text
string
source
string
embeddings
list
In this letter we derive new expressions for tree-level graviton amplitudes in $\mathcal{N}=8$ supergravity from BCFW recursion relations combined with new types of bonus relations. These bonus relations go beyond the famous $1/z^2$ behavior under a large BCFW shift, and use knowledge about certain zeroes of graviton amplitudes in collinear kinematics. This extra knowledge can be used in the context of global residue theorems by writing the amplitude in a special form using canonical building blocks. In the NMHV case these building blocks are dressed one-loop leading singularities, the same objects that appear in the expansion of Yang-Mills amplitudes, where each term corresponds to an $R$-invariant. Unlike other approaches, our formula is not an expansion in terms of cyclic objects and does not manifest color-kinematics duality, but rather preserves the permutational symmetry of its building blocks. We also comment on the possible connection to Grassmannian geometry and give some non-trivial evidence of such structure for graviton amplitudes.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05710v1
[ -0.008392726071178913, -0.017945481464266777, 0.0023893811739981174, 0.01207579206675291, 0.046261176466941833, 0.036678411066532135, -0.06705096364021301, -0.025697357952594757, -0.008788191713392735, -0.02457621321082115, -0.019154131412506104, -0.0604904480278492, -0.050498925149440765, -0.022577648982405663, -0.054835669696331024, 0.003951824735850096, 0.06194499507546425, 0.010265814140439034, -0.02715747430920601, 0.06731315702199936, 0.02906659059226513, -0.06010054796934128, -0.05317547172307968, 0.07076721638441086, -0.025102531537413597, -0.01797585003077984, -0.018105603754520416, -0.028137654066085815, -0.020377617329359055, -0.031647875905036926, 0.0865451917052269, -0.03950059413909912, 0.002917777979746461, -0.017803218215703964, -0.0040822746232151985, -0.020036131143569946, -0.002447235630825162, 0.04331892356276512, 0.03910725191235542, -0.036318399012088776, -0.0024047577753663063, -0.01833304576575756, -0.03853660821914673, -0.018312055617570877, -0.06061015650629997, 0.010689722374081612, 0.0003226676781196147, 0.0028922054916620255, -0.04244145750999451, -0.05838500335812569, 0.032349467277526855, 0.021576937288045883, 0.04389625042676926, 0.042764224112033844, -0.05712568759918213, 0.003870596643537283, -0.005378935486078262, -0.00950555969029665, -0.055775076150894165, 0.010100077837705612, -0.008993838913738728, -0.025291139259934425, 0.029710788279771805, -0.04619550704956055, -0.027137039229273796, 0.06158820167183876, -0.05485796555876732, -0.07748819142580032, 0.0056199138052761555, -0.03979180008172989, 0.031769685447216034, -0.07047783583402634, 0.019829735159873962, -0.027411891147494316, -0.03703521192073822, 0.022286059334874153, -0.03381973132491112, -0.04300505295395851, -0.015354556031525135, 0.03514721244573593, -0.0024840408004820347, 0.00302737089805305, -0.012443270534276962, 0.005745801143348217, -0.0013165588025003672, 0.04439018666744232, 0.05395789444446564, -0.014668538235127926, -0.014492854475975037, -0.059880319982767105, 0.03225077688694, -0.04642194136977196, -0.06696012616157532, -0.042583219707012177, 0.06763047724962234, -0.02238098531961441, 0.03561646491289139, 0.03185608610510826, 0.032724108546972275, -0.019720038399100304, 0.00638463394716382, -0.07765358686447144, 0.002448207698762417, 0.016489019617438316, -0.002482704119756818, -0.015422305092215538, 0.007671149913221598, 0.02496173046529293, -0.048556309193372726, 0.03794030100107193, -0.012816895730793476, -0.0221336018294096, -0.0054761082865297794, -0.029343388974666595, -0.01162075437605381, -0.07232557237148285, 0.04509435221552849, 0.0027309663128107786, 0.04126545041799545, 0.009625600650906563, -0.03270728141069412, 0.00491329375654459, 0.03080100752413273, 0.006526052951812744, -0.003970896825194359, -0.012467869557440281, 0.06857718527317047, 0.012345544993877411, 0.014538337476551533, -0.02579129859805107, -0.032606955617666245, -0.01762659102678299, 0.008771466091275215, -0.003294426016509533, 0.05531660094857216, -0.015083665028214455, -0.0003371371130924672, -0.0363774411380291, 0.01865873485803604, 0.050821807235479355, 0.01853308640420437, -0.06596418470144272, 0.023529108613729477, 0.012891844846308231, 0.04125403240323067, 0.03947006165981293, -0.0769977867603302, 0.021118229255080223, 0.008409220725297928, -0.02385137788951397, -0.04368578642606735, -0.016908640041947365, 0.03402817249298096, 0.029615120962262154, 0.02445182390511036, -0.02557680942118168, 0.04948733374476433, 0.017322057858109474, -0.03282443434000015, 0.01143668033182621, 0.023793503642082214, -0.03032313659787178, -0.03427945822477341, 0.011526823043823242, 0.036685362458229065, -0.009763481095433235, 0.04721366614103317, -0.021150801330804825, -0.004663805942982435, 0.025046048685908318, -0.037209924310445786, -0.013789104297757149, 0.042151108384132385, -0.009332206100225449, -0.039038557559251785, -0.040280673652887344, -0.019551075994968414, -0.06280263513326645, -0.046982813626527786, 0.006229637190699577, 0.028590615838766098, -0.02383003756403923, -0.0390218123793602, 0.019090458750724792, -0.021636297926306725, 0.005711606238037348, -0.06917077302932739, 0.04071541503071785, 0.04345765709877014, 0.022117888554930687, -0.03563134744763374, -0.05297476798295975, 0.04443487152457237, -0.01542462594807148, -0.04623548313975334, -0.011103924363851547, 0.015460621565580368, -0.045339055359363556, -0.035644736140966415, 0.032834503799676895, -0.0799601823091507, -0.052793607115745544, -0.04046738147735596, 0.002631846582517028, 0.017540838569402695, -0.0782509297132492, -0.004794759210199118, 0.04628884419798851, -0.02125055342912674, -0.05587158352136612, 0.05146608129143715, -0.01893513835966587, 0.034267157316207886, -0.05317235738039017, -0.008919387124478817, -0.04804329574108124, -0.0952843576669693, 0.04976104199886322, 0.003529377281665802, 0.026380855590105057, 0.008285745978355408, 0.007243599742650986, 0.0048537105321884155, -0.04517408832907677, -0.018576035276055336, 0.04349089041352272, 0.04588399454951286, 0.04013080522418022, -0.04211030155420303, -0.040862131863832474, 0.009801841340959072, -0.04450908675789833, -0.053949955850839615, -0.07935313135385513, -0.01845688745379448, -0.004798495210707188, -0.030233200639486313, 0.06212956830859184, 0.019741078838706017, -0.06362330168485641, -0.0073239607736468315, -0.017652522772550583, 0.038312893360853195, -0.008631077595055103, -0.06725391745567322, -0.03760318085551262, -0.03933129832148552, -0.02042369917035103, -0.0494844913482666, -0.03460618853569031, 0.04138961806893349, -0.06631011515855789, -0.050589025020599365, -0.039960827678442, -0.003471545409411192, 0.040830209851264954, -0.06870173662900925, 0.01642792485654354, -0.027841603383421898, -0.023540936410427094, -0.01055024191737175, 0.03257689252495766, -0.042854566127061844, 0.017466112971305847, 0.003257032949477434, 0.031249012798070908, -0.06787558645009995, -0.04362630099058151, 0.023714879527688026, -0.011746822856366634, 0.017274394631385803, 0.02455272153019905, 0.05825505778193474, -0.018632808700203896, -0.01737198419868946, 0.04219591245055199, -0.004141074605286121, -0.05740538239479065, 0.015941072255373, 0.013060414232313633, 0.057686351239681244, 0.03333612531423569, -0.05019400641322136, -0.06301707029342651, -0.05742514505982399, 0.002015643520280719, -0.05046879127621651, -0.0283163134008646, -0.04230426624417305, -0.023629119619727135, -0.08306046575307846, 0.0035060173831880093, -0.04830538108944893, -0.04920155927538872, -0.03180826082825661, -0.06849821656942368, 0.028926244005560875, -0.03690072149038315, 0.009710704907774925, -0.08109424263238907, -0.04402397200465202, 0.06025826185941696, 0.01842888444662094, 0.013092503882944584, -0.027618279680609703, -0.06088881567120552, -0.020584894344210625, 0.031175866723060608, -0.016863904893398285, -0.021435299888253212, -0.030815398320555687, -0.006894248072057962, -0.027721397578716278, 0.005642978474497795, 0.01608571596443653, 0.038567859679460526, 0.028946205973625183, -0.039608266204595566, 0.01160204317420721, -0.059996381402015686, -0.04657847434282303, -0.008132382296025753, 0.02269449643790722, -0.003952864557504654, -0.05988175421953201, -0.04999753087759018, 0.049074266105890274, 0.07454250007867813, -0.01490246132016182, -0.022616082802414894, -0.052841801196336746, 0.0011541566345840693, 0.023433145135641098, -0.02209930494427681, 0.041745249181985855, 0.034954626113176346, 0.01885327883064747, -0.04116334766149521, -0.028934931382536888, 0.0036099464632570744, -0.013765824027359486, -0.007314814254641533, -0.05033385381102562, -0.023943835869431496, 0.029834328219294548, -0.08128567785024643, 0.051992181688547134, 0.03095269948244095, 0.06001095473766327, -0.025399399921298027, -0.004060846753418446, 0.010966253466904163, 0.01885034702718258, 0.04035197198390961, -0.010868179611861706, 0.002578619634732604, 0.027225004509091377, 0.06530436128377914, -0.024291682988405228, -0.03173148259520531, -0.02805939130485058, -0.048089295625686646, -0.0354473777115345, 0.020466946065425873, 0.028079751878976822, 0.07655314356088638, 0.029963044449687004, -0.0033405525609850883, 0.04049041122198105, -0.027320407330989838, 0.036629706621170044, -0.040627773851156235, -0.014700254425406456, -0.003566878382116556, 0.012057160958647728, -0.010739259421825409, -0.002595875645056367, -0.021020056679844856, -0.002506081946194172, -0.03631981462240219, -0.04146081581711769, -0.03235020488500595, 0.03434893488883972, 0.007295397575944662, -0.00641594547778368, 0.04547395929694176, -0.0022932651918381453, -0.016020003706216812, 0.04593642055988312, -0.039060499519109726, -0.010506799444556236, -0.040782831609249115, -0.00533914053812623, -0.0035597640089690685, 0.014976010657846928, -0.030070001259446144, -0.03084193542599678, 0.005946663673967123, -0.04062118008732796, -0.031144969165325165, 0.013414488174021244, 0.0003999854379799217, -0.04353275150060654, -0.08693129569292068, -0.02143741026520729, -0.04623958840966225, -0.02843269519507885, -0.01176128163933754, -0.06534094363451004, 0.08320638537406921, -0.0038103419356048107, -0.001763704582117498, -0.007274332456290722, -0.011994447559118271, -0.05767858400940895, -0.004299228545278311, -0.027875537052750587, -0.03782977536320686, 0.03601077198982239, -0.027194686233997345, 0.01851649396121502, -0.018110306933522224, -0.015460112132132053, -0.04418187215924263, 0.0007358172442764044, -0.016828706488013268, 0.02971200831234455, 0.00030396479996852577, 0.06028137356042862, -0.0012107439106330276, 0.01659572497010231, -0.04224864020943642, 0.01662898249924183, 0.023016057908535004, 0.012788478285074234, -0.04097728803753853, 0.04159455746412277, -0.042794596403837204, -0.0232976283878088, -0.04181084409356117, -0.020292000845074654, 0.04141966998577118, -0.04457966983318329, -0.01775476522743702, 0.017248306423425674, 0.029623547568917274, -0.0491567961871624, -0.023627707734704018, -0.04058341681957245, -0.016103709116578102, -0.0688452422618866, 0.008141524158418179, 0.027778208255767822, -0.013311795890331268, -0.039296191185712814, 0.027059456333518028, -0.013116046786308289, 0.03589676693081856, -0.016816643998026848, 0.010442683473229408, 0.017746565863490105, -0.01673763059079647, 0.008598844520747662, -0.005744928494095802, -0.02692374959588051, -0.004132585600018501, -0.03904101252555847, -0.008462092839181423, 0.027088867500424385, 0.038006968796253204, -0.010367687791585922, 0.052813250571489334, -0.07994865626096725, 0.029656140133738518, 0.04680908843874931, -0.0057951295748353004, -0.05362025275826454, 0.03311500325798988, -0.05228497087955475, 0.02637028694152832, 0.0009623681544326246, 0.018786199390888214, 0.009163490496575832, 0.02607126347720623, 0.022672368213534355, -0.021410517394542694, -0.02367720939218998, -0.026242075487971306, 0.004371689632534981, -0.01698978990316391, -0.032941192388534546, 0.0016186573775485158, 0.0034800968132913113, 0.007389575242996216, -0.036095984280109406, 0.045697808265686035, 0.027020977810025215, -0.04544929414987564, -0.0565200112760067, -0.0008431755122728646, -0.0030034317169338465, 0.02949773147702217, 0.0225220937281847, -0.0469370111823082, 0.016334515064954758, 0.03537809103727341, -0.0014169065980240703, -0.012834600172936916, 0.036924097687006, -0.0008505292353220284, -0.02990124374628067, 0.015094498172402382, 0.0026795589365065098, -0.03804643824696541, -0.03204452618956566, -0.05019880831241608, 0.03853736072778702, 0.04149617254734039, 0.003315826877951622, 0.055790577083826065, 0.044274672865867615, 0.02049914374947548, -0.012297457084059715, -0.00022840838937554508, -0.036637190729379654, 0.04786663502454758, -0.049455367028713226, 0.027873648330569267, -0.045696355402469635, 0.04968613386154175, -0.024312641471624374, 0.003650505095720291, -0.021258585155010223, -0.01732904277741909, -0.02313501387834549, -0.006001957692205906, 0.01848120614886284, 0.0011397311463952065, -0.04048043489456177, -0.005975978448987007, 0.05248420313000679, -0.0394006185233593, 0.053778793662786484, -0.0002084146544802934, 0.05204789340496063, 0.03367207944393158, 0.006976324133574963, 0.05260995775461197, -0.04362187534570694, -0.05484145134687424, 0.08090327680110931, -0.06507769227027893, -0.014860289171338081, -0.03619067370891571, -0.059847068041563034, -0.024675827473402023, -0.06716550886631012, 0.031136827543377876, -0.0051298621110618114, -0.04704518988728523, -0.04568690061569214, 0.04827204719185829, 0.024400051683187485, -0.07174986600875854, -0.00269992183893919, 0.049523018300533295, -0.07217620313167572, -0.011964354664087296, -0.003947311080992222, -0.017273331061005592, -0.049085766077041626, 0.021512489765882492, 0.0007828299421817064, -0.029939817264676094, -0.039854202419519424, 0.07286010682582855, 0.06474317610263824, -0.05422273278236389, 0.058968763798475266, 0.04986823350191116, -0.04801281914114952, 0.01768949255347252, -0.051863957196474075, 0.012436478398740292, -0.007062853313982487, 0.01308875996619463, -0.022875454276800156, -0.023643428459763527, -0.01372698973864317, 0.05879567191004753, -0.04488527774810791, -0.018727274611592293, 0.04399363696575165, 0.02005281299352646, 0.04517076164484024, -0.014666507951915264, 0.013205485418438911, -0.004221845883876085, 0.010677611455321312, -0.01840611919760704, -0.003956509754061699, -0.02803155779838562, 0.01765601523220539, 0.026837432757019997, 0.005587179679423571, -0.03381925821304321, -0.01674085482954979, -0.03043675236403942, -0.07962454110383987, -0.016727153211832047, -0.03605028614401817, 0.004265701863914728, -0.01376453135162592, 0.03165442496538162, 0.010487458668649197, 0.030433289706707, -0.030517106875777245, -0.007001971825957298, -0.019687745720148087, 0.019129114225506783, -0.01191528607159853, -0.0108098229393363, 0.01815245859324932, -0.005085962358862162, 0.06596193462610245, -0.05205356702208519, 0.029736638069152832, -0.0312814824283123, -0.06935437768697739, 0.0030415758956223726, -0.021937990561127663, -0.06296907365322113, -0.00739625096321106, 0.016577836126089096, -0.02728545293211937, 0.023684319108724594, 0.007241980638355017, -0.030895546078681946, -0.06651413440704346, 0.008345205336809158, 0.04104258120059967, -0.010955918580293655, 0.03955911844968796, -0.009012316353619099, 0.02058667503297329, 0.031872402876615524, 0.03613920509815216, 0.06843360513448715, -0.008074216544628143, 0.03999705985188484, -0.05231662839651108, -0.008768346160650253, -0.007251083850860596, -0.020132308825850487, -0.014380979351699352, 0.010395540855824947, -0.036985427141189575, -0.07435543090105057, 0.01956089958548546, -0.028256524354219437, 0.00021053246746305376, 0.0002728776598814875, -0.05785422399640083, 0.051972031593322754, 0.013706258498132229, 0.00041754296398721635, -0.06926201283931732, 0.01592211052775383, 0.028526343405246735, 0.00219732359983027, -0.020497366786003113, -0.03285898268222809, -0.05640213564038277, -0.0035283721517771482, -0.08731111139059067, -0.03381524980068207, 0.004844414535909891, 0.011902820318937302, 0.002262270078063011, 0.023904433473944664, -0.0350155346095562, -0.04773964360356331, 0.030634529888629913, 0.008303171023726463, -0.017109913751482964, 0.021666070446372032, -0.025088729336857796, 0.04017743095755577, -0.031238937750458717, 0.02482263185083866, 0.06188464164733887, -0.033676791936159134, 0.033348020166158676, -0.003023686585947871, 0.034012321382761, -0.02898484282195568, 0.040310539305210114, 0.052037350833415985, -0.03141938894987106, 0.027020998299121857, -0.03754497319459915, 0.002928887726739049, -0.04379177838563919, -0.0500987283885479, 0.024445733055472374, -0.049720920622348785, 0.024852942675352097, -0.020452596247196198, -0.0451156385242939, -0.04693717136979103, -0.011210721917450428, -0.03322111442685127, 0.04330664128065109, 0.012567236088216305, -0.024207551032304764, 0.017591087147593498, -0.019405076280236244, -0.04228841885924339, 0.018008941784501076, -0.020814193412661552, -0.02844877541065216, -0.0032093096524477005, 0.0614008754491806, -0.07899995893239975, 0.036420952528715134, -0.07306768000125885, 0.03330887481570244, -0.03854848071932793, -0.020913831889629364, 0.03497463837265968, 0.05648228898644447, 0.0023719570599496365, 0.013425050303339958, -0.03329869732260704, -0.005067001562565565, 0.018852045759558678, -0.07139226794242859, 0.005671910010278225, -0.0033645443618297577, -0.01825767382979393, 0.00862955953925848, 0.0539030060172081, -0.037731070071458817, 0.057069409638643265, -0.021805427968502045, 0.0008558592526242137, 0.012906846590340137, 0.011818677186965942, -0.02831956557929516, 0.028531599789857864, -0.029854144901037216, -0.03601616621017456, -0.025152303278446198, 0.011607586406171322, -0.023853041231632233, -0.007839531637728214, -0.005593116395175457, -0.025536809116601944, 0.026803914457559586, -0.06933213025331497, -0.03482373058795929, 0.048153020441532135, 0.024394996464252472, -0.06197323650121689, 0.05413118377327919, -0.03254367411136627, -0.04296322166919708, -0.060971684753894806 ]
The development of believable, natural, and interactive digital artificial agents is a field of growing interest. Theoretical uncertainties and technical barriers present considerable challenges to the field, particularly with regards to developing agents that effectively simulate human emotions. Large language models (LLMs) might address these issues by tapping common patterns in situational appraisal. In three empirical experiments, this study tests the capabilities of LLMs to solve emotional intelligence tasks and to simulate emotions. It presents and evaluates a new chain-of-emotion architecture for emotion simulation within video games, based on psychological appraisal research. Results show that it outperforms standard LLM architectures on a range of user experience and content analysis metrics. This study therefore provides early evidence of how to construct and test affective agents based on cognitive processes represented in language models.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05076v1
[ -0.007036998402327299, -0.01001904159784317, 0.055523693561553955, -0.02183104306459427, -0.012523510493338108, -0.012419558130204678, 0.0005090986378490925, -0.03183286264538765, -0.06198190525174141, -0.03873356059193611, -0.035238444805145264, 0.029971985146403313, -0.005890070926398039, -0.009917307645082474, -0.061843372881412506, 0.01576755940914154, 0.07509006559848785, 0.03619110584259033, -0.05208529159426689, 0.04120927304029465, 0.006392768118530512, -0.03330148756504059, -0.028237635269761086, 0.04688112810254097, 0.0008760201162658632, -0.01567378267645836, -0.05350221320986748, -0.01376271340996027, -0.0006648364360444248, -0.02046806924045086, 0.06951446086168289, -0.04178307205438614, -0.01397192757576704, -0.05779283121228218, -0.022578522562980652, -0.056762125343084335, -0.03908484801650047, -0.006348953582346439, 0.03823484480381012, -0.06130311265587807, 0.007575725205242634, -0.019723214209079742, -0.08237804472446442, 0.013734882697463036, -0.043102435767650604, 0.018480680882930756, -0.04469265416264534, 0.03962930291891098, -0.08845663070678711, -0.022034574300050735, 0.029092935845255852, -0.02199361100792885, 0.002065492095425725, 0.06190946325659752, -0.03286382555961609, -0.001637343317270279, -0.03405305743217468, 0.004225565120577812, -0.061483681201934814, -0.010784096084535122, 0.007954275235533714, -0.024592315778136253, 0.01733584888279438, 0.035929124802351, 0.017740793526172638, 0.011554363183677197, -0.02304999530315399, -0.029959948733448982, -0.02897295542061329, -0.06153261289000511, 0.052863530814647675, -0.07374384254217148, -0.00812467373907566, -0.03902226686477661, 0.015446632169187069, -0.04127576947212219, 0.0024437911342829466, -0.03064848482608795, -0.03820057958364487, 0.030803777277469635, -0.010205321945250034, 0.05344344303011894, 0.05573708936572075, -0.0009196091559715569, 0.011632904410362244, -0.01893036440014839, 0.03927186504006386, -0.028073465451598167, 0.015322650782763958, -0.055729422718286514, 0.03849346190690994, -0.022771965712308884, -0.05808787792921066, 0.022818688303232193, 0.060204535722732544, 0.00832297746092081, 0.04535987973213196, 0.00510979350656271, 0.005572822410613298, -0.01602860353887081, -0.015685539692640305, -0.025245608761906624, -0.03074616752564907, 0.043068818747997284, 0.036334116011857986, -0.045292407274246216, 0.03343784809112549, -0.013824683614075184, -0.04920882731676102, -0.0154800433665514, -0.03291023522615433, -0.054509036242961884, 0.005807523149996996, -0.05643928050994873, -0.03811566159129143, -0.013120433315634727, 0.060201290994882584, -0.006797031499445438, -0.024834634736180305, 0.03397499397397041, -0.06641582399606705, 0.06471703201532364, -0.00003454397665336728, -0.05911886319518089, -0.03970211744308472, 0.009564677253365517, 0.02970419079065323, 0.01934145763516426, -0.058728769421577454, -0.041314251720905304, -0.033992618322372437, 0.006141026969999075, 0.010547734797000885, -0.038004979491233826, 0.03643137589097023, -0.014283380471169949, -0.049350906163454056, -0.06751567125320435, 0.0090065011754632, -0.013808028772473335, -0.04960864409804344, -0.07275529205799103, 0.026774225756525993, -0.03813046216964722, 0.0071279327385127544, 0.01782621257007122, -0.031193191185593605, -0.008081641048192978, 0.021955138072371483, -0.004422117955982685, 0.021746914833784103, -0.030259214341640472, 0.019046055153012276, 0.03819550201296806, 0.037667226046323776, -0.06403108686208725, 0.04403064027428627, -0.04083499684929848, -0.06177232414484024, -0.020831653848290443, 0.024062244221568108, -0.043374139815568924, -0.007545574568212032, -0.049240563064813614, -0.006512411404401064, 0.0030524907633662224, 0.07191525399684906, -0.020856669172644615, -0.01823127456009388, -0.0417964905500412, -0.0016465142834931612, 0.012517151422798634, -0.01623433828353882, -0.02176741324365139, -0.06320653110742569, -0.05445269122719765, -0.00024467086768709123, -0.055124714970588684, -0.04655556380748749, -0.01681644655764103, 0.043435219675302505, 0.02120380476117134, -0.05066630244255066, -0.022660259157419205, -0.04357711225748062, 0.06148112937808037, -0.06309499591588974, -0.05292200669646263, 0.0413220077753067, 0.024832509458065033, -0.06480398029088974, -0.02123481035232544, -0.0044534276239573956, 0.020457331091165543, -0.04728123918175697, -0.02356797643005848, 0.0008641447639092803, -0.02341455966234207, 0.004952780902385712, 0.04175148904323578, -0.08774135261774063, 0.03821578249335289, -0.03813505172729492, -0.04058996960520744, 0.00005025881182518788, -0.06213907152414322, 0.0002700673649087548, 0.04422793909907341, -0.02434239163994789, -0.04526270553469658, 0.03921578451991081, 0.01586742326617241, 0.05906450003385544, 0.018195539712905884, 0.04739507660269737, 0.03014805167913437, -0.0906427875161171, 0.0672064870595932, 0.0454782135784626, 0.02800522744655609, 0.0289152804762125, 0.029152899980545044, 0.0563584603369236, 0.020876990631222725, 0.004416756797581911, -0.01760147139430046, 0.02228057198226452, -0.008425497449934483, -0.019730493426322937, -0.012278133071959019, -0.014892456121742725, -0.057807471603155136, -0.00011757441097870469, -0.07115347683429718, 0.009935704991221428, -0.0030603869818150997, -0.036445558071136475, 0.04630229249596596, -0.04363011568784714, -0.02595156617462635, -0.03371661528944969, -0.04861379414796829, -0.0008559425477869809, -0.021729666739702225, -0.06386963278055191, -0.05371571332216263, -0.0015420112758874893, 0.0372014045715332, -0.04243545979261398, -0.010230541229248047, -0.03550833463668823, -0.04574749246239662, -0.018539143726229668, -0.0448397658765316, 0.009482779540121555, 0.02087007835507393, -0.030048266053199768, 0.0389767549932003, 0.02881418727338314, 0.045049998909235, 0.05910152569413185, 0.04366485774517059, -0.04726051166653633, 0.04092532768845558, 0.04216320067644119, -0.03482195362448692, 0.00791284628212452, 0.02852722257375717, 0.0008024868438951671, -0.06591370701789856, 0.02118617296218872, 0.04533639922738075, 0.030608272179961205, 0.022534077987074852, -0.041713327169418335, -0.04737306758761406, 0.023176448419690132, -0.032315801829099655, 0.03075799159705639, 0.05671386048197746, 0.03896734490990639, -0.03456369414925575, -0.02419557422399521, -0.06426136940717697, -0.011279573664069176, -0.02862709015607834, -0.05957213044166565, -0.07397346943616867, -0.018778478726744652, -0.01443428359925747, -0.057309214025735855, -0.04773571714758873, -0.0038498544599860907, -0.042906977236270905, 0.00653705932199955, -0.07550211250782013, 0.005189650226384401, -0.05048193410038948, 0.04717394709587097, -0.004992572125047445, -0.03480862081050873, -0.05721728503704071, 0.006931627169251442, 0.00756770558655262, 0.007211707066744566, -0.046032413840293884, -0.020154200494289398, -0.04196884483098984, 0.018336622044444084, -0.03666508570313454, -0.025237958878278732, 0.05491350591182709, -0.03669782355427742, 0.007536493241786957, -0.05110912770032883, -0.00920124538242817, 0.019721807911992073, 0.030855093151330948, -0.02756820246577263, -0.008673267439007759, -0.012835302390158176, -0.04144666716456413, 0.008551464416086674, -0.03495274484157562, -0.013353475369513035, -0.008236597292125225, 0.06240926310420036, -0.025378534570336342, -0.02356407418847084, -0.05676140636205673, -0.013477981090545654, 0.0050420500338077545, 0.03050249069929123, 0.03766624629497528, 0.04678403213620186, -0.00003640546492533758, -0.05661207064986229, -0.017742006108164787, -0.01327864732593298, 0.01532529853284359, -0.034086924046278, -0.0259389765560627, -0.008938487619161606, -0.024262476712465286, 0.03140568733215332, -0.08105029910802841, 0.013506338931620121, 0.058141328394412994, 0.07438676059246063, 0.0065236021764576435, 0.0051996344700455666, 0.012530531734228134, -0.011602824553847313, 0.02179758809506893, -0.01289346069097519, 0.03757106140255928, 0.006403865292668343, 0.049741048365831375, -0.04213344678282738, -0.0000624893291387707, 0.053999487310647964, -0.06282305717468262, -0.05956278368830681, -0.029352456331253052, 0.05172010883688927, 0.041975390166044235, 0.00909359473735094, -0.05246802419424057, 0.034945305436849594, -0.022997822612524033, 0.019584985449910164, -0.008463426493108273, -0.013567490503191948, 0.02598470263183117, -0.07147202640771866, 0.028950929641723633, 0.04132995381951332, -0.0015131577383726835, -0.07155615091323853, -0.029319781810045242, 0.019981330260634422, -0.05601903423666954, 0.011882859282195568, 0.0032899470534175634, -0.03666841611266136, 0.044100817292928696, -0.0009603919461369514, -0.027586953714489937, 0.059953369200229645, -0.02318795770406723, 0.0134219229221344, -0.04058104380965233, -0.03922020271420479, -0.03623156622052193, -0.027409330010414124, -0.06746647506952286, 0.02058565802872181, -0.007834909483790398, -0.05099393427371979, -0.007189912721514702, 0.025116167962551117, 0.020507697016000748, 0.015008685179054737, -0.08010921627283096, -0.018978876993060112, -0.02838175557553768, -0.006143023259937763, 0.015791593119502068, -0.01633395068347454, 0.053274668753147125, -0.027451757341623306, -0.0032797507010400295, -0.012157072313129902, 0.014416076242923737, -0.061258696019649506, -0.029579993337392807, 0.0427577868103981, -0.07730763405561447, 0.006997290067374706, -0.04260256886482239, 0.0030874533113092184, -0.020953278988599777, 0.03091278485953808, -0.03649342805147171, -0.029962727800011635, -0.008074557408690453, 0.04541311040520668, 0.06028759479522705, 0.01606738567352295, -0.034696854650974274, -0.05800860375165939, 0.06788921356201172, -0.030682289972901344, 0.03975008800625801, -0.014169648289680481, 0.0009663131204433739, 0.03951935097575188, -0.044447872787714005, -0.015766790136694908, -0.014559189788997173, 0.0022050514817237854, 0.051774390041828156, -0.01394159346818924, -0.024731844663619995, 0.023528600111603737, 0.013501851819455624, -0.05484652891755104, -0.06263599544763565, -0.04278105869889259, -0.05659586191177368, -0.05514680966734886, -0.002973312744870782, -0.0043706088326871395, 0.05161653459072113, 0.00971886795014143, -0.015992844477295876, -0.01876474730670452, 0.04103226587176323, -0.006787321995943785, 0.006162120029330254, 0.014502303674817085, -0.034463003277778625, -0.009451779536902905, -0.02088511921465397, -0.05812801420688629, 0.0359220877289772, -0.03440365195274353, 0.021507397294044495, -0.02344176173210144, 0.04899740591645241, 0.03676190227270126, 0.03687208890914917, -0.08356642723083496, 0.030550632625818253, 0.055302832275629044, 0.03302522748708725, -0.0368703156709671, 0.0578819140791893, -0.013638562522828579, 0.01804158091545105, -0.04801066964864731, 0.05381813272833824, -0.04144659638404846, -0.029708757996559143, 0.017324378713965416, -0.0271383598446846, -0.023532943800091743, -0.01099284179508686, 0.042421676218509674, -0.024947514757514, -0.06609686464071274, -0.009196417406201363, 0.015503947623074055, 0.0288394708186388, -0.038929376751184464, 0.028118718415498734, 0.040949590504169464, -0.039833590388298035, -0.02641850896179676, -0.03429128974676132, -0.03416282311081886, 0.0017695369897410274, 0.009110837243497372, -0.06670903414487839, 0.013841134496033192, -0.019454415887594223, 0.0006265490083023906, -0.014590251259505749, -0.032544706016778946, -0.005684956442564726, -0.007558006327599287, -0.032527800649404526, -0.014224530197679996, -0.0521080456674099, -0.010372184216976166, -0.05616048350930214, 0.043806977570056915, 0.056592583656311035, -0.007356035057455301, -0.019251517951488495, 0.020904432982206345, -0.026743371039628983, 0.0005040718824602664, -0.0006747751613147557, 0.0010023398790508509, -0.02293982543051243, -0.04428606852889061, 0.03657638654112816, -0.005185007117688656, 0.03827838972210884, 0.012512965127825737, 0.04714127629995346, 0.01679600402712822, -0.002481302944943309, -0.054752327501773834, -0.05645013228058815, 0.007678684312850237, -0.06471805274486542, -0.04847535118460655, 0.041147053241729736, 0.031681641936302185, -0.002604864304885268, 0.003177658887580037, -0.006071676034480333, -0.021666884422302246, -0.01586010865867138, 0.036099933087825775, -0.018805701285600662, -0.06367406994104385, -0.017113149166107178, 0.06790617108345032, -0.027607329189777374, 0.011914243921637535, 0.00914576556533575, -0.04935217648744583, -0.01792474091053009, -0.0549422949552536, 0.0013219908578321338, 0.030644968152046204, 0.004965466912835836, -0.04631204903125763, 0.006792294327169657, 0.023504076525568962, -0.06301325559616089, 0.026832683011889458, -0.01861148700118065, -0.0611504465341568, 0.02441958338022232, 0.01205685455352068, 0.01777450181543827, -0.06825385242700577, 0.049795228987932205, 0.03390731289982796, 0.008454564027488232, -0.013887114822864532, 0.06969207525253296, 0.07331555336713791, -0.022106526419520378, 0.017079290002584457, 0.006683196406811476, -0.04823750630021095, -0.020784221589565277, 0.014207949861884117, -0.03855722397565842, -0.004905981011688709, -0.0011292851995676756, 0.0056638456881046295, -0.038070857524871826, -0.02117927372455597, 0.06632161140441895, 0.033448245376348495, -0.00916755385696888, 0.02590092457830906, -0.02880517952144146, 0.0411732941865921, -0.041115935891866684, -0.01775560900568962, 0.0069632274098694324, -0.006547584198415279, -0.04657511040568352, -0.06685341894626617, -0.013687318190932274, 0.0006690392619930208, 0.03400096669793129, -0.023039525374770164, -0.04221555218100548, -0.030544159933924675, -0.03249606862664223, -0.07619111984968185, 0.0054273949936032295, -0.023922037333250046, -0.014662343077361584, 0.0069650812074542046, 0.008770875632762909, 0.045144397765398026, 0.04269285500049591, -0.05090751498937607, 0.0012983556371182203, -0.00381409446708858, -0.008878592401742935, -0.006925307214260101, -0.032889097929000854, -0.01308018434792757, -0.020619934424757957, 0.026822837069630623, -0.03551528602838516, -0.01909264735877514, -0.014741171151399612, -0.029631566256284714, 0.010396125726401806, 0.024789348244667053, -0.0037431831005960703, -0.05307392030954361, 0.02425643615424633, 0.015797261148691177, 0.033883579075336456, 0.01770113967359066, -0.006523891817778349, -0.04853976517915726, 0.019245702773332596, 0.028924426063895226, -0.008428223431110382, 0.013233393430709839, 0.05791565403342247, 0.03400300070643425, 0.01310661993920803, 0.006486732512712479, 0.012860888615250587, 0.006993201561272144, 0.03218131884932518, -0.061455875635147095, 0.016596609726548195, 0.05739900842308998, -0.012562695890665054, -0.044492051005363464, 0.020112622529268265, 0.0247210580855608, -0.07392255961894989, 0.009937558323144913, 0.03544238954782486, -0.011977105401456356, 0.04149626940488815, -0.0011979748960584402, -0.005997656844556332, -0.002152200322598219, -0.05933234095573425, -0.04689856246113777, 0.01701546460390091, -0.014988556504249573, -0.05074203386902809, 0.005457264371216297, -0.0033823747653514147, -0.03832448646426201, -0.03374633938074112, -0.07888821512460709, 0.030498050153255463, -0.01771221123635769, 0.02202587202191353, -0.02178601548075676, -0.05591600015759468, 0.0029030328150838614, -0.003785952227190137, 0.02753286063671112, -0.014043818227946758, 0.042111724615097046, -0.010801753960549831, 0.012582728639245033, 0.044322237372398376, -0.05789424106478691, 0.008406554348766804, 0.04643086716532707, -0.03476319462060928, -0.002053655683994293, 0.02262096293270588, -0.004377029836177826, -0.008333989419043064, -0.012902209535241127, 0.03925549238920212, -0.030579248443245888, 0.029587730765342712, -0.03624069690704346, 0.020664600655436516, -0.05646450072526932, -0.05558843910694122, 0.057207997888326645, -0.030058525502681732, -0.0041335467249155045, 0.03957817703485489, -0.01888698898255825, 0.006671812850981951, 0.03419700637459755, -0.05299287661910057, 0.02900971844792366, -0.03236992657184601, -0.012054023332893848, 0.05775178596377373, -0.000331085262587294, -0.0285743810236454, -0.041628360748291016, -0.020502356812357903, -0.01601272262632847, 0.04634419083595276, 0.04871154949069023, -0.03911282494664192, 0.017545225098729134, -0.06929543614387512, 0.012914830818772316, 0.012414880096912384, 0.0129504119977355, -0.058883488178253174, 0.079841747879982, 0.02346825785934925, -0.018133632838726044, -0.0498216450214386, -0.0368015393614769, 0.003474635537713766, -0.07683774828910828, -0.03486277535557747, -0.030485019087791443, -0.002430492313578725, -0.011242665350437164, -0.002239550231024623, 0.0027554607950150967, 0.056204311549663544, -0.023482492193579674, 0.03422107174992561, -0.009788758121430874, -0.032895173877477646, -0.017874589189887047, 0.05908868834376335, 0.05475623905658722, 0.010562929324805737, -0.03307130187749863, -0.030890274792909622, -0.03239800035953522, -0.00915885716676712, 0.015728909522294998, -0.012718397192656994, -0.015097206458449364, -0.01729082316160202, 0.021494096145033836, 0.014054310508072376, -0.026732835918664932, -0.030491981655359268, -0.027263227850198746, 0.014375878497958183, -0.0028485923539847136, -0.02527478337287903 ]
Learning-based vehicle planning is receiving increasing attention with the emergence of diverse driving simulators and large-scale driving datasets. While offline reinforcement learning (RL) is well suited for these safety-critical tasks, it still struggles to plan over extended periods. In this work, we present a skill-based framework that enhances offline RL to overcome the long-horizon vehicle planning challenge. Specifically, we design a variational autoencoder (VAE) to learn skills from offline demonstrations. To mitigate posterior collapse of common VAEs, we introduce a two-branch sequence encoder to capture both discrete options and continuous variations of the complex driving skills. The final policy treats learned skills as actions and can be trained by any off-the-shelf offline RL algorithms. This facilitates a shift in focus from per-step actions to temporally extended skills, thereby enabling long-term reasoning into the future. Extensive results on CARLA prove that our model consistently outperforms strong baselines at both training and new scenarios. Additional visualizations and experiments demonstrate the interpretability and transferability of extracted skills.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13614v2
[ -0.00444198539480567, -0.01512298546731472, 0.04515004903078079, 0.03250397369265556, -0.027761617675423622, -0.0032752486877143383, 0.01410757191479206, 0.006598170381039381, 0.008793153800070286, -0.052873216569423676, -0.03906072676181793, 0.0020723494235426188, -0.04950292408466339, -0.03268521651625633, -0.049856316298246384, -0.002025568624958396, 0.06333509087562561, -0.001928970799781382, -0.05724292993545532, 0.019271213561296463, 0.027035478502511978, 0.012910578399896622, -0.04261721298098564, 0.024232175201177597, 0.02468188665807247, -0.032791268080472946, -0.02345220372080803, -0.014989969320595264, -0.027356844395399094, -0.04191671684384346, 0.07803545147180557, -0.012866771779954433, -0.010782538913190365, -0.046250876039266586, -0.0354648120701313, -0.06273284554481506, -0.00663555134087801, 0.009315378032624722, 0.02550181746482849, -0.03110707364976406, 0.02919093891978264, -0.06709076464176178, -0.06416089087724686, 0.02109450288116932, -0.03917235881090164, 0.0062611899338662624, -0.01163900550454855, 0.016883017495274544, -0.08857924491167068, -0.02182076871395111, 0.027545873075723648, 0.013574340380728245, 0.02864055708050728, 0.052819326519966125, -0.025076521560549736, 0.03831566125154495, 0.004946072585880756, 0.014265758916735649, -0.0554332435131073, -0.05480942130088806, 0.012599104084074497, -0.02257498912513256, 0.010784623213112354, 0.0425570085644722, 0.0071422443725168705, 0.05532632768154144, 0.021545425057411194, -0.05644891783595085, -0.04356849566102028, -0.05420306324958801, 0.05428164452314377, -0.06165466085076332, -0.031415726989507675, 0.03441259264945984, -0.05257174372673035, -0.017168471589684486, -0.02906973846256733, -0.056872010231018066, 0.040430329740047455, -0.023266375064849854, -0.011872910894453526, 0.001466434565372765, 0.028065398335456848, 0.02515794336795807, -0.03430179879069328, -0.022747844457626343, 0.05017942935228348, 0.034210171550512314, 0.005550798028707504, -0.007968790829181671, 0.044846177101135254, -0.01851583831012249, -0.06254161149263382, 0.027400273829698563, 0.03331109136343002, -0.006629637908190489, 0.07138785719871521, 0.01881573162972927, 0.006479583214968443, -0.008386769331991673, -0.020774981006979942, 0.009946223348379135, -0.043160997331142426, 0.04870380833745003, 0.07099238783121109, -0.03597300499677658, 0.04254848137497902, -0.004935236647725105, -0.05524307116866112, 0.03928697481751442, 0.01332488376647234, -0.025358516722917557, 0.03217489272356033, -0.04948516935110092, -0.05008390545845032, -0.018062064424157143, 0.04613504931330681, -0.01628923788666725, 0.03971365839242935, 0.005398239940404892, -0.049181580543518066, 0.0455952025949955, 0.038029421120882034, -0.011208773590624332, 0.002539969515055418, 0.003481094026938081, 0.057934537529945374, 0.0005273666465654969, -0.01874598301947117, 0.02166239358484745, -0.0011914849746972322, 0.022022712975740433, -0.0053812600672245026, -0.054015789180994034, 0.03577316179871559, 0.02603033185005188, -0.026535091921687126, -0.03870657831430435, 0.04326602816581726, -0.019061118364334106, -0.061412665992975235, -0.08183909207582474, 0.022016005590558052, -0.047020282596349716, 0.0036997597198933363, 0.0570228211581707, -0.04349051043391228, -0.02799367532134056, -0.0044709001667797565, 0.0407533198595047, 0.03620642423629761, 0.03509039431810379, 0.05325448140501976, 0.008316727355122566, 0.0308414027094841, -0.033160869032144547, 0.06435887515544891, -0.02735411375761032, -0.0637536495923996, -0.01060805656015873, 0.002295796060934663, -0.03608041629195213, 0.007949039340019226, -0.03917977213859558, 0.04069027677178383, -0.013411598280072212, 0.06037610396742821, 0.008449106477200985, -0.0337241105735302, 0.005307454615831375, -0.02738538756966591, 0.03193178027868271, 0.008391267620027065, -0.01287584938108921, -0.07573232054710388, -0.019975753501057625, 0.009697961620986462, -0.05824360251426697, -0.04540248215198517, -0.008712707087397575, 0.02120368555188179, 0.01618781127035618, -0.04668053239583969, -0.012963168323040009, -0.05162827670574188, 0.009699583984911442, -0.07789056748151779, 0.00009835479431785643, 0.014232435263693333, 0.025942975655198097, -0.053803298622369766, -0.040040161460638046, 0.023640478029847145, 0.02343377284705639, -0.05748153105378151, -0.05695556104183197, -0.033823542296886444, -0.04487636685371399, 0.003134277882054448, 0.03541404381394386, -0.09408488869667053, -0.011991221457719803, -0.07178966701030731, -0.02969648316502571, 0.012989107519388199, -0.06870825588703156, -0.0053796954452991486, 0.037955142557621, -0.07057373225688934, 0.011214090511202812, 0.02190786972641945, 0.04209347069263458, 0.04670793190598488, 0.019278941676020622, 0.057554807513952255, 0.023163622245192528, -0.10566890239715576, 0.05827395245432854, -0.002348942682147026, 0.006261012516915798, 0.013427576050162315, 0.01722325012087822, -0.008794326335191727, 0.0025117183104157448, 0.01118986401706934, 0.031430862843990326, 0.03321247920393944, -0.047430504113435745, -0.06427781283855438, -0.04880565404891968, 0.00023725852952338755, -0.06259811669588089, -0.0170015599578619, -0.07948260009288788, -0.011507302522659302, -0.007995721884071827, -0.025188053026795387, 0.04859922081232071, -0.003929840866476297, -0.0201424453407526, -0.04280755668878555, -0.03811005502939224, 0.03710094839334488, -0.015479407273232937, -0.04097917675971985, -0.03994657099246979, -0.02936897985637188, 0.01570078544318676, 0.00555275846272707, -0.042964331805706024, -0.037879884243011475, -0.02554505132138729, 0.01648877188563347, -0.035068392753601074, 0.0193730890750885, 0.03655942156910896, -0.026825889945030212, 0.026606444269418716, -0.04877679422497749, 0.023950325325131416, 0.0042121028527617455, 0.009847336448729038, -0.06978150457143784, 0.032390084117650986, 0.04490429162979126, -0.009893558919429779, -0.0015322952531278133, -0.038641978055238724, 0.025178322568535805, -0.02337113954126835, -0.02032025344669819, 0.006970740854740143, 0.04487811401486397, 0.01084375660866499, -0.0012262463569641113, -0.0227226372808218, 0.018949396908283234, 0.0023957816883921623, -0.01997370831668377, 0.04946063086390495, -0.01514327060431242, 0.032773010432720184, 0.011551464907824993, -0.04437793418765068, -0.015910549089312553, -0.03765726089477539, -0.026880407705903053, -0.04403628036379814, -0.06940613687038422, -0.06059877946972847, -0.05672547593712807, -0.014714516699314117, -0.036552682518959045, -0.015154987573623657, 0.0006362268468365073, -0.03944502770900726, -0.00821926724165678, -0.03326365351676941, 0.03040790557861328, -0.018205983564257622, -0.023663438856601715, -0.05237359181046486, -0.008633219636976719, 0.04489067941904068, -0.04493074491620064, -0.07347741723060608, -0.048062764108181, -0.035954348742961884, 0.005498270504176617, -0.021113628521561623, -0.02731931395828724, 0.04260099679231644, -0.010601448826491833, 0.05354886129498482, 0.01746792159974575, 0.0076851812191307545, -0.008725257590413094, 0.0449829027056694, -0.07666659355163574, -0.04182351753115654, 0.000362532795406878, 0.018338799476623535, -0.002369488123804331, -0.0323619470000267, -0.04025080427527428, 0.008278789930045605, 0.06504349410533905, 0.019773976877331734, -0.005295649170875549, -0.0312604121863842, -0.01782876066863537, 0.012963484972715378, 0.017314720898866653, 0.0007244108710438013, 0.0455574169754982, 0.03382517397403717, -0.04778081551194191, -0.017781775444746017, 0.015914777293801308, -0.019522076472640038, -0.058854877948760986, 0.05801495164632797, -0.04370463266968727, -0.02020428329706192, 0.0468166247010231, -0.09245319664478302, 0.02225686050951481, 0.03434501588344574, 0.05881388857960701, -0.0051005249843001366, 0.02575141005218029, 0.0012892666272819042, 0.04197625070810318, 0.03427211195230484, -0.02161250077188015, 0.03165995329618454, 0.06452002376317978, 0.04380930960178375, -0.028687959536910057, -0.01751437596976757, -0.012207825668156147, -0.08663348853588104, -0.06896210461854935, -0.024321263656020164, 0.05356026440858841, 0.021276582032442093, 0.021600525826215744, -0.06358650326728821, 0.008033119142055511, -0.0033673266880214214, 0.062385160475969315, 0.02306361496448517, -0.03784705325961113, 0.0195451732724905, -0.04527447372674942, 0.0032797304447740316, 0.016535311937332153, 0.021943626925349236, 0.010815775953233242, -0.025249579921364784, -0.0012065083719789982, -0.05475688725709915, 0.026110753417015076, -0.0013327030465006828, -0.015238339081406593, 0.042073216289281845, 0.050916872918605804, -0.000997037161141634, 0.07019408047199249, -0.018401842564344406, -0.022130385041236877, -0.01056655216962099, -0.014279044233262539, -0.025536218658089638, -0.035199057310819626, -0.04850587993860245, 0.016872158274054527, 0.0064086164347827435, -0.023452721536159515, -0.027153555303812027, 0.024030204862356186, 0.03108089789748192, -0.009195726364850998, -0.08135978877544403, 0.026333721354603767, -0.045117396861314774, 0.05940724164247513, -0.028513526543974876, -0.021088387817144394, 0.08188186585903168, -0.019355565309524536, -0.0020689796656370163, -0.040205515921115875, -0.024322591722011566, -0.03959709033370018, -0.02021341398358345, -0.0026383858639746904, -0.07607665657997131, 0.03682621195912361, -0.04007836431264877, 0.042778197675943375, -0.023963825777173042, 0.04659426584839821, -0.04152063652873039, -0.039576150476932526, 0.00010898846812779084, 0.06325061619281769, 0.060944221913814545, 0.05993495136499405, -0.03839004039764404, 0.012526881881058216, 0.021540343761444092, 0.022780347615480423, 0.046524301171302795, -0.05193273723125458, -0.02159513160586357, 0.035590171813964844, -0.04467439278960228, -0.02038794569671154, -0.0071455342695117, 0.019031761214137077, 0.059651341289281845, -0.044410549104213715, -0.03357766568660736, -0.007229371462017298, 0.03577396646142006, -0.05466452240943909, -0.04967356100678444, -0.024579685181379318, -0.05676945298910141, -0.011968162842094898, 0.007769499905407429, 0.04102743789553642, 0.02271171286702156, -0.007659191731363535, 0.017445888370275497, 0.0283553134649992, 0.019926588982343674, 0.004489806480705738, 0.036799319088459015, 0.014351201243698597, -0.009510798379778862, 0.015405426733195782, -0.013734393753111362, -0.09099333733320236, 0.02833721973001957, -0.022176356986165047, -0.026690339669585228, -0.05653780326247215, 0.03140369802713394, 0.011546304449439049, 0.05115456506609917, -0.0895862802863121, 0.008438922464847565, 0.045713093131780624, -0.021146833896636963, 0.015586058609187603, 0.06413561850786209, -0.013305478729307652, 0.0602351650595665, -0.029996424913406372, 0.019928621128201485, 0.04126657173037529, -0.04771793261170387, -0.0017265935894101858, -0.026790376752614975, -0.04005678370594978, 0.013217276893556118, 0.060521144419908524, -0.00452862773090601, -0.028942005708813667, -0.0054850331507623196, 0.021302470937371254, 0.025959474965929985, -0.009079590439796448, 0.040410030633211136, 0.03788536414504051, -0.019780395552515984, -0.011159960180521011, -0.0008852962637320161, 0.01427993830293417, -0.018168440088629723, 0.036704737693071365, -0.02481825463473797, -0.003800012404099107, 0.04789358004927635, -0.006823043804615736, -0.03428058698773384, -0.01601109839975834, 0.0385928601026535, 0.00004049488779855892, -0.042484547942876816, 0.015338548459112644, -0.032516736537218094, -0.028492648154497147, -0.04046233743429184, 0.003406306728720665, 0.012394837103784084, 0.033329885452985764, 0.021191632375121117, 0.0135957645252347, -0.05514056980609894, -0.03582170605659485, 0.009602830745279789, 0.014071889221668243, 0.03300575166940689, -0.06091564521193504, 0.025526564568281174, -0.012386386282742023, 0.013120610266923904, -0.020638149231672287, 0.03821839019656181, 0.03510773181915283, -0.03471682593226433, -0.02880215086042881, -0.00941185001283884, 0.03783144801855087, -0.0413859486579895, -0.04471259191632271, 0.008576585911214352, 0.018542340025305748, 0.0049506425857543945, 0.02479199320077896, -0.009513529017567635, -0.01603008806705475, 0.0010399518068879843, 0.012279480695724487, 0.006004167255014181, 0.014648061245679855, 0.014287857338786125, 0.07886554300785065, -0.05535028502345085, 0.0019788017962127924, -0.01252487488090992, -0.03980591520667076, -0.0029241759330034256, -0.01297083217650652, -0.025954024866223335, -0.01685134693980217, -0.009493936784565449, -0.05488021671772003, 0.06353487074375153, -0.005905719008296728, -0.07498785108327866, 0.02514178678393364, 0.007329869084060192, -0.06349256634712219, -0.010528778657317162, 0.03744666278362274, 0.016091028228402138, -0.07211444526910782, 0.052286721765995026, 0.04173630103468895, -0.021014748141169548, -0.040257394313812256, 0.07135387510061264, 0.07964681088924408, -0.028296394273638725, -0.009418672882020473, 0.021349376067519188, -0.06106264516711235, 0.058560509234666824, -0.029621809720993042, -0.0011063219280913472, 0.00757067883387208, 0.0290120430290699, 0.02010248228907585, -0.05608198419213295, -0.02013637311756611, 0.06339568644762039, -0.05636504665017128, -0.02975744940340519, 0.028854548931121826, -0.03470630198717117, 0.05271631106734276, -0.012535542249679565, -0.04015741124749184, -0.0003873265814036131, -0.029457032680511475, 0.0160167645663023, -0.029440555721521378, -0.03017674759030342, 0.011126927100121975, -0.015039720572531223, 0.01690087653696537, -0.06548121571540833, 0.012903989292681217, -0.036982934921979904, -0.0755813792347908, 0.04269843548536301, -0.05493989586830139, 0.0016806276980787516, 0.013775311410427094, 0.008617027662694454, 0.0034633248578757048, 0.053998470306396484, -0.05497174710035324, 0.0046556186862289906, -0.0005414261249825358, -0.0027973882388323545, 0.016985546797513962, 0.029668454080820084, 0.002826568204909563, 0.01100146770477295, 0.054582737386226654, -0.0387687049806118, -0.021387794986367226, -0.027619104832410812, -0.03959649056196213, -0.0012010502396151423, 0.0034439596347510815, -0.04065101221203804, -0.04814410209655762, 0.0030604361090809107, -0.030822250992059708, 0.024218719452619553, 0.0235939621925354, -0.04619786888360977, -0.08129826933145523, -0.0217865239828825, 0.006370305549353361, -0.0060508339665830135, -0.015272513963282108, 0.008700752630829811, 0.021207638084888458, 0.009789294563233852, 0.031582508236169815, 0.0348084531724453, -0.03337443619966507, 0.026938026770949364, -0.05290326103568077, -0.03319302573800087, 0.015408063307404518, -0.014323103241622448, -0.04023073986172676, 0.0046776351518929005, -0.01557387225329876, -0.05770837143063545, 0.008882865309715271, 0.04238820821046829, 0.033513858914375305, -0.007976391352713108, -0.08043894916772842, 0.024196457117795944, -0.029221367090940475, -0.03296080231666565, -0.0330711230635643, 0.014218362048268318, 0.017673326656222343, -0.011077141389250755, -0.01615183800458908, 0.002580886473879218, -0.049975816160440445, -0.016603879630565643, -0.07734314352273941, -0.0012838400434702635, 0.002670510672032833, 0.017927046865224838, -0.018956225365400314, 0.0003696155908983201, 0.0257929228246212, -0.0374767892062664, 0.038405705243349075, 0.011041799560189247, 0.005957169458270073, 0.01461083721369505, 0.06078530475497246, -0.007607109844684601, -0.053452085703611374, -0.02663384936749935, 0.0430862233042717, 0.00012331039761193097, -0.05257502570748329, 0.03337070345878601, 0.005882641300559044, 0.03311159834265709, 0.0002045032597379759, 0.0586492195725441, -0.022050414234399796, 0.05093371868133545, -0.044285986572504044, 0.02918381430208683, -0.04981395974755287, -0.032545413821935654, -0.007116056978702545, -0.037368543446063995, 0.014461632817983627, 0.028077382594347, -0.037526972591876984, -0.00246435240842402, -0.019379042088985443, -0.024405159056186676, 0.01961163803935051, -0.032262396067380905, -0.015929339453577995, 0.03805644437670708, -0.0340862013399601, -0.0048893895000219345, 0.011637117713689804, -0.01584429107606411, -0.0245077945291996, 0.0510149784386158, 0.05369593948125839, -0.010856226086616516, -0.020514214411377907, -0.054598238319158554, 0.0036908246111124754, -0.027800515294075012, 0.01746346987783909, -0.04191742092370987, 0.06922945380210876, 0.04723813384771347, -0.05845427140593529, -0.014711394906044006, -0.018496397882699966, -0.057459644973278046, -0.06171886995434761, 0.0008312140125781298, -0.04925394058227539, 0.018806707113981247, -0.030391737818717957, 0.009868075139820576, 0.019902484491467476, 0.010786827653646469, 0.01760474219918251, -0.020812345668673515, -0.032019343227148056, 0.019886508584022522, -0.04914451017975807, 0.06552134454250336, 0.004279044456779957, 0.034677062183618546, -0.031209899112582207, 0.02432294376194477, 0.021593935787677765, 0.008576014079153538, -0.01247935090214014, 0.013214507140219212, 0.007285254076123238, -0.06038149818778038, -0.015844490379095078, -0.003032595617696643, -0.007309757638722658, -0.05088873580098152, -0.041320063173770905, 0.018309425562620163, -0.03674040362238884, -0.04762415960431099 ]
We study entanglement transitions in a periodically driven Ising chain in the presence of an imaginary transverse field $\gamma$ as a function of drive frequency $\omega_D$. In the high drive amplitude and frequency regime, we find a critical value $\gamma=\gamma_c$ below which the steady state half-chain entanglement entropy, $S_{L/2}$, scales with chain length $L$ as $S_{L/2} \sim \ln L$; in contrast, for $\gamma>\gamma_c$, it becomes independent of $L$. In the small $\gamma$ limit, we compute the coefficient, $\alpha$, of the $\ln L$ term analytically using a Floquet perturbation theory and trace its origin to the presence of Fisher-Hartwig jump singularities in the correlation function of the driven chain. We also study the frequency dependence of $\gamma_c$ and show that $\gamma_c \to 0$ at special drive frequencies; at these frequencies, which we analytically compute, $S_{L/2}$ remain independent of $L$ for all $\gamma$. This behavior can be traced to an approximate emergent symmetry of the Floquet Hamiltonian at these drive frequencies which we identify. Finally, we discus the behavior of the driven system at low and intermediate drive frequencies. Our analysis shows the presence of volume law behavior of the entanglement in this regime $S_{\ell} \sim \ell$ for small subsystem length $\ell \le \ell^{\ast}(\omega_D)$. We identify $\ell^{\ast}(\omega_D)$ and tie its existence to the effective long-range nature of the Floquet Hamiltonian of the driven chain for small subsystem size. We discuss the applicability of our results to other integrable non-hermitian models.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07661v2
[ -0.04785170033574104, -0.056651439517736435, 0.04843611642718315, -0.021648721769452095, 0.04471062123775482, 0.01372290775179863, -0.0570668987929821, -0.008598140440881252, -0.036534760147333145, -0.017669809982180595, -0.03798464685678482, -0.0682617798447609, -0.057257067412137985, -0.032944194972515106, -0.04913453012704849, 0.019077561795711517, 0.04242035374045372, 0.03090773895382881, -0.011656028218567371, 0.05575481057167053, -0.016042174771428108, -0.018446046859025955, -0.015747569501399994, 0.04716430976986885, -0.006410850677639246, -0.06529010832309723, 0.002711888635531068, -0.003844611346721649, -0.05200877785682678, -0.03425333648920059, 0.06222064793109894, -0.01966819353401661, 0.006473463494330645, -0.015224196016788483, -0.01842350885272026, 0.039951153099536896, -0.030972423031926155, 0.05025041103363037, 0.04987691342830658, -0.04229778051376343, -0.040753163397312164, -0.042464032769203186, -0.015820875763893127, -0.0278947651386261, -0.05461961776018143, -0.00942399725317955, -0.0053089698776602745, 0.026509063318371773, -0.013490242883563042, -0.029071839526295662, -0.0037445812486112118, 0.009320763871073723, 0.01555749960243702, 0.06471221148967743, -0.011989033780992031, -0.011458654887974262, 0.013864697888493538, -0.01332753524184227, -0.04333193227648735, -0.05588832125067711, 0.0053482563234865665, -0.05398168787360191, 0.023539388552308083, -0.03061169758439064, -0.019818535074591637, 0.032539330422878265, -0.027366962283849716, -0.06441012769937515, -0.01921720802783966, -0.06249430775642395, -0.019962333142757416, -0.025418445467948914, -0.0057234386913478374, -0.01876085065305233, -0.07115396112203598, -0.0064887977205216885, 0.003797290613874793, 0.011673604138195515, -0.0328451432287693, -0.030040018260478973, 0.008737128227949142, -0.016999833285808563, -0.010736273601651192, 0.038530778139829636, 0.017121529206633568, -0.0128458421677351, 0.07213639467954636, -0.037636034190654755, -0.03764946386218071, -0.06400839984416962, -0.055120065808296204, -0.04948732256889343, -0.06210236996412277, -0.04513940587639809, 0.005786725785583258, -0.019969606772065163, 0.07270262390375137, 0.0301381666213274, 0.05685397610068321, -0.0007999095250852406, 0.0013727586483582854, -0.03762891888618469, -0.008505214937031269, 0.025804145261645317, 0.04905511438846588, -0.05143863707780838, -0.0030532015953212976, -0.012040014378726482, -0.05085529014468193, 0.06546685844659805, -0.013293355703353882, -0.02987377718091011, -0.006546376273036003, -0.06072991341352463, -0.06990551203489304, -0.04173407703638077, 0.060727961361408234, 0.016569834202528, 0.054860010743141174, 0.01979984901845455, -0.0071546235121786594, 0.03604152053594589, 0.003841192927211523, 0.014360629953444004, -0.017048954963684082, 0.01728261075913906, 0.04993981868028641, 0.028490973636507988, 0.0007765960181131959, -0.0005953088984824717, 0.02305961772799492, -0.02241395227611065, 0.04951459541916847, -0.050612032413482666, -0.0008923542918637395, 0.014379182830452919, 0.0336066298186779, -0.009458630345761776, -0.029916612431406975, 0.026146316900849342, -0.026378963142633438, -0.021380767226219177, 0.041299622505903244, 0.043902862817049026, 0.05032757669687271, 0.04234879091382027, -0.07415004819631577, 0.02100721001625061, 0.051725972443819046, 0.03874194622039795, -0.02099711447954178, 0.04005558043718338, 0.017358792945742607, -0.04855221509933472, 0.009820866398513317, 0.020992396399378777, 0.05842301622033119, -0.0314674936234951, -0.013775226660072803, 0.02974458783864975, 0.021696489304304123, -0.04296581447124481, -0.0006550302496179938, 0.01991521567106247, 0.051631417125463486, 0.03923628479242325, 0.023580344393849373, -0.0034594256430864334, -0.013085572980344296, 0.01823914796113968, -0.01008340623229742, -0.00581955024972558, 0.04037519544363022, -0.058025117963552475, -0.05846670642495155, -0.06320080161094666, -0.017271695658564568, -0.06519845128059387, -0.0456368587911129, -0.018151720985770226, 0.04282363876700401, 0.03892618790268898, -0.04020870476961136, -0.01554271299391985, -0.07237803936004639, 0.027339952066540718, -0.07082279771566391, 0.025718891993165016, 0.03426561504602432, 0.007743342779576778, -0.03996805101633072, -0.05323606729507446, 0.004646230023354292, -0.03824014589190483, 0.012611979618668556, 0.001114540034905076, 0.001040787436068058, -0.05578538775444031, -0.009975519962608814, 0.03186842426657677, -0.03963037580251694, -0.032987453043460846, -0.046217478811740875, 0.022457625716924667, -0.01877051778137684, -0.05583932623267174, 0.03776686638593674, 0.01173486653715372, -0.03006020374596119, -0.01863437332212925, 0.05872027948498726, 0.022872084751725197, 0.027055099606513977, -0.0260633397847414, -0.037242043763399124, -0.0344744548201561, -0.08145161718130112, 0.051538627594709396, 0.007879373617470264, -0.02573332004249096, -0.012324589304625988, -0.021286649629473686, -0.03972150757908821, -0.028211725875735283, -0.035420965403318405, 0.0308627150952816, 0.036985307931900024, 0.006162237375974655, -0.037357449531555176, 0.03199458122253418, 0.0049362038262188435, -0.07510672509670258, -0.02693268470466137, -0.06646791100502014, -0.025789758190512657, 0.012387496419250965, -0.0024537465069442987, 0.04013296961784363, -0.02187090553343296, 0.0013091879663988948, -0.06942799687385559, -0.03131610155105591, 0.05232447385787964, -0.008348194882273674, -0.05805525183677673, -0.0290768351405859, -0.0522601492702961, -0.008443696424365044, -0.0029669664800167084, 0.0004036044701933861, -0.0067140404134988785, -0.040167562663555145, -0.06877512484788895, -0.048401691019535065, 0.002637257566675544, 0.05747371166944504, -0.01515214890241623, 0.04270816221833229, -0.016796892508864403, 0.04132848605513573, -0.0027936927508562803, 0.00011503250425448641, -0.045106325298547745, -0.0008338302723132074, -0.04130177944898605, -0.006436213385313749, -0.06311389803886414, 0.020862054079771042, -0.019733143970370293, -0.013195918872952461, -0.010337920859456062, -0.0005575979594141245, 0.02554289810359478, -0.03943843021988869, -0.01718234457075596, -0.031791988760232925, -0.04372859746217728, -0.006536422297358513, 0.016792459413409233, -0.0052695670165121555, 0.017705591395497322, 0.038321562111377716, 0.019914645701646805, -0.047608062624931335, 0.009599113836884499, -0.008992694318294525, -0.019999735057353973, -0.06931862235069275, -0.06422094255685806, -0.010786120779812336, -0.06153285130858421, 0.05359616130590439, -0.016351906582713127, -0.04433850198984146, -0.0659501850605011, -0.06726402789354324, 0.003924041520804167, 0.002739231800660491, 0.014131804928183556, -0.07001349329948425, -0.06357520073652267, -0.03016972914338112, 0.039771486073732376, 0.015578804537653923, -0.031058605760335922, -0.0039835404604673386, -0.032781071960926056, -0.03920663148164749, 0.012731626629829407, -0.035678714513778687, -0.05301375314593315, -0.022507673129439354, -0.026646271347999573, -0.022820021957159042, -0.029829449951648712, 0.030664844438433647, 0.044285114854574203, -0.04126022383570671, -0.03811628744006157, -0.016469212248921394, 0.0335882194340229, -0.022287404164671898, 0.04974394291639328, -0.01830299198627472, -0.05164960026741028, -0.026516778394579887, 0.05840189382433891, 0.031577300280332565, 0.02588602527976036, -0.05707365646958351, -0.04887020215392113, -0.030995119363069534, -0.006028574425727129, -0.012810752727091312, 0.05067010596394539, 0.01583150587975979, -0.0013793088728561997, -0.0021585547365248203, -0.04891911894083023, -0.0034995137248188257, -0.049437105655670166, 0.004523089621216059, 0.02733546495437622, -0.0046007451601326466, -0.0431654118001461, -0.030949732288718224, 0.022101864218711853, 0.06456118822097778, 0.04381703585386276, -0.05200662836432457, 0.0024430870544165373, 0.04251319169998169, 0.0032292986288666725, 0.05322001874446869, -0.02411315217614174, 0.03425591066479683, 0.047952260822057724, 0.025768931955099106, 0.0037802348379045725, -0.03362557664513588, -0.007249819114804268, -0.06954300403594971, -0.022461192682385445, -0.010450591333210468, -0.02467448078095913, 0.0070164985954761505, 0.0006619289051741362, 0.012062881141901016, 0.021442605182528496, -0.054534442722797394, 0.05877562239766121, -0.018448464572429657, -0.05170623958110809, -0.011908157728612423, -0.018885396420955658, -0.003442470682784915, 0.04517944157123566, 0.009812938049435616, -0.004645007196813822, -0.05650130286812782, 0.0030350752640515566, -0.06276454031467438, 0.020214548334479332, 0.005468994379043579, 0.023626994341611862, 0.022017836570739746, -0.01154685951769352, -0.015279421582818031, 0.03129881992936134, -0.03971011936664581, -0.005857356358319521, -0.025335345417261124, -0.04218591749668121, 0.00922058429569006, 0.010036652907729149, -0.02724646031856537, 0.01709843799471855, 0.003551385598257184, -0.04961051419377327, -0.013925987295806408, 0.04848916828632355, -0.03641842305660248, -0.05315010994672775, -0.07563204318284988, -0.00832242239266634, -0.06254588812589645, 0.006407055538147688, 0.002391811227425933, -0.054240938276052475, 0.06089581176638603, 0.0070820702239871025, -0.03656463325023651, -0.014318248257040977, -0.028202224522829056, 0.011594352312386036, -0.04441413655877113, -0.03876694291830063, -0.000934723939280957, 0.055147457867860794, -0.0605853907763958, 0.037062786519527435, -0.019901767373085022, -0.037938907742500305, -0.05577933415770531, -0.0067079197615385056, 0.004740931559354067, 0.025995230302214622, 0.026199130341410637, 0.054589446634054184, -0.018048515543341637, 0.023964308202266693, -0.06724531203508377, -0.008742040023207664, -0.021874889731407166, -0.01535305567085743, -0.03521318733692169, 0.0325765423476696, -0.05724083632230759, -0.03141076862812042, -0.024671265855431557, 0.0049562412314116955, 0.04000197723507881, -0.01871112734079361, -0.033844467252492905, -0.02152104675769806, 0.027211612090468407, -0.07100129127502441, -0.033293917775154114, -0.028255362063646317, -0.04112761840224266, -0.04159170389175415, 0.04037562385201454, 0.025227140635252, -0.02091345191001892, 0.0015084578189998865, 0.05604346841573715, 0.013786238618195057, 0.04992273449897766, -0.06844019144773483, 0.022474119439721107, -0.028550580143928528, 0.03536011278629303, -0.005853685550391674, 0.00005582857193076052, -0.07351817190647125, 0.028374040499329567, 0.007758314721286297, -0.05112440884113312, -0.022420333698391914, 0.05578497052192688, -0.00979652814567089, 0.02933027409017086, -0.07755515724420547, 0.02158583514392376, 0.061069056391716, -0.0009552244446240366, 0.008451012894511223, 0.01870676688849926, -0.051329076290130615, 0.027608098462224007, -0.05066763609647751, 0.00751370657235384, 0.010718085803091526, 0.03101371042430401, -0.04062807187438011, 0.016559850424528122, -0.04236767068505287, -0.019743537530303, 0.0036635997239500284, -0.02303733490407467, -0.041444581001996994, -0.0009649436105974019, -0.03731020167469978, 0.011472870595753193, -0.06224655359983444, 0.04276531562209129, 0.01950397714972496, -0.038533199578523636, -0.06725570559501648, 0.006919762585312128, 0.037078049033880234, 0.05135377123951912, 0.06947369128465652, -0.024309387430548668, 0.0031897583976387978, 0.000019560065993573517, -0.04092209413647652, 0.04721665009856224, 0.055260833352804184, 0.03077283501625061, -0.019506964832544327, -0.008429951034486294, -0.039130304008722305, -0.06009439006447792, -0.022108111530542374, -0.03339884430170059, -0.014555919915437698, 0.01919436641037464, -0.015794014558196068, 0.029151882976293564, -0.0011085480218753219, 0.033318836241960526, -0.06319136172533035, -0.045953892171382904, -0.040839940309524536, 0.05336424708366394, -0.05620857700705528, -0.01993132382631302, 0.0007207330199889839, 0.06145746633410454, 0.0038051737938076258, -0.008789605461061, -0.015725480392575264, -0.026944579556584358, -0.018890826031565666, 0.019749874249100685, 0.03982715681195259, -0.006445928011089563, -0.028236551210284233, -0.01187222357839346, 0.0340283177793026, -0.036095838993787766, 0.0529232956469059, -0.03940252959728241, 0.03806702792644501, -0.0023899266961961985, 0.02123143896460533, 0.02160729095339775, -0.054141249507665634, 0.043040722608566284, 0.07659883052110672, -0.057162780314683914, 0.022991729900240898, -0.04000220075249672, -0.03672844171524048, -0.02332978881895542, -0.05080244317650795, -0.03053383156657219, 0.037903714925050735, -0.03074650838971138, -0.05386608839035034, 0.048397503793239594, -0.00964435376226902, -0.041982900351285934, -0.03831581771373749, 0.035980165004730225, -0.05720963329076767, 0.01834685169160366, 0.0018891029758378863, -0.029730884358286858, -0.051834847778081894, -0.006504721939563751, -0.048906587064266205, -0.028774075210094452, -0.013133693486452103, 0.028986068442463875, 0.024226482957601547, -0.060471463948488235, 0.005772484466433525, 0.026612110435962677, 0.027982410043478012, 0.02322026528418064, -0.06397855281829834, -0.0036341757513582706, -0.01593933440744877, 0.03924557939171791, 0.03164498507976532, -0.03204392269253731, 0.01715219020843506, 0.035860463976860046, -0.04277493804693222, -0.0006855614483356476, 0.01751267910003662, 0.035905010998249054, 0.016422493383288383, -0.001559765194542706, -0.025016527622938156, -0.0017583791632205248, -0.03285820409655571, -0.0020619782153517008, -0.02268035337328911, 0.04023371636867523, -0.008516405709087849, 0.011379376985132694, 0.02173338271677494, -0.02098432369530201, 0.023369023576378822, -0.018035080283880234, -0.051041364669799805, -0.004285532981157303, -0.059238776564598083, -0.018277056515216827, -0.004709492437541485, 0.011084269732236862, -0.008246124722063541, 0.01792547106742859, -0.057575732469558716, 0.004933868069201708, 0.009807931259274483, -0.018868623301386833, 0.03135177493095398, 0.02420385554432869, -0.0009033567039296031, -0.03000081516802311, 0.05328216031193733, -0.03349710628390312, -0.031845822930336, -0.015908729285001755, -0.0680060014128685, 0.04554548114538193, 0.0076620024628937244, -0.05842575803399086, -0.029020652174949646, -0.008862301707267761, -0.07276815921068192, 0.037315450608730316, -0.0016880555776879191, -0.03929237276315689, -0.03254071995615959, -0.00537808146327734, 0.028408709913492203, 0.034130651503801346, 0.040414176881313324, -0.011005495674908161, 0.014613105915486813, 0.05285346508026123, 0.013622653670608997, 0.04427742585539818, -0.01389532070606947, 0.007948646321892738, -0.046336427330970764, -0.04091709107160568, -0.012649156153202057, -0.029560303315520287, 0.00748213566839695, -0.01005546748638153, -0.03346063941717148, -0.05026193708181381, 0.0002668872766662389, -0.009417440742254257, 0.02006394788622856, -0.05379178002476692, -0.035544101148843765, 0.04920661076903343, -0.024121833965182304, 0.034353286027908325, -0.07820334285497665, -0.036465443670749664, 0.03259599953889847, -0.008029822260141373, -0.034147076308727264, 0.006777487229555845, -0.06509453803300858, 0.0010738578857854009, -0.07227721810340881, -0.05527002736926079, -0.04177507013082504, 0.036331623792648315, 0.04203813150525093, -0.023756494745612144, -0.030576711520552635, -0.04948112368583679, 0.022910889238119125, 0.04276703670620918, 0.00489691412076354, 0.0347454771399498, 0.03659741207957268, -0.036902472376823425, 0.018737386912107468, -0.024437226355075836, 0.05814171954989433, -0.02256779372692108, -0.04610457271337509, 0.05045245587825775, 0.03920580446720123, -0.03917638957500458, -0.04046362638473511, 0.018157418817281723, 0.0050787595100700855, 0.045964449644088745, -0.033696696162223816, -0.04920969158411026, -0.04635518416762352, -0.05610789358615875, 0.00035679980646818876, -0.06954411417245865, -0.02620735578238964, -0.027559371665120125, -0.05128197371959686, -0.01816564053297043, -0.05540016293525696, -0.04582517221570015, 0.002567586023360491, 0.02262851968407631, -0.027796931564807892, 0.03637859597802162, -0.04242207109928131, 0.01933634839951992, 0.02611914649605751, -0.008322848938405514, -0.047756943851709366, 0.0028489609248936176, 0.05338648706674576, -0.03691169247031212, 0.02725788578391075, -0.06753560900688171, 0.0625694990158081, -0.02168140932917595, 0.011005227454006672, 0.04728301241993904, 0.03637702763080597, -0.03565782681107521, 0.002679786179214716, -0.018957117572426796, -0.009857845492661, -0.01567082852125168, -0.06750641763210297, 0.020444821566343307, -0.015044637955725193, -0.021178843453526497, 0.0005068499012850225, 0.02561906911432743, -0.06077207624912262, 0.042054902762174606, 0.04960506036877632, 0.03891229256987572, 0.00137672561686486, -0.01915493793785572, -0.058681052178144455, 0.02185765467584133, -0.013923616148531437, -0.03908322751522064, -0.05687009170651436, 0.010074172168970108, -0.008558494970202446, 0.012439774349331856, -0.05054335296154022, 0.010738224722445011, 0.004548767581582069, -0.06580724567174911, -0.04865093529224396, 0.028708327561616898, -0.01923091895878315, -0.05550195649266243, 0.020742105320096016, -0.008716689422726631, -0.005695207975804806, 0.005997402593493462 ]
We report the first observation of ferroelectric gating in AlScN barrier wide-bandgap nitride transistors. These FerroHEMT devices realized by direct epitaxial growth represent a new class of ferroelectric transistors in which the semiconductor is itself polar, and the crystalline ferroelectric barrier is lattice-matched to the substrate. The FerroHEMTs reported here use the thinnest nitride high K and ferroelectric barriers to date to deliver the highest on currents at 4 A/mm, and highest speed AlScN transistors with fmax larger than 150 GHz observed in any ferroelectric transistor. The FerroHEMTs exhibit hysteretic Id Vgs loops with subthreshold slopes below the Boltzmann limit. A control AlN barrier HEMT exhibits neither hysteretic, nor sub Boltzmann behavior. While these results introduce the first epitaxial high K and ferroelectric barrier technology to RF and mm wave electronics, they are also of interest as a new material platform for combining memory and logic functionalities in digital electronics.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14209v1
[ 0.027803892269730568, -0.027690161019563675, 0.03943653404712677, -0.003210598137229681, -0.02343743108212948, -0.025017155334353447, -0.016185401007533073, -0.011057902127504349, -0.02541900984942913, -0.007317150477319956, 0.009309031069278717, -0.025655770674347878, -0.07081758975982666, -0.05116219073534012, -0.0711950957775116, 0.029689012095332146, 0.0774819403886795, 0.038464248180389404, -0.0032494168262928724, 0.04281063377857208, -0.002428059931844473, -0.017343150451779366, 0.008542652241885662, 0.05161365866661072, 0.03930444270372391, -0.024585073813796043, -0.05134255811572075, 0.03985045850276947, -0.009663430973887444, -0.009324079379439354, 0.07782412320375443, -0.0357399582862854, 0.007291827816516161, 0.028181947767734528, -0.006605315487831831, 0.007453037891536951, -0.013360824435949326, 0.034786857664585114, 0.0421779602766037, -0.05462585762143135, 0.021573873236775398, -0.02000429853796959, -0.03188523277640343, -0.04059356451034546, -0.0015196709427982569, -0.020593147724866867, -0.0684884786605835, 0.019426096230745316, -0.04752035811543465, -0.0409420020878315, 0.013376902788877487, -0.007679408881813288, -0.015462351962924004, 0.04323224350810051, 0.0015524874906986952, -0.054400037974119186, -0.028422439470887184, 0.000237572705373168, -0.006712108850479126, 0.02808137610554695, -0.05956096574664116, -0.031567011028528214, -0.009173090569674969, -0.018296532332897186, -0.0676988884806633, 0.029985245317220688, -0.03044370748102665, -0.05233292281627655, -0.054865334182977676, -0.06451212614774704, 0.022781355306506157, -0.05487734079360962, -0.016995519399642944, 0.005280719604343176, -0.054108183830976486, -0.011648895218968391, -0.03634870424866676, 0.0029481255915015936, -0.012712450698018074, -0.032727811485528946, -0.028218146413564682, 0.04082828760147095, 0.030642205849289894, 0.013099024072289467, -0.02791888639330864, 0.017034480348229408, 0.055017054080963135, -0.023011134937405586, -0.029746994376182556, -0.04371827468276024, 0.05311978980898857, -0.017182277515530586, -0.08321262151002884, 0.046100176870822906, 0.06245746091008186, -0.03368183970451355, 0.04870079457759857, 0.012857208959758282, 0.03713240101933479, -0.012187435291707516, -0.014406009577214718, -0.00728977145627141, -0.016857927665114403, 0.0189504437148571, -0.052283987402915955, -0.009282678365707397, 0.013848157599568367, -0.07407549023628235, -0.020803822204470634, 0.014314120635390282, -0.00931995827704668, -0.01608469896018505, 0.05582220107316971, -0.005925090052187443, -0.02924156002700329, -0.026401972398161888, 0.04824639856815338, 0.022398237138986588, -0.004062806721776724, 0.026202697306871414, -0.02360924333333969, 0.028513602912425995, 0.04376201331615448, -0.0035228263586759567, -0.03199116885662079, 0.025857815518975258, 0.0708073303103447, -0.002687812549993396, -0.03484645113348961, -0.023882722482085228, -0.008911259472370148, 0.07315301150083542, 0.04394704848527908, -0.05224214866757393, 0.02813410758972168, -0.02931741438806057, 0.017861779779195786, 0.03194710984826088, -0.008387521840631962, 0.04481711611151695, 0.0014488238375633955, 0.02479148842394352, 0.0438971072435379, 0.02732679434120655, 0.0043494743295013905, 0.06275206804275513, -0.07429498434066772, -0.006182956974953413, 0.06582041829824448, 0.008361783809959888, 0.008874034509062767, 0.013724248856306076, -0.0088781313970685, -0.022860895842313766, 0.008085773326456547, -0.009453734382987022, 0.039395153522491455, 0.015456529334187508, -0.02179131656885147, 0.03054247982800007, 0.020083729177713394, -0.03171867877244949, 0.0034950096160173416, 0.005483408458530903, 0.026183748617768288, -0.02670884132385254, 0.015141005627810955, -0.002676150295883417, 0.017138004302978516, 0.06974372267723083, -0.04852350056171417, -0.014508421532809734, -0.02341626212000847, 0.013406678102910519, -0.0708438828587532, -0.0041139572858810425, -0.018857760354876518, -0.04697474464774132, -0.062256500124931335, -0.03840092569589615, 0.05112666264176369, 0.006377272307872772, -0.014573687687516212, 0.027615386992692947, -0.05853472277522087, -0.015280385501682758, -0.09170541167259216, -0.010368541814386845, 0.04134916514158249, -0.04786798357963562, -0.03433670848608017, 0.0014817740302532911, -0.016689345240592957, -0.013897182419896126, 0.019592836499214172, -0.003360732924193144, -0.014986550435423851, -0.06365780532360077, -0.05808267742395401, 0.00871244166046381, -0.07106913626194, -0.041612785309553146, -0.030518781393766403, -0.030798105522990227, 0.04389877989888191, -0.07848334312438965, 0.020311979576945305, -0.006516282446682453, -0.04813932627439499, 0.012800060212612152, 0.03332202136516571, 0.03894577547907829, 0.058702681213617325, 0.03907814994454384, 0.03817056119441986, -0.05544513091444969, -0.10115450620651245, 0.040987081825733185, 0.007856790907680988, 0.009549633599817753, 0.010395602323114872, 0.007368604652583599, 0.035580433905124664, 0.030992934480309486, -0.027692126110196114, 0.035992901772260666, 0.049932755529880524, -0.010696710087358952, -0.05609039589762688, 0.04853658005595207, 0.006465222220867872, -0.07072582095861435, -0.07521975040435791, -0.061102382838726044, -0.023899922147393227, 0.019518228247761726, -0.059035465121269226, -0.019151141867041588, -0.014283199794590473, -0.058020759373903275, -0.0012509244261309505, -0.024982113391160965, 0.04578892141580582, 0.036720823496580124, -0.0871543139219284, -0.00845720898360014, -0.0850180983543396, 0.019016269594430923, -0.03826574608683586, -0.036211930215358734, -0.007613489869982004, -0.04186803475022316, -0.03382103517651558, -0.041664689779281616, -0.03560258075594902, 0.046651434153318405, -0.032248590141534805, 0.002916523953899741, -0.026522496715188026, 0.02583972178399563, -0.0038593714125454426, 0.02102483995258808, -0.024478929117321968, 0.038634300231933594, 0.01950320228934288, -0.013117709197103977, -0.05508419871330261, -0.00044998174416832626, 0.015289600938558578, -0.012925486080348492, -0.04500975087285042, 0.04260244965553284, -0.008132105693221092, -0.008837714791297913, -0.020032187923789024, -0.028507297858595848, -0.0361211895942688, -0.03051983378827572, -0.01042372640222311, 0.04243290424346924, 0.049588240683078766, 0.011306975968182087, 0.004407869186252356, -0.05111763998866081, -0.017300546169281006, -0.023997275158762932, 0.006859329994767904, -0.04946156218647957, -0.02173384465277195, -0.033449407666921616, -0.05772394314408302, 0.0092137660831213, -0.041058409959077835, -0.008916672319173813, 0.004431804176419973, -0.030431855469942093, 0.007087280508130789, -0.029531259089708328, 0.021563513204455376, -0.056968361139297485, -0.06058882176876068, 0.0026051155291497707, 0.036833252757787704, -0.005355503410100937, -0.02233993634581566, -0.028112495318055153, 0.011445902287960052, 0.02438177540898323, 0.00663251057267189, -0.0052665825933218, -0.04750310257077217, -0.0005176060367375612, -0.056100476533174515, 0.017875052988529205, 0.026953699067234993, 0.05868387222290039, 0.022508053109049797, -0.01877465471625328, -0.04381626099348068, -0.017756666988134384, -0.04699709266424179, -0.05896889790892601, 0.0167393758893013, 0.012905417941510677, -0.05274093151092529, -0.07136224210262299, 0.05660757049918175, 0.07672116160392761, 0.026872707530856133, -0.023871641606092453, -0.009915993548929691, -0.019773023203015327, 0.003704110626131296, 0.01777549274265766, 0.056746549904346466, -0.016907665878534317, -0.0022603676188737154, -0.008833554573357105, -0.05955367907881737, 0.026778453961014748, -0.0067759607918560505, 0.014084813185036182, 0.022978032007813454, -0.0026509298477321863, -0.0178904477506876, -0.05081093683838844, 0.007843702100217342, 0.01188377570360899, 0.04953603446483612, -0.05186482146382332, -0.001713122590444982, 0.0658053383231163, 0.013215329498052597, 0.06282027810811996, -0.013541214168071747, 0.007704506628215313, 0.03792925924062729, 0.05946732312440872, -0.04649579897522926, -0.031829267740249634, -0.012190642766654491, -0.04656628891825676, -0.02433389239013195, -0.009600781835615635, -0.018517034128308296, 0.04626757651567459, 0.03400244191288948, -0.0038192630745470524, -0.009767729789018631, -0.022961465641856194, 0.0758839100599289, 0.00006179706542752683, -0.03872610256075859, 0.024577893316745758, -0.030508724972605705, 0.01759462058544159, 0.008870033547282219, -0.013871556147933006, -0.00416640006005764, -0.052865900099277496, -0.021463248878717422, -0.07449488341808319, 0.009056071750819683, 0.008653812110424042, -0.009528176859021187, -0.007039577700197697, 0.02724399045109749, 0.00027577424771152437, 0.010859377682209015, 0.009426388889551163, -0.023054301738739014, -0.022531483322381973, -0.009105490520596504, 0.018291689455509186, -0.0021723841782659292, 0.018428413197398186, 0.0036871875636279583, 0.007310525048524141, -0.015281629748642445, 0.03288952261209488, 0.05460864305496216, 0.0014749914407730103, -0.014028957113623619, -0.07892784476280212, -0.012850073166191578, -0.06916538625955582, 0.018049331381917, -0.023904940113425255, -0.06137578934431076, 0.06096513941884041, 0.012335915118455887, 0.017339643090963364, -0.028988003730773926, -0.002604797948151827, -0.03875130042433739, -0.020573478192090988, -0.004959051962941885, -0.05870063602924347, 0.015663927420973778, -0.0228106789290905, 0.015062152408063412, -0.01325986161828041, 0.0047793323174119, -0.07200292497873306, -0.00924000795930624, 0.0016509982524439692, -0.00910083670169115, 0.05496137589216232, 0.04571543633937836, -0.028947724029421806, 0.004109709523618221, -0.05904551222920418, -0.043799955397844315, 0.010364461690187454, 0.020870855078101158, -0.03283139318227768, 0.021009091287851334, -0.03137669339776039, -0.03048509918153286, -0.03182264044880867, -0.013490220531821251, 0.064843088388443, -0.071588896214962, -0.03938926383852959, 0.0592411607503891, -0.005634557921439409, -0.05445428192615509, -0.05054224655032158, -0.03699786961078644, -0.038841743022203445, -0.07700864970684052, 0.003864808240905404, 0.029101738706231117, -0.03593820706009865, -0.002304417546838522, 0.03932604938745499, 0.03969104215502739, 0.040540628135204315, -0.051053237169981, 0.03240993246436119, -0.0008849556907080114, -0.006756913848221302, -0.0298302061855793, -0.0022208094596862793, -0.035608720034360886, -0.003224779386073351, -0.015186125412583351, -0.041775383055210114, 0.0028311272617429495, 0.04202466085553169, -0.042912159115076065, 0.04616259038448334, -0.06886102259159088, -0.006220410577952862, 0.023006930947303772, -0.00948273204267025, -0.038371071219444275, 0.017427103593945503, -0.027233993634581566, 0.05713219940662384, -0.029746733605861664, 0.026461338624358177, 0.011725430376827717, 0.014529318548738956, -0.022856250405311584, 0.04854188114404678, -0.04739846661686897, 0.034698013216257095, 0.007323557510972023, -0.01996534876525402, -0.05623583123087883, 0.0282194372266531, 0.042755693197250366, 0.010291188023984432, -0.020221102982759476, -0.01463704090565443, 0.062213074415922165, 0.003631490282714367, -0.019140318036079407, -0.005996450316160917, -0.0025424493942409754, -0.0084077762439847, 0.03304645046591759, -0.01893831416964531, -0.01793850213289261, 0.0024530619848519564, -0.012619491666555405, 0.042333390563726425, 0.010278456844389439, -0.034931719303131104, -0.013353868387639523, 0.00474327988922596, -0.025282325223088264, -0.05626077577471733, -0.025192024186253548, -0.08082300424575806, 0.011094249784946442, 0.0013163085095584393, 0.0471150241792202, 0.05567847192287445, 0.011565997265279293, 0.030071845278143883, -0.07969827204942703, -0.026119286194443703, -0.06946844607591629, 0.06070690229535103, -0.0641784816980362, -0.008515923283994198, -0.02373867854475975, 0.0562739260494709, -0.0020191711373627186, 0.011194565333425999, 0.009795411489903927, 0.04550684243440628, -0.062057722359895706, -0.007677300367504358, -0.03138520196080208, -0.025057045742869377, -0.0539608933031559, -0.01398271694779396, 0.07645358145236969, -0.06408306956291199, 0.045711368322372437, 0.009735791012644768, 0.017062637954950333, 0.03611404821276665, 0.024118181318044662, -0.0068466635420918465, -0.03756599873304367, -0.0012630877317860723, 0.06902694702148438, -0.05994118005037308, -0.012021076865494251, -0.0008388333953917027, -0.049627307802438736, -0.03234254941344261, -0.025434810668230057, 0.01767832599580288, 0.03134522959589958, -0.014523660764098167, -0.03960154950618744, 0.052429184317588806, 0.015562491491436958, -0.02498900704085827, -0.002169947139918804, 0.04969525709748268, -0.040026746690273285, -0.001170599483884871, 0.015570621937513351, -0.00903034582734108, -0.04610808938741684, -0.008914444595575333, -0.02118910849094391, -0.04365035146474838, -0.0096376808360219, 0.043356578797101974, 0.04749193787574768, -0.021028555929660797, 0.035720132291316986, 0.038480255752801895, 0.01526291761547327, -0.03515731170773506, 0.001539389486424625, -0.021467747166752815, -0.028714638203382492, 0.01022772304713726, 0.0193632785230875, -0.04026380181312561, 0.004984702914953232, 0.044662702828645706, -0.053254444152116776, -0.02692692168056965, -0.008888172917068005, 0.019642872735857964, 0.016367366537451744, -0.027284467592835426, -0.029836304485797882, 0.008997930213809013, -0.035241637378931046, 0.01586473360657692, -0.006054846569895744, 0.009619148448109627, -0.051564864814281464, 0.011269093491137028, 0.012352815829217434, -0.0373263955116272, 0.03122580796480179, -0.03671129792928696, -0.0653892531991005, -0.0075000268407166, 0.014188296161592007, -0.013254438526928425, 0.0026027928106486797, 0.028870508074760437, -0.008329447358846664, 0.045077115297317505, 0.004327375907450914, -0.033326614648103714, -0.06099529564380646, -0.05330680310726166, 0.040920622646808624, -0.022254595533013344, 0.04672926291823387, -0.04628623276948929, 0.03491613268852234, -0.0539533868432045, -0.01797855831682682, 0.04659488424658775, -0.07386981695890427, -0.02142149582505226, 0.0008763557416386902, -0.052002787590026855, -0.0030896535608917475, -0.0413619801402092, -0.019406629726290703, 0.035997092723846436, 0.02118312194943428, 0.0038838819600641727, -0.06706411391496658, -0.028151879087090492, -0.038317419588565826, 0.001020931638777256, 0.03332516923546791, -0.003668406745418906, -0.015382423996925354, -0.01902049034833908, 0.03937918320298195, 0.014103232882916927, -0.0011680654715746641, 0.013925543054938316, -0.054140836000442505, 0.018168281763792038, 0.01166877243667841, 0.0028480286709964275, -0.03468163684010506, -0.007188228890299797, -0.011135611683130264, -0.06014636904001236, 0.002987026935443282, 0.026719748973846436, 0.012915384955704212, -0.026848139241337776, -0.06384016573429108, 0.023367859423160553, 0.016628477722406387, -0.026774082332849503, -0.06579747796058655, 0.027828985825181007, 0.0008877474465407431, -0.006235309410840273, 0.01381655316799879, 0.007725684437900782, -0.0505157932639122, -0.02289142645895481, -0.08563300222158432, -0.04366959631443024, -0.044437017291784286, 0.07944322377443314, 0.01478481199592352, -0.0056899781338870525, -0.07637125998735428, -0.06281460076570511, -0.007168147712945938, 0.027399884536862373, 0.015369678847491741, 0.002706945640966296, -0.03097025491297245, -0.023206621408462524, -0.0501365140080452, 0.028490625321865082, 0.018635079264640808, -0.03599951043725014, 0.03856172412633896, -0.01601579785346985, 0.028906255960464478, -0.03899499028921127, 0.0019480844493955374, 0.043116211891174316, -0.0219686571508646, 0.03019164688885212, -0.04005648195743561, -0.0247809998691082, -0.045603830367326736, -0.035887960344552994, 0.02385988086462021, -0.08036370575428009, 0.038134489208459854, 0.0326351672410965, -0.057064976543188095, -0.002826153300702572, -0.024177782237529755, -0.06056723743677139, -0.03718814626336098, 0.03696177154779434, 0.01254117488861084, 0.05476978048682213, -0.048968903720378876, -0.04890932887792587, 0.016095653176307678, -0.025653788819909096, -0.07231687754392624, 0.03788791596889496, 0.02551233023405075, -0.05926407873630524, -0.005891861394047737, -0.05717410147190094, 0.04886437952518463, -0.02699398063123226, 0.04738137125968933, 0.058519065380096436, 0.04935397580265999, -0.05250164866447449, 0.04812873154878616, -0.049394067376852036, -0.05297687277197838, -0.00510440394282341, -0.0071153799071908, -0.021683204919099808, 0.028003904968500137, 0.006765692960470915, -0.013396085239946842, 0.023412682116031647, -0.019717944785952568, 0.03536318987607956, 0.03909134492278099, -0.04476054757833481, 0.007246728055179119, -0.01081675011664629, 0.0034555112943053246, 0.0632932260632515, 0.018649067729711533, 0.020303072407841682, -0.05788860470056534, 0.03452987223863602, -0.04238428547978401, 0.048069532960653305, -0.025736842304468155, 0.02407836727797985, 0.006844592746347189, -0.05404148995876312, -0.0560276173055172, -0.02343943901360035, -0.014290590770542622, -0.06053336709737778, -0.013124356977641582, -0.006409613881260157, -0.01772548072040081, -0.04357142001390457 ]
The pursuit of long-term autonomy mandates that machine learning models must continuously adapt to their changing environments and learn to solve new tasks. Continual learning seeks to overcome the challenge of catastrophic forgetting, where learning to solve new tasks causes a model to forget previously learnt information. Prior-based continual learning methods are appealing as they are computationally efficient and do not require auxiliary models or data storage. However, prior-based approaches typically fail on important benchmarks and are thus limited in their potential applications compared to their memory-based counterparts. We introduce Bayesian adaptive moment regularization (BAdam), a novel prior-based method that better constrains parameter growth, reducing catastrophic forgetting. Our method boasts a range of desirable properties such as being lightweight and task label-free, converging quickly, and offering calibrated uncertainty that is important for safe real-world deployment. Results show that BAdam achieves state-of-the-art performance for prior-based methods on challenging single-headed class-incremental experiments such as Split MNIST and Split FashionMNIST, and does so without relying on task labels or discrete task boundaries.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08546v3
[ -0.01874033361673355, -0.011007663793861866, 0.0596594512462616, 0.03530098870396614, -0.02222292497754097, 0.012212694622576237, 0.02100597694516182, -0.00040258606895804405, 0.014285612851381302, -0.01593593694269657, -0.05331461504101753, -0.01774340495467186, -0.07025210559368134, -0.04554808512330055, -0.0500783771276474, -0.011563674546778202, 0.04996871203184128, -0.007317856885492802, -0.043626077473163605, 0.05534373223781586, -0.008296079933643341, -0.02078397385776043, -0.052568573504686356, 0.0011026653228327632, 0.006630671676248312, -0.04086762294173241, -0.02761084772646427, 0.027183499187231064, -0.020923305302858353, 0.003358796937391162, 0.05303874984383583, -0.019386788830161095, -0.01584821566939354, -0.06808227300643921, -0.054766930639743805, -0.05536329001188278, -0.028528103604912758, 0.003535347292199731, 0.0361529104411602, -0.029385745525360107, 0.03897521272301674, -0.04617999121546745, -0.06700480729341507, -0.03607919439673424, -0.024940570816397667, 0.003930428996682167, -0.030846700072288513, -0.0012057438725605607, -0.06361988931894302, -0.05143901705741882, 0.032855238765478134, 0.013555376790463924, 0.010419590398669243, 0.0388791523873806, -0.026402775198221207, 0.011420195922255516, -0.0059817638248205185, 0.01483815349638462, -0.06624650955200195, -0.020129799842834473, 0.0532732754945755, -0.011403016746044159, 0.026805641129612923, 0.03662421181797981, 0.012547152116894722, 0.052958954125642776, 0.007216081488877535, -0.06991221010684967, -0.05951917916536331, -0.04112008959054947, 0.04946685582399368, -0.034973811358213425, -0.034371376037597656, 0.04166532680392265, -0.05160867050290108, -0.06167769432067871, -0.043523576110601425, -0.036277685314416885, 0.034319616854190826, 0.016197439283132553, -0.009086929261684418, 0.02846985124051571, 0.03039741888642311, -0.03183876350522041, 0.03735997900366783, -0.010241103358566761, 0.04518526419997215, 0.003116082167252898, 0.007403452880680561, -0.03158813342452049, 0.04593779891729355, -0.05921492725610733, -0.07965151220560074, -0.036257755011320114, 0.08010918647050858, -0.022960767149925232, 0.028136951848864555, 0.06029122695326805, 0.003657149849459529, 0.0003583007783163339, -0.004076831042766571, -0.017817163839936256, -0.04215982183814049, 0.0482090599834919, 0.001175222685560584, -0.024265214800834656, 0.02745717205107212, 0.010295210406184196, -0.009162128902971745, 0.0076192403212189674, 0.021263649687170982, -0.01536643411964178, 0.00019568466814234853, -0.025768514722585678, -0.04448390007019043, -0.035744160413742065, -0.019856827333569527, -0.007806428242474794, 0.018260275945067406, 0.016492314636707306, -0.012196549214422703, 0.02871500328183174, 0.046460993587970734, -0.004352629650384188, -0.01468810997903347, 0.0005155947874300182, 0.058129098266363144, -0.03281077370047569, -0.022625109180808067, -0.008180677890777588, -0.06505446881055832, 0.032373420894145966, 0.010467775166034698, -0.021001756191253662, 0.07395752519369125, 0.025739464908838272, -0.0713149756193161, -0.031965699046850204, 0.07107849419116974, 0.006478156894445419, -0.05369534343481064, -0.056017354130744934, 0.014552169479429722, -0.03022501990199089, 0.040519990026950836, 0.04162011668086052, -0.04840567708015442, -0.025068406015634537, 0.04061827436089516, 0.011291068978607655, 0.0002832143218256533, -0.02312764711678028, 0.016050130128860474, 0.03401068598031998, 0.043391309678554535, -0.007142734248191118, 0.02634155936539173, -0.036773763597011566, -0.07097397744655609, 0.0033872094936668873, 0.03082752227783203, -0.007684357929974794, 0.020319735631346703, -0.02865692973136902, 0.041002411395311356, 0.00019242207054048777, 0.013415523804724216, -0.013143299147486687, 0.001755533623509109, 0.015475486405193806, -0.032258041203022, -0.03225550428032875, -0.008137893863022327, -0.01841484196484089, -0.04928772896528244, -0.00027967055211775005, 0.0004946748376823962, -0.0331948958337307, -0.014657273888587952, 0.0030095414258539677, 0.03908468782901764, -0.008564126677811146, -0.06112056225538254, 0.011738915927708149, -0.05013788491487503, 0.002474617911502719, -0.07996480911970139, 0.014004006050527096, 0.0531587228178978, 0.02534531243145466, -0.03856600075960159, 0.0072284904308617115, 0.007398461457341909, -0.010448526591062546, -0.034724388271570206, -0.01918741874396801, 0.024859223514795303, 0.004016519524157047, 0.02227017655968666, 0.024062754586338997, -0.08436278998851776, -0.0232995618134737, -0.054847754538059235, -0.027510184794664383, -0.025044787675142288, -0.04859123006463051, 0.0027711866423487663, 0.05088838189840317, 0.008579840883612633, 0.034830909222364426, 0.04694085940718651, 0.04178923740983009, 0.04908255487680435, 0.0455448217689991, 0.04617873951792717, 0.018586190417408943, -0.10145127773284912, 0.06014677882194519, -0.0005455734790302813, 0.019112279638648033, 0.01325761154294014, 0.03434429690241814, -0.018905777484178543, -0.018600724637508392, 0.01196138747036457, 0.02979409508407116, 0.04682724550366402, 0.01335684210062027, -0.04493052512407303, -0.032049018889665604, -0.008708332665264606, -0.06127370893955231, -0.051579397171735764, -0.058967042714357376, -0.00828312337398529, 0.018981536850333214, -0.03573267534375191, 0.05749216675758362, -0.02376795932650566, -0.03262776508927345, -0.015180248767137527, -0.040662191808223724, 0.06242474541068077, -0.027412746101617813, -0.04936534911394119, -0.02818824164569378, -0.006409067194908857, 0.03071552887558937, -0.03543633222579956, -0.03935229033231735, -0.03186781704425812, -0.04802345857024193, -0.0009388851467519999, -0.04186765477061272, 0.034245409071445465, 0.001153330784291029, -0.057828471064567566, 0.007664992939680815, 0.010416991077363491, 0.02691546455025673, 0.006314153783023357, 0.03747619688510895, -0.05047444626688957, 0.0012315312633290887, 0.03720759227871895, 0.0013869274407625198, 0.013534052297472954, -0.027987278997898102, -0.019140489399433136, -0.03753409534692764, 0.01028305385261774, 0.03347324952483177, 0.06698303669691086, 0.04807507246732712, -0.02867419645190239, -0.02697082981467247, -0.02519472874701023, -0.05091678723692894, -0.016573704779148102, 0.046225838363170624, 0.04243151471018791, 0.005302163772284985, -0.017942018806934357, -0.04230207949876785, -0.03980579227209091, -0.05509074404835701, -0.03727805241942406, -0.037393372505903244, -0.06800153851509094, -0.061066918075084686, -0.07509569078683853, -0.03913812339305878, -0.007805397734045982, -0.039876021444797516, 0.008851952850818634, -0.031513724476099014, 0.013820589520037174, 0.00909688975661993, 0.04530014470219612, -0.003320105839520693, -0.04997757449746132, -0.026898585259914398, 0.014447914436459541, 0.028278758749365807, 0.00849001295864582, -0.0639537125825882, -0.02756313420832157, 0.0180718582123518, 0.04430786892771721, 0.0058350944891572, -0.029469043016433716, -0.02276758663356304, -0.03352345898747444, 0.020664094015955925, 0.02724241092801094, 0.06258340924978256, 0.009571998380124569, 0.03940533474087715, -0.004757981281727552, -0.024428382515907288, -0.008590863086283207, 0.0445549413561821, 0.012246545404195786, -0.061474911868572235, -0.04268236830830574, -0.026680361479520798, 0.06172472983598709, 0.005952146835625172, -0.02801128290593624, -0.012172003276646137, 0.0074100554920732975, 0.028903363272547722, 0.010102673433721066, -0.0186914149671793, 0.04183643311262131, 0.03385666757822037, -0.00188360083848238, -0.041877005249261856, -0.023665491491556168, 0.006024823524057865, -0.01609903946518898, 0.05493874475359917, -0.026445623487234116, -0.04154425486922264, 0.07336696237325668, -0.08495120704174042, -0.009559014812111855, 0.043214768171310425, 0.05572307109832764, 0.0009649329585954547, 0.009349188767373562, -0.004513341933488846, 0.015256430953741074, 0.028425445780158043, 0.009780136868357658, 0.003979880828410387, 0.05112571641802788, 0.030749907717108727, -0.0194573774933815, -0.051813315600156784, 0.010246062651276588, -0.04839945584535599, -0.03977175056934357, 0.014484331011772156, 0.00385438185185194, -0.01945677027106285, 0.022739853709936142, -0.05096404254436493, 0.006512851919978857, -0.01597060263156891, 0.02224087528884411, -0.012717233039438725, -0.03344167768955231, 0.05489804968237877, -0.04619681462645531, -0.006719997618347406, -0.020288124680519104, -0.023426488041877747, 0.018925806507468224, -0.05789133533835411, 0.011646149680018425, -0.05429134890437126, 0.03618722781538963, 0.02627601847052574, -0.008516639471054077, 0.02182963863015175, 0.0626811757683754, -0.03307327628135681, 0.03959505632519722, -0.008783922530710697, -0.041240498423576355, -0.011343415826559067, 0.018985018134117126, -0.05605851858854294, -0.008184012956917286, -0.07530472427606583, -0.011345308274030685, 0.03882739692926407, 0.015194268897175789, -0.00691645173355937, 0.003721029032021761, 0.005141370464116335, 0.04051167145371437, -0.08428395539522171, 0.025859439745545387, -0.054833993315696716, 0.026287540793418884, -0.004254603758454323, -0.016847766935825348, 0.07008925825357437, -0.013717250898480415, 0.012301558628678322, -0.05313553288578987, -0.03132380172610283, 0.00413609528914094, -0.02446160651743412, -0.0356181375682354, -0.0729096457362175, -0.002815392566844821, -0.04623284935951233, 0.06285281479358673, -0.00838365126401186, 0.0031903337221592665, -0.04112415388226509, -0.04285460710525513, -0.027707984670996666, 0.02236834168434143, 0.06466338783502579, 0.02236548438668251, -0.03000975027680397, -0.029601652175188065, 0.027081431820988655, 0.019776899367570877, 0.002426997758448124, 0.01008701603859663, -0.03896629810333252, 0.012597517110407352, -0.028095176443457603, -0.013128753751516342, -0.05135013163089752, -0.010478271171450615, 0.0795535296201706, -0.048173241317272186, -0.03306949511170387, 0.004582103807479143, 0.04506653547286987, -0.042281441390514374, -0.06711072474718094, 0.011676528491079807, -0.02881036140024662, -0.05086616054177284, -0.03373029828071594, -0.004384397994726896, 0.03808644041419029, -0.014874469488859177, -0.010443632490932941, 0.016895104199647903, -0.015449912287294865, -0.0034980899654328823, 0.0307309590280056, 0.020549381151795387, -0.007637568283826113, -0.016133826225996017, -0.014416744001209736, -0.07811228185892105, -0.04356720298528671, -0.060282349586486816, -0.009362463839352131, -0.01193249225616455, 0.040327288210392, 0.009161889553070068, 0.05914122983813286, -0.08691233396530151, 0.02266688086092472, 0.007990097627043724, -0.016455354169011116, 0.003761189291253686, 0.030827587470412254, 0.00721019646152854, 0.0239780955016613, -0.044501688331365585, 0.02245212160050869, 0.06404478847980499, -0.045458000153303146, -0.015062411315739155, 0.03069995902478695, -0.03258182108402252, -0.023162739351391792, 0.031009884551167488, -0.01412929780781269, -0.04523833841085434, 0.004973461851477623, 0.018709227442741394, 0.03791286051273346, -0.03875163197517395, 0.047222014516592026, 0.01599632017314434, -0.006811116356402636, -0.050948940217494965, -0.005453980062156916, 0.011348328553140163, -0.00953920092433691, 0.021480707451701164, -0.05245264247059822, -0.028953110799193382, 0.041539181023836136, 0.02862415835261345, 0.017183702439069748, -0.003094031708315015, 0.019008969888091087, 0.023445017635822296, -0.05195607244968414, 0.009632778353989124, -0.0730721578001976, -0.04714119806885719, -0.05174262076616287, -0.01858578994870186, -0.0020709908567368984, 0.032456204295158386, 0.016415003687143326, 0.025420643389225006, 0.011408613063395023, -0.002369186608120799, 0.006540358532220125, -0.04584560543298721, 0.0024702372029423714, -0.027186697348952293, 0.036777157336473465, 0.025887729600071907, 0.0375506654381752, 0.02052982896566391, 0.03847215324640274, 0.03833583742380142, -0.04224175959825516, 0.005583477206528187, -0.002860029460862279, 0.02888253889977932, -0.07382139563560486, -0.032767437398433685, 0.034482430666685104, 0.023783033713698387, -0.020095432177186012, 0.04795214161276817, 0.02594728209078312, -0.030989207327365875, 0.05248066410422325, -0.00014092419587541372, -0.009813234210014343, 0.007538108620792627, 0.02748640812933445, 0.06884215027093887, -0.06203538179397583, 0.03973525017499924, -0.03018605336546898, -0.039601366966962814, -0.024264302104711533, -0.021237555891275406, -0.004691615700721741, 0.025930695235729218, 0.014574565924704075, -0.06729345768690109, 0.075785793364048, 0.005442655645310879, -0.06865327060222626, 0.01226014643907547, 0.02592463605105877, -0.08768793195486069, -0.023590698838233948, -0.0122029148042202, -0.006479778792709112, -0.043836332857608795, 0.06021859496831894, 0.043748121708631516, -0.018383819609880447, -0.03462620824575424, 0.05578051880002022, 0.08481617271900177, 0.0008518747636117041, 0.02720368094742298, 0.0017404661048203707, -0.06201465427875519, 0.04304437339305878, -0.008477089926600456, 0.00851252768188715, 0.028792787343263626, 0.004679268691688776, -0.023004641756415367, -0.017118947580456734, -0.049334585666656494, 0.035283707082271576, -0.06376346945762634, -0.01434673648327589, 0.015419852919876575, 0.007468575146049261, 0.039970267564058304, -0.01744113117456436, -0.04252501577138901, 0.012474443763494492, 0.020057547837495804, 0.019609611481428146, -0.024281663820147514, 0.012731482274830341, -0.008577332831919193, 0.026147272437810898, -0.03647308051586151, -0.06687189638614655, 0.054949838668107986, -0.03973356634378433, -0.05389322340488434, 0.02600022405385971, -0.03816921263933182, -0.0031497348099946976, -0.02550206519663334, -0.027125641703605652, 0.01346394419670105, 0.059013523161411285, -0.030885417014360428, -0.022383911535143852, 0.0007903394871391356, 0.01093574333935976, -0.01362952496856451, -0.01144526619464159, 0.034670766443014145, -0.010891681537032127, 0.017619386315345764, 0.02085372433066368, -0.027868039906024933, -0.019060147926211357, -0.0578172393143177, 0.04461732506752014, -0.005622300319373608, -0.018890265375375748, -0.044099826365709305, 0.02610989473760128, -0.022000756114721298, 0.022003134712576866, -0.0073630670085549355, -0.07121776789426804, -0.051972247660160065, -0.007458935026079416, 0.010527161881327629, 0.023406345397233963, 0.013763089664280415, 0.029337545856833458, 0.009155083447694778, -0.01817959174513817, 0.03282301127910614, 0.02713869698345661, 0.020512141287326813, 0.014951006509363651, -0.06573280692100525, -0.04570430517196655, -0.0010178735246881843, -0.02504543960094452, -0.033150918781757355, -0.03392045944929123, -0.01748102717101574, -0.035045646131038666, 0.004658760968595743, 0.052181094884872437, 0.012905800715088844, -0.033395204693078995, -0.05891817808151245, 0.042052898555994034, 0.008983082138001919, -0.032465554773807526, -0.04491439461708069, 0.0379340723156929, 0.018947342410683632, -0.015713544562458992, 0.01281009428203106, -0.002462091390043497, -0.04103127121925354, 0.028392696753144264, -0.08709756284952164, 0.02616836503148079, -0.02834264747798443, 0.05257909744977951, 0.01623271405696869, 0.015760010108351707, -0.0024561474565416574, -0.06098197028040886, 0.027395108714699745, 0.016936464235186577, -0.007421816699206829, 0.015520215034484863, 0.027008410543203354, 0.027229540050029755, -0.07669895142316818, -0.04993388056755066, 0.045984942466020584, -0.014483500272035599, -0.01722022518515587, 0.021615352481603622, 0.04088059440255165, 0.04354482889175415, 0.013126092962920666, 0.05081050470471382, -0.008038013242185116, 0.04162696748971939, -0.025204740464687347, 0.013791217468678951, -0.03235076740384102, -0.07543546706438065, 0.005515920929610729, -0.03890250623226166, 0.034588370472192764, 0.022802414372563362, -0.024710768833756447, -0.0026678971480578184, -0.027299052104353905, -0.01177365705370903, 0.0074096727184951305, 0.010295633226633072, -0.024074655026197433, 0.07279065996408463, -0.00901415478438139, -0.02445784956216812, -0.04722221568226814, -0.06025154888629913, -0.06418804079294205, 0.022232918068766594, 0.0816977471113205, -0.06317735463380814, 0.0022950072307139635, -0.052935559302568436, 0.0431075245141983, -0.020788265392184258, 0.033180028200149536, -0.04686357080936432, 0.06370478868484497, 0.016897575929760933, -0.05065876990556717, -0.03657086193561554, -0.04604380950331688, -0.0714428573846817, -0.0701480582356453, -0.055754777044057846, -0.04071420803666115, 0.02490655519068241, -0.03505626693367958, 0.03869181498885155, 0.025228606536984444, 0.06668951362371445, 0.03521214425563812, -0.0015490439254790545, -0.005049604456871748, 0.007205221336334944, -0.07360842078924179, 0.08418857306241989, 0.00552148325368762, 0.006470201071351767, -0.0363626591861248, 0.04111694172024727, -0.004372856579720974, -0.00025349450879730284, 0.015416107140481472, -0.018779272213578224, 0.01753326691687107, -0.03931361064314842, 0.003069105325266719, -0.036369550973176956, -0.005823887884616852, -0.006447718013077974, -0.03240221366286278, -0.026833349838852882, -0.031785909086465836, -0.04744444042444229 ]
Stacking regressions is an ensemble technique that forms linear combinations of different regression estimators to enhance predictive accuracy. The conventional approach uses cross-validation data to generate predictions from the constituent estimators, and least-squares with nonnegativity constraints to learn the combination weights. In this paper, we learn these weights analogously by minimizing a regularized version of the empirical risk subject to a nonnegativity constraint. When the constituent estimators are linear least-squares projections onto nested subspaces separated by at least three dimensions, we show that thanks to an adaptive shrinkage effect, the resulting stacked estimator has strictly smaller population risk than best single estimator among them, with more significant gains when the signal-to-noise ratio is small. Here "best" refers to an estimator that minimizes a model selection criterion such as AIC or BIC. In other words, in this setting, the best single estimator is inadmissible. Because the optimization problem can be reformulated as isotonic regression, the stacked estimator requires the same order of computation as the best single estimator, making it an attractive alternative in terms of both performance and implementation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09880v3
[ -0.04073789343237877, -0.02918131835758686, -0.0021261873189359903, 0.03347861394286156, -0.002614829922094941, 0.0021480608265846968, -0.014538099057972431, 0.014172520488500595, -0.0033904737792909145, -0.0377807691693306, -0.03266925364732742, -0.03582170605659485, -0.029629118740558624, -0.028810741379857063, -0.019655494019389153, -0.02273719199001789, 0.07164455205202103, 0.018505312502384186, -0.06774207204580307, 0.06561406701803207, 0.01259651966392994, -0.0033985816407948732, -0.0172580573707819, 0.05198289453983307, 0.035768136382102966, 0.02542208507657051, -0.05748540908098221, -0.004912716802209616, -0.05318129062652588, 0.0352434404194355, 0.05250660330057144, -0.017303194850683212, -0.02522931806743145, -0.06837059557437897, -0.002125353552401066, -0.0447247140109539, 0.0018161392072215676, -0.025909140706062317, 0.04055185988545418, -0.04674157127737999, 0.02892773412168026, -0.053644392639398575, -0.02812047302722931, -0.008475175127387047, -0.04125960171222687, 0.005039193667471409, -0.04429295286536217, 0.034549079835414886, -0.05041399970650673, -0.045560237020254135, 0.06191386282444, -0.029058614745736122, 0.005693245679140091, 0.04815100133419037, -0.036780185997486115, 0.021900227293372154, -0.016273969784379005, -0.02812712825834751, -0.06126655638217926, 0.0003067184006795287, 0.007730473298579454, -0.030859891325235367, -0.040940944105386734, -0.018829351291060448, -0.0017671321984380484, 0.06956847757101059, -0.024030130356550217, -0.0631905049085617, -0.04715737700462341, 0.011745703406631947, 0.04742058366537094, -0.07781082391738892, 0.05196632072329521, 0.02944297343492508, -0.03600125014781952, -0.054085589945316315, -0.019551793113350868, -0.04638587310910225, 0.01770368590950966, 0.0036272217985242605, -0.0446564182639122, 0.061184581369161606, 0.024844205006957054, 0.0389590710401535, 0.025030285120010376, 0.008846227079629898, 0.06831848621368408, -0.025820711627602577, 0.017929455265402794, -0.05509670078754425, 0.027555465698242188, -0.050594545900821686, -0.06325522065162659, -0.0026831054128706455, 0.0629473477602005, -0.060114871710538864, 0.0475655160844326, 0.028217477723956108, 0.003880932927131653, -0.027840575203299522, -0.03263599053025246, -0.01852530986070633, -0.016246361657977104, 0.07575500756502151, 0.012728618457913399, -0.04844488948583603, -0.02932363748550415, -0.020206380635499954, -0.022854875773191452, -0.01778705045580864, -0.06491690874099731, -0.03662676364183426, 0.03264256566762924, -0.049512214958667755, -0.03153176233172417, -0.05201144516468048, 0.05648719519376755, 0.01111536379903555, 0.031010426580905914, -0.05632714554667473, -0.039550233632326126, 0.02174348384141922, 0.02262888103723526, -0.0052371942438185215, -0.015997320413589478, -0.02123957686126232, 0.06865013390779495, -0.010400482453405857, 0.017908381298184395, 0.02299778163433075, -0.06259829550981522, 0.005083085969090462, -0.014570075087249279, -0.018296584486961365, 0.05645008757710457, 0.014362669549882412, -0.011063285171985626, -0.05065874382853508, 0.024061216041445732, 0.032170794904232025, 0.024973679333925247, -0.06502218544483185, -0.01334175281226635, -0.0032564550638198853, -0.01614055596292019, 0.06485910713672638, -0.05359422788023949, -0.04332208260893822, 0.003941988572478294, 0.04287724941968918, -0.023897288367152214, -0.026840273290872574, 0.027839507907629013, -0.00633590342476964, 0.03242482990026474, -0.002840663306415081, 0.03982263058423996, 0.01006661169230938, -0.03699580579996109, 0.027736537158489227, 0.034656185656785965, -0.004519063513725996, -0.03146476671099663, 0.018254630267620087, -0.008004123345017433, -0.005424616392701864, 0.043675441294908524, -0.010357130318880081, 0.01184186339378357, -0.01085251197218895, -0.044996023178100586, 0.026865126565098763, -0.006223814561963081, -0.030688907951116562, -0.03642129898071289, 0.01880517229437828, -0.009868384338915348, -0.03991249203681946, -0.050115037709474564, 0.032259780913591385, -0.0020675312262028456, 0.0079061109572649, 0.01899005100131035, 0.04129554331302643, 0.016047704964876175, -0.01410601194947958, -0.08039341121912003, -0.024431539699435234, 0.02360362932085991, 0.016436763107776642, -0.012494848109781742, -0.0381331704556942, 0.023730117827653885, 0.033229321241378784, -0.026436204090714455, -0.0563555583357811, 0.006127613130956888, -0.03635638207197189, -0.027819033712148666, 0.017739448696374893, -0.07973074167966843, -0.017871106043457985, -0.06972353160381317, 0.029996071010828018, -0.010122328996658325, -0.05937737226486206, -0.012058150954544544, 0.042295560240745544, -0.027325265109539032, 0.019826434552669525, 0.05402213707566261, 0.045439403504133224, 0.05692534148693085, 0.036547064781188965, 0.010534359142184258, -0.02150094322860241, -0.08517995476722717, 0.05704580619931221, -0.0215793177485466, -0.018086299300193787, 0.0333993174135685, -0.0006969539681449533, 0.0545758455991745, -0.049169450998306274, -0.050168681889772415, 0.06511949002742767, 0.05986545979976654, -0.009416178800165653, -0.05661410838365555, -0.06026047095656395, -0.008125219494104385, -0.04953934624791145, -0.015330986119806767, -0.07371731847524643, -0.00842675007879734, -0.014581914059817791, 0.00300140050239861, 0.04952064901590347, 0.009020467288792133, -0.030087968334555626, -0.06741926074028015, 0.01584828831255436, 0.025329528376460075, -0.024653015658259392, -0.06096876040101051, -0.043385449796915054, -0.06021536886692047, 0.026295755058526993, -0.029037078842520714, -0.004393995273858309, -0.009876728989183903, -0.061290767043828964, 0.004287302028387785, -0.018688451498746872, 0.03128516674041748, 0.05185511335730553, -0.05313530191779137, 0.012609104625880718, 0.006291112396866083, 0.035500865429639816, 0.01230070274323225, 0.0038438932970166206, -0.06399372220039368, 0.03854652866721153, 0.021814964711666107, -0.01671128161251545, -0.03514169156551361, -0.0342177152633667, 0.03571150079369545, -0.052322402596473694, -0.011062142439186573, 0.01354862842708826, 0.047126684337854385, 0.024779604747891426, 0.01926508918404579, -0.030884098261594772, -0.036313969641923904, -0.03013003244996071, 0.041084762662649155, 0.014916603453457355, 0.03636792674660683, -0.011306674219667912, -0.012561864219605923, -0.07416404038667679, 0.005347273778170347, -0.04341956600546837, 0.028494521975517273, -0.06409932672977448, -0.0585363544523716, 0.005410219542682171, -0.07210490107536316, -0.05521208047866821, -0.05491767078638077, -0.01521459873765707, -0.02797037735581398, -0.05261502414941788, 0.005370590835809708, 0.025380127131938934, 0.014294732362031937, 0.004317382350564003, -0.06032705307006836, 0.025483472272753716, 0.05897069722414017, 0.011666064150631428, -0.0328383594751358, -0.03344790264964104, -0.06448131799697876, 0.0016734586097300053, 0.06158450245857239, -0.010140585713088512, -0.02525874599814415, -0.03363683819770813, -0.02952239289879799, 0.026681579649448395, 0.014000564813613892, 0.020559601485729218, -0.012518603354692459, 0.03368792310357094, 0.025224316865205765, -0.004621956031769514, -0.004112360067665577, -0.028943585231900215, -0.018006980419158936, -0.034219831228256226, -0.0622929148375988, -0.029267316684126854, 0.05400310456752777, 0.026312611997127533, -0.03559054434299469, -0.039792291820049286, -0.007240214850753546, 0.041692957282066345, -0.027378860861063004, -0.05104098841547966, -0.004144029691815376, 0.06495583802461624, 0.002186642726883292, -0.04160196706652641, -0.044034622609615326, -0.003405311843380332, -0.02122015878558159, 0.014857149682939053, -0.0196527112275362, 0.028022559359669685, 0.046892959624528885, -0.08350062370300293, 0.04207567125558853, 0.009934874251484871, 0.0755753442645073, 0.00850693043321371, -0.02717794105410576, 0.025439681485295296, -0.003601555246859789, -0.012032396160066128, -0.012741739861667156, 0.04079087823629379, 0.007744733709841967, 0.06255023926496506, -0.021159883588552475, -0.055911093950271606, -0.02753511257469654, -0.06008449196815491, -0.010752014815807343, -0.012569384649395943, 0.01155319157987833, 0.007310761138796806, 0.03951238468289375, -0.015701493248343468, 0.03633689135313034, -0.008406137116253376, 0.028860079124569893, -0.02471759170293808, -0.01801704801619053, 0.06768030673265457, -0.03409677743911743, 0.01863895170390606, -0.00427381694316864, 0.04433240368962288, 0.021245334297418594, -0.0538930669426918, 0.030488966032862663, -0.06180901452898979, 0.036570560187101364, -0.00781338196247816, -0.03923793137073517, 0.04932788759469986, 0.032060593366622925, -0.03435741737484932, 0.027011532336473465, 0.021489623934030533, 0.005542271304875612, -0.0020730665419250727, -0.000702116871252656, -0.006497853435575962, -0.009073452092707157, -0.04732973128557205, -0.020005635917186737, -0.008937905542552471, -0.040352776646614075, -0.029318997636437416, -0.02604793570935726, -0.0010387252550572157, 0.02668183483183384, -0.07332128286361694, 0.027328351512551308, -0.027605608105659485, -0.010421997867524624, -0.019181646406650543, -0.06424030661582947, 0.061392880976200104, -0.020334260538220406, -0.003276105970144272, -0.06926697492599487, -0.018838627263903618, -0.041899893432855606, -0.01797601394355297, -0.05840558558702469, -0.061391398310661316, -0.01894773170351982, -0.06428234279155731, 0.025343742221593857, 0.024138396605849266, 0.015203471295535564, -0.03992786630988121, -0.001976671162992716, -0.03974970430135727, 0.0233452208340168, 0.04004817083477974, 0.032183971256017685, 0.00009845203749136999, -0.013432368636131287, -0.01457202434539795, 0.004436313174664974, -0.01191206369549036, -0.028055615723133087, -0.025222403928637505, 0.01615576259791851, 0.0020610070787370205, -0.023130089044570923, -0.04506133124232292, -0.019824476912617683, 0.06378614157438278, -0.0448351725935936, -0.03552824631333351, 0.012710398994386196, 0.039802275598049164, -0.07559660822153091, -0.07276520878076553, -0.02618219144642353, -0.02372599206864834, -0.07611734420061111, -0.04099688306450844, -0.00214523752219975, 0.026501620188355446, -0.008766954764723778, 0.020412735641002655, 0.0324285551905632, -0.0072971368208527565, -0.01485547423362732, 0.029207535088062286, 0.03940616548061371, 0.014573858119547367, -0.0227221567183733, -0.04121725261211395, -0.07652369141578674, 0.020846497267484665, -0.026218535378575325, 0.012964294292032719, -0.03125224635004997, 0.058811549097299576, -0.00035782865597866476, 0.03485658019781113, -0.07492589950561523, 0.04088234901428223, 0.01670679822564125, -0.0007286527543328702, 0.014239453710615635, 0.06536617875099182, -0.031026067212224007, 0.053670551627874374, -0.042043786495923996, 0.010072499513626099, 0.02166442759335041, -0.054552022367715836, 0.005590813234448433, -0.029133055359125137, 0.018694959580898285, -0.016471099108457565, 0.061124641448259354, -0.0299934521317482, -0.04022521525621414, -0.0138240996748209, 0.023664506152272224, -0.008142588660120964, -0.034086138010025024, 0.01844882220029831, 0.024479525163769722, -0.0419655404984951, -0.04841892048716545, -0.0036127744242548943, -0.0250212624669075, -0.004148190841078758, 0.02164601907134056, -0.062022864818573, 0.021572047844529152, 0.04326195269823074, 0.02451273612678051, -0.00690636970102787, 0.04616585373878479, -0.020050425082445145, -0.006204402539879084, 0.0016762000741437078, 0.02922038733959198, -0.06614282727241516, -0.00017957745876628906, -0.010827822610735893, 0.06665714830160141, 0.039160169661045074, 0.033718355000019073, 0.031112320721149445, 0.038592565804719925, -0.0615382045507431, -0.0492536835372448, 0.025568261742591858, -0.02310197800397873, 0.038038622587919235, -0.027897397056221962, 0.02659708634018898, 0.021174252033233643, 0.02082192339003086, 0.033924657851457596, -0.019027575850486755, 0.004740695934742689, 0.015562422573566437, -0.02284044586122036, -0.005631841719150543, 0.0029482610989362, 0.009765945374965668, -0.04600448161363602, -0.00998756941407919, 0.015563322231173515, -0.007812209893018007, 0.057013943791389465, 0.03521154448390007, -0.01601470448076725, 0.03153209388256073, -0.03318139910697937, -0.020672744140028954, -0.04601787403225899, 0.009395498782396317, 0.0625419020652771, -0.06449143588542938, -0.015329885296523571, -0.0423414520919323, -0.040994737297296524, 0.009924840182065964, -0.04215618595480919, 0.02544117346405983, -0.011500433087348938, 0.030899392440915108, -0.05915827676653862, 0.01612113043665886, 0.014169842936098576, -0.07193977385759354, 0.010794999077916145, 0.05906471982598305, -0.07642855495214462, 0.004046599380671978, 0.009576478973031044, -0.04236004874110222, -0.0034803447779268026, 0.030919145792722702, -0.03801374509930611, -0.016225596889853477, -0.04217056185007095, 0.075386643409729, 0.07482492923736572, 0.006008646916598082, 0.028647642582654953, 0.02244766801595688, -0.048636022955179214, -0.017903544008731842, -0.013440046459436417, -0.02297411672770977, -0.015261096879839897, 0.032701797783374786, 0.006317125167697668, -0.010786246508359909, -0.02898344025015831, 0.046513285487890244, -0.05350780859589577, -0.013317125849425793, 0.0028185690753161907, -0.02705048769712448, 0.028469983488321304, -0.014919107779860497, -0.018098115921020508, -0.01037174928933382, -0.015034050680696964, -0.0025884867645800114, -0.0041220784187316895, -0.005783664528280497, 0.010893411003053188, 0.05958491563796997, -0.019622769206762314, -0.06372345238924026, 0.005482751410454512, 0.015410018153488636, 0.014281803742051125, 0.017371224239468575, -0.05267385020852089, 0.027682818472385406, 0.0011628898791968822, 0.013674207963049412, 0.02325855940580368, 0.07113585621118546, -0.019117290154099464, 0.010670711286365986, -0.025618761777877808, 0.0418844036757946, 0.023918434977531433, 0.028043482452630997, 0.03619835525751114, -0.03655097633600235, 0.05162201076745987, -0.029343655332922935, -0.005098867230117321, 0.007367107551544905, 0.024569636210799217, 0.03758130595088005, -0.03458920121192932, -0.037038274109363556, -0.054688114672899246, 0.01751277595758438, -0.042927756905555725, 0.024148130789399147, 0.0012828829931095243, -0.027559256181120872, -0.0747205913066864, 0.004766176454722881, -0.028882473707199097, -0.04060451313853264, 0.01534762978553772, 0.0483691468834877, 0.03654920682311058, -0.019208820536732674, 0.04778839647769928, 0.01257354486733675, 0.02515438012778759, 0.01999719627201557, -0.05811478570103645, -0.03347371891140938, 0.032311610877513885, -0.024926302954554558, -0.024608254432678223, -0.01897551119327545, -0.005275374744087458, -0.02987043373286724, 0.022814320400357246, 0.053100500255823135, -0.015282775275409222, -0.004779747221618891, -0.049049053341150284, 0.047537911683321, -0.012615494430065155, -0.05492785945534706, -0.062467336654663086, -0.012334944680333138, -0.021555490791797638, 0.021069321781396866, -0.027871323749423027, -0.03919500485062599, -0.06631600856781006, 0.017215294763445854, -0.0820707380771637, -0.005158264189958572, -0.013579240068793297, 0.0653705820441246, -0.019797492772340775, -0.016790159046649933, -0.033274486660957336, -0.028862277045845985, 0.028993546962738037, -0.06299027800559998, 0.007627754006534815, 0.005474666133522987, 0.04318638890981674, 0.018639344722032547, -0.058759208768606186, -0.010159393772482872, 0.0576440654695034, -0.005445169284939766, 0.02058621682226658, -0.018951384350657463, 0.01756780780851841, -0.02381778694689274, 0.0331248939037323, 0.045768845826387405, 0.004537792410701513, 0.030200375244021416, -0.057531822472810745, 0.02206508442759514, -0.04545934125781059, -0.059801675379276276, 0.04429567977786064, -0.03459758311510086, -0.0003869681095238775, -0.022116705775260925, 0.033669088035821915, -0.046266358345746994, -0.05369587242603302, -0.045795418322086334, 0.024305731058120728, 0.021356772631406784, -0.06205952167510986, 0.05200714245438576, -0.014779062010347843, -0.02586127258837223, -0.036020416766405106, 0.005515003576874733, -0.033062633126974106, 0.024030307307839394, 0.03623276948928833, -0.039849653840065, -0.040790315717458725, -0.036171864718198776, -0.03097163513302803, -0.032365523278713226, -0.003964618314057589, -0.007740360219031572, 0.04351106286048889, -0.0038965221028774977, -0.016914550215005875, -0.04537428542971611, -0.06132877990603447, -0.03531917929649353, -0.07041080296039581, -0.0424349308013916, -0.02903185412287712, 0.028443630784749985, -0.0023591818753629923, 0.02809981256723404, -0.021438082680106163, 0.039943501353263855, 0.046874068677425385, 0.03725801780819893, 0.019715165719389915, 0.004779564216732979, -0.032101552933454514, 0.06057129055261612, 0.01249140128493309, -0.005973821971565485, -0.025469286367297173, 0.01827140338718891, -0.008389939554035664, -0.013192899525165558, 0.019136108458042145, -0.008215382695198059, 0.003692678874358535, -0.06677425652742386, -0.017400085926055908, 0.03130031004548073, 0.009971912950277328, -0.046574223786592484, 0.00911196693778038, 0.019573833793401718, -0.007911811582744122, -0.07120513916015625 ]
This paper develops a new vascular respiratory motion compensation algorithm, Motion-Related Compensation (MRC), to conduct vascular respiratory motion compensation by extrapolating the correlation between invisible vascular and visible non-vascular. Robot-assisted vascular intervention can significantly reduce the radiation exposure of surgeons. In robot-assisted image-guided intervention, blood vessels are constantly moving/deforming due to respiration, and they are invisible in the X-ray images unless contrast agents are injected. The vascular respiratory motion compensation technique predicts 2D vascular roadmaps in live X-ray images. When blood vessels are visible after contrast agents injection, vascular respiratory motion compensation is conducted based on the sparse Lucas-Kanade feature tracker. An MRC model is trained to learn the correlation between vascular and non-vascular motions. During the intervention, the invisible blood vessels are predicted with visible tissues and the trained MRC model. Moreover, a Gaussian-based outlier filter is adopted for refinement. Experiments on in-vivo data sets show that the proposed method can yield vascular respiratory motion compensation in 0.032 sec, with an average error 1.086 mm. Our real-time and accurate vascular respiratory motion compensation approach contributes to modern vascular intervention and surgical robots.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.16451v1
[ -0.028791377320885658, -0.03409285098314285, 0.01264803297817707, 0.012747066095471382, 0.0010348053183406591, -0.03403580188751221, -0.02422158047556877, -0.016545027494430542, 0.006854847073554993, -0.041544098407030106, -0.036616258323192596, -0.005010947119444609, -0.02894376963376999, -0.029257815331220627, -0.03829275071620941, 0.035026032477617264, 0.06500589102506638, 0.023996476083993912, -0.018236225470900536, 0.058691371232271194, 0.006008677650243044, -0.03714067488908768, -0.016895711421966553, 0.022229578346014023, -0.015380638651549816, -0.05170367285609245, -0.009206769987940788, 0.030140351504087448, -0.06488469988107681, 0.033177699893713, 0.06902280449867249, -0.057449281215667725, 0.012305498123168945, -0.021868767216801643, -0.02261638455092907, 0.052058130502700806, -0.013385608792304993, 0.01983891986310482, -0.00775862718001008, -0.022086475044488907, 0.04470103234052658, -0.03435658663511276, -0.012384132482111454, -0.01276552863419056, -0.03104558400809765, -0.04394769296050072, -0.0378534197807312, -0.014398994855582714, -0.03139536455273628, -0.02281831204891205, 0.03671679645776749, 0.030130989849567413, -0.026726694777607918, 0.0530799999833107, -0.05671798810362816, -0.0011790592689067125, -0.020028190687298775, 0.018353339284658432, -0.05079294741153717, -0.0019375639967620373, 0.00004891708886134438, 0.0058097029104828835, 0.029690856114029884, -0.013501536101102829, -0.010118620470166206, 0.06995362788438797, -0.03209527209401131, -0.05775584280490875, -0.0390189066529274, -0.06523627787828445, 0.029882509261369705, -0.04343751445412636, 0.06937432289123535, 0.041071757674217224, 0.0040555982850492, -0.03462780639529228, -0.028554638847708702, -0.02835526131093502, 0.016017522662878036, -0.02503618411719799, -0.0130312480032444, 0.03976922482252121, 0.0027940089348703623, 0.06106637045741081, 0.023029815405607224, -0.034138601273298264, 0.030207540839910507, -0.03044745698571205, -0.007059888448566198, -0.07017818093299866, 0.03184721618890762, -0.06973975896835327, -0.016441520303487778, 0.008039184845983982, 0.04146668314933777, -0.046141255646944046, 0.05150095000863075, 0.035952769219875336, 0.014051364734768867, 0.021638130769133568, -0.00017610169015824795, 0.05910370871424675, 0.026936808601021767, 0.026300674304366112, 0.04430149123072624, -0.049755752086639404, -0.00324737629853189, 0.002472285646945238, -0.008285295218229294, -0.031291812658309937, -0.055060211569070816, -0.03637887164950371, 0.03292782977223396, -0.06625163555145264, -0.04160146042704582, -0.058143436908721924, 0.053750962018966675, -0.034583818167448044, 0.03392186760902405, 0.0061471895314753056, -0.05521007999777794, 0.03652837127447128, 0.006806647405028343, -0.014850394800305367, 0.020505299791693687, -0.008707541041076183, 0.0970190167427063, -0.0014315363951027393, -0.036472663283348083, -0.02133774943649769, 0.015827752649784088, 0.01419176533818245, -0.05298815295100212, -0.0004982008831575513, 0.0007587982108816504, 0.0015576076693832874, 0.04157943278551102, 0.007632303982973099, 0.030893433839082718, -0.01654326729476452, -0.009365293197333813, -0.003732323180884123, 0.0491478256881237, -0.018645795062184334, 0.009131588973104954, 0.04276955500245094, -0.056875549256801605, -0.018592610955238342, 0.028331315144896507, 0.028735918924212456, 0.014792770147323608, -0.025113919749855995, 0.05017691105604172, 0.054458778351545334, -0.00028202231624163687, -0.019441794604063034, 0.06651590764522552, 0.032174158841371536, -0.009032795205712318, -0.0024177515879273415, 0.01816101372241974, -0.019281307235360146, 0.05086083710193634, -0.0225420743227005, 0.039808280766010284, -0.018964124843478203, 0.041221607476472855, 0.015198125503957272, 0.02162143960595131, 0.023446977138519287, -0.03612348437309265, -0.05373600125312805, 0.013628210872411728, 0.01952500082552433, -0.022443274036049843, -0.04106420651078224, 0.03246220946311951, -0.03141915425658226, -0.03412796929478645, 0.005166176240891218, -0.02925628423690796, 0.0071060494519770145, 0.006241655442863703, -0.0037312449421733618, -0.06980743259191513, -0.07241459935903549, -0.09847782552242279, -0.010694816708564758, 0.03330265358090401, 0.030467933043837547, -0.06197825446724892, -0.06547459214925766, 0.036070216447114944, 0.009448215365409851, -0.013565991073846817, -0.02268300950527191, -0.04969640448689461, -0.017406534403562546, -0.004428505897521973, 0.056448400020599365, -0.07870259135961533, -0.026382876560091972, -0.08614390343427658, 0.013420755043625832, -0.017519451677799225, -0.07997697591781616, -0.015552627854049206, 0.024569975212216377, -0.018517306074500084, -0.017393173649907112, -0.0006323030102066696, -0.0017246708739548922, 0.042821891605854034, 0.04112092778086662, 0.03462982550263405, -0.002873595803976059, -0.1146107167005539, 0.03781074658036232, -0.02783394232392311, -0.005076754372566938, 0.038567595183849335, 0.005539503879845142, -0.017402958124876022, -0.024627765640616417, -0.0471225269138813, 0.02825738675892353, 0.024225277826189995, -0.028128549456596375, -0.05621138960123062, -0.01983031816780567, 0.005622985772788525, -0.04581250622868538, -0.0013231603661552072, -0.03950731083750725, -0.036311160773038864, -0.020648621022701263, -0.03543860465288162, -0.0010742421727627516, 0.02625131420791149, -0.010363391600549221, -0.05458870902657509, -0.024008145555853844, 0.05821865051984787, -0.004381557460874319, -0.06875891238451004, -0.027759529650211334, -0.0429946631193161, -0.01273454912006855, -0.005909510422497988, 0.012105816043913364, -0.01833820343017578, -0.02038574405014515, -0.003085206262767315, -0.02310829423367977, 0.05550481379032135, 0.058341775089502335, -0.02356738969683647, -0.015078089199960232, -0.0326877124607563, 0.007497033104300499, 0.01485392265021801, 0.031006785109639168, -0.07102497667074203, -0.0023890789598226547, 0.00092995137674734, 0.0018658287590369582, 0.0021438333205878735, -0.003973739687353373, 0.015061996877193451, -0.025875147432088852, 0.02816866524517536, 0.014560358598828316, 0.023308923467993736, -0.018809258937835693, -0.03375105559825897, 0.016589932143688202, -0.03661293536424637, -0.058196861296892166, 0.023129070177674294, 0.02877829410135746, 0.01736072264611721, 0.019169265404343605, 0.05809227377176285, -0.07200395315885544, 0.006582997739315033, -0.06652846187353134, 0.018864963203668594, -0.05423097312450409, -0.06607954949140549, 0.017206119373440742, -0.06005252152681351, -0.013132580555975437, -0.04985661432147026, 0.03891335427761078, -0.03130047395825386, -0.01651339791715145, -0.034636590629816055, 0.009405328892171383, 0.05354601889848709, -0.009864105843007565, -0.04459401220083237, -0.00408585648983717, 0.01765523850917816, 0.0314713716506958, 0.01237241830676794, -0.009109396487474442, -0.0359148308634758, 0.029487738385796547, 0.010534279979765415, 0.02336765266954899, 0.015420188196003437, 0.02383609488606453, -0.03350760415196419, 0.0047179036773741245, 0.002721187425777316, 0.006291897501796484, 0.0396156907081604, -0.044725049287080765, 0.013516739942133427, -0.04476802051067352, -0.001152687007561326, -0.03663434833288193, 0.003333830973133445, -0.017649447545409203, -0.05417969450354576, -0.021331410855054855, 0.04931386187672615, 0.047767866402864456, -0.008707410655915737, -0.02930356375873089, 0.009012797847390175, -0.01087700854986906, -0.029856182634830475, 0.00795062817633152, 0.04477844759821892, -0.007782785687595606, -0.038701288402080536, 0.01574740745127201, -0.006637279409915209, 0.02455230802297592, -0.04434671998023987, 0.012717917561531067, -0.012901059351861477, -0.0022751889191567898, 0.01985195279121399, -0.08517701178789139, -0.025795837864279747, 0.014866720885038376, 0.0665939673781395, -0.011248118244111538, -0.009738382883369923, 0.005039899609982967, -0.001261316705495119, 0.017267907038331032, -0.012869030237197876, 0.05510156601667404, 0.032697562128305435, 0.03967514634132385, -0.03275149315595627, -0.05977320671081543, 0.024338245391845703, -0.08461535722017288, -0.08076250553131104, 0.028843482956290245, 0.029564497992396355, 0.00682953791692853, 0.054827310144901276, -0.07676194608211517, 0.042699191719293594, -0.02928859181702137, 0.007355483248829842, -0.006030524615198374, -0.03547772765159607, -0.010060189291834831, -0.01853768154978752, 0.01921207457780838, 0.013015331700444221, 0.01431950367987156, -0.00578668899834156, -0.04490583389997482, 0.033860258758068085, -0.03045753575861454, 0.02475452795624733, 0.011940186843276024, -0.000016140160369104706, 0.04638483002781868, 0.04946446418762207, -0.018515488132834435, 0.014208164997398853, -0.02385871671140194, -0.015330134890973568, -0.026563486084342003, -0.057669200003147125, -0.002301999367773533, 0.0005954296793788671, -0.058645471930503845, -0.020474104210734367, -0.013428887352347374, 0.0082272132858634, 0.010475242510437965, -0.009149467572569847, 0.005495865363627672, -0.04966844245791435, -0.08898293972015381, -0.005313660018146038, -0.05667439103126526, 0.0721658319234848, 0.043735571205616, -0.04938925430178642, 0.06791700422763824, -0.03347437456250191, -0.0010501834331080317, -0.02407403290271759, -0.003959247842431068, 0.003602675860747695, -0.06886804103851318, 0.0008973662625066936, -0.03616275638341904, 0.03140895441174507, -0.04363490268588066, 0.05616801604628563, 0.0277605801820755, 0.022577108815312386, -0.04536972939968109, -0.03267072141170502, -0.015254276804625988, -0.0006985762156546116, 0.05133290961384773, 0.015275982208549976, 0.00946159940212965, -0.012487687170505524, -0.027291536331176758, -0.023436451330780983, -0.038221798837184906, -0.01652672328054905, -0.04651188850402832, 0.03200545907020569, -0.02548285387456417, -0.03484920412302017, 0.010918538086116314, -0.022051166743040085, 0.03566211834549904, 0.017791250720620155, -0.011026849038898945, 0.01122127752751112, 0.008771552704274654, -0.05391436815261841, -0.0612495131790638, -0.06149078905582428, -0.04634389281272888, -0.058994047343730927, -0.0012374920770525932, 0.014819593168795109, 0.0034376203548163176, 0.006944397930055857, 0.06440258771181107, 0.08582405745983124, 0.009049750864505768, -0.0636076107621193, 0.017248036339879036, 0.024866975843906403, 0.038959164172410965, -0.004822323098778725, -0.03556513786315918, -0.07181473821401596, -0.0090730469673872, -0.006204761099070311, -0.009714990854263306, -0.04005492106080055, 0.0759163349866867, 0.006402117200195789, -0.009058726020157337, -0.09056063741445541, 0.05661050230264664, 0.031104285269975662, -0.03257225453853607, 0.02070908434689045, 0.027455970644950867, -0.0006020023138262331, 0.0636289045214653, -0.010786285623908043, 0.04902678728103638, -0.018611451610922813, -0.026911495253443718, -0.031899597495794296, -0.01769799180328846, -0.0020895034540444613, -0.0006115790456533432, 0.021268215030431747, -0.019849246367812157, -0.03624813258647919, 0.002329442650079727, 0.0008720330079086125, -0.012792742811143398, -0.003201051615178585, 0.002731122076511383, 0.06404426693916321, -0.04189479351043701, -0.03576454892754555, 0.024124179035425186, 0.015875767916440964, 0.037016451358795166, 0.07499565929174423, -0.02939656190574169, 0.020514052361249924, 0.0265775378793478, 0.01324758492410183, -0.006570898462086916, 0.06763181835412979, 0.0009941437747329473, -0.005274984519928694, 0.009355942718684673, 0.031948164105415344, -0.024888256564736366, -0.03044678084552288, -0.038802944123744965, 0.0022875682916492224, 0.0456915982067585, 0.05620255321264267, 0.0704789087176323, -0.01558281946927309, -0.006759946700185537, -0.06105939298868179, -0.009111867286264896, -0.05637664720416069, 0.03318818658590317, -0.05600422993302345, 0.05017613247036934, -0.018175730481743813, 0.019957059994339943, -0.011375983245670795, 0.02949969656765461, 0.03653072193264961, -0.0010486663086339831, -0.006715888157486916, -0.06459533423185349, 0.03748546168208122, -0.045337382704019547, -0.08076422661542892, 0.029707686975598335, 0.04177260771393776, -0.033342260867357254, 0.03460345044732094, 0.042836517095565796, 0.01646951213479042, 0.05325513705611229, -0.020291363820433617, -0.01624811813235283, -0.029783999547362328, 0.02107428014278412, 0.0731884241104126, -0.043425481766462326, -0.005551273934543133, 0.0013389417435973883, -0.01928720250725746, -0.01626744121313095, -0.022954853251576424, 0.018395425751805305, -0.009959214366972446, 0.009821578860282898, -0.05011683329939842, 0.03821825981140137, 0.024759646505117416, -0.06478576362133026, 0.00504458649083972, 0.020294316112995148, -0.04447842389345169, 0.00438420195132494, 0.0390533022582531, -0.01177143957465887, -0.03499995917081833, 0.019593264907598495, -0.02074648253619671, -0.01338062435388565, -0.06581012904644012, 0.044427573680877686, 0.06730522960424423, -0.011720714159309864, -0.046274732798337936, 0.019376734271645546, -0.04840121418237686, 0.03400469571352005, -0.062101900577545166, 0.025694191455841064, 0.04894305393099785, 0.02483830228447914, 0.03692658990621567, -0.042834196239709854, -0.03738093003630638, 0.06382962316274643, -0.04672086611390114, 0.024019815027713776, -0.004974651150405407, -0.011249514296650887, 0.08274297416210175, 0.00563004007562995, 0.025928126648068428, 0.01718718744814396, -0.054758742451667786, -0.010724852792918682, 0.016405969858169556, -0.0003095217398367822, 0.025511357933282852, 0.01661999709904194, 0.0381951667368412, -0.040976088494062424, 0.01792871206998825, -0.02605384774506092, -0.035073015838861465, 0.015231359750032425, -0.07022233307361603, 0.0002716120798140764, -0.02374919317662716, 0.032996565103530884, 0.023463549092411995, 0.05850302055478096, -0.05739814043045044, -0.002522725146263838, -0.009102636016905308, 0.03587177023291588, 0.047291580587625504, 0.011971777305006981, 0.027393806725740433, 0.008297791704535484, 0.046773117035627365, -0.00047768111107870936, -0.006014188751578331, 0.007780849933624268, -0.05424797162413597, 0.045063942670822144, -0.015463646501302719, -0.028868431225419044, -0.054090481251478195, -0.0032986581791192293, -0.0231963898986578, 0.03266403451561928, 0.006361824460327625, -0.03002968616783619, -0.04328116774559021, 0.04403628036379814, -0.011983610689640045, -0.02360164001584053, 0.030963780358433723, -0.015847692266106606, -0.017462240532040596, -0.014956392347812653, 0.008732479065656662, 0.022184835746884346, -0.048968635499477386, -0.00027656517340801656, -0.07494834065437317, -0.04297959432005882, 0.04157594218850136, 0.0012893108651041985, -0.03546757623553276, 0.010614174418151379, -0.005341067910194397, -0.04738389328122139, 0.04125511646270752, 0.0690973773598671, 0.03137067332863808, 0.008043399080634117, -0.05339102819561958, 0.030551772564649582, -0.004064847249537706, 0.02815927192568779, -0.032497160136699677, -0.01850139908492565, -0.004429997876286507, -0.03167665749788284, -0.023596061393618584, 0.0304554533213377, -0.0789957046508789, -0.01363817322999239, -0.09975594282150269, -0.03027544729411602, -0.03876917064189911, 0.053920213133096695, -0.046165335923433304, -0.0689096450805664, -0.03556694835424423, -0.059817276895046234, 0.0326152965426445, 0.004522112663835287, -0.01882767863571644, -0.031613726168870926, 0.05693430453538895, -0.0057145822793245316, -0.08680959790945053, -0.02708275057375431, 0.012286294251680374, 0.03067106194794178, 0.052794042974710464, 0.04742470011115074, 0.06192396581172943, -0.002027982845902443, 0.0053609926253557205, 0.025715341791510582, 0.029061753302812576, 0.0410296730697155, -0.045107100158929825, 0.0026351213455200195, -0.026427388191223145, -0.017713936045765877, -0.014877429232001305, -0.04190029948949814, 0.028785083442926407, -0.01379853393882513, -0.02240872010588646, -0.0016308851772919297, -0.036746442317962646, -0.02338462509214878, 0.06292512267827988, -0.009982227347791195, 0.024687832221388817, 0.010334039106965065, -0.055269964039325714, -0.015646081417798996, 0.008630470372736454, -0.032016463577747345, -0.049195513129234314, 0.04125578701496124, 0.03362654522061348, -0.013969393447041512, 0.028335412964224815, -0.055527109652757645, 0.011905863881111145, -0.016842907294631004, 0.018993018195033073, 0.023850789293646812, 0.047038737684488297, 0.03433318808674812, -0.013366878032684326, -0.02156696282327175, -0.06486876308917999, 0.0350986123085022, -0.002925324719399214, -0.006376280914992094, 0.020872026681900024, -0.01635739393532276, -0.036185238510370255, 0.05142512544989586, 0.01391464564949274, 0.0258274395018816, 0.05897875130176544, 0.031876131892204285, -0.027889369055628777, -0.029470615088939667, -0.028171874582767487, 0.050942156463861465, -0.007257733028382063, 0.016354568302631378, -0.05344116687774658, 0.009558333083987236, 0.000906177912838757, 0.04913494363427162, -0.0026463146787136793, 0.018413320183753967, 0.02687947265803814, -0.07697359472513199, -0.012526256032288074, 0.04964827001094818, 0.005728205665946007, -0.02318819984793663, -0.034232769161462784, 0.0024709636345505714, -0.03741177171468735, -0.07261624932289124 ]
Topic modeling is admittedly a convenient way to monitor markets trend. Conventionally, Latent Dirichlet Allocation, LDA, is considered a must-do model to gain this type of information. By given the merit of deducing keyword with token conditional probability in LDA, we can know the most possible or essential topic. However, the results are not intuitive because the given topics cannot wholly fit human knowledge. LDA offers the first possible relevant keywords, which also brings out another problem of whether the connection is reliable based on the statistic possibility. It is also hard to decide the topic number manually in advance. As the booming trend of using fuzzy membership to cluster and using transformers to embed words, this work presents the fuzzy topic modeling based on soft clustering and document embedding from state-of-the-art transformer-based model. In our practical application in a press release monitoring, the fuzzy topic modeling gives a more natural result than the traditional output from LDA.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09658v1
[ -0.0007362361648119986, -0.0018209023401141167, 0.03992326185107231, 0.011063761077821255, 0.037435226142406464, -0.004247292410582304, -0.029318666085600853, -0.026966700330376625, -0.030413514003157616, -0.022179707884788513, -0.04358727112412453, -0.02222483977675438, -0.05639776214957237, -0.05926479771733284, -0.01656617783010006, -0.0068599386140704155, 0.07885397970676422, 0.019606782123446465, -0.044919636100530624, 0.017944330349564552, -0.02885221689939499, 0.019903162494301796, -0.03353552892804146, 0.021908408030867577, 0.019160930067300797, -0.007026993669569492, -0.04026910290122032, -0.0295502208173275, -0.045059483498334885, -0.016124028712511063, 0.030804544687271118, -0.01846497133374214, -0.018235918134450912, -0.038716819137334824, -0.06944861263036728, -0.03383573889732361, 0.014500634744763374, -0.02724245935678482, 0.024404184892773628, -0.061272189021110535, 0.01604999601840973, -0.029192928224802017, -0.0640198290348053, -0.0026811405550688505, -0.026482634246349335, 0.028022611513733864, -0.047000471502542496, 0.0576089471578598, -0.06694760918617249, -0.026438508182764053, 0.029679419472813606, -0.02931513451039791, 0.0011291400296613574, -0.007816537283360958, -0.03479226306080818, -0.009059187024831772, 0.032103583216667175, 0.042492885142564774, -0.07297132164239883, 0.00045658217277377844, 0.027038121595978737, -0.02703225426375866, -0.00041169842006638646, -0.018255315721035004, -0.025118818506598473, 0.022369634360074997, 0.013877371326088905, -0.05735541880130768, -0.03444477170705795, -0.06253355741500854, 0.04445316269993782, -0.06476765125989914, 0.013025474734604359, 0.009653606452047825, -0.0033532287925481796, -0.030143186450004578, -0.03449058532714844, -0.006296205800026655, -0.009530977346003056, 0.000652173301205039, 0.003311720909550786, 0.026232311502099037, 0.021268775686621666, 0.0021879044361412525, -0.02100767195224762, -0.04001036286354065, 0.06888620555400848, -0.021616805344820023, 0.001275481772609055, -0.05618639290332794, 0.047621265053749084, -0.06618382036685944, -0.07973767071962357, -0.0012807940365746617, 0.06321283429861069, -0.021558037027716637, 0.0639120489358902, 0.010401357896625996, 0.004994655959308147, -0.016168618574738503, 0.0052673243917524815, -0.002061157487332821, -0.05100604146718979, 0.03638314828276634, 0.028732314705848694, -0.02249958924949169, 0.03542953357100487, -0.00463335495442152, -0.04152020439505577, 0.0024639067705720663, -0.059550948441028595, -0.015262442640960217, -0.0033529819920659065, -0.0285663865506649, -0.04708850011229515, -0.014551267959177494, 0.04296327009797096, 0.011053142137825489, 0.028985951095819473, 0.01475941389799118, -0.025570139288902283, 0.02183198183774948, 0.04299366474151611, -0.0061155701987445354, -0.037750545889139175, -0.037482112646102905, 0.04003065079450607, 0.002447182312607765, -0.004928009118884802, -0.026286637410521507, -0.04994824156165123, -0.0008754911832511425, 0.01818019710481167, -0.004689461085945368, 0.06736655533313751, 0.053878653794527054, -0.036291103810071945, -0.0824139267206192, 0.03200838342308998, 0.00005557757322094403, -0.03495588153600693, -0.05654224008321762, 0.0421643927693367, -0.039233509451150894, -0.017213022336363792, 0.057764939963817596, -0.015479802154004574, -0.027483902871608734, 0.021179061383008957, 0.01524324994534254, -0.015471940860152245, 0.0011697416193783283, 0.034182578325271606, 0.03768032416701317, 0.0018045388860628009, -0.014795437455177307, 0.005597244016826153, -0.024893151596188545, -0.05355808138847351, 0.010020079091191292, 0.032516129314899445, 0.0030223627109080553, 0.010811633430421352, -0.04754779487848282, 0.03377346694469452, -0.013064062222838402, 0.04395032301545143, -0.006143289618194103, -0.036716528236866, -0.02617098018527031, 0.008958705700933933, 0.001411008764989674, 0.012290457263588905, -0.0418366938829422, -0.04346771910786629, -0.001227125758305192, 0.026286762207746506, -0.03846830502152443, -0.004817282315343618, -0.013701836578547955, -0.008544671349227428, 0.02052708901464939, -0.05977880582213402, -0.03840509057044983, -0.02136208489537239, 0.01834738440811634, -0.07379936426877975, -0.03418683260679245, 0.030171338468790054, 0.04235580936074257, -0.05283891782164574, 0.01547101978212595, -0.007572670932859182, 0.004271981306374073, 0.012681448832154274, -0.011850581504404545, 0.028156518936157227, -0.0011730390833690763, 0.014955835416913033, 0.03730694204568863, -0.0788891389966011, -0.03886134922504425, -0.0677870512008667, 0.005322122946381569, -0.03390126675367355, -0.024636153131723404, -0.008444924838840961, 0.01720878668129444, -0.051352135837078094, 0.019026607275009155, 0.05902128294110298, 0.08043728768825531, 0.05785384029150009, 0.036864712834358215, 0.06328870356082916, 0.027417222037911415, -0.1069074496626854, 0.030749153345823288, -0.009393518790602684, 0.011425402015447617, 0.040871087461709976, 0.05102593079209328, 0.03255322203040123, 0.010528339073061943, 0.005547560751438141, 0.05236301198601723, 0.05814061686396599, 0.009972753934562206, -0.0448397696018219, -0.0329790897667408, -0.007482175249606371, -0.060049571096897125, -0.012618460692465305, -0.05252058058977127, -0.015263233333826065, -0.01583925634622574, -0.050763089209795, 0.03509526699781418, 0.008392768912017345, 0.0018475139513611794, -0.04619671776890755, -0.030597150325775146, 0.033087439835071564, -0.0034688464365899563, -0.04712235927581787, -0.04412563517689705, 0.00808694213628769, 0.03989040106534958, -0.028476517647504807, 0.006710199173539877, -0.027229223400354385, -0.0780634805560112, -0.0270873811095953, 0.014366344548761845, 0.004410366527736187, 0.04762876033782959, -0.043963123112916946, 0.014294907450675964, 0.020496809855103493, 0.02133074589073658, 0.041944101452827454, 0.061655301600694656, -0.03740520775318146, 0.004500396549701691, 0.0469544492661953, -0.050591640174388885, 0.002039192942902446, 0.01930171810090542, -0.004279084503650665, -0.02533838339149952, 0.029028071090579033, 0.056563347578048706, 0.041554082185029984, 0.03436490148305893, -0.056999415159225464, -0.010051892139017582, 0.024431314319372177, 0.0005776903126388788, 0.03561747446656227, 0.05382679030299187, 0.033610615879297256, 0.044693946838378906, 0.006155397742986679, -0.053450845181941986, -0.015085096471011639, -0.061700258404016495, -0.03830764442682266, -0.08469695597887039, -0.04463161900639534, -0.025753816589713097, -0.07745149731636047, 0.0041370936669409275, -0.014284975826740265, -0.03798655793070793, 0.007838433608412743, -0.055741772055625916, -0.01592453569173813, 0.028846805915236473, 0.04334845021367073, -0.011411008425056934, -0.06304769963026047, -0.02104721963405609, 0.027040788903832436, -0.011834925971925259, 0.009199989959597588, -0.05966609716415405, -0.04845239222049713, -0.02199544943869114, 0.02035941556096077, 0.03522198274731636, -0.02322288230061531, 0.0069534326903522015, 0.018933042883872986, 0.054537899792194366, 0.0008787476690486073, 0.03382321819663048, 0.03600981831550598, 0.01718124933540821, -0.011740350164473057, 0.006262544542551041, 0.014340803027153015, -0.0007823294145055115, -0.04385542869567871, -0.057330865412950516, -0.034564804285764694, -0.04824328422546387, 0.03751824051141739, 0.004375140182673931, -0.011558989994227886, -0.007984357886016369, -0.0026330396067351103, 0.01292723324149847, 0.0175977423787117, 0.015864677727222443, 0.038904786109924316, 0.02871682494878769, -0.04512126371264458, -0.06526801735162735, 0.0033217628952115774, -0.03486280143260956, 0.0006344871362671256, 0.03750010207295418, -0.04252062737941742, -0.009378444403409958, 0.04192279651761055, -0.0914020761847496, 0.019166599959135056, 0.05552004650235176, 0.04781154915690422, -0.019825605675578117, 0.024794921278953552, 0.004948335234075785, 0.023623069748282433, 0.0274767205119133, 0.007657733745872974, 0.018839962780475616, 0.031987398862838745, 0.014522883109748363, -0.045511286705732346, -0.039986930787563324, 0.002014584606513381, -0.06965183466672897, -0.030407436192035675, -0.010034398175776005, 0.0013745526084676385, -0.002826035488396883, -0.002522453898563981, -0.023448139429092407, 0.0218681488186121, 0.014845583587884903, 0.05701402574777603, -0.011241616681218147, -0.04318389296531677, 0.060580138117074966, -0.052175115793943405, 0.009313362650573254, 0.039153650403022766, 0.0074440473690629005, 0.015134840272367, -0.03132465109229088, 0.0005592521047219634, -0.0468437522649765, 0.05483422428369522, 0.024853531271219254, 0.003048081649467349, 0.002445851219817996, 0.05238770693540573, -0.028218718245625496, 0.06246021017432213, -0.02569258213043213, -0.0385967381298542, 0.016998417675495148, 0.016891710460186005, -0.019462483003735542, 0.04335787147283554, -0.07235751301050186, 0.004484571050852537, 0.030224232003092766, 0.0013526001712307334, 0.017017843201756477, -0.006757143419235945, -0.027380917221307755, -0.01944085769355297, -0.09354731440544128, 0.015193588100373745, -0.030313005670905113, 0.03429695591330528, 0.011504458263516426, -0.07632296532392502, 0.06321323662996292, -0.021731192246079445, 0.00036367939901538193, -0.016166239976882935, -0.049637652933597565, -0.01445574127137661, -0.04120072349905968, -0.010087032802402973, -0.07083659619092941, 0.016932586207985878, -0.028415801003575325, 0.04814288392663002, 0.029082782566547394, -0.002826204290613532, -0.03195696324110031, -0.0572081059217453, 0.015968291088938713, 0.033271607011556625, 0.07368356734514236, 0.04780682548880577, -0.00775679899379611, -0.004724748432636261, 0.0081398980692029, -0.023950517177581787, 0.015571193769574165, -0.05819356068968773, 0.011619596742093563, 0.01816769316792488, -0.031724680215120316, 0.002086662221699953, -0.026986127719283104, -0.006160456221550703, 0.03665393590927124, -0.05468312278389931, -0.021399913355708122, 0.003844072110950947, 0.04475567489862442, -0.04535846784710884, -0.08436206728219986, 0.015309814363718033, -0.015469524078071117, -0.05748770013451576, 0.001348705729469657, 0.03655226156115532, 0.044852305203676224, 0.033403895795345306, 0.001643170602619648, -0.030567064881324768, 0.020042821764945984, 0.008165483362972736, 0.00024763154215179384, 0.018000353127717972, -0.02683674916625023, -0.0377139076590538, 0.004636315628886223, -0.07886110246181488, -0.025424061343073845, -0.019636280834674835, -0.0006888909847475588, 0.008496250957250595, 0.02318396419286728, -0.007057227659970522, 0.07717826217412949, -0.08139994740486145, -0.005705040413886309, 0.038904931396245956, -0.01577863283455372, -0.006023083813488483, 0.05530296638607979, -0.02563648857176304, 0.028646117076277733, -0.017735475674271584, 0.04938625171780586, -0.036267947405576706, -0.06483269482851028, -0.00588284432888031, -0.008976477198302746, 0.024279030039906502, -0.03303377330303192, 0.05519740283489227, -0.03464193269610405, -0.07804927974939346, 0.03714427351951599, 0.015220828354358673, 0.014297005720436573, -0.05132606253027916, 0.011917609721422195, 0.045826174318790436, -0.019883260130882263, -0.025569148361682892, -0.022583143785595894, 0.005466972943395376, 0.060565680265426636, 0.022357290610671043, -0.015944141894578934, -0.004999528639018536, -0.013524326495826244, -0.040150269865989685, 0.015802165493369102, 0.011449691839516163, -0.011791984550654888, 0.027231017127633095, -0.03442281112074852, 0.04482235386967659, -0.06264078617095947, 0.027743956074118614, -0.05447015166282654, 0.04883156716823578, 0.04565462842583656, 0.0028572932351380587, -0.008019654080271721, 0.00983456987887621, 0.013573044911026955, -0.0070708636194467545, -0.008840356953442097, -0.025953488424420357, 0.01677393540740013, -0.033523645251989365, 0.002400825032964349, -0.005458179861307144, 0.024016087874770164, 0.036889877170324326, 0.040738146752119064, 0.04188394173979759, 0.0015829087933525443, -0.003084974829107523, 0.0019416784634813666, 0.022447051480412483, -0.05768290162086487, -0.02701978199183941, 0.047158628702163696, 0.012614443898200989, -0.01564139872789383, 0.012456214986741543, 0.02289511077105999, -0.02352343499660492, 0.034646764397621155, 0.009335259906947613, -0.0307934507727623, -0.023767106235027313, -0.003914456814527512, 0.07627307623624802, -0.026005804538726807, -0.004306659568101168, 0.009847964160144329, -0.028309453278779984, -0.021201157942414284, -0.025638140738010406, 0.032698336988687515, 0.04949140176177025, 0.015111462213099003, -0.05106678605079651, 0.04158761352300644, 0.0021622334606945515, -0.07213776558637619, -0.007237835321575403, 0.046168003231287, -0.06892059743404388, -0.027307827025651932, 0.006026905030012131, 0.036133211106061935, -0.054585691541433334, 0.06200446933507919, 0.007425970397889614, 0.006885726936161518, -0.0348050519824028, 0.0725516602396965, 0.08727031946182251, -0.05659757927060127, -0.005775783210992813, 0.02175675332546234, -0.0692620649933815, 0.029588136821985245, -0.03473812714219093, 0.024016642943024635, 0.022783726453781128, 0.001970374258235097, 0.00506532983854413, -0.03195470944046974, -0.007263533305376768, 0.0686650350689888, -0.032837193459272385, -0.0025290753692388535, 0.0454089418053627, -0.0272980984300375, 0.036035507917404175, -0.04908697307109833, -0.05039054527878761, 0.03336311876773834, 0.001584132551215589, 0.019953671842813492, -0.0210883729159832, -0.019688287749886513, -0.006381244398653507, -0.024033190682530403, -0.025531494989991188, -0.07523365318775177, 0.01650156080722809, -0.02711145021021366, -0.07578212022781372, -0.013436999171972275, -0.05449378862977028, 0.014033523388206959, -0.021589867770671844, 0.030742857605218887, 0.04207765683531761, 0.06634683907032013, -0.05433933809399605, -0.05047641694545746, -0.012579645961523056, -0.012139013968408108, 0.007504378445446491, -0.016690274700522423, 0.00888077449053526, -0.03219437971711159, 0.003667964832857251, -0.052228063344955444, -0.03759217634797096, -0.013504081405699253, -0.056751083582639694, 0.04212621971964836, 0.024315785616636276, -0.022197997197508812, -0.008000464178621769, 0.035808391869068146, -0.0378761850297451, 0.03983347862958908, -0.026047145947813988, -0.045971520245075226, -0.06668037921190262, -0.035054754465818405, 0.002482157200574875, 0.038810115307569504, 0.023133670911192894, 0.030280012637376785, 0.052854981273412704, -0.03628671541810036, 0.02131694369018078, 0.0060845729894936085, 0.013019987381994724, 0.04957442358136177, -0.036537736654281616, -0.015567952767014503, 0.030196670442819595, -0.06024642661213875, -0.004880338907241821, -0.014290215447545052, -0.0005413745529949665, -0.06872928142547607, -0.006702236831188202, 0.04754423350095749, 0.006299394648522139, -0.04026542603969574, -0.05995569005608559, 0.0500093437731266, -0.003410481847822666, -0.048096731305122375, -0.036323949694633484, 0.04077046364545822, 0.03184058144688606, -0.03633514791727066, -0.018320754170417786, -0.006849245168268681, -0.04162631928920746, 0.008081942796707153, -0.09561385959386826, 0.018703363835811615, -0.025611812248826027, 0.012577549554407597, 0.003102129092440009, -0.039569515734910965, 0.039381928741931915, -0.032461442053318024, 0.00947018526494503, 0.0017807837575674057, 0.028311913833022118, 0.048850979655981064, 0.005212381482124329, 0.026509739458560944, -0.04991989582777023, -0.026456253603100777, 0.03928662836551666, -0.02116323821246624, -0.029832912608981133, 0.03718782961368561, 0.04145331680774689, 0.007663701195269823, 0.0013470537960529327, 0.06391974538564682, -0.04551645740866661, 0.026613499969244003, -0.040512196719646454, 0.025461383163928986, -0.033621206879615784, -0.06743798404932022, 0.04034033045172691, -0.05365673080086708, -0.020471813157200813, 0.009450145997107029, 0.0007730117649771273, 0.021851038560271263, -0.039539989084005356, -0.054243601858615875, 0.02530604600906372, -0.040284663438797, -0.03727692365646362, 0.057029444724321365, 0.00729774497449398, -0.017994360998272896, -0.009246459230780602, -0.05928942561149597, -0.026555953547358513, 0.03477286919951439, 0.045796651393175125, -0.02047744393348694, 0.013447140343487263, -0.08626274019479752, 0.03807247057557106, -0.022166719660162926, -0.010770497843623161, -0.029068466275930405, 0.057796910405159, -0.03187287598848343, -0.016033506020903587, 0.010523698292672634, -0.046681661158800125, -0.04224369674921036, -0.06685572117567062, -0.03255731612443924, -0.02429668977856636, 0.03833503648638725, -0.0013739895075559616, 0.01872585155069828, -0.0012262740638107061, 0.06554996967315674, -0.007431159261614084, 0.016797859221696854, 0.04355553165078163, -0.001661591581068933, -0.06764774769544601, 0.07493428885936737, 0.00022928224643692374, 0.0344366580247879, -0.03485383093357086, -0.013983231969177723, 0.03461785241961479, -0.03959396854043007, -0.0011996234534308314, 0.032124198973178864, 0.06882228702306747, -0.07149924337863922, -0.012333426624536514, -0.03375677019357681, 0.012285497039556503, -0.018736431375145912, -0.005506537389010191, 0.026655802503228188, -0.014242216944694519, -0.021471934393048286 ]
In this paper, a kinematically modular approach to robot control is presented. The method involves structures called Elementary Dynamic Actions and a network model combining these elements. With this control framework, a rich repertoire of movements can be generated by combination of basic modules. The problems of solving inverse kinematics, managing kinematic singularity and kinematic redundancy are avoided. The modular approach is robust against contact and physical interaction, which makes it particularly effective for contact-rich manipulation. Each kinematic module can be learned by Imitation Learning, thereby resulting in a modular learning strategy for robot control. The theoretical foundations and their real robot implementation are presented. Using a KUKA LBR iiwa14 robot, three tasks were considered: (1) generating a sequence of discrete movements, (2) generating a combination of discrete and rhythmic movements, and (3) a drawing and erasing task. The results obtained indicate that this modular approach has the potential to simplify the generation of a diverse range of robot actions.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15271v2
[ -0.013724329881370068, -0.028673216700553894, 0.06337835639715195, 0.0074572088196873665, 0.0033101572189480066, -0.03269701078534126, 0.02189554274082184, -0.0026338330935686827, 0.015373745933175087, -0.05666492506861687, -0.021575776860117912, -0.02487812377512455, -0.061289750039577484, -0.019807012751698494, -0.057513654232025146, 0.03316117823123932, 0.07282126694917679, 0.04746720939874649, -0.06371448934078217, 0.029933739453554153, 0.016157012432813644, -0.04782365262508392, -0.05335850268602371, 0.061510927975177765, 0.009563465602695942, -0.009530557319521904, -0.010781538672745228, 0.003609708044677973, -0.0246732234954834, -0.005907360464334488, 0.05629225820302963, 0.014277000911533833, 0.022522544488310814, -0.06046018749475479, -0.05129251629114151, 0.011973919346928596, -0.006774083711206913, -0.016499411314725876, 0.0573023222386837, -0.01381138525903225, 0.014108347706496716, -0.007354993838816881, -0.061521876603364944, 0.006063695996999741, 0.022808203473687172, -0.013322848826646805, -0.038887329399585724, -0.014370243065059185, -0.057059429585933685, -0.06311986595392227, -0.033569641411304474, 0.0010180504759773612, 0.01889384165406227, 0.04545329138636589, -0.06721358746290207, 0.02548140287399292, 0.009067537263035774, 0.022643625736236572, -0.04559655860066414, -0.014440737664699554, 0.029346488416194916, 0.021311456337571144, 0.01997615396976471, 0.011376557871699333, 0.016200706362724304, 0.038699958473443985, -0.034879617393016815, -0.00609643803909421, -0.017687993124127388, -0.022842276841402054, 0.044308681041002274, -0.07420089095830917, 0.046414993703365326, 0.002434121211990714, -0.037045516073703766, -0.06379140168428421, -0.04973651468753815, -0.04114757850766182, 0.0029001503717154264, -0.024339674040675163, 0.007641323376446962, 0.03832271322607994, 0.05235700309276581, 0.0013134562177583575, 0.022284258157014847, -0.029697783291339874, 0.04247739538550377, -0.05821759253740311, 0.0348576158285141, -0.053896550089120865, 0.06235179305076599, 0.0036830739118158817, -0.05955801531672478, 0.02048865333199501, 0.040391188114881516, -0.03768502175807953, 0.029210465028882027, 0.007324108853936195, -0.0073362961411476135, -0.03135344758629799, -0.028507310897111893, 0.020102066919207573, -0.05852637067437172, 0.05534950643777847, 0.025553517043590546, -0.024253981187939644, 0.030613353475928307, -0.01094902865588665, -0.01736581139266491, -0.023712363094091415, 0.0011940558906644583, 0.005931434221565723, 0.02618332765996456, -0.038204461336135864, -0.025740668177604675, -0.030307605862617493, 0.04619563743472099, 0.007600485347211361, -0.00643663015216589, -0.00611542072147131, -0.02297848090529442, 0.024583151564002037, -0.04536819830536842, 0.0011499638203531504, -0.04055401310324669, -0.0455288365483284, 0.05326789245009422, -0.0017919231904670596, -0.012564724311232567, -0.05620715394616127, -0.017732784152030945, -0.020420966669917107, -0.015186929143965244, -0.06230159476399422, 0.023151608183979988, -0.05004088580608368, -0.05260658636689186, -0.07498478889465332, 0.0664265975356102, -0.028565820306539536, -0.06680411100387573, -0.05764812231063843, 0.016217781230807304, -0.04491095244884491, 0.01302937138825655, 0.055293239653110504, -0.0628630593419075, -0.016268804669380188, 0.006290484685450792, 0.017233729362487793, 0.020633282139897346, -0.005312646273523569, -0.013404875993728638, 0.02817794308066368, 0.02606198750436306, -0.028317691758275032, 0.03999540954828262, -0.013214567676186562, -0.07278280705213547, -0.04360440373420715, 0.026018109172582626, -0.041330642998218536, 0.027204900979995728, -0.026329446583986282, -0.0022797416895627975, 0.03049110434949398, 0.06520533561706543, -0.01475532166659832, -0.031019534915685654, -0.037513285875320435, -0.018649360164999962, 0.04401306435465813, 0.026143552735447884, -0.029118938371539116, -0.05911828950047493, -0.03436848521232605, 0.006587862968444824, -0.043226372450590134, -0.02428671345114708, 0.01540672779083252, -0.019920609891414642, 0.015110793523490429, -0.008431492373347282, -0.010330863296985626, -0.05233846604824066, 0.013455811887979507, -0.05536768585443497, -0.032463591545820236, 0.050474103540182114, 0.04511868208646774, -0.026565082371234894, -0.04989628493785858, 0.05092422291636467, 0.020647361874580383, -0.05075787007808685, -0.05098332092165947, -0.02922753430902958, -0.03512304648756981, -0.02012449875473976, 0.04799738898873329, -0.0820617601275444, 0.024953771382570267, -0.06192793324589729, -0.01679900288581848, 0.024521594867110252, -0.07246905565261841, 0.06068553403019905, 0.0199816282838583, -0.033772196620702744, -0.01640375517308712, 0.027122246101498604, 0.02232990972697735, 0.06385798007249832, -0.02661997266113758, 0.020187685266137123, -0.02926945872604847, -0.09286940097808838, 0.020331591367721558, 0.033765219151973724, 0.031560081988573074, 0.060191597789525986, 0.0027993889525532722, 0.027053214609622955, -0.0436142161488533, -0.03377717733383179, 0.03927306830883026, 0.032779257744550705, -0.05179629474878311, -0.04786379262804985, -0.02615928091108799, -0.03650368005037308, -0.07146929204463959, -0.025728804990649223, -0.0497298464179039, -0.017809074372053146, -0.046614211052656174, -0.03612532466650009, 0.04371374845504761, 0.017601123079657555, -0.06504374742507935, -0.03069261461496353, -0.0034503384958952665, 0.04468809813261032, -0.048388563096523285, -0.04747023060917854, -0.04458657652139664, -0.03150517866015434, 0.029396792873740196, -0.04282797873020172, 0.03968670964241028, -0.03932937607169151, -0.036778971552848816, -0.007462756242603064, -0.005355357192456722, 0.04231078177690506, 0.06838110834360123, -0.06743206828832626, -0.006261548958718777, 0.020715024322271347, 0.018591556698083878, 0.0518294982612133, 0.025199010968208313, -0.06189243122935295, 0.017844833433628082, 0.0019149722065776587, 0.014581896364688873, -0.017430379986763, -0.05507786571979523, 0.009561586193740368, -0.04664689674973488, 0.0013580882223322988, -0.004475890658795834, 0.03216862678527832, -0.015419352799654007, -0.026875467970967293, 0.020618630573153496, 0.008034097962081432, -0.033635810017585754, -0.011994616128504276, 0.05220877006649971, 0.03438158705830574, -0.016434993594884872, -0.008274229243397713, -0.06911519169807434, -0.030579328536987305, -0.016343219205737114, -0.025649428367614746, -0.07655896991491318, -0.047688815742731094, -0.05027350038290024, -0.03663316369056702, -0.05469964072108269, -0.06731989234685898, -0.047351349145174026, -0.03174717724323273, -0.06481321901082993, -0.03649163618683815, 0.02120978571474552, -0.01511735375970602, -0.05745285749435425, -0.06477559357881546, 0.0027873313520103693, 0.010047892108559608, 0.023096254095435143, -0.020037870854139328, -0.06942302733659744, -0.02477073483169079, -0.0034196667838841677, 0.0017196672270074487, -0.0006385586457327008, 0.0017987245228141546, 0.026660069823265076, -0.04668670520186424, 0.019134683534502983, 0.00709504121914506, 0.023273907601833344, 0.03967555984854698, 0.042144082486629486, -0.013045350089669228, 0.004154093563556671, -0.02193063125014305, -0.02602878399193287, 0.014939824119210243, -0.03543711453676224, -0.024748669937253, -0.03297451138496399, 0.05108422413468361, 0.05340583622455597, -0.02387145161628723, -0.015276556834578514, 0.005427686497569084, -0.04437500983476639, 0.040049053728580475, -0.001265611033886671, 0.050228770822286606, 0.02038072794675827, -0.03750455006957054, -0.023277293890714645, -0.039291564375162125, 0.03484613075852394, -0.03197484090924263, -0.0016196247888728976, 0.014796800911426544, -0.00616198405623436, 0.0416967011988163, -0.08636121451854706, 0.02575838565826416, 0.054545141756534576, 0.05236571654677391, -0.05792099982500076, 0.025098605081439018, -0.0014898558147251606, 0.03701350837945938, 0.035457395017147064, -0.02837536670267582, 0.042886506766080856, 0.0455952063202858, 0.05695201829075813, -0.014773357659578323, -0.037071894854307175, 0.005094010382890701, -0.07863737642765045, -0.06818107515573502, -0.043593090027570724, 0.03684554249048233, 0.021764449775218964, 0.048247724771499634, -0.07224291563034058, 0.019175980240106583, 0.011495938524603844, 0.00907822698354721, 0.021675091236829758, -0.029152853414416313, 0.019867507740855217, -0.00014087634917814285, -0.022301845252513885, -0.05829658359289169, 0.029934311285614967, -0.05676409974694252, -0.03891395777463913, 0.018566392362117767, -0.06501906365156174, 0.03257264941930771, 0.010388434864580631, -0.01017461996525526, 0.03885013610124588, 0.006493732333183289, -0.030813900753855705, 0.06067284196615219, 0.0001233528455486521, -0.0009740969981066883, 0.020729543641209602, -0.02292555756866932, -0.02132480964064598, -0.05110844597220421, -0.05481673777103424, 0.009054978378117085, -0.015599159523844719, -0.013121483847498894, -0.046175431460142136, 0.03405874967575073, 0.01094096340239048, -0.018353156745433807, -0.08175241947174072, -0.01866309717297554, -0.04587055370211601, 0.01633540168404579, -0.010463634505867958, -0.046370238065719604, 0.07284989207983017, -0.01630912534892559, -0.0251635555177927, -0.005200767889618874, -0.012418067082762718, -0.03937743976712227, -0.04437217861413956, -0.02767404168844223, -0.07065527886152267, 0.003616220550611615, -0.01266095694154501, 0.05393333360552788, -0.018228569999337196, 0.04205503314733505, -0.036114685237407684, 0.0033856569789350033, 0.011861174367368221, 0.030053239315748215, 0.04210318997502327, 0.041831523180007935, 0.049489062279462814, -0.044118840247392654, 0.03124276176095009, 0.0008519015391357243, -0.04796265438199043, 0.0015996589791029692, 0.006381894927471876, 0.04181765764951706, -0.059895262122154236, -0.01949291117489338, 0.002772306092083454, 0.013606015592813492, 0.04589575156569481, -0.022697830572724342, -0.001659149071201682, -0.007532453630119562, 0.06706441193819046, -0.03715052083134651, -0.06423284858465195, -0.06015380099415779, -0.04384162276983261, -0.017064515501260757, -0.0038368827663362026, -0.01818356290459633, 0.052507899701595306, 0.03161628544330597, 0.022110676392912865, 0.029910821467638016, 0.004502628464251757, -0.01577032171189785, -0.011498923413455486, 0.03980402648448944, -0.016736960038542747, 0.04407394304871559, 0.006788950879126787, -0.07770969718694687, 0.05111119896173477, -0.016288353130221367, 0.030589299276471138, -0.027662524953484535, 0.06013005971908569, 0.01888425275683403, 0.010816860012710094, -0.08777789026498795, -0.015583794564008713, 0.029267210513353348, -0.015774527564644814, -0.007176396436989307, 0.04063808545470238, -0.05796247348189354, 0.027737613767385483, -0.036749064922332764, 0.02034367062151432, 0.009974595159292221, -0.01602473109960556, -0.025140894576907158, -0.005964061710983515, -0.021210921928286552, 0.025336453691124916, 0.04648217931389809, -0.043482456356287, -0.03542404994368553, 0.013356144540011883, 0.0028040630277246237, 0.018546156585216522, -0.047888677567243576, 0.054298434406518936, 0.047696903347969055, -0.04159463942050934, -0.048324104398489, 0.01928286999464035, -0.009408022277057171, -0.014366800896823406, 0.025961250066757202, -0.008833818137645721, 0.04546983540058136, 0.04056105762720108, 0.006267992313951254, 0.014242062345147133, -0.016489073634147644, 0.0049930764362216, 0.008800108917057514, -0.013248654082417488, -0.007742732763290405, -0.04020419716835022, -0.02960597723722458, -0.041247762739658356, 0.02800063043832779, -0.0018383784918114543, 0.021944426000118256, 0.030562955886125565, 0.03799363970756531, 0.024240268394351006, -0.036165039986371994, 0.03437909111380577, -0.03133445605635643, 0.05377478152513504, -0.04568757489323616, 0.018567387014627457, -0.026316624134778976, -0.007996096275746822, -0.017689678817987442, -0.007047765888273716, -0.00031705081346444786, -0.05527491122484207, -0.045848023146390915, -0.04894556477665901, -0.02794286049902439, -0.060425154864788055, -0.05256957560777664, 0.031728338450193405, 0.006640295498073101, -0.010974721051752567, 0.00952482782304287, 0.027976421639323235, -0.009350867941975594, 0.021881205961108208, 0.05014423280954361, 0.0168070700019598, -0.043258752673864365, -0.007812543772161007, 0.057502590119838715, -0.03134191408753395, -0.015618832781910896, -0.036866359412670135, -0.054242029786109924, -0.03786212205886841, -0.0112170884385705, -0.015817994251847267, -0.03560606762766838, 0.015063164755702019, -0.07046659290790558, 0.048951733857393265, -0.021245090290904045, -0.0643203929066658, -0.006186413578689098, 0.0012804849538952112, -0.059238363057374954, 0.0020409405697137117, -0.03150612488389015, -0.016394807025790215, -0.04805733263492584, 0.04815170168876648, 0.010154156014323235, -0.049478087574243546, -0.03785762935876846, 0.0737140104174614, 0.06099259480834007, -0.006292110774666071, 0.023241642862558365, 0.04612191021442413, -0.046575676649808884, 0.012257581576704979, -0.06237724423408508, -0.01944524049758911, 0.013820515014231205, 0.03157024085521698, -0.00027348214644007385, -0.06391304731369019, -0.03749493882060051, 0.04823234677314758, -0.023988986387848854, -0.006292878650128841, 0.026830537244677544, -0.019943920895457268, 0.04793481528759003, 0.003574710339307785, -0.017579542472958565, 0.0020619728602468967, -0.03722931072115898, 0.008933634497225285, -0.02084546908736229, -0.008144533261656761, -0.006801377050578594, 0.010551693849265575, -0.016391025856137276, -0.014131658710539341, 0.014085263013839722, 0.0011328455293551087, -0.06920253485441208, -0.02570069581270218, -0.018147403374314308, 0.012815775349736214, 0.03341054916381836, 0.01739988662302494, 0.021488843485713005, 0.02400270849466324, 0.016444362699985504, -0.02724641188979149, -0.0053793746046721935, 0.01437516137957573, 0.03618035092949867, 0.03306560963392258, -0.0175868459045887, 0.021763166412711143, 0.052014902234077454, -0.013612320646643639, 0.030260127037763596, -0.04200274124741554, -0.06889248639345169, 0.010826286859810352, -0.011852018535137177, 0.017294028773903847, -0.02065269835293293, -0.06044108048081398, 0.04894622415304184, 0.029202325269579887, 0.005250653252005577, -0.053626898676157, -0.01415055152028799, 0.015107214450836182, -0.009711740538477898, 0.008611944504082203, -0.03231964260339737, -0.026083191856741905, -0.004316574428230524, 0.00249807583168149, 0.026683613657951355, 0.02328617312014103, 0.007006639149039984, -0.023974966257810593, -0.07037290185689926, -0.006063063163310289, 0.05668231099843979, -0.0018464116146788, -0.05795847624540329, 0.013962308876216412, 0.03129502758383751, -0.06574761122465134, -0.00003588151594158262, 0.013261087238788605, -0.02720724232494831, 0.0040350244380533695, -0.07439717650413513, 0.039773810654878616, -0.036404892802238464, -0.06800863146781921, -0.06378107517957687, -0.010745221748948097, 0.009570473805069923, -0.05309600010514259, 0.007706135045737028, -0.016613837331533432, -0.06539829075336456, 0.021001199260354042, -0.07503212988376617, 0.03160923719406128, 0.0010517280315980315, -0.013499327003955841, -0.01199897937476635, -0.017819589003920555, 0.00584399001672864, -0.04707140102982521, 0.015565872192382812, -0.007943173870444298, 0.04074126482009888, 0.009060992859303951, -0.020952409133315086, 0.037861164659261703, -0.06488355994224548, 0.008835592307150364, 0.043118782341480255, -0.03241228312253952, -0.018918756395578384, 0.041481610387563705, 0.06572804600000381, 0.012625634670257568, -0.04403102770447731, 0.010567699559032917, -0.02528453804552555, 0.01981261931359768, -0.019470836967229843, 0.01328185759484768, -0.04569794237613678, -0.0695267841219902, -0.003863838966935873, -0.018123295158147812, 0.04442961513996124, 0.013103179633617401, 0.007321561221033335, -0.0002992555673699826, -0.007765547838062048, -0.03310074657201767, 0.05960024148225784, -0.0019609963055700064, 0.015490510500967503, 0.05546233057975769, -0.022516004741191864, 0.0009831091156229377, -0.038607217371463776, -0.0328904427587986, 0.008709462359547615, 0.0247857253998518, 0.03412315621972084, -0.01121077872812748, 0.06244643032550812, -0.06046902760863304, 0.028934763744473457, -0.0193382129073143, -0.008355982601642609, -0.03550673648715019, 0.0665813609957695, -0.0025650530587881804, -0.0364835299551487, -0.025497879832983017, -0.0331059955060482, -0.049632374197244644, -0.021254051476716995, -0.04800763726234436, -0.05004274845123291, 0.05042923986911774, -0.001793729024939239, 0.010342027992010117, 0.02305031567811966, 0.05817556008696556, 0.01662275940179825, 0.04376564919948578, -0.02157541550695896, 0.009172843769192696, 0.026821715757250786, 0.050747230648994446, 0.027434635907411575, -0.009098157286643982, -0.057013437151908875, 0.009953116066753864, 0.032689083367586136, 0.01368092279881239, 0.0028472740668803453, 0.0065049948170781136, -0.0013189855962991714, -0.01773948408663273, -0.04663518816232681, 0.03446553274989128, -0.003289907006546855, 0.0061323330737650394, -0.015317116864025593, 0.02905367501080036, -0.004861920140683651, -0.0509846955537796 ]
Diffusion models have gained prominence in the image domain for their capabilities in data generation and transformation, achieving state-of-the-art performance in various tasks in both image and audio domains. In the rapidly evolving field of audio-based machine learning, safeguarding model integrity and establishing data copyright are of paramount importance. This paper presents the first watermarking technique applied to audio diffusion models trained on mel-spectrograms. This offers a novel approach to the aforementioned challenges. Our model excels not only in benign audio generation, but also incorporates an invisible watermarking trigger mechanism for model verification. This watermark trigger serves as a protective layer, enabling the identification of model ownership and ensuring its integrity. Through extensive experiments, we demonstrate that invisible watermark triggers can effectively protect against unauthorized modifications while maintaining high utility in benign audio generation tasks.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13166v2
[ -0.007550802547484636, -0.007090894039720297, 0.05001387372612953, -0.027967486530542374, 0.04738346114754677, 0.013444248586893082, 0.001202134764753282, -0.04088950529694557, -0.0040080975741147995, -0.010178633034229279, -0.052742283791303635, 0.048339031636714935, -0.06434111297130585, -0.042848337441682816, -0.031055372208356857, 0.022078577429056168, 0.08583597093820572, -0.017600851133465767, -0.030672380700707436, 0.05016208067536354, -0.028160378336906433, -0.025858929380774498, -0.019257452338933945, 0.004039723426103592, 0.000822609756141901, -0.019779670983552933, -0.08007299900054932, 0.013272101990878582, -0.041439659893512726, 0.0033122070599347353, 0.04901006817817688, -0.021054042503237724, -0.017757654190063477, -0.02972971647977829, -0.049015555530786514, -0.03101281449198723, -0.0468565970659256, 0.0149201275780797, 0.015033350326120853, -0.05333271995186806, 0.07186657190322876, -0.032222677022218704, -0.04283423721790314, -0.0034705339930951595, -0.030346455052495003, -0.02503596432507038, -0.024723246693611145, 0.01626027375459671, -0.09164908528327942, 0.018538329750299454, 0.004424316342920065, 0.014713945798575878, -0.021458979696035385, 0.037112344056367874, -0.01323422696441412, -0.039523378014564514, -0.0472242571413517, 0.021048061549663544, -0.06045987084507942, 0.03738180175423622, 0.03767697140574455, -0.011468753218650818, -0.011135491542518139, 0.020770350471138954, 0.01002183835953474, 0.02604660950601101, -0.01686309091746807, -0.018963314592838287, -0.03435809537768364, -0.03242553025484085, 0.06056056544184685, -0.03288246691226959, 0.00398644944652915, -0.006852363236248493, 0.018035488203167915, -0.03482583537697792, -0.021709108725190163, -0.0341230072081089, -0.03239837661385536, 0.03637508675456047, -0.009227009490132332, 0.02980118617415428, 0.018617384135723114, 0.05046480521559715, 0.00883438065648079, 0.02999267354607582, 0.010299382731318474, 0.0138009088113904, -0.0001658083638176322, -0.03505004197359085, 0.04193568229675293, -0.031483836472034454, -0.09550203382968903, 0.042215026915073395, 0.048691388219594955, -0.03449243679642677, 0.06181729584932327, 0.004905425012111664, -0.005367341451346874, -0.00986815057694912, -0.02138698473572731, 0.015207718126475811, -0.02193787693977356, 0.021632863208651543, 0.010921649634838104, -0.06005832552909851, 0.04919019341468811, 0.01192234642803669, -0.046449750661849976, -0.004655397497117519, -0.002228982513770461, -0.05562470480799675, -0.006320263724774122, -0.06133625656366348, -0.002929011592641473, -0.006244169548153877, 0.021220022812485695, -0.014971425756812096, -0.004279863554984331, 0.03670860454440117, 0.018457967787981033, 0.02869882993400097, 0.045367199927568436, -0.009666064754128456, -0.011726044118404388, 0.008486089296638966, 0.05739520117640495, 0.010293037630617619, -0.03802754729986191, -0.06501343101263046, -0.019343066960573196, 0.04278956726193428, -0.0074510532431304455, -0.028961999341845512, 0.04923573136329651, -0.0021692782174795866, 0.005426572635769844, -0.04025872051715851, 0.00523040909320116, -0.022627092897892, -0.02227320335805416, -0.060959309339523315, 0.024619149044156075, -0.024056199938058853, 0.02690514363348484, 0.014191016554832458, -0.01953705959022045, 0.009337164461612701, 0.03063216432929039, 0.01964949257671833, 0.02410222589969635, 0.017287125810980797, 0.026278002187609673, 0.04307602718472481, 0.004345410969108343, -0.053932540118694305, 0.0598345622420311, -0.015431361272931099, -0.024678194895386696, 0.04227830842137337, -0.024294868111610413, 0.009668347425758839, -0.00234674708917737, -0.05494697019457817, 0.029073702171444893, -0.034218642860651016, 0.03409009426832199, 0.02974647842347622, -0.035853415727615356, 0.018291456624865532, -0.02536829560995102, -0.004551043268293142, -0.005041345488280058, -0.01593395136296749, -0.048290129750967026, 0.030626526102423668, 0.002409642329439521, -0.039167970418930054, -0.025716988369822502, 0.003639944363385439, 0.012127643451094627, 0.007277179043740034, -0.06064564362168312, -0.03309603035449982, -0.041533809155225754, 0.025331340730190277, -0.08717511594295502, -0.015138231217861176, 0.06317546218633652, -0.03978436440229416, -0.06494174897670746, -0.019934989511966705, -0.026740556582808495, -0.027017440646886826, -0.016663771122694016, -0.004997821990400553, -0.04876277968287468, -0.0016895353328436613, 0.037220150232315063, 0.04999632015824318, -0.08381439745426178, -0.010960809886455536, -0.07558759301900864, -0.014815669506788254, 0.02186107076704502, -0.05992501601576805, -0.03378865867853165, 0.0384674035012722, -0.07994911819696426, -0.007482579443603754, 0.06047925353050232, 0.03984181582927704, 0.06664223968982697, 0.0096119474619627, 0.050831012427806854, 0.01360776275396347, -0.10829827189445496, 0.032879963517189026, 0.002774215769022703, 0.011596367694437504, 0.04415702447295189, 0.0490952730178833, 0.003315033158287406, -0.03737017884850502, -0.016162842512130737, 0.05324971675872803, 0.0868251621723175, -0.04576648771762848, -0.04031122848391533, -0.048070378601551056, -0.0006580407498404384, -0.015439112670719624, -0.056100863963365555, -0.05768460035324097, -0.023065976798534393, -0.031833335757255554, -0.0022261193953454494, 0.004260290879756212, -0.009352241642773151, -0.02372065745294094, -0.007312521804124117, -0.07109183818101883, 0.05833312124013901, 0.025703145191073418, -0.03090057335793972, -0.04154741019010544, -0.020182296633720398, 0.039264414459466934, -0.0372876413166523, 0.026019802317023277, 0.005151046440005302, -0.018951933830976486, -0.022042065858840942, 0.004584204871207476, 0.03731761500239372, 0.022259552031755447, -0.055391620844602585, 0.019595712423324585, -0.025583012029528618, 0.0019385818159207702, 0.0388459675014019, 0.024258485063910484, -0.05424729734659195, -0.0032566729933023453, 0.04922597110271454, -0.02023746259510517, 0.021534588187932968, -0.01674814522266388, -0.0004230124468449503, -0.04650112986564636, -0.024626372382044792, 0.021940164268016815, 0.02341116964817047, -0.01999591663479805, -0.010234863497316837, -0.04252098873257637, 0.009574777446687222, 0.01381593756377697, 0.011979267932474613, 0.017554542049765587, 0.034687627106904984, -0.007390350569039583, 0.0010301878210157156, -0.042201928794384, -0.011470390483736992, -0.06686711311340332, 0.018136626109480858, -0.05887524411082268, -0.02114447019994259, -0.03234964981675148, -0.07485073804855347, -0.027613220736384392, -0.027005301788449287, -0.022179163992404938, -0.028715720400214195, -0.07584024220705032, -0.033211980015039444, 0.031334228813648224, 0.07104798406362534, 0.01583920791745186, -0.03759772703051567, -0.02589583210647106, -0.0034008845686912537, 0.02680509351193905, 0.0059226215817034245, -0.009787309914827347, -0.029920682311058044, -0.00674484996125102, 0.007745010778307915, -0.05262841656804085, -0.00838602613657713, 0.05820254608988762, -0.032474733889102936, 0.040371477603912354, -0.020123446360230446, 0.01248935703188181, 0.052699025720357895, 0.032355207949876785, -0.0030168599914759398, -0.03360803425312042, -0.0104984724894166, -0.01633983477950096, -0.03390052914619446, -0.031744085252285004, -0.009430165402591228, -0.03723480924963951, 0.06345359236001968, -0.019392140209674835, -0.052390266209840775, -0.036655817180871964, -0.055163487792015076, 0.04007284715771675, 0.029514074325561523, -0.0050912220031023026, 0.04266652837395668, 0.040178850293159485, -0.015162614174187183, -0.008574089966714382, -0.02315262146294117, -0.011231024749577045, -0.017628217115998268, 0.03654211387038231, -0.025180678814649582, 0.006613762117922306, 0.06629984080791473, -0.09731466323137283, 0.0032764351926743984, 0.04459347575902939, 0.07390501350164413, -0.009113769978284836, 0.015250087715685368, -0.008541570045053959, 0.00023713248083367944, 0.03931043669581413, 0.022808264940977097, -0.014556756243109703, 0.05686186999082565, 0.03143106773495674, -0.007424373645335436, -0.04403189569711685, 0.019224828109145164, -0.06878270953893661, -0.03627835959196091, 0.010423071682453156, 0.044106267392635345, -0.0009878880809992552, 0.008200383745133877, -0.06531498581171036, 0.02404090017080307, -0.009764145128428936, 0.03071976825594902, -0.025137491524219513, -0.03893924877047539, 0.04439671337604523, -0.05996594950556755, 0.03066331148147583, 0.013226182200014591, -0.03276684880256653, -0.025872910395264626, -0.04882660135626793, 0.006005319766700268, -0.031211284920573235, 0.04714734107255936, 0.022931842133402824, -0.044138938188552856, 0.026713162660598755, 0.06119485944509506, 0.018233664333820343, 0.04085952416062355, -0.020326770842075348, -0.02211650088429451, -0.005721434950828552, -0.009544609114527702, -0.0018238904885947704, -0.01147503312677145, -0.05740773305296898, 0.011443383991718292, -0.006897331215441227, -0.0400954894721508, 0.008057483471930027, 0.0008422221872024238, 0.015267104841768742, 0.04053112119436264, -0.0847051590681076, 0.012516169808804989, -0.023200875148177147, 0.040018703788518906, 0.0354420468211174, -0.04033322632312775, 0.05387314409017563, -0.06628809124231339, -0.014207815751433372, -0.035880494862794876, -0.0012076979037374258, -0.022216906771063805, -0.06280467659235, -0.02087930217385292, -0.0692005529999733, 0.03176211193203926, -0.027983374893665314, 0.073666512966156, -0.012741540558636189, 0.017533551901578903, -0.00027631776174530387, -0.012658338993787766, -0.016697539016604424, 0.015604617074131966, 0.06983447819948196, 0.04351429641246796, -0.0229658130556345, -0.0403299406170845, 0.012049988843500614, 0.0223932396620512, 0.010022418573498726, 0.02874576486647129, -0.00965026207268238, 0.02872966043651104, 0.006015020422637463, 0.0387970469892025, 0.03334587439894676, 0.018508736044168472, 0.06698206812143326, -0.030513174831867218, -0.05829716473817825, 0.0008065152214840055, -0.018123524263501167, -0.03467755764722824, -0.03782159835100174, -0.011355808936059475, -0.04323454201221466, -0.024335037916898727, -0.03262884542346001, 0.053602054715156555, 0.018054833635687828, -0.027524350211024284, 0.014914197847247124, 0.06225436553359032, 0.0001854785077739507, 0.025658246129751205, 0.009264209307730198, 0.08074065297842026, -0.00996517576277256, -0.02582034468650818, -0.041069772094488144, -0.03877167031168938, -0.0041423761285841465, -0.05180917680263519, 0.02082817442715168, -0.00040392769733443856, 0.002421353943645954, 0.046926308423280716, 0.03886876255273819, -0.0859571248292923, 0.0006290196906775236, 0.05669268220663071, -0.02621903084218502, 0.001481761340983212, 0.045426785945892334, 0.004309351090341806, 0.05468066409230232, -0.04634620621800423, 0.015316451899707317, 0.02308904379606247, -0.027233146131038666, -0.021195169538259506, 0.020546304062008858, -0.0277906134724617, -0.026611842215061188, 0.034410879015922546, 0.0034938573371618986, -0.052074987441301346, 0.001167168840765953, 0.046833012253046036, 0.0021050130017101765, 0.0024115759879350662, -0.005611076019704342, 0.0835769921541214, -0.03389417752623558, -0.012625538744032383, 0.020609000697731972, -0.01742868311703205, -0.005578924436122179, 0.03285856917500496, -0.029198236763477325, -0.025205878540873528, -0.013914125971496105, -0.027493994683027267, -0.008695234544575214, 0.031048180535435677, -0.014641587622463703, -0.0390649251639843, -0.03998874872922897, 0.001378588960506022, -0.02472996897995472, -0.04138936847448349, -0.05371139571070671, 0.03191062808036804, 0.06277461349964142, -0.011092192493379116, 0.060818150639534, 0.012934704311192036, -0.01841876283288002, 0.027157753705978394, -0.0365714430809021, -0.0015359452227130532, 0.0028310599736869335, -0.007350738160312176, 0.03872878476977348, 0.010802878066897392, 0.03124990314245224, -0.029785925522446632, 0.03857014328241348, -0.021389180794358253, 0.0265969131141901, -0.046670131385326385, -0.012481789104640484, 0.03136702626943588, -0.04787375032901764, -0.05254276096820831, 0.04518960043787956, 0.03594440594315529, -0.041441772133111954, 0.03135031834244728, 0.014542417600750923, -0.017075790092349052, 0.055243995040655136, -0.021217595785856247, -0.014999264851212502, -0.030005883425474167, -0.04196673259139061, 0.04326833412051201, -0.05248503386974335, 0.026722827926278114, -0.0030260933563113213, -0.020295046269893646, -0.000018266067854710855, -0.07708733528852463, 0.02030463144183159, 0.06502954661846161, 0.009400920942425728, -0.016521528363227844, 0.05299096554517746, -0.02423493191599846, -0.07861132174730301, 0.04933986812829971, 0.02520628459751606, -0.06514505296945572, 0.017152031883597374, -0.012120189145207405, -0.0001991097815334797, -0.025277113541960716, 0.05144805461168289, 0.045108772814273834, -0.007768135983496904, -0.05070910230278969, 0.08131808042526245, 0.08942562341690063, -0.0030125847551971674, -0.015281653963029385, 0.017692793160676956, -0.06538891047239304, 0.000431231310358271, -0.00741147343069315, -0.03019218146800995, 0.021401001140475273, 0.019790923222899437, 0.03416486456990242, -0.050200216472148895, -0.050084106624126434, 0.046578433364629745, -0.04314723610877991, 0.04149315506219864, 0.02018720842897892, -0.006444171071052551, 0.06976929306983948, -0.04555223137140274, -0.01233647856861353, 0.009842761792242527, 0.002098222030326724, 0.03754905238747597, -0.06829649955034256, -0.03717079758644104, 0.007849814370274544, 0.024624381214380264, 0.005251931492239237, -0.07359704375267029, 0.0056518265046179295, -0.013082402758300304, -0.07638964802026749, -0.04614443704485893, -0.06111416965723038, 0.02207529917359352, -0.008045795373618603, 0.03340987116098404, 0.051842570304870605, 0.07492774724960327, -0.016873350366950035, -0.04789900779724121, 0.00855330005288124, -0.006051723845303059, -0.025098660960793495, -0.02566031739115715, 0.0024753608740866184, -0.020147809758782387, 0.03931209444999695, -0.0025212829932570457, 0.0009315863717347383, 0.015361009165644646, -0.05285176634788513, 0.036478057503700256, -0.021142898127436638, -0.03603396937251091, 0.007148064207285643, 0.02332417666912079, -0.022509276866912842, 0.0017496992368251085, -0.010258043184876442, -0.0641251802444458, -0.03372427448630333, -0.03599485009908676, -0.02056238241493702, 0.049347683787345886, 0.00328091811388731, 0.04081006348133087, 0.053667813539505005, -0.047367069870233536, 0.05245780572295189, 0.007275287993252277, -0.012993880547583103, 0.020651839673519135, -0.048962872475385666, 0.010214784182608128, 0.01462248619645834, -0.04442910850048065, -0.03529563918709755, -0.020733637735247612, -0.027822600677609444, -0.061996493488550186, 0.033299751579761505, 0.04327297583222389, 0.01580030284821987, -0.022710325196385384, -0.036867786198854446, 0.051985230296850204, 0.03987959772348404, -0.010913708247244358, -0.05217061564326286, 0.0018477154662832618, -0.01335876528173685, -0.050104569643735886, -0.029776258394122124, 0.000291268719593063, -0.03542056307196617, 0.014107528142631054, -0.08750113844871521, 0.03347281739115715, 0.0491793230175972, 0.04022930935025215, -0.04278983175754547, -0.052482347935438156, 0.031241660937666893, -0.0440206341445446, 0.02467581443488598, 0.020746150985360146, -0.003403996117413044, 0.0030105398036539555, -0.0004934430471621454, -0.04054880514740944, -0.0612238384783268, 0.008892123587429523, 0.021218011155724525, 0.013656361028552055, 0.0163315050303936, 0.020814113318920135, 0.04220433905720711, 0.029738174751400948, 0.017427492886781693, 0.028844250366091728, -0.04570835828781128, 0.03745126351714134, -0.05650044605135918, 0.03276543319225311, -0.035812199115753174, -0.050840217620134354, 0.05943034589290619, -0.04947509616613388, -0.012972895987331867, 0.03444609418511391, 0.0013771200319752097, 0.036193422973155975, -0.011001705192029476, -0.029636653140187263, -0.022143175825476646, -0.04819286987185478, 0.004640549886971712, 0.061686936765909195, -0.02003941684961319, -0.04470366612076759, -0.03174316883087158, 0.007550037931650877, -0.043429914861917496, 0.05252518504858017, 0.032843440771102905, -0.03428109735250473, 0.005533227697014809, -0.015049519948661327, -0.027015212923288345, -0.013202585279941559, 0.01821242831647396, -0.0019477958558127284, 0.07384897023439407, -0.033372316509485245, -0.043133605271577835, -0.0695970207452774, -0.0226996261626482, -0.005832125898450613, -0.04292802885174751, -0.035447608679533005, -0.034458283334970474, 0.018757840618491173, -0.007062533870339394, -0.017180508002638817, -0.007179691921919584, 0.04882990941405296, -0.0036695674061775208, 0.037195559591054916, 0.011151243932545185, -0.03021438978612423, -0.04108469933271408, 0.05811411514878273, 0.0032691231463104486, 0.03814190998673439, -0.027343297377228737, 0.06545533984899521, -0.010135483928024769, -0.04329996183514595, 0.0006948204827494919, -0.029159408062696457, 0.03334257751703262, -0.04689416289329529, 0.045118559151887894, 0.010116364806890488, 0.0004948718124069273, -0.029485968872904778, -0.0258240457624197, 0.005542512517422438, -0.012652521021664143, -0.05986079201102257 ]
Ferroelectricity can exist in elemental phases as a result of charge transfers between atoms occupying inequivalent Wyckoff positions. We investigate the emergence of ferroelectricity in two-dimensional elemental materials with buckled honeycomb lattices. Various multi-bilayer structures hosting ferroelectricity are designed by stacking-engineering. Ferroelectric materials candidates formed by group IV and V elements are predicted theoretically. Ultrathin Bi films show layer-stacking-dependent physical properties of ferroelectricity, topology, and metallicity. The two-bilayer Bi film with a polar stacking sequence is found to be an elemental topological ferroelectric material. Three and four bilayers Bi films with polar structures are ferroelectric-like elemental polar metals with topological nontrivial edge states. For Ge and Sn, trivial elemental polar metals are predicted. Our work reveals the possibility of design two-dimensional elemental topological ferroelectrics and polar metals by stacking-engineering.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14609v1
[ -0.02013903111219406, -0.020418819040060043, 0.02869204804301262, 0.03216934949159622, -0.020042842254042625, -0.055202167481184006, 0.008397663943469524, 0.044760264456272125, -0.02605331502854824, -0.015294021926820278, -0.016820767894387245, -0.05073784664273262, -0.03635617718100548, -0.0536225289106369, -0.028408408164978027, -0.019871097058057785, 0.06720907241106033, 0.06553739309310913, -0.041115373373031616, 0.05195297673344612, -0.017027847468852997, 0.03395136445760727, 0.028474636375904083, 0.040041469037532806, -0.0028249097522348166, 0.016732821241021156, -0.03372275084257126, -0.006759133189916611, -0.05576906353235245, -0.0013646791921928525, 0.023335719481110573, 0.0010303647723048925, 0.026903964579105377, 0.009340350516140461, 0.008968272246420383, -0.021721994504332542, -0.02121320553123951, 0.021943027153611183, 0.024713708087801933, -0.051131442189216614, -0.03428644686937332, 0.0001569232699694112, -0.06195900961756706, -0.022824862971901894, -0.03048236109316349, -0.03612315654754639, -0.050795286893844604, 0.043049611151218414, -0.0756111890077591, -0.06357896327972412, 0.056329548358917236, 0.02905435860157013, 0.0229155533015728, 0.0528041310608387, -0.03497665748000145, 0.00414238590747118, -0.028287436813116074, -0.03332908824086189, -0.01178475096821785, 0.046945761889219284, 0.009458485059440136, -0.01986752264201641, 0.0017624646425247192, -0.01813831552863121, -0.061645954847335815, 0.009170861914753914, -0.062322672456502914, -0.027355752885341644, -0.04137334227561951, -0.07430597394704819, 0.0002464793506078422, -0.07117796689271927, 0.026454102247953415, -0.012040912173688412, -0.06720331311225891, 0.02116454392671585, -0.03744678571820259, -0.01694580353796482, 0.009241188876330853, -0.013392110355198383, -0.016036655753850937, 0.005630650091916323, 0.0008292742422781885, -0.006178889889270067, 0.015568778850138187, 0.012875733897089958, 0.033674780279397964, -0.012157514691352844, -0.0022331352811306715, -0.012279101647436619, 0.0455862395465374, -0.008591128513216972, -0.052560992538928986, 0.041426196694374084, 0.034807320684194565, 0.03230118751525879, 0.05660581216216087, 0.05281195417046547, 0.017207320779561996, -0.027181008830666542, 0.016974763944745064, -0.06966528296470642, -0.0522906556725502, 0.029239535331726074, -0.0446014367043972, -0.023827992379665375, 0.020677877590060234, -0.03595936670899391, -0.019065063446760178, -0.017067251726984978, 0.048304010182619095, 0.03613872081041336, -0.012091141194105148, 0.005989414174109697, -0.02351406030356884, -0.03474334254860878, 0.06188597157597542, 0.04484559968113899, 0.03692870959639549, 0.02419951930642128, -0.031080663204193115, 0.03708459436893463, 0.01144558284431696, 0.0037915045395493507, -0.06159122288227081, 0.006006843876093626, 0.04864912107586861, 0.0167591143399477, 0.014814933761954308, -0.03995237872004509, -0.04278795048594475, 0.024374373257160187, 0.06194613501429558, -0.04893643409013748, 0.011803342960774899, -0.03163347765803337, -0.039645105600357056, 0.009639475494623184, -0.04044417291879654, 0.019214274361729622, -0.04191890358924866, -0.06109265238046646, -0.006555575877428055, -0.0026294891722500324, -0.01872662454843521, 0.030859358608722687, -0.0766235888004303, 0.01698821224272251, 0.029781702905893326, 0.03207250311970711, 0.02813790552318096, -0.015471920371055603, -0.017998231574892998, -0.04855537787079811, -0.03036898747086525, -0.025688305497169495, 0.0087481290102005, 0.013256924226880074, -0.0019488472025841475, 0.008934487588703632, -0.02017725631594658, -0.020059926435351372, 0.050503771752119064, -0.008125793188810349, -0.03533908724784851, -0.048138946294784546, -0.0021363776177167892, -0.011728950776159763, -0.02929225191473961, -0.02008056454360485, -0.04361918941140175, 0.0280044786632061, -0.0149210961535573, -0.05501287803053856, -0.06794183701276779, -0.001304297475144267, -0.021903015673160553, -0.051205649971961975, -0.030387526378035545, 0.013569083996117115, 0.011879131197929382, -0.009774785488843918, 0.03161215782165527, -0.018577340990304947, -0.02812322974205017, -0.024883510544896126, -0.08030533790588379, 0.008827355690300465, 0.026130329817533493, -0.015261327847838402, 0.0029146394226700068, -0.010669540613889694, -0.019977077841758728, -0.010299647226929665, -0.016136053949594498, -0.025645580142736435, 0.023669717833399773, -0.05973486602306366, -0.05000796541571617, 0.03404802829027176, -0.07595488429069519, 0.028405919671058655, 0.01556397881358862, -0.04210197925567627, 0.045725125819444656, -0.06273169070482254, -0.024311617016792297, -0.007556943688541651, -0.03309107571840286, -0.013275264762341976, 0.057501450181007385, 0.0662049725651741, 0.0490492545068264, -0.02360665611922741, 0.0009794902289286256, -0.0009834604570642114, -0.09128139168024063, -0.009272175841033459, -0.04032624512910843, 0.031598396599292755, 0.05675138160586357, 0.029633397236466408, 0.04842409864068031, -0.020745258778333664, -0.029928885400295258, 0.021576547995209694, 0.059916190803050995, -0.005981881637126207, -0.035906318575143814, 0.008540143258869648, -0.03284437209367752, -0.03186734393239021, -0.06660971790552139, -0.031654972583055496, -0.036509089171886444, -0.031636252999305725, -0.06915637105703354, 0.058985792100429535, -0.05942185968160629, -0.05948613956570625, -0.03672615811228752, -0.018896322697401047, -0.005936537869274616, 0.027250144630670547, -0.0347968265414238, -0.013537664897739887, -0.06744855642318726, 0.04223847761750221, -0.042392950505018234, -0.016474571079015732, 0.000678396609146148, -0.07263756543397903, -0.010091071017086506, -0.00562118086963892, -0.016835305839776993, 0.018364015966653824, -0.04319577291607857, 0.006801864597946405, -0.023671362549066544, 0.04955161735415459, 0.006500177551060915, 0.06418228149414062, -0.03734501451253891, 0.014541517943143845, 0.04106151685118675, 0.014256523922085762, -0.04292352497577667, -0.025853309780359268, 0.0344700925052166, -0.059284757822752, -0.0214459877461195, 0.0035524838604032993, 0.012438677251338959, -0.0015892954543232918, 0.004804013296961784, 0.0152872484177351, -0.05734952166676521, -0.0198676660656929, -0.02349836193025112, 0.05382199585437775, 0.07123194634914398, 0.018902812153100967, -0.018006615340709686, -0.03642639145255089, -0.022107046097517014, 0.01851912960410118, 0.014756481163203716, -0.029341047629714012, 0.006500791758298874, -0.05977868288755417, -0.038860101252794266, -0.0161521527916193, -0.0347578302025795, -0.04168786481022835, -0.018373358994722366, -0.030901947990059853, -0.04305203631520271, -0.035290367901325226, -0.001976810861378908, -0.040573667734861374, -0.0660344734787941, 0.02508838288486004, 0.018395792692899704, -0.009832804091274738, -0.06398604065179825, -0.0573006272315979, -0.049098752439022064, 0.03642955794930458, -0.0014050573809072375, -0.05474962294101715, -0.03618568181991577, 0.03448013588786125, -0.07330919057130814, 0.023851415142416954, 0.006011359393596649, 0.03464224934577942, 0.042764317244291306, -0.035916149616241455, 0.017477640882134438, 0.00019438177696429193, -0.03845721110701561, -0.00797323975712061, -0.0050325957126915455, 0.012228865176439285, -0.07333660125732422, -0.026743071153759956, 0.03673063591122627, 0.06679797172546387, -0.01510786172002554, 0.011251554824411869, -0.06773073226213455, -0.05221749097108841, 0.008486546576023102, -0.0021621757186949253, 0.06798414140939713, 0.014763503335416317, -0.05272731930017471, -0.017834484577178955, -0.052924755960702896, -0.00431135343387723, 0.01802182011306286, 0.02936481684446335, 0.0318523533642292, -0.037308238446712494, -0.036524493247270584, -0.024099063128232956, 0.03958427160978317, 0.04477221146225929, 0.06401088088750839, -0.02940537966787815, -0.001971934223547578, 0.00005247568333288655, 0.018361296504735947, 0.03880764916539192, 0.011999196372926235, 0.019541073590517044, -0.01524231769144535, 0.06230056285858154, -0.07130732387304306, -0.03625473380088806, -0.050733376294374466, -0.026812633499503136, -0.07586654275655746, 0.03641921281814575, 0.03914254531264305, 0.030278902500867844, 0.03728725016117096, 0.010100042447447777, -0.004205228760838509, -0.03267916664481163, 0.05713341385126114, -0.019761143252253532, -0.05299045145511627, -0.007659347727894783, -0.0171740110963583, 0.01290878001600504, -0.010561824776232243, -0.029721874743700027, -0.05304790288209915, -0.03719562292098999, -0.003917002584785223, -0.07506570965051651, -0.017834443598985672, 0.01389354933053255, 0.034424640238285065, 0.032465677708387375, 0.027063237503170967, 0.04695418104529381, 0.0417603999376297, 0.00987414550036192, 0.037199608981609344, -0.014475278556346893, 0.01746377907693386, 0.03795721381902695, 0.009809006005525589, -0.012648256495594978, -0.0005992506630718708, -0.005164186470210552, -0.05138596147298813, -0.007984980009496212, 0.031824417412281036, 0.025250304490327835, -0.02381623163819313, -0.05815131589770317, -0.04170024394989014, -0.025792062282562256, -0.008270797319710255, 0.01699555665254593, -0.060533177107572556, 0.0711992084980011, -0.0371272973716259, -0.010383764281868935, -0.010405490174889565, -0.0140687245875597, -0.05514049530029297, -0.023768657818436623, 0.009579772129654884, -0.05838239938020706, 0.003071799408644438, -0.06367386877536774, -0.020104732364416122, -0.0405859537422657, 0.04347861930727959, -0.06734146922826767, 0.06333307921886444, 0.04030146077275276, -0.006400576326996088, 0.04197363927960396, 0.016128798946738243, 0.01512464415282011, -0.028214571997523308, 0.024708224460482597, -0.02186286263167858, -0.027576198801398277, 0.05473167076706886, -0.03880389779806137, 0.0036547172348946333, -0.055318526923656464, -0.01693578250706196, 0.015831273049116135, -0.02825375646352768, 0.06066031754016876, -0.05892075598239899, -0.012562374584376812, 0.0053506940603256226, 0.009820475243031979, 0.01784910261631012, -0.05055093765258789, -0.020162200555205345, -0.03266896307468414, -0.050418611615896225, 0.03585261479020119, 0.007936798967421055, -0.03678195923566818, -0.021604323759675026, 0.043131135404109955, -0.006544517353177071, 0.02850968949496746, -0.0017047086730599403, 0.038716334849596024, 0.00701563898473978, 0.025553034618496895, 0.007359360810369253, -0.025359531864523888, -0.05380287393927574, 0.011942259967327118, 0.0009202087530866265, 0.0074371760711073875, 0.0016485560918226838, -0.0033881908748298883, -0.012175803072750568, 0.04400445148348808, -0.07360381633043289, 0.029452156275510788, 0.0586969368159771, -0.03685066103935242, -0.06685777753591537, -0.022271795198321342, 0.002312015276402235, 0.028941607102751732, -0.004862796049565077, 0.003798060817644, -0.033431556075811386, -0.03471857309341431, 0.037933263927698135, 0.03898244351148605, 0.014965091831982136, 0.005732054356485605, 0.06992898136377335, 0.018903035670518875, -0.058920711278915405, -0.02568437159061432, 0.02278396114706993, -0.03380683809518814, 0.006870927754789591, -0.006800143513828516, 0.009204876609146595, -0.04867681488394737, -0.02388043701648712, -0.00050488265696913, 0.020378589630126953, -0.0022379709407687187, 0.03665701299905777, -0.023159809410572052, 0.013691706582903862, 0.02677450142800808, -0.033430904150009155, 0.054597292095422745, -0.016302326694130898, -0.01858174055814743, 0.012302123941481113, -0.026562806218862534, -0.0031940529588609934, -0.06855736672878265, 0.01049159187823534, -0.0675426498055458, 0.04818109795451164, -0.022721076384186745, 0.027033904567360878, 0.0629177913069725, 0.046296946704387665, -0.004531924147158861, -0.05363894999027252, 0.0028089340776205063, -0.016917476430535316, 0.05877572298049927, -0.04628226161003113, -0.0344977006316185, -0.020231151953339577, 0.05961087346076965, -0.0058178468607366085, -0.035832200199365616, -0.0324317030608654, 0.00947218481451273, -0.06870914250612259, 0.006599813234061003, -0.0091807646676898, -0.01324653159826994, -0.054887183010578156, -0.026953410357236862, 0.06629075855016708, -0.0416010357439518, 0.06758178025484085, 0.030625011771917343, -0.022476842626929283, 0.018710928037762642, 0.010195421986281872, 0.06060304492712021, -0.02342023327946663, -0.04416868835687637, 0.06310342997312546, -0.08543796837329865, -0.026060575619339943, -0.03439868986606598, -0.056045789271593094, -0.048042863607406616, -0.05044688284397125, 0.030464479699730873, 0.037346161901950836, -0.011332238093018532, -0.029852382838726044, 0.01073856744915247, 0.03790766000747681, -0.07155310362577438, 0.022359466180205345, 0.024811264127492905, -0.012034502811729908, 0.00838545523583889, -0.018127581104636192, -0.032632675021886826, -0.03122824616730213, -0.033877186477184296, -0.040971387177705765, -0.048979636281728745, -0.03658612444996834, 0.02878982573747635, 0.033634524792432785, -0.03544481471180916, 0.00022667278244625777, 0.046641476452350616, 0.048250939697027206, -0.01414775662124157, -0.04042348638176918, -0.04401850700378418, -0.012700086459517479, 0.0062799639999866486, 0.02097073383629322, -0.03008018247783184, 0.015106525272130966, 0.01788734458386898, -0.012740788981318474, -0.05154379457235336, 0.037054892629384995, -0.010702630504965782, 0.0053675491362810135, -0.05419262498617172, -0.05202135816216469, 0.04413052275776863, -0.035496171563863754, -0.018434789031744003, -0.00803723931312561, 0.03614816069602966, -0.03452182188630104, 0.026202520355582237, -0.008121184073388577, -0.01334537472575903, -0.005925454199314117, 0.026197072118520737, -0.0617460198700428, -0.011526279151439667, -0.015772080048918724, -0.011706625111401081, 0.018859053030610085, 0.056541476398706436, 0.0030169221572577953, -0.02299424074590206, -0.02431405521929264, -0.0044935038313269615, -0.0028517444152384996, -0.04197341948747635, -0.006745986174792051, 0.02813909761607647, 0.009514597244560719, -0.03726806119084358, 0.05970151349902153, -0.0330171100795269, 0.051578957587480545, -0.03792089223861694, -0.06011107191443443, -0.0125116603448987, -0.006388294976204634, -0.054383158683776855, 0.025099052116274834, -0.035508520901203156, -0.015734564512968063, -0.0233684703707695, 0.0021121888421475887, -0.025441555306315422, -0.07114610075950623, 0.026391208171844482, -0.04731540009379387, -0.01244577020406723, 0.03293502330780029, -0.04658136144280434, 0.06682022660970688, -0.022016527131199837, 0.02690022811293602, 0.043367937207221985, 0.014280976727604866, -0.012513484805822372, -0.05153311416506767, 0.007132265716791153, 0.03127052262425423, 0.014561046846210957, -0.03300340473651886, -0.023780090734362602, -0.022264141589403152, -0.08226337283849716, -0.023148849606513977, -0.03934904932975769, -0.040047574788331985, -0.02864055521786213, -0.06980637460947037, 0.02486363984644413, -0.006249847821891308, -0.011906996369361877, -0.07612733542919159, 0.02825893647968769, -0.006165303755551577, 0.011692477390170097, -0.03472719341516495, -0.008414397947490215, -0.07589896023273468, -0.007166821509599686, -0.06076924130320549, -0.05792925879359245, 0.002686450257897377, 0.08536773920059204, 0.013827893882989883, -0.01712474599480629, 0.0022819493897259235, -0.06009743735194206, -0.01567670702934265, -0.022441811859607697, -0.019252751022577286, -0.03192983940243721, -0.03992205858230591, 0.052446383982896805, -0.008780078962445259, 0.03466867282986641, 0.03267047554254532, -0.024128396064043045, -0.015323284082114697, -0.0027462218422442675, 0.007826194167137146, -0.03666601702570915, 0.03677723929286003, 0.011325515806674957, -0.020483199506998062, 0.0223980899900198, -0.0412154495716095, 0.034100379794836044, -0.018595920875668526, -0.06697454303503036, 0.03941697999835014, -0.03800033777952194, -0.017610512673854828, -0.01964496821165085, -0.04159318283200264, -0.036256469786167145, -0.03574018552899361, -0.0541779026389122, -0.010314399376511574, 0.04473412036895752, -0.009005114436149597, 0.06826557964086533, -0.06165449321269989, 0.02477438934147358, 0.026451854035258293, 0.024965686723589897, -0.014933126047253609, 0.005875968839973211, 0.0069381119683384895, -0.07394126057624817, 0.01459723711013794, -0.060146935284137726, 0.039613403379917145, -0.02365127205848694, -0.01302857231348753, 0.01521881390362978, 0.058252133429050446, -0.07227784395217896, 0.03688402846455574, -0.0632818192243576, -0.00033505918690934777, -0.01003388874232769, -0.05560408532619476, -0.05759534612298012, -0.01877840794622898, 0.018533721566200256, 0.008267689496278763, 0.019034596160054207, -0.007911790162324905, 0.06410104036331177, 0.032314643263816833, -0.04614687338471413, 0.009497962892055511, 0.00955977477133274, 0.026181528344750404, -0.0365474633872509, 0.006286237854510546, -0.02320462465286255, -0.0490134172141552, -0.0006325424765236676, -0.006661921739578247, 0.023877738043665886, 0.03718375787138939, 0.003951173275709152, -0.036574091762304306, -0.0160854272544384, -0.003010075306519866, 0.03366388753056526, -0.016351625323295593, 0.005432290490716696, 0.024153225123882294, 0.023527611047029495, -0.017193112522363663, -0.038385067135095596 ]
The notion of shortcut partition, introduced recently by Chang, Conroy, Le, Milenkovi\'c, Solomon, and Than [CCLMST23], is a new type of graph partition into low-diameter clusters. Roughly speaking, the shortcut partition guarantees that for every two vertices $u$ and $v$ in the graph, there exists a path between $u$ and $v$ that intersects only a few clusters. They proved that any planar graph admits a shortcut partition and gave several applications, including a construction of tree cover for arbitrary planar graphs with stretch $1+\varepsilon$ and $O(1)$ many trees for any fixed $\varepsilon \in (0,1)$. However, the construction heavily exploits planarity in multiple steps, and is thus inherently limited to planar graphs. In this work, we breach the "planarity barrier" to construct a shortcut partition for $K_r$-minor-free graphs for any $r$. To this end, we take a completely different approach -- our key contribution is a novel deterministic variant of the cop decomposition in minor-free graphs [And86, AGG14]. Our shortcut partition for $K_r$-minor-free graphs yields several direct applications. Most notably, we construct the first optimal distance oracle for $K_r$-minor-free graphs, with $1+\varepsilon$ stretch, linear space, and constant query time for any fixed $\varepsilon \in (0,1)$. The previous best distance oracle [AG06] uses $O(n\log n)$ space and $O(\log n)$ query time, and its construction relies on Robertson-Seymour structural theorem and other sophisticated tools. We also obtain the first tree cover of $O(1)$ size for minor-free graphs with stretch $1+\varepsilon$, while the previous best $(1+\varepsilon)$-tree cover has size $O(\log^2 n)$ [BFN19].
