name_test
string | round
int64 | timestamp
string | summary
dict | stats
dict | results
list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
test1
| 8
|
2025-12-27T19:26:16.503710
|
{
"total_judged": 125,
"win_rate": 0.088,
"margin": 0.024,
"avg_gen_time": 19.496174279848734
}
|
{
"total": 128,
"wins": 11,
"draws": 106,
"losses": 8,
"skipped": 0,
"gen_failed": 0,
"render_failed": 0,
"judge_failed": 3
}
|
[
{
"task_id": "014635059549225c114d06bec52227b2c72ff0cb4dd8fd7e16cebfb596b8df45",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 0,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has color and transparency differences; second model has style (solid vs semi - transparent lattice) and detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has solid texture with less transparency and geometric pattern fidelity; second model has better transparency but minor pattern details differ from prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "034311d5eec079eb3bca64550e09f3364971a1e82265fd5a64ec751177d46e2b",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 0,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape and detail variations, screen UI differences, minor design inconsistencies. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail mismatches between models and prompt; second model has more significant UI and structural deviations."
},
{
"task_id": "03587e1a7eba88cd159c561c8014987ad082aee71331f8190dc6cf1eef968554",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 0,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in glass texture, light glow, and overall style consistency.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and texture differences, bulb shape variations"
},
{
"task_id": "0927bdf4078b663300353e4dc6b0ff9607b860a94c4b9feaef2e4e86c818aed2",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 0,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 4.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both 3D models have stylized, less photorealistic leaves with simplified vein details and shape variations compared to the prompt's realistic, highly detailed leaf.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and realism issues compared to the prompt's realistic, detailed leaf."
},
{
"task_id": "0b8f7ddef5e8765598d100c5b64b2ae32e549e554dc1f638e943516b63161ad9",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 0,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing intricate dragon details, and minor metal part discrepancies.. Swapped pass: Dragon designs and metal component details show minor to moderate deviations from the prompt's intricate, traditional dragon patterns and ornate metalwork."
},
{
"task_id": "0bf7a6cb30a42717ad5346729ce2451179eec807d9e86508c82e395570ed8edc",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 0,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4.5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model exhibits color tone deviations, texture differences; second model has closer adherence with minor detail variations.. Swapped pass: First model has color, texture, and detail mismatches; second model has closer color but still some texture and detail differences."
},
{
"task_id": "0dc0530d9c3b7f4dbf1a59499d0ef09c22799242d078647b600e0e2e1bdd529d",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 0,
"winner": "right",
"ours_penalty": 9,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model is abstract, not resembling a bottle; second model has bottle shape but orientation and style differ from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/lighting differences but matches prompt; second model is not a bottle (major category mismatch)"
},
{
"task_id": "109cb158623a7060f5b71d32e18039ecf04b5a29b7a3408a8d7876508b9abdc5",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 0,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4.5,
"leader_penalty": 4.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences from prompt. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details (e.g., grille, headlight details, body contours)"
},
{
"task_id": "1224d91185844b16fc9cdc9ebc0253dde69c2c62c6bc6340d91436ebe05f1ed4",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.91241717338562,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Color mismatch (first model gold, second model redder than prompt's copper/brown), detail differences (eye color, mouth style, paneling intricacy), and minor structural variations. Swapped pass: Color variations (redder/gold vs copper), detail differences (mechanical parts, panel designs), and shape inconsistencies with prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "124fce2c8d90813abcdb2a781495521bc93469b593156eec072933552c0c021e",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.21723771095276,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Rope texture, knot details, and cloth detail do not match the prompt's level of detail.. Swapped pass: rope texture and white object details not matching prompt exactly, minor shape variations"
},
{
"task_id": "183cbe7ad7a71690e4ae6a59c5678ed4eebb0ba6eeb8106314f897e4702c1f38",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.213046550750732,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences, bail design variations, gemstone clarity and arrangement not matching prompt. Swapped pass: Shape differences, gem cut details, and surrounding stone arrangements do not match the prompt exactly; minor to moderate style and detail discrepancies."
},
{
"task_id": "1acf7c53693fcd1e3f6a1266081bfc5ba1f5a795fec863adff1041a1a987b611",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.807051420211792,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major shape and detail issues with fragmented continents.. Swapped pass: Continent shapes and details are distorted; color schemes partially match but lack prompt's precision."
},
{
"task_id": "1b5274b9ffa3ff2a71f726fbab7f24dda28bf2d567a13d5b22d5604ef932ac54",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.4493510723114,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 3,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape differences and missing small details in both 3D models compared to the image prompt. Swapped pass: Minor differences in muscle definition and shading between models and prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "261ee46ca52df07a017b6f1f1c5a2a03809e96c18334d4aa5877619ca4d761f1",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.83264446258545,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor issues with bag details and pillow texture; second model has moderate issues with bag design and pillow pattern consistency. Swapped pass: Pattern distortion, bag details mismatch, texture inconsistencies"
},
{
"task_id": "2831800af7589f7b03f3e8b88498f8526107cb17795f10285731f9a5132fc2fe",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.79077458381653,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both 3D models have significant shape distortions and abstracted forms, with missing realistic details (valves, tubing, bell structure) compared to the prompt's detailed golden brass instrument.. Swapped pass: Shape distortions, missing detailed valve mechanisms and tubing structure compared to prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "2b72f7abb9ba4f586eb29833598306cd8f628351896db2e85e538c06fa4c6fe8",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.635573863983154,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences (e.g., leaf shapes, spadix positioning) from the prompt; first model has slight issues, second model has more noticeable differences.. Swapped pass: Leaf shape, spadix details, and pot/soil features show variations from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "2d99674bf0078adf8b58b4cf75a52896b2192559f97eed2e1926f2f5543c3bfc",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.256025552749634,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor differences in hat shape, feather arrangement, and color intensity variations. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and feather arrangement variations; second model has more significant style and detail differences from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "2dada05044c2be25783e212d298ec3a532c651bdee8f8f864244527c6604eaa8",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 21.373137950897217,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has color mismatches (fruit and bowl) and inconsistent peel details; second model lacks the bowl and peel slices specified in the prompt, missing key elements.. Swapped pass: First model lacks bowl and peel elements; second model has bowl and peel but has color variations and minor detail differences from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "2e3404381c00258e74cb63deba6ff5b9ffaee979f94bfb7b42e4c3d1ec67d218",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.812310457229614,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with color (handle and blade), shape, and texture compared to the prompt; first model’s handle is not as bright orange, blade texture differs, and shape is slightly off; second model’s blade shape and texture also differ from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, minor detail variations in handle and blade proportions"
},
{
"task_id": "2fd46d4a00a43e432c5e3f97aad8da63a5313ec5e5eaddd628b048e03617c737",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 23.644099473953247,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has variations in handle shape, lid design, and body proportions; second model has incorrect handle count (two handles instead of one) and shape inconsistencies with the prompt.. Swapped pass: Handle and lid details inconsistent with prompt, shape variations present"
},
{
"task_id": "335e936c32e6d573acba32ba4e2ffe528962e076677966e8c9e504e102820900",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.232398509979248,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from prompt, including tripod structure and scope proportions. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, lens appearance variations, tripod structure details not matching prompt exactly."
},
{
"task_id": "346e9c57eb002b7b43280e72bb7d711a28a6e5cc5608c0df32d093b88283cc45",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.37093949317932,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and some detail variations from the original prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "3613c7dda6ea4aac4e2cddcbc4399ae742871cf2d4ed3af3e68d6b3452829b73",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.89240598678589,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details like front end design and wheel details. Swapped pass: Shape differences, color tone variations, and minor detail omissions in body contours and front end design."
},
{
"task_id": "364f2e60a97f04ff4292f98b65e765c5bfbfd61615da2ff56ff9fbad4380f625",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.08244228363037,
"winner": "right",
"ours_penalty": 7,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has smoother texture and less accurate crispy coating; second model has closer texture but some shape variations.. Swapped pass: Both models lack the crispy texture, proper golden-brown color tone, and cocoa powder dusting from the prompt; the plate is also not included in the 3D models."
