -0.027312766760587692, 0.02100064978003502, -0.02841159515082836, 0.020619245246052742, 0.032901231199502945, 0.013067040592432022, 0.06989514827728271, -0.022026116028428078, -0.030093010514974594, 0.00013118263450451195, 0.04657880589365959, -0.07687189429998398, -0.045305754989385605, -0.03003588318824768, -0.0636390894651413, -0.04155278205871582, -0.012178303673863411, 0.03540903329849243, 0.029628539457917213, 0.003157130442559719, 0.028149129822850227, 0.0183882936835289, 0.0415819026529789, -0.008247528225183487, 0.025300325825810432, 0.010850267484784126, 0.03527972847223282, 0.026160867884755135, -0.013527821749448776, -0.0757962092757225, -0.0402190200984478, -0.00432861503213644, -0.03589222952723503, -0.04882269352674484, 0.040688563138246536, 0.05156582593917847, 0.04351692274212837, -0.0732085108757019, 0.04047900065779686, 0.010096107609570026, -0.027038441970944405, 0.032260213047266006, 0.059509772807359695, -0.012377346865832806, 0.03659763187170029, -0.024950601160526276, -0.017893895506858826, 0.006378897000104189, -0.03567755967378616, -0.03932609036564827, 0.013455899432301521, -0.004069730173796415, -0.006421091500669718, 0.04741789773106575, -0.03175909444689751, -0.049076829105615616, -0.0071150208823382854, -0.008505281060934067, 0.0053205182775855064, -0.05805009603500366, 0.01711723394691944, 0.02949664182960987, -0.03499053791165352, -0.03291373327374458, -0.022044355049729347, 0.024194277822971344, 0.011235767044126987, 0.012434086762368679, -0.06384119391441345, 0.02453519031405449, 0.027090394869446754, -0.01801236905157566, 0.006138199009001255, -0.0039167036302387714, 0.019477929919958115, -0.011439457535743713, 0.021494105458259583, 0.02687571384012699, -0.05418475717306137, -0.03134749457240105, -0.006425018887966871, 0.027758890762925148, 0.04705946892499924, 0.04574916139245033, 0.02842363342642784, 0.04195849597454071, -0.02391759492456913, -0.018927697092294693, -0.009366312995553017, 0.0047655971720814705, 0.03241818770766258, -0.05382686108350754, 0.030579790472984314, 0.04205438122153282, 0.040463440120220184, 0.021955549716949463, 0.01913897879421711, 0.04340711608529091, -0.02718285843729973, -0.02427654154598713, -0.03050997667014599, -0.0023685197811573744, -0.06791595369577408, -0.07530384510755539, 0.05400220677256584, 0.03655823692679405, -0.021295106038451195, 0.02212737686932087, -0.007164493668824434, -0.02903660759329796, 0.022446252405643463, -0.002995428629219532, 0.003641345538198948, -0.04827724024653435, -0.016331546008586884, 0.07614925503730774, 0.01652437262237072, -0.011154775507748127, 0.039831116795539856, -0.028886904940009117, -0.0442337840795517, -0.025617647916078568, 0.05161605775356293, 0.03832074627280235, -0.041789669543504715, -0.05754707381129265, 0.02550370804965496, 0.005983420182019472, -0.06869062036275864, -0.01704084500670433, 0.03101237490773201, -0.06632192432880402, 0.025246374309062958, 0.03576240316033363, -0.030270498245954514, -0.06328988820314407, 0.04384133219718933, 0.018231553956866264, -0.005530971568077803, -0.03304789215326309, 0.024025723338127136, 0.07531660795211792, 0.024572575464844704, 0.0037631469313055277, -0.019055189564824104, -0.049963004887104034, 0.03387827053666115, -0.05233122035861015, -0.01664312556385994, 0.00939984805881977, 0.037753280252218246, 0.02389809861779213, -0.049817685037851334, -0.0388694703578949, 0.06914354115724564, -0.04818432405591011, -0.01979145035147667, -0.014509347267448902, -0.022922702133655548, 0.06951586157083511, -0.037615448236465454, -0.023363851010799408, 0.010171490721404552, -0.023896941915154457, 0.033826325088739395, -0.04170362278819084, -0.0031528547406196594, 0.008140367455780506, -0.014078889042139053, 0.02026180364191532, -0.04372016713023186, 0.03162389248609543, -0.04239513352513313, -0.047780055552721024, 0.004298074170947075, -0.0382755845785141, 0.027392247691750526, -0.01085771806538105, 0.003976041916757822, 0.02034614607691765, -0.0017908780137076974, -0.06491777300834656, -0.01899559423327446, 0.004208886530250311, 0.011116554029285908, -0.03403954952955246, -0.04876122251152992, 0.04211682453751564, 0.007898212410509586, 0.043117985129356384, -0.010792574845254421, -0.02258908748626709, -0.024358082562685013, -0.04884735494852066, 0.02588368020951748, -0.014490191824734211, -0.058777835220098495, -0.025202792137861252, 0.012507383711636066, -0.040379516780376434, 0.001111240009777248, 0.014899332076311111, -0.05425461009144783, -0.03693518042564392, 0.017918424680829048, -0.02539237029850483, 0.013759410940110683, -0.03521307557821274, 0.04477321356534958, 0.019521184265613556, -0.011914543807506561, -0.0142082329839468, 0.04085279628634453, -0.04419872537255287, 0.00816288497298956, -0.027793876826763153, -0.031221576035022736, 0.014493783004581928, -0.007407954894006252, -0.045360155403614044, -0.029007574543356895, -0.02292640134692192, -0.07365274429321289, 0.027627285569906235, 0.028382882475852966, 0.002845682669430971, -0.003885249374434352, -0.07172868400812149, -0.018824521452188492, -0.0015517635038122535, -0.04308202862739563, -0.0667024552822113, 0.0003627718542702496, -0.021560732275247574, -0.014949356205761433, 0.011031311005353928, -0.009039388038218021, -0.034439265727996826, -0.014265516772866249, -0.07529587298631668, -0.015040899626910686, -0.012490641325712204, -0.018253326416015625, 0.019876301288604736, -0.03719152882695198, 0.004026885610073805, -0.05846437066793442, -0.039449114352464676, 0.04340456426143646, 0.008257928304374218, 0.013610471040010452, 0.04466395080089569, 0.02247687242925167, -0.07201880216598511, -0.026269685477018356, 0.004468587692826986, -0.017317313700914383, 0.0023918752558529377, 0.039287276566028595, 0.02997688017785549, 0.028156926855444908, -0.05943993106484413, 0.035138409584760666, -0.028098175302147865, -0.020518455654382706, -0.03337753936648369, 0.026241714134812355, -0.035280901938676834, -0.056521348655223846, 0.015710104256868362, -0.046703044325113297, 0.020408764481544495, 0.005490205716341734, 0.006770620588213205, 0.020884180441498756, -0.04385192319750786, -0.055994343012571335, 0.05920693650841713, -0.013119312934577465, 0.029827944934368134, 0.05545402690768242, -0.0528373047709465, 0.0008553217630833387, -0.00005083929863758385, -0.020519185811281204, -0.06405571848154068, 0.02194254845380783, 0.03916164115071297, -0.0098022585734725, -0.005389174912124872, -0.070222869515419, -0.012570398859679699, -0.00957250501960516, -0.019486162811517715, -0.058785077184438705, 0.07612580060958862, 0.02799379639327526, -0.04372837021946907, -0.012869100086390972, -0.04792119190096855, -0.059248264878988266, -0.006978586316108704, -0.036687325686216354, -0.019432218745350838, 0.03497486189007759, 0.0036407415755093098, 0.03284060209989548, 0.00892675668001175, 0.05157598853111267, 0.02731117606163025, 0.04461311921477318, -0.005759924650192261, -0.03459708392620087, -0.034263379871845245, 0.06749536097049713, -0.038828976452350616, -0.009230490773916245, -0.027456825599074364, 0.01289785373955965, -0.010896879248321056, -0.022646743804216385, -0.040256597101688385, 0.004901249427348375, 0.030470576137304306, -0.07738552987575531, -0.00909997709095478, 0.010510165244340897, -0.0030706373509019613, -0.039850618690252304, -0.03301491588354111, 0.03004937618970871, -0.04960915073752403, -0.03334848955273628 ]
This paper focuses on the identification of different algorithm-based biases in robotic behaviour and their consequences in human-robot mixed groups. We propose to develop computational models to detect episodes of microaggression, discrimination, and social exclusion informed by a) observing human coping behaviours that are used to regain social inclusion and b) using system inherent information that reveal unequal treatment of human interactants. Based on this information we can start to develop regulatory mechanisms to promote fairness and social inclusion in HRI.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01574v1
[ -0.031512100249528885, -0.04968186467885971, 0.0645875483751297, -0.02232147939503193, 0.025881124660372734, -0.013066980056464672, -0.019349629059433937, 0.005817401688545942, 0.010414382442831993, -0.0694679319858551, -0.05090736970305443, -0.022152366116642952, -0.0422024205327034, -0.030230896547436714, -0.04203839227557182, 0.04437625780701637, 0.03596798703074455, 0.05335339158773422, -0.031983599066734314, 0.0748865157365799, 0.02886354550719261, -0.02395564876496792, -0.03625965863466263, 0.035362210124731064, 0.0027942184824496508, -0.025609541684389114, 0.04798344522714615, -0.029178529977798462, -0.010617990978062153, -0.01682218536734581, 0.03811754658818245, -0.03004779852926731, -0.0015646223910152912, -0.04766644537448883, -0.05813854932785034, 0.002134534064680338, 0.013974630273878574, -0.04291754215955734, -0.003445760114118457, -0.0394584946334362, -0.052642375230789185, 0.004880697466433048, -0.06984743475914001, 0.014774827286601067, -0.016875134781003, 0.0287553109228611, -0.050666797906160355, -0.021727681159973145, -0.06568726152181625, -0.05534734949469566, -0.04558711498975754, 0.0065147667191922665, -0.018234429880976677, 0.055006422102451324, -0.06351898610591888, -0.007712263613939285, -0.025838950648903847, 0.023728230968117714, -0.021698961034417152, 0.025450574234128, 0.03498833626508713, -0.0016022827476263046, 0.00985022634267807, -0.004011400509625673, 0.036739688366651535, 0.014502327889204025, -0.021520746871829033, -0.04621981456875801, -0.013546368107199669, -0.031431302428245544, 0.06213964894413948, -0.0655023455619812, 0.05766638368368149, -0.006421067286282778, -0.049082063138484955, -0.026833154261112213, -0.019838131964206696, -0.028446627780795097, 0.02552417665719986, 0.02314421534538269, -0.055152952671051025, 0.06360182911157608, 0.043207984417676926, -0.004380525089800358, -0.030085671693086624, -0.04647570475935936, 0.03582070395350456, -0.07088596373796463, -0.004977445118129253, -0.03863419219851494, 0.028225962072610855, 0.03699439391493797, -0.05313492193818092, -0.034240975975990295, 0.0325387641787529, -0.021892445161938667, 0.00738891726359725, 0.016611488536000252, -0.013447718694806099, -0.0015093686524778605, -0.046145468950271606, 0.007852685637772083, -0.007695070933550596, 0.0678468644618988, 0.045592859387397766, -0.0285786222666502, -0.03326473385095596, 0.01657678373157978, -0.00038846483221277595, -0.03547896817326546, -0.052577581256628036, -0.008784578181803226, -0.03663020208477974, -0.07865313440561295, -0.06792660057544708, -0.012741198763251305, -0.000781334878411144, 0.004046352114528418, 0.002632583724334836, 0.015656040981411934, -0.0584588497877121, 0.039459940046072006, -0.06693098694086075, 0.00237947516143322, -0.05822195112705231, -0.014826931059360504, 0.03910723328590393, 0.0134959165006876, -0.0627472996711731, -0.030103329569101334, -0.03692186251282692, -0.029460424557328224, -0.030859123915433884, -0.06234966963529587, -0.0009691628511063755, -0.07166419923305511, 0.00325770303606987, -0.0428004153072834, 0.043047547340393066, -0.03990212455391884, -0.051790185272693634, -0.05954516679048538, -0.03677353262901306, -0.028820063918828964, 0.025849495083093643, 0.042832668870687485, -0.032556045800447464, -0.015953704714775085, 0.033624909818172455, 0.03531726449728012, 0.01481185108423233, 0.012032972648739815, 0.017942078411579132, 0.025125771760940552, 0.04993508383631706, -0.027886049821972847, 0.0418488010764122, -0.04885789006948471, -0.05968509241938591, -0.014201793819665909, -0.04041995853185654, -0.038636453449726105, 0.04365420714020729, -0.03355509042739868, -0.012306666933000088, 0.004649844486266375, 0.03647018224000931, 0.008453493937849998, -0.04314335063099861, -0.0403452068567276, -0.034087326377630234, 0.044626738876104355, 0.04646192491054535, -0.03362343832850456, -0.02814406342804432, -0.03421849384903908, -0.014070192351937294, -0.058647044003009796, -0.04541400074958801, 0.0093137938529253, 0.013118274509906769, 0.02187524177134037, -0.016906971111893654, 0.009852609597146511, -0.06340416520833969, -0.004091561771929264, -0.06652554124593735, -0.04991178587079048, 0.03414604440331459, 0.038568999618291855, -0.018720852211117744, -0.05769867077469826, 0.033436354249715805, 0.005459746811538935, -0.053856201469898224, -0.040387704968452454, 0.039817068725824356, -0.04349988326430321, -0.0018084765179082751, 0.05709968879818916, -0.07814410328865051, -0.026663264259696007, -0.040295835584402084, -0.04881744831800461, -0.01825348660349846, -0.050470564514398575, 0.030773555859923363, 0.0035918490029871464, -0.016317421570420265, -0.0376521535217762, 0.022591961547732353, -0.005520259495824575, 0.05259982496500015, -0.04298253357410431, -0.011339922435581684, 0.015472964383661747, -0.08524346351623535, 0.01607358269393444, 0.02924051508307457, -0.009220952168107033, 0.031866658478975296, 0.02020134963095188, 0.009221968241035938, -0.047842301428318024, -0.01634295843541622, 0.01969422958791256, -0.03524598479270935, -0.0065586925484240055, -0.004815883468836546, -0.021034937351942062, -0.062220629304647446, -0.07588713616132736, -0.022006258368492126, -0.06271720677614212, 0.030025320127606392, -0.04363301023840904, -0.03789635747671127, 0.03260102495551109, 0.00908406637609005, -0.055215220898389816, -0.03349987789988518, -0.04820333421230316, 0.04736439511179924, -0.01471263449639082, -0.009911504574120045, -0.05454320088028908, -0.042319681495428085, 0.032972224056720734, -0.03371768444776535, 0.06786737591028214, -0.02075260318815708, -0.026211516931653023, 0.03346725180745125, -0.007739894557744265, 0.03568277508020401, 0.013031167909502983, -0.04130386561155319, -0.00925187673419714, -0.037723418325185776, 0.055431462824344635, 0.0576557032763958, -0.003841604571789503, -0.07271138578653336, -0.008854523301124573, 0.05018075183033943, -0.017785541713237762, 0.009766852483153343, -0.00706076854839921, 0.05011935532093048, -0.061119016259908676, 0.04572126269340515, -0.006184462457895279, 0.025859210640192032, -0.06658024340867996, -0.040416017174720764, 0.011905398219823837, 0.012038285844027996, -0.03584301471710205, 0.00734339514747262, 0.03806740790605545, 0.022345198318362236, 0.04205182567238808, 0.027733884751796722, -0.05954446643590927, -0.018553132191300392, 0.02620689757168293, -0.018627187237143517, -0.05048055946826935, -0.053469620645046234, 0.005439220927655697, -0.06780266761779785, -0.01810435578227043, -0.008497762493789196, -0.029773617163300514, -0.026991240680217743, -0.06257057189941406, -0.07129853218793869, -0.010632560588419437, 0.007521484978497028, -0.04315032809972763, -0.03791298344731331, -0.0387115441262722, -0.007446864619851112, -0.034907691180706024, 0.00779877370223403, -0.05587105080485344, -0.04071866720914841, -0.030483629554510117, -0.013019709847867489, -0.01613921858370304, 0.004398146644234657, 0.007805136498063803, -0.04319768026471138, 0.017559999600052834, -0.0292733833193779, 0.010742234997451305, -0.02972545474767685, 0.020670559257268906, 0.01125851646065712, 0.022099653258919716, 0.033428993076086044, 0.002247337019070983, 0.06039220467209816, -0.043213412165641785, -0.027900833636522293, 0.020131487399339676, 0.04952216520905495, 0.02861294150352478, -0.02417941950261593, -0.04280180111527443, 0.013984337449073792, -0.006149230059236288, 0.02461702935397625, -0.008169478736817837, -0.01926526054739952, 0.015245196409523487, -0.01368164736777544, -0.013414296321570873, 0.015095376409590244, 0.02408026158809662, -0.04278072342276573, 0.003892902983352542, -0.019386349245905876, -0.04319659247994423, -0.04783548042178154, -0.059372399002313614, -0.021833954378962517, 0.016898786649107933, 0.061869263648986816, -0.006743913050740957, -0.01377436239272356, 0.03216559439897537, -0.020694559440016747, 0.018454190343618393, 0.0009026649640873075, 0.04761908948421478, 0.007208249997347593, 0.04934908449649811, -0.004876334220170975, -0.04445689544081688, 0.014007694087922573, -0.04790594056248665, -0.07189617305994034, -0.005234016105532646, 0.035834670066833496, 0.02369690127670765, 0.05637659877538681, -0.06184602156281471, 0.010871036909520626, 0.02903037890791893, -0.03178921714425087, 0.02087034285068512, -0.009615931659936905, 0.024104006588459015, 0.004931333940476179, 0.03290519118309021, -0.02614682726562023, -0.01334426086395979, -0.05302385613322258, -0.0563497431576252, 0.018703460693359375, -0.0638979971408844, 0.04604401811957359, 0.04961755871772766, 0.03287304565310478, 0.0391814298927784, 0.003885731566697359, 0.05290064960718155, 0.05837349221110344, -0.008471759036183357, 0.0030660354532301426, -0.008924489840865135, -0.009117309004068375, -0.02180819772183895, -0.047742508351802826, -0.05620943009853363, -0.007068803533911705, -0.006821895018219948, -0.023331264033913612, -0.014595044776797295, 0.0036300932988524437, -0.008445968851447105, -0.04849566891789436, -0.08244433999061584, -0.010501623153686523, -0.02698517218232155, -0.004185240715742111, -0.012416561134159565, -0.04089169576764107, 0.04857175797224045, -0.03874998167157173, -0.043280087411403656, -0.01603495143353939, 0.016428420320153236, -0.01631755568087101, 0.013670798391103745, -0.022751737385988235, -0.06439931690692902, 0.022980011999607086, -0.04195151850581169, -0.03475520387291908, -0.005098694935441017, 0.008856254629790783, -0.048283081501722336, -0.0034760162234306335, 0.004494486376643181, -0.02508489415049553, 0.03934849798679352, 0.008832531981170177, 0.0207193773239851, -0.06938765197992325, 0.03876744583249092, 0.0052473717369139194, -0.024672986939549446, 0.010980243794620037, -0.02086755447089672, 0.04878693073987961, -0.025458501651883125, -0.018617620691657066, 0.005959810223430395, -0.019924158230423927, 0.025014115497469902, 0.016580617055296898, -0.0326378308236599, -0.052275400608778, 0.05048377811908722, -0.028343329206109047, -0.03756333887577057, -0.04379664734005928, -0.026639191433787346, -0.045167017728090286, -0.041780948638916016, -0.011937337927520275, 0.009558379650115967, -0.006763156037777662, 0.008997520431876183, -0.027564821764826775, 0.036145806312561035, -0.02480354532599449, 0.0009460356086492538, 0.018844034522771835, 0.02228010632097721, 0.018041471019387245, -0.04462951794266701, -0.03973500430583954, 0.030085720121860504, -0.017755864188075066, 0.01779576763510704, -0.04949625954031944, 0.04884423315525055, 0.03834177553653717, 0.03245647996664047, -0.07892297208309174, 0.047637663781642914, 0.059485096484422684, 0.026081504300236702, 0.053269241005182266, 0.04846145957708359, -0.03265368193387985, 0.035580866038799286, -0.05780153349041939, 0.0029096209909766912, 0.015957381576299667, 0.014334479346871376, -0.024705814197659492, -0.042503248900175095, 0.01742997206747532, -0.011680927127599716, 0.05171514302492142, -0.03942317143082619, -0.053456470370292664, -0.035057928413152695, 0.01197008229792118, 0.008431152440607548, -0.041625216603279114, 0.04867005720734596, 0.0360758900642395, -0.05341409891843796, -0.05126144737005234, -0.009088005870580673, 0.0127495052292943, 0.014181927777826786, -0.006950312294065952, -0.0495157428085804, 0.05915346369147301, 0.0013081282377243042, -0.028531990945339203, -0.00008895318751456216, 0.013394329696893692, 0.026492701843380928, 0.041329577565193176, 0.014937388710677624, -0.003155590035021305, -0.04376855120062828, -0.05125794559717178, -0.039827682077884674, 0.06312438100576401, 0.032516658306121826, -0.02551640197634697, 0.020688476040959358, -0.015537177212536335, 0.0022544432431459427, -0.041048627346754074, -0.013397837057709694, -0.006365240551531315, -0.01387815922498703, -0.02979348786175251, 0.04183084890246391, 0.026156775653362274, 0.05660635232925415, 0.02880156971514225, -0.046461399644613266, 0.017034631222486496, -0.040577080100774765, -0.06010300666093826, -0.02302289940416813, 0.015662794932723045, -0.011009719222784042, -0.04921060800552368, 0.02867358922958374, -0.004546387121081352, -0.044252194464206696, -0.009819025173783302, 0.01603325456380844, -0.029558317735791206, -0.017729496583342552, 0.05413978174328804, -0.02100067026913166, -0.04723304510116577, 0.04162795469164848, 0.04867270961403847, -0.03170986473560333, -0.028327634558081627, -0.04527464881539345, -0.030913565307855606, -0.01133409421890974, 0.01069024670869112, -0.02310735546052456, -0.020630935207009315, -0.012955124489963055, -0.0693938285112381, -0.004328995477408171, -0.014438613317906857, -0.022177517414093018, -0.04144618287682533, -0.028477000072598457, -0.07006639987230301, -0.014601766131818295, 0.006029527168720961, -0.026399914175271988, -0.05453159287571907, 0.04694440960884094, -0.050935011357069016, 0.007094892673194408, -0.04962935671210289, 0.04199305549263954, 0.06502977013587952, -0.011260692030191422, -0.0187145434319973, -0.022879842668771744, -0.07129233330488205, -0.03821532800793648, -0.0362466461956501, -0.044743217527866364, -0.012768376618623734, 0.019691484048962593, 0.04503144696354866, -0.050182513892650604, -0.05308080464601517, 0.05274242162704468, 0.004089400637894869, 0.0005781627260148525, -0.019023094326257706, -0.04451500251889229, 0.04714369773864746, 0.0043783895671367645, -0.016301942989230156, 0.004328169859945774, 0.004129727371037006, -0.057688403874635696, -0.045419178903102875, -0.049676451832056046, -0.0044615245424211025, -0.011278065852820873, -0.012814251706004143, -0.03939418867230415, -0.020416120067238808, -0.026927772909402847, -0.02721722610294819, 0.03673112392425537, -0.05927252024412155, 0.036586567759513855, -0.014966665767133236, -0.009333258494734764, 0.01464893575757742, 0.042456381022930145, 0.009583420120179653, 0.027791855856776237, 0.05217161402106285, -0.008730106055736542, 0.02700015902519226, -0.035303398966789246, 0.00856111291795969, 0.028200479224324226, -0.0013342676684260368, -0.0038899611681699753, -0.019623637199401855, -0.039523281157016754, -0.04314340278506279, 0.011368844658136368, 0.03636850416660309, 0.017712850123643875, -0.06739961355924606, -0.015503505244851112, 0.01615152508020401, -0.04374876990914345, 0.018186122179031372, -0.06179222837090492, 0.032628729939460754, 0.03726739436388016, -0.017040306702256203, -0.025311056524515152, -0.06636178493499756, 0.03708639740943909, 0.012726053595542908, 0.039956990629434586, 0.014316889457404613, -0.020949315279722214, 0.032817643135786057, -0.031043337658047676, -0.0747738629579544, -0.0438852421939373, 0.06352599710226059, -0.032082606106996536, -0.010078251361846924, -0.01685664989054203, -0.037028051912784576, -0.05854090675711632, -0.00440444378182292, 0.027269873768091202, -0.026928631588816643, 0.0003178838815074414, -0.06833525002002716, 0.02086210995912552, -0.011584584601223469, -0.06848284602165222, -0.05474170297384262, -0.036287494003772736, -0.01696299947798252, -0.050702258944511414, 0.006296565756201744, -0.016116930171847343, -0.05796220526099205, 0.031247472390532494, -0.07408926635980606, 0.0031208968721330166, -0.01036897674202919, 0.005462173838168383, -0.02600746601819992, -0.020176129415631294, -0.03289317712187767, -0.0605122335255146, 0.04273933172225952, -0.004125152714550495, 0.01732572540640831, 0.0360025130212307, 0.004437614232301712, 0.06245798245072365, -0.039261408150196075, -0.03076765313744545, 0.028989003971219063, -0.025563746690750122, -0.005236182361841202, 0.0320405587553978, 0.04675029218196869, 0.018649278208613396, -0.029289137572050095, 0.0008749209227971733, -0.021628059446811676, -0.01520624104887247, -0.044862113893032074, 0.027266090735793114, -0.06269521266222, -0.06502547115087509, 0.034517500549554825, -0.02047356218099594, 0.05078544095158577, 0.02406238578259945, -0.01145177148282528, -0.03211212530732155, -0.017196517437696457, -0.03752533346414566, 0.06818310916423798, 0.005193860735744238, 0.05427190288901329, 0.03409084305167198, 0.00008726276428205892, -0.0074061076156795025, -0.04116180166602135, 0.012758953496813774, -0.01769452728331089, -0.004894845653325319, 0.0407693050801754, -0.05048641934990883, 0.03021608665585518, -0.05621730536222458, 0.009360766969621181, 0.0276067815721035, -0.028948677703738213, -0.029402418062090874, 0.060121677815914154, 0.009884667582809925, -0.05622846260666847, 0.01563657633960247, -0.019659731537103653, -0.013392896391451359, -0.03037746250629425, -0.04604391008615494, -0.026089215651154518, -0.01671433262526989, -0.007122092880308628, 0.018031854182481766, 0.015125244855880737, 0.03278306871652603, -0.004229087382555008, 0.04758777841925621, 0.026722583919763565, -0.005912246648222208, -0.032198380678892136, 0.07612036168575287, 0.04428496211767197, 0.03448981046676636, -0.06342817842960358, 0.04639948159456253, 0.0054366858676075935, 0.03445430099964142, 0.02776501141488552, -0.003553768154233694, -0.05222958326339722, -0.045561689883470535, -0.019913997501134872, 0.0568387433886528, 0.006710922811180353, -0.0416063517332077, -0.025704074651002884, 0.025767045095562935, -0.03953108191490173, -0.05666279420256615 ]
Legged locomotion is a complex control problem that requires both accuracy and robustness to cope with real-world challenges. Legged systems have traditionally been controlled using trajectory optimization with inverse dynamics. Such hierarchical model-based methods are appealing due to intuitive cost function tuning, accurate planning, generalization, and most importantly, the insightful understanding gained from more than one decade of extensive research. However, model mismatch and violation of assumptions are common sources of faulty operation. Simulation-based reinforcement learning, on the other hand, results in locomotion policies with unprecedented robustness and recovery skills. Yet, all learning algorithms struggle with sparse rewards emerging from environments where valid footholds are rare, such as gaps or stepping stones. In this work, we propose a hybrid control architecture that combines the advantages of both worlds to simultaneously achieve greater robustness, foot-placement accuracy, and terrain generalization. Our approach utilizes a model-based planner to roll out a reference motion during training. A deep neural network policy is trained in simulation, aiming to track the optimized footholds. We evaluate the accuracy of our locomotion pipeline on sparse terrains, where pure data-driven methods are prone to fail. Furthermore, we demonstrate superior robustness in the presence of slippery or deformable ground when compared to model-based counterparts. Finally, we show that our proposed tracking controller generalizes across different trajectory optimization methods not seen during training. In conclusion, our work unites the predictive capabilities and optimality guarantees of online planning with the inherent robustness attributed to offline learning.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15462v2
[ -0.03060561791062355, -0.008387142792344093, 0.035515762865543365, 0.02906051278114319, -0.014516016468405724, -0.008164537139236927, 0.02204672247171402, -0.002696381649002433, 0.01579793356359005, -0.04415104165673256, -0.03393525630235672, -0.025427842512726784, -0.060644302517175674, -0.03720802813768387, -0.02903200313448906, 0.0031087093520909548, 0.0819636732339859, -0.044185820966959, -0.060269251465797424, 0.05459298565983772, -0.004564862698316574, 0.009410853497684002, -0.010172039270401001, 0.010236799716949463, 0.020455535501241684, -0.019412485882639885, -0.04581591486930847, 0.022493498399853706, -0.038221217691898346, -0.014242901466786861, 0.07195690274238586, -0.006203938741236925, -0.02632986754179001, -0.03552209958434105, -0.016483383253216743, 0.006928830873221159, -0.025544822216033936, 0.01727491430938244, 0.06742093712091446, -0.0043603056110441685, 0.04266176372766495, -0.011331871151924133, -0.05967956408858299, 0.011624793522059917, -0.04587264731526375, 0.010387551970779896, 0.0018342992989346385, 0.025224654003977776, -0.06431049853563309, -0.03203806281089783, 0.018941238522529602, -0.03593943640589714, 0.03495222330093384, 0.048770472407341, -0.03152652084827423, 0.018564973026514053, -0.004998400341719389, 0.015628935769200325, -0.044645778834819794, -0.04046924039721489, -0.009349989704787731, -0.02395087294280529, -0.001628001220524311, 0.00015489646466448903, 0.02343520149588585, 0.047847166657447815, 0.00877690315246582, -0.0692874863743782, -0.04246651008725166, -0.008132071234285831, 0.04779639095067978, -0.05286779627203941, 0.017436694353818893, 0.032492559403181076, -0.022718921303749084, -0.005194147117435932, -0.028176935389637947, -0.04197423532605171, 0.025367634370923042, 0.0019615504425019026, -0.03943885862827301, 0.012989509850740433, 0.04289477318525314, 0.03130257874727249, 0.0003573539142962545, -0.01455683633685112, 0.03947197273373604, 0.0028332138899713755, 0.039064232259988785, -0.04481623321771622, 0.03009572997689247, -0.03138250112533569, -0.06020760163664818, -0.008446193300187588, 0.07633478939533234, -0.04535909742116928, 0.06888482719659805, 0.05309710279107094, 0.025230279192328453, -0.008300713263452053, -0.043602749705314636, -0.01835707575082779, -0.04478514567017555, 0.05244903266429901, 0.01776142232120037, -0.05456957593560219, -0.0054782177321612835, -0.010661509819328785, -0.020383968949317932, 0.01744006760418415, -0.004636276047676802, -0.02920791134238243, 0.012640689499676228, -0.06027929112315178, -0.03685792163014412, -0.026680083945393562, 0.06022115424275398, 0.02024960145354271, 0.017341239377856255, 0.007226203568279743, -0.03652285784482956, 0.04213213920593262, -0.0009780871914699674, -0.016354260966181755, 0.006347488146275282, -0.027562811970710754, 0.07022922486066818, 0.008237174712121487, 0.003864507656544447, 0.019375093281269073, -0.04017334058880806, -0.00296028982847929, 0.024133993312716484, -0.05548795685172081, 0.06111260503530502, -0.00010938902414636686, 0.03157311677932739, -0.05048691853880882, 0.034420907497406006, 0.0071970089338719845, -0.026230338960886, -0.07091853767633438, 0.021012013778090477, -0.023703962564468384, 0.015094532631337643, 0.06314927339553833, -0.0653267651796341, -0.017532216385006905, -0.029725782573223114, 0.05186987295746803, 0.04272438585758209, 0.02350904792547226, 0.03833645209670067, 0.0438707061111927, 0.03955339267849922, -0.0027454523369669914, 0.04841430485248566, -0.006864933297038078, -0.05159550905227661, 0.004539487883448601, 0.04463167488574982, -0.04887280985713005, 0.03736318275332451, -0.005564430262893438, 0.019489632919430733, 0.05459482967853546, 0.043577972799539566, -0.0048181782476603985, -0.032562606036663055, 0.0026903951074928045, -0.02327481471002102, 0.018864354118704796, 0.002046380890533328, -0.03009379841387272, -0.06343099474906921, -0.03134239464998245, 0.008785588666796684, -0.04219293221831322, -0.03222846984863281, 0.022562341764569283, 0.021186521276831627, 0.051802411675453186, -0.048366695642471313, 0.03832579776644707, -0.007409518584609032, -0.014174602925777435, -0.09869977086782455, -0.022984016686677933, 0.016825884580612183, 0.014624208211898804, -0.05668623745441437, -0.05316111445426941, 0.013371242210268974, -0.02076968550682068, -0.06201881170272827, -0.0617549903690815, 0.0019468055106699467, -0.0234066229313612, 0.006762394681572914, 0.02261381223797798, -0.09252633899450302, 0.018543966114521027, -0.07085970044136047, -0.00653426256030798, -0.01888854056596756, -0.05706381797790527, 0.01719026453793049, 0.04669591039419174, -0.03385646268725395, -0.0010205155704170465, 0.034772735089063644, 0.045057497918605804, 0.06644748896360397, 0.0026766201481223106, 0.00538252480328083, 0.018599489703774452, -0.10525557398796082, 0.02759002521634102, 0.02025325782597065, 0.012276209890842438, 0.01687168888747692, -0.002929494483396411, -0.019896045327186584, -0.01886574923992157, -0.03502189740538597, 0.0244123712182045, 0.06976540386676788, -0.002510299440473318, -0.036744341254234314, -0.010319232009351254, -0.04770348593592644, -0.07304609566926956, -0.02279581129550934, -0.07035816460847855, -0.054151806980371475, 0.003465672256425023, -0.014775454066693783, 0.05482736602425575, 0.011336665600538254, -0.005199851002544165, -0.050813235342502594, -0.036652904003858566, 0.01770554482936859, -0.037915851920843124, -0.0567522868514061, -0.03703587129712105, -0.034600548446178436, 0.009540356695652008, 0.013862352818250656, 0.005588702391833067, -0.04211327061057091, -0.048329103738069534, -0.0006683142273686826, -0.009465246461331844, 0.009729097597301006, 0.05728834122419357, -0.02142055332660675, -0.00007581801764899865, -0.03905913233757019, 0.05247249826788902, 0.02018079161643982, 0.005608974490314722, -0.07430975139141083, 0.015665270388126373, 0.04141326621174812, 0.0391642302274704, 0.0036103164311498404, -0.021261271089315414, 0.02719416283071041, -0.03909103572368622, 0.003606990445405245, 0.004002735484391451, 0.03500395640730858, 0.011655627749860287, 0.016702141612768173, -0.04092605039477348, -0.004761328920722008, -0.02615686133503914, -0.011975851841270924, 0.060190726071596146, 0.042010799050331116, 0.004806716926395893, 0.016418280079960823, -0.03734814003109932, 0.011443018913269043, -0.04834238439798355, -0.010370689444243908, -0.06354966014623642, -0.053080931305885315, -0.013448994606733322, -0.07400532066822052, -0.027575118467211723, -0.025842813774943352, -0.04952891916036606, -0.035076308995485306, -0.05183921381831169, -0.01343909278512001, 0.03493834286928177, 0.002712121931836009, -0.030051590874791145, -0.0405980721116066, -0.04534772038459778, 0.004117373377084732, 0.03201178461313248, -0.010660090483725071, -0.051561396569013596, -0.04914780706167221, -0.04789363592863083, 0.013388325460255146, -0.029844405129551888, -0.02474481798708439, 0.04172150790691376, -0.006188303232192993, 0.053804609924554825, 0.025932664051651955, 0.0063486057333648205, -0.0065744793973863125, 0.028831100091338158, -0.02848813124001026, 0.015291024930775166, 0.03131362050771713, 0.0022964421659708023, -0.005811662878841162, -0.030834361910820007, -0.03448906168341637, -0.009404278360307217, 0.06508800387382507, -0.028519567102193832, -0.03563273698091507, -0.022577742114663124, 0.01631077006459236, -0.0033572716638445854, 0.023748230189085007, -0.022747376933693886, 0.04216789826750755, 0.05999002605676651, -0.0008032101322896779, -0.013418309390544891, -0.014980664476752281, 0.03713257610797882, -0.018788881599903107, 0.03821937367320061, -0.025394022464752197, 0.019355012103915215, 0.04089263454079628, -0.09478147327899933, 0.029664956033229828, 0.011210470460355282, 0.05727744102478027, -0.016694648191332817, 0.05626172199845314, -0.002963513368740678, 0.006846724543720484, 0.009113628417253494, -0.0014599044807255268, -0.003979473374783993, 0.03673037514090538, 0.06547363847494125, -0.02636338584125042, -0.022300811484456062, -0.0212322436273098, -0.08195865899324417, -0.041071098297834396, 0.005897320806980133, 0.04030179604887962, -0.005814671982079744, 0.026436828076839447, -0.07631988078355789, 0.012848018668591976, -0.01267169788479805, 0.03451741859316826, -0.01664303056895733, -0.03667425364255905, 0.057609230279922485, -0.013315058313310146, 0.017937006428837776, -0.006642131134867668, 0.007175659295171499, 0.04322425276041031, -0.03455488383769989, 0.017206748947501183, -0.06610509753227234, 0.034364838153123856, -0.028967155143618584, -0.028311695903539658, 0.049287546426057816, 0.03533463552594185, -0.04321308061480522, 0.05972317233681679, -0.013585349544882774, -0.029042918235063553, -0.00397407915443182, -0.023162338882684708, -0.02899947762489319, -0.007084926590323448, -0.054794155061244965, 0.008582686074078083, 0.04773908481001854, -0.003498264355584979, -0.006633952725678682, 0.007880297489464283, 0.028680002316832542, -0.00956744235008955, -0.08880121260881424, 0.030297700315713882, -0.03870156407356262, 0.04394562542438507, 0.009888438507914543, -0.00010243036376778036, 0.08696155250072479, -0.03913161903619766, -0.047210708260536194, -0.015764430165290833, -0.03428814932703972, -0.009672587737441063, -0.01624765247106552, -0.04787600785493851, -0.06395302712917328, 0.057596173137426376, -0.062245793640613556, 0.054356835782527924, -0.01940128766000271, 0.04662162438035011, -0.04238736256957054, -0.022203592583537102, 0.012206283397972584, 0.062054701149463654, 0.05580999329686165, 0.023633966222405434, -0.007021700963377953, -0.0037409462966024876, 0.002048318739980459, 0.00868105236440897, 0.005638137459754944, -0.02695518545806408, -0.009187808260321617, 0.03728722780942917, -0.0399681031703949, -0.03316197171807289, -0.0018771745963022113, 0.0060919481329619884, 0.06780532002449036, -0.020801644772291183, -0.008109302259981632, -0.011964981444180012, 0.048874251544475555, -0.0563114732503891, -0.07545346021652222, -0.02616831474006176, -0.03325382620096207, -0.040901292115449905, -0.02748466283082962, 0.04820879548788071, 0.044158678501844406, -0.00977229978889227, 0.009562832303345203, -0.02868807688355446, 0.011941099539399147, -0.023322591558098793, 0.021071048453450203, 0.026836730539798737, 0.004581274464726448, 0.014555316418409348, -0.05071590468287468, -0.08204610645771027, 0.011911105364561081, 0.01638912782073021, 0.012844555079936981, -0.023148586973547935, 0.06372451782226562, 0.01924707368016243, 0.04005930572748184, -0.09635384380817413, 0.012137660756707191, 0.03877263516187668, -0.052806902676820755, 0.03053255006670952, 0.06155746430158615, -0.04994391277432442, 0.021472608670592308, -0.05775771662592888, -0.003918739501386881, 0.030426157638430595, -0.02743413858115673, 0.016175739467144012, 0.009606611914932728, -0.024367060512304306, 0.006304457783699036, 0.06671589612960815, 0.020275214686989784, -0.04584968090057373, -0.004362243227660656, -0.00030369070009328425, 0.02668643370270729, -0.031497035175561905, 0.03545060381293297, 0.028599457815289497, -0.02408459596335888, -0.017002688720822334, -0.01420094445347786, 0.014530167914927006, -0.011055861599743366, 0.007168312557041645, -0.03397266939282417, 0.027448231354355812, 0.0423026978969574, -0.02947121113538742, 0.02731679007411003, 0.01832975633442402, 0.026487592607736588, -0.0005727416137233377, -0.02990228496491909, 0.031917743384838104, -0.07011359184980392, -0.016194701194763184, -0.005018987692892551, 0.03473253175616264, 0.030266478657722473, 0.04510475695133209, 0.007738196291029453, 0.018105339258909225, -0.048641424626111984, -0.012077071703970432, 0.023827577009797096, -0.003189100418239832, 0.024953799322247505, -0.0440790168941021, 0.04659697040915489, 0.0077432431280612946, 0.015980994328856468, 0.029819395393133163, -0.00682518444955349, -0.031984567642211914, -0.03276790305972099, 0.00545456912368536, -0.009593727067112923, 0.0394035279750824, -0.044330887496471405, -0.05033556744456291, 0.04107775166630745, 0.023445816710591316, -0.0027370050083845854, 0.026061654090881348, 0.03385387361049652, -0.007773334626108408, 0.0587172694504261, -0.02062329836189747, -0.005496947094798088, -0.010574039071798325, 0.002791691804304719, 0.07563480734825134, -0.04324759542942047, 0.007341230288147926, -0.039916250854730606, -0.0444549135863781, -0.0281729307025671, -0.05338329076766968, 0.029323171824216843, 0.0002914802171289921, 0.0056474097073078156, -0.05006089061498642, 0.03428987041115761, -0.03646503761410713, -0.05116008222103119, -0.004717875272035599, 0.01853339746594429, -0.08486954867839813, -0.01406514085829258, 0.009177199564874172, -0.011990468949079514, -0.032628368586301804, 0.018555257469415665, 0.024929387494921684, 0.027981165796518326, -0.036895979195833206, 0.06494999676942825, 0.09072080254554749, 0.011287136934697628, -0.0001730945659801364, 0.0037694210186600685, -0.040371354669332504, 0.012122978456318378, -0.027702489867806435, 0.017861101776361465, -0.012685582973062992, 0.03129139915108681, -0.015207882039248943, -0.039339616894721985, -0.0036934325471520424, 0.07989391684532166, -0.040874041616916656, -0.04552904888987541, 0.010342643596231937, 0.0048292032442986965, 0.06625916063785553, -0.006274214014410973, -0.03681739419698715, -0.008357124403119087, 0.029702506959438324, -0.042174141854047775, -0.03947390243411064, -0.03073529154062271, 0.015893172472715378, -0.007544474210590124, -0.04194983094930649, -0.05800747498869896, 0.025412097573280334, -0.01526403147727251, -0.07152938097715378, -0.0012454688549041748, -0.018526220694184303, 0.012867869809269905, -0.04983443021774292, -0.014364792965352535, 0.03726697713136673, 0.03852834179997444, -0.055552273988723755, 0.004938024096190929, -0.015186899341642857, 0.020232582464814186, -0.013457675464451313, -0.027219871059060097, -0.0036719641648232937, 0.003873817389830947, 0.052134931087493896, -0.023403605446219444, -0.00974039826542139, -0.037261713296175, -0.0003908906364813447, 0.01012110710144043, -0.01239081658422947, -0.05003925412893295, -0.020457839593291283, -0.02165207825601101, -0.014750396832823753, 0.025014687329530716, 0.017553158104419708, -0.04157653823494911, -0.0629005879163742, 0.029053324833512306, 0.03656104952096939, 0.01181233860552311, -0.017297856509685516, 0.023383816704154015, 0.006614453159272671, -0.02578243426978588, 0.039605047553777695, 0.05042453482747078, 0.0021011331118643284, 0.0358077809214592, -0.06670800596475601, -0.037991829216480255, 0.006790622603148222, -0.012891951948404312, -0.05562266334891319, -0.03555159643292427, -0.037473563104867935, -0.060648903250694275, -0.005284367129206657, 0.05911461263895035, 0.001699453336186707, 0.0250629223883152, -0.08659538626670837, 0.049015942960977554, -0.020627262070775032, -0.004093596246093512, -0.05170030519366264, 0.007782740984112024, 0.01916763186454773, -0.007287346757948399, -0.009288230910897255, -0.005612984765321016, -0.048290710896253586, 0.006582352332770824, -0.08015158772468567, 0.0020186027977615595, 0.02037741057574749, 0.05054585635662079, 0.00894500594586134, -0.038925252854824066, -0.014012797735631466, -0.04298518970608711, -0.0023224360775202513, 0.02556137926876545, 0.021527530625462532, 0.04582110419869423, 0.051072388887405396, -0.005210280418395996, -0.0561029277741909, -0.01641780324280262, 0.06203494593501091, -0.004803190939128399, 0.025263087823987007, 0.03644896671175957, 0.022269099950790405, 0.04348570853471756, 0.003706286894157529, 0.03131050243973732, -0.039017025381326675, 0.05764814838767052, -0.022587941959500313, 0.04530530422925949, -0.04240716993808746, -0.062020640820264816, 0.01698606088757515, -0.03782222047448158, -0.017891550436615944, 0.016514264047145844, 0.024405036121606827, -0.012989480048418045, -0.030357548967003822, -0.06601706892251968, 0.044811028987169266, -0.0003669370198622346, -0.003722157794982195, 0.046403396874666214, -0.04451525956392288, 0.012103365734219551, -0.04353194683790207, -0.008734303526580334, -0.010441005229949951, 0.03757890686392784, 0.010956540703773499, -0.03194424510002136, -0.011545233428478241, -0.08333106338977814, 0.0016973174642771482, -0.03602008521556854, 0.021133139729499817, -0.045446183532476425, 0.0638020783662796, -0.011325372382998466, -0.017545713111758232, -0.016062427312135696, -0.037088342010974884, -0.06516701728105545, -0.07168329507112503, -0.009980231523513794, -0.061116985976696014, 0.033263374119997025, -0.0018089946825057268, 0.046785272657871246, 0.023912038654088974, 0.05572265759110451, 0.05683450773358345, 0.046444445848464966, -0.04705488309264183, 0.025644227862358093, -0.06433672457933426, 0.08403205871582031, 0.00025132851442322135, -0.010478822514414787, -0.028158964589238167, 0.011303593404591084, -0.0013408638769760728, -0.03484008088707924, -0.06102040782570839, -0.021834099665284157, -0.017262401059269905, -0.06152212247252464, 0.005232333671301603, -0.005081691313534975, -0.006054438650608063, -0.03166472166776657, 0.009796330705285072, 0.019570522010326385, -0.022305456921458244, -0.04176892712712288 ]
The increasing availability of large clinical datasets collected from patients can enable new avenues for computational characterization of complex diseases using different analytic algorithms. One of the promising new methods for extracting knowledge from large clinical datasets involves temporal pattern mining integrated with machine learning workflows. However, mining these temporal patterns is a computational intensive task and has memory repercussions. Current algorithms, such as the temporal sequence pattern mining (tSPM) algorithm, are already providing promising outcomes, but still leave room for optimization. In this paper, we present the tSPM+ algorithm, a high-performance implementation of the tSPM algorithm, which adds a new dimension by adding the duration to the temporal patterns. We show that the tSPM+ algorithm provides a speed up to factor 980 and a up to 48 fold improvement in memory consumption. Moreover, we present a docker container with an R-package, We also provide vignettes for an easy integration into already existing machine learning workflows and use the mined temporal sequences to identify Post COVID-19 patients and their symptoms according to the WHO definition.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05671v1
[ 0.034011710435152054, -0.039594363421201706, 0.06437163054943085, 0.02844826504588127, -0.056306466460227966, 0.04167011380195618, 0.03467210754752159, -0.03465018421411514, -0.00037037511356174946, 0.017095720395445824, -0.03283144533634186, 0.06706936657428741, -0.02892945148050785, -0.02147829346358776, -0.0427229180932045, -0.006885111331939697, 0.06225012242794037, -0.0011280602775514126, -0.029886046424508095, 0.0849180519580841, 0.022429464384913445, 0.013344754464924335, -0.03144896402955055, 0.016969161108136177, 0.01979844644665718, -0.04629216715693474, 0.006515495013445616, -0.02260339818894863, -0.02121930941939354, -0.04136892780661583, 0.08110114187002182, -0.016904043033719063, -0.03369767963886261, -0.04346984252333641, 0.0011840088991448283, -0.018522799015045166, 0.0030917974654585123, 0.013598348945379257, -0.024250313639640808, -0.003735339967533946, 0.01704546995460987, -0.04890114814043045, -0.0505666546523571, -0.026964787393808365, 0.009215661324560642, 0.015837395563721657, -0.02562798745930195, -0.022543849423527718, -0.056977156549692154, -0.039113596081733704, 0.04657750576734543, -0.01605018600821495, -0.029578987509012222, 0.043029651045799255, -0.01311329286545515, -0.00419997051358223, 0.008169688284397125, 0.06285591423511505, -0.0680660605430603, -0.02340773679316044, 0.014258141629397869, 0.02457852102816105, -0.02293672226369381, 0.00028004826162941754, 0.048385243862867355, 0.0681178942322731, -0.039112843573093414, -0.0730457454919815, -0.053299229592084885, -0.04883338138461113, 0.0574166513979435, -0.05645577982068062, 0.02764529548585415, 0.0006903342436999083, -0.05194387212395668, 0.004511035978794098, -0.020709723234176636, -0.011173675768077374, -0.014291875995695591, -0.012855639681220055, -0.03789690509438515, 0.05377838388085365, 0.010624602437019348, 0.014217990450561047, 0.00015909595822449774, -0.04946984723210335, 0.04974382743239403, -0.02317517250776291, -0.004826635587960482, -0.052470654249191284, 0.0352199524641037, -0.03489905595779419, -0.07303950935602188, 0.008693026378750801, 0.08402931690216064, -0.016870759427547455, 0.008318344131112099, 0.04218737408518791, 0.023376604542136192, 0.029413530603051186, -0.052682943642139435, 0.008593376725912094, -0.02474765107035637, 0.03550543263554573, 0.0409669503569603, -0.03191855549812317, 0.018045058473944664, -0.030377186834812164, -0.054283834993839264, -0.012603582814335823, -0.027140727266669273, -0.0043700700625777245, 0.011921891942620277, -0.04574146494269371, -0.031161604449152946, -0.05873753875494003, 0.045627955347299576, -0.01943971961736679, 0.015662549063563347, -0.0011485533323138952, -0.013863928616046906, 0.015973612666130066, 0.04098520800471306, 0.029854975640773773, -0.026330921798944473, -0.03507603704929352, 0.021504666656255722, 0.008559873327612877, -0.04455355927348137, -0.047414109110832214, -0.009496219456195831, 0.03252562880516052, -0.03415562957525253, 0.013105839490890503, 0.048900261521339417, -0.019038552418351173, -0.04958726838231087, -0.06383247673511505, 0.05844524875283241, 0.009107235819101334, -0.052862681448459625, -0.07531259208917618, 0.011960706673562527, -0.02553987316787243, -0.03765401616692543, 0.029713569208979607, -0.04099589213728905, -0.021204525604844093, 0.05267636477947235, -0.010963394306600094, 0.0075225066393613815, 0.0018044455209746957, 0.012324855662882328, -0.005766130983829498, 0.004964039195328951, 0.042881689965724945, 0.044715601950883865, -0.061425626277923584, -0.04486818611621857, 0.020925680175423622, -0.02623855136334896, -0.03479325398802757, 0.01238655298948288, -0.019708048552274704, 0.035939693450927734, -0.028517894446849823, 0.013646970503032207, -0.007110804319381714, 0.014786566607654095, 0.051217567175626755, -0.019800381734967232, -0.025384798645973206, 0.02215500921010971, -0.027893172577023506, -0.03935416042804718, -0.021995916962623596, -0.006834191270172596, -0.020833414047956467, -0.07655230909585953, -0.047805991023778915, -0.0028863013722002506, 0.032437339425086975, -0.021613435819745064, -0.028715210035443306, -0.060338061302900314, -0.0018331281607970595, -0.08245470374822617, -0.0035076055210083723, 0.06167787313461304, 0.029077576473355293, -0.02163323573768139, -0.03399895504117012, -0.012971091084182262, 0.006477776449173689, 0.008859274908900261, -0.02182604745030403, -0.00009923346078721806, -0.05399481952190399, 0.01566726714372635, 0.06626585125923157, -0.0838569924235344, -0.059204936027526855, -0.067965067923069, 0.01953083835542202, 0.040080633014440536, -0.05966053158044815, 0.01757843606173992, -0.0030499701388180256, -0.0482395701110363, -0.0029274101834744215, 0.041796229779720306, 0.02072829008102417, 0.04075619578361511, 0.02700560912489891, 0.047318629920482635, -0.0057806046679615974, -0.11227346956729889, 0.06655372679233551, -0.023631280288100243, 0.025748778134584427, -0.008754084818065166, 0.01714412122964859, -0.019504226744174957, -0.041920892894268036, -0.02286824770271778, 0.05368661507964134, 0.016520967707037926, -0.003994446713477373, -0.03610007092356682, -0.017086077481508255, -0.011794527061283588, -0.03567562997341156, -0.040174227207899094, -0.07250574231147766, -0.0009583799401298165, 0.010372310876846313, 0.014423523098230362, 0.055825915187597275, 0.01223511341959238, -0.026576755568385124, -0.019563280045986176, -0.01768561638891697, 0.06338784843683243, -0.05856812745332718, -0.0383126400411129, -0.026486629620194435, -0.003723424393683672, 0.045000020414590836, -0.031223151832818985, -0.026985615491867065, 0.017922120168805122, -0.022717176005244255, 0.002306924434378743, -0.03326908499002457, 0.02442130446434021, 0.03528093546628952, -0.04132797196507454, -0.010066715069115162, -0.028178678825497627, 0.03438722714781761, -0.010870617814362049, 0.0475916750729084, -0.023259496316313744, 7.881122314756794e-7, 0.025666914880275726, 0.006100843660533428, 0.020399846136569977, -0.0187983475625515, 0.010278693400323391, 0.018098104745149612, 0.0342257134616375, 0.04021952301263809, 0.05176106467843056, -0.002361949533224106, 0.040010761469602585, -0.025957481935620308, -0.0034725815057754517, -0.04827424883842468, 0.011460259556770325, 0.06228114664554596, 0.03431016206741333, 0.009023255668580532, 0.012781716883182526, -0.07402945309877396, -0.010671191848814487, -0.02297983504831791, -0.03693323954939842, -0.03589218482375145, -0.04100721329450607, 0.028086036443710327, -0.07027312368154526, -0.013478619046509266, -0.022152511402964592, -0.023358207195997238, -0.02223210781812668, -0.024731630459427834, -0.030422614887356758, -0.04718083515763283, 0.01316069345921278, 0.0019985309336334467, -0.06046738848090172, -0.05090022459626198, 0.01568853110074997, 0.020985154435038567, 0.004112668801099062, -0.07510693371295929, -0.0519230030477047, -0.0039750137366354465, 0.03236548230051994, 0.0048283678479492664, -0.009478231891989708, 0.03729618340730667, -0.008972935378551483, 0.0104941101744771, -0.004338108468800783, -0.0010783305624499917, 0.0058654192835092545, 0.02860291302204132, 0.0034318407997488976, -0.034673500806093216, 0.04297665134072304, 0.02203221619129181, -0.012620055116713047, -0.01858898438513279, -0.06706157326698303, -0.0024926853366196156, 0.04857465624809265, 0.00942030269652605, -0.031314924359321594, -0.035582225769758224, 0.004674970172345638, -0.018053581938147545, 0.021258773282170296, 0.0214194655418396, 0.05408316105604172, 0.005609727464616299, 0.016560357064008713, -0.04521635174751282, -0.0428328663110733, 0.017112938687205315, -0.04867026209831238, 0.0333985909819603, -0.04668335244059563, -0.04148482903838158, 0.02693563513457775, -0.09548632800579071, 0.03272220119833946, 0.029576720669865608, 0.06204060837626457, 0.02895454317331314, 0.03283984214067459, 0.0010766603518277407, 0.024882640689611435, -0.013535440899431705, 0.018970422446727753, 0.005193022545427084, 0.04717797413468361, 0.021502327173948288, -0.029289240017533302, -0.04578043147921562, 0.03381234034895897, -0.0315890796482563, -0.054177798330783844, 0.021210728213191032, -0.005861387122422457, 0.04534895718097687, 0.047728754580020905, -0.0583639033138752, -0.015813494101166725, -0.05547614023089409, 0.042895395308732986, 0.014535192400217056, 0.0029861268121749163, 0.019892225041985512, -0.021389242261648178, 0.0172100942581892, -0.0229308120906353, -0.033207595348358154, 0.02867269143462181, -0.04318423569202423, 0.02512463554739952, -0.04107727110385895, 0.03264269605278969, 0.054121073335409164, -0.006912681739777327, 0.024648036807775497, 0.05111783742904663, 0.008721997030079365, 0.015552474185824394, -0.019912593066692352, -0.037631720304489136, -0.04643703252077103, 0.008109145797789097, -0.02192237228155136, 0.008924417197704315, -0.050866857171058655, 0.0368778333067894, 0.026037057861685753, 0.045685283839702606, -0.032969389110803604, -0.017750922590494156, -0.043736208230257034, -0.029746992513537407, -0.08062513917684555, -0.014797231182456017, -0.05502553656697273, 0.05664819851517677, -0.0427059568464756, -0.04539947584271431, 0.02944227121770382, -0.048223454505205154, 0.01855928637087345, -0.040567412972450256, -0.03855366259813309, -0.0021395827643573284, 0.014605280011892319, 0.028467092663049698, -0.07015072554349899, 0.017566194757819176, -0.0568675696849823, 0.05713716149330139, -0.008564379066228867, -0.029789887368679047, -0.03317386284470558, -0.025200681760907173, -0.02568650431931019, 0.03421420976519585, 0.036131031811237335, -0.04436167702078819, -0.03994973003864288, -0.01490800827741623, -0.010077942162752151, 0.01461799256503582, 0.03201333060860634, 0.018084637820720673, -0.059091027826070786, 0.030131299048662186, 0.010964428074657917, -0.021391071379184723, 0.006442148704081774, -0.05387016758322716, 0.08561886101961136, -0.04703392833471298, -0.008812770247459412, -0.00600184453651309, 0.038798991590738297, -0.06948272138834, -0.05393332242965698, 0.0034736201632767916, -0.06704778969287872, -0.045475926250219345, 0.001861205673776567, 0.045472677797079086, 0.02056020125746727, -0.000031431303796125576, 0.04169497638940811, 0.03512575849890709, 0.020338142290711403, -0.004596971441060305, 0.0170433446764946, 0.02713906392455101, -0.03165029361844063, -0.004656403791159391, -0.008176462724804878, -0.08267711848020554, -0.03253902867436409, -0.019819682464003563, -0.03419390693306923, 0.013617687858641148, 0.06237517297267914, 0.0014171841321513057, 0.0404868945479393, -0.07209321111440659, 0.049408309161663055, 0.032427288591861725, -0.01582484319806099, 0.043565116822719574, 0.07737652212381363, 0.038300592452287674, 0.04912852495908737, -0.026210051029920578, -0.026493243873119354, -0.010639024898409843, -0.04070785641670227, 0.029905129224061966, 0.017748849466443062, 0.014350960031151772, 0.012919954024255276, 0.03745410591363907, 0.02843562886118889, -0.041314586997032166, 0.011955742724239826, 0.0012440780410543084, 0.019883403554558754, -0.036460425704717636, 0.05762440711259842, 0.010589459910988808, -0.01296295691281557, -0.046365201473236084, 0.007518346421420574, -0.045656055212020874, 0.024226685985922813, 0.005560812074691057, -0.03131652995944023, -0.01628091372549534, 0.04653288424015045, -0.0004580910026561469, 0.003989097662270069, 0.02985529974102974, 0.012492828071117401, 0.0017032255418598652, -0.0023554146755486727, 0.03320147842168808, -0.0607323981821537, -0.009259646758437157, -0.050189707428216934, 0.005058258771896362, -0.0018710157601162791, 0.02126220241189003, 0.0323726162314415, -0.0009564788197167218, -0.008509724400937557, 0.017457066103816032, -0.009995831176638603, 0.002816492924466729, 0.006952263414859772, -0.024943238124251366, -0.0029171942733228207, -0.0017266423674300313, 0.03476852551102638, 0.027280660346150398, 0.0056750718504190445, 0.003648662008345127, 0.007608291693031788, -0.02745734341442585, 0.014793772250413895, 0.01744442619383335, -0.07741178572177887, -0.06583737581968307, -0.011069891974329948, 0.03575371578335762, -0.02677321620285511, 0.061267055571079254, 0.035209108144044876, -0.02167646214365959, -0.025965241715312004, -0.0036065420135855675, -0.014916140586137772, -0.03592444583773613, 0.026351148262619972, 0.06205020844936371, -0.028893528506159782, -0.011463933624327183, -0.03351025655865669, 0.017380522564053535, 0.04043859615921974, -0.0633314773440361, 0.026838477700948715, 0.01364208199083805, -0.0003289644082542509, -0.04969325661659241, 0.08011972904205322, 0.011617935262620449, -0.07300485670566559, 0.012349051423370838, -0.0069525945000350475, -0.08551204204559326, -0.02861054427921772, 0.034778445959091187, 0.0004080139915458858, -0.02498466894030571, 0.05487098917365074, 0.008174012415111065, -0.019177855923771858, -0.04879850521683693, 0.05387576296925545, 0.06547959893941879, 0.01364470086991787, 0.05056409910321236, 0.026950454339385033, -0.07089084386825562, 0.03837210312485695, -0.03576816990971565, 0.037353482097387314, 0.013716667890548706, 0.008822739124298096, -0.04869961738586426, -0.057552438229322433, -0.022724809125065804, 0.0645655021071434, -0.060734547674655914, -0.01592979021370411, 0.012320231646299362, -0.014381230808794498, 0.03371471166610718, -0.04253333434462547, -0.047650404274463654, 0.0016175482887774706, 0.006941573228687048, -0.029669692739844322, -0.003175827208906412, 0.0173906609416008, -0.01279055792838335, 0.03725210204720497, 0.0017630059737712145, -0.03250638768076897, 0.010678859427571297, 0.007710244972258806, -0.09156409651041031, 0.05959560349583626, -0.07900680601596832, -0.0049226488918066025, -0.0042980993166565895, 0.006799121852964163, -0.00029532250482589006, 0.05697992816567421, -0.010764325968921185, 0.011805007234215736, 0.018750691786408424, 0.022826382890343666, 0.024067480117082596, -0.040209148079156876, 0.04940851032733917, -0.02788469009101391, 0.05308181047439575, -0.029688742011785507, -0.0441458486020565, -0.013294484466314316, -0.04965914413332939, 0.013559841550886631, 0.0432574562728405, -0.030213700607419014, -0.02120842970907688, 0.030336208641529083, 0.002552181016653776, 0.019195372238755226, 0.04556501284241676, -0.022649822756648064, -0.07085854560136795, -0.016582362353801727, -0.0141721460968256, -0.003821971593424678, 0.018019143491983414, 0.042171720415353775, 0.022970065474510193, -0.021626023575663567, -0.003515062155202031, -0.00756662106141448, 0.012466742657124996, 0.0073405238799750805, -0.08450981229543686, -0.04716040566563606, -0.017708271741867065, 0.00044979347148910165, -0.03611409291625023, -0.032540660351514816, -0.01690974459052086, -0.08103130012750626, -0.007190619595348835, 0.06423959881067276, 0.03367316350340843, 0.006461742799729109, -0.050705187022686005, -0.014789002947509289, 0.020637407898902893, -0.04759950563311577, -0.03961523249745369, -0.01662183552980423, -0.030473139137029648, 0.00401651207357645, 0.004472840111702681, -0.039240192621946335, -0.007440892979502678, -0.028645800426602364, -0.08434959501028061, 0.013589773327112198, -0.00797279179096222, 0.016154540702700615, -0.015494209714233875, -0.010110223665833473, 0.010059591382741928, -0.05309067294001579, 0.009194810874760151, -0.008271411992609501, 0.006601459346711636, -0.03870042413473129, -0.0043288045562803745, -0.008080348372459412, -0.07231169939041138, -0.033632226288318634, 0.03307120129466057, -0.024904366582632065, -0.010881182737648487, 0.02318507991731167, 0.03512980788946152, -0.006766337435692549, -0.015728073194622993, 0.05921478569507599, 0.023471564054489136, 0.03777188062667847, -0.05588533356785774, -0.019066039472818375, -0.05126391723752022, -0.026124639436602592, 0.03495568782091141, -0.04664313793182373, 0.015538496896624565, 0.02706652507185936, -0.04005970060825348, 0.045674096792936325, 0.0073249489068984985, -0.05161416530609131, 0.028075510635972023, 0.01592751406133175, 0.023033984005451202, 0.03630702570080757, -0.026646895334124565, 0.0449381023645401, -0.024276459589600563, 0.006441961042582989, -0.053712598979473114, -0.016505423933267593, 0.055019624531269073, -0.027119627222418785, 0.011068388819694519, -0.03210816532373428, 0.0291750505566597, -0.02725287154316902, -0.014896935783326626, -0.06885676085948944, 0.0816054418683052, 0.04656456410884857, -0.028908949345350266, -0.05423910915851593, 0.0007792472606524825, -0.037516992539167404, -0.06270118802785873, -0.03331572189927101, 0.007470352109521627, 0.014990169554948807, -0.039256419986486435, 0.040952492505311966, 0.02131715603172779, 0.0387861467897892, 0.026650486513972282, 0.003504724707454443, -0.014833133667707443, 0.04729245603084564, -0.07435347884893417, 0.06647200137376785, -0.004060069564729929, 0.014751075766980648, 0.014586263336241245, 0.0382709875702858, 0.010926307179033756, -0.017129508778452873, 0.012281365692615509, -0.01203929539769888, 0.028267256915569305, -0.06101996824145317, -0.026388946920633316, 0.003958781249821186, -0.022227833047509193, -0.05793290212750435, -0.03944014385342598, -0.007302214857190847, -0.061977460980415344, -0.029011137783527374 ]
Conversational aspect-based sentiment quadruple analysis (DiaASQ) aims to extract the quadruple of target-aspect-opinion-sentiment within a dialogue. In DiaASQ, a quadruple's elements often cross multiple utterances. This situation complicates the extraction process, emphasizing the need for an adequate understanding of conversational context and interactions. However, existing work independently encodes each utterance, thereby struggling to capture long-range conversational context and overlooking the deep inter-utterance dependencies. In this work, we propose a novel Dynamic Multi-scale Context Aggregation network (DMCA) to address the challenges. Specifically, we first utilize dialogue structure to generate multi-scale utterance windows for capturing rich contextual information. After that, we design a Dynamic Hierarchical Aggregation module (DHA) to integrate progressive cues between them. In addition, we form a multi-stage loss strategy to improve model performance and generalization ability. Extensive experimental results show that the DMCA model outperforms baselines significantly and achieves state-of-the-art performance.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15476v1
[ -0.040817778557538986, -0.0103662870824337, 0.05382859706878662, -0.02036985382437706, 0.01577354222536087, 0.003753631841391325, -0.01843496784567833, -0.020763065665960312, -0.022477321326732635, -0.03881677985191345, -0.022227773442864418, -0.018273470923304558, -0.03870775178074837, -0.04018275439739227, -0.03567066043615341, 0.011405606754124165, 0.07419601827859879, 0.011753054335713387, -0.0362560860812664, 0.05333847552537918, -0.01832779496908188, 0.009883238933980465, -0.029561644420027733, 0.050695523619651794, 0.057482119649648666, -0.021071607246994972, -0.03788125887513161, 0.0021466747857630253, -0.015464125201106071, -0.00827001966536045, 0.07760406285524368, -0.004594783764332533, -0.017227714881300926, -0.06683853268623352, -0.013807178474962711, -0.019545909017324448, -0.02370654232800007, 0.021215494722127914, 0.01872819848358631, -0.02770564891397953, 0.04964767396450043, -0.0627482607960701, -0.07614916563034058, 0.007406118791550398, -0.022909656167030334, 0.05045156180858612, 0.01253581140190363, 0.01812097243964672, -0.07462970912456512, -0.029157297685742378, 0.004237049259245396, 0.004605222027748823, 0.010636096820235252, 0.018032986670732498, -0.032725851982831955, 0.013372021727263927, -0.024805685505270958, 0.031496528536081314, -0.04916006699204445, -0.025857040658593178, 0.0025486007798463106, -0.016013745218515396, -0.031209589913487434, 0.009357445873320103, -0.0262546855956316, 0.05521607771515846, -0.009494636207818985, -0.04461370408535004, 0.008862154558300972, -0.025221895426511765, 0.079350046813488, -0.06723251938819885, -0.01582847349345684, 0.0019779254216700792, -0.02952589839696884, -0.0039594704285264015, -0.024668797850608826, -0.05357816070318222, -0.019627312198281288, -0.020493123680353165, 0.016995111480355263, 0.028383422642946243, 0.033994778990745544, 0.009108993224799633, -0.011591268703341484, -0.002647952176630497, 0.06284604221582413, -0.01264016330242157, 0.02372235432267189, -0.06445406377315521, 0.01873641088604927, -0.054653801023960114, -0.07563868165016174, 0.011978935450315475, 0.054123569279909134, -0.03733351081609726, 0.06008988246321678, 0.0027906300965696573, 0.01829218864440918, -0.016190065070986748, -0.031453151255846024, -0.026373352855443954, -0.029222220182418823, 0.023155972361564636, 0.04199507459998131, -0.026176130399107933, 0.025008201599121094, 0.03378812596201897, -0.04700201004743576, 0.033481352031230927, 0.00660833902657032, -0.00013737339759245515, 0.024652810767292976, -0.05546824634075165, -0.007872010581195354, -0.042505547404289246, 0.033489890396595, 0.008258956484496593, 0.00603855075314641, 0.010151904076337814, -0.023259658366441727, 0.059679530560970306, -0.004191838204860687, -0.01872332952916622, -0.04117869213223457, -0.02677536942064762, 0.06383353471755981, 0.020942455157637596, 0.015626324340701103, -0.03707923740148544, -0.05894603580236435, -0.04440522566437721, 0.01822499930858612, -0.011606237851083279, 0.04934448376297951, 0.0243870560079813, -0.016890767961740494, -0.0557786263525486, 0.028503090143203735, 0.0015731466701254249, -0.03731415420770645, -0.08544350415468216, 0.028111597523093224, -0.020621400326490402, 0.003931503277271986, 0.04834355041384697, -0.011942509561777115, -0.03998534008860588, 0.03009362705051899, 0.041003916412591934, -0.018554916605353355, 0.027561498805880547, 0.03564100340008736, 0.024255381897091866, -0.027390537783503532, -0.03444455564022064, 0.04967755079269409, -0.009678085334599018, -0.06121675297617912, 0.05052441731095314, 0.015788938850164413, -0.05262869596481323, 0.0429510660469532, -0.013756323605775833, 0.039236657321453094, 0.00026906601851806045, 0.019209951162338257, -0.02873177081346512, 0.005182045977562666, 0.016845308244228363, 0.015852129086852074, 0.004180564545094967, -0.02404102496802807, -0.03418092429637909, -0.06108637526631355, 0.001981832552701235, 0.0068782297894358635, -0.04981905221939087, -0.056329987943172455, -0.010550755076110363, 0.005291668698191643, 0.03626447170972824, -0.035538431257009506, -0.011842955835163593, -0.05338800325989723, -0.0073330337181687355, -0.07659545540809631, -0.0036900448612868786, 0.05015505850315094, 0.015383251011371613, -0.033150751143693924, -0.02021290548145771, -0.023725144565105438, 0.0726454108953476, -0.05399338901042938, -0.03221321105957031, 0.02190427854657173, -0.016673315316438675, 0.020327357575297356, 0.061174426227808, -0.09391922503709793, -0.016682641580700874, -0.06733804196119308, 0.0017348832916468382, 0.013823424465954304, -0.044860921800136566, -0.0001804978819563985, 0.040318138897418976, -0.07113845646381378, -0.007195143960416317, 0.0591641329228878, 0.06247911974787712, 0.05720546841621399, -0.00022449919197242707, 0.03804415091872215, 0.014274410903453827, -0.11246944218873978, 0.05699297785758972, 0.04715806990861893, 0.03695841133594513, 0.02770531363785267, 0.0531577542424202, 0.018265068531036377, -0.039332687854766846, -0.009511912241578102, 0.045457400381565094, 0.04570934921503067, -0.05197492986917496, -0.041932567954063416, -0.023660818114876747, -0.022436585277318954, -0.07164359092712402, 0.04539839178323746, -0.0767107754945755, 0.007881313562393188, -0.025594037026166916, -0.058386966586112976, 0.043796394020318985, 0.017395678907632828, -0.023126164451241493, -0.013947832398116589, -0.02752619795501232, 0.01954050548374653, -0.01016702875494957, -0.03714854642748833, -0.018696703016757965, 0.00958916638046503, 0.023952022194862366, -0.01736687682569027, -0.007041167002171278, -0.005479116924107075, -0.0648801401257515, -0.030666975304484367, 0.03373716399073601, 0.02750980295240879, 0.06813648343086243, -0.037650905549526215, 0.009024546481668949, 0.026900339871644974, 0.020140182226896286, 0.019138194620609283, 0.05379660055041313, -0.04513972997665405, 0.05103563144803047, -0.0012582190101966262, -0.018290666863322258, 0.01713356375694275, -0.04141005873680115, -0.027478061616420746, -0.005489367991685867, 0.005928220227360725, 0.054981667548418045, 0.06432253867387772, 0.016104111447930336, 0.03016791120171547, -0.0350174643099308, 0.032623041421175, 0.0006957683945074677, 0.02433965355157852, 0.024168677628040314, 0.0007993662729859352, 0.0012111911782994866, 0.006222463678568602, -0.0855904221534729, 0.03324025496840477, -0.02488318271934986, -0.020996278151869774, -0.061260122805833817, -0.03349106013774872, -0.054921623319387436, -0.07092683017253876, -0.035097576677799225, -0.02604830451309681, -0.03005930595099926, -0.02261337824165821, -0.044324640184640884, -0.0035555961076170206, -0.025516733527183533, 0.046380337327718735, -0.0033208364620804787, -0.014131521806120872, -0.03381376340985298, 0.016536768525838852, 0.009555233642458916, -0.019427156075835228, -0.06038133054971695, -0.059683095663785934, -0.033519431948661804, -0.017436007037758827, -0.019334157928824425, 0.0067499964497983456, 0.03456373140215874, -0.007189025636762381, 0.04285381734371185, -0.022875424474477768, 0.042400162667036057, -0.0032720519229769707, 0.059770192950963974, -0.03333214670419693, 0.011930475942790508, 0.017276646569371223, -0.0200379379093647, -0.012613711878657341, -0.05262139439582825, -0.05128476768732071, -0.0434160940349102, 0.06169299781322479, 0.0020160472486168146, -0.007152044214308262, -0.043544720858335495, 0.015348509885370731, 0.02404375560581684, 0.014613492414355278, 0.01596998982131481, 0.050614211708307266, 0.05364815518260002, 0.003136829938739538, -0.033291105180978775, -0.007519765291363001, -0.0035407033283263445, -0.033988043665885925, 0.01061838399618864, -0.03655930608510971, -0.00014654564438387752, 0.04504716023802757, -0.10361076891422272, 0.0570094957947731, 0.05460461229085922, 0.05369202047586441, -0.016623051837086678, 0.008503217250108719, 0.002741741482168436, 0.03374374285340309, -0.0037632824387401342, -0.028933219611644745, 0.011851828545331955, 0.02383665181696415, 0.06252235174179077, -0.05571863800287247, 0.017659062519669533, 0.017840208485722542, -0.07352706044912338, -0.02408723533153534, 0.012335550040006638, 0.011479401960968971, 0.061776865273714066, -0.006718287244439125, -0.05427283048629761, 0.030181748792529106, -0.03356832265853882, 0.05148433521389961, 0.024713411927223206, -0.044984638690948486, 0.03895338624715805, -0.06407634168863297, -0.012690596282482147, 0.009972815401852131, 0.00387222645804286, -0.002362771425396204, -0.01856278069317341, 0.020618043839931488, 0.0007059256313368678, 0.07095778733491898, 0.007493443787097931, -0.031039925292134285, 0.035932257771492004, 0.02966889925301075, -0.02855807915329933, 0.046880289912223816, -0.0027694914024323225, -0.0064439415000379086, -0.00640761386603117, 0.032642804086208344, -0.039439454674720764, -0.0024442707654088736, -0.08706282824277878, -0.006768178194761276, -0.01380627416074276, -0.02756018564105034, -0.02087305299937725, 0.007407623343169689, -0.008500149473547935, 0.012652798555791378, -0.09313750267028809, -0.0023304668720811605, -0.04202830791473389, 0.013450760394334793, 0.001489601214416325, -0.05633936822414398, 0.04483821243047714, 0.013660170137882233, -0.000986779690720141, 0.018622079864144325, -0.02828427590429783, -0.051562730222940445, -0.04388304799795151, 0.013701431453227997, -0.035459261387586594, 0.044336460530757904, -0.06253587454557419, 0.027418414130806923, -0.03789776191115379, 0.0110981659963727, 0.00426556495949626, -0.04754044860601425, -0.010074477642774582, 0.060998689383268356, 0.07513882964849472, 0.026816871017217636, 0.0037473230622708797, -0.019955558702349663, 0.04560078680515289, -0.02253716066479683, 0.02287564054131508, -0.004879764746874571, 0.016609296202659607, 0.04572676494717598, -0.029234394431114197, -0.021023035049438477, 0.000023133045033318922, -0.004003485664725304, 0.012654056772589684, -0.06365039944648743, -0.03506786376237869, 0.004719300661236048, 0.006343612913042307, -0.04258798062801361, -0.029212331399321556, -0.011938080191612244, -0.027508987113833427, -0.03955170884728432, -0.0038306324277073145, 0.004754918627440929, 0.052040886133909225, 0.01932421140372753, 0.033387456089258194, 0.013302730396389961, -0.0212943647056818, -0.010969521477818489, 0.02443474903702736, 0.039309289306402206, -0.023521289229393005, -0.03369889408349991, -0.03369228541851044, -0.0734834298491478, 0.011287612840533257, -0.03586754947900772, -0.024802273139357567, -0.03360201418399811, -0.006227752193808556, 0.006586574949324131, 0.06439931690692902, -0.0889706090092659, -0.002360576530918479, 0.04275479167699814, -0.04237721115350723, 0.03687102720141411, 0.07472378015518188, -0.0058779348619282246, 0.024241644889116287, 0.024571549147367477, -0.004405013285577297, -0.00014667068899143487, -0.042353056371212006, 0.0004177553055342287, 0.017824243754148483, -0.0077470438554883, 0.005820510443300009, 0.04109594598412514, 0.01461682841181755, -0.007503892295062542, 0.003190032672137022, 0.02036377787590027, 0.041708171367645264, -0.02527141571044922, 0.024017352610826492, 0.05661175400018692, -0.03040073998272419, -0.02346792072057724, 0.028559554368257523, -0.02174241654574871, 0.01133752427995205, 0.022669872269034386, -0.03377389907836914, 0.027153121307492256, 0.009509262628853321, -0.02791246585547924, 0.024312611669301987, 0.026875166222453117, 0.028510211035609245, -0.05199651047587395, -0.04914415627717972, -0.0069198510609567165, -0.023414766415953636, -0.027590099722146988, -0.04122819006443024, 0.03727169707417488, 0.051334504038095474, 0.04859879985451698, -0.019348755478858948, -0.0022005774080753326, 0.019104430451989174, -0.0030301224905997515, 0.0032714304979890585, -0.011780427768826485, 0.034091681241989136, -0.033997099846601486, 0.045918602496385574, -0.0011512687196955085, 0.019566917791962624, 0.022247975692152977, 0.016370678320527077, -0.015187288634479046, 0.02294187806546688, -0.03177463263273239, -0.02926957607269287, -0.005185661371797323, -0.04492099955677986, -0.04305257648229599, 0.014879338443279266, 0.022809438407421112, -0.017267568036913872, 0.052599214017391205, -0.007116501685231924, -0.05456924811005592, -0.023749450221657753, 0.017951151356101036, -0.019900131970643997, -0.04455811157822609, 0.005622548051178455, 0.06180707365274429, -0.05825096368789673, -0.01041820552200079, -0.015648547559976578, -0.010373950004577637, -0.0002737444592639804, -0.035467181354761124, -0.0237757358700037, 0.03731589391827583, 0.006095193792134523, -0.03170529380440712, 0.07873516529798508, -0.053792137652635574, -0.05923175811767578, -0.0032287007197737694, 0.0029169574845582247, -0.08991444855928421, -0.0056181796826422215, -0.009473731741309166, 0.02929699420928955, -0.05937560275197029, 0.02013946883380413, 0.04302104935050011, 0.0033769512083381414, -0.035193346440792084, 0.08464478701353073, 0.05684938654303551, -0.03744380548596382, -0.0018302674870938063, 0.03693641349673271, -0.07904863357543945, -0.0023353861179202795, -0.038871776312589645, -0.028951337561011314, 0.011123189702630043, 0.05542528256773949, 0.005607620347291231, -0.01481208298355341, -0.028779292479157448, 0.06236269697546959, -0.022949691861867905, 0.027618255466222763, 0.04359997436404228, -0.030125388875603676, 0.051357850432395935, -0.004657265264540911, -0.028336796909570694, -0.020497627556324005, -0.04024660587310791, 0.004212305881083012, -0.013804872520267963, -0.025377394631505013, 0.01182317640632391, -0.015687108039855957, 0.022600216791033745, -0.0773591697216034, 0.0035677237901836634, 0.0036362491082400084, -0.07775678485631943, 0.02288159728050232, -0.05070502310991287, 0.02306896448135376, -0.010017520748078823, 0.03639634698629379, 0.033114634454250336, 0.05986986309289932, -0.05006660521030426, -0.005683723837137222, -0.021761929616332054, 0.021960509940981865, -0.021448979154229164, -0.0016764565370976925, -0.026449032127857208, -0.06273476779460907, 0.05074438825249672, -0.04247545450925827, 0.009360007010400295, -0.016534021124243736, -0.03372342139482498, 0.012478925287723541, 0.03734586015343666, -0.03323513641953468, -0.04714415594935417, 0.010789673775434494, -0.02491186000406742, 0.033276818692684174, 0.06313799321651459, -0.08160316199064255, -0.06161150708794594, 0.009546165354549885, 0.03957471251487732, -0.004590472672134638, 0.04790778085589409, 0.031127361580729485, 0.026006191968917847, -0.029943352565169334, 0.03925422951579094, -0.003836700227111578, 0.016750458627939224, 0.024828080087900162, -0.07489216327667236, 0.008078176528215408, 0.01904677040874958, -0.01718236692249775, -0.014331590384244919, 0.016579706221818924, 0.009966221638023853, -0.05001351237297058, 0.011331471614539623, 0.046851061284542084, 0.03971325606107712, -0.023069076240062714, -0.03183887153863907, 0.058408867567777634, 0.014015298336744308, -0.04157062992453575, -0.047623395919799805, 0.04392768070101738, -0.02001255564391613, -0.02280927263200283, -0.030644623562693596, -0.015164598822593689, -0.021818822249770164, -0.0340040884912014, -0.09165674448013306, 0.044736310839653015, -0.04518019035458565, 0.04783684387803078, -0.02144586108624935, 0.0029767239466309547, 0.035107437521219254, -0.040513649582862854, 0.008421841077506542, -0.01606081984937191, 0.041228413581848145, 0.02852570451796055, 0.033092375844717026, -0.00691642239689827, -0.06786351650953293, -0.025663157925009727, 0.017077859491109848, -0.010723653249442577, -0.04212501645088196, 0.0510435588657856, 0.03671823814511299, -0.01594996452331543, 0.016534557566046715, 0.03936207294464111, -0.018500100821256638, -0.004661433398723602, -0.03574378415942192, 0.021857233718037605, -0.043841540813446045, -0.04470514506101608, 0.00872199609875679, -0.03433258831501007, 0.00021090364316478372, 0.019928066059947014, 0.035061031579971313, 0.018044807016849518, -0.04129062965512276, -0.06532546132802963, -0.012285198085010052, -0.029483633115887642, -0.020510101690888405, 0.04308024421334267, -0.00349016347900033, -0.008013551123440266, -0.03328723460435867, -0.005477172788232565, -0.015067540109157562, 0.05113878846168518, 0.049963805824518204, -0.03881394490599632, -0.0154450424015522, -0.048329081386327744, 0.06710644066333771, -0.025197898969054222, -0.021921735256910324, -0.03625315800309181, 0.05769016221165657, -0.013210706412792206, -0.008251612074673176, -0.0060698529705405235, -0.014857743866741657, -0.020503804087638855, -0.09044059365987778, -0.009700368158519268, -0.0427570641040802, 0.05980031564831734, 0.0018906716722995043, 0.019085681065917015, -0.0010579024674370885, 0.04734421521425247, -0.015575526282191277, 0.05903970077633858, 0.03493325039744377, 0.013999955728650093, -0.045197904109954834, 0.07627913355827332, 0.048254113644361496, -0.0037272863555699587, -0.03464049845933914, -0.01495435368269682, -0.019408131018280983, 0.02045951411128044, 0.037926845252513885, -0.00477474695071578, -0.004866814706474543, -0.045721374452114105, -0.03415984660387039, 0.023564789444208145, -0.000518430897500366, -0.03085138462483883, -0.03523559123277664, 0.007315289229154587, -0.02024080604314804, -0.05052828788757324 ]
Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) has been the subject of research for many years, and recent studies have focused on improving its performance through various techniques. In the past decade, deep learning studies have shown high performance in various research areas, leading researchers to explore their application to HCI. Convolutional neural networks can be used to recognize hand gestures from images using deep architectures. In this study, we evaluated pre-trained high-performance deep architectures on the HG14 dataset, which consists of 14 different hand gesture classes. Among 22 different models, versions of the VGGNet and MobileNet models attained the highest accuracy rates. Specifically, the VGG16 and VGG19 models achieved accuracy rates of 94.64% and 94.36%, respectively, while the MobileNet and MobileNetV2 models achieved accuracy rates of 96.79% and 94.43%, respectively. We performed hand gesture recognition on the dataset using an ensemble learning technique, which combined the four most successful models. By utilizing these models as base learners and applying the Dirichlet ensemble technique, we achieved an accuracy rate of 98.88%. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of the deep ensemble learning technique for HCI and its potential applications in areas such as augmented reality, virtual reality, and game technologies.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11610v1
[ 0.0036426251754164696, -0.007062368560582399, 0.046263840049505234, -0.023775292560458183, -0.019247522577643394, 0.03391216695308685, 0.043930113315582275, -0.013210992328822613, 0.0025936239399015903, -0.056681159883737564, -0.05293523520231247, 0.03637462854385376, -0.037086449563503265, 0.023289894685149193, -0.06922159343957901, 0.04195638746023178, 0.07609237730503082, 0.040069784969091415, -0.022014284506440163, 0.07376163452863693, 0.01568792201578617, -0.04743809252977371, -0.018873976543545723, 0.03721972554922104, 0.019924338907003403, -0.0032219192944467068, -0.0275456253439188, -0.00482946215197444, 0.039046481251716614, -0.0374460406601429, 0.07181840389966965, 0.010017809458076954, 0.015471023507416248, -0.06456193327903748, -0.006907773204147816, 0.036764129996299744, -0.03737647831439972, 0.044775910675525665, 0.043287452310323715, -0.055588461458683014, 0.02416669763624668, -0.05090998113155365, -0.055633578449487686, -0.057138584554195404, -0.017980752512812614, 0.03526739403605461, -0.02431369014084339, -0.03570692986249924, -0.06798305362462997, -0.0016265553422272205, -0.006260986905544996, -0.010103069245815277, -0.0007547745481133461, 0.040484823286533356, -0.0009626636165194213, -0.05167175084352493, -0.05948394536972046, 0.051928404718637466, -0.0386139452457428, 0.03249301388859749, -0.010109636932611465, 0.021381070837378502, -0.008527213707566261, 0.017267795279622078, 0.011188963428139687, 0.05366019159555435, -0.05703987553715706, -0.05900619924068451, 0.010196712799370289, -0.03816802427172661, 0.0432547964155674, -0.021473353728652, 0.0070306286215782166, -0.0428302101790905, 0.004997482523322105, -0.014532716944813728, -0.03073401190340519, -0.003793831681832671, -0.01882580667734146, -0.04753308743238449, 0.003530477173626423, 0.05923907086253166, 0.03858229145407677, 0.024780549108982086, -0.023714210838079453, -0.057346001267433167, 0.06737981736660004, -0.0062787169590592384, -0.04536838456988335, -0.04787151888012886, 0.0012233229354023933, 0.0047761681489646435, -0.08089499175548553, 0.05870101600885391, 0.04670655354857445, -0.008890610188245773, 0.0479942262172699, 0.019545745104551315, -0.0011240467429161072, -0.002140854252502322, -0.04712242633104324, -0.016005348414182663, -0.03554677963256836, 0.054559990763664246, 0.0172351635992527, 0.004091524984687567, -0.04699849709868431, -0.020651135593652725, -0.04731181263923645, -0.027696065604686737, 0.0069231512024998665, 0.0008907736628316343, 0.01916632242500782, -0.06122265011072159, -0.0311732180416584, -0.06710153818130493, 0.046162400394678116, 0.030486540868878365, -0.03360862284898758, -0.006863565184175968, 0.018535492941737175, 0.028245046734809875, 0.028882259503006935, -0.04736826568841934, -0.028792910277843475, -0.010221514850854874, 0.005059467628598213, -0.00652310810983181, -0.057634346187114716, -0.021654481068253517, 0.013601135462522507, 0.01434953510761261, -0.003523618448525667, -0.0374690443277359, 0.07883080840110779, -0.012979290448129177, 0.02886580489575863, -0.038502130657434464, 0.028652019798755646, 0.006108851637691259, -0.07056742161512375, -0.07590290904045105, -0.01710239239037037, -0.02905363403260708, -0.002997398842126131, 0.07477962970733643, -0.019450291991233826, 0.018254965543746948, 0.022047391161322594, 0.040541425347328186, 0.04301657900214195, 0.02334211766719818, 0.014229337684810162, 0.0013149885926395655, -0.017725566402077675, -0.02382095716893673, 0.04430367052555084, -0.022917475551366806, -0.0673661008477211, 0.012721262872219086, -0.005862805061042309, -0.03891012817621231, 0.026142355054616928, -0.030461443588137627, 0.01018485240638256, -0.014787414111196995, 0.05469348654150963, -0.03950655832886696, -0.04659296199679375, 0.012284724973142147, -0.010871004313230515, -0.02678622491657734, 0.021576447412371635, 0.018951434642076492, -0.07390270382165909, -0.0398871935904026, -0.007366890087723732, -0.05965570732951164, -0.07286596298217773, -0.016831785440444946, 0.0004603674460668117, 0.05707697197794914, -0.02469385601580143, 0.011881266720592976, -0.0395137220621109, 0.04246160015463829, -0.08000215142965317, -0.034563835710287094, 0.029903177171945572, -0.00982402078807354, -0.0016704797744750977, -0.038364533334970474, 0.027583826333284378, 0.0001283694728044793, -0.03799062594771385, -0.07883021980524063, -0.001961049158126116, -0.032933998852968216, 0.00781017541885376, 0.023181574419140816, -0.08479625731706619, -0.04264957830309868, -0.045313164591789246, 0.0029885873664170504, 0.008508685044944286, -0.0686357244849205, 0.04170006513595581, 0.033112574368715286, -0.059349872171878815, -0.03137720003724098, 0.0475161150097847, 0.04330718144774437, 0.04594378173351288, 0.0036576753482222557, 0.00403893506154418, 0.011200564913451672, -0.0957837849855423, 0.06003839522600174, 0.02168227918446064, 0.02049556002020836, -0.016767872497439384, -0.012363792397081852, 0.004763245116919279, -0.033734582364559174, -0.002461130265146494, 0.05504000186920166, 0.07477707415819168, -0.0003592053253669292, -0.03645329549908638, -0.015043456107378006, 0.0007101337541826069, -0.047408703714609146, 0.0035169622860848904, -0.06746738404035568, -0.0055284081026911736, -0.02155204862356186, -0.040901947766542435, 0.06089434400200844, -0.030651766806840897, -0.05477823689579964, 0.015246865339577198, -0.0034426208585500717, 0.03795696049928665, -0.016002008691430092, -0.06060396507382393, 0.004740727599710226, 0.0061936331912875175, 0.030262084677815437, 0.026148008182644844, -0.018575388938188553, -0.02574208192527294, -0.046490009874105453, 0.0071763284504413605, -0.010480746626853943, 0.04878059774637222, 0.019213950261473656, 0.0015413131332024932, 0.054275594651699066, 0.009924323298037052, 0.014661460183560848, 0.04460093006491661, 0.021321017295122147, -0.07313688099384308, 0.027250545099377632, 0.020176099613308907, 0.023882173001766205, -0.0230634193867445, -0.056429605931043625, 0.04680628702044487, -0.013879614882171154, 0.008152107708156109, 0.03636280074715614, 0.031337931752204895, -0.028790360316634178, -0.02321672812104225, -0.02036111056804657, 0.04772785305976868, -0.03201114013791084, 0.034703485667705536, 0.019163526594638824, 0.02752915769815445, 0.020550210028886795, 0.030311480164527893, -0.07287546992301941, 0.0038047749549150467, -0.04576477035880089, -0.06954102963209152, -0.05241595581173897, -0.04053478688001633, 0.008300312794744968, -0.04107847809791565, -0.0707239881157875, -0.030888425186276436, -0.0528099499642849, 0.018549712374806404, -0.05923239514231682, 0.0228642039000988, -0.016681531444191933, -0.010918386280536652, -0.004639658611267805, 0.016286203637719154, -0.0678575187921524, 0.021266525611281395, 0.03404030203819275, -0.005081831943243742, -0.0666680783033371, -0.016917197033762932, -0.05036565661430359, -0.0009717668290250003, -0.015291635878384113, 0.024836836382746696, 0.048264894634485245, -0.04571795091032982, 0.018836431205272675, 0.0007735752151347697, 0.021806972101330757, 0.025135375559329987, 0.04990111291408539, -0.0367891825735569, -0.04020509123802185, 0.026652652770280838, -0.025010887533426285, -0.008808992803096771, -0.00968821533024311, -0.03740542754530907, 0.024392632767558098, 0.061761531978845596, 0.011342307552695274, -0.018289702013134956, -0.0023559594992548227, -0.006242179777473211, 0.010375019162893295, 0.006657564081251621, -0.001703644054941833, 0.01295181829482317, 0.0024240268394351006, -0.04927093908190727, 0.005369566846638918, -0.034179940819740295, 0.054583050310611725, 0.009203014895319939, -0.051362574100494385, -0.026564152911305428, -0.011985158547759056, 0.03613309934735298, -0.08559466898441315, 0.03766767680644989, 0.0499388687312603, 0.06590167433023453, -0.043750543147325516, 0.021254708990454674, 0.0515240840613842, 0.02640789933502674, 0.03824179247021675, -0.023948295041918755, 0.01716386340558529, 0.018970808014273643, 0.081822469830513, -0.020500654354691505, 0.0010410122340545058, 0.020430244505405426, -0.03561059385538101, -0.0196257084608078, -0.014231468550860882, 0.04935946688055992, 0.07426784932613373, 0.0006558125023730099, -0.07778459042310715, -0.004546680953353643, 0.010610527358949184, 0.04394994676113129, 0.011057035066187382, -0.03611210361123085, 0.006435797084122896, -0.04753848910331726, 0.045562081038951874, 0.021165916696190834, -0.008410033769905567, -0.024742739275097847, -0.05762368068099022, 0.026156235486268997, -0.035454001277685165, 0.04067501798272133, -0.014872085303068161, -0.017808211967349052, 0.04814285412430763, 0.024296654388308525, -0.032027240842580795, 0.04687376320362091, -0.0022938759066164494, -0.018629571422934532, -0.04407435283064842, 0.010243342258036137, -0.04908672720193863, -0.027908658608794212, -0.06293164938688278, 0.033775508403778076, 0.027921557426452637, -0.024478930979967117, 0.012674112804234028, -0.004466559737920761, 0.030772235244512558, 0.0033326768316328526, -0.08559782058000565, -0.03565991297364235, -0.03833507373929024, 0.021438177675008774, -0.013031835667788982, -0.0268607996404171, 0.06762201339006424, -0.03157613426446915, -0.007890361361205578, -0.011297272518277168, 0.015280479565262794, -0.04870898649096489, -0.03222787752747536, -0.014681180939078331, -0.07284785062074661, 0.04059964790940285, -0.05592896789312363, 0.04557177051901817, -0.009112907573580742, -0.01949922926723957, -0.00785352848470211, -0.05937568470835686, 0.010703034698963165, 0.04973286762833595, 0.04870110750198364, 0.009538726881146431, 0.024452993646264076, -0.021376198157668114, 0.029598673805594444, -0.011716224253177643, -0.0092087397351861, 0.04421406239271164, 0.018892159685492516, 0.05560540780425072, 0.009282747283577919, -0.010116077028214931, -0.03231261298060417, -0.04397675767540932, 0.05324834957718849, -0.03865258768200874, -0.03014463558793068, 0.03325006365776062, 0.03329929709434509, -0.045445144176483154, -0.040929313749074936, -0.04432135447859764, -0.03348636254668236, -0.022393524646759033, -0.04395434632897377, 0.0012709980364888906, 0.047206852585077286, 0.008478154428303242, -0.035102229565382004, 0.018279459327459335, 0.01566609926521778, -0.04327169433236122, 0.03429241105914116, -0.030911710113286972, -0.009095647372305393, -0.019122835248708725, -0.030623141676187515, -0.05333302542567253, -0.003227555425837636, -0.04290738329291344, 0.031217793002724648, -0.006595152895897627, 0.02721545286476612, 0.03353250399231911, 0.0050308117642998695, -0.0848219022154808, 0.03212868049740791, 0.057144857943058014, 0.032475899904966354, -0.020688356831669807, 0.06176009029150009, -0.009501287713646889, 0.020455608144402504, -0.027771219611167908, -0.011419522576034069, 0.012189128436148167, -0.040648117661476135, -0.03552773967385292, 0.01607566885650158, -0.005486614536494017, -0.0005418630898930132, -0.0031091233249753714, -0.036259643733501434, -0.043955761939287186, 0.017480600625276566, 0.006794489920139313, -0.011302000842988491, -0.02378246560692787, 0.0573146678507328, 0.05365715175867081, -0.014134167693555355, -0.014165251515805721, -0.025739828124642372, -0.009896227158606052, -0.0320800356566906, 0.03744179755449295, -0.0398726724088192, 0.020841455087065697, 0.03201675042510033, 0.0012226575054228306, 0.005993812810629606, -0.0003733831690624356, -0.041283849626779556, -0.018506817519664764, -0.02354155294597149, -0.017328454181551933, -0.032830480486154556, -0.0480341799557209, 0.0008816730114631355, 0.04150748625397682, 0.04746967554092407, 0.04472210630774498, 0.0023025721311569214, 0.013961486518383026, -0.027112457901239395, -0.06016025319695473, 0.004524368792772293, -0.011287926696240902, 0.011326253414154053, -0.033930134028196335, 0.05354324355721474, -0.025468839332461357, 0.06145807355642319, -0.005432216450572014, 0.004545672796666622, 0.0029966351576149464, 0.007097565568983555, -0.04988642781972885, -0.02984238788485527, -0.021980619058012962, -0.03360531106591225, -0.04067569226026535, 0.006434706971049309, 0.05639293044805527, -0.034395281225442886, 0.030585918575525284, 0.007159152068197727, -0.021519072353839874, 0.04011797904968262, 0.045876845717430115, 0.01406140998005867, -0.062470171600580215, 0.025003764778375626, 0.06454667448997498, -0.03537449613213539, -0.018732337281107903, -0.009432478807866573, -0.026006652042269707, 0.007229224778711796, -0.03741370886564255, 0.006547783501446247, 0.058460794389247894, -0.023329928517341614, -0.04935816675424576, 0.054339904338121414, -0.02526438795030117, -0.07147771865129471, 0.0026702857576310635, 0.021888786926865578, -0.07360658794641495, 0.03337316960096359, -0.020994357764720917, 0.008517189882695675, -0.05648397281765938, 0.050365034490823746, 0.004847661592066288, -0.010112693533301353, -0.05869568884372711, 0.02978517673909664, 0.06500190496444702, -0.012028531171381474, 0.014595764689147472, 0.04414953663945198, -0.06704550236463547, -0.03114408440887928, -0.029234087094664574, -0.021280543878674507, 0.026893561705946922, 0.009827511385083199, 0.007578849792480469, -0.056573834270238876, 0.01568847894668579, 0.08012721687555313, -0.04611250385642052, 0.03126326948404312, 0.05292031913995743, 0.005477762781083584, 0.04795435443520546, 0.020806780084967613, -0.014145550318062305, 0.015756137669086456, -0.0014831204898655415, -0.001236015115864575, -0.04508007690310478, -0.0065694693475961685, 0.018576202914118767, 0.02038288488984108, 0.010227711871266365, -0.06835280358791351, -0.047849711030721664, 0.003468470647931099, -0.0675436407327652, 0.037626713514328, -0.040425706654787064, 0.04000852629542351, -0.030207514762878418, 0.0424431636929512, 0.02369075082242489, 0.004516403656452894, -0.017304200679063797, -0.04280146211385727, -0.009577948600053787, -0.009554006159305573, -0.008611646480858326, 0.01651581935584545, 0.015409361571073532, -0.011704537086188793, 0.058700185269117355, -0.05724187195301056, -0.023980101570487022, -0.017393460497260094, -0.05745069310069084, -0.02158358134329319, 0.003714628517627716, -0.03947199881076813, -0.02986297570168972, 0.015650508925318718, 0.043256063014268875, 0.051656000316143036, 0.02953372895717621, -0.02643558196723461, -0.05097658187150955, 0.007628063205629587, 0.004532600753009319, -0.01290335226804018, 0.015627911314368248, -0.00023172864166554064, -0.019855540245771408, 0.012023302726447582, 0.00228677480481565, -0.0015025052707642317, -0.051710180938243866, 0.04027218744158745, -0.03929276764392853, -0.021400969475507736, -0.0028164710383862257, 0.0016245223814621568, -0.01561535894870758, -0.03248905763030052, 0.03392525762319565, -0.08172784000635147, 0.015310482122004032, 0.025849541649222374, 0.023037204518914223, 0.03780378773808479, -0.04935446381568909, 0.03225172683596611, 0.014427943155169487, -0.04256943240761757, -0.053389813750982285, -0.032517530024051666, -0.019445326179265976, -0.06254873424768448, -0.021676385775208473, 0.018970567733049393, 0.0005946636665612459, -0.005057208705693483, -0.07376620173454285, -0.03707534447312355, 0.04592294245958328, -0.013849892653524876, -0.01178779173642397, -0.06580784916877747, 0.01282484270632267, -0.03350045904517174, -0.012885062023997307, 0.0247077364474535, 0.047775186598300934, 0.03378899767994881, 0.04124411568045616, 0.025571608915925026, -0.0351141095161438, -0.044818729162216187, 0.03106173314154148, -0.057897407561540604, -0.0014311103150248528, 0.01924389973282814, 0.0376952588558197, 0.01150557678192854, -0.05161047354340553, 0.07066642493009567, -0.005769320763647556, 0.005144559778273106, -0.00230764620937407, -0.035522181540727615, -0.05596102029085159, -0.04591841250658035, 0.04357033595442772, -0.01564852148294449, -0.012466205283999443, 0.02625027857720852, 0.007942799478769302, 0.02171988971531391, -0.03946096822619438, -0.004801029339432716, -0.02844679169356823, 0.003257186384871602, 0.009547445923089981, 0.044576387852430344, -0.058596041053533554, -0.02686578594148159, -0.008115784265100956, 0.01043230202049017, -0.023674162104725838, -0.006220167502760887, 0.022427748888731003, -0.032742664217948914, 0.020781220868229866, -0.03026965633034706, -0.002088625682517886, 0.040095094591379166, 0.0049823434092104435, -0.0029213866218924522, 0.07612551003694534, -0.00021007179748266935, -0.012559360824525356, -0.01952940598130226, -0.031478408724069595, -0.008216899819672108, -0.04624468833208084, -0.022543396800756454, -0.04414798691868782, 0.05471068620681763, 0.0197104774415493, -0.009804473258554935, -0.022192129865288734, 0.07250116765499115, -0.030533842742443085, 0.041026778519153595, -0.0069485814310610294, -0.009008605033159256, 0.011172311380505562, 0.08122286200523376, -0.006081677507609129, 0.00955453421920538, -0.04892243444919586, 0.05581211671233177, -0.02420072816312313, -0.05100461468100548, 0.03799137845635414, -0.00023771969426888973, -0.02376384660601616, -0.04971689358353615, -0.022790921851992607, 0.02295692265033722, -0.018744133412837982, -0.06509153544902802, -0.009229679591953754, 0.014539145864546299, -0.021690720692276955, -0.03834109753370285 ]
In this work, we assess the theoretical limitations of determining guaranteed stability and accuracy of neural networks in classification tasks. We consider classical distribution-agnostic framework and algorithms minimising empirical risks and potentially subjected to some weights regularisation. We show that there is a large family of tasks for which computing and verifying ideal stable and accurate neural networks in the above settings is extremely challenging, if at all possible, even when such ideal solutions exist within the given class of neural architectures.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07072v1
[ 0.008273452520370483, -0.035102590918540955, 0.044054608792066574, 0.01153688132762909, 0.010365702211856842, -0.04029476270079613, 0.014536242000758648, 0.004905670415610075, -0.0017456182977184653, -0.055213917046785355, -0.007465892471373081, -0.041370175778865814, -0.02789168804883957, -0.06471199542284012, -0.04549166560173035, -0.006419604178518057, 0.05836153030395508, 0.034342195838689804, -0.025045771151781082, 0.07087510824203491, -0.025296853855252266, -0.0506693460047245, -0.028484193608164787, 0.027208836749196053, 0.03879880532622337, 0.000018944734620163217, -0.03323313221335411, -0.03622046858072281, -0.013805755414068699, 0.03700919449329376, -0.005037748254835606, -0.03944697603583336, -0.014758591540157795, -0.03222030773758888, -0.016220111399888992, -0.061753977090120316, -0.013382806442677975, 0.037653159350156784, 0.04009152203798294, -0.000012230007087055128, 0.042810894548892975, -0.02952917106449604, -0.06649821996688843, -0.031078815460205078, -0.04652177169919014, 0.0072928606532514095, -0.01684414967894554, -0.01820344850420952, -0.04978751763701439, 0.008363463915884495, 0.045815594494342804, -0.0364518016576767, 0.0011023192200809717, 0.03072216361761093, -0.045533835887908936, 0.0035937344655394554, -0.04891132190823555, 0.004719266202300787, -0.049571748822927475, -0.004207807593047619, -0.011942286975681782, -0.020700400695204735, -0.021407028660178185, -0.0012484253384172916, -0.0227455273270607, 0.01908271573483944, 0.04322752729058266, -0.05530291795730591, -0.049395617097616196, -0.013786197640001774, 0.04549745097756386, -0.03619549795985222, 0.03341863304376602, -0.025849521160125732, -0.038606684654951096, 0.0036626479122787714, 0.0034904100466519594, -0.010496390052139759, 0.01354081928730011, 0.01942799612879753, 0.00018934904073830694, 0.02281844988465309, 0.00712085934355855, -0.03872343525290489, 0.001783433835953474, -0.04259015992283821, 0.002217100467532873, -0.035743992775678635, -0.008202646858990192, -0.03574774041771889, 0.007920251227915287, 0.006847503129392862, -0.06904124468564987, 0.032281678169965744, 0.04395891726016998, -0.025907430797815323, 0.06597504019737244, 0.045220997184515, 0.013639396987855434, -0.04234327748417854, -0.048403166234493256, -0.061833348125219345, -0.002892264863476157, 0.05488722026348114, 0.04258168488740921, 0.022934366017580032, 0.016725866124033928, -0.01999008283019066, -0.034060582518577576, 0.010744597762823105, 0.012037773616611958, -0.05018915608525276, -0.0159403458237648, -0.07330096513032913, -0.03980126604437828, -0.0012782751582562923, 0.004339592531323433, 0.046424321830272675, -0.010718763805925846, 0.012585614807903767, -0.02100846730172634, 0.037252277135849, -0.03208094462752342, -0.023317601531744003, -0.04535503312945366, -0.042369578033685684, 0.05019637569785118, -0.007115270011126995, -0.017684660851955414, 0.01107272319495678, -0.03077857568860054, -0.018487315624952316, 0.012711363844573498, -0.007716510910540819, 0.049291208386421204, -0.0548192597925663, -0.007167355623096228, -0.014371679164469242, 0.007009899243712425, -0.009532604366540909, -0.04104022681713104, -0.0681246668100357, 0.00969537254422903, -0.029072366654872894, 0.027430493384599686, 0.05510202795267105, -0.03895721957087517, -0.05436906963586807, 0.04650937393307686, 0.06385382264852524, -0.022356344386935234, 0.010004793293774128, -0.04895764961838722, -0.025339344516396523, 0.04410292208194733, 0.01154673844575882, 0.04514015465974808, -0.011073051020503044, -0.05400307849049568, -0.025031281635165215, 0.03636997938156128, -0.024521779268980026, -0.05440981686115265, -0.04742226004600525, -0.03713882714509964, 0.04917227476835251, -0.0012727188877761364, -0.0360163077712059, -0.009351645596325397, -0.04232652112841606, -0.05022304505109787, 0.008109964430332184, 0.021462926641106606, -0.05154483765363693, -0.07149070501327515, -0.05597512423992157, 0.003406879724934697, -0.05537949874997139, -0.031883057206869125, 0.011751087382435799, 0.034644801169633865, -0.017241105437278748, -0.04120450094342232, 0.03242775425314903, -0.032972875982522964, -0.016734473407268524, -0.07153556495904922, 0.03277595713734627, 0.03505927324295044, -0.04036504402756691, -0.02808656543493271, -0.04265103116631508, 0.019515054300427437, 0.01477392204105854, -0.05236844718456268, -0.031889136880636215, -0.030870120972394943, 0.011745254509150982, -0.044858068227767944, 0.02534504607319832, -0.06828203797340393, -0.014804967679083347, -0.010617421939969063, 0.025579972192645073, -0.044455695897340775, -0.05654260516166687, 0.02308848686516285, 0.006925426423549652, -0.03715178370475769, -0.049812961369752884, 0.06472121179103851, 0.04564018175005913, 0.033010974526405334, -0.008142845705151558, 0.012380320578813553, 0.038882263004779816, -0.08493677526712418, 0.03453805297613144, 0.0016471527051180601, 0.03411285951733589, 0.0485522598028183, -0.013624160550534725, -0.0072554550133645535, -0.04132715240120888, 0.04485491290688515, 0.057308901101350784, 0.02352343313395977, 0.015434939414262772, -0.0490606352686882, -0.037607982754707336, -0.04434462636709213, -0.06182055175304413, -0.03266620635986328, -0.06741656363010406, -0.03032086417078972, -0.01680791936814785, -0.03149629756808281, 0.04669325053691864, -0.006890465971082449, -0.055876996368169785, -0.03952845185995102, -0.046471357345581055, 0.023210888728499413, -0.002732395427301526, 0.01603364571928978, -0.04851160943508148, -0.057100605219602585, -0.005744129419326782, 0.004883097484707832, 0.009209174662828445, -0.028688834980130196, -0.035583045333623886, -0.012021378614008427, -0.027057314291596413, 0.043994635343551636, 0.0046781920827925205, -0.022484809160232544, 0.047552689909935, -0.013233944773674011, 0.03045295551419258, 0.0553540401160717, -0.004402194172143936, -0.023808304220438004, -0.0382559709250927, 0.011796281673014164, 0.003192070173099637, -0.037760816514492035, 0.024404121562838554, 0.016306772828102112, -0.06508660316467285, 0.004674026742577553, 0.0005674616550095379, 0.001892773201689124, -0.026083754375576973, -0.03971352428197861, -0.015935838222503662, -0.015686949715018272, -0.055231284350156784, 0.01581648737192154, 0.03281577304005623, 0.018351010978221893, 0.006062858738005161, -0.02251536399126053, -0.07169895619153976, -0.05512696132063866, -0.027131488546729088, 0.031361401081085205, -0.015707049518823624, -0.019592294469475746, -0.06065259873867035, -0.07039359211921692, -0.0282558873295784, 0.006257288157939911, -0.05327398702502251, -0.02158401347696781, -0.05473031848669052, -0.059026628732681274, 0.004682593513280153, 0.03305434063076973, -0.019926538690924644, -0.014720547012984753, -0.06786611676216125, 0.03355684503912926, 0.04218447953462601, 0.01806333102285862, -0.08109799027442932, -0.041757259517908096, 0.0048950472846627235, 0.002178741851821542, 0.007982376962900162, 0.02341320738196373, -0.020873554050922394, -0.029694803059101105, 0.05011120066046715, -0.06451349705457687, -0.008712224662303925, -0.0023395607713609934, -0.037334032356739044, -0.015955965965986252, 0.024896468967199326, -0.011418653652071953, -0.024751214310526848, 0.0008161117439158261, -0.048813410103321075, -0.06402810662984848, 0.011887351982295513, 0.051916901022195816, -0.05341622978448868, -0.035634882748126984, -0.047483738511800766, 0.012238901108503342, 0.027836449444293976, -0.004140584263950586, -0.012908113189041615, 0.04002287611365318, 0.04135294258594513, -0.04676155373454094, 0.04285414144396782, 0.014085924252867699, 0.021378805860877037, 0.013118861243128777, 0.061556048691272736, -0.039426516741514206, -0.05159537494182587, 0.022881653159856796, -0.07446000725030899, 0.012933479622006416, -0.013375717215240002, 0.028412703424692154, -0.01124271284788847, -0.015450246632099152, 0.03637078404426575, 0.007823293097317219, -0.034662190824747086, -0.00822938047349453, -0.016803592443466187, 0.03173630312085152, 0.03945939987897873, -0.020906059071421623, -0.02765282243490219, 0.00516478018835187, -0.041302185505628586, -0.04935120418667793, 0.007281839847564697, 0.05201028659939766, 0.01914924755692482, -0.03555839881300926, -0.06153053417801857, 0.019060272723436356, -0.0027615202125161886, 0.06340928375720978, -0.008810076862573624, 0.037280820310115814, 0.05619622766971588, -0.04880966246128082, 0.025906192138791084, 0.0027544773183763027, 0.010484018363058567, 0.02743356302380562, -0.06940848380327225, -0.008766714483499527, -0.05393807217478752, -0.021983129903674126, 0.002139696618542075, -0.039388883858919144, -0.006653965916484594, 0.0027070569340139627, -0.03958205506205559, 0.033540740609169006, -0.02544078603386879, -0.017760207876563072, -0.01718110591173172, 0.013420303352177143, -0.022584376856684685, -0.011132677085697651, -0.07138427346944809, 0.009251349605619907, 0.0013578372308984399, -0.06842158734798431, 0.0013055517338216305, -0.022900240495800972, 0.022933444008231163, -0.015636304393410683, -0.07173028588294983, 0.020974943414330482, 0.006476531270891428, 0.008648451417684555, -0.03481242433190346, -0.006161319557577372, 0.060391172766685486, -0.005450872238725424, -0.00014204593026079237, -0.038553386926651, -0.05449605733156204, 0.03344015032052994, -0.012301540933549404, -0.042294688522815704, -0.04286877065896988, 0.008991776965558529, -0.012787439860403538, 0.01675005815923214, -0.006095828954130411, 0.019956467673182487, -0.06839839369058609, 0.00958655308932066, 0.03918716683983803, 0.0338725782930851, 0.06148320809006691, 0.03618496656417847, 0.027358558028936386, -0.046822480857372284, 0.05413699522614479, 0.017986048012971878, -0.019281024113297462, -0.02844097465276718, 0.004763090517371893, 0.03021898679435253, -0.024948474019765854, -0.06168973445892334, -0.056176409125328064, 0.006886748131364584, 0.05684661492705345, 0.019580040127038956, -0.01356187742203474, 0.013004292733967304, 0.017216457054018974, -0.05591394379734993, -0.05461587756872177, 0.040227681398391724, -0.04596840217709541, -0.07321863621473312, -0.04923535883426666, 0.031099911779165268, 0.011747372336685658, -0.07415644824504852, 0.03362199291586876, -0.004083091393113136, 0.049910008907318115, -0.005376846995204687, 0.011218448169529438, 0.055740609765052795, 0.010548535734415054, 0.022572629153728485, -0.004170366562902927, -0.042713895440101624, -0.024548590183258057, 0.024545470252633095, 0.03519381955265999, -0.020599374547600746, 0.06490170955657959, -0.045234210789203644, 0.028633272275328636, -0.07689738273620605, 0.03381739556789398, 0.05461273342370987, -0.02790245972573757, 0.04428214207291603, 0.02469879575073719, -0.031171105802059174, -0.021623734384775162, -0.07531213015317917, -0.00472364341840148, 0.0525948591530323, -0.04083535075187683, 0.03262566775083542, 0.015905030071735382, -0.05679076910018921, -0.015985488891601562, 0.01734435185790062, 0.0031817855779081583, -0.03461066260933876, 0.012380605563521385, 0.02421625703573227, 0.03746003285050392, -0.006137076299637556, -0.0041360678151249886, 0.05812961235642433, -0.013821923173964024, -0.02926507219672203, 0.013533495366573334, 0.038496311753988266, -0.005393926054239273, 0.0066922674886882305, -0.043917544186115265, -0.040202006697654724, 0.022204440087080002, -0.026799587532877922, -0.007834511809051037, 0.02511698752641678, 0.03222663700580597, 0.03094794973731041, -0.06344874948263168, -0.022562554106116295, -0.042948149144649506, -0.00022243239800445735, 0.00606723316013813, 0.018807100132107735, 0.015726150944828987, -0.026705505326390266, -0.0012064833426848054, -0.026942487806081772, -0.04462873190641403, -0.05038856714963913, -0.04601303115487099, 0.0033002463169395924, 0.04553902521729469, -0.03892602398991585, -0.0027472754009068012, 0.02114211395382881, 0.0605890266597271, 0.003792308969423175, -0.006225768011063337, -0.04083815589547157, -0.005059797782450914, -0.02038067951798439, -0.036686502397060394, 0.030055146664381027, -0.0320943258702755, -0.057097841054201126, 0.026412220671772957, -0.007116954308003187, 0.021938566118478775, 0.05515583977103233, 0.055648621171712875, 0.012052717618644238, 0.040629658848047256, -0.01646130345761776, -0.03039025329053402, -0.019591214135289192, 0.030329717323184013, 0.057220470160245895, -0.07386147230863571, 0.005672432482242584, -0.06082923710346222, -0.04238714277744293, 0.03358764201402664, -0.0610782727599144, 0.02733900584280491, -0.029881272464990616, 0.0034739025868475437, -0.04770161584019661, 0.028306877240538597, 0.03472333773970604, -0.07264328002929688, 0.008081004023551941, 0.0030902933795005083, -0.0686926618218422, 0.04115813598036766, 0.015131785534322262, 0.010085160844027996, -0.05350492149591446, 0.061507608741521835, 0.018221577629446983, -0.017242470756173134, -0.011660270392894745, 0.04574577510356903, 0.07888860255479813, -0.023748593404889107, -0.015538537874817848, -0.01752062514424324, -0.0025643680710345507, -0.005373683758080006, -0.006657164078205824, -0.009256011806428432, 0.0038960964884608984, 0.03202947601675987, -0.05120004341006279, -0.012764111161231995, -0.06297264993190765, 0.050378963351249695, -0.02325674518942833, -0.021579869091510773, -0.009957786649465561, -0.018397822976112366, 0.04113727807998657, -0.0298960842192173, -0.02841293253004551, -0.0031748716719448566, -0.006170317530632019, -0.0458298921585083, -0.05146634578704834, -0.002414587652310729, -0.03128519654273987, 0.0023725784849375486, -0.059121981263160706, -0.04745589941740036, -0.04001837596297264, 0.00549211585894227, -0.02799026109278202, -0.01731712557375431, -0.06699192523956299, -0.015511996112763882, -0.04201271012425423, -0.014768629334867, -0.026184314861893654, 0.07207965850830078, -0.03896397352218628, -0.017141688615083694, -0.006942621897906065, -0.03656613826751709, 0.011479075066745281, 0.00273001822642982, -0.021401718258857727, -0.037292782217264175, 0.04204942286014557, -0.045958761125802994, 0.02332990989089012, -0.047154683619737625, -0.05261773616075516, -0.018353285267949104, 0.011206516996026039, -0.025949880480766296, -0.044786084443330765, 0.000010513914276089054, -0.05700055882334709, -0.0019884961657226086, -0.023592695593833923, -0.024517204612493515, -0.06349482387304306, 0.026044677942991257, 0.02431616187095642, 0.010806756094098091, -0.01155874039977789, 0.009032485075294971, -0.008732750080525875, -0.026374291628599167, 0.029203128069639206, 0.05201612040400505, 0.04120463877916336, -0.0387703962624073, -0.040719542652368546, 0.007056505419313908, 0.036439888179302216, 0.022173834964632988, -0.03277594968676567, -0.06543610990047455, -0.034321025013923645, -0.07620775699615479, 0.006664537359029055, 0.022758355364203453, 0.013045446947216988, -0.03261507675051689, -0.07713834196329117, 0.04760007932782173, 0.045205529779195786, -0.018133128061890602, -0.04048030078411102, -0.026517795398831367, 0.0008837225614115596, -0.03740231320261955, -0.022186048328876495, 0.011881922371685505, -0.05384887754917145, 0.02176518738269806, -0.07324433326721191, -0.06028399243950844, -0.01373395323753357, 0.06553280353546143, 0.060006801038980484, 0.02955850213766098, -0.057304177433252335, -0.03610549494624138, 0.03872434422373772, -0.034815214574337006, -0.012303272262215614, -0.0046265884302556515, 0.03988843038678169, -0.017970426008105278, -0.020733103156089783, -0.009397159330546856, 0.04644983261823654, -0.033076755702495575, 0.013002101331949234, 0.034947965294122696, -0.007019519340246916, 0.06805644184350967, 0.06236099451780319, 0.032587554305791855, -0.04184390977025032, 0.01464876625686884, -0.033495161682367325, 0.04033054783940315, -0.05423593148589134, -0.06346157938241959, 0.06874150782823563, -0.04266310855746269, -0.016954518854618073, -0.012204599566757679, 0.0071559082716703415, -0.021672166883945465, -0.023236466571688652, -0.049483999609947205, 0.04908134788274765, 0.029795801267027855, 0.010029839351773262, 0.04181239381432533, -0.01359348464757204, 0.01584433577954769, -0.02547733299434185, -0.02672705240547657, -0.05420032888650894, 0.03585020452737808, 0.05068829283118248, -0.06110258772969246, -0.012851610779762268, -0.052282314747571945, -0.0036064970772713423, 0.012436073273420334, -0.008718695491552353, -0.02940515987575054, 0.047076515853405, 0.009871196933090687, -0.01039932668209076, -0.01523267850279808, 0.010089007206261158, -0.05026473104953766, -0.06693796813488007, -0.010440289974212646, -0.053339358419179916, -0.014286288991570473, -0.03522897884249687, 0.04833073914051056, 0.021622955799102783, 0.06229059770703316, -0.004523981362581253, -0.01081801112741232, 0.030757596716284752, -0.025370456278324127, -0.053368404507637024, 0.04444582760334015, 0.029653629288077354, 0.034177955240011215, -0.01066889613866806, -0.013547921553254128, -0.035391487181186676, -0.015857789665460587, 0.03600906953215599, -0.02636101096868515, -0.03332185745239258, -0.05264044925570488, 0.010572783648967743, -0.01845410466194153, 0.009952676482498646, -0.050945766270160675, 0.0024520817678421736, -0.051826152950525284, -0.03526291623711586, -0.06425640732049942 ]
Black holes violate the third law of thermodynamics, and this gives rise to difficulties with the microscopic description of the entropy of black holes. Recently, it has been shown that the microscopic description of the Schwarzschild black hole thermodynamics in $D = 4$ spacetime dimensions is provided by the analytical continuation of the entropy of Bose gas with non-relativistic one particle energy to d =-4 negative spatial dimension. In this paper, we show that the D=5 and D=6 Schwarzschild black holes thermodynamics can be modeled by the d-dimensional Bose gas, d=1,2,3..., with the one particle energy $\varepsilon(k)=k^\alpha$ under conditions $\alpha=-d/3$ and $\alpha=-d/4$, respectively. In these cases the free energy of the Bose gas has divergences and we introduce a cut-off and perform the minimal renormalizations. We also perform renormalizations using analytical regularization and prove that the minimal cut-off renormalization gives the same answer as the analytical regularization by the Riemann zeta-function.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.19827v1
[ -0.06850247085094452, -0.06655876338481903, -0.007536349352449179, -0.040588315576314926, 0.043448686599731445, -0.012191263027489185, -0.025131236761808395, 0.014730487018823624, -0.03835108131170273, 0.012335652485489845, 0.025646623224020004, -0.04830287769436836, 0.017564570531249046, -0.015233242884278297, -0.030542664229869843, 0.003524255007505417, 0.05944710224866867, 0.04121646285057068, -0.029126977548003197, 0.0718822255730629, 0.013860194943845272, -0.019521035254001617, 0.011511691845953465, 0.03899513930082321, 0.005597244948148727, -0.004383156541734934, -0.05869482830166817, -0.009619073942303658, -0.030537962913513184, -0.016701484099030495, 0.06765194982290268, -0.06352385878562927, 0.03918251395225525, -0.057695601135492325, -0.03333019092679024, 0.0067362128756940365, 0.0048813060857355595, 0.02669113129377365, -0.000547274888958782, -0.04256569221615791, 0.021203886717557907, -0.04791927710175514, -0.06683793663978577, -0.00384498736821115, -0.009703753516077995, -0.05021555721759796, -0.04979164898395538, -0.011220836080610752, -0.0388188436627388, -0.06300853937864304, 0.05548716336488724, -0.019555868580937386, 0.000799070461653173, 0.05244695022702217, -0.05311306193470955, -0.009165647439658642, -0.028029169887304306, -0.059565600007772446, 0.023098718374967575, -0.01481686718761921, 0.0390346422791481, -0.014868038706481457, 0.008345830254256725, -0.006702185142785311, -0.025441106408834457, 0.03393813967704773, -0.01619407907128334, -0.03725792467594147, -0.0528290793299675, -0.07118801027536392, -0.023870348930358887, -0.06772524863481522, 0.026556706055998802, -0.016209501773118973, -0.07118890434503555, 0.017387937754392624, -0.027425196021795273, -0.009457056410610676, -0.03319240361452103, -0.0017995324451476336, -0.03543541207909584, -0.0127912862226367, -0.05615009367465973, -0.02898103930056095, 0.02417060174047947, 0.04181542620062828, 0.025054018944501877, -0.03276180103421211, 0.019980624318122864, -0.06660814583301544, -0.0024316501803696156, -0.04966228827834129, -0.022571144625544548, -0.03587039187550545, 0.030159564688801765, -0.04976627603173256, 0.031944021582603455, 0.015163956210017204, 0.03512703254818916, -0.03850145637989044, 0.031154826283454895, -0.0505821667611599, -0.024415239691734314, 0.017884397879242897, -0.008759836666285992, -0.015453818254172802, 0.0042932964861392975, -0.04767347499728203, -0.018319146707654, 0.05336557328701019, -0.02085201069712639, 0.023478914052248, -0.04608383774757385, -0.014765404164791107, -0.03273618966341019, -0.040885888040065765, 0.0527423620223999, 0.031284090131521225, 0.053022824227809906, -0.024317696690559387, -0.050649065524339676, 0.008639132604002953, 0.029272571206092834, 0.012556768953800201, 0.013845067471265793, -0.0037775805685669184, 0.07229865342378616, -0.002110640751197934, -0.041547659784555435, -0.009985962882637978, -0.04046135023236275, 0.015367496758699417, 0.018329795449972153, -0.014782113023102283, 0.016850054264068604, 0.04669852927327156, -0.04179707542061806, -0.010785597376525402, -0.040399372577667236, 0.009276355616748333, -0.028678124770522118, -0.054917655885219574, -0.006023764610290527, -0.003959469497203827, -0.030969584360718727, 0.019483603537082672, -0.055794741958379745, 0.021827561780810356, 0.05035747215151787, -0.00741385156288743, -0.016187192872166634, 0.023108843713998795, -0.02549370937049389, -0.028147079050540924, 0.015436781570315361, 0.014388376846909523, 0.027387462556362152, 0.034812070429325104, -0.03764960914850235, 0.0299528818577528, 0.0031584640964865685, -0.05176310986280441, 0.011325438506901264, 0.015787901356816292, 0.014426451176404953, 0.028285806998610497, 0.02102617733180523, -0.012677880004048347, 0.003444791305810213, 0.030363569036126137, -0.06609062105417252, -0.026102624833583832, -0.004616516176611185, -0.0330028310418129, -0.06625068932771683, -0.056995391845703125, -0.03138638287782669, -0.04950059577822685, -0.04694026708602905, 0.003809217596426606, -0.015478204004466534, -0.027157815173268318, -0.02629939839243889, -0.01664113625884056, -0.04513801634311676, 0.039738286286592484, -0.07254205644130707, 0.054350126534700394, 0.040834877640008926, 0.015445655211806297, -0.009976803325116634, -0.0056592137552797794, 0.03198833391070366, 0.03000328503549099, -0.05610993877053261, 0.03187308833003044, 0.016709977760910988, -0.042979754507541656, -0.025661034509539604, 0.019514797255396843, -0.07625864446163177, -0.06691896915435791, -0.03342282399535179, 0.009839960373938084, -0.021730147302150726, -0.07839556783437729, 0.009086846373975277, 0.07012178003787994, -0.011029289104044437, -0.03963030129671097, 0.07245547324419022, -0.011769060976803303, 0.04461127892136574, -0.025917943567037582, 0.024075806140899658, -0.00023496591893490404, -0.08524484187364578, 0.0679020807147026, -0.008468789979815483, -0.0009978190064430237, 0.018273791298270226, 0.017693961039185524, -0.030561963096261024, -0.06347907334566116, -0.04103732854127884, 0.05360828712582588, 0.01915596053004265, -0.02639777772128582, -0.06636019796133041, -0.0378735326230526, 0.005646158941090107, -0.05381876602768898, -0.06814848631620407, -0.04417121410369873, 0.0112274419516325, -0.005095168016850948, -0.022958951070904732, 0.028203973546624184, -0.02346920035779476, -0.020239893347024918, -0.0648149847984314, 0.04770392179489136, 0.027392514050006866, -0.010676879435777664, -0.050554059445858, -0.05467001348733902, -0.05775652453303337, -0.016402188688516617, -0.06867334991693497, -0.004420252982527018, 0.054490361362695694, -0.03917890042066574, -0.05886394530534744, -0.023111918941140175, 0.025297116488218307, 0.012856739573180676, -0.03692147508263588, 0.029101161286234856, -0.002061452018097043, 0.0441926084458828, -0.01239896658807993, 0.01521188672631979, -0.01664397120475769, -0.02275691367685795, 0.045320022851228714, 0.023883042857050896, -0.04848701134324074, -0.011902334168553352, -0.013818785548210144, 0.033196818083524704, 0.014232558198273182, -0.0047837551683187485, 0.005703915376216173, 0.0030216786544770002, -0.015069792978465557, -0.020446091890335083, -0.02496480941772461, -0.03490307554602623, 0.009302322752773762, -0.008462395519018173, 0.020495133474469185, 0.04966594651341438, 0.00926525890827179, -0.06880677491426468, 0.018107501789927483, 0.016176791861653328, -0.003020868171006441, -0.025319363921880722, -0.05367373675107956, -0.018086489289999008, -0.07403358817100525, 0.0018584012286737561, -0.050879135727882385, -0.01812632754445076, -0.06026342138648033, -0.05693501606583595, -0.04908183962106705, -0.03653153404593468, 0.04430491477251053, -0.07419898360967636, -0.05520949885249138, 0.0445985272526741, -0.009927703067660332, 0.037385571748018265, 0.02207195945084095, 0.008855700492858887, -0.04651680961251259, 0.030408602207899094, -0.05241395905613899, 0.008874217048287392, -0.027898214757442474, -0.000487190845888108, -0.05030016601085663, -0.004852640442550182, 0.0582977794110775, 0.01716489903628826, 0.0005019500385969877, -0.033809415996074677, -0.021739935502409935, -0.0012111342512071133, -0.010298389941453934, 0.011629687622189522, 0.02730242721736431, -0.00920053105801344, -0.03228458762168884, -0.057331353425979614, 0.03642888739705086, 0.06499196588993073, 0.014885387383401394, -0.05653229355812073, -0.06911839544773102, -0.00557677960023284, 0.012868925929069519, -0.010345689952373505, 0.062315646559000015, 0.04720945656299591, -0.03470972925424576, -0.024906352162361145, -0.040332693606615067, -0.007990198209881783, -0.03844127058982849, 0.026398468762636185, 0.0203605554997921, 0.005240981001406908, 0.04690970480442047, -0.06541922688484192, 0.0653383731842041, 0.029386473819613457, 0.04816679656505585, -0.01191986445337534, -0.03525901958346367, 0.007515672128647566, 0.03712047263979912, -0.029863864183425903, -0.03142138943076134, 0.040587376803159714, 0.05514112859964371, 0.03584275022149086, -0.02289607748389244, -0.028623277321457863, 0.026861654594540596, -0.056477151811122894, -0.0443178191781044, 0.03012653812766075, 0.0030530740041285753, 0.035567037761211395, 0.037578243762254715, 0.014449435286223888, -0.0025464030914008617, -0.0337214320898056, 0.019575348123908043, -0.046110641211271286, -0.012674513272941113, 0.02966003306210041, 0.007967467419803143, -0.010930397547781467, 0.004548882134258747, 0.022526612505316734, 0.017030341550707817, -0.04503817483782768, 0.0035171566996723413, -0.054085128009319305, 0.03853851929306984, -0.003782946150749922, -0.04069070518016815, -0.015005461871623993, -0.033592693507671356, 0.013420868664979935, 0.028197726234793663, -0.02245846763253212, 0.000052730458264704794, -0.039242468774318695, -0.03764967620372772, 0.04643138125538826, -0.020001260563731194, -0.03042650781571865, -0.03881022706627846, -0.03317082300782204, -0.04330018535256386, -0.01872085966169834, 0.039251506328582764, 0.012002685107290745, -0.03544855862855911, -0.06770337373018265, -0.05792366713285446, -0.05354194715619087, -0.03168034553527832, -0.054240815341472626, -0.0649498701095581, 0.05502813309431076, 0.010138371959328651, -0.02353346347808838, -0.009172799997031689, -0.042300768196582794, -0.021025020629167557, -0.02347675897181034, -0.012835610657930374, -0.047522444278001785, -0.0007406390504911542, -0.03043602593243122, 0.0535147488117218, -0.036097995936870575, -0.044416382908821106, -0.05855567753314972, 0.04510364308953285, -0.034471698105335236, -0.01570267416536808, 0.02354484237730503, 0.022167721763253212, 0.049558501690626144, 0.011354290880262852, -0.05101877823472023, 0.008206592872738838, -0.05817180126905441, 0.022227376699447632, -0.04667392745614052, 0.0029861675575375557, -0.048553287982940674, -0.05000784248113632, -0.05319211259484291, 0.003468161216005683, 0.06275955587625504, -0.008021689020097256, -0.03713461384177208, -0.015064846724271774, 0.012136448174715042, -0.04972769320011139, -0.016574036329984665, -0.03898358345031738, -0.009636792354285717, -0.06847504526376724, 0.021103177219629288, -0.0022196141071617603, -0.0150187648832798, -0.02594301849603653, 0.053832970559597015, 0.03595345467329025, -0.009415695443749428, -0.007901939563453197, -0.045458365231752396, 0.04522798955440521, 0.0283508263528347, -0.021313350647687912, -0.028113791719079018, -0.0735165923833847, 0.03803304582834244, -0.034309759736061096, -0.022810881957411766, 0.01991886831820011, 0.06601475179195404, -0.028346432372927666, 0.05570833757519722, -0.06868276745080948, 0.014244788326323032, 0.05638021230697632, -0.03277628496289253, -0.04133385047316551, 0.015769649296998978, -0.04155566543340683, 0.011679589748382568, -0.022645559161901474, 0.019016265869140625, 0.026973925530910492, 0.002502867951989174, 0.019747061654925346, -0.0332300029695034, -0.04967320337891579, -0.03298376128077507, 0.017429649829864502, 0.018364302814006805, -0.041410963982343674, 0.00038900773506611586, 0.001985083566978574, 0.010655439458787441, -0.05147746205329895, 0.0076592485420405865, 0.0501047745347023, -0.054837360978126526, -0.03572220355272293, -0.01810060441493988, -0.0030454795341938734, 0.03434107080101967, 0.023842550814151764, -0.06052069365978241, -0.00663210591301322, -0.03005032427608967, 0.0065888590179383755, 0.012179083190858364, 0.05078251287341118, -0.004111194517463446, -0.046622488647699356, 0.023958470672369003, -0.021748771890997887, -0.01993742398917675, -0.003717733547091484, -0.034217070788145065, 0.017442479729652405, 0.016498833894729614, 0.009484217502176762, 0.06111584231257439, 0.016672082245349884, -0.012288937345147133, -0.029203040525317192, -0.022777993232011795, -0.044333308935165405, 0.05910300463438034, -0.000262461748206988, -0.02341022528707981, 0.01633160002529621, 0.02688853070139885, -0.042374178767204285, -0.009916550479829311, 0.020685292780399323, -0.03408614546060562, -0.03551784157752991, -0.03911660239100456, 0.036019135266542435, -0.024277569726109505, -0.031861625611782074, -0.05583652853965759, 0.04015820100903511, -0.02750813029706478, 0.01629745215177536, 0.01512065902352333, 0.02985209971666336, 0.011849341914057732, -0.0037230949383229017, 0.006416247691959143, -0.05953317508101463, 0.006611980963498354, 0.048564694821834564, -0.04688211902976036, -0.010297650471329689, -0.00641279062256217, -0.01578936167061329, -0.013448837213218212, -0.03748887777328491, 0.01987418159842491, -0.028592128306627274, 0.011401900090277195, -0.05683305487036705, 0.06388123333454132, 0.04578523337841034, -0.07462868094444275, 0.029222877696156502, 0.03705836832523346, -0.06895768642425537, 0.0017955193761736155, 0.018413089215755463, -0.022760193794965744, -0.02360755205154419, 0.017651839181780815, -0.04538632184267044, -0.049073901027441025, -0.036669500172138214, 0.04600292444229126, 0.05029819533228874, -0.06376884877681732, 0.05230260267853737, 0.04151967540383339, -0.046753741800785065, 0.025003470480442047, -0.0296873077750206, -0.008997976779937744, -0.052652280777692795, 0.0320729985833168, 0.033837638795375824, 0.0036719420459121466, -0.03286115825176239, 0.017191382125020027, -0.03425474837422371, -0.003114205552265048, 0.009417470544576645, 0.04400879889726639, 0.04500115290284157, 0.005809348542243242, -0.008708362467586994, 0.0393855944275856, -0.047258518636226654, -0.012893427163362503, -0.007634673733264208, 0.03123050183057785, -0.041964609175920486, -0.008488249965012074, -0.010695282369852066, -0.0480923131108284, 0.02835582196712494, -0.032939519733190536, -0.0364387147128582, -0.004085548687726259, -0.034180670976638794, -0.050635069608688354, 0.02372043952345848, 0.003128311363980174, 0.021947165951132774, 0.04804424196481705, -0.023310299962759018, 0.009560219943523407, -0.009750567376613617, 0.014239559881389141, -0.017908405512571335, 0.022122008726000786, 0.02095356583595276, -0.052834268659353256, 0.0721198245882988, -0.03777385130524635, 0.0489145964384079, -0.028854651376605034, -0.02211209014058113, 0.03240747004747391, 0.0063437167555093765, -0.0392952524125576, -0.006660668645054102, -0.022677579894661903, -0.06585206836462021, -0.034108906984329224, 0.03610783815383911, -0.05668427422642708, -0.06822852790355682, 0.004016565158963203, 0.006879310589283705, -0.038677655160427094, 0.01545646321028471, 0.03692597895860672, 0.05161316320300102, 0.01939290016889572, 0.031186720356345177, 0.036147262901067734, 0.02879120036959648, 0.003138791536912322, -0.05595192313194275, -0.02649211697280407, -0.0270079355686903, 0.020480601117014885, -0.03589947521686554, -0.04765972122550011, -0.0010867848759517074, -0.06325530260801315, 0.04413102567195892, -0.015146941877901554, 0.02800225466489792, -0.01694541983306408, -0.05472905933856964, 0.06451702862977982, 0.04235447198152542, -0.0007948955171741545, -0.06420040875673294, -0.02585001476109028, 0.02568628266453743, 0.006660003215074539, 0.01414294820278883, -0.022827161476016045, -0.05413280054926872, 0.0013297500554472208, -0.08197659999132156, -0.02808915078639984, 0.01011273916810751, 0.025967510417103767, 0.011488135904073715, -0.020916614681482315, -0.03079863078892231, -0.05043464154005051, -0.038232315331697464, 0.022402998059988022, 0.0015349044697359204, -0.03006742149591446, 0.023954913020133972, 0.011032282374799252, -0.03520253673195839, -0.013243031688034534, 0.06023752689361572, -0.005416187923401594, -0.00318470923230052, 0.03438901528716087, 0.015508354641497135, -0.06645133346319199, -0.014748629182577133, 0.02805274724960327, -0.02209882065653801, 0.025673557072877884, -0.057883474975824356, 0.0011472407495602965, -0.02183421328663826, -0.06228894367814064, 0.057582058012485504, -0.049487803131341934, 0.019236581400036812, -0.003751390380784869, -0.03255896270275116, -0.03840602934360504, -0.031864676624536514, -0.0661185085773468, 0.010341142304241657, 0.019409777596592903, -0.05092886462807655, 0.04374273493885994, -0.05186767131090164, -0.014383011497557163, -0.009516416117548943, 0.008258610963821411, -0.06257319450378418, -0.011451703496277332, 0.04570610076189041, -0.04656069725751877, 0.011587557382881641, -0.05148511379957199, 0.02675030380487442, -0.03556535765528679, -0.02233189530670643, 0.037788935005664825, 0.04250657930970192, -0.020635686814785004, 0.03141945227980614, -0.018793093040585518, -0.0016785160405561328, 0.016974952071905136, -0.06046578288078308, 0.02259420044720173, -0.0027373002376407385, 0.017296012490987778, 0.01619473658502102, 0.03508295491337776, -0.026399880647659302, 0.04376007243990898, 0.0390995629131794, -0.043408650904893875, 0.015589910559356213, -0.029061676934361458, -0.03267686441540718, 0.017147229984402657, 0.019023284316062927, -0.061833932995796204, -0.061313338577747345, 0.05380212515592575, 0.043592482805252075, 0.02899618074297905, 0.0033145900815725327, 0.03157326951622963, -0.034849803894758224, -0.033846236765384674, -0.03310822322964668, 0.02231629192829132, -0.0017376223113387823, -0.055670708417892456, 0.0479394868016243, -0.03533809259533882, -0.045854561030864716, -0.06673844158649445 ]
The paper establishes an equivalence between localizations of (diagrams of) cubical sets and (diagrams of) directed topological spaces by those maps defining (natural) cubical homotopy equivalences after application of the directed singular functor and a directed analogue of fibrant replacement. This equivalence both lifts and extends an equivalence between classical homotopy categories of cubical sets and topological spaces. Some simple applications include combinatorial descriptions and subsequent calculations of directed homotopy monoids and directed singular 1-cohomology monoids. Another application is a characterization of isomorphisms between small categories up to zig-zags of natural transformations as directed homotopy equivalences between directed classifying spaces. Cubical sets throughout the paper are taken to mean presheaves over the minimal symmetric monoidal variant of the cube category. Along the way, the paper characterizes morphisms in this variant as the interval-preserving lattice homomorphisms between finite Boolean lattice and describes some of the test model structure on presheaves over this variant.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16619v1
[ -0.01498468779027462, -0.04261595383286476, 0.062046755105257034, 0.005174650810658932, 0.011593478731811047, -0.030097834765911102, -0.03609762713313103, 0.034324001520872116, 0.02051904983818531, 0.0254270788282156, -0.03447727859020233, 0.00539964996278286, -0.05493062362074852, -0.04961630329489708, -0.047503478825092316, 0.017462342977523804, 0.03961625695228577, 0.017022917047142982, -0.06564147025346756, 0.06304039806127548, 0.05067287012934685, -0.0029731106478720903, -0.03197767958045006, 0.04755759984254837, -0.054411616176366806, 0.006472680252045393, -0.024421004578471184, 0.0002615473931655288, -0.03216785565018654, -0.0063937013037502766, 0.06808288395404816, -0.01022943202406168, -0.025441396981477737, -0.03615986555814743, -0.023768292739987373, -0.017608268186450005, 0.02553148940205574, -0.012637895531952381, 0.03381189703941345, -0.03954823687672615, -0.00017853680765256286, 0.0004224281874485314, -0.050914060324430466, 0.005749775096774101, -0.05445443466305733, -0.011588497087359428, -0.056493405252695084, 0.00035565905272960663, -0.022495821118354797, -0.0699731782078743, 0.027266450226306915, -0.008433613926172256, 0.014524351805448532, 0.05120839923620224, -0.04509420692920685, 0.023457130417227745, 0.005945460870862007, 0.016504308208823204, -0.045964714139699936, -0.005015387199819088, -0.005854318384081125, -0.027757730334997177, 0.05479475483298302, -0.003415357321500778, -0.010139793157577515, 0.044290635734796524, -0.035629790276288986, -0.07123102247714996, -0.03275032341480255, -0.010925180278718472, 0.04362864047288895, -0.06269263476133347, -0.011745277792215347, 0.04583379998803139, -0.0641423836350441, -0.010772188194096088, -0.009663482196629047, -0.040155887603759766, 0.003169030649587512, -0.010222806595265865, -0.017698686569929123, 0.027217639610171318, 0.01045677624642849, 0.009065202437341213, 0.03320777788758278, 0.011131073348224163, 0.03052811324596405, -0.06189968064427376, 0.018491385504603386, -0.0439128614962101, 0.0006604443769901991, 0.011413906700909138, -0.05940406396985054, 0.00826259981840849, 0.07287897914648056, -0.037627849727869034, 0.024068212136626244, 0.013359754346311092, 0.035852789878845215, -0.04376205801963806, -0.03280669450759888, -0.05878889933228493, -0.002649153582751751, 0.04627149552106857, -0.0005385687691159546, -0.045446593314409256, 0.011781938374042511, 0.001799499848857522, -0.04793035238981247, 0.00299516087397933, -0.04552571102976799, -0.0014716804726049304, 0.0442994050681591, -0.0351995974779129, -0.016757339239120483, -0.061211951076984406, 0.04809768497943878, -0.02650807611644268, 0.06128440797328949, 0.013313968665897846, -0.006503772456198931, 0.04320305585861206, 0.01846551150083542, -0.009068505838513374, -0.04048513248562813, -0.01652929186820984, 0.05395588278770447, 0.008201688528060913, -0.06926096230745316, -0.0655495747923851, -0.03260936588048935, -0.05597361922264099, -0.011348670348525047, -0.05636144429445267, 0.03747502341866493, -0.055103473365306854, -0.007059010211378336, -0.01233744341880083, 0.0275807473808527, 0.02217649109661579, -0.00971743930131197, -0.07432355731725693, -0.020493080839514732, -0.03313814476132393, -0.0006007332121953368, 0.03633693978190422, -0.07344042509794235, -0.04005300998687744, 0.05471926927566528, 0.009260277263820171, -0.014190173707902431, -0.037483036518096924, 0.007739854045212269, 0.028533602133393288, 0.025297611951828003, -0.05932667851448059, 0.0574750192463398, -0.013041774742305279, -0.043036237359046936, 0.03824428468942642, 0.02406938187777996, -0.006377886515110731, -0.0007546943961642683, 0.015005180612206459, 0.00817500613629818, 0.007676637731492519, 0.026645958423614502, -0.0346333347260952, -0.04279867187142372, -0.012380765751004219, -0.03602300584316254, 0.037334904074668884, 0.020836172625422478, -0.04520336911082268, -0.04139357805252075, -0.029185809195041656, -0.0077671147882938385, -0.05620259791612625, -0.058422595262527466, 0.004064031410962343, 0.02035173401236534, 0.005343269091099501, -0.001156977261416614, 0.005945596378296614, -0.06280092895030975, -0.018639106303453445, -0.07844118773937225, 0.022262368351221085, 0.019269967451691628, 0.035299770534038544, -0.020057154819369316, -0.0608498714864254, 0.009612571448087692, 0.013188399374485016, -0.052741505205631256, -0.05690230056643486, -0.0075557539239525795, -0.02161719650030136, -0.04729396849870682, 0.03946129232645035, -0.07361505925655365, -0.036105673760175705, -0.038690321147441864, 0.021634334698319435, -0.006035615224391222, -0.0595216266810894, 0.0204435046762228, 0.06925315409898758, -0.029072433710098267, 0.01026751659810543, 0.05406021326780319, 0.01696987822651863, 0.0584409236907959, -0.06091318279504776, 0.0483689159154892, 0.015828624367713928, -0.08288531005382538, 0.01944352127611637, -0.06164452061057091, 0.0020274040289223194, 0.0514572449028492, 0.0050001381896436214, -0.03355342149734497, -0.05675015598535538, -0.01699587143957615, 0.0661572590470314, 0.03892320767045021, 0.02185063250362873, -0.03880159929394722, -0.041901834309101105, -0.014399798586964607, -0.06414154917001724, -0.04413072392344475, -0.03562194108963013, -0.05307631567120552, -0.0362936332821846, -0.057340070605278015, 0.038591280579566956, -0.007768585812300444, -0.06333253532648087, -0.061874501407146454, 0.02266920916736126, 0.05865880846977234, -0.05981571599841118, -0.04573610797524452, -0.06568101048469543, -0.07133729755878448, 0.04040053114295006, -0.04218049719929695, -0.003012858098372817, -0.01347312331199646, -0.0634809359908104, -0.014305333606898785, -0.044021591544151306, 0.021850483492016792, 0.05230158194899559, -0.04204794764518738, 0.024009114131331444, -0.0215580016374588, 0.04396915063261986, 0.02004353143274784, 0.003855102462694049, -0.07134217768907547, 0.020909160375595093, -0.000411350978538394, 0.00787932425737381, -0.06048399582505226, -0.010351788252592087, -0.0005717393942177296, -0.036626048386096954, -0.005745409522205591, 0.0036574138794094324, 0.048550739884376526, -0.03916879743337631, -0.0034813873935490847, 0.009745008312165737, -0.023096352815628052, -0.0564100444316864, -0.008593629114329815, 0.022000255063176155, 0.07273629307746887, 0.027650650590658188, -0.038709960877895355, -0.07356855273246765, -0.02529265731573105, -0.01383412629365921, -0.016265785321593285, -0.03604568913578987, -0.04811421409249306, -0.03857991844415665, -0.06964927911758423, -0.03330523148179054, -0.03524434566497803, -0.01765327900648117, -0.043121591210365295, -0.04561202600598335, -0.011083981953561306, -0.010006659664213657, -0.016601813957095146, -0.018973609432578087, -0.04216611012816429, -0.036117687821388245, 0.008369315415620804, -0.03631826862692833, -0.00026071222964674234, -0.05480850115418434, -0.029688356444239616, 0.03876950964331627, -0.00028369599021971226, -0.006107202265411615, -0.017074309289455414, 0.02101750858128071, -0.02227134071290493, 0.0023096795193850994, 0.007863490842282772, 0.05575529485940933, 0.024228446185588837, 0.003329870058223605, 0.044197432696819305, -0.014819319359958172, -0.013787869364023209, -0.031039409339427948, 0.003627272555604577, 0.010496946983039379, -0.06634347140789032, -0.010884578339755535, 0.039299726486206055, 0.07150306552648544, -0.01609768532216549, 0.03248176723718643, -0.0003660802321974188, 0.0180232971906662, 0.03434675931930542, -0.024995557963848114, 0.05583259463310242, 0.055430818349123, -0.011889911256730556, -0.00525884423404932, -0.03398400545120239, -0.03897107392549515, 0.02754962258040905, 0.006084863096475601, 0.032056815922260284, -0.021217063069343567, 0.041229408234357834, -0.07668713480234146, 0.03452165052294731, 0.018133174628019333, 0.0474889762699604, -0.021761644631624222, -0.05329076200723648, -0.021014956757426262, 0.0061210040003061295, 0.013112653978168964, 0.00012493199028540403, 0.06389463692903519, 0.011105312034487724, 0.06325647234916687, -0.03843626007437706, -0.05604082718491554, -0.054934848099946976, -0.06092846021056175, -0.055796436965465546, 0.010282150469720364, 0.036590419709682465, 0.03844165802001953, 0.03519931063055992, -0.01930946856737137, 0.032145094126462936, -0.019751286134123802, 0.04816967993974686, -0.050035618245601654, -0.03102114610373974, 0.007858305238187313, -0.012164757587015629, -0.0037477940786629915, -0.02356802485883236, -0.022630544379353523, -0.021979492157697678, -0.03543412312865257, 0.03737689182162285, -0.045287393033504486, 0.02892257645726204, 0.02592272311449051, 0.024304373189806938, 0.03770582005381584, 0.030745964497327805, -0.02716280147433281, -0.0036514471285045147, -0.003841096768155694, -0.0049928477965295315, -0.03371868655085564, -0.01534506306052208, -0.030330859124660492, -0.043483834713697433, -0.06432238966226578, 0.00045849240268580616, -0.027979552745819092, -0.0487218014895916, -0.032089415937662125, 0.005599298048764467, 0.010504642501473427, -0.010588675737380981, -0.07513564825057983, -0.02444496937096119, -0.04076399281620979, 0.00237878505140543, -0.037532538175582886, -0.06375505775213242, 0.07437993586063385, -0.010734673589468002, -0.012611805461347103, 0.038816869258880615, -0.039942409843206406, -0.03881724923849106, 0.007872099056839943, -0.027579931542277336, -0.017563361674547195, 0.0008329547708854079, -0.056287143379449844, 0.017939362674951553, -0.028997283428907394, -0.0025869610253721476, -0.06355437636375427, 0.017373893409967422, -0.017017357051372528, 0.02806549146771431, 0.022776015102863312, 0.027551759034395218, 0.0168897844851017, -0.049076806753873825, -0.019483698531985283, 0.03818371519446373, -0.03222924843430519, -0.027463525533676147, -0.04307052493095398, 0.01546546071767807, -0.02812347561120987, -0.042725592851638794, -0.031666625291109085, 0.020656824111938477, 0.058204252272844315, -0.04044996574521065, -0.02619009092450142, -0.015266071073710918, 0.02879324182868004, -0.036041032522916794, -0.07126325368881226, -0.024450840428471565, -0.00040661284583620727, -0.06682320684194565, 0.0021107285283505917, -0.0003185482928529382, -0.0010849201353266835, -0.014032349921762943, 0.0007040229393169284, -0.02243887633085251, 0.029578126966953278, -0.011567756533622742, -0.004383230581879616, 0.043176714330911636, 0.016524948179721832, 0.033087048679590225, -0.03749687969684601, -0.06381361931562424, 0.003483520122244954, -0.010369021445512772, 0.03926500678062439, -0.03898640722036362, 0.039279308170080185, -0.011572172865271568, 0.02539941668510437, -0.07539837807416916, 0.05244118347764015, 0.050029247999191284, -0.02356441505253315, 0.005164628382772207, 0.04298920929431915, -0.03912394121289253, -0.002659199293702841, -0.007559363730251789, 0.0454157218337059, -0.021962374448776245, -0.015206335112452507, -0.0010232334025204182, -0.01826871931552887, -0.01986587978899479, 0.03117191605269909, 0.04540576413273811, -0.030757201835513115, -0.03199073299765587, -0.002743007615208626, -0.041013214737176895, -0.027893099933862686, -0.05746965855360031, 0.02674521878361702, 0.0406375378370285, -0.023507876321673393, -0.04796991124749184, 0.016944631934165955, -0.026044508442282677, -0.0007957449997775257, -0.042841002345085144, -0.049474891275167465, 0.015204338356852531, 0.05878537893295288, -0.005848555825650692, 0.010347770527005196, 0.017798572778701782, -0.0010302012087777257, 0.017112132161855698, 0.023417960852384567, -0.03674280643463135, -0.04497145488858223, 0.029804859310388565, -0.05648275092244148, 0.013091566041111946, 0.04857673868536949, 0.026154344901442528, 0.04920240119099617, 0.025101428851485252, -0.04515814781188965, -0.00838229525834322, -0.00923165027052164, -0.01755610480904579, 0.03461553156375885, -0.0511421374976635, 0.014077308587729931, -0.014291984960436821, 0.03640762344002724, 0.008714073337614536, -0.02367604710161686, 0.017421094700694084, -0.012150770984590054, -0.05135434865951538, -0.027811940759420395, -0.0049744946882128716, -0.015116467140614986, -0.04814371094107628, -0.01729736477136612, 0.03570254519581795, -0.032253555953502655, 0.00794376339763403, 0.015206499956548214, 0.03454558551311493, 0.04227767884731293, -0.01917658932507038, -0.005342898890376091, -0.02340591698884964, -0.0522875040769577, 0.04371961951255798, -0.06784401834011078, -0.0027495105750858784, -0.018752196803689003, -0.059165555983781815, -0.02127048932015896, -0.04699220880866051, 0.05434565991163254, 0.042270105332136154, -0.02459920197725296, -0.05608164891600609, 0.02554362453520298, 0.05245034396648407, -0.05395028740167618, -0.016916288062930107, 0.024202954024076462, -0.0784563422203064, -0.03721228986978531, 0.011036758311092854, -0.03089616820216179, -0.02194390632212162, 0.023915830999612808, -0.005679228808730841, -0.03395944833755493, -0.051512133330106735, 0.04374237731099129, 0.037739504128694534, -0.011377447284758091, 0.03505120798945427, 0.0004569225711748004, -0.0220471303910017, -0.014488235116004944, -0.059597332030534744, 0.026522228494286537, 0.008876108564436436, 0.05563922971487045, 0.010944731533527374, -0.041972965002059937, -0.02881019003689289, 0.06146198511123657, -0.05960400402545929, -0.04596305638551712, 0.036116186529397964, -0.012084665708243847, 0.0464431494474411, -0.03156932815909386, -0.007283390033990145, -0.010646441951394081, -0.023317482322454453, 0.0024644765071570873, -0.028367938473820686, -0.01366501860320568, -0.043986089527606964, 0.04824230819940567, -0.004624058958142996, -0.0584954209625721, -0.048172727227211, -0.0008977395482361317, -0.05744718760251999, 0.009910878725349903, -0.052105557173490524, 0.001977874431759119, 0.0023321881890296936, 0.015874546021223068, -0.017007263377308846, 0.05749135464429855, -0.0544527992606163, -0.013479397632181644, -0.02971494384109974, 0.028593484312295914, -0.02797195315361023, -0.003871374065056443, 0.02668181248009205, 0.022783132269978523, 0.061868127435445786, -0.023786555975675583, 0.015881385654211044, -0.05627286434173584, -0.0441633015871048, 0.014842753298580647, -0.05036526545882225, -0.05233001336455345, -0.004921249113976955, 0.040252141654491425, -0.04744989797472954, 0.003860486438497901, -0.004720373544842005, -0.04806850850582123, -0.04012426361441612, 0.009271625429391861, -0.0017635223921388388, -0.005265931598842144, 0.006786649115383625, 0.03397455811500549, 0.01865161582827568, -0.008697914890944958, 0.017780253663659096, 0.05180864408612251, 0.009007195942103863, -0.052880723029375076, -0.06904670596122742, -0.023023344576358795, -0.0018946117488667369, 0.043362654745578766, -0.053278375416994095, -0.02773868665099144, -0.046806156635284424, -0.05313277617096901, 0.04636463150382042, 0.022848542779684067, -0.011462435126304626, -0.025251131504774094, -0.059396274387836456, 0.04116427153348923, -0.004004289396107197, -0.010961361229419708, -0.06754694879055023, -0.015161510556936264, 0.011433368548750877, -0.0012063104659318924, -0.04364806413650513, -0.02201809175312519, -0.059660810977220535, 0.0016293985536321998, -0.07306864112615585, -0.015016347169876099, -0.014840954914689064, 0.052979618310928345, 0.03919852897524834, -0.016298213973641396, -0.0395929254591465, -0.022008663043379784, 0.010897340252995491, -0.018898990005254745, -0.010587675496935844, -0.028346890583634377, 0.03501221910119057, 0.022805295884609222, -0.05381374806165695, -0.014408957213163376, 0.04517056792974472, -0.029064904898405075, -0.011854344978928566, -0.01222970150411129, 0.021758273243904114, -0.012120864354074001, 0.017179040238261223, 0.02816060557961464, -0.00933846551924944, 0.047802332788705826, -0.029562709853053093, -0.04415744170546532, -0.05556722357869148, -0.052766621112823486, 0.024572230875492096, -0.022461451590061188, 0.029759801924228668, -0.008645713329315186, -0.01762552373111248, -0.057494036853313446, -0.02799755334854126, -0.06067913398146629, 0.06503356993198395, 0.017011888325214386, -0.042711041867733, 0.04917135089635849, -0.049969255924224854, -0.028548281639814377, 0.016624052077531815, 0.0269596166908741, -0.015235359780490398, -0.014963802881538868, 0.012391861528158188, -0.03551261126995087, 0.05682123452425003, -0.04261774197220802, 0.02389024756848812, -0.028382916003465652, 0.024943461641669273, 0.030083375051617622, 0.05628969520330429, -0.011193611659109592, 0.005280214361846447, -0.0571724995970726, -0.06211055442690849, -0.005326195620000362, -0.06609948724508286, -0.032473813742399216, -0.013914137147367, 0.03359359875321388, -0.015646476298570633, 0.03539480268955231, -0.03137486055493355, 0.05993126705288887, 0.02949950098991394, 0.018261099234223366, -0.008334140293300152, -0.01978212222456932, -0.016810910776257515, 0.041868869215250015, 0.0015165756922215223, -0.04783444479107857, -0.02015691064298153, 0.01149266678839922, 0.0027393356431275606, 0.03134831786155701, -0.01407924946397543, 0.01827327162027359, -0.010261617600917816, -0.04531366378068924, 0.008540951646864414, 0.06202045828104019, 0.0019505000673234463, -0.013180315494537354, 0.02338053658604622, -0.0494813546538353, -0.06012176722288132, -0.062030091881752014 ]
We perform calculations of the energy shift of the nuclear clock transition frequency $^{229}$Th as a function of the number of electrons in Th ion. We demonstrate that the dependence of the nuclear frequency on electron configuration is significant. E.g., removing one electron from the atom leads to relative shift of the nuclear frequency $\sim 10^{-7}$, which is twelve orders of magnitude larger than expected relative uncertainty of the nuclear clock transition frequency ($\sim 10^{-19}$). This leads to difference of the nuclear clock frequencies in Th~IV, Th~III, Th~II and Th~I. The relative change of the nuclear frequency between neutral Th and its bare nucleus is 1\%. We also calculate the field shift constants for isotopic and isomeric shifts of atomic electron transitions in Th ions.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11176v1
[ -0.04747951030731201, -0.04107179865241051, 0.00929661188274622, -0.022188279777765274, 0.02906947396695614, 0.025473035871982574, -0.029820697382092476, 0.060948800295591354, -0.041798386722803116, -0.010166503489017487, 0.016637692227959633, -0.05322861671447754, -0.036481402814388275, -0.01738830655813217, -0.027370605617761612, 0.02489427849650383, 0.06903861463069916, 0.06091603264212608, -0.02772200107574463, 0.04327196255326271, 0.04062782600522041, 0.011985338293015957, -0.026658223941922188, 0.052639756351709366, -0.023639291524887085, -0.052720408886671066, -0.003933547995984554, 0.044896651059389114, -0.02914201281964779, -0.012450302951037884, 0.0348052978515625, -0.03898974135518074, -0.013930349610745907, -0.044575031846761703, 0.00826987810432911, 0.008013690821826458, -0.029079683125019073, 0.05099363625049591, 0.009355196729302406, -0.02677135355770588, -0.018104832619428635, -0.03819392994046211, 0.0111875981092453, -0.04534221813082695, -0.007487718015909195, -0.0404835119843483, -0.039683446288108826, -0.03818580135703087, 0.010721235536038876, -0.06724388152360916, 0.05653876066207886, -0.0038136765360832214, 0.009715120308101177, 0.04619015008211136, -0.038699548691511154, -0.03375899791717529, 0.00682802451774478, -0.04323325306177139, -0.04186960682272911, -0.022804757580161095, 0.024658355861902237, 0.020344218239188194, 0.007082256954163313, -0.04335125535726547, -0.0435197651386261, 0.0315190851688385, -0.040922898799180984, -0.04758225008845329, -0.050049617886543274, -0.032573532313108444, -0.00994261633604765, -0.06113065034151077, 0.058993346989154816, -0.005532435607165098, -0.06286387890577316, 0.017351854592561722, 0.02803799882531166, -0.05094374716281891, -0.018838342279195786, 0.010900978930294514, -0.031413935124874115, 0.017070995643734932, -0.040833376348018646, 0.0151381716132164, 0.02643878012895584, -0.019118906930088997, 0.060692623257637024, -0.03183147683739662, 0.00827859342098236, -0.04009691998362541, -0.0018884397577494383, -0.039519280195236206, -0.04304303973913193, -0.03301945701241493, 0.014516805298626423, -0.041593123227357864, 0.029994823038578033, 0.03249669447541237, -0.03433879837393761, -0.0502106249332428, 0.037576835602521896, -0.07073021680116653, 0.03457419574260712, 0.024504797533154488, 0.01673058047890663, -0.05580700561404228, -0.07088237255811691, 0.0010729243513196707, -0.07170315086841583, 0.049957580864429474, -0.0025942781940102577, -0.011442163027822971, -0.010178178548812866, -0.027411244809627533, -0.0354020819067955, -0.05939190462231636, 0.04966588318347931, 0.023717090487480164, 0.033369190990924835, -0.010428749024868011, -0.054881688207387924, 0.037747275084257126, 0.02417813614010811, 0.04366295412182808, -0.03361879661679268, 0.018358048051595688, 0.046233199536800385, 0.015041516162455082, -0.0040818615816533566, -0.028761090710759163, -0.012185086496174335, 0.03390492498874664, 0.03753802552819252, -0.025386882945895195, -0.012091077864170074, -0.027522753924131393, 0.022364752367138863, -0.06650534272193909, -0.03290707990527153, 0.03339787945151329, 0.010420285165309906, -0.0300888828933239, 0.022397950291633606, 0.040919333696365356, -0.017539791762828827, -0.03749716654419899, -0.06742561608552933, 0.00531132984906435, 0.068707674741745, 0.010689584538340569, -0.02071034349501133, 0.027619704604148865, -0.005676161032170057, -0.04680643230676651, -0.01353246346116066, -0.0009825193556025624, 0.059500496834516525, 0.02115439809858799, -0.03704771399497986, -0.017079608514904976, -0.005494541488587856, -0.039535485208034515, -0.016802547499537468, 0.013791542500257492, -0.030686361715197563, -0.04176747426390648, 0.037445105612277985, 0.008078661747276783, -0.005103512201458216, 0.011817862279713154, -0.008371242322027683, 0.015118177980184555, 0.05923525616526604, -0.0607977919280529, -0.033889319747686386, -0.04555510729551315, 0.021963154897093773, -0.04471120610833168, 0.022612396627664566, 0.018205510452389717, -0.020580438897013664, 0.02680542692542076, 0.0023359654005616903, -0.0384247787296772, -0.05260865017771721, -0.029037361964583397, -0.06672351807355881, 0.05921211466193199, 0.042530957609415054, -0.006710124667733908, -0.03944630175828934, -0.06705212593078613, 0.0428289994597435, -0.023417826741933823, 0.024490708485245705, -0.03657205402851105, 0.005588562227785587, -0.03657231107354164, 0.003958964254707098, 0.05649939179420471, -0.05259585753083229, 0.03416306897997856, -0.01803778111934662, -0.0026474553160369396, -0.014108029194176197, -0.05958813056349754, 0.008742108009755611, -0.0025802329182624817, -0.02850624918937683, -0.00752377649769187, 0.05464549362659454, 0.01699262484908104, -0.026957357302308083, -0.041903119534254074, -0.003164024790748954, -0.061095044016838074, -0.07789763063192368, 0.05143727734684944, -0.018964340910315514, -0.004068859852850437, 0.015214912593364716, -0.0007708391640335321, -0.03142893314361572, -0.025158917531371117, 0.031210295855998993, 0.04734371230006218, 0.04813241586089134, -0.0553598552942276, -0.019751401618123055, -0.048296939581632614, 0.00606381893157959, -0.045559145510196686, -0.07197578996419907, -0.05881199613213539, -0.007406920660287142, -0.0059440904296934605, -0.0298000518232584, -0.00597298564389348, -0.06185699626803398, -0.028205834329128265, -0.05540880560874939, -0.005368513520807028, 0.0468844473361969, 0.03762826323509216, -0.02807052806019783, 0.004903542809188366, -0.04875160753726959, 0.021865298971533775, -0.010100405663251877, -0.009773819707334042, -0.03458001837134361, -0.0377209298312664, -0.016555840149521828, -0.05872679129242897, -0.04555410519242287, 0.05950915068387985, -0.028044307604432106, 0.018454626202583313, 0.0009636651375330985, 0.027902968227863312, -0.06947804987430573, 0.021732395514845848, -0.05308264493942261, -0.016713092103600502, -0.04936689883470535, 0.0005174613324925303, -0.07216285914182663, 0.0006848318735137582, -0.02797895483672619, -0.036589451134204865, -0.03807136416435242, 0.022202951833605766, 0.028378823772072792, 0.000004348908078100067, 0.013052349910140038, -0.03173211216926575, -0.03674018383026123, -0.04204704985022545, 0.05371583253145218, -0.05566737428307533, 0.06082957237958908, 0.03434174880385399, -0.024564441293478012, -0.07142053544521332, -0.057289525866508484, -0.01423604041337967, -0.00025527662364766, -0.05332612618803978, -0.011974379420280457, -0.00925259105861187, -0.03810221329331398, -0.005627740640193224, -0.042426928877830505, 0.008284413255751133, -0.06653450429439545, -0.043814219534397125, -0.0574507899582386, -0.033583469688892365, -0.018427694216370583, -0.055723607540130615, -0.04838203266263008, 0.028808442875742912, -0.004578659310936928, -0.020332980901002884, -0.055089324712753296, -0.02250455878674984, 0.011434444226324558, -0.028695812448859215, 0.010833299718797207, 0.007877197116613388, -0.02480020560324192, -0.01680009625852108, -0.07191979885101318, -0.019910108298063278, -0.03183772787451744, 0.029758021235466003, 0.028848908841609955, -0.06242029741406441, 0.004404011182487011, -0.036832377314567566, -0.011630043387413025, -0.045069944113492966, 0.01483563706278801, 0.03781303018331528, -0.06111109256744385, -0.025250915437936783, 0.0451810397207737, 0.05357040464878082, -0.0009342084522359073, -0.050386179238557816, -0.06289167702198029, -0.015794184058904648, 0.0025626588612794876, -0.011582783423364162, 0.057802990078926086, 0.033725935965776443, -0.029734259471297264, -0.006905470509082079, -0.06097498536109924, 0.03175978362560272, -0.013132759369909763, -0.01819751225411892, 0.043502409011125565, 0.031280457973480225, 0.0009903415339067578, -0.03000020794570446, 0.033602289855480194, 0.060552455484867096, 0.02225685492157936, -0.018763810396194458, 0.036487434059381485, 0.006976114120334387, -0.035260770469903946, 0.023829996585845947, 0.029128989204764366, 0.03758985549211502, 0.052431538701057434, 0.05651278793811798, -0.0523754358291626, -0.00273639103397727, -0.05795131251215935, -0.06987074017524719, -0.023238059133291245, -0.00609236117452383, -0.041238196194171906, 0.028386902064085007, 0.05948828533291817, 0.0073750498704612255, 0.00745747284963727, -0.06200830638408661, 0.060001686215400696, 0.025714512914419174, -0.025460224598646164, -0.038336895406246185, -0.0048544742166996, -0.015915805473923683, -0.01956166699528694, 0.04784996062517166, -0.03525608032941818, 0.011225100606679916, 0.03832989186048508, -0.04946288838982582, -0.023836180567741394, 0.017061013728380203, -0.0228448286652565, -0.015365025959908962, -0.026973193511366844, 0.006066777277737856, 0.028215734288096428, -0.013888492248952389, 0.025753216817975044, -0.03870316967368126, -0.03301388397812843, 0.01985713467001915, 0.038325756788253784, -0.013292530551552773, -0.02451133541762829, 0.06643810123205185, -0.03971961885690689, -0.030733622610569, 0.03354121744632721, -0.034653324633836746, -0.0076102204620838165, -0.06175161153078079, -0.020190509036183357, -0.06774768978357315, -0.02167392708361149, -0.028284240514039993, -0.026196397840976715, 0.06861685961484909, 0.029781300574541092, -0.021589314565062523, -0.0352749302983284, -0.00004298062776797451, -0.0012259125942364335, -0.045906998217105865, 0.01747724786400795, 0.001148375915363431, 0.016979437321424484, -0.033733632415533066, -0.021806582808494568, -0.0034541720524430275, -0.01157422736287117, -0.07190942019224167, 0.029383404180407524, -0.03119741752743721, 0.023000285029411316, 0.006152001209557056, 0.01933249831199646, 0.02000926248729229, 0.00662151537835598, -0.05925427004694939, -0.01473282091319561, -0.015723710879683495, 0.06747592240571976, -0.0137923713773489, 0.0023884782567620277, 0.018973633646965027, -0.003221013117581606, 0.013517419807612896, 0.000548016803804785, 0.030154448002576828, -0.036803826689720154, -0.025842223316431046, -0.023450765758752823, 0.03733780235052109, -0.07029372453689575, -0.057156000286340714, -0.023849036544561386, -0.052251748740673065, -0.06673934310674667, 0.010691097937524319, -0.013632310554385185, -0.020656680688261986, -0.05410361662507057, 0.0479259267449379, 0.05676741525530815, 0.039313219487667084, -0.007867206819355488, 0.03396683186292648, 0.007211894728243351, 0.054109808057546616, 0.0024940134026110172, -0.013086074031889439, -0.06475808471441269, 0.02424273081123829, 0.03338136896491051, -0.027594851329922676, 0.021345820277929306, 0.03693768009543419, -0.013457240536808968, -0.0009870032081380486, -0.07279166579246521, 0.03051024116575718, 0.04288889095187187, -0.02989151142537594, 0.032756559550762177, 0.023555941879749298, -0.0508686900138855, 0.023423990234732628, 0.01708086207509041, 0.0011605949839577079, -0.014115093275904655, -0.025504395365715027, 0.022229645401239395, -0.02659544162452221, -0.04579683020710945, 0.035779163241386414, 0.05092497915029526, -0.02505801059305668, -0.05037501081824303, -0.020875735208392143, 0.006645173765718937, -0.026312517002224922, -0.029304271563887596, 0.026288507506251335, 0.0267651304602623, -0.05701750889420509, -0.06938011199235916, -0.005093070212751627, -0.007951648905873299, -0.004113323520869017, 0.04778226837515831, -0.0029176922980695963, -0.017712729051709175, 0.03080834448337555, -0.028528841212391853, -0.013719183392822742, 0.05587979406118393, 0.016247782856225967, -0.013643926940858364, -0.001650401041842997, -0.011492541059851646, -0.05432276800274849, 0.01576097123324871, -0.035214658826589584, -0.0009004285093396902, -0.02065642923116684, -0.02740972302854061, 0.05792485177516937, 0.05028950050473213, 0.009412530809640884, -0.047180287539958954, -0.02152900956571102, -0.004851371981203556, 0.06479814648628235, -0.006962447427213192, -0.03078826516866684, -0.037919238209724426, 0.04285840690135956, -0.021055199205875397, -0.06624609231948853, -0.011926896870136261, -0.03202071785926819, -0.04716586694121361, -0.003851000452414155, 0.005760702304542065, 0.027666384354233742, -0.022477412596344948, -0.021051075309515, 0.037476375699043274, -0.034975565969944, 0.07040558010339737, -0.0025363240856677294, 0.01950760744512081, -0.02924073114991188, -0.01034412533044815, -0.01569150574505329, -0.03419662266969681, 0.03346072882413864, 0.06690452247858047, -0.06459324061870575, 0.0117830540984869, -0.026605747640132904, 0.03556421026587486, 0.0009965013014152646, -0.026013962924480438, -0.05341054126620293, 0.03928539901971817, -0.04800620302557945, -0.05417530983686447, 0.03171100467443466, -0.009059383533895016, -0.07595744729042053, -0.004707988817244768, 0.03248324245214462, -0.0505882129073143, 0.06414100527763367, 0.015547852031886578, -0.06798352301120758, -0.05486070737242699, -0.008795754052698612, -0.05567356199026108, -0.060461949557065964, -0.0389777347445488, 0.05416702479124069, 0.02543497644364834, -0.03519034385681152, 0.01722065359354019, 0.022371120750904083, 0.024019457399845123, -0.02652406133711338, -0.06009978428483009, -0.0370975062251091, 0.007182413246482611, 0.06977386772632599, -0.017310170456767082, 0.009035465307533741, 0.005446352995932102, 0.03877873346209526, -0.051792167127132416, 0.028710730373859406, 0.01211215928196907, -0.01769176498055458, 0.00398709112778306, -0.03418101742863655, -0.04935076832771301, -0.023375775665044785, -0.04450145736336708, 0.034196771681308746, -0.019130012020468712, 0.04527095705270767, -0.004440142773091793, 0.032870158553123474, -0.005495061166584492, -0.019896356388926506, 0.008364193141460419, 0.06621570140123367, -0.05944085866212845, 0.03896152228116989, -0.058108147233724594, 0.008482427336275578, 0.025895990431308746, 0.032466307282447815, -0.03184787929058075, 0.01902555674314499, -0.02191108837723732, 0.01367259956896305, -0.023818090558052063, -0.016861045733094215, -0.003786044893786311, 0.011265993118286133, 0.016430575400590897, -0.03478775545954704, 0.06860775500535965, -0.008245403878390789, 0.010338593274354935, -0.02165323682129383, -0.04062338173389435, 0.04556064307689667, -0.038070861250162125, -0.014078523963689804, 0.006111801601946354, -0.010816700756549835, -0.03737939894199371, -0.0143992118537426, 0.021038230508565903, -0.005648004822432995, -0.038671985268592834, -0.010355401784181595, -0.03284341096878052, 0.009122177958488464, 0.03452353924512863, -0.050958115607500076, 0.04740149527788162, 0.0011455775238573551, 0.03318364545702934, 0.025917677208781242, -0.02513192780315876, -0.05550086125731468, -0.04935427010059357, -0.016380688175559044, 0.039925046265125275, -0.03171929344534874, -0.0027514840476214886, -0.04514344036579132, -0.049463436007499695, -0.07090076804161072, 0.008877312764525414, 0.0034835031256079674, -0.004871027078479528, -0.04608811438083649, -0.028180574998259544, 0.0364147387444973, 0.05031406134366989, 0.008115116506814957, -0.07676275074481964, 0.00556230777874589, 0.012060674838721752, 0.04254862293601036, -0.01303735002875328, -0.029203061014413834, -0.05854059010744095, 0.029154708608984947, -0.07044897973537445, -0.05726097896695137, 0.0031192065216600895, 0.049252673983573914, 0.015349000692367554, -0.012270839884877205, -0.01675325073301792, -0.042901661247015, 0.01431986503303051, 0.001256267772987485, -0.053997062146663666, -0.005548703949898481, 0.03219124302268028, -0.0062185609713196754, -0.031915079802274704, 0.01279878243803978, 0.0489065945148468, -0.047763973474502563, -0.04004628583788872, 0.05076634883880615, 0.032907284796237946, -0.02966151386499405, -0.01390417106449604, -0.02267359010875225, -0.01669071801006794, 0.0394432432949543, -0.0603908896446228, -0.046564824879169464, 0.01135152019560337, -0.026586204767227173, 0.0039004574064165354, -0.0194903165102005, -0.029328983277082443, -0.04034721851348877, -0.03865226358175278, -0.04816175624728203, -0.02634800411760807, -0.018186122179031372, -0.026728466153144836, 0.04943087324500084, -0.0004337300779297948, 0.050426267087459564, -0.059129636734724045, 0.022130198776721954, 0.005684135016053915, -0.044307876378297806, -0.053626649081707, 0.0017956749070435762, -0.0009309950401075184, -0.05410774052143097, 0.033031318336725235, -0.021287009119987488, 0.0365055687725544, -0.017956193536520004, 0.027275539934635162, -0.0010860951151698828, 0.03772939369082451, -0.061599574983119965, -0.022177059203386307, -0.05054793879389763, -0.019859401509165764, 0.02173374593257904, -0.06876403838396072, 0.028269296512007713, 0.027766704559326172, 0.025102881714701653, 0.0032246981281787157, 0.006897322367876768, 0.01240638829767704, 0.06197086721658707, 0.03487461805343628, -0.027007393538951874, 0.017382871359586716, -0.01381516084074974, 0.04006956145167351, -0.0027688592672348022, 0.0022960216738283634, 0.008217384107410908, -0.07188824564218521, 0.05604802444577217, -0.00643078051507473, -0.004976010415703058, 0.019288422539830208, -0.03376143053174019, -0.010872934013605118, -0.0661642998456955, -0.037681203335523605, 0.05362148582935333, -0.03745514154434204, -0.056270845234394073, 0.04711543396115303, 0.01992366462945938, -0.05183545872569084, -0.04073904827237129 ]