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00555v1
[ -0.013138714246451855, -0.041546426713466644, 0.03130684792995453, -0.014808195643126965, 0.01214861311018467, -0.033796172589063644, -0.06238603964447975, -0.006108155939728022, 0.020898479968309402, -0.011805330403149128, -0.019324498251080513, 0.0005103358416818082, 0.002288250019773841, -0.017242498695850372, -0.07014533877372742, 0.02559669315814972, 0.07285358011722565, 0.01474790833890438, -0.054075077176094055, 0.07300327718257904, 0.0021178682800382376, -0.05831558257341385, -0.0015909909270703793, 0.07570992410182953, -0.027188615873456, -0.025873130187392235, -0.0445522777736187, 0.005400726571679115, -0.06620082259178162, -0.013648001477122307, 0.08304359018802643, -0.03960840031504631, -0.049302615225315094, -0.010979506187140942, -0.007757773622870445, 0.012796659022569656, 0.04330301284790039, 0.04328753054141998, 0.004493508953601122, -0.029349040240049362, 0.044047921895980835, -0.06310320645570755, -0.03352624550461769, -0.03614581748843193, -0.03307129070162773, -0.03605695813894272, -0.0006276017520576715, -0.006889853626489639, -0.039669957011938095, -0.006562845781445503, 0.02626098319888115, -0.00027028756448999047, 0.02516789734363556, 0.05234045907855034, -0.044959601014852524, -0.032378777861595154, 0.02224157005548477, 0.03594667464494705, -0.03158675134181976, -0.032414380460977554, 0.008250861428678036, -0.022616755217313766, -0.008194224908947945, -0.044609434902668, -0.021057726815342903, 0.06229119747877121, -0.04055982455611229, -0.08507808297872543, 0.008205696009099483, -0.03688971325755119, 0.028795484453439713, -0.04901669919490814, 0.04500140622258186, 0.027434682473540306, -0.08406379073858261, 0.02835666388273239, -0.04024618864059448, -0.0244124848395586, 0.012222839519381523, -0.006197056267410517, 0.004059002734720707, 0.013055798597633839, 0.021222876384854317, 0.012083951383829117, -0.0007625864236615598, -0.0006438936688937247, 0.04685023054480553, -0.024159332737326622, 0.03914139047265053, -0.056111276149749756, -0.014249011874198914, -0.008605769835412502, -0.06014780327677727, -0.03817891329526901, 0.059753045439720154, -0.043563809245824814, 0.035771001130342484, 0.06551819294691086, 0.015221137553453445, -0.0015340019017457962, 0.0017257765866816044, -0.08535776287317276, -0.006682121194899082, 0.013565822504460812, 0.05686855688691139, -0.03436855599284172, 0.012589400634169579, 0.03731168434023857, -0.008587273769080639, 0.0479266420006752, -0.030771872028708458, 0.05788768082857132, 0.00035922936513088644, -0.03978867083787918, 0.001837078365497291, -0.0776090994477272, 0.07029277086257935, -0.005386737175285816, 0.0614304356276989, -0.027577832341194153, 0.0006444233586080372, 0.027922270819544792, 0.02055048570036888, 0.013933658599853516, -0.0011494985083118081, -0.030381979420781136, 0.0604698583483696, -0.011626861989498138, 0.03504268825054169, 0.00478643923997879, 0.011063951067626476, -0.045097846537828445, -0.003274703398346901, -0.020496323704719543, 0.03299196437001228, -0.01745055429637432, 0.006178508047014475, -0.03652333840727806, 0.019440777599811554, 0.04052679240703583, -0.03973699361085892, -0.04363211989402771, 0.020605605095624924, 0.017912467941641808, -0.00855295080691576, 0.04845288768410683, -0.07623572647571564, -0.006530748214572668, 0.01750076934695244, 0.043232936412096024, 0.01384593266993761, 0.010696752928197384, 0.0015330009628087282, 0.015004688873887062, 0.005985388066619635, -0.0290669035166502, 0.02752871625125408, -0.02553475648164749, -0.04248584434390068, 0.03433165326714516, 0.019196543842554092, -0.02897248975932598, 0.002240583533421159, -0.014671500772237778, -0.00847911648452282, 0.0025805647019296885, 0.03515620529651642, -0.06590087711811066, 0.04025878384709358, 0.041787564754486084, -0.03096175380051136, 0.027855977416038513, -0.006407793611288071, -0.029892435297369957, -0.024188170209527016, -0.013272932730615139, -0.018819672986865044, -0.06020144000649452, -0.0072644962929189205, -0.010105548426508904, 0.00232609617523849, -0.06601713597774506, -0.011681818403303623, -0.06526093184947968, -0.0470413975417614, -0.01200782973319292, -0.06674058735370636, 0.03534628078341484, 0.026219792664051056, 0.024613099172711372, -0.03896548971533775, -0.03673455864191055, 0.06410533934831619, 0.005657499190419912, 0.011099561117589474, -0.04153449088335037, -0.009645076468586922, -0.0035950292367488146, -0.016995130106806755, 0.03552359342575073, -0.06679347157478333, -0.000833028054330498, -0.017589569091796875, 0.01895816996693611, 0.02202112041413784, -0.08210859447717667, 0.05333474278450012, 0.020822951570153236, -0.013502112589776516, -0.03902263194322586, 0.06529635936021805, -0.006446227431297302, 0.03325865790247917, -0.03808159381151199, -0.02329265885055065, -0.004686777014285326, -0.1019357368350029, 0.013296235352754593, -0.008032958954572678, -0.032645247876644135, -0.022147057577967644, 0.014454588294029236, -0.05037738382816315, -0.07963217794895172, -0.042118512094020844, 0.04664027690887451, 0.027197521179914474, -0.004234749358147383, -0.02198007144033909, -0.003993606194853783, -0.0247251745313406, -0.05056760087609291, -0.029369940981268883, -0.048876795917749405, -0.02431335486471653, -0.00431071687489748, -0.05302252247929573, 0.05392497032880783, -0.008052603341639042, -0.07865110784769058, -0.06920968741178513, 0.0072668613865971565, 0.05615203455090523, -0.009541048668324947, -0.06423916667699814, -0.01991880126297474, -0.06553176045417786, -0.024878080934286118, -0.014791406691074371, 0.04451514780521393, -0.00815535243600607, -0.025727378204464912, 0.0021477434784173965, -0.018187247216701508, 0.017410213127732277, 0.04287172853946686, -0.0016915069427341223, 0.01180026400834322, -0.028621764853596687, 0.01500036008656025, -0.004114523995667696, 0.015202718786895275, -0.021872971206903458, -0.017158890143036842, 0.006447222083806992, 0.007712832186371088, -0.04384135082364082, -0.034743938595056534, -0.007525271736085415, -0.029108190909028053, -0.013071266002953053, -0.0022389802616089582, 0.05898825824260712, -0.019870607182383537, -0.016838669776916504, -0.028866611421108246, -0.003743367036804557, -0.03760402649641037, -0.0018393835052847862, -0.009392421692609787, 0.02757316082715988, 0.035653382539749146, -0.04467329382896423, -0.08341555297374725, -0.023600473999977112, -0.03043603152036667, -0.01759362779557705, -0.05728155001997948, -0.049842964857816696, -0.037857234477996826, -0.05081133171916008, -0.005075217690318823, -0.00646661501377821, -0.03281078487634659, -0.03702255338430405, -0.07268743962049484, 0.004694916307926178, -0.030635427683591843, 0.002816283144056797, -0.06395207345485687, -0.01660425029695034, -0.035314034670591354, 0.025928806513547897, 0.029314445331692696, 0.003998891916126013, -0.05135367810726166, -0.047069452702999115, 0.009000949561595917, -0.021786410361528397, -0.022580306977033615, -0.012642807327210903, 0.02462785504758358, -0.008408939465880394, 0.020253321155905724, 0.030109185725450516, 0.054452914744615555, 0.020902084186673164, -0.06834718585014343, 0.026720620691776276, -0.04815836250782013, -0.01641017012298107, -0.009787346236407757, 0.04578402638435364, -0.03819956257939339, -0.06303251534700394, 0.025392908602952957, 0.025774257257580757, 0.04251972585916519, -0.038663074374198914, -0.024957982823252678, 0.016430068761110306, -0.026660844683647156, 0.004722849000245333, -0.03011452965438366, 0.036628056317567825, 0.036125343292951584, -0.04719463735818863, 0.02696261927485466, -0.03154461085796356, -0.007645587436854839, -0.03492504730820656, 0.04370804876089096, -0.004291120450943708, -0.020350774750113487, -0.006743596401065588, -0.09591610729694366, 0.06216668710112572, 0.07209096848964691, 0.054761070758104324, -0.048401717096567154, 0.0018689744174480438, 0.004630556330084801, 0.007094678469002247, -0.027036793529987335, -0.0583786778151989, -0.015744082629680634, 0.07082094997167587, 0.0643894150853157, -0.021700521931052208, -0.042126525193452835, 0.0005774282035417855, -0.07130687683820724, 0.01882426254451275, 0.019503291696310043, 0.016979122534394264, 0.04176587611436844, 0.054353248327970505, -0.004924061242491007, 0.02703934721648693, -0.029208220541477203, 0.058120422065258026, 0.0065534524619579315, -0.05385460704565048, -0.006185924168676138, 0.0355273112654686, -0.005539290141314268, -0.011240685358643532, -0.020291224122047424, 0.000019756898836931214, -0.04858580231666565, -0.027973949909210205, -0.046055663377046585, 0.016000866889953613, 0.023347876965999603, 0.010571654886007309, 0.0145425945520401, 0.006400567479431629, -0.012373233214020729, 0.02588033676147461, -0.019007422029972076, -0.0009654407040216029, 0.0024218920152634382, 0.045867398381233215, 0.021543942391872406, -0.033707279711961746, -0.024364441633224487, -0.012871607206761837, -0.014996839687228203, -0.05641454458236694, -0.05286376178264618, 0.032318536192178726, 0.008055726066231728, -0.010760641656816006, -0.08275206387042999, -0.029283516108989716, -0.025639137253165245, 0.015043318271636963, -0.006397436372935772, -0.04966703802347183, 0.05786644667387009, -0.03415527194738388, 0.016483455896377563, -0.025662515312433243, 0.025271102786064148, -0.022293251007795334, -0.006079045590013266, -0.03911980614066124, -0.03511298820376396, 0.024113206192851067, -0.012600456364452839, 0.039588939398527145, 0.029841886833310127, 0.00554930604994297, -0.04574446380138397, 0.029371654614806175, -0.05361773818731308, 0.020396530628204346, 0.027554772794246674, 0.05384037271142006, 0.01002417504787445, -0.02430431731045246, -0.02147643454372883, 0.01844475045800209, -0.04923401027917862, -0.017643693834543228, -0.051936693489551544, 0.03253481909632683, -0.005841062404215336, -0.033533308655023575, 0.000016786892956588417, -0.02475205808877945, 0.020858192816376686, -0.07384088635444641, -0.04727867245674133, 0.005772728938609362, 0.017973726615309715, -0.07955392450094223, -0.06316360086202621, 0.005766657646745443, -0.03402510657906532, -0.03915977105498314, -0.02964681386947632, 0.02706640213727951, 0.04064277559518814, -0.0043747639283537865, 0.04451725631952286, 0.02751733921468258, 0.04120602086186409, -0.03473047912120819, -0.0009535254212096334, 0.054817330092191696, 0.022024191915988922, -0.015768105164170265, -0.00627296045422554, -0.06768824905157089, -0.022981833666563034, 0.00027389556635171175, 0.04013960435986519, 0.003958083689212799, 0.033433105796575546, -0.036157701164484024, 0.028533630073070526, -0.07893040776252747, 0.025167865678668022, 0.04644228145480156, -0.0472465343773365, 0.031933460384607315, 0.03547663614153862, -0.008276080712676048, 0.0454028956592083, 0.015263919718563557, 0.04138176888227463, 0.026327351108193398, -0.028305426239967346, -0.017677810043096542, -0.01008083950728178, -0.04082966968417168, 0.015585826709866524, 0.042615532875061035, -0.0256935004144907, -0.015822842717170715, 0.03310994431376457, -0.0031418048311024904, 0.03426201641559601, -0.043141599744558334, 0.03995277360081673, 0.00226992042735219, -0.06050809845328331, -0.07404712587594986, -0.01565932109951973, -0.012585822492837906, 0.00514586828649044, 0.0012896310072392225, -0.03100939653813839, -0.015890920534729958, 0.0520462691783905, -0.009922542609274387, -0.00613792147487402, 0.040562935173511505, 0.01193879172205925, -0.05702086538076401, -0.027602817863225937, -0.0460393987596035, -0.016962910071015358, -0.01675408147275448, -0.02472577430307865, 0.020216958597302437, 0.019336512312293053, -0.027920439839363098, 0.0514126792550087, 0.028273779898881912, -0.03256458044052124, -0.024644862860441208, -0.005657213740050793, -0.019686101004481316, 0.06735016405582428, -0.0633632019162178, 0.006765492260456085, -0.019815487787127495, 0.012441441416740417, -0.003753460245206952, -0.0017088864697143435, -0.04089280217885971, -0.04951713979244232, -0.021556464955210686, 0.027766751125454903, 0.028608666732907295, -0.03226769343018532, -0.054617248475551605, -0.023288263007998466, 0.043073758482933044, -0.06171058490872383, 0.06456109881401062, 0.02141505852341652, 0.034585047513246536, 0.044051967561244965, 0.012031097896397114, 0.02837385982275009, -0.0743924081325531, -0.05194874852895737, 0.023540552705526352, -0.07435279339551926, 0.00024190422846004367, 0.02286873199045658, -0.06375746428966522, -0.012614007107913494, -0.024747192859649658, 0.033577777445316315, 0.009809021838009357, -0.004169975873082876, -0.05649708956480026, 0.06476782262325287, 0.010885056108236313, -0.04864254593849182, -0.0018667193362489343, 0.029525205492973328, -0.06146358698606491, -0.013833832927048206, -0.02403094992041588, -0.02808327041566372, -0.02114560827612877, 0.024175357073545456, -0.01163465902209282, -0.07035000622272491, -0.02808976359665394, 0.039432331919670105, 0.04582483321428299, -0.03434612229466438, 0.06179007142782211, 0.00496722012758255, -0.029740240424871445, 0.011932240799069405, -0.054797932505607605, 0.001359233632683754, -0.01751680299639702, 0.03829914331436157, -0.01567661017179489, -0.03846605122089386, -0.05134123936295509, 0.048611097037792206, -0.03703747317194939, -0.052667390555143356, 0.003297349438071251, -0.006814517546445131, 0.05991022288799286, -0.031936924904584885, -0.019044138491153717, -0.020157847553491592, -0.02997491881251335, 0.01910112053155899, -0.04528113827109337, 0.04553926736116409, -0.020698493346571922, 0.02298809587955475, 0.03780720382928848, 0.0026004365645349026, -0.014833700843155384, -0.017328273504972458, -0.06444597244262695, -0.03484790027141571, -0.08434414118528366, -0.020136717706918716, -0.024050792679190636, 0.0601528063416481, -0.02311493642628193, 0.0215366892516613, -0.017373858019709587, 0.0026586968451738358, -0.04216155409812927, -0.006609495263546705, -0.013813316822052002, -0.00830401387065649, 0.031321872025728226, 0.012011093087494373, 0.06119084358215332, -0.05414728447794914, 0.0470280721783638, -0.03196932375431061, -0.006244594231247902, 0.03108285926282406, -0.04612887650728226, -0.07623368501663208, -0.009487658739089966, 0.007800530642271042, -0.045605823397636414, 0.020039182156324387, -0.0011645585764199495, -0.019326401874423027, -0.05693792551755905, 0.005415655672550201, 0.01222025603055954, -0.02989070676267147, 0.011595812626183033, -0.03129998967051506, 0.013477392494678497, 0.011256055906414986, 0.022835908457636833, 0.05258098989725113, 0.024691976606845856, -0.03172573819756508, -0.048133015632629395, 0.0011184957111254334, 0.007487810682505369, -0.033807363361120224, -0.0342954620718956, -0.02827528491616249, -0.04300081357359886, -0.07326582819223404, 0.026212595403194427, -0.005907080601900816, 0.007951742969453335, -0.059145860373973846, -0.039309076964855194, 0.02306048944592476, 0.0060135358944535255, 0.01567656360566616, -0.06165517866611481, -0.020940210670232773, 0.029461601749062538, -0.019260697066783905, -0.04647032544016838, -0.027006221935153008, -0.06430792063474655, -0.005320950411260128, -0.08189600706100464, -0.035774338990449905, 0.007145215291529894, 0.020456725731492043, 0.031444720923900604, 0.03381479158997536, -0.050348080694675446, -0.022036967799067497, 0.0014388663694262505, 0.009978214278817177, -0.007494825404137373, -0.009819460101425648, 0.035670798271894455, -0.04206341877579689, 0.011852160096168518, 0.007769811898469925, 0.01954428106546402, -0.015936147421598434, 0.009401746094226837, 0.040406495332717896, 0.04901569336652756, -0.026210065931081772, 0.03498705103993416, 0.05929522216320038, 0.014262817800045013, 0.07284945994615555, -0.0530870296061039, -0.03930993750691414, -0.014442889019846916, -0.06103752925992012, 0.002378301229327917, -0.04445295035839081, -0.0232003815472126, -0.016133427619934082, -0.0392741896212101, -0.03575221449136734, 0.009332168847322464, -0.02827991172671318, 0.05348014831542969, -0.014554763212800026, -0.01605459488928318, 0.011058454401791096, -0.0597212016582489, -0.027407217770814896, -0.010685473680496216, -0.02121090143918991, -0.05555533617734909, 0.0272792037576437, 0.05683815851807594, -0.01630697399377823, 0.03591802716255188, -0.05241632089018822, 0.017448246479034424, -0.01750601828098297, -0.0019937779288738966, 0.0649314597249031, 0.014293821528553963, 0.020682232454419136, 0.012755542062222958, -0.054856207221746445, -0.018026385456323624, 0.05811385065317154, -0.043917398899793625, 0.032954972237348557, -0.010341408662497997, 0.0035029936116188765, 0.025468066334724426, 0.02908598631620407, -0.016541840508580208, 0.06294900178909302, 0.04437330737709999, -0.00402044178918004, 0.005196361802518368, 0.04709708318114281, -0.030707649886608124, 0.0705438181757927, 0.0033319001086056232, -0.01611354760825634, -0.03772219642996788, 0.01816863939166069, -0.03434860706329346, -0.00006344637222355232, -0.02861337549984455, -0.016618121415376663, 0.044909585267305374, -0.059382036328315735, 0.02987511456012726, 0.038403771817684174, 0.051616519689559937, -0.04514371231198311, -0.002488731872290373, 0.00855260994285345, -0.023545756936073303, -0.04055162891745567 ]
Deep neural network models can learn clinically relevant features from millions of histopathology images. However generating high-quality annotations to train such models for each hospital, each cancer type, and each diagnostic task is prohibitively laborious. On the other hand, terabytes of training data -- while lacking reliable annotations -- are readily available in the public domain in some cases. In this work, we explore how these large datasets can be consciously utilized to pre-train deep networks to encode informative representations. We then fine-tune our pre-trained models on a fraction of annotated training data to perform specific downstream tasks. We show that our approach can reach the state-of-the-art (SOTA) for patch-level classification with only 1-10% randomly selected annotations compared to other SOTA approaches. Moreover, we propose an uncertainty-aware loss function, to quantify the model confidence during inference. Quantified uncertainty helps experts select the best instances to label for further training. Our uncertainty-aware labeling reaches the SOTA with significantly fewer annotations compared to random labeling. Last, we demonstrate how our pre-trained encoders can surpass current SOTA for whole-slide image classification with weak supervision. Our work lays the foundation for data and task-agnostic pre-trained deep networks with quantified uncertainty.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07113v1
[ -0.018359754234552383, -0.014004811644554138, 0.054033808410167694, 0.00887887179851532, -0.003893574932590127, -0.02248728834092617, 0.031215954571962357, 0.01998906396329403, 0.022006291896104813, -0.05345284566283226, -0.029062187299132347, 0.01653602533042431, -0.06994708627462387, -0.0407402440905571, -0.01669207774102688, 0.008271953091025352, 0.07209498435258865, 0.027272112667560577, -0.04720263555645943, 0.07093959301710129, 0.0456070601940155, 0.01338067278265953, -0.031965792179107666, 0.02043391577899456, 0.01853124052286148, -0.03974214196205139, -0.02502566948533058, -0.009726903401315212, 0.003680917900055647, -0.02618234232068062, 0.048532307147979736, -0.01212029904127121, -0.05004686117172241, -0.020952990278601646, -0.006621356587857008, -0.03278965875506401, 0.0014865652192384005, 0.015120803378522396, 0.0057031805627048016, -0.06480707973241806, 0.04476350173354149, -0.06349021196365356, -0.039615336805582047, -0.03822914510965347, -0.05143450200557709, 0.03543394058942795, -0.038629475980997086, 0.020374275743961334, -0.06514929980039597, -0.01448444090783596, 0.07222031056880951, -0.008167758584022522, -0.01197324600070715, 0.05670154094696045, -0.024238096550107002, 0.010393546894192696, -0.03918813169002533, 0.03762301802635193, -0.07663911581039429, 0.02888024039566517, 0.028918195515871048, -0.03423870727419853, 0.007387677673250437, -0.030313625931739807, 0.02482086420059204, 0.04695529118180275, 0.03275046497583389, -0.07630572468042374, -0.07141021639108658, -0.03697656840085983, 0.06526461243629456, -0.04878431186079979, 0.027428915724158287, 0.011873429641127586, -0.05030239745974541, -0.032995257526636124, -0.040944814682006836, 0.013508933596313, 0.028029976412653923, 0.0021650337148457766, -0.04226992651820183, 0.03415216505527496, 0.004308934323489666, 0.04033023118972778, -0.0077049620449543, -0.04222647845745087, 0.043682560324668884, -0.024702977389097214, -0.0008677799487486482, -0.053240347653627396, 0.00843794271349907, -0.04557707533240318, -0.08190266788005829, 0.0237275380641222, 0.05917760357260704, -0.033251553773880005, 0.04161209613084793, -0.009865154512226582, 0.007947198115289211, -0.005273020826280117, -0.014557315967977047, 0.02035139501094818, 0.01502965483814478, 0.05382144823670387, 0.03621506690979004, -0.014640215784311295, 0.016102394089102745, -0.02521343342959881, -0.07428661733865738, -0.004719575401395559, -0.03927244246006012, -0.0471215695142746, 0.016012826934456825, -0.06041864678263664, -0.05458725616335869, -0.0391584187746048, 0.06291592121124268, 0.0005859195371158421, -0.0039853439666330814, -0.019180648028850555, 0.004440636839717627, 0.03220829740166664, 0.03444484993815422, -0.02105320431292057, -0.039236027747392654, -0.012351294979453087, 0.04642471671104431, 0.004486591089516878, -0.05152428522706032, -0.010928971692919731, -0.020016580820083618, 0.015336076728999615, -0.05010436475276947, 0.0024240780621767044, 0.04937383905053139, -0.03337602689862251, -0.00877327285706997, -0.05282057076692581, 0.02910737134516239, 0.011869692243635654, -0.02278376743197441, -0.04607255384325981, -0.0032903049141168594, -0.016229627653956413, -0.010365108028054237, 0.05643197149038315, -0.05266718193888664, -0.03145163506269455, 0.06419990211725235, 0.02525508962571621, 0.00743476115167141, 0.001891112420707941, -0.005233703646808863, 0.028695959597826004, 0.04940749704837799, -0.019698482006788254, 0.03760037198662758, -0.03764423727989197, -0.05679696798324585, -0.0024362141266465187, -0.021652961149811745, -0.024125337600708008, 0.008840296417474747, -0.046230386942625046, 0.03796705603599548, -0.04482094943523407, 0.010019518435001373, -0.019991323351860046, -0.00309689249843359, -0.005165015812963247, -0.022733740508556366, -0.005556544288992882, 0.001658913679420948, -0.01112111285328865, -0.048069536685943604, -0.009046327322721481, 0.04853254556655884, -0.04334693402051926, -0.05804396793246269, -0.023035136982798576, 0.0014717327430844307, 0.02453780174255371, -0.004844272509217262, -0.014846584759652615, -0.02839881367981434, -0.015482846647500992, -0.08274804800748825, -0.013273998163640499, 0.04465917497873306, -0.005632226821035147, -0.05026471987366676, 0.004027028568089008, 0.03234521672129631, -0.012864088639616966, 0.03977949917316437, -0.04593458026647568, -0.023759113624691963, -0.0035597498062998056, 0.001274332869797945, 0.05032980069518089, -0.09102561324834824, -0.04581044614315033, -0.064837746322155, 0.016173861920833588, 0.005976782646030188, -0.028229176998138428, -0.0007111871964298189, 0.016694996505975723, -0.05462152510881424, 0.031376294791698456, 0.06096010282635689, 0.05828767642378807, 0.059984512627124786, 0.0014879924710839987, 0.05665253475308418, -0.035651277750730515, -0.09670170396566391, 0.042121436446905136, -0.0031810496002435684, -0.02314293198287487, 0.027738861739635468, 0.004916538950055838, -0.0227811336517334, -0.045469511300325394, 0.0023295003920793533, 0.0634637176990509, 0.05988484248518944, -0.012637907639145851, -0.0036666563246399164, -0.033548615872859955, -0.0023989598266780376, -0.025565942749381065, -0.010464074090123177, -0.07548800110816956, -0.012450254522264004, -0.02529534138739109, -0.03976714611053467, -0.00741224130615592, -0.016128545626997948, -0.0067889029160141945, -0.04643772915005684, -0.023668810725212097, 0.03040010668337345, -0.027356937527656555, -0.05723940581083298, -0.021110130473971367, -0.03775382786989212, 0.02100764401257038, 0.015208616852760315, 0.002630260307341814, -0.053299445658922195, -0.029172414913773537, 0.028765182942152023, -0.010651282034814358, 0.05799982324242592, -0.004762620665132999, -0.0171346478164196, 0.02957187220454216, -0.045080773532390594, 0.048163942992687225, 0.0249069482088089, 0.027230003848671913, -0.05441053584218025, 0.00650235079228878, 0.04373561590909958, -0.010733399540185928, -0.020453762263059616, -0.002217405242845416, 0.034510672092437744, -0.02724718675017357, -0.017156969755887985, 0.06517104804515839, 0.0548538938164711, -0.011698559857904911, -0.04346100613474846, -0.04375781863927841, -0.004899989813566208, -0.02813033014535904, 0.026732733473181725, 0.046488258987665176, 0.04966622591018677, 0.026631223037838936, -0.0007516674813814461, -0.06772538274526596, -0.02810966596007347, -0.05960608646273613, 8.253603596131143e-7, -0.07864303886890411, -0.05971214920282364, -0.02467743679881096, -0.0811569020152092, -0.009303940460085869, -0.061772529035806656, -0.020089246332645416, -0.002718186005949974, -0.04725349321961403, -0.0628289207816124, 0.022936131805181503, 0.0264222901314497, 0.00935134943574667, -0.02609904669225216, -0.03358682617545128, 0.023344654589891434, 0.007992533035576344, 0.02145959995687008, -0.07604200392961502, -0.012292169034481049, -0.0005445661954581738, 0.0506763830780983, 0.00939006358385086, 0.0007699565030634403, 0.00484353955835104, -0.031454846262931824, 0.026956843212246895, -0.01562652736902237, 0.030431736260652542, 0.0010100012877956033, 0.04141002893447876, 0.005354695487767458, -0.04382544383406639, 0.047297459095716476, -0.03277600556612015, -0.0117218978703022, -0.06496141850948334, -0.023020049557089806, -0.01123295072466135, 0.06789530813694, 0.01386613491922617, -0.043073467910289764, -0.04330433905124664, 0.0047698053531348705, 0.033881720155477524, -0.012955475598573685, -0.026382669806480408, 0.032835837453603745, 0.05179028958082199, -0.03946081921458244, 0.004554535262286663, -0.002739673713222146, 0.016419237479567528, 0.006806253455579281, 0.025529222562909126, -0.06602741777896881, 0.038396138697862625, 0.054006364196538925, -0.09193896502256393, 0.0012428078334778547, 0.0383576974272728, 0.06628210097551346, -0.002505361568182707, 0.0013883283827453852, -0.004261477384716272, 0.03898627683520317, 0.025085747241973877, 0.019476350396871567, 0.02516551874577999, 0.024996746331453323, 0.053462281823158264, -0.041103873401880264, -0.06295577436685562, 0.007977590896189213, -0.05343928933143616, -0.03470182418823242, 0.029785607010126114, 0.012371989898383617, 0.01613559015095234, 0.006390891037881374, -0.07221812009811401, 0.006397577468305826, 0.024415764957666397, 0.05912955850362778, -0.021509012207388878, 0.0034517799504101276, 0.03608262538909912, -0.06240334361791611, 0.04768260195851326, -0.014690123498439789, -0.0013626808067783713, 0.02153206802904606, -0.03696785494685173, 0.041756074875593185, -0.05964881181716919, 0.012560373172163963, 0.03826485946774483, -0.011401600204408169, 0.02339891903102398, 0.07455781102180481, -0.013552481308579445, 0.019977638497948647, -0.036636289209127426, -0.00899212621152401, 0.0037050906103104353, 0.021021202206611633, -0.007799586746841669, -0.002318659797310829, -0.05749141052365303, -0.027925245463848114, 0.019640261307358742, -0.030841510742902756, -0.0004666996537707746, -0.035702601075172424, -0.002220200141891837, 0.0035027051344513893, -0.08521407097578049, 0.01818566769361496, -0.003914954606443644, 0.03355906158685684, -0.022160949185490608, -0.008091255091130733, 0.045771438628435135, -0.032732490450143814, -0.014862090349197388, -0.03273853659629822, -0.034873947501182556, -0.0065430812537670135, -0.0016581231029704213, -0.016455715522170067, -0.06541656702756882, -0.004067582078278065, -0.05302722752094269, 0.02781561203300953, -0.010530130937695503, 0.009671972133219242, -0.06975472718477249, -0.012005278840661049, -0.02880079485476017, 0.023335976526141167, 0.015618551522493362, 0.01928611658513546, -0.022551439702510834, -0.018323928117752075, 0.031545571982860565, -0.010603725910186768, 0.0037250076420605183, -0.01703498698771, -0.03623247146606445, -0.0019554500468075275, -0.01091055665165186, -0.03066682256758213, -0.04777556285262108, 0.011812008917331696, 0.03421877697110176, -0.030395448207855225, -0.0007125054253265262, -0.012429661117494106, 0.01831754483282566, -0.029880106449127197, -0.05268901214003563, -0.02927849441766739, -0.05355759710073471, -0.046234726905822754, -0.01482868567109108, 0.027507930994033813, 0.04195861890912056, -0.029793525114655495, 0.003362883348017931, 0.04340612515807152, 0.007244110107421875, 0.0062977587804198265, 0.02620728127658367, 0.020048845559358597, -0.01125773973762989, 0.0014723370550200343, -0.023461900651454926, -0.06719445437192917, -0.01725858263671398, -0.007145582232624292, -0.018306424841284752, -0.023786485195159912, 0.030769232660531998, -0.003028128296136856, 0.06594038754701614, -0.07027842849493027, 0.027244582772254944, 0.028940897434949875, -0.017783273011446, 0.02772935852408409, 0.06373776495456696, -0.004609331022948027, 0.03990454226732254, -0.033794987946748734, 0.026175806298851967, 0.017349472269415855, -0.04119404777884483, 0.019658466801047325, 0.0018579349853098392, -0.012705864384770393, -0.022209487855434418, 0.05481351166963577, 0.022964881733059883, -0.04524780809879303, 0.038684308528900146, 0.04588868096470833, -0.002956443466246128, -0.044344499707221985, -0.017054948955774307, 0.060479480773210526, -0.007049659267067909, -0.02598056197166443, 0.02170424349606037, 0.008741597644984722, -0.002568604424595833, 0.022350788116455078, -0.05725352466106415, -0.031595584005117416, 0.07077454030513763, -0.028725607320666313, 0.004011250101029873, 0.04597991704940796, -0.011956672184169292, 0.03283772990107536, 0.02773924730718136, 0.014146149158477783, -0.04489842429757118, -0.04092167690396309, -0.017209067940711975, 0.04795733094215393, 0.05031237378716469, 0.016259480267763138, 0.00997900776565075, 0.02053826116025448, -0.03752946853637695, -0.020012294873595238, -0.031636785715818405, -0.010461078956723213, 0.027484947815537453, -0.03704895079135895, 0.017818305641412735, 0.012089243158698082, 0.03963630646467209, 0.012409817427396774, 0.05459757149219513, -0.004367303103208542, 0.01884758472442627, -0.04088100790977478, 0.0001286849146708846, 0.06028471887111664, -0.005622570402920246, -0.07485494017601013, 0.022761469706892967, 0.009726377204060555, -0.009552686475217342, -0.008928781375288963, 0.031930651515722275, -0.017626570537686348, 0.026757724583148956, -0.006515387911349535, -0.04234733060002327, -0.03542136028409004, 0.024397367611527443, 0.049162887036800385, -0.059216178953647614, 0.016006948426365852, -0.023222940042614937, -0.005964930634945631, 0.03521410748362541, -0.02155882678925991, 0.021833578124642372, 0.029892118647694588, 0.00877764355391264, -0.058505479246377945, 0.024941200390458107, 0.0018800790421664715, -0.07995278388261795, -0.0047543966211378574, -0.005728626623749733, -0.08689629286527634, 0.012956386432051659, 0.027382925152778625, -0.007784514222294092, -0.046918295323848724, 0.05662800371646881, 0.019645031541585922, 0.011851247400045395, -0.020852087065577507, 0.05877028778195381, 0.08795242011547089, 0.01798904314637184, -0.0036520070862025023, 0.03657354786992073, -0.032118216156959534, 0.021894320845603943, -0.053013876080513, 0.028948895633220673, 0.03062547743320465, 0.04019700363278389, -0.020625285804271698, -0.03717910125851631, -0.038522083312273026, 0.06602010875940323, -0.06818651407957077, -0.009037524461746216, 0.0034066769294440746, -0.0248664952814579, 0.056987132877111435, -0.04290012642741203, -0.04771185293793678, 0.047862522304058075, 0.01086220983415842, -0.01059869397431612, -0.06227084621787071, 0.027769073843955994, -0.004746750462800264, 0.011352774687111378, 0.0020374285522848368, -0.08207893371582031, -0.02479698695242405, -0.014087730087339878, -0.056922852993011475, 0.022901611402630806, -0.0812297984957695, 0.016944019123911858, -0.04798388108611107, 0.03823397681117058, 0.035430241376161575, 0.08051254600286484, -0.03802689164876938, -0.038834430277347565, 0.0013365175109356642, 0.03874416649341583, 0.02539731003344059, -0.025816775858402252, 0.005268655717372894, -0.05606325715780258, -0.016402315348386765, -0.03916007652878761, -0.021033652126789093, 0.023263458162546158, -0.044531043618917465, 0.040565330535173416, -0.024611542001366615, -0.027446366846561432, -0.04325222969055176, 0.019595427438616753, -0.06397375464439392, 0.037053465843200684, 0.00022540711506735533, -0.03882092237472534, -0.07392550259828568, -0.03302706405520439, -0.018447594717144966, -0.0008269147365354002, 0.01648411713540554, 0.03850178420543671, 0.043268460780382156, -0.021339435130357742, 0.020085005089640617, 0.015418107621371746, -0.02549026720225811, -0.006981360260397196, -0.06532951444387436, 0.018217645585536957, 0.02236945927143097, 0.016137266531586647, -0.034802138805389404, -0.019378533586859703, -0.023230139166116714, -0.0652952566742897, -0.003135527251288295, 0.025787750259041786, 0.014437045902013779, -0.04013843089342117, -0.06987817585468292, 0.03903414309024811, -0.00990145094692707, -0.016414139419794083, -0.017124852165579796, -0.03608931601047516, -0.005429357290267944, -0.05699664726853371, -0.043771494179964066, -0.03455708175897598, -0.059053532779216766, 0.010544370859861374, -0.08422504365444183, -0.007998570799827576, 0.0057060569524765015, 0.010084280744194984, -0.014474544674158096, -0.04472942650318146, -0.01940322294831276, -0.035548146814107895, 0.022048136219382286, -0.004919877741485834, -0.017116505652666092, -0.007991226390004158, 0.03130854293704033, -0.02419743500649929, -0.06540382653474808, -0.017501942813396454, 0.024876834824681282, -0.05590397119522095, -0.022138819098472595, 0.02215101756155491, 0.042904820293188095, 0.017033079639077187, -0.0011839247308671474, 0.05498471483588219, -0.03782454878091812, 0.03479275479912758, -0.0578947514295578, 0.02758893184363842, -0.033226750791072845, -0.01515886839479208, 0.041272781789302826, -0.028130831196904182, -0.03015737794339657, -0.011092866770923138, -0.016815317794680595, -0.006299077533185482, -0.062149837613105774, -0.024470463395118713, 0.04023861512541771, -0.011591635644435883, 0.017431369051337242, 0.03882987052202225, -0.030841808766126633, 0.006537795066833496, -0.032106272876262665, -0.040066998451948166, -0.02250676043331623, 0.016794700175523758, 0.02963869646191597, -0.033287905156612396, -0.03305705264210701, -0.06295832246541977, -0.01504279300570488, -0.0029224837198853493, -0.00710280891507864, -0.014405093155801296, 0.07093098759651184, 0.02518552541732788, -0.018394632264971733, -0.003104670438915491, -0.05442705377936363, -0.014005540870130062, -0.05486379936337471, -0.029923569411039352, -0.004454411566257477, 0.019043752923607826, -0.034394390881061554, 0.008275560103356838, 0.026565855368971825, 0.06096472218632698, -0.002131848828867078, 0.03186284378170967, -0.005088291130959988, 0.022290412336587906, -0.05441255494952202, 0.08350500464439392, -0.001838389434851706, 0.058676913380622864, -0.03622402995824814, 0.04866598919034004, 0.018013430759310722, -0.031324464827775955, 0.04518607258796692, 0.007403737399727106, 0.033392198383808136, -0.08153242617845535, -0.013110476545989513, 0.017626456916332245, -0.03370371460914612, -0.05475090444087982, -0.004047953989356756, 0.0023667309433221817, -0.031617172062397, -0.06213965639472008 ]
Recent works have shown that in contrast to classical linear elastic fracture mechanics, endowing crack fronts in a brittle Green-elastic solid with Steigmann-Ogden surface elasticity yields a model that predicts bounded stresses and strains at the crack tips for plane-strain problems. However, singularities persist for anti-plane shear (mode-III fracture) under far-field loading, even when Steigmann-Ogden surface elasticity is incorporated. This work is motivated by obtaining a model of brittle fracture capable of predicting bounded stresses and strains for all modes of loading. We formulate an exact general theory of a three-dimensional solid containing a boundary surface with strain-gradient surface elasticity. For planar reference surfaces parameterized by flat coordinates, the form of surface elasticity reduces to that introduced by Hilgers and Pipkin, and when the surface energy is independent of the surface covariant derivative of the stretching, the theory reduces to that of Steigmann and Ogden. We discuss material symmetry using Murdoch and Cohen's extension of Noll's theory. We present a model small-strain surface energy that incorporates resistance to geodesic distortion, satisfies strong ellipticity, and requires the same material constants found in the Steigmann-Ogden theory. Finally, we derive and apply the linearized theory to mode-III fracture in an infinite plate under far-field loading. We prove that there always exists a unique classical solution to the governing integro-differential equation, and in contrast to using Steigmann-Ogden surface elasticity, our model is consistent with the linearization assumption in predicting finite stresses and strains at the crack tips.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13744v3
[ -0.02587294764816761, -0.025753268972039223, 0.01919594220817089, -0.007175524719059467, -0.01635422371327877, -0.00560711370781064, 0.007574291899800301, 0.04195581004023552, -0.02050827257335186, 0.0011333901202306151, 0.0011980730341747403, -0.00021797636873088777, -0.03719497099518776, -0.029369058087468147, -0.027683397755026817, 0.006817691493779421, 0.08196917176246643, -0.019258704036474228, -0.0615851916372776, 0.05536625161767006, 0.01067700982093811, -0.009017908945679665, -0.022927604615688324, 0.05793805047869682, -0.05386919155716896, -0.0010352242970839143, -0.06318225711584091, -0.01729855313897133, -0.004309372510761023, 0.002512097591534257, 0.07045850902795792, -0.01675737462937832, 0.015285324305295944, -0.017509007826447487, -0.0030183130875229836, -0.013556716032326221, -0.015404115431010723, 0.004384043626487255, 0.03265842795372009, -0.03262912109494209, -0.01993517205119133, -0.03297118842601776, -0.05222935229539871, -0.0011631373781710863, -0.01060856506228447, -0.03340638056397438, 0.022434482350945473, 0.036397598683834076, -0.05133112147450447, -0.05101976916193962, 0.06603187322616577, 0.004173147492110729, -0.01482634712010622, 0.009945029392838478, -0.016348708420991898, -0.011674615554511547, -0.01894654892385006, -0.006755588576197624, -0.026218106970191002, -0.048636678606271744, -0.008735648356378078, -0.03588538616895676, -0.05127568915486336, -0.0053694345988333225, -0.04741780832409859, 0.031747493892908096, -0.029280709102749825, -0.06775745749473572, 0.014429818838834763, -0.07528623193502426, 0.015237276442348957, -0.0653696209192276, -0.0049333455972373486, 0.009898821823298931, -0.007201033178716898, 0.02639712393283844, -0.06541068851947784, -0.015367851592600346, -0.024780144914984703, -0.023532329127192497, 0.006038253661245108, -0.002146771876141429, 0.04395417124032974, 0.028898771852254868, 0.03312983736395836, 0.004180715419352055, 0.026159344241023064, -0.015978939831256866, -0.003813304239884019, -0.03515246510505676, 0.05148942396044731, -0.012846292927861214, -0.04636218398809433, -0.006135678384453058, 0.04239807650446892, -0.06420683115720749, 0.02840101160109043, 0.04470678046345711, 0.03585998713970184, -0.03894916549324989, -0.04700247198343277, -0.059237655252218246, -0.02080216258764267, 0.04984292760491371, -0.004052736330777407, -0.00959013681858778, 0.00672597112134099, -0.02193182334303856, -0.0362115241587162, 0.000021293699319357984, -0.012836397625505924, 0.018709121271967888, 0.058982763439416885, 0.00578553369268775, -0.04429525509476662, -0.04800134897232056, 0.021011274307966232, 0.02836691401898861, 0.012515137903392315, -0.011819816194474697, -0.039229780435562134, 0.04749072343111038, 0.025972921401262283, 0.013078402727842331, -0.017660869285464287, -0.019201764836907387, 0.05407460033893585, -0.05006212741136551, -0.018552664667367935, -0.027015885338187218, -0.05349837243556976, -0.030552033334970474, 0.03796590492129326, -0.046083129942417145, 0.07356547564268112, -0.012607975862920284, 0.003496248507872224, 0.029031913727521896, 0.005371875129640102, 0.06430915743112564, -0.06386449933052063, -0.048096537590026855, -0.047025229781866074, 0.0010693391086533666, -0.035051800310611725, 0.052500274032354355, -0.06084022670984268, -0.03181493282318115, -0.02620517648756504, 0.0027070483192801476, 0.03310234472155571, -0.029323019087314606, -0.017343252897262573, 0.021436141803860664, -0.0045515322126448154, 0.005245178937911987, 0.011179090477526188, 0.023711565881967545, 0.012061698362231255, 0.039590634405612946, 0.04748297482728958, 0.011574028991162777, 0.025552021339535713, -0.04706190526485443, 0.0023179370909929276, 0.044196922332048416, 0.031831707805395126, -0.06326661258935928, -0.011438670568168163, 0.0220160111784935, 0.02162087894976139, -0.016288751736283302, -0.013985286466777325, -0.04872029647231102, -0.06692387163639069, -0.030094608664512634, -0.018536420539021492, -0.03839753195643425, -0.04552779719233513, 0.01607166975736618, 0.016567280516028404, -0.016319822520017624, -0.033404089510440826, -0.02510119043290615, -0.030721938237547874, -0.013419900089502335, -0.0838988870382309, -0.02443908527493477, -0.045277468860149384, -0.027834950014948845, 0.024345912039279938, -0.05029715225100517, 0.035587143152952194, 0.01912420243024826, -0.05759265646338463, -0.03249761834740639, 0.03725111484527588, 0.00521464878693223, -0.0022168043069541454, 0.012236257083714008, -0.06347285956144333, 0.015218271873891354, -0.026172548532485962, -0.009664833545684814, -0.03000546619296074, -0.07116474956274033, -0.052979785948991776, 0.06085595861077309, -0.029257377609610558, -0.003266880288720131, 0.05515554919838905, 0.03402294963598251, 0.034117817878723145, -0.03389401733875275, 0.029653994366526604, 0.046124376356601715, -0.0886022225022316, -0.00225561554543674, -0.04311202093958855, 0.008277169428765774, -0.002846681047230959, -0.02144051156938076, 0.010543926618993282, -0.04985269159078598, -0.01988852769136429, 0.03366423770785332, 0.051161929965019226, 0.028496267274022102, -0.0606033094227314, 0.037742000073194504, -0.01800127699971199, -0.06435185670852661, -0.03658820316195488, -0.05363139882683754, -0.018902145326137543, 0.016533253714442253, -0.04644482210278511, 0.06575211882591248, -0.04126652330160141, -0.04816442355513573, 0.009307281114161015, -0.03190835565328598, 0.03500685095787048, 0.021394280716776848, -0.06903371959924698, -0.05796530470252037, -0.06837312877178192, 0.010508304461836815, -0.017129164189100266, -0.04341860115528107, -0.026778925210237503, -0.04519905894994736, -0.006409034598618746, -0.0069212825037539005, 0.05268397927284241, 0.030355384573340416, 0.007893189787864685, 0.007324725389480591, 0.002156146103516221, 0.029235687106847763, 0.0005283468053676188, 0.01907644234597683, -0.02968425862491131, 0.008711530826985836, 0.042957089841365814, -0.0032105003483593464, -0.025385206565260887, -0.027884861454367638, 0.017196442931890488, -0.04601328819990158, 0.03142692893743515, -0.02545074000954628, 0.03339017555117607, 0.006114364601671696, 0.019129803404211998, -0.03143160790205002, -0.03933277353644371, -0.050102319568395615, -0.017219064757227898, 0.05000817030668259, 0.06188507378101349, 0.014375372789800167, -0.03899862617254257, -0.052135445177555084, -0.03407378867268562, -0.05733044445514679, -0.044526733458042145, -0.03341882675886154, -0.052066463977098465, 0.026208503171801567, -0.05176165699958801, -0.020133841782808304, -0.01668884977698326, -0.021369241178035736, -0.06605229526758194, -0.04368290305137634, -0.01603061333298683, 0.02545429952442646, -0.023281147703528404, -0.04989194497466087, -0.03301004320383072, -0.02735755406320095, 0.04146827757358551, 0.058071378618478775, -0.025061454623937607, -0.015266431495547295, -0.04691693186759949, 0.021006131544709206, 0.01226346381008625, -0.020610110834240913, -0.0672946348786354, -0.010289234109222889, -0.02858838438987732, 0.010859750211238861, 0.04225499927997589, 0.05668852478265762, 0.02921532653272152, -0.008366040885448456, 0.037893444299697876, -0.0035930664744228125, -0.018109358847141266, -0.013643555343151093, 0.014526977203786373, 0.014526122249662876, -0.06540665775537491, -0.04624578356742859, 0.04048702493309975, 0.05553758516907692, -0.01536615937948227, -0.0012204644735902548, -0.06519904732704163, -0.0010277508990839124, 0.0318555012345314, 0.0028504838701337576, 0.06413602083921432, 0.030485481023788452, -0.049412865191698074, -0.009005362167954445, -0.02797231823205948, 0.04787910357117653, -0.026921303942799568, -0.02530527487397194, 0.0013625019928440452, -0.014861376024782658, 0.017013568431138992, -0.060500938445329666, 0.036898937076330185, 0.02643788419663906, 0.037372276186943054, -0.005529063753783703, 0.020054655149579048, 0.018597563728690147, -0.004994493443518877, 0.05651841685175896, -0.039050180464982986, 0.004901553969830275, 0.03598847612738609, 0.07207510620355606, -0.024100227281451225, -0.04481698200106621, 0.019391251727938652, -0.032175395637750626, -0.021614091470837593, -0.006676022429019213, 0.04440181329846382, -0.006537336390465498, 0.04503004625439644, -0.008136249147355556, 0.01689157448709011, -0.017230268567800522, 0.01478574238717556, -0.05255967751145363, -0.04355818033218384, 0.04177935793995857, -0.0030167661607265472, 0.002720500808209181, -0.005553724244236946, 0.019406350329518318, -0.03949861600995064, -0.05868536978960037, -0.0023400606587529182, -0.05111943557858467, 0.032131340354681015, 0.060989152640104294, 0.04457426816225052, 0.06772793084383011, 0.04946677014231682, -0.015289298258721828, 0.04223940894007683, 0.021722862496972084, -0.0076739173382520676, -0.0485992357134819, -0.01545788161456585, 0.0018755820346996188, 0.018074382096529007, -0.05536467581987381, -0.013136379420757294, -0.0006895972765050828, -0.04024540260434151, 0.013801555149257183, 0.02720191888511181, 0.03290587663650513, 0.009747329168021679, -0.07791696488857269, -0.030591528862714767, -0.03839860484004021, 0.03377418592572212, -0.015336524695158005, -0.04802953824400902, 0.07086009532213211, -0.04730436950922012, -0.011653467081487179, -0.00046654712059535086, -0.0209385696798563, -0.05216842517256737, 0.011196565814316273, -0.03906174376606941, -0.03929535672068596, 0.02114657126367092, -0.06377750635147095, 0.023909330368041992, 0.022080782800912857, 0.04164586216211319, -0.06256038695573807, 0.026887958869338036, -0.0104428231716156, 0.009043696336448193, 0.07128254324197769, 0.008749080821871758, -0.011745777912437916, -0.022762833163142204, -0.04112739488482475, 0.027581915259361267, 0.0021130191162228584, 0.022555477917194366, -0.03061516024172306, -0.010424088686704636, -0.04190469905734062, -0.0627843514084816, -0.04786527529358864, -0.0029302488546818495, 0.06153038516640663, -0.06618554890155792, -0.030324939638376236, 0.0009892135858535767, 0.04482271522283554, -0.03861192613840103, -0.06738272309303284, -0.009230748750269413, -0.053751714527606964, -0.054681822657585144, -0.0232132226228714, -0.0033002735581249, -0.010210041888058186, 0.03909294307231903, 0.035117946565151215, -0.05089564621448517, 0.022811301052570343, -0.005647554527968168, 0.004665352404117584, 0.05401504039764404, 0.006235896609723568, -0.030687322840094566, -0.017014719545841217, -0.07924579083919525, -0.012535715475678444, -0.005378400906920433, 0.004684831015765667, -0.01016898825764656, 0.059284042567014694, -0.043037012219429016, 0.007800852879881859, -0.05006474629044533, 0.04470132291316986, 0.023425566032528877, -0.010807729326188564, 0.017677681520581245, -0.03700963780283928, -0.032733362168073654, 0.0004888871917501092, -0.04030450060963631, 0.005826225038617849, -0.009210309013724327, -0.03367460519075394, 0.002562494482845068, 0.018763942644000053, -0.00866758357733488, -0.05414542183279991, 0.02752509154379368, 0.01228668075054884, -0.07885675132274628, 0.009435683488845825, -0.02959185466170311, -0.027990376576781273, -0.006375974044203758, 0.019466198980808258, 0.021427227184176445, -0.025579137727618217, 0.021392930299043655, -0.037426821887493134, 0.012970497831702232, 0.011250508949160576, 0.00023517254157923162, -0.06806758046150208, -0.009325445629656315, -0.02076650783419609, 0.020771734416484833, 0.024772560223937035, -0.032700248062610626, 0.013773941434919834, 0.001002242206595838, -0.031239662319421768, 0.015575953759253025, -0.07399281114339828, 0.02952713333070278, -0.05137265473604202, 0.03327394649386406, 0.031633198261260986, 0.02228066325187683, 0.06534320116043091, 0.06279735267162323, -0.050705552101135254, -0.014763697981834412, -0.022830404341220856, -0.006026273127645254, 0.054571107029914856, -0.06171315908432007, 0.021213529631495476, -0.014263915829360485, 0.031056875362992287, 0.027390720322728157, -0.040208954364061356, -0.0405917726457119, -0.0417807400226593, -0.033303480595350266, -0.021814318373799324, 0.0004113993782084435, -0.030227690935134888, -0.03426263481378555, -0.04237838089466095, 0.06246606633067131, -0.05835120752453804, 0.05664486810564995, 0.018509285524487495, 0.030610445886850357, 0.04260724037885666, -0.03110090270638466, 0.03144264966249466, -0.07182517647743225, -0.025841861963272095, 0.07290474325418472, -0.07606138288974762, -0.040928877890110016, 0.007740093395113945, -0.06849882751703262, -0.05090923234820366, -0.04264546185731888, 0.06187092512845993, 0.03705417364835739, -0.024939019232988358, -0.07542761415243149, 0.0615340955555439, 0.015380856581032276, -0.06764744222164154, 0.0372503288090229, 0.003432967234402895, -0.062328044325113297, 0.0193023718893528, -0.025356343016028404, -0.002594031160697341, -0.027777116745710373, 0.01288609765470028, -0.03983618691563606, -0.017013350501656532, -0.04266389459371567, 0.006046990863978863, 0.06956066936254501, -0.03534439951181412, 0.01057052705436945, -0.004964834079146385, -0.02956734038889408, 0.005612536799162626, -0.008361686021089554, 0.026836005970835686, -0.018137089908123016, -0.02830069698393345, -0.007831001654267311, -0.02229910157620907, -0.031504955142736435, 0.03056357428431511, -0.02869960106909275, -0.049981117248535156, 0.02448185533285141, 0.010970283299684525, 0.030542518943548203, -0.03997932747006416, -0.04848562553524971, 0.03234338387846947, 0.015388484112918377, -0.01811911165714264, -0.03779430314898491, 0.01399374008178711, -0.013568869791924953, 0.05711057409644127, 0.0031233683694154024, -0.014833875931799412, 0.044065944850444794, -0.020591940730810165, -0.05035754665732384, -0.003202013438567519, -0.01275144424289465, 0.04159608483314514, -0.033075250685214996, 0.03732793778181076, -0.001310093211941421, 0.009965292178094387, -0.03539498895406723, 0.019959455356001854, -0.015650147572159767, 0.0074413372203707695, -0.010236300528049469, -0.02380756102502346, 0.036303456872701645, 0.004496847279369831, 0.062221210449934006, -0.029145482927560806, -0.012981068342924118, -0.06662128865718842, -0.023349935188889503, -0.0016203097766265273, -0.033577241003513336, -0.04687591642141342, 0.040987130254507065, -0.002575416350737214, -0.05205053091049194, 0.06134100630879402, 0.020965736359357834, -0.03429852053523064, -0.07852178812026978, -0.012685773894190788, 0.023040806874632835, -0.017623020336031914, 0.034823887050151825, 0.031713780015707016, -0.012836037203669548, 0.020868103951215744, 0.019931266084313393, 0.06345292925834656, 0.0027805203571915627, 0.031774409115314484, -0.0788961797952652, 0.0033263638615608215, -0.02060382254421711, -0.01244844775646925, -0.026822412386536598, -0.03034879080951214, 0.008469141088426113, -0.05343114957213402, -0.010121675208210945, -0.0019024725770577788, 0.036135170608758926, -0.03322878107428551, -0.052365683019161224, 0.03271680325269699, 0.035615939646959305, -0.021488552913069725, -0.05331536754965782, 0.03176647424697876, 0.006303343456238508, 0.020157331600785255, -0.019627468660473824, -0.010251631960272789, -0.0736818015575409, 0.00829776655882597, -0.07959619909524918, -0.007466908544301987, 0.002684923354536295, 0.06551723927259445, 0.02313043735921383, -0.02039274573326111, -0.027051005512475967, -0.0373898446559906, 0.028457043692469597, 0.023525584489107132, 0.044794961810112, -0.005294875241816044, 0.0036241174675524235, 0.026719240471720695, -0.0009327027946710587, -0.03256620094180107, 0.06822570413351059, 0.02065313793718815, 0.014357054606080055, 0.008365404792129993, 0.0014395565958693624, -0.010698333382606506, 0.029150860384106636, 0.04531674087047577, -0.020629379898309708, 0.04911181330680847, -0.03816051408648491, 0.03607584536075592, -0.06104850769042969, -0.06909793615341187, 0.036568980664014816, -0.0023901481181383133, 0.005833581555634737, 0.0073739453218877316, 0.024974452331662178, -0.03970734402537346, -0.035733360797166824, -0.04202708601951599, 0.023318393155932426, 0.041152823716402054, -0.018024330958724022, 0.07123503088951111, -0.06375093758106232, -0.014193632639944553, -0.007436116226017475, 0.014840618707239628, -0.04310738295316696, 0.04496004059910774, 0.03274770453572273, -0.03214500844478607, 0.0490100122988224, -0.04767238721251488, 0.02221105247735977, -0.0266971904784441, 0.012404478155076504, -0.005490882322192192, 0.0697360560297966, -0.03159720450639725, 0.011063934303820133, -0.07064756751060486, -0.043514277786016464, -0.018302468582987785, -0.05647279694676399, -0.005138585809618235, -0.02440052665770054, -0.016854923218488693, 0.05276402458548546, 0.03388841822743416, -0.04425326734781265, 0.045075394213199615, 0.026201825588941574, -0.009116367436945438, -0.059489328414201736, 0.023902488872408867, -0.020039137452840805, 0.04764325171709061, 0.0033259449992328882, -0.05561475828289986, -0.044356901198625565, 0.029690047726035118, -0.02896019071340561, -0.028796175494790077, -0.0042601097375154495, -0.002686027204617858, -0.044929374009370804, -0.04026281088590622, -0.021164432168006897, -0.025776855647563934, 0.04167139157652855, -0.03332548588514328, 0.036290399730205536, 0.04114421457052231, -0.03927132487297058, -0.05803680419921875 ]
Video saliency prediction and detection are thriving research domains that enable computers to simulate the distribution of visual attention akin to how humans perceiving dynamic scenes. While many approaches have crafted task-specific training paradigms for either video saliency prediction or video salient object detection tasks, few attention has been devoted to devising a generalized saliency modeling framework that seamlessly bridges both these distinct tasks. In this study, we introduce the Unified Saliency Transformer (UniST) framework, which comprehensively utilizes the essential attributes of video saliency prediction and video salient object detection. In addition to extracting representations of frame sequences, a saliency-aware transformer is designed to learn the spatio-temporal representations at progressively increased resolutions, while incorporating effective cross-scale saliency information to produce a robust representation. Furthermore, a task-specific decoder is proposed to perform the final prediction for each task. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work that explores designing a transformer structure for both saliency modeling tasks. Convincible experiments demonstrate that the proposed UniST achieves superior performance across seven challenging benchmarks for two tasks, and significantly outperforms the other state-of-the-art methods.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08220v1
[ -0.016892772167921066, -0.028301745653152466, 0.03465168550610542, 0.02991100586950779, -0.027295418083667755, -0.04236668720841408, 0.04298519715666771, 0.03228600323200226, -0.03562498465180397, -0.03642238676548004, -0.05378755182027817, 0.05227242037653923, -0.014004804193973541, -0.03137180954217911, -0.038399796932935715, -0.003767997957766056, 0.07609833031892776, -0.019673127681016922, -0.06329602748155594, 0.05894769728183746, 0.003026693593710661, 0.007198302075266838, -0.026416582986712456, 0.02804594673216343, -0.019429324194788933, -0.023824375122785568, -0.04964975640177727, 0.03409598767757416, -0.048161402344703674, -0.0169167909771204, 0.0708390325307846, -0.007388529367744923, -0.032927822321653366, -0.04826583340764046, -0.009225848130881786, -0.03586932271718979, -0.02339467965066433, 0.039079178124666214, 0.027520107105374336, -0.05747198686003685, 0.0282821636646986, -0.047693636268377304, -0.06194256246089935, 0.016269268468022346, -0.022307109087705612, -0.005873431917279959, -0.036129582673311234, 0.024854246526956558, -0.08616331219673157, -0.01531177293509245, 0.030174868181347847, -0.03879614174365997, 0.00862904079258442, 0.041272979229688644, -0.014373976737260818, -0.021521179005503654, -0.02432132512331009, 0.044911760836839676, -0.042472463101148605, 0.0006006017792969942, 0.0270797461271286, -0.02767445147037506, 0.008989378809928894, 0.0020200719591230154, 0.02661915309727192, 0.04449021816253662, -0.05397823825478554, -0.05202954262495041, -0.005269771441817284, -0.02494102530181408, 0.05311523377895355, -0.043478742241859436, -0.019294997677206993, 0.004012908320873976, -0.016175834462046623, -0.05170596390962601, -0.04387863725423813, -0.052741456776857376, 0.022730674594640732, 0.024297228083014488, -0.020077170804142952, -0.015250581316649914, 0.06058588624000549, 0.036338333040475845, 0.013852291740477085, -0.017564021050930023, 0.060216136276721954, 0.03190929442644119, 0.03349374979734421, -0.029149962589144707, 0.022763121873140335, -0.03990345448255539, -0.07402300834655762, 0.013340502977371216, 0.05958421900868416, -0.041757091879844666, 0.05895920842885971, 0.016277411952614784, 0.005456645041704178, -0.02409520000219345, -0.04586539417505264, -0.004940043203532696, -0.03170869126915932, 0.036897335201501846, 0.06506478786468506, -0.03769129142165184, 0.03300030902028084, 0.01834600605070591, -0.054164279252290726, -0.0023563746362924576, -0.041111938655376434, -0.001356380176730454, 0.01114785484969616, -0.07150445133447647, -0.007177216932177544, -0.042613957077264786, 0.06279256194829941, 0.0035900052171200514, 0.010463038459420204, 0.01486597117036581, -0.03260071948170662, 0.03950987756252289, 0.04515702649950981, -0.057233430445194244, -0.05263708904385567, -0.003653323743492365, 0.02696930058300495, 0.007534051313996315, 0.005015100818127394, -0.03369484841823578, -0.022524798288941383, 0.03114238940179348, -0.031760476529598236, -0.032075826078653336, 0.06920826435089111, -0.007883709855377674, 0.011569351889193058, -0.045970894396305084, 0.006427723914384842, -0.019752148538827896, -0.023510847240686417, -0.0659870132803917, -0.003461528802290559, -0.023998858407139778, 0.027165696024894714, 0.04470432549715042, -0.03186460956931114, -0.008476847782731056, -0.010576915927231312, 0.028900250792503357, -0.01877865567803383, -0.016048608347773552, 0.036645472049713135, 0.04906934127211571, -0.00024118003784678876, -0.06304474920034409, 0.0683857798576355, -0.029837200418114662, -0.05000622197985649, 0.045606233179569244, 0.01631803810596466, -0.020566564053297043, -0.0027997714933007956, -0.032507169991731644, 0.014043448492884636, -0.01612759195268154, 0.030757339671254158, -0.022915435954928398, -0.01613570563495159, 0.022835027426481247, -0.013129251077771187, 0.0093338368460536, -0.0024079703725874424, -0.0040798489935696125, -0.06158839538693428, -0.012272262014448643, -0.0030915066599845886, -0.07301074266433716, -0.042117584496736526, 0.0007636132650077343, -0.000837849045637995, 0.006511037703603506, -0.022119110450148582, -0.02426707185804844, -0.05429794266819954, 0.004647469613701105, -0.08209875971078873, -0.0411565899848938, 0.028916286304593086, -0.023056907579302788, -0.02699868381023407, -0.014423053711652756, 0.02797560580074787, 0.03002127818763256, -0.040376342833042145, -0.036536406725645065, 0.007924974896013737, -0.005450977478176355, -0.0026096480432897806, 0.03898324444890022, -0.08604171872138977, -0.021625960245728493, -0.043756138533353806, -0.026910880580544472, 0.001838185009546578, -0.078049436211586, 0.017660655081272125, 0.01762259751558304, -0.04749468341469765, -0.024315930902957916, 0.03768213838338852, 0.04355167597532272, 0.07294486463069916, 0.03436550125479698, 0.023323161527514458, 0.012823881581425667, -0.09894130378961563, 0.015338786877691746, 0.02023068256676197, -0.0131238317117095, 0.025737151503562927, 0.055709417909383774, -0.032798685133457184, 0.001682748319581151, -0.02611815184354782, 0.0674583911895752, 0.05923323705792427, -0.02758653089404106, -0.06516526639461517, -0.009251047857105732, 0.011792920529842377, -0.0029543463606387377, -0.02334507927298546, -0.0806567519903183, -0.03736022859811783, 0.01461256667971611, -0.027107691392302513, 0.03102039359509945, -0.021918147802352905, -0.059835463762283325, -0.02824251540005207, -0.044409237802028656, 0.029531540349125862, -0.043432220816612244, -0.03135601431131363, -0.02744230628013611, -0.022412944585084915, 0.03321791812777519, -0.004156209994107485, -0.004948941990733147, -0.0405145026743412, -0.05300068110227585, -0.006307318340986967, 0.003771880641579628, 0.05521779507398605, 0.023981010541319847, -0.021986637264490128, 0.04504147544503212, -0.005909783765673637, 0.03991372138261795, 0.0028669852763414383, 0.04049055278301239, -0.055353082716464996, 0.04269963130354881, 0.018489839509129524, 0.004701657220721245, -0.027784284204244614, -0.02085363119840622, 0.007651073858141899, -0.06302205473184586, -0.02620484121143818, 0.035352129489183426, 0.038884639739990234, 0.014772651717066765, -0.0004732894594781101, -0.07012064754962921, -0.01500544510781765, -0.01296504121273756, 0.049685489386320114, 0.05540666729211807, 0.031567562371492386, -0.021425729617476463, -0.020891979336738586, -0.05828442424535751, -0.011947485618293285, -0.05075276270508766, 0.00016271752247121185, -0.07518385350704193, -0.05416610836982727, -0.04208843410015106, -0.07084731012582779, -0.033790476620197296, -0.027836423367261887, -0.04106511175632477, -0.0014585170429199934, -0.06989779323339462, 0.04915764927864075, 0.006609360221773386, 0.030096011236310005, 0.024213848635554314, -0.04916968196630478, -0.035442110151052475, 0.0270492322742939, -0.0006007114425301552, -0.019676605239510536, -0.06914526969194412, -0.03849125653505325, 0.007080580573529005, 0.020229529589414597, -0.04296161234378815, -0.0066889249719679356, 0.03544120490550995, -0.014351297169923782, 0.03929989039897919, -0.022885330021381378, 0.00291420123539865, 0.032714422792196274, 0.026286548003554344, 0.008624530397355556, -0.05058884248137474, -0.00105151510797441, -0.025107095018029213, 0.0076240841299295425, -0.036462102085351944, -0.05728616192936897, -0.008161534555256367, 0.06794916838407516, 0.015162143856287003, -0.05484342202544212, -0.04940579831600189, -0.010230672545731068, 0.043225739151239395, 0.008374670520424843, 0.011282370425760746, 0.043172262609004974, 0.019697023555636406, -0.04489615187048912, -0.021616073325276375, -0.00940455961972475, -0.01425450574606657, -0.004855066537857056, -0.017941337078809738, -0.06547147035598755, -0.009975876659154892, 0.06774142384529114, -0.0966634750366211, 0.027074486017227173, 0.06658763438463211, 0.08020199835300446, -0.012241802178323269, 0.005131633952260017, 0.002525747986510396, 0.036043811589479446, 0.008624563924968243, 0.025699947029352188, 0.014914988540112972, 0.01468699797987938, 0.06145019084215164, -0.05950765311717987, -0.013451501727104187, 0.016400735825300217, -0.05905398353934288, -0.05577746033668518, -0.0014494386268779635, 0.03273584693670273, 0.03966285288333893, 0.01726982556283474, -0.029138311743736267, 0.007591704837977886, -0.013223129324615002, 0.07578940689563751, 0.01944112963974476, -0.0033528697676956654, 0.0029023210518062115, -0.07577217370271683, 0.03128237649798393, 0.03583129495382309, -0.016052275896072388, -0.018464677035808563, -0.04198715090751648, 0.03736836835741997, -0.043167054653167725, 0.03875862807035446, -0.030187366530299187, -0.038876987993717194, 0.022432712838053703, 0.036102376878261566, -0.018959661945700645, 0.055730439722537994, -0.005816000979393721, 0.01264925580471754, -0.02235725149512291, 0.0062681506387889385, -0.010023782029747963, -0.008136646822094917, -0.054393645375967026, 0.006816266570240259, -0.0041378275491297245, -0.015080802142620087, 0.00003038684189959895, 0.007113161031156778, 0.019396405667066574, 0.02969684638082981, -0.08307316154241562, 0.03153573349118233, -0.025434404611587524, 0.05132998153567314, 0.02864978089928627, -0.03056793101131916, 0.07632648199796677, -0.03824888914823532, -0.016452712938189507, -0.029757976531982422, 0.0033555766567587852, -0.04743937775492668, -0.06483206152915955, -0.010368653573095798, -0.06779618561267853, 0.003877648850902915, -0.0424145832657814, 0.04317007213830948, -0.005704103969037533, 0.03908723220229149, -0.03204791620373726, -0.047360610216856, -0.015812406316399574, 0.027871016412973404, 0.035253334790468216, 0.007108272518962622, -0.017220644280314445, -0.021216168999671936, 0.05703134462237358, -0.008034743368625641, 0.02308884635567665, 0.01999947987496853, 0.004536873195320368, 0.04861574247479439, -0.0362246036529541, 0.017205242067575455, -0.00914036575704813, -0.004744246602058411, 0.03590938821434975, -0.05796774476766586, -0.0660862997174263, -0.01392313465476036, 0.012087339535355568, -0.049110475927591324, -0.05198201537132263, -0.039402302354574203, -0.03512699902057648, -0.0383048914372921, -0.02216687798500061, -0.009544835425913334, 0.016601381823420525, -0.012168603017926216, -0.023176398128271103, 0.05062717944383621, 0.020822428166866302, 0.00875677727162838, 0.04302402213215828, 0.05872192606329918, 0.019399695098400116, -0.014505917206406593, -0.03706706687808037, -0.06681886315345764, 0.007570820394903421, -0.03067520260810852, 0.013212040066719055, -0.03225671872496605, 0.03951001912355423, 0.042095646262168884, 0.04328744858503342, -0.08856963366270065, 0.030696233734488487, 0.021090857684612274, -0.018165966495871544, 0.018940526992082596, 0.06386791169643402, 0.002883441746234894, 0.050247400999069214, -0.03664257004857063, -0.002687402069568634, 0.038173433393239975, -0.06464805454015732, -0.01618141308426857, 0.0015755194472149014, -0.04744761437177658, 0.005951921455562115, 0.04523850604891777, -0.00012318891822360456, -0.028545819222927094, -0.00006989430403336883, 0.02167337015271187, 0.04964286461472511, -0.023363951593637466, -0.004195766523480415, 0.043153587728738785, -0.04240284860134125, -0.010901615023612976, -0.01180261466652155, -0.05045540630817413, -0.01584620587527752, 0.04750572890043259, -0.0224187932908535, -0.012601581402122974, 0.03269938379526138, 0.01724894344806671, -0.002478148555383086, -0.03374527767300606, -0.002590721705928445, -0.03160105645656586, 0.012175406329333782, -0.004536536522209644, -0.05664028599858284, -0.006729185115545988, -0.015835147351026535, 0.02630683034658432, 0.015162852592766285, 0.0426691398024559, 0.029207978397607803, 0.025606831535696983, -0.04023522511124611, -0.03325902670621872, -0.02189992554485798, -0.055215220898389816, 0.04132508486509323, -0.059156838804483414, 0.05128079280257225, -0.03646872192621231, 0.02861543744802475, -0.017561091110110283, 0.027932535856962204, 0.008888485841453075, 0.04686015471816063, -0.028424201533198357, -0.037206847220659256, 0.02828075923025608, -0.03594942390918732, -0.06432142853736877, 0.009437210857868195, -0.0030342929530888796, -0.014793707057833672, 0.049340423196554184, 0.048190899193286896, -0.02215861901640892, 0.0030211657285690308, 0.020507076755166054, 0.008354288525879383, -0.0316912978887558, -0.02131577953696251, 0.0645342618227005, -0.07018930464982986, 0.004238973371684551, -0.011501751840114594, -0.06328397989273071, 0.013699176721274853, -0.04982861131429672, 0.03351599723100662, 0.01542254351079464, -0.02747369557619095, -0.01345550175756216, 0.03165259212255478, -0.010703233070671558, -0.07804831117391586, 0.022884000092744827, 0.017644988372921944, -0.07356435060501099, 0.009776456281542778, 0.032370395958423615, 0.01975315622985363, -0.02738328091800213, 0.02792881429195404, 0.028429636731743813, -0.004783040843904018, -0.04487963765859604, 0.052112553268671036, 0.08082814514636993, 0.009164106100797653, -0.030104530975222588, 0.03189209848642349, -0.03097560815513134, 0.01816786453127861, -0.0015986539656296372, 0.002821960486471653, 0.003792292671278119, 0.02524007484316826, -0.001419602893292904, -0.05178892984986305, -0.044456031173467636, 0.0790308341383934, -0.013152427971363068, -0.010384716093540192, -0.021101221442222595, -0.0039522950537502766, 0.03981843590736389, -0.04018066078424454, -0.046611323952674866, 0.020732533186674118, -0.020704522728919983, -0.004057218320667744, -0.039110101759433746, 0.016721414402127266, -0.0024556091520935297, 0.020914364606142044, 0.020637625828385353, -0.06629009544849396, 0.01778445765376091, -0.020736373960971832, -0.04259134456515312, 0.014751166105270386, -0.06376922875642776, -0.02596840262413025, 0.020270146429538727, 0.028136232867836952, 0.026332847774028778, 0.053734298795461655, -0.06958913803100586, -0.05733395740389824, 0.0012471271911635995, 0.04002075642347336, -0.015688855201005936, -0.026118529960513115, 0.01933482103049755, -0.007687002420425415, 0.0450751855969429, -0.058858830481767654, 0.010387473739683628, 0.021136581897735596, -0.045500364154577255, 0.018857663497328758, -0.013753702864050865, -0.03173074498772621, -0.053463175892829895, 0.002703176811337471, -0.025440920144319534, 0.007038460113108158, 0.03994683176279068, -0.03482704609632492, -0.08149031549692154, 0.003099330933764577, 0.004401325713843107, -0.04746184125542641, 0.0049590435810387135, 0.02485767938196659, 0.024387177079916, -0.03191790729761124, 0.04528307914733887, 0.029479429125785828, 0.0011517992243170738, 0.011444770731031895, -0.06554963439702988, 0.007270088419318199, 0.03531986102461815, -0.010521064512431622, -0.048507675528526306, -0.022829407826066017, 0.0020763876382261515, -0.060491714626550674, -0.005252690054476261, 0.049895670264959335, 0.0009407661273144186, -0.023655466735363007, -0.06711886823177338, -0.001453831559047103, 0.012591088190674782, -0.03704189136624336, -0.0652233213186264, 0.023200618103146553, -0.011254027485847473, -0.04869001731276512, -0.016142359003424644, -0.012724761851131916, -0.05686928704380989, 0.0005216223653405905, -0.0856427475810051, 0.005623669363558292, 0.023941176012158394, 0.05727148801088333, -0.0005308417021296918, -0.011651661247015, 0.005860886070877314, -0.011486480943858624, 0.009320986457169056, 0.01906895637512207, -0.0027518034912645817, -0.021360184997320175, 0.0029839174821972847, -0.03461406007409096, -0.07675354927778244, -0.012131576426327229, 0.044706083834171295, -0.04193228855729103, -0.0166095532476902, 0.00785413570702076, 0.0257167499512434, 0.01235200371593237, 0.004851110745221376, 0.04161790758371353, 0.01566973701119423, 0.04662038013339043, -0.05165242776274681, 0.026547517627477646, -0.029455965384840965, -0.05555112659931183, 0.03404175117611885, -0.04471366107463837, 0.024975594133138657, -0.001882213749922812, -0.004252832382917404, 0.00046728819143027067, -0.04349995777010918, -0.033576127141714096, 0.015585273504257202, -0.05076289176940918, -0.010017609223723412, 0.05624600127339363, -0.02214724011719227, -0.03664093092083931, -0.011957245878875256, -0.006171104963868856, -0.04305830970406532, 0.04042958840727806, 0.04944099858403206, -0.03368375822901726, 0.00737041374668479, -0.05957549810409546, -0.013538186438381672, -0.016854599118232727, -0.002599443309009075, -0.038085468113422394, 0.06347431242465973, -0.00034508827957324684, -0.03619647026062012, -0.03542795777320862, -0.02519506961107254, -0.010715210810303688, -0.07202094793319702, -0.059534404426813126, -0.013699628412723541, 0.02242155373096466, -0.014419014565646648, 0.006191791035234928, 0.021126864477992058, 0.06102419272065163, -0.010910402983427048, 0.024566054344177246, -0.009720437228679657, 0.006685345433652401, -0.024584287777543068, 0.07312757521867752, 0.006735021248459816, 0.014631708152592182, 0.01280269306153059, 0.026796894147992134, -0.03379051014780998, -0.016082923859357834, 0.02507171966135502, 0.00560104101896286, 0.0249423049390316, -0.06293945759534836, 0.027551308274269104, 0.056736793369054794, -0.03959736227989197, -0.007768082432448864, -0.05325227603316307, 0.015181721188127995, -0.001082114176824689, -0.04690837115049362 ]
This work is devoted to the study of the probability of immunity, i.e. the effect occurs whether exposed or not. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions for non-immunity and $\epsilon$-bounded immunity, i.e. the probability of immunity is zero and $\epsilon$-bounded, respectively. The former allows us to estimate the probability of benefit (i.e., the effect occurs if and only if exposed) from a randomized controlled trial, and the latter allows us to produce bounds of the probability of benefit that are tighter than the existing ones. We also introduce the concept of indirect immunity (i.e., through a mediator) and repeat our previous analysis for it. Finally, we propose a method for sensitivity analysis of the probability of immunity under unmeasured confounding.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11942v2
[ -0.026962868869304657, -0.026730520650744438, 0.018672876060009003, 0.030964437872171402, 0.03528696298599243, -0.021481765434145927, -0.05346115678548813, 0.0022120291832834482, -0.05133096128702164, -0.016916148364543915, -0.0427384227514267, -0.04398613050580025, -0.021396679803729057, -0.04498140513896942, 0.01885337382555008, -0.03763578087091446, 0.05083860084414482, 0.06484648585319519, -0.022898679599165916, 0.046956486999988556, -0.057081446051597595, -0.04864316061139107, -0.0295295100659132, 0.001105518895201385, 0.013397322036325932, 0.004964948631823063, 0.006147089414298534, 0.00895766168832779, -0.06716638803482056, -0.003972790203988552, -0.006297743413597345, -0.017207730561494827, -0.03212135657668114, -0.029437335208058357, -0.010145917534828186, -0.017871765419840813, 0.009913134388625622, -0.012276237830519676, -0.00645550899207592, -0.008074156008660793, 0.017966551706194878, -0.06282692402601242, -0.014013957232236862, 0.0051238927990198135, -0.00868765264749527, -0.021240955218672752, -0.0329228937625885, 0.014317017048597336, -0.05289798974990845, -0.06230657547712326, 0.04318302124738693, 0.024904223158955574, -0.04504924640059471, 0.02481146529316902, -0.060775499790906906, 0.0008691668044775724, -0.005958316847681999, -0.014490223489701748, -0.04816500470042229, 0.0013331921072676778, 0.015850232914090157, -0.03334319218993187, -0.01018670853227377, -0.00958849024027586, 0.00223449501208961, 0.035765666514635086, -0.023198217153549194, -0.0434357225894928, -0.03607945889234543, -0.02916605770587921, 0.038256920874118805, -0.04908885061740875, -0.03531010076403618, -0.010745302774012089, -0.03911501169204712, -0.03472873196005821, -0.03921734541654587, -0.0039851488545536995, 0.03814017400145531, 0.022859858348965645, -0.024868616834282875, 0.04294097423553467, 0.03950786590576172, -0.0023107430897653103, 0.0436616912484169, -0.004806172102689743, 0.0615948848426342, -0.023933693766593933, 0.01436871849000454, -0.021008433774113655, 0.01139312144368887, -0.048694223165512085, -0.05724211409687996, -0.00001891384818009101, -0.010575910098850727, -0.055413372814655304, 0.02104542776942253, 0.02369692362844944, 0.008296637795865536, -0.01424168236553669, -0.022327374666929245, -0.01561532448977232, -0.03145639970898628, 0.0525357723236084, 0.0028722237329930067, -0.0660565197467804, 0.0028865316417068243, -0.019307268783450127, -0.045705199241638184, 0.033888690173625946, -0.04147597402334213, -0.02114299312233925, 0.011298246681690216, -0.063107430934906, -0.02500631846487522, -0.059210292994976044, 0.02857843227684498, -0.0181211456656456, 0.017761757597327232, -0.012018474750220776, -0.04387238621711731, 0.024042317643761635, -0.012288057245314121, 0.04774569347500801, 0.0014166503679007292, 0.01798526756465435, 0.04295884072780609, 0.014053612016141415, -0.03366430476307869, 0.0033331431914120913, -0.0012407981557771564, 0.007552001625299454, 0.0022766022011637688, 0.008251698687672615, 0.023755908012390137, -0.039157621562480927, 0.025394257158041, -0.04660990461707115, 0.02268059365451336, 0.0007783969631418586, -0.0478566512465477, -0.012706592679023743, 0.015855951234698296, -0.011066964827477932, -0.013162431307137012, 0.021666839718818665, -0.06566304713487625, -0.026967018842697144, 0.019398849457502365, 0.04071613773703575, 0.018933173269033432, 0.010113660246133804, -0.03113560751080513, 0.00571596110239625, 0.005148403812199831, -0.022862497717142105, 0.004301850683987141, 0.03225579857826233, -0.006535311695188284, 0.0027779778465628624, 0.04525469243526459, -0.029530227184295654, 0.01103158388286829, -0.018889151513576508, -0.006333420518785715, 0.0031152423471212387, 0.029122648760676384, -0.005089750979095697, -0.016626210883259773, -0.0003495059791021049, -0.02291792258620262, 0.03516880422830582, -0.01686663180589676, -0.024292347952723503, -0.06489542126655579, -0.03443755954504013, 0.013529472053050995, -0.028544209897518158, -0.049613624811172485, 0.0004210486658848822, 0.01401965506374836, 0.0057447077706456184, 0.01317258644849062, -0.004219484515488148, -0.005753679666668177, 0.041094280779361725, -0.0633796975016594, -0.031306978315114975, 0.009836503304541111, -0.038000792264938354, -0.056625429540872574, -0.06865193694829941, 0.0072617600671947, 0.0331830158829689, -0.04057096317410469, -0.03957394137978554, -0.028721455484628677, 0.04925767332315445, -0.013509787619113922, 0.047290630638599396, -0.078717440366745, -0.012219947762787342, -0.06922329217195511, 0.02515331096947193, -0.06299751251935959, -0.007896880619227886, -0.01010803785175085, 0.03995394706726074, -0.03831025958061218, -0.05270659551024437, 0.030431272462010384, 0.010521871037781239, 0.05222988501191139, 0.040861085057258606, -0.01567116752266884, -0.01799948140978813, -0.08659876137971878, 0.051218170672655106, -0.011145958676934242, -0.028150444850325584, 0.05467846244573593, -0.02101772092282772, 0.033070582896471024, 0.028395235538482666, -0.03364843875169754, 0.042963653802871704, 0.05004993826150894, -0.04199662059545517, -0.02312701940536499, -0.058540619909763336, -0.05055664852261543, -0.06457284837961197, -0.026362814009189606, -0.06313531845808029, -0.028070829808712006, -0.030540706589818, -0.00720186298713088, 0.03401675075292587, 0.03497447073459625, -0.042937349528074265, -0.05377165973186493, -0.018973933532834053, 0.053123366087675095, 0.010286903008818626, -0.02418833039700985, -0.07477635890245438, -0.036472294479608536, -0.02716805972158909, -0.004411134868860245, 0.02042504958808422, 0.016301354393363, -0.06709267944097519, 0.02554253116250038, -0.03920798376202583, -0.007177678868174553, 0.021692948415875435, -0.03208412602543831, 0.011962826363742352, -0.007407133001834154, 0.010361576452851295, 0.011349394917488098, 0.054981593042612076, -0.03146321699023247, -0.032886285334825516, 0.052562013268470764, -0.02221890538930893, -0.040569331496953964, -0.05430826172232628, 0.018183883279561996, -0.05169682204723358, -0.005984732415527105, -0.019602205604314804, 0.02000044845044613, 0.013643846847116947, -0.03327905759215355, -0.06436194479465485, 0.027776667848229408, 0.0008522921125404537, 0.05883437767624855, -0.02876262180507183, 0.019931945949792862, -0.00454490352421999, -0.005080314353108406, -0.0731450691819191, -0.024752330034971237, -0.01326340064406395, -0.01666613668203354, -0.03592957183718681, -0.0691753551363945, -0.009741009213030338, -0.07253613322973251, 0.001488721463829279, 0.02186133712530136, -0.020008888095617294, -0.06453008204698563, -0.04582378640770912, -0.06511407345533371, -0.0036978248972445726, 0.012097427621483803, -0.03835408017039299, -0.051330532878637314, -0.04026399180293083, 0.013335530646145344, 0.018863331526517868, 0.04165731742978096, -0.03716013953089714, -0.06937522441148758, -0.0374261736869812, 0.060472939163446426, -0.031144103035330772, 0.012522988021373749, 0.02142311818897724, 0.011836650781333447, 0.028729554265737534, -0.042530253529548645, 0.0011007529683411121, 0.032020632177591324, -0.043365880846977234, 0.022912584245204926, -0.031321894377470016, -0.002809313125908375, -0.02531830035150051, 0.023809732869267464, -0.055814195424318314, -0.04292124882340431, -0.028839711099863052, 0.06112661212682724, 0.014892461709678173, -0.014559012837707996, -0.05634559318423271, -0.04515404254198074, -0.016953080892562866, 0.0011645257472991943, -0.06290489435195923, 0.024463921785354614, 0.002564522437751293, -0.06708146631717682, 0.014131823554635048, -0.025209952145814896, 0.03339597210288048, -0.034661535173654556, 0.04759315773844719, -0.06759456545114517, 0.024022016674280167, 0.040889427065849304, -0.08233712613582611, 0.03420818969607353, 0.015442381612956524, 0.04696201905608177, -0.003085377858951688, -0.0008198135765269399, 0.05224016308784485, 0.030947916209697723, -0.007242969237267971, 0.038847666233778, 0.035715583711862564, 0.048453573137521744, 0.031668901443481445, -0.0036082949955016375, -0.032549649477005005, 0.050313398241996765, -0.059990812093019485, -0.06306131184101105, -0.01899794116616249, 0.06462795287370682, -0.0029483071994036436, 0.009899177588522434, -0.005086984951049089, 0.048883140087127686, -0.00971628725528717, 0.053445566445589066, 0.0012037884443998337, -0.05991322919726372, -0.0030325762927532196, -0.03144139051437378, 0.04889717325568199, 0.04477387294173241, 0.052535783499479294, -0.04067790135741234, -0.06656903028488159, 0.008826090954244137, -0.053780846297740936, 0.030672455206513405, 0.023590026423335075, -0.026678364723920822, 0.06584282219409943, 0.014752586372196674, -0.06036832928657532, 0.03521757572889328, -0.03577761724591255, 0.0010948716662824154, -0.03406533971428871, -0.019825514405965805, 0.058439310640096664, -0.054046716541051865, -0.044710978865623474, -0.008006065152585506, -0.00893471110612154, -0.013219390995800495, 0.010481593199074268, 0.013568935915827751, -0.05365612357854843, 0.011120312847197056, -0.06320589780807495, -0.03847573697566986, -0.012247774749994278, 0.03504575788974762, 0.0245909933000803, -0.017939502373337746, 0.04842100664973259, -0.05076412856578827, 0.014635131694376469, -0.05713358521461487, 0.01122257113456726, -0.03856866806745529, -0.047420013695955276, -0.052933502942323685, -0.05369626730680466, -0.04073503613471985, -0.07497309893369675, 0.014138258993625641, -0.004605355206876993, -0.028632551431655884, -0.04355735331773758, 0.06414294987916946, 0.017487073317170143, 0.013196239247918129, 0.043550774455070496, 0.022256923839449883, 0.051783155649900436, -0.030431490391492844, -0.02318602427840233, -0.04345519840717316, -0.019432594999670982, -0.04122296720743179, -0.017349688336253166, 0.025561988353729248, -0.02725827693939209, -0.03139910474419594, -0.05175014212727547, -0.0031228752341121435, 0.05438411235809326, -0.026738809421658516, -0.012598579749464989, -0.03361488878726959, 0.030144857242703438, -0.0693705677986145, -0.06267493218183517, -0.007254626136273146, -0.03261493891477585, -0.05423407256603241, 0.0074213165789842606, -0.008333944715559483, 0.04819934815168381, -0.02450004406273365, 0.01455331314355135, 0.060436222702264786, 0.04666610807180405, 0.020151332020759583, -0.015403696335852146, 0.0015856848331168294, 0.01458690781146288, -0.03843552991747856, -0.011468050070106983, -0.02767632156610489, -0.022829445078969002, 0.007601155899465084, 0.017282893881201744, -0.0043295640498399734, 0.08067657053470612, -0.0008962159627117217, 0.047564927488565445, -0.0787072703242302, -0.01185072585940361, -0.016256317496299744, 0.0008560535497963428, 0.014024383388459682, 0.01092725433409214, -0.01955869421362877, 0.010665451176464558, -0.05816036835312843, -0.02414778433740139, 0.050486255437135696, -0.004904589150100946, 0.03226159140467644, 0.00450128735974431, -0.022755099460482597, -0.04521816968917847, 0.05925680324435234, -0.05227920785546303, -0.053772635757923126, 0.030150476843118668, 0.03585202991962433, -0.012547818943858147, -0.009507630951702595, -0.00936996378004551, 0.02629484422504902, -0.05069393664598465, 0.014316367916762829, 0.015566891059279442, 0.03585433214902878, 0.03795440122485161, 0.04635307192802429, -0.05199170857667923, -0.010552842170000076, 0.02281937003135681, -0.009474925696849823, 0.004070032387971878, 0.025393635034561157, 0.05142867565155029, 0.007062758319079876, -0.028211990371346474, 0.05032563954591751, -0.069294273853302, 0.009331686422228813, -0.01602746918797493, 0.013802227564156055, 0.03296652436256409, -0.013421243987977505, 0.03690870478749275, -0.02055208943784237, -0.040756721049547195, -0.04304086044430733, -0.03701300546526909, -0.04574906453490257, 0.006987110245972872, -0.012554953806102276, 0.007729655131697655, 0.019467683508992195, 0.04847313091158867, 0.02069207839667797, 0.010472320020198822, 0.018633583560585976, 0.02058999426662922, 0.004283833783119917, -0.028446277603507042, 0.04321293905377388, -0.013288353569805622, -0.03745445981621742, -0.04387565702199936, 0.011165767908096313, -0.025274069979786873, 0.019991328939795494, 0.04849209263920784, -0.028908688575029373, -0.04209742695093155, -0.017218509688973427, -0.017990510910749435, -0.07901540398597717, 0.0063073174096643925, 0.0729374960064888, -0.04123302176594734, 0.03583604097366333, -0.026898344978690147, -0.02963809296488762, -0.037097908556461334, -0.047506120055913925, -0.061055026948451996, 0.019962485879659653, 0.051231905817985535, -0.04684643819928169, -0.011536766774952412, -0.010456095449626446, -0.07279521971940994, -0.012977094389498234, 0.007680411916226149, -0.04889331012964249, 0.036740612238645554, 0.04419688135385513, -0.04366582632064819, 0.04146570712327957, 0.016666868701577187, -0.044007934629917145, -0.02266678586602211, -0.003162811044603586, 0.06807582080364227, 0.06854261457920074, -0.018708836287260056, 0.013732771389186382, -0.012883083894848824, 0.02284858003258705, -0.00015911324589978904, -0.009912088513374329, -0.037914812564849854, -0.006211533211171627, 0.040976349264383316, -0.01710866577923298, -0.007855420000851154, 0.018825439736247063, 0.03726693615317345, 0.01091284304857254, 0.04215388000011444, -0.046551067382097244, 0.017642272636294365, 0.06142021715641022, -0.04155261069536209, -0.04156854376196861, -0.02472303993999958, -0.021789921447634697, -0.0640312135219574, -0.05072934553027153, -0.03190420940518379, -0.02023843117058277, 0.018584081903100014, 0.045908454805612564, -0.05065974220633507, -0.013721727766096592, -0.03235919028520584, -0.004425771068781614, 0.0031459983438253403, -0.03640110790729523, 0.02928607538342476, 0.00026149730547331274, 0.049317773431539536, 0.0544891431927681, 0.05787883698940277, -0.047240059822797775, -0.011114359833300114, -0.006243356503546238, 0.02778579294681549, -0.0055063990876078606, 0.04055485501885414, -0.0035455296747386456, -0.022359691560268402, 0.014718230813741684, -0.05800746753811836, 0.029452038928866386, -0.02427407167851925, -0.044057928025722504, 0.036403246223926544, 0.006540833041071892, 0.018237050622701645, -0.0718320682644844, 0.026931079104542732, -0.07056700438261032, 0.0305293221026659, 0.054022107273340225, -0.04745563492178917, -0.03105963207781315, 0.06729168444871902, -0.041438572108745575, -0.011595752090215683, 0.05234644562005997, 0.04352569580078125, -0.015525964088737965, 0.03407297283411026, 0.04586246237158775, 0.05870148539543152, 0.02769548073410988, 0.03677568957209587, -0.06356754153966904, 0.010264975018799305, 0.050033073872327805, -0.018665675073862076, -0.05092333257198334, -0.01681492291390896, -0.0718473494052887, -0.03054257296025753, 0.0019311909563839436, 0.05048932135105133, 0.0017137292306870222, 0.005954480729997158, -0.025934288278222084, 0.058076318353414536, 0.036947835236787796, -0.06710847467184067, -0.06749462336301804, -0.00009000655700219795, -0.05418599769473076, -0.02427610754966736, 0.011983020231127739, -0.019060388207435608, -0.07101239264011383, 0.011013406328856945, -0.0828833356499672, -0.0170272309333086, -0.023005880415439606, 0.049681805074214935, -0.03142789378762245, -0.02313772588968277, 0.02290435880422592, 0.006620349362492561, 0.04258647561073303, 0.008537237532436848, 0.02065439522266388, 0.04101187363266945, 0.002977210795506835, 0.017907507717609406, -0.0143177080899477, -0.01916562207043171, 0.05487120896577835, -0.012267880141735077, -0.01819285750389099, 0.056934114545583725, -0.0008309092372655869, -0.03622695431113243, 0.021193083375692368, 0.014316520653665066, 0.006993845570832491, -0.017310256138443947, -0.021171187981963158, -0.01881759986281395, 0.01934141106903553, -0.07516518235206604, 0.060462068766355515, -0.037235040217638016, 0.018277769908308983, -0.02859223634004593, -0.010415416210889816, -0.026418868452310562, -0.027857350185513496, -0.01345446240156889, 0.02971854992210865, 0.008061990141868591, -0.03030785173177719, 0.04561357945203781, -0.03672622889280319, 0.003620498115196824, 0.0364820696413517, -0.020437851548194885, -0.042064107954502106, 0.0005065575242042542, 0.03617488965392113, -0.03150514140725136, -0.002028339309617877, -0.0588119812309742, -0.019432179629802704, -0.024130770936608315, 0.03914102166891098, -0.00012622655776795, 0.06951409578323364, -0.028454577550292015, -0.03428259864449501, -0.030361752957105637, -0.05231880769133568, 0.02511596865952015, -0.06705672293901443, -0.0475076325237751, -0.025342881679534912, 0.014720626175403595, -0.039813123643398285, 0.018458355218172073, 0.015583300031721592, 0.046050965785980225, 0.03730904683470726, -0.012614190578460693, -0.013144522905349731, -0.012047374621033669, -0.046518128365278244, 0.07599551975727081, 0.06045755743980408, 0.006183361168950796, -0.047243811190128326, 0.017523394897580147, -0.03257483243942261, -0.006739798467606306, 0.03149738162755966, -0.04796941950917244, -0.05808739736676216, -0.025481602177023888, -0.0452481210231781, 0.05507340282201767, -0.003747381502762437, -0.006737431976944208, 0.003067118814215064, 0.060895856469869614, -0.017329463735222816, -0.05500186234712601 ]
Autonomous vehicles (AVs) are expected to bring major benefits to transport and society. To exploit this potential, their acceptance by society is a necessary condition. However, AV acceptance is currently at stake: AVs face resistance by bystanders and local communities. Resistance can prevent the implementation and use of AVs, threatening road safety and efficiency. The present study performed a qualitative and quantitative text analysis of comments submitted by locals in San Francisco (SF) to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) on the fared deployment of AVs. The results of the analysis are synthesized, and a conceptual framework explaining and predicting resistance is proposed. The framework posits that the occurrence of resistance is a direct result of the perception of threats, which is determined by individual and system characteristics, direct and indirect consequences of system use, reactions of others, and external events. AVs as threat to safety was associated with their unpredictable, and illegal driving behavior, as well as producing conflict situations. The lack of explicit communication between AVs and other road users due to the absence of a human driver behind the steering wheel negatively contributed to perceived safety and trust, especially for vulnerable populations in crossing situations. Respondents reported a negative impact on road capacity, congestion, and traffic flow, with AVs blocking other road users, such as emergency vehicles. Inaccessible vehicle design contributed to the exclusion of vulnerable groups with disabilities. The scientific dialogue on acceptance of AVs needs to shift towards resistance as the 'other' essential element of acceptance to ensure that we live up to our promise of transitioning towards more sustainable mobility that is inclusive, equitable, fair, just, affordable, and available to all.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10484v1
[ -0.023312853649258614, -0.04926175996661186, 0.0023682774044573307, -0.025038613006472588, 0.015357626602053642, 0.029591836035251617, -0.0009249250870198011, 0.047023385763168335, -0.03816811367869377, -0.049538109451532364, -0.06601748615503311, -0.03961183503270149, -0.034883834421634674, -0.009784523397684097, -0.02074272744357586, 0.0011225708294659853, 0.06207014247775078, 0.04431211203336716, -0.020468182861804962, 0.023400431498885155, 0.004365056287497282, -0.03237741068005562, -0.010791049338877201, 0.025593899190425873, 0.0335833840072155, 0.010945343412458897, 0.011590596288442612, 0.004693565424531698, -0.044733334332704544, -0.040193285793066025, 0.056892890483140945, -0.021774452179670334, -0.03954227268695831, -0.033712856471538544, -0.0676797479391098, -0.03584744781255722, -0.00483509199693799, -0.010794168338179588, -0.007490500807762146, -0.03125952556729317, 0.0144423209130764, -0.07016321271657944, 0.01008758693933487, 0.022832944989204407, -0.05584357678890228, -0.021066268905997276, -0.04224076122045517, 0.03404798358678818, -0.0627397894859314, -0.007317437324672937, 0.023938771337270737, 0.014612602069973946, 0.028905468061566353, 0.021616138517856598, -0.04024052992463112, 0.006535734981298447, 0.01748623140156269, 0.02198381908237934, 0.0048092808574438095, -0.022539306432008743, 0.007053302600979805, -0.021449318155646324, 0.01886753737926483, -0.0313071645796299, -0.01672825776040554, 0.05390561372041702, -0.04034723341464996, -0.012866109609603882, -0.020271852612495422, -0.028651032596826553, 0.004627350717782974, -0.05990538373589516, 0.01126429159194231, -0.005735902115702629, -0.028680138289928436, -0.022606482729315758, -0.0512421615421772, -0.03677177429199219, -0.011068489402532578, -0.005239732097834349, 0.006438334472477436, 0.041410282254219055, 0.046657461673021317, 0.03189447894692421, -0.02828417718410492, -0.02409551665186882, 0.06907207518815994, -0.010459806770086288, 0.006447406020015478, -0.043644990772008896, 0.04473854601383209, -0.0580407977104187, -0.05363817140460014, -0.05959220603108406, 0.05238865315914154, 0.008731510490179062, 0.04570375382900238, -0.0034174234606325626, -0.012304987758398056, -0.06725191324949265, -0.049734678119421005, 0.03570915758609772, -0.04442191869020462, 0.04432559385895729, 0.050623588263988495, -0.07459577172994614, 0.017267892137169838, 0.008842360228300095, -0.03935187682509422, -0.0028044988866895437, -0.029406903311610222, -0.06287946552038193, -0.049489833414554596, -0.08447251468896866, -0.05260436609387398, -0.007125244941562414, 0.03381609544157982, 0.006688795518130064, 0.04767058417201042, -0.004145701881498098, -0.08293542265892029, 0.04965013265609741, -0.0049343956634402275, 0.025585006922483444, -0.005250496789813042, 0.012860695831477642, 0.05794985592365265, 0.031030086800456047, 0.01714371144771576, 0.022686205804347992, -0.05866759642958641, 0.053182635456323624, -0.03919774293899536, -0.029601920396089554, 0.045101940631866455, 0.00851792935281992, 0.037800755351781845, -0.009176681749522686, 0.0398905985057354, 0.004195324145257473, -0.020351910963654518, 0.007896737195551395, -0.01122717559337616, 0.01649373583495617, -0.013040986843407154, 0.060830771923065186, 0.004568430595099926, -0.021808739751577377, 0.016047557815909386, 0.029938267543911934, 0.02719390019774437, -0.014192377217113972, 0.050900641828775406, 0.04718781262636185, 0.021376317366957664, -0.019139176234602928, 0.01574099436402321, -0.022648679092526436, -0.048360344022512436, 0.03613927960395813, -0.0044717746786773205, -0.02518739365041256, 0.025906838476657867, -0.008087331429123878, 0.029751572757959366, 0.037123870104551315, 0.07211413234472275, -0.021095361560583115, -0.005135452374815941, 0.012274757027626038, -0.032166656106710434, 0.07588351517915726, -0.03506721556186676, -0.035942379385232925, -0.046875253319740295, -0.011939242482185364, 0.05265151336789131, -0.025539223104715347, 0.03286152333021164, 0.04201206564903259, -0.00605707848444581, 0.006224823649972677, -0.03288627415895462, 0.016577797010540962, 0.0010647193994373083, 0.008838566951453686, -0.08967582136392593, -0.05523436889052391, -0.03392424061894417, 0.011170671321451664, -0.05617886409163475, -0.08816494792699814, -0.038809385150671005, -0.0360751748085022, -0.013637936674058437, -0.018729835748672485, -0.014539792202413082, -0.04379646107554436, 0.0018932895036414266, 0.007919829338788986, -0.0731373056769371, -0.008953223004937172, -0.07199592888355255, -0.03698206692934036, 0.005306439474225044, -0.0753694474697113, 0.03924720361828804, 0.017479579895734787, -0.039059385657310486, -0.027836397290229797, 0.012128484435379505, -0.02302810736000538, 0.021254517138004303, 0.034499164670705795, 0.012435276061296463, -0.006940189283341169, -0.10992534458637238, 0.02355673536658287, 0.0343799889087677, -0.01616484671831131, 0.0668494924902916, -0.0022619839292019606, 0.028476087376475334, 0.006146905943751335, -0.035645272582769394, -0.003520169062539935, 0.023748021572828293, -0.07006864994764328, -0.030560603365302086, -0.02252049930393696, -0.02430936135351658, -0.07247596979141235, -0.018495522439479828, -0.05746069923043251, -0.00492635415866971, -0.0319761224091053, -0.029956264421343803, 0.03294866532087326, -0.01143393013626337, -0.024081893265247345, -0.02925962023437023, -0.07220042496919632, 0.03583679348230362, -0.019976353272795677, -0.019394109025597572, 0.0073470924980938435, -0.043498262763023376, 0.0223805233836174, -0.01919947750866413, 0.04378274455666542, -0.007563232909888029, -0.05520705133676529, 0.016897398978471756, -0.04259278252720833, 0.020597007125616074, 0.04827907681465149, -0.015360199846327305, 0.047369763255119324, -0.034028150141239166, 0.02131214179098606, 0.025190187618136406, -0.0012426750035956502, -0.06221834570169449, 0.024479564279317856, 0.05927076190710068, -0.030296672135591507, 0.0065310136415064335, -0.010268923826515675, 0.02266017161309719, -0.04313818737864494, 0.03849504142999649, 0.005927050486207008, 0.021170957013964653, -0.005426330491900444, 0.026848766952753067, -0.020982597023248672, 0.0501578263938427, -0.0008038976811803877, 0.004004037007689476, 0.029559815302491188, 0.03244825825095177, 0.020061137154698372, 0.017654327675700188, -0.01625063829123974, -0.009518365375697613, -0.006231192499399185, -0.02763720601797104, -0.07063808292150497, -0.02917374297976494, -0.000026421826987643726, -0.062445662915706635, -0.031082546338438988, -0.0041452678851783276, -0.03248327225446701, -0.0001498935598647222, -0.06309179961681366, -0.0547587126493454, -0.006026830989867449, 0.017257334664463997, -0.01790718547999859, -0.040451403707265854, -0.006866400595754385, 0.004106949083507061, 0.005616588983684778, -0.00110782275442034, -0.032338693737983704, -0.03870437294244766, -0.05587409809231758, -0.005725495051592588, -0.02573467046022415, -0.02477567084133625, 0.04876108095049858, -0.03671152517199516, 0.049338750541210175, -0.029200023040175438, -0.02514776587486267, -0.007651136256754398, -0.04941512644290924, 0.011575635522603989, -0.015300239436328411, 0.033457498997449875, 0.00040156859904527664, 0.03610346466302872, -0.05022038519382477, -0.06003944203257561, -0.02372308261692524, 0.07220996171236038, 0.04561843350529671, 0.03554951772093773, -0.07305120676755905, 0.004192455671727657, 0.007046311162412167, -0.02348981983959675, -0.03865385800600052, 0.028494376689195633, -0.006101423408836126, -0.046793028712272644, -0.0341438464820385, 0.0315173864364624, 0.005774241406470537, -0.03516693413257599, -0.0007379809394478798, -0.06139352172613144, 0.003448266303166747, -0.006665179505944252, -0.02219206467270851, -0.03833106905221939, 0.033923570066690445, 0.06762383133172989, 0.0318918451666832, 0.040837183594703674, 0.021900847554206848, -0.02930324897170067, 0.005577618256211281, 0.006427352782338858, 0.039762742817401886, 0.062104206532239914, 0.06389901041984558, 0.041164569556713104, -0.058684393763542175, -0.011381205171346664, -0.07706790417432785, -0.06128617748618126, 0.009279516525566578, 0.03481493890285492, 0.025139780715107918, 0.04527689889073372, -0.030872071161866188, 0.036000411957502365, 0.0007463640067726374, 0.07391326874494553, 0.004109406843781471, -0.03507344424724579, 0.016949621960520744, -0.015864823013544083, 0.009863747283816338, 0.03235341235995293, 0.045805610716342926, -0.046355411410331726, -0.07650242000818253, 0.01532782893627882, -0.07840103656053543, 0.003128553507849574, 0.0015840214909985662, 0.007152635604143143, 0.05206574127078056, 0.07666222751140594, 0.020686516538262367, 0.058461666107177734, 0.005726037546992302, 0.006512552499771118, -0.0217903982847929, -0.042548514902591705, -0.003609306877478957, -0.03184988349676132, -0.014540981501340866, -0.010666776448488235, 0.03671782463788986, -0.006029011216014624, 0.03219297528266907, 0.030145099386572838, -0.0017831864533945918, -0.005184795707464218, -0.09394805133342743, 0.027127202600240707, -0.012956459075212479, 0.010575675405561924, 0.01005520112812519, 0.03173677995800972, 0.048160769045352936, -0.016130954027175903, 0.012608037330210209, -0.06629075109958649, -0.02316574938595295, -0.0241194199770689, -0.0011569877387955785, 0.00139147462323308, -0.023523399606347084, 0.006478951312601566, -0.06772325932979584, -0.007558170706033707, 0.041103947907686234, 0.04490310326218605, -0.014868509024381638, 0.018563153222203255, -0.017569372430443764, 0.029198678210377693, 0.06482347100973129, 0.0006600877968594432, -0.04374878108501434, -0.00849901232868433, -0.003071507206186652, 0.01602655090391636, -0.0058011263608932495, -0.004729560110718012, -0.016616910696029663, 0.02399894967675209, -0.006858234293758869, 0.03574587032198906, -0.00911959633231163, -0.005185570102185011, 0.06177836284041405, -0.018191512674093246, -0.03509078547358513, 0.003769972827285528, 0.029988791793584824, -0.06394955515861511, -0.05384416505694389, -0.050608765333890915, -0.06748636811971664, -0.058625102043151855, 0.0009688508580438793, -0.023098574951291084, 0.008981112390756607, 0.00914718210697174, 0.041692834347486496, 0.04025336354970932, 0.040618907660245895, 0.02623979188501835, 0.05615682154893875, -0.0037545491941273212, 0.0436481274664402, 0.002168040256947279, -0.010086103342473507, -0.05147186294198036, 0.05920841917395592, -0.009695631451904774, 0.013335944153368473, -0.07317674905061722, 0.0608815997838974, 0.028328703716397285, 0.0606280192732811, -0.059828925877809525, 0.0567021407186985, 0.04949616640806198, -0.04129825904965401, 0.03521040827035904, 0.023004619404673576, -0.028356093913316727, 0.033738844096660614, -0.05599779635667801, 0.032575447112321854, 0.03324932977557182, -0.004991265945136547, 0.022442465648055077, -0.011129788123071194, -0.0007325674523599446, 0.007410765625536442, 0.04638472944498062, -0.046230919659137726, -0.07705678045749664, 0.007814660668373108, 0.03815142437815666, 0.0037307485472410917, -0.045607488602399826, -0.01005039643496275, 0.02198631316423416, -0.020271211862564087, 0.015239027328789234, -0.0031722940038889647, 0.009838462807238102, 0.033704087138175964, 0.06542062759399414, -0.07115503400564194, 0.00690265279263258, 0.0034911101683974266, 0.04744023457169533, -0.014176744967699051, 0.0034581541549414396, -0.009490585885941982, -0.009837986901402473, 0.023115551099181175, 0.005115068517625332, -0.07022864371538162, 0.0068320925347507, -0.05559266731142998, 0.060996752232313156, 0.07280213385820389, 0.03495815396308899, 0.03732302784919739, -0.003545039566233754, -0.06690559536218643, -0.0560406818985939, 0.03608722984790802, -0.034349191933870316, -0.0016639487585052848, -0.07200436294078827, 0.03983917087316513, 0.02482505515217781, 0.007560728583484888, 0.009391728788614273, 0.008143624290823936, 0.003865779610350728, -0.014318400993943214, -0.04756951704621315, -0.03957308828830719, 0.004764453042298555, -0.0063087898306548595, -0.05470435321331024, 0.04386458545923233, 0.029428226873278618, -0.026010669767856598, 0.016003023833036423, -0.026620691642165184, -0.056252963840961456, 0.0067934077233076096, 0.006252986378967762, -0.013004256412386894, -0.0038177764508873224, -0.006017978303134441, 0.0803411602973938, -0.05474181845784187, 0.01764523610472679, 0.02193942666053772, -0.04634874686598778, -0.04414474964141846, -0.030884746462106705, -0.020581064745783806, -0.006216282956302166, -0.04587137699127197, -0.03216942027211189, -0.022845769301056862, -0.02130776457488537, -0.07335344702005386, -0.005103935953229666, 0.010963610373437405, -0.04496348276734352, -0.005054857116192579, 0.037762124091386795, -0.00006276020576478913, -0.06021503359079361, 0.0548180490732193, 0.007177624385803938, 0.005020677112042904, -0.01278726663440466, 0.04339417815208435, 0.07266376912593842, -0.0303146094083786, -0.04205318167805672, -0.002745550824329257, -0.02669868804514408, 0.021606653928756714, -0.026807919144630432, 0.007959343492984772, -0.014584374614059925, 0.03336326777935028, 0.0205348189920187, 0.040986448526382446, -0.034840233623981476, 0.07171984761953354, -0.03179534524679184, -0.0005502871354110539, -0.020126810297369957, -0.07145734876394272, 0.048194870352745056, -0.01327816117554903, -0.014845876023173332, 0.006100518628954887, -0.03596457093954086, 0.004901443142443895, -0.030207127332687378, -0.03931209817528725, -0.011148601770401001, -0.021118033677339554, 0.025470728054642677, -0.03498542681336403, 0.017062390223145485, -0.031849198043346405, -0.038845185190439224, 0.025601038709282875, 0.008182575926184654, -0.0059390561655163765, 0.01857459545135498, -0.040364209562540054, 0.003348577069118619, 0.006773245986551046, -0.05950147658586502, 0.007407243829220533, 0.02005799300968647, -0.0042679887264966965, 0.019666798412799835, 0.004842960275709629, 0.003984708804637194, 0.0328461192548275, 0.025855407118797302, -0.03991491347551346, -0.029411733150482178, -0.01739341951906681, 0.04190778732299805, 0.038354191929101944, -0.0382743701338768, -0.047127559781074524, -0.06346956640481949, 0.027108890935778618, -0.009871854446828365, 0.026521407067775726, 0.05150333419442177, -0.008232786320149899, -0.05309143289923668, 0.054095614701509476, -0.006862014997750521, 0.0014244936173781753, 0.0009722099057398736, 0.06369204819202423, 0.034236110746860504, 0.011231381446123123, 0.04955846071243286, 0.041321225464344025, -0.024009160697460175, -0.011548459529876709, -0.052399978041648865, 0.016733553260564804, 0.0410785935819149, -0.029492689296603203, -0.007541888393461704, 0.011048226617276669, -0.03857923671603203, -0.04438784345984459, 0.022741006687283516, 0.026419514790177345, 0.0008885501883924007, -0.003606037236750126, -0.016799552366137505, 0.00921989232301712, -0.013797461986541748, -0.03536658734083176, -0.044365398585796356, 0.014874565415084362, -0.04088917747139931, -0.04630666598677635, 0.01176402810961008, 0.021637074649333954, -0.06627776473760605, -0.028506433591246605, -0.06728829443454742, -0.016934501007199287, 0.005277283955365419, 0.030935464426875114, -0.033731609582901, -0.06217077374458313, 0.025281505659222603, -0.06964018195867538, 0.0438426248729229, 0.05425276234745979, -0.019042668864130974, -0.005781206302344799, 0.04023654758930206, 0.008778548799455166, -0.005416386295109987, -0.010171644389629364, 0.009127344936132431, -0.017049990594387054, 0.017360951751470566, -0.02338007278740406, 0.034034598618745804, -0.04301823675632477, 0.002920525148510933, -0.024662209674715996, -0.0391579233109951, 0.025667641311883926, -0.061606865376234055, 0.033743519335985184, -0.004309411160647869, -0.09041643142700195, -0.015967972576618195, -0.006998100783675909, -0.0013736647088080645, 0.03743674233555794, -0.05013984069228172, -0.014916283078491688, -0.0480889156460762, -0.026932360604405403, 0.05127136781811714, -0.0541059635579586, 0.000803784467279911, 0.0652390569448471, -0.004731913562864065, -0.019741617143154144, -0.013529966585338116, -0.01695612072944641, -0.03183544799685478, 0.0408199243247509, 0.028246551752090454, -0.07688923925161362, -0.014531144872307777, -0.057704243808984756, -0.010450092144310474, 0.02349390834569931, -0.03189486265182495, -0.042743951082229614, 0.03699418902397156, 0.03887525945901871, -0.06223557889461517, -0.03553426265716553, -0.031028252094984055, -0.043980587273836136, -0.07128778845071793, -0.032343629747629166, -0.02505982480943203, 0.0014346609823405743, 0.05129094421863556, 0.016975529491901398, 0.025427421554923058, 0.041960716247558594, -0.016589732840657234, 0.04743768647313118, -0.04767279699444771, 0.006887729279696941, 0.023565534502267838, 0.05820547789335251, 0.020274942740797997, -0.002603468718007207, -0.00270123896189034, 0.02480647899210453, 0.0030386492144316435, 0.018986579030752182, 0.008327650837600231, 0.020932311192154884, -0.01765262521803379, -0.03774125128984451, 0.008556363172829151, 0.06837942451238632, -0.036362577229738235, -0.003456434467807412, -0.051372967660427094, 0.05988799035549164, 0.015781546011567116, -0.029048234224319458 ]
We present the theoretical status of the lifetimes of weakly decaying heavy hadrons containing a bottom or a charm quark, and discuss the current predictions, based on the framework of the Heavy Quark Expansion (HQE), for both mesons and baryons. Potential improvements to reduce the theoretical uncertainties are also highlighted.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14590v1
[ 0.006964368745684624, -0.0046477713622152805, 0.005651665385812521, 0.006217921152710915, 0.009782503359019756, -0.06421992182731628, -0.01866152137517929, 0.03958316892385483, -0.019663985818624496, 0.021358320489525795, 0.036019109189510345, -0.04701768606901169, -0.03158546984195709, -0.05925256013870239, -0.04148861765861511, 0.04866449534893036, 0.03389754146337509, 0.0380396693944931, 0.002690663794055581, 0.07489107549190521, -0.040321897715330124, -0.01097877137362957, -0.02166655845940113, 0.0071889362297952175, -0.012637688778340816, -0.007407245226204395, -0.0424598790705204, -0.004281339235603809, -0.028249027207493782, -0.027362262830138206, 0.016194436699151993, -0.05760829523205757, -0.0016276479000225663, 0.02645178511738777, 0.014132775366306305, -0.0715520977973938, -0.007807381451129913, 0.047457098960876465, 0.05081693455576897, -0.006959863938391209, -0.03546453267335892, -0.04979502782225609, -0.04776918888092041, -0.011369495652616024, 0.007165397051721811, -0.026329252868890762, -0.005402721930295229, -0.016073493286967278, -0.08095423877239227, -0.07935068011283875, 0.04379480332136154, 0.020509816706180573, -0.007600842043757439, 0.045475710183382034, -0.03217848762869835, 0.025664551183581352, 0.017965851351618767, -0.05262336879968643, -0.04204971343278885, 0.0013857262674719095, -0.03305487707257271, -0.041055332869291306, -0.025388101115822792, -0.024895133450627327, -0.04028259590268135, 0.027635319158434868, 0.0069215502589941025, 0.015308050438761711, 0.01568456180393696, -0.07146245241165161, 0.0668984055519104, -0.06462603807449341, 0.04925604537129402, 0.026108000427484512, -0.03579458221793175, 0.02838626317679882, 0.025163743644952774, -0.04856006056070328, 0.0007134345360100269, 0.027862776070833206, -0.070033498108387, 0.0302941482514143, 0.056402042508125305, 0.006528794765472412, 0.001907809404656291, -0.0398583747446537, -0.0336187481880188, -0.021683188155293465, -0.044840067625045776, -0.04070840775966644, 0.054629042744636536, -0.0077630383893847466, -0.07469365745782852, 0.012033598497509956, -0.004526443313807249, 0.01846080832183361, 0.08198095113039017, 0.05328810214996338, 0.0008753746515139937, -0.004519727546721697, 0.009513864293694496, -0.062172628939151764, -0.03550942614674568, 0.04755590856075287, 0.021488023921847343, 0.008499843999743462, 0.026580123230814934, -0.05385994166135788, 0.014322489500045776, 0.028424382209777832, 0.02501203864812851, 0.03496943786740303, 0.008601568639278412, -0.056027527898550034, -0.03150040656328201, 0.013515228405594826, 0.020975178107619286, 0.046361446380615234, 0.01161771547049284, -0.0068075647577643394, -0.01965160109102726, 0.055007267743349075, -0.015863167122006416, 0.025591300800442696, -0.0003956996079068631, -0.016117364168167114, 0.02434157021343708, -0.015383390709757805, -0.011685404926538467, -0.014434367418289185, -0.02748468518257141, -0.003476049518212676, 0.02150043100118637, -0.06559143960475922, -0.018078410997986794, -0.0450388602912426, 0.061789270490407944, 0.014849890023469925, 0.02377287484705448, -0.03956828638911247, -0.06005609780550003, -0.05089995265007019, 0.06700094044208527, 0.029284141957759857, -0.017237534746527672, 0.044125787913799286, -0.05481727048754692, -0.00955415703356266, 0.0436500646173954, 0.05820784345269203, 0.05808734521269798, 0.005300216842442751, 0.005379575304687023, -0.024469146504998207, -0.013600599020719528, -0.016908196732401848, 0.021952027454972267, 0.07573343813419342, -0.0016961612273007631, 0.0258112121373415, 0.02804449573159218, 0.007515510078519583, 0.013803157024085522, 0.03708665445446968, -0.005329919047653675, -0.008213615976274014, 0.00015214765153359622, -0.04748360440135002, -0.03141237422823906, -0.015082686208188534, -0.052430085837841034, 0.03118622489273548, -0.023840179666876793, -0.021415725350379944, -0.047967925667762756, -0.03315736725926399, -0.03158310428261757, -0.05243673175573349, -0.04442395642399788, 0.00152682198677212, 0.04520605877041817, 0.026590164750814438, 0.005115067586302757, 0.044003311544656754, -0.014587935991585255, -0.0563017763197422, -0.04724474996328354, -0.0014558510156348348, 0.01940595917403698, -0.02312992326915264, -0.01579459011554718, -0.025824494659900665, -0.028170239180326462, 0.025558268651366234, -0.055128589272499084, -0.06389206647872925, 0.024833885952830315, 0.01388645637780428, -0.045231569558382034, 0.021720649674534798, -0.060879431664943695, -0.0038721205200999975, 0.012311389669775963, 0.02392335794866085, 0.011971565894782543, -0.024155616760253906, -0.036241933703422546, 0.059453561902046204, -0.051690053194761276, -0.05302955582737923, 0.03441629186272621, 0.04994948208332062, 0.013582570478320122, -0.021131111308932304, 0.02582058124244213, 0.020711105316877365, -0.10948450118303299, 0.02392507717013359, -0.01969376765191555, -0.024055061861872673, 0.027155643329024315, -0.020761681720614433, 0.015500041656196117, 0.023015251383185387, 0.010626601986587048, 0.0004218814428895712, 0.01050021592527628, -0.0017256222199648619, -0.02960815839469433, -0.030061056837439537, -0.019569402560591698, -0.05901869013905525, -0.03249471262097359, -0.017507698386907578, -0.011235657148063183, 0.001375691150315106, -0.054434049874544144, 0.033460747450590134, 0.0036010844632983208, -0.05428902804851532, -0.01133786141872406, 0.014756781049072742, 0.014434898272156715, -0.0388091616332531, -0.024285465478897095, -0.011308387853205204, -0.050554219633340836, -0.0021099220030009747, -0.022564183920621872, -0.024544447660446167, 0.0198920127004385, -0.06405381858348846, 0.008057955652475357, 0.018102984875440598, 0.025389112532138824, 0.011578242294490337, -0.04898563399910927, -0.03803916648030281, -0.047629449516534805, 0.04930057004094124, -0.04117082431912422, -0.008318775333464146, 0.023022495210170746, 0.015248572453856468, 0.00879695639014244, 0.0647222250699997, 0.0011908769374713302, -0.01760435290634632, -0.05570441111922264, 0.012500324286520481, -0.01686987839639187, -0.0336344838142395, 0.043461598455905914, -0.001432091579772532, -0.01089155301451683, 0.021311761811375618, -0.009908764623105526, -0.04640572518110275, -0.022808201611042023, 0.010557791218161583, 0.01749172993004322, 0.03516411408782005, -0.004731910303235054, -0.05120212957262993, -0.0020130916964262724, -0.012941604480147362, -0.06748310476541519, -0.013378565199673176, -0.034123245626688004, -0.0032346085645258427, -0.06586476415395737, 0.011895733885467052, 0.06321799010038376, -0.03066021017730236, -0.030543237924575806, 0.07382819801568985, -0.033973947167396545, -0.03717293590307236, 0.0403774194419384, -0.07168718427419662, -0.0012178001925349236, -0.01871192455291748, 0.011127276346087456, 0.051991771906614304, 0.002809641184285283, -0.027849148958921432, -0.071297287940979, -0.004471438471227884, -0.016212429851293564, 0.023560434579849243, -0.027538955211639404, -0.00774143822491169, 0.015513964928686619, -0.022510908544063568, -0.0020015921909362078, 0.08432608842849731, 0.003587333019822836, -0.03157084062695503, -0.049227919429540634, -0.028018904849886894, -0.040676701813936234, 0.016140257939696312, -0.022423703223466873, -0.03473588824272156, -0.060572151094675064, -0.026753278449177742, 0.06229652464389801, 0.016825295984745026, 0.012360582128167152, 0.02698821760714054, -0.04186783730983734, -0.0325358621776104, -0.005054217763245106, -0.030081769451498985, 0.07279325276613235, 0.012609136290848255, -0.05698559433221817, 0.04114158824086189, 0.000289809686364606, 0.019434703513979912, -0.015076682902872562, 0.07311097532510757, 0.02852608449757099, -0.03554869443178177, -0.07200020551681519, -0.07178787142038345, 0.053503114730119705, -0.006380587350577116, 0.008908373303711414, -0.006413029041141272, 0.00981992669403553, 0.030606985092163086, 0.011807888746261597, 0.015820873901247978, -0.03840450569987297, -0.010808360762894154, -0.006766484584659338, 0.0006687801796942949, -0.0021986246574670076, -0.02353884093463421, 0.035438861697912216, -0.03079826757311821, -0.06332848221063614, 0.048313215374946594, 0.05125708132982254, 0.04890521243214607, 0.04396124184131622, 0.0028959435876458883, 0.03538421913981438, -0.010081556625664234, 0.02333441749215126, -0.01391594484448433, -0.0695464164018631, 0.008940798230469227, 0.009527196176350117, 0.026946190744638443, -0.014730612747371197, 0.004070247057825327, 0.016782572492957115, -0.06613406538963318, -0.04565936326980591, -0.04206472262740135, 0.01216278225183487, 0.015966201201081276, 0.043759819120168686, 0.05497683957219124, -0.015956556424498558, 0.0012613495346158743, 0.046443186700344086, -0.03650060296058655, -0.01653544418513775, -0.032643865793943405, -0.0068443287163972855, 0.024123946204781532, -0.002374144271016121, -0.03490824997425079, -0.04586014524102211, -0.01728266477584839, 0.0009208855917677283, -0.02918240800499916, 0.04188988730311394, -0.0017034434713423252, -0.05555364862084389, -0.07682707905769348, -0.07053227722644806, -0.02609914541244507, 0.03121686354279518, -0.04106094688177109, -0.07194362580776215, 0.07450598478317261, 0.015172259882092476, 0.0236881822347641, -0.03140786662697792, -0.02737315557897091, -0.059576187282800674, -0.012819389812648296, 0.018669921904802322, -0.05621479079127312, 0.03661644831299782, -0.010162582620978355, -0.04210902005434036, -0.0589224137365818, 0.009623370133340359, -0.06550295650959015, 0.025307439267635345, 0.0399521142244339, 0.026849785819649696, 0.04350557550787926, -0.0076189422979950905, 0.0173373743891716, -0.012231274507939816, 0.015440588817000389, 0.009638408198952675, 0.0016899347538128495, -0.006118824239820242, -0.04885564744472504, 0.05124973878264427, -0.03366838023066521, -0.05341063067317009, -0.044288549572229385, 0.05281419679522514, 0.0740816742181778, 0.01368128601461649, -0.0519755519926548, 0.046782393008470535, 0.022773655131459236, 0.021492082625627518, -0.013288287445902824, 0.0733242779970169, -0.04033936187624931, -0.026644635945558548, -0.04268869757652283, -0.004526364151388407, -0.044090382754802704, -0.040364861488342285, 0.06593023985624313, 0.0010022965725511312, 0.04073835909366608, -0.0044284360483288765, 0.011737196706235409, 0.013306742534041405, 0.03290475159883499, -0.04323278367519379, 0.001528188236989081, -0.055875811725854874, -0.021413324400782585, 0.03538032993674278, -0.024025600403547287, -0.014440647326409817, 0.035951144993305206, -0.06490638852119446, 0.019324904307723045, -0.06600794941186905, 0.009240631945431232, 0.012102940119802952, 0.002552049234509468, -0.005539020989090204, -0.007861832156777382, 0.028721239417791367, 0.014289825223386288, -0.026989083737134933, 0.018314003944396973, 0.03494745492935181, 0.004833894316107035, 0.03509548306465149, 0.053011704236269, -0.057371869683265686, -0.008740943856537342, 0.019008558243513107, 0.029505174607038498, -0.007288428954780102, -0.010994239710271358, 0.04350332170724869, 0.01231387723237276, 0.003288812004029751, -0.020381039008498192, 0.03375614061951637, 0.01602698303759098, -0.008078369311988354, 0.02276596799492836, 0.051877494901418686, -0.006060588173568249, 0.04422277957201004, -0.048492297530174255, -0.04503398761153221, -0.0029457472264766693, 0.023228298872709274, 0.004052124451845884, 0.045670438557863235, -0.021245453506708145, 0.04973062127828598, -0.051026977598667145, 0.035546232014894485, -0.0356864258646965, 0.01785861700773239, -0.0115126958116889, 0.017294317483901978, -0.021374810487031937, 0.04721050336956978, -0.00025567630655132234, 0.016573991626501083, 0.00623006746172905, -0.052763715386390686, -0.044167522341012955, 0.0290219746530056, 0.023577915504574776, 0.011782889254391193, -0.04858173429965973, 0.0015537915751338005, 0.006658222060650587, 0.04056324437260628, -0.002113936934620142, 0.00040808855555951595, 0.02294192649424076, -0.038487426936626434, -0.04358234256505966, -0.0024846887681633234, 0.0146006615832448, -0.04671777784824371, -0.048556119203567505, 0.06365732103586197, -0.04252319782972336, 0.032029181718826294, 0.058815475553274155, -0.011245368979871273, 0.032377712428569794, -0.018883846700191498, -0.034292951226234436, -0.09298936277627945, -0.001698862761259079, 0.08976543694734573, -0.01672971434891224, -0.028184305876493454, -0.017669932916760445, -0.018974006175994873, -0.002847027964890003, -0.054161157459020615, 0.06267288327217102, -0.032101478427648544, 0.006217846646904945, -0.03382270038127899, 0.0475923977792263, 0.033046524971723557, -0.055745482444763184, -0.03962056711316109, -0.03698581084609032, -0.039056431502103806, -0.013026166707277298, 0.016612431034445763, -0.016826270148158073, -0.05587936192750931, 0.002378821838647127, -0.037234142422676086, -0.05389348417520523, -0.02869153767824173, 0.05708824470639229, 0.02594938687980175, -0.04757831618189812, -0.0033472299110144377, -0.0631093755364418, -0.021381942555308342, -0.018337557092308998, -0.007999716326594353, -0.03690023347735405, 0.0044303457252681255, 0.007737700827419758, 0.013304315507411957, -0.0061127967201173306, -0.068447045981884, -0.0035904161632061005, -0.0030581310857087374, -0.03773520886898041, 0.014231916517019272, -0.008619279600679874, 0.029343876987695694, -0.03627128154039383, -0.04132777079939842, -0.027658086270093918, 0.008411114104092121, -0.05063437670469284, 0.03083573654294014, -0.01082555390894413, -0.02704080566763878, -0.01660858653485775, 0.006195052061229944, -0.0168879684060812, -0.03272506222128868, 0.0424569696187973, -0.009293001145124435, 0.025648100301623344, -0.03706090524792671, 0.03308982402086258, -0.022103330120444298, 0.050189774483442307, -0.026615016162395477, 0.015611082315444946, -0.040045369416475296, 0.02916073426604271, -0.04382899031043053, -0.017970101907849312, 0.007834002375602722, 0.039376940578222275, 0.005575415212661028, 0.023850098252296448, 0.05090152099728584, -0.024852417409420013, 0.03302820399403572, -0.06665909290313721, -0.07945309579372406, -0.06347130984067917, 0.0674080178141594, -0.02667435072362423, -0.018998989835381508, -0.0400102399289608, -0.049000196158885956, -0.026016799733042717, 0.06759064644575119, -0.023031581193208694, -0.04936420917510986, -0.013273567892611027, 0.04508849233388901, -0.008882589638233185, 0.04387345537543297, -0.06485229730606079, -0.019080957397818565, 0.0029746785294264555, 0.03878046199679375, 0.07291536033153534, -0.009276659227907658, -0.01912809908390045, -0.040680184960365295, -0.027774743735790253, -0.004888590425252914, 0.07058268040418625, -0.0017458287766203284, -0.012485729530453682, -0.014936869032680988, -0.08635354787111282, 0.019566072151064873, 0.035731926560401917, 0.02588880993425846, 0.006691363640129566, -0.051317207515239716, 0.04293600097298622, 0.03405693545937538, -0.038915134966373444, -0.032631803303956985, 0.06221242621541023, -0.0029701492749154568, 0.03934980928897858, -0.03811568394303322, 0.0129405427724123, -0.033296164125204086, 0.0009421611903235316, -0.07730641961097717, -0.02567889355123043, -0.05578906089067459, 0.041181813925504684, -0.0008718348108232021, 0.035554807633161545, -0.02637721411883831, -0.009532690048217773, 0.013890414498746395, 0.05616997182369232, 0.0020788514520972967, -0.0005370588623918593, 0.02090088650584221, 0.047093864530324936, -0.03734150901436806, 0.015753908082842827, 0.02567845955491066, -0.016841182485222816, -0.0133277652785182, 0.014615047723054886, -0.017145680263638496, -0.05423193797469139, 0.0713270753622055, 0.04750528931617737, -0.000358155753929168, -0.03063827194273472, 0.029034312814474106, 0.020623574033379555, -0.02384580858051777, -0.03346055746078491, 0.03148693963885307, -0.009887643158435822, 0.00863250158727169, -0.012909756042063236, 0.016512535512447357, -0.027269234880805016, -0.0151425926014781, 0.0003051309031434357, -0.005938999820500612, 0.031214337795972824, 0.02546510472893715, -0.004429422318935394, -0.06955020874738693, 0.014935671351850033, 0.02484857849776745, 0.05412330478429794, -0.07472702115774155, 0.062313564121723175, -0.03701622039079666, -0.07637031376361847, 0.0020151170901954174, -0.0557306706905365, 0.009621535427868366, -0.052079930901527405, 0.005877094808965921, -0.016281813383102417, 0.04347436502575874, -0.053774040192365646, -0.009027376770973206, -0.03552572801709175, -0.009262093342840672, -0.01451815851032734, -0.03170435503125191, 0.02167198807001114, 0.017817366868257523, 0.036966852843761444, -0.009047336876392365, 0.022330304607748985, 0.018591884523630142, 0.04096684977412224, 0.019620312377810478, -0.04679495841264725, -0.05561576783657074, -0.03250867873430252, -0.07997071743011475, -0.014737728051841259, 0.03216397389769554, -0.019808946177363396, -0.029238015413284302, 0.0030277438927441835, 0.004148231819272041, 0.009789329022169113, -0.011665006168186665, -0.0336582325398922, -0.04871748015284538, -0.015414968132972717, -0.043023593723773956, -0.007959994487464428, -0.010642308741807938, -0.05356375873088837, 0.07788693904876709, 0.02608179859817028, -0.04902932792901993, -0.004840260371565819 ]
As a second-order method, the Natural Gradient Descent (NGD) has the ability to accelerate training of neural networks. However, due to the prohibitive computational and memory costs of computing and inverting the Fisher Information Matrix (FIM), efficient approximations are necessary to make NGD scalable to Deep Neural Networks (DNNs). Many such approximations have been attempted. The most sophisticated of these is KFAC, which approximates the FIM as a block-diagonal matrix, where each block corresponds to a layer of the neural network. By doing so, KFAC ignores the interactions between different layers. In this work, we investigate the interest of restoring some low-frequency interactions between the layers by means of two-level methods. Inspired from domain decomposition, several two-level corrections to KFAC using different coarse spaces are proposed and assessed. The obtained results show that incorporating the layer interactions in this fashion does not really improve the performance of KFAC. This suggests that it is safe to discard the off-diagonal blocks of the FIM, since the block-diagonal approach is sufficiently robust, accurate and economical in computation time.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18083v2
[ -0.025119127705693245, -0.005072972737252712, 0.012672876007854939, 0.0024754302576184273, -0.03181706741452217, 0.002397982869297266, -0.0010154186747968197, 0.014990994706749916, 0.018393931910395622, -0.050416845828294754, -0.00008326365059474483, -0.04400599002838135, -0.035695672035217285, -0.047549597918987274, -0.04803061485290527, 0.03158513084053993, 0.08634535223245621, 0.036540158092975616, -0.04365892335772514, 0.08557342737913132, 0.027936065569519997, -0.04720105975866318, -0.049933530390262604, 0.05487965792417526, 0.049549706280231476, 0.0002881987893488258, -0.06167498975992203, 0.024608293548226357, 0.008111332543194294, -0.034134864807128906, 0.06458412855863571, -0.02336462214589119, -0.034836672246456146, -0.05739988386631012, -0.018018893897533417, 0.013895375654101372, -0.009275225922465324, 0.0640781819820404, 0.0014663704205304384, -0.027502547949552536, 0.045460231602191925, -0.04533206671476364, -0.03571275994181633, -0.04032569378614426, -0.040996477007865906, -0.008326348848640919, -0.030894652009010315, -0.00394777674227953, -0.009166453965008259, -0.0073136393912136555, 0.047485463321208954, -0.006794074550271034, 0.03420690819621086, -0.011684226803481579, -0.05511294677853584, 0.018417783081531525, -0.04731385409832001, 0.02938460372388363, -0.04251983389258385, 0.0029513000044971704, 0.006554866209626198, 0.007523849606513977, 0.011410870589315891, -0.053334858268499374, -0.014835269190371037, 0.05336894094944, -0.03068680129945278, -0.07571705430746078, -0.05030619353055954, 0.0014896331122145057, 0.05565597862005234, -0.06800613552331924, 0.018254803493618965, -0.02120167762041092, -0.07797577977180481, -0.023738322779536247, -0.029336243867874146, -0.006026118993759155, 0.0023668415378779173, -0.013285200111567974, 0.00992214772850275, 0.04436805844306946, 0.003561143996194005, 0.029947545379400253, -0.028084101155400276, -0.0149482237175107, 0.07900671660900116, -0.026296189054846764, 0.021489905193448067, -0.04170576483011246, 0.02999219484627247, -0.06425821781158447, -0.04710737243294716, 0.02001401036977768, 0.05610642582178116, -0.04158889874815941, 0.03976269066333771, 0.05690309777855873, -0.006473306566476822, 0.002649863250553608, 0.006312858778983355, -0.028735071420669556, -0.023560378700494766, 0.04062840715050697, 0.007747618947178125, 0.023302441462874413, 0.0020276850555092096, 0.02551177889108658, -0.03196491301059723, 0.02902236022055149, 0.0408150777220726, -0.02161833830177784, -0.007460861932486296, -0.022129042074084282, -0.03521478548645973, -0.011669052764773369, 0.05338117480278015, 0.030530890449881554, -0.007109250407665968, 0.012885377742350101, 0.001792222959920764, -0.015393964014947414, -0.007887045852839947, -0.021053321659564972, 0.011376301757991314, -0.01580355502665043, 0.06816118955612183, -0.011187171563506126, 0.006860063876956701, -0.03171095624566078, -0.043985363095998764, 0.015207423828542233, 0.028173130005598068, -0.011455527506768703, 0.048685554414987564, -0.013579823076725006, -0.0403260663151741, -0.05322220176458359, 0.032668955624103546, 0.05098968371748924, -0.02439420111477375, -0.06073632836341858, 0.036053311079740524, -0.01887528970837593, 0.037024661898612976, 0.06276595592498779, -0.0682998076081276, -0.018925176933407784, 0.039684440940618515, 0.04510733112692833, -0.025586817413568497, 0.02394537627696991, 0.03407733887434006, 0.02498146891593933, -0.023318005725741386, 0.01818177103996277, 0.044387202709913254, 0.0005990565987303853, -0.03773345798254013, 0.009535927325487137, 0.04922875016927719, -0.02090894803404808, -0.01215918455272913, -0.018952567130327225, 0.018877752125263214, -0.004276059567928314, 0.024303413927555084, 1.205474973176024e-7, 0.022211339324712753, 0.011009939014911652, -0.02210179716348648, -0.013241740874946117, -0.012177303433418274, -0.00024089931685011834, -0.04929203912615776, -0.009679242968559265, -0.014185844920575619, -0.029880348592996597, -0.025463340803980827, 0.005176768638193607, 0.019585121423006058, 0.01779869943857193, -0.007522540632635355, -0.0002199991577072069, -0.039039261639118195, -0.028867146000266075, -0.08919940888881683, 0.018837638199329376, -0.012798898853361607, -0.00003369220212334767, -0.0420653335750103, -0.0646299198269844, 0.0137797174975276, 0.01959432102739811, -0.0487348847091198, -0.021071650087833405, -0.025650881230831146, -0.008959506638348103, -0.011073202826082706, 0.018228750675916672, -0.08287166059017181, -0.06549020111560822, -0.04429599642753601, 0.014818810857832432, -0.002009811345487833, -0.04842609539628029, 0.021646514534950256, 0.028590163215994835, -0.02794301137328148, 0.00989852286875248, 0.05675593391060829, 0.0461350716650486, 0.054175637662410736, -0.011216518469154835, 0.05530882999300957, -0.021064845845103264, -0.10067553073167801, 0.025927504524588585, 0.013787338510155678, 0.03906920924782753, 0.017348453402519226, 0.012603058479726315, 0.005540154874324799, -0.05983613803982735, -0.026513569056987762, 0.0358097217977047, 0.05177873745560646, -0.010133817791938782, -0.043951068073511124, -0.030805448070168495, -0.009424127638339996, -0.05851884186267853, -0.04522370919585228, -0.06023664399981499, -0.018157564103603363, -0.013326587155461311, -0.0648852214217186, 0.030329056084156036, 0.03293684870004654, -0.04807373508810997, -0.03965090215206146, 0.02711419016122818, 0.03189396485686302, -0.018574951216578484, -0.05531569570302963, -0.017696721479296684, -0.02325534075498581, 0.0125012481585145, -0.031248703598976135, -0.003458071034401655, -0.036416273564100266, -0.05781187862157822, 0.001988892210647464, -0.018522853031754494, 0.05647110939025879, 0.024040397256612778, -0.02856443263590336, 0.002886910457164049, -0.010477865114808083, 0.04316505789756775, 0.022619711235165596, 0.03505495935678482, -0.05542901158332825, 0.029309431090950966, -0.016660824418067932, -0.0031815010588616133, -0.03874310478568077, -0.014872128143906593, 0.034687358886003494, -0.04327462986111641, -0.01548804808408022, 0.05896908417344093, 0.04087988659739494, 0.029619932174682617, 0.004420740529894829, -0.004075544886291027, -0.0069212159141898155, -0.0503263883292675, 0.012931814417243004, 0.02165074087679386, 0.030490096658468246, 0.022245850414037704, 0.03833043575286865, -0.07070666551589966, -0.0018842153949663043, -0.05821627750992775, 0.0020910771563649178, -0.03851783275604248, -0.02833685092628002, -0.07197173684835434, -0.04379190504550934, -0.06074194237589836, -0.044703416526317596, -0.054523762315511703, 0.019521094858646393, -0.04480758309364319, -0.003928869962692261, -0.018078135326504707, -0.041202981024980545, 0.01134142279624939, -0.04749813303351402, -0.03479687124490738, 0.0518198236823082, 0.0088692307472229, -0.00015185496886260808, -0.0665067732334137, -0.021440373733639717, 0.02903800457715988, 0.037715230137109756, 0.02910561114549637, 0.010100682266056538, 0.0005355000030249357, -0.0509156808257103, 0.027168864384293556, 0.01923002488911152, 0.037026938050985336, 0.03954646736383438, -0.011972728185355663, -0.013066687621176243, -0.019234275445342064, 0.034446362406015396, -0.025540847331285477, -0.00409944262355566, -0.039625249803066254, -0.06128217652440071, -0.04312010109424591, 0.06149383261799812, 0.01038441527634859, -0.024425039067864418, -0.032248836010694504, 0.020571419969201088, -0.012674545869231224, 0.031779106706380844, -0.0510052815079689, 0.025700349360704422, 0.018707262352108955, -0.022727150470018387, -0.011681678704917431, -0.022389214485883713, 0.011134408414363861, 0.010983170010149479, 0.02463310770690441, -0.0174147617071867, -0.00042560623842291534, 0.04497146233916283, -0.08237122744321823, -0.005553023889660835, 0.04364921152591705, 0.037401460111141205, -0.05889132618904114, 0.02222296968102455, 0.02583710476756096, 0.04617975279688835, -0.013654366135597229, 0.01547408290207386, 0.029258884489536285, 0.039774201810359955, 0.06475964188575745, -0.015922442078590393, -0.01085351500660181, -0.0011400990188121796, -0.0419185534119606, -0.03045499138534069, 0.01704656332731247, 0.01937451772391796, 0.041208334267139435, -0.01923220232129097, -0.06257982552051544, 0.03899113088846207, -0.060777779668569565, 0.04509622976183891, -0.036683954298496246, -0.028078634291887283, 0.04441724717617035, -0.0382969006896019, 0.004099465906620026, -0.010159640572965145, 0.026971036568284035, 0.013420609757304192, -0.07836195081472397, 0.026940220966935158, -0.07110916823148727, 0.023546911776065826, -0.034465331584215164, -0.03010724112391472, 0.03627577796578407, 0.052720215171575546, -0.044523876160383224, 0.05722346529364586, -0.014434349723160267, 0.00036918476689606905, -0.028214653953909874, 0.028803516179323196, 0.0020618275739252567, 0.03424850106239319, -0.08034665882587433, 0.015302655287086964, 0.022371431812644005, -0.025670461356639862, -0.010032055899500847, 0.05135934054851532, 0.004280931781977415, -0.019439909607172012, -0.07775437086820602, 0.03796779736876488, -0.0365319550037384, 0.015921352431178093, -0.02945529669523239, -0.04955810308456421, 0.08052242547273636, 0.04028255119919777, 0.029617775231599808, -0.024529743939638138, -0.014402398839592934, -0.025202929973602295, -0.0073233856819570065, 0.00701825600117445, -0.05844484642148018, -0.021664682775735855, -0.03372399881482124, 0.05822286754846573, 0.010269936174154282, 0.0021169185638427734, -0.06729403138160706, -0.03761707618832588, -0.022855669260025024, 0.02417760342359543, 0.046967506408691406, 0.006064404267817736, -0.028120193630456924, -0.012542953714728355, -0.04274885728955269, 0.020037546753883362, -0.020289139822125435, 0.010695422068238258, -0.042516667395830154, 0.022828828543424606, -0.001988277304917574, -0.06103213503956795, -0.051714811474084854, -0.03430691733956337, 0.036035045981407166, -0.043861109763383865, -0.04078057408332825, 0.020815463736653328, -0.02811359614133835, -0.06860728561878204, -0.03752497583627701, -0.045124467462301254, -0.01852627657353878, -0.06308940798044205, -0.015790000557899475, -0.008285271003842354, 0.055900946259498596, 0.018551316112279892, 0.018247561529278755, 0.03406940773129463, 0.022278353571891785, -0.028308289125561714, 0.04032394289970398, 0.03654734417796135, 0.02572104148566723, -0.03914770483970642, -0.029350684955716133, -0.06862476468086243, -0.0020500035025179386, -0.011298872530460358, 0.03839431703090668, 0.0026210795622318983, 0.0005595573456957936, -0.030680712312459946, 0.03449743613600731, -0.07780446112155914, -0.010282022878527641, 0.06460548937320709, -0.026030108332633972, 0.03364622965455055, 0.045504484325647354, -0.04950831085443497, 0.01706978678703308, -0.008350066840648651, 0.031509917229413986, 0.05485265329480171, -0.045430026948451996, 0.02679494582116604, 0.016746239736676216, -0.056287311017513275, -0.016714977100491524, 0.0048745679669082165, -0.005470046773552895, -0.00935062300413847, 0.027535125613212585, 0.04071330651640892, 0.004301056731492281, -0.010519964620471, 0.022475752979516983, 0.04507693275809288, -0.023333454504609108, -0.0511041022837162, 0.030279729515314102, 0.014706865884363651, 0.008953836746513844, 0.007799466606229544, -0.04201482608914375, -0.0035554745700210333, 0.046465225517749786, 0.0020621088333427906, 0.043194059282541275, 0.01269140001386404, 0.02831212244927883, -0.021600937470793724, -0.053823187947273254, -0.028026189655065536, -0.05395803600549698, -0.03633582592010498, -0.017293555662035942, 0.02337488904595375, 0.003941460512578487, 0.057226162403821945, -0.0064140851609408855, 0.047857072204351425, -0.005630634259432554, -0.02493867091834545, 0.01762576214969158, -0.06059182435274124, 0.06639701873064041, -0.03795557841658592, 0.027898725122213364, -0.029137663543224335, 0.03379741683602333, 0.025801099836826324, -0.0048978570848703384, -0.018817726522684097, 0.007732207886874676, -0.03599424287676811, -0.03613455221056938, 0.03391179442405701, -0.030775947496294975, -0.04733588546514511, -0.010758798569440842, 0.030120210722088814, -0.042829934507608414, 0.04914945736527443, 0.0407567135989666, -0.038489632308483124, 0.016576509922742844, -0.006702450104057789, -0.024833040311932564, -0.02880512736737728, 0.012136317789554596, 0.06863519549369812, -0.07287264615297318, -0.007137513253837824, -0.006257194560021162, -0.04666334390640259, -0.0038520251400768757, -0.0031282484997063875, -0.01579212211072445, 0.0406317375600338, -0.03810041770339012, -0.06781768798828125, 0.050896089524030685, 0.001995222643017769, -0.08584246784448624, -0.030904384329915047, 0.04984631389379501, -0.07936767488718033, -0.0007717650732956827, -0.0057006417773664, 0.0030164956115186214, -0.08071444928646088, 0.011314279399812222, 0.010450482368469238, -0.028084343299269676, -0.047120120376348495, 0.041499603539705276, 0.08111576735973358, -0.04740104824304581, 0.007230404764413834, 0.0509767048060894, -0.04251416400074959, 0.025809630751609802, -0.04019174352288246, 0.04386455565690994, -0.0520915649831295, 0.035698577761650085, -0.015279816463589668, -0.041695479303598404, -0.04115791991353035, 0.06579939275979996, -0.05098295584321022, 0.009407848119735718, 0.05692724511027336, 0.01282865833491087, 0.04150184616446495, -0.024278609082102776, -0.007407425437122583, 0.026031265035271645, -0.04541344568133354, -0.0019992864690721035, 0.00419702148064971, 0.03005721978843212, -0.04311886802315712, -0.00563502823933959, -0.0017109211767092347, -0.054471205919981, 0.04413401708006859, -0.017104173079133034, -0.07247956842184067, 0.006627370603382587, -0.03366632014513016, -0.009053125977516174, 0.0015117322327569127, 0.03363944590091705, -0.0007190135656856, 0.054602719843387604, -0.05435715615749359, 0.01064987387508154, -0.017956404015421867, -0.011656331829726696, 0.0010364740155637264, -0.013167304918169975, 0.00008992076618596911, -0.050204094499349594, 0.05181439220905304, -0.021127821877598763, 0.011310486122965813, -0.0031454400159418583, -0.020127292722463608, 0.0041631609201431274, 0.003496503457427025, -0.042198438197374344, -0.006439373828470707, 0.007488559000194073, -0.007348194252699614, 0.020100407302379608, 0.047797251492738724, -0.04812869802117348, -0.07312893867492676, -0.013115044683218002, -0.013485929928719997, 0.013064895756542683, 0.03606226667761803, -0.004479119088500738, 0.020749399438500404, -0.00433651078492403, 0.04720195010304451, -0.00008630970842204988, 0.009640319272875786, -0.026916302740573883, -0.05557001382112503, -0.02313189022243023, 0.02953479252755642, 0.020878296345472336, -0.03468261659145355, -0.037129808217287064, 0.0027564247138798237, -0.0734984278678894, 0.022134728729724884, 0.001819839933887124, 0.0022369856014847755, -0.017293628305196762, -0.07357524335384369, 0.04082072153687477, -0.01863439567387104, -0.0324588306248188, -0.06973865628242493, 0.041392356157302856, -0.012383515946567059, -0.03524315357208252, 0.01384077500551939, 0.021227464079856873, -0.0034657539799809456, -0.03625786677002907, -0.0820072814822197, -0.0333542600274086, -0.02753061056137085, 0.06950916349887848, 0.02804386243224144, -0.03029649890959263, 0.0011942819692194462, -0.07460521906614304, -0.038030266761779785, -0.014982747845351696, 0.05883262678980827, -0.016925843432545662, 0.04119591414928436, 0.003785585518926382, -0.05449547991156578, -0.016110165044665337, 0.014988692477345467, -0.051297590136528015, 0.028418172150850296, 0.02506190724670887, 0.04168808460235596, 0.04549602419137955, 0.01824852079153061, 0.06869453936815262, -0.018599798902869225, 0.0007863484788686037, -0.0297226719558239, -0.0168481282889843, -0.017960796132683754, -0.04211534187197685, -0.002814259845763445, -0.05954862758517265, -0.02757374756038189, -0.011085075326263905, -0.01855730637907982, -0.045604459941387177, -0.04694062098860741, -0.043710410594940186, -0.006292462814599276, 0.031467217952013016, -0.02364368736743927, 0.038008008152246475, -0.003044544253498316, -0.029587427154183388, 0.0021022362634539604, -0.05274246633052826, -0.044457320123910904, 0.01112489216029644, 0.03439287468791008, -0.049705252051353455, 0.017815541476011276, -0.06377647072076797, 0.06839731335639954, -0.02818017266690731, -0.02689974755048752, -0.006635608617216349, 0.044391632080078125, -0.01604311726987362, 0.01675126701593399, -0.023445000872015953, -0.002581446198746562, -0.026131995022296906, -0.07829565554857254, -0.015928560867905617, -0.052517425268888474, 0.04215197265148163, -0.01351446658372879, 0.02809254080057144, -0.00499613955616951, 0.07327030599117279, 0.02788521908223629, 0.012310252524912357, 0.006283221300691366, -0.01519736833870411, 0.02125614695250988, 0.0686139166355133, -0.00226775580085814, 0.015400957316160202, -0.033779531717300415, 0.0248124822974205, -0.008833500556647778, 0.042673259973526, 0.03740308806300163, -0.013931716792285442, -0.000921368773560971, -0.05731583759188652, -0.013688630424439907, 0.044109147042036057, 0.02009541168808937, -0.025601012632250786, 0.01266581378877163, -0.04872256889939308, -0.01669716089963913, -0.04257889837026596 ]
We propose terminology to classify interpretations of quantum mechanics and models that modify or complete quantum mechanics. Our focus is on models which have previously been referred to as superdeterministic (strong or weak), retrocausal (with or without signalling, dynamical or non-dynamical), future-input-dependent, atemporal and all-at-once, not always with the same meaning or context. Sometimes these models are assumed to be deterministic, sometimes not, the word deterministic has been given different meanings, and different notions of causality have been used when classifying them. This has created much confusion in the literature, and we hope that the terms proposed here will help to clarify the nomenclature. The general model framework that we will propose may also be useful to classify other interpretations and modifications of quantum mechanics. This document grew out of the discussions at the 2022 Bonn Workshop on Superdeterminism and Retrocausality.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12293v2
[ -0.03131668642163277, -0.030420517548918724, 0.027686068788170815, 0.02499246969819069, 0.018577350303530693, -0.022826142609119415, -0.021756038069725037, 0.021423788741230965, -0.01093252282589674, -0.008587712422013283, -0.048229288309812546, -0.016017846763134003, -0.0641600489616394, -0.02573164738714695, -0.008867268450558186, -0.0035550373140722513, 0.06106073409318924, 0.06768080592155457, -0.006892780773341656, 0.06278366595506668, -0.03374958038330078, -0.01907496154308319, -0.047074031084775925, 0.06819649040699005, 0.009766911156475544, 0.008204367943108082, 0.007944708690047264, 0.006775397341698408, -0.01384037546813488, -0.018286393955349922, 0.03187442943453789, -0.06155873090028763, 0.0056207855232059956, -0.025520486757159233, -0.040680672973394394, -0.02316203899681568, 0.011010897345840931, 0.005642200354486704, 0.06608904153108597, -0.025364823639392853, 0.0172896645963192, -0.049443311989307404, -0.035580720752477646, 0.016527656465768814, -0.051226064562797546, -0.04438095912337303, -0.05249348282814026, -0.009010440669953823, -0.07185537368059158, -0.07146813720464706, 0.035344064235687256, 0.05999127775430679, 0.026747314259409904, 0.03843171149492264, -0.03867607191205025, 0.03109082393348217, -0.004056226462125778, 0.0053854999132454395, -0.07543862611055374, -0.028032008558511734, 0.03398282825946808, -0.01963009685277939, 0.018261488527059555, 0.005253098905086517, 0.0033537347335368395, 0.021093247458338737, -0.016346771270036697, -0.0373496375977993, -0.031037908047437668, -0.06283677369356155, 0.025014067068696022, -0.05638067424297333, 0.02618604712188244, -0.001258207717910409, -0.050988491624593735, -0.019309183582663536, -0.03843218833208084, -0.016380436718463898, 0.01536546554416418, 0.04766397178173065, -0.019578823819756508, 0.002854847116395831, -0.0023186265025287867, -0.019994143396615982, 0.01701381802558899, -0.01966523751616478, -0.013606817461550236, 0.02318294160068035, 0.0026677644345909357, -0.042754482477903366, 0.044485971331596375, -0.014745074324309826, -0.0800914615392685, -0.0020577730610966682, 0.024151641875505447, -0.028179114684462547, 0.05866273120045662, 0.06929755955934525, -0.010940572246909142, -0.01664380542933941, -0.011392095126211643, 0.008753341622650623, -0.017239637672901154, 0.012175347656011581, 0.04600651562213898, -0.03731685131788254, 0.0037529594264924526, -0.010042237117886543, -0.03233575448393822, 0.00301915779709816, 0.012283232063055038, 0.004552872851490974, 0.014358156360685825, -0.06820041686296463, -0.03673262894153595, -0.019575340673327446, 0.003914470784366131, 0.014156012795865536, -0.014617523178458214, 0.001225277199409902, -0.04915778711438179, 0.029125262051820755, -0.02153107151389122, 0.019300119951367378, -0.020452463999390602, -0.03974950686097145, 0.06306581944227219, 0.01983490213751793, -0.022613607347011566, -0.0027006869204342365, -0.07195550203323364, -0.00789650622755289, -0.025587409734725952, -0.021714171394705772, 0.05382430925965309, -0.01373192947357893, 0.0442962609231472, -0.06061884015798569, 0.05352650210261345, 0.0004050160350743681, -0.05532872676849365, -0.08019080013036728, 0.030944202095270157, -0.03401147946715355, 0.026864003390073776, 0.032116252928972244, -0.06778109073638916, 0.025115182623267174, -0.008449234068393707, 0.044575903564691544, 0.030096767470240593, 0.00404999777674675, 0.005746274720877409, 0.019788013771176338, 0.014956122264266014, -0.02915891632437706, 0.023011740297079086, 0.013838357292115688, -0.044641658663749695, -0.0016295553650707006, 0.02760591171681881, -0.04169834032654762, -0.010546342469751835, -0.0249825157225132, 0.027581119909882545, 0.01745661161839962, 0.049684666097164154, -0.04687071591615677, -0.02050706371665001, 0.0004999431548640132, -0.01792975328862667, 0.0062333825044333935, 0.023201890289783478, -0.012848539277911186, -0.03208627924323082, -0.004118205513805151, -0.06536175310611725, -0.04138724505901337, -0.0249567162245512, 0.019954070448875427, 0.0005495563964359462, -0.014330333098769188, -0.05916810780763626, 0.02399701252579689, -0.0212042685598135, -0.005168344359844923, -0.06587553024291992, 0.04613297060132027, 0.006648171693086624, -0.043745290488004684, -0.03909739851951599, -0.015368683263659477, 0.019688457250595093, -0.03320842608809471, -0.058291103690862656, -0.055738501250743866, 0.023731175810098648, -0.014935878105461597, -0.031133240088820457, 0.027144422754645348, -0.07512093335390091, -0.03756032511591911, -0.06606745719909668, -0.011144507676362991, -0.023467615246772766, -0.012885195203125477, -0.014543184079229832, 0.053874727338552475, -0.051468051970005035, -0.05926590412855148, 0.03216404840350151, 0.04842599481344223, 0.034016240388154984, 0.023240020498633385, -0.005988928023725748, 0.009300154633820057, -0.09875694662332535, 0.03693539276719093, -0.008625699207186699, -0.0028092171996831894, 0.04194528982043266, 0.016061903908848763, -0.03358927741646767, -0.01392078585922718, 0.001950285048224032, 0.026726625859737396, 0.01935061439871788, 0.03825931251049042, -0.045956797897815704, -0.03888804838061333, -0.04257691651582718, -0.057230398058891296, -0.03948720544576645, -0.05645401403307915, -0.02464606612920761, -0.048288628458976746, -0.013932538218796253, 0.016942758113145828, -0.026582852005958557, -0.062300510704517365, -0.050214171409606934, -0.038900524377822876, 0.03835736960172653, -0.04838893562555313, -0.026791587471961975, -0.04630470648407936, -0.0015668843407183886, 0.032891321927309036, 0.009094980545341969, -0.01027609035372734, 0.0305795818567276, -0.07178480923175812, 0.015448645688593388, -0.032306160777807236, 0.01674569770693779, 0.04443972557783127, -0.07113062590360641, -0.009508088231086731, 0.010992441326379776, 0.00041170173790305853, 0.03683266416192055, 0.05392665043473244, -0.035956624895334244, 0.014989471063017845, 0.06556293368339539, 0.020754631608724594, -0.043999072164297104, -0.03552168980240822, 0.02936406061053276, -0.019110318273305893, 0.04577665776014328, 0.026113934814929962, 0.06852912157773972, -0.007929124869406223, -0.016942037269473076, -0.012398953549563885, 0.01701086200773716, -0.04284597560763359, 0.025810914114117622, 0.022439809516072273, 0.0056547075510025024, -0.0007825993234291673, -0.03703123703598976, -0.07491466403007507, -0.052723731845617294, -0.026778988540172577, -0.015789132565259933, -0.024180160835385323, -0.047991301864385605, -0.04655773565173149, -0.074960857629776, -0.02726736105978489, -0.020745815709233284, -0.05277149751782417, -0.03676510602235794, -0.06317975372076035, -0.03247886151075363, 0.003913644701242447, 0.038275912404060364, -0.0316520556807518, -0.03947233036160469, 0.009028327651321888, 0.000701353361364454, 0.04140510782599449, -0.021455325186252594, -0.07787159830331802, -0.05356878414750099, -0.009711525402963161, -0.026470668613910675, 0.012571906670928001, -0.024827921763062477, 0.0189830269664526, -0.00004436922972672619, 0.040156103670597076, 0.016287459060549736, -0.024764839559793472, 0.0043901377357542515, -0.008670828305184841, 0.008627079427242279, -0.04067731276154518, -0.014177386648952961, 0.027558693662285805, 0.014254789799451828, -0.01555793359875679, -0.056482426822185516, -0.013662721961736679, 0.07281641662120819, -0.0018685945542529225, -0.05686566233634949, -0.04249192401766777, -0.022265691310167313, -0.026265336200594902, 0.03822343796491623, -0.03928179293870926, 0.04975789412856102, 0.04117915779352188, -0.04043135419487953, -0.022111156955361366, -0.005466587375849485, -0.018372101709246635, -0.012890978716313839, 0.05822022631764412, -0.059371739625930786, -0.029876014217734337, 0.010530504398047924, -0.07493149489164352, -0.002610262716189027, 0.021301941946148872, 0.04100291058421135, -0.01483360305428505, -0.0030351884197443724, 0.03582962974905968, -0.021282460540533066, 0.04397820681333542, -0.026344116777181625, 0.03762451931834221, 0.04459349811077118, 0.019519617781043053, -0.013531203381717205, -0.039661962538957596, -0.029714200645685196, -0.06930658221244812, -0.05943824723362923, 0.026492489501833916, 0.060115963220596313, -0.01763518713414669, 0.015735086053609848, -0.0572790801525116, -0.005762710236012936, -0.04934079572558403, 0.058450717478990555, 0.010536438785493374, -0.03468327969312668, 0.0040550921112298965, -0.035144731402397156, -0.019832363352179527, 0.017184337601065636, 0.000017672457033768296, -0.03128822520375252, -0.03497404232621193, -0.0160213615745306, -0.04009605944156647, 0.06852167844772339, 0.030968360602855682, -0.0014165875036269426, 0.015084195882081985, 0.026115598157048225, -0.012115655466914177, 0.03431333228945732, -0.03052152320742607, 0.04396433383226395, -0.0015018171397969127, -0.014522426761686802, 0.016149139031767845, -0.030359936878085136, -0.058555297553539276, -0.0246454905718565, 0.017241818830370903, 0.006213187240064144, 0.00011955806985497475, 0.010609175078570843, -0.02292398363351822, -0.005924396216869354, -0.08571899682283401, 0.02263401448726654, -0.05586349219083786, 0.05097581073641777, -0.009857752360403538, -0.06402795761823654, 0.07818839699029922, -0.019107244908809662, -0.012391253374516964, -0.010914427228271961, -0.04941476881504059, -0.00783165916800499, -0.022017983719706535, -0.014833745546638966, -0.06808378547430038, 0.040956102311611176, -0.05889067426323891, 0.013817163184285164, -0.028455916792154312, 0.034815456718206406, -0.02499140240252018, 0.021020473912358284, 0.016864154487848282, 0.0244719460606575, 0.05353453382849693, 0.0620192252099514, -0.004213942214846611, -0.03995668515563011, 0.013399113900959492, 0.01731065846979618, 0.026714852079749107, -0.033103521913290024, 0.012659944593906403, 0.03192104026675224, -0.013127725571393967, -0.04218168184161186, -0.038852717727422714, -0.0236032847315073, 0.040313053876161575, -0.02467510849237442, -0.06204843148589134, -0.03140269219875336, 0.06921213120222092, 0.016934765502810478, -0.07212322950363159, 0.011592521332204342, -0.02244379371404648, -0.04661326855421066, -0.0039613558910787106, 0.007879975251853466, 0.02259494923055172, -0.04822869598865509, 0.03580135852098465, -0.0023678005672991276, 0.05047287791967392, 0.007972785271704197, 0.027589667588472366, 0.059303391724824905, 0.0037036261055618525, -0.008236122317612171, 0.0207248292863369, -0.01986854150891304, -0.0501379519701004, 0.007877828553318977, 0.007070163264870644, -0.0020058604422956705, 0.0494675412774086, 0.006361663341522217, 0.05975218489766121, -0.08230896294116974, 0.02745983749628067, 0.04771094024181366, 0.0006901799933984876, 0.01657978445291519, 0.02814898081123829, -0.019922757521271706, -0.021708186715841293, -0.05715342238545418, 0.0009349308093078434, 0.052389536052942276, 0.011632001958787441, 0.035619787871837616, 0.015419541858136654, -0.03282898664474487, 0.004047879949212074, 0.0424790196120739, -0.011071017943322659, -0.0371212437748909, -0.006249133963137865, 0.03343605995178223, -0.01419122889637947, -0.011063638143241405, -0.017113618552684784, 0.04368949681520462, -0.03374738246202469, -0.027447182685136795, -0.006092768162488937, 0.0023039556108415127, -0.016181692481040955, 0.023632844910025597, -0.018272433429956436, -0.0082514313980937, 0.045813366770744324, -0.0024845090229064226, 0.0017888350412249565, 0.025463810190558434, -0.01575302705168724, 0.035277269780635834, -0.04705517739057541, 0.0009262539679184556, -0.06367459893226624, -0.004329835530370474, -0.05936093255877495, 0.026649128645658493, 0.049068864434957504, 0.04518642649054527, 0.047184769064188004, 0.04891672357916832, 0.007816076278686523, -0.0028787043411284685, 0.028001710772514343, 0.01216116826981306, 0.028929056599736214, -0.017288731411099434, -0.0051511116325855255, -0.019526256248354912, 0.03194578364491463, 0.04719901084899902, 0.04162365943193436, 0.010986519046127796, -0.018430165946483612, -0.018791798502206802, -0.002823997288942337, -0.006753541994839907, -0.017551802098751068, -0.05157707631587982, -0.01555223111063242, 0.04599102586507797, -0.0011420714436098933, 0.03407861292362213, 0.04142782837152481, 0.010189250111579895, 0.039371557533741, 0.019219625741243362, -0.004589241463690996, -0.055756013840436935, 0.006574044935405254, 0.07932347804307938, -0.05053142458200455, 0.02490946091711521, -0.05616851896047592, -0.02229439839720726, -0.03757435828447342, -0.019606025889515877, 0.013956878334283829, 0.01146866288036108, -0.034925427287817, -0.04905920848250389, 0.046495471149683, 0.03582490608096123, -0.07436049729585648, -0.029193352907896042, -0.0070601291954517365, -0.062162622809410095, -0.01163720153272152, -0.004655920900404453, 0.03678581118583679, -0.013134059496223927, 0.056673601269721985, 0.019260605797171593, -0.031578995287418365, -0.05888484790921211, 0.08108652383089066, 0.08919541537761688, -0.04307029768824577, -0.04324796050786972, -0.002938319696113467, -0.012023160234093666, 0.009347915649414062, -0.02815823070704937, -0.019263528287410736, 0.047473546117544174, -0.00950863491743803, -0.02290380373597145, 0.00023964412685018033, -0.05650710314512253, 0.05051640421152115, -0.05079588666558266, -0.00983482040464878, -0.04055292159318924, -0.03161769360303879, 0.06312551349401474, -0.029198186472058296, -0.0275378730148077, 0.026310119777917862, 0.00747240474447608, -0.026203306391835213, -0.04758273437619209, -0.05921146646142006, -0.032346490770578384, -0.031762976199388504, -0.0016582777025178075, -0.059885334223508835, 0.009461192414164543, 0.007776774000376463, -0.07495997846126556, -0.016270658001303673, -0.04331213980913162, 0.0420246422290802, 0.00814446248114109, 0.042580366134643555, 0.009142866358160973, 0.06668048352003098, -0.003941166214644909, 0.001137342071160674, 0.03083627112209797, -0.029666125774383545, -0.001970465062186122, 0.028859615325927734, 0.008309582248330116, 0.015037070959806442, 0.0332312248647213, -0.020940938964486122, 0.017657600343227386, -0.040171410888433456, -0.08202407509088516, 0.044971831142902374, -0.0053636860102415085, -0.034870974719524384, -0.026955684646964073, 0.009179499931633472, -0.01111800130456686, -0.04527018219232559, 0.044582150876522064, -0.038905154913663864, -0.03814738988876343, 0.028714332729578018, -0.010919138789176941, 0.03279554843902588, -0.02420058101415634, -0.025194497779011726, 0.01642467826604843, 0.017889363691210747, 0.051305245608091354, 0.046154242008924484, 0.019559387117624283, -0.0024612215347588062, -0.03818650543689728, 0.019384732469916344, 0.009110102429986, -0.004476988688111305, -0.03743322193622589, -0.022480430081486702, -0.021762343123555183, -0.07192214578390121, 0.029111171141266823, 0.00966689083725214, -0.03909742459654808, -0.009315156377851963, -0.07337623834609985, 0.03712834045290947, 0.04149513691663742, -0.0488794669508934, -0.07170329988002777, 0.0551728717982769, 0.008534504100680351, -0.0017756489105522633, 0.011919266544282436, -0.02348329685628414, -0.032900866121053696, 0.018399441614747047, -0.08860480040311813, -0.034862078726291656, -0.014307266101241112, 0.029291462153196335, 0.020574718713760376, 0.005715533159673214, 0.040709275752305984, -0.052649009972810745, 0.04010530933737755, 0.00915620755404234, -0.024494493380188942, 0.05495062470436096, -0.030249979346990585, 0.0504060797393322, -0.039825811982154846, -0.019402161240577698, 0.04324136674404144, 0.04412153735756874, -0.027992984279990196, -0.013701404444873333, 0.0425562709569931, 0.006326879374682903, 0.0560128390789032, 0.017762525007128716, -0.02517627365887165, 0.03399495407938957, -0.03319375216960907, 0.028059016913175583, -0.04838449880480766, -0.0805114135146141, 0.03310530260205269, -0.014269651845097542, 0.029242681339383125, 0.03973374515771866, 0.009659092873334885, -0.045128241181373596, -0.04553527012467384, -0.026668846607208252, 0.05050171911716461, -0.03303021937608719, -0.03447241708636284, 0.06905471533536911, -0.015382385812699795, -0.004952849820256233, 0.036585938185453415, -0.007369402330368757, -0.03907519578933716, 0.05395573005080223, 0.02081499621272087, -0.07255295664072037, 0.004708528518676758, -0.0680709034204483, 0.041169051080942154, -0.029546178877353668, 0.02650279365479946, 0.008217710070312023, 0.05771840736269951, -0.04652125760912895, -0.06280969083309174, -0.03811819106340408, 0.0035898752976208925, -0.053551509976387024, -0.05733449384570122, -0.021277043968439102, -0.03706210479140282, 0.025933662429451942, 0.00011459999223006889, 0.04690539091825485, 0.04144454747438431, 0.06646750867366791, 0.029808059334754944, 0.004032854922115803, 0.02569137141108513, -0.004632927011698484, -0.05798828601837158, 0.023620812222361565, 0.03394434228539467, 0.011759735643863678, -0.01865246891975403, 0.005756544414907694, -0.013847756199538708, -0.03425844386219978, 0.0432637557387352, -0.027166316285729408, -0.03385983780026436, -0.038882166147232056, -0.03279951959848404, 0.01852520741522312, -0.002863718196749687, -0.05593714490532875, 0.006844921503216028, 0.020782893523573875, -0.05337728187441826, -0.037016041576862335 ]
Star-forming galaxies are believed to replenish their atomic gas reservoir, which is consumed in star-formation, through accretion of gas from their circumgalactic mediums (CGMs). However, there are few observational constraints today on the gas accretion rate in external galaxies. Here, we use our recent measurement of the scaling relation between the atomic hydrogen (HI) mass $M_{HI}$ and the stellar mass $M_*$ in star-forming galaxies at $z \approx 0.35$, with the relations between the star-formation rate (SFR) and $M_*$, and the molecular gas mass $M_{Mol}$ and $M_*$, and the assumption that star-forming galaxies evolve along the main sequence, to determine the evolution of the neutral gas reservoir and the average net gas accretion rate onto the disks of star-forming galaxies over the past 4 Gyr. For galaxies with $M_* \gtrsim 10^9 M_{\odot}$ today, we find that both $M_*$ and $M_{HI}$ in the disk have increased, while $M_{Mol}$ has decreased, since $z \sim 0.35$. The average gas accretion rate onto the disk over the past 4 Gyr is similar to the average SFR over this period, implying that main-sequence galaxies have maintained a stable HI reservoir, despite the consumption of gas in star-formation. We obtain an average net gas accretion rate (over the past 4 Gyr) of $\approx 6 M_{\odot} yr^{-1}$ for galaxies with the stellar mass of the Milky Way. At low redshifts, $z \lesssim 0.4$, the reason for the decline in the cosmic SFR density thus appears to be the inefficiency in the conversion of atomic gas to molecular gas, rather than insufficient gas accretion from the CGM.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05937v2
[ -0.04980652034282684, -0.055339016020298004, 0.005413858685642481, -0.011006081476807594, -0.03852611035108566, -0.003715125611051917, -0.021570442244410515, 0.039887264370918274, -0.06313985586166382, -0.00889510102570057, 0.027318919077515602, -0.02443099580705166, 0.0016686214366927743, -0.05669255182147026, -0.041825465857982635, 0.04463730379939079, 0.05848119780421257, 0.018979741260409355, -0.00036788807483389974, 0.060315102338790894, 0.03934231027960777, -0.025397559627890587, -0.037763096392154694, -0.0017365871462970972, 0.025688692927360535, -0.01589328981935978, -0.014730559661984444, 0.005525289569050074, -0.021136794239282608, -0.015216604806482792, 0.06061312183737755, -0.05442449823021889, -0.008810969069600105, -0.04771237075328827, 0.01828017644584179, 0.045586105436086655, -0.0321711003780365, 0.05415954440832138, -0.04383563995361328, -0.05150322988629341, -0.04125722125172615, -0.05961732566356659, -0.046799514442682266, -0.06630125641822815, -0.03322933241724968, -0.04293586686253548, -0.021596956998109818, -0.03244590014219284, -0.04888381063938141, -0.06297681480646133, 0.04845941439270973, 0.01590726152062416, 0.004611947573721409, 0.05892103165388107, 0.004142190329730511, -0.035226404666900635, -0.0006913180113770068, -0.03379058092832565, -0.033814191818237305, -0.03958293795585632, -0.035766780376434326, -0.000636681797914207, -0.0019893310964107513, -0.041877977550029755, -0.04898333176970482, 0.026367316022515297, -0.05782073736190796, -0.03926809877157211, -0.030574943870306015, -0.05494596064090729, 0.013316762633621693, -0.061795398592948914, 0.016786513850092888, -0.015622524544596672, -0.04868781194090843, 0.033235255628824234, -0.03750833868980408, -0.018306953832507133, -0.02621208317577839, 0.011665452271699905, 0.00971557479351759, 0.04535685479640961, -0.02115846797823906, 0.0069884564727544785, -0.009180314838886261, -0.027054252102971077, 0.013476191088557243, -0.06507761031389236, -0.029620269313454628, -0.02957460843026638, 0.028799012303352356, -0.040853697806596756, -0.03532639145851135, -0.003210587427020073, 0.07475374639034271, -0.038241226226091385, 0.05136393755674362, 0.04670938476920128, 0.01826798915863037, -0.04849373176693916, 0.010433769784867764, -0.06826620548963547, -0.053328320384025574, 0.022521784529089928, 0.019558323547244072, -0.0072079431265592575, 0.005746009293943644, 0.017208566889166832, -0.03372858837246895, 0.04276173561811447, 0.010673056356608868, -0.027931904420256615, 0.012266038917005062, -0.04704815149307251, -0.07572336494922638, -0.06103470176458359, 0.024709545075893402, -0.014626863412559032, 0.04587678238749504, 0.028989963233470917, -0.061174508184194565, 0.05669047310948372, 0.049985382705926895, -0.008878475986421108, -0.001848456566222012, -0.030272189527750015, 0.03580565005540848, -0.03254351764917374, 0.01445940975099802, -0.0006244566757231951, -0.06315936893224716, 0.015558904968202114, 0.044374916702508926, -0.0390351377427578, -0.011636766605079174, 0.022751109674572945, 0.0179019495844841, 0.0006097700097598135, -0.028432108461856842, 0.036423344165086746, 0.013768430799245834, -0.040028806775808334, 0.043994031846523285, 0.042897678911685944, 0.00024459551787003875, 0.028995037078857422, -0.04640231281518936, -0.03759338706731796, 0.05750870332121849, 0.041618943214416504, 0.006058401428163052, 0.05870617926120758, 0.017281023785471916, -0.0035690697841346264, -0.01067428570240736, 0.031156271696090698, 0.03914228454232216, 0.047957852482795715, -0.054417263716459274, 0.03522874414920807, -0.023573365062475204, -0.02419523149728775, 0.0029837419278919697, 0.04137740656733513, 0.013726088218390942, 0.03599586710333824, -0.02638058550655842, -0.029307888820767403, 0.03390105068683624, 0.03803307190537453, -0.010906095616519451, -0.048387158662080765, -0.006461293902248144, -0.03631196171045303, -0.03628735616803169, -0.040158238261938095, 0.01641756296157837, -0.05558570474386215, -0.028027813881635666, -0.013821704313158989, 0.0017645959742367268, 0.019529353827238083, -0.05093071237206459, -0.04344246909022331, -0.04314952716231346, -0.028863538056612015, -0.06961683183908463, -0.008021365851163864, 0.02020692080259323, 0.01604856550693512, -0.014842300675809383, -0.06033316254615784, -0.01445033960044384, -0.022435015067458153, 0.002369995228946209, 0.013977996073663235, 0.032389432191848755, -0.061104852706193924, -0.01513737440109253, 0.02166621945798397, -0.06430666893720627, -0.032210636883974075, -0.004136116709560156, 0.0025840664748102427, 0.01193135604262352, -0.07556663453578949, -0.0037431956734508276, 0.014775997959077358, 0.0013591153547167778, -0.02979036048054695, -0.0018498668214306235, 0.0035069582518190145, -0.003961054142564535, -0.04143468663096428, 0.013174827210605145, 0.017760924994945526, -0.08499941974878311, 0.06487298011779785, -0.0012047308264300227, 0.010365192778408527, 0.0333985835313797, -0.006336970720440149, 0.001899607595987618, 0.0029073734767735004, -0.019741903990507126, 0.01807226985692978, 0.041811585426330566, -0.049729932099580765, -0.026960287243127823, 0.009008415974676609, -0.009797743521630764, -0.057986460626125336, -0.07177580893039703, -0.02709026075899601, 0.02404438890516758, -0.004516123328357935, -0.04765205457806587, 0.06178188696503639, -0.03675604239106178, 0.009970407001674175, -0.030091125518083572, 0.032614827156066895, 0.0042374576441943645, 0.005679222755134106, -0.06789621710777283, -0.008691309951245785, -0.0590151883661747, -0.0009293098701164126, -0.0531441904604435, 0.006715746596455574, -0.00945150014013052, -0.023415708914399147, -0.04021010175347328, 0.031442973762750626, 0.043723899871110916, 0.006819736212491989, -0.05720297619700432, -0.00881507433950901, -0.023952262476086617, 0.01957600936293602, -0.06687282025814056, 0.01968463510274887, -0.02696039341390133, -0.0157536081969738, -0.041336819529533386, 0.0010223659919574857, -0.0750073567032814, -0.020147627219557762, -0.027480076998472214, 0.020828653126955032, 0.03449637070298195, -0.007298389449715614, 0.0438082329928875, 0.02196258306503296, -0.015725411474704742, 0.02696833573281765, -0.03226926177740097, -0.007185751106590033, -0.0036323550157248974, -0.04150551185011864, 0.05191577970981598, 0.04027730971574783, 0.044571563601493835, -0.06874574720859528, -0.054897159337997437, -0.03296756371855736, -0.04251525178551674, -0.005561704281717539, -0.05057244747877121, 0.02670317515730858, -0.051206182688474655, 0.012294495478272438, -0.014741463586688042, -0.03599134460091591, 0.0011893451446667314, 0.0017338960897177458, -0.03085194155573845, -0.05277635529637337, -0.014140099287033081, -0.06555366516113281, -0.025539245456457138, 0.02474365569651127, 0.02605699747800827, 0.000663045619148761, -0.004044217057526112, 0.005424757953733206, -0.046082835644483566, -0.00150867342017591, 0.008000565692782402, 0.017943134531378746, -0.04982924461364746, 0.02300959639251232, -0.0622129924595356, -0.04383285716176033, -0.03546583652496338, 0.06586790084838867, 0.018755784258246422, -0.05269072949886322, -0.03007442317903042, -0.016163552179932594, -0.05371437594294548, -0.04364344850182533, 0.012890844605863094, 0.007704540621489286, -0.06391013413667679, -0.06950581073760986, 0.008093876764178276, 0.062369223684072495, 0.028396764770150185, -0.04678453505039215, -0.025997672230005264, -0.04608732834458351, -0.04643142968416214, 0.004547061864286661, 0.03517996147274971, 0.008540979586541653, -0.01736976020038128, -0.042323268949985504, -0.04158921167254448, 0.015075577422976494, -0.027444569393992424, 0.02259048819541931, 0.009716593660414219, -0.015801360830664635, -0.019756846129894257, -0.034019194543361664, 0.028633685782551765, 0.030614180490374565, 0.03693262115120888, -0.010073424316942692, 0.05122746154665947, 0.021387586370110512, -0.017012622207403183, 0.030118951573967934, -0.008979112841188908, 0.061990875750780106, -0.008639870211482048, 0.05032419413328171, 0.013586808927357197, -0.012630482204258442, -0.00012920988956466317, -0.046155307441949844, -0.03172195330262184, 0.05762184411287308, -0.02575273998081684, 0.03654921427369118, 0.03444083407521248, -0.01900828257203102, -0.010536781512200832, -0.03293808922171593, 0.017397455871105194, -0.054493051022291183, -0.06391636282205582, -0.008529947139322758, -0.024731649085879326, -0.009421623311936855, 0.009806036949157715, -0.0031229164451360703, -0.025114985182881355, -0.0635678842663765, 0.019202791154384613, -0.048047326505184174, -0.021703248843550682, 0.06005331501364708, 0.02940572053194046, 0.021841872483491898, 0.022112715989351273, 0.02033580094575882, 0.0355985127389431, -0.0566539503633976, -0.06998155266046524, -0.07232493907213211, -0.054249316453933716, -0.023359674960374832, 0.05725414305925369, 0.0112211424857378, 0.020712262019515038, 0.01149276178330183, -0.03711669147014618, -0.04410304129123688, 0.05688527226448059, -0.027974754571914673, -0.05431533604860306, -0.0715911015868187, -0.04073917865753174, -0.05590616166591644, 0.0034910233225673437, 0.011742380447685719, -0.0034838824067264795, 0.057117827236652374, -0.01668304018676281, 0.015113761648535728, -0.06267013400793076, 0.008538483642041683, -0.015330495312809944, 0.0031914052087813616, 0.03332928940653801, -0.027263449504971504, 0.049935441464185715, -0.0504453107714653, -0.021753467619419098, -0.022738676518201828, -0.014621413312852383, -0.07150731235742569, -0.022504903376102448, -0.020274311304092407, -0.018207019194960594, 0.00846841000020504, -0.005466982256621122, 0.006377199664711952, -0.018939221277832985, -0.033371519297361374, -0.020702345296740532, -0.04281953349709511, 0.048932358622550964, -0.05697634443640709, 0.061991721391677856, -0.003416607854887843, -0.06558436155319214, -0.037481650710105896, 0.007073965389281511, 0.05336324870586395, 0.004433456342667341, -0.0014308277750387788, -0.01242806389927864, 0.01726379059255123, -0.050641946494579315, -0.040758442133665085, -0.050038695335388184, -0.033907946199178696, -0.07581377029418945, 0.02786491997539997, -0.02733498066663742, -0.03251275047659874, 0.00736703397706151, 0.02319544553756714, 0.032833125442266464, 0.032124362885951996, -0.041861601173877716, 0.030658133327960968, -0.014704544097185135, 0.04920516535639763, -0.0429842546582222, -0.008933995850384235, -0.05190953239798546, 0.004646207205951214, 0.0009523706394247711, -0.06186383590102196, -0.0217683594673872, 0.05126086249947548, -0.035974983125925064, 0.028359221294522285, -0.0777931809425354, 0.053893618285655975, 0.0527435801923275, -0.03153024613857269, 0.023131702095270157, 0.013901733793318272, 0.009593049995601177, 0.03432878851890564, 0.009793621487915516, 0.040642328560352325, -0.02571377344429493, 0.016671540215611458, -0.018392397090792656, 0.01614258624613285, -0.05199410393834114, -0.03707281872630119, 0.002974371425807476, -0.010776893235743046, -0.053131166845560074, 0.019913796335458755, -0.006302414927631617, -0.052798476070165634, -0.032406311482191086, 0.04957957565784454, 0.04665550962090492, -0.01728336699306965, -0.06740238517522812, -0.0033370666205883026, -0.0024195462465286255, -0.000619271828327328, 0.05760089308023453, -0.040548089891672134, 0.00996755063533783, 0.029354412108659744, -0.009330128319561481, 0.002611034084111452, 0.05784838646650314, 0.0428752675652504, 0.037189047783613205, -0.06226550042629242, -0.025111094117164612, -0.03280739486217499, -0.024395134299993515, -0.06198088079690933, 0.042070355266332626, 0.007363259792327881, 0.007142330519855022, -0.002728752326220274, 0.020947299897670746, 0.011933636851608753, -0.0377279557287693, -0.061115872114896774, -0.03063824586570263, -0.004435590002685785, -0.05155998468399048, -0.022374136373400688, -0.04665488004684448, -0.02462720312178135, 0.018584929406642914, -0.029009707272052765, -0.02231517992913723, 0.0019469419494271278, -0.053031761199235916, -0.01021928247064352, -0.00456603616476059, -0.003201885148882866, 0.019665159285068512, 0.00652858754619956, 0.062478553503751755, -0.04398703947663307, 0.05561736598610878, 0.01783243753015995, 0.0002842314715962857, 0.019884075969457626, -0.027865007519721985, -0.026488786563277245, -0.06774984300136566, -0.016439666971564293, 0.06922487914562225, -0.06412355601787567, 0.012810828164219856, -0.06699110567569733, -0.012074602767825127, 0.002598727121949196, -0.044214878231287, 0.005151018034666777, 0.009657169692218304, -0.02311345748603344, -0.052435990422964096, 0.04531940817832947, 0.025033961981534958, -0.05410308763384819, -0.0043258098885416985, -0.03999602794647217, -0.06326315551996231, -0.007902315817773342, 0.030368879437446594, -0.03070814348757267, -0.051541052758693695, -0.008899482898414135, -0.060790494084358215, -0.012400900013744831, -0.03541218116879463, 0.05081779882311821, 0.027661597356200218, -0.06928428262472153, 0.05182196572422981, 0.040463440120220184, -0.021563809365034103, -0.04358922317624092, -0.005457448773086071, 0.011862150393426418, -0.006048098206520081, 0.05234146863222122, 0.006390467286109924, -0.020542751997709274, -0.026308439671993256, 0.018000314012169838, -0.053367406129837036, 0.005128054413944483, 0.021004054695367813, 0.009497919119894505, -0.0023378748446702957, 0.02097727358341217, -0.04057929292321205, -0.024854881688952446, -0.06639216840267181, -0.027081487700343132, 0.032184917479753494, 0.05098423734307289, -0.030317703261971474, 0.05098448321223259, -0.0033255615271627903, -0.03549390658736229, 0.014283845201134682, -0.007694986183196306, -0.0178575050085783, 0.04108486697077751, 0.0016187381697818637, 0.015197510831058025, -0.03566717356443405, -0.008536703884601593, -0.011878406628966331, 0.050854604691267014, -0.05147161707282066, -0.032878484576940536, -0.03906359523534775, -0.051796555519104004, -0.0010063726222142577, 0.00671514542773366, 0.03308006748557091, 0.031428467482328415, 0.07225193828344345, -0.011597729288041592, -0.05033642426133156, -0.06402275711297989, -0.03086785227060318, 0.0108259916305542, 0.0057501643896102905, -0.047428857535123825, -0.026731599122285843, 0.03927931562066078, -0.043920326977968216, 0.040383853018283844, 0.05827666446566582, -0.0014876120258122683, -0.06122411787509918, -0.019082821905612946, 0.008328709751367569, -0.04636497423052788, 0.045217759907245636, 0.006784617435187101, 0.06386767327785492, 0.016458401456475258, 0.006300805136561394, 0.01558663509786129, 0.00755019998177886, -0.05051978677511215, -0.04399164766073227, -0.054437536746263504, 0.03765753656625748, 0.010567937046289444, 0.007398603484034538, -0.06929326057434082, -0.02539990469813347, -0.06205742806196213, 0.016754984855651855, 0.03902255743741989, 0.0008887792937457561, 0.01783330738544464, -0.029779136180877686, 0.029901357367634773, 0.03121999278664589, 0.013793705962598324, -0.07569675892591476, -0.04515847936272621, -0.0248549934476614, 0.006023173686116934, 0.006904419511556625, 0.025658776983618736, -0.020708682015538216, 0.011005052365362644, -0.06650333851575851, -0.027038825675845146, -0.05042769014835358, 0.06402750313282013, 0.01190858706831932, 0.0009452966623939574, -0.07376611977815628, -0.046192433685064316, 0.022928940132260323, 0.05553784966468811, -0.028202258050441742, 0.0003337028610985726, 0.02586197666823864, 0.0005663667689077556, 0.004528454504907131, -0.02246427722275257, 0.006037847604602575, -0.039917826652526855, 0.014069772325456142, 0.012616146355867386, -0.0016087410040199757, -0.03501320257782936, -0.02616192027926445, 0.009241079911589622, 0.012472080066800117, 0.016579369083046913, -0.015798289328813553, -0.048700544983148575, -0.0038427331019192934, -0.02063642255961895, 0.02930016815662384, -0.029850922524929047, -0.03440547361969948, 0.019580364227294922, -0.021871451288461685, 0.003951590042561293, -0.013187349773943424, -0.02233787626028061, -0.014538062736392021, 0.05559023842215538, -0.030487732961773872, 0.03531960770487785, -0.0560540147125721, 0.011479837819933891, -0.04878787323832512, -0.02137301117181778, -0.05917665734887123, 0.0004932073061354458, 0.005028252024203539, -0.05443378537893295, 0.039390623569488525, -0.05860503017902374, 0.026199404150247574, -0.036456398665905, -0.004835419822484255, 0.01088305190205574, 0.026124533265829086, -0.048917144536972046, 0.031161615625023842, -0.04479529336094856, -0.02532465010881424, 0.0532245971262455, -0.07182169705629349, 0.016550645232200623, 0.03803325444459915, 0.01414478849619627, 0.022305142134428024, 0.016995547339320183, -0.023680953308939934, 0.005660240538418293, -0.010875273495912552, -0.03777146339416504, 0.047454461455345154, -0.0015624150400981307, -0.027551550418138504, -0.010889751836657524, 0.035439204424619675, -0.041294392198324203, -0.04090472683310509, 0.061910584568977356, -0.01341385766863823, 0.018933311104774475, -0.05447019264101982, 0.0171357449144125, -0.01639433763921261, -0.027522718533873558, -0.04523983970284462, 0.054202113300561905, 0.0016832079272717237, -0.03643934428691864, 0.0714709460735321, 0.006815844681113958, -0.04503320902585983, -0.04242069646716118 ]
Various spatial-gradient extensions of standard viscoelastic rheologies of the Kelvin-Voigt, Maxwell's, and Jeffreys' types are analyzed in linear one-dimensional situations as far as the propagation of waves and their dispersion and attenuation. These gradient extensions are then presented in the large-strain nonlinear variants where they are sometimes used rather for purely analytical reasons either in the Lagrangian or the Eulerian formulations without realizing this wave-propagation context.The interconnection between these two modeling aspects is thus revealed in particular selected cases.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05089v2
[ -0.010121842846274376, -0.03553527221083641, -0.010939320549368858, -0.02249346859753132, 0.032723963260650635, -0.028963983058929443, -0.05343171954154968, -0.029499385505914688, -0.038080137223005295, 0.0008622473105788231, -0.04567357152700424, -0.06039350852370262, -0.07031970471143723, -0.026796596124768257, -0.0453353188931942, 0.016186391934752464, 0.04965118318796158, 0.020179009065032005, -0.059191491454839706, 0.03885887935757637, -0.030848048627376556, -0.013119840063154697, -0.009704628959298134, 0.04608526825904846, -0.01129124779254198, 0.03201289102435112, 0.02136841043829918, -0.03687247633934021, 0.04975294694304466, -0.005898192524909973, 0.023426467552781105, -0.013034768402576447, 0.0344453789293766, 0.015221800655126572, -0.023322969675064087, -0.012827178463339806, 0.0229251179844141, 0.053677238523960114, 0.060182325541973114, -0.009297053329646587, -0.045933037996292114, -0.036843448877334595, -0.025610515847802162, 0.01863361895084381, -0.07483235746622086, 0.00850929319858551, 0.003066884819418192, -0.012714644894003868, -0.0393233522772789, -0.03137057647109032, 0.011939426884055138, 0.025106415152549744, -0.019598759710788727, 0.06369643658399582, -0.009818974882364273, -0.024957602843642235, -0.02999976836144924, -0.028290199115872383, -0.0322459451854229, -0.033836353570222855, -0.03988010808825493, -0.05642744153738022, 0.05114075541496277, -0.02117440104484558, -0.06271951645612717, -0.0014472964685410261, -0.062460802495479584, -0.0744570791721344, 0.058285463601350784, -0.06660662591457367, -0.019488757476210594, -0.05298629775643349, -0.027288293465971947, 0.03079731948673725, -0.06411418318748474, 0.018834324553608894, -0.015708817169070244, -0.011995925568044186, 0.006113073322921991, 0.014659985899925232, 0.027502158656716347, -0.01594160869717598, -0.00856684148311615, -0.002900113584473729, 0.019810888916254044, -0.013929537497460842, 0.0041780024766922, -0.044659968465566635, -0.0501883327960968, -0.03081374429166317, 0.025341061875224113, -0.022460579872131348, -0.05876919999718666, 0.0011372047010809183, 0.04572969302535057, 0.016077401116490364, 0.07795433700084686, 0.047423962503671646, 0.045967694371938705, -0.023973774164915085, 0.03469877317547798, -0.0657462403178215, -0.045571599155664444, 0.03718410059809685, 0.05036041513085365, -0.026106659322977066, 0.025535529479384422, 0.017051205039024353, -0.0018968052463606, -0.012923678383231163, 0.01074356958270073, 0.0242928359657526, 0.02979077771306038, -0.049952905625104904, -0.035911910235881805, -0.035764675587415695, 0.020566070452332497, -0.007284097373485565, 0.015047256834805012, 0.00854577124118805, -0.02944999746978283, 0.046963050961494446, 0.024720720946788788, -0.005646324250847101, -0.004694847390055656, 0.01389615423977375, 0.0679079219698906, 0.002945883898064494, -0.01714618317782879, -0.0039833178743720055, -0.01565586030483246, -0.051532842218875885, 0.039748601615428925, 0.02575245499610901, -0.003040190087631345, -0.027606038376688957, 0.05687520653009415, 0.04459003731608391, -0.02536623179912567, 0.00923621840775013, -0.020107083022594452, -0.08491932600736618, 0.05023059621453285, -0.03493495658040047, 0.03142031282186508, 0.0014855351764708757, -0.07882270216941833, 0.026642074808478355, 0.02966148592531681, 0.053107134997844696, 0.020686663687229156, -0.03149709850549698, 0.004240870475769043, 0.0015006541507318616, -0.02976594865322113, -0.022195497527718544, 0.01902586780488491, 0.037408631294965744, 0.03163931146264076, 0.014401880092918873, 0.04084741324186325, -0.04004921391606331, -0.05393928661942482, 0.010233727283775806, -0.012503094971179962, -0.043128546327352524, 0.030605152249336243, -0.06245611235499382, -0.031905997544527054, -0.008693292737007141, -0.06221983581781387, 0.019489850848913193, 0.01562296412885189, 0.02094937115907669, -0.04306759685277939, -0.024886151775717735, -0.0524168387055397, 0.0011770697310566902, -0.040308088064193726, 0.02068239264190197, 0.0458255335688591, -0.0002818862849380821, -0.0541258342564106, -0.0011367545230314136, -0.04047442227602005, 0.012082284316420555, -0.07328139245510101, 0.033265210688114166, -0.004132348112761974, -0.05503234267234802, 0.0009139292524196208, -0.02990257553756237, -0.012229782529175282, -0.006787945982068777, -0.05204330384731293, -0.06242406740784645, 0.04513755813241005, -0.05930865556001663, -0.017947334796190262, 0.003939082846045494, -0.07905936241149902, -0.055020809173583984, 0.01413937658071518, -0.03730085864663124, 0.010431259870529175, -0.022551389411091805, -0.007491689641028643, 0.019229399040341377, -0.024709079414606094, -0.049403272569179535, 0.04202522337436676, 0.04726887866854668, 0.004075678531080484, 0.0007650655461475253, -0.05132349953055382, 0.029787106439471245, -0.08980955928564072, 0.006255859509110451, -0.031819842755794525, -0.004254162311553955, 0.026250338181853294, 0.04238678514957428, -0.015520680695772171, -0.021397506818175316, 0.003659380367025733, 0.044565364718437195, 0.0190004650503397, 0.018579896539449692, -0.06148844212293625, -0.03436528146266937, -0.01972290687263012, -0.03435186669230461, -0.04019397869706154, -0.05470198020339012, -0.04545756056904793, -0.007460036315023899, -0.04213753342628479, 0.04007520526647568, 0.023379327729344368, -0.03756261616945267, -0.01527858804911375, 0.020107775926589966, 0.017191123217344284, 0.017716489732265472, -0.05019085481762886, -0.04689209908246994, -0.04362683743238449, -0.00963528361171484, 0.01204246748238802, -0.01599091850221157, -0.0009061889722943306, -0.08640503883361816, -0.032779570668935776, -0.05459079518914223, 0.01669370010495186, 0.0505405031144619, -0.05376940593123436, 0.053599290549755096, 0.016213592141866684, 0.04513092339038849, 0.020382864400744438, -0.0457305833697319, -0.015744579955935478, -0.015808073803782463, 0.013071573339402676, -0.010135789401829243, -0.06512687355279922, -0.010776101611554623, 0.029645882546901703, -0.04676647484302521, 0.00040532677667215466, -0.037805404514074326, 0.04215994477272034, 0.00045390307786874473, 0.002093955408781767, -0.04395889863371849, -0.02218690514564514, -0.04577494040131569, -0.015530187636613846, 0.05028523877263069, 0.05795970559120178, -0.015933765098452568, -0.04072880744934082, -0.044163674116134644, -0.00656801788136363, -0.05974899232387543, -0.04943826422095299, -0.052321504801511765, -0.046322792768478394, -0.04274941235780716, -0.07915115356445312, 0.0034967195242643356, 0.06676933914422989, -0.0734582245349884, -0.0029625962488353252, -0.07855234295129776, 0.03779427707195282, -0.026893721893429756, 0.03386354073882103, -0.014334465377032757, -0.03467103838920593, -0.025068456307053566, 0.03631937876343727, 0.05063016712665558, -0.019738193601369858, -0.04193401709198952, -0.044665563851594925, 0.043389447033405304, -0.015072893351316452, -0.037673551589250565, -0.03353826701641083, -0.02222350612282753, -0.0563666932284832, 0.017039280384778976, -0.008062118664383888, -0.01872405968606472, 0.02500109374523163, -0.055089790374040604, 0.007002613507211208, -0.030136313289403915, 0.02054126001894474, -0.0008047306328080595, 0.018272627145051956, 0.028115304186940193, -0.006952105090022087, -0.027239128947257996, 0.0057156020775437355, 0.02323795109987259, 0.03721385821700096, -0.03733986243605614, -0.06361919641494751, -0.005126124247908592, 0.002766666002571583, -0.04648732393980026, 0.038721490651369095, 0.03311793506145477, -0.06136731430888176, 0.0037832516245543957, -0.027337219566106796, -0.04280400648713112, 0.026283064857125282, 0.008350253105163574, -0.03537972643971443, 0.0068738400004804134, -0.013654163107275963, -0.0593288280069828, 0.007500891108065844, 0.03345324471592903, 0.008878886699676514, -0.04862174764275551, -0.03435290977358818, -0.004096829332411289, -0.016849765554070473, 0.044781848788261414, 0.016602301970124245, 0.03701220080256462, 0.002716509625315666, 0.045826736837625504, -0.02313806861639023, -0.04363807290792465, -0.025699777528643608, -0.07099653035402298, -0.04422016441822052, -0.012515072710812092, 0.038217052817344666, 0.051566675305366516, 0.021570883691310883, 0.01095590554177761, 0.047120023518800735, -0.04033314064145088, 0.053237397223711014, -0.02326037548482418, -0.05891060084104538, -0.0070805419236421585, 0.037552084773778915, -0.01464885100722313, 0.029124153777956963, -0.05204666033387184, -0.0024237947072833776, -0.05152101442217827, -0.023325471207499504, -0.010920954868197441, 0.057287562638521194, -0.009011335670948029, 0.04026180878281593, 0.06696180254220963, -0.02205432951450348, 0.02129937894642353, 0.027243882417678833, -0.014693055301904678, 0.007946445606648922, 0.010894943960011005, -0.014135976321995258, 0.02505681850016117, -0.029259517788887024, -0.03920933976769447, 0.04214246943593025, -0.0015484638279303908, -0.06344927102327347, -0.005662814248353243, 0.003512780414894223, 0.02017933875322342, -0.030306408181786537, -0.0730338990688324, 0.015526661649346352, -0.0014610255602747202, 0.04814056307077408, -0.05131356045603752, -0.04246395081281662, 0.06783699244260788, -0.02135557122528553, 0.05228886380791664, 0.008559913374483585, 0.00648388871923089, -0.0517069473862648, -0.012413968332111835, -0.026957819238305092, -0.04912636801600456, 0.06016970053315163, -0.02319258823990822, 0.04482563957571983, 0.01254924014210701, -0.0022355334367603064, -0.0036173686385154724, 0.017091553658246994, -0.005948248784989119, 0.04593168944120407, 0.050175853073596954, 0.04604201763868332, -0.01304357685148716, 0.003049570834264159, -0.035419706255197525, 0.02023712359368801, -0.009689489379525185, -0.045767445117235184, 0.03415253758430481, -0.012362675741314888, -0.03287143260240555, -0.012418956495821476, -0.062365833669900894, 0.014481172896921635, -0.020441029220819473, -0.0526561439037323, -0.06754536926746368, 0.060106296092271805, 0.02432212047278881, -0.04987586289644241, -0.06454981863498688, -0.03258313983678818, 0.030921386554837227, -0.05347106233239174, -0.004519327078014612, 0.018357934430241585, -0.03774809464812279, 0.012577918358147144, -0.0005028470768593252, -0.03751223161816597, 0.04312390834093094, -0.0012093557743355632, -0.016793645918369293, 0.004727898631244898, 0.043205711990594864, -0.01306853350251913, -0.057469651103019714, -0.029904616996645927, -0.02336546592414379, 0.0003379465197212994, -0.009527798742055893, -0.0528339259326458, 0.05872654914855957, 0.020691553130745888, -0.019437337294220924, -0.06120946630835533, 0.0492592416703701, 0.01642102375626564, 0.012401600368320942, -0.06056859344244003, 0.03315693885087967, 0.02312949299812317, 0.007703425362706184, -0.008503573946654797, 0.04005541279911995, -0.011804725043475628, 0.003893821267411113, -0.03218035772442818, -0.02732079103589058, -0.01703590899705887, -0.013980626128613949, 0.03215768188238144, -0.01708007976412773, -0.019426938146352768, 0.038649674504995346, -0.014098390936851501, -0.03641635552048683, 0.010242139920592308, -0.004611050244420767, 0.037134431302547455, 0.0027412225026637316, -0.04217824712395668, 0.006271629128605127, 0.030287984758615494, 0.055724550038576126, 0.03508102893829346, -0.031936708837747574, -0.047008611261844635, -0.04891899973154068, -0.049090947955846786, 0.04560896009206772, 0.030506884679198265, -0.021177874878048897, -0.03367195650935173, -0.046169865876436234, -0.05374721437692642, -0.051213450729846954, 0.01623661071062088, -0.046749651432037354, -0.006641807965934277, 0.03318371996283531, 0.033008210361003876, 0.022267766296863556, 0.051414232701063156, -0.005830043461173773, -0.032187893986701965, 0.021168667823076248, 0.04865068197250366, 0.030724655836820602, -0.05699249729514122, -0.004043630324304104, -0.02588837221264839, 0.04811607301235199, -0.021741222590208054, 0.033864010125398636, -0.03811855986714363, -0.03059590421617031, -0.04471545293927193, -0.044335514307022095, -0.027243223041296005, 0.044122885912656784, -0.049670539796352386, -0.007278466131538153, 0.05295451730489731, -0.04988052695989609, 0.05262589454650879, -0.05229632556438446, 0.03624372184276581, 0.027953270822763443, 0.0037415323313325644, 0.020520860329270363, 0.012680216692388058, 0.012290838174521923, 0.0740697979927063, -0.02370511181652546, 0.0016274931840598583, -0.0562286302447319, -0.07035037875175476, -0.008878784254193306, -0.02848379872739315, 0.03574521839618683, 0.01804511249065399, -0.021978428587317467, -0.025706697255373, 0.014575953595340252, 0.030588777735829353, -0.05852007120847702, -0.031050825491547585, 0.021920111030340195, -0.03286735340952873, -0.06508425623178482, 0.021930214017629623, -0.04745703190565109, -0.01897411420941353, 0.01726781390607357, -0.02728009596467018, -0.01917790248990059, -0.05879850313067436, 0.05083971843123436, 0.030300578102469444, -0.007868626154959202, 0.004875574726611376, -0.07501375675201416, -0.013029729016125202, 0.004975890275090933, 0.0000045053002395434305, -0.009053194895386696, 0.0017800756031647325, -0.058669980615377426, 0.006847898475825787, -0.06049581989645958, -0.01422404870390892, 0.022859370335936546, -0.05015462264418602, -0.01932445541024208, -0.011368035338819027, 0.0063324845395982265, 0.024134842678904533, -0.014389936812222004, 0.004651003982871771, -0.03144988790154457, 0.017546100541949272, -0.0014074725331738591, -0.05796142295002937, -0.025532953441143036, 0.03421134874224663, 0.005148074124008417, 0.018774889409542084, -0.031873591244220734, -0.03362274169921875, -0.014391619712114334, -0.009197302162647247, -0.022447405382990837, -0.07069354504346848, -0.017064571380615234, 0.04191991314291954, 0.04937296360731125, -0.003373932559043169, -0.025279855355620384, -0.04350418597459793, -0.013388389721512794, -0.015866369009017944, -0.026285594329237938, -0.0001378183951601386, 0.040972061455249786, 0.014804234728217125, 0.030921824276447296, -0.04603327065706253, -0.05704911798238754, 0.02114044316112995, -0.012348453514277935, -0.06834282726049423, 0.008973701857030392, 0.019345471635460854, -0.06934507936239243, -0.01918228529393673, 0.04155787453055382, -0.044501278549432755, 0.0004183961427770555, 0.05161544308066368, 0.025599945336580276, -0.02024438977241516, -0.012267312966287136, 0.006802998483181, -0.03347449749708176, 0.007329522632062435, 0.02495131455361843, -0.014055733568966389, 0.008353015407919884, 0.03691299632191658, 0.03873581811785698, -0.033478524535894394, 0.03242652490735054, -0.014457977376878262, -0.04418904334306717, 0.03916364908218384, -0.013229632750153542, -0.05660509318113327, 0.022296573966741562, 0.002346655121073127, -0.06316838413476944, -0.025194307789206505, -0.04074976593255997, -0.042718760669231415, -0.010631062090396881, -0.054870910942554474, 0.03316055238246918, 0.029166311025619507, -0.009403015486896038, -0.07749597728252411, 0.03319891542196274, 0.01741577312350273, -0.016507623717188835, -0.04616363346576691, -0.024200307205319405, -0.04567420482635498, -0.010939057916402817, -0.07565564662218094, -0.04289934039115906, -0.03129195794463158, 0.02703711949288845, 0.002327862661331892, -0.028629422187805176, 0.010736589320003986, 0.035767726600170135, 0.03306496515870094, 0.0067387958988547325, -0.0008087885216809809, 0.05303382873535156, 0.022045599296689034, -0.0005694365245290101, -0.0033749013673514128, 0.0013722216244786978, 0.060312867164611816, -0.009279157035052776, -0.028336772695183754, -0.038554154336452484, -0.005129016004502773, -0.04481012746691704, 0.024507790803909302, 0.07971840351819992, -0.028021732345223427, 0.0036790408194065094, -0.03373678773641586, 0.030774850398302078, -0.03499433398246765, -0.05643134191632271, 0.0625147745013237, -0.03468015044927597, 0.004222569987177849, 0.01622004061937332, -0.03383893147110939, -0.064453125, -0.026075851172208786, -0.03971607983112335, 0.041729047894477844, -0.0336504690349102, -0.0439058393239975, 0.06216513365507126, 0.003908658400177956, -0.03843067213892937, 0.05174575746059418, 0.04490353539586067, -0.05445926636457443, 0.06340203434228897, -0.032851237803697586, -0.04505074769258499, 0.032185863703489304, -0.07428622990846634, 0.017761342227458954, -0.02508391998708248, -0.005135675426572561, 0.05324801802635193, 0.02439272217452526, -0.04288346692919731, 0.005956033244729042, -0.0477096289396286, 0.0003310274623800069, 0.02283267118036747, -0.04967561736702919, 0.04181466996669769, -0.027412187308073044, 0.013010562397539616, -0.026962213218212128, -0.007888196967542171, -0.0685962364077568, 0.0499526783823967, -0.049385394901037216, 0.041057366877794266, 0.012298915535211563, 0.0009835438104346395, -0.010307775810360909, 0.031584762036800385, -0.03129193186759949, -0.016135014593601227, -0.02883198857307434, -0.019205909222364426, 0.06355125457048416, -0.022704005241394043, -0.007113240659236908, 0.008196585811674595, -0.030563674867153168, 0.002897874219343066, -0.010061693377792835, -0.013511563651263714, 0.007570716552436352, -0.049675337970256805, 0.0490516722202301, -0.01715650036931038, -0.03549819067120552, -0.061186302453279495 ]
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained and aligned to follow natural language instructions with only a handful of examples, and they are prompted as task-driven autonomous agents to adapt to various sources of execution environments. However, deploying agent LLMs in virtual reality (VR) has been challenging due to the lack of efficiency in online interactions and the complex manipulation categories in 3D environments. In this work, we propose Voice2Action, a framework that hierarchically analyzes customized voice signals and textual commands through action and entity extraction and divides the execution tasks into canonical interaction subsets in real-time with error prevention from environment feedback. Experiment results in an urban engineering VR environment with synthetic instruction data show that Voice2Action can perform more efficiently and accurately than approaches without optimizations.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00092v1
[ -0.04193403571844101, -0.05081962049007416, 0.06601816415786743, 0.014042527414858341, 0.0017203649040311575, -0.0030798858497291803, 0.026369847357273102, -0.008910998702049255, -0.019542260095477104, -0.0703509971499443, -0.025394637137651443, -0.0024509993381798267, -0.05609794706106186, -0.021063361316919327, -0.051791269332170486, 0.02845737710595131, 0.06083754077553749, -0.004026077222079039, -0.03433716669678688, -0.0023175510577857494, -0.0005222276085987687, -0.01947495900094509, -0.06560783833265305, 0.032918691635131836, 0.014793438836932182, -0.0005597657873295248, -0.006146516650915146, -0.013079199008643627, 0.020625518634915352, -0.003938812296837568, 0.07826493680477142, -0.022734012454748154, 0.04798164218664169, -0.0015960156451910734, -0.05209283530712128, -0.0321471206843853, -0.01721273362636566, 0.04784984141588211, 0.04412883520126343, -0.041237425059080124, 0.014476731419563293, -0.023883918300271034, -0.07874750345945358, -0.003364372765645385, -0.06696711480617523, -0.014625238254666328, -0.020338311791419983, -0.00916148629039526, -0.07479871809482574, -0.050805285573005676, -0.004831383936107159, 0.00499239144846797, 0.013136415742337704, 0.04895219951868057, -0.023293806239962578, 0.016376717016100883, -0.0032087175641208887, 0.0041320412419736385, -0.04698364436626434, -0.0022237307857722044, -0.0047380924224853516, -0.058815356343984604, 0.011463768780231476, 0.012191872112452984, -0.032682593911886215, 0.028068887069821358, -0.03875023499131203, -0.01859286054968834, -0.001472263946197927, -0.04731468856334686, 0.041604965925216675, -0.04989143833518028, -0.03770776838064194, -0.033595845103263855, 0.004673883318901062, -0.057696957141160965, -0.03814120963215828, -0.025648605078458786, -0.008500736206769943, -0.000302115484373644, -0.0031927162781357765, 0.01307477243244648, 0.05128682777285576, 0.031006095930933952, 0.03247099369764328, -0.04083320498466492, 0.011191373690962791, 0.007111024111509323, 0.01683739200234413, -0.027878185734152794, 0.059173181653022766, -0.0533781573176384, -0.06343888491392136, 0.011720843613147736, 0.043588753789663315, -0.011865670792758465, 0.06161411851644516, -0.000443360855570063, 0.001726022339425981, -0.017524056136608124, -0.0356251485645771, -0.025492336601018906, -0.03676527366042137, 0.050321031361818314, 0.011461395770311356, -0.024928074330091476, 0.01963278092443943, -0.019676661118865013, -0.0320461168885231, -0.04234519228339195, -0.048126474022865295, -0.02519363909959793, -0.0027524696197360754, -0.07511990517377853, -0.03472055494785309, -0.02880498394370079, 0.004098847042769194, -0.016416998580098152, 0.0045217121951282024, 0.005487571470439434, -0.02949289046227932, 0.05969244986772537, -0.0066488562151789665, -0.049583692103624344, -0.010332426056265831, -0.026119114831089973, 0.06815922260284424, 0.015848977491259575, -0.009590991772711277, -0.006000385154038668, -0.03663534298539162, 0.021905073896050453, -0.0010444044601172209, -0.05126231908798218, 0.024262560531497, 0.0329439640045166, -0.02402677945792675, -0.04660465940833092, -0.0338345542550087, -0.07533988356590271, -0.05846235156059265, -0.07617734372615814, 0.023992251604795456, -0.01779216341674328, 0.020791534334421158, 0.0544373095035553, -0.04420620575547218, -0.03975219652056694, -0.011665388941764832, -0.007541700266301632, 0.030333295464515686, -0.02214936725795269, 0.025289088487625122, 0.044578373432159424, 0.03336814418435097, -0.06294968724250793, 0.0487433597445488, -0.009497465565800667, -0.07441522181034088, -0.008034417405724525, 0.001506296219304204, -0.04217351973056793, 0.0028889155946671963, -0.051580511033535004, 0.010043042711913586, -0.007042295299470425, 0.0596737302839756, -0.05973641946911812, -0.029683353379368782, -0.041733309626579285, -0.03920896351337433, -0.039572615176439285, 0.02187826670706272, -0.01542228925973177, -0.017140144482254982, -0.04998186230659485, 0.032271917909383774, -0.03600003570318222, -0.013076652772724628, 0.02442219853401184, 0.0023510826285928488, 0.03343317285180092, -0.042154859751462936, -0.02770894765853882, -0.06116236746311188, 0.010181006044149399, -0.059524837881326675, -0.06509790569543839, 0.055682167410850525, -0.02368595078587532, -0.04868653044104576, -0.03109710104763508, -0.004422780591994524, 0.04648818075656891, -0.06461279839277267, -0.04142230376601219, -0.01578196883201599, -0.06678131222724915, 0.023659754544496536, 0.016472503542900085, -0.0807168260216713, 0.017138171941041946, -0.021261386573314667, -0.02733292244374752, 0.012337309308350086, -0.05228222906589508, 0.0015890070935711265, 0.03575430437922478, -0.025616664439439774, 0.0054583377204835415, 0.025433624163269997, 0.02128269523382187, 0.05174063518643379, 0.02643587812781334, 0.04378847777843475, 0.011358656920492649, -0.09253791719675064, 0.04699491336941719, 0.044069208204746246, 0.039122726768255234, 0.05226731672883034, 0.023003296926617622, 0.03586285188794136, -0.029931867495179176, 0.011675294488668442, 0.03538829833269119, 0.010360431857407093, -0.04465360939502716, -0.0648999735713005, -0.05558279901742935, -0.02655075304210186, -0.03845105692744255, -0.004972887225449085, -0.07320557534694672, -0.020779021084308624, -0.0323236808180809, -0.013029432855546474, 0.04332832247018814, -0.026973797008395195, -0.008201466873288155, -0.04596772417426109, -0.05475926771759987, -0.009715384803712368, -0.005420645233243704, -0.05466324836015701, -0.06365351378917694, 0.017070021480321884, 0.013589924201369286, -0.035172078758478165, -0.004499149043112993, -0.02077525481581688, -0.036747999489307404, -0.032307218760252, -0.027973098680377007, 0.031673990190029144, 0.04892011359333992, -0.04478994384407997, 0.015486977994441986, 0.0004836002772208303, 0.0383995957672596, 0.06121933460235596, 0.012358888983726501, -0.06142980605363846, -0.0031031949911266565, 0.04167830944061279, -0.03668632730841637, -0.01625118963420391, -0.011998431757092476, -0.03130262717604637, -0.058497555553913116, -0.0020808319095522165, 0.029738055542111397, 0.05562698841094971, -0.03626471385359764, -0.04984549060463905, 0.034975484013557434, 0.00454814825206995, 0.026990221813321114, 0.01800934039056301, 0.05466499179601669, 0.0013842969201505184, -0.04795191064476967, 0.017514992505311966, -0.061444204300642014, -0.04574262723326683, -0.0425945408642292, -0.032894574105739594, -0.07555250823497772, 0.0022081471979618073, -0.05125872790813446, -0.03958192467689514, -0.046285711228847504, -0.05931864306330681, -0.008163993246853352, 0.022763071581721306, -0.04358459264039993, -0.018946999683976173, -0.004928554408252239, 0.03682747110724449, -0.022629374638199806, -0.052708785980939865, 0.012473296374082565, 0.04440164938569069, 0.01109609566628933, -0.003308861516416073, -0.0018641883507370949, -0.028479233384132385, -0.020412493497133255, -0.04366699978709221, 0.01297733560204506, -0.0017683458281680942, 0.04379909858107567, -0.027693506330251694, 0.04960406944155693, -0.0023299362510442734, -0.008071794174611568, 0.007957031950354576, 0.01642998866736889, -0.024352533742785454, -0.03541332483291626, -0.025760097429156303, -0.03427200764417648, 0.020651843398809433, -0.0111264418810606, -0.05270940810441971, -0.038452960550785065, 0.010372012853622437, -0.006585694383829832, -0.011447149328887463, -0.031569864600896835, -0.0034680343233048916, 0.02914266660809517, 0.026807744055986404, 0.01551052462309599, 0.014064591377973557, 0.04830218106508255, -0.03966936469078064, -0.012610801495611668, -0.010100279934704304, -0.02228403650224209, -0.011556887999176979, -0.02046262100338936, -0.046849969774484634, -0.036057792603969574, 0.06327217817306519, -0.0784364715218544, -0.0021006071474403143, 0.04685087502002716, 0.07017253339290619, -0.024475522339344025, -0.004349520895630121, -0.012046804651618004, -0.007052327040582895, 0.06590095162391663, -0.015355882234871387, 0.026359084993600845, 0.01509858202189207, 0.05449698120355606, -0.01607346162199974, -0.034964218735694885, -0.0149171631783247, -0.0782739520072937, -0.037899281829595566, -0.01858796365559101, 0.008315210230648518, 0.03460027649998665, -0.023367585614323616, -0.06787528097629547, 0.03697726130485535, -0.0032956087961792946, 0.02188381366431713, 0.039866190403699875, -0.05820183828473091, 0.0007990623125806451, -0.031233355402946472, -0.031244009733200073, -0.0061754570342600346, 0.00031667653820477426, -0.03325772285461426, 0.010645376518368721, -0.01557464711368084, -0.05951786786317825, 0.026656655594706535, -0.03714107722043991, -0.05461597070097923, 0.038681406527757645, -0.000364864943549037, 0.008557215332984924, 0.04926357790827751, 0.0024296981282532215, -0.007750988472253084, 0.027814442291855812, -0.05009131506085396, -0.02587762475013733, -0.0001663971779635176, -0.05791107192635536, -0.017603566870093346, 0.006523168180137873, -0.053863804787397385, 0.008225473575294018, 0.031004874035716057, 0.02032768912613392, 0.005413970444351435, -0.0709221363067627, -0.036746349185705185, -0.0514996238052845, 0.028880354017019272, 0.035581499338150024, -0.017842067405581474, 0.05349982902407646, -0.010547298938035965, -0.012990888208150864, -0.00487983925268054, 0.0014006078708916903, -0.04863414913415909, -0.06649230420589447, 0.008853545412421227, -0.07345379889011383, 0.021360518410801888, -0.032885510474443436, 0.046597082167863846, -0.025690210983157158, 0.033552445471286774, -0.01669226959347725, -0.021694200113415718, -0.008293675258755684, 0.04199480637907982, 0.03281562030315399, 0.05809539929032326, 0.006659377366304398, -0.024732019752264023, 0.060507696121931076, -0.04545912146568298, 0.0020913276821374893, -0.043314892798662186, 0.003711175639182329, 0.021039994433522224, -0.03291650116443634, -0.01361751463264227, 0.012907176278531551, 0.014818773604929447, 0.004196526948362589, -0.02415294200181961, -0.022011829540133476, 0.008437704294919968, 0.04407850652933121, -0.002494203392416239, -0.040697962045669556, -0.06291437894105911, -0.03824809566140175, -0.05409078672528267, -0.032118942588567734, 0.019875356927514076, 0.033021748065948486, -0.005969918332993984, 0.03254080191254616, 0.020665466785430908, 0.011491739191114902, -0.04793151840567589, -0.015932079404592514, 0.01983335241675377, -0.01660466566681862, 0.008736289106309414, -0.03478667512536049, -0.049272339791059494, 0.03558918833732605, -0.04214658960700035, 0.01688149943947792, -0.05883972719311714, -0.004198023583739996, 0.024669311940670013, 0.04114716127514839, -0.08160006254911423, 0.020686374977231026, 0.05882309749722481, -0.02021380513906479, -0.020726462826132774, 0.016730714589357376, -0.028143465518951416, 0.01767517812550068, -0.043241556733846664, 0.041574977338314056, -0.040178332477808, -0.037549227476119995, -0.03898097202181816, -0.005888873245567083, -0.05247420817613602, -0.004039374645799398, 0.047251880168914795, -0.019298626109957695, -0.06298729032278061, -0.004754939582198858, 0.00034445495111867785, 0.03700081631541252, -0.03801983967423439, 0.030174320563673973, 0.05702117830514908, -0.038540441542863846, -0.008955992758274078, -0.023786749690771103, 0.045149173587560654, 0.025491369888186455, 0.02253985032439232, -0.05681861564517021, -0.010461180470883846, -0.003967838361859322, -0.024952514097094536, -0.031199073418974876, -0.015481133945286274, -0.022406933829188347, -0.017164479941129684, -0.006857168395072222, -0.04876258224248886, -0.05605044215917587, -0.05126645043492317, -0.0506771057844162, 0.035616613924503326, 0.02647092565894127, 0.010687611065804958, 0.036226797848939896, 0.0067715453915297985, -0.02016102895140648, -0.0174300167709589, 0.0038234437815845013, -0.022104740142822266, 0.03569730371236801, -0.05450732633471489, 0.0563601478934288, -0.010244510136544704, 0.016790812835097313, -0.004958175588399172, 0.06372404843568802, -0.01982281170785427, -0.03651764988899231, -0.03961575776338577, -0.06588131934404373, -0.012499834410846233, -0.06994017958641052, -0.039113081991672516, 0.04923079535365105, 0.018283072859048843, -0.022438451647758484, 0.01397178415209055, 0.005542158614844084, 0.0461372435092926, 0.03525937721133232, -0.0015258491039276123, 0.005261548794806004, -0.01395169086754322, 0.002189614810049534, 0.05893389508128166, -0.04788459092378616, 0.005804090760648251, -0.011125541292130947, -0.013154689222574234, 0.01746263913810253, -0.06838871538639069, 0.009867248125374317, 0.004030629526823759, 0.02647901140153408, -0.013974679633975029, 0.05004435032606125, 0.001394779421389103, -0.0664069876074791, 0.010287231765687466, 0.010893017053604126, -0.06796524673700333, 0.007220589555799961, -0.02043233811855316, 0.008815480396151543, -0.07300852239131927, 0.05679379031062126, 0.038106150925159454, 0.039318911731243134, -0.026580622419714928, 0.05774359405040741, 0.05812515690922737, -0.018934212625026703, -0.025329256430268288, 0.03733433037996292, -0.0301147922873497, 0.016459062695503235, -0.02888217382133007, -0.023461157456040382, 0.0371100977063179, -0.024948488920927048, 0.03599397838115692, -0.04641126096248627, -0.013533721677958965, 0.03823014348745346, -0.0048754047602415085, -0.008228643797338009, 0.022966792806982994, -0.032133765518665314, 0.05169852077960968, 0.0015800964320078492, 0.00181099446490407, 0.032730940729379654, -0.019745945930480957, -0.012310601770877838, -0.05506252869963646, -0.01645321026444435, 0.048314303159713745, 0.004805342759937048, -0.020266178995370865, -0.06688729673624039, -0.02977796271443367, -0.007789432071149349, -0.07862270623445511, 0.022997556254267693, -0.05259444937109947, -0.017474452033638954, 0.0031780116260051727, -0.027629513293504715, 0.016061268746852875, 0.0016556397313252091, -0.04134805500507355, -0.05981026217341423, 0.01794692501425743, -0.007579443510621786, -0.000730234372895211, -0.041893988847732544, -0.007930605672299862, -0.029230035841464996, 0.046311475336551666, -0.01422106847167015, -0.04591575637459755, 0.005193216260522604, -0.06354270875453949, 0.013598378747701645, -0.004317378159612417, -0.021739108487963676, -0.04718322679400444, 0.023497924208641052, 0.04697316884994507, 0.010552478022873402, -0.01795838586986065, -0.04287261143326759, -0.0514272078871727, 0.013972564600408077, 0.0300658717751503, -0.011839267797768116, 0.0037555049639195204, 0.0016380364540964365, 0.03608366474509239, -0.03243925794959068, 0.06103622168302536, -0.03209961578249931, 0.008692029863595963, 0.019144270569086075, -0.03432828187942505, -0.051473040133714676, 0.03471815213561058, -0.05032239854335785, -0.04622646048665047, 0.039615217596292496, 0.025351859629154205, -0.06273326277732849, 0.026456058025360107, 0.006486939731985331, -0.011526189744472504, 0.009864200837910175, -0.04386049136519432, 0.03981776162981987, 0.01997976191341877, -0.07128909975290298, -0.06734644621610641, -0.027089253067970276, -0.010530829429626465, -0.06378278136253357, -0.006053541786968708, -0.0009826936293393373, -0.06110736355185509, -0.0017399840289726853, -0.08685287833213806, -0.024054747074842453, -0.005050115752965212, 0.030309459194540977, 0.0019881620537489653, -0.03959822654724121, 0.03915158659219742, -0.05178920179605484, 0.025125375017523766, -0.014406264759600163, -0.02450854517519474, 0.03599080443382263, 0.0378601998090744, 0.03827228769659996, -0.06548767536878586, -0.041685763746500015, 0.044508326798677444, -0.009119140915572643, -0.0019762711599469185, 0.0007567353895865381, 0.02470349706709385, 0.052654679864645004, -0.01814326085150242, 0.06491981446743011, -0.0494101345539093, 0.03620598465204239, -0.05060381442308426, 0.01597023569047451, -0.05386141687631607, -0.0529559850692749, -0.017540182918310165, -0.024783635511994362, 0.05172020569443703, 0.027871785685420036, -0.027368919923901558, -0.006148326210677624, -0.04481106251478195, -0.05356501787900925, 0.026146061718463898, -0.06462803483009338, -0.058973949402570724, 0.05828525871038437, 0.01718996837735176, -0.04302180930972099, -0.05669974163174629, 0.009549181908369064, 0.015279983170330524, 0.05581386387348175, 0.0408083014190197, -0.033810604363679886, -0.01960446685552597, -0.05346398800611496, 0.039710938930511475, -0.00914843287318945, -0.027712658047676086, -0.03993154689669609, 0.06862544268369675, 0.034641943871974945, -0.044024769216775894, -0.010194143280386925, -0.026323257014155388, -0.02267230488359928, -0.042154502123594284, -0.027398165315389633, -0.04005566984415054, -0.035276900976896286, 0.02180051989853382, 0.014685146510601044, -0.00002549921555328183, 0.06676290184259415, -0.00713726133108139, 0.07190395146608353, 0.030146900564432144, -0.018487831577658653, -0.010948109440505505, 0.05410411208868027, 0.005265057552605867, -0.006048908922821283, -0.05008238926529884, -0.04001520201563835, -0.014804992824792862, -0.010514379478991032, -0.007631894666701555, -0.013218860141932964, 0.04562819376587868, 0.004391887225210667, -0.02223385125398636, 0.005561230704188347, 0.005644530989229679, -0.03573515638709068, -0.016150865703821182, -0.014200257137417793, 0.0005867465515621006, -0.06750760972499847 ]
As language models are adopted by a more sophisticated and diverse set of users, the importance of guaranteeing that they provide factually correct information supported by verifiable sources is critical across fields of study. This is especially the case for high-stakes fields, such as medicine and law, where the risk of propagating false information is high and can lead to undesirable societal consequences. Previous work studying attribution and factuality has not focused on analyzing these characteristics of language model outputs in domain-specific scenarios. In this work, we conduct human evaluation of responses from a few representative systems along various axes of attribution and factuality, by bringing domain experts in the loop. Specifically, we collect expert-curated questions from 484 participants across 32 fields of study, and then ask the same experts to evaluate generated responses to their own questions. In addition, we ask experts to improve upon responses from language models. The output of our analysis is ExpertQA, a high-quality long-form QA dataset with 2177 questions spanning 32 fields, along with verified answers and attributions for claims in the answers.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07852v2
[ 0.016762766987085342, -0.03243769332766533, 0.04839089512825012, 0.01671169139444828, -0.017169561237096786, 0.02292441762983799, -0.03618060424923897, -0.025306563824415207, -0.06650952994823456, -0.05154397711157799, -0.035342298448085785, 0.003435066668316722, -0.047289952635765076, -0.02647242695093155, -0.04461812227964401, -0.0049984087236225605, 0.023765407502651215, 0.03602360934019089, -0.0551094114780426, -0.0035421722568571568, -0.04108612984418869, 0.031428657472133636, 0.024231666699051857, 0.05008656531572342, 0.055454056710004807, 0.000007763257599435747, -0.0025888741947710514, -0.030451124534010887, 0.020521895959973335, -0.016944129019975662, 0.056855179369449615, -0.04431137442588806, -0.03380705043673515, -0.04112096503376961, -0.025626307353377342, -0.04807974770665169, -0.0454973503947258, 0.00560485664755106, 0.00002051937008218374, -0.00903251487761736, 0.004559316672384739, -0.060211826115846634, -0.08160226792097092, 0.003270759480074048, -0.04428444802761078, -0.03797789663076401, -0.034869927912950516, 0.030136460438370705, -0.08444321155548096, -0.06170071288943291, -0.0032036188058555126, -0.006966003682464361, -0.01936422288417816, 0.013744834810495377, 0.0029666253831237555, -0.03950057923793793, 0.004560773726552725, 0.017108242958784103, -0.06298968940973282, 0.010799436829984188, 0.007489251904189587, -0.006917799822986126, -0.031844612210989, 0.0320180244743824, -0.04575183987617493, 0.04683130979537964, -0.0056841326877474785, -0.05026540905237198, -0.0027494370006024837, -0.024085896089673042, 0.024710558354854584, -0.0656837597489357, -0.026729224249720573, 0.011033117771148682, 0.016549142077565193, -0.037567947059869766, -0.021383995190262794, -0.002323922934010625, 0.014664101414382458, 0.01360117644071579, -0.011449862271547318, 0.018775029107928276, 0.012137159705162048, 0.03489960357546806, 0.003120000706985593, -0.06759046018123627, 0.03600947931408882, -0.0028024562634527683, 0.012876799330115318, -0.03696810454130173, -0.012927055358886719, -0.05286972224712372, -0.08383876830339432, 0.015884332358837128, 0.07802160829305649, -0.0017879937076941133, 0.0329788401722908, -0.0003263168619014323, 0.0019498348701745272, -0.002528140787035227, -0.030873285606503487, -0.029710670933127403, 0.006639817729592323, 0.052557364106178284, 0.004296747036278248, -0.020126046612858772, -0.0067550428211688995, -0.03486029431223869, -0.06836789101362228, -0.02064448408782482, -0.02771715447306633, -0.024057403206825256, -0.013930648565292358, -0.06979591399431229, -0.021031977608799934, -0.010335675440728664, 0.0384262278676033, 0.02510007843375206, 0.02312813512980938, -0.02941003628075123, -0.038789547979831696, 0.03802228718996048, 0.06343862414360046, -0.04459680989384651, -0.044898856431245804, 0.008389702998101711, 0.02291802689433098, 0.018628545105457306, -0.03553798049688339, 0.029027346521615982, -0.016351327300071716, 0.011009289883077145, -0.00011637467105174437, -0.0017549446783959866, 0.06391377747058868, -0.015300166793167591, 0.02244289219379425, -0.04316175356507301, -0.0017708499217405915, -0.03515241667628288, -0.03463694080710411, -0.08682882785797119, -0.019084462895989418, -0.050041478127241135, -0.010454175993800163, 0.041076693683862686, -0.02035478688776493, -0.006290426943451166, 0.04775868356227875, 0.03489699214696884, -0.007583148777484894, -0.04111577570438385, 0.0017513433704152703, 0.0006047591450624168, -0.014801625162363052, -0.035006895661354065, 0.04166267439723015, -0.0292497705668211, -0.03364710137248039, 0.04259734973311424, -0.02494107186794281, -0.015731243416666985, -0.007955255918204784, -0.04913712292909622, -0.021960612386465073, 0.017456112429499626, 0.02283569611608982, 0.016287576407194138, -0.04110562801361084, -0.03007023222744465, -0.012509082444012165, 0.027649689465761185, -0.04104232043027878, -0.04260187968611717, -0.07131358981132507, 0.0006252729799598455, 0.03640782833099365, 0.008478587493300438, -0.05982498452067375, 0.026050657033920288, 0.004069213755428791, 0.03026590123772621, -0.03322753682732582, 0.046904537826776505, -0.017981408163905144, 0.026517778635025024, -0.07793594151735306, -0.012553601525723934, 0.0182172991335392, -0.03325736150145531, -0.019118988886475563, -0.041421256959438324, -0.02466028556227684, -0.019215211272239685, -0.027916714549064636, -0.006871837191283703, 0.0163642019033432, -0.016990303993225098, 0.026612551882863045, 0.025087838992476463, -0.08525034785270691, -0.02174464613199234, -0.0788525864481926, 0.004149730317294598, -0.021223656833171844, -0.06335356086492538, -0.04722628742456436, 0.0698796883225441, -0.03223609924316406, 0.013039990328252316, 0.04484144225716591, 0.059162307530641556, 0.04487274959683418, 0.05401839315891266, -0.02390618994832039, 0.05132564902305603, -0.09787704050540924, 0.0581163689494133, -0.008068953640758991, 0.02498101256787777, 0.0340689942240715, 0.03905226290225983, 0.006253497209399939, 0.034527990967035294, 0.012048425152897835, 0.020391760393977165, 0.013744932599365711, 0.0036080593708902597, -0.05577065795660019, 0.00561435567215085, -0.017414983361959457, -0.054537951946258545, 0.00904680322855711, -0.07908891886472702, -0.00024589980603195727, -0.04530962556600571, 0.02178215980529785, 0.04935619235038757, -0.023213420063257217, -0.02126247063279152, -0.006107687018811703, -0.04147237166762352, 0.040176305919885635, 0.023854920640587807, -0.016188068315386772, -0.03164299204945564, -0.020496470853686333, 0.006572633981704712, 0.02435060404241085, -0.025729233399033546, -0.022528614848852158, -0.07279311120510101, -0.009208045899868011, 0.02269071340560913, 0.0024366171564906836, 0.0022235745564103127, -0.018046677112579346, 0.06015196815133095, 0.0015993834240362048, 0.04751298204064369, 0.06403088569641113, 0.03650844097137451, -0.049901220947504044, 0.006379523780196905, 0.05233360081911087, -0.022253192961215973, 0.002278219209983945, -0.015308788977563381, -0.010384374298155308, -0.011452744714915752, 0.0182020403444767, 0.03351778909564018, 0.03828960284590721, -0.003975034225732088, -0.054115667939186096, -0.058173492550849915, 0.0410303995013237, -0.009119310416281223, 0.04613826423883438, 0.06081533432006836, 0.027270400896668434, 0.019070448353886604, 0.00920421164482832, -0.057903748005628586, 0.0014729981776326895, -0.04192226380109787, -0.035776734352111816, -0.06247426196932793, -0.03272045776247978, -0.043550003319978714, -0.0581471249461174, -0.06297218799591064, 0.026417113840579987, -0.06274330615997314, 0.004035643767565489, -0.03150012344121933, -0.048677053302526474, -0.01929348148405552, -0.009928949177265167, 0.028141062706708908, -0.026444170624017715, -0.06654545664787292, 0.031414277851581573, 0.0036857149098068476, 0.0032369005493819714, -0.020042624324560165, -0.03794116526842117, -0.01527362409979105, 0.01709195412695408, -0.022658873349428177, 0.006027810741215944, 0.026769418269395828, -0.0025428887456655502, 0.05559768155217171, -0.026032160967588425, -0.03553878143429756, -0.02633151225745678, 0.04888738691806793, -0.01096349861472845, 0.01374460756778717, 0.019569434225559235, -0.00469402177259326, -0.02125530317425728, -0.02383294887840748, -0.038212850689888, -0.02446771040558815, 0.05395353585481644, 0.009614333510398865, 0.013289942406117916, -0.04759299010038376, -0.04254214093089104, 0.06323817372322083, -0.0014846781268715858, -0.015282680280506611, -0.02506115287542343, 0.04259822890162468, -0.016982773318886757, -0.030854295939207077, 0.03969027101993561, 0.0023525513242930174, 0.015399103984236717, 0.021176643669605255, -0.040847912430763245, -0.024331070482730865, 0.05828132480382919, -0.07846418023109436, -0.0072371275164186954, 0.03945307433605194, 0.07632267475128174, 0.01734270714223385, -0.0008603079477325082, 0.018281077966094017, -0.014062734320759773, 0.008110731840133667, -0.011255619116127491, 0.02384217455983162, 0.03429817408323288, 0.04898913949728012, -0.074276402592659, -0.0011421251110732555, -0.021763350814580917, -0.060707200318574905, -0.043960701674222946, -0.012278450652956963, 0.047328997403383255, 0.05052630975842476, 0.029540814459323883, -0.06189941242337227, -0.001736120437271893, 0.006147054024040699, 0.061202503740787506, 0.020311959087848663, -0.05122988298535347, 0.026348071172833443, -0.06252359598875046, 0.058320656418800354, 0.03129428252577782, 0.006109514273703098, 0.02853844314813614, 0.006144810002297163, 0.02493627369403839, -0.04482487216591835, 0.03397340327501297, -0.021517910063266754, -0.03273065388202667, 0.04077238216996193, 0.024888450279831886, 0.012514416128396988, 0.021140333265066147, -0.04584122449159622, 0.01163023803383112, 0.0023260372690856457, -0.01098683848977089, -0.04713151976466179, -0.011996310204267502, -0.0431346595287323, -0.024349026381969452, 0.054677143692970276, -0.02440890111029148, 0.02685443125665188, -0.01960625872015953, 0.01338429469615221, -0.00962604209780693, -0.07573962211608887, 0.05409707501530647, -0.02783198282122612, 0.07068931311368942, 0.024834230542182922, -0.04264552891254425, 0.034338921308517456, -0.03000212088227272, -0.02306167595088482, -0.00454853568226099, 0.0017526422161608934, -0.012153263203799725, -0.04372264817357063, 0.01788053847849369, -0.06487435102462769, 0.010342622175812721, -0.07823695242404938, 0.06862503290176392, 0.00870504043996334, 0.02966751717031002, -0.004673096816986799, -0.03402728587388992, -0.0319104865193367, 0.044990431517362595, 0.07286716997623444, 0.061081599444150925, -0.0157625675201416, -0.01977868564426899, 0.0414600595831871, 0.006210013292729855, 0.03878098353743553, -0.03663649410009384, -0.013671865686774254, 0.03663383051753044, 0.014056519605219364, -0.008871331810951233, 0.0007748431526124477, -0.011647570878267288, 0.018742162734270096, -0.038270920515060425, -0.011438476853072643, -0.002161815296858549, 0.03998376056551933, -0.045591916888952255, -0.08437171578407288, -0.04391610994935036, -0.026036297902464867, -0.06070391833782196, -0.0072989268228411674, 0.047433577477931976, 0.02374964766204357, -0.04601690173149109, -0.016018018126487732, -0.012485723942518234, 0.0020569139160215855, -0.03336334228515625, 0.02195705845952034, 0.010883200913667679, -0.04380510747432709, -0.040450066328048706, -0.024985594674944878, -0.04104883596301079, 0.009310184977948666, -0.034452248364686966, -0.010949918068945408, -0.026401786133646965, 0.06446699053049088, 0.02148233912885189, 0.07052590698003769, -0.08184945583343506, 0.016546906903386116, 0.028599239885807037, -0.017354464158415794, 0.014636244624853134, 0.05890144780278206, 0.01199990976601839, -0.01557847112417221, -0.04738248884677887, 0.010447653010487556, -0.0008916527731344104, -0.03132769092917442, 0.05257381126284599, 0.004799934569746256, -0.011912978254258633, 0.009438815526664257, 0.05545470491051674, -0.011221453547477722, -0.07045333087444305, -0.04109741374850273, 0.06144978478550911, -0.004342898726463318, -0.004814242012798786, 0.021991534158587456, 0.032883621752262115, -0.030457718297839165, -0.035115521401166916, -0.025688672438263893, -0.016159065067768097, -0.00042588336509652436, 0.016380148008465767, -0.0221798587590456, -0.004798825830221176, -0.014322023838758469, -0.014229988679289818, 0.004601070191711187, 0.011346298269927502, -0.027713432908058167, 0.009578363038599491, 0.0250976774841547, 0.020803485065698624, -0.04790612682700157, 0.024184608832001686, -0.033144235610961914, 0.062038980424404144, 0.06773708015680313, 0.03630829229950905, 0.05946747213602066, -0.05226202309131622, 0.0016682521672919393, -0.028378650546073914, -0.008997193537652493, 0.01988999731838703, 0.026422396302223206, -0.0326257087290287, 0.01575705222785473, -0.008636712096631527, 0.05121229216456413, 0.04129950702190399, 0.020452652126550674, 0.018705205991864204, 0.044866278767585754, -0.03040536679327488, -0.035633742809295654, -0.01780117116868496, 0.02125084400177002, -0.050308652222156525, 0.03390258178114891, 0.0362442210316658, -0.024765407666563988, 0.05142219737172127, -0.010700623504817486, -0.014970965683460236, 0.012964512221515179, -0.000010471345376572572, -0.043606407940387726, -0.04059906303882599, 0.026867534965276718, 0.0607365146279335, -0.03908349201083183, 0.04327145591378212, -0.03897338733077049, -0.0034171133302152157, 0.015345638617873192, -0.04675518348813057, 0.02261185646057129, 0.06719043105840683, 0.003160591470077634, -0.0019477432360872626, 0.05725434049963951, 0.0133866211399436, -0.05783814936876297, 0.021444473415613174, -0.002279483014717698, -0.08624114841222763, -0.02807314693927765, -0.01257897075265646, 0.06929358839988708, -0.011008993722498417, 0.05564788356423378, -0.011537672020494938, 0.02767072804272175, -0.016636082902550697, 0.05798695236444473, 0.08663483709096909, -0.021826673299074173, -0.03693432733416557, -0.01488254964351654, -0.046273667365312576, 0.01119756419211626, 0.006797879468649626, -0.0353400893509388, 0.00968229304999113, 0.053211938589811325, -0.009941110387444496, -0.011685737408697605, 0.03862953186035156, 0.06692161411046982, -0.028538404032588005, 0.015256806276738644, 0.021791450679302216, -0.04959361255168915, 0.026189174503087997, -0.055378250777721405, -0.042440030723810196, -0.017638610675930977, 0.0031413512770086527, -0.011768155731260777, -0.042808547616004944, -0.05640322342514992, -0.01249744277447462, 0.003359939670190215, -0.012960280291736126, -0.07900144159793854, 0.008599075488746166, -0.014781556092202663, -0.07446860522031784, 0.036474235355854034, -0.06936454772949219, -0.0006944886990822852, -0.02268613874912262, 0.03279377520084381, 0.02726064622402191, 0.04123760387301445, -0.039289020001888275, -0.02206673100590706, 0.04787106439471245, -0.02251003123819828, -0.0022318416740745306, 0.007894860580563545, -0.003490409115329385, -0.05773163214325905, 0.03545086458325386, -0.05990276113152504, -0.009784040972590446, 0.02056456357240677, 0.016159961000084877, -0.0207623690366745, 0.04529619589447975, -0.032253917306661606, -0.03949343413114548, 0.021195009350776672, 0.023267662152647972, 0.0348978191614151, 0.04984953626990318, -0.04143840819597244, -0.054317407310009, -0.02226179838180542, 0.018578341230750084, -0.02396257035434246, 0.010811994783580303, 0.05099601671099663, 0.03769037127494812, -0.03824255242943764, 0.01568462885916233, -0.04397621750831604, 0.01559606846421957, 0.02913203276693821, -0.0660114511847496, 0.037876930087804794, -0.005472781136631966, -0.05692296847701073, -0.01576315052807331, -0.007412220351397991, 0.0017563560977578163, -0.056268300861120224, 0.005898727104067802, 0.058058373630046844, 0.01894545741379261, -0.020471084862947464, -0.0479331873357296, 0.022873926907777786, 0.03694313019514084, -0.0167295653373003, -0.05134644731879234, 0.009172456339001656, -0.03626329451799393, -0.03866465389728546, -0.0014993185177445412, 0.006065664812922478, -0.0439118891954422, 0.02016240358352661, -0.07379734516143799, 0.020367871969938278, 0.012673811987042427, 0.018382083624601364, -0.005934090819209814, -0.05636065825819969, 0.017026105895638466, -0.049153126776218414, 0.015376326628029346, -0.03617701306939125, -0.015509366057813168, -0.002500728005543351, 0.03586525470018387, 0.04288915917277336, -0.047038618475198746, -0.035833436995744705, 0.04682864993810654, -0.029266569763422012, -0.022917678579688072, -0.017487645149230957, 0.0023782597854733467, -0.011007933877408504, 0.04685915634036064, 0.03574172034859657, -0.05515613034367561, 0.012254446744918823, -0.048108991235494614, 0.04588533565402031, -0.06063232943415642, -0.04592996463179588, 0.02168249525129795, -0.0008922528941184282, -0.03377344831824303, 0.0378887765109539, -0.008709315210580826, -0.02543490193784237, -0.03330133110284805, -0.05411267653107643, 0.015327990986406803, -0.008096927776932716, 0.002794193336740136, 0.053309544920921326, 0.011801513843238354, 0.0029054905753582716, -0.02274179644882679, -0.012392048723995686, -0.02941906452178955, 0.013822264038026333, 0.04348618909716606, -0.05169149488210678, -0.05572166293859482, -0.027863850817084312, 0.0029271577950567007, -0.0367322601377964, 0.025918394327163696, -0.020964011549949646, 0.07792604714632034, 0.01390748005360365, -0.03414832800626755, -0.0032031068112701178, -0.053495220839977264, -0.055895160883665085, -0.08593752980232239, -0.06284084171056747, -0.03408735245466232, 0.032767634838819504, -0.0019926552195101976, -0.02501215972006321, 0.049707915633916855, 0.04931886866688728, -0.03007439151406288, 0.018721645697951317, 0.00806188490241766, 0.015118216164410114, -0.05676791071891785, 0.07664661109447479, -0.03871539607644081, 0.00518313143402338, -0.05240411311388016, 0.0017195804975926876, 0.0013575777411460876, -0.01055824663490057, 0.038208700716495514, -0.016692599281668663, -0.006283779162913561, -0.037810735404491425, 0.011889814399182796, 0.019768012687563896, -0.023536767810583115, -0.055187661200761795, -0.04558851942420006, -0.0009515713318251073, -0.017738552764058113, -0.01172581221908331 ]
The paper deals with the theoretical consideration of surface plasmon-polaritons in the graphene monolayer, embedded into dielectric with spatially separated gain and losses. It is demonstrated, that presence of gain and losses in the system leads to the formation of additional mode of graphene surface plasmon-polaritons, which does not have its counterpart in the conservative system. When the gain and losses are mutually balanced, the position of exceptional point -- transition point between unbroken and broken $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetry -- can be effectively tuned by graphene's doping. In the case of unbalanced gain and losses the spectrum of surface plasmon-polaritons contains spectral singularity, whose frequency is also adjustable through the electrostatic gating of graphene.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16787v1
[ -0.05699513107538223, -0.019800415262579918, 0.01666322723031044, 0.006586859934031963, 0.011079014278948307, 0.021723290905356407, 0.00909834448248148, 0.0008373553864657879, -0.04810279980301857, 0.023391298949718475, -0.02302613854408264, -0.0020931214094161987, -0.022332554683089256, -0.07597123831510544, -0.013263668864965439, -0.03670161962509155, 0.07216931134462357, 0.03092140518128872, -0.023452721536159515, 0.0918443351984024, -0.03102486953139305, 0.00017033952462952584, -0.03237028047442436, 0.05456818267703056, -0.026733828708529472, -0.03523241728544235, -0.024905167520046234, 0.02219434641301632, -0.027630995959043503, -0.03476526215672493, 0.06714507192373276, 0.010855354368686676, -0.03281412646174431, 0.01039952039718628, 0.013980530202388763, 0.017315417528152466, 0.027547821402549744, 0.04403523728251457, 0.06349325180053711, -0.029586225748062134, 0.012303943745791912, -0.02574610337615013, -0.02356586791574955, -0.024308068677783012, -0.012783914804458618, -0.05199176445603371, -0.05213489383459091, 0.016208071261644363, 0.01613849774003029, -0.04973830655217171, 0.06338678300380707, 0.003914839122444391, 0.026893800124526024, 0.047200120985507965, -0.04609993100166321, 0.021054288372397423, 0.03037026710808277, 0.010259495116770267, 0.023029416799545288, 0.015013976022601128, -0.008769277483224869, -0.0421597845852375, 0.009920435026288033, 0.006241896189749241, -0.04349797964096069, 0.0028758621774613857, -0.05586312338709831, -0.06557413935661316, -0.04739158973097801, -0.02964470162987709, 0.00852392241358757, -0.07265974581241608, 0.002018098486587405, 0.03864213451743126, -0.06220509484410286, 0.02640616148710251, -0.03346622735261917, 0.027441736310720444, 0.01690743863582611, -0.00430253054946661, -0.02839558757841587, -0.028652306646108627, -0.023636719211935997, -0.009553543291985989, 0.024604789912700653, 0.0036930700298398733, -0.0167480930685997, 0.013432392850518227, -0.016381561756134033, -0.036718372255563736, 0.018388867378234863, -0.0005193222314119339, -0.03933278098702431, -0.030571531504392624, 0.06846688687801361, -0.028707820922136307, 0.03219166025519371, 0.016293814405798912, 0.0009737731306813657, -0.015499019995331764, -0.01169400755316019, -0.0216644499450922, -0.03678633272647858, -0.05245204642415047, -0.004835170228034258, -0.03610605001449585, 0.013379741460084915, -0.006971349008381367, -0.01576009951531887, 0.05167635902762413, -0.008860544301569462, 0.04727565497159958, -0.048896342515945435, -0.02074999362230301, -0.04825928062200546, -0.02261679247021675, 0.068254254758358, -0.0038394061848521233, 0.010557404719293118, 0.008088905364274979, -0.0242136362940073, 0.015558869577944279, -0.0054564098827540874, 0.02823004312813282, -0.045330651104450226, -0.04112236201763153, 0.07261961698532104, 0.007781360298395157, -0.009975149296224117, -0.048129770904779434, -0.012564443051815033, 0.016525080427527428, 0.05679352954030037, -0.005063894670456648, 0.038282327353954315, -0.0590021051466465, 0.05157679691910744, 0.0018765298882499337, 0.005253118928521872, 0.040646880865097046, -0.006551529746502638, -0.03889257088303566, 0.013161925598978996, 0.000016771271475590765, 0.03380543738603592, 0.02222190983593464, -0.06895726919174194, 0.009517434053122997, 0.02077021636068821, 0.03636941686272621, 0.015800245106220245, 0.00019218024681322277, 0.007116686552762985, 0.036709994077682495, -0.005363869946449995, 0.03333849832415581, 0.042748112231492996, -0.00008159317076206207, 0.001387805794365704, 0.01874270848929882, -0.011719392612576485, -0.006525744218379259, 0.019612105563282967, 0.024189060553908348, 0.018710704520344734, -0.009730865247547626, 0.024783750995993614, -0.036772917956113815, 0.03344723954796791, 0.03590463101863861, -0.03315802291035652, 0.04497290030121803, -0.027212990447878838, -0.03089388832449913, -0.05916314199566841, -0.009313013404607773, -0.06665723025798798, -0.05069921910762787, 0.0031599784269928932, 0.01725887693464756, 0.06271250545978546, 0.014413156546652317, -0.019192349165678024, -0.01117553561925888, -0.048582322895526886, -0.015341067686676979, -0.09399760514497757, 0.048115454614162445, 0.01406419463455677, -0.0032392560970038176, -0.01707935519516468, -0.06160248816013336, 0.0075995298102498055, -0.004865481052547693, -0.03080270253121853, -0.009921066462993622, -0.01610841602087021, -0.037855345755815506, 0.018196560442447662, 0.021260961890220642, -0.07697410881519318, -0.06017482280731201, -0.061408884823322296, 0.036515578627586365, 0.01996626891195774, -0.0639231950044632, -0.01418288890272379, 0.05715356394648552, -0.05049950256943703, -0.008548219688236713, 0.06331586092710495, 0.024246668443083763, 0.020784009248018265, -0.040947459638118744, -0.0012897017877548933, -0.01132230181246996, -0.11098411679267883, 0.0008029742166399956, -0.009760753251612186, 0.03806999698281288, 0.026202259585261345, -0.022311216220259666, -0.009353416040539742, -0.019481446593999863, -0.02506364695727825, 0.04293535277247429, 0.043244216591119766, 0.013747715391218662, 0.02591029927134514, -0.002833796199411154, 0.006469822954386473, -0.052730489522218704, -0.06140974909067154, -0.03479926288127899, -0.04540182277560234, 0.0385390929877758, -0.058493804186582565, 0.05534728616476059, -0.017880642786622047, -0.03196907043457031, -0.08422877639532089, -0.037256039679050446, 0.060106463730335236, -0.0025390798691660166, -0.023234549909830093, -0.02762192115187645, -0.05278776213526726, 0.025692695751786232, -0.03212198615074158, -0.03785889223217964, 0.02961874194443226, -0.06537018716335297, -0.0028693771455436945, -0.061589617282152176, 0.03613841533660889, 0.041986219584941864, -0.05779700353741646, -0.021588748320937157, -0.03470534458756447, 0.05229078605771065, 0.018531087785959244, 0.005429978482425213, -0.0011171646183356643, 0.04701804742217064, 0.015311895869672298, -0.005058515351265669, -0.02844356931746006, -0.007549354340881109, 0.01282983273267746, -0.052898671478033066, 0.028207464143633842, 0.035790540277957916, -0.02104121819138527, 0.016858939081430435, 0.009506748989224434, -0.021178755909204483, -0.03823940455913544, -0.04226330667734146, 0.0040157027542591095, 0.02181273326277733, 0.07004554569721222, 0.0352356992661953, -0.02163274772465229, -0.08352188766002655, 0.03211577236652374, -0.0014239695155993104, -0.0031037726439535618, -0.04173088073730469, -0.055632952600717545, -0.036746546626091, -0.06330142170190811, -0.024680081754922867, -0.04751737043261528, 0.019303495064377785, -0.06716297566890717, -0.03013850748538971, -0.026150204241275787, -0.02193186618387699, -0.04106063023209572, -0.06381738185882568, -0.0678924098610878, -0.008433016948401928, 0.014887836761772633, -0.005233228672295809, -0.012652769684791565, -0.04533156752586365, -0.014038930647075176, 0.019319193437695503, 0.030884061008691788, -0.0024424949660897255, -0.0021558438893407583, -0.042446479201316833, -0.07220078259706497, 0.024319149553775787, -0.0537259578704834, 0.003235511714592576, 0.0402221754193306, -0.06819259375333786, 0.02179487608373165, -0.002526369644328952, -0.0257917158305645, 0.008111626841127872, 0.0030475417152047157, -0.005430443212389946, -0.0555240660905838, -0.019976451992988586, 0.03036518394947052, 0.033309344202280045, 0.02789228968322277, -0.05174345150589943, -0.07604019343852997, -0.030355297029018402, 0.033241745084524155, -0.021299097687005997, 0.03345879167318344, 0.010968741029500961, 0.0055756960064172745, -0.012856489978730679, -0.0413685142993927, 0.035520102828741074, -0.006526592653244734, 0.04374730959534645, 0.0026837496552616358, -0.0002070118353003636, -0.02435656264424324, -0.05021809786558151, -0.007413824088871479, 0.0210126880556345, 0.012513993307948112, -0.011763318441808224, -0.025545239448547363, 0.016715794801712036, -0.0024107450153678656, -0.013659019023180008, 0.018298663198947906, 0.027861125767230988, 0.05777742341160774, 0.01737523265182972, -0.03158700093626976, -0.009139428846538067, -0.038708627223968506, -0.0506984107196331, -0.03600628301501274, 0.025109032168984413, 0.005633594002574682, 0.043336108326911926, -0.005835480522364378, -0.003114106133580208, 0.02668941766023636, -0.025782333686947823, 0.03512652590870857, -0.01980220526456833, 0.062374506145715714, 0.019307652488350868, -0.009199412539601326, 0.030942853540182114, -0.011837486177682877, -0.013898150995373726, -0.005245733540505171, -0.06117481365799904, -0.0013675681548193097, -0.016765199601650238, -0.03902047127485275, 0.024467362090945244, 0.01690664328634739, 0.04629058763384819, 0.013489797711372375, 0.01478994358330965, 0.012627269141376019, -0.004439400043338537, 0.0416477806866169, 0.007052128203213215, -0.009488479234278202, 0.036574963480234146, -0.04800952598452568, -0.03818177431821823, 0.02418181486427784, 0.015493888407945633, 0.01714908704161644, 0.03417055681347847, -0.010617362335324287, 0.004016430117189884, -0.031531330198049545, -0.07485972344875336, 0.003442577552050352, -0.03129661828279495, 0.03922799602150917, -0.005857793614268303, -0.01619092747569084, 0.07365459203720093, 0.009988894686102867, -0.030368689447641373, -0.024701688438653946, -0.03996596112847328, -0.03073088265955448, -0.02263871766626835, -0.009848905727267265, 0.01672065071761608, 0.012706637382507324, -0.034266892820596695, 0.040701910853385925, 0.009564069099724293, 0.010330158285796642, -0.049562014639377594, 0.0365166962146759, 0.017540903761982918, 0.002715607173740864, 0.06027119979262352, 0.0010926452232524753, -0.002286960370838642, 0.006187923718243837, -0.02600187063217163, 0.01345563679933548, 0.026193108409643173, 0.012618765234947205, -0.07797045260667801, 0.03175143897533417, -0.0584351122379303, -0.0357217900454998, -0.019283298403024673, -0.03236173838376999, 0.0587882436811924, -0.056906767189502716, -0.05985067039728165, 0.00787226390093565, 0.037166494876146317, -0.051572125405073166, -0.052765339612960815, -0.016718078404664993, -0.01166626252233982, -0.04642435908317566, 0.018922334536910057, 0.008932017721235752, -0.0182328037917614, 0.013314418494701385, 0.0598175972700119, -0.026076676324009895, 0.030688345432281494, -0.06048684939742088, 0.025243647396564484, 0.06698455661535263, 0.04715607315301895, 0.02052018605172634, -0.07709311693906784, -0.06540795415639877, 0.020638907328248024, -0.0027579658199101686, 0.014028416946530342, 0.03552301228046417, 0.03647025674581528, -0.00956395547837019, 0.02468099631369114, -0.0782884806394577, 0.005621074698865414, 0.05702946335077286, -0.02540597878396511, 0.012729725800454617, 0.047498948872089386, -0.022350000217556953, 0.05624942108988762, 0.0006080466555431485, -0.04456208273768425, 0.025312555953860283, -0.018699204549193382, 0.00427991384640336, 0.003641189308837056, -0.08057354390621185, 0.0046495492570102215, 0.03253161534667015, 0.0278394166380167, -0.07496626675128937, 0.011384044773876667, -0.008108444511890411, -0.005654289852827787, -0.0068389675579965115, 0.00015158300811890513, 0.016720913350582123, -0.06047482416033745, -0.03225681558251381, 0.012388075701892376, -0.03554302453994751, 0.02138829417526722, 0.02739550545811653, -0.0682748407125473, 0.0043053897097706795, 0.006785615347325802, 0.002394859679043293, 0.05152038857340813, 0.03266051784157753, 0.039709001779556274, -0.03078101947903633, -0.0026829540729522705, 0.008486024104058743, -0.09032738953828812, 0.05812361091375351, -0.07441049069166183, 0.039212338626384735, 0.02018251270055771, 0.013273780234158039, 0.05227082222700119, 0.04746529459953308, -0.03251122683286667, 0.007642100099474192, 0.017908865585923195, -0.010883333161473274, 0.04430611431598663, -0.038118626922369, -0.010091063566505909, 0.010114867240190506, 0.0343555323779583, -0.00314286258071661, 0.005389472935348749, 0.0056074527092278, 0.0021814373321831226, -0.03485498204827309, -0.0077543980441987514, 0.02796388790011406, 0.027688652276992798, -0.035660520195961, -0.024419836699962616, 0.05353925749659538, -0.03881305828690529, 0.04150502011179924, 0.012866443023085594, 0.021057002246379852, 0.03370049595832825, 0.015548953786492348, 0.05361446365714073, -0.027374429628252983, 0.00043764419388026, 0.05469576641917229, -0.07006901502609253, 0.03228691220283508, 0.010183678939938545, -0.05940018594264984, 0.005549999885261059, -0.04305259883403778, 0.01101660169661045, 0.04954568296670914, -0.012034224346280098, -0.018051236867904663, -0.02763771079480648, -0.010229896754026413, -0.047565609216690063, -0.00305295386351645, 0.05441349744796753, -0.07831665128469467, -0.005261906888335943, -0.0037211624439805746, -0.04792569950222969, -0.01681378111243248, -0.00035821180790662766, -0.0548822320997715, -0.06790293008089066, -0.036381687968969345, 0.05724765360355377, 0.060744013637304306, -0.058427054435014725, -0.022842910140752792, 0.015121727250516415, -0.016923416405916214, 0.015706466510891914, -0.020213888958096504, 0.004876303486526012, -0.022570447996258736, 0.03204319253563881, -0.0396057665348053, -0.023008694872260094, -0.00014124118024483323, 0.025702930986881256, -0.023547383025288582, -0.04424399137496948, 0.044044479727745056, 0.031831834465265274, 0.05852441489696503, -0.048246048390865326, -0.04268794506788254, 0.04790640249848366, 0.016240213066339493, -0.010736222378909588, -0.056888751685619354, 0.00413052923977375, -0.031249085441231728, 0.04273854196071625, 0.011940923519432545, -0.014932961203157902, 0.019855566322803497, -0.04917270317673683, -0.04051293805241585, -0.02366546355187893, -0.05546887591481209, -0.011422419920563698, 0.03240863233804703, 0.02338400110602379, -0.008701669983565807, 0.04386328533291817, -0.055049486458301544, 0.04160918667912483, -0.004483018536120653, 0.015030546113848686, 0.031865835189819336, 0.0015653719892725348, 0.05920442193746567, -0.03355058655142784, 0.04670117795467377, -0.05499906465411186, 0.052150700241327286, -0.029702303931117058, -0.03620507940649986, 0.04984629154205322, -0.006904548965394497, -0.05336606875061989, -0.0018824844155460596, 0.0332571305334568, -0.0369114950299263, 0.004364999011158943, -0.04198596626520157, 0.04263770580291748, -0.08160889893770218, 0.043189410120248795, -0.014413981698453426, 0.01044723391532898, 0.009953293018043041, -0.008053867146372795, 0.043511293828487396, -0.02147890068590641, 0.07554955035448074, 0.06664364039897919, 0.051558271050453186, 0.02439144439995289, -0.07530873268842697, 0.003708913456648588, 0.03893867880105972, -0.0029495630878955126, -0.0694984570145607, -0.01811843551695347, -0.07603277266025543, -0.06974109262228012, -0.03392978012561798, 0.020667526870965958, -0.04334673658013344, -0.05603781342506409, -0.01302686519920826, 0.009262965992093086, 0.05447922646999359, -0.042432866990566254, -0.05939624086022377, 0.049947772175073624, 0.014848930761218071, -0.002582937479019165, -0.014903969131410122, -0.016606945544481277, -0.036493681371212006, -0.04384863004088402, -0.09074253588914871, -0.01996312476694584, 0.030182965099811554, 0.05602623149752617, 0.007255490403622389, 0.0018576562870293856, -0.03620722144842148, -0.0510576032102108, 0.011054004542529583, -0.014776503667235374, 0.037644870579242706, -0.023100607097148895, 0.010380304418504238, 0.009049943648278713, -0.01749703660607338, -0.01862010732293129, 0.02899281308054924, 0.03618937358260155, -0.0005421477253548801, -0.026368077844381332, 0.03804713487625122, -0.0036404207348823547, 0.03326251357793808, 0.0479755736887455, -0.010901370085775852, 0.06084642931818962, -0.04350671544671059, -0.010641108267009258, -0.03817674517631531, -0.04973343387246132, 0.0672624483704567, -0.042794421315193176, -0.002975874114781618, 0.031886082142591476, -0.04552818089723587, -0.04158163070678711, -0.0083483150228858, -0.07798265665769577, 0.04275824874639511, 0.012841296382248402, -0.03354504704475403, 0.03901765123009682, -0.031728509813547134, -0.01845376379787922, 0.049917373806238174, -0.007235853001475334, -0.025831932201981544, 0.019253481179475784, -0.02825765311717987, -0.015776021406054497, 0.040555816143751144, -0.05586196854710579, 0.03757215663790703, 0.004331277217715979, 0.015776652842760086, 0.039840906858444214, 0.04123473912477493, -0.03845851495862007, -0.018508082255721092, -0.06745727360248566, -0.024875372648239136, 0.031793687492609024, -0.06626008450984955, 0.009727702476084232, 0.01831214502453804, 0.02764480747282505, 0.053064122796058655, 0.06398989260196686, -0.03261289745569229, 0.030325833708047867, 0.037664104253053665, -0.001782308565452695, -0.028978273272514343, 0.005805713590234518, 0.018814029172062874, 0.04081060737371445, 0.012155604548752308, -0.011071943677961826, 0.008619477041065693, 0.014725996181368828, -0.0071764360181987286, 0.019074348732829094, -0.0014486478175967932, 0.012634893879294395, -0.03258826211094856, -0.014421731233596802, 0.011763603426516056, 0.04828711971640587, 0.029951559379696846, -0.04631631821393967, 0.054021187126636505, 0.020300153642892838, -0.03008454293012619, -0.06526706367731094 ]