},
{
"task_id": "366e3f6911f91e13ffe0d443b9138725678484fdd4f3d91af9af057de0a05cca",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.91128897666931,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 4.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with style and missing small details compared to the prompt; color scheme is partially matched but structural and detail accuracy is lacking.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail variations; second model has moderate detail omissions and style differences"
},
{
"task_id": "371ecbf728b0b69ebc3167827e27fa8a60367d88684b29a26d9ac79759ae053c",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 20.527199745178223,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models have deviations in color scheme (first model has green-dominated hues, second has purple-pink tones), bread hole details (variations in hole count/pattern), and toaster structural elements (e.g., buttons, shape details) compared to the prompt; second model has more significant style/color mismatches.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and bread detail variations; second model has significant style/color deviations and bread texture differences from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "3933fbf64a473ccccb328c23242867f0cbdd8e4aa9cc8f1f9657c9d85f251a06",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 20.59692144393921,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both 3D models have stylized/simplified shapes for bottles and cart elements, with some details (e.g., specific bottle forms, wooden texture accuracy) missing or altered compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has stylized bottle shapes and altered cart details; second model has abstracted elements, simplified structure, and missing original bottle details. Both have significant style and detail differences from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "3e0851e6ad60ef9fe1bc81ca1032b31b15b76897f70778dc4cadfda23a7afa70",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.54959511756897,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape differences and missing small details in both models; second model has more noticeable deviations from the original's structural details.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences and missing small details in both models compared to the prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "3ecd482e-9b05-4e76-9b67-a7be1b3183e0",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 20.522525548934937,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to major issues in roof texture, window details (awnings, shape), chimney design, and landscaping.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has significant shape differences, missing key details, and style variations."
},
{
"task_id": "3f1d5d62cb0614cce92d867d793919fe52f580ed9ce5845be9f7b98f5f42c676",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.710249423980713,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3.5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences in base ornate patterns and shade texture. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail variations in base engravings, shade texture, and handle positioning compared to the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "43b62b6f-dddd-42e1-b540-d781a965967a",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 32.10782527923584,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight differences in mane/tail flow and body proportions between models and prompt; both match the unicorn category but have stylistic variations.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details"
},
{
"task_id": "441849fb2c2e3050a629ef68216407ee3d61c61554a3b64fd9f85be926401976",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 29.835458993911743,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape variations, pen holder texture differences, minor pen detail mismatches. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, minor pen position variations"
},
{
"task_id": "449de7f2e694785e0879713b2b4ce3330941e7bd607d8ff0d67ac5b326aacee8",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 23.45671057701111,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details, wood texture variations.. Swapped pass: Both models have moderate to major issues with shape differences, missing small decorative details, and variations in wood texture and brass accents compared to the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "451cb65e16980cd8fe0d55af883cfc0d4426f3d904132f07225bcc47a71ff7c6",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.43766760826111,
"winner": "right",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 3,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has stylized, simplified features (cartoonish) with less detailed mane and facial details; second model has closer realism but minor shape/stance differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)"
},
{
"task_id": "45863577dae88672494c7c79825accb87f6bb3eb5b4e63e5f82ae69fb343e01f",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.413698196411133,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 3,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor differences in small details like tree positions, base shape, and slight variations in model proportions; overall matches the prompt's key elements (lighthouse structure, dome, small building, stairs, and base).. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt, but overall structure and style match."
},
{
"task_id": "47d373b11d1409397e10a871c322533a2ed76f5abd828070c336043f9a936a8c",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 22.05604577064514,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate detail differences, simplified item arrangements, lighting variations. Swapped pass: First model has minor item and color variations; second model has major item and style inconsistencies."
},
{
"task_id": "4b6575be046517851018c88fcb4689db31f92e58ff52e0a0e9d15a1368be2a53",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.598971366882324,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Color variations, shape details, and bead arrangements differ from prompt; structure is similar but not exact.. Swapped pass: First model has minor color and detail variations; second model has significant transparency and color style deviations from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "4c6d3269-5b14-4b69-878a-dbb617e4b6ca",
"status": "judge_failed",
"gen_time": 18.811594009399414,
"winner": null,
"ours_penalty": null,
"leader_penalty": null,
"issues": "All 3 attempts failed. Last error: Failed to parse JSON from response: {'id': 'gen-1766859966-6hRp2iLAiddV0amRVGPg', 'provider': 'Novita', 'model': 'thudm/glm-4.1v-9b-thinking', 'object': 'chat.completion', 'created': 1766859966, 'choices': [{'logprobs': None, 'finish_reason': 'length', 'native_finish_reason': 'length', 'index': 0, 'message': {'role': 'assistant', 'content': '', 'refusal': None, 'reasoning': \"Got it, let's analyze this. First, the image prompt shows a robot with a rusted, mechanical look, specific features like the head with a circular hole, the arm structure with multiple cylindrical parts, and the overall aged, industrial design. \\n\\nNow, let's check the first 3D model (four views). The robots here have different shapes—some have simpler structures, different head designs, and less detailed rust. The style seems less matching the prompt's specific features. So the penalty for first model might be around 5-7, since there are moderate issues like shape differences and missing details.\\n\\nThen the second 3D model (four views). Let's see—does it match? The second model has a head with a circular hole (similar to the prompt), the arm structure with multiple cylindrical parts (like the prompt's hand-like structure with cylinders), and the rusted look. But maybe some details differ? Wait, the prompt's robot has a more specific head shape and arm arrangement. The second model's head has a hole, but the overall structure might still have some differences. Wait, need to compare each model to the prompt.\\n\\nWait, the prompt's robot has a head with a circular hole, a hand-like structure with multiple cylindrical appendages, and a body with mechanical joints. The first 3D model's robots have different head shapes (some are more rounded, no circular hole), different arm structures (not the same as the prompt's hand with cylinders), and less rust detail. So first model penalty around 6-7. Second model: does it have the circular hole? Let's check. The second model's head has a hole, the arm structure has multiple cylinders. But maybe the body structure is different. Wait, the prompt's robot has a more humanoid body with a rounded torso, while the second model's body is more boxy? Hmm. But the key features like the head hole and the arm cylinders—do they match? The prompt's robot has a head with a hole, the second model's head also has a hole. The arm structure with multiple cylinders—second model has that. But maybe the overall style is closer? Wait, the prompt's robot is more detailed with rust, while the second model's rust might be less pronounced. But compared to the first model, the second is closer. Wait, let's think again.\\n\\nFirst model: four views show robots with different shapes, some with simpler heads, no circular hole, different arm structures. So penalty for first model: 6 (moderate issues). Second model: has the circular hole, arm structure with cylinders, but maybe body structure is different. But compared to the prompt, the second model has more similar features (head hole, arm cylinders) than the first. So penalty for second model: 4-5 (minor to moderate issues). Wait, but need to check each model against the prompt.\\n\\nWait, the image prompt's robot has a head with a circular hole, a hand-like structure with three cylindrical appendages (or similar), a body with mechanical joints, and a rusted texture. Let's check first 3D model (four views):\\n\\nTop left: robot with a shield-like arm, no circular hole, simpler body. Top right: robot with a different head, no circular hole. Bottom left: robot with a different head, no circular hole. Bottom right: robot with a head that has a hole? Wait, bottom right's head has a hole? Wait, the second model's top right has a head with a hole, top left has a head with a hole. Wait, maybe I made a mistake. Let's check again.\\n\\nFirst 3D model (four views):\\n\\nTop left: robot with a rounded head, no circular hole, arm has a shield. Top right: robot with a rounded head, no circular hole, arm is different. Bottom left: robot with a rounded head, no circular hole, arm is different. Bottom right: robot with a head that has a hole? Wait, bottom right's head—does it have a hole? The image shows a robot with a head that has a hole? Wait, the original prompt's robot has a head with a hole. Let me check the first model's bottom right: the robot's head—does it have a hole? The image shows a robot with a head that has a hole? Wait, the first model's bottom right robot has a head with a hole? Wait, the original prompt's robot has a head with a hole, and the first model's bottom right robot—does it have that? Let me check again. The first model's bottom right robot: head has a hole? Maybe, but the other robots in first model don't. So first model has robots with varying features, not all matching the prompt's key elements (circular hole, specific arm structure). So first model penalty: 6.