text
string
source
string
embeddings
list
We present a variational Monte Carlo algorithm for estimating the lowest excited states of a quantum system which is a natural generalization of the estimation of ground states. The method has no free parameters and requires no explicit orthogonalization of the different states, instead transforming the problem of finding excited states of a given system into that of finding the ground state of an expanded system. Expected values of arbitrary observables can be calculated, including off-diagonal expectations between different states such as the transition dipole moment. Although the method is entirely general, it works particularly well in conjunction with recent work on using neural networks as variational Ans\"atze for many-electron systems, and we show that by combining this method with the FermiNet and Psiformer Ans\"atze we can accurately recover vertical excitation energies and oscillator strengths on a range of molecules. Our method is the first deep learning approach to achieve accurate vertical excitation energies, including challenging double excitations, on benzene-scale molecules. Beyond the chemistry examples here, we expect this technique will be of great interest for applications to atomic, nuclear and condensed matter physics.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.16848v3
[ -0.010805664584040642, -0.022764623165130615, 0.025521041825413704, 0.0474369078874588, -0.0003678449138533324, -0.039263736456632614, 0.013520482927560806, 0.01587652787566185, -0.014829041436314583, -0.008705386891961098, -0.027043746784329414, -0.042514752596616745, -0.05256163701415062, -0.04935451224446297, -0.06702297925949097, 0.025287868455052376, 0.07418195903301239, 0.05825750157237053, -0.024451756849884987, 0.07099982351064682, 0.04133386164903641, -0.04369302839040756, -0.02132650651037693, 0.05458524823188782, -0.021635444834828377, -0.011641539633274078, -0.043718207627534866, -0.005101364571601152, -0.04022965952754021, -0.035428810864686966, 0.042900070548057556, -0.03569404408335686, -0.011439960449934006, -0.0021320616360753775, -0.025108464062213898, -0.033251501619815826, 0.005207451526075602, 0.055035870522260666, 0.0412849597632885, -0.003270882647484541, 0.011333511210978031, -0.0024244373198598623, -0.05410157889127731, 0.03549613058567047, 0.016960788518190384, -0.0008399070356972516, -0.07067801803350449, 0.028211096301674843, -0.052175406366586685, -0.06672942638397217, 0.00601405743509531, 0.013313676230609417, 0.0077064004726707935, 0.057016048580408096, -0.07469864934682846, -0.01980021223425865, -0.03874146193265915, -0.005285339429974556, -0.06442522257566452, -0.011224856600165367, -0.012035137973725796, -0.004114968702197075, -0.005989503115415573, -0.0465877428650856, 0.014957677572965622, 0.05989846587181091, -0.015448066405951977, -0.06658557802438736, -0.06740835309028625, -0.07456625252962112, 0.026118049398064613, -0.07264932990074158, 0.02490713819861412, -0.009727769531309605, -0.05122584104537964, -0.03812944516539574, -0.005190820898860693, -0.01982889324426651, 0.011056888848543167, 0.01950790546834469, -0.011523211374878883, 0.0022679618559777737, 0.012280109338462353, 0.04543699696660042, -0.00644786236807704, -0.0007825889624655247, 0.06378797441720963, 0.0018653231672942638, 0.0009753490448929369, -0.03406033664941788, 0.045230019837617874, -0.027598056942224503, -0.06638267636299133, -0.0032115252688527107, 0.061820484697818756, -0.04093961790204048, 0.030134011059999466, 0.06142513453960419, 0.04256834834814072, 0.0019405415514484048, 0.0022504108492285013, -0.029343152418732643, 0.009575319476425648, 0.053205180913209915, 0.009817454032599926, -0.027351923286914825, -0.017338458448648453, -0.0012291569728404284, -0.04734379053115845, 0.03695930168032646, -0.01772678829729557, -0.020301708951592445, -0.00001675289786362555, -0.04732828959822655, -0.03180213272571564, -0.04240639507770538, 0.044056106358766556, 0.04014216363430023, 0.006118332501500845, -0.01267563458532095, -0.0387435145676136, 0.02320597507059574, -0.0008537426474504173, -0.01586672104895115, -0.0340043343603611, 0.02748832292854786, 0.07553216069936752, 0.018446417525410652, -0.028325483202934265, -0.02681221254169941, -0.026428015902638435, 0.05433381348848343, 0.018883785232901573, -0.02800319343805313, 0.05860043689608574, -0.01765071600675583, -0.015234542079269886, -0.0315866656601429, 0.000553941645193845, 0.05453252047300339, -0.018326548859477043, -0.03472161665558815, 0.026823988184332848, -0.017714666202664375, 0.003908870276063681, 0.027299318462610245, -0.08006691187620163, -0.01363431103527546, 0.033213287591934204, 0.021871846169233322, -0.027534350752830505, -0.013077019713819027, 0.03241870552301407, 0.009546136483550072, 0.035234905779361725, 0.013118087314069271, 0.030796419829130173, -0.017086071893572807, -0.03456132858991623, 0.008010360412299633, 0.05672011524438858, -0.006351407151669264, 0.003746715607121587, 0.0024421995040029287, -0.004194543696939945, 0.03419250622391701, 0.03737422078847885, -0.030700186267495155, -0.010467945598065853, 0.009746359661221504, -0.0556529201567173, -0.004921815358102322, 0.04771832004189491, -0.03341355174779892, -0.03045908361673355, -0.05520368367433548, -0.0319967120885849, -0.04982639476656914, -0.04337623715400696, -0.02798628993332386, 0.025981582701206207, -0.0014207958010956645, -0.04740491881966591, 0.007715798448771238, -0.044412050396203995, 0.01929071545600891, -0.08936023712158203, 0.0007339863805100322, 0.05113702267408371, -0.005406473763287067, -0.021906087175011635, -0.017757168039679527, 0.048193611204624176, -0.008650082163512707, -0.04033985361456871, 0.001648798119276762, 0.017249902710318565, -0.013435151427984238, -0.03830084204673767, 0.044343896210193634, -0.07375896722078323, -0.039566025137901306, -0.017377614974975586, -0.059132806956768036, -0.04240239039063454, -0.06362366676330566, 0.01364248339086771, 0.04018651321530342, -0.02137935906648636, -0.016188502311706543, 0.04467080533504486, 0.027130091562867165, 0.047379832714796066, 0.0013032747665420175, -0.0019984820391982794, -0.013757657259702682, -0.09658774733543396, 0.06180032342672348, 0.04426287114620209, -0.0255571398884058, 0.028492551296949387, 0.01831371895968914, -0.0033428019378334284, -0.01683850958943367, -0.01900351233780384, 0.06147894635796547, 0.05016312003135681, 0.026907561346888542, -0.04540395364165306, -0.024924928322434425, -0.04194241762161255, -0.03561326488852501, -0.06973206251859665, -0.07828376442193985, -0.03399200737476349, -0.007736372295767069, -0.012017994187772274, 0.01971340924501419, -0.02091129496693611, -0.07391165941953659, -0.06069733202457428, -0.018019862473011017, 0.042284782975912094, -0.02498052455484867, -0.038986686617136, -0.036759454756975174, -0.0460929349064827, 0.027397338300943375, -0.02539144828915596, -0.03879643231630325, -0.004774666391313076, -0.0282882172614336, -0.019010458141565323, -0.028731515631079674, -0.017079582437872887, 0.02720090001821518, -0.029096977785229683, 0.03239631652832031, -0.0069672102108597755, 0.04159422963857651, 0.017420578747987747, 0.044075433164834976, -0.04492584988474846, 0.02196470834314823, 0.016821185126900673, 0.024838710203766823, -0.030295679345726967, -0.0022174869664013386, 0.015378731302917004, -0.05537351593375206, -0.013327130116522312, 0.034865666180849075, 0.036372795701026917, 0.0037498532328754663, -0.011073097586631775, -0.035294804722070694, -0.01686696894466877, -0.03586616739630699, 0.06154686585068703, 0.05242422968149185, 0.033898379653692245, 0.03150589019060135, -0.012894927524030209, -0.061200208961963654, -0.042581357061862946, -0.03601826727390289, 0.01745971478521824, -0.006524533499032259, -0.02416207455098629, -0.03140712529420853, -0.07850706577301025, 0.0002691658737603575, -0.050862669944763184, -0.038932472467422485, -0.02613196149468422, -0.0701085776090622, -0.006102185230702162, -0.028513476252555847, 0.025803830474615097, -0.06158139556646347, -0.07661468535661697, 0.0066586630418896675, 0.048655036836862564, 0.004830330144613981, -0.014393176883459091, -0.03935089334845543, -0.009725801646709442, 0.02304309979081154, 0.028370758518576622, 0.05321905389428139, -0.026079760864377022, -0.004137337673455477, -0.048185475170612335, 0.03217668458819389, 0.03941081836819649, 0.026467135176062584, 0.016318337991833687, -0.011381846852600574, 0.014074143953621387, -0.04193635284900665, 0.026149194687604904, -0.036199986934661865, 0.021719982847571373, 0.009794997051358223, -0.04836368188261986, -0.03429628163576126, 0.07558376342058182, 0.05240518972277641, -0.02987578883767128, -0.00140923832077533, 0.010614834725856781, -0.03752993419766426, 0.017616890370845795, 0.012154407799243927, 0.06674392521381378, 0.028967401012778282, -0.012579130940139294, -0.020426729694008827, -0.02890757843852043, 0.007796450983732939, -0.01069940160959959, 0.0398026779294014, -0.033296313136816025, 0.0011158148990944028, 0.01724817231297493, -0.07896754890680313, 0.04244503751397133, 0.03334174305200577, 0.03437550365924835, -0.011846007779240608, -0.02695951983332634, 0.009052573703229427, 0.0247968677431345, -0.00458862166851759, 0.035141780972480774, 0.030130088329315186, 0.003023653058335185, 0.06439899653196335, -0.046895548701286316, -0.0012687256094068289, -0.026759684085845947, -0.07033649832010269, -0.05535176396369934, 0.00444601709023118, 0.038365669548511505, 0.041434984654188156, 0.020386334508657455, -0.000049730220780475065, -0.006392269395291805, -0.02629585564136505, 0.025791479274630547, -0.0060186004266142845, -0.00999849010258913, 0.05160607025027275, -0.011247918009757996, -0.017730094492435455, 0.045468322932720184, -0.005311222746968269, -0.015387441031634808, -0.06216473504900932, 0.0399109423160553, -0.057375308126211166, 0.021063338965177536, 0.01867988519370556, -0.019164234399795532, -0.00022089773847255856, 0.02440677396953106, -0.0348794087767601, 0.056873440742492676, 0.03189167007803917, -0.018759792670607567, -0.045979518443346024, 0.01996040716767311, 0.012141414918005466, 0.020023483783006668, -0.0551413930952549, -0.026310935616493225, 0.00450172321870923, -0.015979135408997536, 0.004660140722990036, 0.030834469944238663, 0.0038797922898083925, -0.02668115682899952, -0.08794602751731873, -0.012634815648198128, -0.04249254986643791, 0.0014533726498484612, -0.003118726424872875, -0.04004449024796486, 0.07131702452898026, -0.037611059844493866, 0.019117197021842003, -0.04599276930093765, -0.011099573224782944, -0.03275812789797783, -0.0432322695851326, -0.005935091525316238, -0.06404060870409012, 0.05847018584609032, -0.05876149982213974, 0.03480793535709381, -0.05374623462557793, 0.022289099171757698, -0.07660065591335297, 0.012912256643176079, -0.014007209800183773, 0.000692251487635076, 0.033983178436756134, 0.040807805955410004, 0.009202169254422188, -0.01794496923685074, -0.03316205367445946, 0.0004788863006979227, 0.012180429883301258, 0.027102185413241386, -0.02767878957092762, 0.040163133293390274, -0.03818961977958679, -0.04004896804690361, -0.03541894257068634, 0.002816819818690419, 0.06695779412984848, -0.057027436792850494, -0.02743159979581833, -0.006755222100764513, 0.02590988390147686, -0.0474400594830513, -0.04360509291291237, -0.050479404628276825, -0.03473136946558952, -0.06903563439846039, -0.004256656859070063, 0.04165434464812279, -0.02375827729701996, -0.02715974673628807, 0.015433507971465588, 0.03703960403800011, 0.04409625008702278, 0.0005961853894405067, 0.013879314064979553, -0.007751470431685448, 0.0355786494910717, -0.01980195753276348, -0.02519582398235798, -0.03319144248962402, -0.011905420571565628, 0.011185895651578903, -0.014434387907385826, 0.0016351715894415975, 0.0484788753092289, 0.02886754646897316, 0.0693129152059555, -0.08198187500238419, -0.004903749562799931, 0.04440411180257797, -0.0026009997818619013, -0.015941591933369637, 0.022737320512533188, -0.02354910410940647, 0.021602505818009377, -0.044671326875686646, -0.013726573437452316, 0.01950904354453087, -0.0020210526417940855, 0.04990409314632416, 0.013660524040460587, -0.05160173773765564, 0.021097661927342415, 0.04058275744318962, -0.024208061397075653, -0.06394020467996597, 0.023314982652664185, 0.019261902198195457, -0.013498430140316486, -0.03510386496782303, 0.023054689168930054, 0.03698053956031799, -0.030906688421964645, -0.05447100102901459, -0.03128793090581894, 0.012561190873384476, -0.03721635416150093, 0.028956754133105278, -0.04336561635136604, 0.025874553248286247, 0.03529239073395729, 0.05428894981741905, -0.0039305128157138824, 0.011394661851227283, 0.025347387418150902, 0.020582236349582672, -0.0003855967952404171, 0.016596810892224312, -0.06867659837007523, 0.005466412287205458, -0.042486097663640976, 0.016963442787528038, -0.03637964278459549, 0.02626713551580906, 0.045182593166828156, 0.05590549856424332, 0.028708476573228836, -0.012012065388262272, -0.03288517892360687, -0.03138749301433563, 0.03898729011416435, -0.061463113874197006, 0.006255625281482935, -0.007003657519817352, 0.05444593355059624, 0.015401804819703102, -0.05185006931424141, 0.027210216969251633, -0.023476259782910347, -0.030169302597641945, -0.006183816585689783, 0.015243266709148884, 0.005175421945750713, -0.03468947112560272, -0.008035811595618725, 0.027750257402658463, -0.02557871863245964, 0.043905965983867645, 0.0514143630862236, 0.01909048669040203, 0.03972918540239334, 0.000802944297902286, -0.02717389166355133, -0.042241767048835754, 0.030680449679493904, 0.09090346843004227, -0.06144164875149727, 0.014828282408416271, -0.056548841297626495, -0.05750200152397156, -0.01907719485461712, -0.054723989218473434, -0.001104869064874947, -0.0005636892165057361, -0.011904333718121052, -0.060525573790073395, 0.03494306653738022, 0.016370652243494987, -0.08338805288076401, 0.015080584213137627, 0.018734320998191833, -0.06389712542295456, -0.0057602799497544765, 0.054470352828502655, -0.019057076424360275, -0.03106583096086979, 0.038316842168569565, 0.004756529815495014, -0.019335459917783737, -0.004135033581405878, 0.041511207818984985, 0.08268162608146667, -0.03266485407948494, 0.04476965591311455, 0.042770303785800934, 0.005965534597635269, 0.005018808413296938, -0.03603749722242355, 0.006118896882981062, -0.0006034191465005279, 0.030482858419418335, -0.013843204826116562, -0.039182014763355255, -0.009210224263370037, 0.06468302011489868, -0.04502645879983902, 0.0008157978300005198, -0.037834107875823975, 0.02391209825873375, 0.04164139926433563, -0.06058879196643829, -0.048422716557979584, 0.02744116820394993, -0.01888825185596943, -0.02929770015180111, -0.01717355288565159, -0.018511982634663582, -0.030315076932311058, 0.023406364023685455, -0.012848218902945518, -0.0017863793764263391, 0.016676027327775955, -0.033046744763851166, -0.057595446705818176, 0.005686965771019459, -0.06187262758612633, -0.015041185542941093, -0.015944715589284897, 0.012833978049457073, 0.012271142564713955, 0.05417643114924431, -0.0369824580848217, 0.0008366303518414497, -0.028203489258885384, 0.025401998311281204, 0.019416555762290955, -0.018553059548139572, -0.007102421950548887, -0.0458621121942997, 0.03872189670801163, -0.030654001981019974, 0.0022725018206983805, 0.011401342228055, -0.0714661106467247, -0.007921400479972363, -0.000974720052909106, -0.03086293302476406, -0.04087391495704651, -0.0016640244284644723, -0.03634275123476982, 0.01205377746373415, 0.05209578201174736, -0.011259163729846478, -0.056323762983083725, 0.013465444557368755, 0.022210586816072464, 0.01619577221572399, -0.009326915256679058, 0.007633861619979143, 0.02027723379433155, -0.012374484911561012, 0.06509246677160263, 0.05941176414489746, 0.014524489641189575, 0.008640188723802567, -0.06522812694311142, -0.027833040803670883, 0.042061857879161835, -0.0027028468903154135, -0.031343646347522736, -0.06402701884508133, -0.047890372574329376, -0.07163045555353165, -0.01598421111702919, 0.03479718789458275, -0.012565821409225464, 0.050429292023181915, -0.07410997897386551, 0.01299846451729536, 0.0313272699713707, -0.05211600661277771, -0.07863146811723709, -0.0011899002129212022, 0.0004784227639902383, -0.009401696734130383, 0.0154904555529356, -0.027494128793478012, -0.04105450585484505, 0.03211747109889984, -0.08482340723276138, -0.039811957627534866, -0.0334775373339653, 0.05252682790160179, 0.021013882011175156, -0.022627318277955055, -0.03246689215302467, -0.005564291495829821, -0.005440466105937958, 0.02162902243435383, 0.021480128169059753, 0.04129805788397789, 0.01979566179215908, 0.04107241332530975, -0.04837900772690773, -0.03552224859595299, 0.041587602347135544, -0.0505249947309494, 0.004696242976933718, 0.029066238552331924, 0.006651691626757383, -0.007426830939948559, 0.02856864407658577, 0.032295111566782, 0.0008762318175286055, 0.02938893996179104, -0.05077516660094261, -0.001345716998912394, -0.034495048224925995, -0.07745135575532913, 0.05665184557437897, -0.05163118988275528, 0.024187063798308372, -0.017382213845849037, -0.028883058577775955, -0.008425840176641941, -0.020764658227562904, -0.042306117713451385, 0.05039900168776512, 0.028910622000694275, -0.001364407828077674, 0.05930446460843086, -0.03372266888618469, 0.015542085282504559, -0.023378310725092888, -0.022881528362631798, -0.03982405737042427, 0.04040119796991348, 0.04094332829117775, -0.0682474821805954, 0.03893916681408882, -0.06777763366699219, 0.020794976502656937, -0.006553285289555788, 0.02809012122452259, -0.023167060688138008, 0.05756679177284241, -0.03299294412136078, -0.010666092857718468, -0.03456246852874756, -0.023189084604382515, 0.0037178671918809414, -0.06979887932538986, -0.01419257652014494, -0.02978762798011303, 0.008253536187112331, 0.0027076706755906343, 0.040750112384557724, 0.022851264104247093, 0.0588972233235836, 0.05768399313092232, -0.059660654515028, -0.028252817690372467, 0.021171702072024345, -0.058303188532590866, 0.03951304405927658, -0.030316205695271492, 0.03080187551677227, -0.055436305701732635, 0.02081373892724514, -0.00698405085131526, 0.02782442793250084, 0.00003496763019938953, 0.005165923852473497, -0.02736227586865425, -0.04797052592039108, -0.00472157122567296, 0.023487983271479607, -0.014325554482638836, -0.03720130771398544, 0.009725377894937992, 0.008982517756521702, -0.025478551164269447, -0.04141495004296303 ]
La doped SrFeO$_{3}$, La$_{1/3}$Sr$_{2/3}$FeO$_{3}$, exhibits a metal-to-insulator transition accompanied by both antiferromagnetic and charge ordering states along with the Fe-O bond disproportionation below a critical temperature near 200K. Unconventionally slow charge dynamics measured in this material near the critical temperature shows that its excited charge ordering states can exhibit novel electronic structures with nontrivial energy profiles. Here, we reveal possible metastable states of charge ordering structures in La$_{1/3}$Sr$_{2/3}$FeO$_{3}$ using the first-principle and climbing image nudged elastic band methods. In the strong correlation regime, La$_{1/3}$Sr$_{2/3}$FeO$_{3}$ is an antiferromagnetic insulator with a charge ordering state of the big-small-big pattern, consistent with the experimental measurement of this material at the low temperature. As the correlation effect becomes weak, we find at least two possible metastable charge ordering states with the distinct Fe-O bond disproportionation. Remarkably, a ferroelectric metallic state emerges with the small energy barrier of $\sim$7 meV, driven by a metastable CO state of the small-medium-big pattern. The electronic structures of these metastable charge ordering states are noticeably different from those of the ground-state. Our results can provide an insightful explanation to multiple metastable charge ordering states and the slow charge dynamics of this and related oxide materials.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03995v1
[ -0.03858046978712082, -0.028075940907001495, 0.019235819578170776, 0.033154912292957306, -0.005832141265273094, -0.07073359191417694, -0.00641378341242671, 0.042035333812236786, -0.023170294240117073, -0.00733767868950963, 0.027636835351586342, -0.06667379289865494, -0.03850806504487991, -0.047819096595048904, -0.04121662303805351, 0.041734736412763596, 0.05924084037542343, 0.0678567886352539, 0.03012833744287491, 0.04950565844774246, -0.033274680376052856, -0.008532973006367683, -0.008750575594604015, 0.06979503482580185, -0.025129521265625954, -0.016271868720650673, -0.06708641350269318, 0.026719024404883385, -0.01283746026456356, -0.013336218893527985, 0.03370332717895508, -0.030816255137324333, 0.017015676945447922, 0.029896944761276245, -0.019108617678284645, -0.01739647053182125, 0.004864481743425131, 0.033421192318201065, 0.03171613812446594, -0.06036623567342758, -0.029635509476065636, -0.02585544064640999, -0.038289688527584076, -0.0391693152487278, 0.011262474581599236, -0.043958522379398346, -0.04217876121401787, 0.03418319299817085, -0.03327085077762604, -0.06245170906186104, 0.056186992675065994, 0.0044202241115272045, -0.02709532156586647, 0.06060817465186119, -0.026872731745243073, 0.021585673093795776, -0.024203218519687653, -0.056520767509937286, -0.050384748727083206, 0.0073752859607338905, -0.01554248109459877, -0.06266520172357559, 0.009786223992705345, -0.03599309176206589, -0.057864960283041, 0.02252228744328022, -0.014558608643710613, -0.052518345415592194, -0.06539234519004822, -0.08077497780323029, 0.007742982357740402, -0.06122366338968277, 0.018185269087553024, 0.04827222228050232, -0.06235622242093086, -0.040123358368873596, -0.020343689247965813, 0.010248678736388683, -0.04110986739397049, 0.011370471678674221, -0.03378056734800339, 0.017431063577532768, 0.0075929732993245125, 0.010699099861085415, 0.014276341535151005, 0.04323689639568329, 0.005796958226710558, -0.05338892340660095, -0.012096637859940529, -0.03549898415803909, 0.03873226419091225, -0.05241544172167778, -0.05532180517911911, 0.01496797613799572, 0.03715558350086212, -0.01919695921242237, 0.06211308389902115, 0.001172203803434968, 0.04413757473230362, -0.01460458803921938, 0.04443007707595825, -0.03642765060067177, -0.027004417032003403, 0.008237688802182674, -0.0004626110312528908, -0.0455532930791378, 0.035366471856832504, -0.04473697394132614, -0.05028054118156433, 0.03348006680607796, -0.006009805016219616, -0.023091459646821022, -0.014449754729866982, -0.025658944621682167, -0.0552922785282135, -0.029094625264406204, 0.05641884729266167, 0.03520209714770317, 0.0087778614833951, 0.011483135633170605, -0.0009143415372818708, 0.033623870462179184, 0.031069224700331688, -0.010679876431822777, -0.017046526074409485, 0.014302648603916168, 0.05261104181408882, -0.02657790295779705, 0.04450644552707672, 0.003649431047961116, -0.010535046458244324, 0.041274525225162506, 0.04259493201971054, -0.0571717768907547, 0.014810996130108833, -0.015370258130133152, 0.003192616393789649, 0.033613089472055435, -0.0035183418076485395, 0.031963564455509186, 0.0004333403776399791, -0.008290169760584831, 0.025691872462630272, -0.008428437635302544, -0.01852291449904442, 0.0448087602853775, -0.04644596949219704, 0.004809060133993626, 0.035505522042512894, 0.016262581571936607, 0.03381149470806122, -0.00970414374023676, -0.006122924853116274, -0.006033673882484436, 0.019099706783890724, 0.0068978783674538136, 0.0063108946196734905, 0.022646399214863777, -0.03485453128814697, 0.030327308923006058, 0.02590843476355076, 0.0014766440726816654, 0.014915885403752327, -0.04145965725183487, 0.01251996774226427, -0.0013668311294168234, 0.011904043145477772, -0.005869162268936634, 0.00019673154747579247, 0.010150830261409283, -0.017374787479639053, 0.021257074549794197, 0.03102889098227024, -0.05706619471311569, -0.06742773950099945, -0.011206202208995819, -0.0024797425139695406, -0.022687716409564018, -0.05328100174665451, -0.0025370304938405752, 0.048929471522569656, 0.006180678494274616, 0.0021634993609040976, -0.02130042389035225, -0.05443720519542694, -0.03640706464648247, -0.0753246620297432, -0.01865733414888382, 0.03185546398162842, -0.0007901273784227669, -0.04449397698044777, -0.006326801143586636, 0.02583458088338375, 0.005153219681233168, -0.004088249523192644, 0.013119819574058056, 0.023373866453766823, -0.04367709904909134, -0.048104532063007355, 0.02766125276684761, -0.07078944891691208, -0.00042883731657639146, -0.04418317973613739, 0.0026468089781701565, -0.021092688664793968, -0.04933223873376846, -0.003447593655437231, 0.05351455882191658, 0.003410436911508441, -0.005746189504861832, 0.024276357144117355, 0.02139846421778202, 0.04248308017849922, 0.0181556548923254, -0.005787073168903589, -0.061697427183389664, -0.0896974503993988, 0.06473389267921448, 0.05110658332705498, -0.011496962048113346, 0.07042808085680008, 0.017749525606632233, 0.021485399454832077, -0.01551355142146349, -0.02565169893205166, 0.04513416811823845, 0.05180846527218819, 0.024218784645199776, -0.028822384774684906, 0.02819848619401455, 0.031131185591220856, -0.056909214705228806, -0.06741577386856079, -0.06157471984624863, -0.03006739541888237, -0.018818894401192665, -0.0535665899515152, -0.006065646186470985, -0.038897138088941574, -0.06596963852643967, -0.03478052839636803, -0.00873049907386303, 0.03725304454565048, 0.018420012667775154, -0.04948778450489044, -0.06401816755533218, -0.07979211211204529, 0.02379479445517063, -0.0659099668264389, -0.015832513570785522, 0.026002245023846626, -0.035595349967479706, -0.038932766765356064, -0.038687217980623245, 0.030214939266443253, 0.03530517965555191, -0.027141714468598366, 0.007517839781939983, -0.0240657739341259, 0.04189053922891617, -0.031076660379767418, 0.019016677513718605, 0.02731449156999588, 0.010396978817880154, -0.013994322158396244, 0.005918689072132111, -0.03250819072127342, -0.019862990826368332, -0.004000888206064701, -0.019159648567438126, -0.011458830907940865, 0.02886921726167202, 0.02433423511683941, 0.029738273471593857, -0.009365788660943508, 0.00430197874084115, -0.07859792560338974, -0.03991818428039551, 0.0119431521743536, 0.038985587656497955, 0.04285362735390663, 0.022508975118398666, -0.016261259093880653, -0.04993831366300583, -0.050531722605228424, -0.027913207188248634, -0.023781051859259605, -0.052350252866744995, -0.007553258445113897, 0.0008903164998628199, -0.049795880913734436, -0.007715974468737841, -0.040019456297159195, -0.025877997279167175, -0.020616354420781136, -0.04261288046836853, -0.054985206574201584, -0.002769608749076724, 0.02093110792338848, -0.07983069121837616, -0.0695582702755928, 0.03772285580635071, 0.00017591055075172335, 0.021714288741350174, -0.04900484159588814, 0.011754159815609455, -0.013690043240785599, -0.0055268071591854095, 0.032953549176454544, -0.033180370926856995, -0.0523107536137104, -0.016002107411623, -0.062493447214365005, -0.029025468975305557, 0.003266134997829795, 0.027921734377741814, 0.04675532877445221, -0.04569555073976517, -0.01816767454147339, 0.02629590407013893, -0.004844279494136572, -0.05541631951928139, 0.017360927537083626, 0.020466893911361694, -0.021224280819296837, -0.07295413315296173, 0.042023301124572754, 0.0594322569668293, -0.036585334688425064, 0.02208290807902813, -0.06812524050474167, -0.033928245306015015, 0.010828995145857334, -0.01928425021469593, 0.05443333461880684, 0.03216053545475006, -0.014862116426229477, 0.023882154375314713, -0.04595591500401497, -0.007399287074804306, -0.014973186887800694, 0.008724834769964218, 0.051024552434682846, 0.017253616824746132, 0.03504827991127968, -0.05443485081195831, 0.025238897651433945, 0.040995847433805466, 0.05661574378609657, -0.029403693974018097, -0.030093252658843994, 0.02439606375992298, -0.009183316491544247, 0.05090103670954704, -0.008627296425402164, 0.02765941619873047, -0.0014313568826764822, 0.03939986601471901, -0.03412312641739845, -0.035731762647628784, 0.013726788572967052, -0.04779743403196335, -0.06725174188613892, -0.003050667466595769, -0.01839859038591385, -0.002359170699492097, -0.004733729176223278, 0.019323643296957016, 0.06135401502251625, 0.03700827434659004, 0.041782964020967484, -0.057786136865615845, -0.04173716902732849, 0.018968375399708748, -0.006168418098241091, -0.015693392604589462, 0.019795306026935577, -0.0009281203965656459, -0.052673667669296265, -0.056545961648225784, -0.023447275161743164, -0.07761676609516144, -0.005722921807318926, 0.05743393674492836, 0.03326055407524109, 0.024266354739665985, 0.01615058071911335, 0.01212954893708229, 0.044229160994291306, -0.030844107270240784, 0.03122747875750065, -0.011565100401639938, -0.023613642901182175, 0.03139132261276245, -0.0014028422301635146, -0.020725272595882416, -0.05945345759391785, 0.012284810654819012, -0.057631220668554306, -0.03596694394946098, 0.06068198010325432, 0.004531489219516516, -0.02215401642024517, -0.08157730102539062, -0.049626514315605164, -0.029396725818514824, 0.019090743735432625, -0.015985533595085144, -0.06556503474712372, 0.07202542573213577, -0.04175311699509621, 0.009254910983145237, -0.05457407236099243, -0.018919695168733597, -0.05416098237037659, -0.05209340155124664, -0.05139744654297829, -0.05567089840769768, -0.014980540610849857, -0.005607672967016697, 0.013369799591600895, -0.019478730857372284, -0.04299920052289963, -0.07671233266592026, 0.05805978551506996, 0.030902504920959473, -0.020013127475976944, 0.029776424169540405, 0.017811011523008347, 0.014187180437147617, -0.010866940952837467, -0.04799969866871834, 0.018127495422959328, -0.059124309569597244, 0.027929581701755524, -0.05693359300494194, 0.013827295042574406, -0.06215544417500496, -0.005633831024169922, -0.033650610595941544, 0.04756389185786247, 0.0521535687148571, 0.004472776316106319, -0.0022015031427145004, -0.03668343648314476, 0.015356307849287987, 0.00849916785955429, -0.024485571309924126, 0.015857886523008347, -0.03874902054667473, -0.06112443655729294, 0.0091602373868227, 0.006682794075459242, -0.04718612879514694, 0.00446940865367651, 0.049237627536058426, 0.03571215271949768, 0.013393724337220192, -0.02291519194841385, 0.036346856504678726, 0.01523821335285902, -0.002970981178805232, -0.02792927622795105, 0.004119073506444693, -0.06555798649787903, 0.030958810821175575, -0.015020465478301048, -0.00604495033621788, 0.014705014415085316, 0.04236443340778351, -0.04462280124425888, 0.0370279923081398, -0.07824353873729706, -0.022384291514754295, 0.010034214705228806, -0.025394104421138763, -0.045125652104616165, -0.023323848843574524, -0.043080054223537445, -0.00036932071088813245, -0.0496581494808197, 0.02636357955634594, 0.002304508350789547, 0.009485360234975815, 0.019342612475156784, 0.007969917729496956, -0.060604412108659744, -0.036831196397542953, 0.06415321677923203, 0.004722392652183771, -0.06465264409780502, 0.025478437542915344, 0.058249425143003464, 0.008661351166665554, -0.021763140335679054, 0.01528058759868145, 0.04150238633155823, -0.05318453162908554, -0.052147842943668365, -0.009784375317394733, 0.0405811108648777, 0.04488050565123558, 0.049492426216602325, -0.06558659672737122, 0.011433080770075321, 0.006402595899999142, 0.017571337521076202, 0.01997646503150463, 0.043160926550626755, -0.04177570715546608, 0.015249603427946568, 0.012280465103685856, -0.016496162861585617, -0.07907132804393768, 0.027239443734288216, -0.06514354795217514, -0.0173471812158823, -0.03967251628637314, -0.03108757920563221, 0.05423504486680031, 0.051122117787599564, 0.009720287285745144, -0.062090132385492325, -0.04147839918732643, -0.05481741204857826, 0.05012683570384979, 0.010049703530967236, -0.06756382435560226, 0.015678346157073975, 0.019956769421696663, 0.005783920641988516, -0.015729257836937904, -0.02821969799697399, -0.0042854780331254005, -0.03780854865908623, 0.010979822836816311, 0.03547687456011772, 0.0001656668755458668, -0.03727740794420242, 0.002879330888390541, 0.03536689281463623, -0.04762614890933037, 0.026877811178565025, 0.03208894655108452, 0.0131677919998765, -0.004333429504185915, 0.003891235450282693, 0.05075262859463692, -0.06310957670211792, -0.0038133603520691395, 0.07201145589351654, -0.06998420506715775, 0.024118700996041298, -0.06476370990276337, -0.02101965993642807, -0.03372872620820999, -0.052049316465854645, -0.010934315621852875, -0.033427152782678604, -0.0056899660266935825, -0.07385849207639694, 0.012561020441353321, 0.00969489011913538, -0.07653409242630005, 0.005497192032635212, 0.011170584708452225, -0.0009776049992069602, -0.014247354120016098, 0.010355452075600624, -0.03750494867563248, 0.0009043776663020253, 0.00908643938601017, -0.04481850937008858, -0.04434119537472725, 0.012618920765817165, 0.050360243767499924, 0.06024029478430748, -0.012018617242574692, 0.024399731308221817, -0.007204724941402674, -0.016488557681441307, -0.021369634196162224, -0.04936714097857475, -0.04333898425102234, 0.010935423895716667, 0.022304946556687355, 0.027384577319025993, -0.04429631680250168, -0.02556362934410572, 0.020456455647945404, 0.012049085460603237, -0.019758649170398712, 0.026468677446246147, 0.007011503912508488, 0.026681644842028618, -0.03085307963192463, -0.03638751432299614, 0.06615660339593887, -0.03663279861211777, -0.010423175059258938, 0.014389937743544579, 0.051262859255075455, -0.0220705047249794, 0.0025614737533032894, 0.013863745145499706, -0.011344732716679573, -0.0016599083319306374, 0.01676812954246998, -0.053949709981679916, -0.02677220106124878, -0.019328523427248, -0.01194380596280098, 0.03960590809583664, 0.03760545700788498, 0.015361162833869457, 0.03543832153081894, -0.03915444016456604, -0.024601873010396957, 0.002517404267564416, -0.04317644238471985, 0.04984165355563164, 0.02838660404086113, 0.013152693398296833, -0.048579782247543335, 0.03540506213903427, -0.03905376419425011, -0.015352652408182621, -0.026713894680142403, -0.07025662064552307, 0.006626365706324577, -0.009380322881042957, -0.01446318719536066, -0.01993384398519993, -0.035227350890636444, -0.06847673654556274, -0.018568051978945732, 0.008876221254467964, -0.007854297757148743, -0.049360018223524094, -0.011704748496413231, -0.04654654487967491, 0.006696365773677826, 0.05662338435649872, -0.04597829654812813, 0.04637597128748894, 0.008583204820752144, 0.04398466646671295, 0.051427386701107025, 0.006089605391025543, 0.03356444463133812, -0.04430438578128815, -0.010871096514165401, 0.0323379784822464, 0.02378048747777939, -0.03465570509433746, -0.01596430130302906, -0.026327118277549744, -0.058587949723005295, -0.024394934996962547, -0.02962445095181465, 0.013518261723220348, -0.04705008491873741, -0.06041492521762848, 0.06007690355181694, 0.007498913444578648, -0.01526192668825388, -0.07291886955499649, -0.004113117698580027, 0.054268792271614075, -0.01722991093993187, -0.05117266625165939, -0.03024781122803688, -0.07964779436588287, -0.00485615897923708, -0.08279046416282654, -0.023974856361746788, -0.013833540491759777, 0.05093048885464668, 0.037411175668239594, -0.025343893095850945, -0.0314645878970623, -0.0491112545132637, 0.021261626854538918, 0.012735344469547272, 0.027941308915615082, -0.005646852310746908, -0.009421260096132755, 0.026082852855324745, -0.03106123022735119, 0.015945453196763992, 0.05926802009344101, -0.024078821763396263, -0.01183856651186943, 0.0005237908335402608, -0.026817837730050087, -0.02333947829902172, 0.026595531031489372, 0.036865901201963425, -0.01791517622768879, 0.026298440992832184, -0.0057027628645300865, -0.006408346351236105, -0.012693198397755623, -0.06540512293577194, 0.05226663872599602, -0.07037186622619629, 0.019544340670108795, -0.01181394699960947, -0.03628142178058624, -0.067040354013443, -0.024385960772633553, -0.06133882328867912, 0.002343775238841772, 0.016283202916383743, -0.0032728775404393673, -0.006464560516178608, -0.051971059292554855, 0.0014876192435622215, -0.012894665822386742, -0.03175392746925354, -0.011240063235163689, 0.027768846601247787, 0.04271437227725983, -0.049243878573179245, -0.012792911380529404, -0.04209641367197037, 0.0233918409794569, -0.037245482206344604, 0.023420963436365128, 0.004303740803152323, 0.04847234860062599, -0.05535973235964775, 0.045901600271463394, -0.048113420605659485, -0.011642522178590298, 0.026696370914578438, -0.04471886157989502, -0.0028652497567236423, -0.020230421796441078, 0.008479941636323929, 0.030406609177589417, 0.02353876270353794, -0.027420349419116974, 0.02217133343219757, 0.0414540059864521, -0.03413541987538338, -0.021021710708737373, -0.026601281017065048, -0.04281970113515854, 0.008192010223865509, 0.06270645558834076, -0.003348610131070018, -0.07155312597751617, 0.0530141144990921, -0.00923827476799488, 0.011032314971089363, -0.004419228993356228, 0.006100096274167299, -0.018382403999567032, -0.016983715817332268, -0.041022080928087234, 0.04674315080046654, 0.03629971295595169, -0.035264670848846436, 0.03871434926986694, 0.012042483314871788, -0.03423845022916794, -0.030808614566922188 ]
Using the two-component model, we analyze Bose-Einstein correlations in pp collisions at the center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV, measured by the CMS Collaboration at the LHC, and compare results with the $\tau$-model. We utilize data described by the double ratios with an average pair transverse momentum $0\le k_T\le 1.0$ GeV and six intervals described by the reconstructed charged particle multiplicity as $N_{\rm trk}^{\rm offline}$. The estimated ranges are 1-4 fm for the magnitude of extension of emitting source expressed by the exponential function $\exp(-RQ)$ and 0.4-0.5 fm for that by the Gaussian distribution $\exp(-(RQ)^2))$, respectively. Moreover, we estimate the upper limits of the 3-pion BEC to test the two-component model and investigate the role of the long-range correlation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17763v2
[ -0.03605589270591736, -0.020017890259623528, 0.03900241106748581, 0.019334493204951286, -0.0061068180948495865, -0.011939094401896, -0.02751091867685318, 0.04038301482796669, -0.046181570738554, 0.029931701719760895, -0.002746239537373185, -0.03527481481432915, -0.020074518397450447, -0.02050963044166565, -0.06098369136452675, -0.0037451775278896093, 0.031714193522930145, 0.058590274304151535, 0.009872455149888992, 0.04855925217270851, -0.03644375130534172, -0.041485998779535294, -0.03689463064074516, 0.0288992989808321, -0.015323162078857422, 0.005648179445415735, -0.02000964991748333, 0.0232547577470541, -0.04868846386671066, -0.0170291755348444, 0.06306067854166031, 0.0075237806886434555, -0.01929105632007122, -0.031954191625118256, 0.00198436644859612, -0.0012109385570511222, 0.011017207987606525, 0.056043028831481934, 0.030891623347997665, -0.012032617814838886, -0.04500303044915199, -0.06021412834525108, -0.06821597367525101, -0.002797225024551153, 0.0020417238119989634, 0.004671170841902494, -0.016571389511227608, -0.03195543959736824, -0.04155256599187851, -0.07242033630609512, 0.015684017911553383, -0.0064779664389789104, -0.01640583947300911, 0.0548967570066452, -0.04573078081011772, 0.03288475424051285, -0.03306903317570686, -0.01337883435189724, -0.045415718108415604, -0.03167157620191574, 0.016337376087903976, -0.06159336119890213, -0.012724119238555431, 0.02561330422759056, 0.0067983353510499, 0.050682906061410904, -0.04165148735046387, -0.06375877559185028, 0.010971260257065296, -0.06773640215396881, -0.014413106255233288, -0.06338274478912354, 0.01630563661456108, -0.002262093825265765, -0.04004482924938202, -0.027661701664328575, -0.013720696792006493, -0.053642794489860535, -0.04317109286785126, -0.007463378831744194, -0.052086226642131805, 0.019842028617858887, -0.03226113319396973, 0.02482552081346512, 0.021370645612478256, -0.022982632741332054, 0.04959412291646004, -0.03460321202874184, 0.011586925946176052, -0.060973938554525375, 0.004267704673111439, -0.02803218923509121, -0.03427274897694588, -0.02387123927474022, 0.03643054515123367, -0.013730275444686413, 0.07258328795433044, 0.019726427271962166, 0.029844995588064194, -0.04290176182985306, 0.03082716092467308, -0.038036227226257324, 0.038315292447805405, 0.046822015196084976, 0.012074400670826435, 0.03167146071791649, -0.02416279725730419, 0.016890207305550575, -0.06365810334682465, 0.038218360394239426, -0.02855520509183407, -0.00516849011182785, -0.022742101922631264, -0.06638215482234955, -0.05194000154733658, -0.06736403703689575, 0.023388467729091644, 0.03321605920791626, 0.04040072113275528, -0.010591652244329453, -0.03943831846117973, 0.05159896984696388, 0.018584247678518295, -0.024770425632596016, -0.021690528839826584, 0.022531017661094666, 0.043860722333192825, -0.0007660181727260351, -0.02698967047035694, -0.02669217810034752, -0.03154287859797478, -0.026486579328775406, 0.004898510407656431, -0.03293078765273094, -0.01651923358440399, -0.02762678824365139, 0.03401878476142883, -0.023060360923409462, -0.028314393013715744, 0.0008867406286299229, -0.04781591519713402, -0.06760663539171219, -0.032377392053604126, 0.0236276313662529, -0.0033906148746609688, 0.04326144605875015, -0.06076608598232269, -0.05451441928744316, -0.0007512129959650338, 0.014332507736980915, -0.0162544846534729, -0.007886719889938831, -0.0027777112554758787, -0.035357262939214706, -0.00621627876535058, -0.022556060925126076, 0.04460060968995094, 0.02466808259487152, -0.031258050352334976, 0.01826249621808529, 0.02567780390381813, -0.067591592669487, -0.030431898310780525, -0.02011353336274624, -0.017352484166622162, -0.01504877582192421, 0.0060159326530992985, -0.03816249966621399, 0.03101857751607895, -0.008740765042603016, -0.011562508530914783, -0.037624042481184006, 0.012644183821976185, -0.026467133313417435, -0.06134376302361488, -0.04970135912299156, -0.02310939133167267, -0.033671822398900986, -0.05328313633799553, 0.03260301053524017, 0.02137923054397106, 0.027674799785017967, -0.010376058518886566, -0.025412878021597862, -0.042667828500270844, 0.015591789968311787, -0.06336057931184769, -0.013963175937533379, 0.028791062533855438, -0.02873009815812111, -0.0000073741093729040585, -0.05301354080438614, 0.014182300306856632, 0.05456342175602913, -0.0376097708940506, -0.03438336402177811, 0.03156217932701111, -0.024149058386683464, -0.014144346117973328, -0.017296234145760536, -0.07522241771221161, -0.0015274154720827937, -0.03917945921421051, 0.015761008486151695, -0.019234562292695045, -0.06723223626613617, -0.0039141299203038216, 0.047684554010629654, -0.035425640642642975, -0.04209650307893753, 0.0477636344730854, -0.00727148586884141, -0.03216322138905525, 0.013902517035603523, -0.018454503268003464, 0.0027985484339296818, -0.08051459491252899, 0.06911885738372803, 0.01628158614039421, -0.030457105487585068, 0.01774950511753559, 0.018874017521739006, -0.014007717370986938, -0.04557283595204353, -0.02302258089184761, 0.05299708619713783, -0.017746884375810623, 0.04330047219991684, -0.049861978739500046, -0.009282479993999004, -0.017534151673316956, -0.059050824493169785, -0.01975918374955654, -0.06604702025651932, -0.041628479957580566, 0.017085883766412735, -0.03441973403096199, 0.0609225332736969, -0.000662571401335299, -0.05422300100326538, -0.049553439021110535, 0.023168087005615234, 0.03859981149435043, -0.0364609956741333, -0.06962968409061432, -0.04884054884314537, -0.05515109747648239, 0.018326450139284134, -0.05136319622397423, -0.03397237882018089, 0.025253338739275932, -0.048343125730752945, -0.04697893187403679, -0.041840530931949615, 0.028776420280337334, 0.025756821036338806, 0.0001374705316266045, -0.017179099842905998, -0.04079413041472435, 0.0323714017868042, -0.0037038209848105907, 0.013086127117276192, -0.03509150817990303, 0.06160007417201996, -0.03987745940685272, 0.04560595005750656, -0.03488733991980553, -0.014127266593277454, -0.05002858117222786, -0.032983943819999695, -0.0080923642963171, 0.008087831549346447, 0.040853630751371384, 0.03797832131385803, 0.0025391627568751574, 0.005116266664117575, -0.05260547250509262, -0.015057717449963093, 0.03805704042315483, -0.023357445374131203, 0.06320527195930481, 0.038921087980270386, -0.016824379563331604, -0.0712655782699585, 0.031186021864414215, -0.03976746276021004, -0.03262145817279816, -0.058433882892131805, -0.05736483260989189, 0.03731795772910118, -0.03610865771770477, -0.012046467512845993, -0.04458412155508995, -0.018412278965115547, -0.06271877884864807, -0.06410790234804153, 0.021564433351159096, -0.03342698886990547, -0.009693841449916363, -0.07032681256532669, -0.05087684467434883, -0.01965225674211979, 0.01706807129085064, 0.02350231446325779, -0.04023553431034088, 0.012127755209803581, -0.048018500208854675, -0.002767599420621991, -0.013329409062862396, -0.007267441600561142, -0.04677576199173927, -0.010576357133686543, -0.0486152283847332, -0.007947883568704128, -0.00975904893130064, 0.05157499015331268, -0.022358357906341553, -0.02250662073493004, -0.011414625681936741, -0.03186862915754318, 0.00031983977532945573, -0.03747273236513138, 0.03676634654402733, 0.0038861208595335484, -0.07445017993450165, -0.05852572247385979, 0.031693484634160995, 0.06794717907905579, 0.0398162305355072, -0.05789317935705185, -0.04055123031139374, 0.014390497468411922, 0.029878322035074234, 0.025242581963539124, 0.06702721118927002, 0.05078092962503433, -0.02211601473391056, -0.017581455409526825, -0.025500986725091934, 0.04039778932929039, -0.06549858301877975, -0.04241903871297836, -0.017508506774902344, 0.0019593702163547277, 0.033455055207014084, -0.06967733055353165, 0.0608329102396965, 0.04867792874574661, 0.06273607164621353, 0.003414223901927471, -0.03478939086198807, 0.040081385523080826, 0.023435169830918312, -0.006651199888437986, -0.009358486160635948, 0.04156484082341194, 0.03868481516838074, 0.036708515137434006, -0.027796905487775803, -0.016696861013770103, -0.009573740884661674, -0.0628882572054863, -0.05400611832737923, -0.02179236151278019, -0.0032094791531562805, 0.0354282520711422, 0.007521605119109154, 0.007917812094092369, 0.06220350041985512, -0.026405982673168182, 0.024034226313233376, -0.020824020728468895, -0.026312019675970078, -0.019496938213706017, 0.009725361131131649, -0.04423243924975395, 0.014792983420193195, 0.00734397117048502, -0.052417878061532974, -0.029986144974827766, -0.008757186122238636, -0.04964156448841095, 0.017351102083921432, -0.030355624854564667, 0.017970213666558266, 0.043117791414260864, 0.0073066889308393, 0.01597464829683304, 0.028189482167363167, -0.0005796439363621175, 0.01723432168364525, -0.05334100127220154, -0.0240924209356308, -0.011905642226338387, 0.018090348690748215, -0.023449575528502464, -0.05226782336831093, -0.024570640176534653, -0.05413587763905525, -0.05024532228708267, 0.029467975720763206, -0.0116560198366642, -0.02496151812374592, -0.07464394718408585, -0.0724506750702858, -0.03904347121715546, -0.012383349239826202, -0.02570439875125885, -0.01521675568073988, 0.06137755885720253, -0.016780268400907516, -0.0211002379655838, 0.003159391460940242, 0.018397260457277298, -0.05339112505316734, -0.06359048187732697, -0.03869754076004028, -0.025770049542188644, 0.04984501749277115, -0.040333379060029984, 0.036680739372968674, 0.014476663433015347, -0.043141789734363556, -0.07119162380695343, 0.00560171389952302, 0.02969745360314846, -0.018939636647701263, 0.038143645972013474, -0.0011048278538510203, -0.0020502775441855192, 0.010208402760326862, -0.04088694229722023, 0.010095767676830292, -0.023982372134923935, 0.06057840958237648, -0.019988248124718666, 0.02426128275692463, -0.004809509497135878, -0.0487651601433754, -0.010531703010201454, 0.015453294850885868, -0.00336193828843534, -0.008206848055124283, 0.0012323949486017227, 0.011377470567822456, 0.023782890290021896, -0.05957420915365219, -0.010088710114359856, -0.045656803995370865, -0.02121330052614212, -0.06446659564971924, -0.039346471428871155, 0.05581174045801163, -0.010468370281159878, 0.027864962816238403, 0.035716328769922256, 0.0014591595390811563, 0.054048433899879456, -0.05747472122311592, 0.013959838077425957, -0.029627390205860138, 0.031360991299152374, 0.02626727893948555, -0.03467262163758278, -0.07812686264514923, 0.006301920395344496, -0.01307049859315157, -0.051180753856897354, 0.041707832366228104, 0.023431822657585144, 0.020127614960074425, 0.02260204218327999, -0.0781988874077797, 0.04688586667180061, 0.005676610860973597, -0.0357285812497139, -0.014702098444104195, 0.002317948965355754, -0.0233545433729887, -0.028020303696393967, -0.04138590022921562, -0.03693652153015137, -0.026234332472085953, -0.011481276713311672, 0.02173703908920288, -0.016765091568231583, -0.054697223007678986, -0.009825131855905056, 0.0014802785590291023, 0.0008609712240286171, -0.049253690987825394, -0.006020200438797474, 0.02324645034968853, 0.018481699749827385, -0.041651319712400436, 0.03382120281457901, 0.04965520277619362, -0.057357825338840485, -0.06288362294435501, -0.04770195484161377, 0.006226109806448221, 0.01791139505803585, 0.05012436583638191, -0.055276691913604736, 0.02759898081421852, -0.02749628946185112, 0.05882043018937111, -0.023019319400191307, 0.046985238790512085, -0.01623149774968624, -0.02405698597431183, 0.04688704386353493, 0.0055317869409918785, -0.050446800887584686, 0.00999591313302517, -0.040827054530382156, -0.005233271513134241, 0.014755192212760448, 0.02770964242517948, 0.044259559363126755, 0.06711781769990921, -0.020591389387845993, -0.07242277264595032, -0.02125290036201477, -0.03826218470931053, 0.06529473513364792, -0.03222311660647392, -0.0550227016210556, -0.020910145714879036, 0.053042300045490265, 0.014402384869754314, 0.002512692240998149, 0.02708914317190647, 0.0027296284679323435, -0.024663330987095833, -0.03185416758060455, 0.024522505700588226, 0.008126791566610336, 0.003051234409213066, -0.026924697682261467, 0.05206690728664398, -0.05510560795664787, 0.06267034262418747, 0.015354357659816742, 0.045295387506484985, 0.02325955592095852, 0.02793177403509617, 0.02122911997139454, -0.07768632471561432, 0.005267773289233446, 0.05651378259062767, -0.054113250225782394, -0.016935478895902634, -0.027182625606656075, -0.009719980880618095, 0.027394749224185944, -0.068978451192379, -0.040842290967702866, -0.019958393648266792, -0.0013383794575929642, -0.046635646373033524, 0.0700647309422493, -0.005735023878514767, -0.07213756442070007, -0.011833828873932362, 0.033234741538763046, -0.07346799224615097, -0.017556827515363693, -0.027071882039308548, -0.06445278972387314, -0.054784610867500305, -0.00959757436066866, -0.050805769860744476, -0.039901673793792725, -0.03995894268155098, 0.04929537698626518, 0.03233442083001137, -0.004068824462592602, 0.021390970796346664, 0.0003722083638422191, -0.025870678946375847, -0.022730084136128426, -0.0492166168987751, -0.05739147961139679, 0.021197609603405, 0.06490197777748108, 0.023548081517219543, -0.048586584627628326, -0.013105075806379318, 0.05370457470417023, 0.04031616076827049, 0.00035217570257373154, -0.022149180993437767, 0.010011861100792885, 0.04097919911146164, -0.019720427691936493, -0.02988637425005436, -0.011354564689099789, -0.05531899258494377, -0.027961835265159607, -0.017117273062467575, 0.03889184445142746, -0.021025273948907852, 0.06063917279243469, 0.02083246037364006, -0.03620920330286026, 0.010272449813783169, 0.010090098716318607, -0.04236122965812683, 0.021169159561395645, -0.05122942849993706, -0.013605648651719093, -0.026048289611935616, 0.030496926978230476, -0.025169337168335915, 0.008155531249940395, -0.0679728090763092, 0.03423512354493141, -0.02841600775718689, 0.02283311076462269, 0.011902941390872002, 0.04535004496574402, 0.0319523923099041, -0.06172467768192291, 0.050894349813461304, -0.017945580184459686, 0.03530348837375641, -0.04912666603922844, -0.06113304942846298, 0.0025788946077227592, 0.028226403519511223, -0.04705648124217987, -0.036121029406785965, -0.03137362748384476, -0.036224041134119034, -0.006667322479188442, 0.05328062176704407, -0.026463579386472702, -0.06140017509460449, 0.03384428098797798, 0.01628035120666027, -0.056394483894109726, 0.0497126542031765, -0.012523346580564976, 0.03550172969698906, 0.027967968955636024, -0.0032495115883648396, 0.04452742636203766, -0.03270129859447479, -0.0036701036151498556, -0.06888043880462646, -0.003789012786000967, 0.04635947570204735, -0.010136827826499939, -0.00027559412410482764, -0.006255651358515024, -0.01435811910778284, -0.07119519263505936, -0.033237237483263016, -0.013890101574361324, 0.01168661005795002, 0.0012455276446416974, -0.025055453181266785, 0.01907847262918949, 0.03940986841917038, -0.04412168636918068, -0.0750230923295021, -0.013797879219055176, -0.015217497013509274, 0.026354413479566574, -0.009261038154363632, -0.028853900730609894, -0.04225756600499153, -0.028887543827295303, -0.07882560044527054, -0.046283792704343796, -0.03663131594657898, 0.022797798737883568, 0.028883757069706917, 0.031703632324934006, -0.03572425991296768, -0.008575807325541973, -0.01811355911195278, -0.014380414970219135, 0.004393239039927721, 0.002710504224523902, -0.0038589690811932087, 0.018375515937805176, -0.053502943366765976, 0.005325235426425934, 0.046860698610544205, -0.036345113068819046, -0.009192109107971191, -0.012405273504555225, 0.015341208316385746, -0.034873463213443756, -0.028189729899168015, 0.03492355719208717, 0.01657145656645298, -0.004222761373966932, 0.013814163394272327, -0.0609416626393795, -0.03235401585698128, -0.03719521313905716, 0.05229273810982704, -0.009481508284807205, 0.03527556359767914, -0.004824801813811064, -0.026302983984351158, -0.055221132934093475, -0.03530731424689293, -0.014332160353660583, 0.009080229327082634, 0.02126268856227398, -0.03570035472512245, 0.006288006901741028, -0.05704926326870918, -0.003165961941704154, -0.0329391285777092, 0.03337202966213226, -0.03805023431777954, -0.029138818383216858, 0.05158297345042229, -0.060999106615781784, 0.009931527078151703, -0.02615213580429554, 0.004189810715615749, -0.012388537637889385, -0.008178122341632843, -0.01707877777516842, 0.04392406344413757, -0.009229982271790504, -0.01543043740093708, -0.016244616359472275, -0.019825585186481476, 0.022434081882238388, -0.05852789431810379, 0.0360446460545063, -0.03877062350511551, 0.009637236595153809, 0.01604042388498783, 0.048750054091215134, -0.05049598589539528, 0.057881105691194534, 0.02485550194978714, -0.013065313920378685, -0.023428089916706085, -0.029416710138320923, -0.014006008394062519, 0.03580212593078613, -0.009354817681014538, -0.027726642787456512, -0.029452010989189148, 0.03413677588105202, 0.009876294992864132, -0.021629000082612038, 0.02418840490281582, 0.013678607530891895, -0.048214733600616455, -0.06563232094049454, -0.040453046560287476, 0.04921847954392433, -0.004584035836160183, -0.03681178390979767, 0.022845106199383736, 0.030297407880425453, -0.021778954192996025, -0.03575998544692993 ]
We propose a method for learning topology-preserving data representations (dimensionality reduction). The method aims to provide topological similarity between the data manifold and its latent representation via enforcing the similarity in topological features (clusters, loops, 2D voids, etc.) and their localization. The core of the method is the minimization of the Representation Topology Divergence (RTD) between original high-dimensional data and low-dimensional representation in latent space. RTD minimization provides closeness in topological features with strong theoretical guarantees. We develop a scheme for RTD differentiation and apply it as a loss term for the autoencoder. The proposed method "RTD-AE" better preserves the global structure and topology of the data manifold than state-of-the-art competitors as measured by linear correlation, triplet distance ranking accuracy, and Wasserstein distance between persistence barcodes.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00136v2