The development of large high-quality datasets and high-performing models have led to significant advancements in the domain of Extractive Question Answering (EQA). This progress has sparked considerable interest in exploring unanswerable questions within the EQA domain. Training EQA models with unanswerable questions helps them avoid extracting misleading or incorrect answers for queries that lack valid responses. However, manually annotating unanswerable questions is labor-intensive. To address this, we propose AGent, a novel pipeline that automatically creates new unanswerable questions by re-matching a question with a context that lacks the necessary information for a correct answer. In this paper, we demonstrate the usefulness of this AGent pipeline by creating two sets of unanswerable questions from answerable questions in SQuAD and HotpotQA. These created question sets exhibit low error rates. Additionally, models fine-tuned on these questions show comparable performance with those fine-tuned on the SQuAD 2.0 dataset on multiple EQA benchmarks.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05103v1
[ 0.02622135728597641, -0.023664511740207672, -0.0010795298730954528, 0.04166951775550842, -0.013909224420785904, -0.012746455147862434, -0.03584475442767143, -0.0010797424474731088, -0.05220399424433708, -0.02590627409517765, -0.027073079720139503, -0.01101898867636919, -0.02777143381536007, -0.02775309793651104, -0.03551650792360306, -0.04466288164258003, 0.06823927909135818, -0.010925156064331532, -0.05441205948591232, 0.00675615482032299, -0.012781457044184208, 0.01056673750281334, -0.013194447383284569, -0.006824340205639601, 0.04092815890908241, -0.013620369136333466, -0.04202329367399216, -0.007177306804805994, 0.02486370876431465, -0.0011213358957320452, 0.07131657004356384, -0.023084739223122597, -0.041602931916713715, -0.05552738904953003, -0.022979771718382835, -0.039346203207969666, 0.011416580528020859, -0.010884582996368408, 0.005414665210992098, -0.03838784992694855, 0.0045534465461969376, -0.07016885280609131, -0.07814043015241623, -0.013750549405813217, -0.035352472215890884, -0.009164724498987198, 0.011716795153915882, 0.0318891666829586, -0.056617945432662964, -0.04922327399253845, -0.004958660341799259, -0.036541350185871124, -0.053800247609615326, -0.007215765304863453, -0.034609321504831314, -0.022069968283176422, -0.011334355920553207, 0.001871578162536025, -0.06458495557308197, 0.010341617278754711, -0.004252985585480928, -0.032443683594465256, -0.023327942937612534, 0.048671040683984756, -0.037696074694395065, 0.023629754781723022, -0.0005788993439637125, -0.0002994429087266326, -0.008998343721032143, -0.011366733349859715, 0.03750583529472351, -0.06427925080060959, -0.025822818279266357, -0.003229083027690649, 0.006324942223727703, -0.007618707604706287, -0.0017285740468651056, -0.028161514550447464, 0.013240636326372623, -0.011333768256008625, 0.03395981714129448, 0.00954415462911129, 0.048230018466711044, 0.04949633404612541, 0.019077282398939133, -0.04245717078447342, 0.018181979656219482, -0.0011162058217450976, -0.04587918147444725, -0.0698397159576416, 0.014586802572011948, -0.046567875891923904, -0.07874602824449539, 0.006507709622383118, 0.06053847074508667, -0.007721795700490475, 0.025884680449962616, 0.034134477376937866, -0.0137184364721179, 0.023907527327537537, -0.032954972237348557, -0.059619296342134476, -0.05526990443468094, 0.020291343331336975, 0.007763639558106661, -0.009001600556075573, -0.009335484355688095, -0.018608607351779938, -0.07298929989337921, -0.00011431058374000713, -0.029578253626823425, -0.011555808596313, -0.013167772442102432, -0.0552501380443573, -0.07134027034044266, -0.05941246077418327, 0.05958406627178192, 0.04410780593752861, 0.03687413036823273, -0.016063028946518898, 0.010118076577782631, 0.04794972389936447, 0.03936430811882019, 0.023016827180981636, -0.05673766881227493, -0.02968086116015911, -0.004260034766048193, 0.020033635199069977, 0.020157700404524803, -0.014296155422925949, -0.031748391687870026, 0.0527069978415966, -0.044192664325237274, -0.018415410071611404, 0.03781142085790634, -0.02464030310511589, -0.04422586411237717, -0.03871149569749832, 0.02830488793551922, -0.02700861543416977, -0.04879448190331459, -0.08388876914978027, 0.05050325021147728, -0.03789326176047325, -0.024325791746377945, 0.033212944865226746, -0.024060459807515144, -0.04274308681488037, 0.0261122677475214, 0.03921555355191231, -0.017876900732517242, 0.01582374982535839, 0.02571841888129711, 0.014444137923419476, 0.005246745888143778, 0.005797392223030329, 0.03920251503586769, -0.00848090834915638, -0.03028741478919983, 0.0307560246437788, -0.006873173639178276, -0.02129100263118744, 0.01230509951710701, -0.037299975752830505, 0.03019457310438156, 0.0163891464471817, 0.034222688525915146, 0.029865745455026627, -0.04667137935757637, 0.023633992299437523, -0.027456244453787804, 0.04764484614133835, 0.04227269068360329, -0.020987490192055702, -0.0358690582215786, 0.037459176033735275, 0.03227765113115311, -0.0025350155774503946, -0.07547267526388168, -0.023405734449625015, 0.009633283130824566, 0.055311281234025955, -0.00551008153706789, 0.024110030382871628, -0.012487616389989853, -0.0143059603869915, -0.07718536257743835, 0.0052120317704975605, 0.02720372937619686, -0.0015453363303095102, -0.007015724666416645, -0.050385843962430954, 0.0019357566488906741, -0.004836849868297577, 0.010216837748885155, -0.02555745653808117, 0.015614284202456474, 0.0058900173753499985, -0.03470262885093689, 0.04170721769332886, -0.07865454256534576, -0.004091814160346985, -0.036503564566373825, 0.031200071796774864, -0.008182771503925323, -0.058228395879268646, -0.04606427624821663, 0.04901468753814697, -0.025168735533952713, 0.01729905605316162, 0.055077794939279556, 0.039105888456106186, 0.0537567213177681, 0.04826182499527931, 0.021988121792674065, 0.009663130156695843, -0.09140835702419281, 0.05323352292180061, -0.04106811806559563, 0.029811566695570946, 0.046895213425159454, 0.058181654661893845, 0.027783505618572235, 0.02500505931675434, 0.014855930581688881, 0.029981354251503944, 0.015097486786544323, 0.0009305456769652665, -0.027420686557888985, -0.03645478934049606, -0.026768967509269714, -0.05439424887299538, -0.028201742097735405, -0.06196887046098709, -0.04245709627866745, 0.009188721887767315, -0.0005501373088918626, 0.06376302987337112, 0.015137801878154278, -0.023855945095419884, -0.04214838892221451, -0.01968739554286003, 0.04068157449364662, 0.008637364953756332, -0.047769930213689804, -0.0426507331430912, 0.014323044568300247, 0.016602693125605583, 0.03190411254763603, 0.02752763032913208, -0.01749761588871479, -0.07090745121240616, -0.042208168655633926, -0.009753787890076637, 0.0359252393245697, 0.04897099360823631, -0.05055473372340202, 0.03588766232132912, -0.0378430001437664, 0.04722357913851738, 0.025193549692630768, 0.03627006337046623, -0.023314476013183594, -0.028235359117388725, 0.06828170269727707, -0.03505869209766388, 0.007079280912876129, -0.01642916537821293, -0.010925418697297573, -0.03509343042969704, -0.0005220446037128568, 0.046075232326984406, 0.037100858986377716, 0.01299773994833231, -0.03657890483736992, -0.03886246681213379, 0.0024166118819266558, 0.007377925328910351, 0.04302137717604637, 0.04739810526371002, -0.02284848503768444, 0.02649541199207306, 0.013080022297799587, -0.051878686994314194, -0.02116447314620018, -0.03873671591281891, -0.030386144295334816, -0.053453363478183746, -0.04735313728451729, -0.028867991641163826, -0.06885981559753418, -0.05331990122795105, -0.011592515744268894, -0.0320473238825798, -0.04235568270087242, -0.030400285497307777, -0.04341762512922287, -0.003975103609263897, 0.05020996555685997, 0.0013905380619689822, -0.05784633383154869, -0.02970733866095543, 0.008400560356676579, -0.02142457850277424, -0.008225671947002411, -0.027908699586987495, -0.027597034350037575, -0.03185928612947464, 0.036456942558288574, 0.016133306547999382, 0.031820375472307205, 0.0027586829382926226, -0.02583627589046955, 0.03433658182621002, 0.004285111092031002, 0.04092426970601082, 0.03366098180413246, 0.03867155686020851, 0.030604422092437744, -0.031287189573049545, -0.008425881154835224, -0.016564060002565384, -0.01160518266260624, -0.06226251274347305, -0.02974126674234867, -0.04683731123805046, 0.05715370550751686, -0.014797125943005085, 0.004332289099693298, -0.006966843269765377, -0.05030561611056328, 0.015539913438260555, 0.01947684958577156, -0.020145731046795845, 0.0015777441440150142, 0.06620600074529648, -0.027754494920372963, -0.009333494119346142, -0.03601495549082756, 0.004324011504650116, -0.007688440848141909, 0.008874100632965565, -0.019014868885278702, 0.06668716669082642, 0.030034812167286873, -0.0877453163266182, -0.002391928806900978, 0.03415709361433983, 0.045377928763628006, 0.007862887345254421, -0.009290329180657864, 0.007142077665776014, 0.01631234772503376, 0.05055753141641617, 0.000770187471061945, 0.053818229585886, 0.03046182543039322, 0.05849646031856537, -0.03597269207239151, -0.05447695031762123, 0.006165279075503349, -0.06226879730820656, -0.06210414320230484, -0.030108246952295303, 0.028726164251565933, 0.01600843481719494, 0.01854724809527397, -0.07040810585021973, 0.008721685037016869, 0.04753801226615906, 0.03092622384428978, 0.0004593415360432118, -0.042629823088645935, 0.02378217503428459, -0.06318498402833939, 0.026084868237376213, -0.005946354940533638, -0.02605363354086876, 0.01857970841228962, -0.03352759778499603, 0.0037866979837417603, -0.06700596213340759, 0.05091211944818497, 0.014587794430553913, -0.049355752766132355, 0.047995470464229584, 0.027983592823147774, -0.03373165801167488, 0.023560360074043274, -0.032211486250162125, 0.004973928909748793, -0.013633509166538715, 0.03275565803050995, -0.049637459218502045, 0.009428720921278, -0.0017119096592068672, -0.024944275617599487, 0.005949681159108877, -0.058544259518384933, -0.042006250470876694, 0.00819794088602066, 0.0046759299002587795, -0.005871006287634373, -0.07981832325458527, -0.021325521171092987, -0.043124061077833176, 0.07337301969528198, -0.02403188869357109, -0.02428579144179821, 0.06781665980815887, -0.010109073482453823, -0.019448351114988327, -0.0003951764083467424, 0.014333709143102169, -0.008474070578813553, -0.07764264941215515, -0.029169274494051933, -0.07334143668413162, 0.03580460324883461, -0.026522891595959663, 0.050667811185121536, 0.05606056749820709, 0.003476888407021761, -0.041322458535432816, -0.06672714650630951, -0.013796644285321236, 0.009539132006466389, 0.07480388879776001, 0.05162764713168144, 0.0015346724539995193, -0.022102773189544678, -0.011445794254541397, -0.012830058112740517, -0.011680694296956062, -0.05135932192206383, -0.05913164094090462, 0.06527817249298096, 0.04684334620833397, -0.02310921624302864, -0.010525286197662354, -0.026770753785967827, 0.01596612110733986, -0.051026370376348495, -0.057498782873153687, -0.011139488779008389, 0.04055263474583626, -0.042566001415252686, -0.06829193234443665, 0.0025450035464018583, -0.05266980454325676, -0.05647670105099678, -0.01585838571190834, 0.04722004011273384, -0.036105573177337646, 0.0033434450160712004, -0.025102440267801285, 0.014644965529441833, -0.005992078687995672, -0.025612041354179382, 0.00880617555230856, 0.022311795502901077, -0.061388809233903885, -0.025379491969943047, -0.029543567448854446, -0.08473861962556839, -0.036856509745121, -0.061844129115343094, 0.015417328104376793, -0.0468716025352478, 0.02972152829170227, 0.007423826027661562, 0.05978921055793762, -0.07925819605588913, -0.011361426673829556, 0.03332389518618584, 0.02509748749434948, -0.00040951630217023194, 0.023677697405219078, -0.017317350953817368, 0.0172099769115448, 0.014947456307709217, 0.030808718875050545, 0.0047890134155750275, -0.023198824375867844, 0.0503036268055439, 0.01078115776181221, -0.04792087897658348, -0.0059915161691606045, 0.025333823636174202, -0.036082711070775986, -0.06369028985500336, -0.005966982338577509, 0.006855361629277468, 0.026480872184038162, -0.006241177208721638, 0.03764994814991951, 0.04626293480396271, -0.011937743984162807, -0.024893585592508316, -0.05586874857544899, -0.01789003610610962, -0.011081558652222157, -0.010593698360025883, -0.04584560543298721, -0.03019847720861435, 0.03753034397959709, 0.01931481622159481, 0.0008768260013312101, 0.0215744785964489, 0.030186360701918602, 0.018241899088025093, -0.0363522432744503, 0.004125538747757673, -0.029636099934577942, 0.000656747433822602, -0.02577284164726734, 0.02130008302628994, 0.04397093877196312, 0.04491574689745903, 0.024759985506534576, -0.06471078842878342, 0.002193692373111844, -0.053645119071006775, 0.025179190561175346, -0.009491224773228168, -0.00223910273052752, -0.03325267508625984, 0.03397258743643761, -0.019592836499214172, 0.023702217265963554, 0.03874364495277405, 0.03588811680674553, -0.029631786048412323, 0.013094581663608551, -0.05342162400484085, -0.025458119809627533, 0.001192504190839827, -0.0382564440369606, -0.03673066571354866, 0.048094648867845535, 0.037168096750974655, -0.005591412074863911, -0.003992932848632336, -0.014809240587055683, 0.0036513868253678083, 0.024086173623800278, -0.024749726057052612, -0.07323505729436874, -0.03048691339790821, 0.016017507761716843, 0.05069626122713089, -0.05696472153067589, 0.04523647949099541, -0.009925995022058487, -0.011166143231093884, 0.03709099814295769, -0.05422242730855942, 0.05599626153707504, 0.02919561229646206, 0.02014191448688507, -0.028786029666662216, 0.054967865347862244, -0.02456664852797985, -0.07566101849079132, 0.014484667219221592, 0.03786858543753624, -0.07920069992542267, -0.04521730914711952, 0.011603056453168392, 0.040744174271821976, -0.049266498535871506, 0.05258831009268761, 0.04864673316478729, -0.039015043526887894, -0.05207674950361252, 0.07548687607049942, 0.06291957199573517, -0.0365922711789608, 0.007126091979444027, 0.01245010644197464, -0.06873182207345963, 0.045982275158166885, -0.05612175539135933, -0.004655332304537296, 0.005371048580855131, 0.06460731476545334, 0.011829576455056667, -0.03535476326942444, -0.00625967001542449, 0.04358431324362755, -0.04903296008706093, 0.03625493124127388, 0.03247073292732239, -0.0026074983179569244, 0.04764219745993614, -0.028299255296587944, -0.013462970033288002, -0.004882095847278833, -0.016510911285877228, 0.00941393245011568, -0.0007582196849398315, -0.009565900079905987, -0.008114257827401161, 0.027486074715852737, -0.03488007187843323, -0.06781093776226044, 0.013499603606760502, -0.02066321298480034, -0.08049832284450531, 0.048309072852134705, -0.06638352572917938, 0.02322668954730034, 0.018481018021702766, -0.004311750177294016, 0.020121078938245773, 0.04720655828714371, -0.025544505566358566, -0.03802739456295967, 0.01768830232322216, -0.035477813333272934, 0.036907441914081573, 0.024150505661964417, 0.032868582755327225, -0.029435070231556892, 0.04070432111620903, -0.05215544253587723, -0.05617816746234894, -0.0023190949577838182, -0.04910939186811447, -0.0038117358926683664, 0.029702069237828255, -0.029894117265939713, -0.0505671352148056, 0.05117850378155708, -0.028211649507284164, 0.056882455945014954, 0.0234918724745512, -0.06587985903024673, -0.06781686842441559, -0.032576609402894974, 0.029053159058094025, -0.03883795067667961, 0.031142963096499443, 0.012607412412762642, 0.05489286035299301, -0.053847696632146835, 0.03617917373776436, -0.004061981104314327, 0.008907197043299675, 0.022216305136680603, -0.017629360780119896, -0.05343214422464371, -0.0006675142212770879, -0.04845792427659035, -0.01476468238979578, 0.0007510723080486059, 0.004979181569069624, -0.023835724219679832, 0.017512492835521698, 0.0782020315527916, 0.052468013018369675, -0.007588408421725035, -0.04764724522829056, 0.02203470468521118, -0.02140648104250431, -0.03569434955716133, -0.05006136745214462, -0.02739143557846546, -0.005940375849604607, -0.048242565244436264, -0.00835533905774355, -0.007050692569464445, -0.05123269185423851, 0.02269241213798523, -0.07654036581516266, 0.03515647351741791, 0.0013961695367470384, 0.008431063033640385, -0.026530634611845016, -0.01215572003275156, 0.016536571085453033, -0.015284577384591103, 0.0034561583306640387, -0.06276485323905945, -0.03625134006142616, 0.018327992409467697, 0.028138432651758194, 0.012210177257657051, -0.06444644182920456, 0.013667351566255093, 0.026141205802559853, -0.06856602430343628, 0.005707764998078346, 0.002254602499306202, 0.03274054080247879, -0.0012187677202746272, 0.030934374779462814, 0.049381449818611145, -0.05599638447165489, -0.005108396988362074, -0.025798369199037552, 0.04206647351384163, -0.024818673729896545, -0.05385314300656319, -0.007221701089292765, -0.006034943275153637, -0.04706297442317009, -0.014667618088424206, -0.01881827600300312, -0.021930398419499397, -0.007949130609631538, -0.010000019334256649, 0.03296644985675812, -0.011841688305139542, 0.004475143738090992, 0.0450851134955883, -0.043621569871902466, -0.03415114805102348, -0.008570878766477108, -0.004927854984998703, -0.0029790671542286873, 0.04153260588645935, 0.005033079069107771, -0.047500211745500565, -0.05053146183490753, -0.03286284580826759, -0.01696515455842018, -0.03591490164399147, 0.018269244581460953, -0.007757976185530424, 0.0788775235414505, 0.006183629389852285, -0.044094134122133255, -0.017385248094797134, -0.03456564247608185, -0.05454926937818527, -0.0698443129658699, -0.026759864762425423, -0.017271367833018303, 0.029481083154678345, -0.014556089416146278, -0.02843145653605461, 0.013575042597949505, 0.032025814056396484, -0.0025467786472290754, -0.02362683415412903, -0.025759434327483177, -0.0018510340014472604, -0.06507046520709991, 0.05638778582215309, 0.014623287133872509, 0.016435610130429268, -0.04194460064172745, -0.0028754465747624636, 0.03608528524637222, 0.011051631532609463, 0.013400319963693619, -0.010580532252788544, 0.01716066524386406, -0.05508891120553017, 0.014676102437078953, 0.013531895354390144, -0.00523432157933712, -0.04363054409623146, -0.031017277389764786, -0.0289200097322464, -0.057524729520082474, -0.030500123277306557 ]
Accretion disks around compact objects are expected to enter an unstable phase at high luminosity. One instability may occur when the radiation pressure generated by accretion modifies the disk viscosity, resulting in the cyclic depletion and refilling of the inner disk on short timescales. Such a scenario, however, has only been quantitatively verified for a single stellar-mass black hole. Although there are hints of these cycles in a few isolated cases, their apparent absence in the variable emission of most bright accreting neutron stars and black holes has been a lingering puzzle. Here we report the presence of the same multiwavelength instability around an accreting neutron star. Moreover, we show that the variability across the electromagnetic spectrum-from radio to X-ray-of both black holes and neutron stars at high accretion rates can be explained consistently if the accretion disks are unstable, producing relativistic ejections during transitions that deplete or refill the inner disk. Such new association allows us to identify the main physical components responsible for the fast multiwavelength variability of highly accreting compact objects.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.00020v1
[ -0.03710435703396797, -0.011512884870171547, 0.051508087664842606, -0.009463206864893436, 0.008841531351208687, 0.006824001204222441, -0.00875174906104803, 0.03079836070537567, -0.026629358530044556, 0.0014363309601321816, 0.05067862570285797, -0.047726646065711975, -0.01149389985948801, -0.08011287450790405, 0.0031381745357066393, 0.01779395528137684, 0.07691831886768341, 0.03230873867869377, -0.0591963492333889, 0.06258972734212875, 0.018984146416187286, -0.003919957205653191, -0.017651032656431198, 0.027729278430342674, 0.00878440123051405, -0.036156121641397476, -0.04132131114602089, 0.0758005753159523, -0.03469100967049599, -0.016772327944636345, 0.06254326552152634, -0.037393614649772644, -0.0014973253710195422, -0.04380924627184868, -0.007641775533556938, -0.018630223348736763, -0.00818639062345028, 0.05912049487233162, -0.024099592119455338, -0.01333204098045826, -0.041914112865924835, -0.027808871120214462, -0.015462199226021767, -0.012906178832054138, -0.05213821306824684, -0.059860218316316605, -0.006859723012894392, 0.00806250050663948, -0.02325722575187683, -0.03570672124624252, 0.03434273973107338, -0.00032381495111621916, -0.003294646507129073, 0.04710244759917259, -0.020098017528653145, -0.02766181156039238, 0.01221395842730999, -0.0018055264372378588, -0.05982380732893944, -0.0534878671169281, -0.023972293362021446, -0.01965434104204178, 0.011324887163937092, -0.052942316979169846, -0.0575866624712944, 0.036595072597265244, -0.025406992062926292, -0.042769189924001694, -0.03248615562915802, -0.06239292025566101, 0.022946085780858994, -0.07446857541799545, 0.045456137508153915, 0.04289956018328667, -0.0640677884221077, 0.04253929480910301, -0.01878165267407894, 0.010729983448982239, 0.02063594199717045, 0.034585777670145035, 0.007571541704237461, -0.002638113684952259, -0.022290091961622238, 0.024142835289239883, 0.012882829643785954, 0.02323949709534645, 0.05505133047699928, 0.01669916696846485, 0.014248386956751347, -0.04796234890818596, 0.030280884355306625, -0.016538318246603012, -0.03510129451751709, -0.045533571392297745, 0.044695205986499786, -0.0630420669913292, 0.0451328381896019, 0.038190584629774094, 0.014972680248320103, -0.02200017124414444, -0.013280072249472141, -0.06078535318374634, -0.05630556493997574, -0.0039714849554002285, 0.00818959716707468, -0.02920435555279255, 0.0011672591790556908, 0.010816960595548153, -0.04747830703854561, 0.06173866614699364, 0.03402099385857582, -0.0037140222266316414, 0.04522727057337761, -0.05335754528641701, -0.03403284028172493, -0.01616578921675682, 0.06249472126364708, 0.0013504872331395745, 0.012800365686416626, 0.001762924948707223, -0.06279384344816208, 0.0458042174577713, 0.006440847180783749, -0.02746729552745819, -0.019651934504508972, -0.016637688502669334, 0.06520447880029678, -0.0035790158435702324, -0.0015418875264003873, 0.004834068473428488, -0.056234799325466156, 0.0013894359581172466, 0.024373916909098625, -0.049005743116140366, 0.02308736927807331, 0.017853042110800743, 0.016376951709389687, 0.01661340333521366, -0.0001841627963585779, 0.04451977461576462, 0.03769829496741295, -0.03703400865197182, 0.04527509957551956, 0.007592976558953524, -0.015618909150362015, -0.030387619510293007, -0.07257947325706482, -0.03972867876291275, 0.0627630203962326, 0.034772686660289764, -0.021264011040329933, 0.027446774765849113, -0.019582277163863182, 0.007142479997128248, -0.00034800401772372425, 0.02277243696153164, 0.04271780699491501, 0.0251249298453331, -0.016507701948285103, -0.02398778684437275, -0.014875998720526695, -0.014065567404031754, -0.006770266219973564, 0.0025242557749152184, 0.01873679831624031, 0.03163432702422142, 0.02660191059112549, -0.019803758710622787, 0.016043798997998238, -0.00014231781824491918, -0.04480627179145813, 0.03374907001852989, 0.017552413046360016, -0.01733112521469593, -0.06491344422101974, -0.007580384146422148, -0.0570964552462101, 0.0007808780064806342, -0.001058301073499024, 0.0027430590707808733, 0.01689920946955681, -0.004518759436905384, -0.04638683795928955, -0.005385845899581909, -0.02819322608411312, -0.03739764913916588, -0.0875529795885086, 0.0248526930809021, 0.033531807363033295, -0.02104056626558304, -0.024628736078739166, -0.03588278219103813, 0.02169874496757984, -0.007600527722388506, 0.009360241703689098, -0.017648419365286827, 0.0064229536801576614, -0.02404584176838398, -0.04271400719881058, 0.03030819445848465, -0.06799711287021637, -0.021077286452054977, -0.018952103331685066, 0.02091456949710846, 0.03251532465219498, -0.07853103429079056, 0.006581354420632124, 0.010376698337495327, -0.0418773777782917, -0.05127140134572983, 0.041178323328495026, 0.06495669484138489, 0.018880393356084824, 0.016233842819929123, 0.034607600420713425, -0.016174085438251495, -0.09997016936540604, 0.0053572761826217175, -0.0013777004787698388, 0.037623535841703415, 0.03036348521709442, -0.02105940505862236, -0.011284904554486275, -0.036195967346429825, -0.034661974757909775, 0.0554036870598793, 0.03516527637839317, -0.03247001767158508, -0.07460068166255951, -0.05637368559837341, 0.0016613762127235532, -0.060321539640426636, -0.0660109594464302, -0.07579395920038223, -0.008544414304196835, -0.002749088918790221, -0.060877297073602676, 0.0145682068541646, -0.023395031690597534, 0.006333924829959869, -0.04098476096987724, 0.0003315164358355105, 0.016350137069821358, 0.0017909902380779386, -0.06051270663738251, -0.037138987332582474, -0.04002322256565094, 0.020956547930836678, -0.04511558637022972, -0.012883121147751808, -0.03860892727971077, -0.042688705027103424, -0.009815473109483719, -0.00555325485765934, 0.046928003430366516, 0.05570650473237038, -0.06660767644643784, 0.013561046682298183, -0.004951357375830412, 0.0545114241540432, -0.034462060779333115, 0.03588395565748215, -0.03081408329308033, 0.004240631125867367, 0.010224227793514729, 0.017888467758893967, -0.045866284519433975, 0.013166357763111591, 0.02343129739165306, -0.013920399360358715, -0.006046678870916367, 0.034202542155981064, 0.015125378966331482, 0.019554011523723602, 0.040445249527692795, -0.06858374923467636, -0.019614793360233307, -0.027546321973204613, -0.009652460925281048, 0.0004984283586964011, 0.06310378015041351, 0.04589276388287544, -0.01934979297220707, -0.07291436940431595, -0.02393178641796112, -0.043826378881931305, 0.03494526073336601, -0.018326038494706154, -0.030403530225157738, -0.046249426901340485, -0.06155749037861824, -0.004118718206882477, -0.026085123419761658, 0.013257280923426151, -0.021072644740343094, 0.021774213761091232, -0.04359135776758194, -0.019060960039496422, 0.030736932530999184, -0.05797300487756729, -0.052323516458272934, 0.03528834506869316, 0.036413587629795074, 0.016318658366799355, -0.026048794388771057, -0.053735457360744476, -0.024778885766863823, 0.03494676575064659, -0.018324296921491623, -0.022646596655249596, -0.009661148302257061, -0.013277796097099781, -0.06987877935171127, 0.008863532915711403, -0.028575455769896507, 0.03636361286044121, -0.008236601017415524, -0.07154415547847748, -0.0036467115860432386, -0.037920624017715454, -0.035411179065704346, -0.05043625459074974, -0.010382111184298992, -0.018399439752101898, -0.062407903373241425, -0.04503468796610832, 0.06638462096452713, 0.0647069439291954, 0.02805476076900959, -0.04825226217508316, -0.027486208826303482, -0.011752577498555183, -0.02536635845899582, -0.023700475692749023, 0.06698287278413773, 0.02535538747906685, -0.06614738702774048, 0.011234263889491558, -0.054305609315633774, 0.029772527515888214, 0.023623699322342873, 0.024623513221740723, -0.006535602267831564, 0.014844739809632301, -0.004977355245500803, -0.035146865993738174, -0.006829089485108852, 0.0392625629901886, 0.056954044848680496, -0.019778858870267868, 0.01701207458972931, 0.03787340223789215, 0.0029666738118976355, 0.03632710129022598, 0.015644093975424767, -0.03096061944961548, 0.013315783813595772, 0.07520830631256104, -0.050835009664297104, -0.03058614768087864, -0.04068249836564064, -0.04637907072901726, -0.04476374015212059, 0.04329335317015648, 0.0026554791256785393, 0.04832505062222481, 0.035153377801179886, 0.02606097422540188, 0.00952945277094841, -0.011703039519488811, 0.07711368799209595, -0.05120350047945976, -0.004079960752278566, 0.022274624556303024, 0.0030720795039087534, -0.0018663783557713032, -0.050202202051877975, 0.0123455123975873, 0.00008841325325192884, -0.03696571663022041, 0.019018812105059624, -0.056533899158239365, -0.004208160098642111, 0.006368849892169237, 0.03476099297404289, 0.035281483083963394, 0.05221160873770714, 0.0037648531142622232, 0.01319948211312294, 0.034282490611076355, 0.03753088042140007, -0.04329254478216171, -0.019871851429343224, 0.02744193747639656, -0.0009300398523919284, -0.013572248630225658, 0.0017608355265110731, 0.002008236013352871, -0.03645441681146622, 0.011200875043869019, -0.0038475445471704006, 0.0017882437678053975, -0.02840425819158554, -0.07493352144956589, 0.01879597082734108, -0.05293089523911476, 0.060822661966085434, -0.013504624366760254, -0.008610800839960575, 0.06624999642372131, 0.011151890270411968, 0.012623678892850876, -0.04537821188569069, -0.027356788516044617, -0.030956510454416275, -0.053329914808273315, 0.025748753920197487, -0.019260158762335777, 0.01946219615638256, -0.05330187827348709, 0.032856617122888565, -0.020752329379320145, 0.026029057800769806, -0.05097044259309769, 0.023208104074001312, -0.0032962504774332047, 0.04751782491803169, 0.022179219871759415, 0.018390566110610962, 0.006117778830230236, -0.02583998627960682, 0.010842152871191502, -0.01083007175475359, 0.05051963031291962, -0.003042171709239483, -0.04394384101033211, 0.050947777926921844, -0.029271988198161125, -0.06384984403848648, -0.030121654272079468, 0.017257193103432655, 0.06202603504061699, -0.06791680306196213, -0.031052159145474434, 0.03236649930477142, 0.0348341166973114, -0.02781868726015091, -0.04813158139586449, -0.030063709244132042, -0.03521305322647095, -0.06383565813302994, -0.0000042414339986862615, -0.030294140800833702, -0.02668622136116028, -0.01923651061952114, 0.03374428302049637, 0.024639829993247986, 0.016918625682592392, 0.04246867820620537, 0.049021702259778976, 0.02812277339398861, 0.04888104647397995, -0.014079054817557335, -0.026841703802347183, -0.039477307349443436, 0.03724706918001175, 0.040033966302871704, -0.03257095441222191, -0.02544071152806282, 0.013189752586185932, -0.04605972021818161, 0.02145719714462757, -0.07252857834100723, 0.006928580813109875, 0.0549609437584877, -0.011619613505899906, -0.009079935029149055, 0.003430816577747464, -0.009555204771459103, 0.02418924868106842, -0.03740962967276573, 0.03579248487949371, 0.02833922579884529, -0.001980147324502468, 0.03862373158335686, 0.03149699419736862, -0.07253233343362808, -0.017756301909685135, 0.023749422281980515, 0.01330562960356474, -0.04164007306098938, -0.024615028873085976, 0.015249599702656269, -0.04903417453169823, -0.010241667740046978, 0.01551989745348692, 0.029125887900590897, -0.023348551243543625, -0.04814743250608444, 0.015432849526405334, 0.006601568311452866, -0.02465302310883999, 0.04517756402492523, -0.057442642748355865, -0.058824874460697174, 0.021779246628284454, 0.005530392751097679, -0.014486455358564854, 0.04653460532426834, 0.033800121396780014, -0.008362273685634136, -0.012406587600708008, -0.05352584645152092, -0.06809766590595245, 0.031183889135718346, -0.08189025521278381, 0.03654680773615837, -0.036014411598443985, 0.02996143512427807, 0.04927143454551697, 0.03137383982539177, -0.030866455286741257, -0.06354613602161407, -0.019922155886888504, -0.004642471671104431, 0.04296039789915085, -0.015180417336523533, 0.029344500973820686, 0.006116911303251982, 0.048030197620391846, -0.004398495890200138, -0.042804840952157974, -0.018335722386837006, -0.0071643199771642685, -0.043678924441337585, 0.0018696108600124717, 0.018805960193276405, -0.01090548187494278, -0.04984715208411217, 0.009728680364787579, 0.0339825302362442, -0.03752663731575012, 0.04716726392507553, 0.06528190523386002, -0.038558367639780045, 0.016273580491542816, -0.008580395020544529, -0.002199276117607951, -0.015379030257463455, -0.0022520089987665415, 0.0798887386918068, -0.08194912225008011, 0.019121017307043076, -0.04078173637390137, -0.038046643137931824, 0.03466351330280304, -0.016784196719527245, -0.006272056605666876, 0.009957698173820972, -0.013326720334589481, -0.05806474760174751, 0.01686824858188629, -0.011830600909888744, -0.06352615356445312, -0.03368336334824562, 0.007419035769999027, -0.05897793173789978, -0.0009193915757350624, 0.009111315943300724, -0.012173742987215519, -0.06691882759332657, 0.013683099299669266, -0.026379747316241264, -0.06722524762153625, -0.00770794739946723, 0.08700080215930939, 0.05808274447917938, -0.03541559725999832, -0.01666652224957943, 0.014616346918046474, -0.010701301507651806, 0.022605670616030693, -0.019414501264691353, 0.018904000520706177, -0.023872854188084602, 0.04501716047525406, -0.019161716103553772, -0.027141446247696877, -0.019462941214442253, 0.04742896929383278, -0.06855261325836182, -0.000766737328376621, -0.002348484005779028, 0.013156816363334656, 0.026143379509449005, -0.02404245175421238, -0.05336422473192215, 0.03294971585273743, -0.0046819280833005905, 0.0214134082198143, -0.0016670312033966184, 0.0047425925731658936, -0.04084593430161476, 0.04729051515460014, -0.0024674797896295786, -0.05596225708723068, 0.03396962583065033, -0.026346245780587196, -0.051995277404785156, 0.04830004274845123, -0.04132254049181938, -0.02339266985654831, 0.023492533713579178, 0.027986539527773857, 0.01302340067923069, 0.02816738933324814, -0.0334286093711853, 0.02217080630362034, -0.041429899632930756, -0.03430018201470375, 0.021633101627230644, 0.032982487231492996, 0.012615595012903214, -0.00600728765130043, 0.0408024862408638, -0.04188667982816696, 0.02732834778726101, -0.00800648145377636, -0.0272472333163023, 0.0400894470512867, -0.02467207983136177, -0.04541422426700592, -0.01083853468298912, -0.004361874423921108, -0.0567595511674881, 0.027614792808890343, 0.024779967963695526, -0.0027570503298193216, -0.08049038797616959, -0.015880651772022247, -0.03488412871956825, -0.03956357389688492, 0.03712516278028488, 0.008556438609957695, 0.03428475558757782, -0.05056650564074516, 0.0642116442322731, 0.08148467540740967, 0.01713133044540882, -0.014581072144210339, -0.026248497888445854, -0.011186194606125355, 0.023073455318808556, 0.022260036319494247, -0.0313163660466671, -0.038152217864990234, -0.06778139621019363, -0.05473155900835991, 0.03730183467268944, 0.011828339658677578, -0.006906788796186447, -0.04040754958987236, -0.06496956199407578, 0.05285828188061714, 0.04330051690340042, 0.024464963003993034, -0.06369978934526443, 0.03704680874943733, 0.004128086380660534, 0.007566450629383326, 0.0007479808409698308, -0.0024942560121417046, -0.04808706417679787, 0.002967167878523469, -0.08168789744377136, 0.02543499320745468, -0.027810968458652496, 0.06481810659170151, -0.021197857335209846, 0.0253299493342638, -0.06044572964310646, -0.01877073384821415, 0.04318232461810112, 0.014550931751728058, -0.028563566505908966, 0.004218732006847858, 0.014165227301418781, -0.007576463744044304, -0.06260222941637039, -0.03662504628300667, 0.02133662812411785, -0.03905123472213745, -0.02901051938533783, 0.028831282630562782, 0.05973042920231819, -0.00387565977871418, 0.04469979926943779, -0.007870190776884556, -0.016424674540758133, 0.011862864717841148, -0.041360557079315186, 0.04945024475455284, -0.01626984402537346, -0.022397160530090332, 0.04261387512087822, -0.009127316996455193, -0.015185235999524593, 0.037579841911792755, 0.0018557632574811578, -0.023494701832532883, -0.05675856024026871, -0.007352685555815697, 0.019841386005282402, 0.01857905089855194, 0.009629234671592712, 0.07859798520803452, -0.06416189670562744, 0.01692967489361763, -0.012447023764252663, -0.014247085899114609, -0.05352647230029106, 0.018894711509346962, -0.005577628966420889, -0.06589692085981369, -0.043648045510053635, -0.08349785953760147, 0.0533175989985466, -0.04294753447175026, -0.030818374827504158, -0.002468002960085869, 0.02584049478173256, -0.05731593072414398, -0.01972310245037079, -0.050602518022060394, -0.018102198839187622, -0.018005233258008957, -0.07356356084346771, -0.008306254632771015, 0.013302701525390148, 0.040435463190078735, -0.005759130232036114, 0.032918449491262436, 0.03759743645787239, 0.0033605822827667, 0.029218461364507675, -0.012738329358398914, -0.02153771184384823, -0.006417063530534506, -0.0416853241622448, -0.007615098264068365, 0.00939211342483759, 0.008952726610004902, -0.06072402000427246, 0.01357559859752655, 0.011503642424941063, 0.043463218957185745, -0.012412261217832565, -0.011568781919777393, -0.021412551403045654, -0.05821424350142479, -0.04724981263279915, 0.01764874905347824, 0.013673719950020313, -0.020408324897289276, 0.06098177284002304, -0.003012183355167508, -0.022185007110238075, -0.07864375412464142 ]
We present a highly efficient workflow for designing semiconductor structures with specific physical properties, which can be utilized for a range of applications, including photocatalytic water splitting. Our algorithm generates candidate structures composed of earth-abundant elements that exhibit optimal light-trapping, high efficiency in \ce{H2} and/or \ce{O2} production, and resistance to reduction and oxidation in aqueous media. To achieve this, we use an ionic translation model trained on the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database (ICSD) to predict over thirty thousand undiscovered semiconductor compositions. These predictions are then screened for redox stability under Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER) or Oxygen Evolution Reaction (OER) conditions before generating thermodynamically stable crystal structures and calculating accurate band gap values for the compounds. Our approach results in the identification of dozens of promising semiconductor candidates with ideal properties for artificial photosynthesis, offering a significant advancement toward the conversion of sunlight into chemical fuels.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00118v1
[ -0.043348293751478195, -0.05256877467036247, 0.0021456549875438213, -0.027732381597161293, -0.021806219592690468, -0.0718703642487526, -0.005876024253666401, 0.022289181128144264, 0.022869834676384926, -0.05042378976941109, 0.005665406119078398, -0.031087547540664673, -0.03791332244873047, -0.03617751970887184, -0.03272351250052452, 0.06099672242999077, 0.07386284321546555, 0.04162914678454399, -0.0358256995677948, 0.03242124617099762, 0.02362699620425701, 0.019770793616771698, -0.03958602249622345, -0.007885638624429703, 0.008572608232498169, -0.0056333113461732864, -0.0329795777797699, 0.04983579367399216, -0.025738948956131935, -0.009485472925007343, 0.04262718930840492, -0.018813027068972588, 0.011164517141878605, -0.04348214715719223, -0.004258079454302788, -0.016632741317152977, -0.01260767038911581, 0.04517060145735741, 0.03743705525994301, -0.04170907288789749, 0.022765444591641426, -0.046710364520549774, -0.035597700625658035, -0.032721925526857376, 0.034305404871702194, -0.037480831146240234, -0.047312453389167786, -0.011755155399441719, -0.06667318940162659, -0.053960904479026794, 0.009954269044101238, 0.013134692795574665, -0.050998274236917496, 0.04676526039838791, -0.05232207477092743, -0.001055035856552422, -0.01855902373790741, -0.0361059308052063, -0.009113715961575508, 0.015406484715640545, 0.004504818003624678, -0.045608483254909515, 0.015596192330121994, 0.01718830317258835, -0.034051503986120224, 0.02013474516570568, -0.04403659328818321, -0.03567104414105415, -0.04435812681913376, -0.05083689093589783, -0.012883316725492477, -0.05756261199712753, -0.004472864326089621, -0.009040790610015392, -0.04820052534341812, -0.04001306742429733, -0.04161761328577995, -0.009083977900445461, 0.03284027799963951, 0.036376189440488815, -0.06276518851518631, -0.007174831815063953, 0.032707925885915756, 0.05694364756345749, 0.043401703238487244, 0.003553596790879965, 0.030853290110826492, -0.015871616080403328, -0.03707065433263779, 0.0003020703443326056, 0.056958459317684174, 0.0013503669761121273, -0.05807152017951012, 0.05659022554755211, 0.04317294433712959, -0.022244682535529137, 0.049988798797130585, 0.03535221144556999, 0.01892591081559658, -0.02609550580382347, -0.02551129087805748, -0.001112670637667179, -0.01536949910223484, 0.027745919302105904, -0.004107339307665825, -0.0244771558791399, 0.006738574244081974, -0.008862516842782497, -0.05608334019780159, -0.05531833693385124, -0.021865326911211014, -0.024921361356973648, 0.02472452074289322, -0.05335584282875061, -0.06762568652629852, -0.0733146071434021, 0.01908724009990692, -0.04197383299469948, -0.008338093757629395, 0.03990975767374039, -0.004048233386129141, 0.035067442804574966, 0.04754112288355827, -0.027027254924178123, -0.04861045628786087, 0.008673123084008694, 0.06943438202142715, -0.03867267072200775, -0.0011167459888383746, -0.020316239446401596, -0.042069025337696075, 0.06542102247476578, 0.016548369079828262, -0.06779447197914124, 0.035709042102098465, -0.029962047934532166, 0.03097599372267723, 0.007898290641605854, 0.0006898937281221151, 0.015941573306918144, -0.04509757459163666, -0.05553843453526497, -0.0033275659661740065, -0.043794937431812286, -0.016408326104283333, 0.059605520218610764, -0.02546629123389721, -0.0022253270726650953, 0.052875399589538574, 0.0278742928057909, -0.02195187844336033, 0.02162189595401287, 0.023151660338044167, 0.023221725597977638, 0.02637697197496891, -0.059268753975629807, 0.02105214074254036, 0.009576722979545593, -0.04806693270802498, 0.01931849494576454, -0.022652367129921913, -0.04775006324052811, 0.022270845249295235, 0.004420232027769089, -0.0063270749524235725, -0.025147220119833946, -0.02095555141568184, -0.032117027789354324, -0.02618020959198475, -0.02393626794219017, -0.015366248786449432, -0.020860103890299797, -0.012359092012047768, -0.05236637219786644, -0.03667164966464043, -0.011081108823418617, 0.020916517823934555, -0.02508220449090004, -0.051141299307346344, 0.03169949725270271, -0.05094407871365547, -0.011071426793932915, 0.030353963375091553, 0.011371306143701077, -0.04863083362579346, -0.02705536223948002, -0.07785511761903763, 0.018930789083242416, -0.02027100697159767, -0.0393461249768734, -0.044906869530677795, -0.03625698760151863, 0.022952893748879433, -0.04193519055843353, -0.024092311039566994, -0.03262468799948692, 0.01727808453142643, -0.01455068401992321, -0.027356980368494987, 0.019709553569555283, -0.06475081294775009, 0.03415359929203987, -0.019821977242827415, -0.013945802114903927, 0.02009298838675022, -0.06981156766414642, -0.01179805863648653, 0.033066362142562866, -0.0528017096221447, -0.019968634471297264, 0.04845493286848068, 0.03369978070259094, 0.04705796018242836, 0.032157909125089645, 0.021471986547112465, -0.047100309282541275, -0.08447018265724182, 0.0515168197453022, -0.01843900978565216, -0.03286560997366905, 0.014426887966692448, -0.0010138909565284848, 0.028519826009869576, -0.033037010580301285, -0.018935512751340866, 0.059046272188425064, 0.06870964169502258, -0.05172955244779587, -0.04737706109881401, -0.009321673773229122, -0.010671736672520638, -0.009691077284514904, -0.06662755459547043, -0.0672086700797081, 0.005218864884227514, -0.005588654428720474, -0.007475706283003092, -0.02841268852353096, -0.06450068205595016, -0.007842072285711765, -0.019661957398056984, -0.03375077247619629, 0.023433929309248924, -0.007971596904098988, -0.07161299139261246, -0.05666033551096916, -0.059071529656648636, 0.02856464311480522, -0.03651909530162811, -0.01028179656714201, -0.02714403346180916, -0.06223473325371742, -0.03116399049758911, 0.048261914402246475, 0.0025858113076537848, 0.050512056797742844, -0.0035176544915884733, 0.02594550885260105, -0.0397978238761425, 0.04264276102185249, -0.03084457293152809, 0.03876025229692459, -0.030726280063390732, -0.01761111058294773, 0.02428453415632248, 0.022245235741138458, -0.026321664452552795, -0.0582602359354496, 0.004404150880873203, -0.017077988013625145, -0.01178940199315548, 0.04709811136126518, 0.012818689458072186, 0.030400371178984642, -0.006773526780307293, -0.003357924520969391, 0.00020615245739463717, -0.022648056969046593, 0.04238284379243851, 0.01824965700507164, 0.02840420976281166, 0.03966305032372475, 0.028786418959498405, -0.07742586731910706, -0.04630744829773903, -0.05146397650241852, 0.03350040316581726, -0.02382822521030903, -0.04858878627419472, -0.04811371862888336, -0.033695973455905914, -0.024245556443929672, -0.006127904634922743, -0.009620532393455505, 0.0028174014296382666, -0.028931116685271263, -0.03819558396935463, 0.008524814620614052, 0.03749354928731918, -0.02238670364022255, -0.07167122513055801, 0.014612708240747452, 0.03626682236790657, 0.0011440074304118752, -0.04993259161710739, -0.028988882899284363, -0.06885144859552383, -0.0008100278209894896, -0.006265949923545122, -0.02456481195986271, -0.049985457211732864, 0.003179407911375165, -0.05947589874267578, 0.00980314426124096, 0.003038231283426285, 0.0632290169596672, 0.035035111010074615, 0.013219599612057209, -0.0046455212868750095, -0.005890379659831524, -0.029342858120799065, -0.02846663072705269, 0.011668896302580833, 0.0023644189350306988, -0.05401225760579109, -0.05199090763926506, 0.007355618290603161, 0.06143505871295929, -0.02851998060941696, 0.01905108615756035, -0.06644157320261002, 0.002765126060694456, -0.016331594437360764, 0.0020562363788485527, 0.0554305762052536, 0.016465503722429276, -0.048138976097106934, -0.02034809999167919, -0.018247144296765327, -0.0028352097142487764, -0.016393331810832024, 0.011055606417357922, 0.03443014621734619, 0.012774544768035412, 0.02022271603345871, -0.07238621264696121, 0.045716140419244766, 0.03283204138278961, 0.052662286907434464, 0.013272397220134735, -0.04157443344593048, -0.029905641451478004, -0.030795296654105186, 0.044771235436201096, -0.028763547539711, 0.0486910305917263, -0.0139012411236763, 0.058724962174892426, -0.05671990290284157, -0.011649091728031635, -0.03321699798107147, -0.0618281289935112, -0.04698088392615318, -0.003235122188925743, 0.024801351130008698, 0.031323060393333435, 0.0032334227580577135, -0.03585537523031235, 0.016826149076223373, 0.031498465687036514, 0.05219500511884689, 0.013661522418260574, -0.05851009488105774, 0.01795036904513836, -0.06861316412687302, 0.03623555228114128, -0.007362850476056337, 0.024353206157684326, -0.03276263177394867, -0.03342359885573387, 0.006496111862361431, -0.050129108130931854, 0.023802198469638824, 0.06257516145706177, -0.035211991518735886, 0.026834512129426003, 0.04676016792654991, 0.03529107943177223, 0.023379258811473846, -0.042402829974889755, -0.018328137695789337, -0.007432872895151377, -0.0016020339680835605, -0.00737445754930377, -0.01885957643389702, -0.05050678923726082, -0.05236727371811867, 0.007270447909832001, 0.001634684158489108, -0.013046728447079659, 0.019571367651224136, -0.019742121919989586, -0.008533555082976818, -0.07233072817325592, -0.03539131581783295, -0.056384626775979996, 0.018907036632299423, 0.0360841378569603, -0.032091643661260605, 0.05615910515189171, -0.0427987314760685, 0.01872739940881729, -0.06165144965052605, -0.0009041934972628951, -0.02497340738773346, -0.0684342086315155, -0.02351955883204937, -0.06545927375555038, 0.013319665566086769, -0.041482701897621155, -0.02434512786567211, -0.027564967051148415, 0.00017282621411141008, -0.06336740404367447, 0.02968433126807213, -0.030749434605240822, -0.027961203828454018, 0.04370175302028656, 0.019884219393134117, 0.03248723968863487, -0.036696434020996094, 0.036102522164583206, -0.03980208933353424, -0.012380072847008705, 0.055785760283470154, -0.05216273292899132, 0.03802026808261871, -0.029358835890889168, -0.05187040939927101, 0.024345245212316513, 0.015295740216970444, 0.03717955946922302, -0.04736127704381943, -0.025045664981007576, -0.0275727491825819, 0.04539556801319122, -0.018653525039553642, -0.05655943229794502, -0.007774752099066973, -0.04943310469388962, -0.06862620264291763, -0.020201701670885086, 0.04427827149629593, -0.04646303132176399, -0.037998493760824203, -0.008627021685242653, 0.05307159200310707, -0.049870800226926804, -0.014929035678505898, 0.06640461832284927, 0.004055963363498449, -0.005852033384144306, -0.0740872398018837, -0.018968490883708, -0.07368012517690659, -0.014512501657009125, -0.030437923967838287, -0.025339988991618156, -0.045274317264556885, 0.012986776418983936, 0.014108431525528431, 0.030878055840730667, -0.08190175890922546, 0.005483188200742006, 0.011347819119691849, -0.0037838194984942675, -0.02774147130548954, -0.013096033595502377, 0.05763429403305054, 0.02676793746650219, -0.020408840849995613, -0.01653393544256687, 0.01700390875339508, -0.04858376458287239, -0.025960318744182587, 0.007787365932017565, -0.033236585557460785, 0.022650644183158875, 0.0537029504776001, 0.0007282061851583421, -0.05271060764789581, -0.016369249671697617, 0.03657146170735359, 0.0011111900676041842, -0.002598242135718465, 0.0046530538238584995, 0.040914032608270645, -0.04506262019276619, -0.04157619923353195, -0.02535657025873661, 0.020427187904715538, -0.028976943343877792, 0.0037548828404396772, -0.05588666349649429, 0.014643540605902672, 0.035429421812295914, 0.027296103537082672, 0.01644846796989441, 0.038473404943943024, -0.003865969367325306, 0.01714947447180748, -0.00009431453509023413, -0.005013594403862953, -0.05603557080030441, 0.004407844971865416, -0.07471010833978653, 0.02319253422319889, -0.017169930040836334, 0.008599434979259968, 0.052602075040340424, 0.06235538795590401, -0.007392662577331066, -0.06180749088525772, -0.006674760952591896, -0.04380882531404495, 0.024034757167100906, -0.030815601348876953, -0.007218861486762762, 0.01072625070810318, -0.016538457944989204, 0.0011700264876708388, -0.04247028008103371, 0.010599563829600811, 0.0006103393388912082, -0.048110801726579666, -0.050833117216825485, 0.009494795463979244, -0.0035806994419544935, -0.05656517669558525, 0.041870854794979095, 0.038514070212841034, -0.05774063244462013, 0.046037204563617706, 0.044416893273591995, -0.03116767480969429, 0.0442463643848896, -0.039595019072294235, 0.0007856262964196503, -0.017433257773518562, 0.02097816951572895, 0.06612986326217651, -0.07646297663450241, -0.02384018898010254, -0.06705141067504883, -0.009983629919588566, 0.01652456447482109, -0.05984199047088623, 0.02295970544219017, -0.023466037586331367, -0.029659440740942955, -0.04618658497929573, 0.013309753499925137, -0.004185874946415424, -0.06720674782991409, 0.019640441983938217, 0.014699069783091545, -0.029904337599873543, -0.002197190187871456, -0.006374145392328501, -0.013084078207612038, -0.029995089396834373, 0.05147440731525421, -0.02316264621913433, -0.021009888499975204, -0.03349631652235985, 0.06572407484054565, 0.07271117717027664, 0.010145893320441246, -0.000591040588915348, -0.004359342157840729, -0.03781573846936226, -0.020808376371860504, -0.030770355835556984, -0.06781892478466034, 0.004366836044937372, 0.04228490963578224, 0.004487692844122648, -0.039549876004457474, -0.05324147269129753, 0.013287858106195927, -0.023767245933413506, 0.03861291706562042, 0.022510895505547523, -0.010783058591187, 0.002634024014696479, -0.03547228127717972, -0.0052169496193528175, -0.01923300139605999, -0.0354653000831604, -0.0055426317267119884, 0.01820254698395729, -0.024681221693754196, -0.021108608692884445, 0.01003799494355917, 0.03728308156132698, -0.04983771592378616, -0.0037376927211880684, -0.03603711351752281, -0.07024497538805008, 0.018530528992414474, -0.05669373273849487, -0.02787625975906849, 0.014496508054435253, 0.04774164408445358, 0.028440846130251884, 0.04540494456887245, 0.0031140504870563745, -0.008984806947410107, -0.004352107644081116, -0.04547112062573433, 0.0014600895810872316, 0.029619235545396805, -0.009123746305704117, -0.03396017104387283, 0.06768694519996643, -0.03056819923222065, -0.017425665631890297, -0.02818710170686245, -0.013082263059914112, -0.057298362255096436, -0.0019158887444064021, -0.029689868912100792, -0.015078716911375523, 0.005664134863764048, -0.04172123223543167, 0.014452150091528893, 0.03836389631032944, -0.06282159686088562, -0.043425191193819046, 0.015517473220825195, -0.05322421342134476, -0.006264168303459883, 0.019556257873773575, -0.003245584899559617, 0.05425424873828888, -0.04615965485572815, 0.06936297565698624, -0.016592256724834442, 0.03976516053080559, -0.0011582474689930677, -0.013427048921585083, -0.03143357113003731, 0.069236621260643, 0.036353327333927155, -0.058522891253232956, -0.03839877247810364, -0.0015565936919301748, -0.05388912186026573, -0.019112015143036842, 0.022110650315880775, 0.03479963168501854, -0.025840867310762405, -0.06634335219860077, 0.0676581859588623, 0.03201494738459587, -0.05188809707760811, -0.07915246486663818, -0.0033593818079680204, 0.013791042380034924, -0.02049189619719982, -0.009335814043879509, 0.01656840555369854, -0.05617956072092056, 0.0315091572701931, -0.07246440649032593, 0.01316589955240488, -0.016108548268675804, 0.06916388869285583, -0.009367660619318485, -0.032443273812532425, -0.0010995127959176898, -0.04424862936139107, -0.004170584492385387, 0.028331009671092033, -0.007135978899896145, 0.015950024127960205, -0.021162280812859535, 0.006904986221343279, -0.06238282471895218, -0.007167744915932417, 0.015898091718554497, -0.027246631681919098, 0.023120876401662827, 0.006986670661717653, 0.025663286447525024, -0.025091612711548805, 0.010296559892594814, 0.05246507376432419, -0.035873591899871826, 0.04656105116009712, -0.038844987750053406, 0.054591789841651917, -0.02982262521982193, -0.0731121227145195, 0.012451106682419777, -0.029510892927646637, 0.00814425852149725, -0.004184236284345388, 0.01937681809067726, 0.0012833671644330025, 0.003222458530217409, -0.03431122750043869, -0.028713712468743324, 0.021809276193380356, 0.0025802841410040855, 0.06268218159675598, -0.06281857937574387, 0.03490627929568291, -0.030442699790000916, -0.04033855348825455, 0.016927963122725487, 0.06514276564121246, 0.04125728830695152, -0.02414550818502903, -0.04245921969413757, -0.03476791828870773, -0.01973510906100273, -0.00254769972525537, 0.04871605709195137, -0.016734961420297623, 0.0657193660736084, -0.0756714940071106, -0.03728652000427246, -0.03754527494311333, -0.012148096226155758, -0.01853083074092865, -0.03115629404783249, -0.009810781106352806, 0.004270908422768116, 0.012484502047300339, 0.010567174293100834, -0.012010042555630207, 0.0005947820609435439, 0.042564909905195236, 0.024821657687425613, -0.018640363588929176, 0.028960106894373894, 0.024659274145960808, -0.032790981233119965, -0.01094758789986372, 0.05735088884830475, 0.003081841627135873, -0.047684989869594574, 0.0574069619178772, -0.02697734348475933, 0.008197085000574589, -0.048358507454395294, -0.019560500979423523, -0.04199909791350365, 0.003104881616309285, -0.035625260323286057, 0.03171354904770851, 0.02841491438448429, -0.029468292370438576, -0.004509188700467348, 0.036415718495845795, -0.050640713423490524, -0.06380520761013031 ]
Let $r$ be a positive integer, $N$ be a nonnegative integer and $\Omega \subset \mathbb{R}^{r}$ be a domain. Further, for all multi-indices $\alpha \in \mathbb{N}^{r}$, $|\alpha|\leq N$, let us consider the partial differential operator $D^{\alpha}$ defined by \[ D^{\alpha}= \frac{\partial^{|\alpha|}}{\partial x_{1}^{\alpha_{1}}\cdots \partial x_{r}^{\alpha_{r}}}, \] where $\alpha= (\alpha_{1}, \ldots, \alpha_{r})$. Here by definition we mean $D^{0}\equiv \mathrm{id}$. An easy computation shows that if $f, g\in \mathscr{C}^{N}(\Omega)$ and $\alpha \in \mathbb{N}^{r}, |\alpha|\leq N$, then we have \[ \tag{$\ast$} D^{\alpha}(f\cdot g) = \sum_{\beta\leq \alpha}\binom{\alpha}{\beta}D^{\beta}(f)\cdot D^{\alpha - \beta}(g). \] This paper is devoted to the study of identity $(\ast)$ in the space $\mathscr{C}(\Omega)$. More precisely, if $r$ is a positive integer, $N$ is a nonnegative integer and $\Omega \subset \mathbb{R}^{r}$ is a domain, then we describe those mappings $T_{\alpha} \colon \mathscr{C}(\Omega)\to \mathscr{C}(\Omega)$, $\alpha \in \mathbb{N}^{r}, |\alpha|\leq N$ that satisfy identity $(\ast)$ for all possible multi-indices $\alpha\in \mathbb{N}^{r}$, $|\alpha|\leq N$. Our main result says that if the domain is $\mathscr{C}(\Omega)$, then the mappings $T_{\alpha}$ are of a rather special form. Related results in the space $\mathscr{C}^{N}(\Omega)$ are also presented.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03572v1
[ -0.05796562135219574, -0.025591185316443443, 0.0328209213912487, 0.014584289863705635, -0.003268912900239229, -0.025254277512431145, -0.041227586567401886, -0.015625007450580597, -0.056127678602933884, -0.034667208790779114, -0.020693719387054443, -0.056830015033483505, -0.010047417134046555, -0.008609678596258163, -0.02549411915242672, -0.04530206695199013, 0.022844258695840836, 0.05390011519193649, 0.01602061465382576, 0.03297320380806923, -0.010765217244625092, -0.053409747779369354, -0.009574636816978455, 0.062283556908369064, 0.03758171200752258, -0.0029496438801288605, -0.014548687264323235, -0.04286559298634529, -0.01501149870455265, -0.04647726193070412, 0.04478490352630615, -0.04009546339511871, 0.050969190895557404, -0.038719695061445236, 0.018215302377939224, 0.0533590093255043, -0.02402604930102825, 0.023198934271931648, -0.011574240401387215, -0.03316333144903183, 0.020716428756713867, -0.03896589204668999, -0.021226666867733, -0.06217886134982109, -0.026443855836987495, -0.02469324693083763, -0.03625215217471123, -0.02239239402115345, -0.026293372735381126, -0.049415770918130875, 0.008832625113427639, -0.027607571333646774, -0.01199124101549387, 0.0242707971483469, -0.009443680755794048, 0.016001222655177116, 0.03460896387696266, -0.044335056096315384, -0.04953089356422424, -0.028116809204220772, 0.019112087786197662, -0.05097366124391556, -0.04077822342514992, -0.030317356809973717, -0.008382642641663551, 0.0023556468077003956, -0.03843560442328453, -0.03407362103462219, -0.015330187976360321, 0.006706359330564737, -0.034931037575006485, -0.03905490040779114, 0.03386860713362694, 0.033089205622673035, -0.06637468189001083, 0.05311911925673485, 0.03586921840906143, 0.03090226836502552, -0.02685311809182167, 0.025979546830058098, -0.030530806630849838, -0.0523015521466732, -0.0502735935151577, -0.02827470935881138, -0.007012116722762585, -0.026743825525045395, 0.05817199498414993, -0.054111357778310776, 0.04564366117119789, -0.04973871633410454, -0.034557923674583435, -0.04294482246041298, -0.06088230386376381, -0.04899546876549721, -0.021057799458503723, -0.06167351081967354, 0.013196948915719986, -0.0010634618811309338, -0.004130864515900612, -0.030348852276802063, 0.02560744248330593, -0.04936562478542328, -0.029126809909939766, -0.033112332224845886, 0.009474309161305428, -0.04465508460998535, -0.039954233914613724, -0.041856128722429276, -0.06460634618997574, 0.05919091776013374, -0.014868286438286304, 0.005534691270440817, -0.04040855914354324, -0.04907696694135666, -0.046865712851285934, -0.05769883841276169, 0.028082653880119324, 0.036140765994787216, 0.02632860466837883, 0.000445236248197034, -0.010013926774263382, -0.039061952382326126, -0.011985852383077145, -0.033690471202135086, -0.03269101306796074, -0.05166534334421158, 0.04992510378360748, 0.009125921875238419, 0.004623363260179758, 0.030940653756260872, -0.016350213438272476, -0.03478190675377846, 0.05026393383741379, -0.041879527270793915, 0.028610460460186005, 0.022188138216733932, -0.04166397824883461, -0.06001783534884453, -0.04051991552114487, 0.005274476017802954, -0.012811031192541122, -0.060255084186792374, 0.02247798815369606, 0.0470610074698925, 0.0025447073858231306, 0.04545383155345917, -0.06504910439252853, 0.0477818138897419, 0.00029534526402130723, 0.03958434239029884, -0.030467072501778603, 0.05787742882966995, 0.020414305850863457, -0.017863279208540916, -0.018876943737268448, -0.009421813301742077, 0.026949502527713776, -0.028128838166594505, -0.05475557595491409, -0.010723547078669071, 0.04293868690729141, -0.05231904610991478, -0.046197354793548584, 0.02168777585029602, 0.0039024397265166044, 0.054719336330890656, -0.00021852916688658297, -0.0000222094968194142, 0.00431088637560606, 0.028843702748417854, -0.05826953426003456, -0.056161604821681976, -0.002665437525138259, -0.059918854385614395, -0.03705765679478645, -0.04374562203884125, -0.03836090490221977, -0.044185247272253036, -0.01613805443048477, -0.018590833991765976, -0.02317766286432743, -0.055414874106645584, -0.006927717011421919, 0.017660509794950485, -0.05938887968659401, 0.028292590752243996, -0.029140569269657135, 0.02538451924920082, 0.022196585312485695, 0.04678316041827202, -0.021601058542728424, -0.026696931570768356, -0.008243844844400883, -0.013288155198097229, -0.056807953864336014, 0.008334158919751644, -0.024698995053768158, -0.06157199665904045, -0.03157272934913635, -0.005036928690969944, -0.04606034234166145, -0.047343384474515915, -0.05502869933843613, 0.04813157021999359, -0.010908725671470165, -0.04629866033792496, 0.02469470538198948, 0.031597185879945755, -0.017716513946652412, -0.06583242863416672, 0.06290557980537415, -0.017274202778935432, -0.02846921980381012, -0.02205650508403778, -0.044956695288419724, -0.04765556752681732, -0.06890027970075607, 0.0635545551776886, 0.020787259563803673, -0.03247180953621864, 0.0325661338865757, -0.028466394171118736, 0.01026841625571251, -0.05684475600719452, -0.0425943098962307, 0.0030360103119164705, -0.004888706840574741, -0.006294405087828636, -0.0579773373901844, -0.047743815928697586, -0.019107108935713768, -0.062420401722192764, -0.019465913996100426, -0.05986199527978897, 0.0002749496197793633, -0.017756735906004906, 0.015254798345267773, 0.037149105221033096, -0.044020287692546844, 0.025586510077118874, -0.05983920022845268, 0.00048010790487751365, 0.03548114374279976, 0.01919401064515114, -0.03747417777776718, -0.05013176053762436, -0.028828216716647148, -0.01896919123828411, -0.026184044778347015, 0.017480889335274696, -0.019162001088261604, -0.00394449383020401, -0.035476215183734894, -0.004336093552410603, 0.02120842970907688, 0.009254834614694118, -0.04178164526820183, 0.018474256619811058, -0.03534736856818199, 0.036984607577323914, 0.03117830865085125, -0.017860906198620796, 0.03075595013797283, -0.050400082021951675, -0.021960288286209106, -0.024794667959213257, -0.05971914902329445, -0.03773227706551552, 0.03250114247202873, 0.040198322385549545, -0.038154810667037964, -0.023830117657780647, 0.040998201817274094, -0.03937126696109772, -0.04701163247227669, -0.021774038672447205, -0.03813822939991951, 0.029646439477801323, 0.05868745967745781, -0.03887936472892761, -0.004918851889669895, 0.004848604090511799, -0.03927534446120262, -0.06685018539428711, -0.047402869910001755, 0.03256281465291977, -0.023183420300483704, -0.023835118860006332, -0.052303142845630646, -0.03516358882188797, -0.04578053951263428, -0.0065639326348900795, -0.06159530207514763, -0.036325275897979736, -0.05551426485180855, -0.06028037890791893, -0.04885450750589371, -0.012985833920538425, 0.023602573201060295, -0.06503215432167053, -0.042409032583236694, -0.013052674941718578, -0.04698841646313667, 0.03868875280022621, -0.0181538425385952, -0.058650363236665726, -0.05298161134123802, 0.02743305079638958, -0.05033501610159874, 0.029342662543058395, -0.05548518896102905, 0.009929782710969448, -0.05656985193490982, -0.05008459836244583, 0.01803089678287506, -0.03495871648192406, -0.018509678542613983, -0.04693155735731125, 0.007574060466140509, 0.03609854727983475, 0.014327242970466614, -0.028925687074661255, 0.021555759012699127, -0.037233877927064896, 0.017047075554728508, -0.02670564129948616, 0.004405615385621786, 0.0246718879789114, -0.013732245191931725, -0.04634063318371773, -0.054520655423402786, -0.03492432087659836, 0.030368054285645485, -0.028695212677121162, 0.023531489074230194, 0.03604304790496826, 0.011390809901058674, -0.010086966678500175, -0.05002417415380478, -0.030339965596795082, -0.016730867326259613, 0.03375871106982231, -0.01721750944852829, -0.01586255431175232, -0.006537662353366613, -0.06688059121370316, 0.05811493471264839, 0.040453262627124786, 0.03172752633690834, -0.01967083476483822, -0.025819523259997368, 0.04449589177966118, 0.00486185634508729, -0.02232435718178749, -0.03581007570028305, 0.03565627336502075, 0.04200682044029236, -0.016173703595995903, 0.00029215123504400253, -0.05848114565014839, -0.016989439725875854, -0.039293330162763596, 0.0388900451362133, 0.04743215814232826, 0.0010240981355309486, 0.012446955777704716, 0.03518209233880043, -0.030748605728149414, 0.0023390285205096006, 0.013393823988735676, 0.03951532393693924, -0.0345069095492363, 0.022461339831352234, 0.03265736997127533, 0.015250404365360737, -0.05236364156007767, 0.002872608369216323, 0.0152977230027318, 0.005350595340132713, -0.022686805576086044, 0.024375515058636665, -0.003185809589922428, -0.023016266524791718, 0.020516185089945793, -0.05079765245318413, -0.043829601258039474, -0.05245310440659523, -0.03948976472020149, 0.03744051977992058, -0.035751380026340485, 0.029858160763978958, 0.05059433728456497, 0.01066870242357254, 0.008852608501911163, -0.02182311937212944, -0.0477987565100193, 0.03597152978181839, 0.01679467037320137, -0.05282875895500183, -0.05827384442090988, 0.046505801379680634, -0.04559065029025078, -0.028376195579767227, -0.03064071200788021, -0.03890901431441307, -0.06434975564479828, -0.04926987737417221, -0.05902443826198578, -0.03980354964733124, 0.04305366426706314, -0.005493869073688984, -0.034288376569747925, 0.01946636661887169, -0.042370669543743134, 0.014188632369041443, -0.007957988418638706, -0.04669496417045593, -0.04206862673163414, -0.03218195214867592, -0.024179475381970406, -0.007300541270524263, 0.018081873655319214, -0.05095783993601799, -0.05153024196624756, 0.030620377510786057, 0.0036543486639857292, 0.040460240095853806, -0.02396979182958603, 0.05987918749451637, 0.05865258350968361, 0.0016431394033133984, -0.020123040303587914, -0.018515879288315773, -0.05613599345088005, -0.03979678824543953, -0.004703833255916834, 0.03801034390926361, -0.02812696062028408, -0.024409422650933266, -0.02410699799656868, -0.004460624884814024, -0.015249958261847496, -0.02507309801876545, 0.023682914674282074, 0.010083702392876148, 0.01570260524749756, -0.06186779588460922, -0.05159013718366623, -0.02219545841217041, 0.007991991005837917, -0.05661033093929291, 0.03238673135638237, 0.02910364605486393, -0.010117783211171627, -0.02018481120467186, 0.05084894225001335, -0.021648740395903587, 0.04684111475944519, -0.04710933566093445, -0.041554439812898636, -0.009983798488974571, 0.011016611941158772, -0.011140006594359875, -0.021475471556186676, -0.06052996963262558, 0.020638467743992805, -0.04676021635532379, -0.02307591401040554, 0.015937335789203644, 0.04112609475851059, -0.0036117066629230976, 0.04987192898988724, -0.06202901527285576, 0.006282920483499765, 0.03418046236038208, -0.033988386392593384, -0.004957693163305521, 0.004603460431098938, -0.030536023899912834, 0.018628284335136414, -0.03414733707904816, 0.01713625155389309, -0.02287125028669834, -0.006858791224658489, -0.02913070283830166, -0.057265494018793106, 0.0053702956065535545, -0.018178429454565048, 0.02501453459262848, -0.033774640411138535, 0.008855646476149559, -0.04966175556182861, -0.01991318166255951, -0.007466082461178303, -0.05195421725511551, 0.05180075019598007, 0.01852746307849884, -0.047893114387989044, -0.04015139117836952, -0.044132050126791, 0.038136616349220276, -0.03207864984869957, -0.013001599349081516, 0.001915033790282905, -0.0023901748936623335, 0.027462150901556015, -0.06345029175281525, -0.05246920511126518, 0.008229401893913746, 0.017010394483804703, -0.0076454393565654755, -0.013829350471496582, -0.031107289716601372, -0.024706317111849785, -0.022401144728064537, 0.0010475561721250415, 0.0008636827697046101, 0.012302939780056477, -0.03980972617864609, 0.0022147141862660646, 0.03391116484999657, -0.001361402915790677, 0.031609416007995605, -0.017145328223705292, -0.010772493667900562, 0.04075495898723602, 0.013440469279885292, -0.037307966500520706, -0.025579247623682022, 0.016050150617957115, -0.008448826149106026, -0.0449603796005249, -0.014526346698403358, -0.018456099554896355, -0.024304822087287903, -0.02776910364627838, 0.04085034132003784, 0.03337663412094116, -0.031094232574105263, -0.043553732335567474, -0.018361836671829224, -0.04738069698214531, 0.03351738676428795, 0.012213173322379589, 0.03350730240345001, -0.014797531999647617, 0.05391710624098778, 0.04578835144639015, -0.06326242536306381, -0.030336085706949234, 0.0010648443130776286, -0.03671455755829811, -0.00798062700778246, -0.04625225067138672, -0.015658730641007423, 0.009286933578550816, -0.06227267161011696, -0.04440346732735634, -0.033813077956438065, -0.02355087548494339, -0.05099818855524063, 0.0029165996238589287, 0.009125584736466408, -0.06007862091064453, -0.010702214203774929, -0.005880231969058514, -0.05795145034790039, 0.03639886900782585, -0.014865834265947342, -0.037207718938589096, -0.04199806973338127, 0.042295925319194794, -0.0659601166844368, -0.059374306350946426, -0.03648980334401131, 0.05827798694372177, 0.04273560270667076, -0.05781295895576477, 0.05953597277402878, 0.04060196131467819, 0.022179655730724335, 0.04848280921578407, -0.06514929980039597, -0.043373774737119675, -0.059165213257074356, 0.034935422241687775, 0.003457742976024747, -0.03524130955338478, -0.011542242020368576, -0.0015680771321058273, 0.022084306925535202, -0.007599844131618738, 0.035161565989255905, -0.030106576159596443, 0.013593549840152264, 0.02030034363269806, -0.04596893861889839, -0.0330648347735405, -0.05614441633224487, -0.04379541799426079, -0.03688960522413254, 0.034335069358348846, -0.019635027274489403, -0.04892793297767639, -0.023615458980202675, -0.034124117344617844, -0.028501329943537712, -0.018069865182042122, -0.05140041932463646, -0.03962389752268791, -0.06484536826610565, -0.021626275032758713, 0.03588985651731491, 0.04914829134941101, 0.0407448373734951, 0.01949860155582428, -0.03723353520035744, -0.02484641596674919, -0.05181694030761719, -0.012465698644518852, 0.010889383964240551, -0.01686403714120388, -0.019297221675515175, -0.055907201021909714, 0.05739826709032059, -0.05833090841770172, 0.036602456122636795, -0.027708012610673904, -0.028675967827439308, 0.0048900991678237915, 0.012866895645856857, -0.04577828571200371, -0.028751874342560768, -0.005412393249571323, -0.05540720000863075, 0.028278565034270287, 0.011305252090096474, -0.03992254287004471, -0.03491199389100075, 0.034185104072093964, -0.04537225514650345, -0.008559725247323513, 0.007003542501479387, -0.009474663063883781, 0.04661647602915764, 0.042550891637802124, 0.03631792217493057, 0.028278376907110214, 0.03617849946022034, -0.03221220523118973, -0.04830736666917801, -0.01193411834537983, -0.02131609618663788, -0.04004348814487457, 0.0024940057191997766, -0.04126231372356415, -0.06450408697128296, -0.003016117960214615, 0.03964614123106003, -0.0364442877471447, -0.0144082922488451, -0.027861392125487328, -0.05331134796142578, 0.06178393214941025, 0.01615007594227791, 0.03980110213160515, -0.06632021069526672, -0.06423577666282654, 0.015768125653266907, -0.028612395748496056, 0.032871097326278687, -0.04566046595573425, -0.0601981095969677, 0.03928342089056969, -0.06840608268976212, -0.060610998421907425, -0.009782712906599045, -0.009462852962315083, 0.020255394279956818, -0.01751834526658058, -0.0535561703145504, -0.044466447085142136, -0.039021752774715424, -0.04138319566845894, -0.01320421602576971, 0.05129200592637062, 0.0276547409594059, -0.042108871042728424, 0.03901124373078346, 0.023059241473674774, 0.0177292600274086, 0.003812252078205347, -0.05660434812307358, 0.051403243094682693, -0.017278488725423813, -0.03983213007450104, 0.001935349078848958, 0.05261344090104103, -0.047004666179418564, 0.030794154852628708, 0.0067301648668944836, -0.041677411645650864, -0.05872125178575516, -0.058275364339351654, 0.01545672956854105, -0.06333071738481522, -0.04064517095685005, -0.021823972463607788, 0.0027541383169591427, -0.04755168780684471, -0.04958787560462952, -0.06036150082945824, -0.025828471407294273, 0.022235160693526268, -0.053092993795871735, -0.05621583014726639, -0.038844432681798935, -0.01945473626255989, 0.0007140610832720995, 0.003974673803895712, 0.023995304480195045, -0.056897394359111786, 0.048154715448617935, 0.015376893803477287, -0.02945314161479473, -0.020117225125432014, 0.04437541589140892, -0.04668773338198662, -0.022048046812415123, 0.04424731060862541, 0.058722611516714096, 0.03499675542116165, 0.012385990470647812, -0.02036271058022976, 0.031217580661177635, 0.02835679240524769, -0.05682515725493431, 0.02442164532840252, -0.034755889326334, 0.023229502141475677, 0.01904739812016487, 0.032268594950437546, -0.04153447598218918, -0.01611907407641411, 0.02747928723692894, -0.03842783346772194, 0.059654656797647476, 0.01784195750951767, -0.013617515563964844, -0.052945613861083984, -0.007288713473826647, -0.036388229578733444, -0.06259004026651382, -0.015065212734043598, -0.00798435416072607, 0.002396856201812625, -0.011449110694229603, -0.023872502148151398, -0.015410086140036583, -0.06400184333324432, -0.015208910219371319, -0.015141483396291733, 0.025605900213122368, -0.04913683980703354, 0.0279022715985775, 0.0009976906003430486, -0.024837061762809753, -0.042736832052469254 ]
Recent years have witnessed the adoption of differential privacy (DP) in practical database systems like PINQ, FLEX, and PrivateSQL. Such systems allow data analysts to query sensitive data while providing a rigorous and provable privacy guarantee. However, the existing design of these systems does not distinguish data analysts of different privilege levels or trust levels. This design can have an unfair apportion of the privacy budget among the data analyst if treating them as a single entity, or waste the privacy budget if considering them as non-colluding parties and answering their queries independently. In this paper, we propose DProvDB, a fine-grained privacy provenance framework for the multi-analyst scenario that tracks the privacy loss to each single data analyst. Under this framework, when given a fixed privacy budget, we build algorithms that maximize the number of queries that could be answered accurately and apportion the privacy budget according to the privilege levels of the data analysts.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10240v1
[ -0.0013359823497012258, -0.048698000609874725, 0.027657486498355865, 0.009012505412101746, -0.019528687000274658, 0.03713873401284218, -0.03901166841387749, -0.04165948927402496, -0.01047330629080534, -0.05067699775099754, -0.0696496069431305, 0.014419740997254848, -0.005768866278231144, -0.060226768255233765, -0.04021550714969635, -0.027031030505895615, 0.07303928583860397, 0.07034534960985184, -0.014761295169591904, 0.043440867215394974, -0.04662460833787918, 0.012092724442481995, 0.01982593908905983, 0.05579177662730217, -0.003777828300371766, 0.012133163399994373, -0.007535926532000303, -0.022661617025732994, -0.050574712455272675, 0.009471586905419827, 0.05799593776464462, -0.02957531064748764, -0.01743738166987896, -0.06038239225745201, -0.05577978119254112, 0.00847538374364376, 0.019255952909588814, 0.04483300447463989, -0.02594991773366928, -0.044835805892944336, 0.050635915249586105, -0.051103174686431885, -0.048147477209568024, -0.06892336905002594, 0.01020958460867405, 0.007632734254002571, -0.08300644904375076, 0.04917685687541962, -0.0046392157673835754, 0.001463104854337871, 0.029735306277871132, -0.0168249923735857, 0.02079368755221367, 0.019336817786097527, -0.029943162575364113, -0.0009761216933839023, -0.01241622120141983, 0.013608253560960293, -0.010113351978361607, 0.01693272776901722, 0.024912238121032715, -0.004966760519891977, 0.0005571137298829854, -0.009958136826753616, -0.01968369260430336, 0.0784086138010025, -0.03887861594557762, -0.07189622521400452, -0.0031182263046503067, -0.010606074705719948, 0.021894872188568115, -0.028593765571713448, 0.0015883748419582844, -0.01902022585272789, -0.05908394604921341, 0.010620075277984142, 0.016031350940465927, -0.005343000404536724, 0.01632135547697544, -0.003979032393544912, -0.010585032403469086, -0.008552338927984238, 0.010777100920677185, 0.0019526808755472302, -0.02145724557340145, -0.07236095517873764, 0.015330294147133827, 0.0008081231499090791, 0.05393268167972565, -0.04263576120138168, 0.0049809119664132595, -0.030854932963848114, -0.0695486068725586, 0.028999486938118935, 0.06561165302991867, -0.013688387349247932, 0.04665427654981613, 0.0407865084707737, 0.03450490161776543, -0.04336787015199661, -0.013514276593923569, -0.033616840839385986, -0.021309075877070427, 0.038576457649469376, -0.0034010563977062702, -0.008978634141385555, 0.002095908857882023, 0.024366745725274086, -0.08092169463634491, 0.014754119329154491, 0.009979020804166794, -0.015122744254767895, -0.057530973106622696, -0.06430692970752716, -0.011412086896598339, -0.02879621461033821, 0.06569819897413254, 0.04743005707859993, 0.05533353239297867, 0.020490333437919617, -0.031556498259305954, -0.004378178156912327, 0.028595682233572006, -0.014851904474198818, -0.05071257799863815, -0.05101405829191208, 0.07121139764785767, -0.01504190918058157, 0.0018852569628506899, 0.015514037571847439, -0.04089532047510147, -0.009507647715508938, 0.013705447316169739, -0.005640825256705284, 0.04060101881623268, -0.03791690990328789, 0.022940082475543022, -0.03939151391386986, 0.0031805948819965124, 0.021940812468528748, -0.02015170268714428, -0.08560015261173248, -0.010401293635368347, -0.03647483140230179, -0.00677678594365716, 0.014332875609397888, -0.01606893725693226, 0.02667086571455002, 0.01764916628599167, 0.06954780220985413, 0.03064075857400894, 0.01933884248137474, 0.01576317474246025, -0.0146652115508914, -0.011069604195654392, 0.003293569665402174, 0.006707441993057728, -0.05084790289402008, -0.005878821015357971, 0.0466977134346962, 0.01737772300839424, -0.012164173647761345, -0.014072557911276817, -0.02142883650958538, -0.0026822967920452356, 0.03064587153494358, 0.009311201050877571, -0.004056483507156372, 0.04838928207755089, 0.024426735937595367, -0.06839902698993683, -0.03364886716008186, -0.016700580716133118, -0.03995611518621445, -0.06458709388971329, 0.022288935258984566, 0.027767686173319817, -0.016620038077235222, -0.062477242201566696, 0.00317357387393713, -0.0030374478083103895, 0.030383935198187828, -0.02788979560136795, 0.022521847859025, -0.04378033056855202, 0.004275187849998474, -0.03805680572986603, 0.006924772169440985, -0.03137749060988426, -0.004963936284184456, -0.06701155751943588, -0.032585639506578445, -0.03296560421586037, -0.016005730256438255, -0.019604381173849106, -0.029889332130551338, 0.005382634699344635, -0.009338665753602982, -0.0009110450628213584, 0.04009142145514488, -0.08932184427976608, -0.02886224165558815, -0.0606447272002697, 0.028003275394439697, -0.0015346788568422198, -0.032018519937992096, -0.0013626283034682274, 0.0671672374010086, -0.05352407693862915, -0.023097792640328407, 0.049490053206682205, 0.04697667434811592, 0.04876306280493736, 0.00877422746270895, 0.039639513939619064, 0.032981619238853455, -0.09668020159006119, 0.0455479733645916, -0.011056541465222836, 0.042409129440784454, 0.03187556937336922, 0.041104212403297424, 0.000789959158282727, -0.0056110890582203865, -0.04195091128349304, 0.02108044922351837, -0.0180969275534153, 0.02250925451517105, -0.03193230181932449, -0.039631426334381104, -0.03698716685175896, -0.03137393668293953, 0.022561321035027504, -0.07230117917060852, -0.06282800436019897, 0.0034128823317587376, -0.02992674708366394, 0.05464339628815651, -0.01317657995969057, -0.022786948829889297, -0.021799201145768166, -0.004567665047943592, 0.033997826278209686, 0.016747865825891495, -0.010944652371108532, -0.018204156309366226, -0.03160516545176506, 0.029997143894433975, -0.015116426162421703, 0.0168869961053133, 0.013731693848967552, -0.034273162484169006, 0.006855563260614872, -0.021581141278147697, 0.06668490916490555, -0.019650811329483986, -0.005739304237067699, 0.06491518020629883, 0.007610110100358725, 0.04835395887494087, 0.041524142026901245, 0.04765597730875015, -0.06370869278907776, 0.016863375902175903, 0.03117348439991474, -0.05040309205651283, 0.005486060865223408, -0.02062065154314041, 0.030700862407684326, -0.05107545480132103, -0.017352696508169174, 0.005432679317891598, 0.02375847101211548, -0.012410370633006096, -0.005120270419865847, 0.004392009694129229, -0.007582404185086489, -0.028626475483179092, 0.04427064210176468, 0.051891449838876724, 0.03340514376759529, 0.03875924274325371, 0.04048248752951622, -0.08066490292549133, -0.005740479100495577, -0.02763749286532402, 0.012529993429780006, -0.027248039841651917, -0.01813419722020626, -0.06516235321760178, -0.0839100256562233, -0.03070978634059429, 0.010083797387778759, -0.042228590697050095, -0.04184138774871826, -0.03330448642373085, -0.034444913268089294, 0.005409892648458481, -0.011193444952368736, 0.007621506694704294, -0.016797589138150215, -0.0649309903383255, -0.0012220419012010098, 0.01602211408317089, 0.0335896871984005, -0.07313662022352219, -0.05305612459778786, -0.0046251434832811356, 0.034630127251148224, 0.018289022147655487, 0.036192040890455246, 0.047209497541189194, 0.012826838530600071, -0.03223584219813347, -0.019197683781385422, -0.025194179266691208, 0.010319426655769348, 0.00979581568390131, 0.013704980723559856, -0.01756620779633522, 0.030451681464910507, -0.04138527810573578, 0.028899788856506348, -0.0466388463973999, -0.05324419215321541, -0.06778939813375473, -0.002299452666193247, -0.003962683957070112, 0.03824356943368912, -0.04191833361983299, 0.026320766657590866, 0.05208703875541687, 0.02045261301100254, -0.036582350730895996, 0.01957830972969532, 0.05607553571462631, 0.015607588924467564, 0.007737581618130207, -0.013036046177148819, 0.04643719643354416, 0.008701791055500507, 0.07078644633293152, -0.03642839565873146, 0.04277930408716202, 0.045752450823783875, -0.07062504440546036, 0.035171620547771454, 0.030343569815158844, 0.015946868807077408, -0.014000470750033855, -0.0017290691612288356, 0.03438981622457504, 0.020584367215633392, -0.006739412434399128, 0.02845514938235283, 0.0072667719796299934, 0.02922130934894085, 0.04445371404290199, -0.07656875252723694, -0.039794858545064926, 0.017350293695926666, -0.026047538965940475, -0.02402399852871895, 0.05490437522530556, -0.028018973767757416, 0.047856658697128296, 0.004282782319933176, -0.00904961209744215, 0.04804135859012604, 0.00819441583007574, 0.057311687618494034, -0.02513594925403595, -0.033990100026130676, 0.05174000933766365, -0.04393286630511284, 0.05811559781432152, -0.02694832533597946, -0.05571308359503746, 0.041584666818380356, -0.032392848283052444, 0.02056768164038658, -0.048865146934986115, 0.0028282725252211094, -0.005633034743368626, 0.0019894884899258614, -0.02695980668067932, 0.042067352682352066, 0.02739020437002182, 0.04337948560714722, -0.032578855752944946, 0.027417505159974098, 0.031006958335638046, 0.05362442135810852, -0.0514289028942585, 0.010442525148391724, -0.027882907539606094, 0.0014945107977837324, 0.012954626232385635, -0.05069846659898758, -0.06094411388039589, -0.009939410723745823, -0.023731961846351624, 0.03425435721874237, -0.06228714808821678, 0.05877666547894478, -0.03906417638063431, 0.04334535449743271, 0.0026964854914695024, 0.007300025317817926, -0.0032642893493175507, -0.042938631027936935, 0.04616878554224968, -0.012003418058156967, -0.05150417983531952, 0.00095528201200068, 0.0024729319848120213, -0.005986702628433704, -0.03681233525276184, 0.016909021884202957, -0.06519787013530731, 0.0558878555893898, 0.01852596364915371, 0.019173933193087578, -0.012459308840334415, 0.019079240038990974, -0.030115772038698196, 0.039810407906770706, 0.08641969412565231, 0.03795294091105461, 0.02896825224161148, -0.051808129996061325, 0.018170315772294998, 0.04877037927508354, 0.022236239165067673, 0.0063919746316969395, -0.04549689590930939, 0.022593678906559944, 0.018801361322402954, -0.0011072461493313313, 0.008024959824979305, -0.03977453336119652, 0.029711943119764328, -0.02990439347922802, -0.031455863267183304, -0.03235622122883797, 0.013946164399385452, -0.04697079211473465, -0.06313382089138031, -0.040805064141750336, -0.02432263456285, -0.056150954216718674, -0.0512954518198967, 0.009954587556421757, 0.0015706387348473072, -0.01888108067214489, 0.0041907671838998795, 0.014913485385477543, 0.02194972150027752, -0.02016591839492321, -0.02329048328101635, 0.020142704248428345, -0.0017022737301886082, -0.029441246762871742, 0.010057625360786915, -0.06671954691410065, -0.04423469677567482, -0.04537420719861984, -0.02471517212688923, -0.021148929372429848, 0.04419467970728874, 0.03552814573049545, 0.035136085003614426, -0.07823825627565384, 0.01999366283416748, 0.04111964628100395, -0.027547309175133705, 0.058545395731925964, 0.07111077755689621, 0.0036471206694841385, -0.018576107919216156, -0.019804710522294044, -0.00834956206381321, 0.04054125025868416, -0.035540513694286346, 0.0030416990630328655, 0.0026324866339564323, -0.023359090089797974, 0.00519417691975832, 0.06148221343755722, -0.051575981080532074, -0.02003108710050583, -0.03533850237727165, 0.03662250190973282, 0.006634416989982128, -0.019781270995736122, 0.026109645143151283, -0.013133130967617035, -0.06233535706996918, -0.03471312299370766, 0.005369078833609819, 0.013008281588554382, -0.014715530909597874, 0.018906665965914726, -0.04849153757095337, 0.024071455001831055, 0.0280306376516819, -0.03687303513288498, 0.012249190360307693, 0.021677665412425995, 0.032068971544504166, -0.013276496902108192, -0.01505245454609394, -0.02460949867963791, -0.03544079512357712, 0.01998024806380272, -0.04575758054852486, 0.041119784116744995, 0.06794936209917068, 0.05190432071685791, -0.014055727049708366, -0.01848534494638443, -0.02841865085065365, -0.016315434128046036, 0.024773333221673965, 0.00609647436067462, 0.011050611734390259, -0.04574192687869072, -0.03730182722210884, 0.0370405837893486, 0.031615301966667175, 0.04526469111442566, -0.010563597083091736, 0.06180576607584953, -0.0028991634026169777, 0.010788215324282646, -0.047245774418115616, 0.01831766963005066, -0.061701640486717224, -0.05215451493859291, 0.01054941676557064, 0.03212590143084526, -0.04130448400974274, 0.06362951546907425, -0.013516915962100029, -0.002568429335951805, 0.02687479741871357, -0.0020575658418238163, 0.01885237544775009, 0.01689334586262703, 0.008680027909576893, 0.034571386873722076, -0.039482321590185165, 0.021149171516299248, -0.03771687671542168, -0.026072027161717415, 0.002401305828243494, -0.009246901609003544, 0.0018261460354551673, 0.055872585624456406, -0.015617151744663715, -0.048708442598581314, 0.060964252799749374, -0.008582567796111107, -0.06683983653783798, 0.012802377343177795, 0.02808806672692299, -0.0887894555926323, 0.03442375734448433, 0.04596681520342827, -0.004180848598480225, -0.06873612850904465, 0.053669523447752, 0.020054245367646217, -0.03686152771115303, -0.005782941356301308, 0.08311155438423157, 0.08229723572731018, -0.008033931255340576, -0.006254940759390593, -0.02527112327516079, -0.07792166620492935, 0.049175918102264404, -0.03637336194515228, -0.0006721833487972617, 0.03177832067012787, 0.04991326853632927, -0.02796504646539688, -0.01634310744702816, -0.04266567528247833, -0.007883759215474129, 0.02483617700636387, -0.024937953799962997, 0.020940622314810753, -0.025912456214427948, 0.037841033190488815, -0.04842936620116234, -0.019061079248785973, -0.02219417132437229, -0.024465229362249374, 0.02200653962790966, -0.04174967110157013, 0.0388915054500103, 0.006588144693523645, -0.04532622918486595, -0.010652388446033001, -0.06625494360923767, 0.019966913387179375, -0.027258552610874176, -0.039711251854896545, 0.04998941719532013, -0.07185235619544983, -0.02315284125506878, 0.028437543660402298, -0.02160869725048542, 0.01885102316737175, 0.048516448587179184, -0.04894488677382469, 0.026688726618885994, -0.013384458608925343, -0.018848910927772522, 0.015082329511642456, 0.0015475151594728231, -0.011427530087530613, -0.004198867827653885, 0.01010455284267664, -0.0644460916519165, 0.01922154799103737, 0.036682117730379105, 0.002505670767277479, 0.027674410492181778, -0.021651148796081543, -0.048780009150505066, -0.0125384870916605, 0.005572806112468243, -0.06859713047742844, 0.018631549552083015, 0.03261697664856911, -0.05027845874428749, -0.05672674998641014, 0.024676155298948288, -0.05462995544075966, 0.0014572687214240432, -0.01748659461736679, 0.042793821543455124, 0.051355913281440735, -0.02130037546157837, 0.008541827090084553, -0.014797342009842396, 0.0352657213807106, 0.019224537536501884, -0.060124821960926056, -0.006800423376262188, -0.0071096098981797695, -0.03273293748497963, -0.045769333839416504, -0.05732424929738045, -0.01966562680900097, -0.051579125225543976, 0.03451913967728615, 0.03314783424139023, -0.022426918148994446, -0.05104947090148926, -0.06603050231933594, 0.02979348413646221, -0.0015103177865967155, -0.019087404012680054, -0.0180425513535738, -0.011418282054364681, -0.024037983268499374, -0.04688626527786255, 0.032834842801094055, 0.002456244546920061, -0.04504767432808876, 0.021039774641394615, -0.071989506483078, -0.010774496011435986, 0.012650727294385433, 0.0037850819062441587, 0.0218245517462492, -0.0015461035072803497, -0.023053470999002457, -0.047475166618824005, -0.045261215418577194, -0.02242145501077175, -0.024590037763118744, -0.022347349673509598, 0.05955122038722038, -0.03371680527925491, -0.034808360040187836, -0.050111547112464905, -0.0004692364309448749, -0.04088347777724266, -0.02298213168978691, 0.038374487310647964, 0.006776989437639713, -0.005480712745338678, 0.0003174931916873902, 0.018507612869143486, -0.035527877509593964, 0.0036181716714054346, -0.046034328639507294, 0.063644178211689, -0.02279495820403099, -0.051549628376960754, 0.04972951114177704, -0.06869000941514969, -0.06618596613407135, 0.030283425003290176, -0.02314259484410286, 0.0007145785493776202, -0.04764093831181526, -0.07785514742136002, 0.01538071222603321, 0.04340821132063866, 0.021725157275795937, 0.0488741435110569, 0.005709162913262844, 0.014773238450288773, 0.012997860088944435, -0.004395971540361643, -0.04428137093782425, 0.0030467326287180185, -0.010409722104668617, -0.04243858531117439, -0.04334387183189392, -0.03542805835604668, 0.00970903318375349, 0.014637569896876812, -0.026848677545785904, -0.008231598883867264, 0.07848787307739258, -0.009167585521936417, -0.022624889388680458, 0.02309449203312397, -0.06378206610679626, -0.027052156627178192, -0.07630828768014908, -0.049138881266117096, -0.07520723342895508, 0.044352300465106964, 0.016769573092460632, -0.002551072044298053, 0.022085612639784813, 0.02794310636818409, 0.004480266477912664, 0.015950756147503853, 0.03438723832368851, -0.007557455450296402, -0.05628062039613724, 0.06366897374391556, -0.011733115650713444, 0.04579553380608559, 0.020168161019682884, -0.03219044208526611, -0.017545923590660095, 0.062394365668296814, 0.00604631844907999, -0.026326505467295647, 0.03952018544077873, -0.05780695378780365, 0.046849325299263, 0.013921522535383701, 0.023212559521198273, -0.02255711518228054, -0.006914714351296425, -0.004764654207974672, -0.010549774393439293, -0.044976964592933655 ]
We present the first comprehensive study of a giant, $\approx \! \! 70$ kpc-scale nebula around a radio-quiet quasar at $z<1$. The analysis is based on deep integral field spectroscopy with MUSE of the field of HE$\,$0238$-$1904, a luminous quasar at $z=0.6282$. The nebula emits strongly in $\mathrm{[O \, II]}$, $\rm H \beta$, and $\mathrm{[O \, III]}$, and the quasar resides in an unusually overdense environment for a radio-quiet system. The environment likely consists of two groups which may be merging, and in total have an estimated dynamical mass of $M_{\rm dyn}\approx 4\times 10^{13}$ to $10^{14}\ {\rm M_\odot}$. The nebula exhibits largely quiescent kinematics and irregular morphology. The nebula may arise primarily through interaction-related stripping of circumgalactic and interstellar medium (CGM/ISM) of group members, with some potential contributions from quasar outflows. The simultaneous presence of the giant nebula and a radio-quiet quasar in a rich environment suggests a correlation between such circum-quasar nebulae and environmental effects. This possibility can be tested with larger samples. The upper limits on the electron number density implied by the $\mathrm{[O \, II]}$ doublet ratio range from $\log(n_{\rm e, \, [O \, II]} / \mathrm{cm^{-3}}) < 1.2$ to $2.8$. However, assuming a constant quasar luminosity and negligible projection effects, the densities implied from the measured line ratios between different ions (e.g., $\mathrm{[O\,II]}$, $\mathrm{[O\,III]}$, and $\mathrm{[Ne\,V]}$) and photoionization simulations are often $10{-}400$ times larger. This large discrepancy can be explained by quasar variability on a timescale of $\approx 10^4{-}10^5$ years.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.00053v3
[ -0.052331291139125824, -0.03007860854268074, 0.0331076979637146, -0.017210831865668297, -0.009534020908176899, -0.01166347973048687, -0.031120531260967255, 0.039280518889427185, -0.022968413308262825, -0.00443169753998518, 0.05719582736492157, -0.060101091861724854, -0.03458065167069435, -0.06587400287389755, -0.04416229575872421, 0.06536097079515457, 0.04004528373479843, 0.05960661172866821, -0.027259401977062225, 0.05706317350268364, 0.027772441506385803, -0.03759671375155449, -0.03670318424701691, 0.01644340716302395, 0.0319531224668026, -0.034348201006650925, -0.015154012478888035, 0.05498348921537399, -0.004467545542865992, -0.0320071205496788, 0.044969938695430756, -0.03164869174361229, 0.012692369520664215, 0.004721673205494881, -0.026356760412454605, 0.02410774864256382, -0.01990041695535183, 0.06901156902313232, 0.00540955038741231, -0.01251019537448883, -0.022069094702601433, -0.04230014979839325, -0.05605042725801468, -0.02991390973329544, -0.01364345382899046, -0.05449121445417404, -0.04639805853366852, -0.029369039461016655, -0.034846607595682144, -0.07206691056489944, -0.014129851944744587, 0.006761206779628992, 0.02043609693646431, 0.06231113523244858, -0.015348764136433601, -0.03604396805167198, 0.04398416355252266, 0.010620268993079662, -0.03812997043132782, 0.0030605762731283903, 0.02386026456952095, -0.032559629529714584, 0.019412146881222725, -0.04887297749519348, -0.049944113940000534, 0.023977968841791153, -0.060381002724170685, -0.003499853191897273, 0.0023664399050176144, -0.02475927025079727, -0.0036452889908105135, -0.07456515729427338, 0.012587943114340305, -0.025439437478780746, -0.07213097810745239, -0.02086886204779148, -0.01415290217846632, -0.030368506908416748, -0.04453687369823456, 0.056545283645391464, 0.022193988785147667, 0.04784424975514412, 0.0355183482170105, 0.028900885954499245, 0.02203858084976673, -0.011032519862055779, 0.03784475475549698, -0.07016114145517349, -0.008856939151883125, -0.049737464636564255, 0.024369779974222183, -0.05227533355355263, -0.05137452110648155, 0.011993843130767345, 0.06955784559249878, -0.05385052040219307, 0.06616891920566559, -0.010772337205708027, 0.0547986775636673, -0.00804793369024992, -0.015908753499388695, -0.04799792915582657, -0.03643746301531792, 0.04578971862792969, 0.022399159148335457, -0.02739892527461052, 0.014862697571516037, -0.043458350002765656, -0.0025840653106570244, 0.06463301181793213, -0.026699790731072426, 0.02845926769077778, 0.0169372521340847, -0.049585290253162384, -0.04601239785552025, -0.06660105288028717, 0.04238244891166687, 0.0074131241999566555, -0.0030620433390140533, 0.012081746011972427, -0.0078093684278428555, 0.05224403366446495, -0.01203994546085596, -0.03530863672494888, 0.0039958348497748375, -0.03533182293176651, 0.06418709456920624, -0.011368467472493649, 0.03895745426416397, -0.015874667093157768, -0.017606396228075027, 0.0034725950099527836, 0.025821510702371597, -0.017102008685469627, -0.033222097903490067, -0.04386849328875542, 0.02839173562824726, 0.018911616876721382, 0.0018803628627210855, -0.019367091357707977, 0.0036873312201350927, -0.010880670510232449, 0.025864025577902794, 0.01747298054397106, 0.0021632262505590916, 0.00860962737351656, -0.07295055687427521, -0.043260607868433, 0.0766306221485138, 0.04588177055120468, -0.02139992080628872, 0.01636849343776703, 0.01018055435270071, 0.00479885982349515, 0.001939659472554922, -0.006153530441224575, 0.01177535392343998, 0.03366298973560333, -0.04851913079619408, 0.04717748984694481, -0.0076937428675591946, -0.015211890451610088, 0.027251414954662323, 0.012843557633459568, -0.01673373207449913, 0.03251824900507927, 0.019891051575541496, -0.04898291453719139, 0.0006828122423030436, 0.003173082834109664, -0.01384566631168127, 0.0059650857001543045, 0.010320422239601612, -0.03270016238093376, -0.03551841154694557, -0.03291046991944313, -0.014500407502055168, -0.018577197566628456, -0.010900811292231083, 0.02033541165292263, 0.010804641991853714, 0.00856821984052658, -0.0540253110229969, -0.002456158632412553, -0.059957556426525116, -0.02631322294473648, -0.07736575603485107, -0.0441301167011261, 0.05413858965039253, 0.004251629114151001, -0.02990105375647545, -0.02629360370337963, -0.003272456116974354, 0.010266289114952087, -0.014818448573350906, -0.012167075648903847, 0.030921613797545433, -0.01805582083761692, -0.0007545748958364129, 0.020513417199254036, -0.05060578137636185, -0.034502338618040085, 0.012072691693902016, 0.022469108924269676, 0.05057815834879875, -0.07123075425624847, 0.04149595648050308, 0.031084643676877022, 0.012889748439192772, -0.04641268774867058, 0.029890768229961395, 0.012831754982471466, 0.03442879393696785, 0.026576751843094826, -0.0539819709956646, -0.012960574589669704, -0.1017770916223526, 0.06030967831611633, 0.045089371502399445, -0.03385978192090988, 0.07555954903364182, 0.03799609839916229, 0.051189567893743515, -0.019492538645863533, -0.03796498477458954, 0.04295862093567848, 0.029847024008631706, -0.06227971240878105, -0.025933722034096718, -0.00685711158439517, -0.04180044308304787, -0.07636868208646774, -0.049249593168497086, -0.048142243176698685, -0.04136637598276138, 0.006404338404536247, -0.052414942532777786, 0.054354261606931686, 0.00009237590711563826, -0.060930173844099045, -0.05490982159972191, 0.030229156836867332, 0.03213278204202652, -0.007852585054934025, -0.04054168239235878, -0.0060954345390200615, -0.05435427650809288, 0.0002472230407875031, -0.048591360449790955, -0.02582038938999176, 0.000840022403281182, -0.05419566109776497, -0.02890653908252716, 0.046385351568460464, 0.052814558148384094, 0.05856352671980858, -0.03508575260639191, -0.02046350948512554, -0.011758897453546524, 0.06525126099586487, 0.024457711726427078, 0.020989878103137016, -0.059489231556653976, -0.015442809090018272, -0.019435018301010132, 0.025440910831093788, -0.06932752579450607, 0.003093498991802335, -0.02616511844098568, 0.0032577733509242535, 0.05829903855919838, 0.012219442054629326, 0.06080268695950508, 0.0022320204880088568, -0.03350235894322395, -0.04394116252660751, -0.015193520113825798, -0.010580623522400856, -0.012066375464200974, -0.020732728764414787, 0.04552014544606209, 0.032442718744277954, 0.010168904438614845, -0.0755089819431305, -0.024796728044748306, -0.03777291998267174, -0.010259116068482399, -0.057648833841085434, -0.04515615850687027, 0.018672386184334755, -0.03470747917890549, 0.04198945313692093, -0.03519024699926376, -0.03506242483854294, -0.009451634250581264, -0.04032735154032707, -0.05110882222652435, -0.010088576003909111, 0.00031187900458462536, -0.06502825021743774, -0.013997568748891354, 0.04181278124451637, -0.01321808435022831, 0.03912591189146042, -0.01124640554189682, -0.013060308061540127, -0.05818798393011093, 0.020958272740244865, -0.020297391340136528, 0.022921999916434288, -0.037914156913757324, 0.039978981018066406, -0.054983340203762054, 0.008661715313792229, 0.0227784626185894, 0.051621388643980026, 0.020276743918657303, -0.054317403584718704, 0.007841767743229866, 0.010824081487953663, -0.06078203767538071, -0.03199850022792816, 0.022223906591534615, -0.03912491351366043, -0.05325125530362129, -0.04839969426393509, 0.043839775025844574, 0.05455092713236809, 0.019947178661823273, -0.04515012726187706, -0.009419958107173443, -0.021176951006054878, -0.021474367007613182, 0.003380315378308296, 0.043138619512319565, -0.025948883965611458, -0.05958669260144234, -0.0013188534649088979, -0.058346737176179886, 0.029179632663726807, -0.015432610176503658, 0.008163085207343102, 0.012275907211005688, -0.0035153250209987164, 0.02312183752655983, -0.053677234798669815, 0.014418604783713818, 0.048311907798051834, 0.06305316090583801, -0.030500011518597603, -0.0011771766003221273, 0.02789962664246559, -0.0023607530165463686, 0.04766133800148964, -0.015603315085172653, 0.020339732989668846, -0.02219143882393837, 0.05518828332424164, -0.005131262820214033, -0.015192806720733643, 0.0003651148290373385, -0.07132907211780548, -0.030550526455044746, 0.03236835077404976, 0.011700479313731194, 0.041498977690935135, 0.05717729032039642, -0.02197079546749592, 0.017938900738954544, -0.008721444755792618, 0.02830137126147747, -0.002052895724773407, -0.022425686940550804, -0.011294350028038025, 0.023370839655399323, -0.019756831228733063, -0.01934913918375969, -0.019210604950785637, -0.02580234222114086, -0.05719223618507385, 0.014160758815705776, -0.055946752429008484, 0.009018298238515854, -0.00406793924048543, 0.012594573199748993, 0.020276911556720734, 0.018068702891469002, 0.027903281152248383, 0.042703673243522644, -0.030484234914183617, -0.006646283436566591, -0.03477192670106888, -0.025256825610995293, 0.0030787168070673943, 0.00741619523614645, 0.045977938920259476, -0.01895240694284439, -0.004019343759864569, -0.057265445590019226, -0.03124038688838482, 0.015803158283233643, 0.020342690870165825, -0.057047270238399506, -0.0758172944188118, -0.03406069427728653, -0.03208048269152641, 0.0077166566625237465, 0.020337073132395744, -0.00969072338193655, 0.046144403517246246, -0.013777323067188263, -0.022200070321559906, -0.0035159834660589695, 0.012268414720892906, -0.03559035062789917, -0.07159284502267838, -0.007347008679062128, -0.014444728381931782, 0.012159181758761406, -0.06194106489419937, -0.018664060160517693, -0.04302576929330826, -0.005744405556470156, -0.05827953293919563, 0.0471249483525753, -0.007861998863518238, 0.011903504841029644, -0.02919713966548443, 0.024768514558672905, 0.05843449756503105, 0.0097127640619874, -0.00818922370672226, -0.022930191829800606, -0.03018474206328392, 0.06498884409666061, -0.01697435975074768, 0.0765719786286354, -0.07014227658510208, -0.02768009342253208, -0.04229253903031349, -0.008683444000780582, 0.030854810029268265, -0.019035065546631813, -0.005089091137051582, -0.008709614165127277, 0.03613581508398056, -0.018966596573591232, -0.01700393483042717, -0.027502009645104408, -0.06196798011660576, -0.0717395544052124, -0.006637671496719122, 0.004068853799253702, -0.019286442548036575, -0.004556994419544935, 0.06357792764902115, 0.04344872012734413, -0.01792135275900364, -0.023705659434199333, 0.04658297076821327, 0.022260908037424088, 0.03944806754589081, 0.026342738419771194, -0.016310464590787888, -0.041096750646829605, 0.011929882690310478, -0.00828041322529316, -0.016910221427679062, -0.013376877643167973, 0.015312792733311653, -0.012979904189705849, 0.0395720899105072, -0.09079697728157043, 0.020886557176709175, 0.0493340864777565, -0.013830577954649925, 0.002537622582167387, 0.015093008987605572, 0.04351412132382393, -0.01656309887766838, -0.01788259483873844, 0.029371926560997963, -0.010467775166034698, 0.01730099879205227, -0.0396108515560627, 0.005401011556386948, -0.07033227384090424, -0.0005986831965856254, 0.028398238122463226, -0.03062724508345127, -0.039108727127313614, 0.05681857094168663, 0.01346069946885109, -0.007444663438946009, -0.03725309297442436, 0.06127368286252022, 0.0596277229487896, -0.04143926873803139, -0.07591498643159866, 0.010609707795083523, -0.03505055233836174, 0.011968960985541344, 0.05742432177066803, -0.06383861601352692, 0.016584066674113274, 0.02256857044994831, -0.008955287747085094, 0.046730052679777145, 0.06169510632753372, -0.018428225070238113, -0.010808926075696945, 0.05397448316216469, -0.06146274507045746, -0.07099436968564987, -0.030886458232998848, -0.04348301142454147, 0.036185432225465775, -0.014032309874892235, 0.015792375430464745, 0.007556564640253782, 0.020955273881554604, 0.04877130687236786, -0.054974254220724106, -0.02442263811826706, -0.026189973577857018, 0.056354571133852005, -0.0057068513706326485, 0.011439397931098938, 0.02628064900636673, -0.009696501307189465, 0.0050966874696314335, -0.02977403812110424, 0.00968785211443901, -0.018728116527199745, -0.0625447928905487, -0.006392725743353367, 0.011385757476091385, 0.026301424950361252, -0.04353809729218483, 0.017354710027575493, 0.012469232082366943, -0.04435640946030617, 0.06076345220208168, 0.02535676583647728, 0.017575932666659355, 0.018525399267673492, -0.003863651305437088, 0.050313349813222885, -0.07991233468055725, -0.03201385959982872, 0.06410977989435196, -0.05015100911259651, 0.020182494074106216, -0.06014132499694824, -0.016047058627009392, -0.002044043503701687, -0.08230256289243698, 0.02426644042134285, 0.022784752771258354, -0.03280724585056305, 0.002660198602825403, 0.012476899661123753, -0.02223898656666279, -0.05128917470574379, -0.026155667379498482, -0.018282268196344376, -0.07342096418142319, -0.02607836201786995, -0.038942575454711914, -0.00010995595948770642, -0.039503250271081924, 0.01937326416373253, -0.06887681782245636, -0.035256002098321915, 0.007990989834070206, 0.05608028918504715, 0.04081512615084648, -0.03512190282344818, -0.009494121186435223, -0.005319121293723583, 0.030596664175391197, -0.02645781636238098, -0.028903743252158165, -0.02626514434814453, -0.031633537262678146, 0.0684552863240242, 0.0014651961391791701, -0.04702604562044144, 0.011390149593353271, 0.001490958034992218, -0.025021890178322792, 0.038785263895988464, -0.0005532270879484713, -0.00636620307341218, 0.049627117812633514, -0.03071656823158264, -0.002428145846351981, -0.014553952030837536, -0.044417575001716614, -0.0029727062210440636, 0.01754508726298809, 0.020135559141635895, -0.023458674550056458, 0.03945661708712578, 0.01448859740048647, -0.0013186974683776498, 0.00013402095646597445, -0.032995834946632385, -0.008958183228969574, 0.019334647804498672, -0.051343172788619995, 0.0064690993167459965, -0.0004679645935539156, 0.03314608335494995, -0.014179378747940063, -0.028955480083823204, -0.02601797692477703, -0.06347706913948059, -0.02816213294863701, -0.027361523360013962, 0.011195861734449863, 0.002222678856924176, 0.05078541114926338, -0.03207655996084213, 0.06145370379090309, -0.02008366957306862, 0.010375188663601875, -0.01900426670908928, -0.0824294239282608, 0.018591634929180145, -0.019346456974744797, -0.021029746159911156, -0.017878007143735886, -0.02715829573571682, -0.022515729069709778, -0.018713993951678276, 0.046370238065719604, -0.03673360496759415, -0.020118502900004387, -0.0015145456418395042, 0.02211741916835308, -0.03255943953990936, -0.0026567294262349606, -0.02608858421444893, 0.0432940348982811, -0.018335148692131042, 0.041039660573005676, 0.03442050516605377, -0.0006577643216587603, -0.038037221878767014, 0.003056737594306469, -0.006387949455529451, 0.04565168172121048, 0.00173032539896667, -0.030124248936772346, -0.0586039237678051, -0.06734947115182877, -0.07607530057430267, 0.018628446385264397, 0.009827817790210247, -0.0027236780151724815, 0.003124123439192772, -0.04548661410808563, 0.0712837278842926, 0.05878165364265442, 0.030015988275408745, -0.08848206698894501, -0.01951552741229534, -0.027350064367055893, -0.03546873852610588, -0.0035855823662132025, 0.022239485755562782, -0.038338400423526764, 0.02465212531387806, -0.08859891444444656, 0.022515730932354927, -0.012489012442529202, 0.06976884603500366, 0.027630288153886795, -0.003778640879318118, -0.07448737323284149, -0.03590647503733635, -0.046595245599746704, 0.020728478208184242, 0.009772777557373047, 0.026206472888588905, -0.0055527472868561745, 0.025691810995340347, -0.03385406732559204, -0.005591037217527628, -0.014044963754713535, -0.0667867511510849, -0.001135714235715568, 0.00950526911765337, 0.01198990736156702, 0.0032133031636476517, 0.03813216835260391, 0.0026938242372125387, -0.013524221256375313, -0.014292731881141663, -0.008227805607020855, -0.03132425621151924, -0.051110222935676575, -0.06028564274311066, 0.01827879622578621, -0.04394178092479706, 0.013938468880951405, -0.010232887230813503, 0.012147453613579273, -0.0059999157674610615, -0.04913964867591858, -0.042845286428928375, 0.052517227828502655, 0.021070249378681183, 0.03450138494372368, 0.0518898069858551, -0.04832148551940918, 0.009426690638065338, -0.03414979577064514, -0.010049819014966488, -0.06755232810974121, 0.03158469498157501, 0.013241124339401722, -0.044537387788295746, -0.018115157261490822, -0.053627125918865204, 0.013829941861331463, -0.02806018479168415, 0.004875724669545889, 0.01339825801551342, 0.007853955961763859, -0.059158388525247574, -0.020077304914593697, -0.050840169191360474, -0.03616773337125778, 0.03954077139496803, -0.0133963106200099, -0.02712354250252247, -0.003598349168896675, 0.06364093720912933, 0.04196517542004585, 0.021936245262622833, 0.023312659934163094, 0.05952730402350426, 0.01732221245765686, 0.045080218464136124, 0.01603936031460762, -0.03692365437746048, 0.0012122372863814235, -0.0034676892682909966, 0.013670792803168297, -0.06394173949956894, -0.057549696415662766, -0.02639561891555786, 0.026879172772169113, 0.003939236048609018, -0.05777435749769211, 0.01768057979643345, 0.02202482521533966, -0.003999748732894659, -0.042600151151418686, 0.05966828390955925, 0.018063969910144806, -0.010813902132213116, 0.035052135586738586, 0.018706172704696655, 0.055743563920259476, -0.04218823462724686 ]
The cultural heritage buildings (CHB), which are part of mankind's history and identity, are in constant danger of damage or in extreme situations total destruction. That being said, it's of utmost importance to preserve them by identifying the existent, or presumptive, defects using novel methods so that renovation processes can be done in a timely manner and with higher accuracy. The main goal of this research is to use new deep learning (DL) methods in the process of preserving CHBs (situated in Iran); a goal that has been neglected especially in developing countries such as Iran, as these countries still preserve their CHBs using manual, and even archaic, methods that need direct human supervision. Having proven their effectiveness and performance when it comes to processing images, the convolutional neural networks (CNN) are a staple in computer vision (CV) literacy and this paper is not exempt. When lacking enough CHB images, training a CNN from scratch would be very difficult and prone to overfitting; that's why we opted to use a technique called transfer learning (TL) in which we used pre-trained ResNet, MobileNet, and Inception networks, for classification. Even more, the Grad-CAM was utilized to localize the defects to some extent. The final results were very favorable based on those of similar research. The final proposed model can pave the way for moving from manual to unmanned CHB conservation, hence an increase in accuracy and a decrease in human-induced errors.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14354v1
[ 0.017612168565392494, -0.037662722170352936, 0.020021874457597733, -0.0237304475158453, -0.014519046060740948, -0.028586026281118393, 0.006071729119867086, -0.014720604754984379, -0.01588829979300499, -0.040381863713264465, -0.012014324776828289, 0.0048117549158632755, -0.0499054379761219, 0.017611460760235786, -0.04572509601712227, 0.026015808805823326, 0.07814958691596985, 0.008759060874581337, -0.04924824461340904, 0.09379392862319946, 0.005519665777683258, -0.019052056595683098, -0.036199990659952164, -0.005129946395754814, 0.034533146768808365, -0.027017779648303986, -0.05219489708542824, 0.06026351451873779, -0.022240348160266876, -0.052135106176137924, 0.06285267323255539, -0.03272314369678497, -0.007697014138102531, -0.04987480118870735, -0.03773043304681778, -0.002862474648281932, -0.007868288084864616, 0.04630555212497711, 0.0014377001207321882, -0.04778526350855827, 0.030660150572657585, -0.06445881724357605, -0.03946830704808235, -0.048752304166555405, -0.056841012090444565, -0.016616491600871086, -0.05573716759681702, -0.010693365707993507, -0.07816504687070847, -0.03342176973819733, 0.03811490908265114, 0.032374076545238495, -0.008858622051775455, 0.043236956000328064, 0.013056842610239983, -0.004459473770111799, -0.0073118689469993114, 0.04172561317682266, -0.05013040080666542, -0.00030469277407974005, 0.024298977106809616, -0.021824991330504417, 0.013975408859550953, -0.04997443035244942, 0.03433966264128685, 0.05969696491956711, -0.02141142077744007, -0.0541156530380249, -0.0428570881485939, -0.04775021970272064, 0.07123233377933502, -0.0736822560429573, 0.01371549442410469, -0.004270072560757399, -0.012063687667250633, -0.02749142237007618, -0.008794485591351986, -0.038742274045944214, 0.032615114003419876, -0.01179430354386568, -0.07457461208105087, 0.0760372206568718, 0.04176744818687439, -0.025160182267427444, -0.030550038442015648, -0.04081922769546509, 0.07630332559347153, 0.006052975542843342, -0.014084853231906891, -0.0497748963534832, 0.046518027782440186, -0.03370073810219765, -0.06397951394319534, -0.028404248878359795, 0.046656884253025055, 0.01883312687277794, 0.04061933234333992, 0.054614949971437454, -0.023665891960263252, 0.008798105642199516, 0.044502634555101395, 0.019236262887716293, -0.016148051247000694, 0.06932595372200012, 0.0021284986287355423, -0.032104749232530594, -0.020528659224510193, -0.010059799067676067, -0.027929004281759262, 0.002667296677827835, 0.002985583618283272, -0.03356543555855751, -0.019787868484854698, -0.07135181874036789, -0.01402868889272213, -0.02649707905948162, 0.04692615941166878, -0.015320386737585068, 0.0034491794649511576, -0.013326723128557205, -0.046072572469711304, 0.016292830929160118, 0.05373675748705864, -0.0033418128732591867, 0.01695193164050579, -0.004812846425920725, 0.03285428136587143, 0.004386259242892265, -0.034854840487241745, -0.0071715181693434715, 0.0019327201880514622, 0.04970336705446243, -0.011728903278708458, -0.027211327105760574, 0.04369041323661804, -0.01717005856335163, -0.0015362720005214214, -0.06497224420309067, 0.031059522181749344, -0.007457881234586239, -0.006654961500316858, -0.017246996983885765, 0.01808011345565319, -0.01601589471101761, 0.01716807298362255, 0.06086654216051102, -0.014744634740054607, -0.03321292996406555, 0.022628603503108025, 0.04070868343114853, 0.015566452406346798, 0.029248850420117378, 0.037484366446733475, 0.023581724613904953, -0.015225990675389767, -0.04860473424196243, 0.024568121880292892, 0.019309161230921745, -0.05964716896414757, -0.010086159221827984, -0.0009551518596708775, -0.055005550384521484, 0.013816975988447666, -0.022209106013178825, 0.034689463675022125, -0.014934761449694633, 0.03427552431821823, -0.007935764268040657, 0.008473019115626812, 0.027898212894797325, -0.003876676084473729, -0.031180191785097122, 0.00849918369203806, 0.04252896085381508, -0.059557344764471054, 0.006987544242292643, 0.023285124450922012, -0.04166463762521744, 0.0025914350990206003, 0.010955477133393288, 0.013281242921948433, 0.04730580002069473, -0.009428393095731735, -0.02174128033220768, -0.0023370475973933935, 0.016355086117982864, -0.08806796371936798, 0.006865268107503653, 0.03461795672774315, -0.017594480887055397, -0.06650279462337494, -0.006759590469300747, 0.004413447342813015, -0.031998056918382645, -0.007100964896380901, -0.03856557235121727, -0.00934342760592699, -0.07138346135616302, 0.047290556132793427, -0.007593751884996891, -0.09203322976827621, 0.0015801970148459077, -0.0665450319647789, 0.002010305877774954, 0.04146848991513252, -0.05426774546504021, -0.021745046600699425, 0.03960495442152023, -0.04790866747498512, 0.01819092035293579, -0.004246050026267767, 0.02477140538394451, 0.03155810758471489, 0.021172206848859787, 0.060641996562480927, 0.022264733910560608, -0.11746300756931305, 0.049280039966106415, 0.02565515786409378, 0.017191261053085327, 0.00729374261572957, -0.05315452814102173, 0.001775633660145104, -0.008965049870312214, -0.011420083232223988, -0.02956092357635498, 0.06789255142211914, -0.000370411406038329, -0.006422742269933224, -0.05936237424612045, -0.019241679459810257, -0.046339161694049835, -0.020820941776037216, -0.07506434619426727, 0.01151126716285944, -0.03224233165383339, -0.06261495500802994, 0.03568915277719498, -0.013203800655901432, -0.03773258626461029, -0.06097307428717613, -0.018154583871364594, 0.01879984140396118, -0.021611876785755157, -0.059467945247888565, 0.008783319965004921, -0.009210782125592232, 0.009151841513812542, -0.008687599562108517, -0.04550498351454735, -0.03775688633322716, -0.07493294775485992, 0.040849022567272186, -0.024324119091033936, 0.006933998316526413, 0.020620400086045265, -0.026638435199856758, -0.001713507459498942, -0.02816595323383808, 0.02365228720009327, 0.036642808467149734, 0.028751764446496964, -0.05806763097643852, -0.0013991728192195296, 0.02959870547056198, 0.008989972993731499, 0.0125967375934124, -0.004319355357438326, 0.021994488313794136, -0.025353455916047096, -0.023810498416423798, 0.05143623799085617, 0.045015640556812286, 0.01508669089525938, -0.02462310902774334, -0.036765240132808685, 0.06628283113241196, -0.0444038026034832, 0.0024280271027237177, -0.0057854908518493176, -0.005849041976034641, 0.04242148622870445, -0.027815185487270355, -0.0694684088230133, -0.01265799067914486, -0.04889066517353058, -0.057135552167892456, -0.03980907425284386, -0.03936717286705971, -0.017091820016503334, -0.03508307784795761, -0.02221163548529148, 0.017882775515317917, -0.04585767164826393, 0.00959093403071165, -0.023928703740239143, -0.023826513439416885, -0.012073875404894352, 0.01754101924598217, 0.001386119402013719, 0.01704993098974228, -0.05013484135270119, 0.015291267074644566, 0.014277677983045578, 0.045226115733385086, -0.010084634646773338, -0.05192386358976364, -0.03439697250723839, 0.035256292670965195, 0.018343647941946983, -0.010091498494148254, 0.0005516206729225814, -0.032491907477378845, 0.03239816054701805, 0.02925713174045086, 0.03129594773054123, -0.011416460387408733, -0.007384180091321468, -0.01216223742812872, -0.06796211749315262, 0.005789868999272585, -0.00909585040062666, -0.031616710126399994, -0.022701561450958252, -0.0198063887655735, -0.011072712950408459, 0.05926055088639259, -0.007275367621332407, -0.013728821650147438, -0.039599206298589706, 0.014285771176218987, -0.0035883355885744095, -0.0019130341242998838, -0.020280687138438225, -0.007271603215485811, 0.007139736786484718, -0.06208441033959389, 0.000605270266532898, 0.016996821388602257, -0.008008930832147598, 0.021416964009404182, 0.005113610532134771, -0.05821865797042847, -0.035166382789611816, 0.0027601157780736685, -0.08000258356332779, 0.023437777534127235, 0.04187269136309624, 0.07649127393960953, 0.023412048816680908, 0.028196608647704124, 0.038157738745212555, 0.02458205074071884, 0.011020401492714882, -0.005510739516466856, 0.008769740350544453, 0.06426019966602325, 0.059649839997291565, -0.029546532779932022, 0.020456893369555473, 0.03211873769760132, -0.019474303349852562, -0.006727040279656649, -0.0011257452424615622, 0.03315466642379761, 0.047974877059459686, -0.024928199127316475, -0.03968937695026398, 0.03373657166957855, -0.041789449751377106, 0.03962676227092743, -0.02491748332977295, -0.028986096382141113, 0.053055986762046814, -0.018885018303990364, 0.04200201854109764, 0.0014930464094504714, 0.014341358095407486, 0.014175514690577984, -0.06232820451259613, -0.006733665708452463, -0.05034899339079857, 0.0347619503736496, -0.0231351125985384, -0.005976499989628792, 0.046971652656793594, 0.049269966781139374, -0.02753949537873268, 0.04638813063502312, -0.005718273110687733, -0.016331108286976814, -0.03911930322647095, 0.013262440450489521, -0.020689576864242554, -0.022297555580735207, -0.03958303481340408, 0.016445059329271317, 0.06062125042080879, 0.04582364112138748, 0.03101395070552826, 0.005274991970509291, 0.011124017648398876, -0.023090220987796783, -0.06593307107686996, 0.00408419081941247, 0.0019276809180155396, -0.0013394916895776987, -0.021712809801101685, -0.008169455453753471, 0.059915635734796524, -0.0361577570438385, -0.0067016794346272945, -0.05402094125747681, -0.020502472296357155, -0.045538485050201416, 0.013494892977178097, 0.0307752825319767, -0.08767469972372055, -0.012035449035465717, -0.054946452379226685, 0.06766290962696075, 0.03441708907485008, -0.008863760158419609, -0.035298604518175125, 0.0032364437356591225, 0.029411204159259796, -0.003820544807240367, 0.051488131284713745, 0.015964427962899208, -0.04419693723320961, 0.022796615958213806, 0.016698915511369705, -0.028974244371056557, 0.0012626377865672112, 0.027645504102110863, -0.037460170686244965, 0.036056216806173325, 0.02130942977964878, -0.006124650128185749, -0.03731989488005638, -0.04621834680438042, 0.058558572083711624, -0.06279155611991882, -0.007874127477407455, 0.03544964641332626, 0.04439597204327583, -0.015731362625956535, -0.05303562432527542, -0.0027817923109978437, -0.039313580840826035, -0.0401136577129364, -0.036265648901462555, 0.015673959627747536, 0.06134871393442154, -0.019667694345116615, 0.016705896705389023, 0.05619841814041138, -0.00843151193112135, 0.029553327709436417, 0.01797901839017868, -0.01741996593773365, 0.025378599762916565, -0.011178766377270222, -0.03139879181981087, -0.05814327672123909, 0.02081959694623947, 0.01409240998327732, 0.04794662818312645, 0.02071688510477543, 0.036802664399147034, -0.028302380815148354, 0.04459027200937271, -0.09454526752233505, -0.001873617060482502, 0.03481574356555939, 0.01019625086337328, 0.00811429601162672, 0.0771707147359848, 0.030823202803730965, 0.05712543800473213, -0.05936058610677719, 0.018087631091475487, 0.053032588213682175, -0.05419556051492691, 0.03680912405252457, 0.039380885660648346, -0.06497829407453537, 0.006001841742545366, 0.024024924263358116, -0.007078804075717926, -0.030991654843091965, 0.017384584993124008, 0.05898384377360344, 0.0004152552573941648, -0.0267048180103302, 0.014155262149870396, 0.0009550093091093004, 0.011454873718321323, 0.005078241229057312, 0.00410534767434001, 0.015026893466711044, 0.019960518926382065, 0.024400856345891953, -0.03452424332499504, -0.02855580486357212, 0.02083284594118595, -0.0004689060151576996, 0.03276617452502251, -0.01942174695432186, 0.04039740189909935, 0.028113380074501038, -0.03710908070206642, 0.03100457787513733, -0.051676198840141296, -0.06412261724472046, -0.05967909097671509, 0.0412837415933609, 0.038763243705034256, 0.01430038083344698, -0.00840486865490675, 0.02961019054055214, -0.04669753834605217, -0.002352363197132945, 0.0016819601878523827, -0.014525367878377438, 0.026531973853707314, -0.0367223285138607, 0.07774496078491211, -0.004685631953179836, 0.03540702536702156, 0.01732565276324749, 0.05650220066308975, 0.01813316158950329, 0.04510173946619034, -0.0013796200510114431, -0.013436331413686275, 0.023537075147032738, -0.04987456277012825, -0.05448763445019722, 0.04880005493760109, 0.008490580134093761, -0.02646949328482151, 0.017239417880773544, 0.06118552386760712, -0.03905308246612549, 0.05324951559305191, -0.01773969642817974, -0.030205992981791496, -0.020318856462836266, 0.013433697633445263, 0.06980159133672714, -0.04648841544985771, 0.02767837606370449, 0.041600313037633896, 0.0050627985037863255, 0.050515856593847275, -0.010878498665988445, -0.03401003032922745, 0.042246945202350616, -0.011552521958947182, -0.037634555250406265, 0.03709317743778229, -0.02914537861943245, -0.07682241499423981, -0.0023026173003017902, 0.021355684846639633, -0.074547678232193, 0.02554413117468357, -0.012488189153373241, 0.024093452841043472, -0.05896081030368805, 0.05634402483701706, 0.014973055571317673, 0.004745686426758766, -0.03502343222498894, 0.08312191814184189, 0.08479539304971695, 0.013591826893389225, -0.0028984611853957176, -0.016425488516688347, -0.04579910635948181, -0.016570057719945908, 0.004039029125124216, -0.005291463807225227, 0.04238679260015488, 0.035477086901664734, 0.03559400141239166, -0.0029432920273393393, -0.03818798065185547, 0.058659084141254425, -0.01762157306075096, 0.029418714344501495, 0.019767796620726585, -0.02635963447391987, 0.0895431712269783, -0.007705731317400932, -0.01839037798345089, 0.014725198037922382, -0.007140098139643669, 0.008514578454196453, -0.01672857254743576, -0.03662215545773506, -0.027349580079317093, 0.0058520277962088585, 0.005326167680323124, -0.066038116812706, 0.0037783922161906958, -0.03904954716563225, -0.08047327399253845, 0.023641882464289665, -0.01901944912970066, 0.02245994098484516, -0.04084007069468498, 0.013849273324012756, -0.010802811942994595, 0.012479419820010662, -0.03929542750120163, 0.009360904805362225, 0.03408122435212135, -0.02344946563243866, 0.04442348703742027, -0.03693925216794014, 0.04385888949036598, 0.0069390637800097466, -0.03702285885810852, -0.02858685329556465, -0.029689384624361992, -0.01569712720811367, -0.0010504208039492369, -0.0017084229039028287, -0.03431543707847595, -0.03412604704499245, -0.03885926306247711, 0.04110013321042061, 0.020002761855721474, 0.04984298720955849, 0.037618424743413925, -0.003683749819174409, -0.06058279424905777, 0.022025402635335922, 0.003864676458761096, 0.008093997836112976, 0.017350047826766968, 0.023403989151120186, 0.008641918189823627, 0.03323549032211304, 0.03774559870362282, 0.010767380706965923, -0.030750472098588943, -0.007020073011517525, -0.023976199328899384, -0.014031308703124523, -0.00956282764673233, -0.0036375466734170914, -0.055625248700380325, 0.023545587435364723, -0.029856916517019272, -0.08183933049440384, -0.021004706621170044, 0.052779220044612885, -0.003955261316150427, -0.021082138642668724, -0.06946492940187454, 0.04145637899637222, -0.013515828177332878, -0.02982480451464653, -0.03674657642841339, 0.03736266493797302, -0.019671963527798653, -0.051157791167497635, -0.016722869127988815, -0.005140990484505892, 0.02490726299583912, 0.0077274558134377, -0.08834872394800186, 0.012591426260769367, -0.010534198023378849, 0.056798577308654785, 0.008441057056188583, -0.009137731045484543, 0.009198513813316822, -0.04383011907339096, 0.023244911804795265, 0.0384131520986557, 0.009245808236300945, 0.04839784651994705, 0.05350678041577339, 0.02749030478298664, -0.04303094372153282, -0.05163281038403511, -0.01693803071975708, -0.0346517451107502, 0.018515344709157944, 0.024604467675089836, 0.04505472257733345, -0.0101108243688941, 0.022269180044531822, 0.07251705974340439, -0.017633017152547836, 0.05364441126585007, -0.032745491713285446, -0.0015092615503817797, -0.03024470992386341, -0.03647692874073982, 0.0025686139706522226, -0.02726111188530922, -0.03397773951292038, 0.05160322040319443, -0.02607928216457367, 0.01581740193068981, -0.0003456477716099471, 0.0013985540717840195, 0.0262555293738842, -0.0363147109746933, 0.013307888060808182, 0.027252333238720894, -0.042360056191682816, -0.0402241051197052, -0.03809477016329765, -0.0380573496222496, -0.05687014386057854, -0.019936837255954742, 0.06200885772705078, -0.052192315459251404, -0.015294091776013374, -0.06440556049346924, 0.011999211274087429, -0.020244093611836433, 0.034217581152915955, -0.014793740585446358, 0.06796485185623169, 0.009418106637895107, 0.00037249145680107176, -0.0541096106171608, -0.051253095269203186, -0.041553955525159836, -0.04436025768518448, -0.025115065276622772, -0.04344915971159935, 0.0478452704846859, -0.021532028913497925, -0.027616890147328377, 0.04315163195133209, 0.07524174451828003, 0.050582319498062134, 0.031770844012498856, 0.02054762654006481, -0.013147896155714989, -0.025407416746020317, 0.08996958285570145, 0.0233446154743433, 0.046192899346351624, -0.02126622013747692, 0.05590760335326195, 0.018434563651680946, -0.020578106865286827, 0.004158931318670511, -0.059478022158145905, -0.010641676373779774, -0.0742982029914856, -0.019513245671987534, -0.020550478249788284, -0.021546006202697754, -0.05194514989852905, -0.026964228600263596, 0.009092532098293304, -0.03653429076075554, -0.004882742650806904 ]
Rare life events significantly impact mental health, and their detection in behavioral studies is a crucial step towards health-based interventions. We envision that mobile sensing data can be used to detect these anomalies. However, the human-centered nature of the problem, combined with the infrequency and uniqueness of these events makes it challenging for unsupervised machine learning methods. In this paper, we first investigate granger-causality between life events and human behavior using sensing data. Next, we propose a multi-task framework with an unsupervised autoencoder to capture irregular behavior, and an auxiliary sequence predictor that identifies transitions in workplace performance to contextualize events. We perform experiments using data from a mobile sensing study comprising N=126 information workers from multiple industries, spanning 10106 days with 198 rare events (<2%). Through personalized inference, we detect the exact day of a rare event with an F1 of 0.34, demonstrating that our method outperforms several baselines. Finally, we discuss the implications of our work from the context of real-world deployment.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.20056v1
[ -0.014241049066185951, -0.052069008350372314, 0.04964364692568779, -0.026254024356603622, 0.000831783632747829, 0.0020190502982586622, 0.03707290068268776, 0.019559672102332115, -0.010418731719255447, -0.06306393444538116, -0.04421854764223099, -0.033461879938840866, -0.037775978446006775, -0.01383423525840044, -0.019856734201312065, 0.046012695878744125, 0.055048566311597824, 0.024122299626469612, -0.03379515931010246, 0.05723714083433151, 0.05762060359120369, -0.027349097654223442, 0.0020918811205774546, -0.004836484789848328, -0.004128692205995321, -0.02783505618572235, 0.050713006407022476, -0.005592003930360079, -0.012274705804884434, -0.03611066937446594, 0.05397168546915054, -0.024637920781970024, -0.009390107356011868, -0.03953203186392784, -0.030397232621908188, -0.011113045737147331, -0.0042913067154586315, 0.03619907423853874, -0.030211150646209717, -0.009779047220945358, -0.022304672747850418, -0.009023596532642841, -0.045342497527599335, 0.009219127707183361, -0.0378517284989357, 0.021546998992562294, -0.02735305391252041, -0.015689991414546967, -0.0482352040708065, -0.05421809107065201, 0.0335984081029892, 0.007689099293202162, 0.004227705765515566, 0.029222507029771805, -0.02550964243710041, -0.02299913391470909, -0.014873424544930458, 0.049043189734220505, -0.03649019077420235, -0.004411426372826099, 0.060503844171762466, -0.03609602898359299, 0.044877972453832626, -0.022289423272013664, 0.029136795550584793, 0.061995979398489, -0.01001311931759119, -0.07642655819654465, -0.0028807173948735, -0.0666085034608841, 0.010608554817736149, -0.04856269434094429, -0.007167309056967497, 0.010337937623262405, -0.04391227290034294, -0.007741434499621391, -0.04139035940170288, 0.01623006910085678, 0.004620111081749201, 0.034904494881629944, -0.016491517424583435, 0.028148217126727104, 0.037685152143239975, -0.02425971068441868, -0.004141725599765778, -0.05825284495949745, 0.07472804933786392, -0.03486643359065056, -0.0031571153085678816, -0.032700568437576294, 0.03488752245903015, -0.06865769624710083, -0.06252704560756683, -0.02703380584716797, 0.03489871323108673, -0.02098384127020836, 0.03561464697122574, 0.01761220581829548, 0.004286746494472027, -0.002033735392615199, -0.023284096270799637, 0.014642814174294472, 0.003972329199314117, 0.06755243241786957, 0.02938861772418022, -0.053213685750961304, -0.04888585954904556, -0.043521616607904434, -0.07370036840438843, -0.007032634224742651, -0.04449950158596039, -0.017285248264670372, -0.041429147124290466, -0.08254826068878174, -0.048778265714645386, -0.062075696885585785, 0.05870140343904495, 0.009029189124703407, 0.03144082427024841, 0.0070789470337331295, -0.03342162445187569, 0.07721471786499023, -0.006979655474424362, -0.01049995981156826, -0.023691345006227493, 0.015293710865080357, 0.05643351748585701, -0.010612153448164463, -0.04997647926211357, -0.03276314586400986, -0.01005226094275713, 0.029222816228866577, -0.0346376895904541, 0.014860132709145546, 0.0316586047410965, -0.0018537587020546198, -0.019162967801094055, -0.05455267056822777, 0.01643058843910694, -0.017630351707339287, -0.052357230335474014, -0.02329644374549389, -0.026797205209732056, -0.04506063088774681, -0.025375118479132652, 0.03041764162480831, -0.05643928423523903, -0.013934114947915077, 0.07299595326185226, 0.005951295606791973, -0.03010825626552105, -0.01603233814239502, 0.033271919935941696, 0.029723789542913437, 0.04934176802635193, -0.03910905122756958, 0.04231708496809006, -0.04818916320800781, -0.0631527230143547, -0.001710359239950776, 0.013994409702718258, -0.045962486416101456, 0.03098548948764801, -0.059507451951503754, 0.03231479600071907, -0.02323920652270317, 0.03293420746922493, -0.030565405264496803, -0.043648574501276016, -0.023732012137770653, -0.010888914577662945, -0.015002600848674774, 0.019202936440706253, -0.03772895783185959, -0.04858461022377014, -0.017530595883727074, 0.053033653646707535, -0.040988896042108536, -0.0407295823097229, 0.006204416509717703, -0.018701128661632538, 0.039916686713695526, 0.007427994627505541, 0.025076624006032944, -0.03484226390719414, -0.008362834341824055, -0.07957843691110611, -0.042305003851652145, 0.029714688658714294, -0.007665690500289202, -0.05003035068511963, -0.051293663680553436, 0.02008938416838646, -0.0030572921968996525, -0.0310994740575552, -0.01561624463647604, 0.014195125550031662, -0.025982342660427094, 0.009605903178453445, 0.037683404982089996, -0.08404874801635742, -0.02425653673708439, -0.06918274611234665, -0.03903986141085625, -0.023953266441822052, -0.04414023086428642, 0.02448572963476181, 0.009458768181502819, -0.019918033853173256, -0.018754521384835243, 0.045758794993162155, 0.0008485628059133887, 0.06072373688220978, 0.03741351515054703, 0.024619899690151215, -0.037336964160203934, -0.0968913659453392, 0.04932820051908493, 0.025003653019666672, -0.009999345988035202, 0.0004310505755711347, -0.014993757009506226, -0.02063157595694065, -0.011438874527812004, -0.009316928684711456, 0.05736324563622475, 0.007742761168628931, 0.006430828478187323, -0.03800877928733826, -0.029523435980081558, -0.03492969274520874, -0.08091884106397629, -0.055127982050180435, -0.07769376784563065, -0.009873584844172001, -0.019605528563261032, -0.027637923136353493, 0.04331762716174126, -0.02254282683134079, 0.004290881101042032, -0.03245561569929123, -0.016897397115826607, 0.05449056625366211, -0.004612304270267487, -0.03910542652010918, -0.04439365118741989, -0.009587893262505531, 0.015854468569159508, -0.013776670210063457, -0.0009172380669042468, -0.0027232682332396507, -0.06115487590432167, 0.014006496407091618, -0.028357254341244698, -0.0030974927358329296, 0.053990770131349564, -0.03810160234570503, 0.03402780741453171, -0.0005433593760244548, 0.04938346892595291, 0.0066979113034904, 0.048772182315588, -0.052732016891241074, -0.005469679832458496, 0.05477042496204376, -0.0034273280762135983, -0.030438624322414398, -0.02188020944595337, 0.01541027519851923, -0.03784859925508499, 0.008605115115642548, 0.013205667026340961, 0.03310052305459976, -0.024161819368600845, -0.053694434463977814, -0.06546685099601746, 0.017065441235899925, -0.04696561396121979, 0.037053029984235764, 0.03861761465668678, 0.04721364006400108, 0.019517259672284126, 0.05094590783119202, -0.06039849668741226, -0.011063125915825367, -0.03844406083226204, -0.04539693519473076, -0.06899666786193848, -0.049340035766363144, 0.006130915600806475, -0.06643592566251755, -0.005680468399077654, -0.002699467586353421, -0.04883435741066933, -0.023378245532512665, -0.06239337846636772, -0.06671176105737686, 0.022385474294424057, 0.003981240559369326, -0.023152900859713554, -0.02250921167433262, -0.03857170790433884, 0.02538939379155636, -0.0030401458498090506, 0.02656148374080658, -0.028761617839336395, -0.023244213312864304, -0.03768278658390045, -0.020298508927226067, -0.01643551141023636, 0.0369686521589756, 0.03834432363510132, -0.021168721839785576, 0.007148437667638063, -0.040173936635255814, 0.005457607097923756, -0.02400457300245762, -0.00673873582854867, -0.0144265778362751, -0.024969806894659996, 0.05538928508758545, -0.050981972366571426, 0.05206727981567383, -0.026571376249194145, -0.04106924310326576, 0.03271118924021721, 0.06715144962072372, 0.038870085030794144, -0.015240618959069252, -0.032604414969682693, -0.012453150004148483, 0.030587203800678253, 0.018156666308641434, -0.013456990011036396, 0.033301256597042084, -0.03199019655585289, -0.056981660425662994, 0.009442005306482315, -0.027978556230664253, 0.05610889568924904, 0.017932254821062088, -0.026298124343156815, -0.040755193680524826, -0.009938526898622513, 0.02317098341882229, -0.07980619370937347, -0.027542809024453163, 0.03641415387392044, 0.07380013167858124, -0.0019391141831874847, 0.042949095368385315, 0.01866172067821026, 0.02347531169652939, 0.018894469365477562, 0.037239111959934235, 0.008085429668426514, 0.049283966422080994, 0.06652297079563141, -0.004640481434762478, -0.054614122956991196, 0.028299875557422638, -0.06685864180326462, -0.06483057886362076, -0.03175002709031105, 0.030591972172260284, 0.02332262694835663, 0.04683858901262283, -0.042147815227508545, 0.029451215639710426, -0.007317715790122747, 0.05748095363378525, -0.011406676843762398, -0.012952505610883236, 0.02590106427669525, -0.03801042586565018, 0.03190791606903076, -0.018094336614012718, 0.03374063968658447, 0.00005094187872600742, -0.03682456165552139, 0.007250388152897358, -0.057748910039663315, 0.004527623299509287, 0.01352808065712452, 0.047121837735176086, 0.052599336951971054, 0.036158617585897446, -0.03502697870135307, 0.04674360901117325, -0.028743742033839226, -0.009831402450799942, 0.00669966172426939, -0.05428779870271683, -0.011883816681802273, -0.014966247603297234, -0.065422922372818, -0.029580457136034966, 0.049091845750808716, -0.038096290081739426, -0.0016121332300826907, -0.01887189969420433, -0.021915549412369728, 0.0005858184886164963, -0.08107396960258484, -0.005197238642722368, -0.05506974831223488, 0.04329424351453781, -0.018130572512745857, -0.026804422959685326, 0.06621536612510681, -0.03547023609280586, -0.028191378340125084, -0.04214469715952873, -0.026187550276517868, -0.016977459192276, 0.026820486411452293, -0.029904574155807495, -0.056947797536849976, -0.04000796750187874, -0.042211610823869705, 0.017412513494491577, -0.017153682187199593, -0.013635479845106602, -0.044171493500471115, -0.006558976601809263, 0.015964478254318237, 0.039078209549188614, 0.01868193969130516, 0.019176693633198738, 0.01428879052400589, -0.051671065390110016, 0.03270595148205757, -0.009228460490703583, -0.009134877473115921, 0.04100608825683594, -0.02347375638782978, 0.027806371450424194, -0.02332804910838604, -0.021765979006886482, -0.02713417261838913, -0.02816714532673359, 0.07281998544931412, 0.03333531320095062, -0.0294815544039011, -0.015443868935108185, 0.03658858686685562, -0.033387381583452225, -0.04532887041568756, -0.038336772471666336, -0.04973402991890907, -0.03113425523042679, 0.00466950936242938, 0.020083699375391006, 0.02877969667315483, -0.012244214303791523, 0.036036498844623566, -0.0047037941403687, 0.020167144015431404, -0.045030951499938965, 0.019082045182585716, 0.0021071608643978834, 0.024506496265530586, 0.025576943531632423, -0.022368552163243294, -0.07260237634181976, -0.017277145758271217, -0.00854483526200056, -0.039199937134981155, -0.03560227155685425, 0.06108221411705017, 0.023116258904337883, 0.03153519704937935, -0.07980640977621078, 0.03349163010716438, 0.02712978795170784, -0.02128480188548565, 0.031952403485774994, 0.04699629917740822, -0.018955672159790993, 0.004660260863602161, -0.062254585325717926, -0.03937390819191933, 0.012549865059554577, -0.014574356377124786, -0.02298777550458908, -0.005038061644881964, -0.014497376047074795, -0.03292200341820717, 0.03629600256681442, -0.0645308867096901, -0.0639224424958229, -0.014761103317141533, -0.00936646293848753, 0.00714947609230876, -0.041241709142923355, 0.04142838716506958, -0.000060526632296387106, -0.019456181675195694, -0.04356369376182556, -0.03575310483574867, -0.0054076178930699825, 0.03968320041894913, 0.03574046492576599, -0.06995180994272232, -0.0014091931516304612, 0.010747939348220825, 0.005816537421196699, -0.0040962835773825645, -0.01465238444507122, -0.004902251996099949, -0.02118382602930069, 0.05281432718038559, 0.01293580885976553, -0.06943048536777496, -0.03577471897006035, -0.00021885645401198417, 0.04391085356473923, 0.03303058445453644, -0.007414729800075293, 0.038694966584444046, -0.0069585880264639854, -0.01796220801770687, -0.03749554976820946, -0.037647753953933716, -0.02689337730407715, 0.021922912448644638, -0.005081874318420887, 0.04105618596076965, -0.0022142319940030575, 0.058283623307943344, 0.03814069554209709, 0.008884457871317863, 0.020700708031654358, -0.003735190024599433, -0.02793773077428341, -0.025456693023443222, 0.014107239432632923, -0.04697929695248604, -0.06411026418209076, 0.002314978279173374, 0.018367871642112732, -0.0052288551814854145, 0.008665363304316998, 0.024384142830967903, -0.04678749665617943, -0.020168818533420563, 0.016252359375357628, -0.013878997415304184, -0.05269172042608261, 0.026308918371796608, 0.06449577212333679, -0.0352947972714901, -0.011227705515921116, -0.008723526261746883, -0.014343156479299068, -0.008011099882423878, -0.03222355246543884, -0.022131457924842834, 0.022444767877459526, 0.008734939619898796, -0.06705672293901443, 0.013502400368452072, -0.015226494520902634, -0.07013224065303802, -0.03922116011381149, -0.0013918456388637424, -0.06396443396806717, 0.02179565094411373, 0.023585792630910873, 0.0007045150268822908, -0.03294339030981064, 0.051189638674259186, -0.0548824816942215, -0.013808520510792732, -0.004461817443370819, 0.04273797199130058, 0.08419178426265717, 0.01385829783976078, -0.020360104739665985, 0.01988847926259041, -0.033743347972631454, -0.008406907320022583, -0.04502261430025101, 0.025501644238829613, -0.018891066312789917, 0.03553562983870506, -0.02243650145828724, -0.02616325207054615, -0.03571837767958641, 0.08088639378547668, -0.04704964905977249, 0.016022952273488045, 0.042300764471292496, -0.0033110277727246284, 0.005545757245272398, -0.026109125465154648, -0.05609116703271866, -0.007434061728417873, 0.040798477828502655, -0.03746446222066879, -0.04096813499927521, 0.002832697005942464, -0.022415298968553543, 0.015494439750909805, 0.008019029162824154, -0.06302805244922638, -0.025883199647068977, -0.011852595023810863, -0.06615295261144638, 0.05358177796006203, -0.06934352219104767, -0.021669453009963036, -0.017077069729566574, 0.02365987002849579, 0.05969296023249626, 0.0018586054211482406, -0.05186242237687111, -0.005205074790865183, -0.0015170297119766474, 0.009359722957015038, 0.021418435499072075, 0.0051188161596655846, -0.01265766378492117, 0.005865755956619978, 0.012045450508594513, -0.02278846874833107, -0.025812340900301933, -0.02283759042620659, -0.035737812519073486, 0.030363595113158226, -0.019029932096600533, -0.017864208668470383, -0.0617721751332283, 0.006154716946184635, -0.04118110612034798, 0.02165532298386097, 0.05483794957399368, -0.03881882131099701, -0.028221655637025833, 0.004217983689159155, -0.0018235828028991818, 0.013514306396245956, 0.012459340505301952, 0.06291814893484116, 0.01489096600562334, 0.02935807965695858, 0.014557469636201859, 0.03581628203392029, -0.011465323157608509, -0.0001700337161310017, -0.0683383122086525, -0.025797909125685692, 0.04939832165837288, -0.032725121825933456, 0.009976686909794807, -0.022918948903679848, -0.02760588377714157, -0.059829652309417725, -0.00024802127154543996, 0.04550092667341232, -0.006698919925838709, -0.0037073413841426373, -0.07515713572502136, 0.0544571615755558, 0.010021173395216465, -0.04285673052072525, -0.06915348768234253, -0.013344496488571167, -0.007159794215112925, -0.025645188987255096, 0.039514441043138504, 0.01538492739200592, -0.05856766179203987, 0.04074541851878166, -0.07647937536239624, 0.0083928182721138, -0.0025006597861647606, 0.028277475386857986, -0.025120925158262253, -0.05899156630039215, 0.03722883760929108, -0.022433124482631683, 0.00893143005669117, 0.049416135996580124, 0.013284536078572273, 0.03430642560124397, 0.04677895829081535, 0.024850834161043167, -0.06279437988996506, -0.05897640064358711, 0.05338384583592415, -0.05531496927142143, -0.04005727171897888, 0.0629129484295845, 0.03744245320558548, 0.006819174624979496, -0.0476527214050293, 0.027053305879235268, -0.007050079293549061, 0.00433587608858943, -0.023018276318907738, 0.003558272961527109, -0.012868072837591171, -0.06271159648895264, 0.03581026941537857, -0.02231440879404545, -0.0016731137875467539, 0.010367573238909245, -0.02330869808793068, 0.0009342418634332716, -0.05564449727535248, -0.0453714020550251, 0.040836866945028305, 0.026488356292247772, 0.022782497107982635, 0.061200954020023346, -0.026333283632993698, 0.011621695011854172, -0.011196080595254898, 0.0007416015141643584, -0.029590070247650146, 0.00598690053448081, 0.05127384886145592, -0.03161916881799698, -0.014807012863457203, -0.07900701463222504, 0.039672840386629105, 0.015001819469034672, 0.0006206140387803316, -0.047971174120903015, 0.07743526995182037, 0.019961725920438766, -0.03600203990936279, -0.00474588992074132, -0.024941498413681984, -0.0337257981300354, -0.041482213884592056, -0.05169083923101425, 0.011160674504935741, -0.011699738912284374, 0.00979236513376236, 0.005056540947407484, 0.022519614547491074, 0.07110894471406937, -0.002135573886334896, 0.05079067498445511, -0.04376516863703728, -0.013762488961219788, -0.06059323251247406, 0.08158188313245773, -0.01613117940723896, 0.03348598629236221, -0.06656444072723389, -0.0018037890549749136, -0.009957866743206978, 0.0007440909394063056, 0.04172710329294205, -0.00959788914769888, -0.014877009205520153, -0.0701504722237587, -0.012742370367050171, 0.009033716283738613, -0.01773037388920784, -0.032109539955854416, -0.018240924924612045, 0.046889521181583405, -0.03207160905003548, -0.054970115423202515 ]
CaSb$_2$ is a bulk superconductor and a topological semimetal, making it a great platform for realizing topological superconductivity. In this work, we investigate the superconducting upper and lower critical field anisotropy using magnetic susceptibility, and study the superconducting state using muon spin-relaxation. The temperature dependence of transverse-field relaxation rate can be fitted with a single-gap model or two-gap model. Zero-field relaxation shows little temperature dependence when the muon-spin is parallel to the $c*$-axis, while an increase in relaxation appears below 1 K when the muon-spin is parallel to the $ab$-plane. We conclude an $s+is$ order parameter considering the breaking of time-reversal symmetry (TRS), which originates from competing interband interactions between the three bands of CaSb$_2$. To explain the direction-dependent breaking of TRS we suggest loop currents developing in the plane of distorted square-net of Sb atoms.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12457v3