\\n\\nSecond 3D model (four views):\\n\\nTop left: robot with a head that has a hole\", 'reasoning_details': [{'format': None, 'index': 0, 'type': 'reasoning.text', 'text': \"Got it, let's analyze this. First, the image prompt shows a robot with a rusted, mechanical look, specific features like the head with a circular hole, the arm structure with multiple cylindrical parts, and the overall aged, industrial design. \\n\\nNow, let's check the first 3D model (four views). The robots here have different shapes—some have simpler structures, different head designs, and less detailed rust. The style seems less matching the prompt's specific features. So the penalty for first model might be around 5-7, since there are moderate issues like shape differences and missing details.\\n\\nThen the second 3D model (four views). Let's see—does it match? The second model has a head with a circular hole (similar to the prompt), the arm structure with multiple cylindrical parts (like the prompt's hand-like structure with cylinders), and the rusted look. But maybe some details differ? Wait, the prompt's robot has a more specific head shape and arm arrangement. The second model's head has a hole, but the overall structure might still have some differences. Wait, need to compare each model to the prompt.\\n\\nWait, the prompt's robot has a head with a circular hole, a hand-like structure with multiple cylindrical appendages, and a body with mechanical joints. The first 3D model's robots have different head shapes (some are more rounded, no circular hole), different arm structures (not the same as the prompt's hand with cylinders), and less rust detail. So first model penalty around 6-7. Second model: does it have the circular hole? Let's check. The second model's head has a hole, the arm structure has multiple cylinders. But maybe the body structure is different. Wait, the prompt's robot has a more humanoid body with a rounded torso, while the second model's body is more boxy? Hmm. But the key features like the head hole and the arm cylinders—do they match? The prompt's robot has a head with a hole, the second model's head also has a hole. The arm structure with multiple cylinders—second model has that. But maybe the overall style is closer? Wait, the prompt's robot is more detailed with rust, while the second model's rust might be less pronounced. But compared to the first model, the second is closer. Wait, let's think again.\\n\\nFirst model: four views show robots with different shapes, some with simpler heads, no circular hole, different arm structures. So penalty for first model: 6 (moderate issues). Second model: has the circular hole, arm structure with cylinders, but maybe body structure is different. But compared to the prompt, the second model has more similar features (head hole, arm cylinders) than the first. So penalty for second model: 4-5 (minor to moderate issues). Wait, but need to check each model against the prompt.\\n\\nWait, the image prompt's robot has a head with a circular hole, a hand-like structure with three cylindrical appendages (or similar), a body with mechanical joints, and a rusted texture. Let's check first 3D model (four views):\\n\\nTop left: robot with a shield-like arm, no circular hole, simpler body. Top right: robot with a different head, no circular hole. Bottom left: robot with a different head, no circular hole. Bottom right: robot with a head that has a hole? Wait, bottom right's head has a hole? Wait, the second model's top right has a head with a hole, top left has a head with a hole. Wait, maybe I made a mistake. Let's check again.\\n\\nFirst 3D model (four views):\\n\\nTop left: robot with a rounded head, no circular hole, arm has a shield. Top right: robot with a rounded head, no circular hole, arm is different. Bottom left: robot with a rounded head, no circular hole, arm is different. Bottom right: robot with a head that has a hole? Wait, bottom right's head—does it have a hole? The image shows a robot with a head that has a hole? Wait, the original prompt's robot has a head with a hole. Let me check the first model's bottom right: the robot's head—does it have a hole? The image shows a robot with a head that has a hole? Wait, the first model's bottom right robot has a head with a hole? Wait, the original prompt's robot has a head with a hole, and the first model's bottom right robot—does it have that? Let me check again. The first model's bottom right robot: head has a hole? Maybe, but the other robots in first model don't. So first model has robots with varying features, not all matching the prompt's key elements (circular hole, specific arm structure). So first model penalty: 6.\\n\\nSecond 3D model (four views):\\n\\nTop left: robot with a head that has a hole\"}]}}], 'system_fingerprint': '', 'usage': {'prompt_tokens': 4299, 'completion_tokens': 1024, 'total_tokens': 5323, 'cost': 0.0002334216, 'is_byok': False, 'prompt_tokens_details': {'cached_tokens': 0, 'audio_tokens': 0, 'video_tokens': 0}, 'cost_details': {'upstream_inference_cost': None, 'upstream_inference_prompt_cost': 0.000120372, 'upstream_inference_completions_cost': 0.0001130496}, 'completion_tokens_details': {'reasoning_tokens': 1162, 'image_tokens': 0}}}"
},
{
"task_id": "4ce93442-09ab-43ee-be49-b475a16e0a34",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.13007616996765,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape, text style, and small design details vary; second model has more significant deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Carvings, wood texture, and overall shape details do not precisely match the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "4fe364ab983c37c8c741d693fd0e17fccab0abbbafd4aa181ab5097b0c564447",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.35085439682007,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style variations from prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has significant style and shape mismatches with the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "506457b0c6ff7658b8372f8cc7060e389055e6107ea5faaa32d335c19a81cf64",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.490406274795532,
"winner": "right",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 3,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has rounded pendant shape, amber color/detail differences; second model has closer square pendant shape but minor amber internal detail differences. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/amber detail differences; second model has major shape/style differences from prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "52b3a22180471563b27d92632d493df74399bbfe938aae8bb86003bc97f6c6ed",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.120054960250854,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 6.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (toppings, cream swirls, crust color); second model has moderate to major issues (stylized appearance, fewer toppings, altered cream details). Swapped pass: Frosting color variations, topping arrangement differences, crust color differences, minor detail omissions"
},
{
"task_id": "544d229fcbcc483b5d323ea33f7254ae31beb7d44c5bedc560176d5de3340b59",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.843085527420044,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3.5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Color mismatch, minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details (wheel design, body accents)"
},
{
"task_id": "5739aff474a1145cd3759072dbf2971700f1391c785bea8fadcdb29641c4d7cd",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.474642038345337,
"winner": "right",
"ours_penalty": 6.5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models have shape deviations (e.g., added handle, distorted bell form), base inconsistencies, and lack of adherence to the original bell’s structural details.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and base variations; second model adds a handle (not present in prompt), causing major detail issues."
},
{
"task_id": "5dffa92ac67764a8d3f9c472c81f592cd69eee79b13d9e3c6e11a89a64a94c74",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.59711217880249,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6.5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Text does not match 'Sparkling', shape and label style inconsistencies. Swapped pass: Text distortion, shape/label inconsistencies with original prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "5fb32992826792ea15952387d48a7e84e477f0822c29728858f91eedded1dda0",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.52639675140381,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has stylized/cartoonish appearance with minor shape and detail inaccuracies; second model has major hood design mismatch (non-split hood) and stylized appearance, with significant detail inaccuracies.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have stylized appearances with minor shape and detail differences from the prompt's realistic Volkswagen Beetle (e.g., altered headlight shapes, simplified chrome elements, and cartoonish proportions), but still retain the general Beetle silhouette."
},
{
"task_id": "5ff3374f9139683d51fff5804ec0995fda0392e67dd2cd8c795255503ef9f971",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 21.725178956985474,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both 3D models include tire structures not present in the prompt’s image, and the overall style deviates from the prompt’s ornate, tireless wheel design.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail/style differences; second model has major issues with added tire elements altering the original object's structure."
},
{
"task_id": "60864873e3dcef73f60adbdb9fef1eace2b820b86d76967680f4670edf96b340",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.67416477203369,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape differences and minor detail variations in architectural elements and texture compared to the prompt. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail variations, but core elements (tower structure, star, blue color scheme, glowing lights) match prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "658e2f659b3e791cfe553691f5b310b32190e3cc9ec7a1176b2ce904f834dfdf",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.795485973358154,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 3.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences in base and shade elements.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences in lamp base and shade consistency between models and prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "6c8b3c99ed1eb4e55f6ff1c329559efaccc1c1d943a4a4dfa2717260efd0f7d4",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.404067754745483,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has major structural differences (crossbar design change from horizontal to X - shaped). Swapped pass: Style and structural differences (legs, crossbars), texture does not match rustic natural wood appearance of prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "6c92f66045cd8523b7e84cb9e799c4694c3574ca18efc52d63127f1f61edd1ca",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.698593854904175,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape differences in cloak, missing small details (belt decorations, cloak texture), view inaccuracies. Swapped pass: Cloak texture, belt details, and accessory accuracy vary from prompt; first model has minor discrepancies, second has moderate discrepancies."
},
{
"task_id": "6d0b277726f0c7da609a007a13082b2a2bfced27754479a2d2b90cc24a7dadf4",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.800626754760742,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has altered color tone (golden instead of dark metal), less detailed crystal structure, and simplified ornate design; second model also has golden color, simplified crystal arrangement, and less detailed structure, both deviating from prompt's dark metal, clear crystals, and intricate design.. Swapped pass: Both models have incorrect color scheme (golden instead of dark metal), less detailed crystal structures, and overall style mismatch with the original chandelier's ornate design."