[ -0.037515245378017426, -0.0734199658036232, 0.05000930279493332, 0.04108234867453575, -0.025987854227423668, -0.037738580256700516, -0.0304254200309515, 0.027831759303808212, -0.0006419634446501732, 0.028930723667144775, -0.04935162141919136, 0.001553078182041645, -0.06977231800556183, -0.05022941529750824, -0.009415541775524616, 0.00022633974731434137, 0.05938578024506569, -0.019683947786688805, -0.04037601500749588, 0.07253213971853256, -0.026535995304584503, 0.01327094528824091, -0.011964203789830208, 0.00866701826453209, -0.022930264472961426, -0.01315645594149828, -0.05391015112400055, 0.031125647947192192, -0.0478152334690094, 0.015014049597084522, 0.052862413227558136, -0.026496291160583496, 0.014224298298358917, -0.034839753061532974, -0.03842541575431824, -0.0022390044759958982, 0.002059044549241662, -0.010172365233302116, 0.04049927368760109, -0.06925779581069946, 0.013460913673043251, -0.045192692428827286, -0.05624862387776375, -0.021897459402680397, -0.002549869939684868, -0.018508097156882286, -0.042796846479177475, 0.006338202860206366, -0.028488844633102417, -0.06176064908504486, 0.057989757508039474, -0.01118194218724966, -0.044938601553440094, 0.03881503641605377, -0.011548465117812157, 0.050407033413648605, -0.010583285242319107, -0.011817715130746365, -0.026761149987578392, -0.013315376825630665, 0.034602321684360504, -0.05140680819749832, -0.015065265819430351, 0.012523112818598747, 0.015003059059381485, 0.04595327749848366, -0.021077606827020645, -0.07780464738607407, -0.05349057912826538, -0.015026147477328777, 0.030050616711378098, -0.05495505779981613, 0.0152575159445405, 0.040724124759435654, -0.05732221156358719, -0.04151444882154465, -0.017711790278553963, -0.04786054044961929, -0.0007412989507429302, -0.005892437417060137, -0.06700069457292557, 0.045582763850688934, 0.04389314725995064, 0.03768644854426384, 0.017833678051829338, 0.010340608656406403, 0.030958684161305428, 0.014212350361049175, 0.03695689141750336, -0.014964555390179157, 0.027826039120554924, -0.022808948531746864, -0.04526159539818764, 0.00420593935996294, 0.06940805166959763, -0.03224257007241249, 0.05442005395889282, 0.05369893088936806, 0.01831604354083538, -0.040171582251787186, -0.01742376945912838, -0.05678148940205574, 0.002922322368249297, 0.050923902541399, -0.00133809435646981, -0.025862110778689384, 0.002602137392386794, -0.009705633856356144, -0.039676230400800705, 0.044607389718294144, -0.032449498772621155, -0.005556244868785143, 0.025601878762245178, -0.015555936843156815, -0.05338819697499275, -0.03306182846426964, 0.06238020956516266, -0.04963032156229019, 0.06718140095472336, -0.003364966018125415, -0.009875991381704807, 0.03634139895439148, 0.015982279554009438, 0.0077585787512362, -0.05100331827998161, -0.021342620253562927, 0.05324757471680641, -0.00435420498251915, -0.027024362236261368, -0.044615309685468674, 0.0012462662998586893, 0.002313929609954357, 0.02172340452671051, -0.049197763204574585, 0.022592324763536453, -0.010629820637404919, 0.011843889020383358, -0.03647039085626602, 0.03851427510380745, 0.0379064604640007, -0.02349032461643219, -0.05638333037495613, -0.017139744013547897, -0.022717615589499474, -0.04024762287735939, 0.013856785371899605, -0.03922400251030922, -0.033932216465473175, 0.04581480100750923, 0.02910488471388817, 0.02030564844608307, -0.040446601808071136, 0.025725772604346275, 0.047551270574331284, -0.006582253612577915, -0.02965577505528927, 0.06649395823478699, 0.007254081312566996, -0.04911400377750397, 0.019046489149332047, 0.05391397699713707, -0.021062269806861877, 0.036035146564245224, 0.01637183502316475, 0.002680039731785655, -0.014359633438289165, 0.010935666970908642, 0.022698478773236275, 0.003809558227658272, 0.01576852612197399, -0.031562648713588715, -0.0365641713142395, 0.013271532952785492, -0.045154981315135956, -0.06584818661212921, -0.03739907220005989, -0.006919386330991983, -0.021314041689038277, -0.025267556309700012, -0.009517304599285126, 0.01225193589925766, 0.04502374678850174, -0.007093326188623905, -0.029599444940686226, -0.04381582885980606, -0.0061568571254611015, -0.07391650229692459, -0.024970844388008118, 0.030978349968791008, 0.021876152604818344, -0.02346699684858322, -0.03488351032137871, -0.0016919777262955904, 0.0061811404302716255, -0.006136371288448572, -0.07058004289865494, -0.003923059441149235, -0.018546875566244125, 0.013279467821121216, -0.025077277794480324, -0.07832831889390945, -0.017711373046040535, -0.0503305047750473, 0.02490869350731373, -0.021376365795731544, -0.03447852283716202, -0.027804909273982048, 0.07152752578258514, -0.0001016617170535028, 0.03982298821210861, 0.02645035646855831, 0.037920743227005005, 0.03971705213189125, -0.033989764750003815, 0.0028151574078947306, 0.04016882926225662, -0.09217390418052673, 0.022905511781573296, -0.024892712011933327, 0.023240432143211365, 0.035825543105602264, 0.022235717624425888, 0.001930710976012051, -0.03515684977173805, -0.00661005824804306, 0.04468920826911926, 0.06345666944980621, 0.02834179252386093, -0.0676736831665039, -0.031913578510284424, -0.001178642502054572, -0.07352078706026077, -0.03704643249511719, -0.025477154180407524, -0.04184512421488762, 0.018743451684713364, -0.06022997945547104, 0.03302489593625069, -0.0453667975962162, -0.04119197651743889, -0.04885106906294823, -0.018387077376246452, 0.06201974302530289, -0.01871560327708721, -0.04711328446865082, -0.0570574626326561, -0.05166151374578476, 0.03200410678982735, -0.04538222402334213, -0.0341188982129097, -0.0032775686122477055, -0.05555395036935806, 0.0031424821354448795, -0.03881143033504486, -0.0017125668236985803, 0.05389535054564476, -0.015089538879692554, -0.017599474638700485, -0.030292127281427383, 0.06293011456727982, 0.00572980847209692, -0.013072147965431213, -0.06613210588693619, 0.00992906279861927, 0.0023247271310538054, 0.010895672254264355, -0.012461855076253414, -0.008280286565423012, -0.0243308674544096, -0.05297277122735977, 0.006070327013731003, -0.009222105145454407, 0.05340271815657616, 0.014201495796442032, -0.008948829025030136, 0.037608370184898376, -0.04798470437526703, -0.028196347877383232, 0.018811363726854324, 0.04337521269917488, 0.03996584936976433, 0.04172303527593613, -0.011143757030367851, -0.07563833147287369, -0.04307842627167702, -0.031430210918188095, -0.00008805997640592977, -0.06651711463928223, -0.04810857027769089, 0.017864428460597992, -0.06101388484239578, 0.008182327263057232, -0.048698682337999344, -0.013279501348733902, -0.054200172424316406, -0.029537511989474297, -0.0673934817314148, -0.005588897969573736, 0.04463403299450874, -0.04958943650126457, -0.04384732246398926, -0.022631468251347542, 0.010285871103405952, -0.0001226747699547559, -0.02523529902100563, -0.035683345049619675, -0.06090865284204483, 0.02549951709806919, 0.05677337944507599, 0.022699497640132904, -0.04948120936751366, -0.0011072452180087566, -0.048886992037296295, 0.03533849120140076, 0.024121606722474098, 0.0347188338637352, -0.005400069057941437, 0.008582832291722298, 0.029342614114284515, 0.034969620406627655, 0.011348181404173374, 0.0070774490013718605, 0.016104841604828835, -0.012829002924263477, -0.06676596403121948, -0.045777853578329086, 0.015435123816132545, 0.063330739736557, -0.015060513280332088, 0.00794432032853365, -0.005780133884400129, 0.029207510873675346, 0.010019104927778244, 0.0008340274216607213, 0.03784434124827385, 0.06413263082504272, 0.0005408422439359128, -0.05055155232548714, -0.024470007047057152, 0.005963337607681751, -0.006013758480548859, 0.06096447631716728, 0.030121471732854843, -0.0071647679433226585, 0.04175831750035286, -0.08302531391382217, 0.06653302907943726, 0.04884353652596474, 0.05155176669359207, 0.023402713239192963, -0.03135635331273079, 0.005378385540097952, 0.0008730682893656194, 0.017212701961398125, -0.008881899528205395, 0.02421003393828869, -0.011467435397207737, 0.05001460760831833, -0.035180892795324326, -0.05451361462473869, -0.03337465599179268, -0.0746317133307457, -0.050239842385053635, 0.011909244582057, -0.045795243233442307, -0.013283230364322662, 0.03559686243534088, -0.03338897228240967, 0.06707755476236343, -0.02842002548277378, 0.002537844469770789, 0.03199003264307976, -0.055107034742832184, 0.02388419210910797, -0.03768378868699074, 0.0049971239641308784, -0.0008232262916862965, -0.00475142290815711, 0.026637328788638115, -0.05176292359828949, 0.02739313617348671, -0.0556357279419899, 0.0407036691904068, 0.02857980877161026, -0.035675931721925735, -0.0014701412292197347, 0.044272251427173615, -0.0164968129247427, 0.04181969165802002, -0.004247293341904879, -0.01118502113968134, -0.0029619657434523106, 0.009793244302272797, -0.022132327780127525, -0.024154577404260635, -0.019783245399594307, -0.028786994516849518, -0.02492288313806057, -0.029628753662109375, -0.028098465874791145, -0.018767470493912697, -0.010454094968736172, 0.01122063584625721, -0.06275194138288498, -0.0012246803380548954, -0.020125212147831917, -0.0015644492814317346, -0.04763447120785713, -0.04473424702882767, 0.04532675817608833, -0.061775099486112595, -0.007446893956512213, -0.050733502954244614, -0.02323099598288536, -0.01903281919658184, -0.04752889275550842, -0.03182520344853401, -0.05463182181119919, 0.01783994399011135, -0.033659543842077255, 0.04840807989239693, 0.02443276159465313, -0.016368422657251358, -0.07173233479261398, 0.0061376020312309265, -0.022426702082157135, 0.007502137217670679, 0.04760538786649704, 0.007115023676306009, 0.04354548826813698, 0.04019632190465927, -0.03695295378565788, 0.023912284523248672, 0.015307596884667873, -0.01173287071287632, -0.03350201994180679, 0.0307571142911911, -0.05302329733967781, -0.021857719868421555, -0.007952717132866383, 0.010261069051921368, 0.06725174933671951, -0.060598183423280716, -0.04031388461589813, -0.02032286860048771, 0.025853607803583145, -0.040906306356191635, -0.05884981155395508, 0.004912639502435923, -0.03401777893304825, -0.06564421206712723, -0.015412889420986176, 0.0017454737098887563, 0.00795031152665615, -0.027500946074724197, -0.001479307422414422, 0.03860725089907646, -0.009841063991189003, -0.006812261417508125, 0.014414637349545956, 0.025134366005659103, 0.023471761494874954, 0.0008577015832997859, -0.06578031182289124, -0.08483001589775085, -0.012411030009388924, -0.038892559707164764, 0.0012382277054712176, 0.033335573971271515, 0.006599002983421087, -0.004421052057296038, 0.014897776767611504, -0.07907707989215851, 0.02024303562939167, 0.028291266411542892, -0.04464586824178696, 0.029871026054024696, 0.05013412982225418, -0.004207050893455744, 0.01595425046980381, 0.021011294797062874, -0.009000042453408241, 0.012089467607438564, -0.058534346520900726, -0.006488862447440624, -0.02759365551173687, -0.02860899642109871, 0.013886205852031708, 0.07940072566270828, 0.022353412583470345, -0.062389325350522995, -0.02218332700431347, 0.01239967904984951, -0.011561713181436062, -0.0383836105465889, 0.006051222328096628, 0.06603296101093292, -0.03529701754450798, -0.050404682755470276, 0.032977309077978134, -0.032128117978572845, 0.013800079002976418, 0.003990160766988993, -0.05644400045275688, 0.022769324481487274, 0.03485824167728424, -0.006282858084887266, -0.03740683197975159, 0.019852180033922195, -0.0493004284799099, 0.02366599626839161, -0.023779548704624176, 0.02069935016334057, -0.04175645485520363, -0.03553425148129463, -0.03183864429593086, 0.006463830359280109, 0.05819474160671234, 0.04685506969690323, 0.03162452206015587, 0.05930935591459274, -0.013362180441617966, -0.020232977345585823, 0.002819888526573777, -0.017073500901460648, 0.002309215720742941, -0.03641609475016594, 0.016412027180194855, 0.018782969564199448, 0.05011777952313423, -0.015800626948475838, -0.012753977440297604, 0.041237663477659225, -0.004007358569651842, -0.038911521434783936, 0.028221260756254196, 0.007554641924798489, -0.029107922688126564, -0.04469115287065506, 0.012295504100620747, 0.06645181030035019, -0.04299098253250122, 0.0527728907763958, 0.021639205515384674, 0.014745633117854595, 0.061507679522037506, -0.03125379979610443, 0.02567846141755581, -0.022314101457595825, -0.027289465069770813, 0.06953954696655273, -0.014302930794656277, -0.036767132580280304, 0.0013462891802191734, -0.0007871627458371222, -0.019203150644898415, -0.050801072269678116, 0.015677912160754204, 0.020148148760199547, -0.009523995220661163, -0.06104164570569992, 0.042859096080064774, -0.03510219603776932, -0.059887077659368515, 0.020758483558893204, 0.014915107749402523, -0.09031467884778976, -0.007458055391907692, -0.01056609395891428, -0.07119641453027725, 0.007897607050836086, 0.02203185297548771, -0.01527069415897131, -0.03994568809866905, -0.04550483822822571, 0.03995894640684128, 0.03294288367033005, -0.006901267915964127, 0.02861437201499939, -0.027123404666781425, -0.07974088937044144, -0.02334195375442505, -0.035363174974918365, -0.005678233690559864, 0.01399016659706831, 0.030971860513091087, 0.037439145147800446, -0.02917497791349888, -0.03667238727211952, 0.0253366157412529, -0.05391526222229004, -0.007955499924719334, -0.02283708192408085, -0.02948116511106491, 0.06818743050098419, -0.03791018947958946, -0.013992490246891975, -0.005945187993347645, -0.029211705550551414, 0.010004779323935509, -0.012966668233275414, 0.00944547913968563, 0.017860205844044685, 0.019567450508475304, 0.016723114997148514, -0.05202766880393028, -0.03221549466252327, -0.014634400606155396, -0.034705549478530884, 0.004504237323999405, -0.07949686050415039, 0.017508577555418015, 0.005918510258197784, 0.02046307362616062, 0.0022938598413020372, 0.05022253841161728, -0.05951269716024399, 0.018584031611680984, -0.017326457425951958, 0.027152562513947487, -0.019880278035998344, -0.008811167441308498, 0.019971946254372597, 0.018010232597589493, 0.03972548991441727, 0.0032801602501422167, -0.013032105751335621, -0.05284494906663895, -0.02415439859032631, 0.013704657554626465, -0.058572955429553986, -0.016140811145305634, -0.042301490902900696, 0.032602015882730484, -0.054336126893758774, -0.03137645870447159, -0.02705508843064308, -0.04868847504258156, -0.06498789042234421, -0.017177341505885124, -0.036076948046684265, -0.03303271904587746, -0.041191473603248596, 0.0052633159793913364, 0.002572867553681135, -0.013562824577093124, 0.03815120831131935, 0.04555736482143402, -0.005861971527338028, -0.04316718131303787, -0.06659054011106491, -0.028767511248588562, 0.009663070552051067, -0.006801845971494913, -0.050904687494039536, 0.010098443366587162, -0.06311742216348648, -0.0766574889421463, 0.00019179120135959238, 0.030788294970989227, 0.032237663865089417, -0.03531873598694801, -0.0411270372569561, -0.001180261024273932, -0.021183187142014503, -0.028653353452682495, -0.06735380738973618, 0.016457101330161095, 0.02554062195122242, -0.0002375730109633878, -0.05380682647228241, -0.06572986394166946, -0.0764533057808876, -0.008211895823478699, -0.08397179841995239, 0.02976049855351448, 0.016556385904550552, 0.022451750934123993, 0.02570243924856186, -0.022258397191762924, -0.016414407640695572, -0.053136661648750305, -0.017557669430971146, -0.026507269591093063, -0.014331853948533535, 0.012915595434606075, 0.03878694772720337, -0.026141174137592316, -0.0556008480489254, -0.030476871877908707, 0.0024026886094361544, -0.009988165460526943, -0.000497662927955389, 0.004938340280205011, 0.014554458670318127, -0.007794724777340889, 0.03248195722699165, 0.06894361227750778, -0.002331892494112253, 0.0671050176024437, -0.02807672694325447, 0.016685763373970985, -0.055428724735975266, -0.027707384899258614, -0.027239147573709488, -0.07065720111131668, -0.008891935460269451, -0.006036929786205292, -0.02380540780723095, -0.05163844674825668, -0.00028188206488266587, -0.0765557661652565, 0.012694123201072216, -0.009227089583873749, -0.04642665758728981, 0.012337574735283852, -0.035956114530563354, -0.01337406225502491, -0.01020536758005619, -0.02795972302556038, -0.05348380655050278, -0.004248687066137791, 0.011535405181348324, -0.012837329879403114, 0.002305783098563552, -0.03397645056247711, -0.02105003222823143, -0.0077763814479112625, 0.008294101804494858, -0.0022605203557759523, 0.05519796907901764, -0.03394563868641853, -0.014899499714374542, -0.05912156403064728, -0.07692799717187881, -0.031988631933927536, -0.044785842299461365, -0.02399909310042858, -0.07561255246400833, 0.027491606771945953, -0.010133161209523678, 0.03288445249199867, -0.041756756603717804, 0.04613792151212692, 0.05796193331480026, 0.002033652039244771, 0.000052807285101152956, 0.041317593306303024, -0.02529039792716503, 0.07273126393556595, 0.014814606867730618, -0.006620327010750771, -0.03348560631275177, 0.003952813800424337, -0.020615961402654648, -0.038298141211271286, 0.00872736144810915, -0.01909751631319523, -0.009879126213490963, -0.07021184265613556, -0.019710030406713486, -0.00711771659553051, -0.0009546037763357162, -0.05415266007184982, 0.005503857508301735, -0.013412662781774998, -0.04531324282288551, -0.06023523584008217 ]
We study the motion of a domain wall on an ultrathin magnetic film using the magneto-optical Kerr effect (MOKE). At tiny magnetic fields, the wall creeps only via thermal activation over the pinning centers present in the sample. Our results show that this creep dynamics is highly intermittent and correlated. A localized instability triggers a cascade, akin to aftershocks following a large earthquake, where the pinned wall undergoes large reorganizations in a compact active region for a few seconds. Surprisingly, the size and shape of these reorganizations display the same scale-free statistics of the depinning avalanches in agreement with the quenched Kardar-Parisi-Zhang universality class.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12898v1
[ 0.00007545683183707297, -0.003442414803430438, 0.03703886643052101, -0.04188257083296776, -0.0005507590831257403, -0.006685883272439241, 0.03157621994614601, 0.018411528319120407, 0.016411541029810905, 0.007297581993043423, 0.03782596439123154, -0.033513203263282776, -0.03719549626111984, -0.06876464933156967, -0.0547231025993824, 0.06536225229501724, 0.08116747438907623, 0.015584751032292843, -0.05913543328642845, 0.08464395999908447, 0.016997486352920532, -0.045282453298568726, -0.013893814757466316, 0.053254950791597366, -0.0038113747723400593, -0.040361300110816956, -0.06430988013744354, 0.03940148279070854, 0.047424424439668655, -0.013169936835765839, 0.06723352521657944, -0.03662264719605446, -0.008356018923223019, -0.04061825945973396, -0.03973451629281044, -0.007466654758900404, -0.0022953327279537916, 0.06086992472410202, 0.009031047113239765, 0.023456057533621788, 0.007080099545419216, -0.04437081143260002, -0.03329009935259819, -0.018183400854468346, -0.03151591122150421, -0.07387245446443558, -0.029743103310465813, 0.02312617562711239, -0.046082690358161926, -0.035404693335294724, 0.02369426190853119, 0.04448715224862099, 0.011017636395990849, 0.0392954982817173, -0.013420605100691319, -0.01326522696763277, -0.0028937894385308027, 0.00045743846567347646, -0.023261981084942818, 0.013184787705540657, -0.009319446980953217, -0.03090888261795044, -0.004546539857983589, -0.04601983353495598, -0.036521900445222855, 0.022028179839253426, -0.011043340899050236, -0.03553518280386925, 0.0025795777328312397, -0.07416388392448425, 0.04943053424358368, -0.07634563744068146, 0.021599486470222473, -0.01872123032808304, -0.0734240785241127, 0.01025410182774067, -0.02516487054526806, 0.04092833399772644, -0.012140474282205105, 0.043319664895534515, 0.004417019430547953, 0.030171459540724754, 0.006815400905907154, 0.04929070174694061, 0.03311777859926224, 0.008270435966551304, 0.05327886715531349, -0.03695642575621605, -0.01693381555378437, -0.03520689159631729, 0.059090208262205124, -0.042708080261945724, -0.022738732397556305, -0.01653951033949852, 0.05026187002658844, -0.057295236736536026, 0.06783999502658844, 0.02286970242857933, 0.032649047672748566, -0.0016917195171117783, -0.021907135844230652, -0.04108915850520134, -0.0034047970548272133, -0.00045340252108871937, -0.015993356704711914, -0.014013649895787239, -0.027841780334711075, 0.008171133697032928, -0.013361630961298943, 0.014124935492873192, -0.00028340055723674595, 0.008536707609891891, 0.01026602741330862, -0.032303474843502045, -0.0384487546980381, -0.029709747061133385, 0.036059748381376266, 0.04382750764489174, -0.014106901362538338, 0.014000050723552704, -0.016569823026657104, 0.059551917016506195, -0.007062285207211971, -0.03763176500797272, 0.02004759944975376, 0.010192076675593853, 0.060776788741350174, 0.0024289682041853666, 0.024418378248810768, -0.05337788164615631, -0.03464261069893837, 0.0329093299806118, 0.02329232357442379, -0.041986797004938126, 0.01534607820212841, -0.009923575446009636, 0.02231421135365963, 0.03531145676970482, -0.0013166475109755993, 0.016279766336083412, -0.01904509961605072, -0.02310914546251297, 0.023461012169718742, 0.030190521851181984, 0.0022259338293224573, -0.0025851905811578035, -0.08106856048107147, -0.012726062908768654, 0.050118908286094666, 0.028838390484452248, 0.013276983983814716, -0.009688549675047398, 0.007862575352191925, 0.05410797521471977, 0.015160460956394672, -0.022564563900232315, 0.030542152002453804, 0.022337261587381363, -0.0382055826485157, 0.024711159989237785, -0.00011103239376097918, -0.000964455830398947, 0.019401879981160164, -0.04803464561700821, 0.035070765763521194, -0.010859658941626549, 0.060728613287210464, -0.026701070368289948, -0.021408021450042725, -0.02499443292617798, 0.010404039174318314, 0.00584487384185195, -0.01094964798539877, -0.007076114881783724, -0.06167024374008179, -0.018932031467556953, -0.04240184277296066, 0.0042069521732628345, -0.000012350805263849907, 0.01052222028374672, 0.015351947396993637, -0.038145460188388824, -0.04291598126292229, -0.020991461351513863, -0.015241940505802631, -0.025951996445655823, -0.08427456766366959, -0.008033153600990772, -0.011156043969094753, -0.024065781384706497, 0.015958422794938087, -0.022350292652845383, 0.0016579782823100686, 0.01524741668254137, -0.0505158007144928, 0.017925985157489777, -0.012461497448384762, -0.021465977653861046, 0.027504945173859596, -0.005251135211437941, -0.0526401549577713, -0.02175210788846016, 0.00671995198354125, -0.019026387482881546, 0.01603425107896328, -0.07317748665809631, -0.013435561209917068, 0.04288638383150101, -0.035291608422994614, -0.0216187983751297, 0.03548865765333176, 0.0399717353284359, 0.02122156135737896, -0.010768705047667027, -0.004431526642292738, -0.02723369374871254, -0.09926712512969971, -0.016597388312220573, 0.04777681827545166, 0.012521031312644482, -0.004260499961674213, 0.0036053659860044718, -0.013999568298459053, -0.05794740840792656, -0.0415085032582283, 0.04515058919787407, 0.0599164217710495, 0.026386665180325508, -0.041666001081466675, 0.015224774368107319, -0.0127405421808362, -0.05547475442290306, -0.041206393390893936, -0.06210999935865402, -0.042224541306495667, -0.010100926272571087, -0.05848309025168419, 0.05439736321568489, -0.029486602172255516, -0.06097918376326561, -0.023432940244674683, 0.0030716601759195328, 0.008622048422694206, -0.012412057258188725, -0.021215064451098442, -0.002196767134591937, -0.05559884011745453, 0.05844903364777565, -0.057151153683662415, -0.027702245861291885, -0.013222879730165005, -0.04817638918757439, 0.01725700870156288, -0.014692731201648712, 0.03479824960231781, 0.038217127323150635, 0.001019948860630393, 0.01659095659852028, 0.0154691431671381, 0.06083212047815323, 0.03532722219824791, 0.025588547810912132, -0.032949578016996384, 0.038507696241140366, -0.05002356320619583, 0.004500505514442921, -0.057601671665906906, -0.027427058666944504, -0.03205908462405205, -0.047850050032138824, 0.024267885833978653, 0.005952435079962015, 0.040375497192144394, 0.013293414376676083, -0.0275442972779274, -0.03955249860882759, -0.05585760250687599, -0.05914130061864853, -0.015597963705658913, 0.04592086002230644, 0.05711587518453598, 0.019416531547904015, -0.018493840470910072, -0.07814787328243256, -0.010234241373836994, -0.07071299850940704, -0.008502359502017498, -0.04755697771906853, 0.02630952000617981, 0.007047533988952637, -0.051771167665719986, -0.039470016956329346, -0.012905729003250599, -0.028349807485938072, 0.030359411612153053, -0.006051631178706884, -0.007812071591615677, 0.011538627557456493, -0.017627667635679245, -0.021547963842749596, -0.004084356129169464, 0.04630957916378975, 0.06689786165952682, 0.011717415414750576, -0.03384460508823395, 0.018603619188070297, -0.02942749299108982, 0.019423943012952805, 0.030373752117156982, -0.017661498859524727, -0.02496013417840004, 0.0009678881033323705, -0.06590434163808823, 0.027729425579309464, -0.01913510449230671, 0.03484465554356575, -0.0007926137186586857, -0.041278593242168427, 0.011684978380799294, -0.04751454293727875, -0.021623626351356506, -0.05614373832941055, 0.030640235170722008, -0.034048859030008316, -0.03279832378029823, -0.028546001762151718, 0.07853209227323532, 0.05421169847249985, -0.038740124553442, -0.02017444372177124, -0.029404431581497192, 0.0340421237051487, -0.0013670623302459717, 0.009461293928325176, 0.06599052995443344, -0.003241395577788353, -0.07343042641878128, 0.027680344879627228, -0.05042397975921631, 0.04016965627670288, 0.01817263290286064, 0.03624628856778145, -0.006766271777451038, 0.025769945234060287, 0.04963221773505211, -0.05526982620358467, -0.03983785957098007, 0.06217116490006447, 0.04183986410498619, -0.023668644949793816, -0.003542486345395446, 0.03844901919364929, 0.028574777767062187, 0.039756808429956436, -0.013643286190927029, -0.02230958081781864, 0.009480345994234085, 0.07304152101278305, -0.025896895676851273, -0.0008376354817301035, -0.01844179444015026, -0.06278826296329498, -0.039413731545209885, -0.0399206206202507, 0.02503843978047371, 0.04203476384282112, 0.035472121089696884, -0.020786423236131668, 0.042510487139225006, -0.02418247051537037, 0.02838849648833275, -0.030449671670794487, -0.05151553079485893, 0.0506909005343914, -0.005394501145929098, -0.014277495443820953, -0.005772124044597149, 0.010830940678715706, -0.05125536024570465, -0.07813896983861923, -0.005596933886408806, -0.02345540001988411, 0.007246627938002348, 0.006784041412174702, 0.0022535270545631647, 0.055088240653276443, 0.011868857778608799, 0.016498006880283356, 0.03138728067278862, 0.029109112918376923, 0.031361568719148636, -0.06390330940485, -0.008444425649940968, 0.05032893270254135, 0.03173546865582466, -0.04684248939156532, -0.033436644822359085, -0.01379819493740797, -0.0745537281036377, 0.03156742826104164, 0.03028285503387451, 0.02265664003789425, -0.029484372586011887, -0.07798252999782562, -0.005072428844869137, -0.05697547644376755, 0.06351148337125778, -0.008737390860915184, 0.0029155167285352945, 0.06969162076711655, 0.0008415078045800328, 0.037786900997161865, -0.02874055691063404, -0.005508179310709238, -0.05625178664922714, -0.021435057744383812, 0.0009941165335476398, -0.04336312785744667, 0.05187815800309181, -0.03657131642103195, 0.05218227580189705, -0.07009820640087128, 0.03643938899040222, -0.031474336981773376, 0.006808326579630375, -0.05709272250533104, 0.04767417535185814, 0.044068023562431335, 0.0500948503613472, -0.042529407888650894, -0.013972596265375614, -0.032864365726709366, 0.05961041525006294, 0.048183344304561615, 0.017992760986089706, -0.04196242615580559, 0.0025432573165744543, -0.0435233898460865, -0.06820983439683914, -0.03143589198589325, -0.005366223398596048, 0.025388522073626518, -0.03796248137950897, -0.045098088681697845, 0.0486891008913517, 0.017790744081139565, -0.015247054398059845, -0.04347566142678261, -0.01276073232293129, -0.041457004845142365, -0.037504032254219055, 0.01765352115035057, -0.008216466754674911, -0.0065348781645298, -0.0042005362920463085, 0.03786643221974373, -0.008510044775903225, 0.008092471398413181, -0.016933290287852287, 0.03772682324051857, 0.021087929606437683, 0.04657326266169548, -0.04329449310898781, -0.059371691197156906, -0.014548798091709614, 0.015577025711536407, 0.005715542007237673, 0.008192870765924454, 0.021483492106199265, 0.030713200569152832, -0.02498644031584263, 0.026418546214699745, -0.07405673712491989, 0.023896077647805214, 0.025306006893515587, -0.04686231538653374, -0.013944670557975769, -0.019802331924438477, -0.040950529277324677, -0.03248231112957001, 0.01624295487999916, 0.03634771704673767, 0.007924993522465229, -0.03760886937379837, 0.003439786145463586, 0.026431985199451447, -0.06363208591938019, -0.029109032824635506, -0.04407283663749695, -0.0024998970329761505, -0.06339912861585617, 0.022074243053793907, 0.0041989656165242195, -0.041642770171165466, 0.004975713789463043, 0.04339315742254257, 0.05425964295864105, -0.002515337895601988, -0.07102338969707489, 0.006934646982699633, -0.03009764663875103, -0.017223035916686058, 0.02477523684501648, -0.06463363021612167, -0.0028222189284861088, 0.0044222199358046055, 0.05554885417222977, 0.018208017572760582, -0.005454941187053919, -0.04331133887171745, -0.05530804768204689, 0.0425693579018116, -0.05931517109274864, -0.07001397758722305, -0.05676954984664917, -0.05589272826910019, 0.022805310785770416, -0.036359306424856186, 0.06478855758905411, 0.05932728573679924, 0.06238669902086258, 0.025617143139243126, -0.04449914023280144, -0.002923926804214716, -0.0007897341856732965, 0.0382353812456131, -0.0772966518998146, -0.024203617125749588, 0.025020990520715714, 0.04787149280309677, -0.009205049835145473, -0.003765143221244216, -0.03477158769965172, -0.050779856741428375, -0.04905666783452034, -0.02772527188062668, -0.006964727770537138, -0.0026583964936435223, -0.062302954494953156, -0.013986766338348389, 0.06421174854040146, -0.03893670067191124, 0.05733576789498329, 0.0435623824596405, -0.029015619307756424, 0.041372641921043396, -0.02695147693157196, 0.04037652164697647, -0.06495296955108643, -0.02727900631725788, 0.06791914999485016, -0.06845296919345856, -0.03513764217495918, 0.010705430991947651, -0.04490825906395912, -0.006948771886527538, -0.026123953983187675, 0.020950553938746452, 0.00875699333846569, -0.02368125319480896, -0.05701333284378052, 0.023330723866820335, -0.0314251147210598, -0.06578423827886581, -0.028966445475816727, 0.03975040093064308, -0.06048297882080078, -0.030737459659576416, -0.027971845120191574, 0.020720889791846275, -0.03308795019984245, 0.009472613222897053, -0.006883289199322462, -0.03734491392970085, -0.009422368369996548, 0.006944987922906876, 0.04415546730160713, -0.04451477900147438, -0.022593120113015175, 0.010103775188326836, -0.02271483652293682, -0.007144520990550518, -0.04200306534767151, 0.0016894688596948981, -0.058692071586847305, 0.027746228501200676, 0.02422442100942135, -0.030663596466183662, 0.018303759396076202, 0.03557465597987175, -0.030330611392855644, 0.00786132924258709, 0.032269638031721115, -0.0007029628613963723, 0.0277885552495718, -0.060093242675065994, -0.031130127608776093, 0.02697383239865303, 0.011274667456746101, 0.01258937455713749, -0.022607941180467606, 0.012263910844922066, 0.007084058132022619, 0.03618095442652702, 0.01980699598789215, -0.04155213013291359, 0.002810105448588729, -0.03589699789881706, -0.05710870027542114, 0.022638574242591858, -0.026720773428678513, 0.007552420254796743, 0.022489814087748528, 0.05064966529607773, -0.02201966755092144, -0.01265392079949379, -0.05419091135263443, 0.008574209176003933, -0.055059079080820084, -0.007183166220784187, 0.005742059089243412, -0.009094567969441414, 0.05760421231389046, -0.026667067781090736, 0.04786479100584984, -0.012203512713313103, -0.005357397720217705, 0.006368638016283512, -0.030136235058307648, -0.023565296083688736, -0.026658199727535248, -0.029585974290966988, -0.024406710639595985, -0.02036282792687416, -0.051761019974946976, 0.03844038397073746, 0.031271979212760925, -0.017688918858766556, -0.05402751639485359, -0.026144327595829964, 0.00044152027112431824, -0.014108994975686073, 0.03697145730257034, -0.019063517451286316, -0.005889353808015585, -0.06057090312242508, 0.026643695309758186, 0.0513170026242733, -0.003703610273078084, -0.036882590502500534, -0.00931886862963438, 0.007930244319140911, 0.03297419100999832, -0.0034233813639730215, 0.00848222803324461, -0.03240054100751877, -0.03686762973666191, -0.08020857721567154, 0.022848086431622505, 0.005548269022256136, 0.010422434657812119, -0.01036063302308321, -0.038137275725603104, 0.0371646024286747, 0.05385596305131912, -0.02000761777162552, -0.08211500942707062, -0.009326660074293613, -0.0204133540391922, -0.015679247677326202, 0.03232216835021973, -0.00010281720460625365, -0.030853815376758575, 0.00861787237226963, -0.08278830349445343, -0.025191331282258034, -0.04686065390706062, 0.06648769974708557, 0.04699238762259483, -0.03688425570726395, -0.03207971155643463, -0.02521013654768467, -0.0048761265352368355, 0.06379903852939606, 0.04357136785984039, 0.03751081973314285, -0.004012056160718203, -0.008903886191546917, -0.05964324623346329, -0.02866147644817829, 0.004633561708033085, -0.01901649497449398, 0.002938322490081191, 0.002301860600709915, 0.027305182069540024, 0.00010384152119513601, 0.027553347870707512, 0.041394926607608795, 0.028795968741178513, -0.01657257415354252, 0.04081468656659126, 0.0030394354835152626, -0.055178798735141754, -0.05021010711789131, 0.0045172725804150105, -0.03666510060429573, 0.0022489926777780056, 0.03886494040489197, 0.056937456130981445, -0.0006420373683795333, -0.055129438638687134, -0.02506694197654724, 0.019071031361818314, 0.054655782878398895, 0.03678537905216217, 0.07915956526994705, -0.07551820576190948, -0.0060044811107218266, 0.01850973814725876, -0.01884528622031212, -0.03463403135538101, 0.02598179690539837, -0.002523063914850354, -0.06280197948217392, -0.007893580943346024, -0.057545535266399384, 0.05357823148369789, -0.01694592833518982, 0.02024131268262863, -0.02029118314385414, 0.034613657742738724, -0.06032112240791321, -0.017679721117019653, -0.07300922274589539, -0.05735029652714729, -0.018120279535651207, -0.011022314429283142, 0.0447322279214859, -0.020359361544251442, 0.021922998130321503, -0.004546788055449724, 0.034939445555210114, 0.0066041541285812855, 0.04570620879530907, 0.049451179802417755, 0.03158301115036011, -0.03711549937725067, -0.03339342400431633, -0.05508997291326523, 0.02329866588115692, -0.017163528129458427, -0.035845838487148285, -0.05148755759000778, 0.01312378328293562, 0.030363021418452263, -0.0034759261179715395, -0.022598234936594963, -0.04350666701793671, -0.016510501503944397, 0.0003996170125901699, -0.017008721828460693, 0.0110840555280447, 0.019736194983124733, -0.05987290292978287, 0.0006055753328837454, -0.016236264258623123, 0.023905791342258453, -0.050533898174762726 ]
Information extraction systems often produce hundreds to thousands of strings on a specific topic. We present a method that facilitates better consumption of these strings, in an exploratory setting in which a user wants to both get a broad overview of what's available, and a chance to dive deeper on some aspects. The system works by grouping similar items together and arranging the remaining items into a hierarchical navigable DAG structure. We apply the method to medical information extraction.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10057v1
[ -0.003995906561613083, -0.028234951198101044, 0.06773627549409866, 0.031584709882736206, 0.01683913543820381, -0.014027073048055172, -0.018781671300530434, -0.049041371792554855, -0.0358748696744442, -0.00504079507663846, -0.009977679699659348, 0.02394331805408001, -0.03182516619563103, -0.03715824708342552, -0.03176611661911011, 0.03290616720914841, 0.0460859052836895, -0.012515915557742119, -0.029726918786764145, 0.047736912965774536, -0.012985864654183388, 0.0374314971268177, 0.01897869072854519, 0.037887297570705414, 0.0315513052046299, -0.010531855747103691, -0.011868276633322239, -0.003087926423177123, -0.03218504413962364, -0.009245202876627445, 0.023173009976744652, -0.02920992486178875, 0.02652583457529545, 0.013269222341477871, -0.05914134904742241, 0.0018957764841616154, -0.01110843662172556, 0.004692151211202145, -0.039832666516304016, 0.022503742948174477, 0.03632022440433502, -0.07129167020320892, -0.07045160233974457, -0.013992538675665855, -0.007078288588672876, 0.040544379502534866, -0.03911443054676056, -0.020228661596775055, -0.044727977365255356, -0.015580983832478523, -0.03678099066019058, -0.024403411895036697, 0.03990697115659714, 0.04138273000717163, 0.02292507328093052, -0.016125349327921867, 0.012749197892844677, 0.05994413420557976, -0.05992328003048897, -0.00021020829444751143, -0.012986727058887482, -0.03832624852657318, -0.02357657626271248, -0.03418741375207901, -0.04889063537120819, 0.0727730467915535, -0.004143480211496353, -0.0746537297964096, -0.02771477960050106, 0.025703711435198784, 0.05409407615661621, -0.066614530980587, 0.005699644796550274, -0.013744743540883064, -0.043480098247528076, -0.01765463314950466, -0.02333718352019787, -0.006143231876194477, -0.0021726491395384073, -0.007346177473664284, -0.02918560989201069, 0.04444603621959686, 0.016971420496702194, 0.01734764128923416, -0.0006109075620770454, -0.003631928935647011, 0.04628262296319008, -0.04104611650109291, 0.03927171975374222, -0.04225873947143555, -0.006068376358598471, -0.02072926238179207, -0.0871669203042984, 0.03834016993641853, 0.05158628895878792, -0.02725825645029545, 0.013507120311260223, 0.06412390619516373, -0.018815144896507263, -0.007683989126235247, -0.05113838240504265, -0.02617604099214077, -0.04082398861646652, 0.0343867763876915, 0.005455503240227699, -0.018473302945494652, -0.01642613299190998, -0.011444929987192154, -0.023498183116316795, 0.012598068453371525, 0.01256814505904913, -0.023854674771428108, -0.0022655704524368048, -0.0767579898238182, -0.022530540823936462, -0.005279627628624439, -0.007388096768409014, -0.010113134048879147, 0.03670436143875122, -0.018337856978178024, 0.03607224300503731, -0.05117872729897499, 0.0017360149649903178, 0.005884283687919378, -0.06165093556046486, -0.0543670691549778, 0.05273919180035591, 0.020960452035069466, -0.011310040950775146, -0.02183755487203598, -0.02158327028155327, -0.023615656420588493, -0.022835146635770798, -0.007786072790622711, 0.06148163229227066, 0.006400140468031168, -0.004554784391075373, -0.07805468887090683, 0.055391520261764526, -0.0017835547914728522, 0.001407324569299817, -0.0747806578874588, 0.02703961916267872, -0.057895153760910034, -0.03394170105457306, 0.02101675420999527, 0.010245628654956818, -0.030214665457606316, 0.04845542088150978, 0.06434479355812073, -0.02010360173881054, 0.03648802638053894, -0.01768675073981285, -0.027730612084269524, -0.043272729963064194, 0.0449368879199028, 0.010054073296487331, -0.0567760244011879, -0.04120723903179169, 0.008055878803133965, -0.014239635318517685, -0.042799580842256546, -0.04453596845269203, -0.024098515510559082, 0.02426537498831749, -0.00782726053148508, -0.027690419927239418, -0.00433487631380558, -0.014309045858681202, 0.01016891561448574, -0.009875831194221973, -0.043840665370225906, 0.019945207983255386, -0.05244740471243858, -0.01764727756381035, 0.015241292305290699, -0.04571353644132614, -0.0445590615272522, -0.07129768282175064, -0.010450313799083233, -0.0159282349050045, 0.03949159383773804, 0.0006908647483214736, 0.0028552210424095392, -0.030239583924412727, 0.02255919575691223, -0.06227255240082741, 0.013330802321434021, 0.04077807068824768, 0.0234924778342247, -0.01561697106808424, -0.024659940972924232, 0.004901608917862177, -0.00334322452545166, 0.0011902140686288476, -0.026546623557806015, 0.02573821321129799, -0.05889534205198288, -0.018007375299930573, 0.029143916442990303, -0.06819842755794525, -0.06637708097696304, -0.04429396614432335, 0.00043379038106650114, 0.017036814242601395, -0.03973288834095001, 0.012217865325510502, -0.026732493191957474, -0.03400835767388344, 0.03813742846250534, 0.06733813881874084, 0.06585731357336044, 0.05354250594973564, 0.01846693456172943, 0.00694223353639245, -0.006473497487604618, -0.1052030473947525, 0.019504709169268608, -0.008683783933520317, 0.011169214732944965, 0.05894308164715767, 0.04066339135169983, -0.02900455705821514, -0.03671688959002495, 0.02882103994488716, 0.04693477228283882, 0.020126868039369583, 0.005245155189186335, -0.04567660391330719, 0.001662545488215983, 0.010912908241152763, -0.057287268340587616, 0.03260911628603935, -0.0914640724658966, 0.02525293454527855, -0.03320828452706337, -0.03271561488509178, 0.02001621201634407, 0.06908109039068222, -0.031681302934885025, 0.017900243401527405, -0.02854449301958084, 0.06414620578289032, 0.01934855245053768, -0.03346090018749237, -0.011789027601480484, -0.03208193928003311, 0.0026087358128279448, 0.019274840131402016, 0.00031678302912041545, -0.009391427971422672, -0.0835045799612999, -0.03579325973987579, 0.06564101576805115, 0.05014515668153763, -0.035163529217243195, -0.009540732018649578, 0.028142116963863373, -0.026965543627738953, 0.042213357985019684, 0.04073135927319527, 0.012163940817117691, -0.043333426117897034, 0.002620530780404806, -0.044548019766807556, 0.01867084577679634, 0.009580453857779503, -0.03748049587011337, 0.016208570450544357, 0.0025827630888670683, 0.05717025324702263, 0.034775953739881516, 0.05143231898546219, -0.0445525199174881, 0.005566087551414967, -0.04774016886949539, -0.009544138796627522, -0.0385931096971035, 0.009199352003633976, 0.06122726574540138, 0.015760958194732666, 0.040954478085041046, 0.012476789765059948, -0.07498354464769363, -0.019706647843122482, -0.051233045756816864, 0.008195704780519009, -0.05591335520148277, -0.054840222001075745, -0.049269575625658035, -0.09247568249702454, 0.03409401699900627, 0.012037470005452633, -0.06795089691877365, -0.02680882439017296, -0.059137653559446335, -0.009146523661911488, -0.0335908904671669, 0.017336077988147736, 0.02780826948583126, -0.052208513021469116, -0.02477993629872799, 0.038363177329301834, -0.001666640629991889, 0.030828731134533882, -0.07485748827457428, -0.06950464099645615, -0.006237768568098545, -0.02543153055012226, -0.0049699884839355946, 0.011331927962601185, 0.039344530552625656, 0.015017861500382423, 0.04214803874492645, -0.00775637524202466, 0.00762648181989789, -0.004933349788188934, 0.018973056226968765, -0.0029976835940033197, 0.0133548304438591, 0.0015532058896496892, 0.0041024936363101006, 0.012337927706539631, -0.03377891331911087, -0.06418155133724213, -0.06222133710980415, -0.03002418391406536, -0.006175706163048744, -0.0359739325940609, -0.013326562941074371, -0.005934671964496374, -0.004964140243828297, 0.03771492838859558, -0.01676199398934841, 0.014446472749114037, 0.019381994381546974, 0.04924720153212547, -0.03180922567844391, -0.03861478343605995, 0.009706399403512478, -0.013873400166630745, 0.039351936429739, -0.07354841381311417, -0.010256852954626083, 0.015851816162467003, -0.08640969544649124, 0.04111150652170181, 0.005433537997305393, 0.023372773081064224, -0.017327992245554924, 0.03746166080236435, 0.005790346767753363, -0.024609575048089027, 0.043197888880968094, -0.008374338038265705, -0.006240985356271267, -0.05043621361255646, 0.032431699335575104, -0.07773307710886002, -0.014051687903702259, 0.01599627360701561, -0.05090610310435295, -0.01277212705463171, 0.025435611605644226, 0.011690494604408741, 0.06607857346534729, 0.007314623333513737, -0.06628802418708801, -0.007094634231179953, -0.04182892292737961, 0.06578537076711655, 0.008798979222774506, -0.03072476014494896, 0.061147965490818024, -0.028574353083968163, 0.025038275867700577, -0.00774155929684639, -0.05699670687317848, 0.027335571125149727, 0.03267159312963486, 0.02066078595817089, -0.014559626579284668, 0.060926809906959534, 0.0062906029634177685, -0.013273032382130623, -0.0073622348718345165, 0.02853158302605152, -0.030162259936332703, 0.0064957938157022, -0.02369929663836956, -0.03343634307384491, -0.03326502442359924, 0.03792164474725723, -0.04692321643233299, 0.011897388845682144, -0.06287475675344467, 0.024280371144413948, -0.004060749430209398, 0.014241955243051052, -0.030194858089089394, -0.02340027131140232, -0.006045961752533913, -0.023976139724254608, -0.08476260304450989, 0.04348598048090935, 0.034751128405332565, 0.04882166162133217, -0.023809602484107018, -0.04941364750266075, 0.012134365737438202, -0.05178377032279968, 0.011107072234153748, -0.04899928346276283, -0.03923478722572327, 0.008097591809928417, -0.029014993458986282, 0.016771649941802025, -0.07777377218008041, 0.027947071939706802, -0.023699577897787094, 0.0582561269402504, 0.020922934636473656, -0.03381630405783653, -0.025941152125597, -0.05234367772936821, -0.01572473719716072, -0.0035919570364058018, 0.03999700769782066, -0.0010787290520966053, 0.021217621862888336, -0.0032343189232051373, 0.01653095707297325, -0.000026144416551687755, -0.016721557825803757, -0.02890877239406109, -0.01928834617137909, 0.01779763773083687, -0.05456843227148056, -0.014266104437410831, -0.02624969556927681, -0.005842582788318396, 0.00947924330830574, -0.06923501193523407, 0.009103331714868546, -0.02997986599802971, -0.009461609646677971, -0.02408086135983467, -0.05926632136106491, 0.00806079339236021, -0.05137484148144722, -0.047368116676807404, -0.012712170369923115, 0.02267088182270527, 0.011175545863807201, 0.028255166485905647, -0.002161615528166294, -0.0002040843537542969, 0.0006395709351636469, -0.024003397673368454, -0.004680537153035402, 0.01144896075129509, -0.03076247125864029, -0.06469960510730743, 0.00032456949702464044, -0.03775571659207344, 0.001864501740783453, -0.03826167806982994, -0.005157696083188057, 0.0007703236769884825, 0.00686407508328557, 0.018162302672863007, 0.07899810373783112, -0.07430381327867508, 0.025853833183646202, 0.007152171805500984, 0.02371245063841343, 0.03573120757937431, 0.07684304565191269, 0.05421525985002518, 0.01680130511522293, -0.04915459454059601, -0.008016596548259258, 0.035201989114284515, -0.028376447036862373, 0.041210297495126724, -0.00318914488889277, 0.023946208879351616, -0.005801199469715357, 0.0623495988547802, 0.0017719866009429097, 0.00286645395681262, 0.008638372644782066, 0.03663567453622818, 0.00882542971521616, -0.02315913699567318, 0.025608576834201813, 0.007948177866637707, -0.011690519750118256, -0.047253161668777466, 0.02405429072678089, -0.014131849631667137, 0.027219202369451523, 0.01909470558166504, 0.012542196549475193, 0.02755851298570633, 0.021624617278575897, -0.06619376689195633, 0.05687154084444046, 0.05877777934074402, -0.005401663947850466, 0.0022978507913649082, -0.003353104228153825, -0.00008791882282821462, -0.03342018276453018, -0.03817342594265938, -0.024713516235351562, 0.02820185013115406, 0.017399370670318604, 0.04473758861422539, -0.03004271164536476, -0.009829936549067497, 0.0071358694694936275, 0.005381692200899124, -0.019748520106077194, 0.03898052126169205, 0.029418790712952614, -0.03303378075361252, 0.03275427594780922, 0.021689070388674736, 0.022063476964831352, 0.017604554072022438, 0.011573754251003265, 0.0018730702577158809, 0.04073173552751541, -0.02108638361096382, -0.031350284814834595, 0.03196011856198311, -0.034721460193395615, -0.049493011087179184, 0.025541137903928757, 0.02370653860270977, -0.0018339649541303515, 0.03877502307295799, 0.047894105315208435, -0.02008175663650036, 0.001000356045551598, -0.02605544961988926, -0.027666667476296425, -0.009703482501208782, 0.037719689309597015, 0.050522319972515106, -0.025168200954794884, -0.021577343344688416, -0.05986214801669121, 0.020570440217852592, 0.047916535288095474, 0.005972022656351328, 0.06207791715860367, 0.040748484432697296, 0.007750022690743208, -0.041785500943660736, 0.06339570134878159, -0.04310309886932373, -0.032615214586257935, 0.02131756581366062, 0.025991113856434822, -0.07575839012861252, -0.02378552034497261, 0.008247338235378265, 0.04574182257056236, -0.06378138810396194, 0.05309499800205231, -0.007456991355866194, 0.026736760511994362, -0.05562726780772209, 0.07994344085454941, 0.07275421917438507, 0.011977632530033588, 0.0038646741304546595, -0.011593572795391083, -0.07878369837999344, 0.01546918973326683, -0.008369935676455498, 0.0550067201256752, -0.027242619544267654, 0.050452448427677155, -0.022183002904057503, -0.07630303502082825, -0.057088226079940796, 0.018143141642212868, -0.0369269959628582, -0.052261777222156525, 0.036262866109609604, -0.040412601083517075, 0.028365885838866234, -0.01639029197394848, -0.030028890818357468, -0.017436780035495758, -0.0023730460088700056, 0.016964798793196678, 0.012919801287353039, -0.05466585233807564, 0.0010755364783108234, -0.02497998997569084, 0.019170550629496574, -0.05722680687904358, -0.03843534737825394, -0.024079732596874237, -0.052980709820985794, 0.06243863329291344, -0.08626709133386612, 0.0024239742197096348, -0.05647825449705124, 0.0393303707242012, 0.041921261698007584, 0.04713061451911926, -0.029625294730067253, -0.022179821506142616, 0.044791046530008316, 0.006173957604914904, -0.003146566916257143, -0.04493587836623192, -0.035558443516492844, -0.0675373524427414, 0.006780242081731558, -0.05203697830438614, 0.007515418343245983, 0.023985013365745544, -0.015188357792794704, -0.011986694298684597, 0.050943270325660706, -0.05165312811732292, 0.012544765137135983, -0.01961647905409336, -0.03675496205687523, -0.008220607414841652, 0.055066559463739395, -0.03863943740725517, -0.023773273453116417, -0.05728193745017052, -0.0073539335280656815, 0.0007315230905078351, -0.010289309546351433, 0.021866990253329277, 0.038354456424713135, -0.06352628767490387, -0.012339913286268711, -0.010338431224226952, 0.035588931292295456, 0.02327669784426689, -0.02661909908056259, -0.05422075837850571, -0.009126000106334686, -0.04853377491235733, -0.029310021549463272, -0.06945750117301941, -0.005509978160262108, -0.07294026017189026, 0.0020076970104128122, 0.06309063732624054, -0.010825764387845993, -0.03682554140686989, -0.06328703463077545, 0.05535233020782471, -0.01673784665763378, -0.008754923939704895, -0.0451231487095356, 0.0009177306783385575, -0.009491453878581524, -0.018297040835022926, -0.03852444514632225, 0.007812992669641972, 0.023019492626190186, -0.031241267919540405, -0.07837045937776566, 0.03833288699388504, 0.052210140973329544, 0.03035053238272667, -0.039281658828258514, -0.020576111972332, 0.0025456964503973722, -0.044992394745349884, 0.008146154694259167, -0.028886577114462852, 0.08336487412452698, 0.013105787336826324, -0.0018469137139618397, -0.020484762266278267, -0.05914437025785446, -0.0212028119713068, -0.015068501234054565, -0.051680296659469604, 0.020621685311198235, 0.006672070361673832, 0.05416802689433098, 0.011474767699837685, -0.00038608809700235724, 0.06482895463705063, -0.028272073715925217, -0.008807211183011532, 0.006167421583086252, 0.018152296543121338, -0.005663581658154726, -0.06493580341339111, 0.0479288175702095, -0.04774811118841171, -0.048771392554044724, 0.012616204097867012, 0.0193795133382082, 0.03604396805167198, -0.04709511622786522, -0.05286647751927376, 0.0023394408635795116, -0.009114005602896214, 0.018885590136051178, 0.0314285047352314, -0.0290349293500185, 0.011046738363802433, -0.018487123772501945, 0.005092249251902103, -0.008651305921375751, -0.01267356239259243, 0.026310043409466743, -0.010540168732404709, -0.03957703709602356, -0.029355470091104507, 0.0025627752766013145, -0.0027789988089352846, -0.05485418811440468, -0.03646237403154373, 0.04197109490633011, -0.04205218330025673, -0.007148503325879574, -0.001525978441350162, 0.02590997703373432, -0.0411260686814785, -0.06849554926156998, -0.03947094827890396, -0.047892265021800995, 0.06321264058351517, -0.051488980650901794, 0.03751298040151596, 0.015326771885156631, 0.046817149966955185, -0.0087070157751441, 0.0329427570104599, 0.06465926021337509, 0.044329866766929626, -0.07938756793737411, 0.06064438447356224, -0.013668626546859741, 0.007331618573516607, -0.045805417001247406, 0.004660509992390871, -0.002501416951417923, -0.009175754152238369, 0.019188305363059044, 0.014760379679501057, 0.0039552124217152596, -0.04944441094994545, 0.011314965784549713, 0.034922488033771515, 0.028491482138633728, -0.015810826793313026, -0.0242624469101429, -0.002418343909084797, 0.0013236419763416052, -0.04306421056389809 ]
Graphic layout generation, a growing research field, plays a significant role in user engagement and information perception. Existing methods primarily treat layout generation as a numerical optimization task, focusing on quantitative aspects while overlooking the semantic information of layout, such as the relationship between each layout element. In this paper, we propose LayoutNUWA, the first model that treats layout generation as a code generation task to enhance semantic information and harness the hidden layout expertise of large language models~(LLMs). More concretely, we develop a Code Instruct Tuning (CIT) approach comprising three interconnected modules: 1) the Code Initialization (CI) module quantifies the numerical conditions and initializes them as HTML code with strategically placed masks; 2) the Code Completion (CC) module employs the formatting knowledge of LLMs to fill in the masked portions within the HTML code; 3) the Code Rendering (CR) module transforms the completed code into the final layout output, ensuring a highly interpretable and transparent layout generation procedure that directly maps code to a visualized layout. We attain significant state-of-the-art performance (even over 50\% improvements) on multiple datasets, showcasing the strong capabilities of LayoutNUWA. Our code is available at https://github.com/ProjectNUWA/LayoutNUWA.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09506v2
[ 0.009099630638957024, -0.059137847274541855, 0.028910910710692406, -0.04537661001086235, -0.004968980327248573, -0.03652577847242355, -0.023324711248278618, -0.015344665385782719, 0.03678812086582184, -0.011644582264125347, 0.02161754108965397, 0.03808137774467468, -0.0262531116604805, -0.02194184996187687, -0.06510082632303238, 0.010709515772759914, 0.07743269205093384, 0.01801115646958351, -0.0766383484005928, 0.06118214875459671, 0.009722277522087097, -0.023700226098299026, -0.051986973732709885, 0.024805238470435143, 0.005873576737940311, -0.0006100193713791668, -0.05960898473858833, -0.01053216028958559, -0.025214362889528275, -0.03051917441189289, 0.05987847223877907, -0.00339297647587955, -0.022607190534472466, -0.06473993510007858, -0.0396689772605896, -0.02600986137986183, -0.033943746238946915, -0.02332952432334423, 0.032281287014484406, -0.06366300582885742, 0.04004042223095894, -0.05644393339753151, -0.06467881053686142, -0.024887774139642715, 0.00003426496186875738, 0.020003901794552803, -0.05684150755405426, -0.010866471566259861, -0.06730564683675766, -0.05579021945595741, 0.03533722460269928, -0.013958487659692764, -0.03269844502210617, 0.06947430968284607, 0.0029568246100097895, 0.02566460333764553, -0.011310005560517311, 0.020217660814523697, -0.05359051749110222, -0.02100163698196411, 0.03284865617752075, -0.043028537184000015, -0.011834313161671162, -0.027213210240006447, -0.005757625680416822, 0.04551902040839195, 0.004723572172224522, -0.048298805952072144, -0.021695300936698914, -0.034846290946006775, 0.046015843749046326, -0.08227428048849106, -0.01712905429303646, -0.00391844566911459, -0.057406604290008545, -0.022203495725989342, -0.04548219218850136, -0.060439351946115494, 0.0023630082141608, -0.014450978487730026, -0.027857640758156776, 0.055657412856817245, 0.047536417841911316, 0.025109078735113144, -0.02920522540807724, -0.021971629932522774, 0.04869501665234566, -0.01918378658592701, 0.007622167933732271, -0.06405366957187653, 0.021208729594945908, -0.042928632348775864, -0.08211576193571091, 0.013474649749696255, 0.03274386003613472, 0.016190752387046814, 0.05738333985209465, -0.031221630051732063, -0.03532624989748001, -0.0010182192781940103, -0.05962114408612251, -0.000050481001380831, -0.03406992182135582, 0.017220741137862206, 0.03494420275092125, -0.022612474858760834, 0.020175283774733543, -0.013764351606369019, -0.04978128522634506, -0.0119675537571311, -0.02930905669927597, -0.02577066421508789, 0.02406344935297966, -0.06342081725597382, -0.027698347344994545, -0.05839870497584343, 0.0573163703083992, 0.003476253943517804, 0.01714443601667881, -0.023056384176015854, -0.036790043115615845, 0.0017863899702206254, 0.05658813565969467, -0.05382348969578743, -0.043524183332920074, -0.06713341921567917, 0.030470222234725952, -0.0033518741838634014, -0.0018272201996296644, -0.04651692137122154, -0.046625200659036636, -0.011593103408813477, -0.011436380445957184, -0.044137850403785706, 0.06058674678206444, -0.024786725640296936, -0.01161358505487442, -0.07454761117696762, 0.04817403852939606, -0.03229597955942154, -0.05297886207699776, -0.06780871003866196, 0.014924978837370872, -0.05379585549235344, 0.006936321500688791, 0.06577319651842117, 0.018136300146579742, -0.02560938149690628, 0.0296720452606678, 0.0015430013881996274, -0.00273557985201478, -0.03804846480488777, 0.02983758971095085, 0.013578907586634159, 0.011436942033469677, -0.03982388600707054, 0.034379445016384125, -0.030907465144991875, -0.07525094598531723, 0.022717244923114777, 0.011019956320524216, -0.024007555097341537, -0.024707864969968796, -0.039931770414114, -0.027056951075792313, -0.02391274832189083, 0.06914553046226501, -0.008184039033949375, 0.02047376148402691, 0.01764722727239132, 0.016258656978607178, -0.00833010021597147, -0.022525515407323837, -0.00489951204508543, -0.04228730499744415, -0.03815136104822159, 0.03705639764666557, -0.07156052440404892, -0.02580174058675766, -0.010145378299057484, -0.04347062483429909, 0.022355521097779274, -0.015277060680091381, -0.038262441754341125, -0.030233878642320633, 0.014895864762365818, -0.06885526329278946, 0.011122501455247402, 0.019293617457151413, 0.03951369225978851, -0.04176659509539604, 0.006762356031686068, 0.0302006546407938, 0.018501784652471542, -0.027315916493535042, -0.040834687650203705, 0.023380212485790253, -0.03635478392243385, 0.0175467561930418, 0.02867285907268524, -0.08482366800308228, -0.004022820387035608, -0.06074270233511925, 0.030827157199382782, 0.02193738892674446, -0.06969483941793442, -0.001055113272741437, 0.02518220990896225, -0.07265283912420273, 0.016817202791571617, 0.010009623132646084, 0.03470627963542938, 0.07266853004693985, -0.033699534833431244, 0.050707556307315826, -0.00790536217391491, -0.08909539878368378, 0.04054424166679382, -0.006758288946002722, -0.012649589218199253, 0.010818708688020706, -0.003399910405278206, 0.0050055296160280704, -0.04249843209981918, -0.02363777533173561, 0.04286400228738785, 0.06892812997102737, -0.024457773193717003, -0.01580812782049179, -0.004591049626469612, -0.01540848147124052, -0.06020580977201462, -0.0009608815889805555, -0.07460875064134598, -0.011182308197021484, 0.006876146420836449, -0.05853903666138649, 0.043824777007102966, 0.03206414356827736, -0.028413811698555946, -0.05582575872540474, -0.025216562673449516, -0.0008319614571519196, -0.0375184491276741, -0.06874155253171921, -0.03145391121506691, -0.019045721739530563, -0.0011437792563810945, -0.009084713645279408, -0.01632761023938656, -0.04606736823916435, -0.0613538920879364, 0.016045019030570984, 0.002285516820847988, 0.01421187724918127, 0.049530938267707825, 0.0010499523486942053, 0.017737213522195816, 0.0002609478833619505, 0.027518540620803833, 0.01397647988051176, 0.039917849004268646, -0.0614151693880558, 0.032729197293519974, 0.016222093254327774, -0.03363202139735222, -0.013631182722747326, -0.013534773141145706, -0.03371778875589371, -0.036968015134334564, -0.01470767892897129, -0.00659582344815135, 0.04331287741661072, -0.019450800493359566, -0.010481435805559158, -0.018782474100589752, 0.03223307430744171, -0.05703522637486458, -0.006198275368660688, 0.0397038497030735, 0.040197283029556274, 0.027831129729747772, -0.024386433884501457, -0.07775422185659409, 0.03380445018410683, -0.04904978722333908, -0.03870658203959465, -0.07992683351039886, -0.039207786321640015, -0.03740581497550011, -0.030776163563132286, -0.04193698614835739, -0.04585589841008186, -0.042603157460689545, -0.0031512368004769087, -0.06806685775518417, -0.00741479080170393, -0.010491111315786839, -0.02024996653199196, 0.022328276187181473, 0.014422455802559853, -0.06073236092925072, 0.0006511411629617214, 0.0022456867154687643, 0.0019001284381374717, -0.04699699953198433, -0.050498221069574356, -0.022968947887420654, 0.0247481781989336, 0.014486054889857769, -0.029383709654211998, 0.01027392316609621, 0.013062556274235249, -0.002739650895819068, 0.013130995444953442, 0.03947019949555397, -0.020400308072566986, 0.04594516381621361, -0.030104199424386024, -0.0009677832131274045, -0.05718104541301727, 0.021475808694958687, 0.022105105221271515, -0.05305132269859314, -0.009592989459633827, -0.04786597937345505, 0.041683752089738846, -0.012864723801612854, -0.049782369285821915, -0.053349271416664124, -0.017045779153704643, 0.04574327915906906, 0.027372464537620544, -0.014807308092713356, 0.02221705950796604, 0.061924900859594345, -0.057267721742391586, -0.055354222655296326, -0.010655821301043034, -0.02842806652188301, -0.01609179563820362, 0.02086051180958748, 0.009332404471933842, -0.0431283675134182, 0.06429378688335419, -0.08292581140995026, 0.013875359669327736, 0.052357226610183716, 0.07290814816951752, -0.01859138533473015, 0.014519312418997288, -0.03416309505701065, -0.003799931611865759, 0.016817469149827957, -0.03649609163403511, 0.012869272381067276, 0.0487382709980011, 0.06457950174808502, -0.03624282777309418, -0.03554524853825569, -0.01971226930618286, -0.051463253796100616, 0.020752795040607452, -0.015413058921694756, 0.03213876858353615, 0.035103052854537964, -0.008736483752727509, -0.05697578564286232, 0.031178897246718407, 0.00007232934876810759, 0.03057667426764965, 0.04458009824156761, -0.031249716877937317, 0.015582290478050709, -0.07574937492609024, 0.021860510110855103, 0.016854917630553246, 0.01262285653501749, 0.01435683760792017, -0.03167259320616722, 0.005331751890480518, -0.06597311049699783, 0.03962845355272293, 0.008177016861736774, -0.03410760685801506, 0.022610794752836227, 0.03468130901455879, 0.008365687914192677, 0.07249679416418076, -0.038177069276571274, -0.040738239884376526, 0.042901698499917984, 0.040882982313632965, -0.01867375150322914, -0.048458341509103775, -0.04920714721083641, -0.028822777792811394, 0.05053957179188728, -0.019865768030285835, -0.02532772347331047, -0.021929660812020302, -0.014430237002670765, 0.00654540816321969, -0.05934392288327217, -0.0005176353151910007, -0.0478740818798542, 0.017014814540743828, -0.03256339207291603, -0.05372212082147598, 0.02432255819439888, -0.02037939801812172, -0.011297927238047123, -0.013444405049085617, 0.01065512839704752, -0.04297865182161331, -0.03538791462779045, 0.016155537217855453, -0.07574214786291122, -0.0236767940223217, -0.043217699974775314, 0.03705890104174614, 0.039556216448545456, -0.007502064108848572, -0.0076614199206233025, -0.037743665277957916, 0.013941803015768528, 0.005756717640906572, 0.059198375791311264, 0.02128370851278305, -0.009419498965144157, -0.014179187826812267, 0.04283061996102333, -0.03572164103388786, -0.007505258545279503, -0.0047891042195260525, -0.04390298202633858, 0.02261052280664444, -0.0011694279965013266, -0.03657048940658569, 0.024513905867934227, -0.012044431641697884, 0.011574607342481613, -0.05565192177891731, -0.02374275214970112, 0.007064254488795996, 0.03799513354897499, -0.06627992540597916, -0.049069855362176895, -0.02996745891869068, -0.038701675832271576, -0.04912015423178673, -0.049025699496269226, 0.0010204339632764459, 0.05069037899374962, 0.030467068776488304, -0.013969712890684605, 0.02308603562414646, -0.05583225563168526, 0.024979177862405777, 0.018816547468304634, 0.022028924897313118, -0.043449267745018005, -0.024267522618174553, -0.004849536810070276, -0.07314378768205643, 0.0067972457036376, -0.02799908258020878, 0.007406456861644983, 0.021972527727484703, -0.0014384700916707516, 0.014720790088176727, 0.03837570920586586, -0.0826599970459938, 0.025828253477811813, -0.003433079458773136, -0.02117992378771305, 0.017505748197436333, 0.027468355372548103, 0.007450189907103777, 0.01928955316543579, 0.006736309267580509, 0.019444968551397324, 0.012362335808575153, -0.044843889772892, -0.01890287920832634, 0.013409952633082867, -0.027945293113589287, 0.01744575798511505, 0.06380423903465271, -0.0036495323292911053, -0.0372517891228199, 0.030524618923664093, 0.03026766888797283, 0.024561740458011627, -0.03864605724811554, 0.035157956182956696, 0.021206263452768326, -0.01579403132200241, -0.03589696064591408, 0.019614551216363907, -0.030755164101719856, -0.027554137632250786, -0.03950154408812523, -0.0067884111776947975, 0.004732107277959585, 0.023176714777946472, -0.005337377078831196, 0.00595194473862648, 0.00661814771592617, 0.03893386200070381, -0.013598354533314705, -0.00883819255977869, 0.026141967624425888, -0.032518185675144196, -0.007042601238936186, 0.012468407861888409, 0.006854588631540537, 0.07325687259435654, -0.004510912112891674, -0.010869300924241543, 0.025414370000362396, -0.036908108741045, -0.022483956068754196, 0.024851961061358452, -0.0006209973944351077, 0.010482510551810265, -0.06345256417989731, 0.05660664662718773, -0.034706685692071915, 0.0060096485540270805, -0.012052158825099468, 0.05095385015010834, 0.03799630329012871, 0.016062557697296143, -0.045045435428619385, -0.006952817551791668, 0.042261604219675064, -0.03809409961104393, -0.041053567081689835, 0.05243721976876259, 0.045606691390275955, -0.058341722935438156, -0.004972235765308142, 0.03148766979575157, -0.050675954669713974, 0.019535956904292107, 0.004249473102390766, -0.06145985424518585, -0.0731949582695961, 0.001911753206513822, 0.05858244374394417, -0.02595340646803379, -0.02781224064528942, 0.0228569433093071, -0.03327000513672829, 0.03302854672074318, -0.01872365176677704, 0.0232612956315279, 0.0386311337351799, -0.005440453067421913, -0.030051423236727715, 0.04382343590259552, -0.03449580445885658, -0.05713137611746788, 0.009215977042913437, 0.03490838780999184, -0.06724157929420471, 0.006113185081630945, -0.011049947701394558, 0.01746436022222042, -0.051734212785959244, 0.03234831616282463, 0.02223632112145424, -0.027746649459004402, -0.06435008347034454, 0.05849458649754524, 0.0783594623208046, -0.006813410669565201, 0.006943402346223593, 0.03182833269238472, -0.07101888209581375, 0.01606779731810093, -0.02014184184372425, -0.020934347063302994, 0.012449197471141815, 0.03878891095519066, 0.03282485529780388, -0.041044823825359344, -0.011469126679003239, 0.059143807739019394, 0.001979212276637554, -0.013438033871352673, 0.05581098422408104, -0.0380869023501873, 0.01758524961769581, -0.04971912130713463, -0.012393264099955559, -0.017203088849782944, -0.03194313496351242, 0.0064671761356294155, -0.06148437783122063, 0.030316172167658806, -0.03537598252296448, 0.028628051280975342, 0.014542484655976295, -0.07778613269329071, -0.006192775908857584, -0.035533301532268524, -0.07704383879899979, -0.0031070001423358917, -0.07306934893131256, 0.031946826726198196, 0.005209865514189005, 0.04197802394628525, -0.002831891644746065, 0.06202928349375725, -0.027971237897872925, -0.04638005420565605, -0.006551818922162056, -0.011616281233727932, 0.008155287243425846, -0.0071825808845460415, 0.021375762298703194, 0.02524278499186039, 0.020052412524819374, -0.052146732807159424, -0.02418382652103901, -0.008339805528521538, -0.0284607894718647, 0.024492215365171432, -0.004498741123825312, 0.009532343596220016, -0.034040775150060654, -0.003968504257500172, -0.019708778709173203, 0.025712262839078903, 0.019179753959178925, -0.05799730867147446, -0.07656491547822952, -0.02340814098715782, -0.009000572375953197, 0.005700083449482918, 0.023879490792751312, 0.06599235534667969, 0.05283406749367714, -0.000047811365220695734, 0.0014044850831851363, -0.025686651468276978, -0.004459074232727289, 0.012631038203835487, -0.04948752000927925, 0.0014864581171423197, 0.013403354212641716, -0.04903745651245117, -0.058015383780002594, -0.028698168694972992, 0.018671851605176926, -0.053735364228487015, -0.00022786439512856305, 0.06203202158212662, 0.036551427096128464, -0.04006380960345268, -0.0560297816991806, 0.008685396984219551, -0.01674899272620678, -0.07351667433977127, -0.049733784049749374, 0.056002382189035416, 0.015361761674284935, 0.016402672976255417, 0.01914188452064991, -0.021760964766144753, -0.016056213527917862, -0.009410707280039787, -0.07551223039627075, 0.023446759209036827, 0.027253935113549232, 0.03721534088253975, -0.01190439984202385, -0.02055669017136097, 0.011371495202183723, -0.03451254218816757, 0.0008882507681846619, -0.02601282112300396, 0.013362620957195759, -0.006625361740589142, -0.02747349441051483, 0.00829351507127285, -0.06485998630523682, 0.013097883202135563, 0.04734174534678459, -0.052705179899930954, 0.007581762038171291, 0.012458539567887783, -0.0010678548133000731, 0.03163755685091019, -0.0065129646100103855, 0.06507205963134766, -0.01846686378121376, 0.04081546142697334, -0.04322757199406624, -0.009664766490459442, -0.04311282932758331, -0.03404238820075989, 0.010117831639945507, -0.055228330194950104, -0.013012874871492386, 0.03694913908839226, 0.0012197325704619288, 0.01055098045617342, 0.00031249556923285127, -0.044996969401836395, 0.014721199870109558, -0.037321340292692184, -0.01638156734406948, 0.027426542714238167, -0.017862951382994652, -0.011662092991173267, -0.03547130152583122, -0.0490705780684948, -0.0029428470879793167, 0.007816399447619915, 0.06331846117973328, 0.006012607365846634, 0.035907331854104996, -0.03584044426679611, 0.0066537633538246155, 0.0009361903066746891, 0.01311525609344244, -0.02889958769083023, 0.0777912512421608, 0.0018981207394972444, -0.01355966366827488, -0.030760370194911957, -0.056631945073604584, -0.023662114515900612, -0.061228737235069275, -0.01648605987429619, -0.05005522444844246, 0.06077110394835472, -0.020977279171347618, -0.04392058774828911, -0.017472928389906883, 0.02693570964038372, -0.003726337570697069, 0.03067842870950699, 0.04346265643835068, -0.00433379178866744, -0.02783755026757717, 0.06576087325811386, 0.019911764189600945, 0.006816883571445942, -0.010108781047165394, -0.014185876585543156, 0.009640318341553211, -0.041404761373996735, -0.02278287336230278, -0.014502246864140034, 0.04809017851948738, -0.053703341633081436, -0.02174322120845318, 0.005066943354904652, -0.019728530198335648, -0.06179005280137062, -0.0188848115503788, 0.029484890401363373, -0.03832069784402847, -0.04727200046181679 ]