Real-time and efficient path planning is critical for all robotic systems. In particular, it is of greater importance for industrial robots since the overall planning and execution time directly impact the cycle time and automation economics in production lines. While the problem may not be complex in static environments, classical approaches are inefficient in high-dimensional environments in terms of planning time and optimality. Collision checking poses another challenge in obtaining a real-time solution for path planning in complex environments. To address these issues, we propose an end-to-end learning-based framework viz., Path Planning and Collision checking Network (PPCNet). The PPCNet generates the path by computing waypoints sequentially using two networks: the first network generates a waypoint, and the second one determines whether the waypoint is on a collision-free segment of the path. The end-to-end training process is based on imitation learning that uses data aggregation from the experience of an expert planner to train the two networks, simultaneously. We utilize two approaches for training a network that efficiently approximates the exact geometrical collision checking function. Finally, the PPCNet is evaluated in two different simulation environments and a practical implementation on a robotic arm for a bin-picking application. Compared to the state-of-the-art path planning methods, our results show significant improvement in performance by greatly reducing the planning time with comparable success rates and path lengths.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00119v1
[ -0.032822106033563614, -0.0568113774061203, 0.03868607431650162, 0.027913056313991547, -0.011498326435685158, 0.006488812621682882, 0.03209971264004707, 0.01608954183757305, 0.03504890203475952, -0.04561128467321396, -0.04152509942650795, 0.013459887355566025, -0.025548044592142105, -0.02857177145779133, -0.005526486784219742, 0.014238540083169937, 0.08001454919576645, -0.017663249745965004, -0.054772842675447464, 0.03448579087853432, -0.0297823715955019, 0.0033402941189706326, 0.011258278973400593, 0.007785322610288858, -0.03324975445866585, -0.017208769917488098, -0.06891969591379166, 0.007289494853466749, -0.082236148416996, -0.015633754432201385, 0.060252245515584946, -0.032697539776563644, -0.04196660965681076, -0.058894358575344086, -0.029403941705822945, -0.043750785291194916, 0.0027201285120099783, 0.020424682646989822, 0.06234819442033768, -0.03189624845981598, 0.03931596130132675, -0.05816274136304855, -0.05826959013938904, -0.006866153795272112, -0.017745519056916237, -0.04691921919584274, -0.03055420331656933, 0.003992801066488028, -0.05462424084544182, -0.04920356720685959, 0.03006223402917385, 0.003216717392206192, 0.02470221184194088, 0.04024633392691612, -0.04564544931054115, 0.009046461433172226, -0.013254339806735516, 0.04154840111732483, -0.04332629591226578, -0.01843654364347458, -0.02970704808831215, -0.042663563042879105, -0.01619681529700756, 0.0005083039868623018, 0.0279237087816, 0.056536175310611725, -0.009660456329584122, -0.07817454636096954, -0.024854009971022606, -0.026318291202187538, 0.05228689685463905, -0.05009424313902855, -0.0018097123829647899, 0.005498906597495079, -0.019722338765859604, -0.035446349531412125, -0.022312108427286148, -0.038327354937791824, 0.01234415452927351, -0.034238550812006, -0.050294384360313416, 0.011548595502972603, 0.034306157380342484, 0.044346071779727936, 0.002015861216932535, 0.001291582826524973, 0.04405578598380089, 0.03672466054558754, 0.02710082195699215, -0.06175190210342407, 0.012190917506814003, -0.05622616782784462, -0.07674568146467209, -0.006883987225592136, 0.06601845473051071, -0.011655518785119057, 0.059524424374103546, 0.03917676955461502, -0.003741745138540864, 0.0028905102517455816, -0.03400489315390587, -0.009669017978012562, -0.06134365499019623, 0.0573660247027874, 0.030369197949767113, -0.04019736498594284, 0.03887541964650154, -0.014092976227402687, -0.04013935476541519, -0.0073240045458078384, -0.044287990778684616, -0.01478107925504446, 0.010352158918976784, -0.06254318356513977, -0.02005535550415516, -0.022181060165166855, 0.058559853583574295, 0.019218677654862404, 0.05868716537952423, -0.008857899345457554, -0.03705459460616112, 0.012328831478953362, 0.07370545715093613, 0.0240925382822752, -0.019298523664474487, -0.01600431278347969, 0.05227559432387352, 0.024874908849596977, 0.015637876465916634, -0.014628466218709946, -0.009993492625653744, 0.05377654731273651, -0.006055897101759911, -0.02320835180580616, 0.04941238835453987, -0.0008593139937147498, -0.0044556776992976665, -0.036217641085386276, 0.032377902418375015, -0.017921622842550278, -0.06630033254623413, -0.0660913810133934, -0.004375120624899864, 0.0038173850625753403, 0.025168588384985924, 0.06270567327737808, -0.04140067473053932, -0.036758363246917725, -0.030272725969552994, 0.04432746767997742, 0.009465920738875866, -0.008332991041243076, 0.04593922570347786, -0.013920165598392487, 0.03606239706277847, -0.034959886223077774, 0.04970558360219002, -0.037029851227998734, -0.04122462123632431, -0.0036965725012123585, 0.019660424441099167, -0.010238767601549625, 0.0401640348136425, -0.041391026228666306, -0.014832987450063229, 0.012671290896832943, 0.036774806678295135, -0.00489059230312705, 0.010789873078465462, 0.015319470316171646, -0.002530342433601618, 0.0034900072496384382, 0.008627383038401604, -0.04539525881409645, -0.045513201504945755, -0.04992834851145744, 0.013847238384187222, -0.030456146225333214, -0.01941716857254505, -0.014005512930452824, -0.008512982167303562, 0.04417554661631584, -0.034095145761966705, 0.03752673789858818, -0.07034612447023392, -0.0159824900329113, -0.08655648678541183, 0.0036716109607368708, -0.013357667252421379, 0.03536703437566757, -0.017532190307974815, -0.047796063125133514, -0.0013726303586736321, 0.014430003240704536, -0.0398685447871685, -0.05837150663137436, 0.005083231721073389, -0.06935998052358627, 0.03203423693776131, 0.037801891565322876, -0.08055461943149567, 0.013457788154482841, -0.057558923959732056, -0.009318332187831402, 0.01100817508995533, -0.05899311602115631, 0.039287179708480835, 0.022362753748893738, -0.03863615170121193, 0.016210263594985008, 0.021914124488830566, 0.04797019809484482, 0.056696709245443344, 0.032165005803108215, 0.033285632729530334, 0.014779002405703068, -0.09515351057052612, 0.004709648434072733, 0.010072424076497555, 0.05883967876434326, 0.019362740218639374, -0.009534264914691448, -0.019615497440099716, -0.041089996695518494, -0.0290695633739233, 0.03780970722436905, 0.0488513819873333, -0.0031088744290173054, -0.054261207580566406, -0.030239727348089218, -0.04649629816412926, -0.06353580206632614, -0.01429087296128273, -0.06000206246972084, -0.07307446748018265, -0.013700239360332489, -0.06206650659441948, 0.07344725728034973, 0.009890171699225903, 0.0012449396308511496, -0.05076660215854645, -0.05412813276052475, 0.033215105533599854, -0.047457363456487656, -0.0434761717915535, -0.04881355166435242, -0.03299035504460335, 0.03640341758728027, 0.026501940563321114, -0.016166815534234047, -0.0426635704934597, -0.03606301546096802, 0.015120167285203934, -0.02122846059501171, 0.02529936470091343, 0.06204555556178093, -0.029561514034867287, -0.01778600551187992, -0.05506260320544243, 0.027164645493030548, 0.0341784693300724, -0.0014380777720361948, -0.07039490342140198, 0.03148796409368515, 0.04394882917404175, 0.010058999992907047, 0.0011781962821260095, -0.02299647033214569, -0.016930188983678818, -0.06221168488264084, -0.03196617588400841, 0.013855502009391785, 0.041725631803274155, 0.02157164365053177, 0.006744204089045525, -0.06313605606555939, -0.0000113486757982173, 0.003206307999789715, 0.007761694025248289, 0.06450817734003067, 0.009442595764994621, 0.02005658484995365, 0.019664961844682693, -0.0482509583234787, 0.04466628283262253, -0.019631439819931984, 0.011799387633800507, -0.060156989842653275, -0.04894362762570381, -0.06040967255830765, -0.03646475821733475, -0.0078165577724576, -0.07191275805234909, -0.0431893952190876, -0.014109880663454533, -0.032922279089689255, -0.012871799059212208, 0.035521723330020905, -0.026580633595585823, -0.01048905961215496, -0.054106567054986954, -0.0723423883318901, 0.03575962781906128, 0.02510376274585724, 0.008084109984338284, -0.039439763873815536, -0.029050366953015327, -0.039220862090587616, 0.019847456365823746, 0.043560635298490524, -0.03789803758263588, -0.003110679564997554, -0.004643761552870274, 0.043832045048475266, 0.0028854829724878073, -0.019911441951990128, -0.018799496814608574, 0.0034756148234009743, -0.046915266662836075, 0.009320080280303955, 0.030755717307329178, 0.003050501924008131, 0.0038193841464817524, -0.055347152054309845, -0.037303052842617035, 0.002543489681556821, 0.053774408996105194, 0.00428715068846941, -0.053146082907915115, -0.008598205633461475, 0.022696437314152718, -0.007313753943890333, 0.023677418008446693, -0.0029859766364097595, -0.002534792758524418, 0.0004942857776768506, -0.01439699623733759, -0.01623196341097355, -0.012856042012572289, -0.00427000829949975, -0.034826211631298065, 0.02000667341053486, -0.026275109499692917, -0.019141022115945816, 0.04612608626484871, -0.08647771179676056, -0.0011408926220610738, 0.012328745797276497, 0.06329135596752167, -0.03171679750084877, 0.005413467064499855, 0.0030795359052717686, 0.04891558736562729, -0.04567555710673332, 0.033370241522789, 0.015860000625252724, 0.039949048310518265, 0.05628351494669914, -0.011779170483350754, -0.010897107422351837, -0.024327559396624565, -0.06520310789346695, -0.04745008051395416, 0.022424886003136635, 0.024107806384563446, 0.018399475142359734, 0.02123240940272808, -0.04764876887202263, -0.017918115481734276, -0.03688540309667587, 0.026703255251049995, 0.03018125891685486, -0.0276983343064785, -0.0015317712677642703, -0.05899358168244362, 0.009863345883786678, 0.023579230532050133, 0.01968306489288807, 0.03410578519105911, -0.05577138066291809, 0.021329296752810478, -0.08042726665735245, 0.033210840076208115, -0.022920997813344002, -0.05381742864847183, 0.015905285254120827, 0.035607755184173584, -0.011701127514243126, 0.050140414386987686, -0.00047757758875377476, 0.012637543492019176, 0.006072517018765211, -0.024837426841259003, -0.026210999116301537, -0.005213846918195486, -0.016863293945789337, 0.041050635278224945, 0.03242531791329384, 0.018277142196893692, 0.008641158230602741, -0.018431415781378746, -0.015691209584474564, 0.016311712563037872, -0.07285761833190918, 0.00043971952982246876, -0.02094133198261261, 0.03603222966194153, 0.01740245521068573, 0.0038488213904201984, 0.06812665611505508, 0.015266409143805504, -0.015514761209487915, -0.04333767667412758, -0.039799824357032776, -0.034654103219509125, -0.02744312956929207, -0.046311959624290466, -0.05049480125308037, 0.01990453153848648, -0.048956140875816345, 0.05856837332248688, 0.02675432153046131, 0.061905212700366974, -0.05871966853737831, -0.06502173840999603, 0.014223492704331875, 0.053615882992744446, 0.026858443394303322, 0.014681042172014713, -0.03713374212384224, -0.013616764917969704, -0.025611955672502518, -0.012327921576797962, -0.012012084014713764, 0.002758009359240532, -0.03014032170176506, 0.04568508267402649, 0.01673998311161995, -0.015034226700663567, 0.0314047671854496, 0.00093053188174963, 0.06227796897292137, -0.027417603880167007, 0.0013113855384290218, -0.010844865813851357, 0.05500221252441406, -0.07745426148176193, -0.06304246932268143, -0.06492242962121964, -0.03573658689856529, -0.04705719277262688, -0.030590809881687164, 0.03478262573480606, 0.0378543958067894, 0.009542900137603283, 0.006430438719689846, 0.02043098397552967, 0.040467627346515656, -0.04584720730781555, 0.05109834671020508, -0.016488218680024147, -0.013841155916452408, 0.02230498567223549, -0.031100746244192123, -0.08606470376253128, 0.04253609851002693, 0.019298335537314415, 0.019933348521590233, -0.0015201042406260967, 0.03542974591255188, 0.0210117194801569, 0.058004580438137054, -0.08729307353496552, 0.026150453835725784, 0.022316405549645424, -0.054507751017808914, 0.028149647638201714, 0.05240309238433838, -0.042243149131536484, 0.025177622213959694, -0.020589398220181465, -0.022579878568649292, 0.03857320547103882, -0.06583211570978165, -0.007443276233971119, 0.004301560577005148, -0.0369536429643631, 0.031599972397089005, 0.054521314799785614, 0.003355002263560891, -0.055602215230464935, 0.009117253124713898, 0.03172972425818443, 0.028306156396865845, -0.027220314368605614, 0.02929305098950863, 0.004508382175117731, -0.04624290019273758, 0.026303833350539207, -0.041824452579021454, 0.017384517937898636, -0.007339343428611755, -0.030950598418712616, -0.01861920766532421, -0.017818164080381393, 0.027320312336087227, 0.023882217705249786, 0.02434014156460762, 0.004740915726870298, 0.03878602012991905, -0.01092513743788004, -0.010921860113739967, 0.014170038513839245, -0.06267652660608292, 0.010758032090961933, -0.022270379588007927, 0.03988655284047127, 0.020918581634759903, 0.02764754369854927, -0.0035106900613754988, 0.016833048313856125, -0.06448489427566528, -0.06688622385263443, 0.008357787504792213, -0.024774545803666115, 0.03685414418578148, -0.05676424130797386, 0.047935545444488525, -0.023892950266599655, 0.012006791308522224, -0.00773914810270071, 0.013690685853362083, 0.03098233789205551, -0.025806279852986336, -0.030883781611919403, -0.015190135687589645, 0.031716786324977875, -0.05583755671977997, -0.05961846187710762, 0.015643035992980003, 0.007420171517878771, -0.03942640870809555, 0.012187371030449867, 0.04120754450559616, -0.0045560309663414955, 0.02437545172870159, 0.02298971265554428, -0.01303846575319767, -0.02647138014435768, 0.04185401648283005, 0.05273022875189781, -0.06730132550001144, -0.0032538319937884808, 0.006625636480748653, -0.021243706345558167, 0.015111830085515976, -0.01329836156219244, -0.018465926870703697, 0.04138690605759621, -0.011297192424535751, -0.05136323347687721, 0.02504698559641838, -0.02446526475250721, -0.0695255771279335, -0.018476776778697968, 0.04315083473920822, -0.07428011298179626, -0.014912058599293232, 0.02486640214920044, 0.009896529838442802, -0.05465560778975487, 0.035991400480270386, 0.022142644971609116, -0.009219691157341003, -0.039196304976940155, 0.044156838208436966, 0.06371209025382996, 0.0015826524468138814, -0.005235582590103149, 0.038750823587179184, -0.03497570380568504, 0.020127959549427032, -0.02988096885383129, 0.003666769480332732, 0.0268385112285614, 0.06634644418954849, 0.008166401647031307, -0.04696805402636528, -0.00043793447548523545, 0.07903257757425308, -0.04576492682099342, -0.05433795973658562, -0.0030234416481107473, -0.016213230788707733, 0.057262614369392395, -0.023556344211101532, -0.07248963415622711, -0.0030517822597175837, -0.005678222514688969, -0.03562434762716293, -0.028755711391568184, 0.009649484418332577, -0.02931339666247368, 0.0007884220103733242, -0.02321949228644371, -0.03689516335725784, 0.026660772040486336, -0.024393266066908836, -0.0699184313416481, 0.0017664498882368207, -0.04280218854546547, -0.032258354127407074, -0.013767884112894535, -0.035835083574056625, 0.031119829043745995, 0.04061082378029823, -0.0362011082470417, -0.01871291734278202, -0.00003070002276217565, 0.005495247896760702, 0.006895104423165321, 0.011261285282671452, 0.032056499272584915, -0.01821097359061241, 0.03212291747331619, -0.008640018291771412, -0.036518894135951996, -0.034872423857450485, -0.011238143779337406, -0.0038434003945440054, -0.01257361751049757, 0.0006684334366582334, 0.009816335514187813, 0.011439180001616478, 0.011842376552522182, 0.02886234223842621, 0.0024433250073343515, -0.01089756190776825, -0.07236012071371078, 0.03444347158074379, 0.006151226349174976, 0.027285534888505936, -0.03775642812252045, 0.01631222292780876, 0.02111356146633625, -0.006130699068307877, 0.032084591686725616, -0.0000797355460235849, 0.002644840395078063, 0.00266559817828238, -0.06313665956258774, -0.01871454156935215, 0.0340297557413578, -0.006698190234601498, -0.07254420965909958, -0.04515602067112923, -0.026077579706907272, -0.06959734112024307, -0.015353151597082615, 0.06515030562877655, -0.021652286872267723, 0.005848404485732317, -0.060609206557273865, -0.00685009453445673, -0.006923651322722435, -0.06253546476364136, -0.05862434580922127, -0.003924942575395107, -0.0030618244782090187, -0.017154060304164886, -0.0006479084258899093, -0.001551431487314403, -0.057254768908023834, -0.027791447937488556, -0.0782834142446518, -0.022640107199549675, 0.018023652955889702, 0.036658428609371185, 0.016794700175523758, -0.0413576140999794, 0.0010810337262228131, -0.055937256664037704, -0.007991759106516838, 0.018756583333015442, 0.005415909457951784, 0.006166848819702864, 0.042575620114803314, 0.02586480602622032, -0.05521184578537941, -0.013945463113486767, 0.029000069946050644, 0.0119014298543334, -0.013320501893758774, 0.03815946727991104, 0.034240640699863434, 0.05990736931562424, 0.006676789838820696, 0.03826027736067772, -0.034068141132593155, 0.062259823083877563, -0.042469095438718796, 0.022749045863747597, -0.05886435881257057, -0.07092663645744324, -0.023905981332063675, -0.007391430903226137, 0.014971697703003883, 0.02837858349084854, -0.028109978884458542, 0.016865216195583344, -0.04324663057923317, -0.06240089237689972, 0.05774295702576637, -0.03602930158376694, -0.01809222623705864, 0.050237026065588, -0.020296161994338036, 0.0027089130599051714, -0.027848752215504646, -0.0023975602816790342, -0.0032484144903719425, 0.011682460084557533, 0.04940769821405411, -0.019581735134124756, -0.012682855129241943, -0.05135307088494301, 0.03281605988740921, 0.006239230278879404, -0.027711231261491776, -0.04945168271660805, 0.06987478584051132, 0.02815553918480873, -0.038152504712343216, -0.007278700824826956, -0.028424518182873726, -0.07166700810194016, -0.07580450177192688, -0.04195764660835266, -0.04360015690326691, 0.030268337577581406, -0.021689100190997124, 0.040729425847530365, 0.040294624865055084, 0.03793371096253395, 0.005724119022488594, 0.011210445314645767, -0.04004316031932831, 0.015585882589221, -0.038191720843315125, 0.07971920818090439, -0.04244266822934151, -0.004218827001750469, -0.013923468999564648, 0.02906155213713646, 0.006003499496728182, -0.0010802058968693018, -0.028096644207835197, -0.004735094960778952, -0.026026783511042595, -0.04268597438931465, -0.0012639207998290658, 0.03359841927886009, 0.0013908619293943048, -0.03548503294587135, -0.03149283304810524, -0.014007738791406155, -0.024092337116599083, -0.023007672280073166 ]
This paper investigates the transverse Ising model on a discretization of two-dimensional anti-de Sitter space. We use classical and quantum algorithms to simulate real-time evolution and measure out-of-time-ordered correlators (OTOC). The latter can probe thermalization and scrambling of quantum information under time evolution. We compared tensor network-based methods both with simulation on gated-based superconducting quantum devices and analog quantum simulation using Rydberg arrays. While studying this system's thermalization properties, we observed different regimes depending on the radius of curvature of the space. In particular, we find a region of parameter space where the thermalization time depends only logarithmically on the number of degrees of freedom.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04383v2
[ -0.037447489798069, -0.06353574991226196, 0.04867922142148018, 0.007759764324873686, 0.022362450137734413, -0.053625743836164474, 0.0060574752278625965, 0.01343690138310194, 0.02161918766796589, 0.01067446917295456, -0.013724083080887794, -0.009815029799938202, -0.045067910104990005, -0.04775182902812958, -0.04944800212979317, 0.005916181486099958, 0.06592573970556259, 0.03363209217786789, -0.0741892084479332, 0.07431506365537643, 0.04230409115552902, -0.019541515037417412, -0.0055047376081347466, 0.022406596690416336, -0.04339524731040001, -0.026293866336345673, 0.011803162284195423, 0.02950134128332138, -0.026241153478622437, 0.02250637672841549, 0.030847549438476562, -0.02830701321363449, 0.05377767235040665, -0.013850083574652672, -0.048116497695446014, -0.01171265821903944, 0.009164197370409966, 0.0429571159183979, 0.010094600729644299, -0.040680959820747375, -0.011334422044456005, -0.05239604786038399, -0.058819662779569626, 0.006159584037959576, -0.000017119089534389786, -0.022196227684617043, -0.04857988655567169, -0.00385165773332119, -0.02751166559755802, -0.053044818341732025, -0.027161085978150368, 0.030161909759044647, -0.016991736367344856, 0.03797072172164917, -0.029304157942533493, 0.009435567073523998, -0.0275692380964756, 0.046199217438697815, -0.02701760083436966, -0.016577403992414474, -0.03836623951792717, -0.0498068667948246, 0.03161630779504776, 0.021411413326859474, 0.010528039187192917, 0.05758897587656975, -0.05172784626483917, -0.020114324986934662, -0.01548826228827238, -0.06839132308959961, 0.05237656459212303, -0.07106360793113708, 0.022207137197256088, -0.007551887538284063, -0.06272415071725845, -0.018608497455716133, -0.031950630247592926, 0.022189665585756302, 0.03424821421504021, 0.0045682527124881744, -0.009666458703577518, 0.019491715356707573, -0.014798974618315697, 0.06326056271791458, 0.04698285833001137, 0.013068418018519878, 0.024951718747615814, 0.0023709703236818314, 0.01635323092341423, -0.03403005003929138, 0.01928139664232731, -0.019631322473287582, -0.028137173503637314, 0.0001555220951559022, 0.06308072805404663, -0.02284836210310459, 0.039689965546131134, 0.0672324150800705, 0.04050641506910324, 0.003538773162290454, -0.01012388151139021, -0.02744767628610134, 0.023740533739328384, 0.044660456478595734, -0.005692778155207634, -0.001046390039846301, -0.000392217596527189, 0.008536938577890396, -0.046145785599946976, 0.020473908632993698, -0.05513311177492142, -0.0028832030948251486, 0.05611114576458931, -0.03490067273378372, -0.07088858634233475, -0.06869561970233917, 0.05581198260188103, -0.011971971951425076, 0.058149099349975586, -0.003026652382686734, -0.02243649773299694, 0.018796661868691444, -0.002406075596809387, 0.032024141401052475, -0.03093109466135502, -0.016704684123396873, 0.0615423247218132, 0.024135662242770195, -0.02778865396976471, -0.05530661344528198, -0.0016707415925338864, 0.023378757759928703, 0.007962231524288654, -0.04428389295935631, 0.03488225117325783, -0.04672372713685036, -0.01032597478479147, -0.012061763554811478, -0.022478589788079262, -0.0015068443026393652, -0.03691340982913971, -0.061531271785497665, -0.028240954503417015, -0.009693343192338943, -0.010277033783495426, -0.0026711304672062397, -0.06871568411588669, -0.04582899436354637, 0.04491622745990753, 0.048843469470739365, 0.00966815184801817, -0.019863078370690346, 0.021764740347862244, 0.011655776761472225, 0.031823400408029556, -0.04861200228333473, 0.051616743206977844, -0.05089527741074562, -0.05149153620004654, -0.004169021733105183, 0.0366542786359787, -0.03706127405166626, 0.020305389538407326, 0.0017582748550921679, 0.006631015799939632, 0.004095076583325863, 0.04962872341275215, -0.002169261686503887, -0.045076142996549606, -0.007449482101947069, -0.013341519050300121, -0.06158621609210968, 0.05509686842560768, -0.0008170605869963765, -0.05481957644224167, -0.07222729176282883, -0.04064272344112396, -0.03247403725981712, -0.03943900391459465, -0.02265787310898304, 0.014465909451246262, -0.005679892376065254, -0.005839980207383633, -0.041270751506090164, -0.057636238634586334, 0.048273224383592606, -0.0601901113986969, 0.011519729159772396, 0.03502264246344566, -0.03615180775523186, 0.0038448618724942207, -0.03043161891400814, -0.031247422099113464, -0.011364344507455826, -0.041046179831027985, -0.03678196296095848, -0.03608814626932144, -0.025813495740294456, 0.029190991073846817, 0.02959773689508438, -0.06849607080221176, -0.013891065493226051, -0.004865151830017567, -0.039229970425367355, -0.040892552584409714, -0.06425585597753525, 0.010526511818170547, 0.059441570192575455, -0.02336025796830654, 0.01466752216219902, 0.03530261293053627, 0.014971665106713772, 0.018626630306243896, -0.0313669815659523, -0.016085315495729446, 0.0452902615070343, -0.08806758373975754, 0.015190930105745792, -0.034650422632694244, 0.03117605857551098, 0.012214061804115772, 0.030443420633673668, -0.040337078273296356, -0.05239177495241165, -0.0116192065179348, 0.06176977977156639, 0.032228611409664154, 0.05148593336343765, -0.06733379513025284, -0.01632646471261978, -0.023253662511706352, -0.05388598516583443, -0.04504617303609848, -0.056718818843364716, -0.011391904205083847, 0.02878873236477375, -0.01164184883236885, 0.04481223225593567, -0.02509639598429203, -0.02977219596505165, -0.06161198392510414, -0.02165110595524311, 0.007946766912937164, -0.0587204173207283, -0.04324471950531006, -0.06757622212171555, -0.03754590451717377, 0.04275089502334595, 0.01509157009422779, -0.02039055898785591, 0.00470046978443861, -0.04385494813323021, -0.032157979905605316, -0.03336996212601662, 0.03381169214844704, 0.04181582108139992, -0.04204500466585159, 0.0461612194776535, -0.04903639480471611, 0.07199811935424805, 0.03988942503929138, 0.03389947488903999, -0.04592180252075195, 0.0055202823132276535, -0.02620798908174038, -0.02041533961892128, -0.0557715967297554, -0.016586391255259514, -0.0367417186498642, -0.06088272109627724, 0.018921038135886192, -0.03034254163503647, 0.035457052290439606, -0.03727622330188751, -0.012762325815856457, -0.032632019370794296, -0.03765165060758591, -0.03657608851790428, 0.030387775972485542, 0.04607192799448967, 0.03831567242741585, 0.04140712693333626, 0.02989255264401436, -0.07454588264226913, 0.002006207825616002, -0.05394500494003296, 0.011724499985575676, -0.008124836720526218, -0.03629138693213463, -0.029883619397878647, -0.06891307234764099, 0.00003723962072399445, -0.033000439405441284, -0.03413308411836624, -0.02344663441181183, -0.042077939957380295, -0.027070842683315277, -0.0044316696003079414, 0.016464963555336, -0.057939574122428894, -0.04872164502739906, -0.051787275820970535, 0.02176227979362011, -0.004005403257906437, -0.008810102008283138, -0.0016973282909020782, -0.04414290562272072, 0.02092118375003338, 0.018242040649056435, 0.05099106207489967, -0.03787977993488312, 0.01694273203611374, -0.06082902103662491, -0.0024175886064767838, 0.008229570463299751, 0.010742751881480217, 0.009707650169730186, -0.008146107196807861, 0.0028689689934253693, 0.018350712954998016, 0.02645844966173172, 0.043251883238554, 0.04917360097169876, 0.023755231872200966, -0.07034763693809509, -0.043093353509902954, 0.04055895656347275, 0.05762198567390442, -0.0035410369746387005, -0.01726011373102665, 0.007531434763222933, -0.012829244136810303, 0.002459408715367317, -0.02415880747139454, 0.06775431334972382, 0.043526194989681244, 0.02806682512164116, -0.019726647064089775, -0.047532908618450165, 0.004139366094022989, -0.03403177484869957, 0.054902348667383194, -0.025988789275288582, -0.011999608017504215, 0.011933576315641403, -0.06510840356349945, 0.03839857131242752, 0.029426665976643562, 0.028792696073651314, -0.010023199021816254, -0.018478063866496086, 0.018869414925575256, 0.0020533413626253605, 0.022598037496209145, 0.048667989671230316, 0.030126774683594704, 0.001505002030171454, 0.06869463622570038, -0.024248363450169563, -0.019063064828515053, -0.021576235070824623, -0.07199222594499588, -0.060722485184669495, -0.011916663497686386, 0.01534879207611084, 0.029905090108513832, 0.026916291564702988, -0.0513225756585598, 0.026170780882239342, -0.04976886510848999, 0.027006441727280617, 0.015352601185441017, -0.0551908016204834, 0.02513354830443859, -0.05388356000185013, 0.02078409120440483, -0.0028266736771911383, 0.0029234217945486307, -0.0007584923878312111, -0.05977483093738556, 0.005299761425703764, -0.06661760061979294, 0.03112189657986164, 0.019273776561021805, -0.03328462317585945, -0.0003260730882175267, -0.017874784767627716, 0.028622068464756012, 0.013530812226235867, -0.0032763974741101265, 0.007100782357156277, -0.043561555445194244, -0.004854138940572739, 0.00884312018752098, -0.01298010814934969, -0.044403206557035446, 0.004775846842676401, -0.03807282820343971, -0.05543321371078491, 0.022518998011946678, -0.00985744409263134, -0.04151400923728943, 0.008573251776397228, -0.07426770031452179, -0.022947348654270172, -0.0397750549018383, 0.0366765521466732, -0.05149354413151741, -0.05622098222374916, 0.0693744644522667, -0.0486220121383667, 0.03627995774149895, -0.03239704295992851, -0.034305378794670105, -0.01207877416163683, -0.039956361055374146, 0.0030461237765848637, -0.029502438381314278, 0.04722382500767708, -0.05689499154686928, 0.04584839195013046, -0.030033301562070847, -0.007144990377128124, -0.06384948641061783, 0.03298330679535866, -0.023361457511782646, 0.03066176362335682, 0.022483550012111664, 0.021662214770913124, 0.002509268233552575, 0.0003330552426632494, -0.03567375987768173, 0.05571871995925903, -0.004736142233014107, 0.015272160992026329, -0.039239365607500076, 0.025717830285429955, -0.024201059713959694, -0.03032088465988636, -0.029369542375206947, -0.006285793613642454, 0.04405352845788002, -0.0377766415476799, -0.027766048908233643, 0.022837096825242043, 0.032466594129800797, 0.006758354138582945, -0.05944349616765976, -0.04068933427333832, -0.017553796991705894, -0.06536005437374115, -0.010644232854247093, 0.009444809518754482, -0.019836194813251495, -0.001522052800282836, 0.012044518254697323, 0.011837873607873917, 0.05628122389316559, -0.010206780396401882, 0.025350144132971764, -0.00027058093110099435, -0.01080591045320034, -0.010370658710598946, -0.016576940193772316, -0.0732598826289177, 0.0201344545930624, 0.02793470025062561, -0.005248136818408966, -0.023755274713039398, 0.04828096553683281, -0.005148831754922867, 0.005548066459596157, -0.07367271184921265, 0.05035475268959999, 0.06213056668639183, -0.039660003036260605, 0.013231420889496803, -0.021273275837302208, -0.012773610651493073, -0.00407629506662488, -0.02562941424548626, -0.010513337329030037, 0.025602905079722404, -0.04025397449731827, -0.029506860300898552, 0.01868591643869877, -0.03907746821641922, 0.019397234544157982, 0.018038012087345123, -0.008235097862780094, -0.0674770399928093, -0.0039251092821359634, -0.021970555186271667, -0.01915772818028927, -0.04153398796916008, 0.036346692591905594, 0.06047508865594864, -0.020387712866067886, -0.04058082029223442, 0.006465401034802198, 0.02110680192708969, 0.02425176464021206, -0.000429541221819818, -0.019698064774274826, 0.026376424357295036, -0.013013086281716824, 0.016634194180369377, -0.003335260786116123, 0.043612249195575714, -0.005853844340890646, 0.04904820770025253, 0.029974333941936493, -0.04560721665620804, -0.04260488972067833, -0.020001761615276337, -0.026075055822730064, 0.0012217086041346192, 0.002921111648902297, 0.044574279338121414, 0.05688322335481644, 0.037971459329128265, 0.0031160840298980474, -0.06031687557697296, -0.045287515968084335, 0.0020502563565969467, 0.02431674487888813, -0.049922019243240356, -0.012210838496685028, -0.02614768221974373, 0.05742838233709335, -0.046525657176971436, 0.003843387123197317, 0.008444730192422867, -0.031072814017534256, -0.04031694307923317, -0.025966763496398926, 0.021075408905744553, -0.048107538372278214, -0.06339149922132492, -0.04303468018770218, 0.06655889004468918, -0.006948618683964014, 0.03269389644265175, 0.023861093446612358, 0.06297195702791214, 0.03555776923894882, -0.0056322128511965275, -0.01316353864967823, -0.04295260086655617, 0.04317748174071312, 0.07561370730400085, -0.05435686185956001, -0.020876646041870117, -0.028324836865067482, -0.039430830627679825, 0.0020217562559992075, -0.04271635413169861, -0.020905831828713417, -0.012421051040291786, -0.03475020080804825, -0.07006281614303589, 0.040008656680583954, -0.002604871988296509, -0.06430070847272873, -0.018908202648162842, -0.01267167367041111, -0.07643555104732513, -0.01775016263127327, 0.01896149106323719, -0.02963804081082344, 0.0035982225090265274, 0.047854647040367126, 0.0004837563610635698, -0.034518033266067505, -0.059913519769907, 0.03144592046737671, 0.04725474491715431, -0.031931113451719284, 0.006970187649130821, 0.0027281702496111393, -0.03889063745737076, -0.015849879011511803, -0.03690167888998985, 0.009836644865572453, 0.025407282635569572, 0.055480923503637314, 0.03365393728017807, -0.05194037780165672, -0.015134850516915321, -0.006435474380850792, -0.04543323069810867, 0.009251539595425129, -0.03196388855576515, 0.03952569141983986, 0.03386663645505905, -0.032791584730148315, -0.054749611765146255, -0.010226868093013763, -0.05166465416550636, -0.0010011506965383887, -0.04025314375758171, 0.011255927383899689, 0.013265570625662804, 0.07550785690546036, 0.001008274033665657, -0.03303426131606102, -0.018384456634521484, -0.00734121585264802, -0.04071512818336487, 0.05148503556847572, -0.06846144050359726, -0.021978525444865227, -0.026593979448080063, -0.04281633347272873, -0.005261136684566736, 0.028924688696861267, -0.05366361886262894, 0.03418445959687233, -0.013108210638165474, 0.017024246975779533, -0.03055187501013279, 0.028540924191474915, 0.023422034457325935, 0.004598604049533606, 0.01784384809434414, 0.026856234297156334, -0.043940894305706024, -0.0131000354886055, -0.0650622546672821, 0.0024797185324132442, 0.004796198103576899, -0.005636539775878191, -0.043733205646276474, 0.006458509713411331, -0.047731611877679825, -0.052874188870191574, 0.046748656779527664, -0.0340941920876503, -0.049257103353738785, 0.005135206505656242, -0.00824823696166277, -0.013020127080380917, -0.018450723960995674, 0.01635628007352352, 0.039504144340753555, -0.002539502689614892, 0.03203032910823822, 0.0066281529143452644, 0.030977079644799232, -0.02965261973440647, -0.06965169310569763, -0.0689462423324585, 0.013045080937445164, -0.0010457454482093453, -0.022712556645274162, -0.032331280410289764, -0.021499013528227806, -0.0815824493765831, 0.0003006152401212603, 0.033779576420784, -0.018985342234373093, -0.012192453257739544, -0.0168677419424057, -0.0008298975881189108, 0.010523805394768715, -0.04241391643881798, -0.07672380656003952, -0.027947621420025826, -0.015520595014095306, 0.0013933691661804914, -0.015112148597836494, -0.04051551967859268, -0.047540083527565, 0.030634116381406784, -0.0818810984492302, -0.05596483498811722, -0.024538492783904076, 0.04214363545179367, 0.04320315644145012, -0.01602834463119507, 0.010503818280994892, -0.02999868430197239, 0.0075776721350848675, 0.016236718744039536, -0.0018173397984355688, 0.008994754403829575, 0.01714840903878212, 0.02611592598259449, -0.017639856785535812, -0.06352918595075607, -0.0062772734090685844, 0.008376502431929111, 0.0039888108149170876, 0.03426021337509155, 0.03681857883930206, -0.034825894981622696, -0.03917871415615082, 0.05296029895544052, 0.008274844847619534, 0.026685485616326332, -0.03298643231391907, 0.007065461482852697, -0.05744769051671028, -0.06420400738716125, 0.025711391121149063, -0.04561786353588104, 0.012786044739186764, 0.005114451982080936, -0.03924129158258438, 0.02625597082078457, -0.062039513140916824, -0.0536593422293663, 0.04544668644666672, 0.03756824880838394, 0.004331365693360567, 0.07181800901889801, -0.038935236632823944, 0.014461602084338665, 0.016769057139754295, 0.000241675297729671, -0.03570729121565819, 0.030970513820648193, 0.009207403287291527, -0.017420319840312004, 0.05152416229248047, -0.04135400056838989, 0.017883019521832466, 0.013278454542160034, -0.02417667582631111, -0.047205377370119095, 0.07705213874578476, -0.022215284407138824, -0.011934501118957996, -0.06409501284360886, -0.04252626374363899, -0.01865813322365284, -0.04365846514701843, 0.018682461231946945, -0.0502021498978138, 0.004939165897667408, -0.006617574021220207, 0.046005479991436005, -0.025682911276817322, 0.06683916598558426, 0.050933659076690674, 0.031734105199575424, 0.02691657468676567, 0.042671382427215576, -0.06090160086750984, 0.040986280888319016, -0.025126313790678978, -0.022404886782169342, -0.04554840549826622, 0.02373722568154335, 0.037097785621881485, -0.013968090526759624, 0.016035549342632294, 0.0070779877714812756, -0.045774463564157486, -0.027731891721487045, -0.05773638188838959, 0.01254392322152853, -0.0067659481428563595, -0.05987296253442764, 0.021038902923464775, -0.02209475450217724, -0.06609999388456345, -0.06742417812347412 ]
We present PyRPL, an open source software package that allows the implementation of automatic digital feedback controllers for quantum optics experiments on commercially available, affordable FPGA boards. Our software implements the digital generation of various types of error signals, from an analog input through the application of loop filters of high complexity and real-time gain adjustment for multiple analog output signals, including different algorithms for resonance search, lock acquisition sequences and in-loop gain optimization. Furthermore, all necessary diagnostic instruments such as an oscilloscope, a network analyzer and a spectrum analyzer are integrated into our software. Apart from providing a quickly scalable, automatic feedback controller, the lock performance that can be achieved by using PyRPL with imperfect equipment such as piezoelectric transducers and noisy amplifiers is better than the one achievable with standard analog controllers due to the higher complexity of implementable filters and possibilities of nonlinear operations in the FPGA. This drastically reduces the cost of added complexity when introducing additional feedback loops to an experiment. The open-source character also distinguishes PyRPL from commercial solutions, as it allows users to customize functionalities at various levels, ranging from the easy integration of PyRPL-based feedback controllers into existing setups to the modification of the FPGA functionality. A community of developers provides fast and efficient implementation and testing of software modifications.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00086v1
[ -0.02325986512005329, -0.005836441181600094, 0.038892172276973724, 0.00859974604099989, 0.021094368770718575, 0.03325798362493515, -0.014799131080508232, -0.029755592346191406, -0.009490838274359703, -0.034143075346946716, -0.034996770322322845, 0.02282644249498844, -0.06044846773147583, -0.08429466187953949, -0.04462594911456108, 0.027533195912837982, 0.07167419791221619, 0.013630764558911324, -0.023651007562875748, 0.04482463002204895, 0.04481061175465584, -0.02843763306736946, -0.01816439814865589, 0.02859373949468136, -0.004144608974456787, 0.0030725966207683086, 0.01489811111241579, -0.03477593511343002, -0.05007443204522133, -0.04690048098564148, 0.04678972810506821, 0.0013218524400144815, -0.05478333309292793, -0.033760711550712585, -0.03658836707472801, -0.02398805506527424, -0.03372188284993172, 0.0244680717587471, 0.046504415571689606, -0.016636807471513748, 0.03748498857021332, -0.015857698395848274, -0.04025169461965561, -0.0010470697889104486, -0.011195776984095573, -0.02219543606042862, -0.061811238527297974, 0.021177474409341812, 0.0014271448599174619, -0.021367987617850304, -0.009939788840711117, 0.003801963524892926, 0.013249577023088932, 0.03588811680674553, -0.06554602831602097, 0.004726987797766924, 0.024842089042067528, 0.03698551654815674, -0.023572755977511406, -0.00881668459624052, 0.0038329570088535547, 0.03581508249044418, -0.033681947737932205, 0.02146807871758938, -0.03476729989051819, 0.0810767263174057, -0.01823553256690502, -0.052632082253694534, -0.011268728412687778, -0.023863453418016434, -0.02827824465930462, -0.05189944803714752, -0.045553889125585556, 0.00693095475435257, -0.045508574694395065, -0.02827562391757965, 0.02174113690853119, -0.022554336115717888, -0.001446075621061027, -0.02284451201558113, -0.02676256187260151, -0.0195629745721817, 0.00003381839269422926, 0.05749722197651863, -0.01861697807908058, 0.011870691552758217, 0.009225447662174702, 0.018930751830339432, -0.016699109226465225, 0.0027117629069834948, 0.040943749248981476, -0.019172893837094307, -0.06771518290042877, 0.05221939459443092, 0.0777597725391388, 0.0025509819388389587, 0.019095025956630707, 0.0006268750876188278, 0.030550794675946236, 0.025571534410119057, -0.0496392585337162, 0.03901524841785431, -0.0479188971221447, 0.04160528630018234, 0.030753670260310173, -0.023457201197743416, 0.0026717849541455507, -0.021923786029219627, -0.06816144287586212, -0.00821311492472887, -0.023542167618870735, -0.05920526012778282, 0.006115891505032778, -0.060940489172935486, -0.043563541024923325, -0.001053282874636352, 0.07460599392652512, 0.0015874991659075022, 0.03527633473277092, 0.005428621079772711, -0.003041216405108571, 0.01745733618736267, 0.05983935669064522, 0.0026856185868382454, -0.05600307136774063, -0.0024422346614301205, 0.07074539363384247, -0.014503199607133865, 0.0029672516975551844, -0.023070169612765312, 0.011284427717328072, 0.030054865404963493, -0.0000440519506810233, -0.018094366416335106, 0.058933842927217484, -0.003982537891715765, -0.02266894280910492, -0.014745309017598629, 0.017590614035725594, -0.020847806707024574, -0.011974957771599293, -0.024046363309025764, 0.02213912084698677, -0.00889545027166605, 0.03577490895986557, 0.03696422278881073, -0.06705416738986969, -0.016594067215919495, 0.014343921095132828, 0.004883087705820799, -0.03432278707623482, -0.018896862864494324, 0.0064121088944375515, -0.014278130605816841, 0.04626377671957016, 0.05164559185504913, 0.06383287161588669, -0.06960497796535492, 0.019879072904586792, 0.021575096994638443, 0.01788508892059326, 0.03942042589187622, -0.01796465553343296, 0.03938392177224159, 0.012924033217132092, 0.040169939398765564, 0.020859474316239357, 0.01553207915276289, -0.010910364799201488, -0.0002846263814717531, -0.07206997275352478, -0.003341490402817726, 0.007452168967574835, -0.04653748497366905, -0.038613226264715195, 0.0006638775812461972, 0.02283351868391037, -0.03746500983834267, -0.04294093698263168, -0.00459309620782733, 0.03982315585017204, 0.02159290947020054, -0.03867286816239357, 0.01532067358493805, -0.06906954199075699, 0.02068309299647808, -0.08391688764095306, -0.01784481108188629, 0.05514519289135933, 0.04383943974971771, -0.05882770195603371, -0.021752728149294853, 0.028097568079829216, 0.01622624881565571, -0.021361254155635834, 0.029026838019490242, -0.061866387724876404, -0.02797122672200203, -0.003474719589576125, 0.06428328156471252, -0.07640564441680908, -0.02954569086432457, -0.07704334706068039, 0.0010725914034992456, 0.004770905710756779, -0.05925422161817551, 0.0032875442411750555, 0.0014870301820337772, -0.0507010854780674, 0.040921397507190704, 0.03333129733800888, 0.023108404129743576, 0.08281796425580978, 0.0257209911942482, 0.03795870020985603, -0.006696947850286961, -0.10135530680418015, 0.037072908133268356, -0.007349369581788778, 0.005461385473608971, 0.0008136601536534727, -0.02403876557946205, 0.02253967709839344, 0.004344729706645012, -0.004399594850838184, 0.05185135081410408, 0.02907542884349823, -0.042281731963157654, -0.06285756826400757, -0.013395742513239384, 0.024398043751716614, -0.05080196633934975, -0.04090235009789467, -0.08221204578876495, -0.03932763636112213, 0.024869799613952637, 0.015296214260160923, 0.032955270260572433, -0.015604943037033081, 0.007121109403669834, -0.060753095895051956, -0.03911937028169632, 0.06704410165548325, -0.022990113124251366, -0.022879593074321747, -0.034444987773895264, -0.0024928548373281956, 0.04361826926469803, -0.05587446689605713, 0.016296830028295517, -0.023565761744976044, 0.03271038457751274, -0.011028698645532131, -0.04056299105286598, -0.008695455268025398, 0.05097290873527527, -0.03262736648321152, 0.045754559338092804, 0.04200104624032974, 0.059271439909935, 0.009351889602839947, 0.026396973058581352, -0.05035201460123062, 0.025403672829270363, 0.028841648250818253, -0.011139760725200176, -0.010507646948099136, 0.04552893340587616, 0.029476279392838478, -0.027539310976862907, -0.044776320457458496, 0.06328297406435013, 0.025334149599075317, -0.027728112414479256, -0.013070265762507915, 0.02486056089401245, 0.0008525556186214089, 0.01066141203045845, 0.04520258679986, 0.08239005506038666, 0.037663694471120834, 0.019263211637735367, 0.039265524595975876, -0.06477532535791397, -0.017161112278699875, -0.016692033037543297, 0.013961587101221085, -0.02302335947751999, -0.028934646397829056, -0.04274839535355568, -0.06381864100694656, -0.008725395426154137, -0.0291668139398098, 0.007088376209139824, 0.011159614659845829, -0.03635692968964577, -0.002576155122369528, -0.05431292951107025, 0.048254575580358505, -0.003823372069746256, -0.0894378200173378, -0.07052361220121384, 0.043284788727760315, -0.01010197028517723, -0.010988919995725155, -0.051377348601818085, -0.03099306859076023, 0.02135477028787136, 0.04085666313767433, 0.04944869503378868, 0.016249464824795723, 0.04751428961753845, -0.0193548072129488, 0.00884956680238247, -0.02724597044289112, -0.028293222188949585, 0.044320352375507355, 0.027318935841321945, -0.035083185881376266, -0.01503404788672924, 0.03159554675221443, -0.019336622208356857, 0.005788249429315329, -0.02778668887913227, -0.031547077000141144, 0.009067561477422714, 0.050764601677656174, 0.01446140930056572, -0.03534286096692085, -0.03087763488292694, -0.012444688938558102, 0.00826447643339634, 0.050493862479925156, 0.02139361761510372, -0.007404646836221218, 0.020565727725625038, -0.006304445676505566, -0.04008756950497627, -0.0021076404955238104, -0.026502899825572968, 0.013439941219985485, 0.04286672919988632, -0.0021402558777481318, -0.016071626916527748, 0.03810631483793259, -0.08462381362915039, -0.004456662572920322, 0.04602435231208801, 0.032442089170217514, -0.0213253665715456, -0.033901628106832504, 0.006678546313196421, 0.041686687618494034, 0.020942749455571175, -0.02228892408311367, 0.049179550260305405, 0.016231412068009377, 0.019132422283291817, -0.01094498485326767, -0.04526055231690407, -0.0024391687475144863, -0.05018223077058792, -0.05523663014173508, 0.0011344952508807182, 0.0005785140092484653, 0.015818746760487556, 0.02311006747186184, -0.025915954262018204, -0.0024221648927778006, 0.0035002317745238543, 0.06566616892814636, 0.030915692448616028, -0.008081885986030102, 0.035417430102825165, -0.0279840100556612, 0.048406150192022324, -0.0054805525578558445, 0.004128961358219385, 0.013875636272132397, -0.0643114224076271, 0.0286866407841444, -0.06372431665658951, 0.01925462856888771, 0.035334594547748566, -0.007649261504411697, 0.02258201502263546, 0.02652439847588539, 0.004933218006044626, 0.05403628945350647, 0.025339500978589058, -0.010248787701129913, 0.043540745973587036, 0.010418366640806198, -0.037967707961797714, -0.03957664594054222, -0.030407175421714783, 0.00579372001811862, 0.012069608084857464, -0.011283200234174728, -0.0019376332638785243, -0.009515553712844849, -0.008497512899339199, 0.0037995942402631044, -0.07393921911716461, -0.004291747696697712, -0.06969093531370163, 0.05269080027937889, -0.0021925736218690872, -0.020245075225830078, 0.030830545350909233, -0.05480332300066948, 0.040728747844696045, -0.011633464135229588, -0.021855268627405167, -0.025449542328715324, -0.042680345475673676, 0.019543645903468132, -0.06758672744035721, -0.010278615169227123, -0.01826423965394497, 0.06408505141735077, 0.0073309908621013165, 0.009484498761594296, -0.041274264454841614, -0.04246300831437111, -0.027690464630723, 0.047159191220998764, 0.05562647432088852, 0.036291930824518204, -0.012074572965502739, -0.02082439884543419, -0.02162087894976139, 0.05987992137670517, 0.04128177464008331, -0.0005337352049537003, -0.07747455686330795, 0.0579087920486927, -0.04673899710178375, 0.006685677450150251, 0.01636316254734993, 0.0009308607550337911, 0.0426858551800251, -0.04881357401609421, -0.051453202962875366, 0.019886808469891548, 0.011021587997674942, -0.06036755070090294, -0.04991909861564636, -0.038094330579042435, -0.010945558547973633, -0.06156531348824501, -0.011254462413489819, 0.050250887870788574, -0.026319846510887146, -0.015788773074746132, 0.00564005458727479, 0.030950160697102547, 0.012115963734686375, -0.03543956205248833, -0.008342664688825607, 0.040110424160957336, -0.04614470899105072, 0.017370933666825294, -0.04263496398925781, -0.05731719732284546, 0.024523943662643433, -0.0634007602930069, -0.023503582924604416, -0.025905346497893333, 0.0063253650441765785, 0.05830007046461105, -0.002723580226302147, -0.08910452574491501, -0.02460021711885929, 0.08239629864692688, -0.045940645039081573, 0.014084645546972752, 0.0667693093419075, 0.0013371676905080676, 0.04842414706945419, -0.0439995601773262, -0.012768402695655823, 0.01064858864992857, -0.034383226186037064, 0.015688899904489517, -0.02811703458428383, -0.03648129105567932, 0.02511422522366047, 0.026139089837670326, -0.0016522251535207033, -0.04536928981542587, 0.0283584576100111, 0.0363970585167408, 0.0200190469622612, -0.045225393027067184, 0.04420102387666702, 0.0315975546836853, -0.05306526646018028, -0.05835702270269394, -0.026872381567955017, -0.031189214438199997, -0.015221014618873596, 0.05892012268304825, -0.027837999165058136, -0.04300105944275856, -0.005476158112287521, 0.010012253187596798, -0.040759582072496414, 0.02145836129784584, 0.026204844936728477, -0.01856943778693676, -0.022495677694678307, -0.021215518936514854, -0.045907072722911835, 0.02646489255130291, -0.051004402339458466, 0.03072640672326088, 0.024444270879030228, 0.011472206562757492, 0.033616434782743454, -0.02127973549067974, 0.02003074251115322, -0.00818725023418665, -0.0031305127777159214, -0.04061000049114227, 0.017253587022423744, -0.03634722903370857, 0.009640050120651722, 0.004757474642246962, 0.045965783298015594, 0.012317951768636703, 0.00032506059505976737, 0.02381114289164543, -0.006452617235481739, -0.00548670394346118, 0.015132445842027664, 0.022411592304706573, -0.0495130717754364, -0.04161559417843819, 0.01667005941271782, 0.011522646062076092, -0.017501350492239, 0.07583718001842499, 0.03170432895421982, 0.017141694203019142, 0.01575937494635582, 0.023510854691267014, -0.026347683742642403, -0.010808774270117283, 0.06008513271808624, 0.055301446467638016, -0.043744053691625595, 0.005060364957898855, -0.063801608979702, -0.05621170997619629, 0.0285030510276556, -0.04455360397696495, 0.024160340428352356, 0.02537688799202442, 0.017364418134093285, -0.05623909458518028, 0.017638247460126877, 0.01100899837911129, -0.06043960154056549, 0.014821354299783707, 0.020674023777246475, -0.05553145334124565, -0.018392011523246765, 0.060520149767398834, -0.009452254511415958, -0.041949864476919174, 0.04512825608253479, 0.04313039407134056, -0.03271030634641647, -0.026759503409266472, 0.07002589106559753, 0.05065611004829407, -0.05659029260277748, 0.040088947862386703, 0.04061621055006981, 0.005949418060481548, 0.056409697979688644, -0.02934509702026844, 0.0014363857917487621, -0.01379955094307661, 0.003258075099438429, 0.015893209725618362, -0.0411805585026741, 0.011190326884388924, 0.032295189797878265, -0.038628093898296356, 0.017845116555690765, 0.027208229526877403, 0.017512330785393715, 0.0453556589782238, -0.06038317456841469, -0.03118746541440487, 0.0031185385305434465, -0.04307921975851059, 0.004378791898488998, -0.03651851788163185, -0.017372651025652885, 0.02163677290081978, 0.03313468024134636, -0.001819999422878027, -0.028523758053779602, -0.0026531170587986708, -0.05230298638343811, -0.07065454125404358, 0.0012195167364552617, -0.06345588713884354, -0.05041024833917618, 0.03694204241037369, -0.0413195975124836, 0.04512306675314903, 0.05986905097961426, -0.008175179362297058, -0.030231839045882225, 0.014241505414247513, -0.007284466177225113, 0.028542477637529373, 0.009650912135839462, 0.010438630357384682, -0.05068299174308777, 0.023516036570072174, -0.02429264411330223, -0.03902909904718399, 0.04659426957368851, -0.05898405238986015, 0.031838204711675644, -0.019698966294527054, -0.04291963577270508, -0.030581055209040642, -0.00024412632046733052, -0.018383515998721123, 0.009343933314085007, -0.011888659559190273, -0.032371845096349716, -0.07137098908424377, -0.011351445689797401, -0.010347905568778515, 0.05744120478630066, -0.012922228313982487, 0.06697279959917068, 0.03614916652441025, -0.043136756867170334, 0.05675554648041725, 0.01803317479789257, 0.037218011915683746, 0.06416376680135727, -0.03437865898013115, -0.03345012664794922, 0.05837147310376167, -0.04034782946109772, -0.028828829526901245, -0.047234419733285904, 0.018501775339245796, -0.04514066502451897, 0.02010050043463707, 0.03976413235068321, -0.0013737239642068744, 0.000309205410303548, -0.04517386481165886, 0.006059120409190655, 0.025746025145053864, -0.0727706253528595, 0.006098117679357529, 0.008341211825609207, -0.007772368844598532, -0.0381610244512558, 0.025997962802648544, -0.009038656949996948, -0.03651399910449982, 0.011519779451191425, -0.06664830446243286, -0.0008684069034643471, 0.00024276424665004015, 0.010889582335948944, -0.04145345464348793, -0.055042725056409836, -0.030119122937321663, -0.028310801833868027, -0.01635736972093582, 0.010293724946677685, 0.0017706668004393578, -0.02596862241625786, 0.023469192907214165, -0.038148462772369385, -0.04360700771212578, -0.04441361501812935, 0.06452672928571701, -0.02193310484290123, -0.03387068212032318, 0.03676135465502739, 0.013487077318131924, 0.048678454011678696, -0.037986136972904205, 0.04040232673287392, -0.011010685935616493, 0.03676341846585274, -0.07818364351987839, 0.007349394261837006, -0.06418690085411072, -0.06063368171453476, 0.026595141738653183, -0.05131702870130539, -0.0005319523042999208, 0.025714164599776268, -0.02686920575797558, 0.01410140935331583, 0.0137801393866539, -0.0680258572101593, 0.01721062883734703, 0.01159881055355072, -0.01878012716770172, 0.05813419446349144, -0.03881505876779556, 0.04241078346967697, -0.0014481347752735019, 0.023161474615335464, -0.06823302060365677, 0.025448715314269066, 0.04531027376651764, -0.030396059155464172, 0.017799153923988342, -0.0366935096681118, 0.04301290959119797, 0.012614043429493904, -0.009264199063181877, -0.006756646558642387, 0.0755404680967331, -0.004096243996173143, -0.03785642609000206, -0.016493672505021095, -0.0071883425116539, -0.04922805353999138, -0.07452275604009628, -0.04690775275230408, -0.01926673948764801, 0.02009047381579876, -0.008411718532443047, -0.028734641149640083, -0.03349379077553749, 0.0006286274874582887, 0.0256548672914505, -0.024967925623059273, -0.02860281988978386, 0.04908835515379906, -0.056177061051130295, 0.06004573404788971, -0.03903454542160034, 0.02251524291932583, -0.043046724051237106, 0.0009674911852926016, -0.0020190526265650988, 0.056316349655389786, -0.0403665155172348, 0.0002550560748204589, 0.028571324422955513, -0.033953480422496796, -0.012223088182508945, 0.02309498004615307, 0.008363010361790657, -0.040610309690237045, -0.05222070589661598, 0.010497708804905415, -0.00245349551551044, -0.05663541331887245 ]
The reduction of phase noise in electronic systems is of utmost importance in modern communication and signal processing applications and requires an understanding of the underlying physical processes. Here, we systematically study the phase noise in mutually synchronized chains of nano-constriction spin Hall nano-oscillators (SHNOs). We find that longer chains have improved phase noise figures at low offset frequencies (1/f noise), where chains of two and ten mutually synchronized SHNOs have 2.8 and 6.2 dB lower phase noise than single SHNOs. This is close to the theoretical values of 3 and 10 dB, and the deviation is ascribed to process variations between nano-constrictions. However, at higher offset frequencies (thermal noise), the phase noise unexpectedly increases with chain length, which we ascribe to process variations, a higher operating temperature in the long chains at the same drive current and phase delays in the coupling between nano-constrictions.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18097v1
[ -0.05623612180352211, -0.01145912241190672, 0.011316195130348206, -0.014852126128971577, 0.02445952594280243, -0.057653579860925674, -0.0400504507124424, 0.04531075060367584, -0.006376593839377165, 0.011929391883313656, 0.00930387619882822, -0.02109573222696781, -0.04974371939897537, -0.04128684848546982, -0.04915423318743706, 0.051842641085386276, 0.06215206906199455, 0.026878120377659798, -0.020680516958236694, 0.07350601255893707, 0.02831602655351162, -0.010199440643191338, 0.01063720416277647, -0.0089702308177948, -0.04138015955686569, -0.012437497265636921, -0.045123934745788574, 0.046936314553022385, -0.030324673280119896, -0.028347443789243698, 0.05226817727088928, -0.058886513113975525, -0.03559482842683792, -0.04372192546725273, -0.01415954064577818, -0.043043818324804306, -0.019708285108208656, 0.04771963879466057, 0.035662416368722916, -0.04579963907599449, -0.009618387557566166, -0.06917901337146759, -0.03594628721475601, -0.0012712724274024367, -0.029549943283200264, -0.009283830411732197, -0.004157462157309055, -0.02892492711544037, -0.02370896190404892, -0.033792492002248764, 0.042668793350458145, 0.006794772110879421, 0.01375535223633051, 0.052021294832229614, -0.00953244511038065, -0.009576700627803802, -0.04600020870566368, -0.01051353756338358, -0.027866113930940628, -0.03374967724084854, -0.02000531367957592, -0.04616948962211609, -0.008858720771968365, -0.05125096067786217, -0.04430046305060387, 0.06661976128816605, -0.004188963677734137, -0.06973528116941452, -0.0432252436876297, -0.05135148763656616, 0.0024958979338407516, -0.056950971484184265, 0.04073834419250488, 0.004028800409287214, -0.03365820273756981, -0.0007718915585428476, 0.011001687496900558, -0.04392705485224724, -0.02300034835934639, 0.015531209297478199, -0.04821931943297386, 0.024482935667037964, 0.00021202475181780756, 0.026669854298233986, 0.031129073351621628, 0.02906571328639984, 0.03163457661867142, -0.05430958792567253, 0.005639060866087675, -0.07232736051082611, 0.0295303612947464, -0.06948678195476532, -0.0640309602022171, -0.010569529607892036, 0.04327048361301422, -0.033588264137506485, 0.055494263768196106, 0.034752096980810165, -0.0010527452686801553, -0.021224448457360268, -0.01778704859316349, -0.0490417517721653, -0.004856235347688198, 0.05420640483498573, 0.0136843491345644, -0.036892347037792206, -0.02197309024631977, -0.04962568357586861, -0.057195089757442474, 0.029469188302755356, 0.001637385576032102, -0.0531565397977829, -0.0186836589127779, -0.06196357682347298, -0.04384781792759895, -0.011995290406048298, 0.06568849086761475, -0.0036441434640437365, -0.023096567019820213, -0.017608163878321648, -0.04857363551855087, 0.06715851277112961, 0.004785072989761829, 0.05109120532870293, -0.0006423439481295645, 0.04917377978563309, 0.06257364153862, 0.012112976051867008, 0.006133754272013903, -0.038365963846445084, -0.013465223833918571, 0.003096806351095438, 0.010238531045615673, -0.009498674422502518, 0.013881540857255459, -0.00900017935782671, 0.02972770668566227, -0.005340647883713245, 0.016439152881503105, 0.03579040616750717, -0.009548243135213852, -0.014610582031309605, 0.012720560654997826, 0.03747794032096863, 0.0394376777112484, 0.012098235078155994, -0.0698230192065239, 0.025042299181222916, 0.061516012996435165, 0.02380925789475441, -0.017225759103894234, -0.00793786533176899, -0.0022160024382174015, -0.043883807957172394, 0.018011687323451042, 0.01708698645234108, 0.055358245968818665, 0.0034800858702510595, 0.007260090205818415, 0.01593402959406376, 0.02383193001151085, -0.03490555286407471, -0.03595690056681633, -0.03172021359205246, 0.014800329692661762, -0.0471251979470253, 0.025288591161370277, -0.02689792960882187, 0.009599071927368641, 0.025455940514802933, -0.034792277961969376, -0.006401428487151861, 0.04739458113908768, -0.05460376292467117, -0.04304877668619156, -0.041802871972322464, 0.03419124707579613, -0.03442351520061493, -0.009501872584223747, -0.047881316393613815, 0.032557740807533264, 0.041186459362506866, -0.013313813135027885, -0.032068997621536255, -0.06586426496505737, -0.022281872108578682, -0.07526407390832901, 0.04919635131955147, 0.06684751063585281, 0.001990395598113537, -0.0018965975614264607, -0.02283213846385479, 0.034180883318185806, -0.00426742946729064, 0.006788361817598343, -0.047227565199136734, -0.01885133981704712, -0.03793862834572792, -0.02045590803027153, 0.049225009977817535, -0.06895498186349869, -0.047073688358068466, -0.042162515223026276, 0.0037459342274814844, 0.023341570049524307, -0.016683287918567657, 0.03789472579956055, -0.01668604463338852, -0.05695197731256485, 0.024948228150606155, 0.06283683329820633, 0.021788500249385834, 0.01750924065709114, 0.019323304295539856, 0.011726189404726028, -0.04893023148179054, -0.0796952173113823, 0.03494134545326233, 0.017818866297602654, 0.013905194588005543, 0.03201155364513397, 0.0013612712500616908, -0.036676160991191864, -0.010370389558374882, -0.020004699006676674, 0.03141002729535103, 0.0015996868023648858, -0.03864241763949394, -0.05262146145105362, 0.01232084259390831, 0.03272154927253723, -0.07095880806446075, -0.03586909547448158, -0.052315618842840195, -0.016470463946461678, -0.0026012256275862455, -0.05439719185233116, -0.01780896820127964, -0.052056245505809784, -0.039402395486831665, -0.04977182671427727, -0.04576711729168892, 0.041009243577718735, -0.008351251482963562, -0.04985295236110687, -0.0423949770629406, -0.06575998663902283, 0.0476924329996109, -0.044341813772916794, -0.026792533695697784, -0.024693701416254044, -0.03393394872546196, -0.035625141113996506, -0.010040129534900188, -0.020634746178984642, 0.027449751272797585, -0.023928213864564896, 0.023510266095399857, 0.00323078827932477, 0.012008500285446644, -0.04532187059521675, -0.005767820402979851, -0.03968927636742592, 0.04844348877668381, 0.012236550450325012, 0.021187692880630493, -0.03532767668366432, 0.047372590750455856, 0.0024848170578479767, -0.03592073172330856, -0.050089843571186066, 0.0664069876074791, 0.06330786645412445, -0.03767622262239456, 0.040948085486888885, -0.03680127486586571, 0.009191140532493591, -0.010831190273165703, 0.01118228305131197, 0.02018287591636181, 0.005758528597652912, 0.044341783970594406, 0.0016403583576902747, -0.05188902094960213, -0.05053141713142395, -0.054632510989904404, -0.011709360405802727, -0.07067050784826279, -0.01973751373589039, -0.03620108589529991, -0.04441323131322861, 0.0027914198581129313, -0.06443197280168533, 0.022002417594194412, -0.03320310264825821, -0.058968525379896164, -0.0375976525247097, -0.04322904720902443, 0.03742850571870804, -0.0420868806540966, -0.055127307772636414, 0.006652655079960823, 0.05581357330083847, 0.010094776749610901, -0.006941910833120346, -0.00975064653903246, 0.0463489294052124, -0.013376523740589619, 0.01567869819700718, 0.007343592122197151, -0.004584919195622206, -0.0594833679497242, -0.060209281742572784, 0.027648262679576874, 0.001554960268549621, 0.037894781678915024, 0.01954948902130127, -0.05276007205247879, -0.034997615963220596, -0.039540890604257584, 0.013953997753560543, -0.03614060953259468, -0.020741963759064674, -0.011546039953827858, -0.002572892000898719, -0.06412547826766968, 0.07249107211828232, 0.04876766353845596, -0.016938466578722, -0.06516731530427933, -0.030252238735556602, 0.01655007340013981, -0.028372103348374367, 0.019842740148305893, 0.025116685777902603, -0.0009926949860528111, 0.011593635194003582, 0.004840014036744833, -0.06431084126234055, 0.047064393758773804, -0.03657767176628113, -0.016378020867705345, 0.051327984780073166, 0.013541966676712036, -0.016976267099380493, -0.02898264490067959, -0.010329549200832844, 0.049663037061691284, 0.054888829588890076, -0.033571600914001465, -0.018163487315177917, 0.03142949193716049, -0.008056428283452988, 0.03435917943716049, -0.006033376790583134, -0.00226970249786973, 0.020082799717783928, 0.062119752168655396, 0.0076080262660980225, -0.021750574931502342, 0.023959409445524216, -0.06460743397474289, -0.043072670698165894, -0.01367343682795763, -0.06009063869714737, 0.02122872695326805, -0.00270710326731205, -0.036988671869039536, 0.007096847984939814, -0.058252908289432526, 0.041200727224349976, -0.0121220787987113, -0.04146898537874222, -0.011960872448980808, 0.007528488524258137, -0.012124275788664818, -0.04434480145573616, -0.010586696676909924, 0.009391920641064644, -0.058222539722919464, -0.023621732369065285, -0.07073003053665161, 0.030954847112298012, -0.0010689685586839914, -0.01739312894642353, -0.019022246822714806, 0.01858385093510151, -0.040422942489385605, 0.032584916800260544, -0.01843941956758499, 0.027176925912499428, -0.01477187592536211, -0.0626680850982666, -0.013670685701072216, 0.0070647383108735085, 0.014428356662392616, 0.0009443900780752301, 0.0011593436356633902, -0.05432165786623955, 0.03979305922985077, 0.03757600858807564, 0.016510451212525368, 0.009355392307043076, -0.07977624237537384, -0.029497681185603142, -0.04240526258945465, -0.007723349612206221, -0.04956097528338432, -0.03332419693470001, 0.05163206160068512, 0.037253573536872864, -0.044393140822649, -0.026056140661239624, -0.03577275946736336, -0.03259481489658356, -0.0376163013279438, 0.0032538631930947304, -0.0015160158509388566, 0.03176408261060715, -0.022272096946835518, 0.023994602262973785, -0.0038926179986447096, -0.012826317921280861, -0.05253893509507179, -0.02119455114006996, -0.040860965847969055, 0.02671625092625618, 0.022587275132536888, 0.013876660726964474, -0.029315214604139328, 0.018057607114315033, -0.05550389736890793, 0.05746355280280113, -0.030652465298771858, 0.0686323419213295, -0.04768044129014015, 0.02837424725294113, -0.009096027351915836, -0.04742596298456192, -0.012434794567525387, 0.010085048153996468, 0.05537189170718193, -0.036839164793491364, -0.04534436762332916, 0.040380582213401794, -0.02022484317421913, 0.020473837852478027, 0.0019247751915827394, -0.04883632808923721, -0.0583176389336586, -0.06911208480596542, -0.06310487538576126, -0.021412687376141548, -0.008234716951847076, -0.04066475108265877, 0.06177521497011185, 0.044749144464731216, 0.00819452479481697, -0.04575563594698906, 0.004589950665831566, 0.04167861118912697, 0.0194531437009573, -0.008568231016397476, -0.040144167840480804, -0.04414285346865654, 0.014650086872279644, 0.02493244968354702, -0.019431019201874733, -0.018691692501306534, -0.01995554007589817, -0.019659483805298805, 0.008712979964911938, -0.06362202018499374, 0.04449720308184624, 0.04744984209537506, -0.034466151148080826, 0.015078661032021046, 0.05176248028874397, -0.052357032895088196, 0.027767393738031387, -0.046139974147081375, 0.053221963346004486, -0.04207565262913704, -0.005179198924452066, -0.008555599488317966, -0.01227962039411068, -0.0624350942671299, 0.036434024572372437, -0.005169310607016087, 0.009623399935662746, -0.02897140197455883, 0.04491288959980011, 0.05751373991370201, 0.022719616070389748, -0.022198868915438652, -0.005762146785855293, 0.06110962852835655, -0.03461258485913277, -0.0515027679502964, -0.01521364040672779, -0.017670484259724617, 0.016331661492586136, 0.061595406383275986, -0.06855904310941696, -0.04847009479999542, -0.0004190091567579657, -0.0016320239519700408, 0.036496859043836594, 0.048831816762685776, 0.01665632799267769, -0.0543096661567688, 0.010527368634939194, -0.04558391124010086, -0.04914584383368492, -0.06087997928261757, -0.06484062969684601, 0.002007537055760622, -0.027168452739715576, -0.04782622680068016, 0.018050417304039, 0.0031247641891241074, -0.020613260567188263, -0.054343435913324356, -0.024936649948358536, -0.04188322648406029, 0.041914407163858414, -0.036716029047966, 0.01823614537715912, 0.016289889812469482, 0.060165248811244965, 0.013330278918147087, 0.025228453800082207, -0.018109122291207314, -0.008865282870829105, -0.05719083920121193, 0.030536169186234474, 0.026092613115906715, -0.0324067585170269, -0.05720033124089241, -0.011401332914829254, -0.0021635291632264853, -0.05015771836042404, 0.01924653723835945, 0.012865514494478703, 0.04967573657631874, 0.002297750674188137, -0.00851823017001152, -0.04318881779909134, -0.008995000272989273, 0.00190744420979172, 0.06715257465839386, -0.06074713170528412, 0.011964432895183563, -0.04009998217225075, 0.006139913573861122, 0.007795908488333225, -0.004301092121750116, -0.013557009398937225, 0.007013887632638216, -0.05471663177013397, -0.06889106333255768, 0.05801431089639664, 0.017332173883914948, -0.0652671605348587, -0.03108535334467888, 0.023476000875234604, -0.05182943865656853, -0.0022890621330589056, 0.017840709537267685, -0.03390070050954819, -0.06354820728302002, 0.012528575025498867, 0.016577618196606636, -0.06332948058843613, -0.02867589332163334, 0.04111683368682861, -0.0003418566775508225, -0.03310823068022728, -0.05540313571691513, 0.01520590204745531, -0.030251406133174896, -0.0240317452698946, 0.024106863886117935, -0.030802439898252487, -0.022658806294202805, 0.009288294240832329, -0.008314261212944984, -0.007545192260295153, -0.033958014100790024, 0.05918758362531662, -0.052234891802072525, 0.0009417590918019414, -0.007898107171058655, -0.011563207022845745, 0.05047999694943428, -0.022641921415925026, -0.026770956814289093, 0.050798043608665466, -0.04028353467583656, 0.013193923979997635, -0.014993409626185894, -0.03642021492123604, -0.028192443773150444, 0.020327813923358917, 0.052745476365089417, -0.034768182784318924, -0.02698756381869316, 0.009576971642673016, -0.05288812890648842, 0.04039458557963371, -0.04966263473033905, -0.0210882518440485, -0.0043203700333833694, -0.037492331117391586, -0.010587310418486595, 0.03171846270561218, -0.03766188398003578, -0.023561248555779457, -0.03569351136684418, 0.004144062753766775, 0.04934914782643318, -0.01818925514817238, 0.022960005328059196, -0.041167061775922775, 0.022780414670705795, -0.019666990265250206, -0.049308840185403824, 0.025523073971271515, -0.05878733843564987, 0.012140308506786823, -0.016057634726166725, 0.011182616464793682, -0.001554204965941608, -0.012917964719235897, -0.04134685546159744, -0.025702331215143204, 0.04115431755781174, -0.04851498082280159, -0.0192211102694273, -0.024551695212721825, -0.016299985349178314, -0.02126327157020569, -0.024597667157649994, 0.018211640417575836, 0.01778792031109333, -0.042860791087150574, -0.009821660816669464, 0.04694248363375664, -0.004627896472811699, -0.038608331233263016, -0.050697408616542816, -0.032328128814697266, 0.019730906933546066, 0.007868368178606033, -0.0074744136072695255, -0.024692455306649208, -0.028638357296586037, -0.07448182255029678, -0.017803961411118507, 0.038830894976854324, -0.014240914024412632, -0.024484364315867424, -0.048047035932540894, 0.05203862860798836, 0.009558568708598614, -0.02040140889585018, -0.05570267140865326, 0.04457387700676918, 0.020566007122397423, -0.0307714082300663, 0.012395034544169903, 0.012785917147994041, -0.048028163611888885, -0.02938172034919262, -0.07450362294912338, -0.020237531512975693, -0.003634074004366994, 0.057953570038080215, 0.033840276300907135, 0.006922778207808733, -0.030268272385001183, -0.05484404042363167, -0.020179923623800278, -0.0021654050797224045, -0.020237311720848083, 0.0031427706126123667, 0.0248410664498806, 0.020473023876547813, -0.05323807895183563, -0.04320937395095825, 0.05856668949127197, -0.023242540657520294, 0.037589892745018005, 0.015566671267151833, 0.03507908061146736, -0.03405559062957764, 0.053483448922634125, 0.03780257701873779, -0.03771233931183815, 0.031035248190164566, -0.060136158019304276, 0.002695872215554118, -0.020487338304519653, -0.014628643169999123, -0.032626599073410034, -0.06606831401586533, -0.013530906289815903, 0.005131670273840427, -0.03921935334801674, -0.03110671415925026, -0.021921779960393906, -0.03385675698518753, -0.018205879256129265, -0.01674390584230423, 0.019458049908280373, 0.050567466765642166, -0.046709977090358734, -0.015918267890810966, 0.0004399396711960435, 0.02679445594549179, -0.06783728301525116, 0.06400959938764572, 0.026313286274671555, -0.06601699441671371, -0.04799593612551689, -0.058963898569345474, 0.04800838977098465, -0.007406558375805616, -0.022701311856508255, 0.0031141832005232573, 0.032755348831415176, -0.05260990560054779, 0.02564331889152527, -0.044062599539756775, -0.049767304211854935, -0.021094631403684616, -0.05388243496417999, 0.029961125925183296, -0.03972373530268669, 0.020131049677729607, -0.006153135560452938, 0.013380970805883408, 0.013845236971974373, 0.04045061022043228, 0.016682149842381477, 0.028117870911955833, -0.050417471677064896, -0.03745843842625618, -0.030328424647450447, 0.057534538209438324, -0.0014806201215833426, -0.017069445922970772, -0.06148391589522362, 0.04108360409736633, 0.0003520029713399708, 0.014874267391860485, 0.007401062175631523, -0.015689430758357048, -0.02814938873052597, -0.07091555744409561, -0.030099065974354744, -0.009392094798386097, 0.04700961709022522, -0.062477655708789825, -0.025316361337900162, -0.013894546777009964, -0.010832922533154488, -0.05851859971880913 ]
We present a comparative study of the effect of low-temperature opacities on stellar models up to the Red Giant branch (RGB), computed with the GARching STellar Evolution Code. We have used two sets of low-temperature opacities; {\AE}SOPUS ({\AE}) from the University of Padova and those from the Wichita State University group (F05). In the relevant range of temperatures for this study, log \k{appa}{\AE} < log \k{appa}F 05. Therefore, to compare stellar evolutionary tracks, we performed a solar calibration of the {\alpha}mlt, for each set of low-temperature opacities. After carrying such a calibration, we find that stellar evolutionary tracks are almost unaffected by the choice of low-temperature opacities, with largest variations of 25-30 K at the latest evolutionary stages of the RGB phase.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10490v1
[ -0.029350927099585533, -0.019808568060398102, -0.016444813460111618, -0.0025894767604768276, 0.035066280514001846, -0.041481684893369675, -0.022893868386745453, 0.04795350879430771, 0.004642870277166367, -0.03577360883355141, -0.03291644901037216, -0.05826197564601898, -0.03641868010163307, -0.05386986583471298, -0.06942492723464966, 0.06264954060316086, 0.030033579096198082, 0.025159329175949097, -0.03051380254328251, 0.08565504848957062, 0.024448717013001442, -0.009571640752255917, -0.02323773503303528, -0.008956237696111202, 0.0017998506082221866, -0.02070898562669754, 0.024955859407782555, 0.006714928429573774, -0.032240334898233414, -0.040406495332717896, 0.02327210269868374, -0.016505520790815353, -0.012243705801665783, -0.027335496619343758, 0.002056937664747238, -0.03357638418674469, 0.011190399527549744, 0.0675644725561142, 0.028122810646891594, -0.025330498814582825, 0.0116723058745265, -0.05223892256617546, -0.016073817387223244, -0.02089053764939308, -0.016641855239868164, 0.0011783827794715762, -0.019048580899834633, 0.012546093203127384, -0.03215162828564644, -0.05217321962118149, 0.022755641490221024, 0.012082495726644993, -0.029037995263934135, 0.04976816475391388, -0.05791110172867775, -0.008826371282339096, -0.013432784005999565, -0.008371250703930855, -0.028508363291621208, 0.012362951412796974, 0.02341308444738388, -0.02765723317861557, 0.026967238634824753, -0.015388988889753819, -0.05369027331471443, 0.03133055567741394, -0.05181059241294861, -0.054406218230724335, 0.011478878557682037, -0.06298371404409409, 0.008265230804681778, -0.07387981563806534, -0.016185589134693146, 0.05285964906215668, -0.07191802561283112, -0.011837768368422985, -0.032601676881313324, -0.005934880580753088, -0.011589019559323788, -0.0002882812113966793, -0.028926027938723564, -0.03719137981534004, -0.00514356279745698, 0.05671960487961769, 0.0272377859801054, 0.02785460278391838, 0.003345977049320936, -0.02709929272532463, -0.012353836558759212, -0.050170186907052994, 0.036004893481731415, -0.05847679823637009, -0.03474213555455208, -0.01960637979209423, 0.05749104544520378, -0.021897636353969574, 0.07014002650976181, 0.009148746728897095, 0.05737343803048134, 0.02142048440873623, 0.032979439944028854, -0.050004325807094574, 0.018535451963543892, 0.044543687254190445, 0.0354040265083313, 0.010784553363919258, 0.007489468436688185, 0.007223190739750862, -0.029980821534991264, 0.048569515347480774, -0.010257107205688953, -0.028656790032982826, 0.011246214620769024, -0.01679057441651821, -0.06033020839095116, -0.06550285220146179, 0.06605469435453415, -0.018018173053860664, 0.047643277794122696, 0.005426547955721617, 0.006615111138671637, 0.06778940558433533, 0.06941837072372437, 0.018882108852267265, -0.02704545482993126, 0.021552613005042076, 0.019445711746811867, -0.05536545813083649, 0.03953588753938675, 0.0018313174368813634, 0.01705937273800373, 0.04379658401012421, 0.05356939509510994, -0.02681969292461872, 0.023947635665535927, -0.03847556188702583, 0.027557149529457092, 0.017991628497838974, 0.025512898340821266, 0.01197480596601963, 0.0013015270233154297, -0.008168964646756649, 0.02929414063692093, 0.007208585739135742, -0.015032775700092316, 0.011349187232553959, -0.017790747806429863, 0.04560920596122742, 0.05147440358996391, 0.061811432242393494, -0.019046343863010406, 0.009422807022929192, -0.03636633977293968, -0.015948757529258728, 0.014068428426980972, -0.024908876046538353, 0.058656010776758194, -0.0002492940111551434, -0.016452917829155922, 0.044940028339624405, -0.03068467229604721, -0.016461636871099472, 0.004525698721408844, -0.0012207533000037074, -0.025934971868991852, -0.048289403319358826, 0.03223266825079918, -0.012374273501336575, -0.03452541306614876, -0.027126839384436607, 0.01280304603278637, -0.011544154956936836, 0.0029716126155108213, -0.007202232722193003, -0.07984622567892075, -0.0351802296936512, 0.019959216937422752, -0.027174917981028557, -0.05681232362985611, 0.03950008377432823, 0.008379626087844372, -0.018937554210424423, -0.020165475085377693, -0.04010436311364174, -0.03960980102419853, -0.003158962819725275, -0.07307843118906021, 0.011611348018050194, 0.03811104968190193, -0.0234324112534523, -0.010862098075449467, -0.030106933787465096, 0.06673820316791534, -0.0188248660415411, 0.007329931017011404, 0.01415753923356533, 0.008591849356889725, -0.020226510241627693, -0.005111474543809891, 0.008458314463496208, -0.07681000977754593, -0.04701657593250275, -0.05767662078142166, 0.002353040501475334, -0.024357739835977554, -0.05645411089062691, 0.0210717786103487, 0.052314627915620804, -0.011896871030330658, -0.005678499583154917, 0.017308151349425316, 0.033029258251190186, 0.02204900234937668, -0.017726311460137367, -0.042872097343206406, -0.024504760280251503, -0.09692457318305969, 0.06485191732645035, -0.001989465905353427, 0.005661871749907732, 0.0069984798319637775, -0.045813895761966705, -0.03132909908890724, -0.05238472670316696, 0.000030259485356509686, 0.04589715227484703, 0.015211788937449455, -0.015301324427127838, -0.06127835065126419, -0.01344889122992754, 0.06290377676486969, -0.04632056877017021, -0.05613439902663231, -0.06886306405067444, -0.002581884153187275, 0.026357384398579597, 0.0012715195771306753, 0.02060113660991192, -0.017982494086027145, -0.023547984659671783, -0.008977653458714485, 0.04371389374136925, 0.021482108160853386, -0.03792410343885422, -0.029041796922683716, -0.02022561803460121, -0.06409268081188202, -0.015240859240293503, -0.02998906373977661, 0.0016120634973049164, -0.010343391448259354, -0.0202444139868021, -0.02956203557550907, -0.0369262769818306, 0.04331132024526596, 0.02630237489938736, -0.03629595413804054, 0.02756510116159916, -0.044617343693971634, 0.06611894816160202, -0.045579537749290466, -0.002297795843333006, 0.00795209500938654, 0.012849361635744572, -0.03878423199057579, 0.027462735772132874, -0.06358259916305542, -0.019025607034564018, -0.02126513607800007, -0.012376921251416206, -0.03815772384405136, 0.016491567716002464, 0.03125010058283806, 0.021953104063868523, -0.017002763226628304, -0.01001468300819397, -0.026644302532076836, -0.03588476404547691, 0.03270667791366577, 0.022114170715212822, 0.04657124727964401, 0.03865234926342964, 0.010494892485439777, -0.06661869585514069, -0.016201775521039963, -0.06199505180120468, -0.02307199314236641, -0.052548088133335114, -0.049658309668302536, -0.022831594571471214, -0.061035800725221634, -0.022913305088877678, -0.009971519000828266, -0.03480208292603493, 0.0299238134175539, -0.04615538939833641, -0.012524416670203209, 0.011820819228887558, 0.04156090319156647, -0.07210195064544678, -0.048614464700222015, -0.015251560136675835, 0.03748296573758125, 0.02660488709807396, -0.0511217825114727, 0.019889377057552338, 0.03133635222911835, 0.02053818665444851, 0.03227279335260391, 0.011564013548195362, -0.05828692764043808, 0.005616111680865288, -0.06554681807756424, -0.022130759432911873, 0.0016673645004630089, 0.022754540666937828, 0.050550851970911026, -0.01507230568677187, -0.013177542947232723, -0.0006067129434086382, -0.00996620487421751, -0.015482665039598942, -0.003176204627379775, -0.0046406895853579044, -0.014996715821325779, -0.030294576659798622, 0.026338152587413788, 0.0720248818397522, 0.0011873356997966766, -0.009469345211982727, -0.05802973732352257, -0.0034233357291668653, -0.02797483094036579, -0.042084481567144394, 0.04668262600898743, 0.05884617939591408, -0.05426369234919548, 0.02159791626036167, 0.007391840219497681, -0.039366889744997025, 0.011769118718802929, 0.012425229884684086, 0.016722925007343292, 0.025177430361509323, 0.0508536696434021, -0.07870146632194519, 0.03037177212536335, 0.05831456184387207, 0.056328561156988144, -0.04447183012962341, -0.053415555506944656, -0.006805919576436281, 0.005445696413516998, -0.010540954768657684, -0.01585065759718418, 0.02083117887377739, 0.02694312110543251, 0.05086486041545868, -0.041251763701438904, -0.036236464977264404, -0.024611901491880417, -0.03486575931310654, -0.042169202119112015, -0.042303480207920074, 0.019155902788043022, 0.06589526683092117, 0.0272548645734787, -0.022603146731853485, 0.04703392833471298, -0.004645640030503273, 0.051772892475128174, -0.01611706055700779, -0.048158545047044754, -0.021827910095453262, -0.016679301857948303, 0.05916751176118851, 0.002265344141051173, 0.0061973752453923225, -0.0043833497911691666, -0.06418728828430176, -0.028038647025823593, -0.05635007843375206, 0.03165511041879654, 0.04600873589515686, 0.024960890412330627, 0.022817665711045265, -0.0006130128167569637, 0.04861830174922943, -0.021324455738067627, -0.009357713162899017, -0.011657699011266232, -0.05188319459557533, -0.003883220488205552, 0.003332840045914054, -0.0404963344335556, 0.028056904673576355, -0.01180498767644167, 0.044179994612932205, -0.07429935038089752, -0.030243555083870888, -0.01685788854956627, -0.0096877571195364, -0.021158616989850998, -0.08056772500276566, -0.06055276840925217, -0.017286069691181183, -0.0070060198195278645, -0.025344090536236763, -0.011903079226613045, 0.06862391531467438, -0.02460988238453865, -0.028459396213293076, -0.06022508442401886, 0.01603945903480053, -0.007869891822338104, -0.05825671926140785, -0.033008310943841934, -0.03609481453895569, -0.0032371701672673225, 0.017923815175890923, 0.04044559970498085, -0.019654499366879463, -0.019209133461117744, -0.06841771304607391, 0.0001989213633351028, -0.010609772056341171, 0.007074248977005482, 0.027907874435186386, 0.014496439136564732, -0.007071780972182751, 0.0448635034263134, -0.06161535158753395, 0.049906179308891296, -0.019727595150470734, 0.03325127065181732, -0.06191260367631912, 0.02680952660739422, 0.02872520126402378, -0.0169376228004694, -0.0714859738945961, 0.03478541225194931, 0.03515777736902237, -0.03018242120742798, -0.03366324305534363, 0.011455018073320389, 0.007080085575580597, -0.03827749565243721, -0.0603506863117218, -0.016514020040631294, -0.031503546983003616, -0.05670962110161781, -0.014109998941421509, -0.03654281795024872, -0.01680934801697731, 0.0012412292417138815, -0.0018051093211397529, -0.014280439354479313, -0.005181979387998581, -0.041112206876277924, 0.036955464631319046, -0.027697796002030373, -0.024042274802923203, -0.015713199973106384, 0.018014997243881226, -0.06869114190340042, 0.04827088117599487, -0.05668988078832626, -0.024000639095902443, 0.03636084869503975, 0.041975416243076324, -0.028844133019447327, 0.014227580279111862, -0.08487126231193542, 0.02035936713218689, 0.01197894848883152, -0.05846937745809555, -0.044907379895448685, 0.04121809080243111, -0.018864531069993973, 0.03763236105442047, 0.026439404115080833, 0.02835395559668541, 0.017898237332701683, -0.03472939878702164, -0.002528107026591897, 0.03320571780204773, -0.054394859820604324, -0.030300041660666466, 0.0024039463605731726, 0.04897821322083473, -0.019313443452119827, 0.040220897644758224, 0.013087984174489975, -0.02784784510731697, -0.034266095608472824, 0.04853779450058937, 0.05936356633901596, -0.0070737190544605255, -0.06435518711805344, 0.0018666452961042523, -0.015040501952171326, -0.010305343195796013, 0.04218098148703575, -0.03955003619194031, -0.0004977660719305277, -0.03957555443048477, -0.002488232683390379, -0.01842258684337139, 0.06876374781131744, -0.0011058058589696884, 0.06346408277750015, 0.013454192318022251, -0.015616808086633682, -0.057737525552511215, -0.03419271856546402, -0.02777198888361454, 0.006249477621167898, 0.044368259608745575, 0.0018278133356943727, 0.03600475937128067, 0.020277824252843857, 0.039442360401153564, -0.07687893509864807, -0.023118190467357635, -0.008640291169285774, 0.06159992516040802, 0.02946379780769348, -0.02936863712966442, 0.02462962083518505, 0.05237739160656929, -0.06348281353712082, 0.03378770500421524, -0.008562798611819744, -0.05219167843461037, -0.04962949827313423, 0.029508132487535477, 0.005823038052767515, 0.017309313639998436, -0.024399949237704277, -0.017870401963591576, 0.029119353741407394, -0.007573230657726526, 0.04051073268055916, 0.0018146332586184144, 0.028200305998325348, 0.023598233237862587, 0.01020111795514822, 0.0029980973340570927, -0.0679788738489151, 0.007068576756864786, 0.061009205877780914, -0.07663808017969131, 0.012149699963629246, -0.0716879740357399, -0.002232249593362212, -0.018126949667930603, -0.009850185364484787, -0.044908761978149414, 0.023864923045039177, -0.050935644656419754, -0.07884235680103302, 0.03367966040968895, -0.002075857948511839, -0.07298115640878677, -0.007936438545584679, 0.025553666055202484, -0.08668935298919678, -0.06213455647230148, 0.01036179531365633, -0.017996961250901222, 0.009105219505727291, 0.044813673943281174, -0.01675420254468918, -0.05148513615131378, -0.01828509196639061, 0.039739545434713364, 0.01630052737891674, -0.0430084690451622, 0.0626382976770401, 0.005800845567137003, -0.059888824820518494, -0.007476025726646185, -0.035962216556072235, -0.030593877658247948, -0.022634852677583694, 0.07080516219139099, 0.032353322952985764, -0.037186313420534134, 0.00988076627254486, -0.0013772558886557817, -0.06385496258735657, 0.04484442621469498, 0.014604311436414719, 0.038687147200107574, 0.026129689067602158, -0.039760999381542206, -0.04067523777484894, -0.02557866834104061, -0.041615650057792664, 0.02102041244506836, -0.01722363568842411, -0.03213902562856674, 0.033843208104372025, 0.02048657089471817, 0.02940017357468605, -0.05974564328789711, -0.03825003281235695, 0.005189507734030485, -0.01910138688981533, 0.057695455849170685, -0.06923677027225494, -0.009520048275589943, -0.010784837417304516, 0.0017281092004850507, 0.02142282947897911, 0.014671798795461655, -0.05999957397580147, -0.01351894624531269, 0.01137322373688221, -0.05936230346560478, 0.04785434529185295, 0.04029039666056633, 0.06720268726348877, -0.01927127316594124, -0.016443904489278793, -0.036694176495075226, -0.02901654690504074, -0.04553283751010895, -0.03802594915032387, -0.013421372510492802, -0.029987167567014694, -0.01948934979736805, -0.025400670245289803, 0.01068787556141615, -0.017586717382073402, -0.04310709238052368, -0.03251459077000618, 0.005294934846460819, -0.0592774897813797, -0.006504657678306103, -0.00844486616551876, -0.035883739590644836, 0.016606813296675682, -0.036523252725601196, 0.05837932974100113, 0.00663351034745574, 0.016736015677452087, -0.010266179218888283, 0.005724336951971054, -0.02101842872798443, -0.005296814255416393, -0.03711048141121864, 0.046112652868032455, 0.03526971861720085, -0.00743844686076045, -0.019035909324884415, -0.02457532100379467, -0.07314688712358475, 0.018199533224105835, -0.010517384856939316, 0.024224072694778442, -0.011103673838078976, -0.04348352551460266, 0.048589933663606644, 0.034922365099191666, -0.022856201976537704, -0.07092681527137756, -0.03965314105153084, 0.05200926214456558, -0.03589262440800667, -0.0027746970299631357, -0.026824934408068657, -0.050863657146692276, 0.03270089626312256, -0.08365195244550705, -0.02129058539867401, -0.03602273017168045, 0.008547446690499783, 0.00575349060818553, -0.021856557577848434, 0.004659688100218773, -0.034760117530822754, 0.03358244523406029, 0.042402368038892746, -0.043821994215250015, 0.03503511846065521, 0.010400274768471718, -0.025038201361894608, 0.01467205211520195, 0.019275950267910957, 0.0029730310197919607, 0.007448183838278055, -0.0352201908826828, 0.02605680748820305, -0.025193946436047554, -0.036059506237506866, 0.002433959161862731, 0.0816064402461052, -0.007132802624255419, -0.026759952306747437, -0.04291458800435066, -0.037301234900951385, -0.02859259955585003, -0.0343732126057148, 0.009510465897619724, -0.0682578906416893, -0.0017123379511758685, 0.03861526772379875, 0.02230290323495865, -0.05959842726588249, -0.022935695946216583, -0.015622873790562153, -0.003178816055878997, -0.002415477531030774, 0.01736259274184704, 0.0231382604688406, -0.07367533445358276, 0.023252058774232864, 0.003860839642584324, -0.0031868410296738148, -0.06771751493215561, -0.030276017263531685, 0.008475924842059612, -0.03808646649122238, 0.008156458847224712, -0.07287216931581497, -0.014261957257986069, -0.037538081407547, 0.008667854592204094, 0.041140634566545486, 0.006672922987490892, -0.04583648964762688, 0.018378421664237976, -0.04865211248397827, -0.015001612715423107, 0.03246625140309334, -0.014464983716607094, -0.00699937529861927, 0.009977479465305805, -0.014941828325390816, -0.020412156358361244, -0.021503549069166183, -0.07226207107305527, 0.004728887230157852, -0.027843473479151726, -0.0029530730098485947, 0.024971451610326767, -0.010824127122759819, -0.013604175299406052, 0.058687351644039154, 0.0020586594473570585, -0.007597075775265694, -0.06696777790784836, 0.06750451773405075, 0.06797290593385696, -0.011709349229931831, 0.004650486633181572, 0.03755563497543335, -0.0377928800880909, 0.0009300083038397133, -0.05947987735271454, 0.035122647881507874, 0.005817349534481764, -0.05943181738257408, 0.03348880261182785, 0.006518224719911814, -0.0690213292837143, -0.05441378057003021 ]
Finger vein pattern recognition is an emerging biometric with a good resistance to presentation attacks and low error rates. One problem is that it is hard to obtain ground truth finger vein patterns from live fingers. In this paper we propose an advanced method to create finger vein phantoms using 3D printing where we mimic the optical properties of the various tissues inside the fingers, like bone, veins and soft tissues using different printing materials and parameters. We demonstrate that we are able to create finger phantoms that result in realistic finger vein images and precisely known vein patterns. These phantoms can be used to develop and evaluate finger vein extraction and recognition methods. In addition, we show that the finger vein phantoms can be used to spoof a finger vein recognition system. This paper is based on the Master's thesis of Rasmus van der Grift.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14806v1
[ 0.014491482637822628, 0.010267571546137333, 0.023921683430671692, 0.04463111236691475, -0.0067994906567037106, -0.005519341677427292, -0.009095922112464905, -0.03364600986242294, -0.02672874554991722, -0.031978920102119446, -0.0873798355460167, 0.013104074634611607, -0.046840377151966095, -0.027250709012150764, -0.04882555082440376, -0.00982572603970766, 0.05583919212222099, -0.035010989755392075, -0.006051261443644762, 0.05792538821697235, -0.040307238698005676, -0.03367934748530388, -0.012073839083313942, 0.05319685488939285, 0.007858351804316044, -0.021333979442715645, -0.04275265708565712, 0.02573312073945999, -0.06893444806337357, -0.011541119776666164, 0.07660065591335297, -0.045349523425102234, -0.0030622705817222595, -0.0002337326732231304, -0.018577199429273605, 0.0459350124001503, -0.00733632268384099, 0.01343682873994112, -0.005263831466436386, -0.05076611042022705, 0.05197562649846077, -0.0010321270674467087, -0.046850305050611496, -0.015497139655053616, -0.036519188433885574, -0.03585899993777275, 0.0003291976754553616, 0.0355849489569664, -0.07766573131084442, 0.023852437734603882, 0.002222019247710705, -0.021982979029417038, 0.003709828481078148, 0.055493589490652084, -0.055996812880039215, -0.026420915499329567, -0.04490203410387039, 0.05246138572692871, -0.04653535038232803, 0.01142385695129633, 0.0017032986506819725, 0.040179092437028885, -0.03485020250082016, -0.000361415819497779, 0.010879104025661945, 0.03640240430831909, -0.05687819421291351, -0.053571879863739014, -0.024940671399235725, -0.0386655367910862, 0.046468790620565414, 0.011896499432623386, 0.0628097727894783, -0.002743127290159464, 0.016141805797815323, -0.04815516620874405, -0.054253894835710526, -0.00827903300523758, 0.014198791235685349, 0.05422930419445038, -0.0362219512462616, 0.029986126348376274, 0.01608041115105152, 0.043691620230674744, -0.01465041283518076, -0.03351398929953575, 0.030364438891410828, 0.006813285406678915, 0.04427311569452286, -0.054457638412714005, 0.03987272456288338, -0.04634500667452812, -0.05104232579469681, -0.014186098240315914, 0.02479342184960842, -0.0034720487892627716, 0.04066125303506851, 0.053758785128593445, 0.006486996077001095, -0.009295555762946606, -0.01229011919349432, -0.005732226651161909, 0.06126058101654053, 0.026678282767534256, -0.0019232005579397082, -0.03158559277653694, -0.03270513191819191, -0.014896970242261887, -0.023811496794223785, -0.012301093898713589, -0.03578177094459534, -0.04175081476569176, 0.0033165067434310913, -0.048965033143758774, -0.05125989392399788, -0.016630707308650017, -0.017082244157791138, -0.04484325647354126, -0.005420349538326263, 0.024103455245494843, -0.057519085705280304, -0.006880924105644226, 0.015432325191795826, -0.023947691544890404, -0.03613903373479843, 0.008552763611078262, 0.047029025852680206, 0.034160513430833817, 0.003986947704106569, -0.05668912082910538, 0.0021904800087213516, -0.014687229879200459, 0.03331425040960312, 0.03042750619351864, 0.045543499290943146, -0.039667077362537384, -0.009433475323021412, -0.06227536126971245, 0.025059280917048454, 0.026408247649669647, -0.02850165218114853, -0.053262799978256226, -0.008696562610566616, -0.02497156895697117, -0.040446266531944275, 0.044666122645139694, -0.025358833372592926, 0.018601976335048676, 0.012526324018836021, -0.015501069836318493, 0.033627286553382874, -0.06450124830007553, 0.0077932425774633884, 0.05426294729113579, 0.021169738844037056, -0.05916306748986244, 0.0754275843501091, -0.012083102017641068, -0.005029784515500069, -0.05110165849328041, 0.007834306918084621, -0.03523092716932297, 0.015884635969996452, -0.027547596022486687, 0.03560292720794678, -0.029911601915955544, 0.01650780439376831, -0.001489785616286099, -0.0031626943964511156, 0.03994957357645035, -0.05177469924092293, -0.032420963048934937, 0.008030056953430176, 0.009646046906709671, -0.04603670537471771, 0.010791377164423466, 0.027108604088425636, -0.05397091433405876, -0.04436272382736206, -0.013019829988479614, 0.012405233457684517, -0.03366849943995476, 0.00543838320299983, -0.01566588319838047, -0.0011549635091796517, -0.01251651905477047, -0.08293446898460388, -0.061470404267311096, 0.05038648843765259, 0.030766554176807404, -0.05228925123810768, -0.05792711302638054, -0.01368288416415453, -0.0007076992187649012, 0.011758914217352867, -0.00777498260140419, -0.05025407299399376, -0.01313112210482359, 0.0060221366584300995, 0.027309475466609, -0.08388394117355347, -0.007052362430840731, -0.05343777686357498, -0.015580866485834122, -0.03153391554951668, -0.057316262274980545, -0.0178983211517334, 0.022976459935307503, -0.003687252989038825, -0.007052123546600342, 0.024985210970044136, 0.019920676946640015, 0.04929996281862259, 0.023596299812197685, -0.0020427124109119177, 0.014469931833446026, -0.10310343652963638, 0.03177409991621971, 0.00041476855403743684, 0.025747090578079224, 0.004477507434785366, 0.005028442479670048, 0.016748007386922836, -0.02068791538476944, -0.06182746961712837, 0.03155317157506943, 0.07811236381530762, 0.0032293200492858887, -0.05431605130434036, -0.05676732584834099, -0.018538756296038628, -0.027268948033452034, -0.006024811416864395, -0.03768403083086014, -0.015130575746297836, -0.03624564781785011, -0.023415008559823036, 0.018790319561958313, -0.022146165370941162, -0.04662291333079338, 0.04664282500743866, -0.06653395295143127, 0.06158746778964996, 0.0164563599973917, -0.04735581949353218, -0.05711398646235466, -0.0034004158806055784, -0.007110428996384144, -0.03726585581898689, 0.023873228579759598, -0.03275823965668678, -0.03175558149814606, 0.002008773386478424, -0.0015402082353830338, 0.04231005534529686, 0.004802349489182234, -0.029564812779426575, -0.0018423085566610098, -0.0162512194365263, 0.042039841413497925, 0.04603829234838486, -0.0007110598962754011, -0.06258263438940048, 0.00006198490154929459, 0.0439164899289608, 0.027258561924099922, -0.02500131167471409, -0.020435091108083725, 0.04942726716399193, -0.022226203233003616, -0.015384308993816376, 0.05857444927096367, 0.04618896171450615, -0.04601220041513443, -0.058076273649930954, 0.01187861803919077, -0.01056661270558834, -0.032480835914611816, 0.05601494386792183, 0.02099749445915222, 0.014090444892644882, -0.057182177901268005, -0.00045623836922459304, -0.07277758419513702, -0.0023224770557135344, -0.06446100771427155, 0.024192888289690018, -0.046726226806640625, -0.004911405965685844, -0.008315453305840492, -0.0712924674153328, 0.005973649676889181, -0.06934867799282074, -0.034779395908117294, -0.023248685523867607, -0.07767824828624725, -0.01906346157193184, -0.009580394253134727, 0.05373797193169594, 0.04393928870558739, -0.08000493794679642, -0.02948051691055298, 0.03882710263133049, 0.047771092504262924, 0.014453161507844925, -0.055984873324632645, -0.016148768365383148, 0.03865800052881241, 0.013668214902281761, -0.03288979455828667, 0.0009492984972894192, 0.07513738423585892, 0.006279991008341312, 0.0077588059939444065, -0.027597086504101753, 0.001305075129494071, 0.027465367689728737, -0.021893031895160675, 0.020531823858618736, 0.005600837059319019, -0.04981313645839691, -0.0236981101334095, 0.003504788503050804, -0.02618463709950447, -0.06506086885929108, 0.007658704649657011, 0.031281307339668274, -0.04170750081539154, -0.02698325179517269, -0.027203621342778206, 0.008119318634271622, 0.013516157865524292, 0.024123450741171837, 0.01437188871204853, -0.004445315804332495, 0.005795237608253956, 0.042842280119657516, -0.030969010666012764, 0.010121140629053116, 0.01679305173456669, -0.011612018570303917, 0.05500638484954834, -0.0697515681385994, -0.0189103651791811, 0.023065943270921707, -0.09819141775369644, 0.011524450033903122, 0.0006508551887236536, 0.0741797387599945, -0.03825412318110466, -0.014038658700883389, 0.02494344487786293, 0.05239253118634224, 0.014579616487026215, 0.0019204455893486738, -0.002227801363915205, 0.020126016810536385, 0.053568124771118164, -0.035438232123851776, -0.04428946226835251, -0.0026856467593461275, -0.07107467204332352, -0.06542061269283295, 0.030950171872973442, 0.007916039787232876, 0.03683638945221901, 0.03776419162750244, -0.055712584406137466, 0.03383611887693405, -0.0427357517182827, 0.05139709264039993, 0.020989393815398216, 0.013929313980042934, 0.043331533670425415, -0.013956747949123383, 0.06047451123595238, 0.009375352412462234, 0.04193853586912155, -0.0197686068713665, -0.046139996498823166, 0.023620236665010452, 0.038571204990148544, 0.054903168231248856, 0.051199041306972504, -0.05644475296139717, 0.003388967365026474, -0.010306022129952908, -0.04794131591916084, 0.035158272832632065, -0.021445419639348984, 0.003337646136060357, 0.03951094672083855, -0.02661811001598835, 0.023371992632746696, 0.002895006909966469, -0.05119965970516205, 0.016796793788671494, -0.01481762807816267, -0.05567532777786255, 0.06260886788368225, -0.05180196464061737, 0.007302204146981239, -0.03238214552402496, -0.08485186100006104, -0.00443311920389533, -0.026869764551520348, 0.030505765229463577, 0.014928690157830715, -0.041101403534412384, 0.03334080055356026, -0.03932489827275276, -0.02157066948711872, -0.018758652731776237, -0.005222643259912729, -0.022086286917328835, -0.007839021272957325, 0.0034171470906585455, -0.08387099951505661, 0.02319052256643772, -0.05396699532866478, 0.0657978281378746, -0.0045579709112644196, 0.015363354235887527, -0.04869837686419487, -0.005434203892946243, -0.02866644598543644, -0.010880939662456512, 0.054199207574129105, -0.03611473739147186, 0.012502755969762802, -0.012266173958778381, 0.011813166551291943, 0.005032459739595652, -0.016304047778248787, 0.014854967594146729, -0.012173314578831196, 0.010460861027240753, -0.016818759962916374, 0.003935614600777626, -0.0020095910876989365, -0.027549946680665016, 0.03787318244576454, 0.006559209898114204, -0.024334987625479698, -0.036331214010715485, -0.025366242974996567, -0.03379501402378082, -0.07322296500205994, -0.05687766522169113, -0.04357431083917618, -0.011083876714110374, -0.006219606846570969, 0.034840844571590424, 0.03771645575761795, -0.04304460436105728, 0.011063427664339542, 0.025967251509428024, 0.055769164115190506, -0.003714995225891471, -0.02999669685959816, 0.04430576041340828, 0.013047703541815281, -0.022398658096790314, -0.01489745732396841, -0.013290475122630596, -0.01733633689582348, -0.03384760767221451, -0.040161941200494766, 0.0013722256990149617, 0.04880986735224724, 0.017254631966352463, 0.03886041045188904, -0.06065180152654648, 0.03145291283726692, 0.020704206079244614, -0.005162435118108988, -0.02852797321975231, 0.05807201936841011, 0.011611339636147022, 0.04237331449985504, -0.02020389772951603, 0.03576745465397835, -0.01776653341948986, -0.03949790447950363, -0.018942004069685936, -0.007841088809072971, 0.009672236628830433, -0.00937378965318203, 0.02852962166070938, -0.010309096425771713, -0.051547177135944366, -0.03620666265487671, 0.042323071509599686, -0.00780998170375824, 0.00278779910877347, -0.01716354303061962, 0.0270952470600605, -0.05021613836288452, -0.042344238609075546, 0.03668941929936409, -0.011315105482935905, -0.017354363575577736, 0.01915987953543663, -0.032941561192274094, 0.00852337758988142, 0.04171721637248993, -0.04623928293585777, 0.0015818263636901975, 0.00009370577026857063, -0.024181950837373734, -0.023902075365185738, -0.021499553695321083, 0.041682757437229156, -0.03141119331121445, -0.06858303397893906, -0.04059189185500145, 0.046356722712516785, 0.07152508199214935, 0.02651442401111126, 0.02283928170800209, 0.00332575011998415, -0.03968000411987305, -0.033873554319143295, -0.02659563347697258, -0.010088707320392132, 0.003808563807979226, -0.0545174814760685, 0.053202416747808456, -0.016453294083476067, 0.07258343696594238, -0.01148953102529049, 0.00795777142047882, -0.014048891142010689, 0.010462624952197075, -0.011541525833308697, -0.061781104654073715, 0.034781765192747116, -0.010809347964823246, -0.05981150269508362, 0.016349269077181816, 0.04522065445780754, 0.010060587897896767, 0.04651644080877304, 0.01843434013426304, 0.030522719025611877, 0.028105489909648895, 0.010497082024812698, 0.03365606442093849, -0.03822941705584526, -0.04105640575289726, 0.029328564181923866, -0.04172311723232269, -0.02747347019612789, 0.030864402651786804, -0.04919450357556343, -0.044114962220191956, -0.04892551898956299, 0.027237895876169205, 0.01866321638226509, -0.007647300139069557, -0.06576395779848099, 0.055420078337192535, -0.005430858116596937, -0.06472332775592804, 0.05562810227274895, -0.019516680389642715, -0.04413130134344101, 0.06350958347320557, -0.004593063145875931, 0.03233557939529419, -0.042887911200523376, 0.051348209381103516, -0.01779255084693432, -0.03426944091916084, -0.04875339940190315, 0.04561435803771019, 0.06911902874708176, -0.015566656365990639, 0.03803710639476776, 0.04263494908809662, -0.06743836402893066, 0.03891313821077347, -0.008461092598736286, 0.00010747220949269831, 0.017654260620474815, -0.027275897562503815, -0.05377554893493652, -0.027328267693519592, -0.02963642217218876, 0.0567878820002079, -0.035812560468912125, -0.014273197390139103, -0.01571282371878624, -0.025790635496377945, 0.06460822373628616, -0.040733855217695236, -0.0161556638777256, -0.0010406243382021785, -0.010575979016721249, 0.006778814364224672, -0.04304852336645126, -0.029634680598974228, -0.030819162726402283, 0.02869614213705063, 0.020909976214170456, -0.03643135726451874, -0.01625649817287922, -0.03606564924120903, -0.06251213699579239, -0.01991136558353901, -0.06998488306999207, -0.03619108721613884, -0.04011400043964386, 0.05629558116197586, 0.053181242197752, 0.017142601311206818, -0.043238330632448196, -0.022594043985009193, 0.03150544688105583, -0.0010504667880013585, -0.035948414355516434, 0.011370615102350712, 0.0076399752870202065, -0.013537252321839333, 0.046110209077596664, -0.01829863153398037, 0.011306416243314743, -0.04360434412956238, -0.03894948214292526, -0.0075187538750469685, -0.0099516985937953, -0.03325043246150017, 0.028395146131515503, 0.006135246250778437, 0.00964925717562437, 0.002188748447224498, 0.006986503954976797, -0.0331515371799469, -0.06823931634426117, 0.051133204251527786, -0.04374907165765762, -0.006711277179419994, -0.00027464688173495233, 0.022203221917152405, -0.014847955666482449, -0.009222924709320068, 0.04618747532367706, 0.020397108048200607, 0.008702566847205162, 0.03967995569109917, -0.0774039775133133, 0.0023181247524917126, -0.012230989523231983, 0.01180078275501728, -0.034196898341178894, 0.06720657646656036, -0.0642542615532875, -0.09280915558338165, 0.025641661137342453, 0.017202435061335564, -0.046307340264320374, 0.002819740679115057, -0.013919705525040627, 0.042610447853803635, 0.016982894390821457, 0.007359778042882681, -0.049228448420763016, -0.03210805356502533, 0.00775463692843914, -0.02366572991013527, -0.04937410354614258, 0.019716624170541763, -0.03187984228134155, -0.014904066920280457, -0.0937739834189415, 0.02561902068555355, 0.06489310413599014, 0.0604511983692646, -0.039629124104976654, -0.07328864187002182, -0.006817302666604519, -0.06934590637683868, -0.00020750232215505093, 0.018503772094845772, -0.00818129163235426, -0.0008072201744653285, 0.027725696563720703, -0.007468321826308966, -0.048138730227947235, 0.007756597828119993, 0.006525774020701647, 0.04143274948000908, 0.03752785921096802, 0.012879100628197193, 0.028690604493021965, 0.05381319671869278, 0.0225199144333601, 0.046926360577344894, -0.02629965730011463, 0.015305645763874054, -0.012218888849020004, 0.025543786585330963, -0.04807855933904648, -0.004886225331574678, -0.008144034072756767, -0.05577084422111511, -0.06171777471899986, -0.015067190863192081, -0.029902709648013115, 0.03586164116859436, -0.027567071840167046, -0.05778259411454201, -0.012024687603116035, 0.022252149879932404, 0.011673109605908394, 0.011803914792835712, -0.006725556682795286, -0.022411614656448364, -0.033787183463573456, -0.004836783278733492, -0.04801036790013313, 0.01756889931857586, 0.00015027936024125665, -0.04383223503828049, 0.04650994390249252, -0.05449656397104263, -0.02047373354434967, 0.027992522343993187, -0.00045244235661812127, 0.05268267169594765, 0.07128609716892242, -0.0069593703374266624, 0.008996552787721157, -0.028021106496453285, -0.05100959539413452, 0.021064942702651024, 0.02775237336754799, -0.018801381811499596, -0.033274415880441666, 0.001998314168304205, -0.001446660840883851, 0.04545348510146141, -0.012046736665070057, 0.07887518405914307, -0.014181580394506454, 0.037298783659935, -0.0007904981030151248, -0.0063661932945251465, -0.041329436004161835, 0.04344366118311882, -0.0112043097615242, 0.03449133411049843, -0.017096498981118202, -0.038404062390327454, -0.06356554478406906, -0.03145000711083412, 0.048020802438259125, 0.026514049619436264, -0.02240055985748768, -0.06580742448568344, -0.0009917104616761208, 0.005372251849621534, 0.01082461979240179, -0.000979263917542994, -0.02010670118033886, -0.010142190381884575, -0.02571038529276848, -0.060643743723630905 ]
There are many artificial intelligence algorithms for autonomous driving, but directly installing these algorithms on vehicles is unrealistic and expensive. At the same time, many of these algorithms need an environment to train and optimize. Simulation is a valuable and meaningful solution with training and testing functions, and it can say that simulation is a critical link in the autonomous driving world. There are also many different applications or systems of simulation from companies or academies such as SVL and Carla. These simulators flaunt that they have the closest real-world simulation, but their environment objects, such as pedestrians and other vehicles around the agent-vehicle, are already fixed programmed. They can only move along the pre-setting trajectory, or random numbers determine their movements. What is the situation when all environmental objects are also installed by Artificial Intelligence, or their behaviors are like real people or natural reactions of other drivers? This problem is a blind spot for most of the simulation applications, or these applications cannot be easy to solve this problem. The Neurorobotics Platform from the TUM team of Prof. Alois Knoll has the idea about "Engines" and "Transceiver Functions" to solve the multi-agents problem. This report will start with a little research on the Neurorobotics Platform and analyze the potential and possibility of developing a new simulator to achieve the true real-world simulation goal. Then based on the NRP-Core Platform, this initial development aims to construct an initial demo experiment. The consist of this report starts with the basic knowledge of NRP-Core and its installation, then focus on the explanation of the necessary components for a simulation experiment, at last, about the details of constructions for the autonomous driving system, which is integrated object detection and autonomous control.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.00089v1
[ -0.014913205057382584, -0.03791802376508713, 0.03337373957037926, 0.026771090924739838, -0.010446706786751747, -0.013396150432527065, 0.0032440535724163055, -0.006401626858860254, -0.027153685688972473, -0.05222434177994728, -0.022441087290644646, 0.02980542741715908, -0.02205558679997921, -0.026844998821616173, -0.047276366502046585, 0.03992553800344467, 0.06615600734949112, 0.030145373195409775, -0.0533379465341568, 0.02566990628838539, 0.050936393439769745, -0.03120523877441883, -0.029265722259879112, 0.007279413752257824, -0.03175782039761543, 0.024828296154737473, 0.0022633972112089396, 0.0363399013876915, -0.054948944598436356, -0.03688511624932289, 0.06776575744152069, -0.003407828975468874, -0.029733579605817795, -0.05177927762269974, -0.040188129991292953, -0.0312337726354599, 0.013475466519594193, 0.013479132205247879, 0.04086094722151756, -0.023411855101585388, 0.05341590940952301, -0.007917806506156921, -0.06550934910774231, 0.023895172402262688, -0.05874239280819893, -0.013143419288098812, -0.06332618743181229, 0.019235024228692055, -0.07200317084789276, -0.04758295789361, 0.0029672584496438503, 0.005782482214272022, 0.043332621455192566, 0.05210347846150398, -0.02256222814321518, 0.027215618640184402, -0.003189357928931713, 0.006434955168515444, -0.03282037749886513, -0.01525463443249464, -0.01319968979805708, -0.040333107113838196, 0.029589800164103508, -0.015135291963815689, 0.03349286690354347, 0.06473925709724426, -0.018765967339277267, -0.03312240168452263, -0.035887837409973145, -0.044104043394327164, 0.009655790403485298, -0.04475376009941101, 0.01895088329911232, 0.01700236089527607, -0.04032997414469719, -0.034874800592660904, 0.017734605818986893, -0.0334969088435173, 0.03900263085961342, -0.0016990357544273138, 0.0061027477495372295, -0.004448761697858572, 0.03992433473467827, 0.023544710129499435, -0.0004552584432531148, -0.033045828342437744, 0.03399400785565376, -0.013612780719995499, 0.05089791864156723, -0.04184844344854355, 0.054391391575336456, -0.023992028087377548, -0.07496661692857742, 0.03836003690958023, 0.059586890041828156, -0.03683089092373848, 0.022401630878448486, 0.04338788241147995, 0.011550486087799072, -0.028365464881062508, -0.016666894778609276, 0.020819041877985, -0.020272914320230484, 0.03181878849864006, 0.036854714155197144, -0.0642957016825676, 0.010046250186860561, -0.03151954337954521, -0.05255718529224396, -0.022044824436306953, -0.03846774622797966, -0.05202767625451088, 0.020141243934631348, -0.08179796487092972, -0.028920868411660194, -0.03771267458796501, 0.05313514918088913, -0.00282241846434772, 0.04855688288807869, 0.03422001004219055, -0.0506950318813324, 0.054620277136564255, 0.016057871282100677, -0.04250328987836838, -0.02843925729393959, -0.03898218274116516, 0.03961000218987465, 0.02617965266108513, -0.05503731966018677, 0.005785070825368166, -0.021686827763915062, 0.02411581762135029, -0.04167749732732773, -0.02921304479241371, 0.0480751134455204, -0.021061861887574196, -0.04185401275753975, -0.05416226387023926, 0.01414204016327858, -0.035454146564006805, -0.0017256595892831683, -0.05302504450082779, 0.02335120551288128, -0.00561861926689744, -0.008105069398880005, 0.03387444466352463, -0.054568007588386536, -0.01117987185716629, -0.019843392074108124, 0.026322880759835243, -0.01671704463660717, 0.03190792351961136, 0.004720770753920078, 0.016567816957831383, 0.050049733370542526, -0.030141910538077354, 0.02207827754318714, -0.0644148737192154, -0.04153911769390106, -0.027530556544661522, 0.005627523176372051, -0.03208652883768082, -0.051763199269771576, -0.03512583673000336, 0.022705553099513054, 0.022819869220256805, 0.0598786324262619, -0.03507999703288078, -0.012028519995510578, -0.02159695141017437, -0.024059094488620758, 0.016207147389650345, 0.01421390287578106, -0.016042407602071762, -0.032444067299366, -0.0028110737912356853, 0.04401928186416626, -0.02822856977581978, -0.030255792662501335, 0.00855974666774273, 0.022352058440446854, 0.033570677042007446, -0.041944779455661774, -0.013591259717941284, -0.03694305568933487, 0.02733956277370453, -0.06725119799375534, -0.016087539494037628, 0.03776758536696434, 0.03418757766485214, -0.0736117884516716, -0.0458529032766819, 0.022179480642080307, -0.012643508613109589, -0.044933587312698364, 0.007721758913248777, -0.02615334279835224, -0.04749726876616478, -0.027060413733124733, 0.031104089692234993, -0.07696858793497086, 0.024300476536154747, -0.05876782909035683, -0.06978592276573181, 0.012077976949512959, -0.06486298143863678, 0.04599471390247345, 0.04030658304691315, 0.00044937492930330336, -0.03739474341273308, 0.034945063292980194, -0.00044486732804216444, 0.04323546960949898, 0.024137873202562332, 0.05761025846004486, 0.013775704428553581, -0.09459049254655838, 0.05381840094923973, -0.008272971026599407, -0.005986025556921959, 0.012558389455080032, 0.01658337563276291, 0.006401383318006992, 0.0018859343836084008, 0.002834043698385358, -0.006164517253637314, -0.0005050843465141952, -0.033775169402360916, -0.07170093059539795, -0.028308844193816185, -0.016395458951592445, -0.06317372620105743, -0.019747644662857056, -0.07422079145908356, -0.04544588923454285, 0.016347434371709824, -0.02572641149163246, 0.03850257396697998, -0.021004140377044678, -0.00030392964254133403, -0.0655127689242363, -0.03780263289809227, 0.022248046472668648, -0.02615451067686081, -0.06822352111339569, -0.04912758991122246, -0.02190442942082882, 0.014378122054040432, -0.04259392246603966, -0.024283023551106453, -0.05132698640227318, -0.006424253806471825, -0.028770869597792625, -0.02800956554710865, 0.02623482048511505, 0.011463714763522148, -0.05279618874192238, 0.048714444041252136, -0.0037512583658099174, 0.012926720082759857, 0.042961396276950836, 0.03496494144201279, -0.05241691321134567, 0.0004467194667086005, 0.04777907580137253, 0.020098291337490082, -0.030247408896684647, -0.005295922979712486, 0.04839416220784187, -0.058333635330200195, -0.02580161765217781, 0.041225895285606384, 0.0457746759057045, -0.02110915444791317, -0.01128673367202282, -0.0444456972181797, 0.01385763380676508, -0.030117062851786613, 0.017634142190217972, 0.06335640698671341, 0.031137939542531967, -0.03241818770766258, -0.01644624024629593, -0.03442281857132912, -0.03760725259780884, -0.03332610800862312, -0.01908528059720993, -0.05124271288514137, -0.021347615867853165, -0.02962961606681347, -0.06497924774885178, -0.021539023146033287, -0.044361259788274765, -0.04419785737991333, -0.014145941473543644, -0.07826100289821625, -0.01919425278902054, -0.028108030557632446, 0.03388706594705582, 0.021318040788173676, -0.06720322370529175, -0.025577740743756294, 0.011792872101068497, 0.03848792985081673, 0.015448055230081081, -0.06425551325082779, -0.0028945079538971186, -0.01930108107626438, -0.0017181552248075604, 0.019527679309248924, -0.02819422073662281, 0.0473228357732296, -0.027291491627693176, 0.03003181517124176, 0.041493307799100876, -0.05746882036328316, 0.026076940819621086, -0.00961101334542036, -0.020186811685562134, -0.04085791856050491, 0.01983323134481907, -0.05245592072606087, 0.020479731261730194, -0.05767320469021797, -0.02950602024793625, 0.0041832830756902695, 0.050328537821769714, 0.023449162021279335, -0.021922441199421883, -0.058670904487371445, 0.004931136034429073, 0.015473277308046818, 0.008489550091326237, 0.005882919300347567, 0.03784891590476036, 0.009261567145586014, -0.03320401906967163, 0.01658390648663044, -0.015535572543740273, -0.02074277028441429, -0.015288935042917728, 0.00038813368882983923, -0.07860444486141205, -0.048464398831129074, 0.059237103909254074, -0.08674489706754684, -0.05050507187843323, 0.04173847287893295, 0.051987044513225555, -0.017120661213994026, 0.03105444833636284, 0.014055570587515831, -0.014229592867195606, 0.03033936396241188, -0.009717357344925404, 0.04299305006861687, 0.04212383180856705, 0.038371533155441284, -0.0011514064390212297, -0.03931931406259537, -0.005875112023204565, -0.07726602256298065, -0.0686287060379982, 0.02849806472659111, 0.04122674837708473, 0.03539048507809639, 0.02445424534380436, -0.05154382064938545, -0.014468764886260033, 0.022777598351240158, 0.03134199231863022, -0.019280102103948593, -0.0074651543982326984, 0.031985118985176086, -0.0422445610165596, -0.024022413417696953, 0.010696599259972572, 0.01886409893631935, -0.05143798887729645, -0.035910964012145996, 0.00846682209521532, -0.06667842715978622, 0.01791110634803772, -0.019274871796369553, -0.02877659909427166, -0.01266499049961567, 0.028629716485738754, -0.05036571994423866, 0.05034320056438446, 0.002314693760126829, 0.0028781911823898554, -0.00956923607736826, -0.044573139399290085, -0.010759207420051098, -0.041488051414489746, -0.014662177301943302, 0.012144861742854118, 0.010990926064550877, -0.04788508638739586, 0.009246191941201687, 0.01274518109858036, 0.03153643012046814, 0.012092873454093933, -0.08751077204942703, -0.010815482586622238, -0.03536350652575493, 0.017092637717723846, 0.024271991103887558, 0.0201839841902256, 0.06769255548715591, -0.06054080277681351, -0.023450208827853203, -0.012169630266726017, -0.03142765164375305, -0.025058593600988388, -0.03821146860718727, 0.014196005649864674, -0.07371607422828674, 0.025653593242168427, -0.06096091866493225, 0.03926309570670128, 0.015021353028714657, 0.04719696193933487, -0.04966307058930397, -0.025356577709317207, 0.01878899335861206, 0.05763564631342888, 0.024943040683865547, 0.011522208340466022, 0.007075308356434107, -0.01762903295457363, 0.025216104462742805, -0.026887349784374237, -0.004212075378745794, -0.01270091999322176, -0.031259823590517044, 0.027300555258989334, -0.009307058528065681, -0.03902579843997955, -0.025748614221811295, -0.004756397567689419, 0.03981877490878105, -0.02636956050992012, -0.012673250399529934, -0.002146347425878048, 0.03175665810704231, -0.04712476208806038, -0.06745060533285141, -0.07336851954460144, -0.0568922720849514, -0.04588190093636513, 0.018562570214271545, 0.034191157668828964, -0.03175147622823715, -0.04169001430273056, 0.013584785163402557, 0.055839333683252335, 0.055765390396118164, -0.004201064817607403, -0.013046171516180038, 0.004043385852128267, 0.017405297607183456, 0.052157074213027954, -0.037519264966249466, -0.07122216373682022, 0.035005778074264526, -0.005222612526267767, 0.03596865385770798, -0.055815812200307846, 0.05935130640864372, 0.017261574044823647, 0.04270528256893158, -0.08360278606414795, 0.03464336693286896, 0.06136976554989815, 0.005071769002825022, 0.0154050812125206, 0.027553586289286613, -0.01938377320766449, 0.02938954345881939, -0.04408368468284607, 0.04492783918976784, 0.02601650357246399, -0.008084841072559357, 0.00845101848244667, -0.013116794638335705, -0.02269834466278553, 0.015620642341673374, 0.04752388969063759, -0.07141450047492981, -0.01081803161650896, 0.04687737673521042, 0.0018010210478678346, 0.010530729778110981, -0.060717105865478516, 0.019979212433099747, 0.016615355387330055, -0.009041774086654186, -0.009282596409320831, -0.05002764239907265, 0.005430144723504782, -0.039693161845207214, 0.02217760868370533, -0.03882788121700287, -0.03490348160266876, 0.021591180935502052, 0.0015429912600666285, -0.011680887080729008, -0.024651072919368744, 0.029852621257305145, 0.03257827088236809, -0.01896444894373417, -0.021291179582476616, -0.0688270851969719, -0.012899396009743214, -0.0407746359705925, 0.03127443417906761, 0.04059964790940285, 0.012309867888689041, -0.006488814949989319, 0.008784848265349865, -0.06804201006889343, -0.013864153996109962, 0.006653348915278912, -0.028682736679911613, 0.021539755165576935, -0.06627782434225082, 0.05090351030230522, 0.025892145931720734, -0.0053250170312821865, 0.02135833539068699, 0.03516767919063568, 0.023572353646159172, -0.062164515256881714, -0.04104034602642059, -0.03178940713405609, 0.029588354751467705, -0.07306260615587234, -0.04524782672524452, 0.031545717269182205, 0.009337324649095535, 0.011227806098759174, 0.014151426032185555, 0.03771376982331276, 0.05215804651379585, 0.05407048016786575, 0.034930549561977386, -0.040401019155979156, -0.022221220657229424, 0.001407336792908609, 0.0579264871776104, -0.04030397906899452, 0.03267468884587288, -0.032957401126623154, -0.060737233608961105, 0.02127566747367382, -0.032858218997716904, 0.029636263847351074, -0.025695357471704483, -0.03182898089289665, -0.030169058591127396, 0.004238115157932043, -0.004164670128375292, -0.06953822076320648, 0.026533514261245728, 0.011778508313000202, -0.05316049978137016, -0.011245699599385262, 0.056874193251132965, -0.025532187893986702, -0.05988429859280586, 0.07582269608974457, 0.037213150411844254, -0.013312751427292824, -0.014160643331706524, 0.07164458185434341, 0.0687272697687149, -0.011087249033153057, 0.04304073005914688, 0.014136141166090965, 0.019124779850244522, 0.05162544548511505, -0.0158364400267601, 0.0076259830966591835, 0.033825475722551346, 0.02044435404241085, -0.006646654102951288, -0.05127371475100517, -0.02754763327538967, 0.06602783501148224, -0.024917121976614, -0.023809529840946198, -0.005026726983487606, -0.05282263830304146, 0.050924066454172134, -0.029721641913056374, -0.039661068469285965, 0.004038562066853046, -0.0059000966139137745, -0.025817401707172394, -0.038521721959114075, -0.03498908877372742, 0.000009747409421834163, -0.016225052997469902, -0.029413707554340363, -0.05958517640829086, 0.009285084903240204, -0.04924539104104042, -0.08130212873220444, 0.03504631668329239, -0.01988145150244236, -0.016650687903165817, -0.025362852960824966, -0.04010026156902313, 0.048866815865039825, 0.02616436593234539, -0.04253324121236801, -0.03696947172284126, -0.010657529346644878, 0.0042409165762364864, 0.032482124865055084, -0.023828813806176186, -0.008868192322552204, -0.01251795794814825, -0.0000760010298108682, 0.013319366611540318, -0.055973753333091736, -0.014947284944355488, -0.05023135617375374, 0.02954844757914543, -0.017779365181922913, -0.05436776950955391, -0.012257130816578865, -0.004163417499512434, 0.020887987688183784, 0.023664096370339394, 0.011234566569328308, 0.012539798393845558, -0.045935340225696564, 0.03114509955048561, 0.015974614769220352, 0.024518655613064766, -0.056635744869709015, 0.03846771642565727, 0.03913399949669838, -0.025297032669186592, 0.02656799741089344, 0.031988367438316345, -0.03574991226196289, -0.03184263035655022, -0.03375391289591789, -0.025213059037923813, 0.022284619510173798, -0.03468770161271095, -0.06380127370357513, -0.06082553043961525, -0.0040395138785243034, -0.047115955501794815, 0.02684725634753704, 0.03985890746116638, -0.024638496339321136, 0.03725438192486763, -0.0670677199959755, 0.0009911261731758714, -0.016475878655910492, -0.02242286317050457, -0.03838833421468735, -0.0599818229675293, -0.0006576331215910614, -0.06380974501371384, 0.02984178625047207, 0.04167485609650612, -0.05124503746628761, 0.023082325235009193, -0.07576079666614532, -0.031058087944984436, 0.004708909895271063, 0.0186312235891819, -0.004383459221571684, -0.05327640473842621, -0.029644595459103584, -0.007969801314175129, -0.021799668669700623, -0.018771151080727577, -0.022229012101888657, 0.036524802446365356, 0.04328697547316551, 0.0007646425510756671, -0.048850879073143005, -0.00566518772393465, 0.015943201258778572, -0.06499826908111572, -0.014994156546890736, -0.028478574007749557, -0.012188468128442764, 0.04296501353383064, -0.008564011193811893, 0.016351711004972458, -0.05306188389658928, 0.047164347022771835, -0.049282316118478775, 0.030925584957003593, -0.05582282692193985, -0.06349071860313416, 0.000167244637850672, -0.04259353131055832, -0.003323804819956422, 0.05140293017029762, -0.026395220309495926, -0.002354825148358941, 0.002691050060093403, -0.03827898949384689, 0.06903965026140213, -0.02550438977777958, -0.020740464329719543, 0.04180177301168442, -0.04759697616100311, 0.010933897458016872, -0.024766825139522552, -0.016623277217149734, -0.003061885479837656, 0.06648731231689453, 0.04259074106812477, -0.009500227868556976, 0.008227085694670677, -0.0748896598815918, -0.004448567982763052, -0.02313137613236904, 0.008110316470265388, -0.005988525692373514, 0.055791810154914856, 0.03008117526769638, -0.022250451147556305, -0.035206712782382965, -0.03734109178185463, -0.038081757724285126, -0.06067051738500595, -0.029229560866951942, -0.02313716523349285, 0.03460906818509102, -0.02923007868230343, -0.014372359029948711, 0.009596269577741623, 0.033699844032526016, -0.0056113023310899734, 0.02664221078157425, -0.0329044945538044, 0.005128958728164434, -0.037291835993528366, 0.048477787524461746, -0.01605963334441185, -0.010554206557571888, -0.00008719639299670234, -0.01971975527703762, 0.016182079911231995, -0.012273718602955341, -0.034692827612161636, 0.0039008145686239004, 0.0034915339201688766, -0.04730076715350151, -0.007753854151815176, 0.005492059979587793, -0.011135464534163475, 0.02429751120507717, -0.01842169091105461, 0.02840897999703884, -0.025623319670557976, -0.034124504774808884 ]
Reliability quantification of deep reinforcement learning (DRL)-based control is a significant challenge for the practical application of artificial intelligence (AI) in safety-critical systems. This study proposes a method for quantifying the reliability of DRL-based control. First, an existing method, random noise distillation, was applied to the reliability evaluation to clarify the issues to be solved. Second, a novel method for reliability quantification was proposed to solve these issues. The reliability is quantified using two neural networks: reference and evaluator. They have the same structure with the same initial parameters. The outputs of the two networks were the same before training. During training, the evaluator network parameters were updated to maximize the difference between the reference and evaluator networks for trained data. Thus, the reliability of the DRL-based control for a state can be evaluated based on the difference in output between the two networks. The proposed method was applied to DQN-based control as an example of a simple task, and its effectiveness was demonstrated. Finally, the proposed method was applied to the problem of switching trained models depending on the state. Con-sequently, the performance of the DRL-based control was improved by switching the trained models according to their reliability.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16977v2
[ 0.0006293065380305052, -0.04369600862264633, 0.02806469425559044, -0.019208360463380814, -0.018279852345585823, 0.004040990956127644, -0.033630818128585815, -0.02632266655564308, -0.00810706615447998, -0.04528390243649483, -0.04156634956598282, -0.0368461087346077, -0.029040388762950897, -0.01894722692668438, -0.02888054959475994, 0.03426540642976761, 0.08083878457546234, 0.03751485422253609, -0.028872668743133545, 0.07219162583351135, -0.0010616882937029004, -0.03209761902689934, -0.060171496123075485, 0.04416524991393089, 0.03683432564139366, -0.004771650768816471, -0.03383386880159378, -0.0016621386166661978, -0.052239805459976196, -0.006829532328993082, 0.05353314429521561, -0.04728953167796135, -0.02929949387907982, -0.05400446429848671, -0.05053630843758583, -0.023042621091008186, -0.009264366701245308, 0.010984441265463829, 0.04286697506904602, -0.05585154518485069, 0.011195856146514416, -0.03664933145046234, -0.06194701045751572, -0.015090089291334152, 0.003106358228251338, 0.01956723816692829, -0.016815586015582085, 0.011754133738577366, -0.06797346472740173, -0.02364407293498516, -0.005862578749656677, -0.0032167916651815176, 0.012133771553635597, 0.0084029296413064, -0.03389224782586098, -0.013118093833327293, -0.007857593707740307, -0.0051230802200734615, -0.06850793957710266, -0.013941164128482342, -0.016510913148522377, -0.0328570231795311, 0.015569016337394714, -0.015153912827372551, -0.03022622875869274, 0.05186374858021736, -0.02035451866686344, -0.05560249835252762, -0.04209529981017113, -0.04064885526895523, 0.03762485831975937, -0.06926184892654419, 0.01504775881767273, -0.011116698384284973, -0.02175961248576641, -0.022519057616591454, -0.03197678551077843, -0.03650655224919319, 0.010261393152177334, -0.016539424657821655, -0.018064817413687706, 0.045901890844106674, 0.021375028416514397, 0.0311963502317667, -0.01357383094727993, -0.03333664312958717, 0.046025678515434265, 0.01879093050956726, 0.04193387180566788, -0.028425440192222595, 0.033707935363054276, -0.022084642201662064, -0.06258368492126465, 0.017950840294361115, 0.042731404304504395, -0.0009796968661248684, 0.056346479803323746, 0.004813582636415958, 0.0034393242094665766, -0.03796601668000221, -0.009194208309054375, 0.00858423300087452, -0.039876632392406464, 0.0682254433631897, 0.03949825465679169, -0.02159886062145233, 0.01835421845316887, 0.044079024344682693, -0.060692254453897476, 0.0013932238798588514, -0.012618630193173885, -0.059635914862155914, -0.016077518463134766, -0.07352397590875626, -0.028106773272156715, 0.005393103696405888, 0.07676951587200165, 0.06099474057555199, 0.040525883436203, -0.011611394584178925, -0.06735352426767349, 0.0298643596470356, 0.05851050838828087, -0.029104121029376984, -0.0478554293513298, -0.018685033544898033, 0.04696052521467209, 0.04257659986615181, -0.009498711675405502, 0.011121026240289211, 0.0033354011829942465, 0.05094063654541969, 0.009300660341978073, -0.013618092983961105, 0.04640074074268341, -0.02852475270628929, 0.017909007146954536, -0.06648047268390656, 0.02739737741649151, -7.484186426154338e-7, 0.008263563737273216, -0.06924732774496078, 0.052659086883068085, -0.025878166779875755, 0.025992678478360176, 0.0343802347779274, -0.030963266268372536, -0.04813046008348465, -0.0056846654042601585, 0.03535231947898865, -0.01352034229785204, -0.009086335077881813, 0.041705116629600525, 0.0028996241744607687, -0.01189885102212429, -0.03182408586144447, 0.06822757422924042, -0.05022984370589256, -0.04009569063782692, 0.0006362884305417538, 0.07890130579471588, -0.00974942184984684, -0.015044597908854485, -0.03508882597088814, -0.005081642419099808, 0.013422193005681038, 0.044527120888233185, 0.030598502606153488, -0.0071616750210523605, 0.02889774553477764, -0.009341953322291374, -0.012215159833431244, 0.01637609302997589, 0.0032059999648481607, -0.06953554600477219, -0.04925861582159996, 0.027252232655882835, -0.03406809642910957, -0.05459720268845558, -0.0024108546786010265, 0.01301592867821455, 0.05162165313959122, 0.0014110247138887644, 0.011875549331307411, -0.041595716029405594, 0.019423866644501686, -0.08082374930381775, -0.005346477031707764, 0.013968470506370068, 0.004305539187043905, -0.04616519808769226, -0.04979534074664116, 0.03997298330068588, -0.003817120101302862, -0.03142149746417999, -0.042702239006757736, -0.020617708563804626, 0.01566583663225174, 0.008369176648557186, 0.0009454217506572604, -0.08586189895868301, -0.0050960262306034565, -0.07056218385696411, 0.016948528587818146, -0.030413705855607986, -0.05578751862049103, 0.00857632141560316, 0.0258523840457201, -0.04867211729288101, -0.030901974067091942, 0.05075678601861, 0.01470200251787901, 0.050643954426050186, 0.03402053192257881, 0.05585239827632904, -0.014794767834246159, -0.09478221088647842, 0.025840066373348236, 0.004678000696003437, 0.04680090770125389, 0.05913858115673065, 0.012222448363900185, 0.028117386624217033, -0.013384773395955563, 0.03061234951019287, 0.03661155700683594, 0.043332457542419434, -0.011073884554207325, -0.07489996403455734, -0.01990080252289772, -0.0022924880031496286, -0.06073005124926567, -0.037756405770778656, -0.07205163687467575, -0.04616011679172516, -0.012505472637712955, -0.02935931831598282, 0.059581365436315536, 0.016266409307718277, -0.057783931493759155, -0.040784794837236404, -0.023263826966285706, 0.013537357561290264, -0.007277755998075008, -0.03405830264091492, -0.04079978168010712, -0.03199852257966995, 0.02096240594983101, 0.011014971882104874, 0.015705717727541924, -0.038820408284664154, -0.02522934600710869, -0.027172794565558434, -0.031292978674173355, 0.033728472888469696, 0.05520344898104668, -0.006191368214786053, 0.037033822387456894, -0.011554279364645481, 0.0661209300160408, 0.05043601989746094, 0.05056816712021828, -0.07520050555467606, 0.019792752340435982, 0.009257120080292225, -0.020583683624863625, -0.04671751335263252, -0.0057111163623631, 0.0034365346655249596, -0.057118337601423264, -0.009364075027406216, 0.01735011488199234, -0.009968063794076443, 0.006313899997621775, -0.004939720965921879, -0.041264597326517105, -0.005064783617854118, -0.0202559195458889, 0.05783689767122269, 0.0019958033226430416, 0.013667091727256775, 0.03561312332749367, 0.030581088736653328, -0.06646709144115448, -0.017020441591739655, -0.06056883931159973, -0.02364208549261093, -0.0732148289680481, -0.06452901661396027, -0.03473157808184624, -0.07626906037330627, -0.047340862452983856, -0.008353482000529766, -0.029770908877253532, -0.012528280727565289, -0.06938867270946503, -0.0405588261783123, 0.023157456889748573, 0.041153062134981155, -0.040863845497369766, -0.04955046623945236, -0.04605255648493767, 0.0001062706796801649, 0.019409099593758583, 0.01642070896923542, -0.03589529171586037, -0.04045870155096054, -0.055348653346300125, 0.053484074771404266, 0.03611135855317116, -0.010728457942605019, 0.033864233642816544, 0.00591396214440465, 0.009197193197906017, -0.034850891679525375, 0.02049357444047928, 0.04691823944449425, 0.007407981902360916, -0.010747285559773445, -0.046335767954587936, 0.029779352247714996, -0.019507844001054764, -0.01687462627887726, -0.02657424286007881, -0.0029585366137325764, -0.032847046852111816, 0.06418278068304062, 0.022775374352931976, -0.03793453797698021, -0.020638488233089447, 0.0020535846706479788, -0.01942289061844349, 0.015084102749824524, -0.024932578206062317, 0.04866360127925873, 0.037746429443359375, -0.0166002307087183, 0.005638133268803358, 0.004013836849480867, -0.01268607098609209, -0.01710505411028862, 0.0029272777028381824, -0.02034717984497547, 0.02607078105211258, 0.025471555069088936, -0.0691700354218483, -0.012931953184306622, 0.040417131036520004, 0.07303173840045929, -0.005894535221159458, 0.032089732587337494, -0.006866593845188618, 0.016299964860081673, -0.023130027577280998, 0.01866047829389572, 0.056574854999780655, 0.037325337529182434, 0.026115113869309425, -0.025998929515480995, 0.012801445089280605, 0.02942711114883423, -0.046693406999111176, -0.03467937186360359, -0.03567817434668541, 0.02928413823246956, 0.0001569032174302265, 0.023116258904337883, -0.0661146268248558, 0.048951778560876846, -0.0003386551106814295, 0.029948363080620766, 0.011168818920850754, -0.05326119810342789, 0.050197798758745193, -0.05636114254593849, 0.04923243820667267, 0.038333598524332047, 0.04180765524506569, 0.012658142484724522, -0.06960960477590561, 0.05305385962128639, -0.07705322653055191, -0.006833931896835566, 0.012742984108626842, -0.027168359607458115, 0.0587405189871788, 0.05330486595630646, -0.013322594575583935, 0.044441062957048416, -0.00038007416878826916, 0.011189294047653675, -0.024098679423332214, 0.023521557450294495, -0.0025453183334320784, 0.029916489496827126, -0.048712290823459625, -0.0004574861377477646, 0.04656384140253067, 0.00417109252884984, -0.014484863728284836, 0.052081212401390076, 0.004500146489590406, 0.017281603068113327, -0.07562170922756195, -0.007730219047516584, -0.022137295454740524, 0.023329010233283043, -0.03545718640089035, -0.039663754403591156, 0.05435803532600403, -0.04311534762382507, 0.027912935242056847, -0.037827640771865845, -0.013584142550826073, -0.01957841031253338, -0.04399535059928894, -0.03668764978647232, -0.07028961926698685, 0.0006935587734915316, -0.03563378378748894, 0.04111604019999504, 0.032210737466812134, 0.02328910306096077, -0.050551846623420715, -0.03193814307451248, -0.0037255599163472652, 0.047428492456674576, 0.07010497897863388, 0.05180085822939873, 0.019796518608927727, 0.004687522072345018, -0.021727411076426506, -0.005389294121414423, 0.00004178566814516671, 0.018571145832538605, -0.01851867139339447, 0.03834519907832146, 0.004865354858338833, -0.015912659466266632, -0.02933700941503048, -0.002788730664178729, 0.05541346222162247, -0.009771201759576797, -0.030362747609615326, 0.022958777844905853, 0.01393844187259674, -0.06419457495212555, -0.06120244413614273, -0.03085820935666561, -0.027284132316708565, -0.03904838487505913, -0.04022340476512909, 0.028167663142085075, 0.05293932929635048, 0.015884555876255035, -0.008282179944217205, 0.0650862604379654, 0.027596861124038696, 0.013923797756433487, 0.025564121082425117, 0.03448051959276199, 0.029900819063186646, -0.010161994956433773, -0.00967355165630579, -0.0845278650522232, 0.03526555001735687, 0.010773318819701672, 0.0570797435939312, 0.01680845394730568, 0.05582313612103462, 0.03178786858916283, 0.028426678851246834, -0.08182170987129211, 0.0219382606446743, 0.022960633039474487, -0.0012571867555379868, 0.019935712218284607, 0.05968252569437027, -0.02745710499584675, 0.019656633958220482, -0.05961054563522339, -0.008786720223724842, 0.050357189029455185, -0.051295358687639236, 0.03460489958524704, -0.02888622134923935, -0.007639370858669281, 0.0055556949228048325, 0.06192796304821968, -0.012844838201999664, -0.0613241121172905, 0.005895803216844797, -0.005414565559476614, 0.039446428418159485, -0.041120752692222595, 0.019597353413701057, 0.03253685683012009, -0.014584486372768879, -0.004097611177712679, -0.02487478218972683, 0.026452425867319107, 0.01093570701777935, 0.039905548095703125, -0.03048630803823471, 0.012479087337851524, 0.027005231007933617, 0.0008621520828455687, -0.029580295085906982, 0.021722868084907532, -0.010783893056213856, 0.00005922317723161541, -0.016612857580184937, 0.006277401931583881, -0.04094819352030754, -0.02209414169192314, -0.014256864786148071, 0.0450635589659214, 0.04739075526595116, 0.02500867284834385, 0.0019015234429389238, 0.006151084788143635, -0.04913248494267464, -0.039193540811538696, -0.010668796487152576, -0.03148283809423447, 0.031243277713656425, -0.024141650646924973, 0.05961586907505989, -0.022658158093690872, 0.06321071833372116, -0.003037345828488469, 0.013850531540811062, 0.023950230330228806, 0.034188948571681976, 0.007555241696536541, -0.016937335953116417, 0.053682588040828705, -0.0552462637424469, -0.04303479567170143, 0.04834376648068428, 0.006981377489864826, -0.03694963455200195, 0.028232315555214882, 0.028709018602967262, -0.02335514687001705, 0.009280252270400524, -0.006908719893544912, -0.05077335983514786, -0.03765830770134926, 0.039130084216594696, 0.0851169303059578, -0.035058338195085526, 0.0006250583101063967, -0.014432585798203945, -0.03941822424530983, 0.0178214218467474, -0.052921000868082047, -0.045601844787597656, 0.012616060674190521, 0.035858187824487686, -0.06112596392631531, 0.056625351309776306, -0.006282595451921225, -0.08329128473997116, 0.009193864651024342, 0.04407915472984314, -0.053049683570861816, 0.011575841344892979, 0.04251011833548546, -0.02505447156727314, -0.044639259576797485, 0.06841764599084854, -0.0012117268051952124, -0.010159418918192387, -0.05113477632403374, 0.07762855291366577, 0.08640430122613907, -0.0057412320747971535, -0.022454557940363884, -0.00129010621458292, -0.039789505302906036, -0.029826048761606216, -0.007090362254530191, -0.01451809797435999, -0.017654623836278915, 0.02357211522758007, 0.03602312505245209, -0.008068839088082314, -0.048462528735399246, 0.07174111902713776, 0.012611012905836105, 0.014588932506740093, 0.027951819822192192, -0.0134924640879035, 0.04517097398638725, -0.002498326590284705, -0.025327950716018677, -0.006404504179954529, -0.05182969570159912, 0.009546288289129734, -0.05272616073489189, 0.003137448104098439, 0.023164773359894753, 0.013735502026975155, -0.02238449826836586, -0.045691702514886856, -0.013863427564501762, 0.00859685055911541, -0.018863245844841003, 0.029788121581077576, -0.03570222854614258, 0.011615492403507233, 0.0054325838573277, -0.018034987151622772, 0.01534039992839098, 0.0669238269329071, -0.06713031232357025, -0.048112187534570694, -0.0299075897783041, 0.0003537029551807791, 0.034260425716638565, 0.014229949563741684, -0.03394719958305359, -0.01881619542837143, 0.008440359495580196, -0.064168781042099, 0.010722877457737923, -0.010201718658208847, -0.01834234781563282, 0.03162530064582825, -0.01333559863269329, -0.009364284574985504, -0.060286831110715866, 0.01638214662671089, -0.024971237406134605, 0.019093908369541168, 0.01323474757373333, -0.02542996034026146, -0.07554566115140915, 0.0254781823605299, -0.03020656295120716, -0.0006372382049448788, 0.03685011714696884, 0.0004942606901749969, 0.01048938650637865, 0.015573151409626007, 0.026073351502418518, -0.034885473549366, -0.01104734092950821, 0.037096794694662094, -0.06667471677064896, -0.0151895172894001, 0.017054414376616478, -0.023823529481887817, -0.0400005467236042, -0.030372431501746178, 0.016701221466064453, -0.061950478702783585, 0.0049803974106907845, 0.05155327916145325, 0.015239936299622059, -0.01090312097221613, -0.060770295560359955, -0.00014209761866368353, -0.0023018992505967617, -0.04208395257592201, -0.0063719735480844975, -0.0042448267340660095, 0.017341438680887222, -0.06627560406923294, 0.0077139828354120255, 0.011953689157962799, -0.05227414518594742, 0.010417434386909008, -0.08683806657791138, -0.024489333853125572, 0.025022896006703377, 0.060733720660209656, 0.013259506784379482, -0.034782588481903076, 0.01283443532884121, 0.017170654609799385, -0.017971202731132507, -0.010752115398645401, 0.023960605263710022, 0.020390935242176056, 0.06703178584575653, -0.024732248857617378, -0.04918626323342323, -0.03399207442998886, 0.05967816337943077, -0.03422808647155762, 0.002469609957188368, 0.061932921409606934, 0.05548369884490967, 0.01800786331295967, -0.020419897511601448, 0.037688106298446655, -0.03152035176753998, 0.0430302731692791, -0.03716283291578293, -0.00008245385106420144, -0.009393918327987194, -0.07258667796850204, 0.03917641192674637, -0.04948137700557709, -0.013928898610174656, 0.01642836071550846, -0.041822999715805054, -0.01869308575987816, -0.02231774292886257, -0.03170892596244812, 0.016443708911538124, -0.017264116555452347, -0.006261290051043034, 0.05044900253415108, -0.016821062192320824, 0.007706140633672476, -0.020905354991555214, 0.012854453176259995, -0.04791005328297615, -0.02456730045378208, 0.00622680364176631, -0.03976522386074066, -0.008272940292954445, -0.05373996123671532, -0.01898842118680477, 0.015589733608067036, -0.013977710157632828, -0.056840937584638596, 0.0753360465168953, -0.007681240793317556, -0.0346270315349102, -0.019134029746055603, 0.004096356686204672, -0.005872602574527264, -0.07313161343336105, -0.05431035906076431, -0.06387698650360107, 0.0420445054769516, -0.020386237651109695, -0.020840918645262718, 0.026902437210083008, 0.06478306651115417, 0.02562764845788479, -0.008915821090340614, 0.04162389785051346, -0.00508303614333272, -0.010537390597164631, 0.07605816423892975, 0.022092945873737335, -0.0017324630171060562, -0.04126380383968353, 0.029926355928182602, 0.001590715372003615, 0.0014824294485151768, 0.03482383117079735, -0.00502804247662425, 0.015496381558477879, -0.053453218191862106, -0.008371195755898952, 0.00944092869758606, -0.026154307648539543, -0.012388279661536217, 0.008906322531402111, 0.03115321323275566, -0.02436158061027527, -0.026189737021923065 ]
Large language models (LLMs) are highly adept at question answering and reasoning tasks, but when reasoning in a situational context, human expectations vary depending on the relevant cultural common ground. As languages are associated with diverse cultures, LLMs should also be culturally-diverse reasoners. In this paper, we study the ability of a wide range of state-of-the-art multilingual LLMs (mLLMs) to reason with proverbs and sayings in a conversational context. Our experiments reveal that: (1) mLLMs "know" limited proverbs and memorizing proverbs does not mean understanding them within a conversational context; (2) mLLMs struggle to reason with figurative proverbs and sayings, and when asked to select the wrong answer (instead of asking it to select the correct answer); and (3) there is a "culture gap" in mLLMs when reasoning about proverbs and sayings translated from other languages. We construct and release our evaluation dataset MAPS (MulticultrAl Proverbs and Sayings) for proverb understanding with conversational context for six different languages.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08591v2
[ -0.04879266768693924, 0.012755551375448704, 0.0561206117272377, -0.01620630919933319, -0.023021887987852097, -0.0034942517522722483, -0.03675740957260132, 0.00584666570648551, -0.06828013062477112, -0.03387649357318878, -0.045532241463661194, 0.0021343412809073925, -0.05986791104078293, -0.010371783748269081, -0.048864275217056274, -0.0050888340920209885, 0.02457146905362606, 0.05703890696167946, -0.04955480247735977, -0.0001063543459167704, -0.029276298359036446, 0.041082967072725296, -0.042303018271923065, 0.02279711328446865, 0.014803060330450535, -0.022112160921096802, 0.0031597132328897715, -0.0020204598549753428, -0.01649143174290657, 0.00212844368070364, 0.06093594431877136, -0.03265450894832611, -0.053047940135002136, -0.05891172215342522, -0.042182791978120804, -0.02311882935464382, 0.021727530285716057, -0.00217338721267879, 0.010576491244137287, -0.055877991020679474, -0.0035492810420691967, -0.05060521885752678, -0.08048366010189056, -0.002595300320535898, -0.052373647689819336, -0.029544012621045113, -0.024511029943823814, -0.00958054419606924, -0.07105442881584167, -0.06328217685222626, 0.003377902787178755, 0.005595198832452297, -0.014001536183059216, 0.04714398458600044, -0.0018990404205396771, -0.01378735899925232, -0.026858236640691757, 0.019449276849627495, -0.0620817095041275, -0.029731275513768196, 0.036023471504449844, -0.024814926087856293, 0.0055631352588534355, 0.031948599964380264, -0.01748010702431202, -0.014358683489263058, -0.04854851961135864, -0.024055853486061096, 0.029491059482097626, -0.0461425706744194, 0.043290961533784866, -0.06889939308166504, -0.041350629180669785, -0.01533385831862688, -0.013574761338531971, -0.008035944774746895, -0.053399570286273956, -0.0274709053337574, -0.0044402736239135265, -0.0008978289552032948, -0.028117287904024124, 0.03221829980611801, 0.020832296460866928, -0.017971528694033623, 0.009234536439180374, -0.04703398793935776, 0.025775771588087082, -0.02083052322268486, -0.023383021354675293, -0.048694249242544174, 0.011546903289854527, -0.03960986062884331, -0.0691509023308754, -0.01304688025265932, 0.06572797149419785, -0.010295449756085873, 0.019809182733297348, 0.03240411356091499, 0.010779138654470444, -0.022242404520511627, -0.0011686983052641153, -0.049222368746995926, -0.009740577079355717, 0.020316101610660553, 0.02468773163855076, -0.050779394805431366, -0.020362162962555885, 0.0009689620928838849, -0.04999426007270813, -0.023187555372714996, -0.037220265716314316, -0.03705685958266258, 0.003627778496593237, -0.05174252390861511, -0.05107444152235985, -0.03967038169503212, 0.02519877254962921, -0.00930786319077015, -0.019926931709051132, 0.0037956079468131065, -0.07006146758794785, 0.06481721252202988, 0.006260370835661888, -0.060516245663166046, -0.01549488678574562, -0.027147013694047928, 0.03805795684456825, -0.0030960789881646633, -0.051561031490564346, 0.018052736297249794, -0.06459013372659683, -0.034268561750650406, -0.02808777429163456, -0.038544755429029465, 0.04164109379053116, -0.018689079210162163, 0.003066177014261484, -0.03908931091427803, 0.031147722154855728, -0.03540699556469917, -0.030414385721087456, -0.07868251204490662, 0.0154951186850667, -0.048124510794878006, -0.0032835255842655897, 0.02065899223089218, -0.056712888181209564, 0.011610962450504303, 0.02430896833539009, 0.028552880510687828, 0.014696674421429634, -0.023311197757720947, -0.016890384256839752, 0.033131007105112076, 0.008444330655038357, -0.011521754786372185, 0.009376746602356434, -0.01610289327800274, -0.06335634738206863, 0.017978914082050323, 0.0281091146171093, -0.013105550780892372, -0.00007062403892632574, -0.03801198676228523, -0.006265589501708746, -0.009740672074258327, 0.049268752336502075, -0.023836294189095497, -0.02442813850939274, -0.01303150225430727, 0.01273076981306076, 0.007787290029227734, 0.026909753680229187, 0.02777789905667305, -0.06787431240081787, -0.011650338768959045, 0.027895301580429077, -0.015069463290274143, -0.044571809470653534, 0.03791556879878044, -0.004373356234282255, 0.039587266743183136, -0.06843051314353943, -0.03120667114853859, -0.014110430143773556, 0.016004381701350212, -0.07216945290565491, 0.011036735028028488, 0.04343666881322861, 0.0248519629240036, -0.0568101741373539, 0.012619623914361, 0.008526898920536041, 0.023283686488866806, -0.002090470865368843, -0.007626320701092482, 0.05569047853350639, -0.022537382319569588, -0.026804978027939796, 0.05514998361468315, -0.0824505090713501, 0.019473282620310783, -0.04812740534543991, -0.04095429554581642, -0.013666346669197083, -0.03933965042233467, -0.022720225155353546, 0.03098292648792267, -0.016870668157935143, -0.020006973296403885, 0.031866732984781265, 0.03432340919971466, 0.02744969166815281, 0.05435293912887573, -0.022095033898949623, 0.051704660058021545, -0.08431337028741837, 0.05212421715259552, -0.020358897745609283, -0.01403886079788208, 0.031699661165475845, 0.018304985016584396, -0.03389406204223633, 0.050475653260946274, 0.008463244885206223, -0.02095336653292179, 0.032001346349716187, -0.03016701154410839, -0.04249296337366104, -0.01200456265360117, -0.01951480656862259, -0.057342853397130966, 0.00811855774372816, -0.0554751418530941, -0.017870888113975525, -0.04249139502644539, -0.053279221057891846, 0.04282325506210327, -0.030239589512348175, 0.008320705965161324, -0.04931926727294922, -0.023418862372636795, -0.02003958262503147, -0.010667392052710056, -0.07552500069141388, -0.05129546672105789, -0.030834577977657318, 0.03671182692050934, -0.041500117629766464, -0.022687586024403572, -0.025141460821032524, -0.07530898600816727, -0.00664638914167881, -0.002502322429791093, 0.02244054712355137, 0.030702393501996994, -0.04111875593662262, -0.0133965527638793, 0.02746066451072693, 0.05203031748533249, 0.030723299831151962, 0.0553000271320343, -0.06480569392442703, -0.004680213984102011, 0.04763292521238327, -0.023708755150437355, -0.028973232954740524, 0.0053169988095760345, 0.018450193107128143, -0.05749846622347832, 0.01692751981317997, 0.04627479612827301, 0.051121920347213745, -0.007487834431231022, -0.05703238397836685, -0.03304118290543556, 0.0031241835094988346, -0.03172672539949417, 0.0194801464676857, 0.013915624469518661, 0.053512535989284515, -0.006240381859242916, 0.0067759668454527855, -0.06995408236980438, -0.06102103367447853, -0.04845230653882027, -0.06437413394451141, -0.06894829124212265, -0.02361002191901207, -0.06278187781572342, -0.06948459148406982, -0.039761580526828766, 0.028331007808446884, -0.052326541393995285, 0.009435680694878101, -0.043064337223768234, -0.028790416195988655, -0.06021775305271149, -0.011663035489618778, -0.031825996935367584, -0.015844834968447685, -0.044508446007966995, 0.009537030011415482, -0.03200151398777962, 0.0024730393197387457, -0.03352777287364006, -0.06393959373235703, -0.05508975312113762, -0.0029922015964984894, -0.026057839393615723, -0.013495744206011295, 0.05186810344457626, -0.013532537035644054, 0.022866252809762955, -0.015273960307240486, 0.03892986848950386, -0.016545981168746948, 0.010034495033323765, -0.03768840804696083, -0.03679703176021576, 0.016912726685404778, -0.013846849091351032, -0.007294042035937309, 0.005781800951808691, -0.06014746427536011, -0.03038114123046398, 0.059511698782444, 0.039694350212812424, 0.0073883566074073315, -0.06659369170665741, -0.022069472819566727, 0.03609386458992958, -0.0008911066688597202, -0.020013578236103058, -0.013214635662734509, 0.044977545738220215, -0.051082905381917953, -0.04495494067668915, 0.017046703025698662, -0.021709615364670753, -0.0204475000500679, 0.011514835059642792, -0.07105036824941635, -0.022553497925400734, 0.01297216210514307, -0.0750139057636261, 0.03509369120001793, 0.038634296506643295, 0.06411407142877579, -0.01072466466575861, 0.008404462598264217, -0.007119510322809219, -0.01182211097329855, 0.024270908907055855, -0.0332452729344368, 0.01867431029677391, 0.05656498298048973, 0.045445822179317474, -0.044858891516923904, 0.002645568922162056, 0.03834099322557449, -0.06910532712936401, -0.023892395198345184, 0.04432163015007973, -0.011057401075959206, 0.013390938751399517, -0.017484914511442184, -0.05482708662748337, -0.007655731867998838, -0.004237722139805555, 0.01990487612783909, 0.037010736763477325, -0.06447197496891022, 0.025768641382455826, -0.05805762857198715, 0.0037920083850622177, 0.011114952154457569, -0.004487799480557442, -0.03602713346481323, 0.015915440395474434, -0.0027960853185504675, -0.04616968333721161, 0.0016988000134006143, -0.00891327578574419, -0.03236691653728485, 0.010306397452950478, 0.02168547920882702, -0.01194697618484497, 0.052919041365385056, -0.06520412862300873, -0.05893927067518234, -0.030811883509159088, -0.008075078949332237, -0.03408728167414665, -0.006482054013758898, -0.07102196663618088, -0.02826380357146263, 0.03578038513660431, -0.031904496252536774, 0.04628582298755646, 0.024309193715453148, 0.027368012815713882, -0.020073119550943375, -0.08201105147600174, 0.002318248152732849, 0.0001861385680967942, 0.04256993532180786, 0.05799055099487305, -0.038356322795152664, 0.029813172295689583, -0.054751425981521606, -0.06142304837703705, -0.008328823372721672, 0.020157016813755035, -0.0280951876193285, -0.04183996096253395, 0.043099138885736465, -0.0741654485464096, 0.0047964672558009624, -0.07993294298648834, 0.035345934331417084, -0.02176225371658802, -0.012369278818368912, 0.012519994750618935, -0.034715600311756134, -0.009257731027901173, 0.011234953999519348, 0.041059836745262146, 0.03316480293869972, -0.02285994403064251, -0.012996729463338852, 0.03657841682434082, -0.051335714757442474, -0.011777839623391628, -0.04892073571681976, -0.03009365312755108, 0.04026927053928375, -0.012145170010626316, -0.027818018570542336, 0.007665957324206829, -0.006024882663041353, 0.006903709378093481, -0.051784999668598175, -0.04029209539294243, -0.01948385313153267, 0.0391639843583107, -0.02003353461623192, -0.07761742919683456, -0.037186697125434875, -0.04204859584569931, -0.06805893778800964, -0.021184364333748817, 0.00835676770657301, 0.013650504872202873, -0.01666068658232689, -0.012237395159900188, -0.03512541949748993, 0.04568791016936302, -0.02104044519364834, 0.008485864847898483, 0.033047545701265335, -0.037321873009204865, -0.03980615735054016, -0.024839578196406364, -0.06065134331583977, -0.02445974573493004, -0.0054610129445791245, 0.015228965319693089, -0.03931432589888573, 0.018199404701590538, 0.00818947795778513, 0.06599359214305878, -0.07834364473819733, 0.04349229484796524, 0.022053800523281097, -0.025108596310019493, -0.007769112475216389, 0.043865617364645004, -0.01777808740735054, 0.04122991859912872, -0.013355027884244919, 0.044920627027750015, -0.04485973343253136, -0.02907896786928177, 0.02163366973400116, 0.005459273234009743, -0.017687294632196426, -0.04504091292619705, 0.019292153418064117, 0.0003305216378066689, -0.060398589819669724, -0.034398406744003296, 0.039301130920648575, 0.014557181857526302, -0.050637248903512955, 0.031367819756269455, 0.039449844509363174, -0.06050584837794304, -0.07554340362548828, -0.009428905323147774, -0.027056261897087097, -0.005418453831225634, 0.031042736023664474, -0.037755027413368225, 0.017189186066389084, -0.014708842150866985, -0.0539894737303257, 0.0033108540810644627, -0.009328472428023815, 0.02891252003610134, -0.002857315819710493, -0.026192057877779007, 0.035193901509046555, -0.0663665235042572, -0.011210277676582336, -0.06516581773757935, 0.06282796710729599, 0.05248655378818512, -0.011672647669911385, 0.002743885852396488, -0.058898959308862686, -0.026968326419591904, 0.00387762114405632, 0.018632225692272186, 0.008658364415168762, -0.000307342124870047, -0.05522598698735237, -0.009748190641403198, -0.02796424739062786, 0.04188593104481697, 0.05246406048536301, 0.035316240042448044, -0.021171314641833305, -0.018687434494495392, -0.03886452317237854, 0.004247335717082024, -0.01996968500316143, -0.03119894303381443, -0.011151793412864208, 0.04813963547348976, 0.051559124141931534, -0.05463855713605881, 0.042130034416913986, -0.028546860441565514, -0.021868426352739334, 0.048352114856243134, -0.005718665197491646, -0.0419129878282547, -0.046542830765247345, 0.023020613938570023, 0.04078054800629616, -0.026888903230428696, 0.05123744532465935, -0.012270379811525345, -0.03183585777878761, -0.02780134789645672, -0.032785750925540924, 0.030952125787734985, 0.05497465655207634, 0.016482319682836533, 0.0007650672923773527, 0.05630125477910042, 0.006386711727827787, -0.040173113346099854, -0.0036804042756557465, -0.023199427872896194, -0.06809447705745697, -0.006388525012880564, 0.034872040152549744, 0.05085840821266174, -0.04045242443680763, 0.04669170826673508, -0.005693224724382162, -0.03196275979280472, -0.03767910227179527, 0.042404789477586746, 0.06916553527116776, -0.06688125431537628, 0.009403722360730171, -0.01273280754685402, 0.00008303396316478029, 0.02185549959540367, 0.005997598171234131, -0.02296675369143486, 0.025280162692070007, 0.028825322166085243, 0.025842249393463135, -0.046372998505830765, -0.00460994616150856, 0.0685543417930603, -0.02140761911869049, 0.00451784348115325, 0.04578537121415138, -0.01267948653548956, 0.05608469992876053, -0.04829913377761841, -0.03301672637462616, -0.0036246655508875847, -0.03770526871085167, -0.05032871291041374, -0.028416674584150314, -0.055015794932842255, 0.016788261011242867, -0.012468031607568264, 0.0011154271196573973, -0.07338995486497879, 0.03509954735636711, -0.028071610257029533, -0.08010642975568771, 0.006472260691225529, -0.056872881948947906, 0.004662518389523029, -0.03707846626639366, 0.035062603652477264, 0.018945524469017982, 0.012295708991587162, -0.06386525928974152, -0.037306345999240875, -0.00046940858010202646, 0.020352018997073174, -0.0001149541640188545, -0.03519530966877937, -0.014927557669579983, -0.044693779200315475, 0.0012731895549222827, -0.04341365396976471, -0.01961982436478138, 0.011483848094940186, -0.015049428679049015, -0.015492580831050873, 0.04139209911227226, -0.040763553231954575, -0.042901765555143356, 0.05703560635447502, 0.008884747512638569, 0.020068755373358727, 0.02051202766597271, -0.04178851842880249, -0.059936415404081345, -0.002873052377253771, 0.041174158453941345, -0.025288403034210205, 0.008912067860364914, 0.02460775151848793, 0.05605602636933327, -0.034474145621061325, 0.0018694617319852114, -0.05580415949225426, 0.020161423832178116, 0.036054495722055435, -0.061035916209220886, 0.032166823744773865, -0.0024970124941319227, -0.06754335761070251, -0.05633171647787094, 0.0278607327491045, -0.009424812160432339, -0.047027330845594406, -0.003822113387286663, 0.026130175217986107, -0.00999368354678154, -0.016764914616942406, -0.05764966085553169, 0.008898490108549595, 0.010620825923979282, -0.029948441311717033, -0.05491263046860695, 0.017776086926460266, -0.04000270739197731, -0.04734102636575699, -0.02632901817560196, -0.03716326877474785, -0.04422399029135704, 0.010728217661380768, -0.07750232517719269, 0.00019861740292981267, -0.03481695428490639, 0.04957341402769089, 0.01742764748632908, -0.026020143181085587, 0.01010859664529562, -0.04838339984416962, 0.0389990471303463, 0.002090464113280177, -0.025187315419316292, 0.03729655221104622, 0.044400352984666824, 0.02978181466460228, -0.049858540296554565, -0.039853207767009735, 0.0497361421585083, 0.0007009200053289533, -0.020444121211767197, -0.021833496168255806, -0.010526706464588642, -0.009440851397812366, 0.009129006415605545, 0.04670674353837967, -0.03660547733306885, -0.0032001768704503775, -0.02704923041164875, 0.021414414048194885, -0.05090847238898277, -0.042280711233615875, -0.016465624794363976, -0.022109031677246094, -0.010832607746124268, 0.04825906455516815, 0.0010051894932985306, -0.05113576352596283, -0.03139640763401985, -0.04954250529408455, 0.023100294172763824, -0.03472220152616501, -0.013736000284552574, 0.027184983715415, 0.01643958128988743, -0.02001318149268627, -0.00804454181343317, -0.045635536313056946, -0.021873321384191513, 0.049254998564720154, 0.025002112612128258, -0.03639291599392891, -0.05519385635852814, -0.05426626279950142, 0.03568845987319946, -0.048287395387887955, -0.030917972326278687, -0.008560001850128174, 0.06258110702037811, -0.022047758102416992, -0.00730719743296504, -0.0016242089914157987, -0.05722411349415779, -0.01478045154362917, -0.0737769827246666, -0.028776811435818672, -0.04728797450661659, 0.032823994755744934, 0.03385337442159653, 0.010481470264494419, 0.019612720236182213, 0.011994068510830402, -0.01768634282052517, 0.0458415187895298, 0.043852198868989944, 0.0026400370988994837, -0.04069674760103226, 0.04589112848043442, 0.0385153703391552, 0.0030370380263775587, -0.04142937436699867, -0.05173526704311371, -0.009163822047412395, -0.02081780880689621, -0.0016853115521371365, -0.007823101244866848, 0.001005666796118021, -0.03533591702580452, -0.0035243951715528965, 0.024099210277199745, 0.015452026389539242, -0.04907451942563057, 0.016750168055295944, -0.0013950290158390999, -0.046505317091941833, -0.00761614041402936 ]
We compare games under delayed control and delay games, two types of infinite games modelling asynchronicity in reactive synthesis. In games under delayed control both players suffer from partial informedness due to symmetrically delayed communication, while in delay games, the protagonist has to grant lookahead to the alter player. Our first main result, the interreducibility of the existence of sure winning strategies for the protagonist, allows to transfer known complexity results and bounds on the delay from delay games to games under delayed control, for which no such results had been known. We furthermore analyse existence of randomized strategies that win almost surely, where this correspondence between the two types of games breaks down. In this setting, some games surely won by the alter player in delay games can now be won almost surely by the protagonist in the corresponding game under delayed control, showing that it indeed makes a difference whether the protagonist has to grant lookahead or both players suffer from partial informedness. These results get even more pronounced when we finally address the quantitative goal of winning with a probability in $[0,1]$. We show that for any rational threshold $\theta \in [0,1]$ there is a game that can be won by the protagonist with exactly probability $\theta$ under delayed control, while being surely won by alter in the delay game setting. All these findings refine our original result that games under delayed control are not determined.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.19985v4
[ -0.06511123478412628, 0.0033239072654396296, 0.05265700817108154, -0.0035013826563954353, 0.051626015454530716, -0.019970035180449486, -0.03388762101531029, -0.0031740630511194468, -0.024699361994862556, -0.035485390573740005, -0.03164762258529663, -0.007536315359175205, -0.0006602883222512901, -0.07448025047779083, -0.013740713708102703, -0.05475334823131561, 0.08030916005373001, 0.05404851213097572, -0.02860826998949051, 0.059779997915029526, -0.06799682229757309, 0.012851504608988762, -0.03281800448894501, 0.04238080605864525, -0.053830455988645554, -0.024942446500062943, 0.013319454155862331, 0.02998516708612442, -0.044278621673583984, 0.037924934178590775, 0.027098804712295532, -0.02706017717719078, -0.0254162959754467, -0.050521306693553925, 0.008463638834655285, 0.001772198243997991, 0.03725653141736984, 0.011632567271590233, 0.017106706276535988, -0.05466775223612785, 0.01297068689018488, -0.07668614387512207, -0.04898514598608017, -0.04605776444077492, -0.019901486113667488, -0.0015917441342025995, -0.018900921568274498, 0.025905795395374298, -0.0067237261682748795, -0.014923671260476112, 0.045302338898181915, -0.0002493856300134212, -0.04666225239634514, 0.01283472590148449, -0.03208529204130173, -0.01250095758587122, 0.007004584651440382, 0.018575070425868034, -0.04139526188373566, -0.020012160763144493, -0.02818824164569378, -0.0258021280169487, 0.020789440721273422, -0.036435071378946304, -0.0645488053560257, 0.028331130743026733, -0.041568294167518616, -0.04138997942209244, -0.04127563163638115, -0.05158965289592743, 0.04744047299027443, -0.07712996751070023, -0.028892604634165764, 0.01601223088800907, -0.05480348318815231, 0.00007740075670881197, -0.026737043634057045, -0.015920370817184448, 0.0031433298718184233, 0.01303825806826353, -0.029252249747514725, 0.0068299840204417706, 0.03932308405637741, -0.0009830950293689966, 0.014447136782109737, 0.0312652625143528, 0.07376091927289963, 0.030330324545502663, 0.019833426922559738, -0.024731427431106567, -0.03268997371196747, -0.05298817157745361, -0.08076771348714828, 0.00615300377830863, 0.04126976430416107, -0.0583808571100235, 0.057546380907297134, 0.012594872154295444, 0.018707115203142166, 0.006493285298347473, -0.000929241010453552, -0.03307786211371422, -0.07315754890441895, 0.008816640824079514, 0.01313922367990017, -0.04261382669210434, 0.016986848786473274, -0.045175664126873016, -0.04461429640650749, 0.023291360586881638, -0.01916220411658287, -0.019929181784391403, 0.02933562360703945, -0.05993439629673958, -0.05556441843509674, -0.04918844625353813, 0.024134667590260506, -0.00001758414327923674, -0.000008850595804688055, -0.01405557431280613, -0.029548782855272293, 0.05209755897521973, -0.004859460983425379, -0.003975745756179094, -0.05266904458403587, -0.03474604710936546, 0.022909104824066162, -0.03117229789495468, 0.03602520748972893, -0.006975584663450718, -0.023088358342647552, 0.025046847760677338, -0.014361985959112644, -0.031278520822525024, 0.056193757802248, 0.010756001807749271, -0.01052514836192131, -0.02280069887638092, 0.008567453362047672, -0.010647145099937916, 0.0035199769772589207, -0.05229479819536209, 0.025867760181427002, -0.022030318155884743, 0.031202340498566628, 0.03173365816473961, -0.046624306589365005, 0.012489361688494682, -0.007046104874461889, 0.008119582198560238, -0.01694386824965477, 0.004704519174993038, 0.013921605423092842, 0.009443366900086403, 0.021029168739914894, -0.01450110413134098, 0.049202512949705124, 0.004656838718801737, -0.07713386416435242, -0.009170043282210827, 0.047256845980882645, 0.0425882488489151, 0.01761314831674099, -0.0624433271586895, 0.025165632367134094, 0.00249150930903852, 0.06357021629810333, -0.05174911022186279, -0.023267552256584167, -0.04012475535273552, -0.014787347055971622, 0.06030632182955742, 0.029892845079302788, -0.03740936890244484, -0.06909693032503128, -0.05718725174665451, 0.008888750337064266, -0.04940677061676979, -0.04863841086626053, -0.007694548927247524, 0.0018674149177968502, 0.0287630632519722, -0.05282563716173172, -0.014309832826256752, -0.017038343474268913, 0.021483076736330986, -0.07790569961071014, -0.020270178094506264, 0.04514851048588753, 0.03295854479074478, -0.04261381924152374, -0.0658394917845726, -0.011676210910081863, 0.0054474095813930035, 0.024810239672660828, -0.035789743065834045, 0.002777782268822193, -0.008573265746235847, -0.04764673113822937, 0.029849985614418983, -0.08157993108034134, -0.008572166785597801, -0.05984609201550484, 0.046946413815021515, -0.011827857233583927, -0.05157856270670891, 0.04969768598675728, 0.010446878150105476, -0.023752769455313683, -0.036312054842710495, 0.06180338189005852, 0.02888355776667595, 0.028022101148962975, 0.006832699291408062, -0.00796058401465416, 0.01077821385115385, -0.08498037606477737, 0.023103995248675346, -0.040509842336177826, 0.020410822704434395, 0.028728950768709183, -0.009665622375905514, -0.008016364648938179, -0.028659773990511894, 0.034921012818813324, 0.05306286737322807, 0.05206732451915741, -0.032273970544338226, -0.04532335326075554, -0.031334180384874344, -0.016528140753507614, -0.039620086550712585, 0.026395199820399284, -0.05930253490805626, 0.011728497222065926, -0.008749720640480518, -0.057025447487831116, 0.004950452130287886, -0.05162763223052025, 0.02229006215929985, -0.05913785845041275, -0.03715894743800163, 0.04353684186935425, 0.0001306567864958197, -0.01238725334405899, -0.04613998904824257, -0.012855377048254013, -0.015861451625823975, 0.01832122728228569, 0.02055899053812027, -0.034599147737026215, -0.04994872212409973, -0.01960991695523262, -0.0529797188937664, -0.006382777821272612, 0.029562342911958694, -0.017915114760398865, 0.056999288499355316, 0.016390996053814888, 0.047235529869794846, 0.021978382021188736, 0.03586597368121147, -0.06566667556762695, -0.012694192118942738, 0.05581158772110939, -0.01397818885743618, -0.04725486785173416, -0.008532834239304066, 0.038032595068216324, -0.043850164860486984, 0.010251457802951336, 0.028277141973376274, 0.023462895303964615, 0.017582358792424202, 0.006983395200222731, -0.056140318512916565, 0.0396442636847496, -0.012791667133569717, 0.035954561084508896, -0.017561770975589752, 0.023021996021270752, 0.007213467266410589, -0.010341759771108627, -0.07285023480653763, 0.017620231956243515, 0.004981399048119783, -0.04765664413571358, -0.05985148251056671, -0.05663517117500305, -0.042705800384283066, -0.0762123242020607, -0.03234406188130379, -0.028123414143919945, -0.013634052127599716, -0.025840288028120995, -0.042260996997356415, -0.04482797160744667, -0.0023372373543679714, -0.0159600842744112, -0.03598639369010925, -0.059959378093481064, -0.04228466376662254, 0.022780850529670715, -0.024713706225156784, -0.01414064597338438, -0.062138255685567856, -0.014156174845993519, -0.04837989807128906, 0.022993482649326324, -0.03376336395740509, -0.016113299876451492, 0.003378072055056691, -0.0031305530574172735, -0.003143413458019495, -0.05412525311112404, -0.011120525188744068, 0.028650928288698196, -0.01747092232108116, -0.04109768196940422, -0.04334341734647751, 0.03167245537042618, -0.013208317570388317, -0.0017223492031916976, -0.05939776077866554, -0.04026155173778534, -0.05073869973421097, 0.03667926415801048, -0.019069621339440346, 0.029578810557723045, -0.06218358874320984, -0.040238142013549805, -0.013001812621951103, -0.020782744511961937, -0.03843868523836136, 0.015276709571480751, 0.02600046433508396, -0.06586654484272003, -0.02714414894580841, -0.03176897019147873, 0.022890126332640648, 0.019563140347599983, 0.050150711089372635, -0.018145229667425156, 0.032415855675935745, 0.003737695049494505, -0.08461768180131912, -0.022097783163189888, 0.027825605124235153, 0.01035794336348772, -0.05768068507313728, -0.03045879676938057, -0.015632562339305878, -0.04379957169294357, -0.019840633496642113, 0.03879489377140999, -0.012761825695633888, 0.03202187269926071, 0.06387320160865784, -0.037908487021923065, -0.04903634637594223, -0.006772055756300688, -0.032880302518606186, -0.02059541642665863, 0.024203866720199585, -0.012598934583365917, 0.025789299979805946, 0.011910188011825085, 0.012054124847054482, -0.028148377314209938, -0.015528029762208462, 0.04907624423503876, -0.013302236795425415, -0.029420679435133934, -0.03726095333695412, -0.06365025788545609, 0.043575167655944824, 0.0017734210705384612, 0.04458184167742729, -0.015340848825871944, -0.031804196536540985, 0.03130277991294861, -0.06701382249593735, 0.024663491174578667, 0.0024810938630253077, -0.025884635746479034, 0.04897071048617363, 0.027309933677315712, -0.062230221927165985, 0.05605859309434891, -0.047179289162158966, 0.006401798687875271, 0.03628245368599892, 0.02367326058447361, 0.020809952169656754, -0.03798171132802963, -0.04558294638991356, -0.037603799253702164, 0.03341076523065567, -0.029164409264922142, -0.01815515011548996, 0.02235371433198452, -0.020041508600115776, 0.00944120716303587, -0.07759145647287369, -0.010187066160142422, -0.04697295278310776, 0.06295035779476166, 0.03791235759854317, -0.05491248518228531, 0.07405305653810501, -0.021823877468705177, -0.030822070315480232, -0.060474295169115067, -0.02067670039832592, -0.02510588988661766, -0.03349164500832558, 0.005700688809156418, 0.010170216672122478, 0.031470656394958496, -0.06620687246322632, 0.0042039863765239716, 0.04609278216958046, -0.015826862305402756, -0.00974124576896429, -0.022321123629808426, 0.006697170902043581, 0.06085514649748802, 0.062360141426324844, 0.03397030755877495, 0.010876307263970375, -0.02355252206325531, 0.03671562671661377, -0.043677281588315964, -0.024748677387833595, -0.03087582439184189, -0.04069565236568451, 0.04856516793370247, -0.05719409137964249, -0.023506401106715202, 0.015777774155139923, -0.031980257481336594, 0.06530196219682693, -0.05408231168985367, -0.029570478945970535, -0.022384388372302055, 0.025253430008888245, -0.047106340527534485, -0.0479745976626873, -0.023441379889845848, -0.013476315885782242, -0.05746198073029518, 0.015442335978150368, -0.058914173394441605, 0.017476201057434082, -0.012890209443867207, 0.019474612548947334, 0.014700964093208313, 0.026599954813718796, -0.040804799646139145, -0.01152039784938097, 0.020383452996611595, -0.0063413772732019424, -0.02630802057683468, -0.02238883078098297, -0.058705318719148636, 0.023071270436048508, 0.009481903165578842, -0.003934009000658989, -0.0072202798910439014, 0.02497757598757744, 0.024506086483597755, 0.049672260880470276, -0.07805918157100677, -0.023984745144844055, 0.05866728723049164, -0.041826747357845306, 0.01680198311805725, 0.04354400932788849, -0.06423072516918182, 0.03364816680550575, -0.021510399878025055, 0.03046167828142643, 0.03016396053135395, -0.018031757324934006, -0.026983734220266342, 0.02874848246574402, -0.04206018149852753, -0.042176295071840286, 0.04020742326974869, -0.022320875898003578, -0.05037355050444603, -0.00779629684984684, 0.028168153017759323, 0.027211392298340797, -0.03582489863038063, 0.009210971184074879, -0.024510005488991737, -0.07585517317056656, -0.007566211279481649, -0.021828947588801384, -0.005006119608879089, 0.0031465464271605015, 0.0480252243578434, -0.05743952840566635, 0.024561885744333267, 0.07240960747003555, 0.028263844549655914, 0.016214018687605858, 0.007259228732436895, 0.0010529618011787534, -0.014030734077095985, -0.010882619768381119, 0.037973836064338684, -0.06491667777299881, 0.02957884594798088, -0.00952139962464571, 0.04940743371844292, -0.0029166731983423233, 0.0060249860398471355, -0.0040290579199790955, -0.010300117544829845, -0.060684043914079666, -0.05968688800930977, -0.00603734515607357, 0.024862704798579216, -0.003474033670499921, -0.006989393383264542, 0.02035331353545189, -0.009185872040688992, 0.04069807007908821, 0.016765045002102852, 0.01869555376470089, -0.043315209448337555, 0.018985772505402565, -0.033788640052080154, -0.010206174105405807, 0.004472259432077408, -0.025620125234127045, -0.05837421491742134, 0.024683235213160515, 0.02290923334658146, -0.017363054677844048, 0.012909077107906342, -0.002852147212252021, -0.012630281038582325, -0.049657419323921204, -0.0065315342508256435, 0.009035972878336906, -0.05804015323519707, 0.006875528488308191, 0.048708267509937286, -0.06668591499328613, 0.04789053276181221, -0.04370364174246788, -0.004121130332350731, -0.03529222682118416, -0.03389258682727814, -0.03567034378647804, 0.03796994313597679, -0.034383419901132584, -0.04660823941230774, -0.004884502850472927, -0.02878960594534874, -0.06353704631328583, -0.019589167088270187, 0.029115894809365273, -0.04532777890563011, 0.01958680897951126, 0.024556001648306847, 0.01904813013970852, -0.028570398688316345, 0.034736864268779755, -0.0008817712659947574, -0.06214657053351402, -0.0020447205752134323, 0.05725590139627457, 0.06440550833940506, -0.03821025788784027, -0.03311394900083542, -0.014056405052542686, -0.03929691016674042, 0.011624127626419067, -0.02196156047284603, -0.010228590108454227, 0.015692736953496933, 0.015822969377040863, -0.03846443444490433, -0.0015978234587237239, 0.01626967266201973, 0.0670563280582428, -0.0441918708384037, 0.044364623725414276, 0.01345233153551817, 0.02536701038479805, 0.06790008395910263, -0.0030880230478942394, -0.049143098294734955, 0.03021761029958725, 0.026566781103610992, -0.019439954310655594, -0.058067917823791504, -0.003009619889780879, -0.022072767838835716, 0.005394216161221266, 0.0005862058605998755, -0.048378389328718185, 0.002501817885786295, 0.0036221318878233433, -0.050110794603824615, -0.01325036771595478, -0.054387010633945465, 0.028864290565252304, -0.003695049090310931, 0.008718274533748627, 0.03171304613351822, 0.04937734082341194, 0.0013064133236184716, 0.0004878298786934465, -0.03635813668370247, 0.016161294654011726, 0.050056129693984985, 0.023251937702298164, 0.007627030368894339, -0.004372420720756054, 0.027134498581290245, -0.06311800330877304, -0.0015527852810919285, -0.03504231572151184, -0.06786548346281052, 0.07317697256803513, -0.011835921555757523, 0.0002478721144143492, -0.03200075775384903, 0.01571720279753208, -0.05423831567168236, 0.03480641171336174, 0.028574444353580475, 0.0004350774397607893, -0.06812316179275513, -0.0028502868954092264, -0.009123606607317924, -0.026512397453188896, 0.04551086574792862, 0.00993510615080595, 0.037694815546274185, 0.01626591570675373, 0.062175627797842026, 0.07031608372926712, -0.020100343972444534, 0.01272945012897253, -0.06386177241802216, -0.0005004439735785127, 0.015032928436994553, -0.035008661448955536, -0.04653462767601013, 0.02740528993308544, -0.03991024196147919, -0.03336266428232193, 0.024399003013968468, 0.03772200644016266, 0.010218980722129345, -0.03353721275925636, -0.06783845275640488, 0.02958214096724987, 0.018835343420505524, -0.03359521925449371, -0.03747840225696564, 0.03259998932480812, 0.0496966727077961, -0.03863515332341194, -0.03427178040146828, 0.036357250064611435, -0.07458534836769104, -0.03084389679133892, -0.08080761879682541, 0.01364566758275032, 0.0072347200475633144, 0.03433454409241676, -0.013211566023528576, -0.0017359268385916948, -0.013381564989686012, 0.0026178197003901005, 0.009939382784068584, 0.018354833126068115, -0.028524454683065414, 0.008452674373984337, 0.05702833831310272, 0.011777489446103573, -0.04843982309103012, -0.040249742567539215, 0.07802780717611313, -0.03832663968205452, -0.019438404589891434, 0.05313895270228386, 0.02596941590309143, 0.02014828287065029, -0.04034453630447388, 0.0354851558804512, -0.018155412748456, 0.04249313846230507, -0.05479937419295311, 0.020158572122454643, -0.01941068097949028, -0.06295934319496155, 0.015178055502474308, -0.0072404127568006516, -0.052120573818683624, 0.01746322028338909, -0.011387070640921593, -0.018844356760382652, -0.05437791347503662, -0.033203400671482086, 0.030993392691016197, 0.016926197335124016, -0.03418874740600586, 0.052087247371673584, -0.021210411563515663, -0.015936389565467834, -0.022072656080126762, -0.03510091453790665, -0.02096228301525116, 0.03282445669174194, 0.016026590019464493, -0.023078659549355507, -0.028309112414717674, -0.06252004206180573, 0.006544302683323622, 0.0027416434604674578, 0.016792919486761093, 0.022415218874812126, 0.07854864746332169, -0.0012197962496429682, -0.0037903946358710527, 0.01429365947842598, -0.030277281999588013, 0.019879374653100967, -0.0819866806268692, -0.04941238462924957, -0.021615520119667053, 0.0054030162282288074, 0.0412108488380909, 0.053936198353767395, 0.005078843794763088, -0.004948848392814398, 0.012118089012801647, 0.027800774201750755, -0.04642845690250397, 0.014470172114670277, -0.039110131561756134, 0.07225707918405533, 0.017426444217562675, 0.0009906507330015302, -0.028368359431624413, -0.00008878383960109204, 0.005469691939651966, -0.009007809683680534, -0.0035998569801449776, 0.007423699367791414, -0.02848784439265728, -0.0440717488527298, -0.00818330142647028, 0.07513038069009781, 0.018548091873526573, -0.03865588456392288, 0.0066567035391926765, 0.030661890283226967, -0.05601855739951134, -0.06084166094660759 ]
Recently, M. Ludewig and G. C. Thiang introduced a notion of a uniformly localized Wannier basis with localization centers in an arbitrary uniformly discrete subset $D$ in a complete Riemannian manifold $X$. They show that, under certain geometric conditions on $X$, the class of the orthogonal projection onto the span of such a Wannier basis in the $K$-theory of the Roe algebra $C^*(X)$ is trivial. In this short note, we clarify the geometric conditions on $X$, which guarantee triviality of the $K$-theory class of any Wannier projection. We show that this property is equivalent to triviality of the unit of the uniform Roe algebra of $D$ in the $K$-theory of its Roe algebra, and provide a geometric criterion for that. As a consequence, we prove triviality of the $K$-theory class of any Wannier projection on a connected proper measure space $X$ of bounded geometry with a uniformly discrete set of localization centers, coarsely equivalent to $X$.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00125v1
[ -0.03178437799215317, -0.0674309954047203, 0.0004871599085163325, -0.03905302286148071, 0.0021010758355259895, -0.02970585785806179, -0.05219818651676178, 0.00956410076469183, -0.024582769721746445, -0.003851968562230468, -0.002859680214896798, -0.05522485449910164, -0.03739955276250839, -0.024622339755296707, -0.06874497979879379, 0.014516770839691162, 0.06824856996536255, 0.052376456558704376, -0.05082577466964722, 0.056369002908468246, -0.02747255191206932, -0.0184488408267498, -0.0029638493433594704, 0.043478917330503464, -0.009466270916163921, -0.009671727195382118, -0.021608522161841393, -0.016623148694634438, -0.00752852950245142, 0.01183319091796875, 0.07269997149705887, -0.03720464929938316, 0.015589753165841103, -0.0332353450357914, -0.0006739281234331429, 0.008404390886425972, 0.014390392228960991, 0.018916146829724312, 0.027600277215242386, -0.0476008765399456, 0.021068532019853592, -0.019839510321617126, -0.04387836530804634, -0.056375931948423386, -0.010590225458145142, -0.02300385572016239, -0.05221765488386154, -0.007346696685999632, -0.05493282899260521, -0.0410710871219635, 0.03246467188000679, -0.012715959921479225, 0.025654993951320648, 0.050360824912786484, -0.012468746863305569, 0.01783156394958496, 0.006108949426561594, 0.00024980795569717884, -0.027653487399220467, 0.016652900725603104, -0.026495598256587982, -0.04744892194867134, 0.010841182433068752, 0.005112151615321636, -0.021062597632408142, 0.017036668956279755, -0.05832169950008392, -0.06460034847259521, 0.04345608502626419, -0.03932721167802811, 0.024526167660951614, -0.04488999769091606, -0.0038977337535470724, -0.02919086255133152, -0.07626789808273315, 0.04644724354147911, -0.008754828944802284, -0.048464734107255936, -0.01563815400004387, -0.009255202487111092, 0.0010132815223187208, -0.032760269939899445, -0.019669681787490845, 0.011271470226347446, 0.04999151453375816, 0.015022140927612782, 0.06112892925739288, -0.044856831431388855, 0.01728314347565174, -0.06948456168174744, -0.016476083546876907, -0.02419896051287651, -0.07326897978782654, -0.007868364453315735, 0.055647872388362885, -0.05510477349162102, 0.0427500382065773, 0.047890301793813705, 0.04044302925467491, 0.004403997212648392, -0.01617225632071495, -0.0650821179151535, 0.014079887419939041, 0.0030451363418251276, 0.031778741627931595, 0.002316744066774845, -0.0053521012887358665, 0.025984618812799454, -0.04940596595406532, 0.03073035553097725, -0.004962978884577751, 0.03212610259652138, 0.0012858217814937234, -0.03492249548435211, -0.03178713470697403, -0.06338836252689362, 0.050806619226932526, 0.055115990340709686, 0.05033152922987938, 0.013336336240172386, -0.025062281638383865, 0.015662608668208122, 0.001966115552932024, -0.0408148430287838, -0.058306146413087845, -0.05794033035635948, 0.038828641176223755, 0.01913001760840416, 0.00023185042664408684, 0.0031307036988437176, -0.0224180705845356, -0.03978584706783295, 0.03164101392030716, -0.023388028144836426, 0.0032315640710294247, 0.007016701623797417, 0.011414146982133389, -0.032571323215961456, 0.0009174203150905669, 0.05535752698779106, -0.03785090520977974, -0.062460675835609436, 0.016975976526737213, 0.012880043126642704, 0.0031342636793851852, 0.04678461328148842, -0.059092991054058075, 0.016467852517962456, 0.020333027467131615, 0.015335386618971825, 0.005144472699612379, 0.009362640790641308, 0.012747653760015965, 0.01804558001458645, -0.016066668555140495, -0.0508648082613945, 0.043717142194509506, 0.027526026591658592, -0.05275532230734825, 0.02854975499212742, 0.05977237969636917, -0.006889832206070423, -0.008097033947706223, -0.005731469020247459, 0.0013998846989125013, 0.038728706538677216, 0.03318910673260689, -0.04370575398206711, 0.009558969177305698, 0.04046139121055603, -0.032753027975559235, -0.008639373816549778, -0.0014623241731896996, -0.013769526034593582, -0.0475417822599411, -0.037103280425071716, -0.04015615954995155, -0.06008743867278099, -0.04131264239549637, -0.012140251696109772, -0.009465613402426243, -0.039191871881484985, -0.0024949773214757442, 0.031124133616685867, -0.06651884317398071, -0.007313946727663279, -0.05484722927212715, 0.024797406047582626, -0.017430966719985008, 0.011927119456231594, 0.025215638801455498, -0.028171252459287643, -0.004122801125049591, 0.023481637239456177, -0.0588303804397583, -0.023020464926958084, -0.009397242218255997, -0.05380363389849663, -0.038198649883270264, 0.007801190484315157, -0.057821664959192276, -0.01228389423340559, -0.011429957114160061, 0.02695462480187416, -0.014904324896633625, -0.0719531998038292, -0.012412212789058685, 0.058650121092796326, -0.02157316356897354, -0.05979302152991295, 0.05987481400370598, 0.014230533502995968, 0.06448480486869812, -0.049108415842056274, 0.022361747920513153, -0.001488803536631167, -0.08381342142820358, 0.03827119618654251, -0.017158575356006622, -0.01475550141185522, 0.002823830349370837, 0.02204079180955887, -0.037581805139780045, -0.049958985298871994, -0.051712874323129654, 0.06437139213085175, 0.017165301367640495, 0.013162320479750633, -0.052800968289375305, -0.061385396867990494, -0.0023239769507199526, -0.05835912376642227, -0.03317464515566826, -0.055352501571178436, -0.04862836375832558, -0.011724312789738178, -0.017224783077836037, 0.05215016379952431, -0.03623104840517044, -0.04253990948200226, -0.06452515721321106, 0.040421098470687866, 0.020341593772172928, -0.027397019788622856, -0.054891377687454224, -0.06035519391298294, -0.030289998278021812, -0.0011781711364164948, -0.010935510508716106, 0.014626028947532177, 0.027181537821888924, -0.04730004817247391, 0.0005183954490348697, -0.06324812769889832, 0.05003819242119789, 0.036586251109838486, 0.010447331704199314, 0.03568753972649574, -0.024536408483982086, 0.040517061948776245, 0.011273053474724293, 0.04183182865381241, -0.0517185814678669, -0.043513912707567215, -0.015665920451283455, -0.00515261385589838, -0.04758622497320175, -0.03343809396028519, -0.031110191717743874, -0.0015847728354856372, 0.01621575839817524, -0.04048750177025795, 0.05028841271996498, -0.03107641078531742, 0.015480364672839642, -0.017479829490184784, -0.03809104487299919, -0.004665023181587458, 0.02102777734398842, -0.006252531427890062, 0.06304313242435455, 0.03446333855390549, -0.02997675910592079, -0.07531572133302689, -0.03335494175553322, -0.0018146027578040957, -0.046108800917863846, -0.04051199555397034, -0.0513281375169754, -0.024574054405093193, -0.05324792489409447, 0.043946146965026855, -0.03929101303219795, -0.051760800182819366, -0.06897082924842834, -0.05587638169527054, 0.0019542397931218147, 0.009130925871431828, 0.009981394745409489, -0.06324145197868347, -0.024297745898365974, -0.02503339573740959, -0.01926695741713047, 0.0023352059070020914, -0.049470193684101105, -0.047358401119709015, 0.005330007988959551, 0.007816738449037075, -0.04052083566784859, 0.007816045545041561, -0.023235682398080826, 0.014293067157268524, -0.02770821750164032, -0.04185503348708153, 0.029081212356686592, 0.038570988923311234, -0.005274862051010132, -0.024147216230630875, 0.02475147321820259, -0.01988615095615387, -0.024344805628061295, -0.04691918566823006, 0.027567796409130096, -0.04014544561505318, -0.06480130553245544, -0.0475757010281086, 0.04785032570362091, 0.05982870236039162, -0.04354605823755264, -0.013311291113495827, -0.040249552577733994, -0.0103874821215868, 0.03714153170585632, 0.006405962165445089, 0.031992096453905106, 0.03374994918704033, -0.030197110027074814, -0.010588163509964943, -0.042968474328517914, 0.012851904146373272, -0.013635619543492794, 0.04867066442966461, 0.01795087195932865, 0.017307955771684647, -0.008727535605430603, -0.07630293071269989, 0.06404916942119598, 0.04001804068684578, 0.05091436207294464, -0.014078750275075436, -0.003373668994754553, 0.031289778649806976, 0.014166045002639294, -0.010318617336452007, -0.02467169053852558, 0.02819172479212284, 0.026107240468263626, 0.0491752065718174, -0.05256832763552666, -0.039741579443216324, -0.034244682639837265, -0.05538336560130119, 0.020411277189850807, 0.03744088113307953, 0.02972906269133091, 0.0414254292845726, 0.025852901861071587, -0.012652619741857052, 0.02916693687438965, -0.01821090467274189, 0.05653363838791847, -0.04865839704871178, -0.02934596687555313, 0.0059630367904901505, -0.009429083205759525, -0.04461277648806572, 0.009019146673381329, -0.025943517684936523, -0.032935887575149536, -0.02763340249657631, 0.011960954405367374, -0.021507199853658676, 0.03217199072241783, -0.008383037522435188, -0.020718209445476532, -0.018322693184018135, -0.04136406630277634, -0.014494838193058968, -0.011053078807890415, -0.014063644222915173, 0.039090026170015335, -0.04346668720245361, 0.03840278461575508, -0.04362815245985985, 0.004651429131627083, -0.04693639278411865, 0.02026713825762272, -0.03791498765349388, -0.06709480285644531, -0.03264682739973068, 0.020971884950995445, -0.00033587950747460127, -0.0452287495136261, -0.07095307111740112, -0.04127112403512001, -0.05859898403286934, -0.005803206004202366, -0.015777243301272392, -0.0664588063955307, 0.06610853970050812, 0.02604334056377411, -0.0070331827737390995, 0.018415113911032677, -0.02259955182671547, 0.011160220019519329, -0.035733044147491455, -0.06105835363268852, -0.010281161405146122, 0.016774475574493408, -0.039174556732177734, 0.03218628838658333, -0.030256429687142372, 0.005115593783557415, -0.06765463203191757, 0.026656605303287506, -0.008248104713857174, 0.04135928675532341, 0.02560657262802124, 0.057722657918930054, 0.056923773139715195, -0.026797423139214516, -0.01641467772424221, -0.03737984970211983, -0.042848747223615646, -0.022552816197276115, -0.03154988959431648, 0.049019720405340195, -0.050707608461380005, -0.016695603728294373, -0.03829265758395195, -0.01155129261314869, 0.009379617869853973, -0.047820888459682465, -0.0426202230155468, 0.008308333344757557, 0.03344652056694031, -0.058599311858415604, -0.05620617792010307, -0.004913094453513622, 0.007323284633457661, -0.06440386921167374, 0.02501627989113331, -0.02285563200712204, -0.011654658243060112, -0.013442586176097393, 0.021109163761138916, -0.004977589473128319, 0.011156699620187283, -0.03904857486486435, 0.007678125984966755, 0.051803529262542725, 0.010053806938230991, -0.04920050874352455, -0.020644547417759895, -0.07242853194475174, -0.013464721851050854, -0.045273300260305405, 0.005041536409407854, 0.00013191584730520844, 0.03658987581729889, -0.01952875219285488, 0.0026520048268139362, -0.07776445150375366, 0.03261857107281685, 0.034746501594781876, -0.03324906900525093, 0.049879658967256546, 0.024873973801732063, -0.0376756377518177, -0.0057701305486261845, 0.011448511853814125, 0.0016847850056365132, 0.005337333772331476, -0.013509232550859451, -0.01953573152422905, -0.014168285764753819, -0.04462515190243721, 0.03745730221271515, 0.028579242527484894, -0.03645011782646179, -0.023523161187767982, -0.03387534245848656, -0.025699427351355553, -0.016837554052472115, -0.04610660672187805, 0.04068144038319588, 0.05090170353651047, -0.04786650463938713, -0.047397203743457794, 0.022078054025769234, -0.05411509424448013, 0.03031289391219616, 0.019765669479966164, -0.016840994358062744, 0.023362701758742332, 0.006863550748676062, -0.04387914016842842, 0.014807981438934803, 0.022072477266192436, -0.010936407372355461, -0.021717198193073273, -0.003329882165417075, -0.049360450357198715, -0.012609208934009075, -0.01059766486287117, 0.02505285106599331, 0.031714946031570435, 0.04480816423892975, 0.03704587742686272, 0.04184463992714882, 0.015612351708114147, -0.000541286077350378, -0.02858424000442028, -0.009327148087322712, -0.00802305992692709, 0.05459203943610191, -0.05818331241607666, 0.010274781845510006, -0.03237667307257652, 0.013922065496444702, -0.018919138237833977, -0.03160063922405243, -0.017152603715658188, 0.004573043901473284, -0.0503351166844368, -0.030039118602871895, 0.0013913563452661037, 0.009902414865791798, -0.04045872017741203, -0.005058858077973127, 0.05378463864326477, -0.060152944177389145, 0.06242447718977928, 0.021490536630153656, 0.05344843491911888, 0.005351063795387745, -0.006873151287436485, 0.0616268664598465, -0.03347255289554596, -0.05951203405857086, 0.05476229265332222, -0.05415676534175873, -0.010036187246441841, -0.045516010373830795, -0.06129154935479164, -0.0395050048828125, -0.06728233397006989, 0.0079969996586442, 0.034015920013189316, 0.021921079605817795, -0.02741960436105728, 0.05742335319519043, 0.02165750041604042, -0.06706371903419495, -0.0326346829533577, 0.04131209850311279, -0.06817449629306793, 0.002133648842573166, -0.026550963521003723, -0.027989586815238, -0.05271370708942413, 0.01942775398492813, -0.031274981796741486, -0.02580440789461136, -0.025228912010788918, 0.017745664343237877, 0.05665340647101402, -0.04778778553009033, 0.05840756371617317, 0.034691959619522095, -0.016238247975707054, 0.004151028580963612, -0.06662723422050476, -0.036552395671606064, 0.004553908482193947, 0.057254984974861145, -0.02720632031559944, 0.0008196098497137427, -0.03910129889845848, 0.024017995223402977, -0.011157242581248283, -0.04361207038164139, 0.019321372732520103, 0.006952329538762569, 0.04052695259451866, 0.014145360328257084, -0.04847269877791405, -0.04159139096736908, -0.050318047404289246, -0.0037308866158127785, -0.0019380936864763498, 0.05443210154771805, -0.003212482901290059, -0.008943768218159676, -0.016759159043431282, -0.04074406623840332, -0.026715371757745743, -0.003069446422159672, -0.052681613713502884, -0.013348551467061043, -0.061081141233444214, -0.00029208126943558455, -0.028090467676520348, 0.054910287261009216, 0.0008964880253188312, -0.0030104592442512512, -0.020353542640805244, -0.0008315170998685062, -0.04472234100103378, -0.016709860414266586, -0.03653315082192421, 0.007711814250797033, 0.006970572751015425, 0.004065459594130516, 0.06733798235654831, -0.0659608468413353, 0.05223609879612923, -0.020968984812498093, -0.05394689366221428, 0.014709094539284706, -0.037816546857357025, -0.04755343124270439, -0.014135447330772877, 0.021833444014191628, -0.06590131670236588, 0.04501021280884743, 0.03416229784488678, -0.028527015820145607, -0.056183017790317535, 0.021621020510792732, 0.030620306730270386, -0.016332270577549934, -0.00844989251345396, -0.013254995457828045, -0.0146404467523098, 0.04700442776083946, 0.047671329230070114, 0.025333618745207787, 0.04266301915049553, -0.04782719537615776, -0.051983095705509186, -0.002144287806004286, -0.0078084031119942665, 0.002035588026046753, -0.027673687785863876, -0.028904778882861137, -0.05123264342546463, -0.05737403780221939, 0.06132037565112114, -0.015144423581659794, 0.04924321919679642, -0.043426454067230225, -0.02555297128856182, 0.07219283282756805, 0.015657514333724976, 0.04490412026643753, -0.07599179446697235, -0.023577624931931496, -0.009606481529772282, 0.0295387115329504, -0.029675370082259178, -0.03155061602592468, -0.06295686215162277, 0.022195307537913322, -0.07977073639631271, -0.024223120883107185, -0.012100083753466606, 0.04032948240637779, 0.006210022605955601, -0.011395403183996677, -0.032918598502874374, -0.039158519357442856, -0.02027168683707714, 0.0025485530495643616, 0.014487541280686855, 0.03693773224949837, 0.05104098096489906, -0.03102925792336464, 0.01636088266968727, 0.020748360082507133, 0.03602369502186775, -0.046435240656137466, -0.018766984343528748, 0.04212713614106178, 0.018481535837054253, -0.04963814467191696, 0.01731906086206436, 0.04727370664477348, -0.009109096601605415, 0.048817943781614304, 0.005682904738932848, -0.018552901223301888, -0.06423728168010712, -0.05500653386116028, 0.026286499574780464, -0.06961962580680847, -0.010464929975569248, -0.031172171235084534, -0.019579727202653885, -0.06055193766951561, -0.06258435547351837, -0.054970767349004745, 0.018289849162101746, 0.03900317847728729, -0.04570159688591957, 0.020409539341926575, -0.06721072643995285, -0.012362240813672543, -0.0015034762909635901, -0.004641746636480093, -0.02076040767133236, 0.0041265953332185745, 0.015487696044147015, -0.0428595095872879, 0.021076111122965813, -0.029736826196312904, 0.03258054330945015, -0.029069844633340836, 0.0039054681546986103, 0.007001894060522318, 0.062268491834402084, -0.015604319982230663, 0.04145669937133789, -0.037464819848537445, -0.030672144144773483, 0.007750836666673422, -0.060742542147636414, 0.04341050982475281, -0.05415399745106697, 0.031930532306432724, 0.017787188291549683, 0.050369519740343094, -0.019690196961164474, 0.06363065540790558, 0.023624232038855553, -0.0006299295928329229, 0.030068783089518547, 0.036632753908634186, -0.02600504457950592, 0.02079586870968342, 0.005086639430373907, -0.06011027470231056, -0.013672665692865849, 0.004986933432519436, -0.004075323697179556, -0.008668618276715279, -0.03549279645085335, -0.0035300913732498884, 0.035815492272377014, -0.058756254613399506, -0.000580997031647712, 0.03837097808718681, -0.025165949016809464, -0.03900034725666046, 0.01320845726877451, 0.0002906840236391872, -0.046323198825120926, -0.04498151317238808 ]
A millisecond pulsar (MSP) is an old neutron star (NS) that has accreted material from its companion star, causing it to spin up, which is known as the recycling scenario. During the mass transfer phase, the system manifests itself as an X-ray binary. PSR J1402+13 is an MSP with a spin period of $5.89~{\rm ms}$ and a spin period derivative of $\log\dot{P}_{\rm spin}=-16.32$. These properties make it a notable object within the pulsar population, as MSPs typically exhibit low spin period derivatives. In this paper, we aim to explain how an MSP can posses high spin period derivative by binary evolution. By utilizing the stellar evolution code \textsc{MESA}, we examine the effects of irradiation on the companion star and the propeller effect on the NS during binary evolution. We demonstrate that irradiation can modify the spin period and mass of an MSP, resulting in a higher spin period derivative. These results suggest that the irradiation effect may serve as a key factor in explaining MSPs with high spin period derivatives.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16963v1
[ -0.07326611131429672, 0.0164954774081707, 0.04317720979452133, 0.022988328710198402, -0.022004928439855576, 0.023996077477931976, 0.010791320353746414, -0.012094153091311455, -0.028310975059866905, -0.007961022667586803, -0.01424493733793497, -0.02940002642571926, -0.012014279142022133, -0.051072459667921066, -0.017501873895525932, 0.016725918278098106, 0.040055498480796814, 0.04659378156065941, -0.03365807607769966, 0.053533341735601425, 0.003375927684828639, -0.0061190263368189335, -0.04782280698418617, 0.04591246321797371, 0.018100496381521225, -0.05388758331537247, -0.0014305622316896915, 0.040008630603551865, -0.07262648642063141, -0.026336098089814186, 0.041722651571035385, 0.018352698534727097, -0.04863697662949562, -0.0071502854116261005, -0.009840859100222588, 0.011499863117933273, -0.018103420734405518, 0.07572577148675919, -0.0024776789359748363, 0.0013196059735491872, 0.008686093613505363, -0.02977980114519596, 0.010839126072824001, -0.026870671659708023, -0.028971415013074875, -0.06498140096664429, -0.07042736560106277, 0.009653688408434391, -0.0672568753361702, -0.0712343156337738, 0.017138835042715073, 0.0003247316926717758, 0.031832482665777206, 0.06307767331600189, -0.05388929694890976, -0.010292492806911469, 0.03943419083952904, -0.00825321115553379, -0.04583331197500229, 0.004190489184111357, 0.04654877260327339, 0.008874616585671902, -0.02049167826771736, -0.0585385300219059, -0.04032149165868759, 0.05282574146986008, -0.057461049407720566, -0.024804310873150826, -0.021401746198534966, -0.07575219124555588, 0.0017743405187502503, -0.07160602509975433, 0.027924859896302223, 0.052179910242557526, -0.05384654924273491, -0.024445122107863426, -0.03546122834086418, -0.023464815691113472, -0.04267766326665878, 0.037653058767318726, -0.042107317596673965, 0.01345900259912014, 0.023750489577651024, 0.044055063277482986, 0.028558675199747086, 0.008017972111701965, 0.06864733248949051, -0.026120424270629883, 0.027833566069602966, -0.05747205391526222, 0.021503735333681107, -0.031092949211597443, -0.038724370300769806, -0.028894707560539246, 0.06377089023590088, -0.0042194039560854435, 0.07860126346349716, 0.04061020165681839, 0.0012920661829411983, -0.0035636231768876314, -0.011130944825708866, 0.012986453250050545, 0.011392139829695225, 0.04796377941966057, -0.02757357433438301, -0.05261648818850517, 0.005926128942519426, 0.01982530578970909, -0.0594235360622406, 0.008120406419038773, -0.016914719715714455, -0.02627164125442505, -0.028916604816913605, -0.05230182781815529, -0.04460861533880234, -0.06798480451107025, 0.0016114788595587015, -0.026981478556990623, 0.024931907653808594, 0.027752066031098366, -0.03840106725692749, -0.006647318601608276, 0.033603325486183167, -0.04176219552755356, -0.005671646445989609, 0.006507029291242361, 0.06538300216197968, 0.0031847194768488407, -0.05323274806141853, -0.038768310099840164, -0.023501267656683922, 0.027134185656905174, 0.02428577095270157, -0.06255915015935898, 0.03857433795928955, 0.007853087037801743, 0.01016583014279604, -0.03286387026309967, 0.017575053498148918, -0.028396891430020332, 0.026726309210062027, -0.021703004837036133, -0.019906889647245407, 0.004943239036947489, 0.025948408991098404, -0.016980554908514023, -0.05797654762864113, 0.024340389296412468, 0.0318232886493206, 0.0005387846613302827, -0.03034287318587303, -0.02461293525993824, 0.002019669394940138, -0.024309292435646057, -0.018324892967939377, 0.022171596065163612, 0.05855268985033035, 0.023353641852736473, -0.0275004580616951, 0.015489032492041588, -0.025394326075911522, -0.026231056079268456, 0.029915058985352516, -0.006619503255933523, 0.048774585127830505, -0.009350507520139217, 0.0329454243183136, -0.03419509902596474, 0.011983785778284073, 0.006159758660942316, -0.019536811858415604, 0.02217905968427658, -0.014928462915122509, -0.0419333353638649, -0.056647010147571564, 0.011655274778604507, -0.03615959733724594, -0.017430055886507034, 0.03941187635064125, 0.004582966212183237, 0.020341165363788605, 0.02803262323141098, -0.04873720183968544, 0.02225729450583458, -0.07569846510887146, 0.04598801210522652, -0.07909317314624786, 0.013574079610407352, 0.05503855273127556, 0.001173311029560864, -0.02290293760597706, -0.04853391274809837, 0.03196270763874054, -0.01898258924484253, 0.015382304787635803, 0.03455308452248573, -0.008439608849585056, -0.04781867936253548, 0.01127074658870697, 0.033895641565322876, -0.052828576415777206, -0.01634480245411396, -0.07819627970457077, 0.01648506335914135, 0.023373251780867577, -0.08247573673725128, 0.021642593666911125, 0.02558843232691288, -0.04387802258133888, -0.03325699269771576, -0.02915111370384693, 0.04857341945171356, 0.007842524908483028, 0.01890365593135357, 0.031764473766088486, -0.03038557805120945, -0.09713698923587799, 0.06248415261507034, -0.0031180765945464373, -0.026431363075971603, 0.03525615110993385, -0.04402497783303261, -0.009381692856550217, -0.01648876443505287, -0.03768947720527649, -0.0022477463353425264, 0.03989056125283241, -0.014882982708513737, -0.06691992282867432, 0.01836148090660572, 0.03298881649971008, -0.03779192641377449, -0.06806742399930954, -0.07845756411552429, 0.02806774154305458, 0.011263614520430565, -0.022109445184469223, -0.006899466272443533, 0.002538535976782441, 0.020193394273519516, -0.03429986909031868, 0.003354509361088276, 0.05185888335108757, -0.025258637964725494, -0.03303533419966698, -0.020981095731258392, -0.02356550469994545, 0.03438081219792366, -0.0728594958782196, -0.03784053027629852, -0.0035014247987419367, -0.03330835700035095, -0.033714763820171356, 0.009029490873217583, 0.05653708055615425, -0.004116375930607319, -0.05069884657859802, 0.005425642244517803, -0.037029992789030075, 0.021889247000217438, -0.0462992861866951, 0.05756328999996185, -0.07015360891819, 0.03822401538491249, -0.05661848559975624, 0.03232719004154205, -0.05247845873236656, -0.026809686794877052, 0.013074497692286968, 0.04097236320376396, 0.0389573909342289, -0.003989119548350573, 0.060707587748765945, -0.0006403260631486773, 0.020974379032850266, -0.03187837451696396, -0.03786063566803932, -0.007829656824469566, -0.012510252185165882, -0.020797213539481163, 0.08161603659391403, 0.04819747433066368, 0.009365185163915157, -0.06107056885957718, 0.014328470453619957, -0.06223791465163231, -0.017360825091600418, -0.0479239784181118, -0.027354193851351738, -0.00890094693750143, -0.01966613158583641, 0.027556974440813065, -0.007198302075266838, 0.0011186384363099933, -0.011066952720284462, -0.027647346258163452, -0.002162582939490676, 0.01800689287483692, 0.002873981138691306, -0.06239313632249832, -0.05702250450849533, 0.04089706391096115, 0.017311882227659225, 0.00819509755820036, -0.05445769429206848, -0.017815029248595238, -0.022979294881224632, 0.051197271794080734, -0.046023476868867874, -0.0013077021576464176, -0.0272438395768404, 0.04554262012243271, -0.06840639561414719, -0.0582207590341568, -0.019572006538510323, 0.07192271202802658, -0.004493845626711845, -0.05975491553544998, -0.04976065456867218, -0.047005437314510345, 0.0030798716470599174, -0.005114896222949028, -0.025597894564270973, 0.029536938294768333, -0.06795340031385422, -0.04691473767161369, 0.031050177291035652, 0.07551949471235275, 0.0017472195904701948, -0.04615815728902817, -0.04864528030157089, 0.005790996830910444, -0.017990289255976677, 0.020281227305531502, 0.0688231959939003, 0.0049836295656859875, -0.04483523592352867, -0.03799530863761902, -0.05668425187468529, 0.02597128413617611, -0.03310452774167061, 0.02319682016968727, -0.009610525332391262, -0.02147536352276802, 0.012275971472263336, -0.07511527091264725, 0.022298065945506096, 0.04312530532479286, 0.06539853662252426, -0.038600269705057144, -0.005486589390784502, 0.026836542412638664, 0.0006287439027801156, 0.035371627658605576, -0.03919956088066101, 0.02773001231253147, 0.038424886763095856, 0.0017781280912458897, -0.07026685774326324, -0.020868152379989624, -0.03792142495512962, -0.06493109464645386, -0.021506432443857193, 0.02962063066661358, -0.016674382612109184, 0.021704411134123802, 0.047427836805582047, -0.006478633265942335, 0.008190866559743881, -0.04131036624312401, 0.03318514674901962, -0.02351507917046547, -0.02260664664208889, 0.007994907908141613, 0.033069975674152374, -0.03538459911942482, -0.03491969779133797, 0.03982951119542122, -0.04890735074877739, -0.02112744189798832, 0.04768781736493111, -0.03269322216510773, 0.028121700510382652, 0.019588423892855644, -0.0031017360743135214, -0.0092001399025321, 0.004276153165847063, -0.001762918196618557, 0.015303236432373524, 0.0018274933099746704, -0.014550427906215191, -0.02334892936050892, -0.03877144679427147, 0.02601277083158493, 0.009213073179125786, -0.01786908693611622, -0.04320439323782921, -0.006183507852256298, 0.019691571593284607, -0.002474757144227624, 0.02454542927443981, -0.04447867348790169, -0.011232053861021996, -0.07243001461029053, -0.014520746655762196, -0.07350197434425354, 0.03980940952897072, 0.0023668487556278706, -0.034941211342811584, 0.04392329975962639, -0.044995326548814774, -0.015799403190612793, -0.05084018036723137, -0.05662544071674347, -0.0555267408490181, -0.019984424114227295, -0.015866529196500778, -0.027251238003373146, 0.0001479533384554088, -0.05028362199664116, 0.0567500926554203, -0.01996077038347721, 0.008628743700683117, -0.0443086251616478, -0.009464451111853123, 0.0019416270079091191, 0.024315912276506424, 0.03686564788222313, 0.0015972992405295372, -0.036690063774585724, 0.011753927916288376, -0.053349923342466354, 0.00042359117651358247, 0.030397789552807808, 0.03850744664669037, -0.03826073929667473, 0.04059821739792824, -0.035688623785972595, -0.015682730823755264, 0.013782684691250324, 0.005950789898633957, 0.07112453132867813, -0.03228649124503136, -0.0065497481264173985, 0.01725814864039421, 0.033536575734615326, -0.040751371532678604, -0.042913611978292465, -0.051650773733854294, -0.04736737161874771, -0.07166434079408646, -0.012355544604361057, 0.027344446629285812, -0.053726475685834885, -0.02496693655848503, 0.014591389335691929, 0.02809968590736389, 0.02959929220378399, -0.03206263482570648, 0.017662152647972107, 0.024485602974891663, 0.014743953943252563, 0.036943644285202026, -0.008441932499408722, -0.07778792083263397, 0.00463412469252944, -0.022501591593027115, -0.031173916533589363, -0.004593749064952135, -0.01922055520117283, -0.026043085381388664, 0.05833284184336662, -0.08245296031236649, 0.05459766462445259, 0.03884720429778099, -0.01899019628763199, 0.019539382308721542, 0.06338728219270706, -0.015329216606914997, 0.03431151062250137, -0.0018166297813877463, 0.00029022726812399924, -0.0008601305307820439, -0.051769908517599106, 0.01465543918311596, 0.003732740180566907, -0.04811903089284897, 0.0023700466845184565, -0.005432804115116596, -0.025248868390917778, -0.02400846779346466, -0.036713793873786926, 0.04042668640613556, -0.017011089250445366, 0.004950250964611769, 0.058187004178762436, 0.025176825001835823, -0.024714143946766853, -0.06482475996017456, -0.014320088550448418, -0.02181023173034191, -0.002056528115645051, 0.03981245309114456, -0.029823262244462967, -0.0027513804379850626, -0.024886826053261757, 0.06090559810400009, 0.01635264791548252, 0.024037327617406845, 0.011571594513952732, 0.01994485966861248, 0.023990176618099213, 0.04441099241375923, -0.057063646614551544, 0.008836708962917328, -0.08681327104568481, -0.00604301318526268, -0.022062623873353004, 0.015248007141053677, 0.07083243131637573, 0.06060153618454933, 0.004674970172345638, -0.034625083208084106, -0.044832438230514526, -0.031175216659903526, 0.041400473564863205, 0.04343206062912941, -0.00972017738968134, 0.007214741315692663, 0.02783242240548134, -0.005406900309026241, -0.021759822964668274, 0.05901963636279106, -0.0021729571744799614, -0.049885645508766174, 0.006950410548597574, -0.01033984124660492, -0.014337185770273209, -0.05887690559029579, -0.01376135554164648, -0.014269878156483173, -0.009656543843448162, 0.07901497930288315, 0.0455479621887207, -0.003684499766677618, 0.034835461527109146, -0.004138907417654991, 0.04228892922401428, -0.06617455929517746, 0.02176246978342533, 0.06879368424415588, -0.041485950350761414, 0.010316397994756699, -0.053475864231586456, -0.0026521284598857164, 0.03831182420253754, -0.035799067467451096, -0.020075375214219093, 0.022412968799471855, -0.008721842430531979, -0.03955920785665512, 0.056895434856414795, 0.015813583508133888, -0.07510912418365479, -0.005688714794814587, 0.02793300896883011, -0.0742775946855545, -0.012289971113204956, 0.019136665388941765, 0.005632670130580664, -0.025843366980552673, -0.006456148810684681, -0.06441736966371536, -0.04937295615673065, -0.041312139481306076, 0.05467094108462334, 0.06382030993700027, -0.015901004895567894, -0.002460713032633066, 0.02594873309135437, -0.05836557224392891, -0.008210579864680767, -0.0017890557646751404, -0.01608470268547535, -0.0053137498907744884, 0.048829663544893265, 0.023219751194119453, -0.008121338672935963, -0.009036323055624962, -0.00232716859318316, -0.04377736896276474, -0.010795444250106812, -0.017254319041967392, 0.033995699137449265, 0.030671797692775726, -0.048509012907743454, -0.030897488817572594, -0.0077251349575817585, -0.04781046882271767, 0.03703318536281586, -0.02737925387918949, -0.002586072077974677, 0.02564254030585289, 0.013187753967940807, 0.03642342612147331, -0.060402486473321915, 0.016624581068754196, -0.05430276319384575, -0.05014561489224434, 0.033520061522722244, -0.02475813403725624, -0.004992710426449776, 0.011038078926503658, 0.009395204484462738, -0.014080487191677094, 0.021449752151966095, -0.05760098993778229, 0.022845672443509102, -0.05238976329565048, -0.008005991578102112, -0.011751576326787472, 0.01566816121339798, 0.02963152341544628, -0.0006107958615757525, 0.08295050263404846, -0.02914804220199585, -0.02396032214164734, -0.04617684707045555, -0.028503477573394775, 0.02744363248348236, -0.013935006223618984, -0.04115086793899536, -0.010270609520375729, -0.01463364064693451, -0.04775197431445122, 0.000512211408931762, -0.023462418466806412, -0.02580518275499344, -0.04981613904237747, -0.03142227232456207, -0.01668679527938366, -0.015356875956058502, 0.05800838768482208, 0.0064631314016878605, 0.06043127551674843, -0.018238019198179245, 0.030258378013968468, 0.04078439250588417, -0.010570251382887363, -0.01258101500570774, -0.029469551518559456, 0.021257642656564713, 0.040932655334472656, -0.004688590299338102, -0.014829603023827076, 0.01228505652397871, -0.0646391287446022, -0.07534632086753845, -0.027919061481952667, 0.04190465435385704, -0.01780850440263748, -0.005816400051116943, -0.060392819344997406, 0.04814298823475838, 0.05162906274199486, -0.03380502015352249, -0.08814403414726257, 0.040602974593639374, 0.03163452446460724, -0.032301511615514755, 0.04707157239317894, 0.037215132266283035, -0.015738489106297493, 0.04231245815753937, -0.07455353438854218, 0.01431245356798172, -0.03309087082743645, 0.02562713995575905, -0.017533591017127037, 0.0229477621614933, -0.04049249365925789, -0.02953077293932438, 0.026296021416783333, 0.05982358008623123, -0.024632571265101433, 0.012312103062868118, 0.006598833482712507, -0.01918983645737171, -0.06860989332199097, -0.020466692745685577, 0.031270451843738556, -0.000038133457564981654, -0.031821925193071365, 0.044317007064819336, 0.01365622691810131, -0.007415929343551397, -0.029340777546167374, 0.005501549690961838, 0.04210500419139862, 0.0082467095926404, -0.005618338473141193, -0.020403509959578514, -0.000052373310609254986, -0.0410444512963295, 0.0215572752058506, -0.0351824127137661, 0.008034218102693558, 0.06030814349651337, -0.006399756297469139, 0.0018307754071429372, -0.03133518248796463, -0.005740250460803509, 0.027889017015695572, 0.03682900220155716, 0.0031052171252667904, 0.06019004434347153, -0.06239465996623039, -0.0005923777353018522, -0.006506288889795542, -0.03543117642402649, -0.030683841556310654, 0.00839054025709629, 0.03858066722750664, -0.05177896469831467, 0.014463087543845177, -0.049880411475896835, 0.01694825291633606, -0.04000358283519745, 0.003806446911767125, -0.028590697795152664, 0.035632919520139694, -0.04984449967741966, -0.005983212497085333, -0.023990830406546593, -0.019009102135896683, -0.025721443817019463, -0.07092183828353882, -0.04283236339688301, 0.0002787993289530277, 0.01395675539970398, -0.015228835865855217, 0.022683527320623398, -0.00537674967199564, 0.037447456270456314, 0.03610548377037048, -0.054504651576280594, -0.02043372578918934, -0.01840626448392868, -0.034000739455223083, 0.00033196000731550157, -0.010181881487369537, 0.013886971399188042, -0.015102723613381386, 0.05741703882813454, 0.01958763226866722, 0.034550346434116364, -0.05410739406943321, 0.03148714825510979, -0.028146596625447273, -0.04921197146177292, -0.022847488522529602, 0.0352976955473423, 0.02726595662534237, -0.01119450107216835, 0.028448669239878654, 0.013835505582392216, -0.013166632503271103, -0.05086122825741768 ]
Conventional end-to-end Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) models primarily focus on exact transcription tasks, lacking flexibility for nuanced user interactions. With the advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) in speech processing, more organic, text-prompt-based interactions have become possible. However, the mechanisms behind these models' speech understanding and "reasoning" capabilities remain underexplored. To study this question from the data perspective, we introduce instruction-following speech recognition, training a Listen-Attend-Spell model to understand and execute a diverse set of free-form text instructions. This enables a multitude of speech recognition tasks -- ranging from transcript manipulation to summarization -- without relying on predefined command sets. Remarkably, our model, trained from scratch on Librispeech, interprets and executes simple instructions without requiring LLMs or pre-trained speech modules. It also offers selective transcription options based on instructions like "transcribe first half and then turn off listening," providing an additional layer of privacy and safety compared to existing LLMs. Our findings highlight the significant potential of instruction-following training to advance speech foundation models.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09843v1
[ -0.010598515160381794, 0.010759039781987667, 0.06372087448835373, 0.006767231039702892, 0.026761000975966454, -0.013279495760798454, -0.025339927524328232, -0.023832330480217934, -0.02308884635567665, -0.053428664803504944, -0.04793746769428253, 0.007439045235514641, -0.061344411224126816, -0.026337100192904472, -0.053676754236221313, -0.015631306916475296, 0.06315549463033676, 0.01940687745809555, -0.011684291064739227, 0.01412318367511034, -0.015329495072364807, 0.009683254174888134, -0.057519715279340744, 0.045889776200056076, 0.013561555184423923, -0.062223631888628006, -0.04097241908311844, -0.024350369349122047, -0.03629561513662338, -0.009286828339099884, 0.0580148883163929, -0.014309137128293514, -0.02535058557987213, -0.0016030102269724011, -0.07215089350938797, -0.01789754256606102, -0.024540340527892113, 0.013293920084834099, 0.030485978350043297, -0.021944591775536537, 0.032087817788124084, -0.057085685431957245, -0.06931210309267044, -0.014633361250162125, -0.041229769587516785, 0.002810332691296935, -0.011469592340290546, 0.013807770796120167, -0.04059677943587303, -0.03961329162120819, 0.01729453168809414, 0.01590573415160179, -0.04189734160900116, 0.03530409187078476, -0.03221393749117851, 0.0064931404776871204, 0.009105473756790161, -0.0068706064485013485, -0.07406648248434067, -0.013059082441031933, 0.024906111881136894, -0.03743864595890045, -0.021024629473686218, 0.01660505123436451, -0.00861524511128664, 0.03808042034506798, -0.007052756380289793, -0.05081816017627716, -0.037820976227521896, -0.03890901058912277, 0.03138211742043495, -0.0502205453813076, -0.037333983927965164, 0.0032336413860321045, 0.008661719970405102, -0.0411502979695797, -0.039639998227357864, -0.0523182637989521, -0.016000084578990936, -0.04484701156616211, 0.00021891170763410628, 0.03853001445531845, 0.039767563343048096, 0.012777760624885559, -0.007321617566049099, -0.05712416395545006, 0.04504111781716347, -0.015094130299985409, 0.011155655607581139, -0.042017702013254166, 0.03800439089536667, -0.039630334824323654, -0.0725724920630455, 0.03659489378333092, 0.054612260311841965, -0.0310369860380888, 0.05490570887923241, -0.008017458952963352, -0.002483577700331807, -0.003445390844717622, -0.031689874827861786, 0.015309171751141548, -0.041754063218832016, 0.07044916599988937, 0.0268059354275465, -0.03957714885473251, 0.023449433967471123, 0.019763881340622902, -0.05354269966483116, -0.012063492089509964, -0.02640489675104618, -0.055521897971630096, 0.057911623269319534, -0.03484883904457092, -0.02400454320013523, -0.01695092022418976, 0.03083200752735138, 0.002774049062281847, -0.006030801218003035, -0.0087748933583498, -0.021338896825909615, 0.031872205436229706, 0.02100510336458683, -0.02379831299185753, -0.0325198695063591, -0.042750418186187744, 0.058130715042352676, 0.013647300191223621, -0.03358674794435501, -0.011178050190210342, -0.014633995480835438, 0.011685079894959927, -0.020640870556235313, -0.037797991186380386, 0.07649027556180954, -0.0034535862505435944, -0.0369158573448658, -0.06650988012552261, 0.014087351970374584, -0.016846684738993645, -0.04894663020968437, -0.08082506060600281, 0.03451145440340042, -0.06025756150484085, 0.02946266159415245, 0.049945931881666183, -0.050748296082019806, -0.03167805075645447, 0.021598810330033302, 0.04065276309847832, 0.01038738340139389, -0.02128245308995247, -0.005056630354374647, 0.03702074661850929, 0.017343126237392426, -0.0025652614422142506, 0.017545733600854874, 0.0037569464184343815, -0.06584886461496353, 0.005141237284988165, 0.01825822703540325, -0.011923486366868019, 0.03790828213095665, -0.03942171856760979, 0.018923088908195496, 0.004054042976349592, 0.0436878427863121, 0.0024693403393030167, -0.030240552499890327, 0.01401981059461832, -0.051950860768556595, 0.012972275726497173, -0.01930844783782959, -0.0067495545372366905, -0.07923199236392975, 0.009188443422317505, 0.050574012100696564, -0.005131447687745094, -0.011450523510575294, 0.0074245319701731205, -0.0314294770359993, 0.04747878015041351, -0.046448636800050735, -0.028731854632496834, -0.040575090795755386, 0.015569603070616722, -0.06397582590579987, -0.0208903718739748, 0.05654531344771385, 0.04042782634496689, -0.060325756669044495, -0.005233266856521368, 0.016147885471582413, -0.002917350037023425, -0.02497970312833786, -0.014734646305441856, -0.011128025129437447, -0.005927917547523975, 0.019940583035349846, 0.06563722342252731, -0.09620051085948944, 0.012308965437114239, -0.054806213825941086, -0.02676966041326523, -0.004269060213118792, -0.050307463854551315, 0.011335894465446472, 0.03905309736728668, -0.025030335411429405, 0.021350665017962456, 0.024769891053438187, 0.07128144800662994, 0.04887213185429573, 0.03920803964138031, 0.018963873386383057, 0.027851441875100136, -0.10212922096252441, 0.05790741741657257, -0.007339661940932274, -0.01646108739078045, 0.04912940785288811, 0.039056140929460526, -0.003390297992154956, -0.012056391686201096, -0.00924430787563324, 0.01993159018456936, 0.007808456663042307, -0.048564136028289795, -0.040299948304891586, -0.049279503524303436, 0.007974755950272083, -0.055621884763240814, -0.013779329136013985, -0.07169878482818604, -0.006671554408967495, -0.005628678482025862, -0.01514403522014618, 0.03138906881213188, 0.012984259985387325, -0.017161892727017403, -0.06665218621492386, -0.03566727414727211, 0.05689630284905434, 0.020006243139505386, -0.07225257903337479, -0.03928731381893158, -0.01771451160311699, 0.018304817378520966, 0.0016181645914912224, -0.007409604731947184, -0.023520009592175484, -0.041971929371356964, 0.0026844742242246866, -0.0028954283334314823, 0.021823901683092117, 0.02439080737531185, -0.00833811517804861, 0.025325821712613106, 0.015091856010258198, -0.0009232406155206263, 0.04358057305216789, 0.03610503301024437, -0.06541158258914948, -0.005758294835686684, 0.019850974902510643, -0.053295888006687164, 0.030756056308746338, 0.002727632876485586, -0.023093130439519882, -0.03342094272375107, -0.003206852823495865, 0.04261765629053116, 0.029463548213243484, -0.020855465903878212, -0.061918482184410095, -0.03129047155380249, 0.04194489121437073, -0.017175845801830292, 0.010725357569754124, 0.02284260280430317, 0.04744042083621025, 0.0016701272688806057, -0.018396960571408272, -0.06558147817850113, -0.021711094304919243, -0.03582604601979256, -0.04816108196973801, -0.041840046644210815, -0.05129316821694374, -0.04401436448097229, -0.06409309804439545, -0.033785320818424225, -0.0005575742106884718, -0.016278740018606186, -0.02760981395840645, -0.053449880331754684, -0.04158095270395279, -0.03100694715976715, 0.03336749225854874, 0.02007254585623741, -0.049433574080467224, -0.02342008613049984, 0.014807924628257751, 0.009397043846547604, 0.029028603807091713, -0.050661515444517136, -0.07144772261381149, -0.012169702909886837, 0.02782886102795601, 0.03387399762868881, -0.034763529896736145, 0.042485401034355164, 0.0025450349785387516, 0.03761371225118637, 0.010336203500628471, 0.058988675475120544, 0.02749403938651085, 0.029378533363342285, -0.019181527197360992, -0.025886233896017075, -0.02075953595340252, -0.010937231592833996, 0.0041721598245203495, -0.023241104558110237, -0.04508601129055023, 0.00018194651056546718, 0.033234335482120514, -0.015280727297067642, 0.01333705335855484, -0.05392778292298317, 0.00127230619546026, 0.03376725688576698, -0.010222570970654488, -0.008872554637491703, -0.0038493394386023283, 0.03415913134813309, -0.01213931106030941, -0.033531561493873596, -0.02021174132823944, -0.001843229285441339, -0.010886650532484055, 0.007300167344510555, -0.04668257012963295, -0.01590147241950035, 0.0588211752474308, -0.08138175308704376, 0.026087498292326927, 0.05942069739103317, 0.030109833925962448, -0.03295420855283737, 0.005671258084475994, 0.024560915306210518, 0.02478834241628647, 0.044958923012018204, -0.03754909336566925, -0.015046708285808563, 0.050159208476543427, 0.04389170929789543, -0.008010431192815304, -0.03506135568022728, 0.019006991758942604, -0.0650244653224945, -0.022258024662733078, -0.0036154421977698803, -0.005583544261753559, 0.008819476701319218, -0.029292436316609383, -0.059097036719322205, 0.013577530160546303, 0.022843454033136368, 0.05240986868739128, 0.0010190062457695603, -0.04860169440507889, 0.012695064768195152, -0.03612206503748894, 0.020716115832328796, -0.01531516294926405, -0.01297810673713684, -0.03538436442613602, -0.015306821092963219, -0.0120858708396554, -0.04426294192671776, 0.039509329944849014, 0.009933996014297009, -0.0070343902334570885, 0.055452611297369, 0.05286996811628342, -0.02339938096702099, 0.04664674028754234, -0.011449356563389301, -0.0161321721971035, 0.012590604834258556, -0.02273353561758995, -0.0579037107527256, -0.022601494565606117, -0.07298244535923004, -0.0016217617085203528, 0.03486703708767891, 0.010198500007390976, -0.01767006888985634, -0.002618179190903902, 0.025600938126444817, -0.010768468491733074, -0.09178171306848526, -0.01251058280467987, -0.02348337508738041, 0.036342889070510864, 0.017563901841640472, -0.05067162960767746, 0.02506936714053154, -0.02476257085800171, 0.00795099139213562, -0.03145476058125496, 0.014682945795357227, -0.06836944818496704, -0.04875498265028, -0.0014604016905650496, -0.08118657767772675, 0.01031746156513691, -0.08101270347833633, 0.04901519790291786, 0.004546493291854858, -0.006368851289153099, 0.0008653617696836591, 0.008993543684482574, -0.01233992911875248, 0.055622439831495285, 0.046317730098962784, 0.04988919198513031, 0.009758285246789455, -0.03820324316620827, 0.03455880284309387, -0.007005696650594473, 0.01941915601491928, -0.02648826129734516, -0.03200617432594299, 0.013584309257566929, -0.0017464442644268274, 0.032496169209480286, 0.01894468627870083, 0.033229582011699677, 0.03622428700327873, -0.044696684926748276, -0.017213502898812294, 0.013507898896932602, 0.04917138069868088, -0.05557059869170189, -0.08212418109178543, -0.03009277954697609, -0.015205802395939827, -0.05590004846453667, -0.013623276725411415, 0.050605129450559616, 0.038642071187496185, -0.011629058979451656, -0.026916993781924248, 0.04441426321864128, 0.01633760891854763, -0.002295516664162278, -0.01968405582010746, 0.015875371173024178, -0.019955355674028397, -0.009897545911371708, 0.012025185860693455, -0.05035663768649101, -0.010089147835969925, -0.04614789038896561, -0.026188375428318977, -0.05361403152346611, 0.03867000713944435, -0.006167596206068993, 0.045865535736083984, -0.07980349659919739, -0.020894229412078857, 0.03132627159357071, -0.032633256167173386, 0.03681693226099014, 0.07629148662090302, 0.0018630132544785738, 0.06062750145792961, -0.057635851204395294, 0.023007221519947052, -0.007254698313772678, -0.043422043323516846, -0.018749792128801346, 0.03411315381526947, 0.006608163006603718, -0.009175303392112255, 0.034239910542964935, -0.035277124494314194, -0.025076862424612045, 0.028857335448265076, 0.06634826958179474, 0.014484579674899578, -0.04109475016593933, 0.038048770278692245, 0.03294900059700012, -0.037470944225788116, -0.03156021237373352, -0.01265980489552021, 0.01354125514626503, -0.006737151648849249, 0.05564689263701439, -0.04542367532849312, -0.054845310747623444, 0.024349072948098183, -0.011506340466439724, -0.021666059270501137, 0.03643205761909485, 0.012712775729596615, -0.008019006811082363, -0.037554021924734116, 0.02454272098839283, -0.05051230639219284, -0.033576030284166336, -0.06664684414863586, 0.023422546684741974, 0.05444340407848358, -0.02070189267396927, 0.026585586369037628, 0.00658699544146657, -0.040063243359327316, 0.015219834633171558, -0.024558942764997482, -0.007408218923956156, 0.06536699831485748, -0.053637538105249405, -0.005068393424153328, 0.00979207269847393, 0.03415640443563461, 0.032574061304330826, 0.05811397358775139, 0.005932156927883625, -0.02021859958767891, 0.00012548622908070683, -0.02369985729455948, 0.023415660485625267, -0.07644133269786835, -0.010580023750662804, 0.030567975714802742, -0.022131767123937607, -0.037584517151117325, 0.01143419835716486, -0.018241532146930695, 0.0023964173160493374, 0.024575551971793175, 0.040820471942424774, -0.044514816254377365, -0.03253691643476486, 0.020090261474251747, 0.07777176052331924, -0.04309375211596489, 0.010599743574857712, -0.02943536266684532, -0.017306137830018997, 0.00037853236426599324, -0.028797021135687828, 0.014909680932760239, 0.051218751817941666, 0.03881832957267761, -0.05679306387901306, 0.0686885416507721, -0.017091689631342888, -0.07410843670368195, 0.02535039186477661, 0.016075218096375465, -0.060507066547870636, 0.022055400535464287, 0.017915986478328705, 0.006190494634211063, -0.06561741977930069, 0.05636284872889519, 0.059009138494729996, -0.028135191649198532, -0.004155856557190418, 0.0659850686788559, 0.08516338467597961, -0.03475344926118851, -0.014709776267409325, -0.0057079605758190155, -0.02381577342748642, 0.056683409959077835, -0.03998105227947235, -0.0018854060908779502, 0.05034548044204712, 0.01591724343597889, 0.028156369924545288, -0.058707475662231445, -0.0040875026024878025, 0.0432082861661911, -0.011201837100088596, 0.015191573649644852, -0.010443522594869137, -0.028686709702014923, 0.06329406052827835, -0.02343895472586155, -0.01538944523781538, -0.02164122462272644, -0.000695203198119998, 0.025825999677181244, -0.05328798294067383, -0.027368089184165, -0.006700284779071808, 0.0021154996939003468, 0.018202487379312515, -0.08311443775892258, 0.020952533930540085, -0.027789229527115822, -0.0848306268453598, -0.02159918285906315, -0.07016365230083466, 0.007537406403571367, -0.016096064820885658, -0.026005953550338745, 0.009520710445940495, 0.06265196204185486, -0.01406940445303917, -0.08010680973529816, 0.007736223749816418, 0.019740652292966843, 0.03418679162859917, -0.03021909110248089, -0.0068828933872282505, -0.014788628555834293, 0.017292583361268044, -0.022988632321357727, -0.03000594489276409, 0.024172436445951462, -0.06754075735807419, 0.042596861720085144, 0.03126305341720581, -0.01188877783715725, -0.03178081288933754, 0.011506711132824421, -0.008783646859228611, 0.05086299777030945, 0.010008369572460651, -0.05463419482111931, -0.04099944233894348, -0.012121547944843769, 0.03135785833001137, 0.00041618666728027165, 0.011774699203670025, 0.04146397486329079, 0.009086929261684418, -0.02133791707456112, -0.0018813391216099262, -0.026648733764886856, 0.0007213624776341021, 0.04533234238624573, -0.05078025907278061, -0.007791169919073582, 0.017640098929405212, -0.055219125002622604, -0.048728760331869125, 0.02466261200606823, 0.027272118255496025, -0.037537362426519394, 0.0035828042309731245, 0.04449467733502388, 0.01661965437233448, 0.009728733450174332, -0.0686011016368866, 0.047197453677654266, -0.0006212515290826559, -0.06276915222406387, -0.01982092671096325, 0.005195118486881256, -0.0026832332368940115, -0.05998055264353752, -0.0569818876683712, -0.005048509221524, -0.05032740533351898, 0.01330452412366867, -0.08526191860437393, 0.012435766868293285, -0.006756434682756662, 0.04077955335378647, 0.005995267070829868, 0.03021039068698883, 0.003581128316000104, -0.050487689673900604, 0.045174550265073776, 0.02668125182390213, 0.013898019678890705, 0.05047133192420006, 0.023265907540917397, 0.04190289229154587, -0.039509184658527374, -0.030025674030184746, 0.05478208139538765, -0.025640452280640602, -0.015298265963792801, 0.018723241984844208, 0.04728805273771286, 0.03276436775922775, -0.012341837398707867, 0.029184406623244286, -0.010235164314508438, 0.03409136086702347, -0.06671478599309921, -0.00993158109486103, -0.03482857719063759, -0.027455991134047508, 0.01881563849747181, -0.033268604427576065, -0.009185886941850185, 0.055501922965049744, -0.009590886533260345, 0.013793150894343853, -0.015753133222460747, -0.027053967118263245, 0.021907739341259003, -0.06488468497991562, -0.022396065294742584, 0.07350441068410873, -0.011227558366954327, -0.04789102077484131, -0.034976158291101456, -0.042136892676353455, -0.022173995152115822, 0.06736812740564346, 0.04885150492191315, -0.04000944644212723, -0.013046234846115112, -0.0743902176618576, 0.015655549243092537, -0.018489565700292587, 0.011073284782469273, -0.00801326148211956, 0.06734385341405869, 0.0031288110185414553, -0.031530097126960754, -0.015575332567095757, -0.0429229773581028, -0.022951167076826096, -0.0741729736328125, -0.03262640908360481, -0.04254598915576935, 0.015612428076565266, -0.007221032865345478, 0.009708539582788944, 0.03350788354873657, 0.049047864973545074, 0.036206286400556564, 0.052430521696805954, 0.020897276699543, -0.007826587185263634, -0.03536990284919739, 0.06968659907579422, 0.02315697818994522, 0.03637542203068733, -0.053000565618276596, -0.01288536749780178, -0.03694833442568779, 0.01999424584209919, -0.008443920873105526, -0.02718956768512726, 0.05029641464352608, -0.04488698020577431, 0.009945042431354523, 0.029686639085412025, 0.02027512900531292, -0.03988223150372505, -0.0476994514465332, 0.013183052651584148, 0.002638014033436775, -0.0252104289829731 ]
We establish a close analogy between the thermodynamics of the nonlinear systems far from equilibrium and the dissipative solitons. Unlike the solitons in the Hamiltonian systems, their dissipative counterpart looks like an aggregation of bounded quasi-particles interacting on the short range, obeying the Rayleigh-Jeans distribution, and possessing a temperature, entropy, and other thermodynamic characteristics. This ensemble is confined by a collective potential, which defines its negative chemical potential. Such a dissipative soliton represents a strongly chirped pulse generated by a mode-locked laser with the advantage of being energy scalable by the analogy with the Bose-Einstein condensation from an incoherent ``basin.'' We demonstrate the main limits of the dissipative soliton energy scaling which result from the loss of internal soliton coherency and the thermalization due to nontriviality of a ``free energy landscape.''