},
{
"task_id": "6e75a78c7eafe1c7f32f2981cf8ecf257af22a3923a08bd85301bf28fe89d9d0",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 15.93460202217102,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 3,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences (e.g., handle texture, metal end variations) between models and prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in metal end shape and handle texture; second model has more significant style differences (handle texture, metal end details) from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "6fa4fdd5f7655db16833f36dc9408a9b47ab8460fc167cda8406d2cb23622683",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 26.08577561378479,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Stripe pattern variation, ear shape differences, and style consistency issues between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/striping differences; second model has extra small objects and moderate style/striping differences."
},
{
"task_id": "7006ccbdf6a6af59062ca148688c9bbafa489b7fee224754f6830530672820af",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.257328987121582,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape differences, detail variations, and style inconsistencies between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt; first model has tail/ear color variations, second has minor ear/body shape differences."
},
{
"task_id": "715afe937c361b7d5f32bfb5128a3191dccbcd4a470b159a41bdd11b7589b2c7",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 32.62272667884827,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape and detail discrepancies with original piano design; pedal positions and body proportions not matching prompt. Swapped pass: Shape and detail differences from prompt piano; pedal positions and overall structure not matching exactly."
},
{
"task_id": "7171ad88e62858e96cbcd9f6cf1cad5c89f1bfb818f5d208ceacd24e489adb34",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 22.53978705406189,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Pearls not as round/realistic, strand arrangement and detail variations insufficient compared to prompt. Swapped pass: Prompt shows multi - strand pearl necklace with varying pearl sizes and realistic texture; first model has minor shape/texture differences, second model has major uniformity and detail issues."
},
{
"task_id": "73857d200d1a302ec03ba26c3736c04a30e9d2d2040b5f634914377f3e1a6e21",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 21.10986876487732,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Text is distorted/reversed, jar lid details and jar transparency/shape have minor differences from the prompt. Swapped pass: Text does not match 'Pure Honey' (distorted/reversed), jar details (lid, shape) deviate from prompt, and overall prompt adherence is poor"
},
{
"task_id": "741a977c0827aac47f90b9fb88eb07da66df546f4f54e64edf16c79d9e2d7ace",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.574485063552856,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape/perspective variations; second model has color/material differences (more teal/blue-green, translucent appearance) not matching prompt's solid green texture.. Swapped pass: First model has color variations (blue tones) and less accurate texture matching; second model has better color consistency and texture accuracy, closer to prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "7483ea745921efbcb3b8ea021ec2dfb70901357145a7cc90aca09dc11b06d0f7",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.892534017562866,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and detail variations; second model has major shape distortions and structure mismatches with the prompt.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models exhibit significant shape differences and lack the detailed fin structure and body proportions matching the original image prompt’s mermaid tail design."
},
{
"task_id": "74902bb27492f08ca10f2bd983da45c333acd00f5c6df829615f2f023da5c556",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.331653118133545,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape/posture differences and branch inconsistencies; second model has more noticeable stylized shape, color detail deviations, and simplified features.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model includes an extra branch element not present in the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "77b0ad70b5199b1bcd4247bf120a2ae7f0f7b91984fa326a0c136a537817f6d5",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 21.160659551620483,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 6.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has color, text, and detail mismatches; second model has stylized, less realistic style with altered components.. Swapped pass: Both models exhibit significant style differences (stylized/cartoonish vs realistic/metallic), lack specific details like the prompt’s text, camera design, and wheel texture; while overall shape is similar, key details do not match the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "7860f46147866e333a052e0507149d44223dc099d518dacc1e2afed662175e3c",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.85819101333618,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Different color schemes, wheel designs, and body shapes do not match the prompt's sleek, dark - colored sports car with specific front end and wheel details.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has significant style/color deviations from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "7b39e9275d8f27800858bc59e490f61572a469b42f9be5169f5b1faf824f1f41",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.86322045326233,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor color and detail differences; second model has significant style/color changes and detail mismatches. Swapped pass: Clothing color variations (dress, vest), hat color differences, and minor detail inconsistencies with the prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "7dab3b8be4e53ec932dc92b82d0c2b00567dde752b068871b194d9b6b26f5ebf",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 28.971810817718506,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6.5,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with style (stylized vs detailed), figurine details (missing specific animal characteristics), and structural accuracy (wooden texture/lighting differences) compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has stylized figurines with inconsistent animal poses and compartment shape deviations; second model has irregular compartment layout, altered figurine designs, and structural inconsistencies with the original grid."
},
{
"task_id": "7df1d475b93d7da9d32cdf99543eb5e0f7ef01c1bb458309ff4156fbc5d74d17",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.04252815246582,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate issues (slight shape differences, less realistic texture/detail compared to prompt, varied leaf positioning). Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in leaf position and shading; second model has moderate texture and leaf detail variations compared to the prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "7e821772287eaecaa54af4f44b2a8a0d2ed36bdecfb0872a6358a4cee15ce965",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.10482382774353,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4.5,
"leader_penalty": 4.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Pose variations, shape differences, texture inconsistencies"
},
{
"task_id": "7ea0eb96627c5787260dc624fb3b2a312cb1ced08e0da2bdef353fdfd4dc22ff",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.004135370254517,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 3,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences between 3D models and prompt. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details"
},
{
"task_id": "7f691c0b893a85f92a4ff3d2fa6d05db141af1b1938ba570fdb474a688ead51e",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 23.27694869041443,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4.5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor differences in spine definition and texture; second model has more significant texture irregularities and segment inconsistencies.. Swapped pass: Spine density and length differ from prompt; shape has minor deviations; texture details not fully matched."
},
{
"task_id": "7fc7e2ce31d9ceff1351199183a5e37bfb868d76aa2a304f0bbb96e55e031fa5",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 20.689470291137695,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has moderate structural and stylistic differences from the prompt's organic, flowing form.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences; second model has moderate style and detail differences from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "84764b6e8a8b93192ffae3a1e9867063de72e1ac22cbdbbf49fad8f37dac421f",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.181568384170532,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major structural and style deviations.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape and detail differences; second model has more significant style and detail discrepancies from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "84b59867bc8bc38d67b1684eddc75cf9224fa74262bba979e728bcd63faaf7eb",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.77618932723999,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models have differences in color tone, material finish (shiny vs. matte), eye design, and body structure compared to the prompt; first model has lighter/matte variations, second has lighter/silver tones with different detail placement.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have differences in metallic finish, eye design, and overall style compared to the prompt's shiny blue robot; first model has lighter, less shiny appearance with altered details, second model has different color tone and design elements."
},
{
"task_id": "89bf970ded65a92db2ac1369d6feb5d22b6d40d3a909e9cf54bf16ca98a40603",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.975245714187622,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor base differences, shape variations, and texture inconsistencies with prompt.. Swapped pass: First model includes a mossy base not present in the prompt; second model has distorted mushroom shapes and details."
},
{
"task_id": "8a974d9d2ed8fbe9352eba370158719132e546e08f0114ddc7fa07461a5c8547",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.95364546775818,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape and detail mismatches with original prompt's car design; style variations (first model has distorted proportions, second model has overly rounded, stylized features not matching original details). Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style mismatches with original prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "9057afb38cac42878c010953807da791909c3d8a9dfbbec7baee9debf89d7860",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.414305686950684,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape differences, wing structure variations, and minor detail discrepancies from the prompt's insect design.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate shape/wing differences; second model has major structural and style deviations from the insect prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "91cf82827f58ddb58c1bbd49d1685e4b64da2777901c99e6e097c68c7f9b791e",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 20.476929664611816,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6.5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Moderate issues (wrong color scheme, missing specific details like screen content, button layout, and text elements; shape differences in neon outlines and overall style). Swapped pass: Style and color scheme mismatch, screen content and control panel details do not match the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "96a86092eb2ba8b407b7327109456d80c1e76b33bddbf715eaeb5f6c3ad0c3c7",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.131187677383423,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3.5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models have minor to moderate issues with wood grain texture, plank details, and structural precision compared to the prompt; first model has closer shape alignment but second has smoother textures and minor structural differences.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and texture differences from prompt; structure generally matches but details vary."
},
{
"task_id": "970347695eb2da36711a3c3f1cee3275185c6074f08993fef48abf021513c5c0",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 21.53574776649475,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor detail and style differences (e.g., decorative elements, clock face intricacy); second model has moderate detail and style differences (simplified design, less ornate details).. Swapped pass: Missing ornate clock face details, simplified decorative elements, and style deviations from the prompt's design."