[ -0.05579949542880058, -0.04914291203022003, 0.035832252353429794, 0.021771539002656937, 0.035377513617277145, -0.04157198593020439, -0.018573224544525146, 0.04946824908256531, -0.027363784611225128, -0.004636302124708891, 0.025074198842048645, -0.035589929670095444, 0.01008369866758585, -0.043023496866226196, -0.03750266879796982, 0.026776162907481194, 0.014707574620842934, 0.03922430798411369, -0.02890058420598507, 0.07529426366090775, 0.018971813842654228, -0.024449564516544342, 0.00903998501598835, 0.050230588763952255, -0.03374447301030159, -0.011428553611040115, -0.023178672417998314, 0.008206261321902275, -0.06892061978578568, -0.05100642144680023, 0.05470069497823715, -0.03153587877750397, -0.03776431456208229, 0.018865400925278664, -0.008720689453184605, 0.006668414920568466, 0.024749871343374252, 0.030414056032896042, 0.028411386534571648, -0.018836865201592445, 0.011782758869230747, -0.029008129611611366, -0.027593692764639854, -0.011511292308568954, 0.0014102304121479392, -0.030842293053865433, -0.03438245877623558, 0.01905662566423416, 0.000952058588154614, -0.05316467583179474, 0.04432613402605057, 0.01110148150473833, 0.014625323936343193, 0.06838283687829971, -0.05737179145216942, 0.010880887508392334, 0.034286919981241226, -0.019416799768805504, -0.050301216542720795, -0.010532463900744915, 0.0033071127254515886, -0.052037689834833145, 0.015147662721574306, -0.042426079511642456, -0.05430695787072182, 0.05162782967090607, -0.0419171042740345, -0.05249299108982086, -0.027295103296637535, -0.07180584967136383, 0.0058968402445316315, -0.07703769952058792, 0.04369759559631348, 0.05136712267994881, -0.05431560426950455, -0.028149036690592766, -0.04819740727543831, 0.034771692007780075, -0.00849518645554781, 0.02728511393070221, -0.026102157309651375, 0.014595631510019302, 0.03652364760637283, 0.016083616763353348, 0.04494350031018257, 0.01896105520427227, 0.06131979823112488, -0.028868934139609337, 0.039634399116039276, -0.04723314940929413, -0.016003577038645744, -0.034491002559661865, -0.02104019746184349, -0.05480025336146355, 0.06545659899711609, -0.04037490487098694, 0.0657014474272728, 0.03534482419490814, 0.02607976645231247, -0.0012981109321117401, 0.001271105487830937, -0.059214841574430466, -0.006855600047856569, 0.038408927619457245, 0.003921561874449253, -0.05277462676167488, -0.0035485385451465845, 0.014533978886902332, -0.04477199539542198, 0.05206381529569626, -0.06630990654230118, 0.011016800068318844, 0.03530985489487648, -0.03865237906575203, 0.004397503100335598, -0.0753040537238121, 0.052424728870391846, 0.027988484129309654, 0.04818135127425194, 0.014765752479434013, -0.0125108752399683, 0.033617012202739716, -0.010636274702847004, 0.0061694560572505, 0.02074093371629715, -0.008766698651015759, 0.042967356741428375, 0.006838615983724594, 0.004683090839534998, -0.04083031788468361, 0.020621394738554955, 0.011391021311283112, 0.033886250108480453, -0.03989685699343681, 0.05330236256122589, -0.019889170303940773, 0.041858553886413574, 0.00039261271012946963, 0.0035594848450273275, 0.02982591651380062, -0.008637254126369953, -0.04808450862765312, 0.031130220741033554, 0.04834442958235741, 0.006669078953564167, 0.01633967086672783, -0.07059907913208008, -0.0145706282928586, -0.00523507921025157, 0.03597421571612358, -0.036453913897275925, -0.00956932082772255, 0.05100390315055847, 0.008374208584427834, 0.04208527132868767, -0.002856413135305047, 0.04374033212661743, -0.0016203813720494509, -0.022661233320832253, 0.013036544434726238, 0.04728774353861809, -0.0171174556016922, 0.013334328308701515, -0.002740273717790842, -0.002869471674785018, 0.03343833610415459, 0.01937352865934372, -0.016586266458034515, -0.011061858385801315, -0.007239426951855421, 0.012986916117370129, -0.009040550328791142, 0.022425392642617226, -0.03558559715747833, -0.05679066479206085, -0.029277533292770386, -0.022255897521972656, -0.04084581136703491, -0.017219437286257744, 0.0015315202763304114, 0.03049955889582634, 0.027848588302731514, -0.0026506672147661448, -0.059748005121946335, -0.05871010199189186, 0.02854367531836033, -0.06534166634082794, 0.00871776882559061, -0.003739606821909547, -0.007394220679998398, -0.019543729722499847, -0.03278026729822159, 0.06243353709578514, -0.00419942382723093, -0.03707598149776459, 0.0216656643897295, 0.03756241127848625, -0.028491178527474403, -0.03380504623055458, 0.04272690415382385, -0.06830434501171112, -0.004681685473769903, -0.025444161146879196, 0.0068786246702075005, 0.0030899089761078358, -0.08079647272825241, 0.043249670416116714, 0.05728514492511749, -0.05071519687771797, -0.02026732638478279, 0.06263905763626099, -0.01375039853155613, -0.020415455102920532, 0.01279883086681366, -0.027299657464027405, -0.02012898400425911, -0.09241731464862823, 0.03412667289376259, 0.029594169929623604, -0.022067822515964508, 0.030373958870768547, 0.01999533548951149, 0.004687715787440538, -0.025179194286465645, -0.03878296911716461, 0.0375460609793663, 0.053893186151981354, 0.029607074335217476, -0.01868296042084694, 0.018721148371696472, 0.010877737775444984, -0.07867763936519623, -0.05993084982037544, -0.052391186356544495, 0.014575633220374584, -0.007259064819663763, -0.04901794344186783, 0.036137405782938004, 0.02323097176849842, -0.03759489580988884, -0.050953224301338196, -0.029879452660679817, 0.04462321475148201, -0.0411856584250927, -0.055080920457839966, -0.038057807832956314, -0.07414630055427551, -0.0011174252722412348, -0.047412674874067307, -0.003767205635085702, 0.036953892558813095, -0.07450813800096512, -0.01901940442621708, -0.025232313200831413, 0.04016108810901642, 0.049647752195596695, -0.043916430324316025, -0.027307594195008278, -0.013403150252997875, 0.047487445175647736, -0.025447595864534378, 0.005172062199562788, -0.02117304690182209, 0.030059348791837692, -0.007753114216029644, 0.000864373694639653, -0.05020161718130112, -0.007079833187162876, -0.034509435296058655, -0.023828497156500816, 0.011901956982910633, 0.03541872277855873, 0.05131363868713379, 0.00773882120847702, -0.0071796271950006485, -0.03543873503804207, -0.03607788681983948, -0.0191913153976202, 0.03272387757897377, -0.0013945947866886854, 0.06519593298435211, 0.05732407048344612, -0.02384159341454506, -0.07233872264623642, -0.013671302236616611, -0.03864443302154541, -0.0014658686704933643, -0.06706957519054413, -0.041704434901475906, 0.005223618354648352, -0.05855056643486023, -0.028002286329865456, -0.028363538905978203, 0.019274096935987473, -0.0388031005859375, -0.0625302717089653, -0.024487636983394623, -0.016206832602620125, -0.010102528147399426, -0.06679067015647888, -0.042457759380340576, 0.04184229299426079, 0.01880870945751667, 0.01712437905371189, -0.025599410757422447, 0.0003465235058683902, -0.04793470725417137, 0.023868007585406303, 0.011003323830664158, 0.009154511615633965, -0.05173323303461075, -0.017109433189034462, -0.04379398375749588, 0.032911621034145355, 0.03008236549794674, 0.0575268417596817, 0.024304455146193504, -0.039404794573783875, 0.00340003683231771, -0.0034308782778680325, 0.01159580983221531, -0.017306534573435783, -0.016538497060537338, 0.008262363262474537, -0.04914908856153488, -0.052668243646621704, 0.06311941891908646, 0.07304965704679489, -0.03602183237671852, -0.03146100044250488, -0.032717540860176086, 0.020261788740754128, -0.005898864474147558, -0.0343502014875412, 0.06009043753147125, 0.03840713948011398, 0.017184723168611526, -0.003514763666316867, -0.04283373802900314, 0.03712620586156845, -0.02718161791563034, 0.00914537999778986, 0.052883971482515335, 0.006277423817664385, -0.006926444824784994, -0.0558885894715786, 0.04775071144104004, 0.0606512650847435, 0.051228564232587814, 0.00014158464909996837, -0.03252686932682991, 0.05595953390002251, 0.014546186663210392, 0.02369752898812294, -0.018599554896354675, 0.012682023458182812, 0.03239211440086365, 0.04983394220471382, -0.06930604577064514, 0.0007184750866144896, 0.009916475974023342, -0.043729268014431, -0.021877266466617584, 0.004087681416422129, -0.013164535164833069, 0.04213911294937134, 0.05342403054237366, -0.025456560775637627, 0.02910747192800045, -0.029852164909243584, 0.04426845908164978, -0.0486731119453907, -0.05815183371305466, 0.028982531279325485, -0.017301592975854874, 0.0034439442679286003, 0.0023382464423775673, -0.004616625141352415, -0.02726653963327408, -0.04754479601979256, -0.025767039507627487, -0.058980491012334824, 0.01334687601774931, 0.006326745729893446, 0.02952495589852333, 0.04639912024140358, -0.008098202757537365, 0.010229543782770634, 0.016715750098228455, -0.01486121490597725, 0.006601378787308931, -0.03485386446118355, -0.03628416359424591, 0.007640779484063387, -0.005223058629781008, -0.029408784583210945, -0.022841813042759895, 0.0014578307745978236, -0.05876583606004715, -0.006054803263396025, 0.05707918852567673, -0.0008582058362662792, -0.031110554933547974, -0.08606373518705368, -0.03966327756643295, -0.028771834447979927, -0.01895197294652462, 0.021674765273928642, -0.06001860648393631, 0.06110655516386032, 0.04487326368689537, -0.017188191413879395, -0.02726513147354126, -0.016773048788309097, -0.060450367629528046, -0.027976064011454582, -0.035430870950222015, -0.03647357597947121, -0.0038969567976891994, -0.04207084700465202, 0.005756606813520193, -0.02508859895169735, -0.013185742311179638, -0.07149688154459, 0.047724004834890366, -0.023567812517285347, -0.004733650479465723, 0.0003783570427913219, -0.0198366716504097, 0.014051834121346474, 0.009793653152883053, -0.06609924882650375, 0.012025459669530392, -0.03237495943903923, 0.016414128243923187, -0.05155334249138832, 0.011957505717873573, -0.03488212823867798, -0.05595390871167183, -0.010053317062556744, 0.023577328771352768, 0.03292884677648544, -0.05965010076761246, 0.027298709377646446, -0.021087609231472015, 0.023088380694389343, -0.00380538497120142, -0.04546913504600525, -0.03947087749838829, -0.03839881718158722, -0.08346229791641235, 0.022978525608778, 0.009565298445522785, 0.001638618647120893, 0.01792212389409542, 0.041601262986660004, -0.0008538444526493549, -0.0013174214400351048, -0.05386405065655708, -0.004473499022424221, 0.006751047447323799, 0.0007032618159428239, -0.03663995489478111, -0.026605121791362762, -0.06631430238485336, 0.04952998831868172, 0.020009806379675865, 0.014901073649525642, 0.021905632689595222, 0.020411262288689613, -0.06207987293601036, 0.04766641929745674, -0.06766919791698456, 0.04969531670212746, 0.06211091950535774, -0.03647323697805405, -0.013204941526055336, 0.01731075905263424, -0.0629252940416336, 0.01610938087105751, -0.01917044073343277, 0.029334932565689087, -0.011268009431660175, 0.019223783165216446, 0.05004364624619484, 0.004451422020792961, -0.012293362990021706, 0.015518119558691978, 0.007861467078328133, -0.008204219862818718, -0.020769108086824417, 0.027434315532445908, 0.05034737288951874, 0.013608607463538647, -0.06694946438074112, 0.0400521382689476, 0.05265035852789879, -0.06191055849194527, -0.06711631268262863, -0.00021339354861993343, 0.026762573048472404, 0.04436175152659416, 0.0487423911690712, -0.057225167751312256, 0.0469064824283123, -0.019066039472818375, -0.009724341332912445, 0.03540431335568428, 0.050818584859371185, 0.04257086291909218, -0.020176416262984276, 0.04693363606929779, -0.010758684948086739, -0.07317400723695755, -0.003944434691220522, -0.03496408462524414, -0.01211094856262207, -0.021707339212298393, 0.007233116310089827, 0.05639965087175369, 0.027062537148594856, 0.0004953736788593233, -0.04055450111627579, -0.04347403347492218, -0.0574820302426815, 0.06299830973148346, -0.005796500016003847, -0.03754658252000809, -0.0037446455098688602, 0.008403550833463669, 0.03821700066328049, -0.021235117688775063, -0.0012132880510762334, -0.028776073828339577, -0.056157927960157394, -0.002149585634469986, 0.025759397074580193, -0.004197117406874895, -0.04339597746729851, -0.041342947632074356, 0.025664949789643288, -0.05453207716345787, -0.0004639161634258926, 0.04046029970049858, 0.04887595400214195, -0.013356601819396019, 0.000797610089648515, 0.023864034563302994, -0.07052195072174072, -0.009061863645911217, 0.06887498497962952, -0.06475991755723953, -0.0005661803297698498, -0.03393089398741722, -0.012788831256330013, 0.008878671564161777, -0.037254296243190765, -0.007023961283266544, -0.013191383332014084, -0.014276234433054924, -0.035016391426324844, 0.028979744762182236, 0.008011790923774242, -0.062078654766082764, -0.011897400952875614, 0.021312672644853592, -0.06522394716739655, -0.02933415211737156, -0.002844050759449601, -0.04021472856402397, -0.03374912589788437, 0.027060048654675484, -0.03661179542541504, -0.04747666046023369, -0.029197661206126213, 0.04053332284092903, 0.03468288481235504, -0.01991931162774563, 0.014879695139825344, 0.00900016725063324, -0.018615441396832466, -0.006364485714584589, -0.0530071035027504, -0.03234298899769783, -0.018073013052344322, 0.06866345554590225, 0.027685999870300293, -0.05188843980431557, -0.013602719642221928, 0.026627192273736, 0.04264847934246063, -0.03300002962350845, 0.032949209213256836, 0.06160449609160423, 0.05318213999271393, -0.027432577684521675, -0.0272163487970829, -0.0008417358621954918, -0.029350636526942253, -0.011927012354135513, 0.010214658454060555, 0.005514968186616898, -0.022135833278298378, 0.05243131145834923, 0.027063725516200066, -0.04197949916124344, 0.020384905859827995, -0.00986799318343401, -0.06079525128006935, 0.015506299212574959, -0.0631643533706665, -0.002572363940998912, -0.0172401312738657, 0.03330713137984276, 0.01464486587792635, 0.060877714306116104, -0.04569859802722931, -0.010292897000908852, -0.040732551366090775, 0.04942645877599716, 0.016355523839592934, 0.00379271456040442, 0.05333256348967552, -0.04669677093625069, 0.05833112820982933, -0.02846723049879074, -0.030825966969132423, -0.007049258332699537, -0.044071126729249954, -0.006488623563200235, 0.016585346311330795, -0.011885490268468857, -0.026237469166517258, 0.005857490934431553, -0.03843095153570175, -0.008884196169674397, 0.028116904199123383, -0.009468192234635353, -0.05330590531229973, -0.003199195023626089, -0.021581806242465973, -0.030688205733895302, 0.02142874151468277, -0.03856835141777992, 0.004421520512551069, -0.020651835948228836, 0.006680541206151247, 0.024381037801504135, 0.02630380168557167, 0.007537970785051584, -0.06385105103254318, -0.033413972705602646, 0.018979132175445557, 0.045718688517808914, -0.02984854206442833, -0.019257931038737297, -0.0604458786547184, -0.06417161226272583, -0.017129650339484215, 0.004052237141877413, -0.009795470163226128, -0.030866222456097603, -0.06062448397278786, 0.048466335982084274, -0.004716416820883751, -0.003920373041182756, -0.08216281980276108, 0.0043724006973207, -0.01222134754061699, -0.02701606974005699, -0.010856397449970245, 0.022362854331731796, -0.057680029422044754, 0.03147388622164726, -0.07791352272033691, -0.027501005679368973, -0.01762516051530838, 0.029757685959339142, 0.03316711634397507, 0.004541569389402866, -0.030427182093262672, -0.019479267299175262, 0.031657274812459946, 0.015112994238734245, -0.0008092315401881933, 0.00816193874925375, 0.0000954912175075151, 0.015228583477437496, -0.01699863187968731, -0.0355677530169487, 0.027542421594262123, -0.006337263621389866, -0.01696803793311119, 0.038711778819561005, 0.014864768832921982, -0.04314243420958519, -0.018305664882063866, 0.02491721138358116, 0.0020771236158907413, 0.04199313372373581, -0.05949760228395462, -0.018030857667326927, -0.025816887617111206, -0.06953306496143341, 0.02828584611415863, -0.05840400233864784, 0.014188862405717373, -0.015624484047293663, -0.02773522026836872, -0.03171512484550476, -0.048400357365608215, -0.06510481983423233, 0.045648328959941864, 0.03526267036795616, -0.02957596629858017, 0.06014622002840042, -0.06377662718296051, -0.0122542604804039, 0.004523750860244036, -0.03161567077040672, -0.018524661660194397, 0.01705045811831951, 0.05595824867486954, -0.05852804332971573, -0.007233296521008015, -0.06548883020877838, 0.00850504357367754, -0.04043444246053696, 0.028651360422372818, 0.0447947196662426, 0.013454331085085869, -0.03995927423238754, 0.0597340390086174, -0.06924273818731308, -0.046963464468717575, 0.006570934318006039, -0.05817076191306114, 0.016525588929653168, -0.01111583411693573, 0.020326009020209312, 0.00853670109063387, 0.04200782999396324, -0.0023331569973379374, 0.04922039434313774, 0.03224141523241997, -0.002247515134513378, 0.0019254838116467, -0.03089943155646324, -0.05291371792554855, 0.036380335688591, 0.026147298514842987, -0.04108673706650734, -0.059838712215423584, 0.04022659361362457, 0.004978177137672901, 0.0002509979240130633, -0.0032352381385862827, -0.0309025589376688, -0.03937486186623573, -0.023621009662747383, -0.05413777008652687, 0.06647638231515884, 0.02953338250517845, -0.06179310008883476, -0.014466866850852966, 0.04763861000537872, -0.007963428273797035, -0.045097772032022476 ]
We developed a theoretical scheme of incorporating the magnetoelastic contribution into the thermal elastic dynamics for the thin membranes of 2D antiferromagnetic material with restricted geometry. We extended the elastic Gr\"uneisen relation into an effective version which includes the magnetic counterpart to the volume change of internal energy. Based on the specific heat and thermal conductivity from the elastic and magnetic origins we predicted the dependency of observables, such as effective Gr\"uneisen parameter, thermal expansion coefficient, and the damping factor, with respect to a wide range of temperature across the phase transition. Our model of analysis as been validated by applying to the case of FePS3 flake resonator and the theoretical predictions fits well with the reported experiment data.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13991v2
[ 0.028233420103788376, -0.03506700322031975, 0.025180552154779434, 0.01849260926246643, -0.013138968497514725, 0.022118376567959785, -0.018241899088025093, 0.032854314893484116, -0.00814522709697485, -0.014321835711598396, -0.009891124442219734, -0.0323808379471302, -0.023070678114891052, -0.05380583554506302, -0.04838225618004799, 0.05380998179316521, 0.06211380660533905, 0.03840554133057594, -0.000954542076215148, 0.055533941835165024, -0.03912326321005821, -0.00877381395548582, -0.013218475505709648, 0.056974586099386215, -0.014726199209690094, 0.03494429588317871, -0.01769767515361309, -0.00790386088192463, -0.03489794209599495, -0.005314819514751434, 0.02360597811639309, -0.056203074753284454, 0.04122672230005264, -0.009639612399041653, 0.03415828198194504, -0.015131069347262383, -0.02817007713019848, -0.006062706932425499, 0.046136874705553055, -0.02360001765191555, -0.0060554915107786655, -0.028471024706959724, -0.05260670930147171, -0.02340877614915371, 0.003761308966204524, -0.004074728582054377, -0.03667614236474037, 0.024173133075237274, -0.03590617701411247, -0.025260191410779953, 0.01068041380494833, -0.015932651236653328, -0.025925610214471817, 0.04309689998626709, -0.06565675884485245, 0.020283903926610947, -0.005182952620089054, -0.010051698423922062, -0.015641557052731514, -0.00921293068677187, -0.008231624029576778, -0.04180636256933212, 0.0379481241106987, 0.007127672899514437, -0.04700005054473877, 0.028176799416542053, -0.025165216997265816, -0.059721771627664566, -0.02631664089858532, -0.07992135733366013, -0.02872992865741253, -0.06832511723041534, 0.03066132590174675, 0.023267896845936775, -0.0595010370016098, -0.012177415192127228, -0.028882848098874092, 0.024121422320604324, -0.04321282356977463, 0.010584506206214428, -0.036065347492694855, 0.006315379869192839, 0.056778669357299805, 0.05488399788737297, 0.03179745376110077, -0.024454761296510696, 0.030544964596629143, 0.004435553681105375, 0.0009405826567672193, 0.011938370764255524, 0.034137461334466934, -0.039747003465890884, -0.037181954830884933, 0.0012054297840222716, 0.05631018429994583, -0.008174828253686428, 0.058593831956386566, 0.026633387431502342, 0.05383109301328659, 0.006940614897757769, -0.018385229632258415, -0.025994468480348587, 0.01617749035358429, 0.007847714237868786, 0.01574588567018509, -0.03324636071920395, -0.008106558583676815, -0.03768303245306015, 0.00453949673101306, 0.014850632287561893, -0.03519514575600624, 0.0039433748461306095, 0.011408302001655102, -0.003614248475059867, -0.02658136375248432, -0.019556205719709396, 0.039593156427145004, -0.008870584890246391, 0.010184716433286667, 0.045173127204179764, -0.029488004744052887, 0.04790086671710014, -0.015225511975586414, -0.01826179400086403, -0.03673608973622322, 0.000976146780885756, 0.07860106229782104, -0.0439528226852417, 0.021056704223155975, -0.033939871937036514, -0.04431621730327606, 0.009405819699168205, 0.0476546511054039, -0.04761843755841255, 0.0462118424475193, 0.0077688018791377544, 0.021679136902093887, -0.0194049384444952, -0.019155876711010933, 0.026687856763601303, -0.06093703582882881, -0.032562945038080215, -0.007308631204068661, -0.036184269934892654, -0.01887097954750061, 0.02560821920633316, -0.046988122165203094, 0.04924243688583374, 0.012599378824234009, -0.013163544237613678, 0.04116997867822647, -0.05382080748677254, 0.02307063154876232, 0.0456949807703495, 0.01750544272363186, -0.048225339502096176, 0.058398690074682236, -0.036882854998111725, 0.016359843313694, 0.021384617313742638, 0.04211009293794632, -0.04852350428700447, -0.03200012072920799, -0.03233325853943825, -0.013460373505949974, -0.03654127195477486, 0.03926234319806099, -0.043665748089551926, -0.03172026202082634, -0.03701792657375336, 0.0023975151125341654, 0.003619805909693241, 0.006492371670901775, -0.047948986291885376, -0.06353159248828888, -0.04388036951422691, -0.0312095545232296, -0.04058375954627991, -0.06370636820793152, 0.029169412329792976, 0.0359974168241024, -0.014242768287658691, -0.039942119270563126, -0.022967049852013588, -0.03698422387242317, -0.01571124978363514, -0.07621421664953232, -0.027151528745889664, -0.02054767869412899, -0.06318797916173935, -0.04440281540155411, -0.031992968171834946, 0.008208691142499447, -0.008097231388092041, -0.05634516850113869, -0.01686408929526806, 0.018017999827861786, 0.031177453696727753, 0.021439895033836365, -0.034807972609996796, -0.06425387412309647, -0.0424213632941246, -0.045032501220703125, -0.0005458865780383348, -0.04470003768801689, -0.05988798663020134, 0.006916433107107878, 0.019665606319904327, 0.0005869802553206682, -0.029053660109639168, 0.04145522788167, -0.002240382134914398, -0.008825326338410378, -0.007556650787591934, -0.04189373180270195, 0.012554735876619816, -0.08791682869195938, 0.05060243234038353, -0.0003741317195817828, 0.012028133496642113, -0.0338917151093483, -0.010811073705554008, 0.018765950575470924, -0.06006547436118126, 0.0375790111720562, 0.059928905218839645, 0.056896936148405075, 0.04411012679338455, -0.04696257412433624, 0.053649790585041046, 0.02878258004784584, -0.05878794193267822, -0.07429857552051544, -0.03210555762052536, -0.038004763424396515, 0.03024202398955822, -0.004035045858472586, 0.0013349956134334207, -0.05336391553282738, -0.06130654364824295, -0.0005330268177203834, -0.024027014151215553, 0.050584577023983, -0.013362837955355644, 0.0114890830591321, -0.05891086906194687, -0.05536811426281929, 0.020753979682922363, -0.04824056103825569, -0.013755092397332191, 0.004339900333434343, -0.04959966242313385, -0.04569515213370323, -0.028568288311362267, 0.005605767015367746, 0.03290598839521408, -0.02222917601466179, 0.027405358850955963, 0.0491570383310318, 0.04004472494125366, 0.006621287204325199, 0.02037886716425419, 0.015930049121379852, 0.03523167595267296, -0.008898352272808552, -0.004014609381556511, -0.035022519528865814, -0.031241802498698235, 0.0036536806728690863, -0.031637582927942276, 0.044501908123493195, 0.01551641896367073, 0.02510838769376278, 0.02999282442033291, -0.032869670540094376, 0.042014241218566895, -0.022012174129486084, -0.07424314320087433, 0.03922243416309357, 0.02799883298575878, 0.0503075085580349, 0.029963018372654915, 0.020391564816236496, -0.04879482463002205, -0.019335100427269936, -0.0316196084022522, -0.01453158725053072, -0.059492941945791245, -0.025517115369439125, 0.008215799927711487, -0.043869324028491974, -0.05777566134929657, -0.00005576128387474455, -0.039906784892082214, -0.024818819016218185, -0.05346668139100075, -0.03161553665995598, -0.03143259882926941, -0.029151160269975662, -0.04417837783694267, -0.0671449527144432, -0.007942551746964455, 0.029680198058485985, 0.040098097175359726, -0.025823136791586876, -0.0064728641882538795, -0.014716983772814274, 0.03872101753950119, 0.008217576891183853, -0.027690090239048004, -0.047347087413072586, 0.020762957632541656, -0.049956802278757095, 0.0014932513004168868, -0.03803369402885437, 0.0055682361125946045, 0.021314652636647224, -0.007352518383413553, -0.006449052132666111, 0.037592802196741104, 0.03396931663155556, -0.00505490880459547, -0.0033570558298379183, 0.03844360262155533, -0.07389955222606659, -0.05538922920823097, 0.00556566659361124, 0.020248020067811012, -0.021709058433771133, 0.0005160319851711392, -0.06413711607456207, -0.009654784575104713, 0.0216131079941988, 0.03123030997812748, 0.07126706093549728, 0.009476267732679844, -0.007875178940594196, -0.007583868224173784, -0.00835694931447506, 0.030063604936003685, -0.018235908821225166, 0.030319033190608025, 0.02624122053384781, -0.040802113711833954, 0.024366123601794243, -0.02327200397849083, 0.01705164462327957, 0.03294409438967705, 0.03561778739094734, -0.028315983712673187, -0.027682330459356308, 0.027114439755678177, -0.03568601235747337, 0.027272270992398262, 0.03055115044116974, -0.0069899489171803, -0.010708050802350044, 0.05257175862789154, -0.06442827731370926, 0.028867432847619057, -0.04628145694732666, -0.05012841895222664, -0.04478756710886955, -0.028544621542096138, 0.041538309305906296, 0.042143505066633224, 0.045101098716259, -0.018205178901553154, 0.05362953618168831, -0.032851673662662506, 0.05045627802610397, 0.036200717091560364, -0.027615932747721672, -0.00986487977206707, -0.034890949726104736, 0.02257942594587803, 0.0422433465719223, 0.008286398835480213, -0.036698561161756516, -0.04265841096639633, -0.01656525395810604, -0.042727310210466385, 0.04871095344424248, 0.055925510823726654, 0.021420029923319817, 0.047963790595531464, -0.013324357569217682, 0.03588437661528587, 0.028328539803624153, -0.057330239564180374, -0.007175551261752844, -0.017518891021609306, -0.043435074388980865, 0.007653940934687853, -0.019209053367376328, -0.06834582984447479, 0.002735050395131111, 0.04067961499094963, -0.027743661776185036, 0.021409370005130768, 0.016441084444522858, -0.019050920382142067, -0.04824069142341614, -0.07090487331151962, -0.03795717656612396, -0.06470290571451187, 0.04599684104323387, -0.012745472602546215, -0.04854346811771393, 0.050474364310503006, -0.020329739898443222, 0.030821889638900757, -0.0214922484010458, 0.02233756333589554, -0.05056098848581314, -0.048591285943984985, 0.010008463636040688, -0.06248429790139198, 0.046064592897892, -0.040962621569633484, 0.03978154808282852, -0.005213878117501736, -0.027554092928767204, -0.05065217986702919, 0.031324710696935654, -0.024615883827209473, 0.00904078409075737, 0.059619247913360596, -0.002235699910670519, 0.0030625928193330765, -0.012566127814352512, -0.045741911977529526, 0.03130519017577171, 0.0022344524040818214, 0.04790980741381645, -0.011565503664314747, 0.02595706656575203, -0.05325412005186081, -0.06288827210664749, -0.018624357879161835, 0.009160932153463364, 0.0593886561691761, -0.02102518454194069, -0.045125752687454224, -0.03026348166167736, 0.02057581953704357, -0.03974277898669243, -0.05506857857108116, 0.015110346488654613, -0.03223452344536781, -0.05165942758321762, -0.03569987043738365, 0.012983475811779499, -0.0272426325827837, 0.017136644572019577, 0.017496129497885704, -0.023695195093750954, 0.006327245384454727, -0.039752356708049774, 0.011140820570290089, -0.019513821229338646, -0.04376266151666641, -0.06510867178440094, -0.04268353059887886, -0.03898175433278084, -0.012734497897326946, -0.052347585558891296, -0.020410416647791862, 0.04990066587924957, 0.05123765021562576, -0.018298033624887466, 0.035826604813337326, -0.06368494778871536, 0.014716550707817078, 0.04150379076600075, -0.027181504294276237, 0.011140214279294014, -0.009473873302340508, -0.012584888376295567, -0.028605887666344643, -0.04519098624587059, -0.0339881107211113, 0.003865771694108844, -0.019608862698078156, 0.012895691208541393, 0.018262449651956558, -0.02525419369339943, -0.0008772896253503859, 0.0545172393321991, -0.023505961522459984, -0.05652940273284912, 0.0424882248044014, 0.02448333613574505, 0.007678665220737457, -0.031825676560401917, 0.016460401937365532, 0.0542227141559124, -0.03864891082048416, -0.03418164327740669, -0.039381131529808044, -0.013259924948215485, 0.006213483866304159, 0.03607196733355522, -0.064415343105793, 0.037426214665174484, -0.02461344189941883, 0.027884025126695633, -0.02200372889637947, 0.04131896048784256, -0.047528062015771866, -0.007026598323136568, 0.0283296350389719, 0.01847224310040474, -0.07333244383335114, 0.029934927821159363, -0.06801526993513107, -0.0014894184423610568, 0.006995035335421562, 0.06155427172780037, 0.06679841876029968, 0.07389786094427109, 0.025288501754403114, -0.03606715053319931, 0.0036852152552455664, -0.03156433254480362, 0.049178287386894226, -0.03515239432454109, -0.03853197023272514, 0.02037002146244049, 0.07341645658016205, 0.011620388366281986, -0.016576012596488, 0.04534738138318062, -0.031576819717884064, -0.06013021618127823, -0.05368517339229584, 0.002945528831332922, 0.037093788385391235, -0.049330126494169235, -0.022386182099580765, 0.0658382773399353, -0.04680829122662544, 0.05581362918019295, 0.0162274818867445, 0.029501404613256454, -0.016569189727306366, -0.021992329508066177, 0.0382397323846817, -0.06350454688072205, -0.00016004803183022887, 0.08427761495113373, -0.04251158982515335, -0.03510906547307968, -0.048397839069366455, -0.034304551780223846, -0.060383882373571396, -0.06135757640004158, -0.006184885744005442, -0.02268613874912262, -0.03524332866072655, -0.06578552722930908, 0.0296645425260067, -0.014894619584083557, -0.06973818689584732, -0.0021582029294222593, -0.02380935475230217, -0.055846232920885086, -0.023651186376810074, 0.007561165373772383, -0.039123691618442535, -0.019665654748678207, 0.04081977531313896, -0.0706368237733841, -0.04366741329431534, -0.042096491903066635, 0.01958356238901615, 0.07434999942779541, -0.03029824048280716, 0.029491081833839417, -0.03016544133424759, -0.04770355299115181, -0.005602048709988594, -0.029837096109986305, -0.03615545108914375, -0.022110233083367348, 0.008663971908390522, -0.018681712448596954, -0.024529289454221725, -0.004916332196444273, 0.01905790902674198, -0.008194217458367348, -0.000734892557375133, 0.018649455159902573, 0.03796037659049034, -0.008799037896096706, -0.06574104726314545, -0.02734013833105564, 0.02175850421190262, 0.02421770803630352, -0.04341096058487892, 0.0031565732788294554, -0.025783807039260864, -0.01961832493543625, 0.03399522230029106, 0.028745997697114944, -0.02706308849155903, -0.0033525596372783184, -0.037833139300346375, -0.055482178926467896, 0.011886698193848133, -0.05732647329568863, -0.045435067266225815, -0.0020305397920310497, 0.055258117616176605, 0.0173336248844862, 0.02159235067665577, -0.05119303986430168, 0.04128037020564079, 0.009084980934858322, -0.03703401982784271, -0.007045584265142679, 0.015131413005292416, 0.02135542780160904, -0.034258365631103516, 0.05375746265053749, -0.0560743547976017, 0.00006910201045684516, -0.05367911607027054, -0.049273531883955, -0.0283035971224308, 0.04429899528622627, -0.030283356085419655, -0.006862276699393988, -0.014061026275157928, 0.006933392956852913, -0.037150513380765915, 0.05875546857714653, -0.035841479897499084, -0.04681312292814255, 0.05325578153133392, -0.04604266956448555, -0.013291334733366966, 0.017128197476267815, -0.0161890909075737, 0.0351545549929142, -0.03462402895092964, 0.03125815838575363, 0.024792268872261047, 0.015169667080044746, 0.03298672288656235, -0.07096023112535477, -0.03980853408575058, 0.05225304141640663, 0.012045403942465782, -0.02868546172976494, -0.03032662160694599, -0.010224603116512299, -0.07092667371034622, -0.06479111313819885, 0.013626543805003166, 0.00392969511449337, -0.021730706095695496, -0.03179085627198219, -0.010548827238380909, 0.03820100799202919, -0.05953892692923546, -0.07513927668333054, 0.04653676971793175, -0.010752962902188301, 0.005449170246720314, -0.006190146319568157, 0.014649554155766964, -0.05226682499051094, -0.020729582756757736, -0.07893387228250504, -0.03032175824046135, -0.01971282809972763, 0.03782656416296959, 0.015365946106612682, -0.025172848254442215, -0.00026057602372020483, -0.051680803298950195, 0.024785082787275314, 0.007247209083288908, 0.04076403006911278, -0.035992737859487534, 0.013227052986621857, 0.0069176023826003075, -0.02210838906466961, -0.04447168484330177, 0.06613556295633316, 0.008374535478651524, 0.018283996731042862, 0.002520562382414937, 0.006876821164041758, -0.03176049888134003, -0.007938568480312824, 0.06768537312746048, 0.03165636211633682, 0.03685716167092323, -0.0008670926908962429, -0.02336387149989605, -0.03731042146682739, -0.07185360044240952, 0.03390767052769661, -0.033315952867269516, -0.013128205202519894, 0.026915311813354492, -0.0011818432249128819, -0.04470781609416008, -0.017725907266139984, -0.06704346835613251, 0.004658988676965237, 0.040608178824186325, -0.021583404392004013, 0.05479716137051582, -0.020833682268857956, 0.014683333225548267, 0.022740503773093224, -0.010606729425489902, -0.048557355999946594, -0.027320515364408493, 0.03637983277440071, -0.049628887325525284, 0.03987668454647064, -0.05192580819129944, 0.05975551903247833, 0.008985406719148159, 0.015409772284328938, -0.02610444463789463, 0.06095123291015625, -0.06389831751585007, -0.029438719153404236, -0.05438769608736038, -0.00949601549655199, 0.02367808111011982, -0.03984838351607323, -0.023918161168694496, 0.010351323522627354, 0.011693024076521397, 0.019222689792513847, 0.008215075358748436, -0.0509396493434906, 0.061400607228279114, 0.017971238121390343, -0.020318884402513504, -0.0405154675245285, 0.007694669533520937, -0.03332187235355377, 0.03974776342511177, 0.014016508124768734, 0.0133786266669631, -0.05597984045743942, 0.015579168684780598, -0.014319829642772675, -0.0018670521676540375, 0.04844168946146965, 0.04318257048726082, -0.033151887357234955, -0.002229740610346198, -0.03057583048939705, 0.044255245476961136, 0.030203768983483315, -0.04243282228708267, 0.02724565751850605, 0.020114252343773842, -0.0399504117667675, -0.059647418558597565 ]
Let $\mathcal{S}$ be a finite set of integer points in $\mathbb{R}^d$, which we assume has many symmetries, and let $P\in\mathbb{R}^d$ be a fixed point. We calculate the distances from $P$ to the points in $\mathcal{S}$ and compare the results. In some of the most common cases, we find that they lead to unexpected conclusions if the dimension is sufficiently large. For example, if $\mathcal{S}$ is the set of vertices of a hypercube in $\mathbb{R}^d$ and $P$ is any point inside, then almost all triangles $PAB$ with $A,B\in\mathcal{S}$ are almost equilateral. Or, if $P$ is close to the center of the cube, then almost all triangles $PAB$ with $A\in \mathcal{S}$ and $B$ anywhere in the hypercube are almost right triangles.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15338v1
[ -0.05555018037557602, -0.04276767373085022, 0.025675561279058456, 0.003755137324333191, 0.003931496758013964, 0.008603747934103012, -0.027048027142882347, 0.024128975346684456, -0.06242130696773529, -0.036333341151475906, 0.0063629113137722015, -0.051562193781137466, 0.035706065595149994, -0.06017663702368736, -0.019222905859351158, -0.03365657478570938, 0.0070582190528512, 0.04777318611741066, -0.032302726060152054, 0.050065118819475174, -0.05288637429475784, -0.04030129313468933, -0.00796965416520834, 0.049094125628471375, 0.01241259090602398, 0.003521774196997285, 0.024270448833703995, 0.008019368164241314, -0.06634379923343658, -0.029249556362628937, 0.05079387500882149, -0.021078921854496002, -0.03237170726060867, -0.05790810286998749, -0.0006192712462507188, 0.038162413984537125, 0.027429351583123207, -0.03110191784799099, 0.05114799365401268, -0.03483342006802559, 0.05676320567727089, -0.0650365874171257, -0.03771157190203667, -0.05387796089053154, -0.023509126156568527, -0.044699590653181076, -0.04574986547231674, 0.0014054299099370837, 0.011983483098447323, -0.06321084499359131, 0.003607173915952444, -0.037969816476106644, 0.04101233556866646, 0.05155940726399422, -0.030554696917533875, 0.03267568349838257, 0.04528447613120079, -0.01472067553550005, -0.04798472300171852, 0.004573322366923094, -0.013774377293884754, -0.023330282419919968, -0.03397757187485695, 0.006214660592377186, -0.04321485385298729, -0.005051628686487675, -0.04537111148238182, -0.054983120411634445, -0.0029631443321704865, -0.030262738466262817, -0.012766843661665916, -0.06081331521272659, 0.034376922994852066, 0.021051790565252304, -0.0689164400100708, 0.013389235362410545, 0.012265213765203953, 0.0007225423469208181, -0.03494744747877121, 0.046344708651304245, -0.03473198413848877, -0.05972927436232567, -0.005925618577748537, -0.03900648280978203, -0.0014142276486381888, -0.006746496539562941, 0.050891220569610596, -0.0086701400578022, 0.03886989876627922, -0.06327548623085022, -0.05045115202665329, -0.04869695380330086, -0.06710077077150345, -0.034044958651065826, 0.04419967904686928, -0.061057452112436295, 0.03057592175900936, 0.014714875258505344, 0.02112923376262188, -0.027387898415327072, -0.0007104044198058546, -0.06408140063285828, -0.032590240240097046, -0.04975445196032524, -0.003795551136136055, -0.05823332816362381, -0.035384777933359146, -0.04288337007164955, -0.06515514105558395, 0.014783736318349838, -0.044474173337221146, 0.031014207750558853, -0.035339564085006714, -0.04938714951276779, -0.008859656751155853, -0.066407211124897, 0.03383323922753334, 0.024712558835744858, 0.05760536715388298, -0.007701474241912365, 0.00017835509788710624, -0.0163863692432642, -0.024078289046883583, -0.03432369977235794, -0.004403875675052404, -0.04476476088166237, 0.0013295368989929557, 0.003295390633866191, 0.022692851722240448, 0.027514848858118057, -0.045462656766176224, -0.016416748985648155, 0.035814639180898666, 0.030412549152970314, 0.05848519504070282, 0.0404488667845726, -0.020101135596632957, -0.03553116321563721, -0.012154986150562763, 0.027918310835957527, 0.01752380095422268, -0.067642442882061, 0.013503078371286392, 0.029147224500775337, -0.01069741602987051, 0.043069787323474884, -0.06156698241829872, 0.04321741685271263, 0.013975805602967739, 0.05781951919198036, -0.04516053944826126, 0.03617819771170616, 0.011499112471938133, 0.015182249248027802, -0.007300012744963169, -0.01227523572742939, 0.009674864821135998, -0.004407650791108608, -0.06126445531845093, -0.015272708609700203, 0.040157005190849304, -0.018530117347836494, -0.013838263228535652, 0.009652940556406975, 0.0068777683191001415, 0.055314384400844574, 0.032485321164131165, -0.005836775526404381, 0.05491538345813751, 0.020632393658161163, -0.03559812158346176, -0.020126866176724434, -0.03879471495747566, -0.06156880781054497, -0.053875360637903214, -0.028273504227399826, 0.001049453392624855, -0.05163957551121712, -0.030779145658016205, 0.0037799179553985596, 0.02771015278995037, -0.01492720190435648, -0.027314214035868645, 0.011831467039883137, -0.037998709827661514, 0.012118951417505741, -0.05486385524272919, 0.04623677581548691, 0.020072776824235916, 0.06118077412247658, 0.009850690141320229, -0.018095707520842552, 0.008775855414569378, -0.00514638377353549, -0.02519095130264759, 0.00887224730104208, 0.01509938295930624, -0.06255299597978592, -0.021275034174323082, 0.028004104271531105, -0.060063328593969345, -0.00010592657781671733, -0.01900590769946575, 0.04586926847696304, -0.0022942926734685898, -0.06409936398267746, 0.0249184463173151, 0.03902486711740494, -0.013654442504048347, -0.06189216300845146, 0.06826034933328629, -0.00012718902144115418, -0.012129360809922218, 0.03365909680724144, -0.03814747557044029, -0.0346384197473526, -0.07095351070165634, 0.06306102126836777, -0.004920175764709711, -0.027016939595341682, 0.017748206853866577, -0.000016171006791410036, -0.049440477043390274, -0.03031137026846409, -0.057221170514822006, 0.058543793857097626, -0.0006407689652405679, 0.01906450092792511, -0.04459613934159279, -0.03770197182893753, 0.011781140230596066, -0.0653715431690216, 0.014994597993791103, -0.047763723880052567, 0.019459975883364677, -0.03030288964509964, -0.04801677539944649, 0.056006159633398056, -0.006177159491926432, 0.04002486541867256, -0.05362642556428909, 0.023442327976226807, 0.0331072174012661, -0.024215245619416237, -0.022802188992500305, -0.017381517216563225, -0.009019522927701473, -0.0033137425780296326, -0.0028064814396202564, -0.03471019119024277, 0.015945827588438988, -0.034176524728536606, -0.027376331388950348, -0.010153140872716904, 0.042901650071144104, 0.056279513984918594, -0.046492695808410645, -0.007791799493134022, -0.024755259975790977, 0.04029369726777077, 0.03749507665634155, 0.007304697297513485, -0.005765249487012625, -0.04892716556787491, -0.02143617905676365, 0.04137948900461197, -0.05839983746409416, -0.015599607490003109, 0.005710420198738575, 0.0391203872859478, 0.017706898972392082, 0.009854298084974289, 0.055496469140052795, -0.009703059680759907, -0.0026131269987672567, -0.04616907611489296, -0.05847983807325363, 0.024934491142630577, 0.061087608337402344, -0.025714660063385963, 0.04732873663306236, 0.01898474432528019, -0.029233284294605255, -0.07088351994752884, -0.03798595070838928, -0.009075723588466644, -0.007096048444509506, -0.04416075721383095, -0.0549246221780777, -0.024589495733380318, -0.05845954269170761, 0.00013122720702085644, -0.05867176130414009, -0.01547391526401043, -0.03342164307832718, -0.05626207962632179, -0.03047308325767517, -0.020281264558434486, -0.014303230680525303, -0.04163026809692383, -0.01668964885175228, 0.02565430849790573, 0.011102884076535702, 0.0040864599868655205, -0.05294560268521309, -0.0564538799226284, -0.04662574827671051, -0.021056467667222023, 0.041267942637205124, 0.023030731827020645, -0.0337822288274765, -0.0026741009205579758, -0.053297389298677444, -0.02276981808245182, -0.02533901296555996, -0.027402637526392937, -0.0034205601550638676, -0.011034847237169743, 0.0022844963241368532, 0.026741625741124153, -0.060128673911094666, -0.05564979463815689, 0.016865447163581848, -0.06240237131714821, -0.057602863758802414, -0.0413532555103302, 0.04342488944530487, 0.043753672391176224, -0.03356572240591049, -0.02472643181681633, -0.028461193665862083, -0.014201201498508453, -0.00445695361122489, 0.016244178637862206, 0.00735871447250247, 0.03479761257767677, -0.04455128312110901, -0.013828098773956299, -0.03303271532058716, 0.03630966320633888, 0.012300239875912666, 0.023923421278595924, -0.0048054056242108345, 0.005386205390095711, 0.05133792385458946, -0.07010030001401901, 0.04289518669247627, 0.05222167819738388, 0.043086860328912735, -0.02018928900361061, -0.0313958004117012, 0.0604427270591259, 0.020811300724744797, -0.026265600696206093, -0.05054963752627373, -0.008894910104572773, 0.017070919275283813, 0.03630458191037178, -0.05741524696350098, -0.009994029998779297, -0.04380391910672188, -0.023965105414390564, 0.012477438896894455, 0.05479959398508072, -0.014176186174154282, 0.03807063773274422, 0.003970572724938393, -0.04446287453174591, -0.04873521998524666, 0.02618713304400444, 0.05251167714595795, -0.055920276790857315, 0.013317625038325787, 0.033866625279188156, -0.05748530104756355, -0.012397422455251217, -0.006346920970827341, -0.025853946805000305, 0.002446388127282262, -0.03897523507475853, 0.012399239465594292, -0.032806139439344406, 0.015666833147406578, 0.009000510908663273, -0.03358541801571846, -0.032049909234046936, -0.026209166273474693, -0.04630334675312042, 0.03215768560767174, -0.03205017372965813, 0.020468411967158318, 0.023204268887639046, 0.019511226564645767, -0.03470413014292717, 0.0023334352299571037, -0.04098771885037422, 0.0008806099067442119, 0.03078852780163288, -0.05089082941412926, -0.0265955813229084, -0.017251037061214447, -0.03244808316230774, -0.03338407352566719, -0.06983388215303421, -0.0518992617726326, -0.05901002138853073, 0.00965113379061222, 0.010355695150792599, -0.02883548103272915, 0.0479743592441082, 0.008494923822581768, -0.02387840300798416, -0.018447551876306534, -0.046504296362400055, -0.026937054470181465, -0.00911392830312252, -0.04819699004292488, -0.03484700992703438, 0.04011477530002594, -0.04039033129811287, 0.027935750782489777, 0.01765204221010208, -0.05331423506140709, -0.05705490708351135, -0.018481425940990448, -0.012150486931204796, 0.043787870556116104, -0.030578799545764923, -0.0060650622472167015, 0.05337585508823395, 0.007993057370185852, 0.020356643944978714, -0.048134878277778625, -0.04576166346669197, -0.03828765079379082, -0.04225483164191246, 0.028069304302334785, -0.039290644228458405, -0.05703909322619438, -0.028782984241843224, -0.03161928057670593, -0.010806426405906677, -0.04529048874974251, -0.0025963361840695143, -0.0385374054312706, 0.05017413944005966, -0.05965965613722801, -0.0681416466832161, -0.005941055249422789, 0.005352112464606762, -0.06113070249557495, 0.058298707008361816, 0.022368943318724632, 0.01285567507147789, 0.014788687229156494, 0.020542828366160393, -0.056921280920505524, -0.005032924935221672, -0.053236979991197586, 0.03499189019203186, -0.024080712348222733, -0.013869412243366241, -0.02281820960342884, -0.008253907784819603, -0.05603621155023575, -0.015150638297200203, -0.05270368978381157, -0.04180384427309036, 0.04846494272351265, -0.0017058602534234524, -0.02392783761024475, 0.044889967888593674, -0.06916823238134384, 0.01939394511282444, 0.04840005934238434, -0.06346394121646881, -0.010983423329889774, 0.034307993948459625, -0.03619956597685814, 0.02938542515039444, 0.028176352381706238, -0.007133320439606905, -0.026554862037301064, -0.0031556107569485903, -0.012459805235266685, -0.019215069711208344, -0.013918418437242508, 0.009795799851417542, 0.026727287098765373, -0.017659230157732964, -0.04536989703774452, -0.026097554713487625, 0.014376375824213028, -0.005383123178035021, -0.04615546390414238, 0.0539141483604908, -0.019631274044513702, -0.059853967279195786, -0.0689731314778328, -0.04171891137957573, 0.008544296026229858, -0.039275456219911575, 0.03832218423485756, -0.029540587216615677, 0.016495542600750923, 0.03450458496809006, -0.04511309787631035, 0.009309712797403336, -0.003084680065512657, 0.006255971733480692, -0.022853359580039978, 0.01316035259515047, -0.050655730068683624, -0.05815085396170616, 0.015283923596143723, -0.010210806503891945, 0.02258024737238884, -0.005138441454619169, 0.03817175701260567, -0.02065986953675747, -0.0036343522369861603, -0.037853412330150604, -0.050526369363069534, -0.012686297297477722, 0.011152571998536587, 0.02196941152215004, -0.05251779407262802, 0.008869621902704239, 0.023541992530226707, -0.009562029503285885, 0.003836608026176691, -0.04191209003329277, 0.004907241091132164, -0.03023475594818592, -0.013879239559173584, 0.016766659915447235, -0.03830774873495102, -0.0009833869989961386, -0.030055919662117958, 0.013318655081093311, 0.005163427907973528, -0.015526730567216873, 0.06247466802597046, 0.0072304438799619675, 0.03821052983403206, -0.007587063126266003, 0.03774259239435196, 0.04985005781054497, -0.04103756695985794, -0.018800850957632065, -0.010291710495948792, -0.06480082124471664, 0.010373657569289207, -0.037882350385189056, 0.011989906430244446, 0.027296151965856552, -0.05791591852903366, -0.013139008544385433, -0.0024265777319669724, 0.026726560667157173, -0.016784798353910446, -0.0032203681766986847, 0.014192997477948666, -0.06444987654685974, -0.0019212344195693731, -0.00943754706531763, -0.06588829308748245, -0.010524149052798748, -0.004050410818308592, -0.006686617154628038, -0.03249652311205864, -0.017004534602165222, -0.053576357662677765, -0.06280142813920975, -0.036460030823946, 0.061914317309856415, 0.02640046551823616, -0.06119600310921669, 0.0460272841155529, 0.009869986213743687, 0.014172951690852642, 0.02093556337058544, -0.06657176464796066, -0.0597977489233017, -0.02648969367146492, 0.06687036901712418, -0.0536649189889431, -0.022329039871692657, -0.008268019184470177, 0.019512096419930458, -0.00020132948702666909, -0.02685030922293663, 0.046140797436237335, 0.02181336283683777, 0.04174156114459038, -0.02060135453939438, -0.037200987339019775, -0.02838708646595478, 0.0049334024079144, -0.011340359225869179, 0.017166228964924812, 0.043181002140045166, -0.023177731782197952, 0.028921036049723625, -0.03633223846554756, -0.04929061233997345, -0.014010106213390827, 0.031750161200761795, -0.05496053397655487, 0.003051992040127516, -0.05874723196029663, -0.01324821449816227, 0.010055639781057835, 0.05032941699028015, 0.02913045510649681, 0.03710776939988136, -0.010410276241600513, -0.04438655823469162, -0.03237141668796539, -0.01593785732984543, 0.033877432346343994, 0.009091627784073353, 0.04966028034687042, -0.06340841203927994, 0.061716675758361816, -0.06209762394428253, -0.03011298179626465, -0.009764919057488441, -0.014462540857493877, 0.0061599137261509895, -0.005590256303548813, -0.040434714406728745, -0.026336949318647385, 0.00701824901625514, -0.06248245760798454, 0.03882082179188728, -0.004776460118591785, -0.021559609100222588, -0.06949739903211594, 0.011566721834242344, -0.021530119702219963, -0.049657192081213, -0.0021341489627957344, -0.05858704447746277, 0.0433465912938118, -0.023396391421556473, 0.05244524031877518, 0.04138901084661484, 0.02102137915790081, -0.010410120710730553, -0.026770010590553284, 0.02756778709590435, 0.012003056704998016, 0.02309316024184227, -0.012698626145720482, -0.03142533451318741, -0.06031641736626625, -0.02725914493203163, 0.02071581594645977, -0.00477855047211051, 0.007403264753520489, -0.0028208019211888313, -0.03485730290412903, 0.047895606607198715, 0.028462596237659454, 0.017215659841895103, -0.06648782640695572, -0.05877695605158806, 0.0019218542147427797, 0.0015216697938740253, 0.007960891351103783, -0.011862681247293949, -0.053640298545360565, 0.027530312538146973, -0.0711604654788971, -0.05603116750717163, 0.0012205716921016574, 0.009707112796604633, -0.022557340562343597, 0.006505091208964586, -0.06555391848087311, -0.0518752820789814, -0.026981698349118233, -0.013682429678738117, -0.046237170696258545, 0.04279419034719467, 0.033388711512088776, -0.04096467047929764, -0.005902906879782677, -0.010645906440913677, -0.020818568766117096, -0.013959852047264576, -0.04670187085866928, 0.031094897538423538, -0.01784532703459263, -0.03185037150979042, 0.017581123858690262, 0.043998025357723236, -0.040471918880939484, 0.04177297279238701, -0.01467583142220974, -0.04900990054011345, -0.06945986300706863, -0.05790667235851288, -0.009876653552055359, -0.04863320291042328, -0.022340599447488785, -0.03450550511479378, 0.035809002816677094, -0.05253640562295914, -0.06421627849340439, -0.0628795251250267, -0.012033838778734207, 0.04929031431674957, -0.05168444290757179, -0.00009893900278257206, -0.05358191952109337, -0.012172515504062176, -0.03395409137010574, -0.038996245712041855, -0.014572071842849255, -0.05519844591617584, 0.026482094079256058, -0.02914114110171795, -0.05135274678468704, -0.03925080969929695, -0.00523859728127718, -0.053474437445402145, 0.0021552417892962694, 0.05516674742102623, 0.027328744530677795, -0.03918129950761795, 0.03945227339863777, -0.001554446411319077, -0.037833988666534424, -0.04148343950510025, -0.06505616009235382, 0.013641736470162868, -0.02131699211895466, 0.05273539200425148, 0.05243895575404167, 0.06442125886678696, -0.030279137194156647, 0.013321815058588982, 0.0033469004556536674, -0.03708556666970253, 0.03802655264735222, -0.014596063643693924, -0.029492197558283806, -0.03220905736088753, 0.006773994769901037, -0.0637955442070961, -0.04893345758318901, 0.0008217999711632729, -0.00970272533595562, -0.03171990439295769, -0.045065898448228836, -0.02681013010442257, -0.03075806424021721, -0.042706817388534546, -0.036233946681022644, 0.05058913305401802, 0.03699318319559097, -0.04739033058285713, -0.005823975894600153, -0.007909009233117104, -0.03145783394575119, -0.05494086071848869 ]
We study the dynamics of a magneto-optical trap (MOT) operating at high-bandwidth. We find the absolute importance of high recapture efficiency between cycles to maintain a practical atom number. We develop a simple model accounting for MOT trapping forces and pressure induced collisions and validate with experimental data using $\mathrm{{}^{87}Rb}$. This is then applied to quantum sensing predicting a shot noise limited sensitivity of $\mathrm{10^{-7}g/\sqrt{Hz}}$ for a gravimeter at 100 Hz operation. The results are useful for understanding MOT operation at high-bandwidth, particularly in the context of developing mobile high-bandwidth quantum inertial sensors targeting dynamic environments and navigation applications.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14026v1
[ -0.00545347249135375, -0.04055485874414444, 0.05559542402625084, 0.0018791417824104428, -0.03953035920858383, 0.04210124537348747, 0.03342142328619957, 0.01852482743561268, -0.02573261223733425, -0.01610124669969082, -0.04347749426960945, -0.0033901494462043047, -0.049731284379959106, -0.014296001754701138, -0.06912783533334732, 0.031070969998836517, 0.05629833787679672, -0.0171503946185112, -0.012915295548737049, 0.05070407688617706, 0.01708642579615116, -0.0490306131541729, -0.04978778213262558, 0.0034789631608873606, 0.010905752889811993, -0.04936574772000313, -0.02272644266486168, 0.048337556421756744, 0.004840692970901728, -0.03292517364025116, 0.05870135501027107, -0.024174854159355164, -0.04597112536430359, 0.006056285463273525, 0.006038331892341375, -0.010424666106700897, -0.03809957951307297, 0.04008437693119049, 0.05900032818317413, -0.0008279511821456254, 0.044482335448265076, -0.0066861482337117195, -0.03884665668010712, -0.05324222892522812, -0.010706762783229351, -0.03425326570868492, -0.035048723220825195, -0.03550782427191734, -0.017887387424707413, -0.03826164826750755, 0.02194838412106037, -0.020772503688931465, 0.015512815676629543, 0.052207671105861664, -0.02534916065633297, -0.005857206881046295, -0.014581858180463314, -0.002051296178251505, -0.058779094368219376, -0.035003889352083206, 0.011589322239160538, -0.0297172162681818, -0.001952224993146956, 0.019295891746878624, 0.00002980001772812102, 0.04805462807416916, -0.026381416246294975, -0.00451052887365222, -0.016348587349057198, -0.06043560057878494, 0.03241889923810959, -0.007230598479509354, 0.029745658859610558, -0.003971919417381287, -0.008467516861855984, -0.04153429716825485, -0.021840961650013924, 0.0044851903803646564, -0.05918624997138977, -0.003195281373336911, -0.018253600224852562, 0.02845131792128086, 0.021777084097266197, 0.05051129311323166, 0.0333511121571064, -0.03956601768732071, 0.05848172307014465, -0.044841259717941284, -0.029437756165862083, -0.03952089697122574, 0.04936577379703522, -0.026992708444595337, -0.060154061764478683, -0.016664525493979454, 0.04944439232349396, -0.04067384824156761, 0.08481411635875702, 0.010993976145982742, 0.03902841731905937, -0.046794239431619644, -0.054443277418613434, -0.008233199827373028, 0.008289086632430553, 0.02773146890103817, 0.013123680837452412, -0.025354772806167603, -0.02483833022415638, -0.03654555603861809, -0.04918089509010315, 0.003904969897121191, -0.03812272846698761, -0.06374754011631012, 0.028986118733882904, -0.06231970340013504, -0.047161076217889786, -0.04465143755078316, 0.024327844381332397, 0.014929348602890968, -0.04059562832117081, 0.04045894742012024, -0.04026199132204056, 0.06354719400405884, 0.035727523267269135, -0.016533654183149338, -0.015330322086811066, -0.008513006381690502, 0.06514836847782135, -0.018758786842226982, -0.006984707433730364, -0.06112213060259819, -0.019131528213620186, 0.03001369908452034, 0.018902508541941643, -0.056025657802820206, 0.04211513325572014, -0.01756676286458969, 0.010585709474980831, -0.014510616660118103, 0.012998292222619057, -0.01976538635790348, -0.024836212396621704, -0.011365420185029507, 0.045607294887304306, 0.014105265028774738, 0.02868892066180706, 0.029944373294711113, -0.055453382432460785, -0.0028123713564127684, 0.06871335953474045, 0.02071481943130493, 0.004906696733087301, 0.007936200127005577, -0.026385581120848656, 0.043654512614011765, 0.04778362065553665, 0.029382653534412384, 0.06554756313562393, 0.010084600187838078, -0.06569264084100723, -0.022443430498242378, 0.011662367731332779, -0.05439937114715576, -0.0040293363854289055, 0.0018175553996115923, 0.018210340291261673, -0.014437394216656685, 0.03202713280916214, -0.00932350568473339, -0.027224889025092125, 0.01017634104937315, 0.030185265466570854, -0.047667741775512695, 0.044955018907785416, -0.0406433567404747, -0.07959739118814468, -0.06227942183613777, -0.02107110619544983, -0.041966959834098816, -0.03815695643424988, 0.007490362506359816, 0.028314078226685524, 0.017538852989673615, -0.05556071177124977, -0.009073620662093163, -0.044589269906282425, 0.019036998972296715, -0.07400332391262054, -0.022204862907528877, 0.0358162485063076, -0.05178557708859444, -0.03113829717040062, -0.04667562246322632, -0.004134207498282194, -0.006911627482622862, -0.009813333861529827, -0.019739316776394844, -0.03559085354208946, 0.009792622178792953, 0.02637149579823017, -0.0045838188380002975, -0.06458315253257751, -0.03363092243671417, -0.032863132655620575, 0.000378684897441417, 0.00594866368919611, -0.07977092266082764, 0.026813752949237823, 0.014548142440617085, -0.03687136992812157, -0.01740092597901821, 0.06408919394016266, 0.002038514707237482, -0.016374163329601288, 0.05092533305287361, -0.007546957582235336, -0.005163618363440037, -0.09361276030540466, 0.06624234467744827, 0.059782061725854874, -0.02547827921807766, 0.02422834001481533, -0.0021112672984600067, -0.00671748910099268, -0.023800935596227646, 0.026654697954654694, 0.06441285461187363, 0.05742933228611946, -0.032713960856199265, -0.04536203667521477, 0.010647626593708992, -0.030639108270406723, -0.07250089943408966, -0.05218452215194702, -0.059912435710430145, -0.02715209126472473, -0.008409461937844753, -0.040383242070674896, 0.022288229316473007, -0.04723028838634491, -0.026059774681925774, 0.017480116337537766, -0.05339135602116585, 0.059234850108623505, -0.016625475138425827, -0.0640297681093216, -0.023371141403913498, -0.035408057272434235, 0.014824667945504189, -0.039863478392362595, -0.02609214559197426, -0.04697033762931824, -0.027296733111143112, -0.021741488948464394, -0.028739573433995247, 0.037697359919548035, 0.038651108741760254, -0.016847090795636177, 0.007343860808759928, -0.024885058403015137, 0.017158614471554756, -0.019336946308612823, -0.04175332561135292, -0.05397292971611023, 0.028714288026094437, -0.037477776408195496, 0.012352381832897663, -0.0548044890165329, 0.012365642935037613, -0.016798892989754677, -0.038313183933496475, 0.008536678738892078, 0.011640863493084908, 0.04294288158416748, 0.007339403033256531, -0.007279670797288418, -0.01421470008790493, -0.0386812798678875, -0.01820450834929943, 0.015795521438121796, -0.008411431685090065, 0.06446684896945953, -0.021412108093500137, 0.0322381854057312, -0.06606574356555939, -0.031164580956101418, -0.03163729980587959, 0.008661281317472458, -0.08166617155075073, -0.035509832203388214, 0.0032489406876266003, -0.06495068967342377, -0.011407800018787384, -0.03112318366765976, -0.05661690980195999, -0.017954131588339806, -0.0357939675450325, -0.0047058523632586, 0.02836318127810955, 0.02050277777016163, -0.06968715041875839, -0.032535895705223083, -0.012316844426095486, 0.0336880199611187, 0.030522001907229424, -0.03702777996659279, -0.04302910342812538, -0.029793638736009598, -0.018403148278594017, -0.0037884998600929976, -0.0143209770321846, -0.05324747413396835, -0.027078624814748764, -0.06298600882291794, 0.021318618208169937, -0.04357899725437164, 0.05596701800823212, 0.009293252602219582, -0.008037758059799671, -0.03850703686475754, -0.005911638028919697, 0.012538796290755272, -0.03357291221618652, 0.036944400519132614, -0.009605384431779385, -0.04831212759017944, -0.02313445508480072, 0.06820449978113174, 0.048637088388204575, 0.02434425614774227, -0.03896576166152954, 0.008253849111497402, 0.02949034422636032, -0.0007865517982281744, 0.03429710119962692, 0.06178111582994461, -0.01349898986518383, -0.031039902940392494, -0.009231757372617722, -0.04312439262866974, 0.048630163073539734, -0.014903542585670948, -0.01968887448310852, -0.02336001954972744, 0.005260767415165901, 0.023719774559140205, -0.07474230229854584, 0.028182176873087883, 0.05730472505092621, 0.022557979449629784, 0.005206274800002575, 0.028844457119703293, 0.04860640689730644, 0.009937315247952938, 0.04684428125619888, 0.012095973826944828, 0.01277228631079197, 0.03615568205714226, 0.04309113323688507, -0.011054451577365398, -0.02795649878680706, -0.02890743874013424, -0.0799717977643013, -0.030072422698140144, -0.02186358906328678, -0.010607646778225899, 0.0462675467133522, 0.02364201284945011, -0.058960821479558945, 0.020832760259509087, -0.023094212636351585, 0.05072687193751335, 0.02733643911778927, -0.028469078242778778, 0.03255661204457283, -0.024958131834864616, 0.004269305616617203, 0.026865316554903984, 0.018838578835129738, -0.020405752584338188, -0.0502069927752018, 0.02824598178267479, -0.003168311435729265, 0.031077861785888672, 0.0064218007028102875, -0.01551806554198265, 0.016135552898049355, 0.008761410601437092, -0.013667506165802479, 0.025716330856084824, -0.03645200654864311, -0.04193286970257759, -0.00855826586484909, -0.04556233435869217, -0.010005184449255466, 0.02753797173500061, -0.06173053756356239, 0.014464707113802433, 0.0017566478345543146, -0.056721512228250504, 0.02234605886042118, 0.039200857281684875, 0.00466433260589838, -0.04815034568309784, -0.08607985824346542, -0.005255609750747681, -0.08057289570569992, 0.03306308016180992, -0.021715767681598663, 0.032633308321237564, 0.06816788762807846, 0.005521219689399004, -0.03816434368491173, -0.02614111267030239, 0.0021037047263234854, -0.007371843326836824, -0.07020048797130585, -0.04719490930438042, -0.047273918986320496, 0.035834409296512604, -0.02158074639737606, 0.0314338356256485, -0.042966924607753754, 0.011100277304649353, -0.07216299325227737, -0.035125482827425, -0.02746322564780712, 0.043613675981760025, 0.05166570842266083, 0.008735599927604198, -0.020444519817829132, 0.0038610862102359533, -0.047832734882831573, -0.0011923498241230845, 0.01603143848478794, 0.029237112030386925, 0.016702743247151375, 0.02939629927277565, -0.053017403930425644, -0.012746709398925304, -0.03406410291790962, 0.039324868470430374, 0.06697431206703186, -0.016046620905399323, -0.007419740315526724, 0.008048953488469124, 0.05500108003616333, -0.05727638676762581, -0.044272299855947495, -0.029100894927978516, -0.07135557383298874, -0.07137259095907211, -0.03308270126581192, 0.0403638556599617, -0.02341247908771038, -0.007697485387325287, 0.02494320645928383, 0.032431330531835556, 0.040335070341825485, -0.01974407397210598, 0.014735895209014416, 0.026097051799297333, 0.044362545013427734, -0.008466977626085281, -0.02933948114514351, -0.06261449307203293, 0.01034126803278923, 0.01829329878091812, -0.03224153444170952, -0.01267505157738924, 0.035145342350006104, 0.011816048063337803, 0.03614630177617073, -0.062040504068136215, 0.045080672949552536, 0.030084814876317978, -0.032665953040122986, 0.015249015763401985, 0.023717593401670456, 0.0002597234270069748, 0.01441869605332613, -0.040314946323633194, -0.00544422771781683, 0.009303963743150234, -0.05074857547879219, -0.030722493305802345, 0.005378734320402145, -0.040581248700618744, 0.022641552612185478, -0.04146455228328705, -0.0020368515979498625, -0.06413690000772476, 0.03760378062725067, 0.008447473868727684, 0.00567301781848073, -0.030773451551795006, 0.0347827784717083, 0.06272584199905396, 0.03216228634119034, -0.0732063353061676, -0.022971300408244133, 0.013995367102324963, 0.023951495066285133, 0.038427893072366714, -0.06005688011646271, -0.009571581147611141, -0.03112304024398327, 0.019835298880934715, -0.012216293253004551, 0.03214066103100777, 0.006718842778354883, -0.03534805029630661, 0.021542854607105255, -0.04152018204331398, -0.07309720665216446, -0.046722523868083954, -0.04797588661313057, -0.014138666912913322, -0.00032128908787854016, 0.04647011309862137, 0.05876815691590309, 0.05782347172498703, 0.008000531233847141, -0.0725102573633194, -0.05243784561753273, -0.032542306929826736, 0.04838379845023155, -0.05493609979748726, 0.01591305620968342, -0.005592592991888523, 0.04875894635915756, 0.037219151854515076, -0.04258240386843681, -0.010807097889482975, -0.03349584713578224, -0.04242628812789917, -0.05009826645255089, 0.008609576150774956, 0.017679551616311073, -0.039896417409181595, 0.027384497225284576, 0.05113084614276886, -0.041311632841825485, 0.032631129026412964, -0.006323919631540775, 0.0031555264722555876, 0.039593566209077835, -0.006146916653960943, 0.004324105102568865, -0.061785753816366196, 0.0441235788166523, 0.0855231061577797, -0.014731663279235363, -0.006867729127407074, -0.01302760187536478, -0.030788708478212357, -0.005596726201474667, -0.0634143278002739, -0.037388984113931656, -0.03691551834344864, -0.010631570592522621, -0.04350108653306961, 0.029381809756159782, -0.022403331473469734, -0.07580724358558655, 0.023706939071416855, 0.015991969034075737, -0.0719551295042038, 0.00452980725094676, -0.0011374882888048887, -0.05705481395125389, -0.07161804288625717, 0.056308817118406296, -0.009323948994278908, -0.04218577221035957, -0.00937153771519661, 0.025097237899899483, 0.03213419392704964, 0.021540697664022446, 0.01740860939025879, 0.015756716951727867, -0.006319263484328985, 0.027287976816296577, -0.021949879825115204, -0.014437307603657246, 0.019211746752262115, 0.056412965059280396, 0.011432550847530365, -0.0668906569480896, -0.02827964723110199, 0.07329068332910538, -0.04439496248960495, 0.0006891958182677627, -0.003220923477783799, 0.001234006485901773, 0.010780679993331432, -0.020958583801984787, -0.04155978932976723, 0.009699583984911442, -0.03688538447022438, -0.02400077134370804, -0.024961495772004128, 0.006107439752668142, 0.005107993260025978, 0.011058378033339977, 0.007606334984302521, -0.0246172733604908, -0.035749148577451706, -0.033225301653146744, -0.04571288451552391, 0.01691260188817978, -0.06048647686839104, -0.01669487915933132, 0.008685250766575336, 0.01840200275182724, 0.03208829089999199, 0.02435806579887867, -0.056023020297288895, -0.040825940668582916, -0.025076232850551605, 0.0144584896042943, 0.023224439471960068, -0.02324502170085907, 0.04421250894665718, -0.053076740354299545, 0.06040801480412483, -0.005793132819235325, -0.027465110644698143, -0.03412531688809395, -0.07216456532478333, -0.0133586460724473, 0.020482968538999557, 0.010656163096427917, -0.033877838402986526, -0.0349540039896965, -0.00458524189889431, 0.034336961805820465, 0.00804161000996828, -0.015695445239543915, -0.0405212827026844, 0.011803139001131058, -0.0029593859799206257, 0.01252453401684761, -0.008493967354297638, -0.017266836017370224, -0.03168851137161255, -0.031837884336709976, -0.013956994749605656, 0.0321589820086956, -0.0217561237514019, -0.012074028141796589, -0.011469466611742973, 0.005163108929991722, 0.05085747689008713, -0.013362448662519455, -0.0063915010541677475, -0.02172132022678852, -0.023501720279455185, -0.0802648514509201, -0.009184140712022781, 0.0046662259846925735, 0.009371762163937092, 0.01294325664639473, -0.053229618817567825, 0.027223942801356316, 0.030470138415694237, 0.0050704893656075, -0.08609899878501892, -0.03378438949584961, -0.03153456002473831, -0.02075096219778061, 0.021490275859832764, 0.008378295227885246, -0.04856280982494354, 0.012756651267409325, -0.07586763799190521, -0.03408247232437134, -0.013247149996459484, 0.024833884090185165, 0.014192285016179085, -0.04714579880237579, -0.024435237050056458, -0.024788230657577515, 0.022830307483673096, 0.058549296110868454, 0.0010711713694036007, 0.03173623979091644, 0.03467162325978279, -0.02568565122783184, -0.05143972486257553, -0.03614942729473114, 0.0057183667086064816, -0.0028701545670628548, 0.006392241921275854, 0.029031401500105858, 0.04237142577767372, -0.00581927178427577, -0.04854823648929596, 0.031228922307491302, -0.019303372129797935, 0.010971581563353539, -0.0067094461992383, -0.00784937385469675, -0.036479879170656204, -0.06745355576276779, 0.03838011994957924, -0.06051662191748619, 0.009234264492988586, 0.004528096877038479, 0.017277758568525314, 0.05603989586234093, -0.028040334582328796, -0.03182965889573097, 0.017334066331386566, 0.05108240246772766, -0.013429039157927036, 0.04992251098155975, -0.03960511088371277, 0.006869766395539045, -0.00920427218079567, -0.021761860698461533, -0.06610729545354843, 0.049129169434309006, 0.04121353477239609, -0.04710504785180092, 0.002000150503590703, -0.06006040796637535, 0.03807705640792847, 0.006124235689640045, 0.022758854553103447, -0.03271405026316643, 0.0670539140701294, -0.021127022802829742, -0.03563714399933815, -0.06544826179742813, -0.04906272143125534, -0.05130702257156372, -0.019000841304659843, 0.04462520778179169, 0.027738366276025772, 0.023666370660066605, 0.015040529891848564, -0.0007338232826441526, -0.027313143014907837, 0.06148349121212959, 0.010520313866436481, 0.032791513949632645, -0.019201617687940598, -0.053851280361413956, -0.04094628244638443, 0.06910860538482666, 0.007081885356456041, -0.005316156893968582, -0.04672771692276001, 0.016691425815224648, -0.026592016220092773, -0.05538138374686241, -0.00690904725342989, -0.0076459781266748905, -0.017301125451922417, -0.031065279617905617, -0.05605153366923332, 0.012625510804355145, -0.02062380500137806, -0.06505448371171951, -0.035568200051784515, -0.019813451915979385, 0.0036763965617865324, -0.0612218976020813 ]
The classical Minkowski inequality implies that the volume of a bounded convex domain is controlled from above by the integral of the mean curvature of its boundary. In this note, we establish an analogous inequality without the convexity assumption for all bounded smooth domains in a complete manifold with its bottom spectrum being suitably large relative to its Ricci curvature lower bound. An immediate implication is the nonexistence of embedded compact minimal hypersurfaces in such manifolds. This nonexistence issue is also considered for steady and expanding Ricci solitons.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13749v1
[ -0.015225039795041084, 0.004869662690907717, 0.036920879036188126, 0.014698748476803303, 0.00673737982288003, -0.02507384680211544, -0.0842074602842331, 0.006207543890923262, 0.03296525031328201, 0.00891877431422472, -0.0012263370444998145, -0.06930170208215714, -0.07191701233386993, -0.08287008851766586, -0.03844049945473671, 0.0012113492703065276, 0.04676501825451851, 0.04522424936294556, -0.06407604366540909, 0.054010454565286636, 0.008797887712717056, -0.057928666472435, -0.03227391839027405, 0.05160105600953102, 0.05540575087070465, -0.04222632199525833, -0.03971075266599655, 0.0043600816279649734, -0.013259265571832657, -0.02433982864022255, 0.04553183540701866, -0.0054077268578112125, -0.03229115158319473, -0.04453986510634422, 0.03477730229496956, 0.03536076843738556, -0.006635876372456551, 0.008461936376988888, 0.004713156260550022, -0.01823570765554905, -0.003422441426664591, -0.012459700927138329, -0.014697441831231117, -0.020324550569057465, -0.041327785700559616, -0.015294041484594345, -0.028525935485959053, 0.007854009047150612, -0.05204193294048309, -0.036139752715826035, 0.05939214304089546, 0.03315737843513489, 0.016857605427503586, 0.05921643227338791, -0.03739701211452484, -0.05891304835677147, 0.016277780756354332, 0.0036130123771727085, -0.03087160736322403, 0.02008567750453949, -0.03468259051442146, -0.01995396800339222, -0.02734472043812275, -0.04602136090397835, -0.013003315776586533, 0.03397766873240471, -0.028008179739117622, -0.0712505653500557, -0.00998972449451685, -0.02091474086046219, 0.06209727004170418, -0.05522601678967476, 0.00462969159707427, -0.004985824227333069, -0.06736741960048676, -0.01265346072614193, -0.009162835776805878, -0.013375732116401196, -0.005670767277479172, 0.03026445023715496, -0.001078467583283782, 0.016042334958910942, 0.01377804670482874, 0.016751518473029137, -0.002481041243299842, 0.0034923250786960125, 0.04866558685898781, -0.046303872019052505, -0.0060094185173511505, -0.03316878527402878, -0.0245875995606184, -0.009300383739173412, -0.0696687176823616, -0.0030972708482295275, 0.05891643092036247, -0.06349319964647293, 0.04609222710132599, 0.05027519911527634, 0.019047129899263382, 0.015569198876619339, -0.020567724481225014, -0.046122245490550995, -0.03448575362563133, 0.021220484748482704, -0.029066169634461403, 0.0019841238390654325, 0.0008852705359458923, 0.03194361552596092, 0.01282446924597025, 0.04084332659840584, -0.059749405831098557, -0.013028678484261036, 0.0018216291209682822, -0.010128083638846874, -0.031134748831391335, -0.00759185990318656, 0.03882680833339691, 0.03554350137710571, 0.017948295921087265, -0.014726574532687664, -0.053974445909261703, 0.018081847578287125, -0.008670136332511902, -0.008705389685928822, -0.0055502355098724365, -0.043705254793167114, 0.03832253813743591, -0.0003237803466618061, -0.003061033086851239, -0.03315553814172745, -0.052773214876651764, -0.029116744175553322, 0.03821318596601486, 0.0007054166635498405, 0.028538253158330917, 0.012854318134486675, 0.06365508586168289, -0.02379286289215088, 0.01314394548535347, 0.05977315828204155, 0.013761679641902447, -0.013296312652528286, 0.02639147639274597, 0.01949913799762726, 0.03182888776063919, 0.041091736406087875, -0.07373056560754776, -0.014707350172102451, 0.043896835297346115, 0.04166148602962494, -0.026749519631266594, 0.006531310733407736, 0.018836118280887604, -0.00840496364980936, -0.02073793299496174, -0.0013944068923592567, 0.05096585676074028, 0.048405274748802185, -0.013196166604757309, 0.036653779447078705, 0.044079821556806564, 0.011121383868157864, -0.0396140031516552, 0.015377964824438095, -0.0005606943741440773, 0.03972652554512024, 0.029020586982369423, -0.040788743644952774, 0.01725916936993599, -0.001232946291565895, -0.022002751007676125, 0.05323028191924095, -0.003589482279494405, -0.03639572858810425, -0.020125754177570343, -0.03843171149492264, -0.020360706374049187, -0.06582216918468475, 0.010161405429244041, 0.028657421469688416, 0.020427118986845016, -0.03588596358895302, -0.03470180928707123, -0.013911738991737366, -0.020504958927631378, -0.0033290968276560307, -0.04605359584093094, 0.028922026976943016, -0.0008513522334396839, 0.008714274503290653, 0.036375802010297775, -0.057855989784002304, -0.004021570086479187, 0.019379597157239914, -0.06788723170757294, -0.024948986247181892, -0.03189607337117195, -0.006549878045916557, -0.036449506878852844, 0.015808099880814552, -0.07016891241073608, -0.041925039142370224, -0.02155492827296257, 0.02289186231791973, -0.028594564646482468, -0.030073579400777817, 0.035807620733976364, 0.0646577924489975, -0.07388745993375778, -0.016179654747247696, 0.061674024909734726, 0.0006134225404821336, 0.057646602392196655, -0.037463437765836716, 0.010563163086771965, 0.0060719894245266914, -0.0970902219414711, -0.023620188236236572, -0.02052699774503708, 0.022760270163416862, -0.021102184429764748, 0.008913661353290081, -0.029592160135507584, -0.0521903857588768, -0.07391085475683212, 0.07855243235826492, 0.043056339025497437, -0.004286143928766251, -0.04181535914540291, 0.0014276878209784627, -0.01961052417755127, -0.07722537964582443, -0.03508492931723595, -0.03341873735189438, -0.05071882903575897, 0.0030971141532063484, -0.05240719020366669, 0.06023422256112099, -0.028471458703279495, -0.05013120919466019, -0.07743267714977264, 0.02802622877061367, 0.05151720717549324, -0.04001728817820549, -0.011718028225004673, -0.03987613692879677, -0.03673093393445015, 0.026548106223344803, -0.053094781935214996, -0.014881547540426254, 0.015135801397264004, -0.05646102502942085, 0.004031843971461058, -0.054984867572784424, 0.027953460812568665, 0.06035415455698967, -0.03487684950232506, 0.0010724267922341824, 0.037004102021455765, -0.024961676448583603, 0.029536457732319832, -0.014086863957345486, -0.07454921305179596, 0.0022986531257629395, -0.012596918269991875, -0.024707695469260216, -0.07008494436740875, 0.04335613176226616, -0.011431821621954441, -0.028576724231243134, 0.034601420164108276, -0.026908904314041138, 0.03551559895277023, 0.006581395864486694, -0.00079015624942258, 0.02180214412510395, 0.007141636684536934, -0.0153824333101511, 0.04600052908062935, -0.012000796385109425, 0.06419241428375244, 0.03761689364910126, -0.047347575426101685, -0.07243900746107101, 0.01269893441349268, -0.03867102786898613, -0.020258259028196335, -0.02928273379802704, -0.043200768530368805, -0.010807112790644169, -0.04891263693571091, -0.011908755637705326, -0.01763797551393509, -0.014191965572535992, -0.0325872041285038, -0.05870465561747551, -0.025336414575576782, -0.0034373407252132893, -0.018359068781137466, -0.041216760873794556, -0.023731905966997147, -0.03389281406998634, 0.050406936556100845, 0.019338110461831093, -0.013824604451656342, -0.06081818416714668, -0.044988520443439484, 0.035688623785972595, 0.03693190589547157, -0.009039443917572498, -0.013348862528800964, -0.03955720737576485, 0.033640362322330475, -0.007812856696546078, -0.009076982736587524, 0.03356871008872986, -0.0023515461944043636, -0.021773120388388634, 0.04499752074480057, 0.04277468100190163, -0.04181334376335144, -0.043715573847293854, -0.02694687992334366, -0.009598844684660435, -0.04788838326931, -0.05633076652884483, 0.05854145810008049, 0.05297160521149635, -0.019766954705119133, -0.06601302325725555, 0.013384065590798855, -0.006580996792763472, -0.006346701178699732, -0.027308259159326553, 0.06711150705814362, 0.014742598868906498, -0.0273102018982172, 0.012149689719080925, -0.05686955153942108, 0.04130702465772629, 0.0002556398103479296, 0.03176889196038246, -0.006815870758146048, 0.010020275600254536, -0.009512118063867092, -0.07790558785200119, -0.012843402102589607, 0.029289279133081436, 0.04397446662187576, -0.01950732059776783, -0.007230993825942278, 0.009056787006556988, 0.05210603028535843, 0.004608946852385998, -0.039643630385398865, 0.009727569296956062, 0.030796781182289124, 0.07039472460746765, 0.035401761531829834, -0.03408855199813843, -0.010014335624873638, -0.051146816462278366, 0.005265760235488415, 0.0019106153631582856, 0.016315244138240814, 0.005692383274435997, 0.05777711793780327, 0.03198841214179993, -0.009080690331757069, -0.027527086436748505, 0.05803794786334038, -0.037016287446022034, -0.0464651994407177, 0.034770943224430084, -0.0303749181330204, -0.05566241592168808, -0.017888369038701057, 0.025928862392902374, -0.033660534769296646, -0.07391130924224854, -0.023442290723323822, -0.04582231491804123, 0.015270511619746685, -0.03180459514260292, -0.007791712414473295, 0.0508570671081543, 0.02176264114677906, -0.012912343256175518, 0.03926079720258713, 0.05460681393742561, 0.019741211086511612, -0.02608233317732811, -0.0039386204443871975, 0.011077218689024448, 0.006649377755820751, 0.0007005907827988267, 0.011180737987160683, -0.0384763702750206, -0.03823438286781311, 0.026355085894465446, 0.010828056372702122, -0.026107488200068474, -0.046645618975162506, -0.07860518246889114, 0.03421591967344284, -0.019465632736682892, 0.014218400232493877, -0.016196945682168007, -0.06543273478746414, 0.02349700592458248, -0.0004920312785543501, 0.04686325788497925, -0.0226126741617918, -0.0372944101691246, 0.00012853252701461315, 0.003880481468513608, -0.053200867027044296, -0.04090035706758499, 0.03137105330824852, -0.04697849601507187, 0.036680229008197784, -0.018841903656721115, 0.01543259248137474, -0.038480207324028015, -0.02739790827035904, -0.04317241534590721, 0.005965778604149818, 0.018472496420145035, 0.031185198575258255, 0.041486505419015884, -0.0531962588429451, -0.01633470319211483, -0.002528297482058406, 0.03615521639585495, -0.05623507872223854, 0.0018559017917141318, 0.023942232131958008, -0.03253840282559395, -0.05092635378241539, -0.06577576696872711, 0.0341825932264328, -0.0006827979232184589, -0.051034748554229736, -0.05314039811491966, 0.014059292152523994, 0.028641747310757637, -0.05915137380361557, -0.04570869728922844, -0.025462523102760315, -0.017289945855736732, -0.07588422298431396, 0.019909963011741638, -0.028913043439388275, 0.002099025994539261, -0.010731260292232037, 0.04825867339968681, -0.006241566501557827, 0.001234670402482152, -0.028692863881587982, 0.0037937541492283344, 0.05478094890713692, 0.002578664803877473, -0.04828009381890297, -0.02914198860526085, -0.04945289343595505, -0.04551376402378082, 0.007426644675433636, 0.0002210231905337423, -0.04235988110303879, 0.056630972772836685, -0.02360106073319912, -0.04553883150219917, -0.07964012771844864, 0.022111281752586365, 0.02826162986457348, -0.057408057153224945, 0.008677328936755657, 0.01937432959675789, -0.052534397691488266, 0.04062115028500557, -0.0015216160099953413, 0.0414285808801651, 0.023997541517019272, 0.0191702451556921, -0.023662075400352478, 0.007470901124179363, -0.03054168075323105, -0.044287342578172684, -0.0181211419403553, -0.04779702052474022, -0.038779497146606445, 0.01628383807837963, 0.0071748290210962296, -0.037624333053827286, -0.025604721158742905, -0.016663094982504845, 0.07296965271234512, 0.005604996811598539, -0.040346190333366394, 0.04802129790186882, -0.0041260807774960995, -0.0289881844073534, 0.015646718442440033, -0.06451841443777084, 0.0015818156534805894, 0.03640105947852135, -0.01698475144803524, -0.016019729897379875, 0.023058855906128883, -0.003188380738720298, 0.004651897121220827, -0.013736003078520298, 0.005905135069042444, -0.025107992812991142, 0.029391491785645485, -0.011670341715216637, 0.03257724642753601, 0.05199632793664932, 0.0024066094774752855, 0.00940276775509119, 0.018775461241602898, 0.018442407250404358, -0.005400993395596743, 0.022774646058678627, -0.04807469993829727, 0.028155207633972168, -0.0757075846195221, -0.010938916355371475, 0.009960666298866272, 0.058467332273721695, 0.026643602177500725, -0.008033805526793003, -0.010168800130486488, 0.01977335847914219, -0.03965430334210396, -0.037424683570861816, -0.02824428491294384, -0.0065813432447612286, -0.006465393118560314, -0.009935707785189152, 0.025757398456335068, -0.04912934452295303, 0.04873655363917351, -0.0041626994498074055, -0.003193191485479474, 0.029994690790772438, -0.04478123039007187, 0.006319884210824966, -0.07052031904459, -0.059819646179676056, 0.06407034397125244, -0.05435795336961746, -0.02176634594798088, -0.01792466826736927, -0.06661725044250488, -0.03084692917764187, -0.048135463148355484, 0.029803531244397163, 0.019359085708856583, 0.011882889084517956, -0.012564609758555889, 0.00865109171718359, 0.01015451829880476, -0.05807130038738251, -0.029762037098407745, 0.06071528047323227, -0.06718192994594574, -0.003763573244214058, -0.01967574842274189, -0.053364090621471405, -0.036477502435445786, 0.00569992046803236, -0.015063447877764702, -0.01772860623896122, -0.03826355189085007, -0.003729497082531452, 0.05883152782917023, -0.056848250329494476, 0.020323356613516808, -0.0016717221587896347, -0.008122403174638748, 0.020575672388076782, -0.00022020749747753143, 0.020254036411643028, -0.04280653968453407, 0.004477862734347582, -0.05562726408243179, -0.021489618346095085, 0.007626785431057215, 0.053978774696588516, -0.002575240097939968, -0.008036348968744278, -0.006522578187286854, 0.02766420692205429, 0.0494600310921669, -0.027328964322805405, -0.031185947358608246, -0.01304326206445694, -0.01869972050189972, 0.002545110648497939, 0.008150439709424973, 0.01795314997434616, -0.040074869990348816, 0.05323243513703346, -0.04082786664366722, -0.031598277390003204, 0.0004387939698062837, 0.03437338396906853, -0.012108130380511284, -0.057195890694856644, -0.013604347594082355, -0.01992139033973217, -0.032914310693740845, 0.045413509011268616, -0.01993320696055889, 0.060081612318754196, -0.01131779607385397, -0.02593420259654522, -0.046519599854946136, -0.00862887967377901, -0.014816592447459698, -0.031726621091365814, -0.01947861537337303, 0.046807557344436646, 0.06895236670970917, -0.05495143681764603, 0.039477817714214325, -0.01367268431931734, -0.03317829594016075, 0.04685540869832039, -0.04357107728719711, -0.047589901834726334, 0.005390241742134094, -0.033270400017499924, -0.056214768439531326, 0.030879318714141846, 0.03399737551808357, -0.024448763579130173, -0.047887299209833145, 0.008022342808544636, 0.03068232536315918, -0.04077198728919029, -0.034498151391744614, 0.01501172874122858, -0.021815551444888115, 0.0311515424400568, 0.04869156703352928, 0.07115937024354935, 0.025282464921474457, -0.05691538006067276, -0.07456712424755096, -0.020145844668149948, 0.05472472682595253, 0.021188044920563698, -0.0073496331460773945, -0.0353868268430233, -0.02553286775946617, 0.015108280815184116, 0.04426112025976181, -0.013681289739906788, 0.033885031938552856, -0.014856897294521332, 0.009772855788469315, 0.05576835945248604, 0.015636175870895386, -0.04859649017453194, -0.07917694002389908, -0.0033851980697363615, -0.03835392743349075, 0.03182802349328995, -0.01908942125737667, 0.016430247575044632, -0.06019224971532822, 0.01404009759426117, -0.06850103288888931, -0.017471028491854668, -0.025460759177803993, 0.05433175712823868, 0.03110888972878456, 0.0063399216160178185, -0.08046923577785492, -0.01366627961397171, -0.0040907906368374825, 0.0284452885389328, -0.03349091857671738, 0.015893656760454178, 0.030783889815211296, -0.008711017668247223, -0.01736590452492237, -0.022886648774147034, 0.05241462215781212, -0.06744121015071869, -0.02565358206629753, 0.03639527037739754, 0.025476284325122833, -0.01891731657087803, 0.045597970485687256, 0.037073537707328796, -0.013009835965931416, 0.025736156851053238, -0.014592635445296764, -0.016078246757388115, -0.07614514976739883, -0.003567503998056054, 0.01988701894879341, -0.05303619056940079, 0.02688683196902275, -0.010279622860252857, -0.006310937460511923, -0.037221308797597885, -0.05459528788924217, -0.051160264760255814, 0.032813910394907, 0.011486263945698738, -0.01319602970033884, 0.059455547481775284, -0.036577191203832626, 0.01903967373073101, 0.027433782815933228, -0.04048564285039902, -0.06457120180130005, 0.03192628175020218, -0.020808616653084755, -0.03772146999835968, 0.029968151822686195, -0.06594838201999664, 0.00318063679151237, -0.04684581607580185, -0.009428181685507298, 0.06971690058708191, 0.014217010699212551, -0.02634017914533615, 0.008697611279785633, -0.058693576604127884, -0.06669128686189651, 0.042859118431806564, -0.04233277216553688, 0.014476697891950607, -0.0018261878285557032, 0.0184435173869133, -0.03272070735692978, 0.07628045231103897, 0.03141665458679199, 0.014060703106224537, 0.02992725558578968, 0.015431873500347137, -0.03437424823641777, 0.0031832351814955473, -0.046451229602098465, 0.055349402129650116, -0.005271278787404299, -0.04216461256146431, -0.03562060743570328, -0.04211050271987915, -0.008591323159635067, 0.03792520985007286, -0.032884739339351654, -0.0125168701633811, 0.03586341440677643, -0.07368841767311096, -0.04210596904158592, 0.0077130296267569065, -0.0012628893600776792, -0.045813776552677155, 0.050715237855911255, -0.034266069531440735, -0.0037784797605127096, -0.06003750115633011 ]
Quantum dynamics of a collection of atoms subjected to phase modulation has been carefully revisited. We present an exact analysis of the evolution of a two-level system (represented by a spinor) under the action of a time-dependent matrix Hamiltonian. The dynamics is shown to evolve on two coupled potential energy surfaces, one of them binding while the other one scattering type. The dynamics is shown to be quasi-integrable with nonlinear resonances. The bounded dynamics with intermittent scattering at random moments presents the scenario reminiscent to Anderson and dynamical localization. We believe that a careful analytical investigation of a multi-component system which is classically non-integrable is relevant to many other fields, including quantum computation with multi-qubit system.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04235v1
[ -0.03776406869292259, -0.0024372246116399765, 0.020092127844691277, 0.0498545803129673, 0.008294584229588509, -0.04143007472157478, 0.02486642450094223, 0.012793182395398617, 0.03775333613157272, -0.02252938784658909, -0.00395334092900157, -0.059652362018823624, -0.0053115906193852425, -0.03146360442042351, -0.0429215133190155, 0.01656712032854557, 0.062197789549827576, 0.043911825865507126, -0.05843371897935867, 0.0768289640545845, 0.033370986580848694, 0.007962564006447792, -0.04363035783171654, 0.04862320423126221, -0.000057166340411640704, -0.034586694091558456, 0.0018981525208801031, 0.024204200133681297, -0.03808939456939697, -0.01772427000105381, 0.07027620822191238, -0.058762166649103165, 0.02848791517317295, -0.011971276253461838, 0.0015565778594464064, 0.01397322490811348, 0.011697808280587196, 0.031851258128881454, 0.04002326726913452, 0.038239993155002594, -0.019126810133457184, -0.02867710404098034, -0.0682373121380806, 0.007544593885540962, 0.014907075092196465, 0.004847799893468618, -0.042199041694402695, -0.00028924623620696366, -0.05599376931786537, -0.043520137667655945, 0.023575756698846817, 0.003946446347981691, 0.020436495542526245, 0.05057748034596443, -0.04151443392038345, -0.03045840747654438, 0.019314216449856758, -0.007253536023199558, -0.05185402184724808, -0.01038412842899561, -0.03587226942181587, -0.042333073914051056, 0.044919032603502274, -0.045290958136320114, 0.0029544869903475046, 0.05407271534204483, -0.04350408539175987, -0.050813619047403336, -0.04820157214999199, -0.04874700307846069, 0.05586196109652519, -0.06978504359722137, 0.02796151116490364, -0.0006665180553682148, -0.06923665851354599, 0.008681931532919407, -0.019720768555998802, -0.01547362469136715, 0.021519551053643227, 0.0371566042304039, -0.022190747782588005, 0.00007074767199810594, 0.005992510821670294, 0.0398150235414505, 0.03849535062909126, 0.014756259508430958, 0.06623458117246628, 0.010571661405265331, 0.04512052983045578, -0.03302093967795372, -0.0016289097256958485, -0.03128966689109802, -0.052357811480760574, -0.04123969376087189, 0.040071722120046616, -0.04017423465847969, 0.06376451253890991, 0.07185884565114975, 0.013770068995654583, 0.007277301046997309, -0.01997406594455242, -0.06618957966566086, -0.03227319195866585, 0.03983866050839424, -0.002368911635130644, -0.0412660613656044, -0.031440235674381256, 0.013326527550816536, 0.0016816990682855248, 0.06071397289633751, 0.00975659117102623, -0.01774664595723152, -0.016637997701764107, -0.027294138446450233, -0.03869711980223656, -0.01386371161788702, 0.0549640953540802, 0.030745433643460274, -0.002424086444079876, 0.02099224179983139, -0.03069906122982502, 0.001246188534423709, -0.02747242897748947, 0.002198354806751013, -0.03319968655705452, 0.008648768998682499, 0.0700763612985611, 0.043894752860069275, 0.02543913759291172, -0.03273241966962814, -0.04166695103049278, -0.0024533700197935104, 0.02790910378098488, -0.004769585095345974, 0.04970233142375946, -0.035281792283058167, 0.016298510134220123, -0.049546416848897934, -0.003784215310588479, 0.03898017108440399, -0.049633268266916275, -0.06589772552251816, 0.05625487118959427, 0.018123570829629898, 0.01686151698231697, -0.016481569036841393, -0.08076411485671997, 0.018664686009287834, 0.030415890738368034, 0.027203908190131187, -0.014348703436553478, 0.026640363037586212, 0.035329654812812805, -0.01052776351571083, 0.0010292259976267815, -0.020846404135227203, 0.04657802730798721, -0.024284714832901955, -0.067922443151474, -0.02115444466471672, 0.026764873415231705, -0.041249193251132965, -0.004689531400799751, 0.017728637903928757, 0.013927404768764973, 0.028622057288885117, 0.048423342406749725, -0.0551031120121479, -0.03179165720939636, -0.018079126253724098, -0.02255934849381447, 0.02043299376964569, 0.06122273951768875, -0.024387091398239136, -0.03460376709699631, -0.054078344255685806, -0.07664816081523895, -0.07596156001091003, -0.031291473656892776, 0.008275746367871761, 0.06184189394116402, 0.0055924225598573685, -0.05052828788757324, -0.002497960813343525, -0.025696801021695137, 0.02606002427637577, -0.07461120188236237, 0.0018023261800408363, 0.04053313285112381, -0.012938622385263443, -0.016248591244220734, -0.055766068398952484, 0.012696333229541779, -0.011186221614480019, -0.045807525515556335, -0.03369595855474472, 0.04288819432258606, -0.057025786489248276, -0.02080845646560192, 0.047835465520620346, -0.07272029668092728, -0.028885487467050552, 0.0001959297660505399, -0.03589552640914917, -0.02783747762441635, -0.06867115199565887, 0.012021820992231369, -0.017268158495426178, -0.042895879596471786, -0.050510942935943604, 0.059082992374897, 0.03167377784848213, 0.0417405404150486, -0.036681167781353, -0.025951476767659187, -0.01576673425734043, -0.0973224863409996, 0.00828513316810131, 0.010373849421739578, 0.005712224170565605, 0.008164339698851109, 0.040201105177402496, -0.030957577750086784, -0.036934949457645416, -0.019040249288082123, 0.060221511870622635, 0.03780799359083176, 0.025020161643624306, -0.05016923323273659, -0.0177259873598814, -0.05065640062093735, -0.0598372258245945, -0.033118944615125656, -0.0706370547413826, -0.05025852844119072, 0.039530884474515915, -0.01974763162434101, 0.046107079833745956, -0.045260485261678696, -0.05749830603599548, -0.06604879349470139, 0.005598694551736116, 0.018890736624598503, -0.030671346932649612, -0.0407586395740509, -0.04958485811948776, -0.023142322897911072, 0.031166383996605873, 0.02830635942518711, -0.04212075471878052, -0.001793361036106944, -0.06030645966529846, -0.01629219390451908, -0.036404263228178024, 0.014572358690202236, 0.06053148955106735, -0.040578823536634445, 0.05471381917595863, -0.0039162468165159225, 0.049304716289043427, 0.009802638553082943, 0.05509079620242119, -0.06096601486206055, 0.020229116082191467, 0.002017553662881255, 0.02856471575796604, -0.06107715517282486, 0.01643248461186886, -0.015861662104725838, -0.057558055967092514, 0.022551413625478745, 0.036088693886995316, 0.02154938317835331, 0.01251494511961937, 0.004522681701928377, -0.026793917641043663, -0.0005861085373908281, -0.043220169842243195, 0.014762678183615208, 0.00280061736702919, 0.022790007293224335, -0.02523146942257881, -0.025773655623197556, -0.06884242594242096, -0.004954489413648844, 0.0073920548893511295, -0.012109162285923958, -0.02619515173137188, -0.042399439960718155, -0.05135777220129967, -0.08052220195531845, 0.01316898688673973, -0.06251542270183563, -0.0009196216124109924, -0.04801979660987854, -0.05799635127186775, 0.018896151334047318, -0.027503572404384613, 0.0028546073008328676, -0.03839178755879402, -0.061542753130197525, 0.038381751626729965, 0.030134987086057663, 0.024029439315199852, -0.031789686530828476, -0.056503016501665115, -0.055948901921510696, -0.02172478660941124, -0.011373874731361866, 0.005821681581437588, -0.05006571486592293, 0.034554898738861084, -0.022894607856869698, 0.01711278408765793, -0.0013256249949336052, 0.057035550475120544, 0.030458297580480576, -0.030614985153079033, -0.022792724892497063, -0.02350672334432602, -0.013987424783408642, 0.008835242129862309, 0.00571077037602663, -0.00487242778763175, -0.057548731565475464, -0.0309749785810709, 0.055218979716300964, 0.027580928057432175, -0.00794124137610197, -0.03693847358226776, -0.008302003145217896, -0.052258193492889404, -0.0008391450392082334, -0.004761158023029566, 0.07120431959629059, 0.03450063243508339, 0.00925883837044239, -0.017721077427268028, -0.04687555879354477, 0.04303006827831268, -0.019962353631854057, 0.025942759588360786, -0.021072352305054665, -0.010520799085497856, -0.018857238814234734, -0.06397338211536407, 0.03637950122356415, 0.014771371148526669, 0.03018813766539097, -0.007150548510253429, -0.00852829311043024, 0.009958717972040176, -0.01579759642481804, 0.01974635198712349, 0.021749280393123627, -0.003634645137935877, 0.01003268826752901, 0.06493666768074036, -0.03340426832437515, 0.007457173429429531, -0.04969700798392296, -0.06893835961818695, -0.03268755227327347, 0.019155727699398994, 0.02618018351495266, 0.021381720900535583, 0.015303787775337696, -0.03712210804224014, 0.003623328637331724, -0.06417852640151978, 0.05350765585899353, 0.007815876044332981, -0.030431697145104408, 0.019836386665701866, -0.030458465218544006, -0.027503393590450287, -0.019058337435126305, -0.01989150419831276, -0.020346323028206825, -0.043798960745334625, 0.0211679358035326, -0.06775692105293274, 0.019532224163413048, 0.007260938175022602, 0.015490888617932796, 0.010973225347697735, -0.0024695012252777815, -0.019001811742782593, 0.017509831115603447, 0.0011272394331172109, 0.01862909086048603, -0.0434747114777565, -0.020555902272462845, 0.055270444601774216, -0.00729124341160059, -0.026289144530892372, -0.007508592680096626, 0.030500022694468498, 0.000911957467906177, -0.009286917746067047, 0.006295652128756046, 0.006323310546576977, -0.03184718266129494, -0.08100944012403488, -0.0050097000785171986, -0.054311249405145645, 0.01849541999399662, -0.0007971393060870469, -0.06745727360248566, 0.08043280988931656, 0.006992849987000227, -0.02274678833782673, -0.014046222902834415, -0.0021106821950525045, 0.01695423386991024, -0.011874658986926079, 0.017543921247124672, -0.04389471560716629, 0.03542660176753998, -0.06772639602422714, 0.027756623923778534, -0.05703742802143097, 0.04346315562725067, -0.05830559879541397, 0.01330521795898676, -0.0227409228682518, 0.03024396486580372, 0.05008962005376816, 0.03151847422122955, 0.0033703073859214783, -0.013723879121243954, 0.015952039510011673, 0.02153753861784935, 0.03941419720649719, 0.01657126098871231, -0.014401544816792011, 0.02679591067135334, -0.04465483874082565, -0.05644959211349487, -0.02139889821410179, -0.01783599518239498, 0.04585815221071243, -0.05800233781337738, -0.05016603693366051, -0.0027492162771523, 0.04223373904824257, 0.016216756775975227, -0.04197600111365318, -0.036486756056547165, -0.05232034996151924, -0.05884203687310219, -0.02033964917063713, -0.00673876516520977, -0.014074263162910938, -0.016004439443349838, 0.04597419872879982, 0.002136973198503256, 0.008781342767179012, -0.004303252324461937, 0.05193710699677467, 0.007452079560607672, -0.0036504706367850304, -0.04185643792152405, -0.010846286080777645, -0.050399381667375565, 0.01515842042863369, 0.04376934841275215, -0.035871393978595734, -0.03866255655884743, 0.0314478874206543, 0.016222460195422173, 0.05541209876537323, -0.08278955519199371, 0.04178076982498169, 0.020848777145147324, -0.005715200211852789, -0.002777997637167573, 0.01740855909883976, -0.034145064651966095, 0.025715583935379982, -0.0191174428910017, -0.031189408153295517, 0.024816399440169334, 0.033814191818237305, 0.028524409979581833, 0.02653568983078003, -0.050598278641700745, 0.02026921510696411, 0.009832016192376614, -0.02266741171479225, -0.047335557639598846, -0.012395404279232025, -0.03156019747257233, 0.0035845020320266485, -0.05124805122613907, 0.027130382135510445, -0.003982073627412319, -0.03475363925099373, -0.0267633106559515, 0.02755529247224331, -0.0023962289560586214, -0.02150348573923111, 0.04416407272219658, -0.03270416706800461, 0.02559984102845192, 0.0571552999317646, -0.026751019060611725, 0.011507047340273857, 0.029913747683167458, 0.030059918761253357, -0.0077850851230323315, 0.02709256298840046, -0.0069736093282699585, -0.07459935545921326, -0.00778295798227191, -0.03460829704999924, 0.005521558690816164, -0.04325966536998749, 0.028322556987404823, 0.03399999812245369, 0.03905269131064415, 0.013867422007024288, -0.051476504653692245, 0.02390468120574951, 0.025392480194568634, 0.03444608673453331, -0.011893495917320251, 0.017181862145662308, -0.015717696398496628, 0.022329604253172874, 0.01298352237790823, -0.020475169643759727, 0.017736902460455894, -0.02401846833527088, -0.017287133261561394, -0.017670918256044388, 0.001453092903830111, -0.014842315576970577, -0.07264752686023712, -0.04628219082951546, 0.032042644917964935, -0.0008631650707684457, 0.03383779525756836, 0.010940405540168285, 0.010347285307943821, 0.005625380668789148, -0.018925419077277184, -0.019956223666667938, -0.03978974372148514, -0.00859636627137661, 0.09003148972988129, -0.060237906873226166, 0.015004030428826809, -0.051170714199543, -0.04188153147697449, -0.04133224114775658, -0.03011920675635338, -0.006507459562271833, 0.026068760082125664, -0.0452856719493866, -0.05610493943095207, 0.03459063544869423, 0.01622781902551651, -0.05325766280293465, -0.026255736127495766, 0.014074857346713543, -0.04037075117230415, 0.005482071079313755, -0.004141791723668575, 0.015581117942929268, -0.0257387924939394, 0.02987416833639145, -0.04606657102704048, -0.03964601084589958, -0.03137774392962456, 0.050433237105607986, 0.08387105166912079, -0.027604592964053154, -0.041598204523324966, 0.053568433970212936, 0.0039399913512170315, 0.01210217084735632, -0.04706668108701706, 0.004402375780045986, 0.005632474087178707, 0.025425828993320465, -0.055393751710653305, -0.012394220568239689, -0.0003081147442571819, 0.048666395246982574, -0.04366152361035347, 0.002070352202281356, 0.005154878832399845, 0.01851320080459118, 0.00014850629668217152, -0.0627606213092804, -0.049635834991931915, 0.026198813691735268, -0.00020481595129240304, 0.004842848051339388, -0.0007796373683959246, -0.016082121059298515, -0.024320129305124283, 0.04094194248318672, -0.014927918091416359, -0.011833244934678078, 0.015932144597172737, -0.0027284552343189716, -0.04551639035344124, 0.041931215673685074, -0.056202203035354614, -0.013841528445482254, 0.0020337074529379606, 0.025240810588002205, 0.010942255146801472, 0.03236914798617363, -0.02858252264559269, 0.023917654529213905, -0.003533225040882826, 0.046287015080451965, -0.0050822664052248, 0.0032613719813525677, 0.020671816542744637, 0.0014893715269863605, 0.0628245621919632, -0.029628420248627663, 0.02427765354514122, -0.026943296194076538, -0.0652691051363945, 0.018158957362174988, 0.0015380418626591563, -0.038631290197372437, -0.030508235096931458, -0.01923561282455921, -0.040169257670640945, -0.027873694896697998, 0.04667523503303528, -0.041790034621953964, -0.034735679626464844, 0.014640930108726025, 0.009464842267334461, 0.024411965161561966, -0.009566951543092728, -0.029815498739480972, 0.04287354648113251, -0.02083064243197441, 0.04702643305063248, 0.054974496364593506, 0.05823748931288719, -0.0198908019810915, -0.045855794101953506, -0.04762616008520126, 0.0027571464888751507, -0.016111113131046295, -0.0592804029583931, -0.02631497010588646, -0.059778470546007156, -0.07370482385158539, 0.029435766860842705, 0.02649497427046299, -0.02692078799009323, 0.012875370681285858, -0.059384141117334366, 0.009017879143357277, 0.01334327645599842, -0.04148738086223602, -0.08874311298131943, 0.0406128354370594, -0.00253700721077621, -0.0009343419224023819, 0.0016232787165790796, -0.008479484356939793, -0.0335516482591629, 0.022968335077166557, -0.08691058307886124, -0.010817287489771843, -0.043424464762210846, 0.07899940758943558, 0.0265769325196743, -0.0047538066282868385, 0.023498807102441788, -0.026175931096076965, 0.020925331860780716, 0.026118474081158638, 0.02063758112490177, 0.05465521663427353, 0.0046645114198327065, 0.0620277039706707, -0.057732418179512024, -0.02896689809858799, 0.033148638904094696, -0.032313618808984756, 0.03093280829489231, 0.042368028312921524, 0.04645050689578056, -0.018539100885391235, 0.02807503007352352, 0.013684676960110664, 0.0350172184407711, 0.01079303864389658, -0.024183548986911774, 0.0195304062217474, -0.04006730020046234, -0.074216827750206, 0.016076911240816116, -0.04427775740623474, 0.027143390849232674, -0.0072484551928937435, -0.01961933635175228, -0.01269556861370802, -0.029587959870696068, -0.028500311076641083, 0.011632240377366543, 0.027666905894875526, 0.025364000350236893, 0.0794425681233406, -0.06969933211803436, 0.002003787085413933, 0.05472671985626221, -0.017674274742603302, -0.035761650651693344, 0.05210385099053383, 0.007267025299370289, -0.07143635302782059, 0.050496768206357956, -0.07849001884460449, 0.0388893224298954, -0.04491262882947922, -0.002797555411234498, -0.0370846651494503, 0.0524711012840271, -0.057737257331609726, -0.044900063425302505, -0.04314360395073891, -0.0026735581923276186, -0.03380111977458, -0.049395300447940826, -0.028265008702874184, -0.019649339839816093, 0.036284781992435455, -0.0057516563683748245, 0.05213155969977379, 0.048521991819143295, 0.06711598485708237, 0.05048536881804466, 0.001738398103043437, -0.017496978864073753, -0.017986640334129333, -0.049971021711826324, 0.006699699908494949, -0.02717137336730957, 0.004253231920301914, -0.02127167582511902, -0.030836502090096474, -0.0003004494355991483, -0.0002762246585916728, -0.010687233880162239, 0.03180452808737755, -0.020732639357447624, -0.0659329891204834, -0.01781764253973961, 0.004695120267570019, -0.016299456357955933, -0.03307998925447464, 0.04541371762752533, 0.02077830396592617, 0.020980194211006165, -0.0626930370926857 ]
To resolve the non-convex optimization problem in partial wave analysis, this paper introduces a novel approach that incorporates fraction constraints into the likelihood function. This method offers significant improvements in both the efficiency of pole searching and the reliability of resonance selection within partial wave analysis.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14740v1
[ -0.0498824380338192, -0.007854650728404522, -0.043998654931783676, -0.008514217101037502, 0.02614615671336651, 0.013830111362040043, -0.03937578201293945, -0.003282212885096669, 0.030034856870770454, 0.009926424361765385, -0.0441797710955143, -0.02228686772286892, -0.02491905726492405, -0.05632876604795456, -0.013922005891799927, 0.006318590138107538, 0.0639447420835495, -0.012848327867686749, -0.04028791934251785, 0.05794363096356392, 0.011043975129723549, -0.043585773557424545, -0.014735382981598377, 0.024974985048174858, 0.014719599857926369, 0.015610733069479465, -0.06641089171171188, -0.024014221504330635, -0.0281764417886734, 0.03750624880194664, 0.03087630495429039, -0.005906769540160894, -0.07157912105321884, -0.03199831396341324, -0.017713632434606552, -0.02448117733001709, -0.01830955594778061, 0.018735062330961227, 0.029810670763254166, 0.016118451952934265, 0.05021410062909126, -0.03882552310824394, -0.050839055329561234, 0.03925037384033203, -0.015774616971611977, -0.05405387282371521, -0.044167373329401016, 0.013481481932103634, -0.0776519775390625, -0.030011022463440895, 0.01076348964124918, -0.0453474260866642, -0.015077016316354275, 0.011350100859999657, -0.06738084554672241, -0.03833585977554321, -0.0036382307298481464, 0.010463415645062923, -0.041497088968753815, -0.000307647482259199, 0.04859556630253792, 0.013426806777715683, -0.025679169222712517, 0.006161577068269253, 0.004229419864714146, 0.018594125285744667, 0.013805607333779335, -0.059916988015174866, -0.0360991396009922, -0.012961152009665966, -0.009386560879647732, -0.014238809235394001, 0.007010340224951506, 0.007541164755821228, -0.005969857797026634, -0.05737195909023285, 0.006885749287903309, -0.05815983563661575, 0.014978282153606415, 0.02402951568365097, -0.03354813531041145, 0.03921911492943764, 0.027805792167782784, 0.02288883365690708, 0.0028959540650248528, -0.011033467017114162, 0.03823187202215195, -0.014280893839895725, -0.03831339254975319, -0.027266569435596466, 0.021348275244235992, 0.034285061061382294, -0.05439445376396179, -0.003432672005146742, 0.034152209758758545, 0.021918006241321564, 0.04335124418139458, 0.03215572610497475, 0.0014762006467208266, 0.004666151013225317, -0.018907414749264717, -0.06043459475040436, -0.03363152965903282, 0.04179200157523155, 0.00953348632901907, -0.04436936229467392, -0.03689408302307129, -0.00436499435454607, 0.021382058039307594, 0.01241337601095438, -0.04189154505729675, 0.04294588789343834, -0.025135602802038193, -0.05547551065683365, -0.031623583287000656, -0.0322188138961792, 0.0528181791305542, 0.05368619039654732, -0.044007543474435806, -0.014448040165007114, -0.019209349527955055, 0.02968444861471653, 0.011374110355973244, 0.025685984641313553, -0.05501148849725723, -0.03578634932637215, 0.05873551964759827, 0.020762119442224503, -0.053815338760614395, -0.06056925654411316, -0.017904076725244522, 0.016480259597301483, 0.0009998390451073647, -0.008876658044755459, 0.04957273229956627, -0.0018059686990454793, 0.0031217066571116447, -0.03473632410168648, 0.03193775564432144, -0.016636693850159645, -0.01666736789047718, -0.04937062785029411, 0.05355864390730858, -0.0186572577804327, 0.03530849143862724, 0.031133899465203285, -0.05465671792626381, -0.038060471415519714, 0.036961451172828674, 0.031148239970207214, -0.03451051935553551, -0.028879182413220406, -0.009232321754097939, -0.024173734709620476, 0.02694493904709816, 0.03748616576194763, 0.03533853217959404, 0.012943288311362267, 0.013190124183893204, 0.00597331952303648, 0.038283027708530426, 0.025758348405361176, 0.021238239482045174, 0.035762377083301544, -0.059178125113248825, -0.004380748141556978, 0.017479097470641136, 0.010881183668971062, -0.010484317317605019, 0.01272254716604948, -0.07352138310670853, 0.04337315261363983, -0.009043214842677116, -0.04627745971083641, 0.0074968961998820305, -0.027159295976161957, -0.038279831409454346, -0.050893209874629974, -0.025204677134752274, 0.011361717246472836, 0.00486486591398716, -0.05660001561045647, -0.014207402244210243, 0.01650357060134411, -0.009712214581668377, 0.029253367334604263, -0.06836966425180435, 0.020486105233430862, 0.026379650458693504, -0.014342454262077808, -0.051402583718299866, -0.035628583282232285, 0.042503830045461655, 0.019713357090950012, -0.05596332624554634, -0.02546253427863121, -0.013096283189952374, 0.06335285305976868, 0.021051395684480667, 0.02643778920173645, -0.0518919937312603, -0.04123576357960701, -0.02947014383971691, 0.03838937729597092, -0.047946274280548096, -0.06069687008857727, -0.0029944865964353085, 0.03257034718990326, -0.03673679009079933, -0.013882754370570183, 0.05629955604672432, 0.06379334628582001, 0.035158634185791016, 0.014644619077444077, 0.00863311905413866, -0.00026717607397586107, -0.09188251942396164, 0.03712514042854309, -0.027919648215174675, -0.020782196894288063, -0.0009061287273652852, 0.03864094242453575, 0.04130043834447861, -0.026449624449014664, -0.013847840949892998, 0.03338627517223358, 0.0635768324136734, -0.03309076279401779, -0.04315168410539627, -0.01753271371126175, -0.03473086655139923, -0.037039101123809814, -0.07657983154058456, -0.06149569898843765, -0.04793114215135574, 0.015937961637973785, -0.017584178596735, 0.033867333084344864, 0.030289046466350555, -0.07013878226280212, -0.05197769030928612, -0.039789728820323944, 0.06255213171243668, 0.02519376389682293, -0.02378653548657894, -0.04301341995596886, -0.012097266502678394, -0.03945603221654892, -0.02478506602346897, 0.0386403352022171, 0.013708478771150112, -0.053742650896310806, -0.011599795892834663, 0.01465458981692791, -0.00047015390009619296, 0.053229764103889465, -0.03795446455478668, 0.021227022632956505, -0.02092117629945278, 0.01316838525235653, 0.0019343880703672767, 0.002034725621342659, -0.06984695047140121, -0.019475800916552544, 0.028826100751757622, 0.02915458381175995, -0.013822631910443306, -0.017549533396959305, -0.02087317407131195, -0.0692773163318634, -0.021720539778470993, 0.028624512255191803, -0.024087317287921906, 0.02435942552983761, -0.044406890869140625, -0.059767842292785645, 0.014213928952813148, 0.02349681220948696, 0.026151906698942184, 0.013723737560212612, 0.05008833482861519, 0.0001248807820957154, -0.0007981032831594348, -0.024718619883060455, 0.008744235150516033, -0.04272216185927391, 0.02731374464929104, -0.052208200097084045, -0.04805642366409302, -0.014902683906257153, -0.06908714771270752, -0.03348582237958908, 0.009002692066133022, -0.05168288201093674, -0.02842339500784874, -0.058274928480386734, 0.002612443407997489, 0.03771309554576874, 0.07689889520406723, -0.03427350893616676, -0.037934668362140656, -0.04597608000040054, 0.030152054503560066, -0.02109132707118988, -0.03250836208462715, -0.0524318628013134, -0.05748176574707031, 0.020255640149116516, -0.0018374412320554256, -0.00035921300877816975, -0.0012029435019940138, -0.03939813748002052, 0.0024332888424396515, 0.04463297873735428, -0.046019792556762695, 0.06781360507011414, 0.04532330483198166, -0.036928366869688034, 0.031212471425533295, 0.01293102465569973, 0.002261682879179716, 0.030724531039595604, -0.025020308792591095, -0.011243538931012154, -0.037344396114349365, 0.05629240721464157, 0.07276013493537903, -0.015966571867465973, -0.036221060901880264, -0.011764022521674633, -0.03211424872279167, 0.02465404011309147, 0.04866991564631462, -0.02994740754365921, 0.04047014191746712, 0.03283492103219032, -0.05059979856014252, -0.047524601221084595, -0.025187209248542786, -0.026746204122900963, -0.002861427143216133, 0.040200453251600266, 0.012808981351554394, 0.0014179714489728212, -0.02783343754708767, -0.08380278944969177, 0.02411813475191593, -0.014942818321287632, 0.05753583461046219, -0.029010791331529617, -0.026228269562125206, 0.026997826993465424, 0.020763052627444267, -0.017843514680862427, 0.004006518516689539, 0.021193379536271095, 0.0189660731703043, 0.0161647479981184, -0.016453707590699196, -0.04993075132369995, -0.00025840901071205735, -0.07093049585819244, -0.04770080745220184, -0.06797092407941818, 0.046957653015851974, -0.02564815618097782, 0.05268143489956856, -0.03016756847500801, 0.006388974376022816, -0.03149730712175369, 0.013813996687531471, 0.06569134443998337, -0.04975629225373268, 0.0478702113032341, 0.006304939277470112, 0.02753600664436817, 0.0328296422958374, -0.02157440222799778, 0.04963059723377228, -0.055914800614118576, 0.039136018604040146, 0.0027318201027810574, 0.04385446384549141, 0.009717297740280628, -0.02180926874279976, -0.004373498726636171, 0.017406467348337173, -0.06022701784968376, 0.050498541444540024, -0.000958265969529748, 0.002811469603329897, -0.0004915802855975926, 0.024355502799153328, -0.024523815140128136, -0.0037490169052034616, -0.07024966925382614, -0.006452430970966816, -0.038453321903944016, -0.006326205562800169, -0.012761566787958145, -0.03171210363507271, -0.01640656217932701, -0.04324815049767494, -0.06751759350299835, 0.03418239578604698, -0.03542158007621765, 0.03258192539215088, -0.009569307789206505, -0.04918622225522995, 0.059680137783288956, -0.015027199871838093, 0.026999544352293015, 0.003383726580068469, 0.0333535261452198, 0.012724693864583969, -0.07491325587034225, -0.037899721413850784, -0.06125640496611595, 0.02661607228219509, 0.02852916158735752, 0.03886869549751282, 0.010611120611429214, 0.010017016902565956, -0.06808824837207794, -0.05030755698680878, 0.002035938436165452, 0.019005129113793373, 0.06807122379541397, 0.011835077777504921, 0.050134558230638504, -0.0164243932813406, -0.025423597544431686, 0.02450481429696083, 0.037994831800460815, 0.006422602105885744, -0.0024213194847106934, 0.03417740389704704, -0.01860606111586094, -0.0364990234375, -0.007566404994577169, -0.02402380481362343, 0.06770610064268112, -0.0370154045522213, -0.044287603348493576, 0.03736691176891327, 0.019571911543607712, -0.061870694160461426, -0.04709336534142494, -0.05034623295068741, 0.00832897424697876, -0.052974946796894073, -0.04961765930056572, 0.06696970015764236, 0.01021692343056202, -0.06239498406648636, 0.004860091954469681, 0.03094072826206684, 0.03077656775712967, -0.04193557798862457, -0.020551571622490883, 0.06605011969804764, 0.05332879722118378, 0.011446531862020493, -0.05112162232398987, -0.07413593679666519, -0.04554856941103935, 0.029918506741523743, 0.038877155631780624, 0.027244290336966515, -0.014213974587619305, -0.018098365515470505, -0.02037154696881771, -0.05959078297019005, 0.010403750464320183, 0.07317791879177094, -0.003939073532819748, -0.0030287986155599356, 0.051944099366664886, -0.015880964696407318, 0.029929867014288902, -0.03719848021864891, -0.04226292669773102, 0.023570535704493523, -0.06248277425765991, 0.011577355675399303, -0.04531609266996384, -0.0006573261343874037, 0.016829613596200943, 0.016567321494221687, -0.005718901753425598, -0.03858993574976921, 0.0015395903028547764, -0.02469749189913273, 0.048223208636045456, 0.03840424865484238, 0.0066831703297793865, 0.057653408497571945, -0.037554781883955, -0.06491941958665848, 0.00031951064011082053, -0.0403391532599926, -0.00561517896130681, -0.030679870396852493, -0.05010372772812843, -0.05159418284893036, 0.003611075459048152, 0.037344250828027725, 0.005273215472698212, 0.03214285895228386, 0.01268561091274023, -0.038287170231342316, -0.06531453132629395, -0.04644302651286125, -0.0007033345173113048, 0.024872852489352226, 0.014810224063694477, 0.03389209508895874, -0.008991139940917492, -0.031052937731146812, 0.034510962665081024, 0.0343245267868042, 0.006997082848101854, -0.009051432833075523, 0.004715878516435623, -0.06226823106408119, 0.03421411290764809, 0.04306790605187416, 0.04281185194849968, -0.00996468123048544, 0.04559525102376938, 0.0538480319082737, -0.024680200964212418, -0.005495881661772728, 0.04301745444536209, -0.038365527987480164, 0.02702607400715351, 0.023160789161920547, 0.025755854323506355, -0.027899473905563354, -0.02327556163072586, 0.021073848009109497, -0.030315691605210304, 0.056186117231845856, 0.013108110055327415, -0.01647515594959259, 0.02701604552567005, -0.0006306637078523636, -0.06459970027208328, -0.06503058224916458, 0.029091905802488327, 0.05613609775900841, -0.05975892022252083, -0.07192382216453552, 0.019059710204601288, -0.058326490223407745, 0.036367278546094894, -0.020969286561012268, 0.037915874272584915, 0.016189411282539368, -0.00038196652894839644, -0.05695667117834091, 0.028524162247776985, 0.04892969876527786, -0.039867110550403595, 0.01311926543712616, 0.06625902652740479, -0.07272204011678696, -0.030331984162330627, 0.03229382634162903, -0.02842702716588974, -0.012069105170667171, 0.009204321540892124, 0.027239995077252388, -0.047324538230895996, -0.022718891501426697, -0.008940483443439007, 0.0520973727107048, -0.051291316747665405, 0.01834789477288723, 0.002656244207173586, -0.014291933737695217, -0.047360870987176895, 0.00989655964076519, -0.012519421055912971, -0.03811674192547798, 0.016565987840294838, 0.032782793045043945, -0.031786900013685226, -0.055927641689777374, 0.0245684664696455, -0.04463957995176315, -0.002890614327043295, -0.01224754098802805, 0.022485755383968353, 0.03473875671625137, -0.030061500146985054, -0.00042339126230217516, -0.030935175716876984, -0.03646358102560043, 0.008825797587633133, -0.03266860544681549, -0.035334449261426926, -0.007922639138996601, 0.043017201125621796, 0.011527706868946552, -0.025317056104540825, -0.01916864700615406, -0.03997693210840225, -0.0630810484290123, -0.038071393966674805, -0.07834259420633316, -0.03065665066242218, 0.01886012777686119, 0.005062423180788755, 0.006476003676652908, 0.07079025357961655, 0.014701050706207752, -0.0024427396710962057, 0.01948367804288864, 0.04946713522076607, -0.021421916782855988, 0.0363837331533432, 0.0003363655705470592, -0.03197203204035759, 0.06870221346616745, -0.030854009091854095, 0.0462065152823925, -0.03801564872264862, -0.049701984971761703, 0.011002723127603531, 0.03937480226159096, -0.014981657266616821, -0.05506722256541252, 0.004804891534149647, -0.016755999997258186, -0.05806290730834007, -0.05911753699183464, -0.05196957290172577, -0.0682162493467331, -0.00535502377897501, 0.04189646244049072, 0.008143681101500988, 0.027940658852458, 0.03644289821386337, 0.002314976416528225, 0.011897187680006027, -0.008134334348142147, 0.051228638738393784, 0.03819744661450386, 0.04437015578150749, 0.0015164978103712201, -0.03596142306923866, 0.02967362105846405, 0.013119610026478767, -0.017677277326583862, -0.04651407524943352, 0.026018936187028885, -0.06801170110702515, 0.01924237422645092, 0.01912577450275421, -0.02218296006321907, 0.017226599156856537, -0.05524326488375664, 0.013077374547719955, 0.0502743199467659, -0.05623159930109978, -0.04726443067193031, -0.0002623439650051296, 0.030835697427392006, -0.009443005546927452, 0.013319451361894608, -0.024829011410474777, -0.031064631417393684, -0.044671397656202316, -0.032364267855882645, -0.028623925521969795, -0.003238978097215295, 0.05046573281288147, 0.009904192760586739, 0.02084604650735855, -0.010000973008573055, 0.05027911439538002, -0.0036726298276335, -0.057163435965776443, 0.013839448802173138, -0.008108108304440975, 0.012660001404583454, -0.027842415496706963, -0.056170836091041565, 0.010701634921133518, 0.05152985453605652, 0.004861248657107353, 0.0415627546608448, 0.034520480781793594, 0.054597146809101105, 0.02250738814473152, -0.0031861544121056795, 0.040684621781110764, 0.017156843096017838, 0.018338430672883987, -0.0682455524802208, 0.026928717270493507, 0.01139678806066513, -0.05339828133583069, 0.06898869574069977, -0.03661671280860901, -0.007812495343387127, -0.004099294077605009, -0.005469170864671469, 0.007731868885457516, 0.02251203916966915, -0.05006353557109833, 0.0195295549929142, -0.022918077185750008, -0.06090720370411873, 0.06416361033916473, -0.011339966207742691, -0.02451339364051819, 0.032302066683769226, 0.05056563764810562, -0.0558428131043911, 0.048068027943372726, 0.022783176973462105, -0.03785671293735504, 0.015411452390253544, -0.06279146671295166, -0.00733893271535635, 0.03390978276729584, 0.030887309461832047, 0.019900048151612282, 0.010311401449143887, -0.06272303313016891, -0.07648030668497086, -0.008034883998334408, 0.013320875354111195, -0.03525448217988014, -0.07515732944011688, -0.04096405953168869, 0.01262242253869772, 0.024125922471284866, -0.011758748441934586, 0.0070315697230398655, -0.0451599545776844, 0.05489185079932213, 0.0023408059496432543, -0.018471267074346542, -0.019111650064587593, -0.009939326904714108, -0.04638592526316643, 0.06368152797222137, -0.010173024609684944, 0.017481988295912743, -0.036256253719329834, -0.02915220893919468, -0.03596637398004532, 0.01020585373044014, 0.00857059471309185, 0.0030823254492133856, -0.05296306684613228, -0.032784461975097656, 0.0023122234269976616, -0.02492476999759674, 0.0026882002130150795, -0.03725013509392738, -0.0188077911734581, -0.013895239681005478, 0.009522547014057636, -0.03228694573044777 ]
Deep learning algorithms utilizing magnetic resonance (MR) images have demonstrated cutting-edge proficiency in autonomously segmenting multiple sclerosis (MS) lesions. Despite their achievements, these algorithms may struggle to extend their performance across various sites or scanners, leading to domain generalization errors. While few-shot or one-shot domain adaptation emerges as a potential solution to mitigate generalization errors, its efficacy might be hindered by the scarcity of labeled data in the target domain. This paper seeks to tackle this challenge by integrating one-shot adaptation data with harmonized training data that incorporates labels. Our approach involves synthesizing new training data with a contrast akin to that of the test domain, a process we refer to as "contrast harmonization" in MRI. Our experiments illustrate that the amalgamation of one-shot adaptation data with harmonized training data surpasses the performance of utilizing either data source in isolation. Notably, domain adaptation using exclusively harmonized training data achieved comparable or even superior performance compared to one-shot adaptation. Moreover, all adaptations required only minimal fine-tuning, ranging from 2 to 5 epochs for convergence.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20586v1
[ -0.011928824707865715, -0.025953209027647972, 0.042651448398828506, 0.00911429151892662, -0.03822462633252144, 0.030171433463692665, 0.009821997955441475, 0.010375921614468098, 0.029924383386969566, -0.02602366730570793, -0.01660807989537716, 0.01018216647207737, -0.041181474924087524, -0.04964330792427063, -0.05152710899710655, 0.026962770149111748, 0.07150232791900635, -0.01704178750514984, -0.056168459355831146, 0.08186539262533188, 0.011643900536000729, 0.021118197590112686, -0.057670559734106064, 0.030477453023195267, -0.0020347554236650467, 0.009457853622734547, -0.026515983045101166, 0.03914526104927063, 0.013739805668592453, 0.02704615890979767, 0.05860579386353493, -0.03577517718076706, -0.02983025088906288, -0.03176374360918999, -0.023874064907431602, -0.015826618298888206, 0.012495494447648525, 0.029960647225379944, 0.003311348147690296, -0.019079865887761116, 0.0292240958660841, -0.03304799646139145, -0.07158453017473221, -0.007881124503910542, -0.041985902935266495, 0.006608556490391493, -0.010635459795594215, -0.02402612380683422, -0.023366209119558334, -0.036024998873472214, 0.03505585715174675, -0.003291050437837839, 0.0007298715063370764, 0.0646592378616333, 0.013755322434008121, 0.04202927649021149, -0.034834470599889755, 0.009170666337013245, -0.062101829797029495, -0.011760273016989231, 0.026677047833800316, -0.058115169405937195, -0.007879415526986122, 0.003355565248057246, -0.01312133576720953, 0.04807870462536812, -0.030344713479280472, -0.09415535628795624, -0.05321384593844414, -0.04107905551791191, 0.05668118968605995, -0.0667518898844719, -0.022170379757881165, 0.03436911106109619, -0.05862885341048241, -0.03548728674650192, -0.04995996505022049, -0.014252832159399986, -0.00041068551945500076, -0.02434939704835415, -0.047842420637607574, 0.03665865585207939, -0.018734101206064224, 0.04630717635154724, 0.032693952322006226, 0.003209512447938323, 0.07192131131887436, -0.004590930417180061, 0.011333622969686985, -0.02010633423924446, 0.038611363619565964, -0.050187621265649796, -0.07349029183387756, 0.006969986949115992, 0.08736493438482285, -0.04628586396574974, 0.043167367577552795, 0.04300485923886299, 0.035258520394563675, 0.02281337045133114, -0.005133335944265127, -0.044888660311698914, -0.03181219473481178, 0.05297825112938881, 0.0015142470365390182, -0.026321247220039368, -0.004089885391294956, -0.01793777570128441, -0.04421995207667351, 0.018536550924181938, -0.02781757153570652, -0.004389491863548756, 0.01927119679749012, -0.058690983802080154, -0.0428791418671608, -0.01813460886478424, 0.05097788944840431, 0.02255507931113243, -0.02464156597852707, 0.005505608394742012, -0.017175044864416122, 0.031057382002472878, 0.010849911719560623, -0.013645414263010025, -0.01087289210408926, 0.008938785642385483, 0.08532555401325226, -0.026723237708210945, -0.018305540084838867, -0.019631605595350266, -0.04812738299369812, 0.008150450885295868, -0.00012641157081816345, 0.003940379247069359, 0.052256032824516296, 0.0325755774974823, -0.008361516520380974, -0.01364938635379076, 0.055559076368808746, 0.029814602807164192, 0.007004401180893183, -0.07412955909967422, 0.023959705606102943, -0.04149193689227104, -0.015294811688363552, 0.021460551768541336, -0.057821501046419144, -0.03878127783536911, 0.025644691661000252, 0.02035093493759632, -0.014883472584187984, 0.038262560963630676, 0.016653243452310562, 0.05615982040762901, 0.029098456725478172, -0.0019636640790849924, 0.044391561299562454, -0.0033544807229191065, -0.055996377021074295, 0.006189510691910982, 0.00952469278126955, 0.0017201669979840517, 0.013294448144733906, -0.04253244400024414, 0.014356904663145542, -0.00914827175438404, 0.05396852642297745, -0.031782135367393494, 0.0216665118932724, 0.02973298914730549, -0.02644169330596924, -0.016257556155323982, 0.010917006991803646, 0.005537794437259436, -0.05581292510032654, 0.004473677836358547, -0.006326795555651188, -0.02417653053998947, -0.07334749400615692, 0.01441014651209116, 0.03628162294626236, 0.03172089532017708, -0.020001953467726707, -0.015208154916763306, -0.02364879474043846, -0.03306788206100464, -0.09556227922439575, -0.011667454615235329, 0.027753498405218124, 0.003884062636643648, -0.06381805986166, -0.03789493069052696, 0.04858647659420967, 0.02671288512647152, -0.030281487852334976, -0.033956628292798996, -0.008942816406488419, 0.006436089053750038, 0.03249605745077133, 0.01970754563808441, -0.0909317135810852, -0.028137926012277603, -0.062165867537260056, 0.005294273141771555, -0.02262246236205101, -0.07068909704685211, 0.015105939470231533, 0.050876107066869736, -0.011960559524595737, 0.01481410302221775, 0.08035203814506531, 0.06157408282160759, 0.039540670812129974, 0.010098976083099842, 0.031341955065727234, 0.027513649314641953, -0.10274235159158707, 0.062285855412483215, -0.04543241858482361, 0.00812968797981739, 0.01813993602991104, -0.015348129905760288, -0.03070739470422268, -0.06783895939588547, 0.0024138838052749634, 0.055633507668972015, 0.06249797344207764, 0.022990528494119644, -0.05693689361214638, -0.049679145216941833, -0.0156041719019413, -0.04067941755056381, -0.02994159236550331, -0.0815046951174736, -0.029508456587791443, 0.019664723426103592, -0.03606804460287094, 0.02291664481163025, -0.009177790023386478, -0.04116392135620117, -0.03888794034719467, 0.035730261355638504, 0.05324045568704605, -0.012660699896514416, -0.05530395358800888, -0.06531704217195511, -0.013995416462421417, 0.02984090894460678, -0.03188849240541458, 0.0038160299882292747, -0.04432214796543121, -0.055182408541440964, 0.012631405144929886, -0.00012906617484986782, 0.059213120490312576, 0.0386948436498642, -0.02942238189280033, 0.007650598883628845, -0.021953333169221878, 0.036390382796525955, 0.03164659067988396, 0.02551979385316372, -0.08339384943246841, 0.026064136996865273, 0.013304254971444607, 0.02871466428041458, -0.03657355159521103, -0.039993442595005035, 0.023644529283046722, -0.028682315722107887, -0.009140502661466599, 0.05308320373296738, 0.04376045614480972, 0.019023427739739418, -0.01800335757434368, -0.02392580732703209, 0.00019788504869211465, -0.011556609533727169, -0.0025107732508331537, 0.017485812306404114, 0.03664025291800499, -0.012333572842180729, 0.01469363085925579, -0.06670696288347244, -0.007731992285698652, -0.07666675001382828, -0.018502118065953255, -0.03248370438814163, -0.05881727486848831, -0.03973716124892235, -0.08078983426094055, -0.05392783135175705, -0.034481488168239594, -0.0169927179813385, -0.011443653143942356, -0.043313901871442795, -0.01920577697455883, 0.006527327932417393, 0.0034987416584044695, -0.014653462916612625, -0.030550390481948853, -0.010418280959129333, 0.014962692745029926, 0.004845555871725082, -0.045114338397979736, -0.05804423615336418, -0.03558812290430069, -0.0054080975241959095, 0.038977157324552536, -0.004717777483165264, -0.007182419765740633, 0.04793792590498924, -0.02307155355811119, 0.027071690186858177, -0.01353986281901598, 0.040375031530857086, 0.03550898656249046, -0.007702427916228771, -0.016323084011673927, -0.028430266305804253, 0.02387174591422081, -0.04378993809223175, 0.004198091570287943, -0.05869579315185547, -0.04395194724202156, -0.010423149913549423, 0.05453909933567047, 0.04134403169155121, -0.020828668028116226, -0.0159587562084198, 0.007743148133158684, 0.010271796025335789, 0.0017012519529089332, -0.02436847612261772, 0.022899894043803215, 0.043347232043743134, -0.039605747908353806, -0.0025140547659248114, -0.010689230635762215, 0.01418311707675457, -0.0001288197818212211, 0.029897935688495636, -0.05704832822084427, 0.007299541030079126, 0.07783452421426773, -0.09518136829137802, -0.004226233810186386, 0.01886485144495964, 0.04556645452976227, -0.017324207350611687, 0.01342223584651947, 0.014981122687458992, 0.008012979291379452, 0.0336514376103878, -0.019345998764038086, 0.004682290833443403, -0.01040759775787592, 0.06218727305531502, -0.03343475982546806, -0.016125675290822983, -0.0007570356829091907, -0.04718846455216408, -0.02263263799250126, 0.00933616328984499, 0.02295619435608387, 0.0217633917927742, 0.030726848170161247, -0.05342778563499451, 0.028991658240556717, -0.005726363509893417, 0.018621522933244705, -0.007567151449620724, -0.02992047183215618, 0.0332908108830452, -0.011365534737706184, 0.004202330019325018, -0.0008526089950464666, -0.019708530977368355, 0.009627358056604862, -0.030576571822166443, 0.04121391475200653, -0.05387746915221214, 0.04292063042521477, 0.03427424281835556, -0.013859802857041359, 0.06307543814182281, 0.0727558583021164, -0.030199231579899788, 0.028288675472140312, -0.021512558683753014, -0.0026013515889644623, -0.04101698473095894, 0.014521479606628418, -0.03339429199695587, -0.018209049478173256, -0.07301466912031174, -0.009537775069475174, 0.02915974333882332, -0.014657367952167988, 0.0077936663292348385, 0.010101158171892166, 0.025397541001439095, 0.01011767890304327, -0.08679673075675964, -0.01057766005396843, -0.05149185657501221, 0.06571491062641144, 0.004116815980523825, -0.03163134679198265, 0.060713425278663635, -0.03837383911013603, -0.010988011956214905, -0.035468801856040955, 0.02848511002957821, -0.0161356870085001, -0.057647455483675, -0.0060025607235729694, -0.06200138106942177, 0.03066234290599823, -0.057982418686151505, 0.07781016081571579, 0.022252511233091354, 0.004313165787607431, -0.05552135407924652, -0.00882661435753107, -0.024356110021471977, 0.052953075617551804, 0.047944989055395126, -0.01620342954993248, -0.0016535172471776605, -0.012395147234201431, 0.005475812125951052, -0.024412628263235092, 0.03864933177828789, 0.02345014549791813, -0.04890163615345955, 0.013004799373447895, -0.009456455707550049, -0.06783807277679443, -0.052595049142837524, -0.02051832713186741, 0.056819990277290344, -0.05334223806858063, 0.009595217183232307, -0.008991027250885963, 0.0206981860101223, -0.0336424820125103, -0.04321637004613876, -0.05089516565203667, -0.022062456235289574, -0.06316262483596802, -0.007673545274883509, 0.032717205584049225, 0.03303701430559158, -0.0026507379952818155, -0.0056078433990478516, 0.06491591036319733, -0.004557077772915363, -0.013037498109042645, 0.014413357712328434, 0.04584500938653946, 0.004578010644763708, -0.0067870425991714, -0.05554581061005592, -0.0825924277305603, 0.0009403187432326376, -0.02252396009862423, -0.008038573898375034, 0.040782731026411057, 0.016323233023285866, 0.0170879065990448, 0.048531271517276764, -0.07460099458694458, 0.037427376955747604, 0.03547098487615585, -0.04624531790614128, 0.0420101135969162, 0.07272730022668839, -0.022540045902132988, 0.040451642125844955, -0.027838105335831642, -0.005084772128611803, 0.034606993198394775, -0.057663679122924805, -0.014746339991688728, -0.012517762370407581, -0.041733235120773315, -0.031567562371492386, 0.04581931233406067, 0.0005332768778316677, -0.03989164158701897, 0.03405746817588806, -0.0036960996221750975, 0.02363906241953373, -0.009661216288805008, 0.04803125560283661, 0.051514528691768646, -0.02119799517095089, -0.06734075397253036, 0.011975347064435482, -0.030881954357028008, 0.0025999881327152252, 0.019878020510077477, -0.07331825792789459, -0.003113193204626441, 0.05682329833507538, 0.016697291284799576, -0.008962777443230152, 0.029623255133628845, 0.015369890257716179, -0.019214563071727753, -0.009601208381354809, -0.026035133749246597, -0.06422898918390274, -0.04019976779818535, -0.030517062172293663, 0.02186022698879242, 0.008068411611020565, 0.041092876344919205, 0.02628924883902073, 0.04351605847477913, -0.05952013283967972, -0.022237151861190796, -0.0022627969738096, 0.0024950166698545218, 0.03646785393357277, -0.031538065522909164, 0.06052641198039055, 0.014033542014658451, 0.03033333644270897, 0.030795730650424957, 0.03053869493305683, -0.03127435967326164, -0.005335069727152586, -0.02458861842751503, 0.020600920543074608, 0.030423037707805634, -0.04268386960029602, -0.05682073533535004, 0.009065214544534683, 0.032593995332717896, -0.033211249858140945, 0.05270322412252426, 0.03469243273139, 0.01097030658274889, 0.04446597397327423, 0.032288920134305954, -0.02618349716067314, -0.05443288013339043, 0.05034098029136658, 0.044576290994882584, -0.05982811376452446, -0.009447714313864708, -0.02716715633869171, -0.026188533753156662, 0.02687164954841137, -0.02017773874104023, 0.02207670733332634, 0.029753779992461205, 0.006443418562412262, -0.037761420011520386, 0.05231550335884094, 0.003988726530224085, -0.07676377147436142, 0.014021990820765495, 0.015001415275037289, -0.08612063527107239, -0.045687705278396606, 0.018595930188894272, -0.02508695423603058, -0.036844030022621155, 0.03298286721110344, 0.019168252125382423, -0.015551901422441006, -0.00852437037974596, 0.06062335520982742, 0.08017697185277939, 0.020982185378670692, 0.016577893868088722, -0.0081891268491745, -0.04695837199687958, -0.017521461471915245, -0.017932038754224777, 0.0012408217880874872, -0.0004711040819529444, 0.01710982620716095, -0.014360439032316208, -0.058016929775476456, -0.04680847004055977, 0.06416962295770645, -0.037475310266017914, -0.004892157856374979, 0.047712091356515884, 0.036743778735399246, 0.05361555144190788, -0.02938786894083023, -0.035075075924396515, 0.016889112070202827, -0.022184282541275024, 0.002047264017164707, -0.03407132998108864, -0.019228437915444374, 0.01675291173160076, 0.04133010655641556, -0.017083419486880302, -0.059710144996643066, 0.01713191717863083, -0.02081621065735817, -0.07288257777690887, 0.03648187965154648, -0.06700020283460617, 0.021387837827205658, -0.01954825595021248, 0.014155764132738113, 0.025373846292495728, 0.06745174527168274, -0.0237041674554348, 0.007189098279923201, -0.0035598408430814743, 0.04422639310359955, 0.0081802848726511, -0.012152965180575848, 0.04779205098748207, -0.04416642338037491, 0.014116226695477962, -0.04059651494026184, -0.020328320562839508, 0.0007349171792156994, -0.025387872010469437, 0.025309354066848755, -0.016587896272540092, -0.02667776681482792, -0.023062201216816902, 0.04088426008820534, -0.007582795340567827, 0.026265038177371025, 0.01199327502399683, -0.031511738896369934, -0.07163482904434204, -0.01132255606353283, -0.011246043257415295, -0.034306153655052185, 0.03400323539972305, 0.005909370724111795, 0.04281952232122421, -0.009137554094195366, 0.01314176619052887, -0.007825539447367191, -0.01119269896298647, 0.01385907270014286, -0.06029731407761574, 0.0048727854155004025, -0.0030884984880685806, -0.011886986903846264, -0.04008515179157257, -0.009391791187226772, 0.009753799065947533, -0.04585238918662071, 0.0011033022310584784, 0.02324405126273632, 0.052132636308670044, 0.007999418303370476, -0.04660262539982796, 0.023588305339217186, 0.02640906535089016, -0.007693341467529535, -0.05853002890944481, -0.033657655119895935, 0.009858645498752594, -0.03432716056704521, -0.00900813564658165, -0.030161814764142036, -0.039809975773096085, -0.014545701444149017, -0.07493964582681656, -0.006623819936066866, -0.017426157370209694, 0.06156514957547188, 0.009028923697769642, -0.02733447216451168, 0.025980712845921516, 0.018830927088856697, 0.008365016430616379, 0.0047025238163769245, 0.022161638364195824, 0.01756775937974453, 0.027683226391673088, -0.052891962230205536, -0.07190220057964325, -0.012164146639406681, 0.03733871504664421, -0.045246608555316925, 0.01960490643978119, -0.024316174909472466, 0.019188713282346725, 0.02355983853340149, 0.01606743223965168, 0.07354168593883514, -0.0026762813795357943, 0.04853397607803345, -0.044697634875774384, -0.0051030651666224, -0.04651731997728348, -0.05814281478524208, 0.023724190890789032, -0.052064865827560425, 0.00009263783431379125, 0.039967115968465805, -0.026372047141194344, -0.02881133183836937, -0.06626467406749725, -0.056862279772758484, 0.005458417348563671, 0.010540857911109924, -0.04896426945924759, 0.06294270604848862, -0.020002594217658043, -0.038910649716854095, -0.015426685102283955, -0.010497847571969032, -0.024378545582294464, 0.007638746406883001, 0.025945590808987617, -0.0035845106467604637, -0.018493101000785828, -0.06769666075706482, 0.034688130021095276, -0.028843220323324203, -0.013571325689554214, -0.01083639357239008, 0.05733305215835571, -0.023307813331484795, -0.05560874566435814, -0.021197035908699036, -0.0326208621263504, 0.004758086521178484, -0.06388414651155472, -0.01797346957027912, -0.0288213063031435, 0.007910504937171936, -0.03171956539154053, 0.045050252228975296, -0.01015979703515768, 0.052400607615709305, 0.01834624633193016, 0.026456892490386963, -0.009367074817419052, 0.023034516721963882, -0.01984165608882904, 0.07976961880922318, -0.00030751104350201786, 0.03538317233324051, -0.03512677177786827, 0.019318461418151855, 0.01505506131798029, -0.011868196539580822, 0.0019342248560860753, 0.012777241878211498, -0.004434533417224884, -0.04070424661040306, 0.013756071217358112, 0.02631627582013607, 0.014153505675494671, -0.019583456218242645, 0.01359314564615488, -0.0013295680982992053, -0.02427011914551258, -0.08032718300819397 ]
The recent introduction of Transformers language representation models allowed great improvements in many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, if on one hand the performances achieved by this kind of architectures are surprising, on the other their usability is limited by the high number of parameters which constitute their network, resulting in high computational and memory demands. In this work we present BERTino, a DistilBERT model which proposes to be the first lightweight alternative to the BERT architecture specific for the Italian language. We evaluated BERTino on the Italian ISDT, Italian ParTUT, Italian WikiNER and multiclass classification tasks, obtaining F1 scores comparable to those obtained by a BERTBASE with a remarkable improvement in training and inference speed.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18121v1
[ 0.002567635616287589, -0.019589470699429512, 0.07248125970363617, 0.02938738465309143, -0.04363023489713669, -0.03393007814884186, 0.0013030397240072489, -0.007301417179405689, 0.01369310449808836, -0.024327175691723824, -0.07155196368694305, 0.02012592740356922, -0.06215909868478775, 0.01693635806441307, -0.0614614374935627, -0.0015211831778287888, 0.05729212984442711, 0.006600796245038509, -0.013402990065515041, 0.0779949426651001, 0.025574874132871628, -0.0022103965748101473, -0.04194662347435951, 0.07088698446750641, 0.023631617426872253, 0.022049861028790474, -0.032140132039785385, 0.032743729650974274, 0.02639826387166977, -0.003246592590585351, 0.053651031106710434, 0.016058901324868202, 0.012211719527840614, -0.03733866289258003, -0.032081909477710724, -0.008163711987435818, -0.037484362721443176, 0.04885375127196312, 0.03795221820473671, -0.05356459692120552, -0.0075166793540120125, -0.029840996488928795, -0.033163998275995255, -0.01960628665983677, -0.026814710348844528, 0.05219411477446556, -0.015875838696956635, -0.03210419416427612, -0.05801064148545265, -0.0585954375565052, 0.037894535809755325, 0.024194685742259026, -0.01943097822368145, -0.007661654148250818, -0.03860488161444664, -0.008100996725261211, -0.03286389261484146, -0.003684852970764041, -0.07229746878147125, -0.05830933898687363, 0.00993049331009388, 0.0075555904768407345, 0.015525756403803825, -0.04944181814789772, -0.034081462770700455, 0.027997475117444992, -0.0677080750465393, -0.028309829533100128, -0.02890809252858162, -0.05311690643429756, 0.007323168683797121, -0.06613997370004654, -0.02867739647626877, 0.0313083715736866, 0.0011002079118043184, -0.05869293212890625, -0.019354965537786484, 0.008950294926762581, 0.021495919674634933, 0.008410569280385971, -0.043928951025009155, 0.029482364654541016, 0.011655822396278381, -0.015039350837469101, -0.00259215640835464, -0.043323270976543427, 0.0640757754445076, 0.013811181299388409, 0.031273357570171356, -0.006765380967408419, 0.029048923403024673, 0.013440470211207867, -0.07270175963640213, 0.03600160405039787, 0.05948089808225632, -0.0043701957911252975, 0.047398634254932404, -0.0059512583538889885, 0.002152876928448677, -0.03724870830774307, -0.03493107110261917, -0.034360069781541824, 0.0014925830764696002, 0.05908599868416786, 0.02270369976758957, 0.013323173858225346, 0.007235412485897541, -0.0038324655033648014, -0.04976730793714523, 0.015398440882563591, -0.014251994900405407, -0.020397974178195, -0.00193411810323596, -0.04598081111907959, -0.049667730927467346, -0.053660355508327484, 0.05887231230735779, 0.000913245661649853, -0.026798190549016, 0.009716510772705078, -0.005215675104409456, 0.007245504297316074, 0.0358191542327404, -0.05256768316030502, -0.03347844257950783, 0.009357213042676449, 0.007939386181533337, -0.014390910975635052, -0.014042125083506107, 0.01873655803501606, -0.036065474152565, 0.035052474588155746, 0.03563791140913963, -0.06830287724733353, 0.0500464104115963, -0.04055047780275345, -0.020065076649188995, -0.027732685208320618, 0.049706194549798965, 0.01041689794510603, -0.026841597631573677, -0.0741897001862526, 0.006525195203721523, -0.006010096520185471, 0.03328755870461464, 0.07479961961507797, -0.07308599352836609, -0.011623917147517204, -0.006625180132687092, 0.01408582367002964, 0.017339298501610756, -0.0181209035217762, 0.014403273351490498, 0.01482060644775629, 0.023017968982458115, -0.04641684517264366, 0.04095051437616348, -0.02841346338391304, -0.05826887488365173, 0.03841615840792656, 0.016854917630553246, -0.03447380289435387, -0.00009359390242025256, -0.05184426158666611, 0.020211627706885338, -0.014105713926255703, 0.021153217181563377, 0.017382454127073288, -0.02152557298541069, -0.014163416810333729, -0.06273705512285233, -0.0014691194519400597, 0.0017130621708929539, 0.030322851613163948, -0.05249383673071861, -0.00373283913359046, 0.03461248800158501, -0.04636188969016075, -0.011497757397592068, -0.025174323469400406, 0.0032949205487966537, 0.03753262385725975, -0.013815447688102722, -0.02734796516597271, -0.046373698860406876, -0.014846231788396835, -0.07699207961559296, -0.046525921672582626, 0.037702132016420364, -0.015827959403395653, -0.029397903010249138, -0.006597970612347126, 0.004856440704315901, 0.00968154426664114, 0.006715814583003521, -0.048614077270030975, 0.005505131557583809, -0.038526494055986404, -0.0609685480594635, 0.03749231994152069, -0.08776123821735382, -0.0318789966404438, -0.048264965415000916, 0.01589919440448284, 0.038662511855363846, -0.057449083775281906, -0.00031484218197874725, 0.0324273556470871, -0.03129913657903671, -0.007674599997699261, 0.0037025504279881716, 0.038906801491975784, 0.061380814760923386, 0.011348727159202099, 0.04526408389210701, -0.061940163373947144, -0.09813336282968521, 0.06650529056787491, 0.008676781319081783, 0.006709936074912548, 0.0117788789793849, 0.03146248683333397, -0.011157774366438389, -0.04025828465819359, -0.03981006145477295, 0.022838357836008072, 0.04378652945160866, -0.02536887861788273, -0.0572446770966053, -0.008165605366230011, 0.053263384848833084, 0.013430938124656677, -0.062140483409166336, -0.0828058049082756, -0.012962309643626213, 0.011342540383338928, -0.03530888631939888, 0.01507649663835764, -0.018331989645957947, -0.05704213306307793, -0.003985196817666292, -0.016977999359369278, 0.031478483229875565, 0.03008124977350235, -0.023717334493994713, 0.03134709969162941, -0.040751103311777115, 0.02757229097187519, -0.05838804319500923, 0.013176379725337029, -0.06861928105354309, 0.0047378563322126865, 0.005046809557825327, -0.03327150642871857, 0.012384805828332901, 0.051442425698041916, -0.0449867807328701, 0.05515165627002716, -0.007960556074976921, 0.05739940330386162, 0.005409694276750088, 0.04941624402999878, -0.020286276936531067, 0.03709859400987625, 0.0032760207541286945, -0.023618465289473534, -0.01597285456955433, 0.016943607479333878, 0.05860288441181183, -0.013927847146987915, -0.024658605456352234, 0.058103229850530624, 0.045061755925416946, -0.027666758745908737, -0.003714060876518488, -0.01759578287601471, 0.0059883203357458115, -0.002659158781170845, 0.03997587412595749, 0.07005979120731354, 0.01707378774881363, -0.0052751959301531315, 0.00673496862873435, -0.054446522146463394, -0.049331653863191605, -0.00887745339423418, -0.010405171662569046, -0.08003587275743484, -0.021514631807804108, -0.05971105396747589, -0.032284144312143326, -0.06488681584596634, -0.04032961279153824, -0.039300400763750076, 0.02043679542839527, -0.0558011531829834, -0.02621658891439438, -0.025626664981245995, 0.04052117466926575, -0.009272911585867405, -0.04478487744927406, -0.001959634479135275, 0.03669847175478935, -0.040208302438259125, 0.0369294211268425, -0.06338250637054443, 0.0077863577753305435, -0.008117027580738068, 0.042933955788612366, -0.013352347537875175, -0.02630372904241085, 0.018808845430612564, -0.04503883048892021, 0.007493349723517895, -0.01996576599776745, 0.011843133717775345, 0.022155355662107468, 0.03351409733295441, -0.011662758886814117, -0.0587715320289135, 0.004923692438751459, -0.02265128120779991, -0.044977039098739624, -0.039056580513715744, -0.0518612302839756, -0.04092487692832947, 0.03575380891561508, 0.0015554000856354833, 0.005928549915552139, -0.019794750958681107, -0.025246424600481987, 0.030549416318535805, -0.01984015479683876, 0.024710215628147125, 0.020944174379110336, 0.05493738874793053, -0.005385108292102814, -0.04334958642721176, 0.012693183496594429, -0.037628889083862305, 0.021584244444966316, -0.002354143187403679, -0.0356394499540329, -0.03979366272687912, 0.03065134957432747, -0.08597578853368759, -0.018664417788386345, 0.05306721478700638, 0.06416748464107513, -0.06744122505187988, -0.045775942504405975, 0.003392074489966035, -0.010942087508738041, -0.00014994770754128695, -0.030501971021294594, -0.039931897073984146, 0.06648492813110352, 0.051036182790994644, -0.045196786522865295, -0.023205609992146492, -0.007299767341464758, -0.042856745421886444, -0.04316449165344238, 0.0020758984610438347, 0.01932726986706257, 0.04737696051597595, 0.006747347768396139, -0.018499594181776047, -0.027322450652718544, 0.00023198348935693502, 0.05158722773194313, 0.0159302968531847, -0.043307214975357056, 0.024467110633850098, -0.03540598228573799, 0.028029922395944595, 0.026644373312592506, 0.016680799424648285, 0.033796921372413635, -0.051134996116161346, 0.04376489669084549, -0.0760740265250206, 0.03311217576265335, -0.0008812242303974926, -0.02965712919831276, 0.0032703489996492863, 0.06585708260536194, -0.04648071900010109, 0.04598497226834297, -0.009694481268525124, -0.023228371515870094, 0.034244388341903687, 0.02297646924853325, -0.002756943227723241, -0.020887834951281548, -0.03532377630472183, -0.008693799376487732, 0.05633218213915825, 0.028694484382867813, 0.014619199559092522, 0.040309734642505646, -0.0006536981672979891, -0.01645042560994625, -0.07014687359333038, 0.02096131071448326, -0.04798832908272743, 0.013345048762857914, -0.052188754081726074, -0.05460002273321152, 0.07390701770782471, -0.04184610769152641, 0.0014072745107114315, -0.017078811302781105, -0.033249709755182266, -0.030034780502319336, -0.009717384353280067, 0.03709736466407776, -0.07198188453912735, -0.005728152580559254, -0.057745710015296936, 0.01659211702644825, -0.02297711931169033, -0.02635827846825123, -0.05496254563331604, -0.04700159281492233, -0.018605003133416176, 0.02923724241554737, 0.06924410164356232, 0.03495189920067787, -0.006119576282799244, 0.017494847998023033, 0.025945642963051796, -0.004345668945461512, -0.021190278232097626, 0.03262375667691231, 0.017137663438916206, -0.006090441718697548, 0.024103736504912376, 0.004038529004901648, -0.028696822002530098, 0.008155222050845623, 0.042755547910928726, -0.04020494222640991, 0.007268558256328106, 0.018061883747577667, 0.026528848335146904, -0.05829868093132973, -0.08537161350250244, 0.022340111434459686, -0.03475882485508919, -0.01743326336145401, -0.04457581043243408, 0.015701772645115852, 0.04145215079188347, -0.03168464079499245, 0.014278413727879524, 0.0356869138777256, 0.008278897032141685, -0.014850558713078499, -0.016076821833848953, 0.033688951283693314, 0.013964205048978329, 0.026277972385287285, -0.03128243610262871, -0.05982687696814537, 0.034790318459272385, -0.03721451759338379, 0.013796363957226276, 0.015617014840245247, 0.020332051441073418, -0.004538056440651417, 0.038705602288246155, -0.08047689497470856, -0.020559638738632202, 0.06392432004213333, 0.004824984353035688, -0.020881520584225655, 0.053988978266716, -0.020866634324193, 0.049982160329818726, -0.024702277034521103, 0.024990707635879517, -0.01657840423285961, -0.02876901812851429, -0.005758069455623627, -0.001837368356063962, -0.03939685970544815, 0.02142883837223053, 0.059367429465055466, 0.044141534715890884, -0.020152002573013306, 0.03478654846549034, 0.056762441992759705, 0.019633691757917404, -0.057197730988264084, 0.02517763525247574, 0.011773805133998394, -0.007584736216813326, -0.03130295127630234, -0.04157434031367302, -0.031000155955553055, -0.04067554697394371, 0.031995970755815506, -0.021588509902358055, -0.008599568158388138, 0.01134969387203455, 0.016336634755134583, 0.01484206784516573, 0.021905364468693733, -0.030925298109650612, 0.027627812698483467, 0.01005394198000431, -0.0343656949698925, -0.04656178876757622, -0.02680933102965355, -0.06494610756635666, 0.044657204300165176, 0.01915837451815605, -0.00031711446354165673, 0.002371919108554721, 0.05856332182884216, -0.051824092864990234, -0.004621870815753937, 0.03021314926445484, -0.05901014059782028, 0.021635927259922028, -0.029120074585080147, 0.02508448250591755, -0.052629344165325165, 0.02488126792013645, -0.001276472699828446, 0.024160338565707207, -0.040146540850400925, 0.021245619282126427, 0.007506710477173328, 0.03847809508442879, -0.030347464606165886, -0.06228572875261307, 0.004421838093549013, 0.009440962225198746, 0.0203002467751503, -0.0226410124450922, 0.007986189797520638, 0.012430286966264248, 0.015225673094391823, 0.022176172584295273, 0.053930193185806274, 0.0005919478135183454, -0.007508890237659216, -0.010975734330713749, 0.044605087488889694, -0.05151372402906418, 0.0036537079140543938, -0.014509868808090687, -0.06706628948450089, 0.026517659425735474, 0.0007261749706231058, 0.02081855945289135, 0.027057452127337456, -0.050249092280864716, -0.0480380617082119, 0.05153452605009079, -0.02053014002740383, -0.06903479248285294, -0.012848525308072567, -0.005517544224858284, -0.08148925751447678, 0.013112972490489483, 0.0035736646968871355, -0.03198869898915291, -0.04555021598935127, 0.04263688623905182, 0.03843328729271889, -0.04813128709793091, -0.04603758081793785, 0.0630926787853241, 0.06605883687734604, -0.016697756946086884, 0.034331802278757095, 0.04346588999032974, -0.01769784651696682, -0.026487916707992554, 0.03143227472901344, -0.014143303968012333, 0.03258846700191498, -0.023394543677568436, 0.01688576117157936, -0.02937992662191391, -0.0004659099504351616, 0.05733130872249603, -0.06094951555132866, 0.012235073372721672, -0.005143631715327501, 0.020944654941558838, -0.020205555483698845, -0.03653217479586601, -0.01578213833272457, -0.0004660525592043996, -0.010381211526691914, -0.022208288311958313, -0.06842391937971115, -0.02934238314628601, -0.05129769444465637, 0.023410184308886528, 0.003920340910553932, -0.07358898222446442, 0.0207512229681015, 0.008007297292351723, -0.08338609337806702, 0.04725874587893486, -0.03128707781434059, 0.010522217489778996, 0.004463756922632456, -0.01863064430654049, -0.052433501929044724, 0.0440014973282814, -0.06264928728342056, -0.04114317148923874, 0.0038420988712459803, -0.014976025559008121, 0.03855905681848526, -0.032910898327827454, 0.010108668357133865, -0.056988172233104706, 0.040485236793756485, -0.01778397709131241, 0.01815560832619667, 0.02490144409239292, -0.04631427302956581, -0.03244625777006149, 0.0036402009427547455, -0.021912463009357452, -0.042861208319664, 0.006925614550709724, 0.0325775109231472, -0.0030382671393454075, 0.004401184618473053, -0.023671641945838928, -0.0841793417930603, 0.0048763039521873, -0.0050140381790697575, -0.020470868796110153, -0.005115828011184931, 0.027589421719312668, 0.00844634510576725, -0.061786066740751266, 0.03312215209007263, -0.04277805611491203, -0.006465073209255934, 0.022850655019283295, -0.08116880059242249, 0.00953616201877594, 0.01381311472505331, -0.00915205106139183, -0.01687731221318245, 0.03172306343913078, 0.006890003103762865, -0.07867415994405746, -0.029767697677016258, 0.02930961176753044, -0.006467550061643124, -0.016414908692240715, -0.08558967709541321, -0.02923206239938736, -0.0012931197416037321, -0.045751817524433136, -0.040181964635849, 0.0116730947047472, 0.022413741797208786, -0.06510569900274277, 0.014279916882514954, -0.0015675978502258658, -0.023285623639822006, 0.02628074400126934, -0.08835867047309875, 0.004525594413280487, -0.011487890966236591, 0.041590768843889236, 0.01789144240319729, 0.007074850145727396, -0.05086849257349968, -0.05917556956410408, 0.00383067037910223, -0.0386844202876091, -0.048735570162534714, 0.007277082186192274, 0.009070158936083317, 0.009738865308463573, -0.050038114190101624, 0.012202376499772072, 0.057946667075157166, 0.01477422658354044, -0.01264890842139721, -0.00932931900024414, -0.014506908133625984, 0.04596531018614769, 0.008558769710361958, 0.042406193912029266, -0.013468964956700802, 0.054762352257966995, -0.042537786066532135, -0.03438149020075798, -0.04331935569643974, -0.04104785993695259, -0.017908090725541115, -0.06393156945705414, 0.019046902656555176, 0.054972779005765915, -0.015786290168762207, 0.004312412813305855, -0.02122626081109047, -0.03336743637919426, -0.023559445515275, -0.03319665417075157, -0.027570193633437157, 0.015717240050435066, 0.030408011749386787, -0.050255268812179565, -0.03226296603679657, -0.011568469926714897, -0.04050431028008461, -0.02949589304625988, 0.056164637207984924, -0.043158430606126785, 0.02862062305212021, -0.04577617347240448, 0.0061130039393901825, -0.03141948580741882, 0.052109796553850174, -0.013361825607717037, 0.07849644124507904, -0.018109489232301712, 0.03777490183711052, -0.051769714802503586, -0.0289103165268898, -0.01978907361626625, -0.07298348844051361, -0.05179616063833237, -0.027576420456171036, 0.01869170553982258, -0.019801795482635498, -0.02611519768834114, -0.005574004724621773, 0.05723561346530914, -0.042706381529569626, 0.0030458434484899044, 0.009004654362797737, 0.027774421498179436, 0.019178785383701324, 0.06385743618011475, -0.011522510088980198, 0.024002499878406525, -0.005467117764055729, 0.038961656391620636, 0.0170262660831213, -0.020871970802545547, 0.029765890911221504, -0.026009468361735344, 0.020091278478503227, -0.03446425125002861, -0.017256636172533035, -0.011475277133286, -0.008087472058832645, -0.06216903030872345, -0.049879372119903564, 0.006567744538187981, -0.005449135322123766, -0.05820740759372711 ]
A sequential pattern with negation, or negative sequential pattern, takes the form of a sequential pattern for which the negation symbol may be used in front of some of the pattern's itemsets. Intuitively, such a pattern occurs in a sequence if negated itemsets are absent in the sequence. Recent work has shown that different semantics can be attributed to these pattern forms, and that state-of-the-art algorithms do not extract the same sets of patterns. This raises the important question of the interpretability of sequential pattern with negation. In this study, our focus is on exploring how potential users perceive negation in sequential patterns. Our aim is to determine whether specific semantics are more "intuitive" than others and whether these align with the semantics employed by one or more state-of-the-art algorithms. To achieve this, we designed a questionnaire to reveal the semantics' intuition of each user. This article presents both the design of the questionnaire and an in-depth analysis of the 124 responses obtained. The outcomes indicate that two of the semantics are predominantly intuitive; however, neither of them aligns with the semantics of the primary state-of-the-art algorithms. As a result, we provide recommendations to account for this disparity in the conclusions drawn.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11638v1