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16571v2
[ -0.05586572736501694, -0.022149352356791496, 0.001916726934723556, 0.01031977217644453, 0.049112990498542786, -0.055902399122714996, -0.02115909568965435, 0.05236877128481865, -0.008023304864764214, 0.012319573201239109, 0.011076652444899082, -0.053779494017362595, -0.055761437863111496, -0.0591813363134861, -0.014892813749611378, 0.023326274007558823, 0.061539776623249054, 0.053396716713905334, -0.040756091475486755, 0.05290831997990608, 0.016433263197541237, -0.0018198983743786812, -0.019174080342054367, 0.020822817459702492, 0.00390241714194417, -0.017830850556492805, -0.019751576706767082, 0.001863875542767346, -0.015214911662042141, -0.023189911618828773, 0.04972966015338898, -0.04934067651629448, 0.021561207249760628, -0.017640750855207443, -0.03018096089363098, 0.0021492717787623405, 0.030086789280176163, 0.022124959155917168, 0.04915177449584007, -0.01573818363249302, -0.05400347337126732, -0.05976277217268944, -0.05143296718597412, -0.030036620795726776, -0.0006408564513549209, -0.02318439446389675, -0.06317567080259323, 0.001126901595853269, -0.0405128039419651, -0.05752759799361229, 0.022937651723623276, 0.0051324255764484406, 0.006838333327323198, 0.05489332601428032, -0.051680322736501694, 0.000042033901991089806, 0.03243273124098778, -0.03713241592049599, 0.0012609201949089766, 0.008033683523535728, 0.0018724584951996803, -0.012556840665638447, 0.05063793063163757, -0.017555121332406998, -0.0315730944275856, 0.05386146157979965, -0.06130662560462952, -0.06763950735330582, -0.052003610879182816, -0.04852483794093132, -0.028128717094659805, -0.04616444557905197, -0.030215641483664513, -0.020879827439785004, -0.0679241269826889, 0.0007304524187929928, -0.04052824527025223, -0.043476950377225876, 0.04961767420172691, 0.042556580156087875, -0.057154830545186996, 0.017343884333968163, 0.022988328710198402, -0.010175484232604504, 0.02960117906332016, 0.05556826665997505, 0.04643968120217323, -0.013943878933787346, -0.005625670775771141, 0.004703103564679623, 0.021141938865184784, -0.008541717194020748, -0.024967558681964874, -0.005782672204077244, 0.06764145940542221, -0.044940512627363205, 0.04512694478034973, 0.04698630049824715, -0.006133376620709896, -0.026905076578259468, 0.015756165608763695, -0.038880303502082825, -0.026711322367191315, 0.052353400737047195, -0.04797755181789398, 0.0010101963998749852, -0.03402344882488251, -0.0107308654114604, -0.027163589373230934, 0.04876316711306572, -0.004162756726145744, -0.02056904137134552, -0.020244456827640533, -0.017904575914144516, -0.05426982045173645, -0.009378770366311073, 0.05569709464907646, -0.0265863835811615, 0.014509611763060093, -0.011207067407667637, -0.03807703033089638, 0.004065105225890875, -0.024673523381352425, 0.01703176647424698, -0.05889327824115753, 0.0031576554756611586, 0.05556688830256462, -0.00020752895215991884, -0.01639534905552864, -0.018275149166584015, -0.05787025764584541, 0.007442832458764315, 0.043322380632162094, -0.02408331260085106, 0.01184770092368126, -0.0018126064678654075, 0.03190631791949272, 0.009720484726130962, -0.007839275524020195, 0.05396996811032295, -0.03808223083615303, -0.004272161982953548, -0.04442422464489937, -0.0069709718227386475, 0.009516658261418343, 0.04371650144457817, -0.04355141147971153, 0.026150640100240707, 0.024665718898177147, -0.001050718710757792, 0.004020313266664743, 0.02948014624416828, -0.008686055429279804, -0.01946891099214554, 0.03838310390710831, -0.00886572990566492, 0.027367237955331802, -0.005416921339929104, -0.030929090455174446, 0.03347846865653992, 0.017721157521009445, -0.024223079904913902, -0.04618621617555618, 0.023060448467731476, -0.005775196012109518, 0.017477791756391525, 0.024204816669225693, -0.06295742839574814, -0.00488137174397707, -0.03273453190922737, -0.03454773500561714, 0.05779573321342468, 0.03458249941468239, -0.04486783966422081, -0.027860552072525024, -0.05569077283143997, -0.032160282135009766, -0.034340113401412964, 0.027076993137598038, 0.05845029279589653, 0.021653424948453903, -0.0040435269474983215, -0.04548097774386406, -0.05299963802099228, 0.013659813441336155, 0.025764180347323418, -0.07078234106302261, -0.02057686448097229, 0.02895580232143402, -0.0020511557813733816, -0.02828214131295681, -0.04550202563405037, 0.01995578594505787, 0.02351471781730652, -0.027873625978827477, 0.006849946454167366, 0.045495085418224335, -0.023763546720147133, -0.02095007337629795, -0.0011541901621967554, -0.07116895169019699, -0.02893626131117344, -0.011155486106872559, -0.008451981469988823, -0.06475231051445007, -0.04900931566953659, 0.023383770138025284, 0.01568060927093029, 0.003983683418482542, -0.013599573634564877, 0.05483069643378258, 0.027351340278983116, 0.06046224758028984, -0.01866932213306427, 0.00578804686665535, -0.006733758375048637, -0.09667914360761642, 0.028584051877260208, 0.003676254767924547, -0.03757331892848015, -0.01935187540948391, -0.005327478051185608, -0.0027734714094549417, -0.020988216623663902, -0.013976399786770344, 0.0450262576341629, 0.029656877741217613, 0.00901662465184927, -0.04946562647819519, 0.00008400405204156414, -0.03206135705113411, -0.05214453116059303, -0.06196506321430206, -0.06391637027263641, -0.0094932084903121, 0.05574832856655121, -0.009364056400954723, 0.013377958908677101, -0.06336623430252075, -0.05968301370739937, -0.08048931509256363, -0.028803739696741104, 0.04933016374707222, -0.009046829305589199, -0.04674988240003586, -0.07050088047981262, -0.06882430613040924, 0.03121107816696167, -0.05777738615870476, 0.0023650196380913258, 0.030609188601374626, -0.059885695576667786, -0.04816135764122009, -0.026479419320821762, -0.008243166841566563, 0.014456326141953468, -0.026915330439805984, 0.06696439534425735, 0.0331464521586895, 0.04081932082772255, -0.0008338277693837881, 0.021158084273338318, -0.05560661107301712, -0.046135660260915756, 0.023240040987730026, 0.0405287966132164, -0.05208545923233032, 0.0008518581744283438, 0.006214671302586794, -0.050028227269649506, 0.037408556789159775, 0.03322546184062958, 0.0325407050549984, 0.0050919693894684315, 0.01763390377163887, 0.04226335138082504, 0.014498240314424038, -0.05174838379025459, 0.008123891428112984, 0.041802387684583664, 0.06875596195459366, 0.028200780972838402, -0.04153499752283096, -0.07870873808860779, -0.017351264134049416, -0.013604240491986275, -0.02065790258347988, -0.03892933204770088, -0.07442275434732437, 0.03474687784910202, -0.07527346909046173, 0.04076321795582771, -0.04445398226380348, 0.017393721267580986, -0.06971649825572968, -0.027158506214618683, 0.00881997961550951, -0.05851299315690994, 0.005423966329544783, -0.0625663697719574, -0.07669732719659805, 0.017527423799037933, 0.008277886547148228, -0.004295959137380123, -0.037669818848371506, -0.02789977937936783, -0.008401157334446907, 0.03904299810528755, -0.0015209579141810536, -0.018746400251984596, -0.05925045907497406, -0.022706957533955574, -0.05541672930121422, -0.008530663326382637, 0.011862125247716904, 0.04947506636381149, 0.021911896765232086, -0.041024092584848404, -0.014410153031349182, -0.025199223309755325, -0.04707467183470726, -0.0017660441808402538, 0.0005895111244171858, -0.010020299814641476, -0.040493641048669815, -0.06489885598421097, 0.0009757114457897842, 0.07266512513160706, -0.002423854311928153, -0.05771312490105629, -0.061165858060121536, -0.026097683236002922, -0.01599760167300701, 0.004441778641194105, 0.05448494106531143, 0.057843033224344254, -0.01488063670694828, -0.024958709254860878, -0.013981204479932785, 0.027684248983860016, -0.02201145701110363, 0.03372235596179962, -0.017070595175027847, 0.0005884868442080915, 0.05149630829691887, -0.04862594231963158, 0.012055535800755024, 0.028174322098493576, 0.025694193318486214, -0.012646039947867393, -0.0439959317445755, -0.004924718756228685, -0.025456711649894714, 0.04619889333844185, -0.013939863070845604, 0.00890906248241663, 0.019371338188648224, 0.048493750393390656, -0.012003865092992783, 0.0006393165676854551, 0.0006444763275794685, -0.06923912465572357, -0.03954087942838669, 0.018492398783564568, -0.013231571763753891, 0.0037982910871505737, 0.005163080058991909, 0.02944585680961609, 0.05046393349766731, -0.02259649895131588, 0.05461093783378601, -0.012284591794013977, -0.03823114186525345, 0.04516858607530594, 0.008252414874732494, -0.030706414952874184, -0.03012363240122795, 0.013521411456167698, -0.05488898232579231, -0.044650010764598846, -0.028313109651207924, -0.07518799602985382, 0.020661933347582817, -0.004939907696098089, 0.007971396669745445, 0.03679543733596802, 0.01995852403342724, -0.040119998157024384, 0.01474560797214508, 0.008340723812580109, 0.014415368437767029, -0.04400630295276642, -0.028630409389734268, 0.03676174208521843, -0.06996399164199829, 0.022651296108961105, -0.0067976173013448715, -0.0247414018958807, -0.007863383740186691, 0.04303200915455818, 0.009188370779156685, 0.021783120930194855, -0.02605895698070526, -0.07739591598510742, -0.03233267739415169, -0.01096488069742918, -0.011115112341940403, -0.0010497274342924356, -0.03672381117939949, 0.07048985362052917, -0.041218534111976624, -0.005970471538603306, -0.054131947457790375, -0.02216178923845291, -0.019365929067134857, -0.008701986633241177, 0.022444969043135643, -0.012325162999331951, 0.018219487741589546, -0.0561886727809906, 0.00923032034188509, -0.013623771257698536, -0.016839418560266495, -0.05587674304842949, 0.05638935789465904, -0.029055064544081688, -0.025570835918188095, 0.04101622477173805, 0.026983534917235374, 0.04959119111299515, 0.0003387285687495023, -0.027435673400759697, 0.015381473116576672, -0.0034587467089295387, 0.029761074110865593, -0.04312188923358917, -0.010538231581449509, -0.08232232928276062, -0.06013611704111099, -0.053087782114744186, -0.014724494889378548, 0.025520624592900276, -0.06032456457614899, -0.03228801488876343, -0.017654769122600555, 0.026228731498122215, -0.01434333622455597, -0.02839662879705429, -0.023120032623410225, -0.019987938925623894, -0.07468678057193756, -0.007925637066364288, -0.015938695520162582, -0.03670932352542877, -0.0481296144425869, 0.035579804331064224, 0.010451682843267918, -0.033233918249607086, -0.0008236176217906177, 0.01763262040913105, 0.015596887096762657, 0.0017935022478923202, -0.020248858258128166, -0.04487237334251404, -0.03391500189900398, -0.0086422860622406, -0.023904863744974136, -0.02922612428665161, -0.0537676103413105, 0.05108777806162834, -0.028915157541632652, 0.01638319529592991, -0.0825875774025917, 0.0035193227231502533, 0.04881581291556358, 0.007366332225501537, -0.00955982506275177, -0.029462268576025963, -0.021223030984401703, -0.008240003138780594, -0.027553224936127663, -0.0005546992179006338, 0.009771743789315224, 0.0005559207638725638, 0.0355086512863636, -0.005369701888412237, -0.0620906688272953, -0.044544920325279236, 0.039435457438230515, -0.012608340941369534, -0.053729280829429626, 0.05572227016091347, 0.03610201179981232, -0.03743646293878555, -0.07107046246528625, -0.008008107542991638, 0.06051018834114075, -0.04234163463115692, -0.03663165867328644, -0.000476003740914166, -0.05078999698162079, 0.03306173160672188, 0.07087722420692444, -0.06970975548028946, 0.01028610859066248, -0.012512268498539925, 0.007457824889570475, 0.019962584599852562, 0.054410889744758606, -0.0045492984354496, -0.00440300302579999, 0.03923890367150307, 0.003866247832775116, -0.07417409867048264, 0.025770027190446854, -0.06680836528539658, -0.014004995115101337, -0.03667924553155899, 0.03016134537756443, 0.025329742580652237, 0.0541006363928318, -0.02197284996509552, -0.059462595731019974, 0.02566210925579071, -0.02666695974767208, 0.018908053636550903, -0.04844266548752785, -0.005494468379765749, -0.002774376654997468, 0.009807711467146873, -0.0035083370748907328, -0.0027368406299501657, 0.005228016991168261, -0.02726023830473423, -0.04195540025830269, 0.005236406810581684, 0.016011958941817284, 0.0202773530036211, -0.03234342858195305, 0.000014760905287403148, 0.03934798017144203, 0.001003527664579451, 0.046864431351423264, 0.018653102219104767, 0.04588161036372185, 0.052084408700466156, -0.04525883495807648, 0.03479968011379242, -0.016196705400943756, -0.02755296230316162, 0.08028952032327652, -0.051615383476018906, 0.02448429726064205, -0.0614313930273056, -0.05865524709224701, -0.038728341460227966, -0.0103638069704175, -0.014817732386291027, 0.0013558210339397192, -0.03197212517261505, -0.0554305799305439, 0.03517474979162216, 0.01546557992696762, -0.061582617461681366, 0.015293226577341557, 0.028538696467876434, -0.07628878206014633, -0.03037673979997635, -0.004955882206559181, -0.04879561811685562, 0.008793422020971775, 0.04479186236858368, -0.04045196250081062, -0.025014150887727737, -0.03390579670667648, 0.034760747104883194, 0.07103759795427322, -0.04235374554991722, 0.017722904682159424, 0.015555378049612045, -0.02750575542449951, -0.010843886062502861, 0.019316690042614937, -0.001111918711103499, -0.014356313273310661, 0.006750429980456829, -0.043185506016016006, 0.001721348031423986, 0.0061650266870856285, -0.012232822366058826, -0.028586987406015396, 0.013601230457425117, -0.04047127440571785, -0.002149673644453287, 0.020523857325315475, -0.04744227975606918, -0.024759098887443542, 0.018769241869449615, 0.009764333255589008, 0.018901700153946877, -0.009978342801332474, 0.0016512128058820963, -0.015767082571983337, 0.037306394428014755, 0.0024302839301526546, -0.00835502054542303, -0.004072562791407108, -0.013875733129680157, -0.016854101791977882, 0.00804826058447361, -0.015472807921469212, -0.015867609530687332, -0.015475467778742313, 0.013887148350477219, -0.018061604350805283, 0.05813189223408699, -0.008982658386230469, 0.015497226268053055, 0.024202007800340652, -0.004777937196195126, 0.03940892592072487, 0.015057752840220928, 0.024154258891940117, -0.0063524190336465836, 0.04440568387508392, -0.04341903328895569, 0.02347489632666111, 0.0014297545421868563, -0.03285707160830498, 0.04536158964037895, -0.0432509146630764, -0.03721150383353233, -0.02826087735593319, -0.009907345287501812, -0.06907635182142258, -0.029906461015343666, 0.04196474328637123, -0.030088746920228004, -0.03719822317361832, -0.002149426145479083, 0.012858137488365173, -0.05218241363763809, -0.039362840354442596, 0.03149711713194847, 0.019483737647533417, -0.019547248259186745, 0.05367957428097725, 0.06767305731773376, 0.03409621864557266, -0.02143457531929016, -0.02838796004652977, -0.0668255016207695, 0.04738639295101166, -0.013467343524098396, -0.05933276191353798, -0.039502862840890884, -0.023779116570949554, -0.05176175385713577, -0.030897192656993866, -0.007117154076695442, -0.02500215545296669, -0.04217899590730667, -0.018283437937498093, 0.06486799567937851, 0.020321615040302277, -0.05148747190833092, -0.07836645096540451, -0.008849850855767727, -0.00327482633292675, 0.01887461543083191, 0.006362000480294228, -0.013218712992966175, -0.052391376346349716, 0.011676396243274212, -0.08123484253883362, 0.029308728873729706, -0.038382578641176224, 0.07005608081817627, -0.006179050542414188, 0.021553082391619682, -0.02352062426507473, -0.030607594177126884, 0.015863774344325066, 0.011228330433368683, 0.017205093055963516, 0.036401573568582535, 0.007670228369534016, 0.038651950657367706, -0.020436586812138557, -0.009791044518351555, 0.055821023881435394, -0.050000082701444626, 0.022562773898243904, -0.017666619271039963, 0.012318835593760014, -0.03676866367459297, 0.007008198648691177, 0.05076408013701439, 0.010324188508093357, 0.03395092487335205, -0.04230619966983795, 0.03825152665376663, -0.04347499832510948, -0.06695950031280518, 0.04083647578954697, -0.066431425511837, 0.022134263068437576, 0.056609857827425, -0.03861141577363014, -0.06939907371997833, -0.004572967998683453, -0.03277650102972984, 0.0067180367186665535, 0.021733541041612625, -0.048795513808727264, 0.05282887443900108, -0.06744527816772461, 0.004213476553559303, -0.00605031568557024, -0.01733611337840557, -0.014593896456062794, 0.05919863283634186, -0.0018651236314326525, -0.06993569433689117, 0.043139465153217316, -0.049914631992578506, 0.009988163597881794, -0.033614277839660645, 0.048383329063653946, 0.012637854553759098, 0.03729207068681717, -0.056189555674791336, 0.0051432945765554905, -0.05599413067102432, -0.03719716891646385, 0.017366962507367134, -0.04491520673036575, 0.005600332748144865, -0.018125224858522415, 0.04791023209691048, 0.018967611715197563, 0.031131431460380554, -0.007482544053345919, 0.036507248878479004, 0.04291433468461037, -0.010872800834476948, -0.03607950359582901, 0.03887297958135605, -0.04373087361454964, 0.03440695255994797, 0.01776357740163803, -0.048142191022634506, -0.025005940347909927, 0.04286333546042442, 0.030985260382294655, -0.010402042418718338, -0.04826853796839714, 0.051919881254434586, -0.04683530703186989, -0.037936147302389145, -0.05283582583069801, -0.006923063192516565, 0.006342125125229359, 0.003397157182916999, 0.050967082381248474, 0.007052134722471237, 0.02464347891509533, -0.06592529267072678 ]
Speech synthesis systems powered by neural networks hold promise for multimedia production, but frequently face issues with producing expressive speech and seamless editing. In response, we present the Cross-Utterance Conditioned Variational Autoencoder speech synthesis (CUC-VAE S2) framework to enhance prosody and ensure natural speech generation. This framework leverages the powerful representational capabilities of pre-trained language models and the re-expression abilities of variational autoencoders (VAEs). The core component of the CUC-VAE S2 framework is the cross-utterance CVAE, which extracts acoustic, speaker, and textual features from surrounding sentences to generate context-sensitive prosodic features, more accurately emulating human prosody generation. We further propose two practical algorithms tailored for distinct speech synthesis applications: CUC-VAE TTS for text-to-speech and CUC-VAE SE for speech editing. The CUC-VAE TTS is a direct application of the framework, designed to generate audio with contextual prosody derived from surrounding texts. On the other hand, the CUC-VAE SE algorithm leverages real mel spectrogram sampling conditioned on contextual information, producing audio that closely mirrors real sound and thereby facilitating flexible speech editing based on text such as deletion, insertion, and replacement. Experimental results on the LibriTTS datasets demonstrate that our proposed models significantly enhance speech synthesis and editing, producing more natural and expressive speech.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04156v2
[ -0.012843701988458633, -0.05826502665877342, 0.017189621925354004, 0.012402094900608063, 0.006994940806180239, -0.045677248388528824, -0.0064202905632555485, 0.01567673496901989, -0.06517859548330307, -0.03132563829421997, -0.024801105260849, 0.01692202500998974, -0.03985142335295677, -0.01226163748651743, -0.05503667891025543, -0.016211453825235367, 0.05514003708958626, 0.031161705031991005, -0.04545722156763077, 0.008179444819688797, -0.04234775900840759, 0.021675091236829758, -0.03217875584959984, 0.021839892491698265, 0.017796313390135765, -0.008242184296250343, -0.05740698426961899, -0.008486894890666008, -0.044356152415275574, -0.01175786554813385, 0.057628899812698364, -0.021740837022662163, -0.021444126963615417, 0.001605661236681044, -0.07952453941106796, -0.04591602459549904, -0.025303533300757408, 0.022535396739840508, -0.014660127460956573, -0.030993236228823662, 0.03765219822525978, -0.06288771331310272, -0.06851287931203842, 0.005640353076159954, -0.04657573625445366, -0.03937143832445145, -0.043569307774305344, 0.017785856500267982, -0.05393398553133011, -0.028004435822367668, -0.0017792577855288982, 0.02200416661798954, -0.040857814252376556, 0.03506626933813095, -0.044672004878520966, 0.02026999182999134, -0.025108160451054573, -0.009803821332752705, -0.027078023180365562, -0.03534538298845291, 0.024190103635191917, -0.04581983759999275, -0.02414432168006897, 0.01097626332193613, -0.050538841634988785, 0.022360587492585182, -0.04784416779875755, -0.0035656513646245003, 0.019750840961933136, 0.005908789578825235, 0.010122018866240978, -0.07229090481996536, 0.006453793030232191, -0.041326239705085754, 0.004209591541439295, -0.030307946726679802, -0.01730571873486042, -0.051281724125146866, 0.0088678989559412, -0.029148874804377556, 0.027230234816670418, 0.02264612540602684, 0.03822800889611244, 0.06999486684799194, 0.0011001172242686152, -0.041554953902959824, 0.05417724326252937, -0.020191963762044907, -0.02781195566058159, -0.04997729882597923, 0.04846544936299324, -0.06003490835428238, -0.07703214138746262, 0.010799032635986805, 0.049523163586854935, -0.01857052743434906, 0.014340669848024845, -0.006619128864258528, 0.0004759762960020453, -0.00787675566971302, -0.025134919211268425, 0.02945946715772152, 0.011820465326309204, 0.056983958929777145, 0.03826791048049927, -0.036273110657930374, 0.049311913549900055, 0.019505199044942856, -0.055289071053266525, -0.027086814865469933, -0.03223877400159836, 0.015693234279751778, -0.0022810616064816713, -0.06488974392414093, -0.011220530606806278, -0.05287529528141022, 0.03091791644692421, -0.0005006822175346315, 0.025331789627671242, -0.019758358597755432, -0.009831641800701618, 0.06450779736042023, 0.022578392177820206, -0.01925840601325035, -0.03883684426546097, -0.04059648513793945, 0.02477487549185753, -0.005242212675511837, 0.03517712280154228, -0.025483623147010803, -0.021907217800617218, 0.039915673434734344, -0.04355594888329506, -0.012982508167624474, 0.03012179583311081, -0.007294523064047098, 0.004446833394467831, -0.050394922494888306, -0.032618213444948196, -0.04775383695960045, -0.05620522052049637, -0.062075287103652954, 0.0139163164421916, -0.035741060972213745, 0.03631988540291786, 0.04895886778831482, -0.02274603396654129, -0.047356367111206055, 0.0019188912119716406, 0.004500997252762318, -0.018359430134296417, -0.03666523098945618, 0.06828844547271729, 0.028225399553775787, -0.01698760874569416, -0.019148673862218857, 0.03829601779580116, 0.018593691289424896, -0.03530484437942505, 0.044912274926900864, -0.004248286131769419, -0.01941792480647564, 0.026754146441817284, -0.05525296553969383, 0.015289227478206158, -0.006844422779977322, 0.04023795202374458, 0.004396733827888966, -0.047348205000162125, 0.006139845587313175, -0.014422504231333733, 0.030140908434987068, -0.021654581651091576, -0.006725255865603685, -0.013524586334824562, -0.004718457348644733, 0.0540764294564724, -0.026042582467198372, 0.006491002626717091, 0.0295692328363657, -0.05907423794269562, 0.029744276776909828, -0.02815474383533001, -0.03674269840121269, -0.0429767370223999, -0.037454187870025635, -0.07485683262348175, -0.021389897912740707, 0.06371747702360153, -0.002894693985581398, -0.012161968275904655, -0.05089189484715462, -0.019903365522623062, 0.03794495016336441, -0.047147590667009354, -0.027761587873101234, 0.011384467594325542, -0.03990807384252548, 0.022433582693338394, 0.016647301614284515, -0.06894739717245102, 0.009657565504312515, -0.06258770078420639, -0.017518119886517525, 0.04504026472568512, -0.06990400701761246, -0.00716661149635911, 0.044237349182367325, -0.04011296108365059, -0.030103042721748352, 0.018984956666827202, 0.05241990089416504, 0.041930314153432846, 0.025123577564954758, 0.008651436306536198, 0.0186558049172163, -0.10070662200450897, 0.02809954807162285, -0.006567456293851137, -0.0332321897149086, 0.06145176663994789, 0.06080735847353935, 0.02990574575960636, 0.0036142750177532434, -0.003759324550628662, 0.0030142096802592278, 0.05075094848871231, -0.04239282384514809, -0.027199186384677887, -0.050248757004737854, -0.0253915973007679, -0.03363572806119919, -0.02414812706410885, -0.06902775168418884, -0.026195861399173737, 0.0023814579471945763, 0.007228949572890997, 0.03592986986041069, 0.045249905437231064, -0.05216158553957939, -0.03870602697134018, -0.039557211101055145, 0.0072127762250602245, -0.028705088421702385, -0.0582086555659771, -0.014158870093524456, 0.021001869812607765, 0.04147671163082123, -0.01733686588704586, -0.019892461597919464, 0.004455330315977335, -0.07917573302984238, -0.013213957659900188, 0.010895779356360435, -0.02360612154006958, 0.046938784420490265, -0.060521628707647324, 0.029290946200489998, -0.007328353356570005, 0.026083078235387802, 0.02988177165389061, 0.05953650549054146, -0.03927737846970558, 0.02258232608437538, 0.05368267744779587, -0.036033663898706436, 0.050144392997026443, 0.00507670734077692, -0.043787192553281784, -0.05805852636694908, 0.009093091823160648, 0.025693757459521294, 0.03902362287044525, -0.020331021398305893, -0.035299718379974365, -0.015643149614334106, 0.031216507777571678, 0.020279603078961372, 0.026583831757307053, 0.06574127078056335, 0.017700228840112686, -0.019804146140813828, 0.023688754066824913, -0.05188646540045738, 0.005099205765873194, -0.0048924656584858894, -0.03553355485200882, -0.050650231540203094, -0.037828221917152405, -0.030635733157396317, -0.03154012933373451, -0.050702054053545, -0.030688833445310593, -0.010205323807895184, -0.010608220472931862, -0.023101136088371277, 0.02477830834686756, -0.021784614771604538, 0.028893040493130684, -0.004411773756146431, -0.02911764197051525, 0.027172356843948364, 0.005139016546308994, 0.011941897682845592, -0.030528848990797997, -0.020299123600125313, -0.03917516767978668, -0.00979678425937891, 0.016519414260983467, 0.02978467009961605, 0.004938503261655569, 0.04579145088791847, -0.013053414411842823, 0.07061173021793365, 0.03022705391049385, -0.01161595806479454, 0.027469081804156303, 0.0373639315366745, 0.018679294735193253, -0.05839582905173302, -0.017219096422195435, -0.002164366189390421, 0.004005356226116419, -0.021496206521987915, -0.062066543847322464, -0.031907591968774796, 0.044298283755779266, -0.02040981315076351, -0.040313951671123505, -0.028834925964474678, -0.009215051308274269, 0.037425797432661057, 0.012750264257192612, 0.01967722177505493, 0.009926462545990944, 0.06465250253677368, -0.04014860838651657, -0.042906470596790314, -0.02683645486831665, -0.04044218733906746, -0.03637635335326195, 0.02817903831601143, -0.007931043393909931, 0.005926173646003008, 0.030047746375203133, -0.07992824912071228, 0.026027336716651917, 0.0384349450469017, 0.05629749223589897, -0.0218217670917511, -0.02333616465330124, -0.01829994097352028, 0.03496021032333374, 0.027160007506608963, -0.005003134720027447, -0.011747239157557487, 0.01848967932164669, 0.05148382484912872, -0.04401703178882599, 0.0038252377416938543, -0.00867742020636797, -0.058549992740154266, -0.07055341452360153, 0.0031239683739840984, 0.05893763527274132, 0.03298035264015198, -0.014104047790169716, -0.01726820133626461, 0.03614436089992523, -0.041332293301820755, 0.059115778654813766, -0.0045792777091264725, -0.06750161945819855, -0.015912240371108055, -0.039030905812978745, -0.0029322595801204443, 0.0029914684128016233, -0.02465478703379631, -0.06112803518772125, -0.04409589245915413, 0.018379120156168938, -0.06179432198405266, 0.02060021087527275, -0.03615341708064079, -0.04585689306259155, 0.03636894375085831, 0.03280032426118851, 0.015083961188793182, 0.06294362992048264, -0.022860759869217873, -0.004627434071153402, 0.027865516021847725, -0.01941130869090557, -0.009437371045351028, 0.01069844700396061, -0.058864809572696686, -0.048050232231616974, -0.01393513660877943, -0.029897868633270264, -0.044966984540224075, 0.007004056591540575, 0.01262655109167099, -0.00676345732063055, -0.06581944227218628, -0.021805787459015846, -0.04638839513063431, 0.03195950388908386, 0.051718708127737045, -0.0641927644610405, 0.04255666211247444, -0.011586151085793972, -0.019988246262073517, 0.020586170256137848, 0.01877562701702118, -0.07190866768360138, -0.07974375039339066, 0.02963409200310707, -0.07449301332235336, 0.04526432976126671, -0.07936582714319229, 0.04774695634841919, 0.011361966840922832, 0.048874277621507645, -0.02401452697813511, 0.004983612336218357, -0.02970651164650917, 0.0083586061373353, 0.061164941638708115, 0.05002017319202423, -0.019775090739130974, -0.00841972604393959, 0.004242489580065012, -0.004280664026737213, 0.010079638101160526, -0.01418020948767662, 0.010034961625933647, 0.0423087514936924, 0.0030312417075037956, -0.021806884557008743, 0.0414903350174427, -0.006394887808710337, -0.002443009754642844, -0.06655213981866837, -0.05411837249994278, 0.009232044219970703, 0.007230185437947512, -0.04637245461344719, -0.04647424444556236, -0.038941893726587296, -0.019512591883540154, -0.05548681318759918, -0.007995568215847015, 0.022197648882865906, 0.023007862269878387, -0.00437086122110486, 0.019512219354510307, 0.05025423318147659, -0.02195805497467518, 0.0016504439990967512, 0.01714334636926651, 0.057877082377672195, 0.008077194914221764, -0.0172035563737154, -0.016995366662740707, -0.050455912947654724, 0.02171529456973076, -0.052041057497262955, -0.013408164493739605, -0.006077163852751255, 0.004911498166620731, 0.025554047897458076, 0.05080164596438408, -0.0802379846572876, -0.00454962020739913, 0.03648911044001579, -0.03358745202422142, 0.010862772352993488, 0.03837859258055687, -0.022188987582921982, 0.03149300441145897, -0.0079205222427845, -0.0011636503040790558, -0.045401524752378464, -0.04658506065607071, 0.006669607944786549, 0.041091300547122955, 0.004228617530316114, 0.03608022257685661, 0.04822630435228348, -0.01545657217502594, -0.05222571641206741, -0.029469389468431473, 0.04744478315114975, 0.04052869603037834, -0.05375630781054497, -0.008355897851288319, 0.03356025367975235, -0.04994650557637215, -0.02686232514679432, -0.018887566402554512, -0.02576368674635887, 0.022423800081014633, 0.06852740794420242, -0.01139550656080246, -0.028977183625102043, 0.015980781987309456, 0.012792225927114487, 0.028587421402335167, -0.010786423459649086, -0.0008955516386777163, -0.009293782524764538, -0.001850552624091506, 0.010872953571379185, -0.007729560602456331, -0.042773257941007614, -0.04747622832655907, 0.0519869402050972, 0.032522767782211304, 0.028907999396324158, 0.0504852719604969, -0.006972850300371647, -0.027349665760993958, -0.03138723224401474, 0.0025984903331846, -0.04462893307209015, 0.03328530490398407, -0.03529771789908409, 0.014085586182773113, -0.04887012392282486, 0.02904585748910904, 0.01579464226961136, 0.06021375581622124, -0.013262099586427212, 0.012366748414933681, -0.010496336035430431, -0.021483633667230606, 0.013690750114619732, -0.04948781430721283, -0.024106696248054504, 0.03637625277042389, 0.006337855942547321, -0.044041767716407776, 0.05416419729590416, 0.042466532438993454, -0.02040361985564232, 0.01053173840045929, -0.018768351525068283, -0.039342429488897324, -0.05774841830134392, -0.020801713690161705, 0.05793832615017891, -0.05556503310799599, 0.027102282270789146, -0.0313577763736248, 0.013583296909928322, -0.011284894309937954, -0.07611078023910522, 0.05574891343712807, 0.04334564134478569, -0.020529326051473618, -0.0047874595038592815, 0.058880146592855453, -0.024073883891105652, -0.07504303753376007, -0.0038127300795167685, 0.02952234260737896, -0.07132576406002045, -0.008419869467616081, -0.028336232528090477, 0.03850017488002777, -0.0636226013302803, 0.024665886536240578, 0.0659039318561554, 0.033621545881032944, -0.0269936490803957, 0.07913075387477875, 0.041971355676651, -0.0402158759534359, -0.03986576944589615, 0.03542239964008331, -0.031410034745931625, 0.025127669796347618, -0.0516299232840538, -0.040531907230615616, 0.024405978620052338, 0.022385355085134506, 0.04912666231393814, -0.03680483624339104, 0.007988895289599895, 0.06744883209466934, 0.026695607230067253, 0.0394120067358017, -0.007514776661992073, -0.03259097412228584, 0.07771677523851395, -0.03692953661084175, -0.026178574189543724, -0.026477986946702003, -0.06166822090744972, -0.013431682251393795, -0.023500442504882812, -0.0328325517475605, -0.006089038215577602, 0.008605324663221836, 0.040692925453186035, -0.05478757992386818, 0.045448314398527145, -0.0008816266199573874, -0.08371958136558533, 0.009768765419721603, -0.08019702136516571, 0.00027875948580913246, 0.03266451880335808, 0.01669137366116047, 0.002407137304544449, 0.027588622644543648, -0.03954482078552246, -0.026841798797249794, 0.037635885179042816, 0.04531162977218628, -0.001446253270842135, -0.009987371042370796, -0.00455587450414896, -0.03610841557383537, 0.02546502649784088, -0.038654111325740814, -0.05378701910376549, 0.003972952254116535, -0.07201803475618362, -0.02735380083322525, 0.024091631174087524, -0.04069042205810547, -0.041566841304302216, 0.036966025829315186, 0.017388157546520233, 0.032407235354185104, 0.059003863483667374, -0.06508294492959976, -0.038784220814704895, 0.03266961872577667, 0.0267826858907938, 0.007925235666334629, 0.016232874244451523, -0.005042847245931625, -0.0030386578291654587, -0.049258552491664886, 0.04624178633093834, -0.017830865457654, -0.0030167512595653534, 0.01043721754103899, -0.049052439630031586, -0.004891382995992899, 0.025689885020256042, -0.0445813350379467, -0.03734331578016281, 0.016959823668003082, 0.009098591282963753, -0.061081334948539734, -0.008439380675554276, 0.05327223986387253, 0.035710643976926804, -0.010239697061479092, -0.060418423265218735, 0.015577133744955063, 0.006297518033534288, -0.06735395640134811, -0.05040518194437027, 0.03197130560874939, -0.029105862602591515, -0.007653696928173304, -0.02285785973072052, -0.009410462342202663, -0.05215100944042206, -0.010801299475133419, -0.08595433831214905, 0.021424217149615288, -0.04407254979014397, 0.04162975400686264, -0.04181691259145737, -0.0010114234173670411, 0.044599372893571854, -0.06691014766693115, 0.018196899443864822, -0.036042410880327225, -0.03470300883054733, 0.019728802144527435, -0.019402334466576576, 0.009581003338098526, -0.054852236062288284, -0.022618545219302177, 0.03194333612918854, -0.03220982477068901, -0.03829652816057205, 0.0013086330145597458, 0.007761545013636351, 0.03210192173719406, 0.045073676854372025, 0.00851381104439497, -0.035865604877471924, 0.04537219926714897, -0.053142763674259186, -0.0019765894394367933, -0.026194363832473755, -0.05056663602590561, 0.023947210982441902, -0.004670791793614626, 0.0028284527361392975, 0.01758837327361107, 0.03650817275047302, -0.006830946076661348, -0.005699778441339731, -0.037633370608091354, 0.03885325789451599, -0.06762655824422836, -0.036454010754823685, 0.05257432535290718, -0.02025928907096386, -0.014324815943837166, -0.048416659235954285, -0.009592684917151928, -0.024306850507855415, 0.05665910989046097, 0.061441291123628616, -0.04495006799697876, -0.005320065654814243, 0.005056723952293396, -0.004110783338546753, -0.03328239917755127, 0.007584217004477978, -0.018109258264303207, 0.055235110223293304, -0.007408782374113798, -0.03458709269762039, -0.049515966325998306, -0.028422441333532333, -0.015069945715367794, -0.07769053429365158, -0.04146258905529976, -0.04110144078731537, -0.013115756213665009, 0.04964440315961838, -0.00043465683120302856, 0.027841484174132347, 0.04878006875514984, 0.04973997175693512, 0.03599614277482033, 0.010688429698348045, 0.013077137991786003, -0.005469867493957281, 0.027030035853385925, -0.018622148782014847, 0.02614966221153736, -0.005412136670202017, -0.020337795838713646, -0.01612202823162079, 0.006696357857435942, -0.00196840800344944, -0.05342254787683487, 0.02209537662565708, -0.04196828603744507, 0.02943684346973896, 0.03205462172627449, -0.02336353063583374, -0.03960114344954491, -0.04891733452677727, 0.03156299144029617, -0.0159364752471447, 0.011326744221150875 ]
Large language models (LLMs) have shown great promise for capturing contextual information in natural language processing tasks. We propose a novel approach to speaker diarization that incorporates the prowess of LLMs to exploit contextual cues in human dialogues. Our method builds upon an acoustic-based speaker diarization system by adding lexical information from an LLM in the inference stage. We model the multi-modal decoding process probabilistically and perform joint acoustic and lexical beam search to incorporate cues from both modalities: audio and text. Our experiments demonstrate that infusing lexical knowledge from the LLM into an acoustics-only diarization system improves overall speaker-attributed word error rate (SA-WER). The experimental results show that LLMs can provide complementary information to acoustic models for the speaker diarization task via proposed beam search decoding approach showing up to 39.8% relative delta-SA-WER improvement from the baseline system. Thus, we substantiate that the proposed technique is able to exploit contextual information that is inaccessible to acoustics-only systems which is represented by speaker embeddings. In addition, these findings point to the potential of using LLMs to improve speaker diarization and other speech processing tasks by capturing semantic and contextual cues.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05248v3
[ -0.031079646199941635, -0.04499643296003342, 0.03850596025586128, -0.01116260141134262, 0.02884039841592312, 0.01941092498600483, -0.021854372695088387, -0.028826197609305382, -0.03147336095571518, -0.030722996219992638, -0.04291367158293724, 0.021702658385038376, -0.0656476616859436, -0.031048322096467018, -0.05532151833176613, 0.014809224754571915, 0.06252235174179077, 0.02214343287050724, -0.017076317220926285, 0.046733926981687546, 0.03644035384058952, 0.045129407197237015, -0.06459897011518478, 0.05063273385167122, 0.01865553669631481, -0.03448193892836571, -0.03512747213244438, -0.02977045252919197, -0.014959312044084072, -0.007870638743042946, 0.044533271342515945, -0.04237476363778114, -0.013892032206058502, -0.03652758151292801, -0.04118235036730766, -0.0023058843798935413, -0.05063050612807274, -0.008573220111429691, 0.02174350991845131, -0.02571931667625904, 0.03339584171772003, -0.04526781663298607, -0.057925816625356674, -0.0015677792252972722, -0.04118446260690689, 0.005101701710373163, -0.02399403415620327, 0.017233941704034805, -0.07223140448331833, -0.05639972165226936, 0.03924785181879997, 0.01944216527044773, -0.022910334169864655, 0.031307172030210495, 0.002787495031952858, 0.00016818047151900828, -0.02472487837076187, -0.00889495573937893, -0.07048460096120834, -0.006926150526851416, 0.034808218479156494, -0.05050288885831833, -0.017347579821944237, 0.010241156443953514, 0.0038370448164641857, 0.024814294651150703, 0.0070567382499575615, -0.04606153443455696, -0.05348392203450203, -0.04492003843188286, 0.026668773964047432, -0.056111980229616165, -0.015237160958349705, -0.0025563142262399197, -0.01277920976281166, -0.019885778427124023, -0.008700471371412277, -0.05300140008330345, -0.0439288504421711, -0.02226785570383072, -0.0608561746776104, 0.046317171305418015, 0.04173196107149124, 0.04461878165602684, -0.019936654716730118, -0.02429647371172905, 0.05493997037410736, -0.021171731874346733, 0.003839410375803709, -0.037567175924777985, 0.06137062609195709, -0.05219085142016411, -0.07612631469964981, 0.02359582670032978, 0.08073835074901581, -0.03423752263188362, 0.0008739733602851629, 0.004544347058981657, 0.006483730860054493, 0.01477737445384264, -0.025074172765016556, 0.0012980279279872775, -0.020950553938746452, 0.06669078022241592, 0.002418456133455038, -0.05834807828068733, 0.025017788633704185, -0.017044857144355774, -0.0427054725587368, -0.007091084029525518, -0.02727751061320305, -0.026873966678977013, -0.000491534941829741, -0.041210584342479706, -0.04723893851041794, -0.03525402024388313, 0.06765931099653244, -0.0024765210691839457, -0.012324596755206585, -0.038741979748010635, -0.047873158007860184, 0.05857384577393532, 0.022007562220096588, -0.02179758809506893, -0.02528013288974762, -0.016419798135757446, 0.06796693056821823, 0.04071545973420143, -0.04421504959464073, -0.03159617260098457, -0.016640622168779373, 0.03222255781292915, -0.00007990161975612864, -0.02899126522243023, 0.06691759079694748, 0.01949351839721203, -0.013778774067759514, -0.05954919755458832, 0.016402045264840126, -0.012840798124670982, -0.03144080936908722, -0.0679541826248169, 0.06885451078414917, -0.05914190784096718, 0.030417082831263542, 0.02775799296796322, -0.031108401715755463, -0.009196172468364239, 0.04207700863480568, 0.008752470836043358, 0.01234529260545969, -0.0014170195208862424, 0.004746928345412016, 0.044997699558734894, -0.013988965190947056, 0.003637014888226986, 0.038063738495111465, -0.0037914977874606848, -0.05126345902681351, 0.02626826986670494, 0.015182196162641048, -0.003440695349127054, 0.05738500878214836, -0.008826500736176968, 0.008397853001952171, -0.013934207148849964, 0.03984364494681358, -0.022075558081269264, -0.018253441900014877, 0.025301354005932808, -0.03886743262410164, 0.010142586193978786, -0.03264298290014267, -0.008013241924345493, -0.027329813688993454, -0.03824257105588913, 0.033681102097034454, -0.03342660516500473, -0.027832746505737305, -0.009045666083693504, -0.023669501766562462, 0.04132119193673134, -0.0269803237169981, -0.009958717040717602, -0.04461235925555229, -0.002222020411863923, -0.08028879761695862, -0.0014751058770343661, 0.0524594821035862, 0.045856229960918427, -0.03484458103775978, -0.03043917939066887, 0.021182533353567123, 0.006759120151400566, -0.02410290576517582, -0.030507370829582214, -0.012151621282100677, -0.038875073194503784, 0.0036835395731031895, 0.048621077090501785, -0.0750827044248581, -0.0026461847592145205, -0.07908044755458832, -0.02652171067893505, 0.010049298405647278, -0.07382195442914963, 0.003183626802638173, 0.018069088459014893, -0.033696435391902924, -0.00034199224319308996, 0.02756444364786148, 0.03700313717126846, 0.04147794470191002, 0.026550952345132828, -0.004147620406001806, -0.010219288989901543, -0.09432980418205261, 0.06507809460163116, -0.005677266512066126, -0.010022521018981934, 0.058493323624134064, 0.006993462797254324, -0.0069097550585865974, -0.01696132868528366, -0.010632732883095741, 0.008325990289449692, 0.060298796743154526, -0.043613921850919724, -0.055275484919548035, -0.0264948271214962, -0.01643766276538372, -0.02362731099128723, -0.042580291628837585, -0.08040767908096313, -0.009787431918084621, -0.006240449380129576, -0.005417551379650831, 0.006266022566705942, 0.010856155306100845, -0.03894605487585068, -0.04158635437488556, -0.011399973183870316, 0.02951059676706791, -0.017364973202347755, -0.050590138882398605, -0.02658344991505146, -0.022033782675862312, 0.051024023443460464, -0.019577184692025185, 0.015588619746267796, -0.03772665187716484, -0.02412230521440506, -0.038302138447761536, -0.007859551347792149, 0.005303489044308662, 0.0355573445558548, -0.027586117386817932, 0.03356630727648735, -0.005709537770599127, 0.04091265797615051, 0.022710159420967102, 0.04113718867301941, -0.07210063934326172, -0.011866601184010506, 0.03447404131293297, -0.019362613558769226, -0.014082728885114193, -0.015933288261294365, -0.005467458628118038, 0.0007420116453431547, 0.03746146336197853, 0.04435689374804497, 0.06289850920438766, -0.028997622430324554, -0.02575274556875229, -0.01989562064409256, 0.013449370861053467, 0.01686853915452957, 0.006664964370429516, 0.05081434175372124, 0.056060317903757095, 0.018221570178866386, 0.0519680380821228, -0.06250930577516556, -0.019561823457479477, -0.04054297134280205, -0.057493310421705246, -0.06843718141317368, -0.04652739316225052, -0.011109810322523117, -0.06949222087860107, -0.018970707431435585, -0.03265099972486496, 0.004145442508161068, -0.034580111503601074, -0.053864359855651855, -0.03511151298880577, -0.018908677622675896, 0.05600936338305473, -0.04249366372823715, -0.01358366385102272, 0.010326970368623734, 0.0009399048867635429, 0.002664976054802537, -0.016499735414981842, -0.016200002282857895, -0.0475364625453949, -0.030286280438303947, 0.0315311998128891, 0.029817214235663414, -0.028793565928936005, 0.05035486817359924, -0.005767961032688618, 0.02848184108734131, -0.012798630632460117, 0.0522143729031086, 0.0325201153755188, -0.0013403508346527815, -0.003851570188999176, -0.06717950850725174, 0.007740215864032507, -0.017736095935106277, -0.025823689997196198, 0.00009765219147084281, -0.04689681529998779, -0.013575180433690548, 0.05985086038708687, 0.01540781743824482, -0.058407094329595566, -0.028498632833361626, -0.03337905555963516, 0.0057655940763652325, 0.023060845211148262, 0.02285732887685299, 0.032347191125154495, 0.054319191724061966, -0.05385527014732361, -0.04924570769071579, -0.037986841052770615, -0.013064621947705746, -0.016761668026447296, 0.016122912988066673, 0.0052982838824391365, -0.002369372872635722, 0.031979385763406754, -0.07565505802631378, 0.03994029015302658, 0.061000969260931015, 0.06358278542757034, -0.007500944193452597, 0.021951153874397278, -0.005345516372472048, 0.010835771448910236, 0.04714982584118843, -0.026305509731173515, 0.031231120228767395, 0.005600686185061932, 0.03181691840291023, -0.053268589079380035, -0.0472719743847847, 0.022883683443069458, -0.06121227145195007, -0.02957708016037941, 0.002920835744589567, 0.02067113108932972, 0.01827991008758545, 0.044479962438344955, -0.06322334706783295, 0.016641585156321526, -0.02371893636882305, -0.0021080186124891043, 0.02116548828780651, -0.061600830405950546, 0.014989749528467655, -0.033619191497564316, 0.018896840512752533, 0.017037125304341316, -0.04094624146819115, -0.03228877857327461, -0.027561599388718605, 0.023263389244675636, -0.05761140584945679, 0.0016500185010954738, 0.02564002387225628, -0.049324121326208115, 0.013421550393104553, 0.05292918160557747, -0.037713903933763504, 0.036123715341091156, -0.03203112259507179, -0.05000659078359604, -0.02195475995540619, -0.01661176234483719, -0.043946750462055206, 0.0014041111571714282, -0.07255595922470093, 0.0008611965458840132, 0.020599693059921265, 0.009010611101984978, -0.018362686038017273, -0.009258394129574299, -0.004613804165273905, -0.010330166667699814, -0.08171094954013824, 0.0008907287265174091, -0.040852971374988556, 0.030408155173063278, 0.033096570521593094, -0.06098688393831253, 0.03097332827746868, -0.05378960072994232, -0.02494373545050621, -0.017029710114002228, 0.002605155576020479, -0.0592585951089859, -0.05875003710389137, 0.014961054548621178, -0.058539584279060364, 0.04291459172964096, -0.07057949155569077, 0.0411832258105278, -0.012622029520571232, 0.024100027978420258, -0.027849409729242325, 0.005999413318932056, -0.01708664745092392, 0.04659228026866913, 0.03901227191090584, 0.03474962338805199, 0.010211799293756485, 0.005970981437712908, 0.0088540343567729, -0.05551009625196457, -0.00917376670986414, -0.012811736203730106, -0.05177333950996399, 0.029362285509705544, -0.04812633991241455, -0.002953591989353299, 0.03309953212738037, -0.01609809137880802, 0.06270971149206161, -0.06959570944309235, -0.01825309358537197, 0.006766436155885458, 0.042726971209049225, -0.05620013549923897, -0.0612451396882534, -0.04926075413823128, -0.04059692099690437, -0.07715792208909988, -0.007530538365244865, 0.04801812395453453, 0.02952192723751068, -0.03079123981297016, 0.028834929689764977, 0.049239713698625565, -0.0038798584137111902, -0.033750638365745544, 0.012089874595403671, 0.04105019196867943, -0.0013287068577483296, -0.012747484259307384, -0.028542447835206985, -0.06813888996839523, 0.0222477950155735, -0.02862163633108139, -0.041995588690042496, -0.016369227319955826, 0.007950419560074806, 0.016688251867890358, 0.060300372540950775, -0.0720227062702179, 0.015070407651364803, 0.05391579121351242, -0.025047505274415016, 0.025037741288542747, 0.07211096584796906, -0.002516668289899826, 0.06525831669569016, -0.019604286178946495, 0.01763087511062622, -0.044827237725257874, -0.022702233865857124, 0.011518707498908043, 0.01605987176299095, 0.026729686185717583, 0.00008945627632783726, 0.05909652262926102, 0.023727547377347946, -0.05539539456367493, -0.0004118100623600185, 0.0376957543194294, 0.03361457958817482, -0.019396863877773285, 0.03466980531811714, 0.06692758947610855, -0.040413424372673035, -0.06255639344453812, -0.002436145907267928, -0.03883768245577812, 0.00004338186772656627, 0.057931676506996155, -0.06379637122154236, -0.010111373849213123, 0.030891939997673035, -0.017889074981212616, -0.003954928368330002, 0.032983701676130295, -0.012576953507959843, -0.026385722681879997, -0.011557593010365963, 0.022039996460080147, -0.03220151737332344, -0.006901388522237539, -0.049978744238615036, 0.05531661584973335, 0.062249861657619476, 0.017089514061808586, 0.028544429689645767, 0.0337882861495018, -0.006920393090695143, 0.005228196736425161, -0.022164715453982353, -0.02441059611737728, 0.030220478773117065, -0.02981269359588623, 0.04593812674283981, 0.012813527137041092, 0.0322408527135849, 0.024366913363337517, 0.029782796278595924, -0.02786000818014145, 0.05465323477983475, -0.03704337403178215, 0.022088883444666862, 0.019377244636416435, -0.055220555514097214, -0.0411016121506691, 0.052730266004800797, 0.00869725551456213, -0.0639064684510231, 0.030881015583872795, 0.021712854504585266, 0.00007918581832200289, 0.03462482616305351, -0.0026407046243548393, -0.05424034595489502, -0.041557300835847855, 0.01371952798217535, 0.07088162750005722, -0.02579118311405182, -0.030054643750190735, -0.013636072166264057, -0.015357648953795433, 0.006272482220083475, -0.04971897602081299, 0.004411518573760986, 0.04604940488934517, 0.03587363660335541, -0.0374547503888607, 0.06521286815404892, 0.021351641044020653, -0.0732831060886383, 0.01824675314128399, 0.015522177331149578, -0.08042293787002563, 0.004053796641528606, 0.0354338213801384, -0.016748769208788872, -0.055806778371334076, 0.014227167703211308, 0.004694758914411068, 0.02008398249745369, -0.009600172750651836, 0.05550090968608856, 0.06749262660741806, -0.027760645374655724, -0.009252087213099003, 0.021051254123449326, -0.04564347490668297, 0.005534297786653042, -0.04535294324159622, -0.04085957631468773, 0.014092354103922844, 0.02821263112127781, 0.04148951172828674, -0.04155564308166504, -0.014939866960048676, 0.04759391397237778, -0.01658480055630207, 0.04142317175865173, 0.031111350283026695, -0.01875104010105133, 0.05025900900363922, -0.04137072339653969, -0.02116534113883972, -0.002752084983512759, -0.044661425054073334, -0.02198897860944271, -0.044241562485694885, -0.03436720743775368, 0.02285025082528591, 0.0166923850774765, 0.02310284785926342, -0.05079873651266098, 0.0061797634698450565, 0.003510483307763934, -0.07903451472520828, -0.01700195111334324, -0.05543217808008194, 0.04950718209147453, -0.002772711683064699, 0.05409156531095505, 0.026629630476236343, 0.057008855044841766, -0.018155459314584732, -0.0417565256357193, -0.002492585452273488, 0.024106789380311966, 0.01192393247038126, -0.04689156264066696, -0.013418656773865223, -0.04282805323600769, 0.0442555770277977, -0.03800635784864426, -0.007529640104621649, 0.005960413254797459, -0.06267573684453964, -0.010049409233033657, 0.032901205122470856, -0.01075445394963026, -0.06403133273124695, 0.03918043151497841, -0.02147459238767624, 0.02167573757469654, -0.00181663129478693, -0.04713514447212219, -0.058437272906303406, -0.007532595191150904, 0.024115560576319695, -0.01672663353383541, 0.02547067031264305, 0.013932584784924984, 0.030989572405815125, -0.0265427865087986, -0.020550904795527458, -0.023953843861818314, -0.013701630756258965, 0.00890124961733818, -0.061333559453487396, -0.02117278054356575, -0.006248779129236937, -0.023331692442297935, -0.05353444442152977, 0.00964867603033781, 0.028462950140237808, -0.06129738315939903, 0.016982637345790863, 0.05598123371601105, 0.028475705534219742, 0.03245985880494118, -0.05123263597488403, 0.01899160072207451, -0.004773075692355633, -0.05991285294294357, -0.038342129439115524, 0.0049761016853153706, -0.033104848116636276, -0.027999835088849068, -0.030846713110804558, -0.0520767979323864, -0.0685056820511818, -0.03420275077223778, -0.07712151110172272, -0.008269518613815308, -0.016818102449178696, 0.024106184020638466, -0.030975956469774246, -0.03989117220044136, -0.005145440809428692, -0.050677478313446045, 0.022444114089012146, -0.02294510044157505, 0.010563268326222897, 0.012102019973099232, 0.018417272716760635, 0.018218427896499634, -0.06716612726449966, -0.011461653746664524, 0.042986273765563965, -0.0491667315363884, -0.014858780428767204, 0.036985184997320175, 0.010842051357030869, -0.007168835494667292, -0.009882603771984577, 0.06742364913225174, -0.028557462617754936, 0.0447397455573082, -0.06445655971765518, 0.0002885164867620915, -0.02915971539914608, -0.005340758245438337, 0.04113877937197685, -0.06074787303805351, 0.015022538602352142, 0.04606178030371666, -0.011633109301328659, -0.015846310183405876, -0.04793199524283409, -0.035873450338840485, -0.00941779650747776, -0.03312385827302933, -0.030129164457321167, 0.049654122442007065, 0.0022474711295217276, -0.05277309566736221, -0.0527106411755085, -0.015998201444745064, -0.018520968034863472, 0.034059226512908936, 0.046324219554662704, -0.015009555965662003, -0.023998627439141273, -0.06310420483350754, 0.01961357146501541, -0.040445633232593536, 0.007640272844582796, -0.008959942497313023, 0.05884208157658577, 0.011424189433455467, 0.009690459817647934, -0.030885914340615273, 0.007626967038959265, -0.007655936758965254, -0.07452896982431412, -0.052142947912216187, -0.02265949361026287, -0.006843595765531063, 0.04630180820822716, 0.020230688154697418, -0.005562808830291033, 0.039907556027173996, 0.03610241413116455, 0.006006089970469475, 0.021102719008922577, 0.038744401186704636, -0.00555584067478776, 0.056659162044525146, 0.004537361674010754, 0.028742404654622078, -0.05220453813672066, 0.018765650689601898, -0.03348209336400032, 0.010016966611146927, 0.00915501732379198, -0.010903540998697281, 0.040102630853652954, -0.06330280750989914, 0.03293682262301445, 0.027337538078427315, -0.02419872023165226, -0.039368584752082825, -0.0250227190554142, 0.019764099270105362, -0.03057793341577053, -0.018213752657175064 ]
The rise of unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) operations, as well as the vulnerability of the UAVs' sensors, has led to the need for proper monitoring systems for detecting any abnormal behavior of the UAV. This work addresses this problem by proposing an innovative multi-task learning framework (MLF-ST) for UAV state identification and trajectory prediction, that aims to optimize the performance of both tasks simultaneously. A deep neural network with shared layers to extract features from the input data is employed, utilizing drone sensor measurements and historical trajectory information. Moreover, a novel loss function is proposed that combines the two objectives, encouraging the network to jointly learn the features that are most useful for both tasks. The proposed MLF-ST framework is evaluated on a large dataset of UAV flights, illustrating that it is able to outperform various state-of-the-art baseline techniques in terms of both state identification and trajectory prediction. The evaluation of the proposed framework, using real-world data, demonstrates that it can enable applications such as UAV-based surveillance and monitoring, while also improving the safety and efficiency of UAV operations.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06741v1
[ -0.011398307047784328, -0.042939692735672, 0.039612311869859695, 0.030880142003297806, -0.018492715433239937, 0.03639713302254677, 0.008805397897958755, 0.01049371249973774, 0.01595684140920639, -0.016911324113607407, -0.06041916832327843, 0.05987592041492462, -0.04789229854941368, -0.05646640434861183, -0.04080846905708313, 0.04394405335187912, 0.07864503562450409, -0.014441924169659615, -0.03362814709544182, 0.07026289403438568, 0.0318027138710022, -0.01038436684757471, -0.0366501547396183, 0.005462000612169504, 0.01660211756825447, 0.003431132296100259, -0.013777149841189384, -0.010880740359425545, -0.05699077248573303, -0.01384799089282751, 0.06316901743412018, -0.01901751384139061, -0.05223153531551361, -0.0214233361184597, -0.01407027430832386, -0.012126898393034935, -0.036546491086483, 0.0559956319630146, 0.005454242695122957, -0.036122217774391174, 0.03189007192850113, -0.01588664948940277, -0.04077265039086342, -0.016359958797693253, -0.013415022753179073, -0.01921171508729458, -0.052015237510204315, -0.013211054727435112, -0.055075712502002716, -0.017482511699199677, 0.03424674645066261, -0.011186755262315273, 0.0060039120726287365, 0.0541122667491436, -0.01971263997256756, 0.004373055417090654, 0.009085120633244514, 0.002073913114145398, -0.05400276929140091, 0.031878355890512466, 0.041786111891269684, -0.034590743482112885, -0.02994019165635109, 0.0012404294684529305, -0.0006111577968113124, 0.06710698455572128, -0.038160037249326706, -0.06133050471544266, -0.050772447139024734, -0.002193580148741603, 0.048352282494306564, -0.05749769136309624, -0.01043529063463211, 0.029074693098664284, -0.012802723795175552, -0.024507243186235428, -0.023801183328032494, -0.022117681801319122, 0.013961716555058956, -0.02469930797815323, -0.018630320206284523, 0.016995113343000412, 0.05228628218173981, 0.052595797926187515, 0.015290076844394207, -0.021658282727003098, 0.06459470093250275, 0.0066824196837842464, 0.02588607184588909, -0.03188152611255646, 0.04200633615255356, -0.05446065962314606, -0.08381359279155731, -0.021983662620186806, 0.062367476522922516, -0.02181561104953289, 0.05329790711402893, -0.0023005546536296606, -0.018803587183356285, -0.02738887444138527, -0.029981790110468864, 0.008247045800089836, -0.03639286011457443, 0.06428752839565277, 0.033409759402275085, -0.059541378170251846, 0.04217318445444107, 0.023409226909279823, -0.013897424563765526, -0.01563972793519497, -0.01489635743200779, -0.05160796642303467, -0.024709079414606094, -0.0691981390118599, -0.02429276891052723, -0.022482486441731453, 0.058087483048439026, -0.016770755872130394, 0.03203007951378822, 0.054808106273412704, -0.054995033890008926, 0.031688373535871506, 0.0460212305188179, -0.01784502901136875, -0.025349272415041924, 0.0010442589409649372, 0.05840298533439636, 0.01445083599537611, -0.00688934838399291, -0.03198986127972603, 0.0034185482654720545, 0.024539954960346222, -0.008144120685756207, -0.024617113173007965, 0.034598637372255325, -0.02354195900261402, -0.005264503415673971, -0.06262049078941345, 0.013638597913086414, -0.04504556953907013, 0.003494956297799945, -0.06635495275259018, 0.011627462692558765, -0.0331665463745594, 0.0339852012693882, 0.0058462549932301044, -0.022068731486797333, -0.0335693284869194, 0.0074178604409098625, 0.015818841755390167, 0.0035598527174443007, 0.004405331797897816, 0.03400662913918495, 0.04776119440793991, 0.024901576340198517, -0.017203109338879585, 0.06274759024381638, -0.06307628005743027, -0.047948382794857025, 0.0004518356581684202, 0.017993347719311714, -0.005888013169169426, 0.035944100469350815, -0.020241450518369675, -0.01100895181298256, 0.0024892266374081373, 0.015431285835802555, 0.03466172516345978, -0.0017934648785740137, 0.0442705899477005, -0.006999180186539888, 0.012462615966796875, -0.028682276606559753, -0.017260927706956863, -0.05698172375559807, -0.030776165425777435, 0.04324110969901085, -0.058060552924871445, -0.013995976187288761, -0.027661960572004318, 0.006525327451527119, 0.0771183967590332, -0.012494874186813831, 0.005125025752931833, -0.031280625611543655, 0.008286421187222004, -0.08068735897541046, -0.02280806191265583, 0.008222436532378197, 0.02769024670124054, -0.060149237513542175, -0.06577453017234802, 0.020503969863057137, -0.006614774465560913, -0.058593347668647766, -0.035547103732824326, -0.009661753661930561, -0.04209985211491585, 0.031114229932427406, 0.02493637427687645, -0.08226379007101059, 0.009300541132688522, -0.07132382690906525, 0.0012254873290657997, -0.0026149849873036146, -0.07829604297876358, 0.025937519967556, 0.031050190329551697, -0.043495841324329376, -0.008305852301418781, 0.015686776489019394, 0.037560831755399704, 0.05812644213438034, 0.019931836053729057, 0.05218620225787163, 0.00316874822601676, -0.09570853412151337, 0.054473549127578735, -0.0020795364398509264, 0.02042497508227825, 0.05950726941227913, 0.009856174699962139, -0.022832946851849556, -0.019254101440310478, 0.026948291808366776, 0.029458705335855484, 0.07558510452508926, -0.034643080085515976, -0.056054458022117615, -0.019291561096906662, -0.017533667385578156, -0.054505739361047745, -0.07026369869709015, -0.05511333793401718, -0.03434557840228081, -0.021981924772262573, -0.039785485714673996, 0.044283509254455566, 0.01681593619287014, -0.016265278682112694, -0.013734551146626472, -0.011153078638017178, 0.027551934123039246, -0.039197590202093124, -0.047120723873376846, -0.021843252703547478, -0.020390566438436508, 0.0251397006213665, -0.019634779542684555, 0.011005966924130917, -0.03560749813914299, -0.04172844812273979, -0.034344036132097244, -0.006108312401920557, 0.021578215062618256, 0.030305692926049232, -0.049991410225629807, 0.0031563779339194298, -0.051423121243715286, 0.05074585974216461, -0.022228645160794258, 0.01631159521639347, -0.0773313045501709, 0.029399126768112183, 0.030687322840094566, -0.008587165735661983, 0.008492146618664265, -0.008633989840745926, 0.04568515717983246, -0.01204722374677658, -0.00901546236127615, -0.03856991231441498, 0.04368933290243149, -0.0083857960999012, -0.01007527019828558, -0.002186204306781292, -0.014636731706559658, -0.024041300639510155, 0.0007264955784194171, 0.04254814237356186, 0.05489371716976166, 0.02301882952451706, 0.04389296472072601, -0.0664542093873024, 0.0032134815119206905, -0.0608660951256752, -0.005193424876779318, -0.06668022274971008, -0.017476394772529602, -0.06211619824171066, -0.06069997698068619, -0.022135775536298752, 0.0021419087424874306, -0.04082135856151581, -0.0508786216378212, -0.06941670924425125, -0.036763884127140045, -0.031710509210824966, 0.0006893145618960261, 0.010291675105690956, -0.02937084622681141, -0.02970683015882969, -0.0070915441028773785, 0.01687375083565712, -0.03836880624294281, -0.06212645769119263, -0.0431080088019371, -0.02234940603375435, 0.020618142560124397, -0.03256691247224808, -0.003455530386418104, 0.046923842281103134, -0.013816062361001968, 0.030563538894057274, -0.01047102827578783, -0.005028458312153816, 0.0389254167675972, -0.03158893063664436, -0.02269539050757885, -0.029522407799959183, 0.03867696598172188, -0.011385083198547363, -0.007637627422809601, -0.03634730353951454, -0.049267884343862534, -0.030115924775600433, 0.06387835741043091, 0.0027574412524700165, -0.00426793796941638, -0.01383544597774744, 0.006531855557113886, -0.009836796671152115, -0.020389819517731667, 0.02037792280316353, 0.04075644537806511, 0.038475509732961655, -0.03462407365441322, -0.02386607602238655, -0.015668844804167747, 0.017454715445637703, -0.00566819217056036, 0.011356893926858902, -0.05072581768035889, -0.0004261025751475245, -0.0026489251758903265, -0.07173474878072739, 0.022738562896847725, 0.04207485169172287, 0.06321893632411957, 0.02671908587217331, 0.07033903151750565, 0.012723062187433243, 0.048606354743242264, 0.03817746043205261, 0.006752283312380314, 0.029012801125645638, 0.009795757941901684, 0.021860012784600258, -0.041897863149642944, -0.020980268716812134, 0.003108597593382001, -0.06311940401792526, -0.07575599104166031, 0.006825982592999935, 0.013352968730032444, 0.019874295219779015, 0.027322720736265182, -0.05616677552461624, 0.02324654906988144, 0.006729334592819214, 0.054198283702135086, 0.009028412401676178, -0.039982836693525314, 0.024618497118353844, -0.04209887236356735, 0.022708673030138016, 0.014290048740804195, -0.017148097977042198, 0.023949038237333298, -0.05535852909088135, 0.018159063532948494, -0.07354585081338882, 0.003436808008700609, 0.004791791085153818, -0.007184860296547413, 0.05407513305544853, 0.051063619554042816, -0.031093856319785118, 0.051279209554195404, 0.001086676144041121, -0.04879003018140793, -0.01982642151415348, 0.017837507650256157, -0.004736822564154863, 0.004650989547371864, -0.03621578961610794, -0.019971229135990143, 0.005029769614338875, -0.022548982873558998, -0.04092264175415039, 0.036713313311338425, 0.021512094885110855, 0.013725066557526588, -0.07230973988771439, 0.02794075757265091, -0.06217603757977486, 0.04155893996357918, -0.027415087446570396, 0.011339773423969746, 0.07232745736837387, -0.05164478346705437, -0.039117831736803055, -0.04243981093168259, 0.008585535921156406, -0.05474267899990082, -0.04768802970647812, 0.009320743381977081, -0.07275956124067307, 0.011992397718131542, -0.03469190374016762, 0.06190674006938934, -0.009488594718277454, 0.005826984066516161, -0.06642161309719086, -0.03377241641283035, 0.0278546791523695, 0.028003506362438202, 0.04364055395126343, -0.024728618562221527, 0.022696759551763535, 0.020367801189422607, -0.03101871721446514, 0.01100381650030613, 0.030492404475808144, 0.013174506835639477, -0.02419138327240944, 0.054399728775024414, -0.037029705941677094, 0.009638694114983082, 0.0058380779810249805, -0.006096298340708017, 0.07474943995475769, -0.02465367503464222, -0.01809137873351574, -0.01567884162068367, 0.040963299572467804, -0.05343270301818848, -0.03907417505979538, -0.045544229447841644, -0.05530978739261627, -0.037815701216459274, -0.01467229425907135, 0.047905631363391876, 0.05027928203344345, -0.005834686569869518, 0.03222055733203888, 0.039068035781383514, 0.05289221927523613, -0.032312650233507156, -0.0025117669720202684, 0.016106711700558662, 0.04077322036027908, 0.025472141802310944, -0.05530085042119026, -0.062024328857660294, 0.019094090908765793, 0.00756720220670104, 0.015495173633098602, -0.012663797475397587, 0.04414856433868408, 0.04107702895998955, 0.03001488372683525, -0.08441989123821259, 0.04095450043678284, 0.036026060581207275, -0.03857119753956795, 0.03322556987404823, 0.05828920751810074, 0.009045577608048916, 0.052866820245981216, -0.041338831186294556, -0.029607003554701805, 0.045526232570409775, -0.04533711448311806, 0.031758107244968414, 0.033015452325344086, -0.02018509991466999, 0.012248965911567211, 0.05141832306981087, -0.028890706598758698, -0.07275839149951935, 0.0073599014431238174, 0.027668992057442665, -0.009689598344266415, -0.0387231707572937, 0.042509276419878006, 0.04499669373035431, 0.0007491110591217875, -0.02887510135769844, -0.0008194652618840337, 0.03149940073490143, 0.011701039969921112, -0.005874523892998695, -0.039799049496650696, -0.005470935255289078, 0.030112599954009056, -0.03763971105217934, 0.005469663068652153, 0.012853524647653103, 0.0262629184871912, 0.020351339131593704, -0.02921888791024685, 0.04292822629213333, -0.051166847348213196, -0.045065756887197495, -0.007749784272164106, 0.015523887239396572, 0.062256377190351486, 0.035472262650728226, 0.04743203893303871, 0.00911091547459364, -0.022779686376452446, 0.014174964278936386, -0.00007287596963578835, -0.0436398945748806, 0.02429964579641819, -0.04192383214831352, 0.06333558261394501, -0.034786421805620193, 0.0363585464656353, 0.031013203784823418, 0.004771067760884762, 0.008034027181565762, -0.022322598844766617, -0.050519734621047974, 0.005529575515538454, -0.0030835899524390697, -0.015833085402846336, -0.05328032001852989, 0.05351415276527405, 0.041123803704977036, -0.017795855179429054, 0.010965617373585701, -0.0030803782865405083, -0.051715511828660965, 0.025451838970184326, -0.019057266414165497, -0.030615640804171562, -0.03894222900271416, -0.020392712205648422, 0.07460524141788483, -0.046223968267440796, 0.003742618951946497, -0.009035274386405945, -0.028672166168689728, 0.02743801288306713, -0.046912744641304016, -0.0017563893925398588, 0.05531511828303337, -0.006314575206488371, -0.061395563185214996, 0.02156992070376873, -0.027522055432200432, -0.06567729264497757, 0.0606549046933651, -0.02137502282857895, -0.06831231713294983, 0.02193833701312542, 0.03583456948399544, -0.029492691159248352, -0.06445837765932083, 0.047026608139276505, -0.011787245981395245, 0.017054494470357895, -0.037798088043928146, 0.04109358787536621, 0.07543433457612991, 0.028035221621394157, 0.012874839827418327, 0.009980636648833752, -0.03129740059375763, 0.01715240627527237, -0.000512984930537641, 0.012039770372211933, -0.028224343433976173, 0.0298482533544302, 0.04583989456295967, -0.0510881133377552, -0.02441827394068241, 0.06472743302583694, -0.03364957496523857, -0.008238452486693859, 0.014534910209476948, -0.009076104499399662, 0.05093959718942642, -0.010907918214797974, -0.04344639182090759, -0.022443067282438278, -0.0177808478474617, -0.01757359504699707, -0.02773931436240673, -0.011510088108479977, 0.025780901312828064, 0.032834243029356, 0.004499042872339487, -0.015752527862787247, 0.00645139254629612, -0.04822695627808571, -0.06595227122306824, 0.03500843793153763, -0.07165670394897461, -0.0001451938005629927, -0.014555033296346664, 0.009369323030114174, 0.03700271621346474, 0.06680478900671005, -0.07901199907064438, -0.059241555631160736, 0.007284244056791067, -0.009240212850272655, -0.0016037080204114318, -0.019866224378347397, -0.007882633246481419, 0.025323400273919106, 0.04407883808016777, -0.04241373762488365, -0.04424959048628807, -0.02506750449538231, -0.02015664614737034, 0.012788055464625359, -0.028982192277908325, -0.03603358194231987, -0.03114883229136467, 0.02484097145497799, -0.0040047974325716496, 0.013634608127176762, 0.01559091079980135, -0.0449664331972599, -0.07875660806894302, -0.01145388837903738, -0.027850011363625526, 0.007285108789801598, 0.01950790360569954, 0.0495084784924984, 0.06358058750629425, -0.015232216566801071, 0.0015040042344480753, 0.018967198207974434, -0.015347076579928398, -0.00379366846755147, -0.04588291049003601, -0.034789614379405975, 0.04101404547691345, 0.05840698257088661, -0.039495378732681274, -0.01917869970202446, -0.047728292644023895, -0.0525074265897274, 0.011213809251785278, 0.05673946067690849, -0.0340869314968586, 0.028312718495726585, -0.07497522979974747, -0.020240990445017815, -0.02712750993669033, -0.02048671804368496, -0.07259847968816757, -0.03617989271879196, -0.0034018049482256174, -0.027804456651210785, 0.01813146471977234, -0.014907325617969036, -0.025047890841960907, 0.009579549543559551, -0.06618033349514008, -0.010580774396657944, 0.02588062174618244, 0.026036109775304794, -0.007239798549562693, -0.04440287500619888, 0.02028023637831211, -0.04026135429739952, -0.0206658523529768, 0.00280665117315948, 0.01067650131881237, -0.029966551810503006, 0.028020676225423813, -0.038562629371881485, -0.05725782737135887, -0.01625213772058487, 0.017649391666054726, -0.03166275471448898, -0.002568549942225218, 0.018733428791165352, 0.020460765808820724, 0.031924065202474594, -0.02183198556303978, 0.04930001124739647, -0.0291081964969635, 0.03015964664518833, -0.04804353788495064, 0.017813900485634804, -0.003233708906918764, -0.05229412019252777, -0.013633779250085354, -0.07044856995344162, -0.007312711328268051, 0.032800186425447464, -0.04141952842473984, 0.020029323175549507, -0.028818907216191292, -0.06258054822683334, 0.01823613978922367, -0.005387863144278526, -0.029940851032733917, 0.026872392743825912, -0.049441512674093246, -0.011506271548569202, -0.015202928334474564, 0.010361913591623306, -0.008895811624825, 0.0010995324701070786, 0.02066057361662388, -0.05126473307609558, -0.011207868345081806, -0.05715113878250122, 0.034573234617710114, -0.006851079873740673, 0.016414450481534004, -0.07432117313146591, 0.06321453303098679, 0.033927351236343384, -0.016991160809993744, -0.0483103021979332, 0.007533704396337271, -0.016693001613020897, -0.07204067707061768, -0.048992495983839035, -0.031176390126347542, 0.0225045345723629, -0.03341003507375717, 0.004102570004761219, 0.018960287794470787, 0.03515231981873512, 0.016769081354141235, -0.015353664755821228, -0.009193290956318378, -0.001550650573335588, -0.014675413258373737, 0.08321808278560638, -0.0009476850391365588, 0.02340683899819851, -0.024266552180051804, 0.014894028194248676, -0.023999756202101707, -0.02320694550871849, -0.043917469680309296, 0.004902002401649952, -0.02357560209929943, -0.05047900602221489, 0.021018873900175095, 0.019988497719168663, -0.046222906559705734, -0.005340415984392166, -0.0340329185128212, 0.06176206097006798, -0.03647328540682793, -0.04875825345516205 ]
The attention towards food products characteristics, such as nutritional properties and traceability, has risen substantially in the recent years. Consequently, we are witnessing an increased demand for the development of modern tools to monitor, analyse and assess food quality and authenticity. Within this framework, an essential set of data collection techniques is provided by vibrational spectroscopy. In fact, methods such as Fourier near infrared and mid infrared spectroscopy have been often exploited to analyze different foodstuffs. Nonetheless, existing statistical methods often struggle to deal with the challenges presented by spectral data, such as their high dimensionality, paired with strong relationships among the wavelengths. Therefore, the definition of proper statistical procedures accounting for the peculiarities of spectroscopy data is paramount. In this work, motivated by two dairy science applications, we propose an adaptive functional regression framework for spectroscopy data. The method stems from the trend filtering literature, allowing the definition of a highly flexible and adaptive estimator able to handle different degrees of smoothness. We provide a fast optimization procedure that is suitable for both Gaussian and non Gaussian scalar responses, and allows for the inclusion of scalar covariates. Moreover, we develop inferential procedures for both the functional and the scalar component thus enhancing not only the interpretability of the results, but also their usability in real world scenarios. The method is applied to two sets of MIR spectroscopy data, providing excellent results when predicting milk chemical composition and cows' dietary treatments. Moreover, the developed inferential routine provides relevant insights, potentially paving the way for a richer interpretation and a better understanding of the impact of specific wavelengths on milk features.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06999v1
[ -0.0029577843379229307, -0.03136872500181198, 0.011496246792376041, 0.009523208253085613, -0.03706870228052139, -0.048496805131435394, -0.005396603140980005, -0.021621033549308777, -0.029045047238469124, -0.03533964604139328, -0.0723785012960434, -0.02091783657670021, -0.03907978534698486, -0.03252127021551132, -0.04443960636854172, 0.01581614278256893, 0.06877529621124268, 0.0004002547066193074, -0.059593621641397476, 0.0594601184129715, 0.008097180165350437, 0.0035324099007993937, -0.009049502201378345, 0.008106240071356297, 0.03146027773618698, -0.0020719151943922043, -0.026642655953764915, 0.016067786142230034, -0.037764135748147964, 0.017119646072387695, 0.04244592785835266, -0.033743955194950104, -0.03924814239144325, -0.05478585138916969, -0.03255998715758324, 0.027370020747184753, -0.023389369249343872, 0.02659529633820057, -0.007766133174300194, -0.041188132017850876, 0.03786725550889969, -0.034593429416418076, -0.03166309371590614, 0.00920881424099207, -0.041055284440517426, -0.01561968494206667, -0.04177616909146309, 0.013956699520349503, -0.06393031775951385, -0.010951397009193897, 0.03616775572299957, 0.011636572889983654, -0.02503817342221737, 0.06172901764512062, -0.042178332805633545, 0.0026153603103011847, -0.022742217406630516, -0.006509044207632542, -0.038426999002695084, 0.012127256952226162, 0.0025923014618456364, 0.020328126847743988, 0.047251079231500626, 0.027333350852131844, 0.00878282729536295, 0.051727134734392166, -0.05206170305609703, -0.0794207900762558, -0.03185278922319412, -0.06718733161687851, 0.025630220770835876, -0.03408198431134224, 0.03180466964840889, 0.036213528364896774, -0.0650043785572052, 0.021781789138913155, -0.01782226748764515, -0.0066314502619206905, 0.02489028312265873, 0.0033454701770097017, -0.04305996000766754, 0.03157513961195946, 0.015456643886864185, 0.04264095425605774, 0.003292699344456196, -0.009727340191602707, 0.040111955255270004, -0.01199068408459425, -0.0029344181530177593, -0.016427747905254364, 0.045795589685440063, -0.04307935759425163, -0.06186637654900551, -0.02867516689002514, 0.06823551654815674, -0.01713043823838234, 0.027087107300758362, 0.06580979377031326, 0.07336261868476868, -0.016399728134274483, 0.009048779495060444, -0.02359061874449253, -0.006399413570761681, 0.05533657968044281, 0.03920668363571167, -0.04508751630783081, 0.008296642452478409, 0.0026838236954063177, -0.02852708287537098, -0.03191627189517021, -0.00354206096380949, 0.006094644777476788, 0.00021073278912808746, -0.0598008893430233, -0.06939543783664703, -0.021282944828271866, 0.06353624910116196, 0.0092946607619524, 0.03032105788588524, 0.010027417913079262, -0.04953877255320549, 0.03837451711297035, 0.03943062946200371, -0.000773678591940552, -0.06692790985107422, 0.007330958731472492, 0.062282416969537735, 0.014460457488894463, 0.049747951328754425, -0.011478200554847717, -0.05142621323466301, 0.013760089874267578, -0.00840049609541893, -0.004778080154210329, 0.06990880519151688, -0.005543871317058802, 0.010806577280163765, -0.045480355620384216, 0.028078464791178703, 0.0388120636343956, -0.0356488972902298, -0.03794305399060249, 0.048919644206762314, -0.02975720539689064, 0.014105057343840599, 0.0588085763156414, -0.04918888211250305, -0.01610586605966091, 0.018987001851201057, 0.049713633954524994, -0.0006443859310820699, -0.02321608178317547, 0.022347815334796906, 0.026397820562124252, 0.027744432911276817, 0.005811465438455343, 0.054016076028347015, -0.025217203423380852, 0.005884196609258652, 0.01851881667971611, 0.030050616711378098, -0.017213501036167145, 0.026794858276844025, 0.012504116632044315, -0.002535776002332568, -0.007766661699861288, 0.04111611470580101, 0.013492921367287636, -0.04292600601911545, 0.03449319675564766, -0.03231261298060417, 0.00961686484515667, -0.012952092103660107, -0.023959731683135033, -0.0784931555390358, 0.026165610179305077, 0.0038913381285965443, -0.06335874646902084, -0.06183125451207161, -0.0005829292349517345, -0.01821819134056568, -0.0061226217076182365, -0.005469188559800386, 0.014006202109158039, -0.016885755583643913, 0.026106134057044983, -0.09303561598062515, -0.017500968649983406, 0.0450294055044651, 0.0011373988818377256, -0.043991222977638245, -0.04506777226924896, 0.030851518735289574, -0.011811153963208199, -0.03507820889353752, 0.003907063510268927, 0.006662512663751841, -0.053367696702480316, 0.02438061311841011, 0.04571520909667015, -0.07703924924135208, -0.030514473095536232, -0.0725037157535553, -0.0342533104121685, -0.013976718299090862, -0.06848250329494476, 0.014121230691671371, 0.02677098475396633, -0.030769074335694313, 0.013538309372961521, 0.038753293454647064, 0.06863728910684586, 0.06731937825679779, 0.025574499741196632, -0.009930617175996304, 0.00721557205542922, -0.1070762574672699, 0.03005887195467949, 0.017411798238754272, 0.0026628084015101194, -0.010981405153870583, 0.008145909756422043, -0.02244163118302822, -0.008504386991262436, -0.024280399084091187, 0.05221083387732506, 0.0747501477599144, -0.012831714004278183, -0.06738443672657013, -0.002768276259303093, -0.01701156236231327, -0.05384285748004913, -0.06104801595211029, -0.04428194463253021, -0.039013348519802094, -0.03479396551847458, 0.011218220926821232, 0.015948154032230377, -0.027504179626703262, -0.023323575034737587, -0.002113831229507923, -0.0024584413040429354, 0.07481684535741806, -0.0031495383009314537, -0.020737532526254654, -0.06414226442575455, -0.0032205183524638414, 0.01649731583893299, -0.03352396562695503, 0.02235005609691143, -0.029755303636193275, -0.06323026120662689, -0.039663128554821014, 0.02589014731347561, 0.0036691990680992603, 0.012467085383832455, -0.04000496864318848, 0.046168841421604156, -0.03011423349380493, 0.06906518340110779, -0.010776769369840622, 0.04225904867053032, -0.04442660138010979, 0.022585278376936913, 0.024042492732405663, 0.023820186033844948, 0.008871176280081272, -0.016090460121631622, 0.006755405571311712, -0.014476196840405464, -0.003037487855181098, 0.025939645245671272, 0.04577226936817169, -0.012373307719826698, -0.01389366202056408, 0.0005348756676539779, -0.010034809820353985, -0.01219907309859991, 0.05957182124257088, 0.0628366470336914, 0.03513756021857262, 0.014478113502264023, 0.017817573621869087, -0.06061306223273277, -0.0011881465325132012, -0.0116484509781003, -0.0024048404302448034, -0.05445181578397751, -0.07255782186985016, -0.03185774385929108, -0.08084684610366821, -0.0228023212403059, 0.0007547067361883819, -0.07505013793706894, -0.02130977064371109, -0.051481008529663086, -0.011214835569262505, -0.01839638687670231, 0.045526668429374695, 0.0004019279731437564, -0.04720296338200569, -0.02783535234630108, 0.03185246139764786, 0.006744010839611292, -0.027638424187898636, -0.034054189920425415, -0.04235336184501648, 0.014102050103247166, 0.035693757236003876, -0.03021351248025894, -0.0068491678684949875, 0.014774882234632969, -0.0012771736364811659, 0.035211749374866486, -0.024651436135172844, -0.005550754256546497, 0.03570045903325081, -0.003187543712556362, -0.0005355229368433356, 0.020221007987856865, 0.0506012849509716, -0.006007949355989695, 0.023231931030750275, 0.01923389732837677, -0.028420450165867805, -0.01582467183470726, 0.06145913898944855, -0.005526983644813299, -0.02413448877632618, -0.0012066214112564921, 0.0058211530558764935, 0.0148679930716753, 0.016570964828133583, 0.013990013860166073, 0.030446121469140053, 0.03267006203532219, 0.008045388385653496, -0.03780274838209152, -0.02832179144024849, -0.002176948357373476, 0.014041269198060036, 0.03885875269770622, -0.020618783310055733, 0.01814306527376175, 0.02760341577231884, -0.09802453219890594, 0.055821020156145096, 0.04957630857825279, 0.07459753006696701, 0.023120539262890816, -0.008387237787246704, 0.005032015033066273, -0.02176547423005104, -0.02285202592611313, -0.002149558160454035, 0.014697846956551075, -0.015048328787088394, 0.0468842051923275, -0.042703256011009216, -0.035227514803409576, 0.0004263745213393122, -0.056973397731781006, -0.06678137928247452, 0.0030849671456962824, 0.030242880806326866, 0.04270877316594124, 0.04368668794631958, -0.05790354683995247, 0.027334650978446007, -0.03987034410238266, 0.07011860609054565, 0.014894974417984486, -0.06625117361545563, 0.03408972918987274, -0.015445730648934841, 0.06832502037286758, 0.0018031136132776737, -0.015181941911578178, 0.03911711275577545, -0.0615198090672493, 0.02005978859961033, -0.0477658174932003, 0.0652422308921814, 0.04382014647126198, 0.013097009621560574, 0.03082311525940895, 0.04277702420949936, -0.014156635850667953, 0.006525356322526932, -0.009652200154960155, -0.02577914297580719, 0.011903943493962288, 0.015667304396629333, -0.04423726722598076, 0.00626929709687829, -0.06477103382349014, -0.005723495967686176, 0.02679835446178913, 0.008868400938808918, -0.029458273202180862, -0.02184203825891018, -0.046385157853364944, -0.05993707850575447, -0.09108962118625641, 0.02671414241194725, -0.05110472813248634, 0.04708776995539665, 0.005974913481622934, -0.05598997324705124, 0.06500279158353806, -0.044894132763147354, 0.019454998895525932, -0.056322574615478516, 0.03280256688594818, -0.0012446962064132094, -0.043534670025110245, -0.007139267399907112, -0.08460526168346405, 0.0028522941283881664, -0.05497147887945175, 0.06715763360261917, 0.001851579756475985, -0.004886719863861799, -0.029735947027802467, -0.02841535583138466, -0.01484106108546257, 0.02336222305893898, 0.07370050996541977, 0.014534389600157738, -0.007955952547490597, -0.01426622737199068, 0.004806595854461193, 0.04618029296398163, 0.009239482693374157, 0.022295642644166946, -0.02360175922513008, 0.03930742293596268, -0.02024161070585251, 0.017244858667254448, -0.027574658393859863, -0.016533132642507553, 0.0814521536231041, -0.04895160347223282, -0.053222861140966415, 0.01382690854370594, 0.039949264377355576, -0.024613671004772186, -0.07186876237392426, -0.03355332836508751, 0.020147645846009254, -0.06129102781414986, -0.027143681421875954, 0.06564361602067947, 0.027800021693110466, -0.03228887543082237, -0.02735188789665699, 0.033695876598358154, -0.0003977212472818792, 0.006834558676928282, 0.030312880873680115, 0.02808423899114132, 0.01597128063440323, -0.04624254256486893, -0.028327813372015953, -0.056684210896492004, -0.0022864409256726503, -0.010123638436198235, -0.0299685038626194, 0.0014288862003013492, 0.040301062166690826, 0.02570410445332527, 0.03774078190326691, -0.0932188406586647, 0.013679230585694313, 0.03020811825990677, -0.030903032049536705, 0.016804853454232216, 0.07186760753393173, 0.009380081668496132, 0.04404107853770256, -0.03854043409228325, 0.003788518952205777, -0.00297219748608768, -0.05096633359789848, 0.006643993314355612, 0.005220738705247641, -0.00015426175377797335, 0.0006253071478568017, 0.054903753101825714, -0.02831878885626793, -0.05492226779460907, -0.002221207832917571, 0.035414911806583405, 0.011632591485977173, -0.012221385724842548, 0.04015210270881653, 0.03758305311203003, -0.01902296021580696, -0.05169769376516342, -0.0030091453809291124, -0.03178846463561058, 0.027276398614048958, 0.06413896381855011, -0.019890056923031807, -0.04663802310824394, 0.03127150610089302, 0.01343750860542059, -0.0034727200400084257, 0.03840000554919243, -0.01000180933624506, -0.00882240105420351, -0.02243993803858757, 0.0032737047877162695, -0.06390033662319183, -0.029615022242069244, -0.053084686398506165, 0.03689054027199745, 0.0094784926623106, 0.01613432541489601, 0.06574194878339767, 0.011769677512347698, 0.018906641751527786, -0.04392850771546364, -0.02654499188065529, -0.023166349157691002, 0.010398332960903645, 0.0020022836979478598, 0.041937582194805145, -0.02254050225019455, 0.06297696381807327, 0.03260916471481323, -0.007842078804969788, 0.011879454366862774, -0.0001873973524197936, -0.010838573798537254, 0.017841409891843796, 0.039933398365974426, 0.03820161893963814, -0.05766373872756958, 0.04553002864122391, 0.026224350556731224, -0.04232608154416084, 0.06919704377651215, -0.00015918425924610347, -0.03622252866625786, -0.0008386372937820852, 0.006095401477068663, -0.013403707183897495, -0.03894902765750885, 0.030024394392967224, 0.0883382111787796, -0.05611080303788185, -0.022235482931137085, -0.0481879897415638, -0.026962999254465103, -0.031513895839452744, -0.046095363795757294, 0.050537094473838806, 0.007966974750161171, -0.0024964299518615007, -0.07464762777090073, 0.05484074726700783, -0.02614927664399147, -0.07395051419734955, -0.005111122503876686, -0.007981441915035248, -0.057080335915088654, -0.01572125218808651, 0.045483727008104324, 0.02776484750211239, 0.015735236927866936, 0.03286886215209961, -0.003787943162024021, -0.026818444952368736, -0.03315693512558937, 0.04818214476108551, 0.0782543420791626, -0.011288315989077091, 0.03470943495631218, -0.007836677134037018, -0.033936355262994766, 0.01876760832965374, -0.009801898151636124, 0.0019678922835737467, -0.005224472843110561, 0.02303272671997547, 0.028121378272771835, -0.03627069294452667, -0.007560661528259516, 0.07300206273794174, -0.04787725210189819, 0.0173846073448658, -0.001368420198559761, 0.012845812365412712, 0.05264163389801979, -0.017578857019543648, -0.048211704939603806, 0.0076492587104439735, 0.023431280627846718, 0.008602816611528397, 0.004603222943842411, -0.023624565452337265, -0.030428966507315636, 0.024275870993733406, 0.005219041835516691, -0.050457462668418884, 0.027851786464452744, -0.01127544417977333, -0.061271194368600845, 0.006073649041354656, -0.06993172317743301, -0.009230785071849823, 0.009189384058117867, 0.017932986840605736, 0.04539470002055168, 0.011238548904657364, -0.04338550567626953, 0.00995778851211071, 0.028610892593860626, -0.0009332729387097061, 0.018243202939629555, 0.02556171454489231, 0.05239395797252655, 0.0016685419250279665, 0.016059990972280502, -0.056181009858846664, -0.011344745755195618, -0.026160553097724915, -0.011336857452988625, -0.0022286376915872097, 0.031194401904940605, -0.03332219645380974, -0.034161318093538284, -0.03544224053621292, -0.018790781497955322, 0.009029789827764034, 0.06226719915866852, -0.03508437052369118, -0.06057075411081314, -0.010894810780882835, -0.003844085382297635, -0.009117024950683117, 0.015595669858157635, 0.04534027352929115, 0.048748929053545, -0.022211667150259018, 0.028226474300026894, 0.02675968036055565, 0.011844227090477943, 0.04486940801143646, -0.05390920117497444, -0.03824346512556076, 0.024036414921283722, -0.011000622995197773, -0.012043335475027561, 0.0027234230656176805, -0.00526039581745863, -0.04826822504401207, 0.009683456271886826, 0.03705862909555435, 0.02098098397254944, -0.015123673714697361, -0.05342746898531914, 0.03506328538060188, 0.03091057389974594, -0.018916156142950058, -0.06961143016815186, 0.008456754498183727, -0.009947150945663452, -0.015692122280597687, -0.032120026648044586, -0.030538391321897507, -0.05584550276398659, 0.03722718358039856, -0.07999765127897263, 0.01726529374718666, -0.015082282945513725, 0.07217239588499069, -0.0342058502137661, -0.01471292320638895, 0.018078651279211044, -0.045852068811655045, 0.021293453872203827, 0.0403505377471447, 0.03568815439939499, -0.004702380858361721, 0.05017957463860512, -0.02832808904349804, -0.04124055057764053, -0.029226090759038925, 0.026057695969939232, -0.014693748205900192, 0.028924113139510155, 0.00542478496208787, 0.04345647245645523, -0.028375940397381783, 0.004440498538315296, 0.05970601364970207, 0.016222115606069565, 0.0307096466422081, -0.041142191737890244, 0.038459111005067825, -0.024750925600528717, -0.04611517861485481, 0.014576118439435959, -0.028344150632619858, -0.022272929549217224, 0.0055986675433814526, 0.03493514657020569, -0.00252125458791852, 0.0011525049339979887, -0.06320768594741821, 0.02624516561627388, -0.007272037211805582, -0.01688624918460846, 0.04474150761961937, -0.05453156679868698, 0.02565145678818226, -0.027141783386468887, 0.0032956390641629696, -0.05913951247930527, 0.006938169710338116, 0.03492432460188866, -0.057264916598796844, 0.0035181515850126743, -0.07671844959259033, 0.026655856519937515, -0.012539397925138474, -0.007456466555595398, -0.028868673369288445, 0.053706057369709015, -0.03298481926321983, -0.0028510643169283867, 0.0002484464203007519, -0.02595905214548111, -0.02627386897802353, -0.07160607725381851, -0.059753887355327606, -0.0445806160569191, 0.024951787665486336, 0.014427409507334232, 0.004304549656808376, 0.017944596707820892, 0.05039091780781746, 0.0235315952450037, 0.02137104794383049, 0.0037597219925373793, 0.030475132167339325, -0.04967372119426727, 0.06441638618707657, 0.011299596168100834, 0.046252358704805374, -0.05813837796449661, 0.01176171749830246, -0.020761756226420403, -0.030848097056150436, 0.012019060552120209, -0.0026142331771552563, -0.045415572822093964, -0.06032387912273407, 0.015766175463795662, 0.011193555779755116, 0.022481728345155716, -0.05153340473771095, -0.028043927624821663, 0.041824813932180405, -0.035360708832740784, -0.052640896290540695 ]
The Kruskal-Szekeres coordinates construction for the Schwarzschild spacetime could be viewed geometrically as a squeezing of the $t$-line associated with the asymptotic observer into a single point, at the event horizon $r=2M$. Starting from this point, we extend the Kruskal charting to spacetimes with two horizons, in particular the Reissner-Nordstr\"om manifold, $\mathcal{M}_{RN}$. We develop a new method for constructing Kruskal-like coordinates and find two algebraically distinct classes charting $\mathcal{M}_{RN}$. We pedagogically illustrate our method by constructing two compact, conformal, and global coordinate systems labeled $\mathcal{GK_{I}}$ and $\mathcal{GK_{II}}$ for each class respectively. In both coordinates, the metric differentiability can be promoted to $C^\infty$. The conformal metric factor can be explicitly written in terms of the original $t$ and $r$ coordinates for both charts.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10123v2
[ 0.00044106197310611606, -0.06833422183990479, 0.028444578871130943, -0.04387018084526062, -0.022269193083047867, -0.03559371456503868, -0.055641405284404755, -0.013484731316566467, -0.013244908303022385, -0.004921397659927607, -0.026297390460968018, -0.03460334241390228, -0.027429237961769104, -0.027592014521360397, -0.05659247562289238, 0.050513628870248795, 0.0604277141392231, -0.005419744644314051, -0.03517211601138115, 0.06224467232823372, -0.03204992413520813, -0.05725405737757683, -0.01944916509091854, 0.045652784407138824, -0.01757062040269375, -0.02702995389699936, -0.024797385558485985, -0.05856282636523247, -0.06695406138896942, -0.006549125537276268, 0.06118801608681679, -0.06069372594356537, 0.009413373656570911, -0.03896072879433632, -0.027220608666539192, 0.033856555819511414, 0.04041526839137077, 0.03568166494369507, -0.014735287055373192, -0.031204266473650932, -0.019008897244930267, -0.04677600786089897, -0.04373082518577576, -0.024628102779388428, -0.02721293643116951, -0.0334106907248497, 0.003411497687920928, -0.03481409326195717, -0.02149171754717827, -0.01299857534468174, 0.04080141708254814, 0.01844380423426628, -0.004250332713127136, 0.05165822058916092, -0.0052444832399487495, 0.0031487317755818367, 0.002626554574817419, -0.01693497970700264, -0.03707902133464813, -0.01643223874270916, -0.010056070052087307, -0.05333833768963814, 0.0071959407068789005, -0.011838474310934544, 0.014565089717507362, 0.03780914470553398, -0.07010358572006226, -0.07584403455257416, -0.01899661310017109, -0.04770965874195099, -0.024783413857221603, -0.06744150072336197, 0.04526183754205704, -0.0384763665497303, -0.07589089125394821, 0.058386050164699554, -0.03230314701795578, -0.028997058048844337, -0.039193637669086456, 0.006802103482186794, -0.027201784774661064, -0.0015958386939018965, -0.01953866146504879, 0.029683154076337814, 0.009959151037037373, -0.027291754260659218, 0.03704619035124779, -0.005093587562441826, 0.015707308426499367, -0.052233461290597916, -0.037254560738801956, -0.053553126752376556, -0.05047481879591942, -0.03284601494669914, 0.06512638926506042, -0.03587651252746582, 0.06232008710503578, 0.03365326672792435, 0.03593011200428009, -0.018537508323788643, -0.002173915272578597, -0.03068268485367298, 0.013067487627267838, 0.06333617866039276, 0.051524728536605835, -0.014848338440060616, 0.040897201746702194, 0.04342532157897949, -0.02394891157746315, 0.007248674053698778, -0.0017852807650342584, 0.018563324585556984, 0.04914180934429169, -0.027212971821427345, -0.03912804648280144, -0.06729239970445633, 0.04718337580561638, 0.039070721715688705, 0.0562736839056015, 0.005338703282177448, -0.02129298634827137, -0.005762884858995676, 0.04669458791613579, -0.04046567901968956, -0.029446573927998543, -0.045363593846559525, 0.04692217335104942, -0.008966021239757538, 0.0371142253279686, 0.019473187625408173, 0.001663855044171214, -0.03158318251371384, 0.027458414435386658, 0.0020471105817705393, -0.018816471099853516, -0.0025648740120232105, -0.004920256789773703, -0.03650998696684837, 0.006551597733050585, 0.033637117594480515, -0.028476441279053688, -0.0721466988325119, 0.016942208632826805, -0.004426528234034777, 0.0038131659384816885, 0.044562581926584244, -0.05205000564455986, -0.03465331345796585, -0.00034583575325086713, 0.027921637520194054, -0.037596695125103, -0.06073693931102753, 0.060407742857933044, 0.03014235384762287, 0.02304030954837799, -0.03891213983297348, 0.055879876017570496, -0.00914216972887516, -0.0519346185028553, -0.002847391879186034, 0.035321932286024094, 0.004060941282659769, 0.012281540781259537, -0.026835110038518906, 0.009143182076513767, 0.03618011251091957, 0.02769567258656025, -0.019590333104133606, 0.00005156145562068559, 0.024250974878668785, -0.007559982128441334, -0.018518557772040367, 0.017101198434829712, -0.019185522571206093, -0.0684964507818222, -0.028140755370259285, -0.035727161914110184, 0.0015035398537293077, -0.02047751098871231, -0.02020447701215744, -0.03766321390867233, -0.04460434243083, -0.010746757499873638, -0.0043571712449193, -0.07056961208581924, 0.006482232362031937, -0.05315769463777542, 0.017676109448075294, 0.021368520334362984, 0.04472971335053444, 0.010154442861676216, -0.04887039586901665, 0.0313347727060318, 0.0010875912848860025, -0.059021491557359695, 0.013049297034740448, 0.012829495593905449, -0.06515896320343018, -0.015380783937871456, -0.027856191620230675, -0.05792393907904625, -0.04544370248913765, -0.033178385347127914, 0.001034146174788475, 0.02739228680729866, -0.07815323770046234, 0.02779514528810978, 0.012687982060015202, 0.008418482728302479, -0.053267061710357666, 0.053125765174627304, -0.022293949499726295, 0.02758428454399109, 0.0036699974443763494, -0.00906431581825018, -0.00911120604723692, -0.0824347659945488, 0.037415456026792526, -0.039564814418554306, 0.024474216625094414, 0.0071495105512440205, 0.00016799912555143237, -0.020756307989358902, -0.06773731857538223, -0.05028826370835304, 0.040945157408714294, 0.041059743613004684, 0.03150177747011185, -0.06213916093111038, -0.052462004125118256, -0.03878212720155716, -0.07332944124937057, -0.041147954761981964, -0.045942045748233795, -0.019320430234074593, -0.02901880443096161, -0.05532204359769821, 0.052392005920410156, -0.005939836148172617, -0.007958866655826569, -0.05904652178287506, 0.02785346284508705, 0.01636740192770958, -0.05308177322149277, -0.059623319655656815, -0.04965965449810028, -0.0637475997209549, 0.002779776928946376, -0.05994540452957153, -0.0003570261469576508, 0.03856027126312256, -0.04069719463586807, -0.04642609879374504, -0.01557433046400547, 0.009116362780332565, 0.03025144338607788, -0.03299220651388168, -0.004815128166228533, -0.025288622826337814, 0.057135503739118576, -0.005791925359517336, 0.000945175183005631, -0.06176326051354408, -0.01800019107758999, -0.03750522807240486, -0.006145389750599861, -0.06488236784934998, -0.045637477189302444, -0.025542503222823143, -0.015174699947237968, 0.035511355847120285, -0.04924494028091431, 0.052278801798820496, 0.00213574874214828, -0.0388946495950222, 0.006086146924644709, -0.01478249579668045, -0.026772938668727875, 0.026851842179894447, 0.03646346181631088, 0.0387645959854126, 0.04302871227264404, -0.03694314882159233, -0.07137948274612427, 0.03361073508858681, -0.011204304173588753, -0.003934226930141449, -0.029554763808846474, -0.05571519955992699, -0.018902376294136047, -0.03861246630549431, -0.0023590719792991877, -0.031071018427610397, -0.03795146197080612, -0.012890754267573357, -0.07734666019678116, 0.014298520050942898, -0.0021835225634276867, -0.044277556240558624, -0.05843215435743332, -0.020551010966300964, 0.014005391858518124, -0.01440876442939043, 0.042157214134931564, -0.03588421642780304, -0.054878611117601395, -0.05582121014595032, 0.03853186219930649, -0.018919287249445915, 0.04913711175322533, -0.04179782047867775, -0.0046585905365645885, -0.01941331848502159, -0.008267667144536972, 0.024197645485401154, -0.016345903277397156, -0.01879921928048134, -0.054606907069683075, 0.017634399235248566, -0.0166263859719038, 0.0187733992934227, -0.028772706165909767, 0.02156737446784973, -0.03002418391406536, -0.054041169583797455, -0.04892105236649513, 0.008015278726816177, 0.056467458605766296, -0.04488185793161392, -0.024996215477585793, 0.008160981349647045, -0.044844746589660645, -0.02087598294019699, 0.027629723772406578, 0.043986085802316666, 0.00425835931673646, -0.01060833316296339, -0.02250765822827816, -0.04754605144262314, -0.03890136256814003, -0.005255775526165962, 0.0071632531471550465, 0.005449099466204643, -0.0006793745560571551, 0.011612113565206528, -0.07777756452560425, 0.06835878640413284, 0.04713383689522743, 0.042151812463998795, 0.004587529692798853, -0.03369928151369095, -0.01835579238831997, 0.03677773475646973, -0.03310919925570488, -0.02807563915848732, 0.050918664783239365, 0.028565626591444016, 0.020527901127934456, -0.04164187237620354, -0.01919523999094963, 0.008086011745035648, -0.019954776391386986, 0.0020848626736551523, 0.048018328845500946, -0.0017878811340779066, 0.0361044742166996, 0.04651319608092308, -0.009908013045787811, -0.005180953536182642, 0.0066320220939815044, 0.020087918266654015, -0.04177163168787956, -0.030441831797361374, 0.01600906439125538, -0.029139364138245583, 0.006615335587412119, 0.004730794578790665, 0.02784959226846695, 0.010067743249237537, -0.059784092009067535, -0.007620269898325205, -0.04280245676636696, 0.010448249988257885, -0.00484292209148407, -0.016530221328139305, 0.019512396305799484, 0.00949929654598236, 0.028160396963357925, 0.030576178804039955, -0.036234159022569656, 0.007662272080779076, -0.017178842797875404, -0.019348014146089554, -0.018428297713398933, -0.001476419041864574, -0.036991532891988754, -0.010074946098029613, -0.04340391233563423, -0.017330169677734375, -0.06300831586122513, 0.03662596270442009, -0.022579191252589226, -0.03451397642493248, -0.0544765368103981, -0.06519517302513123, -0.03034171462059021, -0.024873940274119377, 0.0059875138103961945, -0.06146417185664177, 0.040845271199941635, 0.017994344234466553, -0.013055206276476383, -0.035324446856975555, 0.010001256130635738, -0.03862014785408974, -0.02004619501531124, -0.046511538326740265, -0.05715808644890785, 0.0032151672057807446, -0.06693264842033386, 0.033335790038108826, 0.011584755033254623, -0.009982895106077194, -0.043948907405138016, 0.00761587405577302, -0.04118821397423744, 0.008523431606590748, -0.0340672992169857, 0.04699243605136871, 0.03986484557390213, -0.02232668735086918, -0.05299290642142296, 0.017088087275624275, -0.03170222043991089, -0.022928383201360703, -0.027935288846492767, 0.06716042011976242, -0.04363664984703064, -0.025738254189491272, -0.011364723555743694, -0.011335529386997223, 0.010031143203377724, -0.031954698264598846, 0.0027886598836630583, 0.019498419016599655, 0.03502452373504639, -0.07086408883333206, -0.045629870146512985, -0.04388123005628586, 0.0031741580460220575, -0.07152938097715378, 0.06372574716806412, 0.04020779952406883, -0.003953006584197283, 0.0033916549291461706, 0.027784638106822968, 0.019190357998013496, 0.007422902621328831, -0.04709935933351517, 0.03279362618923187, -0.014519399963319302, 0.023225141689181328, -0.01313810795545578, -0.02200409583747387, -0.06966868788003922, 0.000006280115485424176, -0.0366823635995388, -0.00831300113350153, 0.026987368240952492, 0.05697246640920639, -0.03157190978527069, 0.05256436765193939, -0.07783274352550507, 0.027014512568712234, 0.012931203469634056, -0.05076286569237709, -0.017960313707590103, 0.03743553161621094, -0.01560268085449934, 0.005839921068400145, 0.01254551112651825, 0.008921724744141102, -0.006556973792612553, -0.0271258894354105, -0.022837527096271515, 0.008189259096980095, -0.01068592444062233, -0.03496258333325386, 0.012382904067635536, -0.009530940093100071, -0.03948678821325302, -0.01145739946514368, -0.028712408617138863, 0.012332350946962833, -0.04123251512646675, 0.06569907814264297, 0.039156511425971985, -0.062115706503391266, -0.039189327508211136, -0.01734987087547779, -0.015698863193392754, 0.05688657611608505, 0.021384866908192635, -0.0008228655206039548, 0.024001164361834526, 0.031495701521635056, -0.0035510689485818148, -0.023864876478910446, 0.03143272548913956, 0.038787953555583954, -0.04748692736029625, 0.028488272801041603, 0.005192648619413376, -0.05308763310313225, -0.03733724728226662, -0.04832037538290024, 0.03985394909977913, 0.04759036377072334, 0.015510577708482742, 0.056403275579214096, 0.012330048717558384, -0.006982411723583937, -0.050652407109737396, -0.015989096835255623, -0.017914969474077225, 0.06164870038628578, -0.055944256484508514, 0.012004079297184944, -0.04535672813653946, 0.017587237060070038, -0.04077107459306717, -0.01687292940914631, 0.04036080464720726, -0.04142584279179573, -0.03280721977353096, -0.018161240965127945, 0.027017051354050636, -0.0042905304580926895, -0.04278405383229256, -0.02805534563958645, 0.024658890441060066, -0.05440286174416542, 0.037312041968107224, 0.057313647121191025, 0.030784975737333298, -0.010758142918348312, 0.022501472383737564, 0.06961893290281296, -0.056315209716558456, -0.01653326116502285, 0.059339337050914764, -0.03207922354340553, 0.0023672785609960556, -0.03578443452715874, -0.019267980009317398, 0.008128835819661617, -0.055550526827573776, 0.007784546818584204, -0.00278128357604146, 0.02669951133430004, -0.04991019144654274, 0.05192701146006584, 0.005928171798586845, -0.06020171195268631, -0.028939880430698395, 0.02375016175210476, -0.05408462882041931, -0.059713393449783325, -0.020246023312211037, -0.031330712139606476, -0.027074838057160378, 0.034353163093328476, -0.06325781345367432, -0.052934419363737106, -0.05577147379517555, 0.035020697861909866, 0.06481388211250305, -0.02713000774383545, 0.05876125022768974, 0.014590580016374588, -0.041198618710041046, 0.02803438901901245, -0.0414879135787487, 0.013191809877753258, -0.020886648446321487, 0.045116376131772995, 0.02408331073820591, -0.05135228857398033, -0.004805173259228468, 0.05677081644535065, -0.027751557528972626, -0.04039696604013443, 0.027104686945676804, 0.005434856750071049, 0.060990676283836365, 0.02317451871931553, -0.014776063151657581, -0.04339458793401718, -0.0247934702783823, -0.029581395909190178, -0.004874351434409618, 0.03229106590151787, -0.016784274950623512, 0.013812139630317688, -0.03768039122223854, -0.017895668745040894, 0.004233502317219973, -0.01749604567885399, -0.04798335209488869, -0.03059365786612034, -0.07015206664800644, 0.022246990352869034, -0.02606223151087761, 0.04459818825125694, -0.0007785431225784123, -0.008680624887347221, -0.060143426060676575, -0.022686412557959557, -0.05291580408811569, -0.0004695903044193983, 0.016810450702905655, 0.018772393465042114, 0.031657855957746506, -0.023094424977898598, 0.05850754305720329, -0.0630110576748848, -0.002798472298309207, -0.050418734550476074, -0.050649430602788925, 0.011368363164365292, -0.027540989220142365, -0.02934892475605011, -0.018924297764897346, 0.01175966951996088, -0.045053452253341675, 0.04376516118645668, 0.049261871725320816, 0.008576747961342335, -0.07007898390293121, 0.01928863488137722, 0.011854350566864014, -0.04783997684717178, -0.014442169107496738, -0.03878749534487724, 0.025685971602797508, 0.03720078244805336, 0.02298732101917267, 0.004352236166596413, -0.015520087443292141, -0.012069263495504856, -0.05681546777486801, -0.0064012338407337666, -0.007108467631042004, -0.012163044884800911, -0.05148394778370857, -0.017702225595712662, -0.049778155982494354, -0.06230897456407547, 0.02888421155512333, 0.02541862614452839, 0.01723458617925644, -0.011113343760371208, -0.06363670527935028, 0.014274007640779018, -0.01683439128100872, 0.034298621118068695, -0.07865949720144272, 0.013166919350624084, -0.015126359649002552, -0.015990907326340675, -0.050633154809474945, 0.004672331269830465, -0.04936489835381508, 0.04611767455935478, -0.0718088373541832, -0.007122574839740992, -0.010170922614634037, 0.04722296819090843, 0.027859903872013092, 0.002594246994704008, -0.04956633225083351, -0.05514921993017197, -0.050207726657390594, -0.012948567047715187, 0.006645143963396549, 0.02362440712749958, 0.026361936703324318, -0.033470332622528076, -0.02452373504638672, -0.0020502503030002117, 0.05740085616707802, 0.020773034542798996, -0.01608191430568695, 0.03798961639404297, 0.030773771926760674, -0.03873176500201225, -0.004309313837438822, 0.0622684471309185, 0.00726995849981904, 0.06027606129646301, -0.03962808847427368, -0.040264520794153214, -0.05008543282747269, -0.05514594912528992, -0.04609346762299538, -0.059946209192276, -0.0023779389448463917, -0.03658687695860863, -0.06613543629646301, -0.04036930203437805, -0.03669438883662224, -0.05898072570562363, 0.04064762592315674, -0.0032802766654640436, -0.039865992963314056, 0.01634545437991619, -0.034201789647340775, -0.0018656919710338116, -0.012572206556797028, -0.01919572986662388, -0.048492807894945145, -0.04348564147949219, 0.014743215404450893, -0.030646443367004395, -0.018035707995295525, -0.05307348072528839, 0.027713067829608917, -0.02738649956882, -0.05017337203025818, 0.04156633839011192, 0.025630902498960495, 0.033504635095596313, 0.05047694966197014, -0.03382866457104683, 0.003947889432311058, 0.02312268503010273, -0.06920447200536728, 0.014187940396368504, -0.04037877172231674, 0.012658137828111649, 0.0028578736819326878, 0.022275863215327263, 0.003131420351564884, 0.054778583347797394, 0.0020620019640773535, -0.008235919289290905, 0.049918998032808304, 0.014233093708753586, 0.014014935120940208, -0.030075546354055405, -0.005631294101476669, -0.035613395273685455, -0.003903045551851392, 0.0271831676363945, 0.028983986005187035, 0.016313379630446434, -0.04535575956106186, 0.006990755908191204, 0.015497533604502678, -0.04522176459431648, -0.004211584106087685, 0.03804323822259903, 0.025990519672632217, -0.07080071419477463, 0.053361646831035614, -0.03722430393099785, -0.05665871873497963, -0.028907276690006256 ]
Sentiment analysis using big data from YouTube videos metadata can be conducted to analyze public opinions on various political figures who represent political parties. This is possible because YouTube has become one of the platforms for people to express themselves, including their opinions on various political figures. The resulting sentiment analysis can be useful for political executives to gain an understanding of public sentiment and develop appropriate and effective political strategies. This study aimed to build a sentiment analysis system leveraging YouTube videos metadata. The sentiment analysis system was built using Apache Kafka, Apache PySpark, and Hadoop for big data handling; TensorFlow for deep learning handling; and FastAPI for deployment on the server. The YouTube videos metadata used in this study is the video description. The sentiment analysis model was built using LSTM algorithm and produces two types of sentiments: positive and negative sentiments. The sentiment analysis results are then visualized in the form a simple web-based dashboard.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16234v1
[ -0.044937413185834885, -0.041625797748565674, -0.0004588354204315692, -0.038969166576862335, -0.03987075388431549, 0.013850877061486244, 0.034385938197374344, 0.0066499896347522736, -0.06667967885732651, -0.060578327625989914, -0.06402390450239182, 0.052860308438539505, 0.024981705471873283, -0.010069390758872032, -0.01859414391219616, 0.0023909523151814938, 0.0707293227314949, 0.002954805502668023, -0.06057581678032875, -0.005437779240310192, -0.008576522581279278, -0.014997834339737892, -0.006008232943713665, 0.01750764809548855, 0.005843738093972206, -0.058391913771629333, -0.04255359247326851, -0.017538629472255707, -0.06029364466667175, -0.04202719032764435, 0.07468917220830917, -0.042162567377090454, -0.07162953913211823, -0.06523715704679489, -0.019586121663451195, -0.0471816211938858, -0.019934115931391716, 0.009308536536991596, 0.0002647440996952355, -0.03688698261976242, 0.0677272155880928, -0.067599818110466, -0.06209756061434746, -0.034272655844688416, -0.00017028221918735653, 0.007855067029595375, -0.07148919999599457, 0.06614790856838226, -0.07925344258546829, -0.03784426674246788, -0.0063039460219442844, -0.053112905472517014, -0.030011165887117386, 0.039378292858600616, -0.07151709496974945, 0.03439004346728325, 0.010265124961733818, -0.029608359560370445, -0.0292655099183321, 0.02046000398695469, 0.047325730323791504, -0.0012594932923093438, -0.038367535918951035, 0.02641182579100132, -0.008068068884313107, -0.011187979951500893, -0.05308571457862854, -0.02712707780301571, -0.021983999758958817, -0.05593837797641754, 0.042734432965517044, -0.06809508800506592, 0.010763147845864296, -0.011717698536813259, -0.03766188770532608, 0.03018428012728691, 0.021734409034252167, -0.026820356026291847, -0.02523387409746647, -0.03310071676969528, -0.03437507897615433, -0.01486540213227272, 0.05856246128678322, 0.03598271682858467, -0.003834574716165662, -0.04728683829307556, 0.008911268785595894, -0.017585450783371925, 0.032010987401008606, -0.046445224434137344, 0.018149735406041145, -0.014954131096601486, -0.05132884532213211, -0.030078576877713203, 0.05140659213066101, -0.02934134006500244, 0.0014436936471611261, -0.007003278937190771, 0.03414864465594292, -0.020808642730116844, -0.050948478281497955, 0.024265041574835777, -0.021995237097144127, 0.004706489387899637, 0.036267563700675964, -0.06280786544084549, -0.0001506602857261896, 0.033011920750141144, -0.058581769466400146, 0.007286017760634422, -0.04688286781311035, -0.01465153880417347, -0.02049037627875805, -0.04151162877678871, 0.0011987695470452309, 0.003046042285859585, 0.065192312002182, 0.012185185216367245, 0.03520336374640465, 0.027900144457817078, -0.03446314483880997, 0.04942421615123749, 0.040081918239593506, -0.05139743164181709, -0.06891856342554092, -0.038005053997039795, 0.003795688273385167, 0.011653578840196133, 0.008555246517062187, -0.048525791615247726, -0.03190115839242935, 0.04926178976893425, -0.03244957700371742, -0.02223213203251362, 0.050512008368968964, -0.016974812373518944, -0.032529816031455994, -0.06614445894956589, -0.014139292761683464, -0.009076613001525402, -0.04053971916437149, -0.06409021466970444, -0.029735423624515533, 0.008591151796281338, -0.009171350859105587, -0.01222322043031454, 0.030582908540964127, 0.037555210292339325, -0.014731261879205704, 0.01797935925424099, -0.0013872969429939985, 0.012007431127130985, 0.0650520771741867, 0.046251751482486725, -0.030017560347914696, -0.013067035004496574, 0.019960453733801842, -0.03219515085220337, -0.02744147554039955, 0.06301826983690262, -0.006679445039480925, -0.040395691990852356, 0.031543780118227005, 0.018246985971927643, 0.005057217553257942, -0.011951405555009842, 0.0438707210123539, -0.020176615566015244, -0.0005140550201758742, -0.009226423688232899, -0.04131549224257469, 0.020762545987963676, -0.06164512038230896, -0.046560633927583694, -0.06726577132940292, -0.023909078910946846, 0.03441017493605614, -0.03033638373017311, -0.043598998337984085, -0.019061380997300148, -0.05890902876853943, 0.04256438463926315, -0.04095258563756943, -0.016811007633805275, -0.037560220807790756, 0.008241208270192146, -0.05960679054260254, -0.037424128502607346, 0.005647990852594376, 0.056367650628089905, 0.006568473763763905, -0.009709296748042107, -0.0345458947122097, -0.01960757002234459, -0.040310148149728775, 0.012942703440785408, 0.061082858592271805, -0.042740002274513245, 0.02201780490577221, 0.044513069093227386, -0.06146220117807388, -0.06390964984893799, -0.055416837334632874, -0.017106104642152786, -0.008154833689332008, -0.07081655412912369, 0.0044160084798932076, 0.027483854442834854, 0.00738499453291297, -0.03922782465815544, 0.024422744289040565, 0.05069512501358986, 0.060350120067596436, -0.008792958222329617, 0.023697005584836006, 0.006505812052637339, -0.08435973525047302, 0.04891445115208626, 0.055126823484897614, -0.0038571686018258333, 0.0010812778491526842, 0.05132414773106575, -0.007684139534831047, 0.013194234110414982, -0.03288770467042923, -0.027247413992881775, 0.02716626040637493, -0.012703318148851395, -0.03147009760141373, 0.0027303388342261314, -0.05506078153848648, -0.04403167590498924, 0.0061572459526360035, -0.025894204154610634, -0.02602255530655384, -0.032776135951280594, -0.00579774659126997, 0.03245462849736214, -0.019061272963881493, 0.02832547016441822, 0.014557437971234322, -0.03557150438427925, 0.00004655312295653857, -0.04128606244921684, -0.03361157700419426, 0.005271767731755972, 0.002187753561884165, 0.058268699795007706, -0.03301726281642914, 0.021470772102475166, -0.04208400845527649, -0.06481627374887466, -0.04817898944020271, -0.007917279377579689, 0.05014294758439064, -0.03411014378070831, 0.008085175417363644, 0.031594168394804, -0.002119834767654538, 0.06205169856548309, 0.011011854745447636, 0.05865490064024925, -0.05938047915697098, 0.02956341579556465, 0.0064736902713775635, -0.01740686036646366, 0.04522794112563133, -0.030414411798119545, 0.021026067435741425, -0.023033883422613144, 0.03455103561282158, 0.050512637943029404, 0.03801431134343147, 0.01580514945089817, -0.04412036016583443, -0.01786862127482891, -0.002908966038376093, -0.007496433332562447, 0.056851670145988464, 0.06428076326847076, 0.042395591735839844, 0.03573627769947052, 0.014483567327260971, -0.061292070895433426, 0.040338654071092606, -0.04714850336313248, -0.05007839947938919, -0.07946597784757614, -0.04869464412331581, -0.0219215527176857, -0.08055106550455093, -0.0072972881607711315, -0.0415472574532032, -0.06734735518693924, -0.02714165486395359, -0.05049720034003258, -0.02313285693526268, -0.05993875861167908, 0.05490626394748688, 0.03603788837790489, -0.04165768623352051, -0.025625688955187798, 0.013193557038903236, -0.035022906959056854, -0.00164342753123492, -0.052401743829250336, -0.019900716841220856, -0.04493044316768646, 0.024114016443490982, -0.016705021262168884, -0.0028557206969708204, 0.04021473228931427, -0.04860518500208855, -0.015488415956497192, 0.011087624356150627, -0.017373522743582726, -0.038509879261255264, 0.05680260807275772, 0.03121069446206093, -0.01153599377721548, 0.044259168207645416, -0.03884449973702431, -0.019441867247223854, -0.06144053116440773, -0.029308877885341644, -0.017362205311655998, 0.036287661641836166, -0.034934595227241516, -0.042535342276096344, -0.0546930730342865, 0.003952746745198965, 0.003759953659027815, -0.0015284180408343673, 0.009160795249044895, 0.04584817588329315, 0.0026649823412299156, -0.019388729706406593, -0.017877593636512756, -0.014408957213163376, -0.016100173816084862, 0.021365268155932426, -0.04260389134287834, -0.032837022095918655, 0.02938668429851532, 0.020971372723579407, -0.07850821316242218, 0.049635693430900574, 0.07281620055437088, 0.05663834884762764, 0.010986944660544395, 0.009306319989264011, 0.01274773757904768, 0.016431456431746483, -0.00999385304749012, 0.020431648939847946, -0.00011920922406716272, -0.007497900631278753, 0.037124667316675186, -0.07009395956993103, -0.012939338572323322, 0.007939773611724377, -0.03182068467140198, -0.050995007157325745, -0.02884359285235405, 0.014332206919789314, 0.06398578733205795, 0.04773076996207237, -0.05267846956849098, 0.03832123801112175, 0.0029463572427630424, 0.03538205102086067, 0.01767447404563427, 0.033236004412174225, 0.003732645185664296, -0.07370676100254059, 0.048014674335718155, 0.028853746131062508, -0.04658662527799606, -0.043282005935907364, -0.004516938701272011, 0.05011669173836708, -0.04162216931581497, 0.04345884919166565, 0.008023872971534729, -0.003009377047419548, 0.010339485481381416, -0.0026801121421158314, -0.024154476821422577, 0.0462801568210125, -0.0110474843531847, -0.03138122707605362, -0.019846893846988678, -0.02371649630367756, -0.030010079964995384, -0.026033850386738777, -0.0383722186088562, 0.015364638529717922, 0.01713133230805397, 0.0043191262520849705, -0.03896361216902733, -0.005079407244920731, -0.011865150183439255, 0.03170138970017433, -0.07570333033800125, 0.012174620293080807, -0.05114710330963135, 0.002901284722611308, 0.0252675898373127, -0.021745692938566208, 0.015708357095718384, -0.023424848914146423, 0.010587443597614765, -0.012254791334271431, -0.008199711330235004, -0.05512016639113426, -0.030402004718780518, 0.03947821259498596, -0.0668005645275116, 0.03534270077943802, -0.06181207299232483, -0.013124476186931133, -0.05505712330341339, 0.041189417243003845, 0.014402320608496666, -0.05077990144491196, -0.06279576569795609, 0.03280363976955414, 0.07642725110054016, -0.02250496670603752, -0.037104520946741104, 0.0029598292894661427, 0.0394429974257946, 0.02009330689907074, 0.008642961271107197, 0.006897816900163889, 0.0008154288516379893, 0.020866312086582184, -0.03152604028582573, 0.01214235182851553, -0.002941938117146492, 0.013969777151942253, 0.023703522980213165, -0.008996480144560337, -0.03742527961730957, -0.016585515812039375, -0.026476196944713593, -0.05617912858724594, -0.06154785305261612, -0.02610022760927677, -0.051455024629831314, -0.02345109172165394, 0.008416548371315002, 0.03641891852021217, 0.02974810265004635, 0.035720136016607285, -0.0008302381611429155, -0.025513211265206337, 0.033387720584869385, 0.001880972064100206, 0.010983605869114399, -0.05228118598461151, 0.002968580462038517, -0.04651814326643944, -0.01808348298072815, -0.036597996950149536, 0.035947877913713455, -0.06237952411174774, -0.018817070871591568, -0.036894604563713074, 0.02719060704112053, 0.042542215436697006, 0.06946210563182831, -0.0697379857301712, 0.02959269843995571, 0.04077373072504997, 0.021906953305006027, 0.0150217916816473, 0.06311111152172089, -0.015144376084208488, 0.02194737270474434, 0.02934695966541767, 0.012455198913812637, -0.01836400292813778, -0.054167523980140686, 0.012390829622745514, 0.04162931442260742, 0.03688757121562958, -0.02462855912744999, 0.018185866996645927, 0.014016491360962391, -0.012909832410514355, 0.01785869337618351, 0.023619653657078743, 0.045021865516901016, -0.015197888016700745, 0.00656275125220418, 0.020682228729128838, -0.054256096482276917, -0.012337462976574898, -0.030369751155376434, -0.0618353970348835, -0.03412320464849472, 0.008306227624416351, -0.026413505896925926, 0.03666592389345169, -0.006774638779461384, -0.03435475379228592, -0.001953482162207365, -0.011818161234259605, 0.038443852216005325, 0.013788077980279922, 0.023098215460777283, 0.014021764509379864, -0.03622446581721306, 0.016464008018374443, 0.010439913719892502, 0.02109057828783989, 0.048141662031412125, 0.056591328233480453, 0.008836137130856514, -0.019547563046216965, 0.03873705863952637, -0.0034165331162512302, 0.04410487413406372, -0.03795190155506134, -0.022893020883202553, -0.04339432343840599, -0.028138935565948486, 0.004911419004201889, 0.01464454922825098, 0.04294070601463318, 0.018229080364108086, 0.06790759414434433, -0.01198053639382124, -0.03660443425178528, -0.026105867698788643, 0.0342257060110569, 0.018915172666311264, -0.06027020141482353, 0.023092232644557953, -0.033881742507219315, 0.014192256145179272, 0.02417336404323578, -0.003076890716329217, -0.05005773529410362, -0.0003164616646245122, 0.041600704193115234, 0.0037061814218759537, -0.034719765186309814, -0.020246559754014015, 0.029536666348576546, 0.008246195502579212, 0.03047896921634674, -0.03645233437418938, -0.043070368468761444, -0.030471595004200935, -0.023527367040514946, 0.013860851526260376, 0.018072091042995453, -0.03700348734855652, -0.0008459718083031476, 0.03994102030992508, -0.0302202720195055, -0.0719972476363182, 0.05513504147529602, -0.0176553875207901, -0.07670924812555313, -0.01268594991415739, 0.06386308372020721, -0.0009180064080283046, -0.02047288604080677, 0.03936616703867912, -0.041068289428949356, 0.01229419931769371, -0.042139727622270584, 0.030827801674604416, 0.03227710351347923, -0.020379815250635147, -0.012205569073557854, 0.01727069355547428, -0.07415550202131271, 0.020253697410225868, 0.00453780684620142, 0.03381558880209923, -0.041106123477220535, 0.016580456867814064, 0.01641419529914856, -0.0529024712741375, 0.019265811890363693, 0.03528508171439171, -0.028029676526784897, 0.00732160871848464, -0.001435662736184895, 0.005737591069191694, 0.03696944937109947, -0.06256784498691559, -0.06368886679410934, 0.032597120851278305, 0.0238792821764946, -0.025096789002418518, -0.011762842535972595, 0.003562804078683257, 0.040900446474552155, -0.027228930965065956, -0.0060647414065897465, -0.05511825531721115, -0.015437752939760685, 0.007419282104820013, -0.06602401286363602, 0.04201587289571762, -0.06269186735153198, -0.029826680198311806, -0.028875630348920822, 0.004479037597775459, 0.04137808457016945, 0.011501671746373177, -0.0741640254855156, -0.009365247562527657, 0.012965369038283825, 0.018928395584225655, 0.00007688144251005724, -0.041661087423563004, 0.03533744439482689, -0.05779252573847771, 0.010134287178516388, -0.05348816514015198, -0.024090435355901718, -0.017184380441904068, 0.045610211789608, -0.00826597586274147, 0.011007732711732388, 0.024708079174160957, -0.07087843120098114, -0.005513984244316816, -0.008190033957362175, 0.005976650398224592, 0.035006601363420486, -0.05700492113828659, -0.045014336705207825, -0.001970423385500908, -0.00035140872932970524, -0.05922357365489006, -0.0005088422913104296, 0.0342988446354866, 0.013025078922510147, -0.007174274418503046, -0.00949341244995594, -0.017707977443933487, -0.017122451215982437, 0.026603737846016884, -0.04279656335711479, -0.024956323206424713, 0.03618466109037399, -0.025974027812480927, -0.03770876303315163, -0.04136336222290993, 0.004478076938539743, -0.043160948902368546, -0.0452260859310627, 0.03900310769677162, -0.04630851000547409, 0.029989490285515785, -0.048528946936130524, -0.06412271410226822, -0.03884505853056908, -0.024514174088835716, -0.012753779999911785, -0.041984375566244125, -0.02262059412896633, -0.06044462323188782, 0.013358605094254017, -0.04291588068008423, -0.0032030625734478235, -0.017423639073967934, -0.06873412430286407, 0.012461643666028976, -0.005625148769468069, -0.06161540746688843, -0.043670035898685455, -0.04373133182525635, -0.002437441609799862, -0.006547173485159874, -0.025053564459085464, 0.009064044803380966, 0.026701005175709724, -0.04565377160906792, 0.0416354238986969, -0.019005343317985535, -0.06527382135391235, 0.0028087098617106676, -0.04533157870173454, -0.030625589191913605, -0.0555165633559227, 0.037563856691122055, 0.0018419127445667982, -0.05231902748346329, -0.042778968811035156, 0.025786828249692917, 0.020089447498321533, -0.023622337728738785, -0.026377741247415543, 0.05305773764848709, -0.022887902334332466, -0.05986478552222252, 0.04699500650167465, -0.008359702304005623, -0.054186493158340454, 0.0006405724561773241, 0.00008072228956734762, -0.04437233880162239, -0.036433733999729156, -0.06910470873117447, 0.019555339589715004, -0.06096034497022629, 0.0023577918764203787, 0.01412783470004797, -0.059156328439712524, 0.03807903453707695, -0.06344949454069138, 0.004625315777957439, 0.021500227972865105, -0.0012079107109457254, -0.0014400474028661847, -0.05986934155225754, 0.0018912195228040218, -0.03339672088623047, -0.029461143538355827, -0.03884204477071762, 0.01052073948085308, -0.049241699278354645, 0.06010282412171364, 0.01681986264884472, 0.022472476586699486, -0.06231136992573738, -0.035598501563072205, 0.02042468823492527, -0.058776892721652985, -0.047396160662174225, -0.012407572939991951, 0.04572434350848198, 0.017070483416318893, -0.020875995978713036, -0.009143232367932796, 0.010101711377501488, -0.02198859490454197, -0.00009929123189067468, 0.008019667118787766, 0.0053089819848537445, 0.016454685479402542, 0.0323350690305233, 0.004351792391389608, -0.028280796483159065, 0.023775067180395126, 0.0144777437672019, 0.01565423421561718, 0.005376753397285938, 0.00035948408185504377, 0.012145821005105972, -0.021506711840629578, -0.030436640605330467, 0.029665790498256683, 0.04256827384233475, -0.04954060539603233, -0.03975106403231621, -0.06296110153198242, 0.029359785839915276, -0.040269725024700165, -0.001671966747380793 ]
Series or orthogonal basis regression is one of the most popular non-parametric regression techniques in practice, obtained by regressing the response on features generated by evaluating the basis functions at observed covariate values. The most routinely used series estimator is based on ordinary least squares fitting, which is known to be minimax rate optimal in various settings, albeit under stringent restrictions on the basis functions and the distribution of covariates. In this work, inspired by the recently developed Forster-Warmuth (FW) learner, we propose an alternative series regression estimator that can attain the minimax estimation rate under strictly weaker conditions imposed on the basis functions and the joint law of covariates, than existing series estimators in the literature. Moreover, a key contribution of this work generalizes the FW-learner to a so-called counterfactual regression problem, in which the response variable of interest may not be directly observed (hence, the name ``counterfactual'') on all sampled units, and therefore needs to be inferred in order to identify and estimate the regression in view from the observed data. Although counterfactual regression is not entirely a new area of inquiry, we propose the first-ever systematic study of this challenging problem from a unified pseudo-outcome perspective. In fact, we provide what appears to be the first generic and constructive approach for generating the pseudo-outcome (to substitute for the unobserved response) which leads to the estimation of the counterfactual regression curve of interest with small bias, namely bias of second order. Several applications are used to illustrate the resulting FW-learner including many nonparametric regression problems in missing data and causal inference literature, for which we establish high-level conditions for minimax rate optimality of the proposed FW-learner.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16798v4
[ 0.012463814578950405, -0.03172592446208, -0.012141181156039238, 0.028020326048135757, -0.020570795983076096, -0.04602649807929993, -0.04078115522861481, 0.010284895077347755, -0.02893296256661415, -0.009706860408186913, -0.06192919611930847, -0.05131741613149643, -0.05148719251155853, -0.041623927652835846, -0.057608895003795624, -0.012195398099720478, 0.07439487427473068, 0.03205513954162598, -0.03689543157815933, 0.06704357266426086, -0.012876352295279503, -0.03286800906062126, -0.04659285768866539, 0.058751180768013, 0.022139405831694603, -0.0241458211094141, -0.02615600824356079, -0.006892944686114788, -0.02831452339887619, -0.0018762728432193398, 0.054745785892009735, -0.05059279128909111, -0.017806870862841606, -0.01675158180296421, -0.028449557721614838, -0.011495212092995644, 0.007240126375108957, -0.012662021443247795, 0.019549479708075523, -0.0586506649851799, 0.014408115297555923, -0.027699725702404976, -0.020245691761374474, -0.02543819323182106, -0.007189642637968063, -0.04114357754588127, -0.046543482691049576, 0.005627940874546766, -0.06018741801381111, -0.057607151567935944, 0.045435499399900436, 0.00721937557682395, -0.007132743019610643, 0.023304367437958717, -0.05382237583398819, -0.027690015733242035, 0.005463567562401295, -0.0022781521547585726, -0.05044170096516609, -0.009615478105843067, -0.0019268527394160628, -0.02075093984603882, -0.013439813628792763, -0.029049662873148918, 0.00529433460906148, 0.054462090134620667, -0.06348352134227753, -0.07681479305028915, -0.03912942856550217, -0.03307316079735756, 0.018323088064789772, -0.05134393647313118, 0.05135149881243706, 0.037019282579422, -0.06344310194253922, -0.01757226139307022, -0.03765404224395752, -0.03798574209213257, 0.037790775299072266, 0.029009662568569183, -0.012714236974716187, 0.024045567959547043, 0.022935763001441956, 0.003881226759403944, 0.01202663965523243, -0.050846587866544724, 0.07361378520727158, -0.015577148646116257, 0.003211316652595997, -0.04728548601269722, 0.026302576065063477, -0.05779904127120972, -0.06024058908224106, -0.03653495013713837, 0.04107842594385147, -0.0554775670170784, 0.05724002420902252, 0.0626600906252861, 0.05435531958937645, 0.0016616624779999256, 0.011362507939338684, -0.023555869236588478, -0.014280161820352077, 0.06013179570436478, 0.025551656261086464, -0.031849272549152374, -0.00357447424903512, 0.0253094844520092, -0.025165222585201263, 0.009554814547300339, -0.04238644614815712, -0.007364589720964432, 0.006182841956615448, -0.05620719492435455, -0.04993581026792526, -0.04244298115372658, 0.06321261078119278, -0.007426131051033735, 0.023489167913794518, -0.027375131845474243, -0.06918883323669434, 0.027973631396889687, 0.04339233785867691, -0.036065876483917236, -0.026685576885938644, -0.028076795861124992, 0.03792256861925125, 0.010304403491318226, 0.011616284027695656, 0.009864621795713902, -0.037327129393815994, 0.0017345185624435544, 0.023480933159589767, 0.015488224104046822, 0.053264517337083817, 0.023640409111976624, -0.014577997848391533, -0.046838853508234024, 0.02635052055120468, -0.019029458984732628, -0.013265320099890232, -0.03353940322995186, 0.034979768097400665, -0.01922750659286976, 0.030858155339956284, 0.0625225380063057, -0.057767514139413834, 0.00566032063215971, 0.017595451325178146, 0.04166443645954132, -0.015665212646126747, -0.027711760252714157, 0.026851680129766464, 0.052261799573898315, 0.03246033564209938, 0.009773287922143936, 0.027095235884189606, 0.008571996353566647, -0.0461302325129509, 0.007449359633028507, 0.04842792823910713, 0.015475166961550713, 0.018319742754101753, 0.011155383661389351, 0.017699139192700386, 0.02335454151034355, 0.0454975888133049, 0.034150831401348114, -0.021726196631789207, 0.03400404378771782, -0.04336072877049446, 0.028718819841742516, 0.007389213424175978, -0.02989933453500271, -0.07438826560974121, -0.03791745752096176, -0.0122492965310812, -0.06388896703720093, -0.04781971126794815, 0.035255927592515945, -0.018889399245381355, -0.020920010283589363, 0.010389011353254318, 0.007714962121099234, -0.02882622554898262, 0.0027269129641354084, -0.08321753144264221, -0.0371430329978466, 0.035506006330251694, 0.006632762495428324, -0.031211528927087784, -0.04560568928718567, 0.013495602644979954, 0.014563542790710926, -0.007577669341117144, -0.018970003351569176, 0.004165327176451683, -0.025440111756324768, -0.00747991818934679, 0.02545638009905815, -0.08565010130405426, -0.039906326681375504, -0.058790162205696106, 0.0004931178991682827, -0.047894615679979324, -0.06359312683343887, 0.002041082363575697, 0.04159769043326378, 0.02094840817153454, -0.010764594189822674, 0.04242031276226044, 0.02853858843445778, 0.05964469537138939, 0.030578816309571266, 0.03142635524272919, 0.003833121620118618, -0.09478090703487396, 0.038463473320007324, -0.01152775902301073, -0.026735946536064148, 0.014009576290845871, 0.0302803386002779, -0.0024650872219353914, -0.009955277666449547, -0.04374101385474205, 0.05981488898396492, 0.05448947474360466, 0.02123280242085457, -0.061919938772916794, -0.021319802850484848, -0.023887846618890762, -0.06681708991527557, -0.045336659997701645, -0.08355287462472916, -0.016212183982133865, 0.015060286037623882, 0.000051536535465857014, 0.05420561507344246, 0.001082003815099597, -0.03439578041434288, -0.0694006010890007, 0.014973378740251064, 0.036071889102458954, -0.01645536907017231, -0.05035696178674698, -0.07692550867795944, -0.02408781088888645, -0.013257157057523727, -0.04347400739789009, -0.028940124437212944, -0.02176588401198387, -0.060337912291288376, 0.008727245032787323, -0.04238751158118248, 0.003138315863907337, 0.006508988328278065, -0.03471098840236664, 0.03998725861310959, -0.020685551688075066, 0.03014383092522621, 0.019287455826997757, 0.04647677764296532, -0.0420440211892128, 0.022015225142240524, 0.034755464643239975, -0.016779322177171707, -0.02354021742939949, 0.020560836419463158, 0.03197164461016655, -0.047950245440006256, -0.019596964120864868, 0.0100101288408041, 0.046700939536094666, 0.0008393122698180377, -0.01160999946296215, -0.03237205743789673, -0.0016464802902191877, -0.020117461681365967, 0.05868040397763252, 0.047437164932489395, 0.03795378655195236, 0.007932350039482117, -0.007441461086273193, -0.08265912532806396, 0.005846022628247738, -0.01593651995062828, -0.014043731614947319, -0.06394059956073761, -0.05696829408407211, -0.02596108801662922, -0.07699401676654816, -0.010566316545009613, -0.023267798125743866, -0.05227214843034744, -0.011975545436143875, -0.028177563101053238, -0.027657460421323776, 0.021070130169391632, 0.007319516036659479, -0.024929286912083626, -0.06555316597223282, -0.02052706480026245, 0.053165335208177567, -0.0015644545201212168, -0.02873031422495842, -0.04503002390265465, -0.042396072298288345, 0.01958920620381832, 0.044091351330280304, 0.011313998140394688, -0.052235059440135956, -0.01993865706026554, -0.0007490377756766975, 0.03511582687497139, 0.013292412273585796, -0.03079068660736084, 0.03959837183356285, 0.008518122136592865, 0.04546889662742615, -0.02005748450756073, 0.011895395815372467, -0.030611934140324593, 0.0029615822713822126, -0.008531599305570126, -0.052778035402297974, -0.02360718697309494, 0.07577245682477951, 0.04416992887854576, 0.005034612026065588, -0.04116987809538841, -0.007414916530251503, 0.011789515614509583, -0.012698465026915073, -0.05191134288907051, 0.010194871574640274, 0.03798558562994003, -0.0009457518463023007, -0.023788146674633026, 0.005080042872577906, 0.021366579458117485, 0.005767752882093191, 0.05128595232963562, -0.05067542567849159, -0.014426442794501781, 0.038467563688755035, -0.08593428134918213, 0.03580615669488907, 0.04031062126159668, 0.07187169045209885, -0.010747234337031841, 0.00006438305717892945, 0.043711259961128235, 0.013244451954960823, -0.0010522935772314668, -0.008434135466814041, 0.02094021439552307, 0.025291630998253822, 0.04762778803706169, -0.016232090070843697, -0.04904983937740326, -0.03622005134820938, -0.054530106484889984, -0.0642833560705185, -0.0111599275842309, 0.0325385183095932, 0.025101270526647568, 0.030783148482441902, -0.009266018867492676, 0.032501280307769775, -0.020948097109794617, 0.057146213948726654, 0.018837615847587585, -0.051935672760009766, 0.05447463318705559, -0.009559310972690582, 0.002890825504437089, 0.012131736613810062, -0.0013298154808580875, 0.003045889316126704, -0.07609906792640686, 0.016380010172724724, -0.03999997675418854, 0.04308135807514191, -0.007484021596610546, -0.0010212896158918738, 0.034536510705947876, 0.0158575177192688, -0.052604734897613525, 0.06481573730707169, -0.005224717315286398, 0.004574497230350971, 0.005520383361726999, -0.002411162480711937, 0.03985481336712837, -0.011047917418181896, -0.04638069495558739, -0.01742146536707878, -0.011134190484881401, -0.02873198129236698, -0.009675281122326851, -0.0035803441423922777, -0.03369102627038956, -0.054555173963308334, -0.08700156956911087, 0.046074628829956055, -0.06127272918820381, 0.0329139269888401, -0.0138505008071661, -0.062268778681755066, 0.07336314022541046, -0.024222085252404213, -0.013578150421380997, -0.047012798488140106, -0.009681720286607742, -0.034617602825164795, -0.009163184091448784, -0.04243391007184982, -0.07588205486536026, -0.006002373993396759, -0.0646037682890892, 0.06241631135344505, -0.026694171130657196, -0.01068873517215252, -0.06414911895990372, -0.029319163411855698, -0.015981830656528473, 0.011311120353639126, 0.035849906504154205, 0.03054346702992916, 0.030407564714550972, 0.004246290773153305, -0.024699563160538673, 0.01473249588161707, 0.04098453372716904, -0.047264061868190765, -0.031897302716970444, 0.016101988032460213, -0.02272607386112213, -0.026130802929401398, -0.06460936367511749, -0.002086964203044772, 0.06517244875431061, -0.05060092732310295, -0.049289166927337646, -0.002523108385503292, 0.023426590487360954, -0.05254395306110382, -0.07373502105474472, -0.048191532492637634, -0.018162013962864876, -0.06080138683319092, -0.003832775866612792, 0.0074611930176615715, 0.018922600895166397, -0.029200008139014244, 0.029965290799736977, 0.000581557338591665, 0.051957398653030396, -0.013150711543858051, 0.024316847324371338, 0.037278205156326294, 0.02216215804219246, -0.025492308661341667, -0.03437124937772751, -0.045803267508745193, -0.007536106742918491, 0.004994208924472332, -0.020477529615163803, -0.0036539589054882526, 0.057076215744018555, 0.010297388769686222, 0.042965713888406754, -0.0855705514550209, 0.038786958903074265, 0.027624787762761116, -0.024709749966859818, -0.02974909543991089, 0.04475526884198189, -0.0332646481692791, 0.02819843217730522, -0.033598802983760834, 0.0007954651373438537, 0.027486320585012436, -0.024043431505560875, -0.005385423079133034, -0.0487174466252327, -0.0073207831010222435, -0.017152059823274612, 0.052648428827524185, -0.029229288920760155, -0.08236059546470642, 0.000702258781529963, 0.008613976649940014, -0.0005960608250461519, -0.0460548959672451, 0.04971124231815338, 0.02846001461148262, -0.02115768939256668, -0.059629570692777634, -0.028200415894389153, -0.0001496462500654161, 0.0036893163342028856, 0.04609917476773262, -0.042733319103717804, -0.001554924063384533, 0.03589992597699165, -0.0013926055980846286, -0.0164884515106678, -0.0037110913544893265, 0.0045018186792731285, 0.02366749383509159, -0.0019396066199988127, 0.02362094819545746, -0.07102534174919128, -0.02702116221189499, -0.03230985999107361, 0.05307205021381378, 0.030202023684978485, 0.033520545810461044, 0.06680896878242493, 0.04503936693072319, -0.01567365974187851, -0.058394305408000946, 0.013320649042725563, -0.03512027487158775, 0.02718932554125786, -0.04603209346532822, 0.0047999052330851555, -0.008164271712303162, 0.04515116289258003, 0.033466409891843796, -0.029468927532434464, 0.0076826829463243484, 0.0035537462681531906, -0.020727837458252907, -0.0007743002497591078, 0.040538620203733444, -0.014905598945915699, -0.039841361343860626, -0.009705554693937302, 0.018106408417224884, -0.022525688633322716, 0.04352826997637749, 0.030612798407673836, -0.011016697622835636, 0.03917945176362991, 0.003976373001933098, 0.010697036981582642, -0.04889752343297005, -0.01645725779235363, 0.08745306730270386, -0.0319359228014946, -0.012216614559292793, -0.05303262546658516, -0.05080871656537056, -0.01721801795065403, -0.04205926135182381, 0.03193941339850426, 0.009920676238834858, -0.025328828021883965, -0.07053717970848083, 0.018668049946427345, 0.012542029842734337, -0.07265851646661758, -0.009718891233205795, 0.0314687043428421, -0.07833874225616455, -0.0032069645822048187, 0.04143909737467766, 0.008413423784077168, -0.0037459898740053177, 0.020720403641462326, -0.026404837146401405, -0.05170721188187599, 0.008108309470117092, 0.04704951122403145, 0.08160215616226196, -0.013788077048957348, 0.02500685304403305, 0.01940537802875042, -0.024917956441640854, 0.020902616903185844, -0.003435811260715127, 0.028805973008275032, -0.038974348455667496, 0.00973611418157816, -0.0060166167095303535, -0.007028857711702585, 0.017603833228349686, 0.0736595168709755, -0.03726042062044144, -0.0031315828673541546, -0.01717696152627468, -0.03750598803162575, -0.0005992941441945732, -0.04320210963487625, -0.05495016276836395, 0.008761339820921421, 0.0024678322952240705, -0.027252478525042534, -0.03682166337966919, -0.011857468634843826, -0.021341491490602493, 0.04163442552089691, 0.007611006498336792, -0.05330691859126091, -0.00414418987929821, -0.01793418638408184, -0.03369846194982529, 0.019986750558018684, -0.0441681370139122, 0.014427557587623596, -0.004775163251906633, -0.005170818418264389, 0.038129959255456924, 0.0574740432202816, -0.04099281132221222, -0.0035040276125073433, 0.007761042565107346, 0.0021700647193938494, 0.021331269294023514, 0.03980288654565811, 0.022822000086307526, 0.024541528895497322, 0.04982791095972061, -0.05740423500537872, -0.022658463567495346, 0.01888354867696762, -0.06019578129053116, 0.03757084906101227, 0.015035377815365791, -0.035192809998989105, -0.033520493656396866, -0.021093036979436874, -0.043953802436590195, 0.007014824077486992, 0.03206448629498482, -0.029859231784939766, -0.06840333342552185, -0.022003334015607834, 0.012849276885390282, -0.006366636138409376, 0.015649156644940376, 0.0370735339820385, 0.036461926996707916, 0.0030944356694817543, 0.045970868319272995, 0.041462164372205734, 0.04171881079673767, 0.043514568358659744, -0.06260089576244354, -0.017201833426952362, 0.013311685062944889, -0.03732500225305557, 0.0006530209793709219, -0.01166621409356594, -0.04202917218208313, -0.060429647564888, 0.040191102772951126, 0.03657292202115059, -0.0048438794910907745, 0.02126503549516201, -0.06803333759307861, 0.04456213861703873, 0.033196721225976944, -0.026802606880664825, -0.07410081475973129, -0.01435172837227583, 0.013961497694253922, -0.007782357279211283, 0.0003706316347233951, -0.03746763616800308, -0.07230719178915024, 0.00926901027560234, -0.08951475471258163, -0.019701587036252022, -0.014222469180822372, 0.06164579093456268, -0.008083640597760677, -0.03527498617768288, -0.020243793725967407, -0.028283746913075447, 0.004695804789662361, -0.01854724995791912, 0.0005465108552016318, 0.05665115639567375, 0.021424327045679092, 0.03956395760178566, -0.046746160835027695, 0.00511043518781662, 0.04475536197423935, -0.02372097223997116, 0.0432271733880043, 0.02203204669058323, 0.03198855742812157, -0.03780888393521309, 0.04214455932378769, 0.04522572457790375, -0.013226345181465149, 0.039895910769701004, -0.04109811782836914, -0.007211056537926197, -0.03976212069392204, -0.05845671519637108, 0.02475702576339245, -0.07437743246555328, -0.009190069511532784, 0.021981393918395042, -0.005156443454325199, -0.03555896505713463, -0.03572876378893852, -0.03739568963646889, 0.05594871565699577, -0.00651471596211195, -0.02997959405183792, 0.01973709836602211, -0.045928146690130234, 0.006683000363409519, 0.03575389087200165, -0.04316985234618187, -0.012866083532571793, 0.006706332787871361, 0.0248271357268095, -0.05101397633552551, 0.004784424789249897, -0.07740630954504013, -0.01291491836309433, -0.011619655415415764, 0.04163144528865814, -0.0015616565942764282, 0.06513439863920212, -0.0197630375623703, -0.029870109632611275, -0.016887610778212547, -0.04987263306975365, 0.01513378694653511, -0.06484448164701462, -0.04509451240301132, -0.011404122225940228, -0.01316424086689949, -0.008658874779939651, 0.02263581193983555, 0.0119690066203475, 0.03919631987810135, 0.04641338810324669, 0.01104950811713934, 0.026959246024489403, 0.0011733119608834386, -0.07023530453443527, 0.06804626435041428, -0.01343405619263649, -0.0060353958979249, -0.04126603156328201, -0.02136397175490856, -0.011231919750571251, -0.007519518490880728, -0.004863466136157513, -0.004320979118347168, 0.017530834302306175, -0.0418829470872879, -0.027378978207707405, 0.02787858061492443, -0.004610793199390173, -0.02378160133957863, 0.003940177615731955, 0.021223021671175957, -0.01271147932857275, -0.02796158380806446 ]
This paper includes the classification, in a simple Lie algebra, of the singularities of Slodowy slices between special nilpotent orbits that are adjacent in the partial order on nilpotent orbits. The irreducible components of most singularities are (up to normalization) either a simple surface singularity or the closure of a minimal special nilpotent orbit in a smaller rank Lie algebra. Besides those cases, there are some exceptional cases that arise as certain quotients of the closure of a minimal orbit in types $A_2$ and $D_n$. We also consider the action on the slice of the fundamental group of the smaller orbit. With this action, we observe that under Lusztig-Spaltenstein duality, in most cases, a simple surface singularity is interchanged with the closure of a minimal special orbit of Langlands dual type (or a cover of it with action). This empirical observation generalizes an observation of Kraft and Procesi in type $A_n$, where all nilpotent orbits are special. We also resolve a conjecture of Lusztig that concerns the intersection cohomology of slices between special nilpotent orbits.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00521v1
[ -0.06298316270112991, -0.029494596645236015, 0.0688624307513237, 0.0028275486547499895, 0.031907886266708374, -0.03057507798075676, -0.06409332156181335, 0.008011824451386929, -0.003130753291770816, -0.012744635343551636, -0.003067528363317251, -0.049909453839063644, -0.027219276875257492, -0.05094859004020691, -0.007729028817266226, 0.01024564541876316, 0.035349778831005096, 0.014068476855754852, -0.03713027760386467, 0.06763402372598648, 0.028533270582556725, -0.052654676139354706, 0.025392472743988037, 0.05757388472557068, -0.046175576746463776, -0.02438853494822979, -0.03865329176187515, -0.0009827727917581797, -0.05867038667201996, 0.0004648686444852501, 0.06854157149791718, -0.0038561599794775248, -0.013921631500124931, -0.04007425531744957, -0.00038851649151183665, 0.007052665110677481, 0.01084915641695261, 0.025793766602873802, 0.02828899770975113, -0.04214434325695038, -0.025134002789855003, -0.004573167767375708, -0.05400726571679115, 0.006869975011795759, -0.0253946240991354, -0.03164905309677124, -0.02283843420445919, 0.04324793443083763, -0.010333338752388954, -0.056797582656145096, 0.04381168261170387, 0.004883433226495981, -0.0026842199731618166, 0.04234116151928902, -0.02617771551012993, -0.003606098238378763, 0.012832939624786377, -0.00747731002047658, -0.053537629544734955, -0.03352273255586624, 0.011597874574363232, -0.06884791702032089, -0.006430606823414564, -0.038753923028707504, -0.0070603941567242146, 0.06531505286693573, -0.03902392089366913, -0.07403811812400818, 0.008986798115074635, -0.052958112210035324, 0.022229550406336784, -0.04891688749194145, -0.01286179106682539, 0.021776283159852028, -0.06268884986639023, -0.008882381021976471, -0.03446472808718681, 0.015738699585199356, 0.01844647526741028, -0.002929488429799676, -0.00010296732216374949, -0.01035404670983553, 0.024486035108566284, 0.0033280823845416307, -0.008414099924266338, -0.021512459963560104, 0.06336397677659988, -0.014884027652442455, 0.015199976973235607, -0.03536159172654152, -0.0427420400083065, -0.03213925287127495, -0.05186908692121506, -0.0036964891478419304, 0.048318635672330856, -0.05320765823125839, 0.02677985653281212, 0.04957588016986847, 0.06104561313986778, 0.002361155580729246, -0.005866941995918751, -0.07084245979785919, -0.03909093514084816, 0.027443913742899895, 0.04441869258880615, -0.05159478262066841, 0.0037263119593262672, 0.0022769561037421227, -0.02785446122288704, 0.060887545347213745, -0.05260138213634491, 0.03339995816349983, 0.017493518069386482, -0.05106668546795845, -0.05185417830944061, -0.0491795688867569, 0.06964406371116638, 0.027340978384017944, 0.06215023621916771, 0.0028784056194126606, -0.02253652736544609, 0.023658577352762222, -0.006656823214143515, -0.026944689452648163, -0.023244336247444153, -0.016364686191082, 0.07369058579206467, 0.022755306214094162, -0.0069025009870529175, -0.036123521625995636, 0.005430690478533506, -0.029753291979432106, 0.051608823239803314, -0.0111324368044734, 0.05604446679353714, -0.030965415760874748, 0.00791416596621275, -0.006662481464445591, 0.0220152847468853, 0.0018524664919823408, -0.03743398189544678, -0.05944480374455452, 0.041612863540649414, -0.017146501690149307, -0.007570568937808275, 0.06391023844480515, -0.0762576162815094, -0.006959018763154745, 0.03912143036723137, 0.04056261107325554, -0.03492497652769089, 0.009321384131908417, -0.022876638919115067, -0.011463667266070843, 0.017897937446832657, -0.004048089496791363, 0.046268150210380554, -0.026658911257982254, -0.012573765590786934, 0.01480853371322155, 0.03950049728155136, 0.005657586734741926, -0.004011357668787241, 0.02369861677289009, 0.00036271935096010566, 0.03766912594437599, 0.03075159527361393, -0.03695038706064224, -0.014013584703207016, 0.0237515177577734, -0.044607993215322495, 0.0438896007835865, 0.01498603168874979, -0.047253306955099106, -0.06556665152311325, -0.009489175863564014, -0.008072959259152412, -0.05576435476541519, -0.04617303982377052, 0.015366696752607822, 0.03700343891978264, -0.01308920606970787, -0.015207275748252869, -0.000916134100407362, -0.049529630690813065, -0.0171648059040308, -0.06955477595329285, 0.025402843952178955, -0.011500842869281769, 0.05445505306124687, -0.0014024379197508097, -0.011677681468427181, 0.05972585082054138, 0.010846756398677826, -0.01748189888894558, -0.016808193176984787, 0.030712146311998367, -0.02241376042366028, -0.03876616805791855, 0.043282415717840195, -0.0657513290643692, -0.027829485014081, -0.016725799068808556, 0.011198421940207481, 0.015102633275091648, -0.07497923076152802, 0.062408167868852615, 0.059524886310100555, 0.02163713425397873, -0.05572215095162392, 0.05599807947874069, 0.057619206607341766, 0.06177522987127304, -0.02576150931417942, -0.0306661706417799, -0.015325495041906834, -0.08984682708978653, -0.009813249111175537, -0.03030049055814743, -0.017207540571689606, 0.04266420751810074, -0.00201069051399827, -0.04267137497663498, -0.025727078318595886, -0.05248286575078964, 0.053669773042201996, 0.023581644520163536, -0.022018790245056152, -0.057560719549655914, 0.008268173784017563, 0.018948135897517204, -0.07876495271921158, -0.04371802881360054, -0.0569811649620533, -0.010052910074591637, -0.02524925023317337, -0.05512414127588272, 0.06962233781814575, -0.01992739364504814, -0.04797329381108284, -0.052211690694093704, 0.033524442464113235, 0.033183034509420395, 0.00032311954419128597, -0.06638980656862259, -0.04442734643816948, -0.06944387406110764, -0.032965801656246185, -0.014845402911305428, -0.013869588263332844, -0.02473502792418003, -0.057552676647901535, -0.04318822920322418, -0.0174839086830616, 0.023775625973939896, 0.04140963405370712, -0.03027113527059555, 0.01200013142079115, -0.0056631905026733875, 0.05237511545419693, 0.003844399005174637, 0.02498401328921318, -0.03917517513036728, -0.01782483048737049, 0.04465717449784279, 0.03305365890264511, -0.049944836646318436, -0.019107645377516747, -0.010902030393481255, 0.00014355903840623796, -0.00041550726746208966, -0.013499883934855461, 0.041309479624032974, -0.04342816397547722, -0.03943147882819176, -0.05422055721282959, 0.01268075779080391, -0.033479027450084686, -0.015556209720671177, 0.002970548113808036, 0.06007789447903633, 0.050383925437927246, 0.01476648636162281, -0.0754862055182457, -0.014630245976150036, -0.03537354990839958, 0.015629036352038383, -0.05489983409643173, -0.03919238969683647, -0.05305448919534683, -0.06829501688480377, 0.03511841595172882, 0.009390744380652905, -0.04759921506047249, -0.06664051860570908, -0.06309385597705841, -0.008017324842512608, 0.002627717098221183, -0.0038580435793846846, -0.0364970937371254, -0.03589291498064995, 0.004535324405878782, 0.017833605408668518, 0.03464408218860626, 0.047273751348257065, -0.058246463537216187, -0.042985815554857254, 0.023784570395946503, -0.013380559161305428, -0.009271866641938686, -0.02962644211947918, 0.009431279264390469, -0.0010605074930936098, 0.03741206228733063, -0.01830621436238289, 0.04994071274995804, 0.015867754817008972, -0.04847850650548935, 0.026729924604296684, -0.01518702507019043, -0.026219571009278297, -0.045866213738918304, 0.00392906041815877, -0.06292325258255005, -0.04878467321395874, -0.005804575979709625, 0.06308663636445999, 0.06845180690288544, -0.004897208418697119, -0.03224717825651169, -0.04226608946919441, 0.001661058864556253, 0.01585889235138893, -0.032596345990896225, 0.05951910838484764, 0.006387235596776009, -0.023036876693367958, 0.015004164539277554, -0.04078718647360802, 0.021553749218583107, 0.01691724918782711, -0.005746161565184593, 0.028141794726252556, -0.012233622372150421, 0.0006505329511128366, -0.0726727619767189, 0.017530737444758415, 0.05168173089623451, 0.06316543370485306, -0.07472845911979675, -0.025388848036527634, 0.03450396656990051, 0.01179446466267109, 0.028456691652536392, -0.037601519376039505, 0.0341043546795845, 0.04771990329027176, 0.03702807053923607, -0.03122900053858757, -0.03235294669866562, -0.02930183708667755, -0.04827691614627838, -0.042884159833192825, 0.02164372429251671, -0.006247588433325291, 0.033562541007995605, 0.042279697954654694, 0.0410982221364975, 0.01010162103921175, 0.02402282878756523, 0.06243319809436798, -0.051077038049697876, -0.03669818863272667, 0.0008569887140765786, 0.0099808219820261, 0.006417141295969486, 0.00964280590415001, -0.016529126092791557, 0.015192615799605846, -0.021417558193206787, 0.0072428262792527676, -0.03426756337285042, 0.035396769642829895, 0.024391649290919304, 0.04722703993320465, 0.029657652601599693, 0.030733197927474976, -0.04404701665043831, 0.010227150283753872, -0.002842195564880967, 0.004197909962385893, 0.00016056686581578106, -0.019504420459270477, 0.029228564351797104, -0.041528210043907166, -0.03623459115624428, -0.0234389491379261, -0.009918800555169582, -0.043690845370292664, -0.01916821487247944, 0.01456721406430006, 0.002854295074939728, -0.011857710778713226, -0.08408337086439133, -0.03329664096236229, -0.03960386663675308, 0.016182560473680496, 0.011244766414165497, -0.06600818037986755, 0.06904623657464981, -0.01702006533741951, -0.007657824549823999, -0.014903394505381584, -0.011658275499939919, -0.004098848439753056, -0.028254229575395584, -0.05616094544529915, -0.01135148387402296, 0.01025241706520319, -0.052150893956422806, 0.024902762845158577, -0.03665762022137642, -0.04842666536569595, -0.05706058070063591, 0.017767827957868576, 0.01508763711899519, 0.057467661798000336, -0.001327290665358305, 0.04940350353717804, 0.0536685511469841, -0.012786888517439365, 0.012629321776330471, -0.015096120536327362, -0.03506024181842804, -0.016220558434724808, -0.056864868849515915, 0.04886258393526077, -0.04098084568977356, -0.05364379659295082, -0.04734538495540619, -0.013593388721346855, 0.052476704120635986, -0.031962066888809204, -0.025740550830960274, -0.037317607551813126, 0.02156687341630459, -0.05382031574845314, -0.07383161038160324, -0.012107492424547672, -0.007309194188565016, -0.05100717395544052, 0.010862973518669605, 0.020313799381256104, 0.001323482720181346, 0.00397614948451519, 0.03092910535633564, -0.0036159351002424955, 0.03810790553689003, -0.012851579114794731, -0.00838902872055769, 0.018389716744422913, 0.02196642942726612, 0.012535784393548965, -0.0065270098857581615, -0.0722062736749649, 0.013847459107637405, 0.022170353680849075, 0.0074630724266171455, -0.026939822360873222, 0.05370457470417023, -0.04106880724430084, 0.03035341203212738, -0.08215408027172089, 0.000004187008016742766, 0.03781966120004654, -0.013507840223610401, -0.004982060752809048, 0.007629756350070238, -0.050378330051898956, 0.039800360798835754, 0.014967596158385277, 0.004838267341256142, 0.0441490076482296, 0.016435815021395683, -0.008983282372355461, -0.006558864377439022, -0.02910785935819149, -0.012463017366826534, 0.04742445424199104, -0.0358758307993412, -0.02098248526453972, 0.013087603263556957, -0.010983654297888279, -0.00413633743301034, -0.03812675550580025, 0.035238273441791534, 0.022043054923415184, -0.026813797652721405, -0.06194017454981804, -0.012467294931411743, 0.005782108288258314, 0.002890986390411854, -0.010115213692188263, -0.038869183510541916, -0.03227371349930763, 0.016238145530223846, -0.017884785309433937, 0.0049223024398088455, 0.0565854087471962, 0.014254528097808361, -0.03800055384635925, -0.0015160472830757499, -0.04465588927268982, -0.07366037368774414, -0.00046730003668926656, -0.05102454498410225, 0.02445877343416214, 0.032585058361291885, -0.016732534393668175, 0.05401390418410301, 0.003717821091413498, -0.042932190001010895, -0.0410173237323761, 0.004022152628749609, -0.033713411539793015, 0.05004671961069107, -0.057526979595422745, 0.008028509095311165, 0.005255336873233318, 0.04150521755218506, 0.040353741496801376, -0.02265768125653267, 0.009057492949068546, -0.02952660620212555, -0.03658171743154526, 0.015014621429145336, 0.01273904088884592, -0.029833398759365082, -0.03241432458162308, -0.015983371064066887, 0.028867481276392937, -0.04460037872195244, 0.047973502427339554, 0.009855454787611961, 0.03681439533829689, 0.027195319533348083, 0.02008790522813797, 0.00008356093167094514, -0.06205892562866211, -0.047310467809438705, 0.06165379658341408, -0.07719240337610245, -0.01574563980102539, -0.04567011445760727, -0.05669302120804787, 0.012115802615880966, -0.0020700462628155947, 0.054047465324401855, 0.047472838312387466, 0.018045863136649132, -0.041257187724113464, 0.028821740299463272, -0.017422424629330635, -0.05865335091948509, -0.02545059844851494, 0.03604329377412796, -0.06635020673274994, 0.0006052136886864901, 0.012211192399263382, -0.0314810611307621, -0.038263965398073196, 0.01760896109044552, -0.0049337525852024555, -0.038670748472213745, 0.012445583008229733, 0.037650711834430695, 0.029742883518338203, -0.059260230511426926, 0.015332634560763836, 0.013251619413495064, 0.008408332243561745, 0.03613065183162689, -0.06070801988244057, -0.0021591447293758392, -0.02796296216547489, 0.05704331398010254, -0.030918581411242485, -0.024457206949591637, -0.011173974722623825, 0.03261420130729675, -0.04743694141507149, 0.006674870382994413, 0.01512399036437273, 0.01188589259982109, -0.005421043373644352, -0.020373113453388214, -0.016751281917095184, -0.0046478332951664925, -0.01971587724983692, -0.0030542761087417603, -0.016617290675640106, 0.004252220969647169, -0.03770318999886513, 0.0011424829717725515, 0.015594144351780415, -0.050485897809267044, 0.015648573637008667, -0.03584872931241989, -0.06375999003648758, 0.02020861953496933, -0.061030637472867966, -0.04259122535586357, -0.004711345303803682, 0.0443127416074276, -0.012393388897180557, -3.9743386537338665e-7, -0.03872012346982956, -0.042805735021829605, -0.059421177953481674, 0.016879750415682793, -0.02531152032315731, 0.013470022939145565, -0.0016631161561235785, 0.011463559232652187, 0.03991612792015076, -0.03581324219703674, 0.03566442430019379, -0.029193447902798653, -0.025479279458522797, 0.03317898139357567, -0.04197398200631142, -0.05178731307387352, -0.004825559910386801, 0.01788296550512314, -0.06482575088739395, 0.05332382395863533, -0.020976383239030838, -0.012537767179310322, -0.062013644725084305, -0.014617574401199818, -0.008192205801606178, -0.025847114622592926, 0.03595579043030739, 0.0017899909289553761, 0.014481764286756516, 0.014440969564020634, 0.004924414679408073, 0.06887228041887283, 0.02657102607190609, -0.011892031878232956, -0.057884544134140015, -0.014995288103818893, 0.006893959827721119, -0.008199458941817284, -0.04515113681554794, -0.026810957118868828, -0.056054823100566864, -0.05628568306565285, 0.048821598291397095, 0.008053460158407688, -0.002741632517427206, -0.03417319431900978, -0.05325477197766304, 0.06088073179125786, -0.02703477069735527, 0.01862477697432041, -0.07031669467687607, -0.04234009608626366, 0.04915433004498482, 0.017539378255605698, -0.013362276367843151, 0.0013645433355122805, -0.06611981987953186, 0.020026883110404015, -0.08559732139110565, -0.02646590583026409, 0.0012313792249187827, 0.045679762959480286, 0.03941137343645096, -0.016827523708343506, -0.046453122049570084, -0.017616892233490944, 0.013664338737726212, 0.03268418461084366, -0.005278828553855419, 0.0040242332033813, 0.015111863613128662, 0.02232903242111206, -0.02037707343697548, -0.004132774192839861, 0.06539158523082733, -0.019946610555052757, -0.040271978825330734, 0.03184133023023605, 0.024490388110280037, -0.025094352662563324, 0.029007818549871445, 0.03727135807275772, -0.01601177081465721, 0.05656197667121887, -0.02859191782772541, -0.02529902011156082, -0.0598021075129509, -0.06663379818201065, -0.011403840966522694, -0.06879137456417084, -0.0020617996342480183, 0.01358399260789156, -0.013290922157466412, -0.06524632126092911, -0.043098680675029755, -0.05625412240624428, -0.0005882211844436824, -0.01581789366900921, -0.055373892188072205, 0.052956875413656235, -0.04711092263460159, -0.022461218759417534, 0.022162023931741714, -0.02044745720922947, -0.024705475196242332, 0.028874695301055908, 0.03867651894688606, -0.0559384860098362, 0.010748668573796749, -0.08157190680503845, 0.05227873846888542, -0.029828840866684914, 0.002697099233046174, 0.07193157821893692, 0.010069789364933968, -0.042082346975803375, 0.019926687702536583, -0.012695590034127235, -0.03556176647543907, 0.015543111599981785, -0.06989775598049164, -0.026297537609934807, 0.008746753446757793, 0.010003949515521526, 0.00009108115045819432, 0.020662890747189522, -0.025624610483646393, 0.06550571322441101, 0.027654416859149933, 0.01323035266250372, -0.015605402179062366, 0.0016245798906311393, -0.018550585955381393, 0.03759421408176422, -0.032957423478364944, -0.039895199239254, -0.038371916860342026, -0.03365316614508629, -0.0047041731886565685, 0.043844908475875854, -0.061918217688798904, -0.007563766557723284, -0.004925922490656376, -0.020027268677949905, -0.015138969756662846, 0.04659649357199669, 0.05076682195067406, -0.02874758653342724, 0.030974814668297768, 0.022346466779708862, -0.00606372207403183, -0.06609407812356949 ]
Quantum software engineering (QSE) is receiving increasing attention, as evidenced by increasing publications on topics, e.g., quantum software modeling, testing, and debugging. However, in the literature, quantum software requirements engineering (QSRE) is still a software engineering area that is relatively less investigated. To this end, in this paper, we provide an initial set of thoughts about how requirements engineering for quantum software might differ from that for classical software after making an effort to map classical requirements classifications (e.g., functional and extra-functional requirements) into the context of quantum software. Moreover, we provide discussions on various aspects of QSRE that deserve attention from the quantum software engineering community.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13358v1
[ -0.00904144998639822, -0.05183945223689079, -0.0015889224596321583, -0.004881799221038818, -0.024037329480051994, -0.0674901157617569, -0.053501732647418976, 0.007800044026225805, -0.013341790065169334, 0.005644591059535742, -0.025929536670446396, 0.014756552875041962, -0.038041964173316956, -0.02193305641412735, -0.04766104370355606, -0.013212593272328377, 0.047543879598379135, 0.051189035177230835, -0.033662099391222, 0.059416595846414566, 0.017368504777550697, -0.008746412582695484, -0.04838055372238159, 0.013799156993627548, 0.023456815630197525, 0.026137005537748337, -0.021857650950551033, -0.028478458523750305, 0.013334735296666622, 0.0015449930215254426, 0.023953815922141075, -0.03460799530148506, -0.03846810758113861, -0.007242058869451284, -0.02203904092311859, -0.049440864473581314, -0.03621233254671097, 0.024527383968234062, 0.01081124134361744, -0.053821954876184464, -0.0029914015904068947, -0.0295221246778965, -0.06585285067558289, -0.012971996329724789, -0.044192831963300705, -0.04127736762166023, -0.046051401644945145, -0.005879934411495924, -0.07814251631498337, -0.053620047867298126, 0.04476046562194824, 0.03888152912259102, -0.010306504555046558, 0.046350184828042984, -0.017407095059752464, -0.023152954876422882, 0.01817089319229126, -0.03886255621910095, -0.004228423815220594, -0.007181416731327772, 0.017164897173643112, 0.011354580521583557, 0.024753306061029434, -0.01672915555536747, -0.014688295312225819, 0.014658281579613686, -0.006487439386546612, -0.04641319066286087, 0.0070830644108355045, -0.03589688986539841, 0.028057895600795746, -0.06301388144493103, -0.002817109925672412, -0.013764269649982452, -0.02261127531528473, -0.0259321890771389, -0.03071131370961666, -0.04507672041654587, 0.046949125826358795, 0.0003755776851903647, -0.030364306643605232, 0.0031232472974807024, -0.005893019959330559, -0.018513040617108345, 0.011451909318566322, -0.0748927891254425, -0.00714179128408432, -0.013075877912342548, -0.011844602413475513, -0.04175915941596031, 0.034409552812576294, -0.0381106361746788, -0.08863241225481033, 0.009730353020131588, 0.049146056175231934, 0.03526531532406807, 0.04627923294901848, 0.03411674126982689, -0.005254928022623062, -0.04408023878931999, 0.042207300662994385, -0.06026742234826088, -0.08255200833082199, 0.06298287957906723, 0.03941354155540466, -0.03936198353767395, -0.00039755424950271845, 0.0327836349606514, -0.03883535414934158, -0.019514387473464012, -0.019236329942941666, -0.004520539194345474, -0.007612811401486397, -0.07731788605451584, -0.038191426545381546, -0.02672255039215088, 0.07933860272169113, 0.035123150795698166, -0.0010592684848234057, -0.02302592806518078, -0.0700109601020813, 0.046849362552165985, 0.06575203686952591, -0.015315735712647438, -0.0655066967010498, -0.014645401388406754, 0.019592054188251495, 0.005526239052414894, 0.01824665069580078, -0.003242668230086565, -0.057304903864860535, -0.017418984323740005, 0.0018541275057941675, -0.004274228122085333, 0.052226584404706955, -0.010606062598526478, -0.01369281392544508, -0.033845528960227966, 0.04016251489520073, -0.05681121349334717, -0.04849782586097717, -0.04814528673887253, 0.03910911828279495, -0.014683798886835575, 0.041154175996780396, 0.05303408205509186, -0.018520522862672806, -0.027132393792271614, 0.01703781634569168, 0.06506846845149994, 0.026775799691677094, -0.02872738242149353, 0.011344232596457005, 0.004268214572221041, 0.04114178568124771, -0.04167666658759117, 0.023428503423929214, -0.013577289879322052, -0.03934893384575844, 0.002728671533986926, 0.010111787356436253, 0.005011965055018663, -0.004573328420519829, -0.049734268337488174, 0.009265786968171597, -0.019190987572073936, 0.03245626017451286, -0.005871017463505268, -0.0017977799288928509, 0.06341008841991425, -0.016122126951813698, 0.00733310729265213, 0.03307944908738136, -0.040061917155981064, -0.06446435302495956, -0.003225078107789159, 0.01381814293563366, -0.05515443533658981, -0.010227502323687077, -0.005849675741046667, 0.02504407800734043, -0.019385669380426407, -0.041766028851270676, -0.005368377082049847, -0.028278645128011703, -0.008413538336753845, -0.05151842534542084, 0.03429866582155228, 0.025010844692587852, 0.006704001221805811, 0.008412519469857216, -0.0048135267570614815, 0.020918570458889008, -0.012763415463268757, -0.008515195921063423, -0.012861927039921284, -0.011154784820973873, -0.036112718284130096, 0.022341089323163033, 0.02400023862719536, -0.09397577494382858, 0.0035022790543735027, -0.02545546181499958, -0.03714193403720856, -0.026607105508446693, -0.06439977884292603, -0.01138053648173809, 0.034909144043922424, -0.039215970784425735, -0.006139242090284824, 0.04623318463563919, 0.03358869254589081, 0.0655626431107521, 0.01202719658613205, 0.026395674794912338, 0.04880942776799202, -0.10263767093420029, 0.008031466975808144, -0.05897744372487068, 0.014076299965381622, 0.04472779482603073, 0.04768526554107666, -0.03230208158493042, 0.007875701412558556, 0.014299300499260426, 0.051931750029325485, -0.018565373495221138, -0.006741673685610294, -0.031981438398361206, -0.005966407712548971, 0.009659642353653908, -0.04564938694238663, -0.005834031384438276, -0.07259568572044373, -0.03194121643900871, 0.010920479893684387, -0.01482083834707737, 0.058447327464818954, -0.03860156983137131, -0.03764556720852852, -0.07251690328121185, -0.027232546359300613, -0.000046975288569228724, 0.022786211222410202, -0.024137618020176888, -0.041768766939640045, -0.005538002122193575, 0.005334991496056318, 0.00950588658452034, 0.0159162450581789, -0.054118525236845016, -0.03745708242058754, 0.009184782393276691, -0.04275178909301758, -0.010759669356048107, 0.029219985008239746, -0.028283681720495224, 0.04477051645517349, 0.02963143400847912, 0.008780671283602715, 0.009856220334768295, 0.04297161474823952, -0.04474155604839325, 0.037288837134838104, 0.017970412969589233, -0.018774360418319702, -0.046378884464502335, 0.03157693147659302, -0.05109460651874542, -0.07137268036603928, 0.011625991202890873, 0.009716168977320194, 0.04095355421304703, -0.04068710654973984, -0.03880453482270241, -0.06523660570383072, 0.04339705780148506, -0.019477542489767075, -0.007797691039741039, 0.07612944394350052, 0.03316161036491394, 0.009836115874350071, -0.021992500871419907, -0.06636139750480652, -0.01040637120604515, -0.0028041962068527937, -0.04584219679236412, -0.02437468059360981, -0.009250391274690628, -0.05736991763114929, -0.06788944453001022, -0.010574905201792717, 0.022637110203504562, -0.014515560120344162, 0.013908366672694683, -0.033125437796115875, -0.015785541385412216, -0.023437796160578728, 0.03612671419978142, 0.001760759623721242, -0.03597612306475639, -0.061133723706007004, -0.012781689874827862, 0.039240721613168716, -0.01479306723922491, -0.041180018335580826, -0.013335592113435268, 0.002003661124035716, -0.029641665518283844, 0.057859692722558975, -0.05254605785012245, 0.0050887614488601685, -0.009693063795566559, 0.017856165766716003, 0.009191525168716908, 0.04010327532887459, 0.018871517851948738, 0.000823942304123193, -0.031785935163497925, -0.01858229748904705, -0.05804131552577019, 0.006505301687866449, 0.035813700407743454, -0.03601667657494545, -0.017241552472114563, -0.007135313935577869, 0.07157492637634277, -0.0011609813664108515, 0.03689778223633766, -0.03166791796684265, -0.02985680103302002, 0.054080117493867874, -0.024358782917261124, 0.030367402359843254, -0.03056822158396244, 0.05407404899597168, -0.03948017209768295, -0.005932935513556004, 0.026952488347887993, -0.0345982126891613, -0.0009184180526062846, 0.04874991998076439, -0.03834759071469307, -0.02829046919941902, 0.018602650612592697, -0.08707558363676071, 0.006624654866755009, 0.058315716683864594, 0.04041512310504913, -0.023975564166903496, -0.008915925398468971, -0.003347409190610051, 0.033324453979730606, 0.01801166869699955, -0.031202519312500954, 0.07303228974342346, 0.04104824736714363, 0.022845394909381866, -0.05781753361225128, -0.049268923699855804, 0.005256878677755594, -0.04351263493299484, -0.04113292694091797, 0.00956395361572504, 0.05631585046648979, -0.014413902536034584, 0.027420634403824806, -0.05245092511177063, -0.03191737085580826, -0.02776997722685337, 0.046638019382953644, 0.009344702586531639, -0.0595477931201458, -0.029322847723960876, -0.052341263741254807, 0.01055328268557787, 0.027806634083390236, -0.0331743098795414, -0.0347982794046402, -0.03614228963851929, 0.02295725978910923, -0.024584082886576653, 0.0038248030468821526, 0.002602896187454462, 0.026295380666851997, 0.00005187066562939435, -0.032014016062021255, 0.03243281692266464, 0.06149199232459068, -0.009329360909759998, 0.019487973302602768, -0.01367836631834507, 0.02882515825331211, -0.002856372855603695, 0.015316898934543133, -0.04314946010708809, -0.005834841635078192, 0.044532548636198044, -0.04181213676929474, -0.024637388065457344, -0.002939180238172412, 0.0019154393812641501, -0.035958725959062576, -0.07340911775827408, 0.005379678215831518, -0.06367955356836319, 0.0673414021730423, -0.028198227286338806, -0.04676920920610428, 0.0639868974685669, -0.038253869861364365, -0.01479027234017849, 0.01924513280391693, 0.03232289105653763, -0.011542810127139091, -0.023831438273191452, 0.003933384548872709, -0.05781685188412666, 0.0052591427229344845, -0.043921101838350296, 0.025879548862576485, 0.0353441946208477, 0.05644592270255089, -0.07022912800312042, -0.008694016374647617, -0.0026657122652977705, -0.015468133613467216, 0.07066057622432709, 0.03944545239210129, -0.027285214513540268, -0.05251035466790199, 0.011853095144033432, 0.025948695838451385, 0.0322459377348423, -0.021827690303325653, 0.0015442949952557683, 0.06038442626595497, -0.0036702577490359545, 0.00985996425151825, -0.03937918320298195, 0.021392296999692917, 0.0375598780810833, -0.03333015739917755, -0.037922050803899765, 0.037797506898641586, 0.044891733676195145, -0.012248905375599861, -0.07659298181533813, -0.05019272863864899, -0.035888586193323135, -0.05709359422326088, -0.04009879007935524, 0.006784495897591114, -0.03787003085017204, -0.06227089464664459, 0.004649859853088856, 0.03857026994228363, 0.026349592953920364, 0.031315647065639496, 0.019761119037866592, 0.04680681973695755, -0.03931527957320213, -0.017476413398981094, 0.030336664989590645, -0.05213398113846779, 0.03593479469418526, 0.009528308175504208, -0.027073245495557785, -0.019533222541213036, 0.022981684654951096, 0.002871082630008459, 0.027107814326882362, -0.0878794938325882, 0.04905719310045242, 0.014206000603735447, -0.040550347417593, 0.0126651581376791, 0.03336526080965996, 0.0005227622459642589, 0.016616329550743103, -0.023514825850725174, 0.04582194611430168, 0.019214017316699028, -0.012708325870335102, 0.01908710040152073, -0.013263537548482418, -0.06325291842222214, 0.044406719505786896, 0.03194723650813103, -0.011368080042302608, -0.03889496996998787, 0.003911270759999752, 0.05895715206861496, -0.026426400989294052, -0.02031613700091839, 0.00839172676205635, 0.026158999651670456, 0.017694545909762383, -0.042491279542446136, -0.027149220928549767, -0.02246357686817646, -0.029600532725453377, 0.02190910093486309, 0.0064123026095330715, -0.04161522909998894, -0.0058800820261240005, 0.006728575099259615, 0.010896463878452778, -0.0001737955171847716, 0.023939896374940872, 0.016115671023726463, -0.040319982916116714, -0.02826203964650631, -0.030848611146211624, -0.034739717841148376, -0.04082011058926582, 0.025286564603447914, 0.05300623178482056, -0.00031128525733947754, 0.052033938467502594, 0.019171884283423424, -0.018435513600707054, -0.03855876252055168, -0.003724038368090987, -0.013014847412705421, 0.046200528740882874, -0.035624854266643524, 0.005025018937885761, -0.04834364354610443, 0.03956072777509689, 0.057547956705093384, 0.005794674623757601, -0.007653403095901012, 0.02340138703584671, -0.0421077162027359, 0.02057514898478985, -0.011359681375324726, -0.05703503265976906, -0.012926584109663963, -0.006785108242183924, 0.03466811031103134, -0.039876874536275864, 0.0512063093483448, 0.005939865484833717, 0.026804810389876366, 0.03225383907556534, 0.01788448728621006, -0.06463371217250824, -0.07185949385166168, 0.03225484862923622, 0.03627115115523338, -0.05682271718978882, -0.003117455868050456, -0.02469945326447487, 0.020923806354403496, 0.009818263351917267, -0.0161838848143816, 0.049470435827970505, 0.03391973674297333, -0.01916275918483734, -0.045057687908411026, 0.026587147265672684, -0.013822674751281738, -0.08498449623584747, 0.010825622826814651, 0.009324898943305016, -0.0593712143599987, -0.023021025583148003, 0.052731823176145554, 0.05750260502099991, -0.047274667769670486, 0.03864165022969246, 0.045467983931303024, -0.04706377536058426, -0.03295329958200455, 0.041086696088314056, 0.09018728882074356, -0.03832925856113434, 0.03285178542137146, -0.010097872465848923, -0.024180544540286064, -0.008541667833924294, -0.02153664641082287, -0.025245996192097664, 0.01957552693784237, 0.01792324334383011, 0.011213990859687328, 0.0017837256891652942, -0.0137410257011652, 0.055712904781103134, 0.026662353426218033, -0.04664923995733261, 0.04113500937819481, -0.042788028717041016, 0.045290712267160416, -0.04355727136135101, -0.052143242210149765, -0.03125609830021858, -0.06324587762355804, 0.004058798309415579, -0.044198427349328995, 0.011398733593523502, -0.03771116957068443, 0.016946515068411827, 0.001334633445367217, -0.08153723180294037, -0.005133550148457289, -0.047525279223918915, -0.07137523591518402, 0.01999550312757492, -0.0430799275636673, 0.013938384130597115, 0.02675948664546013, -0.020276343449950218, -0.027817238122224808, 0.06473126262426376, -0.027747109532356262, -0.0636572614312172, 0.005898991134017706, -0.006800794042646885, 0.010913504287600517, 0.0006952461553737521, 0.03179718926548958, 0.05509011074900627, 0.004014869686216116, -0.02746465429663658, -0.06874607503414154, -0.030332772061228752, -0.06016809493303299, 0.01521931029856205, 0.00581655977293849, -0.013212548568844795, -0.002731298329308629, -0.01770443469285965, -0.016094382852315903, -0.0101086450740695, 0.02166532352566719, -0.03928988054394722, -0.05365818366408348, -0.0063843936659395695, 0.05456665903329849, 0.011696130968630314, -0.013100978918373585, 0.036755893379449844, 0.061693135648965836, -0.007139329332858324, -0.009220515377819538, 0.006581321358680725, 0.053590621799230576, -0.01698114722967148, -0.06850766390562057, -0.014061338268220425, -0.008182214573025703, -0.04472481831908226, -0.0361136794090271, -0.023898093029856682, 0.024244729429483414, -0.06394404917955399, -0.016033176332712173, 0.048802610486745834, 0.02942337468266487, -0.052140794694423676, -0.062641941010952, 0.040658216923475266, -0.004418213851749897, -0.032795052975416183, -0.03993906453251839, 0.04742041230201721, -0.04135974496603012, -0.049727022647857666, 0.024548731744289398, -0.023238765075802803, -0.04895797371864319, 0.0657973513007164, -0.0820549875497818, -0.029851607978343964, -0.005633537657558918, 0.06674852967262268, 0.025897758081555367, 0.00009895141556626186, -0.003801686456426978, -0.022288192063570023, 0.03808494284749031, -0.0024140889290720224, -0.01668187789618969, 0.0473426915705204, 0.0009608498658053577, 0.050080928951501846, -0.015709785744547844, -0.001894489279948175, 0.041245900094509125, -0.04271796718239784, -0.009859682060778141, -0.001288502593524754, -0.0039744204841554165, -0.009584587998688221, 0.04916909709572792, 0.022089244797825813, -0.052138812839984894, 0.01480065006762743, -0.05796903744339943, 0.014219917356967926, -0.03578149154782295, -0.023736659437417984, -0.0002170403313357383, -0.040006719529628754, -0.023864449933171272, 0.045489344745874405, -0.026554180309176445, 0.01586589403450489, -0.017950454726815224, -0.03479982540011406, 0.05193677544593811, -0.0017537135863676667, -0.027622098103165627, 0.07123181223869324, -0.048567816615104675, 0.0033660668414086103, 0.032330382615327835, -0.020704815164208412, -0.0380881167948246, 0.05424843728542328, 0.03793618083000183, -0.07446113973855972, -0.0039041389245539904, -0.05213901028037071, 0.01034870371222496, -0.00747580686584115, 0.01859515905380249, -0.013128213584423065, 0.06694020330905914, 0.006937092170119286, -0.032673951238393784, -0.0331922322511673, -0.03670000284910202, -0.0362054705619812, -0.06564689427614212, -0.04753071442246437, -0.046356238424777985, 0.034436244517564774, -0.02754298970103264, -0.024723034352064133, 0.01065560057759285, 0.04115063697099686, -0.003053582739084959, -0.03275128826498985, 0.046804312616586685, 0.017937157303094864, -0.05893133208155632, 0.07765033841133118, 0.04308284819126129, 0.05387866869568825, -0.02631957083940506, -0.036367688328027725, -0.01947401650249958, -0.02162041701376438, 0.054433438926935196, -0.0190267413854599, 0.009992911480367184, -0.03244136646389961, 0.010396458208560944, -0.021360907703638077, -0.024488583207130432, -0.009337009862065315, -0.05530696362257004, 0.023931806907057762, 0.004850945435464382, -0.014291172847151756 ]
We present optimization of [(15 $\unicode{x212B}$) Ni$_{80}$Fe$_{20}$/(5 $\unicode{xC5}$) M]$_{20}$ single crystal multilayers on (001) MgO, with M being Cu, Cu$_{50}$Pt$_{50}$ and Pt. These superlattices were characterized by high-resolution X-ray reflectivity (XRR) and diffraction (XRD) as well as polar mapping of important crystal planes. It is shown that cube on cube epitaxial relationship can be obtained when depositing at the substrate temperature of 100 $^\circ$C regardless of the lattice mismatch (5% and 14% for Cu and Pt, respectively). At lower substrate temperatures poly-crystalline multilayers were obtained while at higher substrate temperatures {111} planes appear at $\sim$10$^\circ$ off normal to the film plane. It is also shown that as the epitaxial strain increases, the easy magnetization axis rotates towards the direction that previously was assumed to be harder, i.e. from [110] to [100], and eventually further increase in the strain makes the magnetic hysteresis loops isotropic in the film plane. Higher epitaxial strain is also accompanied with increased coercivity values. Thus, the effect of epitaxial strain on the magnetocrystalline anisotropy is much larger than what was observed previously in similar, but polycrystalline samples with uniaxial anisotropy (Kateb et al. 2021).