},
{
"task_id": "976bff3bab25194998e1bb6218a3aaa92af18b67b9433c5baea7ec9687b1a39c",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 20.637317895889282,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the prompt. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details, style variations from the prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "988209beaf8802e7b01184b774fdbbc2b17bcac96dd102343e6bad1527504ee9",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.235483169555664,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Basket textures and flower details show moderate differences from the prompt's original basket (thick rope, specific knot style) and lavender arrangement.. Swapped pass: Basket texture, weaving style, and lavender arrangement vary from the prompt; some models have smoother baskets, different knot styles, or altered flower density."
},
{
"task_id": "98d5a8c67617725b72f1a1da81c154a8ececd8e463340188fa33762b4463ebc3",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.619740962982178,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 4.5,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape and control panel differences; second model has moderate style and detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate details mismatch (control panel, lid handle, and body shape variations from prompt)"
},
{
"task_id": "99221c94762a1948d33c37524b1833aafd27e46c7838e42ad900e392b84def06",
"status": "judge_failed",
"gen_time": 18.097911834716797,
"winner": null,
"ours_penalty": null,
"leader_penalty": null,
"issues": "All 3 attempts failed. Last error: Failed to parse JSON from response: {'id': 'gen-1766861760-WbxW6BuIdaiCoLSNltAc', 'provider': 'Novita', 'model': 'thudm/glm-4.1v-9b-thinking', 'object': 'chat.completion', 'created': 1766861760, 'choices': [{'logprobs': None, 'finish_reason': 'length', 'native_finish_reason': 'length', 'index': 0, 'message': {'role': 'assistant', 'content': '', 'refusal': None, 'reasoning': 'Got it, let\\'s analyze each model against the image prompt. First, the image prompt shows a white grater-like device next to a lemon. \\n\\nFirst 3D model (four views): These are views of the grater device. The shape and structure look like the grater from the prompt, but do they match? The prompt\\'s grater has a specific design with the grating surface and the stand. The first model\\'s views show the grater from different angles, so the main object (grater) seems to match, but wait, the prompt has a lemon next to it, but the first model doesn\\'t include the lemon. Wait, the prompt\\'s first image has a lemon, but the first 3D model is just the grater. So does the first model match? The grater\\'s design—does it have the same structure? The first model\\'s grater has the same general shape as the one in the prompt, but the prompt has a lemon, which the first model doesn\\'t include. So maybe the first model is missing the lemon, but the grater itself—does it match? Let\\'s check. The prompt\\'s grater has a specific grating surface with the \"RR\" pattern? Wait, the first image\\'s grater has a grating surface with some pattern, and the first 3D model\\'s grater has a similar grating surface. But the prompt\\'s grater is next to a lemon, so the first model doesn\\'t include the lemon. So the first model\\'s main object (grater) might match, but the presence of the lemon is missing. So penalty for first model: maybe 5? Wait, no. Wait, the prompt is to generate a 3D model of the image. The image has a grater and a lemon. The first 3D model is four views of the grater, but no lemon. So the first model is missing the lemon, which is part of the prompt. So the penalty would be moderate? Wait, let\\'s think again. The prompt\\'s image has a grater and a lemon. The first 3D model is just the grater (four views), so it\\'s missing the lemon. So the first model doesn\\'t match the prompt\\'s composition (has grater but no lemon). So penalty for first model: 5? Wait, no, maybe 3? Wait, the grater\\'s shape—does the first model\\'s grater match the prompt\\'s grater? The prompt\\'s grater has a specific design with the grating surface and the stand. The first model\\'s grater has the same general structure, but maybe some details. Wait, the prompt\\'s grater has a certain angle, and the first model\\'s grater is shown from different angles, but the main object (grater) is there. But the prompt has a lemon, which the first model doesn\\'t have. So the first model is missing a key element (lemon), so penalty is moderate, maybe 5? Wait, no, let\\'s check the second model. Second 3D model (four views) shows a lemon with a grater-like cover. The prompt\\'s image has a lemon next to a grater. The second model\\'s lemon has a cover, so it\\'s combining the lemon and the grater. But does it match the prompt? The prompt\\'s grater is separate from the lemon, while the second model\\'s lemon has a cover. So the second model\\'s main object is a lemon with a cover, which is different from the prompt\\'s separate grater and lemon. So the second model\\'s penalty would be higher. Let\\'s break down each:\\n\\nFirst 3D model (grater views):\\n- The grater\\'s shape: does it match the prompt\\'s grater? The prompt\\'s grater has a specific design with the grating surface and the stand. The first model\\'s grater has the same general structure, but maybe some details. However, the prompt\\'s image has a lemon next to the grater, which the first model doesn\\'t include. So the first model is missing the lemon, which is part of the prompt. So the penalty would be moderate because it\\'s missing a key element (lemon), but the grater itself might be close. So penalty_1: 5?\\n\\nSecond 3D model (lemon with cover):\\n- The prompt\\'s image has a separate grater and lemon. The second model shows a lemon with a cover, which is not the same as a separate grater and lemon. So the second model\\'s main object is a lemon with a cover, which is different from the prompt\\'s composition. So the penalty would be higher, maybe 7? Wait, no. Wait, the prompt\\'s image has a grater (tool) and a lemon (food). The second model\\'s lemon has a cover, so it\\'s a lemon with a cover, which is not the same as a grater next to a lemon. So', 'reasoning_details': [{'format': None, 'index': 0, 'type': 'reasoning.text', 'text': 'Got it, let\\'s analyze each model against the image prompt. First, the image prompt shows a white grater-like device next to a lemon. \\n\\nFirst 3D model (four views): These are views of the grater device. The shape and structure look like the grater from the prompt, but do they match? The prompt\\'s grater has a specific design with the grating surface and the stand. The first model\\'s views show the grater from different angles, so the main object (grater) seems to match, but wait, the prompt has a lemon next to it, but the first model doesn\\'t include the lemon. Wait, the prompt\\'s first image has a lemon, but the first 3D model is just the grater. So does the first model match? The grater\\'s design—does it have the same structure? The first model\\'s grater has the same general shape as the one in the prompt, but the prompt has a lemon, which the first model doesn\\'t include. So maybe the first model is missing the lemon, but the grater itself—does it match? Let\\'s check. The prompt\\'s grater has a specific grating surface with the \"RR\" pattern? Wait, the first image\\'s grater has a grating surface with some pattern, and the first 3D model\\'s grater has a similar grating surface. But the prompt\\'s grater is next to a lemon, so the first model doesn\\'t include the lemon. So the first model\\'s main object (grater) might match, but the presence of the lemon is missing. So penalty for first model: maybe 5? Wait, no. Wait, the prompt is to generate a 3D model of the image. The image has a grater and a lemon. The first 3D model is four views of the grater, but no lemon. So the first model is missing the lemon, which is part of the prompt. So the penalty would be moderate? Wait, let\\'s think again. The prompt\\'s image has a grater and a lemon. The first 3D model is just the grater (four views), so it\\'s missing the lemon. So the first model doesn\\'t match the prompt\\'s composition (has grater but no lemon). So penalty for first model: 5? Wait, no, maybe 3? Wait, the grater\\'s shape—does the first model\\'s grater match the prompt\\'s grater? The prompt\\'s grater has a specific design with the grating surface and the stand. The first model\\'s grater has the same general structure, but maybe some details. Wait, the prompt\\'s grater has a certain angle, and the first model\\'s grater is shown from different angles, but the main object (grater) is there. But the prompt has a lemon, which the first model doesn\\'t have. So the first model is missing a key element (lemon), so penalty is moderate, maybe 5? Wait, no, let\\'s check the second model. Second 3D model (four views) shows a lemon with a grater-like cover. The prompt\\'s image has a lemon next to a grater. The second model\\'s lemon has a cover, so it\\'s combining the lemon and the grater. But does it match the prompt? The prompt\\'s grater is separate from the lemon, while the second model\\'s lemon has a cover. So the second model\\'s main object is a lemon with a cover, which is different from the prompt\\'s separate grater and lemon. So the second model\\'s penalty would be higher. Let\\'s break down each:\\n\\nFirst 3D model (grater views):\\n- The grater\\'s shape: does it match the prompt\\'s grater? The prompt\\'s grater has a specific design with the grating surface and the stand. The first model\\'s grater has the same general structure, but maybe some details. However, the prompt\\'s image has a lemon next to the grater, which the first model doesn\\'t include. So the first model is missing the lemon, which is part of the prompt. So the penalty would be moderate because it\\'s missing a key element (lemon), but the grater itself might be close. So penalty_1: 5?\\n\\nSecond 3D model (lemon with cover):\\n- The prompt\\'s image has a separate grater and lemon. The second model shows a lemon with a cover, which is not the same as a separate grater and lemon. So the second model\\'s main object is a lemon with a cover, which is different from the prompt\\'s composition. So the penalty would be higher, maybe 7? Wait, no. Wait, the prompt\\'s image has a grater (tool) and a lemon (food). The second model\\'s lemon has a cover, so it\\'s a lemon with a cover, which is not the same as a grater next to a lemon. So'}]}}], 'system_fingerprint': '', 'usage': {'prompt_tokens': 4299, 'completion_tokens': 1024, 'total_tokens': 5323, 'cost': 0.0002334216, 'is_byok': False, 'prompt_tokens_details': {'cached_tokens': 0, 'audio_tokens': 0, 'video_tokens': 0}, 'cost_details': {'upstream_inference_cost': None, 'upstream_inference_prompt_cost': 0.000120372, 'upstream_inference_completions_cost': 0.0001130496}, 'completion_tokens_details': {'reasoning_tokens': 1046, 'image_tokens': 0}}}"
},
{
"task_id": "99da178a46f1dc8fe337c647039cf56df39ac72c5f245e809289200885788078",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.19709038734436,
"winner": "right",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 3.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has stylized clock face elements, simplified bell shapes; second model has improved realism but minor stylization.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and stylized clock face details; second model has more significant style, color, and detail deviations from the original prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "a05c9a0d51d61584267193144e751e950486c63c5b0e85b21fc0cd2f6e552857",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.405401945114136,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 6.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences; second model has major issues with spoon handle design and base elements not matching prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (handle, base details); second model has closer match but some detail variations."