[ -0.028262630105018616, 0.012298350222408772, 0.058954253792762756, 0.0037051569670438766, 0.05350180342793465, -0.014596264809370041, -0.06032945215702057, 0.028617702424526215, -0.0443389005959034, -0.02423194609582424, -0.037127409130334854, -0.013819671235978603, -0.019800301641225815, -0.03893595561385155, -0.002486158162355423, -0.028193708509206772, 0.07186774909496307, 0.06334739178419113, -0.042557183653116226, 0.04495764151215553, -0.02408214658498764, -0.013612702488899231, -0.012655433267354965, 0.05199503153562546, 0.005337175913155079, -0.026991333812475204, -0.02390941232442856, -0.0034179771319031715, -0.048252809792757034, -0.024942995980381966, 0.04396987706422806, -0.0317692756652832, -0.013087923638522625, -0.05251302942633629, -0.05271202698349953, 0.0007561585516668856, 0.02697548270225525, 0.023333190008997917, 0.037020497024059296, -0.027769217267632484, 0.0282744113355875, -0.062201932072639465, -0.07285495102405548, 0.013792051933705807, -0.04070030897855759, -0.007115506567060947, -0.04745587706565857, 0.013138274662196636, -0.05933044105768204, -0.057483647018671036, 0.03326374664902687, 0.0034529410768300295, 0.016124291345477104, 0.001529310247860849, -0.025969993323087692, -0.025321342051029205, 0.0161487627774477, 0.020805958658456802, -0.05507717654109001, -0.0007664058939553797, -0.014564324170351028, -0.03774696961045265, -0.014269252307713032, -0.006632302422076464, 0.01391505915671587, 0.03271172195672989, -0.010821237228810787, -0.06694725155830383, -0.03761764615774155, -0.00702804047614336, 0.05832087993621826, -0.06104722619056702, -0.011297267861664295, 0.013830072246491909, -0.06329011172056198, 0.0017921619582921267, -0.04154536873102188, -0.012657208368182182, 0.032395754009485245, 0.0074057672172784805, 0.010046828538179398, 0.027129042893648148, 0.02088814601302147, -0.002040637657046318, 0.009759892709553242, -0.014470822177827358, 0.05779557675123215, 0.0069561917334795, 0.01796373911201954, -0.0607825368642807, 0.009691738523542881, -0.020242098718881607, -0.07921119779348373, -0.005130502860993147, 0.05033119022846222, -0.033281195908784866, 0.0006409307243302464, 0.053248025476932526, 0.05130669102072716, -0.016647372394800186, 0.005282770376652479, -0.012106831185519695, -0.058514636009931564, 0.032941173762083054, 0.00973005872219801, -0.05781557783484459, -0.014339592307806015, 0.008763507008552551, -0.06801705807447433, 0.02542034350335598, -0.04467928782105446, -0.0004635701479855925, -0.011979568749666214, -0.06102696433663368, -0.047102559357881546, -0.05306856706738472, 0.06026899069547653, 0.03674903139472008, 0.020338483154773712, 0.024974800646305084, -0.03998203203082085, 0.048794832080602646, -0.010279021225869656, -0.010271738283336163, -0.019976604729890823, -0.02785518579185009, 0.0221918523311615, 0.059684962034225464, -0.0375765822827816, 0.012148852460086346, -0.04840470850467682, 0.009112901985645294, -0.0016316884430125356, -0.00386568414978683, 0.07386995106935501, -0.018614202737808228, 0.02324761264026165, -0.06802725046873093, 0.0426032729446888, -0.010389885865151882, -0.006598822772502899, -0.06701819598674774, 0.02406548149883747, -0.0010703911539167166, -0.017515083774924278, 0.040478143841028214, -0.0534236878156662, -0.01976061426103115, 0.02673686295747757, 0.03318529576063156, -0.0016464665532112122, 0.010150676593184471, 0.030283434316515923, 0.006803011521697044, -0.01361851580440998, -0.02059974893927574, 0.014532994478940964, -0.015128455124795437, -0.05745237320661545, -0.00036161739262752235, 0.018861157819628716, -0.015105494298040867, 0.005959478672593832, -0.02557651326060295, 0.04637697711586952, 0.022874873131513596, 0.042116545140743256, -0.02045532502233982, -0.04125135764479637, 0.0070229400880634785, -0.02494983747601509, 0.048197489231824875, -0.008900398388504982, -0.015835875645279884, -0.0515250600874424, 0.029980283230543137, -0.023145124316215515, -0.048393554985523224, -0.05905997380614281, 0.022252613678574562, -0.0004415065632201731, 0.014006521552801132, -0.03873845189809799, -0.006662802305072546, -0.008776439353823662, 0.05408450588583946, -0.07742290943861008, -0.0030492721125483513, 0.05288819596171379, 0.03477959707379341, -0.03215467184782028, -0.04204237833619118, 0.015148027800023556, -0.02486596442759037, -0.04342129826545715, -0.0537208616733551, 0.05084579065442085, -0.008957418613135815, -0.03219682723283768, 0.06682467460632324, -0.08927174657583237, -0.03726622089743614, -0.05561644956469536, -0.04930330067873001, -0.023186786100268364, -0.045451994985342026, 0.027255503460764885, 0.02546272799372673, -0.03685973957180977, -0.04559973627328873, 0.05222206562757492, 0.036763571202754974, 0.05116361752152443, 0.037321072071790695, -0.011244751513004303, 0.0133442971855402, -0.1006414070725441, 0.0590432770550251, 0.015530692413449287, 0.019914545118808746, 0.053624361753463745, 0.052805107086896896, -0.000055713666370138526, -0.011560994200408459, -0.01108468696475029, 0.0510394312441349, 0.04064612090587616, -0.0010215092916041613, -0.04832491651177406, -0.02646850422024727, -0.02369016222655773, -0.06208397448062897, 0.0044058323837816715, -0.07766292989253998, 0.019578833132982254, -0.04674617946147919, -0.028744928538799286, 0.03455343842506409, -0.02428983710706234, -0.03933976590633392, -0.065055713057518, -0.027049073949456215, 0.0462668277323246, -0.01273795310407877, -0.04382021725177765, -0.02575800195336342, -0.017050258815288544, 0.026979006826877594, 0.008535386063158512, 0.021016860380768776, -0.018310435116291046, -0.07861827313899994, -0.05013516917824745, 0.001852541696280241, 0.03858247026801109, 0.03151316195726395, -0.04397942125797272, 0.050862859934568405, -0.0015606918605044484, 0.02612917125225067, 0.05753866583108902, 0.02994929626584053, -0.04182460159063339, -0.013934108428657055, 0.04899249225854874, -0.03022376261651516, -0.005000842269510031, -0.017762714996933937, 0.03100217878818512, -0.028601715341210365, 0.03964070603251457, 0.03134020045399666, 0.03657320514321327, -0.0038098192308098078, -0.021066833287477493, -0.0543503612279892, 0.011984639801084995, -0.01868792250752449, 0.057063065469264984, 0.0449947789311409, 0.05132383853197098, 0.01181112602353096, -0.05683295056223869, -0.08558280020952225, -0.0007180178654380143, -0.023761510848999023, -0.03893684595823288, -0.06932207942008972, -0.05161081254482269, -0.06128707155585289, -0.08364351838827133, -0.023203140124678612, -0.03656813129782677, -0.06179166957736015, -0.04455660283565521, -0.07911981642246246, -0.043937746435403824, 0.003559352131560445, 0.02859610877931118, -0.02854270301759243, -0.05303151533007622, -0.05330096185207367, 0.022119641304016113, 0.018322356045246124, 0.00884750485420227, -0.07278866320848465, -0.04737474024295807, -0.03617428243160248, 0.007815051823854446, 0.002497260458767414, -0.006930927745997906, 0.018101554363965988, 0.01798163913190365, 0.03302764520049095, -0.011693897657096386, 0.017288029193878174, 0.023418527096509933, -0.030678575858473778, 0.04895306006073952, 0.013588150963187218, 0.004566030111163855, -0.017829591408371925, 0.020852630957961082, -0.054620664566755295, -0.03525930643081665, -0.0025459968019276857, 0.04864043369889259, 0.026341618970036507, -0.020496312528848648, -0.07278110086917877, -0.02816222794353962, -0.013418729417026043, 0.005763608030974865, -0.039186347275972366, 0.014715672470629215, 0.01654517836868763, -0.013940688222646713, -0.006525592878460884, -0.03275064006447792, 0.006943482905626297, 0.009015101008117199, 0.03344426676630974, -0.06926952302455902, -0.010936973616480827, 0.014701501466333866, -0.08850391954183578, -0.009145963937044144, 0.04102601855993271, 0.05455079302191734, -0.03358147665858269, 0.00824366882443428, 0.02019449882209301, -0.02410014532506466, 0.02321111597120762, 0.0025763832964003086, 0.03087940439581871, 0.03724277392029762, 0.04822375625371933, -0.03832656517624855, -0.045122016221284866, -0.00009802554995985702, -0.06278721988201141, -0.06663679331541061, 0.026265554130077362, 0.0474306121468544, 0.037163201719522476, 0.015917111188173294, -0.014539145864546299, -0.010481760837137699, -0.007579033728688955, 0.07230167835950851, -0.004661086015403271, -0.01598917506635189, 0.009546990506350994, -0.06714242696762085, 0.032217737287282944, 0.033438872545957565, 0.014949364587664604, -0.02647918276488781, -0.029142852872610092, -0.005980974528938532, -0.056619126349687576, 0.04529837518930435, 0.006104376167058945, -0.04319430887699127, 0.031710248440504074, 0.009485345333814621, -0.029813077300786972, 0.038487568497657776, -0.01877826638519764, 0.03248847648501396, -0.0009090250823646784, -0.01610131934285164, 0.022614380344748497, -0.032212384045124054, -0.046250972896814346, 0.02739528939127922, 0.041198667138814926, -0.02272334136068821, 0.01310102641582489, 0.010703316889703274, -0.003773241303861141, 0.026013208553195, -0.09051922708749771, 0.03686656057834625, -0.0260995514690876, 0.029491065070033073, 0.00427172752097249, -0.0708518847823143, 0.056299928575754166, -0.017038507387042046, 0.000504002848174423, -0.03734568506479263, -0.01587725803256035, -0.030189158394932747, -0.043633799999952316, -0.02975856512784958, -0.04713601991534233, 0.02574506402015686, -0.07477590441703796, -0.0032482196111232042, 0.0016813715919852257, -0.005197132471948862, -0.021002789959311485, 0.013423841446638107, 0.007246060762554407, 0.032165396958589554, 0.05984294041991234, 0.036032240837812424, 0.001654370571486652, -0.0314360037446022, 0.04547491297125816, -0.03756258636713028, -0.00420653959736228, -0.030603336170315742, -0.020473143085837364, 0.056745149195194244, -0.03383773937821388, -0.032495077699422836, -0.04437202215194702, -0.016971196979284286, 0.03437300771474838, -0.06187908351421356, -0.029705651104450226, -0.02931642159819603, 0.04805930331349373, -0.02909335494041443, -0.08030325174331665, -0.04667346552014351, -0.05500514432787895, -0.05106967315077782, 0.014745575375854969, 0.002621202962473035, 0.03511684387922287, -0.03533351048827171, 0.03229261934757233, -0.00387728214263916, 0.046271730214357376, -0.013594170100986958, 0.015958964824676514, 0.02910844422876835, 0.016245152801275253, 0.0020165625028312206, 0.012281112372875214, -0.06149543076753616, -0.014215643517673016, -0.03745434433221817, 0.01702183112502098, -0.036568667739629745, 0.05339490622282028, 0.01373422984033823, 0.05044291540980339, -0.08437590301036835, -0.003127498785033822, 0.026543371379375458, 0.015482706017792225, -0.0009947122307494283, 0.0564693845808506, -0.02188120409846306, 0.01607675664126873, -0.049154020845890045, 0.03967710956931114, 0.014977363869547844, 0.006698788143694401, 0.023141389712691307, 0.032306868582963943, -0.018962450325489044, -0.030652210116386414, 0.05307748541235924, -0.046384625136852264, -0.05223143845796585, -0.0042615048587322235, 0.0120012778788805, 0.01971026137471199, -0.023220419883728027, 0.016154905781149864, 0.025303760543465614, -0.03871212154626846, -0.012839742004871368, -0.026683079078793526, -0.01718047447502613, -0.0002335991448489949, 0.032506465911865234, -0.020038632676005363, 0.007733689621090889, 0.041672781109809875, -0.030547773465514183, 0.010081173852086067, 0.03766622021794319, 0.007526526693254709, 0.00915607437491417, -0.022652022540569305, 0.041344426572322845, -0.06459879875183105, 0.03598129376769066, -0.05758688226342201, 0.06388908624649048, 0.042801856994628906, 0.004435212351381779, 0.00014736835146322846, -0.010433350689709187, -0.022646384313702583, -0.01136298943310976, -0.03321334347128868, 0.00028052786365151405, 0.018873872235417366, -0.020354585722088814, 0.032886896282434464, 0.008177196606993675, 0.0333893746137619, 0.03492368385195732, 0.02308945171535015, 0.010323846712708473, -0.0031849665101617575, -0.022978562861680984, -0.015035955235362053, 0.010002668015658855, -0.028499526903033257, -0.034270547330379486, 0.010636869817972183, 0.016401829198002815, -0.02356819063425064, 0.03131374344229698, 0.015819871798157692, -0.020884327590465546, -0.0034830428194254637, 0.026048200204968452, -0.02413139119744301, -0.07004734873771667, -0.02432495728135109, 0.043640151619911194, -0.02033405750989914, 0.03696399927139282, -0.04045422002673149, -0.03947075828909874, -0.011423636227846146, -0.02574865147471428, 0.03374259173870087, 0.05615159496665001, -0.008402115665376186, -0.030972454696893692, 0.005797412246465683, -0.00509627116844058, -0.06200847402215004, 0.013976537622511387, 0.03923929110169411, -0.05876491963863373, 0.014001836068928242, -0.008159814402461052, 0.04136195406317711, -0.02817649394273758, 0.049791380763053894, 0.0010902541689574718, -0.04113317281007767, -0.039822302758693695, 0.07794813811779022, 0.08751241117715836, -0.055322203785181046, 0.0024359365925192833, 0.032162170857191086, -0.036251697689294815, 0.02637827768921852, -0.03396771475672722, -0.004699278622865677, -0.002205152064561844, 0.016959046944975853, 0.0010458010947331786, -0.04181044176220894, -0.007709691300988197, 0.08101923018693924, -0.009248905815184116, 0.01375308446586132, 0.020688176155090332, -0.03686351701617241, 0.04409607872366905, -0.05028178170323372, -0.035992324352264404, 0.016050854697823524, 0.013808072544634342, -0.0037153379525989294, -0.049046874046325684, -0.0310351625084877, -0.037996821105480194, 0.011679455637931824, -0.0001402972120558843, -0.05935981497168541, 0.004830609541386366, -0.015899095684289932, -0.07365313917398453, 0.022273274138569832, -0.06210651621222496, 0.01120914239436388, -0.0003472966200206429, 0.04579007998108864, 0.02958211675286293, 0.06803359091281891, -0.025955805554986, -0.03091493993997574, -0.00026037811767309904, 0.011445936746895313, 0.004722126293927431, -0.02385748364031315, -0.002436108887195587, 0.006628490053117275, 0.023062163963913918, -0.06028662249445915, 0.019561585038900375, 0.0037296158261597157, -0.03633081167936325, 0.06680720299482346, 0.002870946889743209, -0.049135345965623856, -0.032795291393995285, 0.008562839590013027, -0.028223779052495956, 0.027146775275468826, 0.050231654196977615, -0.006859814282506704, -0.06111418083310127, 0.004055833909660578, -0.005115616135299206, -0.02414262853562832, 0.02279733307659626, 0.0409962497651577, 0.04685107618570328, -0.03425416722893715, 0.010507368482649326, 0.03283850476145744, 0.0065153236500918865, 0.029927948489785194, -0.05626268684864044, -0.0052764443680644035, 0.023055091500282288, -0.03030787780880928, -0.039087843149900436, -0.0014424771070480347, -0.028050510212779045, -0.0311951395124197, 0.017645370215177536, 0.03992171958088875, 0.001595895504578948, 0.00672658858820796, -0.05772016942501068, 0.019153447821736336, 0.006366140209138393, -0.06440744549036026, -0.06589803099632263, -0.0018708831630647182, -0.015563057735562325, -0.05162879452109337, -0.025242960080504417, 0.009117822162806988, -0.05009148642420769, 0.0023310701362788677, -0.09122543781995773, 0.01122676394879818, -0.00932312197983265, 0.0316840223968029, -0.00873338058590889, -0.0319853276014328, -0.0153345400467515, -0.028556402772665024, 0.04815364256501198, -0.01939801312983036, 0.012363717891275883, 0.035601906478405, 0.031076814979314804, 0.032400403171777725, -0.05847055837512016, -0.033812034875154495, 0.05418489873409271, -0.04287903010845184, -0.0039028292521834373, 0.017346862703561783, 0.03553701937198639, -0.018585186451673508, 0.02153361402451992, 0.03611525520682335, -0.010626428760588169, 0.03231101110577583, -0.04317471385002136, 0.0053126271814107895, -0.04230508208274841, -0.05895252525806427, 0.04229070246219635, -0.032629482448101044, -0.010231733322143555, 0.04454808309674263, -0.024075856432318687, -0.047684408724308014, -0.03955129534006119, -0.048013463616371155, 0.055486246943473816, -0.025447212159633636, -0.004455311223864555, 0.05242447927594185, -0.04015817493200302, -0.020199250429868698, -0.004236578941345215, 0.01091845240443945, -0.009782706387341022, 0.038480836898088455, 0.03057289309799671, -0.040734514594078064, -0.0005341095966286957, -0.07455060631036758, 0.00915942620486021, -0.027195559814572334, -0.039232175797224045, 0.024619437754154205, 0.06316687166690826, -0.03308403864502907, -0.0269065722823143, -0.007359290961176157, -0.024910714477300644, -0.012057514861226082, -0.08026375621557236, -0.065299391746521, 0.0068349167704582214, 0.042082928121089935, 0.04169413074851036, 0.02728406898677349, 0.032232873141765594, 0.04569348692893982, -0.023902101442217827, 0.05492164194583893, 0.03979302942752838, -0.008207435719668865, -0.040120501071214676, 0.05923984572291374, 0.03372758999466896, 0.009952276945114136, -0.02938690595328808, -0.01288626343011856, -0.003771033138036728, -0.0017366482643410563, 0.029026353731751442, 0.0036342013627290726, -0.030926773324608803, -0.07072318345308304, 0.002331472234800458, 0.044388581067323685, 0.00018607349193189293, -0.0207962766289711, 0.0062864492647349834, 0.03213045001029968, -0.025389039888978004, -0.027501432225108147 ]
Many are the ways of engineering the band gap of nanoribbons including application of stress, electric field and functionalization of the edges. In this article, we investigate separately the effects of these methods on armchair graphene and boron nitride nanoribbons. By means of density functional theory calculations, we show that, despite their similar structure, the two materials respond in opposite ways to these stimuli. By treating them as perturbations of a heteroatomic ladder model based on the tight-binding formalism, we connect the two behaviours to the different symmetries of the top valence and bottom conduction wave functions. These results indicate that opposite and complementary strategies are preferable to engineer the gapwidth of armchair graphene and boron nitride nanoribbons.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14432v2
[ -0.03452202305197716, -0.010823703370988369, 0.05347283184528351, 0.03284798562526703, 0.034753765910863876, -0.033910177648067474, -0.013387064449489117, 0.008737638592720032, 0.0005633431137539446, -0.026975106447935104, -0.04435090348124504, -0.048258982598781586, -0.04154207557439804, -0.03279543295502663, -0.0003056258719880134, 0.026676055043935776, 0.05835135281085968, 0.029375959187746048, -0.045495741069316864, 0.0818038061261177, 0.005344456527382135, -0.06018301472067833, -0.01456935703754425, 0.07395388185977936, -0.025056416168808937, 0.061925008893013, -0.03606277331709862, -0.00449790945276618, -0.02715178392827511, -0.007315571419894695, 0.06873728334903717, -0.015382809564471245, -0.02858159877359867, -0.013013767078518867, -0.006721414625644684, 0.021855296567082405, -0.0011149499332532287, 0.015029096975922585, 0.0799369215965271, -0.0200131107121706, 0.01500710565596819, -0.050198525190353394, -0.06435441225767136, 0.0031795892864465714, -0.03298525884747505, -0.014493177644908428, -0.015684153884649277, 0.009065471589565277, -0.053499627858400345, -0.05980454012751579, 0.0059887985698878765, 0.05212195962667465, 0.0534064844250679, 0.02171911858022213, -0.07209163159132004, 0.019630346447229385, -0.03683047369122505, -0.00027132523246109486, -0.05682506039738655, 0.04822973906993866, -0.0347198061645031, -0.010317403823137283, 0.030212534591555595, -0.008547468110918999, -0.029100671410560608, 0.04202200472354889, -0.06007224693894386, -0.06752676516771317, -0.030492911115288734, -0.04193096607923508, 0.04456397145986557, -0.032398588955402374, 0.008480903692543507, -0.02494119666516781, -0.030744707211852074, 0.010264208540320396, -0.037018388509750366, 0.02496366761624813, 0.018497686833143234, 0.019809555262327194, -0.05023977532982826, -0.00657986756414175, 0.012626748532056808, -0.001895205699838698, 0.0058972472324967384, 0.02700207009911537, -0.0003476190904621035, 0.017458846792578697, 0.0296175517141819, -0.016965530812740326, 0.026803838089108467, 0.008531149476766586, -0.06056434288620949, 0.009580201469361782, 0.007906357757747173, -0.008546266704797745, 0.032104309648275375, 0.04491632059216499, 0.009311898611485958, -0.0641532614827156, 0.020012343302369118, -0.057564858347177505, -0.036931995302438736, 0.0027317116037011147, -0.01927638240158558, -0.013269374147057533, -0.013777412474155426, -0.008702008984982967, -0.015527695417404175, -0.021571949124336243, 0.0043744780123233795, -0.009152931161224842, -0.011327170766890049, -0.03846808522939682, -0.0131525294855237, -0.01503251027315855, 0.03287641331553459, 0.04893643036484718, 0.01035353448241949, 0.02032455988228321, -0.028198136016726494, 0.023257797583937645, -0.04606607183814049, 0.024282125756144524, -0.05309149622917175, 0.008608264848589897, 0.06362847983837128, 0.04779662936925888, -0.0004381420440040529, -0.042980458587408066, -0.045855797827243805, 0.010559589602053165, 0.01542594749480486, -0.02699349634349346, 0.07889286428689957, -0.059478696435689926, -0.02203129418194294, -0.009761087596416473, 0.019698381423950195, 0.03697405010461807, -0.05651210993528366, -0.05249899625778198, 0.01581828109920025, 0.0070865461602807045, 0.042307544499635696, 0.07681751996278763, -0.07471892237663269, 0.040219202637672424, -0.02105928584933281, 0.05053674429655075, 0.024907687678933144, -0.005904074292629957, 0.006097674835473299, 0.017422184348106384, 0.042899373918771744, -0.02655082941055298, 0.03598739206790924, -0.009372754022479057, 0.01801992580294609, 0.005584972910583019, 0.032450348138809204, -0.028408080339431763, -0.002240579342469573, 0.0034415589179843664, -0.03185354173183441, -0.029290979728102684, 0.03402569144964218, -0.02361007034778595, -0.016169480979442596, -0.027698179706931114, -0.04486289992928505, 0.03181222826242447, 0.00598011864349246, -0.03504907712340355, -0.05996662750840187, -0.026985997334122658, -0.029383612796664238, -0.03695150464773178, -0.051281221210956573, 0.012310733087360859, 0.04012328386306763, -0.01729867048561573, -0.0181195680052042, 0.010927862487733364, -0.0032941752579063177, 0.02565804310142994, -0.08328410238027573, 0.007986854761838913, -0.003688474651426077, -0.021241430193185806, -0.026186887174844742, -0.06689736247062683, 0.05012475326657295, 0.012175953947007656, -0.08701832592487335, -0.04151172935962677, 0.031281039118766785, -0.0017265755450353026, -0.0013065881794318557, 0.01058649830520153, -0.05913456901907921, -0.013837293721735477, -0.009171009995043278, -0.011918107978999615, -0.015295120887458324, -0.0667353942990303, 0.005657176487147808, 0.0525277704000473, -0.03262345492839813, -0.01346288900822401, 0.05649475008249283, 0.02360975742340088, 0.016733678057789803, -0.025532593950629234, -0.014616092666983604, -0.009214098565280437, -0.10168152302503586, 0.041238561272621155, 0.05835166573524475, 0.014667048119008541, 0.03281537443399429, -0.023989789187908173, 0.03075702302157879, -0.042858559638261795, -0.0064458902925252914, 0.0531611368060112, 0.04156283289194107, 0.0022990545257925987, -0.0701960101723671, 0.036470916122198105, -0.017200129106640816, -0.06140218302607536, -0.044366247951984406, -0.04857207462191582, -0.00548317888751626, 0.0029616435058414936, -0.07316748052835464, 0.042148157954216, 0.003103319788351655, -0.06102241948246956, 0.021375207230448723, -0.05137727037072182, 0.0617087297141552, 0.015314956195652485, -0.02367260865867138, -0.04029497131705284, -0.07421550154685974, 0.003991925623267889, -0.041987285017967224, 0.023920709267258644, -0.018633173778653145, -0.04639410600066185, -0.06186608225107193, 0.027274731546640396, 0.05631973594427109, 0.006784484721720219, -0.025021009147167206, 0.03365384042263031, -0.003262036480009556, 0.04202630743384361, 0.008910833857953548, 0.03811876103281975, -0.023507701233029366, 0.030919235199689865, 0.019305741414427757, 0.058645863085985184, -0.03978254273533821, -0.06837344169616699, 0.06552352011203766, -0.06559473276138306, 0.011269677430391312, 0.02387993410229683, 0.010469069704413414, -0.02139919064939022, -0.003827034728601575, 0.03066314570605755, -0.027216196060180664, -0.0484965555369854, 0.030810074880719185, 0.061264730989933014, 0.058311715722084045, 0.003115012077614665, -0.031635578721761703, -0.06069043651223183, -0.03695116564631462, -0.03223634138703346, 0.001866859500296414, -0.059798575937747955, -0.02107025496661663, -0.06889712810516357, -0.06147131323814392, -0.0578477568924427, -0.03576783090829849, -0.05307445302605629, -0.046336159110069275, -0.07691166549921036, -0.0026183926966041327, -0.03057507425546646, -0.008425955660641193, -0.026638291776180267, -0.06017104908823967, 0.0012230188585817814, 0.026795078068971634, 0.02788935974240303, -0.002693654503673315, -0.03917280584573746, -0.013786575756967068, 0.023559939116239548, -0.008960687555372715, -0.029701678082346916, -0.023424692451953888, -0.015053574927151203, -0.05790073424577713, 0.00986567884683609, -0.00914478674530983, 0.035865265876054764, 0.006027258466929197, -0.020273791626095772, -0.009197316132485867, -0.016307832673192024, -0.006133717019110918, 0.029155001044273376, 0.020702581852674484, 0.019304897636175156, -0.039887696504592896, -0.022553207352757454, 0.07417590916156769, 0.061017442494630814, -0.017899716272950172, -0.02452246844768524, -0.01667150668799877, -0.03422338888049126, 0.05985419452190399, -0.026420341804623604, 0.05582010746002197, 0.03480001911520958, 0.017295628786087036, -0.015904869884252548, -0.04495183378458023, 0.028058074414730072, -0.01532118208706379, -0.030254248529672623, -0.017679518088698387, -0.01768343709409237, 0.005603328347206116, -0.07244665920734406, 0.006032801698893309, 0.03653443232178688, 0.05371025204658508, -0.034582652151584625, 0.008137214928865433, 0.02021791785955429, 0.015050946734845638, 0.03247908502817154, 0.014284403994679451, -0.0019926552195101976, 0.02839907445013523, 0.06101550906896591, -0.018517984077334404, -0.006385249551385641, -0.005443633534014225, -0.056748438626527786, -0.06643276661634445, 0.02105167880654335, 0.025759628042578697, 0.044936761260032654, 0.01965484395623207, -0.04528023302555084, 0.015999142080545425, -0.02592918649315834, 0.01879497803747654, -0.037142012268304825, -0.03645963966846466, 0.019755983725190163, -0.024869026616215706, 0.038915473967790604, -0.027688251808285713, 0.03722112253308296, -0.027105513960123062, -0.050145234912633896, -0.017511360347270966, -0.06295671314001083, 0.0393705740571022, -0.006103554740548134, 0.021220499649643898, 0.03081786260008812, -0.012898183427751064, -0.035579826682806015, 0.04050947725772858, -0.012701543979346752, 0.04345231130719185, 0.01122103352099657, 0.017304595559835434, -0.009054402820765972, -0.002912144409492612, -0.06783898174762726, -0.00020494501222856343, 0.0194415133446455, -0.037495505064725876, 0.030230984091758728, 0.011838574893772602, 0.04386831820011139, -0.009743100963532925, -0.09054359793663025, -0.024723365902900696, 0.0013046121457591653, -0.010137411765754223, 0.015866711735725403, -0.05540655553340912, 0.0870339646935463, 0.01285098772495985, 0.004306130576878786, -0.036204151809215546, -0.013519701547920704, -0.06144428625702858, -0.008710882626473904, -0.03738776966929436, -0.033469997346401215, 0.02620803192257881, -0.030016189441084862, -0.013281302526593208, 0.0078407758846879, 0.014013598673045635, -0.05654440447688103, 0.04115823656320572, 0.027888739481568336, 0.056565530598163605, 0.06889132410287857, -0.025538245216012, 0.04409506916999817, -0.02639971673488617, 0.010701163671910763, 0.046759914606809616, -0.03445270285010338, 0.04309393838047981, -0.01923859864473343, 0.010412599891424179, -0.034584470093250275, -0.028202582150697708, -0.013600492849946022, -0.02430363930761814, 0.053944651037454605, 0.0014067930169403553, -0.019983729347586632, -0.0016039927722886205, 0.017889726907014847, -0.0005766585818491876, -0.05368098244071007, -0.04784689098596573, -0.0056068203411996365, -0.048641324043273926, -0.04223860427737236, 0.03663032501935959, 0.025859210640192032, -0.010266939178109169, 0.0033814001362770796, -0.015547684393823147, 0.04157800227403641, -0.013545092195272446, 0.015818096697330475, -0.005935729015618563, 0.0501708909869194, 0.01573340967297554, -0.015185191296041012, -0.045528631657361984, 0.014875775203108788, -0.003905470483005047, 0.04846753180027008, -0.0037368484772741795, 0.03405565023422241, -0.021353311836719513, 0.031551387161016464, -0.06536158174276352, 0.005932150408625603, 0.060782741755247116, -0.021582288667559624, -0.007047347258776426, -0.03214120492339134, -0.060521043837070465, -0.008165841922163963, -0.02774331532418728, 0.005638489034026861, 0.04517946392297745, -0.02405688352882862, 0.012384774163365364, 0.019804462790489197, -0.013035569339990616, 0.02659565396606922, 0.004504517186433077, -0.008232695050537586, -0.03846301883459091, 0.03082835115492344, 0.0661337673664093, 0.025769254192709923, -0.007412032224237919, 0.010504629462957382, 0.0527886226773262, -0.0350194089114666, 0.0028115115128457546, -0.009214481338858604, 0.04423994570970535, -0.011355148628354073, 0.007240085396915674, -0.04279007762670517, 0.0011869483860209584, 0.02544374205172062, 0.034152910113334656, 0.03146844729781151, 0.03797542676329613, 0.00888423714786768, -0.03815574198961258, -0.025173811241984367, -0.026718486100435257, -0.07309272140264511, -0.003981779795140028, -0.04810749366879463, 0.028978433459997177, 0.009876854717731476, 0.02483191341161728, 0.0347415991127491, 0.056523457169532776, -0.005299340933561325, -0.02904674783349037, -0.014856288209557533, -0.025369694456458092, 0.03759606555104256, -0.04661998897790909, 0.016173673793673515, -0.014557353220880032, 0.060294121503829956, 0.03734199330210686, -0.012558315880596638, -0.011035584844648838, -0.02800426445901394, -0.039235301315784454, -0.01630815677344799, 0.001556512201204896, 0.04768827185034752, -0.028424516320228577, -0.02680620364844799, 0.05430400371551514, -0.051237769424915314, 0.04289485514163971, 0.04558643698692322, 0.035632938146591187, 0.023548191413283348, 0.008248255588114262, 0.01967347040772438, -0.05542545020580292, -0.005786886904388666, 0.06725988537073135, -0.08423132449388504, 0.002454523928463459, 0.017572306096553802, -0.07392780482769012, -0.021281758323311806, 0.00122443912550807, -0.01756954751908779, 0.0014478865778073668, -0.03515796735882759, -0.07616396248340607, 0.05261164903640747, 0.006484645884484053, -0.08040402829647064, 0.00973838847130537, 0.023892132565379143, -0.04503850266337395, 0.01060780044645071, -0.0084605123847723, -0.042534805834293365, -0.04176735877990723, 0.021722303703427315, -0.00819594506174326, -0.041132956743240356, -0.05089640989899635, 0.020114963874220848, 0.0686120092868805, -0.02179551124572754, 0.023359183222055435, 0.003465099260210991, -0.0018343982519581914, -0.014922148548066616, 0.011063950136303902, -0.03413616493344307, -0.0003684504481498152, -0.011475889943540096, -0.020701931789517403, -0.04923151060938835, -0.05459905043244362, 0.06929079443216324, -0.00798586755990982, -0.04140930995345116, 0.03629574179649353, 0.025468485429883003, 0.016508737578988075, 0.003302815370261669, -0.015255789272487164, 0.05066254734992981, 0.036917585879564285, -0.04149351269006729, -0.027904992923140526, -0.0027885420713573694, -0.045254554599523544, 0.028378792107105255, -0.008504451252520084, -0.02860487811267376, -0.02117481455206871, -0.0030998822767287493, -0.07518067955970764, 0.00140049634501338, -0.005777696147561073, 0.001145406742580235, 0.007390053477138281, 0.016284417361021042, -0.009291286580264568, 0.024527352303266525, -0.02345554530620575, 0.003911375999450684, 0.007018654141575098, 0.021829329431056976, 0.009012984111905098, 0.0042232307605445385, 0.0016209533205255866, -0.028111860156059265, 0.023066015914082527, -0.020857585594058037, 0.037799227982759476, -0.04804779216647148, -0.028874706476926804, -0.010604375042021275, 0.002910100854933262, 0.00799492560327053, 0.0058361440896987915, -0.03169533982872963, 0.011757474392652512, -0.026252083480358124, 0.033292319625616074, -0.01852235198020935, -0.07467512041330338, 0.02986025996506214, -0.053785327821969986, 0.0074447402730584145, -0.008587811142206192, -0.021036412566900253, -0.01723296567797661, -0.0022951404098421335, 0.00983694102615118, 0.04946736991405487, 0.00987192988395691, -0.00195326074026525, -0.0694514811038971, -0.013429118320345879, 0.013715250417590141, 0.01661721058189869, -0.059828020632267, -0.02577856369316578, 0.01858869008719921, -0.08020565658807755, -0.024328693747520447, -0.05098972097039223, -0.06162555143237114, -0.01462895143777132, -0.059286508709192276, 0.03197327256202698, 0.010752017609775066, -0.034690532833337784, -0.04820965602993965, -0.00712725892663002, 0.0077765402384102345, -0.04659854993224144, -0.016069890931248665, -0.0183874499052763, -0.060317084193229675, 0.006217419635504484, -0.07590212672948837, -0.04792347177863121, 0.04050825536251068, 0.05824030563235283, 0.029535263776779175, -0.012299287132918835, -0.020968414843082428, -0.05483047291636467, -0.015561138279736042, -0.04340752586722374, 0.030445516109466553, -0.0006771832122467458, 0.028052406385540962, 0.050978243350982666, -0.024634329602122307, -0.016750087961554527, 0.059184588491916656, 0.0066156876273453236, 0.03582874312996864, -0.026678455993533134, 0.06649068742990494, 0.00516277551651001, -0.005675717256963253, 0.04680218547582626, -0.037110183387994766, -0.0059294491074979305, -0.03771793842315674, 0.013957072980701923, -0.008848916739225388, -0.06377623975276947, 0.023465657606720924, -0.00466674380004406, 0.0030863292049616575, -0.01158967986702919, -0.009376266971230507, -0.06166723370552063, -0.023303907364606857, -0.04564475640654564, 0.0009027523337863386, 0.05910009890794754, -0.04031820967793465, 0.03797478973865509, -0.01660543493926525, -0.030182359740138054, 0.015856996178627014, 0.04507490620017052, 0.004577477928251028, 0.03763251379132271, 0.03633502870798111, -0.07904967665672302, 0.048703882843256, -0.0735686868429184, 0.06017475575208664, 0.0024115333799272776, -0.053448908030986786, 0.010265183635056019, 0.06140918284654617, -0.036439623683691025, 0.02603885903954506, -0.026715125888586044, -0.004707459360361099, -0.030395030975341797, -0.06913815438747406, -0.02950073778629303, -0.0054392097517848015, 0.0529077984392643, 0.019239481538534164, 0.019087249413132668, -0.00494461739435792, 0.07325871288776398, -0.03512171655893326, 0.01863248273730278, -0.03848285973072052, -0.016378335654735565, 0.051007963716983795, 0.05061459168791771, 0.012251561507582664, -0.0547906793653965, -0.07444470375776291, 0.018115846440196037, -0.03717414662241936, 0.018011460080742836, 0.06406548619270325, -0.022199908271431923, -0.07026389241218567, -0.02992401458323002, -0.04023496434092522, 0.03554781153798103, 0.035791292786598206, -0.02918030507862568, 0.03102240338921547, 0.02006552368402481, -0.01663951948285103, -0.06808899343013763 ]
Translation automation mechanisms and tools have been developed for several years to bring people who speak different languages together. A "new search only approach to machine translation" was adopted to tackle some of the slowness and inaccuracy of the other technologies. The idea is to develop a solution that, by indexing an incremental set of words that combine a certain semantic meaning, makes it possible to create a process of correspondence between their native language record and the language of translation. This research principle assumes that the vocabulary used in a given type of publication/document is relatively limited in terms of language style and word diversity, which enhances the greater effect of instantaneously and rigor in the translation process through the indexing process. A volume of electronic text documents where processed and loaded into a database, and analyzed and measured in order confirm the previous premise. Although the observed and projected metric values did not give encouraging results, it was possible to develop and make available a translation tool using this approach.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10526v1
[ 0.014418482780456543, -0.059691864997148514, 0.00146419124212116, -0.037143584340810776, -0.038974370807409286, 0.00826437957584858, -0.055715836584568024, -0.012928704731166363, -0.030398668721318245, 0.006425340194255114, -0.0703081339597702, 0.040349330753088, -0.025997621938586235, -0.025896670296788216, -0.04904695600271225, 0.009391500614583492, 0.06370767205953598, 0.012573623098433018, -0.0493285171687603, 0.035378046333789825, -0.03888546675443649, 0.012073745019733906, -0.04015275463461876, 0.03963477164506912, 0.04443669319152832, -0.026371587067842484, -0.05770863592624664, 0.027850857004523277, -0.016914067789912224, 0.043393824249506, 0.05683014169335365, -0.054518185555934906, -0.001079401932656765, -0.042275842279195786, -0.0609794557094574, -0.004305174574255943, -0.02621488645672798, -0.01138317584991455, -0.02460707165300846, -0.05882895737886429, 0.038144126534461975, -0.06043270602822304, -0.07140374183654785, 0.022907795384526253, -0.05594949051737785, -0.02905641682446003, -0.05457194522023201, -0.029037270694971085, -0.061909615993499756, -0.04562165588140488, -0.033334843814373016, 0.009417310357093811, -0.027359046041965485, 0.024806641042232513, 0.020178329199552536, -0.013556255958974361, -0.01894310489296913, 0.001018000184558332, -0.05822623521089554, -0.05408621206879616, 0.020719045773148537, -0.016342870891094208, -0.017155354842543602, 0.04554629325866699, -0.0194904413074255, 0.011891200207173824, -0.057796791195869446, -0.06446816027164459, -0.04955869913101196, -0.03974749892950058, 0.027350222691893578, -0.06287528574466705, 0.02617620676755905, 0.03620707616209984, 0.007171374745666981, -0.03914458677172661, -0.0066454606130719185, -0.049529511481523514, -0.032779183238744736, -0.020668240264058113, -0.029483435675501823, 0.05327111482620239, -0.028575479984283447, -0.002156242961063981, 0.01151786744594574, -0.027624882757663727, 0.041236069053411484, -0.04506974294781685, 0.002372279530391097, -0.03896737098693848, 0.04187111184000969, -0.029304618015885353, -0.07382901757955551, -0.0010092428419739008, 0.0736565962433815, -0.031102843582630157, 0.017830796539783478, 0.06431232392787933, 0.01391475647687912, -0.034608036279678345, -0.019621441140770912, -0.028467770665884018, -0.045753855258226395, 0.05453955754637718, 0.034860946238040924, -0.04220921918749809, -0.022534452378749847, -0.001127005205489695, -0.01587461307644844, -0.03409840166568756, -0.025208035483956337, -0.013325486332178116, -0.007851078175008297, -0.06698210537433624, -0.053852178156375885, -0.037895530462265015, 0.05007823184132576, -0.04559529945254326, -0.019287336617708206, -0.002695595845580101, -0.04717784747481346, 0.03609791770577431, 0.011998116038739681, 0.013635150156915188, -0.03914332389831543, -0.008412054739892483, 0.0629187524318695, -0.02554069645702839, -0.021572817116975784, 0.04415885731577873, -0.04903476685285568, 0.001944127376191318, -0.02626209147274494, -0.0238023791462183, 0.03114129602909088, 0.03964047133922577, -0.028581902384757996, -0.06013323739171028, 0.030291758477687836, 0.015803731977939606, -0.03221225365996361, -0.06506121158599854, 0.0024876357056200504, -0.04151894524693489, 0.033187299966812134, -0.013824522495269775, -0.04500435292720795, -0.02596714161336422, -0.01669449917972088, 0.013562815263867378, 0.028426766395568848, 0.00886810664087534, 0.002571713412180543, 0.024491002783179283, 0.029315877705812454, -0.026777004823088646, 0.003148712683469057, -0.011997426860034466, -0.054584577679634094, 0.0071572354063391685, 0.03476184606552124, -0.02107413485646248, 0.04601524770259857, -0.05929427966475487, -0.010381614789366722, 0.001637278706766665, 0.05401284620165825, -0.007651478052139282, -0.047147203236818314, 0.0299043171107769, 0.005437161773443222, 0.014632370322942734, 0.004546829033643007, -0.009791718795895576, -0.022110305726528168, 0.0014070620527490973, 0.0010351918172091246, -0.04402549937367439, -0.04136142134666443, -0.013616061769425869, -0.02854849584400654, 0.010795218870043755, -0.022072724997997284, -0.01575755886733532, -0.038085341453552246, -0.009153368882834911, -0.07414764910936356, -0.016513539478182793, 0.05205636844038963, 0.009671619161963463, -0.06094726547598839, -0.02230990305542946, -0.0019869201350957155, -0.031118353828787804, -0.03561423346400261, -0.02323923073709011, -0.0043965294025838375, -0.046250034123659134, 0.006071425508707762, 0.035275571048259735, -0.05544880032539368, -0.04733844846487045, -0.07376953959465027, -0.018160082399845123, -0.01173672266304493, -0.0719340592622757, -0.011512021534144878, 0.04998752847313881, -0.006473933346569538, -0.021667275577783585, 0.027528250589966774, 0.060391996055841446, 0.04731888696551323, 0.05140163004398346, 0.02516838349401951, 0.02174982987344265, -0.08162248879671097, 0.04422718286514282, -0.002995286602526903, 0.0034299136605113745, 0.015069459564983845, 0.02445516735315323, -0.014747596345841885, -0.04620208963751793, -0.010520301759243011, 0.029736215248703957, 0.021062729880213737, -0.03431805595755577, -0.06612572073936462, -0.06698503345251083, 0.004844795446842909, -0.03586031123995781, -0.034565944224596024, -0.059236761182546616, 0.002765851793810725, -0.03931264206767082, 0.0036676612216979265, 0.0016622573602944613, -0.0004449062398634851, -0.04954596981406212, -0.055748794227838516, -0.009479807689785957, 0.06873586773872375, 0.0032484016846865416, -0.04926247522234917, -0.04099706560373306, -0.019445879384875298, 0.026510359719395638, -0.050919100642204285, 0.007561300881206989, -0.03768309950828552, -0.03238650783896446, 0.0037077267188578844, -0.0273649450391531, 0.03954843804240227, 0.02790696732699871, -0.03617491573095322, 0.04325385019183159, 0.01935736835002899, 0.0023837557528167963, 0.02490692213177681, 0.03360150381922722, -0.05436546355485916, -0.02080189250409603, 0.03803567215800285, 0.006380476523190737, -0.002578227547928691, -0.001954640494659543, 0.0377296581864357, -0.020206458866596222, 0.029971273615956306, 0.04552869126200676, 0.0034279166720807552, 0.006060359999537468, -0.05379393696784973, -0.01913822814822197, -0.018314069136977196, 0.01858963444828987, 0.020820749923586845, 0.0351283922791481, -0.0008603568421676755, -0.013367502950131893, -0.000731592474039644, -0.07013305276632309, -0.01472561713308096, 0.010679097846150398, -0.03336860239505768, -0.04890909045934677, -0.059334222227334976, -0.048804327845573425, -0.05255540460348129, -0.03667423501610756, -0.022392746061086655, -0.04471735283732414, -0.021445319056510925, -0.05809009447693825, -0.023149942979216576, -0.05072133615612984, 0.0498846136033535, 0.011126291938126087, -0.03353257104754448, -0.02342362329363823, 0.011558635160326958, -0.02832491509616375, 0.010488058440387249, -0.04491898790001869, -0.018964333459734917, -0.04358965530991554, -0.00005943315409240313, -0.02551092766225338, 0.014440317638218403, 0.03139205276966095, -0.02316145971417427, 0.02701188437640667, 0.008808852173388004, -0.012852927669882774, 0.004659030120819807, -0.017733179032802582, -0.014449330046772957, -0.01367793045938015, -0.010735111311078072, -0.053518880158662796, -0.012186111882328987, -0.01625347137451172, -0.06284704059362411, -0.03592953085899353, 0.017691636458039284, -0.051903292536735535, -0.0033787230495363474, -0.06608590483665466, -0.008479670621454716, 0.011167239397764206, -0.03728187829256058, 0.009525866247713566, -0.03728972747921944, 0.027988774701952934, -0.018215076997876167, -0.05815037339925766, -0.045643389225006104, -0.04265587031841278, 0.010944829322397709, 0.0056945825926959515, -0.036231618374586105, -0.055397938936948776, 0.010189693421125412, -0.07514346390962601, 0.013253787532448769, 0.04760851338505745, 0.0632915124297142, -0.014267181046307087, 0.0038586959708482027, -0.010211433283984661, -0.04577554017305374, 0.021191557869315147, -0.027903050184249878, 0.02922486513853073, 0.04378823935985565, 0.0545368418097496, -0.033261608332395554, -0.010368477553129196, 0.024829760193824768, -0.06796562671661377, -0.04310063272714615, -0.023112528026103973, 0.020813534036278725, 0.0071408855728805065, 0.003525340463966131, -0.04662198945879936, -0.03683595359325409, -0.05803551524877548, 0.060305312275886536, 0.022718939930200577, -0.0590633824467659, 0.0103604169562459, -0.002861972898244858, 0.008425543084740639, 0.02613699994981289, -0.03430045396089554, -0.014646600931882858, -0.004674707539379597, -0.01478394865989685, -0.05782410129904747, 0.043459925800561905, -0.013431316241621971, -0.031074263155460358, 0.00712400721386075, 0.055563345551490784, -0.06240055710077286, 0.03462672606110573, -0.006985661573708057, -0.03181327134370804, -0.013104447163641453, -0.00354788382537663, -0.04916508495807648, -0.008610406890511513, -0.05482101067900658, 0.014275827445089817, 0.044588424265384674, 0.011629960499703884, -0.0021140570752322674, 0.01248636282980442, 0.016767922788858414, -0.038294509053230286, -0.07349351793527603, 0.04454100504517555, -0.06122728809714317, 0.04222411289811134, -0.03205639496445656, -0.06687024980783463, 0.045079994946718216, -0.03609197959303856, 0.0031389116775244474, -0.04432246834039688, 0.027191059663891792, -0.025037188082933426, -0.04232008010149002, 0.03210265561938286, -0.0682208463549614, 0.02702883630990982, -0.064918152987957, 0.06195935234427452, 0.022183110937476158, -0.0007585647981613874, -0.018203962594270706, -0.017797891050577164, -0.016470875591039658, 0.0016115488251671195, 0.0682358518242836, 0.04342655465006828, -0.034364841878414154, -0.056314438581466675, -0.02986329235136509, -0.014418691396713257, 0.0033225903753191233, -0.016451824456453323, 0.012208503670990467, 0.04808451607823372, -0.019649581983685493, 0.014576882123947144, -0.0028100679628551006, -0.028254788368940353, 0.04525035619735718, -0.04138468578457832, -0.033042825758457184, -0.007976718246936798, 0.03398985415697098, -0.048952870070934296, -0.07654882222414017, -0.023884981870651245, -0.048016730695962906, -0.06581537425518036, -0.031903788447380066, 0.037766750901937485, 0.03259021416306496, -0.02822648361325264, 0.02821901999413967, 0.05189133062958717, 0.04221280664205551, -0.019944308325648308, -0.035696256905794144, 0.04934784024953842, 0.0017942198319360614, -0.04195113852620125, 0.010857968591153622, -0.059111759066581726, -0.001961180241778493, -0.019652901217341423, 0.0014273258857429028, -0.013491528108716011, 0.02194914221763611, -0.008555236272513866, 0.05214405059814453, -0.0704561322927475, -0.0015439387643709779, 0.047604355961084366, -0.0318603552877903, 0.024466905742883682, 0.052922170609235764, -0.0049360631965100765, 0.029186125844717026, -0.06838494539260864, 0.005066823214292526, 0.01868916116654873, -0.055199798196554184, -0.024167973548173904, 0.0030407067388296127, -0.011481200344860554, -0.01740201748907566, 0.0373351164162159, -0.02255566604435444, -0.060222990810871124, -0.025824349373579025, 0.038652122020721436, 0.01879730634391308, -0.027017246931791306, 0.04012785106897354, 0.04714241623878479, -0.053890716284513474, -0.05076408386230469, -0.03754555061459541, -0.042767710983753204, -0.02960434928536415, 0.01630319468677044, -0.052675411105155945, -0.024174420163035393, 0.04226621985435486, 0.015675269067287445, 0.0055983830243349075, 0.002380719408392906, 0.009961452335119247, 0.016766013577580452, -0.05554945021867752, -0.009706425480544567, -0.047260697931051254, -0.014683817513287067, -0.05406094342470169, 0.04170246049761772, 0.04610137641429901, -0.029304563999176025, 0.03783461079001427, 0.0023823590017855167, -0.052625611424446106, -0.014613673090934753, -0.010885186493396759, -0.060399752110242844, 0.01636970229446888, 0.004959853366017342, 0.028775924816727638, -0.03007516823709011, 0.010269985534250736, 0.024885892868041992, 0.01867443136870861, -0.041412997990846634, 0.01493360660970211, -0.00011801407526945695, 0.021557852625846863, -0.025376994162797928, -0.0617818646132946, -0.02163262479007244, 0.06141076982021332, 0.03720586746931076, -0.0336364209651947, 0.0573713555932045, 0.003052368061617017, -0.03951946645975113, 0.014634707011282444, 0.008689289912581444, 0.009345956146717072, -0.023555733263492584, 0.017789481207728386, 0.05042191594839096, -0.04592185467481613, 0.03085276111960411, -0.03509746491909027, -0.0277914647012949, 0.016756635159254074, -0.017373036593198776, 0.035081904381513596, 0.02487766183912754, -0.009145241230726242, -0.06346327811479568, 0.06547436863183975, 0.025816095992922783, -0.06886187195777893, 0.016138548031449318, 0.010917655192315578, -0.05829315260052681, 0.012126972898840904, -0.0023201287258416414, 0.04726102203130722, -0.025347214192152023, 0.019293954595923424, -0.012940658256411552, -0.028916336596012115, -0.04469650611281395, 0.06359131634235382, 0.0776379331946373, -0.00012485218758229166, -0.014038928784430027, -0.030309105291962624, -0.06297080218791962, 0.006019617430865765, 0.008356872014701366, 0.029780305922031403, 0.002596645150333643, -0.017842821776866913, 0.02541789971292019, -0.04826259985566139, -0.05337708815932274, 0.06274886429309845, -0.048999179154634476, -0.006495203822851181, -0.02583162859082222, -0.001923873322084546, 0.07064254581928253, -0.022080479189753532, -0.03977137804031372, -0.02240900695323944, -0.03400500491261482, -0.009869529865682125, -0.035054340958595276, -0.062311384826898575, -0.05822296068072319, 0.03278419002890587, 0.019428366795182228, -0.06807856261730194, 0.036386143416166306, -0.027606237679719925, -0.0774615928530693, 0.0048362575471401215, -0.06164388358592987, -0.015126572921872139, 0.0024547278881073, -0.019534774124622345, -0.019563138484954834, 0.04764113575220108, -0.04535798728466034, 0.012656619772315025, 0.05457635596394539, -0.03300366550683975, 0.02842423878610134, -0.030049102380871773, 0.013872847892343998, -0.022985350340604782, 0.05369338393211365, -0.03866126388311386, -0.020759331062436104, -0.01512365322560072, -0.01815848797559738, 0.040887027978897095, -0.005815719719976187, -0.04122765734791756, -0.05135451629757881, 0.0406191349029541, 0.03208057954907417, -0.0033812914043664932, 0.016159219667315483, -0.014385020360350609, -0.031031949445605278, -0.006284813862293959, 0.013386949896812439, 0.012172237038612366, -0.04219707101583481, 0.028030473738908768, -0.004375068936496973, -0.01058906689286232, 0.021753259003162384, -0.056895218789577484, 0.02729985862970352, 0.04024116322398186, -0.05083952844142914, -0.01864718459546566, -0.013048832304775715, -0.053027089685201645, -0.030541710555553436, 0.011163265444338322, 0.017563557252287865, -0.05744560435414314, 0.0017753795254975557, 0.04899520054459572, 0.00532046752050519, 0.02862292155623436, -0.06725738942623138, -0.011830838397145271, 0.0074521503411233425, -0.03302670270204544, -0.06315627694129944, 0.014340827241539955, -0.0313161164522171, -0.038249969482421875, 0.006298104766756296, -0.04393336549401283, -0.02390376105904579, -0.03077450394630432, -0.0696212649345398, -0.002750745974481106, -0.030182702466845512, 0.05582751706242561, 0.026958979666233063, 0.0014336924068629742, 0.009426018223166466, -0.06008736789226532, 0.0401325449347496, -0.05271214619278908, -0.009288055822253227, 0.014202207326889038, 0.04120722413063049, 0.027205046266317368, -0.014673713594675064, 0.019473647698760033, 0.02473621256649494, -0.012587209232151508, 0.011508653871715069, -0.013231439515948296, 0.02367209456861019, 0.0013826482463628054, 0.03784571960568428, 0.02186219021677971, 0.007310038432478905, 0.0500648207962513, -0.05645319074392319, -0.03739159554243088, -0.04203984513878822, -0.04871410131454468, 0.01959119737148285, -0.040140796452760696, 0.020810117945075035, 0.04622795432806015, -0.03351455554366112, -0.009585907682776451, -0.006102206651121378, -0.04902946576476097, 0.05511321499943733, -0.052037712186574936, -0.05869527906179428, 0.06638258695602417, -0.0036189055535942316, -0.04519334435462952, -0.0515592023730278, 0.004803827963769436, -0.027398202568292618, 0.050411101430654526, 0.06342622637748718, -0.023999780416488647, -0.026952281594276428, -0.03741351515054703, 0.021042373031377792, -0.022264182567596436, 0.03035731613636017, -0.02469412051141262, 0.0534169040620327, -0.02718047983944416, -0.0277878250926733, -0.06284338980913162, -0.046819739043712616, -0.01155201904475689, -0.06756960600614548, -0.052543532103300095, -0.038145944476127625, -0.001324046985246241, -0.0055663022212684155, 0.04417567700147629, 0.01652844250202179, 0.04195372387766838, 0.03070308454334736, 0.04089697450399399, 0.04688047617673874, 0.025712164118885994, -0.011291435919702053, 0.01692950166761875, 0.043300025165081024, 0.035001061856746674, -0.012679717503488064, 0.02184107154607773, -0.00872974656522274, -0.017390331253409386, 0.02405635081231594, -0.0169089175760746, 0.0065124668180942535, -0.04078998044133186, 0.04910960793495178, 0.03595711290836334, 0.022283371537923813, -0.03682791814208031, -0.05047416687011719, -0.0036740631330758333, -0.039966464042663574, -0.05657234415411949 ]
Blind deconvolution over graphs involves using (observed) output graph signals to obtain both the inputs (sources) as well as the filter that drives (models) the graph diffusion process. This is an ill-posed problem that requires additional assumptions, such as the sources being sparse, to be solvable. This paper addresses the blind deconvolution problem in the presence of imperfect graph information, where the observed graph is a perturbed version of the (unknown) true graph. While not having perfect knowledge of the graph is arguably more the norm than the exception, the body of literature on this topic is relatively small. This is partly due to the fact that translating the uncertainty about the graph topology to standard graph signal processing tools (e.g. eigenvectors or polynomials of the graph) is a challenging endeavor. To address this limitation, we propose an optimization-based estimator that solves the blind identification in the vertex domain, aims at estimating the inverse of the generating filter, and accounts explicitly for additive graph perturbations. Preliminary numerical experiments showcase the effectiveness and potential of the proposed algorithm.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09063v1
[ -0.007338250055909157, -0.047226741909980774, 0.03643176704645157, 0.017918851226568222, -0.02159358747303486, 0.007621204946190119, -0.02708406001329422, 0.008842295035719872, -0.03511718288064003, 0.0028414269909262657, -0.06631822139024734, -0.019285986199975014, -0.028013741597533226, -0.04470452666282654, -0.048172030597925186, -0.011062202975153923, 0.07791434973478317, 0.014303497970104218, -0.04284248128533363, 0.06917576491832733, 0.013797183521091938, 0.03275352716445923, -0.04059874638915062, 0.04735022783279419, 0.04813716560602188, -0.0004357141151558608, -0.030257370322942734, 0.028054621070623398, -0.031911641359329224, -0.031174292787909508, 0.05390118807554245, -0.0431261844933033, -0.018550090491771698, -0.01807534322142601, -0.014850160107016563, 0.008605612441897392, -0.014952274970710278, -0.00268582277931273, 0.037919413298368454, -0.05863490700721741, 0.024275347590446472, -0.017904413864016533, -0.02155573107302189, 0.010029850527644157, -0.055439431220293045, -0.021302485838532448, -0.018955769017338753, 0.021704886108636856, -0.043067485094070435, -0.039619531482458115, 0.021785903722047806, -0.021512042731046677, -0.018293607980012894, 0.018555885180830956, -0.04519420117139816, -0.026675980538129807, -0.0010539822978898883, 0.03937255218625069, -0.04218147695064545, -0.020547637715935707, -0.009589320048689842, -0.014243646524846554, -0.03252565115690231, -0.030178803950548172, -0.025347527116537094, 0.057523589581251144, -0.006486483383923769, -0.05041978880763054, -0.03633003681898117, -0.01487161498516798, 0.047555387020111084, -0.06081461161375046, 0.015096241608262062, 0.03676125034689903, -0.04704458639025688, -0.0028876187279820442, -0.012844479642808437, -0.00609915517270565, -0.01979723572731018, 0.030909568071365356, -0.02094646915793419, 0.023775802925229073, 0.01353184599429369, 0.04300235956907272, -0.011760788969695568, 0.0042373319156467915, 0.029691526666283607, -0.012629611417651176, -0.011318909004330635, -0.052883222699165344, 0.04990587383508682, -0.03229836747050285, -0.050748370587825775, -0.022992407903075218, 0.05187142640352249, -0.021218707785010338, 0.04533236846327782, 0.02441227063536644, 0.00005424304254120216, -0.01587110385298729, -0.058485113084316254, -0.007725123316049576, -0.04513976350426674, 0.02051401324570179, 0.027035413309931755, -0.061570070683956146, -0.0025541894137859344, -0.04204907268285751, -0.03771740198135376, 0.028851768001914024, -0.02311868779361248, -0.018921658396720886, 0.002429785206913948, -0.07807276397943497, -0.029091963544487953, -0.03894980996847153, 0.07275644689798355, 0.007658842485398054, 0.04823994264006615, -0.003247240325435996, -0.03427817299962044, 0.024353845044970512, 0.03703365847468376, -0.0073240650817751884, -0.0286070816218853, -0.03200386464595795, 0.06919234991073608, -0.0054017179645597935, 0.010100525803864002, -0.036893267184495926, -0.04844522476196289, 0.020824238657951355, -0.01835792325437069, -0.02132088877260685, 0.04249594360589981, 0.0078366007655859, 0.013793068006634712, -0.05457264930009842, 0.031673770397901535, -0.010683056898415089, 0.027907157316803932, -0.05464336648583412, 0.052923303097486496, 0.008590408600866795, 0.018481450155377388, 0.0523853674530983, -0.04943350329995155, -0.049447834491729736, 0.025158295407891273, 0.0019007913069799542, -0.008675755001604557, 0.019899453967809677, 0.027231883257627487, 0.037733834236860275, 0.009511509910225868, 0.005173254758119583, 0.06601756811141968, 0.006063470151275396, 0.012344416230916977, 0.012844066135585308, 0.0051199039444327354, -0.00993155874311924, -0.02386813424527645, 0.0386032871901989, 0.030025597661733627, 0.00637658080086112, 0.042614344507455826, -0.02336541749536991, 0.0044851540587842464, 0.04249073565006256, -0.054832834750413895, 0.010910946875810623, 0.015468960627913475, -0.049286551773548126, -0.022954972460865974, 0.005895335227251053, -0.01828611083328724, -0.06838972121477127, -0.04517655819654465, 0.03365737572312355, 0.02300359681248665, 0.02464517578482628, -0.038591429591178894, -0.011583673767745495, -0.0284449253231287, 0.005583396181464195, -0.0913909450173378, -0.0074063693173229694, 0.012689488008618355, 0.04077213257551193, -0.05010681971907616, -0.04295835644006729, 0.018520435318350792, -0.0016420260071754456, -0.008679053746163845, -0.01703651063144207, 0.0034447775688022375, 0.03240145370364189, -0.037556882947683334, 0.02902980148792267, -0.08197194337844849, -0.04347407817840576, -0.06953514367341995, 0.03753089904785156, -0.038169704377651215, -0.060459062457084656, -0.018826382234692574, 0.017864495515823364, -0.034994009882211685, -0.0061272019520401955, 0.06325123459100723, 0.044407233595848083, 0.05219848081469536, 0.005556004121899605, 0.012241784483194351, 0.021431203931570053, -0.09839482605457306, 0.03186582773923874, -0.0004912656731903553, -0.03931858390569687, 0.022027667611837387, -0.033206257969141006, 0.006761677097529173, -0.04479241371154785, 0.006205800920724869, 0.057197798043489456, 0.05848553031682968, -0.012469667010009289, -0.047961004078388214, -0.046883415430784225, -0.03871851786971092, -0.05304146558046341, -0.022983770817518234, -0.052375007420778275, -0.01927732303738594, 0.011493689380586147, 0.006177190691232681, 0.01936342380940914, 0.007246010471135378, -0.036853939294815063, -0.05895986780524254, -0.02228628285229206, 0.06706032156944275, -0.006307069677859545, -0.03981299325823784, -0.046949759125709534, -0.039825357496738434, -0.003043167758733034, -0.03084377571940422, 0.032846447080373764, -0.041425760835409164, -0.07555992156267166, 0.011137458495795727, 0.014961360022425652, 0.013285311870276928, 0.0433511920273304, -0.03730860352516174, 0.00522851524874568, -0.023964423686265945, 0.054063525050878525, 0.0523071214556694, -0.0074291531927883625, -0.0412859283387661, 0.018087757751345634, 0.03942039608955383, 0.018733829259872437, -0.032158467918634415, 0.024077031761407852, 0.037100281566381454, -0.057180825620889664, -0.00575051037594676, 0.03156602010130882, 0.013423333875834942, -0.035198599100112915, -0.04129696637392044, 0.003032387001439929, -0.02120901271700859, -0.01418916042894125, 0.0422242246568203, 0.03943415358662605, 0.023951908573508263, 0.026941554620862007, -0.043231818825006485, -0.07654257863759995, -0.02633783221244812, -0.03761157765984535, 0.008886813186109066, -0.06814215332269669, -0.06360048055648804, -0.03560677543282509, -0.08700896054506302, -0.021135659888386726, -0.02441614493727684, -0.06509171426296234, -0.042151015251874924, -0.03892959654331207, -0.047584228217601776, 0.004367805551737547, 0.04168922081589699, -0.03698191046714783, -0.07028457522392273, -0.049350306391716, 0.05313614755868912, -0.004963552113622427, 0.019576698541641235, -0.04669143259525299, -0.062237367033958435, 0.036295704543590546, 0.02214248850941658, -0.005241051781922579, -0.009246940724551678, 0.026187753304839134, -0.028025923296809196, 0.05430298671126366, 0.003217658493667841, 0.03538743406534195, 0.012235211208462715, -0.015003394335508347, 0.008818731643259525, 0.013476215302944183, -0.018245099112391472, 0.029923850670456886, 0.008348590694367886, -0.039014436304569244, -0.05177710950374603, -0.015162767842411995, 0.03685752674937248, 0.006962263956665993, -0.018971092998981476, -0.058474570512771606, -0.024355700239539146, 0.02115526981651783, 0.03204374760389328, -0.039667073637247086, 0.005765477195382118, 0.05640609934926033, -0.01652228832244873, -0.049688126891851425, -0.0020699691958725452, -0.029518727213144302, 0.020018095150589943, 0.030491143465042114, -0.05974353477358818, -0.011352350935339928, 0.028779491782188416, -0.09391709417104721, 0.021945565938949585, 0.03988400474190712, 0.07394254952669144, -0.003911261912435293, 0.004694194067269564, 0.0020807606633752584, -0.015514745377004147, 0.013376056216657162, -0.014389346353709698, 0.03207051008939743, 0.0263255313038826, 0.06060938164591789, 0.007723338436335325, -0.07202181965112686, -0.0007916826289147139, -0.08616255223751068, -0.0323113352060318, 0.02483002282679081, 0.04233201593160629, 0.03924677520990372, 0.022863399237394333, -0.02100575901567936, 0.033577486872673035, 0.007260268088430166, 0.0686035007238388, 0.013125213794410229, -0.0274807121604681, 0.03568444028496742, -0.041058044880628586, 0.03916405141353607, 0.0225693192332983, -0.0016794775146991014, 0.03960838168859482, -0.04325534775853157, 0.0371103510260582, -0.060821402817964554, 0.05319489166140556, 0.03682347759604454, -0.009282461367547512, 0.05223725363612175, 0.02142159268260002, -0.013887419365346432, 0.059975337237119675, 0.004678715951740742, 0.0003883667814079672, 0.019828535616397858, 0.009436202235519886, 0.03452049940824509, 0.005180413834750652, -0.04912467300891876, 0.04555146396160126, 0.027273453772068024, -0.010901490226387978, -0.010965650901198387, 0.007592214271426201, -0.02000204659998417, -0.05065954104065895, -0.07803332060575485, 0.0347953662276268, -0.03733097016811371, 0.044043831527233124, -0.04804539307951927, -0.037612199783325195, 0.06062068045139313, -0.04053047299385071, -0.020588016137480736, -0.03687099367380142, -0.024080896750092506, -0.03299045190215111, -0.039182521402835846, -0.03362647816538811, -0.07876677811145782, 0.018263429403305054, -0.037644051015377045, 0.05450468137860298, 0.044921305030584335, 0.0031797282863408327, -0.023072805255651474, -0.028140820562839508, 0.009762106463313103, -0.019989388063549995, 0.05619611218571663, 0.030860185623168945, -0.02964881621301174, -0.003981640562415123, -0.039815571159124374, -0.022906610742211342, 0.008863951079547405, -0.049779925495386124, -0.05868842825293541, 0.030397169291973114, -0.01532407384365797, -0.024001795798540115, -0.05042385682463646, -0.005377047695219517, 0.06587665528059006, -0.03241919353604317, -0.03080189973115921, -0.004169237334281206, 0.021984227001667023, -0.061038289219141006, -0.07126257568597794, -0.024512579664587975, -0.02651793323457241, -0.0651177242398262, -0.013278926722705364, 0.0019399322336539626, -0.006166846491396427, -0.013691999018192291, 0.03410829231142998, 0.008839941583573818, 0.059047307819128036, -0.004416612908244133, 0.001215041265822947, 0.04704473540186882, -0.014706146903336048, 0.00023562759452033788, -0.052575819194316864, -0.07344348728656769, 0.01775204949080944, -0.035230886191129684, 0.005792703479528427, 0.005766300484538078, 0.03969487175345421, 0.02820194885134697, 0.07449635118246078, -0.06489576399326324, 0.006990897003561258, 0.06130235269665718, -0.010590165853500366, 0.005045628175139427, 0.06769119948148727, -0.0060575539246201515, 0.03519837558269501, -0.053942739963531494, 0.0170176699757576, 0.019156070426106453, -0.02625180408358574, 0.0489886999130249, -0.01994273066520691, -0.00745259178802371, -0.03378267213702202, 0.059655267745256424, -0.006902665831148624, -0.04600000008940697, 0.004098623525351286, 0.010870218276977539, -0.00584294181317091, -0.041830409318208694, 0.0171972569078207, 0.0507209375500679, 0.003748467657715082, -0.036206960678100586, -0.0032797830644994974, 0.0069933095946908, -0.0030606784857809544, 0.01760920323431492, -0.028459670022130013, -0.04476331174373627, 0.045927371829748154, -0.023146668449044228, 0.004205436911433935, 0.02965426631271839, 0.022509660571813583, 0.00423035491257906, -0.042772915214300156, 0.0086056562140584, -0.0545029379427433, 0.007811587769538164, -0.027966147288680077, 0.06310800462961197, 0.06624758988618851, 0.0300968699157238, -0.03740307316184044, -0.0035812132991850376, -0.040499478578567505, -0.0035331761464476585, -0.0172782763838768, 0.006040829233825207, 0.02886188216507435, -0.012559964321553707, 0.028008829802274704, 0.019449273124337196, 0.0545523539185524, 0.027364863082766533, 0.041779499500989914, -0.021880097687244415, 0.0017718643648549914, -0.026995254680514336, -0.012461070902645588, 0.0311112180352211, -0.0012796834344044328, -0.02603977732360363, 0.0051498692482709885, 0.04714412987232208, -0.005287548992782831, 0.03401654213666916, 0.038251761347055435, 0.008270706981420517, 0.0433826670050621, 0.006995758973062038, -0.0326312892138958, -0.06750857830047607, 0.03843732923269272, 0.06290548294782639, -0.04163176193833351, 0.015621201135218143, -0.005703369155526161, -0.061513565480709076, 0.016307594254612923, -0.04680095613002777, 0.06671375781297684, -0.01148952730000019, -0.01865958794951439, -0.02996167726814747, 0.005553452298045158, 0.01834132708609104, -0.05656895786523819, 0.02120836265385151, 0.03363831713795662, -0.07761115580797195, -0.01654045283794403, -0.004366280976682901, 0.03029903583228588, -0.017876971513032913, 0.046790968626737595, -0.040350690484046936, -0.045552920550107956, -0.07225900143384933, 0.07905634492635727, 0.08256641030311584, -0.06086859479546547, 0.02648160047829151, 0.036126624792814255, -0.03491955250501633, 0.020218487828969955, -0.008521892130374908, 0.028949936851859093, -0.04799396172165871, -0.0036325473338365555, -0.005609770305454731, -0.016140276566147804, -0.030970299616456032, 0.06520761549472809, -0.03237272799015045, -0.013929754495620728, 0.02734413929283619, -0.0021996619179844856, 0.0481778085231781, -0.03315361216664314, -0.04839503392577171, -0.008956050500273705, -0.0012526254868134856, -0.024042844772338867, -0.06710704416036606, -0.04703929275274277, -0.015570924617350101, 0.017984488978981972, -0.03216509893536568, -0.07610194385051727, 0.010863404721021652, -0.04915314540266991, -0.0489380843937397, 0.002836317289620638, -0.07053530961275101, 0.003536994569003582, -0.0037834467366337776, 0.023640226572752, 0.03143627569079399, 0.0701034665107727, -0.04685686528682709, -0.027535509318113327, 0.045729219913482666, 0.005587124265730381, -0.011991571635007858, -0.02733633667230606, 0.033372242003679276, -0.013714519329369068, 0.04996710270643234, -0.04598062485456467, 0.0030205801595002413, -0.029281560331583023, -0.011802400462329388, 0.027581553906202316, 0.02806439809501171, -0.07041829079389572, -0.02937740460038185, 0.032836947590112686, -0.02453695610165596, -0.028988631442189217, 0.025833172723650932, -0.019427098333835602, -0.06395892053842545, -0.0018496403936296701, -0.011910737492144108, 0.0002424217527732253, 0.036681171506643295, 0.06179323047399521, 0.05995151773095131, -0.02498692274093628, 0.029649686068296432, 0.03166370466351509, 0.04906214773654938, 0.02950461022555828, -0.04588984325528145, -0.02211206778883934, -0.012072865851223469, -0.03325168043375015, -0.01988527923822403, 0.008141488768160343, -0.02693796344101429, -0.06004169210791588, 0.017965443432331085, 0.05055119842290878, -0.00682270061224699, -0.012182783335447311, -0.03870008885860443, 0.009060997515916824, 0.014860405586659908, -0.03087960183620453, -0.06565841287374496, -0.015955490991473198, -0.013160157948732376, -0.0193439032882452, -0.0038743820041418076, -0.01735020987689495, -0.052524082362651825, 0.0013366714119911194, -0.08709923923015594, -0.012747270986437798, 0.011251653544604778, 0.0681036189198494, -0.007517288438975811, -0.03648673743009567, -0.006278048735111952, -0.00260588969103992, 0.017041891813278198, 0.01618262380361557, 0.002384084975346923, 0.03244372084736824, 0.031067103147506714, -0.01482758205384016, -0.02860790118575096, 0.0038070501759648323, 0.034681860357522964, 0.020065506920218468, 0.03198970481753349, -0.017647581174969673, 0.02268831990659237, -0.0018176904413849115, 0.01949225179851055, 0.06839150190353394, -0.029377607628703117, 0.04313218966126442, -0.05386631563305855, -0.007221990264952183, -0.030083509162068367, -0.06807634979486465, 0.04446912929415703, -0.01684500463306904, -0.006594028789550066, 0.005328568164259195, -0.009230917319655418, -0.017393430694937706, -0.003833655035123229, -0.06270387768745422, 0.05885278806090355, 0.0013211237965151668, -0.020128391683101654, 0.028972899541258812, -0.016319137066602707, -0.008858378045260906, 0.002684645354747772, 0.03143748641014099, -0.051649998873472214, 0.026636982336640358, 0.017846060916781425, -0.04355921223759651, 0.023260844871401787, -0.07602124661207199, 0.024200355634093285, -0.02110525220632553, -0.021768387407064438, 0.03125198185443878, 0.06395691633224487, -0.026582594960927963, -0.02199796587228775, -0.040440842509269714, -0.017865236848592758, -0.020290613174438477, -0.0707644522190094, -0.037361498922109604, -0.02198810875415802, 0.007727215066552162, -0.018011124804615974, 0.01726396195590496, -0.030800800770521164, 0.049013130366802216, 0.03641621395945549, 0.017992587760090828, 0.028559565544128418, 0.019245188683271408, -0.05837670713663101, 0.07368287444114685, 0.030183441936969757, -0.016341643407940865, -0.03351784497499466, -0.0032614278607070446, 0.005071773659437895, -0.032896265387535095, 0.020693298429250717, 0.006759576499462128, 0.017148584127426147, -0.0604591928422451, -0.011503002606332302, 0.03510069102048874, -0.0119809340685606, -0.0326269194483757, 0.016335809603333473, 0.009943981654942036, -0.034015826880931854, -0.04260610044002533 ]
The Gene Regulatory Network (GRN) of biological cells governs a number of key functionalities that enables them to adapt and survive through different environmental conditions. Close observation of the GRN shows that the structure and operational principles resembles an Artificial Neural Network (ANN), which can pave the way for the development of Biological Artificial Intelligence. In particular, a gene's transcription and translation process resembles a sigmoidal-like property based on transcription factor inputs. In this paper, we develop a mathematical model of gene-perceptron using a dual-layered transcription-translation chemical reaction model, enabling us to transform a GRN into a Gene Regulatory Neural Network (GRNN). We perform stability analysis for each gene-perceptron within the fully-connected GRNN sub network to determine temporal as well as stable concentration outputs that will result in reliable computing performance. We focus on a non-linear classifier application for the GRNN, where we analyzed generic multi-layer GRNNs as well as E.Coli GRNN that is derived from trans-omic experimental data. Our analysis found that varying the parameters of the chemical reactions can allow us shift the boundaries of the classification region, laying the platform for programmable GRNNs that suit diverse application requirements.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.04424v1
[ -0.004235741216689348, -0.011729899793863297, 0.06474404036998749, 0.01982024684548378, 0.017489764839410782, -0.02010948956012726, 0.017783615738153458, -0.010275174863636494, -0.0017585924360901117, -0.05187790095806122, -0.042045947164297104, 0.030481714755296707, -0.05837377533316612, -0.0661507174372673, -0.06829977035522461, 0.03931812569499016, 0.059878453612327576, 0.02359141781926155, -0.02605895884335041, 0.06304027140140533, 0.030293220654129982, -0.021323952823877335, -0.04668518528342247, 0.06241389364004135, 0.004294220358133316, 0.012359604239463806, 0.037450630217790604, -0.008467440493404865, -0.020085668191313744, -0.025191200897097588, 0.04419229179620743, -0.01899096928536892, 0.03680817037820816, 0.01699627935886383, -0.04738721251487732, -0.02443312294781208, -0.034382566809654236, 0.0654611885547638, 0.03159589320421219, -0.015076741576194763, -0.005947452504187822, -0.03130021318793297, -0.06267692893743515, -0.023877091705799103, -0.032829802483320236, -0.010682492516934872, -0.05363888293504715, -0.011884793639183044, -0.03370238095521927, -0.02441662922501564, 0.003173624165356159, -0.005826132837682962, 0.027403783053159714, 0.042321428656578064, -0.07014761865139008, 0.01848631165921688, -0.011949224397540092, 0.02765563130378723, -0.06997595727443695, -0.0024750023148953915, 0.007274979259818792, -0.034916024655103683, 0.012231457978487015, -0.012160582467913628, -0.05303134769201279, 0.044851645827293396, -0.02522934414446354, -0.07562200725078583, -0.031852658838033676, -0.06498556584119797, 0.03622175008058548, -0.060125112533569336, -0.0295045655220747, -0.0026951574254781008, -0.01633022353053093, -0.008055143058300018, -0.03822232410311699, 0.02799883298575878, 0.03239655867218971, -0.012746443971991539, -0.028611158952116966, 0.008517005480825901, 0.023351339623332024, 0.05257735028862953, 0.009571476839482784, -0.0104400385171175, 0.035817701369524, 0.02571878582239151, -0.03392934054136276, -0.007445976138114929, 0.04319079965353012, -0.007016134448349476, -0.06271488219499588, 0.021715901792049408, 0.056434765458106995, 0.009951441548764706, 0.041939135640859604, 0.045392803847789764, -0.004212773405015469, 0.016831792891025543, -0.029568450525403023, -0.01777425780892372, 0.017436964437365532, 0.06461578607559204, 0.009402326308190823, 0.011432219296693802, -0.0029568567406386137, 0.0008781604701653123, -0.07355762273073196, 0.03737566992640495, -0.011367358267307281, -0.0649685338139534, -0.018646420910954475, -0.06872396171092987, -0.05910106748342514, -0.014399132691323757, 0.019165899604558945, 0.00896021444350481, 0.025142954662442207, 0.024133404716849327, -0.04603978991508484, 0.013344783335924149, 0.003763761604204774, -0.006723555736243725, -0.0762120932340622, -0.020042547956109047, 0.07567469775676727, 0.03256969153881073, -0.007938651368021965, -0.0015312543837353587, -0.0017551388591527939, 0.005621396936476231, 0.00761193735525012, -0.050233885645866394, 0.07039372622966766, -0.045310769230127335, 0.009772056713700294, -0.06487583369016647, -0.015101720578968525, 0.030912987887859344, -0.04700839892029762, -0.04304113984107971, 0.02357906848192215, -0.011107776314020157, 0.04946080222725868, 0.05594835802912712, -0.06708990782499313, 0.0033497279509902, 0.004702617879956961, -0.006467784289270639, 0.006558207329362631, 0.009051292203366756, 0.011208686977624893, 0.027300791814923286, 0.029914531856775284, 0.0037108894903212786, 0.05881265178322792, -0.060267798602581024, -0.02134125679731369, -0.012549838051199913, 0.014814904890954494, -0.02733183093369007, -0.023801123723387718, -0.06295701116323471, -0.0047114999033510685, -0.011267564259469509, 0.015043807215988636, -0.05597264692187309, -0.006125247105956078, -0.022944649681448936, 0.004230177029967308, -0.0006853779195807874, 0.04400590434670448, -0.025916555896401405, -0.053015463054180145, -0.04165535047650337, 0.005182222928851843, -0.06881655007600784, -0.049418605864048004, 0.038960617035627365, -0.0006176503375172615, 0.04825279489159584, -0.030809078365564346, 0.009209316223859787, -0.06406065821647644, 0.015698488801717758, -0.08569865673780441, 0.022175757214426994, 0.0283177699893713, -0.010708540678024292, -0.030935367569327354, -0.06660448014736176, 0.04889696091413498, -0.007769965101033449, -0.07257591187953949, 0.006429444998502731, 0.004750492516905069, -0.05795574188232422, -0.0015387121820822358, 0.010961385443806648, -0.08103737235069275, -0.008883930742740631, -0.05534905195236206, -0.011779988184571266, 0.013947948813438416, -0.06951344013214111, 0.023337339982390404, 0.023438306525349617, -0.05441276729106903, 0.006016277242451906, 0.017832623794674873, 0.01625855267047882, 0.05584954842925072, -0.010167015716433525, 0.014078022912144661, -0.0056358263827860355, -0.09246828407049179, 0.042445145547389984, 0.024539204314351082, 0.030260151252150536, -0.003925686236470938, -0.0557466521859169, -0.015049455687403679, -0.03636346757411957, 0.03391696512699127, 0.027964694425463676, 0.0644693672657013, -0.0147944875061512, -0.024614471942186356, -0.04789501428604126, -0.007456211838871241, -0.049296677112579346, -0.037466052919626236, -0.07923661172389984, -0.032638244330883026, 0.00577748566865921, -0.021738549694418907, -0.0007472049910575151, -0.02504371665418148, -0.061863481998443604, -0.0519895926117897, -0.031811993569135666, 0.06648235768079758, -0.026939498260617256, -0.00046579178888350725, -0.05378381535410881, -0.040630850940942764, 0.05553478002548218, -0.0050350078381598, -0.013705798424780369, -0.01177302747964859, -0.04829208180308342, -0.03410959988832474, -0.03820532187819481, 0.024321308359503746, 0.010781923308968544, -0.03696635738015175, 0.06461570411920547, -0.014095538295805454, 0.06094491854310036, 0.05206288397312164, 0.03279837593436241, -0.060311879962682724, -0.01034696027636528, -0.01936403289437294, -0.024861715734004974, -0.042729757726192474, -0.029115749523043633, 0.042830053716897964, -0.034351836889982224, 0.030746230855584145, 0.018780281767249107, 0.05209368094801903, -0.05279915779829025, -0.053193047642707825, 0.049101971089839935, 0.020063234493136406, -0.0667799860239029, 0.025329746305942535, 0.01791457086801529, 0.03057894855737686, 0.046634968370199203, 0.012921755202114582, -0.07439202070236206, -0.016880415380001068, -0.023916997015476227, -0.0013653014320880175, -0.011959964409470558, -0.03472059592604637, -0.06673486530780792, -0.06676953285932541, -0.028173347935080528, -0.041427455842494965, -0.05245908722281456, -0.03131739795207977, -0.05231097340583801, -0.04339861124753952, -0.03498983383178711, -0.05170433968305588, -0.030470719560980797, -0.0329427570104599, -0.029174985364079475, 0.04476577788591385, 0.003922143951058388, -0.0025658856611698866, -0.050198595970869064, 0.008578304201364517, -0.028187917545437813, 0.002421591430902481, 0.028365761041641235, 0.009607207961380482, 0.0287745650857687, -0.017196180298924446, 0.014722105115652084, -0.035201963037252426, 0.019114911556243896, 0.03765181079506874, 0.0030222884379327297, -0.02880740538239479, -0.020062116906046867, 0.0025834867265075445, -0.02642383985221386, 0.01334115769714117, -0.008004686795175076, -0.057518914341926575, 0.004963159095495939, 0.02027811110019684, 0.012828311882913113, -0.04555276036262512, 0.00938214361667633, 0.0004978381330147386, 0.023626627400517464, 0.008329390548169613, -0.002874101512134075, 0.05573941767215729, 0.04159080982208252, -0.0020276904106140137, 0.03847773000597954, -0.0024222105275839567, 0.025050915777683258, 0.05555487051606178, 0.04718765243887901, -0.04269784316420555, -0.026700103655457497, 0.017591822892427444, -0.06066169962286949, -0.00042524890159256756, -0.03713790327310562, 0.017129942774772644, -0.05113634839653969, -0.017816202715039253, -0.003977556247264147, 0.030538443475961685, 0.038727957755327225, 0.005707624834030867, -0.0011643959442153573, 0.02969629503786564, 0.056501731276512146, -0.037292033433914185, 0.042930539697408676, -0.05396831035614014, -0.07450541853904724, -0.00527065247297287, 0.009809640236198902, 0.05832267180085182, 0.0668986365199089, -0.037974368780851364, -0.07056901603937149, 0.01419939287006855, -0.023392479866743088, 0.06417667865753174, 0.03365545719861984, -0.035217780619859695, 0.01195298321545124, -0.016175832599401474, 0.03296591341495514, 0.006105410400778055, 0.016826337203383446, -0.059002239257097244, -0.042547162622213364, -0.004600928630679846, -0.058830626308918, 0.021913712844252586, 0.023525653406977654, -0.018358757719397545, 0.0562099926173687, 0.027265947312116623, -0.025781773030757904, 0.03140755370259285, -0.0412197969853878, 0.017565816640853882, -0.0036112433299422264, -0.008368153125047684, -0.017989886924624443, 0.011310516856610775, -0.05959521234035492, 0.03518811613321304, 0.051404666155576706, -0.04739493876695633, 0.0016987989656627178, 0.012907532975077629, 0.04229489341378212, -0.038912441581487656, -0.07014107704162598, 0.018513396382331848, -0.03808990493416786, 0.030442696064710617, 0.016711359843611717, -0.020450646057724953, 0.030645346269011497, -0.01254738587886095, 0.011523187160491943, -0.049794912338256836, 0.004902748856693506, -0.03510314226150513, -0.009422623552381992, 0.03622305020689964, -0.060847874730825424, 0.021995408460497856, -0.046190518885850906, 0.05273467302322388, 0.00026603261358104646, 0.020750215277075768, -0.05139538273215294, -0.0006527482182718813, 0.016464432701468468, 0.04297220706939697, 0.05799250304698944, 0.043272409588098526, -0.01028833445161581, -0.001917243585921824, 0.00652323430404067, 0.025093119591474533, -0.010594124905765057, 0.009731641970574856, -0.042448971420526505, 0.029041510075330734, -0.022178001701831818, -0.05615291744470596, 0.0010282809380441904, -0.0013726605102419853, 0.03349008783698082, -0.054505378007888794, -0.015139186754822731, 0.01616005040705204, 0.02525388076901436, -0.005113817285746336, -0.042350754141807556, -0.026725344359874725, -0.045933954417705536, -0.06458791345357895, -0.03191892430186272, 0.03214558959007263, -0.0024626266676932573, -0.023988276720046997, -0.0032129923347383738, 0.007547678891569376, 0.023712405934929848, -0.01832600310444832, 0.01694503054022789, 0.017582520842552185, 0.022501114755868912, -0.017916062846779823, -0.010434514842927456, -0.03667883947491646, 0.008968038484454155, -0.03600570186972618, 0.02059261128306389, -0.018940838053822517, 0.027621539309620857, 0.0399073101580143, 0.05520012602210045, -0.06933800876140594, 0.027976805344223976, 0.0418112576007843, -0.0052267941646277905, 0.017072251066565514, 0.05332187935709953, -0.02264767698943615, 0.046497974544763565, -0.04274975135922432, -0.009328561834990978, 0.034640438854694366, -0.04525505006313324, 0.012726512737572193, 0.01885797083377838, -0.055374909192323685, 0.03397886082530022, 0.025595849379897118, -0.005001687910407782, -0.011000961996614933, 0.009462724439799786, 0.028527401387691498, 0.028693005442619324, -0.03346583992242813, 0.03753949701786041, 0.0467602014541626, -0.0367482453584671, -0.016109256073832512, 0.0019589904695749283, -0.00799710676074028, -0.007685336284339428, 0.026490988209843636, -0.02882866933941841, 0.005557369440793991, 0.035833097994327545, 0.005147451069205999, -0.018716394901275635, 0.025539487600326538, 0.02217261493206024, 0.03842252865433693, 0.021497352048754692, 0.019977962598204613, -0.060108017176389694, -0.021270208060741425, -0.061352238059043884, 0.03304659202694893, 0.016970375552773476, 0.02045864425599575, 0.010961922816932201, 0.02235807292163372, -0.04944288358092308, -0.005951560568064451, -0.040082838386297226, -0.004997859243303537, 0.05550073832273483, -0.06712326407432556, 0.04453171044588089, -0.02972453646361828, 0.056640271097421646, -0.011129401624202728, 0.03890514746308327, 0.01782369613647461, 0.01762251742184162, -0.0459609217941761, -0.03126731514930725, 0.015754587948322296, 0.01650063879787922, -0.04213763400912285, 0.0157893318682909, 0.014968707226216793, -0.0226866714656353, 0.015979472547769547, 0.023623108863830566, -0.012800822034478188, 0.010425778105854988, -0.007118881214410067, -0.025893105193972588, -0.029637571424245834, -0.005637806374579668, 0.08307666331529617, -0.06802479177713394, -0.003789813257753849, -0.04954878240823746, -0.058005642145872116, 0.022223273292183876, -0.05927469581365585, -0.015810033306479454, 0.04558587819337845, -0.03689102828502655, -0.06601687520742416, 0.027584955096244812, -0.006483251228928566, -0.06780436635017395, 0.0051812417805194855, 0.0032621456775814295, -0.06873512268066406, 0.025537755340337753, -0.007872623391449451, 0.020993106067180634, -0.07767196744680405, 0.0681336522102356, -0.016708875074982643, -0.004750508815050125, 0.0006411602953448892, 0.06634054332971573, 0.08341417461633682, -0.036773331463336945, -0.010809360072016716, 0.03943687677383423, 0.0070994263514876366, 0.017340965569019318, -0.019328707829117775, -0.03737206384539604, 0.03666367009282112, 0.03336738795042038, 0.00018215861928183585, -0.05478598177433014, 0.002698649652302265, 0.05498560518026352, -0.0058303168043494225, 0.0034499180037528276, 0.015094677917659283, -0.0001773320691427216, 0.01512784045189619, -0.0536004975438118, -0.03471386805176735, 0.002443287055939436, -0.00014506342995446175, -0.019918788224458694, -0.03862566128373146, -0.04981505870819092, -0.058913882821798325, 0.02530686929821968, -0.017661407589912415, -0.044534698128700256, -0.05804048478603363, -0.03557312488555908, -0.07042530179023743, 0.026861950755119324, -0.059612419456243515, -0.013431687839329243, -0.022172972559928894, 0.01276230625808239, 0.0210075993090868, 0.007659731898456812, -0.03885217383503914, -0.01280140969902277, -0.001150551368482411, 0.01600993610918522, 0.015687711536884308, -0.0286959707736969, -0.018255583941936493, 0.0020023458637297153, 0.048850737512111664, -0.05467160791158676, 0.005427630618214607, -0.003143331967294216, -0.05549494922161102, -0.03048722818493843, -0.00522322952747345, -0.016644984483718872, -0.03427989035844803, 0.041823577135801315, 0.003460395848378539, 0.04528278857469559, 0.02487373910844326, -0.015889765694737434, -0.05436798185110092, 0.03370725363492966, -0.008757481351494789, -0.002502324292436242, 0.0005019952659495175, -0.019867850467562675, 0.020457610487937927, -0.004903998225927353, 0.020898308604955673, -0.012029570527374744, 0.029384419322013855, 0.006959289312362671, -0.0375792570412159, -0.027727389708161354, 0.04536681994795799, -0.002951613627374172, -0.04525744542479515, -0.04255883768200874, -0.03697168081998825, -0.06489129364490509, -0.01994011178612709, 0.03385420888662338, -0.04326559230685234, -0.03530517965555191, -0.08149874955415726, 0.04056708514690399, 0.03784390538930893, -0.05546547472476959, -0.052752040326595306, -0.026462620124220848, -0.043086569756269455, -0.04435019567608833, -0.011014188639819622, 0.005346728954464197, -0.04321535676717758, 0.01998685486614704, -0.07816462218761444, 0.002461113501340151, 0.003972555976361036, 0.06426496058702469, -0.008105709217488766, -0.009204425849020481, -0.02473822981119156, -0.029091620817780495, 0.028694551438093185, 0.0337674506008625, 0.028412597253918648, 0.005408385768532753, 0.06396735459566116, 0.0032621854916214943, -0.047845374792814255, -0.06414946168661118, 0.05047684907913208, -0.055233635008335114, -0.011156820692121983, 0.016323477029800415, 0.036525774747133255, 0.07187473773956299, 0.019014308229088783, 0.06115356460213661, 0.026255980134010315, 0.0491071417927742, -0.021117115393280983, 0.00480749923735857, -0.058176297694444656, -0.0675271674990654, 0.013442502357065678, -0.042720939964056015, -0.01624830812215805, 0.06718016415834427, -0.027295976877212524, 0.00893295556306839, -0.037306737154722214, -0.055229268968105316, 0.04651390761137009, 0.02824452891945839, 0.0011747393291443586, 0.06798656284809113, -0.060565195977687836, -0.004963274113833904, 0.012570000253617764, -0.02299683913588524, -0.027134301140904427, -0.0012090278323739767, 0.023610714823007584, -0.027955321595072746, 0.0006177185568958521, -0.036981526762247086, 0.05801743268966675, 0.03946908563375473, 0.0066284011118113995, -0.024737486615777016, 0.07694219797849655, -0.011442105285823345, -0.009747073985636234, -0.04374757036566734, -0.018217870965600014, -0.011928170919418335, -0.05269376188516617, -0.023539019748568535, -0.040375322103500366, 0.03142320737242699, -0.016655748710036278, 0.004136731848120689, 0.009514042176306248, 0.04801611229777336, -0.012773272581398487, 0.0013290608767420053, -0.003010455286130309, 0.016031760722398758, -0.010489764623343945, 0.06461676210165024, -0.004500220064073801, 0.004789028316736221, -0.03742435574531555, 0.02635173499584198, -0.01593124307692051, 0.03472878411412239, -0.010545168071985245, 0.041734885424375534, 0.011785504408180714, -0.04240797087550163, 0.006386013701558113, 0.03522281348705292, 0.011187495663762093, -0.028940971940755844, 0.03005150519311428, 0.0016227558953687549, -0.018568459898233414, -0.06496236473321915 ]
Nonlinear optical effects including stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) and four-wave mixing (FWM) play an important role in microwave photonics, optical frequency combs, and quantum photonics. Harnessing SBS and FWM in a low-loss and versatile integrated platform would open the path to building large-scale Brillouin/Kerr-based photonic integrated circuits. In this letter, we investigate the Brillouin and Kerr properties of a low-index (n=1.513 @ 1550 nm) silicon oxynitride (SiON) platform. We observed, for the first time, backward SBS in SiON waveguides with a Brillouin gain coefficient of 0.3$\rm m^{-1}W^{-1}$, which can potentially be increased to 0.95$\rm m^{-1}W^{-1}$ by just tailoring the waveguide cross-section. We also performed FWM experiments in SiON rings and obtained the nonlinear parameter $\gamma$, of 0.02 $\rm m^{-1}W^{-1}$. Our results point to a low-loss and low-index photonic integrated platform that is both Brillouin and Kerr active.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13619v1
[ -0.03533962368965149, -0.007953132502734661, -0.01725630648434162, 0.01694379933178425, 0.005186223890632391, -0.029995935037732124, -0.028437010943889618, 0.011966886930167675, 0.011967472732067108, -0.0008547970792278647, 0.0012427226174622774, -0.05159139260649681, -0.031014716252684593, -0.031005272641777992, -0.0535462349653244, 0.024518068879842758, 0.04767068102955818, 0.019457949325442314, -0.05103025957942009, 0.07380934059619904, 0.031392164528369904, -0.04706927388906479, -0.043603330850601196, 0.028220485895872116, 0.007053132634609938, -0.007173305377364159, -0.01194063201546669, 0.0028577749617397785, -0.04220578446984291, -0.06136281415820122, 0.04243374615907669, 0.013765169307589531, -0.015863114967942238, 0.007487874943763018, 0.030981192365288734, 0.02853422798216343, -0.009587502107024193, 0.04102180153131485, 0.005699889734387398, -0.015274886973202229, 0.014739948324859142, -0.040721241384744644, -0.01519689243286848, -0.03771142289042473, -0.03460889309644699, -0.03328760713338852, -0.006731839384883642, -0.010968009941279888, -0.07004787772893906, -0.06721168756484985, 0.022392306476831436, 0.04355129599571228, 0.029169950634241104, 0.05314695090055466, -0.047062162309885025, 0.019078684970736504, 0.04517333582043648, -0.018482079729437828, -0.001802600221708417, 0.009523680433630943, 0.0296621136367321, -0.008963643573224545, 0.02245461568236351, -0.057507146149873734, -0.04338080435991287, 0.043023787438869476, -0.061907194554805756, -0.04749414324760437, -0.039482638239860535, -0.05413743853569031, -0.049120768904685974, -0.05298449099063873, 0.01099568884819746, -0.01799498312175274, -0.057528626173734665, -0.026145456358790398, -0.07135647535324097, -0.03473607450723648, 0.0010354829719290137, 0.04394270479679108, -0.03614775836467743, 0.010460127145051956, 0.037547655403614044, 0.00222217058762908, 0.02498629316687584, 0.025298291817307472, 0.03624784201383591, -0.034221261739730835, 0.02196888066828251, -0.05043739452958107, 0.030203910544514656, -0.04686616733670235, -0.05013583227992058, 0.04732372984290123, 0.05249117314815521, -0.015641165897250175, 0.058076802641153336, -0.013139592483639717, -0.009174100123345852, 0.041084520518779755, -0.007878636941313744, -0.03387743979692459, -0.015861181542277336, 0.04779613018035889, -0.013876707293093204, -0.041901595890522, -0.004228154197335243, -0.020613718777894974, -0.00268002157099545, 0.026901815086603165, -0.010886176489293575, -0.014206555671989918, -0.031022964045405388, -0.04362262412905693, -0.007128248922526836, -0.042193327099084854, 0.05984575301408768, -0.008441168814897537, -0.02100236713886261, -0.03850463405251503, -0.06411360949277878, 0.03707361966371536, 0.008769205771386623, -0.01325125340372324, 0.025073755532503128, 0.04781995341181755, 0.06020056828856468, 0.006111198104918003, -0.026412494480609894, -0.033605922013521194, -0.0023381065111607313, 0.02935750037431717, 0.026536930352449417, -0.015834692865610123, 0.030819691717624664, -0.026470690965652466, 0.014864424243569374, 0.002289897296577692, -0.024807296693325043, -0.009133742190897465, 0.005073780659586191, 0.004731182008981705, 0.02465762384235859, -0.02550639398396015, 0.03669161722064018, 0.011425090953707695, -0.06789891421794891, 0.03397577255964279, -0.001226638676598668, 0.04764994978904724, 0.002380859339609742, -0.02677001617848873, -0.02022051066160202, 0.00021761823154520243, -0.029304197058081627, -0.025575369596481323, 0.03596658259630203, 0.01841493882238865, -0.017856646329164505, 0.032020263373851776, -0.006621468346565962, -0.05280560255050659, 0.029420625418424606, -0.026232963427901268, 0.0017258995212614536, -0.013578048907220364, 0.03043443150818348, -0.005884541664272547, 0.04736141860485077, 0.04326402395963669, -0.07349330186843872, 0.03166203200817108, -0.02485833130776882, 0.0040354980155825615, -0.05067213997244835, -0.023972712457180023, -0.012140034697949886, -0.04738583415746689, -0.0019373353570699692, 0.021209577098488808, 0.025012999773025513, 0.02134098671376705, 0.02208036370575428, -0.015576723031699657, -0.05772313103079796, -0.017033789306879044, -0.07800140231847763, 0.004254590719938278, 0.027972575277090073, -0.043854210525751114, -0.061543822288513184, -0.07272729277610779, 0.031153246760368347, -0.0032139960676431656, -0.029400980100035667, 0.009714717976748943, -0.016998207196593285, -0.012172086164355278, -0.024385351687669754, 0.046697672456502914, -0.07184356451034546, 0.006310143042355776, -0.02904670685529709, 0.02189621701836586, 0.027292877435684204, -0.04932759702205658, 0.012100252322852612, 0.001281297649256885, -0.06146998330950737, -0.025185616686940193, -0.001023380900733173, -0.011609604582190514, 0.05366380885243416, 0.04991067945957184, -0.0006831481005065143, -0.0607093870639801, -0.09126812219619751, 0.058550335466861725, 0.04327535256743431, -0.03479672968387604, -0.0026308977976441383, -0.023827534168958664, -0.005110162775963545, -0.051520783454179764, -0.055506981909275055, -0.0016197809018194675, 0.060832906514406204, -0.040985092520713806, -0.05821884796023369, 0.04398367553949356, 0.007513559423387051, -0.03744736686348915, -0.07255537062883377, -0.07846424728631973, -0.022297030314803123, 0.02971752919256687, -0.043278127908706665, 0.02885073609650135, -0.011850165203213692, -0.041118670254945755, -0.06287286430597305, -0.019266121089458466, 0.03969966620206833, -0.01839398965239525, -0.017693448811769485, -0.05425797402858734, -0.0707935243844986, -0.020682446658611298, -0.06066674366593361, -0.030807774513959885, -0.022229598835110664, -0.03470117971301079, -0.035281892865896225, 0.019867800176143646, 0.030909733846783638, 0.04391205310821533, -0.0065335966646671295, 0.045905474573373795, -0.026411589235067368, -0.007184512447565794, 0.015498880296945572, 0.027113329619169235, -0.06432075798511505, 0.03112977184355259, -0.0014991366770118475, 0.01841147243976593, -0.07659407705068588, -0.04396253079175949, 0.005530661437660456, -0.008026746101677418, -0.059909697622060776, 0.044159580022096634, 0.035706792026758194, -0.0077822282910346985, 0.036625709384679794, -0.020722832530736923, -0.05163200944662094, -0.0007958707283250988, -0.016305450350046158, 0.003504481166601181, 0.07080058753490448, 0.02811010740697384, 0.000635614909697324, -0.04213818535208702, -0.02534157782793045, -0.06756849586963654, -0.006186195649206638, -0.06287243217229843, -0.058688484132289886, -0.040258318185806274, -0.032561469823122025, -0.008769315667450428, -0.03393321856856346, 0.001330069382674992, -0.018241170793771744, -0.05428965762257576, -0.0323844738304615, -0.0032208855263888836, 0.023466814309358597, -0.06102611497044563, -0.03207496553659439, 0.017583245411515236, 0.01966436579823494, 0.019646478816866875, -0.04447133094072342, 0.002605473157018423, -0.0625401958823204, 0.030602753162384033, 0.0310942642390728, -0.018686365336179733, -0.015028052031993866, 0.019750358536839485, -0.044058673083782196, 0.0023012764286249876, -0.02391381375491619, 0.05331337824463844, 0.04007168486714363, -0.06442232429981232, -0.018260430544614792, -0.07534866780042648, -0.05476570129394531, 0.004095031414180994, 0.008503361605107784, 0.04741847142577171, -0.05471237748861313, -0.018380630761384964, 0.06866074353456497, 0.06280666589736938, -0.012524724006652832, -0.054621025919914246, -0.06420665979385376, -0.04334787279367447, 0.015021739527583122, -0.025130528956651688, 0.0559915266931057, -0.017475295811891556, -0.04987185448408127, -0.021615859121084213, -0.03557455167174339, -0.004210773389786482, -0.03054034523665905, -0.02726660668849945, -0.024139389395713806, -0.02940402552485466, 0.034684572368860245, -0.07890630513429642, 0.007763266563415527, 0.061071593314409256, 0.0744812935590744, -0.024205906316637993, -0.012637483887374401, 0.01276598870754242, 0.013192531652748585, 0.046707071363925934, -0.01281004399061203, 0.02482193149626255, 0.03474646061658859, 0.03733539208769798, -0.016697637736797333, -0.022256286814808846, -0.014810171909630299, -0.024420760571956635, -0.016997119411826134, -0.033215463161468506, -0.030814534053206444, 0.013050970621407032, 0.06659365445375443, -0.03230167180299759, 0.003321313764899969, -0.04665084555745125, 0.0011246618814766407, -0.0004513103631325066, -0.05847571790218353, 0.03310561925172806, 0.0000029459729375957977, 0.04063763841986656, -0.05043303593993187, 0.006757325958460569, -0.001131521537899971, -0.06740610301494598, 0.010023443959653378, -0.06909820437431335, 0.03335891291499138, 0.010219641029834747, -0.017496922984719276, 0.022182224318385124, -0.005178390070796013, -0.00500135961920023, 0.03838961943984032, -0.026790618896484375, 0.002142271026968956, 0.003634336870163679, 0.006914434023201466, 0.00032556639052927494, -0.013588381931185722, 0.018387682735919952, 0.01076336670666933, 0.018581625074148178, 0.017149901017546654, 0.04571769759058952, 0.0669274777173996, 0.011350706219673157, -0.017941880971193314, -0.07221246510744095, -0.038737449795007706, -0.06578659266233444, -0.008339026011526585, 0.016256386414170265, -0.028665054589509964, 0.07096046954393387, -0.0029498660005629063, 0.005054597742855549, 0.0075530908070504665, 0.010148332454264164, -0.029749847948551178, -0.02317155711352825, -0.01215322408825159, -0.04156756401062012, -0.01029073167592287, -0.03869005665183067, 0.04752281308174133, 0.005573922768235207, -0.01865769736468792, -0.06816078722476959, 0.01759565994143486, -0.018511204048991203, -0.016642563045024872, -0.0003596541646402329, 0.013943328522145748, 0.036436811089515686, 0.0382135771214962, -0.006054761819541454, 0.005997274536639452, 0.009746278636157513, 0.05039140209555626, -0.06214596703648567, 0.0061110761016607285, -0.005489144008606672, -0.046415481716394424, 0.000844985363073647, -0.04331893473863602, 0.02584347315132618, -0.050703372806310654, -0.03352119028568268, 0.01244503166526556, 0.03442976623773575, -0.05049341917037964, -0.03386537730693817, -0.07331616431474686, -0.027384737506508827, -0.06673742085695267, -0.018457019701600075, 0.03397604450583458, -0.0036009058821946383, -0.03102005273103714, 0.031015582382678986, 0.05449322238564491, 0.036249592900276184, -0.04103738069534302, 0.020750615745782852, 0.04369402304291725, 0.0008810297003947198, -0.015519366599619389, -0.047421105206012726, -0.06310837715864182, -0.02197997458279133, 0.0038388457614928484, -0.01698482222855091, -0.020330199971795082, 0.015663010999560356, -0.06928504258394241, -0.019409190863370895, -0.08506772667169571, -0.018159519881010056, 0.05232487618923187, -0.024426821619272232, -0.0095529081299901, 0.024542445316910744, 0.0018882480217143893, 0.053239159286022186, -0.029435282573103905, 0.06173679977655411, -0.005810384638607502, -0.007166766095906496, -0.0352080762386322, -0.022588282823562622, -0.04855633154511452, -0.008195345290005207, 0.004015106242150068, 0.025315893813967705, -0.011041742749512196, 0.05185884237289429, 0.018513530492782593, -0.01833587884902954, 0.019382096827030182, 0.010722151026129723, 0.04349910840392113, -0.05719975754618645, -0.06214120239019394, 0.007196040824055672, -0.020280448719859123, 0.017796657979488373, 0.03152118995785713, -0.046631183475255966, -0.003759634681046009, -0.009359557181596756, 0.011211290024220943, 0.05535134673118591, 0.009211082011461258, 0.05405765771865845, -0.009235577657818794, -0.025323258712887764, -0.036808572709560394, -0.055627480149269104, -0.004536686465144157, -0.06091240420937538, 0.00483718141913414, -0.048865966498851776, 0.02952512539923191, 0.0443514846265316, 0.03147494047880173, -0.017775971442461014, -0.0315282829105854, -0.05075005069375038, -0.0681995376944542, 0.07474637776613235, -0.03470825031399727, 0.020804090425372124, 0.037250813096761703, 0.03398073837161064, -0.03915457800030708, -0.013133012689650059, -0.0405876450240612, 0.03417178615927696, -0.04910281300544739, -0.02172347530722618, 0.05676211044192314, -0.02752368524670601, -0.013508313335478306, -0.021251026540994644, -0.0034488141536712646, -0.0727260485291481, 0.05855510011315346, 0.02651818096637726, 0.008735418319702148, 0.045162297785282135, 0.01073823869228363, 0.014360792003571987, -0.0671616792678833, -0.0017057186923921108, 0.06735541671514511, -0.07702574133872986, -0.03257012739777565, -0.01134479884058237, -0.07506757229566574, 0.013370642438530922, -0.026060035452246666, -0.05482614412903786, 0.014845052734017372, -0.017143577337265015, -0.0711263045668602, 0.049190789461135864, 0.002662898739799857, -0.05948815122246742, 0.011643574573099613, 0.019001351669430733, -0.056246206164360046, 0.001419976819306612, 0.021296683698892593, -0.06432409584522247, -0.010621696710586548, -0.03616708517074585, -0.03833417594432831, -0.03142101690173149, -0.0037392459344118834, 0.03163060545921326, 0.060485582798719406, -0.039691224694252014, 0.032445576041936874, 0.0487297959625721, 0.022936703637242317, -0.0431516170501709, -0.007300472818315029, -0.04101640731096268, -0.038938816636800766, 0.008039518259465694, 0.011883934959769249, -0.030236678197979927, -0.025110553950071335, 0.011226996779441833, -0.012225651182234287, -0.0017295252764597535, -0.009380172938108444, 0.01351955533027649, 0.043492481112480164, -0.033925313502550125, 0.013093637302517891, -0.006402007769793272, -0.05172218009829521, -0.00829011294990778, -0.024977723136544228, 0.030507037416100502, -0.02408536709845066, 0.027844605967402458, 0.04078677296638489, -0.006694170646369457, -0.03226710483431816, -0.032347097992897034, -0.027626700699329376, -0.052783071994781494, -0.011377707123756409, -0.042336348444223404, 0.02191094122827053, 0.025098681449890137, 0.006687725428491831, 0.05786898359656334, -0.015822822228074074, -0.046723250299692154, -0.02376091480255127, -0.038617875427007675, 0.013233174569904804, 0.028958676382899284, 0.02053077705204487, -0.04371540993452072, 0.04329364374279976, -0.02082730643451214, 0.025224318727850914, 0.030643926933407784, -0.0541486032307148, 0.02011505328118801, -0.01901458576321602, -0.02262536995112896, -0.041755322366952896, -0.031846314668655396, -0.047271788120269775, 0.0042122118175029755, 0.015406384132802486, -0.015820922330021858, -0.07253170758485794, 0.01657346449792385, -0.011764366179704666, 0.0012807446764782071, 0.038485851138830185, 0.005393276922404766, 0.062896229326725, -0.009539282880723476, 0.03525123372673988, 0.027489395812153816, 0.009642217308282852, -0.0135507732629776, -0.04901155084371567, -0.03396498039364815, 0.06321336328983307, 0.024654019623994827, -0.050494659692049026, -0.019456231966614723, -0.020740395411849022, -0.06972294300794601, -0.007908537983894348, -0.01380980759859085, -0.03719722479581833, -0.011112806387245655, -0.07573817670345306, 0.05193646624684334, 0.03572983294725418, -0.05479492247104645, -0.07953798025846481, 0.014656731858849525, 0.029268082231283188, -0.03593672811985016, 0.042611025273799896, 0.0032411087304353714, -0.06365066021680832, -0.007682898547500372, -0.04238416627049446, -0.05622599646449089, 0.027415147051215172, 0.06917603313922882, 0.022604364901781082, 0.014097822830080986, -0.04727354645729065, -0.031762752681970596, 0.00023128798056859523, 0.054576482623815536, -0.009289002045989037, -0.022914273664355278, -0.01830228604376316, -0.025528505444526672, -0.048068586736917496, -0.008239438757300377, 0.05039988085627556, -0.049653101712465286, 0.016982119530439377, 0.01693539321422577, 0.040212955325841904, -0.010902420617640018, -0.010142790153622627, 0.06574999541044235, 0.010536269284784794, 0.03845769539475441, -0.052789364010095596, -0.026573268696665764, -0.035715747624635696, -0.02724650129675865, 0.005395484156906605, -0.07002551853656769, 0.025191590189933777, 0.0014279609313234687, -0.05499913543462753, 0.02446032129228115, -0.041410502046346664, -0.011629612185060978, -0.022874843329191208, 0.008248812519013882, -0.03473685309290886, 0.047222089022397995, -0.03178216516971588, -0.03175944462418556, -0.008409050293266773, 0.01477125659584999, -0.04997463896870613, -0.016696786507964134, 0.01114615984261036, -0.018234532326459885, -0.013129446655511856, -0.07878348231315613, 0.02589506283402443, -0.029094167053699493, 0.039403483271598816, 0.027100352570414543, 0.05789415165781975, -0.031266551464796066, -0.00981996301561594, -0.024698272347450256, 0.035522762686014175, 0.03743823617696762, -0.03607531636953354, 0.005533542018383741, 0.027419032528996468, 0.01680513098835945, 0.014198443852365017, -0.004275412764400244, -0.043333105742931366, 0.053125400096178055, 0.029818175360560417, -0.010253123007714748, -0.01389244943857193, -0.024677038192749023, 0.023464465513825417, 0.03325868025422096, -0.019493743777275085, -0.01523030735552311, -0.041001107543706894, 0.033489737659692764, -0.0332668237388134, 0.06004912033677101, -0.03667886555194855, 0.021753517910838127, -0.01313964556902647, -0.031232181936502457, -0.027346258983016014, 0.036216557025909424, -0.0017507312586531043, -0.03439197689294815, -0.006828215438872576, 0.030629029497504234, -0.036713071167469025, -0.056603237986564636 ]
We introduce a new neural architecture for solving visual abstract reasoning tasks inspired by human cognition, specifically by observations that human abstract reasoning often interleaves perceptual and conceptual processing as part of a flexible, iterative, and dynamic cognitive process. Inspired by this principle, our architecture models visual abstract reasoning as an iterative, self-contrasting learning process that pursues consistency between perceptual and conceptual processing of visual stimuli. We explain how this new Contrastive Perceptual-Conceptual Network (CPCNet) works using matrix reasoning problems in the style of the well-known Raven's Progressive Matrices intelligence test. Experiments on the machine learning dataset RAVEN show that CPCNet achieves higher accuracy than all previously published models while also using the weakest inductive bias. We also point out a substantial and previously unremarked class imbalance in the original RAVEN dataset, and we propose a new variant of RAVEN -- AB-RAVEN -- that is more balanced in terms of abstract concepts.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10532v3
[ -0.004505222663283348, 0.02901529334485531, 0.03027934767305851, 0.022480955347418785, -0.001118675572797656, -0.04932872951030731, -0.030031703412532806, -0.029259391129016876, -0.05032980814576149, -0.05512150377035141, -0.049367960542440414, 0.005526668857783079, -0.03708069398999214, -0.0543503537774086, -0.039023257791996, -0.01863647811114788, 0.06925874948501587, 0.016354190185666084, -0.04998975247144699, 0.06974515318870544, 0.014224620535969734, -0.041446223855018616, -0.037525199353694916, 0.05347852781414986, 0.015635479241609573, -0.0304749496281147, -0.033419352024793625, 0.03232882544398308, -0.02113211527466774, -0.017135316506028175, 0.07611209899187088, -0.044416286051273346, -0.03641776740550995, -0.031881533563137054, -0.040093161165714264, -0.015422457829117775, 0.014900874346494675, 0.014258754439651966, 0.03822765126824379, -0.03032093308866024, 0.004314684774726629, -0.03771862015128136, -0.07739477604627609, -0.02370869740843773, -0.020759722217917442, -0.021419323980808258, -0.04716518148779869, 0.01682036742568016, -0.0725727304816246, -0.037142954766750336, 0.03676935285329819, -0.003853581612929702, -0.002832324942573905, 0.01909802481532097, -0.06218094006180763, -0.017125971615314484, -0.04609062895178795, 0.04335969686508179, -0.054842181503772736, -0.01664181426167488, -0.03809140622615814, -0.04000313952565193, -0.02004365064203739, -0.01895941235125065, 0.03960511460900307, 0.04956554248929024, -0.03829818591475487, -0.0632256343960762, -0.01322308462113142, -0.013302842155098915, 0.06848550587892532, -0.06541388481855392, 0.014097052626311779, -0.018588725477457047, -0.008016164414584637, -0.0021907230839133263, 0.0018827110761776567, -0.059622641652822495, 0.04878878965973854, 0.016025030985474586, -0.02370322495698929, 0.01619253121316433, 0.024345610290765762, 0.02684858627617359, -0.04465605691075325, -0.03464393690228462, 0.04022428020834923, -0.008033388294279575, -0.00798074435442686, -0.047168418765068054, 0.06143340840935707, -0.0014031300088390708, -0.04903694987297058, -0.003995448350906372, 0.050977159291505814, -0.026379937306046486, -0.00726680550724268, 0.05025505647063255, -0.004738731309771538, 0.001217189710587263, -0.015429763123393059, -0.023062022402882576, -0.016198137775063515, 0.03677336126565933, 0.03873535245656967, 0.0023165636230260134, -0.01241315808147192, 0.006686065811663866, -0.04528674855828285, 0.024261655285954475, -0.043728310614824295, -0.027382735162973404, -0.00028718492831103504, -0.03875507786870003, -0.06518669426441193, -0.04616213217377663, 0.057546231895685196, 0.025750666856765747, -0.011445264331996441, -0.009348933584988117, -0.05742461979389191, 0.049784980714321136, 0.022158155217766762, -0.02239026129245758, -0.03178185969591141, -0.037803322076797485, 0.05152542516589165, 0.03843950480222702, 0.008551357313990593, -0.02939826250076294, -0.03261084482073784, 0.049582090228796005, -0.051757097244262695, -0.009434821084141731, 0.06526979804039001, -0.05281748250126839, -0.02618653140962124, -0.0589248426258564, 0.03481065481901169, -0.00788306538015604, -0.04223613068461418, -0.013220603577792645, 0.03928098827600479, -0.020015589892864227, 0.011479346081614494, 0.06725472956895828, -0.05158237740397453, -0.026565633714199066, -0.02971455454826355, 0.015552544966340065, 0.004927156493067741, 0.024076595902442932, 0.0336482860147953, 0.03190740942955017, 0.016270341351628304, 0.00528539577499032, 0.06817995756864548, -0.011168808676302433, -0.03326306864619255, 0.006744383368641138, 0.013799861073493958, -0.0368804931640625, 0.0031426982022821903, -0.05557636171579361, -0.011994061060249805, -0.010529537685215473, 0.026237763464450836, 0.008303877897560596, -0.014108366332948208, 0.00532683078199625, -0.03861326724290848, 0.023455938324332237, 0.04079371318221092, 0.0070944055914878845, -0.07619136571884155, -0.010470105335116386, -0.03702611103653908, -0.060952719300985336, -0.031211333349347115, 0.004661626648157835, 0.037681370973587036, -0.010259809903800488, -0.03091951087117195, 0.03232613205909729, -0.022477691993117332, 0.0024008045438677073, -0.07584308832883835, -0.023681730031967163, 0.03264069929718971, 0.029960574582219124, -0.016027377918362617, -0.04684610292315483, 0.05156305059790611, 0.030718358233571053, -0.05472613498568535, -0.02945220284163952, -0.007932426407933235, -0.01987689733505249, 0.0019860255997627974, 0.0342787504196167, -0.08384343981742859, -0.011302080936729908, -0.04581049829721451, -0.004211648367345333, 0.023838263005018234, -0.07334773242473602, 0.03158394992351532, 0.02429613098502159, -0.02504146285355091, -0.031839046627283096, 0.030543159693479538, 0.012951369397342205, 0.0625862404704094, 0.0243737380951643, 0.016592713072896004, 0.033036623150110245, -0.09567112475633621, 0.045936066657304764, 0.01672982983291149, 0.044470444321632385, 0.041247643530368805, 0.008723859675228596, 0.010766574181616306, 0.008677981793880463, -0.04087642952799797, 0.018215568736195564, 0.015067321248352528, 0.01697864569723606, -0.02125030942261219, -0.031497772783041, -0.021864809095859528, -0.05415992811322212, -0.038479018956422806, -0.07460076361894608, -0.04750010743737221, 0.04722025245428085, -0.06314417719841003, 0.056207116693258286, -0.004207379184663296, -0.06479505449533463, -0.05282022804021835, -0.049951694905757904, 0.03631508722901344, -0.028483377769589424, -0.05484163016080856, -0.017654187977313995, 0.007865489460527897, 0.018242986872792244, -0.02611677534878254, -0.02552890218794346, -0.02524660900235176, -0.05689779669046402, -0.017437057569622993, -0.05708470195531845, 0.02118406631052494, 0.03941617161035538, -0.005516852717846632, 0.0066917031072080135, -0.028547614812850952, 0.041937485337257385, 0.013027573935687542, 0.04885472357273102, -0.03427514061331749, 0.029001722112298012, 0.045746639370918274, -0.028002865612506866, 0.009483578614890575, -0.0132999736815691, 0.05516346916556358, -0.05438090115785599, 0.0171809121966362, 0.03260834515094757, 0.0018504576291888952, 0.017003092914819717, -0.05297404155135155, -0.015297449193894863, -0.00037440212327055633, -0.058638762682676315, 0.021008413285017014, 0.049414489418268204, 0.014787647873163223, 0.015969395637512207, 0.007538589183241129, -0.07663734257221222, -0.013783357106149197, -0.012166171334683895, -0.03306443616747856, -0.022767361253499985, -0.03732363134622574, -0.01221218891441822, -0.07418248802423477, -0.03184492513537407, -0.010349222458899021, -0.023991594091057777, -0.042868971824645996, -0.05663143843412399, 0.0015481049194931984, -0.027271252125501633, 0.023236578330397606, -0.042157627642154694, -0.016921449452638626, -0.041118983179330826, -0.02807694859802723, 0.025495510548353195, -0.004236417356878519, -0.08386372774839401, -0.02449069544672966, 0.0032407473772764206, 0.0032981084659695625, 0.041199322789907455, -0.018791597336530685, 0.037484534084796906, 0.006313104648143053, 0.022182989865541458, -0.009265256114304066, 0.007291717920452356, -0.007775997277349234, -0.01918267272412777, 0.030471747741103172, -0.05041336268186569, -0.0180385522544384, 0.010484562255442142, 0.0018353116465732455, -0.03781648352742195, -0.044596102088689804, -0.031293030828237534, 0.06630703806877136, 0.024211937561631203, -0.022644011303782463, -0.057577528059482574, 0.0027568754740059376, -0.016747549176216125, 0.04226464405655861, 0.033119700849056244, 0.009739325381815434, 0.02032555267214775, 0.0015807806048542261, -0.019683493301272392, -0.043319422751665115, 0.01037449948489666, -0.03926810622215271, 0.01528692152351141, -0.05222813040018082, 0.034438956528902054, 0.0044658905826509, -0.09107817709445953, 0.012549426406621933, 0.0005205750348977745, 0.05047865957021713, -0.028290880843997, 0.0013867354718968272, 0.05484351888298988, 0.03835584595799446, -0.008345968089997768, -0.014689605683088303, 0.015019788406789303, 0.04950713738799095, 0.06311634182929993, -0.04007740318775177, -0.012000588700175285, 0.0010728940833359957, -0.059043657034635544, -0.06198049336671829, 0.008600900880992413, 0.053785040974617004, 0.01003759354352951, 0.02280835434794426, -0.04809582233428955, 0.0034342112485319376, -0.006249512080103159, 0.0355115570127964, -0.04157458245754242, -0.008011937141418457, 0.0065827155485749245, -0.03803611546754837, 0.030398612841963768, -0.00008464504207950085, 0.013614419847726822, -0.045251086354255676, -0.028503602370619774, -0.013865885324776173, -0.0594761036336422, 0.03368105739355087, -0.013854240998625755, -0.023018907755613327, 0.019752394407987595, 0.009899460710585117, -0.03194640949368477, 0.06877987831830978, -0.0038616766687482595, 0.00870590191334486, -0.014815280213952065, 0.013937514275312424, -0.025958891957998276, -0.004119953606277704, -0.047700319439172745, 0.0031030578538775444, -0.012017471715807915, -0.01924031600356102, -0.04263680800795555, -0.033562980592250824, 0.017764195799827576, -0.036847684532403946, -0.08948146551847458, -0.013166828081011772, -0.020713720470666885, 0.013376925140619278, -0.005345317535102367, -0.05928312987089157, 0.06370295584201813, -0.016251441091299057, -0.017921894788742065, -0.0224690530449152, -0.012074408121407032, -0.05023010075092316, -0.041929833590984344, -0.0066956691443920135, -0.07738423347473145, 0.025396250188350677, -0.030811671167612076, 0.007386273704469204, 0.024625495076179504, 0.034707676619291306, -0.0656476765871048, -0.04391133412718773, -0.011230958625674248, 0.03480882942676544, 0.06626369804143906, 0.03430650383234024, 0.008070793934166431, -0.029538080096244812, 0.04368475079536438, 0.0005898952949792147, 0.0328812301158905, -0.024199772626161575, -0.031273238360881805, 0.07253056019544601, -0.02138957753777504, -0.029295535758137703, -0.012993277050554752, -0.02939685434103012, 0.036360692232847214, -0.04598737135529518, -0.021422797814011574, 0.005681093316525221, 0.035135626792907715, -0.049884263426065445, -0.06530455499887466, -0.03426753357052803, -0.05160984769463539, -0.04652949050068855, -0.02448250912129879, 0.03649163618683815, 0.00045773308374918997, -0.011541296727955341, 0.01598767563700676, 0.018550703302025795, 0.016374748200178146, -0.01052119955420494, 0.02768898382782936, 0.05216001719236374, -0.0016842809272930026, 0.027514217421412468, -0.018538648262619972, -0.07756566256284714, -0.011147631332278252, -0.026399588212370872, -0.00273774447850883, -0.011649689637124538, 0.05725906789302826, 0.011971616186201572, 0.0268202293664217, -0.09203183650970459, 0.007153455633670092, 0.02265167236328125, -0.01023012213408947, 0.023088455200195312, 0.047187674790620804, -0.04149457439780235, 0.013191900216042995, -0.007503120228648186, -0.029191141948103905, 0.033150698989629745, -0.0073506832122802734, 0.003359123133122921, -0.020866485312581062, -0.04091769829392433, 0.013885768130421638, 0.019036587327718735, -0.028561392799019814, -0.05256379395723343, -0.00114188261795789, 0.040126293897628784, 0.05870022624731064, -0.0007209978648461401, 0.019951999187469482, 0.036194153130054474, -0.031197799369692802, -0.002724620746448636, -0.05710182711482048, -0.03012142889201641, -0.013798771426081657, 0.0016175139462575316, -0.015573853626847267, -0.015896717086434364, 0.040988676249980927, 0.014348710887134075, -0.02423323318362236, -0.00001621258707018569, 0.040346257388591766, -0.002359068486839533, -0.030800646170973778, 0.043295200914144516, -0.07226445525884628, -0.012135539203882217, -0.0552545040845871, 0.044588834047317505, 0.02511589787900448, 0.043403416872024536, 0.02377915196120739, 0.03344472497701645, -0.009044807404279709, -0.034933071583509445, 0.0235554538667202, -0.01844344474375248, 0.038834381848573685, -0.04479154571890831, 0.0361441932618618, -0.004144084174185991, 0.04480186477303505, 0.004922255873680115, 0.05734959617257118, 0.007483502849936485, -0.0102866655215621, 0.011034191586077213, -0.02508831024169922, 0.005684968084096909, -0.07092618942260742, -0.03057110495865345, 0.006820680573582649, -0.0003523837949614972, 0.001847582752816379, 0.05075744912028313, 0.03930297866463661, 0.001500826794654131, 0.023214146494865417, 0.013403955847024918, -0.011854948475956917, -0.06279994547367096, -0.03320394828915596, 0.0798046886920929, -0.0552518405020237, -0.02117096446454525, -0.0037904561031609774, -0.05876815319061279, 0.002083410043269396, -0.03933845832943916, 0.02720375917851925, 0.020370204001665115, 0.004821917042136192, -0.06021466851234436, 0.0375048890709877, -0.021100373938679695, -0.07947856187820435, -0.0015805207658559084, 0.03658659756183624, -0.07082481682300568, 0.012086398899555206, 0.03577793762087822, 0.015987902879714966, -0.0629439651966095, 0.03513277322053909, 0.06106700375676155, -0.013790507800877094, -0.05104520916938782, 0.07409019768238068, 0.08666962385177612, -0.02174048125743866, 0.013477819971740246, -0.002812891500070691, -0.04482844099402428, 0.021522212773561478, -0.041950490325689316, -0.03882857412099838, -0.041151341050863266, 0.02257351018488407, 0.0032230501528829336, -0.061546389013528824, -0.02806723490357399, 0.08170276135206223, 0.003811587579548359, 0.005524097476154566, -0.026182949542999268, 0.005208487622439861, 0.05881122872233391, -0.046628378331661224, -0.03459645435214043, -0.005071705207228661, -0.038620151579380035, -0.030018124729394913, -0.030499495565891266, -0.022414421662688255, -0.022844096645712852, 0.046415288001298904, -0.032940976321697235, -0.04279167205095291, -0.003297921735793352, -0.03521440923213959, -0.0645739734172821, 0.0319625660777092, -0.05443497747182846, 0.02350170910358429, -0.007854892872273922, -0.026010731235146523, -0.0195457860827446, 0.014545845799148083, -0.011121256276965141, -0.00032069042208604515, -0.01745167002081871, 0.01225763838738203, 0.01738453097641468, -0.04188023507595062, 0.031477976590394974, 0.0027286296244710684, 0.02449757605791092, -0.04993334785103798, 0.0008655547280795872, -0.02999858558177948, -0.04959464818239212, -0.0011972896754741669, -0.002015093108639121, -0.007862737402319908, -0.05704616382718086, -0.00135105662047863, 0.022374048829078674, 0.0264465119689703, 0.033712804317474365, -0.0032678483985364437, -0.04808011278510094, 0.05421524867415428, 0.00916836317628622, -0.00622281851246953, -0.028487691655755043, -0.009943258948624134, 0.0075747244991362095, 0.011353649199008942, 0.009829924441874027, 0.05537593737244606, 0.0019349950598552823, 0.01025722548365593, -0.07470110803842545, -0.008976985700428486, 0.02722560428082943, -0.037906959652900696, -0.070022813975811, -0.005846337880939245, -0.012302306480705738, -0.07567165791988373, -0.014259247109293938, 0.032249078154563904, 0.024926066398620605, 0.0009973678970709443, -0.07705318927764893, 0.033066973090171814, 0.015213812701404095, -0.06322915852069855, -0.011007803492248058, 0.039598554372787476, -0.017351465299725533, -0.038486551493406296, 0.014790087938308716, -0.012978768907487392, -0.04780440777540207, 0.006685853470116854, -0.09155009686946869, 0.006229636259377003, -0.011758493259549141, 0.042054977267980576, 0.000523695140145719, 0.013071349821984768, -0.03987957164645195, -0.0373709574341774, 0.017178498208522797, -0.038535986095666885, -0.0015975885326042771, -0.0019611010793596506, 0.03945145010948181, 0.03996751084923744, -0.06961392611265182, -0.023452235385775566, 0.052883584052324295, -0.029375644400715828, 0.027537448331713676, 0.035024769604206085, 0.04026990383863449, 0.047037433832883835, 0.00833610724657774, 0.0340648889541626, -0.017961345613002777, 0.03565084934234619, -0.029403114691376686, 0.02461051195859909, -0.04699196293950081, -0.03616390377283096, 0.03593149036169052, -0.04539787769317627, -0.023261738941073418, 0.03946175426244736, -0.013233346864581108, -0.02924388088285923, 0.02813444659113884, -0.0159818846732378, 0.06722284853458405, -0.012275246903300285, 0.03720879554748535, 0.04140438139438629, -0.07193709909915924, -0.031949758529663086, 0.014242121949791908, -0.027275120839476585, -0.058768950402736664, 0.04865873605012894, 0.02993120066821575, -0.06007443740963936, -0.004372227005660534, -0.07133816927671432, 0.015925580635666847, 0.023777984082698822, -0.026164386421442032, 0.013828659430146217, 0.05683232098817825, 0.05058210715651512, -0.019130058586597443, -0.030919935554265976, -0.0322776734828949, -0.0066522047854959965, -0.062010034918785095, -0.008604309521615505, -0.010582434944808483, 0.02229641191661358, 0.0076884375885128975, 0.047658201307058334, 0.04645567014813423, 0.045424509793519974, 0.0150180384516716, 0.009624303318560123, 0.00040493658161722124, 0.007316479925066233, -0.03439426049590111, 0.07952208817005157, 0.014634850434958935, 0.03494317829608917, -0.030193723738193512, -0.0009107113000936806, -0.024993382394313812, 0.04379822686314583, 0.019573252648115158, -0.03701839596033096, 0.009214524179697037, -0.08104059845209122, -0.00817916076630354, 0.015576516278088093, 0.02179819904267788, -0.06345560401678085, -0.0008226082427427173, 0.003357117297127843, -0.010127509944140911, -0.04562501236796379 ]
A large class of type-I fracton models, including the X-cube model, have been found to be fixed points of the foliated renormalization group (RG). The system size of such foliated models can be changed by adding or removing decoupled layers of $2$D topological states and continuous deformation of the Hamiltonian. In this paper, we study a closely related model -- the Ising cage-net model -- and find that this model is not foliated in the same sense. In fact, we point out certain unnatural restrictions in the foliated RG, and find that removing these restrictions leads to a generalized foliated RG under which the Ising cage-net model is a fixed point, and which includes the original foliated RG as a special case. The Ising cage-net model thus gives a prototypical example of the generalized foliated RG, and its system size can be changed either by condensing / uncondensing bosonic planon excitations near a 2D plane or through a linear depth quantum circuit in the same plane. We show that these two apparently different RG procedures are closely related, as they lead to the same gapped boundary when implemented in part of a plane. Finally, we briefly discuss the implications for foliated fracton phases, whose universal properties will need to be reexamined in light of the generalized foliated RG.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.00103v2
[ -0.010106620378792286, -0.015923522412776947, 0.04688071459531784, -0.012636814266443253, 0.04333459213376045, -0.014422403648495674, -0.06136563792824745, -0.03995129093527794, -0.022093920037150383, -0.00786097627133131, -0.005696684587746859, -0.0301239974796772, -0.05731729790568352, -0.05997275561094284, -0.045278385281562805, 0.015908388420939445, 0.05574599280953407, 0.006185060366988182, -0.018180618062615395, 0.07268701493740082, -0.01663125306367874, -0.014040045440196991, -0.0013043340295553207, 0.06185375899076462, -0.02224106341600418, -0.025961995124816895, -0.0054672760888934135, 0.011760281398892403, -0.02827206254005432, -0.003937587607651949, 0.0705685019493103, -0.016315754503011703, 0.04582449421286583, -0.009109769947826862, -0.04839427024126053, 0.00933917611837387, -0.044234614819288254, 0.01909624971449375, 0.051526669412851334, -0.06728189438581467, -0.025061242282390594, -0.013138032518327236, -0.03298918530344963, 0.0008303520153276622, -0.05120420828461647, -0.0057692741975188255, -0.009513698518276215, 0.013653943315148354, -0.011300552636384964, -0.053158897906541824, 0.030924029648303986, -0.02297927998006344, 0.007390524726361036, 0.01716345176100731, -0.005820273421704769, -0.021045269444584846, -0.02349710650742054, 0.009287064895033836, -0.06621906161308289, -0.013393675908446312, -0.033352021127939224, -0.06459328532218933, -0.018290866166353226, -0.02771184779703617, -0.033572666347026825, 0.04270423203706741, -0.04723872244358063, -0.07228156924247742, -0.0012388302711769938, -0.027085529640316963, 0.055766649544239044, -0.053371310234069824, 0.0034529343247413635, 0.020538903772830963, -0.06712175160646439, -0.0009504478657618165, -0.015461038798093796, -0.031717147678136826, -0.004200650844722986, 0.0003046757774427533, -0.050504621118307114, 0.035434018820524216, -0.00588874751701951, 0.019193504005670547, 0.008633911609649658, 0.029789216816425323, 0.010461822152137756, -0.023732857778668404, -0.044749703258275986, -0.0618932768702507, 0.013270406983792782, -0.045174647122621536, -0.0583413764834404, 0.013831399381160736, 0.06137043237686157, -0.043172068893909454, 0.046047136187553406, 0.026994213461875916, 0.023286402225494385, 0.0161313246935606, -0.019727792590856552, -0.058747466653585434, -0.010167345404624939, 0.005080596078187227, 0.009463701397180557, -0.007930937223136425, -0.0016521163051947951, -0.008495381101965904, -0.05090172961354256, 0.058689676225185394, -0.03334279730916023, -0.025482777506113052, 0.02963208593428135, -0.06838277727365494, -0.059441667050123215, -0.03911222517490387, 0.040596187114715576, 0.0023561613634228706, 0.025798466056585312, 0.0047113713808357716, -0.045183129608631134, -0.024369869381189346, -0.010885256342589855, 0.008570811711251736, -0.043132416903972626, -0.054492052644491196, 0.07643545418977737, 0.033106785267591476, 0.0018243140075355768, -0.019651003181934357, -0.016541901975870132, -0.0212533138692379, 0.02636873349547386, -0.035679884254932404, 0.06239659711718559, -0.03685266897082329, 0.05283260717988014, -0.0037946999073028564, 0.009806029498577118, 0.043326206505298615, -0.006713895592838526, -0.07234697788953781, 0.026022234931588173, 0.012865417636930943, 0.013578556478023529, 0.05397087335586548, -0.07307233661413193, -0.00000923337120184442, 0.0062565612606704235, 0.02032426744699478, 0.0009451488149352372, -0.010204293765127659, -0.004331368021667004, 0.008923818357288837, -0.03455391898751259, -0.009527969174087048, 0.0569961778819561, 0.0028605973348021507, 0.008714315481483936, -0.023482676595449448, -0.0015379568794742227, -0.02146936021745205, -0.005612513516098261, 0.03838992863893509, 0.011258607730269432, -0.00009661252988735214, 0.018066933378577232, -0.038424015045166016, 0.0027535855770111084, 0.02723267488181591, 0.0010991650633513927, -0.016462553292512894, 0.03590622544288635, 0.002480689436197281, -0.027036860585212708, -0.03953642025589943, -0.03062819503247738, -0.03163779899477959, -0.05890076234936714, 0.04319755733013153, 0.03638770058751106, 0.010277275927364826, -0.0329972580075264, -0.013678833842277527, -0.06070572882890701, -0.04656460881233215, -0.08341926336288452, 0.00927300937473774, 0.0041076322086155415, 0.036314722150564194, -0.028007345274090767, -0.05990040302276611, 0.011764658614993095, -0.0026066943537443876, -0.01998322829604149, 0.015924381092190742, -0.0007183135603554547, -0.07078898698091507, -0.013122569769620895, 0.0446600541472435, -0.0616753064095974, -0.015541555359959602, -0.035194069147109985, 0.028837043792009354, 0.029066869989037514, -0.07455350458621979, -0.01860957406461239, 0.05180427059531212, -0.030773043632507324, -0.005767425987869501, 0.06353200972080231, -0.004499221686273813, 0.05480586364865303, -0.021288370713591576, -0.006976269651204348, -0.018791871145367622, -0.08678074926137924, -0.007909487001597881, -0.030888164415955544, -0.020318539813160896, 0.0014236676506698132, 0.00777648389339447, -0.019969545304775238, -0.034154050052165985, -0.03691810742020607, 0.029715491458773613, 0.06592319160699844, 0.006502073258161545, -0.06185189262032509, -0.02948194555938244, -0.0006076280260458589, -0.06662320345640182, -0.002142057754099369, -0.06352654099464417, -0.05886364355683327, 0.006830377969890833, -0.042612966150045395, 0.056452345103025436, -0.004247424658387899, -0.042489103972911835, -0.06249452382326126, -0.004090182948857546, 0.05600977689027786, 0.0010739463614299893, -0.04917736351490021, -0.06928413361310959, -0.05870146304368973, 0.051961272954940796, -0.013569017872214317, -0.02477618306875229, -0.012903524562716484, -0.0759102925658226, -0.03229707479476929, -0.03310496732592583, 0.0528746135532856, 0.049442701041698456, -0.030316615477204323, 0.0015311406459659338, -0.021808497607707977, 0.05143030360341072, 0.0361650213599205, -0.014797968789935112, -0.06043626740574837, -0.02458130568265915, -0.0022688331082463264, -0.020166495814919472, -0.07966569066047668, -0.03254694491624832, 0.03701750561594963, -0.014824064448475838, 0.00599423423409462, 0.008870447985827923, 0.04273313283920288, -0.0017652363749220967, 0.01268670056015253, -0.0028161632362753153, -0.02508816123008728, -0.05819779634475708, -0.010669202543795109, 0.03344795107841492, 0.007689603138715029, 0.05612149462103844, -0.04661127179861069, -0.07891383767127991, -0.006562926806509495, -0.04320359602570534, 0.018190251663327217, -0.016152961179614067, -0.06039199233055115, -0.03160640969872475, -0.07162009179592133, -0.011911275796592236, -0.006538298912346363, -0.0253638606518507, -0.04436105862259865, -0.06114054471254349, -0.022622467949986458, -0.03381136432290077, -0.008776108734309673, -0.025406263768672943, -0.05351265147328377, -0.018752090632915497, 0.05067696049809456, 0.01796223595738411, -0.006860122084617615, -0.04565141350030899, -0.04305591061711311, -0.016910763457417488, -0.006097396835684776, -0.014603259973227978, -0.04280271753668785, -0.012096074409782887, -0.01686650514602661, -0.00721319206058979, -0.0034259799867868423, 0.025783834978938103, 0.0490870326757431, -0.004500517621636391, 0.018968777731060982, 0.01146514993160963, -0.03227123245596886, -0.04835362732410431, -0.0005687839584425092, -0.06652513891458511, -0.04835838824510574, -0.026573682203888893, 0.022186484187841415, 0.061847176402807236, -0.03796970471739769, -0.00019979127682745457, -0.05835811048746109, -0.02452407218515873, -0.007601291872560978, -0.011437886394560337, 0.028995350003242493, 0.037782300263643265, 0.007226746063679457, 0.004799133166670799, -0.02694440819323063, 0.03378695994615555, 0.020481344312429428, 0.024414489045739174, -0.023131156340241432, -0.013624119572341442, 0.01599048264324665, -0.07277549803256989, -0.010239052586257458, 0.027628077194094658, 0.0372457318007946, -0.04528757184743881, -0.023169521242380142, 0.01511488389223814, -0.0159310195595026, 0.04792299121618271, -0.019734075292944908, 0.037163145840168, 0.02005593478679657, 0.03356465324759483, -0.01865829899907112, -0.057384319603443146, -0.05220574513077736, -0.0730736255645752, -0.05123680457472801, 0.017171155661344528, -0.0037945564836263657, 0.046430375427007675, 0.034545205533504486, -0.027453942224383354, 0.016875222325325012, 0.00033493724185973406, 0.04640723019838333, -0.020027976483106613, -0.029814252629876137, -0.0007202996057458222, -0.012221015989780426, 0.027143679559230804, -0.014634450897574425, -0.02318989858031273, -0.037949152290821075, -0.05427635833621025, -0.04108273983001709, -0.03309277072548866, 0.06176666170358658, 0.036424800753593445, -0.011940446682274342, 0.04524865373969078, 0.026008659973740578, -0.01570175774395466, 0.018427465111017227, 0.0026781049091368914, 0.03944332152605057, -0.04679382964968681, -0.002290237694978714, 0.017219973728060722, -0.014171603135764599, -0.03578565642237663, -0.009074080735445023, -0.0260783638805151, -0.04500836879014969, -0.018654420971870422, 0.0010405158391222358, -0.032220762223005295, -0.06170278787612915, -0.08080648630857468, -0.020099220797419548, -0.03484600409865379, 0.05178200453519821, 0.005041002761572599, -0.04912811517715454, 0.06012868136167526, -0.008267355151474476, 0.0018919388530775905, -0.04215279966592789, -0.03449090197682381, -0.021865669637918472, -0.0005955897504463792, -0.010424635373055935, -0.03945910185575485, 0.005921009927988052, -0.04001026600599289, 0.044102344661951065, 0.00872561614960432, -0.0171345267444849, -0.020858019590377808, 0.000590248208027333, -0.027462026104331017, 0.04219973459839821, 0.032566335052251816, 0.027203146368265152, -0.03605327382683754, 0.018101487308740616, -0.04455218464136124, -0.0034973069559782743, -0.023679658770561218, 0.014295478351414204, -0.06584043800830841, 0.04816679656505585, -0.048046816140413284, -0.03975555673241615, -0.04101196303963661, -0.021008439362049103, 0.00964557845145464, -0.05770699307322502, -0.05316358804702759, -0.018682511523365974, 0.06336551904678345, -0.04073683172464371, -0.06277290731668472, 0.01728000119328499, -0.030920151621103287, -0.07522410154342651, -0.010790807195007801, -0.0156478863209486, -0.0186451505869627, 0.0069440617226064205, 0.02747097797691822, 0.0003844551683869213, -0.01296646986156702, -0.031138839200139046, 0.010386690497398376, 0.021713651716709137, 0.027085483074188232, -0.011978551745414734, -0.051003266125917435, -0.06391119211912155, 0.044447336345911026, -0.02530401386320591, 0.02609921433031559, -0.012436440214514732, 0.042054563760757446, -0.02384256199002266, 0.013877421617507935, -0.08435148745775223, 0.04844467714428902, 0.05106089264154434, 0.007345051039010286, -0.0017620776779949665, 0.054984185844659805, -0.02976483292877674, 0.050942882895469666, -0.00594826927408576, 0.045626454055309296, 0.0038220363203436136, -0.0008835424087010324, -0.008305910974740982, -0.00950272474437952, -0.05875792354345322, -0.01750301942229271, 0.033159248530864716, 0.005108366720378399, -0.05501715466380119, 0.04113040119409561, 0.0034476083237677813, 0.003103182651102543, -0.004522663541138172, 0.0435664989054203, 0.020362135022878647, -0.052542153745889664, -0.044332899153232574, 0.04525754973292351, -0.014040370471775532, 0.03280503302812576, -0.014538872055709362, -0.04426466301083565, -0.000620877428445965, 0.02985820360481739, 0.012592843733727932, 0.014290573075413704, 0.040911197662353516, -0.01631668023765087, -0.03540586680173874, 0.0000054566712606174406, -0.043764203786849976, -0.05650839954614639, 0.04966432601213455, -0.07018650323152542, 0.04449911415576935, 0.03886013105511665, 0.032763682305812836, 0.0383136160671711, 0.023059401661157608, -0.009974606335163116, -0.03571866825222969, -0.001048710779286921, 0.04620320722460747, 0.017449477687478065, -0.06299043446779251, 0.03399631008505821, 0.004086961504071951, 0.03309953585267067, -0.026794403791427612, -0.0038862479850649834, -0.0021670472342520952, 0.031100204214453697, -0.02634112909436226, -0.029739443212747574, -0.03322649747133255, 0.00509993452578783, -0.0460568442940712, 0.003399415872991085, 0.03947320580482483, -0.053865548223257065, 0.04683336615562439, 0.045512694865465164, 0.012457944452762604, 0.004220830742269754, -0.020437223836779594, 0.023505564779043198, -0.03984192758798599, -0.044212620705366135, 0.07428358495235443, -0.08075597882270813, 0.008904322050511837, -0.04375384375452995, -0.04818860441446304, 0.049445588141679764, -0.03964740037918091, -0.008072402328252792, 0.049665555357933044, -0.020972762256860733, -0.024760758504271507, 0.03451535105705261, 0.01835980825126171, -0.06510595977306366, 0.006229144521057606, 0.03894621133804321, -0.07730486989021301, -0.010384781286120415, -0.02951647900044918, -0.0017361019272357225, -0.06028689444065094, 0.034276142716407776, -0.05964258685708046, -0.04988793283700943, -0.03731913864612579, 0.06967280805110931, 0.04671933501958847, -0.060964521020650864, 0.010155858471989632, -0.02585344761610031, -0.032010018825531006, 0.0068087466061115265, -0.03073772042989731, 0.00031797459814697504, -0.0012619291665032506, -0.010267184115946293, -0.013370378874242306, -0.05223630741238594, 0.02669828198850155, 0.028953611850738525, -0.046876635402441025, -0.0015227396506816149, 0.022564731538295746, -0.0298442505300045, 0.00833643227815628, -0.04392557963728905, 0.010506541468203068, 0.006047764793038368, 0.0016903942450881004, 0.030506856739521027, -0.005541536025702953, -0.015832966193556786, -0.03810402378439903, 0.020160144194960594, 0.003183920169249177, -0.01376630924642086, -0.033212143927812576, -0.019697071984410286, -0.031311940401792526, 0.018934041261672974, -0.010518921539187431, 0.025445031002163887, -0.0119628319516778, 0.020115569233894348, -0.010493473149836063, 0.010587752796709538, -0.04928914085030556, -0.015175992622971535, -0.0014034789055585861, -0.040560223162174225, 0.008847133256494999, -0.0077202594839036465, 0.027303997427225113, -0.028274359181523323, 0.03680913522839546, -0.04846466705203056, 0.003329580184072256, -0.024950431659817696, -0.05273257568478584, 0.024761201813817024, -0.019910017028450966, -0.03388462960720062, -0.014400530606508255, 0.033946625888347626, -0.06001647934317589, 0.05075398460030556, 0.004395763855427504, -0.034636206924915314, -0.06590273976325989, -0.026101872324943542, -0.030749786645174026, -0.018417811021208763, 0.04707377776503563, -0.013261822983622551, 0.031358636915683746, 0.03409910202026367, 0.06834286451339722, 0.04107241705060005, -0.0015103938058018684, 0.032260242849588394, -0.06008540466427803, 0.002600759733468294, 0.006741289980709553, -0.02033623866736889, -0.03437995910644531, -0.0014038779772818089, -0.05926250293850899, -0.056645337492227554, 0.06431511044502258, 0.02465500310063362, 0.008946369402110577, -0.03622167557477951, -0.016102692112326622, 0.0667274072766304, 0.029415616765618324, -0.012662254273891449, -0.07766231149435043, -0.005293046589940786, 0.03609246388077736, -0.026577990502119064, -0.058037810027599335, -0.01623080112040043, -0.06927324086427689, -0.027422968298196793, -0.08687173575162888, -0.00937705859541893, 0.015969645231962204, 0.07390439510345459, 0.021639106795191765, -0.03480473533272743, -0.05763079598546028, -0.056975629180669785, 0.0031313018407672644, 0.009411546401679516, 0.04877621680498123, -0.022474072873592377, 0.04585652053356171, 0.02774640917778015, -0.01293216459453106, -0.007522975094616413, 0.06450090557336807, -0.02898700349032879, -0.002750055631622672, -0.013605785556137562, 0.03217281028628349, -0.01118409913033247, 0.06917472183704376, 0.05731585994362831, -0.0036314327735453844, 0.031291414052248, -0.0042435722425580025, -0.0010106132831424475, -0.07139401882886887, -0.05366021767258644, -0.025361377745866776, -0.06915713846683502, -0.022002438083291054, 0.025790764018893242, -0.01892736926674843, -0.031621381640434265, -0.05208182707428932, -0.06424552947282791, 0.009414861910045147, 0.01460987888276577, -0.014621077105402946, 0.046643003821372986, -0.05069054663181305, -0.02860880270600319, 0.021761024370789528, -0.022251566872000694, -0.056685373187065125, 0.010702681727707386, 0.017031123861670494, -0.02083035185933113, 0.029658840969204903, -0.05200131982564926, 0.03461470454931259, 0.026794064790010452, 0.01387397013604641, 0.05887383222579956, 0.035185690969228745, -0.02073853276669979, 0.0025082998909056187, -0.04083682969212532, -0.026184486225247383, 0.022816233336925507, -0.06738785654306412, 0.013319896534085274, -0.034773748368024826, 0.012493804097175598, -0.04072178155183792, 0.024558408185839653, -0.06443207710981369, 0.032189641147851944, 0.01404643151909113, 0.003916710615158081, -0.009980904869735241, -0.013382893055677414, -0.025977302342653275, 0.03727155551314354, 0.01778455451130867, -0.04927993565797806, -0.04220820218324661, 0.018616270273923874, 0.016313275322318077, 0.012789249420166016, -0.04499459266662598, 0.028388893231749535, 0.028159311041235924, -0.07053481042385101, -0.04833904653787613, 0.04931763932108879, -0.002016870304942131, -0.049285680055618286, 0.024400826543569565, -0.025827426463365555, 0.0067728483118116856, -0.05987973138689995 ]
We study the semi-random graph process, and a variant process recently suggested by Nick Wormald. We show that these two processes are asymptotically equally fast in constructing a semi-random graph $G$ that has property ${\mathcal P}$, for the following examples of ${\mathcal P}$: - ${\mathcal P}$ is the set of graphs containing a $d$-degenerate subgraph, where $d\ge 1$ is fixed; - ${\mathcal P}$ is the set of $k$-connected graphs, where $k\ge 1$ is fixed. In particular, our result of the $k$-connectedness above settles the open case $k=2$ of the original semi-random graph process. We also prove that there exist properties ${\mathcal P}$ where the two semi-random graph processes do not construct a graph in ${\mathcal P}$ asymptotically equally fast. We further propose some conjectures on ${\mathcal P}$ for which the two processes perform differently.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05881v1
[ -0.030318962410092354, -0.05612105503678322, -0.020173847675323486, -0.02108093537390232, 0.001263996004126966, -0.03190978989005089, -0.04112086072564125, 0.0025429287925362587, -0.015362290665507317, -0.025093868374824524, -0.025777123868465424, -0.024556266143918037, 0.003502794774249196, -0.00587676465511322, -0.033069975674152374, 0.0176609568297863, 0.07011473178863525, 0.03407943993806839, 0.01419932022690773, 0.07369276881217957, -0.034497711807489395, -0.04381224513053894, -0.016457805410027504, 0.06751478463411331, -0.009290382266044617, -0.033136848360300064, -0.05995192751288414, -0.019111251458525658, -0.06450707465410233, -0.05486728250980377, 0.06849201768636703, -0.048294324427843094, 0.022382743656635284, -0.053892090916633606, -0.010230074636638165, 0.044892266392707825, -0.0011919561075046659, 0.062126852571964264, 0.05055302008986473, -0.04259200766682625, 0.03862200304865837, -0.06432443857192993, -0.057779427617788315, -0.04872341454029083, -0.02658962458372116, -0.046950384974479675, -0.01774912141263485, 0.017623594030737877, -0.008916330523788929, -0.02656281553208828, 0.012147210538387299, -0.002966676140204072, -0.01459407713264227, -0.0010388472583144903, -0.051333118230104446, -0.04775392264127731, -0.005465046502649784, -0.005576559342443943, -0.03605058416724205, 0.001489096786826849, -0.030222909525036812, -0.033182088285684586, -0.02726888097822666, -0.04964832589030266, -0.044436417520046234, 0.014067408628761768, -0.01917142979800701, -0.057823777198791504, -0.005564634222537279, -0.04291880875825882, 0.03942097723484039, -0.03014160692691803, 0.018696703016757965, -0.016033682972192764, -0.06597407907247543, 0.05574335530400276, -0.0011736535234376788, 0.012181376107037067, -0.014647843316197395, 0.02151014842092991, -0.015776781365275383, -0.008465942926704884, 0.0008008998120203614, -0.00990968570113182, 0.008147499524056911, 0.00886551197618246, 0.03360622376203537, -0.031075268983840942, -0.012751822359859943, -0.06454680114984512, -0.033409394323825836, -0.04663959890604019, -0.07310853153467178, -0.01054064929485321, 0.03248456493020058, -0.057739779353141785, 0.039382219314575195, 0.049738965928554535, 0.03584427759051323, 0.007340469863265753, 0.021032296121120453, -0.04714832827448845, -0.050353556871414185, -0.009770899079740047, 0.03320108726620674, -0.04945269227027893, -0.0019557869527488947, -0.01770065352320671, -0.0392933189868927, 0.028871221467852592, 0.012780239805579185, -0.003504676977172494, -0.029348473995923996, -0.04381931945681572, -0.051583558320999146, -0.06734179705381393, 0.05660184100270271, 0.03901616111397743, 0.06640215218067169, 0.031653862446546555, 0.03637119382619858, 0.006778997369110584, 0.04250771552324295, 0.01580907218158245, -0.051330968737602234, -0.024427060037851334, 0.04579029232263565, 0.03828105330467224, 0.024672191590070724, 0.002441365271806717, 0.02294229157269001, 0.024238241836428642, 0.03329258784651756, -0.0037783090956509113, 0.0187558364123106, -0.014058166183531284, -0.027764329686760902, -0.012422394938766956, -0.01775539666414261, 0.008664412423968315, -0.03128492832183838, -0.07149199396371841, 0.050378210842609406, 0.0561445951461792, 0.021631795912981033, 0.045159801840782166, -0.06061215326189995, 0.04201808571815491, 0.024282578378915787, 0.035671234130859375, -0.026330294087529182, 0.040115926414728165, -0.0004997245850972831, 0.0069693345576524734, 0.012277299538254738, 0.008551777340471745, 0.05180072784423828, -0.019444065168499947, -0.041152361780405045, -0.010298928245902061, 0.0007459349581040442, -0.04050661623477936, 0.044609833508729935, -0.009464561007916927, 0.05827796831727028, 0.027201175689697266, 0.02127484790980816, -0.05038341134786606, -0.020626934245228767, 0.03209229186177254, 0.009550630114972591, 0.0019356810953468084, 0.04803574085235596, -0.0520484559237957, -0.043127670884132385, 0.005501464940607548, -0.04031384363770485, -0.03232942521572113, -0.06193236634135246, -0.02328500896692276, 0.02890648879110813, 0.012347771786153316, -0.020583240315318108, -0.007618392817676067, -0.06717519462108612, -0.005179060623049736, -0.07363205403089523, 0.01744036376476288, 0.04968348145484924, 0.04814593493938446, -0.010383041575551033, -0.03135000541806221, 0.009350803680717945, -0.0018904204480350018, -0.03656861558556557, 0.011059857904911041, -0.011271074414253235, -0.06079291179776192, -0.06136324256658554, 0.04451370611786842, -0.0670282244682312, -0.03653976321220398, -0.04212353751063347, 0.012256840243935585, 0.020501017570495605, -0.060193464159965515, 0.027589596807956696, 0.03982177749276161, 0.0007263280567713082, -0.07238955050706863, 0.0553741455078125, 0.02720576338469982, 0.05516159534454346, -0.03621457517147064, -0.03492450714111328, -0.03621797636151314, -0.08197332918643951, 0.04331282898783684, 0.010039674118161201, 0.010167079977691174, -0.008931169286370277, -0.003325383411720395, -0.018918484449386597, -0.06972625106573105, -0.028252828866243362, 0.044018324464559555, 0.02925441414117813, 0.006818779278546572, -0.05089740455150604, -0.03247850760817528, 0.0435233935713768, -0.056909218430519104, -0.016673536971211433, -0.06215749308466911, -0.011136246845126152, 0.030854826793074608, -0.03205948695540428, 0.06317374110221863, 0.011475143022835255, -0.036399442702531815, -0.054027311503887177, 0.009022250771522522, 0.03722459077835083, -0.015609669499099255, -0.033003564924001694, -0.0020508531015366316, -0.01090890634804964, -0.01029542088508606, -0.00858334917575121, 0.0027215066365897655, -0.024537812918424606, -0.041329752653837204, -0.052724964916706085, -0.04402652755379677, 0.03453383222222328, 0.052577294409275055, 0.002842519199475646, 0.029832415282726288, -0.032098665833473206, 0.034154489636421204, -0.004448551218956709, 0.0015927000204101205, 0.0327221117913723, -0.043525367975234985, 0.02703709527850151, 0.026236308738589287, -0.05502836033701897, -0.04216863587498665, 0.0046689799055457115, -0.03495589643716812, -0.008486582897603512, 0.016186609864234924, 0.037965718656778336, -0.04163733869791031, -0.017168154940009117, -0.04589848220348358, -0.01966152898967266, -0.042059194296598434, 0.03913777694106102, 0.03661206737160683, -0.010216213762760162, 0.030021294951438904, -0.03221926838159561, -0.07615094631910324, 0.01173749752342701, 0.033275194466114044, -0.03271276876330376, -0.01663450337946415, -0.03538461774587631, -0.03542601689696312, -0.07159654796123505, -0.011437837034463882, -0.053098101168870926, -0.022515561431646347, -0.04296942427754402, -0.06350713223218918, -0.0201598908752203, -0.016343148425221443, -0.03476530313491821, -0.03737186640501022, -0.061588991433382034, -0.011289292015135288, 0.012784170918166637, 0.06010131537914276, 0.02654144912958145, -0.030286433175206184, -0.028111780062317848, 0.0028521830681711435, -0.017957186326384544, 0.015078707598149776, -0.0008286371012218297, 0.014652728103101254, -0.029638120904564857, -0.007296998053789139, 0.013559076935052872, 0.02650650590658188, 0.005125414114445448, -0.02824525348842144, -0.01035182736814022, -0.05446438491344452, 0.0001780854945536703, -0.036276042461395264, 0.017684824764728546, -0.05859706550836563, -0.04973679035902023, 0.005597152281552553, 0.04056589677929878, 0.0035079678054898977, -0.049218084663152695, -0.028135990723967552, -0.056336820125579834, -0.03488351032137871, -0.0010600978275761008, -0.024624351412057877, 0.03413271903991699, 0.028454937040805817, -0.002720697084441781, 0.020996421575546265, -0.05981675535440445, 0.023688463494181633, 0.0007703276351094246, 0.019340313971042633, 0.005107888486236334, 0.00501687778159976, 0.022442473098635674, -0.07844620198011398, 0.011444647796452045, 0.058688607066869736, 0.015330600552260876, -0.03735559061169624, -0.03723781183362007, 0.00024284071696456522, -0.014845837838947773, -0.01522332988679409, -0.011689221486449242, 0.04113605618476868, 0.05261077731847763, 0.044179193675518036, -0.020717592909932137, -0.015560475178062916, 0.04263301193714142, -0.025788959115743637, -0.026388701051473618, 0.038527097553014755, 0.004836596082895994, 0.027043910697102547, -0.005602151155471802, -0.014103635214269161, 0.0008206653292290866, -0.03160513564944267, 0.022463200613856316, -0.0424557626247406, -0.026693571358919144, -0.021155014634132385, -0.020527830347418785, 0.015202585607767105, -0.012069459073245525, -0.010924084112048149, -0.02558092400431633, -0.05256260558962822, -0.02811669185757637, -0.0539877787232399, 0.00034823347232304513, 0.035006631165742874, -0.04526283219456673, 0.030437707901000977, -0.030591562390327454, -0.00879733357578516, 0.03099612332880497, -0.04114638268947601, 0.04667149856686592, -0.007988709025084972, 0.01581675000488758, 0.044491615146398544, -0.0019838258158415556, -0.03635554388165474, -0.0038427559193223715, 0.03296101465821266, -0.055537644773721695, -0.05375056341290474, 0.036715246737003326, -0.02566223219037056, -0.034861017018556595, -0.06492036581039429, -0.0652172714471817, -0.06334923952817917, 0.02461659349501133, 0.008627544157207012, -0.05345526337623596, 0.06420587748289108, 0.027734389528632164, -0.022570006549358368, 0.00627331156283617, -0.017451127991080284, -0.04144895821809769, 0.0059228213503956795, -0.04898986965417862, -0.04823262616991997, 0.033444978296756744, -0.03706321865320206, 0.03346497565507889, 0.0015843987930566072, -0.04053466022014618, -0.031046848744153976, -0.007700026500970125, 0.01141263172030449, 0.018209772184491158, 0.04187360405921936, 0.04277179017663002, -0.022166142240166664, -0.020049355924129486, -0.04317670315504074, -0.025803856551647186, -0.061241671442985535, -0.027687324211001396, -0.06076657027006149, 0.05158596485853195, -0.01043142843991518, -0.02428988367319107, -0.004320919048041105, -0.019877607002854347, 0.038809288293123245, -0.025109315291047096, -0.04087034985423088, -0.046227432787418365, 0.038949381560087204, -0.0642257109284401, -0.04920696094632149, -0.001055876025930047, -0.015750663354992867, -0.055464986711740494, 0.011381741613149643, -0.014486368745565414, -0.025646807625889778, 0.014330296777188778, 0.039659351110458374, -0.004947942215949297, 0.018617523834109306, -0.06431614607572556, 0.0027920349966734648, 0.00821130070835352, -0.0186239592730999, -0.05199349299073219, -0.012069282121956348, -0.07224658131599426, 0.012836814858019352, -0.05410247668623924, 0.013629835098981857, 0.007082447409629822, 0.055922240018844604, -0.0216770488768816, 0.06444919854402542, -0.07709193229675293, -0.016237888485193253, 0.020589977502822876, -0.02099861018359661, -0.029221322387456894, 0.034973639994859695, -0.06279701739549637, -0.0002730238193180412, 0.011509426869452, -0.0005817221244797111, 0.023774119094014168, -0.039621684700250626, -0.014707151800394058, 0.03680973872542381, -0.041045017540454865, -0.05681544914841652, 0.013324292376637459, 0.00955138634890318, -0.02852119877934456, -0.021164346486330032, -0.03546905517578125, 0.022957803681492805, -0.046948306262493134, 0.04593285173177719, -0.029842687770724297, -0.06947323679924011, -0.05041556805372238, -0.05119381099939346, 0.03857893869280815, -0.008336289785802364, -0.0057566119357943535, -0.03284051641821861, -0.002912942785769701, 0.06142143905162811, -0.025679659098386765, 0.03321841359138489, 0.028943415731191635, 0.00008971744682639837, -0.03387085348367691, -0.037786129862070084, -0.021162359043955803, -0.04551110416650772, -0.025285914540290833, -0.04094872251152992, 0.04418425261974335, 0.027297483757138252, -0.032311100512742996, -0.01093822531402111, -0.016992175951600075, 0.002275942824780941, -0.04608737677335739, -0.02077244035899639, -0.03731308504939079, 0.051563505083322525, -0.017806394025683403, -0.007979204878211021, -0.010103940963745117, 0.03494342416524887, -0.031498055905103683, 0.011195288971066475, -0.027152886614203453, -0.03701259195804596, -0.03580952063202858, -0.029075760394334793, -0.0036452203057706356, -0.04550588130950928, -0.05327820032835007, 0.0014515966176986694, 0.040145549923181534, -0.04814688488841057, 0.04824654757976532, 0.038639165461063385, 0.02532305009663105, -0.05526097118854523, 0.01624670997262001, 0.01838092878460884, -0.06359319388866425, -0.020193781703710556, 0.04622596874833107, -0.0740482360124588, 0.013347647152841091, -0.04764321446418762, 0.021449685096740723, -0.01577579602599144, -0.0589970126748085, 0.02933604083955288, 0.021844057366251945, -0.016964394599199295, -0.05693770945072174, 0.04419488087296486, -0.012623678892850876, -0.07029493153095245, 0.007196789141744375, 0.03262391686439514, -0.04143065959215164, 0.018201474100351334, -0.028816301375627518, 0.025202278047800064, -0.039014510810375214, 0.002367848763242364, -0.047014329582452774, -0.05762162432074547, -0.03178814798593521, 0.06207473203539848, 0.06324842572212219, -0.06646183878183365, 0.0508444607257843, 0.05696281045675278, -0.04763675853610039, 0.048359356820583344, -0.07858353108167648, -0.027510404586791992, -0.042252425104379654, 0.05464353412389755, -0.04840714484453201, -0.04140860214829445, -0.03695850446820259, 0.03246908634901047, -0.020370155572891235, 0.017861707136034966, 0.05412474647164345, 0.012477261945605278, 0.054158203303813934, -0.01707099750638008, -0.013716691173613071, -0.018966488540172577, 0.00410006009042263, -0.04525898024439812, -0.041302043944597244, 0.04594815894961357, -0.023944752290844917, -0.04026389122009277, -0.01851077936589718, -0.06258203834295273, -0.010076149366796017, -0.04311534762382507, -0.0663280263543129, -0.018238363787531853, -0.04116038605570793, 0.029023686423897743, 0.010143685154616833, 0.04544133320450783, 0.011870806105434895, -0.013002653606235981, -0.034361694008111954, -0.009383938275277615, -0.01041258405894041, -0.039289623498916626, -0.0019722532015293837, 0.008628912270069122, 0.01542331650853157, -0.04523656889796257, 0.06467239558696747, -0.05158039927482605, -0.017385657876729965, -0.06177227571606636, -0.06441131234169006, 0.008941463194787502, 0.030011313036084175, -0.06544290482997894, -0.020868390798568726, 0.04539079964160919, -0.06812026351690292, 0.045047104358673096, 0.009723922237753868, -0.018232060596346855, -0.0311710387468338, 0.02177606336772442, -0.022897658869624138, 0.03378802537918091, 0.021124809980392456, -0.04694175347685814, 0.018392717465758324, -0.0025543798692524433, 0.046859338879585266, 0.029094763100147247, 0.03733256086707115, 0.018460653722286224, -0.05756362900137901, -0.0012580734910443425, -0.035879410803318024, -0.027320904657244682, -0.05023953318595886, -0.03535979986190796, -0.04743196815252304, -0.0629185363650322, 0.054929789155721664, 0.024980058893561363, 0.02109503000974655, -0.0017528967000544071, -0.0627281442284584, 0.035990484058856964, 0.02265077643096447, -0.011121178045868874, -0.07103793323040009, -0.0328301265835762, 0.008934284560382366, -0.016018172726035118, -0.015643032267689705, 0.000603105581831187, -0.05241413414478302, 0.022080034017562866, -0.07909885793924332, -0.03031221032142639, 0.004963058512657881, 0.0543210469186306, 0.031052179634571075, -0.05467677116394043, -0.04357736557722092, -0.05487396940588951, -0.00853086169809103, 0.032342344522476196, -0.01301522832363844, 0.03363236412405968, 0.021880829706788063, -0.004301081411540508, -0.021184545010328293, 0.004095871467143297, 0.02824023924767971, -0.02368297427892685, -0.019001517444849014, 0.027952857315540314, 0.02939976379275322, 0.0009575251024216413, 0.025947123765945435, 0.05570119246840477, -0.007021482102572918, 0.007959573529660702, 0.0017534802900627255, -0.02437552437186241, -0.04221828654408455, -0.048943497240543365, -0.004252722021192312, -0.03361169248819351, -0.03485330566763878, -0.02849471941590309, -0.021557794883847237, -0.05512071028351784, -0.02630981057882309, -0.031934499740600586, -0.010301707312464714, 0.036067333072423935, 0.00613849563524127, 0.0018498231656849384, -0.06538024544715881, 0.002216796390712261, 0.0010297754779458046, 0.031339071691036224, -0.022787809371948242, -0.011124136857688427, 0.02449757605791092, -0.020297521725296974, 0.0040855263359844685, -0.05110800638794899, 0.015519428998231888, -0.0038352899719029665, -0.010560985654592514, 0.06768664717674255, 0.04441400617361069, -0.020127277821302414, 0.03940838575363159, -0.0031742381397634745, 0.04289254546165466, -0.00750426622107625, -0.06137654557824135, -0.010004059411585331, -0.029222603887319565, -0.03036939725279808, 0.014337651431560516, 0.028074441477656364, -0.04461023584008217, 0.03346734866499901, 0.028346747159957886, -0.020576320588588715, 0.011091866530478, -0.01631953753530979, -0.02345392480492592, 0.009863489307463169, -0.00004894757512374781, -0.044776223599910736, -0.037037443369627, 0.04017329961061478, 0.011257749050855637, 0.00265558366663754, -0.039491090923547745, -0.054856035858392715, -0.004715351853519678, -0.04026906564831734, 0.011606442742049694, 0.06564050167798996, 0.03487514704465866, -0.05005088821053505, 0.037737540900707245, -0.02276693843305111, -0.04447342827916145, -0.03829862177371979 ]
Magnetically arrested accretion disks (MADs) around a rapidly rotating black hole (BH) have been proposed as a model for jetted tidal disruption events (TDEs). However, the dynamics of strongly magnetized disks in a more realistic simulation which can mimic the chaotic dynamics during a TDE have previously been unexplored. Here we employ global GRMHD simulations of a pre-existing MAD disk interacting with an injected TDE stream with impact parameter $\beta\equiv R_t/R_p=4-7$ to investigate how strongly magnetized TDEs differ from the standard MAD picture. We demonstrate for the first time that a MAD or semi-MAD state can be sustained and jets powered by the BH spin are produced in a TDE. We also demonstrate that the strength of the self-intersection shock depends on how dense the disk is relative to the stream, or the density contrast $f_\rho=\rho_d/\rho_s$. The jet or funnel can become significantly tilted (by $10-30^\circ$) due to the self-intersection outflow when $f_\rho \leq 0.1$. In models with a powerful jet and $f_\rho\leq 0.01$, the tilted jet interacts with and ultimately tilts the disk by as much as 23 degrees from the incoming stream. We illustrate that as $f_\rho$ increases, the tilt of the jet and disk is expected to realign with the BH spin once $f_\rho \geq 0.1$. We illustrate how the tilt can rapidly realign if $f_\rho$ increases rapidly and apply this to TDEs which have shown X-ray evolution on timescales of days-weeks.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20592v1