In the search for stable lead (Pb) free perovskites, Vacancy ordered double perovskite (VODP), A$_2$BX$_6$ has emerged as a promising class of materials for solar harvesting owing to their nontoxicity, better stability, and unique optoelectronic properties. Here, we present the stability and the key physical attributes of few selected compounds in a systematic manner using state-of-the-art first-principle calculations. A careful structural and stability analysis via simulating convex hull and compositional phase diagrams for different structural prototypes discloses 14 stable and 1 metastable compounds in this class. The electronic structure calculations using hybrid functional reveals six compounds to acquire band gap in the ideal visible region. These six compounds, namely Cs$_2$SnI$_6$, Cs$_2$PdI$_6$, Cs$_2$TeI$_6$, Cs$_2$TiI$_6$, Cs$_2$PtI$_6$, and Cs$_2$PdBr$_6$, show high optical absorption ($\approx$ 10$^{5}$ cm $^{-1}$) giving rise to high spectroscopic limited maximum efficiency, SLME (15-23\%) in the thin-film thickness range. Close inspection of transport properties reveals polar optical phonon scattering to be the dominant mechanism limiting the overall mobility. Further analysis of the polaron excitations discloses the possibility of large polaron formation at low to moderate defect concentrations. At high defect concentrations, ionized impurity scattering takes over. This suggests that, a simulation based guided control of defect concentrations during synthesis can yield a desired candidate for promissing device application. Additionally, few selected compounds show moderate to high electron mobility values ($\sim$13-63 cm$^2$V$^{-1}$ s$^{-1}$) at room temperature. Overall, the present study paves an important path to help design VODP as Pb-free potential candidates for future optoelectronic applications.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06153v1
[ -0.07164714485406876, -0.025345394387841225, 0.007442477624863386, 0.021841086447238922, -0.03025873377919197, -0.04815707728266716, 0.03524192422628403, 0.04142672196030617, -0.00638887844979763, -0.049469832330942154, -0.005565423984080553, -0.054247837513685226, -0.013203266076743603, -0.02113393507897854, -0.024843495339155197, 0.013154980726540089, 0.04669453203678131, 0.045652348548173904, -0.037344228476285934, 0.05040460824966431, -0.00932075921446085, -0.040998540818691254, -0.010418426245450974, -0.006466608494520187, 0.03926974534988403, -0.014545510523021221, -0.0414569266140461, 0.006658736150711775, -0.04918183758854866, -0.0458514429628849, 0.029744895175099373, 0.026187140494585037, -0.03948575258255005, -0.05028104782104492, -0.014875623397529125, -0.041215937584638596, 0.007781644351780415, 0.049960821866989136, 0.054033126682043076, -0.047940708696842194, 0.021693943068385124, -0.07252604514360428, -0.04854527860879898, -0.03368621692061424, 0.02473613992333412, -0.0486576110124588, -0.0623893178999424, 0.006225709803402424, -0.07347947359085083, -0.051836639642715454, 0.02658497542142868, -0.04792399704456329, 0.0009512134711258113, 0.06437036395072937, -0.06344424188137054, 0.010684717446565628, 0.019470298662781715, -0.034290362149477005, -0.009387138299643993, 0.0270986407995224, 0.04538246616721153, -0.017167894169688225, -0.019139384850859642, -0.003582530654966831, -0.026844896376132965, 0.030128033831715584, -0.04282017797231674, -0.04914622753858566, -0.0417223796248436, -0.024720964953303337, 0.0013368127401918173, -0.04827701672911644, 0.02834145538508892, -0.03413094952702522, -0.05353850871324539, -0.04011360555887222, -0.0660102516412735, -0.025496959686279297, 0.01963050663471222, 0.016072582453489304, -0.03878479823470116, -0.03321275860071182, 0.03531866893172264, 0.021380413323640823, 0.04870038852095604, -0.025213681161403656, -0.02670876309275627, -0.025201350450515747, 0.002115638693794608, -0.0310352873057127, -0.007399433758109808, -0.006581971421837807, -0.03982687368988991, 0.037081386893987656, 0.045592620968818665, 0.01862063631415367, 0.05613543093204498, 0.013851002790033817, 0.06021476536989212, -0.04866119474172592, 0.007104616146534681, -0.027737747877836227, -0.04199505224823952, 0.021163644269108772, -0.00014018356159795076, -0.00719528179615736, 0.013004074804484844, 0.008665475994348526, -0.061849869787693024, -0.007050332147628069, 0.029408546164631844, 0.03704074025154114, -0.06997116655111313, -0.03749139606952667, -0.04503028467297554, -0.06092822924256325, 0.05489940196275711, 0.027070235460996628, 0.02408095821738243, 0.028310909867286682, 0.0015373314963653684, 0.021922359243035316, 0.04150403290987015, 0.006851068697869778, -0.026971742510795593, -0.017762526869773865, 0.032470572739839554, -0.0009923008037731051, 0.028691845014691353, 0.02548503689467907, -0.022105298936367035, 0.028227398172020912, 0.04571964219212532, -0.04870128631591797, 0.04814309626817703, -0.047635748982429504, -0.0004009939730167389, -0.016681740060448647, -0.02008514292538166, 0.02694588713347912, -0.06278044730424881, -0.060172028839588165, -0.03984461724758148, -0.03388115018606186, 0.03947160392999649, 0.06929373741149902, -0.051318004727363586, 0.016763299703598022, 0.02333763800561428, 0.052731774747371674, -0.004015377257019281, 0.013051267713308334, -0.01763019897043705, -0.017305824905633926, -0.012133762240409851, 0.013530978932976723, 0.0014776171883568168, 0.016880813986063004, -0.012164127081632614, 0.025806427001953125, 0.03920541703701019, -0.04145476222038269, 0.04196850210428238, 0.009312242269515991, -0.05488220974802971, 0.026696527376770973, -0.007689616177231073, -0.02783368155360222, 0.016542263329029083, 0.018817704170942307, -0.036780159920454025, -0.013029025867581367, -0.03985421732068062, -0.05760946497321129, -0.0719967857003212, -0.013848372735083103, 0.01935691386461258, -0.061313435435295105, -0.04320104047656059, 0.021148893982172012, 0.016280194744467735, -0.022120976820588112, -0.01375676691532135, -0.006340658757835627, -0.04168975353240967, 0.03427233174443245, -0.07784049212932587, -0.01393111888319254, 0.002426925813779235, -0.030047107487916946, -0.004005147609859705, -0.01651650108397007, -0.008925607427954674, -0.01136254332959652, -0.02295638807117939, -0.018794100731611252, 0.010463063605129719, -0.004969709552824497, -0.011160029098391533, -0.005823113489896059, -0.0810340866446495, -0.039980269968509674, -0.014681710861623287, 0.014839697629213333, -0.0035358539316803217, -0.0740603357553482, 0.002185381483286619, 0.046148866415023804, -0.05633881688117981, -0.04033008962869644, 0.04724038392305374, 0.02858600951731205, 0.02334599941968918, 0.01553894579410553, 0.0006130625843070447, -0.04241999238729477, -0.09339708089828491, 0.032414283603429794, 0.03505755588412285, -0.006509285885840654, 0.05822642892599106, 0.056298911571502686, 0.04296652227640152, -0.005888627842068672, -0.07008328288793564, 0.043814368546009064, 0.04844314232468605, -0.027808384969830513, -0.026793649420142174, 0.0050587416626513, 0.009745288640260696, -0.01754358410835266, -0.06613833457231522, -0.04874814674258232, -0.029589179903268814, -0.0127228032797575, -0.026014143601059914, 0.04459601640701294, -0.0316290445625782, -0.06281663477420807, -0.02040845714509487, -0.020999863743782043, 0.04297354817390442, -0.04702179133892059, -0.06064873933792114, -0.001834377646446228, -0.04346970468759537, 0.04445674642920494, -0.00287311477586627, -0.004631415940821171, 0.01824714057147503, -0.06635826826095581, 0.009153214283287525, -0.0072989268228411674, 0.06419812142848969, 0.048827722668647766, -0.01787986420094967, 0.030563032254576683, -0.04126040264964104, 0.03025285340845585, -0.018654130399227142, 0.04436087980866432, -0.0394231416285038, -0.01785089820623398, 0.03975106030702591, 0.05688314139842987, 0.0072800456546247005, -0.04471151530742645, -0.031099949032068253, -0.026722149923443794, -0.025130651891231537, 0.03599241003394127, 0.026217276230454445, 0.031510282307863235, 0.014526464976370335, 0.0010535757755860686, -0.024960996583104134, 0.0032483290415257215, 0.04469897598028183, 0.02665109373629093, 0.05305970832705498, 0.04376734420657158, -0.011350732296705246, -0.07527253031730652, -0.05750947445631027, -0.009601063095033169, -0.007668047212064266, -0.06254217028617859, -0.061149753630161285, -0.037100549787282944, -0.005696797277778387, -0.022489657625555992, -0.044664882123470306, -0.038631781935691833, -0.014813360758125782, -0.0569639652967453, -0.00620072428137064, 0.04095856845378876, 0.024093689396977425, -0.04761580377817154, -0.07249145209789276, 0.023746183142066002, 0.017921196296811104, 0.005131999962031841, -0.06674455851316452, -0.033304546028375626, -0.0718807578086853, 0.031577713787555695, -0.004192146938294172, -0.04011213406920433, -0.02318798564374447, 0.004723657388240099, -0.05059898644685745, -0.0013125004479661584, -0.017482010647654533, 0.06082184240221977, 0.030306197702884674, 0.04304174333810806, -0.002357008634135127, 0.01480657048523426, -0.020318934693932533, 0.026083309203386307, 0.00009207866241922602, -0.012442206963896751, -0.062034375965595245, -0.000946975196711719, 0.041995447129011154, 0.06278269737958908, -0.005822062026709318, 0.004274266306310892, -0.055588338524103165, -0.013467365875840187, -0.0234562698751688, 0.003724513342604041, 0.03243551775813103, 0.00813231524080038, -0.024979136884212494, -0.015266320668160915, 0.028996722772717476, 0.010688427835702896, -0.04134739190340042, 0.03535838797688484, -0.017701497301459312, -0.0377349816262722, 0.008226066827774048, -0.05495531111955643, 0.05931369960308075, 0.035796333104372025, 0.07639089226722717, -0.005070303101092577, -0.025423552840948105, 0.011803187429904938, 0.06251144409179688, -0.025333521887660027, -0.013240105472505093, 0.0329621322453022, 0.013279760256409645, 0.03488166257739067, -0.04938818886876106, -0.04022202268242836, -0.02832539938390255, -0.05001719295978546, -0.06410986185073853, 0.030792364850640297, -0.01412531454116106, 0.025425352156162262, -0.030970176681876183, -0.033508963882923126, 0.048100557178258896, 0.0027423962019383907, 0.05906815454363823, -0.041960909962654114, -0.030063537880778313, -0.023742342367768288, -0.023379920050501823, 0.025495868176221848, -0.043186988681554794, -0.04742800444364548, -0.02250681258738041, -0.06934867054224014, 0.0010322944726794958, -0.05326216667890549, -0.019039267674088478, 0.0008252310217358172, 0.008986318483948708, -0.01731868088245392, 0.029041536152362823, 0.027173632755875587, 0.02408738248050213, -0.014849742874503136, 0.004302592482417822, 0.006259332410991192, 0.008463977836072445, -0.024241963401436806, -0.055577363818883896, 0.0011711937841027975, -0.005400070454925299, 0.017571931704878807, -0.02360677719116211, -0.027290044352412224, -0.0009639856871217489, -0.023548267781734467, 0.0016669591423124075, -0.08571001887321472, -0.038266371935606, -0.0012804862344637513, -0.031585048884153366, -0.0036400228273123503, -0.019618667662143707, 0.03183409944176674, 0.009106134995818138, -0.032107699662446976, -0.025669032707810402, -0.006931039970368147, -0.02630653977394104, -0.06499621272087097, -0.06769372522830963, -0.037441715598106384, -0.01009299885481596, -0.018029648810625076, 0.015836725011467934, -0.027640454471111298, -0.007397799286991358, -0.0780356377363205, 0.027247721329331398, -0.02058878354728222, -0.008441203273832798, 0.03775084763765335, 0.007283435203135014, 0.03653326258063316, -0.012218949384987354, 0.049746375530958176, 0.0382368266582489, -0.04147367924451828, 0.05814545229077339, -0.035122063010931015, 0.04879789426922798, -0.03905908763408661, -0.04548714682459831, 0.01547103188931942, -0.02783862315118313, 0.06755010038614273, 0.018463289365172386, -0.011754903011023998, -0.005420616827905178, 0.0171006191521883, -0.023705143481492996, -0.011676083318889141, -0.008752616122364998, -0.05219082906842232, -0.044889386743307114, -0.05336637794971466, 0.0175783708691597, -0.002433312823995948, -0.03903530538082123, 0.027984125539660454, -0.003622620366513729, -0.03478654474020004, -0.026067769154906273, 0.055263452231884, 0.03932338207960129, 0.03703293576836586, -0.01726340875029564, 0.021355371922254562, -0.08233336359262466, -0.013509709388017654, -0.008273664861917496, 0.0019164986442774534, -0.014376054517924786, -0.025068001821637154, 0.04507619887590408, 0.004954822827130556, -0.08649875223636627, 0.0033159840386360884, 0.027942996472120285, -0.05519646033644676, -0.02864527516067028, 0.030715474858880043, 0.047645434737205505, 0.018563250079751015, -0.02694719284772873, -0.030861740931868553, -0.008280728943645954, -0.04303406551480293, -0.02269873209297657, -0.018100876361131668, -0.06395459175109863, 0.017017142847180367, 0.03885504603385925, 0.03483074903488159, -0.04165615513920784, -0.023463882505893707, 0.02238280698657036, 0.023646531626582146, -0.00925655197352171, 0.017857426777482033, 0.006621665321290493, -0.07230877131223679, -0.050456106662750244, -0.011227928102016449, -0.01270320825278759, -0.02350861392915249, 0.0287068672478199, -0.06134858354926109, -0.008751047775149345, 0.015803562477231026, 0.023019587621092796, 0.05015702545642853, 0.010144094005227089, -0.026793355122208595, -0.00571270240470767, 0.02385348081588745, -0.035624947398900986, -0.06396374851465225, 0.04162868112325668, -0.0556783452630043, -0.02203800156712532, -0.031000031158328056, 0.014061256311833858, 0.0371750146150589, 0.04955851286649704, 0.011856977827847004, -0.03635591268539429, -0.00044626841554418206, -0.05020608752965927, 0.06730721145868301, -0.011747279204428196, -0.028650088235735893, 0.0089255440980196, 0.03512828052043915, 0.0240835789591074, -0.033101845532655716, 0.03407283499836922, 0.019179491326212883, -0.03876759111881256, -0.005382062401622534, -0.002653013449162245, 0.015984494239091873, -0.06290566176176071, 0.016035636886954308, 0.0037100245244801044, -0.023187369108200073, 0.065683513879776, 0.019393278285861015, -0.0036925922613590956, 0.05655743181705475, 0.0017042186809703708, 0.04163249582052231, -0.04634798690676689, -0.04566248133778572, 0.06088058277964592, -0.06557953357696533, 0.012559395283460617, -0.0674026682972908, -0.03631294146180153, -0.03851339966058731, -0.05560213327407837, 0.0188888106495142, 0.029766250401735306, 0.005302424542605877, -0.05101848766207695, 0.01373035367578268, 0.04353389889001846, -0.06805560737848282, 0.05806219205260277, 0.013875818811357021, -0.06625877320766449, 0.00628276402130723, -0.03396094962954521, -0.002299696207046509, 0.005066954530775547, -0.009657754562795162, 0.010533424094319344, -0.036009885370731354, 0.001633189502172172, 0.054896943271160126, 0.04029742628335953, 0.030920352786779404, 0.017936745658516884, 0.01516709290444851, 0.0019936810713261366, -0.007460993714630604, -0.05653791502118111, -0.06167272478342056, -0.0005702421185560524, 0.05491065979003906, 0.015109844505786896, -0.006603058893233538, -0.04702860116958618, 0.032087307423353195, 0.012261038646101952, -0.0009457606938667595, 0.028052417561411858, -0.0012208981206640601, 0.002011129865422845, -0.06005234643816948, -0.011402977630496025, 0.008432845585048199, -0.06577049195766449, 0.016536716371774673, 0.01355200819671154, 0.0533936582505703, -0.0011541221756488085, 0.02449176460504532, 0.04122883453965187, -0.0072131771594285965, 0.00043185317190364003, -0.021652085706591606, -0.028080664575099945, -0.021260006353259087, -0.06479320675134659, -0.05760098993778229, 0.05774012953042984, 0.016468200832605362, -0.026188522577285767, 0.043679967522621155, -0.038905419409275055, 0.0024151396937668324, -0.018578611314296722, -0.034729912877082825, -0.011256687343120575, 0.060856662690639496, 0.033912792801856995, -0.0007159613305702806, 0.06898967921733856, -0.04804181680083275, 0.059993185102939606, -0.0424773171544075, -0.03475243225693703, -0.02729717083275318, -0.01219713594764471, -0.04645807668566704, -0.017976775765419006, -0.002046790439635515, -0.03374317288398743, 0.009399627335369587, 0.011042137630283833, -0.06973779201507568, -0.07035967707633972, 0.00737233879044652, -0.038184862583875656, -0.03756347671151161, 0.0025019540917128325, -0.03017887845635414, 0.06414573639631271, -0.008032402954995632, 0.046680983155965805, 0.0031534992158412933, 0.05444056913256645, -0.020798347890377045, -0.00154030229896307, 0.0008598616113886237, 0.06404881924390793, 0.05711175501346588, -0.04221777617931366, -0.04673708975315094, -0.03958538547158241, -0.07750232517719269, 0.00698866369202733, -0.023365123197436333, -0.0136016346514225, -0.018515266478061676, -0.021536722779273987, 0.05505866929888725, 0.04592367261648178, -0.03671504184603691, -0.060402482748031616, 0.010938284918665886, 0.008392608724534512, -0.018071379512548447, 0.008286993019282818, -0.025021206587553024, -0.04539560154080391, 0.0017340476624667645, -0.07941798865795135, -0.007800617255270481, 0.01245400682091713, 0.033592551946640015, 0.03617066890001297, 0.02559896744787693, 0.02293170616030693, -0.06885839253664017, -0.05230430141091347, -0.0007435422739945352, -0.03702156990766525, -0.03239884227514267, -0.04061998054385185, 0.017993109300732613, -0.04387769103050232, -0.012709328904747963, 0.023134464398026466, -0.01728697121143341, -0.02013329230248928, -0.013260063715279102, 0.042681094259023666, -0.031595055013895035, 0.046147458255290985, 0.04704585671424866, -0.0056970007717609406, 0.030749177560210228, -0.020118316635489464, 0.054462119936943054, -0.0007395426509901881, -0.0644012987613678, 0.05097339302301407, -0.028030136600136757, -0.025543199852108955, 0.00592047069221735, -0.024609673768281937, -0.03271009773015976, -0.03743590787053108, -0.039645858108997345, -0.031316664069890976, 0.03336762264370918, -0.0009941671742126346, 0.060265228152275085, -0.049014609307050705, -0.0051003433763980865, -0.004988562781363726, 0.0017156312242150307, -0.04673447459936142, 0.017259107902646065, 0.04764685034751892, -0.06526485085487366, -0.0050773024559021, -0.024828419089317322, -0.04965495318174362, 0.00936179794371128, 0.018460383638739586, -0.03950253501534462, 0.042818211019039154, -0.07176852226257324, -0.025291146710515022, -0.03797310218214989, 0.006908406503498554, -0.05492613837122917, -0.04570896551012993, -0.04053916037082672, -0.02798093669116497, 0.029729867354035378, 0.05445973947644234, 0.017063049599528313, -0.004029117990285158, 0.05469081923365593, -0.0017156852409243584, -0.027473628520965576, 0.040936876088380814, -0.007213379256427288, 0.024131331592798233, -0.005956808105111122, 0.015392085537314415, -0.035655777901411057, 0.007967058569192886, 0.04407317191362381, -0.003969715442508459, -0.02854079194366932, -0.029339198023080826, 0.011166509240865707, -0.033852607011795044, -0.026947246864438057, -0.0235513336956501, 0.03666342794895172, 0.022689834237098694, 0.006786882411688566, -0.034515734761953354, 0.020773870870471, 0.028781810775399208, -0.03162967413663864 ]
The parent compound of cuprates is a charge-transfer-type Mott insulator with strong hybridization between the Cu $3d_{\mathrm x^2-y^2}$ and O $2p$ orbitals. A key question concerning the pairing mechanism is the behavior of doped holes in the antiferromagnetic (AF) Mott insulator background, which is a prototypical quantum many-body problem. It was proposed that doped hole on the O site tends to form a singlet, known as Zhang-Rice singlet (ZRS), with the unpaired Cu spin. But experimentally little is known about the properties of a single hole and the interplay between them that leads to superconductivity. Here we use scanning tunneling microscopy to visualize the electronic states in hole-doped $\mathrm{Ca_2CuO_2Cl_2}$, aiming to establish the atomic-scale local basis for pair formation. A single doped hole is shown to have an in-gap state and a clover-shaped spatial distribution that can be attributed to a localized ZRS. When the dopants are close enough, they develop delocalized molecular orbitals with characteristic stripe- and ladder-shaped patterns, accompanied by the opening of a small gap around the Fermi level ($E_{\mathrm F}$). With increasing doping, the molecular orbitals proliferate in space and gradually form densely packed plaquettes, but the stripe and ladder patterns remain nearly the same. The low-energy electronic states of the molecular orbitals are intimately related to the local pairing properties, thus play a vitally important role in the emergence of superconductivity. We propose that the Cooper pair is formed by two holes occupying the stripe-like molecular orbital, while the attractive interaction is mediated by the AF spin background.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09260v1
[ -0.04150976613163948, -0.05943062901496887, 0.03680054470896721, -0.022031066939234734, -0.009631240740418434, -0.033840034157037735, -0.013999485410749912, 0.04212699830532074, -0.01181842666119337, 0.019188951700925827, 0.03252168744802475, -0.07056622952222824, 0.005906807724386454, -0.06361199170351028, -0.03229669854044914, 0.020316101610660553, 0.039827506989240646, 0.03817356750369072, -0.04561787471175194, 0.06624950468540192, -0.025599224492907524, -0.019235694780945778, -0.013106785714626312, 0.010439169593155384, -0.0051019517704844475, -0.007998447865247726, -0.05517143756151199, 0.06526251137256622, -0.05325806513428688, -0.017444243654608727, 0.07511822879314423, -0.022762028500437737, -0.04039188474416733, -0.012767956592142582, -0.03729722276329994, -0.011547538451850414, 0.032197367399930954, 0.051710765808820724, -0.006278051994740963, -0.05106348916888237, -0.002204515039920807, -0.023929443210363388, -0.06736255437135696, -0.021524034440517426, -0.0280163437128067, -0.05254976823925972, -0.026738371700048447, -0.006908986251801252, -0.0063420250080525875, -0.04352365434169769, 0.024251312017440796, 0.012288371101021767, 0.005777282174676657, 0.0533437617123127, -0.008135253563523293, 0.02479042299091816, -0.00592154311016202, -0.014978483319282532, 0.007428811863064766, 0.016176775097846985, -0.04055106267333031, -0.06517893821001053, 0.014675226993858814, -0.013813002035021782, -0.03322147578001022, 0.03537411615252495, -0.042116791009902954, -0.026921603828668594, 0.002838535699993372, -0.05489431321620941, 0.030915964394807816, -0.0703076496720314, 0.021549077704548836, 0.011504216119647026, -0.07435233145952225, 0.024999646469950676, -0.04461396858096123, -0.0002527926117181778, -0.023809803649783134, 0.010732810012996197, -0.005652433726936579, 0.007186491042375565, 0.030571820214390755, 0.02954600565135479, 0.005970998201519251, -0.010811069048941135, 0.06730769574642181, -0.03599951043725014, 0.034622520208358765, -0.044451840221881866, 0.037413064390420914, -0.030226102098822594, -0.019752439111471176, -0.012069934979081154, 0.07481960207223892, -0.05201771482825279, 0.080449178814888, 0.056322962045669556, 0.041143205016851425, 0.0021468577906489372, 0.022196665406227112, -0.03542318940162659, -0.0023603446315973997, 0.01792428456246853, -0.011785369366407394, -0.022181564942002296, 0.03203850984573364, 0.009477038867771626, -0.054800406098365784, 0.03410465270280838, -0.034841202199459076, 0.02832091599702835, -0.00967356190085411, -0.0718197226524353, -0.03908345848321915, -0.04573691636323929, 0.07253994047641754, 0.039362210780382156, 0.0715709924697876, 0.02955242060124874, -0.031119676306843758, 0.0379747673869133, 0.03685637190937996, -0.03866216540336609, -0.045966338366270065, -0.03525131940841675, 0.07061590254306793, 0.007926663383841515, 0.03098517470061779, -0.018678782507777214, -0.015403359197080135, 0.012762515805661678, 0.052243225276470184, -0.0542541928589344, 0.023508187383413315, -0.03107587620615959, 0.027269110083580017, 0.0032572054769843817, -0.022335221990942955, -0.004536466207355261, 0.005177782382816076, -0.07176799327135086, 0.024503005668520927, -0.013515847735106945, 0.022491956129670143, 0.022887345403432846, -0.05563576892018318, -0.03622077777981758, 0.03986256942152977, 0.038306377828121185, -0.0295989029109478, 0.022232476621866226, 0.04927673190832138, 0.0499056838452816, -0.014856358990073204, -0.04559008777141571, 0.020912786945700645, 0.01180028822273016, -0.044963523745536804, 0.00701470160856843, 0.01905122958123684, 0.0076610432006418705, 0.023157982155680656, 0.014619358815252781, 0.01744040474295616, 0.04094802215695381, -0.004016349092125893, -0.014187658205628395, 0.0029230050276964903, 0.032349325716495514, -0.018680499866604805, -0.0036502513103187084, -0.0027691011782735586, -0.05641041696071625, -0.04660969227552414, 0.01777251996099949, 0.018108900636434555, -0.030147859826683998, -0.01574038341641426, 0.03837749734520912, 0.025840263813734055, 0.006756773218512535, 0.013030877336859703, -0.036611344665288925, -0.043646395206451416, -0.021364634856581688, -0.08031181246042252, -0.014338470064103603, 0.017030054703354836, 0.002201271941885352, -0.0245742816478014, -0.04066111519932747, -0.0018536282004788518, 0.03450359031558037, -0.016910366714000702, 0.011051754467189312, 0.017614230513572693, -0.017195235937833786, -0.020085018128156662, 0.0012852270156145096, -0.06762784719467163, 0.013174382038414478, -0.028114698827266693, 0.00110332272015512, -0.0017733549466356635, -0.08760370314121246, 0.001327931648120284, 0.036134131252765656, -0.010500652715563774, -0.06169559061527252, 0.05767877399921417, 0.012795299291610718, 0.04656095430254936, 0.029937077313661575, 0.010982019826769829, 0.002469305880367756, -0.09572625905275345, 0.0027017509564757347, 0.031650446355342865, -0.004957129247486591, 0.06236322224140167, 0.04754747077822685, 0.024544009938836098, -0.03782889246940613, -0.04292212799191475, 0.06975766271352768, 0.06093166023492813, 0.02366618439555168, -0.022249020636081696, -0.02002566307783127, -0.01166782807558775, -0.05805576965212822, -0.02438301220536232, -0.032542310655117035, -0.04268892481923103, -0.011930939741432667, -0.07775670289993286, 0.06508614867925644, 0.009905668906867504, -0.060820162296295166, -0.07860615104436874, -0.003289266023784876, 0.05170751363039017, -0.012247513048350811, -0.05811895430088043, -0.048794716596603394, -0.06367328763008118, 0.05577733740210533, -0.03630378097295761, 0.008899099193513393, 0.004214823711663485, -0.07476083189249039, -0.014829255640506744, -0.02242327481508255, 0.04961472377181053, 0.05576437711715698, -0.025050614029169083, -0.00548490509390831, -0.02780279889702797, 0.06198129430413246, -0.004074657801538706, 0.025339536368846893, -0.02444484271109104, 0.004622624255716801, 0.02001071907579899, 0.023992637172341347, -0.023033365607261658, 0.009815826080739498, -0.0179207231849432, -0.03686635568737984, 0.023137323558330536, 0.023457827046513557, 0.026858773082494736, -0.00584470946341753, -0.0016878945752978325, -0.018944161012768745, -0.05460235849022865, -0.008859371766448021, 0.0006709113367833197, -0.035093266516923904, 0.05681857839226723, 0.047202009707689285, 0.002980149118229747, -0.06473226100206375, 0.003871491877362132, -0.02006738819181919, 0.0009285983396694064, -0.057808730751276016, -0.03946472331881523, -0.015995845198631287, -0.05797590687870979, 0.04763897508382797, -0.02932582050561905, -0.0175324734300375, -0.017398258671164513, -0.03951588273048401, -0.020329220220446587, 0.012406977824866772, 0.02771754004061222, -0.03692092373967171, -0.05890147387981415, 0.023345956578850746, 0.018072960898280144, 0.0023810199927538633, -0.008643575012683868, 0.008878347463905811, -0.039782967418432236, 0.015126136131584644, -0.00975436344742775, -0.009341537021100521, -0.00039765526889823377, 0.03777091205120087, -0.07100759446620941, -0.008456840179860592, 0.018881939351558685, 0.07362353056669235, 0.023851025849580765, -0.03243127465248108, 0.0055884853936731815, -0.0030355097260326147, -0.04802227020263672, -0.04828544333577156, 0.008903487585484982, -0.02340865507721901, -0.07324013113975525, -0.008428549394011497, 0.03583681210875511, 0.06928560137748718, -0.02866002544760704, -0.00615726038813591, 0.008045096881687641, 0.020506497472524643, 0.011858866550028324, -0.03539884090423584, 0.028234044089913368, 0.03469361737370491, -0.008990920148789883, -0.02805827185511589, -0.023541772738099098, 0.01813093200325966, -0.005747003480792046, 0.03713206574320793, 0.03142036497592926, -0.0326424315571785, 0.024193359538912773, -0.0691860243678093, 0.0034269136376678944, 0.05244132876396179, 0.051731303334236145, -0.02855866216123104, 0.017642339691519737, 0.014858069829642773, 0.0007004743092693388, 0.027402574196457863, 0.004437742289155722, 0.04420457035303116, 0.0004678273107856512, 0.03950881585478783, -0.05490412563085556, -0.010662218555808067, -0.029479259625077248, -0.07034192234277725, -0.035931576043367386, 0.04633495211601257, -0.02674289606511593, 0.021172909066081047, -0.005977983586490154, -0.0003182966902386397, 0.039242375642061234, -0.02796706184744835, 0.061915844678878784, -0.02738523855805397, -0.04657526686787605, 0.020226214081048965, -0.012522200122475624, -0.028284039348363876, 0.00866164080798626, -0.011576748453080654, -0.0635000690817833, -0.06207236275076866, 0.023261182010173798, -0.060920797288417816, 0.00796456728130579, 0.018145546317100525, 0.0343114398419857, 0.027474962174892426, 0.011642382480204105, 0.01854587532579899, 0.01856248825788498, -0.010718083009123802, 0.03275442123413086, -0.012927262112498283, -0.00813265796750784, 0.029210733249783516, 0.010785515420138836, -0.024953216314315796, -0.041090238839387894, -0.03384090214967728, -0.06920915096998215, -0.0004664410080295056, 0.03681785240769386, 0.001805360778234899, -0.03648841381072998, -0.08338218927383423, -0.04991297051310539, -0.029988059774041176, 0.023992368951439857, 0.02612997032701969, -0.04451398923993111, 0.07607406377792358, -0.027240905910730362, -0.0018451594514772296, 0.006000574678182602, -0.01558184064924717, -0.03991894796490669, -0.06301798671483994, -0.03525708243250847, -0.04610120505094528, 0.007812409196048975, -0.052743494510650635, 0.020938558503985405, 0.0061667319387197495, 0.0001095917759812437, -0.0756964385509491, 0.07542502135038376, -0.00156261189840734, 0.010254361666738987, 0.05266352370381355, -0.002039293060079217, 0.024117328226566315, -0.04383799433708191, -0.005026714876294136, -0.020463719964027405, -0.06226911395788193, 0.044597212225198746, -0.07115133106708527, 0.050194911658763885, -0.05598299205303192, -0.05014573410153389, -0.02273060381412506, -0.0073865801095962524, 0.022359568625688553, -0.03751721233129501, -0.01594703458249569, -0.039029840379953384, -0.012524177320301533, -0.054430462419986725, -0.027862241491675377, -0.04564507305622101, -0.006502548232674599, -0.07316530495882034, 0.012436292134225368, 0.02688063122332096, -0.014931172132492065, 0.0167239923030138, -0.00691525312140584, 0.03869929164648056, 0.009911204688251019, 0.002895721234381199, 0.007304616272449493, 0.060619793832302094, 0.035493843257427216, 0.009615438990294933, -0.03249919041991234, -0.07516110688447952, 0.03835773468017578, -0.013179746456444263, 0.012479230761528015, -0.012786534614861012, 0.02002929337322712, -0.0172584131360054, 0.05819392949342728, -0.08586986362934113, 0.04355141893029213, 0.05336470529437065, -0.054909925907850266, 0.014007226563990116, 0.01778269000351429, 0.013715469278395176, -0.002384844934567809, -0.00838592741638422, 0.02044413611292839, -0.010686440393328667, -0.01658906601369381, -0.015548737719655037, -0.013665705919265747, -0.052435968071222305, 0.02217366173863411, 0.03668250888586044, -0.035308197140693665, -0.042803674936294556, 0.006202508229762316, 0.005015032831579447, 0.00224423804320395, -0.05203302949666977, 0.052399616688489914, 0.027371125295758247, -0.030075181275606155, -0.06018798053264618, -0.018894484266638756, -0.02519923821091652, 0.042216960340738297, 0.059765830636024475, -0.03423266485333443, 0.03228191286325455, 0.01942002773284912, 0.005820142105221748, 0.03285329043865204, 0.025704341009259224, 0.01654895208775997, -0.036063335835933685, 0.030413130298256874, -0.05360790714621544, -0.06739768385887146, -0.025615494698286057, -0.045688431710004807, 0.02439081482589245, 0.031245650723576546, 0.017438042908906937, 0.04970882087945938, 0.023436984047293663, -0.03678188472986221, -0.05188135430216789, -0.05622658506035805, -0.030053090304136276, 0.040782783180475235, -0.05335889011621475, 0.013465402647852898, -0.0032885270193219185, 0.007219546940177679, 0.03084621950984001, -0.03363717719912529, -0.04385426640510559, 0.02054610662162304, -0.0668308436870575, -0.01489934977144003, 0.03564019128680229, -0.0028545064851641655, -0.026392919942736626, 0.02967563457787037, 0.05094921216368675, -0.05226045474410057, 0.01888073794543743, 0.06396308541297913, 0.011215897276997566, 0.02148647978901863, -0.014742466621100903, 0.03840739652514458, -0.024759821593761444, -0.03660794347524643, 0.07307087630033493, -0.06748481094837189, -0.011206768453121185, 0.0008675866411067545, -0.04830119386315346, 0.024588756263256073, -0.056696340441703796, 0.010418773628771305, 0.009378001093864441, -0.008647726848721504, -0.010001519694924355, 0.02164553478360176, -0.023774096742272377, -0.07071606814861298, -0.01822349615395069, 0.009078348986804485, -0.04502414911985397, -0.04820318520069122, -0.007407625205814838, -0.014184428378939629, -0.042739078402519226, 0.0317927747964859, -0.02122517116367817, -0.04499457776546478, 0.0005711293779313564, 0.04746328294277191, 0.03391706570982933, -0.04905185475945473, -0.008674426935613155, 0.024671299383044243, 0.00010511082655284554, 0.019119512289762497, -0.07200291007757187, -0.018045630306005478, 0.009500899352133274, 0.06502599269151688, 0.03207292780280113, -0.038711488246917725, -0.018298018723726273, 0.03050823137164116, 0.04234204441308975, 0.004745566286146641, 0.020411338657140732, 0.014496132731437683, 0.02055838145315647, -0.02457929216325283, -0.04968193545937538, 0.023360902443528175, -0.06463326513767242, 0.011125560849905014, 0.007918418385088444, 0.04334669187664986, -0.019912920892238617, 0.032669275999069214, -0.008784259669482708, -0.043485257774591446, -0.016848519444465637, -0.04976366460323334, -0.04620147496461868, -0.01696498692035675, -0.03638681769371033, -0.008468205109238625, 0.009277794510126114, 0.04145125299692154, 0.001422981033101678, 0.010027575306594372, -0.06022215634584427, 0.000388054788345471, -0.01696234941482544, 0.010359165258705616, -0.019255921244621277, 0.039052676409482956, 0.01533457450568676, -0.014669223688542843, 0.023177189752459526, -0.013689467683434486, 0.014198575168848038, -0.013390736654400826, -0.04203839227557182, 0.036432672291994095, -0.030453097075223923, -0.04306473955512047, -0.009344983845949173, -0.029814381152391434, -0.06836797297000885, 0.029506176710128784, 0.01060416828840971, -0.03576213866472244, -0.07045222818851471, -0.007157304789870977, -0.040803663432598114, -0.018055662512779236, 0.061677008867263794, -0.005865861661732197, 0.05566975474357605, -0.027442632243037224, 0.04451257735490799, 0.04272828996181488, 0.027936620637774467, -0.046111900359392166, -0.029502876102924347, -0.013385839760303497, 0.026295116171240807, 0.007240183651447296, -0.025990823283791542, -0.02035100944340229, -0.06697050482034683, -0.06769689172506332, 0.0012311958707869053, 0.02060745470225811, 0.0017155376262962818, -0.034985605627298355, 0.0005277138552628458, 0.05815419927239418, -0.0047026509419083595, 0.02208765596151352, -0.08266931772232056, -0.03381786495447159, 0.012344122864305973, 0.007630640175193548, -0.01285426877439022, 0.023511268198490143, -0.06087079644203186, 0.023612162098288536, -0.07916896045207977, 0.017974460497498512, -0.021902188658714294, 0.06357146054506302, 0.017585989087820053, -0.02017064020037651, -0.013813415542244911, -0.00551520474255085, -0.02433047629892826, 0.015472067520022392, 0.0000325773362419568, 0.02089867554605007, 0.011461367830634117, -0.01350623182952404, -0.04195859283208847, -0.008224111050367355, 0.018027424812316895, -0.053375232964754105, -0.005520630162209272, 0.0063821738585829735, 0.021791407838463783, -0.037557102739810944, 0.03656560927629471, 0.0028269172180444, -0.030100181698799133, 0.04317363724112511, -0.023067785426974297, -0.01491332333534956, 0.002303207293152809, -0.0766858235001564, 0.03647015616297722, -0.06757370382547379, -0.008928244933485985, 0.01615257002413273, -0.023961348459124565, -0.029093433171510696, -0.0452338270843029, -0.05441054329276085, 0.04194952920079231, 0.0202778372913599, -0.04490095004439354, 0.05907699093222618, -0.06371816247701645, -0.027818338945508003, -0.032718732953071594, -0.008584785275161266, -0.01464077178388834, 0.04243015497922897, 0.049783073365688324, -0.05660716071724892, 0.0025810468941926956, -0.07309127599000931, 0.012218688614666462, 0.00040965373045764863, -0.022519981488585472, 0.02166391909122467, 0.03642716631293297, -0.05401523783802986, 0.03213616833090782, -0.04898637905716896, -0.05848873034119606, 0.041172899305820465, -0.05438460782170296, 0.016157975420355797, -0.010917417705059052, 0.024241715669631958, 0.044572070240974426, 0.01656096614897251, -0.010820820927619934, 0.062240056693553925, 0.039424557238817215, 0.00544999074190855, 0.019834131002426147, 0.009798411279916763, -0.03613651916384697, 0.007779765408486128, 0.019057661294937134, -0.04970827326178551, -0.011756639927625656, 0.010934902355074883, 0.008245727978646755, 0.013107551261782646, -0.05463172867894173, 0.008126544766128063, -0.006082148291170597, -0.028896011412143707, -0.010190694592893124, 0.07310961186885834, 0.03568485379219055, 0.01980680599808693, 0.0251664686948061, 0.011128918267786503, -0.04622657969594002, -0.05754586309194565 ]
For widespread adoption, public security and surveillance systems must be accurate, portable, compact, and real-time, without impeding the privacy of the individuals being observed. Current systems broadly fall into two categories -- image-based which are accurate, but lack privacy, and RF signal-based, which preserve privacy but lack portability, compactness and accuracy. Our paper proposes mmSense, an end-to-end portable miniaturised real-time system that can accurately detect the presence of concealed metallic objects on persons in a discrete, privacy-preserving modality. mmSense features millimeter wave radar technology, provided by Google's Soli sensor for its data acquisition, and TransDope, our real-time neural network, capable of processing a single radar data frame in 19 ms. mmSense achieves high recognition rates on a diverse set of challenging scenes while running on standard laptop hardware, demonstrating a significant advancement towards creating portable, cost-effective real-time radar based surveillance systems.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14625v1
[ -0.04785606637597084, 0.012573045678436756, 0.07427451759576797, 0.031922802329063416, 0.02250879630446434, 0.004068031441420317, 0.012692449614405632, -0.021202024072408676, -0.01916969195008278, -0.05432254448533058, -0.04425344243645668, 0.009921043179929256, -0.06664739549160004, -0.0499359630048275, -0.03242066875100136, 0.036158591508865356, 0.04297937825322151, 0.03137102723121643, -0.028267739340662956, 0.062497399747371674, -0.009408093057572842, -0.05307937040925026, 0.011599713005125523, -0.033080704510211945, -0.03076377883553505, -0.014246001839637756, -0.022034360095858574, 0.025568228214979172, -0.05051064491271973, -0.03319847583770752, -0.01277014147490263, -0.035124246031045914, -0.004991744179278612, -0.0007780323503538966, -0.052262820303440094, 0.010723274201154709, -0.013982788659632206, 0.047124382108449936, -0.015175020322203636, -0.03897809237241745, 0.010603529401123524, -0.02178170718252659, -0.007586585357785225, -0.08048516511917114, -0.02071864902973175, -0.02210301347076893, -0.07444239407777786, -0.0017893911572173238, -0.04383262246847153, 0.011542174965143204, 0.053674206137657166, -0.04282385855913162, 0.045237477868795395, 0.07487187534570694, 0.03878368064761162, -0.01245761476457119, -0.015776323154568672, 0.007192403078079224, 0.025141924619674683, 0.03789541497826576, 0.015630599111318588, -0.031736813485622406, 0.022337259724736214, -0.02513776905834675, 0.03029591776430607, 0.059453919529914856, -0.06617739796638489, -0.0619574598968029, -0.023812225088477135, -0.04239603504538536, 0.024813983589410782, -0.05040965601801872, 0.014939257875084877, 0.035005856305360794, -0.0533457025885582, -0.020023565739393234, -0.015339692123234272, -0.04791467636823654, 0.0038096210919320583, 0.01697869971394539, -0.015265055000782013, 0.026090025901794434, 0.03350629284977913, 0.0029579901602119207, -0.016141723841428757, -0.03510504961013794, 0.04885498434305191, -0.02721703238785267, 0.020281203091144562, -0.009370441548526287, 0.01938493922352791, -0.038653336465358734, -0.08739246428012848, 0.006423781160265207, 0.07690522819757462, 0.026451928541064262, 0.0721466988325119, 0.06060539558529854, 0.006547339726239443, -0.022488921880722046, -0.003586855484172702, 0.002382124774158001, -0.020315010100603104, 0.04209791123867035, -0.007289433386176825, -0.0251470860093832, -0.008856219239532948, 0.0006510626990348101, -0.05423504486680031, 0.012982320040464401, -0.03474397584795952, -0.05001042038202286, -0.02462444081902504, -0.057494889944791794, -0.013990006409585476, -0.04260937497019768, 0.03540604189038277, -0.005460443440824747, -0.005577291361987591, 0.05496497452259064, -0.045944150537252426, -0.00820484384894371, 0.03407590463757515, -0.041956737637519836, -0.0490439310669899, -0.012307759374380112, 0.06460394710302353, -0.026935748755931854, -0.025243300944566727, -0.025393007323145866, -0.011028768494725227, 0.035951461642980576, -0.0072401962243020535, -0.024171626195311546, 0.051160380244255066, 0.0007081832736730576, 0.015618442557752132, -0.05274982005357742, 0.001002738019451499, -0.013826747424900532, -0.0163885485380888, -0.018133124336600304, 0.006341956555843353, -0.030928272753953934, -0.004539914429187775, -0.0014177976408973336, -0.04579164832830429, -0.015153218992054462, 0.028474699705839157, 0.06125793233513832, 0.013322326354682446, -0.026254715397953987, 0.002158181043341756, 0.031903136521577835, -0.018190329894423485, 0.019273219630122185, 0.04370781034231186, -0.052869196981191635, -0.050382643938064575, 0.0014749105321243405, 0.055736273527145386, -0.028796205297112465, 0.016601966693997383, -0.043534040451049805, -0.018082058057188988, 0.013449378311634064, 0.02028566412627697, -0.017597021535038948, 0.006847874261438847, 0.031969115138053894, -0.04216581583023071, -0.05226963385939598, -0.005008838605135679, 0.0003964475472457707, -0.052910175174474716, 0.007719832472503185, -0.013507639989256859, -0.051512978971004486, 0.0028095191810280085, -0.004188746213912964, -0.0030265809036791325, 0.02784058451652527, -0.02478218823671341, -0.0005359968636184931, -0.05961943417787552, -0.0070215254090726376, -0.07076908648014069, -0.042086075991392136, 0.045251160860061646, 0.01614692434668541, -0.06020326539874077, -0.021950863301753998, -0.00915142334997654, -0.019055256620049477, -0.017730901017785072, -0.005103560164570808, -0.043712615966796875, -0.053748708218336105, 0.02741563506424427, 0.02688569948077202, -0.08723752945661545, -0.04591430723667145, -0.054519474506378174, -0.030900729820132256, 0.007043903693556786, -0.04984953626990318, 0.0430920384824276, -0.009683611802756786, -0.03137107193470001, 0.02665376290678978, 0.03319085016846657, 0.04342404752969742, 0.04216703027486801, 0.0255583468824625, 0.031607408076524734, 0.010900933295488358, -0.09732827544212341, 0.014476091600954533, 0.023178264498710632, -0.006478078197687864, 0.04350904002785683, 0.024333201348781586, -0.01974041573703289, 0.01367034763097763, 0.0008790256688371301, 0.044725820422172546, 0.06915614753961563, -0.011529440991580486, -0.04600128158926964, -0.009205485694110394, -0.024852082133293152, -0.07393253594636917, -0.05983700230717659, -0.05417557433247566, -0.056503113359212875, -0.006949145346879959, -0.050317585468292236, 0.04080495238304138, -0.0572480708360672, 0.003499458311125636, -0.03434254229068756, -0.06538695096969604, 0.050060681998729706, -0.02338775061070919, -0.03159324452280998, -0.04101044312119484, -0.020750300958752632, 0.0696864053606987, -0.03878051042556763, 0.006734796334058046, -0.008081014268100262, -0.021745091304183006, 0.008450187742710114, -0.043122317641973495, 0.023341545835137367, 0.05402277782559395, -0.03582753986120224, 0.019505005329847336, 0.005491047631949186, 0.042126793414354324, 0.001368476077914238, 0.004058919381350279, -0.07098820805549622, 0.013726889155805111, 0.025624804198741913, -0.04113994538784027, -0.03770424425601959, 0.01829621195793152, 0.016138918697834015, -0.01829136349260807, -0.011889039538800716, -0.008306346833705902, 0.030130399391055107, -0.04602991044521332, -0.02311927080154419, -0.03273218125104904, 0.033711228519678116, -0.029783306643366814, 0.011877298355102539, 0.029405752196907997, 0.04420273378491402, 0.00038368478999473155, 0.045970190316438675, -0.05750672519207001, -0.024259721860289574, -0.04582994058728218, -0.015949390828609467, -0.052931226789951324, -0.03613632917404175, -0.0005634981789626181, -0.058942049741744995, -0.019650893285870552, -0.0008832549792714417, -0.029092522338032722, 0.026528382673859596, -0.05345163494348526, -0.01076557394117117, 0.018108412623405457, 0.027204928919672966, 0.026714878156781197, -0.021313268691301346, -0.048434991389513016, -0.0009826429886743426, 0.02189011313021183, -0.03172154352068901, -0.06645678728818893, -0.01926007866859436, 0.006976999808102846, 0.020762020722031593, -0.026002218946814537, -0.0006405701860785484, 0.059017300605773926, -0.0019168471917510033, -0.014931698329746723, -0.009159387089312077, -0.0036751830484718084, 0.03196490556001663, -0.016737641766667366, -0.014762873761355877, 0.03326326608657837, 0.03436693921685219, -0.046650879085063934, 0.016032565385103226, -0.029116632416844368, -0.025223078206181526, -0.02355113811790943, 0.019257307052612305, 0.0038206237368285656, -0.018292833119630814, -0.008987325243651867, 0.05600370466709137, 0.04795055463910103, -0.01507968083024025, 0.007783717010170221, 0.02827516943216324, -0.015278799459338188, -0.029070420190691948, 0.016153039410710335, -0.013361512683331966, 0.027695495635271072, 0.0027821252588182688, 0.05872153118252754, -0.030224135145545006, -0.0549415722489357, 0.03853970021009445, -0.08464162051677704, -0.0005829720757901669, 0.025449633598327637, 0.06406573951244354, 0.0009905204642564058, 0.04346524178981781, 0.05443306267261505, 0.03150685504078865, 0.037711773067712784, 0.006771536078304052, -0.010338939726352692, -0.0022790031507611275, 0.055173926055431366, -0.03808026760816574, -0.038747236132621765, 0.028866570442914963, -0.02593144029378891, -0.006914802826941013, 0.03467096760869026, -0.046857718378305435, 0.00769590912386775, 0.048076990991830826, -0.03733324259519577, -0.028375236317515373, -0.0030056857503950596, 0.052676212042570114, 0.01220339722931385, -0.009048678912222385, 0.06420450657606125, -0.025597965344786644, -0.0009626316023059189, -0.0015534317353740335, -0.008135215379297733, -0.007343350909650326, -0.07074549794197083, -0.014799455180764198, -0.052343904972076416, 0.02526763826608658, -0.00967768020927906, -0.0277378149330616, -0.009430032223463058, 0.029610706493258476, 0.004016324412077665, 0.012752084992825985, 0.026522766798734665, -0.017128868028521538, 0.014704334549605846, -0.022052256390452385, -0.01050378754734993, -0.016340045258402824, -0.021342361345887184, -0.0018761483952403069, -0.004147141240537167, -0.02759101428091526, 0.028759298846125603, -0.020344700664281845, -0.050540219992399216, 0.04102294519543648, -0.0718824565410614, -0.005151396617293358, -0.04161734879016876, 0.047664619982242584, -0.02358507178723812, 0.0032099923118948936, 0.051145508885383606, -0.06800723075866699, 0.014612752944231033, -0.029178785160183907, -0.002084561390802264, -0.006708971224725246, -0.03446357697248459, -0.0065935212187469006, -0.06391940265893936, -0.014242243021726608, -0.02418540231883526, 0.06630839407444, -0.02084708772599697, 0.028012868016958237, -0.03372446820139885, -0.029842952266335487, -0.007724416442215443, 0.024325359612703323, 0.007511575240641832, -0.010088478215038776, -0.007965557277202606, -0.035913269966840744, 0.0022165069822221994, 0.041246529668569565, -0.02057499997317791, 0.04960804805159569, 0.012451880611479282, 0.040911994874477386, -0.02780911512672901, 0.012113453820347786, 0.004295465536415577, -0.020842058584094048, 0.042123518884181976, -0.049058545380830765, -0.03382689878344536, 0.013811709359288216, 0.020766038447618484, -0.030775658786296844, -0.025016676634550095, -0.0272662416100502, -0.03227817267179489, -0.07683797925710678, -0.03698095306754112, 0.04250563681125641, -0.008057724684476852, 0.007536723278462887, 0.013621436432003975, 0.0366215780377388, -0.011696064844727516, -0.025621742010116577, -0.04349932819604874, 0.002380001824349165, 0.010381454601883888, -0.013574721291661263, -0.05686769261956215, -0.042391225695610046, -0.04294882342219353, -0.020696043968200684, -0.01641201414167881, -0.012592794373631477, 0.0015796722145751119, 0.03229321166872978, 0.008594273589551449, -0.07494967430830002, 0.014131960459053516, 0.055603861808776855, -0.06437421590089798, 0.053502097725868225, 0.05308043211698532, 0.03974393010139465, 0.045372869819402695, -0.04851255938410759, 0.018178867176175117, 0.04093553498387337, -0.04919833689928055, -0.056137796491384506, 0.04687359184026718, -0.028608495369553566, -0.02689293399453163, 0.01638656109571457, -0.05108313262462616, -0.043559737503528595, 0.023967904970049858, 0.024455884471535683, -0.012752098962664604, 0.0022625040728598833, 0.004322719294577837, 0.05228201672434807, 0.0008142154547385871, -0.05534658953547478, -0.023592902347445488, -0.011066536419093609, 0.03769313171505928, 0.053076911717653275, -0.02385019138455391, -0.023035014048218727, 0.0055661750957369804, -0.05065366253256798, 0.005019063595682383, 0.01878213882446289, -0.021041104570031166, -0.01172549743205309, 0.00014174243551678956, -0.033529117703437805, -0.06653500348329544, -0.04024318605661392, -0.05523053929209709, -0.012286674231290817, 0.034052543342113495, 0.05673665180802345, 0.051831308752298355, -0.017441974952816963, -0.016645357012748718, 0.02224455587565899, -0.020593205466866493, -0.03768396005034447, -0.015895109623670578, -0.02812216430902481, 0.04841885715723038, -0.016678892076015472, 0.06088734790682793, -0.002967462409287691, -0.016947021707892418, 0.02798481285572052, 0.0106290178373456, -0.04716550558805466, -0.02021402306854725, 0.005756506696343422, -0.04442289471626282, -0.0697423592209816, 0.04948151111602783, 0.027610940858721733, -0.046003829687833786, 0.06507192552089691, 0.035911429673433304, -0.010463806800544262, 0.046827320009469986, -0.014375541359186172, -0.00601035775616765, -0.02318049967288971, -0.013665925711393356, 0.04541982337832451, 0.004495239816606045, -0.03195525333285332, -0.047627441585063934, -0.012009767815470695, -0.016578415408730507, -0.058226946741342545, 0.010404211468994617, 0.019183112308382988, -0.006049859803169966, -0.03724364563822746, 0.004306087736040354, -0.02280474081635475, -0.05460023507475853, 0.03813004121184349, -0.011529986746609211, -0.06543564051389694, -0.0012724590487778187, 0.01838035136461258, -0.028043227270245552, -0.04674787074327469, 0.051129963248968124, 0.009422045201063156, 0.012943368405103683, -0.009293974377214909, 0.05653660371899605, 0.06922096014022827, 0.03071240521967411, -0.011049867607653141, -0.008469981141388416, -0.03689280152320862, 0.010012118145823479, -0.03095901384949684, 0.0027734446339309216, 0.025995463132858276, 0.01201410312205553, 0.005303794518113136, -0.078945592045784, -0.05084558576345444, 0.05501873791217804, -0.040164005011320114, -0.052227914333343506, -0.00370794627815485, -0.01314658671617508, 0.0635785236954689, -0.045212727040052414, -0.013565168716013432, -0.000393400143366307, -0.041526902467012405, 0.05935201421380043, 0.015409271232783794, 0.03828210011124611, 0.01597016490995884, 0.00973048061132431, -0.002773895626887679, -0.045568808913230896, -0.009580145590007305, -0.024112779647111893, -0.009213543497025967, -0.0160947497934103, -0.06993405520915985, -0.043226394802331924, -0.017213396728038788, 0.0050912597216665745, 0.06653027981519699, 0.02801281027495861, -0.058933794498443604, -0.03352724015712738, -0.05715654790401459, -0.026506725698709488, -0.0010017359163612127, -0.04125503450632095, 0.05024174973368645, 0.003372115781530738, -0.018629902973771095, -0.03611995652318001, -0.06484830379486084, 0.0075132763013243675, -0.05310278758406639, 0.04225591942667961, -0.03306067734956741, -0.012440637685358524, -0.00005165380935068242, -0.03179096430540085, -0.030204957351088524, 0.007952996529638767, 0.03311466425657272, -0.031142065301537514, -0.031115438789129257, 0.014750020578503609, -0.0366206169128418, -0.01815200224518776, -0.051651112735271454, 0.027932725846767426, 0.01490828674286604, -0.04295450821518898, 0.023976381868124008, 0.05181227624416351, -0.0302419513463974, -0.00044326880015432835, -0.04883291572332382, -0.03352217748761177, 0.06087116152048111, -0.03550843521952629, -0.03177879378199577, -0.05617069825530052, -0.05449407175183296, -0.05968443676829338, -0.012896714732050896, 0.05865490809082985, -0.022205723449587822, -0.0507984422147274, -0.024625960737466812, 0.02679256908595562, 0.00912727601826191, -0.042521025985479355, -0.05982505902647972, 0.03507623076438904, -0.005373732186853886, -0.060064494609832764, -0.01585882157087326, 0.016930781304836273, -0.034302111715078354, 0.05722341313958168, -0.07092507928609848, 0.015115635469555855, 0.0030251992866396904, -0.0002846845891326666, -0.04526154696941376, -0.0566776767373085, -0.04325921833515167, -0.05080428719520569, -0.0460011325776577, 0.07132300734519958, 0.00030312486342154443, -0.013200841844081879, 0.022082384675741196, -0.05210660770535469, -0.047116685658693314, -0.06197502464056015, 0.0032830785494297743, -0.03466874733567238, -0.02460235357284546, 0.041818901896476746, 0.030120935291051865, 0.024661848321557045, -0.016404131427407265, 0.04231656342744827, -0.022017957642674446, 0.03390463814139366, -0.04217302426695824, 0.025464702397584915, -0.04149749130010605, -0.06207077205181122, 0.04258143901824951, -0.055658116936683655, -0.022156575694680214, 0.046606507152318954, -0.03787734732031822, 0.0520983450114727, -0.045894425362348557, -0.07808532565832138, 0.005528122186660767, -0.015984434634447098, 0.004797590896487236, 0.06235432252287865, -0.055857472121715546, -0.017775850370526314, -0.03434767946600914, -0.021634463220834732, -0.07647247612476349, 0.013665718026459217, 0.03529602289199829, -0.03857148066163063, 0.00736428564414382, -0.041642289608716965, 0.000448938604677096, 0.009325021877884865, -0.021782873198390007, -0.07126160711050034, 0.0806695744395256, -0.03674353286623955, -0.00859091430902481, -0.05111520364880562, -0.052321966737508774, 0.01029504369944334, -0.013529408723115921, -0.03275223448872566, -0.06731158494949341, 0.049052655696868896, -0.01087502483278513, 0.004462051670998335, 0.04538218304514885, 0.0204931627959013, 0.03147471696138382, 0.015887051820755005, 0.020062630996108055, -0.006538103334605694, -0.06136542931199074, 0.07249895483255386, 0.00013019835751038045, 0.06355196237564087, -0.04619842767715454, 0.014810006134212017, -0.016572291031479836, -0.008109570480883121, -0.05400380864739418, 0.018337944522500038, 0.026795724406838417, -0.07673604041337967, 0.0218507070094347, -0.024804696440696716, 0.00494483532384038, -0.045511599630117416, -0.051874641329050064, 0.023418022319674492, 0.0012808506144210696, -0.06027942895889282 ]
Future wireless systems are likely to adopt extremely large aperture arrays to achieve higher throughput, wider coverage, and higher spatial resolution. Conventional wireless systems predominantly operate in the far field (FF) of the radiation source. However, as the array size increases and the carrier wavelength decreases, the near field (NF) becomes nonnegligible. Since the NF and FF differ in many aspects, it is critical to identify their corresponding regions. In this article, we first provide a comprehensive overview of the existing NF-FF boundaries, then introduce a novel NF-FF demarcation method based on effective degrees of freedom (EDoF) of the channel. Since EDoF is intimately related to channel capacity, the EDoF-based border is able to characterize key channel performance more accurately than the classic Rayleigh distance and other representative benchmarks. Furthermore, we analyze the main features of the EDoF-based NF-FF boundary, provide insights into system design, and outline the associated challenges and research opportunities.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13238v2