},
{
"task_id": "a14649b9c186508b6862755a231e26a265130babcb7368526b3bae5832e83f39",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.334028005599976,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details (pocket designs, button styles, back panel details). Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and missing small details; second model has more significant style variations, black patches, and missing structural details compared to the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "a1afc9a29b2f04c62a2dbd716f61729eeac3bc6593f0c9184e62462e4a379489",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 23.17005705833435,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has moderate style and detail deviations from prompt. Swapped pass: Minor scale texture variations and slight shape differences between models and prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "a1d4a4f4281b49286ee923e89fa43902f8f45cf5c4a49480a26ba9dad1eb7fde",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 24.81923246383667,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape and detail differences, inconsistent branding, color mismatches between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, text inconsistencies, missing small details"
},
{
"task_id": "a28644504bc3da94d3f4f0fe13c2e5e5343cfa73507c8f1dd72f13a525a81b80",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 20.06127095222473,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models are rubber ducks but with varying adherence to prompt details (glossiness, shape features); first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, slight detail variations between models and prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "a38a36dfa341c365b1841bac3df47ee39e170455efd6a9fe36fb8ec4f2e658db",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 15.930258512496948,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences (color, tail ends); second model has major structural differences (open kite, different tail style). Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and tail detail differences; second model has moderate shape, structural, and detail inaccuracies compared to the prompt's kite structure and tail design."
},
{
"task_id": "a572342222f75df0d81b3cb4dd6f088ba05a4c365cd11d26c0c4efcbf88aedf2",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.323162078857422,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Stylized design, shape differences, missing realistic details (e.g., glossy finish, precise horn/tail details) matching the prompt's realism. Swapped pass: Minor shape and texture differences; some details (like car body structure, horn/tail texture) do not perfectly match the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "a7a515716267db535d65f6982288ed21111c0330dc3abd5c7500bb7b30ece24a",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.67275047302246,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details, style variations. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major issues with animal head and locomotive details."
},
{
"task_id": "a8a4be85624487194e7ef71371cb85e3e1b9deec4a0172cffabf22e0c06f8faa",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.684757471084595,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape/texture deviations; second model has moderate issues with hat structure and band details, not fully matching prompt's design. Swapped pass: First model has minor texture and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail discrepancies compared to the prompt's straw hat structure and texture."
},
{
"task_id": "a9d03b7f0b2d8c343ed951f4d7ac69ab20a99db5d580c9e790bba26d450f0c7e",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 24.046298265457153,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences (bowl, decorative patterns) and detail loss; second model has major style, detail, and bowl shape differences.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the prompt; decorative elements less accurate in both models."
},
{
"task_id": "ac1855012d88079de18eeaa5f221b4dd56cd274fef9935976529b4e9bc3848d2",
"status": "judge_failed",
"gen_time": 19.657840490341187,
"winner": null,
"ours_penalty": null,
"leader_penalty": null,
"issues": "All 3 attempts failed. Last error: Failed to parse JSON from response: {'id': 'gen-1766862281-eLgpbzGEfuPEWgvxwiLU', 'provider': 'Novita', 'model': 'thudm/glm-4.1v-9b-thinking', 'object': 'chat.completion', 'created': 1766862281, 'choices': [{'logprobs': None, 'finish_reason': 'length', 'native_finish_reason': 'length', 'index': 0, 'message': {'role': 'assistant', 'content': '', 'refusal': None, 'reasoning': 'Got it, let\\'s analyze this. First, the image prompt is a steampunk-style robotic cat with brass/gold tones, mechanical parts, cat features (ears, eyes, whiskers), and a mechanical body. Now, we need to check each 3D model (first and second) against the prompt.\\n\\nFirst, look at the first 3D model (four views). The models have similar steampunk elements—mechanical parts, cat shape, brass color. But check details: do they match the prompt\\'s specific features? The prompt\\'s original cat has a certain head shape, eye color, mechanical components. The first model\\'s variations might have slight differences, but overall style is steampunk cat robot. Then the second model—similar style, but check if details match. Wait, the prompt\\'s original has a specific head with blue eyes, whiskers, mechanical parts. The first model\\'s views might have variations, but the second model—do they match the prompt\\'s key elements?\\n\\nWait, the prompt is a robotic cat with steampunk design. Let\\'s check each model\\'s adherence. For the first 3D model (penalty_1), the models have some variations in details (like head shape, mechanical parts arrangement), but overall style is matching. So maybe a 3 penalty? Wait, no—wait, the prompt\\'s original image is a specific robotic cat. The first 3D model\\'s four views—do they capture the prompt\\'s key elements? The second model—similar. Wait, let\\'s think about the penalty scale: 0 is perfect, 3 is minor issues, 5 moderate, etc. If the models have some differences but still match the general concept (robotic cat, steampunk, brass), then maybe 3 for each? Wait, no—wait, the first model\\'s views might have more variation, but the second model—wait, let\\'s check the details. The prompt\\'s cat has a head with blue eyes, whiskers, mechanical ear (the big gear-like thing), and a body with exposed gears. The first 3D model\\'s views—do they have those? The second model—do they? Let\\'s see. The first model\\'s top left view has a similar head shape, but the second model\\'s top left is closer to the prompt\\'s original. Wait, maybe the first model has some issues (like different eye shape, body structure), but the second model is closer? Wait, no, the question is whether each model matches the prompt. So for the first 3D model (penalty_1), let\\'s say it has minor issues—so 3. For the second (penalty_2), maybe also 3? Wait, no, wait. Wait, the prompt\\'s original image is a specific robotic cat. The first 3D model\\'s four views—do they all represent the same cat? The second model\\'s four views—do they? Wait, maybe the first model has more variation, so penalty_1 is 3, penalty_2 is 3? Wait, no, let\\'s think again. The prompt is a single robotic cat. The first 3D model (four views) shows different angles, but do they match the prompt\\'s style? The second model\\'s four views—do they? Let\\'s check the mechanical parts, the cat\\'s features (ears, eyes, whiskers), the color (brass/gold). If the models have some differences but still fit the steampunk robotic cat concept, then minor issues (3) for each. Wait, but maybe the first model has more issues, like different body structure, so 3, and the second is closer, so 3? Wait, no, the question is \"Does each 3D model match the image prompt?\" So we need to assign penalties. Let\\'s think: the first model has some variations in details (like head shape, mechanical components), but overall is a robotic cat. So penalty_1 = 3. The second model—maybe closer, but still some issues, so penalty_2 = 3? Wait, or maybe the first model has 3, second has 3? Wait, no, let\\'s check the original prompt\\'s image. The robotic cat has a head with blue eyes, whiskers, a mechanical ear (the big gear), and a body with exposed gears. The first 3D model\\'s top left view has a similar head, but the second model\\'s top left is closer. Wait, maybe the first model has a 3, second has 3. Then the issues would be \"Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt.\" Wait, but let\\'s confirm. The prompt\\'s image is a specific robotic cat. The first 3D model\\'s four views—do they match the prompt\\'s key elements? The second model\\'s four views—do they? If both models have minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details), then', 'reasoning_details': [{'format': None, 'index': 0, 'type': 'reasoning.text', 'text': 'Got it, let\\'s analyze this. First, the image prompt is a steampunk-style robotic cat with brass/gold tones, mechanical parts, cat features (ears, eyes, whiskers), and a mechanical body. Now, we need to check each 3D model (first and second) against the prompt.\\n\\nFirst, look at the first 3D model (four views). The models have similar steampunk elements—mechanical parts, cat shape, brass color. But check details: do they match the prompt\\'s specific features? The prompt\\'s original cat has a certain head shape, eye color, mechanical components. The first model\\'s variations might have slight differences, but overall style is steampunk cat robot. Then the second model—similar style, but check if details match. Wait, the prompt\\'s original has a specific head with blue eyes, whiskers, mechanical parts. The first model\\'s views might have variations, but the second model—do they match the prompt\\'s key elements?