[ -0.0446377731859684, -0.023354914039373398, 0.05110041797161102, -0.02076731249690056, 0.006364104337990284, 0.008809912018477917, 0.014005533419549465, 0.007502536755055189, -0.05268528312444687, -0.005907537415623665, 0.01677337847650051, -0.036943309009075165, 0.00481329346075654, -0.04545525461435318, -0.02845073491334915, 0.006604842841625214, 0.0687008872628212, -0.009413415566086769, -0.008307477459311485, 0.043042004108428955, -0.03612110763788223, 0.011252051219344139, -0.05465584993362427, 0.05704674869775772, -0.025879675522446632, -0.04199051484465599, -0.06559620797634125, 0.05357866361737251, -0.046198636293411255, -0.006461393088102341, 0.0670464038848877, -0.056579336524009705, 0.030110768973827362, -0.041448041796684265, -0.0560036227107048, 0.020214954391121864, -0.06013035774230957, 0.023247703909873962, 0.05213466286659241, -0.06971750408411026, -0.008690373972058296, -0.03630596399307251, -0.05064965412020683, -0.05866776406764984, -0.03127656877040863, -0.03699272498488426, -0.004807538352906704, -0.007797782309353352, 0.028413347899913788, -0.040866024792194366, 0.025100447237491608, -0.01839469186961651, 0.02011132426559925, 0.032107554376125336, -0.031582050025463104, -0.013429500162601471, -0.006157517898827791, 0.00643958942964673, -0.06140059232711792, -0.06862711161375046, -0.020178908482193947, -0.03755282610654831, -0.008020121604204178, 0.01691564731299877, -0.03963049128651619, 0.022830404341220856, -0.02460305020213127, -0.012566103599965572, -0.01824857108294964, -0.06231517344713211, 0.05490819364786148, -0.06163264811038971, 0.05074948072433472, 0.012154582887887955, -0.0353044830262661, -0.0047079469077289104, -0.03468365594744682, -0.009761232882738113, -0.03739533573389053, 0.014646826311945915, -0.025877773761749268, -0.019712410867214203, -0.009937523864209652, 0.024154221639037132, 0.02461124025285244, -0.0047731841914355755, 0.030641017481684685, -0.024010535329580307, -0.0033150294329971075, -0.046912990510463715, 0.02525647170841694, -0.06092233583331108, -0.03755085915327072, -0.05387319251894951, 0.04689355939626694, -0.055831849575042725, 0.05063707008957863, -0.0017601213185116649, 0.01966199092566967, -0.04692745581269264, -0.01670759916305542, -0.03357773646712303, -0.04617886617779732, -0.017347972840070724, 0.051029473543167114, -0.0630277469754219, 0.017886551097035408, -0.01636568456888199, -0.03587201610207558, 0.026814663782715797, -0.011849798262119293, -0.018933523446321487, -0.008701036684215069, -0.03038264811038971, -0.032609838992357254, 0.0007406182703562081, 0.03272712230682373, -0.012213652953505516, 0.00958438590168953, 0.0408146008849144, -0.056311577558517456, 0.017941627651453018, 0.030119415372610092, -0.017702262848615646, 0.004987547639757395, -0.02584618516266346, 0.07452964037656784, -0.05152834951877594, 0.021349936723709106, -0.04626966640353203, -0.06467906385660172, 0.009106336161494255, -0.005616810172796249, -0.029342228546738625, 0.06470780074596405, -0.020185280591249466, 0.012596542946994305, -0.027593180537223816, -0.015446645207703114, 0.012382132932543755, -0.011275134049355984, -0.07198641449213028, 0.026987627148628235, 0.06408274173736572, -0.03373236581683159, 0.02272183448076248, -0.057312775403261185, -0.016654931008815765, 0.002801261842250824, -0.021009990945458412, 0.017659224569797516, 0.02975291758775711, 0.01510815043002367, 0.04603981226682663, -0.012810016050934792, -0.027885569259524345, 0.034830354154109955, 0.06052931770682335, -0.037599075585603714, -0.005887274164706469, -0.004644162021577358, -0.03944859653711319, 0.015946388244628906, 0.036653440445661545, 0.03275385499000549, 0.003599468618631363, -0.003328421851620078, -0.007491318508982658, -0.007732890546321869, -0.0007378431619144976, -0.0031588145066052675, -0.037230171263217926, 0.024469517171382904, -0.02803860977292061, -0.05778956785798073, -0.0542212575674057, 0.0009011296788230538, -0.05080202966928482, -0.013102808967232704, 0.008231720887124538, 0.05210987105965614, 0.0342479944229126, -0.07109487056732178, 0.0014983731089159846, -0.06091412156820297, -0.032131534069776535, -0.08006913214921951, -0.04450679197907448, 0.0038600172847509384, 0.020390709862113, -0.05724673345685005, -0.015121487900614738, 0.01679154485464096, 0.010661968030035496, 0.018464960157871246, -0.034206390380859375, 0.023086292669177055, -0.009093138389289379, 0.008859879337251186, 0.02890249341726303, -0.04514571279287338, 0.005916471127420664, -0.04433661326766014, 0.04603809118270874, 0.032758306711912155, -0.06298168748617172, -0.0042806584388017654, 0.049778953194618225, -0.026369282975792885, -0.054268501698970795, 0.03893774747848511, 0.04148508980870247, -0.0027219729963690042, 0.03255903720855713, 0.013479367829859257, -0.0006292111938819289, -0.08733601868152618, 0.05233094096183777, 0.009657262824475765, -0.04155009612441063, 0.05947446823120117, 0.032745786011219025, -0.0003139586769975722, -0.022836336866021156, -0.0407588966190815, 0.02850434184074402, 0.06271474808454514, -0.006378603633493185, -0.04287349432706833, -0.011558299884200096, -0.01045462116599083, -0.06775515526533127, -0.004171612206846476, -0.04572712630033493, -0.008320990949869156, -0.03341355174779892, -0.06807690113782883, 0.055329691618680954, 0.018587956205010414, -0.007316055241972208, 0.01953238807618618, 0.00574449123814702, 0.000023127931854105555, 0.00041031866567209363, -0.07189109176397324, -0.04826037585735321, -0.03917535021901131, 0.009487568400800228, -0.037949156016111374, -0.0467977337539196, -0.0277373306453228, -0.04422655329108238, -0.053648579865694046, 0.011157878674566746, 0.04582548886537552, 0.04469737783074379, -0.027446163818240166, -0.018876751884818077, -0.023790789768099785, 0.06325805187225342, -0.009369161911308765, -0.001356565859168768, -0.03501925989985466, 0.016282161697745323, -0.0027671214193105698, 0.030640974640846252, -0.05110469460487366, -0.011573286727070808, 0.009567312896251678, -0.03441770747303963, 0.030497843399643898, 0.05398229882121086, 0.03243454545736313, 0.008286393247544765, 0.006618333514779806, -0.01058276742696762, -0.047147247940301895, -0.020216619595885277, -0.008323343470692635, -0.03542498126626015, 0.01753237098455429, 0.024162352085113525, -0.006716197822242975, -0.06486746668815613, -0.029285753145813942, -0.04604795202612877, 0.009010391309857368, -0.07311327010393143, -0.026446977630257607, -0.029055003076791763, -0.06858083605766296, -0.03945033624768257, -0.022921482101082802, 0.0017561151180416346, -0.02189452573657036, -0.0003972951089963317, -0.002110787434503436, -0.0019789664074778557, -0.013205631636083126, -0.06833278387784958, -0.044357623904943466, 0.04381394013762474, -0.03239129111170769, 0.04824133217334747, -0.01591617614030838, -0.03283488005399704, -0.05099878087639809, -0.05080825090408325, -0.0020230626687407494, -0.004981788340955973, -0.06299848109483719, 0.021359549835324287, -0.04895802214741707, 0.004082816652953625, 0.023806994780898094, 0.05370156466960907, 0.03953017294406891, -0.034342311322689056, -0.010407666675746441, -0.037598948925733566, -0.030243951827287674, -0.03700963035225868, -0.03251240402460098, -0.042982786893844604, -0.05529563128948212, -0.0473468042910099, 0.06391710042953491, 0.04673450440168381, -0.015679679811000824, -0.03678922727704048, -0.03425227478146553, -0.027476269751787186, -0.014108680188655853, -0.005191183183342218, 0.07096464186906815, 0.0578722283244133, -0.030621228739619255, 0.02016252838075161, -0.04140222817659378, 0.042028676718473434, -0.038036953657865524, -0.009487147442996502, -0.006138267461210489, 0.036229413002729416, 0.01626492291688919, -0.06963124126195908, 0.014959003776311874, 0.04134276136755943, -0.008841568604111671, -0.0072446162812411785, 0.02135399542748928, 0.02681835927069187, 0.0244901180267334, 0.058033935725688934, -0.01027191523462534, 0.012972292490303516, 0.030641648918390274, 0.013045690953731537, -0.013049636967480183, -0.018350988626480103, -0.008424956351518631, -0.07011324912309647, -0.05466712266206741, 0.032000068575143814, -0.008783841505646706, 0.019177274778485298, 0.034412164241075516, -0.010699097998440266, 0.06301980465650558, 0.007970019243657589, 0.04700087383389473, -0.056569863110780716, -0.04401654750108719, -0.003786055138334632, -0.0336470827460289, -0.014076859690248966, -0.013716857880353928, -0.003916318062692881, -0.02307419665157795, -0.05336005240678787, 0.02672737091779709, -0.03983907029032707, 0.014494638890028, 0.025221440941095352, 0.03138497471809387, 0.034431710839271545, 0.02284938097000122, 0.005623696371912956, 0.04750700294971466, -0.042055997997522354, -0.0015187530079856515, -0.0047663128934800625, -0.013626547530293465, 0.013485563918948174, 0.03470436856150627, -0.03444637358188629, -0.0077446396462619305, 0.025778664276003838, -0.020086027681827545, -0.021577175706624985, 0.025292929261922836, -0.01714291423559189, -0.060681458562612534, -0.0851440280675888, 0.0012343914713710546, -0.05830731987953186, 0.04883802309632301, -0.009164854884147644, -0.03290986642241478, 0.055648207664489746, 0.03680430352687836, -0.02544279769062996, -0.0006259852088987827, -0.021294325590133667, -0.060673508793115616, -0.04702695459127426, -0.015206082724034786, -0.033177509903907776, 0.04878905788064003, -0.040404412895441055, 0.02957037091255188, -0.0294692050665617, -0.02833481691777706, -0.05709049850702286, 0.002633390948176384, -0.026591917499899864, 0.04720209911465645, 0.051505785435438156, -0.005473753437399864, -0.0165655966848135, 0.024312106892466545, -0.03354484960436821, -0.011998187750577927, 0.020890366286039352, 0.03168025612831116, -0.03403400629758835, -0.006573454011231661, -0.056964144110679626, -0.043402962386608124, -0.055570490658283234, 0.041029684245586395, 0.03592788428068161, -0.028607385233044624, -0.03514266386628151, -0.0006858862470835447, 0.057051584124565125, -0.05217370018362999, -0.0690271258354187, 0.007729814387857914, -0.055361706763505936, -0.06592515110969543, -0.02188183180987835, -0.024699684232473373, 0.022518282756209373, 0.014547898434102535, 0.04192275181412697, 0.01690015383064747, 0.03973890468478203, 0.0112710976973176, 0.056574638932943344, 0.011304330080747604, -0.019688570871949196, -0.01204664632678032, -0.01664840430021286, -0.06085299700498581, 0.018603825941681862, -0.004933146759867668, 0.007486206945031881, 0.015289959497749805, 0.05320287123322487, -0.006110490299761295, 0.04120689630508423, -0.06609466671943665, 0.061766915023326874, 0.03604545071721077, -0.022419802844524384, -0.02319478988647461, 0.0023122301790863276, -0.04793648421764374, -0.01899007149040699, -0.04106523469090462, 0.0402151420712471, 0.0018807618180289865, -0.02856762520968914, -0.00963886920362711, 0.008745251223444939, -0.029161393642425537, 0.0022907780949026346, 0.005160738248378038, 0.031063102185726166, -0.07624196261167526, 0.026072297245264053, 0.005591301713138819, 0.013557768426835537, -0.06217394769191742, 0.006614740937948227, 0.011040925048291683, -0.027279971167445183, -0.018053393810987473, -0.017010977491736412, 0.05289217829704285, -0.020089782774448395, 0.02796369045972824, -0.05658198893070221, -0.04067922383546829, 0.042268056422472, -0.015910763293504715, 0.03056914731860161, 0.009837660938501358, 0.0047646029852330685, -0.003820510348305106, -0.0020834021270275116, -0.01893358677625656, -0.06584259867668152, -0.04081501439213753, -0.07340220361948013, 0.05819757655262947, 0.004456112161278725, 0.023793254047632217, 0.03187102824449539, 0.05441519245505333, -0.007571618538349867, -0.07753012329339981, -0.0013208077289164066, -0.02344619669020176, -0.003601999254897237, -0.003967690747231245, 0.008891293779015541, 0.007875451818108559, 0.012354215607047081, 0.002640197752043605, -0.017731614410877228, 0.009365328587591648, -0.05598004534840584, 0.013988141901791096, -0.05002719163894653, 0.025790026411414146, -0.008308283984661102, -0.07390788197517395, -0.010605023242533207, 0.055035680532455444, -0.05636415258049965, 0.04460655152797699, 0.03887752443552017, -0.002410296816378832, 0.0005716508603654802, -0.017757268622517586, 0.03834155201911926, -0.058537356555461884, -0.006367114372551441, 0.06237347051501274, -0.05650747939944267, 0.03875955939292908, 0.014967206865549088, -0.009060426615178585, 0.01063801720738411, -0.03055594302713871, 0.029484344646334648, 0.004828580189496279, -0.03274370729923248, -0.031542591750621796, 0.02885795384645462, 0.001319464179687202, -0.06280076503753662, -0.015084805898368359, 0.013447634875774384, -0.07622598856687546, 0.01557201612740755, -0.03560914099216461, -0.022589661180973053, -0.07337167859077454, 0.056776538491249084, -0.05864347517490387, -0.04103616997599602, -0.053395744413137436, 0.07414019107818604, 0.04283991828560829, -0.007639408577233553, -0.04852702468633652, -0.030122533440589905, -0.04896695166826248, 0.015543770045042038, -0.04804467782378197, -0.030989237129688263, 0.002297414932399988, 0.0019080491038039327, -0.029015280306339264, -0.009010928682982922, -0.015819696709513664, 0.03286522254347801, -0.001057116431184113, -0.03107689879834652, 0.02158120647072792, -0.011621453799307346, 0.06561800837516785, 0.0077163768000900745, -0.03882957994937897, 0.04647313803434372, -0.013351058587431908, 0.004165546037256718, -0.029760241508483887, 0.027877366170287132, 0.007410986348986626, -0.008830617181956768, 0.021892432123422623, -0.019438322633504868, 0.009349011816084385, -0.039789747446775436, -0.05143855884671211, 0.05328786373138428, 0.0007148613221943378, 0.014916774816811085, -0.0106648039072752, 0.027171164751052856, 0.021380018442869186, 0.005406447686254978, -0.052785735577344894, -0.01117923203855753, -0.02364642731845379, 0.035047415643930435, -0.023436114192008972, -0.004603342618793249, 0.04168865829706192, -0.043464697897434235, 0.05688079819083214, -0.03863786906003952, -0.033134184777736664, -0.04735124856233597, -0.04691363871097565, 0.012292603962123394, -0.012087183073163033, -0.06293605268001556, 0.007687763310968876, -0.010273280553519726, -0.029383989050984383, 0.03754793852567673, 0.0020912247709929943, -0.05417599901556969, -0.06959894299507141, 0.0044037229381501675, -0.060083724558353424, 0.021113522350788116, 0.053785547614097595, -0.02964821457862854, 0.004997411742806435, 0.018080564215779305, 0.025642022490501404, 0.018002010881900787, -0.003326688427478075, 0.06248177960515022, -0.04967980459332466, 0.037037432193756104, -0.04661235958337784, 0.013811739161610603, -0.02207556553184986, -0.029447302222251892, -0.03813459724187851, -0.07894077897071838, 0.01997542940080166, 0.005923154763877392, -0.005903366953134537, -0.030030783265829086, -0.0538712814450264, 0.024340996518731117, 0.028690578415989876, 0.0432976596057415, -0.07051289081573486, -0.03439442440867424, 0.050523146986961365, -0.05579015985131264, -0.002895209239795804, -0.01127710286527872, -0.060599926859140396, -0.04267285764217377, -0.08761706203222275, -0.013634087517857552, -0.03003925271332264, 0.06404664367437363, -0.0037507645320147276, -0.022953622043132782, -0.046469517052173615, -0.04880692809820175, 0.012679901905357838, 0.013568808324635029, 0.005072667263448238, 0.015147375874221325, 0.03401833400130272, 0.03590771555900574, -0.05128851905465126, 0.010336660780012608, 0.014454728923738003, -0.013311750255525112, 0.0009136967710219324, 0.029661571606993675, 0.04108051210641861, -0.013152193278074265, 0.02483305335044861, -0.03445892408490181, -0.05143015459179878, 0.014309619553387165, 0.0075711654499173164, -0.009089411236345768, -0.042763277888298035, -0.06091008335351944, 0.04880818724632263, -0.020076759159564972, -0.00014007469872012734, -0.010046951472759247, 0.05164981633424759, -0.032144784927368164, -0.0010640585096552968, -0.037996720522642136, 0.03635912016034126, 0.03897789493203163, 0.035374827682971954, 0.04033590108156204, -0.03326937183737755, -0.023681938648223877, -0.026972007006406784, -0.029300738126039505, -0.04273427650332451, 0.024850837886333466, 0.015516630373895168, -0.06473859399557114, -0.017852744087576866, -0.06074729561805725, 0.035336676985025406, -0.033059123903512955, -0.006916529033333063, -0.020293496549129486, 0.05625487491488457, -0.07070677727460861, -0.050542689859867096, -0.008958838880062103, -0.056627307087183, -0.013617864809930325, -0.045439478009939194, 0.012231223285198212, 0.027217580005526543, 0.00856615137308836, -0.00015585561050102115, 0.03470442444086075, -0.00589438620954752, 0.05839540809392929, 0.02669205702841282, 0.033177245408296585, 0.027073316276073456, -0.039052363485097885, -0.040829867124557495, 0.029857099056243896, 0.018693335354328156, -0.05292251706123352, -0.061677947640419006, 0.03718031197786331, 0.046967629343271255, -0.0050858729518949986, -0.016644485294818878, -0.0004995927447453141, 0.007599369157105684, -0.0521174892783165, -0.04952997714281082, 0.00041696650441735983, 0.014193872921168804, -0.023054886609315872, 0.0577993169426918, 0.018939688801765442, 0.028626833111047745, -0.04210910573601723 ]
When deploying machine learning estimators in science and engineering (SAE) domains, it is critical to avoid failed estimations that can have disastrous consequences, e.g., in aero engine design. This work focuses on detecting and correcting failed state estimations before adopting them in SAE inverse problems, by utilizing simulations and performance metrics guided by physical laws. We suggest to flag a machine learning estimation when its physical model error exceeds a feasible threshold, and propose a novel approach, GEESE, to correct it through optimization, aiming at delivering both low error and high efficiency. The key designs of GEESE include (1) a hybrid surrogate error model to provide fast error estimations to reduce simulation cost and to enable gradient based backpropagation of error feedback, and (2) two generative models to approximate the probability distributions of the candidate states for simulating the exploitation and exploration behaviours. All three models are constructed as neural networks. GEESE is tested on three real-world SAE inverse problems and compared to a number of state-of-the-art optimization/search approaches. Results show that it fails the least number of times in terms of finding a feasible state correction, and requires physical evaluations less frequently in general.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13985v2
[ -0.05306592583656311, -0.05608353018760681, 0.024809952825307846, 0.008648148737847805, -0.011611075140535831, -0.01207317877560854, 0.0272422656416893, 0.04590379446744919, -0.011239083483815193, -0.030187828466296196, -0.02465108409523964, -0.009454896673560143, -0.036421533674001694, -0.009728409349918365, -0.0433894544839859, 0.036660969257354736, 0.07046397030353546, 0.008684899657964706, -0.03377418592572212, 0.05763515084981918, 0.005872492212802172, 0.045293260365724564, -0.0416124127805233, 0.01396474614739418, -0.026024019345641136, -0.004869934171438217, -0.03502727672457695, 0.009975647553801537, -0.006686793174594641, 0.03201700747013092, 0.05884974077343941, -0.04295143112540245, -0.004687568172812462, -0.058802973479032516, -0.020888926461338997, -0.06388869881629944, -0.008258633315563202, 0.03360183164477348, 0.059539709240198135, -0.05600718408823013, -0.011621478945016861, -0.044714368879795074, -0.075766421854496, 0.013263901695609093, -0.03475101292133331, -0.00954778678715229, -0.03514322638511658, 0.0029393385630100965, -0.04870906099677086, -0.046655166894197464, 0.04086018353700638, -0.04402247816324234, -0.003691153833642602, 0.04869720712304115, -0.039630867540836334, 0.017788290977478027, -0.0342487208545208, -0.006902307737618685, -0.0544632263481617, -0.024282265454530716, 0.029750408604741096, -0.0455508790910244, 0.0006594257429242134, 0.022507792338728905, -0.0009571121190674603, 0.02393489144742489, -0.018254781141877174, -0.04948786273598671, -0.051910966634750366, -0.04296298697590828, 0.03815831243991852, -0.06718887388706207, -0.0022036938462406397, 0.05278295651078224, -0.016914062201976776, -0.06464066356420517, -0.010202040895819664, -0.03786737099289894, 0.02655542455613613, -0.021297723054885864, -0.037236832082271576, 0.0321301706135273, 0.029999516904354095, 0.03229007497429848, 0.008154884912073612, -0.001780143240466714, 0.03741703927516937, -0.012648864649236202, 0.003165109781548381, -0.05497939512133598, 0.01583067514002323, -0.05868325009942055, -0.07975412905216217, -0.02407396398484707, 0.050331730395555496, -0.013844319619238377, 0.05585047975182533, 0.017828062176704407, 0.04415888339281082, -0.03114851377904415, -0.011235796846449375, -0.043117765337228775, -0.04255087301135063, 0.06432186812162399, 0.049172379076480865, -0.05148831009864807, 0.0018150414107367396, -0.01937698759138584, -0.06503531336784363, -0.0008677362347953022, -0.049479175359010696, -0.019043967127799988, 0.01231810450553894, -0.0717846006155014, -0.05609993264079094, -0.037773456424474716, 0.04422953724861145, 0.0064383093267679214, 0.03459708020091057, 0.028116920962929726, -0.027504170313477516, 0.039296139031648636, 0.05599471926689148, -0.036132413893938065, -0.004102346021682024, 0.022178588435053825, 0.05158064141869545, 0.0003143313224427402, -0.01894369162619114, 0.017048170790076256, -0.034244272857904434, 0.048633720725774765, -0.00411726301535964, -0.04856323078274727, 0.026417339220643044, 0.00573264854028821, -0.021080641075968742, -0.013007615692913532, -0.0012939701555296779, -0.014451013877987862, -0.03966883197426796, -0.07226573675870895, 0.006197022739797831, -0.0003720714303199202, 0.04897056147456169, 0.06465979665517807, -0.045886315405368805, -0.03265513479709625, 0.029625868424773216, 0.026799360290169716, 0.03463921695947647, -0.03145505115389824, 0.031912028789520264, 0.019524073228240013, 0.06266303360462189, -0.054168153554201126, 0.03484886512160301, -0.03325660899281502, -0.035402145236730576, 0.004539589863270521, 0.015927523374557495, -0.04230146482586861, 0.020022407174110413, -0.041879963129758835, 0.008818979375064373, 0.0217900313436985, 0.030497727915644646, -0.026709292083978653, -0.01700614020228386, 0.009867940098047256, 0.0039477902464568615, 0.01950685866177082, -0.004126687068492174, -0.020503899082541466, -0.035149116069078445, -0.02855662815272808, 0.036251019686460495, -0.06603001803159714, -0.05372751131653786, -0.0008005964918993413, 0.032402411103248596, 0.051811251789331436, -0.04116053506731987, 0.06078784540295601, -0.038958024233579636, -0.026229199022054672, -0.08993375301361084, 0.01810014620423317, -0.007710081525146961, 0.034320808947086334, -0.01360780093818903, -0.029728339985013008, 0.02114989422261715, 0.008012688718736172, -0.04348205029964447, -0.03672605752944946, 0.04358348622918129, -0.02219831757247448, -0.012364418245851994, 0.024808023124933243, -0.08829285204410553, 0.0175982266664505, -0.028088174760341644, -0.004096410237252712, -0.04166878014802933, -0.0625867024064064, 0.007111240644007921, 0.062060825526714325, 0.019265512004494667, 0.00887200515717268, 0.050620947033166885, 0.01564350165426731, 0.039494115859270096, 0.034342676401138306, 0.025737471878528595, 0.013493816368281841, -0.09491008520126343, 0.06338080763816833, -0.03503846004605293, 0.00538082979619503, 0.04970955103635788, 0.01825750060379505, -0.019896887242794037, -0.019886439666152, 0.03308999165892601, 0.03505653142929077, 0.03030751645565033, -0.037262212485075, -0.024260947480797768, -0.01956717111170292, -0.01927201822400093, -0.05727554112672806, -0.05803820490837097, -0.0627797394990921, -0.015763048082590103, 0.03672465309500694, -0.013707523234188557, 0.04491432383656502, -0.010435793548822403, -0.023406561464071274, -0.04932749643921852, -0.020100602880120277, 0.021459059789776802, -0.01643248088657856, -0.05291007459163666, -0.04020160436630249, -0.04239823296666145, 0.025583839043974876, -0.01956837996840477, 0.006566752679646015, -0.04030217230319977, -0.04005644470453262, -0.024704648181796074, -0.038872744888067245, 0.02239505760371685, 0.050186432898044586, -0.03189339116215706, 0.02062842808663845, -0.023112157359719276, 0.04591929167509079, 0.023940157145261765, -0.02538173273205757, -0.03916265442967415, -0.010529682040214539, 0.05015450343489647, -0.020107323303818703, -0.01197828259319067, 0.0028907954692840576, 0.022992638871073723, -0.05301942303776741, 0.016369175165891647, -0.004924478940665722, 0.06247807294130325, 0.02283180132508278, -0.0231084655970335, -0.045959748327732086, -0.03635710850358009, -0.06543822586536407, 0.030683670192956924, 0.0243676844984293, 0.03770160675048828, 0.004446529783308506, 0.01598561927676201, -0.06467578560113907, 0.005534982308745384, -0.037121858447790146, 0.008467257022857666, -0.0527825653553009, -0.07454197108745575, -0.025540607050061226, -0.08032605051994324, -0.03942389413714409, -0.019180675968527794, -0.041238028556108475, -0.031703267246484756, -0.06713318824768066, -0.0029279969166964293, 0.0118488734588027, 0.030186552554368973, 0.003912534099072218, -0.04461754485964775, -0.041416335850954056, -0.0005155621329322457, 0.04967818036675453, -0.00416402705013752, -0.018364835530519485, -0.03956805542111397, -0.04881848767399788, 0.029225006699562073, -0.019165482372045517, -0.050265539437532425, 0.0012336175423115492, -0.043173860758543015, 0.013981202617287636, 0.00055620790226385, 0.0042876689694821835, -0.003013778477907181, 0.03107330948114395, -0.00961049273610115, -0.010754989460110664, 0.016910025849938393, 0.007873186841607094, 0.03824590891599655, -0.04606063663959503, -0.04678571596741676, -0.033489346504211426, 0.057790715247392654, -0.04066295176744461, -0.04476401209831238, -0.020579105243086815, -0.030623378232121468, 0.02724732831120491, 0.0010614775819703937, -0.022808687761425972, -0.002502844901755452, 0.03935777023434639, -0.04498520866036415, -0.0055774603970348835, 0.00615684362128377, -0.032218556851148605, -0.01820986531674862, 0.03050067275762558, 0.0010161838727071881, 0.01563124731183052, 0.05059763789176941, -0.07472919672727585, 0.0038668138440698385, 0.009311310946941376, 0.07246126979589462, -0.02593863010406494, -0.007381601259112358, 0.013201517052948475, -0.022606585174798965, 0.03739288076758385, -0.026245485991239548, 0.07198686897754669, 0.022572366520762444, 0.05620400235056877, -0.030536819249391556, -0.03382294997572899, 0.010979455895721912, -0.0691794902086258, -0.04071967676281929, 0.0027295227628201246, 0.04961302503943443, 0.026431268081068993, 0.009243875741958618, -0.04921954497694969, 0.030782535672187805, 0.012183550745248795, 0.03845972195267677, -0.004807798657566309, -0.0010005265939980745, 0.05043414607644081, -0.04798836633563042, -0.003594661131501198, 0.06623024493455887, -0.00973664503544569, 0.01253398135304451, -0.06477878242731094, 0.008571682497859001, -0.06079496070742607, 0.030160346999764442, 0.004024027846753597, -0.02845297008752823, 0.0647519901394844, 0.014596863649785519, -0.03923623263835907, 0.059922732412815094, -0.003474840661510825, -0.023843012750148773, -0.0265895314514637, -0.017536334693431854, 0.008033601567149162, -0.016906816512346268, -0.060325346887111664, -0.011840212158858776, 0.013701148331165314, -0.029400628060102463, -0.020998012274503708, 0.0017761057242751122, 0.010064458474516869, -0.011930134147405624, -0.07213117182254791, 0.022983908653259277, -0.024944139644503593, 0.03135273978114128, -0.035653796046972275, -0.019028324633836746, 0.07156351953744888, -0.03125588223338127, -0.01684117689728737, -0.027200790122151375, -0.012023123912513256, -0.06016819179058075, -0.03496897593140602, -0.05097110569477081, -0.07626949995756149, 0.0046845837496221066, -0.03547986224293709, 0.038480326533317566, 0.01354390848428011, 0.016125814989209175, -0.05424519255757332, -0.0632573664188385, 0.012367667630314827, 0.020782025530934334, 0.066312275826931, 0.029983604326844215, -0.04322131723165512, -0.027982881292700768, -0.026757776737213135, -0.03405846282839775, -0.033169325441122055, 0.001472976291552186, 0.006093920208513737, 0.040071748197078705, -0.00538273761048913, -0.030183080583810806, -0.031994182616472244, 0.035461824387311935, 0.06745187193155289, -0.027441339567303658, -0.05090460926294327, 0.002458675531670451, 0.052813608199357986, -0.06650345772504807, -0.06618030369281769, -0.0036613100674003363, -0.041158780455589294, -0.07316269725561142, -0.05367445945739746, 0.021975262090563774, -0.020220734179019928, 0.003128871787339449, 0.0192293468862772, -0.00679773697629571, -0.018978994339704514, 0.01303694024682045, 0.035246796905994415, 0.02288893051445484, 0.024993015453219414, 0.004709258209913969, -0.05708887428045273, -0.08010192960500717, -0.007054294925183058, -0.05478738620877266, 0.02636096253991127, -0.026280364021658897, 0.049645230174064636, 0.0441318117082119, 0.05360841006040573, -0.08027689903974533, 0.04447368532419205, 0.03603685647249222, 0.028381068259477615, -0.01699586771428585, 0.04628855735063553, -0.030131904408335686, 0.0270769614726305, -0.04997092857956886, 0.022704046219587326, 0.028522776439785957, -0.03873034194111824, 0.02933781035244465, 0.001837771967984736, -0.04984712228178978, -0.003174115438014269, 0.07782379537820816, -0.028594976291060448, -0.05332501605153084, 0.013563328422605991, 0.024902861565351486, 0.02926820144057274, -0.007763068191707134, 0.014544370584189892, 0.03991874307394028, -0.011963446624577045, -0.031141504645347595, -0.04717640206217766, 0.013529928401112556, -0.006932099815458059, -0.004706564359366894, -0.06126195192337036, -0.01784403994679451, 0.01643015816807747, 0.030441120266914368, 0.04077199101448059, 0.022062158212065697, -0.03788623958826065, 0.02689078263938427, -0.01447189599275589, 0.02617790549993515, -0.060121532529592514, 0.012081481516361237, -0.011370974592864513, 0.037375904619693756, 0.03621503338217735, 0.03208712115883827, 0.0008732597343623638, 0.02335863560438156, -0.06806930154561996, -0.038247063755989075, 0.029528269544243813, -0.005743295419961214, 0.042408108711242676, -0.04609496891498566, 0.06954709440469742, 0.011990692466497421, 0.02941177785396576, -0.003002370707690716, -0.008964852429926395, 0.0038390373811125755, -0.040165916085243225, -0.03351208195090294, -0.014118099585175514, 0.030898012220859528, -0.016288114711642265, -0.028182975947856903, 0.03236331790685654, 0.01204354502260685, -0.024060292169451714, 0.025178616866469383, 0.03973143920302391, 0.02402462624013424, 0.03456436097621918, -0.026737099513411522, -0.02476978674530983, -0.05251087620854378, 0.05736858397722244, 0.06409838795661926, -0.04340888932347298, 0.03858008235692978, -0.04274093359708786, 0.007047730498015881, 0.027197429910302162, -0.05543746054172516, 0.050039444118738174, -0.014964607544243336, -0.03494453802704811, -0.06139380484819412, 0.03608857840299606, 0.008151962421834469, -0.07003963738679886, -0.016541020944714546, 0.01263967715203762, -0.058858007192611694, -0.0003539836034178734, 0.015539927408099174, 0.01295399758964777, -0.0433979257941246, 0.024989580735564232, -0.01843968592584133, -0.0071135228499770164, -0.05015208572149277, 0.06380274146795273, 0.08155660331249237, 0.005123777315020561, 0.016589896753430367, -0.014838754199445248, -0.04657607525587082, 0.01977052539587021, -0.001992099219933152, -0.030913883820176125, 0.024193905293941498, 0.01771574653685093, 0.03275018930435181, -0.024071747437119484, -0.04608452320098877, 0.07178326696157455, -0.03473985567688942, -0.009433289058506489, 0.027390876784920692, 0.005106261931359768, 0.034013912081718445, -0.02400093711912632, -0.03397136926651001, -0.023646770045161247, 0.0029418880585581064, -0.04382423311471939, -0.034172479063272476, -0.008720016106963158, -0.03173193335533142, 0.002896287012845278, -0.025790560990571976, -0.05113239213824272, 0.018761632964015007, -0.0259537473320961, -0.03702981397509575, 0.014884192496538162, -0.042372457683086395, -0.015977898612618446, 0.01114485040307045, 0.0019035066943615675, 0.021594244986772537, 0.0725112184882164, -0.037822429090738297, -0.006154893431812525, 0.03397030383348465, 0.021593086421489716, 0.002044110558927059, 0.004928522277623415, 0.03155794367194176, -0.020680611953139305, 0.036827925592660904, 0.011283219791948795, -0.06067698448896408, -0.04964222013950348, -0.03088964708149433, 0.012619921006262302, 0.0007896383758634329, -0.01469724252820015, -0.05408107489347458, 0.050901129841804504, -0.027426019310951233, 0.02743838168680668, 0.035624608397483826, -0.042788684368133545, -0.05015471577644348, 0.04047476500272751, 0.01825270615518093, -0.04988477751612663, 0.0001910851860884577, 0.033519960939884186, 0.01678057573735714, -0.019196756184101105, 0.02202809974551201, 0.013989483006298542, -0.008241072297096252, 0.019679542630910873, -0.055725935846567154, -0.04280920699238777, 0.04667221009731293, 0.03634391352534294, -0.05751609429717064, -0.01385013572871685, 0.0019159730290994048, -0.031075943261384964, -0.012350416742265224, 0.06945494562387466, 0.010181532241404057, -0.0016756976256147027, -0.06868404150009155, 0.009956167079508305, -0.011733104474842548, -0.03163713589310646, -0.0369536317884922, -0.003806609893217683, 0.01080721989274025, 0.008277801796793938, -0.02098710462450981, 0.026727432385087013, -0.03579103201627731, 0.014156844466924667, -0.08764248341321945, 0.0030312244780361652, 0.010990736074745655, 0.0658770352602005, -0.02180967666208744, -0.04045923054218292, -0.04207324981689453, -0.027812043204903603, 0.01860848255455494, -0.004451305605471134, 0.005707044154405594, 0.007401662413030863, 0.045640118420124054, 0.022017236799001694, -0.04194176569581032, -0.04262671619653702, 0.07106926292181015, -0.010127585381269455, -0.019123347476124763, 0.02237061783671379, -0.033761799335479736, 0.0386526845395565, 0.018039898946881294, 0.048563938587903976, -0.03555353730916977, 0.03675049543380737, -0.03365935757756233, 0.01994694024324417, -0.06272774934768677, -0.07797084748744965, 0.03019596077501774, -0.02312657982110977, -0.023140015080571175, -0.0037910044193267822, 0.014848481863737106, -0.03755298629403114, -0.011651728302240372, -0.03625171631574631, 0.05969605967402458, -0.01150597259402275, -0.03283116966485977, 0.018511807546019554, -0.022704152390360832, -0.031087961047887802, -0.053059693425893784, 0.0052518825978040695, -0.0040710484609007835, 0.03431009128689766, 0.04006747156381607, -0.060448598116636276, -0.014632018283009529, -0.02180841751396656, -0.014505757950246334, -0.0018869952764362097, 0.0501030832529068, -0.012837703339755535, 0.06605896353721619, -0.004552880767732859, -0.01270734891295433, -0.04511216655373573, -0.037329599261283875, -0.05459160730242729, -0.06779474020004272, -0.016600877046585083, -0.029830684885382652, 0.022413838654756546, -0.009029733948409557, -0.007738293148577213, 0.00018039594579022378, 0.05082240328192711, 0.02772148698568344, -0.006733488757163286, 0.008927585557103157, -0.01694447360932827, -0.04722895473241806, 0.06890623271465302, 0.04498417302966118, -0.02134907804429531, -0.016477620229125023, 0.041099049150943756, 0.014159759506583214, -0.038842059671878815, -0.02073974907398224, 0.013882957398891449, -0.046043556183576584, 0.010782871395349503, 0.020799923688173294, 0.014427215792238712, -0.028032055124640465, -0.020255601033568382, -0.0028516766615211964, 0.021422162652015686, -0.022044237703084946, -0.04283612221479416 ]
Inspired by the detection of $T_{cc}$ tetraquark state by LHCb Collaboration, we preform a systemical investigation of the low-lying doubly heavy charm tetraquark states with strangeness in the quark delocalization color screening model in the present work. Two kinds of configurations, the meson-meson configuration and diquark-antidiquark configuration, are considered in the calculation. Our estimations indicate that the coupled channel effects play important role in the multiquark system, and a bound state with $J^{P}=1^{+}$ and a resonance state with $J^{P}=0^{+}$ have been predicted. The mass of the bound state is evaluated to be $(3971\sim3975)$ MeV, while the mass and width of the resonance are determined to be $(4113\sim4114)$ MeV and $(14.3\sim 16.1)$ MeV, respectively.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07728v1
[ -0.052272673696279526, -0.016075175255537033, 0.06733502447605133, -0.012540049850940704, 0.011308727785944939, -0.021821483969688416, -0.03275797516107559, 0.03730633109807968, -0.032269109040498734, -0.004866099916398525, 0.00492287240922451, -0.05919475853443146, -0.0031153238378465176, -0.03441902622580528, -0.043164633214473724, 0.020685287192463875, 0.0250749122351408, 0.05819447338581085, -0.0062360260635614395, 0.06470687687397003, -0.02659270539879799, -0.039902351796627045, -0.010034157894551754, 0.04081253707408905, 0.021227821707725525, 0.01751566305756569, -0.02142667956650257, 0.012297095730900764, -0.03382168710231781, -0.0008128421031869948, 0.0522029846906662, 0.0013790314551442862, -0.027991238981485367, -0.04188846796751022, -0.006886410992592573, -0.015035203658044338, -0.0019883166532963514, 0.0644621029496193, 0.02367292530834675, -0.0459151566028595, -0.015817075967788696, -0.0302075557410717, -0.07369502633810043, -0.01914733089506626, -0.024692032486200333, -0.023011745885014534, -0.015895109623670578, -0.011173306964337826, -0.049242448061704636, -0.07188202440738678, 0.023037688806653023, 0.032424792647361755, -0.02426658198237419, 0.061417289078235626, -0.029913177713751793, 0.01433858647942543, -0.027274198830127716, -0.04121154174208641, -0.06807715445756912, 0.00594445550814271, 0.008408562280237675, -0.03606012091040611, -0.018139705061912537, -0.010058113373816013, -0.004834052640944719, 0.03112463839352131, -0.06052881106734276, -0.052953433245420456, 0.02723800390958786, -0.0560973696410656, 0.04810122027993202, -0.06547346711158752, 0.02470945380628109, -0.003951480146497488, -0.05755045637488365, 0.009593825787305832, -0.0014789900742471218, -0.03328479081392288, -0.05541868135333061, 0.02934432029724121, -0.047439150512218475, -0.01949162222445011, -0.005557271186262369, -0.0011756144231185317, 0.03000813163816929, 0.01650574989616871, 0.06459018588066101, -0.05555475130677223, 0.018720081076025963, -0.06333734840154648, 0.0038923402316868305, -0.027813561260700226, -0.05805399268865585, -0.0325690396130085, 0.04195527732372284, -0.04764189571142197, 0.0646066814661026, 0.054101090878248215, 0.04941664636135101, -0.02226182259619236, -0.014825675636529922, -0.03571160510182381, 0.009680943563580513, 0.027082419022917747, 0.03965933620929718, -0.011748758144676685, 0.0032423734664916992, -0.006703347899019718, -0.040385618805885315, 0.011109168641269207, -0.03353046253323555, 0.0010605861898511648, -0.01586112752556801, -0.0760967880487442, -0.05610160157084465, -0.03499283641576767, 0.060683030635118484, 0.05308928340673447, 0.01741548627614975, 0.005528996232897043, -0.009672670625150204, 0.05152324214577675, -0.021971434354782104, -0.010971399955451488, -0.032393477857112885, -0.008600790984928608, 0.024900518357753754, 0.0487397238612175, -0.006212178617715836, -0.03405198082327843, -0.031382616609334946, -0.01842336356639862, 0.029481854289770126, -0.06483794748783112, -0.0004917804035358131, -0.036351967602968216, 0.025250140577554703, -0.02892770618200302, 0.00013556201884057373, -0.02058299072086811, -0.037352271378040314, -0.06813955307006836, 0.003913108725100756, 0.018359800800681114, 0.003179393708705902, 0.05478544905781746, -0.066734679043293, 0.007967574521899223, 0.03062363900244236, 0.054231125861406326, -0.012898389250040054, -0.016784384846687317, -0.002449131803587079, -0.010563653893768787, 0.033383529633283615, -0.02781982533633709, 0.06161084398627281, 0.013414664193987846, -0.03461802378296852, 0.06784553080797195, 0.008021580055356026, -0.016582755371928215, 0.006062171421945095, -0.016426121816039085, -0.03921021521091461, -0.006747497245669365, -0.010749518871307373, 0.012194235809147358, -0.012765694409608841, -0.02958095818758011, -0.002017431426793337, -0.02895704098045826, 0.004635769873857498, -0.05254048854112625, -0.06958401203155518, -0.03614799305796623, -0.039237190037965775, -0.04920349642634392, -0.0023993158247321844, -0.0118969501927495, 0.0027189557440578938, -0.00965757854282856, -0.009211909025907516, 0.011213323101401329, -0.056300681084394455, 0.012597444467246532, -0.06726106256246567, 0.017170986160635948, 0.043225061148405075, 0.007036109920591116, 0.009053531102836132, -0.01976887881755829, 0.025544557720422745, 0.02842571958899498, -0.061213262379169464, -0.025972239673137665, 0.018885575234889984, -0.03622893989086151, 0.0068390145897865295, 0.020701676607131958, -0.05874648690223694, -0.003147682175040245, -0.03641926869750023, 0.014535583555698395, 0.0010622256668284535, -0.07688102126121521, -0.015161831863224506, 0.025272035971283913, -0.04956922307610512, -0.0715891569852829, 0.06421491503715515, 0.011103763245046139, 0.044495854526758194, -0.002424434060230851, -0.02663726918399334, 0.02708924002945423, -0.09736426919698715, 0.0535973384976387, 0.06411594897508621, -0.007555890828371048, 0.06601285189390182, -0.01190945040434599, 0.01926240883767605, -0.03319990262389183, -0.05956152081489563, 0.05568929761648178, 0.03583980351686478, 0.026009850203990936, -0.037421077489852905, -0.006227661389857531, 0.0003473154501989484, -0.07112240046262741, -0.01476263627409935, -0.04789847880601883, -0.029678087681531906, -0.046009600162506104, -0.06843340396881104, 0.062197476625442505, -0.00633550388738513, -0.050331853330135345, -0.05462382361292839, 0.016164788976311684, 0.03958489000797272, -0.035211000591516495, -0.04503597319126129, -0.0007805463392287493, -0.06756206601858139, 0.014363340102136135, -0.029487231746315956, 0.02735726349055767, -0.0060021900571882725, -0.0384795255959034, -0.03184300288558006, -0.019797291606664658, 0.026619119569659233, 0.0653916448354721, 0.013915646821260452, -0.019801508635282516, 0.0066416882909834385, 0.0361032597720623, 0.020326685160398483, 0.053953640162944794, -0.02242990955710411, 0.029105015099048615, -0.02973254956305027, 0.032398372888565063, -0.041480422019958496, -0.006947588175535202, -0.019950058311223984, -0.03213247284293175, -0.004177543800324202, -0.02008485049009323, 0.019623106345534325, 0.026502804830670357, 0.004159776493906975, -0.019250208511948586, -0.05187497287988663, 0.005620906129479408, 0.027237094938755035, 0.011615748517215252, 0.05177224427461624, 0.056729983538389206, -0.028055010363459587, -0.07462114095687866, 0.01727481745183468, -0.03602999448776245, -0.026638062670826912, -0.07125944644212723, -0.030775612220168114, -0.0007284299354068935, -0.05736899375915527, -0.00010056539031211287, -0.008278969675302505, -0.016939131543040276, -0.0541776567697525, -0.06679970026016235, -0.029394200071692467, -0.015718430280685425, 0.014719642698764801, -0.07137420028448105, -0.03194650262594223, -0.017675943672657013, 0.017442485317587852, 0.02844189666211605, -0.021341871470212936, -0.029338106513023376, -0.056509487330913544, 0.01921052485704422, -0.00473220506682992, -0.020492689684033394, -0.03247382491827011, 0.004298088606446981, -0.03234313428401947, -0.004368167836219072, -0.011362964287400246, 0.06423357129096985, -0.026649922132492065, -0.055193427950143814, 0.030193962156772614, 0.0068097240291535854, -0.013237584382295609, -0.006305296439677477, 0.009942758828401566, -0.012038295157253742, -0.06185709312558174, -0.0065264953300356865, 0.07470782846212387, 0.07163389027118683, -0.005157595034688711, -0.03536785766482353, -0.026396505534648895, 0.017301371321082115, 0.010172795504331589, 0.022837966680526733, 0.05396975949406624, 0.026150502264499664, -0.04723349213600159, -0.022986581549048424, -0.044077999889850616, 0.012392381206154823, -0.047883860766887665, -0.012788915075361729, 0.017943626269698143, 0.0012409737100824714, -0.011613097973167896, -0.08125116676092148, 0.059976570308208466, 0.06604886054992676, 0.07336451858282089, -0.00953055452555418, 0.005935903638601303, 0.01942405290901661, 0.012618385255336761, -0.034540146589279175, -0.015537688508629799, 0.04324880987405777, 0.021495597437024117, 0.04753771051764488, -0.023466745391488075, -0.03396684303879738, -0.026436125859618187, -0.05098872259259224, -0.05861552432179451, 0.03413596376776695, 0.030795304104685783, -0.007173279300332069, 0.018093092367053032, -0.04837118461728096, 0.04044518247246742, -0.0015529700322076678, 0.033565979450941086, -0.04998284578323364, -0.035049185156822205, -0.007617782335728407, -0.01286398433148861, -0.013692483305931091, 0.0029884784016758204, 0.018304919824004173, -0.0422823429107666, -0.05122696980834007, -0.018144920468330383, -0.07567961513996124, 0.007566434796899557, -0.00930915866047144, 0.021082518622279167, 0.01690397784113884, 0.017056908458471298, 0.017092270776629448, 0.02831762284040451, -0.03199794143438339, 0.016006246209144592, -0.01259284932166338, 0.03220253810286522, 0.006089224014431238, -0.031497418880462646, -0.012692767195403576, -0.026333535090088844, -0.004705837927758694, -0.07305631041526794, -0.03334563598036766, 0.03522560000419617, 0.011813491582870483, -0.05402341112494469, -0.08047054708003998, -0.06508491188287735, -0.00003350722181494348, -0.02461593970656395, 0.030774952843785286, -0.06967512518167496, 0.05239018052816391, -0.0015326847787946463, -0.0009310499299317598, -0.03407725691795349, -0.021633081138134003, -0.01615149900317192, -0.06261932849884033, -0.02551710419356823, 0.004401504527777433, 0.037451572716236115, -0.06317780911922455, -0.00198877090588212, -0.016959546133875847, -0.02895531617105007, -0.06527969241142273, 0.02906147763133049, 0.02997911162674427, 0.04706830531358719, 0.04808958247303963, 0.01602254807949066, 0.029465019702911377, -0.028700057417154312, 0.04464969038963318, -0.04598368704319, -0.04148894175887108, 0.05791798233985901, -0.02143140509724617, 0.052657753229141235, -0.060902975499629974, -0.030598508194088936, -0.011044133454561234, -0.01075634267181158, 0.032360997051000595, 0.008949129842221737, 0.028238102793693542, 0.01663682796061039, 0.015270194038748741, -0.06109316274523735, -0.04206987842917442, -0.014606306329369545, -0.023327112197875977, -0.055226922035217285, 0.011838649399578571, 0.024326123297214508, 0.007817600853741169, -0.03643381595611572, 0.03722625598311424, 0.018573887646198273, 0.03269127011299133, -0.057530373334884644, 0.046807706356048584, 0.017367947846651077, 0.05722874030470848, 0.005209007300436497, -0.0038830717094242573, -0.07884594053030014, 0.03573029115796089, 0.013973899185657501, 0.0008355682366527617, 0.00918878335505724, 0.04315720498561859, -0.007484932895749807, 0.02936297096312046, -0.09346144646406174, 0.03946132957935333, 0.05964542552828789, -0.04765339568257332, 0.012052291072905064, 0.024411233142018318, -0.028503093868494034, -0.02242821641266346, -0.024625934660434723, 0.022303614765405655, -0.017032109200954437, -0.015241333283483982, -0.029167162254452705, 0.022075694054365158, -0.02753414958715439, 0.0050809625536203384, 0.019557124003767967, 0.02614184096455574, -0.058120954781770706, 0.0020040376111865044, 0.052554212510585785, 0.009231379255652428, -0.04907926172018051, 0.06252512335777283, 0.04278900474309921, -0.048893965780735016, -0.059307411313056946, 0.01526891440153122, -0.033216334879398346, 0.049223557114601135, 0.03786291554570198, -0.03213353827595711, 0.003343219868838787, -0.0353873036801815, -0.0024797439109534025, 0.009975163266062737, 0.05184905603528023, -0.000332617579260841, -0.05226103588938713, 0.014513462781906128, -0.0031173143070191145, -0.06380205601453781, 0.025954781100153923, -0.04072690010070801, 0.01563088409602642, 0.01683269627392292, -0.006048701237887144, 0.03818763792514801, 0.02204803004860878, 0.02024986781179905, -0.041846759617328644, -0.050051283091306686, 0.006506967358291149, 0.06787420064210892, -0.023611824959516525, -0.004483355209231377, -0.006021382752805948, 0.011871982365846634, -0.005278999451547861, -0.01958397589623928, -0.025895316153764725, 0.008942047134041786, -0.02930563874542713, 0.004019180778414011, -0.03024483658373356, 0.02298872545361519, -0.027196019887924194, 0.021958984434604645, 0.04939363896846771, -0.047734808176755905, 0.057120535522699356, 0.00016759273421484977, 0.020767103880643845, -0.003911102656275034, 0.02325577847659588, 0.06207488477230072, -0.08827796578407288, -0.021938558667898178, 0.05342606455087662, -0.06602685898542404, 0.0005130062927491963, -0.007757909595966339, -0.023530643433332443, 0.04799512028694153, -0.061564017087221146, -0.019736269488930702, 0.040943317115306854, 0.006961110047996044, 0.0028767359908670187, 0.047581471502780914, -0.0025232317857444286, -0.059860195964574814, -0.0216175839304924, -0.004740784410387278, -0.0724121630191803, 0.03342020884156227, -0.008017659187316895, -0.03337790444493294, -0.010965973138809204, 0.010847965255379677, -0.06226393207907677, -0.05128121376037598, -0.038642797619104385, 0.027181023731827736, 0.051755938678979874, -0.026867931708693504, -0.0032372844871133566, -0.01950334757566452, 0.011697506532073021, -0.006372206844389439, -0.05607780069112778, -0.07284565269947052, 0.005593455396592617, 0.05662835016846657, 0.05520068109035492, -0.03351937234401703, 0.001910718041472137, 0.0345572829246521, 0.06088480353355408, 0.009511929005384445, 0.03842967748641968, -0.0019141724333167076, 0.047659020870923996, 0.013217153027653694, -0.05341162905097008, 0.01991313137114048, -0.049107011407613754, -0.019223595038056374, -0.01776784658432007, 0.0500178299844265, 0.006624060217291117, 0.01509585976600647, -0.005266738589853048, -0.030730457976460457, -0.01623033732175827, 0.015535642392933369, -0.0367652103304863, -0.020366564393043518, -0.061472781002521515, 0.03350001946091652, -0.01591281034052372, 0.05589950829744339, -0.03753712773323059, -0.01595255360007286, -0.027524176985025406, 0.02354126237332821, -0.020094268023967743, -0.0005724949296563864, 0.01357841957360506, 0.03453528508543968, 0.005193905904889107, -0.0443463958799839, 0.045264191925525665, -0.04610433056950569, 0.039480678737163544, -0.03782428801059723, -0.05748128145933151, 0.016495566815137863, -0.004265326075255871, -0.008746204897761345, -0.058824047446250916, 0.005751762073487043, -0.004078330937772989, 0.022879594936966896, 0.0013651393819600344, -0.007065624929964542, -0.05056605115532875, 0.015239810571074486, -0.0009327357984147966, -0.017772626131772995, 0.034721702337265015, -0.015527908690273762, 0.05247129499912262, 0.032857105135917664, 0.007527791894972324, 0.01656750962138176, 0.007889417000114918, -0.029569044709205627, -0.05688313767313957, 0.05084984749555588, 0.05036129057407379, 0.01746409200131893, -0.032439153641462326, -0.0024872547946870327, -0.045926034450531006, -0.0751059278845787, 0.003719809465110302, 0.011491406708955765, -0.008383519947528839, -0.03277850151062012, -0.039546992629766464, 0.03236421197652817, 0.04171871393918991, -0.012404943816363811, -0.0824504867196083, -0.007623251061886549, -0.007891063578426838, 0.0009372408967465162, -0.0240460317581892, -0.04861323535442352, -0.06281520426273346, 0.016789643093943596, -0.07937441766262054, -0.05101244896650314, -0.04639464244246483, 0.05060367286205292, 0.046305324882268906, -0.012316329404711723, -0.04631153866648674, -0.040247589349746704, 0.012414783239364624, 0.003608139930292964, 0.00009389640763401985, 0.0022022181656211615, 0.02713935449719429, 0.03840741142630577, -0.061391670256853104, 0.027059203013777733, 0.04425632581114769, -0.024781251326203346, -0.00427479250356555, 0.01733204908668995, 0.034484006464481354, -0.04861636087298393, 0.03145876154303551, 0.0152170704677701, 0.01189511176198721, 0.02584061026573181, -0.023134512826800346, -0.031554751098155975, -0.0635092556476593, -0.03367478400468826, 0.05788470059633255, -0.03896301984786987, 0.008638991042971611, -0.0013910350389778614, 0.01752571575343609, -0.05478755384683609, -0.05028262361884117, -0.03210008889436722, 0.021153682842850685, 0.03441014885902405, -0.0038697775453329086, 0.021987730637192726, -0.054349422454833984, 0.040000323206186295, -0.04560728371143341, 0.015999723225831985, -0.04087310656905174, 0.034226998686790466, 0.04716736823320389, -0.06384396553039551, 0.0037283424753695726, -0.05877393111586571, 0.01468855980783701, -0.01703839749097824, 0.0022612218745052814, -0.000023213904569274746, 0.039614953100681305, -0.027121245861053467, 0.0059150527231395245, -0.0416993610560894, -0.033860769122838974, 0.03226632997393608, -0.06607676297426224, -0.02995755709707737, -0.005377975758165121, 0.02966025285422802, 0.021656617522239685, 0.051120661199092865, -0.03941831365227699, 0.0627359002828598, -0.0019556735642254353, -0.013053367845714092, 0.025138385593891144, -0.004158851690590382, -0.0018889432540163398, -0.011881089769303799, 0.008737512864172459, -0.042878296226263046, -0.028050366789102554, 0.016486890614032745, 0.015837058424949646, -0.00969541072845459, -0.015597913414239883, -0.026653850451111794, -0.025599604472517967, -0.056227490305900574, -0.02693988010287285, 0.05537409335374832, 0.00609126640483737, -0.026542332023382187, 0.01581374555826187, 0.011127002537250519, -0.02075246162712574, -0.02983628772199154 ]
Large language model (LLM) platforms, such as ChatGPT, have recently begun offering an app ecosystem to interface with third-party services on the internet. While these apps extend the capabilities of LLM platforms, they are developed by arbitrary third parties and thus cannot be implicitly trusted. Apps also interface with LLM platforms and users using natural language, which can have imprecise interpretations. In this paper, we propose a framework that lays a foundation for LLM platform designers to analyze and improve the security, privacy, and safety of current and future third-party integrated LLM platforms. Our framework is a formulation of an attack taxonomy that is developed by iteratively exploring how LLM platform stakeholders could leverage their capabilities and responsibilities to mount attacks against each other. As part of our iterative process, we apply our framework in the context of OpenAI's plugin (apps) ecosystem. We uncover plugins that concretely demonstrate the potential for the types of issues that we outline in our attack taxonomy. We conclude by discussing novel challenges and by providing recommendations to improve the security, privacy, and safety of present and future LLM-based computing platforms.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10254v2
[ 0.01370831485837698, -0.034422967582941055, 0.054447438567876816, -0.009951222687959671, 0.04621155560016632, 0.05269307270646095, -0.050714537501335144, -0.02308087982237339, -0.011083422228693962, -0.03790673241019249, -0.006653317715972662, 0.050681523978710175, -0.024319034069776535, -0.051194705069065094, -0.013901212252676487, -0.004434631671756506, 0.07240700721740723, 0.03837965428829193, -0.02396109141409397, 0.029414495453238487, -0.023975919932127, -0.0424208864569664, -0.0786857157945633, 0.039631061255931854, 0.0013339798897504807, 0.006940366700291634, -0.02730940841138363, -0.028807543218135834, -0.033354826271533966, -0.023380646482110023, 0.060787394642829895, -0.02604803629219532, -0.03413388133049011, -0.03627447411417961, -0.026008253917098045, -0.054234474897384644, -0.014778205193579197, 0.03123105689883232, 0.03611346334218979, -0.047847192734479904, 0.019862473011016846, -0.05761316791176796, -0.054781973361968994, -0.03744262829422951, -0.02444946952164173, 0.029374441131949425, -0.04057559370994568, 0.029196562245488167, -0.05967933312058449, -0.04726939648389816, -0.009241844527423382, 0.012658524326980114, -0.03385382890701294, 0.05532490089535713, -0.03326927870512009, -0.009950486943125725, 0.018109001219272614, -0.0020009451545774937, -0.04509127512574196, 0.026863230392336845, 0.034153666347265244, -0.017061887308955193, -0.033497828990221024, 0.021834872663021088, 0.009656825102865696, 0.039155513048172, -0.024731911718845367, -0.023435642942786217, 0.012181028723716736, -0.03324978053569794, 0.03931301087141037, -0.06521892547607422, -0.05937916785478592, -0.0232405886054039, -0.02009999379515648, 0.006695271469652653, -0.019298246130347252, -0.04544335976243019, -0.028172798454761505, -0.009092306718230247, -0.026137737557291985, 0.029708486050367355, 0.05744452029466629, 0.014282932505011559, -0.010847972705960274, -0.02602333202958107, 0.012216294184327126, 0.019096702337265015, 0.009240052662789822, -0.021451400592923164, 0.0366237573325634, -0.023179136216640472, -0.09283403307199478, -0.00705934502184391, 0.07601572573184967, 0.02735084295272827, 0.025195036083459854, 0.012027952820062637, 0.013400775380432606, -0.03375925123691559, -0.02140277810394764, -0.018664047122001648, -0.03812739998102188, 0.06213175132870674, 0.01740771345794201, -0.03787269443273544, 0.03203409165143967, 0.03662092611193657, -0.04297503083944321, 0.0017921874532476068, -0.04286034405231476, -0.04212073236703873, 0.015135610476136208, -0.08019059896469116, -0.02592199295759201, -0.030332501977682114, 0.013098150491714478, -0.027482809498906136, 0.054455388337373734, 0.03372945263981819, -0.06094655394554138, 0.032936446368694305, 0.05026041343808174, -0.019670642912387848, -0.054973848164081573, -0.030940521508455276, 0.047709498554468155, -0.0025683839339762926, -0.004777640104293823, -0.03937964886426926, -0.03488238900899887, 0.025962447747588158, 0.007164772599935532, -0.05561782047152519, 0.06635674089193344, -0.04616115987300873, 0.013527763076126575, -0.018123021349310875, -0.022485211491584778, -0.04049345850944519, -0.0465107262134552, -0.05855869874358177, -0.0032811472192406654, -0.050378572195768356, 0.008928795345127583, 0.04741091653704643, 0.026947345584630966, 0.01100841723382473, -0.018094316124916077, 0.008436259813606739, 0.05709093436598778, 0.0018253987655043602, 0.015474364161491394, 0.033596545457839966, 0.018286753445863724, -0.039447031915187836, 0.02868867665529251, -0.05254131928086281, -0.08471910655498505, 0.05261169373989105, 0.01763857714831829, 0.01153076346963644, -0.0065102968364953995, -0.00007224668661365286, -0.05302957072854042, -0.002249472076073289, 0.032450977712869644, -0.00016811629757285118, 0.006478059105575085, 0.014108807779848576, -0.022688614204525948, -0.013611315749585629, -0.00860570464283228, 0.008597556501626968, -0.06720250099897385, -0.03775402531027794, 0.0222990233451128, -0.04309204965829849, -0.05273919925093651, -0.03103572502732277, 0.010786544531583786, 0.046594347804784775, -0.04679820314049721, -0.011695199646055698, -0.030657127499580383, 0.049666523933410645, -0.059543970972299576, -0.030269600450992584, 0.042454253882169724, -0.0252650436013937, -0.05936557427048683, -0.043010514229536057, 0.011580989696085453, -0.02519211918115616, -0.009793792851269245, -0.02202989161014557, 0.003386505413800478, -0.05352305620908737, 0.033523209393024445, 0.030834611505270004, -0.08952899277210236, 0.03235558047890663, -0.0562395378947258, 0.014537593349814415, 0.010792562738060951, -0.05750897154211998, 0.026564354076981544, 0.03114953823387623, -0.03879454731941223, -0.020547451451420784, 0.007569693028926849, 0.005486754234880209, 0.07229138165712357, 0.010719610378146172, 0.034658778458833694, 0.058097489178180695, -0.10246133804321289, 0.05677391588687897, 0.02051370218396187, 0.0041011967696249485, 0.04955220967531204, -0.0031058541499078274, 0.013469375669956207, 0.007255548145622015, -0.0014575949171558022, 0.017122304067015648, 0.02325688675045967, -0.023601017892360687, -0.02312551811337471, -0.03940539062023163, -0.05385100096464157, -0.03908449783921242, -0.012428587302565575, -0.07067397981882095, -0.018264811486005783, -0.012100595980882645, -0.05326791852712631, 0.054278552532196045, 0.0019664494320750237, -0.020735042169690132, -0.0030915564857423306, -0.06408484280109406, -0.0015424310695379972, -0.02786368690431118, -0.03938867151737213, -0.03026640973985195, -0.020830072462558746, 0.03196905925869942, -0.007743568159639835, 0.060384318232536316, -0.0050781602039933205, -0.0016622235998511314, 0.006606860086321831, -0.04255179315805435, 0.024926504120230675, -0.0018609454855322838, -0.025966662913560867, 0.010355723090469837, -0.018630649894475937, 0.0522138848900795, 0.03403565660119057, 0.018072357401251793, -0.04090855270624161, 0.011393733322620392, 0.02260361611843109, -0.04233686625957489, -0.01893516629934311, -0.021656271070241928, -0.02014802023768425, -0.007395710330456495, 0.018431538715958595, 0.011827867478132248, 0.04949803650379181, -0.03931138664484024, -0.006034970283508301, -0.0029253102838993073, 0.05061331391334534, 0.006785113364458084, 0.0013275803066790104, 0.044433463364839554, 0.024264108389616013, -0.02944859303534031, 0.01193661242723465, -0.04550563544034958, -0.006493757478892803, -0.004632181953638792, -0.06902652233839035, -0.011729233898222446, 0.030162585899233818, -0.048206962645053864, -0.07704973220825195, 0.02733013778924942, 0.027019983157515526, -0.02638203091919422, -0.02516404166817665, -0.034867435693740845, -0.008889298886060715, -0.047228552401065826, 0.019381441175937653, 0.0010616756044328213, -0.0639197900891304, -0.06309367716312408, 0.017297925427556038, 0.035416942089796066, 0.025136496871709824, -0.023721477016806602, -0.034664176404476166, -0.012396628968417645, 0.022942034527659416, -0.019034594297409058, -0.05294431373476982, 0.066142737865448, 0.0052710226736962795, 0.0023463929537683725, 0.013287751004099846, 0.05647394433617592, 0.02847335673868656, 0.012808619067072868, -0.027870595455169678, -0.016352595761418343, 0.002424889011308551, 0.021895363926887512, 0.03706924244761467, -0.04510087892413139, -0.07283228635787964, -0.011092562228441238, 0.05831310153007507, -0.0335392951965332, 0.024234814569354057, -0.03871932625770569, 0.03241140395402908, 0.04276388883590698, 0.04333000257611275, -0.01159435324370861, 0.0014772354625165462, 0.07008342444896698, -0.04275060445070267, -0.014005661010742188, 0.009511877782642841, -0.016466092318296432, -0.026063935831189156, 0.012588166631758213, 0.011426575481891632, -0.04710357263684273, 0.01859203353524208, -0.08406561613082886, 0.017239924520254135, 0.036856893450021744, 0.060739174485206604, -0.04120662063360214, 0.042924363166093826, 0.01988590508699417, 0.02770456299185753, -0.00005318527473718859, -0.016151057556271553, 0.026706602424383163, 0.05309559777379036, 0.047978393733501434, -0.019595317542552948, -0.04059853032231331, 0.03876823931932449, -0.019331498071551323, -0.011327526532113552, 0.006354300770908594, 0.0015232941368594766, 0.014856354333460331, -0.003837949363514781, -0.041235651820898056, 0.0279634241014719, -0.04057861119508743, 0.013292274437844753, 0.050186071544885635, -0.02807367406785488, -0.007631717249751091, -0.044526975601911545, 0.04443243518471718, 0.052384570240974426, -0.005651924759149551, -0.034960370510816574, -0.061556149274110794, -0.016388844698667526, -0.08054781705141068, 0.01721520721912384, 0.04904559627175331, -0.018171846866607666, 0.026097146794199944, 0.015598388388752937, -0.004706321284174919, 0.05611436069011688, -0.03734717145562172, -0.040006231516599655, -0.04604610428214073, 0.05536164343357086, 0.009651816450059414, -0.06684749573469162, -0.041677024215459824, -0.0230446495115757, 0.03610383719205856, -0.06088767200708389, 0.0008987014298327267, 0.006282386370003223, -0.030406080186367035, 0.0677255392074585, -0.07210737466812134, 0.014668885618448257, -0.040617141872644424, 0.025256222113966942, 0.00031876895809546113, -0.003649734193459153, 0.054793622344732285, -0.08061975985765457, 0.011082208715379238, -0.027890147641301155, 0.02510436624288559, -0.03188614919781685, 0.0021021051798015833, 0.02862146869301796, -0.04713407903909683, -0.015771083533763885, -0.052377376705408096, -0.0006825054297223687, 0.014389810152351856, -0.004670466296374798, -0.019481318071484566, 0.01683521457016468, 0.024196261540055275, 0.04147971048951149, 0.06962303072214127, 0.008394884876906872, 0.029005395248532295, -0.024475742131471634, 0.034542519599199295, -0.012224040925502777, 0.018283655866980553, -0.012578035704791546, -0.0291749257594347, 0.02700994163751602, 0.03932719677686691, 0.010727728717029095, 0.035112906247377396, -0.015615339390933514, 0.0544687919318676, -0.045212507247924805, -0.04450304061174393, 0.033008377999067307, -0.011436067521572113, -0.07558461278676987, -0.04403863102197647, 0.014747950248420238, -0.05203225836157799, -0.051509179174900055, -0.034795694053173065, 0.03376975655555725, 0.059383977204561234, -0.04254823550581932, 0.008291638456285, 0.008762337267398834, 0.05264054238796234, -0.0030333655886352062, -0.0013280826387926936, -0.0027485224418342113, -0.026760347187519073, 0.0005163120222277939, 0.05244627222418785, -0.015437223017215729, 0.032849736511707306, -0.03623688220977783, 0.003923260606825352, -0.023589514195919037, 0.03237833455204964, 0.01600976288318634, 0.06740846484899521, -0.0681740865111351, 0.05110854282975197, 0.0501224510371685, -0.013805149123072624, 0.025769488885998726, 0.005370140075683594, 0.02189325913786888, 0.023461688309907913, -0.008243591524660587, 0.008021922782063484, 0.04825737327337265, -0.015367639251053333, 0.016612496227025986, 0.04291106387972832, -0.015987388789653778, -0.023966634646058083, 0.04825994744896889, -0.00940173864364624, -0.029863353818655014, 0.028996001929044724, 0.059515196830034256, 0.011029507033526897, -0.021211694926023483, 0.04804836958646774, 0.031493641436100006, -0.050420865416526794, 0.013844105415046215, 0.018944241106510162, 0.009801139123737812, 0.014396267011761665, 0.00039365352131426334, -0.04394841566681862, 0.01545234676450491, 0.0051857358776032925, -0.05162236467003822, -0.03174946829676628, 0.05217151716351509, 0.04587595909833908, -0.0019918966572731733, -0.017982760444283485, 0.00794885866343975, -0.04379726201295853, 0.012573780491948128, -0.01554090715944767, 0.0052046156488358974, 0.08590999245643616, 0.03609563782811165, 0.0467161200940609, -0.015451048500835896, -0.014751918613910675, -0.040968745946884155, -0.01359716709703207, -0.022504504770040512, 0.010729499161243439, -0.04439540579915047, 0.007005010265856981, -0.01542758196592331, 0.038038503378629684, 0.017550677061080933, 0.01616854965686798, 0.002540624001994729, 0.0023458891082555056, -0.057065870612859726, 0.009568891488015652, -0.00461757555603981, -0.05674464628100395, -0.04584653675556183, 0.04434560611844063, 0.053348857909440994, -0.04311554506421089, 0.012843106873333454, -0.03405773639678955, -0.005017282906919718, 0.040042176842689514, 0.01656254194676876, -0.057765938341617584, -0.06936563551425934, -0.004470132291316986, 0.039016272872686386, -0.05254675820469856, 0.019647808745503426, 0.017268085852265358, -0.008358744904398918, 0.033905040472745895, -0.00826936773955822, -0.0291037168353796, 0.0810793936252594, 0.005672081373631954, -0.056486576795578, 0.07022429257631302, -0.02793056145310402, -0.05788280814886093, 0.003999054431915283, -0.04152129590511322, -0.09094889461994171, -0.0022548269480466843, 0.06435088068246841, 0.009249136783182621, -0.01491540763527155, 0.059965528547763824, 0.029361378401517868, 0.0036034195218235254, 0.015823641791939735, 0.0527527816593647, 0.07655157893896103, -0.015355465933680534, 0.023709885776042938, 0.012276360765099525, -0.05816158279776573, 0.010942644439637661, 0.008106574416160583, 0.010051175951957703, 0.03461139276623726, 0.06636563688516617, 0.024034200236201286, -0.02176840417087078, 0.009933697059750557, 0.018581246957182884, -0.02214030548930168, -0.00553756020963192, 0.01337173767387867, -0.03448491171002388, 0.04432492330670357, -0.06071744114160538, -0.03928569704294205, -0.03639035299420357, -0.029756709933280945, -0.015144720673561096, -0.07076653093099594, 0.013794826343655586, 0.008614856749773026, 0.0005019587697461247, 0.032183513045310974, -0.04217350855469704, -0.002663102000951767, -0.008389296010136604, -0.08847536891698837, 0.03526725992560387, -0.02446633204817772, 0.03459211811423302, -0.01992754451930523, -0.0011730666738003492, 0.021780962124466896, 0.05990821495652199, -0.06425052136182785, -0.021087482571601868, -0.020131735131144524, -0.03870192542672157, 0.008809782564640045, 0.0011623009340837598, 0.02081398479640484, 0.02820238471031189, 0.007715226151049137, -0.04148082435131073, -0.045011624693870544, -0.03212509676814079, -0.0495404489338398, 0.04521326348185539, 0.0012330900644883513, -0.015511116944253445, -0.0250733382999897, 0.036242980509996414, -0.0061564058996737, 0.00007431366975652054, 0.0058988770470023155, -0.041311152279376984, -0.06522633135318756, 0.005075966473668814, 0.03108847327530384, 0.018773125484585762, 0.024904804304242134, 0.0630042552947998, 0.04740912467241287, 0.010158965364098549, 0.06452402472496033, -0.03763671591877937, 0.023741761222481728, 0.006042986176908016, -0.05663081258535385, -0.016207391396164894, -0.02479134500026703, -0.03622065484523773, -0.04676155373454094, -0.03273935616016388, -0.02101784385740757, -0.05371961370110512, -0.025194471701979637, 0.030007705092430115, -0.007350789848715067, -0.0598163902759552, -0.015793321654200554, -0.0415765717625618, 0.02384837716817856, -0.07657674700021744, -0.015272888354957104, 0.015006971545517445, -0.0013906570384278893, -0.05048833042383194, 0.022014260292053223, -0.04582376033067703, -0.06378887593746185, -0.017951248213648796, -0.07295849174261093, -0.012721267528831959, -0.028003012761473656, -0.012977400794625282, 0.01775669865310192, -0.019290804862976074, 0.003081393660977483, -0.05539654195308685, 0.033507902175188065, -0.007108233869075775, 0.005902265664190054, -0.0160616897046566, -0.0012268273858353496, 0.048147957772016525, 0.013503310270607471, 0.0319036990404129, 0.02820446342229843, -0.041210275143384933, -0.035187624394893646, 0.020898738875985146, -0.03413800522685051, 0.003832861315459013, 0.007560896687209606, 0.051357343792915344, -0.027343813329935074, -0.030794762074947357, -0.053612589836120605, 0.030092250555753708, -0.04892255365848541, -0.054497893899679184, 0.06410415470600128, -0.07347962260246277, 0.018320711329579353, 0.0733444094657898, -0.017629599198698997, -0.014228110201656818, -0.0105672562494874, -0.054581400007009506, 0.0005602447199635208, -0.04265419766306877, -0.02068118005990982, 0.05845420062541962, -0.014029880054295063, -0.016226474195718765, -0.0392584502696991, -0.018626749515533447, 0.00244644982740283, 0.04574792459607124, 0.06059567257761955, -0.05374515429139137, 0.016674548387527466, -0.012661989778280258, 0.018788335844874382, -0.009886165149509907, 0.036876827478408813, -0.028116539120674133, 0.08413393050432205, 0.045570775866508484, -0.007957485504448414, -0.05049314722418785, -0.010793829336762428, 0.010805427096784115, -0.0688757598400116, -0.03512328118085861, -0.021477190777659416, 0.019009597599506378, 0.030340779572725296, -0.0005514761433005333, -0.013886100612580776, 0.030739303678274155, 0.014603988267481327, 0.011690771207213402, 0.0612092986702919, 0.018856868147850037, -0.02044128067791462, 0.08792172372341156, 0.0251621063798666, 0.013971223495900631, -0.030807992443442345, -0.0018941714661195874, -0.02984333038330078, 0.015351912006735802, 0.024773726239800453, -0.0261998251080513, 0.013303558342158794, 0.005989356432110071, 0.005340286996215582, 0.02848430722951889, -0.015455273911356926, 0.013940775766968727, -0.0034135107416659594, 0.022457318380475044, -0.002481707138940692, -0.0260185394436121 ]
The quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) is an appealing proposal to solve NP problems on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware. Making NISQ implementations of the QAOA resilient to noise requires short ansatz circuits with as few CNOT gates as possible. Here, we present Dynamic-ADAPT-QAOA. Our algorithm significantly reduces the circuit depth and the CNOT count of standard ADAPT-QAOA, a leading proposal for near-term implementations of the QAOA. Throughout our algorithm, the decision to apply CNOT-intensive operations is made dynamically, based on algorithmic benefits. Using density-matrix simulations, we benchmark the noise resilience of ADAPT-QAOA and Dynamic-ADAPT-QAOA. We compute the gate-error probability $p_\text{gate}^\star$ below which these algorithms provide, on average, more accurate solutions than the classical, polynomial-time approximation algorithm by Goemans and Williamson. For small systems with $6-10$ qubits, we show that $p_{\text{gate}}^\star>10^{-3}$ for Dynamic-ADAPT-QAOA. Compared to standard ADAPT-QAOA, this constitutes an order-of-magnitude improvement in noise resilience. This improvement should make Dynamic-ADAPT-QAOA viable for implementations on superconducting NISQ hardware, even in the absence of error mitigation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.00047v1
[ -0.04405420646071434, -0.053549110889434814, 0.032824475318193436, 0.04089177027344704, 0.01803692616522312, -0.049694597721099854, 0.0427672415971756, -0.012013477273285389, -0.037091802805662155, -0.020982468500733376, 0.006344359368085861, -0.014649178832769394, -0.038889944553375244, -0.04527340084314346, -0.05897355452179909, -0.0343853123486042, 0.0494057759642601, -0.0212953370064497, -0.029543166980147362, 0.0793071761727333, 0.06304998695850372, -0.05540486052632332, -0.020824063569307327, 0.012779371812939644, 0.037749994546175, 0.005313603673130274, -0.04768546298146248, 0.00495515763759613, -0.016699189320206642, -0.03819882497191429, 0.06562336534261703, -0.024793090298771858, -0.04684511944651604, -0.04540712386369705, 0.00011071754124714062, -0.03326146677136421, -0.0024009952321648598, 0.03306203708052635, 0.05644086375832558, 0.012162520550191402, 0.042089421302080154, -0.07394920289516449, -0.0570361502468586, -0.041928358376026154, -0.013112524524331093, -0.0026183421723544598, -0.013012182898819447, 0.013164733536541462, -0.002100930083543062, -0.05778758227825165, 0.06295329332351685, -0.04319920763373375, -0.025516392663121223, 0.01412492711097002, -0.053244080394506454, 0.04206324741244316, -0.053307294845581055, -0.011799952946603298, -0.00626844959333539, -0.02433442510664463, -0.018335696309804916, 0.01623718999326229, 0.013376238755881786, -0.02913936786353588, 0.00016104955284390599, 0.06719494611024857, 0.020299723371863365, -0.003587597282603383, 0.0034859979059547186, -0.00993479322642088, 0.0199586134403944, -0.0456998236477375, 0.03981173038482666, -0.006771252956241369, -0.025511175394058228, -0.0015480718575417995, -0.006924415472894907, -0.03722510486841202, 0.0376499742269516, 0.000045580956793855876, 0.010149193927645683, 0.016905652359128, 0.027371451258659363, 0.01986764185130596, -0.0059341504238545895, -0.01781027764081955, 0.015381255187094212, -0.028963016346096992, -0.00062136712949723, -0.06754107028245926, 0.051675524562597275, -0.0630829930305481, -0.06779772788286209, 0.013552909716963768, 0.0746190994977951, -0.05732397735118866, 0.03617497906088829, 0.042800575494766235, 0.007568441331386566, -0.0038104832638055086, -0.0238936860114336, -0.042670298367738724, -0.04980382323265076, 0.03287070244550705, 0.02767937071621418, 0.005510640796273947, 0.016392290592193604, -0.03161434829235077, -0.05718887969851494, 0.013674210757017136, -0.00929025188088417, -0.05794331431388855, 0.00890326127409935, -0.058479394763708115, -0.04263541102409363, -0.059983059763908386, 0.0802914947271347, 0.028918661177158356, 0.028137054294347763, -0.03780299425125122, -0.027320530265569687, 0.03249841555953026, 0.036739520728588104, 0.04224078729748726, -0.02715758979320526, -0.03302190080285072, 0.061753030866384506, -0.002426640596240759, 0.040690504014492035, -0.028307583183050156, -0.013029769994318485, 0.052478790283203125, 0.007802492007613182, -0.004795693326741457, 0.07324492186307907, 0.015947218984365463, -0.029012201353907585, -0.03190907835960388, 0.029029453173279762, -0.005349576938897371, -0.051918160170316696, -0.02819127030670643, 0.028256036341190338, 0.00802675075829029, 0.031085245311260223, 0.027470875531435013, -0.04609081894159317, -0.00747988186776638, 0.046735335141420364, 0.043105483055114746, -0.025264207273721695, 0.02782679721713066, -0.012569896876811981, -0.005165239796042442, 0.03824109956622124, 0.03560806065797806, 0.05324145033955574, -0.01757454313337803, -0.033024806529283524, 0.03470136597752571, 0.0631726086139679, -0.03735433891415596, 0.0007792040705680847, 0.04848725348711014, 0.02411506325006485, 0.03930540382862091, 0.029975466430187225, -0.029703009873628616, 0.02486252412199974, 0.01993013173341751, -0.03469303995370865, -0.022929249331355095, 0.03483780473470688, -0.06818123161792755, -0.042789340019226074, -0.04062230885028839, -0.0020886450074613094, -0.014578522183001041, -0.04729839786887169, -0.01723668910562992, 0.011442651972174644, -0.006289368961006403, -0.017557131126523018, 0.049974679946899414, -0.05008847266435623, -0.02040121704339981, -0.07692792266607285, 0.03103422373533249, 0.04806232079863548, 0.02241397649049759, -0.023068085312843323, -0.04259306192398071, 0.008499723859131336, -0.0024621181655675173, -0.03947779908776283, -0.015090488828718662, -0.030833786353468895, -0.0018608086975291371, -0.012879236601293087, 0.022443844005465508, -0.06533730030059814, -0.031232422217726707, -0.052208565175533295, 0.037757016718387604, 0.01265384815633297, -0.06536118686199188, 0.03990945965051651, 0.04133136570453644, -0.014237559400498867, -0.014914406463503838, 0.045084692537784576, 0.011440813541412354, 0.04814126715064049, 0.02999519184231758, -0.03362564370036125, 0.004599742125719786, -0.0983496829867363, 0.06116396561264992, 0.04306666925549507, -0.014828559942543507, 0.03389028087258339, -0.012905375100672245, 0.002928240690380335, -0.001030540093779564, -0.010506236925721169, 0.05320454761385918, -0.00025298428954556584, -0.04920849949121475, -0.04362952709197998, -0.030488139018416405, 0.005566687323153019, -0.048471543937921524, -0.02217504195868969, -0.06937973201274872, -0.03524627909064293, 0.04557041823863983, -0.017084157094359398, 0.05735335871577263, -0.02003379724919796, -0.04418815299868584, -0.06490577012300491, -0.04256443306803703, 0.04012192785739899, -0.06402024626731873, -0.04763999953866005, -0.006550943478941917, -0.0351414792239666, 0.023103581741452217, 0.024951625615358353, -0.02382661961019039, -0.04886043444275856, -0.0058602746576070786, -0.04068713262677193, -0.013625597581267357, 0.020413625985383987, 0.05382855609059334, -0.020990844815969467, 0.04369014874100685, -0.013118626549839973, 0.050805747509002686, -0.006613665726035833, -0.01222475990653038, -0.003440641099587083, 0.03352884575724602, 0.016483454033732414, 0.037458259612321854, -0.03872508555650711, 0.013850581832230091, -0.003104391973465681, -0.027077581733465195, -0.012120996601879597, 0.022948002442717552, 0.04974176362156868, -0.02291116677224636, 0.0049244556576013565, 0.01415165700018406, -0.008338641375303268, -0.016496095806360245, 0.01911243423819542, 0.028294336050748825, 0.008754925802350044, -0.04472043365240097, 0.05894123390316963, -0.0712396651506424, -0.0433654710650444, -0.02463059313595295, -0.0034102958161383867, -0.05089203640818596, -0.0653381273150444, -0.008984302170574665, -0.07098061591386795, -0.019704019650816917, -0.04357964172959328, -0.018831288442015648, -0.006512970197945833, 0.015145239420235157, -0.00919781532138586, -0.013771570287644863, 0.04151896759867668, -0.03928563371300697, -0.06275471299886703, -0.03149160370230675, 0.003244126448407769, 0.0478496327996254, 0.017231063917279243, -0.008046886883676052, 0.01940169557929039, 0.04495742917060852, 0.031451646238565445, 0.07061337679624557, -0.010796620510518551, -0.0063513219356536865, -0.026044072583317757, 0.036606937646865845, 0.04656033590435982, 0.027106575667858124, 0.010024944320321083, 0.01584310084581375, -0.04395686089992523, -0.01178036816418171, -0.011067372746765614, -0.0001155791396740824, -0.003171743592247367, -0.045466452836990356, -0.03208908438682556, -0.026383645832538605, 0.07236094027757645, 0.03443922847509384, 0.009939489886164665, -0.048529185354709625, 0.0012276549823582172, 0.03337022289633751, 0.006820736452937126, 0.021713733673095703, 0.054115332663059235, 0.06779782474040985, -0.03886246308684349, 0.002785013522952795, -0.041911929845809937, -0.021069081500172615, -0.018910681828856468, 0.0437697134912014, 0.04756836220622063, 0.0027606089133769274, 0.049776021391153336, -0.09465775638818741, 0.035626232624053955, 0.0496850349009037, 0.03294261917471886, -0.03342663124203682, -0.002505672164261341, 0.01294428389519453, 0.023983724415302277, 0.007011402398347855, 0.003409773577004671, 0.03739850968122482, 0.05674664303660393, 0.04701477661728859, 0.02959875948727131, -0.038336530327796936, 0.025863144546747208, -0.06635341048240662, -0.012635799124836922, -0.002593755489215255, -0.04827316477894783, 0.031902968883514404, 0.0042236014269292355, -0.07189423590898514, 0.02890651859343052, -0.02760191634297371, 0.010235296562314034, -0.003928381949663162, 0.0018268031999468803, 0.020292134955525398, -0.040320806205272675, -0.021589551120996475, -0.008017913438379765, 0.020908396691083908, 0.00684919860213995, -0.05899269878864288, 0.005214423406869173, -0.051967065781354904, 0.01623796671628952, -0.027159925550222397, -0.054044291377067566, -0.012529497034847736, 0.0028218866791576147, -0.0750284269452095, 0.027038201689720154, -0.03720904141664505, -0.012049885466694832, -0.0195578895509243, 0.012432597577571869, 0.014763519167900085, -0.002345328452065587, -0.046535395085811615, 0.007501685060560703, -0.018562376499176025, -0.060432881116867065, -0.022255143150687218, -0.021029187366366386, 0.008101454935967922, 0.03644271567463875, -0.07455438375473022, -0.011557313613593578, -0.07460301369428635, 0.006299812346696854, -0.04703611508011818, -0.03735377639532089, 0.07304460555315018, 0.015222213231027126, 0.02056903950870037, 0.006208030506968498, -0.042352329939603806, 0.005050427280366421, -0.01783750206232071, -0.03133143112063408, -0.010256797075271606, -0.016593007370829582, 0.029400791972875595, 0.014722845517098904, -0.0007855741423554718, 0.0413493849337101, -0.05853111669421196, -0.030880911275744438, -0.015306803397834301, 0.05887691304087639, 0.016282685101032257, 0.019047291949391365, 0.021592389792203903, 0.009335480630397797, -0.008358942344784737, -0.00038564769783988595, -0.019977709278464317, -0.0334627740085125, -0.0773153007030487, 0.04285580292344093, -0.03648405522108078, -0.018770238384604454, 0.003163324436172843, -0.006773438770323992, 0.05422352999448776, -0.02897954173386097, -0.058898136019706726, 0.028128810226917267, -0.017534706741571426, -0.04815271496772766, -0.05752874165773392, -0.026304293423891068, -0.030999943614006042, -0.07506456971168518, -0.058403629809617996, 0.008855833671987057, 0.002496907953172922, -0.024722564965486526, 0.019447995349764824, 0.051683925092220306, 0.01755422167479992, -0.01307423785328865, -0.01985517330467701, 0.029270179569721222, 0.019160060212016106, 0.00516671035438776, 0.04165596887469292, -0.05485256761312485, 0.011991835199296474, -0.04487396776676178, -0.03194642439484596, -0.06482444703578949, 0.049633026123046875, -0.04736538603901863, 0.041295479983091354, -0.06748072057962418, 0.00982486829161644, 0.035156719386577606, -0.005081835202872753, 0.016127578914165497, 0.017145957797765732, -0.03224410489201546, 0.007561380974948406, 0.027445770800113678, 0.03046673722565174, 0.011044871993362904, -0.029944991692900658, 0.003336599562317133, 0.03172874078154564, -0.06951720267534256, 0.017954319715499878, 0.016470056027173996, 0.004708496853709221, -0.022642934694886208, 0.05209875479340553, -0.015343793667852879, 0.01545506902039051, -0.05084354802966118, 0.01232756208628416, 0.05622753128409386, -0.037990156561136246, -0.0642532929778099, -0.02679411508142948, 0.003741669235751033, -0.0007820648606866598, 0.011140692047774792, -0.05086676403880119, -0.03168276324868202, 0.03160214424133301, 0.03101816587150097, -0.029783738777041435, 0.02236161008477211, 0.01940278708934784, -0.01536676287651062, -0.0215010829269886, -0.03196520358324051, -0.050157155841588974, -0.011631391011178493, -0.0025119672063738108, 0.0168596301227808, 0.0012248202692717314, 0.054324809461832047, 0.038602314889431, -0.018434328958392143, 0.027719000354409218, -0.05038001015782356, -0.036493632942438126, -0.04176700860261917, 0.04468380659818649, 0.0018811386544257402, 0.04295438155531883, 0.002906044013798237, 0.03171232342720032, 0.039459895342588425, 0.014640695415437222, -0.013909650035202503, 0.005656564142554998, -0.0038509774021804333, -0.01877087727189064, 0.014753583818674088, -0.05051073804497719, -0.05732640624046326, 0.009198608808219433, 0.03042641468346119, -0.028661055490374565, 0.04714985936880112, 0.008928084746003151, 0.016660740599036217, 0.04562695324420929, -0.018689850345253944, -0.07025891542434692, -0.05925067886710167, 0.023169128224253654, 0.05377368628978729, -0.05222450941801071, -0.01585257798433304, -0.03161386772990227, -0.03656759858131409, 0.004032626282423735, -0.0378866009414196, -0.01621190644800663, -0.040949538350105286, -0.01695612445473671, -0.030952436849474907, 0.0722053200006485, 0.01854667253792286, -0.08652275055646896, -0.01867930218577385, 0.056677307933568954, -0.08813346177339554, -0.0018423870205879211, 0.04446382448077202, -0.0345865823328495, -0.03883165493607521, 0.028280457481741905, 0.03231684863567352, -0.02486618049442768, -0.010307729244232178, 0.052780285477638245, 0.036187268793582916, -0.049491751939058304, 0.050037920475006104, 0.020650675520300865, -0.04501086100935936, 0.04339071363210678, -0.08392398059368134, -0.0006743692210875452, 0.008177932351827621, 0.06600265204906464, -0.024029964581131935, -0.024615241214632988, -0.031601473689079285, 0.027727045118808746, -0.06125471368432045, 0.037393808364868164, -0.015490052290260792, -0.021890072152018547, 0.05005570873618126, -0.042088743299245834, -0.0002273162972414866, -0.023188643157482147, -0.06348762661218643, -0.02149055339396, -0.0016637597000226378, 0.0009094703709706664, 0.007511581759899855, 0.019080445170402527, -0.004985941108316183, -0.04932262375950813, -0.020804237574338913, -0.004965815227478743, 0.00007674044172745198, -0.0014254659181460738, -0.06167363375425339, -0.016457807272672653, 0.05122173950076103, 0.004813395440578461, 0.01330866850912571, 0.04979044198989868, -0.06272407621145248, -0.0036636274307966232, -0.05316891893744469, 0.02746593952178955, -0.009732158854603767, -0.026855258271098137, 0.04523478075861931, -0.02451486885547638, 0.04828384518623352, -0.00911684799939394, -0.012093910947442055, -0.026717977598309517, -0.05860118940472603, 0.03593474254012108, 0.03022323176264763, -0.011764753609895706, -0.052939437329769135, -0.003985099960118532, -0.023939048871397972, 0.025768253952264786, 0.0032809509430080652, -0.03841881826519966, -0.06622105091810226, 0.015814879909157753, -0.0032611701171845198, 0.007564377039670944, -0.01794142834842205, 0.0006170732085593045, -0.015128668397665024, -0.02836470492184162, 0.046005427837371826, 0.04230700805783272, 0.040154021233320236, -0.045434147119522095, -0.02470257319509983, -0.047651246190071106, -0.011774181388318539, -0.013414893299341202, -0.0231199748814106, -0.05019254609942436, 0.006727019790560007, -0.07523784786462784, -0.004224080126732588, 0.04104185476899147, 0.010314331389963627, -0.022073227912187576, -0.059797219932079315, 0.0315689891576767, -0.00046210933942347765, -0.03330389782786369, 0.00034232588950544596, -0.010666407644748688, -0.01927936263382435, -0.0028249933384358883, 0.01141695212572813, -0.04440580680966377, -0.06785734742879868, 0.017743734642863274, -0.07994586229324341, -0.018064668402075768, -0.0286104679107666, 0.02105873078107834, 0.040419209748506546, 0.02453249879181385, -0.01804894395172596, -0.03900193050503731, -0.0042204586789011955, -0.015702325850725174, -0.014523469842970371, 0.004242526367306709, 0.023861026391386986, 0.02850680984556675, -0.028771404176950455, -0.04015228897333145, 0.04359940439462662, -0.039766762405633926, 0.03245571628212929, 0.04995955526828766, 0.017385508865118027, -0.009672443382441998, 0.009531615301966667, 0.03985375910997391, -0.00025775827816687524, 0.00996255874633789, -0.05795447900891304, 0.007106154225766659, -0.03346863016486168, -0.03511061519384384, -0.0009129563113674521, -0.0645628571510315, 0.013114492408931255, -0.0381273478269577, 0.04459214210510254, -0.0060754199512302876, -0.011160435155034065, -0.04812157154083252, 0.033972904086112976, 0.024370741099119186, -0.05260695889592171, 0.06187651306390762, -0.0424254946410656, -0.02994447387754917, -0.033350348472595215, -0.012512924149632454, -0.06349868327379227, 0.06349402666091919, 0.05376146733760834, -0.04666386544704437, -0.035101208835840225, -0.021074730902910233, 0.022389322519302368, -0.023439893499016762, 0.008364671841263771, -0.006360888481140137, 0.06253461539745331, 0.03965148329734802, 0.014802694320678711, -0.04192904382944107, -0.04355031996965408, -0.06276528537273407, -0.04466263949871063, 0.023707566782832146, -0.011195662431418896, 0.009286952205002308, 0.019491849467158318, 0.03876819089055061, -0.019483815878629684, 0.055789679288864136, 0.014790352433919907, 0.011722244322299957, 0.007139137014746666, 0.029997026547789574, -0.04728066548705101, 0.06699595600366592, 0.002464394550770521, -0.024173002690076828, -0.0505412295460701, -0.005307207815349102, 0.016866937279701233, 0.005948177073150873, 0.027453046292066574, -0.008080713450908661, 0.04024240002036095, -0.07566607743501663, -0.024363992735743523, 0.016711769625544548, 0.010298838838934898, -0.06140296906232834, 0.0062827677465975285, -0.0339541882276535, -0.018221667036414146, -0.06611690670251846 ]
Tensor networks are useful toy models for understanding the structure of entanglement in holographic states and reconstruction of bulk operators within the entanglement wedge. They are, however, constrained to only prepare so-called "fixed-area states" with flat entanglement spectra, limiting their utility in understanding general features of holographic entanglement. Here, we overcome this limitation by constructing a variant of random tensor networks that enjoys bulk gauge symmetries. Our model includes a gauge theory on a general graph, whose gauge-invariant states are fed into a random tensor network. We show that the model satisfies the quantum-corrected Ryu-Takayanagi formula with a nontrivial area operator living in the center of a gauge-invariant algebra. We also demonstrate nontrivial, n-dependent contributions to the R\'enyi entropy and R\'enyi mutual information from this area operator, a feature shared by general holographic states.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06436v1
[ -0.03389839082956314, -0.03522824868559837, 0.05257633700966835, 0.01238531805574894, 0.011721719987690449, -0.011107861064374447, 0.01165609061717987, -0.0023829909041523933, 0.0014640612062066793, -0.01935660094022751, -0.011991001665592194, -0.018600335344672203, -0.0711747258901596, -0.07049769908189774, -0.04952123761177063, 0.017023470252752304, 0.07564204186201096, 0.02507060579955578, -0.05268304795026779, 0.049630336463451385, -0.015129008330404758, -0.03542676568031311, -0.02189771831035614, 0.044298939406871796, -0.011651838198304176, -0.026221681386232376, -0.013809489086270332, 0.003738156519830227, -0.01601782999932766, 0.0007062432123348117, 0.0633455365896225, -0.010585298761725426, 0.0032279998995363712, 0.015331210568547249, -0.03599528968334198, -0.0111989825963974, 0.0026961504481732845, 0.011929367668926716, 0.04094984382390976, -0.0318789929151535, -0.014877545647323132, -0.008058424107730389, -0.04237852618098259, -0.03187786415219307, -0.026849839836359024, -0.025197044014930725, -0.03883708268404007, 0.024155059829354286, -0.04543756693601608, -0.05715157464146614, 0.004632493015378714, 0.034431666135787964, 0.019748471677303314, 0.05665834620594978, -0.03545258939266205, -0.0008537287940271199, 0.004464388824999332, 0.0304814912378788, -0.0546809583902359, 0.025062864646315575, -0.06342898309230804, -0.04717881605029106, -0.0033116734120994806, 0.0037303955759853125, -0.011114026419818401, 0.029393665492534637, -0.04239804297685623, -0.056051790714263916, -0.002326545538380742, -0.04528263211250305, 0.044523805379867554, -0.07408826798200607, 0.029800094664096832, -0.026274845004081726, -0.04108130559325218, 0.05188734456896782, -0.04690631479024887, 0.021835502237081528, 0.010216307826340199, 0.003928016405552626, -0.03662417456507683, 0.012937813997268677, 0.05740091949701309, 0.05054600164294243, 0.03454140946269035, 0.005954998545348644, 0.0472172275185585, -0.017353132367134094, -0.011445777490735054, -0.043106809258461, 0.041088737547397614, 0.002945423824712634, -0.07412596791982651, 0.024129290133714676, 0.07748990505933762, -0.0235079787671566, 0.053885772824287415, 0.0326046422123909, 0.011660671792924404, -0.01217034924775362, -0.03729831054806709, -0.03459792211651802, -0.042961444705724716, 0.03949465975165367, 0.014948115684092045, -0.010479751974344254, -0.02164233662188053, 0.013342943042516708, -0.041443124413490295, -0.007011613808572292, -0.0418739877641201, -0.0004696827381849289, 0.04504939541220665, -0.061467256397008896, -0.029051201418042183, -0.009577314369380474, 0.057129066437482834, 0.001671370817348361, 0.04442819580435753, -0.006729744840413332, -0.01691487617790699, 0.02596929296851158, 0.009294120594859123, -0.013910618610680103, -0.06236400082707405, -0.05190702900290489, 0.07592665404081345, 0.019281571730971336, 0.004043124616146088, -0.03918527811765671, -0.023359470069408417, 0.01221251580864191, -0.004126338753849268, -0.0571100190281868, 0.05774378776550293, -0.02842922881245613, 0.03409681096673012, -0.03371075913310051, -0.015939073637127876, 0.0047810073010623455, -0.027290059253573418, -0.052410706877708435, 0.005425215698778629, 0.025479577481746674, 0.03025989979505539, 0.047939758747816086, -0.06766998767852783, -0.03852046653628349, 0.017604975029826164, -0.0007105026743374765, 0.007726272102445364, -0.00920956488698721, 0.035295262932777405, 0.042286280542612076, 0.015221469104290009, -0.026213405653834343, 0.060767363756895065, 0.02344719134271145, -0.05953078716993332, -0.018504425883293152, 0.015038934536278248, 0.01285241823643446, -0.02490229718387127, 0.018235087394714355, -0.012405341491103172, 0.030240308493375778, 0.05014835670590401, -0.04483902081847191, -0.04135943576693535, -0.007439061999320984, -0.056207939982414246, 0.019835129380226135, 0.03809259831905365, -0.03905321657657623, -0.05832742527127266, -0.04048829525709152, -0.018995236605405807, -0.05689429119229317, -0.02097080834209919, 0.036524660885334015, 0.01220887154340744, 0.041000064462423325, 0.004288093186914921, 0.009684760123491287, -0.029667934402823448, -0.009980681352317333, -0.0796472355723381, -0.03463295102119446, 0.054652176797389984, 0.012849011458456516, -0.004217498004436493, -0.06757547706365585, 0.01976929046213627, 0.03311338648200035, -0.03894207626581192, -0.012776997871696949, -0.004859218839555979, -0.04423071816563606, -0.030578549951314926, -0.009486337192356586, -0.05641496926546097, 0.019248438999056816, -0.022990889847278595, 0.009420651942491531, -0.028368381783366203, -0.07583161443471909, 0.01574656181037426, 0.02681366726756096, -0.021376341581344604, -0.00541816558688879, 0.062307216227054596, 0.02603769302368164, 0.04282667115330696, -0.04577156528830528, 0.018474282696843147, 0.01374425832182169, -0.09791146963834763, -0.00729688024148345, 0.013641160912811756, 0.002870263997465372, -0.0024724595714360476, 0.0003868387429974973, 0.010883721522986889, -0.05520389974117279, 0.013221995905041695, 0.04221285507082939, 0.07302301377058029, 0.056889209896326065, -0.0456664077937603, -0.007992902770638466, -0.0327768512070179, -0.06066306680440903, -0.03674828261137009, -0.0616103857755661, -0.03935849294066429, 0.017413560301065445, -0.053506482392549515, 0.05295790359377861, -0.008733049035072327, -0.005549392197281122, -0.05894725024700165, -0.026685578748583794, 0.061289407312870026, -0.022091394290328026, -0.05717006325721741, -0.06143196299672127, -0.06064546853303909, 0.05765395238995552, -0.03801250457763672, 0.03866540268063545, 0.004255054984241724, -0.07676481455564499, 0.0012404021108523011, -0.029320137575268745, 0.031154602766036987, 0.03748491406440735, -0.05800970271229744, 0.020581254735589027, -0.004752700682729483, 0.052638083696365356, 0.049331068992614746, 0.027261201292276382, -0.06751309335231781, 0.0016693425131961703, 0.017873067408800125, 0.028067465871572495, -0.045692119747400284, -0.036898404359817505, 0.0007774182595312595, -0.06063207611441612, 0.049827877432107925, 0.012290040031075478, 0.0341489277780056, -0.03861575573682785, -0.021221576258540154, 0.041694965213537216, -0.012510483153164387, -0.02814093790948391, 0.029979215934872627, 0.04219399020075798, 0.05746881291270256, 0.04882621392607689, -0.03743307664990425, -0.07892812043428421, -0.029083136469125748, -0.021229900419712067, -0.03362105041742325, -0.06147044152021408, -0.05752231180667877, -0.017665764316916466, -0.07928992807865143, -0.0015498928260058165, -0.021358061581850052, -0.04612523317337036, -0.022312667220830917, -0.006202200427651405, -0.010956889018416405, 0.011123261414468288, 0.0058005014434456825, -0.06403497606515884, -0.0665351152420044, 0.005687618162482977, 0.03953731432557106, 0.009671179577708244, 0.015368674881756306, -0.06213827803730965, -0.03390875086188316, 0.013287076726555824, 0.0047771986573934555, 0.016696278005838394, -0.0013107627164572477, 0.0010531417792662978, -0.06750264763832092, 0.02768724411725998, -0.011651507578790188, 0.052034590393304825, 0.0032780917827039957, 0.0049224901013076305, 0.01125821378082037, -0.021354738622903824, -0.005970065947622061, -0.0056001413613557816, -0.0006661568186245859, 0.0018630807753652334, -0.07653891295194626, -0.018939165398478508, 0.0449034720659256, 0.06246160715818405, -0.022306447848677635, 0.005386771634221077, -0.0034347381442785263, -0.013236727565526962, 0.018125560134649277, -0.0158068984746933, 0.052178751677274704, 0.05273996293544769, 0.014776033349335194, 0.00164208491332829, -0.02206617034971714, -0.00022809975780546665, 0.0036786484997719526, 0.026168018579483032, -0.02624303475022316, -0.014725536108016968, -0.005779747851192951, -0.07508936524391174, 0.03911887854337692, 0.0074425204657018185, 0.04383790120482445, -0.015612800605595112, 0.010364667512476444, 0.018629401922225952, 0.019658023491501808, 0.026139743626117706, -0.0071503943763673306, 0.02059834450483322, 0.012677899561822414, 0.06774637848138809, 0.002839986002072692, -0.04278140887618065, -0.04681682586669922, -0.08283412456512451, -0.02738737314939499, 0.027104508131742477, 0.021798506379127502, 0.056025560945272446, 0.0410408154129982, -0.011040027253329754, 0.0358503982424736, -0.011916943825781345, 0.06274808198213577, 0.015581357292830944, -0.015268079936504364, 0.010583317838609219, -0.011269907467067242, -0.02127797156572342, -0.003096325322985649, 0.019004886969923973, -0.050497621297836304, -0.047576844692230225, 0.01693752594292164, -0.0701318085193634, 0.009064207784831524, -0.004950087983161211, -0.007560259196907282, 0.054411567747592926, 0.02557051181793213, 0.0010807710932567716, 0.051199961453676224, -0.0032957871444523335, 0.017214734107255936, 0.008136487565934658, 0.008574132807552814, -0.022655805572867393, -0.01900111883878708, -0.038887716829776764, 0.012718018144369125, -0.026080457493662834, -0.027291424572467804, 0.01592259667813778, 0.014628161676228046, -0.014409924857318401, -0.06069175899028778, -0.08685506880283356, -0.018307456746697426, -0.012499775737524033, 0.007365209981799126, 0.007055670954287052, -0.028499243780970573, 0.08035646378993988, -0.027959346771240234, 0.010312121361494064, -0.03799303248524666, -0.038752906024456024, -0.035881441086530685, -0.019090354442596436, -0.04228435829281807, -0.04423530399799347, 0.047759149223566055, -0.044262565672397614, 0.022717615589499474, 0.005586519837379456, 0.016581835225224495, -0.05699567496776581, 0.013339370489120483, -0.0321129634976387, 0.057186201214790344, 0.04716631770133972, 0.034686628729104996, 0.038473475724458694, -0.010022342205047607, -0.003979415167123079, 0.02028008922934532, 0.00027738657081499696, -0.010415726341307163, -0.029606686905026436, 0.03128696233034134, -0.04255716875195503, -0.047312237322330475, -0.040821176022291183, -0.012669982388615608, 0.040015898644924164, -0.03404373303055763, -0.029530106112360954, 0.022985512390732765, 0.05689707770943642, -0.0351417101919651, -0.047892890870571136, -0.0018806483130902052, 0.009933005087077618, -0.07639478147029877, 0.004176820628345013, 0.002149837091565132, -0.03421177342534065, -0.005094463936984539, 0.025074560195207596, -0.021907057613134384, 0.026770787313580513, -0.01745305024087429, -0.010915040969848633, 0.03020566515624523, -0.011638738214969635, 0.03322908654808998, -0.05383820831775665, -0.07135885953903198, 0.03333365544676781, -0.026596004143357277, 0.0046075559221208096, -0.021350238472223282, 0.036223869770765305, 0.019473955035209656, 0.054326675832271576, -0.07090767472982407, 0.029197869822382927, 0.05922152101993561, -0.028585972264409065, 0.0020457026548683643, 0.0172480009496212, -0.04623713716864586, 0.02929665520787239, -0.016539335250854492, 0.013956928625702858, 0.006842858623713255, -0.02642134204506874, -0.010713314637541771, -0.01915348507463932, -0.008359144441783428, 0.013686377555131912, 0.020977385342121124, -0.020711645483970642, -0.04614228755235672, 0.01353201549500227, -0.019502175971865654, -0.00494396360591054, -0.05125238746404648, 0.052257560193538666, 0.05877656489610672, -0.01741725206375122, -0.013419631868600845, 0.0006845695315860212, -0.014433717355132103, 0.018713755533099174, 0.03268500417470932, -0.054233845323324203, 0.0020866533741354942, 0.0390077605843544, -0.003269284963607788, -0.0015899353893473744, 0.025686291977763176, -0.017668357118964195, 0.020577166229486465, 0.009990597143769264, -0.006201124284416437, -0.054174695163965225, 0.015201227739453316, -0.022319553419947624, 0.06370694190263748, 0.03028063103556633, 0.04583517834544182, 0.04072752222418785, 0.03201461210846901, -0.017811326310038567, -0.006341344676911831, -0.006917889229953289, 0.016054201871156693, 0.03949948400259018, -0.0691143199801445, -0.007244370877742767, -0.03403599187731743, 0.0661049485206604, 0.009539516642689705, 0.014830483123660088, -0.01203523762524128, -0.015829220414161682, -0.06902499496936798, -0.029190877452492714, 0.03827858716249466, -0.007527510169893503, -0.04060324653983116, 0.0033894118387252092, 0.06499619781970978, -0.049579717218875885, 0.029923101887106895, 0.06396578252315521, 0.054086215794086456, 0.07111573219299316, 0.015663648024201393, 0.017896905541419983, -0.04486075043678284, -0.007981361821293831, 0.08471983671188354, -0.07542892545461655, -0.02725014090538025, -0.031197072938084602, -0.0697474479675293, 0.01768185943365097, -0.05734637379646301, 0.055194731801748276, -0.007393575739115477, -0.027536699548363686, -0.034270595759153366, 0.02921287715435028, 0.007919282652437687, -0.0566878616809845, -0.02065272256731987, 0.038280218839645386, -0.07742607593536377, -0.008465900085866451, 0.010358783416450024, -0.022138159722089767, -0.05038024112582207, 0.06268630921840668, -0.01394872646778822, -0.04606673866510391, -0.04424775019288063, 0.06430362164974213, 0.061232782900333405, -0.018207306042313576, 0.026710381731390953, 0.018496496602892876, -0.01761767454445362, 0.009167583659291267, -0.02740221470594406, 0.023145420476794243, 0.008170286193490028, -0.0018550932873040438, 0.005826105829328299, -0.04028793051838875, -0.0039419191889464855, 0.039070747792720795, -0.02887066639959812, -0.03288935124874115, 0.03371109068393707, -0.004587978590279818, 0.030398666858673096, -0.02965773083269596, -0.054413020610809326, 0.0038965155836194754, 0.005486305337399244, -0.01577799580991268, -0.0590229369699955, 0.007636618800461292, 0.05031733959913254, 0.042713530361652374, -0.012481460347771645, -0.027614925056695938, -0.05981636792421341, -0.02337002567946911, -0.059476468712091446, 0.006317570805549622, -0.06196419149637222, 0.007693851832300425, -0.04204273223876953, 0.007052845787256956, 0.005033204331994057, 0.04688408598303795, -0.015019318088889122, 0.014963831752538681, -0.012157081626355648, 0.03471919149160385, 0.008761030621826649, -0.01655466854572296, -0.006804690230637789, -0.01613435335457325, 0.043980974704027176, -0.055049195885658264, 0.017896750941872597, -0.020571161061525345, -0.05508581921458244, 0.015229026786983013, 0.0008004649425856769, -0.04781155288219452, -0.019283052533864975, -0.0035991838667541742, -0.029106803238391876, 0.022090276703238487, 0.0026606132742017508, -0.017987091094255447, -0.06679106503725052, -0.010602216236293316, 0.025272032245993614, -0.01833435706794262, 0.021983731538057327, 0.010447421111166477, 0.004479648545384407, -0.012981511652469635, 0.05614806339144707, 0.06290554255247116, 0.0001914795720949769, 0.004723676480352879, -0.057428985834121704, -0.00110388093162328, 0.011891501024365425, -0.03897951543331146, -0.018492212519049644, -0.03166833892464638, -0.02467934973537922, -0.06384453177452087, -0.000035887340345652774, 0.01861538365483284, 0.0037405267357826233, -0.021333863958716393, -0.023752357810735703, 0.04914688691496849, 0.01117776520550251, -0.00562100438401103, -0.07840073853731155, -0.05448146164417267, 0.006670338101685047, -0.004568238742649555, -0.05923303961753845, -0.02161506749689579, -0.05901629105210304, -0.01632729172706604, -0.08312081545591354, -0.019545629620552063, -0.0138845918700099, 0.050695061683654785, -0.004528336692601442, -0.02706814557313919, -0.04573056474328041, -0.002952203620225191, 0.00019813068502116948, 0.0025393692776560783, 0.023445677012205124, 0.019007723778486252, 0.03711706027388573, -0.015006039291620255, -0.02654186822474003, 0.003428034018725157, 0.04856269434094429, -0.06280656903982162, -0.006238160654902458, 0.019649948924779892, 0.04594448581337929, -0.007596658542752266, -0.01454396266490221, 0.04341348633170128, -0.013531279750168324, 0.05687786266207695, -0.004743410740047693, 0.02131621167063713, -0.06155020371079445, -0.07424444705247879, 0.0450383685529232, -0.035331785678863525, -0.023152470588684082, 0.0025070158299058676, -0.0024060301948338747, -0.02671247348189354, -0.029579458758234978, -0.05170052871108055, 0.06373527646064758, 0.014562149532139301, -0.02583262324333191, 0.05540607124567032, -0.06887564063072205, -0.003804418258368969, 0.005894067231565714, -0.02178056724369526, 0.016114749014377594, 0.04636223614215851, -0.0000038419316297222394, -0.041563570499420166, 0.053948286920785904, -0.05998663976788521, 0.04920942336320877, 0.033077988773584366, -0.006134169176220894, -0.014270628802478313, 0.07219350337982178, -0.02880915254354477, -0.011824049055576324, -0.05858467519283295, -0.03036659210920334, 0.014084752649068832, -0.07146963477134705, 0.026584237813949585, -0.023311812430620193, 0.02042863890528679, -0.0012407046742737293, 0.03986392542719841, -0.027644051238894463, 0.051287103444337845, 0.02952989935874939, 0.010659650899469852, -0.02281242050230503, 0.03960797190666199, -0.04180840402841568, 0.04469534754753113, -0.03936334699392319, -0.040697600692510605, -0.06044336035847664, -0.015560618601739407, 0.0026730364188551903, -0.01905704475939274, -0.03449215739965439, -0.006826838944107294, 0.016509756445884705, -0.043940573930740356, -0.031305842101573944, 0.042420871555805206, -0.003143321955576539, -0.038783054798841476, 0.051753684878349304, 0.0013552566524595022, -0.025759989395737648, -0.05439233034849167 ]
We implement the Bayesian inference to retrieve energy spectra of all neutrinos from a galactic core-collapse supernova (CCSN). To achieve high statistics and full sensitivity to all flavours of neutrinos, we adopt a combination of several reaction channels from different large-scale neutrino observatories, namely inverse beta decay on proton and elastic scattering on electron from Hyper-Kamiokande (Hyper-K), charged current absorption on Argon from Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) and coherent elastic scattering on Lead from RES-NOVA. Assuming no neutrino oscillation or specific oscillation models, we obtain mock data for each channel through Poisson processes with the predictions, for a typical source distance of 10 kpc in our Galaxy, and then evaluate the probability distributions for all spectral parameters of theoretical neutrino spectrum model with Bayes' theorem. Although the results for either the electron-neutrinos or electron-antineutrinos reserve relatively large uncertainties (according to the neutrino mass hierarchy), a precision of a few percent (i.e., $\pm 1 \% \sim \pm 4 \%$ at a credible interval of $2 \sigma$) is achieved for primary spectral parameters (e.g., mean energy and total emitted energy) of other neutrino species. Moreover, the correlation coefficients between different parameters are computed as well and interesting patterns are found. Especially, the mixing-induced correlations are sensitive to the neutrino mass hierarchy, which potentially makes it a brand new probe to determine the neutrino mass hierarchy in the detection of galactic supernova neutrinos. Finally, we discuss the origin of such correlation patterns and perspectives for further improvement on our results.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00392v2
[ -0.050633639097213745, -0.033671438694000244, 0.039027418941259384, 0.021271061152219772, 0.0017660011071711779, -0.0580727756023407, 0.011436328291893005, 0.03619984909892082, -0.03536933660507202, -0.030375855043530464, -0.01868239790201187, -0.06384923309087753, -0.038263123482465744, -0.07261451333761215, -0.03896311670541763, 0.018878605216741562, 0.04543594643473625, 0.03478279337286949, -0.04405978322029114, 0.0625302642583847, 0.006130628287792206, -0.030716881155967712, 0.035201240330934525, 0.019381940364837646, -0.024962790310382843, -0.0339348204433918, -0.02870842069387436, 0.0059204259887337685, -0.04251736029982567, -0.03620249405503273, 0.029974907636642456, -0.03739410638809204, -0.013736537657678127, -0.03344670683145523, -0.006419044919312, 0.009274005889892578, -0.03542103245854378, 0.04336492717266083, 0.058465853333473206, -0.017753107473254204, -0.029629144817590714, -0.06795307248830795, -0.05615106225013733, -0.030617594718933105, -0.004585618153214455, -0.03093741089105606, -0.010389748029410839, -0.027346648275852203, -0.03325396776199341, -0.06079868972301483, 0.02630084939301014, -0.01899855025112629, -0.006011974066495895, 0.02742508426308632, -0.0550854317843914, 0.03329405188560486, -0.01879790984094143, 0.002052146475762129, -0.06671395897865295, -0.01558003295212984, -0.010753685608506203, -0.03505704551935196, 0.008243962191045284, -0.04214077815413475, -0.044932831078767776, 0.0491042397916317, -0.018040122464299202, -0.05042332038283348, -0.041627418249845505, -0.057323358952999115, 0.025305110961198807, -0.07427559792995453, 0.022061139345169067, 0.0236541498452425, -0.029484650120139122, -0.019422180950641632, -0.01494638156145811, -0.024947665631771088, 0.027736399322748184, -0.00521557591855526, -0.05973631143569946, -0.036073483526706696, 0.00045971275540068746, 0.060103826224803925, 0.009938275441527367, -0.008626949973404408, 0.015399309806525707, 0.005395957268774509, 0.01076849177479744, -0.06162777543067932, 0.038296423852443695, -0.04365279898047447, -0.0594799742102623, -0.011331814341247082, 0.058906372636556625, -0.06169348955154419, 0.0571257509291172, 0.017681214958429337, 0.054075419902801514, -0.03990417346358299, 0.0131915882229805, -0.062104348093271255, -0.017741689458489418, 0.041428808122873306, 0.015326074324548244, 0.007403476629406214, -0.022051984444260597, -0.052167460322380066, -0.04883455112576485, 0.053027987480163574, 0.01131365168839693, -0.0061424048617482185, -0.012687800452113152, -0.01093111652880907, -0.03747554123401642, -0.06608948856592178, 0.0702923834323883, 0.030196109786629677, 0.0058561465702950954, -0.036199864000082016, -0.03779453784227371, 0.039906587451696396, 0.009058194234967232, -0.01667172834277153, -0.0054846266284585, 0.03150317817926407, 0.06688084453344345, -0.02953149378299713, 0.02722729556262493, 0.023054780438542366, -0.015116303227841854, 0.047670893371105194, -0.008649440482258797, -0.013535017147660255, 0.05985971912741661, -0.015438047237694263, 0.0012954061385244131, -0.0323466882109642, 0.0001985264098038897, 0.039527177810668945, -0.02342670038342476, -0.028523080050945282, 0.02647087536752224, 0.03595093637704849, -0.01816900074481964, -0.001188731170259416, -0.07530394941568375, 0.006604299880564213, 0.04288641735911369, 0.03831058368086815, 0.0029736177530139685, 0.013405008241534233, -0.015695108100771904, -0.025610165670514107, -0.024872740730643272, -0.02278531715273857, 0.010747523978352547, 0.02520272321999073, -0.038670942187309265, -0.018312128260731697, 0.03917945548892021, -0.03009503148496151, -0.007669437676668167, -0.008883428759872913, -0.01718093641102314, 0.03224542737007141, 0.012919741682708263, -0.054410774260759354, 0.02937902882695198, 0.0033234201837331057, -0.06848174333572388, 0.036837272346019745, 0.009084182791411877, -0.019067319110035896, -0.04182979837059975, -0.029619799926877022, 0.009522565640509129, -0.027895774692296982, -0.061685048043727875, 0.051639437675476074, 0.0211237370967865, 0.0008262178162112832, -0.04661603271961212, 0.045672524720430374, -0.023731490597128868, 0.0011085073929280043, -0.07394921034574509, 0.029975345358252525, 0.005846131592988968, -0.017005320638418198, 0.026336103677749634, -0.015057592652738094, 0.02579226717352867, -0.02135964296758175, -0.01944093033671379, -0.044684357941150665, 0.022665882483124733, 0.004464585799723864, -0.016987347975373268, -0.0069430372677743435, -0.06499181687831879, -0.0263082105666399, -0.004910854157060385, 0.012830645777285099, 0.009915279224514961, -0.04515520855784416, -0.007417487911880016, 0.03194272890686989, -0.03504915535449982, -0.030560100451111794, 0.03267562761902809, 0.05736273527145386, -0.01430532056838274, 0.022879216820001602, -0.031496286392211914, -0.02916797250509262, -0.0842452421784401, 0.06454101949930191, 0.034824907779693604, -0.02121882513165474, 0.008533871732652187, -0.04715436324477196, -0.019253147765994072, -0.019498484209179878, 0.00821346789598465, 0.06043356657028198, 0.0529891774058342, -0.028748439624905586, -0.05469590052962303, 0.011888398788869381, -0.002778224414214492, -0.045120395720005035, -0.04925677925348282, -0.06382859498262405, -0.03150947391986847, -0.0012765491846948862, -0.014344052411615849, 0.03886864706873894, -0.026372557505965233, -0.034230660647153854, -0.03421974927186966, -0.006352817639708519, 0.013903140090405941, -0.004563804250210524, -0.03886415436863899, -0.031178634613752365, -0.049572426825761795, 0.01217351108789444, -0.031777817755937576, -0.0508914440870285, -0.012115662917494774, -0.0412059910595417, -0.02569330669939518, 0.020031172782182693, 0.00046779224066995084, 0.04463499039411545, -0.03160685673356056, 0.00959406141191721, -0.004500768147408962, 0.05217050015926361, 0.00016981418593786657, 0.006299475207924843, -0.0391981340944767, 0.0353330634534359, -0.0020395468454807997, 0.03933295980095863, -0.015980493277311325, -0.011030083522200584, 0.009216824546456337, -0.0431041345000267, -0.03132898360490799, -0.004920098464936018, 0.054804470390081406, 0.05990350618958473, -0.01891365833580494, -0.0124057587236166, -0.04156725853681564, -0.0404253713786602, 0.027029121294617653, 0.005925314035266638, 0.05193101614713669, 0.05510760843753815, 0.02287573553621769, -0.058817725628614426, -0.0429709292948246, -0.050115831196308136, 0.018196485936641693, -0.0642622858285904, -0.0638296827673912, -0.04031934216618538, -0.07286687940359116, -0.041061483323574066, -0.04340985044836998, -0.02038842812180519, -0.030843963846564293, -0.024262653663754463, -0.03383990377187729, -0.011906670406460762, 0.011616266332566738, -0.07076121121644974, -0.02341284416615963, 0.028574205935001373, 0.03455405682325363, 0.05788423866033554, -0.05686558410525322, -0.02476929873228073, -0.028608011081814766, 0.010855423286557198, 0.023265445604920387, 0.04935552552342415, -0.056296318769454956, -0.03343483805656433, -0.06991499662399292, 0.014834531582891941, -0.009448505006730556, 0.0435422845184803, -0.035261962562799454, -0.014918322674930096, 0.00446361443027854, -0.02852042019367218, -0.007044502999633551, -0.046780262142419815, 0.005144912749528885, 0.012824857607483864, -0.041848935186862946, -0.06746121495962143, 0.03402470424771309, 0.07541000097990036, 0.012215031310915947, -0.05101035535335541, -0.0320037379860878, -0.0036283829249441624, -0.022141920402646065, -0.021820826455950737, 0.06480804830789566, 0.02443980984389782, -0.057176731526851654, 0.03189285099506378, -0.020487550646066666, 0.037310730665922165, 0.018924813717603683, -0.0042267004027962685, -0.02278963103890419, 0.0569111593067646, 0.008077142760157585, -0.059004783630371094, 0.04876796156167984, 0.03319108858704567, 0.04637685418128967, -0.01758400723338127, -0.054892510175704956, 0.03243239223957062, 0.01819533295929432, 0.01441231369972229, 0.004269038327038288, 0.0018819933757185936, 0.03352319449186325, 0.034433986991643906, -0.051889028400182724, 0.009016032330691814, -0.04621914401650429, -0.07314933836460114, -0.027817320078611374, 0.04133116826415062, 0.01080703642219305, 0.06007478013634682, 0.02272297441959381, -0.0023476427886635065, 0.018597479909658432, -0.0035258005373179913, 0.02437056414783001, -0.017256155610084534, -0.04368066042661667, 0.018779337406158447, -0.027636006474494934, 0.030226994305849075, -0.001544172060675919, 0.013404005207121372, 0.020327143371105194, -0.031613174825906754, 0.03803688660264015, -0.04253431782126427, 0.004220068920403719, -0.04820447415113449, 0.02645127847790718, -0.003674810752272606, 0.03446008265018463, -0.03321576490998268, 0.02307834103703499, 0.00004588207957567647, -0.0036503332667052746, -0.004475744906812906, 0.0017044746782630682, -0.035000622272491455, 0.004718428011983633, -0.013078730553388596, -0.021306456997990608, 0.03746255114674568, -0.001174531877040863, -0.0036926334723830223, -0.013640708290040493, 0.025269227102398872, -0.03203639015555382, -0.08103539794683456, -0.01450607180595398, -0.03737266734242439, 0.026205087080597878, -0.02386186271905899, 0.014596620574593544, 0.06060994416475296, 0.02660682611167431, -0.01704840548336506, -0.02003885805606842, 0.006267001386731863, -0.04767962172627449, -0.06112195923924446, 0.003878737101331353, -0.052607692778110504, 0.045860860496759415, -0.002410739194601774, 0.05904138833284378, -0.01131652295589447, 0.03334183990955353, -0.07591398805379868, -0.001566544990055263, -0.05667424201965332, -0.02111060731112957, 0.027258699759840965, 0.04913341626524925, 0.0553806908428669, 0.021196970716118813, 0.011645532213151455, 0.033905770629644394, -0.0012653747107833624, 0.03591364994645119, -0.02460211142897606, 0.0524035282433033, -0.03522460162639618, -0.06829208135604858, -0.018457120284438133, 0.00022230192553251982, 0.01885305717587471, -0.06032821536064148, -0.020031196996569633, -0.004920788109302521, 0.045872610062360764, -0.016956551000475883, -0.06955554336309433, -0.06146889179944992, -0.03130815178155899, -0.06612381339073181, -0.02739524468779564, 0.025993458926677704, -0.012286459095776081, -0.0037011404056102037, 0.012861963361501694, 0.006294888909906149, 0.005088122561573982, -0.03727545961737633, 0.05142774060368538, -0.018796032294631004, 0.032721374183893204, -0.023131905123591423, -0.02974523976445198, -0.06078352779150009, -0.015167996287345886, -0.031240148469805717, -0.03172210231423378, 0.027721183374524117, 0.015144945122301579, -0.03138356655836105, 0.05329236760735512, -0.07626800239086151, -0.016790295019745827, -0.00829362217336893, -0.04577885940670967, 0.009662776254117489, 0.008393814787268639, -0.006175111047923565, 0.002058685990050435, -0.03721969202160835, -0.02859402820467949, 0.011023186147212982, -0.0225095022469759, 0.02758110500872135, 0.03811885416507721, -0.06921987980604172, 0.018417993560433388, 0.013228114694356918, 0.0399690642952919, -0.03427240252494812, 0.008300837129354477, 0.06240852549672127, -0.0439012348651886, -0.013879199512302876, -0.023449812084436417, 0.049748245626688004, -0.038997989147901535, -0.05957138165831566, -0.05141741782426834, 0.022054988890886307, -0.05212980881333351, 0.04229393228888512, -0.039581216871738434, -0.020714929327368736, 0.002909949515014887, 0.024371447041630745, -0.004137458745390177, 0.043824203312397, -0.013999607414007187, 0.03442807495594025, 0.005351717118173838, 0.003534395946189761, -0.0672772228717804, -0.013438341207802296, -0.03307892382144928, 0.04876461252570152, -0.020481863990426064, 0.059200841933488846, -0.008267587050795555, 0.06752250343561172, -0.02850935235619545, -0.06309317797422409, -0.008592598140239716, 0.005947946570813656, 0.05400966480374336, -0.03464892506599426, -0.003432168625295162, -0.012983198277652264, 0.02650456689298153, -0.016159161925315857, -0.01913074404001236, 0.004456645343452692, -0.01115405559539795, -0.022435443475842476, -0.009408866986632347, 0.007576830219477415, 0.057690270245075226, -0.03548412397503853, -0.029202913865447044, 0.033664800226688385, -0.021091213449835777, 0.07336799055337906, 0.03303464129567146, -0.004367451183497906, 0.05559065565466881, -0.017097042873501778, 0.0008176789269782603, -0.06613766402006149, -0.0032930998131632805, 0.07065355032682419, -0.05536029115319252, -0.03315475583076477, -0.057889424264431, -0.05055218189954758, -0.012302304618060589, -0.04571905359625816, -0.03763900324702263, -0.008118770085275173, -0.011225146241486073, -0.056437648832798004, 0.0172562338411808, -0.0004824022180400789, -0.07397571206092834, 0.02135796844959259, 0.0010043352376669645, -0.07531137019395828, -0.026726169511675835, -0.001657842192798853, -0.035532962530851364, -0.06896340847015381, -0.006095195189118385, -0.03229546174407005, -0.03177499398589134, -0.04033314064145088, 0.06026732549071312, 0.057051073759794235, -0.034222234040498734, -0.0042821625247597694, 0.0013503358932211995, 0.03214799985289574, 0.036304034292697906, -0.052698347717523575, -0.04618283361196518, -0.023218529298901558, 0.056832436472177505, -0.01692463457584381, -0.030285939574241638, -0.02220826968550682, 0.04803353175520897, -0.033635374158620834, 0.014349767938256264, -0.050984010100364685, 0.001671448815613985, 0.046376097947359085, -0.047383442521095276, -0.04220299422740936, 0.0224112868309021, -0.026200732216238976, -0.00974819902330637, 0.0060852146707475185, -0.008535828441381454, -0.007428357377648354, 0.02792838215827942, 0.015965711325407028, -0.03338519483804703, -0.006149733439087868, -0.0405249185860157, -0.01813642308115959, 0.0331445187330246, -0.07837744802236557, -0.0015274721663445234, 0.009347518905997276, 0.04462523013353348, 0.013472379185259342, 0.04641643911600113, -0.04596346244215965, -0.024001598358154297, -0.052329570055007935, 0.039008233696222305, 0.05452030524611473, 0.002142862416803837, 0.02295166254043579, -0.049496978521347046, 0.03325448930263519, -0.042364317923784256, 0.056245043873786926, 0.007472035940736532, -0.01809304766356945, -0.010515308938920498, 0.0076124700717628, -0.045936938375234604, -0.017815593630075455, 0.0033765456173568964, -0.028816306963562965, 0.017626898363232613, 0.05241008102893829, -0.0088984165340662, -0.06636280566453934, -0.012002882547676563, -0.024563459679484367, -0.06057046353816986, -0.009020636789500713, -0.04812166467308998, 0.0512910895049572, -0.03189185634255409, 0.032813943922519684, 0.06670650094747543, -0.008886142633855343, -0.039463162422180176, -0.05776141583919525, -0.018750207498669624, 0.06124025583267212, 0.05033492669463158, -0.05381182208657265, -0.03988674283027649, -0.034543171525001526, -0.07008600980043411, -0.02800098992884159, 0.012091122567653656, 0.02484832890331745, -0.00045604020124301314, -0.07055342942476273, 0.038673873990774155, 0.02131972275674343, -0.03491881117224693, -0.06596416980028152, -0.030173221603035927, -0.02150898613035679, 0.005691711325198412, 0.028346478939056396, -0.006102572660893202, -0.030901100486516953, 0.03426899015903473, -0.08099430054426193, -0.025597190484404564, -0.03451552242040634, 0.045085612684488297, 0.006954875774681568, 0.016732515767216682, -0.04741844907402992, -0.03168846666812897, -0.011681756004691124, 0.03867218270897865, 0.0017170750070363283, 0.03344687819480896, 0.04638425633311272, -0.022284848615527153, -0.04629950225353241, -0.05711045488715172, 0.02780357003211975, -0.01888512820005417, -0.046320557594299316, 0.02115408331155777, 0.02599799446761608, -0.052453357726335526, 0.00009678409696789458, 0.05725424736738205, 0.002802326576784253, 0.02053980343043804, -0.03448839485645294, 0.001788259600289166, -0.043746575713157654, -0.044629499316215515, -0.0036659068427979946, -0.014879213646054268, -0.012842864729464054, -0.023193204775452614, 0.012991786003112793, -0.0253326166421175, -0.04812285304069519, -0.022498847916722298, 0.02347331866621971, 0.03996236249804497, 0.015819136053323746, 0.06005551293492317, -0.07745490223169327, -0.009952867403626442, -0.009570810943841934, 0.03781937062740326, -0.054959747940301895, 0.012037658132612705, -0.015085697174072266, -0.06285051256418228, -0.05067501217126846, -0.05506642535328865, 0.01959540881216526, -0.017998313531279564, -0.03454389423131943, -0.007737926673144102, 0.04344742000102997, -0.04884069412946701, -0.004028618801385164, 0.01779382862150669, -0.04181284457445145, -0.011014488525688648, -0.05059867352247238, 0.014928281307220459, -0.022143976762890816, 0.045276276767253876, 0.014676552265882492, 0.04730755463242531, 0.04012493044137955, 0.05060086399316788, 0.014012766070663929, -0.03965747728943825, -0.024983223527669907, 0.035251982510089874, -0.011946567334234715, 0.03325478360056877, -0.016580862924456596, -0.015342703089118004, -0.05958131328225136, 0.020477401092648506, -0.010157156735658646, 0.008776020258665085, -0.0041940766386687756, 0.0021274557802826166, -0.038980964571237564, -0.06658802181482315, -0.035153962671756744, 0.02306332066655159, 0.029331346973776817, -0.043230585753917694, 0.0326513797044754, 0.0274655818939209, 0.00008382466330658644, -0.05938265845179558 ]
Non-governmental organizations for environmental conservation have a significant interest in monitoring conservation-related media and getting timely updates about infrastructure construction projects as they may cause massive impact to key conservation areas. Such monitoring, however, is difficult and time-consuming. We introduce NewsPanda, a toolkit which automatically detects and analyzes online articles related to environmental conservation and infrastructure construction. We fine-tune a BERT-based model using active learning methods and noise correction algorithms to identify articles that are relevant to conservation and infrastructure construction. For the identified articles, we perform further analysis, extracting keywords and finding potentially related sources. NewsPanda has been successfully deployed by the World Wide Fund for Nature teams in the UK, India, and Nepal since February 2022. It currently monitors over 80,000 websites and 1,074 conservation sites across India and Nepal, saving more than 30 hours of human efforts weekly. We have now scaled it up to cover 60,000 conservation sites globally.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01503v1
[ -0.006880414206534624, -0.05200241506099701, 0.05022452399134636, 0.023878581821918488, -0.01844119094312191, -0.009573991410434246, 0.004195105284452438, -0.010075255297124386, -0.02656184323132038, -0.05009125918149948, -0.04807113856077194, 0.04585382714867592, -0.0283929742872715, -0.011773334816098213, -0.019189689308404922, 0.0302941482514143, 0.06483830511569977, -0.009475555270910263, -0.06377849727869034, 0.025277698412537575, -0.00045132002560421824, -0.04232193902134895, -0.012949424795806408, 0.012097331695258617, 0.046264421194791794, -0.029972335323691368, -0.025181850418448448, -0.011461812071502209, -0.041552651673555374, 0.01666146144270897, 0.04273310676217079, -0.015570968389511108, -0.0036928218323737383, -0.01762975938618183, -0.0632862001657486, -0.01571008190512657, -0.04912663996219635, 0.04866567254066467, -0.023831060156226158, -0.016756175085902214, 0.03874116763472557, -0.05584266409277916, -0.051885705441236496, -0.006018264219164848, -0.03093951940536499, -0.04221540689468384, -0.05421377345919609, 0.013618620112538338, -0.06080817058682442, -0.05376458913087845, -0.006099334917962551, 0.01354676391929388, 0.02517417073249817, 0.04200955480337143, -0.0017548472387716174, -0.05296172946691513, -0.011578934267163277, 0.045937471091747284, -0.06063636392354965, 0.028792638331651688, 0.08380457013845444, -0.016063613817095757, -0.017892420291900635, 0.03167140856385231, 0.03683308884501457, 0.06067840754985809, -0.01188336219638586, -0.03950661048293114, 0.00964231975376606, -0.04894794523715973, 0.003300739685073495, -0.032542821019887924, 0.01123929675668478, -0.011566946282982826, -0.007731900084763765, -0.0038912720046937466, -0.02146025002002716, -0.03198913112282753, 0.008201991207897663, 0.03066498413681984, -0.03152874857187271, -0.026508178561925888, 0.0569276288151741, 0.05118432268500328, 0.023591460660099983, -0.024889517575502396, -0.02918328531086445, -0.0045766690745949745, 0.014326325617730618, -0.010184304788708687, 0.030447514727711678, -0.07133524119853973, -0.07271519303321838, -0.027301276102662086, 0.0647590309381485, -0.0011539951665326953, 0.029818158596754074, 0.07875968515872955, 0.0017540770350024104, -0.026039835065603256, -0.037134457379579544, 0.016202177852392197, 0.03030569478869438, 0.03009999915957451, -0.009516503661870956, -0.030766403302550316, -0.0059218816459178925, -0.002576324623078108, -0.04747968167066574, -0.029000485315918922, -0.0066626351326704025, -0.0212171021848917, -0.00998929888010025, -0.08620572835206985, -0.07153720408678055, -0.0599348209798336, 0.032908156514167786, -0.03743135929107666, 0.04085478186607361, -0.02095124125480652, -0.00344818620942533, 0.0471719391644001, 0.05703360214829445, 0.02505575679242611, -0.028634116053581238, -0.009945224970579147, 0.06603573262691498, -0.04244048148393631, -0.009811501950025558, 0.012960807420313358, -0.011629787273705006, 0.06915213912725449, -0.04021573066711426, -0.01622101292014122, 0.03198132663965225, 0.005190558731555939, -0.005015714094042778, -0.030152125284075737, -0.01515281293541193, -0.029297469183802605, -0.035654738545417786, 0.016596447676420212, 0.0201418474316597, 0.0027957384008914232, 0.039528392255306244, 0.037864211946725845, -0.021608347073197365, -0.040511924773454666, 0.0023375493474304676, 0.04106396064162254, 0.0016278151888400316, 0.013514232821762562, 0.06265199929475784, 0.03657285124063492, 0.046434275805950165, -0.0496848039329052, 0.015638606622815132, -0.014334253035485744, -0.05145151540637016, 0.025899739935994148, 0.0009721351671032608, -0.020678678527474403, 0.04454665258526802, -0.047775670886039734, -0.013785932213068008, -0.010636434890329838, -0.001084785209968686, 0.0014441506937146187, 0.024098552763462067, -0.0034427037462592125, -0.007374071981757879, -0.03346341848373413, -0.0013932366855442524, -0.012662747874855995, -0.07207681983709335, 0.0056320661678910255, 0.016109393909573555, -0.021958889439702034, 0.0038709237705916166, 0.005404944531619549, -0.0263343695551157, 0.04082758352160454, -0.01307199988514185, 0.02032332308590412, -0.0025854906998574734, 0.00508722523227334, -0.06727927923202515, -0.034487251192331314, 0.03234109655022621, 0.002240885281935334, -0.01931287907063961, -0.029043611139059067, 0.011594755575060844, -0.04427175968885422, -0.03808256611227989, 0.008589818142354488, -0.0052879140712320805, -0.06815776228904724, 0.06104947626590729, 0.0015980714233592153, -0.06181342899799347, 0.011474213562905788, -0.08958069235086441, 0.024028219282627106, 0.03809988126158714, -0.08324811607599258, -0.05108509212732315, 0.02224826067686081, -0.017473582178354263, 0.0439084991812706, 0.044046998023986816, 0.044977981597185135, 0.06651309877634048, 0.01285646203905344, 0.01011531800031662, 0.0067949453368783, -0.10652530193328857, 0.0024621332995593548, 0.049778517335653305, 0.03872140496969223, 0.007636006455868483, 0.040340080857276917, -0.005371744278818369, 0.042014624923467636, -0.028419267386198044, -0.027804546058177948, 0.013047485612332821, -0.04888839274644852, -0.03969959914684296, -0.03954075649380684, -0.028900163248181343, -0.06278400868177414, -0.013282929547131062, -0.045136403292417526, -0.00829976238310337, -0.03796135634183884, -0.03186928108334541, 0.012751630507409573, 0.004686832427978516, 0.045468833297491074, 0.02664324827492237, -0.015527398325502872, 0.0399605818092823, -0.00344358803704381, -0.02657284587621689, 0.016446193680167198, -0.0027607285883277655, 0.022527595981955528, -0.029254743829369545, -0.04093015193939209, 0.00961565226316452, -0.04804925620555878, 0.005440960638225079, 0.0002069991605821997, 0.036225754767656326, -0.010493101552128792, -0.036855023354291916, 0.022216148674488068, -0.04694759473204613, 0.04698020964860916, -0.007011208683252335, 0.06653518229722977, -0.039706021547317505, -0.01720139943063259, 0.018133221194148064, -0.00701912771910429, -0.03783884644508362, -0.0645240843296051, -0.006388029083609581, -0.0029909603763371706, 0.03700656071305275, -0.007614221423864365, 0.0635145902633667, -0.03783746808767319, -0.04822707921266556, -0.02673272415995598, 0.03982246667146683, 0.02782229520380497, 0.04205334559082985, 0.07408507913351059, 0.00884182658046484, 0.033069364726543427, 0.0556030347943306, -0.06671568751335144, -0.04002761468291283, -0.07201816886663437, 0.021013202145695686, -0.05293094366788864, -0.056716520339250565, -0.0701182633638382, -0.048734430223703384, 0.024500660598278046, -0.02561228536069393, -0.03986174240708351, -0.029737969860434532, -0.0008784983074292541, -0.05755619332194328, -0.00020082524861209095, 0.013739262707531452, -0.015261604450643063, -0.003165586618706584, 0.0018681117799133062, 0.04241856187582016, 0.005048562306910753, 0.009329934604465961, -0.002755481516942382, -0.0018157586455345154, -0.01804194785654545, 0.014566086232662201, 0.04003584384918213, 0.04981662333011627, -0.01849653758108616, -0.03119036927819252, 0.057557664811611176, 0.003061483148485422, 0.013790610246360302, -0.012753482908010483, 0.013582860119640827, 0.006547070574015379, -0.007548878435045481, 0.0072845108807086945, -0.028551196679472923, 0.015948111191391945, -0.05695401877164841, -0.07331220805644989, -0.05253089964389801, 0.041626062244176865, -0.0040117609314620495, -0.004768917337059975, -0.0367165133357048, 0.03875479847192764, 0.02196112647652626, -0.04924893379211426, 0.031362384557724, 0.010912527330219746, 0.019079918041825294, -0.03300546854734421, -0.01108253188431263, 0.014396825805306435, 0.01091077458113432, 0.04669640213251114, -0.002889553550630808, -0.020805291831493378, 0.004940089304000139, 0.04016325622797012, -0.09291335940361023, 0.03919312357902527, 0.02886172942817211, 0.07276113331317902, 0.04446035251021385, 0.04351472854614258, 0.007373490370810032, 0.0408698134124279, 0.02751759998500347, -0.00666745426133275, 0.05231521651148796, 0.03310059383511543, 0.059632837772369385, -0.03855183720588684, -0.03724605590105057, 0.0003700758970808238, -0.044305652379989624, -0.05116445943713188, -0.005638317670673132, 0.024305665865540504, 0.024348057806491852, 0.046428658068180084, -0.050896335393190384, -0.027189187705516815, -0.022893348708748817, 0.045225195586681366, 0.018617749214172363, -0.058248087763786316, 0.041328880935907364, -0.03013390116393566, 0.036624033004045486, -0.01458720676600933, -0.031268421560525894, 0.04515131190419197, -0.04059464856982231, 0.00528864748775959, -0.05503452941775322, 0.017618287354707718, 0.021706942468881607, 0.0063390531577169895, -0.021893195807933807, 0.02194991707801819, -0.02654576301574707, 0.06040070205926895, -0.01073569618165493, -0.06421537697315216, -0.005542305763810873, 0.0013543262612074614, -0.03471866250038147, 0.008652500808238983, -0.048512909561395645, -0.0264674611389637, 0.055198609828948975, 0.020510824397206306, -0.011491590179502964, -0.011668029241263866, -0.03441400080919266, -0.001394464634358883, -0.060982972383499146, 0.054974399507045746, -0.035905513912439346, 0.02696368284523487, 0.03505467250943184, 0.00904111098498106, 0.07198426127433777, -0.07044500857591629, -0.0030740301590412855, -0.06948114931583405, 0.032264646142721176, -0.015154851600527763, -0.016592372208833694, 0.011417504400014877, -0.05557979270815849, 0.02624291367828846, -0.04294537752866745, 0.0686538890004158, -0.01571350358426571, 0.011026092804968357, -0.019427096471190453, -0.04414508491754532, -0.06448245793581009, -0.01599852368235588, 0.05006797984242439, 0.041676972061395645, 0.03499063476920128, -0.002444097539409995, 0.04334596171975136, 0.03652423247694969, 0.012909694574773312, 0.03610392287373543, 0.012874445877969265, 0.030373042449355125, -0.00551133556291461, 0.014452489092946053, -0.019744057208299637, -0.05256883054971695, 0.03883793205022812, -0.010280260816216469, -0.007394337560981512, 0.02006165310740471, 0.017131518572568893, 0.001591521198861301, -0.05974389612674713, -0.017121627926826477, -0.0582360103726387, -0.030812595039606094, -0.008050384931266308, 0.05128272622823715, 0.02753640152513981, -0.010180097073316574, 0.025906603783369064, 0.007703291717916727, 0.011299905367195606, -0.007849538698792458, 0.03078945353627205, -0.023837551474571228, -0.011544088833034039, -0.004581557121127844, 0.00015243330562952906, -0.04540134221315384, -0.0029041587840765715, -0.00708608515560627, -0.038428883999586105, -0.0008202443714253604, 0.03703607991337776, 0.0416971854865551, 0.04139604791998863, -0.08321923762559891, 0.014933976344764233, 0.036100734025239944, -0.010403462685644627, 0.005563896615058184, 0.030115386471152306, 0.0368155762553215, 0.008163440972566605, -0.008530808612704277, -0.003211272181943059, 0.02685532346367836, -0.037215180695056915, 0.018438344821333885, 0.03688785806298256, -0.04457399249076843, -0.002057221019640565, -0.01803099550306797, 0.04103850573301315, -0.059852972626686096, 0.027317257598042488, 0.021903377026319504, 0.019259924069046974, 0.04358137398958206, -0.007624926511198282, 0.04502187296748161, -0.007877507247030735, -0.014463220722973347, -0.016569530591368675, 0.013739376328885555, -0.0037890439853072166, 0.028408123180270195, -0.02967272512614727, -0.0004266579635441303, 0.028571991249918938, 0.0005718299653381109, 0.035674117505550385, 0.03155382722616196, 0.04568151757121086, 0.025264116004109383, 0.013516963459551334, 0.018550951033830643, -0.041543327271938324, -0.047930922359228134, -0.05166652798652649, 0.027415478602051735, 0.05379496142268181, 0.07102086395025253, 0.04376231133937836, 0.014896775595843792, 0.03263436257839203, 0.008833336643874645, -0.0060135312378406525, -0.06305810064077377, -0.03301962837576866, -0.02418290078639984, 0.02422444336116314, -0.015761878341436386, -0.0056981309317052364, 0.006092556286603212, 0.009379294700920582, 0.016425294801592827, 0.016005558893084526, 0.019690606743097305, -0.00993852037936449, 0.01567174680531025, -0.02834673784673214, -0.06078675016760826, 0.0020318306051194668, -0.003578077768906951, -0.03461463749408722, 0.04685935378074646, 0.04896824434399605, -0.04247378557920456, 0.0721619576215744, -0.011244184337556362, -0.031078550964593887, 0.013121766969561577, 0.013549525290727615, 0.06721431016921997, -0.0504685677587986, 0.04039037600159645, 0.012286205776035786, 0.007077435031533241, 0.028248831629753113, -0.00046817230759188533, 0.03532063961029053, 0.04447831213474274, -0.009893055073916912, -0.051373329013586044, 0.0643271878361702, -0.033279698342084885, -0.07423954457044601, 0.02147015556693077, -0.03763146698474884, -0.10100685060024261, -0.018385909497737885, -0.04216521978378296, 0.04678347334265709, 0.02677028439939022, 0.022710531949996948, -0.024654075503349304, 0.020217517390847206, -0.016709089279174805, 0.0684882253408432, 0.07746966928243637, 0.019192643463611603, -0.055920396000146866, 0.03433389216661453, -0.0416417270898819, -0.006463017780333757, 0.021421749144792557, 0.00682083610445261, 0.0026579133700579405, 0.06189412251114845, 0.02160765416920185, -0.022113604471087456, -0.03167075291275978, 0.014342185109853745, -0.07511996477842331, -0.01031119842082262, -0.0012931929668411613, -0.02249152958393097, 0.05226469784975052, -0.0312868133187294, -0.06140855699777603, 0.005066669080406427, -0.0016772131202742457, -0.00009679778304416686, 0.020257914438843727, 0.001353466184809804, 0.014750051312148571, 0.05646347999572754, -0.003553300630301237, -0.06243469938635826, 0.003655487671494484, -0.019299134612083435, -0.05128239840269089, 0.06332147121429443, -0.07698895782232285, 0.009829581715166569, -0.061242491006851196, 0.003411161480471492, 0.042450495064258575, 0.0023446043487638235, -0.03208797797560692, -0.034358009696006775, 0.01138028409332037, -0.02660318836569786, 0.052960578352212906, -0.0032663189340382814, 0.027749458327889442, -0.04624910280108452, 0.04409627616405487, -0.011042362079024315, -0.05322304740548134, -0.01022971048951149, -0.0009912316454574466, -0.012941190972924232, -0.03980829194188118, 0.007831815630197525, -0.04892776161432266, 0.03406662866473198, -0.029233230277895927, 0.019271301105618477, 0.02423754148185253, -0.08350193500518799, -0.04402253404259682, -0.025417830795049667, 0.054959487169981, 0.024315984919667244, -0.00471480842679739, 0.03125784173607826, 0.04329850524663925, -0.024093156680464745, 0.030435286462306976, -0.020749017596244812, 0.0007540729711763561, 0.016944656148552895, -0.05432598292827606, -0.025183016434311867, -0.012723670341074467, -0.017887262627482414, -0.01120843831449747, -0.04008231312036514, 0.0019777538254857063, -0.06845574080944061, -0.04094923660159111, 0.051382068544626236, -0.04310910031199455, -0.014691510237753391, -0.0835445299744606, 0.0114095788449049, -0.018005074933171272, 0.00990151334553957, -0.05836638808250427, 0.006049240007996559, -0.03187951073050499, -0.029512645676732063, 0.024728290736675262, -0.045545272529125214, 0.0007731234072707593, 0.06579475849866867, -0.07008852064609528, 0.01113725733011961, 0.021319998428225517, 0.04850613325834274, -0.012056530453264713, -0.012974920682609081, -0.015016002580523491, -0.05245943367481232, -0.044450026005506516, 0.0385599248111248, -0.0432087704539299, -0.04097383841872215, 0.028904668986797333, 0.04190319776535034, -0.04024290293455124, -0.01487666368484497, -0.021104013547301292, -0.03592853620648384, -0.011328613385558128, 0.055969879031181335, 0.01400439627468586, 0.020491480827331543, -0.01692107319831848, 0.016833271831274033, -0.05276656523346901, -0.027322525158524513, -0.02692103013396263, 0.013569758273661137, -0.001954049803316593, -0.05633339658379555, -0.020304735749959946, -0.01999600976705551, 0.01359509490430355, 0.015628160908818245, 0.006998754106462002, 0.0067284260876476765, -0.056755926460027695, -0.05115118622779846, 0.011451669968664646, -0.005021599121391773, 0.026041176170110703, 0.07690843939781189, -0.0668904185295105, 0.019343679770827293, -0.0013192846672609448, -0.04041990637779236, -0.03519709035754204, 0.010251768864691257, 0.036576688289642334, -0.07778926193714142, 0.0039498470723629, -0.04193023219704628, 0.006256815046072006, -0.002205116907134652, 0.040861889719963074, -0.03862189128994942, 0.05140416696667671, 0.020435187965631485, -0.019565561786293983, -0.0734957605600357, -0.0491635799407959, -0.06457547843456268, -0.05777370184659958, -0.06439781188964844, -0.04607856273651123, 0.02315373532474041, 0.01777016930282116, -0.03697499260306358, 0.010898559354245663, 0.045914459973573685, 0.02345481514930725, 0.015578747726976871, 0.04367651790380478, 0.020798876881599426, 0.0014031401369720697, 0.07672346383333206, -0.03638284280896187, 0.007567898370325565, -0.06124051660299301, 0.02307991124689579, 0.0008681548642925918, 0.014726927503943443, -0.004711313173174858, -0.0539851039648056, -0.003087244927883148, -0.03922438994050026, 0.012156862765550613, 0.0028149322606623173, 0.009025663137435913, -0.037452179938554764, -0.04517841339111328, 0.0139188002794981, -0.020891273394227028, -0.043287817388772964 ]
This paper provides a comprehensive tutorial for Bayesian practitioners in pharmacometrics using Pumas workflows. We start by giving a brief motivation of Bayesian inference for pharmacometrics highlighting limitations in existing software that Pumas addresses. We then follow by a description of all the steps of a standard Bayesian workflow for pharmacometrics using code snippets and examples. This includes: model definition, prior selection, sampling from the posterior, prior and posterior simulations and predictions, counter-factual simulations and predictions, convergence diagnostics, visual predictive checks, and finally model comparison with cross-validation. Finally, the background and intuition behind many advanced concepts in Bayesian statistics are explained in simple language. This includes many important ideas and precautions that users need to keep in mind when performing Bayesian analysis. Many of the algorithms, codes, and ideas presented in this paper are highly applicable to clinical research and statistical learning at large but we chose to focus our discussions on pharmacometrics in this paper to have a narrower scope in mind and given the nature of Pumas as a software primarily for pharmacometricians.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.04752v1
[ -0.004672316834330559, -0.0424947589635849, 0.04671182110905647, 0.01101954560726881, -0.02269030548632145, -0.03125318884849548, -0.023964015766978264, -0.05226456746459007, -0.002271089004352689, -0.014740196987986565, -0.07059217989444733, -0.030175700783729553, -0.03445081785321236, -0.0435149222612381, -0.02956048585474491, 0.007380734197795391, 0.023008670657873154, 0.04942210763692856, -0.01846431940793991, 0.05785318836569786, -0.015209686011075974, -0.02959258109331131, -0.020353538915514946, 0.04251018911600113, 0.042276181280612946, -0.011800432577729225, 0.00667903758585453, -0.03822389990091324, -0.05440870299935341, -0.0007017026073299348, 0.053692419081926346, -0.0745067447423935, -0.030489329248666763, -0.045528776943683624, -0.01357517670840025, -0.01365985069423914, -0.010234229266643524, -0.034395623952150345, 0.02174299582839012, -0.00043401183211244643, 0.045277189463377, -0.049149289727211, -0.04402131214737892, -0.005979280918836594, -0.02446639910340309, -0.00021714223839808255, -0.07071306556463242, 0.05793900415301323, -0.09224358201026917, -0.060519739985466, -0.010370959527790546, -0.005818407982587814, 0.0001838223688537255, 0.07543541491031647, -0.05882667750120163, 0.02439139224588871, 0.024178987368941307, 0.015203054994344711, -0.05645337700843811, 0.026136845350265503, 0.023797184228897095, 0.016078265383839607, 0.04206206277012825, 0.01355900801718235, 0.02359805814921856, 0.04188403859734535, -0.006962908431887627, -0.07194434851408005, -0.04480529949069023, -0.05191449448466301, 0.04453923925757408, -0.03757345676422119, 0.0003622202784754336, 0.04396107792854309, -0.024451976642012596, -0.03703116998076439, -0.01726694218814373, -0.04541154205799103, -0.005658803973346949, 0.05541076138615608, -0.04680411145091057, 0.0115076694637537, 0.024611016735434532, 0.001636373926885426, 0.011356022208929062, -0.054131295531988144, 0.012864377349615097, -0.01200006902217865, 0.020405860617756844, -0.026027774438261986, 0.041162341833114624, -0.05063781887292862, -0.08224881440401077, 0.05115048214793205, 0.05718609690666199, -0.00959443487226963, 0.043999046087265015, 0.02072165720164776, 0.056153979152441025, -0.005103675648570061, 0.014591870829463005, 0.02579590119421482, 0.009128210134804249, 0.047455113381147385, 0.04939021170139313, -0.05810928717255592, 0.03213091567158699, -0.039990268647670746, -0.004454165231436491, -0.03198102489113808, -0.03751996532082558, -0.025746934115886688, 0.0014753482537344098, -0.07531888037919998, -0.012080084532499313, -0.000050720820581773296, 0.03363094851374626, 0.019542042165994644, 0.04765598103404045, -0.014024452306330204, -0.029737848788499832, 0.04795683175325394, -0.001984710805118084, -0.015216635540127754, -0.043984949588775635, 0.0032459741923958063, 0.04798762872815132, 0.002640704857185483, -0.03164656087756157, -0.02200963906943798, -0.05252266302704811, -0.006527773104608059, -0.05232251435518265, 0.01749916933476925, 0.06308692693710327, -0.0021277882624417543, -0.02831118553876877, -0.048340924084186554, 0.060178447514772415, 0.013847843743860722, -0.05229150876402855, -0.0631202682852745, 0.03472920507192612, -0.06587615609169006, 0.020866122096776962, 0.07182963937520981, -0.021746473386883736, 0.02817101590335369, 0.04284713417291641, 0.017622429877519608, 0.016184687614440918, -0.04717177897691727, 0.013168076053261757, 0.00294181308709085, 0.014585954137146473, -0.044029925018548965, 0.050048016011714935, -0.010522768832743168, -0.05250651389360428, 0.009445511735975742, 0.05504721403121948, -0.02468262054026127, 0.02607559785246849, -0.0330001600086689, 0.01773235574364662, -0.015247128903865814, 0.03744881600141525, 0.004548381548374891, 0.014285429380834103, 0.01227969117462635, -0.06170892342925072, 0.028333930298686028, -0.034863680601119995, -0.05659822002053261, -0.061028216034173965, -0.012410352937877178, 0.030092520639300346, -0.05780850723385811, -0.07748287916183472, -0.012473334558308125, 0.01466435007750988, -0.00942276418209076, -0.05864182487130165, 0.04066549986600876, -0.036463454365730286, -0.0013401422183960676, -0.06403113156557083, -0.0015232296427711844, 0.05576398968696594, 0.025145437568426132, -0.023758944123983383, -0.017066102474927902, -0.013077295385301113, -0.0074059064500033855, -0.02307102270424366, -0.01449406985193491, 0.03642243891954422, -0.011765156872570515, 0.01609032042324543, 0.019182905554771423, -0.08388013392686844, -0.044270362704992294, -0.07514780759811401, -0.012410355731844902, -0.03373214602470398, -0.04608152434229851, 0.0045711626298725605, 0.022472161799669266, -0.0016975476173684, 0.002533332444727421, -0.0030425654258579016, 0.05968330428004265, 0.06728554517030716, 0.02369779534637928, -0.011904300190508366, -0.008328177034854889, -0.10546640306711197, 0.06078481674194336, 0.017031248658895493, -0.01135388296097517, 0.014894961379468441, 0.04405468329787254, -0.022471845149993896, -0.005898431874811649, -0.02932409755885601, 0.06170067563652992, -0.016619747504591942, -0.017559215426445007, -0.042542800307273865, -0.009665777906775475, -0.036924026906490326, -0.056057143956422806, -0.002207744400948286, -0.05748807638883591, -0.035605281591415405, -0.0062188333831727505, 0.04245125874876976, 0.03491399064660072, -0.009370856918394566, -0.05266467481851578, -0.04673832654953003, -0.04320646822452545, 0.059955909848213196, 0.005257490091025829, -0.02231249399483204, -0.028393957763910294, -0.041184213012456894, 0.0049943397752940655, 0.016309751197695732, -0.015955165028572083, -0.008764381520450115, -0.012118958868086338, 0.006140060257166624, -0.037357449531555176, 0.0143399927765131, 0.02606537751853466, -0.004944599699229002, 0.01813034899532795, -0.005817193537950516, -0.017114566639065742, 0.0652322843670845, 0.04655462130904198, -0.0485578328371048, 0.027049677446484566, 0.040714081376791, 0.03719567507505417, 0.03861887380480766, -0.018302906304597855, -0.009874878451228142, -0.00626211054623127, 0.03327144309878349, 0.007247725035995245, 0.04695780575275421, -0.02721352130174637, -0.04163724556565285, -0.04390602931380272, 0.010507694445550442, -0.042751677334308624, 0.02807227149605751, 0.06411582231521606, 0.04085543006658554, -0.01631934754550457, -0.013989209197461605, -0.06835214793682098, 0.0013369288062676787, -0.013414894230663776, 0.00047682292643003166, -0.07260068506002426, -0.06336545199155807, 0.005919346585869789, -0.08351358771324158, 0.018296869471669197, -0.01780278980731964, -0.05515904352068901, -0.010014421306550503, -0.060941558331251144, -0.005953826941549778, 0.005566644016653299, 0.059200771152973175, 0.004249867983162403, -0.06350921094417572, -0.040679942816495895, 0.001829093205742538, 0.04963557794690132, 0.00273964018560946, -0.037634897977113724, -0.02097422070801258, 0.022844750434160233, 0.024418793618679047, 0.018061751499772072, -0.04241358861327171, 0.05965353548526764, 0.00016696524107828736, 0.002200986025854945, -0.022629188373684883, -0.007617628667503595, -0.022422121837735176, 0.05705892667174339, -0.015568844974040985, 0.0198146291077137, -0.03211315721273422, 0.0045480248518288136, 0.022498534992337227, -0.0362064503133297, -0.05263160914182663, 0.005306995008140802, 0.05626234784722328, -0.020568184554576874, -0.023123441264033318, -0.019917262718081474, -0.0030372515320777893, 0.03756969794631004, 0.03136899322271347, -0.00015744408301543444, 0.023628510534763336, 0.01708531565964222, 0.00282533117569983, -0.0371081680059433, 0.004101795144379139, -0.012975760735571384, -0.017847878858447075, 0.04342226684093475, -0.03035474382340908, -0.05047743394970894, 0.0643368661403656, -0.08892345428466797, 0.003394348081201315, 0.03287679702043533, 0.07884806394577026, -0.008113282732665539, -0.0242985337972641, 0.03168103098869324, 0.004646570421755314, -0.02518496662378311, -0.01162016112357378, 0.039755258709192276, 0.05595919489860535, 0.018521195277571678, -0.022271061316132545, -0.06035365164279938, 0.00555396405979991, -0.06788311898708344, -0.05931463465094566, -0.008849326521158218, 0.03785233199596405, 0.0018054309766739607, 0.027130799368023872, -0.058487724512815475, 0.012261019088327885, -0.0393143892288208, 0.039089180529117584, 0.018590804189443588, -0.013879372738301754, 0.007251547183841467, -0.060676053166389465, 0.03185359388589859, 0.030096858739852905, -0.021754242479801178, 0.00044303774484433234, -0.03553760051727295, 0.04102222993969917, -0.02598891779780388, 0.04667279124259949, 0.03482656553387642, -0.0015751440078020096, 0.015276681631803513, 0.02146402932703495, -0.024805478751659393, 0.025218365713953972, -0.02687392197549343, 0.00883083138614893, 0.01853366568684578, 0.007507755886763334, -0.04884452745318413, -0.025988036766648293, -0.04929719120264053, -0.00003845669198199175, 0.019781358540058136, -0.026695089414715767, -0.015005506575107574, -0.05793137848377228, -0.030122598633170128, -0.027512425556778908, -0.0870230421423912, 0.01604229398071766, -0.05910749360918999, 0.05215109884738922, 0.015949126332998276, -0.07002069801092148, 0.03569848835468292, -0.03086557239294052, -0.032508734613657, 0.01134877372533083, -0.019356202334165573, -0.0003486083005554974, -0.01731402426958084, -0.017448388040065765, -0.07258027791976929, 0.02594716288149357, -0.0393209233880043, 0.04914887249469757, -0.03572702407836914, 0.01594056934118271, -0.030236802995204926, -0.01474896352738142, -0.011420080438256264, -0.0023053332697600126, 0.06337708234786987, 0.031744636595249176, -0.0020017640199512243, -0.04429275542497635, 0.03993576020002365, 0.03537915274500847, 0.02729487046599388, -0.028238235041499138, -0.007487112190574408, -0.0014748582616448402, -0.022637909278273582, -0.012165133841335773, 0.003925185650587082, -0.015171421691775322, 0.07531604915857315, 0.005073949228972197, -0.023330574855208397, -0.026881955564022064, 0.03107636608183384, -0.054719094187021255, -0.07910145074129105, -0.016030309721827507, -0.01497579924762249, -0.0202335212379694, -0.032674454152584076, 0.052402790635824203, 0.015704428777098656, -0.031704194843769073, 0.028552014380693436, 0.004585620481520891, 0.028361370787024498, -0.024886440485715866, 0.026763806119561195, 0.029561040922999382, -0.008873241022229195, 0.007656990550458431, 0.007325918413698673, -0.04986339807510376, -0.028674667701125145, -0.04815322533249855, -0.02981344610452652, -0.014202842488884926, 0.06620974838733673, 0.016084857285022736, 0.049041472375392914, -0.07660716772079468, 0.021820081397891045, 0.0038309821393340826, -0.028036203235387802, 0.03067556396126747, 0.06382516026496887, -0.004696494434028864, 0.0020833914168179035, -0.0711856409907341, 0.0036461809650063515, 0.024931713938713074, -0.01012501586228609, 0.00402187742292881, 0.008106335066258907, 0.021194960922002792, 0.01864219456911087, 0.046557288616895676, -0.044978067278862, -0.022521216422319412, -0.0008133754599839449, 0.03478839620947838, 0.030738376080989838, -0.025140956044197083, 0.004782222677022219, 0.03701974079012871, -0.033028796315193176, -0.05157467722892761, -0.020866088569164276, -0.019514190033078194, -0.034246545284986496, 0.034915272146463394, -0.01407924946397543, 0.044362910091876984, 0.03513091057538986, 0.01778356358408928, 0.012031948193907738, 0.026215754449367523, -0.029304947704076767, 0.015481258742511272, 0.0008450081222690642, -0.01165582425892353, -0.05412193015217781, -0.015842484310269356, -0.02065965346992016, 0.04679124057292938, 0.062393561005592346, 0.03814443573355675, 0.01983342505991459, -0.0023852293379604816, 0.01871534436941147, -0.023596715182065964, 0.014427848160266876, 0.011713322252035141, 0.043497342616319656, -0.0386955589056015, -0.021410811692476273, 0.027838049456477165, 0.04801088571548462, 0.0716668963432312, 0.040663037449121475, 0.04857609421014786, 0.03844240680336952, -0.03902299702167511, -0.018753673881292343, 0.019671017304062843, -0.033273469656705856, -0.049305349588394165, 0.008004351519048214, 0.014831086620688438, -0.02372199483215809, 0.0707993283867836, -0.01600874774158001, -0.008602595888078213, 0.008069492876529694, 0.05062883347272873, -0.01880699023604393, -0.06108556687831879, 0.01166905090212822, 0.056178390979766846, -0.022647224366664886, -0.006321791559457779, -0.04819111153483391, -0.047008682042360306, -0.05389328673481941, -0.03320813924074173, 0.0066819884814321995, 0.02281840145587921, 0.012390881776809692, -0.05396195128560066, 0.06605923175811768, 0.034909069538116455, -0.06219931319355965, 0.01621866412460804, -0.004511813633143902, -0.06627411395311356, -0.015145272016525269, 0.023243429139256477, 0.07828815281391144, -0.016468960791826248, 0.022559938952326775, 0.02554856613278389, -0.020430151373147964, -0.030223343521356583, 0.026430215686559677, 0.09091421216726303, -0.025570528581738472, 0.013618639670312405, 0.001752439304254949, -0.05122281238436699, 0.0008973192307166755, -0.05462568998336792, -0.02705267444252968, 0.01476721465587616, 0.02453947812318802, -0.030039723962545395, -0.005885032936930656, -0.04850246012210846, 0.06959893554449081, -0.028286447748541832, -0.01056627556681633, -0.02493465505540371, -0.04048864543437958, 0.060599785298109055, -0.054302752017974854, -0.04859314486384392, -0.03119686059653759, -0.014748135581612587, -0.0249689482152462, -0.042895980179309845, -0.029556864872574806, -0.04834042489528656, 0.0037642435636371374, -0.007749511860311031, -0.07714802026748657, -0.021146411076188087, -0.011046444065868855, -0.05499589443206787, -0.012363175861537457, -0.05358263477683067, -0.010989314876496792, -0.005369681864976883, -0.003355977823957801, -0.008051752112805843, 0.07387907058000565, -0.026913311332464218, -0.04199958220124245, 0.013713497668504715, 0.017104389145970345, 0.004636617377400398, 0.010740846395492554, 0.009261319413781166, 0.02910100854933262, 0.020774170756340027, -0.025399137288331985, 0.008538932539522648, -0.018490955233573914, -0.06980440765619278, 0.034488048404455185, 0.0021398004610091448, -0.04965633898973465, -0.052804600447416306, -0.03430137783288956, -0.034078069031238556, -0.00977842416614294, 0.051367469131946564, -0.05723291635513306, -0.029914820566773415, -0.003149479627609253, 0.02964320406317711, 0.010609659366309643, -0.012749787420034409, 0.02407155930995941, 0.03690405562520027, 0.0030897422693669796, -0.015604037791490555, 0.024139337241649628, -0.0003497425059322268, -0.015073076821863651, -0.07299649715423584, -0.017741920426487923, 0.01910282112658024, -0.020862935110926628, -0.02047191746532917, -0.024233650416135788, -0.0012660871725529432, -0.05124988406896591, 0.015461551956832409, 0.029253294691443443, -0.0118849016726017, 0.0016715885140001774, -0.04621393233537674, 0.0350680872797966, 0.00882141012698412, -0.01484882552176714, -0.03773903101682663, -0.00404712837189436, -0.0004603434063028544, -0.014966157265007496, 0.024663805961608887, -0.008205893449485302, -0.02371346578001976, 0.02905101329088211, -0.09049726277589798, -0.02012777142226696, -0.02608775533735752, 0.035748034715652466, 0.020686620846390724, -0.004636717028915882, -0.003608575090765953, -0.069839246571064, -0.004588003270328045, 0.009463106282055378, -0.005850412417203188, 0.030688809230923653, 0.016536889597773552, 0.02307819202542305, -0.06122665852308273, 0.008037105202674866, 0.03083258494734764, 0.0042654662393033504, -0.010305886156857014, 0.008174801245331764, 0.04081857576966286, -0.007808576337993145, 0.006184274330735207, 0.05086032673716545, 0.013216285035014153, 0.0329761877655983, -0.030315574258565903, -0.005879163276404142, -0.06138137727975845, -0.03901081159710884, 0.03321358934044838, -0.0455034002661705, 0.015058654360473156, -0.010576239787042141, 0.02737398073077202, -0.0011587204644456506, -0.03400962054729462, -0.05415361374616623, 0.04835730418562889, -0.005050403531640768, -0.04099782928824425, 0.044475629925727844, -0.0025730303023010492, -0.007801990024745464, -0.025117840617895126, 0.0144623052328825, -0.04375462979078293, 0.00799670908600092, 0.04790343716740608, -0.062425579875707626, 0.014490790665149689, -0.08090904355049133, 0.008254135958850384, -0.007946775294840336, 0.04162803664803505, -0.03066147305071354, 0.0803455114364624, 0.006370901130139828, -0.04649672284722328, 0.0028872124385088682, -0.052071116864681244, -0.05277343466877937, -0.06391099840402603, -0.08473343402147293, -0.025798778980970383, 0.042367059737443924, -0.027531486004590988, 0.03935154527425766, 0.033559106290340424, 0.06235310062766075, 0.04283928498625755, 0.007627597078680992, 0.0034543450456112623, -0.015950750559568405, -0.05975592881441116, 0.06497563421726227, 0.020705202594399452, 0.00333389756269753, -0.030850764364004135, -0.02584855817258358, -0.0136403264477849, 0.02856029011309147, 0.02858894318342209, 0.023186907172203064, 0.009649076499044895, -0.0436227023601532, 0.003809693967923522, 0.03065516985952854, 0.0034995288588106632, 0.019757507368922234, -0.05927421152591705, 0.00024168190429918468, -0.01862209662795067, -0.007920556701719761 ]
In this paper, we develop a novel efficient and robust nonparametric regression estimator under a framework of feedforward neural network. There are several interesting characteristics for the proposed estimator. First, the loss function is built upon an estimated maximum likelihood function, who integrates the information from observed data, as well as the information from data structure. Consequently, the resulting estimator has desirable optimal properties, such as efficiency. Second, different from the traditional maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), the proposed method avoid the specification of the distribution, hence is flexible to any kind of distribution, such as heavy tails, multimodal or heterogeneous distribution. Third, the proposed loss function relies on probabilities rather than direct observations as in least squares, contributing the robustness in the proposed estimator. Finally, the proposed loss function involves nonparametric regression function only. This enables a direct application of existing packages, simplifying the computation and programming. We establish the large sample property of the proposed estimator in terms of its excess risk and minimax near-optimal rate. The theoretical results demonstrate that the proposed estimator is equivalent to the true MLE in which the density function is known. Our simulation studies show that the proposed estimator outperforms the existing methods in terms of prediction accuracy, efficiency and robustness. Particularly, it is comparable to the true MLE, and even gets better as the sample size increases. This implies that the adaptive and data-driven loss function from the estimated density may offer an additional avenue for capturing valuable information. We further apply the proposed method to four real data examples, resulting in significantly reduced out-of-sample prediction errors compared to existing methods.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12872v1