[ -0.016837164759635925, 0.02134847827255726, 0.022375209257006645, 0.05039115622639656, 0.00239616259932518, -0.0350322462618351, -0.03558247536420822, 0.000274154037469998, -0.03475303202867508, 0.008989323861896992, -0.010576133616268635, -0.033648524433374405, -0.06680189818143845, -0.06099411100149155, -0.07013159990310669, 0.006471886765211821, 0.0355788879096508, 0.04575268179178238, -0.009366897866129875, 0.05154731869697571, -0.01779167540371418, -0.020193850621581078, -0.012643651105463505, -0.008824502117931843, 0.05187726393342018, 0.045836031436920166, -0.007870011031627655, -0.0006250478327274323, 0.03704838827252388, -0.022536972537636757, 0.026891030371189117, -0.017410796135663986, -0.046517062932252884, 0.008748259395360947, -0.03881193697452545, -0.004785469267517328, -0.026306824758648872, 0.0532199889421463, -0.0037489328533411026, -0.033405281603336334, 0.011263425461947918, -0.03239613026380539, 0.019435513764619827, -0.02960815466940403, -0.04524191468954086, -0.04301448166370392, -0.026448292657732964, -0.008396800607442856, -0.022093597799539566, -0.039056096225976944, 0.03293861821293831, 0.003938659094274044, -0.011479996144771576, 0.02722918801009655, 0.007070936728268862, 0.0022593578323721886, -0.0323309488594532, -0.0032358388416469097, -0.04677722603082657, 0.026605386286973953, -0.029715612530708313, -0.03503059595823288, 0.005773758515715599, 0.00819697417318821, -0.00740818353369832, 0.016159312799572945, -0.03634848818182945, -0.08021625876426697, -0.006450365763157606, 0.01747327484190464, 0.015562993474304676, -0.029672272503376007, -0.036555215716362, 0.011040620505809784, -0.06944531947374344, 0.016078492626547813, 0.0068163443356752396, -0.011077329516410828, 0.0064857895486056805, 0.022166721522808075, 0.016529036685824394, -0.01094907894730568, 0.017026832327246666, 0.022291839122772217, -0.0437617152929306, 0.011314292438328266, 0.054486267268657684, -0.02058776468038559, -0.024677705019712448, -0.022853026166558266, 0.04739014431834221, -0.03997747227549553, -0.07213893532752991, 0.05278371274471283, 0.03541010990738869, 0.013034466654062271, 0.07298769801855087, 0.019989922642707825, -0.03510620445013046, -0.03036830946803093, -0.009355179965496063, -0.04052424430847168, -0.019965527579188347, 0.004073144402354956, 0.011318628676235676, 0.00015210262790787965, 0.02474173717200756, -0.02463258057832718, -0.05024080350995064, 0.03792644292116165, 0.033518265932798386, -0.021065330132842064, 0.008963150903582573, -0.06806530803442001, -0.033943817019462585, 0.017628248780965805, 0.03761794790625572, 0.005844429135322571, -0.027249077335000038, 0.02631467580795288, -0.03736373782157898, -0.005997986067086458, 0.050407618284225464, -0.00008923409041017294, -0.04122139513492584, 0.012659932486712933, 0.06893281638622284, -0.019678279757499695, 0.0235391017049551, -0.022616442292928696, 0.016417743638157845, 0.026974888518452644, 0.016360865905880928, -0.004212928470224142, 0.062625452876091, -0.019896864891052246, 0.021890750154852867, -0.024683091789484024, 0.0370587483048439, 0.007463658228516579, 0.0021213311702013016, -0.05235018581151962, 0.03678884729743004, -0.04004034399986267, 0.057148437947034836, 0.04901021346449852, -0.07144059240818024, -0.02773769572377205, 0.036712463945150375, 0.04246530309319496, -0.00957091897726059, 0.04338214173913002, 0.0024793038610368967, -0.01005538273602724, -0.04317183047533035, 0.004720091819763184, 0.06409206241369247, 0.017443673685193062, 0.051754094660282135, 0.029490932822227478, 0.01702234148979187, -0.02681022882461548, -0.04893788695335388, 0.010298479348421097, -0.03871769458055496, -0.026479048654437065, -0.031733643263578415, 0.06810916215181351, 0.02287331409752369, 0.05831490084528923, -0.07642089575529099, -0.0262391846626997, -0.028112325817346573, -0.05436459556221962, -0.047492846846580505, -0.01002979651093483, 0.04027505964040756, -0.003910033032298088, 0.04110422730445862, 0.015404561534523964, 0.0016751975053921342, 0.031268149614334106, -0.03470934182405472, 0.01117563433945179, -0.04324684292078018, -0.04430876672267914, -0.0785672664642334, 0.02806314080953598, -0.021887950599193573, 0.0013017849996685982, -0.06363978236913681, -0.06714557111263275, 0.009915775619447231, 0.02333056554198265, -0.04275280609726906, 0.0007407829398289323, -0.006575108505785465, -0.0396028608083725, 0.006473309826105833, 0.007793108932673931, -0.07674963027238846, -0.054941702634096146, -0.034545253962278366, 0.043983664363622665, 0.012484810315072536, -0.031089190393686295, 0.0007520884973928332, 0.018729792907834053, -0.04904801398515701, 0.007127715274691582, 0.03269217908382416, 0.03852437436580658, 0.06794679164886475, 0.04008634015917778, 0.015214663930237293, -0.02174343541264534, -0.10361839085817337, 0.002087055705487728, 0.016804128885269165, -0.03483401983976364, 0.059582240879535675, 0.03830979764461517, -0.023553501814603806, 0.01618332974612713, -0.010598587803542614, 0.010423855856060982, 0.05691486597061157, -0.022963471710681915, -0.06822621822357178, -0.0029194955714046955, -0.01426050253212452, -0.06085338443517685, -0.06062747538089752, -0.02457469515502453, -0.05327919125556946, 0.006715196650475264, -0.06101237237453461, 0.02905946411192417, 0.033121995627880096, -0.040930457413196564, -0.0027555515989661217, -0.022449858486652374, 0.07131049036979675, 0.026156773790717125, -0.04318124055862427, -0.042864132672548294, -0.06612779945135117, 0.015290701761841774, -0.05068085715174675, -0.007919651456177235, 0.015192111022770405, -0.05454973876476288, -0.003251386107876897, 0.02343938872218132, -0.005087700672447681, 0.03678993508219719, -0.0015854197554290295, -0.013787142932415009, -0.03407057374715805, 0.058188289403915405, 0.018537335097789764, -0.0029606546740978956, -0.03258097544312477, 0.02139599807560444, 0.02050691284239292, 0.009734704159200191, -0.04280080646276474, 0.012748287990689278, 0.05807376652956009, -0.005693444982171059, -0.034139372408390045, 0.03463496267795563, 0.04114575684070587, -0.001479782979004085, 0.02010774426162243, -0.009130521677434444, -0.03914495185017586, 0.025506559759378433, 0.013821657747030258, 0.02960718423128128, 0.0427098348736763, 0.03148072585463524, 0.02118418551981449, -0.047664571553468704, -0.0619959719479084, -0.06076280027627945, 0.0104451859369874, -0.06317306309938431, -0.050710830837488174, -0.07211551070213318, -0.05449743941426277, -0.003236968070268631, 0.03632069751620293, -0.08084110915660858, -0.009888223372399807, -0.01700247824192047, -0.03177417069673538, -0.03598303720355034, 0.02971668355166912, -0.007623721845448017, -0.0560787059366703, -0.05986931174993515, 0.034811995923519135, -0.010056812316179276, -0.04340539872646332, -0.07581137120723724, -0.017483865842223167, 0.04036591947078705, 0.018399571999907494, -0.04283188283443451, -0.04258998855948448, 0.012836731970310211, -0.029876207932829857, 0.030264729633927345, 0.0045232768170535564, 0.012506458908319473, 0.06186652556061745, -0.039042793214321136, -0.022843779996037483, 0.017173096537590027, -0.0038511021994054317, 0.0058884695172309875, 0.008438250049948692, -0.016780029982328415, -0.022334614768624306, -0.048523444682359695, 0.07907845079898834, 0.026832500472664833, -0.0072310990653932095, -0.034067776054143906, 0.0055397204123437405, 0.03916824981570244, 0.035267844796180725, -0.008121572434902191, -0.012175953947007656, 0.05561887100338936, -0.03596094623208046, -0.039010364562273026, 0.019855117425322533, -0.01798766851425171, -0.006910084281116724, 0.011048884131014347, -0.06928294152021408, -0.004412232898175716, 0.052598875015974045, -0.08221296221017838, 0.012004218064248562, 0.03355700150132179, 0.0653669536113739, -0.03305184096097946, 0.056002262979745865, 0.04788350313901901, 0.05032439902424812, 0.027788106352090836, 0.026509754359722137, 0.004264592658728361, 0.023499036207795143, 0.04272415488958359, 0.02466394379734993, -0.07033294439315796, -0.015922361984848976, -0.07420587539672852, -0.05596527084708214, -0.00001966139279829804, 0.015030767768621445, 0.01843055710196495, -0.017499346286058426, -0.0452694334089756, 0.04021697863936424, -0.036210887134075165, 0.08972436934709549, -0.0025043420027941465, -0.08115985244512558, 0.01474987156689167, -0.03218357637524605, -0.022390687838196754, 0.024637911468744278, -0.02305730991065502, 0.04033435136079788, -0.05911664292216301, 0.004049642477184534, -0.06495384126901627, 0.03402480483055115, 0.000767728197388351, 0.021531803533434868, 0.020204700529575348, 0.05105314403772354, -0.012599065899848938, 0.06191403418779373, -0.024712976068258286, -0.00035087650758214295, 0.0037308239843696356, 0.029531756415963173, 0.023627648130059242, 0.03686962276697159, -0.009447241201996803, 0.029597299173474312, -0.00851201917976141, -0.05680984631180763, -0.008593746460974216, 0.057262975722551346, -0.004748574458062649, -0.025798240676522255, -0.08799153566360474, 0.06183522567152977, -0.005631431005895138, 0.042509566992521286, -0.04142991080880165, -0.003910690546035767, 0.06106295436620712, -0.04520953446626663, 0.037549372762441635, -0.028992274776101112, -0.00949899386614561, 0.0056332373060286045, -0.04285779222846031, 0.018826017156243324, -0.06777587532997131, 0.008631766773760319, -0.0026469454169273376, 0.05814811959862709, 0.03692358732223511, -0.03726308420300484, -0.07679813355207443, -0.010592995211482048, 0.010291422717273235, 0.031331535428762436, 0.012735752388834953, -0.025362011045217514, 0.031020235270261765, 0.03505782410502434, -0.044562675058841705, 0.0630047395825386, 0.03123451955616474, 0.018758023157715797, -0.0188764538615942, -0.0003761218686122447, -0.03542136400938034, -0.016365740448236465, -0.03293675184249878, -0.006678495556116104, 0.024328678846359253, -0.04791450873017311, -0.04668360576033592, 0.03648339956998825, -0.03253079205751419, -0.06525908410549164, -0.02008664980530739, -0.0312599278986454, -0.01128479279577732, -0.0734945759177208, -0.027228621765971184, 0.02919234335422516, -0.010801911354064941, 0.003233318915590644, 0.00502124335616827, 0.035250093787908554, 0.07300850749015808, -0.02720681019127369, 0.015103572979569435, 0.027505578473210335, 0.025236910209059715, -0.017965765669941902, -0.04899778589606285, -0.018458349630236626, 0.005175554659217596, 0.011985831893980503, -0.039642516523599625, -0.0012222927762195468, -0.006773779634386301, -0.0060036564245820045, 0.000744277669582516, -0.08204125612974167, 0.028504112735390663, 0.043257247656583786, -0.06651044636964798, 0.018204672262072563, 0.037961654365062714, 0.01226811669766903, 0.027674952521920204, -0.023931683972477913, 0.031729333102703094, 0.004989648703485727, -0.0061594415456056595, 0.026163892820477486, 0.0029814434237778187, -0.036251939833164215, 0.02180338092148304, 0.008967623114585876, -0.006827597506344318, -0.05026192218065262, 0.03187187761068344, 0.05860660597681999, -0.014083530753850937, -0.0321863628923893, 0.017244242131710052, 0.07166814059019089, 0.009891930967569351, -0.04018731042742729, 0.04059942066669464, 0.024469662457704544, 0.02061651088297367, 0.053782857954502106, -0.006804590579122305, -0.057668644934892654, 0.026391517370939255, -0.05824601277709007, 0.029384709894657135, 0.006894715595990419, 0.00019392384274397045, -0.003855257062241435, -0.027251096442341805, -0.04480517655611038, -0.015091217122972012, -0.045683614909648895, -0.008922669105231762, -0.044636320322752, 0.00890361238270998, 0.03991921991109848, 0.003318535163998604, -0.01063825748860836, 0.02107149548828602, -0.024471988901495934, -0.0294534619897604, -0.0363844595849514, 0.06035313010215759, -0.025199832394719124, -0.006707856431603432, -0.0009837207617238164, 0.06789275258779526, 0.04315570741891861, 0.024955764412879944, -0.02116447128355503, 0.04693339020013809, -0.024514215067029, -0.002602004213258624, 0.027243608608841896, 0.024508284404873848, -0.023012395948171616, 0.004663709085434675, 0.027655765414237976, -0.05520661547780037, 0.0430254191160202, 0.026579201221466064, 0.0033406950533390045, 0.030147086828947067, -0.006503083277493715, -0.004998710937798023, -0.013913548551499844, -0.016271505504846573, 0.07016907632350922, -0.07072804868221283, 0.010655890218913555, -0.008333930745720863, -0.012347421608865261, 0.011631790548563004, -0.010115880519151688, -0.0334157757461071, 0.05130470544099808, -0.056922949850559235, -0.04245227575302124, 0.03491358458995819, 0.014625301584601402, -0.06029361113905907, -0.0001381132024107501, 0.013383335433900356, -0.07681504637002945, -0.013096231035888195, 0.04947514832019806, -0.03000379167497158, -0.03720977157354355, 0.043193548917770386, -0.03212721645832062, -0.04227191582322121, -0.058030690997838974, 0.009703281335532665, 0.05031679570674896, -0.03676271811127663, 0.013896751217544079, -0.032413873821496964, 0.03125249966979027, -0.014391280710697174, 0.009603708982467651, 0.014200028032064438, -0.05689862743020058, -0.014941872097551823, 0.002805989468470216, -0.05931844934821129, -0.031531449407339096, 0.06324730813503265, -0.014497058466076851, 0.004498439375311136, 0.00786339771002531, -0.032310713082551956, 0.03924224525690079, -0.03473939746618271, -0.06316905468702316, 0.0055189174599945545, -0.053313907235860825, 0.0002732453285716474, -0.0228476133197546, -0.018616128712892532, -0.023449702188372612, -0.004309345968067646, 0.023756353184580803, -0.04356936365365982, 0.0057273791171610355, -0.018424205482006073, -0.042889539152383804, -0.01705416850745678, -0.05060446262359619, -0.03533504158258438, 0.025698576122522354, 0.05421058461070061, 0.030554668977856636, 0.07419970631599426, -0.055595479905605316, -0.0622904933989048, 0.0065942974761128426, -0.006700699683278799, 0.00031940420740284026, -0.02546948380768299, -0.02583974041044712, -0.032267097383737564, 0.008955854922533035, -0.06336664408445358, -0.02675766684114933, 0.012397856451570988, -0.04238598048686981, 0.01171382237225771, 0.000916098419111222, -0.04428044334053993, 0.002236643573269248, 0.02043735980987549, -0.017596399411559105, -0.02335706166923046, 0.05231565982103348, -0.049627311527729034, -0.08491610735654831, -0.033419426530599594, -0.059943437576293945, -0.002597656799480319, 0.03978542238473892, 0.06718810647726059, 0.025002354755997658, -0.021247804164886475, 0.0295413751155138, 0.03745029494166374, 0.02827153168618679, -0.019092706963419914, 0.00800750870257616, 0.003350610611960292, 0.02756660431623459, 0.029496222734451294, -0.042568009346723557, -0.006166903767734766, -0.03139251470565796, -0.07895249873399734, 0.013847369700670242, -0.025217650458216667, -0.013563787564635277, -0.042742371559143066, -0.0505589060485363, 0.038593754172325134, 0.0021321396343410015, 0.015389516949653625, -0.07918150722980499, 0.0024513648822903633, 0.020485835149884224, -0.02384869195520878, 0.01971995271742344, -0.02599317394196987, -0.046421486884355545, -0.04015883803367615, -0.057910576462745667, -0.017879731953144073, -0.003793964860960841, 0.04875743389129639, -0.009544732980430126, 0.008259237743914127, 0.007949893362820148, -0.04227283224463463, -0.07108774781227112, -0.00040252087637782097, 0.0036550327204167843, -0.0039045840967446566, -0.014287840574979782, -0.03709684684872627, -0.03434458002448082, 0.025969907641410828, 0.007205350790172815, -0.06081746891140938, 0.03021533042192459, -0.008860573172569275, 0.012867629528045654, 0.041948072612285614, 0.0326550118625164, 0.06869779527187347, -0.0565001517534256, -0.0022468697279691696, -0.03724195063114166, 0.010982172563672066, -0.020506108179688454, -0.05239519849419594, 0.028484463691711426, -0.0830313116312027, -0.018337078392505646, 0.033581092953681946, -0.04855869710445404, -0.023034801706671715, -0.01145127136260271, -0.07557188719511032, 0.005928913131356239, -0.02091800421476364, -0.02861294522881508, 0.022098330780863762, -0.02533632330596447, -0.01783696934580803, 0.03000391647219658, 0.002298253122717142, -0.05482364445924759, 0.03838618844747543, 0.011477719992399216, -0.06097344681620598, -0.025403307750821114, -0.056558988988399506, 0.006085175555199385, -0.02133631706237793, -0.01406368799507618, -0.021019473671913147, 0.05017409101128578, -0.02169080078601837, 0.00027925174799747765, -0.022097673267126083, -0.024274731054902077, 0.013573156669735909, -0.052471790462732315, 0.008559119887650013, -0.04860053211450577, 0.03970940038561821, -0.0492355078458786, -0.006919161882251501, -0.018648536875844002, 0.04646337404847145, -0.01167280599474907, -0.018178895115852356, 0.03398912027478218, 0.007811894174665213, -0.004023611079901457, 0.08008838444948196, 0.0009730387246236205, -0.0002850883756764233, -0.05756910517811775, 0.01893121749162674, -0.0406956784427166, 0.014782304875552654, 0.019977249205112457, -0.00466323085129261, -0.006428240332752466, -0.05989156290888786, -0.05770059674978256, -0.02367207035422325, -0.013658392243087292, -0.026397306472063065, -0.009175429120659828, 0.0034039344172924757, -0.02849540486931801, -0.005608516279608011 ]
Purpose: Recent disruptive events, such as COVID-19 and Russia-Ukraine conflict, had a significant impact of global supply chains. Digital supply chain twins have been proposed in order to provide decision makers with an effective and efficient tool to mitigate disruption impact. Methods: This paper introduces a hybrid deep learning approach for disruption detection within a cognitive digital supply chain twin framework to enhance supply chain resilience. The proposed disruption detection module utilises a deep autoencoder neural network combined with a one-class support vector machine algorithm. In addition, long-short term memory neural network models are developed to identify the disrupted echelon and predict time-to-recovery from the disruption effect. Results: The obtained information from the proposed approach will help decision-makers and supply chain practitioners make appropriate decisions aiming at minimizing negative impact of disruptive events based on real-time disruption detection data. The results demonstrate the trade-off between disruption detection model sensitivity, encountered delay in disruption detection, and false alarms. This approach has seldom been used in recent literature addressing this issue.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14557v1
[ -0.012543253600597382, -0.054243478924036026, 0.0530039519071579, -0.030796581879258156, -0.017855415120720863, 0.014136216603219509, -0.0023445470724254847, 0.008791914209723473, 0.02046661078929901, -0.028076820075511932, -0.043094053864479065, -0.00759743619710207, -0.05992570146918297, -0.030570700764656067, -0.014520498923957348, 0.04089000076055527, 0.08360344171524048, 0.06294579058885574, -0.02034524641931057, 0.06356209516525269, -0.0022710536140948534, -0.025496456772089005, 0.014361517503857613, 0.014768116176128387, 0.041936054825782776, -0.016898734495043755, -0.029401039704680443, 0.036645468324422836, -0.04437429457902908, -0.015232302248477936, 0.059155866503715515, -0.051989030092954636, -0.024465104565024376, -0.04194940999150276, -0.013985869474709034, -0.005041372496634722, 0.025397883728146553, 0.020122751593589783, 0.0042302245274186134, -0.0534653477370739, 0.018125541508197784, -0.03437723591923714, -0.02599579654633999, -0.007647370919585228, -0.0019144379766657948, 0.007011431269347668, -0.03214162588119507, 0.008263652212917805, -0.046291738748550415, -0.0023293206468224525, 0.041466791182756424, 0.011152219958603382, 0.005892412271350622, 0.048821523785591125, -0.035335440188646317, -0.03401695936918259, -0.044989172369241714, 0.035137105733156204, -0.019198928028345108, 0.006939845159649849, 0.005163326859474182, 0.011361145414412022, 0.018205493688583374, 0.00849945843219757, -0.0014429386937990785, 0.06519219279289246, -0.04088703542947769, -0.05051872506737709, -0.03838307410478592, -0.038447026163339615, 0.05590634047985077, -0.04904819652438164, 0.0703769102692604, 0.01495492272078991, -0.007260872982442379, -0.034153133630752563, -0.035287659615278244, -0.00793417077511549, 0.014996964484453201, 0.0019946603570133448, -0.008213896304368973, 0.043956659734249115, 0.037667661905288696, 0.05752994492650032, -0.015840662643313408, -0.006620412226766348, 0.04967613145709038, 0.024405810981988907, 0.028043100610375404, -0.02550082840025425, 0.05324919521808624, -0.06008223444223404, -0.05749668553471565, 0.0010897008469328284, 0.06483469903469086, -0.027505654841661453, 0.0205905232578516, 0.04150886833667755, -0.00260057277046144, -0.0036520736757665873, -0.022580096498131752, 0.03121669963002205, -0.03487269580364227, 0.04038278013467789, 0.04153260588645935, -0.03998517245054245, 0.0002090735360980034, 0.00805148109793663, -0.035516973584890366, -0.006863731890916824, -0.02812054008245468, -0.04539252072572708, 0.016902973875403404, -0.08809061348438263, -0.038453660905361176, -0.021075809374451637, 0.06980785727500916, 0.021393876522779465, 0.024274814873933792, -0.02776961773633957, -0.0628671944141388, 0.03567935526371002, -0.004413660615682602, 0.006663361098617315, 0.0017130962805822492, -0.020813243463635445, 0.05616111680865288, -0.00339326704852283, -0.006976930424571037, -0.02699832059442997, -0.04175703600049019, 0.044174160808324814, -0.023799726739525795, -0.030020354315638542, 0.041174620389938354, -0.0030518488492816687, 0.03894257918000221, -0.043466418981552124, 0.055105164647102356, 0.029856747016310692, -0.024588167667388916, -0.011859365738928318, 0.019312463700771332, -0.05111970007419586, 0.012714486569166183, 0.047113727778196335, 0.0018191924318671227, -0.0373738557100296, 0.009071080014109612, 0.03295435383915901, 0.024140143766999245, -0.006856262683868408, 0.016553044319152832, 0.025352226570248604, 0.018977712839841843, 0.0008830228471197188, 0.06269221752882004, -0.04510091245174408, -0.03158791363239288, 0.006640257779508829, 0.03882162645459175, -0.012068115174770355, 0.039456114172935486, -0.032859981060028076, -0.014367645606398582, 0.016046740114688873, 0.063713937997818, -0.01559731736779213, 0.012108790688216686, 0.040691398084163666, -0.00493718171492219, 0.00019468543177936226, 0.012583957053720951, -0.011214173398911953, -0.028992710635066032, -0.03397904708981514, -0.012844102457165718, -0.0556282177567482, -0.04988653585314751, 0.00006954324635444209, 0.020209597423672676, 0.03336663544178009, -0.011253957636654377, 0.01243154052644968, -0.04064096510410309, -0.013540960848331451, -0.08872883766889572, -0.004640376195311546, 0.006272025406360626, -0.00811746995896101, -0.04815426096320152, -0.05160878226161003, 0.014845681376755238, 0.013782420195639133, 0.010522130876779556, -0.04775767773389816, 0.006375941913574934, -0.01838020421564579, -0.00496000936254859, 0.0664391964673996, -0.08758878707885742, -0.017151322215795517, -0.08497919142246246, 0.004694912116974592, 0.01397659257054329, -0.06253524124622345, 0.048431478440761566, 0.008299252018332481, -0.03414116054773331, -0.03262719511985779, 0.025907650589942932, 0.021469954401254654, 0.06968782097101212, 0.062314387410879135, 0.031177306547760963, -0.026595892384648323, -0.11003180593252182, 0.017053501680493355, 0.05219576507806778, 0.02699294127523899, 0.03722308948636055, 0.0009378143586218357, -0.010959198698401451, -0.04235019162297249, 0.009236352518200874, 0.031766511499881744, 0.024765223264694214, -0.0057223523035645485, -0.05432332307100296, -0.03370944410562515, -0.011994453147053719, -0.048580870032310486, -0.012841759249567986, -0.054397277534008026, 0.01637754961848259, -0.021991441026329994, -0.03400515392422676, -0.0033171100076287985, -0.04132587090134621, -0.05473813787102699, -0.018224943429231644, -0.025755861774086952, 0.04331382364034653, -0.024623621255159378, -0.046109043061733246, -0.037729308009147644, -0.04152259975671768, 0.04057146981358528, 0.006218000780791044, 0.014038369059562683, -0.013975984416902065, -0.023811250925064087, -0.01227716263383627, -0.03554169088602066, 0.051432009786367416, 0.04246366024017334, -0.015400655567646027, 0.010845097713172436, -0.0023924068082123995, 0.0349620096385479, 0.04768329858779907, 0.017490815371274948, -0.06063717231154442, 0.017956038936972618, 0.06427693367004395, -0.014878557994961739, 0.01900159940123558, -0.009731599129736423, 0.06028152257204056, -0.038716062903404236, -0.0013228151947259903, 0.03146637603640556, 0.006398703437298536, -0.013619701378047466, 0.018622612580657005, -0.03605423495173454, 0.005210644565522671, -0.04860367998480797, 0.004729937762022018, 0.04262107238173485, 0.015330232679843903, 0.039900414645671844, 0.031093714758753777, -0.08024293929338455, 0.005638073664158583, -0.05745164304971695, 0.008693162351846695, -0.05013017728924751, -0.05618361756205559, -0.0058698211796581745, -0.08160362392663956, -0.025528952479362488, -0.034058716148138046, -0.05985362082719803, -0.0058805737644433975, -0.04867607355117798, -0.05371532216668129, 0.009066908620297909, 0.004126270767301321, -0.03144940361380577, -0.04193897172808647, -0.05640824884176254, 0.012102099135518074, 0.003032748121768236, 0.020839527249336243, -0.026786528527736664, 0.003717922605574131, -0.0012942998437210917, 0.03328028693795204, 0.023848356679081917, 0.04861115291714668, 0.03731589764356613, -0.01800372451543808, 0.05193651467561722, -0.031107697635889053, -0.02647264115512371, -0.0007095559849403799, -0.006832289509475231, -0.0019160687224939466, -0.011878288350999355, 0.016317903995513916, -0.021230075508356094, 0.0005487927701324224, -0.043676842004060745, -0.04849962145090103, -0.049346499145030975, 0.049747664481401443, 0.01640031300485134, -0.044894929975271225, -0.02089114487171173, 0.010888257995247841, -0.011739657260477543, 0.007725154515355825, -0.0026972664054483175, 0.04188424348831177, 0.035558365285396576, -0.056589458137750626, -0.006770906038582325, -0.01833396963775158, 0.020562125369906425, -0.0067487978376448154, 0.02516741119325161, 0.004717090167105198, 0.041152145713567734, 0.033040303736925125, -0.08967382460832596, -0.02848016656935215, 0.024727655574679375, 0.05835619196295738, 0.005782626569271088, 0.032743196934461594, 0.028986390680074692, 0.009223838336765766, -0.007727725896984339, 0.03364475071430206, 0.043554969131946564, 0.012498912401497364, 0.07615333795547485, 0.001039458205923438, -0.025575075298547745, 0.03500139340758324, -0.048010312020778656, -0.06196543574333191, -0.0022758657578378916, 0.02098882384598255, 0.04166770726442337, 0.020469926297664642, -0.04544723033905029, 0.01677544414997101, -0.001689363969489932, 0.05454656854271889, 0.0017035382334142923, -0.04011465981602669, 0.018036775290966034, -0.034054215997457504, 0.05930151417851448, -0.005353589076548815, 0.00874676275998354, 0.004720482975244522, -0.07164426892995834, 0.017077386379241943, -0.08374839276075363, 0.05735652521252632, 0.005196000449359417, -0.026159465312957764, 0.04650913551449776, 0.07556790858507156, -0.0270204059779644, 0.03265943378210068, 0.0384858176112175, 0.028470363467931747, -0.00829341821372509, 0.00121842953376472, -0.02704423852264881, -0.012638182379305363, -0.03892792761325836, 0.033750779926776886, 0.010778982192277908, -0.0067625949159264565, 0.0015250913565978408, 0.00852973572909832, -0.0013351922389119864, 0.018641548231244087, -0.08661027252674103, 0.03104472905397415, -0.03505430370569229, 0.02837950550019741, -0.018752148374915123, -0.03936442360281944, 0.052504926919937134, -0.017250731587409973, -0.0005814927280880511, -0.064229816198349, -0.02947583794593811, -0.0008271560072898865, -0.03150912746787071, -0.019438965246081352, -0.049322571605443954, 0.0024396495427936316, 0.0040938230231404305, 0.04621121287345886, 0.019152861088514328, -0.008530788123607635, -0.029186218976974487, -0.023940348997712135, -0.00985671952366829, 0.005969644524157047, 0.06683724373579025, 0.004494933411478996, -0.017160721123218536, -0.03946833312511444, -0.0011343053774908185, -0.0054071806371212006, -0.017131051048636436, 0.013900700025260448, -0.015107670798897743, 0.014226819388568401, -0.0157262422144413, -0.015262829139828682, -0.013205369003117085, -0.04266216605901718, 0.0663200244307518, -0.05301591008901596, -0.051879268139600754, -0.016099868342280388, 0.03628610447049141, -0.056445393711328506, -0.07248334586620331, -0.028750469908118248, -0.04583624750375748, -0.022175118327140808, -0.03873267024755478, -0.0017251720419153571, 0.04517702758312225, 0.007972062565386295, 0.05843515321612358, 0.05774621292948723, 0.04751952737569809, -0.003432667814195156, 0.04219786822795868, 0.04434860870242119, 0.039197888225317, -0.013936358503997326, -0.01127617061138153, -0.06740722060203552, 0.013446430675685406, 0.003049366408959031, 0.04079858213663101, -0.045274749398231506, 0.048244863748550415, 0.047162897884845734, 0.023565353825688362, -0.07422683387994766, -0.036640726029872894, 0.05871492996811867, -0.01201192568987608, 0.030074860900640488, 0.05170797184109688, 0.004697118420153856, 0.02765432931482792, -0.05556097254157066, 0.006596759893000126, 0.04345313087105751, -0.02469734661281109, 0.02722935564815998, 0.0002759370254352689, -0.011030172929167747, -0.01526191458106041, 0.05799486115574837, 0.003458648920059204, -0.05746041238307953, -0.013483433052897453, 0.022685693576931953, 0.032504431903362274, -0.022390132769942284, 0.0178960133343935, 0.05248488858342171, -0.03143901377916336, 0.010065624490380287, -0.03203943744301796, 0.031673233956098557, 0.01751464232802391, 0.010130437090992928, -0.054277077317237854, 0.011796999722719193, 0.016704723238945007, 0.03486842289566994, 0.008073803968727589, -0.0008954833610914648, -0.0056767575442790985, 0.004720221273601055, -0.048234544694423676, -0.01293656975030899, -0.08401105552911758, 0.002123014535754919, -0.04060020297765732, 0.06289384514093399, 0.05576888844370842, 0.051678456366062164, 0.009537927806377411, 0.002042842097580433, -0.02303481288254261, -0.05556395277380943, 0.009445243515074253, -0.04569372162222862, 0.013294585980474949, 0.0029403683729469776, 0.06634766608476639, -0.00007401413313345984, 0.04235296696424484, 0.003909309394657612, -0.016970299184322357, -0.026464561000466347, -0.014708268456161022, -0.02575642056763172, -0.043620526790618896, 0.0324043370783329, -0.05719361826777458, -0.05122232437133789, 0.05568453669548035, 0.02296012081205845, -0.03483135998249054, 0.03896160051226616, 0.03941334784030914, -0.057037629187107086, -0.008138982579112053, -0.0022802131716161966, -0.022601597011089325, 0.0019335654797032475, 0.03354611620306969, 0.06443659961223602, -0.05221026390790939, -0.004381235688924789, 0.005386561620980501, -0.044315699487924576, 0.019236471503973007, -0.01120066549628973, -0.03978390246629715, -0.024794599041342735, -0.01089294720441103, -0.07863285392522812, 0.029652805998921394, -0.000035252531233709306, -0.06860335916280746, 0.004096237476915121, 0.005139963235706091, -0.07749976217746735, 0.024650875478982925, 0.029942601919174194, 0.051521215587854385, -0.06807756423950195, 0.03753276541829109, 0.016158076003193855, 0.008122256956994534, -0.07034583389759064, 0.05892913043498993, 0.08540301769971848, -0.028911471366882324, -0.037648122757673264, 0.03821198642253876, -0.08165626227855682, 0.013383508659899235, -0.03452077507972717, 0.023928683251142502, -0.02779010683298111, 0.049017053097486496, 0.011760263703763485, -0.03249053284525871, -0.060053348541259766, 0.0827564224600792, -0.04507964849472046, 0.01592200994491577, -0.023775922134518623, -0.03720204159617424, 0.07079891860485077, 0.007914697751402855, -0.02849559672176838, 0.010283993557095528, -0.02183447778224945, -0.002110900590196252, -0.019733138382434845, -0.034848231822252274, -0.00435572350397706, 0.009046408347785473, -0.015958767384290695, -0.04637017846107483, -0.00894244946539402, 0.024939650669693947, -0.032720476388931274, 0.04489665478467941, -0.050440650433301926, -0.011252079159021378, -0.005182442255318165, 0.009513053111732006, 0.03275567665696144, 0.05250290036201477, -0.03217201679944992, 0.01490295585244894, 0.014279477298259735, -0.03251791000366211, 0.016352884471416473, -0.0072133964858949184, -0.00470034359022975, -0.010713434778153896, 0.04291542246937752, -0.024415966123342514, 0.01216559112071991, -0.02893713116645813, -0.0116531727835536, 0.0580279640853405, -0.0300576314330101, -0.015786100178956985, -0.04079611226916313, -0.017005153000354767, 0.013744845986366272, -0.0021468456834554672, 0.05734976753592491, -0.03480502963066101, -0.05420302227139473, 0.02699444629251957, -0.013548851944506168, 0.007731039077043533, 0.036300286650657654, 0.006403398234397173, -0.007809660397469997, 0.0245540589094162, 0.0572262741625309, 0.03322463110089302, -0.014201712794601917, -0.014852019026875496, -0.06021391227841377, -0.02419295161962509, 0.047657787799835205, 0.014788231812417507, -0.023419955745339394, -0.008628594689071178, -0.0018241752404719591, -0.05958154425024986, 0.021810051053762436, 0.06186247244477272, -0.0073468987829983234, -0.01368002500385046, -0.06668875366449356, 0.049165334552526474, -0.001017048954963684, -0.042338959872722626, -0.024768738076090813, 0.018361661583185196, -0.011841963976621628, -0.02922806702554226, 0.006922622676938772, 0.027342570945620537, -0.042599909007549286, -0.022845204919576645, -0.08687196671962738, -0.007918019779026508, 0.004099120851606131, 0.03810780122876167, -0.047246478497982025, -0.04322028532624245, -0.006395967211574316, -0.06120438873767853, 0.008029610849916935, 0.0131597351282835, 0.02741875872015953, -0.021851150318980217, 0.031784262508153915, 0.01068226806819439, -0.0466282032430172, -0.03620623052120209, 0.010039478540420532, 0.030871495604515076, -0.0007151972968131304, 0.03814205154776573, 0.05842870473861694, 0.01183456089347601, 0.012582837603986263, 0.04497095197439194, -0.032107796519994736, 0.03360043466091156, -0.057160962373018265, 0.007480147760361433, -0.022143863141536713, -0.06112917885184288, 0.03293710947036743, -0.040604084730148315, 0.0046062651090323925, 0.04462430998682976, -0.02981533668935299, -0.010107397101819515, -0.012819305993616581, -0.053912725299596786, 0.03867030516266823, -0.014207782223820686, 0.002563206013292074, 0.0384051613509655, -0.022058140486478806, 0.01937386766076088, -0.063771091401577, -0.027933543547987938, -0.05938516557216644, 0.022474639117717743, -0.0030670876149088144, -0.059410084038972855, -0.02603108063340187, -0.042724814265966415, 0.03518345206975937, 0.045707955956459045, -0.009767754003405571, -0.04669070616364479, 0.07536332309246063, 0.03628017380833626, -0.024465415626764297, -0.03845060244202614, -0.007407255936414003, -0.025567540898919106, -0.06361167877912521, -0.04948868602514267, -0.043576616793870926, 0.011149656027555466, 0.0037126734387129545, 0.05044887959957123, 0.029648805037140846, 0.06509344279766083, 0.025782151147723198, 0.008128433488309383, 0.0022660656832158566, 0.020632561296224594, -0.04051198065280914, 0.09861902892589569, 0.040559589862823486, 0.03202958032488823, -0.06305591017007828, 0.03901571407914162, 0.010723751969635487, 0.029608557000756264, 0.013565875589847565, 0.015145988203585148, -0.021159173920750618, -0.02973181940615177, -0.017822351306676865, 0.047224074602127075, -0.004653031472116709, -0.039738819003105164, 0.003958433400839567, 0.007184561342000961, -0.0649939626455307, -0.05833842232823372 ]
We explore the ability of large language models (LLMs) to act as speech recognition post-processors that perform rescoring and error correction. Our first focus is on instruction prompting to let LLMs perform these task without fine-tuning, for which we evaluate different prompting schemes, both zero- and few-shot in-context learning, and a novel task activation prompting method that combines causal instructions and demonstration to increase its context windows. Next, we show that rescoring only by in-context learning with frozen LLMs achieves results that are competitive with rescoring by domain-tuned LMs, using a pretrained first-pass recognition system and rescoring output on two out-of-domain tasks (ATIS and WSJ). By combining prompting techniques with fine-tuning we achieve error rates below the N-best oracle level, showcasing the generalization power of the LLMs.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15649v2
[ -0.04914618656039238, -0.01597362384200096, 0.05272077023983002, 0.011123080737888813, 0.0052482313476502895, -0.002120578894391656, -0.03027724102139473, -0.007369524799287319, 0.029862023890018463, -0.04627271369099617, -0.0266397874802351, 0.02740836702287197, -0.07962813973426819, -0.05104710906744003, -0.0522649846971035, 0.001533036702312529, 0.062371112406253815, 0.006130415014922619, -0.020871952176094055, 0.045842062681913376, 0.014243668876588345, -0.012309378013014793, -0.0773104801774025, 0.038119226694107056, 0.015548013150691986, -0.043621838092803955, -0.03505873680114746, 0.0010511645814403892, 0.0028659903910011053, 0.005350145045667887, 0.077510766685009, -0.032899271696805954, -0.041804324835538864, -0.03738582879304886, -0.00025446328800171614, -0.020341942086815834, -0.02569078840315342, 0.042288243770599365, 0.03287480026483536, -0.01641225814819336, 0.0032460764050483704, -0.026565205305814743, -0.07875867933034897, -0.001480893581174314, -0.01337472628802061, 0.0026933234184980392, -0.0099513940513134, 0.01593334786593914, -0.059338152408599854, -0.06471344083547592, 0.008600857108831406, 0.013384085148572922, -0.04212247580289841, 0.0182849932461977, -0.008208030834794044, -0.02692655473947525, -0.010840234346687794, -0.035590626299381256, -0.08054923266172409, 0.005577555391937494, 0.035252220928668976, -0.04160676524043083, -0.04785618558526039, 0.022648116573691368, 0.02411886863410473, 0.04166353493928909, -0.019939543679356575, -0.0448637381196022, -0.04486016184091568, -0.03228418529033661, 0.039424117654561996, -0.034640777856111526, -0.048275794833898544, 0.001720550237223506, -0.012042241171002388, -0.03202951326966286, -0.04110218212008476, -0.02805948071181774, -0.013015263713896275, -0.021985474973917007, -0.05091983079910278, 0.06071631982922554, 0.037717971950769424, 0.049504075199365616, 0.0016757457051426172, -0.02070045843720436, 0.05498800426721573, -0.007592577952891588, 0.02647147700190544, -0.01926681026816368, 0.061615828424692154, -0.043557580560445786, -0.07664468884468079, -0.006496915593743324, 0.06490550935268402, -0.03629333898425102, 0.060038115829229355, 0.016072971746325493, 0.011147819459438324, 0.010631383396685123, -0.01889856345951557, -0.028742382302880287, -0.02937306836247444, 0.07080062478780746, 0.016150012612342834, -0.008907180279493332, -0.01254109013825655, 0.015649991109967232, -0.04059276729822159, 0.011444182135164738, -0.010551180690526962, -0.0337752029299736, 0.04548763483762741, -0.0587209053337574, -0.07157503813505173, -0.0015454000094905496, 0.008182618767023087, 0.029001502320170403, -0.0302754957228899, -0.035586655139923096, -0.0487845316529274, 0.04440205916762352, 0.04025205597281456, -0.06765128672122955, -0.018138151615858078, -0.013338806107640266, 0.06404229998588562, 0.025751126930117607, -0.025237206369638443, -0.012529481202363968, 0.008103540167212486, 0.009609166532754898, 0.03396797925233841, -0.0519360788166523, 0.049086447805166245, -0.028561897575855255, -0.01834249682724476, -0.027241118252277374, 0.01946473866701126, -0.0499768927693367, -0.05698738992214203, -0.06323541700839996, 0.06411800533533096, -0.031343553215265274, 0.04728143289685249, 0.05723917856812477, -0.04541730880737305, -0.018729308620095253, 0.03552042320370674, -0.000412063644034788, 0.023037634789943695, -0.02474311552941799, -0.008264652453362942, 0.02617778070271015, 0.026185469701886177, -0.020625516772270203, 0.050785452127456665, -0.0011369844432920218, -0.081697478890419, 0.003470639931038022, 0.016356641426682472, 0.00831327959895134, 0.031686607748270035, -0.005293095950037241, 0.021774502471089363, 0.022003324702382088, 0.035426534712314606, -0.03327813744544983, -0.0020718092564493418, 0.006624588277190924, -0.046925630420446396, -0.02560454234480858, 0.001282046316191554, 0.02757967822253704, -0.0641130805015564, -0.04440056532621384, -0.006247902754694223, -0.017380695790052414, -0.03008815087378025, -0.044714055955410004, 0.019025318324565887, 0.053475841879844666, -0.024230124428868294, 0.009735146537423134, -0.05914130061864853, 0.006941832602024078, -0.08515306562185287, -0.009776575490832329, 0.06159628927707672, 0.006422070320695639, -0.024479731917381287, -0.015184901654720306, 0.021013544872403145, 0.028607014566659927, -0.05000327527523041, -0.02037057653069496, -0.019054364413022995, 0.01734333112835884, 0.028591983020305634, 0.056529633700847626, -0.09480689465999603, 0.0012409751070663333, -0.03605172410607338, -0.00018829999316949397, -0.04606299102306366, -0.06336336582899094, 0.001734673511236906, 0.05023815110325813, -0.01521657221019268, -0.011735924519598484, 0.01800714060664177, 0.04802453890442848, 0.06870168447494507, 0.006691361777484417, 0.013522225432097912, 0.0018742416286841035, -0.10179205983877182, 0.05656977742910385, -0.0073186373338103294, -0.009014429524540901, 0.03079308569431305, -0.022154491394758224, -0.014935621991753578, -0.022171927616000175, -0.017909282818436623, 0.012740408070385456, 0.04131649434566498, -0.03367667272686958, -0.06786732375621796, -0.027214210480451584, -0.021336203441023827, -0.05622031167149544, -0.036373965442180634, -0.08213628083467484, -0.008781949058175087, 0.026524724438786507, -0.02815520390868187, 0.034909650683403015, -0.028860297054052353, -0.022268515080213547, -0.04316622391343117, -0.0008434968767687678, 0.01915404200553894, -0.017292844131588936, -0.05821491777896881, -0.05733872950077057, -0.013684287667274475, -0.009499392472207546, -0.03058689460158348, 0.02093268558382988, -0.06115292012691498, -0.0026577902026474476, -0.007251600734889507, -0.023859990760684013, 0.009808029048144817, -0.008810770697891712, -0.0024357750080525875, 0.030213162302970886, 0.020279869437217712, 0.06581643223762512, 0.013387272134423256, 0.024544335901737213, -0.0539618544280529, -0.02815464697778225, 0.015506509691476822, -0.023079749196767807, -0.027528898790478706, -0.024511702358722687, -0.009870359674096107, -0.016077445819973946, -0.010708270594477654, 0.03384207934141159, 0.06952492892742157, -0.010957339778542519, -0.04454068839550018, -0.0029132256750017405, -0.012015370652079582, 0.010239616967737675, 0.022755851969122887, 0.02064327709376812, 0.05556194856762886, -0.033828917890787125, 0.013960229232907295, -0.07095373421907425, 0.02181805856525898, -0.04533346742391586, -0.04612824693322182, -0.04446060210466385, -0.03750821202993393, -0.021180354058742523, -0.08296855539083481, -0.004534614272415638, -0.029475804418325424, -0.02032923698425293, -0.03691839799284935, -0.022958315908908844, -0.015998540446162224, -0.015489296056330204, 0.03687756508588791, -0.02326306328177452, -0.05734460800886154, -0.018320100381970406, 0.011985788121819496, 0.046177417039871216, 0.027485737577080727, -0.04709794372320175, -0.04554345831274986, 0.005547014530748129, 0.03192475810647011, 0.03288133442401886, -0.03368077054619789, 0.03899388387799263, -0.0016541279619559646, 0.04629569128155708, -0.004484962671995163, 0.07094169408082962, -0.013702557422220707, 0.027081800624728203, -0.04280826821923256, -0.05390922725200653, -0.007635145448148251, -0.015172804705798626, -0.014579798094928265, -0.04095805436372757, -0.037829045206308365, -0.028570612892508507, 0.06531722098588943, -0.013905419036746025, -0.011432220228016376, -0.06238015741109848, 0.007378153968602419, 0.02700231224298477, 0.008772658184170723, -0.02421770989894867, 0.03290558233857155, 0.04560592398047447, -0.03360682725906372, -0.05632699653506279, -0.04162861779332161, -0.028519228100776672, 0.0012740599922835827, 0.027023324742913246, -0.0016116820042952895, 0.0018349210731685162, 0.060821231454610825, -0.09228880703449249, 0.024471431970596313, 0.06122581288218498, 0.0476466566324234, -0.03761115297675133, 0.007836774922907352, -0.0013137359637767076, 0.012999534606933594, 0.02135350927710533, -0.017480039969086647, 0.05582577735185623, 0.05086616426706314, 0.0459764190018177, -0.009582794271409512, -0.002946854569017887, 0.00962649006396532, -0.05071138218045235, -0.018632283434271812, -0.008738171309232712, 0.02407120354473591, 0.011094373650848866, -0.0008814290631562471, -0.060337554663419724, 0.022129744291305542, 0.0022684335708618164, 0.002109619090333581, 0.04415997862815857, -0.03936736658215523, 0.024717211723327637, -0.0014408763963729143, 0.009676991030573845, 0.010290093719959259, 0.013831919990479946, 0.007996737957000732, -0.04549654573202133, 0.008711986243724823, -0.0653255358338356, 0.02326183207333088, 0.012235046364367008, -0.05418907478451729, 0.05747988447546959, 0.04491708055138588, -0.0379716232419014, 0.03560061380267143, -0.027668951079249382, -0.02090955339372158, 0.01196550764143467, 0.017976591363549232, 0.0007361555472016335, -0.005420769099146128, -0.07199922204017639, -0.016355600208044052, 0.015140710398554802, 0.000692648405674845, 0.0008016150677576661, 0.03174762800335884, 0.01200519222766161, 0.004704652354121208, -0.06223307549953461, -0.04426293820142746, -0.05368510261178017, 0.031278278678655624, 0.006106844171881676, -0.045974280685186386, 0.06053740903735161, -0.058149538934230804, -0.014751700684428215, -0.030655886977910995, 0.025548260658979416, -0.017784923315048218, -0.05228410288691521, -0.021716097369790077, -0.07111276686191559, 0.004047693219035864, -0.05726616457104683, 0.024551115930080414, -0.03276190534234047, 0.0015431995270773768, -0.02901734970510006, -0.01356438361108303, -0.006144129205495119, 0.060040105134248734, 0.0506078265607357, 0.031160756945610046, -0.0033862926065921783, -0.02141408622264862, 0.030728260055184364, -0.031690750271081924, 0.005254758521914482, -0.013870719820261002, -0.04352147504687309, 0.039580803364515305, 0.007102421019226313, -0.004034379962831736, -0.0033342542592436075, 0.02117600105702877, 0.05570937693119049, -0.04145081341266632, -0.0500083789229393, 0.026816563680768013, 0.02481543831527233, -0.0459664948284626, -0.04737548530101776, -0.030882174149155617, -0.004253243561834097, -0.06935624778270721, -0.032323937863111496, 0.024099336937069893, 0.027083830907940865, -0.035380538552999496, -0.019768372178077698, 0.045522503554821014, 0.029338600113987923, -0.0018424891168251634, -0.01739901304244995, 0.03678008168935776, 0.021329838782548904, -0.01798710599541664, -0.02645459771156311, -0.06019807234406471, 0.017303718253970146, -0.03245256468653679, -0.019438575953245163, -0.03474875167012215, 0.046993888914585114, 0.00507732667028904, 0.06169081851840019, -0.0817045196890831, -0.008075525052845478, 0.02421482652425766, 0.00017564056906849146, 0.014745312742888927, 0.04109341278672218, -0.030074885115027428, 0.0374312624335289, -0.013189006596803665, -0.004349391907453537, 0.023189935833215714, -0.0261700376868248, 0.02123420499265194, 0.03232337906956673, -0.02255370281636715, -0.01408632006496191, 0.031330499798059464, 0.03794405236840248, -0.017535796388983727, -0.006748933810740709, 0.027342284098267555, 0.04629843309521675, -0.028689566999673843, 0.05061964690685272, 0.07165247946977615, -0.04215645790100098, -0.04512285068631172, 0.03023604117333889, 0.012393156997859478, 0.006266715936362743, 0.0021946902852505445, -0.05534520000219345, -0.011149179190397263, 0.004847758449614048, -0.011709862388670444, -0.04389458894729614, 0.05504744127392769, 0.04094093292951584, -0.00216693221591413, -0.02755553647875786, 0.016552815213799477, -0.06672599911689758, -0.010194897651672363, -0.020254293456673622, 0.01631864719092846, 0.03447907045483589, -0.024258339777588844, 0.01609111577272415, 0.013624572195112705, 0.0016668976750224829, -0.021995529532432556, 0.008165665902197361, -0.03428015485405922, 0.04592256620526314, -0.04221918806433678, 0.030989238992333412, -0.00656944140791893, 0.0353437103331089, -0.006071899551898241, 0.05352027341723442, -0.014793379232287407, 0.017750175669789314, -0.033218298107385635, 0.013898319564759731, 0.04069365933537483, -0.07358458638191223, -0.006227153353393078, 0.0243782140314579, -0.02832617424428463, -0.05843571200966835, 0.021435989066958427, 0.016017144545912743, 0.030122384428977966, 0.03668177127838135, 0.03452547267079353, -0.03636227548122406, -0.07292667031288147, 0.05377990007400513, 0.057795628905296326, -0.054660242050886154, -0.004869100172072649, -0.03897300735116005, -0.03707578778266907, 0.04823014885187149, -0.044676508754491806, -0.027173765003681183, 0.01567639596760273, 0.047122709453105927, -0.05557840317487717, 0.07459017634391785, -0.014599211513996124, -0.07405933737754822, 0.002163146622478962, 0.010015977546572685, -0.06869044899940491, -0.025699293240904808, 0.02000376395881176, -0.03140673041343689, -0.029830370098352432, 0.017562326043844223, 0.024326523765921593, -0.0029251957312226295, -0.020669469609856606, 0.036531709134578705, 0.08338642120361328, -0.010788945481181145, -0.0035938520450145006, 0.025252006947994232, -0.03339063376188278, 0.03220123052597046, 0.006074878852814436, -0.012383989989757538, 0.045056238770484924, 0.017707793042063713, 0.03385726734995842, -0.027024801820516586, 0.02824636548757553, 0.04561258479952812, -0.040232136845588684, 0.030743177980184555, -0.0175046194344759, -0.007008248940110207, 0.040433477610349655, -0.02536233328282833, -0.03532722219824791, 0.0026007795240730047, -0.02862202376127243, -0.04414772614836693, -0.08255563676357269, -0.021618101745843887, 0.0089442552998662, -0.01913219876587391, -0.018557175993919373, -0.08242952078580856, 0.015690583735704422, -0.024659547954797745, -0.07545885443687439, -0.011273214593529701, -0.0687430277466774, 0.007647563237696886, 0.004166821483522654, 0.0203319750726223, 0.023678716272115707, 0.05654118210077286, -0.03477955237030983, -0.06047041714191437, -0.013074709102511406, 0.040515363216400146, 0.0023106050211936235, -0.030796140432357788, 0.01628136821091175, -0.03401731699705124, 0.03531704097986221, -0.02773461863398552, 0.004752903711050749, -0.0021803011186420918, -0.06729818880558014, 0.0506594218313694, 0.04018932580947876, 0.027769584208726883, -0.06316820532083511, 0.028542041778564453, -0.017183003947138786, 0.04289654269814491, -0.00015545060159638524, -0.042635004967451096, -0.05341733992099762, 0.01339308638125658, 0.026620376855134964, -0.03578028455376625, 0.045347586274147034, 0.012609437108039856, -0.014512453228235245, -0.019884206354618073, 0.03677595779299736, -0.022432012483477592, 0.007615384645760059, 0.004606503993272781, -0.07084998488426208, -0.026285791769623756, -0.010385699570178986, -0.03174947574734688, -0.06952875852584839, 0.032340213656425476, -0.0002270670811412856, -0.040605951100587845, -0.002650074427947402, 0.0286894328892231, -0.005120833870023489, -0.012815614230930805, -0.07777920365333557, 0.03942197561264038, 0.0326278954744339, -0.06351761519908905, -0.0317080058157444, 0.016661735251545906, 0.0025089161936193705, -0.02698429860174656, -0.014152728952467442, -0.007876475341618061, -0.03672318160533905, 0.022008059546351433, -0.08719339966773987, -0.0069296695291996, -0.046496935188770294, 0.04648648574948311, 0.021082615479826927, -0.014173392206430435, -0.018428722396492958, -0.017936237156391144, 0.03069642372429371, 0.025538567453622818, -0.0058830115012824535, 0.0268107820302248, 0.024101227521896362, 0.032217781990766525, -0.06319932639598846, -0.04110534489154816, 0.07390248030424118, -0.011193341575562954, -0.014669581316411495, 0.054804399609565735, -0.0049872794188559055, 0.0575733408331871, -0.022526348009705544, 0.06345910578966141, 0.0013546582777053118, 0.012673619203269482, -0.06799174100160599, 0.0026639667339622974, -0.05144456773996353, -0.015924133360385895, 0.044442713260650635, -0.0681024044752121, 0.043477728962898254, 0.04304834082722664, -0.03617844358086586, -0.024336619302630424, -0.01867464929819107, -0.00796150416135788, -0.018508337438106537, -0.04071345180273056, -0.03271361440420151, 0.03042685240507126, -0.016968363896012306, -0.01135244034230709, -0.04835360124707222, -0.024658313021063805, -0.006758400704711676, 0.048429302871227264, 0.047142837196588516, -0.03675810247659683, 0.021550843492150307, -0.05922967568039894, 0.03175957128405571, -0.032273415476083755, 0.028510749340057373, 0.01042185164988041, 0.0688960924744606, 0.03062165342271328, -0.018456485122442245, -0.02118748426437378, -0.02392437495291233, 0.0052113523706793785, -0.06687963008880615, -0.014218519441783428, -0.03516409918665886, 0.008028621785342693, -0.01606190949678421, -0.018494730815291405, -0.009278613142669201, 0.04502443969249725, 0.03933478891849518, 0.005479108542203903, 0.032097332179546356, 0.01729763112962246, -0.05086912587285042, 0.07729659229516983, 0.01707662083208561, 0.018276726827025414, -0.042923059314489365, -0.00537837203592062, 0.005808832123875618, 0.004321549087762833, -0.03427937626838684, -0.04690082371234894, 0.010803084820508957, 0.005818023346364498, 0.0038092341274023056, 0.01509062759578228, -0.028722191229462624, -0.040167614817619324, 0.0080915167927742, -0.008712096139788628, -0.02890278957784176, -0.04765535518527031 ]
Virtual Reality (VR) has the potential of becoming the next ubiquitous computing platform. Continued progress in the burgeoning field of VR depends critically on an efficient computing substrate. In particular, DRAM access energy is known to contribute to a significant portion of system energy. Today's framebuffer compression system alleviates the DRAM traffic by using a numerically lossless compression algorithm. Being numerically lossless, however, is unnecessary to preserve perceptual quality for humans. This paper proposes a perceptually lossless, but numerically lossy, system to compress DRAM traffic. Our idea builds on top of long-established psychophysical studies that show that humans cannot discriminate colors that are close to each other. The discrimination ability becomes even weaker (i.e., more colors are perceptually indistinguishable) in our peripheral vision. Leveraging the color discrimination (in)ability, we propose an algorithm that adjusts pixel colors to minimize the bit encoding cost without introducing visible artifacts. The algorithm is coupled with lightweight architectural support that, in real-time, reduces the DRAM traffic by 66.9\% and outperforms existing framebuffer compression mechanisms by up to 20.4\%. Psychophysical studies on human participants show that our system introduce little to no perceptual fidelity degradation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00441v1
[ -0.027197105810046196, -0.026424342766404152, 0.021983563899993896, 0.006908101495355368, 0.020438319072127342, 0.0074943844228982925, -0.022855179384350777, -0.026908300817012787, 0.023978227749466896, -0.043098535388708115, 0.009507213719189167, -0.008754043839871883, -0.016709504649043083, -0.020702410489320755, -0.06554059684276581, -0.011232509277760983, 0.0645105168223381, 0.031764525920152664, -0.03646150603890419, 0.07249633222818375, 0.04216807708144188, -0.01668665185570717, -0.048777781426906586, 0.030528701841831207, 0.007783832028508186, -0.028859060257673264, -0.06138766556978226, 0.031033974140882492, -0.048454415053129196, -0.04009242355823517, 0.040589477866888046, -0.04133940860629082, 0.0030831415206193924, -0.04706886410713196, -0.05425645783543587, 0.02320404350757599, -0.050006479024887085, 0.008525985293090343, -0.025475922971963882, -0.049331989139318466, 0.06833545863628387, -0.03026183322072029, -0.01805545575916767, -0.06112120300531387, -0.021772271022200584, -0.011745234951376915, -0.058178894221782684, -0.004803724121302366, -0.05822953209280968, -0.02326219715178013, 0.05468939617276192, 0.018645836040377617, 0.03072528727352619, 0.05980401486158371, -0.007459673099219799, 0.009194305166602135, -0.0282036904245615, 0.0010907800169661641, -0.0038823189679533243, -0.020104842260479927, -0.01893642544746399, -0.0003424071182962507, 0.02725164219737053, -0.039376068860292435, -0.002555469749495387, 0.06896235793828964, -0.031577713787555695, -0.06378708779811859, -0.053928785026073456, -0.02598518319427967, 0.07288721203804016, -0.07305433601140976, 0.046978287398815155, 0.01985327899456024, -0.06534633785486221, -0.025430744513869286, -0.031819891184568405, -0.04537554457783699, 0.011697551235556602, -0.0023227822966873646, -0.034410830587148666, 0.028444677591323853, 0.01272277720272541, 0.014089211821556091, -0.01812015287578106, 0.00997794046998024, 0.060184914618730545, 0.03287871927022934, 0.026578830555081367, -0.003707334864884615, 0.0811556950211525, -0.06809704750776291, -0.06420937925577164, -0.0015575481811538339, 0.04515431448817253, 0.010936460457742214, 0.02146925777196884, 0.06484577059745789, 0.016110209748148918, 0.027881938964128494, -0.03344658389687538, 0.022729210555553436, -0.012704829685389996, -0.002593026962131262, 0.02110353112220764, -0.026465151458978653, 0.005971751641482115, 0.02194909192621708, -0.017917433753609657, 0.05787453055381775, -0.0008381225634366274, -0.027135659009218216, -0.03565800189971924, -0.027151158079504967, -0.04440528526902199, 0.007933584041893482, 0.06627219915390015, 0.003600920084863901, 0.006391575559973717, -0.013452566228806973, -0.03833126276731491, -0.0014283210039138794, 0.03982938826084137, -0.014218760654330254, 0.012053783051669598, -0.025555822998285294, 0.058544524013996124, -0.009641253389418125, 0.038966622203588486, -0.026973027735948563, -0.0359712615609169, 0.014082484878599644, -0.01074063591659069, 0.0011033457703888416, 0.0697588101029396, 0.008789501152932644, 0.0032938073854893446, -0.06027688458561897, 0.061680953949689865, 0.02963694930076599, -0.002078574150800705, 0.0013495830353349447, 0.048467762768268585, -0.004378077108412981, -0.002909600269049406, 0.038532741367816925, 0.03086157888174057, -0.01080898754298687, 0.026381876319646835, 0.03229042515158653, 0.0021209416445344687, 0.008821960538625717, 0.01664576306939125, 0.03631111979484558, -0.014434068463742733, 0.029586385935544968, 0.05815475434064865, -0.022974921390414238, -0.055878087878227234, 0.0033386859577149153, 0.007721031084656715, -0.027302280068397522, -0.016842089593410492, 0.015248997136950493, 0.023799290880560875, -0.029454899951815605, 0.055485740303993225, 0.002284243004396558, 0.02264198288321495, 0.002330291550606489, -0.0458468459546566, -0.050973325967788696, 0.005437706131488085, -0.013814037665724754, -0.0591672919690609, -0.02612510696053505, -0.0492321215569973, -0.08400015532970428, 0.004699441138654947, 0.02233579196035862, 0.014729587361216545, -0.009563019499182701, -0.011234310455620289, -0.039251089096069336, -0.03042680211365223, 0.01636984385550022, -0.06483747810125351, 0.011843050830066204, 0.05428357422351837, 0.029934553429484367, -0.06093323603272438, -0.033542927354574203, 0.014447659254074097, 0.005536626558750868, -0.015787629410624504, -0.021358320489525795, -0.043628059327602386, -0.04497350752353668, 0.024957001209259033, 0.015035134740173817, -0.08268643170595169, -0.050880495458841324, -0.07536137104034424, -0.041133515536785126, -0.0023954620119184256, -0.06284444034099579, 0.012531615793704987, -0.00169700151309371, -0.02615661732852459, -0.011862414889037609, 0.024689972400665283, 0.008534635417163372, 0.057756390422582626, -0.009026898071169853, 0.019996896386146545, -0.009546851739287376, -0.1090690866112709, 0.033317845314741135, 0.027966013178229332, 0.00026531150797381997, -0.01095096580684185, 0.015802234411239624, -0.0181206576526165, -0.05447910726070404, -0.009965827688574791, 0.02230445295572281, 0.06525153666734695, 0.02253921888768673, -0.04694340005517006, -0.011845001950860023, 0.0020589176565408707, -0.039630379527807236, -0.006419606041163206, -0.0802251398563385, -0.02114272303879261, 0.03418350592255592, -0.046419136226177216, 0.019969886168837547, -0.001392707577906549, -0.03780917823314667, -0.045739371329545975, -0.04334847629070282, 0.05935660004615784, -0.023822765797376633, -0.04134371131658554, -0.027063241228461266, 0.015769891440868378, 0.016942234709858894, -0.05708332359790802, -0.00503080990165472, -0.03095465525984764, -0.004032517317682505, 0.029756246134638786, -0.04776950180530548, 0.037628382444381714, 0.007685578893870115, -0.048696424812078476, 0.05611788108944893, -0.02473706193268299, 0.018248502165079117, 0.019178150221705437, 0.03689035773277283, -0.05663208290934563, 0.028289703652262688, -0.01001250371336937, 0.013997599482536316, -0.021319303661584854, 0.018915412947535515, -0.0019956142641603947, -0.06263291835784912, -0.01678857021033764, 0.055725663900375366, 0.03898094967007637, -0.017876196652650833, -0.006742339115589857, 0.010106444358825684, -0.03885882347822189, -0.005087708123028278, 0.00981268472969532, 0.058631088584661484, 0.016682086512446404, 0.003854659153148532, -0.009959587827324867, -0.07795431464910507, -0.0401562824845314, 0.015171993523836136, -0.04178085923194885, -0.05214761942625046, -0.0333847813308239, -0.0362321212887764, -0.06932087242603302, -0.03115002252161503, -0.04321262240409851, -0.051917243748903275, 0.024799127131700516, -0.023172905668616295, 0.005721817258745432, -0.004201954230666161, 0.03906271979212761, -0.04139190539717674, -0.01910717785358429, -0.008674999698996544, 0.02062092162668705, 0.04314424842596054, -0.006414135452359915, -0.05200172960758209, -0.025763841345906258, -0.011033632792532444, 0.03209641948342323, 0.0339268296957016, -0.016408463940024376, 0.026679834350943565, -0.009737654589116573, 0.0363597497344017, -0.023685498163104057, 0.01844569481909275, 0.028787238523364067, -0.013847116380929947, -0.034799639135599136, -0.0012354744831100106, -0.04282553121447563, 0.010856975801289082, 0.03519946709275246, -0.04908403381705284, -0.04446900263428688, -0.025171510875225067, 0.04352822154760361, 0.03369211405515671, -0.023288879543542862, -0.053186483681201935, 0.0039751878939569, 0.028781238943338394, 0.011805562302470207, -0.006104038562625647, 0.02669847570359707, 0.019821172580122948, -0.010060236789286137, -0.03923651948571205, -0.004546711686998606, 0.0005577412666752934, -0.010601496323943138, 0.0725172832608223, -0.06649472564458847, -0.05776729807257652, 0.06041325628757477, -0.10014403611421585, 0.02433909848332405, 0.03756430372595787, 0.05671317130327225, -0.0015784484567120671, 0.01331346295773983, 0.030108720064163208, 0.01961883157491684, -0.0068590897135436535, 0.002066697459667921, -0.03634735941886902, 0.032488275319337845, 0.06831131875514984, -0.013281702063977718, -0.013653060421347618, 0.010245566256344318, -0.07225245237350464, -0.04489968717098236, 0.05356770008802414, 0.030371172353625298, 0.049898650497198105, 0.02831290289759636, -0.024599339812994003, 0.04504344239830971, -0.01839880459010601, 0.049558162689208984, 0.004314337391406298, -0.037698518484830856, 0.036294225603342056, -0.04284858703613281, 0.039839621633291245, -0.005139193497598171, -0.013306469656527042, 0.008703025057911873, -0.059815358370542526, -0.011773699894547462, -0.06834205240011215, 0.03259838744997978, 0.01717745140194893, -0.04122036695480347, -0.02265525795519352, 0.04856456443667412, 0.01915816403925419, 0.07582200318574905, -0.03440229594707489, -0.007092124316841364, 0.01757640764117241, -0.008325501345098019, 0.026636013761162758, -0.009241986088454723, -0.04912366345524788, 0.023987680673599243, 0.03912262246012688, -0.00807888712733984, 0.007332719396799803, -0.011363350786268711, -0.02820374257862568, -0.0019048110116273165, -0.08012307435274124, 0.050531599670648575, -0.052883975207805634, 0.03891441226005554, 0.008976904675364494, -0.048747625201940536, 0.04098861292004585, -0.046187132596969604, 0.007415722589939833, -0.05655644088983536, -0.03874826058745384, 0.004757079761475325, -0.018739880993962288, 0.0015668715350329876, -0.053093116730451584, -0.0012543057091534138, -0.028648139908909798, 0.053428880870342255, 0.004664959851652384, 0.04578191787004471, -0.03349123150110245, -0.0212379340082407, -0.025964731350541115, 0.030755020678043365, 0.0087086521089077, -0.021676450967788696, -0.046777449548244476, -0.014073426835238934, 0.02099713310599327, 0.023797275498509407, 0.030676957219839096, -0.004816756583750248, -0.06745106726884842, 0.01934640482068062, -0.03670516610145569, -0.04118791222572327, -0.022862201556563377, -0.008691278286278248, 0.02992653287947178, -0.04888083413243294, -0.04250873997807503, 0.013718001544475555, 0.01204657182097435, -0.03458889573812485, -0.02835785411298275, -0.02935686893761158, -0.057195600122213364, -0.03461820259690285, -0.03585074096918106, -0.032511793076992035, -0.007461620960384607, -0.04885473474860191, 0.04803173989057541, 0.060098521411418915, -0.004596746526658535, -0.012390218675136566, 0.011230973526835442, 0.04428388550877571, -0.0344058983027935, -0.016219856217503548, -0.022672751918435097, -0.04879027605056763, 0.03852580487728119, -0.007972204126417637, -0.017100488767027855, 0.0019769605714827776, -0.012910987250506878, 0.014313233084976673, 0.016223659738898277, -0.06866215914487839, 0.014813610352575779, 0.05988031625747681, -0.039675962179899216, 0.02081998437643051, 0.059731289744377136, -0.021482348442077637, 0.04673260822892189, -0.022532928735017776, 0.01069750264286995, 0.04278678447008133, -0.03926505893468857, -0.028259648010134697, 0.005870210472494364, -0.0608837828040123, -0.013450403697788715, 0.03274136781692505, 0.019966883584856987, -0.02213980257511139, -0.001230834168381989, 0.03556499257683754, 0.04610180854797363, -0.02771320566534996, 0.028565706685185432, 0.02859560027718544, -0.0433475486934185, -0.045339375734329224, 0.025508519262075424, -0.01895887963473797, -0.026522580534219742, 0.0707695260643959, -0.05517379194498062, -0.018685566261410713, 0.01760006509721279, -0.006585136521607637, -0.042938265949487686, -0.0006536617875099182, 0.007523674983531237, 0.02801426872611046, -0.010268469341099262, -0.023911090567708015, -0.04924199357628822, -0.03974688798189163, -0.04089542478322983, 0.023638300597667694, 0.01973733678460121, 0.03135179355740547, -0.015822570770978928, 0.045298315584659576, -0.017979172989726067, -0.012996144592761993, -0.005380974616855383, -0.017298515886068344, 0.032542090862989426, -0.041850775480270386, 0.012427027337253094, 0.020330222323536873, 0.03114108368754387, 0.003565410152077675, 0.029894277453422546, 0.03736415132880211, -0.0012567659141495824, -0.013134623877704144, -0.022130826488137245, 0.05011860653758049, -0.06572195142507553, -0.05939255282282829, -0.015116626396775246, 0.03676537424325943, -0.0219456534832716, 0.06388188898563385, 0.03332226350903511, -0.017972996458411217, 0.04036965221166611, 0.044841084629297256, -0.0038754555862396955, -0.03578183054924011, 0.008213697001338005, 0.04951251670718193, -0.0466298907995224, -0.032596562057733536, -0.012336885556578636, -0.05674148350954056, -0.041489217430353165, -0.023353537544608116, -0.014274831861257553, -0.03214980289340019, -0.014837597496807575, -0.04269881919026375, 0.019994480535387993, -0.012020417489111423, -0.07008691132068634, 0.03303457424044609, 0.06721411645412445, -0.07491591572761536, 0.02894573286175728, 0.03684945032000542, -0.0004905069945380092, -0.06424091756343842, 0.044101532548666, 0.002311840420588851, -0.04939397796988487, -0.055327408015728, 0.08344896137714386, 0.07907480001449585, -0.05227135121822357, 0.005710163619369268, 0.043222058564424515, -0.08950323611497879, 0.039293378591537476, -0.0010025210212916136, -0.009363607503473759, -0.006818805821239948, -0.013037975877523422, -0.005728025455027819, -0.03811757266521454, -0.06147398427128792, 0.027768574655056, 0.0012596240267157555, -0.022936679422855377, 0.04088643193244934, -0.027779486030340195, 0.07140940427780151, -0.03342343494296074, -0.03755192458629608, 0.044083718210458755, -0.05870728939771652, 0.03575028106570244, -0.05219465494155884, 0.006513906642794609, 0.02487359568476677, 0.025317784398794174, 0.006986974272876978, -0.05848561227321625, 0.008905048482120037, -0.02195335365831852, -0.05851408839225769, 0.02106735296547413, -0.07714079320430756, -0.030447987839579582, 0.00522178690880537, 0.011626103892922401, 0.017435157671570778, 0.057968828827142715, -0.02910417877137661, 0.01225504744797945, -0.0022650407627224922, 0.019861659035086632, 0.01426293421536684, -0.050439994782209396, 0.044397320598363876, 0.019271478056907654, 0.022428657859563828, -0.05075807496905327, -0.002356969751417637, 0.01288012508302927, -0.01876937597990036, 0.00463337916880846, 0.01945270039141178, -0.017804138362407684, -0.024265918880701065, -0.02468533255159855, -0.024677393957972527, -0.015619643032550812, 0.021602725610136986, -0.004264700226485729, -0.0734628215432167, 0.004341289401054382, 0.0015131549444049597, 0.040655095130205154, -0.013979795388877392, 0.011079423129558563, 0.014311976730823517, -0.020503170788288116, 0.022595595568418503, 0.010923967696726322, 0.018097640946507454, -0.0018720554653555155, -0.06768668442964554, -0.023498402908444405, -0.0024123822804540396, -0.06123553588986397, -0.04337356612086296, -0.030266720801591873, -0.00896158441901207, -0.07509098947048187, 0.01763126626610756, 0.037514906376600266, 0.032425668090581894, -0.016479317098855972, -0.016959384083747864, 0.014190050773322582, 0.033114466816186905, -0.06749488413333893, -0.04093771055340767, 0.055055152624845505, -0.00536453677341342, -0.027124224230647087, -0.011337075382471085, -0.00461177434772253, -0.04372258111834526, -0.0410941019654274, -0.0872168317437172, -0.0037030938547104597, 0.0006887773051857948, 0.05041705071926117, -0.022423213347792625, -0.02776426076889038, -0.025507573038339615, -0.05615740641951561, 0.04959256574511528, 0.023444896563887596, -0.007067812606692314, 0.00896263588219881, 0.007194153498858213, -0.010811355896294117, -0.05856465920805931, -0.006791639141738415, -0.01934703439474106, -0.042813193053007126, 0.025219064205884933, 0.04628855362534523, 0.04026884213089943, 0.029041143134236336, 0.025928206741809845, 0.07594063133001328, 0.010001711547374725, 0.04883856698870659, -0.042010530829429626, 0.023608891293406487, -0.03934864327311516, -0.005830487702041864, 0.0621904619038105, -0.05974557623267174, -0.00611512316390872, 0.021051539108157158, -0.024052120745182037, -0.006296912208199501, -0.005920931696891785, -0.06391744315624237, -0.009661358781158924, 0.0018627737881615758, 0.03200659528374672, 0.01708551123738289, -0.012700416147708893, -0.013495158404111862, 0.003053941996768117, -0.06508693844079971, -0.060867685824632645, 0.033853016793727875, 0.058737628161907196, -0.004757511895149946, 0.03257721662521362, -0.05005412548780441, 0.004549449309706688, -0.03279862925410271, -0.0472680926322937, -0.000836376566439867, 0.06830786168575287, 0.010988283902406693, -0.0529143325984478, -0.043031223118305206, -0.0280064195394516, -0.0030358650255948305, -0.037396349012851715, -0.019904257729649544, -0.03224233537912369, 0.03620488941669464, 0.005038516595959663, 0.04593128338456154, 0.000024544935513404198, -0.002187610836699605, 0.03827608376741409, 0.016430871561169624, 0.009181229397654533, 0.019014550372958183, -0.06265179067850113, 0.08151384443044662, 0.006658351048827171, 0.04978572577238083, -0.008436551317572594, -0.007753474172204733, -0.004830282647162676, 0.022559620440006256, 0.029399897903203964, -0.005108709912747145, 0.049212466925382614, -0.07909832149744034, -0.015667425468564034, 0.016413621604442596, 0.007470341864973307, -0.06038060784339905, -0.006879749707877636, -0.011128395795822144, -0.0040937988087534904, -0.0410320945084095 ]