\\n\\nWait, the prompt is a robotic cat with steampunk design. Let\\'s check each model\\'s adherence. For the first 3D model (penalty_1), the models have some variations in details (like head shape, mechanical parts arrangement), but overall style is matching. So maybe a 3 penalty? Wait, no—wait, the prompt\\'s original image is a specific robotic cat. The first 3D model\\'s four views—do they capture the prompt\\'s key elements? The second model—similar. Wait, let\\'s think about the penalty scale: 0 is perfect, 3 is minor issues, 5 moderate, etc. If the models have some differences but still match the general concept (robotic cat, steampunk, brass), then maybe 3 for each? Wait, no—wait, the first model\\'s views might have more variation, but the second model—wait, let\\'s check the details. The prompt\\'s cat has a head with blue eyes, whiskers, mechanical ear (the big gear-like thing), and a body with exposed gears. The first 3D model\\'s views—do they have those? The second model—do they? Let\\'s see. The first model\\'s top left view has a similar head shape, but the second model\\'s top left is closer to the prompt\\'s original. Wait, maybe the first model has some issues (like different eye shape, body structure), but the second model is closer? Wait, no, the question is whether each model matches the prompt. So for the first 3D model (penalty_1), let\\'s say it has minor issues—so 3. For the second (penalty_2), maybe also 3? Wait, no, wait. Wait, the prompt\\'s original image is a specific robotic cat. The first 3D model\\'s four views—do they all represent the same cat? The second model\\'s four views—do they? Wait, maybe the first model has more variation, so penalty_1 is 3, penalty_2 is 3? Wait, no, let\\'s think again. The prompt is a single robotic cat. The first 3D model (four views) shows different angles, but do they match the prompt\\'s style? The second model\\'s four views—do they? Let\\'s check the mechanical parts, the cat\\'s features (ears, eyes, whiskers), the color (brass/gold). If the models have some differences but still fit the steampunk robotic cat concept, then minor issues (3) for each. Wait, but maybe the first model has more issues, like different body structure, so 3, and the second is closer, so 3? Wait, no, the question is \"Does each 3D model match the image prompt?\" So we need to assign penalties. Let\\'s think: the first model has some variations in details (like head shape, mechanical components), but overall is a robotic cat. So penalty_1 = 3. The second model—maybe closer, but still some issues, so penalty_2 = 3? Wait, or maybe the first model has 3, second has 3? Wait, no, let\\'s check the original prompt\\'s image. The robotic cat has a head with blue eyes, whiskers, a mechanical ear (the big gear), and a body with exposed gears. The first 3D model\\'s top left view has a similar head, but the second model\\'s top left is closer. Wait, maybe the first model has a 3, second has 3. Then the issues would be \"Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt.\" Wait, but let\\'s confirm. The prompt\\'s image is a specific robotic cat. The first 3D model\\'s four views—do they match the prompt\\'s key elements? The second model\\'s four views—do they? If both models have minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details), then'}]}}], 'system_fingerprint': '', 'usage': {'prompt_tokens': 4299, 'completion_tokens': 1024, 'total_tokens': 5323, 'cost': 0.0002334216, 'is_byok': False, 'prompt_tokens_details': {'cached_tokens': 0, 'audio_tokens': 0, 'video_tokens': 0}, 'cost_details': {'upstream_inference_cost': None, 'upstream_inference_prompt_cost': 0.000120372, 'upstream_inference_completions_cost': 0.0001130496}, 'completion_tokens_details': {'reasoning_tokens': 1064, 'image_tokens': 0}}}"
},
{
"task_id": "ac95819bbee4dc432018cc7ec43066fc35fa7ed4619b3047d8317f08646afafa",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.22786855697632,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4.5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape/color variations, slight detail differences from the original prompt's specific textures and shading.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in texture and pose details; second model has moderate differences in color tones, clothing details, and hat texture."
},
{
"task_id": "ae32314c7b3f4e52777fb675ec65a8f38075d2c0409ba25f8be20b349f3e98e1",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.11930751800537,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor detail issues (hummingbird wings, umbrella texture); second model has more significant issues (umbrella color, hummingbird position, detail).. Swapped pass: Hummingbird details (wings, body) and umbrella texture differ from prompt; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues."
},
{
"task_id": "aeef64af9f4f637a4f8ed35b4ddce883cfdb6138ad02fb22ea840272b48da247",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.527135133743286,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4.5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the prompt (e.g., base design variations, lampshade tone/texture discrepancies). Swapped pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues with base design (shape and decorative elements) and lampshade details, not matching the prompt's elegant, tall structure with specific decorative elements."
},
{
"task_id": "b56856d58cae8c5503d1e06163e758e1501941ce422f34b30a0fc08159b53e9f",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.697691917419434,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail issues; second model has major issues with style and missing details.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail mismatches, style deviations from prompt's original model features"
},
{
"task_id": "bdd9988c3cfcd6be01c9908f5470c083d61d461d780848a804fc8c6597fc25f8",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 20.12797212600708,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 7,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has slight shape and detail variations; second model has major key material and body style deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape irregularities, key details mismatch, decorative elements incomplete"
},
{
"task_id": "c6f8d07eaba9d7e1d83efc3fb48bfb36f8c918d32ef1d603dfb5699c51708c08",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 35.58064413070679,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape/pattern/bean differences; second model lacks coffee beans and has significant pattern/shape issues.. Swapped pass: First model lacks coffee beans; second model has different mug decorative patterns and coffee beans not matching the image prompt's arrangement/style."
},
{
"task_id": "c8043aa34480377ed1efc8e872594016bccf759ab63fbdbfc2a5a7fa24fa6113",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.77057933807373,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3.5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in crystal details, base texture, and chandelier design compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small decorative details in crystals and base"
},
{
"task_id": "cecdad57a9844079239221070d8905ba6cabc6b196154298120c72b35508b9aa",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 21.37317705154419,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 7,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape and spine detail differences; second model has major issues with extra non-cactus elements.. Swapped pass: First model has extra non-cactus elements (white blobs); second model has minor shape/detail differences from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "d454a863a15901b9a092980e08a2a411d2ce569b318e89b5035c3e7644510a12",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.706550121307373,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small design details (wheel accents, rear light strip, body contours). Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details (rear light strip, wheel accents, body contours)"
},
{
"task_id": "d48fdaea8b8cec973f812aafb3a5d1c6dc0aaf752a536c9a24d650fc467ec2d4",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.071126699447632,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: Texture appears smoother than the prompt's rustic/aged look; shape has minor variations; rope details differ.. Swapped pass: Both models have ring shapes similar to the prompt but lack the detailed rust texture and specific rope appearance of the original image; first model has minor shape/texture differences, second model has moderate differences in texture and overall detail adherence."
},
{
"task_id": "d5755871455cbf88f1d15c60cdcd9c1e4423feb8a792fff4eecf390d53f08068",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.719285011291504,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences (e.g., grille, headlights, body contours not matching prompt). Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences (e.g., front grille, wheel design, and interior elements) from the original car's specifications"
},
{
"task_id": "da7c927ed1b41d4aaea94091e3e3234fdf87a4d5bf25188aa3a3b7e44ca8f900",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.063405752182007,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences; both models have similar robotic hand structure but don't perfectly match prompt's specific mechanical details and finger configuration.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, finger arrangement, and detail accuracy vary from the prompt's robotic hand structure."
},
{
"task_id": "dc764d36cfa19dc0da0ffe9a16bc69cc4b04186f6c87d4092418e1787317943b",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.778215169906616,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 6.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has moderate shape differences and detail loss; second model has major shape and style deviations from the prompt's teardrop - shaped, glossy object with internal sparkles.. Swapped pass: Shape of the main object (teardrop/gem-like) does not match rounded forms in both models; rock base texture is smoother than the prompt's rough, irregular texture; internal sparkles/detail in the prompt's object are not fully represented."