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14745v1
[ -0.048362165689468384, -0.024555183947086334, -0.013891543261706829, -0.025215115398168564, -0.053615912795066833, -0.05024883896112442, 0.03800521045923233, 0.03851225972175598, -0.053560853004455566, -0.011396897956728935, 0.025634566321969032, -0.016547320410609245, -0.023510511964559555, -0.026959488168358803, -0.06604917347431183, 0.03059759922325611, 0.05133078247308731, 0.030593380331993103, -0.03836844861507416, 0.06840754300355911, 0.024098163470625877, -0.01639222353696823, -0.05398108437657356, 0.02390960045158863, 0.021832935512065887, 0.00789879634976387, -0.039205193519592285, 0.050809748470783234, 0.015333656221628189, -0.058961376547813416, 0.05427207425236702, 0.05221311375498772, -0.04779074713587761, -0.051116324961185455, 0.029180239886045456, 0.0312790721654892, -0.009759606793522835, 0.057782769203186035, 0.014495543204247952, -0.014339772053062916, 0.037049856036901474, -0.03878207132220268, 0.004173436667770147, -0.0639093890786171, -0.00015112449182197452, -0.03436850383877754, -0.036995239555835724, -0.014533639885485172, -0.047009777277708054, -0.004079443868249655, 0.047979630529880524, -0.022782351821660995, -0.026769205927848816, 0.030729996040463448, -0.00455893762409687, -0.01348577719181776, -0.019346186891198158, -0.010187821462750435, -0.024206750094890594, -0.027480140328407288, 0.013948413543403149, -0.027207408100366592, -0.031583815813064575, -0.04654280096292496, -0.050962794572114944, 0.018920810893177986, -0.05109219625592232, -0.05489743873476982, -0.020168187096714973, -0.03798927366733551, 0.01173105277121067, -0.06615638732910156, -0.017802590504288673, 0.038908232003450394, -0.07223892956972122, 0.019239403307437897, -0.06340327858924866, -0.026249174028635025, 0.004215009044855833, 0.02315542660653591, -0.04689834639430046, -0.018329666927456856, -0.011699539609253407, -0.0025757960975170135, 0.010536079294979572, -0.02618243359029293, 0.02676302194595337, -0.0724509060382843, -0.021294819191098213, -0.029566247016191483, 0.021405795589089394, 0.010748698376119137, -0.04699473828077316, 0.02046707086265087, 0.060978733003139496, -0.034041013568639755, 0.06317818909883499, 0.004554860293865204, 0.04736855998635292, -0.0008430999587289989, 0.001763558597303927, -0.05634411796927452, -0.012190911918878555, 0.011346976272761822, 0.024422530084848404, -0.04212763532996178, 0.01822494901716709, -0.006924660876393318, -0.04712120071053505, 0.03723061829805374, 0.047123804688453674, 0.006105479318648577, 0.012669017538428307, 0.012673694640398026, -0.03308720514178276, -0.07363872975111008, 0.017987918108701706, -0.012976336292922497, -0.05143432691693306, -0.014646324329078197, 0.0036701627541333437, 0.05470370873808861, 0.054432690143585205, -0.006100450176745653, -0.03689246624708176, -0.03842683508992195, 0.04866163805127144, -0.04912593215703964, 0.0011540716513991356, -0.032251182943582535, -0.023030392825603485, -0.002009795978665352, 0.05658856779336929, -0.03499669209122658, 0.019598636776208878, -0.04676644131541252, 0.0182221420109272, -0.0025128270499408245, -0.023803912103176117, 0.05244807153940201, 0.0006175116286613047, -0.04184287413954735, -0.0020439913496375084, -0.021205520257353783, -0.014529460109770298, 0.0377591997385025, -0.0645185336470604, 0.05702633038163185, 0.03415968641638756, 0.0386192724108696, -0.01995851844549179, -0.008199422620236874, -0.023943636566400528, 0.057631343603134155, -0.022158384323120117, 0.03106248751282692, 0.04544154182076454, 0.06540928781032562, -0.020431866869330406, 0.0322541706264019, -0.03058222122490406, -0.02922494150698185, 0.027118908241391182, -0.009921570308506489, 0.012530701234936714, 0.0023746183142066, -0.025451384484767914, -0.013078445568680763, 0.026072537526488304, 0.013986092060804367, -0.021425174549221992, -0.0016681900015100837, -0.024539824575185776, -0.030125781893730164, -0.0737888291478157, -0.00203593703918159, 0.005134105682373047, -0.03185379132628441, -0.025792524218559265, -0.0217258483171463, 0.03156397119164467, -0.005355326924473047, 0.002046349458396435, -0.041397981345653534, -0.0612015463411808, 0.009792051278054714, -0.07889106124639511, 0.04229632392525673, 0.007816742174327374, -0.05509455129504204, -0.02195202372968197, -0.026912154629826546, 0.057686880230903625, -0.0008244931232184172, 0.008644144050776958, 0.015040871687233448, -0.053349819034338, -0.01407062727957964, -0.0408417284488678, -0.003710639663040638, -0.05788886547088623, -0.054942671209573746, -0.041937243193387985, 0.033866818994283676, 0.029821433126926422, -0.06935719400644302, 0.005373145453631878, 0.03448133170604706, -0.050851963460445404, -0.023379294201731682, 0.016439048573374748, 0.01720179244875908, -0.008742805570363998, -0.042963627725839615, -0.012427013367414474, -0.04339704290032387, -0.0844661295413971, 0.05734500288963318, -0.004751888569444418, -0.016227921470999718, 0.03734538331627846, -0.04917551577091217, -0.0005403256509453058, -0.020368505269289017, -0.0702911987900734, 0.05591907724738121, 0.06658705323934555, -0.04535665735602379, 0.01963038556277752, 0.012837892398238182, 0.032598331570625305, -0.061184246093034744, -0.0637047216296196, -0.045059967786073685, -0.00559281138703227, -0.020521236583590508, -0.05084792524576187, 0.04707074910402298, -0.008920273743569851, -0.045721735805273056, -0.03361903876066208, 0.011710498481988907, 0.0031954229343682528, 0.0010745240142568946, -0.0695762112736702, -0.0214142594486475, -0.048223935067653656, -0.02812252752482891, -0.02724986895918846, -0.01711226813495159, -0.0493047758936882, -0.055155135691165924, 0.011968336068093777, -0.03684283420443535, 0.025683052837848663, 0.022069213911890984, 0.02382100746035576, -0.014705339446663857, -0.028019031509757042, 0.040071602910757065, -0.05459184944629669, 0.007837671786546707, -0.028075294569134712, 0.026245787739753723, -0.039051156491041183, 0.00777118606492877, -0.0689748227596283, -0.017685499042272568, 0.011415314860641956, -0.03599218279123306, -0.04429323971271515, 0.04463599994778633, -0.004558824468404055, 0.036045148968696594, 0.013020510785281658, -0.03364400938153267, -0.03889521583914757, -0.05497879534959793, -0.008580395020544529, -0.00853013712912798, 0.06063307821750641, 0.0045643942430615425, -0.02576397731900215, -0.060989052057266235, -0.0420810803771019, -0.04533768445253372, -0.005842350423336029, -0.0612628310918808, -0.025076473131775856, -0.013847834430634975, -0.04118853062391281, -0.02817995473742485, -0.001791246933862567, 0.009263377636671066, -0.018949532881379128, -0.05552414432168007, -0.02700919285416603, 0.03123728558421135, 0.010152740404009819, -0.03427974507212639, -0.048965465277433395, 0.017877135425806046, -0.0020485559944063425, 0.025348110124468803, -0.054513681679964066, -0.022383611649274826, -0.03132770210504532, 0.04242066666483879, 0.026042813435196877, 0.0022087222896516323, -0.04131317511200905, -0.003130014520138502, -0.0687045156955719, -0.000015777215594425797, 0.004275392275303602, 0.06955669820308685, 0.009870692156255245, -0.032286226749420166, -0.010810152627527714, -0.02622857317328453, -0.03383671119809151, -0.041641127318143845, -0.015951571986079216, 0.011307361535727978, -0.039199285209178925, -0.054146282374858856, 0.06062306463718414, 0.05559389293193817, 0.005837286822497845, -0.03792130947113037, -0.059706635773181915, 0.020280644297599792, -0.0009403643198311329, -0.0008389622671529651, 0.03178608790040016, 0.036884408444166183, -0.05053916200995445, 0.012992745265364647, -0.0554165355861187, -0.010209739208221436, 0.0048110876232385635, -0.009810508228838444, 0.022684449329972267, 0.01441977359354496, -0.028345292434096336, -0.07615184038877487, 0.05994478613138199, 0.05858834087848663, 0.016850320622324944, 0.011732438579201698, -0.017912263050675392, 0.044404029846191406, 0.015238696709275246, 0.0024549472145736217, -0.03095625899732113, 0.013273063115775585, 0.03709716349840164, 0.0252652820199728, -0.06957703083753586, -0.05832329019904137, -0.02357436530292034, -0.04613366350531578, 0.008382786065340042, -0.017004020512104034, -0.022976495325565338, 0.02170991152524948, -0.002253492595627904, -0.03871311619877815, 0.05045221373438835, -0.04465296491980553, 0.01397986151278019, -0.0491751953959465, -0.021182751283049583, -0.00505106383934617, -0.00018038158304989338, 0.003807111643254757, -0.015035189688205719, 0.013715345412492752, 0.00008633587276563048, -0.05642886832356453, 0.02897668071091175, -0.0341462679207325, -0.0303973201662302, 0.048557594418525696, 0.03013038821518421, -0.014514812268316746, 0.012374618090689182, 0.025408154353499413, 0.03825940191745758, -0.01843462698161602, 0.006450737360864878, -0.00841350294649601, 0.022091494873166084, 0.04043798893690109, -0.004850402474403381, -0.0008119327249005437, -0.02962404303252697, 0.03239264711737633, -0.046103980392217636, 0.02075248211622238, 0.041596151888370514, -0.006724556442350149, -0.01735643856227398, -0.07825110852718353, -0.03425374999642372, -0.06877108663320541, 0.03180629014968872, -0.027264978736639023, 0.011356551200151443, 0.04411955922842026, -0.011062891222536564, -0.016097338870167732, 0.028884515166282654, 0.031107619404792786, -0.03532232344150543, -0.04544697701931, -0.037484366446733475, -0.04960331320762634, 0.012185364030301571, -0.020743172615766525, 0.010573472827672958, 0.011973435059189796, -0.0018497410928830504, -0.06345894187688828, 0.05727098509669304, 0.03271564096212387, -0.013647195883095264, 0.04632346332073212, -0.018158571794629097, 0.010798388160765171, 0.019242212176322937, -0.02977251075208187, -0.024832144379615784, -0.03479382023215294, 0.03238967806100845, -0.053386297076940536, 0.053566258400678635, 0.014036779291927814, -0.05216040089726448, -0.025696173310279846, 0.030293650925159454, 0.027688827365636826, -0.050275351852178574, -0.0029523251578211784, 0.02750486694276333, -0.010388984344899654, -0.050429269671440125, -0.06349072605371475, -0.01094420813024044, -0.016636772081255913, -0.06557456403970718, 0.026919199153780937, -0.036174651235342026, 0.024931784719228745, 0.019591806456446648, -0.005816376768052578, -0.03587963804602623, -0.010669341310858727, -0.028015008196234703, 0.02811906486749649, 0.02574693039059639, 0.013618938624858856, -0.04264330863952637, -0.059855230152606964, -0.057676009833812714, 0.02135368250310421, 0.004066322930157185, -0.00715397484600544, 0.02634008601307869, 0.029663298279047012, -0.041552960872650146, 0.02807621844112873, -0.07863598316907883, 0.03894926980137825, -0.009340723976492882, -0.05293735861778259, -0.011783650144934654, 0.04498368501663208, -0.025260193273425102, 0.007833672687411308, 0.02771182172000408, 0.022805320098996162, -0.028659043833613396, -0.03824383765459061, -0.03139360249042511, 0.011704676784574986, -0.06676510721445084, 0.030750039964914322, 0.032595064491033554, 0.043769240379333496, -0.056015994399785995, -0.0034770267084240913, 0.027051148936152458, -0.050593070685863495, 0.013742553070187569, 0.02059827744960785, -0.02131694369018078, -0.036482296884059906, -0.07255968451499939, 0.03212393820285797, -0.02488807961344719, 0.02685200795531273, 0.02436017245054245, -0.026746757328510284, -0.01559767872095108, 0.021432118490338326, 0.00008890060416888446, 0.04581920802593231, -0.016541272401809692, 0.04858068376779556, -0.05321827158331871, -0.012254281900823116, -0.03322182595729828, -0.056299809366464615, -0.030059276148676872, -0.05741991102695465, -0.006335845682770014, 0.007979017682373524, -0.01686934567987919, 0.07125341892242432, 0.05547591298818588, -0.014367977157235146, -0.039860986173152924, -0.010128681547939777, -0.040233977138996124, 0.06818593293428421, -0.02480980195105076, -0.009985411539673805, 0.0045731584541499615, 0.01253417693078518, -0.004832422826439142, -0.03928551450371742, -0.0031208530999720097, 0.018710821866989136, -0.010160472244024277, 0.01359825860708952, -0.007074298337101936, 0.05057986080646515, -0.038079340010881424, 0.0022649664897471666, 0.03260458633303642, -0.06815431267023087, 0.04163135588169098, 0.02718229778110981, -0.013748549856245518, -0.006886757910251617, -0.015197855420410633, 0.045420847833156586, -0.05770786479115486, -0.008695274591445923, 0.03271973133087158, -0.07069232314825058, 0.008853337727487087, -0.0694989487528801, -0.021237654611468315, 0.0010434800060465932, -0.052136726677417755, 0.0036773933097720146, 0.04948044940829277, 0.006679811514914036, -0.03554540500044823, 0.031957585364580154, -0.026792846620082855, -0.05327015370130539, -0.011697951704263687, 0.025010153651237488, -0.05776863172650337, -0.03290044888854027, -0.002589873969554901, -0.04768078029155731, -0.0031321903225034475, -0.02887002006173134, -0.06392780691385269, -0.054569944739341736, -0.0024394760839641094, 0.010387171059846878, 0.053285520523786545, 0.004387981723994017, 0.030032318085432053, -0.024355025961995125, 0.007645404897630215, -0.04215036332607269, -0.04140251874923706, -0.035751502960920334, -0.03500231355428696, 0.03775380924344063, -0.04139428585767746, -0.00293678673915565, -0.015501311048865318, 0.027193287387490273, -0.0069988495670259, -0.03149578720331192, 0.019712373614311218, 0.05159805342555046, 0.061601802706718445, -0.03768543899059296, -0.014032457955181599, 0.030922628939151764, -0.054924797266721725, 0.005611790344119072, -0.032363615930080414, 0.02017921768128872, -0.03197266161441803, 0.00525136012583971, 0.044291384518146515, -0.05307608097791672, 0.010620436631143093, -0.048956263810396194, -0.04999525472521782, -0.031282052397727966, -0.03475020453333855, 0.029296888038516045, 0.0419943742454052, 0.060977376997470856, 0.003980002831667662, 0.038195449858903885, -0.04844972491264343, 0.0009528950322419405, -0.05737974867224693, -0.0036134689580649137, -0.016024833545088768, 0.009884316474199295, 0.05226431041955948, -0.019465504214167595, 0.05697958543896675, -0.05149315297603607, -0.006315164268016815, -0.05711793527007103, -0.03417779505252838, -0.04440746456384659, -0.018211597576737404, -0.05671236664056778, -0.032500870525836945, 0.032115042209625244, -0.025360267609357834, 0.05233270302414894, -0.0284371767193079, -0.006871113553643227, -0.06494445353746414, -0.010041901841759682, -0.051019053906202316, -0.00028472201665863395, 0.027955785393714905, 0.006460478529334068, 0.02792614884674549, -0.009646623395383358, 0.0613417774438858, -0.007771054282784462, 0.059196002781391144, -0.027074914425611496, -0.06386920064687729, -0.001620506402105093, 0.04511110484600067, 0.023653969168663025, -0.07180370390415192, -0.04372646287083626, -0.07342888414859772, -0.07421573251485825, 0.01088467426598072, -0.017615770921111107, 0.03773344308137894, -0.054696306586265564, -0.06714437901973724, 0.05196830630302429, 0.04681039974093437, 0.015427649952471256, -0.07979933172464371, 0.041437581181526184, 0.04396925866603851, -0.011348230764269829, 0.03688977658748627, -0.034420646727085114, -0.05764424055814743, 0.007141925860196352, -0.07299229502677917, -0.012533864937722683, -0.03203105926513672, 0.05843363329768181, 0.024883650243282318, -0.017325878143310547, -0.018663406372070312, -0.04593728855252266, -0.003418818349018693, 0.008739722892642021, 0.009569703601300716, 0.019613027572631836, -0.03698435425758362, -0.03714454919099808, 0.006243934854865074, 0.030015667900443077, 0.026629187166690826, -0.024091869592666626, 0.03199920058250427, -0.04353345185518265, -0.010954311117529869, -0.04692313075065613, 0.01919827237725258, 0.06501112133264542, -0.02180735021829605, 0.042676374316215515, -0.010211454704403877, -0.029955968260765076, -0.036828357726335526, -0.018308080732822418, 0.03385768458247185, -0.056818995624780655, -0.027937065809965134, -0.0066480012610554695, -0.0038050950970500708, -0.033581096678972244, -0.02017887681722641, -0.026593543589115143, -0.027882682159543037, 0.048542190343141556, 0.023486051708459854, -0.0001403595379088074, -0.05461369454860687, -0.015862571075558662, -0.0372486338019371, -0.04648527130484581, -0.030286462977528572, 0.03665417060256004, 0.025135992094874382, -0.02338053658604622, 0.006747984793037176, -0.06608367711305618, 0.004891799762845039, -0.03127804398536682, 0.006836471147835255, 0.03695672005414963, 0.030755192041397095, -0.06102409586310387, 0.040061239153146744, -0.04229734465479851, -0.05453808605670929, -0.025518683716654778, -0.022130314260721207, 0.02186952531337738, -0.0343027226626873, -0.007111047860234976, 0.031382735818624496, 0.01863890513777733, -0.06344662606716156, 0.03992579132318497, 0.03407195955514908, -0.01373180653899908, 0.045102957636117935, -0.00515483133494854, 0.03384929522871971, -0.002171145984902978, 0.0031224892009049654, -0.020795686170458794, -0.028097985312342644, 0.05871105194091797, -0.0026964375283569098, -0.030359389260411263, -0.01593470387160778, -0.033568769693374634, -0.013152697123587132, -0.049711283296346664, -0.03828119486570358, 0.015486602671444416, 0.03852047771215439, -0.033080682158470154, 0.006792922969907522, 0.03616435080766678, -0.06254716962575912, -0.05693378299474716 ]
Despite their success, Machine Learning (ML) models do not generalize effectively to data not originating from the training distribution. To reliably employ ML models in real-world healthcare systems and avoid inaccurate predictions on out-of-distribution (OOD) data, it is crucial to detect OOD samples. Numerous OOD detection approaches have been suggested in other fields - especially in computer vision - but it remains unclear whether the challenge is resolved when dealing with medical tabular data. To answer this pressing need, we propose an extensive reproducible benchmark to compare different methods across a suite of tests including both near and far OODs. Our benchmark leverages the latest versions of eICU and MIMIC-IV, two public datasets encompassing tens of thousands of ICU patients in several hospitals. We consider a wide array of density-based methods and SOTA post-hoc detectors across diverse predictive architectures, including MLP, ResNet, and Transformer. Our findings show that i) the problem appears to be solved for far-OODs, but remains open for near-OODs; ii) post-hoc methods alone perform poorly, but improve substantially when coupled with distance-based mechanisms; iii) the transformer architecture is far less overconfident compared to MLP and ResNet.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16220v1
[ -0.020444341003894806, -0.030527520924806595, 0.047705840319395065, -0.014893964864313602, -0.04787895828485489, 0.022259986028075218, 0.032168563455343246, 0.005350843537598848, -0.0032018222846090794, -0.018478630110621452, -0.005452938377857208, -0.01751505210995674, -0.054863639175891876, -0.03421063721179962, -0.03700318932533264, 0.0210302472114563, 0.05987195670604706, 0.05300717055797577, -0.04225593060255051, 0.0399237684905529, -0.008515275083482265, -0.007705257274210453, -0.05852018669247627, -0.010685563087463379, 0.013852416537702084, -0.003465080400928855, 0.010557216592133045, 0.02732340805232525, 0.013437003828585148, -0.026179872453212738, 0.032118529081344604, -0.01319896150380373, -0.030316803604364395, -0.059499841183423996, -0.02572581358253956, -0.011187521740794182, 0.029098588973283768, 0.011985626071691513, -0.0007882549543865025, -0.05230215564370155, 0.01288359984755516, -0.03949364647269249, -0.04962877929210663, -0.03861674666404724, -0.014779273420572281, 0.034990277141332626, 0.002092157257720828, -0.05492806434631348, -0.03086025081574917, -0.018806418403983116, 0.047337695956230164, 0.01778794825077057, -0.016079401597380638, 0.015417148359119892, -0.02037399262189865, -0.0063326102681458, -0.05163156986236572, 0.021616246551275253, -0.06797356903553009, -0.006023645866662264, -0.0009032348170876503, 0.0071845995262265205, 0.0012587226228788495, 0.013322564773261547, 0.016488974913954735, 0.025297095999121666, -0.05908306688070297, -0.07107099890708923, -0.0288541279733181, -0.044973768293857574, 0.06207188218832016, -0.06119684502482414, -0.00021100677258800715, 0.004692812450230122, -0.06426139920949936, -0.013821829110383987, -0.002868992742151022, -0.008873050101101398, 0.02802989073097706, 0.005507340654730797, -0.024302808567881584, 0.03972906246781349, -0.022208891808986664, 0.0002641489263623953, 0.0004972073365934193, -0.05712752416729927, 0.05322781577706337, -0.023657508194446564, 0.009722741320729256, -0.035552117973566055, 0.04197169095277786, -0.056505583226680756, -0.07509728521108627, 0.021507365629076958, 0.05614210292696953, -0.05766146630048752, 0.03738420456647873, 0.031492121517658234, 0.014829039573669434, -0.01626872643828392, -0.010813085362315178, -0.04228929802775383, -0.07152718305587769, 0.04572615399956703, 0.0357537716627121, -0.03993590921163559, -0.008900215849280357, 0.006216081324964762, -0.059303540736436844, -0.043844982981681824, -0.013959376141428947, -0.041912373155355453, 0.026299627497792244, -0.07738027721643448, -0.022847093641757965, -0.03571280464529991, 0.05492941662669182, 0.010312643833458424, 0.000010890943485719617, -0.005550961475819349, -0.03321027383208275, 0.018091527745127678, 0.009398973546922207, -0.007027176674455404, 0.0068131620064377785, -0.040199849754571915, 0.030918767675757408, -0.000012157294804637786, -0.044280972331762314, -0.024433856830000877, -0.06590000540018082, 0.02203127183020115, -0.018421880900859833, -0.006711774505674839, 0.05954437330365181, -0.007069645449519157, -0.0023536481894552708, -0.006133291404694319, 0.05699119716882706, 0.0022838048171252012, -0.024052895605564117, -0.08614926040172577, 0.006369380280375481, -0.04561946541070938, -0.017456939443945885, 0.0398196205496788, -0.08053090423345566, -0.020456945523619652, 0.036876875907182693, 0.06189415231347084, 0.023325767368078232, 0.02768447808921337, 0.005288397893309593, 0.04313602298498154, 0.008210169151425362, -0.013147138990461826, 0.04590445011854172, -0.01904512755572796, -0.066166453063488, 0.0034801922738552094, 0.02325775846838951, -0.02105611376464367, -0.01599491573870182, -0.043003056198358536, 0.008693240582942963, 0.0028899444732815027, 0.04261348024010658, 0.02692369744181633, 0.011768104508519173, 0.014367961324751377, -0.019153214991092682, -0.02980477176606655, 0.032491929829120636, 0.0003586291568353772, -0.036562126129865646, -0.03514722362160683, 0.03936300799250603, -0.027840526774525642, -0.07091135531663895, 0.0011876822682097554, 0.024945158511400223, 0.06255538761615753, -0.03918170556426048, -0.014982827007770538, -0.040500182658433914, -0.002722729230299592, -0.08015219867229462, 0.0012315958738327026, -0.0030014771036803722, -0.00007772907702019438, -0.056075889617204666, -0.014871400780975819, 0.037376437336206436, 0.027153242379426956, -0.02338290400803089, -0.06384031474590302, -0.002727269195020199, -0.021592432633042336, 0.01997855305671692, 0.07251619547605515, -0.09170021861791611, 0.0025232541374862194, -0.033900026232004166, -0.0029788315296173096, -0.019036976620554924, -0.035547949373722076, -0.003480596002191305, 0.014774839393794537, -0.06267710030078888, -0.02190021425485611, 0.041169408708810806, 0.023709658533334732, 0.027931729331612587, 0.01531598437577486, 0.05271625891327858, 0.011173282749950886, -0.09848881512880325, 0.03606134280562401, -0.02854286879301071, 0.009777454659342766, 0.04012596607208252, -0.0033303657546639442, -0.01786433905363083, -0.025287620723247528, -0.018735429272055626, 0.07133082300424576, 0.04047752171754837, 0.011623424477875233, -0.05840142071247101, -0.03642969951033592, -0.03029947727918625, -0.06733223795890808, -0.0346997007727623, -0.05413464084267616, -0.038812216371297836, -0.007439570967108011, -0.06202762573957443, 0.06874197721481323, 0.006193541921675205, -0.03905949369072914, -0.04669615253806114, 0.012587076053023338, 0.020798582583665848, 0.013373923487961292, -0.03224313631653786, -0.029161805287003517, -0.010855218395590782, 0.02373644895851612, 0.008011587895452976, 0.011500416323542595, -0.0471377931535244, -0.02610771358013153, 0.012788739055395126, -0.01223786175251007, 0.044196076691150665, 0.05982375517487526, -0.016230227425694466, -0.0387376993894577, -0.008524819277226925, 0.03647257015109062, 0.05846524238586426, 0.03039383329451084, -0.045405808836221695, 0.018554141744971275, 0.029616784304380417, -0.021559637039899826, -0.010331038385629654, 0.014927120879292488, 0.045771922916173935, -0.0704682469367981, 0.013910540379583836, 0.006854169070720673, 0.01901371218264103, -0.00897710956633091, 0.03962128236889839, -0.03612926974892616, 0.001939007779583335, -0.05248582363128662, 0.022136524319648743, 0.05674818903207779, 0.02127162739634514, 0.00016709716874174774, 0.01127014309167862, -0.07059046626091003, -0.04903818666934967, -0.06492599099874496, -0.004318500403314829, -0.046735454350709915, -0.06766007840633392, -0.0007553817122243345, -0.0807332918047905, -0.037815723568201065, -0.007995798252522945, -0.023089472204446793, -0.0131098423153162, -0.06787679344415665, -0.0741172730922699, 0.010178056545555592, 0.03634682670235634, 0.00023565356968902051, -0.047387417405843735, -0.07085277885198593, 0.010565918870270252, 0.019975533708930016, 0.005144110880792141, -0.06668014079332352, -0.04916096106171608, -0.03173195570707321, 0.040518619120121, 0.013539839535951614, 0.00577710522338748, 0.03499801829457283, -0.03395726531744003, 0.028003009036183357, 0.0030501752626150846, 0.02299349009990692, 0.006722031161189079, 0.013750584796071053, -0.017887944355607033, -0.018918650224804878, 0.025013329461216927, -0.023967748507857323, 0.004365943837910891, -0.0192885585129261, -0.045264020562171936, -0.024784410372376442, 0.06527604907751083, 0.039356715977191925, -0.017603281885385513, -0.019194481894373894, 0.0008784765959717333, -0.0029788732063025236, 0.012237384915351868, -0.026605883613228798, 0.031864866614341736, 0.039925459772348404, -0.0630154237151146, -0.023697711527347565, -0.013958148658275604, -0.011591722257435322, -0.031169051304459572, 0.010561785660684109, -0.07179760932922363, 0.02211039327085018, 0.043461017310619354, -0.0820377767086029, -0.02965550124645233, 0.06557637453079224, 0.04288144409656525, 0.015309973619878292, 0.011097793467342854, 0.006529767997562885, 0.011842021718621254, 0.00976481381803751, 0.032018620520830154, 0.008270887657999992, -0.004661799408495426, 0.05309882014989853, -0.027017366141080856, -0.046188902109861374, 0.0436762198805809, -0.0599847249686718, -0.06160373613238335, 0.03832529857754707, 0.0294366292655468, -0.001852099783718586, 0.009725278243422508, -0.07878847420215607, -0.00964705366641283, -0.016195815056562424, 0.008363396860659122, 0.018415428698062897, -0.030709918588399887, 0.008945736102759838, -0.036671232432127, 0.002287869341671467, 0.029668796807527542, -0.010814073495566845, 0.01871257834136486, -0.050988584756851196, 0.02608736976981163, -0.07915978878736496, 0.0422414094209671, 0.0116913802921772, -0.013142690062522888, 0.04149913042783737, 0.08408991992473602, 0.03500542417168617, 0.03666922450065613, 0.017350703477859497, -0.009151699021458626, -0.027723532170057297, 0.03441184014081955, -0.024265825748443604, -0.014365001581609249, -0.052094895392656326, 0.010163703002035618, 0.011104072444140911, 0.0046144467778503895, 0.0025522944051772356, -0.020909877493977547, -0.023999696597456932, 0.005910144653171301, -0.09005042910575867, -0.011783513240516186, -0.011731618084013462, 0.03501768410205841, -0.031920596957206726, -0.01272996049374342, 0.05375378578901291, -0.05378783121705055, 0.05056753382086754, -0.030537597835063934, -0.01825527474284172, -0.004807581193745136, -0.03989096358418465, -0.03301580250263214, -0.08247195929288864, 0.01744174398481846, -0.047955069690942764, 0.016694162040948868, 0.010590814054012299, 0.002633454976603389, -0.05610589683055878, -0.01973024383187294, 0.0150194326415658, 0.011648811399936676, 0.051899753510951996, 0.001323799486272037, -0.01437308918684721, -0.004573640879243612, -0.004427189938724041, -0.05880873650312424, -0.0008955398225225508, 0.006375105120241642, -0.032343789935112, 0.008676629513502121, -0.011032157577574253, -0.04888959228992462, -0.05827231705188751, -0.014356257393956184, 0.0447254553437233, -0.04888341575860977, -0.01840854622423649, -0.017147483304142952, 0.041832324117422104, -0.06266393512487411, -0.06854338198900223, -0.040421001613140106, -0.04499455913901329, -0.04735366255044937, -0.0026087090373039246, 0.021183976903557777, 0.039671774953603745, -0.014375433325767517, -0.017398804426193237, 0.04862149804830551, 0.003121623070910573, 0.023968227207660675, 0.031356122344732285, 0.02915174700319767, 0.024084312841296196, -0.000119072399684228, -0.048064734786748886, -0.077385812997818, -0.018813403323292732, -0.025148028507828712, 0.04185164347290993, -0.006224516313523054, 0.04677265137434006, 0.04251013696193695, 0.030156567692756653, -0.08813027292490005, 0.04941585659980774, 0.03938860446214676, -0.029605191200971603, 0.033693645149469376, 0.056078147143125534, 0.03709091618657112, 0.0016777686541900039, -0.022316763177514076, 0.006593438796699047, 0.01640569046139717, -0.04836070165038109, -0.006011336576193571, -0.02790728025138378, 0.025302786380052567, -0.04243435338139534, 0.07300612330436707, -0.018887383863329887, -0.06056087464094162, 0.00027602867339737713, 0.024657435715198517, -0.01914648897945881, -0.04734088480472565, 0.04945049434900284, 0.008618773892521858, -0.01202131062746048, -0.049405455589294434, -0.008826587349176407, 0.006181987002491951, -0.0024303707759827375, 0.02433328703045845, -0.029938872903585434, -0.019376832991838455, 0.03264652192592621, -0.0350227914750576, 0.009391715750098228, 0.016436101868748665, 0.000038602443964919075, 0.008018496446311474, -0.028617406263947487, -0.03639614209532738, -0.0630660429596901, -0.0163216944783926, -0.03884352371096611, 0.03306396305561066, 0.027020219713449478, 0.026713872328400612, -0.02139722742140293, -0.016505753621459007, -0.0405726283788681, -0.020564034581184387, 0.02526765502989292, 0.009443359449505806, 0.01727410964667797, -0.03980691730976105, 0.056601714342832565, 0.02772386558353901, 0.023706091567873955, 0.0026954158674925566, -0.009250993840396404, -0.04371920973062515, -0.029265334829688072, -0.015372616238892078, 0.005675736349076033, -0.005680570844560862, -0.061215125024318695, -0.05193640664219856, 0.06162644177675247, 0.004761391784995794, -0.05991445109248161, 0.05220901593565941, 0.00248330133035779, -0.01134897954761982, 0.016416391357779503, -0.006627244409173727, -0.002347561065107584, -0.019703393802046776, 0.06928187608718872, 0.05587947741150856, -0.060725126415491104, -0.0041338372975587845, -0.03695950657129288, -0.035122100263834, 0.040299125015735626, -0.05521030351519585, 0.009094104170799255, 0.04082946851849556, 0.01708429865539074, -0.02552996203303337, 0.020001739263534546, -0.018585966899991035, -0.07919491827487946, -0.045023657381534576, -0.0019328478956595063, -0.07564333826303482, -0.022808833047747612, 0.030034244060516357, -0.01597542129456997, -0.048642970621585846, 0.06430187821388245, 0.0175972618162632, -0.03354031592607498, -0.06931901723146439, 0.04187291860580444, 0.08246918767690659, 0.0030554451514035463, -0.003672810038551688, -0.04858384281396866, -0.020669404417276382, 0.026293424889445305, -0.04450162127614021, 0.02340485341846943, 0.02780863083899021, 0.004887169227004051, -0.0077186329290270805, -0.03126253932714462, -0.04349086433649063, 0.06939590722322464, -0.03444172069430351, -0.011328892782330513, 0.029557693749666214, -0.013969456776976585, 0.05163465812802315, -0.014590048231184483, -0.016299201175570488, -0.01218423992395401, -0.007871202193200588, -0.009092436172068119, -0.0417315810918808, -0.001373619888909161, 0.012920941226184368, -0.010316663421690464, -0.00807937327772379, -0.04225233942270279, 0.021415473893284798, 0.020502883940935135, -0.06410182267427444, 0.03258292004466057, -0.04289746657013893, 0.033685971051454544, -0.016605831682682037, 0.0041121188551187515, 0.020485268905758858, 0.062152791768312454, -0.04869965836405754, -0.016163701191544533, -0.006133789196610451, 0.018686993047595024, 0.01762937195599079, -0.027278810739517212, -0.0037692647892981768, -0.018109196797013283, -0.005194626282900572, -0.010720107704401016, -0.020973561331629753, -0.030606970191001892, -0.03918880969285965, 0.04416057839989662, -0.006091021932661533, -0.042056698352098465, -0.04421849548816681, 0.01977536268532276, -0.007629746571183205, 0.020999157801270485, 0.005791653413325548, -0.04284346103668213, -0.06833606958389282, -0.006408868357539177, -0.03077280893921852, -0.008792053908109665, 0.018081991001963615, 0.014705208130180836, 0.03929947316646576, -0.032109931111335754, 0.028841903433203697, -0.00974565651267767, -0.02923176996409893, 0.004553292412310839, -0.07623570412397385, -0.0067198690958321095, 0.046938106417655945, -0.02688717469573021, -0.04942772537469864, -0.01609552465379238, -0.01803618110716343, -0.042347848415374756, 0.005255555734038353, 0.04839320480823517, 0.050628576427698135, 0.003006789367645979, -0.07668246328830719, 0.011601912789046764, 0.0257362499833107, -0.043667279183864594, -0.05282152071595192, -0.0205658208578825, 0.019308200106024742, -0.04350747540593147, -0.005354792810976505, -0.012757483869791031, -0.06033467501401901, 0.007219725288450718, -0.0804511308670044, -0.03486977890133858, -0.02102978341281414, 0.05946006625890732, -0.025499235838651657, -0.01649714820086956, 0.0047147502191364765, -0.05575836822390556, -0.002443710109218955, -0.00865865871310234, -0.0015085056656971574, 0.018743764609098434, 0.0065413350239396095, 0.002117619849741459, -0.05895308032631874, -0.02638752944767475, -0.0006137164309620857, -0.054365601390600204, 0.011478844098746777, 0.01748499646782875, 0.00833509024232626, 0.003782942658290267, 0.014919053763151169, 0.050175923854112625, -0.022623112425208092, 0.019459929317235947, -0.05779414623975754, 0.004010519478470087, -0.07610008120536804, -0.07519271969795227, 0.004580639768391848, -0.025694018229842186, 0.04356703534722328, 0.013067486695945263, 0.008762634359300137, -0.005695926956832409, -0.05454304441809654, -0.045094821602106094, 0.05200652778148651, -0.01913994736969471, 0.01819727011024952, 0.02543630264699459, 0.0011693648993968964, -0.007800354156643152, -0.0667194351553917, -0.026406122371554375, -0.050406210124492645, 0.013696784153580666, -0.006247476674616337, -0.02659272775053978, 0.006980678997933865, -0.07231961935758591, 0.02645210549235344, 0.012774198316037655, -0.043491728603839874, -0.06398845463991165, 0.08035948127508163, 0.00020148481416981667, -0.049724455922842026, 0.022616581991314888, -0.03840655833482742, -0.025542134419083595, -0.05324499309062958, -0.037213053554296494, -0.055955369025468826, 0.02889174595475197, -0.041377633810043335, 0.03759486600756645, 0.031595710664987564, 0.04776834696531296, 0.0068811154924333096, 0.027669133618474007, 0.02071021869778633, 0.015590808354318142, -0.036076560616493225, 0.07806228846311569, -0.02135229855775833, 0.026009097695350647, -0.05343104153871536, 0.018568523228168488, 0.009168121963739395, -0.04658430069684982, 0.008516067638993263, -0.0335848443210125, 0.01020276453346014, -0.05239712446928024, -0.0328349694609642, 0.017067719250917435, -0.005914120469242334, -0.028951629996299744, 0.0019213072955608368, 0.0030814267229288816, -0.05601010099053383, -0.04229467362165451 ]
Distributed learning on edge devices has attracted increased attention with the advent of federated learning (FL). Notably, edge devices often have limited battery and heterogeneous energy availability, while multiple rounds are required in FL for convergence, intensifying the need for energy efficiency. Energy depletion may hinder the training process and the efficient utilization of the trained model. To solve these problems, this letter considers the integration of energy harvesting (EH) devices into a FL network with multi-channel ALOHA, while proposing a method to ensure both low energy outage probability and successful execution of future tasks. Numerical results demonstrate the effectiveness of this method, particularly in critical setups where the average energy income fails to cover the iteration cost. The method outperforms a norm based solution in terms of convergence time and battery level.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06033v1
[ -0.04162383824586868, -0.04894816130399704, 0.010696535930037498, -0.009065707214176655, -0.05419772118330002, -0.001249557244591415, 0.01642680913209915, 0.03169749677181244, 0.006082437001168728, -0.030392954126000404, 0.0036186024080961943, -0.04729726165533066, -0.02141398936510086, -0.0046244957484304905, -0.04959648847579956, 0.016297195106744766, 0.07202097028493881, 0.06475192308425903, -0.03838270902633667, 0.056022368371486664, 0.02130887284874916, 0.05720231309533119, -0.04862323775887489, 0.014223232865333557, 0.046399977058172226, 0.001357145607471466, -0.06035848334431648, 0.039947908371686935, -0.008868821896612644, -0.028076214715838432, 0.05618607625365257, -0.001895813038572669, -0.062362316995859146, -0.05573089048266411, -0.0063495696522295475, -0.013746834360063076, 0.012866994366049767, 0.04840366169810295, 0.04716137796640396, -0.022318171337246895, 0.04236118495464325, -0.06641592085361481, -0.07218822091817856, -0.02727481722831726, -0.017960596829652786, 0.02255275845527649, -0.06364099681377411, 0.0015482449671253562, -0.05717858299612999, -0.058809153735637665, 0.0040594832971692085, 0.038884978741407394, 0.002406303770840168, 0.03725413233041763, -0.019620919600129128, 0.020478589460253716, 0.019830189645290375, 0.013906159438192844, -0.025111019611358643, -0.008118752390146255, -0.0025410018861293793, -0.001586399506777525, 0.012442263774573803, 0.025361698120832443, -0.06012405827641487, 0.03483967110514641, 0.00823367852717638, -0.06663799285888672, -0.03557620570063591, -0.040842991322278976, 0.015438374131917953, -0.04842709004878998, -0.021630000323057175, 0.02631833218038082, -0.05975112318992615, -0.03308231011033058, -0.02915983833372593, -0.027633175253868103, 0.02666272595524788, -0.04142265394330025, -0.0509679801762104, 0.01639004424214363, -0.03458257019519806, -0.006717259529978037, -0.04055268317461014, 0.004950904753059149, 0.07053171843290329, -0.017028629779815674, -0.026156863197684288, -0.027742817997932434, 0.058363039046525955, -0.022471502423286438, -0.07189451903104782, 0.02918817102909088, 0.040367454290390015, -0.004442827310413122, 0.0568593367934227, 0.028611989691853523, -0.0010940853971987963, -0.028933163732290268, 0.0005537889082916081, -0.037256330251693726, -0.06263190507888794, 0.023331042379140854, 0.01127310749143362, -0.01571972854435444, 0.03756080940365791, -0.017767980694770813, -0.04898378252983093, 0.02678532712161541, -0.0039823646657168865, 0.016210924834012985, 0.005551155190914869, -0.04510115459561348, -0.049386538565158844, 0.002265581162646413, 0.06381780654191971, 0.01977440156042576, -0.020576372742652893, -0.007191712502390146, -0.0063672177493572235, 0.008281141519546509, 0.02366499789059162, 0.015916595235466957, -0.018966546282172203, 0.0021027857437729836, 0.046510960906744, -0.04013543948531151, -0.0175565667450428, -0.025242621079087257, -0.0514032244682312, 0.045252725481987, 0.016629302874207497, -0.038071949034929276, 0.005663632415235043, 0.03297654166817665, -0.02048080787062645, -0.009535732679069042, 0.05101899057626724, 0.013558318838477135, -0.03992271423339844, -0.06316066533327103, 0.011654478497803211, -0.04551820456981659, 0.04006176441907883, 0.07956227660179138, -0.0010679505066946149, -0.03342854231595993, 0.026640620082616806, 0.01242437306791544, 0.00781301036477089, 0.0567057766020298, 0.01976728066802025, -0.008356094360351562, 0.030668385326862335, -0.007242558058351278, -0.0014799925265833735, 0.01248689740896225, -0.063430555164814, 0.0037701213732361794, -0.01169416680932045, -0.052974797785282135, -0.023769190534949303, 0.001274988753721118, 0.004489317070692778, 0.0024840000551193953, 0.013732428662478924, -0.004828218370676041, -0.02352672629058361, 0.006609381176531315, -0.041938092559576035, 0.013812999241054058, -0.009650364518165588, -0.005545396823436022, -0.06604538857936859, -0.02231140062212944, 0.016341639682650566, -0.053810182958841324, -0.05366704612970352, 0.001236921874806285, 0.0439474992454052, 0.04109516739845276, -0.0357353650033474, -0.009591015055775642, -0.007409007288515568, -0.007051478605717421, -0.0882202610373497, 0.06062693893909454, -0.006806923076510429, -0.019285209476947784, -0.033578239381313324, -0.015967989340424538, 0.012700095772743225, -0.00943794660270214, 0.003420943161472678, -0.03168337047100067, 0.04055964946746826, -0.04941903427243233, -0.03522881865501404, 0.028954559937119484, -0.07622820138931274, -0.003931958694010973, -0.05981185659766197, 0.011603164486587048, -0.004803064279258251, -0.07177264243364334, 0.012405595742166042, 0.006144492421299219, -0.034981124103069305, -0.0005544875748455524, 0.05173379182815552, 0.05365976691246033, 0.03185969963669777, 0.023496748879551888, 0.05288160592317581, -0.01783410646021366, -0.09729393571615219, 0.043204326182603836, 0.008010569028556347, -0.005347446538507938, 0.042118433862924576, -0.0021385184954851866, -0.038729477673769, -0.009059857577085495, 0.027985677123069763, 0.04424810782074928, 0.011112033389508724, -0.037528395652770996, -0.03889189288020134, 0.0037662300746887922, -0.02308979257941246, -0.054772645235061646, -0.04773590341210365, -0.07965923845767975, -0.011356075294315815, -0.012798728421330452, -0.03296786919236183, 0.028848635032773018, -0.015180930495262146, -0.03291903808712959, -0.04466073587536812, -0.009627679362893105, 0.05833975598216057, 0.03639107197523117, -0.08309361338615417, -0.06474922597408295, -0.05856439471244812, 0.0038328564260154963, -0.029828201979398727, 0.012281405739486217, -0.045568499714136124, -0.04258756712079048, -0.0024547516368329525, -0.014225540682673454, 0.024222323670983315, 0.01372317224740982, -0.049077730625867844, 0.0036000674590468407, -0.05773896351456642, -0.004131682217121124, 0.011273522861301899, 0.04182007908821106, -0.06759752333164215, 0.008676758036017418, 0.016921894624829292, 0.017046205699443817, -0.012766994535923004, 0.01081156823784113, 0.03261622041463852, -0.034259725362062454, 0.0025490850675851107, 0.06153412535786629, 0.019313188269734383, 0.04948392137885094, 0.02730565518140793, -0.04025481268763542, -0.023019634187221527, -0.016004126518964767, -0.00005284979852149263, 0.001403435948304832, 0.052303146570920944, 0.031156938523054123, 0.01341170072555542, -0.06363455206155777, -0.014125626534223557, -0.02863096259534359, -0.045417483896017075, -0.0405343696475029, -0.05923277884721756, -0.06870522350072861, -0.0633242279291153, -0.0365377813577652, -0.022823195904493332, -0.0635451003909111, -0.01759686879813671, -0.05137985944747925, -0.004187340848147869, -0.041026730090379715, 0.021322695538401604, -0.05005998536944389, -0.0765761062502861, -0.05266760662198067, 0.0386354997754097, -0.030177216976881027, -0.029681557789444923, -0.020026035606861115, -0.026633139699697495, -0.052820686250925064, 0.0002683000057004392, -0.038239456713199615, -0.017038123682141304, -0.015208705328404903, -0.07304759323596954, 0.040262963622808456, -0.016290977597236633, 0.043426498770713806, 0.028255222365260124, -0.015412267297506332, -0.07630185782909393, -0.029298599809408188, -0.004835501313209534, -0.0037439034786075354, 0.03373590111732483, -0.03933127224445343, -0.03771814703941345, -0.0494169220328331, 0.01969037763774395, 0.03227679803967476, -0.015403049997985363, -0.015968166291713715, -0.03674982115626335, -0.02709849178791046, 0.061668574810028076, -0.009939941577613354, -0.013435402885079384, 0.011141540482640266, -0.065705306828022, -0.04094953462481499, -0.036781102418899536, 0.015017878264188766, -0.026692407205700874, 0.012525686994194984, 0.010241910815238953, 0.03676053509116173, 0.018052533268928528, -0.06948790699243546, 0.0390777550637722, 0.02592182159423828, 0.07346717268228531, -0.025886598974466324, 0.0343659445643425, 0.031992409378290176, -0.018738584592938423, 0.04329216480255127, 0.0005290984991006553, 0.022341152653098106, 0.038173213601112366, 0.03710092976689339, -0.03011590987443924, -0.02960437908768654, 0.007050980348140001, -0.05930430442094803, -0.0432937927544117, -0.038539860397577286, -0.012206019833683968, 0.04863162338733673, -0.02742098644375801, -0.03705453872680664, 0.03030761145055294, -0.005788372829556465, 0.06600473821163177, -0.009016593918204308, -0.02613666281104088, 0.024536997079849243, -0.044789593666791916, 0.006896115839481354, 0.04263307526707649, -0.03822721913456917, 0.007791123352944851, -0.03576735034584999, 0.039065826684236526, -0.07527255266904831, 0.01927606575191021, 0.017496753484010696, 0.02562863565981388, 0.017110120505094528, 0.06279508769512177, -0.016409091651439667, 0.022616758942604065, -0.014206537976861, -0.05593515560030937, -0.061840713024139404, 0.0059616356156766415, -0.04390620440244675, -0.014312184415757656, -0.05679638311266899, 0.016484374180436134, 0.04165085032582283, 0.0024630073457956314, -0.015468732453882694, 0.046142760664224625, 0.025195732712745667, -0.038633231073617935, -0.0793241411447525, 0.029256505891680717, -0.027674000710248947, 0.028045818209648132, -0.005397062283009291, 0.013562502339482307, 0.08661556988954544, -0.015097551047801971, -0.018792422488331795, -0.057947564870119095, -0.017510686069726944, 0.015214341692626476, -0.04481539502739906, -0.016813192516565323, -0.06612071394920349, 0.008013790473341942, -0.021110115572810173, 0.05291426181793213, 0.03823734447360039, -0.013118020258843899, -0.06503710150718689, -0.03313259407877922, 0.04069431871175766, -0.03712679073214531, 0.07060578465461731, 0.02809772454202175, -0.04960957169532776, -0.016645921394228935, -0.020952370017766953, -0.022089438512921333, -0.007320559583604336, 0.0004202915297355503, -0.0438024178147316, 0.021430496126413345, -0.03709070011973381, -0.03205133602023125, -0.02419278211891651, 0.010998698882758617, 0.05754395201802254, -0.05544491857290268, -0.019412556663155556, 0.01866353675723076, 0.0370764285326004, -0.04898787662386894, -0.04753436520695686, -0.005873501766473055, -0.0465729720890522, -0.041923344135284424, -0.05607256665825844, 0.052728280425071716, 0.019410358741879463, 0.0005696590524166822, 0.027266375720500946, 0.002168161328881979, 0.010780676268041134, -0.021596252918243408, 0.06052892282605171, -0.00169921584893018, -0.023112095892429352, -0.04000728949904442, -0.037670910358428955, -0.07647370547056198, 0.008465336635708809, 0.008137783035635948, 0.048364270478487015, 0.0004315620462875813, -0.019078683108091354, 0.0012984923087060452, 0.0006501981988549232, -0.0813022032380104, -0.014241674914956093, 0.057643018662929535, -0.021143896505236626, 0.04630398005247116, 0.026521814987063408, -0.010052583180367947, 0.08157407492399216, -0.042778026312589645, -0.009465876035392284, 0.027368105947971344, -0.06187763065099716, 0.038167670369148254, -0.004318634979426861, -0.051914505660533905, 0.0011566784232854843, 0.020209966227412224, -0.020934227854013443, -0.046327028423547745, 0.003867175430059433, 0.03413071855902672, -0.021269002929329872, -0.0054644630290567875, 0.014556136913597584, 0.0011755345622077584, -0.01906253769993782, -0.016250403597950935, -0.019408099353313446, 0.028849929571151733, -0.0040325685404241085, 0.024913299828767776, -0.05171164497733116, -0.03523608669638634, 0.0266696959733963, 0.01970888487994671, 0.034096524119377136, 0.005512116942554712, 0.021910596638917923, -0.025386346504092216, -0.04971056059002876, -0.02666422910988331, -0.058767590671777725, -0.0016232593916356564, -0.030103012919425964, -0.0031512861605733633, -0.030991479754447937, 0.02544066682457924, 0.00842328555881977, 0.013068288564682007, -0.020752647891640663, -0.07076612859964371, 0.03621485084295273, -0.0362541638314724, 0.04943672940135002, -0.014700585044920444, -0.004293101839721203, -0.015555006451904774, -0.0014777432661503553, 0.03966967761516571, 0.00028832859243266284, 0.00786381121724844, 0.005249762441962957, -0.026853105053305626, 0.0008984913001768291, 0.03944869711995125, -0.02622867561876774, -0.01908726803958416, 0.007501778192818165, 0.05082395300269127, -0.022959867492318153, 0.054909899830818176, 0.020744144916534424, -0.020350398495793343, 0.05631833150982857, 0.017522409558296204, -0.026824332773685455, 0.03232496604323387, 0.061569467186927795, 0.04138893261551857, -0.06673499941825867, 0.026530494913458824, -0.018757188692688942, -0.026230767369270325, 0.02748780883848667, 0.004289264790713787, -0.053063638508319855, -0.005678477697074413, -0.008746379055082798, -0.052499499171972275, 0.06225698068737984, -0.013528809882700443, -0.07268952578306198, -0.02424304187297821, 0.0278477780520916, -0.061149824410676956, -0.030438216403126717, 0.03977172449231148, 0.033708587288856506, -0.06675883382558823, 0.03753942623734474, -0.030682414770126343, -0.017059843987226486, -0.03419552370905876, 0.05638132616877556, 0.05059640854597092, -0.05587547644972801, -0.03350755199790001, 0.025364233180880547, -0.05179504677653313, 0.009297220036387444, 0.02502918429672718, -0.007018513977527618, -0.023993082344532013, 0.033476416021585464, -0.007502812892198563, -0.029536563903093338, -0.03956210985779762, 0.06410418450832367, -0.06313374638557434, 0.0029780855402350426, 0.04671742022037506, -0.005928335711359978, 0.048372991383075714, 0.002893662080168724, -0.05134781450033188, -0.003956625238060951, -0.03666104003787041, 0.0038567748852074146, 0.002668241038918495, -0.018123643472790718, -0.00995913427323103, -0.003420787863433361, -0.0017236233688890934, -0.05691143125295639, 0.04912467673420906, -0.017942767590284348, -0.07848136872053146, 0.04250018671154976, -0.034443918615579605, -0.04585091769695282, 0.024897560477256775, 0.0265694297850132, -0.014087564311921597, 0.06944774091243744, -0.009853883646428585, 0.0035147194284945726, 0.048774734139442444, -0.025558561086654663, 0.04569365084171295, 0.02961774729192257, 0.01881292089819908, -0.05952401086688042, 0.039142075926065445, -0.06063685193657875, -0.02951749600470066, -0.026144830510020256, -0.011110836640000343, -0.009225252084434032, 0.02457576058804989, -0.04491814598441124, -0.04042711481451988, -0.016355257481336594, -0.010367981158196926, 0.012747475877404213, 0.011442041024565697, -0.035479720681905746, -0.07127366960048676, -0.01971699856221676, 0.028104975819587708, -0.016161497682332993, 0.05277888476848602, 0.01708967424929142, 0.0169499721378088, 0.012650090269744396, 0.03879686817526817, 0.01512971706688404, 0.041636016219854355, 0.007227911613881588, -0.026145413517951965, -0.051087457686662674, 0.035824961960315704, -0.023807911202311516, -0.05485457554459572, -0.023021966218948364, -0.0031598308123648167, -0.05414724722504616, -0.019139686599373817, 0.027548957616090775, -0.0022788706701248884, -0.011894097551703453, -0.0608198419213295, 0.02753898687660694, -0.01797102577984333, -0.030218223109841347, -0.05989907681941986, 0.026358161121606827, 0.0696612223982811, -0.020965831354260445, -0.020832795649766922, 0.015610504895448685, -0.021669257432222366, -0.07317731529474258, -0.07290687412023544, -0.029027201235294342, -0.003356532659381628, 0.033889636397361755, 0.003247856628149748, 0.012968870811164379, 0.01207713596522808, -0.05053121596574783, 0.036597322672605515, 0.013785745948553085, 0.05206428840756416, 0.02689167484641075, 0.006435134913772345, -0.0070957001298666, -0.03127061948180199, 0.029242556542158127, 0.04198286682367325, -0.02622201107442379, 0.020895574241876602, 0.017614800482988358, -0.002580139320343733, 0.004492943175137043, -0.015361354686319828, 0.048379696905612946, -0.06886319071054459, 0.019884221255779266, -0.014859672635793686, 0.014038070105016232, -0.007801385130733252, -0.07207845151424408, 0.05939604714512825, -0.03853556513786316, 0.003383924253284931, 0.007073918357491493, -0.00504268566146493, -0.0361567921936512, -0.008332139812409878, -0.025007348507642746, -0.0035174607764929533, -0.014959034509956837, -0.02837175317108631, 0.02266460470855236, 0.010866501368582249, -0.04574059695005417, -0.022606544196605682, -0.004166691564023495, -0.002645893022418022, 0.03228197619318962, 0.036859191954135895, -0.04033990576863289, -0.006121193524450064, -0.03577191382646561, 0.02717781439423561, -0.02274305745959282, 0.03267492726445198, -0.03275343403220177, 0.058616794645786285, -0.027011390775442123, -0.022647729143500328, -0.033176179975271225, -0.008912072516977787, -0.06917677074670792, -0.06188686192035675, -0.01882898062467575, -0.039754848927259445, 0.024483703076839447, -0.00296088051982224, 0.03491070494055748, -0.04415523633360863, 0.027821827679872513, 0.015909824520349503, -0.008258219808340073, -0.05045444145798683, 0.00989095214754343, -0.016963964328169823, 0.07266561686992645, 0.05077734962105751, 0.009723450988531113, -0.04641759395599365, 0.0447954386472702, -0.005732733756303787, -0.01561563741415739, -0.03566012158989906, -0.010054691694676876, -0.058058902621269226, -0.004321565851569176, -0.03157509118318558, -0.018854321911931038, 0.0315149687230587, -0.01768179051578045, -0.0016517520416527987, 0.017598334699869156, -0.051209598779678345, -0.04004676267504692 ]
Argument mining is to analyze argument structure and extract important argument information from unstructured text. An argument mining system can help people automatically gain causal and logical information behind the text. As argumentative corpus gradually increases, like more people begin to argue and debate on social media, argument mining from them is becoming increasingly critical. However, argument mining is still a big challenge in natural language tasks due to its difficulty, and relative techniques are not mature. For example, research on non-tree argument mining needs to be done more. Most works just focus on extracting tree structure argument information. Moreover, current methods cannot accurately describe and capture argument relations and do not predict their types. In this paper, we propose a novel neural model called AutoAM to solve these problems. We first introduce the argument component attention mechanism in our model. It can capture the relevant information between argument components, so our model can better perform argument mining. Our model is a universal end-to-end framework, which can analyze argument structure without constraints like tree structure and complete three subtasks of argument mining in one model. The experiment results show that our model outperforms the existing works on several metrics in two public datasets.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09300v1
[ -0.019832292571663857, -0.014230018481612206, 0.038460854440927505, 0.019637346267700195, 0.009637795388698578, -0.007846206426620483, -0.029264317825436592, -0.026088308542966843, -0.029523834586143494, -0.039026547223329544, -0.030421152710914612, 0.019184250384569168, -0.03645946457982063, -0.03256900608539581, -0.02221992425620556, -0.012225544080138206, 0.0766594186425209, 0.013502678833901882, -0.05115332454442978, 0.04574856907129288, 0.008089722134172916, 0.0113269267603755, -0.043264247477054596, 0.046672552824020386, 0.012012884952127934, -0.03578514605760574, -0.04325685650110245, -0.01317309495061636, -0.041084662079811096, 0.011853122152388096, 0.06605200469493866, -0.05626207962632179, -0.030676357448101044, -0.03738054633140564, -0.05515392869710922, -0.027035893872380257, 0.003089279867708683, -0.047480300068855286, 0.012900331057608128, -0.03871046379208565, 0.04961750656366348, -0.04511210322380066, -0.06757500022649765, 0.014949650503695011, -0.04147566854953766, -0.0011978737311437726, -0.01976453699171543, 0.03744227811694145, -0.08509846776723862, -0.05005224049091339, 0.012763170525431633, -0.008796320296823978, -0.0018192415591329336, 0.019645042717456818, -0.03560847043991089, -0.023245126008987427, -0.011505834758281708, 0.009780905209481716, -0.05807456001639366, 0.016371073201298714, 0.024116849526762962, -0.03210132196545601, -0.04403119161725044, 0.002322939457371831, -0.002104079117998481, 0.0318729504942894, -0.0010573114268481731, -0.05305910483002663, -0.043798040598630905, -0.035550229251384735, 0.07294586300849915, -0.07306458801031113, 0.02937825582921505, -0.032695092260837555, -0.0077853091061115265, -0.031577084213495255, -0.029398703947663307, -0.045442983508110046, -0.001997804269194603, 0.018895115703344345, -0.007264735177159309, 0.05135367810726166, 0.03793245553970337, 0.0017299718456342816, -0.014960472472012043, -0.03526028245687485, 0.02724614553153515, -0.004558396991342306, 0.012488724663853645, -0.06475097686052322, 0.05563643202185631, -0.05030498281121254, -0.07154639065265656, 0.01972978562116623, 0.06636841595172882, -0.03231589123606682, 0.005284127779304981, 0.05371064320206642, 0.0022146916016936302, -0.004367409273982048, -0.03225644677877426, -0.050380904227495193, -0.019175559282302856, 0.03808906301856041, 0.0062042297795414925, -0.0494132824242115, 0.012050969526171684, 0.013630423694849014, -0.02177518606185913, 0.0258812066167593, -0.03845856338739395, -0.023984402418136597, 0.006935796234756708, -0.040963780134916306, -0.030168971046805382, -0.030721498653292656, 0.02821670100092888, 0.02363421395421028, 0.009897343814373016, 0.0028314744122326374, -0.024338752031326294, 0.0429786778986454, 0.012333313934504986, -0.016828274354338646, -0.05946506932377815, -0.049318693578243256, 0.053853023797273636, 0.05268898978829384, -0.0051997750997543335, -0.034970689564943314, -0.04841160029172897, -0.009956968948245049, -0.031615857034921646, 0.01408588606864214, 0.07067521661520004, -0.03236142173409462, -0.038564544171094894, -0.07992223650217056, 0.0037797223776578903, 0.013895715586841106, -0.03077573888003826, -0.0729701966047287, 0.023459849879145622, -0.040990956127643585, 0.013451412320137024, 0.03459397330880165, -0.03503130003809929, -0.02994897961616516, 0.0071883718483150005, 0.0230291448533535, -0.00445703836157918, 0.007268132176250219, 0.03973786532878876, 0.03069106489419937, -0.006118004210293293, -0.009797567501664162, -0.006412865128368139, -0.0024725126568228006, -0.029384687542915344, 0.002170500112697482, 0.024661557748913765, -0.03437823802232742, 0.034619785845279694, -0.04639560729265213, 0.006125879939645529, -0.019029639661312103, 0.03882697597146034, -0.0496864840388298, -0.013682896271348, 0.018960848450660706, -0.008179061114788055, 0.03447788208723068, 0.03309277072548866, -0.0347147211432457, -0.04522925987839699, -0.021122535690665245, 0.026800505816936493, -0.05247608572244644, -0.04694544896483421, 0.017095113173127174, 0.016107354313135147, 0.00878074485808611, -0.06048627942800522, -0.035813964903354645, -0.0003331784682814032, 0.023920351639389992, -0.07200761884450912, -0.0020495017524808645, 0.05363669991493225, 0.053993094712495804, -0.023075895383954048, -0.020294955000281334, 0.019237952306866646, 0.002003396861255169, 0.002275556093081832, 0.011185367591679096, 0.042393963783979416, -0.012992645613849163, 0.008137623779475689, 0.06751181185245514, -0.08096632361412048, -0.008496887981891632, -0.04087217152118683, -0.0547955222427845, -0.01224263571202755, -0.06120460852980614, -0.002663742983713746, 0.02513088658452034, 0.0016490143025293946, 0.0013661884004250169, 0.05885685980319977, 0.04595141485333443, 0.03932766988873482, 0.02039995789527893, 0.02329104393720627, 0.008440569043159485, -0.08943015336990356, 0.029194172471761703, 0.011148043908178806, 0.019784074276685715, 0.040888428688049316, 0.06384766846895218, 0.004936483688652515, -0.008943160995841026, 0.006436249241232872, 0.027714313939213753, 0.03952193632721901, -0.021669749170541763, -0.04369203373789787, -0.016761451959609985, -0.059097856283187866, -0.04854469746351242, 0.0020738341845571995, -0.052991241216659546, -0.019149143248796463, 0.003360239788889885, -0.03392086923122406, 0.062049586325883865, 0.024638334289193153, -0.046931345015764236, -0.035476744174957275, -0.05697954446077347, 0.018520822748541832, 0.02573595941066742, -0.062168870121240616, -0.044361505657434464, -0.007813210599124432, 0.036791879683732986, -0.0253886878490448, -0.006526607554405928, -0.012897860258817673, -0.06931030005216599, -0.0322473980486393, 0.030540527775883675, 0.03751185163855553, -0.015731163322925568, -0.050897300243377686, -0.01377495750784874, -0.009945515543222427, 0.03152790293097496, 0.049104802310466766, 0.05304255336523056, -0.053054049611091614, 0.026076901704072952, 0.059680450707674026, -0.023976221680641174, -0.014760041609406471, 0.0036510510835796595, 0.02734234556555748, -0.05310662463307381, 0.04737977683544159, 0.06566408276557922, 0.05167727544903755, 0.006897513754665852, -0.06434879451990128, -0.04824818670749664, 0.010273966006934643, -0.03618374094367027, 0.014337285421788692, 0.06096196547150612, 0.017656419426202774, 0.03589291125535965, -0.018405726179480553, -0.07865479588508606, -0.019547848030924797, -0.03765029087662697, -0.02524065226316452, -0.04124591872096062, -0.02558963932096958, -0.031483206897974014, -0.08527632057666779, 0.001484238775447011, -0.03780755400657654, -0.06084803491830826, -0.04071730747818947, -0.06294367462396622, -0.04770835116505623, -0.029555028304457664, 0.044585324823856354, 0.009443270042538643, -0.047639768570661545, 0.02180527150630951, 0.023132212460041046, -0.021899404004216194, 0.05011807754635811, -0.059746887534856796, -0.06741850078105927, -0.01710135117173195, 0.01587075926363468, 0.013477650471031666, -0.014636510983109474, 0.029748359695076942, 0.000183419935638085, 0.0417446568608284, 0.01694175787270069, 0.0369771383702755, 0.021052608266472816, 0.029147179797291756, 0.028867550194263458, 0.004564897157251835, -0.01870916038751602, -0.019352128729224205, 0.0003087851800955832, -0.06295471638441086, -0.04245626926422119, -0.044174373149871826, 0.04391470551490784, -0.02310684695839882, -0.05284740775823593, -0.03790929540991783, -0.009875564835965633, 0.0336708202958107, 0.018910473212599754, 0.011017884127795696, 0.010428078472614288, 0.04955847188830376, 0.002903660060837865, -0.04847417771816254, -0.013162166811525822, 0.01218264177441597, 0.005029699765145779, 0.029841257259249687, -0.07007314264774323, -0.008913940750062466, 0.058991532772779465, -0.08652788400650024, 0.04401402175426483, 0.021190153434872627, 0.06856025755405426, -0.010474041104316711, 0.02097065933048725, 0.014904788695275784, 0.020863447338342667, 0.04525459557771683, 0.0060918303206563, 0.012290175072848797, -0.0010983477113768458, 0.06411726027727127, -0.05348172038793564, -0.030738743022084236, -0.004068576730787754, -0.06953368335962296, -0.04115570709109306, 0.01790676824748516, -0.001988764386624098, 0.041898004710674286, 0.03472393751144409, -0.048189520835876465, 0.0022673222701996565, 0.004600096493959427, 0.018331322818994522, 0.02235710620880127, -0.037092842161655426, 0.04131454974412918, -0.05656322091817856, 0.014703154563903809, 0.023991411551833153, -0.04195491597056389, -0.02608400769531727, -0.012163817882537842, 0.002916082041338086, -0.02325073815882206, 0.06766200065612793, 0.05050446465611458, -0.03897247835993767, 0.02019556798040867, 0.021408462896943092, -0.04495813325047493, 0.07160167396068573, -0.0029839493799954653, -0.03786672279238701, -0.03824169188737869, -0.010167257860302925, -0.002694604452699423, 0.029505498707294464, -0.05945896729826927, -0.024676762521266937, 0.003813197137787938, -0.031174270436167717, -0.027243994176387787, -0.013424340635538101, 0.013329712674021721, 0.0007489380659535527, -0.0871938094496727, 0.01769123785197735, -0.015979692339897156, 0.02731473743915558, 0.031606175005435944, -0.04889795184135437, 0.052706457674503326, -0.05741003528237343, -0.04365776851773262, -0.02300131879746914, -0.0021949978545308113, -0.05808509886264801, -0.038232091814279556, 0.009261766448616982, -0.07280237972736359, 0.05819110944867134, -0.06672312319278717, 0.012899150140583515, -0.016256868839263916, 0.03705223649740219, -0.0204971544444561, -0.001629801350645721, -0.008544142358005047, 0.02530667744576931, 0.05405847355723381, 0.02466423436999321, -0.010829064063727856, -0.015278163366019726, 0.02493365667760372, -0.019729986786842346, 0.003128949785605073, -0.022330638021230698, -0.03262273222208023, 0.027393249794840813, -0.03060421347618103, -0.026783401146531105, 0.013018326833844185, -0.021932004019618034, 0.04159829393029213, -0.054070863872766495, -0.011039885692298412, -0.0431508868932724, 0.02287069335579872, -0.046616073697805405, -0.06109486520290375, -0.034865085035562515, -0.05614018067717552, -0.056126587092876434, -0.018419282510876656, 0.0586400106549263, 0.024401560425758362, -0.011143987067043781, 0.021346203982830048, -0.0009417046676389873, 0.04461204260587692, 0.012165187858045101, -0.014776257798075676, 0.02925337478518486, -0.03907874971628189, 0.004397915676236153, -0.014327284879982471, -0.05725455284118652, -0.0207279771566391, -0.01060004997998476, -0.0068784900940954685, -0.012178822420537472, 0.03511621803045273, 0.011854556389153004, 0.08128612488508224, -0.07449564337730408, 0.014618749730288982, 0.0463733971118927, 0.0016316375695168972, 0.029097985476255417, 0.061226896941661835, -0.00915888324379921, 0.040239039808511734, -0.013712599873542786, 0.026148660108447075, -0.014579011127352715, -0.008637511171400547, 0.033530689775943756, 0.008104311302304268, 0.022862033918499947, -0.024570558220148087, 0.04809069260954857, -0.017567211762070656, -0.06069641560316086, 0.04734353348612785, 0.03803460672497749, 0.03687997907400131, -0.0021900131832808256, 0.021511761471629143, 0.03833054378628731, -0.04653742536902428, -0.03215322270989418, -0.04219585657119751, -0.006189123727381229, -0.00658303452655673, -0.006083208601921797, -0.028888344764709473, 0.03719396889209747, 0.04252009838819504, 0.002038489328697324, 0.033797524869441986, -0.008359642699360847, 0.021463831886649132, 0.00399833545088768, -0.016608091071248055, 0.03710700944066048, -0.04391517862677574, -0.006489701569080353, -0.03865722939372063, 0.04691873863339424, 0.048633210361003876, 0.01774079166352749, -0.0063156746327877045, 0.013108298182487488, 0.01266527734696865, 0.009809507988393307, -0.014642740599811077, -0.011403237469494343, 0.025738252326846123, -0.06487541645765305, 0.02588404156267643, 0.025417892262339592, 0.039058618247509, 0.05262279137969017, 0.02015009894967079, -0.009731327183544636, 0.0052081816829741, -0.026690468192100525, -0.010390399023890495, 0.014341294765472412, -0.04614339396357536, -0.03970777243375778, 0.007292216178029776, 0.008588519878685474, -0.0014280297327786684, 0.01722993142902851, 0.023587197065353394, -0.007330505643039942, 0.0410262830555439, 0.02020948939025402, -0.043903645128011703, -0.042758140712976456, -0.034000031650066376, 0.06566881388425827, -0.05077364668250084, -0.011532124131917953, -0.032450176775455475, -0.03219027444720268, -0.03695310279726982, -0.04470658302307129, 0.018836013972759247, 0.0370316244661808, 0.012164677493274212, -0.03506024181842804, 0.0629161074757576, -0.014858158305287361, -0.06537948548793793, 0.05116543173789978, 0.008525766432285309, -0.07453636080026627, 0.01844155788421631, 0.01861114241182804, 0.05467473715543747, -0.04018602892756462, 0.05207536742091179, 0.00902586244046688, 0.016719713807106018, -0.012989887967705727, 0.07710063457489014, 0.08493310958147049, -0.05615196377038956, 0.012947505339980125, 0.03708786144852638, -0.05931884050369263, 0.008023764938116074, -0.017368817701935768, 0.011610683985054493, -0.003932802937924862, 0.0402243472635746, -0.016407854855060577, -0.05870984494686127, -0.012712270952761173, 0.06197300925850868, -0.024129653349518776, 0.005091758444905281, -0.004057636484503746, -0.03358732908964157, 0.0468384325504303, -0.052317675203084946, -0.04601489007472992, 0.007689421996474266, 0.009623320773243904, -0.01499165128916502, -0.03396111726760864, -0.04009544476866722, -0.023548969998955727, 0.03562909737229347, -0.027374329045414925, -0.07047139108181, 0.032414063811302185, -0.012956197373569012, -0.0789547711610794, -0.013559451326727867, -0.04417966678738594, 0.014983239583671093, -0.04838928207755089, 0.013651453889906406, 0.02193254418671131, 0.061603985726833344, -0.0322863794863224, -0.0582832396030426, -0.0008455644128844142, 0.03560800850391388, -0.01058132667094469, -0.04497036710381508, -0.009568648412823677, -0.051780980080366135, 0.038423143327236176, -0.02455904334783554, -0.04215948283672333, -0.02291969209909439, -0.046648044139146805, -0.007389552425593138, 0.03388218581676483, 0.016576655209064484, -0.021517863497138023, -0.011316386982798576, -0.025247722864151, 0.005264956504106522, 0.04271050915122032, -0.042499832808971405, -0.058929942548274994, 0.0009776492370292544, 0.039479948580265045, -0.00613211328163743, 0.008820309303700924, 0.03118634782731533, 0.05740517005324364, -0.018475811928510666, 0.0004021740169264376, 0.004705850966274738, 0.029227731749415398, 0.04380558058619499, -0.05308406800031662, -0.02049286663532257, 0.019126374274492264, -0.06550183147192001, -0.02284427173435688, -0.018604466691613197, -0.004185076802968979, -0.06555230915546417, -0.014717145822942257, 0.07022876292467117, -0.024110309779644012, 0.030248308554291725, -0.053262803703546524, 0.0317898653447628, 0.014000488445162773, -0.050123121589422226, -0.0463675782084465, 0.0018509224755689502, -0.020752932876348495, -0.03974918648600578, -0.03487545996904373, -0.036850184202194214, -0.05528058856725693, -0.0034270642790943384, -0.0839880108833313, 0.01908680610358715, 0.018265681341290474, 0.03330688551068306, -0.012297099456191063, -0.007917781360447407, -0.038709256798028946, -0.028119845315814018, 0.02289593406021595, -0.020936643704771996, 0.03314657136797905, 0.035192929208278656, -0.007196705788373947, 0.04229477420449257, -0.05357206240296364, 0.015621487982571125, 0.024269504472613335, -0.04692155122756958, 0.02292252704501152, 0.007233132608234882, 0.03924031928181648, 0.032228171825408936, 0.04473806545138359, 0.044880058616399765, -0.04248437285423279, 0.017878510057926178, -0.0365573912858963, 0.04599156230688095, -0.035814277827739716, -0.05060504004359245, 0.042695268988609314, -0.03111424297094345, -0.02474779449403286, 0.023098420351743698, -0.021617744117975235, 0.02400534227490425, -0.01952298730611801, -0.05492619052529335, 0.03434319049119949, -0.011969760060310364, 0.010100769810378551, 0.05982941761612892, -0.006445139180868864, -0.03523943945765495, -0.01901300996541977, -0.03444909676909447, -0.007729182951152325, 0.04893394932150841, 0.042559318244457245, -0.0613195039331913, -0.0021274592727422714, -0.06241273880004883, 0.015771469101309776, -0.025830617174506187, 0.007707575336098671, -0.010157487355172634, 0.05965196341276169, -0.004679874517023563, 0.003887265222147107, -0.017833637073636055, -0.015550903975963593, -0.02075648121535778, -0.07511727511882782, -0.05108767747879028, -0.04144975170493126, 0.038349591195583344, -0.002568743424490094, 0.028962358832359314, 0.030597927048802376, 0.046015363186597824, 0.01307945791631937, 0.003569667926058173, 0.030057474970817566, 0.017977414652705193, -0.06409386545419693, 0.06916245073080063, 0.026467645540833473, -0.007153753191232681, -0.0277643334120512, -0.021093523129820824, 0.009389277547597885, -0.009445838630199432, 0.03772156685590744, -0.00808730535209179, 0.0365770123898983, -0.06197601556777954, 0.016907377168536186, 0.024508297443389893, 0.008966956287622452, -0.01687511056661606, -0.022419603541493416, -0.0008340765489265323, -0.026821523904800415, -0.011776304803788662 ]
Exhibiting an explicit Boolean function with a large high-order nonlinearity is an important problem in cryptography, coding theory, and computational complexity. We prove lower bounds on the second-order, third-order, and higher-order nonlinearities of some trace monomial Boolean functions. We prove lower bounds on the second-order nonlinearities of functions $\mathrm{tr}_n(x^7)$ and $\mathrm{tr}_n(x^{2^r+3})$ where $n=2r$. Among all trace monomials, our bounds match the best second-order nonlinearity lower bounds by \cite{Car08} and \cite{YT20} for odd and even $n$ respectively. We prove a lower bound on the third-order nonlinearity for functions $\mathrm{tr}_n(x^{15})$, which is the best third-order nonlinearity lower bound. For any $r$, we prove that the $r$-th order nonlinearity of $\mathrm{tr}_n(x^{2^{r+1}-1})$ is at least $2^{n-1}-2^{(1-2^{-r})n+\frac{r}{2^{r-1}}-1}- O(2^{\frac{n}{2}})$. For $r \ll \log_2 n$, this is the best lower bound among all explicit functions.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11229v1
[ -0.036614976823329926, -0.05970947816967964, 0.04383115470409393, 0.00320232892408967, 0.022359037771821022, -0.040570784360170364, -0.062025342136621475, 0.04258883744478226, -0.0195598341524601, -0.02762048877775669, -0.028879314661026, -0.0496966615319252, -0.01739337481558323, -0.00514602568000555, -0.020083166658878326, -0.040650755167007446, 0.06653492897748947, 0.041514333337545395, -0.03936702013015747, 0.07030841708183289, -0.014516029506921768, -0.05176025629043579, -0.032880887389183044, 0.0579671673476696, -0.022959670051932335, -0.023541292175650597, -0.06568720191717148, -0.045737333595752716, -0.01685834676027298, -0.03244546800851822, 0.04523839056491852, -0.05385013297200203, 0.024803878739476204, -0.04304458945989609, 0.038618747144937515, -0.015834830701351166, 0.007852399721741676, 0.02213718369603157, 0.051526378840208054, -0.030017007142305374, 0.013128474354743958, -0.05624687671661377, -0.05535629764199257, -0.06425726413726807, -0.03925958648324013, -0.015398608520627022, -0.012779143638908863, -0.050957586616277695, -0.054949820041656494, -0.048126544803380966, 0.0630437508225441, 0.010096777230501175, -0.007484177593141794, 0.0412176288664341, -0.003930454608052969, -0.024358408525586128, 0.015592940151691437, -0.05699757859110832, -0.061425160616636276, -0.0025286602322012186, 0.005339420400559902, -0.023216761648654938, -0.02970387600362301, -0.021259278059005737, -0.03611183911561966, 0.011074380949139595, -0.02661253698170185, -0.057926055043935776, -0.010356458835303783, -0.04197205603122711, 0.008520549163222313, -0.035257671028375626, 0.0034830200020223856, -0.018764454871416092, -0.0678117424249649, -0.008612521924078465, -0.03217250853776932, 0.017895670607686043, -0.03508778661489487, 0.019239850342273712, -0.03680466115474701, 0.019155310466885567, -0.02621982991695404, -0.04538877680897713, 0.00998095702379942, -0.02371123433113098, 0.05553465336561203, 0.0003306905855424702, 0.022782834246754646, -0.06845144182443619, -0.013621400110423565, -0.05275711789727211, -0.06828232109546661, -0.038208577781915665, -0.017518021166324615, -0.04267266020178795, 0.05083737522363663, 0.020913150161504745, 0.042787548154592514, -0.005833783652633429, 0.011347013525664806, -0.06843388080596924, -0.02638365887105465, 0.019464945420622826, 0.02990865148603916, -0.00929422676563263, -0.01544642448425293, -0.011721956543624401, -0.03059159219264984, 0.0518876388669014, -0.011625530198216438, -0.01893242821097374, -0.04370175302028656, -0.04315906763076782, -0.04340342432260513, -0.045632973313331604, 0.020974691957235336, 0.0528864786028862, 0.04343816637992859, -0.015237687155604362, -0.0037490162067115307, 0.0326036661863327, -0.005611763335764408, -0.04060332104563713, -0.06133180484175682, -0.02352692000567913, -0.007753830403089523, 0.03777254745364189, 0.008939775638282299, 0.02581722103059292, 0.0011884454870596528, -0.016045143827795982, 0.040734682232141495, -0.020349426195025444, 0.058823518455028534, 0.011459332890808582, -0.03666513040661812, -0.03481939807534218, 0.016708992421627045, -0.017044613137841225, -0.04947424307465553, -0.05779094994068146, 0.054243527352809906, -0.016155477613210678, -0.02621294930577278, 0.05913630872964859, -0.05366341024637222, 0.04435238242149353, 0.00823172740638256, 0.006579967215657234, 0.019696082919836044, -0.002310162177309394, -0.009260298684239388, 0.006187422666698694, 0.022629031911492348, 0.0033768117427825928, 0.03911034017801285, 0.00307343527674675, -0.063679538667202, -0.0023707824293524027, 0.04945465922355652, -0.0033550257794559, -0.0431525819003582, 0.021905329078435898, -0.001172554213553667, 0.032377008348703384, 0.025852056220173836, 0.0001367975928587839, 0.045342817902565, 0.013051813468337059, -0.05649370700120926, 0.0024816934019327164, 0.03229363262653351, -0.056732177734375, -0.06611999869346619, -0.04075608402490616, -0.022735655307769775, -0.06173962354660034, -0.045260071754455566, -0.04526901990175247, -0.004628115799278021, -0.024170083925127983, -0.022973112761974335, 0.022909538820385933, -0.030279740691184998, 0.052267976105213165, -0.06728316098451614, 0.027272753417491913, 0.059250134974718094, 0.022231632843613625, 0.040676217526197433, -0.019655946642160416, 0.040534716099500656, -0.013194392435252666, -0.010514541529119015, -0.0515563040971756, 0.0030881112907081842, -0.04161342978477478, -0.040998876094818115, 0.02631371282041073, -0.07101496309041977, -0.03620443120598793, -0.005829550325870514, 0.02777472510933876, 0.00796931516379118, -0.06275076419115067, 0.00980067066848278, 0.03812357783317566, -0.04171666502952576, -0.03859328106045723, 0.06611815094947815, 0.024359440430998802, 0.03481968492269516, -0.01735246554017067, -0.022299228236079216, -0.0351480208337307, -0.07712461054325104, 0.06280805915594101, 0.01037854515016079, -0.03319750726222992, -0.0058853039517998695, -0.036829445511102676, -0.012498472817242146, -0.029575999826192856, -0.04219779744744301, 0.03937383368611336, 0.03832147270441055, -0.029310103505849838, -0.05361006408929825, 0.005470813252031803, -0.016164900735020638, -0.05511583015322685, -0.02554500848054886, -0.06586086004972458, 0.01055506244301796, -0.03217773139476776, -0.02228395827114582, 0.05510280653834343, -0.05329927057027817, -0.016439326107501984, -0.049630146473646164, -0.021566826850175858, 0.024248652160167694, 0.04432385042309761, -0.03403373062610626, -0.02897222340106964, -0.0437355674803257, -0.03968869522213936, -0.02530084177851677, -0.014823639765381813, 0.019936656579375267, -0.021415067836642265, -0.05827585607767105, -0.024912606924772263, 0.008957506157457829, 0.012833339162170887, -0.022063305601477623, 0.029651429504156113, 0.011199211701750755, 0.05095308646559715, -0.019961964339017868, -0.010202660225331783, -0.00471064168959856, -0.017587747424840927, -0.0029520646203309298, -0.02787950076162815, -0.0348491370677948, 0.007157159969210625, 0.0008377608028240502, 0.010292859748005867, -0.04612978175282478, 0.005898572504520416, 0.05498182401061058, -0.035968247801065445, -0.022172821685671806, -0.02524871751666069, -0.03960072994232178, -0.0058671566657722, 0.04163512587547302, 0.009815840050578117, 0.03136606514453888, 0.02085702493786812, -0.033386144787073135, -0.06655912846326828, -0.026201589033007622, 0.014204933308064938, -0.03825916349887848, -0.06433285027742386, 0.011593534611165524, -0.01593230850994587, -0.06517301499843597, 0.03255012631416321, -0.05073077231645584, -0.043346285820007324, -0.060336049646139145, -0.06694617867469788, -0.057249244302511215, 0.03640466928482056, 0.030994286760687828, -0.06433725357055664, -0.038184698671102524, -0.004691429901868105, 0.018961982801556587, 0.04145605117082596, -0.0036339787766337395, -0.04317554831504822, -0.05191425606608391, -0.04504851996898651, 0.013792028650641441, -0.03536652401089668, -0.06041070818901062, -0.005534713622182608, -0.050742167979478836, 0.0010849364334717393, 0.020523661747574806, 0.02549278549849987, 0.02615378051996231, -0.028079522773623466, -0.005325039848685265, -0.01984836906194687, -0.030576685443520546, -0.02735959179699421, -0.014165480621159077, -0.03647996857762337, -0.027265362441539764, -0.044613663107156754, 0.0552717000246048, 0.03751472383737564, -0.03197212889790535, -0.058173783123493195, -0.04436637461185455, -0.0012848596088588238, 0.024406302720308304, -0.029875515028834343, 0.04267723485827446, -0.005990850273519754, -0.026530856266617775, -0.05401206389069557, -0.04221910238265991, 0.035596076399087906, 0.017458809539675713, 0.04038800671696663, 0.0495976023375988, -0.017100032418966293, 0.028679871931672096, -0.07474227994680405, 0.06254671514034271, 0.034750789403915405, 0.06873015314340591, -0.04118610918521881, -0.03634083643555641, 0.015168152749538422, 0.018239205703139305, -0.016780829057097435, -0.05048106610774994, -0.011802654713392258, 0.061825428158044815, 0.025386415421962738, -0.0010279840789735317, -0.057226795703172684, 0.007373906206339598, -0.04086751863360405, 0.021848363801836967, 0.01945502683520317, -0.02457188442349434, 0.008409754373133183, 0.016827642917633057, -0.02062375098466873, -0.016947682946920395, -0.02843504585325718, 0.0031250857282429934, 0.02148573473095894, -0.012374957092106342, 0.029385296627879143, -0.023910710588097572, -0.010738521814346313, 0.03384407237172127, 0.01728901080787182, 0.0466131754219532, -0.06594614684581757, -0.016367793083190918, -0.06333144754171371, 0.019492564722895622, 0.03385693579912186, -0.06482309103012085, -0.034241847693920135, -0.012397518381476402, -0.014191112481057644, 0.03834478184580803, -0.03143162280321121, -0.007844686508178711, 0.0266815647482872, 0.02211660146713257, 0.020801903679966927, 0.0008751580026000738, -0.02169128879904747, -0.02166973240673542, 0.046889528632164, -0.06260326504707336, -0.008835582993924618, 0.03199814632534981, 0.025362113490700722, 0.021664604544639587, -0.07083285599946976, -0.03246186673641205, -0.04839044809341431, -0.0395599864423275, -0.0368351936340332, -0.05321640893816948, 0.05682823807001114, -0.022495277225971222, -0.04744810238480568, -0.03928687795996666, -0.015992077067494392, 0.0012752166949212551, -0.04426413029432297, -0.0694013386964798, -0.040703415870666504, -0.02433105930685997, -0.0058541749604046345, -0.0020613442175090313, -0.015013688243925571, -0.03033643215894699, -0.04537218436598778, 0.00420089578256011, 0.006445576902478933, 0.03897662088274956, 0.04543524980545044, 0.0510622076690197, 0.055169347673654556, 0.020663196220993996, 0.02542921155691147, -0.03696189448237419, -0.058195605874061584, -0.02223043330013752, -0.052486687898635864, 0.029598450288176537, -0.039284490048885345, -0.003304216777905822, -0.030112851411104202, 0.023854339495301247, 0.05434807389974594, -0.042466964572668076, -0.008685695007443428, -0.014638489112257957, 0.027476651594042778, -0.06348422914743423, -0.05030461773276329, -0.01841099001467228, -0.036069709807634354, -0.04673443362116814, 0.004626687150448561, 0.010594865307211876, 0.02767794020473957, -0.05435007065534592, 0.022779911756515503, 0.003561628283932805, -0.029324330389499664, -0.046668797731399536, -0.023982176557183266, 0.03998948261141777, 0.0012947078794240952, -0.02278044819831848, 0.02000994235277176, -0.07159014046192169, -0.02442064695060253, -0.02184302732348442, -0.001785280299372971, 0.03628722205758095, 0.03267892077565193, -0.01791498251259327, 0.06158506125211716, -0.06790611147880554, -0.0052620163187384605, 0.04670264199376106, -0.03178815543651581, -0.029101505875587463, -0.024777689948678017, -0.028027689084410667, 0.0035150598268955946, -0.020182207226753235, 0.015267526730895042, 0.022329453378915787, 0.01109008677303791, -0.031155386939644814, -0.035574011504650116, -0.044627971947193146, -0.026690930128097534, 0.01640905626118183, 0.029782863333821297, -0.015022270381450653, -0.04318707808852196, 0.03693663701415062, 0.03013502061367035, -0.05405827984213829, 0.046702854335308075, 0.0396624319255352, -0.04789164662361145, -0.03466110676527023, -0.04257945716381073, 0.02414756827056408, 0.01454797200858593, 0.02475641295313835, -0.02398448809981346, 0.002079525263980031, -0.014163498766720295, -0.02760792337357998, -0.04573784023523331, 0.05275807902216911, 0.011947515420615673, -0.05867511034011841, -0.026545869186520576, -0.03694721311330795, -0.04373571649193764, -0.02770114876329899, -0.00670789647847414, 0.012038304470479488, 0.043666791170835495, -0.031121648848056793, 0.031901855021715164, 0.0009759041131474078, -0.036335788667201996, -0.03030959703028202, -0.04949662834405899, -0.03712904080748558, 0.03636331483721733, -0.04688918590545654, 0.004302221816033125, -0.03283213824033737, 0.014698811806738377, -0.013262661173939705, -0.019083358347415924, -0.03988184407353401, -0.01971427910029888, -0.06342785060405731, 0.02740679495036602, 0.04269576445221901, -0.010837607085704803, -0.029911033809185028, -0.01699846237897873, 0.01035191398113966, -0.049383968114852905, 0.02431541495025158, -0.008019017055630684, 0.02411784417927265, 0.0008661923347972333, 0.02339193783700466, 0.03928248584270477, -0.06282181292772293, -0.022605055943131447, 0.03127317130565643, -0.04711107537150383, -0.011145174503326416, -0.022028185427188873, -0.024109503254294395, -0.013952272944152355, -0.061962418258190155, -0.008989842608571053, 0.00863986648619175, 0.04228565841913223, -0.0481988899409771, 0.05476958677172661, -0.003279884112998843, -0.056524381041526794, 0.010976710356771946, 0.0015331542817875743, -0.03983168303966522, 0.03693578392267227, -0.017101919278502464, -0.04048372805118561, -0.03163920342922211, 0.0493629015982151, -0.02248041331768036, -0.05696168169379234, -0.023482073098421097, 0.028091339394450188, 0.06435123085975647, -0.04938246309757233, 0.03644653037190437, 0.05661596357822418, -0.012174472212791443, 0.029246069490909576, -0.03804304823279381, -0.04569447413086891, -0.0063093253411352634, 0.04116855561733246, 0.013126954436302185, -0.012885039672255516, -0.018507003784179688, 0.0447598397731781, 0.0011738586472347379, -0.048669736832380295, 0.015208380296826363, 0.012614519335329533, 0.03827290236949921, -0.010606694035232067, 0.0010236556408926845, 0.00010617529915180057, -0.0036272553261369467, -0.04764477536082268, -0.03623988479375839, 0.06412606686353683, -0.036810602992773056, -0.026508644223213196, -0.03856766223907471, -0.05075819045305252, -0.0076390705071389675, 0.0010640975087881088, -0.07086406648159027, -0.049757156521081924, -0.05934181809425354, -0.027261747047305107, 0.012333645485341549, 0.060143306851387024, -0.024196216836571693, 0.024959513917565346, -0.03536698967218399, -0.035699255764484406, -0.06633904576301575, 0.034216590225696564, -0.01006506197154522, 0.009307133965194225, 0.014699616469442844, -0.05125897377729416, 0.061725545674562454, -0.03640070557594299, 0.0386492945253849, 0.002735426649451256, -0.05112086981534958, 0.020936477929353714, 0.014541961252689362, -0.008873648010194302, -0.0023885960690677166, -0.02618156187236309, -0.055362947285175323, 0.019155094400048256, 0.009182152338325977, -0.002865122864022851, -0.07035757601261139, -0.017286136746406555, -0.014397306367754936, -0.023089105263352394, -0.0018878511618822813, -0.024878252297639847, 0.03604293242096901, -0.004066311754286289, 0.027236202731728554, 0.028520086780190468, 0.02913522720336914, -0.012188870459794998, -0.06985056400299072, -0.021293848752975464, -0.0015441825380548835, -0.06038380786776543, -0.005098104476928711, -0.005981500260531902, -0.06074509397149086, -0.046255990862846375, 0.008897142484784126, -0.017355630174279213, 0.03779793530702591, -0.047528792172670364, -0.06979500502347946, 0.049360089004039764, 0.02438436821103096, -0.012430552393198013, -0.06687967479228973, -0.005158460233360529, 0.028677944093942642, -0.0505937822163105, -0.01366947777569294, -0.03393977880477905, -0.06981030106544495, 0.025677137076854706, -0.07610438019037247, -0.01174744963645935, 0.01689734123647213, 0.02377750538289547, 0.03733418136835098, -0.01533915102481842, -0.06623432785272598, -0.057998739182949066, 0.00411269860342145, 0.01815297082066536, -0.01552089024335146, 0.04846613481640816, 0.011116454377770424, -0.024021558463573456, -0.0016400188906118274, 0.0006470382213592529, 0.0649014562368393, -0.02575051784515381, -0.04233242943882942, 0.039233382791280746, 0.0032823795918375254, -0.036450084298849106, 0.047329131513834, 0.06039642170071602, -0.03995302692055702, 0.04444246366620064, -0.03705825284123421, -0.00532055739313364, -0.056531865149736404, -0.046458881348371506, 0.023290783166885376, -0.06500308960676193, -0.012469209730625153, -0.028048137202858925, -0.04174784570932388, -0.04629023000597954, -0.034081991761922836, -0.03462308272719383, -0.02319606952369213, 0.007396094035357237, -0.03813384100794792, -0.04563914239406586, -0.01281014271080494, -0.00008253625128418207, -0.00937082339078188, -0.039948154240846634, -0.04277349263429642, -0.013310728594660759, 0.057506412267684937, -0.042058128863573074, -0.006817284040153027, -0.06258252263069153, 0.018058571964502335, -0.06389530003070831, -0.006786427926272154, 0.045603640377521515, 0.05708438903093338, 0.025123434141278267, 0.04071125388145447, -0.0037434049881994724, -0.02753276936709881, -0.023669997230172157, -0.062120694667100906, 0.0010746949119493365, -0.014982747845351696, 0.014772347174584866, 0.038962170481681824, 0.05080066993832588, 0.006132326554507017, 0.0327690951526165, 0.0032406842801719904, -0.029164476320147514, -0.01401850301772356, 0.008677154779434204, -0.03568079695105553, -0.002721107332035899, -0.0030604202765971422, -0.04330160841345787, -0.05903191119432449, 0.007848471403121948, 0.004049133509397507, -0.03910595178604126, -0.000660002464428544, -0.062484096735715866, 0.00501642469316721, -0.04254524037241936, 0.00935921911150217, 0.006594553589820862, 0.04767291620373726, -0.06677711755037308, 0.03715282306075096, -0.005289469379931688, 0.0020251453388482332, -0.03679204359650612 ]
Auxiliary data sources have become increasingly important in epidemiological surveillance, as they are often available at a finer spatial and temporal resolution, larger coverage, and lower latency than traditional surveillance signals. We describe the problem of spatial and temporal heterogeneity in these signals derived from these data sources, where spatial and/or temporal biases are present. We present a method to use a ``guiding'' signal to correct for these biases and produce a more reliable signal that can be used for modeling and forecasting. The method assumes that the heterogeneity can be approximated by a low-rank matrix and that the temporal heterogeneity is smooth over time. We also present a hyperparameter selection algorithm to choose the parameters representing the matrix rank and degree of temporal smoothness of the corrections. In the absence of ground truth, we use maps and plots to argue that this method does indeed reduce heterogeneity. Reducing heterogeneity from auxiliary data sources greatly increases their utility in modeling and forecasting epidemics.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16546v1
[ -0.01788484863936901, -0.047303903847932816, 0.04805998504161835, 0.01613752171397209, -0.011922867968678474, 0.01677781715989113, -0.0165999885648489, 0.004400134086608887, -0.0033824171405285597, -0.0057966518215835094, -0.050668466836214066, 0.010323555208742619, -0.0524614118039608, -0.0526856929063797, -0.026957061141729355, 0.004440878983587027, 0.07332319766283035, 0.01884227804839611, -0.05422085151076317, 0.06788436323404312, 0.008531334809958935, 0.0114287706092, -0.0031668657902628183, 0.028482437133789062, 0.0280894935131073, -0.039070259779691696, -0.012566694989800453, -0.01933160610496998, -0.019321423023939133, 0.03773423656821251, 0.03376103937625885, -0.04816816374659538, -0.0221859160810709, -0.0560983344912529, -0.03255782276391983, 0.02178160659968853, 0.015092005953192711, 0.038601893931627274, 0.0323762372136116, -0.025119824334979057, 0.025055287405848503, -0.05235647037625313, -0.010292615741491318, -0.040968719869852066, -0.06722358614206314, -0.0056915003806352615, -0.029172634705901146, -0.0036884837318211794, -0.048204731196165085, -0.03199838846921921, 0.04912962391972542, -0.02355174906551838, 0.0007613089983351529, 0.06310908496379852, -0.01625576615333557, -0.0115578668192029, -0.0061038704589009285, 0.010269488207995892, -0.06298168748617172, 0.0033951790537685156, 0.027925727888941765, 0.007846750319004059, 0.033132974058389664, -0.0007486806134693325, 0.025788595899939537, 0.046844180673360825, -0.014834156259894371, -0.07683867961168289, -0.03167171776294708, -0.029787858948111534, 0.02871571108698845, -0.06328494846820831, 0.03849215805530548, 0.03995605930685997, -0.07238834351301193, 0.025877555832266808, -0.02685113251209259, -0.003861816134303808, 0.006002215202897787, 0.004506758879870176, -0.024154504761099815, 0.011479070410132408, 0.023033013567328453, -0.00546608492732048, 0.011345808394253254, 0.010623561218380928, 0.05191841349005699, 0.00465396698564291, -0.009771553799510002, -0.04644327610731125, 0.025958437472581863, -0.05306867137551308, -0.06720142811536789, -0.03153879940509796, 0.06851743161678314, -0.017107563093304634, 0.055269189178943634, 0.04745674505829811, 0.04590357840061188, -0.021653633564710617, -0.03482432663440704, -0.012326453812420368, 0.0073456610552966595, 0.042822133749723434, 0.021535471081733704, -0.05545378848910332, -0.0004038635524921119, -0.04619204252958298, -0.04111818969249725, -0.002143895486369729, -0.03612702712416649, -0.019296783953905106, 0.020346852019429207, -0.05588690564036369, -0.07219382375478745, -0.046682942658662796, 0.04714139550924301, -0.022456465288996696, 0.04105958715081215, -0.017441526055336, -0.012904069386422634, 0.026157481595873833, 0.004036009777337313, 0.04220309853553772, -0.022377047687768936, 0.001907005556859076, 0.05898958072066307, 0.03189651668071747, -0.009709067642688751, -0.003964961040765047, -0.028555823490023613, 0.04096405580639839, -0.03646572306752205, -0.028723185881972313, 0.03200004994869232, 0.05366382747888565, 0.009441367350518703, -0.06003408879041672, 0.03302444890141487, 0.049174532294273376, 0.00546632707118988, -0.0581948347389698, 0.00026286294450983405, -0.026351306587457657, -0.010977869853377342, 0.021784819662570953, -0.07140617817640305, -0.02327168732881546, 0.050289709120988846, 0.033957209438085556, -0.008796659298241138, -0.03115997090935707, 0.044058606028556824, 0.025471065193414688, 0.029087522998452187, -0.029701383784413338, 0.05606304109096527, 0.016518838703632355, -0.033188216388225555, 0.018303677439689636, 0.02877064235508442, 0.0007204539724625647, 0.01628042757511139, 0.017911696806550026, 0.00953016895800829, 0.004482345189899206, 0.031006107106804848, 0.01376216858625412, -0.010049091652035713, -0.003732629818841815, -0.05472446233034134, -0.0031985787209123373, 0.004286519251763821, -0.048791687935590744, -0.05484725907444954, 0.011258726008236408, -0.006206704769283533, -0.03760889917612076, -0.019358808174729347, -0.03626375272870064, -0.024466248229146004, 0.04754325747489929, -0.027350006625056267, 0.008992848917841911, -0.007273651659488678, 0.026754150167107582, -0.08542058616876602, 0.016491418704390526, 0.045221198350191116, 0.0038853485602885485, -0.05875514820218086, -0.04854726418852806, 0.022135809063911438, -0.029640519991517067, -0.011814973317086697, -0.054287221282720566, -0.013584836386144161, -0.04510905593633652, 0.00048754928866401315, 0.01975560560822487, -0.07417263835668564, -0.04620903730392456, -0.08223540335893631, 0.02596411481499672, -0.030429381877183914, -0.05309761315584183, -0.013868638314306736, 0.021136881783604622, -0.011463701725006104, 0.04611559212207794, 0.04282637685537338, 0.04034946858882904, 0.039295829832553864, 0.02007790096104145, -0.021887538954615593, 0.019756725057959557, -0.09719349443912506, 0.04047831892967224, -0.02122204564511776, 0.03055884875357151, 0.006339491344988346, 0.004563318565487862, -0.0008018860244192183, -0.0204811692237854, -0.00044725468615069985, 0.028592227026820183, 0.04905784875154495, -0.0062233866192400455, -0.049140814691782, -0.06295444071292877, -0.05221889168024063, -0.047738153487443924, -0.05582671985030174, -0.04047289863228798, 0.013545842841267586, -0.055258553475141525, -0.0225994810461998, 0.02368202619254589, -0.012775381095707417, -0.0037352528888732195, -0.06580480188131332, -0.000849622767418623, 0.066706582903862, -0.02185267210006714, -0.04077797010540962, -0.022808078676462173, -0.017656957730650902, 0.015538295730948448, -0.027628619223833084, -0.003499669721350074, 0.02528652362525463, -0.06730378419160843, -0.010337203741073608, -0.03401848301291466, -0.0018645558739081025, 0.050754364579916, -0.050344374030828476, 0.010525685735046864, -0.029333606362342834, 0.04069652408361435, 0.012666822411119938, 0.02921253629028797, -0.06535865366458893, 0.008090154267847538, 0.023389773443341255, -0.006477856542915106, -0.0060522244311869144, -0.006871452089399099, 0.038548074662685394, -0.03743697330355644, -0.0053943763487041, 0.0014871266903355718, 0.06497637927532196, -0.03696521371603012, -0.009919819422066212, 0.013128121383488178, -0.026991097256541252, 0.004715817514806986, 0.0374646857380867, 0.034088898450136185, 0.04868767037987709, 0.007793801836669445, 0.024439601227641106, -0.07307200878858566, -0.02796173095703125, -0.048699285835027695, 0.023051593452692032, -0.06965065747499466, -0.060701604932546616, -0.008465960621833801, -0.07097715139389038, 0.002019071951508522, -0.009362083859741688, -0.03199984133243561, -0.046398598700761795, -0.046033866703510284, -0.04450634866952896, 0.000551930395886302, 0.06538136303424835, -0.013086788356304169, -0.05952708423137665, -0.034175511449575424, 0.039969876408576965, 0.0030720005743205547, -0.0038623602595180273, -0.04173188656568527, -0.05340953543782234, 0.023777330294251442, 0.04524533450603485, -0.010982487350702286, 0.0017817317275330424, 0.008752282708883286, -0.023087400943040848, 0.03128170222043991, -0.006108506582677364, -0.023912733420729637, -0.0003535938449203968, -0.024487154558300972, -0.001748804934322834, -0.010565293952822685, 0.04931376874446869, 0.03215738758444786, 0.023133976384997368, -0.0046404628083109856, -0.06933850049972534, -0.028184933587908745, 0.02906559221446514, -0.007079319562762976, -0.01271822676062584, -0.04086969792842865, 0.04138481989502907, 0.03247828781604767, -0.012902215123176575, 0.0014915384817868471, -0.014948209747672081, 0.04717576503753662, -0.05277407169342041, -0.04933394491672516, -0.0321136936545372, -0.006715185474604368, 0.011079560965299606, 0.06794168055057526, -0.04130267724394798, 0.012889151461422443, 0.03232773765921593, -0.0907660648226738, 0.042933423072099686, 0.020218931138515472, 0.07153312861919403, 0.060825739055871964, 0.027507152408361435, 0.04225451126694679, -0.008750330656766891, 0.0067765358835458755, -0.002595878206193447, 0.038294076919555664, 0.009896399453282356, 0.04863622412085533, -0.03283412382006645, -0.07643341273069382, 0.003233322873711586, -0.07356705516576767, -0.042771775275468826, 0.016247456893324852, -0.011854078620672226, 0.015220016241073608, 0.0330333337187767, -0.03997962176799774, 0.05314553901553154, -0.0447884127497673, 0.05047457292675972, 0.029672101140022278, -0.01924186199903488, 0.052412211894989014, -0.015650788322091103, 0.03505241498351097, -0.007983963936567307, 0.011456980369985104, 0.07321082800626755, -0.057272352278232574, 0.01425141841173172, -0.06605235487222672, 0.021970471367239952, 0.049795642495155334, -0.030552465468645096, 0.018149152398109436, 0.023176703602075577, -0.04957346245646477, 0.04483279213309288, 0.01068265363574028, -0.049290262162685394, -0.013725969940423965, 0.004961554892361164, -0.01629754528403282, -0.008704609237611294, -0.05821860954165459, -0.011259357444941998, 0.011827369220554829, -0.013484514318406582, 0.0043957591988146305, -0.006898478139191866, -0.03381828963756561, -0.0052877916023135185, -0.07060881704092026, 0.04537060111761093, -0.04574167728424072, 0.04787968099117279, -0.024965807795524597, -0.05959214270114899, 0.05317617207765579, -0.05302399769425392, -0.009511429816484451, -0.06972376257181168, -0.0077851638197898865, -0.04472114518284798, -0.014350876212120056, 0.005722000729292631, -0.06613557040691376, 0.029522789642214775, -0.05086713284254074, 0.0576150044798851, 0.010529591701924801, -0.009906885214149952, -0.010875697247684002, -0.012034818530082703, -0.025778930634260178, 0.02176554687321186, 0.023877762258052826, 0.03681354969739914, 0.01685470901429653, -0.0014800606295466423, -0.022808564826846123, -0.005824629683047533, 0.005982828792184591, -0.05810321122407913, -0.02379477769136429, 0.015261981636285782, -0.01610344648361206, -0.021984566003084183, -0.022591615095734596, -0.021182170137763023, 0.08031376451253891, -0.04619693383574486, -0.03238556906580925, 0.003330465406179428, 0.03650503233075142, -0.06524308025836945, -0.0715549886226654, -0.008792301639914513, -0.0157293900847435, -0.06571636348962784, -0.023419981822371483, 0.011204990558326244, 0.027081850916147232, -0.04025261849164963, 0.028260646387934685, 0.016636790707707405, 0.03800751268863678, -0.05649557337164879, -0.0015151570551097393, 0.007691014092415571, 0.021419065073132515, -0.006929146125912666, -0.05157942697405815, -0.058844488114118576, -0.030265560373663902, -0.023914759978652, -0.0069818925112485886, -0.024771807715296745, 0.028947198763489723, 0.02253207191824913, 0.017696917057037354, -0.06919724494218826, 0.0337756983935833, 0.053027164191007614, 0.0008861794485710561, 0.0441400520503521, 0.08442255854606628, -0.019122883677482605, 0.0355595238506794, -0.03758484125137329, 0.02864070050418377, 0.005211162846535444, -0.056023117154836655, 0.005719304550439119, 0.010765684768557549, -0.039242930710315704, -0.015490780584514141, 0.06417345255613327, -0.014391460455954075, -0.05283215269446373, 0.0021607601083815098, -0.010539243929088116, -0.020106306299567223, -0.02264770120382309, 0.00982626061886549, 0.028501052409410477, -0.04604930058121681, -0.06618396192789078, 0.006299320608377457, -0.032552316784858704, 0.04181034490466118, 0.027947187423706055, -0.042641907930374146, 0.011384678073227406, 0.04208061844110489, 0.014641962945461273, -0.008462107740342617, 0.022808223962783813, -0.0341491773724556, -0.018857188522815704, -0.01978050358593464, 0.034663181751966476, -0.056974269449710846, -0.01632978580892086, -0.0318433977663517, 0.04415915906429291, 0.05764608457684517, 0.03710144758224487, 0.026249416172504425, 0.002140303608030081, -0.037319064140319824, -0.01422482542693615, -0.025168372318148613, 0.014628381468355656, 0.0018194232834503055, -0.01406558696180582, 0.04470827057957649, 0.017368795350193977, 0.051916517317295074, 0.012914486229419708, 0.02097100391983986, -0.00458135548979044, -0.00886292103677988, -0.02007323130965233, 0.017030857503414154, 0.022708861157298088, 0.00029180600540712476, -0.057291850447654724, 0.03777259215712547, 0.040078550577163696, -0.03485206887125969, 0.04915773123502731, -0.011394430883228779, -0.012493216432631016, 0.02057485841214657, -0.005801554303616285, 0.019696040078997612, -0.0205316711217165, 0.03410956636071205, 0.07221688330173492, -0.012235110625624657, -0.0007786532514728606, -0.005927872844040394, 0.002999429125338793, -0.01425206195563078, -0.023972710594534874, 0.033672530204057693, 0.004404177889227867, 0.02205989882349968, -0.0573539137840271, 0.052378904074430466, 0.008893660269677639, -0.057670507580041885, -0.00076360406819731, -0.008874302729964256, -0.08479251712560654, 0.005770237185060978, 0.03066953457891941, 0.007681952323764563, 0.019422734156250954, 0.01845463551580906, -0.05237725377082825, -0.02082405984401703, -0.06250982731580734, 0.05550263822078705, 0.06816664338111877, -0.03139698505401611, 0.02923782356083393, -0.011158962734043598, -0.04711559787392616, 0.0015894550597295165, -0.02076674811542034, -0.0007176300277933478, -0.012047762982547283, -0.007085393648594618, 0.015280220657587051, -0.007798272650688887, -0.04027567431330681, 0.059642523527145386, -0.06074531376361847, -0.021513216197490692, 0.01099235936999321, -0.0041201296262443066, 0.07892461121082306, -0.019631629809737206, -0.05848834291100502, 0.004564342088997364, 0.0035446370020508766, 0.01520924735814333, -0.03526776283979416, -0.018578222021460533, 0.021996941417455673, 0.04444824159145355, -0.012818499468266964, -0.07196376472711563, 0.021130286157131195, -0.009624137543141842, -0.030773308128118515, 0.016762513667345047, -0.07965846359729767, 0.027636639773845673, 0.017165256664156914, 0.0342835895717144, 0.03146776556968689, 0.06472718715667725, -0.02611963450908661, 0.01997719518840313, 0.011295171454548836, -0.0014738448662683368, 0.014504182152450085, 0.014737153425812721, 0.040491506457328796, 0.03186693787574768, 0.05013054236769676, -0.053764570504426956, -0.053583793342113495, -0.04273652657866478, -0.02715822122991085, 0.056849077343940735, -0.038348693400621414, -0.052746545523405075, -0.054082468152046204, 0.05928618460893631, -0.03345896303653717, 0.0033744589891284704, 0.019175376743078232, -0.04343413934111595, -0.07505548745393753, -0.04396059364080429, -0.010442513972520828, -0.014083543792366982, 0.017451774328947067, 0.058702047914266586, 0.045043740421533585, -0.035084471106529236, 0.04388423264026642, 0.02581317164003849, 0.0007561914972029626, 0.01831609383225441, -0.05301789939403534, -0.0579744428396225, 0.011439536698162556, -0.00112459238152951, -0.03181794285774231, 0.005329325795173645, -0.03670179471373558, -0.07008092105388641, 0.010665174573659897, 0.052723322063684464, -0.024134017527103424, -0.0163884237408638, -0.06456594914197922, 0.013541469350457191, 0.011844148859381676, -0.024517958983778954, -0.06825321167707443, -0.008716496638953686, 0.0020304997451603413, 0.0037578935734927654, -0.03362759202718735, -0.041079722344875336, -0.047725189477205276, 0.02558247745037079, -0.07525565475225449, 0.0070427944883704185, -0.020010601729154587, 0.04875577613711357, -0.0141246123239398, -0.004931689240038395, -0.016491424292325974, -0.018192267045378685, 0.015738235786557198, -0.008825927041471004, 0.002921268343925476, 0.01541623193770647, 0.04194270819425583, -0.002131070476025343, -0.06002624332904816, -0.05510561168193817, 0.01450240146368742, -0.008180604316294193, 0.016170861199498177, 0.02710251323878765, 0.04675412178039551, -0.009066354483366013, -0.031574297696352005, 0.06974994391202927, 0.0011452416656538844, 0.04518250748515129, -0.05000460147857666, 0.009817667305469513, -0.03252233564853668, -0.03381894901394844, 0.032475560903549194, -0.044596437364816666, -0.011762194335460663, -0.016828950494527817, -0.012007659301161766, -0.0398518405854702, -0.04471410810947418, -0.06589893996715546, 0.059634748846292496, 0.012525648809969425, -0.045246053487062454, 0.043459661304950714, -0.019006431102752686, -0.009091227315366268, -0.044370342046022415, 0.006711987312883139, -0.035824235528707504, -0.005990217439830303, -0.0067853741347789764, -0.03456104174256325, -0.00338593777269125, -0.06027717888355255, 0.0025807239580899477, -0.011791613884270191, -0.004439082928001881, -0.030672989785671234, 0.06611942499876022, -0.0034290882758796215, -0.006041712127625942, -0.015038345009088516, -0.04581629857420921, -0.04438942298293114, -0.05304387956857681, -0.04815586656332016, -0.03952794149518013, 0.014235522598028183, 0.011004443280398846, 0.02571975253522396, -0.002530614146962762, 0.05362020432949066, 0.04191680997610092, 0.05260482802987099, 0.021585337817668915, 0.016943352296948433, -0.06369579583406448, 0.062423769384622574, 0.018014559522271156, 0.02074061706662178, -0.02997046709060669, 0.0038637984544038773, -0.025635451078414917, -0.02672366425395012, 0.004501728806644678, -0.0034493780694901943, 0.0024568543303757906, -0.07814554870128632, -0.006877387408167124, 0.021256685256958008, 0.006516332738101482, -0.05748621001839638, 0.0010576904751360416, 0.008444643579423428, -0.08000974357128143, -0.04100613296031952 ]
The ever-increasing computational and storage requirements of modern applications and the slowdown of technology scaling pose major challenges to designing and implementing efficient computer architectures. In this paper, we leverage the architectural balance principle to alleviate the bandwidth bottleneck at the L1 data memory boundary of a tightly-coupled cluster of processing elements (PEs). We thus explore coupling each PE with an L0 memory, namely a private register file implemented as Standard Cell Memory (SCM). Architecturally, the SCM is the Vector Register File (VRF) of Spatz, a compact 64-bit floating-point-capable vector processor based on RISC-V's Vector Extension Zve64d. Unlike typical vector processors, whose VRF are hundreds of KiB large, we prove that Spatz can achieve peak energy efficiency with a VRF of only 2 KiB. An implementation of the Spatz-based cluster in GlobalFoundries' 12LPP process with eight double-precision Floating Point Units (FPUs) achieves an FPU utilization just 3.4% lower than the ideal upper bound on a double-precision, floating-point matrix multiplication. The cluster reaches 7.7 FMA/cycle, corresponding to 15.7 GFLOPS-DP and 95.7 GFLOPS-DP/W at 1 GHz and nominal operating conditions (TT, 0.80V, 25^oC) with more than 55% of the power spent on the FPUs. Furthermore, the optimally-balanced Spatz-based cluster reaches a 95.0% FPU utilization (7.6 FMA/cycle), 15.2 GFLOPS-DP, and 99.3 GFLOPS-DP/W (61% of the power spent in the FPU) on a 2D workload with a 7x7 kernel, resulting in an outstanding area/energy efficiency of 171 GFLOPS-DP/W/mm^2. At equi-area, our computing cluster built upon compact vector processors reaches a 30% higher energy efficiency than a cluster with the same FPU count built upon scalar cores specialized for stream-based floating-point computation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10137v1
[ 0.023658497259020805, -0.021906796842813492, 0.04618779942393303, 0.034633852541446686, -0.029574278742074966, -0.008303269743919373, -0.03899623081088066, -0.006697508506476879, 0.01632522977888584, 0.006721640937030315, -0.0004951829323545098, 0.016107406467199326, -0.029013724997639656, -0.005030006170272827, -0.07380165159702301, -0.0029935098718851805, 0.03061281517148018, 0.05261256918311119, -0.06084762513637543, 0.06924272328615189, -0.018140092492103577, -0.02944744937121868, -0.052857737988233566, -0.02944323979318142, 0.029050832614302635, 0.001385764335282147, -0.028572337701916695, 0.035582561045885086, -0.04779824987053871, -0.020230591297149658, 0.03801216930150986, 0.03908699378371239, -0.021275682374835014, -0.029846683144569397, -0.010815250687301159, -0.026997150853276253, -0.004232850391417742, 0.039717018604278564, 0.03358195722103119, -0.039045605808496475, 0.04898630455136299, -0.005975932814180851, -0.05633397027850151, -0.036592479795217514, 0.014295329339802265, -0.0213168915361166, -0.07350317388772964, -0.011720292270183563, -0.04006907716393471, -0.0514138899743557, 0.07116194814443588, -0.010842335410416126, 0.018319271504878998, 0.08202829957008362, -0.018993647769093513, 0.018229762092232704, 0.0008307541138492525, 0.008534105494618416, 0.012429359368979931, -0.029637085273861885, 0.03296351060271263, -0.033353645354509354, -0.03765306994318962, -0.02521062269806862, -0.005399977322667837, 0.08437646925449371, 0.0010411852272227407, -0.054056163877248764, -0.003393229329958558, -0.017594458535313606, 0.03717585653066635, -0.043551232665777206, 0.05802253633737564, 0.03551790490746498, -0.05621911212801933, -0.050296053290367126, -0.044435061514377594, -0.0318593755364418, 0.02036537230014801, -0.03533520922064781, -0.018763212487101555, 0.011794932186603546, 0.028212638571858406, 0.04029129818081856, -0.0051554045639932156, -0.05923628807067871, 0.07261491566896439, -0.012999136000871658, 0.011551156640052795, -0.010129692032933235, 0.024143490940332413, -0.05295337364077568, -0.06810604780912399, 0.01778479851782322, 0.06633885204792023, 0.03204242140054703, 0.039406102150678635, 0.051504578441381454, 0.019268160685896873, 0.007279598154127598, -0.014112773351371288, -0.03301063925027847, -0.03274340555071831, 0.011737605556845665, -0.012230427004396915, 0.023505309596657753, -0.01181101705878973, 0.021940551698207855, -0.04609016701579094, 0.01791508123278618, -0.03562367707490921, 0.04046245291829109, -0.0339832529425621, -0.028177211061120033, -0.01772434450685978, -0.03178379312157631, 0.06310275942087173, 0.010561889037489891, 0.044239260256290436, 0.006904583424329758, -0.03215621039271355, 0.03496371582150459, 0.03654765337705612, 0.0056566339917480946, 0.03321342542767525, -0.031822483986616135, 0.034224554896354675, -0.04905727505683899, 0.01706351526081562, -0.018266895785927773, -0.04130050912499428, 0.0359283871948719, 0.02792624570429325, -0.018221095204353333, 0.03398818522691727, 0.0018783439882099628, -0.018920693546533585, -0.034058213233947754, 0.05076811835169792, 0.001518174889497459, -0.03877811133861542, -0.05192751809954643, 0.021863801404833794, -0.005886135157197714, 0.03228147327899933, 0.07541508972644806, -0.03565068542957306, -0.03729384019970894, 0.028901735320687294, 0.01869550719857216, -0.011145250871777534, -0.0019232475897297263, -0.026258695870637894, 0.014639671891927719, -0.02482464723289013, 0.05969515070319176, 0.029519308358430862, -0.023382971063256264, -0.03232969343662262, -0.02138729952275753, 0.013341321609914303, -0.03587552532553673, -0.032983288168907166, -0.001047038589604199, 0.03596064820885658, -0.03290153667330742, -0.01788070984184742, -0.013285281136631966, 0.05221916362643242, 0.03890202194452286, -0.05517401546239853, -0.03031250461935997, -0.016519734635949135, 0.016264773905277252, -0.06450322270393372, -0.006833404768258333, 0.040385618805885315, -0.03310931846499443, -0.016799161210656166, 0.015585709363222122, 0.02621685527265072, 0.029362045228481293, 0.01803715154528618, -0.018313759937882423, -0.05627946928143501, -0.04644768312573433, -0.06151318550109863, 0.019104253500699997, 0.030012713745236397, 0.002147509017959237, -0.01019361987709999, 0.005396015476435423, 0.006911472417414188, 0.018744219094514847, 0.016045326367020607, -0.02198554016649723, 0.014461461454629898, -0.06693273782730103, 0.012889510951936245, 0.008597325533628464, -0.09646958857774734, -0.05388845130801201, -0.04277961328625679, -0.013338235206902027, 0.06003156676888466, -0.05949437618255615, 0.04302911460399628, 0.024257875978946686, -0.03821441903710365, 0.0014820994110777974, 0.06367103010416031, 0.026280364021658897, 0.054438889026641846, 0.01845606043934822, 0.040042996406555176, -0.0211030300706625, -0.10188444703817368, -0.01381528377532959, -0.025615515187382698, 0.008886024355888367, 0.01511533372104168, 0.025234945118427277, -0.028461573645472527, -0.02386343665421009, -0.04446471109986305, 0.03068259358406067, 0.051593195647001266, 0.013722235336899757, -0.0026369066908955574, 0.030056359246373177, 0.011264858767390251, -0.05248219519853592, -0.037297457456588745, -0.07102609425783157, -0.0054449765011668205, 0.02700521983206272, -0.02628091536462307, 0.042872533202171326, -0.01917462982237339, -0.046393752098083496, -0.03474138677120209, -0.022442512214183807, 0.014871104620397091, -0.05689302086830139, -0.06794929504394531, -0.04351101815700531, -0.01222917065024376, 0.034587159752845764, -0.03857961669564247, -0.005572587251663208, -0.025649119168519974, -0.027060408145189285, -0.001293492503464222, -0.05007569491863251, 0.039510298520326614, 0.0233846977353096, -0.056481607258319855, 0.04535818472504616, -0.01952667348086834, 0.011746233329176903, 0.012737349607050419, 0.033276401460170746, -0.005792043171823025, 0.01443623099476099, -0.014907152391970158, 0.0294103492051363, -0.015777843073010445, 0.005009304732084274, -0.020574793219566345, -0.01725327968597412, -0.04276653006672859, 0.05611317232251167, 0.041699159890413284, 0.0012028674827888608, 0.030294256284832954, 0.023765597492456436, -0.026812098920345306, 0.007759233471006155, -0.018707573413848877, 0.06483305990695953, 0.06675565987825394, 0.004832147154957056, 0.02062435820698738, -0.06786920130252838, -0.006415695417672396, -0.021414298564195633, -0.027517830953001976, -0.08117014914751053, -0.05036073550581932, -0.04407018423080444, -0.03421062231063843, -0.0239203330129385, -0.007091666106134653, -0.03626786172389984, 0.047398682683706284, 0.022331329062581062, 0.006349180359393358, -0.02475048415362835, -0.007798424921929836, -0.060921188443899155, -0.05798632651567459, -0.03879846632480621, 0.036107394844293594, 0.03638211637735367, -0.00788016989827156, -0.05167226493358612, 0.013578162528574467, 0.02269771322607994, 0.0377255417406559, 0.0269313994795084, -0.009600331075489521, 0.001009713509120047, -0.032270289957523346, 0.002529673045501113, -0.02173229493200779, 0.06239895150065422, 0.021852882578969002, 0.03014831617474556, -0.013456893153488636, 0.010219699703156948, -0.05027235671877861, 0.006553731393069029, -0.00735928351059556, -0.06685467809438705, -0.046845801174640656, -0.05954432487487793, 0.03958363085985184, 0.03077981062233448, -0.02686474286019802, -0.000996083253994584, 0.021202484145760536, 0.012545169331133366, -0.0652509555220604, 0.01329971756786108, 0.038334961980581284, 0.03297032415866852, -0.001566146849654615, -0.03696143627166748, -0.03580690175294876, 0.008669606409966946, -0.0162412878125906, 0.03397060185670853, -0.0015390439657494426, -0.0415901280939579, 0.061234910041093826, -0.09051883965730667, 0.02311433106660843, 0.05661221966147423, 0.06526010483503342, -0.07031620293855667, 0.004333354998379946, 0.026607571169734, 0.06424169987440109, -0.007067863363772631, -0.02130207046866417, -0.035467639565467834, 0.05517464503645897, 0.06550870090723038, -0.030002715066075325, -0.037073906511068344, -0.024357503280043602, -0.0390223003923893, -0.036250825971364975, 0.017495354637503624, -0.021282579749822617, 0.0301459152251482, 0.01551069412380457, -0.023881224915385246, 0.02244674041867256, -0.04108178988099098, 0.058612287044525146, -0.006829895079135895, -0.06421168893575668, 0.0034171477891504765, -0.01603054068982601, 0.02275269851088524, -0.039428822696208954, -0.03617048263549805, 0.023096779361367226, -0.04357321187853813, 0.016429729759693146, -0.06416453421115875, 0.0325203575193882, -0.023276587948203087, -0.02224043570458889, 0.019991248846054077, -0.0011714519932866096, 0.013535866513848305, 0.045811351388692856, -0.0003724210546351969, -0.029884273186326027, 0.009283057413995266, -0.023010985925793648, 0.013325375504791737, 0.006679036654531956, -0.041341472417116165, 0.044931359589099884, 0.03867802023887634, 0.007520720828324556, -0.025445707142353058, 0.028436169028282166, -0.021809665486216545, -0.00888888444751501, -0.0804157555103302, 0.000831927580293268, -0.0604775995016098, 0.010337306186556816, -0.017121871933341026, -0.054565902799367905, 0.05021638423204422, -0.012524351477622986, -0.003943281713873148, -0.04063621163368225, -0.04297119751572609, -0.02447715774178505, -0.0188817847520113, -0.022300807759165764, -0.05550163984298706, 0.024240367114543915, -0.03851625323295593, 0.07287141680717468, -0.01889774203300476, -0.0022505978122353554, -0.03202856704592705, -0.015868788585066795, -0.011951426975429058, -0.0040343645960092545, -0.00476047582924366, -0.014189938083291054, -0.0654003843665123, -0.012456326745450497, -0.010471300221979618, 0.021391334012150764, -0.03374314680695534, 0.03158499673008919, -0.05612810701131821, 0.01673039421439171, -0.00719479052349925, -0.06748516112565994, 0.00797995738685131, 0.03979264944791794, 0.046405043452978134, -0.06334421783685684, 0.0014433179749175906, 0.04128077253699303, 0.026204844936728477, -0.02835969254374504, -0.03762126341462135, -0.03904499113559723, -0.0557573139667511, -0.01676793210208416, -0.04117553308606148, -0.011305585503578186, -0.006065215449780226, 0.005709945689886808, 0.057727985084056854, 0.023774893954396248, 0.010714830830693245, 0.0036815330386161804, 0.027770038694143295, 0.01734226383268833, -0.041960209608078, 0.0171000175178051, -0.008830376900732517, -0.07881027460098267, 0.02879134938120842, -0.007035552989691496, -0.04377417266368866, 0.0015037049306556582, -0.022767582908272743, -0.011777120642364025, -0.037056323140859604, -0.07483656704425812, 0.06393347680568695, 0.019283661618828773, -0.06290902942419052, -0.01398465596139431, 0.038356631994247437, 0.010189556516706944, 0.05591250956058502, 0.009794676676392555, -0.020194772630929947, 0.012735273689031601, -0.011887678876519203, -0.009917672723531723, 0.027562996372580528, -0.06614935398101807, 0.03469488024711609, 0.024955989792943, 0.003540253499522805, -0.01512997318059206, 0.005935625173151493, 0.04442010819911957, 0.004316619597375393, -0.007246155757457018, 0.044812511652708054, 0.03278322517871857, -0.008471360430121422, -0.049311794340610504, 0.025050969794392586, 0.008165651932358742, -0.026208914816379547, 0.05607705935835838, -0.011690227314829826, -0.0307281706482172, 0.0163896381855011, 0.0007573264301754534, 0.007811050396412611, 0.015124529600143433, 0.008928090333938599, -0.0022531456779688597, -0.015416685491800308, -0.03477873653173447, -0.056131117045879364, -0.024136463180184364, -0.030092284083366394, -0.027488986030220985, -0.04055221751332283, 0.041674982756376266, 0.019312439486384392, 0.018903039395809174, -0.0006702401442453265, -0.057101693004369736, -0.00963207520544529, -0.020318234339356422, 0.053650930523872375, -0.051871586591005325, -0.038528598845005035, -0.019547563046216965, 0.03274879604578018, 0.03890281543135643, 0.012225037440657616, 0.03349337726831436, 0.0004356089630164206, -0.03716345503926277, -0.0018757381476461887, 0.041640833020210266, -0.08276425302028656, -0.019954238086938858, -0.029169263318181038, 0.04905260354280472, -0.05372416973114014, 0.05921775475144386, 0.06412042677402496, -0.003123215399682522, 0.07489576190710068, 0.014049360528588295, -0.03585255891084671, -0.03362073004245758, 0.009074130095541477, 0.014708857983350754, -0.03495540842413902, 0.020328279584646225, -0.06018981337547302, -0.04120054468512535, -0.007707820739597082, 0.00024876176030375063, 0.04782872274518013, -0.0020744153298437595, -0.011129462160170078, -0.02049478515982628, 0.060027871280908585, 0.006378691177815199, -0.08235948532819748, 0.0033539547584950924, 0.07359310984611511, -0.07342631369829178, -0.02287999540567398, 0.019425926730036736, -0.05104205757379532, -0.02564898692071438, 0.015304814092814922, 0.03514786809682846, -0.03684355318546295, -0.032236482948064804, 0.04990539699792862, 0.02710191160440445, 0.017552537843585014, 0.03265366703271866, 0.016398867592215538, -0.07200150191783905, -0.017949804663658142, -0.027677573263645172, -0.037597764283418655, -0.018788600340485573, 0.0048386831767857075, -0.022248320281505585, -0.04406524449586868, -0.020762791857123375, 0.05982973054051399, -0.015908217057585716, -0.05435410514473915, 0.025001559406518936, 0.014991450123488903, -0.018315160647034645, -0.0764409750699997, -0.04812837019562721, 0.001757918973453343, -0.062104370445013046, 0.016022665426135063, -0.0103932349011302, 0.04703590273857117, -0.012608576565980911, 0.0626126155257225, -0.01863548532128334, -0.06614416837692261, 0.031476281583309174, -0.016139481216669083, -0.021040337160229683, 0.023737089708447456, -0.06262177228927612, -0.06082047149538994, 0.003777560545131564, -0.003956714645028114, -0.00250204186886549, 0.06834029406309128, -0.034279271960258484, -0.010279789566993713, -0.025435524061322212, 0.012857232242822647, -0.01916414126753807, -0.0267881378531456, 0.043094176799058914, -0.03490292653441429, 0.05061087757349014, -0.029978245496749878, -0.014042739756405354, 0.01897088624536991, -0.043204884976148605, -0.037533536553382874, 0.021387849003076553, -0.058352936059236526, -0.036229416728019714, -0.05106421187520027, -0.02206851728260517, 0.03089788742363453, -0.002903643762692809, -0.04974142462015152, -0.07539983093738556, -0.000781682669185102, 0.011232011951506138, -0.02866668440401554, 0.04336685314774513, 0.01811910606920719, -0.0013667093589901924, -0.04292638227343559, -0.021515842527151108, -0.015053805895149708, 0.011269896291196346, -0.016502011567354202, -0.06541087478399277, -0.03885766863822937, 0.012414631433784962, 0.001195014570839703, -0.027546819299459457, -0.040468763560056686, 0.03289705142378807, -0.08057864755392075, -0.030396273359656334, 0.04151717200875282, 0.0351550430059433, -0.004099640063941479, -0.04243159666657448, 0.026266135275363922, -0.023097636178135872, -0.03835161030292511, -0.05438658967614174, 0.04419812560081482, 0.0055092452093958855, 0.023527996614575386, 0.026243185624480247, 0.013330281712114811, -0.038521695882081985, -0.021374717354774475, -0.08023834228515625, -0.05476638302206993, 0.011261247098445892, 0.0257074236869812, 0.0035994830541312695, 0.0026537736412137747, -0.012192824855446815, -0.06671195477247238, 0.006132097449153662, 0.009097195230424404, -0.03623635694384575, -0.06009089574217796, 0.0071963719092309475, 0.00889225210994482, -0.055934593081474304, -0.013787467032670975, 0.0406605526804924, -0.028360677883028984, -0.0263699721544981, 0.040627799928188324, 0.0024820943363010883, -0.000012082484317943454, 0.011174066923558712, 0.07322543114423752, 0.01027729082852602, 0.05118967220187187, -0.020894089713692665, -0.025886213406920433, -0.04497235268354416, -0.022606492042541504, 0.020853063091635704, -0.06247187405824661, -0.01597459241747856, 0.04723871871829033, -0.009592315182089806, 0.024363206699490547, -0.019873755052685738, -0.05288894101977348, -0.0019683109130710363, 0.024805035442113876, -0.01044734101742506, 0.015724575147032738, -0.028861088678240776, -0.003688853234052658, -0.01997833140194416, -0.04735206067562103, -0.03576637804508209, 0.02368294447660446, 0.05846024677157402, -0.059761907905340195, 0.020360805094242096, -0.0323517769575119, -0.01807328872382641, -0.0049967775121331215, -0.015879305079579353, 0.00834286492317915, 0.05542914569377899, 0.03304658457636833, 0.01232614740729332, -0.07020457834005356, -0.06924902647733688, -0.034093499183654785, -0.06177828460931778, -0.021745853126049042, -0.04924273118376732, 0.024201028048992157, -0.007798176724463701, 0.027586419135332108, -0.061773430556058884, 0.053110700100660324, 0.03549317643046379, 0.014417161233723164, 0.008960613049566746, 0.060086362063884735, -0.06184633448719978, 0.0730632096529007, -0.007106088567525148, 0.02099473401904106, 0.03679678216576576, 0.045306187123060226, 0.011610339395701885, 0.010618298314511776, -0.033474355936050415, -0.027671054005622864, 0.02790735848248005, -0.02369781956076622, -0.03685970976948738, -0.018263256177306175, 0.021429242566227913, -0.04195324331521988, 0.002120773773640394, -0.040351852774620056, 0.0027904396411031485, -0.025439174845814705 ]
Many infrastructure managers have the goal to increase the capacity of their railway infrastructure due to an increasing demand. While methods for performance calculations of railway line infrastructure are already well established, the determination of railway junction capacity remains a challenge. This work utilizes the concept of queueing theory to develop a method for the capacity calculation of railway junctions, solely depending on their infrastructure layout along with arrival and service rates. The implementation of the introduced approach is based on advanced model-checking techniques. It can be used to decide which infrastructure layout to build, i.e. whether an overpass for the analysed railway junction is needed. The developed method hence addresses the need for fast and reliable timetable independent junction evaluation in the long-term railway capacity calculation landscape.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14351v1
[ 0.04191064462065697, -0.05554080754518509, 0.028205573558807373, 0.023358197882771492, -0.04632265493273735, -0.032187964767217636, -0.014338505454361439, -0.02777346782386303, 0.01048761885613203, -0.012145728804171085, -0.05804004892706871, 0.00352503452450037, -0.03986090049147606, -0.0313229113817215, -0.045257098972797394, 0.01018027774989605, 0.06884093582630157, -0.03527937829494476, -0.03387362137436867, 0.04787878692150116, -0.04869427904486656, 0.01642296090722084, 0.03715170919895172, 0.0025363685563206673, 0.02545456402003765, 0.0024704255629330873, -0.05998925864696503, -0.015130153857171535, -0.07360170036554337, 0.009675946086645126, 0.037921953946352005, -0.05166321620345116, -0.060643430799245834, -0.021066419780254364, -0.053563911467790604, 0.003043948207050562, -0.027569996193051338, 0.000560218992177397, 0.0474533811211586, -0.021955860778689384, -0.008584449999034405, -0.022555824369192123, -0.039643868803977966, 0.02798484079539776, -0.01738925836980343, -0.0011464240960776806, -0.008715610951185226, 0.022695457562804222, -0.06339047104120255, -0.032558802515268326, 0.012821430340409279, 0.004311955068260431, 0.003411349141970277, 0.045352958142757416, -0.019821031019091606, 0.006031746510416269, 0.006573393940925598, -0.0034377514384686947, -0.055493585765361786, -0.05267833173274994, -0.03249349817633629, 0.020972663536667824, -0.009634599089622498, 0.007324038073420525, 0.023921363055706024, 0.03945758938789368, -0.017789609730243683, -0.07952877134084702, -0.021222563460469246, -0.05267844349145889, 0.043972622603178024, -0.02955838106572628, 0.05685438588261604, -0.024590663611888885, -0.04453936964273453, -0.012377189472317696, -0.00830982718616724, -0.03703414276242256, 0.006340536754578352, -0.03369482606649399, -0.04304831847548485, 0.023125257343053818, 0.0433061383664608, 0.032851602882146835, -0.04216450825333595, -0.029882658272981644, 0.0430564284324646, 0.0249226875603199, 0.015180079266428947, -0.07699994742870331, 0.041988957673311234, 0.011248618364334106, -0.07064565271139145, -0.006037546321749687, 0.04994076117873192, 0.03370876982808113, 0.06091023236513138, 0.06393956393003464, -0.005100680980831385, -0.05414018779993057, -0.012781333178281784, -0.0280798077583313, -0.06772154569625854, 0.03669147193431854, 0.023117758333683014, -0.04792207479476929, 0.02235986478626728, 0.033663664013147354, -0.02361101098358631, -0.05138927325606346, -0.031073078513145447, -0.04533333703875542, 0.02002043090760708, -0.07255508750677109, -0.03904863819479942, -0.0017588480841368437, 0.07635325193405151, 0.01969313435256481, 0.028322426602244377, -0.01087645161896944, -0.04025496169924736, 0.009328784421086311, 0.06257491558790207, -0.009289843030273914, -0.05540311336517334, -0.024961061775684357, 0.04992114380002022, 0.036585498601198196, 0.019772905856370926, 0.020257949829101562, -0.030434556305408478, 0.03240078687667847, 0.01989920809864998, -0.06685321778059006, 0.058777984231710434, 0.02493400312960148, -0.006089063826948404, -0.06493969261646271, 0.06457112729549408, 0.007106775883585215, -0.038850508630275726, -0.0710667297244072, -0.011034921742975712, 0.0038954338524490595, 0.04360109940171242, 0.0660645142197609, -0.020427733659744263, -0.03425679728388786, -0.01630176603794098, 0.040994077920913696, 0.03843136876821518, -0.0002615715202409774, 0.03964099660515785, -0.021075498312711716, 0.026472343131899834, -0.028081854805350304, 0.02825198508799076, -0.01819148287177086, -0.029361005872488022, -0.005490178242325783, 0.020236214622855186, -0.03840547427535057, -0.017316065728664398, 0.008240850642323494, -0.014032863080501556, 0.03494212031364441, 0.01836961880326271, 0.027560535818338394, -0.026602094992995262, 0.041509002447128296, -0.015996702015399933, -0.02757706120610237, 0.013611450791358948, -0.05373978242278099, -0.014721822924911976, -0.034154247492551804, 0.029310865327715874, -0.04742051661014557, -0.026075312867760658, -0.023847004398703575, -0.03399067372083664, 0.010936581529676914, 0.005134883336722851, 0.006784211378544569, -0.04108814895153046, -0.02826722525060177, -0.08250883221626282, -0.013171214610338211, -0.023156944662332535, 0.020494846627116203, -0.03793894499540329, -0.027227766811847687, 0.004772747401148081, -0.006554130464792252, 0.0014268762897700071, -0.03971167653799057, 0.04090481251478195, -0.03280078247189522, 0.016648944467306137, 0.03544699028134346, -0.060554139316082, 0.005780510138720274, -0.051110051572322845, -0.01112874411046505, -0.04833453893661499, -0.07302775979042053, -0.012410472147166729, -0.020575614646077156, -0.06292089074850082, 0.01622486487030983, 0.02318008989095688, 0.043535467237234116, 0.0032081049866974354, -0.011263874359428883, 0.03912082314491272, 0.011325358413159847, -0.08955949544906616, -0.007395653054118156, 0.035109907388687134, 0.0045778946951031685, -0.02127472683787346, 0.0023700727615505457, -0.003959346562623978, -0.015193376690149307, -0.0020191040821373463, 0.06395141035318375, 0.04498818889260292, 0.0004989519366063178, -0.05162953585386276, 0.03841463848948479, -0.045314397662878036, -0.06404314190149307, -0.016560394316911697, -0.049741748720407486, -0.031430378556251526, -0.003011261345818639, -0.037825293838977814, 0.06395624577999115, 0.0340924933552742, -0.013096352107822895, -0.022400109097361565, -0.06608659774065018, 0.052747443318367004, -0.04740041121840477, -0.0464288704097271, -0.010675434954464436, -0.053689081221818924, 0.014649802818894386, -0.017233381047844887, -0.0020729892421513796, -0.04831107705831528, -0.04483940452337265, -0.006779574789106846, 0.03488845378160477, 0.015776896849274635, 0.04575272649526596, -0.032663214951753616, -0.02990882284939289, -0.020548643544316292, 0.01724798046052456, -0.04146978631615639, 0.02151893638074398, -0.04287877678871155, 0.03761913999915123, 0.032119281589984894, 0.005134465638548136, -0.008288886398077011, -0.004698002710938454, 0.038805656135082245, -0.05627206712961197, 0.022466663271188736, -0.025470811873674393, -0.007764677982777357, 0.012164446525275707, 0.06920038163661957, -0.03231533616781235, -0.017670873552560806, -0.006768197752535343, 0.012981057167053223, 0.05819682776927948, 0.020046912133693695, 0.01413001213222742, 0.0316239558160305, -0.06419387459754944, 0.02323901653289795, -0.017311586067080498, -0.018682055175304413, -0.07510765641927719, -0.061313048005104065, -0.04094473645091057, -0.034884341061115265, -0.023168489336967468, 0.020144080743193626, -0.0650615319609642, 0.0002005660062422976, -0.014356770552694798, 0.0031543723307549953, 0.004229661542922258, 0.05291292071342468, -0.017395105212926865, -0.058843519538640976, -0.066307432949543, 0.042227085679769516, 0.014608197845518589, 0.006159850396215916, -0.0655946284532547, -0.058258768171072006, -0.04302382841706276, 0.048568256199359894, -0.04390513896942139, -0.05321228504180908, -0.004536195658147335, -0.018942156806588173, 0.014086010865867138, -0.0029118910897523165, 0.01960769295692444, 0.002803608775138855, 0.02003626897931099, -0.002632935531437397, 0.035236433148384094, 0.04018685594201088, 0.01541276928037405, 0.017855381593108177, -0.020752467215061188, -0.05776500329375267, -0.04786262661218643, 0.053778864443302155, -0.028351765125989914, -0.04132675752043724, -0.021045755594968796, 0.05466414615511894, -0.005275598261505365, -0.01161951944231987, 0.01705370470881462, 0.009920244105160236, 0.018953735008835793, -0.01480521634221077, -0.026090992614626884, 0.00802538450807333, -0.048450224101543427, -0.05181244760751724, 0.010019052773714066, -0.03976716101169586, -0.012791040353477001, -0.055711034685373306, -0.05769455060362816, 0.04024619609117508, 0.016552109271287918, 0.06773718446493149, 0.006599497981369495, 0.03937314823269844, 0.005326051265001297, 0.007895490154623985, -0.027901433408260345, 0.029815014451742172, 0.025502989068627357, 0.03129902482032776, 0.01630152016878128, 0.005686834920197725, -0.03834792971611023, -0.026433605700731277, -0.06475415080785751, -0.06225334480404854, 0.01561107486486435, 0.027747556567192078, 0.0051996889524161816, 0.02328677475452423, -0.026976455003023148, 0.0015595012810081244, -0.05235418304800987, 0.06399309635162354, 0.0016419606981799006, -0.045976027846336365, 0.042557213455438614, -0.056490276008844376, -0.021928664296865463, 0.06604234874248505, 0.010229944251477718, 0.026792973279953003, -0.061774756759405136, 0.02594405598938465, -0.0534503273665905, 0.029197240248322487, -0.019875695928931236, 0.02670036070048809, 0.009985722601413727, 0.03500708192586899, 0.014868765138089657, 0.05253509804606438, -0.017276957631111145, -0.04732091724872589, -0.041982296854257584, -0.00044154285569675267, -0.018162602558732033, 0.05159449577331543, -0.06369258463382721, 0.059715498238801956, 0.02344639040529728, 0.026417018845677376, -0.010695633478462696, 0.017575465142726898, -0.009745326824486256, -0.07050933688879013, -0.07233639061450958, 0.06257803738117218, 0.012831483967602253, 0.03152419999241829, -0.029919344931840897, -0.013731063343584538, 0.0705006942152977, -0.01341131329536438, 0.01359759271144867, -0.06997686624526978, -0.028882663697004318, -0.011410175822675228, -0.004133105278015137, -0.03879665955901146, -0.06771427392959595, 0.05079411715269089, -0.03456529229879379, -0.007914826273918152, 0.0190314669162035, 0.0017630819929763675, -0.06908518821001053, -0.03952028229832649, 0.009052254259586334, 0.040623631328344345, 0.0633382797241211, -0.036904968321323395, -0.042884986847639084, 0.0010014495346695185, -0.028797566890716553, 0.011593596078455448, -0.0026340147014707327, -0.011063930578529835, -0.0021286122500896454, 0.03773757442831993, -0.025730349123477936, 0.008150112815201283, 0.02051936835050583, -0.027419431135058403, 0.07002834230661392, -0.015801990404725075, -0.00972971972078085, -0.014990157447755337, 0.05011065676808357, -0.06734718382358551, -0.07078702747821808, -0.002065949374809861, -0.04988163337111473, -0.05735941603779793, -0.03488479554653168, 0.05753612518310547, 0.02925887517631054, -0.015400880016386509, 0.007362553384155035, 0.035149022936820984, 0.041089124977588654, -0.019976817071437836, 0.0205680001527071, -0.011587309651076794, 0.008951181545853615, -0.01825314573943615, -0.013844980858266354, -0.06914384663105011, 0.005638675298541784, 0.053556617349386215, -0.016673583537340164, -0.009008721448481083, 0.03491352126002312, -0.0011684412602335215, -0.004320942331105471, -0.07143083959817886, 0.034123744815588, 0.03546678274869919, -0.05833049491047859, 0.029073040932416916, 0.04494713991880417, -0.014369574375450611, 0.041538067162036896, -0.049635786563158035, -0.02874160185456276, 0.02134029194712639, -0.05409911647439003, 0.011838242411613464, 0.021981459110975266, 0.014891160652041435, 0.03853040561079979, 0.01858856901526451, -0.03850708529353142, -0.05845007300376892, 0.0510406531393528, 0.004193088971078396, -0.007968774996697903, -0.026896394789218903, 0.03112328238785267, 0.005834007635712624, -0.006999312434345484, -0.022997526451945305, 0.022720344364643097, 0.04380599781870842, -0.02578592672944069, 0.00462162122130394, -0.017661921679973602, -0.008916792459785938, 0.034499287605285645, -0.010689912363886833, 0.05691458284854889, 0.025252142921090126, 0.003951042424887419, 0.021675052121281624, -0.03273501619696617, 0.01856851950287819, -0.0015024584718048573, 0.0016239328542724252, 0.004009667318314314, 0.03816073015332222, 0.009706459008157253, 0.01469865906983614, -0.017435425892472267, 0.04952893406152725, -0.04622951149940491, -0.03993256762623787, 0.0027133175171911716, -0.013938525691628456, 0.009159603156149387, -0.0613747276365757, 0.04345676302909851, -0.023634882643818855, 0.036233555525541306, 0.02573096938431263, -0.026031939312815666, -0.025682669132947922, -0.017937762662768364, 0.021689919754862785, 0.007688901852816343, 0.00662889052182436, -0.044941745698451996, -0.06790340691804886, 0.04968143254518509, 0.05635621026158333, -0.04044564068317413, 0.05459649860858917, 0.04128306359052658, -0.02842755988240242, 0.03419731557369232, -0.035672660917043686, -0.019594471901655197, 0.003324792254716158, 0.02651921845972538, 0.07792629301548004, -0.050679534673690796, -0.05217257887125015, -0.027285249903798103, -0.05313989147543907, 0.04392828792333603, -0.011681532487273216, -0.018620304763317108, -0.0304928757250309, -0.0223504900932312, -0.050156090408563614, 0.035801179707050323, 0.010973261669278145, -0.06505566090345383, 0.026948997750878334, 0.004911406431347132, -0.053821783512830734, 0.0002706956584006548, 0.017990827560424805, -0.02185329981148243, -0.05729763209819794, 0.025963176041841507, -0.008553793653845787, -0.00896946806460619, -0.07187972217798233, 0.03926058113574982, 0.05695809796452522, 0.013311811722815037, 0.02388918213546276, -0.02388148382306099, -0.05311519280076027, 0.008675253950059414, 0.0009907456114888191, 0.03547653555870056, 0.015076734125614166, -0.00848811212927103, 0.03632669150829315, -0.043444618582725525, -0.037260331213474274, 0.0765114352107048, -0.027254238724708557, -0.05086126551032066, -0.013686015270650387, -0.027708841487765312, 0.013062693178653717, -0.026931706815958023, -0.030689364299178123, -0.010100314393639565, -0.012992464005947113, -0.007492185104638338, -0.011950971558690071, -0.007811585441231728, -0.031224088743329048, 0.024371664971113205, -0.026860494166612625, -0.037860605865716934, 0.049142997711896896, -0.02447858639061451, -0.06923551112413406, 0.019248399883508682, -0.04132970795035362, -0.002637733705341816, -0.028312740847468376, 0.017609037458896637, 0.02419755421578884, 0.0716477483510971, -0.05185721442103386, 0.0045311632566154, 0.05960847809910774, -0.02475632168352604, 0.04021180048584938, -0.020067745819687843, -0.04676792025566101, 0.0020902554970234632, 0.05537128075957298, -0.0665922537446022, -0.021296925842761993, -0.046436943113803864, 0.035467423498630524, -0.02065972052514553, 0.02233997918665409, -0.035066667944192886, -0.025386787950992584, -0.02675340138375759, 0.0010026637464761734, -0.004032966215163469, 0.05792482569813728, -0.03823369741439819, -0.0793759748339653, 0.015436572954058647, -0.009781609289348125, 0.00348279788158834, -0.00017190873040817678, 0.03463057428598404, -0.010991460643708706, -0.03281132131814957, -0.006677314173430204, -0.009945244528353214, 0.015259841457009315, 0.038872089236974716, -0.0556936152279377, -0.01689390279352665, -0.0027231373824179173, 0.035552918910980225, -0.043388430029153824, -0.015734247863292694, 0.023350924253463745, -0.06203119456768036, -0.06184018403291702, 0.053220584988594055, -0.030910633504390717, 0.011430728249251842, -0.048065222799777985, -0.022992989048361778, -0.04918374866247177, -0.024270830675959587, -0.0640815868973732, -0.017276354134082794, -0.011180146597325802, 0.01707879640161991, -0.052621062844991684, -0.0025813314132392406, -0.005885920487344265, -0.02523317001760006, -0.033276963979005814, -0.03181116655468941, -0.004072936717420816, 0.04445001855492592, 0.008470767177641392, -0.01016828790307045, -0.0260331854224205, -0.03420865163207054, 0.02099585346877575, -0.0014704017667099833, -0.0021771867759525776, 0.007623848970979452, 0.04023340716958046, -0.019162343814969063, -0.010836799629032612, 0.018899541348218918, 0.03860672563314438, -0.0020170186180621386, 0.03286509960889816, 0.02078891731798649, 0.04756353050470352, -0.009999115020036697, -0.02797805145382881, 0.002541603520512581, -0.03498183190822601, 0.05886009708046913, -0.047304268926382065, 0.050451479852199554, -0.009469910524785519, -0.06908456981182098, 0.004250281024724245, -0.04615480452775955, -0.03935828432440758, -0.018067436292767525, -0.03771361708641052, 0.04919227212667465, 0.01427171379327774, -0.05596376582980156, 0.06346588581800461, 0.018229767680168152, -0.022584829479455948, 0.021011296659708023, -0.008187700062990189, 0.036578547209501266, -0.002003591740503907, 0.018365876749157906, 0.008398422971367836, 0.014687716029584408, 0.0219945777207613, -0.06527230888605118, 0.03770389035344124, -0.05831173434853554, 0.007325273007154465, 0.0027648156974464655, -0.039389193058013916, -0.05926797166466713, 0.039546724408864975, -0.011025097221136093, -0.04340368136763573, -0.04342644289135933, -0.015926413238048553, -0.0739428773522377, -0.0765162780880928, -0.020521782338619232, -0.04158135876059532, 0.018681179732084274, -0.05907704308629036, -0.011773946695029736, 0.020531343296170235, 0.00119347486179322, 0.01430430170148611, -0.025634419173002243, 0.017769068479537964, 0.0558386966586113, -0.05565261468291283, 0.06572399288415909, 0.022588029503822327, -0.03197246044874191, -0.04529507830739021, -0.0012701665982604027, -0.01581747829914093, -0.04608511924743652, -0.00810314528644085, -0.01980014704167843, -0.008551322855055332, -0.0651761069893837, -0.013464207760989666, 0.028867507353425026, -0.028420893475413322, -0.02207074873149395, -0.037842024117708206, 0.0049520512111485004, -0.02383967489004135, -0.01900227554142475 ]
We develop a semi-analytical description for the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) like phase transition in nonequilibrium Bose-Einstein condensates. Our theoretical analysis is based on a noisy generalized Gross-Pitaevskii equation. Above a critical strength of the noise, spontaneous vortex-antivortex pairs are generated. We provide a semi-analytical determination of the transition point based on a linearized Bogoliubov analysis, to which some nonlinear corrections are added. We present two different approaches that are in agreement with our numerical calculations in a wide range of system parameters. We find that for small losses and not too small energy relaxation, the critical point approaches that of the equilibrium BKT transition. Furthermore, we find that losses tend to stabilize the ordered phase: keeping the other parameters constant and increasing the losses leads to a higher critical noise strength for the spontaneous generation of vortex-antivortex pairs. Our theoretical analysis is relevant for experiments on microcavity polaritons.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11201v1
[ -0.011834953911602497, -0.05262821167707443, 0.012998362071812153, 0.016259577125310898, 0.0067225354723632336, -0.029436660930514336, -0.007012650370597839, 0.05514763295650482, -0.011921070516109467, 0.0096472492441535, -0.049621034413576126, -0.04197898879647255, -0.030320649966597557, -0.0721873939037323, -0.0688716247677803, 0.018423739820718765, 0.06993933022022247, 0.026636848226189613, -0.03960060328245163, 0.067103810608387, 0.014128786511719227, 0.008661762811243534, -0.01697693206369877, 0.05433940142393112, -0.006276617757976055, -0.017461158335208893, -0.0008082295535132289, 0.0036991240922361612, -0.06805096566677094, 0.012407752685248852, 0.05077371746301651, 0.0028164293617010117, -0.025302475318312645, -0.04940517991781235, -0.0120472963899374, -0.020321594551205635, 0.003385623451322317, 0.03255601227283478, 0.034048136323690414, -0.0394582636654377, 0.016918687149882317, -0.043355826288461685, -0.05421679466962814, 0.0020036480855196714, 0.02322220616042614, 0.007550871931016445, -0.01636439561843872, 0.03383524343371391, -0.053772568702697754, -0.05118647590279579, 0.065408855676651, 0.042924705892801285, -0.025876406580209732, 0.059441421180963516, -0.07789105176925659, 0.01357734389603138, -0.014401608146727085, -0.044214069843292236, -0.03060077503323555, -0.03799466788768768, 0.03634248301386833, -0.0032108703162521124, 0.011440201662480831, -0.035900767892599106, -0.03637591004371643, 0.07629144936800003, -0.007678719703108072, -0.054617736488580704, -0.05560777336359024, -0.07239953428506851, -0.04853813350200653, -0.06618006527423859, 0.05758333206176758, 0.004118676297366619, -0.044848356395959854, -0.05593230575323105, -0.04611964523792267, -0.03664771094918251, 0.026459848508238792, 0.035959936678409576, -0.04242734611034393, 0.028412386775016785, -0.014497144147753716, -0.023523161187767982, 0.02947211265563965, 0.0070535894483327866, 0.008725486695766449, -0.009984328411519527, -0.0024367624428123236, -0.05628932639956474, 0.026600539684295654, -0.055474892258644104, -0.055593643337488174, -0.019524136558175087, 0.041132088750600815, -0.0447990708053112, 0.05690277740359306, 0.019861510023474693, 0.027127591893076897, 0.018992256373167038, -0.04782278835773468, -0.04013015329837799, 0.025505250319838524, 0.06507031619548798, 0.006380016915500164, -0.04230273514986038, 0.017581291496753693, -0.008365729823708534, -0.02287827990949154, 0.038633719086647034, 0.005210602190345526, -0.01052920799702406, 0.014358709566295147, -0.04781290516257286, -0.021068952977657318, -0.02480892650783062, 0.06430016458034515, 0.007021541707217693, 0.039689213037490845, -0.03441286459565163, -0.01994793675839901, 0.05366200953722, 0.012041835114359856, 0.012448246590793133, -0.010765333659946918, -0.012027429416775703, 0.04678690433502197, 0.040712468326091766, 0.01718234270811081, 0.010900532826781273, -0.024168388918042183, -0.015172955580055714, 0.017766593024134636, 0.03706729784607887, 0.04162411019206047, 0.01389935053884983, 0.037390727549791336, -0.027851246297359467, -0.004207793623209, 0.06059970334172249, -0.027667995542287827, -0.012674698606133461, 0.004119281657040119, 0.0037802481092512608, 0.04623306170105934, 0.03790696710348129, -0.06906294822692871, 0.021952921524643898, 0.04395408555865288, 0.021107308566570282, 0.0014856525231152773, -0.03465905785560608, 0.004494074732065201, 0.002645529806613922, 0.040164656937122345, 0.024153441190719604, 0.04618993401527405, -0.0023694958072155714, -0.009132063016295433, 0.013344044797122478, 0.0402374267578125, -0.034082744270563126, 0.02291623130440712, 0.026812583208084106, 0.004946910310536623, -0.0017092872876673937, 0.04084865748882294, -0.03197146952152252, -0.003340770723298192, 0.01212348323315382, -0.032027434557676315, 0.023563962429761887, 0.0185836311429739, -0.017536498606204987, -0.04212182015180588, -0.053566399961709976, -0.010685401037335396, -0.04964543506503105, -0.047067053616046906, 0.029962442815303802, -0.0116701265797019, 0.0027529338840395212, -0.020152384415268898, 0.00773084769025445, -0.03917381539940834, 0.004888949450105429, -0.07011066377162933, 0.0262528695166111, 0.04591459780931473, 0.0004132762842345983, 0.0461735762655735, -0.009515314362943172, 0.016797784715890884, 0.0029039443470537663, -0.02136869542300701, -0.01887139491736889, 0.0336688756942749, 0.02950242906808853, -0.012433943338692188, 0.021271344274282455, -0.08975296467542648, -0.04860648512840271, -0.01835031993687153, 0.023373175412416458, -0.02360987477004528, -0.046816255897283554, 0.03750104829668999, 0.05015014111995697, -0.018830541521310806, 0.006893071345984936, 0.057209908962249756, -0.0009026185143738985, 0.02857307717204094, 0.03462522476911545, 0.011075175367295742, -0.025262365117669106, -0.09904871881008148, 0.0389670766890049, -0.021597374230623245, -0.01395313162356615, -0.025813639163970947, 0.000962997495662421, -0.021413085982203484, -0.03625769913196564, -0.028130551800131798, 0.046887874603271484, 0.03591316565871239, 0.00850679911673069, -0.04555213823914528, -0.014145523309707642, -0.015232905745506287, -0.04085203632712364, -0.05552846938371658, -0.053181812167167664, -0.0288388691842556, 0.04336589574813843, -0.012169580906629562, 0.03722058981657028, -0.026405679062008858, -0.06828884035348892, -0.05718668922781944, 0.0006384061416611075, 0.022631483152508736, -0.031485579907894135, -0.03204073756933212, -0.005229859612882137, -0.05690263956785202, 0.03817291557788849, -0.05649815499782562, -0.009297576732933521, 0.01439399179071188, -0.005890931002795696, -0.0038581332191824913, -0.007938615046441555, 0.015335737727582455, 0.026644708588719368, -0.05630684643983841, 0.041424427181482315, 0.029072405770421028, 0.023575598374009132, -0.024450551718473434, 0.007168783340603113, -0.05516746640205383, 0.06453289836645126, 0.02397536300122738, 0.03244283050298691, -0.03034250997006893, 0.02530703693628311, 0.0007278809789568186, -0.04023000970482826, -0.009238128550350666, 0.012155136093497276, 0.04459401220083237, 0.029636451974511147, -0.002521891612559557, -0.04748125001788139, -0.030021216720342636, -0.04146962985396385, 0.027810988947749138, 0.04816491901874542, 0.06982623785734177, 0.04370146244764328, -0.017723258584737778, -0.06733863055706024, 0.013123712502419949, -0.029323112219572067, 0.02137361839413643, -0.034661151468753815, -0.054481182247400284, -0.03759206831455231, -0.061547599732875824, -0.01814872771501541, -0.0497443750500679, -0.01577179692685604, -0.06650109589099884, -0.06821565330028534, -0.03235284239053726, -0.02543887309730053, 0.028077777475118637, -0.040326278656721115, -0.05457863584160805, 0.042265161871910095, 0.05406717583537102, -0.008215711452066898, 0.011501130647957325, -0.03329728543758392, -0.02377762831747532, 0.008569657802581787, 0.0310719795525074, 0.02474525012075901, -0.03897489234805107, -0.04002414271235466, -0.047143347561359406, 0.03405417129397392, -0.002513355575501919, 0.027669783681631088, -0.014772888273000717, 0.03465450927615166, 0.02004445716738701, -0.03960425406694412, -0.0035635901149362326, -0.010893935337662697, -0.017542218789458275, -0.005598291754722595, -0.06734295189380646, -0.038745637983083725, 0.06621018797159195, 0.037692949175834656, -0.010210364125669003, -0.039354026317596436, -0.0427512526512146, -0.012696933932602406, -0.010516462847590446, 0.009146144613623619, 0.0663980096578598, 0.04431803897023201, -0.043201908469200134, -0.04934973642230034, -0.038958027958869934, 0.03174576535820961, 0.003952683415263891, 0.019805127754807472, 0.019317403435707092, 0.03417366370558739, 0.04085709527134895, -0.06741113215684891, 0.027301453053951263, 0.05332791805267334, 0.07169760763645172, -0.044611625373363495, -0.053637392818927765, -0.0010293113300576806, 0.02374318242073059, -0.013552218675613403, 0.03462308645248413, -0.016921978443861008, 0.014974859543144703, 0.07271799445152283, -0.04124614968895912, -0.013020817190408707, -0.022661276161670685, -0.03141101822257042, -0.04739311710000038, -0.006392760202288628, 0.005567159038037062, 0.03517334535717964, 0.044437848031520844, 0.009731628000736237, 0.013705456629395485, -0.030351268127560616, 0.04233042150735855, -0.02277134172618389, -0.02467324212193489, 0.020112186670303345, -0.008714016526937485, 0.03379630297422409, -0.00650609377771616, 0.019181519746780396, 0.0018294076435267925, -0.04974621161818504, 0.006192890461534262, -0.06043652445077896, 0.04251237213611603, 0.013055143877863884, 0.024506429210305214, 0.01228051446378231, 0.04219415783882141, -0.03944285213947296, 0.04825318977236748, 0.005315182264894247, 0.0013524718815460801, -0.012329746969044209, -0.032197821885347366, 0.009945736266672611, -0.030365409329533577, -0.04265322536230087, -0.05119400843977928, -0.017627857625484467, -0.037391297519207, 0.009451710619032383, 0.0011046088766306639, 0.0463896282017231, -0.024845842272043228, -0.08402003347873688, -0.04396023228764534, -0.031737636774778366, -0.001163122826255858, -0.014207403175532818, -0.04138902202248573, 0.05458059906959534, 0.012195484712719917, 0.0064641195349395275, -0.017886312678456306, -0.00883037131279707, -0.050253912806510925, -0.02708488516509533, 0.005511965602636337, -0.03648475557565689, 0.012867672368884087, -0.042672187089920044, 0.029433473944664, -0.016614481806755066, -0.0072619072161614895, -0.05053054541349411, -0.017729423940181732, -0.05526021495461464, -0.0031873052939772606, 0.0510527528822422, 0.042458899319171906, 0.028311124071478844, 0.0033960449509322643, -0.04575379192829132, 0.03911175578832626, -0.012715822085738182, 0.010817085392773151, -0.021216705441474915, 0.0014565873425453901, -0.021342258900403976, -0.02021685056388378, -0.025265363976359367, 0.02749159187078476, 0.04856811836361885, -0.05110521242022514, -0.041961852461099625, 0.007185014430433512, 0.03460691496729851, -0.010773335583508015, -0.040286533534526825, -0.01498479675501585, -0.011821652762591839, -0.055053722113370895, -0.01508807111531496, 0.029382579028606415, 0.018218792974948883, -0.03344816341996193, 0.043006863445043564, 0.030436068773269653, 0.007319234777241945, -0.03914899379014969, 0.0398603156208992, 0.04049025475978851, 0.04714371636509895, 0.02484610117971897, -0.020025620236992836, -0.04675393924117088, 0.00017967342864722013, -0.015330527909100056, -0.03305632621049881, -0.015111648477613926, 0.04528902471065521, -0.006324284244328737, 0.060396708548069, -0.07828429341316223, 0.01499635074287653, 0.04462758079171181, -0.014662894420325756, 0.004222159273922443, 0.07105869054794312, -0.06025693565607071, 0.023101190105080605, -0.010087919421494007, -0.04680762067437172, 0.04852519929409027, 0.00034882829640991986, 0.00969423446804285, -0.001283940626308322, -0.03255822882056236, -0.0055845556780695915, 0.042690884321928024, 0.03433249890804291, -0.0489344485104084, 0.04549423232674599, 0.02715274877846241, -0.01631160080432892, -0.04403045400977135, -0.018078530207276344, 0.014255682937800884, -0.07179851830005646, -0.08153394609689713, 0.0038877283222973347, -0.000016644151401123963, -0.040899474173784256, 0.046668339520692825, -0.06169309839606285, 0.01414016354829073, 0.02197340503334999, 0.03739653900265694, 0.0006420735735446215, 0.024855786934494972, -0.0025481292977929115, -0.025843767449259758, 0.023711543530225754, -0.0030560707673430443, -0.05850595980882645, 0.0044977664947509766, -0.040640685707330704, 0.04203085973858833, 0.0030154369305819273, 0.04897027835249901, 0.036672160029411316, 0.0746457576751709, -0.03590337932109833, -0.0698886439204216, 0.007746813353151083, -0.043974343687295914, 0.06470289826393127, -0.0484333373606205, 0.0017180211143568158, 0.003198753111064434, 0.06927259266376495, -0.004700871650129557, -0.015757596120238304, 0.011705511249601841, -0.021950410678982735, -0.001599105540663004, 0.025603458285331726, -0.0068428716622292995, -0.015776723623275757, -0.008222663775086403, -0.015652209520339966, 0.02396094799041748, -0.015500952489674091, 0.04949149489402771, 0.03686058893799782, 0.002601060550659895, 0.003454117802903056, -0.008441150188446045, -0.00960681214928627, -0.03213750198483467, 0.02113306149840355, 0.08186102658510208, -0.06230362877249718, -0.0183368269354105, -0.03183875232934952, -0.038877349346876144, -0.01785438135266304, -0.008021004498004913, 0.0008458236115984619, -0.025587545707821846, 0.014969184063374996, -0.07338877022266388, 0.0641198679804802, 0.03818606957793236, -0.07085518538951874, -0.02849438041448593, 0.016918405890464783, -0.08395065367221832, -0.023690223693847656, -0.0006753485067747533, -0.06363192945718765, -0.026166027411818504, -0.022053981199860573, 0.01695890538394451, -0.04154485836625099, -0.006028202828019857, 0.06378877907991409, 0.07133336365222931, -0.06328272819519043, 0.013680698350071907, 0.03526989370584488, -0.00891977921128273, 0.03114132769405842, -0.011688170954585075, 0.0018729624571278691, -0.0030801906250417233, 0.036436840891838074, -0.023946892470121384, -0.019651232287287712, 0.000359733821824193, 0.05014164745807648, -0.0589781329035759, 0.03730208799242973, -0.03464687615633011, 0.025421325117349625, 0.019643699750304222, -0.02931063063442707, -0.03347623348236084, 0.010967033915221691, 0.004475414287298918, -0.014336293563246727, -0.022812550887465477, -0.028333216905593872, -0.02067195437848568, 0.04897139593958855, 0.03255815804004669, -0.012180001474916935, 0.04709060490131378, 0.02918774075806141, -0.014328405261039734, 0.009933661669492722, -0.03911009803414345, -0.028064677491784096, 0.03410232067108154, -0.03668644279241562, -0.013405426405370235, 0.04761415719985962, -0.05605040118098259, -0.027794193476438522, -0.009085094556212425, 0.019677406176924706, 0.025157466530799866, 0.06401227414608002, 0.04824728146195412, -0.014339949004352093, 0.07203663140535355, -0.0038840060587972403, 0.03470861166715622, -0.004661595914512873, -0.06506245583295822, 0.046648673713207245, -0.0012253728928044438, -0.00806141272187233, -0.04100582376122475, -0.025218864902853966, -0.04454416036605835, -0.02521456778049469, 0.024123480543494225, -0.05279470980167389, -0.0565730519592762, 0.04784545302391052, 0.031498633325099945, -0.006727780215442181, -0.0329524502158165, 0.0037594265304505825, 0.023676395416259766, -0.029789866879582405, 0.02201339229941368, 0.06905674934387207, 0.01988622546195984, 0.013271217234432697, -0.05182087421417236, -0.025548603385686874, 0.043609149754047394, 0.009783408604562283, -0.006279403809458017, -0.009802198968827724, -0.008702676743268967, -0.05844394862651825, 0.014426009729504585, 0.0390540212392807, -0.03200864419341087, 0.003278028219938278, -0.08213074505329132, 0.025870351120829582, 0.038646869361400604, -0.07327423244714737, -0.025250142440199852, 0.04305696859955788, 0.0059133428148925304, 0.017327304929494858, -0.00817420519888401, -0.011109893210232258, -0.0485377162694931, 0.027165450155735016, -0.07742688059806824, -0.028930600732564926, 0.02145140804350376, 0.04735533893108368, 0.00984865240752697, 0.007131295744329691, -0.041265714913606644, -0.044591184705495834, -0.008576364256441593, -0.003978698048740625, -0.03672705218195915, 0.012207006104290485, 0.02199842594563961, 0.04596726968884468, -0.07599178701639175, -0.04456179216504097, 0.06697183102369308, 0.00837343093007803, 0.029097365215420723, 0.022859549149870872, 0.03055707924067974, -0.027517803013324738, 0.03100516088306904, 0.04403550177812576, 0.025344260036945343, 0.05154493823647499, -0.06934678554534912, 0.020182237029075623, -0.016132904216647148, -0.06499382108449936, 0.006595587357878685, -0.04391742870211601, 0.039954863488674164, 0.030501144006848335, -0.01671111397445202, -0.03538641706109047, -0.04213077947497368, -0.03890971094369888, 0.01936432532966137, 0.021949170157313347, -0.036048244684934616, 0.07871924340724945, -0.03680139034986496, 0.0067536779679358006, -0.013879165053367615, -0.01729467697441578, -0.060872770845890045, 0.014148564077913761, -0.0025184685364365578, -0.0613555908203125, -0.019432898610830307, -0.06251280009746552, -0.010886692441999912, 0.01550636813044548, 0.052479490637779236, 0.05312103033065796, 0.034200966358184814, -0.05450831353664398, 0.044856008142232895, -0.050694238394498825, -0.012693331576883793, -0.014774343930184841, -0.05075444281101227, -0.012772255577147007, 0.00048268542741425335, 0.011794631369411945, 0.012191549874842167, 0.04182914271950722, -0.0007707728655077517, 0.05437632277607918, 0.04309571534395218, -0.022684048861265182, -0.046604953706264496, 0.024502066895365715, -0.02357759326696396, 0.042967814952135086, -0.01510653831064701, -0.05835169926285744, -0.040351852774620056, 0.004140860866755247, 0.02456916868686676, 0.012624362483620644, 0.0066594211384654045, -0.010118391364812851, 0.005548000335693359, -0.04617876559495926, -0.029347270727157593, 0.0312467310577631, -0.0348573662340641, -0.07247721403837204, -0.022266091778874397, 0.020728223025798798, -0.020389746874570847, -0.06006656587123871 ]
Collaborative robotics is a new and challenging field in the realm of motion control and human-robot interaction. The safety measures needed for a reliable interaction between the robot and its environment hinder the use of classical control methods, pushing researchers to try new techniques such as machine learning (ML). In this context, reinforcement learning has been adopted as the primary way to create intelligent controllers for collaborative robots, however supervised learning shows great promise in the hope of developing data-driven model based ML controllers in a faster and safer way. In this work we study several aspects of the methodology needed to create a dataset to be used to learn the dynamics of a robot. For this we tune several PD controllers to several trajectories, using a multi-objective genetic algorithm (GA) which takes into account not only their accuracy, but also their safety. We demonstrate the need to tune the controllers individually to each trajectory and empirically explore the best population size for the GA and how the speed of the trajectory affects the tuning and the dynamics of the robot.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08988v1
[ -0.009798894636332989, -0.037919964641332626, 0.0288543738424778, -0.005034768488258123, -0.004500058479607105, 0.01491530705243349, 0.01838637702167034, 0.005046383943408728, -0.007605962920933962, -0.054041069000959396, -0.052259039133787155, 0.03299267962574959, -0.03869688883423805, -0.05862709879875183, -0.05430671572685242, 0.043855950236320496, 0.07866436243057251, -0.005193053744733334, -0.05141039937734604, 0.05371932312846184, -0.0054046381264925, 0.0027037474792450666, -0.04741542041301727, -0.0005926796584390104, 0.0038520810194313526, -0.0011799351777881384, -0.000794125662650913, 0.01772049441933632, -0.04994393512606621, 0.007753534242510796, 0.05599084496498108, -0.0281023271381855, -0.015691978856921196, -0.06743846833705902, -0.05645399168133736, 0.01030786707997322, -0.03095697984099388, 0.03304210677742958, 0.05881417542695999, -0.02969159372150898, 0.014696834608912468, -0.02888306975364685, -0.07125283777713776, -0.013327951543033123, -0.021789217367768288, 0.003555628005415201, -0.06631912291049957, 0.009664182551205158, -0.046357955783605576, -0.047351423650979996, -0.01724551059305668, -0.005783119238913059, 0.05149766802787781, 0.061846595257520676, -0.054131291806697845, 0.03344956785440445, 0.007616506423801184, 0.04212142899632454, -0.06383174657821655, -0.019451284781098366, -0.007657893933355808, 0.009484851732850075, 0.031590092927217484, 0.012595314532518387, 0.02591721899807453, 0.05933845788240433, 0.0008018846274353564, -0.057270895689725876, -0.04987894371151924, -0.026879040524363518, 0.06254392862319946, -0.07072829455137253, 0.03656953200697899, 0.02250189334154129, -0.025056276470422745, -0.03024660237133503, -0.044931910932064056, -0.0507545992732048, -0.00623850803822279, -0.01577548310160637, -0.03313380479812622, 0.04363996163010597, 0.030026568099856377, 0.03303863853216171, -0.02272416651248932, -0.0030806344002485275, 0.030379561707377434, -0.037201691418886185, 0.03056364879012108, -0.053541917353868484, 0.061655279248952866, -0.011110805906355381, -0.08743511885404587, -0.007476436905562878, 0.05122493952512741, -0.022732404991984367, 0.0653306096792221, 0.03648891672492027, 0.003751967567950487, -0.04272093623876572, -0.05709654092788696, -0.011713571846485138, -0.01976698264479637, 0.04165814816951752, 0.05349363759160042, -0.05508469045162201, 0.028799723833799362, -0.017199978232383728, -0.03740504011511803, -0.024106143042445183, -0.017502373084425926, -0.05575148016214371, 0.006657189689576626, -0.07166788727045059, -0.062452733516693115, -0.0008921096450649202, 0.032917220145463943, -0.02361243963241577, 0.04353216290473938, 0.02716667205095291, -0.056177034974098206, 0.055292680859565735, 0.015262747183442116, 0.021950606256723404, -0.03263356536626816, -0.030744634568691254, 0.07093523442745209, 0.014732602052390575, -0.0392223596572876, -0.027150562033057213, -0.021476950496435165, 0.009353719651699066, -0.04118266701698303, -0.050279200077056885, 0.06147447228431702, -0.013249591924250126, -0.0005537286051549017, -0.0707172304391861, 0.015255400910973549, -0.016215085983276367, -0.04171457886695862, -0.07175491750240326, 0.020894544199109077, 0.003979024477303028, 0.009223618544638157, 0.04065053164958954, -0.015911279246211052, -0.014278866350650787, 0.02021176554262638, 0.040023334324359894, 0.03147502243518829, 0.03389508277177811, 0.02028965763747692, 0.020238246768712997, 0.04395702853798866, -0.04643504321575165, 0.05441369488835335, -0.05105575919151306, -0.07130991667509079, -0.027232976630330086, -0.008287752978503704, -0.009717106819152832, 0.010258156806230545, -0.042441532015800476, 0.0042038485407829285, -0.00785791128873825, 0.04764525964856148, 0.003987020347267389, -0.03910314291715622, -0.0064978450536727905, 0.016878539696335793, -0.005808127578347921, 0.0164482444524765, -0.033704813569784164, -0.06904585659503937, -0.049128565937280655, 0.021396387368440628, -0.064032182097435, -0.018449779599905014, 0.012380768544971943, 0.014595412649214268, 0.038774143904447556, -0.05206617712974548, 0.020959727466106415, -0.03795774653553963, 0.028225136920809746, -0.07630541920661926, -0.05724276602268219, 0.026202769950032234, 0.0313776470720768, -0.054374199360609055, -0.06649729609489441, 0.01953982561826706, -0.03451869264245033, -0.047439660876989365, -0.03421524539589882, -0.017027951776981354, -0.02682696096599102, 0.046591054648160934, 0.035173676908016205, -0.08202768862247467, 0.005108474753797054, -0.055179331451654434, -0.003744581714272499, -0.019611390307545662, -0.07025600969791412, 0.03487682715058327, 0.03508029505610466, -0.048359524458646774, 0.029483720660209656, 0.029013127088546753, 0.03327589109539986, 0.03722277656197548, -0.006820487789809704, 0.042334992438554764, 0.026468344032764435, -0.09817362576723099, 0.050795603543519974, 0.018155159428715706, 0.041856564581394196, 0.03208189085125923, 0.0057284217327833176, 0.006143643520772457, -0.03533565253019333, -0.010483503341674805, 0.03620732203125954, 0.02300584502518177, -0.008599807508289814, -0.03363361954689026, -0.029838338494300842, -0.0017840334912762046, -0.07849513739347458, -0.0014204250182956457, -0.0555015467107296, -0.04056335985660553, -0.024767417460680008, -0.0450422465801239, 0.04447828233242035, 0.022747859358787537, -0.02599295973777771, -0.02413618192076683, -0.04709469527006149, 0.05267176032066345, -0.03211171552538872, -0.048227716237306595, -0.022563783451914787, -0.025080561637878418, 0.02181381545960903, -0.005401707720011473, 0.035519808530807495, -0.02292301319539547, 0.011184616014361382, 0.00747122336179018, -0.00817690696567297, 0.04646763578057289, 0.025387777015566826, -0.04370386525988579, 0.028263622894883156, -0.05107185244560242, 0.021976932883262634, 0.03163667768239975, -0.0074068959802389145, -0.06181313470005989, 0.026066605001688004, 0.016267182305455208, 0.01605619676411152, -0.03299417346715927, -0.020609810948371887, -0.0003946927608922124, -0.03951592370867729, 0.01825055666267872, -0.0014471992617473006, 0.0495041161775589, -0.007798057049512863, -0.03618254512548447, -0.0015911265509203076, -0.022738786414265633, -0.011757041327655315, 0.014353415928781033, 0.01898406445980072, 0.027518220245838165, 0.0046448358334600925, 0.03106871247291565, -0.04975653439760208, -0.013417430222034454, -0.008914265781641006, 0.001242373837158084, -0.06856659799814224, -0.041057221591472626, -0.0300090704113245, -0.05762780085206032, -0.02870713733136654, -0.047579601407051086, -0.04609822854399681, -0.021054305136203766, -0.0695442408323288, 0.006255218293517828, 0.019964726641774178, -0.019261527806520462, -0.05015568062663078, -0.04472968727350235, -0.0171024352312088, -0.027571681886911392, 0.005586045794188976, -0.025624072179198265, -0.07514876872301102, -0.025398600846529007, -0.05947072058916092, -0.0033690747804939747, -0.01410604827105999, -0.031214922666549683, 0.06223320960998535, -0.02738891914486885, -0.009115238673985004, -0.026966705918312073, -0.009626786224544048, 0.0021419834811240435, 0.01782906800508499, -0.056084513664245605, 0.02903645671904087, 0.02105848677456379, -0.00589123647660017, 0.035053178668022156, -0.025167830288410187, -0.04876212775707245, 0.015594171360135078, 0.06137162819504738, -0.010381046682596207, -0.0024826813023537397, -0.04913606494665146, 0.041325557976961136, -0.015515313483774662, -0.005897891707718372, -0.009770154021680355, 0.017759358510375023, 0.005854670889675617, -0.016557686030864716, -0.024541858583688736, -0.02658350020647049, 0.013742190785706043, -0.04399392381310463, 0.03783103823661804, -0.032324083149433136, -0.05062752217054367, 0.024144811555743217, -0.0808168351650238, -0.024635473266243935, 0.0013323809253051877, 0.04684838280081749, -0.012481238692998886, 0.04964494705200195, 0.013916829600930214, 0.003086196258664131, 0.00675894133746624, 0.011052282527089119, 0.048416003584861755, 0.027627207338809967, 0.03666312247514725, 0.0005217964062467217, -0.023813698440790176, -0.02236451767385006, -0.07537051290273666, -0.04634721577167511, -0.011763005517423153, 0.03084678016602993, 0.014864436350762844, 0.0365116111934185, -0.08641039580106735, 0.00005050684922025539, -0.029592592269182205, 0.0379674956202507, 0.029430020600557327, -0.019206156954169273, 0.016331620514392853, -0.043693024665117264, 0.017377780750393867, 0.0017088062595576048, 0.032549016177654266, -0.023713693022727966, -0.04827204719185829, 0.018815774470567703, -0.07181444764137268, 0.013862553052604198, -0.0002590058429632336, -0.0011746863601729274, 0.025986982509493828, 0.04621247202157974, -0.0075688050128519535, 0.04736335203051567, -0.04706733673810959, -0.050515156239271164, -0.01229778304696083, -0.01572791114449501, -0.04538416117429733, -0.01615503616631031, -0.032006580382585526, 0.013163244351744652, 0.026638120412826538, -0.04095153138041496, 0.0182878989726305, -0.02165173552930355, 0.009935260750353336, -0.048235006630420685, -0.08643028140068054, 0.017468055710196495, -0.024499788880348206, 0.046637341380119324, -0.0033077977132052183, -0.02215574122965336, 0.0638650432229042, -0.028068872168660164, -0.02866571955382824, -0.04216836765408516, 0.01035657711327076, -0.013623454608023167, -0.0365167073905468, 0.0020491406321525574, -0.0563492514193058, 0.01860799267888069, -0.04036286473274231, 0.03327954187989235, 0.008996627293527126, 0.008997933007776737, -0.037045396864414215, -0.053705815225839615, 0.009720835834741592, 0.05754012614488602, 0.06875859200954437, -0.0014173239469528198, -0.018590731546282768, -0.03872491419315338, 0.0007757348357699811, 0.034408193081617355, 0.007817757315933704, 0.01756216771900654, 0.025357870385050774, 0.023020243272185326, -0.011080926284193993, 0.011059288866817951, -0.011250343173742294, -0.00383944739587605, 0.056791309267282486, 0.019125601276755333, -0.027469998225569725, -0.028965802863240242, 0.059516388922929764, -0.05868648737668991, -0.0598791278898716, -0.04037262126803398, -0.03395993262529373, -0.045668743550777435, -0.02891159988939762, 0.036447253078222275, 0.035204410552978516, -0.008564182557165623, -0.023093977943062782, 0.026692954823374748, 0.0283912792801857, -0.04202195256948471, 0.024055147543549538, 0.002400175901129842, -0.004865837749093771, 0.03816593065857887, -0.0032377594616264105, -0.0715494155883789, 0.027807535603642464, -0.0005807525594718754, 0.02057867869734764, -0.0009271460003219545, 0.0551510751247406, 0.020516490563750267, 0.04944053292274475, -0.08519323915243149, 0.048764292150735855, 0.04845704883337021, -0.04765840247273445, 0.057608794420957565, 0.05611070990562439, -0.05194540321826935, 0.025915054604411125, -0.033690810203552246, -0.01945432648062706, 0.04453771188855171, -0.03897182643413544, -0.028362417593598366, 0.019993698224425316, -0.043848343193531036, 0.016034631058573723, 0.0219124685972929, -0.020582202821969986, -0.06972719728946686, 0.015145832672715187, 0.0025257349479943514, 0.006707292515784502, -0.061031635850667953, 0.013376334682106972, 0.04358423501253128, -0.03522045910358429, -0.05496569350361824, -0.010096886195242405, 0.018524261191487312, -0.03780759125947952, -0.016689792275428772, -0.03261122107505798, 0.03256829082965851, 0.016117481514811516, 0.009499406442046165, -0.026433249935507774, 0.025200309231877327, 0.006281222216784954, 0.028296802192926407, -0.013018964789807796, 0.009202337823808193, -0.0377037338912487, -0.056413255631923676, -0.013026200234889984, 0.0282029639929533, 0.05963776633143425, 0.00019118731142953038, 0.03272530436515808, 0.026873508468270302, -0.025567475706338882, -0.06822888553142548, 0.0013262054417282343, -0.004982126411050558, 0.012631026096642017, -0.05757603049278259, 0.04652640223503113, -0.019458888098597527, 0.012568365782499313, -0.016484297811985016, 0.014106417074799538, 0.013296695426106453, -0.043017178773880005, -0.050544608384370804, -0.007866154424846172, 0.013834871351718903, -0.05335821956396103, -0.05965075641870499, 0.05389353632926941, 0.03042285516858101, 0.008543016389012337, 0.026928763836622238, -0.0034343088045716286, -0.030599385499954224, 0.04172475263476372, 0.021471664309501648, -0.0353679358959198, -0.022084224969148636, 0.017430821433663368, 0.08368770778179169, -0.037108831107616425, -0.008184030652046204, 0.008416134864091873, -0.04937457665801048, -0.0011059576645493507, -0.017431437969207764, -0.02035392075777054, 0.0014862511307001114, -0.017085473984479904, -0.07569524645805359, 0.013635990209877491, -0.00009960735042113811, -0.046789903193712234, -0.01300789788365364, -0.015910709276795387, -0.07455296069383621, -0.029193077236413956, 0.019902793690562248, -0.03389410674571991, -0.06140229105949402, 0.07639850676059723, 0.031319789588451385, -0.0010281162103638053, -0.01857360266149044, 0.05323353409767151, 0.0793318822979927, -0.018361493945121765, 0.003223711857572198, 0.01048446074128151, -0.05890228971838951, 0.003475900972262025, -0.03650980070233345, -0.013202846981585026, 0.04193885624408722, 0.038764722645282745, 0.0419672392308712, -0.054876651614904404, -0.02844223380088806, 0.07371748983860016, -0.04880457744002342, -0.017313489690423012, 0.004901495762169361, -0.024567274376749992, 0.06159814074635506, -0.0004935878678224981, -0.044648975133895874, -0.003747215960174799, -0.01467080321162939, -0.002906881272792816, -0.05398082733154297, -0.012633675709366798, -0.013620655983686447, 0.014431600458920002, 0.0018248598789796233, -0.03323184326291084, -0.01925823651254177, -0.04490215331315994, -0.07356886565685272, 0.014310583472251892, -0.03418777510523796, -0.0025481199845671654, 0.017713434994220734, -0.05250957980751991, 0.018972767516970634, 0.04507116228342056, -0.03497276455163956, 0.0006143311620689929, 0.015033181756734848, -0.012436166405677795, 0.030090918764472008, 0.015881016850471497, 0.0188023392111063, 0.037454377859830856, 0.025431660935282707, -0.019278528168797493, -0.020321495831012726, -0.014166775159537792, -0.026165276765823364, 0.04690319299697876, 0.009114537388086319, -0.015270206145942211, -0.01026840042322874, -0.050155021250247955, 0.011989395134150982, 0.006869128439575434, -0.013154825195670128, -0.02648739330470562, -0.042761754244565964, 0.012362725101411343, 0.011555112898349762, 0.030614307150244713, -0.06216518208384514, 0.02041240781545639, 0.024805456399917603, 0.013254460878670216, -0.00775382062420249, 0.03357769176363945, -0.0411069393157959, -0.01423581037670374, -0.05300431698560715, -0.020757418125867844, 0.03403998538851738, -0.024771785363554955, -0.007244451902806759, -0.041619058698415756, -0.0162853691726923, -0.07868273556232452, 0.016884727403521538, 0.025439120829105377, -0.018653694540262222, 0.023641595616936684, -0.07303603738546371, 0.0015069659566506743, -0.00811796821653843, -0.04036945849657059, -0.037945326417684555, -0.03543245792388916, 0.0064792451448738575, -0.056735556572675705, 0.035626668483018875, -0.0026094038039445877, -0.012776024639606476, 0.0007887902902439237, -0.056932345032691956, -0.011658520437777042, -0.000040197319322032854, 0.0034600673243403435, 0.02091401070356369, -0.05100532993674278, 0.017813321202993393, -0.0723501667380333, 0.002542483154684305, 0.0018040051218122244, 0.004408718552440405, 0.020598800852894783, 0.03793290629982948, 0.005751896183937788, -0.05406064912676811, -0.026109062135219574, 0.00832770112901926, -0.04554353281855583, 0.01956959255039692, 0.019141731783747673, 0.04493486136198044, 0.06059146299958229, -0.04230730980634689, 0.007172747515141964, -0.05012841150164604, 0.03246978297829628, -0.026783563196659088, 0.01960085891187191, -0.042284827679395676, -0.07434393465518951, 0.010249736718833447, -0.01779320277273655, -0.010460933670401573, 0.04300983250141144, 0.00773374829441309, 0.025032030418515205, -0.02214604988694191, -0.03274070471525192, 0.0680803507566452, -0.023478247225284576, -0.02806912176311016, 0.05913436785340309, -0.019234376028180122, -0.03047066368162632, -0.03316636383533478, -0.025378776714205742, -0.028484098613262177, 0.00668604951351881, 0.04900399595499039, -0.009355969727039337, 0.02158157154917717, -0.08123829215765, 0.01022382639348507, 0.025273844599723816, 0.002499883295968175, -0.039629366248846054, 0.06806103140115738, -0.00506971962749958, -0.05821285396814346, -0.0029436645563691854, -0.06172223016619682, -0.037712205201387405, -0.046889834105968475, -0.024284658953547478, -0.035944078117609024, 0.015524364076554775, 0.021517354995012283, -0.022340305149555206, 0.023188240826129913, 0.0424007847905159, 0.005346779711544514, 0.04366093873977661, -0.01296231709420681, 0.014658326283097267, -0.04056813195347786, 0.06364434957504272, 0.003724768292158842, 0.012503842823207378, -0.040929824113845825, 0.032287854701280594, 0.02692900039255619, -0.030215978622436523, -0.022957544773817062, 0.04062259942293167, -0.021223505958914757, -0.054814908653497696, -0.01831064559519291, 0.04523621127009392, -0.007509002462029457, -0.04010523483157158, -0.015565801411867142, 0.029923150315880775, 0.0005340557545423508, -0.07126299291849136 ]
The increasing capacities of large language models (LLMs) present an unprecedented opportunity to scale up data analytics in the humanities and social sciences, augmenting and automating qualitative analytic tasks previously typically allocated to human labor. This contribution proposes a systematic mixed methods framework to harness qualitative analytic expertise, machine scalability, and rigorous quantification, with attention to transparency and replicability. 16 machine-assisted case studies are showcased as proof of concept. Tasks include linguistic and discourse analysis, lexical semantic change detection, interview analysis, historical event cause inference and text mining, detection of political stance, text and idea reuse, genre composition in literature and film; social network inference, automated lexicography, missing metadata augmentation, and multimodal visual cultural analytics. In contrast to the focus on English in the emerging LLM applicability literature, many examples here deal with scenarios involving smaller languages and historical texts prone to digitization distortions. In all but the most difficult tasks requiring expert knowledge, generative LLMs can demonstrably serve as viable research instruments. LLM (and human) annotations may contain errors and variation, but the agreement rate can and should be accounted for in subsequent statistical modeling; a bootstrapping approach is discussed. The replications among the case studies illustrate how tasks previously requiring potentially months of team effort and complex computational pipelines, can now be accomplished by an LLM-assisted scholar in a fraction of the time. Importantly, this approach is not intended to replace, but to augment researcher knowledge and skills. With these opportunities in sight, qualitative expertise and the ability to pose insightful questions have arguably never been more critical.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14379v1
[ -0.02141345851123333, -0.05626218765974045, 0.053563348948955536, -0.03469198942184448, -0.04361124336719513, 0.0044207461178302765, -0.014267273247241974, -0.030004924163222313, -0.018119344487786293, -0.024123206734657288, -0.04693813621997833, 0.02722383663058281, -0.052777182310819626, -0.0033348307479172945, -0.02955501526594162, -0.005035570822656155, 0.045352041721343994, 0.03275453671813011, -0.04649573564529419, 0.0535510778427124, 0.02359538897871971, 0.04202328994870186, -0.027867287397384644, 0.044219739735126495, 0.0073902904987335205, -0.03752759471535683, -0.009374269284307957, -0.01752629317343235, 0.014078316278755665, 0.013761579990386963, 0.038230061531066895, -0.05141744390130043, -0.0011486201547086239, -0.06825729459524155, -0.024393433704972267, -0.016015317291021347, -0.020226212218403816, -0.012958378531038761, 0.0038533660117536783, -0.05782889574766159, 0.009148996323347092, -0.03909331187605858, -0.07321023941040039, 0.0027424681466072798, -0.06010044366121292, 0.008503146469593048, -0.04240906238555908, 0.009729313664138317, -0.08631952852010727, -0.03799579665064812, 0.054482895880937576, 0.0006422039587050676, -0.0405561588704586, 0.05990905314683914, 0.015299301594495773, 0.000013656147530127782, -0.018296202644705772, -0.023702219128608704, -0.059498488903045654, -0.04090810567140579, 0.043002650141716, -0.02872421406209469, 0.01942100003361702, 0.01692301407456398, 0.016016177833080292, -0.006023255176842213, -0.011794875375926495, -0.05349425971508026, -0.034636225551366806, -0.07646707445383072, 0.056985560804605484, -0.07203391194343567, 0.0009130344842560589, 0.014320316724479198, -0.026497209444642067, -0.013384491205215454, 0.013752697966992855, -0.02464691922068596, -0.024258414283394814, 0.01717294007539749, -0.047096699476242065, 0.051753997802734375, 0.024463851004838943, -0.03451672941446304, -0.018284451216459274, -0.05686439573764801, 0.04169958457350731, -0.025264183059334755, -0.02064967341721058, -0.04721951484680176, 0.04576719552278519, -0.03635956346988678, -0.06628835201263428, -0.0060040997341275215, 0.07843014597892761, 0.005294472444802523, 0.027454175055027008, 0.008654032833874226, -0.005087836645543575, -0.009192892350256443, -0.003679760033264756, -0.028218282386660576, -0.04389681667089462, 0.0657089352607727, 0.027118965983390808, -0.06134118139743805, 0.012365349568426609, -0.03403053432703018, -0.02580399252474308, -0.006255552638322115, -0.015393498353660107, -0.019036587327718735, -0.010212579742074013, -0.05636836960911751, -0.042769480496644974, -0.046348024159669876, 0.05496206134557724, -0.007685921620577574, -0.005528965964913368, -0.0029536718502640724, -0.053185272961854935, 0.05548854544758797, 0.001901554292999208, -0.022751672193408012, -0.05290840566158295, 0.0015724996337667108, 0.05481070652604103, -0.0008825046825222671, -0.04059164971113205, -0.0063338750042021275, -0.06559500098228455, -0.026957865804433823, 0.015828676521778107, -0.03746428340673447, 0.059871502220630646, 0.030964581295847893, -0.06608756631612778, -0.06443386524915695, 0.042260561138391495, -0.024966632947325706, -0.05194300040602684, -0.08295419067144394, 0.01122160442173481, -0.06401988863945007, 0.034157536923885345, 0.02540067583322525, -0.04396779462695122, -0.007329030428081751, 0.01714462786912918, 0.010729310102760792, 0.030618198215961456, -0.01420877780765295, 0.006048311945050955, 0.03917388990521431, 0.0302659310400486, -0.031195087358355522, 0.004576502833515406, -0.021328020840883255, -0.04197993502020836, -0.007222966756671667, 0.013134668581187725, 0.00587718328461051, 0.03633861988782883, -0.025466548278927803, 0.003361891256645322, 0.00902851577848196, 0.05118133872747421, -0.03482936695218086, -0.025972485542297363, 0.030176682397723198, -0.01990857534110546, 0.021633556112647057, 0.003915127366781235, -0.03365097567439079, -0.04288323223590851, -0.024845005944371223, 0.049606818705797195, -0.03668524697422981, -0.028078777715563774, 0.005705141928046942, 0.0015790534671396017, 0.016885561868548393, -0.026886945590376854, -0.01124426256865263, -0.017737215384840965, 0.03978152200579643, -0.07237483561038971, -0.0018515251576900482, 0.027365168556571007, 0.03038482740521431, -0.04590373858809471, 0.04008139297366142, 0.004641733597964048, 0.003837915835902095, -0.02761838585138321, -0.026236485689878464, 0.014500685036182404, -0.059343624860048294, 0.015426828525960445, 0.06167210265994072, -0.0862230733036995, -0.011451523751020432, -0.054180338978767395, -0.03031139448285103, 0.029477931559085846, -0.07659497857093811, -0.003942206036299467, 0.05503581091761589, 0.014016836881637573, -0.033022284507751465, 0.03603518754243851, 0.057510826736688614, 0.03839486092329025, 0.009626021608710289, 0.034424763172864914, 0.009651632979512215, -0.0926160141825676, 0.030871542170643806, -0.03231857717037201, -0.009633511304855347, 0.03867732733488083, 0.009123085997998714, 0.007845554500818253, 0.005323847755789757, -0.011184152215719223, -0.014927361160516739, 0.023980330675840378, -0.006049289833754301, -0.03296290710568428, -0.04277690500020981, -0.028442613780498505, -0.06593992561101913, 0.00878013577312231, -0.0693732500076294, 0.01990596018731594, -0.0330609567463398, -0.030783629044890404, 0.03185795247554779, -0.03477837145328522, -0.033734895288944244, -0.04180128499865532, -0.021188929677009583, -0.0008211883832700551, -0.017368825152516365, -0.07098066806793213, -0.035256464034318924, -0.009129481390118599, 0.03826488181948662, -0.018666213378310204, -0.02383846789598465, -0.02446933090686798, -0.05681901425123215, -0.01916775479912758, -0.035292044281959534, 0.019944122061133385, 0.024732977151870728, -0.05737898126244545, 0.0386025533080101, 0.030567355453968048, 0.02909781225025654, 0.030269095674157143, 0.045265521854162216, -0.06405270844697952, -0.005906798876821995, 0.07259723544120789, -0.03225642070174217, -0.01653963141143322, 0.021181320771574974, 0.025529678910970688, -0.02946823462843895, 0.02329663187265396, 0.04163257032632828, 0.06732973456382751, -0.032119691371917725, -0.042316779494285583, -0.04053720459342003, 0.035817816853523254, -0.03427150845527649, -0.0006359119433909655, 0.06669846177101135, 0.05417321249842644, -0.0025827393401414156, 0.005718212109059095, -0.0641612634062767, -0.023331062868237495, -0.018880628049373627, -0.05810140073299408, -0.05995927378535271, -0.04179641604423523, 0.007181771099567413, -0.07562267035245895, -0.03472508490085602, 0.021994885057210922, -0.05284847691655159, 0.0005552241345867515, -0.07112602889537811, -0.018142253160476685, -0.028205109760165215, 0.034810516983270645, 0.02259843610227108, -0.00805931817740202, -0.02497776597738266, -0.00882604718208313, -0.015029093250632286, -0.00024061411386355758, -0.04132398962974548, -0.0482381135225296, -0.04391651228070259, 0.00620088679715991, -0.04095536097884178, -0.02681116573512554, 0.026940925046801567, -0.05199712514877319, 0.01604544185101986, -0.014173921197652817, 0.009461495094001293, -0.0016780613223090768, 0.023497726768255234, -0.0039008045569062233, -0.012569676153361797, -0.004911186173558235, -0.024189934134483337, -0.024495165795087814, -0.031652141362428665, -0.034577466547489166, -0.006042066961526871, 0.07025047391653061, -0.03159138932824135, -0.023023683577775955, -0.05179014056921005, 0.004852693527936935, 0.049750976264476776, -0.0057676006108522415, 0.02447047270834446, 0.020008787512779236, 0.05418441444635391, -0.051994871348142624, -0.04361420124769211, 0.010022073052823544, 0.01800372637808323, 0.014522760175168514, -0.007707179989665747, -0.036724627017974854, -0.05464279279112816, 0.03735153377056122, -0.08127108961343765, 0.025782445445656776, 0.038452520966529846, 0.07741770148277283, 0.010954219847917557, -0.0001434060832252726, 0.03345892205834389, -0.002253674902021885, 0.04998968541622162, -0.03315034881234169, 0.027948368340730667, 0.05544471740722656, 0.020093630999326706, -0.049846351146698, -0.035894282162189484, 0.037491705268621445, -0.06432797014713287, -0.039946164935827255, 0.017057398334145546, 0.004312803037464619, 0.013207406736910343, 0.0031452099792659283, -0.045742638409137726, -0.01825411431491375, 0.004050231538712978, 0.030467165634036064, 0.006036356557160616, -0.04488397762179375, 0.02909603901207447, -0.035036876797676086, 0.009534824639558792, 0.02735709212720394, -0.026026131585240364, 0.0009132263949140906, -0.017866672948002815, 0.024935033172369003, -0.056179746985435486, 0.04743741452693939, 0.039101213216781616, 0.004938451107591391, 0.03780972212553024, 0.05823206156492233, -0.005201214924454689, 0.04450986906886101, -0.018023980781435966, -0.04022523760795593, -0.029022909700870514, -0.03307441249489784, -0.03736918792128563, -0.007109346799552441, -0.07430422306060791, -0.010393429547548294, 0.049116350710392, 0.011277501471340656, -0.022674648091197014, 0.004367012996226549, 0.0069081601686775684, -0.007246708031743765, -0.0832759365439415, 0.000849403440952301, -0.0435139425098896, 0.018695076927542686, 0.0008267494267784059, -0.042502667754888535, 0.03638806194067001, -0.040584318339824677, -0.015536639839410782, -0.012751408852636814, 0.008030811324715614, -0.04998866096138954, -0.0029529044404625893, 0.03008858673274517, -0.0765867531299591, 0.004015735350549221, -0.07761571556329727, 0.02852076292037964, 0.0029496115166693926, 0.025883954018354416, -0.031230254098773003, -0.003009508829563856, 0.004915706813335419, 0.01995040848851204, 0.05025932565331459, 0.02196626365184784, -0.05765698105096817, -0.04913410544395447, 0.053456854075193405, -0.02572791278362274, 0.014976456761360168, -0.03541262447834015, -0.03542960062623024, 0.0007756935083307326, -0.027048280462622643, -0.013717250898480415, 0.00551682198420167, -0.037003811448812485, 0.0596698597073555, -0.045574482530355453, -0.030421391129493713, -0.0033049192279577255, 0.06535249203443527, -0.0634617730975151, -0.08481709659099579, -0.02932223118841648, -0.04329630732536316, -0.06962300091981888, -0.03855162113904953, 0.023509148508310318, 0.018727170303463936, -0.004360479302704334, 0.0018089161021634936, 0.0027801720425486565, 0.010588595643639565, 0.015259799547493458, -0.004836111795157194, -0.030835170298814774, -0.031111473217606544, -0.009867336601018906, -0.017866872251033783, -0.0583379790186882, -0.011981070972979069, 0.03434048220515251, -0.012876009568572044, -0.011720189824700356, 0.04422968998551369, 0.0061355819925665855, 0.0536874495446682, -0.07359423488378525, 0.04629933834075928, 0.05316794663667679, -0.009002028033137321, 0.009525910019874573, 0.05734666436910629, -0.003669963451102376, 0.05204564332962036, -0.033327363431453705, 0.03789946809411049, -0.03744145482778549, -0.03316127136349678, -0.01034326571971178, -0.00009231767035089433, -0.0040007103234529495, -0.03732841834425926, 0.04849892109632492, -0.011835814453661442, -0.058395251631736755, -0.02525564841926098, 0.006134637165814638, 0.013712262734770775, -0.04207899048924446, 0.043351028114557266, 0.006519582588225603, -0.040010251104831696, -0.04395601898431778, -0.03593550994992256, -0.009739561006426811, -0.003134122584015131, 0.00894197914749384, -0.05243644490838051, -0.017929235473275185, 0.015185151249170303, 0.027177881449460983, -0.006271013058722019, -0.028704078868031502, -0.0033005219884216785, 0.0077957287430763245, -0.014934629201889038, -0.012362436391413212, -0.0711829736828804, -0.01492562796920538, -0.07109047472476959, 0.049883462488651276, 0.06372994184494019, -0.02068900130689144, 0.025267576798796654, 0.012047592550516129, -0.049060970544815063, 0.01888766698539257, 0.015998704358935356, -0.020084967836737633, -0.0036655827425420284, -0.031581707298755646, 0.047215886414051056, 0.017153605818748474, 0.013218478299677372, 0.051209378987550735, 0.038974497467279434, 0.009651816450059414, 0.012611609883606434, -0.03189729154109955, 0.01765555702149868, 0.009211206808686256, -0.057571135461330414, -0.035100359469652176, 0.05385693907737732, 0.026899291202425957, -0.031596798449754715, 0.03292703628540039, 0.014892318286001682, -0.04295879974961281, 0.02199205756187439, 0.01522559579461813, -0.03681400790810585, -0.028529608622193336, 0.012366271577775478, 0.06224243342876434, -0.01931816153228283, -0.007569579407572746, -0.01042927335947752, -0.02117178775370121, 0.01540665328502655, -0.023116393014788628, 0.007776929531246424, 0.007744093891233206, 0.016005374491214752, -0.04910106956958771, 0.04981044679880142, 0.013049401342868805, -0.07091625034809113, 0.02035171538591385, -0.0342056043446064, -0.0694824755191803, 0.0005663568736054003, 0.04461365565657616, 0.041434939950704575, -0.054883431643247604, 0.03507865592837334, -0.021733466535806656, 0.03455926105380058, -0.029465271160006523, 0.056447576731443405, 0.0794735699892044, -0.029054488986730576, -0.006483660079538822, -0.04064154997467995, -0.050281304866075516, -0.00006491989188361913, -0.01533737126737833, -0.02383197471499443, 0.04191387817263603, -0.011634007096290588, 0.00876667257398367, -0.032877229154109955, -0.03644615784287453, 0.05291072651743889, -0.017240500077605247, 0.0013566180132329464, 0.0178905688226223, -0.02436247281730175, 0.052002910524606705, -0.037231363356113434, 0.0107417618855834, 0.024184515699744225, 0.0006212118314579129, -0.0481703020632267, -0.05338117107748985, -0.035152971744537354, -0.014494325965642929, 0.006457334849983454, -0.020553061738610268, -0.08125080913305283, 0.03980439901351929, -0.036358047276735306, -0.07926521450281143, 0.018247166648507118, -0.03431647643446922, 0.0025088258553296328, 0.014694498851895332, 0.008826933801174164, 0.005593332927674055, 0.04919501394033432, -0.04132650047540665, -0.02165531925857067, 0.008922608569264412, 0.027367791160941124, 0.003413622733205557, -0.04862089082598686, -0.00004817475564777851, -0.011466000229120255, 0.029874533414840698, -0.048320360481739044, -0.040864672511816025, -0.010480770841240883, -0.02382260374724865, 0.021225852891802788, 0.03809264674782753, -0.01675237901508808, -0.05235437676310539, 0.03054038994014263, 0.0035074923653155565, 0.031113704666495323, -0.00792369619011879, -0.039201486855745316, -0.060898710042238235, -0.02194325067102909, 0.01399405486881733, -0.036586564034223557, 0.022564254701137543, 0.058243315666913986, 0.032581135630607605, 0.011959439143538475, 0.010129122994840145, -0.01965317130088806, 0.031087754294276237, 0.03325691819190979, -0.06690128147602081, 0.005134707782417536, 0.004535955842584372, -0.04099709168076515, -0.04516967758536339, 0.010368544608354568, 0.01874774508178234, -0.057311031967401505, -0.012583119794726372, 0.0370260626077652, 0.0014047606382519007, 0.02786015346646309, -0.05198047682642937, 0.0034595585893839598, -0.026790166273713112, -0.034326162189245224, -0.054519183933734894, 0.01558462344110012, -0.024065859615802765, -0.02309100143611431, 0.008094679564237595, -0.04761612415313721, -0.06594458222389221, 0.020191790536046028, -0.07904650270938873, 0.025044651702046394, -0.03438311442732811, 0.024717213585972786, -0.017444778233766556, -0.01289705652743578, 0.011560710147023201, -0.041413117200136185, 0.043594203889369965, -0.0038718227297067642, -0.006886081304401159, 0.033991213887929916, -0.016169678419828415, 0.028674563392996788, -0.0366162545979023, -0.008711746893823147, 0.0481051467359066, -0.0212248582392931, -0.03926282748579979, -0.007581545505672693, 0.0014374310849234462, -0.025743018835783005, 0.020399317145347595, 0.04624420776963234, -0.03397861123085022, 0.06463506817817688, -0.059032030403614044, 0.020948825404047966, -0.047783974558115005, -0.05406996235251427, 0.0058490559458732605, -0.036658093333244324, 0.02483244799077511, 0.03596518561244011, -0.04648793488740921, -0.016934150829911232, -0.028946269303560257, -0.047739092260599136, 0.026562567800283432, -0.034316807985305786, -0.04710323363542557, 0.056985680013895035, 0.035098861902952194, -0.04072985425591469, -0.047887951135635376, -0.0163295678794384, -0.021231263875961304, 0.03409451246261597, 0.06963635236024857, -0.04573998600244522, -0.014819073490798473, -0.07080667465925217, 0.03838561102747917, -0.031238717958331108, -0.009783083572983742, -0.04063546285033226, 0.06802473962306976, 0.02991403453052044, -0.0035104036796838045, -0.012558698654174805, -0.0639699175953865, -0.04149240255355835, -0.07660316675901413, -0.0399683378636837, -0.0489344485104084, -0.0070288171991705894, -0.004041423089802265, 0.01919322833418846, 0.015293496660888195, 0.06167422980070114, 0.01937253400683403, 0.039061423391103745, 0.0025322979781776667, 0.0052111768163740635, -0.03099818527698517, 0.04716102406382561, 0.052333246916532516, 0.05264328420162201, -0.0007324297330342233, 0.021583739668130875, 0.01804175227880478, -0.0319531187415123, 0.0073023331351578236, -0.014537286944687366, 0.020136557519435883, -0.057654693722724915, -0.006275875959545374, 0.002300861058756709, 0.01146136038005352, -0.05124810338020325, -0.013194347731769085, 0.0069708130322396755, -0.046253398060798645, -0.03797424957156181 ]
Exploring hit positions of recorded events can help to understand and suppress backgrounds in rare event searching experiments. In this study, we virtually segment a small contact P-type high purity germanium detector (HPGe) into two layers. Single-site events (SSEs) in each layer are selected by an algorithm based on two pulse shape parameters: the charge pulse drift time ($T_{Q}$) and current pulse rise time ($T_{I}$). To determine the shapes and volumes of the two layers, a Th-228 source is placed at top and side positions to irradiate the detector. The double escape peak events from 2614.5 keV $\gamma$-ray are selected as typical SSEs, their numbers in the two layers are used to calculate the volumes and shapes of those layers. Considering the statistical and systematic uncertainties, the inner layer volume is evaluated to be 47.2\%$\pm$0.26(stat.)\%$\pm$0.22(sys.)\% of the total sensitive volume. We extend our analysis for SSEs in 1400-2100 keV, the spectra of inner layer events acquired from experimental data using the selection algorithm are in good agreement with those from the simulation. For sources outside the HPGe detector, the outer layer can act as a shielding for the inner layer. Selecting the inner layer as the analysis volume can reduce the externalbackground in the signal region of Ge-76 neutrinoless double beta (0$\nu\beta\beta$) decay. We use the Th-228 source to evaluate the background suppression power of the virtual segmentation. After performing the single and multi-site event discrimination, the event rate in the 0$\nu\beta\beta$ signal region can be further suppressed by 12\% by selecting the inner layer as the analysis volume. The virtual segmentation could be used to efficiently suppress surface background like electrons from Ar-42/K-42 decay in 0$\nu\beta\beta$ experiments using germanium detector immersed in liquid argon.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03605v1
[ -0.0345492847263813, -0.05508770793676376, 0.042561326175928116, 0.004561387933790684, -0.006396146956831217, 0.012052053585648537, 0.005490810610353947, 0.04644101485610008, -0.052519187331199646, 0.012472000904381275, -0.030293840914964676, -0.019231481477618217, -0.0404348261654377, -0.06303027272224426, -0.04616512358188629, 0.03812776505947113, 0.06429160386323929, 0.010877929627895355, -0.03361322358250618, 0.06651619076728821, -0.004223148338496685, -0.023421788588166237, 0.021944239735603333, 0.05405481159687042, 0.002343375002965331, -0.05133131518959999, -0.01581832766532898, -0.01771336980164051, -0.03108097054064274, -0.018988799303770065, 0.017386512830853462, -0.029036112129688263, 0.00502473209053278, -0.042066242545843124, 0.019406266510486603, -0.031403034925460815, -0.059718601405620575, 0.051352985203266144, 0.02678556554019451, -0.05246356874704361, -0.005375537555664778, -0.07499523460865021, -0.05805987864732742, -0.031799715012311935, -0.012195130810141563, 0.003472182434052229, -0.03253251314163208, 0.005660282913595438, -0.048111047595739365, -0.048083528876304626, 0.0008392140152864158, 0.012041989713907242, -0.05527142807841301, 0.04829026386141777, 0.007707318291068077, -0.02309444174170494, 0.002103865146636963, -0.0024949810467660427, -0.05732407048344612, -0.019506540149450302, 0.05861099809408188, -0.0626804381608963, -0.04595090076327324, -0.018983440473675728, -0.026091868057847023, 0.06626056879758835, -0.051597289741039276, -0.04055490717291832, -0.004305958282202482, -0.06786853075027466, 0.0034740858245640993, -0.0707046315073967, 0.041374754160642624, 0.013870838098227978, -0.054624106734991074, -0.023793069645762444, -0.010159163735806942, 0.011505465023219585, -0.04584810137748718, 0.01900799199938774, -0.030181780457496643, 0.01963900215923786, 0.01165018230676651, 0.03821459040045738, 0.025932716205716133, -0.02706901915371418, 0.04963240027427673, -0.0461934357881546, -0.02975337579846382, -0.06966491788625717, -0.02136451192200184, -0.06660864502191544, -0.04365680366754532, -0.016489451751112938, 0.06489507108926773, -0.010254660621285439, 0.08025664836168289, 0.014713448472321033, 0.05616296827793121, 0.017737073823809624, -0.013637897558510303, -0.008227795362472534, 0.0015811733901500702, 0.054380156099796295, 0.05699120834469795, -0.01570552960038185, -0.03268694505095482, -0.017021406441926956, -0.046958938241004944, 0.04453325271606445, -0.01795279234647751, 0.0007125993724912405, -0.0004684966115746647, -0.05795902758836746, -0.039637044072151184, -0.030526697635650635, 0.08071170002222061, 0.017370615154504776, 0.03918328136205673, -0.006621230393648148, -0.0179594699293375, 0.055810801684856415, 0.03097371943295002, 0.021769298240542412, -0.03515072911977768, 0.004492003936320543, 0.03757075220346451, 0.006727580912411213, 0.03033502772450447, 0.005805120803415775, 0.05257856100797653, 0.016141198575496674, 0.009774057194590569, 0.023807695135474205, 0.012622114270925522, -0.022256556898355484, -0.000029102913686074317, -0.027241356670856476, -0.051876116544008255, 0.0026224127504974604, -0.04889338091015816, -0.037856921553611755, -0.007625590078532696, 0.03431645408272743, 0.026861852034926414, 0.03197573870420456, -0.031018489971756935, -0.0039420705288648605, 0.05558188259601593, 0.021661439910531044, -0.006941627245396376, -0.04627315700054169, 0.014359639026224613, -0.02310720831155777, -0.010120137594640255, 0.008845468051731586, 0.062330227345228195, -0.01882234960794449, -0.027208680287003517, 0.013560046441853046, 0.013935932889580727, 0.005392125807702541, 0.0369831807911396, -0.015449265018105507, 0.0034842430613934994, -0.00784154050052166, 0.02649884857237339, -0.024831384420394897, 0.023561108857393265, 0.010177823714911938, -0.0021402572747319937, -0.008180012926459312, 0.01167717669159174, -0.04978305473923683, -0.07629656791687012, -0.05650271847844124, 0.012283978052437305, -0.043942421674728394, -0.05096789821982384, -0.025539055466651917, -0.011722462251782417, 0.028687991201877594, -0.027747977524995804, 0.008947666734457016, -0.0706978514790535, -0.0018767239525914192, -0.0824781209230423, 0.03258085623383522, 0.058614712208509445, 0.004501256626099348, 0.026882367208600044, 0.011351590976119041, -0.008854982443153858, -0.020687703043222427, -0.014932742342352867, -0.012000961229205132, 0.04768123850226402, -0.04041245952248573, 0.042493633925914764, -0.01373467780649662, -0.07136882841587067, -0.023520829156041145, -0.06550630182027817, 0.02993660606443882, 0.021911438554525375, -0.07115650177001953, 0.008404136635363102, 0.002283657668158412, 0.0140419602394104, -0.020190149545669556, 0.03425867483019829, 0.03753272071480751, -0.007436743471771479, 0.013608453795313835, -0.054946113377809525, -0.03513184189796448, -0.09283380955457687, 0.028147028759121895, 0.024830380454659462, -0.010070541873574257, 0.029988545924425125, 0.021738102659583092, -0.010251018218696117, -0.014591100625693798, 0.0021637810859829187, 0.03405699506402016, 0.036992397159338, -0.0360037200152874, -0.0283026285469532, 0.010459371842443943, -0.02424364537000656, -0.07516977936029434, -0.023506443947553635, -0.07701205462217331, 0.009078241884708405, -0.022838788107037544, 0.013047958724200726, 0.06557226926088333, -0.007337820716202259, -0.018841976299881935, -0.03689534589648247, 0.006660663988441229, 0.02904483675956726, -0.025628456845879555, -0.047255318611860275, -0.015282540582120419, -0.05258296802639961, 0.023840676993131638, 0.021682487800717354, -0.019824856892228127, -0.0041906763799488544, -0.05497380346059799, -0.028281735256314278, -0.01979665458202362, 0.01702255569398403, -0.0002681942714843899, -0.03249090909957886, 0.04246986284852028, -0.022654395550489426, 0.06696703284978867, 0.05201272293925285, -0.0009197042090818286, -0.02648117020726204, -0.019418535754084587, -0.00972385611385107, 0.013376024551689625, -0.030182959511876106, 0.02148769050836563, -0.027737196534872055, -0.03862009197473526, 0.0037500783801078796, 0.005164764355868101, 0.06290639936923981, 0.012105664238333702, -0.04119962081313133, -0.04433180391788483, -0.04386333376169205, -0.017919199541211128, 0.05113363638520241, 0.04409872367978096, 0.061016786843538284, 0.06508240103721619, -0.00493007805198431, -0.07283046096563339, 0.03998388350009918, -0.04810598865151405, 0.00525654386729002, -0.07885932177305222, -0.04934227094054222, 0.004052432719618082, -0.06365663558244705, 0.013454833067953587, -0.01717333309352398, -0.06101439148187637, -0.04244847595691681, -0.05155804008245468, -0.044232696294784546, 0.01460574846714735, 0.016752691939473152, -0.04777516424655914, -0.05652433633804321, 0.005533300340175629, 0.04026942700147629, 0.05475148186087608, -0.017793046310544014, 0.0034553322475403547, -0.045757509768009186, -0.008539349772036076, 0.034404050558805466, 0.004464796744287014, -0.03357135131955147, -0.029093807563185692, -0.05963067710399628, 0.03692830353975296, -0.04405985027551651, 0.007090657949447632, -0.011827349662780762, 0.016569815576076508, 0.01638316549360752, -0.012835905887186527, 0.008297000080347061, -0.03314335271716118, 0.03848779574036598, -0.041796669363975525, -0.05853434279561043, -0.019162671640515327, 0.04584835469722748, 0.021308450028300285, 0.01669434830546379, -0.05541184917092323, -0.026747336611151695, 0.0411255769431591, -0.04411650821566582, 0.01833580806851387, 0.06475725024938583, -0.017082104459404945, -0.05174881964921951, -0.016796067357063293, -0.04909798875451088, 0.04711608961224556, 0.021788591518998146, 0.024571310728788376, 0.009302507154643536, 0.012439116835594177, -0.02757747657597065, -0.06623050570487976, 0.06393150240182877, 0.06557455658912659, 0.07763320952653885, 0.0037209829315543175, -0.019738471135497093, 0.039347149431705475, 0.014436617493629456, 0.025454632937908173, 0.010603664442896843, 0.013666395097970963, 0.038855042308568954, 0.045164406299591064, -0.03967466205358505, -0.03900821506977081, -0.02599192224442959, -0.0475294254720211, -0.06731860339641571, -0.024204635992646217, -0.016134269535541534, 0.06315882503986359, 0.015973735600709915, -0.00073049939237535, 0.062334612011909485, -0.0009792015189304948, 0.06482038646936417, 0.02338523603975773, 0.01189056970179081, 0.0006414740346372128, -0.037793274968862534, 0.044781845062971115, 0.03584442287683487, -0.05453488975763321, 0.0019299970008432865, -0.068944551050663, 0.006005567964166403, -0.03985366225242615, 0.01708286441862583, 0.011473165825009346, -0.007369506638497114, 0.005660049617290497, 0.00887715257704258, 0.011644845828413963, 0.05418384447693825, 0.007754868362098932, 0.010282604955136776, -0.015598524361848831, -0.02237251028418541, 0.021908309310674667, -0.007561421487480402, 0.011815928854048252, -0.0018662987276911736, 0.02060982957482338, -0.0633271262049675, -0.009591073729097843, -0.017583495005965233, -0.02878103405237198, -0.0283016636967659, -0.06846877932548523, -0.014672924764454365, -0.033447787165641785, 0.017824355512857437, -0.029367422685027122, -0.006888489704579115, 0.04434075579047203, 0.010787458159029484, -0.017612295225262642, -0.04654092714190483, 0.006157492753118277, -0.05185985565185547, -0.040442146360874176, -0.02718985825777054, -0.052095603197813034, 0.053642645478248596, -0.043497830629348755, 0.04631710425019264, 0.0038055679760873318, -0.05331851541996002, -0.0448208712041378, -0.038622789084911346, -0.0014421844389289618, 0.0014229471562430263, 0.02591201290488243, 0.03745395317673683, -0.017227087169885635, 0.04288441687822342, -0.007322071585804224, 0.028175653889775276, -0.0065968697890639305, 0.030298396944999695, -0.03700128197669983, 0.05694949999451637, -0.013384558260440826, -0.048798151314258575, -0.0034123638179153204, 0.002359977690503001, 0.0448145754635334, -0.036858025938272476, -0.007584803272038698, 0.02614564634859562, 0.03707887977361679, -0.06236720085144043, -0.048664577305316925, 0.015046687796711922, -0.04485394060611725, -0.06200137361884117, 0.003206513822078705, 0.022612420842051506, -0.0054611144587397575, 0.014206064864993095, 0.05520368367433548, -0.03677605837583542, 0.03942802920937538, -0.06801149249076843, 0.032327547669410706, -0.02480720356106758, 0.028121916577219963, 0.007215685676783323, -0.02365075796842575, -0.06295830756425858, 0.02756044641137123, -0.02109309658408165, -0.0443275086581707, 0.03093656525015831, 0.04235239699482918, 0.0008131806389428675, 0.04936438798904419, -0.07242640852928162, 0.025820434093475342, 0.04981048032641411, 0.0036951445508748293, -0.0005280800978653133, 0.04504377394914627, -0.003993348218500614, 0.02970001846551895, -0.035170044749975204, -0.01899562031030655, -0.005733684170991182, -0.048465292900800705, 0.0016464687651023269, 0.022149445489048958, -0.031149115413427353, -0.004377506673336029, 0.02361898683011532, 0.023305319249629974, -0.0656740814447403, -0.00017407046107109636, 0.010087424889206886, -0.011865743435919285, -0.03203414008021355, 0.041281551122665405, 0.0455758199095726, -0.06412620842456818, -0.06133901700377464, 0.006432802882045507, -0.022216038778424263, 0.046441901475191116, 0.0311545729637146, -0.05411088466644287, -0.00397582957521081, -0.032705776393413544, 0.026134811341762543, 0.021662920713424683, 0.028561171144247055, -0.016678771004080772, 0.0051083690486848354, 0.03701399266719818, -0.028860008344054222, -0.065313421189785, -0.011761177331209183, -0.008647032082080841, 0.01982378214597702, 0.043087515980005264, 0.023355906829237938, 0.03523118793964386, 0.01973595656454563, 0.011350457556545734, -0.06389880925416946, -0.016106903553009033, 0.005591333843767643, 0.05494939908385277, -0.0331215038895607, -0.020989159122109413, 0.011605704203248024, 0.07681400328874588, 0.0032303552143275738, 0.025333935394883156, 0.04103261977434158, 0.013764766976237297, -0.06464420258998871, -0.01621527224779129, 0.03372178599238396, 0.03904982656240463, -0.0654640942811966, -0.01915890909731388, 0.049169447273015976, -0.05665481090545654, 0.06991470605134964, 0.014161663129925728, -0.007749181240797043, -0.009399243630468845, 0.0238512996584177, 0.03454095870256424, -0.07293013483285904, 0.019480915740132332, 0.05952196940779686, -0.048549726605415344, 0.011517207138240337, -0.053443942219018936, 0.017081309109926224, 0.03273860737681389, -0.04042699933052063, 0.0031856351997703314, 0.023874429985880852, -0.004768153186887503, -0.05021536350250244, 0.046742189675569534, -0.0034396490082144737, -0.053509630262851715, 0.026703909039497375, 0.000014831174667051528, -0.078348807990551, -0.0005263044149614871, -0.01955227367579937, 0.006606364622712135, -0.002435327973216772, -0.00302355014719069, -0.07062298059463501, -0.004466128069907427, -0.008573731407523155, 0.053292252123355865, 0.03895919770002365, 0.006680270191282034, -0.02539391815662384, 0.0096800671890378, -0.018599430099129677, -0.007086317986249924, -0.015194888226687908, -0.035974401980638504, -0.008982427418231964, 0.05845561996102333, 0.009320015087723732, -0.010944142937660217, -0.0005375741166062653, 0.05522396042943001, -0.02569500170648098, 0.03350050002336502, 0.0066374423913657665, -0.010826441459357738, 0.046855442225933075, -0.01642482727766037, -0.057700324803590775, 0.0034561383072286844, -0.01567874290049076, -0.0471770204603672, -0.035419758409261703, 0.022395463660359383, -0.0045081852003932, 0.02655285969376564, 0.03528706356883049, -0.04918273165822029, 0.009671594016253948, -0.016294831410050392, -0.026871604844927788, 0.037830520421266556, -0.08697164803743362, -0.035665545612573624, -0.0048112450167536736, 0.04405279830098152, 0.01773081347346306, 0.01230439729988575, -0.06052456796169281, -0.011965236626565456, -0.0033686875831335783, -0.013119206763803959, 0.02633819915354252, 0.05580461025238037, 0.05844254419207573, -0.0353550910949707, 0.021298889070749283, -0.045887406915426254, -0.019643671810626984, -0.015660613775253296, -0.06478333473205566, 0.007839398458600044, 0.025405146181583405, -0.03415553271770477, -0.05773808807134628, 0.044624797999858856, -0.04102081432938576, 0.04426981508731842, 0.035421356558799744, 0.001998112304136157, -0.04778643324971199, -0.01790112815797329, 0.008679619058966637, -0.04258180037140846, 0.05036533251404762, 0.021747183054685593, 0.035199686884880066, 0.01889306679368019, -0.006772187538444996, 0.010800976306200027, 0.007934950292110443, 0.010124243795871735, -0.033947378396987915, -0.018122952431440353, 0.050841074436903, 0.009827536530792713, 0.0027376236394047737, -0.026910394430160522, -0.06106298416852951, -0.08429574966430664, -0.030111661180853844, 0.051661137491464615, -0.04656675457954407, -0.017566116526722908, -0.03067103773355484, -0.013155318796634674, 0.02272127941250801, -0.007728186901658773, -0.07595930993556976, -0.03266148641705513, 0.024927036836743355, 0.027748554944992065, -0.025933437049388885, -0.02376936934888363, -0.05837160348892212, -0.018354473635554314, -0.08867523819208145, -0.019390366971492767, -0.014548562467098236, 0.03521537780761719, 0.028391769155859947, -0.03201998397707939, -0.038798797875642776, -0.040409546345472336, -0.0016434300923720002, 0.022267211228609085, -0.01365711074322462, 0.010023005306720734, 0.008239415474236012, 0.009162796661257744, -0.034492235630750656, -0.039224207401275635, 0.042297303676605225, 0.005042902193963528, -0.06001921370625496, 0.03949466720223427, 0.01578333228826523, -0.058944471180438995, 0.036287955939769745, 0.07490614801645279, 0.04133150726556778, 0.03598671033978462, -0.026222461834549904, -0.0028247379232198, -0.06567209959030151, -0.036024708300828934, 0.055352773517370224, -0.052014950662851334, -0.007546841166913509, -0.014530936256051064, -0.011561539955437183, -0.01978018321096897, -0.04200407862663269, -0.049428652971982956, 0.006567937787622213, 0.005140101071447134, 0.0261718537658453, 0.042065031826496124, -0.04817108064889908, 0.0468548983335495, 0.0036545717157423496, 0.02007623016834259, -0.04051357880234718, -0.011932393535971642, 0.051455944776535034, -0.06495920568704605, -0.02557424269616604, -0.03850564733147621, 0.020945534110069275, -0.017382889986038208, 0.022149361670017242, -0.022583432495594025, 0.06872984021902084, -0.0239317175000906, 0.003208233742043376, -0.055391576141119, -0.0067202746868133545, -0.004668235778808594, -0.06146456301212311, -0.028605308383703232, 0.021425532177090645, 0.010149583220481873, 0.014188741333782673, 0.03227955847978592, -0.039488427340984344, 0.045492928475141525, 0.004421132616698742, -0.0058399527333676815, -0.013906900770962238, -0.0005632313550449908, -0.02828166075050831, 0.03895048424601555, -0.011531087569892406, -0.011531610041856766, -0.029318049550056458, -0.013333807699382305, 0.055721934884786606, -0.020373910665512085, -0.03320642188191414, -0.01724236272275448, -0.03061043657362461, -0.03239588066935539, 0.016277311369776726, 0.035999588668346405, -0.024467140436172485, -0.056327227503061295, -0.013704856857657433, 0.024216722697019577, -0.024257667362689972, -0.015284626744687557 ]
Logic locking and hardware Trojans are two fields in hardware security that have been mostly developed independently from each other. In this paper, we identify the relationship between these two fields. We find that a common structure that exists in many logic locking techniques has desirable properties of hardware Trojans (HWT). We then construct a novel type of HWT, called Trojans based on Logic Locking (TroLL), in a way that can evade state-of-the-art ATPG-based HWT detection techniques. In an effort to detect TroLL, we propose customization of existing state-of-the-art ATPG-based HWT detection approaches as well as adapting the SAT-based attacks on logic locking to HWT detection. In our experiments, we use random sampling as reference. It is shown that the customized ATPG-based approaches are the best performing but only offer limited improvement over random sampling. Moreover, their efficacy also diminishes as TroLL's triggers become longer, i.e., have more bits specified). We thereby highlight the need to find a scalable HWT detection approach for TroLL.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15067v1
[ -0.004193257540464401, -0.06328137964010239, 0.031703777611255646, -0.008757716044783592, 0.020182505249977112, 0.014671322889626026, 0.004583483096212149, 0.02254488505423069, -0.014494866132736206, -0.029630711302161217, -0.025918375700712204, 0.01885833404958248, -0.03256598487496376, -0.028824999928474426, -0.04824618995189667, 0.01316317543387413, 0.08799757063388824, 0.006294469814747572, -0.017390325665473938, 0.07488736510276794, -0.0046065920032560825, 0.019227664917707443, -0.056203268468379974, 0.020764349028468132, 0.014269364066421986, 0.016788555309176445, -0.031633853912353516, -0.005913021508604288, -0.051331162452697754, 0.02352653443813324, 0.08043088763952255, -0.010044810362160206, -0.035559508949518204, -0.04701874032616615, -0.017939690500497818, -0.04727959632873535, 0.030335498973727226, 0.020643487572669983, 0.028466083109378815, -0.06554973125457764, 0.01229933649301529, -0.04285745322704315, -0.060494258999824524, -0.04034411162137985, -0.012006165459752083, 0.045753613114356995, -0.03669958934187889, -0.0065737152472138405, -0.014607371762394905, -0.02129443921148777, 0.03670448437333107, -0.013009029440581799, 0.002340693026781082, 0.03707270696759224, -0.030223866924643517, 0.0186037365347147, -0.034592896699905396, 0.029592296108603477, -0.023520324379205704, 0.011796734295785427, -0.014228629879653454, -0.026111967861652374, -0.02376811020076275, 0.02060704305768013, 0.0008919889223761857, 0.04261740297079086, -0.002997966017574072, -0.06401250511407852, -0.019390251487493515, -0.010767381638288498, 0.07357539236545563, -0.0372689925134182, 0.023387929424643517, 0.001533451140858233, -0.035861387848854065, -0.021000603213906288, -0.05421862751245499, -0.016140704974532127, 0.03462665155529976, -0.05199979618191719, -0.049664534628391266, 0.03570491075515747, 0.032205551862716675, -0.02722172997891903, -0.004667029716074467, -0.026512376964092255, 0.0493784062564373, 0.00573233887553215, 0.03000948391854763, -0.03581038862466812, 0.04654187336564064, -0.01420643925666809, -0.07792160660028458, -0.006057430524379015, 0.056979209184646606, -0.04971116781234741, 0.05769253894686699, 0.04486948996782303, 0.05526319146156311, -0.0006788527825847268, -0.014108866453170776, -0.03943921998143196, -0.055727697908878326, 0.05203423276543617, 0.05003063380718231, 0.009426294825971127, 0.04664447531104088, 0.024287886917591095, -0.04466531053185463, 0.028846625238656998, -0.046348776668310165, -0.010356707498431206, 0.03792058676481247, -0.05972682684659958, -0.04277685284614563, 0.0020703517366200686, 0.0870576947927475, 0.009845864027738571, 0.05525746941566467, 0.03405413404107094, -0.04343179240822792, 0.059467632323503494, 0.03819512948393822, 0.052450984716415405, -0.05271914228796959, -0.027928510680794716, 0.04381832107901573, 0.027027560397982597, -0.01775648631155491, 0.0073033408261835575, 0.02955622412264347, -0.00032676314003765583, 0.0016670420300215483, -0.008257301524281502, 0.03150468319654465, -0.01744600012898445, 0.0165896974503994, -0.06111158803105354, -0.010321377776563168, -0.03502025082707405, -0.03676316887140274, -0.06823273748159409, 0.022935576736927032, -0.041750457137823105, 0.0511036142706871, 0.06238311529159546, -0.03925498202443123, -0.037334177643060684, 0.028890559449791908, 0.01547093503177166, 0.007838656194508076, 0.031161539256572723, 0.0035290559753775597, 0.022324372082948685, 0.04668451100587845, -0.0007566977292299271, 0.03548040613532066, -0.039193399250507355, -0.02909008227288723, -0.028107523918151855, 0.003513844683766365, -0.012964311055839062, 0.03611357882618904, 0.007276400923728943, -0.0031528379768133163, -0.05617193877696991, 0.01306831557303667, 0.01109272986650467, -0.013187277130782604, 0.03875255212187767, 0.0006822030409239233, -0.03472891449928284, 0.01787961646914482, -0.03171791136264801, -0.06878656893968582, -0.04331950470805168, 0.03155393525958061, -0.06725118309259415, -0.04072510823607445, -0.015488055534660816, 0.03735829144716263, 0.020392807200551033, -0.024462472647428513, -0.033988893032073975, -0.026474604383111, 0.0027434395160526037, -0.05559086054563522, -0.02549661323428154, 0.05887934938073158, 0.026414673775434494, -0.03773770481348038, -0.010190888307988644, 0.02565627358853817, 0.019307367503643036, 0.008900299668312073, -0.05432358756661415, -0.02973640151321888, -0.03173605352640152, 0.0326337106525898, 0.02822170965373516, -0.09055525064468384, -0.0016565631376579404, -0.05584753304719925, 0.03089299239218235, -0.00128193071577698, -0.05071078985929489, 0.0029732482507824898, 0.026793772354722023, -0.027836978435516357, -0.03341938555240631, 0.07082582265138626, 0.015401417389512062, 0.06128668040037155, 0.007880118675529957, 0.03812655806541443, 0.024836597964167595, -0.1106223538517952, 0.003952173050493002, -0.023252064362168312, 0.023599131032824516, 0.04194021224975586, -0.0012362106936052442, 0.0210486501455307, -0.018715620040893555, -0.0024517117999494076, 0.03739795461297035, 0.043168190866708755, -0.026921747252345085, -0.03682621940970421, -0.05623432993888855, 0.011253726668655872, -0.020313667133450508, 0.0036301463842391968, -0.06150052323937416, -0.017244815826416016, -0.0033109241630882025, -0.0388774499297142, 0.05730196833610535, 0.012422720901668072, -0.03590122237801552, -0.04002484306693077, 0.012653390876948833, -0.0063317748717963696, 0.023253802210092545, -0.058314647525548935, -0.038830891251564026, -0.020608441904187202, 0.03792493790388107, 0.006387587636709213, 0.03692787140607834, -0.04099544137716293, -0.013267109170556068, 0.010325661860406399, -0.012362523935735226, 0.03104645013809204, 0.012873699888586998, -0.025484472513198853, 0.018187265843153, -0.041308823972940445, 0.04473419114947319, 0.03747512400150299, 0.017393585294485092, -0.04254750534892082, -0.0061154491268098354, 0.04402659460902214, 0.016350753605365753, -0.013056572526693344, 0.03326813504099846, 0.02243744768202305, -0.05835022032260895, -0.01315572764724493, 0.018971402198076248, 0.044390082359313965, -0.01738923415541649, -0.04512996971607208, -0.019549379125237465, 0.0035862780641764402, -0.005686748772859573, 0.028028137981891632, 0.02989245019853115, 0.04716993495821953, 0.011644970625638962, -0.016225965693593025, -0.0820993036031723, -0.029332119971513748, 0.00006420192949008197, -0.006638858933001757, -0.05701012164354324, -0.025329232215881348, -0.04498361051082611, -0.08416128158569336, 0.04301101341843605, -0.025518659502267838, 0.01637844182550907, -0.04988561198115349, -0.042516179382801056, -0.037010155618190765, -0.04221758991479874, 0.020108520984649658, -0.027633726596832275, -0.05499717593193054, -0.035775382071733475, 0.025159472599625587, -0.02340753562748432, 0.02725580707192421, -0.04309508576989174, -0.029375407844781876, -0.04324036464095116, 0.02935056947171688, 0.043427661061286926, -0.016165966168045998, 0.015942467376589775, -0.00633214320987463, 0.04577598348259926, -0.036398377269506454, 0.04675872623920441, 0.04151621833443642, 0.01363278552889824, -0.003754350822418928, -0.029043307527899742, -0.007862798869609833, 0.012762101367115974, 0.005639040842652321, -0.060231879353523254, -0.04873266443610191, 0.03748397156596184, 0.06086030602455139, 0.01225042063742876, -0.005339293275028467, -0.03309381753206253, 0.02150845155119896, 0.0244426466524601, 0.01757517270743847, -0.0025309377815574408, -0.013667342253029346, 0.06994622945785522, -0.05087912455201149, -0.026866912841796875, 0.013379454612731934, 0.003832048736512661, -0.023902008309960365, 0.06580650806427002, -0.018311897292733192, -0.02637500874698162, 0.008684024214744568, -0.0889962911605835, 0.04759209603071213, 0.03800686448812485, 0.045742329210042953, -0.03154432028532028, 0.07042499631643295, 0.026198845356702805, 0.045640893280506134, 0.0464833565056324, 0.026273168623447418, 0.016392260789871216, 0.013408102095127106, 0.04300922900438309, -0.05053412541747093, -0.02950628288090229, 0.049308087676763535, -0.0038832221180200577, -0.04724676162004471, 0.0014917204389348626, -0.05071832984685898, 0.0317525640130043, -0.04510088637471199, -0.03653744235634804, 0.06337137520313263, -0.02315674163401127, 0.05086645483970642, 0.035002388060092926, -0.04633277654647827, 0.00040199203067459166, -0.01992015913128853, 0.03346983715891838, 0.02111467905342579, -0.012174272909760475, 0.0081200385466218, -0.04985332489013672, -0.015660108998417854, -0.06333746016025543, -0.007221426349133253, 0.04925564303994179, 0.005065497942268848, 0.009393475018441677, 0.01520274393260479, -0.04843868315219879, 0.06903650611639023, -0.013185471296310425, -0.02604196034371853, -0.03457467630505562, 0.030725836753845215, 0.03095587156713009, -0.02339053899049759, -0.025424934923648834, -0.014759316109120846, 0.006456055212765932, -0.06314966827630997, 0.0007022942882031202, 0.001497729099355638, -0.014694220386445522, 0.03113342635333538, -0.07737310230731964, -0.019674869254231453, -0.0359816737473011, 0.047886934131383896, -0.015106623992323875, -0.05164491757750511, 0.03643752634525299, -0.05459010973572731, 0.017700521275401115, -0.029143040999770164, 0.0001149751988123171, -0.03700600564479828, -0.02447337657213211, 0.00760518666356802, -0.05166998505592346, 0.010486657731235027, -0.03766639158129692, 0.020205553621053696, 0.039141252636909485, -0.02116570807993412, -0.04470667615532875, 0.016110053285956383, 0.04692470282316208, 0.05622418597340584, 0.05421586334705353, 0.02112986333668232, 0.03134653717279434, -0.014853831380605698, -0.0028232778422534466, -0.009319660253822803, -0.012391608208417892, -0.016685545444488525, -0.04102687910199165, 0.020582569763064384, -0.046535674482584, -0.03004777617752552, -0.04422388970851898, -0.007115547079592943, 0.05256180092692375, -0.03243347629904747, -0.04145696759223938, 0.02142988331615925, -0.0014396528713405132, -0.059988006949424744, -0.04997337982058525, 0.002121497178450227, -0.018983758985996246, -0.05301744118332863, -0.04732692241668701, 0.0469009131193161, 0.06693129986524582, -0.025286782532930374, -0.004326346796005964, 0.021430013701319695, 0.05517452210187912, 0.016152923926711082, -0.017604675143957138, 0.048677027225494385, 0.02438763715326786, 0.040385834872722626, 0.008619464002549648, -0.06951379776000977, 0.00920550525188446, 0.01963975839316845, 0.0154142826795578, 0.01759265922009945, 0.05787960812449455, -0.012295740656554699, 0.048421695828437805, -0.06709091365337372, 0.034385036677122116, 0.052014123648405075, -0.032223064452409744, 0.008488931693136692, 0.08154267817735672, -0.012551338411867619, 0.062126524746418, -0.02607530914247036, 0.006341815460473299, 0.034305598586797714, -0.06173528730869293, 0.00026957367663271725, -0.005569193512201309, -0.039263635873794556, 0.013145863078534603, 0.059916991740465164, 0.015863971784710884, -0.07512173801660538, 0.037220876663923264, 0.042543526738882065, 0.013770570047199726, -0.05318869650363922, 0.0519358329474926, 0.03132791817188263, -0.006521122995764017, -0.0127421198412776, -0.0021712598390877247, 0.027326473966240883, 0.042167820036411285, 0.027860179543495178, -0.06567320972681046, -0.017141755670309067, 0.006011584773659706, -0.02273748442530632, -0.012603647075593472, -0.0025534348096698523, 0.0015177398454397917, -0.011152059771120548, -0.020147694274783134, 0.011608853004872799, -0.024569012224674225, -0.04700439050793648, -0.021965857595205307, 0.027898982167243958, 0.04030102491378784, 0.01744351163506508, 0.02660631202161312, -0.004686146043241024, -0.033963240683078766, -0.0540323406457901, -0.028142917901277542, -0.023268969729542732, 0.022303301841020584, -0.028998440131545067, 0.03250447288155556, -0.04229319840669632, 0.05748225003480911, 0.04483780264854431, -0.014922854490578175, -0.021953905001282692, 0.011391656473279, -0.03348993882536888, 0.0324111208319664, 0.012519451789557934, -0.03231888636946678, -0.06089664623141289, 0.017083050683140755, 0.057798899710178375, -0.020281650125980377, 0.012214777059853077, 0.030019497498869896, 0.030517982318997383, -0.027489634230732918, 0.03184079751372337, -0.03317607566714287, -0.030289538204669952, 0.005111804697662592, 0.0714544728398323, -0.03717316687107086, -0.011139861308038235, 0.006651825737208128, 0.02199985459446907, 0.016545863822102547, -0.015657398849725723, 0.005544526502490044, 0.047205712646245956, 0.020199356600642204, -0.06689775735139847, 0.06147700920701027, -0.012281280010938644, -0.07031527161598206, -0.004032348282635212, -0.0003781634150072932, -0.08651168644428253, 0.02627852000296116, 0.05160210654139519, -0.03557834401726723, -0.05305525287985802, 0.04745222628116608, -0.0041792853735387325, -0.039731208235025406, 0.013341299258172512, 0.0666925385594368, 0.04798085615038872, -0.03676604852080345, 0.02635408565402031, 0.0359174944460392, -0.04854276403784752, 0.024775536730885506, -0.03916238993406296, -0.006187316030263901, 0.058040134608745575, 0.03782586008310318, 0.03088853508234024, -0.0419657938182354, -0.020059889182448387, 0.0387645959854126, -0.030973166227340698, 0.012724318541586399, 0.02790970914065838, -0.019624434411525726, 0.05461154878139496, -0.0185195691883564, -0.03939572349190712, -0.008866406977176666, -0.0198931023478508, -0.021366020664572716, -0.02987637370824814, -0.001562230521813035, 0.029942484572529793, 0.01847635768353939, 0.01947355642914772, -0.050925739109516144, -0.05115392804145813, -0.002591103781014681, -0.06713288277387619, 0.04042791947722435, -0.04733230546116829, 0.029809966683387756, -0.002845385577529669, -0.00046417274279519916, -0.014372484758496284, 0.046609096229076385, -0.03555513918399811, -0.020436247810721397, -0.0017290423857048154, 0.03483739495277405, -0.000047770485252840444, 0.02269681729376316, 0.03753091022372246, 0.02776331827044487, -0.006115315016359091, -0.023474764078855515, -0.03768176585435867, -0.025868088006973267, -0.07969449460506439, 0.049903806298971176, -0.021184489130973816, -0.011193420737981796, -0.03968029096722603, -0.003501158207654953, -0.026978526264429092, 0.007254655472934246, -0.017217867076396942, -0.03680601343512535, -0.08779389411211014, 0.007274240721017122, -0.0005490194889716804, -0.02916715294122696, 0.029234062880277634, 0.03591203689575195, 0.008211128413677216, 0.020811356604099274, 0.01803410053253174, 0.006237484049052, 0.04002067819237709, 0.01990053430199623, -0.0157144907861948, -0.033062808215618134, 0.01275587361305952, -0.010754968039691448, 0.008154722861945629, 0.027219587936997414, -0.029907606542110443, -0.08727484196424484, 0.004105591680854559, 0.033679936081171036, -0.025651967152953148, -0.03251143917441368, -0.029509030282497406, -0.006850589532405138, 0.0028337484691292048, -0.037564489990472794, -0.012680141255259514, -0.03094511292874813, 0.000020644107280531898, -0.03323199599981308, -0.04696022719144821, -0.07252179086208344, -0.058694515377283096, -0.019719233736395836, -0.09136411547660828, -0.02578294835984707, 0.0037768350448459387, 0.027973860502243042, 0.029913349077105522, -0.007626672275364399, 0.011897502467036247, -0.02442151866853237, 0.019733812659978867, -0.026646114885807037, -0.032031990587711334, 0.03686283901333809, 0.023926490917801857, 0.012433316558599472, -0.047858625650405884, -0.006966565735638142, 0.044171884655952454, -0.012176374904811382, 0.017122110351920128, 0.016782043501734734, 0.04211140796542168, -0.012227514758706093, -0.003629860235378146, 0.06558527797460556, -0.03863037750124931, 0.030249806120991707, -0.05562067776918411, -0.00098375731613487, -0.04478301852941513, -0.02353891171514988, 0.02694293111562729, -0.058731406927108765, -0.034617532044649124, 0.026126937940716743, -0.016487373039126396, 0.0015052055241540074, -0.03415524587035179, -0.04393383115530014, -0.014523311518132687, -0.004168337676674128, -0.047338373959064484, 0.04699655622243881, -0.03608847036957741, -0.03204933553934097, -0.03260965645313263, 0.008848260156810284, -0.029327480122447014, 0.0182650163769722, 0.03954619914293289, -0.06687279045581818, -0.0031934953294694424, -0.07115530222654343, 0.013642723672091961, 0.015807878226041794, 0.03232193365693092, -0.008214845322072506, 0.07095083594322205, -0.03440398722887039, 0.016203582286834717, -0.03454038128256798, -0.040024418383836746, -0.0370674654841423, -0.047820981591939926, -0.0570499561727047, 0.02644515037536621, -0.017835421487689018, 0.0000024541352559026564, 0.0019184253178536892, -0.03328069671988487, 0.0578455813229084, 0.005450122058391571, 0.024546148255467415, 0.04228784888982773, 0.05827701836824417, -0.04854221269488335, 0.08917395770549774, 0.04237615689635277, 0.008859647437930107, -0.010046036913990974, 0.004034386016428471, 0.01633802056312561, -0.03938884660601616, 0.00575470644980669, -0.018455304205417633, 0.004401788115501404, -0.07066745311021805, -0.04894218593835831, -0.0167460385710001, -0.028066137805581093, -0.030950622633099556, 0.018259942531585693, 0.031168775632977486, -0.019406912848353386, -0.042285848408937454 ]