BRC-20 (short for Bitcoin Request for Comment 20) token mania was a key storyline in the middle of 2023. Setting it apart from conventional ERC-20 token standards on Ethereum, BRC-20 introduces non-fungibility to Bitcoin through an editable field in each satoshi (0.00000001 Bitcoin, the smallest unit), making them unique. In this paper, we pioneer the exploration of this concept, covering its intricate mechanisms, features, and state-of-the-art applications. By analyzing the multi-dimensional data spanning over months with factual investigations, we conservatively comment that while BRC-20 expands Bitcoin's functionality and applicability, it may still not match Ethereum's abundance of decentralized applications and similar ecosystems.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10652v1
[ 0.06461817771196365, -0.05814099311828613, 0.05905110388994217, 0.03445590287446976, 0.013032487593591213, -0.02848753146827221, -0.010997626930475235, 0.047942958772182465, 0.06078649312257767, 0.025565195828676224, -0.013814670965075493, -0.004694324918091297, -0.05179232358932495, -0.03176933154463768, -0.035203732550144196, 0.03551279380917549, 0.07107896357774734, 0.05770636349916458, 0.0009620184428058565, 0.06950506567955017, -0.039240945130586624, -0.012848029844462872, -0.0482354462146759, 0.037226978689432144, 0.014539990574121475, -0.036215901374816895, -0.02648293599486351, 0.003175660502165556, -0.04326196387410164, 0.0048929741606116295, 0.05280795320868492, -0.0705675482749939, 0.013125380501151085, 0.02612191252410412, -0.023337125778198242, -0.008429311215877533, 0.007644927129149437, 0.027801183983683586, -0.021864058449864388, -0.02645481377840042, -0.008746694773435593, -0.04012897238135338, -0.04538634046912193, -0.029207849875092506, -0.013092237524688244, -0.031195664778351784, -0.052315060049295425, -0.07026325911283493, -0.05070015415549278, -0.027928033843636513, 0.054654162377119064, 0.02077198028564453, -0.014387060888111591, 0.03535202145576477, -0.046619314700365067, 0.0036781085655093193, 0.011328008957207203, -0.023710422217845917, -0.028284704312682152, 0.02935350313782692, -0.03156009316444397, -0.01707463525235653, 0.02596930041909218, -0.0360342301428318, -0.05769342556595802, 0.03286603093147278, -0.021766729652881622, -0.039516691118478775, -0.008981441147625446, -0.020666593685746193, 0.04630950465798378, -0.04732922464609146, -0.0006779406685382128, 0.05106273666024208, -0.043148692697286606, -0.0689408928155899, 0.007465971168130636, 0.005904002580791712, 0.04209281876683235, 0.011826332658529282, -0.03681326285004616, 0.05435803905129433, -0.03842676430940628, -0.01887398771941662, 0.06228848174214363, -0.007549791131168604, 0.04017465189099312, 0.03830033913254738, 0.009110355749726295, -0.05397854372859001, 0.03719957172870636, 0.040123000741004944, -0.08207832276821136, 0.0003436551196500659, 0.05045686662197113, -0.0107184499502182, 0.045407094061374664, 0.03232957050204277, -0.004068445414304733, -0.0019311417127028108, 0.025933966040611267, -0.04167483374476433, 0.0046412162482738495, 0.019214769825339317, -0.009350200183689594, 0.02914828062057495, -0.005040331277996302, 0.029106587171554565, 0.00569761311635375, 0.022682299837470055, -0.0005880380631424487, -0.0024888315238058567, -0.0253425445407629, -0.07944898307323456, -0.006845572497695684, -0.05918900668621063, -0.03139611706137657, 0.01687406748533249, 0.019704727455973625, 0.0019328113412484527, 0.005628883372992277, 0.03294169157743454, 0.05005098134279251, -0.03416963294148445, -0.05825081467628479, -0.04194307699799538, -0.010494284331798553, -0.01697106473147869, -0.012123328633606434, 0.013088925741612911, -0.025521624833345413, -0.03879363089799881, -0.014070195145905018, -0.04538598656654358, 0.03375372290611267, -0.01309463195502758, 0.025887714698910713, -0.02684229053556919, 0.03489633649587631, -0.027899177744984627, -0.016630491241812706, 0.008437594398856163, 0.005738823674619198, -0.004875974263995886, 0.019008753821253777, 0.02327820099890232, 0.02021874114871025, -0.06587910652160645, 0.01599273644387722, 0.020641546696424484, 0.009439757093787193, 0.02207151986658573, 0.037696901708841324, 0.03254372626543045, -0.028975285589694977, -0.03497427701950073, 0.014284421689808369, 0.014608613215386868, -0.04280983284115791, -0.03566788509488106, 0.03192698583006859, -0.003613147884607315, 0.003111771307885647, -0.007326184306293726, 0.00724834343418479, -0.04928508400917053, 0.020145094022154808, -0.017008105292916298, 0.03758852183818817, 0.00942777656018734, -0.05787839740514755, 0.014214628376066685, 0.04971926659345627, -0.014017581939697266, 0.018657581880688667, 0.0034892417024821043, -0.014604444615542889, -0.07341480255126953, -0.061963971704244614, 0.062314629554748535, 0.017382323741912842, 0.015100106596946716, -0.016664553433656693, 0.02609425224363804, -0.05528378486633301, -0.034636788070201874, -0.04460960999131203, 0.0024302389938384295, -0.003950871527194977, -0.018419157713651657, -0.01840248890221119, -0.04303276166319847, -0.024778902530670166, 0.016160139814019203, 0.0057077049277722836, -0.07232077419757843, 0.0470622181892395, -0.024981053546071053, -0.03363115340471268, -0.034876395016908646, -0.07703297585248947, -0.04200591519474983, -0.023185985162854195, -0.030700253322720528, -0.01043839380145073, -0.016390934586524963, -0.013090426102280617, 0.027388520538806915, -0.052621811628341675, -0.009132507257163525, 0.017443574965000153, 0.010158603079617023, 0.06475453078746796, 0.0027255259919911623, 0.06069330498576164, -0.06359563022851944, -0.10807273536920547, 0.019402258098125458, 0.032471053302288055, -0.012967596761882305, -0.010892367921769619, -0.004681662656366825, -0.01863231137394905, -0.033499326556921005, -0.03280347213149071, 0.05261358618736267, 0.06082099676132202, 0.018917545676231384, -0.04523652791976929, 0.009253437630832195, -0.02322898618876934, 0.022251108661293983, 0.023599253967404366, -0.049492333084344864, -0.053855519741773605, -0.028961103409528732, -0.06981423497200012, 0.02257237210869789, -0.035545360296964645, -0.07236850261688232, -0.01593654416501522, -0.023154685273766518, 0.017090588808059692, -0.020215393975377083, -0.0353708490729332, 0.04815738648176193, -0.07046009600162506, 0.02448146790266037, -0.033134736120700836, -0.03197504207491875, 0.023569906130433083, 0.0028825404588133097, 0.024484967812895775, -0.02812623418867588, -0.014804682694375515, 0.041068434715270996, -0.03886307775974274, -0.010229839943349361, -0.014757325872778893, -0.02858198806643486, 0.0015245586400851607, 0.027678702026605606, -0.052525486797094345, 0.058384254574775696, 0.04851674288511276, -0.03757869824767113, -0.0007008196553215384, -0.015431668609380722, 0.031728051602840424, -0.03593689203262329, -0.02230381779372692, -0.002036652062088251, 0.046459347009658813, -0.010678923688828945, 0.0038754171691834927, 0.01669696718454361, -0.0299079529941082, -0.06470690667629242, 0.024751782417297363, 0.0310197863727808, 0.004893133882433176, 0.014232831075787544, -0.04350194334983826, -0.07942286133766174, -0.022262193262577057, 0.019567575305700302, -0.011544284410774708, -0.02732815593481064, -0.0028044020291417837, -0.036219965666532516, -0.04210491478443146, 0.00009422568837180734, -0.05378323420882225, -0.045571934431791306, -0.010721635073423386, 0.02899673767387867, -0.07055875658988953, 0.015252319164574146, 0.05850759893655777, -0.04741457477211952, 0.0010775026166811585, 0.021671101450920105, 0.03472789004445076, 0.0018269172869622707, -0.03658308833837509, -0.015391463413834572, -0.06999653577804565, -0.03617192432284355, -0.029652608558535576, -0.025069888681173325, -0.009671501815319061, -0.00889766775071621, -0.018579112365841866, 0.007452669553458691, -0.011075060814619064, 0.030388714745640755, -0.02872905321419239, 0.037812698632478714, -0.05431406572461128, -0.02451329305768013, -0.07245268672704697, -0.024623241275548935, 0.017133278772234917, -0.033319443464279175, -0.08853081613779068, -0.011311319656670094, -0.023852791637182236, 0.029606539756059647, -0.04148319736123085, 0.031274519860744476, 0.012337814085185528, 0.03368981555104256, -0.018013158813118935, -0.03580455854535103, 0.03819023817777634, -0.009170694276690483, -0.022019440308213234, -0.030766384676098824, 0.040015365928411484, 0.03738173842430115, 0.04820566624403, 0.054885365068912506, -0.027810342609882355, -0.07413417100906372, 0.04282839223742485, -0.07578819990158081, 0.03620132431387901, -0.010401259176433086, 0.04626723751425743, -0.06262123584747314, -0.029103994369506836, 0.00006324151763692498, -0.024889875203371048, 0.010731210000813007, -0.009168519638478756, -0.07006088644266129, 0.043690670281648636, 0.05016717687249184, -0.024919254705309868, -0.04803216829895973, -0.04880182445049286, -0.04566814750432968, -0.02900499477982521, 0.004866000264883041, 0.03304348140954971, 0.010425121523439884, 0.009991548024117947, 0.01624157279729843, -0.016981765627861023, -0.03291773051023483, 0.04621707648038864, 0.04496413841843605, -0.058904871344566345, 0.015785912051796913, -0.0537223219871521, 0.03049609251320362, 0.0027254612650722265, -0.02355012483894825, 0.020915377885103226, -0.03334541246294975, 0.007771934848278761, -0.06360232084989548, 0.03303370624780655, 0.026734480634331703, 0.009088494814932346, 0.010153261944651604, -0.019015289843082428, 0.03853001445531845, 0.029716603457927704, -0.016588404774665833, -0.00012064170005032793, 0.012279735878109932, -0.0009199673077091575, 0.014033623039722443, -0.025850869715213776, -0.000675097166094929, -0.032500896602869034, 0.024759305641055107, 0.008268514648079872, 0.030550803989171982, -0.022702373564243317, 0.012645887210965157, 0.007087049540132284, -0.0716983750462532, 0.01573716476559639, -0.043519869446754456, 0.02925846166908741, 0.04058020934462547, -0.03817835822701454, 0.03394179418683052, -0.02917773462831974, -0.003042826661840081, -0.039914511144161224, -0.00478375144302845, -0.006432520225644112, -0.025303732603788376, -0.02760135568678379, -0.05977329611778259, -0.02456231415271759, 0.004121186677366495, -0.010150598362088203, -0.01419901754707098, 0.027496930211782455, -0.06384869664907455, 0.006622105371206999, -0.02110149897634983, -0.0647716075181961, 0.055116601288318634, 0.05639807879924774, 0.039456628262996674, -0.029230324551463127, 0.057734981179237366, 0.022889724001288414, 0.018066653981804848, -0.01080896146595478, -0.028202734887599945, 0.04086199775338173, 0.005766591988503933, -0.011922435835003853, -0.020343760028481483, 0.024212252348661423, 0.014285293407738209, -0.03029216080904007, 0.0010955389589071274, -0.03643130511045456, 0.04493606463074684, -0.005931684281677008, -0.05213291198015213, -0.010379842482507229, -0.03931738808751106, -0.034962236881256104, -0.04982496798038483, -0.01612096279859543, 0.020667295902967453, -0.04264277219772339, 0.049815431237220764, 0.027634838595986366, 0.05955436825752258, -0.05012214556336403, 0.03869080916047096, 0.026806768029928207, -0.028757182881236076, -0.035988252609968185, -0.03338832035660744, -0.002136725001037121, -0.006707313936203718, 0.0035237730480730534, 0.008326929062604904, 0.0194451492279768, 0.038554903119802475, -0.02253958396613598, 0.03204083815217018, -0.10054045915603638, 0.027956172823905945, -0.0068329921923577785, -0.009029578417539597, -0.013631307519972324, -0.03651810437440872, 0.02352299727499485, -0.022678853943943977, -0.05318627133965492, -0.0014234663685783744, 0.08047853410243988, 0.02020522765815258, -0.01561737060546875, 0.04404551908373833, -0.05221005529165268, -0.009932824410498142, -0.018138453364372253, -0.017766861245036125, -0.07039496302604675, -0.015600806102156639, 0.08665850013494492, 0.009572182781994343, -0.05958406627178192, 0.003745484631508589, 0.00382271152921021, -0.04805804044008255, 0.001253112219274044, 0.011830348521471024, 0.030007246881723404, -0.05347348377108574, 0.019393455237150192, 0.02634015679359436, 0.0627325251698494, 0.03014039434492588, -0.042979881167411804, -0.05627990886569023, 0.05728328600525856, -0.052820608019828796, 0.06735002249479294, -0.007121113128960133, -0.022318167611956596, -0.017428802326321602, -0.019090838730335236, -0.032040417194366455, 0.04716524854302406, 0.030052434653043747, 0.03356590121984482, -0.004648165311664343, 0.009628379717469215, -0.03248566761612892, -0.06628582626581192, 0.00935861375182867, -0.058969009667634964, -0.004452668130397797, -0.01852908730506897, -0.03329030051827431, -0.04322601109743118, 0.028565019369125366, 0.024295220151543617, -0.025504220277071, -0.02002890408039093, 0.019840816035866737, -0.022449873387813568, 0.01698611117899418, -0.026277964934706688, 0.0009104487835429609, 0.029814520850777626, -0.02092839777469635, 0.023043423891067505, -0.047081395983695984, 0.010529745370149612, 0.061358820647001266, -0.051340263336896896, 0.06539257615804672, -0.007985875010490417, 0.0020116674713790417, -0.07792380452156067, -0.0167889092117548, 0.029259486123919487, -0.0055459425784647465, -0.006292939186096191, -0.024886220693588257, -0.046603716909885406, -0.05414174497127533, -0.0367472805082798, -0.018542736768722534, 0.04488811641931534, -0.021548600867390633, -0.05356071889400482, 0.05457189679145813, -0.010849570855498314, 0.013991910964250565, 0.036007389426231384, 0.03133499249815941, -0.03709279000759125, 0.010062684305012226, -0.04522620886564255, -0.004217364825308323, -0.03774520009756088, 0.04594084620475769, -0.011312673799693584, -0.0326707623898983, -0.0059242816641926765, 0.042360398918390274, 0.07886210829019547, -0.012793639674782753, 0.019937410950660706, 0.05249687656760216, -0.0633431226015091, -0.04759610816836357, -0.02591007389128208, 0.007583294995129108, 0.05292542651295662, -0.012712962925434113, -0.007512038107961416, -0.036990340799093246, -0.03648850694298744, 0.04903094097971916, -0.019703591242432594, -0.018350018188357353, -0.037314027547836304, -0.05771401524543762, 0.019291771575808525, -0.04768748581409454, -0.07222141325473785, 0.04744255915284157, -0.022292958572506905, 0.007574254181236029, 0.04010388255119324, -0.015459630638360977, -0.008780869655311108, 0.04871407523751259, -0.017282729968428612, -0.05395444855093956, -0.02551509626209736, 0.028664549812674522, -0.08167937397956848, -0.007741621695458889, -0.04152153432369232, -0.006158884149044752, 0.002310773590579629, 0.018654951825737953, 0.015294427052140236, 0.0749577134847641, -0.059568919241428375, -0.00956993829458952, -0.0033322509843856096, -0.0227533970028162, 0.0016562128439545631, 0.011196673847734928, -0.02169174514710903, 0.01756996102631092, 0.021692242473363876, 0.03719300031661987, 0.011045455932617188, -0.007285504136234522, -0.036750417202711105, -0.01738065667450428, -0.05048779770731926, -0.03288041800260544, -0.02203221060335636, -0.026356365531682968, 0.0011675854912027717, -0.0427621491253376, 0.00749958073720336, -0.040384452790021896, -0.056887608021497726, -0.02188487909734249, 0.03275321424007416, 0.04060635343194008, 0.02310428023338318, -0.05774936079978943, 0.0862056091427803, -0.05157938227057457, 0.009993791580200195, -0.013219127431511879, 0.043379805982112885, -0.023388992995023727, -0.05969545617699623, -0.00688468012958765, 0.058921825140714645, 0.011325368657708168, -0.011917504481971264, -0.024070702493190765, -0.04039963334798813, -0.02367120236158371, 0.027182696387171745, 0.023521102964878082, -0.008964810520410538, -0.052950840443372726, -0.08628423511981964, 0.026787273585796356, 0.050754621624946594, -0.0321313813328743, -0.04342404007911682, -0.0032075478229671717, 0.005563011392951012, -0.03481609374284744, 0.0023693146649748087, -0.044676873832941055, -0.03379625454545021, 0.03573078662157059, -0.08654528856277466, 0.025594303384423256, -0.03343880921602249, 0.006910087540745735, -0.013506821356713772, 0.0037325802259147167, -0.026763051748275757, -0.05415259301662445, 0.011377603746950626, 0.03199148550629616, -0.05852792039513588, 0.014875425025820732, 0.004427629057317972, 0.009224719367921352, -0.07644496858119965, 0.010185626335442066, 0.0292062945663929, -0.004992302041500807, -0.0008543770527467132, -0.04753636568784714, 0.010453576222062111, 0.0260666161775589, 0.04306519404053688, 0.05597503483295441, 0.018695779144763947, 0.05204889550805092, 0.034287746995687485, 0.0062642525881528854, -0.06403017789125443, -0.04956330358982086, -0.01055435836315155, 0.002085318323224783, 0.04625711217522621, 0.04893345758318901, -0.014337163418531418, 0.05347554013133049, -0.02280978485941887, -0.008890856988728046, 0.026756197214126587, -0.005088368896394968, -0.03733353316783905, -0.03146779164671898, -0.050588950514793396, 0.006566858384758234, -0.0183420330286026, -0.0467836819589138, -0.037657372653484344, -0.015562260523438454, 0.029873235151171684, -0.0786004513502121, 0.023873234167695045, 0.004615140147507191, 0.0038347113877534866, -0.006920137908309698, 0.01576968841254711, -0.020447496324777603, 0.050344474613666534, 0.000014270818610384595, -0.02934783510863781, -0.05098550766706467, -0.053062211722135544, 0.036183323711156845, -0.060343340039253235, -0.05129917338490486, -0.021299274638295174, 0.02268657274544239, -0.046954263001680374, 0.029404569417238235, 0.052882205694913864, -0.0038934198673814535, -0.016827888786792755, 0.006919519975781441, 0.036923568695783615, 0.04199645668268204, -0.05892995372414589, 0.0570988804101944, 0.011537151411175728, 0.005889286752790213, -0.024817844852805138, 0.01466343179345131, -0.03327035531401634, 0.006129200104624033, 0.054756905883550644, -0.023155122995376587, 0.03133866935968399, -0.06579526513814926, -0.05702001228928566, 0.009889061562716961, -0.010117246769368649, -0.05814342945814133, -0.007704207208007574, -0.009600107558071613, -0.033163536339998245, -0.04801521450281143 ]
Human motion capture either requires multi-camera systems or is unreliable when using single-view input due to depth ambiguities. Meanwhile, mirrors are readily available in urban environments and form an affordable alternative by recording two views with only a single camera. However, the mirror setting poses the additional challenge of handling occlusions of real and mirror image. Going beyond existing mirror approaches for 3D human pose estimation, we utilize mirrors for learning a complete body model, including shape and dense appearance. Our main contributions are extending articulated neural radiance fields to include a notion of a mirror, making it sample-efficient over potential occlusion regions. Together, our contributions realize a consumer-level 3D motion capture system that starts from off-the-shelf 2D poses by automatically calibrating the camera, estimating mirror orientation, and subsequently lifting 2D keypoint detections to 3D skeleton pose that is used to condition the mirror-aware NeRF. We empirically demonstrate the benefit of learning a body model and accounting for occlusion in challenging mirror scenes.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04750v2
[ -0.02015509642660618, 0.03839343041181564, 0.02321598306298256, -0.006592822261154652, 0.03735979273915291, -0.03047175519168377, 0.023451322689652443, -0.0021188934333622456, 0.0015163600910454988, -0.0563901886343956, -0.020075572654604912, -0.005493053700774908, -0.023235326632857323, -0.07256292551755905, -0.025929763913154602, 0.02846820093691349, 0.07093675434589386, -0.05710403993725777, -0.053508613258600235, 0.05432848259806633, 0.05025323107838631, -0.01621643826365471, -0.01816726289689541, -0.0012860450660809875, -0.022608323022723198, -0.005122244358062744, -0.02862895466387272, 0.018046552315354347, -0.057492006570100784, -0.027719469740986824, 0.05373622104525566, -0.027601266279816628, -0.014646099880337715, -0.02506898157298565, -0.01899067498743534, 0.007977060042321682, 0.005213059950619936, 0.03137233853340149, -0.04494529217481613, -0.04707030951976776, 0.04732890799641609, -0.02530975267291069, -0.04681085795164108, -0.0026888977736234665, -0.06004980951547623, -0.017401335760951042, -0.02880978398025036, 0.0012736221542581916, -0.07857056707143784, -0.0016708694165572524, 0.03691120445728302, -0.004393735434859991, 0.04372365027666092, 0.049220163375139236, 0.0060640559531748295, 0.01723542995750904, -0.025137832388281822, 0.029151078313589096, -0.018289629369974136, 0.007196428719907999, 0.041761770844459534, -0.05102405697107315, -0.00024001323617994785, -0.05046182498335838, 0.041115209460258484, 0.057148177176713943, -0.01516485121101141, -0.06474333256483078, -0.014552817679941654, -0.04198896139860153, 0.0511065274477005, -0.07127954065799713, 0.006659739185124636, 0.016388706862926483, -0.036704760044813156, -0.005279872566461563, -0.024823086336255074, -0.024195415899157524, 0.004327028524130583, 0.019868925213813782, -0.04737398028373718, 0.012183952145278454, 0.031099187210202217, 0.054123375564813614, -0.021847959607839584, -0.027727389708161354, 0.04728758707642555, 0.007288557011634111, 0.015163715928792953, -0.008640793152153492, 0.06201591342687607, -0.06440435349941254, -0.0400979109108448, 0.0360460989177227, 0.034170202910900116, -0.033219434320926666, 0.05791758373379707, 0.047177135944366455, 0.026123492047190666, 0.028165459632873535, -0.003448844188824296, 0.01566987857222557, -0.0044282833114266396, 0.028717244043946266, 0.034878481179475784, -0.05643538013100624, 0.014649413526058197, -0.009008258581161499, -0.0295308418571949, -0.002893497934564948, -0.0422201082110405, -0.0463525727391243, 0.025680143386125565, -0.057099848985672, -0.026636973023414612, -0.023296315222978592, 0.054682545363903046, -0.011581437662243843, -0.021348994225263596, 0.02068239077925682, -0.05592143163084984, 0.022690201178193092, 0.024747759103775024, -0.040701139718294144, -0.002256060019135475, -0.024842625483870506, 0.07688207179307938, -0.00884050689637661, 0.005389068275690079, -0.02076590433716774, -0.034756481647491455, 0.025150073692202568, -0.041772086173295975, -0.02586217224597931, 0.03768880292773247, -0.001490738708525896, 0.006724491249769926, -0.06319030374288559, -0.025582021102309227, -0.021264471113681793, -0.02245725877583027, -0.0600307434797287, 0.01379281934350729, -0.0484478734433651, -0.0371052622795105, 0.053488150238990784, -0.03934088721871376, -0.047268662601709366, -0.015151162631809711, 0.03163976967334747, 0.015509014949202538, -0.01348489336669445, 0.043946489691734314, 0.050101347267627716, -0.020829450339078903, -0.04014502838253975, 0.022862311452627182, -0.03606629744172096, -0.05065947771072388, 0.0005742721841670573, -0.004978310316801071, -0.02563258819282055, 0.009232135489583015, -0.04465894028544426, 0.015298043377697468, 0.020125744864344597, 0.003988344222307205, -0.002320826519280672, -0.006353205535560846, 0.00930585153400898, -0.038799792528152466, -0.05827633664011955, -0.014224981889128685, 0.02910744398832321, -0.06601978093385696, 0.03396938741207123, 0.003749116789549589, -0.0633828341960907, -0.03443470224738121, 0.029964717105031013, -0.026205364614725113, 0.0014747062232345343, -0.005746084731072187, 0.02132478728890419, -0.023908285424113274, -0.04547654464840889, -0.08757882565259933, -0.013806190341711044, 0.011315857991576195, 0.01131301000714302, -0.05847042798995972, -0.025890862569212914, 0.007179522421211004, 0.0359361506998539, -0.06392975151538849, -0.007912106812000275, -0.04848776385188103, -0.006473184563219547, 0.04730885475873947, 0.02169879339635372, -0.07901033014059067, 0.02493073232471943, -0.040620625019073486, -0.048409078270196915, -0.02932954765856266, -0.07033129781484604, 0.0013736927649006248, 0.014483089558780193, -0.04949949309229851, 0.007928173057734966, 0.030460458248853683, 0.025005703791975975, 0.040016770362854004, -0.016724176704883575, 0.024072278290987015, 0.027516430243849754, -0.09564187377691269, 0.012070715427398682, -0.003736341604962945, 0.012632505968213081, 0.03511185944080353, 0.02091089077293873, -0.011893179267644882, -0.017107898369431496, -0.021924754604697227, 0.03637595474720001, 0.07897164672613144, -0.012128299102187157, -0.05673419311642647, -0.012028243392705917, -0.023225918412208557, -0.0774565190076828, -0.010480462573468685, -0.042886361479759216, -0.06380350887775421, -0.014874192886054516, -0.059838809072971344, 0.05046533793210983, -0.009225184097886086, -0.02119511552155018, -0.047817718237638474, -0.03821495547890663, 0.015143807977437973, -0.02505667693912983, -0.029638420790433884, -0.010072953999042511, -0.010261761955916882, 0.06374412029981613, -0.04010225087404251, -0.005151944700628519, -0.04645431786775589, -0.052851974964141846, -0.00005755295933340676, -0.015959344804286957, 0.04090958833694458, 0.040311336517333984, -0.03421447053551674, -0.007153148762881756, -0.016871115192770958, 0.05514320731163025, 0.028466181829571724, 0.00976149644702673, -0.07127963751554489, 0.024284454062581062, 0.04260462149977684, 0.0031314995139837265, -0.05610886216163635, -0.021292945370078087, 0.05197949707508087, -0.034496620297431946, -0.006505321245640516, 0.021133439615368843, 0.0194303710013628, 0.04844869673252106, -0.02311835251748562, -0.015620749443769455, -0.01616324670612812, -0.05440010130405426, 0.03762533515691757, 0.03749515116214752, 0.02093348652124405, 0.018886828795075417, -0.0015325973508879542, -0.048008035868406296, -0.007643993943929672, -0.07177480310201645, -0.0069964234717190266, -0.03346998617053032, -0.06268240511417389, -0.04746762290596962, -0.07718272507190704, -0.0452573336660862, -0.014403730630874634, -0.02496763877570629, 0.0009196012397296727, -0.05404289811849594, -0.02503385953605175, -0.0029460922814905643, 0.05085871368646622, 0.004009953234344721, -0.02979043498635292, -0.008004634641110897, 0.02394699677824974, 0.05593029409646988, -0.013010515831410885, -0.07048559188842773, -0.06717786937952042, -0.02024022862315178, 0.0021282427478581667, -0.04238865524530411, 0.010650874115526676, 0.05511026829481125, -0.013996097259223461, 0.023692704737186432, 0.010074164718389511, 0.015547657385468483, 0.01608266867697239, -0.00012092250108253211, 0.011916893534362316, 0.004224692936986685, 0.013360314071178436, -0.016876351088285446, 0.022903164848685265, -0.042337093502283096, -0.0567854605615139, 0.024041201919317245, 0.028365395963191986, 0.02684803493320942, -0.05258522555232048, 0.0005785907851532102, 0.012418771162629128, 0.025507139042019844, 0.02134728990495205, -0.012472916394472122, 0.024572450667619705, -0.02594207599759102, -0.038683876395225525, -0.0304653849452734, 0.009279627352952957, 0.006837278604507446, -0.0009179710759781301, -0.004162908531725407, -0.07048588246107101, -0.0366356335580349, 0.03960035741329193, -0.09170739352703094, 0.03416883200407028, 0.02443775348365307, 0.07333941757678986, -0.013588852249085903, 0.0514223538339138, 0.013343987986445427, 0.04279135912656784, 0.02727203629910946, 0.0046900799497962, -0.014472569338977337, 0.006627256982028484, 0.055313944816589355, -0.028685014694929123, -0.0648651197552681, -0.016736235469579697, -0.05674584209918976, -0.059888992458581924, 0.05269383266568184, 0.034131795167922974, -0.004034547135233879, 0.06435554474592209, -0.054577574133872986, 0.003091278485953808, -0.004823816474527121, 0.046981003135442734, -0.018335938453674316, -0.008627127856016159, 0.03161139786243439, -0.06785590946674347, 0.030465051531791687, 0.023779280483722687, -0.00017790622950997204, -0.030281510204076767, -0.06324146687984467, -0.011989694088697433, -0.02369089610874653, 0.0563606321811676, -0.020860128104686737, 0.011433787643909454, 0.02013080008327961, 0.036000415682792664, 0.022092560306191444, 0.05269400775432587, -0.030112840235233307, -0.011025894433259964, -0.013695244677364826, -0.003929751459509134, 0.010153199546039104, 0.0023293804842978716, -0.06234283745288849, -0.021509863436222076, 0.0022149740252643824, -0.032273516058921814, 0.0017198165878653526, -0.011730771511793137, -0.01494573149830103, -0.02143244445323944, -0.06424525380134583, 0.003483990440145135, -0.0312984399497509, 0.05566687136888504, 0.034956954419612885, -0.012724820524454117, 0.0684654712677002, -0.04992463439702988, -0.0016882424242794514, -0.035764168947935104, -0.029477758333086967, -0.030657369643449783, -0.04436314478516579, 0.026728404685854912, -0.08530633896589279, 0.014591401442885399, -0.054333675652742386, 0.036089058965444565, 0.008873476646840572, 0.04401830956339836, -0.04076239839196205, -0.03063570149242878, -0.021974841132760048, 0.043262481689453125, -0.01350689772516489, -0.020198194310069084, -0.034052956849336624, 0.018417324870824814, 0.04998556151986122, 0.0024524617474526167, 0.012762174941599369, 0.0047839186154305935, -0.029576171189546585, 0.059740178287029266, -0.032752737402915955, -0.03158986195921898, 0.006640439387410879, -0.01066017895936966, 0.02425631694495678, -0.029183583334088326, -0.029553502798080444, -0.025227591395378113, 0.02617013454437256, -0.04175431281328201, -0.03590254858136177, -0.04461051896214485, -0.026995841413736343, -0.028275739401578903, 0.019963642582297325, 0.03730127960443497, -0.033836521208286285, 0.03727016597986221, 0.00237067649140954, 0.008324652910232544, 0.01914961077272892, -0.024828538298606873, -0.0016913883155211806, 0.01643557660281658, 0.0064066192135214806, -0.008311091922223568, -0.040066640824079514, -0.07389700412750244, 0.02218087948858738, -0.017102675512433052, 0.002592617180198431, -0.0016608259174972773, 0.02557440847158432, 0.013409978710114956, 0.02750999666750431, -0.08179578185081482, 0.0452444851398468, 0.06833439320325851, -0.01770475134253502, 0.034770987927913666, 0.05933229997754097, 0.02893686480820179, 0.035191334784030914, -0.03507016599178314, 0.039523761719465256, 0.04286494478583336, -0.04087434709072113, -0.039640411734580994, 0.010282195173203945, -0.011491644196212292, -0.03703154996037483, 0.06179350987076759, 0.009344415739178658, -0.06492672115564346, 0.007704578340053558, -0.0010096087353304029, -0.006317680235952139, -0.014950975775718689, 0.014833994209766388, -0.0033995562698692083, -0.05007566884160042, -0.02041282132267952, 0.026616228744387627, -0.0014900399837642908, 0.016856081783771515, 0.03932539001107216, -0.02818921208381653, -0.025977516546845436, 0.034782953560352325, -0.01675119437277317, -0.0212863739579916, -0.007166236639022827, 0.006648378446698189, -0.025782743468880653, 0.005871098022907972, 0.006785036996006966, -0.054567914456129074, -0.025020938366651535, -0.021824026480317116, 0.042096856981515884, 0.04327262192964554, 0.06784866750240326, 0.022613856941461563, 0.013169274665415287, -0.06046849116683006, 0.02715313620865345, -0.021825753152370453, -0.004205610603094101, 0.03338463976979256, -0.07007970660924911, 0.05734706297516823, 0.0004655378870666027, 0.02304917946457863, -0.008230962790548801, 0.006183283869177103, 0.03324112668633461, 0.029080742970108986, -0.022008517757058144, -0.0628630742430687, 0.05271464213728905, -0.03573576733469963, -0.04113137722015381, 0.01395141240209341, 0.012985242530703545, -0.03602135553956032, 0.014518051408231258, 0.06474678963422775, -0.03416849300265312, 0.030422667041420937, -0.013404065743088722, 0.03578481450676918, -0.03435613214969635, 0.008889656513929367, 0.05133398249745369, -0.056617602705955505, -0.04326656460762024, -0.005770703312009573, -0.06224335357546806, 0.01452181488275528, -0.03313927724957466, 0.030116470530629158, 0.0103141563013196, -0.023491624742746353, -0.041663870215415955, 0.006628783419728279, -0.017873963341116905, -0.07543184608221054, 0.02017691731452942, -0.024135617539286613, -0.04498911276459694, -0.004117851611226797, 0.05084175616502762, 0.031972091645002365, -0.028986873105168343, 0.04470135644078255, -0.03801947832107544, 0.011081197299063206, -0.04052003100514412, 0.05798535421490669, 0.07866667956113815, -0.021397769451141357, -0.005350731313228607, 0.0069511630572378635, -0.022572806105017662, 0.036021847277879715, -0.041705988347530365, 0.03836894780397415, -0.026701565831899643, -0.00075291539542377, 0.02982739917933941, -0.0688752681016922, -0.047996215522289276, 0.0568828247487545, -0.026653917506337166, -0.04201241955161095, 0.043646663427352905, -0.004272913094609976, 0.05312846601009369, -0.021129095926880836, -0.06216520816087723, 0.010928095318377018, -0.0298621729016304, -0.008941512554883957, -0.027416042983531952, -0.0005185178597457707, 0.012250551022589207, -0.014567564241588116, 0.012741505168378353, -0.053422898054122925, -0.0036222958005964756, -0.06413470953702927, -0.04298320412635803, 0.0027528665959835052, -0.06803448498249054, -0.045200902968645096, -0.03426140174269676, 0.04441734775900841, 0.07202707976102829, 0.06046678125858307, -0.0571676567196846, -0.023319542407989502, 0.01728888414800167, 0.01667048968374729, -0.0203313659876585, -0.005832838360220194, 0.035177282989025116, -0.024863755330443382, 0.019444260746240616, -0.008658814243972301, -0.004510671831667423, 0.004459470976144075, -0.0068670534528791904, -0.020803648978471756, -0.025345152243971825, -0.03965705260634422, -0.04039229080080986, -0.016909798607230186, -0.013081741519272327, 0.005419663619250059, 0.03748750314116478, -0.07183150947093964, -0.08322753012180328, 0.03489851951599121, -0.03177615627646446, 0.0016442305641248822, 0.012044425122439861, 0.04399272799491882, 0.058000776916742325, -0.024060387164354324, 0.03604450821876526, 0.04717099294066429, -0.055109426379203796, 0.03713963180780411, -0.0663972869515419, -0.03612837940454483, -0.004297795705497265, 0.011325119994580746, -0.049504995346069336, -0.024571502581238747, -0.025354692712426186, -0.05973246693611145, 0.011087480932474136, 0.05503544211387634, -0.0254018846899271, -0.021546727046370506, -0.055368587374687195, 0.004474597983062267, -0.005828443914651871, -0.018961964175105095, -0.059245284646749496, 0.007178471889346838, 0.002657447475939989, -0.015842417255043983, -0.030054772272706032, 0.00853887852281332, -0.038170862942934036, -0.0001950503938132897, -0.08546702563762665, 0.005460071377456188, 0.013077208772301674, 0.06723835319280624, -0.0406673438847065, -0.07003938406705856, -0.015289012342691422, -0.042347367852926254, -0.03283637389540672, 0.049422480165958405, 0.016253845766186714, -0.027419688180088997, 0.04601113870739937, -0.03581827133893967, -0.06849638372659683, -0.05386396870017052, 0.03342915326356888, -0.01791691780090332, -0.014417814090847969, 0.033639345318078995, 0.024644851684570312, 0.02191253937780857, 0.013171291910111904, 0.028670549392700195, -0.0102904187515378, 0.06291808933019638, -0.04780915006995201, 0.03327321633696556, -0.04022609442472458, -0.040226757526397705, 0.026629982516169548, -0.013931331224739552, -0.02087527886033058, -0.022518215700984, 0.004466368816792965, 0.028871141374111176, -0.061480384320020676, -0.07145992666482925, 0.019264796748757362, -0.03223291039466858, 0.0188477523624897, 0.036273397505283356, -0.049477607011795044, -0.0005154161481186748, -0.012803955003619194, -0.028470778837800026, -0.049873124808073044, 0.004196627531200647, 0.034016191959381104, -0.021957924589514732, 0.01412008423358202, -0.08001651614904404, 0.02334141544997692, -0.04782767966389656, -0.05339813977479935, -0.03473222628235817, 0.06204850226640701, -0.016037091612815857, -0.03914999961853027, -0.035905513912439346, -0.03484418988227844, 0.03233695402741432, -0.05382832512259483, -0.008744151331484318, -0.018685299903154373, 0.0405556745827198, -0.0026369986589998007, 0.013469722121953964, 0.005557471886277199, 0.04320984333753586, 0.03436582535505295, 0.011340690776705742, -0.027486633509397507, -0.005217965692281723, -0.03658025711774826, 0.034186795353889465, 0.017978839576244354, 0.025913378223776817, -0.018951203674077988, -0.02609470672905445, -0.03696146979928017, 0.0033311962615698576, -0.02896495908498764, -0.0005117218825034797, 0.013393844477832317, -0.0763181820511818, -0.00976525992155075, 0.024669010192155838, -0.034558579325675964, -0.0308067724108696, -0.007960917428135872, -0.013798878528177738, -0.0473383292555809, -0.05371337756514549 ]
In this paper we give an explicit solution of Dzherbashyan-Caputo-fractional Cauchy problems related to equations with derivatives of order $\nu k$, for $k$ non-negative integer and $\nu>0$. The solution is obtained by connecting the differential equation with the roots of the characteristic polynomial and it is expressed in terms of Mittag-Leffler-type functions. Under the some stricter hypothesis the solution can be expressed as a linear combination of Mittag-Leffler functions with common fractional order $\nu$. We establish a probabilistic relationship between the solutions of differential problems with order $\nu/m$ and $\nu$, for natural $m$. Finally, we use the described method to solve fractional differential equations arising in the fractionalization of partial differential equations related to the probability law of planar random motions with finite velocities.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04988v1
[ -0.028996188193559647, -0.04101860150694847, 0.006511184386909008, -0.04604759067296982, 0.03869923949241638, -0.026932137086987495, -0.04634241387248039, -0.04031793773174286, -0.05507655069231987, -0.008079364895820618, -0.021856512874364853, -0.05274202302098274, -0.047363054007291794, -0.038142889738082886, -0.0504499115049839, 0.009568492881953716, 0.05796779692173004, 0.052739467471838, -0.005401052534580231, 0.060874298214912415, -0.023625653237104416, -0.06058900058269501, -0.046693842858076096, 0.06304852664470673, -0.01752239279448986, 0.0007548735593445599, -0.03374768793582916, -0.03182463347911835, -0.025172891095280647, -0.010264956392347813, 0.04679229483008385, 0.0028144612442702055, -0.025879712775349617, -0.04010508954524994, -0.007663495372980833, 0.0032034663017839193, 0.02793598175048828, 0.010704823769629002, 0.058583814650774, -0.02382429875433445, 0.005261048208922148, -0.02046751230955124, -0.03948676958680153, -0.02652730420231819, 0.002442979719489813, -0.022272754460573196, -0.03082716278731823, 0.005952471401542425, -0.004439385142177343, -0.07391530275344849, 0.015932967886328697, 0.011702625080943108, -0.03243592381477356, 0.008954290300607681, -0.06484749168157578, 0.021646685898303986, -0.02379346452653408, -0.02694053202867508, -0.020005855709314346, -0.01522518415004015, 0.014262710697948933, -0.02150195837020874, 0.017998680472373962, -0.027771487832069397, -0.01344969216734171, 0.015492163598537445, -0.046340443193912506, -0.04520072788000107, 0.019509857520461082, -0.04868703335523605, -0.04807782918214798, -0.05542459711432457, 0.03662046417593956, -0.02331557311117649, -0.06325781345367432, 0.017346950247883797, 0.004072657786309719, -0.005467716604471207, -0.010143949650228024, 0.020099271088838577, 0.03822227939963341, -0.006859273184090853, -0.01958337053656578, -0.0041443780064582825, 0.01902152970433235, -0.035276349633932114, 0.06928642094135284, -0.05806801840662956, -0.007697049528360367, -0.06583498418331146, 0.028921036049723625, -0.025521032512187958, -0.06745258718729019, -0.03827879577875137, 0.04755597561597824, -0.03330468758940697, 0.03384195268154144, 0.02982812188565731, 0.02779904194176197, -0.042788807302713394, 0.012653417885303497, -0.060628943145275116, -0.05773435905575752, 0.032882772386074066, 0.0340096540749073, -0.002133938716724515, -0.011354713700711727, 0.019112642854452133, -0.03106267750263214, -0.019816061481833458, -0.02208860218524933, 0.020219676196575165, -0.03517315909266472, -0.052881672978401184, -0.04909316077828407, -0.07002018392086029, 0.04079284518957138, 0.020256930962204933, 0.048099614679813385, -0.029901089146733284, -0.02895045280456543, 0.02005827985703945, 0.012174819596111774, -0.034786779433488846, -0.05538016930222511, -0.037204310297966, 0.05759584158658981, 0.01005671638995409, -0.003201198996976018, -0.05687571316957474, -0.0339512825012207, -0.023236721754074097, 0.019776977598667145, 0.0005824617692269385, 0.03316530957818031, -0.009226859547197819, -0.041559211909770966, -0.03214709088206291, 0.03984661027789116, 0.010860943235456944, -0.045828722417354584, -0.047543298453092575, 0.02768201008439064, -0.02099594846367836, -0.010688049718737602, 0.03747479245066643, -0.07026808708906174, 0.0005842478130944073, 0.0497676283121109, 0.011669832281768322, -0.04799908399581909, -0.0006727015133947134, 0.006576885003596544, 0.035229966044425964, 0.023314669728279114, 0.009323565289378166, 0.0466163344681263, 0.03568734973669052, -0.04768884927034378, 0.033639196306467056, 0.03545716777443886, 0.004765573889017105, -0.011706935241818428, 0.011296440847218037, 0.006098729558289051, 0.012687304057180882, 0.0053789857774972916, -0.003586644073948264, -0.01718348264694214, -0.02416645549237728, -0.05305439978837967, 0.030953766778111458, 0.028946232050657272, -0.06172742322087288, -0.03693684935569763, -0.013694231398403645, -0.0025991746224462986, -0.022804604843258858, -0.01383998617529869, -0.014992188662290573, -0.0050037335604429245, -0.029392898082733154, -0.012850497849285603, 0.024969609454274178, -0.054989274591207504, -0.003827537875622511, -0.06790094077587128, 0.04172564297914505, 0.03588094189763069, 0.05170125141739845, -0.007171797100454569, -0.044209349900484085, 0.02819686383008957, 0.003951956517994404, -0.04036625102162361, 0.008865504525601864, 0.00513490941375494, -0.008475604467093945, -0.055726565420627594, 0.05537017434835434, -0.06280066072940826, -0.03478927165269852, -0.036450352519750595, 0.032772500067949295, 0.008062547072768211, -0.0570463128387928, 0.0414796881377697, 0.06371695548295975, 0.005368642043322325, -0.05441914498806, 0.07572297751903534, 0.04009145125746727, 0.07016614824533463, -0.0027068976778537035, -0.0047467234544456005, -0.004709836561232805, -0.08573796600103378, 0.052204910665750504, -0.03826381266117096, -0.03362657129764557, 0.053131286054849625, -0.018667567521333694, -0.009247852489352226, -0.038088440895080566, -0.05240427702665329, 0.06698232889175415, 0.0015362472040578723, 0.0018546852516010404, -0.026948587968945503, -0.03862617164850235, 0.018719395622611046, -0.058679670095443726, -0.03963526338338852, -0.05492093414068222, 0.006353803910315037, -0.04194646328687668, -0.0255095474421978, 0.07217210531234741, -0.015594935975968838, -0.0384918674826622, -0.06718812137842178, 0.013771824538707733, 0.058693788945674896, -0.03125619515776634, -0.032960571348667145, -0.026102853938937187, -0.04274098202586174, -0.03185942396521568, -0.0674782544374466, 0.0048513105139136314, 0.02206173911690712, -0.04772231727838516, -0.06373149901628494, -0.03139917925000191, -0.021517999470233917, 0.029585853219032288, 0.009740752167999744, 0.009872240014374256, 0.02168598212301731, 0.0713721439242363, 0.0210042092949152, 0.019782669842243195, -0.015513872727751732, -0.022766640409827232, 0.03192437067627907, 0.041171617805957794, -0.004322596825659275, -0.017281940206885338, 0.016227226704359055, -0.00416382635012269, 0.03271230682730675, -0.01582663133740425, 0.019329706206917763, -0.005974447820335627, -0.014146185480058193, 0.009860488586127758, -0.0015328200533986092, -0.04671790450811386, 0.009100043214857578, -0.008857154287397861, 0.05523529276251793, 0.015662869438529015, 0.00282532861456275, -0.07104088366031647, 0.028867626562714577, -0.004839862696826458, -0.031370263546705246, -0.06360606104135513, -0.04229322075843811, -0.011932754889130592, -0.0757797434926033, -0.010175192728638649, -0.016581686213612556, -0.06131451949477196, -0.047074005007743835, -0.05399540811777115, -0.04863257333636284, -0.0040875449776649475, 0.009577726013958454, -0.05366253852844238, -0.07030538469552994, -0.0033665725495666265, -0.002221643691882491, 0.005031724460422993, 0.032308198511600494, -0.04529837891459465, -0.015160503797233105, 0.05245506018400192, -0.024074934422969818, 0.007644426543265581, -0.026406310498714447, -0.03137767314910889, -0.01640889048576355, 0.009910604916512966, 0.029434841126203537, 0.022596919909119606, 0.01595129258930683, -0.04449993744492531, 0.03381543606519699, -0.02441886067390442, -0.011577787809073925, -0.03174912929534912, 0.004373155068606138, -0.04914914816617966, -0.019005006179213524, -0.05546022951602936, 0.06094742566347122, 0.04930936172604561, 0.03877248987555504, -0.03844612464308739, -0.05898548290133476, 0.0014591753715649247, 0.03392629697918892, 0.0013473671860992908, 0.058860037475824356, 0.05766863375902176, -0.0474405363202095, -0.018688056617975235, -0.04204583913087845, -0.0034237783402204514, 0.021209467202425003, 0.018804285675287247, 0.05859312415122986, 0.021362964063882828, 0.01714874431490898, -0.08045458793640137, 0.018315594643354416, 0.06009877845644951, 0.030619489029049873, -0.042209990322589874, -0.03680881857872009, -0.02082834020256996, -0.012820376083254814, -0.02664894051849842, -0.01604606583714485, 0.04007555544376373, 0.0602143332362175, 0.033196255564689636, 0.01370916236191988, -0.0496140755712986, 0.003957380540668964, -0.05241401121020317, -0.007274279836565256, 0.0012912082020193338, 0.018573958426713943, 0.03983459249138832, 0.024573002010583878, 0.009527013637125492, 0.0033852725755423307, -0.00834971759468317, 0.015459085814654827, -0.04810350760817528, -0.024947842583060265, 0.005354408174753189, 0.038453321903944016, -0.042469654232263565, 0.007636622060090303, 0.03721000999212265, -0.006428300403058529, -0.034243203699588776, 0.01997029408812523, -0.0399651825428009, 0.010046012699604034, -0.009127572178840637, 0.016048124060034752, 0.06182289123535156, -0.008864864706993103, -0.042856182903051376, 0.031059520319104195, -0.05232753977179527, 0.020765619352459908, 0.032014258205890656, 0.03235006704926491, 0.00368372886441648, -0.011213693767786026, -0.06571435928344727, 0.0028449378442019224, -0.00887239258736372, -0.042181774973869324, -0.04597938060760498, 0.04179944470524788, 0.009645994752645493, -0.041461553424596786, -0.08347643166780472, -0.04038792848587036, -0.06567706167697906, 0.0006292876787483692, -0.00872126966714859, -0.0634823888540268, 0.05804332718253136, -0.003577441442757845, -0.009605812840163708, 0.0000330371294694487, -0.054659150540828705, -0.004393600393086672, -0.025474900379776955, -0.05604775249958038, -0.02224675379693508, 0.011165454983711243, -0.026714399456977844, 0.018745683133602142, 0.000959835248067975, -0.04210760071873665, -0.04633382707834244, 0.028607549145817757, 0.04405103996396065, 0.02590584009885788, 0.047376200556755066, 0.01748000830411911, 0.06756801158189774, -0.012526389211416245, -0.01347348839044571, -0.02871783822774887, -0.04744665324687958, -0.02754833735525608, -0.05799991264939308, 0.02906005084514618, -0.06019480153918266, 0.004330101888626814, -0.013447611592710018, 0.02024618536233902, 0.06692873686552048, -0.01622791402041912, -0.00594799779355526, 0.004807434976100922, 0.01626504398882389, -0.07257378101348877, -0.06050437316298485, -0.007443405222147703, 0.020525654777884483, -0.04343678429722786, 0.03478863090276718, 0.03477535396814346, -0.009318513795733452, 0.023921120911836624, 0.041816167533397675, -0.0133725106716156, 0.029721157625317574, -0.058503586798906326, -0.049247581511735916, 0.042105384171009064, 0.042456090450286865, -0.03933187574148178, -0.022990738973021507, -0.07278814911842346, 0.017653541639447212, -0.04343478009104729, -0.0044447495602071285, -0.021444229409098625, 0.07349981367588043, -0.014904799871146679, 0.027961572632193565, -0.07193683832883835, 0.0002140726282959804, 0.054424986243247986, -0.02299615368247032, -0.016005946323275566, -0.03947318717837334, -0.029767543077468872, -0.01350992452353239, -0.020437734201550484, -0.010155145078897476, 0.0033680403139442205, -0.0061309849843382835, -0.017136994749307632, -0.0013071181019768119, -0.0036249516997486353, -0.00707605853676796, 0.009133247658610344, -0.02566707693040371, -0.05494045838713646, -0.03684891760349274, -0.026025505736470222, 0.009074234403669834, -0.06381097435951233, 0.02574652060866356, 0.019765812903642654, -0.03705013915896416, -0.06963279098272324, -0.04962107911705971, 0.000013359459444473032, 0.04195615276694298, 0.028013287112116814, -0.05506221204996109, 0.010639571584761143, 0.040918271988630295, 0.0053179883398115635, -0.007233638782054186, 0.030019167810678482, 0.019832026213407516, -0.023352496325969696, -0.030333077535033226, -0.004052476957440376, -0.07143806666135788, -0.0024419864639639854, -0.0069917538203299046, 0.03342596814036369, 0.038051787763834, -0.022993603721261024, 0.05468999594449997, -0.0004883080837316811, 0.02931416593492031, -0.02684304118156433, 0.005457327701151371, -0.04967612400650978, 0.04265790432691574, -0.0052587068639695644, -0.015439827926456928, 0.018749605864286423, 0.04606745392084122, 0.0454297736287117, -0.03155340626835823, 0.0029061047825962305, -0.04087858647108078, -0.013340113684535027, -0.02876848354935646, 0.0008560285205021501, -0.03146681934595108, 0.0007087221601977944, 0.025875410065054893, 0.03575817495584488, -0.029394766315817833, 0.04540163278579712, -0.01687249355018139, 0.03328380361199379, 0.022397620603442192, -0.008235001005232334, 0.007507187779992819, -0.05677156150341034, -0.0062136901542544365, 0.06469652056694031, -0.04404764249920845, -0.0010972559684887528, -0.041321802884340286, -0.05732464790344238, -0.0218022670596838, -0.060391616076231, 0.02738218754529953, -0.006807809695601463, 0.020784124732017517, -0.03979150578379631, 0.048751942813396454, -0.005948282312601805, -0.07217765599489212, -0.020336462184786797, 0.060053031891584396, -0.05696849897503853, -0.0074754455126821995, 0.04423597455024719, -0.046531420201063156, -0.040162939578294754, 0.04122583195567131, -0.015094101428985596, -0.04581748694181442, -0.05544362589716911, 0.045462943613529205, 0.06820636987686157, -0.042142562568187714, 0.04819155111908913, 0.006197257433086634, -0.025280894711613655, 0.04115820303559303, -0.07403368502855301, 0.001509162480942905, -0.056745897978544235, 0.04873407259583473, -0.054272618144750595, -0.03990163654088974, -0.04728950932621956, 0.04376572370529175, -0.035999707877635956, 0.017491476610302925, 0.038625847548246384, 0.005819541402161121, 0.046442486345767975, -0.02168404497206211, -0.0019625360146164894, -0.018656853586435318, -0.006463999394327402, -0.027965862303972244, -0.02089923806488514, 0.01077726949006319, -0.04720323532819748, 0.01125321350991726, -0.02471012994647026, -0.04515349864959717, -0.005423038732260466, -0.015135470777750015, -0.06113090738654137, -0.02631996013224125, -0.06888406723737717, -0.008784053847193718, 0.011255459859967232, 0.04315175861120224, 0.0187887754291296, -0.013368033803999424, -0.025470243766903877, 0.019172264263033867, -0.030521433800458908, 0.018274517729878426, 0.0234422218054533, -0.0006189162377268076, -0.018551183864474297, -0.04054673761129379, 0.06931151449680328, -0.028104040771722794, 0.04938066005706787, -0.05842406302690506, -0.047556500881910324, 0.05035943537950516, 0.028882291167974472, -0.04723556712269783, 0.0033344929106533527, 0.007329682353883982, -0.008388906717300415, 0.010401741601526737, -0.008689369075000286, -0.009720723144710064, -0.04874653369188309, 0.02388591133058071, 0.010188115760684013, 0.01742827147245407, 0.026058729737997055, 0.01850779913365841, -0.021207960322499275, 0.018863363191485405, 0.03329186886548996, 0.0435698926448822, 0.007642701733857393, -0.02290535718202591, -0.06390376389026642, 0.015388697385787964, -0.01014420110732317, -0.03244829177856445, -0.035971786826848984, -0.011711165308952332, 0.027566062286496162, -0.0650128424167633, 0.03458426520228386, -0.04065632447600365, 0.05065196380019188, -0.032485321164131165, -0.07126957178115845, 0.06216975301504135, -0.003145193448290229, 0.014970211312174797, -0.07074496150016785, -0.0054285554215312, 0.040092721581459045, 0.0014536856906488538, 0.03520449623465538, 0.02946879342198372, -0.060056284070014954, 0.026265786960721016, -0.07275357097387314, -0.020784135907888412, -0.02705308608710766, 0.02703089267015457, 0.007859721779823303, -0.028816092759370804, -0.010574711486697197, -0.026594581082463264, -0.030593162402510643, -0.019025316461920738, 0.02388356812298298, 0.0381411574780941, 0.04524115473031998, 0.01571701280772686, -0.021815435960888863, 0.011429823003709316, 0.05615180358290672, -0.03311175853013992, 0.016318408772349358, 0.03953777998685837, 0.04520244151353836, -0.03217310085892677, -0.015995625406503677, 0.020032070577144623, -0.02998456172645092, 0.01077975146472454, -0.04794060066342354, -0.04066025838255882, -0.03652399405837059, -0.06572984158992767, 0.05001918599009514, -0.05212024599313736, 0.0005379227222874761, -0.014386269263923168, -0.0033445339649915695, -0.0561949722468853, 0.04063555225729942, -0.034797102212905884, 0.06411713361740112, 0.03648384287953377, -0.05087573453783989, 0.0078037879429757595, -0.04588940739631653, 0.024659626185894012, -0.021208636462688446, 0.011124235577881336, -0.01378935668617487, 0.04555036500096321, 0.024336114525794983, -0.025963328778743744, 0.008951525203883648, -0.049962934106588364, 0.046162139624357224, -0.022422101348638535, 0.010443251579999924, 0.057175178080797195, 0.05496874079108238, 0.005055608227849007, 0.05270727351307869, -0.01611269637942314, -0.031477026641368866, 0.044571761041879654, -0.0687934160232544, 0.023381197825074196, 0.007372363470494747, -0.01520028617233038, 0.03606791794300079, 0.05077836290001869, -0.0426957905292511, 0.07282664626836777, 0.010055523365736008, 0.04653434455394745, 0.026777179911732674, 0.00045758867054246366, -0.04981793835759163, 0.02038075029850006, -0.004301928915083408, -0.05767717957496643, -0.041215769946575165, 0.011013557203114033, 0.02656678669154644, 0.006420173682272434, 0.0044460175558924675, -0.03546522557735443, 0.031066853553056717, 0.005838125012814999, 0.010294509120285511, 0.03482678532600403, 0.05676443502306938, -0.012573926709592342, 0.044412754476070404, 0.002998713403940201, -0.030882522463798523, -0.04019899666309357 ]
3D perceptual representations are well suited for robot manipulation as they easily encode occlusions and simplify spatial reasoning. Many manipulation tasks require high spatial precision in end-effector pose prediction, which typically demands high-resolution 3D feature grids that are computationally expensive to process. As a result, most manipulation policies operate directly in 2D, foregoing 3D inductive biases. In this paper, we introduce Act3D, a manipulation policy transformer that represents the robot's workspace using a 3D feature field with adaptive resolutions dependent on the task at hand. The model lifts 2D pre-trained features to 3D using sensed depth, and attends to them to compute features for sampled 3D points. It samples 3D point grids in a coarse to fine manner, featurizes them using relative-position attention, and selects where to focus the next round of point sampling. In this way, it efficiently computes 3D action maps of high spatial resolution. Act3D sets a new state-of-the-art in RL-Bench, an established manipulation benchmark, where it achieves 10% absolute improvement over the previous SOTA 2D multi-view policy on 74 RLBench tasks and 22% absolute improvement with 3x less compute over the previous SOTA 3D policy. We quantify the importance of relative spatial attention, large-scale vision-language pre-trained 2D backbones, and weight tying across coarse-to-fine attentions in ablative experiments. Code and videos are available on our project website: https://act3d.github.io/.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17817v2