},
{
"task_id": "dd6e1665c6c29451e7eb48e57f2b8a38c9c60539d7305f9d5e188a74f5f1bf07",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.737691402435303,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6.5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape distortions, missing detailed embroidery, texture mismatches. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (slight shape differences, detail inaccuracies); second model has major issues (significant shape distortion, category mismatch)"
},
{
"task_id": "ddef1ea68580c673465043a74ff76679209b72b92d7b91d8ed118570f651cd6e",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 33.808226585388184,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape differences, minor texture variations from the prompt's aged wood appearance. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, less detailed wood texture compared to prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "e0355662024ef9e95ffd1ed97e302246292487046d0b40037e1eef6983aa0f2d",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 21.345033884048462,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details (e.g., pot design, bottle/glass arrangement). Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details, inconsistent item arrangement"
},
{
"task_id": "e23672684cf6cfdb72620d5fb86d1417364ad89455cc1a230be831bc2d8eea1e",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.640917539596558,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor differences in wood texture, frame structure, and base details; second model has more noticeable style and detail discrepancies (e.g., wood uniformity, container shape, base design) compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and texture differences; second model has moderate style and detail differences in wooden frame and base elements."
},
{
"task_id": "e39a1d0f4d551b0a93e08a50da4738d4b1b5854aca4176d665a2c5d65404969f",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.57668685913086,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4.5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Minor issues in color tone, base details, and slight shape differences compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Color mismatch (not bronze), base details differ, slight shape differences from prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "e54ef712f929bcab5aa6fd2848bf0cbb095e53f3af1efa2d4eec779145c4100b",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 19.937747716903687,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6.5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with style (less realistic, stylized appearance) and detail (missing aged texture, specific binding elements like tassels/rope) compared to the prompt's realistic, aged book.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (slight shape differences, inconsistent text style, binding variations); second model has major issues (wrong style, missing handwritten text, incorrect binding details, less aged appearance)"
},
{
"task_id": "e5846d5547a3ac830b2916013243cce604ccbbbe6610237973b0c21202b72cc2",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 21.25809931755066,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Control panel details, door reflection, and overall design fidelity do not match the prompt's specific elements.. Swapped pass: Control panel details, door transparency, and minor shape differences do not match the prompt exactly."
},
{
"task_id": "e611000d205ded6786cc30ba41e05d24a9ede5262b8df4ddca73268b958c98f5",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.144182205200195,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has slight droplet placement differences and minor texture variations; second model lacks small droplets from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model lacks surrounding droplets and has simplified 3D rendering; second model has surrounding droplets with minor variations in their positions."
},
{
"task_id": "ea40e89d2371a4db0b5e521eac3f95a3c2b528c4cf87aba111d070029bc5164c",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.49338984489441,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape, texture, and color variations from the prompt bowl. Swapped pass: Slight shape and shading variations from the prompt bowl; overall category matches but minor details differ."
},
{
"task_id": "eb4df482b234ecfee9849a94737da64068dbe804006bc2fa3c0f8ef6baa1daa0",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 15.495355606079102,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Missing gemstones, chain, and detailed texture; crossguard and pommel designs do not match prompt details.. Swapped pass: Missing detailed gemstones, chain texture, and hilt design; simplified crossguard and sword texture."
},
{
"task_id": "ebe73a17-6e49-4486-b329-4d22e946429f",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.274582862854004,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 7,
"leader_penalty": 7,
"issues": "Direct pass: Color mismatch (original is orange/yellow, models are yellow), structural differences (joints, body shape), missing detailed mechanical elements from the prompt. Swapped pass: Color mismatch (yellow vs. orange), significant detail differences, and style deviations from the prompt's robot design"
},
{
"task_id": "ef05bab8c9e61f942b1fa7aea1777c1678e6d2325f767657b4dfac1285900218",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 15.314209461212158,
"winner": "left",
"ours_penalty": 3,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape/angle variations and slight shading differences; second model has color mismatch, shape deviation, and detail differences from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has color mismatch (beige instead of gold), shape irregularities (bumps on blade); second model has closer color but minor base texture differences."
},
{
"task_id": "ef3f66dfe4c36cf6fbafe5419bb5cfe7b78149a9bc204030f01e28d1e4935052",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.420445919036865,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Knitting patterns and texture details do not fully match the prompt's specific cable and ribbing designs; color variations and pom - pom details are inconsistent.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have variations in texture detail (cable knit definition) and color consistency compared to the prompt’s specific cable knit pattern and color; first model has slight shape/color differences, second has more moderate texture/detail issues."
},
{
"task_id": "f22624ab8a4f50b2959fdc63c297f0bf727cf37a680b23bb1634ba27431e8425",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 22.48587727546692,
"winner": "right",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 3.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has color variations in rim patterns and central decorative ring; second model has minor differences in central decorative ring but closer rim patterns matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate details missing, color/style variations from prompt"
},
{
"task_id": "f2c7e07d6278504f7453f7a9465f11cdb7dba8dd27223d555c4d246f29214eb3",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.436760902404785,
"winner": "right",
"ours_penalty": 5.5,
"leader_penalty": 3.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: Shape and detail mismatches, style deviations from prompt's mechanical device.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has significant style and structural differences from the prompt's mechanical device."
},
{
"task_id": "f626e402b01b5681ed545acb0d994c4b107eadeeca673b278a18b4887ef05e3d",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.247597455978394,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight variations in wing color/shading and beak details; overall category and style match the prompt.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models match the cartoon hummingbird style of the prompt, but the second model has slightly less color contrast in wing feathers and minor differences in beak length compared to the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "f786960904a42e5a3a576c76b0efc6e0bedc72ea9777a8284c31c9a4e283f464",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.078284740447998,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 3.5,
"leader_penalty": 4,
"issues": "Direct pass: Slight shape differences, minor detail inconsistencies (e.g., handle positioning, container proportions) between models and prompt; second model has more noticeable style variations.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, handle details, and color shading variations from the prompt."
},
{
"task_id": "fd39cb5e4d3c421f5d4a2d6371b3a05a9c35cc6372ef491ad5fd02d59de034ea",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.13697361946106,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6.5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has extraneous powder outside the bottle; second model uses a non-transparent, gray material instead of clear glass. Swapped pass: First model has incorrect glass material (matte gray instead of clear glass), altered powder color, and slight shape variations; second model includes spillage around the bottle (not present in the prompt) and incorrect glass texture."
},
{
"task_id": "fe37418c9a9a7e1fd1f8d54029eb42d86b2a453ecc18bb56aabfa6eb5586a18e",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 18.08874273300171,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 5,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues: missing intricate filigree details, differences in small diamond arrangement, and less ornate design compared to the prompt's elaborate style."
},
{
"task_id": "fffa1d42-6004-4b07-bc2e-a4c4610b2c15",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 17.927953243255615,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 6,
"leader_penalty": 6,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has moderate detail differences (shield, helmet, cape); second model has major shield detail change (music note) and style variations. Swapped pass: Shield design, armor detail, and base texture differ from prompt; stylized elements not matching original realism."
},
{
"task_id": "fffa86ddece1ad8effb60840a32a5acdaccfe934a1f7f98b3e83113cf2228529",
"status": "success",
"gen_time": 16.5828697681427,
"winner": "draw",
"ours_penalty": 4,
"leader_penalty": 5,
"issues": "Direct pass: First model has minor shape and size differences; second model has moderate differences in size and decorative details compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Color mismatch (red cover instead of brown), texture differences in leather, minor discrepancies in gold decorative details."
}
] |
YAML Metadata
Warning:
empty or missing yaml metadata in repo card
(https://huggingface.co/docs/hub/datasets-cards)
📊 Task Overview
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Total tasks | 128 |
| Total judged | 125 |
| Skipped | 0 |
| Generation failed | 0 |
| Render failed | 0 |
| Judge failed | 3 |
| 🏁 Results | |
| Outcome | Count |
| ------- | ----: |
| Wins | 11 |
| Draws | 106 |
| Losses | 8 |
| 📈 Performance Metrics |
Win Rate: 8.8%
Margin: 2.4%
Average Generation Time: 19.50 seconds
📝 Notes
No tasks were skipped or failed during generation/rendering.
A small number of tasks (3) failed during judging.
The majority of evaluated tasks resulted in draws, indicating close or balanced performance.
- Downloads last month
- 264