[ -0.02257346734404564, -0.019379323348402977, 0.04782044515013695, 0.043010178953409195, -0.027455514296889305, 0.021770333871245384, -0.044861260801553726, -0.01180658396333456, 0.03442269563674927, -0.02421429008245468, -0.019814221188426018, -0.047908298671245575, -0.04530626907944679, -0.037778738886117935, -0.026155954226851463, 0.009457143023610115, 0.08073829114437103, 0.06791257858276367, -0.02875649742782116, 0.06827590614557266, -0.030296584591269493, -0.031990744173526764, -0.05397059768438339, 0.06428147852420807, 0.03720035031437874, -0.0018329353770241141, -0.05549946054816246, -0.0067589171230793, -0.030497342348098755, 0.02381408028304577, 0.040363866835832596, -0.02383441850543022, -0.028177199885249138, -0.06715460121631622, -0.01313516404479742, -0.013950953260064125, -0.0299894530326128, 0.010511712171137333, 0.06539103388786316, -0.04329278692603111, 0.04272645711898804, -0.043229348957538605, -0.018902212381362915, -0.04113457724452019, -0.02387160062789917, 0.0035467299167066813, -0.043473511934280396, 0.02721765823662281, -0.06870245933532715, -0.036875270307064056, 0.04271469637751579, -0.03703425079584122, -0.0007221035775728524, 0.053346212953329086, -0.051093921065330505, 0.013469808734953403, -0.013260271400213242, -0.002407086780294776, -0.06305013597011566, 0.0265729408711195, 0.010496172122657299, -0.008576944470405579, -0.01916855201125145, -0.019017226994037628, -0.007499307859688997, 0.052590273320674896, -0.0011993946973234415, -0.06520183384418488, -0.06841856986284256, -0.027476061135530472, 0.05923369154334068, -0.06853919476270676, 0.017658645287156105, 0.013858160004019737, -0.060521215200424194, -0.009458588436245918, -0.003342590294778347, -0.02432444505393505, 0.010086840949952602, 0.00892168190330267, -0.029991207644343376, 0.03478628396987915, 0.03581247478723526, 0.01908658631145954, -0.03147098049521446, -0.03371214121580124, 0.06931672245264053, -0.02821948006749153, 0.030868757516145706, -0.02623068541288376, 0.0021356914658099413, -0.03241285681724548, -0.07576153427362442, 0.019902637228369713, 0.042391132563352585, -0.047845423221588135, 0.05110227316617966, 0.022525770589709282, 0.037821173667907715, -0.030197063460946083, -0.03463173657655716, -0.005659882444888353, -0.010131538845598698, 0.05133373662829399, 0.017359960824251175, -0.03825300559401512, 0.016208328306674957, 0.0015268786810338497, -0.04305176064372063, 0.005993120837956667, -0.034145765006542206, -0.020607611164450645, 0.014615573920309544, -0.04599344730377197, -0.03843895345926285, -0.04509677365422249, 0.04454547166824341, 0.03949568793177605, 0.012741059064865112, 0.029854053631424904, -0.030799485743045807, -0.019324081018567085, -0.00268021528609097, -0.0423375703394413, -0.04814140871167183, -0.0387750081717968, 0.060076046735048294, -0.015151376836001873, -0.010692897252738476, -0.010942005552351475, -0.05208525061607361, 0.010370750911533833, 0.019352640956640244, -0.029000727459788322, 0.049231208860874176, -0.011455824598670006, 0.0010751025984063745, -0.05397150665521622, 0.04116237908601761, 0.00767676904797554, 0.00151636463124305, -0.06794106215238571, 0.02982388809323311, -0.004893098957836628, 0.022142285481095314, 0.05019930750131607, -0.06771690398454666, -0.027774672955274582, 0.019197124987840652, 0.015778815373778343, 0.011019960977137089, 0.003256359603255987, 0.003841313999146223, 0.03686807304620743, 0.030505569651722908, 0.021788857877254486, 0.038409944623708725, -0.011629924178123474, -0.0033453754149377346, 0.026304900646209717, 0.05698785185813904, -0.01558174192905426, -0.014495140872895718, -0.023981304839253426, 0.012847168371081352, 0.0002032811171375215, 0.040945153683423996, 0.007928995415568352, 0.016020266339182854, 0.0193052738904953, -0.04584246873855591, 0.05101865530014038, -0.01902945712208748, -0.031020332127809525, -0.048014212399721146, -0.014497999101877213, 0.03480397164821625, -0.047612909227609634, -0.0332200713455677, 0.006158561911433935, 0.024889055639505386, 0.008293957449495792, -0.05853791534900665, 0.026641009375452995, -0.029010556638240814, 0.007535079028457403, -0.07662998884916306, -0.017433082684874535, 0.020131634548306465, 0.0355139784514904, -0.04190419614315033, -0.03382376953959465, 0.014336043037474155, 0.022974185645580292, -0.023914175108075142, -0.04287935048341751, -0.00010817137081176043, -0.006637982092797756, -0.02849997580051422, 0.020880382508039474, -0.08921749889850616, -0.021950479596853256, -0.06581997126340866, 0.02087920345366001, -0.01759149134159088, -0.03837328031659126, 0.02194894291460514, 0.035497210919857025, -0.013260607607662678, -0.04968835040926933, 0.04752342402935028, 0.06846807897090912, 0.06530391424894333, 0.013730179518461227, 0.022346992045640945, -0.04847955331206322, -0.09790701419115067, 0.05031217634677887, 0.019079085439443588, -0.0055383904837071896, 0.0521349273622036, 0.02333635650575161, 0.022738946601748466, -0.02052396722137928, -0.0012729852460324764, 0.04548211023211479, 0.06902468204498291, -0.009703257121145725, -0.03680959716439247, -0.006506016477942467, -0.02039218135178089, -0.06180023029446602, -0.05286678299307823, -0.08279120177030563, -0.021556979045271873, -0.004667474888265133, -0.010836255736649036, 0.05256223678588867, 0.02047647535800934, -0.04573938623070717, -0.05015888065099716, 0.0002610016381368041, 0.046794451773166656, 0.021797770634293556, -0.04838179424405098, -0.051824845373630524, -0.03080812096595764, 0.03414394333958626, -0.040710706263780594, 0.017103668302297592, -0.037374962121248245, -0.03689942881464958, -0.012290654703974724, -0.02998424507677555, 0.011145757511258125, 0.054194990545511246, -0.019764266908168793, 0.0029268988873809576, 0.004221087787300348, 0.041386742144823074, 0.026652462780475616, 0.0553303062915802, -0.05419343337416649, 0.013133709318935871, 0.016684457659721375, -0.02299148216843605, -0.003960176836699247, -0.019927119836211205, 0.038941893726587296, -0.05680815503001213, 0.02073638141155243, 0.001983421854674816, 0.05681353434920311, -0.004006662871688604, -0.012966513633728027, -0.03572027385234833, -0.025323038920760155, -0.05100426450371742, 0.036242805421352386, 0.031151236966252327, 0.04269552603363991, 0.017358535900712013, 0.009373393841087818, -0.0657496303319931, -0.029041223227977753, -0.03910411521792412, -0.014916867949068546, -0.0726427510380745, -0.05555699020624161, -0.007621133700013161, -0.07452929019927979, -0.019571717828512192, -0.026798103004693985, -0.046017684042453766, -0.02150248922407627, -0.06665661185979843, -0.03544892743229866, -0.006710297428071499, 0.009068178944289684, -0.007765736430883408, -0.05459865182638168, -0.022380394861102104, 0.02143685519695282, 0.03220411390066147, -0.014883186668157578, -0.0650276243686676, -0.06002248078584671, 0.012940393760800362, 0.06536465883255005, -0.013869400136172771, -0.025174276903271675, 0.0022143349051475525, -0.020690467208623886, 0.0033052770886570215, -0.019901076331734657, 0.03522418066859245, 0.02206553891301155, -0.010848568752408028, -0.0036525579635053873, -0.011489324271678925, 0.016458503901958466, -0.016973724588751793, -0.0037246886640787125, -0.050133585929870605, -0.046569325029850006, -0.04137636348605156, 0.05834202468395233, -0.005071567837148905, -0.05724334716796875, -0.035083819180727005, -0.012162761762738228, 0.018581489101052284, 0.021918468177318573, -0.009769394993782043, 0.045928411185741425, 0.04920646548271179, -0.027589792385697365, -0.002552282065153122, -0.019536398351192474, 0.028409482911229134, -0.023476658388972282, 0.03733149170875549, -0.052872344851493835, 0.02147901989519596, 0.05775672197341919, -0.08346075564622879, 0.005196660757064819, 0.04889138787984848, 0.0737062469124794, -0.034041281789541245, 0.025600528344511986, 0.01734658144414425, 0.030720116570591927, 0.026907023042440414, 0.007457376457750797, 0.01533067598938942, 0.029932281002402306, 0.04319773241877556, -0.02674655243754387, -0.052226174622774124, 0.01979009434580803, -0.06971405446529388, -0.012776913121342659, 0.01979197934269905, 0.02385368011891842, 0.007218280807137489, 0.040850844234228134, -0.017404723912477493, 0.04077710583806038, 0.015652449801564217, 0.03079397790133953, -0.00863292720168829, -0.04562506079673767, 0.055896300822496414, -0.04012826085090637, 0.00565402302891016, 0.014036917127668858, 0.003976739011704922, -0.0012030303478240967, -0.07049170881509781, 0.030732037499547005, -0.06324739009141922, 0.02912602387368679, 0.022761456668376923, -0.0227783415466547, 0.04741182550787926, 0.05063324794173241, -0.0317835658788681, 0.06029723584651947, 0.008620033971965313, -0.024887826293706894, 0.010224728845059872, 0.038487426936626434, 0.029914595186710358, -0.008554196916520596, -0.05309285596013069, -0.025372538715600967, 0.018946561962366104, 0.005621823947876692, -0.03206251561641693, 0.002547220792621374, -0.037006866186857224, -0.00611446937546134, -0.08393067121505737, 0.03940144553780556, -0.03484078124165535, 0.031187282875180244, -0.007382725831121206, -0.02717624604701996, 0.044667650014162064, -0.049961112439632416, 0.025014715269207954, -0.0407172329723835, -0.01714381016790867, -0.0453559085726738, -0.04504113271832466, -0.04046667739748955, -0.07093501091003418, 0.04052009806036949, -0.06349214166402817, 0.03990751504898071, -0.0010222482960671186, 0.0215553380548954, -0.04341059550642967, -0.019964080303907394, 0.021372521296143532, 0.043297458440065384, 0.052675761282444, 0.05408627912402153, 0.022847484797239304, -0.03030136413872242, -0.020639490336179733, -0.047692280262708664, 0.0070703052915632725, -0.012960243038833141, -0.004395096562802792, 0.02534981071949005, -0.054114148020744324, -0.025972215458750725, -0.052063193172216415, -0.004382672719657421, 0.06820296496152878, -0.032413315027952194, -0.014569917693734169, -0.0026380789931863546, 0.03125684708356857, -0.0857052132487297, -0.06238760054111481, -0.008639581501483917, -0.0377320721745491, -0.046258896589279175, -0.018527232110500336, 0.03464551270008087, 0.03479853644967079, -0.023275893181562424, 0.026423653587698936, 0.03467375040054321, 0.028962643817067146, 0.004839319735765457, 0.034009434282779694, 0.016806770116090775, 0.000804265437182039, -0.02398906834423542, -0.0490771159529686, -0.06723413616418839, -0.03102724812924862, -0.015787070617079735, 0.006563994102180004, -0.011037472635507584, 0.055514197796583176, 0.020541438832879066, 0.034868258982896805, -0.08906251192092896, -0.004187965765595436, 0.014738780446350574, -0.015522991307079792, 0.035182129591703415, 0.04763383790850639, -0.021289581432938576, 0.040349435061216354, -0.03830850496888161, -0.0019602349493652582, 0.033229146152734756, -0.04641435667872429, 0.0005792949232272804, -0.007695785257965326, 0.01045171171426773, -0.02256729081273079, 0.07803832739591599, -0.039688583463430405, -0.05428043752908707, 0.007186243310570717, 0.05173850432038307, 0.002062898827716708, -0.02849476784467697, 0.03543141484260559, 0.04286327585577965, 0.00256667984649539, -0.021421434357762337, -0.03439880162477493, 0.004005868453532457, -0.014176564291119576, 0.040015872567892075, -0.04649589583277702, -0.0277103241533041, 0.05084648355841637, -0.025934893637895584, 0.0323050431907177, 0.03871613368391991, -0.03294286131858826, -0.012952362187206745, -0.009880774654448032, 0.05121886357665062, -0.06433623284101486, -0.008823146112263203, -0.02944781817495823, 0.01797201856970787, 0.040077418088912964, 0.03764212131500244, 0.015585953369736671, 0.03981637582182884, -0.013250570744276047, -0.021248765289783478, 0.004836553707718849, -0.010876674205064774, 0.035499170422554016, -0.03168051317334175, 0.01472326461225748, 0.015051967464387417, 0.044760752469301224, 0.029287930577993393, -0.0037999001797288656, 0.024082250893115997, -0.024704812094569206, -0.02118227817118168, -0.011211720295250416, 0.03579327464103699, -0.006486707832664251, -0.0427938736975193, 0.02476920373737812, 0.050884898751974106, -0.016584021970629692, 0.0547216422855854, 0.03832707554101944, -0.010920906439423561, 0.02954927459359169, -0.010811328887939453, -0.006116572301834822, -0.06067754328250885, 0.01316079031676054, 0.08432789891958237, -0.032887328416109085, -0.018720852211117744, -0.05570206791162491, -0.034544337540864944, -0.036646679043769836, -0.05909120291471481, 0.01274168211966753, 0.03447289764881134, 0.018002847209572792, -0.03681577369570732, 0.026418305933475494, -0.023651063442230225, -0.07866528630256653, 0.0146245202049613, 0.028130168095231056, -0.0754537284374237, 0.03487912937998772, 0.02640487067401409, -0.0469551719725132, -0.042545244097709656, 0.03056016005575657, -0.03176556155085564, -0.03263641893863678, -0.04493359848856926, 0.06173329055309296, 0.08994286507368088, -0.0012847869656980038, 0.027391590178012848, 0.0038219268899410963, -0.035279128700494766, 0.01249598991125822, -0.021711191162467003, -0.014309977181255817, -0.019870977848768234, 0.026980001479387283, -0.019069723784923553, -0.024990947917103767, -0.01613881252706051, 0.06451017409563065, -0.016407761722803116, 0.0009255860932171345, -0.005466700531542301, -0.003728617215529084, 0.0357535146176815, -0.03570820391178131, -0.027754807844758034, -0.009749352931976318, 0.006067067850381136, -0.020248156040906906, -0.04128453880548477, 0.025727534666657448, 0.033172667026519775, 0.01194982323795557, -0.027536656707525253, -0.07315080612897873, 0.021756915375590324, -0.02853568084537983, -0.03846513107419014, 0.0058946190401911736, -0.040087707340717316, 0.0441732294857502, -0.011609287932515144, 0.057094756513834, 0.0033878316171467304, 0.06803136318922043, -0.04367354139685631, -0.006676200311630964, -0.036634474992752075, 0.00048531152424402535, 0.016737347468733788, 0.0012949228985235095, -0.012437555007636547, -0.03132038190960884, 0.04483088478446007, -0.04446490854024887, 0.006467868573963642, -0.021915286779403687, -0.058927539736032486, 0.03754548728466034, 0.0034960105549544096, -0.04058975726366043, -0.04660758003592491, 0.00630796467885375, -0.049079518765211105, 0.027800003066658974, 0.013333713635802269, -0.03208304941654205, -0.06705042719841003, 0.002307272283360362, -0.007840693928301334, -0.02532963454723358, 0.03584670275449753, 0.04089096933603287, 0.02379675954580307, -0.005662079900503159, 0.028624089434742928, 0.04547198861837387, -0.007482990622520447, 0.01971391588449478, -0.06462965160608292, -0.003411670681089163, 0.0548994280397892, -0.027661828324198723, -0.03630976006388664, -0.04666195809841156, -0.03383110836148262, -0.05493113026022911, 0.007488486357033253, 0.06231609359383583, 0.01997537352144718, -0.013753590174019337, -0.04939033091068268, 0.027768930420279503, 0.01593872718513012, -0.04119662567973137, -0.060369234532117844, -0.013492546044290066, 0.0017282709013670683, -0.008285177871584892, 0.007866064086556435, -0.002968702232465148, -0.07385078817605972, 0.007772346027195454, -0.09416375309228897, -0.007612898480147123, -0.016919076442718506, 0.04147028923034668, -0.010977029800415039, -0.01820429414510727, -0.05026985704898834, -0.03372597321867943, 0.008243790827691555, -0.015415406785905361, 0.038059718906879425, 0.030102478340268135, 0.021516652777791023, -0.0075910864397883415, -0.03983718529343605, 0.011943305842578411, 0.05841883271932602, -0.033891115337610245, -0.016925550997257233, 0.012398092076182365, -0.0010274586966261268, 0.03544529154896736, 0.0320889912545681, 0.038580555468797684, -0.0038393321447074413, 0.02425643987953663, 0.011151617392897606, 0.007050157990306616, -0.037454769015312195, -0.04505069553852081, 0.05194676294922829, -0.0554569810628891, -0.014671938493847847, 0.014553583227097988, 0.02273750863969326, -0.015217909589409828, -0.043362464755773544, -0.045735519379377365, 0.04318325221538544, 0.01708194427192211, 0.000026893192625720985, 0.02753829024732113, -0.02708488143980503, 0.009561740793287754, -0.026961887255311012, -0.029904816299676895, -0.0215102918446064, 0.03517349064350128, 0.038744375109672546, -0.060463130474090576, 0.0049438439309597015, -0.038336124271154404, -0.01649441570043564, -0.0044339494779706, 0.025037534534931183, -0.04300442710518837, 0.08111771941184998, -0.03868711367249489, -0.012782116420567036, 0.007774419616907835, -0.029327379539608955, -0.005700183100998402, -0.07213211804628372, -0.06005246192216873, -0.05658045411109924, 0.031718235462903976, -0.035812292248010635, 0.03216806426644325, 0.013653363101184368, 0.05625680088996887, 0.05446214973926544, 0.0014647092903032899, 0.013652407564222813, 0.012177403084933758, -0.038279470056295395, 0.0832221582531929, -0.002038144739344716, 0.011485900729894638, -0.01762159913778305, 0.0322919562458992, -0.03106134757399559, -0.014999428763985634, 0.00014455345808528364, -0.013907022774219513, 0.002906128531321883, -0.06773710250854492, -0.02248036116361618, 0.002588847419247031, 0.02051265351474285, -0.0065800705924630165, 0.004503301344811916, 0.025466682389378548, -0.01514041144400835, -0.032039426267147064 ]
While several previous studies have devised methods for segmentation of polyps, most of these methods are not rigorously assessed on multi-center datasets. Variability due to appearance of polyps from one center to another, difference in endoscopic instrument grades, and acquisition quality result in methods with good performance on in-distribution test data, and poor performance on out-of-distribution or underrepresented samples. Unfair models have serious implications and pose a critical challenge to clinical applications. We adapt an implicit bias mitigation method which leverages Bayesian predictive uncertainties during training to encourage the model to focus on underrepresented sample regions. We demonstrate the potential of this approach to improve generalisability without sacrificing state-of-the-art performance on a challenging multi-center polyp segmentation dataset (PolypGen) with different centers and image modalities.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06807v2
[ -0.03759915009140968, 0.028923220932483673, 0.017605740576982498, 0.0017461171373724937, -0.038906753063201904, 0.004435279872268438, 0.011563255451619625, -0.006080241408199072, 0.011208606883883476, 0.0014980343403294683, -0.05692977458238602, -0.04292185604572296, -0.03227401152253151, -0.04898367077112198, -0.03111385367810726, -0.018255792558193207, 0.049839455634355545, 0.02105998806655407, -0.0463382713496685, 0.06918645650148392, -0.0383378230035305, -0.0398155152797699, 0.012889090925455093, 0.011033520102500916, 0.046484898775815964, 0.012359919026494026, -0.026941001415252686, 0.0009062105091288686, -0.021491507068276405, -0.013682126998901367, 0.04148929566144943, -0.0018686947878450155, -0.048662811517715454, -0.04251815378665924, -0.022556178271770477, -0.00839501153677702, -0.00787969771772623, 0.04054560139775276, 0.05350932851433754, -0.023292861878871918, 0.06041858717799187, -0.06104988604784012, -0.07067827135324478, -0.005789017304778099, -0.023078111931681633, 0.01855272240936756, -0.030637303367257118, -0.013452530838549137, -0.05580252408981323, -0.03210136666893959, 0.031357329338788986, -0.02720332145690918, 0.006604504771530628, 0.03501274064183235, -0.07946255803108215, 0.021137144416570663, -0.022341836243867874, 0.03225850686430931, -0.07745487242937088, -0.004109708592295647, 0.05477631092071533, 0.03043787181377411, 0.012428808026015759, 0.0067915660329163074, 0.0022006325889378786, 0.041299041360616684, -0.03612648695707321, -0.08126096427440643, -0.014357446692883968, -0.04988376423716545, 0.03527257964015007, -0.04703718051314354, -0.01385586243122816, 0.05570388212800026, -0.052743054926395416, -0.049563758075237274, -0.004585907328873873, -0.029691023752093315, 0.02170143462717533, 0.04148867353796959, -0.04292498156428337, 0.029281770810484886, -0.018510909751057625, -0.019761057570576668, 0.0062044477090239525, 0.01155449915677309, 0.04638507589697838, 0.00031278355163522065, 0.01773819513618946, -0.03200511261820793, -0.012003411538898945, -0.028765805065631866, -0.04001558944582939, 0.028852544724941254, 0.0814543142914772, -0.03355703875422478, 0.0772063285112381, 0.05660127475857735, 0.057001713663339615, 0.003369697602465749, 0.04294911399483681, -0.018402596935629845, -0.035063736140728, 0.03740816190838814, -0.016978811472654343, -0.024902714416384697, -0.04051667079329491, -0.026611998677253723, -0.04349327087402344, -0.02906038612127304, -0.019965635612607002, -0.024363242089748383, -0.03489769622683525, -0.0725582018494606, -0.040801092982292175, -0.04067745432257652, 0.04624966159462929, 0.00610753707587719, 0.0011323787039145827, -0.022619787603616714, 0.0005099621484987438, 0.014765681698918343, -0.006869336124509573, 0.0019169648876413703, -0.04622531309723854, -0.0046982006169855595, 0.04677949473261833, -0.00047292077215388417, -0.05117087811231613, -0.00531789381057024, -0.05886300653219223, 0.0073329247534275055, 0.009510045871138573, 0.01840365305542946, 0.05004062503576279, 0.02784022130072117, -0.015537954866886139, -0.0096913892775774, 0.04440636187791824, 0.020979393273591995, 0.007218664046376944, -0.08725201338529587, -0.03021232783794403, -0.014624806120991707, -0.004587358795106411, 0.04211878776550293, -0.07582207024097443, 0.0037248374428600073, 0.008962985128164291, 0.05982647091150284, 0.0206246729940176, 0.004686425440013409, 0.009190401062369347, 0.01719171740114689, 0.009837573394179344, -0.01959305815398693, 0.03227708488702774, 0.0033693904988467693, -0.04782828688621521, 0.006945139728486538, -0.0017799633787944913, -0.030107220634818077, 0.0046556256711483, -0.01939014531672001, 0.02445262297987938, 0.008053519763052464, 0.023906825110316277, 0.008820915594696999, 0.015706349164247513, -0.00446712551638484, -0.05814698338508606, 0.003867729101330042, -0.0021496370900422335, -0.023596711456775665, -0.03200794383883476, 0.03414945676922798, 0.025163279846310616, -0.017165234312415123, -0.07349274307489395, 0.023209627717733383, 0.0424291230738163, 0.036102790385484695, -0.04525453597307205, 0.020164335146546364, -0.003872862784191966, -0.004958454519510269, -0.08952021598815918, -0.0033753947354853153, 0.017418593168258667, -0.01992104947566986, -0.04672098532319069, 0.012607291340827942, 0.022887254133820534, 0.030397964641451836, -0.039104804396629333, -0.05518080294132233, 0.03483442962169647, -0.017703430727124214, 0.018211355432868004, 0.029707064852118492, -0.09079202264547348, -0.029341278597712517, -0.06963416188955307, 0.006957820151001215, -0.01915467530488968, -0.04079154506325722, -0.02732277475297451, 0.0418454073369503, -0.04079367220401764, 0.010312031954526901, 0.030327962711453438, 0.07233969867229462, 0.05190219357609749, 0.028572918847203255, -0.01705304905772209, 0.03494144231081009, -0.0956084206700325, 0.042123883962631226, -0.0019991928711533546, -0.0038987903390079737, -0.004670698661357164, 0.012338005006313324, -0.01650872267782688, -0.03603173419833183, -0.018107343465089798, 0.057993583381175995, 0.04305701330304146, -0.012400707229971886, -0.037624675780534744, -0.037623144686222076, -0.017902720719575882, -0.02537272498011589, -0.00762921804562211, -0.06434771418571472, -0.02702605538070202, -0.0012520308373495936, -0.02354707010090351, 0.056454136967659, 0.01505616120994091, -0.039438165724277496, -0.05501290038228035, 0.018595123663544655, 0.06112578138709068, -0.015052313916385174, -0.004427600186318159, -0.027986478060483932, 0.008905556052923203, -0.0014270333340391517, 0.029583383351564407, -0.0035682523157447577, -0.035333603620529175, -0.03783191740512848, 0.024501405656337738, -0.04056748375296593, 0.059038180857896805, 0.04073525592684746, -0.009674455970525742, -0.013695322908461094, -0.033088088035583496, 0.02180643007159233, 0.07890010625123978, 0.022116368636488914, -0.06435655057430267, 0.029881371185183525, 0.03447151556611061, 0.03926975280046463, 0.0013486780226230621, -0.00032775962608866394, 0.03546733781695366, -0.0545649416744709, 0.0056135826744139194, 0.025268474593758583, 0.05060369893908501, 0.03726496174931526, 0.05774328485131264, -0.038583263754844666, -0.01572485826909542, 0.00022222843836061656, 0.03919699415564537, 0.02796201966702938, 0.06193993613123894, -0.01024546381086111, -0.015844710171222687, -0.06286964565515518, -0.020702367648482323, -0.06709939986467361, 0.013119642622768879, -0.0767335519194603, -0.07636900246143341, -0.03890753909945488, -0.08289121091365814, -0.03229697421193123, -0.009755128063261509, -0.03514426201581955, -0.008035770617425442, -0.05314210057258606, -0.050157081335783005, 0.004351814277470112, 0.05062423273921013, 0.0136114452034235, -0.04369625076651573, -0.06704489141702652, 0.013959766365587711, 0.035083889961242676, -0.004206455312669277, -0.043236542493104935, -0.03016491048038006, -0.005721156019717455, 0.032659951597452164, -0.03167238458991051, 0.00853851530700922, 0.037551749497652054, -0.043346136808395386, 0.011342322453856468, -0.01674000732600689, 0.018404383212327957, -0.010018538683652878, 0.033313315361738205, -0.011484971269965172, 0.010613203048706055, 0.02174985595047474, 0.00028369302162900567, -0.020274892449378967, -0.03815658390522003, -0.049660682678222656, 0.0160392913967371, 0.040865082293748856, 0.011747602373361588, -0.043931715190410614, -0.03802156820893288, 0.007809920236468315, 0.03215445578098297, 0.014835711568593979, -0.053046174347400665, 0.03217240795493126, 0.043025217950344086, -0.06824622303247452, -0.026988212019205093, 0.0035979878157377243, -0.0049238186329603195, 0.007078932132571936, 0.00971435010433197, -0.07416785508394241, 0.0447840616106987, 0.05084645003080368, -0.0895073339343071, 0.008327738381922245, 0.028332805261015892, 0.05988205596804619, -0.007824317552149296, -0.049421072006225586, -0.004738199058920145, -0.02291146107017994, -0.03725631162524223, 0.012994339689612389, 0.0100368307903409, 0.02052490785717964, 0.027952678501605988, -0.04812842980027199, -0.05587635934352875, -0.0008706606458872557, -0.05879611894488335, -0.060445111244916916, 0.03701213747262955, 0.041864827275276184, -0.03156740963459015, -0.026747871190309525, -0.07687491923570633, 0.01467643678188324, -0.03596797585487366, 0.04283691942691803, -0.015793783590197563, -0.02518629841506481, 0.0365586057305336, -0.013617326505482197, 0.01991615816950798, 0.017454177141189575, -0.051144979894161224, 0.014502369798719883, -0.02982521802186966, 0.0518486425280571, -0.04002956673502922, 0.06712193787097931, -0.014206473715603352, 0.025355059653520584, 0.027720756828784943, 0.06416881829500198, 0.001391502213664353, 0.013318771496415138, 0.03232221677899361, 0.024379488080739975, -0.010486203245818615, 0.027286017313599586, -0.02740919403731823, -0.020182179287075996, -0.03927601873874664, -0.010458082892000675, 0.027270380407571793, -0.021606216207146645, -0.002597356680780649, -0.03677092120051384, -0.002219893503934145, -0.01431068405508995, -0.0810738205909729, 0.03726756572723389, -0.008560634218156338, 0.03043563850224018, 0.004503502510488033, -0.004256127867847681, 0.052064042538404465, -0.0260760560631752, 0.02866724319756031, -0.03169822320342064, 0.0032196480315178633, -0.011274430900812149, -0.006155253387987614, -0.028285687789320946, -0.08046343922615051, 0.03782329335808754, -0.029894741252064705, 0.06323237717151642, 0.012992511503398418, -0.015574089251458645, -0.05760590359568596, -0.031046412885189056, -0.01722741685807705, 0.014497054740786552, 0.06809712201356888, -0.0267188660800457, -0.012768705375492573, -0.0037120492197573185, 0.020183494314551353, 0.013859117403626442, -0.017264939844608307, 0.029035544022917747, -0.03664126992225647, 0.018346263095736504, -0.014607195742428303, -0.028696421533823013, -0.04163574054837227, 0.009136783890426159, 0.05501856654882431, -0.045116160064935684, -0.02097628079354763, -0.030964436009526253, 0.028745032846927643, -0.031880587339401245, -0.0749613344669342, -0.04418439790606499, -0.004690831061452627, -0.05085693299770355, -0.05324211344122887, 0.025710316374897957, 0.03780032694339752, -0.0159402284771204, -0.020401237532496452, -0.015916720032691956, -0.002342037158086896, -0.022052621468901634, 0.029730090871453285, 0.029125818982720375, 0.0220041386783123, 0.0008364616660401225, -0.07293509691953659, -0.06733960658311844, -0.01674949750304222, -0.05026356130838394, 0.025065623223781586, -0.0014905703719705343, 0.008399609476327896, 0.009602099657058716, 0.021431488916277885, -0.08895706385374069, 0.041563063859939575, 0.04248621314764023, -0.030198130756616592, 0.01036805473268032, 0.07622724771499634, 0.01851772516965866, 0.003068320220336318, -0.038633931428194046, -0.008042840287089348, 0.018215961754322052, -0.06320217996835709, 0.0037752536591142416, -0.018731126561760902, -0.028230860829353333, -0.03455888107419014, 0.04731019213795662, 0.014895823784172535, -0.034812718629837036, 0.004057521931827068, 0.05420072004199028, -0.012822804041206837, -0.007368436548858881, 0.030127430334687233, -0.014486926607787609, -0.058753665536642075, -0.07003689557313919, -0.025085100904107094, -0.023135293275117874, -0.02266003005206585, 0.02558949962258339, -0.034379005432128906, -0.009455867111682892, 0.0367373488843441, 0.010306721553206444, 0.008403719402849674, 0.033432189375162125, -0.04054703563451767, 0.0012691287556663156, -0.02554815448820591, -0.023756075650453568, -0.04340524971485138, -0.012951897457242012, -0.02398962713778019, 0.044220346957445145, 0.016549337655305862, 0.01305651105940342, -0.031844694167375565, 0.017401989549398422, -0.059605441987514496, -0.01447706576436758, 0.01570320688188076, 0.02885502018034458, 0.029104353860020638, 0.03439433500170708, 0.02955980785191059, 0.03467393293976784, 0.028016243129968643, 0.009979693219065666, -0.0028398639988154173, -0.03015878237783909, -0.0014905219431966543, -0.011261693201959133, 0.003845215542241931, 0.02362155169248581, 0.006499714218080044, -0.05464846268296242, 0.05955599248409271, 0.023667728528380394, -0.030670257285237312, 0.07450169324874878, 0.005286818835884333, -0.011544529348611832, 0.01818590611219406, 0.004843076691031456, 0.023835016414523125, -0.016916627064347267, 0.055477678775787354, 0.017682306468486786, -0.07006297260522842, -0.007321696262806654, -0.05298599228262901, -0.03429530933499336, 0.022826064378023148, -0.04796767607331276, 0.01767856441438198, 0.056940048933029175, -0.005062074866145849, -0.030577367171645164, 0.022508176043629646, 0.01477985642850399, -0.07078123092651367, -0.006099673453718424, 0.007745391223579645, -0.08608273416757584, -0.03891463205218315, -0.012402468360960484, -0.020980725064873695, 0.0023589073680341244, 0.019490690901875496, -0.0012593604624271393, -0.030336933210492134, -0.047827571630477905, 0.02335473708808422, 0.07796633988618851, 0.00756206177175045, 0.0022059897892177105, -0.03841802105307579, -0.026009660214185715, -0.012456008233129978, -0.028075581416487694, -0.035062048584222794, 0.018508227542042732, -0.0020325002260506153, -0.03533279150724411, -0.0017434849869459867, -0.055332086980342865, 0.055580273270606995, -0.036585770547389984, -0.031110845506191254, -0.0020392241422086954, 0.03304396569728851, 0.0691496729850769, -0.03431301191449165, -0.027062587440013885, 0.0040201302617788315, 0.02726091258227825, 0.005295000039041042, -0.06517163664102554, 0.016387835144996643, -0.005150635726749897, 0.019765933975577354, -0.025590935721993446, -0.0682661235332489, -0.004548714496195316, -0.03751160949468613, -0.03494730219244957, 0.00979344081133604, -0.06810735166072845, 0.004338821396231651, -0.02693498134613037, 0.021708965301513672, 0.020068978890776634, 0.058706898242235184, -0.02996586449444294, 0.02356221154332161, 0.04617992416024208, 0.02272535301744938, -0.022350477054715157, 0.01975829526782036, 0.013843274675309658, -0.03925405070185661, 0.007089102175086737, -0.02633291855454445, 0.043896161019802094, -0.02417643554508686, -0.021115107461810112, 0.04778454080224037, -0.02855832315981388, -0.07348249852657318, -0.06052917614579201, 0.05413200333714485, -0.021862685680389404, -0.006760681979358196, -0.006631398573517799, -0.04165836423635483, -0.0692933052778244, -0.0007877669995650649, 0.002363653387874365, -0.029268013313412666, 0.03351132199168205, 0.037268053740262985, 0.03925108537077904, -0.03518054261803627, 0.032904624938964844, 0.03238467872142792, 0.024276822805404663, 0.052324652671813965, -0.04188106954097748, -0.015516706742346287, 0.04403235763311386, 0.023267269134521484, -0.0634048730134964, -0.020807739347219467, -0.04311060532927513, -0.07096773386001587, 0.010399612598121166, 0.029226552695035934, -0.0269478689879179, 0.012818342074751854, -0.06431668996810913, 0.028450649231672287, 0.043390657752752304, -0.02753201499581337, -0.05191710963845253, -0.04000641405582428, 0.03847559541463852, -0.021071182563900948, 0.00435726810246706, -0.020617105066776276, -0.01601335220038891, -0.015931380912661552, -0.07528859376907349, 0.010000161826610565, 0.004359005484730005, 0.06339128315448761, -0.006938675884157419, -0.006868337746709585, -0.013010906055569649, -0.02877238765358925, 0.009164039045572281, -0.006399936508387327, -0.030433861538767815, 0.004361985716968775, 0.0442521907389164, -0.013245425187051296, -0.0753648579120636, -0.02877729944884777, 0.0047459532506763935, -0.03348618745803833, -0.02224419079720974, -0.012758849188685417, 0.030734766274690628, 0.00831877812743187, 0.02149309031665325, 0.05287584289908409, 0.014947732910513878, 0.03820484131574631, -0.035986438393592834, 0.004017744679003954, -0.0754559189081192, -0.07272731512784958, 0.05257318913936615, -0.018104001879692078, -0.011964678764343262, -0.013995890505611897, 0.01830371655523777, -0.01701744832098484, -0.04714669659733772, -0.04355138912796974, 0.04983513429760933, 0.0005996636464260519, -0.031102068722248077, 0.03514187037944794, -0.02235080674290657, -0.008792498148977757, -0.06100974604487419, 0.04803362488746643, -0.02981724590063095, -0.002640428952872753, 0.004149368032813072, -0.05960272252559662, -0.0036063974257558584, -0.06975717097520828, -0.046072665601968765, 0.007098195608705282, -0.02810686267912388, -0.02729789912700653, 0.06489590555429459, -0.03352660685777664, -0.04456035792827606, 0.0256781168282032, -0.056643370538949966, -0.028824349865317345, -0.0682927817106247, -0.06184476241469383, -0.045732710510492325, 0.03535112738609314, -0.029178794473409653, 0.030411923304200172, -0.0222560316324234, 0.0747990533709526, -0.023747481405735016, 0.02088354341685772, -0.026904169470071793, 0.010609939694404602, -0.02838907390832901, 0.06882598251104355, -0.004859887063503265, 0.010525419376790524, -0.01065883506089449, 0.023984946310520172, 0.026582879945635796, -0.045227792114019394, 0.00977125484496355, -0.003015101421624422, -0.030215350911021233, -0.05369953066110611, 0.02627977728843689, 0.04336598142981529, 0.04054810851812363, -0.001154901459813118, -0.013307151384651661, -0.014819161966443062, -0.03791060298681259, -0.03984004259109497 ]
This paper discusses the application of artificial intelligence (AI) technology in optical communication networks and 5G. It primarily introduces representative applications of AI technology and potential risks of AI technology failure caused by the openness of optical communication networks, and proposes some coping strategies, mainly including modeling AI systems through modularization and miniaturization, combining with traditional classical network modeling and planning methods, and improving the effectiveness and interpretability of AI technology. At the same time, it proposes response strategies based on network protection for the possible failure and attack of AI technology.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13396v1
[ -0.03621178865432739, -0.049211710691452026, 0.05729744955897331, -0.00997367687523365, 0.05745198577642441, 0.0014878513757139444, -0.035158466547727585, -0.03952806070446968, -0.043054234236478806, -0.04683270305395126, -0.03261171281337738, -0.028831591829657555, -0.0432598814368248, -0.005823420826345682, -0.020313149318099022, -0.01703961007297039, 0.05963722616434097, 0.053024210035800934, -0.019345248118042946, 0.07882966846227646, 0.019191456958651543, -0.028459105640649796, -0.0019147024722769856, -0.020368900150060654, -0.0012673708843067288, 0.024659689515829086, -0.017897089943289757, -0.03926508128643036, -0.0373879037797451, -0.012680452316999435, 0.005925249308347702, -0.041058044880628586, -0.04986175522208214, 0.00048117616097442806, -0.008260711096227169, -0.01373997237533331, -0.03868813067674637, 0.02526538446545601, 0.01744792051613331, -0.05006854236125946, 0.0020813224837183952, -0.009552838280797005, -0.038704946637153625, -0.024266241118311882, -0.019029399380087852, 0.015905676409602165, -0.060873664915561676, 0.021437162533402443, -0.04838462173938751, -0.013498258776962757, 0.0025975299067795277, 0.016944337636232376, -0.016951140016317368, 0.05899730324745178, -0.05482837185263634, 0.012962165288627148, -0.0007392994011752307, 0.020732056349515915, -0.017870865762233734, 0.0375458225607872, 0.008878091350197792, -0.009987050667405128, 0.007192885037511587, -0.03437405824661255, -0.059128280729055405, 0.047243233770132065, -0.0037928905803710222, -0.03504740446805954, -0.007415377534925938, 0.02185126021504402, 0.059826724231243134, -0.05355317145586014, -0.00005660062743118033, -0.0157520342618227, -0.003998962230980396, -0.05112408474087715, 0.011470983736217022, -0.04832566902041435, 0.04614017531275749, -0.02080645225942135, -0.004791060462594032, 0.07075944542884827, 0.04038148373365402, 0.023527147248387337, -0.022628966718912125, 0.04042154923081398, 0.01650935970246792, -0.027349121868610382, -0.034108880907297134, -0.02428177185356617, 0.03676310181617737, -0.023901456966996193, -0.06882065534591675, 0.0512852668762207, 0.054377954453229904, 0.023981204256415367, 0.04446869716048241, -0.0019977018237113953, -0.040151309221982956, -0.002626585541293025, -0.02566797100007534, -0.02435160242021084, -0.025680983439087868, 0.0633922666311264, -0.01901182346045971, -0.041388604789972305, 0.03957262262701988, -0.04983332008123398, -0.007546114735305309, -0.014844737015664577, -0.029794782400131226, -0.04793950542807579, 0.03538167476654053, -0.07533904910087585, -0.028876513242721558, -0.06837211549282074, 0.0186967384070158, -0.007992484606802464, 0.024445151910185814, -0.025509662926197052, -0.010309937410056591, 0.041969768702983856, -0.002188378246501088, -0.022239534184336662, -0.05998821184039116, 0.009846634231507778, 0.06827456504106522, -0.03922192379832268, -0.016896478831768036, -0.0696709156036377, 0.009799842722713947, 0.04344969242811203, -0.02379499562084675, -0.025019099935889244, 0.0309311430901289, -0.06400735676288605, -0.007558540906757116, -0.0038821983616799116, 0.05623055621981621, -0.045237936079502106, -0.05062497779726982, -0.010920223779976368, -0.03203935921192169, -0.0603349432349205, 0.042670976370573044, 0.07045605033636093, 0.004801659379154444, -0.07016770541667938, -0.022976085543632507, 0.026707638055086136, 0.028957964852452278, -0.0287445317953825, 0.007746661547571421, -0.0322340726852417, 0.03597687929868698, -0.025060519576072693, 0.07113149762153625, -0.03388085588812828, -0.03513849526643753, 0.008441299200057983, 0.03052131086587906, -0.0231169443577528, 0.011528129689395428, -0.0059975627809762955, -0.052334222942590714, -0.022512923926115036, 0.02904166281223297, 0.0010174422059208155, -0.038374047726392746, -0.01947573944926262, -0.04427162930369377, -0.0019523496739566326, 0.008356748148798943, -0.033479489386081696, -0.024491170421242714, -0.03990349918603897, 0.0332292839884758, -0.05947290360927582, -0.0014298654859885573, -0.025567078962922096, 0.021704306825995445, 0.06305527687072754, -0.030097223818302155, -0.005795074626803398, -0.03613389655947685, -0.004932090640068054, -0.07225187122821808, 0.004374770913273096, -0.0016918801702558994, -0.03962545469403267, -0.04226687178015709, -0.06959857791662216, 0.0009387215250171721, 0.00956131424754858, 0.0034132327418774366, -0.05797013267874718, -0.028042512014508247, -0.005166537594050169, -0.015247124247252941, 0.04571942612528801, -0.07129544019699097, 0.03642790764570236, -0.05687106400728226, 0.018634814769029617, 0.0318601168692112, -0.06047293543815613, 0.006773278582841158, 0.009416142478585243, 0.00377757684327662, -0.00568861048668623, -0.020288489758968353, 0.036081742495298386, 0.06594680994749069, 0.010509195737540722, -0.020650364458560944, 0.011754303239285946, -0.0847456082701683, 0.0045046694576740265, -0.01499976310878992, -0.01394863985478878, 0.06713416427373886, -0.01595325581729412, 0.05229809507727623, -0.023085759952664375, 0.058313142508268356, 0.0015068169450387359, 0.014443769119679928, -0.03670565411448479, -0.029000945389270782, -0.01775212399661541, -0.05732256919145584, -0.04445159062743187, -0.03556078299880028, -0.04147009178996086, 0.0026584637816995382, 0.005408484023064375, -0.03250979259610176, 0.03908848017454147, 0.009907670319080353, -0.04592925310134888, 0.015192926861345768, -0.0634695515036583, 0.035532575100660324, 0.03296016901731491, -0.038591206073760986, -0.020677469670772552, -0.031123867258429527, -0.04241820424795151, 0.038133323192596436, 0.04497635364532471, -0.023084057494997978, -0.007485813461244106, 0.007695913780480623, 0.0017831139266490936, -0.00026191925280727446, 0.02219413034617901, -0.04261445254087448, -0.03513043373823166, -0.05547600984573364, 0.004988429136574268, 0.06177312508225441, 0.01627388410270214, -0.058568719774484634, 0.027489526197314262, 0.06366729736328125, -0.03827206417918205, -0.03514585271477699, -0.014420553110539913, 0.053529415279626846, -0.05393475666642189, -0.0027509990613907576, -0.0026041411329060793, 0.012653524987399578, -0.04703305661678314, -0.036256078630685806, -0.018007446080446243, 0.01034222450107336, -0.02568882331252098, -0.005236041732132435, 0.008183883503079414, 0.04016512259840965, -0.021226804703474045, 0.04927331209182739, -0.05737186223268509, -0.047566380351781845, -0.004333428107202053, -0.01466809120029211, -0.033965662121772766, -0.012720516882836819, -0.04568491131067276, -0.07395166903734207, -0.04702582210302353, 0.030569031834602356, -0.05714021250605583, 0.004625977948307991, -0.04612536355853081, -0.0473652109503746, -0.03474383056163788, 0.016896571964025497, -0.0006140490295365453, -0.06786586344242096, -0.058947812765836716, -0.0026715409476310015, 0.011149486526846886, -0.0169020127505064, -0.03646627813577652, -0.044626738876104355, 0.008701515384018421, -0.013964196667075157, -0.023708002641797066, 0.0005860776291228831, 0.04326177388429642, -0.052776891738176346, 0.04338257387280464, -0.011548800393939018, -0.006306338589638472, 0.03024100698530674, -0.015973543748259544, -0.04037263244390488, -0.0033897077664732933, -0.022693028673529625, 0.03982510045170784, 0.05920043960213661, -0.07015329599380493, -0.05607801675796509, 0.030575620010495186, 0.04136950150132179, -0.03769514337182045, -0.016168490052223206, -0.029733233153820038, 0.020311439409852028, 0.03244195133447647, 0.05879325792193413, -0.04144670069217682, -0.02243303693830967, 0.012945450842380524, -0.03887943923473358, -0.009624752216041088, -0.005278464872390032, 0.0023289164528250694, -0.026882007718086243, 0.04006055369973183, 0.01810288429260254, -0.059035491198301315, -0.017972255125641823, -0.07345838099718094, -0.022775979712605476, -0.02266664244234562, 0.061281967908144, -0.042497653514146805, -0.008572384715080261, 0.048318322747945786, -0.028018854558467865, 0.009016265161335468, -0.00390437338501215, 0.042472127825021744, 0.03599747270345688, 0.05166826397180557, 0.014612493105232716, -0.05091473460197449, 0.004688664805144072, -0.02942255139350891, -0.050838861614465714, 0.011096634902060032, 0.028443150222301483, 0.00044242796138860285, 0.003212857525795698, -0.03460060805082321, 0.0013841524487361312, -0.016670221462845802, 0.015691202133893967, 0.016053957864642143, -0.03191186115145683, -0.008850368671119213, -0.04984796419739723, 0.03511419519782066, 0.04810154438018799, -0.016587866470217705, -0.013201157562434673, -0.05357114598155022, 0.012960204854607582, -0.06514742970466614, 0.0270086657255888, 0.03317670524120331, -0.0009573111310601234, 0.027329061180353165, -0.0031116455793380737, -0.010344276204705238, 0.0525955893099308, 0.015680920332670212, -0.04810422658920288, -0.030781324952840805, 0.04446740448474884, 0.025947388261556625, -0.033337585628032684, -0.059668898582458496, -0.03559504821896553, 0.025834612548351288, -0.06197752058506012, -0.01876758597791195, 0.004263944458216429, -0.015433398075401783, 0.060303639620542526, -0.053167201578617096, -0.00624545942991972, -0.017601829022169113, 0.008356302045285702, 0.011751540005207062, -0.022088434547185898, 0.06296232342720032, -0.04587816819548607, -0.016011059284210205, -0.03404371067881584, 0.01655333675444126, -0.014614404179155827, -0.006048889365047216, 0.003768603317439556, -0.04222528636455536, -0.021052390336990356, -0.010930721648037434, -0.019972745329141617, 0.03341149911284447, -0.016920050606131554, -0.05272633954882622, -0.011649202555418015, 0.043175678700208664, -0.021647348999977112, 0.05491967871785164, 0.01490237470716238, -0.00448986841365695, -0.03251635655760765, 0.007926354184746742, 0.004968058783560991, -0.017015252262353897, -0.0012241090880706906, -0.03169885650277138, 0.06439080089330673, 0.0358123742043972, -0.020218653604388237, 0.02225101739168167, -0.051610544323921204, 0.057871703058481216, -0.02711142785847187, -0.04500963166356087, 0.02418779395520687, -0.04370163008570671, -0.07001953572034836, -0.053369153290987015, -0.0024504787288606167, -0.05576183274388313, -0.06898375600576401, -0.0597393661737442, 0.01247447356581688, -0.005457636434584856, -0.006070527248084545, 0.020322533324360847, 0.046259913593530655, 0.06088653951883316, -0.004206882324069738, 0.015932491049170494, 0.014864245429635048, -0.03959692642092705, 0.030858604237437248, -0.06404651701450348, 0.0025557393673807383, 0.013600814156234264, 0.010992316529154778, 0.04280998930335045, -0.02289227955043316, 0.0037828765343874693, 0.0038440576754510403, 0.016392741352319717, -0.08076094090938568, 0.026047777384519577, 0.04519209638237953, 0.0061463345773518085, 0.055976033210754395, -0.03598563373088837, 0.012650186195969582, 0.0577971413731575, -0.02047301083803177, -0.007808214519172907, 0.04499078541994095, -0.03973907604813576, 0.041344624012708664, 0.025248052552342415, -0.01387843769043684, 0.025913303717970848, 0.03397981822490692, -0.05597395822405815, -0.030551407486200333, 0.05392448604106903, 0.036644745618104935, -0.008314414881169796, -0.0036320025101304054, -0.02080768346786499, 0.04910001903772354, -0.038549017161130905, -0.02871355228126049, -0.014756657183170319, 0.057619404047727585, 0.015088211745023727, -0.0033035161904990673, -0.010241596028208733, 0.014176677912473679, 0.02747870609164238, -0.009650452062487602, 0.011427138932049274, 0.007928079925477505, -0.005839111283421516, 0.05556885525584221, -0.05832529813051224, 0.03389456123113632, -0.02824006788432598, -0.05585116147994995, 0.012704803608357906, 0.023496227338910103, 0.06670010834932327, 0.014889323152601719, 0.02765076793730259, -0.019403401762247086, -0.013698488473892212, -0.03495145961642265, 0.0054009705781936646, -0.05556092783808708, -0.021850304678082466, -0.026660526171326637, 0.042245931923389435, 0.0308128222823143, 0.04747984558343887, 0.02633465640246868, -0.00862671248614788, -0.04026753082871437, 0.016627740114927292, -0.055416058748960495, -0.028416384011507034, 0.0017999950796365738, -0.02347022294998169, -0.052947770804166794, 0.04702463001012802, 0.050315070897340775, -0.014498184435069561, 0.07017789036035538, 0.03285536170005798, -0.0260438434779644, 0.058584194630384445, -0.013935678638517857, -0.06197630986571312, -0.06851804256439209, 0.03769660368561745, 0.013785271905362606, -0.06198719143867493, 0.02535439282655716, 0.013849499635398388, 0.0015614537987858057, 0.009477982297539711, -0.02383425645530224, -0.048956967890262604, 0.035079725086688995, -0.028888365253806114, -0.0655614584684372, 0.0055929855443537235, -0.020771993324160576, -0.06716551631689072, -0.036056000739336014, 0.00009950780076906085, -0.05763276666402817, 0.026214664801955223, 0.04582121968269348, 0.016435295343399048, -0.057963501662015915, 0.020712224766612053, 0.019689202308654785, 0.00032485989504493773, -0.06429138779640198, 0.03894193843007088, 0.03214101493358612, -0.05596836283802986, 0.0026610034983605146, 0.015544581227004528, -0.04742429032921791, -0.01822574809193611, -0.04021969437599182, -0.051267895847558975, 0.004976462107151747, -0.005214928183704615, 0.009846813045442104, -0.03496943786740303, -0.06905268877744675, 0.0376569963991642, -0.03437501937150955, 0.023550676181912422, -0.01358748972415924, -0.06211964413523674, 0.0653323084115982, -0.02364424802362919, 0.0029256409034132957, -0.04849054664373398, -0.06937586516141891, -0.05303678289055824, -0.05794106051325798, -0.04885416477918625, 0.012711339630186558, 0.011428656056523323, 0.014479448087513447, -0.051164206117391586, -0.04250708594918251, -0.006108609959483147, -0.0501570850610733, -0.027119265869259834, -0.047678392380476, 0.008182945661246777, 0.017599405720829964, -0.014899851754307747, 0.007607016712427139, 0.07378961145877838, -0.0017010492738336325, -0.030168142169713974, -0.01507533062249422, -0.0180206336081028, -0.04553605988621712, -0.017113065347075462, -0.01862831972539425, 0.01347775012254715, 0.009691215120255947, 0.0049263909459114075, -0.04818476736545563, -0.027636414393782616, -0.04912272095680237, 0.01918831281363964, -0.016131114214658737, -0.009984862059354782, -0.03970557451248169, 0.021827131509780884, 0.02623184770345688, 0.01667672209441662, 0.01805587112903595, -0.016417451202869415, -0.02972252108156681, 0.041612353175878525, -0.012650216929614544, 0.052655816078186035, 0.05925513431429863, 0.03068765439093113, 0.01307005062699318, 0.00256501161493361, 0.054032932966947556, -0.021258242428302765, 0.03152076154947281, 0.00286585814319551, -0.06090052053332329, -0.02040236070752144, 0.055383749306201935, -0.048789773136377335, -0.055033598095178604, -0.029260795563459396, -0.050221092998981476, -0.0756126195192337, -0.0020777748432010412, 0.026222754269838333, -0.02662421017885208, -0.03256208449602127, -0.022098302841186523, -0.010283827781677246, 0.016140254214406013, -0.04756695404648781, -0.02916613407433033, 0.007930412888526917, 0.0020582883153110743, -0.01933065615594387, 0.01828080601990223, -0.008711675181984901, -0.056005317717790604, -0.008139423094689846, -0.06545636057853699, -0.05487528815865517, 0.002589733572676778, 0.02065633423626423, -0.02449795976281166, -0.01329883374273777, 0.03358383849263191, -0.05947818234562874, -0.022949865087866783, -0.010408627800643444, -0.04606792330741882, 0.0013276550453156233, -0.03766341879963875, 0.020884618163108826, 0.0008662300533615053, 0.03567047044634819, 0.008005892857909203, -0.024318598210811615, -0.01176642905920744, -0.003682426642626524, 0.007315901108086109, 0.06909269094467163, 0.008626032620668411, 0.040084533393383026, -0.054222285747528076, -0.017248351126909256, -0.0033771672751754522, 0.016789333894848824, -0.05137858912348747, -0.07242179661989212, 0.051779188215732574, -0.05516992136836052, -0.029162898659706116, -0.002386860316619277, -0.01582058146595955, -0.002757470589131117, 0.024436231702566147, -0.05585218593478203, 0.03024941496551037, -0.0025664072018116713, -0.03639945387840271, 0.029203549027442932, 0.03446167707443237, -0.040545787662267685, -0.05430901423096657, 0.005863253027200699, -0.02288319356739521, 0.02008049003779888, 0.06637238711118698, -0.050290461629629135, 0.014799118041992188, -0.01271517388522625, 0.013449481688439846, 0.026916785165667534, -0.01792607456445694, -0.004876633640378714, 0.0737019032239914, 0.04186783730983734, -0.03327523171901703, -0.03464581072330475, -0.006875296588987112, -0.005818920210003853, -0.07043097168207169, -0.022335147485136986, -0.06283208727836609, -0.009862984530627728, -0.005546766333281994, -0.015563451685011387, -0.035879358649253845, 0.0660560354590416, 0.023599272593855858, 0.010065262205898762, 0.047696687281131744, -0.008413032628595829, 0.01324436068534851, 0.08111459761857986, 0.061317287385463715, 0.038554877042770386, -0.04144425690174103, 0.009439499117434025, -0.07135801017284393, 0.004351724870502949, 0.04746544361114502, -0.016076715663075447, -0.03827868029475212, -0.019939275458455086, -0.03320680558681488, 0.03536973148584366, -0.019466804340481758, -0.018750041723251343, -0.04569960758090019, 0.03195725381374359, -0.04913735017180443, -0.0543864481151104 ]
We study of the properties of a new class of circumgalactic medium absorbers identified in the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest: "Strong, Blended Lyman-$\alpha$" (or SBLA) absorption systems. We study SBLAs at $2.4<z<3.1$ in SDSS-IV/eBOSS spectra by their strong extended Lyman-$\alpha$ absorption complexes covering 138 $\,\,{\rm km}\,{\rm s}^{-1}$ with an integrated $\log (N_{HI}/$cm$^{-2}) =16.04\substack{+0.05 \\ -0.06}$ and Doppler parameter $b=18.1 \substack{+0.7 \\ -0.4}\,\,{\rm km}\,{\rm s}^{-1}$. Clustering with the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest provides a large-scale structure bias of $b = 2.34\pm0.06$ and halo mass estimate of $M_h \approx 10^{12}{\rm h^{-1}M_{sol}}$ for our SBLA sample. We measure the ensemble mean column densities of 22 metal features in the SBLA composite spectrum and find that no single-population multiphase model for them is viable. We therefore explore the underlying SBLA population by forward modelling the SBLA absorption distribution. Based on covariance measurements and favoured populations we find that $\approx 25$\% of our SBLAs have stronger metals. Using silicon only we find that our strong metal SBLAs trace gas with a $\log(n_H / $cm$^{-3}) > -2.40$ for $T=10^{3.5}$K and show gas clumping on $<210$ parsec scales. We fit multiphase models to this strong sub-population and find a low ionization phase with $n_H=1$cm$^{-3}$, $T=10^{3.5}$K and $[X/H]=0.8$, an intermediate ionization phase with $\log(n_H / $cm$^{-3}) = -3.05$, $T=10^{3.5}$K and $[X/H]=-0.8$, and a poorly constrained higher ionization phase. We find that the low ionization phase favours cold, dense super-solar metallicity gas with a clumping scale of just 0.009 parsecs.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06813v2
[ -0.06901347637176514, 0.017148328945040703, 0.049793075770139694, 0.010944727808237076, 0.02188110537827015, -0.028519755229353905, -0.02753966674208641, -0.030579641461372375, -0.05192558839917183, -0.033481158316135406, 0.008601304143667221, -0.009034092538058758, -0.03129301592707634, -0.032482318580150604, -0.06817828118801117, 0.03381256386637688, -0.06038357689976692, 0.019611986353993416, 0.009776061400771141, 0.05754665657877922, 0.012787561863660812, -0.023355495184659958, -0.03903106600046158, 0.024989506229758263, 0.044199489057064056, -0.04233203083276749, -0.030863195657730103, 0.013843654654920101, -0.014355872757732868, -0.06416763365268707, 0.042339179664850235, 0.0031909530516713858, 0.0004566523421090096, -0.03905428573489189, -0.0055498043075203896, 0.01963851787149906, -0.05099340155720711, 0.030656231567263603, -0.03532965108752251, -0.005582000128924847, -0.03654063120484352, -0.019020114094018936, -0.061378609389066696, -0.05022120475769043, -0.02350337989628315, 0.020552342757582664, 0.0005807079141959548, -0.022654131054878235, -0.04306448996067047, -0.05972880497574806, 0.025149105116724968, 0.0030055800452828407, -0.015069016255438328, 0.06870824843645096, 0.02222435548901558, 0.019752182066440582, 0.0073193134739995, -0.0669192299246788, -0.01608223468065262, 0.007222129497677088, 0.027615906670689583, -0.04503558576107025, -0.00786722730845213, -0.011699779890477657, 0.0072203162126243114, 0.046909578144550323, -0.03765850514173508, -0.031199883669614792, -0.011955552734434605, -0.003829908324405551, -0.0011343627702444792, -0.006689511705189943, 0.006706382147967815, -0.007839691825211048, -0.07042186707258224, 0.022608600556850433, 0.014933273196220398, -0.03850310295820236, -0.044112857431173325, 0.0054966164752841, -0.0627196654677391, 0.024615686386823654, 0.053058378398418427, 0.029623445123434067, 0.030436687171459198, -0.008070004172623158, 0.008465209975838661, -0.045224614441394806, 0.018139062449336052, -0.02413773164153099, -0.002200527349486947, -0.02060852199792862, -0.026809953153133392, 0.009870984591543674, 0.07265722006559372, -0.053890906274318695, 0.04022781923413277, -0.011790992692112923, 0.038599178194999695, -0.020256496965885162, -0.024867773056030273, -0.04593934863805771, -0.028790656477212906, 0.057214826345443726, 0.024080688133835793, -0.015102531760931015, -0.008202875033020973, -0.004718665033578873, -0.018160032108426094, 0.04631402716040611, 0.034928128123283386, 0.012391342781484127, 0.012996177189052105, -0.032231323421001434, -0.061446551233530045, -0.037393491715192795, 0.06996972113847733, -0.003087688237428665, -0.026208849623799324, -0.023128842934966087, -0.04184126853942871, 0.03227008879184723, -0.0003387494070921093, -0.004824984818696976, 0.006109023466706276, -0.0031778921838849783, 0.05833614245057106, -0.013330639339983463, 0.03620363399386406, 0.04871445894241333, -0.011542847380042076, -0.03924121707677841, 0.03911086171865463, -0.046310942620038986, 0.030749693512916565, -0.0707978829741478, 0.007459405809640884, 0.004462016746401787, -0.013557681813836098, 0.003494793316349387, -0.06025726720690727, -0.06556592136621475, 0.04254918172955513, 0.023112768307328224, 0.004791789222508669, 0.028784532099962234, -0.06563161313533783, -0.0009957707952708006, -0.024692382663488388, 0.03231634572148323, 0.03343683481216431, 0.048605844378471375, -0.058391205966472626, -0.04198583588004112, 0.025582998991012573, 0.03200632706284523, -0.018392566591501236, -0.048067715018987656, -0.04173529893159866, 0.05557253956794739, 0.011336584575474262, -0.04706573113799095, 0.00622566556558013, -0.006295769475400448, -0.03278971463441849, 0.008943464607000351, -0.02384754829108715, -0.02736569009721279, 0.012458725832402706, 0.0006917408318258822, -0.04357435554265976, 0.009178012609481812, -0.0004988739965483546, -0.04528516158461571, -0.06792376190423965, -0.03279028832912445, -0.041935648769140244, -0.012483264319598675, -0.013524968177080154, -0.02105383761227131, 0.05061256140470505, 0.015285439789295197, -0.021671593189239502, -0.013074809685349464, -0.038272611796855927, 0.0047884369269013405, -0.059556253254413605, -0.02272522822022438, 0.030193310230970383, 0.03772444278001785, -0.045294467359781265, -0.06348855048418045, 0.016195714473724365, 0.021678050979971886, -0.029836589470505714, -0.03126392886042595, 0.03678661212325096, -0.054820526391267776, 0.021652815863490105, 0.011879408732056618, -0.059990160167217255, 0.006446182262152433, -0.04204897582530975, 0.01704128459095955, 0.026213625445961952, -0.06870967894792557, 0.02625717967748642, 0.03249542787671089, 0.00882689468562603, -0.06387127935886383, 0.038854341953992844, -0.001141766901127994, 0.01059479359537363, 0.028839731588959694, -0.06228458881378174, -0.04325978830456734, -0.08559039235115051, 0.06630120426416397, 0.06744251400232315, -0.03916887566447258, 0.029218541458249092, 0.03094489686191082, 0.0073465583845973015, 0.009593510068953037, -0.027301577851176262, -0.01941213198006153, 0.056051164865493774, -0.024265220388770103, -0.051919009536504745, 0.021915914490818977, -0.005752137862145901, -0.06277058273553848, -0.03471073508262634, -0.0673077255487442, -0.04126006364822388, 0.03273799642920494, -0.04310281202197075, 0.04127177968621254, -0.011808043345808983, -0.03398078307509422, -0.034306783229112625, 0.012583288364112377, 0.04933290556073189, -0.02793615125119686, -0.05680370330810547, -0.04613576456904411, -0.0730285495519638, -0.0043184347450733185, -0.06170567870140076, -0.006936685182154179, 0.01548729371279478, 0.005853382404893637, -0.039291560649871826, -0.009673310443758965, 0.037554651498794556, 0.012006519362330437, -0.012974104844033718, 0.026799123734235764, -0.034544944763183594, 0.060190729796886444, 0.0029447469860315323, 0.04717644676566124, -0.02605404704809189, 0.008490664884448051, -0.03210819140076637, 0.066891610622406, -0.04031640291213989, -0.06520281732082367, -0.04014310985803604, 0.0241829976439476, 0.015876101329922676, 0.019999464973807335, 0.047361403703689575, 0.02461955137550831, -0.007828372530639172, 0.033297646790742874, -0.03127232566475868, 0.0019297132967039943, -0.04110950231552124, 0.026116428896784782, 0.01157611794769764, 0.04119442030787468, -0.02412344701588154, -0.02636720798909664, -0.025175482034683228, -0.006398595403879881, -0.06962181627750397, -0.054878219962120056, -0.07090810686349869, 0.010450645349919796, -0.05537581443786621, 0.0026113814674317837, -0.005890611559152603, -0.020059866830706596, -0.0520252026617527, -0.04738059639930725, -0.008060768246650696, -0.05540597066283226, -0.0020668061915785074, -0.0758911594748497, -0.02715841308236122, 0.04835927113890648, -0.01633421704173088, 0.04019327089190483, -0.05003167316317558, -0.05341657996177673, -0.06313467025756836, 0.01736760139465332, 0.013968156650662422, -0.03493683412671089, -0.062240228056907654, 0.03423357754945755, -0.03277375176548958, 0.016634168103337288, 0.04159807041287422, 0.06548189371824265, 0.01769009232521057, -0.034805409610271454, -0.009821361862123013, 0.015912767499685287, 0.0053846645168960094, -0.0339907668530941, 0.028695283457636833, -0.020982328802347183, -0.024349553510546684, -0.007588033098727465, 0.03809046000242233, 0.04021476209163666, 0.001386638730764389, -0.0335717499256134, -0.05152083933353424, -0.02381277084350586, -0.025552621111273766, 0.007416157983243465, 0.051226358860731125, 0.028746867552399635, 0.02395019307732582, 0.01341100875288248, -0.03312882035970688, 0.0009713912731967866, -0.05264044925570488, -0.008939314633607864, 0.0008792972657829523, -0.03844499588012695, 0.001245495630428195, -0.07341498881578445, 0.06896339356899261, 0.05665803328156471, 0.03347444161772728, -0.0021738309878855944, -0.023399917408823967, 0.03475698456168175, -0.009828650392591953, 0.03434326872229576, -0.05840977281332016, 0.01704413816332817, 0.034629084169864655, 0.011767236515879631, 0.010697084479033947, 0.00062507763504982, 0.019856546074151993, -0.043194856494665146, -0.04177534580230713, 0.033627066761255264, -0.031959645450115204, 0.049608729779720306, 0.026254922151565552, -0.025528723374009132, 0.04609262943267822, 0.02038494125008583, 0.019236484542489052, -0.03374869003891945, -0.05549050122499466, -0.0063218409195542336, 0.027502961456775665, -0.0101223299279809, -0.04199783504009247, -0.06406092643737793, -0.024265525862574577, -0.05373334139585495, -0.04546530917286873, -0.04735025018453598, -0.03215142711997032, -0.014461868442595005, 0.02024618722498417, 0.007334501016885042, 0.017282932996749878, -0.014512688852846622, 0.0010145261185243726, -0.05100727826356888, -0.02210824191570282, -0.047050006687641144, -0.0020219427533447742, -0.017548946663737297, -0.06043897569179535, -0.0005157280247658491, -0.010905702598392963, -0.017764592543244362, -0.031441956758499146, -0.06256631016731262, 0.054141815751791, 0.003850631881505251, -0.031231921166181564, -0.07639443129301071, -0.05731528252363205, -0.02092231810092926, -0.051423609256744385, 0.00898823793977499, -0.018217477947473526, 0.05292889475822449, -0.034116871654987335, -0.05192520096898079, -0.00704751443117857, -0.012952379882335663, -0.005068193189799786, -0.04236331582069397, 0.008554517291486263, -0.03415888920426369, 0.02150583826005459, -0.07997133582830429, 0.031384870409965515, -0.056305140256881714, -0.06323600560426712, -0.04661714658141136, 0.048286326229572296, 0.005253191571682692, 0.020371990278363228, -0.006942826323211193, 0.007934769615530968, 0.05642826482653618, 0.04671928286552429, 0.026287222281098366, 0.02911985106766224, 0.011139955371618271, 0.05063838139176369, -0.03755005821585655, 0.03889495134353638, -0.06526705622673035, -0.058004725724458694, -0.0011388651328161359, -0.0037781221326440573, 0.010064933449029922, -0.013682516291737556, 0.02890702150762081, 0.0060463519766926765, 0.03575020655989647, -0.0284818597137928, -0.015911800786852837, -0.019506225362420082, -0.022494865581393242, -0.04248286411166191, -0.0025812708772718906, 0.038384951651096344, 0.0008794647292234004, -0.05271067097783089, 0.02323397807776928, 0.03685392439365387, 0.012347111478447914, -0.03264804184436798, 0.0155068039894104, -0.01059757824987173, 0.00985847506672144, 0.005589688662439585, -0.021070560440421104, -0.06964927911758423, 0.01929064840078354, -0.025940876454114914, -0.06636527925729752, -0.015108281746506691, 0.04202992469072342, -0.027516737580299377, 0.028329674154520035, -0.0818224623799324, 0.01396801508963108, 0.05219649150967598, 0.023474963381886482, -0.0335160531103611, 0.0053673116490244865, 0.039782267063856125, 0.0034372881054878235, -0.050113871693611145, -0.0024751240853220224, -0.003476083977147937, 0.03794232755899429, -0.00019302277360111475, 0.0031302091665565968, -0.016645491123199463, -0.001969949807971716, 0.015880441293120384, 0.035142723470926285, 0.021172715350985527, 0.018627401441335678, 0.017743591219186783, 0.01807287521660328, -0.04792483150959015, 0.062379442155361176, 0.05193066596984863, -0.061761464923620224, -0.061240240931510925, -0.004941084887832403, -0.024932025000452995, -0.01356636080890894, 0.04662320017814636, -0.05389818176627159, -0.03804215043783188, 0.039419542998075485, -0.053088683634996414, 0.02535102888941765, 0.05256988853216171, 0.03626306727528572, -0.027318505570292473, 0.010139361023902893, -0.05339810624718666, -0.07367172092199326, -0.029413817450404167, -0.047338224947452545, -0.02088930457830429, -0.017486197873950005, 0.02061072364449501, -0.01228516735136509, 0.04340113326907158, 0.04375527799129486, -0.016695501282811165, 0.01941048726439476, -0.03183994069695473, 0.030012257397174835, 0.02089677006006241, -0.04521709308028221, 0.006786471698433161, 0.007517539896070957, 0.009647492319345474, -0.03832995146512985, -0.023351645097136497, 0.005701275076717138, -0.044160209596157074, 0.012514458037912846, 0.04211651161313057, -0.007221042178571224, -0.005689728073775768, -0.0263382438570261, 0.02501070126891136, -0.048538729548454285, 0.05644642561674118, -0.023853851482272148, 0.020231416448950768, 0.02847369760274887, 0.04958481714129448, 0.020430369302630424, -0.06875578314065933, -0.02661132626235485, 0.04951855167746544, -0.02360936440527439, 0.036924365907907486, -0.053012583404779434, -0.04884803295135498, 0.017707787454128265, -0.04434904456138611, -0.012745741754770279, 0.01060505397617817, -0.01425305288285017, -0.049056317657232285, 0.07107425481081009, -0.01893499307334423, -0.021660974249243736, 0.027359597384929657, -0.022642003372311592, -0.079434834420681, -0.019342700019478798, 0.005456522107124329, -0.05345774069428444, -0.009655595757067204, 0.012037116102874279, -0.05233176052570343, 0.00033538020215928555, 0.0492248572409153, 0.044601552188396454, -0.00021406484302133322, -0.023156356066465378, 0.04983339086174965, -0.015395992435514927, 0.02976970188319683, 0.00404718890786171, -0.05219491943717003, -0.05335323140025139, -0.039536356925964355, 0.042992979288101196, 0.014140629209578037, -0.023205455392599106, 0.026563020423054695, -0.03761143982410431, 0.03455782309174538, 0.013643087819218636, 0.0420052595436573, -0.04860134795308113, 0.039784375578165054, -0.021820276975631714, -0.014102578163146973, -0.013144906610250473, -0.057436924427747726, -0.04500725492835045, -0.020046435296535492, 0.03571479395031929, -0.011702753603458405, -0.004532420542091131, 0.04617278277873993, 0.019403578713536263, 0.006596119608730078, -0.03150061145424843, -0.03968442231416702, -0.0009385746670886874, -0.04167395085096359, 0.00862883497029543, -0.039948470890522, 0.039091192185878754, 0.0023201899603009224, -0.009132906794548035, -0.043490346521139145, -0.02794097550213337, -0.046398330479860306, -0.01144952792674303, 0.03584767132997513, -0.011667497456073761, 0.03669782355427742, -0.057991959154605865, 0.02218252792954445, -0.04849701002240181, 0.03305928409099579, -0.0028021535836160183, -0.04158955067396164, -0.01592865400016308, 0.029201244935393333, -0.055966515094041824, -0.051743749529123306, -0.05337144434452057, -0.04124227166175842, 0.021036459133028984, 0.03096834383904934, -0.06389962881803513, -0.027733946219086647, -0.013273480348289013, 0.02467118389904499, -0.04909167438745499, 0.051541026681661606, -0.0008456995710730553, 0.05733151733875275, -0.019501615315675735, -0.03142842277884483, 0.021375758573412895, -0.00647220341488719, 0.027237065136432648, -0.013565507717430592, 0.0009554516291245818, -0.04211316257715225, 0.034841060638427734, -0.0068346052430570126, -0.03288485109806061, -0.03476396203041077, -0.057512298226356506, 0.0029658288694918156, -0.016549350693821907, 0.008883261121809483, -0.0020536116790026426, -0.018512137234210968, 0.025468919426202774, 0.013037710450589657, -0.0031892159022390842, -0.07598025351762772, -0.05025617405772209, -0.011173197068274021, -0.04116125777363777, -0.015950407832860947, -0.05164182558655739, -0.040456488728523254, -0.00016284416778944433, -0.07399420440196991, -0.01964595355093479, -0.051565125584602356, 0.02453789673745632, 0.037561871111392975, 0.026147155091166496, -0.045604392886161804, -0.05550088360905647, -0.03140178695321083, 0.012059110216796398, 0.03352480009198189, -0.012927556410431862, -0.04567888006567955, 0.028076689690351486, -0.03905373066663742, 0.023023158311843872, 0.03793329373002052, -0.05588763207197189, -0.0009238842176273465, 0.02011851593852043, -0.010996297001838684, -0.05611461028456688, -0.0019613078329712152, 0.05822112411260605, 0.023274419829249382, -0.02445133775472641, -0.03249752148985863, -0.04141215607523918, -0.046547140926122665, -0.024533210322260857, 0.0012622663052752614, -0.07111130654811859, 0.037972986698150635, 0.03205857053399086, 0.0043280902318656445, -0.04951111972332001, 0.00625388789921999, -0.0680239275097847, -0.052513789385557175, 0.014907343313097954, 0.01784420572221279, 0.009889966808259487, -0.07121054083108902, 0.01781444624066353, -0.03661871328949928, -0.008226735517382622, -0.03190983086824417, -0.004294192884117365, 0.05034555494785309, -0.05123158171772957, -0.0472802110016346, -0.06882408261299133, 0.05927765369415283, -0.05888679623603821, 0.03167886659502983, 0.008413154631853104, 0.013127941638231277, -0.03805229812860489, -0.027810750529170036, -0.03865167871117592, 0.025320712476968765, 0.04892013221979141, -0.06199507787823677, -0.030913764610886574, -0.03872646018862724, 0.04669797793030739, 0.04649084061384201, 0.013024439103901386, -0.05966145172715187, 0.006522695533931255, -0.007349992636591196, -0.007956827990710735, -0.007753387093544006, 0.02370538003742695, -0.007159540429711342, 0.035357896238565445, 0.0457703061401844, -0.03607669100165367, -0.051306165754795074, 0.002628464950248599, -0.04362190514802933, -0.026860332116484642, -0.0782347023487091, 0.011344852857291698, -0.029987310990691185, -0.036339450627565384, -0.022902479395270348, 0.021655552089214325, 0.008196698501706123, -0.013348937034606934, 0.01356150396168232, 0.012190648354589939, 0.04022606834769249, -0.037962593138217926 ]
Large language models (LLM) such as OpenAI's ChatGPT and GPT-3 offer unique testbeds for exploring the translation challenges of turning literacy into numeracy. Previous publicly-available transformer models from eighteen months prior and 1000 times smaller failed to provide basic arithmetic. The statistical analysis of four complex datasets described here combines arithmetic manipulations that cannot be memorized or encoded by simple rules. The work examines whether next-token prediction succeeds from sentence completion into the realm of actual numerical understanding. For example, the work highlights cases for descriptive statistics on in-memory datasets that the LLM initially loads from memory or generates randomly using python libraries. The resulting exploratory data analysis showcases the model's capabilities to group by or pivot categorical sums, infer feature importance, derive correlations, and predict unseen test cases using linear regression. To extend the model's testable range, the research deletes and appends random rows such that recall alone cannot explain emergent numeracy.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13382v1
[ -0.005199309438467026, -0.03857588395476341, 0.06794807314872742, 0.0038585709407925606, -0.006305092014372349, 0.05183674395084381, -0.011882652528584003, -0.011186981573700905, -0.00661401217803359, -0.004113039467483759, -0.04993892088532448, 0.04022247716784477, -0.0658375471830368, -0.016281282529234886, -0.02176491916179657, -0.03260229155421257, 0.06168042868375778, 0.006316817365586758, -0.04394681006669998, 0.03829653561115265, 0.0244005024433136, 0.03312849998474121, -0.0659438818693161, 0.03557754307985306, 0.036625977605581284, -0.04577131196856499, -0.010393593460321426, -0.0134726632386446, 0.018484780564904213, -0.02289966680109501, 0.054097730666399, -0.029246097430586815, -0.008964736945927143, -0.05312353000044823, -0.016048619523644447, -0.03744180500507355, 0.0037597292102873325, -0.008865144103765488, 0.04864862188696861, -0.055300720036029816, -0.013522682711482048, -0.048855505883693695, -0.06790218502283096, -0.023016899824142456, -0.041251424700021744, 0.01851380243897438, -0.02254720963537693, -0.005626633297652006, -0.03726267069578171, -0.05461038649082184, 0.0038420180790126324, -0.009789817966520786, -0.04505855217576027, 0.023807315155863762, -0.03409626707434654, -0.01958649978041649, 0.0006259180954657495, 0.010657833889126778, -0.07372672855854034, -0.01854752004146576, 0.038494519889354706, -0.018265442922711372, -0.014607327990233898, 0.03524909168481827, 0.014661172404885292, 0.037979383021593094, -0.04089939221739769, -0.043653879314661026, -0.05630302056670189, -0.03629423677921295, 0.06403975933790207, -0.07897770404815674, -0.02269655093550682, 0.020184513181447983, -0.013568631373345852, -0.03473154827952385, -0.0006012012017890811, -0.01699603535234928, -0.029015667736530304, 0.014337660744786263, -0.026572514325380325, 0.0546673946082592, 0.007404373027384281, 0.00271430891007185, 0.007560956757515669, -0.056284140795469284, 0.04448577016592026, -0.009934380650520325, -0.038577765226364136, -0.03720643371343613, 0.0423056036233902, -0.015207238495349884, -0.040976814925670624, 0.005764310248196125, 0.07343708723783493, -0.0030294698663055897, 0.021233314648270607, 0.004364701919257641, -0.03615257516503334, -0.0005598644493147731, -0.02629854716360569, -0.02426152303814888, -0.05772042274475098, 0.07153341174125671, 0.0026826343964785337, -0.010765118524432182, -0.02601700834929943, 0.021935340017080307, -0.0639127716422081, 0.03119988739490509, -0.02248471975326538, -0.0252360999584198, 0.00883389450609684, -0.04921268671751022, -0.024019259959459305, -0.06742091476917267, 0.021673360839486122, 0.017095543444156647, 0.029351677745580673, 0.0004427024978213012, -0.004308199509978294, 0.03527570515871048, 0.0456276535987854, -0.012092585675418377, -0.05730917304754257, -0.03275009244680405, 0.044568609446287155, -0.011930420994758606, -0.04368390887975693, -0.04959848150610924, -0.056249190121889114, -0.014545456506311893, -0.009607939049601555, -0.034902386367321014, 0.05933080241084099, -0.02310730330646038, -0.05754883587360382, -0.0626486986875534, 0.01910329796373844, -0.0060646869242191315, -0.03543926775455475, -0.08805493265390396, 0.014102524146437645, -0.0457313172519207, 0.024055926129221916, 0.023902527987957, -0.04899004101753235, -0.04000144079327583, 0.02598167024552822, -0.017001379281282425, 0.015618206933140755, -0.012096145190298557, -0.012413938529789448, 0.032969944179058075, 0.034261591732501984, 0.030061990022659302, 0.025479882955551147, -0.04436923936009407, -0.054083146154880524, 0.000015229465134325437, 0.04158255457878113, -0.01998119428753853, 0.009681280702352524, 0.008160253055393696, -0.001675463281571865, -0.0312696173787117, 0.05100186914205551, -0.02677389234304428, -0.01719844527542591, -0.010062319226562977, -0.010240119881927967, -0.011844823136925697, 0.02246958762407303, -0.014132115058600903, -0.045101527124643326, -0.03312143683433533, 0.009393936023116112, -0.056829627603292465, -0.050307754427194595, -0.001881023054011166, -0.001169082010164857, 0.04871230944991112, -0.045524097979068756, -0.03693647310137749, -0.04676896706223488, 0.0449381098151207, -0.07907664775848389, 0.00547135341912508, 0.032444726675748825, 0.030804026871919632, -0.039186470210552216, 0.0233970545232296, 0.015834445133805275, 0.01257170457392931, -0.004643335472792387, -0.04861726239323616, 0.025306373834609985, -0.0016437239246442914, -0.0010172585025429726, 0.05744453892111778, -0.08904074132442474, -0.03447088599205017, -0.029779329895973206, -0.004449996165931225, 0.03592122718691826, -0.0499628521502018, 0.022252636030316353, 0.05084384232759476, -0.02065720409154892, 0.009790944866836071, 0.056694526225328445, 0.03965345025062561, 0.040589358657598495, 0.01709727756679058, 0.04352787509560585, -0.0016632785554975271, -0.09257660806179047, 0.06107228621840477, -0.029185788705945015, 0.01659029722213745, 0.010819587856531143, 0.0072180116549134254, 0.00008814657485345379, -0.029605364426970482, 0.006899119354784489, 0.034090567380189896, 0.021243544295430183, 0.0036353697068989277, -0.005129318684339523, -0.05656822398304939, -0.04867187887430191, -0.045431409031152725, -0.0023486705031245947, -0.05695411190390587, -0.01936417818069458, -0.012901504524052143, -0.030943619087338448, 0.06275632977485657, -0.003598857205361128, -0.03410624712705612, -0.03182346001267433, -0.006952639669179916, 0.03794987127184868, -0.04341181367635727, -0.06601200252771378, -0.04090253636240959, -0.025166403502225876, 0.05559989809989929, 0.0269992146641016, -0.0293036587536335, -0.042164456099271774, -0.06509020924568176, -0.015848392620682716, -0.055716969072818756, 0.017476193606853485, 0.03233988210558891, -0.05293913558125496, 0.02729598991572857, 0.006438715383410454, 0.05145794153213501, 0.03052866831421852, 0.002760316012427211, -0.060835909098386765, -0.018053846433758736, 0.03406860679388046, -0.06068437546491623, -0.025775345042347908, -0.004271261859685183, -0.006869425065815449, -0.0027402564883232117, 0.006111620459705591, 0.0646507516503334, 0.039541032165288925, -0.02996351197361946, -0.06473039835691452, -0.02066243626177311, -0.02035997435450554, -0.06014523282647133, 0.02132570557296276, 0.04735578969120979, 0.05824660882353783, 0.02489772066473961, -0.03207552060484886, -0.08116351813077927, -0.008188603445887566, -0.04029681161046028, -0.04790686070919037, -0.040635913610458374, -0.055518005043268204, -0.0011142208240926266, -0.08395340293645859, 0.008565389551222324, -0.012783359736204147, -0.05897803232073784, -0.028784489259123802, -0.04101719334721565, -0.024411460384726524, -0.016617819666862488, -0.003490937640890479, 0.000028643238692893647, -0.024731893092393875, -0.02456175722181797, 0.013600182719528675, -0.02128773368895054, 0.03244206681847572, -0.06932556629180908, -0.07600245624780655, -0.010994235053658485, 0.05628815293312073, -0.019360313192009926, -0.0058367494493722916, 0.0034834318794310093, -0.04990512505173683, 0.011719741858541965, -0.024799110367894173, 0.0624820850789547, 0.008753183297812939, 0.04494863748550415, 0.007138893473893404, -0.013976112008094788, -0.01766693778336048, -0.0016160254599526525, -0.0052086906507611275, -0.0632937029004097, -0.05764203891158104, -0.01589375175535679, 0.008387470617890358, -0.016362249851226807, -0.011114985682070255, -0.03352629765868187, -0.009351210668683052, 0.05192725732922554, 0.022009823471307755, -0.00678463326767087, 0.03296194598078728, 0.05023195967078209, -0.0016918930923566222, -0.04137041047215462, -0.03008689358830452, 0.013830641284584999, 0.037799179553985596, 0.005411700811237097, -0.017418071627616882, -0.011838429607450962, 0.042114999145269394, -0.07876888662576675, 0.015741638839244843, 0.05596721172332764, 0.04719693213701248, -0.035529185086488724, -0.015002754516899586, 0.02147190272808075, 0.025751367211341858, 0.0537773072719574, -0.03320930525660515, 0.006367945112287998, 0.05000551417469978, 0.048755597323179245, -0.029206382110714912, -0.041089966893196106, 0.00879119522869587, -0.06635868549346924, -0.030351359397172928, -0.005606797989457846, -0.0055735548958182335, 0.023552749305963516, 0.0027728979475796223, -0.05000820755958557, 0.01813608407974243, 0.0015678672352805734, 0.04001398757100105, 0.03595295548439026, -0.011474652215838432, 0.03842268884181976, -0.05096403881907463, 0.027468841522932053, 0.004483965691179037, -0.013758900575339794, -0.007594215217977762, -0.023726284503936768, 0.010009395889937878, -0.06105049327015877, 0.05322268232703209, 0.04997269809246063, -0.01571648381650448, 0.07381255179643631, 0.06190662831068039, -0.015255860984325409, 0.04882202297449112, -0.02427041530609131, 0.005971335340291262, -0.007634139619767666, 0.03593697026371956, -0.004415145609527826, -0.021238872781395912, -0.05691517889499664, 0.034418657422065735, 0.05422499403357506, -0.0018095148261636496, -0.0431789793074131, -0.023692084476351738, 0.0017930646426975727, -0.005035886075347662, -0.07817668467760086, 0.004497437737882137, -0.060329366475343704, 0.032650724053382874, -0.05910373479127884, -0.019958864897489548, 0.05246470868587494, -0.045265212655067444, 0.0179302841424942, -0.030469974502921104, -0.021411139518022537, -0.045869648456573486, -0.030393829569220543, -0.030758827924728394, -0.07354849576950073, 0.021617412567138672, -0.05798811465501785, 0.022032467648386955, 0.014343160204589367, -0.01984141767024994, -0.01534829568117857, -0.021915104240179062, 0.01647322066128254, 0.04493739828467369, 0.04332686588168144, 0.0213267020881176, -0.04483671113848686, -0.01725631207227707, 0.005477565806359053, -0.02849251963198185, 0.026050500571727753, -0.026893138885498047, -0.05067199096083641, 0.025289420038461685, -0.01713409088551998, 0.01377809327095747, -0.028172871097922325, 0.000025990739231929183, 0.038227058947086334, -0.05458671599626541, -0.008701246231794357, 0.007759251166135073, 0.07258623093366623, -0.07025037705898285, -0.0802382305264473, 0.009181142784655094, -0.05318697914481163, -0.06884857267141342, 0.005435638595372438, 0.03219609707593918, 0.05021094158291817, -0.011078796349465847, -0.019660135731101036, -0.007895332761108875, 0.04470237344503403, 0.0033567410428076982, -0.0021616017911583185, 0.021858269348740578, -0.03628102317452431, 0.0011446501594036818, -0.0137654272839427, -0.07209958136081696, -0.02814573422074318, -0.03473113104701042, -0.031870149075984955, -0.016050709411501884, 0.030587121844291687, 0.04000682383775711, 0.0701541006565094, -0.07416068762540817, 0.026521440595388412, 0.04202500358223915, 0.031124159693717957, -0.02406621351838112, 0.04465759918093681, 0.02924085035920143, 0.03958505019545555, -0.030015861615538597, 0.022550735622644424, 0.011608036234974861, -0.05066080018877983, 0.0083842184394598, -0.015761492773890495, 0.010883823968470097, -0.03497881442308426, 0.0492919497191906, 0.0015739635564386845, -0.04241873323917389, 0.017433270812034607, 0.015281672589480877, 0.023233653977513313, -0.0487881638109684, 0.051044974476099014, 0.052763525396585464, -0.024755695834755898, -0.02374957501888275, -0.01728486828505993, -0.006612949538975954, 0.020673710852861404, -0.013617816381156445, -0.049730222672224045, -0.002884285058826208, 0.020873427391052246, -0.02573416940867901, -0.028002439066767693, 0.030596641823649406, -0.002823237329721451, 0.017667818814516068, 0.003942534793168306, -0.024971574544906616, -0.06626318395137787, 0.03517741337418556, -0.04863910377025604, 0.015173974446952343, 0.06685876101255417, 0.04095574468374252, -0.01322083082050085, 0.015875663608312607, -0.03237083554267883, 0.004134226590394974, 0.0245930477976799, 0.015748005360364914, 0.029628995805978775, -0.042020343244075775, 0.01132238283753395, 0.014036684297025204, 0.04909210652112961, 0.026733599603176117, 0.04986288398504257, 0.025779850780963898, -0.01830526441335678, -0.011128303594887257, -0.02327428013086319, -0.00892353430390358, -0.04098347947001457, -0.03239012882113457, 0.02546796016395092, 0.03794523701071739, 0.008110543712973595, 0.002843915019184351, 0.0015388857573270798, -0.06364750117063522, 0.0368986614048481, 0.019090309739112854, -0.0227903351187706, -0.019564833492040634, 0.011531504802405834, 0.06934221088886261, -0.02531902864575386, 0.016198530793190002, -0.0013326217886060476, -0.050562649965286255, 0.05916576832532883, -0.037336934357881546, 0.02532239444553852, 0.015590803697705269, 0.04262147098779678, -0.06333420425653458, 0.03513374924659729, 0.02886129729449749, -0.05302798002958298, 0.030419709160923958, 0.02255568653345108, -0.08402317017316818, 0.00453706132248044, 0.006841553375124931, 0.0034779971465468407, -0.051549218595027924, 0.06289247423410416, -0.00727841816842556, -0.030652064830064774, -0.045075323432683945, 0.076686330139637, 0.08094541728496552, -0.002843620488420129, 0.010821356438100338, 0.0009552408009767532, -0.06552073359489441, 0.0388680137693882, -0.02235865592956543, 0.005264721345156431, 0.020804300904273987, 0.0485735684633255, -0.006463588215410709, -0.038553591817617416, 0.015149645507335663, 0.020661285147070885, -0.04377933591604233, 0.022492896765470505, 0.02245537005364895, 0.02408558875322342, 0.013925948180258274, -0.05131859704852104, -0.01674843020737171, 0.006544932257384062, 0.03912637010216713, -0.012928781099617481, -0.0527418814599514, 0.004941985476762056, 0.0016722232103347778, 0.045918937772512436, -0.04644082859158516, -0.06751958280801773, 0.0010011057602241635, -0.017264068126678467, -0.08094847202301025, 0.01762893795967102, -0.056047067046165466, -0.02650383673608303, -0.002494942396879196, 0.024740280583500862, 0.015203547663986683, 0.059067875146865845, -0.05907420814037323, -0.0324714221060276, -0.005679629277437925, 0.016717657446861267, -0.006940941791981459, -0.03705200180411339, 0.02599470503628254, -0.03922312706708908, 0.036200784146785736, -0.022307138890028, -0.0004683348524849862, -0.013758566230535507, -0.05604516342282295, 0.026316078379750252, 0.050101518630981445, -0.008824577555060387, -0.04015745595097542, 0.04202170670032501, -0.014622229151427746, 0.028284648433327675, -0.020597241818904877, -0.02481023408472538, -0.05855255946516991, -0.01822016015648842, 0.007408001460134983, -0.020566901192069054, 0.01575182005763054, 0.030690152198076248, 0.04218677058815956, 0.005030517932027578, 0.021587317809462547, -0.03900086507201195, 0.021116094663739204, 0.006070802453905344, -0.06602198630571365, -0.034315332770347595, 0.04469121992588043, -0.0330469086766243, -0.02170049026608467, -0.004599631763994694, 0.014511439017951488, -0.04334380477666855, -0.023937305435538292, 0.0518837571144104, 0.009085693396627903, -0.020274121314287186, -0.04281822219491005, 0.001684671500697732, 0.012227777391672134, -0.06874851137399673, -0.039438940584659576, 0.005084296688437462, -0.006974802352488041, -0.023944811895489693, -0.0006693709292449057, -0.04993977025151253, -0.05813239887356758, -0.03346923366189003, -0.08716744929552078, 0.0349910706281662, -0.01945986971259117, 0.009458087384700775, 0.00987729150801897, 0.0017076319782063365, -0.014027014374732971, -0.01595745049417019, 0.04778590798377991, -0.012520135380327702, 0.015844307839870453, 0.0008433637558482587, 0.007312658708542585, 0.04154907166957855, -0.02545773983001709, -0.004126221872866154, 0.05381312221288681, -0.03639218956232071, -0.05844693258404732, -0.004944289103150368, 0.03306641802191734, 0.015446546487510204, -0.002061143284663558, 0.06563621014356613, 0.0067250351421535015, 0.030545849353075027, -0.010829750448465347, -0.01141431462019682, -0.05428766831755638, -0.05360540747642517, 0.036827944219112396, -0.022047534584999084, 0.0216860082000494, 0.0238027386367321, -0.02967296540737152, -0.010008138604462147, -0.006926480680704117, -0.03600802645087242, 0.04140800982713699, 0.00961100123822689, -0.020728111267089844, 0.04472595453262329, 0.016519859433174133, -0.018951937556266785, -0.011301584541797638, -0.04804927110671997, -0.051166653633117676, 0.006204596254974604, 0.043922245502471924, -0.04770434647798538, 0.007962985895574093, -0.05248408764600754, 0.058558639138936996, -0.006674803793430328, 0.007218705490231514, -0.017862379550933838, 0.08201629668474197, 0.03361782804131508, -0.04463909938931465, -0.030666930601000786, -0.05205926299095154, -0.04727094992995262, -0.07385463267564774, -0.02121105045080185, -0.021503573283553123, 0.03134876489639282, -0.03964540734887123, 0.030548693612217903, 0.012421941384673119, 0.050873637199401855, 0.020142460241913795, 0.00438601803034544, 0.025294074788689613, 0.008693205192685127, -0.04713136702775955, 0.0805964469909668, 0.006930702831596136, 0.006672704592347145, -0.017230359837412834, 0.026800207793712616, 0.03832782432436943, -0.028771350160241127, 0.025526978075504303, -0.022496236488223076, 0.049563441425561905, -0.037576984614133835, -0.021515879780054092, 0.031029364094138145, -0.012990860268473625, -0.024602292105555534, 0.028480172157287598, -0.027721773833036423, -0.012358509004116058, -0.05616157874464989 ]
Loop quantum gravity, as one branch of quantum gravity, holds the potential to explore the fundamental nature of black holes. Recently, according to the quantum Oppenheimer-Snyder model in loop quantum cosmology, a novel loop quantum corrected black hole in de Sitter spacetime has been discovered. Here, we first investigate the corresponding quasinormal modes and late-time behavior of massless neutral scalar field perturbations based on such a quantum-modified black hole in de Sitter spacetime. The frequency and time domain analysis of the lowest-lying quasinormal modes is derived by Prony method, Matrix method as well as WKB approximation. The influences of loop quantum correction, the black hole mass ratio, and the cosmological constant on the quasinormal frequencies are studied in detail. The late-time behaviors of quantum-modified black holes possess an exponential decay, which is mainly determined not only by the multipole number but also by the cosmological constant. The impact of loop quantum correction on the late-time tail is negligible, but it has a significant impact on damping oscillation. To explore spacetime singularities, we examine the validity of strong cosmic censorship for a near-extremal quantum-modified black hole in de Sitter spacetime. As a result, it is found that the strong cosmic censorship is destroyed as the black hole approaches the near-extremal limit, but the violation becomes weaker as the cosmological constant and the loop quantum correction increase.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04962v2
[ -0.05768812447786331, -0.028010616078972816, 0.00889714527875185, -0.023608604446053505, 0.012935442849993706, 0.015666065737605095, -0.00083209975855425, -0.0043764798901975155, 0.0017724683275446296, 0.013204501010477543, -0.021157190203666687, -0.05177849903702736, -0.052398890256881714, -0.05112893506884575, -0.06168077886104584, 0.002017034450545907, 0.06948553770780563, 0.03240459784865379, -0.07693006843328476, 0.08183754980564117, 0.04259413108229637, -0.02882535569369793, 0.0029610525816679, 0.035179849714040756, -0.005289966706186533, -0.033110640943050385, -0.042776722460985184, 0.02838677167892456, -0.02956010401248932, -0.021261557936668396, 0.04608297720551491, -0.007094093132764101, 0.002345180371776223, -0.030746785923838615, -0.045962315052747726, -0.034652888774871826, -0.02990705706179142, 0.05360094830393791, 0.027287866920232773, -0.04500718042254448, -0.0047713085077703, -0.030979730188846588, -0.03361595422029495, 0.012981838546693325, -0.01728464476764202, -0.07285656780004501, -0.03726824373006821, 0.032071299850940704, -0.05276213958859444, -0.07112585753202438, 0.03269128501415253, 0.020074717700481415, -0.001301783719100058, 0.02921907790005207, -0.06356677412986755, -0.011286528781056404, -0.005089105572551489, 0.0009196975152008235, -0.022522490471601486, 0.006595461163669825, -0.027440790086984634, 0.011874907650053501, 0.030912796035408974, -0.027529234066605568, 0.03232834115624428, 0.038324203342199326, -0.02767990343272686, -0.04449523612856865, -0.0037188001442700624, -0.05967458710074425, 0.03925367444753647, -0.05502063408493996, 0.04952012747526169, -0.008367065340280533, -0.06159980222582817, 0.007640712428838015, -0.031567953526973724, -0.01688290946185589, -0.0084585165604949, 0.03241201490163803, -0.006886587478220463, 0.011472797952592373, 0.013817375525832176, 0.021586783230304718, 0.016237838193774223, 0.009062382392585278, 0.050008345395326614, 0.016331275925040245, 0.009923150762915611, -0.07465745508670807, 0.049640487879514694, -0.022907624021172523, -0.04319983720779419, -0.04449966549873352, 0.062494173645973206, -0.03950532153248787, 0.026781940832734108, 0.07167337834835052, 0.04883905500173569, 0.018136072903871536, 0.0307141225785017, -0.027038030326366425, -0.016061101108789444, 0.048755545169115067, -0.010633451864123344, -0.033070046454668045, 0.019101707264780998, 0.009706392884254456, -0.013465974479913712, 0.04096699506044388, 0.004887267015874386, 0.024522265419363976, 0.0036116281989961863, -0.01912563294172287, -0.05063916742801666, -0.06625059247016907, 0.07627885043621063, 0.03200894594192505, 0.03064911440014839, -0.03487803786993027, -0.06303594261407852, 0.04934071749448776, 0.013465854339301586, -0.0057503595016896725, -0.018480541184544563, 0.01663951948285103, 0.036001406610012054, 0.04069586843252182, -0.021871641278266907, -0.03955717012286186, -0.03411553427577019, 0.013119923882186413, 0.030752714723348618, -0.031763605773448944, 0.04944368079304695, 0.0030175484716892242, -0.017610393464565277, -0.022817576304078102, 0.010631605051457882, -0.004056463949382305, -0.03874824196100235, 0.0005849638837389648, 0.027647310867905617, 0.002595573663711548, 0.02004718966782093, -0.017230970785021782, -0.08271035552024841, -0.011301666498184204, 0.040564343333244324, 0.023187795653939247, 0.018134407699108124, -0.009385413490235806, 0.006865679752081633, 0.005049744620919228, 0.02471110038459301, -0.0010541018564254045, 0.058377593755722046, 0.01628376729786396, -0.02577635645866394, 0.021213585510849953, 0.013231925666332245, 0.009713525883853436, 0.02630987949669361, 0.01937052607536316, 0.01694060117006302, 0.03469167277216911, 0.07149362564086914, 0.016367336735129356, -0.04605167359113693, 0.05650294944643974, -0.06288543343544006, 0.02240973338484764, 0.01757931523025036, -0.013521242886781693, -0.049978479743003845, -0.03888970986008644, -0.03721737861633301, -0.036287788301706314, 0.02033228985965252, 0.009927349165081978, -0.0047867149114608765, 0.0016452526906505227, -0.023709621280431747, 0.03073580004274845, -0.04735272005200386, 0.021059373393654823, -0.0832650437951088, 0.016227466985583305, 0.037134308367967606, 0.016685491427779198, -0.008493762463331223, -0.048335570842027664, 0.023226216435432434, 0.008646756410598755, -0.05138840898871422, -0.033169977366924286, 0.005510188173502684, -0.0002483345742803067, 0.028277095407247543, 0.04939892515540123, -0.05291685834527016, -0.007361714728176594, -0.0070375120267271996, -0.037251491099596024, -0.007305189501494169, -0.08541062474250793, 0.04352633282542229, 0.06726555526256561, -0.0026234209071844816, -0.020726678892970085, 0.044022999703884125, 0.022475512698292732, 0.0558319054543972, -0.006966345943510532, 0.0004164924321230501, 0.02077467180788517, -0.10771112889051437, 0.02044476754963398, 0.012892226688563824, 0.01310731377452612, 0.008416928350925446, -0.008579705841839314, -0.02385813556611538, -0.041220150887966156, -0.03344452381134033, 0.0399957112967968, 0.04653479531407356, 0.0010850554099306464, -0.058710914105176926, -0.023877425119280815, 0.024260148406028748, -0.04834846779704094, -0.050057291984558105, -0.042812809348106384, -0.02213498018682003, 0.0027338832151144743, -0.016277756541967392, 0.04981566220521927, -0.031143056228756905, -0.03715121001005173, -0.06619776040315628, 0.04728763923048973, 0.030650842934846878, -0.05620035156607628, -0.02682986855506897, -0.016331274062395096, -0.020201662555336952, 0.003940650261938572, -0.04404180124402046, -0.037611059844493866, -0.003094865707680583, -0.01956658810377121, -0.022453732788562775, -0.0441608764231205, 0.023261025547981262, 0.028019821271300316, -0.045250218361616135, 0.03624766692519188, 0.024660784751176834, 0.06042024493217468, 0.027986226603388786, 0.05404999107122421, -0.055772073566913605, 0.020435992628335953, 0.02875383384525776, 0.03879017382860184, -0.06170034781098366, 0.004818380810320377, -0.02827705629169941, -0.006365135312080383, 0.01083886343985796, -0.018772464245557785, 0.049528516829013824, -0.01602724939584732, 0.011367972940206528, -0.06025116518139839, -0.036613963544368744, -0.02108706720173359, 0.021611075848340988, 0.027234075590968132, 0.07063234597444534, 0.02497982047498226, 0.015106727369129658, -0.07299207895994186, 0.012381454929709435, -0.03418775275349617, -0.039673008024692535, -0.03967877849936485, -0.02323990687727928, -0.030559947714209557, -0.06442255526781082, 0.015913331881165504, -0.011167941614985466, -0.053193479776382446, -0.03629438579082489, 0.004276822321116924, -0.0021324409171938896, 0.03717269375920296, 0.025930797681212425, -0.06643254309892654, -0.04094991460442543, 0.01660509780049324, 0.009054450318217278, -0.0015491681406274438, -0.012993311509490013, -0.016723593696951866, -0.013425536453723907, 0.03933144360780716, 0.01252092607319355, 0.03403446450829506, -0.04011998325586319, -0.0037345169112086296, -0.041327640414237976, 0.0014950106851756573, 0.03490192070603371, 0.04633910208940506, 0.014270715415477753, -0.051445018500089645, 0.026912936940789223, -0.022341327741742134, -0.0054170540533959866, 0.01315015833824873, 0.008563145995140076, 0.016527028754353523, -0.06698344647884369, -0.0020764062646776438, 0.08656806498765945, 0.059264980256557465, -0.002463012235239148, -0.04154369235038757, -0.019070180132985115, 0.0226898156106472, 0.013270692899823189, -0.02278042398393154, 0.07161178439855576, 0.045338068157434464, -0.06460925936698914, -0.024600135162472725, -0.037557799369096756, 0.016080887988209724, 0.030170416459441185, 0.012897015549242496, -0.008657793514430523, -0.020879557356238365, 0.0048441519029438496, -0.06608091294765472, 0.02644920162856579, 0.038333408534526825, 0.06590783596038818, -0.04606718569993973, -0.0004161526740062982, 0.026917988434433937, 0.042225711047649384, 0.005963264964520931, 0.021064558997750282, 0.03091518022119999, 0.034791555255651474, 0.059895046055316925, -0.00024679882335476577, -0.014145701192319393, -0.015158180147409439, -0.06232694163918495, -0.06701277196407318, 0.013802851550281048, 0.0730164423584938, 0.048996176570653915, 0.05353680998086929, -0.009485883638262749, -0.01647697575390339, -0.05721417814493179, 0.012463514693081379, -0.030666353181004524, -0.04539673402905464, 0.014283784665167332, -0.013833709992468357, -0.004492189735174179, -0.01877649314701557, 0.02241114340722561, 0.003031525993719697, -0.07880677282810211, 0.04057510942220688, -0.07462194561958313, 0.028578059747815132, -0.04187173396348953, 0.009734680876135826, 0.007252479437738657, 0.009285726584494114, 0.0046045612543821335, 0.040348656475543976, 0.0033297890331596136, 0.017687592655420303, -0.04403340071439743, -0.018822653219103813, 0.02621668018400669, 0.004061726853251457, -0.03051947057247162, -0.010732147842645645, 0.006533200386911631, -0.04063695669174194, 0.016962379217147827, 0.007940327748656273, -0.008839105255901814, 0.005380707327276468, -0.08352342993021011, -0.004979623947292566, -0.051848046481609344, 0.015103913843631744, -0.023016955703496933, -0.05053483322262764, 0.06801945716142654, 0.012723696418106556, 0.02812819369137287, -0.022052086889743805, -0.03300125151872635, -0.028307383880019188, -0.02178732119500637, -0.032256219536066055, -0.014219689182937145, 0.036896053701639175, -0.0699802115559578, 0.05234876647591591, -0.011568079702556133, 0.021035533398389816, -0.07692835479974747, 0.014673391357064247, -0.015105405822396278, 0.062155164778232574, 0.0055233086459338665, -0.015263195149600506, 0.014315307140350342, 0.009825053624808788, -0.011223889887332916, 0.04567493125796318, 0.02908279560506344, 0.030572449788451195, -0.051880013197660446, 0.04405520111322403, -0.05196430906653404, -0.0017048731679096818, -0.06273449212312698, -0.022803187370300293, 0.07726278901100159, -0.014641718938946724, -0.06490881741046906, 0.036133356392383575, 0.007659520022571087, -0.03404274582862854, -0.05020451918244362, -0.04994973540306091, 0.009193288162350655, -0.039523739367723465, 0.0005608587525784969, -0.009704513475298882, 0.007976599968969822, -0.030069589614868164, 0.017596006393432617, 0.021922022104263306, 0.06813289225101471, -0.023420240730047226, 0.015738246962428093, 0.03054536134004593, 0.03455018997192383, 0.009435486979782581, -0.01048059668391943, -0.07717283070087433, 0.0283560398966074, 0.039441779255867004, -0.02504999190568924, -0.030223814770579338, 0.05577600747346878, -0.02975171059370041, 0.03218211978673935, -0.07920476794242859, 0.003471642266958952, 0.06895177811384201, -0.03885098174214363, -0.01377427764236927, 0.0012081456370651722, -0.049542251974344254, 0.002761587267741561, -0.016294073313474655, 0.02176503650844097, 0.03988823667168617, -0.005938882473856211, -0.041568830609321594, 0.03410972282290459, -0.05298670008778572, 0.01037802454084158, 0.00019364370382390916, -0.002156053204089403, -0.057488296180963516, -0.018768860027194023, -0.006079926621168852, -0.012264220044016838, -0.04824106767773628, 0.043607670813798904, 0.024278685450553894, 0.010315703228116035, -0.04939328134059906, -0.009301145561039448, -0.01782388426363468, -0.0021681927610188723, 0.048974305391311646, -0.04961402714252472, -0.047158949077129364, -0.014858617447316647, 0.050596024841070175, -0.00247446121647954, 0.024049833416938782, 0.010255591943860054, 0.017258917912840843, 0.009613045491278172, -0.03868142515420914, -0.05862685292959213, -0.0015500230947509408, -0.025269819423556328, 0.029060032218694687, 0.014950554817914963, 0.03674854710698128, 0.052504390478134155, 0.03773341700434685, 0.01784222386777401, -0.05104683339595795, -0.03564731031656265, -0.05221695080399513, 0.07090889662504196, -0.01810542121529579, 0.026988478377461433, 0.004224318079650402, 0.06177954375743866, -0.00989481620490551, -0.03199584409594536, 0.0013731541112065315, -0.02763911709189415, -0.007473043166100979, -0.002995629096403718, 0.013489891774952412, -0.04405631124973297, -0.023369628936052322, -0.023543482646346092, 0.04585763067007065, -0.007971059530973434, 0.05043504014611244, 0.029710663482546806, 0.004814709071069956, 0.041743576526641846, 0.004729151260107756, -0.011099583469331264, -0.06079244241118431, -0.002271907636895776, 0.09044764190912247, -0.050412505865097046, -0.01958460360765457, 0.003372480161488056, -0.0551539771258831, -0.01346385758370161, -0.052244219928979874, -0.006551392376422882, 0.02095559984445572, -0.0008581847650930285, -0.06828327476978302, 0.05322746932506561, 0.0007635093643330038, -0.0640893504023552, -0.013430693186819553, 0.025834083557128906, -0.08721830695867538, 0.020795322954654694, 0.020626746118068695, -0.023131346330046654, -0.035091206431388855, 0.019734501838684082, 0.003901680698618293, -0.05761493742465973, -0.046510592103004456, 0.019022690132260323, 0.059545211493968964, -0.0644291490316391, 0.013592435047030449, 0.03896954283118248, 0.019133076071739197, 0.007581427227705717, -0.04188252240419388, -0.00031499454053118825, -0.01814325712621212, 0.043944042176008224, 0.04580334946513176, -0.005830133333802223, 0.00036090935464017093, 0.026695935055613518, -0.05536551773548126, 0.026966089382767677, -0.022756125777959824, 0.01505065243691206, 0.03034665435552597, -0.01901138573884964, -0.042233582586050034, 0.02452808804810047, -0.0044156587682664394, 0.021260270848870277, -0.03750530257821083, 0.03358583524823189, -0.016759907826781273, 0.06746558099985123, -0.009405451826751232, -0.03630213439464569, 0.02989192120730877, -0.029780736193060875, -0.04488873854279518, 0.025815075263381004, -0.035121288150548935, -0.02774740383028984, 0.01968403160572052, -0.022825531661510468, -0.019001035019755363, 0.00604288699105382, -0.02638743445277214, 0.006104940548539162, -0.045922212302684784, 0.03128757327795029, -0.018529299646615982, 0.020977303385734558, 0.012408407405018806, 0.010889294557273388, 0.04785747453570366, 0.012119833379983902, 0.022887231782078743, -0.003771565156057477, -0.058672212064266205, 0.06423747539520264, 0.0002847182913683355, -0.023885658010840416, -0.00809983815997839, -0.031690776348114014, -0.03128373622894287, -0.02915046736598015, 0.02842053957283497, -0.018549807369709015, -0.07827717810869217, 0.014917495660483837, 0.03731783479452133, -0.007017221767455339, 0.022752726450562477, 0.035467736423015594, 0.00792289525270462, -0.005034915171563625, 0.029584310948848724, 0.05894763767719269, 0.00409860722720623, -0.027927547693252563, -0.03780566155910492, -0.029091086238622665, -0.027826672419905663, 0.019906936213374138, -0.003453643759712577, 0.0020739310421049595, -0.019813958555459976, -0.08276607096195221, 0.022798461839556694, 0.009815157391130924, -0.00043172846199013293, -0.0017643957398831844, -0.031884294003248215, 0.036093730479478836, 0.04468164220452309, -0.015888100489974022, -0.07640062272548676, -0.01228739321231842, -0.01345725916326046, 0.011586248874664307, 0.011849772185087204, -0.027540400624275208, -0.051972221583127975, 0.030423836782574654, -0.07918357849121094, -0.010231890715658665, -0.05466442182660103, 0.02565455436706543, -0.01189575344324112, -0.018682630732655525, -0.01596195437014103, -0.04374733939766884, 0.03106152079999447, 0.029872024431824684, -0.013642997480928898, 0.02135484851896763, 0.03633831813931465, 0.04427995905280113, -0.056629933416843414, -0.03279002010822296, 0.015152492560446262, -0.04520310088992119, 0.009185153990983963, 0.02809293381869793, 0.06551241874694824, -0.04601757973432541, 0.004642331041395664, 0.0069447229616343975, -0.01293479185551405, 0.03951369225978851, -0.05289311334490776, -0.03301747515797615, -0.04004433751106262, -0.05883835628628731, 0.01884625107049942, -0.029392844066023827, 0.009655549190938473, 0.01077739242464304, -0.0409112386405468, -0.0008508191094733775, -0.05758485570549965, -0.02161005698144436, 0.03490947186946869, 0.007185002788901329, -0.027024127542972565, 0.08454176783561707, -0.06851314753293991, -0.0014888450969010592, -0.007118645589798689, -0.020815294235944748, -0.06802687793970108, 0.03762688487768173, 0.03597690910100937, -0.07369502633810043, 0.03750091791152954, -0.07619040459394455, 0.04294385015964508, -0.041553325951099396, -0.016117196530103683, -0.028076570481061935, 0.036139633506536484, -0.02793324738740921, -0.021816641092300415, -0.04229220375418663, -0.05140456184744835, 0.009797895327210426, -0.06944994628429413, -0.040510233491659164, 0.014079014770686626, 0.023086652159690857, 0.029383935034275055, 0.027812708169221878, 0.029371531680226326, 0.08243037760257721, 0.03618626669049263, -0.0006009844364598393, -0.027675697579979897, 0.0035431303549557924, -0.05232587829232216, 0.04426879063248634, -0.0171807911247015, -0.03512164577841759, -0.05018562078475952, 0.019476095214486122, 0.01667890138924122, 0.02457042969763279, 0.016191279515624046, 0.006883863825351, 0.014898247085511684, -0.053604114800691605, -0.022633321583271027, 0.012875591404736042, -0.024398861452937126, -0.019384456798434258, 0.05704055353999138, -0.0020473795011639595, -0.039721257984638214, -0.05228817090392113 ]
A \emph{$\nu$-reliable spanner} of a metric space $(X,d)$, is a (dominating) graph $H$, such that for any possible failure set $B\subseteq X$, there is a set $B^+$ just slightly larger $|B^+|\le(1+\nu)\cdot|B|$, and all distances between pairs in $X\setminus B^+$ are (approximately) preserved in $H\setminus B$. Recently, there have been several works on sparse reliable spanners in various settings, but so far, the weight of such spanners has not been analyzed at all. In this work, we initiate the study of \emph{light} reliable spanners, whose weight is proportional to that of the Minimum Spanning Tree (MST) of $X$. We first observe that unlike sparsity, the lightness of any deterministic reliable spanner is huge, even for the metric of the simple path graph. Therefore, randomness must be used: an \emph{oblivious} reliable spanner is a distribution over spanners, and the bound on $|B^+|$ holds in expectation. We devise an oblivious $\nu$-reliable $(2+\frac{2}{k-1})$-spanner for any $k$-HST, whose lightness is $\approx \nu^{-2}$. We demonstrate a matching $\Omega(\nu^{-2})$ lower bound on the lightness (for any finite stretch). We also note that any stretch below 2 must incur linear lightness. For general metrics, doubling metrics, and metrics arising from minor-free graphs, we construct {\em light} tree covers, in which every tree is a $k$-HST of low weight. Combining these covers with our results for $k$-HSTs, we obtain oblivious reliable light spanners for these metric spaces, with nearly optimal parameters. In particular, for doubling metrics we get an oblivious $\nu$-reliable $(1+\varepsilon)$-spanner with lightness $\varepsilon^{-O({\rm ddim})}\cdot\tilde{O}(\nu^{-2}\cdot\log n)$, which is best possible (up to lower order terms).
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16612v1
[ -0.038658395409584045, -0.035023368895053864, 0.00551700359210372, 0.0019726725295186043, -0.01246702391654253, 0.03154679387807846, -0.0457678958773613, -0.004324392881244421, -0.03388403356075287, -0.03205176070332527, -0.010585817508399487, -0.07148297876119614, 0.011222213506698608, -0.010715455748140812, -0.06040246784687042, -0.015124975703656673, 0.02939177304506302, 0.027474915608763695, -0.02310638315975666, 0.040739238262176514, -0.05278722569346428, -0.046155210584402084, -0.01932864636182785, 0.025677910074591637, 0.0004584050620906055, -0.04340038076043129, -0.028537273406982422, 0.023514550179243088, -0.06977955996990204, 0.00432079192250967, 0.050404321402311325, -0.02190997637808323, -0.03519916534423828, -0.043811291456222534, 0.019520927220582962, 0.04021940380334854, -0.03498021513223648, -0.010237093083560467, 0.043300166726112366, -0.05405627191066742, 0.048132386058568954, -0.04243540018796921, 0.003797696204856038, -0.06589406728744507, -0.010560158640146255, 0.00429139519110322, -0.0035440397914499044, 0.004758207593113184, -0.04387245699763298, -0.038113854825496674, 0.038348112255334854, -0.03385096415877342, 0.026328014209866524, 0.03619261085987091, -0.0385734923183918, -0.023834526538848877, -0.0017223766772076488, -0.02188357710838318, -0.0602043941617012, -0.0363972932100296, -0.04715877026319504, -0.014734589494764805, -0.0037417993880808353, -0.04129394143819809, -0.029437610879540443, 0.04680720716714859, -0.023549897596240044, -0.07449214160442352, -0.019315872341394424, -0.02798912487924099, 0.022845374420285225, -0.03909739479422569, 0.025274984538555145, 0.022479059174656868, -0.07291345298290253, 0.02158607915043831, -0.02618684619665146, -0.04712635651230812, -0.04698628559708595, 0.01671633869409561, -0.02428952045738697, -0.009770138189196587, 0.0019974380265921354, -0.06858711689710617, 0.034813594073057175, -0.01217259094119072, 0.062446050345897675, -0.04537930712103844, 0.03938908129930496, -0.06250789761543274, -0.05013320595026016, -0.05342913419008255, -0.07659219950437546, -0.062291525304317474, 0.03272407129406929, -0.058580104261636734, 0.06448118388652802, 0.03195258975028992, 0.04412893205881119, -0.035087715834379196, -0.030334943905472755, -0.06816891580820084, -0.02539329044520855, -0.0015328183071687818, 0.043465353548526764, -0.04689041152596474, 0.0029514001216739416, 0.025317318737506866, -0.02287757769227028, 0.05399995297193527, 0.00641590403392911, 0.01306224800646305, -0.018759891390800476, -0.016912385821342468, -0.004453506786376238, -0.048743411898612976, 0.06603167951107025, 0.004714344162493944, 0.05590242147445679, -0.007917205803096294, 0.011093058623373508, 0.005295353010296822, 0.036635614931583405, -0.01229559164494276, 0.021939868107438087, 0.0038418895564973354, 0.047861598432064056, -0.01322081033140421, 0.04012847691774368, 0.05472354218363762, -0.04869304597377777, -0.03207172453403473, 0.041015543043613434, 0.020875131711363792, 0.035045843571424484, 0.028961919248104095, -0.009939782321453094, -0.03266895189881325, 0.020247474312782288, 0.03907652199268341, -0.009534385986626148, -0.046301137655973434, 0.03360830992460251, 0.04568606615066528, 0.03451306000351906, 0.04114570468664169, -0.07452847063541412, 0.046195581555366516, 0.014810166321694851, 0.03834051266312599, -0.01622949168086052, 0.033475395292043686, 0.0054676709696650505, 0.015969188883900642, -0.0027573329862207174, -0.03604617342352867, 0.04863604158163071, 0.03467424213886261, -0.04760186746716499, 0.024287128821015358, 0.04285714402794838, -0.012126232497394085, -0.04135143756866455, 0.019051743671298027, 0.0024778360966593027, 0.014424517750740051, -0.009170331992208958, 0.01322555635124445, 0.0046652331948280334, 0.06297699362039566, -0.05900529772043228, 0.012531178072094917, -0.03816622495651245, -0.058312468230724335, -0.06821399182081223, -0.053674791008234024, -0.0003679424407891929, -0.060662586241960526, 0.002154120709747076, 0.022745680063962936, 0.028499452397227287, -0.027195284143090248, -0.025365889072418213, -0.004204477183520794, -0.051443662494421005, -0.019466141238808632, -0.06189635023474693, 0.026834741234779358, 0.01680411770939827, 0.031655993312597275, -0.030266372486948967, -0.003808365436270833, 0.01473008282482624, -0.044389739632606506, 0.024310074746608734, -0.03717757761478424, -0.004314822144806385, 0.016244083642959595, -0.03190324082970619, 0.026632020249962807, -0.06290008872747421, -0.021185733377933502, -0.04387751594185829, 0.05840153619647026, -0.029954880475997925, -0.06326785683631897, 0.007880596444010735, 0.029267750680446625, 0.007150363177061081, -0.06791189312934875, 0.0700470507144928, 0.006845578551292419, -0.00017304856737609953, -0.00043800147250294685, -0.010341753251850605, -0.028248365968465805, -0.08228004723787308, 0.050896644592285156, 0.0017480936367064714, -0.038467299193143845, 0.035667598247528076, -0.0040673320181667805, -0.037665076553821564, -0.04313120245933533, -0.0647612065076828, 0.05614954233169556, 0.017329977825284004, -0.0016263965517282486, -0.0181245356798172, -0.023987671360373497, 0.0001918780617415905, -0.05226794630289078, -0.023279573768377304, -0.031135359779000282, -0.0260157473385334, -0.03293323144316673, -0.0337727889418602, 0.04881490767002106, 0.003608592553064227, -0.0181589312851429, -0.04954608157277107, 0.0055823372676968575, 0.04554004222154617, 0.0003151619166601449, -0.06364896893501282, -0.049578845500946045, -0.05827220529317856, -0.03865394741296768, -0.008334637619554996, 0.023447949439287186, -0.01781006157398224, -0.017285309731960297, 0.0013038014294579625, -0.022773072123527527, 0.04317966476082802, 0.041109349578619, -0.005990893114358187, -0.003084931755438447, -0.027376944199204445, 0.008037623018026352, 0.004367133602499962, 0.031206287443637848, -0.01512517686933279, -0.03653593733906746, -0.02279921993613243, 0.05253946781158447, -0.04467106983065605, -0.0008027788135223091, -0.004971370100975037, -0.0019677141681313515, 0.00328727625310421, 0.009092102758586407, 0.0606512613594532, -0.003359746653586626, -0.02348681166768074, -0.06357109546661377, -0.03762897104024887, -0.01290778536349535, 0.018419424071907997, -0.0486084446310997, 0.049593035131692886, 0.03139136731624603, -0.033199530094861984, -0.07137291133403778, -0.05226108804345131, -0.0031323714647442102, -0.00633906340226531, -0.06911866366863251, -0.06527160108089447, -0.03985196724534035, -0.03936311602592468, 0.004158534109592438, -0.03146703913807869, -0.01111610233783722, -0.058049362152814865, -0.06364395469427109, -0.009118701331317425, 0.0180757287889719, 0.005349750630557537, -0.06590934097766876, -0.039100103080272675, -0.007916624657809734, 0.012983456254005432, 0.010435115545988083, -0.0023014878388494253, -0.05771610140800476, -0.0352136604487896, -0.019890135154128075, -0.021190088242292404, -0.021266480907797813, -0.034232448786497116, -0.012417901307344437, -0.04324699193239212, -0.0465543307363987, -0.027310974895954132, 0.05472176522016525, 0.0067312936298549175, -0.04445946216583252, 0.025643721222877502, -0.019717834889888763, -0.0247922595590353, -0.013996165245771408, -0.0014296758454293013, -0.037101007997989655, -0.0537063293159008, -0.018079953268170357, 0.06807661056518555, 0.032735906541347504, 0.002987167565152049, -0.04852260276675224, 0.0031982387881726027, -0.005775295197963715, -0.02065320499241352, -0.03258299455046654, 0.022772179916501045, 0.029437735676765442, -0.012428776361048222, 0.036363039165735245, -0.03875379264354706, 0.03273681551218033, -0.04652795195579529, 0.015002340078353882, -0.03674166277050972, 0.0025115932803601027, -0.0019483903888612986, -0.07772824168205261, 0.0653197169303894, 0.06701181828975677, 0.07254042476415634, -0.0048325760290026665, 0.005596012808382511, 0.05929701775312424, 0.014914198778569698, -0.014604683965444565, -0.006111095659434795, -0.029190339148044586, 0.05686688423156738, 0.041553132236003876, -0.0450727678835392, -0.028950491920113564, 0.012106185778975487, -0.05380503833293915, 0.027614491060376167, 0.04953278601169586, -0.02469641901552677, 0.017086300998926163, 0.0002957074611913413, -0.030849948525428772, 0.0414896197617054, 0.009755376726388931, 0.05769022926688194, -0.05340316891670227, -0.02420566976070404, 0.0013100785436108708, 0.021678632125258446, -0.007465527392923832, -0.014613083563745022, 0.0008032500045374036, 0.040306456387043, -0.029960723593831062, 0.0520329624414444, -0.04378558695316315, 0.0003292156907264143, 0.007823855616152287, 0.0027132134418934584, -0.03837418556213379, -0.007244217675179243, -0.03398030996322632, 0.03006374090909958, -0.05452509596943855, -0.005868569482117891, 0.0001744036126183346, -0.014096678234636784, 0.018524622544646263, 0.005262488033622503, -0.01147847156971693, 0.019965095445513725, 0.019651228561997414, -0.04628969728946686, -0.04086921364068985, 0.0386316291987896, -0.01645570807158947, -0.03089218959212303, -0.0783621296286583, -0.03682146966457367, -0.017404980957508087, -0.019244391471147537, -0.033096447587013245, -0.035725533962249756, 0.06593125313520432, 0.018315406516194344, -0.034191422164440155, -0.024784794077277184, -0.004219261929392815, -0.02007765881717205, -0.027440708130598068, -0.06587018072605133, -0.023364350199699402, 0.009292302653193474, -0.06125456467270851, 0.02559773623943329, -0.003673781640827656, -0.038158662617206573, -0.06287511438131332, 0.002295312937349081, -0.00607357919216156, 0.031085483729839325, -0.016925251111388206, 0.052176583558321, 0.033162981271743774, -0.03009018301963806, -0.020254647359251976, -0.014734980650246143, -0.05372218042612076, -0.03938261792063713, -0.013330470770597458, 0.008332360535860062, -0.04362044483423233, -0.037765536457300186, -0.02561153843998909, -0.01973097026348114, 0.04422394558787346, 0.01313695590943098, 0.00423930399119854, 0.028243232518434525, 0.0037008561193943024, -0.07879912853240967, -0.0686928778886795, 0.034126706421375275, -0.04259005934000015, -0.043393246829509735, -0.01729472354054451, 0.012302862480282784, 0.04874942824244499, -0.012563410215079784, 0.03431222587823868, -0.01223321445286274, 0.03430511802434921, -0.024470416828989983, 0.018945083022117615, 0.0141066275537014, -0.010506102815270424, -0.004774973262101412, 0.0058065676130354404, -0.0508701466023922, -0.03391019627451897, 0.028709515929222107, -0.003123841481283307, 0.027047473937273026, 0.05730413645505905, -0.05141197144985199, 0.027563558891415596, -0.065531887114048, 0.016930457204580307, 0.026394018903374672, -0.06371847540140152, 0.011422334238886833, 0.04756271839141846, -0.019072188064455986, 0.02048216201364994, -0.04786166921257973, 0.0033813680056482553, -0.006261864211410284, -0.0003603565273806453, -0.030138393864035606, -0.016887856647372246, -0.04473118111491203, 0.0033358645159751177, 0.010581957176327705, -0.022118696942925453, -0.028869885951280594, -0.024280723184347153, 0.014534243382513523, -0.01516842283308506, -0.05445607751607895, 0.03415448218584061, -0.01440134271979332, -0.0517144575715065, -0.06907814741134644, -0.02520653046667576, 0.02782956324517727, -0.01952705904841423, 0.04118653014302254, -0.05258399620652199, -0.022177308797836304, 0.046548109501600266, -0.04523829370737076, 0.02055327221751213, 0.053784795105457306, 0.015592497773468494, -0.036309633404016495, -0.023323360830545425, -0.03535566106438637, -0.04939912259578705, -0.040446143597364426, 0.006098851561546326, 0.00008065350266406313, -0.014007136225700378, 0.012234830297529697, 0.02585943043231964, 0.021095188334584236, -0.016280656680464745, -0.06344737112522125, -0.023005492985248566, -0.04317493364214897, 0.04698999971151352, -0.029847662895917892, 0.001569467131048441, 0.027637064456939697, 0.028618860989809036, 0.019415274262428284, -0.052912838757038116, -0.015281337313354015, -0.0013663647696375847, -0.015205241739749908, -0.0033489211928099394, 0.041654303669929504, -0.02581700310111046, -0.05100106820464134, -0.026096945628523827, 0.015873532742261887, -0.0341772735118866, 0.06790126860141754, 0.026995079591870308, 0.05466483160853386, 0.03077295608818531, 0.0494079664349556, 0.055824168026447296, -0.042150698602199554, -0.06123177707195282, 0.05747193843126297, -0.051013071089982986, 0.007451092824339867, -0.051640670746564865, -0.04082012176513672, -0.047778189182281494, -0.0519612692296505, -0.03358805552124977, 0.02425975352525711, 0.00044737503048963845, -0.04279424622654915, 0.040744930505752563, 0.011564597487449646, -0.07175850868225098, -0.03607141971588135, -0.0008174401591531932, -0.06953015923500061, 0.023656079545617104, -0.023587537929415703, -0.045825280249118805, -0.010845099575817585, 0.01617278717458248, -0.057545870542526245, -0.06127779930830002, -0.03545120358467102, 0.04350069910287857, 0.06303764879703522, -0.04032110422849655, 0.06311359256505966, 0.019437983632087708, -0.005207332316786051, -0.004260357469320297, -0.060759566724300385, -0.03773701563477516, -0.015108296647667885, 0.05876883119344711, -0.06174907833337784, -0.00682465173304081, -0.03964853286743164, 0.04577900469303131, -0.03279643505811691, -0.04318777471780777, 0.007873285561800003, 0.028384283185005188, 0.04643448814749718, 0.032606713473796844, -0.026194246485829353, -0.0336599238216877, 0.006932127755135298, 0.013941660523414612, -0.014645996503531933, 0.044505082070827484, -0.016052160412073135, 0.003590632462874055, 0.023241981863975525, -0.045397888869047165, 0.02063823491334915, 0.02193884551525116, -0.018651457503437996, -0.0164327435195446, -0.03276308625936508, 0.01200147159397602, -0.034253884106874466, 0.02359667792916298, -0.024349648505449295, 0.022423146292567253, -0.03355471044778824, -0.03871209919452667, -0.056507524102926254, -0.00867420807480812, 0.000716355862095952, 0.022569026798009872, 0.019491862505674362, -0.02193783037364483, 0.07117567956447601, -0.05925886332988739, 0.03556064888834953, -0.02237374521791935, -0.03860722482204437, 0.045720454305410385, -0.022806571796536446, -0.05116792023181915, -0.00008840311784297228, -0.02978280745446682, -0.05632678046822548, 0.03328459709882736, 0.0028193220496177673, -0.009570404887199402, -0.06696771085262299, 0.02490367367863655, -0.0010731009533628821, -0.04291951283812523, 0.03053450584411621, -0.02420039288699627, -0.01663294993340969, 0.047441739588975906, 0.009671787731349468, 0.040959399193525314, 0.03852759301662445, 0.01888754405081272, -0.042069051414728165, 0.0073314206674695015, 0.002743363380432129, -0.014698042534291744, -0.008596349507570267, -0.028463365510106087, -0.06746278703212738, -0.045219387859106064, 0.03467705845832825, -0.002314445096999407, 0.020913202315568924, -0.02188737317919731, -0.018086526542901993, 0.050196029245853424, 0.003889647079631686, 0.05443347245454788, -0.071578249335289, -0.047194819897413254, 0.009565841406583786, -0.03119177743792534, -0.021833958104252815, -0.030553728342056274, -0.06670621782541275, 0.0023861140944063663, -0.07639029622077942, -0.0389709435403347, 0.008928458206355572, 0.030738472938537598, 0.03544244542717934, 0.04420364648103714, -0.04901359602808952, -0.043862104415893555, 0.006123910658061504, 0.014034435153007507, -0.030881674960255623, 0.05611070245504379, 0.032610952854156494, -0.0406908318400383, -0.00926749687641859, 0.03358500450849533, 0.02171216532588005, -0.010604082606732845, 0.020264185965061188, 0.058912284672260284, 0.0376322902739048, -0.0562833733856678, 0.011591955088078976, 0.023666294291615486, -0.04636261984705925, 0.05740216746926308, -0.010035911574959755, -0.049239952117204666, -0.048602234572172165, -0.06784902513027191, -0.010806775651872158, -0.05262010544538498, -0.02143837884068489, -0.04794871062040329, -0.008087679743766785, -0.03523390367627144, -0.05780455097556114, -0.026164133101701736, -0.01276009064167738, 0.043448783457279205, -0.026573069393634796, -0.011588708497583866, -0.030817346647381783, -0.05389106646180153, -0.024043729528784752, -0.00740768201649189, -0.05837186425924301, -0.023569006472826004, 0.036713145673274994, -0.04757292941212654, -0.014323444105684757, -0.06503552943468094, 0.011766776442527771, -0.04422774165868759, 0.028238823637366295, 0.033017054200172424, 0.010718125849962234, -0.044628821313381195, 0.02666326053440571, -0.021008197218179703, -0.05823702737689018, 0.007613953668624163, -0.06230222061276436, -0.03845611959695816, -0.0025678968522697687, 0.02320806495845318, 0.03992992639541626, 0.0484953410923481, -0.024634044617414474, 0.04625800624489784, 0.016958843916654587, -0.0024629286490380764, 0.026541423052549362, -0.01442771777510643, -0.03909946233034134, 0.03012305498123169, 0.01611311361193657, -0.03615075349807739, -0.031642112880945206, 0.03217172622680664, -0.043813128024339676, -0.014000827446579933, -0.010435639880597591, -0.026385493576526642, 0.05761270597577095, -0.06571213901042938, -0.020154643803834915, 0.021330641582608223, 0.027646798640489578, -0.012103268876671791, 0.01679718680679798, 0.025311259552836418, -0.00648026168346405, -0.018212970346212387 ]
Field-level inference is emerging as a promising technique for optimally extracting information from cosmological datasets. Indeed, previous analyses have shown field-based inference produces tighter parameter constraints than power spectrum analyses. However, estimates of the detailed quantitative gain in constraining power differ. Here, we demonstrate the gain in constraining power depends on the parameter space being constrained. As a specific example, we find that field-based analysis of an LSST Y1-like mock data set only marginally improves constraints relative to a 2-point function analysis in $\Lambda$CDM, yet it more than doubles the constraining power of the data in the context of $w$CDM models. This effect reconciles some, but not all, of the discrepant results found in the literature. Our results demonstrate the importance of using a full systematics model when quantifying the information gain for realistic field-level analyses of future data sets.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.00070v1
[ -0.0384284071624279, -0.06269659847021103, 0.03731229156255722, 0.010706540197134018, -0.01563679426908493, 0.04190204292535782, -0.0443962998688221, -0.010423753410577774, -0.012413252145051956, -0.027290796861052513, -0.008448773063719273, -0.03458491712808609, -0.01200636476278305, -0.017002571374177933, -0.04805740714073181, 0.005896780174225569, 0.064014732837677, 0.02493363991379738, -0.004789893049746752, 0.06802255660295486, -0.004129623528569937, 0.03404767066240311, -0.04105301946401596, 0.0530317984521389, 0.03799114748835564, -0.016745364293456078, -0.03318032622337341, -0.03148936107754707, -0.011350556276738644, -0.0009102210169658065, 0.0426303893327713, -0.050261907279491425, -0.03273405507206917, -0.033330388367176056, -0.013137643225491047, -0.008455323986709118, -0.030046746134757996, 0.030616527423262596, -0.0019871206022799015, -0.04869223013520241, 0.03629441559314728, -0.03564662113785744, -0.05149022117257118, -0.02315855585038662, -0.027221564203500748, 0.022631634026765823, -0.04237234964966774, 0.013716721907258034, -0.06956937909126282, -0.05595189705491066, 0.0655173659324646, -0.024708257988095284, 0.011350658722221851, 0.04885010048747063, 0.004572771023958921, 0.02356243133544922, 0.03667183965444565, -0.038290366530418396, -0.06899214535951614, -0.002711270237341523, 0.040031589567661285, -0.03380361944437027, -0.020684542134404182, -0.02314489707350731, -0.035850755870342255, 0.054485857486724854, 0.004428556654602289, -0.07882862538099289, -0.06193189695477486, -0.03665205091238022, 0.03889141231775284, -0.0686543881893158, 0.007275998126715422, -0.018935110419988632, -0.058821097016334534, -0.02688295766711235, -0.0468420572578907, 0.003495876444503665, -0.004930105060338974, 0.03176841512322426, -0.05205441266298294, 0.0036737907212227583, 0.011972062289714813, 0.029344802722334862, 0.018995996564626694, -0.004591898526996374, 0.060131654143333435, -0.0071493759751319885, 0.029651887714862823, -0.048344045877456665, -0.0017340012127533555, -0.06908049434423447, -0.04416494444012642, 0.0022182187531143427, 0.06058143824338913, -0.04574473574757576, 0.03980346396565437, 0.009435473941266537, 0.04177059233188629, 0.009452955797314644, 0.0015378807438537478, -0.06845835596323013, -0.02708701230585575, 0.0345744751393795, 0.010910521261394024, -0.048139654099941254, 0.006868674419820309, 0.0010778466239571571, -0.035198796540498734, 0.040900230407714844, -0.03291281685233116, 0.0059298002161085606, -0.03952573612332344, -0.03580249473452568, -0.05139877274632454, -0.042464014142751694, 0.06955229490995407, 0.0622016042470932, 0.007949440740048885, -0.012259980663657188, -0.005007443018257618, -0.013184020295739174, 0.012043925002217293, 0.01872921921312809, -0.015945471823215485, -0.029534246772527695, 0.03370320424437523, 0.008292523212730885, 0.02235918864607811, 0.022608762606978416, -0.057614438235759735, 0.010640989989042282, 0.0451216883957386, -0.005471975542604923, 0.06058830767869949, 0.0324929840862751, -0.02389274165034294, -0.057349011301994324, 0.06516917794942856, 0.04395206645131111, -0.023242633789777756, -0.07852863520383835, 0.033426638692617416, -0.0014864569529891014, 0.0012451952788978815, 0.03270172327756882, -0.03770968317985535, -0.020500516518950462, 0.016486484557390213, -0.005593928042799234, 0.016939334571361542, 0.011606097221374512, -0.006170331966131926, -0.0036931228823959827, 0.028814181685447693, 0.026139099150896072, 0.029311686754226685, -0.028410349041223526, -0.05074971914291382, -0.004048586823046207, 0.05727279186248779, -0.008002585731446743, -0.031051578000187874, -0.02721688337624073, 0.03303565829992294, -0.005925999954342842, 0.03447653725743294, -0.026765957474708557, 0.026171768084168434, 0.04780828580260277, 0.0011177938431501389, -0.012178094126284122, 0.005070485640317202, -0.05694248154759407, 0.003590809414163232, -0.059598468244075775, 0.0071702622808516026, -0.03689255565404892, -0.041299380362033844, -0.0006113434210419655, -0.0031440884340554476, -0.014527954161167145, -0.048567675054073334, -0.020983655005693436, -0.042518582195043564, -0.0032096365466713905, -0.05563176050782204, 0.01410062238574028, 0.002239296678453684, 0.030537357553839684, -0.040478501468896866, -0.00015915156109258533, 0.04920535534620285, 0.005992397200316191, -0.019835609942674637, -0.03918496519327164, 0.03647104278206825, -0.009180821478366852, 0.02703847549855709, 0.017949940636754036, -0.08613279461860657, -0.06699727475643158, -0.022080188617110252, 0.0014827969716861844, -0.04253840073943138, -0.06403855979442596, 0.019418632611632347, 0.04824472591280937, -0.018991494551301003, 0.0052933041006326675, 0.07887029647827148, 0.03581058979034424, 0.05439348518848419, 0.0023301388137042522, 0.016739044338464737, -0.053768619894981384, -0.09353992342948914, 0.035310663282871246, -0.00909142754971981, -0.005173191428184509, 0.03311200067400932, 0.037294115871191025, -0.03689999878406525, -0.03842660412192345, -0.0036047908943146467, 0.058148276060819626, 0.05061203986406326, 0.026265576481819153, -0.05310887098312378, 0.015447502955794334, -0.016110792756080627, -0.052094582468271255, -0.04110516607761383, -0.08445048332214355, -0.009355791844427586, -0.01063518412411213, 0.0415804460644722, 0.052009474486112595, 0.0072579956613481045, -0.03469790518283844, -0.02535778097808361, 0.003938895650207996, 0.01154958363622427, 0.007954413071274757, -0.047597505152225494, -0.06488975882530212, 0.0012748345034196973, 0.014536245726048946, 0.009937608614563942, -0.009201143868267536, -0.030587119981646538, -0.048785656690597534, -0.035484544932842255, -0.013392996042966843, 0.035439398139715195, 0.03040679544210434, -0.03702623397111893, 0.043970052152872086, -0.021492309868335724, 0.04047879949212074, 0.03318425267934799, 0.04586753994226456, -0.04418094456195831, 0.016801657155156136, 0.024227144196629524, 0.01878657378256321, -0.047469399869441986, -0.01630319468677044, -0.029792658984661102, -0.017478281632065773, 0.041659824550151825, 0.0413750484585762, 0.06625384092330933, 0.016730470582842827, 0.006194322369992733, -0.04324127361178398, -0.03282662853598595, 0.019403573125600815, 0.03238704428076744, 0.05286151543259621, 0.05415409058332443, 0.040837980806827545, 0.018621837720274925, -0.06640545278787613, -0.024848414584994316, -0.04673394560813904, -0.037093497812747955, -0.08270006626844406, -0.07208094745874405, -0.01816204935312271, -0.07448877394199371, -0.01914265565574169, -0.019343694671988487, -0.04038527235388756, -0.0313149131834507, -0.05824194848537445, -0.007656004745513201, -0.00046286475844681263, 0.017665738239884377, -0.06443650275468826, -0.039018481969833374, 0.02004280686378479, 0.035826675593853, 0.021963702514767647, -0.03835419937968254, -0.05801703780889511, -0.04276283085346222, -0.022498520091176033, 0.030844006687402725, -0.011257398873567581, -0.04436386749148369, 0.005283663980662823, 0.013139822520315647, 0.01661626063287258, -0.022252893075346947, 0.04825548827648163, 0.03146509453654289, -0.03707082197070122, 0.002649388974532485, -0.012780191376805305, 0.010415703989565372, -0.029975401237607002, 0.028744515031576157, -0.042768217623233795, -0.03782070800662041, -0.06745228916406631, 0.015864478424191475, 0.021858759224414825, -0.0528198778629303, -0.030939636752009392, -0.018522709608078003, 0.021057596430182457, -0.008938251063227654, 0.044103361666202545, 0.04941881075501442, 0.053672295063734055, -0.04782476648688316, -0.02742493711411953, -0.022167077288031578, 0.021669883280992508, -0.0006252384046092629, 0.025907283648848534, -0.06067713722586632, 0.02355770580470562, 0.061056047677993774, -0.08062024414539337, 0.02850361168384552, 0.06762226670980453, 0.06920851022005081, -0.009168272837996483, 0.008419746533036232, 0.016398387029767036, 0.025258436799049377, 0.01878342218697071, 0.00701681524515152, 0.010541430674493313, 0.0164800975471735, 0.011859544552862644, -0.06293874979019165, -0.03892891854047775, 0.018989892676472664, -0.044918354600667953, -0.022649254649877548, 0.002071889815852046, 0.007703800220042467, 0.03281890228390694, 0.0271450262516737, -0.05170876532793045, 0.04055694490671158, -0.03182316944003105, 0.027828237041831017, -0.006236369255930185, -0.047180064022541046, -0.004439272452145815, -0.05896175280213356, 0.011637890711426735, 0.024519475176930428, -0.03922345116734505, 0.01741640642285347, -0.010840984992682934, 0.030410252511501312, -0.05365539714694023, 0.013704624958336353, 0.021255336701869965, -0.03578362613916397, 0.016991566866636276, 0.04660587012767792, -0.0124939801171422, 0.044650088995695114, -0.02920222468674183, -0.020498070865869522, -0.031099846586585045, 0.03506053611636162, 0.012334882281720638, 0.033789392560720444, -0.04511742293834686, -0.012406682595610619, 0.0350126251578331, -0.013888314366340637, -0.0170154869556427, 0.002467595972120762, -0.01759270764887333, -0.021402282640337944, -0.06453794986009598, 0.021246396005153656, -0.053759217262268066, 0.035728003829717636, 0.010618175379931927, -0.033916544169187546, 0.05482878163456917, 0.005462740547955036, -0.02006329409778118, -0.02962000109255314, 0.0033975220285356045, -0.0005840037483721972, -0.04736211523413658, -0.02208065055310726, -0.035487011075019836, 0.039131809026002884, -0.05218822509050369, 0.050789330154657364, -0.0029866043478250504, -0.008604138158261776, -0.0630640760064125, -0.009225122630596161, -0.04439366236329079, 0.0022762143053114414, 0.0007733219536021352, 0.01573924534022808, -0.031114203855395317, 0.03222496807575226, -0.006448468659073114, -0.03276154398918152, 0.024093003943562508, -0.025438949465751648, -0.03673165291547775, -0.010105411522090435, -0.06824442744255066, -0.05952363461256027, -0.03829016163945198, -0.0013836434809491038, 0.04803336411714554, -0.05368814989924431, 0.02741250954568386, -0.015238065272569656, 0.03463345393538475, -0.0652574673295021, -0.051120273768901825, -0.04551863297820091, -0.03590644523501396, -0.04096636176109314, -0.00547616183757782, 0.013688113540410995, 0.04276174306869507, -0.027508018538355827, 0.03292732685804367, 0.01829340122640133, 0.045998815447092056, -0.0352386012673378, 0.024550050497055054, 0.03052952140569687, -0.02524256892502308, -0.0390387624502182, -0.022442538291215897, -0.07163874804973602, 0.03739449381828308, 0.013685761950910091, -0.04344770684838295, 0.04139309749007225, -0.014298476278781891, -0.00315588666126132, 0.0642566904425621, -0.072088822722435, 0.029875867068767548, 0.033914510160684586, -0.0028005302883684635, 0.02717065066099167, 0.048467960208654404, -0.044291723519563675, 0.029254434630274773, -0.013353170827031136, 0.012239739298820496, -0.011066930368542671, -0.036610063165426254, 0.006399018224328756, -0.019621876999735832, -0.03574960306286812, -0.0391664020717144, 0.045457709580659866, 0.007855391129851341, -0.06244417652487755, 0.03732629120349884, 0.018551062792539597, 0.03673053905367851, -0.040938761085271835, 0.036948010325431824, 0.024899261072278023, -0.06455621123313904, -0.0689651221036911, -0.018851105123758316, 0.015029634349048138, 0.026255900040268898, 0.020985420793294907, -0.06532055884599686, 0.04593922942876816, 0.023506352677941322, -0.04324205592274666, 0.019835982471704483, 0.010897833853960037, -0.006192534230649471, -0.017925547435879707, 0.00989216472953558, -0.025311525911092758, -0.05086793377995491, -0.02532356232404709, -0.01996712200343609, 0.023934179916977882, 0.01458035223186016, 0.005989862140268087, 0.010086051188409328, 0.04789617285132408, -0.00043446753988973796, -0.024147968739271164, 0.00025279680266976357, -0.01880711130797863, 0.045079220086336136, -0.03272491320967674, 0.01447218656539917, -0.0021330337040126324, 0.009054703637957573, 0.029108913615345955, 0.0038810784462839365, 0.01385512575507164, 0.01648634858429432, -0.018123045563697815, 0.009009446017444134, 0.04527146741747856, -0.03892701864242554, -0.05544992536306381, 0.010654418729245663, 0.027462249621748924, -0.026005875319242477, 0.06531906872987747, 0.019517559558153152, 0.02764333039522171, -0.019134217873215675, -0.013706876896321774, 0.004976636730134487, -0.06627441197633743, -0.0011190416989848018, 0.05363570153713226, -0.016993148252367973, 0.0031020899768918753, -0.040312882512807846, 0.011651881970465183, 0.00005431986937765032, -0.03628968447446823, -0.0030559448059648275, 0.0134052699431777, 0.01610250398516655, -0.03660253807902336, 0.05348122492432594, 0.03701814264059067, -0.08258891105651855, 0.04375048726797104, 0.04104263707995415, -0.08360812067985535, -0.00046726426808163524, 0.02068333327770233, -0.014669361524283886, -0.061451505869627, 0.034009430557489395, -0.02820918709039688, 0.003385963151231408, -0.03432318940758705, 0.046231403946876526, 0.07849757373332977, -0.012224887497723103, 0.040232736617326736, 0.00033868104219436646, -0.06021880730986595, -0.003576293820515275, -0.04358230531215668, 0.00869698915630579, -0.034025125205516815, 0.05084330961108208, -0.017334911972284317, -0.018286678940057755, -0.009250671602785587, 0.035156697034835815, 0.0017342724604532123, -0.03340733051300049, 0.04411856457591057, 0.03615778312087059, 0.03143278881907463, -0.02135268598794937, -0.05433911085128784, 0.007342648692429066, -0.02062942646443844, -0.016810808330774307, -0.04333430528640747, 0.01472384948283434, 0.03141764923930168, 0.0057182409800589085, -0.028869587928056717, -0.05425772815942764, 0.04912891983985901, 0.0020000485237687826, -0.03861239552497864, 0.050093308091163635, -0.0616571269929409, 0.00195731851272285, -0.0036135362461209297, 0.05020987614989281, 0.028693245723843575, 0.07336558401584625, -0.06700676679611206, -0.016292886808514595, -0.0011817502090707421, 0.009968722239136696, -0.01811143010854721, -0.034305863082408905, 0.011404719203710556, -0.0644073635339737, 0.05632957071065903, -0.07127829641103745, -0.0036932348739355803, 0.015383810736238956, -0.030521100386977196, 0.032372236251831055, 0.022093787789344788, -0.04135715216398239, -0.041241440922021866, 0.030341148376464844, -0.04731249436736107, 0.009598690085113049, -0.0035213609226047993, -0.04596639797091484, -0.07526756823062897, -0.0298777986317873, 0.020957447588443756, -0.04976103454828262, 0.03774145618081093, 0.0043355245143175125, 0.06058245897293091, 0.012053168378770351, -0.009541129693388939, -0.0009448565542697906, 0.00219541834667325, 0.038187772035598755, -0.05042755603790283, -0.024035029113292694, 0.0020099792163819075, -0.012993836775422096, -0.032192163169384, -0.01972656510770321, -0.01588454097509384, -0.06812501698732376, 0.012297723442316055, 0.03272536024451256, 0.04838841035962105, -0.009584343060851097, -0.03919646143913269, 0.003124924609437585, 0.02277953550219536, -0.03396821394562721, -0.07473623752593994, -0.004500898998230696, -0.0015276612248271704, 0.005893701687455177, 0.022804925218224525, -0.04255346581339836, -0.051223013550043106, -0.01202393602579832, -0.08821140974760056, -0.03891073912382126, -0.018374325707554817, 0.012734707444906235, 0.030180929228663445, -0.009318391792476177, -0.0006161349010653794, -0.046891264617443085, 0.00701772328466177, -0.009215520694851875, 0.03286648169159889, 0.022071806713938713, 0.011029697023332119, -0.014058667235076427, -0.05524696037173271, -0.01396225392818451, 0.02756340801715851, -0.032699815928936005, -0.017133351415395737, 0.03479214757680893, 0.010221139527857304, -0.009419206529855728, 0.005843591410666704, 0.07922358810901642, -0.012962467968463898, 0.031667307019233704, -0.03563656657934189, 0.01696593128144741, -0.024946188554167747, -0.04885690659284592, 0.032223474234342575, -0.07364227622747421, 0.023275699466466904, -0.019725395366549492, -0.0342172309756279, -0.032282017171382904, -0.06746795028448105, -0.056905053555965424, -0.02683565765619278, 0.016825443133711815, -0.05181422084569931, 0.040128443390131, 0.002468456979840994, 0.01458757184445858, -0.0070803225971758366, -0.05075382813811302, -0.027845028787851334, -0.04633241891860962, 0.04885519668459892, -0.032809894531965256, -0.02602430433034897, -0.0651877224445343, 0.010643944144248962, -0.022716734558343887, -0.008048677816987038, -0.058081332594156265, 0.062439918518066406, 0.02059450000524521, -0.01926879957318306, 0.015360149554908276, -0.0021681981161236763, 0.010241792537271976, -0.07966197282075882, -0.05228976160287857, -0.031290434300899506, -0.003796206321567297, 0.0017203337047249079, 0.04982434958219528, -0.02513197250664234, 0.06562525033950806, -0.0011466883588582277, -0.03389003500342369, 0.028777949512004852, 0.03317038714885712, -0.04270755127072334, 0.07322061061859131, 0.029207559302449226, 0.020951498299837112, -0.021729465574026108, 0.0074514467269182205, -0.01362101174890995, -0.05340494588017464, -0.012597419321537018, -0.002470947802066803, 0.039330821484327316, -0.06918308883905411, 0.004619695246219635, 0.03189801797270775, 0.022124087437987328, -0.01918705925345421, 0.0023266372736543417, 0.011825828813016415, -0.026428764685988426, -0.04130745306611061 ]
Randomized control trials, RCTs, have become a powerful tool for assessing the impact of interventions and policies in many contexts. They are considered the gold-standard for inference in the biomedical fields and in many social sciences. Researchers have published an increasing number of studies that rely on RCTs for at least part of the inference, and these studies typically include the response data collected, de-identified and sometimes protected through traditional disclosure limitation methods. In this paper, we empirically assess the impact of strong privacy-preservation methodology (with \ac{DP} guarantees), on published analyses from RCTs, leveraging the availability of replication packages (research compendia) in economics and policy analysis. We provide simulations studies and demonstrate how we can replicate the analysis in a published economics article on privacy-protected data under various parametrizations. We find that relatively straightforward DP-based methods allow for inference-valid protection of the published data, though computational issues may limit more complex analyses from using these methods. The results have applicability to researchers wishing to share RCT data, especially in the context of low- and middle-income countries, with strong privacy protection.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14581v1
[ -0.012726361863315105, -0.058294955641031265, 0.04172949492931366, -0.03201491758227348, -0.031679049134254456, -0.008685018867254257, -0.0000922585604712367, -0.04509694501757622, -0.044885240495204926, -0.024723228067159653, -0.029574092477560043, -0.014492747373878956, -0.01682206615805626, -0.022610004991292953, -0.017698852345347404, -0.0024122127797454596, 0.06044181436300278, 0.05109376832842827, -0.037493571639060974, 0.06907415390014648, -0.01913408935070038, -0.0009279671940021217, -0.011456242762506008, 0.05208403244614601, 0.037420667707920074, 0.014383102767169476, -0.02587258815765381, -0.01490901317447424, -0.031753141433000565, 0.01045888103544712, 0.032370731234550476, -0.04402071237564087, -0.02742815390229225, -0.05246251821517944, -0.043770384043455124, -0.010419945232570171, 0.030984465032815933, -0.01998627744615078, -0.025775879621505737, -0.0211475882679224, 0.052858415991067886, -0.0771428719162941, -0.05776811018586159, -0.040290333330631256, -0.01573062501847744, -0.024591991677880287, -0.0665392205119133, 0.0149864936247468, -0.06380150467157364, -0.026041002944111824, 0.04924904555082321, 0.0027605299837887287, -0.0058313035406172276, 0.04002375528216362, -0.06348354369401932, 0.023707160726189613, 0.01141466572880745, 0.006440003402531147, -0.06789921224117279, -0.026998067274689674, 0.0016407222719863057, -0.006916052661836147, -0.0018748582806438208, -0.004215728957206011, -0.015390858985483646, 0.05274425819516182, -0.016479475423693657, -0.06435447186231613, -0.034232910722494125, -0.05867975950241089, 0.05463503673672676, -0.053784262388944626, 0.012598547153174877, -0.0023533618077635765, -0.052891671657562256, -0.013508129864931107, -0.02606932446360588, -0.026429837569594383, 0.03175435587763786, 0.035932235419750214, -0.05632038414478302, 0.0328139029443264, -0.0034207189455628395, -0.01789558120071888, 0.005776603240519762, -0.021077368408441544, 0.04377507418394089, -0.006773835048079491, -0.004267347510904074, -0.02899070829153061, 0.01260300911962986, -0.021127771586179733, -0.05734141916036606, 0.037188537418842316, 0.06742527335882187, -0.04448579624295235, 0.041294559836387634, 0.02052253670990467, 0.048495497554540634, -0.009782335720956326, 0.012139505706727505, -0.029552176594734192, -0.03353982791304588, 0.058029092848300934, 0.024835774675011635, -0.043749336153268814, 0.00557458121329546, -0.047121547162532806, -0.06502805650234222, 0.011721836403012276, -0.037591785192489624, -0.043638307601213455, -0.046793799847364426, -0.07291953265666962, -0.02710842899978161, -0.023087341338396072, 0.06254695355892181, -0.01141682080924511, 0.04474134370684624, -0.020484238862991333, -0.04704218730330467, 0.01836921088397503, -0.009188255295157433, 0.03153388574719429, -0.03898826614022255, -0.02329985983669758, 0.06949594616889954, 0.006996020674705505, -0.035011738538742065, -0.004019381478428841, -0.04866299033164978, 0.02080533280968666, -0.0013136647175997496, -0.010992646217346191, 0.05892676115036011, 0.015824925154447556, -0.036336272954940796, -0.04376081004738808, 0.03955651447176933, -0.011874847114086151, -0.02284259907901287, -0.0742209181189537, -0.006819082424044609, -0.05727299675345421, -0.019608328118920326, 0.03767110034823418, -0.03287150710821152, -0.008265574462711811, 0.02431011013686657, 0.05602608621120453, 0.010483941063284874, 0.014046051539480686, 0.021961960941553116, 0.014550883322954178, 0.024370603263378143, 0.0053440360352396965, 0.02629721723496914, -0.004140468779951334, -0.04012362286448479, -0.01013505831360817, 0.024259990081191063, -0.019587790593504906, 0.019658267498016357, -0.055497195571660995, 0.006799972150474787, 0.0001689588971203193, 0.026654040440917015, 0.0011836679186671972, -0.011771822348237038, 0.016396980732679367, -0.04202553257346153, 0.039930302649736404, 0.018378883600234985, -0.04539499059319496, -0.0747734010219574, -0.024964217096567154, 0.03143252432346344, -0.026884615421295166, -0.06656533479690552, 0.03890509530901909, 0.015196102671325207, 0.008135749958455563, -0.02558732219040394, -0.0016457469901069999, -0.004288495983928442, 0.04536149650812149, -0.06859498471021652, -0.00600394094362855, -0.010010017082095146, -0.005484133958816528, -0.05527294799685478, -0.014095366932451725, 0.003145374823361635, -0.029118206351995468, -0.018483363091945648, -0.01554302778095007, -0.021327903494238853, -0.033483777195215225, 0.0034687144216150045, 0.03210734948515892, -0.08218656480312347, -0.03373467177152634, -0.06111247465014458, 0.034379925578832626, 0.0032941948156803846, -0.058747485280036926, 0.005437388550490141, 0.06033271178603172, -0.024030866101384163, 0.004242291208356619, 0.03186435624957085, 0.039261236786842346, 0.0406520701944828, 0.05108402296900749, 0.045522291213274, 0.014309223741292953, -0.08889544010162354, 0.039386630058288574, -0.011834715493023396, -0.012563634663820267, 0.04249455779790878, 0.019657621160149574, 0.0014104167930781841, -0.02435830794274807, -0.02850375510752201, 0.05613574758172035, 0.0385986790060997, -0.018970953300595284, -0.05407096445560455, -0.03946791589260101, -0.013437255285680294, -0.0444415807723999, -0.000544945418369025, -0.08007501065731049, -0.023678351193666458, -0.04581637308001518, -0.009507623501121998, 0.057231757789850235, -0.003425742033869028, -0.013487097807228565, -0.025532718747854233, -0.005936389788985252, 0.026746558025479317, 0.014720506966114044, -0.030373018234968185, -0.06791389733552933, -0.02552442066371441, -0.0042803287506103516, 0.009563694708049297, -0.007510714698582888, -0.007714143488556147, -0.052957963198423386, -0.0047495621256530285, -0.00649163918569684, 0.05617470294237137, 0.012422106228768826, 0.0014983073342591524, 0.0434500016272068, -0.034899599850177765, 0.003540636505931616, 0.07131294161081314, 0.037212975323200226, -0.06597612798213959, 0.011897220276296139, 0.03322010487318039, -0.008844560012221336, 0.0034400522708892822, -0.027629204094409943, -0.011314528994262218, -0.032990291714668274, 0.041058819741010666, 0.03196784853935242, 0.032401956617832184, -0.02175283059477806, 0.002189725637435913, -0.03804966062307358, 0.009201491251587868, -0.022705763578414917, 0.019628575071692467, 0.03737074136734009, 0.0433262474834919, 0.04192676022648811, 0.03559846058487892, -0.07539983838796616, -0.034792788326740265, -0.033759959042072296, -0.0077204336412250996, -0.0550558865070343, -0.06883448362350464, -0.004312347155064344, -0.08236190676689148, -0.04129698500037193, 0.01749379187822342, -0.023315448313951492, -0.014649195596575737, -0.04660087451338768, -0.05525914952158928, 0.02616819366812706, 0.011975126340985298, -0.016448326408863068, -0.018973197788000107, -0.03614620491862297, 0.004969577305018902, -0.0033835493959486485, -0.012860145419836044, -0.021466374397277832, -0.0704987421631813, -0.03596370667219162, 0.02160521224141121, -0.02673416957259178, 0.03167138248682022, 0.0350627526640892, 0.012412060983479023, 0.023669632151722908, -0.05255477502942085, 0.0012280030641704798, -0.0035532808396965265, 0.010020153596997261, -0.008559400215744972, -0.04100706800818443, -0.01462862454354763, -0.030453765764832497, 0.01195900421589613, -0.03847602754831314, -0.04742066189646721, -0.013007818721234798, 0.06594232469797134, 0.007011407054960728, -0.016348838806152344, -0.05328166484832764, -0.0010856706649065018, 0.05380675569176674, 0.020830662921071053, -0.005931055638939142, 0.03999701887369156, 0.05516187846660614, -0.037333205342292786, 0.012935986742377281, 0.0030482423026114702, 0.058940839022397995, -0.023670151829719543, 0.05831927806138992, -0.05601651221513748, 0.029493555426597595, 0.058839816600084305, -0.08014991879463196, 0.038432057946920395, 0.009022576734423637, 0.06209058687090874, 0.006536627188324928, -0.009022990241646767, 0.043843530118465424, 0.009945953264832497, 0.002650054870173335, -0.000010197817573498469, 0.016499945893883705, 0.038024451583623886, 0.006146748550236225, -0.06234736740589142, -0.02632668986916542, 0.014715569093823433, -0.044736072421073914, -0.03989836201071739, 0.014326231554150581, -0.014311597682535648, 0.008408873341977596, 0.008391577750444412, -0.05319930613040924, 0.03822176158428192, -0.01851252280175686, 0.048068754374980927, -0.019860122352838516, -0.04657358676195145, 0.034280478954315186, -0.048549603670835495, 0.05361364036798477, -0.008559673093259335, -0.00969528965651989, 0.02470356784760952, -0.03837175667285919, 0.04829179123044014, -0.03959152102470398, 0.00020336256420705467, 0.017040496692061424, -0.00605257973074913, 0.019307265058159828, 0.050835274159908295, -0.013495078310370445, 0.043655507266521454, -0.005921369418501854, -0.020154917612671852, -0.032707661390304565, 0.03852774575352669, -0.021501582115888596, -0.026824569329619408, -0.036433178931474686, -0.031722571700811386, 0.040414199233055115, -0.029749741777777672, -0.015341624617576599, -0.03475938364863396, -0.01884494721889496, -0.024471577256917953, -0.08339011669158936, 0.034902021288871765, -0.054704099893569946, 0.05447239801287651, 0.0022720787674188614, -0.030748173594474792, 0.026099104434251785, -0.030427422374486923, 0.03323935717344284, -0.03653515875339508, 0.005128227174282074, -0.024316666647791862, -0.021111300215125084, -0.014423894695937634, -0.05819261074066162, 0.028169864788651466, -0.06746712327003479, 0.06644424796104431, 0.0019521701615303755, -0.02824975922703743, -0.0626857727766037, 0.016915731132030487, -0.03306758403778076, -0.0029233810491859913, 0.059545453637838364, 0.02986201085150242, 0.009949375875294209, -0.018142038956284523, 0.05252818763256073, 0.019661827012896538, 0.0028543800581246614, -0.04263249784708023, -0.04888923466205597, -0.011402402073144913, -0.030928634107112885, -0.05178980901837349, -0.017575738951563835, -0.023832613602280617, 0.06703808903694153, -0.050203412771224976, 0.010961856693029404, -0.02960395999252796, 0.026041487231850624, -0.07342703640460968, -0.08162608742713928, -0.01717274636030197, -0.03115851804614067, -0.0680636391043663, -0.03201984986662865, 0.04213639721274376, 0.014778148382902145, -0.005087291821837425, -0.0009141033515334129, 0.035699985921382904, 0.013533078134059906, 0.010979607701301575, 0.018336180597543716, -0.0018852530047297478, -0.02967960573732853, -0.0353965125977993, -0.011897877790033817, -0.06923103332519531, -0.02395796589553356, -0.004097330383956432, 0.00973870325833559, 0.03509420156478882, 0.05017602816224098, 0.007681784685701132, 0.05128052830696106, -0.08033346384763718, 0.012002901174128056, 0.023513473570346832, -0.031162865459918976, 0.059392523020505905, 0.06100214645266533, -0.005270057823508978, 0.009572052396833897, -0.05100316181778908, 0.03620212525129318, 0.003070465987548232, -0.06381560117006302, 0.00582378963008523, -0.042482390999794006, 0.0029347010422497988, -0.025534575805068016, 0.029361724853515625, -0.03461954742670059, -0.06821802258491516, 0.017179209738969803, 0.03742481395602226, -0.013487912714481354, -0.010790069587528706, 0.02609376050531864, -0.003779012942686677, -0.055408552289009094, -0.062168221920728683, -0.024571016430854797, -0.008256918750703335, 0.015322159044444561, 0.037266552448272705, -0.05262947082519531, 0.010047306306660175, 0.029621528461575508, 0.02939091995358467, -0.001388814183883369, 0.014646992087364197, -0.03030293807387352, -0.025213688611984253, 0.03620262071490288, -0.0012495401315391064, -0.0602576807141304, 0.010233905166387558, -0.06023285165429115, 0.06566273421049118, 0.028384985402226448, 0.03425492346286774, 0.04664500057697296, -0.022550668567419052, -0.038460858166217804, -0.03677763789892197, -0.013334083370864391, -0.009390367195010185, -0.018625356256961823, -0.03233279660344124, 0.00434744730591774, 0.04424671456217766, 0.039064276963472366, 0.03310627117753029, -0.03884228691458702, 0.030800500884652138, 0.04462449997663498, -0.01731598749756813, 0.010501275770366192, 0.0341942273080349, -0.011853624135255814, -0.06029042601585388, 0.04696503281593323, 0.03670847415924072, -0.04132460057735443, 0.07569801062345505, 0.03319927304983139, -0.030314169824123383, 0.005013607908040285, -0.04285168647766113, -0.0074448655359447, -0.04489341005682945, 0.012032653205096722, 0.04299408942461014, -0.021763022989034653, 0.007165447808802128, -0.018450705334544182, 0.007996785454452038, 0.02495887316763401, -0.04071272909641266, 0.0013884344371035695, 0.02115226909518242, 0.026154521852731705, -0.05096907168626785, 0.04528532549738884, -0.020658046007156372, -0.0779772698879242, 0.015320356003940105, 0.011654307134449482, -0.0774679109454155, -0.003256869036704302, 0.05038901045918465, 0.027744341641664505, -0.04543226957321167, 0.06524371355772018, -0.021548857912421227, 0.012647969648241997, 0.02161913923919201, 0.06927162408828735, 0.08497554808855057, 0.01332191750407219, -0.017903948202729225, -0.031999748200178146, -0.05161324143409729, 0.019849278032779694, -0.04590766504406929, -0.03577788174152374, 0.002891991753131151, 0.05249732360243797, -0.030487004667520523, -0.036462437361478806, -0.061075884848833084, 0.03949012979865074, 0.00940952729433775, 0.005402661859989166, 0.03075278364121914, -0.043426334857940674, 0.04947504773736, -0.05793159082531929, -0.017354654148221016, 0.00449266517534852, -0.001120900735259056, -0.03303755819797516, -0.018247786909341812, -0.02334381453692913, 0.00394770922139287, 0.01138678565621376, 0.03914354369044304, -0.06321461498737335, -0.02512977086007595, -0.018059017136693, -0.04220622777938843, 0.03439036011695862, -0.04935863986611366, -0.0009006039472296834, 0.015599025413393974, 0.0015670163556933403, -0.0009144338546320796, 0.07155711203813553, -0.02066420204937458, 0.02766413614153862, 0.013443133793771267, -0.0016930088168010116, 0.006020613946020603, 0.015793433412909508, 0.004161542747169733, -0.010717025026679039, 0.005353482440114021, -0.05502142757177353, -0.017911948263645172, 0.005914249457418919, 0.011806195601820946, 0.022553330287337303, -0.006948482245206833, -0.027056191116571426, -0.055182356387376785, 0.020126288756728172, -0.0545407272875309, 0.02937978506088257, 0.004413099028170109, -0.015617487020790577, -0.06762389093637466, -0.03426790609955788, -0.013496588915586472, -0.0029363587964326143, -0.010748588480055332, 0.04803948476910591, 0.04782818257808685, -0.009163817390799522, -0.013464284129440784, -0.005121199414134026, 0.05297771468758583, 0.049953147768974304, -0.04882856830954552, -0.0005675511201843619, 0.04720471799373627, -0.05927689000964165, -0.014765107072889805, -0.04213752970099449, -0.04598962515592575, -0.0741511881351471, 0.03841705620288849, 0.042445506900548935, 0.042568109929561615, 0.009433516301214695, -0.0479886569082737, 0.03084559552371502, 0.00960797630250454, -0.014806537888944149, -0.041666869074106216, -0.05408531427383423, -0.015312470495700836, -0.026909083127975464, 0.03320389986038208, -0.06417319923639297, -0.06373629719018936, 0.0009416480897925794, -0.0772470235824585, 0.0055239382199943066, 0.017599713057279587, 0.030815159901976585, -0.024755124002695084, -0.04905947297811508, -0.007331401109695435, -0.03627970442175865, 0.019711334258317947, -0.003636701498180628, 0.015685755759477615, -0.017727719619870186, 0.035380274057388306, -0.028766436502337456, -0.0669109895825386, -0.02160283550620079, 0.0075675868429243565, -0.058674123138189316, 0.003589292522519827, 0.024270277470350266, 0.030131764709949493, 0.002585522597655654, 0.017577389255166054, 0.04342726990580559, -0.01527300663292408, 0.010897111147642136, -0.005822539329528809, 0.02125374600291252, -0.04494328424334526, -0.07118119299411774, 0.05266597867012024, -0.045238569378852844, -0.0035795005969703197, 0.02976890094578266, 0.01193219143897295, -0.0008209943189285696, -0.05646754056215286, -0.03758501261472702, 0.040854908525943756, 0.025398818776011467, -0.01865205354988575, 0.05621889978647232, 0.0011048289015889168, 0.004682510159909725, -0.024992624297738075, 0.0031736630480736494, -0.03432605043053627, -0.037913933396339417, 0.03247988224029541, -0.026401767507195473, -0.05760606750845909, -0.04436201974749565, -0.027471570298075676, 0.028691593557596207, -0.013056416064500809, -0.05868692696094513, 0.08193589001893997, 0.007111025042831898, -0.033066414296627045, 0.010951855219900608, -0.06070864200592041, -0.028081398457288742, -0.07028649002313614, -0.03671359643340111, -0.05928462743759155, 0.006871709134429693, 0.022272294387221336, 0.022331709042191505, 0.017513174563646317, 0.049858786165714264, 0.018384180963039398, 0.027023091912269592, 0.011013581417500973, -0.00691946828737855, -0.06098492816090584, 0.05812065675854683, 0.014698339626193047, 0.030142810195684433, -0.029668819159269333, 0.02834431454539299, 0.008438816294074059, -0.006739447358995676, 0.014246348291635513, -0.008458739146590233, 0.007440895773470402, -0.05635600537061691, -0.01989738643169403, 0.028874265030026436, 0.03936975821852684, -0.024933207780122757, -0.03376961871981621, 0.022238783538341522, -0.02773827314376831, -0.06642930954694748 ]
In this paper, the maze generation using quantum annealing is proposed. We reformulate a standard algorithm to generate a maze into a specific form of a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problem suitable for the input of the quantum annealer. To generate more difficult mazes, we introduce an additional cost function $Q_{update}$ to increase the difficulty. The difficulty of the mazes was evaluated by the time to solve the maze of 12 human subjects. To check the efficiency of our scheme to create the maze, we investigated the time-to-solution of a quantum processing unit, classical computer, and hybrid solver.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04792v2