[ 0.003875250229611993, -0.02704228274524212, 0.04380897805094719, 0.0344061553478241, -0.02078389935195446, -0.01789996586740017, 0.007099615875631571, -0.022227700799703598, 0.021025309339165688, -0.040350016206502914, -0.023724332451820374, 0.013931983150541782, -0.017203286290168762, -0.004362959880381823, -0.0465855598449707, -0.004977841395884752, 0.06958268582820892, -0.023708388209342957, -0.06728130578994751, 0.06790495663881302, 0.03455216810107231, -0.017042409628629684, -0.010523783043026924, 0.0599643737077713, 0.009792458266019821, -0.006683923304080963, -0.06105697154998779, 0.038403186947107315, -0.0402250774204731, 0.0051719313487410545, 0.06657136231660843, -0.022137191146612167, -0.021293267607688904, -0.04545965790748596, -0.019166382029652596, 0.0039057459216564894, -0.020841823890805244, 0.020391082391142845, 0.04191869497299194, -0.05504676699638367, 0.038127586245536804, -0.02084791474044323, -0.06043359264731407, -0.01238909363746643, -0.04021664708852768, 0.0007395748398266733, -0.06650827080011368, 0.041286617517471313, -0.04245720058679581, -0.050676748156547546, 0.05067549645900726, -0.022899150848388672, 0.035628415644168854, 0.05575058236718178, -0.04980108514428139, 0.02492448128759861, 0.0034747293684631586, -0.002451784210279584, -0.06945279240608215, 0.025767941027879715, 0.00003357727837283164, -0.03312140330672264, -0.023979552090168, -0.0036370502784848213, 0.00723913311958313, 0.07720250636339188, -0.006165060214698315, -0.05910731852054596, -0.03847255930304527, -0.0483335517346859, 0.06165577471256256, -0.0627017468214035, 0.005022690165787935, 0.03730789199471474, -0.04897996038198471, -0.043362807482481, -0.01206876989454031, 0.0024371002800762653, 0.020232802256941795, -0.00841507688164711, -0.008833665400743484, 0.0036361769307404757, 0.03492231294512749, 0.06614569574594498, -0.0014393238816410303, -0.004149057902395725, 0.05016329139471054, 0.011898287571966648, 0.026313450187444687, -0.03143993020057678, 0.004382491577416658, -0.036023665219545364, -0.05034611374139786, 0.02940254844725132, 0.017671722918748856, -0.040449827909469604, 0.06430940330028534, 0.02473004162311554, 0.03530143201351166, 0.004875190556049347, -0.042491547763347626, 0.04707012325525284, 0.029468867927789688, -0.0011657836148515344, 0.04292064905166626, -0.019738689064979553, 0.02000313811004162, 0.01313089206814766, -0.038958217948675156, -0.03513845428824425, -0.059889230877161026, -0.022260691970586777, 0.052069664001464844, -0.03691055625677109, -0.05096123740077019, -0.024810345843434334, 0.031824227422475815, 0.004986213985830545, 0.030071765184402466, 0.028633641079068184, -0.04560587555170059, 0.0032686758786439896, 0.023946888744831085, -0.025927061215043068, -0.06038094311952591, -0.0535600371658802, 0.07637608051300049, -0.0014426587149500847, -0.032647646963596344, -0.03484899550676346, -0.012174512259662151, 0.0205826535820961, -0.04014468565583229, -0.0629369243979454, 0.05615943670272827, 0.02062903344631195, -0.017126034945249557, -0.0672537311911583, 0.0003829756169579923, -0.046486664563417435, -0.019046086817979813, -0.06457900255918503, 0.028757156804203987, -0.027790246531367302, -0.0003180800413247198, 0.06829580664634705, -0.027827272191643715, -0.05658102408051491, 0.008738105185329914, -0.02737075462937355, -0.02239079773426056, -0.030353669077157974, 0.02516116388142109, 0.04260123521089554, 0.022311439737677574, -0.016979003325104713, 0.06579262018203735, -0.006611948367208242, -0.046749915927648544, -0.031559064984321594, 0.028138229623436928, -0.03833996504545212, -0.009778969921171665, -0.01844899356365204, -0.003447294468060136, 0.002654528245329857, 0.06249690428376198, 0.023150766268372536, 0.013356050476431847, 0.02025347575545311, -0.020807338878512383, -0.04297558218240738, 0.004442370962351561, -0.017342394217848778, -0.05334952846169472, -0.013091595843434334, -0.007700310554355383, -0.06474191695451736, -0.05224695801734924, -0.02017032727599144, -0.00415591336786747, 0.01753268763422966, 0.008522932417690754, 0.0031308268662542105, -0.07804638147354126, -0.02301453799009323, -0.06302431225776672, -0.03962322697043419, 0.03461317718029022, 0.02601967193186283, -0.04007729887962341, -0.02456214651465416, 0.003146987408399582, 0.03169700875878334, -0.0569114089012146, -0.04572005942463875, -0.02701440267264843, -0.027822617441415787, 0.017673896625638008, -0.02183724194765091, -0.07930785417556763, -0.02296462655067444, -0.06206328421831131, 0.022470887750387192, -0.0032139127142727375, -0.0649629607796669, -0.003168275812640786, 0.06924984604120255, -0.04876457527279854, 0.035986002534627914, 0.03885308653116226, 0.04370106756687164, 0.06255247443914413, -0.03536653146147728, 0.045103900134563446, 0.026971161365509033, -0.0971241444349289, 0.03013404831290245, 0.0264706052839756, 0.019664710387587547, 0.026854651048779488, 0.03450482711195946, 0.01852905936539173, -0.027467329055070877, -0.024617543444037437, 0.06087827309966087, 0.06799066811800003, -0.008172926492989063, -0.06579314917325974, -0.03149356320500374, 0.0029988540336489677, -0.08302871137857437, -0.014205082319676876, -0.07607082277536392, -0.015808969736099243, -0.002850260818377137, -0.05966472998261452, 0.036500997841358185, 0.008727331645786762, 0.002038787119090557, -0.03996558114886284, -0.02048960141837597, 0.040838535875082016, -0.031142722815275192, -0.060001686215400696, -0.023056093603372574, -0.01707323081791401, 0.012158308178186417, -0.00848691537976265, -0.02678842283785343, -0.041830018162727356, -0.025809556245803833, -0.002526210155338049, -0.024314725771546364, 0.05636407807469368, 0.05507294833660126, -0.0026546295266598463, -0.00016297560068778694, -0.053048256784677505, 0.020319096744060516, 0.0337601937353611, -0.005446757655590773, -0.05444224923849106, 0.04018932953476906, 0.001647439319640398, -0.011358145624399185, 0.00911712646484375, -0.012046940624713898, 0.008091965690255165, -0.01848185807466507, -0.024510979652404785, 0.013630338944494724, 0.02541058324277401, 0.004734546411782503, -0.0010502354707568884, -0.015985118225216866, -0.029437853023409843, -0.014514007605612278, 0.05203741788864136, 0.023371966555714607, 0.028899218887090683, 0.03263532370328903, -0.01867007277905941, -0.061549343168735504, -0.013514835387468338, -0.0534527525305748, 0.03905004262924194, -0.07537122815847397, -0.06411271542310715, -0.031070362776517868, -0.04945778101682663, -0.051099956035614014, -0.054324641823768616, -0.01863173581659794, -0.013951355591416359, -0.0333939753472805, -0.03813689574599266, 0.05221891030669212, 0.040266841650009155, -0.013321381993591785, -0.021299652755260468, -0.01813650317490101, 0.029284872114658356, 0.04455947503447533, -0.04129507765173912, -0.045008886605501175, -0.029674215242266655, 0.02218174934387207, 0.01791662536561489, 0.007599970791488886, -0.02332613430917263, -0.0022254888899624348, -0.03557173162698746, 0.00535054225474596, 0.010427270084619522, 0.02735339105129242, 0.018596375361084938, 0.04195964336395264, -0.011806195601820946, 0.027518903836607933, 0.009033577516674995, 0.010447181761264801, 0.022672727704048157, -0.043275315314531326, -0.04285583645105362, -0.017461441457271576, 0.037505969405174255, 0.0364423543214798, -0.05267946794629097, -0.02251449227333069, 0.01392397377640009, 0.07071038335561752, 0.03577787056565285, 0.01132801454514265, 0.04494032636284828, 0.030742932111024857, 0.027752690017223358, -0.013925347477197647, -0.008071103133261204, 0.0202905535697937, -0.003817153163254261, -0.0072795553132891655, -0.0019737156108021736, 0.005695477593690157, 0.04697857424616814, -0.08921461552381516, 0.02601245604455471, 0.025099558755755424, 0.06887564063072205, -0.02039024792611599, 0.022536801174283028, -0.01477532833814621, 0.015238020569086075, 0.026275046169757843, -0.018168305978178978, 0.02856774628162384, 0.05269790068268776, 0.055341120809316635, -0.05494667589664459, -0.06859035789966583, -0.04518307372927666, -0.07718931883573532, -0.0247370433062315, -0.00925600714981556, -0.001428681891411543, -0.0015797123778611422, 0.03709452226758003, -0.06368263065814972, 0.00585216423496604, 0.009872384369373322, 0.017411252483725548, 0.009446326643228531, 0.0041554211638867855, 0.04427090659737587, -0.06598365306854248, -0.010376855731010437, -0.007242150139063597, 0.00030835563666187227, 0.02386939898133278, -0.018836520612239838, 0.0392201729118824, -0.04052148386836052, 0.0429016537964344, 0.005958857014775276, -0.0033723749220371246, 0.0026436801999807358, -0.004772794432938099, 0.013114096596837044, 0.040095794945955276, 0.0019966778345406055, -0.0009702141978777945, 0.0073967804200947285, 0.02918797917664051, -0.01654544100165367, -0.004651594907045364, -0.04643450304865837, -0.041092053055763245, -0.007812104187905788, -0.0345785915851593, -0.02460995689034462, -0.00335054867900908, -0.03553411364555359, -0.029139339923858643, -0.0698460265994072, 0.02541237138211727, -0.0379207544028759, 0.03475130721926689, -0.0010531391017138958, -0.046246666461229324, 0.0572257898747921, 0.0038419049233198166, 0.010618855245411396, -0.016883723437786102, -0.026620106771588326, -0.024646447971463203, -0.0592561699450016, -0.04072093591094017, -0.07511778175830841, 0.013169663958251476, -0.004830701742321253, 0.05290496349334717, -0.0035770994145423174, 0.02191879227757454, -0.04892021790146828, -0.0577707514166832, -0.009072599932551384, 0.044814642518758774, 0.03702523559331894, 0.017922451719641685, 0.0018361133988946676, -0.006486053578555584, 0.035013001412153244, -0.016034724190831184, 0.028246210888028145, -0.03494977578520775, -0.023671487346291542, 0.03721659258008003, -0.014110495336353779, 0.0015532512916252017, -0.010094688273966312, 0.01827063411474228, 0.023648742586374283, -0.03166678920388222, 0.0017553255893290043, 0.006318810395896435, 0.05908733978867531, -0.04885394871234894, -0.0487026609480381, -0.05253472179174423, -0.03353815898299217, -0.053794458508491516, 0.012423221953213215, 0.011577771976590157, 0.02180483378469944, 0.024502158164978027, -0.00803182739764452, 0.014605209231376648, -0.0227082259953022, -0.044857222586870193, 0.02150072529911995, 0.04734671115875244, -0.008525780402123928, 0.00801076553761959, -0.03457336127758026, -0.08384328335523605, 0.023028017953038216, -0.017364230006933212, -0.005938880145549774, 0.009600640274584293, -0.022149277850985527, -0.0015748164150863886, 0.016368748620152473, -0.0780724361538887, 0.02403390407562256, 0.04874870926141739, 0.013898424804210663, 0.019175216555595398, 0.052441634237766266, -0.037195418030023575, 0.03728760406374931, -0.009591084904968739, 0.02494242787361145, 0.048448219895362854, -0.034445907920598984, -0.02450225129723549, -0.036446698009967804, -0.01976955682039261, 0.04158893972635269, 0.038369644433259964, -0.029245149344205856, -0.07281633466482162, -0.034561119973659515, -0.003245441010221839, 0.008756812661886215, -0.024244405329227448, 0.029988335445523262, 0.04663784056901932, -0.030513180419802666, -0.010391688905656338, 0.015709197148680687, 0.011719610542058945, 0.016925068572163582, -0.022786222398281097, 0.0066040558740496635, -0.013900200836360455, 0.01011505164206028, -0.008552264422178268, -0.02419247478246689, 0.036063361912965775, -0.007749440148472786, -0.014932631514966488, 0.002577706938609481, -0.017398221418261528, -0.037420377135276794, -0.027337215840816498, -0.0018496497068554163, 0.0191962830722332, 0.045382607728242874, 0.04875514656305313, 0.035096414387226105, 0.03777388110756874, -0.005919154733419418, 0.008447312749922276, -0.03613905981183052, 0.0022391260135918856, 0.04441434517502785, -0.04629942402243614, 0.058625273406505585, -0.015818193554878235, 0.028365613892674446, -0.0009192772558890283, 0.04601270705461502, 0.05666182190179825, -0.020104264840483665, -0.051262106746435165, -0.0543208010494709, 0.03345823287963867, -0.034799885004758835, -0.043752625584602356, 0.014258324168622494, 0.04377676174044609, -0.0554446317255497, -0.0024270249996334314, 0.04595016688108444, 0.01147783175110817, 0.007693449035286903, 0.027239708229899406, 0.001870115171186626, -0.044311124831438065, 0.03214557096362114, 0.06393454223871231, -0.027059413492679596, -0.05204015597701073, 0.011076011694967747, -0.03177264332771301, -0.0046058883890509605, -0.04009279981255531, 0.04160049185156822, 0.01708102598786354, -0.00140845263376832, -0.05644789710640907, 0.04279815033078194, -0.009026650339365005, -0.05802358686923981, 0.04049732908606529, 0.03551342338323593, -0.0760960578918457, 0.017555255442857742, -0.009359187446534634, -0.014395726844668388, -0.037322934716939926, 0.06297354400157928, 0.015114999376237392, -0.013178792782127857, -0.04621298983693123, 0.052713893353939056, 0.07259856164455414, 0.001372820814140141, 0.008324049413204193, 0.0420096181333065, -0.05914601683616638, 0.02365165762603283, -0.051990631967782974, -0.009226592257618904, 0.02993897534906864, 0.015373599715530872, 0.035965029150247574, -0.034314319491386414, -0.048294615000486374, 0.026922980323433876, -0.0043602618388831615, -0.04254544526338577, 0.021886765956878662, 0.0017067505978047848, 0.03457591310143471, -0.014740981161594391, -0.05472017452120781, 0.04128280282020569, -0.04178706556558609, 0.018738150596618652, -0.04651203379034996, 0.033390287309885025, 0.02625242806971073, 0.030207106843590736, -0.0033360037487000227, -0.07914715260267258, -0.009739788249135017, -0.05996840447187424, -0.056420959532260895, 0.0221831277012825, -0.06138754263520241, 0.0023091561160981655, -0.019471922889351845, 0.0021557125728577375, 0.02701539546251297, 0.058623991906642914, -0.04205064848065376, -0.013092480599880219, -0.018777763471007347, 0.03091093711555004, -0.034586645662784576, -0.007860780693590641, 0.05257516726851463, -0.03967105224728584, 0.0502343624830246, -0.0019437519367784262, -0.028296932578086853, 0.0025512168649584055, -0.047193195670843124, 0.01824255846440792, -0.013604851439595222, -0.02765556052327156, -0.04014493525028229, -0.015723666176199913, -0.024479204788804054, 0.03907112404704094, -0.026170950382947922, -0.05176475644111633, -0.08104211837053299, -0.003466871799901128, -0.01532728411257267, 0.030232103541493416, 0.010791114531457424, 0.03185788914561272, 0.028764864429831505, -0.03629331663250923, 0.0006269078003242612, 0.020599761977791786, -0.01647806353867054, 0.041168805211782455, -0.06936803460121155, -0.015714745968580246, -0.005951927043497562, 0.0051148151978850365, -0.03437301889061928, -0.021420326083898544, -0.0060479724779725075, -0.05118759348988533, 0.05881347134709358, 0.039397936314344406, -0.02097097784280777, -0.05869804695248604, -0.04707198217511177, 0.007629778236150742, 0.016999876126646996, -0.0043623666279017925, -0.05198478326201439, -0.029941702261567116, 0.03178832307457924, -0.0327976755797863, -0.031146494671702385, -0.022698480635881424, -0.040394946932792664, 0.046735137701034546, -0.08927649259567261, 0.035197604447603226, -0.0013904544757679105, 0.030910659581422806, -0.0026289536617696285, -0.05046222358942032, -0.04077082499861717, -0.028050554916262627, -0.012175929732620716, -0.01905542053282261, -0.0017607134068384767, -0.02040715143084526, 0.047061316668987274, 0.016520392149686813, -0.07279655337333679, -0.03949667140841484, 0.044823646545410156, 0.016045520082116127, -0.001789136091247201, 0.013902074657380581, 0.05845256894826889, 0.039812568575143814, -0.02743883989751339, 0.05577561631798744, -0.028640417382121086, 0.058532651513814926, -0.05014670640230179, 0.0062384698539972305, -0.07067585736513138, -0.023338232189416885, 0.001662305323407054, -0.019202223047614098, 0.006746858358383179, -0.018604757264256477, 0.03473508730530739, 0.028386220335960388, -0.05504114180803299, -0.06919422000646591, 0.05113718658685684, -0.009344260208308697, -0.029558362439274788, 0.04149053990840912, -0.0421452522277832, -0.006464029662311077, -0.025064045563340187, -0.06271378695964813, -0.02172958478331566, 0.0007977769710123539, 0.039917297661304474, -0.03511330112814903, 0.048516932874917984, -0.043933555483818054, 0.002060488099232316, 0.013791361823678017, -0.0035961498506367207, -0.011162124574184418, 0.07051987200975418, -0.011619539931416512, -0.032731976360082626, -0.03579220175743103, -0.06644283980131149, -0.023887785151600838, -0.06389524787664413, 0.0014088534517213702, -0.02155732922255993, 0.04302987456321716, -0.040467049926519394, -0.010948478244245052, -0.006529045756906271, 0.04358591511845589, 0.025261882692575455, 0.014722678810358047, -0.009070777334272861, -0.020727613940835, -0.03270457684993744, 0.06741191446781158, -0.00851269718259573, -0.007290108595043421, -0.04359881579875946, -0.017384124919772148, -0.0031952233985066414, -0.015262134373188019, -0.0032719760201871395, -0.024331124499440193, 0.03181419521570206, -0.06448619067668915, -0.05030062794685364, 0.017581261694431305, 0.005055156536400318, -0.07997111231088638, -0.03765885531902313, -0.015685074031352997, -0.0244499109685421, -0.08112356066703796 ]
Earthquakes are produced by the propagation of rapid slip along tectonic faults. The propagation dynamics is governed by a balance between elastic stored energy in the surrounding rock, and dissipated energy at the propagating tip of the slipping patch. Energy dissipation is dictated by the mechanical behaviour of the fault, which is itself the result of feedbacks between thermo-hydro-mechanical processes acting at the mm to sub-mm scale. Here, we numerically simulate shear ruptures using a dual scale approach, allowing us to couple a sub-mm description of inner fault processes and km-scale elastodynamics, and show that the sudden localisation of shear strain within a shear zone leads to the emergence of classical cracks driven by a constant fracture energy. The fracture energy associated to strain localisation is substantially smaller than that predicted assuming uniform shearing. We show the existence of a unique scaling law between the localised shearing width and the rupture speed. Our results indicate that earthquakes are likely to be systematically associated to extreme strain localisation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16820v1
[ 0.013154545798897743, -0.03798689693212509, 0.01888152025640011, -0.020554328337311745, -0.004331629723310471, 0.02344982512295246, -0.02892550453543663, 0.026080235838890076, 0.03188757225871086, 0.008216067217290401, 0.02479536272585392, -0.051993176341056824, -0.04098138213157654, -0.06165587529540062, -0.04977099224925041, 0.014258768409490585, 0.0805748999118805, 0.014014285989105701, -0.05359826236963272, 0.0785261020064354, 0.02826906181871891, 0.03528418764472008, -0.0009136451408267021, 0.06875243037939072, 0.0017607673071324825, -0.06427452713251114, -0.06989721208810806, 0.03208620101213455, -0.032771892845630646, 0.016886727884411812, 0.06168324872851372, -0.03644421696662903, -0.0008315708837471902, -0.02501259371638298, -0.006612944882363081, 0.020287899300456047, -0.0018441096181049943, 0.03222082927823067, 0.037788040935993195, 0.0009460683213546872, -0.0010569366859272122, -0.022076968103647232, -0.03870759531855583, 0.005365061108022928, -0.040507953613996506, 0.0073663173243403435, -0.010766110382974148, 0.02354654110968113, -0.04014580324292183, -0.04304024204611778, 0.05049751698970795, 0.0212138369679451, 0.010784314014017582, 0.074284628033638, -0.017311887815594673, -0.026601368561387062, -0.010528506711125374, -0.03656601905822754, -0.0011633712565526366, -0.022863851860165596, -0.04002421349287033, -0.027064315974712372, -0.022463086992502213, -0.022039487957954407, -0.01484040729701519, 0.025796206668019295, 0.003090987680479884, -0.07186783105134964, -0.02855074591934681, -0.06576204299926758, 0.05004386231303215, -0.06742436438798904, 0.03458097577095032, -0.023374859243631363, -0.06459599733352661, 0.021783903241157532, -0.017097333446145058, -0.010235839523375034, 0.004664706531912088, 0.002768018050119281, -0.04291840270161629, 0.032957468181848526, 0.01754673756659031, 0.03318445011973381, 0.036017633974552155, 0.0045042261481285095, 0.06642584502696991, -0.04677300527691841, 0.01691036857664585, -0.034971464425325394, 0.0214407816529274, -0.033261436969041824, -0.02091740444302559, -0.0672706812620163, 0.06668578833341599, -0.03299403563141823, 0.0751040130853653, -0.005839751102030277, 0.060417965054512024, -0.03713657334446907, -0.03277059644460678, -0.07765312492847443, -0.03821733221411705, 0.04485639929771423, -0.010355628095567226, -0.03927610069513321, -0.001863234443590045, -0.0003885241167154163, -0.034513235092163086, 0.05106005072593689, -0.0461142361164093, 0.03557206317782402, -0.007068966515362263, -0.023431021720170975, -0.07120633870363235, -0.014713872224092484, 0.0474088229238987, 0.03256796672940254, 0.013116754591464996, -0.025397052988409996, -0.0634908527135849, 0.036147892475128174, -0.015612109564244747, 0.03861505910754204, 0.0021262054797261953, 0.03184971213340759, 0.06600214540958405, 0.015610701404511929, 0.03374418243765831, -0.027318548411130905, -0.0549137257039547, 0.0037420305889099836, 0.0525185652077198, -0.037552978843450546, 0.006722087971866131, 0.004096668213605881, 0.046441297978162766, 0.039126232266426086, 0.04458963871002197, 0.05859561264514923, -0.04149381071329117, -0.020426079630851746, 0.01654651015996933, 0.033308081328868866, -0.016314806416630745, -0.01607443206012249, -0.0702405720949173, -0.027660975232720375, 0.03898575156927109, -0.011844437569379807, 0.01776668056845665, -0.022599782794713974, 0.025283208116889, 0.020968927070498466, 0.04167475178837776, -0.009281175211071968, 0.04795093461871147, 0.02179555408656597, -0.023869289085268974, 0.010432702489197254, -0.004349213559180498, -0.035724662244319916, 0.023331355303525925, 0.01315243262797594, 0.027584772557020187, 0.014697438105940819, 0.04998809099197388, -0.01639534719288349, -0.02130037173628807, -0.010178657248616219, -0.003971640020608902, 0.05496615171432495, 0.003961529117077589, -0.0563654825091362, -0.02907189354300499, -0.02244901843369007, 0.002200859598815441, -0.04760860651731491, 0.024947280064225197, 0.010626787319779396, 0.04186621308326721, -0.020637858659029007, -0.061495341360569, -0.029776079580187798, -0.04079832136631012, -0.04555384814739227, -0.08750610053539276, 0.015455964021384716, 0.0027208193205296993, 0.023414216935634613, -0.020944099873304367, -0.04564123600721359, 0.022127211093902588, -0.0009641273645684123, -0.016553016379475594, -0.023969711735844612, 0.037632204592227936, -0.03192015737295151, 0.00242628320120275, 0.046229515224695206, -0.06737902015447617, 0.004945061169564724, -0.025328820571303368, -0.001051835948601365, -0.0025161111261695623, -0.06507515162229538, 0.020153995603322983, 0.029267311096191406, -0.04225577414035797, -0.036411039531230927, 0.06262925267219543, 0.02556171827018261, 0.045453030616045, -0.030548183247447014, -0.04601912945508957, -0.012639130465686321, -0.09462081640958786, -0.037285562604665756, -0.007875044830143452, 0.016716500744223595, 0.030206987634301186, -0.003251017304137349, -0.02136509120464325, -0.05357390642166138, -0.03925171121954918, 0.028104955330491066, 0.06891465932130814, -0.009601552039384842, -0.02468053251504898, -0.002884054323658347, -0.05023948475718498, -0.05718008056282997, -0.05456698685884476, -0.06589547544717789, -0.03369753062725067, -0.0061540971510112286, -0.05747317522764206, 0.049142174422740936, -0.04688816890120506, -0.06705143302679062, -0.041493069380521774, -0.028501369059085846, 0.02314976043999195, -0.003915103618055582, -0.0183635912835598, -0.04030314087867737, -0.05345834046602249, 0.06269396096467972, -0.06197286769747734, -0.021461499854922295, -0.03725878894329071, -0.04829774424433708, -0.014451314695179462, -0.014839001931250095, 0.019317321479320526, 0.046356067061424255, -0.010256522335112095, 0.012670619413256645, 0.03548916429281235, 0.040572721511125565, -0.013651778921484947, -0.0004723231540992856, -0.07050423324108124, 0.023281877860426903, 0.0005541126010939479, 0.02378770522773266, -0.03573521599173546, 0.00726941367611289, 0.034348152577877045, -0.048509154468774796, 0.048301633447408676, -0.016553709283471107, 0.057878777384757996, 0.00459032179787755, -0.0063986401073634624, 0.012748188339173794, -0.03323280066251755, -0.05790647864341736, -0.005724051967263222, 0.010513820685446262, 0.06452975422143936, -0.006081493105739355, -0.024410169571638107, -0.05010626092553139, 0.016875283792614937, -0.02422720566391945, -0.014600810594856739, -0.05964815989136696, -0.0159094650298357, 0.018703244626522064, -0.06352601200342178, -0.027900321409106255, -0.03342341631650925, 0.028734557330608368, -0.03880957514047623, -0.03976379334926605, -0.022944923490285873, -0.018485937267541885, 0.016014564782381058, -0.045261483639478683, -0.03795839473605156, -0.0021240117494016886, 0.05492468178272247, 0.017244843766093254, -0.03522834926843643, -0.015445229597389698, -0.04905317351222038, -0.030215883627533913, 0.03816499188542366, -0.008530279621481895, -0.04833575710654259, -0.0010203762212768197, -0.024128759279847145, 0.029909417033195496, -0.029193174093961716, 0.010885929688811302, 0.01738339103758335, -0.06177479401230812, -0.0156412310898304, -0.04565638676285744, -0.0064973728731274605, -0.04857996478676796, 0.008250612765550613, -0.009574713185429573, -0.04049031808972359, -0.05639881640672684, 0.04760167747735977, 0.013051570393145084, -0.0332857184112072, -0.059374988079071045, -0.05010424554347992, 0.01831885799765587, 0.004743492696434259, 0.03009050153195858, 0.06251571327447891, 0.05652537941932678, -0.05489914119243622, -0.00896407850086689, -0.05916241556406021, 0.0671735405921936, -0.009289798326790333, 0.037203267216682434, 0.014160659164190292, 0.0519552081823349, 0.011447719298303127, -0.05837574973702431, -0.01802928000688553, 0.06814905256032944, 0.019427908584475517, -0.005465863272547722, 0.03727167472243309, 0.004382368177175522, -0.0017692969413474202, 0.052290838211774826, 0.02358792908489704, -0.007455506827682257, 0.02270391955971718, 0.06763175874948502, -0.034254781901836395, 0.0064725447446107864, 0.011374152265489101, -0.05638611316680908, -0.03201649710536003, -0.00855745654553175, -0.016256103292107582, 0.043062079697847366, 0.06249562278389931, 0.02065560407936573, 0.02744406834244728, -0.01840311475098133, 0.03795851394534111, -0.020150762051343918, -0.051935821771621704, 0.026857808232307434, 0.014859767630696297, 0.020788855850696564, -0.033031899482011795, 0.0032992635387927294, -0.02438058704137802, -0.061523839831352234, 0.007855785079300404, -0.03278447315096855, -0.018497206270694733, 0.04282047227025032, -0.003180128987878561, 0.06249263882637024, 0.005621486343443394, -0.02700510248541832, 0.05037495493888855, 0.00472745718434453, -0.030807621777057648, -0.06351757794618607, -0.04366419464349747, 0.023885073140263557, 0.032897017896175385, -0.03192561864852905, -0.009227815084159374, 0.05054711177945137, -0.02774122729897499, 0.021980788558721542, 0.030770232900977135, 0.010057730600237846, -0.008968289941549301, -0.07364413142204285, -0.002126071136444807, -0.06518600881099701, 0.04604019224643707, 0.017027584835886955, -0.0077495272271335125, 0.060830678790807724, -0.009230335243046284, -0.020072147250175476, -0.02098090574145317, -0.020416004583239555, -0.027524832636117935, -0.004661367274820805, 0.002666613319888711, -0.013031627982854843, 0.056566573679447174, -0.06135716661810875, 0.011516084894537926, -0.026180949062108994, 0.05478571727871895, -0.023496998474001884, 0.03308456018567085, -0.03446931764483452, 0.029028046876192093, 0.04736531525850296, 0.029543843120336533, -0.025026055052876472, -0.006817396730184555, -0.029167408123612404, -0.0009429409983567894, 0.03213139995932579, 0.009013151749968529, -0.02599499374628067, -0.04341627657413483, -0.0741383507847786, -0.06306770443916321, -0.009607376530766487, 0.009065771475434303, 0.0465812087059021, -0.05273624509572983, -0.037360575050115585, 0.029013419523835182, 0.019836926832795143, -0.05520543083548546, -0.05978163331747055, -0.04574861750006676, -0.04825421795248985, -0.05480319261550903, -0.0015677388291805983, -0.03525996580719948, 0.03173435479402542, 0.00018782484403345734, 0.0684308335185051, -0.01135806180536747, 0.028220733627676964, -0.002921996871009469, 0.022465376183390617, 0.01911647617816925, 0.04293916001915932, -0.03550261631608009, -0.057117361575365067, -0.04903864115476608, 0.027454473078250885, 0.01843903586268425, -0.01725205034017563, -0.012356934137642384, 0.058046214282512665, -0.01264078076928854, -0.002961209509521723, -0.05479958653450012, 0.05171168968081474, 0.022144246846437454, -0.04497833922505379, 0.014812065288424492, 0.004597259219735861, -0.05055340379476547, 0.03251035138964653, 0.002262268215417862, 0.009349741972982883, -0.028009608387947083, -0.004910722374916077, 0.0023729961831122637, -0.008414904586970806, -0.04851743206381798, -0.02007029764354229, 0.03913088142871857, -0.007362936623394489, -0.07279632240533829, 0.009408186189830303, -0.027625609189271927, -0.014063320122659206, -0.03092803619801998, 0.02485731989145279, 0.031473707407712936, -0.04485972225666046, -0.05256190150976181, -0.002327072201296687, 0.009104958735406399, -0.00008922121196519583, 0.04950758069753647, -0.08000823855400085, 0.017263444140553474, 0.021065201610326767, 0.013120964169502258, -0.0010915887542068958, 0.01325615867972374, 0.02626165561378002, -0.05182858556509018, 0.008473897352814674, 0.04023861512541771, -0.08437839150428772, -0.02151162177324295, -0.04481545835733414, 0.03170539438724518, -0.03568947687745094, 0.01031068991869688, 0.03904090076684952, 0.04163253307342529, -0.016796013340353966, -0.060714028775691986, -0.0009117622394114733, -0.022740967571735382, 0.016370641067624092, -0.06240427866578102, 0.006946297828108072, 0.010423868894577026, 0.03453868255019188, 0.008313781581819057, -0.03580903261899948, -0.034159835427999496, -0.04690321907401085, -0.026208586990833282, -0.0264772716909647, 0.05196725204586983, -0.016182931140065193, -0.04473339393734932, 0.006138418801128864, 0.037474241107702255, -0.04062649980187416, 0.06122572347521782, 0.026165183633565903, -0.018667876720428467, -0.0169678907841444, -0.06142845004796982, 0.027300860732793808, -0.03402610868215561, -0.0001758271682774648, 0.06921078264713287, -0.034629691392183304, -0.03181294724345207, 0.017178254202008247, -0.011626734398305416, -0.036353446543216705, -0.026912810280919075, 0.020307401195168495, 0.00006874352402519435, -0.024103831499814987, -0.05431019887328148, 0.056813016533851624, -0.021067911759018898, -0.08376504480838776, -0.006758588831871748, 0.034146998077631, -0.06694832444190979, 0.002181953052058816, 0.010928685776889324, -0.032180774956941605, -0.059695832431316376, -0.0017762146890163422, -0.042437005788087845, -0.01821911893785, -0.06246434897184372, 0.015416104346513748, 0.04227301478385925, -0.04266830533742905, -0.03055366314947605, 0.010355610400438309, -0.050310809165239334, -0.0002956005046144128, -0.02174338512122631, 0.004525047726929188, -0.03998623043298721, 0.009260734543204308, -0.01524330023676157, -0.01790277473628521, -0.0034634771291166544, 0.06427332758903503, -0.014408508315682411, -0.000021955231204628944, 0.011511911638081074, 0.0162615068256855, 0.04870309308171272, -0.03599482774734497, -0.04082813858985901, 0.018881844356656075, 0.0193116944283247, -0.011389823630452156, 0.0034419256262481213, -0.020250236615538597, 0.001890493673272431, 0.04362823814153671, -0.0067006973549723625, -0.05273370444774628, 0.059709347784519196, 0.029024340212345123, -0.04492231085896492, 0.03981853649020195, -0.030046649277210236, 0.012334662489593029, 0.005713231861591339, 0.04915749281644821, -0.029096044600009918, 0.027726510539650917, -0.05912119522690773, 0.04232814162969589, -0.023757388815283775, 0.037491194903850555, -0.00031757683609612286, -0.04617255926132202, 0.018036406487226486, -0.01505433302372694, 0.07328471541404724, -0.023476453498005867, -0.01592579483985901, -0.03690434992313385, -0.006210478022694588, 0.04429774731397629, -0.024314086884260178, -0.02854442410171032, 0.006262886803597212, 0.0033803666010499, -0.03657347336411476, 0.022026007995009422, 0.028648365288972855, -0.05780484899878502, -0.0483521893620491, 0.0412476621568203, 0.0019396392162889242, -0.024548549205064774, 0.02812277525663376, -0.007692655082792044, -0.016565950587391853, -0.016013238579034805, 0.029277697205543518, 0.051910314708948135, -0.014363744296133518, -0.018491432070732117, -0.07978260517120361, -0.019315289333462715, -0.008846928365528584, 0.005340901669114828, -0.02526092529296875, -0.0037775200325995684, -0.045968495309352875, -0.0663684606552124, 0.008961254730820656, 0.004939622711390257, 0.02375936321914196, -0.022076327353715897, -0.055083297193050385, 0.04640548676252365, 0.026119308546185493, -0.010975474491715431, -0.07743262499570847, 0.013008271344006062, -0.026395244523882866, 0.027128906920552254, 0.008212014101445675, 0.030596313998103142, -0.07164590060710907, 0.019811291247606277, -0.07597102224826813, -0.0031871413812041283, -0.03087354637682438, 0.07323965430259705, 0.03441082313656807, 0.0019188168225809932, -0.026744185015559196, -0.020263755694031715, 0.03683477267622948, 0.03471590206027031, 0.020522650331258774, 0.01695655845105648, 0.03273819014430046, -0.00864365417510271, -0.034896694123744965, -0.008345186710357666, 0.05903979763388634, -0.00853615254163742, 0.03364693745970726, 0.04983682557940483, 0.017265427857637405, -0.011052653193473816, 0.02813047543168068, 0.007322248537093401, 0.0002359921927563846, 0.023760894313454628, -0.028786664828658104, -0.012715627439320087, -0.0564255565404892, -0.02983921207487583, 0.015499391593039036, -0.043557990342378616, 0.0185252632945776, 0.01905120722949505, -0.01457044668495655, -0.007984164170920849, -0.025653941556811333, -0.04439163953065872, 0.02649298869073391, 0.033752840012311935, 0.016457555815577507, 0.05763215571641922, -0.047752536833286285, 0.019359422847628593, -0.014105970971286297, -0.014778743498027325, -0.030076319351792336, 0.027939725667238235, -0.014195509254932404, -0.04454721882939339, 0.020317111164331436, -0.06049932911992073, 0.035735007375478745, -0.014760302379727364, 0.033364713191986084, 0.007611768785864115, 0.020560389384627342, -0.037817057222127914, -0.002862202236428857, -0.05986229330301285, -0.05603894218802452, 0.019642120227217674, -0.029641438275575638, 0.0031069444958120584, -0.006752570625394583, -0.02350030280649662, 0.02922840602695942, 0.07212302833795547, -0.002803524024784565, 0.05000143498182297, 0.032759133726358414, 0.04673471301794052, -0.059646449983119965, -0.0148226423189044, -0.059992559254169464, 0.04400147125124931, 0.0180797316133976, -0.023367391899228096, -0.05182992294430733, 0.0033937639091163874, -0.01575419493019581, 0.016758259385824203, -0.015199913643300533, -0.03503119945526123, -0.038273587822914124, -0.06635382771492004, -0.014262866228818893, 0.014170673675835133, 0.04517359659075737, -0.023464052006602287, 0.04292198270559311, 0.0045479536056518555, -0.014623625203967094, -0.06318213045597076 ]
In this paper, we present a novel method to automatically classify medical images that learns and leverages weak causal signals in the image. Our framework consists of a convolutional neural network backbone and a causality-extractor module that extracts cause-effect relationships between feature maps that can inform the model on the appearance of a feature in one place of the image, given the presence of another feature within some other place of the image. To evaluate the effectiveness of our approach in low-data scenarios, we train our causality-driven architecture in a One-shot learning scheme, where we propose a new meta-learning procedure entailing meta-training and meta-testing tasks that are designed using related classes but at different levels of granularity. We conduct binary and multi-class classification experiments on a publicly available dataset of prostate MRI images. To validate the effectiveness of the proposed causality-driven module, we perform an ablation study and conduct qualitative assessments using class activation maps to highlight regions strongly influencing the network's decision-making process. Our findings show that causal relationships among features play a crucial role in enhancing the model's ability to discern relevant information and yielding more reliable and interpretable predictions. This would make it a promising approach for medical image classification tasks.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10725v1
[ 0.003558684140443802, 0.002767786383628845, 0.05971124768257141, 0.0014096017694100738, 0.0008762189536355436, 0.011007427237927914, -0.02152777463197708, -0.01812177523970604, 0.02755121700465679, -0.051020607352256775, -0.040312156081199646, -0.03362356498837471, -0.03371996060013771, -0.061685845255851746, -0.020291641354560852, 0.03933196887373924, 0.06977318227291107, 0.03679796680808067, -0.048012200742959976, 0.07431741058826447, 0.011556901969015598, -0.05612872913479805, -0.05593133717775345, 0.043441809713840485, 0.04669951647520065, -0.030112048611044884, -0.042252082377672195, -0.014005820266902447, -0.03162781149148941, 0.009395093657076359, 0.04750203713774681, -0.041426099836826324, -0.04339917376637459, -0.04785546660423279, -0.024341419339179993, -0.03275430575013161, 0.015216167084872723, 0.03262687101960182, 0.013209172524511814, -0.03674546256661415, 0.046550214290618896, -0.02511981502175331, -0.064548060297966, -0.007962225936353207, -0.05062191188335419, 0.0010680198902264237, -0.04097278043627739, 0.004089383874088526, -0.0810748040676117, -0.029206329956650734, -0.004661227110773325, -0.00878812000155449, 0.02864898182451725, 0.05316494405269623, -0.05499764531850815, -0.007159812841564417, -0.023678412660956383, 0.03856939077377319, -0.0736483484506607, 0.02403024025261402, 0.04112516716122627, -0.027004938572645187, -0.016603464260697365, -0.02261107973754406, 0.03412285074591637, 0.03771187365055084, -0.004349830094724894, -0.07332351803779602, -0.039907779544591904, -0.047386039048433304, 0.06547003239393234, -0.06075504422187805, 0.028196176514029503, -0.0001683331502135843, -0.04284672439098358, -0.024292590096592903, -0.029721034690737724, -0.014898811466991901, -0.0018065939657390118, 0.02533998154103756, -0.006543904542922974, 0.04909128323197365, 0.03527430444955826, 0.058797672390937805, -0.01556573435664177, -0.009682667441666126, 0.07420503348112106, -0.01988399773836136, 0.004643321502953768, -0.03487883508205414, 0.02680753916501999, -0.016493748873472214, -0.05826384574174881, 0.0010574843036010861, 0.04937232285737991, -0.01843045838177204, 0.04270852729678154, 0.03367830067873001, 0.03203975036740303, 0.0016128415009006858, -0.038743436336517334, 0.004383509047329426, 0.03254357725381851, 0.05723241716623306, 0.03925786539912224, -0.047918420284986496, -0.010917188599705696, 0.005688392091542482, -0.04825403541326523, -0.011755329556763172, -0.03214583173394203, -0.03626677021384239, -0.0024891290813684464, -0.0717696100473404, -0.0633087083697319, -0.002494318410754204, 0.02658010646700859, 0.03180200606584549, 0.019112883135676384, 0.016796093434095383, -0.036125194281339645, 0.029348978772759438, -0.023647218942642212, -0.05405034124851227, -0.05380408465862274, -0.01709362305700779, 0.06511646509170532, 0.05142202600836754, -0.04871027171611786, -0.03707025572657585, -0.041077714413404465, 0.01265657227486372, -0.032176319509744644, -0.032502200454473495, 0.027794193476438522, -0.044281862676143646, -0.024114256724715233, -0.06659972667694092, 0.03353327140212059, 0.009947394952178001, -0.01853998936712742, -0.04937289282679558, 0.024272946640849113, -0.025784501805901527, -0.0034484316129237413, 0.044619180262088776, -0.041403114795684814, -0.027541832998394966, 0.04506721347570419, 0.029030466452240944, -0.011227325536310673, 0.0020264543127268553, 0.025096479803323746, 0.03815393149852753, 0.015785641968250275, -0.035902414470911026, 0.0483219176530838, -0.04168282449245453, -0.05310925468802452, 0.0027106767520308495, -0.0077634528279304504, -0.024953989312052727, 0.01805642433464527, -0.05557605251669884, -0.002912903903052211, -0.018210656940937042, 0.03359542042016983, 0.015960825607180595, -0.010578448884189129, -0.020014476031064987, -0.02057678997516632, 0.018051572144031525, 0.016912981867790222, -0.024877311661839485, -0.06749475002288818, -0.006533621810376644, -0.010008364915847778, -0.042503148317337036, -0.05122186988592148, -0.011852353811264038, 0.019644470885396004, -0.009549668990075588, -0.013441180810332298, 0.006784066092222929, -0.019913922995328903, -0.0025803796015679836, -0.0860535204410553, -0.03918498009443283, 0.04018590226769447, 0.0030697989277541637, -0.02916031703352928, -0.046109434217214584, 0.04255736619234085, 0.02681773155927658, -0.03351961821317673, -0.012918657623231411, -0.014694534242153168, 0.030037088319659233, 0.0062263901345431805, 0.032177384942770004, -0.07471013814210892, -0.024799365550279617, -0.06075390428304672, -0.005573119502514601, -0.023741064593195915, -0.07262642681598663, 0.019296254962682724, -0.004565182141959667, -0.03412865102291107, -0.03198198601603508, 0.057867631316185, 0.06209777668118477, 0.06739598512649536, 0.01762554608285427, 0.029472174122929573, 0.012545122765004635, -0.09295044094324112, 0.029895110055804253, 0.01157288160175085, 0.023722805082798004, 0.04633478820323944, -0.00012293852341827005, 0.023328250274062157, -0.05806120112538338, -0.003104775445535779, 0.0364542156457901, 0.059587229043245316, 0.00699821999296546, -0.04062577709555626, -0.028929803520441055, -0.04916340857744217, -0.0738479346036911, -0.03706630691885948, -0.07550957053899765, 0.006674512755125761, -0.017495127394795418, -0.053626708686351776, 0.03863285481929779, 0.015431364998221397, -0.054955944418907166, -0.028066569939255714, -0.04027378186583519, 0.05628766492009163, -0.0314306765794754, -0.030749795958399773, -0.046122558414936066, -0.01263689249753952, 0.039626121520996094, -0.017458105459809303, 0.028072500601410866, -0.028460074216127396, -0.048675328493118286, -0.009368783794343472, -0.020394233986735344, 0.050986744463443756, 0.023343736305832863, 0.003294644644483924, 0.01516674179583788, -0.04265933483839035, 0.05614813044667244, 0.04419628158211708, 0.04885933920741081, -0.06609489768743515, 0.0199220459908247, 0.030209017917513847, 0.030100194737315178, -0.0010266021126881242, -0.035789571702480316, 0.052818771451711655, -0.05157973989844322, 0.02345861867070198, 0.02368736080825329, 0.04291386902332306, -0.0293028075248003, -0.01670372113585472, -0.0162780974060297, -0.008426982909440994, -0.0429069958627224, 0.018058469519019127, 0.03335683420300484, 0.053532954305410385, 0.03310352936387062, -0.005480299703776836, -0.05543459206819534, -0.0010376503923907876, -0.06275247782468796, -0.004768972750753164, -0.06505578011274338, -0.028543097898364067, -0.046546850353479385, -0.07400359958410263, -0.0070285070687532425, -0.03100043162703514, -0.04849785566329956, -0.021256251260638237, -0.05127657204866409, -0.03881463035941124, -0.009962940588593483, 0.03716963902115822, -0.01641690358519554, -0.04850812256336212, -0.04820743203163147, 0.03620336949825287, 0.03187079727649689, -0.0019739456474781036, -0.07134297490119934, -0.01997305266559124, -0.006814850959926844, 0.024681977927684784, -0.03521294891834259, -0.006075240671634674, 0.0370631217956543, -0.028686070814728737, 0.02908545732498169, -0.04622010514140129, 0.02461172081530094, 0.010336781851947308, -0.015170524828135967, 0.0016242373967543244, -0.018366558477282524, 0.031151389703154564, -0.00042712088907137513, 0.01598978415131569, -0.055509310215711594, -0.053556665778160095, 0.012429696507751942, 0.0696030929684639, 0.014170506969094276, -0.05642116069793701, -0.03324543684720993, 0.019990449771285057, 0.00046821427531540394, 0.023028511554002762, -0.011274316348135471, 0.039861422032117844, 0.02740461565554142, -0.04216036573052406, -0.015795564278960228, -0.013472164049744606, 0.013037831522524357, -0.009677868336439133, 0.01572924479842186, -0.05961597338318825, 0.001164351007901132, 0.038523897528648376, -0.08741144835948944, -0.019115978851914406, 0.02823682315647602, 0.07729768753051758, -0.008933426812291145, 0.03317469730973244, 0.024479832500219345, 0.005597427953034639, -0.015406839549541473, 0.0065493518486619, 0.02488192357122898, 0.013068567030131817, 0.04691646248102188, -0.028712376952171326, -0.0331924743950367, -0.02060122974216938, -0.056921057403087616, -0.05620604008436203, -0.0014996672980487347, 0.05636817589402199, 0.015230602584779263, 0.03386338800191879, -0.07253521680831909, 0.027927882969379425, -0.004895919933915138, 0.05019533261656761, 0.006299667526036501, -0.011375980451703072, 0.03190377727150917, -0.03135596215724945, 0.024101288989186287, 0.020129313692450523, 0.018391042947769165, -0.04321575164794922, -0.060127705335617065, 0.02474326081573963, -0.0635836198925972, 0.03996072709560394, 0.03146751597523689, 0.0015442753210663795, 0.056166600435972214, 0.04230174422264099, -0.03468439728021622, 0.020032085478305817, -0.025578321889042854, -0.00034403835888952017, -0.033218175172805786, 0.025967923924326897, -0.0002773847372736782, 0.002874539000913501, -0.07899145036935806, -0.019512848928570747, -0.0004349235678091645, -0.022727424278855324, 0.0007044633384793997, 0.005332505330443382, 0.001658393070101738, -0.03546144440770149, -0.0844065472483635, 0.003614427987486124, -0.011999813839793205, 0.0353836715221405, 0.018962843343615532, -0.03350891172885895, 0.05995064228773117, -0.050794556736946106, -0.020045464858412743, -0.03873463720083237, -0.005714243743568659, -0.02407832071185112, -0.03929159790277481, -0.01305971760302782, -0.06299260258674622, 0.008890574797987938, -0.05269395560026169, 0.026183107867836952, -0.015800155699253082, 0.02381870523095131, -0.054704125970602036, -0.010099894367158413, -0.0018222419312223792, 0.0364498607814312, 0.05990760028362274, -0.000016780169971752912, -0.0046691372990608215, -0.035604607313871384, 0.039422087371349335, -0.020054420456290245, 0.015134084969758987, -0.018442891538143158, -0.03337472677230835, 0.044976938515901566, -0.03402979299426079, -0.030013224110007286, -0.01853553019464016, -0.021110476925969124, 0.06887559592723846, -0.022181499749422073, -0.014381066896021366, -0.018067272379994392, 0.01958015188574791, -0.06819061189889908, -0.03839583694934845, -0.03846454992890358, -0.05530418083071709, -0.03471080958843231, -0.027536310255527496, 0.05382118746638298, 0.03822256252169609, -0.027877965942025185, 0.016570325940847397, 0.02784031629562378, 0.03825221583247185, -0.014474182389676571, 0.04697266221046448, 0.035027649253606796, 0.013953857123851776, -0.007664186879992485, -0.03587494045495987, -0.05326268449425697, -0.00039166712667793036, -0.013109557330608368, 0.03486669063568115, -0.0074446313083171844, 0.0456116758286953, 0.019384752959012985, 0.0496864952147007, -0.08491332083940506, 0.03349517658352852, 0.04669820889830589, 0.002372259274125099, 0.04174695909023285, 0.048409976065158844, -0.02847142145037651, 0.00992317870259285, -0.04531758278608322, -0.00802328810095787, 0.04852331802248955, -0.05354982614517212, 0.022734995931386948, -0.0027424765285104513, -0.009249117225408554, -0.01574954017996788, 0.05543174967169762, 0.0013559891376644373, -0.055774983018636703, 0.010643061250448227, 0.02517036907374859, 0.03744199499487877, -0.006584862247109413, 0.032919567078351974, 0.05231441929936409, -0.021642042323946953, -0.05690539628267288, -0.010212556459009647, -0.021260857582092285, -0.005814066156744957, 0.014878652058541775, -0.03581319749355316, 0.016144024208188057, 0.05631992220878601, -0.007835748605430126, -0.005435090512037277, 0.03574888035655022, 0.01782798208296299, -0.009476716630160809, -0.022049052640795708, 0.026811975985765457, -0.0575963519513607, -0.048491623252630234, -0.018299762159585953, 0.04204064980149269, 0.04070279002189636, 0.03717206045985222, 0.038789451122283936, 0.02322266809642315, -0.028420105576515198, -0.03590260073542595, -0.014672361314296722, 0.01420210674405098, 0.03351801261305809, -0.04821668565273285, 0.04726765677332878, 0.02271767519414425, 0.06731732934713364, -0.00844284426420927, 0.020342884585261345, -0.001667636795900762, -0.025253724306821823, -0.04888733848929405, -0.022108908742666245, 0.042964447289705276, -0.017336530610919, -0.05910472944378853, 0.05131366476416588, 0.014962166547775269, -0.0072339908219873905, 0.029764754697680473, 0.04060646891593933, -0.03977005556225777, 0.024989807978272438, 0.008532757870852947, -0.0009317203657701612, -0.06030578538775444, 0.009266945533454418, 0.0771561786532402, -0.05905019864439964, -0.0239555686712265, -0.018304580822587013, -0.04260251298546791, 0.014802368357777596, -0.046014368534088135, 0.013104824349284172, 0.025517098605632782, 0.008768756873905659, -0.06831442564725876, 0.025758346542716026, -0.0069898744113743305, -0.07584165781736374, 0.013256124220788479, 0.010923719964921474, -0.0744907483458519, -0.006903963629156351, 0.011632357724010944, -0.0015524945920333266, -0.03616555780172348, 0.02829383872449398, 0.0025765872560441494, 0.015578980557620525, -0.022597048431634903, 0.04641509801149368, 0.08552689105272293, -0.018357282504439354, 0.018720557913184166, 0.03829565644264221, -0.04741544649004936, 0.013965465128421783, -0.04067135602235794, -0.005359305068850517, -0.02560129389166832, 0.04558074101805687, -0.003627056023105979, -0.04146972671151161, -0.03541657701134682, 0.08068130165338516, -0.03353538736701012, -0.02740778774023056, 0.00032783689675852656, -0.00753750279545784, 0.05446401610970497, -0.037782806903123856, -0.05243536829948425, 0.013047948479652405, -0.017498385161161423, -0.027397222816944122, -0.06383569538593292, 0.00770321860909462, 0.010487167164683342, 0.01981048472225666, -0.025767939165234566, -0.0598234198987484, -0.03354986757040024, -0.04349098354578018, -0.06666503101587296, 0.027399122714996338, -0.07204452902078629, 0.014289679005742073, -0.03158809617161751, 0.05317489802837372, 0.0475996769964695, 0.042849600315093994, -0.03162330761551857, -0.00689036725088954, 0.028387388214468956, 0.0031199611257761717, 0.006942334119230509, -0.011768843978643417, -0.01010165736079216, -0.03915603458881378, 0.030123984441161156, -0.042216479778289795, 0.016763662919402122, -0.011401653289794922, -0.029872406274080276, 0.022955272346735, -0.0011400642106309533, -0.035136524587869644, -0.04723100736737251, 0.01589229889214039, -0.02161509357392788, 0.006812154781073332, 0.004138799849897623, -0.048135027289390564, -0.050405941903591156, 0.01189278345555067, -0.015461578965187073, -0.007867539301514626, 0.030510909855365753, 0.014024315401911736, 0.039057839661836624, -0.004945717751979828, 0.02468656189739704, 0.039721131324768066, -0.030942954123020172, -0.007412418723106384, -0.06421277672052383, -0.0012654922902584076, 0.04450422525405884, 0.008957614190876484, -0.03925899788737297, -0.04065084457397461, -0.018374398350715637, -0.07413198798894882, 0.0022152941673994064, 0.023091228678822517, -0.005644398741424084, -0.010182973928749561, -0.06361505389213562, 0.01692967489361763, 0.02353185974061489, -0.051395006477832794, -0.05025278404355049, -0.02015881985425949, 0.00562497042119503, -0.035159673541784286, -0.003385898657143116, 0.001141226151958108, -0.046148788183927536, 0.012881851755082607, -0.07640767097473145, 0.0008686509099788964, -0.0160550307482481, 0.039973367005586624, -0.025988547131419182, -0.04867562651634216, -0.023083997890353203, -0.025815371423959732, 0.027884986251592636, -0.02773032896220684, 0.05054118111729622, 0.00881966296583414, 0.039900872856378555, -0.010941863991320133, -0.0770430937409401, -0.009440152905881405, 0.03837961331009865, -0.04926132410764694, 0.003316855290904641, 0.03433937206864357, 0.05827298387885094, 0.057156387716531754, 0.00576289277523756, 0.035476721823215485, -0.024102231487631798, 0.022832265123724937, -0.02954797074198723, 0.026816081255674362, -0.025736846029758453, -0.05476461723446846, 0.06467310339212418, -0.04432790353894234, -0.006707665044814348, 0.027971208095550537, -0.00508818170055747, -0.024774005636572838, -0.02090630494058132, -0.02853625826537609, 0.039480019360780716, 0.01087038591504097, 0.02368876524269581, 0.03564166650176048, -0.034758176654577255, 0.025970425456762314, -0.033730167895555496, -0.0007801569299772382, 0.00013990711886435747, 0.0006926438072696328, 0.028417307883501053, -0.04901779443025589, 0.0030522681772708893, -0.07189767807722092, 0.013164965435862541, 0.006404624320566654, -0.028917772695422173, -0.035735148936510086, 0.06896791607141495, 0.006641243118792772, -0.03180620074272156, 0.0026953674387186766, -0.010478691197931767, 0.002448203507810831, -0.06699685752391815, -0.050054535269737244, -0.006335652898997068, 0.009309099055826664, -0.024883998557925224, 0.007905571721494198, 0.015038777142763138, 0.06897860765457153, 0.02354845404624939, 0.03450265899300575, 0.020209383219480515, 0.0067932093515992165, -0.03713694587349892, 0.06843085587024689, 0.013773633167147636, 0.03273724764585495, -0.03167033940553665, 0.021505573764443398, -0.013409492559731007, 0.018334005028009415, 0.030582180246710777, -0.014587410725653172, -0.00015081503079272807, -0.05425650626420975, -0.0024477688129991293, 0.04859869182109833, 0.0008512093918398023, -0.0028660823591053486, -0.014142832718789577, -0.014783180318772793, -0.018261658027768135, -0.05326461419463158 ]
Simulation-based inference techniques are indispensable for parameter estimation of mechanistic and simulable models with intractable likelihoods. While traditional statistical approaches like approximate Bayesian computation and Bayesian synthetic likelihood have been studied under well-specified and misspecified settings, they often suffer from inefficiencies due to wasted model simulations. Neural approaches, such as sequential neural likelihood (SNL) avoid this wastage by utilising all model simulations to train a neural surrogate for the likelihood function. However, the performance of SNL under model misspecification is unreliable and can result in overconfident posteriors centred around an inaccurate parameter estimate. In this paper, we propose a novel SNL method, which through the incorporation of additional adjustment parameters, is robust to model misspecification and capable of identifying features of the data that the model is not able to recover. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach through several illustrative examples, where our method gives more accurate point estimates and uncertainty quantification than SNL.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13368v2
[ -0.042051006108522415, -0.011923225596547127, 0.033566683530807495, 0.02294917032122612, -0.002122386358678341, -0.029316185042262077, 0.006554695311933756, -0.02158244699239731, 0.005387859418988228, -0.03380349650979042, -0.06485651433467865, -0.035416971892118454, -0.04048125445842743, -0.04031966254115105, -0.020135710015892982, -0.03422173485159874, 0.05839464068412781, 0.013204722665250301, -0.03803619369864464, 0.06226791441440582, 0.00953675340861082, -0.030444197356700897, -0.023936579003930092, 0.01749263145029545, 0.002809444908052683, -0.04281821846961975, -0.01973201148211956, -0.03985628858208656, -0.04996572434902191, -0.022057894617319107, 0.026875538751482964, -0.03302823752164841, -0.01906149834394455, -0.047701191157102585, -0.037879642099142075, -0.0060575371608138084, -0.019916119053959846, 0.0035042630042880774, 0.0558861643075943, -0.02858167514204979, 0.016462359577417374, -0.020690690726041794, -0.057260338217020035, -0.022724902257323265, -0.050583384931087494, 0.00794560182839632, -0.029221463948488235, 0.023981353268027306, -0.06281066685914993, -0.04993775114417076, 0.04890366271138191, -0.029270486906170845, -0.01377335749566555, 0.038875311613082886, -0.06281477957963943, 0.04207606613636017, 0.005321112927049398, 0.005019021220505238, -0.07908278703689575, 0.007487854454666376, 0.0466478168964386, -0.002793579362332821, 0.021296778693795204, -0.01198167260736227, -0.0005779492203146219, 0.02863091230392456, 0.010733340866863728, -0.06637202948331833, -0.06857357919216156, -0.05968637391924858, 0.031095467507839203, -0.051366012543439865, 0.02224910445511341, -0.007848410867154598, -0.03889482468366623, -0.03248736262321472, -0.01873091235756874, -0.022236883640289307, 0.04013630375266075, 0.04886316880583763, -0.05551538243889809, 0.04802045226097107, 0.017328105866909027, 0.020533941686153412, -0.005033494438976049, -0.01577254757285118, 0.051508404314517975, -0.02324524149298668, 0.014915745705366135, -0.061509422957897186, -0.0033830783795565367, -0.05129138007760048, -0.05504574254155159, -0.007711768615990877, 0.06469127535820007, -0.037636108696460724, 0.04273572191596031, 0.026535730808973312, 0.032123152166604996, 0.002013697987422347, -0.0014078619424253702, -0.0017116290982812643, -0.030515849590301514, 0.06409434229135513, -0.010503426194190979, -0.047291431576013565, -0.02623073197901249, -0.014052090235054493, -0.05295916646718979, -0.03813955932855606, -0.04166417568922043, -0.05157816410064697, -0.013937601819634438, -0.052139200270175934, -0.055399902164936066, -0.06392514705657959, 0.05369670316576958, 0.006374699994921684, 0.0012187487445771694, -0.0013795142294839025, -0.04290284961462021, 0.02150484174489975, -0.024858573451638222, -0.03955809026956558, -0.042425476014614105, -0.008346328511834145, 0.05976460129022598, 0.008174845948815346, -0.05161343514919281, -0.011082187294960022, -0.04439914599061012, 0.040679268538951874, -0.0008670227834954858, 0.0014073303900659084, 0.059440936893224716, 0.010897637344896793, -0.04933227226138115, -0.06756316125392914, 0.012836434878408909, 0.014335032552480698, -0.018502742052078247, -0.06482672691345215, 0.018152032047510147, -0.0452558808028698, 0.01727817952632904, 0.040740858763456345, -0.07099340856075287, -0.011590228416025639, -0.01345340721309185, 0.019354883581399918, -0.0037318365648388863, -0.013954036869108677, 0.037449564784765244, 0.03341354429721832, 0.05564040318131447, -0.005676774308085442, 0.0249504204839468, -0.014608459547162056, -0.04035520553588867, -0.020301027223467827, 0.04666789248585701, -0.042295902967453, 0.0020076767541468143, -0.029034044593572617, 0.04236919432878494, 0.020888419821858406, 0.035258688032627106, 0.00023625577159691602, 0.005842155311256647, -0.018485482782125473, -0.05406135693192482, 0.01845427416265011, 0.0017739502945914865, 0.0030423507560044527, -0.02624860778450966, -0.0017857297789305449, 0.04583899676799774, -0.04224870353937149, -0.03645607829093933, 0.00324560166336596, 0.01779315620660782, 0.04475848004221916, -0.03762330859899521, 0.03205640986561775, -0.0070075374096632, 0.00997373927384615, -0.07848034054040909, -0.012845748104155064, 0.03761615231633186, 0.04911022633314133, -0.03406110778450966, -0.043594714254140854, 0.01916951686143875, -0.0024596177972853184, -0.037853166460990906, -0.0346931554377079, -0.00543717946857214, -0.00894390419125557, -0.0037381709553301334, 0.03083605132997036, -0.0819283202290535, 0.00764855183660984, -0.05767861008644104, 0.008949351496994495, -0.05638260021805763, -0.03242132067680359, -0.005844760220497847, 0.036511458456516266, -0.010624481365084648, -0.018732376396656036, 0.04940405115485191, 0.061643607914447784, 0.03952920809388161, 0.01866365410387516, 0.014647014439105988, 0.00996481254696846, -0.08557376265525818, 0.05668075382709503, -0.026709143072366714, -0.03254186734557152, 0.007016291376203299, -0.026868673041462898, 0.0015625422820448875, -0.01858101412653923, -0.00904123019427061, 0.028334790840744972, 0.04870501533150673, 0.02353653497993946, -0.01934613101184368, -0.029375117272138596, -0.0066904835402965546, -0.04121126979589462, -0.048097167164087296, -0.07780607044696808, 0.02180681750178337, 0.013077592477202415, 0.01104507502168417, 0.04140942543745041, 0.011413071304559708, -0.005746324546635151, -0.0665697231888771, 0.0004089392314199358, 0.04613998904824257, -0.028786661103367805, -0.048819661140441895, -0.02550932578742504, 0.018956691026687622, 0.018667349591851234, -0.023226087912917137, 0.00442932453006506, -0.02721332758665085, -0.05857358127832413, -0.03798704966902733, -0.04289068654179573, 0.004588903393596411, 0.028486132621765137, -0.03608937934041023, 0.020731091499328613, -0.014046754688024521, 0.045987918972969055, 0.05811955779790878, 0.05728679895401001, -0.06781570613384247, -0.017882250249385834, 0.0524955652654171, -0.0011217863066121936, -0.013329043984413147, 0.013705185614526272, 0.04689699783921242, -0.05427275598049164, 0.04209979623556137, -0.007120645605027676, 0.05622553080320358, 0.037083059549331665, -0.03021896816790104, -0.017315955832600594, -0.011211884208023548, -0.034533388912677765, 0.049150824546813965, 0.05041069537401199, 0.0571296252310276, 0.020146792754530907, 0.02398962713778019, -0.06304262578487396, -0.017046118155121803, -0.05273449048399925, -0.017177967354655266, -0.0714632049202919, -0.07370491325855255, -0.016789134591817856, -0.08188693225383759, -0.028703223913908005, -0.020087989047169685, -0.01480151154100895, -0.0212984848767519, -0.060698967427015305, -0.04072051867842674, -0.002047876361757517, 0.042049918323755264, -0.02589450404047966, -0.04856441915035248, -0.032996807247400284, -0.021963583305478096, 0.046099089086055756, -0.013549527153372765, -0.05591091141104698, -0.05033603683114052, -0.012183645740151405, 0.057961609214544296, 0.010610189288854599, -0.02725140005350113, 0.023388691246509552, -0.0373745933175087, 0.004635542631149292, 0.0037479165475815535, 0.025579560548067093, 0.0036454752553254366, 0.005281242076307535, -0.0022460848558694124, -0.04494849592447281, 0.04234246164560318, 0.014037218876183033, -0.01815691404044628, -0.0462539941072464, -0.026332112029194832, -0.018864626064896584, 0.069777712225914, -0.011253220960497856, -0.0594877153635025, -0.035910576581954956, -0.014059629291296005, 0.002784962300211191, 0.02092924900352955, -0.03884466737508774, 0.05271197482943535, 0.032083380967378616, -0.05197417736053467, -0.02358432672917843, -0.016649553552269936, -0.001056337496265769, -0.01174128707498312, 0.035040922462940216, -0.052847955375909805, 0.03232294321060181, 0.010626008734107018, -0.07690144330263138, 0.013245045207440853, 0.027468176558613777, 0.06434616446495056, -0.010407177731394768, -0.004774945788085461, 0.012912264093756676, 0.014944965951144695, 0.037312787026166916, 0.006587782874703407, 0.03829431161284447, 0.0421341136097908, 0.021243099123239517, -0.039475217461586, -0.054832205176353455, 0.022536827251315117, -0.06378554552793503, -0.05413932353258133, 0.029422445222735405, 0.03485981374979019, -0.0230867862701416, 0.0074635338969528675, -0.05745837092399597, 0.015450112521648407, -0.0012759274104610085, 0.01524141151458025, -0.025956610217690468, -0.020060688257217407, 0.062347736209630966, -0.0360172875225544, 0.01950952783226967, 0.024411415681242943, 0.002484898781403899, -0.00529893534258008, -0.05404634401202202, 0.01999475806951523, -0.07094179838895798, 0.020960796624422073, -0.004271510057151318, -0.024912994354963303, 0.043151333928108215, 0.05427568405866623, -0.05726465582847595, 0.03794563189148903, -0.01076475903391838, -0.031756795942783356, -0.004230956546962261, 0.004010003991425037, -0.009905260987579823, 0.004694732371717691, -0.06466924399137497, -0.03026566095650196, 0.02639501541852951, -0.013308375142514706, -0.008326332084834576, 0.00590072525665164, -0.032586466521024704, -0.016023891046643257, -0.07882428169250488, 0.017910396680235863, -0.04502241685986519, 0.021326526999473572, 0.002306330017745495, -0.01791294291615486, 0.05696655809879303, -0.03471478819847107, -0.001905550598166883, -0.03763561695814133, -0.03284434974193573, -0.04970378801226616, -0.014879191294312477, -0.025997303426265717, -0.07728473842144012, 0.02981354109942913, -0.05956869572401047, 0.033723797649145126, 0.004923130851238966, 0.008698147721588612, -0.055262695997953415, -0.02223072201013565, -0.0030647683888673782, 0.003623556112870574, 0.05975166708230972, 0.056345123797655106, 0.0015434701927006245, 0.0006040313746780157, -0.004462950862944126, -0.012454735115170479, -0.006434677634388208, -0.03423561155796051, -0.02579081431031227, 0.01728706993162632, -0.05068778991699219, -0.039688535034656525, -0.045081377029418945, -0.027183128520846367, 0.06633380055427551, -0.010064332745969296, 0.001028690836392343, 0.009063600562512875, 0.05103607103228569, -0.043224677443504333, -0.07051413506269455, -0.03431248292326927, -0.013597275130450726, -0.06409727036952972, -0.013321678154170513, 0.05697641521692276, 0.039192672818899155, -0.023244649171829224, 0.01497015729546547, -0.025339625775814056, 0.0008476649527437985, -0.009664244949817657, 0.009216263890266418, 0.00995591375976801, -0.0015958925941959023, 0.001601082505658269, -0.028466010466217995, -0.07511283457279205, -0.04914095997810364, -0.049841005355119705, 0.0033611746039241552, -0.023042406886816025, 0.04231267049908638, -0.02799619548022747, 0.05675872415304184, -0.07580453157424927, 0.005101657938212156, 0.04630149528384209, -0.007882087491452694, -0.014224457554519176, 0.05268083140254021, -0.017934316769242287, 0.0411880798637867, -0.0483243390917778, 0.004476386122405529, 0.020171361044049263, -0.0464172437787056, 0.026133548468351364, -0.01993441954255104, 0.014665108174085617, -0.049841977655887604, 0.045618414878845215, -0.011615393683314323, -0.05152237415313721, -0.0027906177565455437, 0.031882114708423615, -0.017217189073562622, -0.02888280339539051, 0.03789180517196655, -0.01174231804907322, -0.03350289165973663, -0.05056912451982498, -0.04381542280316353, 0.027972737327218056, 0.007056446745991707, 0.012341952882707119, -0.045298319309949875, -0.03353189304471016, 0.04296841844916344, -0.0023839417845010757, 0.03212399408221245, 0.014977684244513512, -0.015577658079564571, 0.028642570599913597, -0.031878549605607986, 0.04929045960307121, -0.05387995392084122, -0.011477319523692131, -0.03368109464645386, 0.04562556371092796, 0.03413517400622368, 0.02928258664906025, -0.023544572293758392, 0.030159326270222664, -0.05708411708474159, 0.0019669414032250643, -0.013624940067529678, -0.027299756184220314, 0.008271384984254837, 0.0010950576979666948, 0.05618858337402344, 0.004235806409269571, 0.04673098027706146, 0.028020521625876427, 0.02700057066977024, 0.005407233722507954, -0.026210471987724304, 0.009634997695684433, 0.020943600684404373, 0.053476281464099884, -0.042103707790374756, -0.03873680159449577, 0.03207119554281235, 0.022751810029149055, -0.0008300848421640694, 0.045600682497024536, 0.027721604332327843, 0.0070137279108166695, 0.03805709630250931, -0.003676299238577485, -0.03935321047902107, -0.046967823058366776, 0.04612387716770172, 0.07207024842500687, -0.04926621913909912, -0.02225263975560665, -0.05782628431916237, -0.027329305186867714, -0.006261690519750118, -0.05594375357031822, 0.005046152044087648, 0.017390063032507896, -0.000734942383132875, -0.06718043982982635, 0.024934232234954834, 0.03553737699985504, -0.07732481509447098, -0.01786978170275688, 0.011258167214691639, -0.0747847706079483, 0.0168395284563303, 0.03860318288207054, -0.02434341050684452, -0.05086928606033325, 0.022526081651449203, 0.013285030610859394, -0.007873432710766792, -0.050973787903785706, 0.06433388590812683, 0.08135122805833817, -0.013259545899927616, 0.022034823894500732, 0.0010108951246365905, -0.024705421179533005, 0.03731956705451012, -0.047954946756362915, -0.010490695014595985, -0.0100816385820508, -0.0016427547670900822, -0.014322619885206223, -0.020481325685977936, -0.046676602214574814, 0.053030673414468765, -0.021961664780974388, -0.0038389291148632765, 0.019565628841519356, 0.006343100685626268, 0.05047735199332237, -0.04866558313369751, 0.00042002188274636865, -0.008325708098709583, 0.02073938213288784, -0.040002740919589996, -0.05827973037958145, 0.008115704171359539, 0.0012793794739991426, 0.0015800015535205603, -0.038187988102436066, -0.06209094822406769, 0.018547959625720978, -0.04902179166674614, -0.05578688904643059, 0.008836248889565468, -0.05765833705663681, 0.013095956295728683, -0.004219018388539553, 0.015558390878140926, 0.01219188142567873, 0.06684909760951996, -0.041217148303985596, 0.03590556979179382, -0.0021239693742245436, 0.037573084235191345, 0.00735392514616251, -0.018369166180491447, -0.02164270170032978, -0.04370180517435074, 0.0317828468978405, -0.029568718746304512, -0.024042801931500435, -0.033724941313266754, -0.050059329718351364, 0.037840329110622406, 0.00020087658776901662, -0.05508952960371971, -0.07386667281389236, 0.04680461809039116, -0.04962893947958946, 0.019406389445066452, -0.004474723245948553, -0.041785597801208496, -0.07051799446344376, 0.03163077309727669, 0.01900584064424038, -0.032452329993247986, 0.019677123054862022, 0.03580458089709282, 0.030223358422517776, -0.016528546810150146, 0.018234238028526306, 0.045511357486248016, -0.010410038754343987, 0.058838747441768646, -0.055501025170087814, -0.04828866198658943, 0.03834131732583046, -0.0027783727273344994, -0.049514975398778915, -0.012736924923956394, -0.016954634338617325, -0.05087343975901604, -0.018215155228972435, 0.055783528834581375, -0.014970604330301285, 0.023870425298810005, -0.07267758995294571, 0.01782693713903427, -0.024299371987581253, -0.03791733831167221, -0.0526944175362587, -0.02453545853495598, 0.02116774395108223, -0.014018738642334938, 0.01622854918241501, -0.010418368503451347, -0.042542167007923126, 0.029244260862469673, -0.07952030748128891, -0.026830380782485008, -0.025848835706710815, 0.0548366904258728, -0.014134617522358894, -0.021763306111097336, -0.029591141268610954, -0.027843382209539413, 0.012378757819533348, 0.012874373234808445, 0.003924024756997824, 0.0368383415043354, 0.03845499828457832, 0.014492222107946873, -0.043961118906736374, -0.0404847115278244, 0.04928409308195114, -0.03163718059659004, -0.024653468281030655, 0.0331345796585083, 0.01942809671163559, -0.00032971156178973615, -0.018759962171316147, 0.053763724863529205, -0.012073307298123837, 0.043712109327316284, -0.046293459832668304, 0.012528372928500175, -0.060758356004953384, -0.06338809430599213, 0.028092721477150917, -0.041969992220401764, -0.049910880625247955, -0.028336897492408752, -0.010741223581135273, -0.010362915694713593, -0.04243822023272514, -0.01647317409515381, 0.04729960486292839, 0.03048458695411682, -0.02406608872115612, 0.032019663602113724, -0.04028269276022911, -0.02458186261355877, -0.04119129478931427, -0.0040713343769311905, -0.028973212465643883, 0.03213420510292053, 0.03212999179959297, -0.04877377673983574, -0.009715125896036625, -0.07116138935089111, -0.011409316211938858, -0.021665604785084724, 0.021929873153567314, -0.03765030577778816, 0.07138688117265701, -0.012553942389786243, -0.0035629593767225742, 0.009475133381783962, -0.018917273730039597, -0.0556110218167305, -0.07314997911453247, -0.03871682286262512, -0.043895553797483444, -0.004462870769202709, -0.020012326538562775, 0.042140066623687744, 0.00638019060716033, 0.06368666142225266, 0.03935066983103752, -0.02379750832915306, -0.0025260557886213064, 0.013881982304155827, -0.05598423629999161, 0.04464368522167206, 0.025431061163544655, 0.03133492171764374, -0.03656363859772682, 0.013968013226985931, -0.01778569258749485, -0.03806702792644501, -0.01673971302807331, -0.018289223313331604, -0.010746588930487633, -0.07107372581958771, 0.029021017253398895, -0.02396344393491745, -0.009368276223540306, -0.019828565418720245, 0.006868472322821617, 0.011027397587895393, -0.04185879975557327, -0.038542408496141434 ]