Advancements in deep neural networks have allowed automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems to attain human parity on several publicly available clean speech datasets. However, even state-of-the-art ASR systems experience performance degradation when confronted with adverse conditions, as a well-trained acoustic model is sensitive to variations in the speech domain, e.g., background noise. Intuitively, humans address this issue by relying on their linguistic knowledge: the meaning of ambiguous spoken terms is usually inferred from contextual cues thereby reducing the dependency on the auditory system. Inspired by this observation, we introduce the first open-source benchmark to utilize external large language models (LLMs) for ASR error correction, where N-best decoding hypotheses provide informative elements for true transcription prediction. This approach is a paradigm shift from the traditional language model rescoring strategy that can only select one candidate hypothesis as the output transcription. The proposed benchmark contains a novel dataset, HyPoradise (HP), encompassing more than 334,000 pairs of N-best hypotheses and corresponding accurate transcriptions across prevalent speech domains. Given this dataset, we examine three types of error correction techniques based on LLMs with varying amounts of labeled hypotheses-transcription pairs, which gains a significant word error rate (WER) reduction. Experimental evidence demonstrates the proposed technique achieves a breakthrough by surpassing the upper bound of traditional re-ranking based methods. More surprisingly, LLM with reasonable prompt and its generative capability can even correct those tokens that are missing in N-best list. We make our results publicly accessible for reproducible pipelines with released pre-trained models, thus providing a new evaluation paradigm for ASR error correction with LLMs.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15701v2
[ -0.04628002643585205, -0.015370061621069908, 0.05709688737988472, -0.0003205846587661654, 0.03388221934437752, -0.004092950373888016, -0.010915185324847698, -0.029590152204036713, -0.05020010098814964, -0.059737421572208405, -0.03828113526105881, -0.0028639757074415684, -0.05199568346142769, -0.023361776024103165, -0.06771954894065857, 0.008319517597556114, 0.04804014042019844, 0.04129539057612419, -0.04098471626639366, 0.04848579317331314, -0.00410176906734705, 0.04069460183382034, -0.04996765777468681, 0.04947333782911301, 0.016056811437010765, -0.024388646706938744, -0.04227525740861893, -0.01027764193713665, -0.010546809062361717, -0.002208294114097953, 0.03968549519777298, -0.012919168919324875, -0.052441924810409546, -0.03401317074894905, -0.048955172300338745, -0.03330306336283684, -0.038228001445531845, 0.010640879161655903, -0.007954820990562439, -0.04486307129263878, 0.01940225623548031, -0.020169222727417946, -0.06923149526119232, -0.010318910703063011, -0.01691904291510582, 0.02389809489250183, -0.0445580929517746, -0.0016366031486541033, -0.0476897768676281, -0.04789450019598007, 0.02676774375140667, 0.0023315972648561, -0.0483088344335556, 0.037956759333610535, -0.02733602374792099, -0.033434152603149414, -0.0319344624876976, 0.014620021916925907, -0.07660123705863953, 0.0062084561213850975, 0.005288770422339439, -0.051919758319854736, -0.037704192101955414, 0.01378689706325531, -0.03498007729649544, 0.03662817180156708, -0.020298238843679428, -0.05648822337388992, -0.03673677146434784, -0.03576723486185074, 0.05887117236852646, -0.07302028685808182, 0.00897071324288845, 0.019851813092827797, 0.002535852137953043, -0.027330780401825905, -0.024477502331137657, -0.010778901167213917, -0.021294843405485153, -0.025246312841773033, -0.04319295659661293, 0.052462197840213776, 0.018053889274597168, 0.039432376623153687, -0.02925308421254158, -0.02981160208582878, 0.04611688107252121, -0.048577528446912766, 0.001722182147204876, -0.04552279785275459, 0.05406171828508377, -0.044779837131500244, -0.07550947368144989, 0.012007203884422779, 0.0677468329668045, -0.03611234948039055, 0.017785772681236267, -0.007420907728374004, 0.014388580806553364, 0.0356413833796978, -0.05706087872385979, 0.028877630829811096, -0.011212213896214962, 0.07167648524045944, 0.012483739294111729, -0.0274994894862175, -0.0038661540020257235, 0.026712210848927498, -0.05249996855854988, 0.014570876024663448, -0.058704882860183716, -0.054672837257385254, 0.005730133503675461, -0.042608506977558136, -0.0472213551402092, -0.022218236699700356, 0.054831452667713165, 0.02086150273680687, -0.010055105201900005, -0.024600626900792122, -0.05743357539176941, 0.03561888635158539, 0.06331039220094681, -0.0475199930369854, -0.026717273518443108, -0.01382540911436081, 0.07515766471624374, -0.012986565008759499, -0.02913237363100052, 0.014819348230957985, -0.0037282460834831, 0.03479133918881416, -0.009967800229787827, -0.0044225468300282955, 0.06836998462677002, 0.007767305243760347, -0.007191226817667484, -0.059249263256788254, 0.019611168652772903, -0.008322850801050663, 0.016298916190862656, -0.07356652617454529, 0.013713876716792583, -0.03933032229542732, 0.039607200771570206, 0.04471272602677345, -0.05429908260703087, -0.03981860727071762, 0.027862558141350746, 0.0024847970344126225, -0.023079626262187958, 0.010697834193706512, 0.0042272768914699554, 0.036213018000125885, 0.02471845969557762, 0.0014380980283021927, 0.05486217886209488, -0.028320401906967163, -0.06681584566831589, 0.04110398888587952, 0.015083150938153267, -0.0021759828086942434, 0.008816872723400593, -0.006992726121097803, -0.013886083848774433, 0.019125064834952354, 0.014727395959198475, 0.005597475450485945, -0.014161108992993832, -0.003759583458304405, -0.04321186617016792, -0.0068076904863119125, -0.02285403572022915, -0.0003151902637910098, -0.041675932705402374, -0.029914094135165215, 0.03336793929338455, -0.038170721381902695, -0.04089263826608658, 0.012976076453924179, -0.03786672279238701, 0.0512731559574604, -0.025039175525307655, 0.015378346666693687, -0.03818634897470474, 0.013891668990254402, -0.08656112104654312, -0.0034701270051300526, 0.06684893369674683, 0.03472362458705902, -0.04058149456977844, -0.02215476892888546, 0.008522444404661655, 0.02319714054465294, -0.027643244713544846, -0.017721273005008698, -0.015458598732948303, -0.03101370297372341, -0.0030065958853811026, 0.053265515714883804, -0.08707305043935776, -0.02473538927733898, -0.07856016606092453, 0.003089592792093754, 0.006233781576156616, -0.07421912997961044, 0.015396549366414547, 0.05852461978793144, -0.028317473828792572, -0.03176324814558029, 0.03455543890595436, 0.03428063541650772, 0.05090231075882912, 0.030096985399723053, 0.008380640298128128, 0.017416438087821007, -0.09321019798517227, 0.07511880248785019, -0.020314842462539673, -0.019635574892163277, 0.053532954305410385, 0.009148236364126205, 0.025029221549630165, 0.0014524032594636083, 0.001393212121911347, 0.028317904099822044, 0.045221008360385895, -0.01364014483988285, -0.05245358124375343, -0.03978092223405838, 0.005042586475610733, -0.050598397850990295, -0.04721524566411972, -0.08167532086372375, -0.0023434506729245186, 0.014294843189418316, -0.036828458309173584, 0.008150015026330948, 0.02964380383491516, -0.022688817232847214, -0.0296223983168602, -0.026373039931058884, 0.03964630886912346, 0.009997319430112839, -0.06519895792007446, -0.06065401807427406, -0.01777251623570919, 0.036725595593452454, -0.04834461584687233, -0.006902056280523539, -0.012110540643334389, -0.0508919321000576, -0.02259419672191143, 0.015018324367702007, 0.02093959040939808, 0.010755900293588638, -0.016155607998371124, 0.04327778145670891, -0.007127969991415739, 0.05356433615088463, 0.03106677159667015, 0.03173040971159935, -0.0626455619931221, -0.0012598333414644003, 0.039412721991539, -0.04087211191654205, 0.010716778226196766, 0.053980182856321335, 0.03075254335999489, -0.013568073511123657, 0.027034511789679527, 0.058642420917749405, 0.01876991055905819, -0.014830086380243301, -0.055559124797582626, -0.040515266358852386, 0.012354771606624126, -0.011463291011750698, 0.03381092846393585, 0.01336961891502142, 0.061707861721515656, 0.010041067376732826, 0.025637522339820862, -0.0702793076634407, -0.020908914506435394, -0.045414187014102936, -0.05369112268090248, -0.04394904524087906, -0.05236028507351875, -0.04652966931462288, -0.07775288820266724, -0.03299912437796593, 0.007546257693320513, -0.0348333977162838, -0.013724368996918201, -0.07073929160833359, -0.06263689696788788, -0.00292003620415926, 0.04683732986450195, -0.034291401505470276, -0.028001759201288223, -0.018866082653403282, 0.00578647293150425, -0.0017317981692031026, 0.02746361680328846, -0.03187267854809761, -0.049959681928157806, -0.03188877925276756, 0.00689090508967638, 0.016775889322161674, -0.02878100983798504, 0.048246074467897415, -0.009774850681424141, 0.037177301943302155, 0.0014943944988772273, 0.04037297144532204, 0.010794193483889103, 0.03214184194803238, 0.03281451389193535, -0.020458780229091644, 0.027007952332496643, -0.02106732316315174, -0.03319302201271057, -0.023064278066158295, -0.04199570044875145, -0.03317616507411003, 0.04705994576215744, 0.025563394650816917, -0.006494973320513964, -0.05124687775969505, 0.03280812129378319, 0.02346528321504593, 0.0013473016442731023, 0.015644293278455734, 0.00950128585100174, 0.057238128036260605, -0.017903750762343407, -0.0329713299870491, 0.019826315343379974, -0.021832648664712906, -0.016410451382398605, 0.017394622787833214, -0.019055956974625587, -0.012244625017046928, 0.0193913746625185, -0.08241642266511917, 0.010642004199326038, 0.025175658985972404, 0.07253280282020569, -0.012193392962217331, -0.025680061429739, 0.01902451552450657, 0.007833664305508137, 0.010394028387963772, -0.029196616262197495, 0.0015253816964104772, 0.001965488074347377, 0.06743284314870834, -0.033369194716215134, -0.026551557704806328, 0.01639454811811447, -0.06473077833652496, -0.04530875012278557, 0.018203770741820335, 0.008111520670354366, 0.039391327649354935, -0.0014214222319424152, -0.028668509796261787, 0.04707563668489456, 0.008677627891302109, 0.03893177956342697, -0.005351292435079813, -0.04086923971772194, 0.04064025729894638, 0.006975123193114996, -0.0037490935064852238, 0.03655169531702995, 0.003764281515032053, -0.015801558271050453, -0.026240047067403793, 0.011466097086668015, -0.06548401713371277, 0.02151207998394966, 0.0401965007185936, -0.026229552924633026, 0.01940968818962574, 0.056978773325681686, -0.02028505504131317, 0.04803092032670975, -0.02125588059425354, 0.002580167492851615, -0.015846895053982735, -0.008641327731311321, -0.023905102163553238, -0.0053397612646222115, -0.07928884029388428, -0.013358011841773987, 0.046251583844423294, 0.005295091774314642, -0.0025582388043403625, 0.003440548200160265, 0.01838696375489235, -0.0144499521702528, -0.08646482229232788, 0.025131726637482643, -0.03500726446509361, -0.0003238973440602422, -0.008462603203952312, -0.06637345999479294, 0.04526551067829132, -0.06209170073270798, -0.014142869040369987, -0.03493756428360939, -0.025359779596328735, -0.050949178636074066, -0.045345842838287354, -0.0045310682617127895, -0.07888809591531754, 0.014275331981480122, -0.07258092612028122, 0.03690800070762634, 0.024518825113773346, -0.016430730000138283, -0.03401412442326546, -0.03313761577010155, -0.005147946532815695, 0.05967037379741669, 0.05159760266542435, 0.01539439707994461, 0.008906731382012367, -0.024632854387164116, 0.020877540111541748, -0.027592847123742104, -0.007492270786315203, -0.005658941809087992, -0.03740957751870155, 0.013596243225038052, -0.0015656148316338658, -0.009754909202456474, 0.010354910045862198, 0.029469262808561325, 0.0359945148229599, -0.03493990749120712, -0.01235332153737545, 0.016619378700852394, 0.009446975775063038, -0.047468993812799454, -0.06168818101286888, -0.0365666002035141, -0.03608858957886696, -0.0810374841094017, -0.03396806865930557, 0.040761880576610565, 0.021448876708745956, -0.0245547853410244, -0.007426769006997347, 0.02782393805682659, 0.0022968295961618423, -0.005439788568764925, -0.0018379529938101768, 0.056873224675655365, 0.026364890858530998, -0.02410668320953846, -0.029738308861851692, -0.04525858908891678, 0.01728872023522854, -0.028467709198594093, -0.02999752387404442, -0.030053170397877693, 0.018935546278953552, 0.03573523089289665, 0.05948703736066818, -0.06528040766716003, 0.04358348250389099, 0.04057439789175987, -0.033467862755060196, 0.007311743684113026, 0.07994087040424347, -0.022887468338012695, 0.060932498425245285, -0.0471775121986866, -0.0018271146109327674, -0.021772589534521103, -0.038572654128074646, 0.009232177399098873, -0.016776420176029205, 0.015133965760469437, 0.009956791996955872, 0.04516852647066116, 0.012283840216696262, -0.03819616511464119, -0.009539082646369934, 0.04863233119249344, 0.016897769644856453, -0.056427065283060074, 0.03947653993964195, 0.06057053059339523, -0.05342642217874527, -0.036775633692741394, -0.024179348722100258, -0.0018361120019108057, 0.013603810220956802, 0.026510706171393394, -0.07493271678686142, -0.019010858610272408, 0.00754908611997962, -0.03529612347483635, -0.003311114851385355, 0.027327626943588257, -0.0105180274695158, 0.018761955201625824, 0.0099662309512496, 0.009833201766014099, -0.03424855321645737, -0.017026357352733612, -0.03218069300055504, 0.06387690454721451, 0.054804302752017975, -0.015603473410010338, 0.02040964551270008, 0.01746363192796707, -0.04019904509186745, 0.023343447595834732, -0.01930682547390461, -0.014413770288228989, 0.04409974068403244, -0.0030842970591038465, 0.038258206099271774, 0.022183625027537346, 0.05174015089869499, 0.06740418821573257, 0.02792290225625038, -0.010257947258651257, 0.014567654579877853, -0.01844465546309948, -0.019609898328781128, 0.013576456345617771, -0.053943976759910583, -0.05128049850463867, 0.028122207149863243, -0.00411297706887126, -0.025969306007027626, 0.016285710036754608, 0.022262392565608025, 0.0024897297844290733, 0.04087502509355545, 0.023989608511328697, -0.040341757237911224, -0.03507470339536667, 0.020725172013044357, 0.0748794749379158, -0.04794777184724808, -0.007083115633577108, -0.04554932191967964, -0.017246128991246223, 0.010601372458040714, -0.04336753860116005, 0.026461875066161156, 0.04247545450925827, -0.0023393509909510612, -0.04135508090257645, 0.05478964373469353, 0.018317412585020065, -0.07210219651460648, 0.0009305665153078735, 0.014177164994180202, -0.0796269029378891, 0.012645905837416649, 0.04622369259595871, -0.018574869260191917, -0.05622801184654236, 0.04237879812717438, -0.01777646318078041, 0.020555512979626656, -0.035101670771837234, 0.06531725078821182, 0.06909093260765076, -0.008229374885559082, -0.007172362878918648, -0.02467733435332775, -0.0348045788705349, 0.01057145930826664, 0.009619309566915035, -0.03529377281665802, 0.02031823992729187, 0.02138003520667553, 0.0001763313775882125, -0.03560800477862358, -0.023383747786283493, 0.059503208845853806, -0.019258655607700348, 0.05316642299294472, -0.002938926452770829, -0.015315395779907703, 0.0611797496676445, -0.03853354603052139, -0.027524832636117935, -0.00944595132023096, -0.01775370165705681, -0.030084708705544472, -0.03336634859442711, -0.06137792393565178, 0.012711258605122566, 0.018303968012332916, -0.01665041223168373, -0.05612962320446968, 0.011034196242690086, -0.01713797077536583, -0.05794906988739967, 0.011869546957314014, -0.06465985625982285, 0.0007307382766157389, -0.03633994981646538, 0.016318216919898987, 0.0341329462826252, 0.06700577586889267, -0.04072226211428642, -0.057052191346883774, -0.005771954543888569, 0.04560879245400429, -0.004071589559316635, -0.06962211430072784, -0.0036284353118389845, -0.05111001059412956, 0.024624869227409363, -0.047798458486795425, -0.007176588289439678, -0.0039672222919762135, -0.04841179400682449, -0.0020352951250970364, 0.055664461106061935, -0.022475825622677803, -0.046274714171886444, 0.03554650396108627, 0.01101892814040184, 0.019082915037870407, 0.024601474404335022, -0.04617675393819809, -0.0663290023803711, -0.0008534955559298396, -0.015516653656959534, -0.01766163855791092, 0.02091151289641857, 0.05520687997341156, -0.009751446545124054, -0.016582949087023735, 0.03448333963751793, -0.052582547068595886, 0.04525959491729736, 0.022351816296577454, -0.07003376632928848, 0.00902547873556614, 0.016072647646069527, -0.03857066482305527, -0.045070383697748184, -0.0014779280172660947, 0.007148548495024443, -0.05034395307302475, -0.0029773772694170475, 0.04579920694231987, 0.03416433185338974, 0.024281879886984825, -0.06457550823688507, 0.03204502537846565, 0.00924470741301775, -0.04409008473157883, -0.020046504214406013, -0.016201229766011238, -0.015306839719414711, -0.02940923161804676, -0.04639549180865288, 0.004311929456889629, -0.0533573143184185, -0.011178961023688316, -0.08669675886631012, 0.017832506448030472, 0.008063639514148235, 0.0507664792239666, -0.0010057083563879132, -0.01988239400088787, -0.04399988427758217, -0.02628742903470993, -0.002340913750231266, -0.014653956517577171, -0.01139724813401699, 0.03844915330410004, 0.028227973729372025, 0.02978026680648327, -0.045889269560575485, -0.052162379026412964, 0.04909232631325722, -0.03245305269956589, -0.014973098412156105, 0.05007558315992355, 0.009980575181543827, 0.008723007515072823, 0.0044154031202197075, 0.05938556045293808, -0.036626625806093216, 0.002671530470252037, -0.06258339434862137, -0.013676476664841175, -0.04807446151971817, -0.0404341034591198, 0.058447372168302536, -0.06151968240737915, -0.028819702565670013, 0.03901946172118187, 0.00903220847249031, -0.028864245861768723, -0.02913236804306507, -0.06112515926361084, 0.015873581171035767, -0.019642584025859833, 0.007849253714084625, 0.03986945003271103, -0.02001562900841236, -0.05302448570728302, -0.04069691151380539, -0.028734389692544937, -0.04006724804639816, 0.04722081497311592, 0.05156722292304039, -0.0324721522629261, -0.019031818956136703, -0.04408144950866699, -0.020140565931797028, -0.01622651144862175, -0.010038900189101696, 0.02242986671626568, 0.06494138389825821, 0.0018616890301927924, -0.008445830084383488, -0.016780821606516838, -0.028278667479753494, -0.00646532466635108, -0.06260991096496582, -0.02007916010916233, -0.014703347347676754, 0.009765749797224998, 0.02208353951573372, 0.027533074840903282, 0.012296970002353191, 0.037001315504312515, 0.039283670485019684, 0.030046924948692322, 0.03939727693796158, 0.021745238453149796, -0.03022102825343609, 0.08428242057561874, -0.011033949442207813, 0.010504924692213535, -0.04644269123673439, -0.005923022050410509, -0.031035427004098892, -0.012101000174880028, -0.013650062493979931, -0.01929750107228756, 0.03387627750635147, -0.05463857203722, 0.012336461804807186, 0.02856243960559368, 0.010117532685399055, -0.060408078134059906, 0.008608427830040455, 0.018180834129452705, -0.02832271344959736, -0.052238792181015015 ]
In this paper, we have realized the left-right symmetric model with modular symmetry. We have used $\Gamma$(3) modular group which is isomorphic to non-abelian discrete symmetry group $A_4$. The advantage of using modular symmetry is the non-requirement for the use of extra particles called 'flavons'. In this model, the Yukawa couplings are expressed in terms of modular forms $(Y_1,Y_2,Y_3)$. In this work, we have studied minimal Left-Right Symmetric Model for both type-I and type-II dominances. Here, we have calculated the values for the Yukawa couplings and then plotted it against the sum of the neutrino masses. The results obtained are well within the experimental limits for the desired values of sum of neutrino masses. We have also briefly analyzed the effects of the implications of modular symmetry on neutrinoless double beta decay with the new physics contributions within Left-Right Symmetric Model.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13552v1
[ -0.047816887497901917, -0.013410947285592556, 0.03479110077023506, 0.03469250351190567, 0.0449221208691597, 0.01201883889734745, -0.05337012559175491, 0.015658430755138397, -0.0296449214220047, -0.03854179009795189, -0.03425142168998718, -0.05739513412117958, -0.05715608596801758, 0.008538712747395039, -0.03966042771935463, -0.00447079399600625, 0.07070884108543396, 0.0631561130285263, -0.056574176996946335, 0.07017587125301361, 0.006860056892037392, -0.05490473285317421, -0.05494823306798935, 0.039777860045433044, -0.009916300885379314, 0.010840403847396374, -0.02090580016374588, -0.026073455810546875, 0.004631284158676863, -0.03150122985243797, 0.03845296800136566, -0.015364529564976692, -0.00806508306413889, -0.06621167063713074, 0.007482441142201424, 0.00010208689491264522, 0.00039692214340902865, -0.005623324308544397, 0.016508957371115685, -0.0453302375972271, -0.003760565770789981, -0.041719190776348114, -0.03416650369763374, 0.005103094503283501, -0.034769196063280106, -0.004853704944252968, -0.028182178735733032, 0.0009075502166524529, -0.06282402575016022, -0.06140100583434105, 0.0541866198182106, 0.012329121120274067, 0.02250446192920208, 0.059923768043518066, -0.04555115848779678, 0.01939178630709648, 0.029402829706668854, -0.006176446098834276, -0.03854099661111832, 0.022078758105635643, 0.02246953919529915, -0.0155176455155015, 0.043547824025154114, -0.02850363776087761, -0.042368922382593155, 0.036898788064718246, -0.02793431095778942, -0.04282562434673309, -0.031314052641391754, -0.03190228343009949, 0.03281410038471222, -0.05534711480140686, 0.0416368693113327, 0.01617484912276268, -0.047084663063287735, 0.02818579226732254, -0.047271981835365295, -0.01768169179558754, -0.011086315847933292, 0.014794176444411278, -0.006772021763026714, 0.004560079425573349, 0.01338812056928873, 0.008884343318641186, 0.03653877228498459, 0.024816786870360374, 0.03191190958023071, -0.039810534566640854, 0.014215320348739624, -0.041925180703401566, 0.014423157088458538, -0.03180590271949768, -0.05959673225879669, -0.0047053685411810875, 0.04218069091439247, -0.020737821236252785, -0.020124729722738266, 0.05754677206277847, 0.03702173009514809, 0.007010068744421005, 0.011776336468756199, -0.053089067339897156, -0.008467674255371094, 0.0001498419005656615, 0.041121311485767365, -0.04850294068455696, 0.0019476189045235515, 0.016346657648682594, 0.005478803068399429, 0.03591696918010712, 0.01816328801214695, 0.00468100979924202, 0.004103873856365681, 0.011887190863490105, -0.05826893076300621, -0.055055294185876846, 0.05645273998379707, 0.042795129120349884, 0.0323602519929409, -0.005500713363289833, -0.007721119560301304, 0.034608278423547745, -0.026473375037312508, 0.04260935261845589, -0.0009366458398289979, -0.027761902660131454, 0.015287506394088268, -0.008304247632622719, -0.0060729687102139, -0.05257256701588631, -0.061731014400720596, -0.009969787672162056, 0.043941158801317215, 0.006734457798302174, 0.04735178127884865, -0.03607974201440811, -0.0023824619129300117, -0.06260856986045837, 0.05677969753742218, 0.016249246895313263, -0.037400174885988235, -0.05873208865523338, 0.04838556796312332, 0.01242835819721222, -0.012233490124344826, 0.03864569589495659, -0.05331796780228615, 0.014836443588137627, 0.003269180655479431, 0.007844425737857819, 0.021105708554387093, 0.00044159291428513825, -0.02817820943892002, 0.026970496401190758, -0.004830334335565567, 0.009608184918761253, 0.036752231419086456, 0.006927491631358862, -0.056346628814935684, 0.0159992054104805, 0.025759173557162285, -0.039666797965765, -0.005006623920053244, 0.006259343586862087, -0.014943323098123074, 0.02616087719798088, 0.021439459174871445, -0.04052823409438133, -0.045022305101156235, -0.020816845819354057, -0.061482224613428116, 0.04876384139060974, 0.0279680285602808, -0.03728257864713669, -0.0401323176920414, -0.01073091197758913, -0.004592450801283121, -0.04593905061483383, -0.043085355311632156, 0.01806085929274559, 0.022115038707852364, 0.00048659121966920793, -0.025069130584597588, -0.002171602565795183, 0.007974030449986458, 0.018346477299928665, -0.0717340037226677, 0.022691698744893074, 0.06778255105018616, 0.03140328451991081, 0.005423237103968859, -0.045253779739141464, 0.06634420156478882, 0.01129008736461401, -0.05286111310124397, -0.03886624053120613, 0.015784528106451035, 0.01083152275532484, 0.007139542605727911, 0.01597609929740429, -0.0818430557847023, -0.033968355506658554, -0.038389261811971664, -0.0037152240984141827, -0.017634641379117966, -0.032445281744003296, 0.04080923646688461, 0.0241363737732172, -0.014825290068984032, -0.030396398156881332, 0.04412320256233215, 0.025916846469044685, 0.03743375837802887, -0.04509446397423744, -0.039871715009212494, -0.03682022541761398, -0.09847090393304825, 0.07259458303451538, 0.020609118044376373, -0.004138267133384943, 0.03310881182551384, 0.02166804112493992, -0.03727035969495773, -0.05338949337601662, -0.008950256742537022, 0.06244625523686409, 0.05745294690132141, -0.016105473041534424, 0.003743933280929923, 0.00318100955337286, 0.03550194203853607, -0.05066494271159172, -0.05948510020971298, -0.04231104254722595, -0.00815962441265583, -0.005770200397819281, 0.009087054058909416, 0.047382403165102005, -0.006495669484138489, -0.06552453339099884, -0.05582158640027046, -0.0016043063951656222, 0.039637744426727295, 0.021406074985861778, -0.009636919014155865, -0.058920830488204956, -0.040947992354631424, -0.02917025052011013, -0.05762159079313278, 0.065003901720047, 0.022276923060417175, -0.04907205328345299, -0.03816477581858635, -0.02098473533987999, 0.03612499311566353, 0.007565088104456663, -0.06305538862943649, 0.02860860340297222, 0.005819345358759165, 0.012704520486295223, 0.031381115317344666, 0.040868908166885376, -0.01712513528764248, -0.007368889171630144, -0.00249565695412457, 0.01878080889582634, -0.06281907111406326, -0.054352108389139175, -0.00008969048940343782, 0.020196830853819847, 0.0337907150387764, 0.009418770670890808, 0.04967426508665085, 0.009485337883234024, -0.024262236431241035, 0.001066140248440206, -0.020826229825615883, -0.03090125508606434, 0.037399277091026306, 0.022927992045879364, 0.06744859367609024, 0.04681754484772682, -0.03730681911110878, -0.06718707084655762, -0.052850786596536636, -0.02111978456377983, -0.010969791561365128, -0.07288309931755066, -0.0666586309671402, -0.006321527063846588, -0.06827177107334137, -0.04210304841399193, -0.03822393715381622, -0.04356363043189049, -0.05299275368452072, -0.06973189115524292, -0.021436192095279694, 0.028144359588623047, 0.005475659389048815, -0.0669982060790062, -0.06590795516967773, 0.02540658414363861, 0.0026563070714473724, 0.03684186190366745, 0.017941642552614212, -0.0367281474173069, 0.0007392857223749161, 0.04694663733243942, 0.06168206408619881, -0.040859535336494446, 0.003023291239514947, 0.04223429411649704, -0.056766048073768616, -0.011689323000609875, -0.014925583265721798, 0.054874878376722336, 0.0384112112224102, -0.03593243658542633, 0.0697636604309082, -0.01337475422769785, -0.005338957067579031, 0.027460485696792603, -0.018196113407611847, -0.019988611340522766, -0.056085631251335144, -0.008209752850234509, 0.044922035187482834, 0.06175868213176727, -0.03113655559718609, -0.011466595344245434, -0.07554580271244049, -0.06130397692322731, 0.024579092860221863, -0.06044076010584831, 0.0665568932890892, 0.052313562482595444, -0.012013696134090424, -0.026804178953170776, -0.02957487292587757, -0.0015590073307976127, -0.03534069284796715, 0.0054345098324120045, 0.012752923183143139, -0.009049706161022186, 0.04932938143610954, -0.08436256647109985, 0.03614983707666397, 0.045808903872966766, 0.07254048436880112, -0.018939882516860962, -0.02386513166129589, 0.018156668171286583, 0.02730363979935646, 0.02467728778719902, -0.03819577395915985, 0.04121159389615059, 0.041126105934381485, 0.0580437146127224, 0.009312446229159832, -0.05193260684609413, -0.02462509088218212, -0.06940697133541107, -0.04276082664728165, -0.010267956182360649, 0.05490259453654289, 0.047781433910131454, 0.052886247634887695, -0.011403989046812057, 0.03809450566768646, -0.0056196050718426704, 0.005115407053381205, -0.0034174418542534113, -0.04197455197572708, -0.023938680067658424, -0.0009035748080350459, 0.016771569848060608, 0.01013330090790987, -0.006076824851334095, -0.003490237519145012, -0.058996088802814484, 0.024074988439679146, -0.05568615719676018, 0.03768632933497429, 0.028678424656391144, -0.02855115756392479, 0.07073524594306946, 0.011525203473865986, -0.01192720327526331, 0.03485676273703575, -0.021831747144460678, 0.03607972711324692, -0.03796696662902832, 0.0010135902557522058, 0.008718958124518394, -0.012402108870446682, -0.021502647548913956, 0.024722179397940636, 0.008174446411430836, -0.026658104732632637, -0.010625706985592842, -0.003713456680998206, 0.006363498512655497, 0.0026869664434343576, -0.0833597481250763, -0.027034178376197815, -0.045613765716552734, -0.01789160631597042, -0.0037170120049268007, -0.04957270249724388, 0.07849538326263428, -0.003832263872027397, -0.03465736284852028, 0.0004099352518096566, -0.01701187901198864, 0.00431861774995923, -0.05181542783975601, -0.05726240947842598, -0.030515819787979126, 0.035865455865859985, -0.0441218800842762, 0.03836776688694954, -0.05434770509600639, -0.028052976354956627, -0.043160997331142426, 0.03843018412590027, 0.009317537769675255, 0.018951304256916046, 0.024722058326005936, 0.037461817264556885, 0.06159738451242447, -0.0030937232077121735, 0.013372347690165043, 0.01753980480134487, -0.04506691172719002, 0.027921656146645546, -0.04066714644432068, 0.040650542825460434, -0.032354701310396194, -0.04613245651125908, -0.03527436405420303, 0.0229469146579504, 0.0558769665658474, -0.009688721969723701, 0.0024524671025574207, -0.033007051795721054, 0.012732080183923244, -0.05171399563550949, -0.05534175783395767, -0.0020118330139666796, -0.008077124133706093, -0.004127801861613989, 0.01636371947824955, -0.027112461626529694, -0.0058569456450641155, -0.0004684306913986802, 0.048497799783945084, 0.027495594695210457, 0.020501520484685898, -0.033254630863666534, -0.030837688595056534, 0.023799601942300797, 0.010418666526675224, 0.0253278911113739, -0.018650460988283157, -0.07540250569581985, -0.02630653791129589, -0.04321105778217316, 0.0339314341545105, 0.007609518710523844, 0.07146723568439484, -0.021824205294251442, 0.04941606894135475, -0.08562391251325607, 0.01624068059027195, 0.06103935465216637, 0.0005719322944059968, -0.026753604412078857, 0.017716631293296814, -0.0456317700445652, 0.02530290000140667, 0.004717438947409391, 0.03256640210747719, 0.010686677880585194, -0.004466935992240906, 0.01236927229911089, 0.015403211116790771, -0.017621653154492378, -0.009697302244603634, 0.06002681329846382, -0.0012700443621724844, -0.03407228738069534, 0.010779581032693386, -0.04422077536582947, -0.0066408803686499596, -0.004280977416783571, 0.03336293250322342, 0.0408034585416317, -0.027455711737275124, -0.03143845871090889, -0.0026181002613157034, 0.009694951586425304, 0.014782773330807686, 0.022689949721097946, -0.02648526057600975, -0.006204035133123398, 0.061623748391866684, -0.011547332629561424, 0.003437706734985113, 0.05416656658053398, 0.03295007720589638, 0.005050797015428543, -0.03409646824002266, -0.03636574745178223, -0.06594564765691757, 0.003575415350496769, -0.012413821183145046, 0.024504905566573143, 0.04553544148802757, -0.016745194792747498, 0.056133151054382324, 0.03775125741958618, 0.037912823259830475, -0.0021600364707410336, -0.004738510120660067, -0.018327273428440094, 0.05993743613362312, -0.04366939142346382, -0.010808458551764488, -0.02303711324930191, 0.02034793794155121, 0.0316171795129776, 0.0009917704155668616, -0.006590705364942551, -0.03539172559976578, -0.042338211089372635, -0.032767154276371, 0.04810670018196106, 0.024800963699817657, -0.01703585311770439, -0.029201583936810493, 0.04559137299656868, -0.023142406716942787, 0.029212309047579765, 0.006289823446422815, 0.04598499834537506, -0.0040898616425693035, 0.03356510400772095, 0.045438725501298904, -0.07070568203926086, -0.02672833390533924, 0.037903476506471634, -0.06505240499973297, 0.051474008709192276, -0.04820806533098221, -0.05787014588713646, -0.03765367716550827, -0.030175061896443367, 0.005320630501955748, 0.03104245476424694, 0.009861108846962452, -0.04654351994395256, 0.051716890186071396, 0.030098462477326393, -0.07521463930606842, -0.013257591053843498, 0.023415811359882355, -0.07639414817094803, -0.018667912110686302, 0.007124308496713638, -0.050257157534360886, -0.010943776927888393, 0.0020991377532482147, -0.02915232442319393, -0.06094752252101898, -0.03985827788710594, 0.027365054935216904, 0.05009599030017853, -0.05883948132395744, 0.05049077048897743, 0.05178440734744072, -0.031170595437288284, -0.008262544870376587, -0.043075382709503174, -0.008274192921817303, -0.015173126943409443, 0.042463209480047226, -0.019280286505818367, -0.0002099152625305578, 0.0038787114899605513, 0.0368453748524189, -0.05539586767554283, 0.014657197520136833, 0.039891138672828674, 0.012416128069162369, 0.031157152727246284, 0.0013696703827008605, -0.01159890741109848, 0.021566670387983322, -0.01707102544605732, -0.004059127066284418, -0.06302114576101303, 0.01634901948273182, 0.006620774976909161, 0.03063187189400196, -0.014862271025776863, -0.0021358118392527103, -0.04346609488129616, -0.006379213649779558, -0.020621169358491898, -0.023568084463477135, -0.04598451405763626, -0.0023156797979027033, 0.003800308331847191, 0.03570984676480293, 0.018651776015758514, 0.05417393893003464, -0.02236022986471653, -0.018652232363820076, -0.019748404622077942, 0.007521502673625946, -0.040022946894168854, 0.04360660910606384, 0.034863293170928955, -0.02719586342573166, 0.06880376487970352, -0.03478935360908508, 0.05341324955224991, -0.0462200753390789, -0.06267089396715164, 0.0415022075176239, -0.043672267347574234, -0.03428153321146965, -0.05224713683128357, -0.011450611986219883, -0.02894567884504795, 0.038795240223407745, 0.016978086903691292, -0.05113367736339569, -0.06100199744105339, 0.034051720052957535, -0.00791272334754467, -0.04556111991405487, 0.036468926817178726, -0.0019289121264591813, 0.04758255556225777, 0.012135053053498268, 0.021991200745105743, 0.061344679445028305, 0.00007278558769030496, 0.00653515849262476, -0.055432870984077454, -0.05539083853363991, 0.031108031049370766, -0.041927844285964966, -0.002782532013952732, -0.01820266619324684, -0.031328629702329636, -0.07217210531234741, 0.019389331340789795, 0.012542148120701313, 0.004563061520457268, -0.011580340564250946, -0.006634520832449198, 0.05471188947558403, -0.008002033457159996, -0.01971530355513096, -0.08612960577011108, -0.020819656550884247, 0.042948875576257706, -0.01751413568854332, -0.010063006542623043, -0.018633725121617317, -0.05923287570476532, 0.023439614102244377, -0.08934033662080765, -0.0286113154143095, -0.003274153685197234, 0.002645164728164673, -0.0015438547125086188, -0.03313455730676651, -0.015263073146343231, -0.055526550859212875, 0.018401864916086197, 0.006359793711453676, 0.024990176782011986, 0.03143040090799332, 0.007907775230705738, 0.039982158690690994, -0.027395768091082573, 0.011629031039774418, 0.06817302107810974, -0.02573464810848236, -0.006414992269128561, 0.03263979032635689, 0.026321951299905777, -0.03537580370903015, 0.007926653139293194, 0.03614381328225136, 0.004215330351144075, 0.011733506806194782, -0.019430452957749367, -0.027348775416612625, -0.02270572818815708, -0.06280835717916489, 0.02756819874048233, -0.026708880439400673, 0.0034759182017296553, -0.048947494477033615, 0.015426774509251118, -0.061217885464429855, 0.005722035188227892, -0.006916106212884188, 0.017122728750109673, -0.00669952342286706, -0.051663223654031754, 0.009636569768190384, -0.02134191431105137, -0.017024103552103043, -0.023167675361037254, -0.020993294194340706, -0.023356180638074875, -0.006437213160097599, 0.032012939453125, -0.03967631980776787, 0.05567295476794243, -0.0674455538392067, 0.04314552620053291, -0.0587746798992157, 0.003639763919636607, 0.019676193594932556, 0.055852849036455154, -0.04770169407129288, -0.02213415876030922, -0.03959941864013672, -0.037605755031108856, 0.0417151153087616, -0.07756224274635315, -0.017014866694808006, -0.02002785913646221, 0.003061579540371895, 0.023279570043087006, 0.053144171833992004, -0.03369975462555885, 0.08120585232973099, 0.01346844807267189, -0.004251318052411079, -0.013985664583742619, 0.002585005946457386, -0.0074262553825974464, 0.03173071891069412, 0.01184065081179142, -0.005203562788665295, -0.059893373399972916, 0.029243402183055878, 0.026488041505217552, 0.003906567115336657, 0.002031364943832159, 0.009857209399342537, -0.03104841150343418, 0.0012039850698783994, 0.02062450535595417, 0.05406146124005318, 0.028696320950984955, -0.016763826832175255, 0.05751851946115494, 0.006576658226549625, -0.04403090849518776, -0.038778580725193024 ]
We introduce Secure Haplotype Imputation Employing Local Differential privacy (SHIELD), a program for accurately estimating the genotype of target samples at markers that are not directly assayed by array-based genotyping platforms while preserving the privacy of donors to public reference panels. At the core of SHIELD is the Li-Stephens model of genetic recombination, according to which genomic information is comprised of mosaics of ancestral haplotype fragments that coalesce via a Markov random field. We use the standard forward-backward algorithm for inferring the ancestral haplotypes of target genomes, and hence the most likely genotype at unobserved sites, using a reference panel of template haplotypes whose privacy is guaranteed by the randomized response technique from differential privacy.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07305v1
[ -0.024401972070336342, -0.02742660604417324, 0.040978070348501205, -0.005129419267177582, 0.037964265793561935, -0.010273010469973087, -0.023441452533006668, -0.035856764763593674, -0.04125408083200455, -0.016391010954976082, -0.032969746738672256, 0.01413235068321228, -0.05673765018582344, -0.05230510234832764, -0.04397584870457649, -0.01743876188993454, 0.0436188206076622, 0.013496190309524536, -0.053299013525247574, 0.05086234211921692, -0.033518027514219284, -0.025056537240743637, -0.03722832724452019, -0.004569891840219498, 0.024074455723166466, -0.05271948501467705, -0.0014608368510380387, -0.008416568860411644, -0.0431855134665966, -0.05500554293394089, 0.016441790387034416, 0.019947724416851997, -0.0059319715946912766, 0.028373800218105316, -0.06072346493601799, -0.011819686740636826, 0.013104330748319626, 0.002601443324238062, 0.0032018106430768967, -0.052004482597112656, -0.005173634272068739, -0.02550412528216839, -0.06711074709892273, -0.04963093623518944, -0.02213914319872856, -0.005919078830629587, -0.04942712560296059, 0.005588302854448557, 0.006884557660669088, -0.06396813690662384, 0.002297891303896904, -0.042490702122449875, -0.04276971518993378, 0.04465058445930481, -0.05731254070997238, -0.0031240833923220634, 0.03150616213679314, 0.06128336861729622, -0.05470118299126625, 0.05398513004183769, 0.013280938379466534, -0.03967386856675148, -0.032875705510377884, -0.004109212663024664, -0.03388617932796478, 0.025994563475251198, -0.0038696834817528725, -0.07347900420427322, -0.018037747591733932, 0.0030131088569760323, 0.059239912778139114, -0.06068698316812515, -0.01191643811762333, 0.019027089700102806, -0.03740761801600456, 0.0007518110214732587, -0.009620856493711472, -0.033132731914520264, -0.0010253085056319833, -0.020014366135001183, -0.012701922096312046, 0.01806599646806717, 0.038892440497875214, 0.059510841965675354, -0.005986290518194437, -0.02867344580590725, 0.06964471936225891, -0.03769945353269577, -0.0037779042031615973, 0.0012183766812086105, -0.020521337166428566, 0.021038241684436798, -0.0784933939576149, 0.006864772643893957, 0.07208015024662018, -0.03532792627811432, 0.05323367938399315, 0.01081934105604887, 0.012814849615097046, 0.025244569405913353, -0.032536283135414124, 0.025049807503819466, -0.008869352750480175, 0.03334204480051994, -0.035542987287044525, 0.005053745117038488, -0.003392723621800542, 0.01588062383234501, -0.060926653444767, 0.0006539855967275798, -0.07125166058540344, -0.022574326023459435, 0.021597061306238174, -0.010226567275822163, -0.021806154400110245, -0.05065155029296875, 0.042130742222070694, -0.04298035055398941, 0.07095560431480408, 0.03291606158018112, -0.029961785301566124, 0.030569717288017273, 0.05912788212299347, 0.0008555844542570412, -0.06477770954370499, -0.0038247096817940474, 0.0534600093960762, -0.012135948054492474, -0.07155968993902206, -0.057617656886577606, 0.015582593157887459, 0.06443196535110474, -0.014638135209679604, -0.032270513474941254, 0.012728727422654629, -0.025820719078183174, -0.024022595956921577, -0.02502632513642311, -0.040668632835149765, 0.012668275274336338, -0.013170145452022552, -0.06262777000665665, -0.023538537323474884, -0.02146783657371998, -0.008032064884901047, 0.03918568044900894, -0.06272855401039124, -0.005943454802036285, 0.030492445454001427, 0.021994058042764664, -0.017569461837410927, -0.006350355222821236, 0.020323440432548523, 0.046306002885103226, -0.006040855776518583, -0.018246635794639587, 0.052121471613645554, -0.044435758143663406, -0.061223167926073074, 0.06600602716207504, -0.026603084057569504, 0.010808040387928486, 0.016128389164805412, -0.046974435448646545, 0.010676401667296886, -0.052439212799072266, -0.013315515592694283, 0.02254665456712246, -0.025211328640580177, -0.040939606726169586, -0.013797065243124962, 0.007773823570460081, -0.022305727005004883, -0.05215955525636673, -0.054133594036102295, -0.01750015653669834, 0.009556297212839127, -0.02742203325033188, -0.01587347872555256, -0.007098641712218523, -0.022696390748023987, 0.04653121531009674, -0.016394663602113724, -0.0004164162965025753, -0.048329953104257584, -0.010365597903728485, -0.08859778940677643, -0.039373863488435745, 0.0155318109318614, 0.015407427214086056, -0.05296965688467026, -0.047580793499946594, -0.007510139606893063, -0.03117990307509899, -0.009170065633952618, -0.032944608479738235, -0.025638913735747337, -0.0401938334107399, 0.021107764914631844, 0.007037793286144733, -0.08943134546279907, -0.023572800680994987, -0.07042908668518066, 0.034037232398986816, 0.011417167261242867, -0.009257785975933075, -0.03521452099084854, 0.047687727957963943, -0.06690934300422668, 0.040494028478860855, 0.04317381605505943, 0.06439004838466644, 0.058621905744075775, -0.027561388909816742, 0.032773204147815704, 0.07889704406261444, -0.09743621200323105, 0.03928721323609352, -0.008455798961222172, -0.004294764716178179, 0.04267873242497444, -0.016781190410256386, 0.021052079275250435, -0.028656868264079094, -0.01801786944270134, 0.06140902265906334, 0.051106784492731094, -0.003353913314640522, 0.02880462259054184, -0.06225927546620369, -0.020090557634830475, -0.06305494159460068, -0.016756661236286163, -0.06134847551584244, -0.003078978741541505, -0.007230144459754229, -0.02552158199250698, 0.03190679848194122, 0.018276125192642212, -0.009804552420973778, -0.06958380341529846, -0.04051007702946663, 0.06789551675319672, -0.0463724322617054, -0.029128989204764366, -0.06255429238080978, -0.015028661116957664, 0.014330103993415833, -0.0005461638793349266, -0.026677947491407394, -0.01846872642636299, -0.06063152477145195, 0.04422546178102493, -0.0598280169069767, -0.02676531858742237, 0.03182996064424515, 0.040964700281620026, 0.03987016901373863, -0.05728551372885704, 0.02913731150329113, 0.07972443103790283, 0.027876919135451317, -0.044930748641490936, -0.02630401775240898, 0.029606519266963005, -0.008091835305094719, 0.02496284991502762, 0.0035454309545457363, -0.012614729814231396, -0.05883372202515602, 0.01257933396846056, 0.017700789496302605, 0.03630780801177025, -0.04495404660701752, -0.041978660970926285, 0.024976536631584167, 0.021323947235941887, -0.0162804052233696, 0.030575858429074287, 0.01571006327867508, 0.06619621813297272, 0.04605402424931526, 0.011342242360115051, -0.058570634573698044, 0.022352848201990128, -0.04132683947682381, -0.027646582573652267, -0.061707597225904465, -0.06205153092741966, 0.004625772591680288, -0.06787078827619553, 0.01750793866813183, -0.01522101741284132, 0.03462010622024536, -0.03386695310473442, -0.0159564558416605, -0.06898597627878189, -0.01254229061305523, -0.04802323132753372, -0.027874821797013283, -0.05541067197918892, -0.07408878952264786, 0.018088147044181824, -0.012341293506324291, -0.010418415069580078, -0.04684772342443466, -0.028286848217248917, 0.013397433795034885, 0.035782989114522934, 0.010578982532024384, -0.0368887297809124, 0.04351259022951126, -0.015625761821866035, 0.015899674966931343, 0.020755214616656303, 0.01963810808956623, -0.0393369235098362, 0.039813295006752014, 0.05113038793206215, 0.02944088727235794, 0.048816099762916565, 0.043384239077568054, 0.02183193899691105, -0.002244844799861312, -0.04080631583929062, -0.013234204612672329, 0.021101966500282288, 0.024605602025985718, -0.019010210409760475, -0.013596276752650738, 0.01751900650560856, 0.010582555085420609, 0.021580670028924942, -0.03290282189846039, 0.010634126141667366, 0.03684418648481369, -0.028209812939167023, 0.005298021715134382, -0.032188620418310165, -0.006092147435992956, -0.01943795196712017, 0.053982242941856384, -0.002045457251369953, -0.019392186775803566, 0.0027736437041312456, -0.07549013197422028, -0.009561346843838692, 0.021412568166851997, 0.024738604202866554, -0.006332849618047476, -0.00501166982576251, 0.039612025022506714, 0.016623592004179955, 0.016534345224499702, 0.007638626731932163, 0.007389522157609463, 0.03174693137407303, 0.05977889895439148, -0.055815886706113815, -0.011521277949213982, -0.005199338775128126, -0.042987070977687836, -0.02958846651017666, 0.004311504308134317, 0.009727220050990582, 0.009427757002413273, -0.006677813362330198, -0.06545373797416687, 0.06772322207689285, -0.028561804443597794, -0.011429358273744583, 0.002292816061526537, -0.01844003237783909, 0.02142169326543808, -0.02643551677465439, 0.035248931497335434, -0.021053405478596687, -0.00298571796156466, -0.03932805731892586, -0.016792409121990204, 0.018441325053572655, -0.048431236296892166, 0.0009785586735233665, 0.019254371523857117, 0.011316229589283466, 0.06613882631063461, 0.029861237853765488, -0.014370230957865715, 0.05722454562783241, -0.027123430743813515, 0.01233021542429924, -0.022669712081551552, 0.022510111331939697, -0.016190052032470703, -0.01971856690943241, -0.02469620108604431, 0.0234285406768322, 0.009847499430179596, -0.055601149797439575, -0.0016775225521996617, -0.023678909987211227, -0.020145539194345474, -0.004432585556060076, -0.06404399126768112, -0.0010751148220151663, -0.02363262139260769, 0.022321537137031555, -0.005897820461541414, -0.06746984273195267, 0.0004692677757702768, -0.05054900795221329, 0.01744934357702732, -0.023193005472421646, -0.03222913295030594, -0.04528866708278656, -0.01323382556438446, -0.0020997149404138327, -0.07693054527044296, 0.0222475603222847, -0.08047495782375336, 0.06125709414482117, 0.004773818422108889, -0.015000291168689728, -0.011867758817970753, -0.00817752256989479, 0.01834135130047798, 0.0050651514902710915, 0.03133725747466087, 0.04208781197667122, 0.008580472320318222, -0.020394977182149887, 0.014676643535494804, 0.019145097583532333, 0.025555554777383804, -0.06056883558630943, -0.034232039004564285, 0.0009806269081309438, -0.018294043838977814, -0.04899867996573448, 0.01563839428126812, 0.02325071021914482, 0.03745150938630104, -0.02354988269507885, -0.00559721514582634, 0.020079132169485092, -0.002316487254574895, -0.04865878447890282, -0.06222958117723465, -0.03620193526148796, -0.019313430413603783, -0.055331140756607056, 0.0031973926816135645, 0.03566107526421547, 0.029880687594413757, 0.006897862534970045, -0.0002755926689133048, -0.0155132245272398, 0.00007041775097604841, 0.0015995524590834975, 0.013382744044065475, 0.018633244559168816, -0.004130369517952204, -0.055508002638816833, -0.05933637171983719, -0.050188567489385605, -0.038279686123132706, -0.061363350600004196, 0.01614508219063282, -0.029352528974413872, 0.018351204693317413, -0.014560125768184662, 0.02807321585714817, -0.0622134655714035, 0.048184577375650406, 0.058451149612665176, -0.051793601363897324, -0.006976739969104528, 0.061256926506757736, 0.03301084041595459, 0.0356968455016613, -0.02599538117647171, -0.012553395703434944, -0.014863770455121994, -0.06399358063936234, -0.02402084693312645, 0.016312705352902412, 0.0033513056114315987, -0.031069910153746605, 0.05750996246933937, -0.020138215273618698, -0.03533890098333359, -0.006270228885114193, 0.04120346158742905, -0.05380723625421524, -0.029061008244752884, 0.016081370413303375, 0.017973540350794792, -0.03532569110393524, -0.007759979926049709, 0.007236461155116558, -0.006291493773460388, 0.04267137497663498, -0.002374120522290468, -0.05377791076898575, -0.0024594913702458143, 0.04594390094280243, -0.053454507142305374, -0.022767284885048866, 0.0021940323058515787, -0.009175779297947884, 0.041706718504428864, 0.017562223598361015, 0.029643118381500244, -0.044974248856306076, -0.033745307475328445, -0.018801715224981308, 0.0465007983148098, 0.03406738489866257, 0.045933354645967484, 0.019489385187625885, -0.02011263743042946, -0.020708400756120682, -0.014918188564479351, -0.008381898514926434, 0.004842620342969894, 0.014297774992883205, -0.0257891695946455, 0.02839295007288456, 0.040538489818573, 0.06991756707429886, -0.0034213357139378786, 0.016970595344901085, 0.013744606636464596, 0.01907867006957531, -0.06408943235874176, -0.02203155681490898, 0.03038197197020054, -0.01744752749800682, -0.04259944334626198, 0.016072992235422134, 0.04680689796805382, -0.03400746360421181, 0.04527958109974861, 0.010123987682163715, -0.012428821064531803, 0.0532543919980526, -0.004766310565173626, -0.009434718638658524, -0.04292941093444824, -0.042585909366607666, 0.0667206421494484, -0.008920222520828247, 0.016548888757824898, -0.030049510300159454, -0.005146760027855635, 0.004048310685902834, -0.06368262320756912, 0.02415432780981064, 0.07973773777484894, -0.004485015757381916, -0.046294309198856354, -0.015400740318000317, -0.017624925822019577, -0.06630408018827438, -0.02167142555117607, 0.03657224401831627, -0.08895964175462723, -0.007516867946833372, 0.014610406942665577, -0.03722904995083809, -0.004717706236988306, 0.05872267112135887, -0.03393825516104698, 0.03567340970039368, -0.018207980319857597, 0.02505873516201973, 0.06639551371335983, -0.015349037945270538, -0.015729958191514015, 0.0027400061953812838, -0.044588636606931686, 0.006732109468430281, -0.0773433968424797, 0.004135599359869957, -0.01554815098643303, 0.06255944073200226, 0.012684591114521027, -0.028161298483610153, 0.02341589331626892, 0.04890067130327225, -0.04102561995387077, -0.007395649328827858, 0.023456277325749397, -0.019842276349663734, 0.05445025488734245, -0.06373079866170883, -0.041912514716386795, -0.044172462075948715, 0.010718818753957748, 0.03086163103580475, -0.05751616880297661, 0.009630979970097542, -0.043483808636665344, 0.011016199365258217, -0.003334974404424429, -0.06784417480230331, -0.031214803457260132, -0.029620546847581863, -0.03281504288315773, 0.01960267499089241, -0.07746535539627075, 0.031160593032836914, -0.059022966772317886, 0.040267519652843475, 0.056242916733026505, 0.022216899320483208, -0.03734113276004791, 0.033066339790821075, 0.011584254913032055, 0.005250673275440931, -0.02047606185078621, -0.033391498029232025, -0.010152789764106274, 0.002653320785611868, 0.0015248782001435757, -0.03489268943667412, -0.03152570128440857, -0.029406631365418434, -0.0505969300866127, 0.04095974192023277, -0.020576870068907738, -0.06303431838750839, -0.045786865055561066, 0.05762939900159836, -0.051922593265771866, 0.03856220468878746, -0.00829662848263979, -0.04453766718506813, -0.0008664442575536668, -0.012787900865077972, -0.012362179346382618, -0.003030225168913603, -0.004805470816791058, 0.05599170923233032, 0.0047684041783213615, 0.037557464092969894, 0.04854575917124748, 0.028159508481621742, 0.029780754819512367, 0.005680573172867298, -0.038102272897958755, -0.027139656245708466, 0.022892959415912628, -0.01010784413665533, -0.025668645277619362, -0.028574494644999504, -0.056552138179540634, -0.07949353009462357, -0.013028413988649845, 0.022659096866846085, -0.0061116525903344154, -0.019848817959427834, -0.05536231771111488, 0.017320483922958374, 0.0054108877666294575, -0.03313492238521576, -0.05290250852704048, -0.01618870347738266, 0.010784919373691082, -0.02747812308371067, -0.01704261265695095, -0.011779414489865303, -0.0527866967022419, -0.014896789565682411, -0.07644342631101608, -0.007770139258354902, 0.02469341829419136, 0.03776470571756363, 0.01946140080690384, -0.03700627014040947, 0.0022495489101856947, -0.02377198450267315, -0.009204592555761337, 0.010715385898947716, -0.012335894629359245, 0.02030603028833866, 0.015912458300590515, 0.04597119241952896, -0.04442653805017471, -0.06595782190561295, -0.011764767579734325, -0.032389186322689056, -0.03325077146291733, 0.054686516523361206, 0.04993896186351776, 0.01100463792681694, -0.03785919025540352, 0.06725094467401505, 0.0017025000415742397, -0.001055115950293839, -0.04492747783660889, -0.012960121966898441, -0.07274453341960907, -0.03740979731082916, 0.048450130969285965, -0.02129279263317585, -0.05114876851439476, -0.00007711184298386797, -0.01732610911130905, 0.0037202986422926188, -0.035462215542793274, -0.057276759296655655, 0.019964899867773056, 0.01621585339307785, 0.012280750088393688, 0.04993677884340286, -0.07598713040351868, 0.019175419583916664, -0.03480052947998047, 0.00015530423843301833, -0.03595082834362984, 0.0012696190970018506, 0.006560345180332661, 0.011584456078708172, -0.0031811269000172615, -0.05355590209364891, -0.025351010262966156, 0.02662278525531292, 0.037922319024801254, 0.02834373153746128, 0.07575250416994095, -0.0030741996597498655, -0.016836531460285187, -0.04952922835946083, -0.06975236535072327, -0.0036060307174921036, -0.04764772951602936, -0.04765932261943817, -0.007485781330615282, 0.006615728139877319, 0.00569132249802351, 0.01563514769077301, -0.041026923805475235, 0.062111735343933105, 0.023215163499116898, 0.04321708530187607, 0.03555441275238991, 0.0377066396176815, -0.053252577781677246, 0.0860825702548027, -0.008626500144600868, 0.025587044656276703, -0.03882182762026787, 0.04204501584172249, -0.005451478995382786, 0.0033215691801160574, -0.05103810876607895, 0.02206351049244404, 0.03123641386628151, -0.03898291289806366, 0.012490457855165005, 0.03644314780831337, -0.012125912122428417, -0.011803841218352318, 0.04437847435474396, 0.036685384809970856, -0.02561921253800392, -0.04615364968776703 ]
Screw and Lie group theory allows for user-friendly modeling of multibody systems (MBS) while at the same they give rise to computationally efficient recursive algorithms. The inherent frame invariance of such formulations allows for use of arbitrary reference frames within the kinematics modeling (rather than obeying modeling conventions such as the Denavit-Hartenberg convention) and to avoid introduction of joint frames. The computational efficiency is owed to a representation of twists, accelerations, and wrenches that minimizes the computational effort. This can be directly carried over to dynamics formulations. In this paper recursive $O\left( n\right) $ Newton-Euler algorithms are derived for the four most frequently used representations of twists, and their specific features are discussed. These formulations are related to the corresponding algorithms that were presented in the literature. The MBS motion equations are derived in closed form using the Lie group formulation. One are the so-called 'Euler-Jourdain' or 'projection' equations, of which Kane's equations are a special case, and the other are the Lagrange equations. The recursive kinematics formulations are readily extended to higher orders in order to compute derivatives of the motions equations. To this end, recursive formulations for the acceleration and jerk are derived. It is briefly discussed how this can be employed for derivation of the linearized motion equations and their time derivatives. The geometric modeling allows for direct application of Lie group integration methods, which is briefly discussed.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17793v1
[ -0.005348170176148415, -0.030415838584303856, 0.0484483502805233, 0.02362191304564476, 0.006279667839407921, -0.04020741954445839, -0.019477643072605133, -0.02032271958887577, -0.022743599489331245, -0.016089409589767456, -0.04077424481511116, -0.023627614602446556, -0.037911202758550644, -0.008436047472059727, -0.05765660107135773, -0.007704672869294882, 0.07245789468288422, 0.04822327569127083, -0.07287685573101044, 0.0625213012099266, 0.017131904140114784, -0.021460210904479027, -0.03936035558581352, 0.06510389596223831, -0.027675529941916466, -0.002279012929648161, 0.0037777493707835674, -0.00025745079619809985, -0.01771240308880806, -0.021242834627628326, 0.07073353230953217, 0.0015471813967451453, 0.0190573837608099, -0.0435294583439827, -0.04440435767173767, -0.0120859919115901, -0.0007825240027159452, 0.005852103233337402, 0.062198929488658905, 0.00039139200816862285, 0.004785958211869001, -0.020905952900648117, -0.046615153551101685, -0.022632472217082977, -0.038165412843227386, -0.022405819967389107, -0.03243212401866913, 0.007514990866184235, -0.04157407581806183, -0.041814643889665604, 0.01366545632481575, -0.004056003410369158, 0.020836442708969116, 0.04960126057267189, -0.02403932623565197, 0.025110401213169098, -0.0048384894616901875, 0.005763026885688305, -0.06486639380455017, -0.0376904122531414, -0.005702480673789978, -0.021539151668548584, 0.006727383006364107, -0.008574728854000568, 0.01212369091808796, 0.04678799584507942, -0.04332177713513374, -0.06282521039247513, -0.014168580062687397, -0.030070913955569267, 0.014422643929719925, -0.061603281646966934, 0.04533762112259865, -0.012625914067029953, -0.05294151231646538, 0.00007879667828092352, -0.024256227537989616, -0.04661509394645691, 0.021666178479790688, 0.02310909330844879, -0.03757268562912941, 0.019246600568294525, 0.009609480388462543, 0.008959485217928886, 0.007041564676910639, -0.03108076937496662, 0.06875628978013992, -0.058982715010643005, -0.018111692741513252, -0.04510422796010971, 0.05796867609024048, -0.015307311899960041, -0.07853667438030243, -0.005770107265561819, 0.03974035382270813, -0.040411680936813354, 0.05151301994919777, 0.04301799461245537, 0.007255336735397577, -0.01201228704303503, -0.01795460283756256, -0.03697365149855614, -0.040002599358558655, 0.06478000432252884, 0.03546303138136864, -0.042099304497241974, 0.02505115047097206, -0.011081297881901264, -0.05288335308432579, 0.009836049750447273, 0.02220146544277668, -0.027270715683698654, 0.018161166459321976, -0.03805256262421608, -0.007601973135024309, -0.04057219251990318, 0.0555056557059288, -0.02014889195561409, 0.02207348123192787, -0.002850869670510292, -0.04012829437851906, -0.011809885501861572, 0.014723123051226139, -0.015059537254273891, -0.03104640170931816, -0.025658326223492622, 0.060415152460336685, 0.015197992324829102, -0.01557108573615551, -0.027823058888316154, -0.025338882580399513, 0.004379461985081434, 0.0041984631679952145, -0.030133988708257675, 0.03973667323589325, -0.02042352594435215, -0.02896108105778694, -0.06600955873727798, 0.03904511779546738, 0.028940264135599136, -0.05390138179063797, -0.08121639490127563, 0.016983307898044586, -0.03619310259819031, 0.006821229588240385, 0.06405669450759888, -0.07428168505430222, 0.025559213012456894, -0.006996568758040667, 0.01897386834025383, -0.013592002913355827, -0.007013148628175259, 0.007608035579323769, 0.011979757808148861, 0.003971170634031296, 0.006676630582660437, 0.0111937765032053, 0.009455869905650616, -0.03071468695998192, -0.017640704289078712, 0.049605995416641235, -0.03864995017647743, -0.037478066980838776, -0.003663289360702038, 0.001137363025918603, 0.04466284066438675, 0.036090608686208725, -0.029014864936470985, -0.027057016268372536, 0.01957356184720993, -0.043957632035017014, 0.035463832318782806, 0.02618628926575184, -0.024061262607574463, -0.0701240748167038, -0.01829897053539753, -0.018488707020878792, -0.05197830870747566, -0.019443508237600327, 0.02003566175699234, -0.03943011909723282, 0.023582536727190018, -0.022227784618735313, 0.03534381836652756, -0.0038080669473856688, 0.017229750752449036, -0.08912427723407745, 0.028455359861254692, 0.025470394641160965, 0.06924974918365479, 0.0000033554872516106116, -0.05141959711909294, 0.027444347739219666, 0.005724429152905941, -0.02084495685994625, -0.048795606940984726, 0.019037574529647827, -0.047194913029670715, -0.03987216204404831, 0.03810881823301315, -0.07299647480249405, -0.017727313563227654, -0.020578812807798386, -0.0056589818559587, 0.006477731745690107, -0.07014340907335281, 0.0328994020819664, 0.04669852927327156, -0.008608896285295486, -0.05498920753598213, 0.06226681172847748, 0.0386684387922287, 0.03731270134449005, -0.022883428260684013, 0.03522701933979988, 0.0009859323035925627, -0.09935131669044495, 0.037150200456380844, -0.02428899146616459, -0.028107713907957077, 0.02334899641573429, -0.002278595929965377, -0.006478528957813978, -0.03195589408278465, -0.019769027829170227, 0.04233207181096077, 0.03031894937157631, 0.0009033361566253006, -0.05527640879154205, -0.032196156680583954, -0.006418081000447273, -0.06222507730126381, -0.05151639133691788, -0.06359107047319412, -0.0009250770090147853, -0.014363668859004974, -0.03162424638867378, 0.05925581976771355, -0.010721760801970959, -0.06439124792814255, -0.04188460111618042, 0.015432256273925304, 0.03473136946558952, -0.00539284897968173, -0.07556161284446716, -0.06566522270441055, -0.051766470074653625, -0.010217093862593174, -0.05513273552060127, -0.0013174484483897686, 0.00890269223600626, -0.0711829736828804, -0.027769194915890694, -0.015319461934268475, 0.006862115114927292, 0.03836873173713684, -0.03470481559634209, 0.04212738946080208, 0.014869187958538532, 0.023694727569818497, 0.02899257279932499, 0.022307436913251877, -0.03130277618765831, -0.022683318704366684, 0.012575273402035236, 0.019082162529230118, -0.027785656973719597, -0.006745421327650547, 0.05814322829246521, -0.022280516102910042, 0.01768854819238186, -0.001737155020236969, 0.033678069710731506, -0.01371746975928545, -0.000018391941921436228, -0.004318940918892622, 0.001834446913562715, -0.06579027324914932, -0.0029355220030993223, 0.05416107922792435, 0.052347779273986816, 0.0039894175715744495, -0.028930973261594772, -0.07524266839027405, -0.031639035791158676, -0.04078613966703415, -0.04003703594207764, -0.059553112834692, -0.061986301094293594, -0.027671944350004196, -0.07867898046970367, -0.012450115755200386, -0.013814800418913364, -0.06322804093360901, -0.056046660989522934, -0.06973227858543396, 0.027496417984366417, 0.02227066643536091, 0.0016435772413387895, -0.04161304235458374, -0.07164811342954636, 0.036292169243097305, 0.03363455832004547, 0.029612062498927116, -0.015475059859454632, -0.07986089587211609, -0.042079076170921326, 0.02053593471646309, 0.0195536557585001, 0.013281350024044514, -0.039234861731529236, -0.007147960364818573, -0.045441821217536926, 0.031952355057001114, 0.0645904541015625, 0.012701119296252728, 0.0532115213572979, -0.00892834272235632, 0.03381739929318428, -0.0642872229218483, -0.034115441143512726, -0.016701536253094673, -0.01149238832294941, -0.020425770431756973, -0.038130681961774826, -0.01760096661746502, 0.04431360214948654, 0.02665414847433567, -0.021220114082098007, -0.02334834635257721, -0.04118053987622261, 0.008039981126785278, 0.012461676262319088, -0.020057300105690956, 0.04106415808200836, 0.0423455648124218, -0.018557481467723846, -0.033275846391916275, -0.036634378135204315, 0.023268036544322968, -0.009034817107021809, -0.008749431930482388, -0.01711605302989483, -0.020122982561588287, 0.06032787635922432, -0.08925937861204147, 0.03228316083550453, 0.02485656924545765, 0.03844721242785454, -0.05745217949151993, 0.010181012563407421, 0.012496168725192547, -0.016271360218524933, 0.05450773611664772, -0.04706865921616554, 0.01679261401295662, 0.04900945723056793, 0.050476618111133575, -0.016445836052298546, -0.027833499014377594, -0.01747627928853035, -0.06973851472139359, -0.039811406284570694, -0.0077403392642736435, 0.049671102315187454, 0.0399315170943737, 0.0307549387216568, -0.01866832561790943, 0.02705073356628418, -0.01903577335178852, 0.027074767276644707, -0.027127746492624283, -0.010986569337546825, 0.04341547563672066, 0.02892918325960636, -0.03134290874004364, 0.0013114886824041605, 0.020546378567814827, 0.007887021638453007, -0.043953102082014084, -0.0018602281343191862, -0.05492957681417465, 0.04815026372671127, -0.02850271947681904, -0.026417655870318413, 0.04052416980266571, 0.025136122480034828, -0.04650440439581871, 0.057964760810136795, -0.025129521265625954, 0.009306239895522594, -0.012675553560256958, 0.007046903017908335, 0.02737128734588623, -0.03169592097401619, -0.06604763120412827, 0.009989769198000431, 0.018341002985835075, -0.006301619578152895, -0.036755189299583435, 0.010968074202537537, 0.018020067363977432, -0.03151683881878853, -0.08353704959154129, -0.008777936920523643, -0.04061342030763626, 0.0035766256041824818, -0.07182785123586655, -0.055202800780534744, 0.0841369554400444, -0.049507785588502884, -0.0018540810560807586, -0.021446168422698975, -0.014926285482943058, -0.041194815188646317, -0.011064485646784306, -0.038120485842227936, -0.06994064152240753, 0.0477498359978199, -0.037985868752002716, 0.05119821056723595, -0.018483327701687813, 0.02280178666114807, -0.020379522815346718, -0.017452461645007133, -0.010768435895442963, 0.074307382106781, 0.060777537524700165, 0.05104096606373787, -0.005268359091132879, -0.0007981053786352277, -0.018222659826278687, -0.001911513740196824, -0.02191532403230667, -0.027967188507318497, -0.026846768334507942, -0.011893275193870068, -0.028865400701761246, -0.038687363266944885, -0.029119133949279785, -0.0011485242284834385, 0.05421188846230507, -0.0548267662525177, -0.035882335156202316, 0.007994817569851875, 0.062154147773981094, -0.07856352627277374, -0.08082893490791321, -0.020462162792682648, -0.02091985009610653, -0.057629428803920746, 0.001590225612744689, 0.024831796064972878, 0.027408471331000328, 0.03916126489639282, 0.02297680824995041, -0.00569345336407423, 0.018975919112563133, 0.03664792701601982, -0.008110621944069862, 0.013434677384793758, 0.013889730907976627, 0.028724798932671547, 0.028145844116806984, -0.07395195215940475, -0.02311115339398384, -0.04610872268676758, 0.01864505559206009, -0.011264818720519543, 0.07479351758956909, 0.03921634331345558, 0.03958449140191078, -0.079976387321949, 0.043453771620988846, 0.0074697379022836685, 0.02062697522342205, -0.025340082123875618, 0.04511556029319763, -0.028426339849829674, -0.001386167830787599, -0.004547542426735163, 0.030480798333883286, 0.008853225968778133, -0.028531035408377647, 0.005992046091705561, -0.014360975474119186, 0.020078953355550766, -0.0023855173494666815, 0.07482068985700607, 0.0006294478662312031, -0.03497793525457382, 0.03248267620801926, -0.024232767522335052, -0.023901261389255524, -0.03478465601801872, 0.05007778853178024, 0.013757363893091679, -0.014709154143929482, -0.03518185764551163, -0.017234820872545242, -0.007407851051539183, 0.030353711917996407, 0.02016127109527588, -0.016293177381157875, -0.02817697636783123, 0.005485353525727987, 0.00705290213227272, 0.03291379660367966, 0.010828489437699318, -0.015429847873747349, -0.03765597939491272, 0.008542242459952831, 0.004622559528797865, -0.06524018198251724, 0.010604596696794033, -0.033027078956365585, 0.01843121461570263, 0.020353564992547035, 0.04300069063901901, 0.02599378116428852, 0.05916798114776611, -0.041588086634874344, -0.016089562326669693, 0.0052122194319963455, 0.0050292061641812325, 0.05706078186631203, -0.07181102782487869, 0.03230104222893715, -0.0010985455010086298, 0.020457008853554726, -0.0012149411486461759, -0.013864722102880478, 0.0011516991071403027, -0.04936014115810394, -0.002065966371446848, -0.014721878804266453, 0.029223233461380005, -0.03932496905326843, -0.03960973769426346, 0.024342339485883713, 0.04087227210402489, -0.05206304416060448, 0.04520020633935928, 0.03859091177582741, 0.011024866253137589, 0.043199460953474045, 0.022358836606144905, 0.02813039906322956, -0.02191515825688839, -0.018832795321941376, 0.07494597882032394, -0.03195463493466377, -0.035000815987586975, -0.04070453345775604, -0.06260373443365097, -0.0010924688540399075, -0.03877601772546768, 0.057932283729314804, -0.017106087878346443, -0.014864691533148289, -0.04031391441822052, 0.06860920041799545, -0.003671409795060754, -0.07880580425262451, -0.02739563398063183, 0.06586389243602753, -0.062242407351732254, 0.002822031732648611, -0.0037508246023207903, -0.01752951182425022, -0.041797440499067307, 0.05475406348705292, -0.020511897280812263, -0.04425923898816109, -0.058944083750247955, 0.06239929422736168, 0.07519613206386566, -0.003828838700428605, 0.024124784395098686, -0.0032353380229324102, -0.025858907029032707, 0.05475183203816414, -0.03474600613117218, -0.017153505235910416, -0.025921761989593506, -0.02861005626618862, -0.03497288003563881, -0.054460495710372925, -0.02213539183139801, 0.06442517787218094, -0.029022887349128723, -0.03391335904598236, 0.004977980628609657, -0.051460761576890945, 0.022089526057243347, -0.027588794007897377, -0.004518081899732351, -0.004261147230863571, 0.014271230436861515, -0.010158968158066273, -0.036803726106882095, -0.014226749539375305, -0.0032479194924235344, -0.019378120079636574, 0.006089355330914259, -0.038465552031993866, 0.025028470903635025, -0.018291037529706955, -0.056478649377822876, -0.02361048385500908, -0.05385106801986694, 0.002606106922030449, 0.029962271451950073, 0.04124043136835098, 0.0025132193695753813, 0.030153736472129822, 0.004908979870378971, -0.0005465602152980864, -0.02569708228111267, 0.01465075183659792, 0.02816072292625904, -0.004485570825636387, 0.03774869069457054, 0.008152319118380547, 0.041332095861434937, -0.01729569025337696, 0.0029508755542337894, -0.013451265171170235, -0.04954203590750694, -0.007517650723457336, 0.02340550906956196, -0.04572303220629692, -0.0056642149575054646, -0.011680012568831444, -0.011438018642365932, 0.0419318862259388, 0.029181769117712975, -0.03108883649110794, -0.04094356298446655, -0.003328039776533842, -0.013988093473017216, -0.007290170062333345, -0.01341725792735815, 0.03154352679848671, -0.024207796901464462, -0.017773358151316643, 0.029461756348609924, 0.0416802316904068, 0.0013262948486953974, 0.0319930836558342, -0.03623514622449875, -0.029141195118427277, -0.005619200877845287, -0.04444589838385582, -0.04442966356873512, -0.02315610460937023, 0.017775705084204674, -0.07084628194570541, -0.005886574275791645, 0.03414631634950638, -0.003422917565330863, 0.009724225848913193, -0.085695281624794, 0.02721647545695305, -0.04274357110261917, -0.010952555574476719, -0.0716029480099678, -0.021917840465903282, 0.03769449144601822, 0.004046088550239801, -0.0004248755576554686, -0.009833596646785736, -0.0452694296836853, 0.002799968235194683, -0.09301719069480896, 0.009971335530281067, -0.017112795263528824, 0.05531421676278114, -0.0422787107527256, -0.017222031950950623, -0.024759091436862946, -0.015442286618053913, 0.02827315777540207, 0.01872347481548786, 0.04371633008122444, 0.05240296572446823, -0.01684107817709446, 0.054863572120666504, -0.031221436336636543, 0.030111145228147507, 0.07557272166013718, -0.026058368384838104, 0.033350054174661636, -0.00105389638338238, 0.021170588210225105, -0.006365180481225252, 0.013784399256110191, 0.03547890856862068, -0.01898014172911644, 0.04412378370761871, -0.004136205650866032, -0.017837202176451683, -0.047059040516614914, -0.07849304378032684, 0.03443541005253792, -0.03909233585000038, -0.005894915666431189, 0.0060701919719576836, 0.0024645791854709387, -0.0456160306930542, -0.002301495987921953, -0.008699469268321991, 0.05882097780704498, -0.0158627238124609, -0.01599731482565403, 0.04608621448278427, -0.04447917640209198, -0.03961525484919548, -0.028353242203593254, -0.006645315792411566, -0.022355392575263977, 0.03170795366168022, 0.033446863293647766, -0.04290289059281349, 0.06545412540435791, -0.05399753525853157, 0.024566808715462685, -0.05605147406458855, 0.018250562250614166, 0.008531343191862106, 0.06212921068072319, -0.04204748570919037, 0.014952214434742928, -0.029885826632380486, -0.03333448991179466, -0.04135899245738983, -0.05372496694326401, 0.006760729942470789, -0.055591508746147156, 0.0519842728972435, -0.014471862465143204, 0.016025085002183914, -0.014057504013180733, 0.07415059953927994, 0.04482647776603699, 0.016643375158309937, -0.00876059290021658, 0.0024733191821724176, -0.006855605635792017, 0.024437211453914642, -0.02480149455368519, -0.058409322053194046, -0.02753542736172676, 0.042186614125967026, 0.044664595276117325, -0.023421546444296837, -0.045202046632766724, -0.003906477242708206, 0.02088601142168045, -0.02258368395268917, -0.02010253816843033, -0.0049228970892727375, 0.010210276581346989, -0.022209053859114647, 0.03385753184556961, 0.024511558935046196, -0.02133551612496376, -0.047119900584220886 ]
This paper is about the study of F-transforms based on overlap and grouping maps, residual and co-residual implicator over complete lattice from both constructive and axiomatic approaches. Further, the duality, basic properties, and the inverse of proposed F-transforms have been studied, and axiomatic characterizations of proposed direct F-transforms are investigated.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12894v1
[ -0.06656870245933533, -0.00509873079136014, -0.019506627693772316, 0.05471227318048477, -0.01993957906961441, -0.031824879348278046, -0.019786182790994644, 0.010417244397103786, -0.03246200457215309, -0.00450514629483223, -0.06180194020271301, -0.03016829676926136, -0.05745024234056473, -0.006645901128649712, -0.05607862025499344, -0.0011221790919080377, 0.006317005958408117, 0.05309246852993965, 0.02933306246995926, 0.06282716989517212, -0.022005777806043625, -0.02258099429309368, -0.04161043092608452, 0.06051990017294884, -0.01543847844004631, 0.028135007247328758, 0.024523094296455383, 0.027004433795809746, 0.009283015504479408, -0.01690548285841942, 0.035458408296108246, -0.02442682534456253, 0.0017392908921465278, -0.0033909729681909084, -0.03611298277974129, 0.009100468829274178, -0.022800663486123085, -0.012272943742573261, 0.029945094138383865, -0.03644094616174698, -0.0022109178826212883, -0.028812304139137268, -0.01718134433031082, 0.017537640407681465, -0.0115209324285388, -0.050034984946250916, -0.06187208741903305, 0.0484933964908123, -0.07650015503168106, -0.041738804429769516, -0.029698491096496582, -0.03097311407327652, 0.0052713374607264996, 0.01897064410150051, -0.044179487973451614, -0.016141461208462715, 0.037456266582012177, 0.04343048483133316, -0.01521606557071209, 0.02536744438111782, 0.003359171561896801, -0.025726651772856712, -0.003326606238260865, -0.014680420979857445, -0.021914996206760406, -0.0070944917388260365, -0.03715395927429199, -0.033979665488004684, -0.009999207220971584, -0.027196750044822693, -0.0029760540928691626, -0.02104972116649151, -0.015413798391819, 0.03196464106440544, -0.06119904667139053, 0.0011178961722180247, 0.019077574834227562, -0.037831153720617294, -0.014825313352048397, 0.011646597646176815, -0.007145551964640617, 0.0030159824527800083, -0.008627799339592457, -0.0013281161664053798, 0.00877227820456028, -0.03687731921672821, 0.026018837466835976, -0.047517936676740646, -0.023330291733145714, 0.016491616144776344, -0.022029951214790344, 0.04768352210521698, -0.024558264762163162, -0.007851075381040573, 0.04217257350683212, 0.026760468259453773, 0.037453290075063705, 0.040081799030303955, -0.03634219989180565, -0.03147662803530693, -0.02803129144012928, -0.01672445610165596, 0.005450291559100151, -0.0010655112564563751, 0.04300069436430931, -0.0028895526193082333, 0.041584793478250504, 0.011786277405917645, 0.05213893949985504, 0.0319092720746994, 0.02093762345612049, 0.02468186616897583, 0.033244308084249496, -0.01687438040971756, -0.044996511191129684, -0.035094112157821655, 0.0017390939174219966, -0.016664350405335426, 0.010540901683270931, 0.055690206587314606, 0.01574430800974369, -0.02210409939289093, -0.020459285005927086, -0.021346133202314377, -0.04601304233074188, -0.04916069284081459, 0.042362622916698456, -0.048654552549123764, 0.016046810895204544, -0.05968044325709343, -0.03603997454047203, -0.058695267885923386, 0.04404279217123985, -0.05583027005195618, 0.0427837148308754, -0.069022536277771, 0.02180440165102482, -0.039721906185150146, 0.05700013414025307, -0.010238692164421082, -0.06762547045946121, -0.08248885720968246, 0.041033901274204254, 0.0035067792050540447, 0.0502200573682785, 0.07037802785634995, -0.07948607951402664, -0.0010900943307206035, 0.01486661471426487, 0.03208445757627487, -0.0008997308323159814, -0.03651668131351471, -0.0029402212239801884, 0.04114470258355141, -0.002365685533732176, 0.004551338497549295, 0.06544984877109528, 0.0349748358130455, -0.017089683562517166, 0.02196624130010605, -0.008850973099470139, -0.05345786362886429, 0.061725277453660965, 0.03431922197341919, -0.022560887038707733, 0.00933794490993023, -0.011949805542826653, -0.0007735594408586621, -0.05372144281864166, -0.03926986828446388, -0.06362011283636093, 0.05315114185214043, -0.0324641689658165, -0.05433339625597, -0.05896495655179024, -0.04033326730132103, -0.03604806587100029, -0.03416852653026581, 0.02474893070757389, 0.015622712671756744, -0.00777015695348382, 0.0073438603430986404, -0.025021137669682503, -0.0679786428809166, -0.05741378292441368, 0.002799671608954668, -0.04744811728596687, 0.008037109859287739, 0.008702144026756287, -0.03466236963868141, -0.04366924613714218, -0.06711786985397339, -0.006573091726750135, -0.0339474081993103, -0.07951539009809494, -0.025965416803956032, -0.007476340513676405, -0.01930529624223709, -0.012464943341910839, 0.009883490391075611, -0.08069175481796265, 0.001542731304652989, -0.03606795519590378, 0.033904802054166794, 0.006647036410868168, -0.065529465675354, 0.0031367288902401924, 0.032411202788352966, 0.013823343440890312, -0.021583974361419678, 0.01851661503314972, 0.04913579672574997, 0.007618390955030918, -0.07819981127977371, -0.045001283288002014, 0.007274612318724394, -0.09335774928331375, 0.026980645954608917, -0.028703799471259117, -0.02852197177708149, 0.0467204712331295, 0.06268350034952164, 0.003167100716382265, -0.0157500971108675, -0.01525228749960661, 0.007983199320733547, 0.03754500299692154, 0.01330583542585373, 0.022098099812865257, -0.02804403007030487, -0.024764563888311386, -0.07650578022003174, -0.06246507167816162, -0.04201839864253998, -0.021959805861115456, 0.003590115811675787, 0.03431485965847969, 0.039776939898729324, -0.0011111225467175245, -0.06003228947520256, -0.04907436668872833, 0.010746542364358902, 0.030023863539099693, -0.01811985857784748, -0.03961127623915672, -0.03187631443142891, -0.05638330802321434, -0.02814781665802002, -0.016617925837635994, 0.0179672222584486, 0.022006018087267876, -0.06619654595851898, -0.0076901172287762165, -0.05288948863744736, -0.027305470779538155, 0.032030198723077774, -0.025590119883418083, -0.022280845791101456, -0.019156673923134804, 0.020303256809711456, 0.010223782621324062, 0.04032036289572716, -0.01932471990585327, 0.022152289748191833, -0.015342123806476593, 0.018635137006640434, -0.03184088319540024, -0.035633329302072525, 0.01240493729710579, -0.04714458808302879, 0.024253005161881447, 0.009918373078107834, 0.019056374207139015, -0.023617539554834366, -0.062161266803741455, 0.0015144613571465015, 0.05737524479627609, -0.023472461849451065, -0.014250379987061024, 0.020629094913601875, 0.013633494265377522, 0.03861817345023155, -0.032942451536655426, -0.03741799667477608, 0.022909386083483696, 0.0038694890681654215, 0.0013336727861315012, -0.0014580144779756665, -0.023023109883069992, 0.0006255521439015865, -0.06837385147809982, -0.06143314391374588, 0.0020918764639645815, -0.055692270398139954, 0.026575548574328423, -0.06123166158795357, -0.02696143463253975, -0.0472157821059227, -0.03793115168809891, -0.0031533576548099518, -0.07714611291885376, -0.056284099817276, 0.005002253223210573, -0.02419121377170086, -0.02633804641664028, -0.06446590274572372, -0.06311018764972687, 0.0531686507165432, -0.00800552498549223, -0.06347911804914474, -0.03430734574794769, 0.001139419968239963, -0.04935375228524208, 0.03500279039144516, 0.013627652078866959, 0.030536189675331116, 0.020416850224137306, -0.010417315177619457, 0.047672342509031296, 0.05822882801294327, -0.002506950870156288, 0.013716476038098335, -0.0078407758846879, -0.030202986672520638, -0.05802620202302933, 0.04589568451046944, 0.047176361083984375, -0.022463737055659294, -0.010631185956299305, 0.04256187006831169, -0.04407545551657677, -0.020233292132616043, 0.04050499573349953, -0.06961507350206375, 0.041957754641771317, 0.05705523490905762, 0.04620769992470741, -0.026453623548150063, 0.02258588746190071, 0.023335065692663193, -0.007531589828431606, 0.04298358038067818, 0.02680179476737976, -0.06035490334033966, 0.0028583102393895388, -0.006863605231046677, 0.0219127144664526, 0.05753098055720329, 0.06039072945713997, 0.004908705595880747, -0.0237735565751791, 0.053142767399549484, 0.029351912438869476, 0.004811098799109459, -0.026402954012155533, 0.03847852721810341, 0.03255457058548927, 0.026276545599102974, 0.001052520121447742, -0.021397942677140236, -0.07256052643060684, -0.07672196626663208, -0.06819847971200943, -0.04543766379356384, 0.06234842911362648, 0.016375446692109108, 0.03202465549111366, -0.0012695570476353168, 0.0394061915576458, -0.005570415873080492, 0.0305836983025074, 0.04716285690665245, -0.048247575759887695, -0.03362393379211426, 0.001125521957874298, -0.004794890061020851, -0.005020509473979473, -0.0036909738555550575, -0.03641974553465843, -0.05703338608145714, 0.02632235921919346, -0.01878032647073269, 0.030872376635670662, 0.04128406196832657, 0.014196258969604969, 0.07322492450475693, -0.01921076700091362, -0.002692410023882985, 0.031184189021587372, -0.017573067918419838, 0.05519523844122887, -0.01782727614045143, 0.0113950464874506, -0.013710500672459602, -0.031219417229294777, -0.052902188152074814, -0.011078313924372196, -0.0034325651358813047, -0.04209360107779503, -0.059829775243997574, 0.0033202755730599165, -0.019809864461421967, -0.0720318928360939, -0.06695716828107834, -0.03502792492508888, -0.015650365501642227, 0.01902403123676777, 0.004193654749542475, -0.043867241591215134, 0.06363298743963242, 0.04751405119895935, 0.025183213874697685, 0.03347214683890343, -0.027432318776845932, -0.04168320819735527, -0.034375857561826706, 0.02296190708875656, -0.05088653042912483, 0.06750188022851944, -0.04357440024614334, 0.034619126468896866, -0.055936578661203384, 0.012801704928278923, -0.05204038321971893, 0.05914700776338577, 0.0330938994884491, -0.04635314270853996, 0.026331350207328796, 0.00015322239778470248, -0.00015305459965020418, 0.006426750682294369, -0.012963048182427883, 0.03823862224817276, -0.009426610544323921, 0.01343336421996355, -0.010678092949092388, 0.01709083467721939, -0.0014378215419128537, -0.016685694456100464, -0.027266457676887512, -0.024088922888040543, 0.04664689302444458, -0.04581842198967934, -0.016340121626853943, -0.011297084391117096, -0.020383119583129883, -0.03359122946858406, -0.06013096496462822, 0.01591099612414837, -0.012794598937034607, -0.027931535616517067, 0.03033899888396263, -0.01276751421391964, 0.006577537395060062, 0.002831848803907633, -0.021815970540046692, -0.025945106521248817, 0.05021604150533676, -0.012843280099332333, 0.006274707615375519, -0.00012430302740540355, 0.016487903892993927, -0.0015170560218393803, -0.05852667987346649, -0.045992039144039154, 0.020535169169306755, -0.006636957172304392, 0.01367155835032463, 0.032791923731565475, 0.04854969307780266, 0.0004968264838680625, -0.0007333542453125119, -0.07899297773838043, 0.027083411812782288, 0.06958942115306854, -0.049938224256038666, -0.026438996195793152, 0.03607423976063728, -0.04815853014588356, 0.027823932468891144, -0.059922438114881516, -0.023596351966261864, 0.00009997779125114903, -0.009812846779823303, 0.022861408069729805, -0.033666934818029404, 0.02683011069893837, 0.07072769105434418, 0.03940250352025032, -0.032201457768678665, -0.020663227885961533, -0.006977187469601631, -0.033854853361845016, 0.0049140783958137035, -0.05702609196305275, 0.04230254888534546, 0.026223668828606606, -0.0026330191176384687, -0.060600560158491135, 0.038924235850572586, -0.003435334889218211, 0.011069643311202526, 0.03877060487866402, 0.009225582703948021, 0.020075855776667595, 0.05861210823059082, -0.03173593059182167, 0.029772797599434853, 0.027878979220986366, 0.006862084846943617, 0.0317641980946064, -0.05208182707428932, -0.05222230404615402, -0.06015646830201149, -0.0329391248524189, -0.009688949212431908, -0.008799722418189049, 0.05208833888173103, -0.031707700341939926, 0.04274432361125946, 0.04019805043935776, 0.04099772498011589, 0.023816589266061783, 0.05496935546398163, -0.011113044805824757, 0.021437421441078186, -0.047904521226882935, -0.0437629297375679, 0.012736325152218342, -0.00013614344061352313, 0.03396494314074516, 0.030644960701465607, 0.012397625483572483, 0.009204558096826077, -0.05747315287590027, -0.03323100507259369, 0.008838624693453312, -0.0030602391343563795, -0.00737624429166317, -0.06595837324857712, 0.0376528799533844, 0.0034893883857876062, 0.016294779255986214, 0.008748996071517467, 0.022188296541571617, 0.0005094283260405064, 0.05759119614958763, 0.0014156359247863293, -0.041175831109285355, -0.061933353543281555, 0.05397320166230202, -0.06689472496509552, 0.027550755068659782, -0.05735405534505844, -0.04760676622390747, -0.034845080226659775, -0.035746920853853226, 0.012023385614156723, 0.05381479114294052, -0.055852487683296204, -0.025458717718720436, -0.00392715772613883, 0.0043380227871239185, -0.02689787931740284, -0.028201468288898468, -0.023324068635702133, -0.05873629450798035, -0.014156285673379898, -0.015197161585092545, 0.02224048785865307, -0.03955777361989021, -0.0023950987961143255, -0.0025025701615959406, -0.0592341348528862, -0.054051484912633896, 0.012853970751166344, 0.042434968054294586, -0.05672844499349594, -0.01950119622051716, -0.0010042029898613691, 0.029788177460432053, -0.040819957852363586, -0.04843805357813835, -0.03691451624035835, -0.010996515862643719, 0.016830502077937126, -0.033068157732486725, -0.007492187432944775, -0.005722488276660442, 0.019602715969085693, -0.010095812380313873, -0.007170888129621744, 0.01350227277725935, -0.05838609114289284, -0.029812408611178398, -0.02274521067738533, 0.00046731947804801166, -0.019300654530525208, -0.04658997431397438, 0.0010505600366741419, -0.06339560449123383, -0.06105922535061836, -0.05262339487671852, 0.011412059888243675, 0.02603752166032791, -0.051712941378355026, -0.006997545249760151, -0.00037263843114487827, -0.056884005665779114, -0.01542628463357687, 0.02361258491873741, 0.04660791531205177, -0.044825516641139984, -0.04088887199759483, -0.03436563163995743, 0.007080166134983301, -0.031213343143463135, -0.03983297199010849, 0.04501716420054436, 0.044108204543590546, -0.05797566473484039, 0.03029637038707733, -0.04535219073295593, 0.004816384986042976, 0.07056913524866104, -0.017863068729639053, -0.005142332054674625, -0.061701174825429916, -0.07578077167272568, 0.01730360835790634, 0.005751230288296938, -0.06426455825567245, -0.008288823999464512, -0.016801979392766953, -0.006759360898286104, -0.0494842566549778, -0.005573694594204426, -0.0513182170689106, -0.02353292517364025, 0.020286481827497482, -0.017665555700659752, 0.0034695968497544527, 0.04562375694513321, -0.026861660182476044, 0.007313174195587635, 0.04406740516424179, 0.029005300253629684, 0.019770633429288864, 0.026901615783572197, -0.003834314178675413, -0.03533570468425751, 0.02430504932999611, 0.013912583701312542, -0.020356090739369392, 0.005317247472703457, -0.024795565754175186, -0.035127680748701096, -0.08664194494485855, 0.04370178282260895, -0.06263087689876556, -0.055658165365457535, -0.002207841956987977, -0.010422872379422188, 0.016431165859103203, 0.008587874472141266, 0.02409995160996914, -0.08414628356695175, 0.014855820685625076, 0.026778776198625565, 0.022898446768522263, -0.057589445263147354, -0.02335556037724018, -0.030534744262695312, 0.04098917543888092, -0.042706891894340515, -0.06266926974058151, 0.0036704903468489647, 0.008146330714225769, 0.026012195274233818, -0.02451470121741295, 0.045722298324108124, -0.04918922111392021, -0.060250263661146164, -0.006089614704251289, 0.01990998163819313, 0.015715263783931732, -0.02929846942424774, 0.04356325417757034, 0.016321931034326553, 0.03660459816455841, -0.02415584959089756, 0.02756405808031559, 0.024130655452609062, -0.040775150060653687, 0.03217790275812149, -0.006862023379653692, 0.00532082375138998, -0.006270026788115501, -0.021381204947829247, 0.011576582677662373, -0.03849271684885025, -0.03354094922542572, -0.01643390953540802, -0.0614204965531826, 0.0021986388601362705, -0.03219353407621384, 0.01685814931988716, 0.02334192767739296, 0.013084943406283855, -0.04126540198922157, 0.026833564043045044, -0.06601137667894363, 0.010769260115921497, -0.031192125752568245, -0.01460083294659853, 0.04291420057415962, -0.04975734278559685, 0.010122756473720074, 0.06403128802776337, -0.011740513145923615, -0.020459765568375587, 0.018453866243362427, 0.03234578296542168, -0.05882455036044121, 0.07001421600580215, -0.06037415936589241, 0.01653553731739521, 0.02435225434601307, 0.04748879373073578, -0.000055852768127806485, 0.024888431653380394, -0.06343185156583786, -0.04198041558265686, -0.030517911538481712, 0.005548989400267601, -0.0023747491650283337, -0.06481678038835526, -0.05547333136200905, -0.06530040502548218, 0.020462462678551674, -0.019299400970339775, -0.0015700333751738071, -0.056857023388147354, 0.06100504472851753, 0.03910592570900917, -0.00007933616143418476, 0.032893646508455276, -0.04109141603112221, -0.010695252567529678, 0.045216988772153854, -0.006953636184334755, -0.012860258109867573, -0.012270694598555565, 0.031994108110666275, -0.024453377351164818, -0.010289219208061695, -0.0044069779105484486, -0.015376393683254719, -0.039737097918987274, 0.03050207532942295, -0.03970447555184364, 0.04986342042684555, -0.05506555736064911, 0.03260699287056923, -0.024914195761084557, -0.008573712781071663, -0.03802378475666046, 0.00514970114454627 ]
Low-rank tensor completion (LRTC) aims to recover a complete low-rank tensor from incomplete observed tensor, attracting extensive attention in various practical applications such as image processing and computer vision. However, current methods often perform well only when there is a sufficient of observed information, and they perform poorly or may fail when the observed information is less than 5\%. In order to improve the utilization of observed information, a new method called the tensor joint rank with logarithmic composite norm (TJLC) method is proposed. This method simultaneously exploits two types of tensor low-rank structures, namely tensor Tucker rank and tubal rank, thereby enhancing the inherent correlations between known and missing elements. To address the challenge of applying two tensor ranks with significantly different directly to LRTC, a new tensor Logarithmic composite norm is further proposed. Subsequently, the TJLC model and algorithm for the LRTC problem are proposed. Additionally, theoretical convergence guarantees for the TJLC method are provided. Experiments on various real datasets demonstrate that the proposed method outperforms state-of-the-art methods significantly. Particularly, the proposed method achieves satisfactory recovery even when the observed information is as low as 1\%, and the recovery performance improves significantly as the observed information increases.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16208v2
[ -0.022055864334106445, -0.0686311274766922, 0.028003202751278877, 0.0018368425080552697, -0.01909911260008812, -0.019146554172039032, -0.016084127128124237, -0.014320998452603817, -0.005216405261307955, -0.03008904866874218, -0.050185710191726685, -0.014100240543484688, -0.04851853847503662, 0.0025918034370988607, -0.046009182929992676, 0.012855270877480507, 0.08238397538661957, 0.049651239067316055, -0.03573298081755638, 0.0784398540854454, -0.007541553117334843, 0.018120888620615005, -0.04607152193784714, 0.055921100080013275, 0.015090997330844402, 0.0009176612948067486, -0.05431576073169708, 0.03099936805665493, -0.02577086165547371, 0.0031263427808880806, 0.055790048092603683, -0.029989946633577347, -0.0031642860267311335, -0.06081138551235199, -0.0009366227313876152, -0.0028952141292393208, 0.014327790588140488, 0.004123211372643709, 0.05324721708893776, -0.054048433899879456, 0.01644372008740902, -0.017804449424147606, -0.04879070818424225, -0.023467624559998512, 0.025614971294999123, -0.008888707496225834, -0.041947141289711, 0.031602390110492706, -0.05322694778442383, -0.046607088297605515, 0.03586079180240631, 0.025946035981178284, -0.032271649688482285, 0.01345117762684822, -0.04097882658243179, 0.0024909772910177708, 0.003585003549233079, -0.0048788501881062984, -0.05249735713005066, -0.006157665979117155, -0.009495974518358707, -0.008318222127854824, -0.017792679369449615, -0.009315351955592632, -0.031138084828853607, 0.04785127192735672, 0.0022098394110798836, -0.06963138282299042, -0.04715820774435997, -0.041096340864896774, 0.031759027391672134, -0.06529992073774338, 0.03497442230582237, 0.02574280835688114, -0.03864274173974991, -0.04475697875022888, -0.03071513958275318, -0.03264034911990166, 0.003014094429090619, -0.01689264364540577, -0.0596589632332325, 0.05244605243206024, 0.022828655317425728, -0.003607804188504815, -0.011995671316981316, -0.016171889379620552, 0.07082023471593857, -0.04825277253985405, 0.008149179629981518, -0.06788542866706848, 0.05101175233721733, -0.030440419912338257, -0.06930384039878845, -0.01433196198195219, 0.06654650717973709, -0.04361815005540848, 0.034761976450681686, 0.03105466067790985, 0.028158506378531456, -0.027902768924832344, -0.001561098382808268, -0.017983239144086838, -0.03636159747838974, 0.051838263869285583, 0.044558845460414886, -0.026012636721134186, 0.006386085879057646, 0.013789501041173935, -0.03483279049396515, -0.013666611164808273, -0.03320849686861038, -0.01760028675198555, 0.0380769744515419, -0.044222548604011536, -0.01330990344285965, -0.05054336041212082, 0.06581838428974152, 0.0223738681524992, 0.00363168609328568, -0.024338819086551666, -0.033275291323661804, 0.02892652153968811, 0.035142023116350174, -0.006780343595892191, -0.0690251886844635, -0.034779079258441925, 0.037425726652145386, 0.021719016134738922, -0.01799086481332779, -0.017246728762984276, -0.02985832840204239, 0.011917725205421448, 0.01985008642077446, -0.014126821421086788, 0.03657188639044762, -0.005780702456831932, 0.01682046428322792, -0.057145606726408005, 0.04690616577863693, 0.019425559788942337, -0.016487933695316315, -0.048126254230737686, 0.04060276970267296, -0.040700484067201614, -0.01284361258149147, 0.0588688924908638, -0.0527697391808033, -0.05717944726347923, 0.014053106307983398, 0.00559210916981101, -0.01278475672006607, -0.023897835984826088, 0.0063041443936526775, 0.0444803386926651, 0.036305978894233704, 0.035240646451711655, 0.045169979333877563, 0.010622034780681133, -0.00988632719963789, 0.027526745572686195, 0.052094265818595886, -0.02375219203531742, 0.01905117556452751, 0.010960369370877743, 0.025966111570596695, 0.004069553688168526, 0.03164318948984146, -0.02014213800430298, -0.002716234652325511, 0.04031021147966385, 0.00009013927046908066, -0.028970105573534966, 0.015842663124203682, -0.0003095917054452002, -0.04475052282214165, -0.029955893754959106, 0.006686062086373568, -0.05361098051071167, -0.06475891172885895, -0.03978307917714119, 0.014363333582878113, 0.043766509741544724, 0.02300400286912918, -0.011387387290596962, -0.038648467510938644, -0.010225055739283562, -0.08481688797473907, -0.005511817056685686, 0.026559576392173767, 0.017272334545850754, -0.02639012224972248, -0.03347654268145561, 0.02878614142537117, 0.007017417810857296, -0.017846856266260147, -0.042862776666879654, -0.01998603343963623, -0.04986727610230446, -0.026736989617347717, 0.03645843267440796, -0.08459591865539551, -0.019309036433696747, -0.056255195289850235, 0.006339102052152157, -0.021718965843319893, -0.05042729154229164, 0.016998877748847008, 0.06195688247680664, -0.030844641849398613, 0.007008799351751804, 0.060196470469236374, 0.05491364747285843, 0.0457615926861763, 0.0013325433246791363, 0.04714200645685196, -0.0117705212906003, -0.09788385033607483, 0.04196351394057274, -0.014189180918037891, 0.015707651153206825, 0.03711982071399689, -0.021914644166827202, -0.0016787927597761154, -0.058447517454624176, -0.04602184146642685, 0.059399791061878204, 0.05950712040066719, 0.04194248095154762, -0.04602040350437164, -0.0228855200111866, 0.01784037984907627, -0.051303841173648834, -0.010130289942026138, -0.07710679620504379, -0.04077914357185364, -0.030364805832505226, -0.020286796614527702, 0.045738834887742996, 0.0010570684680715203, -0.025128938257694244, -0.0404684916138649, 0.022908713668584824, 0.03527337685227394, 0.0030283054802566767, -0.06024927273392677, -0.023943422362208366, -0.047167375683784485, 0.033427052199840546, -0.030950060114264488, 0.029485493898391724, -0.05602985993027687, -0.054460376501083374, 0.0057639265432953835, -0.03236015886068344, -0.006285540293902159, 0.06615724414587021, -0.01601426675915718, 0.019536782056093216, -0.005084364674985409, 0.05187186598777771, 0.011617762967944145, 0.026958854869008064, -0.053772903978824615, 0.02556612715125084, -0.003464065259322524, -0.00631989911198616, -0.01793653517961502, -0.016624178737401962, -0.003983609843999147, -0.017651913687586784, -0.03640676289796829, 0.04615294560790062, 0.020994706079363823, 0.03576377406716347, -0.002123597078025341, -0.04136490076780319, -0.024273818358778954, -0.04684094712138176, 0.057563941925764084, 0.04104268178343773, 0.026959609240293503, 0.028649436309933662, -0.0014842816162854433, -0.0843038260936737, 0.009772559627890587, -0.03466947749257088, -0.02525046467781067, -0.06754253804683685, -0.051979195326566696, -0.014815105125308037, -0.08190794289112091, -0.025764815509319305, -0.0505470409989357, -0.02445416897535324, -0.059906184673309326, -0.05126854404807091, -0.03752153366804123, 0.014172207564115524, 0.03163006156682968, -0.023826254531741142, -0.06666222959756851, -0.013232738710939884, 0.010028286837041378, -0.002152291825041175, 0.00436616875231266, -0.05320170894265175, -0.06187209114432335, -0.014582726173102856, 0.05698027461767197, 0.011535396799445152, -0.030787933617830276, -0.021164026111364365, -0.023512547835707664, 0.04856939613819122, 0.020352870225906372, 0.042140644043684006, 0.021875981241464615, -0.000363740895409137, 0.010678374208509922, -0.03324812650680542, 0.014580655843019485, -0.02052941732108593, -0.027890853583812714, -0.026021001860499382, -0.04722248390316963, -0.026489799842238426, 0.06765570491552353, 0.018022222444415092, -0.017295928671956062, -0.02457427978515625, -0.020112471655011177, 0.004850844386965036, 0.03600506857037544, -0.016828441992402077, 0.022857394069433212, 0.052964627742767334, -0.00522632198408246, -0.03951562941074371, -0.009176386520266533, -0.028428325429558754, -0.001982604619115591, 0.045805033296346664, 0.019859133288264275, -0.0034477270673960447, 0.004121515434235334, -0.0843566507101059, 0.04796111583709717, 0.043403465300798416, 0.06312613189220428, -0.0007216967642307281, 0.01722967065870762, 0.024854712188243866, 0.02297847345471382, -0.014713018201291561, -0.015723219141364098, 0.021708138287067413, 0.0020629423670470715, 0.05363057926297188, -0.06808630377054214, -0.036202870309352875, 0.030703337863087654, -0.04628320783376694, -0.029490599408745766, -0.029582908377051353, -0.012111598625779152, 0.045174602419137955, 0.026841608807444572, -0.017322208732366562, 0.0325782336294651, -0.03850473836064339, 0.02320420742034912, -0.001449208240956068, -0.025819549337029457, 0.047031715512275696, -0.034962207078933716, 0.011439439840614796, 0.04121933877468109, 0.016468601301312447, 0.015206960961222649, -0.04104238003492355, 0.030399134382605553, -0.06893553584814072, 0.026871472597122192, 0.04826321080327034, -0.016200214624404907, 0.044741541147232056, 0.05000438541173935, -0.02846447192132473, 0.03799612075090408, 0.020085806027054787, -0.025956373661756516, 0.0005414389888755977, 0.0538397878408432, -0.014299139380455017, -0.001177737140096724, -0.03504069522023201, 0.010658551007509232, 0.022275814786553383, 0.004431714303791523, -0.013822519220411777, 0.007136850617825985, -0.005502647254616022, -0.024242665618658066, -0.08785390853881836, 0.005021934397518635, -0.012632121331989765, 0.026140302419662476, -0.01210392452776432, -0.049826961010694504, 0.05621699243783951, -0.03205491602420807, 0.016369018703699112, -0.03002765029668808, -0.03150070831179619, -0.02701655402779579, -0.045309677720069885, -0.020776376128196716, -0.061310358345508575, 0.03186461701989174, -0.05334874615073204, 0.04995055869221687, 0.019200926646590233, -0.0031532985158264637, -0.054097939282655716, 0.008509713225066662, 0.017505403608083725, 0.036285970360040665, 0.07718192785978317, 0.029031647369265556, 0.011096243746578693, 0.0054427762515842915, -0.04166487231850624, -0.050482410937547684, -0.03113362193107605, -0.013982047326862812, -0.021755995228886604, 0.04901997745037079, -0.013890056870877743, -0.00011462199472589418, -0.06120907515287399, 0.024406233802437782, 0.06404218077659607, -0.04371916130185127, -0.02529958449304104, 0.028006475418806076, 0.04365265369415283, -0.05962054058909416, -0.06140197068452835, -0.0001608553866390139, -0.02317797765135765, -0.05049321427941322, -0.004979968536645174, 0.005345993675291538, 0.03966429829597473, 0.01330987736582756, 0.028775839135050774, 0.04627092555165291, 0.015266180038452148, -0.009193231351673603, 0.024680467322468758, 0.031091082841157913, 0.008107930421829224, -0.03714730963110924, -0.04881558194756508, -0.08686444163322449, 0.03451971337199211, 0.026551568880677223, -0.010420347563922405, 0.021284613758325577, 0.0578804537653923, -0.012531610205769539, 0.04923970252275467, -0.07807153463363647, -0.0016232505440711975, 0.005314074922353029, -0.020852334797382355, 0.03816134110093117, 0.07569599151611328, -0.010653655044734478, 0.04718543216586113, -0.014894609339535236, -0.007287857588380575, 0.05013732239603996, -0.04698590934276581, 0.009088347665965557, -0.024203423410654068, -0.011295436881482601, 0.014548474922776222, 0.060546621680259705, 0.019223062321543694, -0.0601743645966053, -0.008263605646789074, 0.0005261890473775566, -0.011008871719241142, -0.029281092807650566, 0.026181116700172424, 0.02734825201332569, 0.021219871938228607, -0.03580167889595032, 0.021226465702056885, -0.00323650985956192, 0.04646451398730278, 0.02177262492477894, -0.03549165651202202, -0.021711694076657295, 0.042777303606271744, -0.009032594040036201, 0.03546846657991409, 0.030156467109918594, -0.0031499704346060753, -0.010202399455010891, -0.03067432902753353, 0.016801992431282997, -0.06559387594461441, -0.004101953003555536, -0.049915675073862076, 0.04088146984577179, 0.05958743020892143, 0.029422376304864883, 0.01804158464074135, 0.042365964502096176, -0.016401389613747597, -0.02777596190571785, 0.023983487859368324, -0.05616018548607826, 0.029338719323277473, -0.03425298258662224, 0.0360107459127903, -0.029585236683487892, 0.029027676209807396, 0.0107226287946105, -0.016394739970564842, -0.0056070685386657715, 0.03205171599984169, -0.009068339131772518, 0.030828025192022324, 0.016610324382781982, -0.03435318171977997, -0.023927517235279083, 0.04598003998398781, 0.046053532510995865, -0.039345335215330124, 0.008802361786365509, 0.01980404183268547, 0.005613054148852825, 0.01853765919804573, 0.02882504090666771, -0.02965567260980606, -0.04561275616288185, 0.05734538286924362, 0.08104177564382553, -0.04921766370534897, -0.02987878955900669, -0.05080786347389221, -0.024706773459911346, 0.0026081677060574293, -0.04141867905855179, -0.0008797784685157239, -0.004883156158030033, 0.021322838962078094, -0.05760801210999489, 0.07242237776517868, -0.0027568950317800045, -0.07049960643053055, -0.0019256494706496596, 0.03357667103409767, -0.08207293599843979, 0.000291127449600026, 0.03988156467676163, -0.015465281903743744, -0.033593855798244476, 0.03426232188940048, -0.0033632845152169466, -0.036620236933231354, -0.0339927114546299, 0.07559458911418915, 0.08536192774772644, 0.000761933799367398, 0.03240585699677467, 0.012205283157527447, -0.042447786778211594, -0.007699363399296999, -0.05135941877961159, 0.0010725947795435786, 0.030382167547941208, 0.02652525156736374, 0.012528352439403534, -0.014377948828041553, -0.049365054816007614, 0.04185480251908302, -0.02087405137717724, 0.0076864780858159065, 0.031000740826129913, 0.008914794772863388, 0.034625668078660965, -0.014730432070791721, -0.0335860513150692, -0.002376709133386612, -0.032478801906108856, -0.009386619552969933, -0.012212956324219704, 0.01975441351532936, 0.029232237488031387, 0.01868659444153309, -0.005985770374536514, -0.053117845207452774, 0.003013933077454567, -0.007325826212763786, -0.05999886617064476, 0.019289514049887657, -0.04317692294716835, 0.036816541105508804, 0.010770256631076336, 0.020852338522672653, 0.006154580041766167, 0.046182967722415924, -0.027418125420808792, 0.027111124247312546, -0.01810130663216114, 0.00018767360597848892, 0.014553519897162914, 0.011452585458755493, 0.02273470349609852, -0.06018121540546417, 0.023473232984542847, -0.05048396810889244, -0.00023997823882382363, -0.023798374459147453, -0.051946140825748444, 0.010821896605193615, 0.01645650900900364, -0.0323452465236187, -0.04983009770512581, 0.009936940856277943, -0.036126118153333664, 0.027660222724080086, -0.0005829460569657385, 0.004506583325564861, -0.07874108850955963, 0.04063523933291435, 0.011483707465231419, -0.02019830234348774, 0.021241942420601845, 0.011906483210623264, -0.012313144281506538, 0.006227648351341486, 0.0510358065366745, 0.007423994597047567, 0.02848477102816105, 0.045576062053442, -0.07696747779846191, -0.00306767039000988, 0.010396985337138176, -0.014345962554216385, -0.05924579128623009, 0.014066253788769245, -0.010223107412457466, -0.05025693401694298, -0.0014913521008566022, 0.04711642488837242, 0.04048803448677063, -0.0414949469268322, -0.06005190312862396, 0.032653819769620895, 0.012386769987642765, -0.025424256920814514, -0.057675838470458984, 0.0239554550498724, -0.025057174265384674, -0.01785229705274105, -0.05912437289953232, -0.06381872296333313, -0.06626403331756592, -0.020169051364064217, -0.09074018150568008, -0.009792170487344265, -0.045576062053442, 0.048706311732530594, -0.012938425876200199, -0.03583664074540138, -0.01698603667318821, -0.003750496543943882, 0.03783668950200081, -0.00979676004499197, 0.019482480362057686, 0.02853523939847946, 0.039026230573654175, -0.006560849491506815, -0.05607667937874794, -0.009283146820962429, 0.03838832303881645, -0.0370304174721241, 0.005730931647121906, -0.011760750785470009, 0.055334605276584625, -0.025862617418169975, -0.0038361926563084126, 0.0666998028755188, -0.027451811358332634, 0.04921196401119232, -0.040211014449596405, -0.0005053170025348663, -0.05124231427907944, -0.05737137794494629, 0.01565191149711609, -0.0376722626388073, -0.010976339690387249, 0.01794407330453396, 0.00030743726529181004, -0.031247558072209358, -0.0389837920665741, -0.034567318856716156, 0.03119529038667679, 0.005058605223894119, -0.022406065836548805, 0.035084012895822525, -0.019629936665296555, 0.0008931744378060102, -0.053685352206230164, -0.046722039580345154, -0.04113764688372612, 0.027425523847341537, 0.053744472563266754, -0.00426355330273509, 0.02381240762770176, -0.06738206744194031, 0.044085338711738586, 0.006481715478003025, 0.033195286989212036, -0.02002936787903309, 0.05918996036052704, -0.044260941445827484, 0.026683833450078964, -0.02749268338084221, -0.03437168151140213, -0.02127126231789589, -0.06638003140687943, -0.019172778353095055, -0.05630173161625862, 0.016550274565815926, -0.016572458669543266, 0.034628015011548996, -0.021322760730981827, 0.039954982697963715, 0.039892662316560745, 0.00682204170152545, 0.016494477167725563, 0.04861897975206375, -0.04900338500738144, 0.06975244730710983, 0.03463862091302872, -0.0028232126496732235, -0.04620347172021866, 0.01599700376391411, -0.00905467476695776, -0.055063892155885696, 0.024457691237330437, -0.03887719288468361, 0.012365835718810558, -0.061795424669981, -0.03834133595228195, -0.015707695856690407, -0.03754274547100067, -0.03731389343738556, -0.023088499903678894, 0.02816152200102806, -0.05426529794931412, -0.026744268834590912 ]
In this work the LvN quantization of the type IIB superstring is carried on in a time dependent plane wave background with a constant self-dual Ramond-Ramond 5-form and a linear dilaton in the light-like direction. Such an endeavour allows us to define an invariant density matrix and study important issues in real time string thermodynamics. In particular, the Hagendorn temperature is calculated as function of the thermalization time.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11567v1
[ -0.014909844845533371, -0.04081663116812706, 0.04132642224431038, 0.03932281211018562, -0.0031707645393908024, -0.028103964403271675, -0.05058596283197403, -0.033406130969524384, -0.009322918951511383, 0.046199776232242584, -0.040794823318719864, -0.04677341505885124, -0.058185428380966187, 0.012523465789854527, -0.03529830649495125, 0.018238937482237816, 0.02724280208349228, 0.032499492168426514, -0.06090237945318222, 0.05956282839179039, 0.015052422881126404, -0.02203410491347313, -0.015751492232084274, 0.031248239800333977, 0.007055917289108038, -0.037228215485811234, 0.024413438513875008, 0.029117347672581673, -0.017142951488494873, -0.04636423662304878, 0.04599098861217499, -0.041260942816734314, 0.045544084161520004, -0.006900745443999767, -0.01834801584482193, -0.0018828039756044745, 0.0014729915419593453, 0.034513749182224274, 0.049319952726364136, -0.04068297520279884, -0.057400740683078766, -0.014364641159772873, -0.0426357164978981, -0.037114959210157394, -0.027464263141155243, -0.013219792395830154, -0.044777970761060715, 0.008663308806717396, -0.07159823179244995, -0.07211343944072723, 0.023800313472747803, 0.043481841683387756, 0.017125872895121574, 0.05317465588450432, -0.0017282392363995314, -0.03770441561937332, 0.019244594499468803, -0.006458294112235308, -0.06726881116628647, 0.03462850674986839, -0.0009681081282906234, -0.030456336215138435, 0.04083582013845444, 0.007695325184613466, -0.02704002894461155, 0.02410840429365635, -0.06865941733121872, -0.03397505730390549, -0.010963194072246552, -0.08581220358610153, 0.03149405121803284, -0.050911370664834976, -0.01898861676454544, -0.007223445922136307, -0.030803270637989044, -0.03493213281035423, -0.038867078721523285, 0.02369670569896698, -0.017187612131237984, 0.048851415514945984, -0.02778376266360283, -0.0351991131901741, 0.005007339175790548, 0.0155780715867877, 0.05934090539813042, -0.03141916170716286, 0.029030632227659225, -0.005487507674843073, -0.02206231653690338, -0.03009587526321411, -0.004753976594656706, -0.03772836551070213, -0.04453013837337494, -0.02975590154528618, 0.012064483016729355, 0.01748495362699032, 0.05995584651827812, 0.03715760260820389, -0.019679520279169083, 0.01124200876802206, 0.032918721437454224, -0.030120771378278732, -0.021515030413866043, 0.03195618838071823, 0.011647697538137436, 0.027748113498091698, -0.0043652900494635105, 0.004289534408599138, -0.032696064561605453, 0.03062169812619686, -0.05914201959967613, 0.033176764845848083, 0.004885155241936445, 0.03658599779009819, -0.05722137913107872, -0.017882252112030983, 0.0265815369784832, -0.02217024564743042, 0.03006722964346409, 0.018898800015449524, -0.050072081387043, -0.012470263056457043, 0.002993363654240966, 0.02326703630387783, 0.0028823139145970345, -0.00538992416113615, 0.036418866366147995, 0.0468287356197834, -0.024906909093260765, -0.07703284174203873, -0.0038606079760938883, 0.018781980499625206, 0.037713102996349335, -0.03722904995083809, -0.0016887469682842493, -0.049147263169288635, -0.02187812142074108, -0.000350059854099527, 0.003988139797002077, 0.040115248411893845, -0.045221924781799316, -0.03449205681681633, 0.009441817179322243, -0.0018207922112196684, 0.002339087426662445, 0.0251307375729084, -0.08301684260368347, 0.05585572496056557, 0.025721753016114235, 0.034387875348329544, -0.02802189625799656, -0.0022694075014442205, 0.026234246790409088, 0.009750302881002426, -0.03114144690334797, -0.04669932648539543, 0.06585170328617096, 0.005671998485922813, -0.011252278462052345, 0.030158117413520813, 0.026665862649679184, -0.038802456110715866, -0.013776903040707111, -0.010881069116294384, -0.00210873456671834, -0.030016399919986725, 0.00945968646556139, -0.0221315436065197, -0.020935658365488052, -0.011509344913065434, -0.0333128422498703, -0.0580308623611927, 0.023069310933351517, 0.00814775750041008, -0.06246804818511009, -0.07667238265275955, -0.04114673286676407, -0.058788541704416275, -0.013454507105052471, -0.026554763317108154, 0.010408500209450722, -0.02422805316746235, 0.005430079996585846, -0.04193184897303581, -0.05002947524189949, 0.05316108092665672, -0.06375128030776978, 0.001097081578336656, 0.0019886952359229326, -0.04930320382118225, 0.0008800285868346691, -0.01755841262638569, -0.004173819441348314, -0.02814488671720028, -0.052373889833688736, -0.03208448365330696, -0.0002274096041219309, -0.02184630185365677, 0.030303750187158585, 0.012692087329924107, -0.07850668579339981, -0.058139633387327194, 0.019592085853219032, 0.019367309287190437, -0.02915683016180992, -0.03763905540108681, -0.012546706944704056, 0.02701074257493019, -0.0427241176366806, 0.007539920508861542, 0.06865168362855911, -0.008591314777731895, 0.023328201845288277, -0.0306417103856802, 0.02989150397479534, 0.003073727013543248, -0.0989290401339531, 0.03443281725049019, -0.00888489093631506, 0.02593710832297802, 0.01924593187868595, -0.00666449498385191, -0.005166614428162575, -0.01565760187804699, -0.0228839423507452, 0.05957377329468727, -0.005844175815582275, 0.059318434447050095, -0.03021889552474022, -0.008167436346411705, -0.001133415149524808, -0.05944918841123581, -0.07474979758262634, -0.06459405273199081, -0.01590278372168541, 0.050074558705091476, -0.02865584008395672, 0.030724620446562767, -0.04312076047062874, -0.047715265303850174, -0.015742318704724312, 0.0012470479123294353, 0.047731850296258926, -0.026536213234066963, -0.04307074472308159, -0.07392002642154694, -0.02210032381117344, 0.013183293864130974, -0.0023358722683042288, -0.03130840137600899, 0.019743051379919052, -0.0771908164024353, -0.043760377913713455, -0.049233999103307724, 0.029737841337919235, 0.04382893815636635, -0.043960489332675934, 0.028894953429698944, -0.04460971802473068, 0.0324268564581871, 0.01884986273944378, 0.07171695679426193, -0.024448558688163757, -0.011654073372483253, -0.007206416688859463, -0.05124557390809059, -0.06344003230333328, -0.012339635752141476, -0.005425106268376112, -0.02656077966094017, 0.013957275077700615, -0.0021100796293467283, 0.03391517326235771, -0.023360423743724823, -0.02321857213973999, -0.03959298133850098, -0.005964617244899273, -0.03315486013889313, 0.02026681788265705, 0.03447250649333, -0.024210505187511444, 0.056422822177410126, -0.021544672548770905, -0.06523974984884262, -0.023059651255607605, -0.0789928212761879, -0.03152032941579819, -0.0510794036090374, -0.039763547480106354, -0.023826606571674347, -0.016408558934926987, 0.04680353030562401, -0.005422323010861874, -0.06141327694058418, -0.02620755322277546, -0.07141194492578506, -0.035979244858026505, -0.01894274912774563, 0.005236280150711536, -0.05753325670957565, -0.07221639156341553, -0.03472297266125679, 0.017809689044952393, -0.001838594558648765, 0.02692992426455021, -0.026696333661675453, -0.02575204148888588, 0.036230675876140594, 0.029545532539486885, 0.015595602802932262, -0.059795185923576355, -0.008053787052631378, -0.0251799076795578, -0.043274886906147, 0.02723700739443302, 0.04686037823557854, 0.011226513423025608, -0.0585976280272007, -0.004466041922569275, 0.011480221524834633, -0.03564295545220375, 0.033439576625823975, 0.011606588959693909, 0.022554127499461174, -0.037622686475515366, -0.06473952531814575, 0.02232312597334385, 0.04144969582557678, 0.030475255101919174, -0.0027631609700620174, -0.06363391131162643, -0.05269087851047516, -0.007350728381425142, -0.008223232813179493, 0.07106684148311615, -0.02888559177517891, 0.01141007523983717, -0.024797776713967323, -0.0763319805264473, -0.011930892243981361, -0.03925490006804466, 0.0034863469190895557, 0.01370969694107771, -0.014877251349389553, -0.03675633668899536, -0.0385553203523159, 0.00017734918219503015, 0.021386366337537766, 0.039001740515232086, 0.009345579892396927, 0.008557876572012901, 0.01779300905764103, 0.03814355656504631, 0.022507617250084877, 0.05228686332702637, 0.00846666470170021, 0.01193576492369175, 0.020705560222268105, -0.020063884556293488, 0.014437587931752205, 0.002577655715867877, -0.04037172719836235, -0.0702987015247345, -0.06281615793704987, 0.04655250534415245, 0.047787975519895554, 0.042845968157052994, -0.02357504703104496, 0.01285781990736723, -0.06318491697311401, 0.023484468460083008, 0.02049361914396286, -0.021921390667557716, -0.002103876555338502, -0.0005598939605988562, 0.013755331747233868, 0.015619429759681225, 0.019004570320248604, -0.006875697989016771, -0.05170963704586029, -0.04682333022356033, -0.04737584665417671, 0.05608160421252251, -0.006665215361863375, -0.02464962564408779, 0.02081049606204033, -0.01934664696455002, 0.021985281258821487, -0.03627310320734978, -0.03547194227576256, 0.0197603777050972, -0.019424403086304665, -0.02858561836183071, 0.005707327276468277, 0.034914303570985794, -0.024530457332730293, 0.061251040548086166, 0.012184263207018375, -0.020270099863409996, 0.02937747724354267, 0.0018273408059030771, -0.024914581328630447, -0.06396062672138214, -0.06429989635944366, -0.02824210934340954, -0.0430513359606266, -0.0124588618054986, -0.06836866587400436, -0.07693418115377426, 0.07442043721675873, -0.028184974566102028, 0.012394233606755733, -0.03147384896874428, -0.05293961241841316, -0.003756680293008685, -0.035829488188028336, -0.025247665122151375, -0.041726481169462204, -0.017872683703899384, -0.010060811415314674, 0.007047658786177635, -0.04312698170542717, -0.0314202755689621, -0.0571339949965477, -0.009920869022607803, -0.041177988052368164, 0.00764011824503541, 0.016505714505910873, -0.00860496237874031, 0.007907753810286522, 0.050704147666692734, -0.04180324450135231, 0.07129368931055069, -0.02346160262823105, 0.02774108201265335, 0.005089611746370792, -0.020139161497354507, -0.021472519263625145, -0.0035096395295113325, -0.042940184473991394, -0.030310675501823425, 0.05429971218109131, -0.01139405369758606, -0.050711631774902344, 0.018235543742775917, 0.05635285750031471, 0.03135320544242859, -0.056926049292087555, 0.04963498190045357, -0.028612477704882622, 0.001959376037120819, -0.023766934871673584, -0.002489815466105938, 0.0016621730756014585, -0.02107110060751438, 0.032689329236745834, -0.0043809060007333755, 0.01754998415708542, -0.036157041788101196, -0.024760877713561058, 0.003946252632886171, -0.008849021978676319, -0.02776901237666607, -0.00272590690292418, -0.08203476667404175, -0.02462856099009514, 0.014011647552251816, 0.020039420574903488, -0.021535228937864304, 0.03761754557490349, -0.0016351013910025358, -0.021919462829828262, -0.057203732430934906, -0.0006070703384466469, 0.04153832048177719, -0.026823023334145546, -0.03157973289489746, -0.013500591740012169, -0.0033779810182750225, 0.03827006742358208, 0.028053687885403633, -0.00381347700022161, 0.00860657449811697, -0.018553607165813446, -0.03730378672480583, 0.0025142927188426256, -0.03392574191093445, 0.01216251403093338, -0.025848761200904846, -0.007254546042531729, -0.053506966680288315, 0.011911682784557343, -0.0002550919307395816, 0.006955580320209265, -0.010406462475657463, 0.03326867148280144, 0.04340241104364395, -0.008133932948112488, 0.014459327794611454, 0.024949384853243828, 0.02248312532901764, 0.04150157421827316, -0.028773581609129906, -0.06207358092069626, 0.018709592521190643, -0.0486837662756443, -0.05426350235939026, 0.036293886601924896, 0.03311782702803612, -0.013688532635569572, 0.00813423004001379, 0.02886727824807167, -0.03522081673145294, -0.06864344328641891, -0.02308766357600689, -0.05451905354857445, -0.021879857406020164, -0.0035792046692222357, 0.01708483137190342, 0.0599735789000988, 0.05812845751643181, 0.0651140809059143, -0.004143571946769953, 0.0021945794578641653, 0.013236748985946178, 0.049409784376621246, -0.02874724008142948, -0.03430015221238136, -0.05281714349985123, 0.06342831999063492, -0.016025559976696968, 0.056132663041353226, 0.04816373810172081, -0.019929299131035805, -0.04545987769961357, -0.02836173214018345, 0.017284635454416275, -0.041363537311553955, -0.05834027752280235, -0.05030738189816475, 0.052329711616039276, -0.054509542882442474, -0.004186693113297224, -0.04743150621652603, 0.0626351609826088, -0.021347785368561745, 0.025531627237796783, 0.004059102386236191, -0.024478325620293617, -0.04645879566669464, 0.080051951110363, -0.06826596707105637, -0.015296422876417637, 0.018264740705490112, -0.06593356281518936, -0.013783715665340424, -0.05359431728720665, -0.014227158389985561, 0.014643595553934574, -0.0260495413094759, -0.07270601391792297, 0.03255403786897659, 0.024212727323174477, -0.07180573046207428, -0.029169151559472084, 0.035697586834430695, -0.0624801404774189, 0.0005582495359703898, -0.023158127442002296, -0.018867550417780876, -0.0477941669523716, 0.03944496437907219, -0.021718965843319893, -0.05087887495756149, -0.06116499379277229, 0.004165396559983492, 0.020059557631611824, -0.009565637446939945, 0.008714481256902218, -0.013916868716478348, -0.05014009401202202, -0.005272210109978914, 0.02799418568611145, -0.0038283716421574354, -0.004873140249401331, 0.02270546182990074, 0.01321522518992424, -0.03375590965151787, 0.011763525195419788, 0.005012481007725, -0.027940193191170692, -0.03079085983335972, 0.008546611294150352, 0.04192578047513962, -0.013609647750854492, -0.04176140949130058, -0.035277657210826874, 0.011721765622496605, 0.0053022089414298534, 0.049827687442302704, -0.02267441339790821, -0.008133689872920513, -0.0427246019244194, 0.07059986144304276, -0.03151339665055275, -0.004685486666858196, 0.017778737470507622, -0.000008061463631747756, -0.04456843435764313, 0.04762536659836769, -0.0649368166923523, -0.05656733736395836, 0.010639491491019726, -0.025587862357497215, -0.0181720107793808, -0.02391650341451168, -0.04592794179916382, -0.0027945847250521183, -0.009212599135935307, -0.065299853682518, 0.020522240549325943, -0.0068318829871714115, 0.046145498752593994, 0.028246445581316948, -0.010129798203706741, -0.058568622916936874, 0.02014773339033127, 0.008998891338706017, -0.06554704904556274, -0.021307379007339478, 0.008965106680989265, 0.0032788875978440046, 0.006432793568819761, -0.018170949071645737, -0.047253821045160294, -0.03981705382466316, 0.03399963304400444, -0.025779569521546364, -0.03641115501523018, -0.027819368988275528, 0.02471090666949749, -0.016172992065548897, -0.004325273912400007, 0.011842179112136364, -0.028449637815356255, 0.054279327392578125, 0.02704189531505108, 0.016162294894456863, -0.016743779182434082, -0.0018796194344758987, -0.0534890778362751, -0.06624489277601242, 0.023175455629825592, -0.008782148361206055, -0.01356483530253172, 0.024734394624829292, -0.03609471768140793, -0.0738910436630249, -0.017993617802858353, -0.00448914198204875, -0.03168991953134537, -0.042342156171798706, -0.02193884551525116, 0.03914281353354454, 0.0026709085796028376, -0.0275805052369833, -0.0891951322555542, 0.012725796550512314, 0.013395081274211407, -0.021912291646003723, -0.028140122070908546, 0.008631337434053421, -0.034691162407398224, 0.01801302656531334, -0.08662296831607819, -0.030081769451498985, 0.003090463113039732, 0.041038572788238525, 0.036368776112794876, -0.021987102925777435, 0.01220036018639803, -0.048742178827524185, -0.01403625588864088, 0.00597933167591691, 0.03182436525821686, 0.008689659647643566, -0.009909550659358501, 0.06328210979700089, -0.010901969857513905, -0.022059598937630653, 0.029713183641433716, 0.022685403004288673, 0.004865954164415598, 0.06284715235233307, 0.04416494816541672, -0.031299203634262085, 0.010275164619088173, 0.0820164605975151, -0.03603219613432884, -0.01658892072737217, -0.03399712219834328, 0.020845428109169006, -0.026182306930422783, -0.054613128304481506, -0.021124131977558136, -0.06113804504275322, 0.006228137295693159, -0.0036750920116901398, -0.05020613223314285, 0.013886037282645702, -0.04991236329078674, -0.03624286502599716, -0.036105602979660034, 0.02053251303732395, 0.007126599550247192, 0.0558590404689312, -0.0014457858633249998, -0.018463604152202606, 0.04966055229306221, -0.057618286460638046, -0.06620781123638153, -0.025320973247289658, 0.024404818192124367, -0.044150277972221375, 0.06844009459018707, -0.0681452602148056, 0.060255177319049835, -0.02249971032142639, 0.01740300841629505, -0.04710699990391731, 0.0812830924987793, -0.017479348927736282, 0.014800450764596462, -0.0793972983956337, -0.014665431343019009, -0.0016408510273322463, -0.0028246755246073008, -0.01834690012037754, -0.00970470067113638, 0.007538070436567068, -0.056042615324258804, 0.022184502333402634, -0.019244449213147163, 0.06255050748586655, -0.00928791519254446, -0.008852683007717133, -0.004240812733769417, -0.021951116621494293, -0.06066801771521568, 0.05897153541445732, -0.02571343258023262, -0.03255376219749451, -0.06564898043870926, -0.024230634793639183, 0.04867244139313698, 0.022317586466670036, -0.009183002635836601, 0.038537632673978806, 0.00852182973176241, -0.02683727629482746, -0.04680503159761429, -0.04181694611907005, -0.015926223248243332, -0.05533846467733383, -0.005875641945749521, -0.01986662857234478, -0.03505833446979523, -0.05445734038949013 ]
Numerous applications have been developed to assist visually impaired individuals that employ a machine learning unit to process visual input. However, a critical challenge with these applications is the sub-optimal quality of images captured by the users. Given the complexity of operating a camera for visually impaired individuals, we advocate for the use of Apple Live Photos and Android Motion Photos technologies. In this study, we introduce a straightforward methodology to evaluate and contrast the efficacy of Live/Motion Photos against traditional image-based approaches. Our findings reveal that both Live Photos and Motion Photos outperform single-frame images in common visual assisting tasks, specifically in object classification and VideoQA. We validate our results through extensive experiments on the ORBIT dataset, which consists of videos collected by visually impaired individuals. Furthermore, we conduct a series of ablation studies to delve deeper into the impact of deblurring and longer temporal crops.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08022v1
[ 0.0018291287124156952, -0.005700305104255676, 0.025791237130761147, -0.012478003278374672, -0.006474021822214127, -0.03651348873972893, 0.039163071662187576, 0.006815358530730009, -0.03581330180168152, -0.05876102298498154, -0.05711826682090759, 0.026795871555805206, -0.04110625013709068, -0.03510559722781181, -0.014903215691447258, 0.022186649963259697, 0.07377977669239044, -0.06038958579301834, -0.058043889701366425, 0.06409979611635208, 0.05223949998617172, -0.010030651465058327, -0.01855834759771824, -0.035867754369974136, 0.012541485019028187, -0.014121927320957184, -0.02710474096238613, 0.05530687794089317, -0.03156110644340515, -0.03777489811182022, 0.07692969590425491, 0.002506950870156288, -0.03461236134171486, -0.043761540204286575, -0.020600387826561928, -0.01326731313019991, 0.008476272225379944, 0.05074553191661835, -0.045192427933216095, -0.02187950909137726, 0.066086046397686, -0.06729572266340256, -0.0483270101249218, -0.016914507374167442, -0.0208137109875679, -0.023174524307250977, -0.038365788757801056, 0.032975293695926666, -0.08791206032037735, -0.024930069223046303, 0.013931979425251484, 0.01796773634850979, 0.016861582174897194, 0.011718589812517166, -0.01718810945749283, 0.006235057488083839, 0.008771929889917374, 0.04014791548252106, -0.0031338934786617756, -0.004995450377464294, 0.014259262010455132, -0.005024089012295008, -0.010731644928455353, -0.015247851610183716, 0.030124299228191376, 0.05076754465699196, -0.03242696449160576, -0.053543366491794586, -0.009394865483045578, -0.01841864176094532, 0.06297746300697327, -0.0390622541308403, -0.028683559969067574, 0.019629383459687233, 0.008296305313706398, -0.034377556294202805, -0.026711711660027504, -0.04673641920089722, 0.04476142302155495, 0.01642841473221779, -0.04440261796116829, 0.01611817069351673, 0.03888729587197304, 0.02605793997645378, -0.014432096853852272, -0.02298024483025074, 0.057938333600759506, -0.012602075934410095, -0.0026055180933326483, 0.028088999912142754, 0.06910935789346695, -0.05253630131483078, -0.05997785925865173, 0.026395145803689957, 0.03329719975590706, -0.03699105978012085, 0.025529738515615463, 0.02745695412158966, 0.02068954147398472, 0.010143723338842392, -0.002972039859741926, 0.0033028777688741684, -0.05870192497968674, 0.04450790584087372, 0.03359265625476837, -0.07136814296245575, 0.023426322266459465, -0.024667495861649513, -0.06060798838734627, -0.03346555680036545, -0.0014240574091672897, -0.04179912433028221, -0.026119498535990715, -0.06237778440117836, -0.042650267481803894, -0.03371678292751312, 0.04869067668914795, -0.045556362718343735, 0.006419115234166384, 0.0095584811642766, -0.009007426910102367, 0.061507176607847214, 0.04574843496084213, -0.030410442501306534, -0.02487706020474434, 0.0017832848243415356, 0.02009258046746254, -0.013186687603592873, -0.005599695723503828, -0.06974641978740692, -0.0516963005065918, 0.0399998277425766, -0.03982357308268547, -0.026637332513928413, 0.054899875074625015, 0.012303060851991177, -0.028280828148126602, 0.027553575113415718, 0.03289763256907463, -0.01982354186475277, -0.055528707802295685, -0.03713991120457649, 0.01312930602580309, -0.029164178296923637, -0.026550117880105972, 0.0629480704665184, 0.0046931179240345955, -0.022934723645448685, 0.035326264798641205, 0.0654253214597702, 0.03252897784113884, 0.042698998004198074, 0.005268967244774103, 0.051784053444862366, -0.023603538051247597, -0.01995401829481125, 0.03937843441963196, -0.027368200942873955, -0.04906254634261131, 0.024487599730491638, -0.02189057506620884, -0.03991032391786575, 0.04522319510579109, -0.039922118186950684, 0.020240599289536476, 0.008605945855379105, 0.027588482946157455, -0.015746096149086952, -0.04957786202430725, 0.021489975973963737, -0.011718443594872952, -0.05234641209244728, -0.013024752028286457, -0.0036870124749839306, -0.0709022805094719, 0.025591719895601273, 0.0007151636527851224, -0.053499143570661545, -0.05726795271039009, 0.018243655562400818, 0.012513728812336922, 0.005716963205486536, -0.0011743651703000069, -0.028644734993577003, -0.0029803363140672445, -0.031370725482702255, -0.07726506143808365, -0.05700743570923805, 0.025210408493876457, 0.0005357591435313225, -0.030920496210455894, -0.046935804188251495, -0.020442672073841095, 0.018680574372410774, -0.023780182003974915, -0.023972520604729652, -0.037137579172849655, -0.00499505503103137, 0.04336196556687355, 0.01725757122039795, -0.0823175236582756, -0.0041620442643761635, -0.019926199689507484, -0.03792028874158859, -0.026180244982242584, -0.07644077390432358, 0.01670982502400875, 0.027017710730433464, -0.040755920112133026, 0.011110397055745125, 0.037061627954244614, 0.03422285243868828, 0.061276886612176895, 0.03267504274845123, 0.05351938307285309, 0.03691494092345238, -0.09453603625297546, 0.03360860422253609, 0.025685030966997147, 0.010409703478217125, 0.02791016176342964, 0.004804946016520262, -0.044676315039396286, -0.018818112090229988, -0.020255347713828087, 0.046710941940546036, 0.018829520791769028, -0.01690554805099964, -0.07817133516073227, -0.031920455396175385, -0.006163585931062698, -0.04239439219236374, -0.011219900101423264, -0.06636157631874084, -0.016996849328279495, 0.01523536629974842, -0.022036809474229813, 0.05294838547706604, -0.05548553168773651, -0.05872460454702377, 0.019340261816978455, -0.062228698283433914, 0.031480200588703156, 0.009110747836530209, -0.036810893565416336, -0.010902502574026585, 0.005275936797261238, 0.04244197905063629, -0.018339715898036957, 0.011027849279344082, -0.06103656068444252, -0.0415341891348362, -0.013472702354192734, -0.004562633112072945, 0.0674305334687233, 0.029474575072526932, -0.01999713107943535, 0.03739752620458603, -0.050452057272195816, 0.02751248888671398, 0.013574663549661636, 0.017628002911806107, -0.051620882004499435, 0.041335757821798325, 0.036444421857595444, 0.03674350678920746, -0.013025909662246704, -0.059625040739774704, 0.02148173376917839, -0.041873883455991745, -0.029278285801410675, 0.02976522035896778, -0.013575301505625248, -0.011273586191236973, 0.011586014181375504, -0.06255314499139786, 0.013905562460422516, 0.006452623754739761, -0.004361086059361696, 0.059423867613077164, 0.003891889937222004, -0.030991343781352043, 0.004395788535475731, -0.059140078723430634, -0.06200414523482323, -0.060289282351732254, -0.04317062720656395, -0.03174327313899994, -0.05041775479912758, -0.02404465153813362, -0.0708075687289238, -0.04606383293867111, -0.003617754438892007, -0.0418732576072216, 0.006942250765860081, -0.010339587926864624, 0.0056464215740561485, -0.02189006842672825, 0.05886852741241455, 0.03138395771384239, -0.021239520981907845, -0.05466536805033684, 0.037568993866443634, 0.003700018860399723, 0.018928494304418564, -0.02762768417596817, -0.05219811573624611, -0.0036989564541727304, 0.011354858987033367, -0.06436018645763397, 0.027242258191108704, 0.05171409994363785, -0.04542123153805733, 0.03858646750450134, -0.006091452669352293, 0.02226906828582287, 0.015198609791696072, -0.010465147905051708, -0.03785218298435211, -0.060372862964868546, -0.023855865001678467, -0.042125899344682693, 0.010189507156610489, -0.02934158593416214, -0.03660018369555473, 0.03662175312638283, 0.0408911406993866, 0.05256393551826477, -0.012093344703316689, -0.002131860004737973, -0.03138473629951477, 0.012170503847301006, 0.026831289753317833, -0.01719941385090351, -0.004031644202768803, -0.01719856448471546, -0.053312551230192184, -0.01857333444058895, -0.0035918380599468946, 0.015296471305191517, 0.010016747750341892, -0.026316221803426743, -0.06832559406757355, -0.01744883693754673, 0.07481653988361359, -0.09208648651838303, 0.015899918973445892, 0.056344226002693176, 0.07861290872097015, -0.014663644134998322, 0.05001968890428543, -0.0008946266025304794, 0.007642949931323528, 0.041754383593797684, 0.01277952454984188, -0.013690396212041378, 0.007250776514410973, 0.07165505737066269, -0.009278012439608574, -0.06436291337013245, 0.04188118502497673, -0.04057946056127548, -0.05595973879098892, -0.014603102579712868, 0.022465288639068604, 0.01832018606364727, 0.05723964795470238, -0.06444364041090012, -0.0028978323098272085, -0.011383773759007454, 0.04453214630484581, -0.020576488226652145, -0.03732071444392204, 0.0024067454505711794, -0.0177485179156065, 0.05960756912827492, -0.011803476139903069, -0.022184722125530243, -0.0325927734375, -0.05110728740692139, 0.01061444915831089, -0.045567356050014496, 0.052746862173080444, 0.009006231091916561, -0.0014220396988093853, 0.03949795290827751, 0.05363171175122261, -0.01821669191122055, 0.03413452208042145, -0.007818554528057575, -0.01842603273689747, -0.05763031169772148, -0.0024848701432347298, -0.03336798772215843, -0.04165545850992203, -0.05789617449045181, 0.024680811911821365, 0.01151902973651886, -0.031359829008579254, 0.005990560166537762, -0.03123060241341591, 0.008922328241169453, 0.004982796497642994, -0.0707726702094078, -0.030868791043758392, -0.04362991079688072, 0.05060062184929848, 0.018022285774350166, 0.009864849969744682, 0.07662351429462433, -0.07234350591897964, 0.004816131666302681, -0.036092083901166916, -0.018324697390198708, 0.0036438412498682737, -0.03041687235236168, 0.01717035472393036, -0.05619669705629349, -0.02483709342777729, -0.009817845188081264, 0.04825107753276825, 0.0017203863244503736, 0.04921480268239975, -0.04368044063448906, -0.044272638857364655, -0.01250417623668909, 0.03719309717416763, 0.053238775581121445, -0.05184190720319748, -0.05097780004143715, 0.015606939792633057, 0.03899403661489487, 0.00035968219162896276, 0.013079558499157429, 0.04035940766334534, -0.03446881100535393, 0.03379922732710838, -0.004679440055042505, 0.04142695665359497, 0.00690790731459856, -0.004068249370902777, 0.06617105007171631, -0.041233617812395096, -0.05474201962351799, -0.004574791062623262, 0.003042851574718952, -0.018057435750961304, -0.04218605160713196, -0.04497702419757843, -0.05021732673048973, 0.009700086899101734, -0.04241238906979561, 0.006110206712037325, -0.025479493662714958, 0.010125000961124897, 0.015076925046741962, 0.04297853261232376, 0.013660107739269733, 0.00619914848357439, 0.0023417614866048098, 0.021333348006010056, 0.010710639879107475, -0.0058111404068768024, -0.022318117320537567, -0.07390483468770981, 0.034153345972299576, -0.04134255647659302, 0.010266145691275597, -0.04489206522703171, 0.010949519462883472, 0.03944993391633034, 0.014231828041374683, -0.08192715048789978, 0.022423183545470238, 0.035038355737924576, -0.009798330254852772, 0.039400309324264526, 0.019992530345916748, 0.022724973037838936, 0.04357978701591492, -0.04147929698228836, 0.004363895859569311, 0.04247395694255829, -0.05591604858636856, -0.05202148109674454, -0.006283048540353775, -0.03656846657395363, -0.044793032109737396, 0.040341731160879135, -0.013774714432656765, -0.053092118352651596, -0.008721443824470043, -0.00963304378092289, 0.011282500810921192, 0.01733456924557686, 0.023909786716103554, 0.00030288848211057484, -0.03561917692422867, -0.03705255314707756, -0.01616792567074299, -0.010461666621267796, -0.035297147929668427, 0.041821517050266266, -0.030873922631144524, -0.03765895962715149, 0.037546101957559586, -0.005523585714399815, -0.03654913604259491, -0.03764604404568672, 0.024654177948832512, -0.03082086704671383, -0.03478768840432167, -0.026807202026247978, -0.04267434775829315, -0.0449465811252594, -0.03645339235663414, 0.030005119740962982, 0.015632107853889465, 0.051384467631578445, 0.015606575645506382, 0.0020505182910710573, -0.04277314618229866, -0.038015954196453094, -0.05136922001838684, -0.0036738410126417875, 0.015449602156877518, -0.04614479839801788, 0.04785642400383949, -0.012592950835824013, 0.002928961766883731, -0.008126208558678627, 0.0133008798584342, -0.017779923975467682, 0.022331511601805687, -0.031311094760894775, -0.020668556913733482, 0.024400096386671066, -0.0637509897351265, -0.05963902175426483, 0.05408842861652374, 0.003695633728057146, -0.0050826300866901875, 0.04234796762466431, 0.04859738051891327, -0.04350897669792175, 0.03523256629705429, -0.01417477335780859, -0.012800420634448528, -0.01459298562258482, 0.01709350384771824, 0.014503740705549717, -0.07395698130130768, -0.01804323121905327, 0.001485492568463087, -0.058348413556814194, 0.011054983362555504, -0.02020042948424816, -0.006345943082123995, -0.015370403416454792, -0.01599273830652237, -0.042131926864385605, 0.04731060564517975, -0.024940479546785355, -0.07507041096687317, 0.02112971991300583, -0.014352397993206978, -0.06364310532808304, -0.016145700588822365, 0.05002373456954956, 0.04156875982880592, -0.01526210643351078, 0.03252121061086655, 0.04141894727945328, 0.005537038203328848, -0.0027398806996643543, 0.05285438150167465, 0.061229072511196136, 0.0012451928341761231, 0.026877643540501595, 0.002276636892929673, -0.0631360337138176, -0.0018959519220516086, -0.028905555605888367, 0.04321296513080597, -0.025995438918471336, 0.04127379134297371, 0.0016336123226210475, -0.07365163415670395, -0.05871107056736946, 0.05286554992198944, -0.06179768964648247, 0.0029094680212438107, 0.04594443738460541, -0.026905152946710587, 0.03835682570934296, -0.029795385897159576, -0.06115034967660904, -0.029378781095147133, -0.037562500685453415, 0.0038551457691937685, -0.039360836148262024, -0.007816281169652939, 0.03887476399540901, 0.014437902718782425, 0.05000033974647522, -0.05628879368305206, -0.03881559893488884, -0.023973258212208748, -0.04926063120365143, 0.024939605966210365, -0.048279765993356705, -0.04948733374476433, 0.03399162366986275, -0.01833817921578884, 0.03199935331940651, 0.030197761952877045, -0.061501242220401764, -0.01858130656182766, 0.03911030665040016, -0.01917271316051483, -0.004247843753546476, -0.00939172599464655, 0.036922574043273926, 0.013564753346145153, -0.0051935650408267975, -0.00463551701977849, -0.025239067152142525, -0.0043105934746563435, 0.012156840413808823, -0.04323374107480049, 0.0010298187844455242, -0.021260252222418785, -0.06329973042011261, -0.02833339013159275, -0.021158484742045403, 0.010200184769928455, 0.0012183741200715303, -0.0471678301692009, -0.055479586124420166, 0.014070426113903522, -0.02081877738237381, -0.01255224458873272, -0.02265693061053753, 0.0155071672052145, 0.03331484645605087, -0.04122844338417053, 0.029361646622419357, 0.04818294569849968, -0.04060790315270424, -0.00853334553539753, -0.06112898886203766, -0.04549747705459595, -0.01575527898967266, -0.03132275491952896, -0.04465879499912262, -0.012090081349015236, 0.020013591274619102, -0.058865781873464584, 0.03255072236061096, 0.02294175699353218, 0.013492894358932972, 0.007836829870939255, -0.06176102161407471, 0.01556488499045372, -0.019404888153076172, -0.04661641642451286, -0.04489178583025932, -0.028417104855179787, -0.011201930232346058, -0.05776703357696533, 0.021814867854118347, -0.012581326067447662, -0.04713289067149162, 0.008814000524580479, -0.0753045529127121, -0.0023975579533725977, 0.002081981161609292, 0.03824079409241676, -0.028266988694667816, -0.05506120249629021, 0.038325950503349304, -0.011195080354809761, 0.02870028093457222, 0.05303202196955681, 0.014001992531120777, -0.020069243386387825, 0.03869304805994034, -0.029622064903378487, -0.05336431786417961, -0.021509187296032906, -0.02973729372024536, -0.037694066762924194, 0.0176109466701746, 0.021872328594326973, 0.01784648559987545, 0.01569691300392151, 0.004428259562700987, 0.049218956381082535, -0.038626428693532944, 0.037757955491542816, -0.03835232928395271, 0.04760948568582535, -0.022829962894320488, -0.04607991501688957, 0.026904692873358727, -0.01714909076690674, 0.012375026009976864, 0.009213358163833618, 0.026505663990974426, 0.020141495391726494, -0.0241385530680418, 0.0003790953487623483, -0.0074820611625909805, -0.0471368171274662, -0.004017443396151066, 0.049328628927469254, -0.046795837581157684, -0.024446871131658554, -0.051908981055021286, 0.008646358735859394, -0.043297600001096725, -0.004183046519756317, 0.040876977145671844, -0.012416178360581398, -0.0022507545072585344, -0.07104537636041641, 0.004552322905510664, -0.03612210601568222, -0.013026740401983261, -0.047491952776908875, 0.07041408121585846, 0.0165043156594038, -0.0237483661621809, -0.05223001539707184, -0.028759203851222992, -0.012399647384881973, -0.042756855487823486, -0.0454927459359169, -0.02746695838868618, 0.01680862531065941, 0.001919022761285305, -0.007501482032239437, -0.02540316805243492, 0.028900884091854095, 0.021975761279463768, 0.05569764971733093, -0.03919056057929993, -0.025142250582575798, -0.025899233296513557, 0.06435766071081161, -0.013022033497691154, 0.023144366219639778, -0.039101794362068176, 0.021526483818888664, -0.016703221946954727, -0.014740865677595139, 0.022860180586576462, -0.026574047282338142, -0.02802206017076969, -0.0623345822095871, 0.01257875096052885, 0.02456614002585411, -0.007155487313866615, -0.008002229034900665, -0.0720088928937912, -0.015198025852441788, -0.025591975077986717, -0.06459728628396988 ]
This letter investigates a cache-enabled multiuser mobile edge computing (MEC) system with dynamic task arrivals, taking into account the impact of proactive cache placement on the system's overall energy consumption. We consider that an access point (AP) schedules a wireless device (WD) to offload computational tasks while executing the tasks of a finite library in the \emph{task caching} phase, such that the nearby WDs with the same task request arriving later can directly download the task results in the \emph{task arrival and execution} phase. We aim for minimizing the system's weighted-sum energy over a finite-time horizon, by jointly optimizing the task caching decision and the MEC execution of the AP, and local computing as well as task offloading of the WDs at each time slot, subject to caching capacity, task causality, and completion deadline constraints. The formulated design problem is a mixed-integer nonlinear program. Under the assumption of fully predicable task arrivals, we first propose a branch-and-bound (BnB) based method to obtain the optimal offline solution. Next, we propose two low-complexity schemes based on convex relaxation and task-popularity, respectively. Finally, numerical results show the benefit of the proposed schemes over existing benchmark schemes.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13546v1
[ -0.005548378918319941, -0.049325671046972275, 0.05517646297812462, 0.03649398684501648, -0.03182411938905716, 0.018445445224642754, -0.018690984696149826, 0.02364642359316349, 0.0200335793197155, -0.05436867102980614, -0.031820595264434814, -0.016224000602960587, -0.009534643031656742, -0.04529089853167534, -0.001691058510914445, -0.005461754743009806, 0.05958496779203415, 0.057153522968292236, -0.02373350039124489, 0.03785379230976105, -0.016902204602956772, 0.0023436888586729765, -0.048515379428863525, 0.03993024304509163, 0.014420543797314167, 0.009871937334537506, -0.047446202486753464, 0.027499092742800713, -0.07710770517587662, -0.016156412661075592, 0.05027858167886734, -0.025877123698592186, -0.03791625797748566, -0.024648359045386314, 0.0003769785398617387, -0.03384488448500633, -0.017702918499708176, -0.0024408313911408186, 0.04949697107076645, -0.031602974981069565, 0.039901137351989746, -0.07321427762508392, -0.06319122761487961, -0.03028775192797184, -0.004816844593733549, -0.01089705154299736, -0.05469898134469986, 0.04719143733382225, -0.06575947254896164, -0.07657422870397568, 0.004613902885466814, 0.025765923783183098, 0.006437383126467466, 0.031090347096323967, -0.045053400099277496, 0.006969375070184469, 0.009828575886785984, 0.02669789269566536, -0.029528407379984856, -0.01449387613683939, 0.04201753810048103, -0.03630494326353073, -0.03360437601804733, -0.011277545243501663, 0.01402360387146473, 0.07396122068166733, -0.0023062999825924635, -0.06523369997739792, -0.01897731050848961, -0.04865438491106033, 0.024112151935696602, -0.02894478850066662, -0.01229902170598507, -0.012731578201055527, -0.06244061514735222, -0.03922347351908684, -0.024637162685394287, -0.029791733250021935, -0.013900816440582275, -0.022228628396987915, -0.025019273161888123, 0.01880525052547455, 0.04593822360038757, 0.028910256922245026, -0.010860946029424667, -0.024237673729658127, 0.07465330511331558, 0.0021683687809854746, 0.022240513935685158, -0.032935600727796555, 0.0320873036980629, -0.054602108895778656, -0.07728949934244156, -0.008624354377388954, 0.0352877713739872, -0.00025342099252156913, 0.057118818163871765, 0.05053999274969101, 0.020404178649187088, -0.028987787663936615, -0.01874430477619171, -0.04015582054853439, -0.07324974983930588, 0.046812765300273895, 0.0011699390597641468, -0.01675998419523239, 0.014948815107345581, 0.007078994531184435, -0.032793838530778885, 0.020432818681001663, -0.04135987162590027, -0.005607163067907095, -0.028138060122728348, -0.041636161506175995, -0.027483366429805756, -0.014404655434191227, 0.052234429866075516, 0.02711484208703041, 0.04694769158959389, -0.03525642305612564, -0.045520488172769547, 0.02184298262000084, 0.018405986949801445, -0.003319681156426668, -0.014875358901917934, -0.010336280800402164, 0.05149203538894653, -0.009130113758146763, 0.03371068835258484, -0.02024153061211109, -0.03795735165476799, 0.021694382652640343, -0.02163274772465229, -0.040124714374542236, 0.02786584198474884, 0.028235670179128647, -0.06345213949680328, -0.029118122532963753, 0.04289320856332779, -0.017369918525218964, -0.0738476887345314, -0.01934933476150036, 0.02895522676408291, -0.019076893106102943, 0.02151041477918625, 0.07308296114206314, -0.019928183406591415, -0.03304359316825867, 0.03976043686270714, 0.027529923245310783, 0.0053216940723359585, -0.006367146037518978, -0.020158890634775162, 0.009023485705256462, 0.02522941865026951, -0.0060028512962162495, 0.009366698563098907, -0.012644386850297451, -0.06708730757236481, 0.028170395642518997, 0.04397489130496979, -0.019005198031663895, -0.004586750641465187, -0.03440658375620842, -0.010223065502941608, 0.018388517200946808, 0.015222028829157352, 0.01649429090321064, 0.028896335512399673, 0.026272453367710114, -0.038514457643032074, -0.010102160274982452, 0.012499240227043629, -0.04041554033756256, -0.04177257418632507, -0.05830385908484459, -0.00045572101953439415, -0.05700647830963135, -0.04277263209223747, -0.03622003644704819, 0.011276018805801868, 0.016162175685167313, -0.023071810603141785, 0.020933765918016434, -0.06288450956344604, -0.03844771906733513, -0.07909651100635529, 0.021487878635525703, 0.021719960495829582, 0.02504553087055683, -0.022033199667930603, -0.01247387658804655, 0.0030315020121634007, 0.0415210984647274, -0.026423605158925056, -0.042710598558187485, 0.035595882683992386, -0.021891191601753235, -0.025005575269460678, 0.017023392021656036, -0.08260229974985123, 0.0000833300655358471, -0.0316242016851902, 0.021053746342658997, -0.02508273348212242, -0.061961233615875244, 0.008786395192146301, 0.011483493261039257, -0.024105466902256012, -0.01069507747888565, 0.050098009407520294, 0.012267019599676132, 0.05807417258620262, 0.022035151720046997, 0.051089826971292496, 0.013558603823184967, -0.09605449438095093, 0.012290162034332752, 0.028807301074266434, -0.008683362975716591, 0.04904185235500336, -0.012811964377760887, -0.035466957837343216, -0.009873520582914352, 0.00036716301110573113, 0.05526130273938179, 0.014080584049224854, -0.019476568326354027, -0.07049506902694702, -0.009134638123214245, -0.050137072801589966, -0.0798754021525383, -0.027278823778033257, -0.08068136125802994, -0.015207432210445404, 0.006084241904318333, -0.04410634934902191, 0.06649859994649887, -0.019727081060409546, -0.040590837597846985, -0.040375225245952606, -0.025785675272345543, 0.05179813876748085, -0.045660246163606644, -0.03326067328453064, -0.0584452785551548, -0.04690655693411827, -0.003413927974179387, -0.04042153060436249, 0.000148159044329077, -0.036427438259124756, -0.00747642433270812, 0.005217735655605793, -0.03754076361656189, 0.035672251135110855, 0.042833417654037476, -0.013763785362243652, 0.03224663436412811, 0.007752897217869759, 0.044226620346307755, 0.020181916654109955, 0.051105938851833344, -0.051611125469207764, -0.013864953070878983, -0.0010176621144637465, 0.031109293922781944, 0.011797405779361725, 0.00005576062903855927, -0.007436877116560936, -0.05195995792746544, 0.010705635882914066, -0.007876916788518429, 0.04005832597613335, 0.006311681121587753, 0.03594069555401802, -0.024605346843600273, -0.020404420793056488, -0.013441251590847969, 0.0069095962680876255, 0.042490679770708084, 0.03471779078245163, 0.000956665666308254, 0.007532896474003792, -0.07810965925455093, -0.011465169489383698, -0.017348144203424454, -0.017225952818989754, -0.03985898196697235, -0.0476452074944973, -0.055853504687547684, -0.06950989365577698, -0.024560803547501564, -0.02088114060461521, -0.056119851768016815, -0.024045608937740326, 0.008105333894491196, -0.03765895217657089, -0.027879036962985992, 0.027621328830718994, 0.0030437407549470663, -0.06096974015235901, -0.052579089999198914, 0.06085945665836334, 0.009005534462630749, 0.014188057743012905, -0.018980497494339943, -0.03633487969636917, 0.011003256775438786, -0.014318853616714478, 0.039712656289339066, -0.023277321830391884, 0.008378342725336552, -0.0019599173683673143, 0.03743910789489746, -0.0025289072655141354, 0.06308680772781372, -0.017457084730267525, 0.011468548327684402, -0.009265663102269173, 0.003807956352829933, -0.009272070601582527, -0.019502762705087662, 0.04728807136416435, -0.042043495923280716, -0.07474329322576523, -0.05796562507748604, 0.046912599354982376, 0.04779091477394104, -0.0017949872417375445, -0.03562157601118088, 0.009657525457441807, 0.021247996017336845, 0.027644742280244827, 0.0021004967857152224, 0.036907706409692764, 0.005159395281225443, -0.0571194663643837, -0.012130122631788254, -0.016663765534758568, 0.022283246740698814, -0.011406658217310905, 0.007573177572339773, -0.02222350239753723, -0.011556008830666542, 0.04559222236275673, -0.08156939595937729, 0.027733394876122475, 0.044285353273153305, 0.07593920081853867, -0.008378678001463413, 0.02771945670247078, -0.0032678046263754368, 0.030098970979452133, 0.011432064697146416, -0.002111312234774232, 0.006874638609588146, 0.05117853358387947, 0.07015933841466904, -0.013913953676819801, -0.03392837941646576, 0.00302094011567533, -0.06711149215698242, -0.023511463776230812, 0.019426168873906136, 0.019112784415483475, 0.017467211931943893, 0.0255979523062706, -0.0135732376947999, 0.012456811033189297, -0.010775424540042877, 0.059008579701185226, -0.018106387928128242, -0.0455334447324276, 0.02140231616795063, -0.021725747734308243, -0.03841307386755943, 0.004722348880022764, -0.015684140846133232, 0.004924251697957516, -0.03165662661194801, 0.03228505700826645, -0.07493499666452408, 0.019072236493229866, -0.032479509711265564, -0.008177904412150383, 0.028340674936771393, 0.010823759250342846, -0.03173848241567612, 0.041255369782447815, -0.024399805814027786, -0.03406521677970886, -0.042166389524936676, 0.01819058507680893, -0.014893476851284504, 0.024154147133231163, -0.07024427503347397, 0.03982290253043175, 0.0417475588619709, -0.00241537275724113, -0.02742754854261875, 0.0256075207144022, -0.03355308249592781, -0.012095962651073933, -0.06339863687753677, -0.0020814230665564537, -0.030217718333005905, 0.037079744040966034, 0.011018381454050541, -0.009591279551386833, 0.06913181394338608, -0.011403925716876984, 0.010177883319556713, -0.06430277228355408, -0.02275005728006363, -0.002951038768514991, -0.002958593424409628, -0.038324180990457535, -0.044735684990882874, 0.02123098634183407, -0.04010353609919548, 0.053960610181093216, 0.03353548049926758, 0.03449641913175583, -0.07132992148399353, -0.026018261909484863, 0.04218866303563118, 0.001602049800567329, 0.0310992319136858, 0.002051706425845623, -0.021934406831860542, -0.05300627648830414, 0.005516241770237684, -0.04509472846984863, -0.0003949419769924134, -0.024753669276833534, -0.03997068479657173, 0.03162219747900963, -0.03166760876774788, -0.03559853509068489, 0.01782110705971718, 0.008105574175715446, 0.07563529163599014, -0.03220603987574577, -0.018175609409809113, 0.003448005998507142, 0.026161547750234604, -0.06730809062719345, -0.03243666887283325, -0.02844560705125332, -0.06130042299628258, -0.04964134469628334, -0.04689491540193558, 0.015262287110090256, 0.049149222671985626, -0.005392291117459536, 0.04891575872898102, -0.004442553035914898, 0.044654909521341324, -0.014808383770287037, 0.030328162014484406, -0.011409612372517586, -0.001365091884508729, -0.03777921944856644, 0.026225851848721504, -0.07955286651849747, 0.0011274117277935147, 0.0029517982620745897, -0.021409520879387856, -0.02924206107854843, 0.010852145031094551, 0.02422957308590412, 0.022205756977200508, -0.06392676383256912, 0.008818726055324078, 0.0333576425909996, -0.04571922495961189, 0.0480068139731884, -0.010988259688019753, -0.021658524870872498, 0.033618830144405365, -0.05637483298778534, -0.04440292343497276, 0.05966363847255707, -0.030181672424077988, 0.015387081541121006, 0.012306900694966316, -0.02314724028110504, 0.022097568958997726, 0.04761369898915291, -0.031469136476516724, -0.038746513426303864, -0.019214767962694168, 0.03562503308057785, 0.017317650839686394, -0.03146146610379219, 0.02851416915655136, 0.040117546916007996, -0.04084485024213791, -0.027904750779271126, -0.0021832087077200413, 0.03346587345004082, -0.03786284476518631, 0.028319567441940308, -0.05204623192548752, -0.013544111512601376, 0.055034130811691284, 0.0036802110262215137, -0.00004515883847489022, 0.02720170095562935, 0.05266089737415314, 0.018734009936451912, -0.026598939672112465, 0.014323954470455647, -0.07026423513889313, 0.00034320945269428194, -0.00657045328989625, -0.017575209960341454, 0.009057573974132538, 0.04972643405199051, -0.029356690123677254, 0.02552499994635582, -0.0009037895943038166, -0.04420270025730133, -0.008928430266678333, -0.030141429975628853, 0.052541278302669525, -0.06178092211484909, -0.013259870000183582, 0.02540704421699047, 0.024468636140227318, 0.04189739003777504, -0.004508078098297119, 0.04130464792251587, 0.004939787555485964, -0.03434337303042412, -0.03898384049534798, 0.004999732598662376, -0.0751059427857399, -0.046580515801906586, 0.01138549018651247, 0.042380429804325104, -0.04022177681326866, 0.06040891259908676, 0.04023386165499687, -0.017871402204036713, 0.045724887400865555, -0.016147425398230553, -0.03193233907222748, -0.04039079695940018, 0.04530464485287666, 0.040953099727630615, -0.06337378919124603, -0.0050885421223938465, -0.016721663996577263, -0.039472099393606186, -0.018901988863945007, -0.04527847096323967, -0.02120925672352314, -0.009634480811655521, 0.028893303126096725, -0.05392005667090416, 0.07218267023563385, -0.046716831624507904, -0.0779261589050293, 0.009338052943348885, 0.04817518964409828, -0.07361581921577454, 0.016883129253983498, 0.019083572551608086, 0.01302019227296114, -0.06421973556280136, 0.030044928193092346, -0.0038811923004686832, -0.011479496955871582, -0.0358748584985733, 0.05656455457210541, 0.0791107639670372, 0.0183932576328516, -0.003486927365884185, 0.009361541830003262, -0.03456440940499306, 0.014613509178161621, -0.031160622835159302, -0.009277784265577793, 0.007436793763190508, 0.06350349634885788, -0.027761075645685196, -0.010113399475812912, -0.0515427328646183, 0.06759988516569138, -0.03187272697687149, -0.042960237711668015, 0.01359624695032835, -0.029516618698835373, 0.04888897016644478, -0.02445167861878872, -0.06741951406002045, -0.02240017242729664, -0.04131298512220383, -0.040635693818330765, -0.01515429001301527, 0.03647893667221069, -0.04872412979602814, 0.027265140786767006, -0.019943706691265106, -0.07353131473064423, 0.040293894708156586, -0.029229560866951942, -0.06125818192958832, 0.032194335013628006, -0.07012392580509186, -0.03063012659549713, -0.03370214253664017, -0.003357528941705823, -0.013424225151538849, 0.05148862302303314, -0.016856864094734192, -0.043770067393779755, 0.017331913113594055, 0.019869497045874596, 0.008208549581468105, -0.015270574018359184, 0.01918415166437626, -0.025178899988532066, 0.06748045235872269, -0.04343293234705925, -0.01433485746383667, -0.02907019853591919, -0.055054888129234314, 0.022303035482764244, 0.03396055847406387, -0.012091712094843388, -0.048843033611774445, -0.010982571169734001, -0.03430718183517456, 0.0046771252527832985, 0.02691267617046833, -0.06935937702655792, -0.046530917286872864, 0.035874880850315094, -0.0010896148160099983, -0.006336881313472986, 0.028124839067459106, 0.010163997299969196, -0.023205773904919624, -0.014565779827535152, 0.016547806560993195, 0.006784665398299694, 0.04082540422677994, -0.050163041800260544, -0.0742814913392067, -0.026569955050945282, -0.020749662071466446, -0.004666545428335667, -0.06742367148399353, -0.044718675315380096, 0.024392759427428246, -0.0585906058549881, -0.01991296000778675, 0.05579809844493866, -0.001394784078001976, -0.038713760673999786, -0.06587114185094833, 0.01715313084423542, -0.0028083487413823605, -0.05480004474520683, -0.06414750963449478, 0.018151037395000458, -0.01179893221706152, 0.0023878656793385744, 0.0022032586857676506, 0.02103392593562603, -0.05320979654788971, 0.0037125907838344574, -0.08296476304531097, -0.026903923600912094, -0.022646144032478333, 0.04581023007631302, 0.036454297602176666, 0.006299661472439766, -0.0001507926353951916, -0.05724453553557396, 0.02538355439901352, 0.03563334047794342, 0.019179154187440872, -0.006302257534116507, 0.04983009770512581, 0.04873601347208023, -0.04898059740662575, -0.0026354112196713686, 0.03382934257388115, -0.014264160767197609, 0.0032115436624735594, 0.05536884069442749, 0.02185213938355446, 0.02187209390103817, -0.016109464690089226, 0.03484329953789711, -0.029692525044083595, 0.016495607793331146, -0.04225657135248184, -0.029059400781989098, -0.02411370538175106, -0.06428681313991547, 0.04745583236217499, -0.0217511635273695, 0.04809023067355156, 0.004936410114169121, -0.013596138916909695, -0.010114885866641998, -0.0343402698636055, -0.04493384808301926, 0.03670257702469826, 0.02028590440750122, -0.011604875326156616, 0.0456894114613533, -0.03007066436111927, 0.0068089310079813, -0.008922146633267403, -0.0013146753190085292, -0.0027583788614720106, 0.01539069227874279, 0.060029126703739166, -0.0695410668849945, 0.012439985759556293, -0.008441188372671604, 0.03969348967075348, -0.02360733412206173, 0.00022651435574516654, -0.045273829251527786, 0.0631822720170021, 0.032509543001651764, -0.008303029462695122, -0.04579564556479454, -0.017849450930953026, -0.0560474693775177, -0.054453879594802856, -0.06178073585033417, -0.024158230051398277, 0.04457024484872818, -0.04022902622818947, 0.043349094688892365, 0.003758520120754838, 0.04765024408698082, 0.03917986527085304, 0.020299892872571945, -0.020227309316396713, -0.014968829229474068, -0.053705908358097076, 0.08286359906196594, 0.02677437849342823, -0.02441931888461113, -0.0451037622988224, -0.009094586595892906, -0.026781177148222923, 0.0492081344127655, 0.02204575389623642, -0.04205441102385521, 0.009674684144556522, -0.03360499441623688, -0.018930131569504738, 0.04434004798531532, 0.009296398609876633, 0.022013649344444275, -0.05010739713907242, -0.0019476300803944468, -0.007282223552465439, -0.03391977772116661 ]
Most interpretability research in NLP focuses on understanding the behavior and features of a fully trained model. However, certain insights into model behavior may only be accessible by observing the trajectory of the training process. We present a case study of syntax acquisition in masked language models (MLMs) that demonstrates how analyzing the evolution of interpretable artifacts throughout training deepens our understanding of emergent behavior. In particular, we study Syntactic Attention Structure (SAS), a naturally emerging property of MLMs wherein specific Transformer heads tend to focus on specific syntactic relations. We identify a brief window in pretraining when models abruptly acquire SAS, concurrent with a steep drop in loss. This breakthrough precipitates the subsequent acquisition of linguistic capabilities. We then examine the causal role of SAS by manipulating SAS during training, and demonstrate that SAS is necessary for the development of grammatical capabilities. We further find that SAS competes with other beneficial traits during training, and that briefly suppressing SAS improves model quality. These findings offer an interpretation of a real-world example of both simplicity bias and breakthrough training dynamics.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07311v5
[ -0.053753841668367386, -0.01961801014840603, 0.03660689294338226, -0.023284632712602615, 0.00011618984717642888, -0.009210488758981228, 0.021619299426674843, 0.0020984767470508814, -0.03225109353661537, -0.05781439691781998, -0.03893493488430977, -0.022397205233573914, -0.029467297717928886, -0.021552490070462227, -0.04136548563838005, -0.030952226370573044, 0.046429965645074844, -0.019592182710766792, -0.03410513326525688, 0.052954502403736115, 0.0242078248411417, 0.005788478069007397, -0.050039105117321014, 0.05690225586295128, 0.006309857591986656, -0.04896867275238037, -0.03299115598201752, -0.02827497012913227, -0.03949635848402977, -0.0369705855846405, 0.06730039417743683, -0.037442922592163086, -0.017300769686698914, -0.018903864547610283, -0.049296438694000244, -0.038524311035871506, -0.03472789376974106, 0.021094458177685738, 0.038838524371385574, -0.03103991225361824, 0.014128217473626137, -0.04480791464447975, -0.05729074776172638, 0.009309511631727219, -0.05781980976462364, 0.019437991082668304, -0.037657592445611954, 0.04392331466078758, -0.06495153158903122, -0.039481859654188156, 0.01345785427838564, -0.013281784951686859, 0.007735787890851498, 0.04772826284170151, -0.040047306567430496, 0.05591616779565811, -0.004951854236423969, -0.0034502234775573015, -0.0505591481924057, -0.044611286371946335, 0.007290735840797424, -0.0533403605222702, 0.008410527370870113, -0.023202715441584587, -0.021466540172696114, 0.011476757936179638, 0.008877290412783623, -0.06329647451639175, -0.05354869365692139, -0.0534120574593544, 0.04724996164441109, -0.04692500829696655, -0.00999417807906866, 0.02406970039010048, -0.020249487832188606, -0.023482000455260277, -0.04457304626703262, -0.029519489035010338, 0.013661567121744156, -0.014446367509663105, -0.02419508434832096, 0.04881810024380684, 0.040622446686029434, -0.015154107473790646, -0.011581603437662125, -0.047190722078084946, 0.04111579433083534, -0.020731639117002487, 0.026227151975035667, -0.0605999194085598, 0.013710849918425083, -0.017703847959637642, -0.03646104037761688, -0.006087477784603834, 0.067728191614151, -0.017478495836257935, 0.04105608910322189, -0.021590443328022957, 0.01852424070239067, -0.03601716086268425, -0.0077190338633954525, 0.007517807185649872, -0.01957787573337555, 0.0715799555182457, 0.02911006100475788, -0.0557839460670948, 0.03005228564143181, 0.019490869715809822, -0.06528079509735107, 0.0018726445268839598, -0.030197637155652046, -0.017273522913455963, 0.011047263629734516, -0.07455533742904663, -0.05724659934639931, -0.0366850383579731, 0.050431616604328156, 0.011639075353741646, 0.011090358719229698, 0.016245990991592407, -0.056018564850091934, 0.06037970259785652, 0.006501310970634222, -0.06849406659603119, -0.021724047139286995, -0.0030913129448890686, 0.04085662588477135, 0.015117481350898743, -0.05365011468529701, 0.00143155746627599, -0.027000118046998978, -0.032698653638362885, -0.0021521204616874456, -0.046389345079660416, 0.07148135453462601, -0.022311626002192497, -0.007629034575074911, -0.03934421017765999, 0.023247091099619865, -0.0460207536816597, -0.012407680973410606, -0.07057229429483414, 0.0030355651397258043, -0.0471511110663414, 0.0406809039413929, 0.062350671738386154, -0.0021936397533863783, -0.02836032025516033, -0.003002090146765113, 0.012074780650436878, 0.014755402691662312, -0.013079718686640263, 0.0381338968873024, 0.03405839949846268, 0.03692277520895004, -0.022232219576835632, 0.05582831799983978, -0.0070486487820744514, -0.08012373000383377, -0.02154749259352684, -0.013970695436000824, -0.060733795166015625, 0.05338728427886963, -0.053328078240156174, 0.062296729534864426, -0.015031490474939346, 0.04853235185146332, -0.012847728095948696, -0.04108717292547226, -0.012867049314081669, 0.003272002562880516, 0.014788501895964146, -0.02372078411281109, 0.00567244878038764, -0.07448679953813553, 0.007849486544728279, 0.045409195125103, -0.05259350314736366, -0.011064273305237293, -0.008452248759567738, 0.03352731466293335, 0.05142035335302353, -0.06143711507320404, -0.03516777977347374, -0.04614878073334694, 0.022264983505010605, -0.08151852339506149, -0.03618573769927025, 0.047918614000082016, 0.048648715019226074, -0.053619418293237686, -0.029594816267490387, 0.0236114040017128, 0.0353727750480175, -0.01918831095099449, -0.0020645109470933676, 0.03540908917784691, -0.019824480637907982, 0.02349671721458435, 0.04979925975203514, -0.08500466495752335, 0.011077988892793655, -0.06359776854515076, -0.03239469230175018, -0.028385205194354057, -0.06196761131286621, 0.038562193512916565, 0.0396675169467926, -0.03233632817864418, -0.05379688739776611, 0.016565142199397087, 0.06420812010765076, 0.04603179544210434, 0.027327749878168106, 0.0471661277115345, -0.02108641527593136, -0.09691019356250763, 0.061902303248643875, 0.013193952850997448, -0.0029316353611648083, 0.03160446137189865, 0.021890491247177124, -0.01001466903835535, -0.007240458391606808, -0.002313618315383792, -0.02693748287856579, 0.029195616021752357, -0.007057311944663525, -0.02575509250164032, -0.005845348816365004, 0.03464104235172272, -0.042870186269283295, -0.01790650002658367, -0.07459918409585953, 0.01945398561656475, 0.012909558601677418, -0.04620951786637306, 0.0032808613032102585, 0.020912034437060356, 0.001618067966774106, -0.032343458384275436, -0.039944570511579514, 0.022252243012189865, -0.011611645109951496, -0.06191098317503929, -0.020148923620581627, -0.017792874947190285, 0.008687824942171574, -0.023576542735099792, 0.001315615838393569, -0.06442377716302872, -0.06549064069986343, -0.020216818898916245, -0.01650783233344555, 0.02560417726635933, 0.021184803918004036, -0.0396173819899559, 0.006080070044845343, -0.027800068259239197, 0.024933023378252983, 0.02571367472410202, 0.040813297033309937, -0.06756903231143951, 0.014539978466928005, 0.026920955628156662, -0.01629447378218174, -0.014977393671870232, -0.02875644341111183, 0.0027712229639291763, 0.025727208703756332, 0.038024693727493286, 0.04790366068482399, 0.051135461777448654, 0.013349780812859535, -0.05494531989097595, -0.04522925615310669, 0.02724304050207138, -0.04121234267950058, -0.0024657694157212973, 0.028198713436722755, 0.057060062885284424, 0.0007812763215042651, -0.013807965442538261, -0.06620729714632034, 0.006323738023638725, -0.008147024549543858, -0.058755628764629364, -0.061988215893507004, -0.060689136385917664, -0.04231305792927742, -0.06496211141347885, -0.026155933737754822, -0.01840337924659252, -0.029203182086348534, 0.015578283928334713, -0.05327092483639717, -0.019956011325120926, -0.0288462582975626, 0.018941663205623627, -0.027315059676766396, -0.013595914468169212, -0.005058362614363432, -0.03180874139070511, -0.015304824337363243, -0.006893502082675695, -0.0814671590924263, -0.03746160864830017, -0.022145140916109085, -0.015152035281062126, 0.002370996866375208, -0.039967749267816544, 0.04935193806886673, -0.014680571854114532, 0.02192676067352295, -0.026853719726204872, 0.0424228310585022, 0.0006069374503567815, 0.026631157845258713, -0.04464900866150856, -0.05704476684331894, 0.030635438859462738, -0.01416301354765892, -0.008405813947319984, -0.05281190201640129, -0.04204517602920532, 0.01785869337618351, 0.059291087090969086, -0.012362382374703884, -0.01947883516550064, -0.05784611031413078, -0.0407034270465374, 0.04435697942972183, -0.008127703331410885, 0.0025034542195498943, 0.027381516993045807, 0.04159186780452728, -0.018428467214107513, -0.01374321524053812, 0.01636042445898056, -0.011541971005499363, 0.010628712363541126, 0.00030561303719878197, -0.05060424283146858, -0.0407259427011013, 0.017916284501552582, -0.07287702709436417, 0.006736955139786005, 0.049816280603408813, 0.03497243672609329, -0.04362315312027931, -0.0059374431148171425, 0.01082848571240902, 0.004514615051448345, 0.04137677326798439, -0.03159298002719879, 0.037981826812028885, 0.04110226035118103, 0.01737258769571781, -0.03221738338470459, -0.006201603449881077, 0.021277382969856262, -0.05300571396946907, -0.05759964883327484, 0.03587031736969948, 0.028481533750891685, 0.03231804817914963, -0.019934117794036865, -0.0604250468313694, -0.0014494938077405095, 0.01886237971484661, 0.06887207180261612, -0.05923907831311226, -0.03322591260075569, 0.017913322895765305, -0.058037299662828445, -0.01077056210488081, -0.005395634565502405, -0.009540681727230549, -0.055000100284814835, -0.016078095883131027, 0.003496735356748104, -0.013967560604214668, 0.028819071128964424, -0.007541104685515165, -0.003952607046812773, 0.03099369816482067, 0.031417179852724075, -0.03890381008386612, 0.048882704228162766, -0.04996034875512123, -0.03363577276468277, 0.0019124592654407024, -0.05663051828742027, -0.007695725653320551, -0.03935299813747406, -0.08166220039129257, -0.01736614666879177, 0.030561525374650955, 0.0028100390918552876, 0.004333904944360256, 0.020173462107777596, -0.0015719063812866807, -0.01242181658744812, -0.08923935145139694, 0.009760068729519844, -0.06711899489164352, 0.04346247762441635, 0.02401389740407467, -0.025019336491823196, 0.06405967473983765, 0.01819564588367939, -0.0390772670507431, 0.015704916790127754, -0.035843104124069214, -0.025631384924054146, -0.007985119707882404, 0.002209397964179516, -0.0661899670958519, 0.015596174634993076, -0.07412032037973404, 0.006626296788454056, -0.022455474361777306, -0.01252912636846304, -0.05194176733493805, -0.042096976190805435, -0.0020554426591843367, 0.06118403375148773, 0.05702986940741539, 0.022781673818826675, -0.028996510431170464, 0.00184336316306144, 0.019466130062937737, -0.014802168123424053, 0.010276170447468758, -0.017599808052182198, -0.013896084390580654, 0.036695729941129684, -0.05321599543094635, -0.038025423884391785, -0.02137724682688713, 0.007452577818185091, 0.0554400198161602, -0.018493816256523132, -0.00861778948456049, -0.004374744836241007, 0.04272134602069855, -0.01487705297768116, -0.07241079211235046, -0.036112379282712936, -0.017112573608756065, -0.056727100163698196, 0.025274714455008507, 0.02253914065659046, 0.045980941504240036, -0.025014709681272507, -0.01607496850192547, -0.01678047701716423, 0.014002742245793343, -0.007879946380853653, -0.004238564986735582, 0.03137299045920372, -0.009131786413490772, 0.04104132205247879, -0.03601381182670593, -0.07542967796325684, 0.029149925336241722, -0.03366214036941528, -0.024154145270586014, -0.041522543877363205, 0.044563084840774536, -0.03796771913766861, 0.04771794378757477, -0.09029987454414368, 0.007656495552510023, 0.035523779690265656, -0.003873260458931327, 0.0024683517403900623, 0.051976900547742844, -0.05637190863490105, 0.048218779265880585, -0.04395928978919983, 0.023779748007655144, -0.00667012482881546, -0.028180019930005074, 0.013363647274672985, -0.005370954982936382, 0.005019990727305412, -0.014095538295805454, 0.042120251804590225, -0.0038928056601434946, -0.026140175759792328, 0.030887853354215622, 0.02254328317940235, 0.05492742732167244, -0.052644722163677216, 0.030845411121845245, 0.05757374316453934, -0.00884988158941269, -0.034078702330589294, 0.0004131939203944057, 0.0011724099749699235, 0.012310180813074112, 0.04803627356886864, -0.04888932406902313, -0.028355790302157402, 0.010244935750961304, -0.024103736504912376, 0.042541585862636566, 0.011705712415277958, 0.025219090282917023, 0.023575669154524803, 0.012837328016757965, 0.047471288591623306, -0.04291283339262009, -0.00865260325372219, -0.041605670005083084, 0.008508199825882912, 0.024999000132083893, 0.029662031680345535, -0.016766080632805824, 0.030864236876368523, -0.04711266607046127, 0.001995410304516554, -0.002159885363653302, -0.04051605984568596, 0.04857663810253143, -0.03339335694909096, 0.01277842279523611, 0.01027569267898798, 0.03543961048126221, 0.01932024210691452, 0.06286276876926422, -0.006521217990666628, -0.011940904892981052, -0.0120365796610713, -0.019228242337703705, 0.027162475511431694, -0.061349015682935715, -0.038751572370529175, 0.029464734718203545, -0.037442006170749664, 0.013995815068483353, -0.02197609655559063, 0.004950696136802435, -0.002731532324105501, 0.0014297340530902147, 0.04358243942260742, -0.03367606922984123, -0.05746079608798027, 0.003080588998273015, 0.07821553945541382, -0.04754604026675224, 0.018531830981373787, -0.01889457367360592, -0.006760515738278627, 0.025756960734725, -0.002878269413486123, -0.00598429748788476, 0.03618907555937767, -0.01041833870112896, -0.057837944477796555, 0.033815544098615646, -0.001156506361439824, -0.055885378271341324, -0.00008986597822513431, 0.005472477525472641, -0.07767005264759064, -0.0047107115387916565, 0.018124381080269814, 0.01944366842508316, -0.07117508351802826, 0.03252008184790611, 0.04506121575832367, -0.007670878432691097, -0.03253605589270592, 0.055847056210041046, 0.07483294606208801, -0.025037705898284912, 0.01068204827606678, 0.01502798218280077, -0.06458858400583267, 0.028715910390019417, -0.03578924015164375, -0.021262845024466515, 0.0024869320914149284, 0.015282826498150826, 0.05061715096235275, -0.01749083399772644, 0.012520295567810535, 0.06440655142068863, -0.0037151083815842867, 0.011041488498449326, 0.03199363499879837, -0.020333779975771904, 0.04138325899839401, -0.02550533041357994, -0.002786430763080716, -0.023047544062137604, -0.010689159855246544, -0.04271960258483887, -0.0611533485352993, -0.030631287023425102, 0.006573865655809641, -0.013308444991707802, 0.012331761419773102, -0.08635760843753815, -0.0017410687869414687, -0.05825287476181984, -0.08879543840885162, 0.018934791907668114, -0.03157524764537811, 0.007890412583947182, -0.011614114046096802, -0.006619757041335106, -0.018815286457538605, 0.06963163614273071, -0.05873613432049751, -0.04369455203413963, -0.007042332552373409, 0.02525351196527481, 0.0221273023635149, -0.029394594952464104, -0.021387461572885513, -0.020504651591181755, -0.00248182681389153, -0.04034445062279701, -0.03640173375606537, -0.001884686411358416, -0.03623390942811966, 0.015182659029960632, 0.03838376700878143, -0.014063568785786629, -0.06323328614234924, 0.020782601088285446, -0.025960398837924004, 0.05377398058772087, 0.02240620367228985, -0.034804265946149826, -0.054133154451847076, 0.005744497757405043, 0.05049250274896622, -0.019643248990178108, 0.04539079964160919, 0.018490655347704887, 0.010952895507216454, -0.015609458088874817, 0.010459682904183865, 0.0056112976744771, -0.030216384679079056, 0.03317121043801308, -0.05133576691150665, 0.010953843593597412, 0.027240440249443054, 0.008430826477706432, -0.025005735456943512, 0.04822518676519394, -0.01384397130459547, -0.05944420024752617, -0.025079503655433655, 0.03236134350299835, 0.00000614816644883831, -0.001254345173947513, -0.07027564942836761, 0.04134584963321686, -0.029979819431900978, -0.0365213006734848, -0.036882434040308, 0.02723926305770874, 0.03090059757232666, -0.061001431196928024, 0.012229502201080322, 0.027971507981419563, -0.03902033343911171, -0.017917683348059654, -0.08610271662473679, 0.012948982417583466, -0.046728476881980896, 0.00973571091890335, 0.008099658414721489, 0.024650925770401955, 0.0003830870846286416, -0.038502100855112076, 0.0632593184709549, 0.025511521846055984, -0.00589475454762578, 0.039290159940719604, 0.039907269179821014, -0.021044816821813583, -0.05979398638010025, -0.022347712889313698, 0.06912428140640259, -0.0257719773799181, -0.03639078512787819, 0.023765377700328827, 0.002504670061171055, 0.024808654561638832, 0.0061691273003816605, 0.041349831968545914, -0.011029883287847042, 0.03037913702428341, -0.02433169260621071, 0.005295711103826761, -0.05198243260383606, -0.019809884950518608, 0.008536490611732006, -0.04626164212822914, -0.02714981511235237, 0.05579177290201187, -0.007090730592608452, -0.013282790780067444, -0.01982690766453743, -0.013377461582422256, 0.02909582108259201, -0.05049888789653778, -0.05012182146310806, 0.04552163928747177, -0.02522640861570835, -0.04368691146373749, -0.02186819538474083, -0.033790163695812225, 0.011899402365088463, 0.04010666534304619, 0.06717748194932938, -0.028411535546183586, -0.010687733069062233, -0.08599768579006195, 0.050510331988334656, -0.03594117984175682, 0.034645985811948776, 0.0018332339823246002, 0.06391225755214691, 0.005515567027032375, 0.009086794219911098, 0.008251122198998928, -0.012925970368087292, -0.05162525922060013, -0.0883932039141655, -0.013977413065731525, 0.008853115141391754, -0.0013567603891715407, -0.002985735423862934, 0.002695920644327998, 0.0150215532630682, 0.0373014360666275, -0.005744430236518383, 0.04016534984111786, 0.011738280765712261, -0.011941985227167606, -0.026315465569496155, 0.07091814279556274, 0.02752949483692646, 0.011478171683847904, -0.011967318132519722, 0.037256140261888504, 0.0008900808752514422, -0.002005010610446334, -0.0012980629689991474, 0.00994572602212429, -0.02775948867201805, -0.046225860714912415, -0.026954442262649536, 0.035051990300416946, -0.027969762682914734, -0.042438194155693054, -0.026617374271154404, -0.006951361428946257, -0.012460378929972649, -0.034793585538864136 ]
We discuss a string-net construction on 2-framed surfaces, taking as algebraic input a finite, rigid tensor category, which is neither assumed to be pivotal nor semi-simple. It is shown that circle categories of our framed string-net construction essentially compute Drinfeld centers twisted by powers of the double dual functor.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14779v3
[ 0.000033210486435564235, 0.03706015273928642, 0.06083112955093384, 0.049090057611465454, -0.0029190459754318, -0.02612180821597576, -0.06481385231018066, 0.0023340682964771986, 0.011915070004761219, -0.053428977727890015, 0.013449687510728836, -0.07257048785686493, 0.005138075910508633, -0.023038407787680626, -0.01148971077054739, 0.0367022305727005, 0.04579766467213631, 0.0013814752455800772, -0.05277690291404724, 0.033924736082553864, -0.03898175060749054, -0.04837002977728844, -0.02503829263150692, 0.07005484402179718, 0.02029687911272049, 0.016000930219888687, -0.06385285407304764, 0.002825556555762887, -0.05736996978521347, -0.04100140556693077, 0.0340300127863884, -0.04062328115105629, -0.014875480905175209, -0.0031503436621278524, -0.03561772033572197, 0.029170971363782883, 0.01807321608066559, -0.00613563135266304, 0.009500844404101372, -0.04510597139596939, -0.005181334912776947, -0.04920719936490059, -0.04141051322221756, -0.011268075555562973, -0.05307099595665932, -0.017963239923119545, 0.02622867375612259, 0.013247623108327389, -0.03694529831409454, -0.010919068939983845, 0.025104934349656105, 0.04037985950708389, 0.04587453603744507, -0.016095386818051338, -0.03755324333906174, -0.03269638121128082, 0.04744508117437363, 0.011201444081962109, -0.06312830746173859, -0.004525138530880213, -0.03843138739466667, -0.005216213874518871, -0.05338708311319351, -0.05308499187231064, -0.053181834518909454, 0.04779111593961716, -0.03682873770594597, -0.04204513505101204, -0.021335219964385033, -0.03339124470949173, 0.03237735107541084, -0.062171000987291336, 0.0531860888004303, -0.04479964077472687, -0.06488194316625595, 0.045839134603738785, -0.012646104209125042, 0.0376916341483593, -0.02279074676334858, 0.03708316385746002, -0.013498237356543541, -0.03717301785945892, 0.05853104591369629, 0.0027480637654662132, -0.02794719487428665, -0.045955486595630646, 0.051470257341861725, 0.03321363404393196, 0.02640298381447792, 0.02092418447136879, -0.03655321151018143, -0.0106699513271451, -0.026292258873581886, 0.022998526692390442, -0.02860970050096512, -0.025206297636032104, 0.0810398980975151, 0.07628219574689865, -0.026082679629325867, -0.00047910731518641114, 0.004987786989659071, -0.061600618064403534, -0.03421223163604736, -0.02854353003203869, -0.03721494600176811, 0.017078544944524765, 0.010683477856218815, -0.024182308465242386, -0.04451347514986992, 0.061473481357097626, -0.024119414389133453, 0.021753478795289993, -0.02207287587225437, -0.04180992767214775, 0.0005824723630212247, 0.02067916840314865, 0.04687781631946564, 0.060856036841869354, -0.006740194279700518, 0.018750088289380074, 0.03396187722682953, -0.03882367163896561, -0.004244842100888491, 0.018812615424394608, -0.03540491312742233, -0.04599618911743164, 0.03269908204674721, 0.037408992648124695, 0.06139052286744118, 0.0014608948258683085, -0.024042224511504173, 0.005060922354459763, 0.06728856265544891, -0.0290670245885849, 0.03527143597602844, -0.0549505278468132, 0.036401938647031784, -0.06567341089248657, -0.04525356367230415, 0.02812742255628109, -0.053491245955228806, -0.07231421023607254, 0.04684009402990341, 0.021403292194008827, 0.032149605453014374, 0.08499667793512344, -0.07224306464195251, 0.01628447324037552, -0.056909363716840744, 0.013705060817301273, -0.011452722363173962, -0.016682209447026253, 0.017332715913653374, -0.054474614560604095, -0.042305897921323776, -0.015516909770667553, 0.021663226187229156, -0.011253670789301395, 0.012747631408274174, -0.022500116378068924, 0.015698455274105072, -0.006176268681883812, -0.015453435480594635, -0.0126840490847826, 0.0029842937365174294, 0.0478198304772377, 0.032355405390262604, -0.04698039963841438, -0.03549141064286232, -0.049016665667295456, -0.027178406715393066, -0.0006351305637508631, 0.005983554292470217, -0.07096494734287262, -0.061675429344177246, -0.016928570345044136, -0.043844033032655716, -0.0675492137670517, -0.008459820412099361, -0.0026853138115257025, 0.005412054713815451, -0.0010153710609301925, 0.01552594918757677, -0.03191904351115227, -0.05110056698322296, -0.0226735919713974, -0.047596342861652374, -0.009464532136917114, -0.03142564371228218, -0.03369630128145218, -0.02332134172320366, -0.03154994174838066, 0.014736979268491268, 0.03139635920524597, -0.05524526163935661, -0.031285714358091354, 0.016163360327482224, -0.030580732971429825, -0.017273860052227974, -0.015276767313480377, -0.05976487323641777, -0.011300603859126568, 0.019074762240052223, 0.00161605270113796, -0.00518394447863102, -0.04162810742855072, 0.0008039353415369987, -0.01875758357346058, -0.06477256119251251, -0.019352728500962257, 0.048557817935943604, 0.04456069692969322, 0.045507196336984634, -0.042218901216983795, 0.007038548123091459, -0.014320144429802895, -0.09172753244638443, -0.02897953800857067, 0.051632724702358246, 0.01471925713121891, 0.007146561983972788, -0.009267143905162811, 0.02015138417482376, -0.0348086878657341, -0.05080673471093178, 0.02672838605940342, 0.06941048055887222, 0.024082856252789497, -0.04177767410874367, 0.05157390236854553, -0.05950280651450157, -0.0815681517124176, 0.0007588714943267405, -0.04524822160601616, -0.05996261537075043, -0.01945924013853073, -0.06903868913650513, 0.07319256663322449, 0.023021675646305084, -0.0662478655576706, -0.0383182093501091, -0.024074388667941093, 0.03484450653195381, -0.00007958273636177182, 0.026249846443533897, -0.013645107857882977, -0.0501587837934494, 0.015110637061297894, 0.0005668195663020015, -0.0008945040171965957, -0.020575521513819695, -0.041558023542165756, 0.016883431002497673, -0.00015083728067111224, 0.0030094964895397425, 0.038404688239097595, -0.05425708740949631, 0.04010985419154167, -0.00817271787673235, 0.020855771377682686, 0.02892264723777771, 0.04412020370364189, 0.006605891045182943, -0.021675171330571175, 0.006540496367961168, -0.0024730078876018524, -0.06953421980142593, -0.0029504147823899984, -0.010640840046107769, -0.06203393638134003, 0.005360414274036884, 0.04424659535288811, 0.020047402009367943, -0.03600131347775459, -0.02669336646795273, 0.040314264595508575, 0.006643299479037523, 0.002546735107898712, 0.04495735466480255, 0.011007104068994522, -0.03980052471160889, 0.03316659852862358, -0.03269380331039429, -0.050713714212179184, 0.002261863322928548, -0.012416568584740162, 0.004215930588543415, -0.07156389951705933, -0.02878868766129017, -0.0610618032515049, -0.04880287125706673, -0.03044094517827034, -0.020904090255498886, -0.03429925814270973, -0.0324869304895401, -0.04738529399037361, -0.008470437489449978, 0.0054442607797682285, -0.05649220570921898, -0.01721964031457901, -0.04460621997714043, -0.01319248229265213, 0.05845088139176369, 0.02026243321597576, 0.012618071399629116, -0.07904943078756332, -0.059611231088638306, 0.011019260622560978, 0.018303336575627327, -0.027980903163552284, -0.01734834536910057, -0.00373635720461607, 0.010665567591786385, 0.005167718511074781, -0.010063236579298973, 0.03907810524106026, -0.0007258415571413934, -0.03511311486363411, 0.005452568177133799, 0.023645123466849327, -0.034160345792770386, 0.004220257978886366, -0.021872468292713165, -0.05144212022423744, -0.056976936757564545, -0.005920161493122578, 0.005694931838661432, -0.020627403631806374, -0.07269878685474396, 0.04456916078925133, 0.03008171170949936, -0.05151261016726494, 0.005119104869663715, -0.056129828095436096, 0.027387041598558426, -0.018161442130804062, 0.01812395639717579, -0.006587260868400335, -0.023494591936469078, 0.01663530245423317, -0.02294449880719185, -0.006530979182571173, -0.035618264228105545, -0.041595615446567535, 0.0032470831647515297, -0.06442758440971375, 0.013712907209992409, 0.03188825771212578, 0.01540905050933361, -0.057435907423496246, -0.01815909333527088, 0.058219000697135925, 0.028994346037507057, 0.03958604112267494, -0.01716153882443905, -0.05713723599910736, -0.024226980283856392, 0.04694165661931038, -0.03492477908730507, -0.009392911568284035, -0.017434561625123024, -0.019380934536457062, -0.0012067729840055108, 0.014416322112083435, 0.031066223978996277, -0.01980101689696312, -0.013799095526337624, 0.0018806799780577421, 0.0060028135776519775, -0.05338511988520622, 0.05718819797039032, 0.01242396142333746, -0.0609467513859272, 0.0187993086874485, -0.05979244410991669, 0.04453564062714577, 0.026707611978054047, 0.026194224134087563, -0.007445469964295626, -0.0547260046005249, -0.007226153742522001, -0.06923922151327133, 0.03843757137656212, -0.022160477936267853, 0.015451676212251186, 0.008447009138762951, -0.003452765056863427, -0.005452163517475128, 0.04210197180509567, -0.010666808113455772, 0.053537942469120026, 0.050199899822473526, 0.021259255707263947, 0.026455160230398178, 0.004816611763089895, -0.007335933391004801, 0.027429403737187386, -0.01731843687593937, -0.022267557680606842, -0.03684517741203308, 0.03047240898013115, -0.026151767000555992, -0.06867963075637817, -0.026353903114795685, -0.019535014405846596, -0.017378101125359535, -0.03167428821325302, 0.0017366703832522035, -0.08140833675861359, 0.053268641233444214, 0.034731317311525345, 0.011469846591353416, -0.004924147855490446, 0.0094213942065835, -0.03537534177303314, -0.019389312714338303, -0.021056760102510452, -0.07459969073534012, 0.03785787522792816, -0.039534807205200195, -0.023919103667140007, -0.011740259826183319, -0.024722928181290627, -0.06683845072984695, 0.01433071680366993, -0.014876391738653183, 0.04480268806219101, 0.027748074382543564, 0.014513167552649975, 0.0033346409909427166, -0.015836821869015694, 0.013783899135887623, -0.01386993657797575, -0.030618589371442795, -0.029845360666513443, -0.0025030849501490593, 0.02685725688934326, -0.03233261778950691, -0.08174332976341248, -0.05117784067988396, -0.014876207336783409, -0.010639632120728493, -0.03953081741929054, 0.015685131773352623, -0.037591420114040375, 0.018226459622383118, -0.046427171677351, -0.019129639491438866, 0.01981317810714245, -0.036263689398765564, -0.04975025728344917, 0.013385359197854996, 0.0039585428312420845, 0.004885499831289053, -0.020862096920609474, 0.03195509687066078, -0.03574194759130478, 0.022885266691446304, -0.01501473132520914, 0.021198850125074387, 0.01759890466928482, -0.035082992166280746, -0.011012289673089981, 0.012256039306521416, -0.0445246659219265, -0.006526291836053133, 0.01809314452111721, 0.050460416823625565, 0.02531963586807251, -0.012272720225155354, -0.03183578699827194, 0.04933733493089676, -0.06665683537721634, 0.014463813044130802, 0.07194915413856506, -0.008229476399719715, 0.036335233598947525, -0.011275393888354301, -0.05029771104454994, 0.007838360965251923, 0.0071385931223630905, 0.02217147685587406, 0.0047066048718988895, -0.009383633732795715, -0.01068990956991911, 0.02360442467033863, 0.011238607577979565, -0.04006687551736832, 0.02178945019841194, -0.025316372513771057, -0.03296707198023796, 0.02552155591547489, 0.030559832230210304, -0.008308541029691696, 0.009130407124757767, 0.023791702464222908, 0.006011452525854111, -0.024566326290369034, 0.06494157016277313, -0.010756189934909344, 0.05320155248045921, 0.027601903304457664, 0.01800539903342724, 0.028392568230628967, -0.01712155155837536, 0.060577116906642914, -0.06640656292438507, 0.007684046868234873, 0.025189219042658806, 0.04332594573497772, 0.007460746914148331, -0.013463865034282207, -0.06559760123491287, -0.057966794818639755, -0.0028415631968528032, -0.043789319694042206, 0.03646889328956604, -0.018146274611353874, -0.0016549244755879045, 0.01621866412460804, 0.004085947293788195, -0.007448752410709858, -0.045542266219854355, 0.0027735871262848377, -0.014988933689892292, 0.05619104951620102, -0.05548766627907753, -0.007999232970178127, -0.027949048206210136, 0.017635300755500793, 0.015197554603219032, -0.008539475500583649, -0.03997427970170975, 0.00004405509389471263, -0.021507950499653816, -0.012110332027077675, 0.03678137809038162, 0.004072444047778845, -0.05608430132269859, -0.05627845600247383, 0.011824402026832104, -0.03463570773601532, 0.004635653458535671, 0.06094721704721451, 0.03546607866883278, -0.026263929903507233, 0.013435306027531624, 0.06295481324195862, -0.06231674179434776, -0.014576207846403122, 0.06953386962413788, -0.048770029097795486, -0.012184524908661842, 0.015167990699410439, -0.05892452597618103, -0.0001279817515751347, -0.002948260633274913, 0.037478212267160416, 0.015424821525812149, -0.009841959923505783, 0.009223931469023228, 0.024655399844050407, 0.004382742568850517, -0.06541597843170166, -0.02188151516020298, 0.029230322688817978, -0.013792414218187332, -0.004470831714570522, -0.06996490061283112, 0.008875099010765553, -0.04714502766728401, -0.020317673683166504, -0.05325479060411453, -0.018142228946089745, -0.018787739798426628, 0.049108218401670456, 0.04299890249967575, -0.022267213091254234, -0.054490361362695694, 0.02175031416118145, 0.03215840831398964, 0.009142035618424416, -0.02767093852162361, -0.012436768040060997, -0.029018022119998932, 0.006754521280527115, -0.054624397307634354, -0.01449038740247488, -0.011547989211976528, 0.014629077166318893, 0.008532620966434479, -0.045587208122015, 0.04860066622495651, 0.032922059297561646, -0.04747629165649414, -0.020982222631573677, -0.05449245870113373, 0.035352256149053574, -0.0032407352700829506, 0.02332129329442978, -0.03514116257429123, 0.04842390865087509, -0.043925296515226364, -0.01589701697230339, -0.05663520097732544, -0.02389351651072502, -0.028017506003379822, 0.03998737037181854, -0.03885804861783981, -0.022423110902309418, -0.009339912794530392, 0.016091501340270042, -0.06419949233531952, 0.0635492205619812, 0.010251197963953018, 0.002388491528108716, -0.010999591089785099, -0.03560449928045273, 0.03388656675815582, -0.035277124494314194, -0.04693571850657463, 0.018902946263551712, 0.02550669014453888, -0.04852345213294029, 0.0611722506582737, -0.06101740151643753, 0.004118750337511301, -0.021289631724357605, -0.06937889009714127, -0.012038829736411572, -0.021573977544903755, -0.029173091053962708, 0.00666933786123991, -0.03836370259523392, -0.05977156385779381, 0.00833591166883707, 0.022510472685098648, -0.04549732059240341, -0.08122589439153671, -0.0016625397838652134, -0.008383898064494133, 0.02512972801923752, 0.04746837168931961, -0.05676504597067833, 0.009385509416460991, -0.014212938956916332, -0.020778367295861244, 0.042438045144081116, 0.02573748119175434, -0.014891114085912704, -0.02169017307460308, -0.018084144219756126, -0.047552887350320816, -0.008626719936728477, -0.011079424992203712, -0.012924491427838802, -0.04249844327569008, -0.07476164400577545, 0.007137759122997522, 0.021769987419247627, -0.028778478503227234, -0.07092472165822983, 0.008611123077571392, 0.01781080849468708, -0.003901310032233596, -0.02618882991373539, -0.0831524133682251, 0.03603818640112877, 0.010911754332482815, -0.0012382499407976866, -0.039139311760663986, 0.04755005985498428, -0.05207118019461632, -0.013936785981059074, -0.0786462277173996, -0.05767298489809036, 0.0203511044383049, 0.06055782735347748, 0.031246785074472427, -0.051106929779052734, -0.044714681804180145, -0.04498236998915672, -0.05304456502199173, -0.014098143205046654, -0.04213840141892433, -0.023787008598446846, 0.005751380231231451, 0.028857586905360222, -0.025791676715016365, 0.0020179967395961285, 0.04199711233377457, 0.024584706872701645, -0.027940137311816216, 0.040723372250795364, 0.02989497035741806, 0.02912496030330658, 0.03869284689426422, -0.013159184716641903, -0.003434365149587393, 0.03137395903468132, -0.01786971651017666, 0.002776426961645484, -0.022362470626831055, -0.06211473420262337, -0.006751592271029949, -0.05553753674030304, -0.04544702544808388, -0.04213628172874451, -0.05274203047156334, -0.020587624981999397, -0.05348910391330719, -0.06949078291654587, -0.02985064499080181, 0.01940275728702545, 0.009213816374540329, 0.020098615437746048, -0.0396437831223011, 0.02865142934024334, 0.05364763364195824, -0.03490220755338669, -0.016145434230566025, -0.03671625629067421, 0.014454932883381844, -0.06608495116233826, 0.0398811474442482, -0.07265455275774002, 0.025957636535167694, -0.0009648205596022308, -0.032790057361125946, 0.016751067712903023, 0.05432286858558655, -0.053744956851005554, 0.00616529630497098, -0.05870763584971428, -0.025563761591911316, -0.008079473860561848, -0.07265998423099518, -0.01816323585808277, -0.0394059494137764, 0.029660694301128387, -0.04492887109518051, -0.0049855075776577, 0.014324039220809937, 0.07399515062570572, -0.0120457224547863, -0.03744826465845108, 0.004806019831448793, 0.0030005166772753, 0.009020581841468811, 0.004371550865471363, -0.031229261308908463, -0.04090259596705437, -0.05030025541782379, -0.058345161378383636, -0.04648316279053688, 0.003595516085624695, -0.05276937410235405, -0.03856382891535759, 0.004971541464328766, -0.0493650883436203, -0.03828608989715576, 0.009276948869228363, 0.03657585754990578, -0.05864838510751724, 0.03335079178214073, -0.028095684945583344, 0.009616479277610779, 0.00282358773984015 ]
Weyl points (WP) are robust spectral degeneracies, which can not be split by small perturbations, as they are protected by their non-zero topological charge. For larger perturbations, WPs can disappear via pairwise annihilation, where two oppositely charged WPs merge, and the resulting neutral degeneracy disappears. The neutral degeneracy is unstable, meaning that it requires the fine-tuning of the perturbation. Fine-tuning of more than one parameter can lead to more exotic WP mergers. In this work, we reveal and analyze a fundamental connection of the WP mergers and singularity theory: phase boundary points of Weyl phase diagrams, i.e., control parameter values where Weyl point mergers happen, can be classified according to singularity classes of maps between manifolds of equal dimension. We demonstrate this connection on a Weyl--Josephson circuit where the merger of 4 WPs draw a swallowtail singularity, and in a random BdG Hamiltonian which reveal a rich pattern of fold lines and cusp points. Our results predict universal geometrical features of Weyl phase diagrams, and generalize naturally to creation and annihilation of Weyl points in electronic (phononic, magnonic, photonic, etc) band-structure models, where Weyl phase transitions can be triggered by control parameters such as mechanical strain.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05506v1
[ -0.0531218983232975, -0.0011785653186962008, 0.02120518498122692, 0.029478898271918297, 0.01834838278591633, 0.032145291566848755, 0.018443426117300987, 0.044132083654403687, -0.015662824735045433, -0.014282787218689919, -0.03029925748705864, -0.053043629974126816, -0.03430794179439545, -0.06214247643947601, -0.04249076917767525, -0.027123939245939255, 0.07328987866640091, 0.03170090541243553, -0.06388824433088303, 0.040235601365566254, -0.04437793046236038, 0.02398335561156273, -0.009765898808836937, 0.035256579518318176, -0.016970781609416008, -0.009036236442625523, -0.02318105474114418, -0.02543560601770878, -0.06328457593917847, -0.03511356562376022, 0.050466202199459076, 0.02205377258360386, -0.04590918868780136, -0.037243977189064026, -0.022841153666377068, -0.006316875573247671, -0.007290615700185299, 0.03183828294277191, 0.05118854343891144, -0.0477428175508976, 0.003509871196001768, -0.00981577392667532, -0.019262412562966347, 0.021677790209650993, -0.03425851836800575, -0.009733736515045166, -0.039090003818273544, 0.021125853061676025, -0.03293575346469879, -0.06344904005527496, 0.03294557332992554, 0.003412437392398715, 0.03753219544887543, 0.05754236504435539, -0.0593208484351635, 0.000516388681717217, 0.029010897502303123, 0.025308335199952126, -0.03749097138643265, 0.00929131731390953, 0.005153905600309372, -0.01187651976943016, -0.0030853766947984695, -0.02657611109316349, -0.05666496977210045, 0.05129328370094299, -0.05247499793767929, -0.07331445068120956, -0.032747987657785416, -0.035362228751182556, 0.024752529338002205, -0.0658952072262764, 0.01774679869413376, 0.012668238952755928, -0.07653311640024185, 0.02306285686790943, -0.07026895880699158, -0.05124416574835777, 0.0010440908372402191, 0.04354875907301903, -0.01651180535554886, -0.027526354417204857, 0.023592445999383926, -0.011161142028868198, 0.03467223420739174, 0.040546149015426636, 0.023803425952792168, 0.009958459064364433, 0.002167361555621028, -0.05620158836245537, 0.015644526109099388, -0.02727990411221981, -0.04614323005080223, -0.04544719308614731, 0.048212796449661255, -0.01113359909504652, 0.06362234801054001, 0.04204249754548073, 0.018025318160653114, -0.020399663597345352, -0.04623481631278992, -0.05387851595878601, -0.020396670326590538, 0.01915173977613449, -0.017828064039349556, -0.037474624812603, 0.011005357839167118, -0.0008810424478724599, -0.024424754083156586, 0.024894729256629944, 0.01799061894416809, 0.03881864249706268, -0.032272472977638245, -0.041829999536275864, -0.02470848709344864, -0.028805594891309738, 0.05016257241368294, 0.023826662451028824, 0.04073895886540413, -0.03104531392455101, -0.02917960099875927, 0.046998679637908936, 0.011318606324493885, 0.02258235216140747, -0.03872549906373024, 0.008402816019952297, 0.05631214752793312, 0.012830225750803947, -0.01207362674176693, -0.03458208218216896, -0.0371098630130291, -0.03225167840719223, 0.04971297085285187, 0.04160936176776886, 0.028818123042583466, -0.025468701496720314, 0.031231733039021492, -0.029393160715699196, -0.02138839289546013, 0.04380315542221069, 0.00011382051889086142, -0.06088947877287865, -0.016334589570760727, -0.004714254755526781, 0.04357394948601723, 0.05071096122264862, -0.06376171857118607, 0.01899448037147522, 0.022475924342870712, -0.001413727062754333, -0.018410246819257736, -0.028797874227166176, 0.01801077090203762, 0.025047114118933678, 0.0051208180375397205, 0.003958018496632576, 0.052018310874700546, 0.02454708144068718, -0.03243640810251236, -0.014583677053451538, 0.014079909771680832, -0.00830677431076765, 0.0021066467743366957, 0.03507218137383461, 0.007715262472629547, -0.008488454855978489, 0.03127413988113403, -0.04901500791311264, 0.0030544206965714693, -0.029121829196810722, -0.06746348738670349, 0.05599119886755943, 0.009736625477671623, -0.04812876880168915, -0.04566125571727753, -0.015352935530245304, 0.014965660870075226, -0.06700856238603592, 0.021929558366537094, 0.032167281955480576, 0.01423221081495285, 0.037320949137210846, -0.04017322137951851, -0.02586977556347847, -0.04108189791440964, -0.023633118718862534, -0.0805894136428833, 0.03639015555381775, 0.05316720902919769, 0.021908031776547432, -0.026001835241913795, -0.060016222298145294, 0.026001231744885445, 0.0478469580411911, -0.0319039560854435, -0.035954177379608154, 0.033394232392311096, -0.047234732657670975, -0.05441078916192055, 0.010855870321393013, -0.08274348825216293, -0.015422063879668713, -0.027109378948807716, 0.014014789834618568, -0.020724251866340637, -0.029647154733538628, -0.00800380390137434, 0.018549788743257523, -0.04076975956559181, -0.04212114214897156, 0.06199071183800697, 0.02490054816007614, 0.07622260600328445, -0.007356476970016956, 0.015670955181121826, -0.03580659627914429, -0.0930723175406456, -0.005179727915674448, -0.002200318966060877, 0.013440734706819057, 0.014048977755010128, -0.011840724386274815, -0.014014755375683308, -0.026322511956095695, -0.05068424344062805, 0.04168516770005226, 0.06482946872711182, 0.02419661544263363, -0.05197034031152725, -0.020815810188651085, -0.029057100415229797, -0.043132953345775604, -0.034082282334566116, -0.05396376922726631, -0.022807234898209572, -0.017792196944355965, -0.05582894757390022, 0.052803777158260345, -0.000992666115052998, -0.04508199915289879, -0.05796055868268013, -0.00879652425646782, 0.04684020206332207, -0.023754330351948738, -0.027512619271874428, -0.04067165404558182, -0.028057685121893883, 0.009576776064932346, -0.0425967238843441, -0.032698411494493484, 0.028983263298869133, -0.07459117472171783, -0.022370558232069016, -0.03254414722323418, 0.015309247188270092, 0.03683583438396454, -0.06317859888076782, 0.003478558734059334, -0.00903037004172802, 0.039056599140167236, 0.040512483566999435, 0.0005182092427276075, -0.05762976035475731, -0.0030057854019105434, 0.047283243387937546, 0.04039132967591286, -0.06088491529226303, -0.004437685944139957, 0.03933632746338844, -0.03946475312113762, 0.011704618111252785, 0.011707144789397717, 0.061256296932697296, 0.026739832013845444, 0.020593833178281784, -0.008138865232467651, -0.0428256131708622, -0.010177936404943466, 0.017599256709218025, 0.03774449974298477, 0.07657401263713837, 0.016935158520936966, -0.06297970563173294, -0.07580417394638062, 0.0019567152485251427, -0.01873229257762432, 0.011591223068535328, -0.07390829175710678, -0.039301905781030655, -0.05191658064723015, -0.07689642161130905, -0.0093073770403862, -0.033835217356681824, -0.01644398644566536, -0.05259721353650093, -0.048821743577718735, -0.0005055549554526806, -0.016524499282240868, -0.008318074978888035, -0.05219661444425583, -0.06423962116241455, 0.02740667015314102, 0.06313005834817886, 0.006674626842141151, -0.04489125311374664, -0.062309380620718, -0.033389538526535034, 0.033883869647979736, -0.007754318881779909, -0.02756308577954769, 0.017190244048833847, -0.01964220218360424, -0.04253107309341431, 0.00833409745246172, -0.02798454277217388, 0.0153189143165946, 0.022542156279087067, -0.031029874458909035, 0.021857719868421555, -0.035678260028362274, -0.021791797131299973, -0.02456005848944187, -0.03959440812468529, -0.03226979076862335, -0.06637733429670334, -0.0024221811909228563, 0.04930809140205383, 0.06237272545695305, -0.011977924033999443, -0.007845567539334297, -0.044528208673000336, -0.028678670525550842, 0.017927292734384537, -0.04220215231180191, 0.05180821195244789, 0.05706285312771797, -0.05934664234519005, -0.03726362809538841, -0.0017955098301172256, 0.02225686050951481, 0.035165153443813324, 0.038627345114946365, -0.039481502026319504, -0.000669606844894588, 0.05263195559382439, -0.0750376284122467, 0.035694245249032974, 0.042109474539756775, 0.052013643085956573, -0.03160984069108963, -0.02111794985830784, -0.017461484298110008, 0.01633339561522007, 0.024001535028219223, -0.02206525020301342, 0.037612393498420715, 0.005145393777638674, 0.06765449047088623, -0.04817894846200943, -0.041061170399188995, -0.055611997842788696, -0.06910402327775955, -0.06071808934211731, 0.018032440915703773, 0.0033678202889859676, 0.0332898274064064, -0.01189696229994297, 0.03278149664402008, 0.03109358809888363, -0.03419307619333267, 0.07395739108324051, 0.007829435169696808, -0.026592619717121124, 0.012859318405389786, 0.028681740164756775, 0.005322025623172522, -0.02489650994539261, 0.03613903373479843, 0.002970309229567647, -0.03400484472513199, 0.041107162833213806, -0.05937403440475464, 0.007870100438594818, 0.011897416785359383, -0.01884499564766884, 0.052747394889593124, -0.0024716188199818134, -0.025339527055621147, 0.04922579973936081, 0.018763434141874313, 0.03365342691540718, 0.002108866348862648, -0.008630510419607162, 0.027316885069012642, -0.025771187618374825, -0.018017807975411415, 0.0012881088769063354, -0.007764573674649, -0.046790506690740585, 0.030153246596455574, 0.012320148758590221, 0.014344222843647003, -0.02112634852528572, -0.0649162009358406, -0.03943159058690071, -0.03000616282224655, 0.026618069037795067, 0.045626070350408554, -0.020712506026029587, 0.06558530032634735, 0.009399861097335815, -0.03735391050577164, -0.005046342499554157, -0.027031414210796356, -0.034708958119153976, -0.0011764551745727658, -0.011773738078773022, -0.028576456010341644, 0.03307380899786949, -0.04294462874531746, 0.03074725903570652, -0.007303957361727953, -0.0029612891376018524, -0.04918276518583298, 0.0064805252477526665, -0.00892452523112297, 0.012874482199549675, 0.04129860922694206, 0.010824915021657944, 0.007743533700704575, 0.01628166250884533, 0.0017851535230875015, 0.012194238603115082, 0.009362674318253994, 0.005920566152781248, -0.03311072289943695, -0.038910873234272, -0.05632674694061279, -0.06377898156642914, -0.02292686142027378, -0.022350525483489037, 0.05178167298436165, -0.0499521940946579, -0.040514130145311356, 0.001924249459989369, 0.030118292197585106, -0.04395930841565132, -0.01892106793820858, -0.02727530337870121, -0.0173468217253685, -0.06313755363225937, 0.021696805953979492, -0.017509736120700836, -0.0008818907663226128, -0.013043764978647232, 0.04887208342552185, -0.060140591114759445, 0.028535528108477592, -0.005647513084113598, 0.006217442452907562, 0.05304151028394699, 0.013293089345097542, 0.03296053782105446, -0.06601062417030334, -0.049910448491573334, 0.009037373587489128, -0.023581935092806816, -0.0026403190568089485, -0.03609258681535721, 0.030996600165963173, -0.00721126701682806, 0.03992587327957153, -0.07796301692724228, 0.055415887385606766, 0.045346979051828384, -0.04748811572790146, -0.04242647811770439, 0.043596211820840836, -0.04438052326440811, 0.04032803326845169, 0.015743494033813477, 0.012641017325222492, -0.019805574789643288, -0.02846582606434822, 0.03955891355872154, -0.013482816517353058, -0.0370008610188961, -0.0009566599619574845, 0.0421237051486969, 0.02008645050227642, -0.04804744943976402, 0.013696807436645031, -0.01285611279308796, -0.024209771305322647, -0.015187268145382404, -0.003188936272636056, 0.008902402594685555, -0.05552089586853981, -0.055682674050331116, -0.008218660950660706, 0.022293083369731903, 0.02058808133006096, 0.02375958487391472, -0.05072447285056114, 0.0031853890977799892, 0.041520629078149796, -0.04491333290934563, 0.027633000165224075, -0.0000316993027809076, 0.029407206922769547, -0.0052626063115894794, -0.008356091566383839, 0.003954550251364708, -0.0624532550573349, 0.01342704426497221, -0.02621365897357464, 0.025810401886701584, -0.010115139186382294, 0.015357027761638165, 0.025966010987758636, 0.021836936473846436, -0.0425877645611763, -0.04675603657960892, 0.026018623262643814, 0.00026460731169208884, 0.05172206461429596, -0.0680246502161026, 0.020895512774586678, -0.010302999056875706, 0.0355464443564415, 0.03493320569396019, -0.012278994545340538, -0.03490648418664932, -0.03397947922348976, -0.04835674911737442, -0.020438849925994873, 0.021117132157087326, -0.0015229701530188322, -0.050749946385622025, -0.03220701590180397, 0.03638671338558197, -0.015316935256123543, 0.06355457752943039, 0.010226347483694553, 0.004421789664775133, 0.0251483041793108, 0.0013346016639843583, 0.053749505430459976, 0.01136555802077055, -0.02469811961054802, 0.07538148015737534, -0.06962958723306656, 0.023767434060573578, -0.0069772326387465, -0.04386170208454132, -0.029695158824324608, -0.04337572678923607, 0.015859687700867653, 0.028680017217993736, -0.008099356666207314, -0.030520057305693626, 0.03627948462963104, 0.03178250044584274, -0.07473943382501602, 0.017311226576566696, 0.042307816445827484, -0.07211236655712128, -0.007435401435941458, -0.011165452189743519, -0.024355370551347733, -0.032362233847379684, -0.033728957176208496, -0.01309135276824236, -0.05617089942097664, -0.04389767348766327, 0.05227832868695259, 0.002440419513732195, -0.028690025210380554, -0.003677977714687586, 0.022160204127430916, -0.026568736881017685, 0.007360676769167185, -0.027160678058862686, -0.0049896095879375935, -0.02094939351081848, 0.028188828378915787, -0.05846928060054779, -0.003180124331265688, 0.018557898700237274, 0.03819546848535538, -0.06706082820892334, -0.010572770610451698, 0.022496189922094345, -0.004249046556651592, 0.02792702056467533, -0.03544501215219498, -0.04514003545045853, 0.012946113012731075, 0.0018017101101577282, 0.015547778457403183, -0.033182233572006226, 0.021160900592803955, 0.010842802003026009, 0.023646628484129906, -0.03683370351791382, -0.01651245914399624, -0.03899184241890907, -0.0026198914274573326, -0.027784645557403564, -0.006109996233135462, -0.033814139664173126, -0.038710374385118484, 0.010227044112980366, 0.04062877222895622, 0.007604580372571945, 0.016102280467748642, -0.03205403685569763, 0.001588228507898748, -0.0051547084003686905, 0.021732592955231667, -0.028813302516937256, 0.03053736500442028, 0.0055260732769966125, -0.02793130651116371, 0.06389078497886658, -0.05715767666697502, 0.018572377040982246, -0.02189226634800434, -0.05796821415424347, 0.04633140563964844, -0.038279443979263306, -0.06540091335773468, -0.030302559956908226, 0.025163834914565086, -0.061401501297950745, 0.002317416714504361, -0.02758386917412281, -0.04142076149582863, -0.086850106716156, 0.014538840390741825, 0.006009700242429972, -0.020856712013483047, 0.04698096215724945, -0.012944472022354603, 0.044170647859573364, -0.01022664736956358, 0.05704129487276077, 0.0710865929722786, 0.019061509519815445, 0.007537462282925844, -0.038157086819410324, -0.007428816519677639, 0.039239488542079926, -0.0043649254366755486, -0.04429231584072113, -0.010020079091191292, -0.04770597070455551, -0.06442967802286148, 0.03409672901034355, 0.012879066169261932, -0.05682680010795593, -0.005180947482585907, -0.05141834914684296, 0.043069396167993546, 0.031021736562252045, -0.02286257967352867, -0.07973010092973709, 0.023718206211924553, 0.03561626747250557, 0.028044091537594795, -0.004236598964780569, -0.005437748972326517, -0.051720988005399704, -0.010224717669188976, -0.06843922287225723, -0.03300054743885994, 0.00545152323320508, 0.06263440102338791, 0.01219901442527771, -0.027270957827568054, 0.0055213929153978825, -0.03293617069721222, -0.009055660106241703, 0.00173919927328825, -0.05351092293858528, 0.0033357436768710613, 0.019221672788262367, 0.008999412879347801, -0.06456581503152847, 0.029943546280264854, 0.049954868853092194, -0.028091611340641975, -0.004625082481652498, 0.02825314737856388, 0.004796088207513094, -0.027109717950224876, 0.016238968819379807, 0.05349721014499664, -0.028465837240219116, 0.043926507234573364, -0.04463305324316025, 0.021697117015719414, -0.0639675036072731, -0.06132801994681358, 0.013698291964828968, -0.06481092423200607, -0.0027278701309114695, -0.03025016188621521, -0.034184906631708145, -0.05812447518110275, -0.018713675439357758, -0.047279175370931625, 0.02660384215414524, 0.005917694419622421, -0.04144872725009918, 0.04665876552462578, -0.057312555611133575, -0.02583686076104641, 0.019714321941137314, 0.018100447952747345, -0.03543657809495926, 0.016731826588511467, -0.01898343861103058, -0.0620829276740551, 0.028583187609910965, -0.0712662786245346, 0.019185541197657585, -0.02282322570681572, 0.029759062454104424, 0.05239415541291237, 0.03366696089506149, -0.05022665113210678, 0.015688123181462288, -0.03440980985760689, -0.03427199274301529, -0.01186862401664257, -0.07504024356603622, -0.018791550770401955, -0.01570446975529194, 0.0055573019199073315, 0.02628457546234131, 0.029913101345300674, -0.057845525443553925, 0.05464143678545952, 0.019769268110394478, -0.024603700265288353, -0.050316222012043, -0.009862561710178852, -0.025482704862952232, 0.014513424597680569, -0.015303556807339191, -0.05704358220100403, -0.007993577979505062, -0.03414555639028549, 0.03531138598918915, 0.005265605635941029, -0.04202912375330925, 0.017942998558282852, -0.010686716064810753, -0.05359947308897972, -0.01677674613893032, 0.043513111770153046, 0.021160399541258812, 0.008081064559519291, 0.03585352003574371, -0.0010502688819542527, -0.03937472775578499, -0.07225386053323746 ]
This article describes a multi-modal method using simulated Lidar data via ray tracing and image pixel loss with differentiable rendering to optimize an object's position with respect to an observer or some referential objects in a computer graphics scene. Object position optimization is completed using gradient descent with the loss function being influenced by both modalities. Typical object placement optimization is done using image pixel loss with differentiable rendering only, this work shows the use of a second modality (Lidar) leads to faster convergence. This method of fusing sensor input presents a potential usefulness for autonomous vehicles, as these methods can be used to establish the locations of multiple actors in a scene. This article also presents a method for the simulation of multiple types of data to be used in the training of autonomous vehicles.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03177v1