[ -0.016762524843215942, -0.05633315443992615, 0.02283204160630703, 0.01283275056630373, -0.012998867779970169, 0.017183711752295494, -0.016448868438601494, -0.02174111269414425, -0.038070276379585266, -0.012518591247498989, -0.02006172016263008, -0.00340083846822381, -0.015799744054675102, 0.007817300967872143, -0.04672882705926895, 0.030499350279569626, 0.06558991968631744, -0.016039257869124413, -0.027010785415768623, 0.05805229768157005, 0.0026005953550338745, -0.025128047913312912, -0.04332319274544716, 0.03270852938294411, 0.05403337627649307, -0.0011508460156619549, -0.04758032038807869, 0.030466563999652863, -0.051328450441360474, -0.038028258830308914, 0.06944280117750168, -0.03890098258852959, 0.00949143711477518, -0.05254904553294182, -0.04484599456191063, -0.04980866611003876, -0.005113130901008844, 0.017631612718105316, 0.03901787847280502, -0.03065742738544941, -0.005230782553553581, -0.03555867820978165, -0.07008112221956253, -0.013373828493058681, -0.023748526349663734, -0.014426500536501408, -0.007015259005129337, -0.0033678787294775248, -0.06887601315975189, -0.06247522681951523, 0.011431667022407055, -0.010752029716968536, 0.00029761367477476597, 0.02442071959376335, -0.025453751906752586, -0.021409891545772552, -0.00875519122928381, -0.013993038795888424, -0.029936786741018295, -0.048579927533864975, 0.027890492230653763, 0.016770198941230774, -0.003224852727726102, -0.00741922203451395, 0.016688290983438492, 0.06842456758022308, -0.026809299364686012, -0.028614042326807976, 0.010347413830459118, -0.03475639969110489, 0.016631579026579857, -0.06547167897224426, 0.044618669897317886, 0.0019132294692099094, -0.02138422057032585, -0.02366711013019085, -0.036457039415836334, -0.05841049179434776, 0.020116964355111122, 0.04874224588274956, -0.010770189575850964, -0.0021087261848151684, 0.0018048492493107915, 0.0013359294971451163, 0.03955234959721565, -0.04318100959062576, 0.05630829557776451, 0.01776350662112236, -0.007232677657157183, -0.07144501805305481, 0.04118090122938156, -0.04647976905107498, -0.0644485279917717, -0.023794924840331078, 0.061910007148981094, 0.013099844567477703, 0.05782964453101158, 0.07592710107564926, -0.007269340567290783, 0.02107279933989048, 0.013932375237345695, -0.06442368775606155, -0.0451379232108593, 0.014728698879480362, 0.04595889896154404, -0.006172820460051298, -0.01796296052634716, -0.012414826080203056, -0.042537037283182144, 0.0167396180331707, -0.033223580569028854, 0.050521764904260635, -0.005954566411674023, -0.0482931062579155, -0.02372252196073532, -0.07179034501314163, 0.04315384477376938, 0.03786855563521385, 0.04659602791070938, -0.043545451015233994, 0.00551442289724946, 0.02868628315627575, 0.04636529088020325, 0.03546057641506195, -0.04554439336061478, -0.053016070276498795, 0.05302814394235611, 0.017399420961737633, -0.013808959163725376, -0.003508463269099593, -0.048748910427093506, 0.041535284370183945, 0.01836753636598587, -0.034605927765369415, 0.03285997360944748, 0.010071353055536747, -0.04779442027211189, -0.06122836843132973, 0.01377969142049551, 0.008895430713891983, -0.06604814529418945, -0.05510719120502472, 0.06040879711508751, -0.000903207459487021, -0.02373065985739231, 0.03862733021378517, -0.04218096286058426, 0.019410789012908936, 0.030180415138602257, -0.0008276715525425971, 0.0022361839655786753, 0.00837863702327013, 0.0042279805056750774, 0.019422559067606926, 0.02746809460222721, 0.0035959354136139154, 0.05142978951334953, 0.016889534890651703, -0.044480372220277786, 0.04349050298333168, 0.0164472796022892, -0.050135865807533264, 0.006635339464992285, 0.02888067439198494, 0.00030760964727960527, 0.025526707991957664, 0.028433198109269142, -0.003089053789153695, -0.011113702319562435, 0.0028367359191179276, -0.04994145780801773, -0.0478600338101387, 0.0513174943625927, -0.030205540359020233, -0.029076501727104187, -0.036922696977853775, -0.05070921778678894, -0.03393712639808655, -0.044208597391843796, -0.019456440582871437, -0.004474157467484474, -0.02327023632824421, 0.0019785556942224503, 0.0385344997048378, -0.054028868675231934, 0.004207008983939886, -0.0781080424785614, 0.013293729163706303, 0.06305845081806183, 0.0017508900491520762, -0.01767639070749283, -0.004919215105473995, 0.05272471159696579, -0.010303857736289501, -0.014550141990184784, -0.02116101048886776, 0.004812375642359257, 0.021951278671622276, 0.0032883400563150644, 0.0399542972445488, -0.06448858976364136, -0.03738971799612045, -0.05616088956594467, 0.004036114551126957, 0.004890442360192537, -0.08744101971387863, -0.005636812653392553, 0.03513747826218605, -0.00544189615175128, -0.008220886811614037, 0.06806613504886627, -0.007453227881342173, 0.05064518004655838, 0.006816045381128788, 0.02495751343667507, 0.03319421410560608, -0.10271027684211731, 0.0554187186062336, 0.011671464890241623, -0.003038220340386033, -0.019925620406866074, -0.011788391508162022, 0.030554627999663353, -0.0000659828947391361, -0.03076896257698536, 0.041716113686561584, 0.03741409629583359, -0.032456621527671814, -0.03199297562241554, -0.03243738040328026, -0.019367214292287827, -0.03943917155265808, -0.04718317091464996, -0.06240086629986763, -0.002877709688618779, 0.034233175218105316, 0.045003414154052734, 0.06212182343006134, -0.0023876349441707134, -0.044845085591077805, -0.06610333919525146, -0.0055494774132966995, 0.052452411502599716, -0.04266456887125969, -0.05921740457415581, -0.004711255896836519, -0.008066808804869652, -0.007392427418380976, 0.01725205034017563, 0.030432799831032753, -0.016194365918636322, -0.025308780372142792, 0.0020682564936578274, -0.03020881861448288, 0.00693558482453227, 0.05787704885005951, -0.05117051303386688, 0.028191646561026573, 0.013061576522886753, 0.0703347697854042, -0.02189694344997406, 0.06008587405085564, -0.016034865751862526, -0.003176205325871706, 0.04053063318133354, 0.03005935251712799, -0.05024010315537453, -0.05717513710260391, -0.032873645424842834, -0.018969349563121796, -0.014711873605847359, 0.024088148027658463, 0.014184120111167431, 0.025102004408836365, -0.021024391055107117, -0.02394034154713154, 0.021264489740133286, -0.034853365272283554, 0.029551925137639046, 0.03199560195207596, -0.04511773958802223, 0.022314731031656265, 0.024730870500206947, -0.07739338278770447, 0.015770353376865387, -0.009063906967639923, -0.033882077783346176, -0.053246237337589264, -0.05324460193514824, 0.012434582225978374, -0.06539978086948395, -0.001868183258920908, 0.0051019443199038506, -0.046643391251564026, -0.007430634927004576, 0.005366270896047354, 0.02376164309680462, -0.006386925466358662, 0.05057094991207123, -0.04915506765246391, -0.08599433302879333, -0.019815096631646156, 0.028020543977618217, 0.04363981634378433, 0.031388141214847565, -0.010311695747077465, -0.03356216102838516, 0.023944087326526642, -0.0022365928161889315, 0.06483251601457596, -0.018220847472548485, 0.037439778447151184, -0.018296480178833008, 0.0026467933785170317, 0.036526601761579514, 0.0636972188949585, 0.017423510551452637, 0.015566147863864899, -0.03798021003603935, 0.010768667794764042, -0.02667705900967121, 0.015100700780749321, 0.01885877549648285, -0.039798445999622345, -0.05183293670415878, -0.030596034601330757, 0.040625207126140594, 0.018639802932739258, -0.008602974936366081, 0.024120694026350975, -0.041368257254362106, -0.014206323772668839, 0.012705632485449314, -0.01293592993170023, 0.032539792358875275, 0.050229139626026154, -0.04357285797595978, -0.04346583038568497, -0.047516971826553345, -0.05895724892616272, -0.02254687435925007, 0.045493513345718384, 0.04598751291632652, -0.009987960569560528, -0.007476598955690861, -0.0981510654091835, 0.07979106903076172, 0.025832289829850197, 0.04227708652615547, -0.03702310845255852, 0.01729176752269268, 0.0032596306409686804, 0.021380193531513214, -0.03017672710120678, -0.010447703301906586, 0.03180009126663208, 0.05265543609857559, 0.02118849568068981, -0.025621462613344193, -0.03349418193101883, 0.008836451917886734, -0.07284186780452728, -0.014453211799263954, -0.004383302293717861, 0.04818778485059738, 0.04705313593149185, 0.03670353442430496, -0.016869373619556427, -0.03533065319061279, -0.053953804075717926, 0.019116230309009552, 0.026332279667258263, -0.029494578018784523, 0.006756544578820467, -0.019429242238402367, 0.040204498916864395, 0.028631938621401787, 0.029221253469586372, 0.03363596647977829, -0.04673938453197479, 0.020734019577503204, -0.03809542581439018, 0.05912676826119423, -0.016983961686491966, -0.05185664817690849, 0.01652715355157852, 0.005527198314666748, -0.013550486415624619, 0.03608379885554314, -0.052104637026786804, 0.00035272326203994453, -0.0036084142047911882, 0.02445741556584835, -0.006174883805215359, 0.017924029380083084, -0.03541319817304611, -0.014982419088482857, -0.010720818303525448, -0.019333239644765854, -0.040970515459775925, 0.025311913341283798, -0.0033022682182490826, -0.01637447252869606, -0.061251599341630936, -0.06465193629264832, -0.0579666867852211, 0.007717007305473089, -0.01570194400846958, -0.056148234754800797, 0.0741550624370575, -0.011558040045201778, -0.009945218451321125, -0.030388718470931053, -0.011170728132128716, -0.006790535058826208, -0.04866435378789902, -0.028203990310430527, -0.05360519513487816, 0.000312608404783532, 0.008719157427549362, 0.02658945880830288, 0.01942703127861023, 0.018438084051012993, -0.039782311767339706, 0.007938414812088013, -0.024334242567420006, 0.0300397090613842, 0.06249918043613434, 0.03845703601837158, 0.010267983190715313, -0.027485638856887817, -0.0035182698629796505, -0.009791381657123566, -0.012002282775938511, -0.002575610764324665, -0.04773881658911705, 0.07993599772453308, -0.013706903904676437, -0.02324424870312214, 0.006765462923794985, -0.022066686302423477, 0.0736021175980568, -0.03184834495186806, -0.038925427943468094, 0.012610545381903648, 0.044440314173698425, -0.06879663467407227, -0.04705128073692322, 0.03600523993372917, -0.019973501563072205, -0.012315484695136547, -0.024423018097877502, 0.022224735468626022, 0.029848657548427582, -0.012906077317893505, 0.021724019199609756, 0.013185269199311733, 0.00480607058852911, -0.036894023418426514, -0.024133922532200813, 0.022869978100061417, -0.016567371785640717, -0.023524349555373192, 0.022049620747566223, -0.08881334215402603, 0.022682765498757362, -0.024847451597452164, 0.0014556761598214507, 0.006711948662996292, 0.07137085497379303, 0.025673309341073036, 0.08020558953285217, -0.07453079521656036, -0.0164304468780756, 0.07000516355037689, -0.022051475942134857, -0.005630676634609699, 0.03219098597764969, 0.005272126756608486, 0.01025867834687233, 0.002151869935914874, -0.010619518347084522, 0.024516617879271507, -0.021609103307127953, -0.012258966453373432, 0.01832476630806923, -0.04682976379990578, 0.04073653370141983, 0.03556932508945465, -0.027039259672164917, -0.0027662445791065693, -0.017953136935830116, -0.008190058171749115, 0.03930051624774933, -0.03156830742955208, 0.04740416631102562, -0.016726531088352203, -0.04135799780488014, -0.056424275040626526, -0.021688370034098625, -0.016901502385735512, 0.00042975714313797653, -0.007835895754396915, -0.02126101776957512, 0.02514706365764141, 0.02836628071963787, 0.04912230372428894, -0.04841298609972, 0.033414456993341446, 0.028834249824285507, -0.034833475947380066, -0.03523193672299385, -0.014921195805072784, -0.01881093718111515, 0.008151747286319733, -0.02024560421705246, 0.041773486882448196, 0.010435890406370163, 0.03914337977766991, 0.06737097352743149, -0.009488307870924473, 0.022438950836658478, -0.02901240438222885, -0.016170717775821686, -0.021351490169763565, 0.045607056468725204, 0.023487543687224388, 0.01579369232058525, -0.05225001648068428, 0.02162829227745533, 0.016607603058218956, -0.0067036752589046955, 0.0297236405313015, 0.0006199476774781942, 0.008900684304535389, -0.027151593938469887, 0.013448758982121944, -0.04922939091920853, -0.043264828622341156, -0.02918103151023388, 0.06955106556415558, -0.02748269960284233, 0.055727388709783554, 0.021754274144768715, -0.0026784606743603945, 0.020101265981793404, -0.01300396490842104, -0.05243474990129471, -0.06208280846476555, 0.03154339641332626, 0.04713229462504387, -0.04261571913957596, -0.011826624162495136, -0.030990811064839363, -0.022761577740311623, 0.025786692276597023, -0.0626414343714714, 0.03737835958600044, -0.033215560019016266, 0.029357949271798134, -0.025176286697387695, 0.06834971904754639, 0.03265843540430069, -0.055314790457487106, 0.005857421550899744, 0.050466958433389664, -0.07676855474710464, -0.017984643578529358, -0.03970500826835632, 0.01642727106809616, -0.019571412354707718, 0.045944396406412125, 0.014488336630165577, -0.04313391447067261, -0.03262154385447502, 0.08767285943031311, 0.07559191435575485, -0.041336316615343094, 0.06734929233789444, 0.02543448656797409, -0.07075212150812149, 0.0007378548034466803, -0.053662922233343124, -0.016182294115424156, -0.020177820697426796, 0.05081615597009659, 0.009823677130043507, -0.010746878571808338, -0.04958808049559593, 0.024785133078694344, -0.047273170202970505, -0.03311476111412048, 0.0026771484408527613, 0.03685570880770683, 0.04125078767538071, -0.013837108388543129, -0.03617837652564049, -0.031230192631483078, -0.04159168526530266, 0.022626658901572227, -0.006312463898211718, 0.029883697628974915, -0.01646776683628559, 0.04599408060312271, -0.0437677763402462, -0.04508737847208977, 0.010737880133092403, -0.010207652114331722, -0.044756896793842316, 0.017001140862703323, -0.07358355820178986, -0.0359564870595932, 0.015343545004725456, 0.013686027377843857, 0.007963813841342926, 0.015312658622860909, 0.0053618066012859344, 0.04724077135324478, -0.029645457863807678, -0.004517821595072746, -0.02209196425974369, 0.042510174214839935, 0.029756322503089905, -0.013720547780394554, 0.07857953757047653, -0.03254338353872299, 0.0091168861836195, -0.047261446714401245, -0.04114370793104172, 0.006171501241624355, 0.03305799886584282, -0.031772155314683914, -0.050060633569955826, 0.014402166940271854, -0.0024618678726255894, 0.009461400099098682, 0.020506499335169792, -0.05213877558708191, -0.06117003783583641, 0.030067577958106995, 0.03461844101548195, 0.026411086320877075, 0.009403197094798088, 0.017111729830503464, 0.01658753678202629, 0.012457995675504208, 0.04139554873108864, 0.0030976987909525633, 0.030937302857637405, 0.0029108391609042883, -0.05090460553765297, -0.055374596267938614, -0.022659342736005783, -0.042583104223012924, -0.02698974870145321, -0.04323359951376915, 0.004535714164376259, -0.07909322530031204, 0.012156656943261623, 0.05663282051682472, 0.017057806253433228, -0.013152378611266613, -0.04472536966204643, 0.05466140806674957, 0.05437711998820305, -0.028969207778573036, -0.05833984538912773, 0.04419296979904175, 0.021636471152305603, -0.029466629028320312, 0.011076316237449646, -0.02650444209575653, -0.01821841113269329, 0.017252406105399132, -0.08374843746423721, 0.012724102474749088, -0.04393398016691208, 0.010713419876992702, -0.018287530168890953, -0.01252681203186512, 0.0058266944251954556, -0.04620066657662392, 0.014249775558710098, -0.025861693546175957, 0.006107395049184561, -0.003541658166795969, 0.030586106702685356, 0.030001457780599594, -0.025628013536334038, 0.021974844858050346, 0.06529035419225693, -0.022395430132746696, 0.03362727165222168, 0.05861515924334526, 0.05069858208298683, -0.041926879435777664, 0.006455347407609224, 0.035332243889570236, -0.0017972346395254135, 0.05717328190803528, -0.05681012570858002, -0.008833286352455616, 0.001736270496621728, -0.07596683502197266, 0.06353962421417236, -0.013090304099023342, -0.0031484905630350113, -0.01571570709347725, -0.018803207203745842, 0.038775473833084106, 0.02991849184036255, -0.046094026416540146, 0.005253039766103029, 0.032427284866571426, -0.03262907266616821, 0.05618826299905777, -0.019324269145727158, 0.0012266270350664854, 0.0029590509366244078, -0.017516380175948143, -0.058581169694662094, 0.03630870208144188, 0.06263446807861328, -0.05071834474802017, 0.019439993426203728, -0.04886752739548683, 0.022062381729483604, -0.03375642001628876, 0.015230857767164707, -0.024741174653172493, 0.05051440745592117, 0.011568441055715084, -0.038278695195913315, -0.05976174399256706, -0.024716829881072044, -0.0389147512614727, -0.06753755360841751, -0.034467052668333054, 0.013385220430791378, -0.000030043829610804096, -0.011742765083909035, 0.041592542082071304, -0.016293806955218315, 0.07502671331167221, 0.01725824363529682, -0.048793092370033264, 0.020528612658381462, 0.034789931029081345, -0.06933166831731796, 0.040054310113191605, 0.006730368826538324, -0.020307140424847603, -0.056984759867191315, 0.012552174739539623, 0.03710882365703583, 0.014581870287656784, -0.0028060174081474543, -0.03762048855423927, 0.043567609041929245, -0.037931762635707855, 0.011348242871463299, 0.015198337845504284, -0.01603793539106846, -0.02719208411872387, 0.0025848860386759043, -0.013965854421257973, -0.0011325140949338675, -0.027427595108747482 ]
Object understanding in egocentric visual data is arguably a fundamental research topic in egocentric vision. However, existing object datasets are either non-egocentric or have limitations in object categories, visual content, and annotation granularities. In this work, we introduce EgoObjects, a large-scale egocentric dataset for fine-grained object understanding. Its Pilot version contains over 9K videos collected by 250 participants from 50+ countries using 4 wearable devices, and over 650K object annotations from 368 object categories. Unlike prior datasets containing only object category labels, EgoObjects also annotates each object with an instance-level identifier, and includes over 14K unique object instances. EgoObjects was designed to capture the same object under diverse background complexities, surrounding objects, distance, lighting and camera motion. In parallel to the data collection, we conducted data annotation by developing a multi-stage federated annotation process to accommodate the growing nature of the dataset. To bootstrap the research on EgoObjects, we present a suite of 4 benchmark tasks around the egocentric object understanding, including a novel instance level- and the classical category level object detection. Moreover, we also introduce 2 novel continual learning object detection tasks. The dataset and API are available at https://github.com/facebookresearch/EgoObjects.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08816v1
[ -0.024029571563005447, -0.02101009339094162, 0.04519381374120712, 0.009262161329388618, -0.008873021230101585, -0.048667386174201965, -0.006925762165337801, 0.00794996414333582, -0.00479553360491991, -0.03698204085230827, 0.0027505606412887573, 0.03335707262158394, -0.056234508752822876, -0.06582928448915482, -0.04166477546095848, -0.0027453985530883074, 0.07022259384393692, -0.019518738612532616, -0.0802266076207161, 0.04623870924115181, 0.03667937591671944, -0.05328221619129181, -0.00125142524484545, -0.0017926307627931237, 0.026727372780442238, -0.04333171620965004, 0.006746093276888132, 0.042256806045770645, -0.0030428648460656404, 0.006340623367577791, 0.08120068907737732, -0.01838180422782898, 0.024436095729470253, -0.03089364990592003, -0.010611790232360363, -0.042176540940999985, 0.0032462861854583025, 0.014686747454106808, -0.061702437698841095, -0.03270377963781357, 0.01515602134168148, -0.05634865164756775, -0.07390164583921432, -0.023646928369998932, 0.011325276456773281, -0.032606784254312515, -0.04056622087955475, 0.038268573582172394, -0.0885649174451828, -0.04501967504620552, 0.02417779341340065, -0.025286182761192322, -0.014795935712754726, 0.028033247217535973, 0.0031178032513707876, -0.025704650208353996, -0.018816212192177773, 0.0383744016289711, -0.022256432101130486, 0.02436247281730175, 0.028264330700039864, -0.039765749126672745, -0.06332958489656448, -0.006000287365168333, 0.04266629368066788, 0.07278268039226532, 0.024158358573913574, -0.06242867931723595, -0.029123403131961823, -0.020794933661818504, 0.06286583095788956, -0.08209457993507385, -0.023523695766925812, 0.0018588301027193666, -0.03930925950407982, 0.003106106771156192, 0.002713702851906419, -0.03702227771282196, 0.013494715094566345, -0.010895613580942154, 0.005782263819128275, 0.02736121229827404, 0.03220512345433235, -0.004702685866504908, -0.013453184626996517, -0.0495741069316864, -0.0031854647677391768, -0.025827009230852127, -0.006094355136156082, -0.003597631584852934, 0.03992457687854767, -0.05627954751253128, -0.06720048189163208, 0.07200739532709122, 0.06665342301130295, -0.029452988877892494, 0.029139630496501923, 0.02856430970132351, 0.01323701348155737, -0.014179273508489132, -0.024353502318263054, -0.0025955538731068373, 0.0010100858053192496, 0.017162736505270004, 0.010920176282525063, -0.027579346671700478, 0.030604960396885872, -0.0244190264493227, -0.04784322530031204, 0.027031103149056435, 0.031977493315935135, 0.01259414292871952, 0.016480552032589912, -0.03754277154803276, -0.05239778012037277, -0.04381931200623512, 0.048528268933296204, -0.0022576821502298117, -0.010957283899188042, -0.019218560308218002, 0.010417173616588116, 0.05093105137348175, 0.056801918894052505, -0.028965922072529793, -0.04198114946484566, -0.025831785053014755, 0.0391647070646286, -0.018594475463032722, 0.022680629044771194, -0.03940802067518234, -0.035210419446229935, -0.00288001517765224, -0.025626936927437782, -0.008771752007305622, 0.002532397164031863, -0.030368873849511147, -0.02593788504600525, -0.039453618228435516, -0.008766526356339455, -0.03840634971857071, -0.01829967088997364, -0.05889196693897247, 0.00906058494001627, -0.022698989138007164, -0.023479489609599113, 0.030219364911317825, -0.04225587099790573, -0.050735946744680405, 0.05771636590361595, 0.05466518551111221, -0.006023293361067772, 0.009345327503979206, 0.01473364420235157, 0.004897346720099449, -0.03769003599882126, -0.02082577534019947, 0.009788459166884422, -0.04008384048938751, -0.0535648874938488, 0.034740496426820755, -0.01736660674214363, -0.004540307447314262, -0.006549981888383627, -0.061294615268707275, 0.015560111030936241, -0.005944277625530958, 0.00888859387487173, -0.002308961469680071, 0.03417772799730301, 0.030891181901097298, -0.05142476037144661, -0.008434692397713661, -0.033926576375961304, -0.03471764177083969, -0.08382795751094818, 0.037457238882780075, -0.040898244827985764, -0.04308442398905754, -0.06816257536411285, 0.00223765941336751, -0.0002608670329209417, 0.002430934924632311, 0.022568712010979652, 0.011399343609809875, -0.020425986498594284, 0.021590877324342728, -0.06060405075550079, 0.006306143943220377, 0.05643085762858391, 0.017474761232733727, 0.011342204175889492, -0.017443552613258362, -0.010724926367402077, 0.005290053319185972, -0.03767802566289902, -0.010071155615150928, -0.0350571870803833, -0.012696216814219952, 0.03528544679284096, -0.0014424953842535615, -0.09273750334978104, 0.007966611534357071, -0.04055623337626457, -0.025190142914652824, -0.02389564923942089, -0.06426847726106644, -0.006365897133946419, 0.040524136275053024, -0.014218737371265888, 0.009096594527363777, 0.038178183138370514, 0.06771021336317062, 0.06575969606637955, 0.006190769840031862, 0.036424871534109116, 0.015510080382227898, -0.09520352631807327, 0.06284048408269882, 0.02251400612294674, 0.05025269836187363, 0.047405458986759186, 0.050428807735443115, -0.03647294268012047, -0.018889574334025383, -0.033204078674316406, 0.04428750276565552, 0.00876726396381855, -0.007440251763910055, -0.04004734009504318, -0.007943704724311829, -0.029095932841300964, -0.06575575470924377, -0.0038647556211799383, -0.03352898731827736, -0.022028718143701553, 0.0015846968162804842, -0.041870880872011185, 0.04459288716316223, -0.04328524321317673, -0.04738481715321541, -0.03915883228182793, -0.008600392378866673, 0.031506266444921494, -0.01602521911263466, -0.05277116224169731, -0.02378152124583721, -0.020988700911402702, 0.04698909819126129, -0.031196443364024162, -0.03748135268688202, -0.005430882330983877, -0.05210272595286369, -0.02287696860730648, -0.022090159356594086, 0.0007326769409701228, 0.045096080750226974, -0.05888165906071663, -0.0011921091936528683, -0.03557543084025383, 0.017622562125325203, 0.01728062517940998, 0.042235128581523895, -0.032339613884687424, 0.02492976374924183, 0.02844575233757496, 0.0006522749317809939, 0.006010585464537144, -0.051351215690374374, -0.002057293662801385, -0.03811459615826607, 0.010625592432916164, 0.0012856059474870563, 0.026925846934318542, -0.022511867806315422, -0.030197354033589363, -0.0334230437874794, -0.01447477750480175, -0.03279868885874748, 0.027238918468356133, 0.057131409645080566, 0.008856849744915962, 0.006193199194967747, -0.03833529353141785, -0.06635729223489761, -0.04603350907564163, -0.04006437212228775, -0.03610548377037048, -0.02647816576063633, -0.040075384080410004, -0.04586339369416237, -0.06120331957936287, 0.007517153397202492, -0.02168833650648594, -0.07092069089412689, -0.07205935567617416, -0.052796199917793274, -0.05468582361936569, -0.045340828597545624, 0.006140117067843676, 0.01130622811615467, 0.02118414267897606, -0.02258349396288395, 0.011531483381986618, -0.017333416268229485, 0.009882716462016106, -0.0762304961681366, -0.036427564918994904, 0.013201410882174969, 0.006153642665594816, -0.012172717601060867, 0.03325213864445686, 0.012059999629855156, -0.03650549426674843, 0.04932917281985283, 0.008652015589177608, 0.014044765383005142, -0.052921097725629807, 0.06107747554779053, 0.015158327296376228, 0.031631454825401306, -0.022063594311475754, -0.0573892667889595, 0.003232133574783802, -0.04128384217619896, -0.05818935111165047, -0.025964071974158287, 0.012336651794612408, 0.057143114507198334, -0.02455410175025463, -0.042049188166856766, -0.023348167538642883, -0.009538673795759678, 0.04326234757900238, -0.0053143370896577835, 0.03343653306365013, 0.00013833427510689944, -0.007727622054517269, -0.049230072647333145, -0.04250035434961319, -0.0052884602919220924, 0.048608388751745224, -0.0435856357216835, -0.0707709863781929, -0.04337961971759796, 0.06048506125807762, -0.0857788547873497, 0.06469612568616867, 0.04232730716466904, 0.07267117500305176, 0.02842569351196289, 0.046163689345121384, 0.015687495470046997, 0.0014493003254756331, 0.044987477362155914, 0.024657104164361954, 0.026806162670254707, 0.0019021396292373538, 0.07245727628469467, -0.03855528682470322, -0.023285778239369392, 0.017525356262922287, -0.05224870890378952, -0.05181162431836128, 0.028861507773399353, 0.041370783001184464, 0.030456330627202988, 0.0546095035970211, -0.028637254610657692, -0.01403468381613493, 0.0368693508207798, 0.05336405709385872, -0.03952918201684952, -0.05492530018091202, -0.013882565312087536, -0.05571097135543823, 0.023305898532271385, -0.03269658610224724, -0.03377785533666611, -0.034030482172966, -0.0005837962962687016, 0.0013449635589495301, -0.029753975570201874, 0.07606443762779236, 0.0208850409835577, 0.02117306739091873, 0.017537932842969894, 0.052284494042396545, 0.029257502406835556, 0.06190354377031326, -0.019657697528600693, 0.0290388036519289, -0.020437121391296387, -0.009790891781449318, -0.023682851344347, -0.013164888136088848, -0.00868098996579647, -0.008432505652308464, -0.031571827828884125, -0.05650180205702782, -0.04274208843708038, -0.009459619410336018, -0.00487383222207427, 0.025181962177157402, -0.06936796754598618, -0.006991177331656218, -0.046254366636276245, 0.01757933758199215, -0.0316876582801342, -0.04285912960767746, 0.0672386884689331, -0.07428503036499023, 0.03738103434443474, -0.02147075906395912, 0.007719533517956734, -0.004683144856244326, -0.051033712923526764, 0.01395933423191309, -0.06717200577259064, -0.004412399604916573, -0.027006737887859344, 0.04386288672685623, 0.014826399274170399, 0.030328845605254173, -0.05476053059101105, -0.014499044045805931, -0.007362441625446081, 0.0028116023167967796, -0.018421560525894165, 0.02112814225256443, 0.01849999837577343, -0.02700263448059559, 0.058691851794719696, 0.021400142461061478, 0.026575038209557533, 0.03146746754646301, -0.01143661979585886, 0.0763297900557518, -0.02295042760670185, 0.016428424045443535, -0.025376271456480026, -0.03349684923887253, 0.037183817476034164, -0.01571897603571415, -0.01749083213508129, -0.023062098771333694, -0.014651810750365257, 0.018997929990291595, -0.037165891379117966, -0.009590093977749348, -0.03678276017308235, -0.030817493796348572, 0.018717270344495773, -0.001613060012459755, -0.0357174389064312, 0.021721251308918, 0.012818532064557076, -0.0028558289632201195, 0.051146939396858215, 0.04091082513332367, -0.003436579369008541, 0.013641114346683025, -0.044098496437072754, -0.018652325496077538, -0.028552250936627388, -0.06054023280739784, 0.01161637157201767, -0.037486959248781204, -0.03762168809771538, -0.020011400803923607, 0.04829339310526848, 0.039428018033504486, 0.030306745320558548, -0.08981150388717651, 0.011146046221256256, 0.02202364057302475, 0.012283485382795334, 0.013323288410902023, 0.03899916261434555, 0.010819373652338982, 0.027988534420728683, -0.03303861618041992, -0.042360082268714905, 0.02762373723089695, 0.02980608306825161, -0.03630391135811806, -0.019706230610609055, -0.009937609545886517, -0.027417855337262154, 0.06745800375938416, -0.011593659408390522, -0.049700696021318436, -0.028204258531332016, 0.013434367254376411, -0.006025105249136686, -0.003953505307435989, 0.04790307208895683, 0.0253592599183321, -0.015552827157080173, -0.024370793253183365, -0.0055965520441532135, -0.0037674992345273495, -0.03034711442887783, 0.012525813654065132, 0.022255439311265945, -0.02419425919651985, 0.05411488562822342, -0.043914489448070526, -0.029776262119412422, -0.005610242020338774, 0.030511386692523956, 0.02874433435499668, -0.018881840631365776, -0.014032401144504547, -0.05277593061327934, -0.016852520406246185, -0.03251444548368454, 0.00021959515288472176, 0.005025829188525677, 0.050038062036037445, 0.022882500663399696, 0.01607554964721203, 0.02811943180859089, 0.0007735735271126032, -0.016984902322292328, -0.021040957421064377, 0.0423765555024147, -0.04472775384783745, -0.0032845179084688425, -0.02798156440258026, 0.013861793093383312, -0.014608657918870449, 0.03246007114648819, -0.002959993900731206, 0.03726045787334442, -0.04858402535319328, -0.019268613308668137, -0.006522040348500013, -0.07105881720781326, 0.004609278868883848, -0.03584805876016617, 0.029898330569267273, -0.00011405873374314979, 0.009210478514432907, 0.035576995462179184, -0.013108308427035809, 0.048075512051582336, 0.0588672012090683, -0.0010292617371305823, -0.05412188917398453, -0.02479196898639202, 0.07372413575649261, -0.06456989049911499, -0.018546782433986664, -0.07174799591302872, -0.055839382112026215, -0.004990096669644117, -0.0415133573114872, 0.005972716026008129, 0.04413357749581337, 0.0008590245270170271, -0.03125688061118126, 0.04860636219382286, -0.025177190080285072, -0.05143250524997711, 0.029427899047732353, -0.028966454789042473, -0.08124102652072906, -0.05170729383826256, -0.017207225784659386, 0.011305581778287888, 0.04622168466448784, 0.024243131279945374, 0.016920922324061394, -0.007571649271994829, 0.010093367658555508, 0.06808102130889893, 0.07150335609912872, -0.007296999916434288, 0.008061010390520096, 0.012194175273180008, -0.021741261705756187, -0.03975236788392067, -0.04480275511741638, 0.036413926631212234, 0.017200255766510963, 0.07466329634189606, 0.016985906288027763, -0.04066692665219307, 0.013613415881991386, 0.04625082388520241, -0.07155566662549973, -0.020232833921909332, -0.007415770087391138, -0.049071673303842545, 0.005671028513461351, -0.01435815542936325, -0.07245300710201263, -0.015619350597262383, -0.01774570718407631, 0.0003729224263224751, -0.031200004741549492, 0.003295158501714468, -0.02462737448513508, 0.052207101136446, -0.012115438468754292, -0.07021600753068924, -0.021470682695508003, -0.03325540944933891, -0.05788753554224968, 0.032734859734773636, -0.07465948164463043, -0.005375867243856192, 0.010868939571082592, 0.028831176459789276, 0.050746992230415344, 0.046326398849487305, -0.03286204859614372, -0.05861211568117142, 0.01310379896312952, -0.01232321560382843, 0.01796717196702957, 0.016364509239792824, 0.012506798841059208, -0.0024875395465642214, 0.0315612368285656, -0.031612709164619446, 0.000601099047344178, 0.03493038937449455, -0.04030609503388405, 0.015033449977636337, -0.025413362309336662, -0.022544942796230316, -0.040018558502197266, -0.03759487345814705, -0.036841873079538345, 0.006169453263282776, 0.04895205795764923, -0.05636339262127876, -0.025766925886273384, -0.027827877551317215, 0.0035645882599055767, -0.021162133663892746, -0.0028338846750557423, 0.04133736342191696, 0.07419898360967636, -0.002184791024774313, 0.0004230682970955968, 0.04285433515906334, 0.029397809877991676, -0.028238993138074875, -0.047947388142347336, -0.025020889937877655, -0.014777004718780518, -0.011425319127738476, -0.03692863509058952, -0.037905532866716385, -0.002188277430832386, -0.03439008817076683, -0.02123236283659935, 0.03525961562991142, -0.03360971063375473, -0.021454276517033577, -0.07070010155439377, 0.04007697105407715, -0.009367053396999836, -0.022540539503097534, -0.06113599240779877, -0.0023768646642565727, -0.04299052432179451, 0.00603532837703824, -0.013510786928236485, -0.05614633113145828, -0.05702357366681099, 0.04512648284435272, -0.08413862437009811, 0.015227699652314186, -0.007408445701003075, 0.03484753891825676, -0.012673853896558285, -0.012596669606864452, 0.017625486478209496, 0.005569703411310911, -0.028212377801537514, -0.0063317460007965565, 0.02821826934814453, -0.03781702741980553, -0.04241469129920006, 0.010304365307092667, -0.051757846027612686, -0.024025557562708855, 0.01620125025510788, -0.03525836020708084, -0.0040854644030332565, 0.02713407389819622, 0.005713827442377806, -0.025656474754214287, 0.020518144592642784, 0.038667332381010056, -0.018449867144227028, 0.04775206372141838, -0.0431460440158844, 0.04002988338470459, -0.055267516523599625, -0.013708008453249931, 0.029329344630241394, -0.04442867264151573, 0.021840104833245277, 0.0031508575193583965, -0.027802307158708572, 0.03004860319197178, -0.03987782076001167, -0.06232384592294693, 0.0019020229810848832, -0.028368350118398666, 0.02214154414832592, 0.06142687425017357, -0.06633087992668152, 0.011327466927468777, 0.01444530300796032, -0.03128772974014282, -0.02902001328766346, -0.0030077164992690086, 0.04463765025138855, -0.05776681751012802, -0.022633900865912437, -0.0631074532866478, 0.0267029982060194, -0.04188752919435501, -0.005712634883821011, -0.04100780189037323, 0.06409810483455658, -0.022203853353857994, -0.005694717168807983, -0.0616627112030983, -0.032962191849946976, -0.01781586743891239, -0.06867789477109909, -0.03326830267906189, -0.036430474370718, 0.03972579911351204, -0.040760260075330734, -0.0372370220720768, -0.014782247133553028, 0.0006248310673981905, 0.0017627297202125192, 0.030374955385923386, 0.015746207907795906, 0.03755846992135048, -0.01929316855967045, 0.06307277083396912, -0.011734004132449627, 0.00467431265860796, -0.029237177222967148, 0.0258779413998127, 0.01415109634399414, 0.013658715412020683, 0.023614604026079178, -0.034892525523900986, 0.03456501290202141, -0.06677767634391785, -0.03150959312915802, 0.018003692850470543, -0.03739094361662865, -0.05176838859915733, -0.04417059198021889, -0.004317151848226786, -0.07178190350532532, -0.051147498190402985 ]
We find that, in the mesoscopic regime, modification of the material's surface can induce an extensive change of the material's magnetic moment. In other words, perturbation of order $N^2$ atoms on the surface of a 3-dimensional solid can change the magnetic moment proportionally to $N^3$. When the solid's surface is perturbed, it triggers two changes in the magnetization. One arises from variations of the electron wavefunction and energy, while the other arises from a modification in the kinetic angular momentum operator. In the macroscopic regime of our model, these two bulk effects cancel each other, resulting in no impact of the surface perturbation on the magnetization - consistent with prior work. In the mesoscopic regime, we find a departure from this behavior, as the cancelation of two terms is not complete.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03957v3
[ -0.06877663731575012, -0.0162156131118536, 0.015709422528743744, 0.0023138714022934437, 0.019544502720236778, 0.018082905560731888, -0.029737912118434906, 0.02637437917292118, -0.017256958410143852, -0.007818604819476604, 0.02508004754781723, -0.03619169071316719, -0.006882306654006243, -0.04936116933822632, -0.008199800737202168, 0.01503989938646555, 0.0723809003829956, 0.02956518903374672, -0.014549807645380497, 0.0514642708003521, -0.007434934843331575, -0.028608741238713264, -0.03671136870980263, 0.0727839320898056, -0.05461008474230766, -0.04518565163016319, -0.05848259851336479, 0.005857893731445074, -0.025840597227215767, 0.008524390868842602, 0.044961173087358475, -0.020996902137994766, 0.00971369631588459, -0.017636435106396675, -0.049949295818805695, -0.02284766361117363, -0.011468619108200073, 0.029754383489489555, 0.003976439591497183, -0.03959924727678299, -0.0021303172688931227, -0.03630070388317108, -0.01959145814180374, 0.022959517315030098, -0.034807659685611725, -0.06068597361445427, -0.02876860648393631, 0.019095439463853836, -0.03898783028125763, -0.04134390503168106, 0.045605920255184174, 0.028966957703232765, 0.030084608122706413, 0.055914901196956635, -0.04854651540517807, 0.005510197952389717, -0.029348935931921005, -0.03304208815097809, -0.05888596922159195, -0.0170820914208889, 0.04186420887708664, -0.04970242828130722, -0.000283743574982509, -0.05508740618824959, -0.06306570023298264, -0.01842687651515007, -0.021272800862789154, -0.05924421548843384, -0.021107560023665428, -0.07701372355222702, 0.013423208147287369, -0.07535551488399506, 0.029806924983859062, 0.00783400796353817, -0.04681513085961342, -0.01722610555589199, -0.04439492151141167, 0.027469011023640633, -0.03630203381180763, 0.023339543491601944, 0.0049309078603982925, 0.00075319386087358, -0.0025007135700434446, 0.014671054668724537, 0.05305755138397217, 0.035946089774370193, 0.019957978278398514, -0.024599913507699966, 0.013493492268025875, -0.06263665109872818, 0.02031085267663002, -0.06566215306520462, -0.05360202118754387, -0.04387872666120529, 0.008223151788115501, -0.06482487171888351, 0.0016205983702093363, 0.03814059495925903, 0.024553941562771797, -0.027189023792743683, 0.01874913088977337, -0.04950743168592453, -0.03490663692355156, -0.019692035391926765, -0.0025970989372581244, -0.0664757788181305, -0.015064120292663574, 0.008662056177854538, -0.03746138513088226, 0.022116830572485924, -0.002033319091424346, 0.013900700025260448, 0.018609654158353806, -0.03440015763044357, -0.05093079060316086, -0.06247302144765854, 0.014228704385459423, 0.03509063273668289, -0.007467573042958975, 0.007682546507567167, -0.025374457240104675, 0.02940986678004265, 0.013588376343250275, 0.008613147772848606, 0.0069107902236282825, 0.01845788024365902, 0.06684843450784683, -0.019795889034867287, 0.010708569549024105, -0.033355437219142914, -0.06438998878002167, 0.02475622296333313, 0.024645434692502022, -0.04800904542207718, 0.043067045509815216, 0.006148193497210741, 0.005697113461792469, -0.009313786402344704, -0.00027593891718424857, 0.035665132105350494, 0.013693979009985924, -0.03352154791355133, 0.02926880121231079, 0.014174502342939377, 0.022760115563869476, -0.04182995855808258, -0.07388866692781448, 0.014820655807852745, 0.008128230459988117, -0.010505776852369308, 0.023869121447205544, -0.032904431223869324, 0.0035082618705928326, -0.008729290217161179, 0.0219840370118618, -0.025660216808319092, 0.010558814741671085, 0.021087737753987312, -0.041078630834817886, -0.031720828264951706, -0.02836046740412712, -0.0238270852714777, 0.023568319156765938, -0.06676468998193741, 0.0074798595160245895, -0.02724882960319519, 0.05900493636727333, -0.016947178170084953, -0.02287796139717102, 0.0056780665181577206, 0.02916654758155346, 0.011719698086380959, 0.03588476777076721, -0.05758843570947647, -0.013468963094055653, -0.018374288454651833, -0.03867686912417412, -0.018057290464639664, -0.034366264939308167, -0.022274058312177658, -0.001445230795070529, -0.02608993649482727, -0.06488785147666931, -0.01813310943543911, -0.04597582668066025, -0.01986824721097946, -0.06892608106136322, 0.045559920370578766, 0.023056000471115112, 0.018459666520357132, -0.009009874425828457, -0.04220116510987282, 0.0682373121380806, -0.01896146684885025, -0.0695914626121521, 0.0017408626154065132, 0.03760736435651779, -0.01916266791522503, 0.031101778149604797, 0.03383897989988327, -0.06641516089439392, -0.006042557302862406, -0.03648437187075615, -0.04090499132871628, -0.014499177224934101, -0.07529216259717941, -0.001747200614772737, 0.05174854397773743, -0.04825000464916229, -0.05079340189695358, 0.05702853202819824, 0.021956413984298706, -0.013635302893817425, -0.043691813945770264, -0.018091436475515366, -0.05301445350050926, -0.08000928163528442, 0.009841601364314556, 0.012274639680981636, 0.0303507037460804, 0.017631880939006805, -0.004015810787677765, -0.008594944141805172, -0.05072870850563049, -0.002796698361635208, 0.031033413484692574, 0.0493750236928463, -0.027411462739109993, -0.04275643453001976, 0.00973366480320692, 0.03877418488264084, -0.06112264096736908, -0.073021300137043, -0.06410066783428192, -0.011265309527516365, -0.01902449131011963, -0.059862423688173294, -0.006796279922127724, -0.026171637699007988, -0.03477942571043968, -0.015537711791694164, -0.03940949589014053, 0.023864759132266045, 0.038909610360860825, 0.0065024234354496, -0.007879694923758507, -0.0562385618686676, 0.023647358641028404, -0.0595984011888504, -0.010269864462316036, -0.01890050433576107, -0.04178881645202637, -0.02696867845952511, -0.028668595477938652, 0.024098509922623634, 0.014397675171494484, -0.06011410057544708, -0.031447432935237885, 0.008194368332624435, 0.01791834458708763, -0.015287362039089203, 0.04015282168984413, -0.028752155601978302, 0.04583921656012535, -0.015081355348229408, 0.012328208424150944, -0.06567896157503128, -0.051172900944948196, -0.0022687604650855064, -0.021453572437167168, 0.06062735989689827, -0.02349459007382393, 0.043958935886621475, 0.046510275453329086, -0.021935103461146355, -0.06234772503376007, -0.0396091602742672, -0.06406912207603455, 0.01621335558593273, -0.0006876488914713264, 0.06166530027985573, 0.018273605033755302, -0.04869195818901062, -0.05896075442433357, -0.02714272402226925, -0.05046815797686577, -0.000020787645553355105, -0.02368495985865593, -0.031940337270498276, -0.03470977023243904, -0.06862964481115341, -0.03536728769540787, -0.05590697377920151, -0.008545173332095146, -0.029228614643216133, -0.06944391131401062, -0.06417084485292435, -0.02473413199186325, -0.013679237104952335, -0.06802714616060257, -0.04185071587562561, 0.05540872737765312, 0.001972867175936699, 0.04953301325440407, -0.02369423396885395, -0.014488037675619125, -0.003159858053550124, 0.004736799746751785, -0.014926583506166935, -0.019223256036639214, -0.05260848253965378, -0.04235893487930298, -0.07188611477613449, -0.011906567960977554, 0.003448554314672947, 0.01422189362347126, 0.00401295954361558, -0.06629426032304764, 0.011606286279857159, 0.012946679256856441, 0.01174276601523161, -0.03602014482021332, 0.02100616693496704, 0.026147983968257904, -0.0078157102689147, -0.05814313143491745, 0.05898990482091904, 0.06266982853412628, -0.0530313178896904, -0.03193197771906853, -0.07423097640275955, -0.015299889259040356, 0.013715815730392933, -0.04077718406915665, 0.06327395141124725, -0.010347902774810791, -0.04837091639637947, 0.03454304486513138, -0.06223275139927864, 0.017990900203585625, -0.011622668243944645, -0.04281356930732727, 0.001310807536356151, 0.04542175680398941, 0.010330460965633392, -0.03910500183701515, -0.03175883740186691, 0.026936406269669533, 0.053147606551647186, -0.05349934846162796, -0.00988626666367054, -0.03328878805041313, -0.025381669402122498, 0.01857219822704792, -0.014043253846466541, 0.0250005591660738, 0.017207985743880272, 0.056882571429014206, -0.051730383187532425, -0.004683137871325016, -0.03498034179210663, -0.0641627237200737, -0.04960533231496811, 0.01623072661459446, 0.018917670473456383, 0.014118899591267109, 0.05208452790975571, -0.03250390291213989, -0.017382793128490448, -0.04059852659702301, 0.01035288069397211, -0.03372691571712494, -0.023346370086073875, -0.011819095350801945, -0.010814233683049679, -0.044548749923706055, 0.024401584640145302, 0.005573759786784649, -0.05283006653189659, 0.006245599593967199, -0.004923487082123756, -0.026835814118385315, 0.026559283956885338, 0.019131414592266083, 0.017575621604919434, 0.04789716377854347, -0.012033614329993725, 0.013611016795039177, 0.03200453147292137, -0.02572025917470455, 0.03312248736619949, -0.05105847865343094, -0.04818335548043251, 0.04962369427084923, 0.020418183878064156, -0.058157626539468765, -0.05620377138257027, 0.040805209428071976, -0.028932897374033928, -0.03329043090343475, 0.03552024066448212, -0.007648669183254242, 0.0055650328285992146, -0.07235222309827805, -0.04075780138373375, -0.0653892308473587, 0.040980249643325806, 0.006908760406076908, -0.03859272599220276, 0.06977453082799911, 0.003726123832166195, 0.007102581672370434, -0.04089866578578949, -0.02082192711532116, -0.04295557364821434, -0.0290007796138525, -0.00223351432941854, -0.03771043196320534, 0.04308260232210159, -0.054773978888988495, 0.022253427654504776, -0.01943778619170189, 0.04341384023427963, -0.05049768090248108, 0.024232609197497368, -0.02890169806778431, 0.03658421337604523, 0.036022450774908066, 0.036168139427900314, -0.007807237561792135, -0.022448444738984108, -0.05645079165697098, -0.016793131828308105, 0.000051268805691506714, 0.04752836376428604, -0.029848262667655945, 0.04193891957402229, -0.03261546418070793, -0.040928538888692856, -0.0092571210116148, 0.027659762650728226, 0.045573145151138306, -0.03112122416496277, -0.032209958881139755, -0.022444644942879677, 0.023619305342435837, 0.0010286183096468449, -0.029124736785888672, -0.07099340111017227, -0.04227448254823685, -0.06793314963579178, 0.018024588003754616, -0.02202831767499447, -0.024031462147831917, -0.0043525174260139465, 0.013984765857458115, -0.0030146348290145397, 0.011198262684047222, 0.00977251771837473, 0.009404127486050129, 0.03439231216907501, 0.046855323016643524, 0.01417587511241436, -0.008624386973679066, -0.05757267400622368, 0.04285977780818939, 0.0005119186243973672, -0.013695926405489445, 0.03637544810771942, 0.023319046944379807, -0.009102274663746357, 0.05447234585881233, -0.06655600666999817, 0.0502699613571167, 0.007990863174200058, -0.012491594068706036, -0.049079377204179764, -0.012152455747127533, -0.06691425293684006, -0.014619827270507812, -0.013824629597365856, 0.02209545113146305, 0.008625498041510582, 0.013470699079334736, 0.022456059232354164, -0.005795762408524752, -0.04587829113006592, -0.02761259488761425, 0.04853065684437752, -0.025909995660185814, -0.0528315044939518, 0.020239170640707016, 0.03465881571173668, -0.020713234320282936, 0.024420814588665962, 0.038951773196458817, 0.050565075129270554, -0.05731163173913956, -0.05894019454717636, -0.02360103279352188, -0.013802303932607174, -0.0038328703958541155, 0.02193872071802616, -0.06486809253692627, -0.0050702281296253204, 0.015458116307854652, 0.046641960740089417, 0.029740018770098686, 0.05035984516143799, -0.02128051407635212, -0.04220142588019371, 0.03197065740823746, 0.020113203674554825, -0.05939725413918495, 0.0077463965862989426, -0.06631236523389816, 0.008036909624934196, -0.027851488441228867, -0.027838269248604774, 0.052693989127874374, 0.06945691257715225, -0.018176676705479622, 0.021569442003965378, -0.028125878423452377, -0.02824418805539608, 0.06289560347795486, -0.021369071677327156, -0.013015137985348701, -0.024297386407852173, 0.03985883668065071, -0.004473885986953974, -0.0466434583067894, -0.016288913786411285, -0.05377674102783203, -0.06342067569494247, -0.01967495121061802, 0.0006384872831404209, 0.024766433984041214, -0.05132117122411728, -0.011977948248386383, 0.043263811618089676, -0.042940039187669754, 0.018461937084794044, 0.011565263383090496, -0.002695032162591815, -0.03020826168358326, -0.0036071345675736666, 0.020963847637176514, -0.07618547230958939, 0.030321937054395676, 0.06874299794435501, -0.06991003453731537, 0.005671866238117218, -0.04728277400135994, -0.01318111177533865, -0.023239320144057274, -0.021745070815086365, 0.011041580699384212, 0.05418627709150314, -0.04700499400496483, -0.04647299274802208, 0.01704186201095581, -0.037396349012851715, -0.07782378792762756, -0.04178543761372566, 0.024447083473205566, -0.012666703201830387, 0.030266286805272102, -0.012114468961954117, -0.02111717313528061, -0.04481442645192146, -0.004280110355466604, -0.04572989046573639, -0.06261124461889267, -0.03474557399749756, 0.054338838905096054, 0.06537190824747086, -0.0381067730486393, 0.01720241829752922, -0.005598888732492924, -0.03165588527917862, -0.013510570861399174, -0.023122962564229965, -0.027052203193306923, -0.0009935562266036868, 0.024784505367279053, 0.010203217156231403, -0.027768848463892937, -0.009370836429297924, 0.01093919575214386, -0.035583704710006714, -0.023263582959771156, 0.031329892575740814, 0.04389602318406105, 0.03919341415166855, -0.023322956636548042, -0.04956062510609627, 0.023274071514606476, -0.010708962567150593, 0.02422213740646839, -0.04709130898118019, 0.0019568081479519606, -0.0201711468398571, 0.018242966383695602, 0.01371296588331461, -0.027948299422860146, 0.04981733113527298, -0.024159535765647888, -0.06984003633260727, -0.02712659351527691, -0.026578379794955254, 0.0256672240793705, -0.001037722104229033, 0.034601084887981415, 0.0017380672506988049, 0.037352655082941055, -0.010150526650249958, -0.03424353897571564, -0.047767579555511475, 0.04457346722483635, -0.02397768571972847, -0.027084214612841606, 0.004716500639915466, -0.03983660787343979, 0.04295932874083519, -0.006571154575794935, 0.011197928339242935, -0.039788540452718735, -0.05952812731266022, 0.043078500777482986, -0.02532925270497799, 0.008906080387532711, 0.00818178616464138, 0.014625277370214462, -0.029470762237906456, 0.007776621263474226, 0.02198091894388199, -0.027398180216550827, -0.047072429209947586, -0.020579874515533447, -0.04161623492836952, -0.016254667192697525, 0.053567513823509216, -0.03785930201411247, 0.053462885320186615, -0.012361626140773296, 0.01360680628567934, 0.04482557252049446, -0.035873446613550186, 0.040655601769685745, -0.05900677293539047, 0.029939355328679085, 0.018460547551512718, -0.007523593492805958, -0.04647745564579964, -0.017742794007062912, -0.02184063382446766, -0.05785679072141647, -0.023401157930493355, 0.01200712937861681, -0.017204411327838898, -0.025027692317962646, -0.0444515086710453, 0.012300228700041771, 0.04490267112851143, -0.03195129334926605, -0.07558438926935196, 0.030232401564717293, -0.00020644348114728928, 0.03583034500479698, -0.02563384734094143, 0.004689832683652639, -0.05662767216563225, 0.01655368134379387, -0.07557281851768494, -0.03874976933002472, 0.015785442665219307, 0.046647537499666214, 0.016665030270814896, -0.009369977749884129, -0.035699885338544846, -0.032629404217004776, 0.04628613963723183, 0.05622928962111473, -0.005872341338545084, 0.005794377066195011, 0.012267975136637688, 0.017325911670923233, -0.05457419529557228, -0.02213433012366295, 0.059728190302848816, -0.016495760530233383, -0.029898738488554955, 0.023762861266732216, 0.024434754624962807, -0.021458039060235023, -0.014138360507786274, -0.009044905193150043, -0.01796579919755459, 0.03871871531009674, -0.046252354979515076, -0.008633360266685486, -0.04212302714586258, -0.05163261666893959, -0.0063698492012917995, -0.011489017866551876, 0.01823470927774906, -0.005361876450479031, 0.014424611814320087, -0.026752743870019913, -0.055541735142469406, -0.06462253630161285, -0.004277061205357313, 0.022111184895038605, -0.013591340743005276, 0.07101906090974808, -0.06334271281957626, 0.017575690522789955, -0.007649099919945002, -0.024324215948581696, -0.016217423602938652, 0.04315198212862015, 0.03331351280212402, -0.050133705139160156, 0.0312504768371582, -0.06943079829216003, 0.0633348897099495, -0.018306130543351173, -0.017703168094158173, 0.029762689024209976, 0.026657138019800186, -0.06355959922075272, -0.03486848250031471, -0.037900663912296295, -0.002033172408118844, 0.024742107838392258, -0.06935035437345505, -0.01000999752432108, 0.01475146971642971, 0.03178543969988823, 0.02155250869691372, 0.046150609850883484, -0.01297969650477171, 0.04337611049413681, -0.004381201229989529, -0.008088072761893272, -0.04530452936887741, -0.04611389711499214, 0.02947331964969635, 0.0010617633815854788, -0.03229241073131561, -0.027756476774811745, -0.06862969696521759, 0.011110681109130383, -0.007216337602585554, -0.013966206461191177, 0.02604302018880844, -0.032156020402908325, -0.05301525816321373, -0.02311847172677517, -0.03207017108798027, 0.054044514894485474, 0.04632076621055603, -0.04462813958525658, 0.0540064200758934, 0.021283356472849846, -0.015470311976969242, -0.057452309876680374 ]
Multi-array systems are widely used in sonar and radar applications. They can improve communication speeds, target discrimination, and imaging. In the case of a multibeam sonar system that can operate two receiving arrays, we derive new adaptive to improve detection capabilities compared to traditional sonar detection approaches. To do so, we more specifically consider correlated arrays, whose covariance matrices are estimated up to scale factors, and an impulsive clutter. In a partially homogeneous environment, the 2-step Generalized Likelihood ratio Test (GLRT) and Rao approach lead to a generalization of the Adaptive Normalized Matched Filter (ANMF) test and an equivalent numerically simpler detector with a well-established texture Constant False Alarm Rate (CFAR) behavior. Performances are discussed and illustrated with theoretical examples, numerous simulations, and insights into experimental data. Results show that these detectors outperform their competitors and have stronger robustness to environmental unknowns.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17979v2
[ -0.04479864984750748, 0.01150602288544178, 0.034500278532505035, 0.03719460591673851, -0.019149137660861015, -0.024260548874735832, 0.04582653194665909, 0.008429896086454391, -0.038867272436618805, -0.023767990991473198, -0.06706953793764114, 0.006126401014626026, -0.06341397762298584, -0.05072396248579025, -0.056536126881837845, 0.03665447607636452, 0.04443489760160446, -0.0015837892424315214, -0.05340675264596939, 0.07806556671857834, 0.05907377600669861, -0.026073098182678223, -0.06192350015044212, 0.029457388445734978, 0.017545608803629875, 0.026265090331435204, 0.010872471146285534, 0.04265265911817551, 0.05021669343113899, -0.019205620512366295, 0.06107821315526962, 0.010134093463420868, -0.021305430680513382, -0.05367284268140793, -0.040606968104839325, -0.014067604206502438, -0.014803285710513592, 0.055890608578920364, 0.05100204050540924, -0.030169272795319557, 0.010271197184920311, -0.049942780286073685, -0.06356862187385559, -0.02601506933569908, -0.03600720688700676, 0.012626883573830128, -0.018156368285417557, -0.021771550178527832, -0.017720885574817657, -0.02168058045208454, 0.023679113015532494, -0.018574152141809464, 0.000413204514188692, 0.02919510379433632, -0.01740919053554535, 0.04328974708914757, -0.03661837428808212, 0.0043752677738666534, -0.0674634501338005, 0.017105484381318092, -0.005196652840822935, -0.0405762754380703, 0.04043598100543022, 0.012949371710419655, 0.009860233403742313, 0.03133257478475571, -0.015855394303798676, -0.0568716824054718, -0.015417724847793579, -0.0121891088783741, 0.04533994197845459, -0.017959073185920715, -0.020822731778025627, 0.026642341166734695, -0.06159478425979614, -0.015087723731994629, 0.004529140889644623, 0.009759345091879368, 0.01227054838091135, 0.014277955517172813, -0.026183627545833588, 0.027310969308018684, 0.036722708493471146, 0.056036658585071564, -0.017847523093223572, -0.004367884248495102, 0.055028285831213, -0.027094298973679543, -0.01228893268853426, -0.026154326274991035, 0.04871489852666855, -0.0461835153400898, -0.06748682260513306, -0.016429902985692024, 0.06894394755363464, -0.02958436869084835, 0.03966672345995903, 0.023463018238544464, 0.042659249156713486, -0.005579431541264057, -0.019483856856822968, -0.0109906867146492, -0.024559855461120605, 0.03530528023838997, 0.044651273638010025, -0.017711477354168892, 0.020068179816007614, -0.040160033851861954, -0.048047564923763275, 0.0007688711048103869, -0.03267452493309975, -0.04250049963593483, 0.018388954922556877, -0.05704318732023239, -0.06607510894536972, -0.05675561726093292, 0.03807957097887993, -0.003362705698236823, -0.039989810436964035, 0.02257467620074749, -0.047634635120630264, 0.037519991397857666, 0.0075722262263298035, -0.013663522899150848, -0.040507860481739044, 0.011225474998354912, 0.06812813878059387, 0.018138693645596504, -0.001164688728749752, -0.018598495051264763, -0.018764596432447433, 0.042042866349220276, -0.009206597693264484, -0.03501403331756592, 0.06912517547607422, -0.02063722535967827, -0.02806437760591507, -0.024273891001939774, 0.004131482448428869, -0.02915499545633793, -0.04389579966664314, -0.06701929122209549, 0.06634371727705002, -0.0005420353263616562, 0.03354434669017792, 0.054295409470796585, -0.07789734750986099, -0.040238477289676666, 0.02594568580389023, 0.026771770790219307, -0.00041652756044641137, -0.003246166044846177, 0.014431877993047237, 0.06379106640815735, 0.042543817311525345, 0.00892104022204876, 0.051411814987659454, -0.051301259547472, -0.033873215317726135, 0.027530761435627937, 0.009377126581966877, -0.012039801105856895, 0.010207736864686012, -0.011415212415158749, 0.002109269145876169, 0.00018454357632435858, 0.004092808347195387, -0.0026518525555729866, 0.016118166968226433, 0.009272409602999687, -0.02437068335711956, -0.020914511755108833, -0.01325762365013361, -0.0277384202927351, -0.07106126844882965, -0.004636157304048538, -0.024588819593191147, -0.02804337628185749, -0.05272061750292778, 0.0021181805059313774, 0.025424912571907043, 0.02039770595729351, -0.020550904795527458, 0.03736080229282379, -0.03933906927704811, 0.02881850115954876, -0.08421459794044495, -0.02639627642929554, 0.03770354017615318, 0.010346333496272564, -0.060415975749492645, -0.051259517669677734, 0.024989375844597816, -0.004064351785928011, -0.06043583154678345, -0.0015904833562672138, -0.03252515569329262, -0.03403914347290993, 0.006317446008324623, 0.03423874080181122, -0.08186668157577515, -0.0403066948056221, -0.04976500943303108, -0.00967103336006403, -0.00007881694182287902, -0.061274781823158264, 0.022578103467822075, 0.0023317402228713036, -0.02018805779516697, 0.014789538457989693, 0.0521346852183342, 0.015034959651529789, 0.04956941679120064, 0.039225466549396515, -0.01257264707237482, 0.005404753144830465, -0.08981315046548843, 0.054871439933776855, 0.027424940839409828, 0.015961838886141777, 0.04220382869243622, 0.015233057551085949, 0.024268215522170067, 0.01272575929760933, 0.005476805847138166, 0.03420286998152733, 0.0707627534866333, -0.05743582919239998, -0.06306160241365433, -0.02812235616147518, 0.002454409608617425, -0.032555099576711655, -0.04769798368215561, -0.07495775073766708, -0.04195353761315346, -0.0036731520667672157, -0.02295089326798916, 0.0025961650535464287, -0.011739985086023808, -0.02314588986337185, 0.0029351129196584225, -0.03775443881750107, 0.010098456405103207, -0.024891022592782974, -0.05008958280086517, -0.041511502116918564, -0.02184782177209854, 0.03351018577814102, -0.0346282497048378, -0.009213983081281185, -0.03707451373338699, -0.04927653446793556, -0.050385959446430206, -0.013410978019237518, 0.02011084370315075, 0.03119875304400921, -0.04573284462094307, 0.03524458408355713, -0.027187405154109, 0.07183904200792313, 0.03574047610163689, 0.025624321773648262, -0.06235732510685921, 0.03214741498231888, 0.017832884564995766, -0.030171021819114685, -0.038277629762887955, -0.024660801514983177, 0.033164214342832565, -0.019738906994462013, -0.029273545369505882, 0.05918312072753906, 0.054609525948762894, -0.0020319593604654074, -0.005151886492967606, 0.007580827921628952, -0.043780986219644547, -0.013156499713659286, 0.03161472827196121, 0.056785937398672104, 0.044254790991544724, 0.0006997882155701518, 0.036733873188495636, -0.04292678087949753, -0.02758624404668808, -0.05061570554971695, -0.004495788365602493, -0.06238187849521637, -0.049069806933403015, -0.04374614730477333, -0.08496590703725815, -0.018098069354891777, -0.04619745910167694, -0.005225612781941891, 0.012316587381064892, -0.05908321589231491, -0.03379695490002632, -0.01888641156256199, 0.02330978959798813, -0.02054978907108307, -0.04757549241185188, -0.01959064044058323, 0.0066065662540495396, 0.013930967077612877, -0.0391889289021492, -0.0687253549695015, -0.038494132459163666, -0.010774771682918072, 0.05099623650312424, -0.014207559637725353, -0.0416596494615078, 0.02571365423500538, -0.03837522119283676, 0.02952004224061966, -0.023004667833447456, 0.018917223438620567, 0.0514964759349823, -0.014452063478529453, 0.0077886260114610195, -0.03010505437850952, 0.040218379348516464, 0.007597135379910469, 0.018091322854161263, -0.02762823924422264, -0.014079793356359005, -0.03239189460873604, 0.07117605954408646, 0.021424129605293274, -0.03315187245607376, -0.005806062836199999, 0.03442428261041641, 0.01036345586180687, 0.002341051585972309, 0.012117891572415829, 0.014465954154729843, 0.03902234509587288, -0.007749087177217007, -0.008221342228353024, -0.02523350901901722, -0.00015043842722661793, -0.030715785920619965, 0.027059756219387054, -0.02055445872247219, 0.007168335374444723, 0.046934355050325394, -0.08520478010177612, 0.028702793642878532, 0.013820464722812176, 0.05608382076025009, -0.03261800855398178, 0.02464173547923565, 0.040074724704027176, 0.0035930380690842867, 0.033294349908828735, -0.012208767235279083, 0.03797060623764992, 0.0012065500486642122, 0.026075396686792374, -0.021758388727903366, -0.06547955423593521, 0.00416764197871089, -0.0556262731552124, -0.06089623272418976, -0.0013470514677464962, -0.013328681699931622, 0.0022654025815427303, -0.008205381222069263, -0.07512616366147995, 0.04428023099899292, -0.014492957852780819, 0.012123586609959602, 0.026556439697742462, -0.0456070713698864, 0.055239804089069366, -0.03504592180252075, 0.03041498176753521, 0.006857050117105246, -0.016601400449872017, 0.021151907742023468, -0.07121536880731583, 0.011875133961439133, -0.0567990317940712, 0.02228844165802002, 0.027437439188361168, -0.03635537996888161, 0.022885026410222054, 0.0614507831633091, -0.05554259568452835, 0.042903054505586624, 0.0007961232913658023, -0.0012278452049940825, -0.001196996308863163, 0.01884949393570423, -0.016223538666963577, 0.010478504933416843, -0.05574106052517891, -0.009439007379114628, -0.008779487572610378, -0.048020537942647934, -0.01844817027449608, 0.03345521166920662, -0.012869849801063538, -0.013965075835585594, -0.08489018678665161, -0.012011755257844925, -0.040681641548871994, 0.02021302469074726, -0.03814757242798805, -0.026877090334892273, 0.06492079794406891, -0.05024970322847366, 0.021890508010983467, -0.03808704391121864, 0.027502436190843582, -0.047781601548194885, -0.06598290801048279, 0.018795549869537354, -0.07222006469964981, 0.022640909999608994, -0.048814211040735245, 0.04039453715085983, 0.007509714923799038, -0.034672416746616364, -0.027626914903521538, -0.04356729984283447, 0.000001240951064573892, 0.057401981204748154, 0.04609115421772003, -0.0009202048531733453, 0.03273588418960571, 0.027205541729927063, 0.0038487606216222048, 0.022551948204636574, -0.017854340374469757, 0.020059628412127495, -0.018351608887314796, 0.05355418100953102, -0.032926302403211594, -0.029985511675477028, -0.005971356760710478, -0.010695043951272964, 0.03878481313586235, -0.058344002813100815, -0.03282494097948074, 0.017305802553892136, 0.026522595435380936, -0.0071467990055680275, -0.04461916163563728, -0.051306597888469696, 0.004072811920195818, -0.07401503622531891, -0.03149612247943878, 0.03547116741538048, 0.010191374458372593, -0.006817209534347057, -0.036466918885707855, 0.03990298509597778, 0.010386557318270206, -0.02973266877233982, 0.026957716792821884, 0.010919041000306606, 0.05151008814573288, 0.0038163787685334682, -0.054565224796533585, -0.06243988126516342, 0.0003952535626012832, -0.03299775719642639, -0.02466253936290741, -0.0068184733390808105, -0.008781974203884602, 0.028037503361701965, 0.05881720408797264, -0.07610060274600983, 0.045901451259851456, 0.047892309725284576, -0.04035758227109909, -0.004359850659966469, 0.06270945817232132, -0.0015493949176743627, 0.04131413623690605, -0.026279959827661514, 0.017485156655311584, -0.008104032836854458, -0.03380037844181061, -0.024440547451376915, -0.005497134756296873, -0.04691497981548309, 0.00979329738765955, 0.0307365320622921, 0.0014478403609246016, -0.052008721977472305, 0.029558733105659485, 0.016521338373422623, 0.017412925139069557, -0.05357542261481285, 0.05663945525884628, 0.06082100793719292, -0.0035286664497107267, -0.05395623669028282, 0.03400565683841705, -0.026142258197069168, 0.051195356994867325, 0.018841158598661423, -0.05613959953188896, -0.01799047365784645, 0.01736106537282467, 0.02658054605126381, -0.03340211883187294, 0.014485418796539307, -0.011853001080453396, -0.049721840769052505, 0.014058749191462994, -0.05147962272167206, -0.05454539507627487, -0.042805787175893784, -0.04218003898859024, 0.018776454031467438, -0.0019229395547881722, 0.05407861992716789, 0.023472726345062256, 0.0016445835353806615, -0.01376424077898264, -0.022038400173187256, -0.028888938948512077, -0.04328974708914757, 0.00835425965487957, -0.011219438165426254, 0.07015865296125412, -0.005500397179275751, 0.04749663174152374, 0.027547942474484444, 0.008638032712042332, -0.00045658371527679265, 0.023654496297240257, -0.04665188491344452, 0.02126847766339779, 0.04775186628103256, 0.027354300022125244, -0.03545931354165077, 0.022802310064435005, 0.022678706794977188, -0.05098355561494827, 0.012876264750957489, -0.007768452167510986, -0.0022167612332850695, -0.00642418721690774, 0.014509588479995728, -0.04540577903389931, -0.04239480569958687, 0.02511165477335453, 0.07180636376142502, -0.05383794382214546, 0.00541401281952858, -0.040368132293224335, -0.041622523218393326, 0.03067305125296116, -0.046199049800634384, -0.002637011231854558, 0.01673302613198757, -0.017368044704198837, -0.05394138768315315, 0.04393592104315758, -0.011253156699240208, -0.03716548532247543, -0.019097231328487396, -0.048462964594364166, -0.07226267457008362, -0.03646586462855339, 0.04813063517212868, -0.04093329980969429, -0.004550698678940535, 0.057592567056417465, -0.012569243088364601, -0.004884420428425074, 0.010622947476804256, 0.04928918927907944, 0.06890293955802917, -0.006163470912724733, 0.012576832436025143, 0.01434453297406435, 0.03590937703847885, -0.02410935051739216, -0.02791520766913891, -0.041844140738248825, -0.006659319158643484, 0.008069259114563465, 0.0367056243121624, -0.057561855763196945, -0.022704195231199265, 0.05589915066957474, -0.015347090549767017, 0.03136454522609711, 0.02431657910346985, -0.011979489587247372, 0.031639810651540756, -0.047192614525556564, -0.03250475227832794, 0.03653055429458618, -0.04045585170388222, 0.0031010713428258896, -0.01428957749158144, 0.0018597296439111233, 0.020310794934630394, 0.05157426372170448, 0.015704452991485596, -0.018501490354537964, -0.0025849712546914816, -0.055830229073762894, -0.030763011425733566, 0.01032117661088705, -0.05480304732918739, 0.03352566808462143, 0.032210178673267365, 0.019674032926559448, 0.03398873656988144, 0.054046716541051865, -0.0549534372985363, -0.03959592804312706, -0.022409826517105103, 0.049155429005622864, 0.03111518733203411, -0.00252891075797379, 0.037695012986660004, -0.04434818774461746, -0.034642018377780914, -0.04366276413202286, -0.05212772637605667, 0.010113853961229324, -0.06618443131446838, 0.005389299709349871, 0.02377457730472088, 0.014723099768161774, -0.07154309004545212, 0.020117925480008125, -0.031214486807584763, 0.012880109250545502, 0.017209546640515327, -0.036148544400930405, -0.07145384699106216, -0.013038749806582928, -0.014626318588852882, -0.02755606174468994, 0.03075631894171238, 0.040013961493968964, 0.03789783641695976, -0.04680779203772545, 0.03566703200340271, 0.031545594334602356, 0.005976446438580751, 0.04088365286588669, -0.02369420975446701, -0.05237378552556038, 0.03662785515189171, 0.0012266086414456367, -0.034958042204380035, 0.008282441645860672, -0.03371284529566765, -0.06978153437376022, 0.012518147006630898, 0.011092708446085453, -0.014292962849140167, -0.0024616792798042297, -0.054323289543390274, -0.009079196490347385, -0.0008559838752262294, -0.03783312439918518, -0.05272515118122101, -0.05026434734463692, -0.02350800298154354, -0.06419431418180466, -0.020404353737831116, -0.04703608527779579, -0.0668460801243782, -0.0007270664209499955, -0.08401540666818619, -0.015426697209477425, -0.019611341878771782, 0.06458211690187454, -0.002241159090772271, -0.04735119268298149, -0.012815701775252819, -0.01462693139910698, -0.023861516267061234, -0.013304533436894417, 0.02510271966457367, 0.004076244775205851, 0.026713911443948746, 0.0125138433650136, -0.0751538798213005, -0.06519563496112823, 0.05003558099269867, -0.043348271399736404, 0.008475958369672298, -0.025676680728793144, 0.021534359082579613, 0.027450064197182655, -0.013939091004431248, 0.06314060091972351, -0.014274991117417812, 0.01704378053545952, -0.046328965574502945, 0.011163030751049519, -0.04634098336100578, -0.061601798981428146, 0.0012506683124229312, -0.05520123988389969, 0.009746252559125423, 0.01754690892994404, -0.01897984929382801, -0.01170431263744831, -0.04295801743865013, -0.05223916098475456, 0.014698448590934277, 0.0012421184219419956, -0.035537123680114746, 0.05009566619992256, -0.046045273542404175, -0.011322280392050743, -0.006614479701966047, 0.005915030837059021, -0.0492389015853405, 0.02603650465607643, 0.046279288828372955, -0.04258238524198532, -0.03599216789007187, -0.06668727844953537, 0.03233036771416664, -0.005061871837824583, -0.02915564551949501, -0.04807675629854202, 0.05769064649939537, -0.030168285593390465, -0.02341335453093052, -0.011845249682664871, -0.015457596629858017, -0.027956314384937286, -0.05735224857926369, -0.04920150712132454, -0.04709102213382721, 0.026755357161164284, 0.019206324592232704, 0.010920814238488674, -0.03093067742884159, 0.04145267605781555, -0.01656153053045273, 0.025281518697738647, 0.009315483272075653, 0.02038915455341339, -0.02189096063375473, 0.062001559883356094, 0.027051132172346115, -0.0035879090428352356, -0.04178200289607048, -0.0014560993295162916, -0.026446262374520302, -0.045325685292482376, -0.011381701566278934, 0.004233178682625294, -0.0371231846511364, -0.05054902285337448, -0.020316218957304955, -0.018929749727249146, -0.03931253030896187, -0.03173062205314636, -0.004904190544039011, 0.020159097388386726, -0.011457039974629879, -0.052211686968803406 ]
Event identification is increasingly recognized as crucial for enhancing the reliability, security, and stability of the electric power system. With the growing deployment of Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs) and advancements in data science, there are promising opportunities to explore data-driven event identification via machine learning classification techniques. However, obtaining accurately-labeled eventful PMU data samples remains challenging due to its labor-intensive nature and uncertainty about the event type (class) in real-time. Thus, it is natural to use semi-supervised learning techniques, which make use of both labeled and unlabeled samples. %We propose a novel semi-supervised framework to assess the effectiveness of incorporating unlabeled eventful samples to enhance existing event identification methodologies. We evaluate three categories of classical semi-supervised approaches: (i) self-training, (ii) transductive support vector machines (TSVM), and (iii) graph-based label spreading (LS) method. Our approach characterizes events using physically interpretable features extracted from modal analysis of synthetic eventful PMU data. In particular, we focus on the identification of four event classes whose identification is crucial for grid operations. We have developed and publicly shared a comprehensive Event Identification package which consists of three aspects: data generation, feature extraction, and event identification with limited labels using semi-supervised methodologies. Using this package, we generate and evaluate eventful PMU data for the South Carolina synthetic network. Our evaluation consistently demonstrates that graph-based LS outperforms the other two semi-supervised methods that we consider, and can noticeably improve event identification performance relative to the setting with only a small number of labeled samples.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10095v2
[ 0.003529610577970743, -0.06237754598259926, 0.02826545760035515, 0.002644157502800226, -0.014849825762212276, 0.016358507797122, 0.05037662759423256, 0.025913171470165253, 0.004601492080837488, -0.027575504034757614, -0.05041499808430672, -0.009777041152119637, -0.04672802984714508, -0.030659843236207962, -0.04411426559090614, 0.0024190014228224754, 0.06959851086139679, 0.005497407168149948, -0.05648950859904289, 0.05370011553168297, 0.014517038129270077, -0.03573289141058922, -0.060171905905008316, 0.022738397121429443, 0.03174266219139099, -0.00911099836230278, -0.03656040504574776, -0.047674987465143204, -0.06346186995506287, -0.019859958440065384, 0.029081501066684723, -0.0441170334815979, 0.009118189103901386, -0.0464496836066246, -0.0373348742723465, -0.05415256321430206, -0.024659302085638046, -0.001610012142919004, -0.010334692895412445, -0.05367810279130936, 0.017706872895359993, -0.06286827474832535, -0.04468032717704773, -0.0446641743183136, -0.019479120150208473, -0.001785093336366117, -0.029653921723365784, -0.014742778614163399, -0.07193607836961746, -0.006755306385457516, 0.03982919082045555, -0.01823253184556961, -0.01449105329811573, 0.06333902478218079, -0.018556440249085426, -0.0027321178931742907, -0.03742754086852074, 0.02492613159120083, -0.03866691514849663, 0.004477834329009056, 0.0406200997531414, -0.019812708720564842, -0.013983627781271935, 0.009427516721189022, 0.030448131263256073, 0.04334498569369316, 0.0003699800290632993, -0.04684162884950638, -0.03923163190484047, -0.06738433986902237, 0.05123342573642731, -0.06766614317893982, 0.04593609645962715, -0.027567263692617416, -0.062385935336351395, -0.010105358436703682, -0.03454718738794327, -0.03375520929694176, -0.017318816855549812, 0.015228369273245335, -0.04107231646776199, 0.033322110772132874, 0.01444508321583271, -0.02201754041016102, -0.004172894172370434, -0.055107418447732925, 0.047400325536727905, -0.0033114508260041475, 0.0146602438762784, -0.04229513928294182, 0.047714829444885254, -0.05729991942644119, -0.07111012190580368, -0.05543971806764603, 0.05442475527524948, 0.008291875012218952, 0.06346873939037323, 0.008235870860517025, 0.0236895103007555, -0.04264042526483536, -0.006627861876040697, 0.008912346325814724, -0.05144503340125084, 0.0689375177025795, 0.036723554134368896, -0.037955787032842636, 0.038578975945711136, -0.0007127711432985961, -0.04275268688797951, -0.020180249586701393, -0.019896622747182846, -0.009375016205012798, -0.045526839792728424, -0.07540759444236755, -0.027808984741568565, 0.023741424083709717, 0.046571217477321625, 0.010042077861726284, 0.04150092229247093, -0.0066979932598769665, -0.04871256276965141, 0.02387750707566738, 0.04226633161306381, -0.024701541289687157, -0.04673701152205467, 0.003195843193680048, 0.06942295283079147, -0.004123881459236145, 0.012701715342700481, -0.029632076621055603, -0.040189702063798904, 0.05535447597503662, -0.029492579400539398, 0.04204518347978592, 0.05775817856192589, -0.014727314934134483, -0.03155374526977539, -0.06633933633565903, -0.008285338059067726, -0.04275137186050415, -0.050032392144203186, -0.06858759373426437, -0.010393809527158737, -0.020756971091032028, 0.0060953544452786446, 0.049434274435043335, -0.012424733489751816, -0.004183815326541662, 0.002304238732904196, 0.00993314292281866, 0.008553626015782356, -0.027442190796136856, 0.010969649069011211, 0.02353353053331375, 0.03196515887975693, -0.035826656967401505, 0.051267463713884354, -0.04029449447989464, -0.06761845201253891, 0.0020954746287316084, 0.006512677762657404, -0.03897813335061073, 0.00976522546261549, -0.024662980809807777, 0.007306886371225119, -0.047463830560445786, 0.03279964253306389, -0.006403339095413685, 0.01713418960571289, -0.02361358143389225, -0.059376925230026245, 0.016141384840011597, -0.016389627009630203, -0.03438402712345123, -0.07873506098985672, -0.016258837655186653, 0.013230057433247566, -0.06611507385969162, -0.019197529181838036, -0.012596712447702885, -0.004259916953742504, 0.04620834439992905, -0.03641892597079277, 0.014483731240034103, -0.035607900470495224, 0.03128992021083832, -0.08239961415529251, -0.008330370299518108, 0.022545889019966125, -0.010821844451129436, -0.022779181599617004, -0.0008066374575719237, 0.012852534651756287, -0.008046022616326809, 0.005022608675062656, -0.01988050527870655, -0.0013652286725118756, -0.036682236939668655, 0.036551959812641144, -0.015333243645727634, -0.08944063633680344, -0.005717869848012924, -0.06124189496040344, -0.004512349143624306, -0.0173213928937912, -0.026835808530449867, 0.006392955780029297, -0.038863494992256165, -0.05029528960585594, -0.04322339966893196, 0.0318940132856369, 0.0680016353726387, 0.051011256873607635, 0.0374668687582016, 0.029285293072462082, 0.002731478773057461, -0.09727423638105392, 0.043912436813116074, 0.009340766817331314, 0.003346359357237816, 0.05636207014322281, 0.014895515516400337, -0.024867119267582893, -0.02324584499001503, -0.016296928748488426, 0.055854178965091705, 0.053364891558885574, -0.03574001044034958, -0.02129872515797615, -0.047585178166627884, -0.03462349250912666, -0.02610432170331478, -0.06622105091810226, -0.0670323520898819, -0.009028355590999126, -0.02738194167613983, -0.021593423560261726, 0.062410712242126465, 0.019305966794490814, -0.04644966870546341, -0.019303003326058388, -0.03142144903540611, 0.03764220327138901, -0.025912228971719742, -0.009388460777699947, -0.04274008423089981, -0.006000041030347347, 0.03793789818882942, -0.016984401270747185, 0.003948200959712267, -0.00463070347905159, -0.048286810517311096, 0.0037929455284029245, -0.03820725157856941, 0.0037295983638614416, 0.04314049705862999, -0.04669307917356491, -0.007203233428299427, -0.04201377183198929, 0.04363791272044182, 0.031139850616455078, 0.03828584775328636, -0.04198876768350601, 0.029288392513990402, 0.05391187220811844, -0.006135775242000818, -0.013167766854166985, -0.040336497128009796, 0.02243209071457386, -0.057944368571043015, 0.006883205845952034, 0.0023309621028602123, 0.04329061880707741, -0.021535994485020638, -0.022050688043236732, -0.005044423975050449, -0.006613846868276596, -0.04485904052853584, 0.01010577380657196, 0.031082436442375183, 0.02964102290570736, 0.02004425786435604, 0.022084370255470276, -0.03956294432282448, 0.008342665620148182, -0.019488070160150528, 0.004389655776321888, -0.06949987262487411, -0.05032339319586754, -0.049019791185855865, -0.06750781089067459, 0.0016248119063675404, -0.010170958004891872, -0.028480444103479385, -0.018515612930059433, -0.07366450130939484, -0.058564186096191406, -0.017779933288693428, 0.019381843507289886, 0.007299487479031086, -0.0638783872127533, -0.05023171752691269, 0.01798401214182377, 0.05252531170845032, 0.010119699873030186, -0.07171867042779922, -0.04528377577662468, -0.017381390556693077, 0.01666961796581745, 0.001117646461352706, -0.01571700908243656, 0.03851071745157242, -0.0318034328520298, 0.03854017332196236, -0.01830047182738781, -0.026028577238321304, -0.020938778296113014, 0.023118281736969948, -0.009622227400541306, -0.020006326958537102, 0.03543196991086006, 0.03510715067386627, 0.013501161709427834, -0.05024858936667442, -0.06032092496752739, -0.019641071557998657, 0.06358285993337631, -0.01739337295293808, -0.0346132293343544, -0.03453022986650467, -0.014806652441620827, -0.0035589546896517277, 0.005552498158067465, -0.01642618328332901, 0.054500214755535126, 0.01643364317715168, -0.04179726168513298, -0.04391328617930412, -0.014384590089321136, 0.011557563208043575, -0.04108673334121704, 0.05273575335741043, -0.04716047644615173, -0.010815300978720188, 0.011703618802130222, -0.07945752888917923, 0.04600968956947327, 0.0523904524743557, 0.0758604034781456, 0.03357427194714546, 0.01639268361032009, 0.034405581653118134, 0.016725029796361923, 0.007470197509974241, 0.03107828088104725, 0.031120754778385162, 0.025298483669757843, 0.036099761724472046, -0.019352013245224953, -0.04911036416888237, 0.024182168766856194, -0.04711560904979706, -0.05567144975066185, 0.0023504234850406647, 0.007811561692506075, 0.020173238590359688, 0.016608333215117455, -0.03851410746574402, 0.03421512618660927, 0.0030433922074735165, 0.05435103178024292, 0.03810160234570503, -0.0036740684881806374, 0.028193248435854912, -0.02535087615251541, 0.04064392298460007, 0.01575305685400963, -0.029469428583979607, 0.0010145186679437757, -0.0693032443523407, 0.0013245200971141458, -0.060344673693180084, 0.014942986890673637, 0.03874022886157036, -0.0018691044533625245, 0.014391530305147171, 0.04993207007646561, 0.024465510621666908, 0.05526294186711311, -0.018150653690099716, -0.03591449558734894, 0.009974230080842972, -0.011814515106379986, 0.013619204051792622, -0.028244558721780777, -0.058912623673677444, -0.0006676935008727014, 0.010911840945482254, 0.0034183922689408064, -0.03399266302585602, -0.012637432664632797, -0.051900409162044525, -0.004388617817312479, -0.07304053008556366, 0.0059340717270970345, -0.05556425452232361, 0.021737854927778244, -0.003624347737058997, -0.015646211802959442, 0.04609993100166321, -0.04652922973036766, 0.0005743465153500438, -0.06831629574298859, 0.0037514211144298315, -0.034866515547037125, -0.04619871824979782, -0.03261072561144829, -0.08581284433603287, 0.0016421813052147627, -0.041526053100824356, 0.05969617888331413, -0.024964068084955215, -0.016827313229441643, -0.04482979327440262, -0.016533488407731056, -0.005899067036807537, 0.005679894704371691, 0.03158719092607498, 0.038480352610349655, -0.001261949772015214, -0.0016483927611261606, 0.022388944402337074, -0.009218576364219189, -0.009980866685509682, 0.018626105040311813, -0.018974553793668747, 0.038141168653964996, -0.007425419054925442, -0.024228332564234734, -0.047837935388088226, 0.004557677544653416, 0.08358189463615417, -0.015762316063046455, -0.023832427337765694, 0.00011794205784099177, 0.05308716744184494, -0.04246803745627403, -0.051934923976659775, -0.028563182801008224, -0.020411426201462746, -0.040405187755823135, -0.041581157594919205, 0.03644423559308052, 0.04232103005051613, -0.0192122720181942, 0.011722339317202568, 0.027107127010822296, 0.024054231122136116, 0.049143169075250626, 0.03160124272108078, 0.013133140280842781, -0.014007692225277424, -0.008658505976200104, -0.03678727522492409, -0.04522421583533287, -0.030888807028532028, -0.03966641053557396, 0.02438012883067131, -0.014193079434335232, 0.05510730668902397, 0.03488179296255112, 0.046761855483055115, -0.08263499289751053, 0.05602135881781578, 0.010896041989326477, -0.023776832967996597, 0.0335187129676342, 0.05064378306269646, 0.023170987144112587, 0.05183115229010582, -0.0621720552444458, -0.03428801894187927, 0.05132054165005684, -0.04454188048839569, 0.00005711930134566501, 0.007724626921117306, 0.016818169504404068, -0.014928942546248436, 0.06916938722133636, -0.0027804342098534107, -0.06561057269573212, 0.018154412508010864, 0.05405205115675926, -0.030005162581801414, 0.0019646913278847933, 0.033315110951662064, 0.02526850812137127, -0.004184296354651451, 0.0015157494926825166, 0.022348402068018913, 0.0028351026121526957, -0.010522614233195782, 0.02805020846426487, -0.020033594220876694, -0.04508180171251297, 0.049592502415180206, -0.0239668320864439, -0.012097482569515705, 0.00853909645229578, 0.015715859830379486, 0.0041256132535636425, 0.005818059202283621, 0.0376984104514122, -0.05411743000149727, -0.03703494742512703, -0.02657216601073742, 0.053789637982845306, 0.02999189682304859, 0.05430019274353981, 0.03703659027814865, 0.021224647760391235, -0.019163742661476135, -0.036533862352371216, 0.020404363051056862, -0.023527106270194054, 0.03964975103735924, -0.022319762036204338, 0.03441159799695015, 0.010900279507040977, 0.068376824259758, -0.0013226668816059828, 0.029893944039940834, -0.0012793721398338675, -0.01749982312321663, -0.04818759858608246, 0.004355922341346741, 0.01902765966951847, -0.0026849694550037384, -0.04862133786082268, 0.01067474577575922, 0.0329512320458889, -0.05951601639389992, 0.03146706148982048, 0.014289036393165588, -0.0400436669588089, -0.001920303562656045, 0.029030028730630875, -0.01126187015324831, -0.04451126977801323, 0.028675712645053864, 0.07442926615476608, -0.053692713379859924, -0.014455713331699371, -0.018740404397249222, 0.005861297715455294, 0.015191932208836079, -0.059389032423496246, 0.0027963551692664623, 0.022791506722569466, 0.011580105870962143, -0.05847836658358574, 0.03099668212234974, -0.03277956321835518, -0.08211565017700195, 0.005371082574129105, -0.010622457601130009, -0.07418372482061386, -0.008248871192336082, 0.02302522398531437, -0.02115900069475174, -0.028277084231376648, 0.0456351563334465, -0.02396664023399353, 0.0024469385389238596, -0.015110827051103115, 0.06636375933885574, 0.07928382605314255, 0.01474788784980774, -0.003730830503627658, 0.008266240358352661, -0.03344415873289108, 0.029706662520766258, -0.040112510323524475, -0.024003157392144203, -0.013401898555457592, 0.03114236518740654, -0.017109375447034836, -0.011744676157832146, -0.04476245492696762, 0.061226554214954376, -0.026324601843953133, -0.008553542196750641, 0.019075779244303703, -0.049983106553554535, 0.0215658750385046, -0.043040186166763306, -0.04492489621043205, -0.031376682221889496, -0.019132345914840698, -0.016611779108643532, -0.03293517231941223, 0.01110126730054617, 0.0035818107426166534, 0.021842030808329582, -0.009556770324707031, -0.051536109298467636, 0.017310289666056633, -0.0313473604619503, -0.036642640829086304, 0.005892620887607336, -0.061191048473119736, -0.021205667406320572, 0.022681748494505882, 0.03882337361574173, 0.047527533024549484, 0.03542367368936539, -0.047575678676366806, -0.008731864392757416, 0.030334027484059334, -0.017698053270578384, -0.022522995248436928, 0.03036651387810707, 0.020287394523620605, 0.020092399790883064, -0.008590457029640675, -0.038344427943229675, -0.02727488800883293, -0.03947116434574127, -0.030232632532715797, 0.02587657794356346, -0.0030825224239379168, -0.013630020432174206, -0.056532569229602814, 0.023492788895964622, -0.020175164565443993, 0.010805859230458736, 0.011606140993535519, -0.022518759593367577, -0.0621245875954628, 0.0070678540505468845, -0.015568464994430542, 0.017410118132829666, 0.03573918342590332, 0.05807740241289139, 0.07490988820791245, 0.022488154470920563, 0.04701556637883186, -0.0018705319380387664, 0.02494891732931137, 0.04187704250216484, -0.0492292195558548, 0.0030752120073884726, 0.037257831543684006, -0.0012728854781016707, -0.037138767540454865, -0.010582240298390388, -0.03342999890446663, -0.07712290436029434, -0.03051500953733921, 0.03302337974309921, -0.05056842043995857, -0.023394202813506126, -0.059861473739147186, 0.010135600343346596, 0.023424973711371422, -0.07147742062807083, -0.0731780156493187, 0.018648162484169006, 0.02753593400120735, -0.04358946532011032, 0.019839975982904434, -0.021354500204324722, -0.0678114965558052, -0.004799259826540947, -0.09027766436338425, -0.025169340893626213, 0.018222728744149208, 0.0439513698220253, -0.022052256390452385, -0.020721320062875748, 0.03681507334113121, -0.0376131497323513, 0.014454206451773643, 0.03959865868091583, -0.011253216303884983, -0.00934353843331337, -0.0183542650192976, 0.010025515221059322, -0.05067804455757141, -0.022803595289587975, 0.03972109407186508, -0.024414807558059692, -0.009084594435989857, 0.04896833002567291, 0.02030983939766884, -0.003080503549426794, 0.030670834705233574, 0.03974670544266701, 0.008632924407720566, 0.013709262944757938, -0.0423431359231472, 0.02014317363500595, -0.03357284888625145, -0.06494791060686111, 0.039763398468494415, -0.04606449976563454, -0.0030088245403021574, 0.04172645881772041, -0.01810292713344097, 0.023680880665779114, -0.024926811456680298, -0.04453165456652641, 0.011810630559921265, -0.025068821385502815, 0.002741881413385272, 0.05553701892495155, -0.013666866347193718, 0.013162320479750633, -0.026676738634705544, 0.00833895243704319, -0.024349918588995934, 0.0032933184411376715, 0.040528640151023865, -0.06353462487459183, -0.03183814510703087, -0.0669092908501625, 0.029916338622570038, 0.028046993538737297, -0.0020641516894102097, -0.07686267048120499, 0.08569631725549698, -0.0031931460835039616, -0.05951378121972084, -0.0189975555986166, 0.006969110108911991, -0.06538502126932144, -0.06500553339719772, -0.05947912484407425, -0.032939597964286804, -0.0008565582102164626, -0.013093824498355389, 0.011106506921350956, 0.007327744737267494, 0.052555397152900696, -0.0051315282471477985, 0.02388455532491207, 0.042671166360378265, 0.027412163093686104, -0.04236965253949165, 0.07286708801984787, -0.010405768640339375, 0.04158268868923187, -0.02429005689918995, 0.03642389550805092, 0.003979925997555256, -0.00042060247506015003, 0.0035751531831920147, -0.006359230726957321, 0.011950170621275902, -0.05135587230324745, 0.01643671840429306, 0.0032656346447765827, -0.05663197860121727, -0.015883101150393486, -0.03547179326415062, 0.03227270767092705, -0.022004395723342896, -0.02012856863439083 ]
We present RLLTE: a long-term evolution, extremely modular, and open-source framework for reinforcement learning (RL) research and application. Beyond delivering top-notch algorithm implementations, RLLTE also serves as a toolkit for developing algorithms. More specifically, RLLTE decouples the RL algorithms completely from the exploitation-exploration perspective, providing a large number of components to accelerate algorithm development and evolution. In particular, RLLTE is the first RL framework to build a complete and luxuriant ecosystem, which includes model training, evaluation, deployment, benchmark hub, and large language model (LLM)-empowered copilot. RLLTE is expected to set standards for RL engineering practice and be highly stimulative for industry and academia.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16382v1
[ 0.03120720200240612, -0.030631912872195244, 0.05295941233634949, 0.04472009465098381, -0.04317104443907738, -0.03475220873951912, -0.06376153975725174, -0.0661081075668335, 0.04160361364483833, -0.007652993313968182, -0.01522039994597435, 0.001784801366738975, -0.06551308929920197, -0.00539550231769681, -0.056857574731111526, 0.019615067169070244, 0.060568809509277344, 0.05846212059259415, -0.02231322042644024, 0.009078127332031727, -0.0032489008735865355, -0.014199464581906796, -0.057058174163103104, 0.04453671723604202, 0.040399447083473206, -0.013084624893963337, -0.034002698957920074, -0.0029441926162689924, 0.0021645035594701767, 0.01342428382486105, 0.0680316761136055, -0.02474968507885933, 0.011313053779304028, -0.021552834659814835, -0.049364328384399414, -0.020165765658020973, -0.009419549256563187, 0.014027022756636143, 0.027306364849209785, -0.04244532063603401, -0.009709285572171211, 0.019489139318466187, -0.0446448028087616, 0.031076328828930855, 0.009948085993528366, 0.035979751497507095, -0.05695369094610214, 0.014716465026140213, -0.07933048903942108, -0.05463121831417084, -0.024476824328303337, -0.009002955630421638, -0.017526211217045784, 0.057875365018844604, -0.010228845290839672, 0.0010971060255542397, 0.051283158361911774, -0.006576082203537226, -0.06474380940198898, -0.025964882224798203, 0.006730995140969753, -0.03537081182003021, -0.010893547907471657, 0.024229971691966057, 0.0061954474076628685, 0.02669544890522957, -0.0115650100633502, -0.007738388609141111, 0.01712259091436863, -0.03167674317955971, 0.021998241543769836, -0.053092919290065765, -0.027337586507201195, 0.020827215164899826, -0.01653934456408024, -0.010004302486777306, 0.002688559703528881, -0.039218612015247345, 0.02238111011683941, 0.03324658423662186, -0.048951927572488785, 0.025339582934975624, 0.013400154188275337, 0.055838242173194885, -0.03884292021393776, -0.032315801829099655, 0.04268752038478851, -0.010073686949908733, 0.0264996737241745, 0.024276401847600937, 0.04500524327158928, -0.0005396868218667805, -0.06800650805234909, 0.047960568219423294, 0.05851643905043602, 0.00779220974072814, 0.060209330171346664, 0.024299319833517075, -0.011560681276023388, 0.011171495541930199, -0.025851206853985786, -0.04106368497014046, -0.025419406592845917, 0.04362909495830536, 0.04956250265240669, -0.049981098622083664, 0.04923909530043602, 0.011002310551702976, -0.049331583082675934, -0.001735170022584498, -0.04360749199986458, -0.04838312044739723, 0.07299531251192093, -0.0591680146753788, -0.04121946915984154, -0.020572425797581673, 0.047631923109292984, -0.003996733576059341, -0.0008390831644646823, 0.035044584423303604, -0.06357816606760025, -0.0036582660395652056, 0.037223733961582184, -0.04949277266860008, -0.02825613133609295, -0.05415605008602142, -0.0071480474434792995, 0.029350673779845238, -0.06029720604419708, -0.0032643405720591545, -0.030708547681570053, 0.00023009374854154885, 0.04195163771510124, -0.07735923677682877, 0.014597214758396149, -0.04379433020949364, 0.02078738994896412, -0.059288784861564636, 0.031058156862854958, -0.035663314163684845, -0.0633665919303894, -0.07398803532123566, 0.06278948485851288, -0.05094529688358307, 0.007969860918819904, 0.052060890942811966, -0.0033147099893540144, -0.027570996433496475, -0.004357804544270039, 0.02505091391503811, 0.02572895586490631, -0.01518241036683321, 0.02875557914376259, 0.015453942120075226, 0.03517387434840202, -0.053251128643751144, 0.008462794125080109, -0.04800773039460182, -0.05161915719509125, 0.018942883238196373, 0.013037011958658695, -0.0371587760746479, -0.007398073561489582, -0.021398700773715973, -0.011552657000720501, 0.015816891565918922, 0.05247589200735092, 0.009577516466379166, -0.028241053223609924, 0.045534323900938034, -0.028377683833241463, -0.008120495826005936, 0.020168723538517952, 0.011656861752271652, -0.07964539527893066, -0.031697094440460205, -0.007367575541138649, -0.02011212334036827, -0.010141877457499504, -0.02479739859700203, 0.003334619803354144, 0.014964963309466839, -0.0439390167593956, -0.023783084005117416, -0.020981257781386375, 0.000007618731160619063, -0.03220857307314873, -0.03153487667441368, 0.0020526961889117956, 0.010420563630759716, -0.05906934663653374, 0.0014286458026617765, 0.00796523317694664, -0.022984642535448074, -0.007491633761674166, -0.013880365528166294, 0.014141745865345001, -0.06915616989135742, -0.021104423329234123, 0.04103110730648041, -0.077039934694767, 0.04019105061888695, -0.05517168715596199, -0.05648870766162872, 0.00931158009916544, -0.06802148371934891, 0.02327822893857956, 0.030641034245491028, -0.05259238928556442, -0.015851246193051338, -0.0388113297522068, 0.03290659561753273, 0.07381053268909454, 0.023263776674866676, 0.028836773708462715, 0.012667416594922543, -0.10223197191953659, 0.03937670961022377, 0.003855073358863592, -0.0055276183411479, 0.02734408900141716, 0.05738886445760727, 0.018267760053277016, 0.011248179711401463, -0.036559492349624634, 0.008651930838823318, 0.02321537211537361, -0.01965547725558281, -0.07972289621829987, -0.046102482825517654, -0.004779616836458445, -0.06886891275644302, -0.020544661208987236, -0.07495323568582535, -0.045046065002679825, 0.04380986839532852, -0.004148058593273163, 0.03561471030116081, 0.01657632738351822, -0.03538641706109047, -0.039138760417699814, -0.0027290175203233957, -0.03550039231777191, -0.0011469264281913638, -0.075044646859169, -0.06437141448259354, -0.05431456118822098, 0.033912401646375656, -0.020828891545534134, 0.005209736526012421, -0.04391026869416237, -0.005380713380873203, 0.026548495516180992, 0.01136426068842411, -0.014816698618233204, 0.050889644771814346, 0.0007063534576445818, 0.012156865559518337, -0.024931007996201515, 0.011806756258010864, 0.02837482839822769, 0.013003132306039333, -0.051808204501867294, -0.0020630185026675463, 0.03038642182946205, -0.031635038554668427, -0.04645594209432602, 0.009784696623682976, -0.022652670741081238, -0.04208013415336609, 0.0030140364542603493, 0.00030197834712453187, 0.06158202514052391, -0.044204119592905045, -0.03978954628109932, -0.012935190461575985, 0.06746747344732285, 0.010081524029374123, -0.016237689182162285, 0.06656350195407867, 0.01096375659108162, 0.01465696468949318, 0.007573943119496107, -0.07236547023057938, -0.028079818934202194, -0.012361082248389721, -0.04397839680314064, -0.028587793931365013, -0.02800207957625389, -0.013994931243360043, -0.03143133223056793, 0.024350754916667938, -0.029535645619034767, 0.004525992088019848, 0.011095605790615082, -0.045119136571884155, 0.020551659166812897, -0.049724873155355453, 0.03864923119544983, -0.035665594041347504, -0.07193078845739365, -0.06093573942780495, -0.03018064983189106, 0.03698350489139557, -0.027033301070332527, -0.05137477442622185, -0.03617175295948982, -0.01179095171391964, 0.026082051917910576, 0.04318413883447647, -0.06240280717611313, 0.045667946338653564, -0.00031365701579488814, 0.03505531698465347, 0.021030055359005928, 0.023413434624671936, 0.04602847248315811, -0.022077124565839767, -0.06109684333205223, -0.0011999562848359346, -0.04563286527991295, -0.016858983784914017, 0.004370164126157761, -0.013954908587038517, -0.01708337850868702, -0.009742822498083115, 0.01628241315484047, 0.015453312546014786, 0.0023296743165701628, 0.0029023708775639534, -0.0165849681943655, 0.009351569227874279, -0.02430824004113674, 0.01039324514567852, 0.018363259732723236, 0.06068691611289978, -0.03702772781252861, -0.051169127225875854, 0.01915023662149906, -0.05025506764650345, -0.03934681415557861, 0.05723745375871658, -0.0032526920549571514, -0.05076777562499046, 0.06324687600135803, -0.08131011575460434, 0.04780689626932144, 0.05126294493675232, 0.02472228743135929, -0.04795990511775017, 0.01936795935034752, 0.016743622720241547, 0.046017684042453766, 0.023660089820623398, -0.02285374328494072, 0.04839145392179489, 0.045222699642181396, 0.010303935967385769, -0.020560184493660927, 0.00614017341285944, -0.0030766872223466635, -0.05076107755303383, -0.013917799107730389, -0.050413828343153, 0.02550581470131874, 0.02766183204948902, 0.03629074990749359, -0.044713761657476425, -0.00745355524122715, 0.027262389659881592, 0.033088959753513336, 0.05004670470952988, -0.03716030716896057, 0.007073338143527508, -0.031148595735430717, 0.014378655701875687, 0.010399101302027702, -0.025856701657176018, 0.017478976398706436, -0.04642326757311821, -0.0030521713197231293, -0.06469331681728363, 0.024637354537844658, 0.030327290296554565, -0.047941841185092926, 0.005829076282680035, 0.029166029766201973, 0.027092942968010902, 0.05841614678502083, -0.012870951555669308, -0.05928029119968414, -0.002624529181048274, 0.03572497516870499, -0.030294092372059822, -0.030498139560222626, 0.023718412965536118, 0.03506423532962799, 0.008735972456634045, 0.011795124970376492, -0.013002326712012291, -0.009570139460265636, 0.012705464847385883, -0.02864266373217106, -0.014119928702712059, 0.012833831831812859, -0.02651362679898739, 0.02454547956585884, -0.012407916598021984, -0.02518824301660061, 0.03811151906847954, -0.07460960745811462, -0.0030705693643540144, 0.005537080578505993, 0.014028193429112434, -0.05612852796912193, -0.03999421000480652, 0.02069314755499363, -0.05733633041381836, -0.004306579940021038, -0.027758657932281494, 0.016708115115761757, -0.0331643782556057, 0.04376966878771782, -0.047074031084775925, 0.024626614525914192, 0.004431265871971846, 0.05640631914138794, 0.06241776794195175, 0.05932917073369026, 0.0023884400725364685, -0.017543403431773186, 0.00404283357784152, -0.016071747988462448, 0.051422446966171265, -0.03319748863577843, -0.022104615345597267, 0.00992844719439745, 0.0031197790522128344, 0.024961870163679123, -0.016710899770259857, -0.014535128138959408, 0.025266136974096298, -0.06825073808431625, -0.030011380091309547, 0.029055999591946602, 0.054357241839170456, -0.06910286098718643, -0.07774599641561508, -0.012271090410649776, -0.042112044990062714, -0.02430539019405842, -0.03936232998967171, 0.07554490864276886, -0.023483630269765854, -0.03128565102815628, -0.015222367830574512, 0.037385325878858566, 0.019752856343984604, 0.033955663442611694, 0.025026975199580193, -0.01821032539010048, -0.04210005700588226, -0.022977100685238838, 0.02833297662436962, -0.05876943841576576, 0.021304901689291, -0.003095471067354083, 0.01935315877199173, -0.005933599546551704, 0.05552535876631737, 0.007114157546311617, 0.012470194138586521, -0.08720631152391434, -0.022153642028570175, 0.0012707613641396165, -0.015852678567171097, -0.0124336713925004, 0.07577770203351974, 0.022463615983724594, 0.02147722989320755, -0.028621038421988487, 0.03421540930867195, 0.0004180540854576975, -0.01684945821762085, 0.013318431563675404, -0.034523770213127136, -0.014962411485612392, 0.0314665324985981, 0.07009401172399521, -0.013634124770760536, -0.020469345152378082, 0.033111292868852615, 0.042276568710803986, 0.016526613384485245, -0.032422229647636414, 0.05670003592967987, 0.06505393236875534, 0.0322125107049942, -0.005880330223590136, -0.00812570657581091, -0.00322954379953444, -0.025344306603074074, -0.024002553895115852, -0.021605266258120537, -0.02424970641732216, -0.02828090265393257, -0.0191767867654562, -0.02277481183409691, 0.01047412771731615, 0.005000027362257242, 0.033685922622680664, -0.0132477767765522, 0.01050474587827921, -0.022167036309838295, -0.025513526052236557, -0.07063304632902145, -0.018076660111546516, 0.035400163382291794, -0.022856324911117554, 0.027878880500793457, 0.02593955211341381, -0.006462079472839832, -0.03788495436310768, -0.00518953800201416, -0.026433071121573448, 0.021007053554058075, -0.04257499426603317, -0.015136199072003365, -0.03852728754281998, -0.026787282899022102, -0.03131872043013573, 0.011154317297041416, 0.03367599844932556, 0.00485571613535285, -0.008803273551166058, 0.050910916179418564, 0.049392759799957275, -0.06963837891817093, -0.01611923985183239, 0.037845902144908905, -0.00321930437348783, -0.06228458881378174, 0.01882823370397091, -0.008343462832272053, 0.03918125852942467, 0.03646494075655937, 0.043859854340553284, -0.03800501301884651, -0.0257862638682127, -0.038925718516111374, 0.0640500858426094, -0.013870454393327236, -0.016801049932837486, -0.02887994423508644, -0.04344647377729416, 0.03965381160378456, -0.055909186601638794, 0.00699332170188427, 0.02815845236182213, -0.03584509715437889, -0.015694279223680496, 0.05034806951880455, -0.015117005445063114, -0.053894102573394775, 0.013345723040401936, 0.008002893067896366, -0.06953560560941696, -0.008657541126012802, 0.038647666573524475, -0.008199641481041908, -0.028014738112688065, 0.04475419595837593, 0.037031661719083786, -0.019993744790554047, -0.008345999754965305, 0.059490930289030075, 0.07997367531061172, -0.02343771979212761, 0.031159795820713043, 0.01647162064909935, -0.06878615915775299, -0.0031944422516971827, -0.018118323758244514, -0.014641986228525639, 0.01604447141289711, 0.01755901426076889, 0.053954292088747025, -0.061964001506567, 0.027321431785821915, 0.03678291663527489, -0.02892608568072319, -0.020636847242712975, -0.03163214400410652, -0.04779069870710373, 0.032683420926332474, -0.04470525681972504, -0.03931288421154022, -0.0629536360502243, -0.05276486650109291, 0.012882585637271404, -0.037603624165058136, -0.010000667534768581, 0.020898956805467606, -0.02464238554239273, -0.006322988774627447, -0.058602988719940186, -0.017435237765312195, -0.010307038202881813, -0.08088497817516327, -0.0060447752475738525, -0.011156942695379257, 0.012725412845611572, 0.0035555451177060604, 0.010454881936311722, 0.026570504531264305, 0.02851027622818947, -0.002454217057675123, -0.06716325134038925, -0.022023702040314674, -0.05567891523241997, 0.03503553196787834, -0.004630641546100378, -0.009111781604588032, 0.04278254136443138, 0.006209892686456442, -0.04089217633008957, -0.03354524075984955, 0.000748389691580087, -0.047631870955228806, -0.05507563427090645, -0.029536286368966103, -0.010276874527335167, -0.019564110785722733, 0.003859971882775426, -0.01726653426885605, 0.001167187001556158, -0.007423753384500742, -0.028229979798197746, -0.03916967287659645, -0.0303784366697073, 0.0492417998611927, 0.0033573212567716837, -0.04327905923128128, 0.03197120875120163, 0.027356533333659172, 0.008759476244449615, 0.03379177302122116, -0.033626556396484375, 0.027184365317225456, 0.019926149398088455, -0.03376491740345955, -0.019640570506453514, 0.00019008509116247296, -0.025717806071043015, -0.06305161118507385, -0.0193400327116251, -0.05015198513865471, -0.05859532579779625, -0.018574275076389313, 0.04569246619939804, -0.02678597904741764, -0.0029596062377095222, -0.07957574725151062, 0.03675125911831856, -0.004488237202167511, -0.0322064645588398, -0.04589825123548508, 0.02058129757642746, 0.00962414126843214, -0.05797150731086731, -0.0023963875137269497, -0.043892357498407364, -0.04325249046087265, 0.029775256291031837, -0.08362981677055359, 0.0004380055470392108, -0.028672415763139725, 0.014177590608596802, 0.0026532532647252083, 0.020692480728030205, -0.01580449379980564, -0.012605477124452591, 0.01377285085618496, 0.0016243330901488662, -0.001046648365445435, 0.06849569082260132, -0.03659320995211601, 0.001381822396069765, -0.02792172320187092, 0.02995319291949272, 0.016916504129767418, -0.031801868230104446, -0.02726861461997032, 0.003642950439825654, -0.023539233952760696, 0.042791660875082016, 0.024112490937113762, 0.02909998968243599, -0.05747634917497635, -0.003118830034509301, -0.018395768478512764, 0.00043657812057062984, -0.07307671755552292, -0.006797344423830509, 0.02248341590166092, -0.06105143949389458, 0.044838376343250275, 0.045694150030612946, -0.0220588780939579, 0.026628199964761734, 0.01832895539700985, -0.06782235205173492, -0.002434632508084178, -0.08073589950799942, -0.004884007852524519, 0.02608400769531727, -0.0020301067270338535, 0.023765727877616882, -0.019558902829885483, -0.050145965069532394, -0.03927551582455635, 0.027974462136626244, 0.04521197825670242, -0.001908030011691153, 0.014415542595088482, -0.07554755359888077, -0.015488479286432266, -0.0623462051153183, 0.059671446681022644, -0.04701691493391991, 0.06548471748828888, -0.0069507150910794735, -0.027964966371655464, -0.027169043198227882, -0.022244758903980255, -0.039691261947155, -0.02923811599612236, -0.02694045752286911, -0.0742308497428894, 0.047785114496946335, -0.057479213923215866, -0.03444593399763107, 0.019516002386808395, -0.003088688012212515, 0.027232665568590164, -0.02985651232302189, 0.057380836457014084, 0.04709317162632942, -0.03699491545557976, 0.04920288920402527, -0.016224145889282227, 0.028199858963489532, -0.03102278709411621, -0.002040677471086383, 0.030678780749440193, -0.025666261091828346, -0.0651404857635498, -0.0012704008258879185, 0.057627737522125244, -0.036481358110904694, -0.03392186015844345, -0.05137953534722328, -0.010626262985169888, -0.03682132065296173, -0.04393226280808449, 0.03181801736354828, 0.005740873049944639, -0.010847924277186394 ]
Unit testing is a commonly-used approach in software engineering to test the correctness and robustness of written code. Unit tests are tests designed to test small components of a codebase in isolation, such as an individual function or method. Although unit tests have historically been written by human programmers, recent advancements in AI, particularly LLMs, have shown corresponding advances in automatic unit test generation. In this study, we explore the effect of different prompts on the quality of unit tests generated by Code Interpreter, a GPT-4-based LLM, on Python functions provided by the Quixbugs dataset, and we focus on prompting due to the ease with which users can make use of our findings and observations. We find that the quality of the generated unit tests is not sensitive to changes in minor details in the prompts provided. However, we observe that Code Interpreter is often able to effectively identify and correct mistakes in code that it writes, suggesting that providing it runnable code to check the correctness of its outputs would be beneficial, even though we find that it is already often able to generate correctly-formatted unit tests. Our findings suggest that, when prompting models similar to Code Interpreter, it is important to include the basic information necessary to generate unit tests, but minor details are not as important.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00483v1
[ -0.018116790801286697, -0.05960036814212799, 0.01842193678021431, -0.05143033713102341, 0.004846635740250349, 0.02413335070014, -0.03183656185865402, 0.005640788935124874, -0.01894358918070793, -0.015852058306336403, -0.015262393280863762, 0.05234037712216377, -0.04148226976394653, -0.045593101531267166, -0.052952948957681656, -0.04108373075723648, 0.08590676635503769, 0.00994429923593998, -0.03501724824309349, 0.04340090975165367, -0.02204025164246559, -0.004476686008274555, -0.05071423202753067, 0.029854558408260345, -0.0017228360520675778, -0.013256044127047062, -0.01476273126900196, -0.002624401357024908, 0.0014251150423660874, -0.01582009717822075, 0.0634150579571724, -0.005961381830275059, 0.0028745897579938173, -0.03479898348450661, -0.05979973077774048, -0.02350124530494213, -0.03483233600854874, -0.0037299985997378826, 0.03679194673895836, -0.03212258219718933, 0.003900000127032399, -0.045036766678094864, -0.05491049587726593, -0.023716526105999947, -0.040402159094810486, -0.02118968963623047, -0.04270503297448158, 0.01724529080092907, -0.057459756731987, -0.06704501807689667, 0.017152249813079834, -0.02987808920443058, -0.022831343114376068, 0.05665619298815727, -0.04426687955856323, -0.0030120473820716143, -0.004440321587026119, -0.04511106386780739, -0.05217632278800011, -0.04270463436841965, 0.023589227348566055, -0.011930970475077629, -0.05162493884563446, 0.010092566721141338, 0.022405995056033134, 0.02143223024904728, -0.014231002889573574, -0.04969828575849533, -0.01982548087835312, -0.049533795565366745, 0.01070457324385643, -0.07586074620485306, 0.0006086622597649693, 0.0008170317159965634, -0.00989195890724659, -0.02657497487962246, -0.04518972709774971, -0.01767006516456604, 0.0086806146427989, -0.03433066979050636, -0.04358166456222534, 0.01580875553190708, 0.004825094249099493, -0.020703697577118874, 0.025610892102122307, -0.06629662960767746, 0.03999698534607887, 0.019898299127817154, -0.030282357707619667, -0.05684232339262962, 0.03581281006336212, 0.006593773607164621, -0.08662649989128113, 0.009746831841766834, 0.044269125908613205, -0.02095864899456501, 0.048827849328517914, 0.03185294568538666, 0.0053388215601444244, -0.0069357422180473804, -0.0197380892932415, -0.031397171318531036, -0.05360990762710571, 0.05419667810201645, 0.020934652537107468, -0.02222393825650215, -0.005999080836772919, -0.01687641255557537, -0.058066900819540024, 0.0051989005878567696, -0.03354206681251526, -0.027074938639998436, 0.00816196110099554, -0.08425547182559967, -0.07564471662044525, -0.020109890028834343, 0.03638782352209091, -0.0069861928932368755, 0.0033150494564324617, 0.006357859820127487, -0.029238495975732803, 0.042331114411354065, 0.03683728352189064, -0.0042619346641004086, -0.03667396306991577, -0.047616735100746155, 0.00802359078079462, 0.022599192336201668, 0.0012920242734253407, -0.004284474533051252, -0.04384154826402664, -0.002501032780855894, 0.025811083614826202, -0.05059466511011124, 0.08080146461725235, 0.006908860523253679, -0.014715539291501045, -0.04892165586352348, 0.04585700482130051, -0.04600740596652031, -0.040469907224178314, -0.07446231693029404, 0.008906587958335876, -0.02857484295964241, 0.02054639719426632, 0.06116760894656181, -0.0383070707321167, 0.025481607764959335, 0.034207429736852646, 0.03798140957951546, 0.020093118771910667, 0.023124419152736664, 0.005658378358930349, 0.000458070746390149, -0.006822557654231787, -0.0002677194424904883, 0.013973419554531574, -0.030379578471183777, -0.05850323662161827, -0.027926798909902573, -0.006307585164904594, 0.018998702988028526, 0.009552144445478916, -0.03196448087692261, 0.004662328399717808, 0.006247130688279867, 0.04295133799314499, -0.008945396170020103, -0.0004414349386934191, 0.06325072050094604, -0.039590056985616684, -0.00792122632265091, -0.017271192744374275, -0.04660375043749809, -0.05190189555287361, -0.030636444687843323, 0.030253365635871887, -0.03109888732433319, -0.054246991872787476, 0.02336563542485237, -0.0245028268545866, 0.013018635101616383, -0.03393816575407982, -0.013063854537904263, -0.025897245854139328, 0.007478632032871246, -0.07846646755933762, -0.021222731098532677, 0.021742144599556923, 0.02015727199614048, 0.0023853674065321684, -0.0042362455278635025, 0.03426266834139824, -0.031210605055093765, -0.019959719851613045, -0.019562389701604843, 0.01787078194320202, -0.017301641404628754, 0.059200022369623184, 0.04729548096656799, -0.08712323755025864, -0.027564069256186485, -0.04936874285340309, 0.014406213536858559, -0.036920636892318726, -0.06503398716449738, -0.0007848158711567521, 0.04401758313179016, -0.0494350902736187, 0.01961909607052803, 0.05262351036071777, 0.031255174428224564, 0.06983190029859543, 0.017834948375821114, 0.030710162594914436, 0.012378066778182983, -0.09504104405641556, 0.05284903571009636, -0.025756942108273506, 0.01964532770216465, -0.02857706882059574, -0.024466926231980324, -0.036485038697719574, -0.047549013048410416, -0.025439850986003876, 0.04362071305513382, 0.03030765987932682, -0.020445412024855614, -0.0286403838545084, -0.054519638419151306, -0.02501112036406994, 0.0012455551186576486, -0.014227786101400852, -0.0740259438753128, 0.0033205768559128046, -0.0032566755544394255, 0.03426855430006981, 0.04065985605120659, -0.006801657844334841, -0.019305165857076645, -0.04906391724944115, -0.04387981444597244, 0.020648052915930748, -0.011243357323110104, -0.04211580380797386, -0.06346191465854645, 0.0008958264370448887, 0.05304417014122009, 0.009990881197154522, 0.035568587481975555, -0.05512768030166626, -0.03216581046581268, 0.0191387590020895, -0.029571283608675003, 0.03289296105504036, 0.013758060522377491, -0.018878931179642677, 0.0326196625828743, 0.025903023779392242, 0.03718433156609535, 0.014846782200038433, 0.05087115988135338, -0.055440593510866165, 0.025772010907530785, 0.043202683329582214, -0.031222231686115265, -0.0001514161704108119, 0.010225711390376091, -0.020233698189258575, 0.0050083352252841, 0.02220715582370758, 0.004850310273468494, 0.03677402809262276, -0.05535123124718666, -0.007364002522081137, -0.06481118500232697, -0.008622587658464909, -0.004628974013030529, 0.010327327065169811, 0.05561215803027153, 0.028124326840043068, 0.011803115718066692, 0.021413428708910942, -0.07504378259181976, 0.014446273446083069, -0.031214704737067223, -0.02888735570013523, -0.05505692958831787, -0.041251327842473984, -0.034178223460912704, -0.05551104247570038, 0.008686978369951248, -0.03607182949781418, -0.017516551539301872, -0.042371489107608795, -0.02928726002573967, -0.031057415530085564, -0.0018076668493449688, 0.007227030117064714, 0.005092806648463011, -0.06410449743270874, -0.0598299615085125, 0.049422137439250946, -0.03787371143698692, 0.020563896745443344, -0.045060086995363235, -0.04607858136296272, -0.03304816409945488, 0.04016697779297829, -0.006821031216531992, -0.009557845070958138, 0.05218883603811264, -0.019022980704903603, -0.003841354278847575, -0.02030949853360653, 0.020751336589455605, -0.00008914595673559234, 0.024430733174085617, 0.02021208591759205, -0.004537526518106461, -0.03002418391406536, -0.0209425650537014, 0.027662597596645355, -0.06451569497585297, -0.07153034955263138, 0.02717062085866928, 0.036519911140203476, -0.04815685376524925, -0.02042965777218342, -0.032755620777606964, -0.037698131054639816, 0.03444492444396019, 0.009328197687864304, -0.026276202872395515, -0.006445147562772036, 0.03835269436240196, -0.05898560211062431, -0.014844244346022606, -0.025998368859291077, -0.011710871011018753, 0.015694016590714455, -0.0006120650796219707, -0.03736308589577675, -0.048989977687597275, 0.05542939901351929, -0.06565771996974945, -0.032128747552633286, 0.06364649534225464, 0.06513683497905731, -0.03266093507409096, 0.006681439001113176, 0.005365408957004547, 0.044067349284887314, 0.03212995454668999, 0.008719650097191334, 0.024136530235409737, 0.04594842717051506, 0.044147688895463943, -0.027148470282554626, -0.05038692429661751, -0.007006296422332525, -0.013901091180741787, -0.026053624227643013, -0.00829856563359499, 0.028806623071432114, 0.01641290821135044, -0.026822328567504883, -0.04388188198208809, 0.013748745433986187, -0.03467833623290062, 0.04448217153549194, 0.027748363092541695, -0.021910881623625755, 0.004290078766644001, -0.05753174051642418, 0.055480003356933594, 0.006826378405094147, 0.045168839395046234, -0.04784255474805832, -0.027750195935368538, 0.04564477503299713, -0.059103529900312424, 0.010403144173324108, 0.02633712813258171, -0.02245843969285488, 0.05164581537246704, 0.03817862644791603, -0.0084896394982934, 0.04823971912264824, -0.008578927256166935, -0.0081779221072793, -0.021596524864435196, -0.012635624967515469, -0.0008969266200438142, 0.00961156003177166, -0.04505951330065727, -0.010533759370446205, 0.0590871199965477, -0.049174513667821884, 0.03256566449999809, -0.01583070494234562, -0.0012682712404057384, 0.005947870202362537, -0.07884196192026138, 0.015778640285134315, -0.0838247761130333, 0.07040779292583466, -0.03362993523478508, -0.04710863158106804, 0.04668137803673744, -0.042555276304483414, -0.011495725251734257, -0.030154146254062653, 0.019004764035344124, -0.020940326154232025, -0.05556685850024223, -0.011036192998290062, -0.05741693079471588, 0.0020175909157842398, -0.06549710780382156, 0.029890529811382294, 0.004916568752378225, 0.0056263478472828865, -0.02848125994205475, 0.03992875665426254, -0.017676033079624176, -0.0021291649900376797, 0.056150153279304504, 0.006195108871906996, 0.0028034441638737917, -0.04055667668581009, 0.017742734402418137, 0.009874673560261726, -0.014139238744974136, -0.012694142758846283, -0.045048292726278305, 0.005920539144426584, -0.01682198978960514, -0.01623791828751564, -0.008340077474713326, -0.024510229006409645, 0.05444905161857605, -0.033028922975063324, -0.04160171002149582, -0.026230715215206146, 0.02686033770442009, -0.07454191148281097, -0.0784623920917511, -0.00700891949236393, -0.04244803637266159, -0.018861331045627594, -0.039581190794706345, 0.020185552537441254, 0.051467444747686386, -0.03916235268115997, 0.0066548902541399, 0.04291096329689026, 0.03346244618296623, -0.01868603192269802, -0.025286193937063217, 0.04047266021370888, 0.022079866379499435, 0.0005511044291779399, 0.037355463951826096, -0.07347422093153, 0.030219493433833122, -0.0408327542245388, -0.010129023343324661, -0.01752953790128231, 0.046794015914201736, 0.011654585599899292, 0.028103481978178024, -0.08526632934808731, -0.0208844393491745, 0.034798990935087204, -0.01837053894996643, 0.014549560844898224, 0.045233868062496185, -0.017762254923582077, 0.023028811439871788, -0.054667890071868896, -0.004121480509638786, 0.020935572683811188, -0.04284090921282768, -0.026058612391352654, 0.029363803565502167, -0.04611678421497345, -0.02492210641503334, 0.03900681808590889, 0.02390272356569767, -0.05534824728965759, -0.0028580648358911276, 0.03013237752020359, 0.024094711989164352, -0.029382342472672462, 0.0351703017950058, -0.022085372358560562, -0.05561819672584534, -0.05113290622830391, -0.034506604075431824, 0.008400971069931984, -0.03666015341877937, 0.010583736002445221, -0.04005158320069313, 0.02200685255229473, -0.01772560365498066, -0.012871378101408482, -0.018694700673222542, 0.032132893800735474, 0.014198355376720428, -0.00917472317814827, -0.011227983981370926, -0.036477863788604736, -0.06437081098556519, 0.012319758534431458, 0.00818431843072176, 0.02706313505768776, 0.06157324090600014, 0.004756440874189138, 0.04695744439959526, 0.027551492676138878, -0.05057650804519653, -0.05429923161864281, -0.03789879381656647, -0.0009459818247705698, 0.04803149402141571, -0.033808473497629166, -0.014433545991778374, -0.030070634558796883, 0.051403678953647614, 0.005462747998535633, -0.01762690208852291, -0.02922428771853447, 0.039524566382169724, -0.0062978556379675865, 0.019523203372955322, 0.0325038842856884, -0.06237657368183136, -0.04881278797984123, 0.019128305837512016, 0.009615430608391762, -0.029669931158423424, 0.03817911818623543, 0.02739839442074299, -0.015020285733044147, -0.001725108828395605, 0.0465192012488842, -0.02809114009141922, -0.04410134628415108, 0.010020716115832329, 0.04054339602589607, -0.057009946554899216, 0.0020296406000852585, -0.015162925235927105, -0.04294032230973244, 0.04366469755768776, -0.019549643620848656, 0.0002692239067982882, 0.042141593992710114, 0.04035012796521187, -0.05661704018712044, 0.02619127929210663, 0.007499952334910631, -0.08033504337072372, 0.036902111023664474, 0.017960932105779648, -0.07855508476495743, -0.01320841908454895, 0.009618420153856277, 0.003658902132883668, -0.06435234099626541, 0.052561040967702866, 0.0255289189517498, -0.03700164332985878, -0.013566797599196434, 0.040116939693689346, 0.07670626044273376, -0.0372675359249115, 0.004670067224651575, 0.042384687811136246, -0.053927965462207794, 0.026130573824048042, -0.011140196584165096, -0.014262453652918339, 0.020157435908913612, 0.02634589560329914, 0.043351590633392334, -0.03818582370877266, 0.0448274090886116, 0.05722958222031593, -0.027285810559988022, 0.007637720089405775, 0.026395786553621292, -0.020319830626249313, -0.008287182077765465, -0.05874813348054886, -0.0245179682970047, 0.024382155388593674, 0.03091985359787941, 0.018504703417420387, -0.08039887994527817, -0.0025266355369240046, -0.03335287421941757, 0.04382718726992607, -0.008051913231611252, -0.07241558283567429, 0.002517902757972479, 0.012852448038756847, -0.08325687050819397, 0.026738476008176804, -0.05319840461015701, 0.02183130942285061, 0.04019990935921669, -0.024454127997159958, -0.013581635430455208, 0.04620330035686493, -0.027148336172103882, -0.05191565677523613, 0.046829354017972946, -0.03169458359479904, 0.008370294235646725, 0.014379113912582397, 0.0030054592061787844, 0.04274705797433853, 0.052566662430763245, -0.030032966285943985, -0.016839303076267242, -0.01056369673460722, -0.03558371216058731, 0.06536389142274857, -0.03336614370346069, 0.013121791183948517, -0.006617244333028793, 0.0032129015307873487, -0.030989427119493484, 0.008198531344532967, -0.016027910634875298, -0.05990030989050865, -0.06902869045734406, -0.02148395963013172, 0.03089081682264805, -0.050799738615751266, 0.00682017533108592, 0.046569399535655975, 0.04557706043124199, -0.007848231121897697, 0.03141651302576065, 0.0006338890525512397, 0.0337081104516983, 0.01740243472158909, -0.05117016285657883, -0.05066675692796707, 0.026699479669332504, -0.050940338522195816, 0.01856840029358864, -0.005513796117156744, -0.00680934963747859, -0.06717284768819809, 0.009894818998873234, 0.04607227444648743, 0.019463947042822838, -0.02652132883667946, -0.05536505579948425, 0.03839241340756416, 0.012935294769704342, -0.0731215551495552, -0.04747255891561508, -0.025619540363550186, -0.000709790620021522, -0.019333992153406143, 0.027750786393880844, -0.05074187368154526, -0.009508590213954449, 0.02692420780658722, -0.07635267078876495, -0.001646419637836516, 0.004214688204228878, 0.0006818252732045949, 0.01988190971314907, -0.035461582243442535, 0.002486994955688715, -0.057285796850919724, 0.028965456411242485, 0.015002279542386532, 0.0032129110768437386, 0.005488415248692036, 0.0025498606264591217, 0.02604520507156849, -0.06563204526901245, -0.008648931980133057, 0.06556235998868942, -0.04636059328913689, -0.027383802458643913, 0.005613386631011963, -0.005444821435958147, 0.04242869094014168, -0.021405577659606934, 0.03037048876285553, -0.03519248217344284, 0.013620086014270782, -0.059216395020484924, 0.024568652734160423, -0.01874164305627346, -0.05818912759423256, 0.019170532003045082, -0.04135602340102196, 0.02252250164747238, 0.06132922321557999, -0.017101988196372986, 0.015019635669887066, -0.07122517377138138, 0.001090124947950244, 0.027943136170506477, 0.0038396120071411133, -0.05117551237344742, 0.07979614287614822, -0.032279059290885925, -0.016996955499053, -0.029330989345908165, 0.00768340053036809, -0.03424800559878349, 0.008691251277923584, 0.0381394624710083, -0.03932369872927666, 0.01080477423965931, -0.059534553438425064, 0.02344166859984398, 0.03411359712481499, 0.034502606838941574, -0.036603983491659164, 0.08126773685216904, 0.013193544931709766, -0.03291797265410423, -0.037202976644039154, -0.056761883199214935, -0.037031326442956924, -0.06860177963972092, -0.06147504597902298, -0.028684206306934357, -0.021532807499170303, 0.019154606387019157, -0.008698851801455021, -0.03337901458144188, 0.050515349954366684, -0.0003614671586547047, 0.011480743996798992, 0.03803972899913788, 0.011416716501116753, -0.056218523532152176, 0.059669654816389084, 0.010051286779344082, 0.011244705878198147, -0.04883081838488579, 0.029743315652012825, 0.02346774749457836, -0.007012736052274704, 0.015182669274508953, -0.035711999982595444, 0.02282808907330036, -0.04326018691062927, 0.0004712885420303792, 0.04433019459247589, 0.00813145563006401, -0.003958316519856453, -0.03208255022764206, 0.008821879513561726, -0.02460501529276371, -0.03769436106085777 ]
Fano varieties are basic building blocks in geometry - they are `atomic pieces' of mathematical shapes. Recent progress in the classification of Fano varieties involves analysing an invariant called the quantum period. This is a sequence of integers which gives a numerical fingerprint for a Fano variety. It is conjectured that a Fano variety is uniquely determined by its quantum period. If this is true, one should be able to recover geometric properties of a Fano variety directly from its quantum period. We apply machine learning to the question: does the quantum period of X know the dimension of X? Note that there is as yet no theoretical understanding of this. We show that a simple feed-forward neural network can determine the dimension of X with 98% accuracy. Building on this, we establish rigorous asymptotics for the quantum periods of a class of Fano varieties. These asymptotics determine the dimension of X from its quantum period. Our results demonstrate that machine learning can pick out structure from complex mathematical data in situations where we lack theoretical understanding. They also give positive evidence for the conjecture that the quantum period of a Fano variety determines that variety.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05473v1
[ -0.020829593762755394, -0.03439553454518318, 0.007729461416602135, 0.0022963013034313917, 0.009803528897464275, -0.013670898973941803, 0.03494597226381302, 0.01799132488667965, -0.03821711242198944, -0.012518358416855335, -0.048417828977108, -0.04785802587866783, -0.053550928831100464, -0.04145975038409233, -0.07087738066911697, -0.021402183920145035, 0.07770853489637375, 0.053425535559654236, -0.0415986105799675, 0.06164342910051346, 0.016852885484695435, 0.018619505688548088, 0.032044362276792526, 0.017988421022892, 0.014489022083580494, -0.04373642057180405, 0.004918170627206564, 0.004455511458218098, -0.03836170583963394, -0.020698869600892067, 0.0784115344285965, -0.057498060166835785, -0.01676342263817787, -0.04444786533713341, -0.01922735758125782, -0.0209701806306839, 0.003816328477114439, 0.01682964339852333, 0.008869732730090618, -0.022427208721637726, 0.041549619287252426, -0.04118228331208229, -0.011263152584433556, -0.0372755229473114, -0.03236275166273117, -0.022244572639465332, -0.05167204514145851, 0.016302183270454407, -0.06905612349510193, -0.03227199241518974, 0.06377348303794861, -0.02300761081278324, 0.022075163200497627, 0.052021320909261703, -0.028192494064569473, -0.03417441248893738, -0.052541885524988174, 0.00038572255289182067, -0.01769178919494152, 0.027255691587924957, -0.02488420531153679, -0.011896706186234951, 0.039769496768713, -0.02553829364478588, 0.02869148924946785, -0.0017376290634274483, -0.0080280601978302, -0.07509800046682358, -0.027736380696296692, -0.03838516026735306, 0.04590420797467232, -0.05973197892308235, 0.02565774694085121, -0.01312191877514124, -0.0719219222664833, 0.03852884843945503, -0.012546303682029247, -0.01672874577343464, 0.012805238366127014, 0.018186431378126144, -0.0171608105301857, 0.007324334233999252, 0.03113885037600994, -0.02120104618370533, 0.032485511153936386, -0.0374426506459713, 0.06424324959516525, -0.014868639409542084, -0.018341373652219772, -0.07429444789886475, 0.05445544421672821, -0.013197275809943676, -0.0810920000076294, -0.03161749616265297, 0.06958019733428955, -0.02520756423473358, 0.048429153859615326, 0.07014113664627075, -0.013436383567750454, 0.007605459541082382, 0.0009677383350208402, -0.05223407968878746, 0.017675528302788734, 0.018228841945528984, -0.010808602906763554, -0.003620031988248229, 0.008705398999154568, -0.03846686705946922, -0.05630948767066002, 0.05155184492468834, 0.040830761194229126, 0.01166515052318573, -0.00960971973836422, -0.030044864863157272, -0.03978060185909271, -0.06071869656443596, 0.05518179386854172, 0.05304362252354622, 0.0004720022261608392, 0.00633380888029933, -0.0244450606405735, 0.018169177696108818, 0.03440515324473381, 0.006443548947572708, -0.03395744040608406, -0.024001184850931168, 0.04674439877271652, 0.02719959057867527, -0.008599895052611828, -0.02004855126142502, -0.024785403162240982, 0.03392670676112175, 0.0133513193577528, 0.01459935586899519, 0.04471006616950035, -0.018990177661180496, 0.0002838682848960161, -0.07468482851982117, 0.040297772735357285, 0.04666006192564964, -0.04623137414455414, -0.05796137452125549, 0.011243479326367378, -0.004903824534267187, -0.0004489902057684958, 0.01787426322698593, -0.061542779207229614, 0.03334673121571541, 0.07713732123374939, 0.019201040267944336, -0.017468247562646866, -0.002843806752935052, 0.03124282695353031, -0.027521224692463875, -0.00476249773055315, -0.026653533801436424, 0.04314224794507027, 0.007384797092527151, -0.04260888695716858, -0.019028712064027786, 0.019200105220079422, -0.040080081671476364, 0.0076798140071332455, -0.015378924086689949, 0.015598448924720287, -0.014245455153286457, 0.0425262413918972, -0.06071026995778084, -0.01924147456884384, -0.0018468432826921344, -0.06988166272640228, 0.009183702059090137, -0.020941853523254395, -0.03987834230065346, -0.03088906966149807, -0.02825595997273922, -0.023556925356388092, -0.06119685620069504, 0.01243057381361723, 0.029470324516296387, -0.03486885502934456, -0.038833074271678925, -0.04091328755021095, 0.004657841753214598, -0.023951886221766472, 0.03012361377477646, -0.06688299030065536, 0.05248093232512474, 0.03927810862660408, 0.017876043915748596, -0.01965939626097679, -0.04866316542029381, 0.0018286464037373662, -0.026465237140655518, 0.009404469281435013, -0.0009419752168469131, -0.033433422446250916, -0.026087936013936996, -0.018102195113897324, 0.0370599664747715, -0.07405643165111542, -0.036976251751184464, -0.018741974607110023, -0.029797060415148735, -0.025981681421399117, -0.06712675839662552, 0.05037838965654373, 0.008248488418757915, -0.03443334996700287, -0.028414567932486534, 0.06783270835876465, 0.028699668124318123, 0.029654642567038536, -0.0063872127793729305, 0.017857851460576057, -0.023676631972193718, -0.09977893531322479, 0.05293726548552513, -0.02520950324833393, 0.009643372148275375, -0.018078701570630074, 0.03626895323395729, -0.039440326392650604, -0.042266834527254105, -0.02942483499646187, 0.058634351938962936, 0.05286325514316559, 0.03816380724310875, -0.021881291642785072, -0.049760300666093826, -0.034987710416316986, -0.014035535044968128, -0.06860613077878952, -0.01885354146361351, -0.05850760266184807, -0.000051231225370429456, 0.0009851892245933414, 0.04152738302946091, -0.05209096521139145, -0.03665006905794144, -0.04937189817428589, -0.006112910341471434, 0.046279408037662506, -0.028698336333036423, -0.02278199791908264, -0.024598944932222366, -0.003259018762037158, 0.04525412991642952, -0.018594900146126747, -0.0206748154014349, 0.012221629731357098, -0.07912507653236389, 0.0032436472829431295, -0.04497881233692169, -0.0026485761627554893, 0.021699970588088036, -0.02419194020330906, 0.03720754012465477, -0.00788386445492506, 0.038888052105903625, 0.02382293902337551, 0.047418564558029175, -0.05115704610943794, -0.012956068851053715, 0.04393859952688217, -0.010873707942664623, -0.04316950961947441, 0.005750476382672787, 0.011469973251223564, 0.001908401376567781, 0.02033626288175583, 0.03323667123913765, 0.04207003489136696, 0.016338931396603584, -0.05784543603658676, -0.025765080004930496, -0.0022323692683130503, -0.04656234756112099, 0.044520724564790726, -0.002728519029915333, 0.05126326158642769, 0.011625927872955799, -0.020556548610329628, -0.07001206278800964, -0.003838843898847699, -0.015507188625633717, -0.032483380287885666, -0.05120624229311943, -0.048577211797237396, -0.012975665740668774, -0.07614278048276901, -0.0008010647725313902, -0.043839797377586365, -0.058213263750076294, -0.05097205191850662, -0.06164547801017761, -0.023852039128541946, 0.008146784268319607, 0.026531709358096123, -0.04561075195670128, -0.04982726648449898, -0.015834759920835495, 0.03637468069791794, -0.002063772175461054, -0.029502620920538902, -0.0860188752412796, 0.03686363622546196, 0.03352365642786026, -0.007683682255446911, 0.006639835890382528, -0.013652583584189415, 0.011852343566715717, -0.009682564064860344, -0.03643554821610451, 0.006242310628294945, 0.012504943646490574, 0.029060248285531998, -0.022767750546336174, 0.037970125675201416, -0.022736335173249245, 0.011479262262582779, -0.031700026243925095, 0.01667626202106476, -0.027804702520370483, -0.04054887592792511, -0.016004653647542, 0.041745495051145554, 0.00614551454782486, -0.026750948280096054, -0.02122877910733223, -0.048758361488580704, 0.005812371149659157, 0.01783563569188118, -0.00008426528074778616, 0.04137637838721275, 0.034127168357372284, -0.023376449942588806, -0.007420181296765804, -0.06010972335934639, 0.04028940573334694, 0.01579129882156849, 0.0759904533624649, -0.017204424366354942, -0.01501745730638504, 0.017094800248742104, -0.08221437782049179, 0.028940431773662567, 0.03703179582953453, 0.05122599005699158, -0.007820053026080132, 0.020970067009329796, 0.04058631882071495, 0.015608054585754871, -0.006028736475855112, 0.024440985172986984, -0.007337826304137707, 0.025218568742275238, 0.06761986017227173, -0.032324664294719696, -0.048363953828811646, -0.032976362854242325, -0.064014732837677, -0.02912432700395584, 0.001178172416985035, 0.05193253234028816, 0.07205787301063538, 0.029209047555923462, -0.013814888894557953, 0.005957665853202343, -0.04834604263305664, 0.07962881773710251, 0.008039278909564018, -0.0033180757891386747, -0.00463864067569375, -0.05670646205544472, -0.001431967131793499, -0.0032434212043881416, 0.015226710587739944, -0.021241117268800735, -0.0558357872068882, 0.017724687233567238, -0.026019182056188583, 0.001991132739931345, 0.020052721723914146, -0.048144638538360596, -0.0228916984051466, 0.007401340641081333, -0.038502126932144165, 0.018779143691062927, -0.02260432578623295, 0.031390298157930374, -0.008531843312084675, -0.011427992954850197, 0.01977555826306343, 0.020538533106446266, -0.04922093451023102, 0.027406062930822372, -0.002657383680343628, -0.051511503756046295, -0.012548611499369144, -0.015788782387971878, -0.030417313799262047, -0.011396696791052818, -0.07626558095216751, -0.003119667526334524, -0.06868061423301697, 0.0428013801574707, -0.037185221910476685, -0.057655218988657, 0.06358073651790619, 0.0019123402889817953, -0.008385962806642056, -0.026672037318348885, -0.04849613830447197, 0.005450061522424221, -0.0025400137528777122, -0.015227672643959522, -0.06668239086866379, 0.030383717268705368, -0.0551334023475647, 0.029781706631183624, -0.02593640424311161, 0.039183612912893295, -0.04881798475980759, 0.03318823128938675, -0.04859860613942146, 0.015178645960986614, 0.024774199351668358, 0.017640864476561546, 0.012471995316445827, -0.018386445939540863, 0.0018437315011397004, -0.0045290193520486355, 0.002357586519792676, 0.021238861605525017, -0.041670121252536774, 0.015139925293624401, -0.03226117789745331, -0.040934737771749496, -0.03790520504117012, -0.024750040844082832, 0.07381278276443481, -0.038522109389305115, -0.03778435289859772, -0.0039934320375323296, 0.021361589431762695, -0.05631867051124573, -0.057058338075876236, -0.01973113976418972, -0.0332825630903244, -0.07030512392520905, 0.021946139633655548, -0.01305700559169054, 0.015709757804870605, -0.045342881232500076, 0.0013097129995003343, 0.014826354570686817, 0.05365126207470894, -0.03549543768167496, -0.008893807418644428, 0.03408069163560867, 0.014197626151144505, -0.0313316285610199, -0.013457748107612133, -0.05879078432917595, -0.015569671057164669, -0.026665184646844864, -0.05428507179021835, 0.0166025310754776, 0.05145518481731415, -0.01763026788830757, 0.07067487388849258, -0.07920075953006744, 0.05102233961224556, 0.024034442380070686, -0.014171639457345009, 0.026195907965302467, 0.0640936940908432, -0.033629048615694046, 0.01876385696232319, -0.017683574929833412, 0.020463254302740097, -0.025213144719600677, 0.0012744726845994592, 0.018933840095996857, 0.05668177455663681, -0.012263523414731026, 0.011924425140023232, 0.03092247061431408, -0.033363670110702515, -0.05238538607954979, -0.00031872332328930497, -0.005157955456525087, -0.005603977013379335, -0.05950641632080078, 0.024928968399763107, 0.04392578452825546, -0.008371411822736263, -0.05195090174674988, 0.009078171104192734, -0.03229357674717903, 0.004063113126903772, 0.04308659955859184, -0.03904717043042183, -0.0007263197330757976, 0.04703309014439583, 0.013658861629664898, 0.022763166576623917, -0.020560650154948235, -0.007379508577287197, 0.015675552189350128, 0.010793766006827354, 0.021357549354434013, -0.03241739794611931, -0.00874827429652214, -0.003825536696240306, 0.05025149881839752, 0.036958981305360794, 0.03899131715297699, 0.04258587211370468, 0.03559361398220062, 0.02607152983546257, -0.032304685562849045, -0.00598310399800539, 0.0047218650579452515, 0.019063211977481842, -0.015453038737177849, -0.0062026153318583965, -0.0068952590227127075, 0.0739104226231575, 0.01135648600757122, 0.04362479969859123, 0.013421916402876377, 0.019905000925064087, -0.04350363090634346, -0.030647510662674904, -0.0036906853783875704, -0.012059638276696205, -0.059637319296598434, -0.022515667602419853, 0.02591334655880928, 0.006678344216197729, 0.02052774466574192, 0.021682847291231155, -0.005413048900663853, 0.019863059744238853, 0.014035327360033989, 0.01825023628771305, -0.03750162199139595, -0.052520886063575745, 0.08151817321777344, -0.05856645852327347, 0.01217083353549242, -0.02778359316289425, -0.026492683216929436, -0.03902919590473175, -0.04854186996817589, 0.005237729754298925, 0.03226947784423828, -0.02709246426820755, -0.03564460948109627, 0.05069525167346001, 0.03706066310405731, -0.0769132748246193, 0.001721736858598888, 0.06203003600239754, -0.07955503463745117, 0.03278455510735512, 0.006952241063117981, 0.014675840735435486, -0.0662146732211113, 0.04487133026123047, -0.04489981383085251, -0.07676374167203903, -0.029265960678458214, 0.03631174936890602, 0.07497932761907578, -0.05721093341708183, 0.05681704729795456, 0.04440976679325104, -0.004565240815281868, 0.03664742037653923, -0.06611374765634537, 0.0010310773504897952, -0.016495971009135246, 0.042864177376031876, -0.042660634964704514, -0.03074244037270546, 0.015166676603257656, 0.04951054975390434, -0.07078969478607178, -0.011134305037558079, -0.0031929367687553167, -0.009420421905815601, 0.018852684646844864, -0.0578840896487236, -0.0713973343372345, 0.0020224768668413162, 0.0317227840423584, 0.015032729133963585, -0.04191789776086807, -0.020490704104304314, -0.035681165754795074, 0.0092094074934721, -0.028215760365128517, -0.05373000353574753, 0.0005212047835811973, 0.017032571136951447, -0.054384827613830566, -0.011062459088861942, -0.06511448323726654, -0.02856733277440071, 0.00549662858247757, 0.058031558990478516, 0.05233791843056679, 0.03802436217665672, -0.005516533739864826, -0.01043988112360239, -0.007660432253032923, -0.005073246546089649, -0.013665290549397469, -0.0026823633816093206, -0.0014682953478768468, -0.007308966480195522, 0.05616818740963936, -0.06099152937531471, 0.021881399676203728, -0.03965163230895996, -0.051393359899520874, 0.033937718719244, -0.0005695595755241811, -0.02310766652226448, 0.012978870421648026, -0.004371483810245991, -0.03491269424557686, 0.00967844482511282, 0.0282327588647604, -0.027442554011940956, -0.05870354175567627, 0.020263323560357094, -0.010126610286533833, -0.0009455825202167034, 0.012883391231298447, 0.019732723012566566, 0.022942036390304565, 0.018971115350723267, 0.046141576021909714, 0.04736637324094772, 0.029525572434067726, -0.044652022421360016, -0.0486815944314003, -0.005442551802843809, 0.022739244624972343, -0.006498644594103098, -0.004755598958581686, 0.018072595819830894, -0.04732402414083481, -0.07372039556503296, 0.008585034869611263, -0.01498359814286232, 0.01534213311970234, -0.025512589141726494, -0.037567369639873505, 0.05600035935640335, 0.020208952948451042, -0.01910370960831642, -0.08927565813064575, -0.00016991519078146666, -0.015853140503168106, 0.00992317870259285, 0.0015656350878998637, 0.010510524734854698, -0.04490119218826294, 0.018689116463065147, -0.08311744034290314, -0.011317979544401169, -0.028553785756230354, 0.030457479879260063, -0.0138967614620924, -0.0025208289735019207, -0.0006052744574844837, -0.035071343183517456, -0.005201026331633329, 0.0398654006421566, 0.012134329415857792, 0.05276089534163475, 0.019610077142715454, -0.008943598717451096, -0.03147256374359131, 0.003124263370409608, 0.039164356887340546, -0.05719340220093727, 0.0058225225657224655, 0.05517470836639404, 0.03147429972887039, -0.0031147641129791737, 0.010590161196887493, 0.03596999868750572, -0.011988532729446888, 0.039579134434461594, -0.009004415944218636, -0.011526868678629398, -0.0035074674524366856, -0.048662107437849045, 0.04035697132349014, -0.053796641528606415, -0.038040801882743835, 0.00810207985341549, -0.026245851069688797, -0.0021970944944769144, -0.03381843864917755, -0.0563059002161026, 0.031363364309072495, 0.031920500099658966, 0.011644906364381313, 0.07018882781267166, -0.05885306000709534, 0.005704357288777828, 0.018830157816410065, -0.02967626228928566, -0.07056313008069992, -0.0029292344115674496, 0.024723295122385025, -0.058876920491456985, 0.025865472853183746, -0.0634150505065918, 0.022026032209396362, -0.0225470419973135, 0.003117562038823962, 0.0021400221157819033, 0.05191522464156151, -0.01464235782623291, 0.000615293683949858, -0.03154299408197403, -0.03831539675593376, -0.005208779126405716, -0.04935936629772186, -0.010988774709403515, -0.0233131293207407, 0.012369667179882526, 0.01718154549598694, 0.04804769158363342, 0.03585117682814598, 0.07019376754760742, 0.025801165029406548, -0.010078128427267075, -0.008119647391140461, 0.0020278790034353733, -0.07006245851516724, 0.051002323627471924, 0.006807202938944101, 0.016537530347704887, -0.022769315168261528, 0.005036748014390469, -0.022542288526892662, -0.003509949194267392, 0.05289020016789436, 0.038226064294576645, 0.034245651215314865, -0.08508265763521194, -0.015305629931390285, -0.004944672342389822, -0.06043655797839165, -0.035141780972480774, 0.03274727612733841, -0.017106063663959503, -0.049610674381256104, -0.028518684208393097 ]
Online social media have become an important forum for exchanging political opinions. In response to COVID measures citizens expressed their policy preferences directly on these platforms. Quantifying political preferences in online social media remains challenging: The vast amount of content requires scalable automated extraction of political preferences -- however fine grained political preference extraction is difficult with current machine learning (ML) technology, due to the lack of data sets. Here we present a novel data set of tweets with fine grained political preference annotations. A text classification model trained on this data is used to extract policy preferences in a German Twitter corpus ranging from 2019 to 2022. Our results indicate that in response to the COVID pandemic, expression of political opinions increased. Using a well established taxonomy of policy preferences we analyse fine grained political views and highlight changes in distinct political categories. These analyses suggest that the increase in policy preference expression is dominated by the categories pro-welfare, pro-education and pro-governmental administration efficiency. All training data and code used in this study are made publicly available to encourage other researchers to further improve automated policy preference extraction methods. We hope that our findings contribute to a better understanding of political statements in online social media and to a better assessment of how COVID measures impact political preferences.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04444v1
[ 0.016478171572089195, -0.042862147092819214, 0.01797092892229557, -0.008372311480343342, -0.02979329414665699, 0.04092447832226753, 0.015286730602383614, 0.021492155268788338, -0.04397260397672653, -0.0564151257276535, -0.04973963275551796, 0.008573497645556927, -0.016093788668513298, 0.01800530217587948, 0.009022860787808895, 0.020110923796892166, 0.08519645780324936, 0.013570704497396946, -0.04492250084877014, 0.023497821763157845, 0.02399206906557083, 0.017497094348073006, -0.006481747608631849, 0.0667370930314064, 0.036475908011198044, 0.0038251220248639584, -0.015911765396595, -0.0577242411673069, -0.03275586664676666, -0.044551800936460495, 0.05476299673318863, -0.06648987531661987, -0.033930595964193344, -0.05571286752820015, -0.05010440573096275, -0.025604665279388428, -0.016142290085554123, -0.006862994749099016, -0.035257887095212936, -0.04580928757786751, 0.06559024751186371, -0.08072739839553833, -0.06283381581306458, -0.00756812933832407, -0.04015236720442772, 0.012682844884693623, -0.05521157383918762, 0.025434060022234917, -0.08384028822183609, -0.03751656413078308, 0.02589283138513565, -0.013444939628243446, -0.011088237166404724, 0.04956619441509247, -0.060073841363191605, 0.015273665077984333, -0.01941499300301075, -0.004166153725236654, -0.06696302443742752, -0.006491813808679581, 0.026350170373916626, 0.04518691450357437, -0.0004657093377318233, 0.00037438914296217263, -0.0376863069832325, 0.013526244089007378, -0.03574454039335251, -0.06966827809810638, -0.06408252567052841, -0.07905420660972595, 0.057067740708589554, -0.06831948459148407, 0.019841862842440605, -0.0032601631246507168, -0.03803671896457672, 0.03671848401427269, -0.04068398103117943, -0.02867499180138111, 0.024388132616877556, -0.002181438496336341, -0.011516847647726536, 0.004656540229916573, 0.012797847390174866, 0.00853202398866415, -0.030485427007079124, -0.013963883742690086, -0.03057744912803173, 0.022345518693327904, 0.006091619376093149, -0.04434717446565628, 0.029927540570497513, -0.02710569091141224, -0.05949140712618828, -0.0028342469595372677, 0.06569943577051163, -0.04767501354217529, 0.012291080318391323, 0.03081761673092842, -0.00901268981397152, -0.005313228350132704, -0.011584708467125893, 0.005063303746283054, 0.02130504697561264, 0.04228082299232483, 0.01832328923046589, -0.052186284214258194, -0.003745329799130559, -0.00194101023953408, -0.037674032151699066, 0.011416736990213394, -0.021444430574774742, -0.01782587729394436, -0.030727284029126167, -0.0545760802924633, -0.03360771760344505, -0.008507688529789448, 0.03459269180893898, 0.013519614934921265, 0.05327468365430832, -0.004231285769492388, -0.058244891464710236, 0.04612045735120773, 0.020964181050658226, 0.025112377479672432, -0.04686669632792473, -0.012186896055936813, 0.03464670106768608, 0.014160975813865662, -0.02202754281461239, -0.016416557133197784, -0.04749590903520584, 0.04707406833767891, -0.015721241012215614, -0.0056016650050878525, 0.06381480395793915, 0.02364617958664894, -0.0018030409701168537, -0.056166160851716995, 0.0327804759144783, 0.018618298694491386, -0.035801321268081665, -0.05134440213441849, 0.005158644635230303, -0.012567280791699886, -0.020215077325701714, 0.04815635085105896, 0.042292676866054535, 0.012634006328880787, 0.003754369681701064, 0.030756201595067978, 0.048101749271154404, 0.024955883622169495, 0.05282893776893616, 0.04774222895503044, -0.0012877347180619836, 0.016422633081674576, 0.029941199347376823, 0.011452383361756802, -0.0509876050055027, 0.030413642525672913, -0.007089255843311548, -0.032578449696302414, 0.031089141964912415, -0.05426875129342079, -0.02514432556927204, -0.014190400950610638, 0.07477128505706787, 0.005953003186732531, -0.006692524068057537, -0.002361314371228218, -0.027858654037117958, 0.05380998179316521, 0.0051266783848404884, 0.013033735565841198, -0.05663919448852539, -0.01757916435599327, 0.022778145968914032, -0.03858034685254097, -0.037548262625932693, -0.020782237872481346, -0.04030473530292511, 0.04473806172609329, -0.0512545183300972, -0.03987888991832733, 0.0015230157878249884, 0.028820738196372986, -0.059666238725185394, -0.005207861308008432, 0.006152496673166752, 0.011238837614655495, -0.024816224351525307, -0.030742483213543892, -0.017897075042128563, -0.0016756406985223293, -0.028502488508820534, -0.035108838230371475, 0.03943539410829544, -0.04655245319008827, 0.03657156229019165, 0.05067940428853035, -0.08340176939964294, -0.04013616591691971, -0.06444503366947174, -0.030970854684710503, -0.012315369211137295, -0.07110247761011124, -0.03280448168516159, 0.02626127004623413, -0.04748757183551788, 0.0047359773889184, 0.007689854595810175, 0.045111291110515594, 0.0420774444937706, 0.02998848259449005, 0.05433681234717369, 0.023987440392374992, -0.09998320043087006, 0.041488900780677795, 0.03726981580257416, 0.018887372687458992, -0.0012061047600582242, 0.03488089516758919, -0.019271086901426315, 0.0012199262855574489, 0.007996287196874619, -0.003548338310793042, 0.040870118886232376, -0.027700966224074364, -0.023507745936512947, -0.029801687225699425, -0.04509001970291138, -0.05366966500878334, -0.04323867708444595, -0.04065857082605362, 0.027575144544243813, -0.027609990909695625, -0.016452664509415627, 0.029072357341647148, 0.0073508527129888535, -0.018868742510676384, 0.02410515584051609, -0.03915965184569359, 0.019295690581202507, 0.007342434022575617, -0.014546079561114311, -0.024540215730667114, -0.00647525442764163, 0.012498128227889538, 0.012404624372720718, 0.020003946498036385, 0.011191564612090588, -0.019037460908293724, -0.017790289595723152, -0.023983869701623917, 0.01729421503841877, 0.025167346000671387, -0.00989660806953907, 0.022949187085032463, -0.03225835785269737, -0.010167732834815979, 0.023913541808724403, 0.05932094156742096, -0.0653081014752388, 0.027602236717939377, 0.06370371580123901, -0.02317035011947155, -0.004207311663776636, -0.03379310294985771, 0.017137974500656128, -0.02677859738469124, 0.05144676938652992, 0.011960827745497227, 0.05420228838920593, -0.011944100260734558, 0.01585603877902031, -0.014630054123699665, 0.03424326702952385, -0.000257504521869123, 0.032338742166757584, 0.060596808791160583, 0.03176480904221535, 0.06762818247079849, 0.03997177630662918, -0.05643843859434128, -0.014476177282631397, -0.04199259355664253, -0.03689384460449219, -0.0831976979970932, -0.05656954273581505, -0.030582424253225327, -0.08437234908342361, -0.05664161965250969, -0.044225189834833145, -0.02186349220573902, -0.016916364431381226, -0.0636189877986908, -0.056373145431280136, -0.014688185416162014, 0.014103136956691742, 0.0006339818937703967, 0.007468072231858969, -0.0027234270237386227, 0.018811523914337158, -0.0014241266762837768, -0.05051044747233391, -0.028090374544262886, -0.009022442623972893, -0.0509561263024807, 0.005413773003965616, 0.002341569634154439, 0.03192434459924698, 0.026126336306333542, -0.002365915570408106, 0.02694476954638958, -0.005632096901535988, -0.03623904660344124, -0.009408202022314072, 0.030808424577116966, -0.027262574061751366, -0.0210107434540987, 0.028766587376594543, 0.0049434988759458065, 0.013940874487161636, 0.030296126380562782, -0.03998255357146263, -0.008159194141626358, 0.05657639354467392, -0.0059072826988995075, -0.017534984275698662, -0.0450429730117321, -0.003894123947247863, 0.009869936853647232, 0.029832376167178154, 0.001244921120814979, 0.04875359311699867, 0.04651491716504097, -0.023253370076417923, -0.016544071957468987, 0.019494902342557907, 0.01554768718779087, -0.02219315804541111, 0.014644241891801357, -0.06833088397979736, 0.05169786885380745, 0.05190536379814148, -0.08302858471870422, 0.023755697533488274, 0.020764203742146492, 0.049754466861486435, 0.03250742331147194, 0.023927031084895134, -0.01780540682375431, -0.011665266938507557, -0.006080701015889645, 0.023204442113637924, 0.03387666866183281, 0.04007915407419205, 0.04862753674387932, -0.0464930422604084, -0.03141426295042038, -0.009100448340177536, -0.06121588870882988, -0.037108439952135086, -0.0003841715806629509, 0.04298261180520058, 0.021268321201205254, 0.031857021152973175, -0.06337796151638031, -0.00732353376224637, -0.0033842637203633785, 0.02710876427590847, 0.029890598729252815, -0.047026537358760834, 0.011589172296226025, -0.05485619604587555, 0.05407147482037544, 0.015332766808569431, 0.009575769305229187, -0.006598369218409061, -0.02252785488963127, 0.04933478310704231, -0.05504113808274269, 0.028032947331666946, 0.027366211637854576, -0.018808690831065178, 0.03537505492568016, 0.049873415380716324, 0.03450939804315567, 0.049147188663482666, -0.031946200877428055, -0.02818307839334011, -0.014091100543737411, -0.00729828467592597, -0.045873962342739105, -0.032198335975408554, -0.02261807583272457, -0.028178449720144272, 0.07604371011257172, -0.02694655768573284, 0.01967974193394184, -0.0020980490371584892, 0.005284987855702639, -0.016593484207987785, -0.09031566977500916, 0.04056548699736595, -0.04851023107767105, 0.024325642734766006, 0.0349813774228096, -0.03961023688316345, 0.03802679106593132, 0.011468470096588135, 0.01883586309850216, -0.05410139262676239, 0.007650231011211872, -0.02692412957549095, 0.009910739958286285, 0.013903280720114708, -0.0768955796957016, 0.038889359682798386, -0.036546215415000916, 0.03462608903646469, -0.04139361158013344, 0.023522691801190376, -0.0644850879907608, -0.054700445383787155, -0.07013028860092163, -0.013708346523344517, 0.07891219109296799, 0.002581199398264289, -0.022389590740203857, 0.006733626592904329, 0.01974775828421116, 0.02230418287217617, 0.02803116664290428, -0.012777249328792095, -0.005672792438417673, 0.02635464258491993, 0.028065968304872513, -0.018330657854676247, 0.01477957796305418, -0.02611459419131279, 0.05137665569782257, -0.040397707372903824, -0.034841183573007584, -0.0478508360683918, 0.035236794501543045, -0.08187578618526459, -0.07938172668218613, -0.03958366438746452, -0.051245152950286865, -0.04400011524558067, 0.009007983841001987, 0.01665416918694973, 0.04371723532676697, -0.00017672890680842102, 0.0006431089714169502, 0.01920386031270027, 0.027740007266402245, -0.009732653386890888, 0.046535052359104156, -0.01776835508644581, 0.004363155458122492, -0.04349518567323685, -0.03192470967769623, -0.04595990851521492, 0.00994937401264906, -0.020352749153971672, 0.011529646813869476, -0.010936523787677288, 0.0530242882668972, -0.00030758717912249267, 0.07960411161184311, -0.08063151687383652, 0.01833968795835972, 0.054098114371299744, 0.00528687983751297, 0.06458238512277603, 0.05097498744726181, -0.047490183264017105, 0.034325096756219864, 0.028482401743531227, 0.04992412403225899, -0.043059028685092926, -0.05869585648179054, 0.031579915434122086, -0.006618015002459288, 0.029923241585493088, -0.027999307960271835, 0.0401640459895134, -0.01697355881333351, -0.0689910352230072, 0.03723328933119774, 0.02409905008971691, -0.0055133202113211155, -0.019654057919979095, 0.0018830093322321773, 0.043308746069669724, -0.06237311288714409, -0.017815355211496353, -0.02396477945148945, -0.03367093205451965, -0.027752511203289032, 0.018156401813030243, -0.021408963948488235, 0.057367198169231415, 0.012509864754974842, -0.010580687783658504, -0.05239596590399742, 0.014036945067346096, 0.026745744049549103, 0.038098014891147614, -0.00331987370736897, 0.0154520059004426, -0.049819428473711014, 0.0026454776525497437, -0.036856379359960556, 0.06703702360391617, 0.06710494309663773, 0.05794446915388107, 0.04079589247703552, -0.03354303166270256, -0.004628494381904602, -0.01157320849597454, 0.012811184860765934, -0.009247854351997375, -0.025674104690551758, -0.046500422060489655, 0.017658526077866554, -0.0007643400458618999, 0.0011083231074735522, 0.007890594191849232, 0.00591832771897316, 0.03323649987578392, -0.030067864805459976, -0.04874859377741814, -0.009331388399004936, -0.010909439995884895, 0.027016734704375267, -0.0363985151052475, 0.03561757877469063, 0.04176890105009079, -0.033778224140405655, 0.012299606576561928, -0.004733570851385593, -0.050025712698698044, 0.0007591194589622319, -0.020360371097922325, -0.043791115283966064, -0.03289555385708809, 0.012190323323011398, 0.058794114738702774, 0.010642369277775288, 0.031225409358739853, 0.024147050455212593, -0.006770788691937923, -0.03881793096661568, 0.009393654763698578, 0.008120531216263771, 0.030299309641122818, -0.021060680970549583, -0.05396268516778946, 0.02562354877591133, -0.03565750643610954, -0.060961075127124786, 0.047125548124313354, 0.003949903883039951, -0.08033990859985352, -0.013753863051533699, 0.039778728038072586, 0.007750250399112701, -0.025876585394144058, 0.05122410133481026, -0.006668530870229006, 0.010754309594631195, -0.027019046247005463, 0.04007132723927498, 0.07665509730577469, -0.032858505845069885, 0.021591199561953545, 0.0425872839987278, -0.081852987408638, 0.00023169390624389052, -0.002539173699915409, 0.013673943467438221, -0.0074439081363379955, 0.02964971959590912, 0.013381502591073513, -0.008277918212115765, -0.015731485560536385, 0.06623312830924988, -0.04149104654788971, 0.00865856185555458, 0.020311301574110985, -0.048196665942668915, 0.05697054788470268, -0.04392477124929428, -0.06031684949994087, 0.03944171965122223, 0.024415867403149605, -0.006107250228524208, -0.03459220752120018, -0.025635983794927597, 0.009432650171220303, -0.03357180953025818, -0.0007096122717484832, -0.07638511806726456, -0.015784891322255135, 0.02746165171265602, -0.07220367342233658, 0.0467221699655056, -0.04883642867207527, 0.05727577582001686, -0.02828221209347248, 0.007972178049385548, 0.019731879234313965, 0.06499099731445312, -0.047301728278398514, 0.012373078614473343, 0.03653125837445259, -0.035609859973192215, 0.01652110181748867, 0.005697342567145824, 0.019459012895822525, 0.005515307188034058, 0.022897396236658096, -0.03944791853427887, -0.024752795696258545, 0.0092472517862916, 0.03204559162259102, 0.01102480012923479, 0.010301247239112854, -0.01959150843322277, -0.07168491929769516, 0.03906730189919472, 0.006045217625796795, 0.018496135249733925, 0.03472353145480156, -0.0234183631837368, -0.05681086331605911, -0.02663874253630638, 0.010302683338522911, -0.001446311711333692, -0.00823733489960432, 0.046844206750392914, 0.06613186001777649, 0.003882158547639847, 0.0032115450594574213, -0.052025895565748215, -0.021363796666264534, 0.02883841097354889, -0.06101776659488678, -0.020486652851104736, 0.025090573355555534, -0.04469628259539604, -0.034250322729349136, -0.04604635015130043, -0.016429396346211433, -0.04626694694161415, 0.013738071545958519, 0.037853699177503586, -0.006758350413292646, 0.04400789737701416, -0.042481083422899246, -0.035770729184150696, 0.010091406293213367, -0.025702625513076782, -0.032046787440776825, -0.01200353167951107, -0.006768743973225355, -0.03268209099769592, 0.03288803994655609, -0.037045031785964966, -0.038548342883586884, 0.01771514117717743, -0.073652483522892, -0.002101369434967637, 0.017950015142560005, -0.01940263621509075, -0.06150968745350838, -0.07082077860832214, 0.017942452803254128, -0.06401697546243668, 0.016425929963588715, 0.03250669315457344, -0.021777302026748657, -0.009807969443500042, 0.06061926484107971, 0.023019280284643173, -0.053229182958602905, -0.01700497604906559, 0.002463448327034712, -0.03666648641228676, -0.027734078466892242, 0.0035213222727179527, 0.026148248463869095, 0.009292085655033588, -0.0009395726374350488, 0.04987000301480293, -0.006980726029723883, 0.014940852299332619, -0.043411511927843094, 0.0379432737827301, -0.0005796895129606128, -0.0663846880197525, 0.03312695398926735, -0.018825070932507515, -0.031709372997283936, 0.04680214822292328, -0.010959042236208916, -0.03020135872066021, -0.04783863574266434, -0.05559484288096428, 0.040895044803619385, -0.04771321639418602, -0.02392878383398056, 0.05975070595741272, -0.0257705170661211, 0.016684113070368767, -0.023119889199733734, -0.02100863866508007, -0.011570856906473637, -0.02036181092262268, -0.04321233928203583, -0.03984898701310158, -0.01647704280912876, -0.018822774291038513, -0.05117939040064812, -0.0038236971013247967, -0.00939636304974556, -0.03406999632716179, 0.07018467038869858, 0.041140712797641754, 0.006493574474006891, -0.020625310018658638, -0.031964417546987534, 0.03138456493616104, -0.06398408114910126, -0.02417737990617752, -0.009710203856229782, 0.018403982743620872, 0.027637016028165817, 0.0005903778364881873, 0.04179272800683975, 0.015122245997190475, -0.014890236780047417, -0.008541824296116829, 0.013931254856288433, 0.0008416210766881704, 0.024060463532805443, 0.06949672847986221, 0.004046316724270582, 0.03845997527241707, -0.01819869875907898, 0.04935320094227791, 0.01380330789834261, 0.02245211973786354, 0.027556058019399643, 0.038616281002759933, -0.02705838717520237, -0.03672967478632927, 0.004734382964670658, 0.029408732429146767, -0.01828664168715477, -0.06141306459903717, -0.01786710135638714, 0.05146950110793114, -0.07459394633769989, -0.03561723232269287 ]
We consider a version of the classical group testing problem motivated by PCR testing for COVID-19. In the so-called tropical group testing model, the outcome of a test is the lowest cycle threshold (Ct) level of the individuals pooled within it, rather than a simple binary indicator variable. We introduce the tropical counterparts of three classical non-adaptive algorithms (COMP, DD and SCOMP), and analyse their behaviour through both simulations and bounds on error probabilities. By comparing the results of the tropical and classical algorithms, we gain insight into the extra information provided by learning the outcomes (Ct levels) of the tests. We show that in a limiting regime the tropical COMP algorithm requires as many tests as its classical counterpart, but that for sufficiently dense problems tropical DD can recover more information with fewer tests, and can be viewed as essentially optimal in certain regimes.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07264v2