In this work, we focus on a robotic unloading problem from visual observations, where robots are required to autonomously unload stacks of parcels using RGB-D images as their primary input source. While supervised and imitation learning have accomplished good results in these types of tasks, they heavily rely on labeled data, which are challenging to obtain in realistic scenarios. Our study aims to develop a sample efficient controller framework that can learn unloading tasks without the need for labeled data during the learning process. To tackle this challenge, we propose a hierarchical controller structure that combines a high-level decision-making module with classical motion control. The high-level module is trained using Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL), wherein we incorporate a safety bias mechanism and design a reward function tailored to this task. Our experiments demonstrate that both these elements play a crucial role in achieving improved learning performance. Furthermore, to ensure reproducibility and establish a benchmark for future research, we provide free access to our code and simulation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06621v1
[ -0.0013966694241389632, -0.025636930018663406, 0.05733441188931465, -0.0032360670156776905, -0.013912111520767212, 0.0023327218368649483, -0.02330516278743744, -0.01757068559527397, 0.01904122903943062, -0.0598333477973938, -0.025913355872035027, -0.021999334916472435, -0.06677036732435226, -0.051159705966711044, -0.027768414467573166, 0.026359660550951958, 0.07480768114328384, -0.01729317009449005, -0.02369123324751854, 0.046967651695013046, -0.004617011174559593, 0.0010202336125075817, -0.04110223799943924, 0.017549730837345123, 0.040994055569171906, -0.008802625350654125, -0.010088415816426277, 0.005918297916650772, -0.03830167278647423, -0.0008559617563150823, 0.06327376514673233, -0.00013255001977086067, -0.006029487121850252, -0.06516262888908386, -0.041726354509592056, 0.0029943224508315325, -0.021578051149845123, -0.0028710621409118176, 0.044222068041563034, -0.044496506452560425, 0.03785201162099838, -0.040958479046821594, -0.061817679554224014, -0.04691549018025398, -0.04372206702828407, 0.021053193137049675, -0.02798621729016304, 0.014681549742817879, -0.06785382330417633, -0.04729572683572769, -0.011626805178821087, 0.015188097953796387, 0.04317864775657654, 0.04803873226046562, -0.026377560570836067, -0.016381006687879562, 0.011582477949559689, 0.02244042046368122, -0.06737031042575836, -0.010356700979173183, -0.0014627036871388555, -0.022734297439455986, -0.011883094906806946, 0.01198689453303814, 0.013165650889277458, 0.06084326654672623, -0.01589459739625454, -0.03525212034583092, -0.04471674934029579, -0.0503990538418293, 0.05597250163555145, -0.07355234771966934, -0.003026360645890236, 0.009707741439342499, -0.008482610806822777, -0.02414005436003208, -0.06434068828821182, -0.043598972260951996, -0.005965305957943201, -0.02365810237824917, -0.04503001645207405, 0.004674166440963745, 0.03319200500845909, 0.03468582406640053, 0.0004217227688059211, -0.01613217405974865, 0.03527040407061577, 0.016347698867321014, 0.012759996578097343, -0.0020205280743539333, 0.05717694014310837, -0.01829998567700386, -0.0763450562953949, 0.019335079938173294, 0.03312366083264351, -0.007428825367242098, 0.07339398562908173, 0.01668660342693329, 0.02198616787791252, -0.0015636468306183815, -0.04765978455543518, 0.014755106531083584, -0.031535837799310684, 0.038429830223321915, 0.043443575501441956, -0.021611329168081284, 0.01755676232278347, -0.004457490984350443, -0.054307471960783005, 0.000618811056483537, 0.0006988777313381433, -0.04536041244864464, 0.0003781973209697753, -0.07464445382356644, -0.04107772186398506, 0.027881059795618057, 0.03576406463980675, 0.02308645285665989, 0.01569255255162716, 0.013791531324386597, -0.031146446242928505, 0.029303336516022682, 0.030233558267354965, -0.02080151066184044, -0.020559385418891907, -0.05729617923498154, 0.03699061647057533, 0.03382670506834984, -0.020164594054222107, -0.0302177295088768, -0.01755083166062832, 0.003662554547190666, -0.028321251273155212, -0.06015707552433014, 0.05190460756421089, -0.014311829581856728, -0.020032217726111412, -0.06729403883218765, 0.016943369060754776, -0.015281548723578453, -0.028311895206570625, -0.07292470335960388, 0.05092449486255646, -0.02325168251991272, -0.000045806569687556475, 0.06861831992864609, 0.012958217412233353, -0.012412004172801971, 0.005823921877890825, 0.04831452667713165, -0.011864257976412773, -0.015555296093225479, 0.019011417403817177, 0.02151857502758503, -0.010124331340193748, -0.0372069850564003, 0.04260801896452904, -0.04136406257748604, -0.06339332461357117, -0.03459806740283966, -0.015813341364264488, -0.013119025155901909, 0.01664194092154503, -0.03952460736036301, 0.020077312365174294, 0.0314825177192688, 0.031216375529766083, -0.010437099263072014, -0.013467834331095219, 0.002952167298644781, -0.02467646263539791, -0.04863516241312027, 0.0036230047699064016, 0.0029974256176501513, -0.08273635804653168, -0.0277689341455698, -0.026902254670858383, -0.05951271578669548, -0.057900939136743546, 0.017244495451450348, 0.009464939124882221, 0.024587690830230713, -0.025456517934799194, -0.00702825840562582, -0.0322369709610939, 0.02927476353943348, -0.06892743706703186, -0.04714360460639, 0.04426737502217293, 0.010864507406949997, -0.0330628976225853, -0.016579871997237206, 0.0247604139149189, 0.005634578876197338, -0.04819554463028908, 0.006685249507427216, -0.046637654304504395, -0.0017855901969596744, 0.02060544490814209, 0.01723158173263073, -0.09047991782426834, 0.0022761079017072916, -0.0562671460211277, 0.019094012677669525, -0.026591874659061432, -0.07328064739704132, -0.012678260914981365, 0.020165657624602318, -0.06929135322570801, 0.036384761333465576, 0.044353242963552475, 0.01757701113820076, 0.06319672614336014, 0.024252990260720253, 0.06467944383621216, 0.006023278925567865, -0.0958051010966301, 0.04670986533164978, 0.00022151641314849257, 0.03160175681114197, 0.023451993241906166, 0.005745396483689547, 0.015956299379467964, -0.05746108666062355, -0.0044417064636945724, 0.055273525416851044, 0.04263679310679436, -0.0014680542517453432, -0.06806044280529022, -0.03564034774899483, -0.010491352528333664, -0.06684481352567673, -0.0037581122014671564, -0.08263775706291199, -0.026390552520751953, -0.003195275319740176, -0.016736546531319618, 0.060314685106277466, -0.007574078626930714, -0.038042400032281876, -0.04040520265698433, -0.038328275084495544, 0.04830475524067879, -0.005332759115844965, -0.031975965946912766, -0.06017858907580376, -0.006161069497466087, 0.034172892570495605, -0.0184478797018528, 0.031280048191547394, -0.039869796484708786, -0.01592458225786686, 0.004546923562884331, -0.015074145048856735, 0.0678742453455925, 0.030893728137016296, -0.019458813592791557, 0.043464966118335724, -0.021261682733893394, 0.015096927992999554, 0.030063217505812645, -0.011014279909431934, -0.06253163516521454, -0.02752993069589138, 0.012250973843038082, 0.002893307711929083, 0.005736989434808493, -0.03132612630724907, -0.012932914309203625, -0.04834570735692978, -0.012938152067363262, 0.03211390972137451, 0.007093288004398346, -0.01592492312192917, -0.01847602240741253, -0.01663125678896904, -0.02659577876329422, 0.0039251698181033134, 0.019455403089523315, 0.045565348118543625, 0.020528055727481842, 0.05447915196418762, -0.038586318492889404, -0.05767127498984337, -0.036530956625938416, -0.055168718099594116, -0.021630864590406418, -0.05106699839234352, -0.05306059867143631, 0.0012230960419401526, -0.07073267549276352, -0.038187380880117416, -0.0336996354162693, -0.04616387560963631, -0.016748249530792236, -0.058753497898578644, -0.031021442264318466, 0.007369798142462969, 0.017283719033002853, -0.01061602495610714, -0.047249775379896164, -0.0330134816467762, 0.027856888249516487, 0.03017287328839302, -0.006062841042876244, -0.05771348252892494, -0.059006936848163605, -0.016694968566298485, 0.025671029463410378, -0.009023978374898434, -0.014701711013913155, 0.038043830543756485, -0.009986326098442078, 0.010691715404391289, -0.04093973711133003, 0.03775550797581673, 0.012422050349414349, 0.05818773806095123, -0.04368643835186958, -0.026363905519247055, -0.030865341424942017, 0.001607136451639235, 0.007542120758444071, -0.01461807545274496, -0.038796670734882355, -0.010532653890550137, 0.03881607577204704, 0.022514618933200836, -0.03008503094315529, -0.03743357211351395, -0.026045432314276695, -0.008804317563772202, 0.011020928621292114, -0.013137639500200748, 0.03756625950336456, 0.030170291662216187, -0.0013220044784247875, -0.044467743486166, -0.015201577916741371, 0.02888343669474125, -0.01714288629591465, 0.035421933978796005, -0.06002466753125191, -0.01631605252623558, 0.06854551285505295, -0.08864238858222961, 0.009538566693663597, 0.036301370710134506, 0.04895363003015518, 0.020156804472208023, 0.04012530669569969, 0.009501646272838116, 0.039816007018089294, 0.03481584042310715, -0.012457787059247494, 0.027528686448931694, 0.03579035401344299, 0.029323391616344452, -0.01956445910036564, -0.028617920354008675, -0.0059258099645376205, -0.06466810405254364, -0.04298250377178192, -0.01325622946023941, 0.023096628487110138, 0.022722650319337845, 0.027423763647675514, -0.07722209393978119, -0.005633012391626835, 0.03200139105319977, 0.04245014861226082, -0.0036849938333034515, -0.023843366652727127, 0.0457179881632328, -0.037086959928274155, 0.04761207848787308, -0.039279013872146606, 0.020320989191532135, -0.015591300092637539, -0.05632232129573822, -0.005637063644826412, -0.06973986327648163, 0.043325748294591904, 0.007456971798092127, -0.014385565184056759, 0.05751002952456474, 0.048749759793281555, 0.01022221427410841, 0.04325340688228607, -0.024493083357810974, -0.006367099937051535, 0.007407842203974724, 0.0030964065808802843, -0.06908709555864334, -0.003934875596314669, -0.038713082671165466, 0.02227790094912052, 0.007997636683285236, -0.011731619015336037, 0.008153272792696953, -0.010332498699426651, -0.006794659420847893, -0.054052844643592834, -0.07955194264650345, -0.02611258439719677, -0.02439841255545616, 0.05114609748125076, -0.003579396288841963, -0.04073397442698479, 0.04775363579392433, -0.06264086812734604, -0.014348345808684826, -0.045374419540166855, -0.027724530547857285, -0.025003844872117043, -0.05910813435912132, -0.04019733518362045, -0.07609338313341141, -0.0011646063067018986, -0.02012615278363228, 0.058555345982313156, -0.0029156252276152372, 0.02510003373026848, -0.03814532235264778, -0.0035934029147028923, -0.019939377903938293, 0.025859162211418152, 0.05815127491950989, 0.014789951965212822, -0.009975519962608814, -0.02818227745592594, 0.02695074863731861, 0.013471943326294422, -0.002834837418049574, 0.012412109412252903, -0.04157344251871109, 0.011285989545285702, -0.033893655985593796, 0.006441478151828051, -0.013032550923526287, -0.000605918699875474, 0.053454913198947906, -0.012963048182427883, -0.01080954261124134, -0.03125501424074173, 0.06767375022172928, -0.03853415325284004, -0.04490549862384796, -0.029789375141263008, -0.03883504122495651, -0.033220548182725906, -0.021681606769561768, 0.03973611444234848, 0.00047698491835035384, -0.014285397715866566, 0.0017066572327166796, 0.029444187879562378, -0.026845958083868027, -0.027929415926337242, -0.009567199274897575, 0.026192868128418922, -0.033695656806230545, 0.0000109540324046975, -0.013114520348608494, -0.08647213131189346, 0.04811496287584305, -0.04478408396244049, 0.02597872167825699, -0.009357101283967495, 0.032733626663684845, 0.02427050471305847, 0.03984721004962921, -0.08655230700969696, -0.009464725852012634, 0.06569308787584305, -0.03311787545681, 0.03238309547305107, 0.06980733573436737, -0.025556223466992378, 0.03628486022353172, -0.06704709678888321, -0.007261716760694981, 0.04638015106320381, -0.03948844224214554, -0.009174610488116741, -0.004868220537900925, -0.034149687737226486, -0.01942717470228672, 0.037665851414203644, 0.02284001000225544, -0.05255681648850441, -0.016440419480204582, 0.037870388478040695, 0.01915460266172886, -0.03631801903247833, 0.04845208302140236, 0.03367194905877113, -0.040136490017175674, -0.022171080112457275, -0.00442381901666522, -0.003203204134479165, -0.022863440215587616, 0.03781542554497719, -0.017315417528152466, -0.004783479031175375, -0.006394799333065748, 0.00819450244307518, -0.03791264072060585, 0.014084945432841778, 0.010796107351779938, -0.012478233315050602, -0.03785998374223709, -0.005430199205875397, -0.05981706082820892, -0.02467484585940838, -0.04933296516537666, 0.039959847927093506, 0.0468563474714756, 0.0267130546271801, 0.018848752602934837, 0.01571960747241974, -0.0152986329048872, 0.0015108260558918118, -0.026438256725668907, 0.038762904703617096, 0.04465769976377487, -0.05937529727816582, 0.026257598772644997, -0.005021586548537016, 0.022065073251724243, -0.04419282451272011, 0.04830290004611015, 0.02746034786105156, 0.0119216563180089, -0.04034477844834328, -0.024372724816203117, 0.020528603345155716, -0.06242850795388222, -0.045350633561611176, 0.04304574057459831, 0.011446156539022923, -0.0038726713974028826, 0.0337088368833065, 0.04678064212203026, 0.0020716828294098377, 0.01727466471493244, 0.004463075194507837, 0.015294818207621574, -0.002966666826978326, 0.01951557770371437, 0.06968171149492264, -0.06389802694320679, -0.024588648229837418, -0.0224843081086874, -0.049088865518569946, 0.052586961537599564, -0.06059451401233673, 0.0007317657582461834, -0.03185058757662773, 0.05450739338994026, -0.05730839818716049, 0.04109534993767738, -0.012819460593163967, -0.07064767926931381, 0.04152994975447655, 0.041318442672491074, -0.06751084327697754, -0.026539936661720276, -0.010845784097909927, -0.0072395652532577515, -0.06391194462776184, 0.066633440554142, 0.031624507158994675, 0.008145615458488464, -0.02789432927966118, 0.08092831820249557, 0.08698464184999466, -0.00412856787443161, -0.013386298902332783, 0.022685246542096138, -0.060841385275125504, 0.045607808977365494, -0.0011024484410881996, -0.015857461839914322, 0.035245008766651154, 0.03385847061872482, 0.04507286474108696, -0.0635063573718071, -0.041775353252887726, 0.048134829849004745, -0.027415117248892784, -0.028975792229175568, 0.018882781267166138, -0.010836058296263218, 0.052478790283203125, 0.010097239166498184, -0.051773857325315475, 0.0205258596688509, -0.0017737355083227158, 0.00738118588924408, -0.06252918392419815, -0.005290392320603132, 0.014656107872724533, -0.0003931599494535476, -0.028923651203513145, -0.0637608990073204, -0.0325937420129776, -0.020981425419449806, -0.06347247958183289, 0.0015352413756772876, -0.0543953962624073, -0.014241950586438179, -0.009295818395912647, -0.022188231348991394, 0.023845119401812553, 0.04910862073302269, 0.010694336146116257, -0.04987182840704918, 0.037709712982177734, -0.02143215574324131, 0.03520650416612625, 0.0218008141964674, 0.03544053062796593, 0.0028961084317415953, 0.03192378953099251, -0.03936079144477844, 0.008869403973221779, 0.0013697240501642227, -0.043788980692625046, 0.020193923264741898, 0.015287423506379128, -0.016255943104624748, -0.011376448906958103, -0.017124006524682045, -0.030453132465481758, 0.027434606105089188, -0.024642590433359146, -0.04471698775887489, -0.06320545077323914, -0.020430443808436394, 0.00500917574390769, 0.02539989724755287, -0.015588170848786831, 0.03579401597380638, 0.03263197839260101, -0.010791385546326637, 0.00384030444547534, 0.02813083305954933, -0.016844874247908592, 0.008992290124297142, -0.06674657016992569, -0.030045315623283386, 0.012257363647222519, -0.03438236564397812, -0.04473090171813965, -0.017364464700222015, 0.015111100859940052, -0.061752598732709885, 0.007361915428191423, 0.03866277262568474, 0.01921875774860382, -0.013035362586379051, -0.07538864016532898, 0.05650459602475166, -0.015758082270622253, -0.04996109753847122, -0.017926257103681564, 0.011688072234392166, 0.031960196793079376, -0.0628194808959961, -0.003883292665705085, 0.004069930873811245, -0.02553597278892994, 0.02326759323477745, -0.0800643190741539, 0.030630402266979218, 0.03951219469308853, 0.035744596272706985, -0.0016583994729444385, -0.02571248821914196, -0.023242143914103508, -0.030564218759536743, 0.027309928089380264, 0.011703291907906532, 0.03862341493368149, 0.015237866900861263, 0.04050647094845772, -0.025349406525492668, -0.06452632695436478, -0.03808705881237984, 0.04539007321000099, -0.0047927736304700375, -0.01546222623437643, 0.04341233894228935, 0.05801145359873772, 0.06090250983834267, -0.021691298112273216, 0.044149111956357956, -0.052185289561748505, 0.03923522308468819, -0.059931978583335876, 0.04562459886074066, -0.007594560272991657, -0.038800936192274094, 0.05645180493593216, -0.014881852082908154, 0.004220117814838886, 0.04113136604428291, -0.01255845557898283, 0.03348865732550621, -0.03835335001349449, -0.021659089252352715, 0.007375173270702362, -0.023037532344460487, 0.02867274545133114, 0.05589262396097183, -0.03345884382724762, 0.016462797299027443, -0.03263303264975548, -0.01850535348057747, -0.039298538118600845, -0.012682168744504452, 0.039152178913354874, -0.020967161282896996, 0.009544226340949535, -0.08000313490629196, -0.020637884736061096, 0.00842854380607605, -0.021131206303834915, -0.030744029209017754, 0.08493640273809433, 0.006624185014516115, -0.03108474612236023, -0.0127522898837924, -0.01713787205517292, -0.05093754455447197, -0.045508742332458496, -0.015127548947930336, -0.04609556868672371, 0.043523795902729034, -0.02902350202202797, -0.021028827875852585, -0.0049237534403800964, 0.03401866927742958, 0.03298357501626015, 0.004816337488591671, -0.003045963356271386, 0.0034754679072648287, -0.06999390572309494, 0.06333363801240921, 0.005858113989233971, 0.017634252086281776, -0.03953581675887108, 0.04059357941150665, 0.04648181051015854, 0.004527839832007885, -0.03396978601813316, -0.006611724849790335, 0.032244011759757996, -0.05654511600732803, -0.04025256633758545, 0.016000475734472275, 0.0024275665637105703, -0.05629317834973335, -0.03434428572654724, -0.01444130390882492, -0.013096125796437263, -0.06336908787488937 ]
Topological properties in quantum materials are often governed by symmetry and tuned by crystal structure and external fields, and hence symmetry-sensitive nonlinear optical measurements in a magnetic field are a valuable probe. Here we report nonlinear magneto-optical second harmonic generation (SHG) studies of non-magnetic topological materials including bilayer WTe2, monolayer WSe2 and bulk TaAs. The polarization-resolved patterns of optical SHG under magnetic field show nonlinear Kerr rotation in these time-reversal symmetric materials. For materials with three-fold rotational symmetric lattice structure, the SHG polarization pattern rotates just slightly in a magnetic field, whereas in those with mirror or two-fold rotational symmetry the SHG polarization pattern rotates greatly and distorts. These different magneto-SHG characters can be understood by considering the superposition of the magnetic field-induced time-noninvariant nonlinear optical tensor and the crystal-structure-based time-invariant counterpart. The situation is further clarified by scrutinizing the Faraday rotation, whose subtle interplay with crystal symmetry accounts for the diverse behavior of the extrinsic nonlinear Kerr rotation in different materials. Our work illustrates the application of magneto-SHG techniques to directly probe nontrivial topological properties, and underlines the importance of minimizing extrinsic nonlinear Kerr rotation in polarization-resolved magneto-optical studies.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09512v1
[ -0.054143890738487244, -0.04381641745567322, 0.03377190977334976, -0.014852861873805523, 0.023815277963876724, -0.048853784799575806, 0.01952502317726612, 0.04033278301358223, -0.05069730430841446, 0.008735128678381443, 0.025204036384820938, -0.052263665944337845, -0.029691597446799278, -0.03208856284618378, -0.03200540319085121, 0.0156136155128479, 0.07161617279052734, 0.0109934750944376, -0.0631144642829895, 0.07178237289190292, 0.03756890073418617, 0.021358629688620567, -0.003734557656571269, 0.0024563372135162354, -0.041587669402360916, -0.05658514052629471, -0.03311002627015114, 0.01148094329982996, 0.012510158121585846, -0.003273269860073924, 0.0461445078253746, -0.008415508083999157, 0.03815628960728645, -0.03236726298928261, -0.011091754771769047, -0.015290721319615841, -0.03325395658612251, 0.05188397690653801, 0.0015617844182997942, -0.043221279978752136, -0.041434939950704575, -0.0333251878619194, -0.050036944448947906, -0.013515327125787735, -0.042374398559331894, -0.057740576565265656, -0.0576351024210453, -0.004658450372517109, -0.03716951981186867, -0.029121698811650276, 0.06333747506141663, 0.016314707696437836, 0.024028975516557693, 0.03800101950764656, -0.029261833056807518, 0.04169127717614174, 0.009500113315880299, -0.01537897065281868, -0.012827159836888313, 0.013549506664276123, 0.0006330074393190444, -0.05186979100108147, 0.042177800089120865, -0.025393616408109665, -0.059123869985342026, 0.007499607279896736, -0.02556428126990795, -0.04901440441608429, 0.003314525354653597, -0.05663646012544632, 0.03273904696106911, -0.07239411771297455, -0.009068007580935955, -0.029499366879463196, -0.06968363374471664, -0.012510432861745358, -0.03557712957262993, 0.002771098166704178, -0.0014803411904722452, 0.005727595649659634, -0.007322607096284628, 0.03144371882081032, -0.014422246254980564, 0.034909866750240326, 0.06075158715248108, 0.025659125298261642, 0.029738899320364, -0.020648358389735222, -0.04957707226276398, -0.04984593018889427, 0.030998019501566887, -0.05336708575487137, -0.021584348753094673, -0.003995837178081274, 0.05311598628759384, -0.02822883427143097, 0.049694206565618515, 0.025965247303247452, 0.05800432339310646, 0.005017242860049009, -0.014939581044018269, -0.02832949347794056, -0.05164157599210739, 0.037368420511484146, -0.005400868132710457, -0.03359071910381317, 0.008888333104550838, 0.015508581884205341, -0.004018284846097231, -0.0024649000260978937, -0.0034130599815398455, -0.0001715180987957865, 0.04877801984548569, -0.03880947828292847, -0.05148182064294815, -0.07183101773262024, 0.054495859891176224, 0.014410771429538727, 0.010344667360186577, 0.039131294935941696, -0.03508496657013893, 0.06390062719583511, 0.01436407770961523, -0.011763068847358227, -0.06276261806488037, -0.01670956425368786, 0.06321519613265991, 0.003369598649442196, 0.018196575343608856, -0.04448492079973221, -0.025404658168554306, 0.016468334943056107, 0.022332675755023956, -0.03225903585553169, 0.024867696687579155, -0.02036546915769577, 0.0037804520688951015, 0.01410291064530611, -0.026288924738764763, -0.03683651611208916, -0.025861000642180443, -0.05903680622577667, 0.0021961438469588757, -0.009783468209207058, 0.019921034574508667, -0.014051558449864388, -0.06923229247331619, -0.04254786670207977, 0.03313996270298958, 0.03414110466837883, -0.02833130769431591, -0.03873355686664581, 0.04551657289266586, 0.031963225454092026, 0.031182866543531418, -0.015121301636099815, 0.039817266166210175, 0.020541291683912277, -0.016632135957479477, 0.004989365581423044, -0.000034749133192235604, 0.002139447024092078, 0.04058508202433586, -0.01078468281775713, 0.031813472509384155, -0.016651764512062073, 0.03351389616727829, -0.0236763097345829, -0.05092719942331314, 0.00525822676718235, 0.0026193163357675076, 0.014815208502113819, 0.010899240151047707, -0.037657227367162704, -0.05736804008483887, -0.01132559310644865, -0.03488190844655037, -0.03543182462453842, -0.021545298397541046, 0.016905132681131363, -0.00042527567711658776, 0.010222571901977062, -0.02915652096271515, -0.01772194541990757, -0.030962184071540833, 0.000571302545722574, -0.07660621404647827, 0.00040837086271494627, 0.014825008809566498, -0.014769088476896286, 0.00694846548140049, -0.06130461022257805, 0.010781599208712578, -0.002452206565067172, -0.057930827140808105, -0.010693631134927273, -0.01939300261437893, -0.03458108752965927, -0.01389303244650364, 0.008629823103547096, -0.056794099509716034, -0.0038500346709042788, 0.023259490728378296, -0.04143650084733963, -0.008059445768594742, -0.07846930623054504, -0.03855353966355324, 0.04855206236243248, -0.008831992745399475, -0.005921133328229189, 0.02774164266884327, 0.06515844911336899, 0.02695864625275135, -0.010411063209176064, -0.010362601839005947, 0.002839918015524745, -0.08505956828594208, 0.0013339441502466798, -0.05458986386656761, 0.01647375337779522, 0.04169858619570732, 0.012604651972651482, 0.01932799629867077, -0.017394298687577248, -0.007950146682560444, 0.0289906058460474, 0.06879094243049622, 0.02835484780371189, -0.04425554350018501, 0.003841082099825144, 0.025072624906897545, -0.05432557314634323, -0.061656974256038666, -0.05714580416679382, -0.02022654376924038, 0.01578410342335701, -0.06436052918434143, 0.046793848276138306, -0.050224751234054565, -0.012180867604911327, -0.04172565042972565, -0.0135068129748106, 0.009483903646469116, -0.021562129259109497, -0.04245438426733017, -0.03384749963879585, -0.04250601306557655, 0.0255065206438303, -0.03187589719891548, -0.01806948520243168, -0.0229693241417408, -0.07856503874063492, -0.045690398663282394, -0.019817665219306946, 0.0520620234310627, 0.04428952932357788, -0.0656895861029625, 0.03878873959183693, -0.026889948174357414, 0.04408064857125282, 0.03952298313379288, 0.03607042133808136, -0.0651157945394516, 0.02599853090941906, -0.010512239299714565, -0.005464879795908928, -0.06244569271802902, 0.0076160551980137825, -0.03293444588780403, -0.039749693125486374, 0.039561476558446884, -0.027127951383590698, 0.04085523635149002, -0.0071548959240317345, -0.043214019387960434, -0.03173743560910225, -0.028091559186577797, -0.03135306388139725, 0.020390577614307404, 0.03832231089472771, 0.06574945896863937, 0.031445570290088654, -0.028668230399489403, -0.055178675800561905, -0.01880299113690853, -0.04569598287343979, -0.016501503065228462, -0.03051653876900673, -0.033562563359737396, -0.059190016239881516, -0.06166166439652443, 0.010015766136348248, -0.030645420774817467, 0.0057589709758758545, -0.04373592138290405, -0.03759424015879631, -0.04874540492892265, 0.018166227266192436, 0.005525172222405672, -0.04457993805408478, -0.04549568146467209, 0.045821789652109146, 0.015758903697133064, -0.008901119232177734, -0.06285806745290756, 0.003302408382296562, -0.057840876281261444, 0.019089294597506523, -0.03359653428196907, -0.04176139831542969, -0.023199252784252167, 0.005687561351805925, -0.06733955442905426, -0.006069413386285305, -0.013405018486082554, 0.04492763802409172, 0.04389487951993942, -0.035473939031362534, 0.0043902150355279446, 0.02316119894385338, 0.008108054287731647, 0.006948987953364849, -0.019954901188611984, -0.009168128482997417, -0.049858443439006805, 0.0028249709866940975, 0.07109050452709198, 0.05320306122303009, -0.0344751738011837, -0.03067938983440399, -0.04692857712507248, -0.034724850207567215, -0.008380431681871414, 0.0013048864202573895, 0.049354735761880875, -0.04007744416594505, -0.03870478272438049, -0.0008738181786611676, -0.05821515992283821, 0.0024051559157669544, -0.0034613325260579586, 0.02892567217350006, 0.01089536864310503, -0.04344929754734039, -0.02368597313761711, -0.040405116975307465, -0.008782119490206242, 0.030613726004958153, 0.054870907217264175, -0.027244718745350838, 0.007742634043097496, 0.009094162844121456, 0.01666225492954254, 0.059726834297180176, -0.006798009388148785, 0.03792411461472511, -0.03393799439072609, 0.047373685985803604, -0.05078796669840813, -0.044730257242918015, -0.03193868696689606, -0.06197826564311981, -0.07349179685115814, 0.0031045665964484215, -0.00018194495351053774, -0.010265819728374481, 0.02532261796295643, -0.043905794620513916, 0.03441939130425453, -0.05735386908054352, 0.031166937202215195, -0.02194019965827465, -0.039310384541749954, -0.018678786233067513, -0.039115771651268005, -0.02457117661833763, -0.020161010324954987, 0.007850862108170986, -0.031020861119031906, -0.03722351789474487, -0.02152455411851406, -0.0415150448679924, -0.013974259607493877, 0.04612063243985176, 0.04059559851884842, 0.033122994005680084, -0.003380718408152461, 0.010790602304041386, 0.027354978024959564, -0.007837094366550446, 0.054809972643852234, -0.06256905943155289, -0.048186611384153366, 0.03177101910114288, -0.0025441476609557867, -0.03692493960261345, -0.03705799952149391, -0.023294314742088318, -0.06241795793175697, -0.005752634722739458, 0.026615764945745468, -0.021226827055215836, -0.020221881568431854, -0.0715031698346138, 0.006232903338968754, -0.04821476340293884, 0.06252680718898773, -0.014364397153258324, -0.03798184543848038, 0.07948682457208633, -0.007681876886636019, 0.013681246899068356, -0.022336339578032494, -0.01107580866664648, -0.05687638372182846, -0.049171146005392075, -0.017466092482209206, -0.029979318380355835, -0.002745432546362281, -0.06977307051420212, -0.0076336124911904335, -0.03636637702584267, 0.04122611880302429, -0.042769655585289, 0.03431031480431557, 0.020887818187475204, 0.033664509654045105, 0.030696237459778786, 0.034225694835186005, -0.009175939485430717, 0.014196578413248062, -0.03439735248684883, 0.04299712926149368, 0.011093766428530216, 0.031013939529657364, -0.03218769282102585, 0.05597127228975296, -0.06493490934371948, -0.01316418033093214, -0.03242587670683861, -0.023528888821601868, 0.04336674138903618, 0.0075556496158242226, -0.03444014489650726, 0.025689033791422844, 0.008222381584346294, 0.031629692763090134, -0.06013142317533493, -0.048228081315755844, -0.029145902022719383, -0.07196654379367828, 0.04774566739797592, -0.010248331353068352, -0.03140086680650711, -0.050460174679756165, -0.0016529933782294393, 0.009212390519678593, 0.0004223971045576036, -0.004847252741456032, 0.01953699253499508, 0.023139789700508118, 0.021925972774624825, 0.025687051936984062, -0.045074354857206345, -0.0678434818983078, 0.03713409975171089, -0.01293880958110094, -0.02259475737810135, -0.0015144571661949158, 0.00968247465789318, -0.055672213435173035, 0.057570189237594604, -0.07811018824577332, 0.06493625789880753, 0.03509172052145004, -0.015291796065866947, -0.05728339031338692, 0.019857903942465782, -0.004510778933763504, 0.013708299025893211, 0.011545431800186634, 0.027973966673016548, 0.00744236633181572, -0.025755157694220543, -0.02200559340417385, 0.00035074949846602976, -0.059258345514535904, -0.024344852194190025, -0.009857242926955223, 0.006682111881673336, -0.06812325865030289, -0.004346685484051704, 0.003892510663717985, -0.04211127385497093, -0.022998517379164696, 0.03855263441801071, 0.0453663133084774, -0.01767848990857601, -0.0632263571023941, -0.005420447327196598, -0.025978589430451393, 0.038121987134218216, 0.03586001321673393, -0.05468042567372322, -0.023220563307404518, 0.004105657339096069, 0.03201928734779358, 0.023037001490592957, -0.006327560171484947, -0.009901058860123158, -0.01277190912514925, 0.024665409699082375, -0.047319669276475906, -0.03694934397935867, -0.03020353987812996, -0.0726652443408966, 0.021332422271370888, 0.002979860408231616, 0.040283121168613434, 0.06546458601951599, 0.025087956339120865, -0.0062255291268229485, -0.041779085993766785, -0.04557699337601662, -0.04078259691596031, 0.020097393542528152, -0.020309140905737877, 0.0030171400867402554, -0.02219262905418873, 0.06388736516237259, -0.02008332870900631, -0.02930912934243679, 0.009766215458512306, -0.021669307723641396, -0.07447729259729385, -0.023205634206533432, -0.0124076958745718, 0.014986379072070122, -0.07248564064502716, 0.0008818642818368971, 0.039263252168893814, 0.001660892623476684, 0.05947962403297424, 0.04157131910324097, 0.019739069044589996, 0.004362268373370171, 0.027168696746230125, 0.0245442483574152, -0.05970131978392601, -0.010793042369186878, 0.07392469793558121, -0.07664848119020462, -0.013424946926534176, -0.05343441665172577, -0.04773060604929924, -0.024951446801424026, -0.04896906763315201, 0.04830237105488777, 0.06285862624645233, -0.05580650269985199, -0.07125066965818405, -0.001241561840288341, 0.004097035154700279, -0.05343806371092796, -0.0496336854994297, 0.011228595860302448, -0.05962647125124931, -0.012649714015424252, -0.00520536070689559, -0.012881427071988583, -0.006115018390119076, 0.019148753955960274, -0.05693730711936951, -0.06775372475385666, 0.002263628412038088, 0.045073337852954865, 0.023054704070091248, -0.06735647469758987, 0.004715217277407646, 0.038486577570438385, 0.018139341846108437, -0.030604582279920578, -0.03916266933083534, -0.008428837172687054, -0.003393019549548626, 0.0015729661099612713, 0.04314025491476059, -0.024899141862988472, 0.024473655968904495, -0.009786240756511688, -0.037138745188713074, -0.015339013189077377, 0.038422998040914536, 0.026615941897034645, 0.023069223389029503, -0.04508588835597038, -0.006850824691355228, -0.012726383283734322, -0.032671909779310226, -0.010211022570729256, -0.024429792538285255, 0.04241511970758438, 0.006347220856696367, 0.042595505714416504, 0.02843695506453514, 0.021360304206609726, 0.01704622618854046, -0.05856689065694809, -0.06040366366505623, 0.011276752687990665, -0.01858438365161419, -0.008961129933595657, 0.03506899252533913, 0.026805633679032326, 0.0008811242296360433, 0.005433976650238037, -0.06063215062022209, 0.010795734822750092, -0.02546265907585621, 0.012703269720077515, -0.03527015447616577, 0.05463290959596634, 0.03543122112751007, 0.009647563099861145, 0.034335166215896606, 0.006285822484642267, -0.028617657721042633, -0.03883573040366173, -0.07138404250144958, 0.0019295754609629512, -0.023810068145394325, -0.03293180838227272, 0.0022935352753847837, -0.009312942624092102, -0.05291697010397911, -0.022418098524212837, -0.0050919740460813046, -0.023013845086097717, -0.07132574170827866, -0.030824894085526466, 0.018595615401864052, -0.04325030744075775, 0.06053401157259941, 0.014880537986755371, 0.05908551067113876, -0.011854353360831738, 0.036537446081638336, 0.048911646008491516, 0.017389558255672455, 0.017396027222275734, -0.021198933944106102, -0.05186980217695236, 0.018530866131186485, -0.004294296260923147, 0.0035709915682673454, 0.01332789659500122, -0.05555691942572594, -0.07639888674020767, 0.033774133771657944, 0.028683379292488098, -0.007554322946816683, -0.01497572660446167, -0.03765542805194855, -0.0024971417151391506, 0.0269709974527359, 0.028252877295017242, -0.07956080883741379, 0.007671241648495197, -0.004964959342032671, -0.02642226219177246, -0.04475647956132889, -0.023603374138474464, -0.05607534572482109, 0.03228532150387764, -0.07003778964281082, -0.010069401934742928, -0.027564553543925285, 0.07772225141525269, 0.051545318216085434, 0.007997840642929077, 0.01613219641149044, -0.04258669540286064, 0.005178363528102636, 0.035907942801713943, 0.0019342857412993908, 0.03435589373111725, -0.025344062596559525, 0.00590975396335125, -0.05195775255560875, -0.0325239822268486, 0.04051987826824188, -0.04037201404571533, -0.03251969441771507, -0.03642437979578972, 0.04740582033991814, -0.023670654743909836, 0.027086123824119568, 0.02176566794514656, -0.016775188967585564, 0.03623948618769646, 0.0086727449670434, 0.01956079714000225, -0.05339007079601288, -0.06110348924994469, -0.04401896521449089, -0.03377622738480568, -0.027073724195361137, -0.00566822150722146, -0.00546302692964673, -0.006589692551642656, -0.06559190899133682, -0.06397934257984161, 0.012990914285182953, 0.02904537506401539, -0.014149992726743221, 0.0739789679646492, -0.06053285300731659, -0.01874183490872383, 0.022960856556892395, 0.0036724996753036976, -0.030421486124396324, 0.020252102985978127, 0.039027146995067596, -0.06280164420604706, 0.02422185428440571, -0.07694242149591446, 0.06529916077852249, -0.02567359246313572, -0.004412489477545023, -0.008019994013011456, 0.03718019276857376, -0.06786578893661499, -0.015462839975953102, -0.04329090937972069, 0.008240175433456898, -0.02147212252020836, -0.07047087699174881, -0.024372365325689316, 0.006775374058634043, 0.0030379618983715773, 0.03693461790680885, 0.020831923931837082, -0.034790441393852234, 0.059504374861717224, 0.033028170466423035, 0.01071535237133503, -0.026356633752584457, -0.03568332642316818, 0.015078798867762089, -0.03814241290092468, 0.018690600991249084, -0.03459528833627701, -0.04738597199320793, -0.014731970615684986, 0.016597004607319832, -0.0061246552504599094, 0.030227642506361008, 0.023777296766638756, -0.035469915717840195, -0.032182496041059494, -0.031071359291672707, 0.000015323254046961665, -0.03433603793382645, -0.03841303661465645, 0.01642424799501896, 0.008062385953962803, -0.00622937036678195, -0.03843744099140167 ]
The main aim of this paper is to develop extreme value theory for $\theta$-expansions. We get the limit distribution of the largest value of $\theta$-continued fraction mixing stationary stochastic process and some related results. These are analogous to J.Galambos and W.Philipp theorems for the regular continued fractions. We also have to note that a Borel-Bernstein type theorem plays an important role.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12654v1
[ 0.020195040851831436, -0.039104361087083817, 0.028780123218894005, 0.033754993230104446, 0.0006798597169108689, 0.0049279737286269665, -0.04250610992312431, -0.024360425770282745, -0.056810587644577026, 0.034801073372364044, -0.04614439234137535, -0.03996768966317177, -0.020649420097470284, -0.021065790206193924, -0.07812457531690598, -0.015630699694156647, 0.030537325888872147, 0.058449629694223404, 0.01162646058946848, 0.08182751387357712, -0.05131565034389496, 0.008124417625367641, 0.008842992596328259, 0.06240423768758774, 0.0267777182161808, -0.01253830548375845, -0.015534356236457825, 0.026388658210635185, -0.05498968064785004, -0.033380914479494095, 0.03735843300819397, 0.01228975597769022, -0.01574251987040043, -0.006392426323145628, 0.003969638142734766, 0.032877031713724136, -0.012433646246790886, 0.02312866970896721, 0.03783988952636719, -0.03592619299888611, 0.02232035994529724, -0.018367161974310875, -0.03498610854148865, 0.0024148316588252783, 0.02668021433055401, 0.021473374217748642, -0.060321636497974396, 0.021584630012512207, -0.05347582325339317, -0.08139416575431824, 0.03412269055843353, 0.01690092496573925, -0.004561421927064657, 0.053960613906383514, -0.061971984803676605, -0.028920117765665054, 0.04934900254011154, 0.017364652827382088, -0.04275814816355705, -0.01600673794746399, -0.012045982293784618, 0.028796521946787834, 0.006006116513162851, 0.004544567782431841, -0.031150925904512405, 0.0418999157845974, -0.016581617295742035, -0.02889879047870636, -0.048279959708452225, -0.0612022839486599, 0.003120327601209283, -0.017190974205732346, 0.022013509646058083, 0.046559352427721024, -0.06425533443689346, -0.0016810199012979865, 0.027603069320321083, -0.017460981383919716, 0.011433897539973259, 0.05816300958395004, -0.042005762457847595, 0.002715730108320713, -0.02750086784362793, -0.04279670864343643, 0.030595915392041206, 0.018143238499760628, 0.04658496007323265, -0.006380659993737936, 0.026684658601880074, -0.0026333967689424753, 0.01174247357994318, 0.037735678255558014, -0.048507630825042725, -0.050507739186286926, 0.021962344646453857, -0.02288231998682022, 0.055832162499427795, 0.042182039469480515, 0.022594312205910683, -0.02479327842593193, -0.02439570426940918, -0.055762674659490585, -0.006501949392259121, 0.01888146810233593, 0.03448935225605965, -0.011738545261323452, 0.010602959431707859, -0.026807738468050957, 0.005188980605453253, 0.05346914008259773, 0.0012790937907993793, 0.05443195253610611, -0.026911847293376923, -0.05288587883114815, -0.03287778049707413, -0.03528766706585884, 0.02085832506418228, 0.02411090023815632, 0.06196264550089836, 0.006830157712101936, -0.02980908937752247, 0.005286635830998421, 0.004381335806101561, 0.01884249970316887, -0.052136342972517014, -0.024085113778710365, -0.025021377950906754, 0.02633039280772209, -0.017949650064110756, -0.049863602966070175, -0.022320108488202095, -0.06480579823255539, 0.056741584092378616, -0.00003946549622924067, 0.04762649908661842, -0.015033140778541565, -0.015238236635923386, -0.013434741646051407, 0.043480370193719864, 0.023294677957892418, -0.05200115963816643, -0.06559442728757858, 0.035726744681596756, 0.044828496873378754, -0.004155136179178953, 0.03619983047246933, -0.04699571430683136, 0.004011127166450024, 0.04522431641817093, 0.027958745136857033, -0.008708619512617588, 0.008465254679322243, -0.02918163500726223, 0.02661382406949997, 0.00839835125952959, 0.0403171069920063, 0.059724289923906326, -0.01678626984357834, -0.03446686640381813, 0.0232226699590683, 0.025248248130083084, -0.049400150775909424, -0.023651709780097008, 0.03888888284564018, 0.008203865960240364, -0.006858093198388815, -0.00976080447435379, -0.02807105891406536, -0.013502655550837517, -0.0010984718101099133, -0.014437001198530197, 0.00897836685180664, -0.00883617252111435, -0.05353694409132004, -0.06589678674936295, -0.025631899014115334, -0.04149531573057175, -0.0596197210252285, -0.019820841029286385, 0.02252126671373844, 0.04341007396578789, -0.03573335334658623, -0.03086000122129917, -0.037131309509277344, -0.013138570822775364, 0.027999520301818848, -0.048750586807727814, -0.0016510393470525742, 0.06881092488765717, 0.042644742876291275, 0.005204478278756142, -0.0023555075749754906, 0.005689583253115416, 0.010269725695252419, -0.02190886251628399, -0.027004249393939972, 0.05245767906308174, -0.0328349731862545, -0.0622066929936409, -0.002741078846156597, -0.07339974492788315, -0.05711705982685089, -0.034683458507061005, -0.0014149080961942673, 0.008942093700170517, -0.05515126883983612, 0.028167065232992172, 0.053036388009786606, -0.015120657160878181, -0.019087087363004684, 0.05015303194522858, 0.027519840747117996, 0.041516248136758804, -0.01723981834948063, -0.01472370233386755, -0.010803086683154106, -0.1065659150481224, 0.041502803564071655, 0.03151461109519005, -0.04798233509063721, -0.022389207035303116, 0.025785161182284355, -0.0016394061967730522, -0.003997880965471268, -0.027736201882362366, 0.058275844901800156, 0.034460801631212234, 0.05074635520577431, -0.055159587413072586, -0.015001961961388588, -0.009310968220233917, -0.05370873212814331, -0.02842721715569496, -0.06379774212837219, 0.009510931558907032, 0.051538389176130295, -0.021473510190844536, 0.04026378318667412, -0.010573044419288635, -0.08193855732679367, -0.010876466520130634, -0.008802824653685093, 0.06706497818231583, 0.020023709163069725, -0.014792717061936855, -0.03230280056595802, -0.051243871450424194, -0.03915058821439743, -0.06225252524018288, -0.03788968548178673, 0.006453368347138166, -0.04000496119260788, -0.04175081476569176, -0.0013517338084056973, 0.0317208431661129, -0.019236624240875244, -0.02377292513847351, 0.049231547862291336, 0.009394966065883636, -0.030750034376978874, 0.015171630308032036, 0.0016239687101915479, 0.02763928659260273, 0.02053612470626831, 0.00874735414981842, 0.06290962547063828, -0.03982143849134445, -0.006353492382913828, -0.019467664882540703, 0.015853697434067726, 0.016145190224051476, 0.03345170244574547, 0.04406678304076195, -0.017329497262835503, -0.005364479497075081, -0.03826238960027695, -0.03618676960468292, -0.00229858816601336, 0.017710067331790924, 0.0375700369477272, 0.045242056250572205, 0.050949033349752426, -0.06271804124116898, -0.06834845244884491, -0.016896169632673264, 0.01814671792089939, -0.030407605692744255, -0.05316324159502983, -0.06488018482923508, 0.021371396258473396, -0.06300703436136246, 0.03592855483293533, -0.009271426126360893, -0.06980632245540619, -0.06691815704107285, -0.07270301878452301, 0.0000239763903664425, -0.05089479684829712, 0.01470808032900095, -0.05809303745627403, -0.0506008043885231, 0.012392493896186352, 0.052540186792612076, 0.0022573252208530903, 0.04401105269789696, -0.049787357449531555, -0.019700784236192703, 0.030529528856277466, 0.02603250928223133, -0.04362890124320984, -0.03559640422463417, -0.04857039451599121, -0.0289535541087389, 0.035931553691625595, -0.03599190339446068, 0.0191239845007658, 0.012521463446319103, -0.025570129975676537, 0.00765180541202426, -0.02366655133664608, -0.05699150636792183, 0.007214764598757029, 0.01396250445395708, -0.024770740419626236, -0.05782003328204155, 0.01316788885742426, 0.03867018222808838, 0.008594504557549953, 0.014059575274586678, -0.06523594260215759, -0.05664985254406929, -0.02040119096636772, 0.021752456203103065, 0.03513655811548233, 0.06486130505800247, 0.06322962790727615, -0.00945753138512373, -0.06884267181158066, -0.0028281507547944784, 0.04489731788635254, -0.005594079848378897, 0.05929603800177574, 0.006311563774943352, -0.06617584824562073, 0.05425766855478287, -0.08958665281534195, 0.04250325635075569, 0.08330528438091278, 0.01560906134545803, -0.047398485243320465, -0.029049266129732132, 0.02977079711854458, -0.018702097237110138, -0.010920409113168716, -0.014411823824048042, -0.04679010808467865, 0.05967237055301666, 0.027362195774912834, -0.0321868434548378, 0.014417598955333233, -0.020733756944537163, -0.05419129133224487, -0.04783223941922188, -0.0164718609303236, 0.007374126929789782, 0.06414823234081268, 0.037584926933050156, 0.022301124408841133, 0.013842250220477581, -0.032036952674388885, 0.05504268780350685, -0.0028966814279556274, -0.0004618980747181922, 0.024432480335235596, 0.031369276344776154, 0.03273636847734451, 0.0022271962370723486, 0.0001226519962074235, 0.024908998981118202, -0.04358416423201561, 0.0009470441727899015, -0.012475553900003433, 0.05867941305041313, 0.05078713595867157, -0.0022906975354999304, 0.010823722928762436, 0.001789269968867302, -0.043186288326978683, 0.03098851814866066, -0.009074772708117962, -0.015376686118543148, -0.029250606894493103, 0.011203129775822163, -0.007997717708349228, -0.018057357519865036, -0.02353288047015667, 0.017657103016972542, 0.0034772497601807117, -0.012279178015887737, 0.006526560056954622, -0.029853854328393936, 0.017215369269251823, -0.06369932740926743, -0.0773201510310173, -0.023157892748713493, -0.00784787442535162, -0.025528768077492714, 0.0026810895651578903, -0.051839686930179596, 0.06199357658624649, -0.025217698886990547, -0.010406007058918476, -0.04593238607048988, -0.06805513054132462, -0.025239912793040276, -0.04261670634150505, -0.036843929439783096, 0.021794304251670837, 0.03224841132760048, -0.04147768020629883, 0.015762217342853546, -0.03615507110953331, -0.043775949627161026, -0.05263693630695343, -0.008045178838074207, 0.03835892304778099, 0.00015345400606747717, 0.0559522844851017, -0.01901896856725216, 0.003787373425439, 0.04266512393951416, -0.007961904630064964, 0.008668296039104462, -0.03154423087835312, 0.01223096251487732, -0.02278146892786026, -0.049243420362472534, -0.06338498741388321, -0.009551863186061382, -0.03004041314125061, -0.01644335500895977, 0.06281273812055588, -0.0559270903468132, -0.011608216911554337, -0.016623975709080696, 0.051219742745161057, -0.05104910582304001, -0.04831906035542488, 0.029836827889084816, -0.028414977714419365, 0.007814235985279083, -0.005046383943408728, 0.02645288035273552, -0.019923394545912743, -0.047483742237091064, 0.04609595239162445, 0.007352942600846291, 0.01914762333035469, -0.028180910274386406, -0.026636704802513123, -0.012426999397575855, 0.03866567462682724, -0.02081180177628994, -0.04621608182787895, -0.03467835858464241, -0.009570399299263954, -0.02064565382897854, -0.038016851991415024, 0.04005017876625061, 0.053766973316669464, -0.020968329161405563, 0.05621785297989845, -0.08811230957508087, 0.0026518364902585745, 0.022014491260051727, -0.024365004152059555, -0.02722235396504402, 0.0470292791724205, -0.02012568898499012, 0.009740784764289856, -0.017095383256673813, -0.031365327537059784, 0.0268727894872427, -0.026652876287698746, -0.008919494226574898, -0.022875308990478516, -0.022671379148960114, 0.013823514804244041, 0.039847828447818756, -0.016301386058330536, -0.029620224609971046, 0.04311312362551689, 0.00403396924957633, 0.007038258947432041, -0.065627820789814, 0.02595997415482998, -0.01364172250032425, -0.06213732808828354, -0.07730750739574432, -0.017665408551692963, -0.016515372321009636, -0.03789930418133736, 0.062432099133729935, -0.019114790484309196, 0.008088141679763794, 0.007807464804500341, -0.0014135201927274466, 0.009812424890697002, 0.018667833879590034, -0.025031108409166336, -0.012783259153366089, -0.025541070848703384, 0.020086314529180527, -0.05509568750858307, -0.012949377298355103, -0.03324460610747337, -0.00042090690112672746, -0.02989908494055271, -0.01839437708258629, -0.024000555276870728, 0.046278394758701324, 0.0399608351290226, -0.04371391609311104, -0.04447096213698387, 0.015353991650044918, 0.026472976431250572, -0.02438071370124817, -0.05666327476501465, 0.02634783647954464, 0.04077776148915291, -0.0006586296949535608, -0.017101507633924484, 0.034002210944890976, -0.03109324723482132, -0.007315424270927906, 0.03816285356879234, 0.035300590097904205, 0.006973381154239178, -0.004568804521113634, -0.01197496522217989, 0.058678850531578064, 0.0037045972421765327, 0.08273100107908249, 0.030021993443369865, 0.04327276721596718, -0.017684074118733406, 0.027952665463089943, 0.019001703709363937, -0.02924516424536705, -0.041047558188438416, 0.0572100467979908, -0.057021722197532654, 0.0058568618260324, -0.011669672094285488, -0.03201216459274292, -0.007562181446701288, -0.03873061761260033, 0.01992618478834629, -0.004122833721339703, -0.016037415713071823, -0.048805028200149536, 0.06983789056539536, 0.022985199466347694, -0.05456050857901573, 0.0015054040122777224, 0.05497434735298157, -0.08515894412994385, 0.022131267935037613, 0.022115370258688927, -0.04637977108359337, -0.009440216235816479, 0.01998223550617695, -0.03131658956408501, -0.05890040472149849, -0.03201264515519142, 0.036098696291446686, 0.010956340469419956, -0.06843698769807816, 0.035633351653814316, 0.014238388277590275, -0.06133526191115379, 0.00009934303670888767, 0.00902432482689619, -0.0019885937217622995, -0.007581687532365322, 0.02831103652715683, -0.04305652901530266, -0.01795998401939869, -0.01394705194979906, 0.030736401677131653, -0.07133062928915024, 0.0006822290597483516, -0.027436191216111183, 0.001064470037817955, 0.02395116537809372, -0.02412627823650837, -0.03594253212213516, -0.017723511904478073, 0.052713219076395035, -0.02184203639626503, -0.054918184876441956, 0.007330377120524645, -0.03989459574222565, 0.028869321569800377, -0.029387857764959335, -0.025131620466709137, 0.017219919711351395, 0.021077165380120277, 0.0008212327375076711, 0.010643969289958477, -0.029785821214318275, -0.021107621490955353, -0.026557935401797295, 0.024806488305330276, -0.012481209821999073, 0.017896605655550957, -0.05121413618326187, 0.02473975531756878, 0.0006442143931053579, -0.03143149986863136, 0.014413667842745781, 0.02838977798819542, 0.03209260478615761, -0.027371332049369812, 0.05313970148563385, -0.04196256399154663, 0.06849874556064606, -0.064358651638031, -0.06284081935882568, 0.03306841105222702, 0.03816083446145058, -0.05283477157354355, -0.032573893666267395, -0.022006558254361153, -0.05814104899764061, -0.0469595231115818, -0.03385505825281143, -0.012184986844658852, -0.06403995305299759, 0.003062637522816658, 0.0479276217520237, 0.003283839439973235, -0.011345898732542992, 0.00419064424932003, -0.02034982480108738, 0.006285938899964094, -0.0075669302605092525, 0.08163150399923325, 0.020396407693624496, -0.013302819803357124, -0.033691029995679855, 0.015649225562810898, -0.009134692139923573, -0.022829603403806686, 0.026230860501527786, -0.01647881604731083, -0.06101274862885475, -0.0870349258184433, -0.008693222887814045, -0.00562373548746109, -0.02377740480005741, 0.0180216021835804, -0.06932874023914337, 0.03337172791361809, 0.020802216604351997, 0.017433244735002518, -0.050466109067201614, 0.004751431290060282, 0.0634036436676979, -0.012931867502629757, -0.00372977158986032, -0.024371648207306862, -0.037234220653772354, 0.0026372489519417286, -0.08610996603965759, 0.002995384158566594, -0.0015962093602865934, 0.003618319984525442, 0.019788706675171852, 0.05577928572893143, -0.05380870774388313, -0.019123805686831474, 0.02779279090464115, -0.020815422758460045, -0.009639878757297993, 0.04683511331677437, -0.012162623926997185, 0.01798328198492527, -0.031518563628196716, 0.016888733953237534, 0.005680355709046125, 0.010236336849629879, 0.003919802140444517, 0.01057684887200594, 0.015501086600124836, -0.029942115768790245, 0.018504761159420013, 0.05260903760790825, 0.01938982680439949, -0.015787895768880844, -0.010905898176133633, -0.052731409668922424, -0.03496125340461731, -0.05027931556105614, 0.05352232605218887, -0.039318282157182693, 0.028541533276438713, -0.009351100772619247, 0.004099920392036438, -0.004587529227137566, 0.022897308692336082, -0.027467964217066765, -0.00819284189492464, -0.020008616149425507, -0.020627934485673904, -0.003957361448556185, -0.02711915783584118, 0.00978307705372572, 0.0028769068885594606, -0.010128634981811047, -0.07330106943845749, -0.03754761815071106, 0.05954206734895706, -0.04183625802397728, 0.0577024482190609, -0.07694314420223236, 0.0020050795283168554, -0.020639246329665184, 0.06315398216247559, 0.0673890933394432, 0.0049513280391693115, -0.047764573246240616, 0.05348491668701172, -0.041092272847890854, -0.024695582687854767, 0.014547626487910748, -0.05399473011493683, -0.032705556601285934, -0.02821953594684601, 0.040954798460006714, -0.01090038102120161, 0.04677639529109001, -0.046631403267383575, 0.06647025048732758, 0.024883154779672623, -0.027426332235336304, -0.03522276505827904, -0.012885402888059616, -0.070677749812603, 0.06046340987086296, -0.003778110956773162, -0.04058919474482536, -0.018338892608880997, 0.046596791595220566, 0.014698473736643791, -0.04198829457163811, 0.0015384323196485639, -0.0018580112373456359, -0.02137116715312004, -0.044577114284038544, -0.04154302179813385, 0.03386695683002472, 0.010192980989813805, -0.05185192450881004, -0.012947702780365944, 0.017249321565032005, -0.0031639558728784323, -0.045298438519239426 ]
In the evaluation of the half-life of the neutrinoless double-$\beta$ decay ($0\nu\beta\beta$) of a doubly closed-subshell nucleus $^{96}$Zr, the structure of the nucleus $^{96}$Mo is essentially important. The $\alpha$-clustering aspects of $^{96}$Mo are investigated for the first time. By studying the nuclear rainbows in $\alpha$ scattering from $^{92}$Zr at high energies and the characteristic structure of the excitation functions at the extreme backward angle at the low-energy region, the interaction potential between the $\alpha$ particle and the $^{92}$Zr nucleus is determined well in the double folding model. The validity of the double folding model was reinforced by studying $\alpha$ scattering from neighboring nuclei $^{90}$Zr, $^{91}$Zr, and $^{94}$Zr. The double-folding-model calculations reproduced well all the observed angular distributions over a wide range of incident energies and the characteristic excitation functions. By using the obtained potential the $\alpha$ +$^{92}$Zr cluster structure of $^{96}$Mo is investigated in the spirit of a unified description of scattering and structure. The existence of the second-higher nodal band states with the $\alpha$+ $^{92}$Zr cluster structure, in which two more nodes are excited in the relative motion compared with the ground band, is demonstrated. The calculation reproduces well the ground-band states of $^{96}$Mo in agreement with experiment. The experimental $B(E2)$ value of the transition in the ground band is also reproduced well. The effect of $\alpha$ clustering in $^{96}$Mo on the the half-life of the $0\nu\beta\beta$ double-$\beta$ decay of $^{96}$Zr is discussed.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17777v1