[ -0.05354279279708862, -0.046681661158800125, 0.007579546421766281, 0.004773927852511406, -0.0061169820837676525, -0.03391989693045616, -0.00004917717524222098, -0.0326666422188282, 0.01541274506598711, -0.05566542595624924, -0.055255379527807236, 0.023772217333316803, -0.015684740617871284, -0.037317343056201935, 0.00009380159463034943, 0.030660303309559822, 0.06994525343179703, -0.028009947389364243, -0.07063587009906769, 0.06800476461648941, 0.047323212027549744, -0.021819714456796646, -0.044904954731464386, 0.026969993487000465, -0.04284055903553963, -0.02391354739665985, -0.02009708061814308, 0.043633319437503815, -0.0509834848344326, -0.0018428317271173, 0.031282298266887665, 0.021984592080116272, 0.011844782158732414, -0.03252231702208519, -0.026446811854839325, 0.0020817893091589212, 0.01762966811656952, 0.012112868949770927, 0.03292557969689369, -0.03829733282327652, 0.018528608605265617, -0.010894149541854858, -0.05040249228477478, 0.011145229451358318, -0.02396346628665924, -0.010170681402087212, -0.06819164752960205, 0.026893166825175285, -0.06801271438598633, -0.04037443548440933, 0.0037223671097308397, -0.030354652553796768, 0.014859549701213837, 0.04872531443834305, -0.020058149471879005, 0.032919201999902725, -0.0013718563131988049, 0.027067026123404503, -0.04940160736441612, -0.017364412546157837, 0.04895145818591118, -0.050597403198480606, 0.006732804700732231, -0.036971770226955414, 0.024014711380004883, 0.055539123713970184, -0.026618117466568947, -0.0584673248231411, -0.05212999880313873, -0.034653808921575546, 0.02662687748670578, -0.06829822808504105, 0.001628523226827383, 0.02843109332025051, -0.061992429196834564, -0.06384457647800446, -0.026688694953918457, -0.019357945770025253, 0.005635645240545273, -0.015245351940393448, -0.017720261588692665, 0.06281892210245132, 0.04247492551803589, 0.0616120807826519, -0.026444707065820694, 0.034588806331157684, 0.0519082173705101, -0.004642979241907597, 0.0296108927577734, -0.03839705511927605, 0.011608997359871864, -0.05887379124760628, -0.05981878191232681, 0.049431055784225464, 0.03635471686720848, -0.026499154046177864, 0.05456019937992096, -0.006448781117796898, 0.003034537425264716, 0.010297449305653572, -0.024834323674440384, 0.033681340515613556, -0.026537615805864334, 0.030319832265377045, 0.02457183413207531, -0.057246461510658264, -0.022599006071686745, 0.027385002002120018, -0.02025730162858963, 0.002532945480197668, -0.03364014998078346, -0.03077240101993084, 0.02167663164436817, -0.06151344254612923, -0.04836249724030495, -0.037007227540016174, 0.05200335755944252, -0.052803266793489456, 0.053588129580020905, -0.005624675657600164, 0.00788375735282898, 0.0035955633502453566, 0.008162600919604301, -0.053932446986436844, -0.053558267652988434, -0.032638806849718094, 0.06688147038221359, 0.017953136935830116, -0.005378843750804663, -0.0587238185107708, -0.017239170148968697, 0.04216599836945534, -0.048500996083021164, -0.034117914736270905, 0.04348122701048851, 0.016579562798142433, -0.027592333033680916, -0.04001805931329727, 0.020434552803635597, -0.014219085685908794, 0.009534123353660107, -0.055703673511743546, 0.0037293191999197006, -0.05044431611895561, -0.026118764653801918, 0.03570719435811043, -0.035028643906116486, -0.033285923302173615, -0.033178478479385376, 0.02138381078839302, -0.011081621050834656, -0.006246956530958414, 0.03719351440668106, 0.034092891961336136, -0.03281411901116371, -0.0320826917886734, 0.05260126292705536, -0.03502068668603897, -0.06020075082778931, -0.0027527729980647564, -0.011741514317691326, 0.018462467938661575, -0.015143909491598606, -0.022704966366291046, 0.035262126475572586, -0.012641499750316143, 0.039650190621614456, 0.009260703809559345, 0.019403116777539253, 0.030339261516928673, -0.015941808000206947, -0.005003129597753286, -0.012767135165631771, -0.033979382365942, -0.03751462697982788, 0.003615517634898424, -0.045874372124671936, -0.04262009263038635, -0.03704957291483879, -0.029452674090862274, 0.008856236934661865, 0.024251502007246017, 0.04815391078591347, 0.023125039413571358, -0.03608589991927147, -0.0019287141039967537, -0.07813918590545654, -0.04540060833096504, 0.013323669321835041, 0.044303543865680695, -0.005723757669329643, -0.03795521333813667, 0.018985342234373093, -0.004774428904056549, -0.013504107482731342, -0.03842506557703018, -0.03975587338209152, -0.0441703163087368, 0.023714056238532066, 0.046432014554739, -0.0710928663611412, -0.013402550481259823, -0.0575883649289608, -0.01546163484454155, -0.022272417321801186, -0.07560622692108154, 0.0007727280026301742, 0.045868419110774994, -0.029192717745900154, 0.04130396991968155, 0.05203414708375931, 0.06762130558490753, 0.06217961758375168, -0.04192233458161354, 0.02430369146168232, 0.019157404080033302, -0.08241728693246841, 0.01471396628767252, -0.0370001383125782, 0.008515728637576103, 0.03538931906223297, 0.018675653263926506, -0.02163994126021862, -0.03377186506986618, -0.038305044174194336, 0.03983624279499054, 0.045089442282915115, -0.027045417577028275, -0.06061038747429848, -0.025187799707055092, -0.014878871850669384, -0.05725232511758804, -0.024577045813202858, -0.06618800759315491, -0.013122095726430416, 0.002297312719747424, -0.013090361841022968, -0.006535111926496029, 0.014018189162015915, 0.029817013069987297, -0.04850782826542854, -0.012432103976607323, 0.03245207294821739, -0.01929771713912487, -0.05018160864710808, -0.037273891270160675, 0.004332206677645445, 0.028883088380098343, 0.009488504379987717, -0.017389696091413498, -0.04601847380399704, -0.04138350114226341, -0.03542359545826912, -0.016599737107753754, 0.0538264662027359, 0.02908899262547493, -0.03610605001449585, 0.017087014392018318, -0.053678739815950394, 0.05877631530165672, 0.03576557710766792, 0.03237224742770195, -0.0772925615310669, 0.028308814391493797, -0.016140887513756752, 0.027113251388072968, -0.025443680584430695, -0.05193144083023071, 0.033953823149204254, -0.034516237676143646, -0.01858295127749443, 0.00117031903937459, -0.0007524702814407647, -0.013586806133389473, 0.028798550367355347, -0.034702520817518234, -0.032057974487543106, -0.03882111981511116, 0.012809617444872856, 0.03912260755896568, 0.045322202146053314, 0.027301467955112457, 0.02094133384525776, -0.03785765543580055, 0.0018696956103667617, -0.07299857586622238, 0.02869650349020958, -0.072999507188797, -0.06421788781881332, -0.052193786948919296, -0.06956411153078079, -0.014104848727583885, -0.03792310133576393, -0.03738069534301758, -0.03947683423757553, -0.06858961284160614, -0.04535569250583649, 0.03516359627246857, 0.02710934728384018, 0.009880718775093555, -0.05233161151409149, -0.002931659808382392, 0.035062748938798904, -0.011690580286085606, -0.027633409947156906, -0.06265074014663696, -0.0524420291185379, -0.011524391360580921, 0.0325506366789341, -0.04055647552013397, -0.0384846031665802, 0.054092127829790115, -0.04746632277965546, 0.008552292361855507, 0.022262314334511757, 0.00123747275210917, -0.01783859170973301, -0.011990794911980629, -0.028856225311756134, 0.012574856169521809, 0.03954251855611801, -0.021104412153363228, 0.033026643097400665, -0.04450429603457451, -0.05257547274231911, -0.025518804788589478, 0.017715953290462494, 0.04005345702171326, -0.048470743000507355, -0.013419907540082932, -0.032353173941373825, -0.015681006014347076, 0.04549792408943176, -0.022331997752189636, 0.039391350001096725, -0.023681307211518288, -0.018908197060227394, -0.048928700387477875, -0.03640006482601166, -0.035541731864213943, 0.032182302325963974, -0.025511015206575394, -0.045686233788728714, -0.018098998814821243, -0.013610119000077248, -0.08232197910547256, -0.011251900345087051, 0.016358632594347, 0.07446032762527466, -0.0003095815482083708, 0.003410638775676489, -0.005001518409699202, -0.022023430094122887, -0.007934188470244408, 0.001661062939092517, 0.025024542585015297, 0.014655888080596924, 0.03047475963830948, -0.032161109149456024, -0.06878194957971573, -0.03939696401357651, -0.06893711537122726, -0.05954097956418991, 0.018842648714780807, 0.020842380821704865, -0.021919939666986465, 0.03713808208703995, -0.0488465279340744, 0.02432987093925476, 0.015386850573122501, 0.003623022697865963, -0.007956367917358875, 0.0038703903555870056, 0.02809588611125946, -0.06234605610370636, 0.005221495404839516, 0.030968621373176575, -0.02815830335021019, -0.023924686014652252, -0.030538802966475487, 0.05214740335941315, -0.0460638552904129, 0.053417857736349106, -0.0021194652654230595, -0.0010363258188590407, 0.006876110564917326, 0.04533590003848076, 0.003076167544350028, 0.04440505430102348, 0.02080116607248783, -0.01893594115972519, 0.00916493870317936, 0.007228008005768061, 0.006761666387319565, -0.011082279495894909, -0.05850678309798241, -0.0095609650015831, -0.00625046668574214, -0.025454081594944, -0.015748918056488037, -0.014427651651203632, -0.01661340519785881, 0.012359502725303173, -0.07676992565393448, 0.024475162848830223, -0.05564158037304878, 0.030863214284181595, -0.04152011126279831, -0.06634259968996048, 0.06967546790838242, -0.06275900453329086, 0.0024561944883316755, -0.05758392810821533, -0.004938638303428888, -0.03327033296227455, -0.04315405711531639, -0.0333181731402874, -0.07074873149394989, -0.016334183514118195, -0.023315370082855225, 0.05280078202486038, 0.015633584931492805, -0.004772447049617767, -0.04704834148287773, -0.06391695141792297, 0.021059447899460793, 0.024703143164515495, 0.026077711954712868, -0.01584070362150669, -0.008079960942268372, 0.04363754391670227, -0.007079065777361393, -0.015063058584928513, -0.011913374997675419, -0.0246676504611969, -0.029049701988697052, 0.05968773737549782, -0.043153852224349976, 0.006897592917084694, 0.022760026156902313, -0.005341292358934879, 0.03909219056367874, -0.01800612546503544, -0.040710270404815674, -0.013922910206019878, 0.025798475369811058, -0.04346109554171562, -0.06183155998587608, -0.03192339092493057, 0.00849422812461853, -0.029150890186429024, 0.025150945410132408, 0.013720063492655754, -0.003188502509146929, 0.04900621622800827, -0.0062339832074940205, 0.025212181732058525, -0.011758211068809032, -0.015056510455906391, 0.02948947437107563, 0.03032565489411354, 0.026410652324557304, -0.004957849625498056, -0.05166503041982651, -0.08062299340963364, 0.060207799077034, 0.007173577789217234, 0.010635605081915855, -0.015851855278015137, -0.0311092808842659, 0.021212786436080933, 0.02810421772301197, -0.06481703370809555, 0.0031228498555719852, 0.06650608032941818, 0.011983870528638363, 0.02430226095020771, 0.03487398475408554, -0.010651795193552971, 0.05892369523644447, 0.005493168719112873, -0.03177284076809883, 0.057047322392463684, -0.02933572046458721, -0.04341842606663704, -0.029011493548750877, -0.03830568119883537, -0.009193566627800465, 0.052194368094205856, -0.023184381425380707, -0.02284994162619114, -0.04499252140522003, -0.020861076191067696, 0.01769993267953396, -0.007846054621040821, 0.014655726961791515, -0.024600492790341377, -0.04395740479230881, -0.048261065036058426, 0.022106686607003212, -0.018500391393899918, 0.0037492208648473024, -0.03820633515715599, -0.013153323903679848, 0.021236587315797806, 0.042847536504268646, 0.017445158213377, -0.02257653698325157, 0.007793521974235773, -0.02454984188079834, -0.006915316451340914, -0.03808874264359474, 0.0017030928283929825, -0.0576457753777504, -0.021908709779381752, 0.011378555558621883, 0.037751831114292145, 0.02611430175602436, 0.06413447111845016, 0.03142819181084633, 0.0656924620270729, -0.054654497653245926, -0.007383524905890226, -0.002406831830739975, -0.027912555262446404, 0.025400465354323387, -0.029094727709889412, 0.05466198921203613, 0.01202524732798338, 0.004139753989875317, -0.025823820382356644, -0.003146320814266801, 0.04479045793414116, 0.00021451916836667806, -0.03692363202571869, -0.029775355011224747, 0.0445428304374218, -0.0526469349861145, -0.05891101062297821, 0.027631249278783798, 0.015539340674877167, -0.037023041397333145, -0.00019777864508796483, 0.0391678549349308, -0.01281234435737133, 0.03832632303237915, 0.01269897073507309, -0.004625039175152779, -0.04777317866683006, 0.04732572287321091, 0.047702357172966, -0.03176424652338028, -0.03199344873428345, -0.0352695994079113, -0.06605001538991928, 0.03723962977528572, 0.012627576477825642, 0.02537684142589569, 0.0006483548204414546, 0.01492407824844122, -0.053673192858695984, 0.030530516058206558, -0.019916465505957603, -0.0591503344476223, 0.004027130547910929, 0.018757544457912445, -0.04584375023841858, -0.03801599517464638, 0.001391165773384273, -0.039087746292352676, 0.021711278706789017, 0.028234021738171577, -0.0354100726544857, 0.022072292864322662, -0.04916418343782425, 0.05081875994801521, 0.07676134258508682, 0.004543716087937355, -0.007197401020675898, 0.026683500036597252, -0.061068955808877945, -0.03263314440846443, -0.0357925109565258, 0.011525332927703857, -0.007690315134823322, 0.011846499517560005, 0.019077667966485023, -0.05524950847029686, -0.06670385599136353, 0.05099831521511078, -0.05032789334654808, -0.053872719407081604, 0.03503577783703804, 0.030198464170098305, 0.04620230197906494, -0.044186417013406754, -0.03159602731466293, 0.0041440753266215324, -0.036822255700826645, 0.03905336558818817, -0.03317945450544357, 0.0035325349308550358, -0.002505744341760874, 0.026831205934286118, 0.01804318279027939, -0.059947382658720016, 0.0006950841634534299, -0.05685397982597351, -0.0454130619764328, 0.025042660534381866, -0.07615895569324493, 0.014781726524233818, 0.00675329240038991, 0.029922449961304665, 0.041798222810029984, 0.060374680906534195, -0.04758094251155853, -0.010682925581932068, -0.0029333047568798065, 0.036809906363487244, -0.022650228813290596, 0.01060475129634142, 0.035281822085380554, -0.036590758711099625, 0.03410778567194939, -0.0107925059273839, 0.016229236498475075, 0.01957414485514164, 0.011023514904081821, 0.019005263224244118, -0.027700098231434822, -0.0575685054063797, -0.04764420539140701, -0.010482298210263252, -0.03523911535739899, -0.00026026839623227715, 0.00396199943497777, -0.04852200672030449, -0.05574239790439606, -0.00992346741259098, -0.04761221259832382, 0.010218916460871696, 0.005300439428538084, 0.016460059210658073, 0.044725481420755386, -0.02310103178024292, 0.05618005618453026, 0.037598785012960434, -0.019142720848321915, 0.034230731427669525, -0.05970196798443794, -0.05002022162079811, -0.015263451263308525, -0.037630632519721985, -0.06727110594511032, -0.007012540474534035, 0.001804059837013483, -0.047200772911310196, 0.02895798347890377, 0.02200939692556858, -0.012919280678033829, -0.015185187570750713, -0.06478869169950485, -0.028845863416790962, -0.06312147527933121, -0.06231166049838066, -0.06270606815814972, 0.004241432528942823, 0.02990587055683136, -0.03115164488554001, -0.02677810937166214, -0.005413277540355921, -0.03992311656475067, -0.0011250167153775692, -0.07653911411762238, 0.023541711270809174, 0.04238345846533775, 0.03587164729833603, -0.025847813114523888, -0.0702100545167923, 0.01842990145087242, -0.02562657557427883, -0.021940503269433975, 0.004760772455483675, 0.055363744497299194, -0.006937966216355562, 0.018320022150874138, -0.0015821383567526937, -0.057389646768569946, -0.05174151062965393, 0.022841263562440872, -0.0108559625223279, -0.033951710909605026, 0.026243112981319427, 0.03486078605055809, 0.018991725519299507, -0.04719182476401329, 0.06951232254505157, 0.017236921936273575, 0.05147532746195793, -0.05472851172089577, 0.030596081167459488, -0.0463084913790226, -0.06496714800596237, 0.00207536737434566, -0.05320480093359947, -0.0049812523648142815, -0.0072452835738658905, -0.0190628282725811, -0.02217167429625988, -0.04214699566364288, -0.038597818464040756, 0.0071298833936452866, 0.016582658514380455, -0.05523907393217087, 0.0035364499781280756, -0.033539287745952606, -0.006142288446426392, -0.025011496618390083, -0.04847622662782669, 0.02515479363501072, 0.006579855922609568, 0.030117349699139595, 0.02059992589056492, 0.04655276611447334, -0.06047319248318672, 0.010933480225503445, -0.04591725394129753, -0.0361139290034771, -0.020477168262004852, 0.05341794714331627, -0.008429232984781265, -0.01651933416724205, -0.04785827174782753, -0.035497721284627914, -0.01851944997906685, -0.06691738963127136, -0.03970424085855484, -0.02464110217988491, 0.016767075285315514, -0.014218548312783241, 0.01914997026324272, -0.06034651771187782, 0.04460244998335838, 0.04363236948847771, 0.031987305730581284, -0.006366015411913395, 0.03058827482163906, 0.02030598558485508, 0.03864840418100357, -0.010364423505961895, 0.03752417489886284, -0.011150394566357136, 0.01481249276548624, 0.0038008661940693855, -0.04258056730031967, -0.03144843503832817, 0.030362199991941452, 0.006432611960917711, -0.054354388266801834, 0.0269502904266119, 0.04711076244711876, -0.008352912031114101, -0.03240824490785599, -0.01887361705303192, 0.032236553728580475, -0.01430431380867958, -0.06072800233960152 ]
Harmful Algal and Cyanobacterial Blooms (HABs), occurring in inland and maritime waters, pose threats to natural environments by producing toxins that affect human and animal health. In the past, HABs have been assessed mainly by the manual collection and subsequent analysis of water samples and occasionally by automatic instruments that acquire information from fixed locations. These procedures do not provide data with the desirable spatial and temporal resolution to anticipate the formation of HABs. Hence, new tools and technologies are needed to efficiently detect, characterize and respond to HABs that threaten water quality. It is essential nowadays when the world's water supply is under tremendous pressure because of climate change, overexploitation, and pollution. This paper introduces DEVS-BLOOM, a novel framework for real-time monitoring and management of HABs. Its purpose is to support high-performance hazard detection with Model Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) and Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) infrastructure for dynamic environments.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04618v1
[ -0.039603639394044876, -0.05062177777290344, 0.01872720569372177, -0.01598004437983036, 0.016095779836177826, 0.014178524725139141, -0.014701222069561481, -0.03144500404596329, -0.019407369196414948, -0.012749100103974342, -0.06632733345031738, 0.023908019065856934, -0.016268281266093254, -0.05138259008526802, -0.05718676373362541, 0.029969502240419388, 0.05361330136656761, 0.008883971720933914, -0.027273019775748253, 0.05452049896121025, 0.006861806381493807, -0.027949927374720573, -0.03894460201263428, 0.014165419153869152, 0.048227109014987946, -0.013093656860291958, -0.030322358012199402, 0.03787276893854141, -0.03374793753027916, -0.02059812657535076, 0.04996350407600403, -0.06199852377176285, -0.022743351757526398, -0.05020240694284439, -0.054674986749887466, -0.002309006405994296, -0.04438943415880203, 0.046800605952739716, 0.014637814834713936, -0.03631822392344475, 0.06782974302768707, -0.030530031770467758, -0.033275116235017776, -0.024495353922247887, -0.05013059452176094, -0.011226734146475792, -0.0512942299246788, 0.015501203015446663, -0.08185715228319168, -0.048163026571273804, 0.031802721321582794, 0.02213025651872158, 0.006582586094737053, 0.0688474103808403, -0.04820012301206589, -0.049485161900520325, 0.007194092497229576, -0.0035045132972300053, -0.0494283027946949, 0.028141656890511513, 0.03491609916090965, -0.004693503025919199, 0.030449463054537773, 0.017662858590483665, -0.0006021675653755665, 0.06570253521203995, -0.03332109749317169, -0.009683660231530666, -0.0030642300844192505, -0.07029406726360321, 0.021323619410395622, -0.040494050830602646, 0.03159218654036522, 0.003981615416705608, -0.0016763920430094004, -0.022059455513954163, 0.0004667878383770585, -0.019862113520503044, 0.009143752977252007, 0.061082370579242706, -0.0314166285097599, 0.0157544557005167, 0.017608867958188057, 0.0330619178712368, 0.029524460434913635, 0.0020150255877524614, 0.003463281551375985, -0.05536683648824692, 0.0028243456035852432, -0.04582767188549042, 0.0599520206451416, -0.05157678946852684, -0.047843996435403824, -0.05895929038524628, 0.05931325629353523, -0.012623997405171394, 0.033471331000328064, 0.061140961945056915, 0.018026912584900856, -0.05536695197224617, -0.015523508191108704, 0.026123223826289177, -0.005827410612255335, 0.06217058748006821, -0.005317952949553728, -0.043407972902059555, 0.01379682682454586, -0.0023839587811380625, 0.006101338658481836, -0.06637195497751236, -0.02946300059556961, -0.0038979430682957172, -0.04058745875954628, -0.07677751779556274, -0.07996372878551483, -0.053845178335905075, 0.01923833042383194, -0.03796733170747757, 0.03135230392217636, 0.0038446083199232817, -0.08041519671678543, 0.051491525024175644, 0.048448093235492706, 0.043816376477479935, 0.011048076674342155, 0.015595326200127602, 0.05095953866839409, 0.01563858613371849, 0.010969238355755806, 0.01289274264127016, -0.03363632410764694, 0.06403513252735138, -0.012743543833494186, -0.026291562244296074, 0.008798057213425636, -0.005006459541618824, -0.012161964550614357, -0.02609337866306305, -0.024268778041005135, -0.001299221534281969, -0.006669271271675825, -0.011763270013034344, 0.030068477615714073, -0.004391888156533241, 0.008030036464333534, 0.028772952035069466, -0.0023322938941419125, -0.03677218034863472, 0.012353207916021347, -0.030237656086683273, 0.03259159252047539, 0.010486559011042118, 0.03410487622022629, 0.021381797268986702, 0.0565757192671299, -0.043517861515283585, 0.01805059425532818, -0.02436576783657074, -0.05183195322751999, 0.009112436324357986, 0.02996329963207245, -0.023940719664096832, 0.012145868502557278, 0.0038898023776710033, 0.007655133493244648, -0.0007400971953757107, 0.01706671714782715, -0.024448726326227188, 0.03464120998978615, 0.0030756674241274595, -0.024432821199297905, -0.029491804540157318, -0.045780546963214874, 0.0020298922900110483, -0.025035209953784943, -0.010012292303144932, 0.03296132758259773, -0.054102495312690735, -0.027748966589570045, -0.01713833026587963, -0.0005217385478317738, 0.00505710719153285, -0.04456866905093193, 0.026705525815486908, -0.032538339495658875, 0.03281855210661888, -0.08920376747846603, -0.026039475575089455, 0.03798797354102135, 0.013478276319801807, -0.06556130200624466, -0.0283930953592062, -0.022038521245121956, -0.046294573694467545, -0.05534911900758743, -0.01702585257589817, 0.04404692351818085, -0.08041419088840485, 0.023953445255756378, -0.01600266806781292, -0.09084956347942352, 0.007067269179970026, -0.06790029257535934, 0.013105642050504684, 0.03946352377533913, -0.08149755001068115, -0.017312077805399895, 0.04908858984708786, 0.00008166285988409072, 0.019121436402201653, 0.03484150767326355, -0.006805136799812317, 0.04853825643658638, 0.042757924646139145, -0.01506851427257061, 0.006061190739274025, -0.10738785564899445, 0.04556744173169136, 0.04292793199419975, 0.005536610726267099, 0.06491729617118835, 0.010817787609994411, 0.026640210300683975, 0.012787584215402603, -0.017089173197746277, 0.013529744930565357, 0.06000763550400734, -0.06406335532665253, -0.04687730222940445, -0.07291538268327713, -0.06060948967933655, -0.031667906790971756, -0.034198082983493805, -0.05812307074666023, -0.01409151405096054, -0.06267283856868744, -0.020057694986462593, 0.0036259235348552465, -0.04897819459438324, -0.020857468247413635, -0.011342049576342106, 0.0032271051313728094, 0.04989318549633026, -0.03682873025536537, -0.052709534764289856, -0.01590999960899353, -0.010269776917994022, 0.009663752280175686, -0.03913439065217972, -0.004688074346631765, -0.0048050046898424625, -0.04823896288871765, -0.02100967802107334, -0.05058945342898369, -0.0018790749600157142, 0.020637625828385353, -0.06443051993846893, 0.014566068537533283, -0.03850701451301575, 0.04307162016630173, 0.03898586705327034, 0.036029186099767685, -0.04064814746379852, -0.0258498415350914, 0.04546809941530228, 0.024287953972816467, 0.03193790093064308, -0.009669803082942963, -0.004206136334687471, 0.01566476933658123, 0.035856280475854874, 0.03267119079828262, 0.07342605292797089, -0.006902270019054413, -0.00023271777899935842, 0.035294413566589355, 0.012805272825062275, 0.031619757413864136, 0.03703514114022255, 0.010694766417145729, 0.03736360743641853, 0.007409641984850168, 0.006962732411921024, -0.06270914524793625, 0.011267966590821743, -0.013738220557570457, -0.01582883857190609, -0.03371591120958328, -0.02050803415477276, -0.01929822377860546, -0.056200023740530014, -0.012280584312975407, 0.007575266528874636, -0.04387243837118149, -0.019172759726643562, -0.03809461370110512, -0.03528277948498726, -0.04349023103713989, 0.06789383292198181, -0.02115352265536785, -0.04719847813248634, -0.0028436060529202223, 0.05659585818648338, 0.03230724483728409, -0.00398199912160635, 0.01504325307905674, -0.0329429991543293, -0.04871733486652374, 0.009960928000509739, -0.019664688035845757, -0.016610227525234222, 0.012160949409008026, 0.0037442089524120092, 0.03715670853853226, 0.028577664867043495, 0.018760334700345993, 0.01783202961087227, -0.01583719812333584, -0.02204778976738453, -0.01824789121747017, -0.004271642304956913, 0.018420295789837837, 0.012722750194370747, -0.014856848865747452, -0.04598148167133331, -0.05248752981424332, 0.03504568710923195, 0.017258495092391968, 0.04181806743144989, -0.04408811405301094, 0.015846215188503265, 0.017094705253839493, -0.03930965065956116, 0.04245852306485176, 0.02840622141957283, 0.01669500768184662, -0.04877356067299843, -0.034217897802591324, -0.013050679117441177, 0.011244983412325382, -0.011840750463306904, 0.022659460082650185, -0.015187066048383713, 0.005640445742756128, 0.007748027797788382, -0.07069698721170425, 0.024668293073773384, 0.02944558672606945, 0.08181559294462204, 0.062415216118097305, 0.01561648678034544, 0.005033118184655905, -0.002201923867687583, 0.011425768956542015, 0.008492575958371162, 0.04447917640209198, 0.052956148982048035, 0.043598320335149765, -0.006241567432880402, -0.013302760198712349, 0.029324017465114594, -0.05192634090781212, -0.061499208211898804, 0.0019288455368950963, 0.025304920971393585, 0.06100383400917053, 0.019693437963724136, -0.06699225306510925, 0.02285335212945938, -0.01400096993893385, 0.033640600740909576, -0.004333890043199062, -0.03331705927848816, 0.048150330781936646, -0.030537083745002747, 0.03672993928194046, -0.012558264657855034, -0.032944031059741974, 0.02210110053420067, -0.06034308299422264, -0.01715630665421486, -0.045668989419937134, 0.02355077676475048, 0.017958099022507668, -0.028363103047013283, 0.0247668344527483, 0.031879398971796036, -0.00925658643245697, 0.010774328373372555, -0.017059484496712685, -0.051878541707992554, -0.024357033893465996, -0.03514814376831055, -0.037446968257427216, -0.006594072096049786, 0.003024892183020711, -0.019907161593437195, 0.015124033205211163, -0.043191272765398026, -0.007814735174179077, -0.009641943499445915, -0.016682788729667664, -0.010785994119942188, -0.07067415863275528, 0.022142332047224045, -0.03631279990077019, -0.03715280815958977, 0.011828120797872543, 0.017609748989343643, 0.036055002361536026, -0.023114025592803955, -0.02150525152683258, -0.06740130484104156, -0.000049084279453381896, -0.012874442152678967, -0.020652398467063904, 0.05204916000366211, -0.06587105989456177, 0.016534872353076935, -0.0563134141266346, 0.05755139887332916, -0.0009394336957484484, 0.007621990516781807, -0.023149488493800163, -0.004857141058892012, -0.012755351141095161, -0.04600811004638672, 0.056761305779218674, -0.006338745821267366, -0.005735932383686304, -0.02709372527897358, 0.01790030673146248, 0.008618097752332687, -0.01054963655769825, 0.038200706243515015, -0.0435115247964859, 0.0071262335404753685, -0.04025477170944214, 0.0004936126642860472, 0.0027498635463416576, -0.027828527614474297, 0.07032204419374466, -0.0032915365882217884, -0.010384893976151943, 0.033982452005147934, 0.0337638221681118, 0.025981104001402855, -0.033033452928066254, -0.022862931713461876, -0.04390024393796921, -0.04568098857998848, -0.03254074230790138, 0.03506181016564369, 0.01659568026661873, -0.04923027381300926, 0.05133365839719772, 0.02376953512430191, 0.004309133626520634, -0.03134191781282425, 0.008695870637893677, 0.013819451443850994, 0.03285859897732735, -0.03328917920589447, -0.01899716444313526, -0.02735758014023304, 0.018850307911634445, -0.020846951752901077, -0.018153155222535133, -0.03937043994665146, 0.03845473378896713, 0.05543031916022301, 0.035022735595703125, -0.06508299708366394, 0.03768733888864517, 0.05088728666305542, 0.016064371913671494, -0.03414471819996834, 0.02430610917508602, 0.07197486609220505, 0.05810730159282684, -0.05928465351462364, 0.030540768057107925, 0.02089928463101387, -0.036168865859508514, 0.019145051017403603, 0.033521316945552826, -0.027732858434319496, -0.0010863725328817964, 0.01523943804204464, -0.02250782772898674, -0.07502923160791397, -0.030866973102092743, 0.020219560712575912, 0.02990972436964512, -0.060003332793712616, -0.022989563643932343, 0.025060761719942093, -0.04882507026195526, -0.010745451785624027, -0.015034273266792297, 0.016055969521403313, 0.0227727759629488, 0.03634319826960564, -0.07149678468704224, -0.01450405828654766, -0.0034366860054433346, -0.008420027792453766, 0.03937332704663277, 0.023154031485319138, 0.018819188699126244, -0.03109525702893734, -0.018607426434755325, 0.007837379351258278, -0.07302046567201614, -0.04024878144264221, -0.06774380058050156, 0.022532321512699127, 0.058652546256780624, 0.024502363055944443, 0.010924860835075378, 0.00627086590975523, 0.0022205025888979435, -0.021693747490644455, 0.015083600766956806, -0.04355892911553383, -0.022551879286766052, -0.03392121568322182, 0.04071870818734169, -0.020471116527915, 0.006350668612867594, -0.006569084711372852, 0.03813455253839493, 0.020423920825123787, 0.01664401777088642, -0.019846074283123016, -0.06251921504735947, 0.006609785370528698, -0.039094872772693634, -0.04911688342690468, 0.04890677332878113, 0.06198033317923546, -0.0423736609518528, 0.054627034813165665, -0.04463197663426399, -0.02581966482102871, 0.060748141258955, -0.03541610762476921, -0.01800783909857273, -0.016697367653250694, -0.007610570173710585, 0.06134521961212158, -0.021357664838433266, 0.05389681085944176, 0.03216591477394104, -0.012470172718167305, -0.008386164903640747, -0.07096448540687561, 0.02036384679377079, 0.002744504949077964, -0.007590561173856258, -0.03778468444943428, 0.043208736926317215, 0.03649695962667465, -0.07562236487865448, 0.0404806062579155, -0.04345470666885376, -0.06519035995006561, 0.027546055614948273, -0.013485206291079521, 0.037773437798023224, -0.036479998379945755, 0.07014109194278717, 0.0019075784366577864, 0.037997353821992874, -0.032093144953250885, 0.07445219159126282, 0.03213569521903992, 0.017785612493753433, -0.02804584614932537, -0.02441338449716568, -0.030697474256157875, 0.006074659992009401, 0.025815065950155258, -0.05108256638050079, 0.02090473286807537, 0.03718007728457451, 0.05015666037797928, 0.03919602185487747, -0.046220242977142334, 0.04645309969782829, -0.03037048503756523, 0.01588524505496025, 0.007267913315445185, -0.03621521219611168, 0.08185266703367233, 0.030052313581109047, -0.03628135472536087, -0.02656557969748974, -0.026766512542963028, -0.009364910423755646, -0.020278679206967354, -0.03231395408511162, -0.04141426831483841, 0.028721598908305168, 0.01005468051880598, -0.03785637766122818, 0.038112375885248184, -0.03762267902493477, -0.04734879732131958, 0.030295182019472122, -0.04161674901843071, -0.011617712676525116, -0.027753418311476707, -0.03793008252978325, 0.032954953610897064, -0.014886707998812199, -0.04088647663593292, -0.014220014214515686, 0.014027568511664867, -0.03000984713435173, 0.02683718316257, 0.013354741968214512, 0.06775099784135818, 0.0008721917984075844, 0.04018114134669304, -0.023816000670194626, -0.008312719874083996, -0.028115784749388695, -0.035456717014312744, 0.036924220621585846, -0.024496188387274742, -0.07243376225233078, -0.027805227786302567, 0.047755416482686996, 0.013649762608110905, 0.02549678459763527, 0.04183308035135269, -0.07848537713289261, -0.0035143685527145863, 0.01326747052371502, 0.009664329700171947, -0.008291850797832012, 0.029852941632270813, 0.04084927588701248, 0.057199131697416306, -0.010863269679248333, 0.0028471776749938726, -0.00648061977699399, 0.025248300284147263, 0.028389791026711464, -0.009891936555504799, -0.04441692680120468, -0.013455222360789776, 0.042765431106090546, -0.025998631492257118, 0.00983758457005024, -0.027690066024661064, -0.07283302396535873, 0.015257203951478004, 0.04829871281981468, -0.055306971073150635, -0.024060655385255814, -0.04842052236199379, 0.033898111432790756, 0.03847353532910347, -0.034943755716085434, -0.02214162051677704, -0.035597916692495346, -0.01622905768454075, -0.024168463423848152, 0.016072174534201622, -0.007279062643647194, -0.029109980911016464, 0.004713945556432009, -0.09071546792984009, 0.021599803119897842, -0.017768898978829384, 0.0445098951458931, 0.010999456979334354, -0.008579268120229244, -0.0036442307755351067, -0.04758497327566147, -0.024555673822760582, 0.02278698980808258, -0.03967372700572014, -0.02797461859881878, 0.04357317462563515, 0.055475637316703796, -0.07087121158838272, -0.03845130652189255, -0.03998410329222679, 0.024035267531871796, 0.04498701170086861, 0.018192896619439125, 0.02043020911514759, -0.04166220501065254, -0.007907247170805931, 0.03187078610062599, -0.056563567370176315, 0.01945740170776844, -0.07290636003017426, 0.06093011423945427, -0.022664960473775864, -0.05601681396365166, 0.014345097355544567, -0.027848053723573685, 0.04620787128806114, 0.013671373017132282, -0.0015687273116782308, 0.02723836340010166, -0.024308057501912117, -0.0657603070139885, 0.028598716482520103, -0.01467319019138813, 0.026706060394644737, 0.07457827031612396, -0.05479101091623306, 0.0022719737607985735, -0.042829547077417374, 0.0019239544635638595, -0.06687507778406143, 0.012733694165945053, 0.045138318091630936, -0.06391949951648712, -0.035015445202589035, -0.04541716352105141, -0.015659887343645096, 0.011048264801502228, 0.049935270100831985, -0.05052255094051361, 0.06597764790058136, -0.014809283427894115, -0.018211133778095245, -0.05979173630475998, -0.02165752276778221, -0.02303948812186718, -0.023096637800335884, -0.057050444185733795, -0.023498762398958206, 0.03377432003617287, 0.022048665210604668, 0.020193273201584816, 0.014781245961785316, 0.0441812202334404, -0.015193803235888481, 0.032031480222940445, 0.020244400948286057, -0.04133813828229904, -0.04138697683811188, 0.05675578862428665, 0.03499355912208557, -0.03279244899749756, -0.045741498470306396, 0.01769372634589672, -0.018305117264389992, -0.009203952737152576, -0.025203580036759377, -0.024690642952919006, -0.03832019492983818, -0.030848883092403412, 0.016771549358963966, -0.007248746231198311, 0.006152487825602293, -0.014117586426436901, -0.015572483651340008, 0.04999252036213875, -0.04595755413174629, -0.03942631930112839 ]
We provide the results of pattern recognition experiments on mathematical expressions. We give a few examples of conjectured results. None of which was thoroughly checked for novelty. We did not attempt to prove all the relations found and focused on their generation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.01624v1
[ -0.0384921170771122, 0.0029291603714227676, 0.009328743442893028, -0.012380748055875301, 0.026215292513370514, -0.013377607800066471, -0.022944187745451927, -0.005472396966069937, -0.0049988762475550175, -0.03455132246017456, -0.05902630835771561, -0.05377858877182007, -0.013285038992762566, -0.05396881327033043, -0.009904039092361927, 0.01401902548968792, 0.03352029621601105, -0.0021341517567634583, -0.012046626769006252, 0.024662252515554428, -0.048682525753974915, -0.055784326046705246, -0.038165826350450516, 0.04290720447897911, -0.004855838604271412, -0.044439997524023056, 0.03590435907244682, 0.014367994852364063, -0.015545932576060295, -0.02928682044148445, 0.03700961545109749, -0.05844386667013168, -0.011783922091126442, -0.03518195077776909, -0.038589753210544586, 0.01441322360187769, 0.029512319713830948, -0.009590968489646912, 0.03246823325753212, -0.019999196752905846, -0.003034261055290699, -0.06278367340564728, -0.08116480708122253, 0.013196133077144623, -0.04129870608448982, -0.016427557915449142, 0.06513602286577225, -0.04509711265563965, -0.07655605673789978, -0.039168085902929306, -0.05151853710412979, 0.00018205560627393425, -0.03225468844175339, -0.04148949310183525, -0.06339787691831589, -0.05048166960477829, -0.02315612882375717, 0.017550550401210785, -0.0654868632555008, -0.005760847590863705, -0.03311153128743172, -0.008325125090777874, -0.029352502897381783, -0.003048446960747242, -0.02819961868226528, -0.0549594946205616, -0.027322741225361824, -0.05405396968126297, -0.024179967120289803, -0.027415549382567406, 0.06357655674219131, -0.036957476288080215, -0.01960475742816925, -0.022802090272307396, 0.0036841100081801414, 0.013921797275543213, -0.02736019343137741, 0.00913774874061346, 0.018878526985645294, 0.07115193456411362, -0.034759268164634705, -0.00652901129797101, -0.03458147868514061, -0.0072224619798362255, -0.018316542729735374, 0.026500852778553963, 0.006720749195665121, -0.012195989489555359, 0.021797437220811844, -0.03547576814889908, -0.025442779064178467, 0.0033258036710321903, -0.07764624804258347, -0.02553657442331314, 0.05034230276942253, -0.06095603108406067, 0.04349750652909279, 0.034291427582502365, -0.014405211433768272, -0.004421301186084747, 0.012270241044461727, -0.06170184910297394, -0.035349100828170776, 0.012070865370333195, -0.025246310979127884, 0.018341518938541412, -0.005418842658400536, 0.0014256814029067755, -0.03860703855752945, 0.0027487019542604685, -0.005128331948071718, -0.04972117766737938, -0.00835560355335474, -0.05620777606964111, -0.03048619069159031, -0.04167722165584564, -0.025029756128787994, -0.013884996995329857, 0.02554871328175068, 0.06042939051985741, -0.006959038320928812, 0.015502921305596828, -0.002734470646828413, -0.037248022854328156, -0.039233267307281494, 0.022222796455025673, -0.017416412010788918, 0.04268160089850426, -0.03658170998096466, 0.013810421340167522, -0.046437088400125504, 0.015783702954649925, 0.023656275123357773, 0.024036232382059097, 0.05865665525197983, -0.044758833944797516, 0.017898453399538994, -0.0540534108877182, 0.0009525823988951743, -0.017235588282346725, -0.05501043424010277, -0.08144021779298782, 0.01869185082614422, 0.022741280496120453, 0.041765786707401276, 0.0260697603225708, -0.06518401205539703, 0.036021050065755844, 0.045865483582019806, 0.02123812586069107, -0.01796857826411724, 0.023600274696946144, -0.008153187111020088, 0.017628850415349007, 0.03339088708162308, -0.05241177976131439, 0.025009220466017723, 0.02405237779021263, -0.055592868477106094, -0.00874005164951086, 0.010084693320095539, -0.04462376609444618, 0.04030109569430351, -0.06581229716539383, 0.03859744966030121, 0.018831467255949974, 0.017596939578652382, -0.054729532450437546, -0.05993419140577316, -0.0252863597124815, -0.00904376432299614, 0.054227277636528015, 0.010586274787783623, -0.006128009408712387, -0.05677364394068718, -0.032344236969947815, -0.0006858077831566334, -0.0550009086728096, -0.05184008553624153, 0.03798900544643402, 0.038121771067380905, -0.03501400351524353, -0.0533083938062191, 0.009276329539716244, 0.006068938411772251, 0.059150658547878265, -0.048638615757226944, -0.005208998918533325, 0.044148027896881104, -0.0072486125864088535, -0.0003325859142933041, -0.048364877700805664, -0.01689680851995945, 0.0002877167717088014, -0.06711024045944214, 0.017793424427509308, -0.0010348041541874409, 0.02635224349796772, -0.04695086181163788, 0.04195745289325714, -0.07634340226650238, 0.00953078456223011, 0.012579587288200855, -0.04204285517334938, -0.06540512293577194, 0.01121243555098772, -0.05134004354476929, 0.04333754628896713, -0.020637352019548416, -0.07738607376813889, 0.0207676962018013, 0.037576280534267426, 0.015890788286924362, 0.0088121946901083, -0.035928986966609955, 0.01785767823457718, -0.08658616244792938, 0.065029077231884, 0.033072035759687424, 0.03178393468260765, -0.02750936895608902, 0.019580315798521042, -0.05592785030603409, -0.05368647351861, 0.030351346358656883, 0.04589350149035454, 0.036386407911777496, 0.038734275847673416, -0.031120767816901207, -0.02401703968644142, 0.0009464994654990733, -0.049465592950582504, -0.007700604852288961, -0.06912947446107864, 0.014668770134449005, -0.0036864259745925665, 0.030897192656993866, 0.057864151895046234, 0.029282892122864723, -0.021988382562994957, 0.006893731653690338, -0.018862837925553322, 0.049490295350551605, 0.01151729840785265, 0.01014714315533638, -0.059100277721881866, 0.05055645480751991, -0.014359635300934315, 0.00954905804246664, 0.03133765235543251, -0.009203909896314144, -0.05739755183458328, -0.028500374406576157, 0.004747187253087759, -0.018671464174985886, 0.048833590000867844, -0.06023922935128212, 0.016532722860574722, -0.005994558800011873, 0.012430651113390923, 0.04571819305419922, -0.02990092523396015, -0.009451642632484436, -0.03253266215324402, 0.0487142950296402, 0.033670879900455475, -0.029749881476163864, -0.007057881914079189, 0.01511729508638382, -0.051324501633644104, 0.027505720034241676, 0.02908680960536003, 0.04217887297272682, 0.0023465922567993402, -0.07787484675645828, -0.030178705230355263, 0.035833507776260376, -0.012460753321647644, 0.04717756062746048, 0.007679325062781572, 0.019459368661046028, -0.014108349569141865, -0.008809546940028667, -0.06529127806425095, 0.01913502626121044, -0.014359693974256516, -0.02867085672914982, -0.025460919365286827, -0.06521520018577576, -0.03211740776896477, -0.0841888040304184, -0.04647427052259445, -0.0026567308232188225, -0.008680107071995735, 0.02351079322397709, -0.0585874579846859, -0.028665872290730476, 0.03248929977416992, 0.01787302829325199, -0.04170788452029228, -0.032792095094919205, -0.035005681216716766, 0.022643228992819786, 0.027927188202738762, -0.023172002285718918, -0.062193404883146286, -0.03905881568789482, -0.03102981299161911, 0.014632382430136204, -0.04081958904862404, -0.009402469731867313, 0.009373743087053299, 0.0004219782422296703, -0.008797095157206059, -0.05899392068386078, 0.004451654851436615, -0.028387432917952538, -0.01280305441468954, -0.025825656950473785, -0.019051970914006233, -0.01627858728170395, -0.030569693073630333, -0.015669476240873337, -0.04612164571881294, -0.02439158409833908, 0.03745613992214203, 0.051792439073324203, -0.0360310859978199, -0.030453996732831, -0.039984848350286484, -0.06065857782959938, -0.013293789699673653, 0.015893127769231796, -0.056847281754016876, -0.024089764803647995, 0.0363302156329155, 0.009075585752725601, 0.01135363057255745, 0.013841351494193077, -0.003682975424453616, -0.01668803207576275, 0.026972968131303787, -0.07958770543336868, -0.0328495092689991, 0.05174138769507408, -0.08133536577224731, -0.013942880555987358, 0.027690954506397247, 0.057189054787158966, -0.03105217218399048, -0.047442421317100525, 0.03477082401514053, 0.010037856176495552, 0.022277306765317917, 0.010984606109559536, -0.0546560175716877, 0.02453801780939102, 0.031206820160150528, -0.0056606922298669815, 0.026374924927949905, 0.0012830231571570039, -0.036735568195581436, -0.010211830958724022, 0.02426118776202202, 0.044585295021533966, 0.030144518241286278, 0.021126624196767807, -0.04527099430561066, 0.00436999648809433, 0.025933215394616127, 0.019088007509708405, 0.0145315732806921, -0.015843534842133522, -0.015124894678592682, -0.061952996999025345, 0.038757797330617905, 0.022492552176117897, 0.05309014767408371, -0.04910048469901085, -0.03457091003656387, -0.007872060872614384, -0.020617572590708733, 0.03881412744522095, 0.024117909371852875, -0.05288898944854736, 0.04498522728681564, -0.010508634150028229, -0.053900208324193954, 0.04308576136827469, -0.025808194652199745, 0.006440151482820511, 0.01828397624194622, 0.05690287798643112, 0.0007341427844949067, -0.03415168449282646, -0.0337543748319149, -0.009345089085400105, 0.030278073623776436, -0.05289642512798309, -0.007127266842871904, -0.007947645150125027, 0.013157051056623459, -0.05549103766679764, -0.07734360545873642, -0.0464286133646965, -0.013268768787384033, 0.01867818832397461, -0.018964624032378197, -0.05367574095726013, 0.0461227148771286, 0.04920998215675354, 0.03399676829576492, 0.03414471447467804, 0.03132449835538864, -0.05000966787338257, -0.02808038331568241, -0.05250879004597664, -0.0686969980597496, 0.05874862149357796, 0.0018135977443307638, 0.004681865684688091, -0.011640116572380066, -0.008735070936381817, -0.055996932089328766, -0.05469372123479843, 0.016496170312166214, 0.01353631354868412, 0.057466477155685425, 0.05264919623732567, 0.016230856999754906, -0.04256017878651619, 0.05067914351820946, -0.04002473130822182, 0.04234258085489273, -0.052867740392684937, 0.0068734087981283665, 0.03076276369392872, -0.02363480255007744, -0.06909103691577911, -0.053871240466833115, -0.0026404797099530697, -0.0007615975919179618, 0.012793982401490211, -0.01137380488216877, -0.04299859702587128, 0.049377333372831345, -0.04535270482301712, -0.06893173605203629, -0.0002460175601299852, 0.008040529675781727, -0.05067015811800957, 0.02281595766544342, 0.013863764703273773, 0.013529655523598194, -0.05086992681026459, -0.04733425751328468, -0.0346556156873703, 0.027087876573204994, 0.026699058711528778, 0.009748189710080624, 0.043686218559741974, -0.044393084943294525, -0.04393509775400162, 0.028213810175657272, -0.02242863178253174, -0.059082742780447006, -0.06519485265016556, -0.017471732571721077, 0.04684450104832649, 0.040416426956653595, -0.013600839301943779, 0.05236358940601349, -0.08066573739051819, -0.01634998805820942, 0.018411027267575264, -0.03526808321475983, -0.017339635640382767, 0.043967340141534805, -0.0204646997153759, -0.011827143840491772, -0.044970978051424026, 0.007129504345357418, -0.0006189185660332441, -0.010598981752991676, -0.029422815889120102, 0.012611606158316135, 0.00035537470830604434, -0.0711994543671608, 0.018299641087651253, 0.042639054358005524, -0.032157693058252335, -0.023537691682577133, -0.019889703020453453, 0.036950357258319855, -0.020137043669819832, -0.002493811072781682, 0.018351731821894646, -0.00817448552697897, -0.031508103013038635, -0.046629879623651505, -0.008212274871766567, 0.025448720902204514, -0.006515255197882652, -0.027110634371638298, -0.050726909190416336, 0.01766449213027954, -0.024472717195749283, -0.015274289064109325, -0.0008323234505951405, -0.03972693532705307, 0.05122467875480652, -0.005364800803363323, 0.004071780480444431, -0.007042602635920048, -0.016307879239320755, 0.02734379470348358, 0.041495393961668015, 0.03085930645465851, -0.03519401326775551, -0.03645235300064087, -0.013659732416272163, -0.026972275227308273, -0.04937833547592163, -0.05504633113741875, -0.009802092798054218, -0.007305189035832882, 0.022897174581885338, 0.05663510039448738, -0.013092078268527985, 0.02876802161335945, -0.05053503438830376, 0.04123299568891525, -0.06063036993145943, 0.012906612828373909, 0.017715947702527046, 0.02242542989552021, 0.0317915640771389, 0.020858772099018097, -0.0016097516054287553, -0.014193757437169552, 0.02921646274626255, 0.001182041596621275, 0.033597297966480255, 0.000704034639056772, 0.00235661375336349, -0.023844191804528236, 0.04826902970671654, 0.021948786452412605, -0.08131961524486542, -0.012293643318116665, 0.02933679148554802, -0.0167166069149971, 0.008877710439264774, -0.05625353753566742, -0.014722402207553387, -0.030950458720326424, -0.027666140347719193, -0.018324432894587517, 0.010779527015984058, -0.017538385465741158, -0.04610157757997513, -0.009296603500843048, 0.02948460355401039, -0.05831271409988403, -0.0018661008216440678, -0.020243221893906593, -0.052466608583927155, -0.007086107973009348, -0.01526606921106577, 0.04238013178110123, -0.010702318511903286, 0.02231469936668873, -0.014821378514170647, -0.01639293134212494, -0.04519670829176903, 0.0711139664053917, 0.0807231143116951, -0.037304677069187164, 0.013808206655085087, -0.01772274635732174, -0.027267441153526306, 0.0033855726942420006, -0.04640695080161095, -0.031614143401384354, -0.010307504795491695, 0.03460320085287094, -0.038141507655382156, -0.0315152071416378, -0.02259107120335102, 0.05771669000387192, 0.0003397006366867572, 0.03898470103740692, 0.031179947778582573, 0.04441196471452713, -0.014823672361671925, -0.007687847130000591, -0.000421159784309566, -0.06671455502510071, 0.05136365070939064, -0.05326749011874199, -0.06723196804523468, -0.057080116122961044, -0.0052400873973965645, -0.0031623237300664186, -0.00005510612390935421, -0.058136604726314545, -0.057844944298267365, -0.008572457358241081, -0.04088231548666954, -0.030185675248503685, -0.05201945826411247, 0.054005980491638184, -0.03385718911886215, 0.05507155880331993, 0.03285806626081467, 0.044981375336647034, 0.009871340356767178, -0.010693855583667755, 0.056470077484846115, -0.006438538897782564, -0.02019057609140873, 0.034805506467819214, -0.008947090245783329, -0.03699621930718422, 0.021212486550211906, -0.03938107565045357, 0.005794954486191273, -0.04560336843132973, -0.0664639100432396, 0.004859516397118568, 0.04762960225343704, -0.016285674646496773, -0.04107515513896942, 0.02940068393945694, -0.031273361295461655, -0.024409787729382515, 0.026765769347548485, 0.00822984054684639, -0.0386546328663826, 0.04913518205285072, -0.02263294719159603, -0.031143808737397194, -0.039576154202222824, -0.03845203295350075, -0.006916619837284088, 0.042824674397706985, 0.03012002259492874, 0.02266686223447323, 0.0353439599275589, 0.03416365385055542, -0.042372945696115494, 0.03038465417921543, 0.0538409985601902, -0.025822296738624573, 0.040337078273296356, 0.023283127695322037, -0.04530782252550125, -0.0653306245803833, 0.05693840980529785, -0.010163971222937107, 0.029358986765146255, 0.000857667881064117, -0.01939052902162075, 0.016929810866713524, 0.05952027440071106, -0.0753624439239502, -0.06724104285240173, -0.05486926808953285, 0.022487565875053406, -0.013436596840620041, 0.009225758723914623, -0.004766265396028757, -0.0400371178984642, -0.011861220002174377, -0.07829093933105469, -0.026416951790452003, 0.015950610861182213, 0.0030088152270764112, 0.0016594233456999063, -0.03362081199884415, -0.007798830047249794, 0.0054873027838766575, 0.03491600230336189, 0.04413719102740288, -0.016434304416179657, 0.0753345862030983, -0.02397109754383564, 0.0012628933181986213, -0.03664021193981171, 0.011481821537017822, 0.04711820185184479, -0.024169953539967537, -0.027371224015951157, 0.011845584027469158, 0.019338641315698624, 0.05725202336907387, 0.006660409737378359, 0.024991096928715706, 0.030252939090132713, -0.02520541474223137, 0.024448085576295853, 0.009163732640445232, -0.06441959738731384, -0.0432729572057724, 0.01953701861202717, -0.013154067099094391, 0.04565833881497383, 0.008814677596092224, -0.007536609657108784, -0.05203044041991234, -0.010683313943445683, 0.00908145122230053, 0.03406490758061409, 0.040348391979932785, 0.046166904270648956, 0.02417793869972229, -0.017139378935098648, -0.026822732761502266, 0.006608252879232168, 0.046360913664102554, -0.05483193323016167, 0.0036095180548727512, 0.04407956078648567, -0.022013917565345764, -0.02323298528790474, -0.054566849023103714, -0.0002670072135515511, -0.005306136794388294, 0.016519935801625252, 0.041730158030986786, 0.06853325664997101, -0.05605171620845795, -0.0023079728707671165, 0.046829160302877426, 0.005906315520405769, -0.018211280927062035, -0.06468282639980316, -0.002735840855166316, 0.01095653884112835, -0.0615786537528038, -0.02246990241110325, 0.057520657777786255, 0.012945897877216339, 0.04574200138449669, -0.0747041329741478, 0.002590833231806755, 0.052389711141586304, -0.015096881426870823, -0.05532977730035782, 0.047156475484371185, -0.002297016093507409, -0.0067429556511342525, -0.03462827205657959, 0.037189021706581116, 0.001168422750197351, -0.0675642266869545, 0.03507407382130623, 0.006936222780495882, -0.05497320368885994, -0.03413575142621994, -0.02856973372399807, 0.054609403014183044, -0.005294602829962969, -0.023421360179781914, 0.01973184384405613, -0.014077735133469105, -0.026898475363850594, -0.038801372051239014 ]
The collection of reflecting hyperplanes of a finite Coxeter group is called a reflection arrangement and it appears in many subareas of combinatorics and representation theory. We focus on the problem of counting regions of reflection arrangements and their deformations. Inspired by the recent work of Bernardi, we show that the notion of moves and sketches can be used to provide a uniform and explicit bijection between regions of (the Catalan deformation of) a reflection arrangement and certain non-nesting partitions. We then use the exponential formula to describe a statistic on these partitions such that distribution is given by the coefficients of the characteristic polynomial. Finally, we consider a sub-arrangement of type C arrangement called the threshold arrangement and its Catalan and Shi deformations.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.16653v1
[ -0.007097629830241203, -0.007103951647877693, 0.017013318836688995, -0.02771640382707119, 0.0020059330854564905, -0.06563704460859299, -0.021339207887649536, 0.01808217726647854, 0.0062214466743171215, -0.01607070490717888, -0.02391953393816948, -0.046694740653038025, -0.05192366987466812, -0.06291811168193817, -0.06725049018859863, 0.022953391075134277, 0.05340074002742767, 0.040863487869501114, -0.07287532836198807, 0.08021499216556549, 0.032409947365522385, -0.012236612848937511, 0.02042410336434841, 0.05378130450844765, 0.021088775247335434, -0.008795423433184624, 0.01823035068809986, -0.0032035240437835455, -0.03293110057711601, -0.03162573277950287, 0.07510273903608322, -0.011524675413966179, -0.00867962185293436, -0.009483668953180313, -0.01899901032447815, 0.03512340784072876, 0.02352011390030384, 0.006083023268729448, 0.06263170391321182, -0.04028094559907913, -0.015156399458646774, -0.027404749765992165, -0.05488652363419533, 0.0120992511510849, 0.008824325166642666, -0.02355494163930416, -0.046768996864557266, 0.016754640266299248, -0.05121632665395737, -0.03334219008684158, -0.004076692275702953, 0.05844113603234291, -0.0031487392261624336, 0.035633280873298645, -0.061971452087163925, -0.020775584504008293, 0.0007147681317292154, -0.01047580037266016, -0.029876461252570152, -0.011267326772212982, 0.017293943092226982, -0.007157560437917709, 0.02851870469748974, -0.03691741079092026, 0.016370095312595367, 0.03178086131811142, -0.0706171914935112, -0.06255173683166504, 0.0012474498944357038, -0.04376997798681259, -0.000627388886641711, -0.0799562931060791, 0.03471733629703522, 0.005336217116564512, -0.08754865825176239, 0.007629370782524347, -0.008946546353399754, -0.014958917163312435, 0.028703222051262856, 0.03582226112484932, -0.016886889934539795, 0.013036111369729042, 0.0032671880908310413, 0.0034910207614302635, 0.028733206912875175, 0.026104066520929337, 0.07101679593324661, -0.03793546184897423, -0.012986735440790653, -0.03872676193714142, 0.015889884904026985, 0.009304025210440159, -0.053601671010255814, -0.014549504965543747, 0.05415298044681549, -0.00881232600659132, 0.0779186263680458, 0.012237649410963058, 0.011208322830498219, -0.024103250354528427, -0.02571243979036808, -0.0170595720410347, 0.03401980549097061, 0.038733795285224915, 0.01820976845920086, 0.016185447573661804, 0.004764234647154808, 0.0002654967538546771, 0.009450260549783707, 0.04345681890845299, 0.0054792724549770355, 0.028846681118011475, -0.0044539086520671844, -0.07285796850919724, -0.007700002286583185, -0.05401383340358734, 0.044539593160152435, -0.03127555176615715, 0.024585630744695663, -0.024007141590118408, -0.014675422571599483, 0.0016629718011245131, -0.0029396514873951674, -0.03928808495402336, -0.05346382409334183, -0.02094261348247528, 0.04279110208153725, 0.008084897883236408, 0.019995272159576416, -0.04389588534832001, -0.023735880851745605, -0.04538683965802193, 0.016504332423210144, -0.028264516964554787, 0.03653081879019737, -0.04706583172082901, 0.04317328706383705, -0.026071390137076378, 0.018316125497221947, 0.02498224563896656, -0.05412546545267105, -0.06853422522544861, -0.01501251757144928, -0.01376273762434721, 0.004396788310259581, 0.07224404811859131, -0.06987015902996063, 0.010319462046027184, 0.0303154606372118, 0.029247703030705452, -0.02595227025449276, -0.027593087404966354, 0.05151819437742233, -0.010425545275211334, -0.011687865480780602, -0.051257915794849396, 0.05559656769037247, 0.009692572057247162, -0.06165986508131027, 0.02260378748178482, 0.00795282144099474, -0.0029691075906157494, -0.001535551156848669, 0.024523546919226646, -0.018803594633936882, 0.012759076431393623, 0.03414101153612137, -0.015780668705701828, -0.04873010516166687, -0.04266176000237465, -0.04776076227426529, 0.015506815165281296, 0.0028825905174016953, 0.0008133724331855774, -0.06090272217988968, -0.00845941063016653, -0.04693920165300369, -0.07197697460651398, 0.018419159576296806, 0.02434629201889038, -0.00830874778330326, -0.01708756946027279, -0.027714937925338745, -0.023287219926714897, -0.03367012366652489, 0.022272413596510887, -0.07538103312253952, 0.026043951511383057, 0.01063449401408434, 0.0036280821077525616, 0.020857729017734528, -0.03609331324696541, 0.021532008424401283, 0.0397326834499836, -0.06323227286338806, -0.003188642207533121, 0.018976544961333275, -0.05154646188020706, -0.017859846353530884, 0.02540387026965618, -0.06785006821155548, -0.023702872917056084, -0.027884462848305702, 0.027017252519726753, 0.01799415610730648, -0.07808646559715271, 0.011499409563839436, 0.021945657208561897, -0.05145980045199394, -0.036375708878040314, 0.02037784829735756, 0.01890147291123867, 0.07273910939693451, -0.0350712388753891, -0.0034974259324371815, 0.012161795981228352, -0.09821467846632004, 0.00039447195013053715, -0.012187836691737175, -0.05526728183031082, -0.05179828777909279, 0.039150238037109375, -0.014394000172615051, -0.051056332886219025, -0.060968220233917236, 0.0554671473801136, 0.04876772314310074, 0.02453041262924671, -0.05725790187716484, -0.017212338745594025, -0.04269120842218399, -0.04708440601825714, -0.03420213982462883, -0.04213537648320198, -0.05553737282752991, -0.01514566782861948, -0.050465911626815796, 0.050823960453271866, -0.020308692008256912, -0.052252866327762604, -0.06720571219921112, 0.012147069908678532, 0.049580007791519165, -0.049424659460783005, -0.029693713411688805, -0.03734856843948364, -0.06549009680747986, 0.017535684630274773, -0.05529466271400452, 0.009613857604563236, 0.013108511455357075, -0.0771637111902237, 0.03539247065782547, -0.012458780780434608, 0.0014935778453946114, 0.030610455200076103, -0.04470868036150932, 0.03588579222559929, 0.0020596859976649284, 0.06448499113321304, 0.03906220197677612, 0.03758937865495682, -0.07153289020061493, -0.010075933299958706, -0.005883418954908848, 0.006361817009747028, -0.03547772392630577, -0.0022337776608765125, 0.006027676165103912, -0.0070916772820055485, -0.006962202955037355, -0.02242979407310486, 0.01581510156393051, 0.004440837539732456, -0.011935858055949211, 0.013905721716582775, -0.0015331549802795053, -0.04333270341157913, 0.035120557993650436, 0.012873861007392406, 0.05054261162877083, 0.027362721040844917, -0.018235167488455772, -0.08721931278705597, 0.012741721235215664, -0.012337969616055489, 0.010750142857432365, -0.03232302889227867, -0.06451345980167389, -0.015233082696795464, -0.06824665516614914, -0.01933816261589527, -0.020681869238615036, -0.05523436516523361, -0.029409751296043396, -0.06532522290945053, 0.026726437732577324, 0.0005406471900641918, 0.015196189284324646, -0.004385432694107294, -0.030893808230757713, 0.01581839844584465, 0.02868741750717163, -0.012959371320903301, -0.026324767619371414, -0.06840962171554565, -0.07279795408248901, 0.06491194665431976, -0.0015055846888571978, -0.030118873342871666, -0.025862453505396843, 0.011272427625954151, -0.029589632526040077, 0.033530429005622864, 0.007297394797205925, 0.004370348993688822, -0.0009811798809096217, 0.02366299368441105, 0.012569204904139042, -0.04041532427072525, 0.009842924773693085, 0.035676490515470505, 0.020178908482193947, -0.030182918533682823, -0.05277889966964722, 0.016255725175142288, 0.0595373772084713, 0.06746606528759003, -0.034132618457078934, -0.021085461601614952, -0.0038421018980443478, 0.03743845224380493, 0.029397202655673027, -0.02505090832710266, 0.026372356340289116, 0.03336203098297119, -0.016454165801405907, -0.05361400917172432, -0.029217040166258812, 0.016662051901221275, -0.0027381964027881622, 0.04773679003119469, -0.016098881140351295, -0.010527770034968853, -0.02091735228896141, -0.08912816643714905, 0.051789212971925735, 0.03423411399126053, 0.0737595334649086, -0.006925506982952356, -0.04389911890029907, 0.023043712601065636, 0.0057581341825425625, -0.048442453145980835, -0.049689747393131256, -0.019510213285684586, 0.028739601373672485, 0.0665813460946083, -0.027894526720046997, -0.04576100409030914, -0.07025589793920517, -0.07379801571369171, -0.03683930262923241, 0.04581943526864052, 0.05267016589641571, 0.02795867994427681, 0.012243770994246006, -0.008577193133533001, 0.015648065134882927, -0.018170634284615517, 0.07280180603265762, -0.018657730892300606, -0.03865190967917442, 0.04790731891989708, -0.022411126643419266, 0.04008694365620613, 0.014164934866130352, 0.001982030225917697, -0.022805403918027878, -0.07547619938850403, 0.04224521666765213, -0.051845721900463104, 0.05722175911068916, 0.02467288076877594, 0.05063965916633606, 0.021397866308689117, 0.01577635668218136, 0.01430546771734953, 0.01550421305000782, 0.03191762790083885, 0.004123569931834936, 0.004508959129452705, 0.060282424092292786, 0.019808121025562286, -0.06955081969499588, -0.04803076758980751, -0.016227805987000465, -0.04286860302090645, -0.039954639971256256, -0.03816862404346466, -0.0042435419745743275, 0.0029094351921230555, -0.06476261466741562, -0.08458572626113892, -0.03553741052746773, -0.016591986641287804, -0.0010039289481937885, -0.012862853705883026, -0.07708743214607239, 0.08195363730192184, -0.012940877117216587, -0.006527848541736603, -0.022927934303879738, -0.008600051514804363, -0.03054518811404705, 0.02949809841811657, -0.010636689141392708, -0.07148674130439758, 0.0242647472769022, -0.05219712853431702, 0.05108838155865669, -0.03734821081161499, -0.012461088597774506, -0.050044991075992584, 0.00968506745994091, -0.03992123529314995, 0.004805591888725758, 0.043132249265909195, 0.05263615772128105, 0.041683223098516464, 0.005587656982243061, 0.01573675498366356, 0.02107156626880169, 0.030414050444960594, -0.00437715370208025, -0.020421570166945457, 0.04380441829562187, -0.022906800732016563, -0.04857120290398598, -0.04017964377999306, -0.030686471611261368, 0.013895167969167233, -0.06365972012281418, -0.043195921927690506, 0.013752080500125885, 0.013355356641113758, -0.05052692070603371, -0.04011308029294014, -0.013413622975349426, 0.011962222866714, -0.07297464460134506, 0.0228767991065979, -0.02436092309653759, 0.014884322881698608, -0.008794055320322514, 0.006922988686710596, -0.03410675376653671, -0.008983073756098747, -0.04008050635457039, 0.046838220208883286, 0.02300337143242359, 0.03828094154596329, -0.014085721224546432, -0.04659765586256981, -0.059343863278627396, 0.03763788565993309, -0.0058774990029633045, -0.005254942923784256, 0.010076138190925121, 0.0163277555257082, 0.0057458532974123955, 0.030705396085977554, -0.09073681384325027, 0.05365265905857086, 0.04864886403083801, -0.010214979760348797, 0.017131997272372246, 0.038005128502845764, 0.005383067298680544, 0.015490603633224964, 0.020202910527586937, 0.00459325173869729, 0.01090447511523962, 0.008133407682180405, 0.015709692612290382, -0.010636912658810616, 0.004667283035814762, 0.005997481755912304, 0.018215570598840714, -0.012021335773169994, -0.025220908224582672, 0.01396690309047699, -0.00395236536860466, -0.04218907654285431, -0.05968737602233887, 0.03239043056964874, 0.023456996306777, -0.03024597279727459, -0.054532457143068314, 0.031408436596393585, -0.05556892231106758, 0.02419552393257618, 0.02857487089931965, 0.012711507268249989, -0.00014625961193814874, 0.019143888726830482, 0.012120082974433899, 0.005708010867238045, 0.030204299837350845, -0.012069851160049438, 0.01492251642048359, 0.0372248999774456, -0.014775083400309086, -0.045322392135858536, 0.02370869368314743, -0.02392839640378952, 0.05363438278436661, 0.039289768785238266, 0.018454579636454582, 0.023794399574398994, 0.02377047948539257, 0.0007049159612506628, -0.043397244065999985, 0.025100350379943848, 0.010296346619725227, 0.03286315128207207, -0.048528704792261124, 0.0024175592698156834, 0.0238801259547472, 0.03704415634274483, -0.012841572985053062, 0.0007682062569074333, 0.028325624763965607, 0.0017408073181286454, -0.02331365831196308, 0.019291529431939125, -0.005419580265879631, 0.04691997170448303, -0.045164790004491806, -0.002581924432888627, 0.0263078436255455, -0.0005530627677217126, 0.04024269059300423, 0.042382895946502686, -0.017248209565877914, 0.025904418900609016, 0.00751027837395668, 0.0485842302441597, -0.04278673976659775, -0.01936556212604046, 0.07267982512712479, -0.08114542812108994, -0.029447147622704506, -0.02349243499338627, -0.07455810904502869, 0.02130306139588356, 0.0016528514679521322, 0.02024136669933796, 0.00899922102689743, -0.0021257256157696247, -0.03413793817162514, 0.051254745572805405, 0.005529564339667559, 0.007841822691261768, -0.049585770815610886, 0.024533985182642937, -0.07141857594251633, -0.043850935995578766, -0.01714293099939823, 0.023255640640854836, 0.02627214416861534, 0.06477370113134384, -0.040417131036520004, -0.040662746876478195, -0.06175721809267998, 0.05647420138120651, 0.06392835080623627, -0.05409551411867142, -0.007816053926944733, 0.019465388730168343, 0.007071905303746462, -0.004101981408894062, 0.011042448692023754, -0.0349544994533062, -0.0323965810239315, -0.023916443809866905, -0.0066512757912278175, -0.025833304971456528, -0.007436390034854412, 0.05141201987862587, -0.024207860231399536, 0.009000645019114017, 0.025332627817988396, -0.009659482166171074, -0.008842846378684044, -0.04263163357973099, -0.037885215133428574, -0.00023164812591858208, 0.010251985862851143, -0.007208553608506918, -0.04017452523112297, -0.013387655839323997, -0.029457150027155876, 0.0329713374376297, 0.03227706626057625, -0.04951159656047821, -0.024860890582203865, -0.015488128177821636, -0.03406137973070145, -0.022211499512195587, -0.08017092198133469, 0.02043994888663292, -0.01667063869535923, 0.045170702040195465, -0.02421846054494381, 0.06385156512260437, 0.015023997984826565, 0.028684183955192566, 0.010249133221805096, 0.0032451488077640533, 0.005457278341054916, 0.04586237296462059, 0.03755267336964607, 0.01140456274151802, 0.06958243995904922, -0.05922319367527962, 0.019268568605184555, -0.03595014661550522, -0.027690144255757332, -0.0009716525673866272, -0.0120149040594697, -0.03354999050498009, -0.030752265825867653, 0.02040165849030018, -0.03247254714369774, -0.01175762340426445, 0.04152476042509079, -0.04339075833559036, -0.06296922266483307, 0.02709490992128849, -0.0019883466884493828, -0.00811624713242054, -0.020059484988451004, 0.040134381502866745, 0.001955044222995639, -0.006083792075514793, 0.06631428003311157, 0.036249104887247086, 0.04720950871706009, -0.051788024604320526, -0.051954127848148346, 0.0018620871705934405, 0.0024262811057269573, -0.000999161507934332, -0.05340716615319252, 0.005616647191345692, -0.0527973473072052, -0.0788443386554718, 0.054988421499729156, -0.019860384985804558, -0.00836771447211504, -0.03248230367898941, -0.05368876829743385, 0.05131322145462036, 0.02815035730600357, -0.026854798197746277, -0.08654650300741196, 0.008773787878453732, 0.022387245669960976, 0.013808663003146648, 0.0002657316217664629, -0.01541815884411335, -0.01894572004675865, 0.02240625210106373, -0.08467122167348862, 0.015980573371052742, -0.012526433914899826, 0.07519551366567612, 0.0027525871992111206, 0.005344645585864782, -0.013099618256092072, -0.031650688499212265, 0.0030682203359901905, 0.03750986605882645, 0.010149664245545864, 0.04186612740159035, 0.01282509882003069, 0.026009364053606987, -0.021214215084910393, -0.006971288938075304, 0.032749295234680176, -0.01256115548312664, -0.017156334593892097, 0.006115428637713194, 0.019176101312041283, -0.029279526323080063, 0.021433105692267418, 0.019204560667276382, 0.012537125498056412, 0.038397256284952164, -0.026062652468681335, 0.0030612326227128506, -0.06226079538464546, -0.0661059096455574, 0.048086877912282944, -0.04841525852680206, 0.010715962387621403, 0.019978336989879608, 0.01584690250456333, -0.05716013163328171, 0.009564263746142387, -0.02954677678644657, 0.07002909481525421, -0.003816436743363738, 0.00007323818863369524, 0.04727346450090408, -0.06313002109527588, 0.017748042941093445, 0.0327356681227684, 0.01856604777276516, -0.029183920472860336, 0.027356216683983803, 0.019808435812592506, -0.046615563333034515, 0.05436386540532112, -0.06095260754227638, 0.012314388528466225, -0.01434039231389761, 0.022233281284570694, 0.04624386876821518, 0.011005849577486515, -0.03158729150891304, 0.015816766768693924, -0.054938625544309616, -0.040277037769556046, 0.05049867928028107, -0.03113311156630516, 0.04373563081026077, -0.037881847470998764, 0.044182296842336655, 0.003163865301758051, 0.02799198217689991, 0.02184051088988781, 0.06539580971002579, 0.019012542441487312, 0.021259773522615433, -0.00045889036846347153, -0.004954786039888859, -0.03366381675004959, 0.033526964485645294, 0.005921647418290377, -0.052657756954431534, -0.007864330895245075, -0.009817501530051231, 0.002722545061260462, -0.01530605461448431, -0.018393956124782562, 0.002163285156711936, -0.033072810620069504, -0.044844526797533035, -0.036115847527980804, 0.02354636788368225, 0.008501963689923286, -0.051413290202617645, 0.004498710390180349, 0.018687836825847626, -0.008483762852847576, -0.04098251089453697 ]
Food image classification is a fundamental step of image-based dietary assessment, enabling automated nutrient analysis from food images. Many current methods employ deep neural networks to train on generic food image datasets that do not reflect the dynamism of real-life food consumption patterns, in which food images appear sequentially over time, reflecting the progression of what an individual consumes. Personalized food classification aims to address this problem by training a deep neural network using food images that reflect the consumption pattern of each individual. However, this problem is under-explored and there is a lack of benchmark datasets with individualized food consumption patterns due to the difficulty in data collection. In this work, we first introduce two benchmark personalized datasets including the Food101-Personal, which is created based on surveys of daily dietary patterns from participants in the real world, and the VFNPersonal, which is developed based on a dietary study. In addition, we propose a new framework for personalized food image classification by leveraging self-supervised learning and temporal image feature information. Our method is evaluated on both benchmark datasets and shows improved performance compared to existing works. The dataset has been made available at: https://skynet.ecn.purdue.edu/~pan161/dataset_personal.html
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08744v1
[ -0.018613794818520546, -0.014074430800974369, 0.017289038747549057, 0.029556581750512123, -0.049645088613033295, -0.05434189364314079, 0.034194689244031906, -0.010641747154295444, -0.04960378631949425, -0.0661400705575943, -0.06558671593666077, 0.030205799266695976, -0.04221656545996666, -0.034852441400289536, -0.028976978734135628, 0.04175290837883949, 0.07272271811962128, -0.04793681204319, -0.043370407074689865, 0.015926720574498177, 0.0424329936504364, -0.005173057783395052, -0.007807631976902485, -0.00256281066685915, 0.020478183403611183, -0.02169719710946083, -0.026622209697961807, 0.007838288322091103, -0.04780544340610504, -0.048276375979185104, 0.08061494678258896, -0.0412345789372921, -0.031931862235069275, -0.04157114773988724, -0.059393011033535004, 0.006885425187647343, 0.014173243194818497, 0.033966582268476486, -0.056115929037332535, -0.03496111184358597, 0.026225602254271507, -0.04646527022123337, -0.057976044714450836, -0.01655365712940693, -0.04150009900331497, -0.008774470537900925, -0.05136836692690849, 0.03417092561721802, -0.0865509957075119, -0.031185036525130272, 0.009281879290938377, -0.0065797134302556515, 0.015586219727993011, 0.043932776898145676, -0.03853278234601021, -0.02503194287419319, -0.018544521182775497, 0.06253089010715485, -0.032749857753515244, 0.00003711502722580917, 0.016907943412661552, -0.028722861781716347, 0.027635499835014343, -0.03167549893260002, 0.030293619260191917, 0.03804028406739235, -0.037382811307907104, -0.08952148258686066, -0.0383831262588501, -0.036842480301856995, 0.05759128928184509, -0.02468743547797203, -0.0034590752329677343, 0.00683512631803751, -0.024822719395160675, 0.0032998090609908104, -0.052089761942625046, -0.03699745237827301, 0.04031243920326233, -0.0027030131313949823, -0.03557107225060463, 0.04124351218342781, 0.027135513722896576, 0.01915864460170269, -0.02362901158630848, -0.06723848730325699, 0.018812237307429314, -0.019112585112452507, -0.002371434587985277, 0.00014821108197793365, 0.02216927707195282, -0.007820434868335724, -0.06844700127840042, -0.01993752084672451, 0.07072056084871292, -0.00502888485789299, -0.011561628431081772, 0.06069594621658325, 0.022990094497799873, -0.018006635829806328, 0.014833823777735233, -0.0012396839447319508, -0.007322455756366253, 0.051482122391462326, 0.00872806552797556, -0.02488904446363449, 0.006751203443855047, 0.015795323997735977, -0.07070089876651764, 0.016864417120814323, -0.015274700708687305, 0.02429308369755745, -0.017562348395586014, -0.043080441653728485, -0.07254628092050552, -0.017940156161785126, 0.03430616483092308, -0.015654245391488075, 0.049418698996305466, -0.00321527780033648, -0.041374824941158295, 0.05834413692355156, 0.06164658069610596, -0.009879880584776402, -0.05511171743273735, 0.006032972130924463, 0.03392445296049118, 0.008069060742855072, 0.0037200956139713526, -0.04752802103757858, -0.04092787578701973, 0.03103436715900898, -0.052277788519859314, 0.01282133162021637, 0.011502059176564217, -0.04648251086473465, 0.015652451664209366, -0.06790226697921753, -0.0007954417960718274, 0.04211990162730217, -0.04065157473087311, -0.039215367287397385, 0.016887689009308815, -0.02868066355586052, -0.026838071644306183, 0.06984895467758179, -0.03283169865608215, -0.04080204293131828, 0.01419009268283844, 0.02666870877146721, 0.00831595528870821, -0.002151667606085539, 0.013805104419589043, 0.011091087013483047, -0.002931560855358839, -0.0125691257417202, 0.04682308807969093, -0.022020477801561356, -0.01795266941189766, 0.031357429921627045, -0.02079097554087639, -0.04386576637625694, 0.02832145243883133, -0.052641090005636215, 0.023795241490006447, -0.011941150762140751, 0.006154293194413185, -0.0025907985400408506, -0.031087152659893036, 0.02637294866144657, -0.030110707506537437, -0.014728235080838203, -0.0006579598411917686, 0.013022969476878643, -0.06194831430912018, 0.02870905213057995, 0.01380929071456194, -0.06137974187731743, -0.05608699843287468, -0.010577259585261345, -0.022772932425141335, 0.04873078316450119, -0.008828270249068737, 0.002978566335514188, -0.05412176623940468, -0.0088355652987957, -0.08181370049715042, -0.053815435618162155, 0.0405912809073925, -0.013242806307971478, -0.04534908011555672, -0.0651119202375412, 0.003314979374408722, -0.009989707730710506, -0.010919049382209778, -0.015441007912158966, 0.027895228937268257, -0.05682156980037689, 0.01574893295764923, 0.03358716517686844, -0.08150549978017807, -0.027484526857733727, -0.05291729047894478, -0.048005517572164536, -0.017461849376559258, -0.05228301137685776, -0.004950430244207382, 0.025289569050073624, -0.013619327917695045, 0.013307892717421055, 0.0175261702388525, 0.05882968381047249, 0.07688848674297333, -0.03143538534641266, 0.030166974291205406, 0.019098669290542603, -0.09272418171167374, 0.03434298187494278, 0.029028458520770073, 0.046200431883335114, -0.0037114263977855444, 0.012142080813646317, -0.02895200625061989, -0.0011462944094091654, -0.013113318011164665, 0.014304045587778091, 0.05059584602713585, 0.01575724221765995, -0.03433500975370407, -0.0056670717895030975, -0.04014590010046959, -0.06886656582355499, -0.06259036064147949, -0.058819156140089035, -0.049958523362874985, -0.014415000565350056, -0.0014065805589780211, 0.045614928007125854, -0.030390540137887, -0.03932098299264908, -0.0039013519417494535, -0.010665449313819408, 0.04499654099345207, -0.012835217639803886, -0.03122914396226406, -0.06419568508863449, 0.015995249152183533, 0.04446951299905777, -0.01892448216676712, 0.0045509967021644115, -0.02271471545100212, -0.0739627406001091, -0.01669175922870636, -0.02190629206597805, 0.013846986927092075, -0.006861407309770584, -0.042679835110902786, 0.01489229965955019, -0.0546695776283741, 0.06785248219966888, 0.027978966012597084, 0.06441261619329453, -0.05929703265428543, 0.014373875223100185, 0.03609096631407738, -0.023530013859272003, -0.039512768387794495, -0.06096142530441284, 0.004367545247077942, -0.03348984196782112, -0.012921788729727268, 0.044926226139068604, 0.027529962360858917, -0.001397480838932097, -0.04679484665393829, -0.019254274666309357, 0.007227867841720581, -0.037361543625593185, 0.027649905532598495, 0.06306922435760498, 0.005572359077632427, 0.03592102974653244, -0.028978025540709496, -0.06391274183988571, -0.02003788948059082, -0.05412885919213295, -0.04105059430003166, -0.05741191655397415, -0.07021742314100266, -0.034852467477321625, -0.08270743489265442, -0.01551899779587984, -0.04356355965137482, -0.0729847401380539, -0.020832551643252373, -0.034536756575107574, -0.025176305323839188, -0.04852741211652756, -0.021648917347192764, -0.011497572995722294, -0.04784423112869263, -0.054131880402565, 0.032268211245536804, 0.0002069642796413973, 0.024429498240351677, -0.062088459730148315, -0.035882435739040375, 0.0057237036526203156, 0.01827904023230076, 0.020681431517004967, 0.026291366666555405, 0.023977646604180336, 0.027515331283211708, 0.04745681583881378, -0.012813663110136986, 0.01593085564672947, -0.02597329393029213, -0.0018351939506828785, 0.007390680722892284, -0.0036176969297230244, 0.057535093277692795, -0.03994358330965042, 0.008393842726945877, -0.013343694619834423, -0.04237544536590576, -0.019948240369558334, 0.025312267243862152, 0.020233506336808205, -0.03643334284424782, -0.006797581445425749, -0.016688287258148193, -0.02240126207470894, 0.036503855139017105, -0.0238108579069376, 0.03031795471906662, 0.008911939337849617, 0.03258313238620758, 0.003968247212469578, -0.031880855560302734, -0.02654075063765049, 0.002616639481857419, -0.03845072537660599, -0.07851556688547134, 0.049926433712244034, 0.021102890372276306, -0.08590036630630493, 0.035531848669052124, 0.0031905723735690117, 0.07541807740926743, 0.02984643541276455, 0.01647101901471615, -0.013861503452062607, 0.003877924056723714, -0.017762167379260063, 0.022152189165353775, 0.039831798523664474, 0.022722512483596802, 0.05555219575762749, -0.014825398102402687, -0.03577520325779915, 0.019063618034124374, -0.043018754571676254, -0.054954398423433304, 0.015315846540033817, 0.042856208980083466, 0.05044066160917282, 0.0390191376209259, -0.03706931322813034, 0.0273140762001276, -0.013509096577763557, 0.05195944011211395, -0.03235819190740585, -0.062352925539016724, 0.018647190183401108, -0.030589580535888672, 0.05741780996322632, -0.012532925233244896, -0.0011117001995444298, -0.010213947854936123, -0.03295819088816643, 0.02271663397550583, -0.048745498061180115, 0.04416443035006523, 0.015610561706125736, 0.013207933865487576, 0.031001560389995575, 0.029785167425870895, -0.0055045015178620815, 0.023609932512044907, -0.05237111449241638, -0.0011436459608376026, -0.014837515540421009, -0.03525333106517792, -0.0594303235411644, 0.01457025296986103, -0.04399615153670311, 0.019319219514727592, 0.01937102898955345, -0.0015407151076942682, -0.05008159950375557, 0.007181304972618818, -0.024346740916371346, -0.023263756185770035, -0.0703660100698471, 0.01732504740357399, -0.01917162537574768, 0.038907796144485474, -0.0012839139671996236, -0.04859635978937149, 0.040629319846630096, -0.019861027598381042, -0.00581837585195899, -0.042637377977371216, -0.012190908193588257, 0.006508519873023033, 0.015482439659535885, 0.04355327785015106, -0.07644253224134445, -0.0039140572771430016, -0.05336717143654823, 0.061819080263376236, 0.018413912504911423, 0.01001566182821989, -0.05937390401959419, -0.06661687791347504, -0.025502366945147514, -0.007125775329768658, 0.046332310885190964, 0.018201937898993492, -0.015247267670929432, -0.0016714051598683, 0.018939374014735222, 0.011037035845220089, 0.021672045812010765, 0.031004298478364944, 0.001411499921232462, 0.019455494359135628, 0.01963484287261963, -0.01516425795853138, -0.011234366334974766, -0.025334874168038368, 0.06662613898515701, 0.0012159193865954876, -0.056572869420051575, -0.019414611160755157, 0.02723468653857708, 0.004046081565320492, -0.06824971735477448, -0.04729366675019264, -0.013779191300272942, -0.025556473061442375, -0.006778110284358263, 0.019649071618914604, 0.04330621287226677, 0.019210798665881157, -0.007444308139383793, 0.009174914099276066, 0.032299455255270004, 0.008202847093343735, 0.026934051886200905, 0.013282442465424538, -0.009640282951295376, -0.028276892378926277, -0.03706757351756096, -0.08097334206104279, -0.009230852127075195, -0.018196597695350647, -0.023577075451612473, -0.015267341397702694, 0.06490622460842133, 0.01875295117497444, 0.04409187659621239, -0.08170994371175766, -0.01060983445495367, 0.0158084649592638, -0.0008864915580488741, 0.029435977339744568, 0.06356453895568848, -0.020198814570903778, 0.044366639107465744, -0.045886751264333725, 0.0014216771814972162, -0.001228551845997572, -0.03925390541553497, 0.01176298875361681, 0.018501996994018555, -0.03427444398403168, -0.016164347529411316, 0.0791342630982399, -0.02957426756620407, -0.05527343228459358, -0.014768755994737148, 0.019906045868992805, 0.020164182409644127, -0.008383180946111679, 0.00022078635811340064, -0.01908503659069538, -0.029862165451049805, -0.010769417509436607, 0.00029004973475821316, -0.028839124366641045, 0.03245089203119278, 0.025230618193745613, -0.0019842626061290503, -0.02820519357919693, 0.06269659847021103, -0.028666671365499496, 0.006455094553530216, 0.009712203405797482, 0.023475291207432747, 0.020118432119488716, -0.018957385793328285, 0.044781818985939026, -0.026530224829912186, -0.028190962970256805, -0.04523705691099167, 0.056428179144859314, -0.0030895331874489784, 0.013986358419060707, 0.017279133200645447, 0.0029703094623982906, -0.03356243297457695, -0.029433825984597206, -0.00955894123762846, -0.04139215871691704, 0.043511904776096344, -0.03562090918421745, 0.032067034393548965, -0.0757380947470665, 0.03523659706115723, 0.012323111295700073, 0.02097238041460514, 0.05180089548230171, 0.038649581372737885, 0.004384850617498159, -0.026935888454318047, 0.06037163734436035, -0.010232632048428059, -0.055456530302762985, 0.010162721388041973, -0.0004275742976460606, -0.03297523409128189, 0.011157943867146969, 0.019383274018764496, -0.022266952320933342, 0.015571115538477898, -0.00781257450580597, -0.03142835572361946, -0.03307262808084488, -0.009600433520972729, 0.05333370342850685, -0.046852197498083115, 0.0340825617313385, -0.03879402577877045, -0.03692646697163582, -0.021430881693959236, -0.05287295579910278, 0.04476635903120041, 0.010167279280722141, -0.004548344761133194, -0.041738491505384445, 0.05749860405921936, -0.03571072220802307, -0.06845232844352722, 0.0136524373665452, -0.017370667308568954, -0.07517348229885101, 0.01188733335584402, 0.005942908115684986, 0.03503943607211113, -0.033547013998031616, 0.03621266782283783, -0.012748967856168747, 0.027352474629878998, -0.02762868069112301, 0.0673442929983139, 0.07996996492147446, 0.003876186441630125, 0.034015364944934845, 0.04588966444134712, -0.06324240565299988, -0.006540134083479643, -0.009876487776637077, 0.048949699848890305, -0.023337533697485924, 0.05260361358523369, 0.00779357785359025, -0.05590108036994934, -0.02409333921968937, 0.07976052910089493, -0.04742959886789322, -0.03417731821537018, -0.0007491647847928107, -0.04914090037345886, 0.03784001246094704, -0.01896367035806179, -0.07132977247238159, -0.004494786262512207, 0.014096174389123917, 0.023161327466368675, -0.026586556807160378, 0.008043197914958, -0.05973204970359802, 0.01011712197214365, 0.0007174750789999962, -0.059730224311351776, -0.01142645999789238, -0.03062291257083416, -0.06185445562005043, 0.029222361743450165, -0.069073386490345, -0.033651791512966156, -0.030606020241975784, -0.0035309731028974056, 0.024272684007883072, 0.012347632087767124, -0.04463614150881767, -0.006250178907066584, 0.028221894055604935, 0.013807647861540318, -0.009506696835160255, -0.01805907115340233, -0.0025545302778482437, 0.01066705770790577, 0.006579946726560593, -0.04982345551252365, -0.013430080376565456, -0.03780962526798248, -0.0030966270714998245, -0.0055178492330014706, 0.011311892420053482, -0.05182592198252678, -0.04044097661972046, -0.004104631021618843, -0.03915759176015854, 0.01340839546173811, 0.06668773293495178, -0.04032134637236595, -0.036884576082229614, -0.004415133036673069, -0.03164882957935333, -0.020623663440346718, 0.009919382631778717, 0.05010371655225754, 0.04146530106663704, 0.015709830448031425, 0.02527746558189392, 0.04311381280422211, 0.006913331337273121, 0.03424635902047157, -0.07390464842319489, -0.01581123098731041, -0.005822938866913319, -0.03781340271234512, -0.042016979306936264, -0.04230717942118645, 0.014842970296740532, -0.06172168254852295, 0.002569881733506918, 0.04800798371434212, 0.007081091869622469, -0.04260961338877678, -0.07343968003988266, 0.0268939808011055, 0.033073775470256805, -0.04186825454235077, -0.05242287740111351, -0.03110908903181553, -0.02557273581624031, -0.03589184582233429, -0.026788149029016495, -0.017354657873511314, -0.015059353783726692, 0.007891158573329449, -0.07299423217773438, 0.01153914537280798, 0.01069705467671156, 0.03854667767882347, -0.007476826664060354, -0.031920384615659714, 0.02408512681722641, -0.047693781554698944, 0.008945723995566368, 0.022544248029589653, 0.03112921118736267, -0.03864366561174393, 0.05343087017536163, -0.025163277983665466, -0.05863313004374504, 0.0014369008131325245, -0.0224918145686388, -0.05861465632915497, 0.001604500925168395, 0.02338338829576969, 0.045869164168834686, 0.030494244769215584, -0.0381428487598896, 0.04269769415259361, 0.010705680586397648, 0.06307317316532135, -0.027986612170934677, 0.03623909503221512, 0.0012949513038620353, -0.03983938321471214, 0.02101345919072628, 0.002941409358754754, -0.03829900547862053, 0.014572430402040482, -0.03460624814033508, 0.004064332693815231, -0.009093751199543476, -0.060338135808706284, 0.04440108686685562, -0.03789651021361351, 0.03590447083115578, 0.047800008207559586, -0.05373845621943474, -0.0075762574560940266, -0.03819020092487335, -0.0059875077567994595, -0.007755117956548929, -0.03488133102655411, -0.0023006354458630085, -0.04136136546730995, 0.01989535614848137, -0.0605308823287487, -0.00787691492587328, -0.027457240968942642, -0.012104153633117676, -0.029946988448500633, 0.06927275657653809, 0.002982576610520482, -0.01601542718708515, 0.005399433430284262, -0.025067580863833427, 0.0011012488976120949, -0.06135036051273346, -0.0735776498913765, -0.036773111671209335, 0.03192562237381935, -0.017289496958255768, -0.008189449086785316, 0.028261300176382065, 0.055926740169525146, -0.012343266978859901, 0.0142333609983325, -0.004491159226745367, -0.0013532954035326838, -0.040417857468128204, 0.07938791066408157, -0.03158446028828621, 0.045224644243717194, -0.008962055668234825, 0.03020334802567959, -0.024004586040973663, 0.02393442578613758, 0.032698605209589005, 0.013012952171266079, 0.004237723536789417, -0.08026038110256195, 0.005323649384081364, 0.01416675467044115, -0.032215919345617294, 0.008847997523844242, -0.0007653982029296458, 0.0071693602949380875, -0.036177944391965866, -0.03983655199408531 ]
Sonification as a complement of visualization is been under research for decades as a new ways of data deployment. ICAD conferences, gather together specialists from different disciplines to discuss about sonification. Different tools as sonoUno, starSound and Web Sandbox are attempt to reach a tool to open astronomical data sets and sonify it in conjunction to visualization. In this contribution, the sonoUno web version is presented, this version allows user to explore data sets without any installation. The data can be uploaded or a pre-loaded file can be opened, the sonification and the visual characteristics of the plot can be customized on the same window. The plot, sound and marks can be saved. The web interface were tested with the main used screen readers in order to confirm their good performance.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00081v1
[ -0.045977331697940826, -0.05165606737136841, 0.0044380901381373405, -0.012704592198133469, 0.003384637413546443, 0.0016001532785594463, 0.0409611314535141, -0.019123166799545288, -0.023701025173068047, 0.011645191349089146, -0.033481698483228683, 0.04653201997280121, -0.05822885036468506, -0.056159086525440216, 0.010628917254507542, 0.01761879026889801, 0.057473644614219666, -0.021466363221406937, -0.05660879239439964, 0.0489237979054451, -0.0051560248248279095, -0.01581365242600441, 0.020122261717915535, -0.03962335363030434, 0.004545684438198805, -0.012354536913335323, -0.02542155794799328, 0.044606778770685196, -0.03030502237379551, 0.006838147062808275, 0.0651659294962883, -0.025055022910237312, -0.028290193527936935, 0.00979478470981121, -0.034305673092603683, -0.03733805567026138, -0.04012599587440491, 0.037739742547273636, -0.036037422716617584, -0.04326474666595459, -0.001040357630699873, -0.08221039175987244, -0.0542902909219265, 0.04574539139866829, -0.033946726471185684, -0.02274509333074093, -0.016398301348090172, 0.007558321580290794, -0.08749739080667496, -0.030855048447847366, -0.017742855474352837, -0.0043179951608181, 0.03475324064493179, 0.05250309407711029, 0.059740908443927765, 0.007276855409145355, 0.012903828173875809, -0.01533761527389288, -0.022399840876460075, 0.043944280594587326, 0.03508351370692253, -0.07152380794286728, 0.008452310226857662, -0.017872102558612823, 0.0075825899839401245, 0.03619781881570816, -0.06140235811471939, -0.059724606573581696, -0.019445480778813362, 0.004106222651898861, 0.0067445626482367516, -0.0670485571026802, -0.03624426946043968, -0.000304735527606681, -0.051036808639764786, -0.005591745022684336, 0.009674700908362865, -0.02434392459690571, -0.0104666193947196, 0.013902508653700352, -0.01137339137494564, -0.01226897444576025, 0.039955057203769684, 0.0727350115776062, 0.04173049330711365, 0.02109077200293541, -0.024702351540327072, 0.028095195069909096, 0.03442537412047386, -0.030179310590028763, 0.01450428832322359, -0.02505199983716011, -0.0917513370513916, 0.029621487483382225, 0.08589170128107071, 0.02224966511130333, 0.04032348841428757, 0.005597532261162996, -0.06421443074941635, -0.03667120635509491, -0.04347575083374977, -0.019897814840078354, -0.04524891451001167, 0.041299980133771896, 0.0151589410379529, -0.02977147325873375, 0.012534928508102894, -0.005300035234540701, -0.026127692312002182, 0.050172969698905945, 0.03390553221106529, 0.028162015601992607, -0.02551557682454586, -0.055904701352119446, 0.003487291978672147, -0.03640624135732651, 0.03141273558139801, 0.012544739991426468, 0.008104287087917328, -0.039634790271520615, 0.015318379737436771, 0.016376273706555367, 0.011439479887485504, -0.008978852070868015, -0.022282063961029053, -0.005236268043518066, 0.06125630810856819, 0.000734389410354197, 0.008340150117874146, -0.02699478715658188, -0.034195151180028915, 0.0392654649913311, -0.033918656408786774, -0.02753181755542755, 0.03432268276810646, -0.01669357717037201, -0.017903955653309822, -0.04166753590106964, -0.01024627685546875, 0.010503175668418407, -0.050493743270635605, -0.0452251173555851, -0.002888841088861227, -0.021927231922745705, 0.04021899774670601, -0.03132835030555725, -0.029800254851579666, 0.015440213494002819, -0.005004776641726494, 0.06071878597140312, 0.014162927865982056, -0.006323952693492174, 0.06672252714633942, -0.006498859729617834, -0.024646731093525887, -0.04681260511279106, -0.017767271026968956, -0.034217603504657745, -0.03273797035217285, 0.057622894644737244, 0.02388550341129303, 0.023922884836792946, 0.014414424076676369, -0.0520109161734581, -0.05206193029880524, -0.00337508087977767, 0.030065404251217842, -0.02989579550921917, 0.004159615375101566, 0.05499470233917236, -0.06406944245100021, -0.01733236014842987, -0.038271576166152954, 0.012080632150173187, -0.005372979212552309, 0.01085043977946043, -0.023127872496843338, -0.05405031889677048, 0.000753547705244273, -0.003679250832647085, -0.051925573498010635, 0.019205914810299873, 0.034521859139204025, -0.03215552121400833, 0.00750739686191082, 0.014924101531505585, -0.06511019915342331, -0.029163606464862823, 0.03484336659312248, -0.03478459268808365, -0.05345983803272247, -0.04322275146842003, 0.0007512489682994783, -0.014938446693122387, -0.015277571976184845, 0.005848002154380083, -0.04439220577478409, -0.034725695848464966, 0.00017152247892227024, 0.03107682801783085, -0.04995085299015045, -0.013684122823178768, -0.05888845771551132, -0.0015898806741461158, 0.019688958302140236, -0.07373034954071045, -0.027628527954220772, 0.018545493483543396, -0.05832762271165848, 0.0019761330913752317, -0.0029519679956138134, 0.016550397500395775, 0.06860101222991943, 0.010481142438948154, 0.04174061864614487, 0.0052660671062767506, -0.10337390750646591, 0.04080915078520775, 0.012444797903299332, -0.01545464526861906, 0.03373308479785919, 0.04667557403445244, 0.003313136752694845, -0.011628183536231518, -0.05829598382115364, 0.019839776679873466, 0.03414576128125191, -0.02552352286875248, -0.08543313294649124, -0.051398348063230515, -0.012101181782782078, -0.023949777707457542, -0.019843189045786858, -0.046668507158756256, -0.057698365300893784, -0.010022051632404327, -0.01337309367954731, 0.006371420808136463, -0.016867641359567642, -0.0030509878415614367, -0.010614728555083275, -0.03494999185204506, 0.03237174078822136, -0.04446499049663544, -0.046307358890771866, -0.030823253095149994, -0.011213904246687889, 0.0161737073212862, -0.010911495424807072, -0.00297144684009254, 0.01251227967441082, -0.06137041002511978, -0.010416010394692421, 0.006720979232341051, 0.07391520589590073, 0.0081064123660326, -0.05029550567269325, 0.03881297633051872, -0.011305112391710281, 0.053029146045446396, 0.009358608163893223, 0.021602071821689606, -0.0705743283033371, -0.00747251883149147, 0.01834079809486866, 0.016360383480787277, 0.005350629333406687, -0.062480516731739044, 0.005393129773437977, -0.042235203087329865, -0.0001415118749719113, 0.013887573033571243, 0.05505000427365303, -0.03381619602441788, -0.04142262786626816, -0.05430615693330765, 0.024092426523566246, 0.026389751583337784, 0.028553316369652748, 0.06478677690029144, -0.012129073962569237, 0.0014796943869441748, 0.0038069162983447313, -0.04249133914709091, -0.0012374140787869692, -0.07000675797462463, -0.03273306414484978, -0.054823264479637146, -0.030656181275844574, 0.011655359528958797, -0.06173066422343254, 0.005760480649769306, -0.04283317178487778, -0.012383205816149712, -0.05156642198562622, -0.07631313055753708, 0.020215490832924843, 0.019460340961813927, 0.06533640623092651, 0.06878315657377243, -0.022273123264312744, 0.02520023286342621, 0.003523424966260791, -0.01574300043284893, -0.04418563097715378, -0.010309633798897266, -0.031147832050919533, 0.026232779026031494, -0.02271169237792492, -0.024344520643353462, 0.014054539613425732, 0.06236598268151283, -0.023516815155744553, -0.012869183905422688, 0.03624458983540535, -0.0014035063795745373, 0.013061143457889557, 0.02209002710878849, -0.003775795456022024, -0.05462287738919258, -0.026980487629771233, -0.03371529281139374, -0.01217743381857872, -0.038022127002477646, -0.038785725831985474, -0.05424076318740845, 0.03587552160024643, -0.00998426228761673, -0.037664953619241714, -0.047073859721422195, -0.005982191767543554, 0.02185000106692314, 0.009613770060241222, -0.014244602993130684, 0.010935924015939236, 0.053237807005643845, 0.007501866202801466, -0.021865960210561752, -0.02501532807946205, 0.023122645914554596, -0.03366304934024811, 0.02944624237716198, -0.056429073214530945, -0.019911009818315506, 0.032711710780858994, -0.09076102823019028, 0.015810249373316765, 0.036676499992609024, 0.07160703092813492, 0.026361417025327682, 0.0636044293642044, 0.019473286345601082, 0.025307612493634224, 0.0630270391702652, -0.01436995342373848, -0.009142537601292133, 0.019247431308031082, 0.02007332816720009, -0.04958239197731018, -0.04556656256318092, 0.020623229444026947, -0.06305490434169769, -0.0164675023406744, 0.003942031413316727, 0.024800056591629982, 0.01721620187163353, 0.04657901078462601, -0.06521148234605789, -0.02237858809530735, -0.023524155840277672, 0.02081659622490406, -0.013543209061026573, -0.0297529473900795, -0.025116343051195145, -0.04576391726732254, 0.051451023668050766, -0.04557907581329346, -0.011556681245565414, -0.004845624789595604, -0.034045375883579254, 0.03336493670940399, -0.06755641847848892, 0.032463256269693375, -0.010206542909145355, -0.002041475148871541, 0.005534336436539888, 0.020287955179810524, -0.0265432670712471, 0.04082881286740303, -0.006852986756712198, 0.04260122776031494, -0.019724292680621147, 0.007074698805809021, -0.06364777684211731, -0.00360988755710423, 0.02386939711868763, -0.018479259684681892, -0.02880730852484703, -0.0445965901017189, -0.02282150834798813, 0.011488751508295536, -0.001584122539497912, 0.06669516116380692, -0.05388819798827171, -0.034731652587652206, -0.009674841538071632, 0.038847923278808594, -0.03028913028538227, -0.015242322348058224, 0.04161839932203293, -0.055045247077941895, 0.014508838765323162, -0.00500218803063035, 0.017936820164322853, -0.021884892135858536, -0.010063935071229935, 0.018840376287698746, -0.0742865726351738, -0.022480817511677742, -0.001616663415916264, 0.06053466722369194, 0.03660375997424126, 0.06571061164140701, -0.0036217288579791784, 0.02675958164036274, -0.02364363521337509, -0.0013631650945171714, 0.04474494606256485, -0.007497203070670366, 0.02053878642618656, -0.012604903429746628, 0.04848349094390869, 0.07027497887611389, 0.061156220734119415, 0.0357498824596405, -0.013934683986008167, 0.034171756356954575, -0.006980420555919409, -0.003065437776967883, 0.026241229847073555, -0.04591327905654907, 0.030588462948799133, -0.006643553730100393, -0.05931984260678291, 0.032372500747442245, -0.04729646444320679, -0.019050361588597298, -0.03934162110090256, -0.03915421664714813, -0.05671272426843643, -0.0771930143237114, -0.04277931898832321, 0.00389846065081656, 0.04862477630376816, -0.0011456040665507317, 0.022042401134967804, 0.06297091394662857, 0.031065650284290314, 0.011717652902007103, -0.010666437447071075, 0.028409002348780632, -0.006556143052875996, -0.033034227788448334, -0.026581749320030212, -0.07228627800941467, 0.03166935592889786, -0.02953392267227173, -0.02950672246515751, 0.038857944309711456, -0.03509673476219177, 0.010824989527463913, 0.07350686937570572, -0.06605415791273117, 0.061874568462371826, 0.07925333082675934, -0.018762914463877678, -0.011413655243813992, 0.0236363522708416, 0.03825300931930542, 0.03168007731437683, -0.03521832078695297, 0.008192292414605618, -0.0003971408004872501, -0.0032039824873209, 0.03396774083375931, 0.03637292981147766, -0.02004009298980236, -0.0019599825609475374, 0.017356304451823235, -0.025580406188964844, 0.015034262090921402, -0.004168551415205002, 0.04896741360425949, 0.039952345192432404, -0.008265352807939053, 0.008540191687643528, 0.05142612382769585, -0.00853830948472023, -0.01728983409702778, 0.006652660667896271, -0.055811524391174316, -0.014450807124376297, 0.031099747866392136, -0.030035484582185745, -0.01868469826877117, 0.0316259041428566, 0.008710518479347229, -0.006279509048908949, 0.001952941296622157, 0.02364674024283886, 0.019416777417063713, -0.015486357733607292, -0.07340174913406372, -0.026976533234119415, -0.021642081439495087, 0.03531074523925781, 0.010634486563503742, 0.018311284482479095, 0.0045150816440582275, 0.06114785745739937, 0.015052962116897106, -0.002582862740382552, 0.018982328474521637, 0.013096313923597336, -0.05776837840676308, -0.04424412548542023, 0.016455115750432014, 0.03369883820414543, -0.005719408858567476, -0.03336234390735626, 0.019313035532832146, 0.0642424151301384, 0.006996932439506054, 0.0540567971765995, -0.04186089709401131, 0.018003087490797043, 0.01889057829976082, -0.033392831683158875, -0.03537490963935852, -0.004510391503572464, -0.024808984249830246, -0.015989845618605614, 0.04183065891265869, 0.04333880916237831, -0.002893359400331974, 0.04651331529021263, 0.015912048518657684, 0.014954332262277603, -0.05979977548122406, -0.04894058778882027, 0.015715466812253, -0.0349733829498291, 0.01740683801472187, -0.013662935234606266, -0.01699017360806465, 0.0413861982524395, -0.03779374435544014, 0.02792854607105255, 0.042875200510025024, 0.00962423998862505, -0.051662594079971313, 0.06279383599758148, -0.027367115020751953, -0.07426588982343674, 0.06046992912888527, -0.01007014885544777, -0.07436320185661316, 0.003009672509506345, 0.0032273780088871717, 0.02117164060473442, 0.007475131191313267, 0.01477757841348648, -0.030092287808656693, 0.033841945230960846, -0.01815038174390793, 0.052855148911476135, 0.06433156132698059, -0.005027275998145342, -0.03739512339234352, -0.00602097250521183, -0.046590983867645264, -0.04391184076666832, 0.021690215915441513, 0.05649872496724129, -0.007069560699164867, 0.026467984542250633, -0.001610928331501782, -0.04434293508529663, -0.014952640980482101, -0.02619890123605728, -0.05371953174471855, -0.05466664209961891, -0.007117883302271366, 0.0014298682799562812, 0.05161341279745102, -0.03166241943836212, -0.04912187531590462, 0.0075899153016507626, -0.016127850860357285, 0.027881383895874023, -0.008036705665290356, 0.0047704437747597694, -0.03827507421374321, 0.040201377123594284, 0.050074394792318344, -0.06323686242103577, 0.003976097330451012, -0.016215642914175987, -0.07319089770317078, 0.046982064843177795, -0.08465608954429626, -0.009120202623307705, -0.03543814271688461, 0.0164090096950531, 0.0629928782582283, 0.04162789508700371, -0.04525303095579147, -0.0489749051630497, 0.0016658494714647532, 0.018851041793823242, 0.024007542058825493, 0.0028588061686605215, -0.011875729076564312, -0.00046796101378276944, 0.029077516868710518, -0.048478517681360245, -0.06716764718294144, 0.011645667254924774, -0.021282969042658806, 0.022959845140576363, -0.05355878546833992, -0.0197384562343359, -0.014277128502726555, -0.0013039292534813285, -0.03343947231769562, -0.041955944150686264, 0.047175243496894836, -0.06116693094372749, -0.06386127322912216, -0.0558362640440464, -0.03530982881784439, -0.018925465643405914, -0.011988707818090916, 0.039202217012643814, 0.06565725058317184, -0.007161926478147507, 0.07253243029117584, -0.012054462917149067, 0.0045705013908445835, -0.02954849787056446, -0.03227351978421211, -0.04643965885043144, -0.02573337033390999, -0.010483553633093834, -0.03412262722849846, -0.06894630938768387, 0.002513321815058589, -0.0600530169904232, 0.0312749445438385, 0.03340785205364227, -0.04423482343554497, -0.0018624146468937397, -0.015430287458002567, 0.04412868246436119, -0.005889454390853643, 0.004953337367624044, -0.029569806531071663, -0.01978987269103527, -0.030951010063290596, -0.061116959899663925, 0.030363429337739944, -0.010450256988406181, -0.037530943751335144, 0.028671367093920708, -0.05388539656996727, 0.01267736405134201, 0.04441022872924805, 0.010137675330042839, -0.012196602299809456, -0.006182303186506033, 0.06183704361319542, -0.027731304988265038, -0.04853687435388565, -0.03564624488353729, 0.05692542716860771, -0.021289650350809097, -0.03543298318982124, -0.04012608155608177, -0.004348400514572859, 0.023479683324694633, -0.0010351110249757767, -0.03989379480481148, -0.015817973762750626, -0.008350974880158901, 0.017557114362716675, -0.012923797592520714, -0.0015896281693130732, 0.012973329983651638, -0.028512028977274895, 0.029684660956263542, -0.06833939999341965, 0.04264424741268158, 0.00681530125439167, -0.04557637870311737, 0.04105406999588013, -0.012934764847159386, -0.03991246223449707, -0.025009147822856903, -0.06944651901721954, 0.04422346502542496, -0.04591575264930725, -0.04860693961381912, -0.04154043644666672, -0.03984496742486954, -0.03641001507639885, 0.07270695269107819, -0.041230686008930206, -0.02426263503730297, -0.033684033900499344, 0.026578040793538094, -0.029957998543977737, 0.026113590225577354, 0.03953259438276291, -0.060928408056497574, -0.037084948271512985, -0.0022638188675045967, -0.02347998321056366, -0.056906186044216156, -0.029224086552858353, -0.056466031819581985, 0.016452662646770477, -0.021477842703461647, -0.023484377190470695, -0.07333647459745407, -0.010116290301084518, 0.005655498243868351, -0.0542195700109005, -0.06378400325775146, -0.052786216139793396, 0.03629520162940025, -0.040798380970954895, -0.0011758643668144941, 0.026845058426260948, 0.045400142669677734, -0.009292986243963242, 0.00612687086686492, 0.0036190920509397984, 0.018396377563476562, -0.009076542221009731, -0.014852476306259632, 0.0273185633122921, 0.03702045604586601, 0.005688761826604605, 0.032783184200525284, 0.014446020126342773, -0.04598597064614296, 0.0035133082419633865, 0.02712837979197502, 0.013368739746510983, -0.035361845046281815, 0.05646578222513199, 0.03803827241063118, -0.010951627977192402, -0.009857195429503918, -0.03458475321531296, 0.039338305592536926, 0.005627012811601162, -0.08107125759124756 ]
We investigate the internal behavior of Transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs) when they generate factually incorrect text. We propose modeling factual queries as constraint satisfaction problems and use this framework to investigate how the LLM interacts internally with factual constraints. We find a strong positive relationship between the LLM's attention to constraint tokens and the factual accuracy of generations. We curate a suite of 10 datasets containing over 40,000 prompts to study the task of predicting factual errors with the Llama-2 family across all scales (7B, 13B, 70B). We propose SAT Probe, a method probing attention patterns, that can predict factual errors and fine-grained constraint satisfaction, and allow early error identification. The approach and findings take another step towards using the mechanistic understanding of LLMs to enhance their reliability.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15098v2
[ -0.03891265392303467, -0.023912575095891953, 0.0692179724574089, 0.019090985879302025, 0.019426267594099045, -0.003856002353131771, -0.03870726749300957, 0.012433251366019249, -0.03245703503489494, -0.03571409732103348, -0.07128722220659256, 0.015871617943048477, -0.05320866405963898, -0.020327188074588776, -0.03388477861881256, -0.00864504650235176, 0.025855431333184242, -0.005062340758740902, -0.051511865109205246, 0.031096838414669037, -0.01172808650881052, 0.003948975820094347, -0.07042404264211655, 0.018735110759735107, 0.03738312050700188, -0.02673702873289585, 0.01945679821074009, 0.008762206882238388, -0.016707023605704308, -0.041445158421993256, 0.06577549129724503, -0.03611311316490173, -0.013900293968617916, -0.02513231337070465, -0.03274492546916008, -0.013018853031098843, 0.003702710848301649, -0.04375358670949936, 0.05419383943080902, -0.041492342948913574, -0.0021835952065885067, 0.018307948485016823, -0.0700625330209732, -0.03126482293009758, -0.04837929084897041, -0.005467171315103769, 0.00982681941241026, 0.0200232844799757, -0.06474088877439499, -0.061086833477020264, 0.020631683990359306, -0.008407625369727612, -0.016984395682811737, 0.041261982172727585, -0.03906878083944321, -0.0026910104788839817, 0.011727418750524521, -0.012312439270317554, -0.0707535520195961, 0.007341807242482901, 0.045534417033195496, -0.043682001531124115, 0.0038696513511240482, 0.028340788558125496, 0.02023407071828842, 0.010343383066356182, -0.037210650742053986, -0.02002107724547386, 0.015457935631275177, -0.019769901409745216, 0.04745781421661377, -0.035312309861183167, -0.01309124007821083, 0.026260167360305786, 0.01976866088807583, -0.02258368767797947, -0.028975222259759903, -0.02572370320558548, -0.03423222154378891, 0.009791544638574123, -0.05444762855768204, 0.01994284801185131, 0.06074266880750656, 0.026475215330719948, 0.025536349043250084, -0.04909045249223709, 0.0608571358025074, -0.02356208674609661, 0.00473024370148778, -0.03583144396543503, 0.03553368151187897, -0.014760328456759453, -0.07625258713960648, -0.052543122321367264, 0.05532805249094963, -0.01946113631129265, 0.03993348777294159, 0.018040530383586884, 0.001017628121189773, -0.039636898785829544, -0.03311598673462868, -0.014197965152561665, -0.007674743887037039, 0.04746294766664505, 0.04104810208082199, -0.027633344754576683, 0.0033448697067797184, 0.007235541939735413, -0.051555924117565155, -0.016915980726480484, -0.05100380629301071, -0.036328572779893875, 0.020653188228607178, -0.04941893741488457, -0.07038774341344833, -0.028368743136525154, 0.05441322922706604, 0.005711210425943136, -0.008625867776572704, 0.03562510758638382, -0.06644630432128906, 0.04779573157429695, 0.017511948943138123, -0.039671190083026886, -0.03227104991674423, -0.029065964743494987, 0.002904352266341448, 0.04101429134607315, -0.031054284423589706, -0.0411483533680439, -0.0542922168970108, -0.01705830544233322, -0.016596166417002678, -0.03799555450677872, 0.06610451638698578, -0.04414621740579605, -0.03435364365577698, -0.046201132237911224, 0.024883843958377838, -0.013286186382174492, -0.03761232644319534, -0.05631377547979355, 0.05851089581847191, -0.022324424237012863, -0.007441244088113308, 0.07176780700683594, -0.027334898710250854, 0.00019283362780697644, 0.031884245574474335, 0.008200576528906822, 0.003485033754259348, -0.03107566200196743, -0.00947269145399332, 0.02699805423617363, 0.05271689593791962, -0.01312658004462719, 0.05534111708402634, -0.025732632726430893, -0.05859415605664253, 0.011113757267594337, 0.026474833488464355, -0.05648493021726608, 0.049707576632499695, -0.011988891288638115, 0.0008730238769203424, 0.007739521563053131, 0.03510316461324692, 0.003619537455961108, -0.023231487721204758, -0.018054625019431114, 0.0079065952450037, -0.004375337157398462, 0.009076440706849098, -0.005537748336791992, -0.07978656142950058, -0.037865836173295975, 0.0008974099764600396, -0.04379677399992943, -0.04012934863567352, 0.015229777432978153, 0.02574855647981167, 0.046685487031936646, -0.03872399777173996, 0.001924722921103239, -0.02661597542464733, 0.023053426295518875, -0.08038294315338135, -0.04254063591361046, 0.022678418084979057, 0.01926286332309246, -0.06557032465934753, -0.031694937497377396, 0.04097915068268776, 0.0018246243707835674, -0.025912854820489883, -0.0369352325797081, 0.034803055226802826, 0.032200392335653305, 0.03588470444083214, 0.04589252173900604, -0.09249146282672882, 0.024915961548686028, -0.042439546436071396, 0.021684683859348297, -0.03807315602898598, -0.06739708036184311, 0.020704952999949455, 0.033156368881464005, -0.016132421791553497, 0.01697944849729538, 0.06469742208719254, 0.014979544095695019, 0.03344595804810524, 0.03587090224027634, 0.02420666813850403, 0.036675211042165756, -0.10596031695604324, 0.06490346789360046, 0.05256214365363121, -0.00034421533928252757, 0.023992329835891724, 0.00200640712864697, 0.01142542902380228, 0.012538614682853222, 0.002602157648652792, 0.01651052013039589, 0.03054800070822239, 0.0010163254337385297, -0.025187278166413307, -0.010966413654386997, -0.02280590869486332, -0.08019762486219406, -0.03199143707752228, -0.0513387992978096, -0.005857341457158327, 0.024421509355306625, -0.04191678389906883, 0.01869363710284233, -0.0034280705731362104, -0.01591424085199833, -0.014109211973845959, -0.028817927464842796, 0.03402465581893921, -0.04173962399363518, -0.049091849476099014, -0.022344443947076797, -0.003509123343974352, 0.02123800292611122, -0.031144626438617706, 0.04112410172820091, -0.0428573340177536, -0.041763946413993835, 0.000009751498510013334, -0.02310328744351864, 0.005830981303006411, 0.05305078625679016, -0.008182689547538757, 0.005657699424773455, 0.01555059663951397, 0.07549748569726944, 0.023825369775295258, 0.048394255340099335, -0.04188936576247215, 0.004464630037546158, 0.025237370282411575, -0.02694794163107872, -0.0030427651945501566, 0.0076091354712843895, -0.00730701070278883, 0.008210215717554092, 0.023446885868906975, 0.049757134169340134, 0.05876533314585686, 0.004491358529776335, -0.06582915782928467, 0.005658786278218031, -0.007289526052772999, 0.009332639165222645, 0.03696397691965103, 0.06392873078584671, 0.05497677996754646, -0.020847806707024574, -0.011449641548097134, -0.06545808166265488, 0.012842689640820026, -0.04820415750145912, -0.026522209867835045, -0.08183465152978897, -0.05745925381779671, -0.0027044161688536406, -0.07669737190008163, -0.013560027815401554, -0.02919798530638218, -0.023408515378832817, -0.03611067309975624, -0.03101467341184616, -0.02646125853061676, 0.0030380520038306713, 0.025255296379327774, -0.06401418149471283, -0.019270634278655052, -0.032471656799316406, -0.012988140806555748, 0.021410444751381874, -0.001342891831882298, -0.05104869231581688, -0.05071079730987549, -0.0013596686767414212, 0.054123904556035995, -0.027449702844023705, -0.04783029854297638, 0.04962892085313797, -0.0011623724130913615, 0.04016706719994545, -0.008603009395301342, 0.05999681353569031, -0.026126006618142128, 0.02790611796081066, 0.016132159158587456, 0.024027299135923386, 0.010931153781712055, 0.0024874547962099314, -0.0034945111256092787, -0.03128989040851593, -0.04099028557538986, 0.005353483371436596, 0.07212807238101959, 0.02719569392502308, -0.005247517954558134, -0.02122795209288597, 0.008176679722964764, 0.023335440084338188, 0.007308983709663153, 0.01774432696402073, 0.026559924706816673, 0.07356768846511841, -0.042614299803972244, -0.03071150742471218, 0.0011568026384338737, -0.014696209691464901, -0.02043776586651802, -0.001232712995260954, 0.001771388459019363, -0.03510351479053497, 0.047884028404951096, -0.08694124966859818, 0.036528076976537704, 0.0608205609023571, 0.07462746649980545, 0.003003606339916587, 0.017545629292726517, 0.040807466953992844, 0.036217741668224335, 0.039829980581998825, -0.03092772886157036, 0.016842780634760857, 0.04813853278756142, 0.05831010267138481, -0.03033844567835331, -0.03122817724943161, 0.011541477404534817, -0.06417255848646164, -0.06478279829025269, -0.012259479612112045, 0.022762976586818695, 0.012351546436548233, 0.049990635365247726, -0.07769662141799927, 0.05812060460448265, 0.010182100348174572, 0.04442025348544121, 0.03524821624159813, -0.040518566966056824, 0.03624916821718216, -0.046058643609285355, 0.04675627872347832, -0.0001446205424144864, -0.013287335634231567, -0.013995534740388393, -0.039161067456007004, -0.019276753067970276, -0.07885400205850601, 0.03778764605522156, 0.02479587495326996, -0.033457089215517044, 0.06127377599477768, 0.02279639057815075, -0.029355250298976898, 0.030585523694753647, -0.04292897507548332, -0.011091466061770916, 0.026104824617505074, -0.004174157045781612, -0.030918054282665253, -0.011918251402676105, -0.05934463441371918, 0.0017254517879337072, 0.03410501778125763, -0.035054322332143784, 0.0035304406192153692, -0.014487742446362972, -0.012452127411961555, -0.01473370473831892, -0.08778402209281921, -0.020888639613986015, -0.04758231341838837, 0.008152267895638943, -0.004108480643481016, -0.010584870353341103, 0.06310150027275085, -0.02866269461810589, -0.035687465220689774, 0.006917247083038092, 0.00982559286057949, -0.023678166791796684, -0.04554738849401474, -0.02729753777384758, -0.058214277029037476, -0.014150673523545265, -0.06985095888376236, 0.03054286725819111, -0.0028817709535360336, 0.009228454902768135, -0.02882288210093975, -0.004795291926711798, -0.004671589005738497, 0.04452686011791229, 0.06595095247030258, 0.006709275767207146, 0.012241475284099579, -0.013191116973757744, 0.040617842227220535, -0.021047722548246384, 0.006312904879450798, -0.020598560571670532, 0.017661169171333313, 0.024646321311593056, -0.03200167790055275, 0.0089256064966321, 0.026190582662820816, 0.0157548189163208, 0.03478172793984413, -0.02078322134912014, -0.010360293090343475, -0.0033342805691063404, 0.06084079667925835, -0.02407541684806347, -0.061191678047180176, -0.031072640791535378, -0.037715524435043335, -0.04491982236504555, -0.02535456046462059, 0.01036022137850523, 0.04346930980682373, 0.007868765853345394, -0.005656614433974028, -0.030246498063206673, 0.013042192906141281, -0.003550925524905324, 0.011767092160880566, 0.008963314816355705, -0.0031904352363198996, 0.038347888737916946, 0.0073568131774663925, -0.07962465286254883, -0.00504279276356101, -0.02187991328537464, -0.022313708439469337, -0.003939657472074032, 0.04310709238052368, 0.0020000238437205553, 0.0536031574010849, -0.07636707276105881, 0.036001477390527725, 0.04509107768535614, -0.016282612457871437, -0.019656194373965263, 0.041612766683101654, -0.017368854954838753, -0.013505679555237293, -0.04543503746390343, 0.006827380042523146, -0.008483855985105038, -0.027733707800507545, 0.03973102942109108, 0.04302232339978218, -0.0039005165454000235, -0.004103542771190405, 0.05454150587320328, 0.054860059171915054, -0.0559169203042984, -0.015896666795015335, 0.036884333938360214, 0.06695137172937393, -0.05493678152561188, 0.012833312153816223, 0.07469040900468826, -0.024247655645012856, -0.05105024576187134, 0.007589013781398535, 0.008730434812605381, 0.055723536759614944, 0.001151269068941474, -0.04378153383731842, -0.006005164235830307, -0.02323467843234539, -0.043206654489040375, -0.01926383562386036, 0.03590751066803932, 0.024791371077299118, 0.007459052838385105, -0.00017351748829241842, -0.003444628557190299, -0.08111152052879333, 0.013007777743041515, -0.05211491882801056, -0.0012763625709339976, 0.07494819164276123, 0.04369601234793663, 0.007189163938164711, 0.017751311883330345, -0.00435149110853672, -0.04763007536530495, -0.01453429739922285, -0.012645033188164234, 0.02773665264248848, -0.013640683144330978, 0.039737518876791, -0.032413143664598465, 0.05615207925438881, 0.04043770954012871, 0.04717276245355606, -0.018323801457881927, 0.020784882828593254, -0.014685316942632198, -0.004648198839277029, 0.02974584884941578, -0.03843279927968979, -0.029420483857393265, 0.045771773904561996, -0.019472314044833183, -0.03825189918279648, 0.0013912820722907782, -0.004016497638076544, -0.03968366980552673, 0.030094755813479424, 0.03509503975510597, -0.045045558363199234, -0.07058529555797577, -0.014662086963653564, 0.07367566227912903, -0.048303425312042236, 0.02525058574974537, -0.0037211598828434944, -0.039363421499729156, 0.0012213303707540035, -0.021519608795642853, -0.04400661587715149, 0.02730395831167698, 0.04027320072054863, -0.05734303221106529, 0.06250869482755661, 0.024193421006202698, -0.05304757505655289, 0.011122113093733788, -0.01054193452000618, -0.09613561630249023, -0.0046582878567278385, -0.00007800965977367014, 0.02317979745566845, -0.028892967849969864, 0.027104446664452553, -0.0023179908748716116, -0.01346710603684187, -0.03936995938420296, 0.06130615249276161, 0.08692445605993271, 0.004046905320137739, 0.012837291695177555, 0.025351883843541145, -0.02698918804526329, 0.00918162427842617, -0.03178822249174118, -0.032642483711242676, 0.016656488180160522, 0.04597017541527748, 0.04947658255696297, -0.02982296422123909, 0.013318144716322422, 0.05989186093211174, 0.01414557546377182, -0.00006018603016855195, 0.0248624999076128, -0.0030832872726023197, 0.01682807318866253, -0.0010579475201666355, -0.030112963169813156, 0.011966214515268803, -0.017666608095169067, -0.024215752258896828, -0.06320622563362122, 0.02078913524746895, 0.0011099000694230199, 0.028833147138357162, -0.02251191809773445, -0.0637829527258873, 0.005079756025224924, 0.008843604475259781, -0.0702664852142334, 0.023337090387940407, -0.058514244854450226, 0.0033462713472545147, 0.013836000114679337, 0.010274234227836132, 0.039452243596315384, 0.028530018404126167, -0.050774283707141876, -0.04847000911831856, -0.003111459780484438, 0.04474090039730072, -0.004722381941974163, -0.018579760566353798, 0.018116354942321777, -0.034509316086769104, 0.008657628670334816, -0.05885866656899452, -0.02000921219587326, -0.026646459475159645, -0.039916589856147766, 0.020067820325493813, 0.0259848702698946, 0.041294775903224945, -0.057824794203042984, 0.0012998864986002445, -0.01296741608530283, 0.027616672217845917, 0.00045753689482808113, -0.06042036786675453, -0.048651013523340225, 0.019409161061048508, 0.002655481453984976, -0.02848070301115513, 0.02304987981915474, -0.006582410074770451, 0.014543718658387661, -0.03224797919392586, -0.014667433686554432, 0.007830725982785225, -0.01956905610859394, 0.037082597613334656, -0.07424835860729218, 0.021429743617773056, 0.030045460909605026, -0.014935947023332119, -0.015681559219956398, 0.032059021294116974, 0.011651216074824333, -0.05298864096403122, -0.045989084988832474, 0.017114413902163506, 0.0017672603717073798, -0.017169572412967682, -0.05522898584604263, 0.03220182657241821, 0.00880227517336607, -0.06309656798839569, -0.047144871205091476, 0.020858915522694588, -0.003042372642084956, -0.03511938452720642, -0.021379811689257622, -0.05128217115998268, -0.053737346082925797, 0.027961494401097298, -0.0862678810954094, 0.014517291449010372, -0.042555149644613266, 0.012877004221081734, -0.012029101140797138, 0.0028127976693212986, -0.018589625135064125, -0.04052077606320381, 0.039490729570388794, -0.0030526048503816128, -0.010997367091476917, 0.012887995690107346, -0.0007876228773966432, 0.024833954870700836, -0.05958903953433037, -0.01635008305311203, 0.05265246704220772, -0.020553840324282646, -0.03254522755742073, 0.05385594815015793, 0.04018419608473778, -0.014848265796899796, -0.02082066237926483, 0.07016422599554062, -0.043441612273454666, 0.004634452052414417, -0.061046067625284195, 0.017859265208244324, -0.05484257638454437, -0.03364071622490883, 0.04444490000605583, -0.03290967643260956, 0.019946174696087837, 0.044312022626399994, 0.031289175152778625, -0.03960956260561943, -0.01596970297396183, -0.05148573964834213, 0.007257866207510233, 0.003010473446920514, -0.006958462297916412, 0.040046870708465576, -0.0433490090072155, 0.0063414801843464375, -0.03173834830522537, -0.037927910685539246, -0.03252819553017616, 0.031247880309820175, 0.05986412614583969, -0.053941283375024796, 0.02730518952012062, -0.08372403681278229, 0.05006709694862366, -0.012042342685163021, 0.0198796596378088, -0.004935825243592262, 0.06663496047258377, 0.004688345827162266, -0.012735521420836449, -0.007367496378719807, -0.05352352559566498, -0.03664429858326912, -0.05280860885977745, -0.048510633409023285, -0.013481453992426395, 0.041144341230392456, 0.011138633824884892, -0.0018450308125466108, -0.007462360430508852, 0.04630381986498833, -0.004242612514644861, 0.023930085822939873, 0.028086340054869652, -0.004736173432320356, -0.03535405918955803, 0.08438313752412796, 0.0532991923391819, 0.009537864476442337, -0.07101447135210037, -0.018723510205745697, -0.004452209919691086, -0.025407448410987854, 0.022731665521860123, -0.023191317915916443, 0.012150653637945652, -0.05112680047750473, -0.02488096058368683, 0.01221579872071743, -0.043377071619033813, -0.01856916956603527, -0.00951903872191906, 0.028877750039100647, 0.0043088155798614025, -0.0237581729888916 ]
We consider arbitrary bounded discrete time series originating from dynamical system. Without any use of the Fourier transform, we find periodic points which suitably characterizes (i.e. independent of Lyapunov exponent) the corresponding time series. In particular, bounded discrete time series generated by the autoregressive model (without the white noise) is equivalent to a quasi periodic function.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00290v6
[ 0.009657149203121662, -0.011735247448086739, 0.036905113607645035, 0.033141475170850754, 0.05251893773674965, -0.04022636637091637, -0.026802539825439453, -0.0045253378339111805, -0.011270538903772831, 0.020207513123750687, -0.018062973394989967, -0.06837610900402069, -0.026552410796284676, -0.05128809064626694, -0.0715048611164093, 0.003799781436100602, 0.0442323237657547, 0.050301000475883484, -0.06272637844085693, 0.020304324105381966, -0.01672768034040928, -0.03128543868660927, -0.01427528727799654, 0.027596846222877502, -0.05462739244103432, -0.074942447245121, 0.006130010820925236, -0.039209283888339996, -0.060228489339351654, -0.015415772795677185, 0.02160581760108471, 0.020905904471874237, 0.027391253039240837, -0.02915751002728939, -0.042846620082855225, -0.0506817102432251, 0.004069228190928698, 0.00949431024491787, -0.006380369421094656, -0.01255258172750473, -0.026838310062885284, -0.046529099345207214, 0.005924560595303774, -0.031070107594132423, -0.022755537182092667, -0.040133170783519745, -0.044208839535713196, -0.0515877902507782, 0.0044264113530516624, -0.06583243608474731, 0.026373503729701042, -0.0064533730037510395, -0.03293418139219284, 0.00328285014256835, -0.03882830590009689, 0.014514787122607231, 0.015528255142271519, 0.030950088053941727, -0.016635986045002937, -0.003969501703977585, -0.030160151422023773, -0.02082052268087864, -0.010105842724442482, -0.0038764015771448612, -0.006562177557498217, 0.0382210835814476, -0.0548010915517807, -0.03380013629794121, 0.004049084614962339, -0.01121370680630207, -0.016486849635839462, -0.054096024483442307, 0.0031152786687016487, -0.05918745696544647, -0.06763546168804169, -0.009935826994478703, -0.016665004193782806, -0.019454604014754295, 0.021288586780428886, 0.006864689290523529, -0.002269834280014038, -0.029980793595314026, 0.010305387899279594, -0.0005159269785508513, 0.022933384403586388, -0.03556564822793007, 0.016165511682629585, 0.0023030289448797703, -0.021522818133234978, -0.0545581616461277, 0.008435179479420185, -0.031942520290613174, -0.03935307264328003, -0.04624997824430466, 0.005800298880785704, -0.014546134509146214, 0.05865725874900818, 0.041520893573760986, -0.01982387714087963, 0.04503176733851433, -0.012699156068265438, -0.03680714592337608, -0.053792405873537064, 0.03288581222295761, -0.020261850208044052, -0.03980235755443573, -0.024340834468603134, -0.003222346305847168, -0.0597173236310482, 0.0391470268368721, -0.023157667368650436, -0.021851390600204468, -0.05284583941102028, -0.034051548689603806, -0.00596251618117094, -0.05473201349377632, 0.0710485428571701, 0.013123591430485249, 0.04113324359059334, 0.008819283917546272, -0.014325805939733982, -0.04002360999584198, 0.04478877782821655, 0.03822043910622597, -0.05088936910033226, -0.030522435903549194, 0.05140107870101929, 0.02336828038096428, 0.04650939628481865, -0.012416018173098564, 0.015686724334955215, 0.02707856334745884, -0.009411104023456573, 0.01652631163597107, -0.03180583938956261, -0.00026918755611404777, 0.007453248370438814, -0.06205542013049126, -0.011720000766217709, -0.016927845776081085, -0.017901431769132614, -0.021129854023456573, -0.01130704116076231, -0.00876808725297451, 0.03750770911574364, -0.03264625370502472, -0.08204296976327896, 0.008889907039701939, 0.040119800716638565, 0.033674780279397964, -0.02873806096613407, 0.025043750181794167, -0.0027843706775456667, -0.008237630128860474, -0.01873125694692135, -0.012759963050484657, -0.0006830694037489593, 0.009013568051159382, -0.020840223878622055, -0.014673291705548763, -0.03529651090502739, -0.028793439269065857, -0.008917504921555519, 0.0654657632112503, 0.03151581436395645, 0.03771223872900009, 0.04125233739614487, 0.0021959803998470306, -0.0038091521710157394, -0.020219696685671806, -0.07135587185621262, -0.031415171921253204, 0.016398705542087555, -0.047999195754528046, -0.0006969243986532092, -0.025785766541957855, -0.013089340180158615, -0.05665270611643791, 0.004374782554805279, 0.03229323402047157, -0.045233048498630524, 0.0100481566041708, -0.0032458326313644648, -0.018848305568099022, -0.03770451620221138, -0.004689490422606468, -0.021475302055478096, 0.025549696758389473, 0.04641187936067581, 0.01927826553583145, -0.021240832284092903, -0.03716157376766205, -0.04705161601305008, 0.05610772222280502, 0.005415359511971474, -0.017627572640776634, -0.014316566288471222, -0.05311066657304764, -0.014648616313934326, 0.05951767414808273, -0.05409620329737663, -0.04014245793223381, -0.012862314470112324, -0.030019640922546387, -0.036258306354284286, -0.018008636310696602, -0.0011606168700382113, -0.0028684905264526606, -0.05044671893119812, -0.048332277685403824, 0.047266457229852676, 0.0571846179664135, 0.061773285269737244, -0.016424205154180527, -0.02443702146410942, -0.03993288055062294, -0.08576388657093048, 0.019151680171489716, -0.035525523126125336, -0.03925204277038574, 0.004471146035939455, 0.01077310275286436, -0.055645398795604706, -0.013954130932688713, -0.06346754729747772, 0.04083859920501709, 0.024250909686088562, 0.0257746409624815, -0.0174747034907341, -0.05548698455095291, -0.04144890233874321, -0.045262906700372696, -0.06512722373008728, -0.059755221009254456, -0.04308808594942093, 0.046598583459854126, -0.03391603007912636, 0.07188493013381958, -0.0013219575630500913, -0.05418376624584198, -0.08107945322990417, -0.0010994999902322888, 0.038343675434589386, -0.0602889209985733, 0.021366430446505547, -0.05525500699877739, -0.01574283093214035, 0.049020372331142426, -0.05670040845870972, -0.026049140840768814, 0.06790915131568909, -0.06629814207553864, 0.012911894358694553, -0.025344979017972946, -0.030511705204844475, 0.06045403704047203, -0.05481196939945221, 0.06108741834759712, 0.005289334803819656, 0.04811310023069382, 0.0007038527983240783, 0.047621581703424454, -0.04877426475286484, -0.03673027455806732, -0.012547885067760944, -0.018827978521585464, -0.04740804806351662, 0.05112949758768082, -0.04119763523340225, -0.06815573573112488, -0.036056336015462875, -0.011183847673237324, 0.01371375285089016, 0.00032921417732723057, -0.055174849927425385, 0.033808425068855286, 0.0032737390138208866, -0.04105084016919136, 0.030860591679811478, 0.0005407185526564717, 0.010347911156713963, 0.00631495239213109, -0.014939947053790092, -0.05802563205361366, -0.008539510890841484, 0.04168358072638512, -0.014903980307281017, -0.06730729341506958, -0.05654554441571236, -0.058016251772642136, -0.06809034198522568, 0.02845551259815693, -0.03417954593896866, -0.043797221034765244, -0.05054063722491264, -0.030777785927057266, -0.03733372315764427, -0.0021838368847966194, 0.03629518300294876, -0.052834369242191315, -0.07219284027814865, -0.03678704425692558, 0.04870922118425369, -0.05988774821162224, 0.004678128752857447, -0.057173002511262894, -0.030844921246170998, -0.001955364365130663, 0.01978353224694729, 0.022987185046076775, -0.03004242107272148, -0.04510011523962021, -0.025245828554034233, -0.03553757071495056, 0.024068813771009445, -0.024419574066996574, 0.04324212670326233, -0.018295055255293846, 0.03551412373781204, -0.022064192220568657, -0.036456987261772156, 0.013074680231511593, -0.001755400444380939, -0.014527501538395882, -0.04137284681200981, -0.05160427466034889, 0.014337371103465557, 0.012485411949455738, 0.0032094153575599194, -0.0021569649688899517, -0.024441177025437355, -0.06665503233671188, -0.027146484702825546, -0.057381004095077515, -0.008253797888755798, 0.010424254462122917, -0.012921466492116451, -0.016652001067996025, -0.04468735307455063, -0.02383006177842617, -0.003983026370406151, 0.019132623448967934, -0.060292549431324005, -0.029527990147471428, 0.04330059513449669, -0.0678495317697525, -0.01287811528891325, 0.05166083946824074, 0.007682093419134617, -0.04660292714834213, -0.030283382162451744, 0.0067441524006426334, 0.037850212305784225, -0.028384875506162643, 0.03164159506559372, -0.026756010949611664, -0.026695378124713898, 0.048785723745822906, 0.02785550430417061, -0.0440986305475235, 0.016264431178569794, -0.04936802014708519, -0.03675300255417824, -0.020590143278241158, -0.012108293361961842, 0.05351264774799347, -0.002711748005822301, 0.031639520078897476, 0.009164302609860897, -0.04967184364795685, 0.036600835621356964, 0.020326213911175728, -0.05536607652902603, -0.03120160847902298, -0.013353479094803333, -0.041838400065898895, -0.040031787008047104, -0.010744386352598667, 0.020319726318120956, -0.049105204641819, -0.05248332396149635, -0.06935418397188187, -0.02116987854242325, -0.022480834275484085, 0.030300986021757126, 0.013335452415049076, -0.023474663496017456, 0.011082972399890423, 0.014063792303204536, 0.010197877883911133, 0.04258771240711212, 0.050287067890167236, -0.0075513264164328575, 0.023920254781842232, -0.03342167288064957, -0.02815151959657669, 0.039477281272411346, -0.017170637845993042, 0.06098821014165878, -0.06388504803180695, 0.018834706395864487, -0.04400672763586044, -0.049617230892181396, -0.05633610859513283, -0.030453594401478767, -0.07250653207302094, 0.03423123434185982, -0.056103333830833435, -0.07084283977746964, 0.038944777101278305, -0.05152813345193863, 0.02785167284309864, -0.030395129695534706, -0.027273526415228844, -0.018980855122208595, -0.03016209788620472, -0.03487927466630936, -0.0693361759185791, -0.00812581181526184, -0.02988552115857601, 0.045699071139097214, -0.03273862972855568, -0.006482150871306658, -0.03632796183228493, 0.005899031646549702, -0.04926235228776932, 0.04321037605404854, 0.012879250571131706, 0.05263836681842804, 0.02518339641392231, -0.012219690717756748, -0.03157996013760567, 0.04325820505619049, -0.02330922521650791, 0.0055198366753757, -0.04357071593403816, -0.0007706853211857378, -0.01309214811772108, -0.003922387026250362, -0.058672625571489334, 0.032076019793748856, 0.031019896268844604, -0.01761735789477825, -0.032029520720243454, 0.008897016756236553, 0.06977847218513489, -0.05247190222144127, -0.047860752791166306, -0.020995015278458595, 0.028871716931462288, -0.05487387999892235, 0.003655831329524517, -0.013855770230293274, -0.01943371817469597, -0.04031383618712425, 0.03516474366188049, 0.039521947503089905, -0.018551524728536606, -0.0004974761395715177, -0.005989126395434141, -0.00006073167605791241, 0.0012315026251599193, -0.009441129863262177, 0.001342798350378871, -0.06936869025230408, -0.043922070413827896, -0.06162498518824577, -0.007172129116952419, -0.04232863709330559, 0.05703326687216759, 0.02380388416349888, 0.00684192543849349, -0.08146744966506958, 0.006642994936555624, 0.01940433494746685, -0.04384905844926834, -0.018892085179686546, 0.017202435061335564, -0.00773434666916728, 0.038226041942834854, -0.01407928392291069, -0.05769951269030571, 0.00013983648386783898, -0.025510631501674652, -0.04758608341217041, 0.034554824233055115, -0.03078330121934414, -0.049291640520095825, 0.017332898452878, 0.010890860110521317, -0.024169670417904854, -0.009016411378979683, -0.010873233899474144, -0.04860595986247063, -0.05463408678770065, 0.04715834930539131, 0.029305633157491684, 0.004158221650868654, -0.018896646797657013, 0.010328926146030426, -0.01302633062005043, 0.03289118409156799, 0.06252150237560272, -0.02201366238296032, -0.03631173446774483, 0.025384487584233284, -0.029340853914618492, 0.00044374351273290813, 0.005361125338822603, 0.04205844923853874, 0.02613823115825653, 0.011629555374383926, -0.041201941668987274, -0.04514904320240021, -0.027231216430664062, -0.028477421030402184, 0.031062887981534004, -0.032639674842357635, 0.0017890435410663486, 0.031149057671427727, -0.005231393501162529, 0.01649888977408409, -0.02991141937673092, -0.027878066524863243, 0.005259073805063963, 0.018435021862387657, -0.002899956190958619, -0.04024771973490715, 0.013439762406051159, 0.06795495003461838, -0.02824409119784832, 0.033339399844408035, 0.018836498260498047, -0.052123453468084335, 0.028168778866529465, 0.030145451426506042, 0.023856637999415398, -0.03945348411798477, -0.037659481167793274, -0.0362759567797184, -0.025033215060830116, 0.0009365968289785087, 0.016409801319241524, 0.017053147777915, 0.05536741390824318, -0.013380826450884342, 0.01860962249338627, 0.03259652107954025, -0.047032829374074936, 0.005696580279618502, 0.07684964686632156, -0.02409813180565834, -0.005645017139613628, -0.04346924647688866, -0.03203104808926582, -0.04488677158951759, -0.021897904574871063, 0.0349104069173336, 0.019892539829015732, -0.0304286926984787, -0.058056510984897614, -0.02001088298857212, -0.03190618008375168, -0.06614918261766434, -0.02661202661693096, 0.05011690407991409, -0.05048198625445366, 0.009804150089621544, -0.008577673695981503, -0.057977430522441864, 0.023211326450109482, -0.028422344475984573, -0.025943171232938766, -0.0710090845823288, -0.016381504014134407, 0.06446269154548645, 0.011424106545746326, -0.039854977279901505, 0.026984797790646553, 0.01652894727885723, 0.049434028565883636, 0.032318081706762314, -0.034808579832315445, 0.04096034914255142, -0.03763030096888542, 0.010227103717625141, -0.04519253969192505, -0.06155027821660042, 0.04352555423974991, -0.03209313005208969, -0.05489661917090416, 0.01563386805355549, -0.019667554646730423, 0.043693657964468, 0.014015907421708107, -0.06388480961322784, -0.039042871445417404, -0.02323550172150135, 0.017589235678315163, 0.025633061304688454, -0.01684202440083027, 0.019446367397904396, 0.014568786136806011, 0.0003013704263139516, -0.06102699413895607, -0.004219521302729845, -0.0059917280450463295, 0.002046669367700815, 0.003920211456716061, -0.028301367536187172, -0.06697522848844528, -0.03897874802350998, -0.00003936589928343892, 0.003979358822107315, 0.031097937375307083, -0.003536854637786746, -0.022586321458220482, -0.02222616784274578, 0.055543698370456696, -0.012318778783082962, 0.021567832678556442, 0.009440667927265167, 0.044888678938150406, -0.0043447441421449184, -0.01440094131976366, 0.032440003007650375, 0.03953837975859642, -0.005158811341971159, -0.07184214890003204, 0.04532076045870781, -0.009961950592696667, -0.0190209299325943, -0.0601230226457119, -0.009476833045482635, -0.051693107932806015, -0.06098766252398491, 0.015343123115599155, -0.051919445395469666, -0.04892037436366081, 0.004190846811980009, -0.02627795748412609, -0.000572604185435921, -0.017700759693980217, 0.03140684962272644, 0.032844796776771545, 0.020522139966487885, 0.03664999455213547, 0.0506296381354332, 0.018271805718541145, -0.0277878288179636, 0.019114306196570396, -0.06326109170913696, 0.025008130818605423, -0.037267010658979416, -0.016537392511963844, 0.019577691331505775, 0.005300483200699091, -0.0588265098631382, 0.03302612900733948, 0.005823508836328983, 0.006871238816529512, -0.025404607877135277, -0.01589660905301571, 0.02469363436102867, -0.0012023377930745482, -0.0665702074766159, -0.0802900418639183, -0.00417541665956378, -0.014992346055805683, -0.008837888948619366, 0.02898416854441166, 0.01701396517455578, -0.064764603972435, -0.015294969081878662, -0.07850605994462967, -0.041119713336229324, -0.013951352797448635, 0.016656585037708282, -0.03173397108912468, 0.027067050337791443, 0.0174349807202816, -0.04647151380777359, -0.002840714529156685, 0.05828314274549484, -0.044679075479507446, 0.0514044426381588, -0.003141597378998995, 0.009017134085297585, -0.030692163854837418, -0.04785730317234993, 0.026239564642310143, -0.013922379352152348, -0.004980580415576696, 0.0474449023604393, 0.050756655633449554, -0.05739601328969002, -0.005773448850959539, -0.013452564366161823, 0.053927235305309296, -0.0065100472420454025, -0.04588481783866882, -0.03286723792552948, -0.03720361739397049, -0.06561542302370071, 0.0010776185663416982, -0.056222882121801376, -0.0072837108746171, -0.010697555728256702, -0.0618959441781044, -0.010625374503433704, -0.011139673180878162, -0.040296562016010284, 0.028249964118003845, -0.0404440239071846, 0.00023629271890968084, 0.0380745530128479, -0.07255643606185913, 0.03802581503987312, 0.0268242284655571, 0.011411827988922596, -0.0525023527443409, -0.01410225871950388, 0.008197227492928505, -0.021716423332691193, 0.034715019166469574, -0.06363771110773087, 0.01575029268860817, -0.04718903452157974, -0.015247653238475323, -0.015590131282806396, 0.06550029665231705, -0.03112226165831089, -0.03193311020731926, -0.05607610568404198, -0.007895439863204956, -0.031672969460487366, -0.032572779804468155, 0.0036332951858639717, 0.009079528041183949, -0.0032490307930856943, -0.03605430945754051, 0.052097052335739136, 0.018139541149139404, 0.06942543387413025, 0.05876823514699936, 0.0439850278198719, 0.009399894624948502, 0.0032022958621382713, -0.05648881569504738, 0.00770031800493598, -0.06633709371089935, -0.05246463418006897, -0.027036204934120178, -0.028709828853607178, 0.04539408162236214, 0.03062010556459427, -0.06357841193675995, -0.005221637897193432, 0.027258440852165222, -0.040605511516332626, -0.03477893024682999, -0.024758119136095047, -0.03598112240433693, -0.06554275751113892, 0.017488673329353333, -0.014074432663619518, -0.007252556271851063, -0.00898781605064869 ]
Black hole (BH) X-ray binaries cycle through different spectral states of accretion over the course of months to years. Although fluctuations in the BH mass accretion rate are generally recognized as the most important component of state transitions, it is becoming increasingly evident that magnetic fields play a similarly important role. In this article, we present the first radiative two-temperature (2T) general relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) simulations in which an accretion disk transitions from a quiescent state at an accretion rate of $\dot{M} \sim 10^{-10} \dot{M}_{\rm Edd}$ to a hard-intermediate state at an accretion rate of $\dot{M} \sim 10^{-2} \dot{M}_{\rm Edd}$. This huge parameter space in mass accretion rate is bridged by artificially rescaling the gas density scale of the simulations. We present two jetted BH models with varying degrees of magnetic flux saturation. We demonstrate that in `Standard and Normal Evolution' models, which are unsaturated with magnetic flux, the hot torus collapses into a thin and cold accretion disk when $\dot{M} \gtrsim 5\times 10^{-3} \dot{M}_{\rm Edd}$. On the other hand, in `Magnetically Arrested Disk' models, which are fully saturated with vertical magnetic flux, the plasma remains mostly hot with substructures that condense into cold clumps of gas when $\dot{M} \gtrsim 1 \times 10^{-2} \dot{M}_{\rm Edd}$. This suggests that the spectral signatures observed during state transitions are closely tied to the level of magnetic flux saturation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15926v2
[ -0.008490822277963161, -0.026108643040060997, 0.03336195647716522, 0.00795570109039545, -0.010545150376856327, 0.005225553642958403, 0.023532593622803688, 0.01994846947491169, -0.03446738049387932, -0.002992397639900446, -0.010869004763662815, -0.014069746248424053, 0.01348695158958435, -0.030504116788506508, -0.034604042768478394, 0.0633593425154686, 0.05293362960219383, 0.01576152816414833, -0.02980884350836277, 0.060786910355091095, 0.007452649530023336, 0.001135129015892744, -0.04489491879940033, 0.06895937025547028, -0.004761963617056608, -0.006703387480229139, -0.06590934842824936, 0.029694411903619766, -0.039852600544691086, 0.008250797167420387, 0.05573609843850136, -0.053929198533296585, 0.023741792887449265, -0.0383763425052166, -0.023824747651815414, 0.003713656449690461, -0.029763322323560715, 0.02635500207543373, 0.03418993949890137, -0.07096461951732635, -0.03586749732494354, -0.040254153311252594, -0.06242837384343147, -0.017103062942624092, -0.037512995302677155, -0.0020851443987339735, -0.035041727125644684, -0.01461921539157629, -0.037112727761268616, -0.053966160863637924, 0.01565207913517952, 0.029309185221791267, 0.0005610978114418685, 0.06179477646946907, -0.021518249064683914, -0.03451722115278244, -0.01084069162607193, -0.024622350931167603, -0.08511161059141159, -0.012605853378772736, 0.0014294115826487541, -0.021182464435696602, 0.031966883689165115, -0.03232107311487198, -0.06376688927412033, 0.03113829344511032, -0.03200403228402138, -0.04652532935142517, -0.006162062752991915, -0.08493296056985855, 0.02558792755007744, -0.05755533277988434, 0.043382514268159866, 0.05142269283533096, -0.05325907841324806, -0.010085131041705608, -0.033439893275499344, -0.00852342788130045, -0.011059513315558434, 0.05314194783568382, -0.021401291713118553, 0.06494741886854172, -0.04966781288385391, -0.005009544547647238, 0.045432206243276596, 0.014280456118285656, 0.024496637284755707, -0.02285926602780819, -0.04483729973435402, -0.06215475872159004, 0.03299932926893234, -0.044611021876335144, -0.03764983266592026, -0.005316630937159061, 0.05224035307765007, -0.036804020404815674, 0.08220458030700684, 0.022502752020955086, 0.0186623428016901, 0.021449675783514977, 0.020114760845899582, -0.06943505257368088, -0.0330214686691761, 0.011076973751187325, 0.03542635217308998, -0.011427068151533604, -0.011677976697683334, -0.020594578236341476, -0.02104298584163189, 0.049301255494356155, -0.002733811968937516, 0.01597214676439762, -0.011050730012357235, -0.04259425029158592, -0.050751153379678726, -0.029139213263988495, 0.04124654456973076, 0.011380404233932495, 0.013881098479032516, 0.023197824135422707, -0.044534433633089066, 0.03687657415866852, 0.043731771409511566, 0.03249543160200119, -0.01659834198653698, -0.008966436609625816, 0.06510507315397263, 0.01694110780954361, -0.005089696031063795, 0.003559095785021782, -0.06147034093737602, -0.0015430661151185632, 0.04910692200064659, -0.003998853266239166, 0.04036040976643562, 0.02888045273721218, 0.021807953715324402, 0.008477569557726383, -0.013291160576045513, 0.05120637267827988, -0.010865007527172565, -0.055409591645002365, 0.030985282734036446, 0.021175963804125786, 0.0035080628003925085, 0.015677589923143387, -0.054910313338041306, 0.05383756384253502, 0.03591457009315491, -0.0024510324001312256, 0.007837647572159767, 0.01797138899564743, 0.040546830743551254, 0.022630950435996056, 0.00309384404681623, -0.03405695781111717, 0.07227980345487595, 0.04702086001634598, -0.026779361069202423, 0.004733436740934849, -0.019370611757040024, -0.019403235986828804, 0.02326894924044609, 0.019441235810518265, 0.00034297091769985855, -0.04206974804401398, 0.029987983405590057, 0.0020820158533751965, -0.010803865268826485, -0.002981807105243206, -0.010457166470587254, -0.042894668877124786, 0.06746874749660492, -0.004600268788635731, -0.03955737501382828, -0.025275034829974174, -0.02667270228266716, -0.04524092748761177, -0.049247708171606064, -0.002347436733543873, 0.047463104128837585, 0.004709940403699875, -0.05767415463924408, -0.01054301392287016, -0.03822891786694527, -0.006262894254177809, -0.09370583295822144, 0.0068972487933933735, 0.05296771228313446, -0.026300404220819473, -0.015437508001923561, 0.04034871235489845, 0.017164720222353935, -0.03537692502140999, -0.045222483575344086, -0.041062552481889725, 0.046219807118177414, -0.012537025846540928, 0.016678176820278168, -0.000022698519387631677, -0.060390204191207886, -0.02588738314807415, -0.014329527504742146, 0.015248593874275684, 0.012446952983736992, -0.05758997052907944, 0.008178352378308773, 0.045411448925733566, -0.01161472499370575, -0.013694648630917072, 0.04229415953159332, 0.03206440433859825, -0.015643754974007607, -0.01083260215818882, 0.021061144769191742, 0.004463145975023508, -0.10435934364795685, 0.05202735587954521, -0.018336640670895576, -0.013760820031166077, 0.010111955925822258, 0.004543015733361244, 0.012630797922611237, 0.018862366676330566, -0.021996870636940002, 0.04020633548498154, 0.08407611399888992, 0.031089166179299355, -0.052437376230955124, -0.01010766252875328, 0.004985651932656765, -0.051669925451278687, -0.05917271599173546, -0.05316172540187836, -0.03598187118768692, 0.006813032552599907, -0.05584429204463959, 0.060646720230579376, 0.0080427760258317, -0.04061785712838173, -0.007108592893928289, 0.015016340650618076, 0.05004548281431198, 0.012457591481506824, -0.06035235896706581, -0.03541870415210724, -0.049655165523290634, 0.031968504190444946, -0.020760539919137955, -0.011986752040684223, 0.008220543153584003, -0.05334947258234024, -0.016607480123639107, 0.023913294076919556, 0.04133142530918121, 0.03696339204907417, -0.056694161146879196, 0.01855705864727497, -0.02995411492884159, 0.0519515760242939, -0.024489199742674828, 0.037022195756435394, -0.06884776800870895, 0.040003202855587006, -0.0144322095438838, 0.013576233759522438, -0.0731339231133461, -0.010568751953542233, -0.01612047106027603, -0.029068423435091972, 0.008013350889086723, 0.03528762236237526, 0.07193226367235184, 0.035566799342632294, -0.008258351124823093, -0.005879439879208803, -0.047134608030319214, -0.05091516301035881, 0.03349245712161064, -0.0004965726984664798, 0.053080104291439056, 0.03171723335981369, -0.03704068809747696, -0.03212891146540642, -0.01985127106308937, -0.059385914355516434, -0.00706379022449255, -0.014559915289282799, -0.028455346822738647, -0.014022178016602993, -0.05563466250896454, -0.05105285346508026, -0.012188914231956005, 0.0030445577576756477, -0.005508886184543371, -0.06264094263315201, -0.023646920919418335, -0.011889267712831497, 0.02528352662920952, -0.04433107376098633, -0.03920084983110428, 0.054434165358543396, 0.001808580127544701, 0.0360131599009037, -0.01903722435235977, 0.018824489787220955, -0.02719893306493759, -0.04039664939045906, -0.03907017782330513, -0.0052198562771081924, -0.06119775027036667, -0.003964757081121206, -0.06517934054136276, -0.013930007815361023, -0.010542943142354488, 0.06291919946670532, 0.0106190862134099, -0.031794749200344086, -0.021623767912387848, -0.02191946841776371, -0.041466325521469116, -0.04215904697775841, 0.0034488479141145945, 0.00015597042511217296, -0.029559988528490067, -0.04483309015631676, 0.06818301975727081, 0.08142271637916565, 0.006645075045526028, -0.003863976337015629, -0.042426176369190216, -0.018030963838100433, -0.011419333517551422, 0.013010631315410137, 0.06705421209335327, 0.011109607294201851, -0.031271204352378845, -0.015433802269399166, -0.05109185725450516, 0.02284167893230915, 0.008843752555549145, 0.030324865132570267, 0.02204667404294014, 0.010004953481256962, -0.0014932031044736505, -0.04861845821142197, 0.03812951594591141, 0.046522755175828934, 0.047892071306705475, -0.017293568700551987, -0.03254610300064087, 0.03330616652965546, -0.038288429379463196, 0.04975028336048126, 0.03697042539715767, -0.029912032186985016, 0.013993030413985252, 0.043323393911123276, -0.03315715491771698, -0.009781528264284134, -0.04405934363603592, -0.06993541866540909, -0.05518816038966179, 0.03404064103960991, 0.01429690234363079, 0.01790899783372879, 0.033862702548503876, -0.014701804146170616, 0.04652449116110802, -0.015943842008709908, 0.05430472642183304, -0.017716016620397568, -0.05560626462101936, -0.006564600393176079, -0.013370737433433533, 0.025166084989905357, 0.04920400306582451, -0.0310633834451437, 0.01273766066879034, -0.03998543322086334, 0.003830644302070141, -0.039507269859313965, 0.03656913712620735, 0.03314439207315445, 0.0373125784099102, 0.004334729164838791, 0.041337840259075165, 0.041616130620241165, 0.0018107099458575249, -0.05885148420929909, 0.0072653875686228275, -0.05024323984980583, -0.05124890059232712, 0.004323958419263363, 0.04266340658068657, -0.021296875551342964, -0.016462063416838646, 0.01789061538875103, -0.03776545822620392, -0.007644682191312313, 0.012965119443833828, -0.007713092025369406, -0.0428013913333416, -0.08908683061599731, -0.05091226100921631, -0.045603152364492416, 0.038843218237161636, 0.01939498633146286, -0.028506267815828323, 0.06465519219636917, 0.03931348770856857, -0.006043920759111643, -0.03587524965405464, 0.03509817272424698, -0.04625682160258293, -0.05487050861120224, 0.008996146731078625, -0.06345959007740021, 0.025929467752575874, -0.027201542630791664, 0.021624214947223663, 0.012674937956035137, -0.0222905445843935, -0.049207936972379684, -0.04861411824822426, -0.03484233096241951, 0.02394917979836464, 0.0456555150449276, 0.00768583919852972, 0.009836185723543167, 0.01282578520476818, -0.031137635931372643, 0.019649136811494827, 0.007272160146385431, 0.05006470903754234, -0.051351066678762436, 0.06112338602542877, -0.012521672062575817, -0.050212837755680084, -0.00559628289192915, 0.049328144639730453, 0.06022427976131439, -0.016080399975180626, -0.03163910657167435, 0.01709333248436451, 0.06904509663581848, -0.011983745731413364, -0.01722102053463459, 0.015110168606042862, -0.024568701162934303, -0.049175482243299484, -0.04331536963582039, 0.016862211748957634, -0.03859834000468254, -0.014921794645488262, -0.010489360429346561, 0.0033893489744514227, -0.015463560819625854, -0.04260597750544548, 0.06156894564628601, -0.0029632446821779013, 0.040340933948755264, -0.021458635106682777, -0.03198140487074852, -0.027308758348226547, -0.010095570236444473, 0.012984491884708405, 0.0016171984607353806, 0.05247467756271362, 0.02444044128060341, -0.02237013354897499, 0.05577685311436653, -0.06331239640712738, 0.0526956208050251, 0.04292555898427963, -0.005682781338691711, 0.011953745037317276, 0.028261683881282806, -0.03698107972741127, 0.01391467172652483, -0.0007989061996340752, 0.04945744574069977, 0.0014645163901150227, -0.006904279347509146, -0.033933691680431366, -0.006902732420712709, -0.03499382734298706, -0.0024646478705108166, -0.000022377596906153485, -0.0073819756507873535, -0.05193248763680458, 0.009488132782280445, 0.027797717601060867, -0.019629759714007378, -0.012054765596985817, 0.02593114972114563, 0.013504233211278915, -0.06081581488251686, -0.05489739775657654, 0.007895499467849731, 0.015179791487753391, -0.01223987340927124, 0.029907943680882454, -0.07919219136238098, 0.004714164417237043, 0.02910609357059002, 0.036189161241054535, -0.02791062369942665, 0.06975958496332169, -0.02265184000134468, -0.007862291298806667, 0.01831178553402424, -0.02910892851650715, -0.06054328754544258, -0.0062158377841115, -0.08335258811712265, 0.03918195515871048, -0.01791299320757389, 0.04208078607916832, 0.05730745196342468, 0.05153020843863487, 0.021358083933591843, -0.057788074016571045, -0.00014618708519265056, 0.020901234820485115, 0.025424223393201828, 0.002464229241013527, 0.000536839768756181, 0.00027378584491088986, 0.06447406113147736, 0.0196935273706913, -0.0034714334178715944, 0.06172806769609451, -0.00849046278744936, -0.04056720435619354, 0.0007773638935759664, 0.0033780706580728292, 0.0211421437561512, -0.04256316274404526, -0.0004897011676803231, 0.06980301439762115, -0.06088290736079216, 0.032890018075704575, 0.03609002009034157, 0.007061024662107229, 0.016409242525696754, 0.012821001000702381, 0.010744360275566578, -0.05926566943526268, -0.005705351009964943, 0.0878538116812706, -0.07554098218679428, 0.0006205664831213653, -0.022358732298016548, -0.013837160542607307, -0.009766502305865288, -0.051239170134067535, 0.012296841479837894, 0.039924733340740204, -0.0002925761800725013, -0.02540326863527298, 0.06235167384147644, 0.008782414719462395, -0.06282386928796768, -0.030496995896100998, 0.0378664955496788, -0.06072661653161049, -0.05276639014482498, -0.006205608136951923, -0.03369079902768135, -0.05830221623182297, 0.013450427912175655, -0.06670296937227249, -0.05353530868887901, -0.046801429241895676, 0.07993434369564056, 0.059668801724910736, -0.010313277132809162, 0.014132819138467312, -0.011303307488560677, -0.05063946917653084, -0.022827908396720886, -0.018339969217777252, -0.031070830300450325, 0.02631271816790104, 0.02348950505256653, 0.007887126877903938, -0.006328600458800793, -0.0272939782589674, 0.04768522456288338, -0.04768528789281845, -0.007421954534947872, 0.03299146518111229, 0.04018821567296982, 0.04105421155691147, 0.0006272477330639958, -0.03358374908566475, 0.0359991081058979, 0.016260256990790367, 0.016917789354920387, -0.01916457526385784, 0.0170846339315176, -0.01703028939664364, 0.031387809664011, 0.013968092389404774, -0.039951492100954056, 0.008720677345991135, -0.01030481606721878, -0.031020475551486015, 0.0635601282119751, -0.04708590731024742, 0.008417305536568165, 0.010349337011575699, 0.0014279043534770608, -0.014785042963922024, 0.01302361860871315, -0.04507235810160637, -0.02536567486822605, -0.04651915654540062, -0.02693748287856579, -0.008906081318855286, 0.026115121319890022, 0.07912728935480118, 0.016515478491783142, 0.055442504584789276, -0.056436654180288315, -0.0015166510129347444, -0.014085536822676659, -0.06319406628608704, 0.013967295177280903, 0.02466813661158085, -0.03163160756230354, -0.01947198249399662, 0.04106961190700531, -0.007003914564847946, 0.004337156191468239, 0.0030067656189203262, -0.0383804589509964, -0.05723737180233002, -0.031431470066308975, -0.013244131579995155, -0.009533346630632877, 0.03109908103942871, -0.028699660673737526, 0.04663979634642601, 0.00703627523034811, 0.0397474579513073, 0.036377787590026855, 0.010125931352376938, 0.023111341521143913, -0.04987827688455582, -0.03806046023964882, -0.00559865590184927, -0.021726755425333977, -0.0000777828463469632, -0.05311118811368942, -0.06532157212495804, -0.0692022293806076, 0.024325178936123848, 0.03069918602705002, -0.0015279736835509539, -0.0004244165902491659, -0.042395543307065964, 0.02099861577153206, 0.0743897557258606, 0.01847335323691368, -0.09016761183738708, 0.009534104727208614, 0.04054147005081177, -0.012045818381011486, -0.02276640199124813, 0.0058866869658231735, -0.03385740518569946, 0.005442481022328138, -0.09536904841661453, 0.010205465368926525, 0.010060573928058147, 0.08590497076511383, 0.03684472665190697, -0.021439513191580772, -0.0350145660340786, -0.04463966563344002, 0.02284088358283043, 0.023882463574409485, -0.0046081566251814365, 0.01695532165467739, 0.012561804614961147, 0.039947494864463806, -0.06751299649477005, -0.015003030188381672, 0.04761986806988716, -0.026480207219719887, 0.013071076013147831, 0.02385043539106846, 0.015553356148302555, -0.01867426559329033, 0.047569792717695236, 0.043171271681785583, 0.0064945886842906475, 0.0018914166139438748, -0.000849972537253052, -0.0007232542848214507, -0.025956397876143456, -0.055050019174814224, 0.035007014870643616, -0.033532191067934036, 0.017306189984083176, -0.011510107666254044, 0.0002395902993157506, -0.002662783255800605, -0.05669816583395004, -0.01794695109128952, -0.022470558062195778, 0.03936372697353363, 0.009008700028061867, 0.05527804419398308, -0.038536436855793, -0.015675868839025497, 0.010620386339724064, 0.00413588248193264, -0.05354763939976692, 0.006116230506449938, 0.011627468280494213, -0.04746152088046074, 0.014312813058495522, -0.06435340642929077, 0.03227885812520981, -0.01748112589120865, -0.02954825945198536, 0.005248438101261854, 0.020205507054924965, -0.06320900470018387, -0.017350591719150543, -0.01592123508453369, -0.03865699842572212, 0.020893990993499756, -0.02550160326063633, 0.009849385358393192, 0.03316831588745117, 0.034946538507938385, -0.02572924643754959, 0.0460149347782135, 0.013803130015730858, 0.051765233278274536, -0.02843954600393772, 0.014517373405396938, -0.028635472059249878, -0.038356561213731766, -0.037342049181461334, 0.022214915603399277, 0.0002045352739514783, 0.010807933285832405, -0.07365968823432922, 0.022819403558969498, 0.014290686696767807, -0.036123499274253845, 0.014523385092616081, 0.017530543729662895, 0.03337090089917183, -0.06415943801403046, -0.03956637904047966, 0.0035560084506869316, 0.023213762789964676, -0.04988441243767738, 0.05165574699640274, 0.024850184097886086, 0.013979379087686539, -0.05568088963627815 ]
We argue that the higher weak isospin $SU(3)_L$ manifestly unifies dark matter and normal matter in its isomultiplets for which dark matter carries a conserved dark charge while normal matter does not. The resultant gauge symmetry is given by $SU(3)_C\otimes SU(3)_L \otimes U(1)_X\otimes U(1)_G$, where the first factor is the color group, while the rest defines a theory of scotoelectroweak in which $X$ and $G$ determine electric charge $Q=T_3-1/\sqrt{3}T_8+X$ and dark charge $D=-2/\sqrt{3}T_8+G$. This setup provides both appropriate scotogenic neutrino masses and dark matter stability as preserved by a residual dark parity $P_D=(-1)^D$. Interpretation of the dark charge is further discussed, given that $SU(3)_L$ is broken at very high energy scale.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12091v2
[ -0.05206749215722084, -0.061256084591150284, 0.0457923449575901, 0.0017430140869691968, 0.006731683854013681, -0.015562894754111767, -0.005626438185572624, 0.04595803841948509, -0.06563149392604828, -0.02769751474261284, 0.045341525226831436, -0.046920545399188995, -0.0038474416360259056, 0.029330074787139893, -0.039226509630680084, 0.005431291647255421, 0.046295344829559326, 0.03126363828778267, -0.006854464765638113, 0.042854342609643936, 0.019124051555991173, 0.01340364571660757, -0.04393531754612923, 0.0006165501545183361, -0.026923449710011482, -0.036312285810709, -0.06654888391494751, -0.0020710553508251905, -0.035298388451337814, -0.040969498455524445, 0.04408033564686775, -0.0324934758245945, -0.027286743745207787, -0.03893708437681198, 0.0208467748016119, 0.007465821225196123, 0.01027364656329155, 0.009908150881528854, -0.021019618958234787, -0.04576580226421356, -0.035734426230192184, -0.024863796308636665, -0.025851069018244743, -0.04013191908597946, -0.01994623802602291, 0.004420872312039137, -0.022915171459317207, 0.0140372971072793, -0.05074004828929901, -0.053000807762145996, 0.06264970451593399, -0.01246035099029541, -0.028097547590732574, 0.04944312572479248, -0.0010538195492699742, 0.00804084725677967, 0.012608533725142479, -0.06578534096479416, -0.016888227313756943, -0.03672794625163078, -0.009276180528104305, -0.036199845373630524, 0.006354648619890213, -0.04155812785029411, -0.06723272055387497, 0.02323591522872448, -0.020076338201761246, -0.05108813941478729, -0.03173886239528656, -0.004424925893545151, -0.022462820634245872, -0.05623690038919449, 0.050929561257362366, -0.019305521622300148, -0.06775008887052536, 0.03695930168032646, -0.023232141509652138, 0.00935638602823019, -0.05951574444770813, -0.0026828008703887463, -0.0021304641850292683, -0.01609705574810505, -0.01490982249379158, -0.02065313793718815, 0.010293103754520416, -0.009147865697741508, 0.015705080702900887, -0.03951137885451317, 0.03379744291305542, -0.05506942793726921, 0.021094754338264465, -0.03371675685048103, -0.026331795379519463, -0.0021089103538542986, 0.015743376687169075, -0.07268821448087692, 0.0010670151095837355, 0.032504163682460785, 0.041102178394794464, -0.037623386830091476, -0.04815278947353363, -0.018715623766183853, -0.009977957233786583, 0.01278675440698862, 0.034092601388692856, 0.010611897334456444, 0.04406183212995529, 0.004942427389323711, -0.04841246083378792, 0.05975973978638649, 0.012303868308663368, 0.0021466282196342945, -0.010852589271962643, -0.04125846549868584, -0.050020672380924225, -0.03997332230210304, 0.03857264667749405, 0.05567542463541031, 0.023715713992714882, -0.04107102006673813, 0.007955901324748993, 0.05680527538061142, 0.00933631882071495, -0.036427728831768036, -0.04908640682697296, -0.03713788837194443, 0.0029236474074423313, -0.011903924867510796, 0.016005098819732666, 0.0028359265998005867, -0.02499557100236416, -0.01896745152771473, -0.012927915900945663, -0.060190003365278244, 0.03082493506371975, -0.028335070237517357, 0.050095804035663605, -0.04652273654937744, -0.04196431487798691, 0.005632950458675623, -0.03308529779314995, -0.0235085841268301, -0.030244583263993263, -0.05806298926472664, -0.034881167113780975, 0.03425800800323486, -0.00408764136955142, -0.020499100908637047, -0.014315508306026459, 0.0009097701986320317, -0.012774378061294556, 0.01669088937342167, -0.030970504507422447, -0.009184512309730053, -0.037664782255887985, 0.05033724382519722, 0.051976583898067474, 0.02090369164943695, -0.04722520336508751, 0.049539029598236084, -0.006028556264936924, -0.03784399852156639, -0.05491865426301956, -0.023295607417821884, -0.026075126603245735, 0.0272121112793684, 0.0056176320649683475, -0.05178317055106163, 0.002245514653623104, -0.03667396679520607, 0.005279193166643381, -0.006958147510886192, -0.012076922692358494, -0.055104054510593414, -0.05821584537625313, -0.03970307856798172, -0.011185347102582455, -0.06506305932998657, -0.045632701367139816, -0.00634796405211091, -0.016997452825307846, 0.016084890812635422, -0.026918798685073853, -0.06066448241472244, -0.05168600007891655, 0.02500239573419094, -0.0618705153465271, 0.03121783770620823, 0.05087800323963165, -0.02261957898736, 0.03401781991124153, -0.04980041831731796, 0.056012921035289764, -0.01195652037858963, -0.022514620795845985, -0.041167158633470535, 0.005145776551216841, -0.01842856965959072, -0.049680907279253006, -0.036439936608076096, -0.049937546253204346, -0.043573178350925446, -0.053685080260038376, 0.03249293193221092, -0.016224723309278488, -0.050882842391729355, 0.03127451613545418, 0.03239864483475685, -0.037168391048908234, -0.05285138636827469, 0.054532360285520554, 0.008992196060717106, 0.0410812683403492, -0.04144509881734848, 0.0005768590490333736, -0.0527816042304039, -0.07589005678892136, 0.04338059946894646, -0.004495972767472267, -0.04505383223295212, 0.03437018394470215, -0.036858126521110535, -0.03538310155272484, -0.024955524131655693, -0.05092652887105942, 0.06324151903390884, -0.004864006768912077, 0.006928678136318922, -0.021922558546066284, -0.0025475153233855963, 0.034356821328401566, -0.05000179260969162, -0.033756744116544724, -0.06553059071302414, -0.027167534455657005, 0.015517746098339558, -0.015456339344382286, 0.02589821256697178, -0.01603265106678009, -0.02348247915506363, -0.04958897456526756, 0.0055727059952914715, 0.015098039992153645, -0.0035445066168904305, -0.04992837831377983, -0.02689957059919834, -0.062474530190229416, 0.016570130363106728, -0.04705313593149185, -0.010440248996019363, -0.005596485920250416, -0.037131231278181076, -0.05809507891535759, -0.023622853681445122, 0.04407908394932747, -0.022706473246216774, -0.045328643172979355, 0.017830204218626022, -0.03393791243433952, 0.040803249925374985, -0.025937369093298912, 0.0390985831618309, -0.020471304655075073, 0.011569730006158352, 0.00343098072335124, 0.0026649166829884052, -0.04598933830857277, 0.032864198088645935, -0.026298142969608307, 0.009920476004481316, -0.004092756658792496, 0.01610220968723297, -0.029866483062505722, 0.03416314721107483, -0.0006283440161496401, -0.05683735013008118, -0.07070934772491455, -0.036911286413669586, 0.009489351883530617, 0.021566592156887054, 0.05756237730383873, 0.04872730374336243, -0.0375170074403286, -0.06801488250494003, -0.05096284672617912, 0.020947199314832687, -0.009923155419528484, -0.05421524494886398, -0.053392909467220306, 0.046986162662506104, -0.055051710456609726, 0.039435360580682755, -0.04170340672135353, -0.019389702007174492, -0.06596702337265015, -0.07013889402151108, -0.042194437235593796, -0.010647980496287346, -0.022458285093307495, -0.0655047744512558, -0.045280538499355316, 0.056884754449129105, -0.005782921798527241, 0.024692922830581665, 0.00007349839870585129, -0.04164618253707886, -0.03682965040206909, 0.005127886310219765, 0.008757037110626698, -0.04415717348456383, -0.03430641070008278, 0.01014694757759571, -0.06604896485805511, 0.005602234974503517, -0.012693200260400772, 0.03916171193122864, 0.011965520679950714, -0.04146895185112953, 0.03205112740397453, -0.021070493385195732, -0.024177145212888718, -0.001972331665456295, 0.032878778874874115, -0.04025286063551903, -0.05218707025051117, -0.057055797427892685, 0.008928731083869934, 0.05577922239899635, -0.020800020545721054, -0.0614820271730423, -0.06097440794110298, 0.021550152450799942, 0.037388455122709274, -0.023073717951774597, 0.06069637089967728, 0.004447761923074722, -0.04570941999554634, -0.0014355021994560957, -0.0434788316488266, 0.03031490370631218, -0.05384421721100807, 0.0003268853179179132, 0.04841272532939911, 0.020567217841744423, -0.009135228581726551, -0.05666916072368622, 0.05973168835043907, 0.04604949429631233, 0.06903135776519775, 0.0028988351114094257, -0.01163904182612896, 0.031199967488646507, 0.00499621219933033, 0.01645169034600258, -0.04235304892063141, -0.003903415286913514, 0.033070359379053116, 0.04787386208772659, -0.045540399849414825, -0.04824262112379074, 0.011613820679485798, -0.02493378333747387, -0.011022428050637245, 0.044299688190221786, -0.017385993152856827, 0.023262524977326393, -0.009754405356943607, 0.008355486206710339, 0.022628769278526306, 0.008184947073459625, 0.03855864331126213, -0.06596890091896057, 0.03571246191859245, 0.005030190106481314, -0.02085639163851738, -0.021257368847727776, -0.020019138231873512, -0.023189453408122063, -0.041331104934215546, -0.04692026972770691, 0.013734509237110615, -0.07008099555969238, -0.02754257433116436, 0.054960962384939194, 0.0022218513768166304, -0.035387735813856125, 0.03327295184135437, 0.037645164877176285, 0.006215422879904509, -0.035274654626846313, -0.023803094401955605, -0.06196185201406479, -0.03232099860906601, 0.04983824864029884, 0.005656790919601917, 0.0039032341446727514, -0.04682127386331558, -0.016710396856069565, -0.05754046514630318, -0.05162429437041283, 0.05119584873318672, 0.02209630236029625, 0.02850603498518467, -0.06795844435691833, -0.06165030226111412, -0.04008609429001808, 0.009655664674937725, 0.016885360702872276, -0.04220575839281082, 0.06424117833375931, -0.05343906208872795, -0.06618839502334595, -0.04684597998857498, -0.03738861531019211, 0.020291734486818314, -0.06716818362474442, -0.04658800736069679, -0.020259927958250046, -0.0028074877336621284, -0.04369121417403221, -0.008245538920164108, 0.016053644940257072, -0.025523046031594276, -0.06029713153839111, 0.04328951984643936, 0.03507605940103531, -0.03497565537691116, -0.00034019394661299884, 0.03086981363594532, 0.015956934541463852, -0.002329775132238865, -0.013464165851473808, -0.03231975436210632, -0.05699087679386139, -0.0025179993826895952, -0.054430559277534485, 0.06565314531326294, -0.052610453218221664, -0.05769171565771103, -0.04572766646742821, 0.02475591003894806, 0.03816398233175278, -0.024780504405498505, 0.0017891338793560863, -0.019920840859413147, 0.015085800550878048, -0.05561571568250656, -0.017977144569158554, 0.029148036614060402, -0.051882367581129074, -0.05283403396606445, -0.011705833487212658, -0.008500944823026657, -0.03474705293774605, -0.004727507475763559, -0.007635043002665043, 0.00435711769387126, -0.025989089161157608, -0.039466626942157745, 0.00479503208771348, 0.05804453790187836, 0.01530308648943901, 0.001725772162899375, -0.00673172902315855, -0.07165119051933289, -0.0024055796675384045, -0.0019969160202890635, -0.0011508101597428322, 0.014901472255587578, 0.030932513996958733, -0.05070662871003151, 0.041049957275390625, -0.07362192869186401, -0.009190832264721394, 0.031402673572301865, -0.014286530204117298, 0.02808467485010624, -0.007513456046581268, -0.027481047436594963, 0.04010212421417236, -0.056055761873722076, -0.005630810279399157, 0.008570917882025242, -0.012583276256918907, 0.01566041260957718, -0.008752364665269852, -0.06572006642818451, -0.03850695490837097, 0.024560514837503433, -0.0010259748669341207, -0.04661824554204941, -0.00972107332199812, -0.006302273366600275, -0.036288194358348846, -0.0450354665517807, 0.0288455318659544, 0.037848249077796936, -0.053570706397295, -0.026453744620084763, 0.018880387768149376, -0.022243395447731018, 0.03796646371483803, 0.054871782660484314, -0.034590788185596466, -0.009320950135588646, 0.0017099427059292793, -0.004105614498257637, 0.015751097351312637, 0.034869562834501266, 0.008506975136697292, -0.009699773043394089, 0.028096279129385948, -0.015148382633924484, -0.06146617978811264, 0.024812093004584312, -0.04796548932790756, -0.013878446072340012, 0.014077900908887386, -0.018576540052890778, 0.028497178107500076, 0.04738206788897514, -0.02320818044245243, -0.015010508708655834, -0.031839944422245026, -0.04014194756746292, 0.05083642527461052, -0.02274712175130844, -0.027972828596830368, 0.01873137801885605, 0.019564058631658554, 0.004656391683965921, -0.0213637538254261, -0.018955940380692482, -0.021071311086416245, -0.035169363021850586, 0.03869341313838959, 0.03676653653383255, 0.04055756330490112, -0.008154037408530712, -0.015358028933405876, 0.024461893364787102, -0.04054628312587738, 0.03730079159140587, 0.024577850475907326, 0.03606441244482994, 0.003260027151554823, 0.011875517666339874, 0.058657772839069366, -0.06646714359521866, -0.029665475711226463, 0.0417603924870491, -0.06880166381597519, 0.02492484450340271, -0.06659068912267685, -0.0013340332079678774, -0.001091846264898777, -0.06707365810871124, 0.011768187396228313, -0.012561837211251259, 0.02471200004220009, -0.041210148483514786, 0.04047923907637596, -0.017925497144460678, -0.06168485805392265, 0.004691068083047867, -0.0046163336373865604, -0.05809289216995239, 0.04475744813680649, 0.007884159684181213, -0.030785277485847473, -0.03708014264702797, 0.0014291537227109075, -0.06306734681129456, -0.023869318887591362, -0.01959896646440029, 0.06908676773309708, 0.056323543190956116, -0.05929756164550781, 0.03205130249261856, 0.02333424799144268, -0.042278457432985306, 0.033557165414094925, -0.05575995519757271, -0.015296938829123974, -0.04845437780022621, 0.05826036259531975, 0.00041286516352556646, -0.0269840769469738, -0.03626987338066101, -0.025169936940073967, -0.014839453622698784, -0.019677750766277313, 0.036322593688964844, 0.017012106254696846, 0.05352361127734184, 0.0006243202369660139, -0.03693511709570885, 0.02986747957766056, -0.027146589010953903, 0.016151567921042442, -0.02380700223147869, 0.041294533759355545, -0.030424633994698524, -0.0007295614341273904, -0.03936197608709335, -0.047317661345005035, 0.031062297523021698, 0.003094662446528673, -0.03576213866472244, -0.02853997051715851, -0.031370412558317184, -0.023912208154797554, -0.002298001665621996, 0.028956526890397072, -0.030157282948493958, 0.016277022659778595, -0.059960804879665375, 0.0017298029270023108, -0.053058743476867676, -0.035323698073625565, -0.023623168468475342, 0.016592824831604958, 0.009235336445271969, -0.019783902913331985, 0.05462752655148506, -0.06653660535812378, 0.02963552623987198, -0.05688152834773064, -0.04120209068059921, 0.004209492355585098, -0.04592808708548546, -0.016757527366280556, -0.016201239079236984, -0.031352948397397995, -0.06822080910205841, 0.04967976361513138, 0.010641884990036488, 0.022064462304115295, -0.07161644101142883, -0.032422151416540146, -0.01256290078163147, -0.019458308815956116, 0.04255788400769234, -0.009058591909706593, 0.054102178663015366, 0.003490831470116973, 0.02959766611456871, 0.05719156190752983, 0.050073858350515366, -0.04351438954472542, -0.033586837351322174, -0.010983246378600597, 0.026380542665719986, -0.03971068933606148, -0.03141885623335838, -0.0379948653280735, -0.05902719125151634, -0.048193711787462234, -0.004645135253667831, 0.025105290114879608, 0.0260135680437088, -0.06771925091743469, -0.024761036038398743, 0.05006660148501396, 0.02881455048918724, -0.019047867506742477, -0.07056023925542831, 0.022502081468701363, 0.039865441620349884, -0.02816854976117611, -0.026967037469148636, -0.049261610954999924, -0.0663423240184784, -0.006547167897224426, -0.07193613797426224, -0.031177692115306854, 0.02010234072804451, 0.007081062998622656, 0.04531663656234741, 0.030682312324643135, -0.05154843255877495, -0.04954876750707626, 0.03332335501909256, 0.018575942143797874, -0.008836343884468079, 0.004732940811663866, -0.037068143486976624, -0.051761090755462646, -0.016359098255634308, -0.0069404663518071175, 0.04496081545948982, -0.008251091465353966, -0.03903251886367798, -0.027384422719478607, 0.027875974774360657, -0.05221987143158913, 0.02698904275894165, 0.04000668227672577, -0.036275457590818405, 0.03190672770142555, -0.01821778528392315, -0.013177312910556793, -0.02158353105187416, -0.03113640658557415, 0.0631340891122818, -0.02635243721306324, -0.000325939676258713, -0.04024288430809975, 0.025954389944672585, -0.060698721557855606, -0.014606423676013947, -0.028506683185696602, -0.043856870383024216, -0.012481072917580605, -0.020109916105866432, -0.04212452471256256, -0.04622109979391098, 0.015554964542388916, -0.04659544304013252, -0.0438782162964344, -0.05055912956595421, -0.03234056383371353, 0.03307705372571945, 0.014844809658825397, -0.01762228272855282, -0.05570560693740845, 0.00014382599329110235, -0.06025243178009987, -0.010225672274827957, 0.008932412602007389, 0.0012684488901868463, -0.04364459216594696, 0.02635474130511284, -0.052532121539115906, 0.0011227508075535297, -0.005803094711154699, -0.0653843954205513, -0.0018688385607674718, -0.0289938822388649, 0.009874626994132996, 0.055485472083091736, 0.051843732595443726, -0.02531195618212223, -0.0031971149146556854, 0.032605305314064026, -0.042055629193782806, -0.0173345934599638, -0.00460358802229166, -0.014223000966012478, -0.029268933460116386, 0.03545116260647774, -0.040545765310525894, -0.019632255658507347, 0.02463059313595295, -0.009219072759151459, -0.03510120511054993, -0.04913622885942459, -0.005249865353107452, 0.007945535704493523, -0.06607621163129807, 0.022566894069314003, 0.042581427842378616, -0.01602916419506073, -0.06214611977338791, 0.05153840407729149, 0.025437531992793083, -0.01776265911757946, -0.031423598527908325 ]
We introduce stability conditions (in the sense of King) for representable modules of continuous quivers of type A along with a special criteria called the four point condition. The stability conditions are defined using a generalization of delta functions, called half-delta functions. We show that for a continuous quiver of type A with finitely many sinks and sources, the stability conditions satisfying the four point condition are in bijection with measured laminations of the hyperbolic plane. Along the way, we extend an earlier result by the first author and Todorov regarding continuous cluster categories for linear continuous quivers of type A and laminations of the hyperbolic plane to all continuous quivers of type A with finitely many sinks and sources. We also give a formula for the continuous cluster character.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14792v1
[ -0.0128384530544281, -0.024595104157924652, 0.03198467567563057, 0.01972665823996067, 0.009947806596755981, -0.05187760666012764, -0.004239378497004509, 0.0007006740779615939, 0.0072591123171150684, 0.0337660014629364, -0.03830219805240631, -0.02331402897834778, -0.05191569775342941, -0.04936538636684418, -0.07291268557310104, -0.01619870774447918, 0.03278304263949394, 0.011510944925248623, -0.07375159114599228, 0.03562275692820549, 0.014284730888903141, -0.060972895473241806, -0.007755034603178501, 0.03678230196237564, -0.01572878472507, -0.021298138424754143, 0.0023409128189086914, 0.003768048482015729, -0.056624941527843475, -0.04491536319255829, 0.07017792016267776, 0.03459691256284714, -0.00845084898173809, 0.036854155361652374, -0.020391905680298805, -0.03610089421272278, 0.013660678640007973, 0.005473768338561058, 0.0475752167403698, -0.016325227916240692, 0.03233148530125618, -0.03014557436108589, -0.0723935067653656, 0.0016028218669816852, 0.056084923446178436, -0.01199599914252758, -0.03636074438691139, 0.04557367041707039, -0.054530512541532516, -0.04689527302980423, 0.014515545219182968, 0.03497859090566635, -0.02916744165122509, 0.023042602464556694, -0.05665145069360733, -0.027564693242311478, 0.052335143089294434, -0.031136464327573776, -0.06417062878608704, -0.0014019495574757457, -0.03920098766684532, -0.006675104610621929, -0.023642906919121742, 0.0077116056345403194, -0.03475170210003853, 0.022134890779852867, -0.019399132579565048, -0.03178521990776062, -0.006670468952506781, -0.04151943325996399, 0.02074577286839485, -0.06817040592432022, 0.019405875355005264, 0.006960001774132252, -0.03618304431438446, 0.05717918649315834, -0.03712539002299309, 0.01968051679432392, -0.01010562852025032, 0.013465198688209057, 0.018115492537617683, -0.008175492286682129, 0.006665192544460297, 0.026396870613098145, 0.04875180497765541, -0.024779662489891052, 0.05132577568292618, 0.010320926085114479, -0.007881884463131428, -0.038542866706848145, 0.006128020118921995, 0.031106973066926003, -0.08243428170681, -0.003240700578317046, -0.0010303923627361655, -0.027155471965670586, 0.060486674308776855, 0.003842678153887391, 0.019581427797675133, -0.05117412284016609, 0.003537395503371954, -0.04751499742269516, -0.05550330504775047, 0.024252112954854965, 0.021102290600538254, -0.04667416214942932, 0.02135324291884899, 0.000541287416126579, -0.05929947644472122, -0.0014827875420451164, -0.015751298516988754, -0.02244037389755249, 0.002439690986648202, -0.03475000336766243, 0.007306053303182125, -0.05373601242899895, 0.04041245952248573, 0.015101638622581959, 0.04944266006350517, -0.014561358839273453, -0.056145768612623215, 0.016193481162190437, 0.04320937395095825, -0.016630927100777626, -0.05019866302609444, -0.030165113508701324, 0.03483763337135315, 0.03155429661273956, 0.006424555554986, -0.040211740881204605, -0.02293696254491806, -0.03945498913526535, 0.04531390219926834, -0.029535887762904167, 0.07060319930315018, -0.03811967745423317, -0.017841225489974022, 0.0022198043297976255, -0.008426136337220669, 0.03830169513821602, -0.0627254918217659, -0.06624633073806763, -0.012968788854777813, 0.033284250646829605, -0.030996048822999, 0.048817723989486694, -0.07213172316551208, -0.016074053943157196, 0.044029466807842255, 0.006940002553164959, 0.005358460824936628, 0.01128692738711834, -0.0030078021809458733, 0.009273320436477661, 0.01062424574047327, -0.009366210550069809, 0.039792500436306, -0.007762187626212835, -0.07491584867238998, 0.017075294628739357, 0.019337784498929977, -0.023004326969385147, 0.028595730662345886, 0.008855204097926617, 0.0166474599391222, 0.06479419022798538, 0.0437462255358696, -0.03905949741601944, -0.02826709672808647, 0.0060364133678376675, -0.03547592833638191, -0.018073255196213722, 0.006024136207997799, -0.03092978522181511, -0.07534580677747726, -0.018986627459526062, -0.004832523874938488, -0.05401845648884773, -0.07371044903993607, 0.0021886785980314016, -0.0026578365359455347, 0.008214627392590046, -0.016059832647442818, 0.0001660721463849768, -0.029595408588647842, 0.057214073836803436, -0.0862044245004654, 0.018296904861927032, 0.027637144550681114, -0.018331147730350494, 0.01379470806568861, -0.025869986042380333, -0.03280453011393547, 0.022719740867614746, -0.03784283250570297, -0.010344983078539371, 0.031874265521764755, -0.048784807324409485, -0.046583548188209534, 0.027830934152007103, -0.0673309713602066, 0.007419421337544918, 0.007321740500628948, -0.007474876940250397, -0.005993682891130447, -0.06209973245859146, 0.044127047061920166, 0.04709794372320175, -0.07408633828163147, -0.01929617114365101, 0.05886977165937424, 0.03342566639184952, 0.05450041964650154, -0.052715763449668884, 0.04624322056770325, -0.0065795304253697395, -0.09509432315826416, 0.06152892857789993, -0.00685129314661026, -0.019803212955594063, 0.023113127797842026, 0.04189356416463852, -0.008294932544231415, -0.02095011994242668, -0.04384816810488701, 0.07206571847200394, 0.06351573020219803, 0.022235993295907974, -0.06847845017910004, 0.007474307902157307, -0.0033765360713005066, -0.05948153883218765, -0.02594098635017872, -0.047362711280584335, -0.040359627455472946, -0.018208052963018417, -0.04161824285984039, 0.04779384657740593, -0.027698760852217674, -0.030724745243787766, -0.042480479925870895, -0.005522186402231455, 0.034329283982515335, -0.021775048226118088, -0.04201393947005272, -0.010581216774880886, -0.07686251401901245, 0.014079894870519638, -0.016611188650131226, -0.003684805938974023, -0.00230877916328609, -0.05528207868337631, -0.03311796486377716, -0.0006815643864683807, -0.013365917839109898, 0.050481922924518585, -0.04426960647106171, 0.048599179834127426, -0.002332931151613593, 0.05935170128941536, 0.004722190089523792, 0.05913742259144783, -0.05201864242553711, 0.010814021341502666, 0.031365878880023956, -0.017358755692839622, -0.030914878472685814, -0.03251950815320015, 0.00629115616902709, 0.005994750186800957, -0.022098293527960777, -0.013677551411092281, 0.035036373883485794, -0.024362675845623016, 0.02846122719347477, 0.00019886640075128525, 0.006211701314896345, -0.011347200721502304, 0.033078547567129135, 0.006649338640272617, 0.03757265582680702, 0.013196387328207493, -0.03581772372126579, -0.0755760446190834, -0.002235864056274295, 0.029425743967294693, -0.014115872792899609, -0.02750064805150032, -0.05674416571855545, -0.050546493381261826, -0.0621124729514122, -0.02013888955116272, -0.03261048346757889, -0.039482299238443375, -0.04935498908162117, -0.06491651386022568, -0.03885374590754509, -0.0064277383498847485, 0.020363761112093925, -0.062496088445186615, -0.06751304864883423, 0.015687312930822372, 0.027320772409439087, 0.007375386077910662, -0.0008519414695911109, -0.061071839183568954, -0.03876431658864021, -0.01097142230719328, 0.00016879798204172403, -0.03833598271012306, -0.04220139980316162, 0.014788206666707993, 0.0008091559866443276, 0.025757700204849243, 0.052399277687072754, 0.05704011395573616, -0.01779910735785961, 0.050829075276851654, -0.01337006688117981, -0.03475920483469963, -0.03967202827334404, -0.027595069259405136, -0.020874151960015297, -0.0023663833271712065, -0.06392930448055267, -0.013863425701856613, 0.06609117239713669, 0.07595589756965637, 0.031838834285736084, 0.05844610184431076, -0.033427171409130096, -0.050471000373363495, -0.008469986729323864, -0.010913162492215633, 0.07266191393136978, 0.04805949330329895, -0.010233473964035511, 0.0077263652347028255, -0.0305086188018322, 0.0035507765132933855, 0.006938390899449587, 0.027753179892897606, -0.013369856402277946, -0.005429355427622795, -0.04077044129371643, -0.07264097779989243, 0.08032213151454926, 0.037938836961984634, 0.027047174051404, -0.03491893410682678, -0.026324985548853874, 0.023928478360176086, 0.03988814726471901, -0.04384322091937065, 0.006246035452932119, -0.04706040024757385, 0.029669998213648796, 0.055465396493673325, 0.008249850943684578, -0.03930715098977089, -0.04994479566812515, -0.058606360107660294, -0.03170861676335335, 0.006497672758996487, 0.05939348414540291, 0.03604203090071678, 0.03337904438376427, -0.026577111333608627, -0.029396049678325653, -0.02218400500714779, 0.06701228767633438, -0.02657085657119751, -0.04253596439957619, 0.01737123914062977, -0.021447470411658287, 0.021067725494503975, -0.0035888897255063057, -0.001462540589272976, -0.01378576084971428, -0.06165231019258499, 0.030113017186522484, -0.039736729115247726, 0.02784227766096592, 0.01247713714838028, 0.023083297535777092, 0.011909314431250095, 0.044916797429323196, 0.0049657924100756645, -0.008848201483488083, 0.0051112789660692215, -0.0138264000415802, 0.029690885916352272, 0.03233721852302551, 0.0006071724346838892, -0.027843907475471497, -0.028176605701446533, 0.03231113776564598, -0.04172767326235771, -0.03826522082090378, -0.057421304285526276, 0.01827791891992092, 0.02461463212966919, -0.03528165817260742, -0.0807260051369667, -0.07718893140554428, -0.0504593625664711, -0.02584938146173954, -0.042941559106111526, -0.06614764779806137, 0.05112734064459801, -0.010949959978461266, -0.00946719292551279, 0.014313522726297379, 0.004149315878748894, 0.005618628114461899, 0.017239563167095184, -0.04770992323756218, -0.03138231858611107, 0.030415035784244537, -0.04000717028975487, 0.014566389843821526, -0.04948582500219345, 0.002966799307614565, -0.06637358665466309, 0.019308771938085556, -0.032756201922893524, 0.06397397071123123, 0.06613734364509583, 0.028819236904382706, 0.04177755489945412, 0.02271941676735878, -0.00239622057415545, 0.041549067944288254, -0.026580659672617912, -0.023052558302879333, -0.001042070216499269, 0.02912011928856373, -0.011867856606841087, -0.024086827412247658, -0.0008989173220470548, 0.03038254752755165, 0.06690725684165955, -0.05591154471039772, -0.04396424442529678, 0.012195869348943233, 0.06487498432397842, 0.02663753367960453, -0.06193720921874046, 0.04060354083776474, -0.011105683632194996, -0.027246536687016487, 0.009807557798922062, 0.011618014425039291, -0.01699386164546013, 0.01272406056523323, 0.036817751824855804, -0.03917821869254112, 0.027427824214100838, 0.009483866393566132, 0.0032793243881314993, -0.001246843719854951, 0.03528339043259621, -0.03134595602750778, 0.04363039508461952, -0.054641757160425186, 0.026983024552464485, -0.03295815736055374, 0.008224858902394772, -0.022805098444223404, 0.03278389200568199, 0.031327832490205765, 0.037618596106767654, -0.05927274003624916, 0.044710371643304825, -0.017941158264875412, -0.056254275143146515, -0.013369022868573666, -0.010353746823966503, -0.02796882390975952, 0.04490205645561218, 0.01845160685479641, -0.027901481837034225, 0.01958857849240303, 0.0179249607026577, -0.023045936599373817, 0.023044278845191002, 0.02797728031873703, 0.048962853848934174, 0.02368965931236744, 0.01874738559126854, -0.03283921256661415, -0.03765435516834259, -0.054039809852838516, -0.021534085273742676, -0.07761130481958389, 0.04591895639896393, 0.030525008216500282, -0.02001744881272316, 0.00456262519583106, 0.059307388961315155, 0.024761144071817398, -0.0474381223320961, -0.023302927613258362, -0.030540447682142258, -0.008360727690160275, 0.05050469934940338, -0.04198973998427391, -0.01806851476430893, 0.037058908492326736, 0.03379752114415169, 0.03222496807575226, 0.012671482749283314, -0.014462219551205635, -0.04634843021631241, 0.00698527367785573, 0.0060572512447834015, 0.029290152713656425, 0.024393899366259575, 0.00022287352476269007, 0.04433807358145714, -0.0024799425154924393, 0.007074641063809395, -0.047005973756313324, -0.023840313777327538, 0.0028927791863679886, 0.05431641638278961, -0.04880242422223091, -0.020992141216993332, 0.006225373595952988, 0.07230822741985321, 0.013305649161338806, 0.007492355536669493, 0.007343772333115339, -0.029976313933730125, -0.03364802151918411, 0.0431382991373539, 0.018741007894277573, -0.009632251225411892, -0.01908900961279869, -0.03074915148317814, 0.03011600486934185, -0.045328836888074875, -0.006237443070858717, -0.02366185374557972, 0.01770666614174843, 0.025887615978717804, -0.026931779459118843, 0.00972026027739048, -0.059897810220718384, -0.057012349367141724, 0.07193152606487274, -0.08186472952365875, 0.019078616052865982, -0.02592620812356472, -0.05976937338709831, -0.028688447549939156, -0.05450301244854927, 0.0032305216882377863, 0.01884453557431698, 0.018754566088318825, -0.03767386078834534, 0.06350408494472504, 0.013957386836409569, -0.03322480618953705, 0.02099594846367836, 0.021103542298078537, -0.028454624116420746, -0.012041939422488213, -0.01749010570347309, -0.019932743161916733, 0.030414972454309464, 0.041494786739349365, -0.005965458694845438, -0.05518001690506935, -0.012278770096600056, 0.038533713668584824, 0.05014270916581154, -0.010914896614849567, 0.051485881209373474, 0.010900462977588177, 0.02544073760509491, 0.0011842652456834912, -0.05216563865542412, 0.0055759926326572895, -0.029583720490336418, 0.0160727147012949, 0.015820421278476715, -0.008156679570674896, 0.0174090676009655, 0.05395326018333435, -0.058677710592746735, -0.020205935463309288, 0.026062745600938797, 0.013586046174168587, -0.010886779054999352, -0.02445157989859581, -0.05456212908029556, -0.019573187455534935, -0.03062458522617817, -0.0013998644426465034, -0.03638786822557449, -0.002926522633060813, -0.004072297364473343, 0.037307772785425186, -0.0034011309035122395, -0.023415274918079376, -0.04694495350122452, -0.02396482042968273, -0.028411954641342163, 0.000929047993849963, -0.07128162682056427, -0.013527360744774342, 0.005992652382701635, 0.01577017828822136, 0.01544464286416769, 0.0409620963037014, -0.030404189601540565, -0.024168480187654495, -0.05251450836658478, 0.013569396920502186, 0.015956509858369827, 0.019934765994548798, 0.0022917590104043484, -0.01139161828905344, 0.054304156452417374, -0.06876437366008759, 0.04644956439733505, -0.029174817726016045, -0.02915334887802601, -0.004323320928961039, -0.014300373382866383, -0.03941996395587921, -0.019963959231972694, 0.010939221829175949, -0.06480864435434341, 0.04302332177758217, -0.012564647011458874, -0.06861113756895065, -0.08150860667228699, -0.0004365177301224321, -0.011201131157577038, 0.019507138058543205, 0.031465090811252594, -0.019487997516989708, -0.0177838783711195, -0.02124200575053692, 0.04984128102660179, 0.06401681900024414, 0.03719266504049301, -0.025809353217482567, -0.04436960443854332, 0.01994391344487667, -0.04366491734981537, -0.0070240977220237255, 0.015399188734591007, -0.006579938810318708, -0.056026529520750046, -0.035184964537620544, 0.04782579094171524, -0.024405699223279953, 0.00009336201765108854, -0.03261281177401543, -0.07884705066680908, 0.06364502012729645, -0.005263563245534897, -0.022359414026141167, -0.06867434084415436, -0.05207545682787895, 0.030615687370300293, -0.02321937493979931, -0.021975502371788025, -0.015900379046797752, -0.06579632312059402, 0.007510431110858917, -0.08809467405080795, -0.02291679196059704, -0.012681887485086918, 0.052934590727090836, -0.011555064469575882, 0.021888116374611855, 0.0021563819609582424, 0.006702105514705181, 0.01517330203205347, -0.0005802815430797637, -0.025080393999814987, 0.028697125613689423, 0.0034538893960416317, 0.016058191657066345, -0.0068627772852778435, -0.02190079726278782, 0.05833534523844719, -0.010189631022512913, -0.006691944785416126, 0.06813175976276398, 0.007013603579252958, -0.057303864508867264, 0.04332756996154785, -0.011573013849556446, -0.006592053920030594, 0.02269958332180977, -0.044789426028728485, 0.011333934031426907, -0.05289708077907562, -0.07307473570108414, 0.03718046098947525, -0.01685907505452633, 0.007873590104281902, -0.024351000785827637, 0.004569879733026028, -0.004240210633724928, 0.0007879402837716043, -0.026414675638079643, 0.04705365374684334, -0.006057519931346178, -0.023647809401154518, 0.044252909719944, -0.07972007989883423, 0.041765566915273666, 0.03805218264460564, 0.005265981424599886, -0.02180270105600357, 0.00022397059365175664, 0.02127736248075962, -0.0027640140615403652, 0.035778697580099106, -0.04708859324455261, 0.024002719670534134, -0.017035003751516342, 0.017110496759414673, -0.029474878683686256, 0.07351601123809814, -0.05225798860192299, 0.006202323362231255, -0.06757892668247223, -0.043201517313718796, -0.011422625742852688, -0.04791213199496269, 0.007959999144077301, -0.021081117913126945, 0.019984543323516846, -0.0062787351198494434, 0.03987518325448036, -0.019939741119742393, 0.014043902978301048, 0.029278317466378212, -0.005832584574818611, -0.0002626523491926491, 0.011993775144219398, -0.029683630913496017, 0.015839064493775368, -0.031591977924108505, -0.06969070434570312, -0.07646793872117996, -0.027300961315631866, -0.009814144112169743, -0.028340214863419533, -0.030447062104940414, 0.018709266558289528, 0.0019940747879445553, -0.017971763387322426, -0.013232167810201645, 0.00646408274769783, -0.04934404790401459, -0.04791640862822533, 0.0004525868280325085, 0.04290615767240524, -0.02476121112704277, -0.05421663820743561 ]
We answer a question of Pakhomov by showing that there is a consistent, c.e. theory $T$ such that no theory which is definitionally equivalent to $T$ has a computable model. A key tool in our proof is the model-theoretic notion of mutual algebraicity.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11598v1
[ -0.0047402032651007175, -0.021503791213035583, -0.03832348436117172, -0.0015063368482515216, 0.019311321899294853, -0.012337136082351208, -0.05032116919755936, -0.0010212574852630496, -0.06338571012020111, 0.012785534374415874, -0.009559941478073597, -0.045561254024505615, 0.02254706248641014, -0.039548926055431366, -0.050350114703178406, -0.02714262716472149, 0.061780061572790146, 0.04743729531764984, 0.014025128446519375, 0.021152827888727188, -0.06574495881795883, 0.01772134192287922, -0.00921966414898634, 0.05385809764266014, -0.03441083803772926, -0.03350313380360603, -0.031859979033470154, -0.023869846016168594, -0.04153010994195938, -0.010184387676417828, 0.07053840160369873, -0.023679567500948906, -0.0351504310965538, -0.024695128202438354, 0.01226898469030857, 0.02088957093656063, 0.0349954254925251, 0.014500563964247704, 0.047541022300720215, -0.021946236491203308, 0.061124660074710846, -0.03790505602955818, -0.06763391941785812, -0.06938809901475906, 0.03562932834029198, -0.04032059386372566, -0.04271477460861206, -0.023573074489831924, -0.04074189439415932, -0.058881666511297226, 0.03633628785610199, -0.006338375620543957, 0.011344335041940212, -0.026284419000148773, -0.058994438499212265, -0.03393283113837242, 0.026335297152400017, 0.006625068373978138, -0.013426115736365318, 0.01777184009552002, -0.00821315124630928, 0.03161421790719032, -0.024794111028313637, 0.004136316012591124, -0.04893050342798233, -0.031677402555942535, -0.011960623785853386, -0.022570142522454262, -0.016853513196110725, 0.0031714916694909334, 0.0014213689137250185, -0.031855642795562744, 0.015803145244717598, -0.03344391658902168, -0.06289192289113998, 0.021329347044229507, 0.0172182135283947, -0.018052035942673683, -0.01282872911542654, 0.009343595243990421, -0.0024766840506345034, -0.03935830667614937, -0.01082934346050024, -0.05828489363193512, 0.02965790033340454, -0.010413703508675098, 0.009033206850290298, -0.02806168422102928, 0.02737063355743885, -0.06149498000741005, 0.002481588628143072, -0.017023256048560143, -0.07108812034130096, -0.05381489172577858, 0.03499757871031761, -0.06994634866714478, 0.0032403196673840284, 0.038543686270713806, -0.020873088389635086, -0.013656371273100376, 0.0026233268436044455, -0.0719950944185257, -0.029680225998163223, -0.06052807718515396, -0.03403891995549202, -0.034266822040081024, 0.010710148140788078, -0.030850356444716454, -0.05513433739542961, 0.049395035952329636, -0.04922987148165703, 0.010873974300920963, -0.0524405874311924, -0.02504916675388813, 0.020772891119122505, -0.07013514637947083, 0.034634556621313095, 0.05480937287211418, 0.03279205411672592, 0.008734914474189281, -0.007793947588652372, 0.0021802312694489956, 0.03717251121997833, -0.013283664360642433, -0.039568595588207245, -0.06133990362286568, -0.021485311910510063, 0.01775733008980751, 0.0018759721424430609, -0.025018448010087013, -0.02517744153738022, -0.025598442181944847, 0.010205757804214954, -0.022007780149579048, 0.036604367196559906, 0.0037267899606376886, -0.003998422063887119, -0.05088203027844429, 0.0020904482807964087, -0.008336585946381092, -0.0019565608818084, -0.0734112337231636, 0.016661733388900757, 0.028539404273033142, -0.0383581779897213, 0.0013012278359383345, -0.061021145433187485, 0.018144864588975906, -0.01206791028380394, 0.032469965517520905, -0.034746091812849045, 0.016391003504395485, -0.0079573355615139, 0.024412140250205994, -0.017731711268424988, -0.04327522963285446, 0.019357066601514816, -0.00259747845120728, -0.06551304459571838, 0.023740792647004128, -0.02519129402935505, 0.012584778480231762, 0.010625342838466167, -0.02296181581914425, 0.028329430148005486, 0.015862565487623215, -0.0322713740170002, -0.016602037474513054, 0.014071619138121605, 0.007513163611292839, 0.03298141807317734, -0.020698081701993942, -0.010539035312831402, -0.04445982724428177, -0.0587594099342823, 0.000252185040153563, -0.03255348280072212, -0.051972609013319016, -0.047706764191389084, 0.03520631045103073, -0.0026067004073411226, -0.05316821485757828, -0.049806661903858185, -0.026765981689095497, -0.01814599707722664, 0.0538053959608078, -0.012362830340862274, 0.03213972970843315, 0.03422662243247032, 0.008067987859249115, -0.030486388131976128, -0.048452213406562805, -0.010301745496690273, 0.016242096200585365, -0.027874784544110298, 0.022677309811115265, -0.0020806521642953157, -0.0013663074932992458, -0.045265331864356995, 0.05596844106912613, -0.06954901665449142, 0.039928652346134186, -0.024903053417801857, -0.006596314255148172, -0.05901479721069336, -0.057239312678575516, -0.04276583343744278, 0.05130573362112045, -0.031003743410110474, -0.06103600561618805, 0.07019461691379547, 0.010346248745918274, 0.056339044123888016, -0.01771274209022522, -0.013526510447263718, -0.007451763842254877, -0.08186084777116776, 0.0711074098944664, -0.017233887687325478, 0.010609961114823818, -0.026834703981876373, 0.04160367324948311, 0.003944339230656624, -0.02602655626833439, -0.029604721814393997, 0.050825923681259155, 0.010977410711348057, 0.06187383458018303, 0.007874352857470512, -0.018987277522683144, 0.009596253745257854, -0.042070645838975906, -0.029076380655169487, -0.06517957150936127, -0.0621076300740242, 0.024175861850380898, -0.034519609063863754, 0.043591469526290894, -0.036930669099092484, -0.0543753020465374, -0.06709699332714081, -0.042410556226968765, 0.007057973183691502, 0.01072845607995987, -0.0004154699563514441, -0.03539233282208443, 0.027211962267756462, 0.020637869834899902, -0.0472039058804512, -0.005016270559281111, 0.053258009254932404, -0.06247527524828911, -0.034199073910713196, -0.04798552393913269, -0.01453216653317213, 0.037839002907276154, -0.015081857331097126, 0.01471574418246746, 0.014703403227031231, -0.016557246446609497, -0.004635371267795563, 0.04487454891204834, 0.024537600576877594, -0.05142626911401749, 0.027679666876792908, -0.04835310950875282, -0.028935082256793976, 0.029532460495829582, -0.04450372979044914, -0.03398367017507553, 0.0123291639611125, 0.04512619599699974, 0.003845633240416646, 0.030400222167372704, -0.03558119013905525, -0.021601511165499687, -0.05476200208067894, -0.04898025095462799, 0.04683861508965492, -0.007817556150257587, 0.025142092257738113, -0.043661586940288544, -0.05142868682742119, -0.07467062026262283, -0.039484020322561264, 0.05491824820637703, -0.05974551662802696, -0.018871735781431198, -0.02656853012740612, 0.0056571257300674915, -0.07653418928384781, 0.01142027322202921, -0.04466976597905159, -0.028216207399964333, -0.061273831874132156, -0.06909488141536713, -0.05638590827584267, -0.06190994009375572, -0.012944699265062809, -0.0693385973572731, -0.053616806864738464, -0.029471218585968018, -0.05681559070944786, -0.01925664022564888, -0.025675753131508827, -0.06731921434402466, -0.013656681403517723, -0.02131984569132328, -0.03543832153081894, -0.004178130533546209, -0.02477443777024746, -0.01717517338693142, -0.0021594837307929993, 0.0005452333716675639, 0.0008427646243944764, -0.022381747141480446, 0.04276770353317261, -0.007801984902471304, 0.02673565037548542, 0.021042976528406143, -0.03618743643164635, -0.00129610113799572, 0.0009643933735787868, -0.03889874741435051, -0.04359276965260506, -0.0193136315792799, 0.01887623593211174, 0.009075256995856762, -0.0364229679107666, -0.04006226733326912, -0.052579522132873535, -0.056685954332351685, 0.04190344363451004, 0.021273886784911156, -0.025835849344730377, 0.04272359237074852, 0.006551533937454224, -0.0033361027017235756, -0.047661248594522476, 0.0033993434626609087, -0.05430248752236366, 0.052352048456668854, -0.04211414232850075, -0.014615222811698914, 0.04264605790376663, -0.07725279778242111, 0.051193371415138245, 0.037805963307619095, -0.004482418764382601, 0.017471836879849434, -0.002480001887306571, 0.037586625665426254, -0.02428535185754299, -0.059261880815029144, 0.003732624463737011, -0.013002353720366955, 0.022540021687746048, -0.014665099792182446, -0.06419452279806137, -0.0005275325383991003, 0.039059288799762726, -0.002222944051027298, -0.0058662849478423595, 0.04203511029481888, -0.03973675146698952, 0.014089935459196568, 0.02104882150888443, -0.04478834569454193, -0.024819279089570045, -0.03260991722345352, 0.022841300815343857, -0.007957357913255692, -0.03297320753335953, -0.006621779873967171, -0.03890295699238777, -0.032889969646930695, 0.01647236943244934, 0.021863972768187523, -0.062172818928956985, -0.01636837236583233, -0.04782937839627266, -0.03065124899148941, 0.009748194366693497, 0.0366702601313591, -0.05318266525864601, -0.04617894068360329, -0.04982852563261986, -0.01038588397204876, 0.0030172504484653473, -0.046035733073949814, -0.0028741518035531044, -0.022402673959732056, 0.060193415731191635, 0.0045846314169466496, -0.0035870166029781103, -0.05102800950407982, -0.025527890771627426, 0.004044366534799337, -0.038456499576568604, -0.05008317157626152, 0.010335167869925499, 0.019044997170567513, -0.051459651440382004, -0.07474246621131897, -0.06542797386646271, -0.06748925149440765, -0.010545541532337666, -0.015165301971137524, -0.07467284053564072, 0.05997026711702347, -0.04761979356408119, 0.01398425828665495, 0.022890372201800346, -0.0372791513800621, -0.02324553020298481, -0.05810956656932831, -0.0334959514439106, -0.035012226551771164, -0.01368273701518774, -0.04316718503832817, -0.015309639275074005, 0.01690049096941948, -0.02594652585685253, -0.046611934900283813, 0.0020430968143045902, 0.007828759029507637, -0.0037931499537080526, 0.05474476143717766, 0.0047379485331475735, 0.04150032624602318, -0.053628355264663696, -0.02546774409711361, -0.06336349993944168, -0.049404583871364594, -0.028265001252293587, -0.01863725855946541, 0.016972562298178673, -0.02759222313761711, 0.006795275490731001, -0.024653319269418716, -0.042980995029211044, 0.006641529966145754, -0.05566969886422157, -0.024673160165548325, -0.06284792721271515, 0.05668478459119797, -0.05711347982287407, -0.06792113929986954, 0.010838513262569904, -0.021298538893461227, -0.06467701494693756, 0.010793131776154041, 0.014802735298871994, -0.01492395345121622, -0.051696356385946274, -0.029941152781248093, -0.015819182619452477, -0.007701884489506483, -0.011989220976829529, -0.023077189922332764, 0.020835595205426216, -0.04639318212866783, -0.05412955954670906, -0.015319372527301311, -0.06510890275239944, -0.043903253972530365, -0.06387640535831451, 0.03461509943008423, 0.06240713223814964, 0.0464966706931591, -0.03368525579571724, 0.0022622309625148773, -0.08023981750011444, 0.028840195387601852, -0.0023052848409861326, -0.05529952421784401, 0.030985821038484573, 0.027638059109449387, -0.05313519760966301, -0.026300255209207535, 0.03276017680764198, -0.05248161032795906, -0.044551171362400055, -0.04478610306978226, 0.018852371722459793, -0.0214922484010458, -0.029076123610138893, -0.044146161526441574, 0.03339869901537895, -0.014250815846025944, -0.060184918344020844, 0.01521936897188425, 0.007244980428367853, -0.025159277021884918, -0.07359801977872849, 0.011550557799637318, 0.01541123352944851, -0.06377708911895752, -0.034606680274009705, -0.041775885969400406, -0.04488006979227066, 0.014209214597940445, 0.018360871821641922, -0.0038580670952796936, 0.020982731133699417, 0.001185907982289791, -0.04650568217039108, 0.011960669420659542, -0.009355714544653893, -0.037500638514757156, -0.02560575306415558, -0.0039921775460243225, 0.0462673045694828, -0.01194857433438301, 0.03321719542145729, -0.0236780047416687, 0.002890697680413723, -0.0007441154448315501, -0.014097603037953377, 0.02017849124968052, 0.008324508555233479, 0.045806702226400375, 0.00407540425658226, -0.01248136442154646, -0.023100584745407104, 0.002141085686162114, 0.03576481714844704, -0.02761872485280037, -0.022261938080191612, -0.016609277576208115, -0.00917000975459814, -0.04243577644228935, -0.034079983830451965, -0.02153475023806095, -0.0047673676162958145, 0.047672491520643234, -0.03045886568725109, -0.04216029867529869, -0.015324210748076439, -0.00929141603410244, 0.04734041541814804, 0.01526679378002882, 0.04520580172538757, -0.029692118987441063, 0.04173145443201065, -0.01713603548705578, -0.003299364820122719, 0.030128851532936096, -0.06957823038101196, -0.043535757809877396, 0.051995981484651566, -0.051842961460351944, 0.008937747217714787, -0.018328972160816193, -0.011943385004997253, -0.03444172814488411, -0.05957360938191414, -0.009172177873551846, 0.04100664332509041, 0.01112228911370039, -0.0020273008849471807, 0.013419627211987972, -0.030434204265475273, -0.0707818865776062, 0.010522820986807346, 0.03512221947312355, -0.06411334872245789, 0.02745058573782444, 0.015578397549688816, -0.03695610538125038, 0.005271941423416138, 0.03431302309036255, -0.01629498228430748, -0.04532691463828087, -0.028766408562660217, 0.04157667234539986, 0.057948898524045944, -0.07028935849666595, 0.06423746794462204, 0.005070907063782215, -0.009643914178013802, 0.01756814308464527, -0.07059179991483688, -0.04291609302163124, 0.02049882337450981, 0.05708964541554451, -0.029050009325146675, -0.043019652366638184, 0.014236267656087875, 0.017378192394971848, -0.00629667192697525, -0.025885293260216713, 0.025917712599039078, 0.012906702235341072, 0.05112887918949127, -0.028255796059966087, -0.03684433549642563, -0.04612422734498978, -0.008262179791927338, -0.03361497074365616, -0.00974027719348669, 0.021479303017258644, -0.0021594157442450523, -0.00046620750799775124, -0.06080333888530731, -0.018421083688735962, -0.01853051781654358, -0.0006875713006593287, -0.06919490545988083, -0.0576954111456871, -0.028004014864563942, 0.02861202321946621, 0.012319888919591904, 0.043538644909858704, 0.022008391097187996, 0.05185189098119736, 0.01160349976271391, -0.024513106793165207, 0.023184161633253098, -0.030722571536898613, -0.03174317255616188, -0.011577486991882324, 0.0017976826056838036, -0.05495917797088623, 0.0481010265648365, -0.05281071737408638, 0.035283688455820084, -0.035652514547109604, -0.065618135035038, 0.04889800772070885, 0.04082964360713959, -0.030830834060907364, 0.01670617237687111, -0.002489160280674696, -0.05071515217423439, -0.03998427838087082, -0.048870254307985306, -0.0012821001000702381, -0.0548575334250927, 0.01981465518474579, 0.0203693900257349, 0.02842753380537033, 0.008916912600398064, -0.033068567514419556, 0.02363256737589836, -0.002550677629187703, 0.01203297358006239, 0.037567585706710815, 0.0443352535367012, -0.00762043846771121, -0.053578708320856094, 0.038409993052482605, 0.0002822769165504724, -0.05789501592516899, -0.036909084767103195, -0.03194992616772652, -0.04245247691869736, -0.04783036559820175, 0.005230914801359177, -0.04221812263131142, 0.051420968025922775, -0.013765592128038406, -0.03462546691298485, 0.040235698223114014, 0.04961670935153961, -0.02596433460712433, -0.06082094460725784, -0.013851422816514969, 0.022531194612383842, -0.019110005348920822, -0.02441437914967537, -0.04820944741368294, -0.06885144114494324, -0.028069712221622467, -0.07804349064826965, -0.05982087180018425, 0.029678020626306534, -0.005577280651777983, 0.03991129249334335, 0.007858994416892529, 0.0006577479653060436, -0.038579583168029785, 0.01485082320868969, -0.029374442994594574, -0.022859180346131325, 0.04954542592167854, -0.0031530349515378475, -0.03274375572800636, -0.01633049175143242, -0.004876714665442705, 0.014928893186151981, -0.011490060947835445, -0.031678736209869385, 0.023549340665340424, 0.020752673968672752, -0.04331415146589279, 0.01817939057946205, -0.02864789217710495, -0.03140623867511749, 0.0003518414159771055, -0.02032206952571869, -0.00022877409355714917, -0.046594586223363876, -0.03814435005187988, 0.05202991142868996, -0.035105738788843155, -0.03251788392663002, -0.019130196422338486, 0.0073904539458453655, -0.03415348008275032, -0.002597541082650423, -0.06670353561639786, 0.03707566484808922, -0.007497668731957674, -0.0035617388784885406, -0.022579407319426537, -0.06550765037536621, -0.013034173287451267, 0.03250311315059662, -0.012459653429687023, -0.011409033089876175, -0.018622301518917084, 0.04473671689629555, -0.02137910947203636, 0.005257585551589727, -0.04981561750173569, -0.01686066761612892, -0.0110921086743474, 0.04419996589422226, 0.043856970965862274, 0.05457063019275665, -0.020746350288391113, 0.02606721967458725, -0.037978868931531906, -0.0024284610990434885, -0.004968872759491205, -0.05114103853702545, 0.019933488219976425, 0.017838310450315475, 0.026663433760404587, 0.05172280967235565, 0.04776773229241371, -0.014449226669967175, 0.023753918707370758, 0.02413921244442463, -0.001948860939592123, 0.02681182138621807, 0.020013997331261635, -0.06532569229602814, 0.04681737348437309, 0.0260219294577837, -0.06503573060035706, -0.03169569745659828, 0.011571409180760384, -0.031375702470541, -0.06597691029310226, 0.0018777576042339206, -0.04779784008860588, -0.0008288643439300358, -0.06232835352420807, -0.025519784539937973, 0.03468628600239754, -0.026241665706038475, -0.04904841631650925, 0.004636006895452738, 0.008124131709337234, -0.04982537776231766, 0.005990092176944017 ]
Oxide heterostructures exhibit a vast variety of unique physical properties. Examples are unconventional superconductivity in layered nickelates and topological polar order in (PbTiO$_3$)$_n$/(SrTiO$_3$)$_n$ superlattices. Although it is clear that variations in oxygen content are crucial for the electronic correlation phenomena in oxides, it remains a major challenge to quantify their impact. Here, we measure the chemical composition in multiferroic (LuFeO$_3$)$_9$/(LuFe$_2$O$_4$)$_1$ superlattices, revealing a one-to-one correlation between the distribution of oxygen vacancies and the electric and magnetic properties. Using atom probe tomography, we observe oxygen vacancies arranging in a layered three-dimensional structure with a local density on the order of 10$^{14}$ cm$^{-2}$, congruent with the formula-unit-thick ferrimagnetic LuFe$_2$O$_4$ layers. The vacancy order is promoted by the locally reduced formation energy and plays a key role in stabilizing the ferroelectric domains and ferrimagnetism in the LuFeO$_3$ and LuFe$_2$O$_4$ layers, respectively. The results demonstrate the importance of oxygen vacancies for the room-temperature multiferroicity in this system and establish an approach for quantifying the oxygen defects with atomic-scale precision in 3D, giving new opportunities for deterministic defect-enabled property control in oxide heterostructures.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.00139v1
[ -0.07704423367977142, -0.057571541517972946, 0.027441781014204025, 0.01871325634419918, -0.019520876929163933, -0.03966892510652542, -0.005430905148386955, 0.02478662319481373, 0.012521096505224705, -0.03382566198706627, 0.03243489935994148, -0.06799326837062836, -0.015519289299845695, -0.041749462485313416, -0.035769812762737274, 0.013927140273153782, 0.05454336479306221, 0.04863898456096649, -0.028854258358478546, 0.06878724694252014, 0.035304781049489975, -0.0372309610247612, -0.032809287309646606, 0.04332350939512253, -0.020461753010749817, -0.02625865489244461, -0.05272863060235977, 0.011874099262058735, 0.0304451584815979, -0.010712722316384315, 0.05004162713885307, -0.011419701389968395, -0.01169488113373518, -0.008751153945922852, -0.03843923658132553, 0.006888169329613447, 0.007207666523754597, 0.06776197999715805, 0.002900443971157074, -0.029307983815670013, -0.01503800693899393, -0.025703227147459984, -0.059427905827760696, -0.017471248283982277, -0.003089500591158867, -0.045513253659009933, -0.011631280183792114, -0.015289600007236004, -0.03911870718002319, -0.05860685929656029, 0.0676216408610344, 0.024986889213323593, -0.016706541180610657, 0.05928625911474228, -0.027990933507680893, 0.006259002722799778, -0.025972584262490273, -0.05922824516892433, 0.0001828549720812589, -0.00042371064773760736, -0.011336884461343288, -0.0540824756026268, 0.027277976274490356, -0.0470782034099102, -0.03969375044107437, 0.018791917711496353, -0.04446929693222046, -0.07010840624570847, -0.02540772035717964, -0.06056633219122887, 0.007638666778802872, -0.06749660521745682, 0.00586008932441473, -0.0164894200861454, -0.06525528430938721, -0.0008248556987382472, -0.04212534427642822, 0.0264496598392725, -0.02951022796332836, 0.02770267054438591, -0.017117254436016083, -0.014285370707511902, -0.03072992153465748, -0.00024282994854729623, 0.013756789267063141, -0.014106296002864838, -0.00179336778819561, -0.05424630641937256, 0.03239024057984352, -0.04030315950512886, 0.023632319644093513, -0.026678811758756638, -0.010011021047830582, 0.03115655854344368, 0.059975966811180115, -0.033771734684705734, 0.04913334921002388, 0.02512999065220356, 0.042268168181180954, -0.0643189549446106, 0.010910076089203358, -0.06777124106884003, -0.000849905249197036, 0.017900509759783745, -0.01568111591041088, -0.00015191486454568803, -0.0012928243959322572, 0.013834494166076183, -0.06035389006137848, 0.04392847791314125, -0.0011940335389226675, 0.035399723798036575, -0.04682270810008049, -0.05063753202557564, -0.07348962128162384, -0.031375952064991, 0.04366147890686989, 0.045556262135505676, 0.036271099001169205, 0.031533438712358475, -0.009720460511744022, 0.03518977016210556, 0.028979727998375893, 0.0035273844841867685, -0.03716002404689789, 0.008847342804074287, 0.05639342591166496, -0.0028221530374139547, 0.04359959438443184, -0.0192587748169899, -0.056696463376283646, 0.029705891385674477, 0.06876441836357117, -0.04440431669354439, 0.03776155412197113, -0.05660960078239441, 0.048327088356018066, -0.002111968584358692, -0.03276963159441948, 0.04219960421323776, -0.020894212648272514, -0.07261615991592407, 0.011516092345118523, -0.032434605062007904, 0.02856168895959854, -0.0049875215627253056, -0.06741500645875931, -0.007864496670663357, 0.04833662882447243, 0.04968757554888725, 0.005290644243359566, 0.026478169485926628, 0.00282927299849689, -0.024848535656929016, -0.0039972267113626, 0.011527255177497864, 0.01559573132544756, 0.027805261313915253, -0.014332480728626251, 0.004196036607027054, -0.03330761939287186, -0.03631800785660744, 0.00838815700262785, -0.019226251170039177, -0.016296688467264175, -0.0040379902347922325, 0.025508375838398933, 0.0021395194344222546, 0.007737047038972378, 0.016133863478899002, -0.020948341116309166, -0.008200137875974178, 0.01808159612119198, -0.067002072930336, -0.06320448219776154, -0.008067503571510315, 0.05109022185206413, -0.018566375598311424, -0.015467028133571148, 0.009912083856761456, 0.0238078273832798, -0.020023399963974953, -0.019102545455098152, -0.026873044669628143, -0.020371440798044205, 0.013369807042181492, -0.05418065935373306, 0.030236557126045227, 0.008391539566218853, -0.013209679163992405, 0.013025443069636822, -0.05304023623466492, 0.03717944771051407, -0.004997404757887125, -0.05814211070537567, 0.011952338740229607, 0.05039559304714203, -0.04272979870438576, 0.014964532107114792, 0.028493886813521385, -0.07846099883317947, 0.013436478562653065, 0.003870030865073204, -0.01667655259370804, 0.014592016115784645, -0.0668291449546814, -0.01782126910984516, 0.06985361129045486, -0.012304103933274746, -0.04110235348343849, 0.05684410408139229, 0.040704645216464996, 0.013818665407598019, -0.032422445714473724, -0.04056977108120918, -0.05790132284164429, -0.09710021317005157, 0.044660020619630814, 0.044208597391843796, 0.018171772360801697, 0.0673772469162941, 0.05458709970116615, -0.014029506593942642, -0.040140796452760696, -0.020128285512328148, 0.053985364735126495, 0.03618123009800911, -0.02956700511276722, -0.016565509140491486, 0.03295105695724487, 0.004581806715577841, -0.035340242087841034, -0.06283434480428696, -0.05977384001016617, -0.04310530051589012, -0.013431854546070099, -0.05224634334445, 0.049652837216854095, -0.010375771671533585, -0.03225935623049736, -0.036299437284469604, -0.006065110210329294, 0.05845392867922783, 0.03787887096405029, -0.06292405724525452, -0.04510688781738281, -0.06904379278421402, 0.04295719042420387, -0.04037848114967346, -0.031269557774066925, 0.021188585087656975, -0.059286076575517654, -0.03184812143445015, -0.017812959849834442, 0.01386973075568676, 0.05225983262062073, -0.027645491063594818, -0.005740805994719267, -0.03963295742869377, 0.036289114505052567, -0.03597225621342659, 0.022902628406882286, -0.04503488168120384, 0.045174144208431244, -0.016725320369005203, 0.01137149054557085, -0.044544413685798645, -0.011496362276375294, -0.03786948695778847, -0.042526256293058395, -0.0037330042105168104, 0.018035292625427246, 0.02998393215239048, 0.010474038310348988, 0.006238727830350399, -0.005925661884248257, -0.05896884948015213, -0.021669406443834305, 0.020298637449741364, 0.011493518948554993, 0.07026994973421097, 0.0308748297393322, 0.013128154911100864, -0.0673791915178299, -0.06321344524621964, -0.007421327754855156, -0.00028056695009581745, -0.050059087574481964, -0.012237983755767345, -0.034005820751190186, -0.04440592601895332, 0.011649607680737972, -0.04081650450825691, -0.04707726836204529, -0.02407907135784626, -0.0669315978884697, -0.05004839599132538, -0.010543061420321465, -0.0064391642808914185, -0.049866560846567154, -0.05081376060843468, 0.04573941230773926, 0.008137194439768791, -0.0004060003557242453, -0.030711155384778976, -0.006291714496910572, -0.04597413167357445, -0.010027101263403893, 0.019519994035363197, -0.03897649422287941, -0.036315932869911194, -0.025198137387633324, -0.08349243551492691, 0.027216484770178795, -0.01289635431021452, 0.051481977105140686, 0.002689620479941368, -0.043362006545066833, 0.004830898717045784, 0.03531856834888458, -0.02626764588057995, -0.0307345949113369, 0.03913048654794693, 0.03332104533910751, -0.05122122913599014, -0.05496371164917946, 0.027112282812595367, 0.07689923793077469, 0.013745018281042576, -0.050757598131895065, -0.055912990123033524, 0.008569956757128239, 0.042809560894966125, -0.03115195967257023, 0.0554397888481617, 0.03951917961239815, 0.002007768489420414, -0.03960662707686424, -0.041411884129047394, 0.02762933447957039, -0.017701219767332077, -0.027089934796094894, 0.002114734845235944, 0.03408330678939819, 0.03492305427789688, -0.02127140946686268, 0.05600382015109062, 0.05989012494683266, 0.0758369043469429, 0.017409564927220345, -0.00043321936391294, 0.009004021063446999, -0.012760919518768787, 0.04197827726602554, 0.00414627231657505, 0.03789205849170685, 0.04287605360150337, 0.03966753929853439, -0.018344826996326447, -0.025985313579440117, -0.035856693983078, -0.06556668132543564, -0.038751617074012756, 0.022374451160430908, -0.05777117609977722, 0.05647871270775795, -0.011149433441460133, 0.014773081056773663, 0.019286585971713066, 0.007433521561324596, 0.04959999769926071, -0.05041172727942467, -0.054964739829301834, 0.012120053172111511, -0.02849116176366806, -0.009264147840440273, 0.002077714540064335, -0.009164093062281609, -0.04032508283853531, -0.048938900232315063, -0.0080630574375391, -0.0655689537525177, -0.015207957476377487, 0.03561265766620636, 0.031329404562711716, 0.021052036434412003, 0.03093111328780651, 0.06314486265182495, 0.039617739617824554, 0.0035342795308679342, -0.011390125378966331, -0.04288939759135246, -0.029386622831225395, 0.025605488568544388, 0.031717780977487564, 0.03204797953367233, -0.06671074032783508, 0.016762563958764076, -0.05208921432495117, -0.048240628093481064, 0.05733084678649902, 0.009740693494677544, -0.012327426113188267, -0.08956215530633926, -0.017608337104320526, -0.03036198578774929, -0.014095723628997803, -0.006139311473816633, -0.0058255973272025585, 0.06857538968324661, -0.0041290754452347755, 0.0012298201909288764, -0.014440742321312428, -0.007979776710271835, -0.012963513843715191, -0.05859939381480217, -0.029460575431585312, -0.03498333320021629, -0.0035522393882274628, -0.03593811020255089, 0.015542312525212765, 0.007383706979453564, -0.005821504630148411, -0.08207186311483383, 0.03507910296320915, -0.012054377235472202, -0.014382976107299328, 0.04233027249574661, 0.017665548250079155, 0.03970678150653839, -0.031778302043676376, 0.0020379608031362295, 0.02469804510474205, -0.005824417341500521, 0.07551835477352142, -0.055444199591875076, 0.029688550159335136, -0.04948602244257927, -0.03331668674945831, -0.022573743015527725, 0.003233101451769471, 0.015494311228394508, 0.009803498163819313, 0.004215950611978769, -0.0336160846054554, 0.038712143898010254, -0.04244018346071243, -0.029400141909718513, -0.04412089288234711, -0.034152328968048096, -0.07248609513044357, -0.019861316308379173, 0.03153345361351967, -0.023448416963219643, -0.017140626907348633, -0.009618370793759823, 0.021235976368188858, -0.010016004554927349, 0.0004138059448450804, 0.030004847794771194, 0.020608091726899147, 0.028611209243535995, 0.0004798697482328862, -0.019920557737350464, -0.07853589206933975, -0.0035181944258511066, 0.01502651534974575, -0.031060345470905304, 0.002960731042549014, 0.04070241004228592, -0.01603526808321476, 0.013030972331762314, -0.08990301191806793, -0.0033835393842309713, 0.045927636325359344, -0.04327068850398064, 0.004854281898587942, -0.0245982613414526, -0.0006754794158041477, 0.02035030536353588, -0.02133381925523281, 0.013864287175238132, -0.023258434608578682, -0.007266404572874308, -0.021903084591031075, -0.031147651374340057, -0.06234360858798027, 0.006030081305652857, 0.04987054690718651, -0.01989235170185566, -0.06201041862368584, -0.015160706825554371, 0.005809095688164234, -0.010768426582217216, 0.017010336741805077, 0.029854822903871536, 0.02495528757572174, 0.0013080972712486982, -0.060073789209127426, -0.010023610666394234, 0.02428700588643551, 0.025207998231053352, 0.049995001405477524, -0.05095856264233589, -0.015240215696394444, 0.00927021075040102, 0.01874599978327751, 0.052398085594177246, 0.04480576515197754, -0.006594927981495857, -0.039800964295864105, 0.0370672382414341, -0.04678244888782501, -0.06429862231016159, 0.018018214032053947, -0.041514139622449875, -0.0058028786443173885, -0.02077416330575943, -0.01775599829852581, 0.056545525789260864, 0.06517209857702255, -0.0006451105582527816, -0.006852046586573124, -0.011978575959801674, -0.02104351297020912, 0.06669683009386063, -0.018657315522432327, -0.03778494894504547, -0.023224376142024994, 0.03279011324048042, -0.0018251563888043165, -0.05143522098660469, -0.019934719428420067, -0.027117332443594933, -0.03102014772593975, -0.0012915958650410175, 0.04011903330683708, 0.03913513198494911, 0.02418074570596218, -0.009335326962172985, 0.06711127609014511, -0.059831295162439346, 0.0435062050819397, 0.014153415337204933, 0.03199046477675438, 0.05018484592437744, -0.014146766625344753, 0.03985795006155968, -0.0615309476852417, -0.004479856695979834, 0.07820405066013336, -0.06878519058227539, 0.006082965061068535, -0.04237164556980133, 0.000788766541518271, 0.003469708375632763, -0.04311409965157509, 0.000830447708722204, 0.0038217513356357813, -0.029718104749917984, -0.05200599133968353, 0.033110786229372025, -0.012079411186277866, -0.07725080102682114, 0.014680318534374237, 0.011944669298827648, -0.0381903313100338, 0.023020915687084198, 0.021200941875576973, -0.061119940131902695, -0.03903444483876228, 0.0010117697529494762, -0.006647201720625162, -0.009433288127183914, 0.005061723291873932, 0.03643925115466118, 0.05245104432106018, -0.04922248050570488, 0.020565897226333618, 0.022059539332985878, 0.020968932658433914, 0.011091739870607853, -0.0379612036049366, -0.01945342868566513, 0.007338361814618111, 0.051157187670469284, 0.015359857119619846, -0.040689464658498764, -0.00048126219189725816, 0.04468977823853493, 0.03224349766969681, -0.002877328544855118, 0.05389660596847534, 0.022857196629047394, -0.0069709159433841705, -0.018605880439281464, -0.009372027590870857, 0.03876321762800217, -0.0434439517557621, -0.01925060525536537, -0.01962355524301529, 0.06536194682121277, -0.03755995258688927, 0.021999385207891464, 0.007647127378731966, -0.028907589614391327, 0.005318155977874994, -0.02943003922700882, -0.07161781191825867, -0.01749451644718647, -0.043248310685157776, -0.046506404876708984, 0.04406372457742691, 0.018671857193112373, -0.031900640577077866, 0.018110137432813644, -0.053370919078588486, -0.02724873274564743, -0.005491061136126518, 0.0007424645591527224, 0.005943648982793093, 0.009445644915103912, -0.016974758356809616, -0.03430579602718353, 0.046537142246961594, -0.010826374404132366, 0.019290026277303696, -0.028403742238879204, -0.020945478230714798, 0.030707141384482384, -0.025736713781952858, -0.040802862495183945, 0.022769536823034286, -0.03933945670723915, -0.04206940159201622, 0.022676214575767517, 0.023578360676765442, -0.015468449331820011, -0.05461351200938225, -0.0053219981491565704, -0.04549286887049675, -0.04053027182817459, 0.02125708758831024, 0.009359749034047127, 0.07364121079444885, 0.0031178249046206474, 0.024120502173900604, 0.044039059430360794, 0.046539440751075745, -0.038227710872888565, -0.04180373251438141, -0.013231961987912655, 0.07359787821769714, 0.024303127080202103, -0.016178235411643982, -0.05275939032435417, -0.03892810270190239, -0.06567850708961487, -0.005551594775170088, -0.04847651347517967, 0.001156346290372312, -0.032877638936042786, -0.0027432627975940704, 0.05467534810304642, 0.03273415565490723, -0.040915753692388535, -0.08845551311969757, -0.037228334695100784, 0.03405870869755745, 0.02145807258784771, 0.014753472991287708, -0.021070638671517372, -0.07068148255348206, 0.024449869990348816, -0.0696466937661171, -0.04496503993868828, 0.02849479578435421, 0.03776734322309494, 0.04731305316090584, -0.009807989001274109, -0.023579424247145653, -0.0488918162882328, -0.0108975013718009, 0.016282768920063972, 0.008810024708509445, -0.004518454894423485, -0.023452091962099075, -0.016411399468779564, -0.010904684662818909, -0.016069553792476654, 0.04262268543243408, -0.05339992046356201, 0.002002155873924494, -0.020377755165100098, 0.015488808043301105, -0.026076139882206917, 0.01462247222661972, 0.019988883286714554, -0.021889759227633476, 0.04701193422079086, -0.0457378588616848, 0.02802453003823757, -0.005994597915560007, -0.04887925088405609, 0.04536609351634979, -0.046930454671382904, 0.01303027756512165, -0.031015152111649513, -0.019688500091433525, -0.024302760139107704, 0.001799458172172308, -0.05772280693054199, -0.011209849268198013, 0.02732563205063343, -0.005678542423993349, 0.05271859094500542, -0.020625928416848183, 0.023308945819735527, -0.004308994859457016, -0.005239591468125582, -0.00794328935444355, 0.06268038600683212, 0.028256848454475403, -0.051833625882864, -0.019328229129314423, -0.07030773907899857, 0.01187902595847845, -0.008955826051533222, -0.019618162885308266, -0.008937946520745754, 0.05414586514234543, -0.07199697941541672, 0.006563575007021427, -0.019349833950400352, -0.013548333197832108, 0.018890857696533203, -0.07167253643274307, 0.020742574706673622, 0.015154575929045677, 0.004372733645141125, 0.04394062981009483, 0.05754995346069336, 0.00877764169126749, 0.04778994247317314, -0.0340358205139637, -0.007995200343430042, 0.007638988550752401, 0.011485778726637363, 0.038491979241371155, -0.019593898206949234, 0.006001607980579138, -0.017060110345482826, -0.05128060281276703, 0.024214111268520355, -0.010148814879357815, -0.03400431200861931, -0.0127189252525568, -0.03777758404612541, -0.026945311576128006, -0.031200099736452103, -0.03699677437543869, 0.04181714355945587, 0.03288743272423744, -0.0371246263384819, 0.03909015655517578, 0.013105412013828754, -0.022243168205022812, -0.04579825699329376 ]
The remarkable growth and significant success of machine learning have expanded its applications into programming languages and program analysis. However, a key challenge in adopting the latest machine learning methods is the representation of programming languages, which directly impacts the ability of machine learning methods to reason about programs. The absence of numerical awareness, aggregate data structure information, and improper way of presenting variables in previous representation works have limited their performances. To overcome the limitations and challenges of current program representations, we propose a graph-based program representation called PERFOGRAPH. PERFOGRAPH can capture numerical information and the aggregate data structure by introducing new nodes and edges. Furthermore, we propose an adapted embedding method to incorporate numerical awareness. These enhancements make PERFOGRAPH a highly flexible and scalable representation that effectively captures programs intricate dependencies and semantics. Consequently, it serves as a powerful tool for various applications such as program analysis, performance optimization, and parallelism discovery. Our experimental results demonstrate that PERFOGRAPH outperforms existing representations and sets new state-of-the-art results by reducing the error rate by 7.4% (AMD dataset) and 10% (NVIDIA dataset) in the well-known Device Mapping challenge. It also sets new state-of-the-art results in various performance optimization tasks like Parallelism Discovery and NUMA and Prefetchers Configuration prediction.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.00210v2