[ -0.02956271357834339, -0.05371248349547386, 0.003343109739944339, -0.00980791263282299, -0.006348469294607639, -0.010624522343277931, 0.031492989510297775, 0.05500989034771919, -0.015353764407336712, 0.006226901430636644, 0.0011481224792078137, -0.008320349268615246, -0.04102485626935959, -0.03379617631435394, -0.032233815640211105, 0.022391069680452347, 0.06516260653734207, 0.023878958076238632, -0.06823189556598663, 0.06634301692247391, 0.044129516929388046, -0.004568384028971195, -0.037232592701911926, 0.04512808844447136, 0.014791376888751984, 0.049243662506341934, -0.022618331015110016, -0.003380524693056941, -0.00756067642942071, -0.06748337298631668, 0.060471080243587494, -0.032718200236558914, 0.003936755936592817, -0.07241926342248917, -0.0184357687830925, -0.046699102967977524, 0.02934402972459793, -0.0047574774362146854, 0.04377566650509834, -0.058875083923339844, 0.036803506314754486, -0.07888750731945038, -0.06692130863666534, -0.009413032792508602, 0.011356105096638203, -0.03142991289496422, -0.047144658863544464, -0.024895694106817245, -0.016227122396230698, -0.053749930113554, 0.0313415452837944, 0.00041542170220054686, -0.013679333962500095, 0.028461575508117676, -0.0729614645242691, -0.0013228652533143759, -0.007878337986767292, -0.012602729722857475, -0.05685817450284958, -0.03967874124646187, -0.004647842608392239, 0.019224736839532852, -0.02891801856458187, -0.022091379389166832, 0.0041081286035478115, 0.056206341832876205, -0.02496195212006569, -0.057761285454034805, -0.05960164591670036, -0.03393738716840744, 0.05908602103590965, -0.07472795248031616, 0.023622440174221992, -0.004039033316075802, -0.04390082508325577, -0.02638394944369793, -0.03959741070866585, -0.01950536109507084, 0.000677566509693861, 0.01691991649568081, -0.05504154413938522, 0.012759979814291, 0.02207905799150467, -0.03678583353757858, -0.0017585067544132471, -0.028773704543709755, 0.03993634507060051, -0.014169391244649887, -0.04011675715446472, -0.06439720094203949, 0.0257972814142704, -0.022665688768029213, -0.04117854684591293, -0.015776703134179115, 0.04794028028845787, -0.0557144470512867, 0.03164927288889885, 0.027876166626811028, 0.01992383413016796, 0.02873518317937851, 0.004285138566046953, -0.005687496159225702, 0.0041052005253732204, 0.06417791545391083, 0.0352022647857666, -0.011788494884967804, -0.014944042079150677, -0.06559326499700546, -0.06070328876376152, 0.020787851884961128, -0.05134980380535126, -0.017763011157512665, -0.032310184091329575, -0.07134228199720383, -0.03168575093150139, -0.03537769615650177, 0.037875138223171234, -0.005343201104551554, 0.0397801510989666, -0.05578972026705742, -0.04283043369650841, 0.03559011593461037, 0.008521228097379208, 0.05541403219103813, -0.02277730591595173, -0.023210227489471436, 0.04294170066714287, -0.01947854831814766, -0.024930445477366447, 0.008261275477707386, -0.036569688469171524, -0.018468044698238373, 0.01824820227921009, 0.0004895536694675684, 0.07501555234193802, -0.03555712103843689, -0.004185127094388008, -0.037915270775556564, 0.003523745108395815, -0.017607424408197403, -0.016913847997784615, -0.06921983510255814, -0.018518716096878052, -0.021867534145712852, -0.04620921239256859, 0.05806857347488403, -0.03948157653212547, 0.0033503116574138403, 0.036714352667331696, 0.018053477630019188, -0.006715346127748489, 0.035678930580616, -0.0014773999573662877, -0.0005728155956603587, 0.008243200369179249, 0.028742598369717598, 0.03996855020523071, -0.02074863575398922, -0.02892199344933033, 0.035424962639808655, -0.01461945939809084, -0.03948816657066345, 0.020216472446918488, 0.012345392256975174, 0.01838463917374611, 0.032105475664138794, 0.013296798802912235, -0.034630656242370605, 0.03817218914628029, -0.025597792118787766, -0.021217573434114456, -0.021105319261550903, 0.041721101850271225, -0.057812683284282684, -0.04220706224441528, -0.03899765387177467, -0.005752307362854481, -0.0520208440721035, -0.06985343992710114, 0.039359938353300095, 0.0125226816162467, 0.05246351659297943, -0.032422199845314026, -0.011980796232819557, -0.0680888369679451, 0.04523138329386711, -0.08104776591062546, 0.0032104281708598137, 0.027466773986816406, -0.012967078015208244, -0.028706133365631104, 0.003066546516492963, 0.03513922914862633, 0.01369506400078535, -0.04564032331109047, -0.044574037194252014, 0.03092610277235508, -0.03892335295677185, 0.01687130518257618, 0.017140084877610207, -0.08475932478904724, -0.021734019741415977, -0.02272193506360054, 0.02487710863351822, -0.015902303159236908, -0.043852340430021286, 0.017713656648993492, 0.041367802768945694, -0.043475307524204254, -0.02181178890168667, 0.014443145133554935, 0.0025195383932441473, 0.05781707167625427, 0.04106271639466286, 0.01559614297002554, -0.003209809772670269, -0.08800934255123138, 0.0717877447605133, 0.005789997987449169, -0.013072201050817966, 0.01798306778073311, -0.030768990516662598, 0.021335963159799576, -0.04813450574874878, -0.044113531708717346, 0.05065565183758736, 0.06501559913158417, -0.00275259162299335, -0.01176270842552185, -0.029700199142098427, -0.0064463852904737, -0.033754754811525345, -0.003356250235810876, -0.07896314561367035, -0.008545948192477226, -0.04565456882119179, -0.0011086268350481987, 0.03358883038163185, -0.005644140765070915, -0.0547267347574234, -0.06523990631103516, -0.014353781007230282, 0.02298790216445923, -0.062862828373909, -0.00453514838591218, -0.028179602697491646, -0.03499559313058853, 0.04246464744210243, -0.002052341355010867, -0.011261883191764355, -0.04465474188327789, -0.06646527349948883, -0.007372962310910225, -0.034834183752536774, -0.0012999378377571702, 0.06228146329522133, -0.030550943687558174, 0.011446962133049965, -0.0006849133060313761, 0.057929351925849915, 0.04070394113659859, 0.02765660174190998, -0.038291558623313904, 0.028204096481204033, 0.020539753139019012, -0.0010365633061155677, 0.006050600670278072, -0.0053790416568517685, -0.010650798678398132, 0.005595060531049967, -0.029753053560853004, 0.06509009003639221, 0.05449238792061806, -0.009169152937829494, 0.013706071302294731, -0.005679632071405649, -0.030364755541086197, -0.042556941509246826, 0.03697880357503891, 0.013093485496938229, -0.018402796238660812, 0.040389999747276306, -0.005527272820472717, -0.07906486839056015, -0.010671372525393963, -0.05381215363740921, -0.010850337333977222, -0.04488837718963623, -0.037373825907707214, 0.01594509556889534, -0.08056160062551498, -0.03900276497006416, -0.03189709037542343, -0.0033119681756943464, -0.029105104506015778, -0.0494944304227829, -0.0673629492521286, -0.0186176560819149, -0.03498584032058716, -0.022378623485565186, -0.05616513267159462, -0.04192221537232399, 0.017464935779571533, 0.02602127008140087, -0.0056861331686377525, -0.02978353761136532, -0.055918097496032715, -0.02483494020998478, 0.039133377373218536, 0.016412578523159027, -0.02831229381263256, 0.013532557524740696, -0.010172851383686066, 0.028342198580503464, 0.010905063711106777, 0.007685701362788677, -0.026014411821961403, 0.05184383690357208, -0.004337318707257509, -0.02938576228916645, 0.013946739956736565, -0.0015076601412147284, -0.0351947620511055, -0.006945514120161533, -0.057944703847169876, -0.01877767965197563, 0.07078622281551361, 0.052943356335163116, -0.02697720378637314, 0.0049704210832715034, -0.004500388167798519, 0.012411883100867271, 0.013160157017409801, -0.0038025807589292526, 0.0447487011551857, 0.05432027950882912, -0.021896036341786385, -0.016687842085957527, -0.028013009577989578, 0.03243372216820717, -0.04030827060341835, 0.03652852401137352, -0.030056744813919067, 0.02273106761276722, 0.048264842480421066, -0.08036945015192032, 0.05816525220870972, 0.04179210588335991, 0.04819375276565552, 0.0023219482973217964, -0.028883952647447586, 0.013332175090909004, 0.03819567710161209, -0.03126399591565132, -0.010278436355292797, 0.02680027484893799, 0.009186619892716408, 0.0509926863014698, -0.029703151434659958, -0.023257095366716385, 0.010336751118302345, -0.05852367356419563, -0.03801115229725838, 0.015346920117735863, 0.003768439404666424, 0.024316461756825447, -0.018518710508942604, -0.04155489802360535, 0.019593598321080208, -0.020783916115760803, 0.05356417968869209, 0.003075237153097987, -0.05161748826503754, 0.04917323216795921, -0.05153673514723778, 0.05451955646276474, -0.029284710064530373, 0.027787091210484505, -0.009360607713460922, -0.06005606800317764, 0.025120491161942482, -0.06507647037506104, 0.03882565721869469, 0.0430319681763649, -0.046821486204862595, 0.010787345468997955, 0.057266149669885635, -0.01523407269269228, 0.022446511313319206, -0.00288415071554482, 0.01153086218982935, -0.017819968983530998, 0.014009743928909302, -0.01164284534752369, -0.016069060191512108, -0.007777598686516285, -0.03523969650268555, 0.025323929265141487, -0.025568334385752678, -0.01359647698700428, -0.010478970594704151, 0.007664189673960209, -0.0031812244560569525, -0.08455823361873627, -0.053283434361219406, -0.061552807688713074, -0.009424909017980099, -0.007819583639502525, -0.04883625730872154, 0.014609730802476406, -0.0035309195518493652, 0.00474228709936142, -0.023968307301402092, -0.017074164003133774, -0.02478071302175522, -0.020046863704919815, 0.005536384880542755, -0.0751810148358345, 0.035536330193281174, -0.05194922909140587, 0.04725446179509163, 0.017479097470641136, -0.05314869433641434, -0.06911235302686691, 0.008359747007489204, -0.01675167679786682, -0.024021217599511147, 0.014465480111539364, -0.03295370563864708, 0.017268650233745575, -0.002319857943803072, -0.010946475900709629, -0.012039154767990112, -0.037259697914123535, -0.0052316938526928425, -0.05917099863290787, 0.03764849528670311, -0.0051328581757843494, -0.06501677632331848, -0.049269143491983414, 0.017616158351302147, 0.048301905393600464, -0.05289633199572563, -0.025359170511364937, -0.05878090858459473, 0.021376440301537514, -0.03922853618860245, -0.04622134193778038, -0.0256025493144989, -0.022085146978497505, -0.06845869868993759, -0.002114224247634411, -0.018005501478910446, 0.03412980958819389, -0.018388789147138596, -0.02460099197924137, 0.013119063340127468, 0.016599293798208237, -0.036284130066633224, 0.03231915086507797, 0.013594221323728561, -0.006608163472265005, -0.02736704982817173, -0.012398432940244675, -0.07316289097070694, 0.03447353094816208, -0.02922947145998478, 0.002572163939476013, -0.01872672513127327, 0.044407036155462265, -0.0036331324372440577, 0.06490582227706909, -0.08213642239570618, 0.026085302233695984, -0.01142896432429552, -0.026832036674022675, 0.04121067374944687, 0.04374392703175545, 0.00041496811900287867, 0.0132818091660738, -0.040930330753326416, 0.01370804663747549, -0.008877723477780819, -0.03497331961989403, 0.004601259715855122, -0.01509117055684328, -0.02333598956465721, -0.002502118470147252, 0.03894136846065521, 0.026778018102049828, -0.059203632175922394, -0.0013077175244688988, 0.013900103978812695, 0.0012464808532968163, -0.07896431535482407, 0.0416894368827343, 0.022945057600736618, -0.05749755725264549, -0.05286375433206558, 0.003951285034418106, -0.046247877180576324, 0.002813548082485795, 0.00033698597690090537, -0.0520625039935112, 0.01603524386882782, 0.003644324839115143, -0.004093455150723457, -0.031041018664836884, 0.017602358013391495, 0.03359154239296913, 0.018053894862532616, 0.0435909740626812, 0.004108744207769632, -0.06738501042127609, 0.03910425677895546, -0.04971390217542648, 0.05547334998846054, 0.031062541529536247, 0.018762221559882164, 0.012158510275185108, -0.01847001165151596, -0.015262600965797901, -0.04962082579731941, 0.0012655418831855059, -0.008345355279743671, 0.04250377044081688, -0.03338589519262314, -0.006665466818958521, 0.024316612631082535, 0.026107706129550934, 0.02015218697488308, 0.009453849866986275, 0.0037401136942207813, 0.007768998853862286, -0.05329088494181633, 0.0012261916417628527, -0.040563710033893585, 0.009035761468112469, -0.05308967083692551, -0.0017269478412345052, 0.012955154292285442, 0.003794781630858779, 0.021164538338780403, -0.006991105154156685, -0.006485891994088888, -0.017020272091031075, -0.041479624807834625, -0.0351930595934391, -0.059035949409008026, 0.0512787401676178, 0.046104975044727325, -0.07013016939163208, 0.015657631680369377, -0.036867301911115646, 0.008680392988026142, 0.0357714407145977, -0.03783075138926506, 0.007082048337906599, 0.035977642983198166, 0.00889393500983715, -0.04505982622504234, 0.00978916883468628, -0.006375835742801428, -0.05827968940138817, 0.00138454872649163, -0.020285606384277344, -0.07765233516693115, -0.04062360152602196, -0.011871117167174816, 0.006915739271789789, -0.029208563268184662, 0.05613502860069275, -0.019703222438693047, 0.007515205070376396, 0.004744645673781633, 0.07548467069864273, 0.06879612803459167, 0.0012003341689705849, 0.029297657310962677, -0.009523537009954453, -0.021760346367955208, -0.02672933042049408, -0.04477199539542198, -0.05830681696534157, 0.012311014346778393, 0.04962114244699478, -0.0014692798722535372, -0.018859438598155975, -0.03126880154013634, 0.04462854936718941, 0.014277089387178421, 0.034917451441287994, 0.012467035092413425, -0.0278137419372797, 0.024408863857388496, -0.049508821219205856, -0.04053891822695732, 0.00858885794878006, -0.03142306208610535, -0.025346258655190468, -0.014700648374855518, -0.023289930075407028, 0.021846462041139603, 0.04648691043257713, -0.010609393939375877, -0.054477643221616745, -0.03268801420927048, 0.0013526618713513017, -0.04241916164755821, 0.008243834599852562, -0.036808621138334274, 0.001011885004118085, 0.029848797246813774, 0.011157892644405365, -0.03704804182052612, 0.06932435929775238, -0.019595401361584663, 0.014721238985657692, 0.024860559031367302, 0.013123828917741776, -0.013749716803431511, 0.032405078411102295, 0.06059667468070984, -0.031305160373449326, 0.009905715472996235, -0.05184139311313629, -0.036900147795677185, 0.002484716475009918, -0.021439149975776672, 0.020350195467472076, 0.013436567038297653, 0.005418040789663792, -0.031160715967416763, 0.05160095542669296, -0.04042353853583336, 0.03737093508243561, -0.00427369587123394, -0.01974453404545784, -0.07318896055221558, -0.014478047378361225, -0.014011780731379986, -0.016592178493738174, -0.00494565861299634, 0.020768744871020317, 0.04989267513155937, -0.02411006949841976, 0.036569319665431976, -0.003976880572736263, 0.05795653164386749, -0.019862227141857147, -0.057147517800331116, -0.04233282431960106, 0.03926981985569, -0.023837625980377197, -0.042029254138469696, -0.02130979113280773, -0.040720053017139435, -0.06951651722192764, 0.011116480454802513, 0.045864444226026535, -0.012504084035754204, -0.032866813242435455, -0.04809633269906044, 0.03089251182973385, 0.05873465910553932, -0.06916124373674393, -0.051877979189157486, -0.036429084837436676, -0.03440423309803009, -0.03317226469516754, 0.007587225176393986, -0.06277669966220856, -0.062031202018260956, 0.007128495257347822, -0.08517371863126755, 0.016205912455916405, -0.004541271366178989, 0.023316172882914543, 0.03705921024084091, -0.0526483952999115, -0.01815645769238472, -0.043824534863233566, 0.02983025461435318, -0.004754725843667984, -0.024369871243834496, 0.002457707654684782, 0.02918262779712677, 0.023314742371439934, -0.07274356484413147, -0.0683889389038086, 0.027118876576423645, -0.03720337152481079, -0.03439294174313545, -0.0024614662397652864, 0.017964081838726997, -0.01704881154000759, 0.05524231866002083, 0.06429798901081085, -0.006821786053478718, 0.04291154071688652, -0.06978460401296616, 0.022396033629775047, -0.07044322788715363, -0.05731485038995743, 0.03736034035682678, -0.039512548595666885, 0.04414160177111626, 0.03940286487340927, 0.002855523256585002, -0.018985871225595474, -0.043632835149765015, -0.045010875910520554, 0.04847729951143265, 0.02089206501841545, -0.01222400926053524, 0.054294295608997345, -0.03669143468141556, 0.04630560055375099, -0.013544262386858463, -0.0032352772541344166, -0.06377886235713959, 0.013711855746805668, 0.04122604802250862, 0.01358933188021183, -0.04244624823331833, -0.04077734798192978, -0.022281916812062263, 0.012323531322181225, -0.006904494483023882, -0.029323259368538857, 0.06937699019908905, 0.021788330748677254, -0.0364500917494297, -0.013776041567325592, -0.03985808417201042, -0.00920564029365778, -0.04414892569184303, -0.014176608063280582, -0.019978508353233337, 0.028893733397126198, 0.042116884142160416, 0.052670497447252274, 0.00623369449749589, 0.046402156352996826, 0.020844679325819016, 0.03033686801791191, -0.009830452501773834, -0.0005601986194960773, -0.05041104182600975, 0.06584293395280838, 0.010242379270493984, -0.029773233458399773, -0.0423441119492054, 0.02955944463610649, 0.019918492063879967, 0.010140331462025642, -0.0034646126441657543, -0.008206740021705627, -0.042882923036813736, -0.056334175169467926, -0.060276515781879425, 0.025271398946642876, -0.029917165637016296, -0.03815305605530739, 0.006210746243596077, 0.00208099652081728, -0.05575111508369446, -0.028610900044441223 ]
An accurate motion model is a fundamental component of most autonomous navigation systems. While much work has been done on improving model formulation, no standard protocol exists for gathering empirical data required to train models. In this work, we address this issue by proposing Data-driven Robot Input Vector Exploration (DRIVE), a protocol that enables characterizing uncrewed ground vehicles (UGVs) input limits and gathering empirical model training data. We also propose a novel learned slip approach outperforming similar acceleration learning approaches. Our contributions are validated through an extensive experimental evaluation, cumulating over 7 km and 1.8 h of driving data over three distinct UGVs and four terrain types. We show that our protocol offers increased predictive performance over common human-driven data-gathering protocols. Furthermore, our protocol converges with 46 s of training data, almost four times less than the shortest human dataset gathering protocol. We show that the operational limit for our model is reached in extreme slip conditions encountered on surfaced ice. DRIVE is an efficient way of characterizing UGV motion in its operational conditions. Our code and dataset are both available online at this link: https://github.com/norlab-ulaval/DRIVE.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10718v2
[ -0.019836395978927612, -0.02731592208147049, 0.02709328755736351, 0.03539160639047623, -0.052087150514125824, 0.008229444734752178, 0.03562006726861, 0.006753952242434025, 0.0025815258268266916, -0.04566040262579918, -0.03431088849902153, 0.016343489289283752, -0.0314236655831337, -0.0028760309796780348, -0.04721292108297348, 0.024199314415454865, 0.07112537324428558, -0.0426538921892643, -0.057718005031347275, 0.008363387547433376, 0.034035131335258484, 0.013872797600924969, -0.031016651540994644, 0.018650641664862633, -0.007703849580138922, 0.0006229388527572155, -0.062112122774124146, 0.023668263107538223, -0.019441133365035057, 0.0016718001570552588, 0.07513116300106049, -0.010356033220887184, 0.013157808221876621, -0.042531050741672516, -0.04129505529999733, -0.04139726608991623, -0.012304693460464478, -0.01035534217953682, 0.04425794258713722, -0.05466315895318985, 0.027214940637350082, -0.06388183683156967, -0.05384198576211929, 0.018956560641527176, -0.05316385626792908, 0.024660490453243256, -0.013171915896236897, 0.026874171569943428, -0.041118476539850235, -0.05717889219522476, 0.015628719702363014, -0.03426874428987503, 0.03006017953157425, 0.03955995664000511, 0.009552490897476673, -0.015467152930796146, -0.021019069477915764, 0.029939213767647743, -0.002932812087237835, -0.036128509789705276, -0.013947405852377415, -0.027244970202445984, -0.0343407467007637, 0.03326046094298363, 0.005237203557044268, 0.05833464488387108, 0.019858144223690033, -0.043781209737062454, -0.04482994228601456, -0.0413363054394722, 0.05889074504375458, -0.059674426913261414, 0.04905441775918007, 0.04445243626832962, 0.010717105120420456, -0.025970064103603363, -0.04972866177558899, -0.04034958779811859, -0.005248332396149635, -0.042265672236680984, -0.0033498932607471943, 0.01881423220038414, 0.05683092400431633, 0.04629486799240112, -0.031330011785030365, -0.038446418941020966, -0.00467462744563818, -0.005647769197821617, 0.01020396500825882, -0.027145126834511757, 0.05154702812433243, -0.019739380106329918, -0.057806339114904404, 0.031017430126667023, 0.07139704376459122, -0.012228772044181824, 0.05182312801480293, 0.02752554416656494, 0.01570563204586506, -0.009241325780749321, -0.057588715106248856, -0.014243247918784618, -0.04899104684591293, 0.014954760670661926, 0.05126442387700081, -0.03968733176589012, 0.030597347766160965, -0.051580797880887985, -0.057339858263731, 0.036854088306427, -0.04312409833073616, -0.01288425363600254, -0.004640945233404636, -0.04276864230632782, -0.0447998009622097, -0.0414288230240345, 0.0570511519908905, -0.006022780202329159, 0.050313081592321396, -0.038879577070474625, -0.0165901780128479, 0.060861628502607346, 0.05612286552786827, -0.003572126617655158, 0.022299310192465782, -0.01575395092368126, 0.06897515803575516, -0.008090557530522346, -0.002124340273439884, 0.007989143021404743, -0.003635244444012642, 0.008655987679958344, -0.003868523519486189, -0.051880527287721634, 0.06069418415427208, -0.003886439371854067, -0.018790632486343384, -0.05182082951068878, 0.027585279196500778, 0.004052243661135435, -0.011021492071449757, -0.07072141021490097, 0.009756729006767273, -0.02092764340341091, -0.01732219196856022, 0.04778603836894035, -0.049050647765398026, -0.01887153834104538, -0.007995201274752617, 0.032993193715810776, 0.008706421591341496, 0.03035200946033001, 0.01504149753600359, 0.0289631225168705, 0.005844578146934509, -0.018261950463056564, 0.044211145490407944, -0.009225866757333279, -0.03012257255613804, -0.0027550451923161745, -0.011723950505256653, -0.047868285328149796, 0.037074800580739975, -0.020491141825914383, 0.02558089792728424, -0.0030771135352551937, 0.03582004830241203, -0.010688619688153267, -0.021612104028463364, 0.026485109701752663, -0.030098527669906616, -0.017988910898566246, 0.013783400878310204, -0.043631572276353836, -0.05138540267944336, -0.03416884317994118, 0.03901631385087967, -0.0662241205573082, -0.07029712945222855, 0.01569194160401821, -0.0035085477866232395, 0.05165639892220497, -0.019838429987430573, 0.014662872068583965, -0.04631928727030754, -0.020360760390758514, -0.08987704664468765, -0.030807768926024437, 0.018432939425110817, 0.044328510761260986, -0.010982896201312542, -0.03368959575891495, 0.033084671944379807, 0.03631792590022087, -0.030365269631147385, -0.04778848960995674, -0.0031443547923117876, -0.018980322405695915, -0.03366340696811676, 0.0027414136566221714, -0.09018667042255402, -0.021949512884020805, -0.060928184539079666, -0.03437007963657379, 0.003720685839653015, -0.06093190237879753, -0.0011087210150435567, 0.04133341833949089, -0.035416699945926666, 0.01525106281042099, 0.01856960356235504, 0.02248801663517952, 0.07504357397556305, 0.01643478497862816, 0.01746269501745701, -0.005178570281714201, -0.09771058708429337, 0.05723964050412178, 0.00538627477362752, 0.025142120197415352, 0.03604641184210777, 0.00811153557151556, -0.0011940799886360765, -0.03863702341914177, -0.0305066779255867, 0.042318932712078094, 0.057356297969818115, -0.029324013739824295, -0.06476666033267975, -0.031696125864982605, -0.0011039794189855456, -0.041977737098932266, -0.0020240938756614923, -0.07861235737800598, -0.0485617034137249, 0.012063414789736271, -0.01739971525967121, 0.037189655005931854, 0.02979774959385395, -0.03029276244342327, -0.008927388116717339, -0.01728067547082901, 0.047565385699272156, -0.018017396330833435, -0.0483778677880764, -0.023769089952111244, -0.056183408945798874, 0.050117697566747665, -0.018029989674687386, -0.04012436792254448, -0.05121605470776558, -0.04258966073393822, -0.007813611999154091, 0.004237309563905001, 0.030547305941581726, 0.04442904144525528, -0.02449122630059719, 0.043492939323186874, -0.04960007593035698, 0.044313449412584305, -0.01268675085157156, -0.007863456383347511, -0.060062799602746964, 0.021665098145604134, 0.04243825748562813, 0.037276491522789, -0.011345655657351017, -0.037195708602666855, 0.030046304687857628, -0.019590947777032852, -0.026919808238744736, 0.01859460398554802, 0.04206594079732895, -0.027076231315732002, -0.020225998014211655, -0.02787848562002182, -0.04961952567100525, -0.0457182377576828, 0.013027967885136604, 0.06992016732692719, 0.008302493952214718, 0.033150020986795425, 0.022721389308571815, -0.06109589338302612, -0.014997466467320919, -0.050952229648828506, 0.01248728483915329, -0.069341279566288, -0.027384789660573006, -0.024966280907392502, -0.0786169022321701, -0.0310378335416317, -0.03530748933553696, -0.05281839892268181, 0.0018363019917160273, -0.05392756313085556, -0.04304748401045799, -0.02064420096576214, 0.006213631480932236, 0.0021515798289328814, -0.04226492717862129, -0.04063049331307411, 0.0013745292089879513, 0.030917232856154442, 0.021917302161455154, -0.0441262349486351, -0.03285833075642586, -0.04294275492429733, 0.006540631875395775, 0.029849965125322342, -0.029113279655575752, 0.05148285627365112, -0.02964376099407673, 0.04115702956914902, 0.025918232277035713, 0.012080421671271324, -0.03766653314232826, 0.05052802711725235, -0.0010816063731908798, -0.01686403714120388, -0.0034672613255679607, -0.031552013009786606, 0.00337373954243958, -0.006160045508295298, -0.06274476647377014, -0.032001860439777374, 0.029717115685343742, 0.03777115046977997, -0.017863765358924866, 0.002468402497470379, -0.036563705652952194, -0.0008193074027076364, -0.003499633399769664, -0.03322326019406319, 0.048097241669893265, 0.03402198851108551, 0.006896350998431444, 0.005274525843560696, -0.01705174520611763, -0.01996956206858158, -0.010798080824315548, 0.008353888057172298, -0.07302393019199371, -0.02992505393922329, 0.06679263710975647, -0.08640896528959274, 0.02230631746351719, 0.019478052854537964, 0.045033812522888184, -0.008445358835160732, 0.021324247121810913, -0.01272223424166441, 0.037266939878463745, 0.036726564168930054, -0.0018050711369141936, 0.04310503229498863, 0.006342906039208174, 0.06824138760566711, -0.02449916861951351, -0.040436916053295135, 0.0033534830436110497, -0.08174708485603333, -0.06285598129034042, 0.016749011352658272, 0.017212161794304848, 0.05564688518643379, 0.04655744880437851, -0.04975130036473274, -0.003682835726067424, 0.036306265741586685, 0.04491952806711197, 0.0021880543790757656, -0.06036360189318657, 0.015563868917524815, -0.018741069361567497, 0.018828459084033966, 0.024271436035633087, 0.004675773438066244, -0.0015599901089444757, -0.023839270696043968, 0.020651718601584435, -0.05021163821220398, 0.011847239919006824, -0.0007806558278389275, -0.013967717997729778, 0.03622680529952049, 0.030738409608602524, -0.008433476090431213, 0.04873386397957802, -0.026223011314868927, -0.048133593052625656, 0.02827204018831253, -0.029211340472102165, -0.03499329462647438, 0.021601829677820206, -0.015745945274829865, 0.04223235696554184, 0.01634868048131466, -0.019939366728067398, -0.017636943608522415, -0.007435888517647982, 0.01618056930601597, -0.02074887603521347, -0.08594933897256851, -0.0024318851064890623, -0.04190193489193916, 0.045632585883140564, -0.046238649636507034, -0.045959826558828354, 0.04285065457224846, -0.03944047912955284, -0.021426944062113762, -0.006449694745242596, -0.019622230902314186, -0.046727027744054794, -0.03721238672733307, -0.040995195508003235, -0.06056811287999153, 0.06452015042304993, -0.019735654816031456, 0.04328460991382599, 0.006720246747136116, 0.035146743059158325, -0.03364630043506622, -0.013400822877883911, -0.001637700479477644, 0.03075365163385868, 0.028698507696390152, 0.007212737575173378, 0.0006830700440332294, 0.006250794045627117, -0.0008874034974724054, -0.012984772212803364, -0.008580313064157963, -0.013451707549393177, -0.046092439442873, 0.03135036677122116, -0.045744579285383224, -0.02814074419438839, -0.02574397809803486, 0.044753339141607285, 0.07501769065856934, -0.006241213995963335, -0.04323458671569824, -0.016094151884317398, 0.03778795897960663, -0.05415813997387886, -0.045221149921417236, -0.040701255202293396, -0.0743105560541153, -0.047762610018253326, -0.06112844496965408, 0.02843632735311985, -0.00034031568793579936, -0.021595129743218422, 0.03767305240035057, 0.033477019518613815, 0.03872400149703026, 0.016628006473183632, 0.0001698559644864872, 0.042297907173633575, -0.020697761327028275, 0.028438972309231758, -0.026420777663588524, -0.09010424464941025, 0.01135662104934454, -0.010090168565511703, 0.0008625348564237356, -0.045190371572971344, 0.0515151284635067, 0.04859354346990585, 0.038431160151958466, -0.07184552401304245, 0.03434593975543976, 0.025905387476086617, -0.05960799753665924, 0.019437123090028763, 0.052419207990169525, -0.03247104957699776, 0.0537387877702713, -0.01658152975142002, 0.0035741988103836775, 0.02198169007897377, -0.023716263473033905, -0.021572813391685486, -0.033599041402339935, -0.026199860498309135, -0.0044006118550896645, 0.06675851345062256, 0.007853369228541851, -0.023374656215310097, 0.012161323800683022, 0.0191495344042778, 0.026953913271427155, -0.020583491772413254, 0.023988310247659683, 0.05619371309876442, 0.013450319878757, 0.019538188353180885, -0.05082493647933006, 0.03300745412707329, -0.06523502618074417, -0.01786886155605316, -0.0574507862329483, -0.005532418843358755, 0.06650566309690475, -0.021941788494586945, -0.003320542862638831, 0.005130705423653126, 0.014832708984613419, 0.04665963724255562, -0.008934292010962963, 0.01419585756957531, -0.04516906291246414, -0.02370200864970684, -0.0077434745617210865, 0.042736392468214035, 0.04361575096845627, 0.04857168346643448, 0.006487223319709301, 0.03395568206906319, -0.03859037905931473, -0.03946274146437645, 0.01632346585392952, -0.018678145483136177, 0.046671900898218155, -0.052501507103443146, 0.03079097531735897, 0.02878444455564022, 0.001160911051556468, -0.005336925853043795, 0.018863536417484283, -0.012452158145606518, -0.012266851961612701, -0.03556222468614578, -0.02100347727537155, 0.013723653741180897, -0.056306321173906326, -0.05790887027978897, 0.0013877283781766891, 0.02838428132236004, 0.017860444262623787, -0.018070382997393608, -0.0036057732068002224, 0.038334619253873825, 0.040306851267814636, 0.021508101373910904, 0.007622059900313616, -0.014561276882886887, -0.002386990236118436, 0.06700140237808228, -0.01086766179651022, -0.00781355332583189, -0.01938599906861782, -0.03844526410102844, -0.008382394909858704, -0.03537936136126518, 0.06259387731552124, -0.04211600497364998, 0.01494460180401802, -0.024145204573869705, 0.03769996389746666, -0.04408105090260506, -0.0698133260011673, 0.049939971417188644, 0.05235159397125244, -0.07077701389789581, 0.01562902145087719, -0.0006953805568628013, -0.04649067670106888, -0.06102903559803963, 0.02277621626853943, 0.019413819536566734, 0.013721690513193607, -0.022409694269299507, 0.07055067270994186, 0.06552078574895859, 0.05432581156492233, 0.007448304444551468, -0.02194419875741005, -0.07598289102315903, 0.020665166899561882, -0.05131387338042259, -0.014311915263533592, 0.022121887654066086, 0.04281998798251152, 0.02860291488468647, -0.06054762005805969, -0.03372056782245636, 0.07660136371850967, -0.051743701100349426, -0.03161926940083504, 0.020421072840690613, -0.03352475166320801, 0.03273360803723335, 0.0005388492718338966, -0.03794296830892563, 0.007356300484389067, -0.03459843993186951, 0.005464704241603613, -0.03729699179530144, -0.03919728100299835, 0.007728277239948511, 0.03592243418097496, -0.01708327978849411, -0.060452885925769806, -0.036516621708869934, -0.037884872406721115, -0.0640542060136795, 0.0284139234572649, -0.04514549300074577, -0.010213781148195267, -0.011206608265638351, -0.0026617548428475857, -0.006209994666278362, 0.011787626892328262, -0.031875647604465485, -0.0464179664850235, -0.023082301020622253, 0.026674719527363777, -0.039716936647892, -0.01880616880953312, 0.017665890976786613, 0.00013694021617993712, 0.05300059914588928, -0.021891964599490166, -0.028860408812761307, -0.0072815814055502415, -0.04359403997659683, 0.014403535053133965, -0.0035388474352657795, -0.0438409224152565, -0.02113047055900097, -0.000022944757802179083, -0.020014969632029533, 0.001078884000889957, 0.02746393345296383, -0.044088322669267654, -0.06870729476213455, -0.006962199229747057, -0.012176120653748512, -0.017532166093587875, -0.0318942628800869, 0.01769237220287323, 0.010974006727337837, -0.025284647941589355, -0.004535424057394266, 0.024273987859487534, -0.03747013956308365, 0.005610065534710884, -0.05314375087618828, -0.04327000677585602, 0.002860989421606064, -0.046732526272535324, -0.04929997771978378, -0.03358757495880127, 0.0181573573499918, -0.06868664920330048, -0.004225260112434626, 0.05936100333929062, 0.03388015180826187, 0.03421080857515335, -0.07502051442861557, 0.025098925456404686, -0.028720635920763016, -0.02513439580798149, -0.03710515797138214, -0.03147665411233902, -0.01716545782983303, -0.02456042543053627, -0.018778907135128975, -0.012069199234247208, -0.054046764969825745, -0.025721833109855652, -0.08249661326408386, -0.010850136168301105, 0.06295063346624374, -0.013830545358359814, 0.022710537537932396, -0.05206698924303055, -0.02137593924999237, -0.03166590631008148, 0.0076645007357001305, -0.013432622887194157, 0.012350996024906635, -0.009709694422781467, 0.05374322086572647, 0.01939527317881584, -0.07366779446601868, 0.010979660786688328, 0.04244714230298996, -0.030616940930485725, -0.01321997307240963, 0.018182916566729546, 0.013190166093409061, 0.04089372232556343, 0.002231033518910408, 0.03287816792726517, -0.05884034186601639, 0.02017124369740486, -0.04848998412489891, 0.04505357891321182, -0.014871235005557537, -0.01384294219315052, 0.02086273953318596, -0.03491280600428581, -0.0037646533455699682, 0.013175803236663342, -0.036106258630752563, 0.013611284084618092, -0.028086276724934578, -0.03910648822784424, 0.032894909381866455, 0.002888752380385995, 0.022235460579395294, 0.03239726275205612, -0.03288590535521507, -0.030078165233135223, 0.005783579312264919, 0.005376425571739674, -0.011128362268209457, 0.046883586794137955, 0.03371768817305565, 0.01652722805738449, -0.03858761116862297, -0.06919606775045395, -0.03183859586715698, 0.006236344110220671, -0.0023409693967550993, -0.0372147262096405, 0.0792691707611084, 0.03270895406603813, -0.016215818002820015, -0.034815963357686996, -0.060758959501981735, -0.05699687823653221, -0.024238314479589462, -0.04567008092999458, 0.003669216064736247, -0.002361240331083536, -0.0292452871799469, 0.006450035143643618, -0.0026623050216585398, 0.03135322406888008, -0.009602182544767857, 0.050325896590948105, -0.0041620912961661816, 0.05269010737538338, -0.03900504112243652, 0.07926258444786072, -0.009626297280192375, -0.007414836902171373, -0.05097004771232605, 0.029888464137911797, 0.03450842946767807, -0.002696343930438161, -0.02675275318324566, 0.033441804349422455, 0.04598575457930565, -0.061564549803733826, 0.019285831600427628, 0.04299367591738701, 0.018292922526597977, -0.020629070699214935, -0.00631697429344058, 0.00029517870279960334, -0.05206390097737312, -0.06704282760620117 ]
The correlation between the sharpness of loss minima and generalisation in the context of deep neural networks has been subject to discussion for a long time. Whilst mostly investigated in the context of selected benchmark data sets in the area of computer vision, we explore this aspect for the acoustic scene classification task of the DCASE2020 challenge data. Our analysis is based on two-dimensional filter-normalised visualisations and a derived sharpness measure. Our exploratory analysis shows that sharper minima tend to show better generalisation than flat minima -even more so for out-of-domain data, recorded from previously unseen devices-, thus adding to the dispute about better generalisation capabilities of flat minima. We further find that, in particular, the choice of optimisers is a main driver of the sharpness of minima and we discuss resulting limitations with respect to comparability. Our code, trained model states and loss landscape visualisations are publicly available.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16369v2
[ -0.03575138375163078, -0.008773240260779858, 0.053233202546834946, 0.00781955849379301, -0.0016227025771513581, -0.0120334941893816, 0.010885853320360184, -0.0014032621402293444, -0.026877231895923615, -0.024601707234978676, -0.009464064612984657, -0.013868042267858982, -0.06190767511725426, -0.06456919014453888, -0.03215328976511955, 0.028667090460658073, 0.05028016120195389, 0.0014075356302782893, -0.042183298617601395, 0.09068864583969116, 0.044655028730630875, 0.011328731663525105, -0.03266812860965729, 0.004214370623230934, 0.04911891371011734, -0.0156033243983984, -0.036884844303131104, 0.04899333417415619, 0.007633286062628031, -0.03884969279170036, 0.03867911547422409, -0.049882885068655014, -0.04083291441202164, -0.05490966886281967, 0.0020097338128834963, -0.009744547307491302, -0.006222544237971306, 0.032109037041664124, -0.008908617310225964, -0.05186976119875908, 0.004861547611653805, -0.059564702212810516, -0.0434703566133976, -0.03375154361128807, -0.04964284971356392, 0.03573426976799965, -0.026081491261720657, 0.012254124507308006, -0.07022808492183685, -0.0155537324026227, 0.062252093106508255, 0.0013665891019627452, 0.013803659938275814, 0.012999873608350754, 0.012908144854009151, -0.013899640180170536, -0.027187492698431015, 0.006889712996780872, -0.006236197892576456, 0.0009452892700210214, 0.017479397356510162, -0.03498220443725586, 0.008188667707145214, -0.04923389479517937, -0.023606743663549423, 0.06272663176059723, 0.002855305327102542, -0.07775754481554031, -0.025967447087168694, -0.01423619408160448, 0.057022031396627426, -0.059347204864025116, 0.016804827377200127, -0.0012010859791189432, -0.049028895795345306, 0.006194159854203463, -0.026417188346385956, 0.00012634920130949467, 0.009802666492760181, 0.02396310307085514, -0.015558739192783833, 0.0038433163426816463, 0.018020320683717728, 0.019232168793678284, -0.026113493368029594, -0.0222775861620903, 0.054855216294527054, -0.0025620583910495043, 0.005554208066314459, -0.010727612301707268, 0.02249002642929554, -0.07285856455564499, -0.07148744910955429, 0.010176267474889755, 0.07525300234556198, -0.04454018920660019, 0.07261759787797928, 0.006948091089725494, 0.02572944387793541, -0.0077876076102256775, -0.017647290602326393, -0.01313535962253809, -0.034575205296278, 0.02596484124660492, 0.032918378710746765, -0.013276181183755398, 0.047640737146139145, -0.0009031297522597015, -0.03520132973790169, 0.05625195801258087, -0.00048826014972291887, -0.006261229049414396, -0.011032411828637123, -0.05344356223940849, -0.05572979152202606, -0.02330801822245121, 0.051003072410821915, 0.001600097049959004, -0.017103487625718117, -0.03695176914334297, -0.03161035478115082, 0.03643505647778511, 0.046578314155340195, 0.0034808635246008635, -0.021648354828357697, 0.008683192543685436, 0.053545061498880386, -0.01051222626119852, 0.03923356905579567, -0.05190497636795044, -0.04850452020764351, 0.024603065103292465, 0.016725704073905945, 0.010069123469293118, 0.051841892302036285, 0.02281651832163334, 0.04945455119013786, -0.028184428811073303, 0.0219957884401083, 0.028653329238295555, -0.04552821069955826, -0.0467691645026207, 0.02934970147907734, -0.03104948066174984, 0.012454573065042496, 0.053589459508657455, -0.013157631270587444, -0.0408930629491806, 0.048815831542015076, 0.05231667309999466, 0.011043829843401909, 0.02930212765932083, 0.03652942553162575, 0.03898955509066582, -0.017632778733968735, 0.003592569148167968, 0.050894223153591156, 0.017670877277851105, -0.030739055946469307, 0.05481208488345146, 0.024174069985747337, -0.0038874477613717318, -0.004225785378366709, -0.02654877118766308, -0.0008270235848613083, 0.0023659486323595047, 0.020965028554201126, -0.018818305805325508, -0.019917704164981842, 0.00804250780493021, -0.01063387468457222, -0.010867519304156303, -0.01484436634927988, -0.05231999233365059, -0.05883248895406723, -0.010395415127277374, -0.02807842195034027, -0.07122527807950974, -0.006427360698580742, 0.014509081840515137, 0.017297979444265366, 0.05261658877134323, -0.029430026188492775, -0.01268331054598093, -0.03597249463200569, -0.023187512531876564, -0.09223881363868713, 0.003070974722504616, 0.015678564086556435, -0.02165352553129196, -0.028109639883041382, -0.05433797091245651, -0.0049786134622991085, 0.044228263199329376, -0.016723448410630226, -0.045578740537166595, -0.017185334116220474, 0.03467685356736183, 0.012802080251276493, 0.012200568802654743, -0.09362175315618515, -0.05426771193742752, -0.05202316865324974, 0.009052040986716747, -0.037531279027462006, -0.054598551243543625, 0.018073149025440216, 0.048903532326221466, -0.0580972321331501, -0.028701672330498695, 0.07858621329069138, 0.05942574143409729, 0.06728551536798477, 0.04672624543309212, 0.0006126975640654564, 0.024941153824329376, -0.10946136713027954, 0.026670848950743675, 0.025477265939116478, 0.015745574608445168, 0.06172323226928711, 0.031636569648981094, -0.034532155841588974, -0.005669158883392811, 0.001508528832346201, 0.0657200813293457, 0.06425228714942932, -0.020106183364987373, -0.049886349588632584, -0.007030223496258259, -0.009130016900599003, -0.06577222049236298, -0.013080563396215439, -0.05477648600935936, -0.028107168152928352, 0.009098468348383904, -0.06572556495666504, 0.06491319090127945, -0.01756621152162552, -0.048347584903240204, -0.025794534012675285, -0.027462879195809364, 0.023212555795907974, -0.042831163853406906, -0.009102379903197289, 0.011632516048848629, -0.03104476071894169, 0.037455275654792786, -0.00479436619207263, -0.029372064396739006, -0.04771588370203972, -0.06049187853932381, -0.017557699233293533, -0.02789168618619442, 0.029944563284516335, 0.051232848316431046, -0.02925499714910984, 0.03095535933971405, -0.029775086790323257, 0.0553632490336895, 0.02509884536266327, 0.020014790818095207, -0.06973091512918472, 0.04665280133485794, 0.05698247626423836, 0.026539869606494904, -0.014519267715513706, 0.014475125819444656, 0.03777220472693443, -0.012005392462015152, 0.005644294433295727, 0.026469828560948372, 0.03069896250963211, -0.004324654117226601, 0.012345674447715282, -0.038687244057655334, 0.012574510648846626, -0.0000652332091704011, 0.015184580348432064, 0.03423723205924034, 0.022110292688012123, 0.041963424533605576, 0.02123408205807209, -0.07631326466798782, 0.008272076025605202, -0.06866572797298431, 0.0010465697851032019, -0.07725505530834198, -0.0601673424243927, -0.014403619803488255, -0.09561432152986526, -0.032155994325876236, -0.0017724649515002966, -0.008504694327712059, -0.03088877908885479, -0.03155125677585602, -0.033995531499385834, 0.01925136335194111, 0.06570800393819809, 0.027792466804385185, 0.0002171799715142697, -0.019828760996460915, 0.0102101294323802, 0.04158772528171539, -0.009566541761159897, -0.06045189127326012, -0.05055292323231697, 0.029255159199237823, 0.025951188057661057, -0.024567363783717155, 0.007561697158962488, 0.028114326298236847, -0.006821621209383011, 0.05644823983311653, 0.0010517577175050974, 0.03014179691672325, -0.02759503200650215, 0.011380495503544807, -0.03207333758473396, -0.024511873722076416, 0.022833356633782387, 0.004258143249899149, -0.038785941898822784, -0.04558030515909195, -0.04082682728767395, -0.03648518770933151, 0.06105548515915871, 0.0068893455900251865, -0.0055274274200201035, -0.0267521683126688, 0.020233307033777237, 0.038623012602329254, 0.009094953536987305, 0.010939731262624264, 0.03090103715658188, 0.04488163813948631, -0.04683360457420349, -0.031207488849759102, -0.0026819889899343252, 0.012385860085487366, -0.010886235162615776, 0.005846220999956131, -0.04426844045519829, 0.010717014782130718, 0.06535918265581131, -0.09753215312957764, 0.00862269476056099, 0.05285940319299698, 0.058171410113573074, 0.00006433083763113245, 0.020300740376114845, 0.014872518368065357, 0.016645876690745354, 0.04092377796769142, -0.0028684332501143217, 0.007111039478331804, 0.013386365957558155, 0.05255642533302307, -0.0301329605281353, -0.060020145028829575, 0.0013258004328235984, -0.054352935403585434, -0.030861850827932358, 0.03740353137254715, 0.01798195205628872, 0.004974812269210815, 0.030186284333467484, -0.02783520147204399, 0.007465275935828686, -0.017810098826885223, 0.04303991422057152, -0.0413273423910141, -0.04806426167488098, 0.0016910632839426398, -0.04859251156449318, 0.021081263199448586, 0.009628650732338428, -0.008457898162305355, 0.012595976702868938, -0.060542356222867966, 0.028268888592720032, -0.047036755830049515, 0.030273765325546265, 0.01049940474331379, 0.023003019392490387, 0.060069967061281204, 0.04539219290018082, -0.009849095717072487, 0.05322021245956421, -0.01107862126082182, 0.01780516654253006, -0.013448424637317657, 0.035877205431461334, 0.012784134596586227, -0.011501587927341461, -0.03784927725791931, -0.00786981824785471, -0.0038858591578900814, -0.04199227690696716, -0.001707215909846127, 0.012547144666314125, 0.013894625939428806, -0.007113415282219648, -0.08892794698476791, 0.01102517731487751, -0.02560446970164776, 0.03329315036535263, -0.021260835230350494, -0.03854314982891083, 0.07437758147716522, -0.011817432940006256, -0.0029977525118738413, -0.015221384353935719, -0.025457317009568214, -0.005154059734195471, -0.029214467853307724, 0.0010124847758561373, -0.034285176545381546, 0.01845015585422516, -0.03144039586186409, 0.01920824684202671, 0.0005971143255010247, 0.029441647231578827, -0.0552670881152153, -0.011479831300675869, -0.003078887704759836, 0.0307641439139843, 0.043393686413764954, 0.0033830760512501, 0.006647679954767227, 0.026650208979845047, 0.03683491051197052, -0.028409138321876526, 0.05897420272231102, -0.0029505148995667696, 0.021306367591023445, 0.0544290766119957, -0.04747353866696358, -0.02683359384536743, -0.0320260263979435, -0.00938216969370842, 0.05380728095769882, -0.01925969310104847, -0.025336025282740593, -0.010684504173696041, -0.021057631820440292, -0.06501703709363937, -0.039908938109874725, -0.023203177377581596, -0.046232134103775024, -0.06504827737808228, -0.007955714128911495, -0.04498181492090225, 0.04238273575901985, -0.00454008299857378, 0.03082587942481041, 0.013562511652708054, 0.018594883382320404, -0.014623439870774746, 0.0215896125882864, 0.042936477810144424, -0.0001437022292520851, -0.024450022727251053, -0.045905910432338715, -0.07237006723880768, 0.02395641803741455, -0.013501026667654514, -0.05194007232785225, 0.0006151047418825328, 0.021958352997899055, 0.02608841098845005, 0.06364909559488297, -0.08933255821466446, 0.06385856866836548, 0.07496587932109833, -0.007678865455091, 0.022256797179579735, 0.03491758555173874, -0.014639957807958126, 0.03701624646782875, -0.01402471587061882, 0.006838623434305191, 0.018863476812839508, -0.013766437768936157, -0.027717486023902893, 0.0044344631023705006, -0.03909153491258621, -0.022581571713089943, 0.048703137785196304, 0.02623593993484974, -0.06958835572004318, 0.007162389345467091, 0.029552578926086426, -0.0069725727662444115, -0.03268598020076752, -0.023749174550175667, 0.0523068942129612, -0.01127493754029274, -0.04156709089875221, 0.002427689265459776, -0.012132382020354271, 0.04282095283269882, 0.03894919529557228, -0.041080743074417114, 0.0075523946434259415, 0.029569197446107864, -0.019288893789052963, -0.04472704231739044, 0.014966076239943504, 0.02067706361413002, -0.021597398445010185, -0.025931278243660927, -0.04567208141088486, -0.07063227146863937, -0.012576784938573837, -0.025131935253739357, 0.027229536324739456, 0.048318713903427124, 0.06241381913423538, -0.0025392526295036077, 0.008628119714558125, -0.03328145667910576, -0.034221529960632324, -0.02421475015580654, -0.014857538044452667, 0.005399617832154036, -0.012349817901849747, 0.04353771358728409, 0.035075441002845764, 0.0357838049530983, 0.015043716877698898, 0.012848022393882275, 0.004670661874115467, 0.049700770527124405, -0.016352349892258644, -0.02720835991203785, 0.025710705667734146, -0.014386093243956566, -0.016781076788902283, 0.032913193106651306, -0.011923513375222683, -0.022777501493692398, 0.01684539206326008, 0.022901766002178192, -0.03060714341700077, 0.008047814480960369, -0.025965193286538124, 0.007222082931548357, -0.06349337846040726, 0.0011175405234098434, 0.06551060080528259, -0.03745519742369652, -0.006909944582730532, -0.015946494415402412, -0.007035659626126289, -0.015481792390346527, -0.024395285174250603, 0.007626878097653389, 0.04695712774991989, -0.009386878460645676, -0.029943687841296196, 0.05087621510028839, -0.0329311341047287, -0.06567718088626862, 0.013895655982196331, -0.02652939409017563, -0.09637998044490814, 0.010305164381861687, 0.017411774024367332, 0.006691827438771725, -0.01748206652700901, 0.03876962885260582, -0.029588516801595688, 0.024324793368577957, -0.024947283789515495, 0.07362277805805206, 0.08674058318138123, -0.028298845514655113, -0.02644839882850647, -0.010549483820796013, -0.058165404945611954, -0.02622693032026291, -0.03653370589017868, 0.014019095338881016, -0.046655308455228806, 0.014705032110214233, -0.03529193252325058, -0.016240986064076424, -0.02171621285378933, 0.0590570792555809, -0.021345434710383415, 0.01739998534321785, 0.021014396101236343, -0.018114810809493065, 0.047250982373952866, -0.010455187410116196, -0.06693442165851593, 0.032327331602573395, -0.037965431809425354, 0.00016730939387343824, -0.05785472318530083, -0.0037540607154369354, 0.004908323287963867, 0.020909780636429787, 0.014507725834846497, -0.06124958023428917, 0.01256297156214714, -0.009419530630111694, 0.01099152397364378, 0.02434929460287094, -0.06652605533599854, 0.03012957237660885, -0.014833418652415276, 0.05905822291970253, 0.027665775269269943, 0.07967895269393921, -0.06973050534725189, -0.014981423504650593, -0.0062196869403123856, 0.02001843973994255, -0.017860880121588707, 0.015340549871325493, 0.03169542923569679, -0.030990665778517723, 0.04268921911716461, -0.026067359372973442, -0.04871175065636635, -0.0161301176995039, -0.04097605124115944, 0.04017137736082077, -0.01918225921690464, -0.00955198984593153, -0.05594967305660248, -0.00858219526708126, -0.04005682095885277, -0.016834665089845657, 0.055644579231739044, -0.07257862389087677, -0.07424968481063843, -0.001997821033000946, -0.03688467666506767, 0.010082121938467026, 0.03468052297830582, 0.04394184798002243, 0.05743167921900749, -0.031022056937217712, 0.044362667948007584, 0.04789428040385246, -0.030737755820155144, -0.026384903118014336, -0.07708121836185455, -0.0362577848136425, -0.0182891134172678, 0.004382584244012833, -0.01465675514191389, -0.028490204364061356, -0.0221289973706007, -0.07469616085290909, 0.04842839017510414, 0.03269122913479805, 0.039739180356264114, -0.041053012013435364, -0.04017788544297218, 0.040048036724328995, 0.03636757656931877, 0.006534676533192396, -0.05237278342247009, 0.02161359414458275, -0.013792040757834911, 0.007660717703402042, 0.029166672378778458, -0.006623282562941313, -0.04500091075897217, 0.03417065739631653, -0.09397213160991669, 0.007707788143306971, -0.00950563419610262, 0.04691018536686897, -0.00948624312877655, -0.04541241005063057, 0.027203842997550964, -0.04005347192287445, -0.019922494888305664, 0.015538045205175877, 0.01249732542783022, 0.005239078309386969, 0.03496103733778, 0.0007083010859787464, -0.06637898087501526, -0.035014040768146515, 0.02283841371536255, -0.031125839799642563, -0.01082842331379652, -0.013318924233317375, 0.029550056904554367, 0.01544301025569439, 0.026412632316350937, 0.04948204383254051, -0.046115364879369736, 0.051866427063941956, -0.05706017464399338, 0.03347586840391159, -0.034769341349601746, -0.046902500092983246, 0.05126972496509552, -0.07055416703224182, -0.002856094390153885, 0.009725726209580898, 0.007687097880989313, -0.0008824151591397822, -0.044215817004442215, -0.053707513958215714, -0.018026107922196388, -0.008642615750432014, -0.022724635899066925, 0.04651139676570892, -0.025454377755522728, -0.014776792377233505, -0.030359331518411636, -0.04624065384268761, -0.044303324073553085, -0.004035003948956728, 0.009729813784360886, -0.06607353687286377, -0.03677167370915413, -0.06383068114519119, 0.0015029347268864512, -0.0081173125654459, 0.010635978542268276, -0.0021041403524577618, 0.05131736397743225, -0.009936381131410599, 0.0005289739929139614, -0.046367548406124115, -0.03756316751241684, 0.05232201889157295, -0.06429232656955719, -0.016837501898407936, -0.026648348197340965, -0.005089485552161932, -0.001083280541934073, 0.03293981775641441, 0.010396584868431091, 0.05944420024752617, 0.01479647308588028, 0.006493964232504368, 0.010411503724753857, -0.015355054289102554, -0.01920825056731701, 0.08499439060688019, 0.010934431105852127, 0.022708097472786903, -0.014042844995856285, 0.0043840669095516205, -0.010093804448843002, -0.04211131110787392, 0.03233148902654648, -0.02124957926571369, 0.017543185502290726, -0.07064186036586761, 0.001702147419564426, 0.012660986743867397, -0.02127075381577015, -0.03571799024939537, -0.016895748674869537, 0.019552266225218773, -0.050108883529901505, -0.05488743260502815 ]
The recent advancements in transformer-based visual trackers have led to significant progress, attributed to their strong modeling capabilities. However, as performance improves, running latency correspondingly increases, presenting a challenge for real-time robotics applications, especially on edge devices with computational constraints. In response to this, we introduce LiteTrack, an efficient transformer-based tracking model optimized for high-speed operations across various devices. It achieves a more favorable trade-off between accuracy and efficiency than the other lightweight trackers. The main innovations of LiteTrack encompass: 1) asynchronous feature extraction and interaction between the template and search region for better feature fushion and cutting redundant computation, and 2) pruning encoder layers from a heavy tracker to refine the balnace between performance and speed. As an example, our fastest variant, LiteTrack-B4, achieves 65.2% AO on the GOT-10k benchmark, surpassing all preceding efficient trackers, while running over 100 fps with ONNX on the Jetson Orin NX edge device. Moreover, our LiteTrack-B9 reaches competitive 72.2% AO on GOT-10k and 82.4% AUC on TrackingNet, and operates at 171 fps on an NVIDIA 2080Ti GPU. The code and demo materials will be available at https://github.com/TsingWei/LiteTrack.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09249v1
[ -0.029248647391796112, -0.015705760568380356, 0.05563297122716904, 0.0361904501914978, -0.01552899181842804, -0.030410509556531906, 0.02626299113035202, -0.017414145171642303, 0.0499601736664772, -0.055102940648794174, -0.04765206202864647, 0.05785178393125534, -0.05308633670210838, -0.05361611396074295, -0.029757529497146606, 0.0014959413092583418, 0.07960765063762665, -0.03361378610134125, -0.0442398302257061, 0.07025620341300964, 0.04739886149764061, -0.009226208552718163, -0.020474573597311974, 0.016385000199079514, -0.029407348483800888, -0.01786131039261818, -0.017448438331484795, 0.04630015045404434, 0.00814916379749775, 0.010054551064968109, 0.07313041388988495, 0.03385845199227333, -0.015527365729212761, -0.05001439154148102, -0.011360484175384045, -0.013576295226812363, -0.061598680913448334, 0.042022667825222015, 0.032471902668476105, -0.02022111788392067, 0.002286954317241907, -0.05594060197472572, 0.009833792224526405, -0.06185096874833107, -0.023317459970712662, -0.02177952416241169, -0.027059704065322876, 0.010825270786881447, -0.05944597348570824, -0.017327187582850456, 0.041875094175338745, 0.002439873991534114, -0.010042892768979073, 0.022573698312044144, 0.026799770072102547, 0.04616899788379669, -0.007812009658664465, 0.003037817543372512, -0.027640651911497116, -0.021900564432144165, -0.027546552941203117, -0.021870238706469536, -0.0009827578905969858, -0.022156501188874245, -0.01803652197122574, 0.059078045189380646, 0.010019349865615368, -0.06956677883863449, -0.026638194918632507, -0.025216341018676758, 0.035486020147800446, -0.04061387851834297, -0.023387400433421135, 0.025442006066441536, -0.03942573815584183, -0.0375438928604126, -0.020484253764152527, -0.0001682911824900657, 0.052363380789756775, -0.00924575887620449, -0.049804504960775375, 0.017888832837343216, 0.04251770302653313, 0.03318836912512779, -0.024162152782082558, -0.007540320511907339, 0.04825000464916229, 0.017704693600535393, -0.012423144653439522, -0.0470641627907753, 0.04483826085925102, -0.056513991206884384, -0.08983894437551498, 0.03217807412147522, 0.04502487927675247, -0.01996448077261448, 0.04022584855556488, 0.007128647994250059, -0.007602703291922808, 0.017530903220176697, -0.06507784128189087, -0.01953839510679245, -0.04930216446518898, 0.030865665525197983, 0.04497522860765457, -0.02579263411462307, 0.01905384659767151, -0.04165729135274887, -0.018719036132097244, 0.022712556645274162, -0.0026737088337540627, -0.006699602585285902, 0.05468873307108879, -0.05374947190284729, -0.0615064799785614, -0.029020942747592926, 0.04765716940164566, -0.01891152560710907, -0.007611623499542475, 0.018861345946788788, 0.05249486118555069, 0.034278977662324905, 0.039693672209978104, -0.025440942496061325, -0.025230729952454567, -0.01611335016787052, 0.00903649814426899, -0.006908662151545286, 0.02480762079358101, -0.00809531845152378, 0.006126733496785164, 0.026820408180356026, -0.0233053769916296, -0.04785148799419403, 0.07851338386535645, -0.018456880003213882, 0.034013599157333374, -0.013249286450445652, 0.0627460852265358, -0.04245666787028313, -0.058637674897909164, -0.0019027964444831014, 0.06641080975532532, 0.031254347413778305, 0.021853726357221603, 0.07207611203193665, -0.05909816920757294, -0.024343987926840782, -0.005240690428763628, 0.008451546542346478, 0.014399506151676178, 0.009222343564033508, 0.01060158759355545, -0.0013650193577632308, 0.01879659667611122, -0.010552446357905865, 0.0440322645008564, -0.03608313202857971, -0.022614024579524994, -0.024844197556376457, -0.001804404892027378, -0.01651754043996334, -0.015814315527677536, -0.019819961860775948, 0.018347803503274918, -0.02775430679321289, -0.015109582804143429, 0.008694241754710674, 0.010372809134423733, 0.05580566078424454, -0.033579275012016296, -0.022637739777565002, -0.016294019296765327, -0.04543072730302811, -0.036804065108299255, -0.0061017791740596294, -0.018696358427405357, -0.033633843064308167, -0.048572834581136703, -0.031103914603590965, 0.015540373511612415, 0.0318044014275074, -0.007547722663730383, 0.04337678477168083, -0.041999559849500656, -0.0395282506942749, -0.07466170191764832, -0.04736706614494324, 0.03518497571349144, 0.020837174728512764, 0.01684790849685669, -0.0732112005352974, -0.013455119915306568, -0.010992481373250484, -0.01767817884683609, -0.060408588498830795, -0.028071779757738113, -0.02072736993432045, 0.032377444207668304, 0.025024021044373512, -0.0828014612197876, -0.033764541149139404, -0.050435904413461685, 0.030709324404597282, -0.011542164720594883, -0.0490681417286396, 0.051080718636512756, 0.019488830119371414, -0.06271612644195557, 0.015952253714203835, 0.05166478455066681, 0.03437601402401924, 0.07129684090614319, 0.00038681284058839083, 0.03949088975787163, -0.05755512788891792, -0.10399407148361206, 0.02582535520195961, -0.024126291275024414, 0.01934841275215149, -0.035814765840768814, -0.039999473839998245, -0.03762175142765045, -0.04700172692537308, -0.03843514621257782, 0.04981379956007004, 0.05031055957078934, -0.03305205702781677, -0.056612279266119, 0.03455185890197754, 0.015539792366325855, -0.0404348187148571, -0.0682351142168045, -0.05396256595849991, -0.030155301094055176, 0.00929749384522438, 0.014544152654707432, 0.03163813427090645, -0.006627913098782301, 0.017101824283599854, 0.00853089988231659, -0.06985156238079071, 0.03969968855381012, 0.01824607513844967, -0.059990569949150085, -0.006634166464209557, -0.02228458598256111, 0.025061599910259247, -0.034943580627441406, -0.0017888139700517058, -0.03753754869103432, 0.006341144908219576, -0.03221619129180908, -0.02174430526793003, -0.000050441809435142204, 0.053745172917842865, -0.030684668570756912, -0.005663133226335049, -0.04621516913175583, 0.062048397958278656, -0.05340779572725296, 0.00713350297883153, -0.05452027916908264, 0.05121052637696266, 0.009407972916960716, -0.003602566197514534, 0.029132017865777016, -0.029511332511901855, 0.02603524550795555, -0.015585176646709442, -0.031201235949993134, 0.004408422391861677, 0.017087573185563087, 0.007728907745331526, 0.0059626754373312, -0.04518293961882591, -0.01449755858629942, -0.03737304359674454, -0.007965733297169209, 0.07038336992263794, 0.0400657132267952, 0.02519736811518669, 0.04116754233837128, -0.03044232353568077, -0.001793449860997498, -0.04016740247607231, -0.017099613323807716, -0.06493224948644638, -0.04967398941516876, -0.02711690217256546, -0.05756751075387001, -0.03179909661412239, -0.04625993221998215, -0.029691088944673538, -0.02161671407520771, -0.001450242823921144, -0.030261369422078133, 0.008120575919747353, 0.006516283843666315, 0.03347570449113846, -0.03889146074652672, -0.05553624406456947, 0.02501625381410122, -0.014087270945310593, -0.0033873652573674917, -0.06958958506584167, 0.016943762078881264, 0.0017638026038184762, 0.03269901126623154, -0.00900979246944189, -0.05106819421052933, 0.01044552680104971, -0.035993825644254684, 0.024943606927990913, -0.014737430028617382, 0.03399520739912987, 0.028077008202672005, 0.023464355617761612, -0.03453465551137924, -0.020667271688580513, 0.0208583977073431, -0.025565821677446365, -0.014566304162144661, -0.04968462139368057, -0.027641458436846733, -0.04499407112598419, 0.050985902547836304, 0.007006424013525248, -0.04747682809829712, -0.006006337236613035, -0.029282033443450928, 0.031678203493356705, 0.018921563401818275, -0.015386918559670448, 0.023775707930326462, 0.010382398031651974, 0.015550908632576466, -0.004447590559720993, -0.03973373398184776, 0.03912601247429848, 0.03403467684984207, -0.010216924361884594, 0.0030335572082549334, -0.016576308757066727, 0.05030403286218643, -0.09215997904539108, -0.028529778122901917, 0.02496635913848877, 0.07383809983730316, -0.040451422333717346, 0.04980645328760147, 0.01613263040781021, 0.0022174573969095945, 0.041827186942100525, 0.018637873232364655, -0.02425631321966648, 0.05595472827553749, 0.03300733491778374, -0.010908521711826324, -0.058834414929151535, 0.015620855614542961, -0.0603732168674469, -0.030309734866023064, -0.017561180517077446, -0.016820168122649193, 0.028572367504239082, 0.05569743737578392, -0.04718958958983421, -0.019538121297955513, -0.0009327779407612979, 0.03749005123972893, -0.005360009148716927, -0.06842438131570816, -0.020407147705554962, -0.04880155995488167, 0.04374990984797478, -0.029802273958921432, 0.02111123502254486, 0.05396464467048645, 0.005043637473136187, 0.015560332685709, -0.0785871148109436, 0.04588662087917328, -0.01590905338525772, -0.007025453727692366, 0.0287170372903347, 0.06013568490743637, -0.024288052693009377, 0.027057304978370667, -0.008115018717944622, -0.03501534461975098, 0.03421289846301079, -0.013252402655780315, -0.026128217577934265, 0.008112064562737942, -0.025715040042996407, 0.017414076253771782, 0.0436822883784771, -0.00620228610932827, -0.011395477689802647, 0.01871340349316597, -0.010381964966654778, 0.01123886276036501, -0.08763432502746582, 0.019496290013194084, -0.07943697273731232, 0.058651477098464966, -0.04414951056241989, -0.015248284675180912, 0.08145368099212646, -0.014623213559389114, 0.03469444066286087, -0.015085456892848015, -0.005775120574980974, 0.010917154140770435, -0.04309576004743576, -0.002730289474129677, -0.03369273990392685, 0.008530091494321823, 0.02062300592660904, 0.04863429814577103, -0.00562452943995595, 0.023641468957066536, -0.04172059893608093, -0.060135941952466965, 0.012935014441609383, 0.02944386936724186, 0.049644626677036285, 0.007429126184433699, -0.01103126909583807, 0.010777592658996582, -0.01951127126812935, 0.043360404670238495, 0.0008581263246014714, 0.0050072502344846725, -0.034983161836862564, 0.03801051899790764, 0.00423441780731082, 0.017502745613455772, 0.019665852189064026, -0.0029225351754575968, 0.07251500338315964, -0.032687537372112274, -0.03310688957571983, 0.02771715819835663, 0.01200404204428196, -0.02806088887155056, -0.05326959490776062, -0.016237230971455574, -0.024661589413881302, -0.022287046536803246, -0.03198070079088211, 0.040890470147132874, 0.03300458565354347, 0.011982858180999756, -0.0033449148759245872, 0.017056534066796303, 0.045243002474308014, -0.06184105575084686, 0.0034852849785238504, 0.04275023937225342, -0.012484990991652012, 0.017608044669032097, -0.029651369899511337, -0.08853251487016678, 0.02656465768814087, 0.006090700160712004, -0.017268285155296326, -0.006475600879639387, 0.007105881813913584, -0.004900142550468445, -0.021477503702044487, -0.08188070356845856, -0.010015029460191727, 0.04185088723897934, -0.018358130007982254, 0.03189835697412491, 0.03409423306584358, -0.050099004060029984, 0.0246370080858469, -0.04282891005277634, -0.027685636654496193, 0.04051362723112106, -0.00044298279681243, -0.040126752108335495, 0.005990443751215935, -0.028444625437259674, 0.023079615086317062, 0.03210751712322235, 0.012796097435057163, -0.03998636454343796, -0.014086767099797726, 0.03101077862083912, 0.030995920300483704, -0.004128915257751942, 0.03800377994775772, 0.017454521730542183, 0.008454553782939911, -0.011036159470677376, -0.008048336021602154, 0.025509677827358246, -0.036177366971969604, 0.007235606200993061, -0.0004365017812233418, -0.04186041280627251, 0.04973796010017395, -0.03461698070168495, -0.006719293538480997, 0.0346771664917469, -0.011106135323643684, -0.007713500875979662, -0.011751285754144192, -0.03002508543431759, -0.05228342488408089, -0.04788735881447792, 0.022252891212701797, -0.05383952707052231, -0.005584042519330978, 0.04129413515329361, 0.034974731504917145, 0.05252527445554733, -0.012386532500386238, -0.03529797121882439, -0.008004956878721714, -0.06112479791045189, 0.02849995717406273, -0.0060117184184491634, 0.03086751326918602, -0.062442708760499954, -0.004036752972751856, 0.02522028237581253, 0.019513018429279327, 0.00376046821475029, 0.029991060495376587, -0.01954258792102337, 0.022752130404114723, 0.008333263918757439, -0.06270727515220642, -0.038643304258584976, -0.001999401254579425, 0.035349417477846146, -0.041400033980607986, 0.015627199783921242, 0.017402945086359978, 0.022962981835007668, -0.031973909586668015, 0.045504529029130936, -0.03644374758005142, -0.04598183557391167, 0.014909140765666962, 0.03179362043738365, -0.05103091523051262, -0.05283835902810097, -0.043679531663656235, -0.04415931925177574, 0.010840632021427155, -0.016719074919819832, 0.0035433885641396046, 0.04922398179769516, -0.012966237962245941, -0.05985157564282417, 0.0564022958278656, -0.057811278849840164, -0.04157748073339462, -0.01805541291832924, 0.005257928743958473, -0.07122640311717987, -0.02399902604520321, 0.0077734943479299545, -0.045624036341905594, -0.06266717612743378, 0.00930817425251007, 0.03342084959149361, -0.01181303896009922, -0.034358009696006775, 0.019495371729135513, 0.06544428318738937, 0.004964048974215984, -0.0050404309295117855, 0.029092878103256226, -0.04938044026494026, 0.0014401017688214779, -0.011634018272161484, 0.0039650932885706425, -0.015386190265417099, 0.000815778796095401, -0.00847562588751316, -0.07322852313518524, -0.016222121194005013, 0.04574524983763695, -0.052138831466436386, -0.026345673948526382, 0.011442318558692932, -0.00872709695249796, 0.022615794092416763, -0.017176959663629532, -0.05591750144958496, -0.002785635879263282, 0.0057487161830067635, 0.015208977274596691, -0.03307323157787323, 0.00407900707796216, -0.010015941224992275, 0.05069323256611824, 0.02021397091448307, -0.05448472499847412, 0.023062290623784065, 0.011697459034621716, -0.08043858408927917, 0.041375335305929184, -0.04633127525448799, 0.0010247520403936505, 0.020290449261665344, 0.004701968748122454, -0.00135746446903795, 0.06230604648590088, -0.03314888849854469, -0.06863968819379807, -0.039653319865465164, 0.009639457799494267, 0.04089592397212982, -0.011235969141125679, 0.06513144075870514, 0.01385143306106329, 0.03833909332752228, 0.011264239437878132, -0.036733780056238174, 0.024162601679563522, -0.022744813933968544, 0.0038178893737494946, -0.012470213696360588, -0.007268807850778103, -0.00253970711492002, -0.04833156615495682, 0.00574782257899642, 0.004890287294983864, 0.026521654799580574, -0.030349230393767357, -0.06815993040800095, -0.043615881353616714, -0.02383108250796795, -0.018719540908932686, 0.017834734171628952, 0.008218334056437016, 0.0014896170469000936, -0.06604618579149246, 0.003726089373230934, 0.028964975848793983, -0.024816278368234634, -0.003219352336600423, -0.05999558046460152, -0.0746055468916893, 0.019509674981236458, -0.008350402116775513, -0.04518160596489906, -0.01079501211643219, 0.01138368621468544, -0.0314425528049469, 0.0043419585563242435, 0.04424938187003136, 0.017167063429951668, -0.058031000196933746, -0.0706157237291336, -0.016815049573779106, -0.032548245042562485, -0.061322662979364395, -0.04060480743646622, 0.023706750944256783, -0.00035883058444596827, -0.033257246017456055, 0.009049282409250736, 0.03249424695968628, -0.023296304047107697, 0.031189827248454094, -0.08709417283535004, -0.004908355884253979, -0.010813162662088871, 0.009703260846436024, -0.011384458281099796, -0.0425901785492897, -0.020725803449749947, -0.046907804906368256, -0.01357561070472002, 0.04634876176714897, 0.033255353569984436, -0.006663328967988491, 0.030945468693971634, -0.02527957409620285, -0.07759908586740494, -0.024783609434962273, 0.047319166362285614, 0.012178859673440456, 0.033456120640039444, 0.009366150014102459, 0.04715028032660484, 0.04799719899892807, -0.03155211731791496, 0.06747106462717056, -0.029095973819494247, 0.04921992868185043, -0.07100926339626312, 0.033567894250154495, -0.06579457968473434, -0.008441206999123096, -0.037514857947826385, -0.022343069314956665, 0.0155479172244668, 0.046041712164878845, -0.007570128422230482, 0.030371876433491707, -0.037137776613235474, -0.046930037438869476, -0.02057741768658161, 0.005835229996591806, -0.03081360273063183, 0.054095763713121414, -0.062060944736003876, -0.02822178043425083, -0.028532830998301506, -0.007425311952829361, -0.051857154816389084, 0.03892235457897186, 0.019871454685926437, -0.0351688452064991, -0.013751468621194363, -0.04967641830444336, 0.049227047711610794, -0.04694982245564461, 0.02518845722079277, -0.0429544635117054, 0.06526269763708115, -0.0005523305153474212, 0.026271268725395203, -0.03972003608942032, -0.006887630093842745, -0.05227198079228401, -0.03327339515089989, -0.029848193749785423, -0.01401494536548853, 0.025904472917318344, -0.028782665729522705, 0.023875709623098373, -0.029625579714775085, -0.008545772172510624, -0.018387706950306892, 0.04587952792644501, -0.040077995508909225, 0.05212659761309624, -0.02991834655404091, 0.08479730039834976, -0.037730637937784195, -0.013095125555992126, -0.04178931936621666, 0.04349083453416824, -0.007348901126533747, -0.05566372349858284, -0.04910098761320114, -0.06345849484205246, -0.007486993446946144, -0.05426940321922302, -0.03492126241326332, -0.028581170365214348, 0.019556375220417976, -0.07413536310195923, -0.051525406539440155, 0.037314318120479584, -0.02182679995894432, -0.06065584719181061 ]
We introduce logical synchrony, a framework that allows distributed computing to be coordinated as tightly as in synchronous systems without the distribution of a global clock or any reference to universal time. We develop a model of events called a logical synchrony network, in which nodes correspond to processors and every node has an associated local clock which generates the events. We construct a measure of logical latency and develop its properties. A further model, called a multiclock network, is then analyzed and shown to be a refinement of the logical synchrony network. We present the bittide mechanism as an instantiation of multiclock networks, and discuss the clock control mechanism that ensures that buffers do not overflow or underflow. Finally we give conditions under which a logical synchrony network has an equivalent synchronous realization.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00144v3
[ -0.03824243322014809, -0.03848714008927345, 0.022498464211821556, -0.006763224955648184, 0.04347889870405197, -0.03769727796316147, -0.028734927996993065, -0.009823630563914776, 0.0453331433236599, -0.02361086942255497, 0.006513554602861404, 0.02763761393725872, -0.041015978902578354, -0.070940762758255, -0.02105049602687359, 0.023897547274827957, 0.07832054793834686, 0.0612570084631443, -0.0647241398692131, 0.05982822924852371, -0.038399532437324524, -0.008037129417061806, -0.019337840378284454, 0.009503216482698917, -0.031308066099882126, -0.045727670192718506, -0.008272040635347366, 0.013155554421246052, -0.07097266614437103, 0.025693431496620178, 0.05082624405622482, -0.017857644706964493, 0.03126634657382965, -0.03131107985973358, -0.023649368435144424, 0.022454913705587387, -0.005393656902015209, 0.03919418528676033, 0.04311814904212952, -0.029003296047449112, 0.003556868527084589, -0.03718578815460205, -0.0595700666308403, -0.02496664971113205, 0.00877275038510561, -0.0005252531263977289, -0.05730683356523514, -0.004138413816690445, -0.024374233558773994, -0.014425019733607769, -0.0027858458925038576, 0.034194715321063995, 0.030388470739126205, 0.05506865680217743, -0.0303924810141325, -0.017991239205002785, -0.002832596655935049, 0.021549275144934654, -0.012599845416843891, -0.014302591793239117, -0.007383835501968861, -0.025157548487186432, -0.016127830371260643, -0.020032504573464394, 0.012704660184681416, 0.061725396662950516, -0.014462143182754517, -0.059645190834999084, 0.0024037479888647795, -0.024294113740324974, 0.03536241129040718, -0.07569948583841324, 0.019419347867369652, -0.010110786184668541, -0.05845613405108452, 0.011646384373307228, -0.009558777324855328, -0.029264315962791443, 0.017691895365715027, 0.015730993822216988, -0.020739620551466942, 0.006830860860645771, 0.037844497710466385, 0.020228883251547813, -0.001961461966857314, 0.039030950516462326, 0.06978988647460938, -0.002496015280485153, 0.024999642744660378, -0.05482518672943115, 0.034979283809661865, -0.05501142516732216, -0.08317486196756363, 0.0064988345839083195, 0.06662017852067947, -0.04481743276119232, 0.057492341846227646, 0.05789988860487938, -0.0371260941028595, -0.008225941099226475, -0.05811654031276703, -0.00647047208622098, -0.05280429124832153, 0.04658012092113495, 0.013574130833148956, -0.019356172531843185, 0.0006061486201360822, 0.012595899403095245, -0.04106674715876579, 0.01973060891032219, -0.041718244552612305, -0.015123322606086731, 0.034390825778245926, -0.05512998625636101, -0.0020954967476427555, -0.017994416877627373, 0.023438969627022743, -0.01595371775329113, 0.0520816445350647, -0.01379181258380413, -0.019064653664827347, 0.023488659411668777, -0.018855884671211243, -0.011568601243197918, -0.044052854180336, -0.04039463400840759, 0.06735734641551971, 0.038465991616249084, -0.000887750240508467, -0.02005067840218544, -0.022742856293916702, 0.015095346607267857, -0.022189635783433914, -0.027360830456018448, 0.03866427764296532, -0.01799117960035801, 0.04114089161157608, -0.05800950899720192, -0.04045472666621208, -0.002493091393262148, -0.035100698471069336, -0.06045396998524666, -0.003348956350237131, 0.009867197833955288, 0.04405205696821213, 0.015248788520693779, -0.060743752866983414, 0.011430950835347176, 0.02607572451233864, 0.005101311020553112, -0.014558455906808376, -0.0017327500972896814, 0.010686423629522324, -0.01106326188892126, 0.02713736891746521, -0.029976775869727135, 0.03257258981466293, -0.04223465919494629, -0.07176866382360458, 0.008683677762746811, 0.024641841650009155, -0.036007050424814224, -0.022249624133110046, -0.01588529720902443, -0.00011007118882844225, 0.015295803546905518, 0.03568677604198456, -0.03130270540714264, -0.01167810894548893, 0.0037411353550851345, -0.03517049551010132, -0.015161762945353985, 0.026627959683537483, -0.03448915854096413, -0.04344883933663368, -0.05864517763257027, -0.013982541859149933, -0.06975037604570389, 0.012660769745707512, -0.03343403339385986, -0.013143030926585197, 0.055220846086740494, 0.0061318278312683105, 0.019749803468585014, -0.04743275046348572, -0.006458095274865627, -0.07706987857818604, 0.028654346242547035, 0.05535149946808815, 0.013134834356606007, 0.011414035223424435, -0.03579910844564438, 0.0073603554628789425, 0.03701815754175186, -0.0314532034099102, -0.017037713900208473, 0.004401471000164747, -0.0736708715558052, -0.06351421028375626, 0.06623613834381104, -0.06510410457849503, 0.0052052997052669525, -0.05891164019703865, -0.0355735644698143, -0.002778952242806554, -0.03465094044804573, 0.029689613729715347, 0.007489614188671112, -0.05535658821463585, -0.04553920775651932, 0.029984470456838608, 0.02863519825041294, 0.0800701454281807, -0.0092001436278224, 0.011794707737863064, -0.008143940009176731, -0.08859699964523315, -0.009539145976305008, 0.003869620617479086, 0.0347110815346241, -0.008453436195850372, 0.0025320053100585938, -0.06062154099345207, -0.05196812376379967, -0.05242889001965523, 0.0499420128762722, 0.05474923923611641, 0.03369097039103508, -0.05404769256711006, -0.023412389680743217, -0.06119484454393387, -0.06312142312526703, -0.03393220156431198, -0.04326323792338371, -0.02413281798362732, 0.004219905938953161, -0.05767461657524109, 0.02582579292356968, 0.03148345276713371, 0.02265145070850849, -0.07084497809410095, -0.03709981590509415, 0.03299214690923691, -0.06603503972291946, -0.037525489926338196, -0.047825079411268234, -0.03621521219611168, 0.061508260667324066, -0.020166439935564995, 0.005964599549770355, 0.04614611715078354, -0.04393867403268814, -0.00977401714771986, -0.02733396179974079, 0.008697781711816788, 0.06354150176048279, -0.0655926838517189, 0.02684435248374939, 0.0052798655815422535, 0.06016363576054573, -0.016177188605070114, 0.03813127800822258, -0.06550899893045425, -0.02201082929968834, 0.00046991303679533303, -0.017342614009976387, -0.012467866763472557, -0.009335650131106377, 0.0028990954160690308, -0.029383735731244087, -0.0054054856300354, -0.00139916583430022, 0.05057835578918457, -0.047940902411937714, 0.0023238221183419228, 0.0032348129898309708, -0.011553745716810226, -0.05249757319688797, 0.019695883616805077, 0.040682993829250336, 0.04343198239803314, 0.01476411335170269, 0.025642529129981995, -0.0771419107913971, 0.03755725547671318, 0.012958086095750332, -0.010292300023138523, -0.028122572228312492, -0.03293609246611595, -0.05277362838387489, -0.07690151780843735, 0.04434605687856674, -0.044344909489154816, 0.005352403037250042, -0.06252065300941467, -0.03950889781117439, 0.003251272952184081, -0.022626107558608055, -0.007378334179520607, -0.010780513286590576, -0.060918621718883514, -0.019389504566788673, 0.05491124093532562, -0.001522972248494625, 0.038107506930828094, -0.06628620624542236, -0.002033489989116788, -0.023785695433616638, -0.006503778509795666, 0.03199236840009689, 0.016001518815755844, 0.01541412528604269, -0.03432382270693779, 0.008190104737877846, 0.005597227718681097, 0.0138265835121274, 0.004293662030249834, -0.0007641991251148283, -0.007998978719115257, -0.0009430197533220053, -0.002784815849736333, -0.013857071287930012, 0.0059426878578960896, -0.04886266589164734, -0.0711660236120224, -0.06493131071329117, 0.04306517168879509, -0.02567754127085209, -0.06337185204029083, -0.03885243460536003, 0.03664986416697502, -0.027954231947660446, 0.004061244428157806, -0.036206647753715515, 0.021829679608345032, 0.02976035699248314, 0.013589113019406796, -0.006162324920296669, -0.06867772340774536, 0.0002741240314207971, -0.012629964388906956, 0.04305984824895859, -0.0037833123933523893, -0.010488244704902172, 0.02115579880774021, -0.07911516726016998, 0.01618053950369358, 0.011680038645863533, 0.0357748419046402, -0.034569114446640015, 0.03486647084355354, 0.019488446414470673, 0.01244878489524126, -0.004151997156441212, 0.009556323289871216, -0.01722496747970581, 0.020851317793130875, 0.06454073637723923, -0.03545456379652023, 0.01625724695622921, 0.012766953557729721, -0.05531442537903786, 0.002176127629354596, 0.016616210341453552, -0.036409828811883926, 0.015450109727680683, 0.01203764695674181, -0.032914355397224426, -0.028345152735710144, -0.0482817105948925, 0.07125655561685562, -0.002879909472540021, -0.0231336560100317, 0.009270921349525452, -0.04799545928835869, -0.012595168314874172, -0.021928412839770317, 0.02031443640589714, 0.0016216951189562678, -0.026004500687122345, -0.022877592593431473, -0.08286011964082718, 0.0108642578125, -0.01086046639829874, -0.023544253781437874, 0.013144170865416527, 0.03194858133792877, -0.03156118094921112, 0.037700265645980835, 0.009902858175337315, -0.042462632060050964, 0.0026109288446605206, 0.0194109994918108, -0.002894137054681778, -0.018942009657621384, -0.035057101398706436, 0.008889297023415565, 0.0031237462535500526, 0.009736999869346619, -0.04126804322004318, 0.03664923459291458, -0.026122670620679855, 0.006280208472162485, -0.07307833433151245, -0.019263939931988716, -0.030221300199627876, 0.021278681233525276, -0.00695868581533432, -0.05029357969760895, 0.0753650814294815, -0.037607450038194656, 0.01419692113995552, -0.05438220128417015, -0.04034009948372841, -0.029377304017543793, 0.0003974422870669514, -0.002376006217673421, -0.02433360181748867, 0.030291864648461342, -0.047046516090631485, 0.03134719654917717, -0.005809769965708256, 0.026163386180996895, -0.014632323756814003, 0.0064980387687683105, 0.03649638220667839, 0.04017191752791405, 0.05459516867995262, 0.04716942831873894, 0.019411103799939156, -0.06877738237380981, -0.013901625759899616, -0.007603529375046492, -0.034899137914180756, -0.01822287030518055, -0.011855801567435265, 0.0511358343064785, -0.024203123524785042, -0.032143734395504, 0.0021295901387929916, -0.005916007794439793, 0.03916129469871521, -0.052398476749658585, -0.06958626955747604, 0.004451799672096968, 0.06116683781147003, -0.04822937399148941, -0.029571067541837692, 0.004732916131615639, -0.017169788479804993, -0.07040209323167801, -0.01672274060547352, 0.017986025661230087, 0.03879281133413315, -0.021114995703101158, 0.04067688062787056, 0.0029012649320065975, 0.008560414426028728, -0.017041148617863655, 0.024629369378089905, 0.031409114599227905, -0.03486098721623421, -0.03019149973988533, -0.01712002605199814, -0.044316619634628296, -0.04351034387946129, 0.010579787194728851, -0.00250232988037169, -0.032323043793439865, 0.05359967425465584, 0.03497357293963432, 0.02159799076616764, -0.08215060830116272, 0.03795372694730759, 0.022328615188598633, -0.053516704589128494, 0.048510562628507614, 0.038946546614170074, -0.03468526899814606, 0.03313661366701126, -0.04273519665002823, -0.05768246576189995, 0.058212313801050186, -0.010012581944465637, -0.004530543461441994, 0.055735908448696136, -0.020851457491517067, -0.01155270915478468, 0.035715389996767044, -0.008760150521993637, -0.002935112686827779, -0.004842003341764212, 0.028330717235803604, -0.008384804241359234, -0.030484501272439957, 0.013540903106331825, 0.052205394953489304, -0.0059517668560147285, 0.00980315450578928, 0.023270856589078903, 0.014679341576993465, -0.006431290414184332, 0.027674751356244087, -0.007654826622456312, 0.015579926781356335, 0.042605210095644, -0.05179794132709503, 0.024011464789509773, 0.049638595432043076, 0.035303644835948944, 0.028232086449861526, 0.01782468520104885, 0.038662753999233246, -0.03470538929104805, -0.008948895148932934, 0.022632170468568802, -0.01507297158241272, 0.024181660264730453, 0.03431802615523338, 0.01240864209830761, -0.0005304228980094194, -0.006413666997104883, -0.04209238663315773, -0.01724591851234436, -0.03808443248271942, 0.02303687110543251, -0.04213642328977585, 0.005147073417901993, -0.039625927805900574, 0.03230534866452217, -0.030925588682293892, 0.026404760777950287, -0.00178409309592098, -0.020842518657445908, -0.01844748854637146, -0.015020482242107391, 0.014512419700622559, -0.05916667357087135, -0.06439883261919022, 0.018261374905705452, 0.04588015377521515, -0.030777491629123688, 0.024255061522126198, 0.0500798262655735, -0.020527664572000504, 0.014796409755945206, 0.021698055788874626, -0.004299737513065338, -0.014435687102377415, -0.006703485269099474, 0.06591074913740158, -0.0653499960899353, -0.02406887896358967, -0.04966605082154274, -0.0333314947783947, -0.013945751823484898, -0.041594382375478745, 0.015502726659178734, 0.023458344861865044, -0.003724244423210621, -0.06819773465394974, 0.052898332476615906, -0.0392952598631382, -0.048497073352336884, -0.042119525372982025, 0.007925376296043396, -0.05480346828699112, 0.029763825237751007, 0.02778378687798977, -0.01654861308634281, -0.016369476914405823, 0.020245596766471863, -0.032834555953741074, -0.002386248903349042, -0.050714097917079926, 0.0715838074684143, 0.07917476445436478, -0.033091407269239426, -0.038228072226047516, 0.04084744304418564, -0.03425607830286026, 0.034452885389328, -0.027849549427628517, 0.006274515762925148, 0.005352414678782225, 0.009343295358121395, -0.020607085898518562, -0.03987034037709236, -0.00525914691388607, 0.040350541472435, -0.04778267443180084, -0.04378034546971321, -0.016927028074860573, 0.038205645978450775, 0.05762540549039841, -0.03652144968509674, -0.03997211903333664, -0.03246967867016792, 0.0072119878605008125, -0.03030867502093315, -0.028858058154582977, 0.04987548291683197, -0.003921916708350182, 0.03148316964507103, -0.018417466431856155, -0.034476857632398605, 0.0063545964658260345, 0.004897711798548698, -0.061466753482818604, -0.017977586016058922, -0.06132860109210014, -0.014390324242413044, -0.04629318788647652, 0.03792830929160118, 0.06057974323630333, 0.03691687807440758, 0.017178231850266457, -0.03982297331094742, -0.01504920981824398, -0.003971260506659746, 0.016631651669740677, -0.00013556383782997727, -0.015938838943839073, 0.010469375178217888, 0.0513094961643219, -0.04305831715464592, -0.018987441435456276, 0.00022644829005002975, -0.06433264166116714, 0.04143490642309189, -0.025460517033934593, -0.010990016162395477, -0.02401026338338852, -0.02710545063018799, -0.056980282068252563, -0.012434655800461769, 0.047744691371917725, -0.04591266065835953, -0.02835150621831417, 0.03408931568264961, 0.007721401751041412, 0.0074965800158679485, -0.016424117609858513, 0.016820009797811508, -0.013627411797642708, -0.024433976039290428, 0.06690014153718948, 0.020754175260663033, 0.04118835926055908, -0.039805617183446884, -0.06317711621522903, -0.04876803606748581, 0.046257033944129944, -0.01159172784537077, -0.05000995099544525, -0.0679226741194725, -0.03139721229672432, -0.045362815260887146, 0.0060991523787379265, 0.06524401903152466, -0.051897212862968445, -0.04196001589298248, -0.07181496173143387, 0.044527389109134674, 0.02663610689342022, -0.07654611021280289, -0.07514505088329315, 0.032627858221530914, -0.008880608715116978, -0.013057324104011059, -0.002087901346385479, 0.02502172812819481, -0.03277500718832016, -0.003674318315461278, -0.08088791370391846, -0.018803231418132782, -0.037646230310201645, 0.054617058485746384, -0.018622759729623795, 0.006963042076677084, -0.01854916289448738, -0.06233084201812744, 0.019059577956795692, 0.040885988622903824, 0.0195124801248312, 0.015846841037273407, 0.0014785300008952618, 0.003986738622188568, -0.05815904214978218, -0.012304346077144146, 0.060180485248565674, -0.04638815298676491, -0.024606876075267792, 0.05975981801748276, 0.04818437993526459, 0.0397159606218338, -0.02249128371477127, -0.006566100288182497, -0.0012795829679816961, 0.036027196794748306, -0.026910429820418358, 0.015922078862786293, -0.06578969210386276, -0.066653773188591, 0.04778106510639191, -0.044058043509721756, 0.028129810467362404, 0.02835402637720108, -0.017072588205337524, 0.0025280758272856474, -0.03879319131374359, -0.07056965678930283, 0.045443907380104065, 0.004106838256120682, 0.007413316518068314, 0.05514403432607651, -0.036779746413230896, 0.01381593942642212, -0.02997209131717682, 0.017365146428346634, -0.00932079367339611, 0.04844123125076294, 0.0166865773499012, -0.04430542141199112, 0.020505130290985107, -0.05182778462767601, 0.0660799965262413, -0.02020624466240406, 0.0021324437111616135, -0.012024953961372375, 0.05053344741463661, -0.025279993191361427, 0.038134340196847916, -0.03662201762199402, -0.01632837764918804, -0.04351562261581421, -0.05059455707669258, -0.0066650123335421085, -0.03240157291293144, 0.02007143385708332, -0.019456028938293457, 0.07146342098712921, 0.01308557391166687, 0.030733201652765274, 0.046446286141872406, 0.03537615016102791, 0.011752710677683353, 0.03818320855498314, -0.061623118817806244, 0.04936014115810394, -0.008559352718293667, -0.054305702447891235, -0.0461384654045105, 0.035468216985464096, 0.011441127397119999, 0.007952895946800709, -0.058844324201345444, -0.04177146032452583, 0.025957511737942696, -0.048319410532712936, -0.012335874140262604, 0.03696655109524727, -0.025038141757249832, -0.043073490262031555, 0.011068263091146946, 0.02529740147292614, -0.01483302004635334, -0.04986301064491272 ]
Axions and axion-like particles (ALPs) are one of the most widely discussed extensions of the Standard Model when it comes to the strong CP problem and dark matter candidates. Current experiments are focused on the indirect searches of invisible pseudoscalars in a wide parameter range. In this paper we investigate limits on ALP mass, and its couplings to photons and leptons from 3-photon annihilation at $e^+e^-$ colliders. We provide detailed calculations and apply them to the particular kinematics of the Belle II experiment, covering the ALP mass range from few hundred MeV to around 10 GeV. Our results, which improve upon previous analyses by also including the ALP coupling to electrons, show that such future analyses will allow to significantly extend the ALP search range and impose much more stringent restrictions on their couplings.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15106v2
[ -0.0014588076155632734, 0.026200400665402412, 0.04472583159804344, 0.033861272037029266, -0.005334231536835432, 0.02420051582157612, -0.010626566596329212, 0.003778131678700447, -0.04048139229416847, -0.02703974023461342, -0.01941126585006714, -0.01507923286408186, -0.010795886628329754, -0.06313913315534592, -0.03624344989657402, 0.012400923296809196, 0.03233296051621437, 0.013180462643504143, -0.03789260610938072, 0.046121589839458466, 0.040702544152736664, 0.010210310108959675, -0.022163135930895805, 0.024769213050603867, 0.017517419531941414, 0.007315166760236025, 0.006775031331926584, 0.01105476077646017, -0.05284499749541283, -0.07726041972637177, 0.04058035835623741, 0.028769364580512047, -0.019635042175650597, -0.011295214295387268, -0.01832282729446888, -0.02901020646095276, 0.020498599857091904, 0.024538088589906693, 0.04596484825015068, -0.008430641144514084, 0.01747492514550686, -0.019250601530075073, -0.06686616688966751, 0.006832150276750326, -0.005182542372494936, -0.023073652759194374, -0.04342672601342201, 0.06128111854195595, -0.07353512197732925, -0.06691119074821472, 0.019092919304966927, -0.014752482995390892, -0.03329465165734291, 0.04499521106481552, -0.06209585443139076, -0.025957785546779633, -0.0015425494639202952, 0.012766972184181213, -0.05945822596549988, 0.007264290936291218, -0.01905360072851181, -0.015612687915563583, -0.014799521304666996, -0.025506416335701942, -0.031032448634505272, 0.06318916380405426, 0.017168167978525162, -0.047818806022405624, -0.028717612847685814, -0.062474675476551056, 0.04264725744724274, -0.03675026074051857, -0.018757810816168785, 0.03149588778614998, -0.04064949229359627, -0.0151447718963027, -0.022894419729709625, -0.032945677638053894, -0.027089538052678108, 0.03266286849975586, -0.05935584008693695, 0.04030752554535866, 0.03685855120420456, 0.005367941223084927, -0.026424791663885117, -0.0028541856445372105, 0.022038666531443596, -0.034827712923288345, -0.019970910623669624, 0.0038211550563573837, 0.04355219006538391, -0.005637519992887974, -0.04475950822234154, 0.03017028421163559, 0.07175499200820923, -0.032492201775312424, 0.050807371735572815, 0.04291841760277748, 0.04171878471970558, 0.0007395630236715078, 0.028380990028381348, -0.04002585634589195, -0.022860238328576088, 0.05185972526669502, 0.00826331228017807, -0.021482545882463455, 0.044750310480594635, -0.05197694152593613, -0.051718875765800476, 0.05017649382352829, 0.013245007023215294, -0.00006393629882950336, -0.009243964217603207, -0.05654124170541763, -0.0298687182366848, -0.06403093785047531, 0.01283718179911375, -0.01996411569416523, 0.02931455336511135, 0.02606029622256756, -0.00023692802642472088, 0.05554566532373428, 0.04076835513114929, 0.013760972768068314, -0.012304475530982018, 0.03060651570558548, 0.059847380965948105, -0.008028269745409489, 0.007143047638237476, -0.055556636303663254, -0.019507424905896187, 0.0032853176817297935, 0.027974694967269897, 0.0011066810693591833, 0.038014017045497894, -0.041949037462472916, -0.010395563207566738, 0.012726139277219772, -0.01581592485308647, 0.005798928905278444, -0.04467282444238663, -0.03179433196783066, 0.04443497955799103, -0.03845130279660225, -0.04750527814030647, 0.03920483961701393, -0.05902928113937378, -0.033616140484809875, 0.024709420278668404, 0.020346762612462044, 0.013589221052825451, 0.04840640351176262, -0.010989701375365257, -0.03652151674032211, -0.010633150115609169, 0.014564341865479946, 0.033156514167785645, 0.003917118534445763, 0.02263312041759491, -0.00016170430171769112, 0.004644356202334166, 0.0020331144332885742, -0.029105113819241524, 0.0004714489623438567, -0.004374236799776554, -0.014069531112909317, -0.014307022094726562, -0.02010231465101242, -0.011156001128256321, 0.0007082246011123061, -0.06958948075771332, 0.026506619527935982, 0.008392333053052425, -0.045556798577308655, -0.0710834413766861, 0.022744450718164444, -0.02149498090147972, -0.05143818259239197, -0.06587785482406616, -0.00020538635726552457, 0.06365610659122467, 0.03016202710568905, -0.0411946177482605, -0.0192074254155159, -0.035055503249168396, 0.03787379711866379, -0.08488083630800247, -0.0019515473395586014, 0.01717282086610794, 0.012852231971919537, -0.02827342413365841, -0.02481192536652088, 0.05057266727089882, 0.021227169781923294, -0.011510550044476986, -0.05564498156309128, 0.04708883538842201, 0.0048853326588869095, -0.020696694031357765, 0.025066278874874115, -0.0860462561249733, -0.014048528857529163, 0.00048419806989841163, 0.0030943432357162237, 0.019119445234537125, -0.07676916569471359, 0.03658118471503258, 0.0068884920328855515, -0.031949810683727264, 0.0031249108724296093, 0.07814264297485352, 0.06892045587301254, 0.028856201097369194, 0.031072750687599182, -0.006273162085562944, 0.015620381571352482, -0.10573449730873108, 0.05555978789925575, 0.0461454875767231, -0.009901524521410465, 0.047922711819410324, 0.02241705171763897, 0.011027018539607525, 0.02057696506381035, -0.010425990447402, 0.0673353299498558, -0.005955995060503483, -0.022016290575265884, -0.018892481923103333, -0.024185821413993835, 0.022839931771159172, -0.040632862597703934, -0.029913974925875664, -0.057018306106328964, -0.01843765750527382, 0.0021048402413725853, -0.033731188625097275, 0.028650615364313126, -0.015894507989287376, -0.07814513891935349, 0.008368076756596565, 0.006455400958657265, 0.05259716510772705, -0.015703482553362846, -0.037705034017562866, 0.010608120821416378, -0.04489544779062271, 0.029944175854325294, -0.009979307651519775, -0.023221183568239212, -0.0159441027790308, -0.03427433967590332, -0.010126815177500248, -0.026383178308606148, 0.0065100896172225475, 0.016930686309933662, -0.042373403906822205, -0.01700887270271778, -0.0203850157558918, 0.04965856298804283, 0.035789914429187775, 0.03709978237748146, -0.04268645495176315, 0.011591121554374695, 0.06896163523197174, 0.043736476451158524, -0.035318709909915924, -0.00313176354393363, 0.007147863041609526, 0.032488878816366196, -0.010699780657887459, 0.053665705025196075, 0.025724703446030617, 0.041179828345775604, -0.013163774274289608, -0.029186556115746498, -0.04358486086130142, -0.018629781901836395, 0.0005487924790941179, 0.03717169538140297, 0.02380499430000782, 0.03167193755507469, -0.00003943566116504371, -0.07262518256902695, -0.06760240346193314, -0.05878065526485443, -0.008206874132156372, -0.03479326143860817, -0.03380986675620079, -0.0005538144614547491, -0.08866339176893234, 0.00007940258365124464, -0.010835172608494759, -0.04333478957414627, -0.046933963894844055, -0.04057646542787552, -0.004081252962350845, -0.02563249133527279, 0.036188192665576935, -0.03644024208188057, -0.046231068670749664, 0.025799734517931938, 0.0032249572686851025, 0.03233236074447632, -0.0064638638868927956, -0.056260693818330765, -0.06125057861208916, 0.03085564821958542, 0.04212789982557297, -0.020407479256391525, -0.03190454840660095, 0.02462204359471798, -0.061714719980955124, 0.042083561420440674, 0.024128222838044167, 0.06878504902124405, -0.005047507584095001, -0.02903694286942482, -0.03520887345075607, 0.002607037778943777, -0.009853278286755085, -0.03325733169913292, -0.027551352977752686, -0.009886014275252819, -0.05377298220992088, -0.0037553985603153706, 0.06016046926379204, 0.06951577216386795, 0.019293367862701416, 0.008588630706071854, -0.04036520794034004, 0.028027022257447243, 0.05771665275096893, 0.01769200526177883, 0.04871316999197006, 0.008906884118914604, -0.044220663607120514, -0.004295260179787874, -0.031003020703792572, 0.017371946945786476, 0.003102645743638277, -0.027051551267504692, -0.028468696400523186, -0.023048710078001022, 0.01848468743264675, -0.08502500504255295, 0.04492863640189171, 0.01776416413486004, 0.07977373898029327, -0.020344054326415062, -0.038480281829833984, 0.044256750494241714, 0.017545120790600777, -0.0016006204532459378, -0.03579599782824516, 0.035101115703582764, 0.036877043545246124, 0.03951649367809296, -0.03473164513707161, -0.011074530892074108, -0.03379938006401062, -0.05002439767122269, -0.07631466537714005, 0.011059192940592766, 0.039548058062791824, 0.04411965236067772, 0.03934183344244957, -0.015871556475758553, 0.011547129601240158, -0.0024197555612772703, 0.06206308677792549, -0.036254942417144775, -0.03623335063457489, -0.002164606237784028, 0.007825452834367752, 0.023950060829520226, 0.03740107640624046, -0.034434378147125244, -0.009043966419994831, -0.047596417367458344, 0.032878950238227844, -0.0680842325091362, 0.04768099635839462, 0.05095895752310753, 0.024810610339045525, 0.028081897646188736, 0.016102319583296776, 0.05281103402376175, 0.02255520410835743, -0.01785093918442726, -0.04153531417250633, -0.03301238268613815, 0.02247019298374653, 0.03319070115685463, -0.004791003651916981, -0.00577169144526124, 0.017963873222470284, 0.05233250930905342, -0.06487618386745453, -0.02482067048549652, 0.013740330934524536, 0.022823244333267212, 0.0031242617405951023, -0.09293220937252045, -0.07161035388708115, -0.050113189965486526, 0.010434559546411037, -0.03336541727185249, -0.014001833274960518, 0.06594391912221909, -0.05813183635473251, 0.035615887492895126, -0.009363727644085884, 0.008162027224898338, -0.027189981192350388, -0.03227148950099945, -0.01813836768269539, -0.03964919224381447, 0.027545403689146042, -0.017386971041560173, 0.03362451493740082, 0.022135157138109207, -0.030124256387352943, -0.08497433364391327, 0.0005181412561796606, -0.0021331042516976595, 0.02041579782962799, 0.048537477850914, -0.02749190293252468, -0.000161954274517484, 0.003966505639255047, 0.021492211148142815, 0.00677379360422492, 0.03159854933619499, 0.04594377800822258, -0.023835215717554092, 0.05376558005809784, 0.015210973098874092, -0.015531112439930439, -0.006337224971503019, -0.02808745950460434, 0.05759182199835777, -0.05189000815153122, 0.014155485667288303, 0.0034402008168399334, 0.0028891507536172867, -0.04135410860180855, -0.06023868918418884, 0.013755980879068375, -0.006983295548707247, -0.054900314658880234, -0.03709319606423378, 0.054140567779541016, -0.007744256407022476, 0.024843202903866768, -0.019943712279200554, -0.03517909348011017, 0.030858200043439865, -0.0241900272667408, -0.0006073957192711532, -0.02353505790233612, -0.014427625574171543, 0.03057084046304226, 0.008380018174648285, -0.08207620680332184, 0.014981802552938461, -0.0010185546707361937, -0.04732218012213707, -0.025044413283467293, 0.014033286832273006, -0.02464640885591507, 0.05795032158493996, -0.0839538648724556, 0.020953699946403503, 0.04691702499985695, -0.017158908769488335, -0.004688095301389694, 0.006317867431789637, 0.011277087964117527, 0.02428189106285572, -0.026572128757834435, -0.0099937804043293, -0.015675770118832588, -0.011969024315476418, 0.017047876492142677, -0.026011956855654716, -0.0562918558716774, 0.007826708257198334, 0.047299522906541824, -0.0036485118325799704, -0.05243612825870514, 0.015310006216168404, 0.0255851112306118, -0.002705745864659548, -0.00026611832436174154, 0.009573716670274734, 0.04215254262089729, -0.047504816204309464, -0.057660214602947235, -0.024244895204901695, 0.027658723294734955, 0.02363085001707077, 0.03324862942099571, -0.0334053635597229, -0.044832225888967514, 0.009383507072925568, -0.004208604339510202, -0.0261930450797081, 0.0360402837395668, -0.0019959094934165478, 0.0019963199738413095, -0.04006340727210045, -0.0159227903932333, -0.08501891791820526, 0.02088121511042118, -0.0829310491681099, -0.015540964901447296, -0.002071514492854476, 0.043466486036777496, 0.011832687072455883, 0.043876904994249344, 0.002227434888482094, -0.05876350402832031, -0.04384824261069298, 0.0027907814364880323, 0.06187484413385391, -0.021505845710635185, -0.013202897273004055, 0.023151395842432976, 0.05018282309174538, 0.016298778355121613, 0.0008424471598118544, 0.04153157025575638, 0.012959909625351429, -0.027654755860567093, 0.032617006450891495, 0.00530190160498023, -0.00022617183276452124, -0.0246865376830101, -0.010451111942529678, 0.037486035376787186, -0.01686386950314045, 0.06369174271821976, 0.014817488379776478, -0.017201462760567665, 0.04229944944381714, -0.002377206925302744, -0.05819666013121605, -0.04171508923172951, 0.019220253452658653, 0.07402535527944565, -0.07670053094625473, 0.012411377392709255, -0.04048459604382515, -0.04172734171152115, 0.04412960633635521, -0.04370012506842613, -0.005544745828956366, 0.03648117184638977, 0.03807927295565605, -0.04661805182695389, 0.053154438734054565, -0.004316226579248905, -0.05222814530134201, 0.01212967000901699, -0.0031318478286266327, -0.06195863336324692, 0.0029787239618599415, 0.027911966666579247, 0.017898764461278915, -0.0029234052635729313, 0.03378334268927574, 0.019651619717478752, -0.03052099049091339, -0.009704610332846642, 0.08425727486610413, 0.06611624360084534, -0.03765348345041275, 0.035733360797166824, 0.004017164930701256, -0.007374386768788099, -0.03178611025214195, -0.05480455607175827, -0.0402199886739254, -0.02179759368300438, 0.06038082018494606, -0.004946643020957708, -0.06639908254146576, -0.026516443118453026, 0.020962197333574295, -0.04912528023123741, 0.03761077672243118, 0.0010781422024592757, -0.008089234121143818, 0.04314052686095238, -0.052851028740406036, -0.037229109555482864, 0.029974810779094696, -0.03775573894381523, 0.030317602679133415, -0.03109024651348591, -0.007081538438796997, -0.02437678538262844, 0.025657249614596367, 0.0042993552051484585, -0.053572267293930054, 0.011426515877246857, -0.04231133684515953, -0.04623725265264511, 0.013619179837405682, -0.06543410569429398, -0.0398833192884922, 0.03456294164061546, 0.004293219652026892, -0.02600901573896408, 0.0645478293299675, -0.03491097316145897, -0.02274598740041256, -0.05208253860473633, -0.028461763635277748, -0.009783520363271236, 0.02656019851565361, 0.05389201268553734, -0.06256990134716034, 0.03134483844041824, -0.04450815171003342, 0.027942830696702003, 0.014160510152578354, -0.04074486717581749, -0.008084431290626526, 0.0381491519510746, -0.05468176305294037, -0.0361395999789238, 0.01759067364037037, -0.01666957139968872, 0.029088107869029045, -0.025229956954717636, 0.00018854966037906706, -0.05578060448169708, -0.01634575054049492, -0.03834584355354309, -0.016064299270510674, 0.03299478068947792, 0.0040955799631774426, 0.040293555706739426, -0.051698677241802216, -0.011377546004951, 0.02873651497066021, 0.003301105462014675, 0.013755936175584793, -0.034766122698783875, -0.006158795207738876, 0.01922960765659809, 0.008623500354588032, -0.051230475306510925, -0.0012258925708010793, -0.027948278933763504, -0.06653062999248505, -0.008460406213998795, 0.0036067089531570673, 0.03111661598086357, -0.025196585804224014, -0.03870842978358269, 0.016010180115699768, 0.04288814961910248, -0.052509505301713943, -0.07483003288507462, -0.009187913499772549, 0.005640403367578983, 0.01784083992242813, 0.018550055101513863, -0.049334049224853516, -0.03193120285868645, -0.014858916401863098, -0.094977006316185, -0.02801930159330368, -0.03296906501054764, 0.007887067273259163, 0.006929193623363972, -0.026943741366267204, 0.024045264348387718, -0.01368285808712244, 0.0314505472779274, 0.03400883823633194, -0.028603781014680862, -0.0076491194777190685, -0.008003593422472477, 0.019322264939546585, -0.02622392401099205, 0.0008874250343069434, 0.016276834532618523, -0.03127710893750191, -0.014253180474042892, -0.021049002185463905, -0.0018901391886174679, -0.03244145214557648, 0.012229767628014088, 0.07384265214204788, -0.0370001383125782, 0.035382021218538284, -0.05296836420893669, 0.003727346658706665, -0.051292214542627335, -0.06263305246829987, 0.04448120296001434, -0.045364171266555786, 0.0397898331284523, 0.011160782538354397, 0.009335861541330814, -0.04570935666561127, 0.010945221409201622, -0.04271600395441055, -0.024014992639422417, 0.012295224703848362, -0.010774374939501286, 0.05682278424501419, -0.07354184240102768, -0.005558127537369728, 0.008592811413109303, 0.00042118545388802886, -0.0752084031701088, 0.031071651726961136, 0.06609329581260681, -0.05885523557662964, -0.00014560521231032908, -0.08264914155006409, 0.023469146341085434, -0.03583890199661255, 0.028816109523177147, 0.03308684378862381, -0.0014817436458542943, -0.040436599403619766, -0.003486026544123888, -0.053278613835573196, -0.039923276752233505, 0.004408888518810272, -0.06529311835765839, -0.034535933285951614, -0.031936585903167725, 0.01934906467795372, 0.014831207692623138, 0.00719468155875802, -0.041586734354496, 0.054465197026729584, 0.0001888313563540578, -0.055453360080718994, -0.013799364678561687, -0.04061638563871384, -0.006168074440211058, 0.06564236432313919, -0.003961130511015654, 0.032158102840185165, -0.06262874603271484, 0.02561035193502903, 0.003738321363925934, 0.02357848547399044, 0.017803244292736053, -0.0028046497609466314, -0.007674964610487223, -0.06560364365577698, -0.028626974672079086, 0.019083179533481598, 0.03071230836212635, 0.01593855954706669, -0.030723409727215767, 0.046771157532930374, -0.009194113314151764, -0.07226289063692093 ]
We propose a new boson expansion method using a norm operator. The small parameter expansion, in which the boson approximation becomes the zeroth-order approximation, requires the double commutation relations between phonon operators that are not closed between the phonon excitation modes adopted as boson excitations. This results in an infinite expansion regardless of whether the type of the boson expansion is Hermitian or non-Hermitian. The small parameter expansion does not hold when the commutation relations are closed. The norm operator is expressed as a function of the number operator in the physical subspace, which enables us to obtain substantially a finite boson expansion regardless of the Hermitian or non-Hermitian type. We also point out the problems of the conventional boson expansion methods. The normal-ordered linked-cluster expansion theory has failed to refute Marshalek's claim that KT-1 and KT-2 are of chimerical boson expansion. The Dyson boson expansion theory does not have exceptional superiority over other types. Previous studies using the boson expansion methods should be re-examined.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17986v2
[ -0.010643670335412025, -0.007330961525440216, -0.016692351549863815, 0.06007144972681999, 0.05548989400267601, -0.02043520100414753, -0.06328495591878891, 0.012446176260709763, -0.008594469167292118, 0.03559202328324318, -0.008359372615814209, -0.04519962519407272, -0.045438848435878754, -0.06680688261985779, -0.021296387538313866, -0.013507843017578125, 0.06757725775241852, 0.034871455281972885, -0.03464193269610405, 0.049190644174814224, -0.012771893292665482, -0.03750527277588844, -0.017786363139748573, 0.01990467496216297, -0.02779453434050083, -0.019844625145196915, -0.034801386296749115, 0.004007759504020214, -0.048547666519880295, 0.022647246718406677, 0.06645644456148148, -0.07214245945215225, 0.038421329110860825, -0.031661126762628555, -0.03511500731110573, -0.01923055201768875, -0.026523848995566368, 0.014452497474849224, 0.03803238645195961, -0.02626299299299717, -0.006232750602066517, -0.01670265942811966, -0.029188666492700577, 0.036798086017370224, -0.01306457445025444, -0.05108889937400818, -0.024017557501792908, 0.005592019762843847, -0.03657364845275879, -0.07871735841035843, 0.04448370262980461, 0.019021231681108475, 0.01295947004109621, 0.00207280064933002, -0.048839062452316284, -0.037620481103658676, -0.005608436185866594, -0.021010635420680046, -0.0829710140824318, -0.013214710168540478, -0.03365242853760719, -0.013870407827198505, 0.03787943720817566, -0.015069272369146347, 0.01567382737994194, 0.05335991829633713, -0.035391878336668015, -0.07422085106372833, -0.05433610454201698, -0.048667509108781815, 0.03374604135751724, -0.05855076014995575, 0.00623437250033021, 0.06056129187345505, -0.0438573881983757, 0.0037807421758770943, -0.009605618193745613, -0.05615503340959549, -0.0011268423404544592, 0.027053719386458397, -0.0259430892765522, 0.0740434005856514, 0.01035245880484581, -0.04729672893881798, 0.00703776441514492, 0.02295757830142975, 0.06669801473617554, 0.003808774286881089, 0.017664173617959023, -0.07695382088422775, 0.04810858517885208, -0.048485465347766876, -0.05474534258246422, -0.024950075894594193, 0.0756707638502121, -0.06317546218633652, 0.06671848893165588, 0.07097692787647247, -0.003603174351155758, 0.0051923152059316635, 0.04485867917537689, -0.06637588888406754, -0.01833348348736763, 0.034117866307497025, -0.020854966714978218, -0.026198122650384903, -0.01894369162619114, -0.007104440126568079, -0.010108222253620625, 0.03468437120318413, -0.020915422588586807, 0.012912401929497719, 0.024347824975848198, -0.05749490112066269, 0.0005183347384445369, -0.02135876566171646, 0.05813893303275108, 0.01973467878997326, 0.027330521494150162, -0.016063574701547623, -0.005514572840183973, 0.039617449045181274, 0.01091392058879137, 0.021555844694375992, -0.020482826977968216, 0.002430001040920615, 0.0866723358631134, 0.04627195745706558, -0.028999797999858856, 0.013568103313446045, -0.01653240993618965, 0.0024070311337709427, 0.02272263914346695, 0.026353605091571808, 0.05970020964741707, 0.026112210005521774, 0.0459374263882637, -0.021013276651501656, 0.02270137518644333, 0.026288459077477455, -0.023739967495203018, -0.04453718289732933, 0.05745205655694008, 0.00525352219119668, 0.022981399670243263, -0.002233735518530011, -0.07386099547147751, -0.010430969297885895, 0.0480184368789196, 0.01993759535253048, 0.005932915490120649, 0.00018345822172705084, 0.01110909879207611, 0.0015614500734955072, 0.0011012606555595994, -0.01282269973307848, 0.03308078646659851, 0.009739675559103489, 0.017208753153681755, 0.0018006529426202178, 0.04102532938122749, 0.009423190727829933, -0.007195604033768177, 0.05357658863067627, 0.01618044264614582, -0.006100441794842482, 0.03831900656223297, -0.02616947330534458, -0.02723185159265995, 0.04820328578352928, -0.05344022065401077, -0.016073208302259445, 0.028314827010035515, -0.033306002616882324, -0.014604425989091396, -0.0007643431308679283, -0.032007843255996704, -0.015441784635186195, -0.01007064525038004, 0.023608187213540077, -0.003577012103050947, 0.009119695983827114, -0.04128091037273407, 0.00667237862944603, -0.03282168507575989, -0.04894285649061203, -0.07501475512981415, -0.011271404102444649, 0.024129675701260567, 0.011702504009008408, -0.01369063463062048, -0.03717011585831642, 0.042053256183862686, 0.011037813499569893, -0.014547795057296753, -0.025976834818720818, 0.03493831306695938, -0.04020068421959877, 0.01962227374315262, 0.03745085746049881, -0.0785345733165741, -0.056744251400232315, -0.027572711929678917, -0.033109311014413834, -0.02025020681321621, -0.06208963692188263, 0.012739946134388447, 0.049772828817367554, -0.03614502772688866, 0.0005308861727826297, 0.04369645565748215, 0.04156213253736496, 0.03184324875473976, -0.014395498670637608, 0.021706288680434227, 0.034418318420648575, -0.10331248492002487, 0.023850755766034126, -0.006839666981250048, -0.016808319836854935, -0.014239897951483727, 0.04021061211824417, -0.02592126652598381, -0.014335925690829754, -0.03980081155896187, 0.03783886879682541, 0.049406055361032486, 0.009127103723585606, -0.059581197798252106, -0.013550552539527416, -0.02936455048620701, -0.03749452903866768, -0.04930955916643143, -0.018517525866627693, -0.0592978335916996, 0.006050126161426306, -0.03851946443319321, 0.06500352919101715, 0.01623617112636566, -0.056227367371320724, -0.07430347800254822, 0.0169894527643919, 0.04534154012799263, -0.003954451065510511, -0.023463891819119453, -0.01738603040575981, -0.051547273993492126, 0.015974698588252068, -0.03913617506623268, 0.012662366032600403, 0.005726470611989498, -0.06232881918549538, 0.01822161115705967, -0.014826099388301373, 0.0027299155481159687, 0.03933808207511902, -0.038266267627477646, 0.00912475399672985, 0.03492993861436844, -0.006941603496670723, -0.025875842198729515, -0.006398290395736694, -0.01061037927865982, 0.005402478389441967, 0.02842392586171627, 0.003957683220505714, -0.052843447774648666, -0.015266145579516888, -0.004053842276334763, -0.022154884412884712, 0.01885359361767769, 0.021857818588614464, 0.07085117697715759, 0.040553685277700424, 0.019149059429764748, -0.016326745972037315, 0.005894686561077833, -0.026435410603880882, 0.030828211456537247, -0.0050658173859119415, 0.011366814374923706, 0.05326204001903534, -0.01806466653943062, -0.055980805307626724, -0.012600054033100605, -0.011558687314391136, -0.01917088031768799, -0.05406901612877846, -0.058584652841091156, -0.02770773321390152, -0.07523989677429199, 0.016632821410894394, -0.00386024103499949, -0.022482264786958694, -0.07181201875209808, -0.020781200379133224, 0.0079791359603405, -0.024222027510404587, 0.034634485840797424, -0.07017560303211212, -0.047853514552116394, -0.0017505104187875986, 0.03576561436057091, 0.0508611686527729, 0.006417523603886366, -0.0647808089852333, -0.03778529912233353, 0.0014225183986127377, -0.014192835427820683, 0.026466945186257362, -0.04508485272526741, -0.019513284787535667, -0.03214797377586365, 0.0016683141002431512, 0.034193217754364014, 0.053902655839920044, 0.03547148406505585, -0.01592969335615635, 0.011278873309493065, -0.02857346273958683, -0.0009740196401253343, 0.004147083964198828, -0.02241230197250843, 0.003416740335524082, -0.05406928062438965, -0.018918802961707115, 0.06597922742366791, 0.05726517364382744, -0.02156771719455719, -0.02976110205054283, -0.023436440154910088, -0.025305846706032753, 0.00358507945202291, -0.04725745692849159, 0.035281673073768616, 0.014706914313137531, -0.0032314222771674395, -0.05997179448604584, -0.03895832970738411, 0.056596674025058746, -0.012419799342751503, 0.020995935425162315, -0.001796396099962294, -0.042553436011075974, 0.024058884009718895, -0.06480619311332703, 0.02919345535337925, 0.053594984114170074, 0.03872200846672058, -0.04639989510178566, -0.008689450100064278, 0.021112294867634773, -0.03182661905884743, -0.011358940042555332, -0.002629983937367797, 0.010182516649365425, 0.016919167712330818, 0.02594733238220215, -0.027495993301272392, -0.04097798839211464, 0.01625078357756138, -0.0736297219991684, -0.013508417643606663, 0.020551510155200958, 0.01774466410279274, 0.011952637694776058, 0.055639348924160004, 0.005811815150082111, 0.0031276477966457605, -0.07395152747631073, 0.045480772852897644, 0.01839066669344902, -0.06790632754564285, 0.027925316244363785, 0.005670808721333742, -0.02117093652486801, 0.024290617555379868, 0.012579057365655899, 0.023534419015049934, -0.02664056606590748, 0.00173870287835598, -0.05671381950378418, 0.06327242404222488, 0.007988810539245605, -0.000653547584079206, 0.02757325954735279, 0.029737740755081177, -0.0273588914424181, 0.05651652812957764, -0.009533332660794258, 0.010088402777910233, -0.01741277612745762, -0.0395253449678421, 0.023883912712335587, 0.008371572941541672, -0.008487051352858543, -0.011796860955655575, -0.035607706755399704, -0.015792274847626686, 0.03452678397297859, 0.03149764612317085, -0.009909928776323795, -0.03672236576676369, -0.08874648064374924, 0.02151820994913578, -0.012206358835101128, 0.0372016467154026, 0.012662990018725395, -0.08369512856006622, 0.043202660977840424, 0.00012523384066298604, 0.023918520659208298, -0.030378291383385658, -0.016065094619989395, -0.02239389158785343, -0.003970724530518055, 0.002914471086114645, -0.0630362331867218, 0.004436939023435116, -0.027111979201436043, 0.023714080452919006, -0.0008861267124302685, 0.01967804878950119, -0.02830718830227852, 0.010884842835366726, -0.02587706781923771, 0.046316105872392654, 0.04846906661987305, 0.026062868535518646, 0.019723152741789818, -0.021953172981739044, -0.062309540808200836, 0.00870660599321127, 0.0013434371212497354, 0.017176711931824684, -0.025604406371712685, 0.03410107269883156, -0.04210218787193298, -0.026401380077004433, -0.06179008260369301, 0.002350954106077552, 0.06117909401655197, -0.06303077936172485, -0.05330965667963028, -0.018269484862685204, 0.05221626162528992, -0.023768454790115356, -0.054171621799468994, -0.019498169422149658, -0.023365257307887077, -0.09168507158756256, -0.0267106294631958, -0.011607273481786251, 0.017665931954979897, -0.018908115103840828, 0.03433769941329956, 0.04209611937403679, 0.03527503088116646, -0.01976827345788479, 0.0024548019282519817, 0.05967480316758156, 0.0241075586527586, -0.02267548069357872, -0.01660826988518238, -0.02842264622449875, 0.025380248203873634, -0.009373540058732033, -0.020593702793121338, 0.001416169572621584, 0.051116958260536194, -0.048499736934900284, 0.05829381197690964, -0.08265181630849838, 0.04790939763188362, 0.011260565370321274, -0.019891226664185524, -0.004009121097624302, 0.044123079627752304, -0.030930085107684135, 0.0010201706318184733, -0.005691213067620993, 0.021430613473057747, 0.01609608717262745, 0.02652156539261341, 0.01372387446463108, -0.015284353867173195, -0.027123158797621727, -0.01806475780904293, 0.050437115132808685, -0.047120656818151474, -0.056166622787714005, 0.036982692778110504, 0.04860901087522507, 0.00038351729745045304, -0.05122460797429085, 0.039912618696689606, 0.05151234194636345, -0.04496054723858833, -0.06115637719631195, 0.010229415260255337, -0.027820732444524765, -0.0020592682994902134, 0.06186053901910782, -0.022192977368831635, 0.012513997964560986, 0.02660418301820755, 0.013510448858141899, -0.005691118538379669, 0.06340450793504715, -0.025486746802926064, -0.023038383573293686, -0.05000901594758034, 0.020464563742280006, -0.00035644511808641255, 0.020824437960982323, -0.03552084416151047, 0.016557302325963974, -0.008977672085165977, -0.0055725765414536, 0.05084271728992462, 0.052626390010118484, 0.015411407686769962, -0.056934818625450134, -0.015172461047768593, -0.02518233098089695, 0.0414830781519413, -0.02239254117012024, 0.0006685729022137821, -0.026959091424942017, 0.007870067842304707, -0.007141598965972662, -0.02115117572247982, 0.00015047607303131372, -0.013504426926374435, -0.03141302987933159, 0.006796153262257576, -0.0026060142554342747, -0.02584550715982914, -0.03000418096780777, -0.02361152321100235, 0.018254701048135757, -0.048280104994773865, 0.026877565309405327, 0.05504254624247551, 0.03130393847823143, 0.04870269447565079, 0.0010119166690856218, -0.0026561797130852938, -0.05081764608621597, 0.002528880024328828, 0.0970839262008667, -0.04529307037591934, -0.01018781028687954, -0.03631225973367691, -0.048101212829351425, -0.015177193097770214, -0.006018171552568674, -0.00703689269721508, 0.04036455228924751, -0.002679467434063554, -0.020963741466403008, 0.07105691730976105, 0.05237191542983055, -0.08003108948469162, -0.018856151029467583, 0.04149848222732544, -0.06962695717811584, -0.049360428005456924, -0.03955546021461487, -0.041074834764003754, -0.007659267634153366, 0.010975700803101063, -0.01448800414800644, -0.06867558509111404, -0.023159602656960487, 0.04213527590036392, 0.07650242745876312, -0.0593884214758873, 0.028883231803774834, -0.0012500128941610456, -0.04567790776491165, -0.01270647719502449, -0.027498237788677216, 0.015199868008494377, 0.014077315106987953, -0.002041422761976719, -0.02302430011332035, -0.016236498951911926, -0.029264330863952637, 0.04619752615690231, -0.05565604194998741, 0.016390202566981316, -0.045106399804353714, 0.028645604848861694, 0.01751396432518959, -0.03783460333943367, -0.06931614875793457, 0.009813467040657997, 0.014921773225069046, 0.003859528573229909, -0.012976993806660175, 0.006267925724387169, -0.029143450781702995, 0.023969236761331558, 0.006898438557982445, -0.038212645798921585, 0.005854027811437845, 0.00598737969994545, -0.023686833679676056, -0.02579837292432785, -0.0036597982980310917, 0.030103860422968864, -0.011902078986167908, 0.03985929116606712, -0.007411492522805929, 0.07413659989833832, -0.035417988896369934, 0.019592277705669403, -0.0306326262652874, 0.03942779451608658, 0.0067311436869204044, 0.019994864240288734, 0.02013404108583927, -0.009835380129516125, 0.06717811524868011, -0.00261666695587337, 0.05159994214773178, -0.006338407751172781, -0.07436778396368027, 0.06920182704925537, 0.0031749936752021313, -0.036730311810970306, -0.008464084938168526, 0.02135535143315792, -0.07114438712596893, -0.030326440930366516, 0.04118768498301506, -0.022160643711686134, -0.06225260719656944, -0.0030953334644436836, -0.006049338262528181, -0.02827821858227253, 0.004595044534653425, 0.0057576848194003105, 0.032244887202978134, -0.019149240106344223, 0.02238546498119831, 0.07155076414346695, 0.027409326285123825, -0.014224020764231682, -0.07204519212245941, -0.03845421224832535, 0.008095579221844673, 0.006303349044173956, -0.041101135313510895, -0.004561258014291525, -0.02865864336490631, -0.04400457814335823, 0.025169584900140762, 0.03085724636912346, 0.003300535725429654, 0.002000229898840189, -0.040726497769355774, 0.049121323972940445, 0.016135575249791145, -0.028330931439995766, -0.07169846445322037, 0.04094749316573143, -0.007702110335230827, -0.001846572384238243, -0.008550954051315784, -0.031239112839102745, -0.0642063170671463, 0.006066759582608938, -0.09124895930290222, 0.022615527734160423, -0.019110852852463722, 0.04189709946513176, 0.01922658085823059, 0.005454970058053732, -0.010138926096260548, -0.0015988742234185338, 0.024006396532058716, 0.017135880887508392, -0.016675103455781937, 0.011279048398137093, 0.026944667100906372, 0.04366329312324524, -0.043516647070646286, -0.009935803711414337, 0.03866775706410408, -0.050915658473968506, 0.009045475162565708, 0.021479221060872078, 0.01688973978161812, -0.06647603958845139, 0.04466080665588379, 0.04050593823194504, 0.024515962228178978, 0.05155656859278679, -0.040667030960321426, 0.01796320080757141, -0.03597179800271988, -0.06432920694351196, 0.024561777710914612, -0.06153354421257973, 0.02387314848601818, 0.018895700573921204, -0.04205302521586418, -0.009375968016684055, -0.032920148223638535, -0.015063044615089893, 0.055455274879932404, -0.016750475391745567, -0.044590193778276443, 0.045294709503650665, -0.042671047151088715, -0.047109268605709076, 0.033619970083236694, -0.030780592933297157, -0.0610697939991951, 0.04955032840371132, 0.03111445903778076, -0.05415337160229683, 0.05108451098203659, -0.08272594213485718, -0.012326610274612904, -0.06028365343809128, 0.01783512905240059, 0.0428662933409214, -0.002433659741654992, -0.02040291763842106, -0.00256895599886775, -0.046520914882421494, -0.06752393394708633, 0.030456172302365303, -0.06320500373840332, -0.013197962194681168, 0.00914053712040186, 0.045088138431310654, -0.004660365171730518, 0.012126433663070202, 0.03328389674425125, 0.041281212121248245, 0.03136533498764038, -0.042402517050504684, -0.027192890644073486, 0.015180927701294422, -0.03611796721816063, 0.0448559895157814, -0.053804539144039154, -0.007497074082493782, -0.05346165969967842, 0.03446013480424881, 0.00018891104264184833, 0.01970890536904335, 0.03419722989201546, -0.006872942671179771, -0.006550976075232029, -0.0691283792257309, -0.02761799655854702, 0.02939251810312271, -0.005942667368799448, -0.03613515570759773, 0.050288427621126175, 0.0006419835262931883, -0.006753758527338505, -0.0659397765994072 ]
In recent years, there is a growing interest in combining techniques attributed to the areas of Statistics and Machine Learning in order to obtain the benefits of both approaches. In this article, the statistical technique lasso for variable selection is represented through a neural network. It is observed that, although both the statistical approach and its neural version have the same objective function, they differ due to their optimization. In particular, the neural version is usually optimized in one-step using a single validation set, while the statistical counterpart uses a two-step optimization based on cross-validation. The more elaborated optimization of the statistical method results in more accurate parameter estimation, especially when the training set is small. For this reason, a modification of the standard approach for training neural networks, that mimics the statistical framework, is proposed. During the development of the above modification, a new optimization algorithm for identifying the significant variables emerged. Experimental results, using synthetic and real data sets, show that this new optimization algorithm achieves better performance than any of the three previous optimization approaches.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03770v1
[ -0.0181801225990057, -0.05678483098745346, 0.038420408964157104, 0.026739155873656273, -0.042863670736551285, -0.014322272501885891, -0.0019632712937891483, -0.04104303941130638, -0.010660219937562943, -0.03550730645656586, -0.040207505226135254, 0.01572822779417038, -0.0027020478155463934, -0.014273255132138729, -0.05659443512558937, 0.0053011211566627026, 0.07422418892383575, 0.01601630635559559, -0.04451758787035942, 0.07549601793289185, 0.011509551666676998, -0.006384033244103193, -0.014538563787937164, 0.04860775172710419, 0.015025707893073559, -0.021890195086598396, -0.0637570172548294, -0.012844908982515335, -0.02069951593875885, 0.01058861706405878, 0.0660056471824646, -0.06086470186710358, -0.03186451271176338, -0.06861148029565811, -0.03116833046078682, -0.03391531854867935, -0.013561984524130821, 0.01017315685749054, 0.00702478364109993, -0.04855501279234886, 0.04689246416091919, -0.039845094084739685, -0.05683277174830437, -0.015994442626833916, -0.006713884882628918, 0.0172053724527359, -0.05851699784398079, -0.01397724449634552, -0.0764879435300827, -0.023514650762081146, 0.031904518604278564, -0.04544532671570778, -0.007417888380587101, 0.04765910655260086, -0.03550896793603897, 0.024801699444651604, -0.04836830869317055, -0.014133451506495476, -0.0674482136964798, -0.0027511126827448606, -0.012192318215966225, -0.020669233053922653, 0.002811373909935355, -0.02116437256336212, -0.01749025098979473, 0.05124843493103981, -0.032512180507183075, -0.07991106063127518, -0.0762261226773262, -0.013463285751640797, 0.06132799759507179, -0.07647845894098282, 0.038327328860759735, 0.019298652186989784, -0.03848132863640785, -0.0255078487098217, -0.004991824738681316, -0.03481536731123924, 0.03841327503323555, -0.0038148805033415556, -0.020796198397874832, 0.056963250041007996, -0.02458466961979866, 0.02468258887529373, -0.006975189317017794, -0.03710942715406418, 0.04125431180000305, -0.026893213391304016, 0.04325680434703827, -0.06337705999612808, 0.013019789010286331, -0.0190868116915226, -0.07110528647899628, 0.011733721010386944, 0.06956668943166733, -0.04447649046778679, -0.001965914387255907, 0.0303615964949131, 0.03942618891596794, 0.021420283243060112, -0.01284706685692072, -0.041338611394166946, -0.04098013788461685, 0.061297640204429626, 0.030967935919761658, -0.05762344226241112, -0.01220637932419777, -0.0007862520287744701, -0.03764108195900917, 0.006479374598711729, -0.005989796482026577, -0.008033744059503078, 0.031389519572257996, -0.053942784667015076, -0.04021931067109108, -0.06076359003782272, 0.06842585653066635, 0.05967740714550018, 0.009518221952021122, 0.016206545755267143, -0.03666689246892929, 0.03495185449719429, 0.04102950170636177, -0.0027567411307245493, -0.04181494563817978, -0.025091415271162987, 0.03351084142923355, 0.03508470207452774, -0.028728578239679337, 0.013314705342054367, -0.01437637209892273, 0.041292719542980194, 0.0029759707394987345, 0.007361928466707468, 0.06391087174415588, -0.006852226331830025, -0.0197063647210598, -0.07041118294000626, 0.03896629065275192, 0.025143971666693687, -0.003712431527674198, -0.07484010607004166, 0.0322984904050827, -0.04454841464757919, 0.03229566290974617, 0.006953597534447908, -0.05442401394248009, -0.03294433280825615, -0.024469371885061264, 0.016731057316064835, 0.010974357835948467, 0.022172225639224052, 0.03083736076951027, -0.006919059436768293, 0.04726432263851166, 0.023532124236226082, 0.028795212507247925, -0.05522773787379265, -0.04166637361049652, -0.0010664328001439571, 0.05070576071739197, -0.021225150674581528, -0.006566039752215147, -0.05306374654173851, -0.017526881769299507, -0.013030561618506908, 0.06712724268436432, 0.008349720388650894, -0.0068291183561086655, 0.04060043394565582, -0.02141115441918373, 0.01516592688858509, 0.0049321819096803665, -0.001200336730107665, -0.03335681930184364, 0.0021253000013530254, -0.01423787884414196, -0.04072020575404167, -0.07225163280963898, -0.048712730407714844, 0.01532321609556675, 0.029008246958255768, -0.03734373301267624, 0.023154178634285927, -0.026562916114926338, 0.023913711309432983, -0.07748448103666306, -0.015437567606568336, 0.03290560096502304, 0.028955303132534027, -0.04097221419215202, -0.04470030218362808, 0.03710094466805458, -0.004598995205014944, -0.039831820875406265, -0.04498773440718651, -0.013520018197596073, -0.04632236063480377, 0.010580834932625294, 0.04307672381401062, -0.08017280697822571, -0.06280696392059326, -0.058119699358940125, -0.024455886334180832, -0.010171681642532349, -0.07091909646987915, 0.05429542064666748, 0.05482674390077591, -0.01159182470291853, -0.03537049517035484, 0.04115838557481766, 0.06383015215396881, 0.048854418098926544, 0.01886281743645668, 0.023967791348695755, -0.032345693558454514, -0.08664244413375854, 0.0640076994895935, -0.019117971882224083, 0.04323853924870491, 0.015085979364812374, 0.014462478458881378, 0.00010361667955294251, -0.027842579409480095, -0.0006225172546692193, 0.026817021891474724, 0.040963977575302124, 0.022928619757294655, -0.045269567519426346, -0.030863802880048752, 0.0076492903754115105, -0.05317002907395363, -0.06437492370605469, -0.06654742360115051, -0.01335593406111002, 0.02624213881790638, 0.011088700965046883, 0.06273283809423447, 0.016003210097551346, -0.06303273141384125, -0.04635211452841759, -0.006656801328063011, 0.015336276963353157, -0.0003703832335304469, -0.05025795102119446, -0.039916425943374634, -0.010293458588421345, 0.031872086226940155, 0.006478860974311829, 0.00837315246462822, -0.041144371032714844, -0.04725521430373192, -0.020932504907250404, -0.02020362764596939, 0.038800764828920364, 0.02044522389769554, -0.041210900992155075, 0.028245478868484497, -0.045810192823410034, 0.033489029854536057, 0.002908666618168354, 0.043273814022541046, -0.06191955506801605, 0.04564798250794411, 0.03352454677224159, -0.01373334787786007, -0.024957427754998207, -0.036058422178030014, 0.03126449137926102, -0.0317641980946064, -0.011453784070909023, 0.008733113296329975, 0.023907877504825592, 0.00214163726195693, -0.03104918822646141, -0.06392891705036163, 0.001911624101921916, -0.02456522174179554, 0.04042656719684601, 0.04659877344965935, 0.026708796620368958, 0.025836734101176262, 0.006366046145558357, -0.06809268891811371, -0.0030727642588317394, -0.04550056532025337, -0.027887871488928795, -0.06083016097545624, -0.07524539530277252, -0.032326389104127884, -0.0749848484992981, -0.050003066658973694, -0.07060059905052185, -0.04343254119157791, -0.030339941382408142, -0.07319840788841248, 0.006856461986899376, -0.021430356428027153, 0.027564430609345436, -0.0026626356411725283, -0.04959036409854889, -0.0071670194156467915, 0.004204655531793833, 0.023471461609005928, -0.03009229153394699, -0.062262021005153656, -0.004262132104486227, -0.011628503911197186, 0.04830382764339447, 0.02000134252011776, -0.01792440563440323, 0.012031652964651585, -0.017243502661585808, 0.020357750356197357, 0.001543933991342783, -0.007505347952246666, 0.013146067969501019, 0.006174656096845865, -0.02292356640100479, -0.01148837711662054, 0.03715362772345543, -0.002009187825024128, -0.018199464306235313, -0.0348239503800869, -0.019213078543543816, -0.015463343821465969, 0.05452625826001167, -0.036507029086351395, -0.0454997792840004, -0.03238504007458687, -0.018884235993027687, -0.027869688346982002, -0.012057148851454258, -0.016509775072336197, 0.0036760352086275816, 0.03881513327360153, 0.02719908207654953, -0.04010481759905815, -0.04633018746972084, -0.02849685773253441, -0.02621970884501934, 0.04034103453159332, -0.016643106937408447, -0.00009725182462716475, 0.040602006018161774, -0.0803275853395462, -0.021145589649677277, 0.031525444239377975, 0.06683830916881561, -0.049142468720674515, 0.0023984459694474936, 0.034311480820178986, -0.022791236639022827, -0.0032725664786994457, -0.004291891120374203, 0.008584728464484215, 0.002184714889153838, 0.053545232862234116, -0.05109965428709984, -0.016853857785463333, 0.006745126098394394, -0.0505598783493042, -0.043034568428993225, -0.02292921580374241, 0.02418866939842701, 0.048218194395303726, 0.024990832433104515, -0.06285322457551956, -0.006586721632629633, -0.04194740578532219, 0.0010857755551114678, -0.020692380145192146, -0.012461752630770206, 0.032316625118255615, -0.03815949335694313, 0.032366614788770676, 0.018840108066797256, -0.03129056468605995, 0.031489044427871704, -0.03681909665465355, 0.021002793684601784, -0.056255754083395004, 0.01796652562916279, 0.02233603596687317, -0.04113229364156723, 0.037899550050497055, 0.043213602155447006, -0.06556622684001923, 0.030387716367840767, -0.016084909439086914, 0.01853962428867817, -0.035078518092632294, -0.009329156018793583, -0.03741254657506943, -0.02831151895225048, -0.05327751860022545, 0.019360195845365524, 0.020994672551751137, 0.020535854622721672, -0.035184673964977264, -0.008084134198725224, -0.0070659089833498, 0.021137701347470284, -0.08069032430648804, 0.039297930896282196, -0.05493468418717384, 0.04090498015284538, -0.031502798199653625, -0.06299793720245361, 0.06299386918544769, -0.00772728119045496, -0.013058336451649666, -0.035702306777238846, -0.00815883930772543, -0.03329133614897728, -0.03192463144659996, -0.019880110397934914, -0.07094970345497131, 0.01224274281412363, -0.0426342636346817, 0.04142890125513077, -0.012586570344865322, 0.04476536065340042, -0.04854170233011246, -0.051897745579481125, -0.0016997673083096743, 0.05146683380007744, 0.06518567353487015, 0.050441160798072815, 0.005384540185332298, -0.007867535576224327, -0.027230801060795784, -0.010451936163008213, 0.031816549599170685, 0.017147567123174667, -0.034767113626003265, 0.043354738503694534, -0.0017427022103220224, -0.025514382869005203, -0.03623795881867409, -0.024592066183686256, 0.07759968936443329, 0.0012905909679830074, -0.01791728101670742, -0.0005811246810480952, 0.01533440686762333, -0.053162265568971634, -0.06889347732067108, -0.07081953436136246, -0.017806215211749077, -0.025421928614377975, -0.015817344188690186, 0.03671636804938316, 0.05914796516299248, -0.002048610243946314, -0.011252099648118019, 0.05513997748494148, 0.034210775047540665, -0.026311742141842842, 0.020355047658085823, 0.03325779363512993, 0.02726023457944393, 0.0038001632783561945, -0.0189020037651062, -0.07275252789258957, 0.01493587251752615, -0.029483264312148094, -0.0010745488107204437, 0.03675365075469017, 0.05044693127274513, -0.002139357151463628, 0.06268513947725296, -0.08237234503030777, 0.025472670793533325, 0.0320257768034935, 0.043164994567632675, 0.00349190691486001, 0.07863738387823105, -0.03911963105201721, 0.02726876176893711, -0.044249970465898514, -0.00764525355771184, 0.034018684178590775, -0.05048474296927452, -0.00084383983630687, -0.017378902062773705, -0.012208571657538414, 0.006247060839086771, 0.07604443281888962, -0.03241715952754021, -0.03593803569674492, 0.02912103570997715, 0.025235071778297424, 0.02755618281662464, -0.007264574524015188, 0.05754796043038368, 0.010861977934837341, -0.02102975733578205, -0.036278676241636276, -0.055379949510097504, -0.04517153277993202, -0.039145324379205704, -0.0018304851837456226, -0.02737971767783165, -0.0002006556314881891, 0.05941595137119293, 0.005366171710193157, 0.02457440085709095, 0.02469429187476635, 0.005703587085008621, -0.0019098649499937892, -0.03613894060254097, -0.01373242773115635, -0.04027222469449043, -0.01707921177148819, -0.030409937724471092, 0.029979776591062546, 0.02896883338689804, 0.008140060119330883, 0.01000992488116026, 0.026068953797221184, -0.0446331761777401, -0.02472137100994587, -0.0019365147454664111, -0.020492151379585266, 0.031248487532138824, 0.01237561460584402, 0.05209455266594887, -0.04707948863506317, 0.03397412970662117, 0.017395319417119026, 0.006934234872460365, 0.019776618108153343, -0.001964114373549819, -0.007588837295770645, 0.03363041579723358, 0.01809828355908394, -0.025060681626200676, -0.04302909970283508, 0.030698060989379883, 0.006482444237917662, 0.012221559882164001, 0.024311771616339684, 0.0019465364748612046, 0.011812152341008186, -0.013406025245785713, 0.03273354470729828, -0.036841485649347305, -0.06059269234538078, 0.02316855825483799, 0.06658387184143066, -0.03473242372274399, 0.007649322506040335, -0.06543947011232376, -0.026891382411122322, -0.008641107939183712, -0.022720564156770706, 0.025953542441129684, 0.029650086537003517, -0.02207496017217636, -0.06456515938043594, 0.050031017512083054, 0.02605740912258625, -0.07461967319250107, 0.025897769257426262, 0.044150177389383316, -0.07526862621307373, -0.013296395540237427, 0.03852972388267517, -0.01320266630500555, -0.022093312814831734, 0.022524118423461914, 0.004888744559139013, -0.036191653460264206, -0.03977692499756813, 0.06568824499845505, 0.07873953133821487, -0.006462116725742817, 0.03803255036473274, 0.02849765494465828, -0.06370329111814499, -0.027991168200969696, -0.025634078308939934, 0.022199342027306557, -0.023715384304523468, 0.02939044125378132, 0.002287104493007064, -0.05886000022292137, -0.01576565019786358, 0.06859610229730606, -0.04619202762842178, -0.004269601311534643, 0.011659790761768818, 0.023287180811166763, 0.023711545392870903, -0.032777730375528336, -0.0459282249212265, -0.019714463502168655, 0.01451191771775484, -0.01611158438026905, -0.050668731331825256, -0.013692934066057205, -0.002449577208608389, 0.02912512980401516, -0.03490663319826126, -0.039035242050886154, 0.010639584623277187, -0.008625350892543793, -0.06620235741138458, 0.03077615238726139, -0.05723121389746666, 0.003564245766028762, 0.009607868269085884, -0.014003475196659565, 0.020859288051724434, 0.0705856904387474, -0.05656234174966812, 0.0019718848634511232, -0.019553637132048607, 0.007712587248533964, 0.02691725268959999, -0.01138236653059721, 0.04597083479166031, -0.015354915522038937, 0.019434813410043716, -0.021219337359070778, -0.012128007598221302, -0.0400000736117363, -0.036406829953193665, 0.041333701461553574, 0.01917656697332859, -0.001803889754228294, -0.05471945181488991, 0.019723037257790565, 0.017157483845949173, -0.015019058249890804, 0.012688927352428436, -0.011213184334337711, -0.05313221365213394, -0.019734259694814682, -0.02459121309220791, -0.03803533315658569, -0.012228688225150108, 0.021423839032649994, 0.045093875378370285, 0.007083427160978317, 0.010515081696212292, 0.0049186875112354755, -0.01292465440928936, 0.03088175505399704, -0.05953581631183624, -0.04580262303352356, 0.0033892637584358454, -0.007919837720692158, -0.03533955290913582, -0.03739742189645767, 0.005414055660367012, -0.0600142702460289, 0.0019358837744221091, 0.06424625962972641, 0.009800978004932404, 0.04563736915588379, -0.07050641626119614, -0.025151627138257027, 0.007422675844281912, -0.022898314520716667, -0.032760269939899445, -0.005955914966762066, 0.027425821870565414, -0.030443286523222923, 0.03822920843958855, -0.012971541844308376, -0.017758488655090332, -0.006557924672961235, -0.08174227923154831, -0.017217254266142845, 0.0067554558627307415, 0.03964489698410034, 0.004608245566487312, 0.011671709828078747, -0.014447581954300404, -0.016124257817864418, 0.01005890965461731, -0.04821014404296875, 0.03601394593715668, 0.011887740343809128, 0.013866880908608437, -0.005650761071592569, -0.044622600078582764, -0.0008202089229598641, 0.04424576088786125, -0.03378411754965782, 0.024393854662775993, -0.021763309836387634, 0.03838120773434639, 0.027526630088686943, -0.002691680798307061, 0.05537433922290802, 0.03569088131189346, 0.0493488647043705, -0.04501887783408165, -0.03874468803405762, -0.01793852634727955, -0.047964636236429214, 0.027726462110877037, -0.05641738697886467, -0.032581910490989685, 0.028699947521090508, -0.0295742005109787, -0.019481580704450607, -0.022512443363666534, -0.056710198521614075, 0.031590186059474945, -0.02928273379802704, -0.041987720876932144, 0.049450356513261795, -0.03257918730378151, -0.04017696902155876, -0.04772934690117836, -0.001140166656114161, -0.02709612436592579, -0.005895017180591822, 0.034483715891838074, -0.026023950427770615, -0.007217095699161291, -0.06338151544332504, -0.015139688737690449, -0.0032568033784627914, 0.016349026933312416, -0.03198947757482529, 0.06157998368144035, -0.014732488431036472, -0.006559992209076881, 0.007457372732460499, -0.016484947875142097, -0.009189586155116558, -0.07601329684257507, -0.04299641400575638, -0.03805871680378914, 0.016792060807347298, -0.028541650623083115, 0.03842427209019661, 0.027524441480636597, 0.053645338863134384, 0.023466743528842926, -0.003407943295314908, 0.03134806081652641, 0.007699655834585428, -0.03196097910404205, 0.06858079880475998, -0.011318528093397617, 0.017796440050005913, -0.007708543445914984, 0.03724837303161621, -0.01580667868256569, -0.036999378353357315, 0.005157995503395796, -0.00896727479994297, -0.013952109962701797, -0.05811420828104019, 0.026073148474097252, 0.015570864081382751, 0.010199375450611115, -0.05583164840936661, -0.010102708823978901, 0.029256565496325493, -0.03336746618151665, -0.04644632712006569 ]
Quantum amplification is recognized as a key resource for precision measurements. However, most conventional paradigms employ an ensemble of independent particles that usually limit the performance of quantum amplification in gain, spectral linewidth, etc. Here we demonstrate a new signal amplification using cooperative 129Xe nuclear spins embedded within a feedback circuit, where the noble-gas spin coherence time is enhanced by at least one order of magnitude. Using such a technique, magnetic field can be substantially pre-enhanced by more than three orders and is in situ readout with an embedded 87Rb magnetometer. We realize an ultrahigh magnetic sensitivity of 4.0 fT/Hz$^{1/2}$ that surpasses the photon-shot noise and even below the spin-projection noise of the embedded atomic magnetometer, allowing for exciting applications including searches for dark matter with sensitivity well beyond supernova constraints. Our findings extend the physics of quantum amplification to cooperative spin systems and can be generalized to a wide variety of existing sensors, enabling a new class of cooperative quantum sensors.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11374v1
[ 0.001162784406915307, 0.020875493064522743, 0.026640428230166435, 0.03355199843645096, 0.0002161185402655974, 0.00465875118970871, -0.00628271559253335, -0.010413996875286102, -0.04230954870581627, -0.005878068041056395, 0.006723137106746435, -0.011896675452589989, -0.050488729029893875, -0.054317399859428406, -0.0647268295288086, 0.020911671221256256, 0.06298145651817322, -0.018234344199299812, -0.031218769028782845, 0.06489025056362152, 0.027667729184031487, -0.032139599323272705, -0.017773954197764397, 0.03231097012758255, 0.002626483328640461, -0.043059688061475754, -0.02815285325050354, 0.0146134402602911, 0.028463510796427727, -0.023428400978446007, 0.050132617354393005, -0.032697249203920364, -0.005365167278796434, 0.00884450227022171, -0.03383880481123924, -0.015911730006337166, -0.05735335126519203, 0.021678870543837547, 0.009453974664211273, -0.024522114545106888, -0.012027563527226448, -0.008843270130455494, -0.049767911434173584, -0.02414482645690441, -0.013694166205823421, -0.030669933184981346, -0.0010879236506298184, -0.018543584272265434, -0.00256143300794065, -0.05540934205055237, 0.010372119955718517, -0.007194544654339552, -0.008773120120167732, 0.053124118596315384, -0.01358089316636324, -0.022964389994740486, -0.04195180907845497, -0.0023745016660541296, -0.06674083322286606, -0.02314407378435135, -0.005212736781686544, -0.028352592140436172, -0.006039136089384556, 0.013612193055450916, -0.001468657166697085, 0.049672383815050125, -0.02082706242799759, -0.06955006718635559, -0.03930272161960602, -0.04228208586573601, 0.020793812349438667, -0.07110559940338135, 0.022938143461942673, 0.03182017430663109, -0.042928799986839294, -0.04400252178311348, -0.010821197181940079, -0.024527456611394882, -0.01935899257659912, 0.015126199461519718, -0.0018413079669699073, 0.020881960168480873, 0.025660129263997078, 0.03878896310925484, -0.0017554720398038626, 0.017114996910095215, 0.05348345264792442, -0.03969164937734604, -0.008168160915374756, -0.05669993907213211, 0.05377413332462311, -0.058985572308301926, -0.0665348693728447, 0.028537677600979805, 0.0837487056851387, -0.04742314666509628, 0.043996721506118774, 0.03979918360710144, 0.045366041362285614, -0.004499848932027817, -0.03562938794493675, -0.0369391106069088, -0.01744760200381279, 0.022618163377046585, 0.00982330646365881, -0.02064443752169609, 0.012172916904091835, -0.04383254796266556, -0.033065859228372574, 0.03991328552365303, -0.031509555876255035, -0.022439604625105858, 0.027298346161842346, -0.04088977351784706, -0.038936153054237366, -0.05227655917406082, 0.0657760351896286, -0.009184298105537891, -0.04080071672797203, 0.0010421461192891002, -0.005647978279739618, 0.030741503462195396, 0.042427908629179, 0.01081430446356535, -0.021152585744857788, 0.04259920120239258, 0.07815008610486984, -0.03102678805589676, -0.01479229424148798, -0.028808925300836563, -0.008151106536388397, 0.04662622883915901, 0.009557128883898258, -0.0017880300292745233, 0.05089743807911873, 0.017397115007042885, 0.009988175705075264, -0.02660045213997364, 0.00578894279897213, -0.0015555619029328227, 0.007385770324617624, -0.021231716498732567, 0.051327239722013474, 0.0030603474006056786, 0.01496412418782711, -0.02158200554549694, -0.08657480031251907, -0.04512832313776016, 0.0612674281001091, 0.006461618468165398, -0.03855382278561592, -0.0037981378845870495, -0.022024547681212425, -0.01920647919178009, 0.02555316686630249, 0.016725054010748863, 0.05440909415483475, 0.008124355226755142, -0.011572210118174553, 0.01564827188849449, -0.002658164594322443, -0.030931128188967705, -0.03103773109614849, 0.0006965934881009161, -0.011887661181390285, -0.005571035668253899, 0.00603995518758893, 0.010313110426068306, -0.012807469815015793, 0.06291143596172333, -0.050560057163238525, -0.042618900537490845, 0.0020530917681753635, -0.03867972642183304, -0.06257059425115585, -0.013349497690796852, -0.04784013703465462, -0.03759419918060303, -0.0546012781560421, 0.00024883559672161937, 0.029101436957716942, -0.018620166927576065, -0.04260919988155365, 0.039073411375284195, -0.05588015541434288, -0.009433242492377758, -0.06915699690580368, 0.004846763331443071, 0.061903148889541626, -0.011873478069901466, -0.016308126971125603, -0.0196433924138546, 0.04468945413827896, -0.012556446716189384, -0.029807519167661667, -0.009761717170476913, -0.04436763375997543, -0.015299733728170395, 0.015331583097577095, 0.029001381248235703, -0.06819313764572144, -0.06005288287997246, -0.06153279170393944, -0.007558360230177641, 0.012777418829500675, -0.07834335416555405, 0.017657872289419174, 0.00929392222315073, -0.019087841734290123, 0.0009865878382697701, 0.05416264757514, 0.03367580100893974, 0.03488476201891899, 0.014624890871345997, -0.031063349917531013, 0.004933631047606468, -0.0913776159286499, 0.05292034149169922, 0.028723563998937607, -0.015066849999129772, 0.011152863502502441, 0.04825945198535919, -0.011175648309290409, -0.024709247052669525, -0.005478960461914539, 0.059350382536649704, 0.03281879425048828, -0.009496411308646202, -0.047702107578516006, -0.015739059075713158, 0.02016163431107998, -0.04516524448990822, -0.0702805444598198, -0.06782617419958115, -0.03211157023906708, 0.0017968135653063655, 0.0018812186317518353, -0.008753347210586071, 0.019468974322080612, -0.04967022314667702, -0.02533651515841484, 0.01713891699910164, 0.0591033436357975, 0.003674603532999754, -0.04509821906685829, -0.03400475159287453, -0.04129139333963394, 0.03260399028658867, -0.05411796644330025, -0.043578680604696274, -0.0007098552887327969, -0.02580275945365429, 0.004359055310487747, 0.0042371079325675964, -0.016035525128245354, 0.019583964720368385, -0.05059456080198288, 0.009753069840371609, 0.00541110010817647, 0.030105166137218475, -0.015020674094557762, 0.011377433314919472, -0.04396691918373108, 0.040975626558065414, 0.018440142273902893, 0.021248312667012215, -0.05587704852223396, 0.012519756332039833, -0.013389172963798046, 0.01385316252708435, -0.006756687071174383, 0.04777362570166588, 0.04110903665423393, 0.033853087574243546, -0.019194025546312332, -0.048729125410318375, -0.04654800519347191, -0.014639799483120441, 0.037537284195423126, 0.02608099766075611, 0.05685879662632942, 0.010492004454135895, 0.030981790274381638, -0.05827933922410011, -0.042403362691402435, -0.025306090712547302, -0.006024980451911688, -0.05768238753080368, -0.061177946627140045, -0.03676566481590271, -0.06659989058971405, -0.008797569200396538, -0.04846077784895897, -0.023235542699694633, -0.0077902027405798435, -0.035293690860271454, 0.016791149973869324, -0.035730209201574326, 0.0000132087780002621, -0.06825805455446243, -0.029295526444911957, 0.020834961906075478, 0.03722813352942467, 0.04430469498038292, -0.03252078965306282, -0.06494569033384323, -0.0056613534688949585, 0.03812774270772934, 0.04131801053881645, 0.028289251029491425, -0.028823820874094963, -0.02346852421760559, -0.05100780725479126, 0.04412226006388664, -0.0034229345619678497, 0.02794182114303112, 0.05326003581285477, -0.021587584167718887, 0.026985445991158485, -0.008542181923985481, -0.0297263003885746, -0.028656693175435066, 0.036126550287008286, 0.002390674315392971, -0.04296668618917465, -0.040554799139499664, 0.06657196581363678, 0.0490078404545784, 0.007473084609955549, -0.054576072841882706, -0.007042653858661652, 0.04275244101881981, 0.028513344004750252, 0.02405231073498726, 0.02154596708714962, 0.03383185341954231, -0.013084948062896729, 0.010458216071128845, -0.05399007350206375, 0.027659669518470764, -0.028905296698212624, -0.0010372598189860582, -0.0189041905105114, -0.010802201926708221, 0.04569355398416519, -0.07753865420818329, 0.03150931000709534, 0.04046999290585518, 0.0490381084382534, -0.01618349552154541, 0.015727102756500244, 0.05588056519627571, 0.037794776260852814, 0.02187296189367771, -0.0031948613468557596, 0.025479428470134735, -0.018343377858400345, 0.04515065625309944, -0.03833399713039398, -0.03776387497782707, -0.006136150099337101, -0.05375733599066734, -0.05261523276567459, 0.012581410817801952, -0.023872042074799538, 0.05024461820721626, 0.04544489458203316, -0.020379848778247833, 0.00777470925822854, -0.03038805164396763, 0.060248587280511856, -0.00392135651782155, -0.04581085219979286, 0.017696499824523926, -0.01244316529482603, -0.00271720252931118, 0.014006521552801132, -0.0320378839969635, 0.0026589485350996256, -0.05848138779401779, 0.013322005048394203, -0.0338936522603035, 0.03916117176413536, -0.00688733346760273, -0.0013010993134230375, 0.010723806917667389, 0.029845744371414185, -0.010575663298368454, 0.04830856993794441, -0.008715322241187096, -0.013706350699067116, -0.023912321776151657, -0.007739618886262178, -0.011090930551290512, 0.025061501190066338, -0.0011717606103047729, -0.016625553369522095, 0.006307625211775303, -0.04293819144368172, -0.010647918097674847, 0.02814985066652298, -0.004317754413932562, -0.02002028375864029, -0.08576114475727081, 0.0032056374475359917, -0.06860986351966858, 0.05032811313867569, -0.0620596781373024, -0.05126604437828064, 0.0570865273475647, -0.014435132965445518, 0.04037003591656685, -0.03727007284760475, 0.03351010009646416, -0.034065764397382736, -0.058899588882923126, 0.0018437583930790424, -0.059826113283634186, 0.03373182564973831, -0.03654617816209793, 0.061404988169670105, -0.013133365660905838, -0.02372843585908413, -0.06661617010831833, -0.027631279081106186, -0.057373400777578354, 0.04781467467546463, -0.004264614079147577, 0.04368318244814873, 0.028887320309877396, -0.013938880525529385, -0.019694626331329346, 0.051765598356723785, 0.04764973744750023, 0.04822953790426254, -0.0029598635155707598, 0.05528496950864792, -0.04127320647239685, -0.0434659868478775, -0.06175942346453667, -0.016499875113368034, 0.04879485443234444, -0.06282592564821243, -0.043996624648571014, 0.037867140024900436, 0.01587698981165886, -0.051400765776634216, -0.03935116529464722, -0.027576493099331856, -0.023298390209674835, -0.08030691742897034, -0.0424460768699646, 0.038771852850914, -0.04385082423686981, 0.016370264813303947, 0.018419034779071808, 0.04914849251508713, 0.03331860527396202, -0.006304330658167601, 0.02621881291270256, 0.021578285843133926, 0.016675841063261032, -0.001296340604312718, -0.0253463014960289, -0.02171265333890915, 0.007219694089144468, -0.0041552940383553505, -0.06503872573375702, 0.027784550562500954, 0.024017106741666794, -0.008069443516433239, 0.03678169846534729, -0.06638480722904205, 0.0032071482855826616, 0.03162112087011337, -0.04826701432466507, -0.009465605951845646, 0.05512305349111557, 0.00014961179113015532, 0.012323272414505482, -0.025646118447184563, 0.011073533445596695, -0.012365605682134628, 0.0013806951465085149, -0.011447724886238575, -0.013947230763733387, -0.052553728222846985, 0.010754541493952274, 0.013552439399063587, -0.009725918062031269, -0.048111654818058014, 0.04656873270869255, 0.025965334847569466, -0.01941387727856636, -0.004035556688904762, 0.050463199615478516, 0.0539466068148613, 0.0010846861405298114, -0.07173966616392136, 0.007489352487027645, -0.03229557350277901, -0.007159530185163021, 0.06524071097373962, -0.06745908409357071, -0.050583258271217346, 0.018896790221333504, 0.04390755668282509, -0.005740704480558634, 0.03479306027293205, -0.04359211027622223, -0.025050681084394455, 0.03581220284104347, -0.02872489206492901, -0.04318345710635185, -0.03963984176516533, -0.05032826587557793, 0.006833522114902735, -0.027527861297130585, 0.04524323716759682, 0.0707383006811142, 0.05596406012773514, 0.024978259578347206, -0.049364879727363586, -0.056345004588365555, -0.0591588094830513, 0.05646191164851189, -0.004953408148139715, 0.03531734645366669, -0.0070944493636488914, 0.04997418448328972, 0.04217490181326866, -0.037764597684144974, -0.0006036065169610083, -0.0027768027503043413, -0.007818732410669327, 0.005039366427809, 0.02706739865243435, 0.015997054055333138, -0.050124555826187134, -0.01523082610219717, 0.05853252857923508, -0.05424967408180237, 0.06450305879116058, 0.024332966655492783, 0.02496154047548771, 0.01791548915207386, 0.021948296576738358, -0.01677888073027134, -0.06439444422721863, 0.024307001382112503, 0.0838848277926445, -0.0374203585088253, -0.02978004328906536, -0.06658317148685455, -0.005371124017983675, 0.01757914386689663, -0.04994911700487137, 0.01475708931684494, -0.006569995079189539, -0.020322728902101517, -0.04534155875444412, 0.04735003784298897, 0.026791758835315704, -0.07490677386522293, -0.011558282189071178, 0.013512348756194115, -0.08423584699630737, -0.032563466578722, 0.021639568731188774, -0.043807920068502426, -0.03931085020303726, 0.013805030845105648, -0.011939892545342445, -0.04935551807284355, -0.003053064690902829, 0.06259945034980774, 0.05868258699774742, 0.004793118219822645, 0.018144676461815834, 0.01994265429675579, 0.004235520493239164, 0.01515936478972435, -0.025550756603479385, -0.009651601314544678, -0.017668966203927994, 0.024387048557400703, -0.011575222946703434, -0.06616615504026413, -0.03258106857538223, 0.03705388680100441, -0.04774799942970276, 0.0232903640717268, -0.012085982598364353, 0.022660071030259132, 0.02659922093153, -0.051578983664512634, -0.050009068101644516, 0.024639040231704712, -0.02735925279557705, 0.025682037696242332, 0.010445515625178814, 0.012684999033808708, -0.004022481385618448, 0.060583025217056274, 0.03498516231775284, -0.04016616940498352, -0.005989384837448597, -0.03660472482442856, -0.014417586848139763, 0.03641081601381302, -0.06929196417331696, -0.0028799723368138075, 0.020574869588017464, 0.028132865205407143, 0.024205338209867477, 0.05582934990525246, -0.009281444363296032, -0.037476398050785065, -0.040476180613040924, 0.009106374345719814, 0.019611617550253868, -0.018138587474822998, 0.049017101526260376, -0.053838230669498444, 0.04430137947201729, -0.038800448179244995, -0.0023556691594421864, 0.022641561925411224, -0.0713978186249733, 0.022324886173009872, 0.014113684184849262, -0.027432842180132866, -0.02134060487151146, -0.008322417736053467, -0.0179818794131279, 0.0033727919217199087, 0.04661930352449417, -0.016857406124472618, -0.05989443510770798, -0.007461394648998976, -0.012461774051189423, -0.0322536863386631, -0.012866971082985401, 0.045336827635765076, 0.00021503391326405108, -0.03364311903715134, 0.02369758114218712, 0.05598333850502968, 0.008821088820695877, 0.03384730964899063, -0.031885795295238495, 0.01114599034190178, 0.03135387599468231, 0.0022680156398564577, -0.02357715368270874, -0.03961014375090599, -0.04027926176786423, -0.07496485114097595, -0.02100346051156521, 0.011272232048213482, 0.02094816416501999, 0.0338861458003521, -0.022405821830034256, 0.02350139617919922, 0.03138484060764313, -0.012539571151137352, -0.08120441436767578, 0.0038161608390510082, -0.05226973816752434, -0.00754924863576889, -0.005598897114396095, -0.05358531326055527, -0.04573585093021393, -0.00989060290157795, -0.0819951742887497, -0.012263566255569458, -0.013724884018301964, 0.05607257038354874, -0.022117964923381805, 0.00023889404837973416, -0.05292753875255585, 0.006583181209862232, -0.024287350475788116, 0.012882865965366364, -0.008155064657330513, -0.0010138045763596892, -0.01871529594063759, 0.007841058075428009, -0.05878078565001488, -0.021660486236214638, 0.03886378929018974, -0.07051343470811844, 0.009920699521899223, 0.0004556878993753344, 0.036569129675626755, -0.01958691142499447, 0.014656877145171165, 0.024441678076982498, 0.000990317203104496, 0.024440301582217216, -0.060804761946201324, -0.039252061396837234, -0.04476485773921013, -0.032912932336330414, 0.05727939307689667, -0.05716760456562042, 0.02190835028886795, -0.013565950095653534, -0.02802434377372265, 0.008440446108579636, -0.038262926042079926, -0.03452076390385628, 0.03480667248368263, 0.02403571829199791, -0.0259616207331419, 0.07910583168268204, -0.060273297131061554, -0.026413628831505775, 0.016308920457959175, 0.002672834089025855, -0.07847602665424347, 0.04433346912264824, 0.05133550241589546, -0.0645257756114006, -0.014136366546154022, -0.06455539166927338, 0.02532368339598179, -0.03927214816212654, -0.0011506627779453993, -0.014015331864356995, 0.03205622360110283, -0.05623113736510277, -0.03735865280032158, -0.05498969927430153, -0.046169452369213104, -0.009870409034192562, -0.04418039694428444, 0.009165279567241669, 0.026743918657302856, 0.016198234632611275, 0.007736685685813427, 0.0332963764667511, -0.0012667193077504635, 0.05826302617788315, 0.006500303279608488, -0.0319904163479805, -0.0018087264616042376, 0.007068134844303131, -0.05186060070991516, 0.06421994417905807, -0.02282184176146984, 0.02394803613424301, -0.062117353081703186, 0.0023700243327766657, -0.03242087364196777, 0.0007721487199887633, 0.03978621959686279, -0.011548589915037155, 0.003920722287148237, -0.06713227927684784, -0.03655475750565529, 0.009379942901432514, -0.034460701048374176, -0.05921142175793648, -0.0020129161421209574, 0.010851843282580376, 0.015558140352368355, -0.06913134455680847 ]