[ -0.023394696414470673, -0.004816100466996431, 0.022769512608647346, 0.0073212794959545135, -0.04980889707803726, 0.009929005056619644, -0.010722141712903976, 0.0041121370159089565, 0.016504129394888878, -0.012143734842538834, -0.07192500680685043, 0.030009258538484573, -0.044808752834796906, -0.020135870203375816, -0.058720141649246216, -0.014462715946137905, 0.07547729462385178, 0.036911893635988235, -0.03475450724363327, 0.07656458765268326, 0.017577489838004112, -0.0026782432105392218, -0.06098112091422081, 0.050961241126060486, 0.010110332630574703, -0.011947304010391235, -0.03376321122050285, -0.003049428341910243, 0.03657771274447441, 0.0009470531949773431, 0.06549447029829025, -0.03950178995728493, -0.03596692532300949, -0.027136823162436485, -0.03890922665596008, -0.029971325770020485, -0.0409054271876812, 0.02263362891972065, 0.04293001815676689, -0.05192664638161659, 0.05144877731800079, -0.039881277829408646, -0.04051147401332855, -0.023816294968128204, -0.04705721139907837, 0.0025410682428628206, -0.04282349720597267, 0.008101933635771275, -0.04912886396050453, -0.04098684340715408, 0.046983107924461365, -0.0182383731007576, -0.006971375085413456, 0.05735151469707489, -0.01387583464384079, -0.000528033182490617, -0.026610979810357094, -0.009168867021799088, -0.0404212512075901, 0.011570271104574203, 0.03155390918254852, -0.006908513605594635, -0.05334507301449776, 0.006761415861546993, 0.00035081608803011477, 0.024909261614084244, -0.023454846814274788, -0.06870637834072113, -0.04167608171701431, -0.03636354207992554, 0.027061983942985535, -0.06613098829984665, -0.022356398403644562, 0.04944941774010658, -0.03511838987469673, -0.002661614678800106, 0.011483852751553059, -0.026382412761449814, -0.00403983611613512, -0.030380940064787865, -0.02798154577612877, -0.006745300255715847, 0.014475042000412941, 0.033881496638059616, -0.02846655808389187, -0.027313511818647385, 0.0370311476290226, -0.0216966662555933, -0.01890808343887329, -0.018275534734129906, 0.04799163341522217, -0.039908938109874725, -0.07905859500169754, 0.013037403114140034, 0.06588884443044662, 0.01763823628425598, 0.029956666752696037, 0.019022364169359207, 0.018607469275593758, -0.038706108927726746, -0.07370597869157791, -0.0027257013134658337, -0.0273294597864151, 0.046186644583940506, 0.030090799555182457, -0.027776578441262245, -0.001520741730928421, -0.02784031815826893, -0.05927225202322006, -0.014727429486811161, -0.021646039560437202, -0.0038445298559963703, -0.021459421142935753, -0.06064118072390556, -0.06479225307703018, -0.05232396349310875, 0.03718678653240204, -0.012504524551331997, -0.00904113333672285, -0.00367396860383451, -0.03239705413579941, 0.022643249481916428, 0.052571363747119904, -0.035173382610082626, -0.0574653223156929, -0.008657692931592464, 0.052381712943315506, -0.018413539975881577, 0.0004937467165291309, -0.022843293845653534, -0.028830265626311302, 0.0432395301759243, -0.013580604456365108, -0.037823472172021866, 0.07189160585403442, 0.005646626465022564, -0.01172596588730812, -0.04757164791226387, 0.061869412660598755, 0.001423632726073265, -0.033771637827157974, -0.05709262564778328, 0.02530115284025669, -0.012528683058917522, 0.009868934750556946, 0.06563842296600342, -0.030959999188780785, -0.010235592722892761, 0.007474144920706749, -0.003907104954123497, 0.0022050663828849792, -0.021501785144209862, 0.027362264692783356, 0.023787712678313255, 0.018088895827531815, 0.01955534517765045, 0.04529137164354324, -0.02703123353421688, -0.05384915694594383, 0.033291105180978775, 0.00561482971534133, -0.0233925711363554, 0.049069974571466446, -0.011285549029707909, 0.012115178629755974, 0.002027645241469145, 0.05351782962679863, -0.019276730716228485, 0.0005179738509468734, 0.0461445190012455, -0.06316491216421127, 0.002522879047319293, -0.038666993379592896, -0.035594914108514786, -0.07123169302940369, 0.001130225253291428, 0.019467761740088463, -0.07491042464971542, -0.0565764456987381, -0.031109359115362167, 0.00537039153277874, 0.03017530031502247, -0.02609201706945896, -0.0065652746707201, -0.01915954239666462, -0.007514323573559523, -0.08663591742515564, 0.018738873302936554, 0.029911475256085396, 0.05001353845000267, -0.0286722294986248, -0.05306139588356018, 0.025728045031428337, 0.011628549546003342, -0.018214957788586617, -0.029072342440485954, 0.012270214036107063, -0.03831006586551666, 0.002078528283163905, 0.032219067215919495, -0.07994945347309113, -0.02979293279349804, -0.07652392238378525, 0.011376537382602692, 0.007655742112547159, -0.07723014056682587, -0.024615658447146416, 0.03960461542010307, -0.024861760437488556, 0.009630989283323288, 0.040121667087078094, 0.02923581190407276, 0.06654198467731476, 0.009393773041665554, 0.007010763511061668, -0.0009518141159787774, -0.09082911908626556, 0.06993411481380463, 0.00007459854532498866, -0.0020636466797441244, 0.019212594255805016, -0.02426101639866829, -0.014601273462176323, -0.04097338020801544, 0.01396426185965538, 0.025923235341906548, 0.04474668204784393, -0.009050151333212852, -0.05535814166069031, -0.043144334107637405, 0.0020893565379083157, -0.038314200937747955, -0.03720482811331749, -0.06969378143548965, -0.009493290446698666, 0.03825511783361435, -0.027739740908145905, 0.023392047733068466, -0.016966944560408592, -0.038160212337970734, -0.028953460976481438, -0.041794948279857635, 0.06810351461172104, -0.002623142907395959, -0.03850981220602989, -0.04004126414656639, -0.013237688690423965, 0.033900801092386246, -0.046563420444726944, -0.021974019706249237, -0.022627675905823708, -0.024285564199090004, 0.003999937325716019, -0.05392029881477356, 0.010478348471224308, 0.037458259612321854, -0.011429434642195702, 0.034029874950647354, 0.008400002494454384, 0.025488130748271942, -0.01130950078368187, 0.01799263246357441, -0.04427805170416832, 0.04891066625714302, 0.03229987248778343, -0.006628526374697685, 0.007745163980871439, -0.009242971427738667, 0.04930363595485687, -0.04811151325702667, -0.016868233680725098, 0.047854963690042496, 0.039041630923748016, -0.025555424392223358, -0.04882597550749779, 0.013599986210465431, -0.00320428516715765, -0.03210480883717537, 0.014264222234487534, 0.06664712727069855, 0.01720540225505829, -0.009473809972405434, 0.007795314304530621, -0.06514788419008255, -0.02321377582848072, -0.025843653827905655, -0.06713545322418213, -0.03855445235967636, -0.030884353443980217, -0.04748908802866936, -0.07357650995254517, -0.05936185270547867, -0.021786240860819817, -0.04827786237001419, 0.0159912146627903, -0.044467631727457047, -0.015079289674758911, -0.017854996025562286, 0.04384498670697212, 0.014216089621186256, -0.036461055278778076, -0.06097128987312317, 0.022125162184238434, 0.018455564975738525, -0.01568090356886387, -0.07440134137868881, -0.03091111034154892, -0.0033658549655228853, 0.052329860627651215, 0.019214140251278877, -0.014880920760333538, 0.039717063307762146, -0.036691054701805115, 0.002647570101544261, 0.007177556399255991, 0.007407213561236858, 0.034297842532396317, 0.024841183796525, -0.012896006926894188, -0.01892661862075329, 0.00414867652580142, 0.007032498717308044, 0.032955992966890335, -0.04423928260803223, -0.040040113031864166, -0.01233125664293766, 0.02606709487736225, -0.011304769665002823, -0.021178875118494034, -0.036125440150499344, -0.014341187663376331, 0.0516105592250824, 0.013284928165376186, -0.00812474824488163, -0.01839824765920639, 0.0553756020963192, -0.013051350601017475, -0.05713972449302673, -0.010805275291204453, 0.004968032706528902, 0.012079757638275623, 0.02585097961127758, -0.03415577858686447, -0.03464408591389656, 0.06827548146247864, -0.08591506630182266, 0.0047307685017585754, 0.039874367415905, 0.05873434990644455, 0.006532073486596346, 0.023063920438289642, 0.008160581812262535, 0.015114830806851387, 0.025161277502775192, -0.02727663703262806, 0.04223962500691414, 0.03194636479020119, 0.06599774956703186, -0.016281772404909134, -0.0731603354215622, 0.022580642253160477, -0.057318080216646194, -0.029425185173749924, 0.014585621654987335, 0.033406246453523636, 0.032085120677948, 0.03526259586215019, -0.05629034340381622, -0.0019008646486327052, 0.03086342103779316, 0.04281920939683914, 0.03666604310274124, -0.023610049858689308, 0.012789405882358551, -0.03934549540281296, 0.03289417177438736, 0.005921072792261839, -0.011014174669981003, 0.007254065480083227, -0.06100776419043541, 0.03351122885942459, -0.0686105340719223, 0.043716076761484146, 0.06240014359354973, -0.010274196974933147, 0.024250319227576256, 0.04272249713540077, -0.03737780079245567, 0.0698641836643219, 0.006315625738352537, -0.03988093510270119, 0.026020850986242294, 0.03400053083896637, -0.04282211884856224, -0.038416553288698196, -0.06322816014289856, -0.03627703711390495, 0.06389990448951721, -0.013491346500813961, -0.04079423472285271, 0.004829635377973318, -0.0091771325096488, -0.005115995183587074, -0.06860852241516113, 0.019869878888130188, -0.0748516097664833, 0.02338300831615925, -0.03843643516302109, -0.01329200528562069, 0.05328647419810295, -0.05054948478937149, -0.022819379344582558, -0.03111344389617443, -0.032785166054964066, -0.03677920624613762, -0.024590861052274704, 0.00017749963444657624, -0.0751606822013855, 0.021551642566919327, -0.02744387835264206, 0.061341650784015656, 0.03415422514081001, 0.005777623038738966, -0.02490386553108692, -0.029144080355763435, -0.007262649945914745, 0.03541845828294754, 0.0748998150229454, -0.015538696199655533, -0.04350931569933891, -0.014201833866536617, 0.010099201463162899, 0.005110465921461582, 0.01417269092053175, 0.026359563693404198, -0.04889199510216713, 0.020658034831285477, 0.009403071366250515, -0.0055574714206159115, -0.02000688947737217, -0.031492117792367935, 0.07204873859882355, -0.04941752925515175, -0.04936018958687782, -0.003182296408340335, 0.014534879475831985, -0.060643624514341354, -0.05221820995211601, -0.019147105515003204, -0.060827743262052536, -0.05410080403089523, -0.04439795762300491, -0.00349821406416595, -0.018188223242759705, -0.024747353047132492, 0.0214240625500679, 0.03037404455244541, 0.007471869233995676, -0.017786044627428055, 0.010964090935885906, 0.01934264600276947, -0.0028007314540445805, 0.008118667639791965, -0.04324110969901085, -0.07908124476671219, 0.007770658936351538, -0.06345075368881226, -0.01166175864636898, 0.0007335513946600258, 0.0034391414374113083, 0.054829809814691544, 0.045799434185028076, -0.07514958083629608, 0.017459575086832047, 0.04742003232240677, -0.024966556578874588, 0.01794472150504589, 0.06550684571266174, 0.000881560321431607, 0.04835733771324158, -0.033337388187646866, 0.002395528368651867, 0.024136150255799294, -0.03152937814593315, -0.0007827900699339807, -0.0021378351375460625, -0.030285602435469627, -0.027869805693626404, 0.05751533433794975, 0.0031403338070958853, -0.0469968318939209, -0.0035797988530248404, 0.020841913297772408, 0.05114978924393654, -0.01842159777879715, 0.053899817168712616, 0.029045801609754562, -0.015980195254087448, -0.007305567618459463, -0.057339146733284, -0.02838081866502762, -0.0413234569132328, 0.033006422221660614, -0.04428431764245033, -0.04439900442957878, 0.05154376104474068, 0.029607662931084633, -0.01859450526535511, -0.024517565965652466, 0.01054871454834938, 0.005044640973210335, -0.055830325931310654, -0.0033390484750270844, -0.06443797796964645, -0.03226089850068092, -0.002455475740134716, -0.008019722066819668, 0.06937814503908157, 0.010316452011466026, 0.020888453349471092, 0.01206993404775858, -0.05383437126874924, 0.0024748831056058407, 0.015518291853368282, -0.014677944593131542, 0.014624294824898243, -0.030264025554060936, 0.04912899434566498, 0.023576680570840836, 0.02046831324696541, 0.0133614307269454, 0.04240519925951958, -0.023839933797717094, -0.026925211772322655, -0.02379630319774151, 0.016345564275979996, 0.02982846274971962, -0.06289573013782501, -0.009100806899368763, 0.012110933661460876, 0.023941228166222572, -0.02032426930963993, 0.03658181428909302, 0.017450429499149323, -0.03185940533876419, 0.034977301955223083, 0.05897689238190651, -0.02072288654744625, -0.0403728187084198, 0.04977277293801308, 0.06225012615323067, -0.04944605752825737, -0.011615865863859653, -0.006458805873990059, -0.027332372963428497, 0.01611628383398056, -0.03428271412849426, 0.04471265897154808, 0.022498220205307007, -0.0488894060254097, -0.06270156055688858, 0.04823135584592819, 0.013296926394104958, -0.07284995913505554, 0.04306682199239731, 0.005014233756810427, -0.07428517192602158, 0.020152932032942772, 0.058096516877412796, 0.039794739335775375, -0.03796808049082756, 0.03194816783070564, 0.03172992914915085, -0.04303210228681564, -0.05789122357964516, 0.032952480018138885, 0.06406557559967041, -0.017005711793899536, 0.028482189401984215, 0.011341556906700134, -0.06227017939090729, 0.02358769066631794, 0.006651810836046934, -0.011689628474414349, -0.032356731593608856, -0.027898525819182396, 0.007460078690201044, -0.004386294167488813, -0.033771634101867676, 0.07352288067340851, -0.006338021252304316, -0.02112147957086563, 0.05117480456829071, -0.00946782249957323, 0.02694610133767128, -0.03442220389842987, -0.05017803981900215, -0.01024626288563013, -0.015034664422273636, 0.012133916839957237, -0.06383449584245682, -0.007065052632242441, -0.01752971112728119, 0.01453512441366911, 0.009193173609673977, -0.08033055067062378, 0.0007962348172441125, -0.04456193372607231, -0.07778878509998322, 0.041818514466285706, -0.06684642285108566, 0.034146543592214584, 0.021418698132038116, -0.026676608249545097, -0.003984874580055475, 0.05440293624997139, -0.03473025560379028, -0.006861440371721983, 0.029321787878870964, 0.007229447830468416, 0.011373955756425858, -0.035130757838487625, 0.0198539849370718, -0.006027495488524437, 0.05192260071635246, -0.03921956568956375, -0.06525754183530807, -0.01678726263344288, -0.044339749962091446, -0.016615744680166245, -0.0022121642250567675, -0.03660382702946663, -0.027177205309271812, 0.030722737312316895, 0.0017148813931271434, 0.02583186700940132, 0.0217768345028162, -0.03960197791457176, -0.06580815464258194, -0.005758208222687244, 0.01247867476195097, 0.015273859724402428, 0.03984331339597702, 0.05182954668998718, 0.03743063285946846, -0.003881756216287613, 0.04158512130379677, -0.0052819568663835526, -0.002406995976343751, 0.02764648199081421, -0.07047104090452194, -0.008144174702465534, -0.03120269440114498, -0.016197824850678444, -0.04978034645318985, -0.025266414508223534, 0.010812821798026562, -0.06332801282405853, 0.014970553107559681, 0.05926972255110741, 0.04502400383353233, -0.008632934652268887, -0.05087748542428017, 0.0035848189145326614, 0.013263068161904812, -0.06150953471660614, -0.02000003308057785, 0.01456108782440424, 0.011348042637109756, -0.0443551205098629, 0.020695926621556282, -0.0005874601774848998, -0.04834556207060814, -0.006762285716831684, -0.07469566911458969, -0.017227843403816223, 0.013254106044769287, 0.0312785804271698, 0.008126766420900822, -0.037269771099090576, -0.014145156368613243, -0.03316160663962364, -0.028651345521211624, -0.02497473917901516, 0.029542475938796997, -0.0029531638137996197, 0.01745126210153103, -0.012370693497359753, -0.04840400442481041, -0.009443716146051884, 0.05104708671569824, -0.011743203736841679, -0.03018312156200409, -0.002946973079815507, -0.0160735622048378, 0.03186213597655296, 0.029090600088238716, 0.05598803982138634, -0.03813251480460167, 0.02022896707057953, -0.039265163242816925, -0.0029536026995629072, -0.04255649819970131, -0.029591212049126625, 0.03662016615271568, -0.046854786574840546, -0.04016948491334915, 0.03686128184199333, -0.020841022953391075, -0.018018275499343872, -0.0013099326752126217, -0.06584642082452774, 0.027625856921076775, -0.020862329751253128, -0.014995315112173557, 0.04595395550131798, -0.047486063092947006, -0.01849774457514286, -0.018249405547976494, -0.01990465819835663, -0.03301548585295677, 0.02818707935512066, 0.05625644698739052, -0.029211223125457764, 0.006392159033566713, -0.04627082869410515, -0.006686855107545853, 0.0007518159691244364, 0.020982936024665833, -0.03017592243850231, 0.07842212915420532, 0.02766330912709236, -0.011964719742536545, -0.0320093147456646, -0.021484997123479843, -0.026848118752241135, -0.07008125633001328, -0.049469541758298874, -0.056256309151649475, 0.01366150751709938, 0.001521800528280437, -0.0176201444119215, -0.013579534366726875, 0.0348619669675827, 0.0033034172374755144, -0.005440974608063698, 0.00463489256799221, 0.023892434313893318, -0.04067142680287361, 0.0732216015458107, 0.0168292336165905, 0.014179760590195656, 0.003322281176224351, 0.01955709606409073, -0.03956518694758415, -0.006262635812163353, 0.028785720467567444, -0.012269015423953533, -0.011640910990536213, -0.04689083248376846, 0.005881312303245068, 0.030347395688295364, 0.007163053844124079, -0.06009437143802643, -0.030520129948854446, -0.00780227966606617, -0.06411722302436829, -0.048205409198999405 ]
Leo T is the lowest mass galaxy known to contain neutral gas and to show signs of recent star formation, which makes it a valuable laboratory for studying the nature of gas and star formation at the limits of where galaxies are found to have rejuvenating episodes of star formation. Here we discuss a novel study of Leo T that uses data from the MUSE integral field spectrograph and photometric data from HST. The high sensitivity of MUSE allowed us to increase the number of Leo T stars observed spectroscopically from 19 to 75. We studied the age and metallicity of these stars and identified two populations, all consistent with similar metallicity of [Fe/H] $\sim$ -1.5 dex, suggesting that a large fraction of metals were ejected. Within the young population, we discovered three emission line Be stars, supporting the conclusion that rapidly rotating massive stars are common in metal-poor environments. We find differences in the dynamics of young and old stars, with the young population having a velocity dispersion consistent with the kinematics of the cold component of the neutral gas. This finding directly links the recent star formation in Leo T with the cold component of the neutral gas.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03188v1
[ -0.03597618266940117, -0.0036283163353800774, 0.005332223605364561, -0.0034252016339451075, -0.023434728384017944, 0.022501900792121887, -0.004927238915115595, 0.019728930667042732, -0.03444956615567207, 0.003325150813907385, 0.00038254912942647934, -0.04136567562818527, -0.0038594654761254787, -0.0571279302239418, -0.013328860513865948, 0.05060712620615959, 0.0637940764427185, 0.022580496966838837, -0.028946081176400185, 0.044256363064050674, 0.016537470743060112, 0.032878048717975616, 0.038026172667741776, 0.014697074890136719, 0.013221299275755882, -0.05186043679714203, -0.0286402590572834, 0.04473601281642914, -0.001146099530160427, 0.0059809610247612, 0.06460772454738617, -0.041325848549604416, -0.013108378276228905, -0.04171301797032356, 0.026574790477752686, 0.010007405653595924, -0.04197638854384422, 0.054285306483507156, -0.018371904268860817, -0.07556677609682083, -0.05339392274618149, -0.02302035316824913, -0.03921908885240555, -0.04241195321083069, -0.0009461473673582077, -0.054918739944696426, -0.02076912298798561, 0.027507459744811058, -0.07958222925662994, -0.06024617701768875, 0.016194529831409454, -0.04925885796546936, -0.02792160026729107, 0.04736899212002754, -0.008860391564667225, -0.04005000367760658, 0.007460550405085087, -0.02035028114914894, -0.0459689125418663, 0.010281766764819622, -0.0253339521586895, -0.02695493772625923, 0.02533281408250332, -0.03852849453687668, -0.030132606625556946, 0.02201714739203453, -0.07170400023460388, -0.039292722940444946, -0.05556982383131981, -0.05740673467516899, 0.03636138141155243, -0.07241453975439072, 0.0209413543343544, 0.018007252365350723, -0.05116406828165054, 0.03183643892407417, -0.010184690356254578, -0.0288081094622612, -0.009579903446137905, 0.0419231541454792, -0.04081656038761139, 0.030329003930091858, 0.004157371819019318, 0.024387260898947716, -0.028318559750914574, 0.03588302806019783, 0.03746362775564194, -0.057889148592948914, -0.021683083847165108, -0.027534393593668938, 0.011870893649756908, -0.00119925441686064, -0.028202364221215248, -0.03145113214850426, 0.07876094430685043, -0.028110062703490257, 0.06533492356538773, 0.05549484118819237, 0.021658657118678093, -0.014536570757627487, -0.002262379275634885, -0.07524634897708893, -0.021824590861797333, 0.05838819593191147, -0.019718267023563385, -0.04035339877009392, 0.010098783299326897, -0.04196355491876602, -0.030756771564483643, 0.06097065657377243, 0.006686039734631777, -0.00773448683321476, 0.03658872842788696, -0.010692385025322437, -0.07050938904285431, -0.06106282398104668, 0.06984120607376099, -0.009595440700650215, 0.012799610383808613, 0.043905727565288544, -0.05742904916405678, 0.043926555663347244, 0.06821735203266144, -0.03199281170964241, -0.03681753948330879, -0.021809477359056473, 0.02062317170202732, 0.012332716025412083, -0.01802288368344307, -0.02149205096065998, -0.0008350870339199901, 0.024615583941340446, 0.04647635668516159, -0.056014131754636765, 0.014347190037369728, -0.017835121601819992, 0.027551835402846336, -0.014106377959251404, -0.03264673799276352, 0.029994776472449303, 0.03240353614091873, -0.019846098497509956, 0.02302628941833973, 0.00467650918290019, -0.015177048742771149, -0.005338597577065229, -0.055843956768512726, 0.01364865805953741, 0.0678299069404602, 0.022275498136878014, 0.012457436881959438, 0.0313694141805172, -0.013635131530463696, -0.03457195311784744, 0.01278489176183939, -0.009966577403247356, 0.05207177996635437, 0.01227392628788948, -0.04920901730656624, 0.016644075512886047, -0.013843342661857605, -0.015469785779714584, 0.034218139946460724, 0.008386258967220783, -0.04725194722414017, 0.0030151894316077232, 0.0012052262900397182, -0.006324420217424631, -0.026058761402964592, 0.04615556821227074, 0.008953348733484745, 0.02794019877910614, 0.011946739628911018, -0.0074573177844285965, -0.07101808488368988, -0.008992848917841911, 0.001596548710949719, -0.04900515824556351, -0.02663290686905384, 0.00361873721703887, 0.01765369437634945, 0.03375834971666336, -0.03034561313688755, -0.04532494768500328, -0.0006196726462803781, -0.014571988955140114, -0.06183946132659912, -0.01644211821258068, 0.05084236338734627, 0.0032153939828276634, -0.023371722549200058, -0.013737313449382782, -0.011116002686321735, -0.008599387481808662, 0.02491873688995838, -0.004882601089775562, 0.05742371827363968, -0.04783350229263306, -0.01911374181509018, 0.012571556493639946, -0.06270872056484222, -0.006225255783647299, -0.013350440189242363, -0.028229031711816788, 0.0035799823235720396, -0.08616811037063599, 0.04148886352777481, 0.021291906014084816, 0.03689119964838028, -0.007752854842692614, 0.010888619348406792, 0.06489789485931396, 0.033327143639326096, -0.013661963865160942, -0.009916039183735847, 0.004408125765621662, -0.09946031123399734, 0.03748660907149315, -0.02834373153746128, 0.05422341823577881, 0.03466598689556122, 0.004117766860872507, -0.01290680281817913, -0.005028497893363237, -0.017296548932790756, 0.025943031534552574, 0.058626607060432434, -0.009593368507921696, -0.04638740420341492, 0.007660123519599438, 0.01974937878549099, -0.06736734509468079, -0.09040296822786331, -0.01751391775906086, 0.01249082200229168, -0.003115573897957802, -0.052587736397981644, 0.03914075717329979, -0.0478135347366333, -0.0368601493537426, -0.01826481893658638, 0.0378027968108654, 0.01644187979400158, -0.01624554581940174, -0.067493736743927, -0.002499091438949108, -0.06082702428102493, 0.014522836543619633, -0.06321898102760315, 0.00587568199262023, 0.03159485384821892, -0.048036884516477585, -0.02400350570678711, -0.018922867253422737, 0.011644437909126282, 0.04438718408346176, -0.03335893526673317, -0.025784730911254883, -0.021208593621850014, 0.055735550820827484, -0.06315302103757858, 0.025374408811330795, -0.03450920060276985, -0.03681804984807968, 0.014467490836977959, 0.021523024886846542, -0.056737300008535385, 0.018611688166856766, 0.0036976239643990993, 0.032844334840774536, 0.030508246272802353, -0.004950409755110741, 0.03712475299835205, 0.03335299342870712, -0.051806945353746414, -0.0341266430914402, -0.016514213755726814, -0.041982948780059814, -0.01177280768752098, -0.017994292080402374, 0.07407592236995697, 0.056913409382104874, 0.014780282974243164, -0.059289295226335526, -0.0350005179643631, -0.008300418965518475, -0.014249609783291817, -0.04305373877286911, -0.04241007938981056, 0.04378557205200195, -0.059869758784770966, 0.010163628496229649, -0.019144047051668167, -0.010379894636571407, -0.051270097494125366, -0.00977138988673687, -0.004774283152073622, 0.008274350315332413, 0.039274539798498154, -0.05978769809007645, -0.028104489669203758, 0.03541264683008194, -0.0063310046680271626, -0.0015515098348259926, -0.04549648240208626, -0.039102934300899506, -0.000727109785657376, 0.032020796090364456, -0.02675226517021656, -0.06836904585361481, -0.056385863572359085, 0.016682730987668037, -0.06613035500049591, -0.04955305904150009, -0.014800399541854858, 0.065697580575943, 0.034973226487636566, -0.06194150820374489, -0.03314860165119171, -0.01714092679321766, -0.04350637272000313, -0.0326460599899292, -0.04268598183989525, 0.026647502556443214, -0.05755173787474632, -0.04574761167168617, 0.024188270792365074, 0.07270698249340057, 0.029295239597558975, -0.03584226965904236, -0.06418953835964203, -0.012739600613713264, -0.02152666449546814, -0.004509204067289829, 0.026692792773246765, 0.026740146800875664, -0.017392510548233986, -0.00846475176513195, -0.028322376310825348, 0.010643985122442245, 0.004468427039682865, 0.02098449505865574, 0.0011805612593889236, -0.015676656737923622, 0.00042755668982863426, -0.023371661081910133, 0.019593603909015656, 0.04760154336690903, 0.0766989141702652, -0.001789734000340104, 0.04956119507551193, 0.045580197125673294, -0.006177100352942944, 0.05695023015141487, -0.006478366442024708, 0.02929905615746975, -0.00956773106008768, 0.06449801474809647, -0.07756870985031128, 0.003086429787799716, -0.017848894000053406, -0.042650774121284485, -0.03866299241781235, 0.00985345896333456, -0.015605916269123554, 0.0378897525370121, 0.07319876551628113, 0.004933608695864677, -0.01812983676791191, 0.00841932836920023, 0.06880023330450058, -0.03790505602955818, -0.04014499485492706, 0.007862755097448826, -0.0035120202228426933, 0.015587989240884781, -0.01614736206829548, 0.006456067319959402, 0.001826921827159822, 0.0003821093123406172, 0.013338308781385422, -0.06880895793437958, -0.013998384587466717, 0.02633187733590603, 0.027351999655365944, 0.036961983889341354, 0.018262794241309166, 0.030468998476862907, -0.00241307495161891, -0.010766377672553062, -0.02773495577275753, -0.06307525932788849, -0.035724181681871414, 0.022072482854127884, -0.00039733279845677316, 0.06293941289186478, -0.00041608186438679695, -0.014302941039204597, -0.04725515469908714, -0.019514355808496475, 0.012215248309075832, -0.010448617860674858, -0.04941057041287422, -0.08019575476646423, -0.03629034012556076, -0.02755873277783394, 0.01421208493411541, -0.032563772052526474, -0.02503267303109169, 0.06258589774370193, -0.04142599180340767, -0.0082217026501894, -0.027751188725233078, 0.036158062517642975, -0.035700902342796326, -0.03626539930701256, 0.014833035878837109, -0.05512521415948868, 0.016282960772514343, -0.026695387437939644, 0.006843548268079758, -0.055069904774427414, -0.008541996590793133, -0.07880450785160065, -0.0010633174097165465, 0.000009005015272123273, 0.009826567955315113, 0.02975114993751049, -0.009310481138527393, 0.025232842192053795, -0.011580385267734528, -0.05102623626589775, -0.011024150997400284, -0.012905355542898178, 0.062092483043670654, -0.032454442232847214, 0.06970052421092987, -0.040949031710624695, -0.025303365662693977, -0.0185155738145113, -0.006403745152056217, 0.08030939102172852, -0.024890627712011337, -0.005053380969911814, -0.009070749394595623, 0.03651951625943184, -0.04767562448978424, -0.027423694729804993, 0.019131949171423912, -0.03012806549668312, -0.07754499465227127, 0.021191563457250595, 0.006042725872248411, -0.06339471787214279, -0.011178426444530487, 0.027731694281101227, 0.03621610999107361, 0.010808633640408516, -0.01930062845349312, 0.026915183290839195, 0.02970096282660961, 0.012079133652150631, 0.006721540354192257, -0.032116107642650604, -0.06918986886739731, 0.012243932113051414, -0.01119795348495245, -0.028401510789990425, 0.006943888030946255, 0.05582971125841141, -0.05417739599943161, 0.04676391929388046, -0.09075841307640076, 0.027345877140760422, 0.05223628133535385, 0.009406543336808681, -0.0021281123626977205, 0.03747844323515892, 0.006031142547726631, 0.02822905033826828, -0.00800147745758295, 0.01394046563655138, -0.0087124053388834, -0.037504810839891434, 0.042044498026371, 0.03397708013653755, -0.0195520780980587, -0.03026220202445984, 0.0614837221801281, 0.008354118093848228, -0.06778325885534286, -0.022415703162550926, -0.011631201021373272, 0.004757273942232132, -0.036526504904031754, 0.011110411025583744, 0.05214262008666992, 0.012550129555165768, -0.06631915271282196, -0.004002798348665237, -0.04971824958920479, 0.023242169991135597, 0.018570996820926666, -0.04235372692346573, -0.003105157520622015, -0.00027883885195478797, -0.045643214136362076, 0.030833903700113297, 0.06317010521888733, -0.02462509088218212, 0.03570499271154404, 0.012229816056787968, -0.012385410256683826, -0.06196920946240425, -0.010113080032169819, -0.052431512624025345, -0.0021998558659106493, 0.03253432363271713, 0.004481582436710596, 0.06189873814582825, 0.04539463296532631, 0.010056217201054096, -0.055527109652757645, -0.028743410483002663, -0.026588641107082367, 0.03153052181005478, -0.01001827698200941, -0.012190624140202999, -0.007758315186947584, 0.028716862201690674, -0.02423996850848198, -0.012369626201689243, -0.031974490731954575, 0.012683866545557976, -0.04548157751560211, 0.03064352087676525, -0.024060240015387535, 0.004202635958790779, -0.04902442544698715, 0.044535476714372635, 0.047941312193870544, -0.01981913484632969, 0.05206645280122757, 0.003457751590758562, 0.018811624497175217, 0.022597670555114746, -0.006933326367288828, 0.04242532700300217, -0.0533977635204792, -0.05485004559159279, 0.08732341974973679, -0.06411255896091461, -0.009936410002410412, -0.04296630248427391, -0.014051640406250954, -0.008199011906981468, -0.04974069073796272, 0.022442322224378586, 0.028261546045541763, -0.029008235782384872, -0.05461898818612099, 0.026705415919423103, 0.011829717084765434, -0.060887087136507034, 0.025891557335853577, -0.008700013160705566, -0.06442003697156906, -0.006889040116220713, 0.007493356242775917, -0.011385736055672169, -0.03354864940047264, -0.03208344429731369, -0.05699629709124565, -0.04088328406214714, -0.019010037183761597, 0.034480299800634384, 0.0444696806371212, -0.013884694315493107, 0.04351351782679558, 0.017449798062443733, -0.02008601278066635, -0.021140815690159798, -0.008828660473227501, 0.019015923142433167, -0.025097696110606194, 0.05514091998338699, 0.02182849310338497, -0.03236296400427818, 0.0005973305087536573, 0.028017958626151085, -0.07600150257349014, 0.028979061171412468, -0.008080546744167805, 0.032936450093984604, 0.014894498512148857, 0.009072337299585342, -0.059207357466220856, 0.016294216737151146, -0.039659857749938965, 0.009154753759503365, 0.010001081973314285, 0.038314394652843475, -0.013257070444524288, 0.017294831573963165, -0.005399857647716999, -0.042479924857616425, -0.002116137184202671, -0.00570514053106308, -0.04419131949543953, 0.04067317768931389, -0.018526943400502205, -0.025578772649168968, -0.00009107714868150651, 0.012889541685581207, 0.027008971199393272, -0.012208973988890648, -0.015296360477805138, -0.04820128530263901, 0.00026941773830913007, -0.0785813182592392, 0.037422746419906616, 0.021255241706967354, 0.050776027143001556, 0.029321959242224693, 0.05334923788905144, -0.031851526349782944, 0.0007356523419730365, -0.04089277982711792, -0.030854705721139908, 0.03466712683439255, -0.029900988563895226, -0.037190526723861694, 0.001167295966297388, 0.027687326073646545, -0.02166937291622162, -0.015765739604830742, 0.0009012309019453824, -0.0011578456033021212, -0.05383790284395218, -0.03362105414271355, -0.014952626079320908, -0.06514160335063934, 0.010349620133638382, -0.04653731733560562, 0.0636541023850441, -0.010335228405892849, -0.021267790347337723, 0.055908434092998505, -0.017138052731752396, -0.022385690361261368, -0.014731956645846367, -0.03345220163464546, 0.044716183096170425, 0.03997521102428436, -0.038455378264188766, -0.036425866186618805, -0.044782862067222595, -0.07425404340028763, 0.02315520867705345, 0.021890966221690178, -0.009762600995600224, -0.023856012150645256, -0.04155556857585907, 0.0428992435336113, 0.015046600252389908, 0.02405075915157795, -0.0755753219127655, -0.022250475361943245, 0.040281374007463455, 0.014112969860434532, -0.003692886559292674, 0.037679899483919144, -0.027772577479481697, 0.011759910732507706, -0.07954397052526474, 0.009427949786186218, -0.04766956716775894, 0.04689345136284828, 0.011146732605993748, -0.019880235195159912, -0.04947543144226074, -0.03889548406004906, 0.0019429854582995176, 0.04099331423640251, -0.03476324677467346, 0.019888238981366158, -0.0017389843706041574, 0.025649085640907288, -0.027700694277882576, 0.0068528661504387856, -0.005192243028432131, -0.04758060723543167, -0.01524963416159153, 0.021349655464291573, 0.025183459743857384, -0.03779381886124611, -0.014410520903766155, 0.006354903802275658, -0.012426930479705334, 0.0331815704703331, -0.03904709964990616, 0.018469905480742455, -0.020732823759317398, -0.048485126346349716, 0.03691123425960541, -0.04625634849071503, -0.018484007567167282, 0.04095097631216049, -0.038219064474105835, -0.03295978903770447, -0.008750016801059246, -0.02880658023059368, 0.017351847141981125, 0.012106881476938725, -0.0203885268419981, 0.05539802461862564, -0.07923083007335663, -0.0003003292076755315, -0.04959755763411522, -0.014544048346579075, -0.078546442091465, 0.004327619448304176, 0.015998560935258865, -0.05710481107234955, -0.003906334284693003, -0.0766933411359787, 0.012431446462869644, -0.05456812307238579, 0.006746403872966766, 0.0036121958401054144, 0.038370281457901, -0.07774045318365097, 0.06888056546449661, -0.04029953107237816, -0.018455762416124344, 0.05217931792140007, -0.04376453906297684, -0.029813360422849655, 0.02130439504981041, 0.0456690639257431, -0.004630560986697674, 0.0045614708214998245, 0.023811716586351395, 0.031739335507154465, 0.010080075822770596, -0.024563701823353767, 0.03658878058195114, -0.018293632194399834, -0.01692689023911953, 0.016238030046224594, 0.02661031298339367, -0.021611621603369713, -0.043186016380786896, 0.07446910440921783, 0.022561948746442795, -0.03021411970257759, -0.047766897827386856, 0.057598378509283066, -0.016667917370796204, -0.03415367007255554, -0.028314009308815002, 0.029234664514660835, -0.011955500580370426, -0.030557753518223763, 0.03871403634548187, 0.03407810628414154, -0.056310273706912994, -0.04515325650572777 ]
In the constrained planarity setting, we ask whether a graph admits a planar drawing that additionally satisfies a given set of constraints. These constraints are often derived from very natural problems; prominent examples are Level Planarity, where vertices have to lie on given horizontal lines indicating a hierarchy, and Clustered Planarity, where we additionally draw the boundaries of clusters which recursively group the vertices in a crossing-free manner. Despite receiving significant amount of attention and substantial theoretical progress on these problems, only very few of the found solutions have been put into practice and evaluated experimentally. In this paper, we describe our implementation of the recent quadratic-time algorithm by Bl\"asius et al. [TALG Vol 19, No 4] for solving the problem Synchronized Planarity, which can be seen as a common generalization of several constrained planarity problems, including the aforementioned ones. Our experimental evaluation on an existing benchmark set shows that even our baseline implementation outperforms all competitors by at least an order of magnitude. We systematically investigate the degrees of freedom in the implementation of the Synchronized Planarity algorithm for larger instances and propose several modifications that further improve the performance. Altogether, this allows us to solve instances with up to 100 vertices in milliseconds and instances with up to 100 000 vertices within a few minutes.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20632v1
[ -0.000601615640334785, -0.011700784787535667, 0.04037236049771309, 0.03296404331922531, 0.02254246547818184, -0.007533256430178881, -0.0007116699125617743, -0.03257647156715393, -0.012345260940492153, -0.013471240177750587, -0.019602105021476746, -0.015638597309589386, -0.011476882733404636, -0.05560534819960594, -0.06982260942459106, -0.01933281682431698, 0.05066654458642006, -0.00968176033347845, -0.059757426381111145, 0.07438083738088608, 0.027433818206191063, -0.0046157087199389935, -0.0373300276696682, 0.0558420829474926, 0.03993833810091019, -0.005009488668292761, 0.008082580752670765, -0.0006339587853290141, -0.007987428456544876, -0.011588259600102901, 0.06653665006160736, 0.016373978927731514, 0.0008577322587370872, -0.04136639088392258, -0.019615687429904938, -0.024214861914515495, -0.006548119708895683, 0.03094606101512909, 0.05747755989432335, 0.002526581287384033, 0.027544526383280754, -0.02366073988378048, -0.05833808332681656, -0.014459640718996525, -0.04196909815073013, -0.0001547072606626898, -0.005384564399719238, 0.017172178253531456, -0.035819362848997116, -0.044575709849596024, 0.034912921488285065, 0.010215943679213524, 0.011607279069721699, 0.04172145202755928, -0.03855447098612785, -0.029246274381875992, 0.014857475645840168, -0.006024439353495836, -0.04538223147392273, -0.03792434185743332, -0.018714547157287598, -0.020779717713594437, -0.004253279883414507, -0.0011372363660484552, -0.007919560186564922, 0.05232163518667221, -0.009391387924551964, -0.08114532381296158, -0.017463238909840584, -0.04156353697180748, 0.03509106859564781, -0.06643799692392349, -0.02231202833354473, 0.034157123416662216, -0.07013790309429169, -0.007619212381541729, -0.043103646486997604, 0.001146218623034656, 0.03904487192630768, 0.02297772839665413, -0.00707894004881382, -0.02080238051712513, -0.0006170043488964438, -0.03481535241007805, 0.023154908791184425, -0.02024795673787594, 0.04165038838982582, 0.01391625590622425, -0.018821705132722855, -0.05215277150273323, -0.004673386458307505, -0.041869595646858215, -0.07477957010269165, 0.005914365407079458, 0.07184438407421112, 0.0021560396999120712, 0.03772610425949097, 0.03274015709757805, 0.026592141017317772, -0.026001345366239548, -0.026740381494164467, -0.07278303802013397, -0.06973639130592346, 0.03341742604970932, 0.05370229482650757, -0.037720635533332825, -0.02638053521513939, 0.010094071738421917, -0.0053199161775410175, 0.03326769545674324, -0.031178196892142296, 0.033500853925943375, 0.005387911573052406, -0.07222090661525726, -0.015054065734148026, -0.03813956305384636, 0.03841687738895416, 0.013458354398608208, 0.044376395642757416, -0.0035146495793014765, -0.014375570230185986, 0.022874565795063972, 0.0293942429125309, 0.0072244880720973015, -0.019523566588759422, -0.022782936692237854, 0.06561412662267685, 0.01907053031027317, 0.02333669923245907, 0.01901550404727459, -0.038453903049230576, -0.0051161120645701885, 0.02277236431837082, 0.0026866449043154716, 0.08144969493150711, 0.016382811591029167, 0.009327063336968422, 0.003962738439440727, 0.022316081449389458, 0.018517764285206795, -0.022727109491825104, -0.06777551025152206, 0.04376253858208656, -0.004150351509451866, 0.0007245668093673885, 0.07815021276473999, -0.06784076243638992, -0.019101671874523163, 0.03501809388399124, 0.048991858959198, -0.0016736072720959783, 0.027411915361881256, -0.017948634922504425, 0.013888870365917683, 0.039741359651088715, 0.01513044722378254, 0.040146686136722565, 0.005808464251458645, -0.06325904279947281, 0.008441435173153877, 0.01381122786551714, -0.04111143946647644, -0.01677432842552662, 0.014905145391821861, 0.006604232359677553, 0.02529783733189106, 0.03438751399517059, -0.04949137568473816, 0.003450706135481596, 0.02756229043006897, -0.04989219829440117, -0.009986569173634052, 0.0014491775073111057, -0.010408681817352772, -0.07211486250162125, -0.04140932112932205, -0.014033102430403233, -0.06143369898200035, -0.059943411499261856, -0.010927344672381878, 0.043189071118831635, 0.00012073160178260878, -0.03387833014130592, 0.02748456783592701, -0.011677577160298824, 0.002591283293440938, -0.08620288968086243, 0.008740013465285301, 0.03685664013028145, 0.019777778536081314, -0.03536785766482353, -0.032299771904945374, 0.05517767742276192, 0.028499022126197815, -0.026984065771102905, 0.004407113883644342, 0.001509004388935864, -0.03382371738553047, -0.02773093618452549, 0.052595093846321106, -0.0826190933585167, -0.030078034847974777, -0.03966289013624191, 0.00757897412404418, -0.03624910116195679, -0.07399095594882965, 0.04521442577242851, 0.053160473704338074, -0.03582381829619408, 0.006004087161272764, 0.06015864014625549, 0.020229613408446312, 0.060810986906290054, 0.005153626203536987, -0.011636702343821526, 0.016384748741984367, -0.09791206568479538, 0.046871136873960495, -0.02770143561065197, 0.009458646178245544, -0.014505825936794281, -0.007756088860332966, -0.04460425302386284, -0.05053335428237915, -0.04285365715622902, 0.07229868322610855, 0.0330517552793026, -0.004619667772203684, -0.06725464761257172, -0.020386433228850365, -0.020300744101405144, -0.03775528818368912, -0.054052356630563736, -0.06135140359401703, -0.03440341725945473, 0.01205274648964405, -0.02262565866112709, 0.07484296709299088, 0.007848299108445644, -0.029785504564642906, -0.05624592304229736, -0.007061472628265619, 0.0467219278216362, -0.009692897088825703, -0.04108869284391403, -0.034933142364025116, -0.05335948243737221, -0.005560293328016996, 0.020993025973439217, 0.01234115194529295, -0.032034680247306824, -0.042989153414964676, -0.011383675038814545, -0.01378011517226696, 0.024004679173231125, 0.048444535583257675, -0.04139215871691704, 0.017464477568864822, -0.016420375555753708, 0.04859870299696922, 0.03183712065219879, 0.006432889495044947, -0.028191644698381424, 0.005094071850180626, 0.007876025512814522, 0.007532198913395405, -0.04429575055837631, -0.020532425493001938, -0.0016998574137687683, 0.007301704492419958, 0.0069298092275857925, 0.03994296118617058, 0.01328293140977621, -0.018149692565202713, 0.0007736381376162171, -0.04139954596757889, -0.005049139726907015, -0.03825505077838898, 0.031181499361991882, 0.04373420774936676, 0.02795671671628952, 0.008808142505586147, -0.03177531808614731, -0.08397961407899857, -0.018460219725966454, -0.017313385382294655, -0.038211941719055176, -0.017369547858834267, -0.057085197418928146, -0.05626702308654785, -0.07252410799264908, -0.01473353710025549, -0.00031702558044344187, -0.03505289554595947, -0.03323988616466522, -0.03275429084897041, -0.011934160254895687, 0.009757060557603836, 0.02183329313993454, -0.015303573571145535, -0.057075630873441696, -0.0385187529027462, 0.058709174394607544, 0.011540481820702553, 0.03747531771659851, -0.059475548565387726, -0.060787174850702286, 0.0004934766329824924, 0.011135736480355263, -0.014228787273168564, -0.013377978466451168, 0.025506744161248207, 0.01981022208929062, 0.0508081316947937, -0.005917249247431755, 0.049288924783468246, 0.02755497768521309, -0.010467536747455597, -0.0418679416179657, -0.04037872329354286, -0.037543367594480515, 0.01635989360511303, -0.0018356157233938575, -0.039804812520742416, -0.07250192761421204, 0.009186772629618645, 0.05528521165251732, 0.001116379862651229, 0.020008036866784096, -0.02009965479373932, -0.007876237854361534, 0.010373868979513645, 0.005198642145842314, 0.0035148211754858494, 0.013757157139480114, 0.06867635250091553, -0.025070877745747566, 0.0037978587206453085, -0.02335260435938835, -0.026299456134438515, -0.0031462013721466064, 0.030761340633034706, -0.04990532621741295, -0.03317537531256676, 0.050953835248947144, -0.0926717147231102, 0.05162123590707779, 0.043595023453235626, 0.05573468282818794, -0.03400343284010887, 0.021019913256168365, 0.021451985463500023, 0.024975718930363655, -0.034930337220430374, -0.0469207800924778, -0.008095091208815575, 0.05606608837842941, 0.06291240453720093, -0.016019053757190704, -0.05846790596842766, -0.0009182737558148801, -0.06622191518545151, -0.02243167906999588, 0.004873159807175398, 0.01678798533976078, 0.04433564469218254, 0.01384314801543951, -0.04645324870944023, -0.005496816243976355, -0.01865472085773945, 0.05777671933174133, -0.02444782666862011, -0.019451843574643135, 0.009865524247288704, -0.03662355616688728, 0.032341185957193375, 0.012511235661804676, 0.00686729745939374, 0.051093101501464844, -0.03196434676647186, -0.011515354737639427, -0.038003988564014435, 0.026273902505636215, 0.020227203145623207, -0.0012107989750802517, 0.04622215777635574, 0.019654255360364914, -0.021937210112810135, 0.02410401590168476, 0.030778635293245316, -0.010183260776102543, -0.01859952323138714, 0.04443502798676491, -0.013127954676747322, -0.023072246462106705, -0.04391888156533241, 0.01660706289112568, 0.021226651966571808, -0.04562794417142868, -0.02174152433872223, -0.01140735112130642, 0.01347299013286829, -0.031786948442459106, -0.09079230576753616, -0.0028913889545947313, -0.022464971989393234, 0.026073722168803215, -0.04642448201775551, -0.0377226248383522, 0.08219338953495026, -0.03142327070236206, 0.02142343483865261, -0.035940639674663544, -0.010536251589655876, 0.0073800706304609776, 0.013686777092516422, -0.06173713505268097, -0.03583455830812454, 0.01303950883448124, -0.03263824060559273, 0.04874734580516815, -0.010547877289354801, -0.011799115687608719, -0.028696902096271515, 0.0001973794715013355, 0.015790557488799095, 0.05875805392861366, 0.051342472434043884, 0.03693278133869171, 0.021406788378953934, -0.0003742825938388705, 0.025096163153648376, -0.0047106873244047165, -0.008909550495445728, -0.04728555306792259, -0.050689294934272766, 0.040982138365507126, -0.015169044956564903, -0.025571905076503754, -0.018163813278079033, 0.0034559243358671665, 0.07372210919857025, -0.042858850210905075, -0.03885510191321373, 0.024417616426944733, 0.06021340936422348, -0.05457600578665733, -0.07519474625587463, 0.0427200123667717, -0.025368766859173775, -0.07722985744476318, -0.009967549704015255, 0.0004500836075749248, 0.02258066087961197, -0.03294140845537186, 0.039684440940618515, -0.02323015220463276, 0.021886831149458885, -0.04079805687069893, 0.005779522005468607, 0.028098640963435173, -0.00202819611877203, 0.021689781919121742, -0.017222605645656586, -0.0727502852678299, 0.033720191568136215, -0.005704081617295742, -0.03176649287343025, -0.023312807083129883, 0.04549816995859146, -0.005037762224674225, 0.05822286754846573, -0.08673923462629318, 0.048544786870479584, 0.05228281021118164, -0.032420724630355835, -0.017820853739976883, 0.05274166166782379, -0.012228764593601227, 0.03712442144751549, -0.02872692421078682, 0.036221519112586975, 0.03124171681702137, -0.01285755354911089, 0.01681330054998398, 0.012793385423719883, -0.04586058482527733, -0.012297249399125576, 0.05830851197242737, -0.02294110879302025, -0.02834797464311123, 0.014997804537415504, -0.012505292892456055, 0.033659692853689194, -0.031106848269701004, 0.05460304766893387, -0.0020177941769361496, -0.01932717114686966, -0.056459441781044006, 0.016543997451663017, 0.005297978408634663, -0.012852094136178493, 0.0022972826845943928, -0.03620431199669838, -0.01631763204932213, 0.04051513969898224, -0.00282059027813375, 0.005827785469591618, 0.0468827560544014, 0.026118969544768333, -0.030811013653874397, -0.023397918790578842, -0.04625101014971733, -0.05064673349261284, 0.04335259646177292, 0.018643207848072052, 0.021799437701702118, 0.009541485458612442, 0.017058538272976875, 0.038576897233724594, -0.02263013832271099, -0.02028178796172142, -0.029484562575817108, -0.018479229882359505, 0.007083771284669638, 0.0692429170012474, -0.041156210005283356, 0.01011083647608757, 0.02740086056292057, 0.059761155396699905, 0.018857039511203766, 0.006967861671000719, 0.0054381913505494595, -0.01306508295238018, 0.024864809587597847, -0.011575394310057163, 0.012601718306541443, -0.04619671031832695, -0.027395442128181458, 0.0010596938664093614, 0.018579144030809402, -0.043357718735933304, 0.04040884971618652, 0.024700187146663666, 0.04188454523682594, 0.03357455134391785, 0.021733010187745094, -0.011684376746416092, -0.051111988723278046, 0.02200751006603241, 0.035783153027296066, -0.08848989754915237, 0.021916868165135384, -0.04385276883840561, -0.038980837911367416, 0.021202826872467995, -0.02914402075111866, 0.0462302602827549, 0.020562533289194107, 0.04220883920788765, -0.04643303528428078, 0.06619714945554733, 0.023326553404331207, -0.04680835083127022, 0.00606581149622798, 0.04716623201966286, -0.07659197598695755, -0.0037141661159694195, 0.008761592209339142, -0.0012237142072990537, 0.02891935221850872, 0.05088088661432266, -0.023736361414194107, -0.0491776317358017, -0.00013330897490959615, 0.05390254035592079, 0.08297069370746613, -0.03141919523477554, 0.055076342076063156, 0.005290965083986521, -0.02388768456876278, 0.005624470300972462, -0.008852485567331314, 0.023061420768499374, -0.004527631215751171, 0.027792412787675858, -0.04249712824821472, -0.015507670119404793, 0.010442575439810753, 0.038410257548093796, -0.04490404576063156, -0.039896637201309204, 0.054071661084890366, 0.03901867941021919, 0.020791620016098022, -0.05269413813948631, -0.04624946787953377, -0.015242604538798332, 0.03251240402460098, -0.009780734777450562, -0.047361381351947784, 0.020595459267497063, -0.02586565911769867, 0.03818906098604202, -0.015759065747261047, -0.045495856553316116, 0.003737569320946932, -0.01389123871922493, -0.04919710382819176, 0.026627248153090477, -0.05967731028795242, -0.022911839187145233, -0.02712542936205864, 0.024387752637267113, 0.014579896815121174, 0.0739595964550972, -0.03812557831406593, -0.03202049806714058, -0.02840990014374256, -0.03114735707640648, 0.02905367873609066, 0.005520262755453587, 0.050845131278038025, 0.0007652822532691061, 0.053628601133823395, -0.05079246312379837, 0.00226565171033144, -0.050121285021305084, -0.012507237493991852, 0.015087639912962914, -0.0013323702150955796, -0.06034044548869133, -0.03916154429316521, 0.02899005077779293, -0.043743837624788284, 0.01606626622378826, 0.0028915132861584425, -0.01708815060555935, -0.08542309701442719, 0.0111714918166399, 0.026878340169787407, -0.006013556383550167, 0.014436068013310432, 0.03272844851016998, 0.03528931736946106, -0.03953075781464577, 0.04290582984685898, 0.041418805718421936, 0.051307808607816696, 0.023224571719765663, -0.0486014187335968, -0.043882954865694046, -0.009721197187900543, -0.028523843735456467, -0.03169099986553192, -0.058671217411756516, -0.03777425363659859, -0.050769828259944916, 0.04377055540680885, 0.0375201441347599, 0.030520007014274597, -0.02136518433690071, -0.062216710299253464, 0.057397082448005676, 0.04800516739487648, -0.03201752528548241, -0.02778080478310585, -0.020911457017064095, 0.03164515271782875, -0.0340619832277298, -0.025583066046237946, -0.0246355552226305, -0.058229874819517136, 0.0022262001875787973, -0.0908612459897995, -0.04063103348016739, -0.009155219420790672, 0.0695856362581253, 0.020376095548272133, 0.025181220844388008, -0.059993647038936615, -0.0315650999546051, 0.047299548983573914, -0.008329631760716438, 0.002976659219712019, 0.010832760483026505, 0.04723994433879852, 0.0360812209546566, -0.024143369868397713, -0.014380738139152527, 0.06089138984680176, -0.05478638410568237, 0.02726035751402378, 0.02589886076748371, 0.0010923316003754735, 0.0308708343654871, 0.04228293150663376, 0.06864836812019348, 0.00022149716096464545, 0.041289057582616806, -0.056530535221099854, 0.024880943819880486, -0.0636134073138237, -0.06419548392295837, 0.059572916477918625, -0.018623242154717445, 0.016893425956368446, 0.014019427821040154, 0.01621585339307785, -0.014617996290326118, -0.028611859306693077, -0.043629322201013565, 0.05911978334188461, 0.02012796513736248, -0.02083064429461956, 0.062483783811330795, -0.026967333629727364, -0.02850172109901905, -0.01535616721957922, -0.021842237561941147, -0.0317307785153389, 0.024027274921536446, 0.0392494797706604, -0.04446456953883171, 0.008226272650063038, -0.07268283516168594, 0.03309614211320877, -0.03314395248889923, 0.0021839842665940523, 0.018220441415905952, 0.03962840139865875, -0.012382720597088337, 0.00857920479029417, -0.004534719977527857, -0.0008773973095230758, -0.030735280364751816, -0.055776700377464294, -0.0022331438958644867, -0.0008217511931434274, 0.007919663563370705, -0.01329468097537756, 0.06587651371955872, -0.025084951892495155, 0.04349413514137268, 0.012399252504110336, 0.0015691273147240281, 0.017854837700724602, 0.01988895609974861, -0.05124262720346451, 0.07230676710605621, -0.007650114130228758, -0.04908490926027298, -0.057088371366262436, -0.011703617870807648, 0.019942201673984528, -0.03375869616866112, 0.009383322671055794, -0.031010888516902924, 0.029440784826874733, -0.02831489033997059, -0.00021576757717411965, 0.002101574093103409, 0.020359233021736145, -0.04140598699450493, 0.013867207802832127, -0.0003752293123397976, 0.004465177189558744, -0.05983122065663338 ]
Deep learning (DL) reconstruction particularly of MRI has led to improvements in image fidelity and reduction of acquisition time. In neuroimaging, DL methods can reconstruct high-quality images from undersampled data. However, it is essential to consider fairness in DL algorithms, particularly in terms of demographic characteristics. This study presents the first fairness analysis in a DL-based brain MRI reconstruction model. The model utilises the U-Net architecture for image reconstruction and explores the presence and sources of unfairness by implementing baseline Empirical Risk Minimisation (ERM) and rebalancing strategies. Model performance is evaluated using image reconstruction metrics. Our findings reveal statistically significant performance biases between the gender and age subgroups. Surprisingly, data imbalance and training discrimination are not the main sources of bias. This analysis provides insights of fairness in DL-based image reconstruction and aims to improve equity in medical AI applications.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14392v1
[ -0.029773132875561714, -0.035978902131319046, 0.05794442817568779, 0.015780426561832428, -0.022531121969223022, 0.017903808504343033, -0.008145777508616447, -0.02908671461045742, 0.009733283892273903, -0.05514202266931534, -0.04594659060239792, -0.016284547746181488, -0.035077717155218124, 0.009143752045929432, -0.013637387193739414, 0.04286948963999748, 0.06318217515945435, 0.02797619253396988, -0.033221807330846786, 0.08776221424341202, 0.0453779473900795, 0.004091340582817793, -0.048929858952760696, 0.05196881294250488, 0.03570865839719772, -0.024420639500021935, -0.04943470284342766, 0.0170754361897707, -0.0013325922191143036, -0.006092750001698732, 0.052435390651226044, -0.056037433445453644, -0.016818245872855186, -0.07228706032037735, -0.020818863064050674, 0.0024022040888667107, -0.026040779426693916, 0.01066533476114273, -0.01789119653403759, -0.036446236073970795, 0.03300231322646141, -0.00922209583222866, -0.057056862860918045, -0.0023832947481423616, -0.048436470329761505, 0.028572091832756996, -0.049281030893325806, -0.0012269463622942567, -0.09030222147703171, -0.024079835042357445, 0.029554827138781548, -0.014053323306143284, 0.020459644496440887, 0.046063799411058426, -0.019692130386829376, 0.01122941542416811, -0.008498030714690685, 0.029021769762039185, -0.07845300436019897, 0.011790662072598934, 0.044948775321245193, 0.010573389008641243, 0.005830742884427309, -0.03940172120928764, 0.002748822094872594, 0.04615241661667824, 0.003798164427280426, -0.05489392951130867, -0.05929848924279213, -0.04600909724831581, 0.06884688138961792, -0.06804036349058151, 0.03248727694153786, -0.012033342383801937, 0.0018708400893956423, -0.0025431725662201643, -0.018096745014190674, -0.02238285541534424, 0.011251145042479038, 0.023208988830447197, -0.05810735002160072, 0.06707235425710678, -0.013052701950073242, 0.04279608279466629, -0.03315810486674309, -0.02527237869799137, 0.06306656450033188, -0.020644303411245346, 0.01456521451473236, -0.02049058862030506, 0.040843233466148376, -0.008776228874921799, -0.020668789744377136, 0.030465081334114075, 0.017706144601106644, -0.011254645884037018, 0.03541450574994087, 0.03438963741064072, 0.00636875769123435, 0.018254274502396584, 0.012557870708405972, -0.03169606998562813, 0.030234690755605698, 0.07560393959283829, 0.03344256430864334, -0.05303565785288811, -0.03381494805216789, -0.00503607839345932, -0.046631790697574615, 0.0019870426040142775, 0.003995288163423538, -0.06179189682006836, 0.0057882764376699924, -0.032406166195869446, -0.06081755459308624, -0.023180590942502022, 0.06008094176650047, 0.02601788006722927, 0.0002808370627462864, -0.0014743173960596323, -0.04034747928380966, 0.009834476746618748, -0.0018710014410316944, -0.031137539073824883, 0.008387659676373005, -0.005477843806147575, 0.03795226663351059, 0.01434233132749796, -0.07110031694173813, -0.04184693098068237, -0.03316115215420723, 0.004995632451027632, -0.016891445964574814, -0.05452760308980942, 0.024495309218764305, -0.03465336933732033, -0.036457885056734085, -0.059964872896671295, 0.038625460118055344, 0.028938444331288338, -0.010853482410311699, -0.06659993529319763, 0.01578971929848194, -0.04310368373990059, -0.04083099961280823, 0.03186104819178581, 0.004781938623636961, -0.03580661863088608, 0.03247165307402611, 0.03984706103801727, 0.02488139271736145, 0.007799982093274593, 0.031146738678216934, 0.025897739455103874, -0.02017323672771454, -0.026730740442872047, 0.0613299198448658, 0.02434808574616909, -0.0392540767788887, 0.00093356694560498, 0.014314006082713604, -0.04093904793262482, 0.044459108263254166, -0.05656671151518822, -0.005587718449532986, 0.005911179352551699, 0.0430004857480526, 0.018307458609342575, -0.012189991772174835, -0.012076083570718765, -0.025884592905640602, -0.003641487332060933, 0.04036376625299454, 0.013164008967578411, -0.0687006488442421, -0.0033458953257650137, 0.019226742908358574, -0.05030718073248863, -0.052540697157382965, -0.007523281034082174, 0.011429224163293839, 0.049917589873075485, -0.009532595053315163, -0.008804108947515488, 0.004387315828353167, 0.005665746051818132, -0.09024236351251602, -0.0016615076456218958, 0.053088534623384476, 0.015526847913861275, -0.06090004742145538, -0.06278764456510544, 0.031829241663217545, 0.009548856876790524, -0.041982315480709076, -0.05736658722162247, -0.017204375937581062, 0.013179026544094086, 0.016750693321228027, 0.033146873116493225, -0.09116469323635101, 0.002943699713796377, -0.04808872565627098, -0.012662268243730068, -0.03228916600346565, -0.05796205252408981, -0.02381438948214054, 0.036605436354875565, -0.016331780701875687, -0.00470180157572031, 0.0510089285671711, 0.058073025196790695, 0.035625211894512177, -0.026054175570607185, 0.06457331031560898, 0.0023668878711760044, -0.09989063441753387, 0.05844796821475029, -0.038455765694379807, 0.02995438687503338, 0.03028135560452938, -0.000923659245017916, -0.005665976088494062, -0.0335785336792469, 0.001361000002361834, 0.0022729712072759867, 0.042591266334056854, 0.017003925517201424, -0.024508127942681313, -0.03565741330385208, 0.0077363792806863785, -0.07749348133802414, -0.02760475128889084, -0.08736419677734375, 0.02358408272266388, 0.000022942520445212722, -0.01914142444729805, 0.05990488827228546, -0.019261660054326057, -0.038476403802633286, -0.03637082502245903, -0.007796054240316153, 0.012337625958025455, 0.04604971036314964, -0.04836497828364372, -0.04346603900194168, 0.000026411305952933617, -0.011804108507931232, -0.040868550539016724, 0.027829401195049286, -0.02116643451154232, -0.0501289889216423, -0.003938957117497921, -0.03935462236404419, 0.04059950262308121, 0.03487982600927353, -0.014188707806169987, 0.00454269303008914, -0.03833917900919914, 0.051385339349508286, 0.04369485005736351, 0.06199723109602928, -0.08602092415094376, -0.005575193092226982, 0.025944072753190994, -0.01675751805305481, -0.02399301901459694, -0.008211336098611355, 0.042373497039079666, -0.05139092728495598, 0.02940352074801922, 0.023700663819909096, 0.014916667714715004, -0.006655213888734579, -0.02634989470243454, -0.030485672876238823, 0.001060962793417275, -0.053451769053936005, 0.01935502327978611, 0.004438931122422218, 0.021994339302182198, 0.03602108731865883, 0.015698719769716263, -0.060107916593551636, -0.008814939297735691, -0.06536740809679031, -0.006740314420312643, -0.03910936787724495, -0.04502922296524048, 0.03071509301662445, -0.08546271175146103, -0.05736219137907028, -0.0031380564905703068, -0.0451558418571949, -0.011112098582088947, -0.060629598796367645, -0.05826736241579056, 0.008155790157616138, 0.053759001195430756, -0.022882943972945213, -0.01928643509745598, -0.020435675978660583, -0.024549013003706932, 0.023567231371998787, -0.01341292168945074, -0.049039844423532486, -0.07084828615188599, -0.02748914062976837, 0.053484369069337845, -0.03615029156208038, -0.01089736633002758, 0.05044039711356163, -0.04273061826825142, 0.010815002024173737, -0.0276288203895092, 0.031134258955717087, 0.021382194012403488, -0.036875657737255096, -0.02084295265376568, -0.011758747510612011, 0.014777383767068386, -0.030200455337762833, -0.013356450945138931, -0.035573165863752365, -0.0352809838950634, 0.003317758673802018, 0.05071845278143883, 0.009596023708581924, -0.038395073264837265, -0.0035657703410834074, -0.012405898422002792, 0.011222133412957191, -0.009371004067361355, -0.01255453284829855, 0.04339287430047989, 0.016331149265170097, -0.054388780146837234, -0.007035206537693739, 0.015087912790477276, 0.004529761150479317, -0.016523614525794983, 0.013729569502174854, -0.04082593694329262, 0.008363057859241962, 0.04241160675883293, -0.08230297267436981, 0.010826514102518559, -0.004267675802111626, 0.0759454071521759, 0.007614799775183201, 0.014188455417752266, 0.031041469424962997, 0.0028334332164376974, 0.0031382234301418066, -0.029768139123916626, 0.01157947164028883, 0.035083554685115814, 0.04918070137500763, 0.0006782332784496248, -0.03316004201769829, 0.010656656697392464, -0.05374923720955849, -0.041792768985033035, -0.03304005414247513, 0.07462266087532043, 0.03643615543842316, 0.04614643752574921, -0.06809898465871811, 0.05265373736619949, -0.029545672237873077, 0.000844507128931582, -0.011217663995921612, -0.009217271581292152, 0.06269308179616928, -0.03970165178179741, 0.04183897748589516, 0.039412181824445724, 0.010621480643749237, 0.02543952874839306, -0.06829096376895905, 0.0391678623855114, -0.06264995783567429, 0.018680622801184654, 0.01539943553507328, -0.03189781308174133, 0.06512375175952911, 0.06794431805610657, -0.01835012249648571, 0.036021217703819275, -0.02113642543554306, -0.009136442095041275, -0.07050514221191406, 0.0139819560572505, -0.015593383461236954, 0.016149962320923805, -0.08216012269258499, -0.010973450727760792, 0.031277816742658615, 0.009958785027265549, -0.0005011452594771981, -0.021241428330540657, 0.009885964915156364, -0.044331565499305725, -0.06649065017700195, 0.024673616513609886, -0.0018308646976947784, 0.014516391791403294, -0.02758992835879326, -0.012733285315334797, 0.05399163067340851, -0.0614355131983757, -0.02705962210893631, -0.030685389414429665, -0.029714396223425865, -0.007880506105720997, -0.01923377253115177, 0.008274750784039497, -0.07054968178272247, 0.00046711304457858205, -0.03487442433834076, 0.03574787452816963, 0.010814501903951168, 0.017934734001755714, -0.05752719193696976, -0.031983084976673126, 0.014497424475848675, 0.03523299843072891, 0.0699978619813919, -0.028927026316523552, -0.02117043361067772, 0.00799974612891674, 0.015222919173538685, -0.025946613401174545, 0.03707002103328705, 0.02061721868813038, -0.022948065772652626, 0.008471076376736164, 0.010753455571830273, -0.019871756434440613, -0.026627033948898315, -0.011355413123965263, 0.06758107244968414, 0.002900138031691313, 0.0036910437047481537, -0.01016515213996172, 0.009762877598404884, -0.06036140397191048, -0.05899607762694359, -0.0035658027045428753, -0.04500069469213486, -0.010237986221909523, -0.010455898009240627, 0.02811415120959282, 0.03294641897082329, -0.02601858228445053, 0.0020243057515472174, 0.03574061021208763, -0.009927851147949696, 0.012073204852640629, 0.030138857662677765, 0.02571278065443039, 0.0014097891980782151, 0.00019405882630962878, -0.05564294755458832, -0.08484961092472076, -0.00957398023456335, -0.029435480013489723, 0.04251323640346527, 0.034935761243104935, 0.04724445939064026, 0.02344173565506935, 0.03468327969312668, -0.08180772513151169, 0.02808738499879837, 0.0620349757373333, 0.03039173223078251, 0.037426430732011795, 0.0583464540541172, -0.01825508289039135, 0.04678001627326012, -0.04827465862035751, 0.012326718308031559, 0.015967974439263344, -0.06684841215610504, 0.011239403858780861, -0.02649129368364811, 0.016840092837810516, -0.014456842094659805, 0.05810379981994629, 0.02612556517124176, -0.05009504407644272, -0.019449464976787567, -0.00526997959241271, 0.01708596758544445, -0.004704913590103388, 0.01397810596972704, 0.027299802750349045, -0.017918182536959648, -0.04059557616710663, 0.001407819683663547, -0.023053761571645737, 0.02682855911552906, 0.007313448004424572, -0.05409955978393555, 0.023419255390763283, 0.018360396847128868, -0.014863942749798298, -0.01854724995791912, 0.01155498530715704, 0.003311558859422803, 0.00231903581880033, -0.04387470707297325, 0.01704808697104454, -0.041004616767168045, -0.034468408674001694, -0.034468021243810654, 0.03733024746179581, 0.07552202045917511, -0.015022043138742447, -0.006644615437835455, 0.028144270181655884, -0.05698051303625107, 0.014423960819840431, 0.005333020351827145, 0.03463498502969742, 0.024448227137327194, -0.017201470211148262, 0.053461842238903046, 0.0002970375935547054, 0.0518159382045269, -0.013337480835616589, 0.00013716565445065498, 0.031166190281510353, 0.004146477673202753, -0.005420405883342028, -0.004813064821064472, 0.060839712619781494, -0.056527186185121536, -0.046287164092063904, 0.02596561424434185, 0.013752640224993229, -0.0026724818162620068, 0.04133998975157738, 0.025295009836554527, -0.0415419265627861, 0.02018205262720585, 0.003901796881109476, -0.032670699059963226, -0.051428746432065964, 0.028084835037589073, 0.05902373418211937, -0.0411057323217392, -0.04454079270362854, 0.004997734911739826, -0.03171546012163162, 0.009648571722209454, -0.04449606314301491, 0.007205750327557325, 0.019557254388928413, 0.006139757577329874, -0.05437697842717171, 0.04066222533583641, 0.010049748234450817, -0.07525013387203217, 0.05001123249530792, 0.009740682318806648, -0.07621212303638458, 0.03660565987229347, 0.034991562366485596, 0.001820418401621282, -0.05902479588985443, 0.012006296776235104, -0.0063094645738601685, 0.0015551677206531167, -0.05826102942228317, 0.07809121906757355, 0.0887732058763504, -0.010913951322436333, 0.011111501604318619, -0.003354288637638092, -0.07506662607192993, -0.03720886632800102, -0.0051817218773067, -0.009163832291960716, -0.029941031709313393, 0.02856380306184292, 0.03306778147816658, -0.022289462387561798, -0.0527077242732048, 0.068902388215065, -0.023492317646741867, -0.01128173153847456, 0.05166551098227501, -0.0070826103910803795, 0.0645047202706337, -0.00823181588202715, -0.0022260367404669523, -0.004664242267608643, -0.038874201476573944, -0.01905820332467556, -0.06967800110578537, -0.004089577589184046, 0.044301945716142654, 0.006088942289352417, -0.03873445466160774, -0.058076128363609314, -0.014211338944733143, -0.009327579289674759, -0.05941266566514969, 0.033065199851989746, -0.061598774045705795, 0.030874479562044144, -0.012543287128210068, 0.005757090635597706, 0.018910372629761696, 0.06569784134626389, -0.038903944194316864, 0.03850243613123894, 0.014510700479149818, 0.009842121973633766, 0.003896788926795125, -0.03101414442062378, 0.009187765419483185, -0.039394646883010864, 0.01823665387928486, -0.03688938543200493, 0.012471271678805351, -0.034566204994916916, 0.0021075664553791285, -0.01717335730791092, 0.008961400017142296, -0.01892058365046978, -0.04223332926630974, 0.029476992785930634, -0.021410059183835983, 0.004366709850728512, -0.022969476878643036, -0.039538539946079254, -0.06650932878255844, -0.011671781539916992, -0.004496688023209572, -0.03254679590463638, 0.035468362271785736, 0.032039985060691833, 0.03404944762587547, 0.02395680360496044, -0.005891264416277409, 0.003833639668300748, -0.054460857063531876, 0.006483438424766064, -0.07464514672756195, -0.02180027775466442, -0.004924429580569267, -0.03650422766804695, -0.018824506551027298, -0.010023044422268867, 0.008040716871619225, -0.08214694261550903, 0.009476028382778168, 0.03877757117152214, 0.04545699059963226, -0.006453716661781073, -0.06801962852478027, 0.002921114442870021, 0.009268524125218391, 0.0029454436153173447, -0.02944808453321457, -0.015261373482644558, 0.03612082451581955, -0.021229393780231476, -0.02816137857735157, 0.012584776617586613, -0.03150404617190361, 0.008627272211015224, -0.08541510999202728, -0.0028360250871628523, -0.004555186256766319, 0.05746614560484886, -0.02443009987473488, -0.0639415755867958, -0.012960009276866913, -0.033599935472011566, 0.027564560994505882, 0.01055836956948042, 0.05172301083803177, 0.030966807156801224, 0.04533437266945839, -0.04359845817089081, -0.05621042102575302, -0.0007408835808746517, 0.008923487737774849, -0.0241935383528471, -0.003074206644669175, 0.017273686826229095, 0.013050529174506664, 0.030886804684996605, -0.0009535507415421307, 0.02956196665763855, -0.031932227313518524, 0.029598169028759003, -0.03469901531934738, 0.019444333389401436, -0.04165336862206459, -0.022873850539326668, 0.06363695859909058, -0.04880206659436226, -0.032961830496788025, -0.02020154893398285, -0.0010985539993271232, -0.02845301665365696, 0.0024692234583199024, -0.038232408463954926, 0.007597922347486019, -0.01021912693977356, 0.041496194899082184, -0.00667613884434104, -0.024098968133330345, 0.005159663502126932, -0.027543870732188225, -0.03162625804543495, -0.03725650906562805, -0.04439374804496765, 0.035302285104990005, -0.021876342594623566, 0.022889642044901848, -0.05960354208946228, -0.02028895728290081, -0.005801079794764519, -0.0010544578544795513, -0.051996029913425446, 0.07874210178852081, -0.004299861844629049, -0.04039346054196358, -0.011425822973251343, -0.021497977897524834, 0.014850844629108906, -0.05674150586128235, -0.0266557689756155, -0.06382666528224945, 0.015948796644806862, -0.053319141268730164, 0.020347069948911667, 0.008591569028794765, 0.06946168094873428, 0.04725981876254082, 0.008442413993179798, -0.00042894980288110673, -0.05195673182606697, -0.013360775075852871, 0.061087314039468765, 0.007208747789263725, 0.04478256776928902, -0.041392285376787186, 0.017929138615727425, 0.005730056669563055, -0.023692477494478226, 0.022284619510173798, -0.02307993173599243, -0.012748596258461475, -0.07145082205533981, 0.028778616338968277, -0.016087934374809265, 0.01672683097422123, -0.032468054443597794, -0.0075436970219016075, -0.015916401520371437, -0.0420912466943264, -0.03500021621584892 ]
Automatic Pronunciation Assessment (APA) is vital for computer-assisted language learning. Prior methods rely on annotated speech-text data to train Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) models or speech-score data to train regression models. In this work, we propose a novel zero-shot APA method based on the pre-trained acoustic model, HuBERT. Our method involves encoding speech input and corrupting them via a masking module. We then employ the Transformer encoder and apply k-means clustering to obtain token sequences. Finally, a scoring module is designed to measure the number of wrongly recovered tokens. Experimental results on speechocean762 demonstrate that the proposed method achieves comparable performance to supervised regression baselines and outperforms non-regression baselines in terms of Pearson Correlation Coefficient (PCC). Additionally, we analyze how masking strategies affect the performance of APA.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.19563v1
[ -0.053934868425130844, -0.023252883926033974, 0.013699891977012157, 0.002709415275603533, 0.010944070294499397, -0.010810251347720623, 0.009338593110442162, -0.016493763774633408, -0.043513089418411255, -0.05557840317487717, -0.05728183686733246, -0.028854209929704666, -0.04116996377706528, -0.012387976050376892, -0.052376050502061844, -0.032538462430238724, 0.06029234081506729, 0.02166002057492733, -0.0425676666200161, 0.05403466522693634, 0.0027069931384176016, -0.006368482019752264, -0.03130156546831131, 0.004594265948981047, 0.019668690860271454, -0.06199797987937927, -0.033916033804416656, -0.020593445748090744, -0.026067133992910385, -0.0017848999705165625, 0.0652853325009346, -0.002390362089499831, -0.042056430131196976, -0.024282237514853477, -0.06634203344583511, -0.018561873584985733, -0.005097766872495413, -0.021199483424425125, 0.02194688655436039, -0.05428504943847656, 0.03250294178724289, -0.06545677781105042, -0.06706501543521881, 0.015695225447416306, -0.020399101078510284, 0.005283829290419817, -0.03405296057462692, 0.047123901546001434, -0.027309522032737732, -0.05916839838027954, 0.014111194759607315, 0.027375008910894394, -0.05273470655083656, -0.02406499907374382, -0.05468989536166191, 0.010243796743452549, -0.01457266416400671, 0.008528642356395721, -0.06490767747163773, -0.023319294676184654, 0.017231697216629982, -0.02945798449218273, -0.03924047201871872, 0.04538152366876602, 0.006248440593481064, 0.03452976793050766, 0.0052401297725737095, -0.03464357554912567, -0.052182912826538086, -0.01407303474843502, 0.0573209784924984, -0.05262081325054169, 0.03625485673546791, 0.01438587810844183, -0.006307364907115698, -0.029249873012304306, -0.03235918655991554, -0.02865193970501423, -0.026982557028532028, -0.03765219822525978, -0.0392424501478672, 0.06597384065389633, 0.020990608260035515, 0.044655732810497284, -0.01532196905463934, -0.02643687278032303, 0.04512918367981911, -0.032901305705308914, -0.007715425919741392, -0.057007141411304474, 0.042056646198034286, -0.05770079419016838, -0.047295402735471725, -0.012115741148591042, 0.06331153959035873, -0.0486220046877861, 0.04305114597082138, -0.003450098680332303, 0.010188834741711617, 0.02773439884185791, -0.03659435734152794, 0.06107761710882187, 0.022226693108677864, 0.048522740602493286, -0.008080283179879189, -0.018137812614440918, -0.008757468312978745, -0.011604991741478443, -0.06859396398067474, 0.005293907131999731, -0.040055595338344574, -0.009294429793953896, 0.013575040735304356, -0.05551522225141525, -0.043731074780225754, -0.06411533802747726, 0.0454687662422657, 0.020026028156280518, 0.002058781683444977, -0.044352829456329346, -0.006379642523825169, 0.06334393471479416, 0.023651065304875374, -0.016144439578056335, -0.037440888583660126, -0.024906417354941368, 0.05405270308256149, 0.012014771811664104, -0.014371532946825027, -0.02687772922217846, -0.005987661425024271, 0.05226876214146614, -0.014315586537122726, -0.004039947874844074, 0.06367271393537521, -0.019045818597078323, -0.04008433595299721, -0.05541472136974335, 0.004693260416388512, -0.040012259036302567, -0.0626063421368599, -0.059487275779247284, 0.0253615640103817, -0.007376864552497864, 0.04224947467446327, 0.064541757106781, -0.038219183683395386, -0.027584901079535484, 0.019799843430519104, 0.03296554088592529, 0.0042416611686348915, -0.024191197007894516, 0.052368082106113434, 0.03158425912261009, 0.0019225750584155321, 0.0003033473331015557, 0.03711288422346115, -0.022670602425932884, -0.05910682678222656, 0.03357449546456337, 0.0042640650644898415, -0.006136459298431873, 0.05906370282173157, -0.012842526659369469, 0.061304476112127304, 0.013143803924322128, 0.058104030787944794, 0.02384449541568756, -0.059175893664360046, 0.0311832744628191, -0.02436692640185356, -0.0102874506264925, -0.04585815593600273, -0.03168901428580284, -0.04922089725732803, -0.02911556139588356, 0.0321970134973526, -0.05780528113245964, -0.030187362805008888, 0.012049063108861446, -0.03134114667773247, 0.03696920722723007, 0.012306703254580498, 0.001590265892446041, -0.03205816075205803, 0.013139419257640839, -0.0786985233426094, 0.014187121763825417, 0.045498546212911606, 0.0518060103058815, 0.017311133444309235, -0.027360383421182632, 0.006529168225824833, -0.0003692213213071227, -0.01543522346764803, 0.00949303712695837, -0.004965051077306271, -0.002174295485019684, 0.0436275340616703, 0.05303560569882393, -0.08028063923120499, -0.017998449504375458, -0.07780323177576065, -0.002174059394747019, -0.016478776931762695, -0.08053810894489288, -0.02433856576681137, 0.05185750871896744, -0.06188805401325226, -0.002208615420386195, 0.012933737598359585, 0.03268178179860115, 0.023714130744338036, 0.035176485776901245, 0.018514148890972137, 0.006310955621302128, -0.0944618210196495, 0.06556212157011032, 0.008785760961472988, -0.03975345194339752, 0.0040039303712546825, 0.02284407988190651, 0.009848931804299355, -0.044033925980329514, -0.02128036506474018, 0.007381926290690899, 0.039971645921468735, -0.01791219599545002, -0.04556531086564064, -0.02006591111421585, -0.03509706258773804, -0.027867665514349937, -0.019686607643961906, -0.06851266324520111, 0.0102229043841362, 0.020466897636651993, 0.0206829234957695, 0.009137971326708794, 0.029589194804430008, 0.007434168364852667, -0.0323362834751606, -0.03382052481174469, 0.040189292281866074, -0.03399772197008133, -0.0518832802772522, -0.0498431995511055, -0.025452641770243645, 0.026725955307483673, 0.00605761306360364, -0.019125109538435936, -0.023432547226548195, -0.0316130556166172, 0.005593797191977501, 0.002111386973410845, -0.00013737585686612874, 0.012405290268361568, -0.0321182906627655, 0.04876021668314934, -0.027159487828612328, 0.009279225952923298, 0.05762556195259094, 0.055276479572057724, -0.06106023117899895, 0.02216864749789238, 0.03303636983036995, -0.023671505972743034, 0.020036622881889343, -0.004354515112936497, -0.029897388070821762, -0.02477273717522621, -0.00156286614947021, 0.03444330394268036, 0.013660488650202751, -0.0073284609243273735, -0.03405207768082619, -0.02005534991621971, -0.03306909278035164, -0.007651281543076038, 0.0398954413831234, 0.02260511927306652, 0.04088028147816658, 0.030005117878317833, 0.038590528070926666, -0.0776820182800293, 0.006663333624601364, -0.02081511914730072, -0.04088442400097847, -0.07433628290891647, -0.06714163720607758, -0.017634015530347824, -0.07730108499526978, -0.038595352321863174, -0.0214215237647295, -0.01695386879146099, -0.034304890781641006, -0.045198675245046616, -0.033413589000701904, 0.020702382549643517, 0.03331971541047096, -0.015800155699253082, -0.019608622416853905, -0.009615481831133366, 0.010432358831167221, -0.02938830293715, -0.004496922250837088, -0.031257547438144684, -0.05763964354991913, -0.035878315567970276, 0.03371244668960571, 0.04903769865632057, -0.018452882766723633, 0.000041186780435964465, -0.04808948561549187, 0.038743194192647934, -0.017316557466983795, 0.03529635816812515, -0.010962974280118942, 0.06718369573354721, 0.0119234723970294, -0.040184248238801956, 0.032716549932956696, 0.020758524537086487, 0.01732594147324562, -0.020588798448443413, -0.031620901077985764, 0.006452563218772411, 0.03832307457923889, 0.01834036409854889, -0.024180622771382332, -0.05127209052443504, -0.011422039940953255, 0.010164784267544746, 0.0286201611161232, -0.039109185338020325, 0.017896661534905434, 0.019331583753228188, 0.010953685268759727, -0.051245659589767456, -0.03793836757540703, -0.012473114766180515, -0.029614698141813278, 0.005296556279063225, -0.006137439049780369, 0.021238883957266808, 0.028907161206007004, -0.07916269451379776, 0.022783055901527405, 0.04015287756919861, 0.06015996262431145, -0.025298304855823517, -0.034515585750341415, 0.019324421882629395, 0.009258238598704338, 0.0034929050598293543, -0.018489358946681023, 0.057630956172943115, 0.05947631224989891, 0.03937100991606712, -0.021908791735768318, -0.042171087116003036, -0.014763318933546543, -0.04157746583223343, -0.053447626531124115, -0.0115492083132267, 0.0352117121219635, 0.010988558642566204, -0.018284184858202934, -0.05835147947072983, 0.012842492200434208, 0.001354950712993741, 0.018419157713651657, -0.010988167487084866, -0.05013837292790413, 0.02066410519182682, -0.0539020337164402, 0.05843029171228409, -0.0017739803297445178, 0.008671417832374573, -0.02951444312930107, -0.0503729023039341, 0.04130149632692337, -0.03730937838554382, 0.04749293252825737, 0.025014836341142654, -0.031943388283252716, 0.020571701228618622, 0.0471651628613472, -0.006344633176922798, 0.04473648965358734, -0.031760893762111664, 0.007299613673239946, 0.031144699081778526, 0.0017121884739026427, -0.029938315972685814, 0.00929543562233448, -0.06675857305526733, -0.01861909218132496, 0.020047077909111977, -0.010806668549776077, -0.03384746238589287, 0.008056356571614742, -0.0022948042023926973, -0.025365371257066727, -0.0806981697678566, -0.038847293704748154, -0.06429099291563034, 0.012607348151504993, -0.026396704837679863, -0.08144260197877884, 0.062121860682964325, -0.01964273862540722, -0.026582492515444756, -0.031993843615055084, -0.01800072379410267, -0.057944271713495255, -0.04712608829140663, -0.034614671021699905, -0.07834712415933609, 0.0223696269094944, -0.06358905881643295, 0.02339978516101837, 0.017308825626969337, -0.011805594898760319, -0.0453939251601696, -0.011868263594806194, -0.03850972279906273, 0.044988732784986496, 0.07267019152641296, 0.03842148184776306, -0.032559581100940704, -0.019415581598877907, -0.01157592236995697, 0.02076541818678379, 0.001057076035067439, 0.00526857515797019, -0.057258885353803635, 0.06136249005794525, -0.00039323477540165186, -0.014525668695569038, -0.004989104811102152, -0.01946086622774601, 0.03887653350830078, -0.027986453846096992, -0.059133876115083694, 0.0012865832541137934, 0.02290922962129116, -0.05227616801857948, -0.06984234601259232, -0.03041454777121544, -0.037929121404886246, -0.08109469711780548, -0.015429130755364895, 0.03638342395424843, 0.031285591423511505, -0.01984206959605217, -0.0026915986090898514, 0.028414545580744743, 0.010782942175865173, -0.01805020309984684, 0.0033834294881671667, 0.05312642082571983, 0.018856767565011978, -0.018363868817687035, -0.002612093463540077, -0.07592756301164627, 0.028792059049010277, -0.049439314752817154, -0.02705032378435135, -0.03097759373486042, 0.02883576974272728, -0.007780684158205986, 0.0629248395562172, -0.08187168091535568, 0.0024662166833877563, 0.033768631517887115, -0.0604715459048748, 0.04736912623047829, 0.05996489152312279, -0.04251393675804138, 0.05993601679801941, -0.016356205567717552, -0.02209344506263733, -0.028293320909142494, -0.05324820429086685, -0.0015639218036085367, 0.004436750430613756, 0.003515581600368023, 0.0061240834183990955, 0.00972414668649435, -0.024972308427095413, -0.03289300575852394, -0.025939898565411568, 0.03559594601392746, 0.0221225768327713, -0.03661121800541878, 0.052934058010578156, 0.05069442838430405, -0.03640320897102356, -0.0519871823489666, -0.02433980628848076, 0.004001546651124954, 0.005221404135227203, 0.011722653172910213, -0.02587643824517727, -0.02439827471971512, 0.009342419914901257, 0.04757615178823471, -0.029864512383937836, 0.016384176909923553, -0.00997977890074253, 0.026713309809565544, -0.009169993922114372, 0.034430742263793945, -0.03336559236049652, -0.047693461179733276, -0.014646504074335098, 0.06909429281949997, 0.015758370980620384, 0.03493845462799072, 0.03741554543375969, 0.01485552079975605, -0.01504768431186676, -0.0413048155605793, -0.0316016785800457, -0.010035897605121136, 0.023432770743966103, 0.006166630890220404, 0.00949274655431509, 0.02148229070007801, 0.04075225070118904, 0.010636165738105774, 0.034104738384485245, 0.003638338064774871, 0.006387623958289623, 0.0034547089599072933, 0.008389904163777828, 0.04298887401819229, -0.03816615045070648, -0.023350464180111885, -0.010663887485861778, -0.012555437162518501, -0.025542130693793297, 0.026638533920049667, 0.025921663269400597, -0.014900446869432926, 0.040477510541677475, 0.025120237842202187, -0.027042413130402565, -0.07188475877046585, 0.04699954763054848, 0.06567051261663437, -0.05496814846992493, 0.0005523992003872991, -0.02107618935406208, 0.008596066385507584, 0.049957964569330215, -0.03656213358044624, -0.008516388945281506, 0.0028566981200128794, 0.012766900472342968, -0.055923495441675186, 0.05645107850432396, -0.0004573641635943204, -0.05434618890285492, -0.023095862939953804, 0.04070029780268669, -0.07923392206430435, 0.01826508343219757, -0.025774629786610603, 0.004847709089517593, -0.03528951480984688, 0.023299790918827057, 0.019164543598890305, -0.02529352717101574, -0.028437476605176926, 0.05844488739967346, 0.06974819302558899, -0.037606917321681976, -0.02025773748755455, 0.011121682822704315, -0.065155528485775, 0.03932683914899826, -0.05033116415143013, -0.0443718247115612, 0.011578883975744247, 0.030879167839884758, 0.050427623093128204, -0.005529259331524372, 0.002315429039299488, 0.05400634557008743, -0.026988772675395012, 0.0489603653550148, -0.01876729726791382, -0.04575852304697037, 0.05424930527806282, -0.0433042086660862, -0.03509528934955597, -0.0014492430491372943, -0.019782932475209236, 0.01645956188440323, -0.057757578790187836, -0.029701778665184975, 0.004174168221652508, 0.015591331757605076, 0.029917117208242416, -0.0696331039071083, -0.004180822987109423, -0.008351013995707035, -0.0627371147274971, -0.015221284702420235, -0.06641162931919098, 0.027895696461200714, 0.0011660053860396147, 0.004851957783102989, -0.002492653438821435, 0.07977233082056046, -0.01289359014481306, -0.005139895249158144, 0.025278234854340553, 0.047733452171087265, 0.006464855745434761, -0.009978746995329857, 0.019933653995394707, -0.03825358301401138, 0.043220628052949905, -0.024425935000181198, -0.02918211929500103, -0.010132262483239174, -0.04871422052383423, 0.02580692432820797, 0.050450779497623444, -0.007771496661007404, -0.07084603607654572, 0.01718958094716072, -0.04518798366189003, 0.03729967772960663, 0.019485827535390854, -0.06006089597940445, -0.050198689103126526, 0.007351442705839872, -0.012016053311526775, 0.00615000119432807, 0.03249290585517883, 0.016067076474428177, 0.021046504378318787, 0.017956500872969627, 0.017406264320015907, -0.029682815074920654, 0.059273842722177505, 0.0019112576264888048, -0.06078869476914406, -0.019397933036088943, 0.025125982239842415, -0.04450113698840141, -0.02884680964052677, 0.048541609197854996, -0.008966500870883465, -0.05033678933978081, 0.02372410148382187, 0.05612289533019066, 0.03620986267924309, 0.027412133291363716, -0.054039567708969116, 0.04604289308190346, -0.02112441696226597, -0.07328659296035767, -0.02866596356034279, -0.01365723181515932, -0.013147445395588875, -0.03898599371314049, -0.008308246731758118, -0.018716469407081604, -0.0505308173596859, 0.004881163593381643, -0.08546620607376099, -0.016113458201289177, -0.01826978661119938, 0.030686622485518456, 0.0007310085347853601, 0.007986225187778473, 0.03206972777843475, -0.06232842803001404, 0.03659646213054657, -0.003134871367365122, -0.028140520676970482, 0.02341962605714798, 0.030832771211862564, 0.04819171503186226, -0.05356515944004059, -0.06213264539837837, 0.05246230959892273, 0.01268424466252327, -0.034511346369981766, 0.053580619394779205, 0.04684581235051155, 0.006833236198872328, -0.031995709985494614, 0.042613763362169266, -0.0016900612972676754, 0.01708877459168434, -0.041533276438713074, -0.022223206236958504, -0.04019586369395256, -0.05258175730705261, 0.03533549979329109, -0.03441770002245903, -0.01097932830452919, 0.01431551855057478, 0.010973888449370861, 0.014275487512350082, -0.009334865026175976, -0.014683346264064312, 0.012867942452430725, -0.017760764807462692, -0.007690193597227335, 0.03734062984585762, -0.019414430484175682, -0.05203462764620781, -0.03106868825852871, -0.020147304981946945, -0.02795788273215294, 0.021847430616617203, 0.05089477449655533, -0.02012377791106701, 0.0014014440821483731, -0.049488164484500885, -0.010608666576445103, -0.019989246502518654, 0.021743925288319588, 0.013489956967532635, 0.054032567888498306, 0.03557172790169716, -0.027148155495524406, -0.03706551715731621, -0.03388260304927826, -0.038983531296253204, -0.07179339975118637, -0.04728017747402191, -0.028365474194288254, -0.02638787217438221, 0.04331174120306969, -0.0063677201978862286, -0.003581710858270526, 0.05566822737455368, 0.05059674382209778, 0.02132854238152504, 0.02492208033800125, -0.0019112381851300597, -0.0008703399216756225, 0.0680251270532608, -0.00018165138317272067, 0.010349303483963013, -0.04194382205605507, 0.03066902980208397, -0.030261676758527756, 0.007342956960201263, 0.019076617434620857, -0.02726052701473236, -0.01973818801343441, -0.060753535479307175, -0.0013796673156321049, 0.042257118970155716, -0.028697149828076363, -0.06565482914447784, -0.03469030186533928, 0.022484933957457542, -0.04843511804938316, -0.030434055253863335 ]
Visual active tracking is a growing research topic in robotics due to its key role in applications such as human assistance, disaster recovery, and surveillance. In contrast to passive tracking, active tracking approaches combine vision and control capabilities to detect and actively track the target. Most of the work in this area focuses on ground robots, while the very few contributions on aerial platforms still pose important design constraints that limit their applicability. To overcome these limitations, in this paper we propose D-VAT, a novel end-to-end visual active tracking methodology based on deep reinforcement learning that is tailored to micro aerial vehicle platforms. The D-VAT agent computes the vehicle thrust and angular velocity commands needed to track the target by directly processing monocular camera measurements. We show that the proposed approach allows for precise and collision-free tracking operations, outperforming different state-of-the-art baselines on simulated environments which differ significantly from those encountered during training. Moreover, we demonstrate a smooth real-world transition to a quadrotor platform with mixed-reality.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.16874v2
[ -0.022684134542942047, -0.02987421303987503, 0.020822782069444656, 0.008926896378397942, -0.0201015193015337, 0.0030265473760664463, 0.03910769894719124, -0.00960166472941637, 0.01171597559005022, -0.054148416966199875, -0.035089440643787384, 0.014561367221176624, -0.044244471937417984, -0.05535192787647247, -0.03769513592123985, 0.03640270605683327, 0.08176721632480621, -0.05205884203314781, -0.044150710105895996, 0.02431861311197281, 0.0456843301653862, -0.02494044229388237, -0.009872181341052055, 0.009599112905561924, 0.002443342236801982, -0.01252985280007124, -0.023215951398015022, 0.036519356071949005, -0.02762388437986374, -0.003393893362954259, 0.08582436293363571, -0.017744889482855797, -0.017457731068134308, -0.032078519463539124, -0.016992708668112755, 0.014115999452769756, -0.03553957864642143, 0.03879418969154358, 0.012794981710612774, -0.05178176984190941, 0.04322321340441704, -0.02435731515288353, -0.026910876855254173, -0.03612557426095009, -0.02456585317850113, -0.05368630960583687, -0.032140102237463, 0.008637981489300728, -0.05055902525782585, -0.0393366701900959, 0.03933725506067276, -0.001217043143697083, 0.031955353915691376, 0.044370003044605255, -0.019872695207595825, -0.00014757939788978547, 0.013640864752233028, 0.025620633736252785, -0.010960672050714493, -0.00160817033611238, 0.010374397970736027, -0.0011424280237406492, 0.02995188906788826, 0.020248159766197205, 0.02624209225177765, 0.060398802161216736, -0.036212410777807236, -0.04250679910182953, -0.05129656940698624, -0.04189292713999748, 0.052783235907554626, -0.035551656037569046, 0.0031639195512980223, 0.020840829238295555, -0.02682468295097351, -0.023340817540884018, -0.028006570413708687, -0.049117330461740494, 0.04758952930569649, -0.022358043119311333, -0.0080139534547925, 0.003544147126376629, 0.0519818551838398, 0.0069922395050525665, 0.0015800675610080361, -0.014792902395129204, 0.016358008608222008, 0.016181278973817825, 0.012695789337158203, -0.011587523855268955, 0.06625870615243912, -0.06816984713077545, -0.06325049698352814, -0.03560726344585419, 0.04621005803346634, -0.03419642150402069, 0.06421422213315964, 0.019283758476376534, 0.0011186483316123486, -0.004493136424571276, -0.012394359335303307, -0.0005996038089506328, -0.036241717636585236, 0.0067142401821911335, 0.05083572864532471, -0.06728091090917587, 0.028368478640913963, -0.01886892504990101, 0.0033909990452229977, 0.017739703878760338, -0.011584663763642311, -0.019926447421312332, -0.004013396799564362, -0.07469966262578964, -0.03632434830069542, -0.020168138667941093, 0.06179984286427498, -0.02887360006570816, 0.02937275916337967, 0.013603828847408295, -0.03422290459275246, 0.037675946950912476, 0.040415048599243164, -0.01474008522927761, 0.013369210064411163, -0.028598232194781303, 0.07230262458324432, -0.0070373015478253365, 0.03629632666707039, -0.056670527905225754, -0.025899158790707588, 0.024359986186027527, -0.04422854632139206, -0.01696394756436348, 0.04067876189947128, 0.023783909156918526, -0.006057800259441137, -0.04020953178405762, 0.03478638455271721, -0.05369628593325615, -0.03644653037190437, -0.023956000804901123, 0.05147043243050575, -0.0067942021414637566, -0.005918323528021574, 0.05688534677028656, -0.04581228271126747, -0.03839771822094917, -0.012460925616323948, 0.04475821927189827, 0.029605723917484283, 0.013391946442425251, 0.05136606842279434, 0.067904032766819, 0.0373847559094429, -0.04472140222787857, 0.062183305621147156, -0.020813535898923874, -0.06694095581769943, 0.002066472778096795, -0.0021632665302604437, 0.003220426384359598, 0.03455568104982376, -0.016913000494241714, 0.019490862265229225, -0.00542060611769557, 0.014044711366295815, 0.02056686021387577, -0.009754265658557415, 0.025016972795128822, -0.021546384319663048, -0.031709667295217514, -0.00618246803060174, -0.01807061955332756, -0.06022137776017189, -0.019736338406801224, -0.0149400494992733, -0.07442454993724823, -0.008421502076089382, 0.0012031079968437552, -0.007245933171361685, 0.023570481687784195, -0.01338967401534319, 0.0035995435900986195, -0.03512894734740257, -0.01583218201994896, -0.058820679783821106, -0.04180321469902992, 0.018790841102600098, 0.028851820155978203, -0.05361250042915344, -0.04394066706299782, 0.011388842947781086, 0.0009448883356526494, -0.06569017469882965, -0.0414353609085083, -0.045151207596063614, -0.048449281603097916, 0.0668364018201828, 0.019677571952342987, -0.09778373688459396, 0.0035115850623697042, -0.04636906087398529, -0.004460504278540611, -0.013541682623326778, -0.08589264750480652, 0.023441830649971962, 0.04296700283885002, -0.028845427557826042, 0.0323321707546711, 0.017723506316542625, 0.0283814687281847, 0.06836879253387451, -0.0014606158947572112, 0.04758070036768913, 0.025461746379733086, -0.11428327113389969, 0.028358403593301773, 0.017212416976690292, 0.028470264747738838, 0.031211622059345245, 0.03393230214715004, -0.015861202031373978, -0.016333000734448433, -0.03523721173405647, 0.06313659250736237, 0.05950278788805008, -0.03172188997268677, -0.0338786244392395, -0.03686216473579407, -0.0008879608358256519, -0.06570065766572952, -0.04817286878824234, -0.06587614119052887, -0.04114227369427681, -0.029076213017106056, -0.04219578951597214, 0.0495145358145237, -0.019901471212506294, -0.0025554613675922155, -0.046331170946359634, -0.03665537387132645, 0.04012163355946541, -0.014070039615035057, -0.03390000760555267, -0.022619586437940598, 0.005213048774749041, -0.017352301627397537, -0.022762054577469826, -0.007688640151172876, -0.035402555018663406, -0.015141025185585022, 0.00843836460262537, -0.037057507783174515, 0.026206526905298233, 0.042499687522649765, -0.027400309219956398, 0.013751891441643238, -0.05288364365696907, 0.016024496406316757, 0.0016017399029806256, -0.007823162712156773, -0.045206520706415176, 0.01835748180747032, 0.03205336257815361, -0.004921430256217718, 0.012902644462883472, -0.042763158679008484, -0.011268175207078457, -0.030867241322994232, -0.002551313955336809, -0.01463131234049797, 0.017148509621620178, 0.005646831821650267, -0.025059906765818596, -0.02099752239882946, -0.013312578201293945, -0.01744246669113636, -0.002758397487923503, 0.05975168198347092, 0.017217757180333138, 0.015532809309661388, 0.045930780470371246, -0.04761197417974472, -0.025177476927638054, -0.0423240065574646, 0.009222605265676975, -0.06410260498523712, -0.030690988525748253, -0.01750847138464451, -0.05303994193673134, -0.036413129419088364, -0.0322205014526844, -0.03648830205202103, -0.03597554564476013, -0.04154072701931, -0.031086057424545288, 0.013903153128921986, 0.021540964022278786, 0.0001126289353123866, 0.0013852727133780718, -0.03450145944952965, -0.02317465841770172, 0.03683304414153099, -0.017355279996991158, -0.05537442862987518, -0.011081329546868801, 0.0001651384518481791, -0.012187405489385128, -0.0004961632657796144, -0.015087448991835117, 0.03252459317445755, -0.009984809905290604, 0.042538803070783615, -0.0022392631508409977, -0.027013424783945084, 0.007004281040281057, 0.0009408327168785036, -0.02575615979731083, -0.01973169483244419, -0.004168759100139141, -0.014808866195380688, 0.024146977812051773, -0.02151142619550228, -0.03472907096147537, -0.005867341998964548, 0.07188841700553894, 0.019409699365496635, 0.0036110314540565014, -0.022514667361974716, 0.001064195530489087, 0.025157315656542778, 0.03762219101190567, 0.015262691304087639, 0.03457360714673996, 0.03351520001888275, -0.028432097285985947, -0.014102021232247353, -0.01658497378230095, 0.026465097442269325, -0.006143320817500353, 0.03585210070014, -0.06225220859050751, -0.009589381515979767, 0.028808949515223503, -0.10455350577831268, -0.009803655557334423, 0.04536456614732742, 0.050866615027189255, 0.03663139045238495, 0.058941394090652466, 0.010024862363934517, 0.044126957654953, 0.014375116676092148, 0.008681189268827438, 0.034667856991291046, 0.03229784965515137, 0.047182150185108185, -0.042132921516895294, -0.03095238283276558, -0.01988016813993454, -0.08776456862688065, -0.0786990150809288, 0.014664024114608765, 0.0357334241271019, 0.023856641724705696, 0.05788695067167282, -0.06362276524305344, -0.001208286383189261, 0.013330847024917603, 0.05301996320486069, -0.00003531137917889282, -0.050414588302373886, -0.0018886012258008122, -0.028653467074036598, 0.028333133086562157, 0.002011014148592949, 0.0022029534447938204, 0.019155988469719887, -0.03316068276762962, 0.011912868358194828, -0.05090159922838211, 0.05273996666073799, -0.0224919430911541, 0.007027244661003351, 0.040869709104299545, 0.01234117429703474, 0.009388603270053864, 0.058832526206970215, 0.015657655894756317, -0.02489033155143261, 0.029192090034484863, -0.008355310186743736, -0.020095737650990486, 0.0026607043109834194, -0.030458271503448486, -0.0011600475991144776, -0.014400525949895382, -0.03167299926280975, -0.024572307243943214, -0.008956441655755043, 0.002294885693117976, -0.0361458994448185, -0.07821964472532272, 0.03447093442082405, -0.07323772460222244, 0.06852163374423981, 0.004883682820945978, -0.023504557088017464, 0.08552665263414383, -0.031091509386897087, 0.007177574560046196, -0.03742676600813866, 0.010914112441241741, -0.031149310991168022, -0.050992149859666824, -0.017219772562384605, -0.06464861333370209, 0.015134836547076702, 0.012616983614861965, 0.057186342775821686, -0.02867504581809044, 0.021597865968942642, -0.06265202909708023, -0.048752740025520325, -0.0266178697347641, 0.026812667027115822, 0.005306589882820845, -0.004680228885263205, 0.005625586491078138, 0.008794519118964672, 0.030989138409495354, 0.005929439328610897, 0.030783172696828842, -0.026974065229296684, -0.018968256190419197, 0.04731259122490883, -0.04013116657733917, 0.017522800713777542, 0.00690902303904295, 0.009219453670084476, 0.0711212307214737, -0.010600060224533081, -0.018712610006332397, 0.005810461472719908, 0.048408228904008865, -0.033244241029024124, -0.04525947570800781, -0.04339949041604996, -0.03371979668736458, -0.027426138520240784, -0.0028501919005066156, 0.03019373118877411, 0.00992882065474987, -0.03377979248762131, 0.03349614515900612, 0.053488731384277344, 0.03591646999120712, -0.04021977260708809, 0.00709006329998374, 0.03423743322491646, 0.027273137122392654, 0.014735769480466843, -0.04844847694039345, -0.07153698801994324, 0.04675881937146187, 0.006037416402250528, 0.009916674345731735, -0.04806540533900261, 0.036572400480508804, 0.026188379153609276, 0.003807827364653349, -0.09462450444698334, 0.037997256964445114, 0.06794638931751251, -0.05647573247551918, 0.06097191199660301, 0.0520489364862442, -0.03308922052383423, 0.03993287310004234, 0.00657228846102953, -0.0005791811854578555, 0.050724249333143234, -0.031022129580378532, -0.03570854663848877, -0.029917003586888313, -0.04127943888306618, 0.03624926880002022, 0.03681666776537895, -0.031693268567323685, -0.06781886518001556, -0.0038064380642026663, 0.012966346926987171, 0.0177104901522398, -0.015614233911037445, 0.03521884232759476, 0.034028127789497375, -0.03672042116522789, -0.030996592715382576, 0.0007077146437950432, 0.016371751204133034, 0.0037645623087882996, 0.002547260606661439, -0.027164312079548836, -0.0228481013327837, 0.04057648032903671, 0.011756529100239277, -0.017424218356609344, -0.031319860368967056, 0.011524218134582043, 0.0002801625232677907, -0.024934547021985054, -0.01876494102180004, -0.06066672131419182, -0.050678856670856476, -0.014078429900109768, 0.033520814031362534, 0.02211110293865204, 0.06043365225195885, 0.06775074452161789, 0.03516814857721329, 0.003647521371021867, -0.01827339641749859, 0.007022659759968519, -0.043685007840394974, 0.027867615222930908, -0.05268198996782303, 0.06353744864463806, -0.00648847408592701, -0.019300799816846848, -0.0013190426398068666, 0.02813604474067688, 0.010990787297487259, -0.028835369274020195, -0.03114129789173603, -0.022545015439391136, -0.0017196856206282973, -0.06172522157430649, -0.04959874600172043, 0.04701573774218559, 0.03649381175637245, -0.012872356921434402, 0.027654225006699562, 0.001594256260432303, 0.002641496015712619, 0.02605319581925869, 0.010082680732011795, 0.012013223953545094, -0.013264155946671963, 0.0004647479800041765, 0.0774119570851326, -0.049333713948726654, -0.03660040348768234, 0.027083110064268112, -0.04481463506817818, 0.022386204451322556, -0.0510949045419693, 0.01371968537569046, -0.00441772723570466, 0.0060896375216543674, -0.0370691753923893, 0.011503055691719055, -0.05513773113489151, -0.067508764564991, 0.0308777317404747, 0.012808042578399181, -0.08289103209972382, -0.010733635164797306, 0.018778249621391296, -0.004357136320322752, -0.06215894594788551, 0.03998653218150139, 0.04170284420251846, 0.011063648387789726, -0.0204508975148201, 0.04135587811470032, 0.08064749091863632, 0.011877300217747688, -0.00475229462608695, 0.008397291414439678, -0.041522227227687836, 0.02571081556379795, -0.03812152147293091, 0.031610969454050064, 0.022029109299182892, 0.04381747543811798, 0.02548651024699211, -0.04389340803027153, -0.04287208244204521, 0.05998343974351883, -0.06956417113542557, -0.033604804426431656, 0.0008706580265425146, -0.026201866567134857, 0.07107525318861008, 0.03818812221288681, -0.05506064370274544, 0.019795477390289307, -0.024502351880073547, 0.019411204382777214, -0.028326690196990967, -0.010973037220537663, 0.010783590376377106, 0.02339777536690235, 0.0045448848977684975, -0.05816604197025299, -0.011761450208723545, -0.05378382280468941, -0.058633092790842056, 0.045265693217515945, -0.060135260224342346, -0.024731600657105446, 0.014639181084930897, -0.009495927952229977, 0.02681785635650158, 0.04047898203134537, -0.04740239679813385, -0.03429081663489342, 0.012283663265407085, -0.014484480023384094, 0.005429062992334366, 0.008281741291284561, 0.06149645522236824, 0.038741473108530045, 0.056625910103321075, -0.011392396874725819, -0.02351468987762928, -0.0012425783788785338, -0.024436192587018013, 0.05507722124457359, -0.03755427896976471, -0.027915799990296364, -0.033951688557863235, -0.016879672184586525, 0.014403055422008038, 0.024567460641264915, 0.0007673663785681129, -0.019139692187309265, -0.0725068673491478, 0.010619169101119041, 0.027289075776934624, 0.038424670696258545, -0.03756661340594292, 0.016602324321866035, 0.010429536923766136, -0.010408654808998108, 0.02125825360417366, 0.06141391023993492, -0.030299268662929535, 0.010856377892196178, -0.0521995835006237, -0.04376711696386337, 0.024705667048692703, -0.008470946922898293, -0.06159760057926178, 0.0018046334153041244, -0.021351734176278114, -0.04306358844041824, 0.03159196302294731, 0.033603549003601074, 0.016134653240442276, -0.01074984110891819, -0.0733509436249733, 0.019442476332187653, -0.012033535167574883, -0.008125749416649342, -0.05416622385382652, -0.01674773544073105, -0.0019199572270736098, -0.020744988694787025, 0.00021571415709331632, 0.009914679452776909, -0.05208856239914894, 0.029975473880767822, -0.09038528054952621, -0.009152131155133247, 0.02734408900141716, 0.013863463886082172, -0.019509732723236084, -0.07170429080724716, 0.0016776499105617404, -0.03631623461842537, 0.01270004641264677, 0.03247736394405365, 0.0014320897171273828, 0.010928084142506123, 0.05341280996799469, 0.01503085158765316, -0.06303184479475021, -0.03689698129892349, -0.01331327110528946, -0.0012993160635232925, 0.007542155217379332, 0.050448521971702576, 0.04591765254735947, 0.03916935250163078, -0.030658528208732605, 0.032484591007232666, -0.03465971350669861, 0.05564889684319496, -0.07158979773521423, 0.037485599517822266, -0.03255940601229668, -0.04108604043722153, -0.014902974478900433, -0.05135596916079521, 0.014348216354846954, 0.033397573977708817, -0.00009109515667660162, 0.035785261541604996, -0.03270815312862396, -0.05581801012158394, 0.0546073392033577, -0.014333785511553288, -0.02761068008840084, 0.05180945247411728, -0.06507741659879684, -0.011456584557890892, -0.009302289225161076, -0.04622165113687515, -0.02625136449933052, 0.0395936593413353, 0.044468145817518234, -0.026099035516381264, 0.00710512138903141, -0.07184533774852753, 0.023301757872104645, -0.006677139084786177, 0.016804829239845276, -0.05348842591047287, 0.08238578587770462, 0.04927215725183487, -0.03217046707868576, -0.0511157251894474, -0.043781500309705734, -0.008111309260129929, -0.037003569304943085, -0.016858549788594246, -0.011904703453183174, 0.019974252209067345, -0.006186061073094606, 0.0012057418935000896, 0.038563258945941925, 0.032053690403699875, 0.028964564204216003, 0.044758185744285583, -0.032056018710136414, 0.007169000338762999, -0.05062129721045494, 0.09643572568893433, -0.006151178386062384, 0.041323479264974594, -0.03661108389496803, -0.0009161632624454796, 0.0018658475019037724, -0.00888657197356224, -0.03749406710267067, 0.00956905446946621, 0.026271820068359375, -0.06662848591804504, -0.01902894303202629, 0.034371163696050644, -0.0315665677189827, -0.0349130742251873, -0.06451558321714401, 0.032988134771585464, -0.04540286585688591, -0.07191735506057739 ]
Automatic text-to-3D generation that combines Score Distillation Sampling (SDS) with the optimization of volume rendering has achieved remarkable progress in synthesizing realistic 3D objects. Yet most existing text-to-3D methods by SDS and volume rendering suffer from inaccurate geometry, e.g., the Janus issue, since it is hard to explicitly integrate 3D priors into implicit 3D representations. Besides, it is usually time-consuming for them to generate elaborate 3D models with rich colors. In response, this paper proposes GSGEN, a novel method that adopts Gaussian Splatting, a recent state-of-the-art representation, to text-to-3D generation. GSGEN aims at generating high-quality 3D objects and addressing existing shortcomings by exploiting the explicit nature of Gaussian Splatting that enables the incorporation of 3D prior. Specifically, our method adopts a progressive optimization strategy, which includes a geometry optimization stage and an appearance refinement stage. In geometry optimization, a coarse representation is established under 3D point cloud diffusion prior along with the ordinary 2D SDS optimization, ensuring a sensible and 3D-consistent rough shape. Subsequently, the obtained Gaussians undergo an iterative appearance refinement to enrich texture details. In this stage, we increase the number of Gaussians by compactness-based densification to enhance continuity and improve fidelity. With these designs, our approach can generate 3D assets with delicate details and accurate geometry. Extensive evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, especially for capturing high-frequency components. Our code is available at https://github.com/gsgen3d/gsgen
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16585v4
[ -0.040234144777059555, -0.05596781149506569, 0.0368991494178772, 0.02593166008591652, -0.011777705512940884, -0.0015785149298608303, 0.016538575291633606, -0.02377159148454666, -0.0350181870162487, -0.01343949418514967, -0.03177666291594505, -0.010409764014184475, 0.0010777285788208246, -0.0034962829668074846, -0.039139386266469955, -0.04361910745501518, 0.049965690821409225, -0.06430812925100327, -0.05443393066525459, 0.06812234222888947, 0.008284320123493671, 0.03184465691447258, -0.01597762666642666, 0.03643477335572243, -0.009798548184335232, -0.005117232445627451, -0.07306647300720215, 0.006224463693797588, -0.05728970840573311, 0.0030686273239552975, 0.06566028296947479, -0.04690854996442795, 0.030966470018029213, -0.038760095834732056, -0.03743807226419449, 0.006583570037037134, -0.05659853667020798, 0.014212805777788162, 0.014323401264846325, -0.07033085823059082, 0.011034193448722363, -0.04229140281677246, -0.06264671683311462, -0.025561485439538956, -0.04727546125650406, 0.02071579359471798, -0.027947816997766495, 0.058483369648456573, -0.05863366276025772, -0.04365214705467224, 0.04600834846496582, -0.04987804591655731, -0.017016589641571045, 0.05725988745689392, -0.011553705669939518, 0.036090534180402756, -0.013034945353865623, -0.01571430265903473, -0.04623643308877945, -0.022861341014504433, -0.00010954516619676724, -0.026161903515458107, 0.0111515698954463, -0.028559252619743347, -0.04685262218117714, 0.056744419038295746, -0.015492615289986134, -0.0637047067284584, -0.0514824241399765, -0.06651828438043594, 0.0509212464094162, -0.07035241276025772, 0.019090157002210617, 0.03820822015404701, -0.038013920187950134, -0.016673380509018898, -0.043327610939741135, -0.011419556103646755, -0.0076569668017327785, -0.01552832406014204, -0.030629504472017288, 0.02419273555278778, 0.007312344387173653, 0.047815851867198944, 0.004370091482996941, 0.005879172123968601, 0.006561594549566507, 0.00950833410024643, 0.03774711862206459, -0.059278231114149094, 0.03766634315252304, -0.0684380754828453, -0.053341250866651535, -0.008630342781543732, 0.06545078009366989, -0.028470173478126526, 0.047793496400117874, 0.033021338284015656, 0.04775361344218254, -0.02343827299773693, -0.042349573224782944, -0.033266495913267136, -0.022130951285362244, 0.0206163227558136, 0.02998107671737671, -0.024028146639466286, 0.01323716714978218, -0.005466303322464228, 0.001332797110080719, 0.0017441397067159414, -0.0445120669901371, 0.028544871136546135, 0.03371284529566765, -0.045516178011894226, -0.050729524344205856, -0.041057661175727844, 0.03939652442932129, -0.007537693716585636, 0.020516958087682724, -0.0005782827502116561, -0.03151869401335716, 0.017894728109240532, 0.029308877885341644, -0.03954533115029335, -0.05617257207632065, -0.03898743540048599, 0.08048523962497711, 0.00004075950346305035, -0.001559078344143927, -0.039669595658779144, -0.028311414644122124, 0.004506511148065329, 0.00311257503926754, -0.036319732666015625, 0.08051982522010803, 0.022225935012102127, 0.0018316750647500157, -0.0706525519490242, -0.018271230161190033, 0.0011724975192919374, -0.02930205687880516, -0.06535495817661285, 0.021449776366353035, -0.0464654378592968, -0.006330539938062429, 0.048695359379053116, 0.02060261368751526, -0.03884395211935043, -0.007673902437090874, -0.01493827998638153, 0.01625928096473217, -0.05877860635519028, 0.03649858757853508, 0.038190364837646484, -0.00870011281222105, -0.024380523711442947, 0.07008934020996094, 0.02157365344464779, -0.04031069576740265, 0.01895941235125065, 0.008850587531924248, -0.06696293503046036, 0.040281541645526886, -0.012694599106907845, 0.015416460111737251, -0.029280977323651314, 0.05800257623195648, -0.05046296492218971, 0.00935779232531786, 0.045205965638160706, -0.025514760985970497, -0.04491063579916954, -0.025817643851041794, -0.0032626718748360872, -0.03230459615588188, 0.012178814969956875, -0.04076787829399109, -0.07417573034763336, -0.05952968820929527, -0.043824922293424606, -0.018643949180841446, 0.010157260112464428, -0.023306716233491898, -0.017905421555042267, -0.05405532568693161, -0.029283538460731506, -0.08483753353357315, -0.031194549053907394, 0.050009019672870636, 0.02436920814216137, -0.024289734661579132, -0.03326580673456192, -0.010441907681524754, 0.025411000475287437, -0.033677369356155396, -0.03330123797059059, -0.001379145309329033, -0.03935007005929947, 0.022262219339609146, 0.006212606560438871, -0.08100894093513489, -0.06295891106128693, -0.06559043377637863, 0.020694687962532043, -0.009513165801763535, -0.06320838630199432, -0.04113643243908882, 0.05409052222967148, -0.028664089739322662, 0.0056596361100673676, 0.016503261402249336, 0.0606614425778389, 0.0518721342086792, -0.028559977188706398, 0.02014816179871559, 0.03442724049091339, -0.09594805538654327, 0.041924186050891876, -0.019238246604800224, 0.005487795919179916, 0.01691192388534546, 0.006960729137063026, -0.00575190270319581, -0.036520570516586304, -0.016466481611132622, 0.04839462414383888, 0.06411835551261902, -0.016490120440721512, -0.05862782150506973, -0.03609839454293251, 0.033167578279972076, -0.04459744319319725, -0.019527379423379898, -0.05116306245326996, 0.001268867403268814, 0.024124717339873314, -0.01839466579258442, 0.04701603949069977, -0.006045667454600334, -0.023524129763245583, -0.032046202570199966, -0.0024938443675637245, 0.06752336025238037, 0.0032028870191425085, -0.03148714452981949, -0.009571102447807789, -0.0077193486504256725, -0.00990429800003767, -0.010174855589866638, -0.021825268864631653, -0.0400969460606575, -0.047649577260017395, -0.0415799506008625, 0.014145426452159882, 0.055626362562179565, 0.05713553726673126, -0.048440348356962204, -0.005723528563976288, -0.03606921806931496, 0.03865917772054672, 0.007908220402896404, -0.0010080699576064944, -0.04875016212463379, 0.03275689855217934, 0.006857524160295725, 0.007163516245782375, -0.007147741969674826, -0.042815323919057846, -0.0005952967330813408, -0.010198629461228848, 0.02256646193563938, 0.009760485030710697, 0.027988217771053314, 0.017349520698189735, -0.013760668225586414, -0.03291040658950806, -0.007368225138634443, -0.02362212724983692, 0.016470711678266525, 0.004171211738139391, 0.0020245760679244995, 0.026324672624468803, -0.021676136180758476, -0.07066560536623001, 0.030291680246591568, -0.0387469157576561, -0.007119266781955957, -0.06460341066122055, -0.07930829375982285, -0.0015904062893241644, -0.07767967134714127, -0.03918522596359253, -0.05974337458610535, -0.03668076545000076, -0.02644096128642559, -0.02608809992671013, -0.018105901777744293, 0.0035771087277680635, 0.04170316830277443, 0.0113975265994668, -0.02843444235622883, 0.010271172970533371, -0.0027710446156561375, 0.04588378220796585, -0.018085993826389313, -0.025319373235106468, -0.04084580019116402, 0.032162562012672424, -0.02356625348329544, 0.009983147494494915, -0.044342175126075745, 0.030391864478588104, -0.019014574587345123, -0.003834417322650552, 0.02610245905816555, 0.05929994955658913, 0.0068055372685194016, 0.03259526193141937, -0.0195095743983984, 0.023027224466204643, -0.0277248565107584, 0.016373099759221077, -0.008697498589754105, -0.05023486912250519, -0.04386620223522186, -0.048375342041254044, -0.00935135968029499, -0.006081684958189726, -0.04121078550815582, -0.0033363106194883585, -0.021676430478692055, 0.03705195337533951, -0.001233451534062624, 0.008593868464231491, 0.04314778000116348, 0.03462681546807289, -0.0003318052622489631, -0.05952011048793793, -0.010599604807794094, -0.027338434010744095, -0.007323551923036575, 0.04183987155556679, -0.0017884263070300221, -0.004338530357927084, 0.051132719963788986, -0.09068465977907181, 0.050155024975538254, 0.015597866848111153, 0.06367090344429016, -0.019452210515737534, -0.0068470872938632965, -0.03221286088228226, -0.02251138538122177, 0.030018329620361328, -0.0033930353820323944, 0.03453541547060013, -0.0009072624379768968, 0.05620303750038147, -0.04705195873975754, -0.05434525012969971, -0.03941325470805168, -0.07049442827701569, -0.00217430735938251, 0.016321729868650436, 0.03526180982589722, 0.03528226912021637, 0.020956536754965782, -0.04519753158092499, -0.002803961979225278, -0.029349317774176598, 0.031304292380809784, -0.03217041492462158, 0.004844134207814932, 0.034218478947877884, -0.04078693315386772, 0.012227999046444893, 0.014747493900358677, -0.01892818510532379, 0.03987681120634079, -0.011664513498544693, 0.006867453455924988, 0.009735952131450176, 0.06570473313331604, 0.0350826159119606, -0.009794607758522034, 0.01824379526078701, 0.04254072159528732, -0.00248967157676816, -0.001499169273301959, -0.03797554597258568, -0.01647832989692688, -0.008530376479029655, -0.022409703582525253, -0.01992586813867092, -0.0067179505713284016, -0.0648723840713501, -0.014510939829051495, -0.009799426421523094, -0.021354811266064644, -0.017389345914125443, -0.020143479108810425, -0.04089660942554474, -0.036837462335824966, -0.060576967895030975, -0.02312476933002472, -0.041040465235710144, 0.055516138672828674, -0.011716734617948532, -0.05358094349503517, 0.039401836693286896, -0.0005220255116000772, -0.007260751444846392, -0.018870364874601364, -0.015381098724901676, -0.023514335975050926, -0.04488784074783325, -0.005339111667126417, -0.05920318514108658, 0.020128799602389336, -0.011083969846367836, 0.05539897829294205, 0.02514994516968727, 0.018826168030500412, -0.020170705392956734, -0.03433215618133545, -0.022568069398403168, 0.02274656482040882, 0.06224675104022026, 0.00992104597389698, -0.039663247764110565, -0.0007916790782473981, -0.00965192262083292, -0.012838413938879967, -0.007103749085217714, 0.004216915927827358, -0.040230490267276764, 0.056714460253715515, -0.033700328320264816, -0.020072035491466522, -0.03737541660666466, -0.019198929890990257, 0.0551772266626358, -0.059830792248249054, -0.04163395240902901, -0.0010277758119627833, 0.03978871554136276, -0.009743740782141685, -0.06169355288147926, -0.02753768116235733, -0.0057535250671207905, -0.06743007153272629, -0.0073889619670808315, 0.02113829180598259, 0.019981181249022484, 0.03142985329031944, -0.027295289561152458, 0.011121505871415138, -0.05388329178094864, -0.011184435337781906, -0.018466629087924957, 0.049978237599134445, -0.01529315859079361, -0.020537350326776505, -0.042119577527046204, -0.07412949204444885, 0.020160865038633347, -0.07236026972532272, -0.04043223336338997, -0.0010254568187519908, -0.001953620696440339, -0.016574373468756676, 0.07611890137195587, -0.07636281847953796, 0.013966549187898636, 0.04405216872692108, 0.010203391313552856, 0.00032042342354543507, 0.06627187877893448, 0.004901733715087175, 0.061839696019887924, -0.021448304876685143, 0.019300909712910652, 0.009685086086392403, -0.041183795779943466, -0.03718570992350578, 0.017834661528468132, -0.014148483984172344, 0.007560571655631065, 0.056150998920202255, -0.009824678301811218, -0.051151905208826065, -0.005073985550552607, -0.007788983639329672, 0.003075513755902648, -0.015875108540058136, 0.03369288891553879, 0.029160117730498314, 0.009881657548248768, -0.031093066558241844, 0.0028822447638958693, -0.044273603707551956, -0.006986668799072504, 0.012766431085765362, -0.019672460854053497, -0.03287747502326965, 0.032821908593177795, -0.006092133931815624, 0.015848863869905472, 0.029637139290571213, -0.012365595437586308, -0.0022659043315798044, -0.027595778927206993, -0.011426353827118874, -0.02274252101778984, -0.013708549551665783, -0.050581131130456924, 0.027234172448515892, 0.03628282994031906, 0.04743007943034172, 0.015711236745119095, 0.04524664208292961, -0.046407900750637054, 0.02653130702674389, -0.030587099492549896, 0.007620318792760372, 0.013155192136764526, -0.0028167041018605232, 0.07145632803440094, -0.011033760383725166, 0.03136665001511574, -0.03813425824046135, 0.047701265662908554, 0.026651330292224884, 0.0005870627937838435, -0.024042462930083275, -0.04591228440403938, 0.0001182882915600203, -0.0194779634475708, -0.0364501029253006, 0.008724180050194263, 0.038355398923158646, -0.05436185747385025, 0.032103754580020905, 0.024036021903157234, 0.016372570767998695, -0.014614510349929333, 0.00881139375269413, -0.019081708043813705, -0.06830187886953354, 0.00047679117415100336, 0.05660519003868103, -0.06473474949598312, -0.05606764182448387, -0.011890795081853867, -0.015394417569041252, -0.01572910137474537, -0.06723335385322571, 0.05231674015522003, 0.013226778246462345, 0.0008844968397170305, -0.06560514867305756, 0.061585016548633575, 0.01179143413901329, -0.05284836143255234, 0.04354357719421387, 0.02379380352795124, -0.07942446321249008, 0.02026205137372017, -0.02575029619038105, 0.02446936070919037, -0.03978172317147255, 0.013001439161598682, -0.015391007997095585, -0.01602461189031601, -0.06812003254890442, 0.08279638737440109, 0.07265659421682358, -0.05093967169523239, 0.01443818025290966, 0.025662515312433243, -0.08373132348060608, 0.02158232592046261, -0.04374626278877258, -0.010472488589584827, 0.017926165834069252, -0.007590544410049915, 0.003593065543100238, -0.0332903154194355, -0.03679430112242699, 0.0015720633091405034, -0.02789335511624813, -0.03341691195964813, 0.02676781639456749, -0.0064785960130393505, 0.04219665005803108, -0.020233439281582832, -0.021393276751041412, 0.015129918232560158, -0.035806190222501755, 0.03195376321673393, -0.037614692002534866, 0.01610139198601246, -0.013810820877552032, 0.022750306874513626, 0.019804595038294792, -0.07427569478750229, 0.007414605468511581, -0.06172774359583855, -0.04812130704522133, 0.01746545545756817, -0.06281834840774536, 0.0011857738718390465, -0.020990638062357903, 0.024646997451782227, 0.041358936578035355, 0.030759839341044426, -0.05488540232181549, -0.010562518611550331, -0.015464995056390762, 0.01719477027654648, -0.031000303104519844, -0.01150707621127367, 0.06141326576471329, -0.016671370714902878, 0.057463161647319794, -0.05155264213681221, -0.029236793518066406, -0.0641009658575058, -0.029598718509078026, 0.02202639915049076, 0.012199259363114834, -0.03416009619832039, -0.026378292590379715, 0.037761539220809937, -0.02758069522678852, 0.02361997961997986, 0.007631194777786732, -0.043255195021629333, -0.0794464498758316, 0.00959873292595148, -0.006411869544535875, -0.026311354711651802, 0.05384714901447296, 0.04216969013214111, 0.048688728362321854, -0.04676763713359833, 0.03522380813956261, 0.02016063965857029, -0.004376744851469994, 0.035199739038944244, -0.05395328626036644, -0.029809802770614624, -0.03865716978907585, -0.002883746987208724, -0.03992585092782974, 0.019450416788458824, -0.026984116062521935, -0.05963307246565819, 0.020452439785003662, 0.07433481514453888, -0.020105410367250443, -0.055129524320364, -0.010325883515179157, 0.019354844465851784, 0.033128585666418076, -0.016478197649121284, -0.05067883059382439, 0.05025345832109451, 0.03249295428395271, -0.021107928827404976, -0.04667287319898605, -0.009550578892230988, -0.012049668468534946, 0.004440739285200834, -0.08980554342269897, 0.040619686245918274, -0.0005319729680195451, 0.07218345254659653, -0.03186890855431557, -0.0203498937189579, -0.034947630017995834, -0.035417117178440094, 0.0032813088037073612, 0.017961105331778526, 0.022919021546840668, -0.011424179188907146, 0.03561762347817421, -0.004265066236257553, -0.041932977735996246, -0.0345119833946228, 0.04251665994524956, 0.038329727947711945, 0.006345718167722225, -0.017927126958966255, 0.03280683234333992, -0.002086165128275752, 0.03201046958565712, 0.06924737244844437, 0.03006947971880436, 0.06866921484470367, -0.05033942684531212, -0.015150152146816254, -0.04363949969410896, -0.023461075499653816, 0.02892347238957882, -0.011926266364753246, -0.05108000710606575, -0.0007664979202672839, 0.017385438084602356, 0.03771054372191429, -0.015071609988808632, -0.0756717398762703, 0.014738311991095543, -0.01977677270770073, -0.03972269222140312, 0.04324532672762871, -0.04922118037939072, -0.03421657159924507, -0.0585014671087265, -0.00026494936901144683, -0.050924476236104965, 0.002803830662742257, 0.024245087057352066, -0.025020506232976913, 0.03687230497598648, -0.05570414289832115, 0.00524479802697897, -0.0034709826577454805, -0.0009922133758664131, -0.016997432336211205, 0.06306114047765732, -0.051496610045433044, -0.010566068813204765, -0.02425437793135643, -0.03131874278187752, -0.0072771105915308, -0.06939280778169632, -0.023860976099967957, -0.0097770094871521, 0.04341350123286247, -0.019485432654619217, 0.013633648864924908, -0.04045740142464638, 0.05087161809206009, 0.017698369920253754, -0.020329289138317108, 0.023548001423478127, 0.003351581981405616, -0.0388384610414505, 0.02328788861632347, 0.019971922039985657, -0.01594303734600544, -0.01957775093615055, -0.006929474417120218, -0.0052802469581365585, -0.029105307534337044, -0.008528392761945724, 0.022394774481654167, 0.03769620507955551, -0.05129383131861687, 0.02729124203324318, 0.010536609217524529, -0.0025421211030334234, -0.07474017888307571, -0.01847456395626068, -0.013414299115538597, -0.02772054262459278, -0.07555999606847763 ]
Despite the remarkable capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4, producing complex, structured tabular data remains challenging. Our study assesses LLMs' proficiency in structuring tables and introduces a novel fine-tuning method, cognizant of data structures, to bolster their performance. We unveil Struc-Bench, a comprehensive benchmark featuring prominent LLMs (GPT-NeoX-20B, GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Vicuna), which spans text tables, HTML, and LaTeX formats. Our proposed FormatCoT aids in crafting format-specific instructions from the intended outputs to populate this benchmark. Addressing the gap in task-centered evaluation, we propose two innovative metrics, P-Score (Prompting Score) and H-Score (Heuristical Score), to more accurately gauge LLM performance. Our experiments show that applying our structure-aware fine-tuning to LLaMA-7B leads to substantial performance gains, outshining its LLM counterparts across most measures. In-depth error analysis and creating an ability map across six dimensions -- coverage, formatting, reasoning, comprehension, pragmatics, and hallucination -- highlight areas for future enhancements and suggest forthcoming research trajectories. Our code and models can be found at https://github.com/gersteinlab/Struc-Bench.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08963v3
[ -0.02750994637608528, -0.034063950181007385, 0.06504528969526291, 0.004180933814495802, -0.0229911170899868, 0.004887586459517479, 0.018613968044519424, -0.027425525709986687, -0.005232229363173246, -0.006511087063699961, -0.050882626324892044, 0.041267476975917816, -0.07633499801158905, -0.015269707888364792, -0.06831309199333191, -0.024326883256435394, 0.06928963959217072, -0.01573878340423107, -0.018526142463088036, 0.0629040077328682, -0.021632015705108643, -0.004310427699238062, -0.06259293109178543, 0.05037807300686836, 0.05817955732345581, -0.01383552048355341, -0.03311147913336754, -0.03611494228243828, 0.05409177392721176, -0.017490485683083534, 0.0682256892323494, -0.018754949793219566, -0.01720864325761795, -0.04948655143380165, -0.003996401093900204, -0.0011829229770228267, -0.029750827699899673, -0.006079995073378086, 0.06615965813398361, -0.04988454282283783, 0.006369251292198896, -0.024014068767428398, -0.06418873369693756, -0.029157983139157295, -0.020207086578011513, 0.015317519195377827, 0.004960892256349325, 0.01851772889494896, -0.06277710944414139, -0.05502945929765701, 0.07770765572786331, -0.02936079539358616, -0.03091535158455372, 0.04909369722008705, -0.02712724730372429, 0.01245104894042015, -0.018610961735248566, -0.05477413907647133, -0.06386157125234604, -0.03826398029923439, 0.03736680746078491, -0.013628402724862099, -0.05325879901647568, 0.025278301909565926, 0.012446041218936443, -0.015795715153217316, -0.0021356146316975355, -0.04677673056721687, -0.007984655909240246, -0.06178220361471176, 0.05065234377980232, -0.054788894951343536, 0.007211990188807249, 0.015832828357815742, 0.0068973093293607235, -0.007507218047976494, -0.021304048597812653, -0.028630319982767105, -0.02539517730474472, 0.008705943822860718, -0.04605720937252045, 0.01219762023538351, -0.001888729864731431, -0.023324783891439438, 0.012853485532104969, -0.07434993982315063, 0.009581946767866611, 0.005129809956997633, -0.032250333577394485, -0.04074361175298691, 0.04121173918247223, -0.03152663633227348, -0.06410946696996689, -0.00883268378674984, 0.06965072453022003, -0.005760886240750551, 0.05413291975855827, -0.015072837471961975, -0.018899589776992798, -0.051252368837594986, -0.057311009615659714, -0.039040837436914444, -0.04574527218937874, 0.022179920226335526, 0.04911034181714058, 0.008163513615727425, -0.003383074188604951, -0.006797987036406994, -0.011224493384361267, -0.000917394703719765, 0.013149958103895187, 0.007588373031467199, 0.03238030895590782, -0.04341558367013931, -0.07350940257310867, 0.000506424403283745, 0.04023446515202522, 0.044976018369197845, -0.0361986979842186, 0.0015167577657848597, -0.015983272343873978, 0.02732907235622406, 0.0031429508235305548, -0.017659557983279228, -0.05620575696229935, -0.0631147027015686, 0.013625496998429298, -0.0025009955279529095, 0.02535620518028736, 0.00486628245562315, -0.0735550969839096, -0.023226391524076462, 0.046172142028808594, -0.035115379840135574, 0.0668940469622612, -0.03176456689834595, -0.04161975905299187, -0.05261727795004845, 0.06915176659822464, -0.013906107284128666, -0.07266228646039963, -0.08932492136955261, 0.044923536479473114, -0.013934453018009663, 0.020062195137143135, 0.06881086528301239, -0.02789800986647606, 0.005972171667963266, 0.009244040586054325, -0.0006275332416407764, 0.05116421729326248, 0.0007148230215534568, -0.045084621757268906, 0.05222482606768608, 0.039306506514549255, 0.046208687126636505, 0.02508501335978508, -0.027433278039097786, -0.05658790096640587, 0.027981750667095184, 0.009331178851425648, -0.041656773537397385, 0.04199475049972534, 0.008946185000240803, -0.01517549715936184, -0.011680452153086662, 0.032494042068719864, -0.034699518233537674, 0.014766082167625427, 0.03447410836815834, -0.03918126970529556, -0.018286842852830887, -0.018708599731326103, -0.027458729222416878, -0.07568535208702087, -0.03221278637647629, 0.01387834269553423, -0.02650591917335987, -0.04675424098968506, 0.006283103954046965, -0.015028790570795536, 0.0332852303981781, -0.046496834605932236, -0.0013192633632570505, -0.014049641788005829, -0.011891758069396019, -0.0776626393198967, -0.020809924229979515, 0.010031918063759804, 0.032631341367959976, -0.00634471932426095, 0.020039841532707214, 0.04089847952127457, 0.006075590383261442, -0.0575684979557991, -0.0389113686978817, 0.05312103033065796, -0.021354472264647484, 0.03233509138226509, 0.01742304302752018, -0.0965200662612915, -0.03850030526518822, -0.04852714017033577, 0.03234005346894264, -0.0014150270726531744, -0.07257145643234253, 0.008499512448906898, 0.04467994347214699, -0.02392067387700081, -0.0005798634374514222, 0.03061353601515293, 0.04449361935257912, 0.048207420855760574, -0.022321151569485664, -0.00009779748506844044, -0.0025011131074279547, -0.1008545458316803, 0.06660196185112, 0.01541251689195633, -0.01148917805403471, 0.006835682317614555, -0.006710737943649292, -0.022894959896802902, -0.04082122817635536, -0.025065772235393524, 0.021954549476504326, 0.05788308009505272, 0.007429660763591528, 0.000737353868316859, -0.008653263561427593, -0.03925352916121483, -0.04591823369264603, -0.028091520071029663, -0.062034230679273605, -0.005454640835523605, 0.03601820394396782, -0.03700738400220871, 0.03938570246100426, -0.009353790432214737, -0.043118469417095184, -0.01596195064485073, -0.01853577047586441, 0.023815248161554337, -0.030429145321249962, -0.057046305388212204, -0.028904112055897713, -0.030775850638747215, 0.0290568545460701, -0.015236997045576572, 0.0311571191996336, -0.040064312517642975, -0.039778128266334534, -0.003070067148655653, -0.024932486936450005, 0.04027961939573288, 0.0466204434633255, -0.0000684098995407112, 0.012267599813640118, -0.007973060943186283, 0.058005623519420624, 0.015598702244460583, 0.03454803302884102, -0.004328923765569925, 0.030522307381033897, 0.00011425313277868554, 0.005329151172190905, 0.0009548768284730613, -0.03131096810102463, 0.005323819350451231, 0.016864068806171417, 0.030706973746418953, 0.03172774240374565, 0.052052706480026245, -0.024122757837176323, -0.026147641241550446, 0.016117949038743973, 0.004872194025665522, -0.015083654783666134, 0.016369780525565147, 0.07814724743366241, 0.0445859432220459, 0.0025036002043634653, -0.013266805559396744, -0.07138022035360336, 0.0011986581375822425, -0.020284803584218025, -0.058819834142923355, -0.07590693980455399, -0.03537091985344887, -0.0034161414951086044, -0.03208662196993828, -0.04478941112756729, -0.020529616624116898, -0.05381322279572487, -0.035990431904792786, -0.04060819000005722, -0.03459801897406578, -0.017061475664377213, 0.0015814841026440263, -0.026218242943286896, -0.03620642051100731, -0.0344243161380291, 0.022998416796326637, 0.03180107846856117, -0.012614577077329159, -0.06465311348438263, -0.02814580127596855, -0.011242209933698177, 0.04072413593530655, -0.026492875069379807, -0.028253814205527306, 0.030436690896749496, -0.02919651009142399, 0.026747088879346848, -0.008837511762976646, 0.05610093101859093, -0.0075163873843848705, 0.041508592665195465, -0.006850328762084246, 0.035296425223350525, -0.013255602680146694, 0.016826357692480087, -0.025978337973356247, -0.0724787786602974, -0.04170377552509308, -0.01045467983931303, 0.048646267503499985, -0.05029306933283806, -0.02564135566353798, -0.019099613651633263, -0.005342933349311352, 0.02024436555802822, -0.0042910161428153515, -0.014516604132950306, 0.04979602247476578, 0.08051908016204834, -0.04171948507428169, -0.06052929162979126, -0.009328070096671581, -0.014774128794670105, 0.009691685438156128, 0.008720786310732365, -0.03170669451355934, -0.01579435169696808, 0.0644926205277443, -0.09209046512842178, 0.044198136776685715, 0.0765896663069725, 0.054564181715250015, -0.03232064098119736, 0.009428692981600761, 0.004855581093579531, 0.03277339041233063, 0.022352024912834167, -0.057466596364974976, -0.0004229371843393892, 0.07303590327501297, 0.034445349127054214, -0.025257596746087074, -0.014291009865701199, -0.003250723471865058, -0.06880950182676315, -0.02652141824364662, 0.001873072236776352, -0.004613558761775494, 0.034304458647966385, -0.01296925824135542, -0.07919781655073166, 0.011370956897735596, 0.02502843365073204, 0.03036722168326378, 0.04211295768618584, -0.01936478726565838, -0.022238578647375107, -0.03318669646978378, 0.05097930505871773, 0.013308970257639885, 0.008606377989053726, 0.02243562415242195, -0.02583167888224125, -0.013791156001389027, -0.06253979355096817, 0.03660925477743149, 0.046328429132699966, -0.030241601169109344, 0.054787635803222656, 0.044204406440258026, -0.003924969583749771, 0.036842770874500275, -0.033838167786598206, -0.012714201584458351, 0.005986262112855911, 0.015420611016452312, -0.03219764679670334, -0.0039109354838728905, -0.06216618791222572, -0.0030705502722412348, 0.03607336804270744, -0.004359436221420765, -0.05031899735331535, -0.0012484397739171982, -0.007689740974456072, -0.010541075840592384, -0.060138385742902756, -0.020577145740389824, -0.05190999060869217, 0.01938677951693535, -0.02907155081629753, -0.022336704656481743, 0.06788098812103271, -0.0050655389204621315, -0.03767858445644379, -0.01242916937917471, -0.005243237130343914, -0.04804162681102753, -0.027788478881120682, -0.018427738919854164, -0.055270083248615265, -0.0027525501791387796, -0.05640281364321709, 0.011416612192988396, -0.026520008221268654, 0.023985620588064194, -0.010587393306195736, 0.021354174241423607, -0.01454458199441433, 0.014023411087691784, 0.0498184859752655, 0.005447966977953911, -0.03249378502368927, 0.008628509938716888, 0.042392462491989136, 0.011497735977172852, -0.008607892319560051, -0.027177641168236732, -0.037550538778305054, -0.019423170015215874, -0.03932962194085121, -0.00827156100422144, -0.008929388597607613, -0.003851251909509301, 0.05859406664967537, -0.0177182424813509, 0.011097275651991367, 0.016610674560070038, 0.06199786067008972, -0.05202906206250191, -0.06624040752649307, 0.03179888054728508, -0.052572209388017654, -0.02205195650458336, -0.034138552844524384, 0.045950885862112045, 0.04760098457336426, -0.04913660138845444, 0.014855719171464443, -0.0027392362244427204, 0.0175158753991127, 0.0020472316537052393, 0.013613296672701836, 0.01289947610348463, -0.009661437012255192, -0.0054733240976929665, 0.002113312715664506, -0.07247638702392578, 0.006837173365056515, -0.04396151751279831, -0.012733682990074158, 0.010016124695539474, 0.03763163834810257, 0.005686483811587095, 0.06910919398069382, -0.07122094184160233, 0.01236006896942854, 0.019030431285500526, -0.03214816004037857, -0.0045766825787723064, 0.06301619857549667, -0.013119017705321312, 0.007284881081432104, 0.017425552010536194, -0.02057749405503273, 0.027819344773888588, -0.02957337722182274, 0.0040062833577394485, 0.009037917479872704, 0.006951579824090004, -0.02137506939470768, 0.0445520281791687, 0.06869661808013916, -0.03014068678021431, 0.010652139782905579, 0.04233567789196968, 0.05315940082073212, -0.010951210744678974, 0.06432736665010452, 0.04419442638754845, -0.027107367292046547, -0.04376573860645294, -0.006979076191782951, -0.0009832094656303525, -0.02526453323662281, -0.014526627957820892, -0.021229567006230354, -0.026713673025369644, 0.02648230642080307, -0.03142445161938667, -0.0108480891212821, 0.02177315764129162, 0.005152092780917883, -0.017970457673072815, -0.025304032489657402, -0.030220363289117813, -0.06869744509458542, 0.013341594487428665, -0.03838692232966423, -0.001898357761092484, 0.060192231088876724, 0.027896473184227943, 0.007675642147660255, 0.03121175616979599, 0.0011634111870080233, -0.013068520464003086, 0.011383083648979664, 0.0007333271205425262, 0.048338633030653, -0.012837857007980347, -0.012181206606328487, -0.04561430588364601, 0.027064163237810135, 0.031838949769735336, 0.03894811123609543, -0.014586351811885834, -0.003347603837028146, -0.023837663233280182, 0.031972091645002365, 0.017429625615477562, -0.03811800852417946, -0.03282769024372101, 0.021542958915233612, 0.048224762082099915, -0.03676587715744972, 0.03872198238968849, -0.004562607500702143, -0.001875919522717595, 0.030556613579392433, 0.07411697506904602, -0.005260259844362736, -0.05044780671596527, -0.002080147387459874, 0.03737751394510269, -0.039129093289375305, -0.02060951665043831, -0.01175035908818245, -0.05164885148406029, 0.013417604379355907, -0.048095304518938065, 0.03657403960824013, 0.014787285588681698, 0.00502536166459322, -0.05168711766600609, 0.05988750979304314, 0.010775831528007984, -0.07240736484527588, 0.049208495765924454, -0.021105224266648293, -0.09428956359624863, -0.011142653413116932, -0.025449693202972412, -0.017427552491426468, -0.0256080012768507, 0.012709006667137146, 0.00022317042748909444, -0.033284105360507965, -0.02363685518503189, 0.041755612939596176, 0.06748641282320023, -0.01819549687206745, 0.03277137875556946, 0.024126585572957993, -0.06475506722927094, 0.03168046101927757, -0.024749763309955597, -0.024966396391391754, 0.01596963033080101, 0.005929864011704922, 0.019065232947468758, -0.02268679253757, 0.02306937240064144, 0.04000584036111832, -0.047268643975257874, -0.03628917410969734, 0.044318754225969315, -0.024726087227463722, -0.03449413180351257, -0.0303894504904747, -0.015661703422665596, 0.004178898874670267, 0.023652223870158195, -0.03721187263727188, -0.08207514137029648, 0.014994896948337555, 0.003322400152683258, -0.00480165658518672, -0.04755748063325882, -0.06721299141645432, 0.024752862751483917, 0.0016041387571021914, -0.07263677567243576, -0.003579801879823208, -0.04000220447778702, 0.03452001139521599, 0.024134354665875435, 0.036904189735651016, 0.0015793251805007458, 0.013722788542509079, -0.0525064580142498, -0.034042052924633026, 0.0016507470281794667, -0.01902984268963337, -0.024534543976187706, -0.00487010832875967, 0.04570815712213516, -0.028702348470687866, 0.06368844211101532, -0.052623551338911057, 0.008749538101255894, -0.06439681351184845, -0.03156471624970436, 0.014866512268781662, 0.015939481556415558, -0.0002052331401500851, -0.05820869654417038, -0.001054891967214644, 0.009133952669799328, 0.017679737880825996, -0.03779679909348488, -0.05801049992442131, -0.0788547545671463, -0.009927150793373585, 0.020777348428964615, -0.05112903565168381, 0.028514422476291656, 0.025510573759675026, 0.02062661200761795, -0.006480323616415262, -0.019802242517471313, -0.02335331216454506, 0.03302495926618576, 0.03399626538157463, -0.04795380309224129, 0.018472159281373024, -0.014095797203481197, -0.026412274688482285, -0.023055072873830795, 0.0034243708942085505, 0.025876881554722786, -0.07882706075906754, -0.03531227633357048, 0.025452114641666412, -0.008265883661806583, -0.019706808030605316, -0.06415929645299911, 0.008807417936623096, 0.03788142278790474, -0.040007513016462326, -0.03177022188901901, 0.020474474877119064, 0.0059306020848453045, -0.02782507985830307, -0.0228401031345129, -0.0764661580324173, -0.03222410008311272, 0.036038484424352646, -0.07927541434764862, 0.012972538359463215, -0.005619395524263382, -0.0006227797130122781, 0.023925630375742912, 0.014523064717650414, -0.013013220392167568, -0.05594182759523392, 0.017375590279698372, -0.013901486061513424, 0.021457992494106293, 0.001311967265792191, -0.04205534607172012, 0.0238155797123909, -0.05295925959944725, 0.050137147307395935, 0.05151784420013428, -0.000645794440060854, -0.006095541641116142, -0.009030348621308804, 0.0002710359403863549, 0.02991032414138317, 0.00483289547264576, 0.07203670591115952, -0.00752101419493556, 0.03145257383584976, -0.05713704228401184, 0.03133711963891983, -0.05536522716283798, -0.03592323511838913, 0.0011110507184639573, -0.05005759745836258, 0.025153495371341705, 0.05456315726041794, 0.02190166339278221, 0.002017117105424404, -0.026026804000139236, -0.07251664251089096, -0.023205021396279335, -0.02164490893483162, -0.027210770174860954, 0.043644391000270844, 0.0015060803852975368, -0.030334535986185074, -0.031560834497213364, -0.030451403930783272, -0.03710392117500305, 0.011579020880162716, 0.021775005385279655, -0.052109189331531525, 0.023783985525369644, -0.07138688117265701, 0.049586422741413116, -0.02672281488776207, 0.012820049189031124, -0.05145860090851784, 0.0654621571302414, 0.03390605375170708, 0.010833930224180222, -0.013485747389495373, -0.028266582638025284, -0.03670215606689453, -0.06422334164381027, -0.027991773560643196, -0.05013563483953476, 0.022720076143741608, 0.015199058689177036, 0.01435837522149086, -0.049475107342004776, 0.04329478368163109, -0.038104116916656494, -0.005321620497852564, 0.015542097389698029, 0.047498077154159546, -0.009488965384662151, 0.07599304616451263, 0.0461866557598114, 0.013915066607296467, -0.03682985529303551, 0.019723303616046906, 0.026984810829162598, -0.060055576264858246, 0.012251119129359722, -0.035069357603788376, 0.04923400655388832, -0.033146634697914124, -0.0029315962456166744, -0.008641408756375313, -0.0219670869410038, -0.05849515646696091, -0.002458165865391493, -0.005738634616136551, -0.005900774151086807, -0.037249062210321426 ]
Fact-checking in financial domain is under explored, and there is a shortage of quality dataset in this domain. In this paper, we propose Fin-Fact, a benchmark dataset for multimodal fact-checking within the financial domain. Notably, it includes professional fact-checker annotations and justifications, providing expertise and credibility. With its multimodal nature encompassing both textual and visual content, Fin-Fact provides complementary information sources to enhance factuality analysis. Its primary objective is combating misinformation in finance, fostering transparency, and building trust in financial reporting and news dissemination. By offering insightful explanations, Fin-Fact empowers users, including domain experts and end-users, to understand the reasoning behind fact-checking decisions, validating claim credibility, and fostering trust in the fact-checking process. The Fin-Fact dataset, along with our experimental codes is available at https://github.com/IIT-DM/Fin-Fact/.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08793v2
[ 0.007778550963848829, -0.06725380569696426, -0.0025310537312179804, -0.011015607044100761, -0.07288065552711487, 0.0066565657034516335, -0.015356178395450115, -0.009008262306451797, -0.006819648668169975, -0.0021924427710473537, -0.07601768523454666, 0.025813141837716103, -0.07507640868425369, -0.05384368076920509, -0.016335543245077133, 0.028603166341781616, 0.08235238492488861, 0.036979664117097855, 0.024117538705468178, 0.022686999291181564, -0.04706297069787979, -0.04020441323518753, -0.023723281919956207, 0.03716445341706276, 0.06981544941663742, 0.0021307351998984814, 0.0009730954188853502, -0.038029056042432785, 0.026968352496623993, -0.0008323551737703383, 0.07833705097436905, -0.04740685224533081, -0.04841253533959389, 0.012578140944242477, 0.019492609426379204, 0.014483490958809853, 0.00843836273998022, -0.0380815789103508, -0.041638363152742386, 0.0009361893753521144, 0.06067119538784027, 0.0026603916194289923, -0.014182619750499725, -0.04211241751909256, -0.012354733422398567, -0.008486282080411911, -0.05011638253927231, 0.020041197538375854, -0.09768982231616974, 0.02795056253671646, 0.04068358242511749, -0.0021031200885772705, -0.011666402220726013, 0.04561000317335129, 0.003082981100305915, -0.008876761421561241, 0.00888251792639494, 0.008969302289187908, 0.0030434562359005213, 0.018243839964270592, 0.03981468081474304, 0.018811237066984177, 0.0077170031145215034, -0.013928836211562157, 0.0008392003946937621, -0.008408567868173122, -0.007158102001994848, -0.042829640209674835, -0.0028464391361922026, -0.024007832631468773, -0.00876057893037796, -0.030553821474313736, 0.025846363976597786, -0.010492716915905476, -0.004379264544695616, -0.008961266838014126, -0.010986745357513428, 0.003829560475423932, 0.002544908318668604, 0.05683440342545509, -0.019007062539458275, 0.02922087348997593, -0.01683151349425316, 0.011632213369011879, -0.003880793461576104, -0.0735417827963829, 0.0017866540001705289, -0.04983479157090187, 0.0033303513191640377, -0.021726060658693314, 0.020485831424593925, -0.02763587422668934, -0.08543162047863007, 0.022382322698831558, 0.061558473855257034, -0.005406706128269434, 0.01430660393089056, -0.04123733937740326, -0.0476255938410759, 0.01556340791285038, -0.05019967630505562, -0.020699193701148033, -0.012828892096877098, 0.0142440190538764, 0.029568416997790337, -0.00710347481071949, -0.0033351490274071693, -0.019088951870799065, -0.008983884938061237, 0.030036497861146927, 0.02383711189031601, 0.005717899184674025, -0.030567696318030357, -0.08237545937299728, -0.004609831143170595, 0.017445385456085205, 0.016029832884669304, 0.032434530556201935, 0.029391296207904816, 0.02633597142994404, 0.0072599793784320354, 0.02341022528707981, 0.03685798868536949, -0.03647336736321449, -0.04784372076392174, -0.03721768409013748, 0.008945268578827381, -0.009939339011907578, 0.026986248791217804, -0.022679636254906654, -0.05567985028028488, -0.022240448743104935, 0.019305676221847534, 0.015390678308904171, 0.029740523546934128, -0.017696315422654152, 0.03409026190638542, -0.03996380791068077, 0.042572736740112305, 0.019223378971219063, -0.04785800725221634, -0.06881634145975113, 0.03556782007217407, -0.048547375947237015, 0.03501715138554573, 0.04465898498892784, 0.005053170956671238, 0.0072531369514763355, 0.00842568464577198, 0.004287894815206528, 0.02642517350614071, -0.037861596792936325, 0.05111933499574661, 0.014521053992211819, -0.02495875023305416, -0.007519450969994068, 0.03641481697559357, -0.019113799557089806, 0.008178708143532276, 0.036252688616514206, 0.039610132575035095, -0.01787235029041767, 0.0316619798541069, -0.02932134084403515, -0.025446638464927673, -0.003813650691881776, 0.004024648107588291, 0.010090809315443039, 0.027481993660330772, 0.021911505609750748, -0.05732489377260208, 0.030374549329280853, -0.04201465845108032, -0.045308422297239304, -0.05168166756629944, 0.016348250210285187, -0.01038229838013649, -0.042316265404224396, -0.016976868733763695, 0.038666944950819016, 0.013332652859389782, 0.005146105773746967, -0.0077309561893343925, 0.0187363401055336, 0.0269864983856678, -0.0022125530522316694, -0.05037284642457962, -0.05992544814944267, -0.021511945873498917, -0.01269765105098486, -0.03895428031682968, -0.04141204059123993, -0.06594592332839966, -0.049811623990535736, -0.028792090713977814, 0.015919402241706848, -0.008253992535173893, 0.0049403076991438866, 0.020609160885214806, 0.03714004531502724, -0.08366569876670837, -0.04546523839235306, -0.07061717659235, 0.04662352055311203, -0.026051992550492287, -0.04938144236803055, -0.0435517355799675, 0.037047043442726135, -0.025429828092455864, 0.021375391632318497, 0.049802955240011215, 0.033930376172065735, 0.04732690379023552, -0.009368999861180782, 0.006124405190348625, -0.013460804708302021, -0.11107835918664932, 0.005826062988489866, -0.012411294505000114, 0.007777264341711998, -0.030824724584817886, 0.04576012119650841, 0.01648646593093872, -0.0006801565759815276, -0.022677693516016006, -0.011951060965657234, 0.030481411144137383, 0.005537501536309719, -0.013129137456417084, 0.003657458582893014, -0.05758696421980858, -0.03133518621325493, -0.017017774283885956, -0.02433851733803749, -0.04818706214427948, -0.03610830008983612, 0.035171039402484894, 0.01608177274465561, -0.04528350010514259, -0.025706985965371132, 0.014749502763152122, -0.044930025935173035, 0.04642695561051369, 0.031179126352071762, -0.02333519607782364, -0.026718176901340485, -0.014573294669389725, 0.0171519722789526, -0.02260972000658512, -0.014061874710023403, 0.025268033146858215, -0.08647642284631729, 0.024151049554347992, -0.03574429079890251, 0.029467443004250526, 0.014994287863373756, -0.02857755869626999, 0.02200928144156933, -0.000673535920213908, 0.04082454741001129, 0.03545151650905609, 0.05387064442038536, -0.057868968695402145, 0.05700840801000595, 0.04423079267144203, -0.02236648090183735, 0.03210364654660225, -0.030662372708320618, -0.01610282063484192, -0.006017590407282114, -0.006236807908862829, 0.030983954668045044, 0.030477283522486687, -0.05156741663813591, -0.06262123584747314, 0.023053530603647232, 0.022319266572594643, 0.007022592704743147, 0.031459562480449677, 0.08106204867362976, 0.056375958025455475, -0.004071213770657778, 0.03148467466235161, -0.056337520480155945, 0.04735053703188896, -0.05647557973861694, -0.00010340390872443095, -0.04416327551007271, -0.006209912244230509, 0.03839850053191185, -0.07048287242650986, -0.007758048828691244, -0.013255295343697071, -0.05054381117224693, -0.04391294717788696, -0.047020092606544495, -0.02480613812804222, -0.02642759680747986, 0.034666676074266434, 0.037056874483823776, -0.02839745581150055, -0.05132731795310974, -0.0013655528891831636, 0.007679746486246586, 0.03955458849668503, -0.05028567090630531, -0.04581587761640549, -0.013947849161922932, 0.04892801120877266, -0.058613937348127365, 0.032256290316581726, 0.026151521131396294, -0.029088249430060387, 0.03818773105740547, -0.052640315145254135, -0.02789941430091858, -0.028102926909923553, 0.01634923741221428, 0.013455884531140327, 0.00884158443659544, 0.002718112198635936, -0.024202173575758934, -0.030513526871800423, -0.020650314167141914, -0.04552731662988663, -0.07160510122776031, 0.05482872575521469, -0.0629429817199707, -0.006699841935187578, -0.004217976704239845, -0.03980870544910431, 0.015617480501532555, 0.03298941254615784, 0.0003822816361207515, 0.01285025104880333, 0.03393007814884186, 0.018792230635881424, -0.0728793665766716, 0.023979246616363525, -0.005323231220245361, 0.01872118189930916, 0.061113014817237854, -0.02617093175649643, 0.007468692492693663, 0.05386263132095337, -0.09096520394086838, 0.004824304487556219, 0.05223511531949043, 0.09042996168136597, 0.043182261288166046, 0.00830619502812624, 0.03796247020363808, 0.005323327146470547, 0.02726430632174015, 0.02583620510995388, 0.0017886178102344275, 0.07839693129062653, 0.01584627293050289, -0.04383508488535881, -0.04956724867224693, -0.0217838566750288, -0.030277300626039505, -0.03572691231966019, -0.01325485110282898, 0.031229248270392418, 0.01704464666545391, 0.05551581829786301, -0.026309533044695854, 0.0557461753487587, -0.008277762681245804, 0.07335478067398071, 0.052294712513685226, -0.010615774430334568, 0.0479738786816597, -0.05399589240550995, 0.07755307853221893, 0.016653625294566154, -0.012766462750732899, 0.041811566799879074, -0.05091187357902527, 0.05474729835987091, -0.024790454655885696, 0.028927234932780266, 0.05638175457715988, -0.026736486703157425, 0.04926042631268501, 0.055813807994127274, 0.007184721063822508, 0.05231589823961258, -0.03179125487804413, 0.015494969673454762, 0.023739203810691833, -0.0016209614695981145, -0.052988119423389435, 0.029589636251330376, -0.057561445981264114, -0.00908681284636259, 0.017972523346543312, -0.005884801037609577, -0.00962485559284687, -0.0302656851708889, -0.02604113705456257, -0.009350894950330257, -0.0507960170507431, 0.02516043558716774, -0.07225446403026581, 0.0587863065302372, -0.0199211947619915, -0.011376000009477139, 0.06389766186475754, -0.029574371874332428, -0.014431968331336975, 0.01398305594921112, -0.004989017266780138, -0.015629447996616364, -0.020344477146863937, 0.01765945553779602, -0.051725707948207855, 0.0013456263113766909, -0.04619796201586723, 0.05754120647907257, 0.007480474188923836, 0.028674358502030373, -0.009451556950807571, -0.000691011780872941, -0.03857605904340744, -0.0630270466208458, 0.0773288831114769, 0.028711294755339622, 0.001219320809468627, 0.0007388819940388203, 0.008016030304133892, 0.04357490316033363, 0.05487345531582832, -0.008262118324637413, -0.03443172201514244, -0.006322330329567194, -0.017210856080055237, 0.01824834756553173, -0.0001875935704447329, -0.041387103497982025, 0.041010353714227676, 0.02177593670785427, -0.02955000288784504, -0.011095767840743065, 0.0033224145881831646, -0.055399660021066666, -0.06335527449846268, 0.001836154144257307, 0.006708426401019096, 0.0017297500744462013, -0.03325028344988823, 0.06481891125440598, 0.023813096806406975, 0.020304102450609207, 0.014751940965652466, 0.02780170924961567, 0.029066618531942368, 0.0025495989248156548, -0.025853900238871574, 0.022919882088899612, -0.032866399735212326, -0.047230057418346405, -0.03483648598194122, -0.05984022468328476, -0.04402279853820801, -0.007741974201053381, -0.04590216279029846, 0.05838007107377052, 0.06743492186069489, 0.015679392963647842, 0.0664934515953064, -0.04308484122157097, -0.003507160348817706, 0.03892343491315842, -0.035405483096838, 0.04176969453692436, 0.04824461787939072, 0.03927860036492348, -0.011294590309262276, -0.05240331217646599, -0.005417234264314175, 0.023878101259469986, -0.0021306367125362158, 0.05763861536979675, -0.01077899057418108, 0.011281106621026993, -0.0279688760638237, 0.04875802993774414, -0.010945897549390793, -0.024548836052417755, 0.003625298384577036, 0.029901711270213127, 0.020346401259303093, 0.00008981244900496677, -0.016657410189509392, 0.018068013712763786, -0.005693337414413691, -0.02045183815062046, 0.020850175991654396, -0.01789540797472, 0.022771816700696945, -0.0009061766322702169, -0.05038709565997124, 0.04234878346323967, -0.0053353202529251575, -0.0061839609406888485, 0.03180291876196861, -0.017343048006296158, -0.01564992405474186, -0.01153385266661644, -0.018236152827739716, -0.014868912287056446, -0.03627365082502365, 0.03877490013837814, -0.009143810719251633, 0.05140599235892296, 0.08885731548070908, 0.07665116339921951, 0.04290025308728218, -0.027349604293704033, -0.02353910356760025, -0.0028295626398175955, 0.032434385269880295, -0.0394226536154747, -0.01971653290092945, -0.013490765355527401, -0.04252281412482262, -0.039490826427936554, 0.037498120218515396, 0.06127176061272621, 0.015460548922419548, 0.011467314325273037, 0.07342252135276794, -0.03333460912108421, -0.02722814492881298, 0.062099993228912354, 0.024501940235495567, -0.03934891149401665, 0.015571570955216885, 0.0607612170279026, -0.04689754918217659, 0.05175745114684105, -0.010228071361780167, -0.06099546328186989, 0.015594775788486004, -0.008706778287887573, -0.029748251661658287, -0.03014245070517063, -0.03497030958533287, 0.036846041679382324, -0.05576832965016365, 0.02956826239824295, -0.021096207201480865, -0.043263062834739685, -0.025056015700101852, -0.05872185528278351, 0.03551562875509262, 0.01584143377840519, -0.003311638720333576, -0.010544197633862495, 0.04688584432005882, -0.028423931449651718, -0.05685155838727951, 0.004512447863817215, -0.01810980960726738, -0.05786117538809776, 0.038721077144145966, 0.02415967360138893, 0.027625391259789467, -0.023200182244181633, 0.013768961653113365, -0.03474492207169533, 0.02551295980811119, -0.056213293224573135, 0.05584130808711052, 0.09588835388422012, -0.012917105108499527, 0.004905304871499538, 0.02906065620481968, -0.05153196305036545, -0.005060162860900164, -0.03439818322658539, 0.02724630944430828, -0.021076055243611336, 0.03519924357533455, -0.005166003480553627, -0.03263452649116516, -0.0203956700861454, 0.07638898491859436, -0.016354959458112717, -0.035579614341259, 0.03149619698524475, -0.04891922324895859, 0.008710445836186409, -0.056283287703990936, -0.031171642243862152, -0.044473838061094284, 0.000022826472559245303, -0.029140358790755272, -0.04290860891342163, -0.010720553807914257, -0.0363786406815052, -0.01925004832446575, -0.002462481614202261, -0.07413055747747421, 0.034675274044275284, 0.013808397576212883, -0.0765455886721611, -0.02067405916750431, -0.06019222363829613, -0.03221850469708443, 0.005946428515017033, 0.03723796829581261, 0.0346117727458477, 0.03730743005871773, -0.055378179997205734, -0.041908908635377884, 0.0338188111782074, -0.031233351677656174, -0.004652929957956076, 0.022406795993447304, -0.014218291267752647, -0.0400528647005558, 0.052650950849056244, -0.052394915372133255, -0.006790065672248602, -0.029316816478967667, 0.01945488154888153, 0.02581462264060974, -0.004826949443668127, -0.05548689141869545, -0.02276458591222763, -0.043870892375707626, -0.0074697318486869335, -0.024743851274251938, 0.05207620561122894, -0.06834301352500916, -0.019402388483285904, 0.0010003386996686459, -0.003456822130829096, 0.02739148773252964, 0.01116964966058731, 0.036523133516311646, 0.038434166461229324, 0.006438432261347771, 0.044263456016778946, 0.021838100627064705, 0.016482330858707428, 0.03674265369772911, -0.07739479839801788, 0.02111056074500084, 0.004812940023839474, -0.05277484655380249, 0.03463241085410118, -0.03472290560603142, -0.007370711769908667, -0.04928326606750488, -0.019887682050466537, -0.0024571530520915985, -0.007625087630003691, -0.014533983543515205, -0.06688831746578217, 0.040801625698804855, 0.004390286281704903, 0.018121803179383278, -0.04715520888566971, 0.03647743910551071, -0.037278179079294205, 0.02678840607404709, 0.006427987944334745, -0.00861414335668087, 0.00892106257379055, 0.011089790612459183, -0.05806706100702286, -0.022968560457229614, 0.04756448045372963, 0.03155051916837692, -0.010823268443346024, -0.05994578078389168, 0.013211873359978199, -0.039574071764945984, -0.0378316305577755, 0.015858352184295654, 0.05444277450442314, -0.022298885509371758, -0.02284010499715805, -0.02903304435312748, -0.01073059905320406, 0.02249956876039505, -0.013251528143882751, 0.0011968073667958379, -0.009716753847897053, -0.00408180570229888, 0.01107124611735344, 0.025345470756292343, -0.010837242938578129, 0.030149519443511963, -0.026532435789704323, 0.0367547832429409, -0.02251793071627617, 0.03724483773112297, 0.01053705345839262, -0.06285332888364792, 0.03614446148276329, -0.04771704971790314, -0.04119318351149559, -0.025568470358848572, -0.03107636608183384, 0.0027832144405692816, -0.03830588608980179, -0.0829881802201271, -0.039116498082876205, -0.004459361545741558, -0.03195304796099663, 0.036026567220687866, 0.0021177090238779783, 0.0431450679898262, 0.017884505912661552, 0.025425521656870842, -0.0622120127081871, -0.023953357711434364, -0.019056379795074463, -0.058659233152866364, 0.0020822593942284584, -0.037357304245233536, 0.02113509550690651, -0.019963936880230904, 0.026423437520861626, -0.03832171857357025, 0.06695433706045151, 0.022349316626787186, 0.005807681940495968, -0.0010252894135192037, 0.006349463947117329, -0.02589566446840763, -0.059838101267814636, -0.07699696719646454, -0.06779693812131882, 0.05185195431113243, 0.003527198452502489, 0.020083323121070862, 0.019906939938664436, 0.050718042999506, 0.016592953354120255, 0.044760990887880325, -0.010355383157730103, 0.0038588608149439096, -0.04671625792980194, 0.06631406396627426, 0.021720530465245247, 0.050878144800662994, -0.0047425986267626286, 0.013073726557195187, -0.04735376313328743, -0.016323577612638474, 0.04819219559431076, 0.00821084063500166, 0.03545573726296425, -0.05435070022940636, 0.01750786416232586, 0.01858498714864254, -0.06481541693210602, 0.008472402580082417, -0.036366112530231476, 0.05642199143767357, -0.0064267609268426895, -0.004168838728219271 ]
To easily obtain the knowledge about autism spectrum disorder and help its early screening and diagnosis, we create AsdKB, a Chinese knowledge base on autism spectrum disorder. The knowledge base is built on top of various sources, including 1) the disease knowledge from SNOMED CT and ICD-10 clinical descriptions on mental and behavioural disorders, 2) the diagnostic knowledge from DSM-5 and different screening tools recommended by social organizations and medical institutes, and 3) the expert knowledge on professional physicians and hospitals from the Web. AsdKB contains both ontological and factual knowledge, and is accessible as Linked Data at https://w3id.org/asdkb/. The potential applications of AsdKB are question answering, auxiliary diagnosis, and expert recommendation, and we illustrate them with a prototype which can be accessed at http://asdkb.org.cn/.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16773v2
[ 0.0007405396900139749, -0.05789339542388916, 0.05578793212771416, -0.005615396425127983, -0.04926377907395363, -0.012821516953408718, 0.02297770231962204, 0.022580979391932487, -0.03394552320241928, -0.025029610842466354, -0.012878447771072388, -0.02293027751147747, -0.05866405367851257, -0.04582199826836586, -0.007361330091953278, 0.018772363662719727, 0.05422373116016388, 0.03640500828623772, -0.06574177742004395, 0.04177385941147804, 0.014535547234117985, -0.02378561533987522, -0.013240289874374866, 0.007249988615512848, 0.055261362344026566, -0.03235664218664169, 0.02374710701406002, -0.04265280440449715, 0.006396281532943249, -0.022623294964432716, 0.07013732194900513, -0.039832137525081635, -0.02840634621679783, -0.002747334074229002, -0.0643390417098999, -0.03703634813427925, 0.022563045844435692, -0.022820638492703438, -0.041379015892744064, -0.048361506313085556, 0.003446572460234165, -0.06136765703558922, -0.0624547116458416, 0.02980026975274086, 0.012118172831833363, 0.02292848937213421, -0.033670827746391296, 0.021271226927638054, -0.06439592689275742, -0.00715797720476985, 0.022854844108223915, -0.031853944063186646, -0.020585428923368454, 0.06399358063936234, -0.0486462265253067, 0.012428763322532177, 0.0022134592290967703, 0.02591198869049549, -0.011381084099411964, 0.012861505150794983, 0.05985422804951668, -0.01593434438109398, -0.01192365400493145, 0.005550803616642952, 0.005320349242538214, -0.01311692874878645, 0.004381753038614988, -0.05321492999792099, 0.005999050568789244, -0.037432052195072174, 0.02825324609875679, -0.07548823207616806, 0.05604232847690582, -0.05004600062966347, -0.04126053303480148, -0.05187196657061577, -0.03828294202685356, 0.04875814542174339, 0.03871450200676918, -0.005356670822948217, 0.02469058521091938, 0.012396421283483505, 0.02039007470011711, 0.0412580743432045, 0.030893707647919655, -0.06461545825004578, 0.025217274203896523, -0.043790750205516815, 0.011480801738798618, -0.05776766315102577, -0.014817432500422001, -0.06271374225616455, -0.05713018774986267, -0.0025195623748004436, 0.05661299452185631, -0.004999830387532711, -0.03501726686954498, -0.02001582272350788, 0.005570059176534414, -0.018169930204749107, -0.04735039547085762, 0.02620703913271427, 0.043048955500125885, 0.037268493324518204, 0.010210885666310787, -0.03908120468258858, 0.015244921669363976, -0.03584503382444382, -0.013683700934052467, -0.01334737055003643, -0.023550700396299362, -0.024003546684980392, 0.009993679821491241, -0.0689736157655716, -0.03876043111085892, 0.00012455224350560457, 0.033326297998428345, 0.037528976798057556, 0.015904461964964867, 0.015142472460865974, -0.03182830661535263, 0.013318455778062344, -0.03236070275306702, -0.023758912459015846, -0.04028177633881569, -0.0006287613068707287, 0.001403352478519082, -0.0011135331587865949, -0.059606365859508514, 0.004500270821154118, 0.005605384707450867, 0.005410239566117525, -0.015756558626890182, 0.010575791820883751, 0.0018749104347079992, -0.04649197682738304, -0.008492449298501015, -0.04718995839357376, 0.023578200489282608, 0.03280656784772873, -0.04999788478016853, -0.04604204371571541, -0.041669029742479324, -0.04876329004764557, -0.026856591925024986, 0.03161461278796196, -0.034300658851861954, -0.04458373785018921, 0.02450428530573845, 0.022021036595106125, 0.000915980082936585, -0.04197676479816437, 0.03917975723743439, 0.006746615283191204, 0.00675478670746088, -0.044199589639902115, 0.05573512613773346, -0.03873651102185249, -0.022324424237012863, 0.021945420652627945, 0.02071985974907875, -0.010074902325868607, 0.03432901203632355, -0.03347701206803322, -0.018978014588356018, 0.035847149789333344, 0.047322653234004974, 0.004254328552633524, 0.024091556668281555, 0.04713244363665581, -0.006565224379301071, -0.022079668939113617, 0.004580280277878046, -0.024671077728271484, -0.06649031490087509, 0.01737392693758011, 0.0030788187868893147, -0.036220308393239975, -0.06660724431276321, -0.00908946804702282, 0.03806288167834282, 0.04948628693819046, -0.01139780692756176, 0.02881198562681675, -0.034522973001003265, -0.012348211370408535, -0.051003288477659225, -0.06315255165100098, -0.0084775909781456, -0.03620883449912071, -0.04417310282588005, -0.05955541506409645, 0.025308718904852867, -0.037350062280893326, -0.025306547060608864, 0.04414152354001999, -0.006424791179597378, -0.016479361802339554, -0.027461061254143715, 0.03134949505329132, -0.07174573093652725, 0.00649038702249527, -0.05048123374581337, 0.002562753390520811, -0.017817283049225807, -0.08087127655744553, -0.028150135651230812, 0.0012549407547339797, -0.05707148462533951, -0.006132499780505896, 0.0017500156536698341, 0.010525600053369999, 0.06589996814727783, 0.028600506484508514, 0.011272979900240898, 0.009479009546339512, -0.08844029158353806, 0.04174608364701271, -0.028538290411233902, -0.005393459927290678, 0.006069714203476906, 0.03404117748141289, 0.048856221139431, -0.004262793343514204, -0.02894657291471958, -0.027913706377148628, 0.00355049641802907, 0.011261739768087864, -0.05803248658776283, -0.028165223076939583, -0.03415580093860626, -0.07209598273038864, -0.023739846423268318, -0.03572414442896843, 0.005663659889250994, -0.020365865901112556, 0.006789880339056253, -0.04178538918495178, -0.010414152406156063, -0.042211465537548065, 0.0031737536191940308, -0.004893808159977198, 0.029497623443603516, -0.022513093426823616, -0.05185650289058685, 0.016286905854940414, -0.019834434613585472, 0.00008068689203355461, 0.020949555560946465, -0.020643198862671852, -0.0037862081080675125, -0.07557807862758636, 0.034270621836185455, -0.04219770058989525, 0.04449447616934776, 0.03492576256394386, -0.0034044450148940086, -0.009054332971572876, 0.011554858647286892, 0.05242364853620529, 0.05109121650457382, 0.03711043670773506, -0.06479835510253906, 0.021864119917154312, 0.038206372410058975, 0.0035231781657785177, 0.01338681485503912, -0.01585111953318119, 0.03781389817595482, -0.03504050523042679, 0.025456463918089867, 0.025697778910398483, 0.017634207382798195, -0.0710805281996727, -0.04125703498721123, 0.025957657024264336, 0.024873506277799606, -0.01136120967566967, 0.05201781913638115, 0.030830275267362595, 0.025040939450263977, -0.01348219346255064, 0.023220406845211983, -0.0672396719455719, -0.05021902918815613, -0.05999363958835602, -0.0420340821146965, -0.019812820479273796, -0.021634675562381744, -0.0026451689191162586, -0.03350090608000755, 0.019006267189979553, -0.011473630554974079, -0.01834760420024395, -0.03789239749312401, -0.06254356354475021, -0.06938900053501129, -0.048925772309303284, 0.006400314625352621, 0.03531001880764961, -0.05962114781141281, -0.032172441482543945, -0.014727215282619, 0.03376048803329468, -0.015117092989385128, -0.005561353638768196, -0.04485872760415077, 0.01414652168750763, -0.016469111666083336, 0.0016061936039477587, 0.037623416632413864, 0.04315807670354843, 0.017612263560295105, 0.0652712881565094, 0.028756234794855118, -0.03155486285686493, -0.011856457218527794, 0.061090972274541855, -0.052958641201257706, -0.008188256062567234, 0.046686429530382156, 0.0039541167207062244, 0.002323305932804942, -0.05380627512931824, -0.06526941806077957, -0.0507776103913784, 0.04740374907851219, 0.051207851618528366, -0.003879946656525135, -0.055086590349674225, 0.0017646978376433253, -0.03721221908926964, -0.0064719198271632195, 0.02787592075765133, 0.010573005303740501, 0.019779693335294724, -0.02841370552778244, -0.04111358895897865, 0.04849643260240555, 0.02210332825779915, -0.03264275938272476, 0.02543199248611927, -0.06175364926457405, -0.025600500404834747, 0.023661866784095764, -0.054362572729587555, 0.02157408371567726, 0.008621924556791782, 0.06625604629516602, 0.042032837867736816, 0.02948646992444992, 0.03702384978532791, 0.058201078325510025, 0.036111634224653244, -0.014089865610003471, 0.06694836914539337, 0.009894712828099728, 0.028166908770799637, -0.052338607609272, -0.019274601712822914, 0.04339412599802017, -0.0534980483353138, -0.050231851637363434, 0.029119007289409637, 0.006724151317030191, -0.032035794109106064, 0.03787730634212494, -0.0670773983001709, -0.0013722190633416176, 0.014206978492438793, 0.02016947977244854, -0.01636752486228943, 0.005319331772625446, -0.007109947502613068, -0.04190801456570625, 0.0615948885679245, -0.012684199027717113, -0.016412803903222084, -0.01868748851120472, -0.02602701634168625, 0.02163461223244667, -0.056103698909282684, 0.05301954597234726, 0.03694707900285721, -0.013279085978865623, -0.0016167410649359226, 0.0146204624325037, 0.01894580014050007, 0.039961934089660645, 0.005055019166320562, -0.010927870869636536, -0.06342481076717377, -0.010941551066935062, -0.07023801654577255, -0.02045033685863018, -0.04608998820185661, -0.029581326991319656, -0.02724066562950611, -0.021591050550341606, 0.02533147670328617, -0.028828894719481468, -0.025163784623146057, 0.029582303017377853, -0.06316404789686203, -0.03651881963014603, 0.01776616834104061, -0.0321384035050869, -0.021351158618927002, -0.05004081502556801, 0.0037687821313738823, 0.02688899077475071, 0.003593710483983159, 0.0491824597120285, 0.039578307420015335, -0.020691588521003723, 0.040710873901844025, 0.023864775896072388, -0.07409106194972992, -0.04003708437085152, -0.06658061593770981, -0.008952147327363491, 0.013066058978438377, 0.025937959551811218, -0.04838588088750839, 0.0350341871380806, -0.057475801557302475, -0.048426829278469086, 0.016966231167316437, -0.0013243522262200713, 0.012951681390404701, -0.03678591176867485, 0.005815303884446621, -0.030686739832162857, 0.04378088191151619, -0.03454862907528877, -0.048918768763542175, 0.021010974422097206, -0.014372598379850388, -0.052053384482860565, -0.04643082618713379, -0.06678736954927444, 0.03664015978574753, -0.003201394807547331, -0.038977280259132385, -0.03854715824127197, -0.05985534191131592, 0.001406933064572513, -0.018912846222519875, -0.05484597012400627, -0.07041777670383453, -0.06478425860404968, -0.012124191038310528, -0.0012764163548126817, 0.0031166451517492533, 0.012063851580023766, 0.024449076503515244, 0.01542647648602724, 0.02107034996151924, 0.03226369619369507, 0.009954093024134636, -0.006529845762997866, -0.04455552250146866, -0.052080780267715454, 0.019618598744273186, -0.04234110191464424, 0.0512770339846611, -0.02428295463323593, -0.008282303810119629, -0.02649092674255371, 0.039411742240190506, 0.017200404778122902, 0.061836618930101395, -0.06490403413772583, 0.05410568788647652, -0.01932249590754509, 0.011138924397528172, 0.007248410023748875, 0.05392274633049965, -0.007117349188774824, -0.020609484985470772, -0.028205793350934982, 0.02203838713467121, 0.0064691659063100815, 0.04044315218925476, 0.03810398653149605, -0.016184408217668533, 0.012489463202655315, -0.033754345029592514, 0.0688953772187233, -0.056535571813583374, -0.023847147822380066, 0.009897083975374699, 0.03406404331326485, 0.011161821894347668, -0.0662284716963768, 0.008850130252540112, 0.02676744945347309, -0.025748779997229576, -0.03459388017654419, 0.003927181009203196, -0.034987784922122955, 0.006966068409383297, 0.014068909920752048, -0.027752786874771118, -0.015542256645858288, 0.045243039727211, -0.026629488915205002, 0.03441205620765686, -0.04540057107806206, 0.012424778193235397, 0.05368359014391899, 0.05252741649746895, 0.03982027620077133, -0.033069126307964325, -0.027054516598582268, -0.053803473711013794, 0.03639081493020058, 0.03941018506884575, 0.04252129793167114, 0.04435834661126137, -0.06390319019556046, -0.008899266831576824, -0.012105843983590603, -0.0056507824920117855, -0.054120298475027084, 0.029092516750097275, -0.0543358288705349, 0.033394042402505875, 0.024478234350681305, 0.04281555116176605, 0.054064635187387466, 0.012152948416769505, 0.03848790004849434, -0.015512252226471901, -0.05269308388233185, -0.03107031248509884, -0.02179872803390026, -0.05189579725265503, -0.07390689104795456, 0.046890560537576675, -0.009819640778005123, -0.027259431779384613, 0.0244849044829607, -0.025657353922724724, 0.011364264413714409, 0.02781585603952408, 0.020846912637352943, -0.02540447935461998, -0.06425191462039948, 0.04938419163227081, 0.05196905508637428, -0.050761982798576355, 0.02875961922109127, -0.015613140538334846, -0.0008386524277739227, -0.03635292872786522, -0.03356452286243439, 0.020529910922050476, 0.052354440093040466, 0.039802759885787964, -0.029359988868236542, 0.06130421906709671, 0.007438307628035545, -0.05165581777691841, -0.010821165516972542, -0.05430488660931587, -0.07134465873241425, 0.02870899997651577, -0.021274199709296227, 0.052362971007823944, -0.04853072762489319, 0.026150720193982124, -0.03853193297982216, 0.030192935839295387, -0.06240983307361603, 0.03924575448036194, 0.06603646278381348, -0.002277318388223648, -0.01861744560301304, -0.008088715374469757, -0.021254396066069603, 0.018780961632728577, -0.0608946867287159, -0.024822603911161423, 0.017544249072670937, 0.0014903458068147302, 0.0040775262750685215, -0.013799763284623623, -0.04838813468813896, 0.042891886085271835, -0.023737752810120583, -0.019254522398114204, 0.0019350042566657066, -0.05653787776827812, 0.017203956842422485, -0.03832541033625603, -0.014300338923931122, -0.059399306774139404, -0.06631363928318024, -0.00712957326322794, 0.0038648247718811035, -0.025804638862609863, 0.009321870282292366, 0.028253229334950447, 0.020513933151960373, -0.025615977123379707, 0.016029249876737595, -0.007927747443318367, -0.049635451287031174, 0.04377814009785652, -0.06601082533597946, 0.02780952677130699, -0.0218814704567194, 0.04002971574664116, 0.019403772428631783, 0.04829319193959236, -0.033134303987026215, -0.025766804814338684, 0.03185240924358368, 0.0054229749366641045, -0.04616760462522507, -0.0009914854308590293, -0.01079940889030695, -0.022645441815257072, 0.00780066242441535, -0.03488738462328911, -0.05945436656475067, -0.03139417991042137, -0.0222413782030344, -0.010273711755871773, 0.00583031727001071, -0.021702950820326805, -0.0404396578669548, 0.031879574060440063, -0.02467636577785015, 0.011223026551306248, 0.05833273380994797, -0.07494752109050751, -0.02924734354019165, -0.01424764096736908, -0.05401582643389702, -0.003521422389894724, 0.014619443565607071, -0.01708320900797844, 0.03768021985888481, 0.024968918412923813, 0.055619653314352036, -0.04956069961190224, 0.04378914088010788, -0.006960954517126083, -0.07740241289138794, 0.04121559113264084, -0.04774746671319008, -0.006054059602320194, -0.06038926914334297, 0.004362981766462326, -0.056459832936525345, -0.06760185956954956, -0.026032740250229836, -0.002909275470301509, -0.03997145593166351, -0.00527450256049633, -0.05743958801031113, 0.0020653940737247467, -0.005068582948297262, 0.021633950993418694, -0.0094870300963521, 0.020948847755789757, -0.0613766647875309, -0.03269631043076515, -0.030253736302256584, -0.03579216077923775, -0.031381990760564804, 0.05002766102552414, -0.053661081939935684, 0.0069299363531172276, 0.008064636960625648, 0.04760367423295975, 0.02892293408513069, 0.035263121128082275, 0.0428793802857399, -0.043444711714982986, -0.029896855354309082, -0.04052137956023216, -0.010966893285512924, -0.03628528118133545, -0.04312235862016678, 0.020487941801548004, -0.04404231160879135, -0.03853989019989967, -0.017016027122735977, -0.04480905830860138, -0.05622592940926552, -0.009593876078724861, 0.029320748522877693, -0.023526379838585854, 0.029764195904135704, -0.004811453633010387, -0.025724399834871292, -0.005572405178099871, -0.03610527515411377, 0.05857044830918312, -0.05482392758131027, -0.01850298047065735, -0.0024047824554145336, -0.03695477545261383, -0.013907660730183125, -0.027581753209233284, -0.06198665499687195, 0.0009971796534955502, -0.06973825395107269, -0.07468459755182266, 0.011889774352312088, -0.018633484840393066, 0.039564888924360275, 0.08270866423845291, 0.006069996859878302, -0.016357343643903732, -0.033011917024850845, -0.020698565989732742, -0.05107772722840309, -0.006925058085471392, 0.004976582247763872, -0.0688471645116806, -0.018846698105335236, -0.04239431023597717, -0.02189313806593418, -0.020051902160048485, 0.0007060755742713809, -0.043526578694581985, 0.02936563268303871, 0.024909522384405136, -0.01655110903084278, -0.005215809214860201, 0.01500964816659689, -0.039493218064308167, -0.02376195229589939, -0.03825424611568451, -0.030343126505613327, 0.0450667068362236, -0.03205636143684387, 0.00131272675935179, 0.025979572907090187, 0.06973586976528168, 0.0110987713560462, 0.04174238070845604, 0.0439961738884449, -0.0023383265361189842, 0.018238628283143044, 0.04842542111873627, 0.005803195293992758, 0.012099036015570164, -0.02109607495367527, -0.016852539032697678, -0.019475968554615974, 0.009421848691999912, 0.07095052301883698, 0.002933317795395851, -0.003873610869050026, -0.06516606360673904, -0.01862427219748497, 0.00552103016525507, -0.0525265708565712, -0.031177211552858353, -0.023816941305994987, 0.025758283212780952, -0.01568974182009697, -0.03978642821311951 ]
Agent-based modeling (ABM) and simulation have emerged as important tools for studying emergent behaviors, especially in the context of swarming algorithms for robotic systems. Despite significant research in this area, there is a lack of standardized simulation environments, which hinders the development and deployment of real-world robotic swarms. To address this issue, we present Zespol, a modular, Python-based simulation environment that enables the development and testing of multi-agent control algorithms. Zespol provides a flexible and extensible sandbox for initial research, with the potential for scaling to real-world applications. We provide a topological overview of the system and detailed descriptions of its plug-and-play elements. We demonstrate the fidelity of Zespol in simulated and real-word robotics by replicating existing works highlighting the simulation to real gap with the milling behavior. We plan to leverage Zespol's plug-and-play feature for neuromorphic computing in swarming scenarios, which involves using the modules in Zespol to simulate the behavior of neurons and their connections as synapses. This will enable optimizing and studying the emergent behavior of swarm systems in complex environments. Our goal is to gain a better understanding of the interplay between environmental factors and neural-like computations in swarming systems.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17744v1
[ -0.038702234625816345, -0.021210888400673866, 0.06618072092533112, 0.031054222956299782, 0.032941050827503204, -0.0024907507468014956, 0.0016318332636728883, -0.0020198985002934933, 0.01264029461890459, -0.057529255747795105, -0.02821805328130722, 0.02799270488321781, -0.03888927400112152, -0.07459007203578949, -0.03640713915228844, 0.01625414565205574, 0.058771368116140366, 0.02194134332239628, -0.024685367941856384, 0.057077404111623764, 0.01565934345126152, -0.02964644506573677, -0.05498329550027847, -0.020057568326592445, -0.026965875178575516, -0.009783736430108547, 0.03554904833436012, 0.0036983939353376627, -0.05987720191478729, -0.019246108829975128, 0.06579449772834778, -0.03937363252043724, -0.023442363366484642, 0.022549383342266083, -0.03349471092224121, -0.015968315303325653, -0.025756822898983955, 0.026605485007166862, 0.046050168573856354, -0.00040154284215532243, 0.051841024309396744, 0.01841682754456997, -0.0691191777586937, 0.02538846991956234, -0.002819596789777279, -0.011494386941194534, -0.06894965469837189, 0.035458724945783615, -0.0778808444738388, -0.06552383303642273, 0.00015102719771675766, -0.0004707339103333652, 0.03538301959633827, 0.0700250118970871, -0.06915493309497833, 0.006106099113821983, -0.004875614773482084, 0.018509766086935997, -0.053734105080366135, 0.017758311703801155, 0.0029951268807053566, -0.03411339968442917, -0.0017507701413705945, -0.03342699259519577, 0.047234874218702316, 0.06493467837572098, -0.005191099364310503, -0.020409561693668365, -0.044547468423843384, -0.019953090697526932, 0.036167971789836884, -0.07075147330760956, -0.02899390459060669, -0.00032916845520958304, -0.027214543893933296, -0.017237121239304543, 0.024079704657197, -0.03261026367545128, -0.006968418136239052, 0.05132332444190979, -0.056422822177410126, 0.015236656181514263, 0.0769963189959526, 0.04231585934758186, 0.014231926761567593, -0.001841043820604682, 0.03144129738211632, -0.035354357212781906, 0.04163584113121033, -0.0014089529868215322, 0.05692511051893234, -0.0025711781345307827, -0.07112130522727966, 0.047136466950178146, 0.08182023465633392, -0.01622115448117256, 0.031866494566202164, 0.026260094717144966, 0.032330211251974106, 0.004650138784199953, -0.046514011919498444, 0.028700513765215874, -0.0121579859405756, 0.062214337289333344, 0.019218917936086655, -0.0547407828271389, 0.001809846144169569, -0.012532315216958523, -0.02529289945960045, -0.02145174704492092, -0.048400696367025375, -0.03526794910430908, 0.012477989308536053, -0.08485676348209381, -0.035714782774448395, -0.02454540878534317, 0.0328383669257164, -0.026562592014670372, 0.04002988710999489, 0.02958792820572853, -0.03012552298605442, 0.06917709857225418, 0.0013709376798942685, -0.021135592833161354, 0.0007485445821657777, -0.035063549876213074, 0.05716531351208687, 0.036711644381284714, -0.0629696324467659, -0.03553671017289162, 0.0006620441563427448, 0.010519937612116337, -0.02121138572692871, -0.055495284497737885, 0.0658775120973587, -0.045173924416303635, -0.00046349072363227606, -0.05678434669971466, -0.016737325116991997, -0.07717613130807877, -0.039986927062273026, -0.05915778502821922, 0.020478826016187668, -0.0262710303068161, 0.03656904399394989, 0.03165678679943085, -0.0401138998568058, -0.02388923242688179, 0.00012020086433039978, -0.0013128933496773243, 0.023852001875638962, -0.012823921628296375, 0.022334545850753784, 0.02140308916568756, 0.0346294529736042, -0.028485318645834923, 0.040250252932310104, -0.04861526936292648, -0.04470677673816681, -0.022333916276693344, 0.03946623206138611, 0.010702802799642086, 0.004006572533398867, -0.01655622199177742, -0.028110016137361526, -0.018887950107455254, 0.0030065197497606277, -0.029978198930621147, -0.03315882384777069, -0.00645214831456542, -0.036033593118190765, 0.012403001077473164, 0.015722110867500305, -0.034642916172742844, -0.03642110899090767, -0.031692057847976685, 0.02001182921230793, -0.061558205634355545, -0.04411045089364052, 0.016128912568092346, 0.03557486832141876, 0.03499622270464897, -0.04478146508336067, 0.01551268994808197, -0.03984202817082405, 0.026871295645833015, -0.0791844055056572, -0.057821858674287796, 0.060678377747535706, 0.04360437020659447, -0.04275483638048172, -0.06554627418518066, 0.03568587824702263, 0.025094030424952507, -0.05647481977939606, -0.00908834207803011, -0.018731873482465744, -0.0321979783475399, 0.024379312992095947, 0.0213936697691679, -0.09446517378091812, 0.0021865726448595524, -0.03677774593234062, -0.021674780175089836, 0.0060828556306660175, -0.04952108487486839, 0.024368198588490486, 0.03429876267910004, -0.038396939635276794, -0.0028205490671098232, 0.028673464432358742, -0.015884792432188988, 0.08008818328380585, 0.006097810808569193, 0.02802051603794098, 0.024318479001522064, -0.1118946224451065, 0.05323990806937218, 0.04600093886256218, -0.013384083285927773, 0.04180683195590973, 0.007552476599812508, 0.019614387303590775, -0.0006577707827091217, -0.03034227527678013, 0.038442738354206085, 0.05445936694741249, -0.009708414785563946, -0.02541438862681389, -0.021695604547858238, -0.019348371773958206, -0.039125509560108185, -0.007147769909352064, -0.052800316363573074, -0.04477376863360405, -0.020932195708155632, -0.02344651147723198, 0.03530332073569298, 0.02978762611746788, -0.0035804251674562693, -0.06020519882440567, -0.04070829972624779, 0.03730092942714691, -0.05686971917748451, -0.025689706206321716, -0.04607393965125084, -0.03238867223262787, 0.048204436898231506, -0.032394107431173325, 0.007851674221456051, -0.014936289750039577, -0.016233254224061966, -0.008633839897811413, -0.03504136577248573, 0.03724149614572525, 0.06119101867079735, -0.026441549882292747, 0.018006065860390663, 0.0010866463417187333, 0.05785396322607994, 0.03641149401664734, 0.0066307890228927135, -0.051674310117959976, -0.014412648975849152, 0.04678301885724068, 0.020700596272945404, -0.032576534897089005, -0.029915452003479004, 0.02712789736688137, -0.04820050299167633, 0.008391201496124268, 0.017596395686268806, 0.06300508230924606, -0.030583973973989487, -0.0222832802683115, -0.0030493487138301134, 0.001797224278561771, 0.026414766907691956, 0.022503890097141266, 0.0614747628569603, 0.057118285447359085, -0.00900738500058651, 0.016850918531417847, -0.061924561858177185, -0.03155239671468735, -0.025384806096553802, -0.0011820514919236302, -0.0635284036397934, -0.020772913470864296, -0.012344585731625557, -0.07061624526977539, 0.021026702597737312, -0.021012065932154655, -0.019534364342689514, -0.025655414909124374, -0.050027020275592804, -0.002337022917345166, -0.015641996636986732, 0.016919972375035286, -0.02228141762316227, -0.0456327386200428, -0.013837163336575031, 0.012760214507579803, 0.05218606814742088, 0.010110104456543922, -0.05480814352631569, -0.0183429978787899, -0.008485370315611362, 0.011132159270346165, 0.03877859562635422, -0.016688937321305275, 0.07101693749427795, -0.019952330738306046, 0.011758671142160892, -0.006852120626717806, 0.05068916827440262, 0.024998018518090248, 0.048674821853637695, 0.0008143024169839919, -0.01217613648623228, 0.000996581045910716, 0.0026868279092013836, -0.006064767949283123, -0.008856910280883312, -0.058169811964035034, 0.024930525571107864, 0.05381812900304794, 0.00994478352367878, -0.05798004940152168, -0.015693502500653267, 0.023608550429344177, 0.0038969649467617273, 0.011967841535806656, 0.020662391558289528, 0.03767215088009834, 0.033588189631700516, 0.002424391685053706, -0.04006604850292206, 0.015384103171527386, 0.015672920271754265, -0.010515887290239334, 0.0206935815513134, -0.04848793148994446, -0.05451174080371857, 0.05125920847058296, -0.09552846848964691, 0.017484962940216064, 0.0432959720492363, 0.056597866117954254, -0.021072885021567345, 0.009242682717740536, -0.00032371250563301146, 0.04143522307276726, 0.028867390006780624, 0.011204699985682964, 0.04921712726354599, 0.046313878148794174, 0.03976527228951454, -0.035723619163036346, -0.033803485333919525, -0.0023639581631869078, -0.09193116426467896, -0.03722700476646423, 0.028042037039995193, 0.033720262348651886, 0.014188477769494057, 0.02145994082093239, -0.07309071719646454, -0.006247173994779587, 0.007361981552094221, 0.03638928011059761, -0.011723075062036514, -0.03620859235525131, 0.010035944171249866, -0.03265249729156494, 0.022764988243579865, -0.01614907756447792, -0.003408139804378152, -0.044060565531253815, -0.030480777844786644, 0.027385445311665535, -0.06670130789279938, 0.04725281521677971, 0.024919608607888222, -0.026412591338157654, 0.01260323729366064, -0.008242310956120491, -0.011136949993669987, 0.07399923354387283, -0.037512440234422684, -0.03988117724657059, 0.020940113812685013, -0.032013460993766785, 0.02294686809182167, -0.033259037882089615, -0.035735633224248886, 0.009955078363418579, -0.020257696509361267, -0.039681386202573776, 0.017162024974822998, 0.0012242577504366636, -0.014170734211802483, -0.0208420567214489, -0.08642503619194031, -0.032991934567689896, -0.012209968641400337, 0.017820924520492554, 0.04511011764407158, -0.012053102254867554, 0.03713158145546913, -0.03957187384366989, -0.030866246670484543, 0.009738730266690254, -0.040358614176511765, -0.04504118859767914, -0.007548680063337088, -0.009542773477733135, -0.05905834212899208, 0.03245675191283226, -0.05781792104244232, 0.028328603133559227, -0.04100918024778366, 0.05392207205295563, -0.036686040461063385, 0.020726893097162247, 0.0137048764154315, 0.039365075528621674, 0.027028286829590797, 0.0035257902927696705, 0.014380816370248795, -0.04230371117591858, 0.028349105268716812, -0.01156394649296999, 0.014242468401789665, 0.008358954451978207, -0.053545575588941574, 0.038918402045965195, -0.05101102963089943, -0.044313497841358185, 0.012338241562247276, -0.001237130374647677, 0.06311290711164474, 0.014534927904605865, 0.009078842587769032, -0.03842424228787422, 0.0500686876475811, -0.024895116686820984, -0.05596243217587471, -0.05890811234712601, -0.053061697632074356, -0.048835813999176025, -0.02114028111100197, 0.038318049162626266, 0.009917969815433025, -0.0010559221263974905, 0.008196631446480751, -0.010685406625270844, 0.04808613657951355, -0.005429649725556374, -0.021758362650871277, 0.008043905720114708, -0.0166108887642622, 0.05653604492545128, -0.025437604635953903, -0.039804354310035706, 0.04000542685389519, 0.0007433494320139289, -0.012039885856211185, -0.03044145740568638, 0.03936260566115379, 0.009182232432067394, 0.038389235734939575, -0.10038022696971893, 0.04020588472485542, 0.07374738901853561, -0.0016462960047647357, -0.003034989582374692, 0.045118510723114014, -0.010309644974768162, -0.0054039196111261845, -0.05271819978952408, -0.00532140675932169, 0.0013449961552396417, 0.03132430091500282, 0.0031472896225750446, 0.009789283387362957, -0.015505248680710793, 0.01315777376294136, 0.052411358803510666, -0.007119863759726286, -0.057906296104192734, 0.030853813514113426, 0.03537324443459511, 0.04857226461172104, -0.03275908902287483, 0.04622571915388107, 0.029508477076888084, -0.030018839985132217, 0.0007410264224745333, -0.02257133089005947, 0.02226307988166809, -0.01677178591489792, 0.0244586318731308, -0.01968580298125744, -0.005625296849757433, 0.03813784942030907, -0.03553498163819313, 0.03083089180290699, 0.017135493457317352, 0.033896803855895996, 0.007412532810121775, -0.011344953440129757, 0.015014683827757835, -0.053806617856025696, -0.0001852044224506244, -0.034378014504909515, -0.0038693384267389774, 0.02005336433649063, 0.017478417605161667, -0.00581196416169405, 0.03690445423126221, -0.020557358860969543, 0.016808761283755302, -0.032821811735630035, 0.011861392296850681, 0.018215080723166466, -0.035157084465026855, 0.026802554726600647, 0.003953351639211178, 0.002755610505118966, 0.0013920426135882735, 0.023528022691607475, 0.006844182964414358, -0.001410441822372377, -0.061015862971544266, -0.02573513425886631, 0.012102125212550163, -0.05840576812624931, -0.0032541656401008368, 0.020435435697436333, 0.0043216487392783165, 0.011258143931627274, 0.021076852455735207, 0.06066117435693741, 0.04804660379886627, 0.04465869441628456, -0.003842409932985902, -0.017784854397177696, -0.06014672666788101, -0.0008823080570437014, 0.07767310738563538, -0.0342780239880085, 0.012751190923154354, -0.05163748562335968, -0.038128361105918884, 0.033796653151512146, -0.04029984772205353, 0.011487357318401337, 0.046764224767684937, 0.0216323584318161, -0.03976988419890404, 0.032656919211149216, 0.04252978414297104, -0.07353545725345612, 0.037537917494773865, -0.0018942932365462184, -0.07530360668897629, 0.00381683511659503, 0.07375524193048477, -0.003135108156129718, -0.033487360924482346, 0.05412190407514572, 0.02936551719903946, 0.004334659315645695, -0.022709157317876816, 0.04619099199771881, 0.08134742826223373, 0.00401704479008913, 0.02838539518415928, -0.002563700545579195, -0.019719820469617844, 0.009576348587870598, -0.05156645178794861, -0.01442248560488224, 0.00891249068081379, 0.009635050781071186, 0.03451940789818764, -0.047528285533189774, 0.01577448844909668, 0.04484129324555397, -0.0017753124702721834, -0.03061814047396183, 0.015066142193973064, 0.021753069013357162, 0.03217476233839989, -0.031254399567842484, -0.0320039801299572, -0.006626369431614876, -0.004434978123754263, -0.05019591748714447, -0.07001656293869019, -0.020244864746928215, 0.0069494531489908695, 0.024792078882455826, 0.01589273288846016, -0.037516266107559204, -0.052417509257793427, -0.057518377900123596, -0.07023226469755173, 0.028720494359731674, -0.039372678846120834, -0.02004936710000038, -0.01960354670882225, -0.035606224089860916, 0.04690762236714363, 0.04601147770881653, -0.040963586419820786, -0.031419962644577026, -0.006797716952860355, 0.03178340196609497, 0.007121822331100702, -0.017065268009901047, -0.013213243335485458, -0.0006769270403310657, 0.05796503275632858, -0.0166059210896492, -0.036933209747076035, -0.008343657478690147, -0.07020276039838791, 0.008365772664546967, -0.02242158353328705, -0.019755233079195023, -0.024046722799539566, 0.00988429132848978, 0.0038242714945226908, 0.0028714253567159176, -0.007924212142825127, -0.04265759512782097, -0.02031182311475277, 0.030736738815903664, 0.016025537624955177, 0.01422830019146204, 0.0003992098500020802, 0.0421234592795372, 0.055089354515075684, -0.029732368886470795, 0.029839837923645973, 0.01865062490105629, 0.017547478899359703, 0.009118758141994476, -0.04323536902666092, -0.015722721815109253, 0.026198741048574448, 0.0423935241997242, -0.07085779309272766, -0.03913448378443718, -0.02772504650056362, -0.070521779358387, -0.011433852836489677, 0.05102911591529846, -0.05270741507411003, 0.025672540068626404, -0.06246079504489899, 0.0358593724668026, -0.0018025458557531238, -0.06989863514900208, -0.06391781568527222, -0.024130450561642647, 0.014285673387348652, -0.04930133372545242, 0.04748902842402458, -0.009412422776222229, -0.02691146358847618, 0.012353918515145779, -0.08744805306196213, -0.01382824033498764, -0.008205312304198742, 0.025579197332262993, 0.01905224844813347, -0.033782973885536194, -0.002349379239603877, 0.0033918784465640783, -0.01944201998412609, 0.014260548166930676, 0.00988073367625475, 0.0004999967059120536, 0.0359753742814064, 0.015498784370720387, -0.05250166356563568, -0.023446129634976387, 0.06459242105484009, -0.0029883701354265213, -0.021526848897337914, 0.042033709585666656, -0.00409091217443347, 0.034810978919267654, -0.026234665885567665, 0.04558587446808815, -0.0004016788734588772, 0.05291500687599182, -0.048636358231306076, 0.00041690701618790627, -0.05636846646666527, -0.03943054378032684, 0.05574290081858635, -0.031419962644577026, 0.0039089214988052845, 0.023676397278904915, 0.019968276843428612, 0.026494445279240608, -0.014449356123805046, -0.05168319493532181, 0.06727410852909088, 0.0006317166844382882, -0.018299579620361328, 0.05654751509428024, -0.05274224281311035, 0.01298413798213005, -0.028188694268465042, 0.026821283623576164, -0.004468726459890604, 0.06448693573474884, 0.04353742673993111, -0.032364532351493835, 0.03568772226572037, -0.07676935940980911, -0.0024747452698647976, 0.006980461068451405, 0.03210516646504402, -0.03437557816505432, 0.06806562095880508, -0.020460274070501328, 0.006651066709309816, -0.037066295742988586, -0.044990673661231995, 0.000256378116318956, -0.07808248698711395, -0.035308171063661575, 0.00011015756172128022, 0.03645673021674156, 0.00882759690284729, -0.017261484637856483, -0.014588529244065285, 0.045453041791915894, 0.012248612008988857, 0.018853649497032166, 0.012514394707977772, 0.017511414363980293, -0.056662511080503464, 0.052326541393995285, 0.007827915251255035, 0.021213501691818237, -0.018470091745257378, 0.030462544411420822, -0.00017431151354685426, -0.010928280651569366, -0.04853108152747154, -0.013373592868447304, -0.00043187534902244806, -0.018571434542536736, -0.016315864399075508, 0.0757054015994072, 0.020986422896385193, -0.020223122090101242, 0.004872049670666456, 0.014255213551223278, -0.011943451128900051, -0.04858146607875824 ]
We study the gravitational bremsstrahlung owing to collisions mediated by a $1/r$ potential. We combine classical and first order Born approximation results in order to construct an approximate gravitational `Gaunt factor' for the total emitted energy. We also obtain the cross-section with an angular momentum cut-off, and hence the cross-section for emission via close hyperbolic encounters in a gravitating cluster. These effects are the dominant source of very high frequency gravitational noise in the solar system. The total gravitational wave power of the Sun is $76\pm 20\,$MW.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06972v2
[ -0.04504477232694626, -0.05669631063938141, -0.020052984356880188, -0.01210086140781641, 0.023288827389478683, 0.0012407181784510612, -0.014640328474342823, 0.02104492299258709, -0.04937607795000076, -0.033865779638290405, -0.008275774307549, -0.06293987482786179, -0.03693706542253494, -0.018185604363679886, -0.03376362472772598, 0.046104125678539276, 0.05516034737229347, 0.013957309536635876, -0.025708697736263275, 0.07722959667444229, 0.0074480073526501656, 0.017810598015785217, -0.0252903513610363, 0.06279783695936203, 0.024615727365016937, -0.02887655422091484, -0.024414705112576485, 0.00613734545186162, -0.06290516257286072, -0.016768066212534904, 0.04241987690329552, -0.0031460027676075697, -0.03583882004022598, 0.003172246040776372, -0.037268124520778656, 0.0018389147007837892, 0.020028751343488693, 0.03393911197781563, 0.0479888990521431, -0.05059003084897995, -0.04227867349982262, -0.07603337615728378, -0.03363584727048874, 0.005300481803715229, -0.053518958389759064, -0.04335092380642891, -0.01371618453413248, 0.019698334857821465, -0.03526010364294052, -0.0629362240433693, -0.03340456634759903, -0.0047622788697481155, 0.029049105942249298, 0.0539313405752182, -0.021282168105244637, -0.022804051637649536, 0.05836925655603409, 0.03194912150502205, -0.011892075650393963, 0.02089109644293785, -0.010162877850234509, -0.022430771961808205, 0.0013717885594815016, -0.04441768303513527, -0.05738222971558571, 0.052352093160152435, -0.030076205730438232, -0.046656232327222824, 0.05367626994848251, -0.03410634398460388, 0.013390029780566692, -0.030083248391747475, 0.04832875728607178, 0.024529991671442986, -0.020546764135360718, 0.03268860653042793, -0.058369625359773636, -0.010054735466837883, -0.018030930310487747, 0.03841561824083328, -0.019902875646948814, -0.024579143151640892, 0.03508336469531059, 0.06369946151971817, -0.0045878952369093895, 0.042695045471191406, 0.045017700642347336, 0.0028593901079148054, 0.020631611347198486, -0.0446595624089241, 0.04842989146709442, -0.044680189341306686, -0.023512952029705048, -0.03554429113864899, 0.03818366676568985, -0.05866895243525505, 0.07826928794384003, 0.014918273314833641, 0.017195597290992737, -0.020797887817025185, -0.04203007370233536, -0.03129030019044876, 0.011189430020749569, 0.0176873616874218, 0.04375728964805603, -0.0020726528018712997, -0.0003247421409469098, -0.016358807682991028, -0.03313419595360756, 0.03913092613220215, -0.05063880234956741, 0.046647313982248306, -0.008519213646650314, -0.015399828553199768, -0.044350989162921906, -0.05973181873559952, 0.03931128978729248, 0.049658652395009995, 0.03021634742617607, -0.02830605022609234, -0.05186085402965546, 0.014899523928761482, -0.003505128202959895, 0.0019565080292522907, -0.01644386537373066, 0.00453431811183691, 0.0400315597653389, -0.00128785555716604, 0.05511406809091568, -0.04166630282998085, -0.041514135897159576, 0.006489954423159361, 0.047247085720300674, -0.03142216429114342, 0.010280388407409191, -0.008632578887045383, 0.04778019338846207, -0.006785242352634668, 0.013791464269161224, 0.02633988857269287, -0.04706558957695961, -0.01108801644295454, 0.013235446996986866, 0.03642132878303528, 0.03858476132154465, 0.0644453689455986, -0.029781868681311607, -0.03422878310084343, 0.002107552718371153, 0.022685209289193153, -0.03125326707959175, 0.013234932906925678, -0.030332667753100395, -0.005434333346784115, 0.05396582931280136, 0.007671228609979153, 0.06881934404373169, -0.00079097825801, -0.01851949468255043, 0.03819765895605087, -0.039433252066373825, -0.05967773497104645, -0.0036990679800510406, 0.004252755548804998, -0.011777513660490513, 0.017663009464740753, 0.06428023427724838, -0.06532744318246841, -0.033191122114658356, 0.01027651783078909, 0.0357290655374527, 0.02479368820786476, 0.011585199274122715, -0.054510459303855896, -0.03062727488577366, -0.029907291755080223, -0.029303746297955513, -0.01710866019129753, 0.029454534873366356, 0.04257579520344734, -0.029197553172707558, -0.05175550654530525, -0.038697320967912674, -0.004419366363435984, -0.03705228120088577, -0.015536253340542316, -0.08149389177560806, -0.028296547010540962, 0.021825460717082024, -0.043249018490314484, -0.018018916249275208, -0.03634949028491974, 0.040343306958675385, 0.05496048927307129, -0.009385667741298676, 0.03612413629889488, 0.027665168046951294, -0.012336332350969315, -0.010284340009093285, 0.025603163987398148, -0.013698742724955082, -0.03218024596571922, -0.07272909581661224, 0.0007030772976577282, 0.01335741113871336, -0.06625501066446304, 0.04079366847872734, -0.004122546408325434, -0.008587601594626904, -0.03452853485941887, 0.062477946281433105, 0.0034153189044445753, 0.05390303581953049, 0.0019313979428261518, -0.03684566915035248, -0.0018534117843955755, -0.10476204007863998, 0.010808327235281467, 0.030298439785838127, -0.04060311242938042, 0.023299645632505417, 0.008519813418388367, -0.00385145447216928, -0.046350687742233276, 0.0203781109303236, 0.028423931449651718, 0.025476135313510895, -0.04843611270189285, -0.08306901901960373, -0.0012637751642614603, -0.03526078909635544, -0.07372786849737167, -0.032045166939496994, -0.08268561214208603, -0.027509847655892372, 0.04966641589999199, 0.013605574145913124, 0.02401316910982132, 0.02682756632566452, -0.041370466351509094, -0.012249561958014965, -0.020943140611052513, 0.050668179988861084, 0.02105771005153656, -0.02241191267967224, -0.03908725082874298, -0.040905728936195374, -0.019813191145658493, -0.04199403151869774, 0.00834150891751051, -0.00153403973672539, -0.04544838145375252, -0.03223596513271332, 0.06538849323987961, 0.018102293834090233, -0.00045327257248573005, -0.03566479682922363, 0.029010286554694176, -0.004799341317266226, 0.015070080757141113, -0.0059935287572443485, -0.00990783516317606, -0.0548139289021492, 0.0030126990750432014, 0.017153672873973846, 0.04390489310026169, -0.056963469833135605, -0.010307256132364273, 0.0006597968167625368, -0.01167976576834917, -0.009627836756408215, 0.03666858747601509, 0.05747900903224945, -0.017584476619958878, 0.000938424258492887, -0.03127303346991539, -0.003940796013921499, 0.005941878072917461, 0.02744101546704769, -0.01992739364504814, 0.04928677901625633, 0.022868363186717033, -0.014055515639483929, -0.07426013052463531, 0.026197733357548714, 0.010174986906349659, 0.001756080542691052, -0.06229810416698456, -0.0810653567314148, 0.04592730477452278, -0.06572329252958298, 0.011622545309364796, -0.009027978405356407, -0.04213859140872955, -0.007093937136232853, -0.03828985616564751, 0.026790771633386612, 0.0068625654093921185, -0.013221467845141888, -0.0757310688495636, -0.069862000644207, 0.026981348171830177, 0.06345897912979126, -0.004253558348864317, -0.05513909459114075, 0.027395742014050484, -0.03680039942264557, 0.046481598168611526, -0.04680565744638443, -0.010197669267654419, -0.041175611317157745, -0.02497727796435356, -0.029300671070814133, 0.04511956870555878, -0.0093960240483284, 0.02939791977405548, 0.02181997150182724, -0.06040314957499504, 0.0012848320184275508, -0.033982254564762115, -0.04383735731244087, -0.030089089646935463, 0.05520356073975563, -0.04425305128097534, -0.045816440135240555, -0.060753412544727325, -0.011014801450073719, 0.07370077818632126, -0.0336979404091835, -0.06326929479837418, -0.05094556510448456, -0.033452365547418594, 0.02092777006328106, 0.0349457710981369, 0.01471398863941431, 0.06473629921674728, -0.0491282120347023, -0.01667114906013012, -0.01891360618174076, 0.05017504841089249, -0.01978527195751667, 0.0007953611784614623, -0.003565378487110138, 0.00002270958066219464, 0.055671628564596176, -0.084290511906147, 0.028652135282754898, 0.012551543302834034, 0.05863509699702263, -0.050460681319236755, 0.013427645899355412, 0.050575632601976395, -0.0064461613073945045, 0.028423314914107323, -0.0345037505030632, -0.019026901572942734, 0.00851911585777998, 0.027872513979673386, -0.00792000349611044, -0.0022414319682866335, -0.026244264096021652, -0.0452968031167984, -0.024918360635638237, -0.03416585177183151, 0.023407863453030586, 0.06231814995408058, 0.05352922901511192, 0.04638375714421272, -0.011054126545786858, -0.015413186512887478, 0.023187747225165367, -0.0036905109882354736, -0.017452357336878777, 0.018668975681066513, 0.029276899993419647, 0.008043423295021057, -0.0343325175344944, 0.013334201648831367, -0.015050581656396389, -0.05259476974606514, -0.04352710396051407, -0.02318076230585575, 0.04083622992038727, -0.011199942789971828, 0.04045196995139122, 0.034920912235975266, -0.002875295467674732, -0.01147972047328949, 0.04304732754826546, 0.02062126435339451, -0.023227613419294357, -0.03728177398443222, 0.011449246667325497, 0.0035105403512716293, 0.00909485388547182, 0.0037109546829015017, -0.009235573001205921, 0.013770297169685364, -0.03692975267767906, -0.01568649150431156, -0.012668746523559093, -0.01285459566861391, -0.05376790463924408, -0.0819445326924324, -0.05577285215258598, -0.03365170210599899, 0.013499701395630836, 0.023848257958889008, -0.015558474697172642, 0.05123861879110336, 0.02798357792198658, -0.057901136577129364, -0.025758014991879463, -0.027479084208607674, -0.048903197050094604, -0.03550472855567932, -0.025753876194357872, 0.008115374483168125, 0.041550662368535995, -0.012388802133500576, 0.03471623361110687, 0.04516392573714256, 0.011317341588437557, -0.04339531809091568, -0.028365319594740868, -0.027702316641807556, 0.015757497400045395, 0.01780329830944538, 0.0351068414747715, 0.007123088464140892, 0.01487698219716549, -0.05140785500407219, 0.03417045623064041, 0.012378078885376453, 0.024663327261805534, -0.020768046379089355, 0.017376551404595375, -0.05603121966123581, -0.06390976160764694, -0.035913627594709396, -0.03446033224463463, -0.02919675037264824, -0.07557251304388046, -0.06272036582231522, -0.010791604407131672, 0.017976978793740273, -0.047890860587358475, -0.027428030967712402, -0.03419960290193558, -0.01765526458621025, -0.04799695685505867, -0.019993899390101433, -0.0010504950769245625, -0.032118238508701324, 0.017354195937514305, 0.05454133078455925, -0.009589326567947865, 0.022465713322162628, -0.048988088965415955, 0.010041523724794388, 0.04733511805534363, 0.02547338418662548, -0.019854901358485222, -0.021664246916770935, -0.05586601793766022, -0.010817831382155418, -0.022461825981736183, -0.04019004851579666, 0.03147321566939354, -0.007096376735717058, 0.027299508452415466, 0.0676150768995285, -0.06830514222383499, 0.027515193447470665, 0.06116108596324921, -0.05197050794959068, 0.020957086235284805, 0.029491547495126724, -0.04750625044107437, 0.025035131722688675, 0.009395584464073181, -0.023069722577929497, -0.011583840474486351, -0.039558351039886475, -0.03153635188937187, -0.016880903393030167, -0.033506862819194794, 0.008435037918388844, 0.01319956686347723, -0.007807007059454918, -0.047720737755298615, 0.05827517807483673, -0.007185189984738827, -0.009057499468326569, -0.05591879412531853, 0.054782453924417496, 0.056684352457523346, 0.0042034233920276165, -0.05433614179491997, -0.02958942949771881, -0.033613238483667374, 0.008778294548392296, 0.054147228598594666, -0.07190560549497604, 0.0024407452438026667, -0.029142793267965317, 0.02378033474087715, 0.0012606078526005149, -0.005493138916790485, 0.027804303914308548, -0.024738285690546036, 0.056753452867269516, 0.007427105214446783, -0.061315760016441345, -0.038405321538448334, -0.02581273950636387, 0.04973297938704491, 0.003867906518280506, 0.01594245247542858, 0.04539802670478821, 0.0404917448759079, 0.015660874545574188, -0.07629621773958206, -0.028710387647151947, -0.020035844296216965, 0.06036103144288063, -0.0290326289832592, 0.022032463923096657, 0.004192717839032412, 0.008566498756408691, 0.009975881315767765, -0.004941843915730715, 0.016847435384988785, -0.06754646450281143, -0.016524402424693108, -0.004680894780904055, 0.048893075436353683, 0.037454359233379364, -0.05068467929959297, -0.024723870679736137, 0.020338008180260658, -0.03379698097705841, 0.06863704323768616, 0.0349092110991478, 0.03523699939250946, -0.02302340231835842, -0.04041053354740143, 0.03662822023034096, -0.06429968774318695, -0.0287198293954134, 0.05928293615579605, -0.0435958169400692, 0.018594633787870407, -0.004997577518224716, 0.004078682977706194, -0.01941557601094246, -0.019434815272688866, -0.011283786036074162, -0.06389445811510086, -0.02248760685324669, -0.06125587597489357, 0.06877059489488602, -0.026783717796206474, -0.05259958282113075, -0.021216215565800667, 0.03920629620552063, -0.07114150375127792, -0.02261485531926155, -0.030356748029589653, -0.0013116997433826327, -0.04352393373847008, -0.007125279866158962, -0.062360309064388275, -0.008321093395352364, -0.05855542793869972, 0.0641443207859993, 0.014566169120371342, -0.05303087830543518, -0.011318359524011612, 0.011924642138183117, -0.012615437619388103, 0.020410608500242233, -0.01317735854536295, -0.03582640737295151, -0.04931536689400673, 0.06928379088640213, -0.006440021097660065, -0.02241082489490509, -0.025082025676965714, 0.04413242265582085, -0.005339550320059061, 0.031203176826238632, -0.02530784346163273, -0.029810048639774323, 0.037300676107406616, -0.030226295813918114, -0.07582980394363403, -0.030172286555171013, -0.030473493039608, -0.02832178585231304, 0.010769499465823174, -0.03974083065986633, 0.0108965327963233, 0.04546419531106949, -0.00012831148342229426, -0.015675457194447517, -0.004610574338585138, -0.004796213004738092, 0.035697560757398605, 0.03731357306241989, -0.04355507716536522, 0.027509573847055435, -0.011811513453722, 0.040455617010593414, -0.005830228794366121, 0.0018289040308445692, 0.001876358175650239, -0.055966634303331375, 0.0016506791580468416, -0.00555798877030611, 0.032545413821935654, 0.004985681734979153, 0.05867258831858635, -0.06435242295265198, 0.041749242693185806, -0.049048569053411484, -0.015694526955485344, -0.03252381458878517, -0.04344053938984871, 0.021807081997394562, 0.01264968328177929, -0.03619819134473801, -0.022081252187490463, -0.01287637185305357, -0.039980728179216385, -0.021469121798872948, 0.06505298614501953, -0.034354809671640396, -0.0672101378440857, 0.023617662489414215, 0.006549692712724209, -0.009448147378861904, -0.012864856980741024, -0.013478105887770653, -0.021717041730880737, 0.00691253924742341, 0.04992375895380974, 0.04395255818963051, -0.001667796983383596, -0.021802784875035286, -0.015651755034923553, -0.012773465365171432, 0.016787033528089523, -0.05557547137141228, 0.02683934196829796, -0.03156040236353874, -0.0577637180685997, -0.08551856130361557, 0.006920432671904564, -0.012767237611114979, -0.018116027116775513, -0.017242789268493652, -0.02088819444179535, 0.062252920120954514, 0.05624065548181534, -0.039180148392915726, -0.07933531701564789, -0.009224437177181244, -0.019211295992136, -0.0066935052163898945, 0.021911049261689186, 0.022291425615549088, -0.05982809513807297, 0.013712361454963684, -0.08920027315616608, -0.011510518379509449, -0.020221136510372162, 0.036593735218048096, -0.023715810850262642, 0.010523902252316475, -0.028515608981251717, -0.025057252496480942, -0.0063086869195103645, 0.014447695575654507, 0.0058234864845871925, 0.06869830191135406, 0.010504738427698612, 0.0031275744549930096, -0.020348573103547096, 0.0005681505426764488, 0.037778936326503754, 0.013473866507411003, 0.005440411623567343, 0.038658507168293, 0.04205026850104332, -0.013565301895141602, 0.01789255440235138, 0.030877070501446724, -0.02600299008190632, -0.04206202179193497, -0.03218286111950874, -0.04071250557899475, -0.014548680745065212, -0.048408009111881256, 0.04494612663984299, -0.012443219311535358, 0.015112549066543579, 0.012733886949717999, 0.0006297287181951106, -0.04231373965740204, 0.020343003794550896, -0.01728350669145584, 0.005116971209645271, -0.00338858924806118, -0.008708908222615719, 0.046937666833400726, -0.03706449642777443, 0.01681964471936226, -0.019954968243837357, -0.000032115483918460086, -0.06227581948041916, -0.0025846182834357023, 0.03562624379992485, -0.07937710732221603, 0.008847519755363464, -0.05070226639509201, 0.0010068878764286637, -0.04845859482884407, 0.020668955519795418, 0.019665762782096863, -0.010938678868114948, -0.03767383098602295, -0.03116379864513874, -0.02588740922510624, 0.000049481568566989154, 0.006961044855415821, -0.03248998150229454, 0.006506658624857664, 0.04188869148492813, 0.016620757058262825, 0.034028708934783936, 0.04826263338327408, -0.030144937336444855, 0.061169568449258804, 0.0001373035047436133, 0.013694231398403645, -0.016791561618447304, 0.014991026371717453, -0.039410341531038284, 0.04393443092703819, 0.02385113202035427, -0.06971320509910583, -0.03877533599734306, 0.028304003179073334, 0.008822071366012096, -0.029372012242674828, -0.03822527453303337, 0.05012340098619461, -0.020070843398571014, -0.03511572256684303, -0.05078989267349243, 0.038172442466020584, 0.008531331084668636, -0.03958085551857948, 0.014491111040115356, 0.020970098674297333, 0.043020687997341156, -0.07308541238307953 ]
Content metadata plays a very important role in movie recommender systems as it provides valuable information about various aspects of a movie such as genre, cast, plot synopsis, box office summary, etc. Analyzing the metadata can help understand the user preferences to generate personalized recommendations and item cold starting. In this talk, we will focus on one particular type of metadata - \textit{genre} labels. Genre labels associated with a movie or a TV series help categorize a collection of titles into different themes and correspondingly setting up the audience expectation. We present some of the challenges associated with using genre label information and propose a new way of examining the genre information that we call as the \textit{Genre Spectrum}. The Genre Spectrum helps capture the various nuanced genres in a title and our offline and online experiments corroborate the effectiveness of the approach. Furthermore, we also talk about applications of LLMs in augmenting content metadata which could eventually be used to achieve effective organization of recommendations in user's 2-D home-grid.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08787v1
[ -0.028714416548609734, -0.05196443572640419, 0.05797681212425232, -0.04021845757961273, 0.03916625306010246, -0.023921694606542587, -0.05507965013384819, -0.04502801224589348, -0.004412248730659485, -0.04426184296607971, 0.0004786124627571553, 0.04677441343665123, -0.053237006068229675, -0.06345692276954651, -0.021787164732813835, -0.0029065764974802732, 0.07946473360061646, 0.0010400566970929503, -0.03541341796517372, 0.02279125154018402, -0.019032971933484077, -0.0540367029607296, -0.042167626321315765, 0.03397085517644882, 0.01087571494281292, -0.042516909539699554, -0.016776522621512413, -0.05612014979124069, -0.034102343022823334, -0.016956502571702003, 0.05425696820020676, -0.004600117914378643, -0.04658494517207146, 0.019176296889781952, -0.028837187215685844, -0.04785044863820076, -0.013988432474434376, -0.02058849297463894, -0.027501491829752922, -0.025827281177043915, 0.059928975999355316, -0.04614289477467537, -0.04595628008246422, -0.047826021909713745, -0.043125830590724945, -0.013537880033254623, -0.051860373467206955, 0.043984297662973404, -0.0893004760146141, 0.001693608472123742, 0.02534751407802105, 0.0016101652290672064, -0.010986088775098324, 0.05828600749373436, -0.008339746855199337, 0.013859046623110771, 0.027981912717223167, -0.025767378509044647, -0.06676100939512253, 0.0009151147096417844, 0.05953679978847504, -0.028661474585533142, 0.01651892438530922, 0.015871169045567513, -0.0008205832564271986, -0.02047640271484852, -0.034462105482816696, -0.07746358960866928, -0.037268877029418945, -0.040798939764499664, 0.019561653956770897, -0.07751597464084625, 0.0022928633261471987, -0.03406517952680588, -0.023154105991125107, -0.018358120694756508, -0.015685923397541046, -0.0389847606420517, -0.04160099849104881, 0.002523938426747918, -0.04183294624090195, -0.0012610862031579018, 0.06569381058216095, 0.015027551911771297, 0.025518644601106644, -0.04989444464445114, 0.03607482463121414, 0.022716626524925232, 0.01802656799554825, -0.010495823808014393, 0.011288370005786419, -0.040407419204711914, -0.09033158421516418, 0.02097295969724655, 0.05554872378706932, 0.005006071645766497, 0.04777221381664276, -0.016151366755366325, -0.006518588867038488, -0.01704220287501812, -0.0035372073762118816, -0.022434614598751068, -0.0015145340003073215, 0.04584125056862831, 0.05703673139214516, -0.06358885020017624, 0.04288434237241745, 0.025955596938729286, -0.04794295132160187, -0.004735727794468403, 0.005306393839418888, -0.037929829210042953, 0.02045491151511669, -0.06859768182039261, 0.001057473011314869, 0.007581342477351427, 0.014905395917594433, -0.02297002077102661, -0.02083185315132141, -0.004418566357344389, -0.013863643631339073, 0.022889969870448112, 0.050469812005758286, -0.06130725517868996, -0.08501312881708145, -0.03784313425421715, 0.027791421860456467, 0.028171183541417122, 0.028884224593639374, -0.05269750580191612, -0.03800276666879654, -0.0375523716211319, -0.027288878336548805, -0.006066249683499336, 0.07057689130306244, -0.04044210910797119, -0.01965559646487236, -0.0712999477982521, 0.03139631450176239, 0.018654540181159973, -0.03823159635066986, -0.06672313064336777, 0.035948481410741806, -0.051612887531518936, 0.02625264972448349, 0.004231361206620932, 0.01093470398336649, 0.00611842842772603, 0.002533277729526162, 0.02989140897989273, 0.0062033068388700485, -0.04647498577833176, 0.02290204167366028, 0.027816295623779297, -0.003975077532231808, -0.038003791123628616, 0.031928014010190964, -0.06009822338819504, -0.017913885414600372, 0.036195844411849976, -0.0035067745484411716, 0.023471100255846977, -0.0009793289937078953, -0.039766691625118256, -0.024739669635891914, -0.039360612630844116, 0.04777959734201431, -0.0013018790632486343, 0.00820100400596857, -0.010701599530875683, 0.012541882693767548, 0.026781465858221054, -0.029094092547893524, -0.04437986761331558, -0.06024910509586334, -0.02836679108440876, -0.02082434482872486, -0.02705267444252968, -0.023130202665925026, -0.03286988288164139, -0.0028295936062932014, 0.015331530012190342, -0.06915153563022614, -0.019282761961221695, -0.04022551327943802, 0.0556500181555748, -0.07019606232643127, -0.011881816200911999, 0.03605414554476738, -0.00805579498410225, -0.0378284677863121, -0.04381866008043289, -0.007590313442051411, -0.02030864916741848, 0.01613745652139187, 0.023792332038283348, 0.015011731535196304, -0.04163440316915512, 0.061190638691186905, 0.03474615514278412, -0.06815173476934433, -0.009190943092107773, -0.058877937495708466, 0.024372488260269165, 0.020015446469187737, -0.07612543553113937, 0.005195804871618748, 0.034517280757427216, -0.04231414198875427, -0.017979517579078674, 0.014768801629543304, 0.06737244129180908, 0.03192821517586708, -0.004763912409543991, 0.021372953429818153, -0.01792195253074169, -0.0944141075015068, 0.049256518483161926, 0.028862157836556435, -0.025907427072525024, 0.008161469362676144, 0.0353303924202919, -0.01559081207960844, -0.031128697097301483, 0.040099382400512695, -0.02003924921154976, 0.03175508603453636, -0.003002260345965624, -0.059428829699754715, 0.02580680511891842, -0.030199110507965088, -0.04653988033533096, 0.014246908016502857, -0.05117156356573105, 0.02086745947599411, -0.032485589385032654, -0.0323137566447258, 0.003495557699352503, -0.029897887259721756, -0.005490199197083712, -0.02559877745807171, -0.06439872831106186, 0.05023127421736717, 0.00686605554074049, -0.02764282561838627, -0.045467015355825424, -0.0353868193924427, 0.01934528723359108, -0.037648558616638184, -0.023110659793019295, -0.006512523163110018, -0.04687032476067543, -0.048021383583545685, -0.024692999199032784, 0.029381809756159782, -0.042583148926496506, -0.03127747029066086, 0.05649670585989952, 0.00977511890232563, 0.045787036418914795, 0.018648294731974602, 0.056195393204689026, -0.06277775764465332, 0.03853212296962738, 0.004628910217434168, -0.013302910141646862, 0.003229899099096656, -0.02899857796728611, -0.00008379558857996017, -0.01621735468506813, 0.03600994125008583, 0.021147726103663445, 0.058864425867795944, -0.023780645802617073, -0.006993548013269901, -0.04284099489450455, 0.04263738915324211, -0.018487101420760155, -0.01227013859897852, 0.06714069843292236, 0.035873278975486755, 0.021971428766846657, -0.035355571657419205, -0.06062031537294388, -0.00333335786126554, -0.030976014211773872, -0.03310978040099144, -0.07979349046945572, -0.008488229475915432, -0.050732165575027466, -0.06934349983930588, 0.019642025232315063, -0.009024349972605705, -0.06627632677555084, -0.05926378443837166, -0.0717824399471283, -0.008301876485347748, -0.04475616663694382, 0.01073641050606966, 0.007199346553534269, -0.021573033183813095, 0.00477608572691679, 0.011108274571597576, -0.04052937030792236, 0.016118023544549942, -0.058857113122940063, -0.03318764269351959, -0.017858851701021194, -0.006053084973245859, -0.02201543189585209, -0.038768015801906586, 0.015190701931715012, -0.005701674148440361, 0.04809815436601639, -0.013598051853477955, -0.0055812569335103035, -0.031300339847803116, 0.05677391588687897, -0.020538952201604843, -0.032419703900814056, 0.01573675125837326, -0.001135885831899941, -0.028998704627156258, -0.03910135105252266, -0.05200149491429329, -0.021212909370660782, 0.0637366846203804, -0.03164352476596832, -0.04748302325606346, -0.03485867753624916, -0.029986713081598282, 0.012642149813473225, 0.03219892829656601, 0.021869555115699768, 0.030435215681791306, 0.04083265736699104, -0.04381405934691429, -0.05116394907236099, 0.010033134371042252, -0.03705781325697899, 0.019843146204948425, -0.015966109931468964, -0.053606949746608734, -0.016064314171671867, 0.05035705864429474, -0.09161565452814102, 0.03676550090312958, 0.06606905907392502, 0.0651775673031807, 0.019549783319234848, 0.011203262023627758, 0.0036171497777104378, -0.006508288439363241, 0.03186842054128647, 0.0031341207213699818, -0.028584657236933708, 0.017112407833337784, 0.015899743884801865, -0.06877783685922623, -0.026932472363114357, -0.046066612005233765, -0.021796440705657005, 0.0012751963222399354, 0.023451196029782295, 0.02253253012895584, 0.04392620921134949, 0.037025004625320435, -0.0381794236600399, 0.033714305609464645, -0.03233771771192551, 0.04781171679496765, 0.0025952390860766172, -0.047935694456100464, -0.015837498009204865, -0.06552522629499435, 0.04702441766858101, -0.005296096205711365, -0.02168404497206211, -0.04492056369781494, 0.00369413779117167, 0.009623965248465538, -0.026911817491054535, 0.06470208615064621, 0.016538193449378014, -0.006660896353423595, 0.006414347793906927, 0.038392193615436554, -0.009843598119914532, 0.035044677555561066, -0.05683400481939316, 0.018355604261159897, 0.017797157168388367, 0.014486134983599186, -0.04517897218465805, -0.0012933018151670694, -0.059387270361185074, -0.002364550484344363, 0.02440520003437996, -0.025548622012138367, -0.024019232019782066, 0.005298558156937361, 0.0030031041242182255, -0.003255959367379546, -0.0809071809053421, 0.04271207004785538, -0.054648611694574356, 0.04647988826036453, 0.04092122241854668, -0.06513096392154694, 0.02146242745220661, -0.05306139215826988, -0.027185868471860886, -0.02863851562142372, 0.003060006070882082, -0.012478682212531567, -0.0193873830139637, 0.037952207028865814, -0.04141886532306671, 0.012496969662606716, -0.054373666644096375, 0.014769244939088821, 0.0015981780597940087, 0.014611833728849888, -0.021042900159955025, -0.003705258248373866, -0.021734723821282387, 0.058276914060115814, 0.045338742434978485, 0.007978010922670364, -0.017484838142991066, 0.017442986369132996, 0.024415647611021996, 0.011247371323406696, 0.06415888667106628, -0.03917262703180313, 0.027845580130815506, 0.0017973040230572224, -0.0410960353910923, 0.034282781183719635, 0.03384234756231308, -0.026024267077445984, 0.050005339086055756, -0.03946799412369728, -0.05493532866239548, -0.00866936706006527, 0.026494743302464485, -0.055314984172582626, -0.06141442432999611, 0.008613168261945248, -0.04587845131754875, -0.05928405001759529, -0.013728426769375801, 0.036868538707494736, 0.028610289096832275, -0.017226843163371086, 0.015245496295392513, 0.02943863347172737, 0.042704835534095764, 0.04757838323712349, 0.009759720414876938, 0.01005831453949213, -0.030181456357240677, -0.056010883301496506, 0.02711048349738121, -0.04293936863541603, 0.030117962509393692, -0.030295655131340027, -0.0071256570518016815, -0.007785520516335964, 0.008801452815532684, 0.014482407830655575, 0.0746716782450676, -0.05445976182818413, 0.03416283801198006, 0.05310336500406265, 0.001280620926991105, 0.0498841367661953, 0.04756716638803482, 0.01503666490316391, 0.024324802681803703, -0.014727169647812843, 0.013246642425656319, 0.027735190466046333, -0.03775852173566818, 0.03162778168916702, 0.011269164271652699, -0.005790057126432657, 0.004338826052844524, 0.048600032925605774, 0.03974771499633789, -0.034513406455516815, 0.00794369075447321, 0.041404690593481064, 0.04990917444229126, -0.028160402551293373, 0.01290588267147541, 0.030031030997633934, -0.04445144161581993, -0.025326088070869446, -0.0011906628496944904, -0.02744336612522602, 0.013528500683605671, -0.007945911958813667, -0.024368498474359512, -0.01747870072722435, 0.02334296889603138, -0.005419475957751274, 0.008520838804543018, -0.01122075691819191, 0.02635602280497551, 0.01075174193829298, -0.01675265282392502, -0.015205705538392067, -0.054933901876211166, 0.007936917245388031, -0.054492510855197906, 0.043207887560129166, 0.06489215046167374, 0.038549408316612244, 0.053491994738578796, 0.03105679713189602, -0.03137454390525818, -0.022227659821510315, -0.017190832644701004, -0.007894051261246204, -0.002158230636268854, -0.02397674135863781, 0.0011866536224260926, -0.028631072491407394, 0.04787341132760048, 0.014070206321775913, -0.0057189990766346455, 0.03393927961587906, 0.04690287634730339, -0.06471160799264908, -0.002148325787857175, 0.04460997134447098, 0.02944835089147091, -0.07066658139228821, 0.025955919176340103, -0.014030475169420242, -0.021046040579676628, 0.03889700397849083, 0.0004008231044281274, -0.039108630269765854, 0.008816666901111603, -0.0064577204175293446, -0.002492875326424837, -0.016884485259652138, 0.004811638966202736, 0.056604787707328796, -0.04411735758185387, 0.018473567441105843, -0.021991761401295662, -0.026661651208996773, 0.029758287593722343, -0.030787786468863487, -0.04048747196793556, 0.03174291551113129, -0.009082749485969543, -0.02663077972829342, 0.05108650401234627, -0.03634857386350632, -0.0728197991847992, 0.025622883811593056, -0.03390884026885033, -0.08584968000650406, -0.02319486252963543, 0.02873862162232399, 0.050586603581905365, -0.033883996307849884, 0.04186045378446579, -0.031930577009916306, 0.0064094034023582935, -0.02482813410460949, 0.035095375031232834, 0.08026985824108124, -0.020100241526961327, 0.01152681466192007, -0.0036892786156386137, -0.04803549498319626, -0.01964140310883522, 0.021046310663223267, 0.04810255020856857, 0.007001526653766632, 0.05096503719687462, -0.0003805190499406308, -0.026019202545285225, -0.009161279536783695, 0.05836166813969612, -0.05193963646888733, -0.04228450357913971, -0.0011249602539464831, -0.0425909161567688, 0.06001366302371025, -0.027820343151688576, -0.04522320628166199, -0.00129704421851784, 0.0331268236041069, -0.019380558282136917, -0.058315832167863846, -0.010438275523483753, -0.03348639979958534, -0.045195095241069794, 0.01498568244278431, -0.07320503890514374, -0.02607361227273941, -0.015181660652160645, -0.08913879096508026, -0.01054742094129324, -0.08008017390966415, 0.003926742356270552, 0.0012589454418048263, 0.06685255467891693, 0.03674081712961197, 0.04907894879579544, -0.04329056665301323, -0.045032575726509094, 0.024704966694116592, 0.004792654421180487, 0.030042916536331177, -0.028300533071160316, -0.020701367408037186, -0.02314264327287674, 0.041938550770282745, -0.05334201455116272, -0.04055534303188324, -0.017394088208675385, -0.0251751895993948, 0.03795339912176132, -0.001997734885662794, -0.0026328612584620714, -0.03658239170908928, 0.024456527084112167, -0.01728547178208828, -0.0025802403688430786, 0.0318153090775013, -0.06725026667118073, -0.07140741497278214, -0.05562363564968109, 0.022077960893511772, 0.0029928043950349092, 0.016434891149401665, 0.013253631070256233, 0.04065233841538429, 0.038155775517225266, 0.04565053805708885, -0.0006315262289717793, 0.00024115285486914217, 0.0030197047162801027, -0.03693762049078941, 0.028555814176797867, -0.023765254765748978, -0.02286403439939022, -0.039483800530433655, 0.0180768184363842, -0.001181733445264399, -0.06079809367656708, -0.02833515778183937, 0.013691099360585213, -0.007858742028474808, -0.050078168511390686, -0.07134584337472916, 0.014807072468101978, -0.003689412958920002, -0.02137604169547558, -0.0719643160700798, 0.03093807026743889, -0.026145048439502716, -0.04968702048063278, -0.0204144436866045, -0.04138368368148804, -0.027968760579824448, -0.001596325309947133, -0.0691547766327858, 0.01506017055362463, 0.0030371840111911297, 0.008115249685943127, -0.04123949632048607, 0.006688236258924007, -0.003357277950271964, -0.03736600652337074, 0.016080506145954132, -0.00013736715482082218, 0.021149050444364548, -0.016235357150435448, -0.016404833644628525, -0.011798973195254803, -0.026790780946612358, 0.03141239285469055, 0.00854505505412817, -0.04626638442277908, -0.015806859359145164, 0.005148824770003557, 0.03981678932905197, 0.0034974184818565845, 0.0029026505071669817, 0.0302000492811203, -0.0019930254202336073, 0.0752071663737297, -0.03923764079809189, 0.03719743341207504, -0.02038728818297386, -0.03761911764740944, 0.02426326274871826, -0.04178742691874504, -0.02930298261344433, 0.05307643488049507, -0.04097377508878708, -0.004567308817058802, -0.0024952960666269064, -0.05938668176531792, 0.02880179136991501, -0.03237198665738106, -0.040893346071243286, 0.053503312170505524, 0.003113117069005966, 0.0225251242518425, -0.03528696671128273, -0.05463060364127159, -0.005500942934304476, 0.012782043777406216, 0.036772023886442184, -0.04055620729923248, -0.007070443592965603, -0.04826727509498596, 0.04755210503935814, -0.03626377508044243, 0.01772979460656643, -0.041858792304992676, 0.0727480947971344, 0.004571021534502506, -0.02413088083267212, -0.031335797160863876, 0.007111649960279465, -0.02904016710817814, -0.09155924618244171, -0.06751541793346405, -0.037006743252277374, 0.03088972717523575, -0.016129789873957634, -0.019378604367375374, -0.035848017781972885, 0.05803981050848961, 0.00212109531275928, 0.01823338493704796, 0.014450528658926487, 0.009610866196453571, 0.006176959723234177, 0.060617830604314804, 0.016867633908987045, 0.0209064781665802, -0.03319372236728668, -0.0017077686497941613, -0.016185002401471138, 0.020073844119906425, 0.02661191113293171, 0.027794165536761284, 0.02281595580279827, -0.011915313079953194, -0.00014668154472019523, 0.031928159296512604, -0.04286815971136093, -0.03210999071598053, -0.037429481744766235, 0.002962906612083316, -0.034098803997039795, 0.0039299242198467255 ]