[ -0.06574372202157974, -0.023950867354869843, 0.043856892734766006, -0.011268691159784794, 0.0030970878433436155, -0.012282920069992542, -0.007911213673651218, 0.039331477135419846, -0.011189034208655357, -0.02626453898847103, -0.0012060415465384722, -0.04463454708456993, 0.01986665464937687, -0.008685696870088577, -0.042931489646434784, 0.049608998000621796, 0.04010699689388275, 0.06973942369222641, -0.018193984404206276, 0.08059760928153992, 0.04373777657747269, -0.053293753415346146, -0.02961709536612034, 0.05378277599811554, 0.008808596059679985, -0.02424565516412258, -0.03954341635107994, 0.019266080111265182, -0.016997411847114563, -0.06202167272567749, 0.05676250532269478, -0.03571762144565582, -0.032682958990335464, -0.03955540806055069, -0.0029995469376444817, 0.017914792522788048, -0.03445505350828171, 0.055473990738391876, -0.0007050068234093487, -0.018129104748368263, 0.048695050179958344, -0.05233609676361084, -0.050371479243040085, -0.04787144437432289, -0.002936271484941244, -0.047832243144512177, -0.04600220546126366, -0.02941567450761795, -0.06521347910165787, -0.048950519412755966, -0.01833196170628071, 0.006816856097429991, 0.05588114634156227, 0.031341005116701126, -0.03842491656541824, -0.010208028368651867, 0.0014793198788538575, 0.013669444248080254, -0.06098724529147148, 0.0396457314491272, -0.005777454003691673, -0.016333607956767082, -0.016143765300512314, -0.034765731543302536, -0.03814129903912544, 0.058419689536094666, -0.04812943935394287, -0.016140975058078766, 0.018453793600201607, -0.04599572718143463, 0.029144765809178352, -0.05040284991264343, -0.005026176106184721, 0.006243528798222542, -0.06536581367254257, 0.006230104714632034, -0.026654217392206192, -0.0018312373431399465, -0.0419592447578907, 0.026137787848711014, 0.007838728837668896, 0.004184754099696875, -0.0012830864870920777, 0.03091142512857914, 0.0015866373432800174, -0.0024786917492747307, 0.05556856095790863, -0.013676624745130539, 0.015807438641786575, -0.03790245205163956, -0.019449451938271523, 0.008318670094013214, -0.049253933131694794, 0.03880514204502106, 0.04052251577377319, -0.03512038290500641, 0.0700966864824295, 0.02899620309472084, 0.05109284818172455, -0.01484428159892559, 0.02249450795352459, -0.031106822192668915, -0.014852575957775116, 0.0019255731021985412, 0.02472662925720215, -0.020080441609025, 0.023920755833387375, 0.02262010984122753, -0.03687479719519615, 0.03723359853029251, 0.04749980941414833, -0.02349899150431156, 0.0011259682942181826, -0.007137720473110676, -0.03849509730935097, -0.06985695660114288, 0.06486833840608597, 0.0405963659286499, -0.005425761919468641, 0.016582943499088287, -0.009463504888117313, 0.04187621921300888, 0.005808349698781967, -0.03003845177590847, 0.0023062117397785187, 0.012443283572793007, 0.041212912648916245, -0.0032558985985815525, -0.01457587257027626, -0.040951769798994064, 0.02874944731593132, 0.002629767172038555, 0.048059314489364624, -0.023878809064626694, 0.015315893106162548, -0.02653798647224903, -0.008685766719281673, -0.03550614044070244, -0.006626941729336977, -0.043752990663051605, -0.02372218854725361, -0.07042905688285828, 0.05059616640210152, -0.007210421841591597, 0.024332966655492783, 0.029047323390841484, -0.06622499972581863, 0.013943270780146122, 0.030842263251543045, 0.032057374715805054, -0.014925241470336914, 0.03464113548398018, -0.0016796855488792062, -0.009077010676264763, -0.01958242431282997, -0.014215163886547089, 0.0496458038687706, 0.0004074202151969075, -0.04443676397204399, 0.007914353162050247, 0.027244742959737778, -0.003064216347411275, 0.01717967353761196, 0.012031624093651772, -0.016689615324139595, 0.030043549835681915, -0.0026232926174998283, -0.027037138119339943, 0.01147106010466814, 0.03014436922967434, -0.0307957474142313, 0.041300952434539795, -0.0013578020734712481, -0.0343126580119133, -0.061235394328832626, -0.0439295694231987, -0.009118136018514633, -0.00022787688067182899, -0.04417232424020767, 0.004001704975962639, 0.03913489356637001, 0.016118332743644714, -0.02934500202536583, -0.002836952917277813, -0.05438495799899101, 0.03991859406232834, -0.06849508732557297, 0.04057404398918152, 0.042696163058280945, -0.026844043284654617, -0.016377944499254227, -0.05541224777698517, 0.02868853695690632, 0.0000023117465843824903, -0.04730696603655815, -0.020404478535056114, -0.014021999202668667, 0.01171910110861063, 0.020041542127728462, -0.0011660908348858356, -0.054183557629585266, -0.026799917221069336, -0.03352043405175209, 0.024684997275471687, 0.025953220203518867, -0.07485124468803406, 0.04435041919350624, 0.0512969084084034, -0.02590012364089489, -0.06042502075433731, 0.06358882039785385, 0.029001278802752495, -0.01271033938974142, -0.046658895909786224, -0.02893081121146679, -0.030459007248282433, -0.08723047375679016, 0.06252213567495346, 0.049076858907938004, -0.02643873728811741, 0.0637042298913002, -0.0007303868187591434, -0.020136602222919464, -0.044284917414188385, 0.01673397421836853, 0.05456537753343582, 0.06023789569735527, -0.04894023761153221, -0.05219331756234169, 0.029284687712788582, 0.01828838512301445, -0.07716226577758789, -0.048091575503349304, -0.05957797169685364, 0.02633855864405632, -0.011196021921932697, -0.03720588982105255, 0.07075320929288864, 0.006957841105759144, -0.040741510689258575, -0.04567328095436096, 0.003578661475330591, -0.009291687048971653, 0.009388361126184464, -0.04232218116521835, -0.03200524300336838, -0.05567891150712967, -0.03963443636894226, -0.025891458615660667, -0.022256165742874146, 0.030677370727062225, -0.029684633016586304, -0.0545039176940918, 0.0195446889847517, 0.062262777239084244, -0.006117436569184065, -0.015983445569872856, 0.01487373374402523, -0.014843884855508804, 0.03562374785542488, -0.003329072380438447, 0.03619864210486412, -0.03874959424138069, 0.015471069142222404, -0.005751536227762699, 0.017086172476410866, -0.07441795617341995, -0.03367925062775612, -0.0014259027084335685, -0.005148229189217091, -0.010130809620022774, 0.002687936881557107, 0.04285917803645134, 0.01624688133597374, 0.024871069937944412, -0.04370380565524101, -0.030049117282032967, -0.02201208658516407, 0.02152208238840103, -0.04890893027186394, 0.059938929975032806, 0.04397799074649811, 0.013504277914762497, -0.06560184806585312, -0.01080945786088705, -0.05268700048327446, -0.03320159390568733, -0.06301944702863693, -0.05144752562046051, -0.03774486109614372, -0.06349457055330276, -0.03841337189078331, -0.04715665057301521, -0.053041938692331314, -0.035488661378622055, -0.05282464623451233, -0.029936274513602257, 0.012632668949663639, -0.013433088548481464, -0.07589849084615707, -0.021416954696178436, -0.011634629219770432, -0.006187712773680687, 0.05385498329997063, -0.0514354407787323, -0.020626846700906754, -0.04733000323176384, 0.0012089340016245842, -0.00998386088758707, -0.014786319807171822, -0.025329645723104477, 0.028847163543105125, -0.0670490488409996, -0.008536385372281075, 0.009146471507847309, 0.06592708826065063, 0.04904920235276222, -0.05107143148779869, -0.013632591813802719, -0.01608257181942463, -0.0024129392113536596, -0.02202858217060566, -0.024345336481928825, -0.02194151282310486, -0.03327079862356186, -0.04282333701848984, 0.07253827154636383, 0.06439974159002304, -0.027038367465138435, -0.04965118318796158, -0.05711640790104866, -0.025876523926854134, 0.019140681251883507, -0.05173415690660477, 0.06755813211202621, 0.0128124775364995, -0.009386822581291199, 0.00180436996743083, -0.02726154215633869, 0.03334798291325569, -0.005354221444576979, -0.042468637228012085, 0.02174866758286953, -0.004129097796976566, 0.026336977258324623, -0.060171712189912796, 0.04458029568195343, 0.05561025068163872, 0.06505928188562393, -0.027137435972690582, 0.015307167544960976, 0.03150487691164017, 0.025083130225539207, 0.01295565627515316, -0.03814287856221199, 0.05269164219498634, 0.05062396824359894, 0.021065551787614822, -0.009634210728108883, 0.00287593062967062, -0.0072596436366438866, -0.058230191469192505, -0.014648779295384884, 0.017309866845607758, 0.01846614107489586, 0.05409185215830803, 0.012301327660679817, -0.03787488490343094, 0.024446362629532814, -0.01954534836113453, -0.021202342584729195, -0.03158975765109062, -0.06438921391963959, 0.03290863335132599, -0.046057265251874924, -0.021205442026257515, 0.00974744651466608, 0.01518819760531187, -0.004175072070211172, -0.06393162906169891, 0.020803146064281464, -0.04280854016542435, 0.0009529991657473147, -0.017252162098884583, 0.008690445683896542, 0.026420075446367264, -0.008737945929169655, -0.022370388731360435, 0.03151511400938034, -0.021678119897842407, 0.012174759060144424, -0.053589243441820145, 0.009393444284796715, 0.026438726112246513, 0.0359155647456646, -0.030285602435469627, -0.022561090067029, -0.012391065247356892, -0.05694930627942085, -0.03509265556931496, 0.0597965382039547, 0.0162308681756258, -0.011361339129507542, -0.07594817876815796, -0.021717041730880737, -0.03713527321815491, -0.01811332441866398, -0.019220508635044098, -0.019657883793115616, 0.06361347436904907, 0.025645721703767776, -0.02289528399705887, 0.013318106532096863, -0.027956556528806686, -0.03444590047001839, -0.055723488330841064, -0.034955162554979324, -0.015231541357934475, 0.048377182334661484, -0.055635154247283936, 0.028351448476314545, -0.054004862904548645, -0.020194659009575844, -0.05981391295790672, 0.025679511949419975, 0.006076655816286802, 0.04244817793369293, 0.0015282995300367475, 0.018002716824412346, 0.06073262542486191, 0.01960749551653862, -0.016818208619952202, 0.014552854001522064, -0.037104781717061996, 0.06352850049734116, -0.05020029842853546, 0.024352122098207474, -0.03946904093027115, -0.05827706307172775, -0.025054210796952248, -0.014099129475653172, 0.05164371803402901, -0.014664792455732822, -0.0041766236536204815, -0.02184351533651352, -0.016541393473744392, -0.025256982073187828, -0.02406926080584526, -0.05609513074159622, -0.022248901426792145, -0.030567297711968422, 0.00790384691208601, -0.01055471133440733, -0.002372763818129897, 0.03694207966327667, 0.04023861140012741, 0.021276721730828285, 0.01512167602777481, -0.02022560127079487, 0.04092607647180557, 0.0029579137917608023, 0.024504519999027252, -0.011650954373180866, -0.02849983237683773, -0.07648921757936478, 0.005169234238564968, 0.010995094664394855, 0.004233797546476126, 0.02707737684249878, 0.006648818030953407, -0.037831343710422516, 0.029574351385235786, -0.07508867233991623, -0.0045150225050747395, 0.07234921306371689, -0.029332512989640236, -0.025608832016587257, -0.014712417498230934, -0.02783394232392311, -0.02897048555314541, -0.006451786030083895, 0.010980725288391113, 0.021297834813594818, 0.0189324039965868, -0.017078720033168793, 0.006567058619111776, -0.032967809587717056, 0.014007920399308205, 0.005021665710955858, 0.02294880896806717, -0.05038027837872505, 0.01382241491228342, 0.025918448343873024, -0.024399423971772194, -0.026405297219753265, 0.06237990781664848, 0.029409362003207207, -0.021137714385986328, -0.05605139955878258, -0.027539115399122238, 0.03612016886472702, -0.0018517281860113144, 0.05415584146976471, -0.0135880745947361, 0.02064371109008789, 0.022165030241012573, 0.016623226925730705, 0.03275245428085327, 0.05317559093236923, 0.031361453235149384, -0.06051606684923172, -0.0299233365803957, -0.06351523101329803, -0.048879921436309814, -0.043308764696121216, -0.006561429239809513, 0.011105251498520374, 0.017340276390314102, 0.007893694564700127, 0.03427496179938316, 0.04945804551243782, -0.015605024993419647, -0.032734744250774384, -0.0432589091360569, -0.01596786081790924, 0.0612809844315052, -0.000993836554698646, 0.009066675789654255, -0.03406137973070145, -0.008324705995619297, -0.000944086816161871, -0.05880492180585861, -0.0022999385837465525, -0.018882712349295616, -0.05291170999407768, -0.020823314785957336, 0.05782931298017502, 0.013610322028398514, -0.009982539340853691, -0.032821834087371826, 0.05070219561457634, -0.043019577860832214, 0.03042934276163578, 0.01984827034175396, 0.030729500576853752, 0.016656935214996338, 0.008931794203817844, 0.04150383546948433, -0.06859017163515091, -0.01000744104385376, 0.0637325868010521, -0.037678830325603485, 0.02831050381064415, -0.05533747375011444, -0.046263232827186584, -0.010322993621230125, -0.06800443679094315, -0.05945026874542236, 0.024969270452857018, -0.023270148783922195, -0.03191573917865753, 0.0709330141544342, -0.009114894084632397, -0.07708628475666046, 0.04580145329236984, -0.02223164215683937, -0.06970667093992233, -0.035619668662548065, -0.008241859264671803, -0.02553434856235981, -0.06184597685933113, 0.023296115919947624, -0.04428645223379135, -0.05994343385100365, -0.02349504828453064, 0.01672518439590931, 0.04627280309796333, -0.050895076245069504, 0.004113674629479647, 0.052003681659698486, 0.03237021714448929, -0.006132904905825853, -0.04309391602873802, -0.03416869044303894, -0.020524561405181885, 0.07542260736227036, -0.0005880268290638924, 0.006011728662997484, -0.03458920121192932, 0.02813146822154522, 0.0013686887687072158, 0.032819341868162155, 0.04255380108952522, 0.01184807252138853, 0.018011262640357018, -0.005419091321527958, -0.019492056220769882, 0.010462123900651932, -0.05764215812087059, 0.00128680479247123, -0.04730349779129028, 0.03097059205174446, -0.02529866062104702, 0.00036551800440065563, 0.008206895552575588, -0.024476414546370506, -0.022286642342805862, -0.042677026242017746, -0.016547415405511856, 0.023879896849393845, -0.03481584042310715, 0.016361692920327187, 0.014275110326707363, 0.043253518640995026, 0.01024276576936245, 0.04135793820023537, -0.03788740187883377, -0.054433658719062805, -0.046279340982437134, 0.023651104420423508, -0.01925939880311489, 0.03178950399160385, -0.04732736572623253, -0.06222807988524437, 0.06643453240394592, 0.017545882612466812, 0.03834254667162895, -0.02122499980032444, -0.0665309876203537, 0.005156727973371744, -0.004530513659119606, -0.043473515659570694, -0.03128939867019653, -0.00784902274608612, -0.03794407472014427, -0.017825160175561905, 0.04894906282424927, -0.038397304713726044, -0.06442856788635254, -0.03169730678200722, -0.03255733475089073, -0.021731946617364883, 0.05781790614128113, -0.028932640329003334, 0.05257142707705498, 0.0015851426869630814, 0.023548487573862076, 0.03832617029547691, 0.014843392185866833, -0.013162486255168915, -0.035484492778778076, -0.012034337967634201, 0.004387626424431801, 0.02648126520216465, -0.01581783965229988, -0.05579962581396103, -0.04302484914660454, -0.08042588084936142, 0.022515377029776573, -0.03089328110218048, 0.007061341777443886, -0.004794349428266287, -0.053289398550987244, 0.040878236293792725, 0.013964857906103134, 0.05047370493412018, -0.08449114114046097, -0.04505188763141632, 0.00445309653878212, -0.03470325842499733, 0.015058433637022972, 0.024630915373563766, -0.010467884130775928, 0.04133284091949463, -0.06879981607198715, -0.023839250206947327, -0.018097180873155594, 0.023922687396407127, 0.012485402636229992, -0.05242188647389412, -0.025630513206124306, -0.02952498570084572, -0.05769505351781845, 0.04557664692401886, 0.027948161587119102, 0.021393781527876854, 0.027638129889965057, 0.0008453525369986892, -0.01685907505452633, 0.0009730169549584389, 0.02363523654639721, -0.03915538266301155, -0.02874141000211239, 0.030093679204583168, 0.0008986621396616101, -0.03732115030288696, -0.04420368745923042, 0.005759127903729677, -0.04485418647527695, 0.018744921311736107, -0.013102632015943527, -0.05290977284312248, -0.013088910840451717, -0.05211296305060387, 0.003042753553017974, -0.04400264099240303, -0.0049357241950929165, -0.023928144946694374, -0.029463380575180054, -0.031297117471694946, -0.045989785343408585, -0.012617819011211395, 0.009840930812060833, 0.03892987221479416, -0.027985652908682823, 0.04035715386271477, -0.05716807022690773, 0.00696779927238822, -0.032820265740156174, -0.006466721650213003, -0.0001742365857353434, 0.01522810012102127, 0.02492198720574379, -0.07642729580402374, 0.031511615961790085, -0.0615074522793293, 0.008104206994175911, -0.039718147367239, -0.001566210063174367, -0.0026655984111130238, 0.048215776681900024, -0.05553753674030304, -0.004735781345516443, -0.03792077675461769, -0.0007418936584144831, 0.008908648043870926, -0.07492917776107788, 0.0011941788252443075, -0.049415431916713715, 0.06230643391609192, 0.04062169790267944, -0.025731541216373444, -0.04173349216580391, 0.07734259963035583, 0.006097785197198391, -0.02381792850792408, -0.017263595014810562, -0.0536225289106369, -0.013744588010013103, -0.010450688190758228, -0.013824543915688992, -0.06346196681261063, -0.04698263853788376, 0.039972178637981415, 0.02586532197892666, -0.013379418291151524, 0.008815809153020382, -0.017524471506476402, -0.04774818941950798, -0.01224721409380436, -0.05731575936079025, 0.05268220603466034, 0.03599542751908302, -0.006260511465370655, 0.045214686542749405, -0.010557564906775951, -0.02335566096007824, -0.041575271636247635 ]
Early detection of cardiac dysfunction through routine screening is vital for diagnosing cardiovascular diseases. An important metric of cardiac function is the left ventricular ejection fraction (EF), where lower EF is associated with cardiomyopathy. Echocardiography is a popular diagnostic tool in cardiology, with ultrasound being a low-cost, real-time, and non-ionizing technology. However, human assessment of echocardiograms for calculating EF is time-consuming and expertise-demanding, raising the need for an automated approach. In this work, we propose using the M(otion)-mode of echocardiograms for estimating the EF and classifying cardiomyopathy. We generate multiple artificial M-mode images from a single echocardiogram and combine them using off-the-shelf model architectures. Additionally, we extend contrastive learning (CL) to cardiac imaging to learn meaningful representations from exploiting structures in unlabeled data allowing the model to achieve high accuracy, even with limited annotations. Our experiments show that the supervised setting converges with only ten modes and is comparable to the baseline method while bypassing its cumbersome training process and being computationally much more efficient. Furthermore, CL using M-mode images is helpful for limited data scenarios, such as having labels for only 200 patients, which is common in medical applications.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03759v1
[ -0.00037503059138543904, -0.020826134830713272, 0.0032791830599308014, 0.012444027699530125, -0.04182352125644684, -0.025617273524403572, 0.01964079774916172, 0.014278060756623745, 0.014292511157691479, -0.021650854498147964, -0.011602845042943954, -0.040986958891153336, -0.024074267596006393, -0.0016409402014687657, -0.05419745296239853, 0.03432070463895798, 0.09158314019441605, 0.017495689913630486, -0.044221773743629456, 0.06020487844944, 0.04290180653333664, -0.010297800414264202, -0.025741487741470337, -0.004842053633183241, 0.030323754996061325, -0.021743057295680046, -0.036849718540906906, -0.0031227166764438152, -0.02215951681137085, -0.011752559803426266, 0.07892090082168579, -0.0382588692009449, -0.009562875144183636, -0.028357088565826416, -0.016879554837942123, -0.008112740702927113, 0.033714745193719864, 0.02916003204882145, -0.011858424171805382, -0.04488871619105339, 0.07432931661605835, -0.03960024565458298, -0.0552198626101017, -0.005256672855466604, -0.012377794831991196, -0.04774357005953789, -0.05578077584505081, -0.015132445842027664, -0.06901444494724274, -0.011634325608611107, 0.05179601162672043, -0.010601429268717766, -0.019434981048107147, 0.07038608193397522, -0.02983914129436016, 0.02610887587070465, -0.007012323942035437, 0.012436962686479092, -0.06576430052518845, -0.018603838980197906, 0.0169345922768116, -0.01995120570063591, -0.024874838069081306, -0.012929734773933887, 0.014841745607554913, 0.0543740876019001, -0.0044911750592291355, -0.07123621553182602, -0.04658711701631546, -0.04013923555612564, 0.058462321758270264, -0.07075541466474533, 0.027841711416840553, 0.008105711080133915, -0.029717493802309036, -0.02318921685218811, 0.004737840499728918, -0.018239447847008705, -0.016468094661831856, 0.0064167059026658535, -0.03526417538523674, 0.03114739991724491, -0.008794301189482212, 0.014439546503126621, 0.01711762510240078, -0.0277340617030859, 0.08077454566955566, -0.025027522817254066, -0.04419543594121933, -0.05389842763543129, 0.03418990969657898, -0.03672655671834946, -0.053790945559740067, 0.011347196996212006, 0.009522479958832264, -0.05501503124833107, 0.0639348179101944, 0.04623577743768692, 0.009240471757948399, 0.032546285539865494, 0.0270713921636343, -0.0004899227642454207, 0.014362220652401447, 0.06355472654104233, 0.03736136108636856, -0.06821061670780182, 0.00918541755527258, -0.06921173632144928, -0.0485888347029686, 0.019491059705615044, -0.03523106127977371, -0.04597596824169159, -0.021728023886680603, -0.05375475063920021, -0.0553867407143116, -0.0010627921437844634, 0.05868534371256828, 0.02680923603475094, -0.005856588948518038, 0.014754313975572586, -0.015753621235489845, 0.03133293613791466, 0.007802085485309362, -0.018002334982156754, 0.033700790256261826, 0.0025799027644097805, 0.06506766378879547, 0.0032904446125030518, -0.023383265361189842, -0.06235373392701149, -0.028148507699370384, 0.03656050190329552, 0.000897791818715632, 0.02323845960199833, -0.018254099413752556, -0.00677516357973218, -0.038777828216552734, -0.040573690086603165, 0.03788938745856285, 0.013364984653890133, -0.02586592361330986, -0.07477180659770966, 0.033354949206113815, -0.03479628637433052, -0.040670644491910934, 0.06147410720586777, -0.0532725565135479, -0.0070679099299013615, 0.04902758449316025, 0.026426030322909355, -0.009275641292333603, 0.020595047622919083, 0.04170183464884758, 0.005065917037427425, 0.011295340023934841, -0.008946605958044529, 0.06508569419384003, 0.006813386455178261, -0.03935432806611061, 0.01672695204615593, 0.0014923413982614875, -0.03425435721874237, 0.009854973293840885, -0.02625146694481373, 0.042656343430280685, -0.012647242285311222, 0.030069613829255104, 0.03578498959541321, -0.03240747004747391, 0.031379178166389465, -0.05435940995812416, -0.027360927313566208, 0.03023722395300865, 0.0019818972796201706, -0.06188081577420235, 0.012063049711287022, 0.03321307897567749, -0.05103292688727379, -0.027931377291679382, 0.026551632210612297, -0.010863550938665867, 0.033973366022109985, -0.019608749076724052, -0.004865705501288176, -0.0006170404958538711, -0.029990410432219505, -0.09425786137580872, 0.008076684549450874, 0.021308371797204018, 0.018042592331767082, -0.05881708487868309, 0.022973569110035896, 0.027249732986092567, 0.017321359366178513, -0.020337669178843498, -0.022971687838435173, 0.016760889440774918, -0.010679922997951508, 0.020887697115540504, 0.0522802397608757, -0.0925925150513649, -0.012387234717607498, -0.01677950844168663, -0.022164924070239067, -0.005220864433795214, -0.06373799592256546, 0.0014024190604686737, 0.004095712210983038, -0.04346313327550888, -0.0014092841884121299, 0.04664887115359306, 0.06244833022356033, 0.04577813297510147, 0.033682309091091156, 0.061060935258865356, -0.014193549752235413, -0.10682594776153564, 0.07308027893304825, -0.022107364609837532, -0.03401167318224907, 0.02333691343665123, -0.0045840502716600895, -0.030729033052921295, -0.02159813791513443, -0.027154548093676567, 0.05918180197477341, 0.05631430447101593, -0.004355293232947588, -0.03475169092416763, -0.04110134392976761, -0.021747073158621788, -0.05932458117604256, -0.06618635356426239, -0.046000827103853226, -0.012755620293319225, 0.028730787336826324, -0.032468318939208984, 0.027711860835552216, 0.0036867994349449873, -0.060673657804727554, -0.04693169519305229, 0.0346149317920208, 0.023305922746658325, -0.012190300971269608, -0.08121638000011444, -0.040304236114025116, -0.026788368821144104, 0.0063753509894013405, -0.022476352751255035, 0.0010422097984701395, -0.0018610504921525717, -0.05527476966381073, 0.03052978590130806, -0.024720748886466026, 0.01487565878778696, 0.062122274190187454, -0.0032100570388138294, -0.02045855112373829, -0.015873754397034645, 0.02519434504210949, 0.009212489239871502, 0.03761642798781395, -0.05045445263385773, 0.019025053828954697, 0.052797652781009674, 0.004252782091498375, 0.006642292253673077, 0.041485417634248734, 0.020428277552127838, -0.02403142862021923, -0.010734313167631626, 0.040961723774671555, 0.03779473900794983, -0.010928499512374401, -0.01229909248650074, -0.02569943107664585, -0.01652383990585804, -0.04998613893985748, -0.0050660171546041965, 0.02438988909125328, 0.003565739607438445, -0.0054941726848483086, 0.024477114900946617, -0.07827594131231308, -0.03257586807012558, -0.07913424074649811, -0.022342823445796967, -0.05729274824261665, -0.06329692900180817, -0.004997064359486103, -0.06223754584789276, 0.0037025525234639645, -0.0516936220228672, -0.03736279904842377, -0.04001978784799576, -0.0474376417696476, -0.025787372142076492, -0.02976102940738201, 0.0536479726433754, -0.004710394423455, -0.047461528331041336, -0.02078334055840969, 0.013096383772790432, 0.017670126631855965, 0.014905352145433426, -0.04709300026297569, -0.057445693761110306, -0.00905559491366148, 0.03430180251598358, -0.046465810388326645, 0.018471023067831993, 0.021977316588163376, -0.03576749190688133, 0.013859221711754799, 0.017238259315490723, 0.01908445730805397, 0.01647805981338024, -0.023222098127007484, -0.022241782397031784, -0.020352059975266457, -0.004461970180273056, -0.012201071716845036, 0.014756685122847557, -0.029959525913000107, -0.026512619107961655, -0.0019387640058994293, 0.06834183633327484, 0.026757728308439255, -0.03604848310351372, -0.0268846582621336, -0.023271961137652397, -0.02459695003926754, 0.01973448507487774, -0.011398090049624443, 0.0005715331644751132, 0.028693219646811485, -0.04692794010043144, -0.029505813494324684, -0.03696884214878082, 0.01930879056453705, -0.04918774589896202, 0.007473401725292206, -0.06961978226900101, 0.029808497056365013, 0.050411149859428406, -0.08891028165817261, 0.03795219585299492, 0.01481259148567915, 0.0798691064119339, 0.016574816778302193, 0.005416760686784983, 0.04100984334945679, 0.01443057507276535, 0.01386877242475748, 0.016424918547272682, -0.0008489394094794989, 0.04429350793361664, 0.049048975110054016, 0.020962093025445938, -0.033465638756752014, -0.0038367712404578924, -0.07066375017166138, -0.04982011765241623, 0.0011513683712109923, 0.05472539737820625, -0.017887761816382408, 0.01993892528116703, -0.06729450076818466, 0.043697506189346313, -0.009995496831834316, 0.05577801167964935, -0.017244452610611916, -0.036906078457832336, 0.03805159777402878, -0.016062341630458832, 0.03501944616436958, 0.016073687002062798, 0.018695907667279243, 0.021408598870038986, -0.04540187492966652, 0.013833235949277878, -0.06901121884584427, 0.03693009540438652, 0.013284941203892231, -0.038906365633010864, 0.05313354358077049, 0.05574662610888481, 0.0011288527166470885, 0.029568731784820557, -0.050847094506025314, -0.02506912499666214, -0.03394187614321709, -0.028827596455812454, 0.005303515121340752, 0.023142807185649872, -0.04493444785475731, 0.0074980235658586025, 0.02669333480298519, -0.011078739538788795, -0.021568601951003075, -0.012475451454520226, 0.044134192168712616, -0.05257381498813629, -0.08105003088712692, -0.025665901601314545, -0.06846614181995392, 0.0184637438505888, -0.020753826946020126, -0.04167385399341583, 0.0788106918334961, -0.03891556337475777, -0.015199669636785984, -0.043836064636707306, 0.012647761963307858, -0.014031483791768551, -0.050938092172145844, 0.0021387883462011814, -0.08595828711986542, 0.02237989753484726, -0.05252489075064659, 0.04233960434794426, -0.006834190338850021, -0.021637873724102974, -0.08841092884540558, -0.021217435598373413, -0.017907574772834778, 0.016114620491862297, 0.011112966574728489, -0.018748078495264053, -0.02422739379107952, -0.0015677788760513067, 0.000989939784631133, -0.026676766574382782, -0.014801227487623692, 0.003419147804379463, -0.04883738234639168, 0.023433474823832512, -0.02710762992501259, -0.0344657376408577, -0.03372114151716232, -0.028628790751099586, 0.08006121963262558, -0.009068633429706097, -0.012602635659277439, -0.026181727647781372, 0.0006242662202566862, -0.07476932555437088, -0.042610760778188705, -0.02792329154908657, -0.047720663249492645, -0.0250060074031353, -0.025852413848042488, 0.03594491630792618, -0.004051334224641323, 0.02248043194413185, 0.04451725259423256, 0.060606107115745544, 0.029161516577005386, -0.005193579010665417, 0.027503320947289467, 0.0019521478097885847, -0.010250629857182503, -0.0406227670609951, -0.041199032217264175, -0.0842278003692627, -0.025586111471056938, -0.0010449487017467618, 0.020441586151719093, 0.0119539899751544, 0.0674099549651146, -0.0028255865909159184, 0.013132757507264614, -0.09150990843772888, 0.032744020223617554, -0.010382021777331829, -0.031430311501026154, 0.05450574681162834, 0.06300197541713715, -0.027288567274808884, 0.06640426814556122, -0.02755446545779705, -0.002114069415256381, -0.005902922712266445, -0.061646103858947754, -0.02827286534011364, -0.0031198167707771063, -0.006463589146733284, -0.007361723575741053, 0.05485648661851883, -0.017145797610282898, -0.0758523941040039, 0.03067971020936966, 0.03184979408979416, -0.013206806033849716, -0.054484497755765915, 0.03873596340417862, 0.03699050843715668, -0.012837878428399563, -0.052081529051065445, 0.017949489876627922, -0.004560246132314205, 0.007688693702220917, 0.048610515892505646, -0.033871494233608246, -0.025348078459501266, 0.03294479846954346, -0.035912178456783295, 0.010337759740650654, 0.04024803638458252, 0.006465652491897345, 0.0018148972885683179, 0.007873632945120335, 0.030377207323908806, -0.038739901036024094, -0.0501084066927433, -0.021339688450098038, 0.01586371473968029, -0.0031162803061306477, 0.016359644010663033, 0.04109201952815056, -0.026337891817092896, -0.041015565395355225, -0.03706977516412735, -0.009605388157069683, 0.03719961270689964, 0.0452597439289093, -0.054095152765512466, 0.016003714874386787, 0.0009788664756342769, 0.011381926015019417, 0.02605903148651123, 0.02808578871190548, 0.015969209372997284, -0.016196515411138535, 0.011527705937623978, 0.006826843600720167, 0.03560333326458931, -0.039185501635074615, -0.06496670097112656, 0.04168184474110603, 0.03401694446802139, 0.0032873963937163353, 0.018718689680099487, 0.019944021478295326, 0.0023459873627871275, 0.046569567173719406, -0.017953529953956604, -0.005532919429242611, -0.047552820295095444, 0.01454756036400795, 0.06046249344944954, -0.06579867750406265, 0.01151212863624096, -0.0002516488020773977, -0.014079798012971878, -0.0009589549154043198, -0.056700777262449265, 0.02435438707470894, 0.036801163107156754, -0.0016697399551048875, -0.04157156124711037, 0.03220200911164284, -0.007354972418397665, -0.08215279132127762, 0.004518209025263786, 0.036296743899583817, -0.04862060397863388, 0.025989005342125893, 0.024096932262182236, -0.0014925784198567271, -0.03694703057408333, 0.026287714019417763, -0.027601400390267372, -0.03254460543394089, -0.05360794439911842, 0.0334271565079689, 0.07966192811727524, -0.021889319643378258, 0.036797359585762024, 0.03262806683778763, -0.029741106554865837, 0.018850918859243393, -0.03475182130932808, 0.010276892222464085, 0.003597051603719592, 0.04389799386262894, -0.013252470642328262, -0.04757285863161087, -0.04884989932179451, 0.07729526609182358, -0.04926510527729988, 0.005389987025409937, 0.02440791390836239, 0.0009630817221477628, 0.05610502138733864, 0.005886571016162634, -0.04218507185578346, 0.0032044106628745794, -0.012180170975625515, -0.011657524853944778, -0.03644142299890518, 0.011038951575756073, 0.03480900079011917, 0.005754015874117613, -0.025648780167102814, -0.042400699108839035, 0.020182454958558083, -0.00890774093568325, -0.05572979152202606, -0.0016489798435941339, -0.07956087589263916, -0.01846076175570488, 0.018266698345541954, 0.04293778911232948, 0.03509237617254257, 0.060188766568899155, -0.005660845432430506, -0.030010249465703964, 0.05837216228246689, 0.0013903012732043862, 0.0009027560008689761, -0.023685520514845848, 0.013015919364988804, -0.015692397952079773, 0.023341411724686623, -0.017974616959691048, -0.042481228709220886, 0.02613000199198723, -0.03672034665942192, -0.00332156615331769, -0.022984936833381653, -0.04332660511136055, -0.051729824393987656, 0.025095604360103607, -0.037132032215595245, 0.023937571793794632, -0.0010600293753668666, -0.015028051100671291, -0.06420119106769562, -0.027428779751062393, -0.02941860258579254, 0.0026086862199008465, 0.023487266153097153, 0.01986629329621792, 0.03603924438357353, 0.005792008712887764, 0.007893089205026627, -0.0016543372767046094, 0.006038622464984655, -0.0022021844051778316, -0.03689880296587944, -0.03672358766198158, 0.02250852808356285, -0.00738992914557457, -0.04393468052148819, 0.0003034619730897248, -0.0224198866635561, -0.07913471758365631, 0.01865396648645401, 0.04652804136276245, 0.03181091696023941, 0.0431893989443779, -0.05358752980828285, 0.0474676638841629, -0.0027868885081261396, -0.010546511970460415, -0.08291637897491455, -0.0353834331035614, 0.029257817193865776, 0.025843216106295586, 0.004340127110481262, -0.030870458111166954, -0.03468462824821472, -0.015798592939972878, -0.09396316856145859, -0.007602861151099205, -0.016193976625800133, 0.04749253764748573, -0.03916404768824577, -0.05019789934158325, 0.039094824343919754, -0.05603909492492676, 0.028771821409463882, 0.04514104127883911, 0.007380235940217972, 0.03601749241352081, 0.017173320055007935, -0.02541249990463257, -0.077992744743824, 0.006078238133341074, 0.013553299941122532, -0.03477371111512184, 0.02451685070991516, 0.022774962708353996, 0.01303981151431799, 0.02135186456143856, 0.01877586916089058, 0.043801531195640564, -0.018704066053032875, 0.05179222673177719, -0.022569462656974792, 0.005694686435163021, -0.046731650829315186, -0.046133093535900116, 0.03870397061109543, -0.03748466446995735, -0.022295646369457245, -0.010322454385459423, -0.004541329573839903, 0.011251713149249554, -0.010470349341630936, -0.05097956582903862, -0.0006299346568994224, -0.03489449620246887, -0.0029932509642094374, 0.014097596518695354, -0.022289257496595383, -0.0038276612758636475, -0.019414441660046577, -0.006648369133472443, -0.03884332254528999, 0.03908767178654671, 0.007590040564537048, -0.022174401208758354, -0.003380777779966593, -0.06391929090023041, -0.014225177466869354, -0.0564282089471817, 0.007665945217013359, -0.03736633434891701, 0.06283047050237656, 0.0015000392450019717, -0.037201881408691406, -0.02668432705104351, -0.04810018464922905, 0.0006397017277777195, -0.02107062004506588, -0.01038056705147028, -0.021850934252142906, 0.013742761686444283, -0.029807185754179955, 0.012372142635285854, 0.007939379662275314, 0.07682241499423981, 0.0639071986079216, 0.03453263267874718, -0.023649998009204865, -0.03541157767176628, -0.03684955835342407, 0.05151133984327316, -0.008528251200914383, 0.03146442025899887, -0.031823351979255676, 0.021812917664647102, -0.012328955344855785, 0.005418218672275543, -0.011197265237569809, -0.008464946411550045, 0.024831922724843025, -0.06796491146087646, -0.02512691728770733, -0.020170923322439194, -0.02811482921242714, -0.019042933359742165, -0.025856338441371918, 0.016504161059856415, -0.058151956647634506, -0.04210814833641052 ]
Image camouflage has been utilized to create clean-label poisoned images for implanting backdoor into a DL model. But there exists a crucial limitation that one attack/poisoned image can only fit a single input size of the DL model, which greatly increases its attack budget when attacking multiple commonly adopted input sizes of DL models. This work proposes to constructively craft an attack image through camouflaging but can fit multiple DL models' input sizes simultaneously, namely OmClic. Thus, through OmClic, we are able to always implant a backdoor regardless of which common input size is chosen by the user to train the DL model given the same attack budget (i.e., a fraction of the poisoning rate). With our camouflaging algorithm formulated as a multi-objective optimization, M=5 input sizes can be concurrently targeted with one attack image, which artifact is retained to be almost visually imperceptible at the same time. Extensive evaluations validate the proposed OmClic can reliably succeed in various settings using diverse types of images. Further experiments on OmClic based backdoor insertion to DL models show that high backdoor performances (i.e., attack success rate and clean data accuracy) are achievable no matter which common input size is randomly chosen by the user to train the model. So that the OmClic based backdoor attack budget is reduced by M$\times$ compared to the state-of-the-art camouflage based backdoor attack as a baseline. Significantly, the same set of OmClic based poisonous attack images is transferable to different model architectures for backdoor implant.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04036v2
[ -0.041083402931690216, -0.00706309312954545, 0.013494919054210186, -0.033924639225006104, 0.0056678298860788345, 0.05594346672296524, -0.010374091565608978, -0.021228011697530746, 0.04618510231375694, -0.03541174158453941, -0.009307789616286755, 0.00973797868937254, -0.0005800811341032386, -0.062287718057632446, -0.0240547563880682, 0.0037083555944263935, 0.07654496282339096, 0.006305414251983166, -0.036388590931892395, 0.06124097481369972, 0.0028130472637712955, -0.015277998521924019, -0.07124502956867218, 0.04800209030508995, -0.012970393523573875, 0.012155978009104729, -0.011002915911376476, 0.05783067271113396, -0.05140485614538193, -0.016320310533046722, 0.06272406131029129, 0.009259040467441082, -0.01745952107012272, -0.07753781974315643, -0.022143948823213577, 0.02401832304894924, -0.03409546613693237, 0.028895244002342224, -0.008887385949492455, -0.017592469230294228, 0.07553699612617493, -0.04399626702070236, -0.042861390858888626, -0.03162665292620659, -0.021456921473145485, 0.028500651940703392, -0.024102985858917236, 0.03074105642735958, -0.03493089973926544, -0.0286012664437294, 0.021582497283816338, -0.001123572583310306, 0.003813148709014058, 0.03346489742398262, -0.02724563702940941, 0.0008554421365261078, 0.024141354486346245, 0.033583469688892365, -0.07176285237073898, -0.024534547701478004, 0.024373970925807953, -0.008369704708456993, -0.060730691999197006, -0.03204077109694481, -0.012269367463886738, 0.054740339517593384, 0.04033283144235611, -0.05711931362748146, -0.02697223611176014, -0.03769027441740036, 0.061175864189863205, -0.04916924238204956, -0.03652559220790863, 0.03918503224849701, -0.0705866888165474, -0.017297646030783653, -0.04503107815980911, -0.021259497851133347, -0.020954402163624763, -0.01053664181381464, -0.022717753425240517, 0.036836158484220505, -0.018233388662338257, 0.02899860218167305, -0.012812110595405102, 0.01785748079419136, 0.03996562585234642, -0.03184564411640167, 0.02494308166205883, -0.04966361075639725, 0.04117317497730255, -0.025936393067240715, -0.08382471650838852, -0.004948905203491449, 0.07153888046741486, -0.05820521339774132, 0.06253927946090698, -0.0006191057036630809, 0.046375952661037445, 0.02112920954823494, -0.022312594577670097, -0.012632963247597218, -0.017670145258307457, 0.0047050900757312775, 0.04455282911658287, -0.05390697717666626, 0.04227827861905098, 0.02548089064657688, -0.0392196923494339, 0.038062818348407745, -0.022889485582709312, -0.05094734951853752, 0.016083410009741783, -0.006206859368830919, -0.0336521714925766, -0.03485626354813576, 0.048607490956783295, -0.047865331172943115, 0.010392098687589169, 0.0281267948448658, -0.03068561665713787, 0.03264768421649933, 0.04710153490304947, -0.034848619252443314, 0.01767643541097641, -0.04408864304423332, 0.06682972609996796, -0.026605499908328056, 0.010868644341826439, -0.01951717771589756, -0.03496737778186798, -0.040421538054943085, -0.0229495819658041, -0.020265497267246246, 0.016169503331184387, -0.01399810891598463, -0.023063668981194496, -0.05174100771546364, 0.0014323184732347727, -0.010759900324046612, -0.0011035706847906113, -0.058355897665023804, 0.04691321402788162, -0.030189726501703262, -0.026301223784685135, 0.04178399592638016, -0.04150018095970154, -0.026402026414871216, 0.02151401713490486, 0.016034729778766632, 0.0148056261241436, 0.014265062287449837, -0.0024832552298903465, 0.041884493082761765, -0.03429993987083435, 0.004067331552505493, 0.022378822788596153, -0.01786988601088524, -0.05013582482933998, 0.006971171125769615, -0.03703983500599861, 0.009413670748472214, -0.0054203723557293415, -0.0441458635032177, 0.01971481926739216, 0.008170580491423607, 0.0031685444992035627, -0.019523300230503082, 0.03124656341969967, 0.029539579525589943, 0.0018029891652986407, -0.03835597634315491, -0.01930094324052334, 0.02772839367389679, -0.02312302030622959, -0.0014240822056308389, -0.009745736606419086, -0.046825505793094635, -0.04920921102166176, 0.0005259155295789242, 0.018706655129790306, -0.02932307869195938, -0.039735402911901474, -0.01413041539490223, -0.008919772692024708, -0.011779758147895336, -0.07259920239448547, -0.009525720030069351, 0.045495521277189255, 0.03459162637591362, -0.05853907763957977, -0.04116642102599144, 0.0007117305067367852, 0.026165837422013283, 0.016044916585087776, -0.023443851619958878, -0.05419342964887619, -0.02373530901968479, 0.03842674940824509, 0.04748871922492981, -0.08424562960863113, 0.025493809953331947, -0.05339954048395157, 0.05241154506802559, -0.027657436206936836, -0.04500243812799454, 0.001574641210027039, 0.027328919619321823, -0.0580618791282177, -0.028132038190960884, 0.06530939042568207, 0.014322541654109955, 0.04105683043599129, 0.006967896595597267, 0.03827795386314392, 0.014100288040935993, -0.09452042728662491, 0.05095316842198372, 0.013331763446331024, -0.00863755214959383, 0.05032766982913017, -0.02273673750460148, -0.014924058690667152, -0.0838274359703064, -0.02955387718975544, 0.06787292659282684, 0.0701768547296524, -0.036710262298583984, -0.05838930234313011, -0.04784766957163811, -0.030058996751904488, -0.04284839332103729, 0.03747357800602913, -0.07094322890043259, -0.037743519991636276, -0.05403173342347145, 0.013784847222268581, 0.04052414372563362, -0.01081981509923935, -0.006497938651591539, -0.0049098217859864235, 0.01754623092710972, -0.015957657247781754, -0.0010369590017944574, -0.05457406863570213, -0.01215802039951086, 0.022909430786967278, 0.01005161926150322, -0.0272726621478796, 0.05200786143541336, -0.052849117666482925, 0.004032982978969812, -0.016785403713583946, -0.018559563905000687, 0.04461114481091499, 0.04652359336614609, 0.011783021502196789, -0.0001009052139124833, 0.0069467779248952866, 0.036856312304735184, 0.04647144302725792, 0.04838791489601135, -0.05230666697025299, -0.011202278546988964, 0.036170799285173416, -0.02689773589372635, -0.06741007417440414, -0.0005006564315408468, 0.009494908154010773, -0.0329916886985302, 0.0031250386964529753, 0.017809534445405006, 0.044395994395017624, 0.0642649307847023, 0.042301565408706665, -0.010989180766046047, -0.04506631940603256, -0.02830636501312256, -0.004821123089641333, -0.019218608736991882, 0.017159217968583107, -0.01665225811302662, -0.028619304299354553, -0.07163262367248535, -0.01780400052666664, -0.0542556531727314, -0.01809733174741268, -0.04990182816982269, -0.0010650730691850185, -0.05141633749008179, -0.08459299057722092, -0.052910275757312775, -0.031053336337208748, -0.0006971861002966762, -0.017907284200191498, -0.07163015753030777, -0.03561932221055031, -0.022615056484937668, 0.01425945945084095, -0.018237119540572166, -0.042734112590551376, -0.025289034470915794, 0.005889254622161388, 0.023775000125169754, -0.00965349841862917, -0.06315138936042786, -0.07704032957553864, -0.043744686990976334, 0.016085905954241753, -0.04183105751872063, -0.028056202456355095, 0.05580925568938255, 0.007093177642673254, 0.014792758971452713, 0.004552754107862711, 0.04940866678953171, 0.01689140871167183, -0.030949147418141365, 0.022042738273739815, -0.03177258372306824, -0.005718082655221224, -0.030138647183775902, 0.03509623929858208, -0.048397086560726166, -0.03066161274909973, -0.0048650773242115974, 0.03924451395869255, -0.003590512787923217, -0.053353678435087204, -0.03449494019150734, 0.0033893962390720844, 0.018043743446469307, 0.04221014305949211, -0.0340985544025898, 0.027249818667769432, 0.0408836230635643, -0.06469219923019409, -0.022227412089705467, -0.00525004044175148, -0.016675587743520737, -0.007584395352751017, 0.004832820501178503, -0.05967248976230621, -0.005806844215840101, 0.06499600410461426, -0.08842989057302475, 0.03283848986029625, 0.018829885870218277, 0.04827939346432686, -0.008273791521787643, 0.049251507967710495, -0.028227658942341805, 0.01777864433825016, -0.014876223169267178, 0.02887428179383278, 0.012664981186389923, 0.05806790292263031, 0.04678121209144592, -0.013513696379959583, -0.06855785846710205, 0.0203347560018301, -0.05246724560856819, 0.017906149849295616, 0.01878930628299713, 0.00479546096175909, 0.018744483590126038, -0.000891223200596869, -0.028769660741090775, 0.04887959733605385, -0.005118745379149914, 0.03723795339465141, -0.0023969325702637434, -0.026547400280833244, 0.030173595994710922, -0.03468110039830208, 0.013635151088237762, 0.04629567638039589, 0.018862877041101456, 0.00521562434732914, -0.054199542850255966, 0.0479467399418354, -0.05131974816322327, 0.05138924717903137, 0.041588783264160156, -0.03643812611699104, 0.03250206634402275, 0.0582081638276577, 0.023585602641105652, 0.030711762607097626, -0.010831649415194988, -0.05512576550245285, -0.04100752994418144, 0.04040544480085373, 0.021908557042479515, 0.030676139518618584, -0.019664470106363297, -0.032768309116363525, 0.0354781299829483, -0.07414981722831726, -0.0033679986372590065, 0.03111492469906807, -0.024558421224355698, 0.02677479386329651, -0.046643584966659546, 0.013452832587063313, -0.044645652174949646, 0.031214140355587006, -0.00033016331144608557, -0.008486639708280563, 0.0018989950185641646, -0.059708014130592346, 0.03340262547135353, -0.008938402868807316, 0.0004055078898090869, 0.006196566391736269, -0.05236350744962692, 0.010498828254640102, -0.05346238985657692, 0.015523790381848812, -0.04814952611923218, 0.05775152146816254, 0.047124896198511124, -0.01209445483982563, -0.01083808857947588, -0.00046864873729646206, -0.0073945410549640656, 0.027639975771307945, 0.06081005558371544, -0.019451366737484932, -0.044607456773519516, 0.005393122788518667, 0.0017186948098242283, -0.026485182344913483, -0.015782354399561882, -0.006782837677747011, -0.043653469532728195, -0.006118084769695997, 0.04139896482229233, -0.035188570618629456, 0.002453917171806097, -0.037391260266304016, 0.0006639208295382559, -0.033359769731760025, -0.040581025183200836, -0.000561532739084214, 0.015931958332657814, -0.08484842628240585, -0.05973537638783455, 0.024379849433898926, -0.041657160967588425, -0.0407186895608902, -0.035042982548475266, 0.022358715534210205, 0.0657884031534195, 0.03016955591738224, 0.029320277273654938, 0.010926715098321438, -0.006844782270491123, 0.038239993155002594, 0.013139916583895683, 0.03850565478205681, -0.03823775798082352, -0.033433862030506134, -0.012407917529344559, -0.07595793902873993, -0.014931916259229183, -0.012711548246443272, 0.01265451405197382, 0.007001523394137621, 0.04854154959321022, 0.001450442592613399, 0.041846245527267456, -0.06047138199210167, -0.007249285001307726, 0.021770119667053223, -0.061941877007484436, 0.041217055171728134, 0.036123838275671005, -0.006113480310887098, 0.033960599452257156, -0.037812262773513794, 0.023474859073758125, -0.0014689634554088116, -0.05212646350264549, -0.03981592878699303, 0.0006666526314802468, -0.010586717166006565, -0.030540769919753075, 0.039303336292505264, 0.004752058535814285, -0.043618809431791306, 0.010441092774271965, 0.003022826975211501, -0.027293125167489052, -0.04430502653121948, 0.0641455128788948, -0.026491830125451088, -0.045203596353530884, -0.02894025482237339, 0.025932352989912033, 0.010069004260003567, 0.010865467600524426, -0.021215030923485756, -0.03745284304022789, -0.036366384476423264, 0.047733500599861145, -0.033677488565444946, -0.0142861632630229, 0.03159279003739357, 0.03643278032541275, -0.053008366376161575, -0.04621591046452522, -0.004586289171129465, -0.030735254287719727, -0.0322953462600708, 0.006150187458842993, 0.01781630888581276, 0.053618382662534714, 0.0252107921987772, 0.015660356730222702, 0.0186979528516531, -0.03415592387318611, -0.008485519327223301, 0.016428567469120026, -0.023450622335076332, 0.019509894773364067, -0.04000256210565567, 0.026006102561950684, -0.017629964277148247, -0.023167366161942482, -0.03291226550936699, -0.002973544178530574, -0.03315858915448189, 0.008457908406853676, 0.0025005333591252565, 0.0017217922722920775, 0.0534784272313118, -0.06141228228807449, -0.04365870729088783, 0.024581680074334145, 0.03847349435091019, -0.04692252352833748, 0.03144697844982147, 0.020655138418078423, -0.02934710681438446, 0.026129893958568573, -0.025491897016763687, -0.040279876440763474, -0.05380178242921829, -0.011312072165310383, -0.0005573813105002046, -0.05125730112195015, -0.002877197926864028, -0.052038781344890594, -0.030482109636068344, 0.02104857750236988, -0.0636017918586731, -0.05478125810623169, 0.01983763463795185, 0.014005441218614578, 0.0011482906993478537, 0.06420671939849854, -0.03257380425930023, -0.07104399055242538, 0.0344560481607914, 0.008486819453537464, -0.057762499898672104, -0.020069323480129242, 0.019088178873062134, -0.0038878419436514378, -0.050837114453315735, 0.054246339946985245, 0.0021151830442249775, 0.005912331864237785, -0.01364718098193407, 0.06242946535348892, 0.08018513768911362, -0.010906158946454525, 0.03225262835621834, 0.024843228980898857, -0.04280337691307068, 0.04256048426032066, -0.06098918989300728, -0.004794894251972437, 0.04618076980113983, 0.03413502871990204, -0.010021469555795193, -0.02570231445133686, -0.03214029595255852, 0.038085076957941055, -0.04732251167297363, 0.016648437827825546, 0.03542199358344078, -0.03856253623962402, 0.060400158166885376, -0.004471513908356428, -0.003615292953327298, 0.01002489309757948, -0.04988059401512146, 0.009782969020307064, -0.06636642664670944, 0.02231036312878132, 0.0031300720293074846, -0.040136709809303284, 0.030598202720284462, -0.07447929680347443, 0.005241173319518566, -0.03298605978488922, -0.0726688876748085, -0.0024601630866527557, -0.03894425556063652, 0.03272009268403053, 0.027108188718557358, 0.02303764596581459, 0.013280405662953854, 0.0560084693133831, -0.019658507779240608, -0.03445878624916077, -0.005125776864588261, 0.004902996122837067, -0.0066184052266180515, -0.006169368512928486, 0.0014292777050286531, -0.03315635770559311, 0.0021956132259219885, -0.05415612831711769, 0.024131055921316147, 0.007331055123358965, -0.015429574996232986, 0.054254330694675446, -0.03361434116959572, -0.07123120874166489, -0.038906898349523544, -0.0016578094800934196, -0.06259095668792725, 0.037799011915922165, -0.012913093902170658, -0.0494556687772274, -0.07532093673944473, 0.020828528329730034, -0.022994911298155785, -0.02765999175608158, 0.06263396143913269, 0.05213618278503418, 0.0348232239484787, -0.03527234494686127, 0.03704838454723358, 0.013830084353685379, 0.0223435927182436, 0.055622126907110214, -0.030513141304254532, -0.01179106067866087, 0.00017382079386152327, -0.04005826264619827, -0.038180604577064514, -0.028240738436579704, -0.035689037293195724, -0.013851595111191273, 0.019188808277249336, 0.006463608704507351, 0.02311597391963005, -0.03900868445634842, -0.03956723213195801, -0.014538204297423363, 0.008148803375661373, -0.024306630715727806, -0.06786257773637772, -0.045483965426683426, -0.004165158607065678, -0.024848440662026405, -0.017557771876454353, -0.05569172650575638, -0.051719438284635544, -0.01687137596309185, -0.08633890002965927, -0.017217043787240982, -0.04878558591008186, 0.023798441514372826, -0.0065392074175179005, -0.06959876418113708, -0.020623095333576202, -0.02447543852031231, 0.021060632541775703, 0.04731885343790054, -0.016756586730480194, 0.0033386051654815674, 0.03793945908546448, -0.051663465797901154, -0.06055894121527672, 0.00009738411608850583, 0.03102196380496025, -0.00790508184581995, -0.014650783501565456, 0.02101900242269039, -0.014350716955959797, 0.0058822943829, -0.034893639385700226, 0.0527244508266449, -0.054662447422742844, 0.03052091971039772, -0.06424181163311005, -0.007183027919381857, -0.05201883241534233, -0.04717539623379707, 0.04165283590555191, -0.023768743500113487, 0.004417519085109234, 0.0014388876734301448, 0.015206475742161274, 0.03009226731956005, -0.04747115820646286, -0.004477868787944317, -0.004390429705381393, -0.01231849379837513, 0.013632318936288357, 0.05116282030940056, -0.040299516171216965, 0.0069678062573075294, -0.05975169315934181, -0.02863573282957077, -0.05097218602895737, 0.008577841334044933, 0.06224780157208443, -0.017423098906874657, 0.005717362277209759, -0.04864313080906868, 0.0040830401703715324, -0.04169421270489693, -0.01884566619992256, -0.04574277997016907, 0.05701815336942673, -0.010752416215837002, -0.017885377630591393, -0.025230256840586662, -0.005449407268315554, 0.021601799875497818, -0.0625007227063179, -0.036248885095119476, -0.025842588394880295, 0.02014424093067646, -0.02104678563773632, -0.02090073563158512, -0.05391843616962433, 0.011056534945964813, 0.037873584777116776, 0.03824179992079735, 0.03076336160302162, 0.015562289394438267, -0.03135004639625549, 0.04158184677362442, 0.03927195072174072, 0.009005571715533733, 0.0008460422395728528, 0.00033039620029740036, 0.030921442434191704, -0.047607485204935074, -0.03212359547615051, -0.016456138342618942, 0.052913520485162735, -0.07402854412794113, -0.016453303396701813, 0.00020037264039274305, -0.008799013681709766, -0.016012487933039665, -0.006891307421028614, -0.009767928160727024, -0.04987305402755737, -0.07300888746976852 ]
The lattice Boltzmann method, after close to thirty years of presence in computational fluid dynamics has turned into a versatile, efficient and quite popular numerical tool for fluid flow simulations. The lattice Boltzmann method owes its popularity in the past decade to its efficiency, low numerical dissipation and simplicity of its algorithm. Progress in recent years has opened the door for yet another very challenging area of application: Combustion simulations. Combustion is known to be a challenge for numerical tools due to, among many others, the large number of variables and scales both in time and space, leading to a stiff multi-scale problem. In the present work we present a comprehensive overview of models and strategies developed in the past years to model combustion with the lattice Boltzmann method and discuss some of the most recent applications, remaining challenges and prospects.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07517v2
[ -0.0047579798847436905, -0.039763227105140686, 0.02637479081749916, 0.03559881076216698, -0.04221806302666664, -0.007069800049066544, -0.00960463285446167, -0.039205946028232574, 0.011832640506327152, 0.04566854238510132, -0.06202714145183563, -0.02411564067006111, 0.02620982937514782, -0.019079161807894707, -0.035612765699625015, -0.032511960715055466, 0.023557089269161224, 0.00723684998229146, -0.0754418596625328, 0.05677342414855957, 0.025979459285736084, 0.011976202949881554, -0.007068443577736616, 0.05194763094186783, 0.023650312796235085, 0.02765107899904251, -0.038754649460315704, 0.03836642578244209, -0.03528193011879921, -0.02602623589336872, 0.0623990073800087, -0.06333739310503006, -0.02538982592523098, -0.0545169934630394, 0.0034090583212673664, 0.02480168081820011, -0.0216278824955225, 0.008434307761490345, 0.055571299046278, -0.03197271376848221, 0.04088273644447327, -0.04397706314921379, -0.07264252007007599, 0.02227264828979969, 0.008412642404437065, 0.016935152933001518, -0.02401566691696644, 0.006924642249941826, -0.08498552441596985, -0.060466621071100235, -0.006341729313135147, -0.0034943337086588144, -0.028460688889026642, 0.04283612594008446, -0.04753716662526131, -0.04701277241110802, 0.02421759068965912, -0.025179045274853706, -0.035358723253011703, -0.021048158407211304, 0.0085695069283247, 0.04537324234843254, 0.03974667564034462, -0.007043426390737295, -0.025982802733778954, 0.05901239812374115, -0.04331466183066368, -0.01631920412182808, -0.026342710480093956, -0.08303150534629822, -0.03496077284216881, -0.0349157378077507, 0.0038190949708223343, 0.011076783761382103, -0.044980838894844055, -0.0585331991314888, -0.0035729992669075727, 0.010322542861104012, 0.008960675448179245, 0.07011421024799347, -0.06096379831433296, -0.0003892275271937251, -0.023433318361639977, -0.008921682834625244, 0.00983295775949955, -0.002911528805270791, 0.04930531233549118, -0.013459524139761925, 0.031364452093839645, -0.024417022243142128, 0.03439423814415932, -0.045457590371370316, -0.06132299080491066, -0.03484492748975754, 0.08061928302049637, -0.021707650274038315, 0.0641879290342331, 0.07072295248508453, -0.0024416109081357718, -0.03871123865246773, -0.012360397726297379, -0.043277572840452194, -0.04741298034787178, 0.03475519269704819, 0.0075653609819710255, -0.024497980251908302, 0.004768661689013243, -0.014743787236511707, 0.04904522746801376, 0.0016499144257977605, -0.036972302943468094, -0.011937998235225677, -0.012457061558961868, -0.03860323876142502, -0.04450757056474686, -0.011908607557415962, 0.04709368199110031, -0.02906329743564129, 0.027798157185316086, 0.011279863305389881, -0.06500784307718277, -0.04536225274205208, 0.022648027166724205, 0.013157910667359829, -0.014972012490034103, -0.005305067636072636, 0.020555628463625908, -0.0027254854794591665, -0.022129567340016365, -0.013076158240437508, -0.07581043243408203, 0.010214166715741158, 0.038130369037389755, -0.02789202891290188, 0.05985395982861519, 0.037667062133550644, -0.01663910038769245, -0.058737121522426605, 0.0174573827534914, 0.01443095039576292, -0.06152227893471718, -0.06329047679901123, 0.014410341158509254, -0.03577041998505592, -0.00780267920345068, 0.035057976841926575, -0.04731306806206703, 0.04494408518075943, -0.022402632981538773, 0.0018960810266435146, 0.01771230250597, 0.0166445542126894, 0.00484418636187911, -0.018446888774633408, 0.0233272984623909, -0.007092367857694626, 0.013608635403215885, -0.008280050940811634, -0.051132816821336746, 0.04105154424905777, 0.03834539279341698, -0.06562017649412155, -0.03887893259525299, 0.017745468765497208, -0.013706388883292675, -0.00316929561085999, 0.04163201525807381, -0.030926935374736786, -0.015464261174201965, 0.033388227224349976, -0.048670101910829544, -0.004621642641723156, 0.01351774949580431, -0.002785554388538003, -0.04463913291692734, -0.05478782206773758, -0.0502016544342041, -0.06414742022752762, -0.05276239663362503, -0.021767789497971535, 0.029896503314375877, -0.04432481899857521, -0.038372669368982315, -0.04493759945034981, 0.005395690444856882, 0.054266802966594696, -0.06350237131118774, 0.024060465395450592, 0.010139020159840584, -0.024296153336763382, -0.033999018371105194, -0.0046433755196630955, -0.043566275388002396, -0.04277380183339119, -0.013267852365970612, -0.016407277435064316, 0.060955923050642014, -0.07188131660223007, -0.016159849241375923, 0.03466012701392174, -0.06298019737005234, -0.047463808208703995, -0.036603402346372604, -0.052350692451000214, 0.010206916369497776, -0.06977124512195587, 0.030476277694106102, 0.039950527250766754, -0.026349620893597603, -0.042406875640153885, 0.06033565476536751, 0.033023521304130554, 0.03244827315211296, 0.05782490596175194, 0.011699186637997627, 0.034123606979846954, -0.09829264879226685, 0.021428128704428673, 0.0026743693742901087, 0.0016843746416270733, -0.02939189225435257, 0.055178847163915634, -0.019544821232557297, -0.012558327987790108, -0.05001721903681755, 0.06399170309305191, 0.02996739186346531, 0.015458665788173676, -0.08322735875844955, 0.013956277631223202, -0.0003873612149618566, -0.02974259853363037, -0.04903629794716835, -0.04429100453853607, -0.03165125474333763, 0.017392871901392937, -0.011626247316598892, 0.04661248251795769, -0.04266023635864258, -0.03827853128314018, -0.01590164378285408, -0.01819939911365509, 0.0380321741104126, -0.03214384987950325, -0.061715640127658844, -0.04448695108294487, -0.06123770773410797, 0.023300642147660255, -0.009419316425919533, -0.011119269765913486, -0.016597706824541092, -0.0290193073451519, -0.04484269395470619, 0.009657161310315132, 0.0004322473250795156, 0.04127040505409241, -0.02060067467391491, 0.025912398472428322, 0.013969749212265015, 0.03556860610842705, -0.000867541297338903, 0.01848696358501911, -0.03599705174565315, 0.00698160519823432, 0.017760129645466805, 0.060162242501974106, -0.0501667745411396, 0.032948777079582214, 0.01260718610137701, -0.007898270152509212, 0.01061308290809393, 0.03561977297067642, 0.04769309610128403, 0.044842153787612915, 0.025690054520964622, -0.039615046232938766, 0.01048539113253355, -0.03500674292445183, 0.010629727505147457, 0.033473674207925797, 0.022100945934653282, -0.03239303454756737, 0.012130925431847572, -0.052399832755327225, 0.021320238709449768, -0.016776541247963905, -0.03937969729304314, -0.06424973160028458, -0.0658479630947113, -0.009851397015154362, -0.06641100347042084, -0.02819189615547657, -0.05230507627129555, -0.04921795800328255, -0.021039845421910286, -0.0643230527639389, 0.027226872742176056, -0.04481196776032448, 0.06666945666074753, -0.013470509089529514, -0.07630709558725357, -0.025276437401771545, 0.004750621970742941, 0.05085260793566704, -0.0033395991194993258, -0.024522017687559128, -0.03978770971298218, 0.008458035066723824, -0.020487641915678978, -0.03203524649143219, -0.06909606605768204, 0.0158334169536829, 0.0011653028195723891, 0.01499566063284874, 0.060232482850551605, 0.0077740345150232315, 0.043700866401195526, -0.028340939432382584, -0.06360374391078949, -0.007883423008024693, -0.023256251588463783, 0.04020807892084122, -0.02281322330236435, 0.009563830681145191, -0.014817505143582821, -0.045660994946956635, 0.00951069314032793, 0.022367175668478012, 0.032418400049209595, -0.02556608058512211, -0.02624562196433544, 0.028886903077363968, 0.022041495889425278, 0.014710812829434872, 0.06656971573829651, 0.052749153226614, -0.0016103294910863042, -0.07101906090974808, -0.029701318591833115, -0.015257889404892921, -0.048825569450855255, 0.03436362370848656, -0.015761639922857285, -0.013196583837270737, 0.027791859582066536, -0.08849149197340012, 0.050604019314050674, 0.05401996150612831, 0.05433213338255882, -0.02013954147696495, 0.0007220279658213258, -0.020514676347374916, -0.03197441250085831, -0.03075249120593071, 0.02507825754582882, 0.021478259935975075, 0.04595218226313591, 0.02758420817553997, -0.02711353451013565, -0.02267233468592167, 0.01787356100976467, -0.07967059314250946, -0.043642688542604446, -0.021777387708425522, -0.0033520632423460484, 0.019656697288155556, 0.02994692698121071, -0.06487876921892166, -0.03917376697063446, -0.05720224976539612, 0.03601739928126335, 0.028245026245713234, -0.0399097241461277, 0.03233586624264717, -0.036462604999542236, 0.013625488616526127, 0.04987687990069389, -0.030667856335639954, 0.022835267707705498, -0.055623140186071396, 0.04041297733783722, -0.06162944808602333, 0.06543175131082535, 0.0019409925444051623, -0.024348212406039238, -0.029310759156942368, 0.04050515219569206, -0.022269219160079956, -0.018676452338695526, -0.007285244297236204, -0.05892268195748329, -0.03128458186984062, 0.018474264070391655, 0.00885610468685627, -0.03653479367494583, 0.009387522004544735, 0.0032220736611634493, 0.020693086087703705, 0.004247010685503483, -0.025197431445121765, 0.009711657650768757, 0.01733717881143093, -0.019784605130553246, -0.07903958857059479, 0.01220627874135971, -0.031872134655714035, -0.0196920707821846, -0.0488223098218441, -0.026381609961390495, 0.07582506537437439, -0.02645806409418583, -0.021527821198105812, -0.03246438503265381, -0.022399254143238068, 0.011518835090100765, 0.0028735389932990074, 0.03126290440559387, -0.05854107812047005, 0.007378225680440664, -0.017881715670228004, 0.06611572206020355, -0.025868555530905724, 0.028859594836831093, -0.051616597920656204, -0.02483449876308441, -0.03805224224925041, 0.001377913635224104, 0.06613665074110031, 0.0038155443035066128, -0.01523999497294426, -0.025359734892845154, -0.000785828335210681, -0.015511267818510532, -0.016790226101875305, -0.011178617365658283, -0.038062747567892075, 0.004401540849357843, -0.032093290239572525, -0.012212551198899746, -0.0065798950381577015, -0.01696571335196495, 0.06139605492353439, -0.0649230033159256, -0.04069320112466812, 0.03146454691886902, 0.04020993411540985, -0.061832133680582047, -0.07130406051874161, -0.047664985060691833, -0.046842046082019806, -0.04062854126095772, -0.027837827801704407, 0.05372455343604088, 0.04321518912911415, -0.03084106743335724, 0.006250850856304169, -0.0023689339868724346, 0.004614466801285744, -0.017357738688588142, 0.04869351536035538, 0.012418891303241253, 0.002318819286301732, -0.039305027574300766, 0.020711950957775116, -0.04492967575788498, -0.0046767620369791985, 0.03787423297762871, -0.0028133259620517492, -0.026288341730833054, 0.056077443063259125, -0.014884504489600658, 0.03875001519918442, -0.07968559116125107, 0.030524583533406258, 0.04741567745804787, 0.022282378748059273, -0.02375880442559719, 0.024049492552876472, 0.027365775778889656, 0.01807340607047081, -0.0562928281724453, 0.02933190017938614, 0.01183189358562231, 0.010722637176513672, 0.005336238536983728, -0.015512575395405293, -0.0034690205939114094, -0.00184107746463269, 0.015525829046964645, -0.009039697237312794, -0.040464092046022415, -0.00976428110152483, 0.022859729826450348, -0.010462159290909767, -0.06225701421499252, 0.033879321068525314, 0.013123756274580956, -0.004224578849971294, -0.009730992838740349, -0.035985611379146576, -0.035118114203214645, -0.0057163843885064125, 0.006988080218434334, -0.003961094189435244, -0.030887089669704437, -0.021407339721918106, 0.014133270829916, 0.03139426186680794, 0.035577960312366486, -0.010172245092689991, -0.0300434622913599, -0.010371284559369087, -0.041195034980773926, -0.07187099754810333, 0.018487753346562386, -0.03257467597723007, -0.016653520986437798, -0.00509528536349535, 0.055088113993406296, 0.017865559086203575, 0.039839647710323334, 0.017034610733389854, -0.05872298777103424, 0.0268844123929739, -0.045531265437603, 0.013229376636445522, 0.017640501260757446, 0.02997913584113121, -0.01756688393652439, -0.017254207283258438, 0.019027775153517723, 0.0023877485655248165, -0.009048650972545147, -0.007757034618407488, -0.00762539729475975, 0.004900089930742979, -0.009187586605548859, -0.06346067041158676, -0.0015710637671872973, 0.00357312080450356, 0.05903720483183861, -0.03454868867993355, -0.017716502770781517, -0.043580517172813416, -0.006449243053793907, 0.04741897061467171, 0.032764982432127, -0.04067898541688919, -0.041943345218896866, -0.03235284611582756, 0.06821291148662567, -0.029457498341798782, -0.04515460878610611, -0.02313299849629402, -0.0663365051150322, -0.03518560528755188, -0.025255069136619568, -0.00876996573060751, 0.011218803003430367, -0.03659197315573692, -0.054106757044792175, 0.08066011220216751, 0.03645765408873558, -0.05360100418329239, 0.04189929738640785, 0.013565749861299992, -0.07515472918748856, -0.007358158938586712, 0.03669930621981621, 0.03809366747736931, 0.016346149146556854, 0.0655440166592598, 0.009835378266870975, -0.023762397468090057, -0.061742689460515976, 0.027237407863140106, 0.08622854202985764, -0.04525113105773926, 0.024582762271165848, 0.028731269761919975, -0.047914475202560425, 0.019077306613326073, 0.004920166451483965, -0.004416975192725658, -0.0014227571664378047, -0.03139350190758705, -0.052991800010204315, -0.02372637204825878, -0.008955564349889755, 0.0306253582239151, -0.04045043885707855, -0.023380810394883156, -0.03579945117235184, 0.0013715274399146438, -0.015871047973632812, -0.017012037336826324, -0.017708487808704376, 0.03281078487634659, -0.0031459308229386806, 0.0033530639484524727, -0.01686244085431099, 0.009870990179479122, -0.01777932606637478, 0.013640816323459148, 0.01291444431990385, -0.045172832906246185, 0.048627786338329315, -0.029506133869290352, -0.0641351044178009, 0.033138688653707504, -0.01671708934009075, -0.022495541721582413, -0.0004466024984139949, -0.025368032976984978, 0.027429459616541862, 0.02164456620812416, -0.024661367759108543, -0.010344939306378365, -0.012029831297695637, -0.035919997841119766, -0.010439449921250343, -0.003553007496520877, 0.021420715376734734, -0.039772260934114456, 0.06267888844013214, -0.026130475103855133, 0.006696708034723997, -0.02746889367699623, -0.014109758660197258, 0.002592853270471096, 0.03610112518072128, -0.05187906324863434, 0.014335911720991135, -0.058877598494291306, 0.03256390988826752, -0.05154627934098244, 0.017358263954520226, -0.022052990272641182, -0.06129587069153786, 0.00351267890073359, 0.01735355518758297, -0.0011646372731775045, -0.044522494077682495, 0.028506360948085785, 0.05943337827920914, -0.02517995424568653, 0.04497440159320831, -0.004924064036458731, 0.026909222826361656, 0.022395998239517212, -0.040579188615083694, -0.05472820624709129, -0.008121143095195293, -0.013606736436486244, -0.050029873847961426, -0.06486335396766663, -0.00028549638227559626, -0.06149710714817047, -0.000506441225297749, 0.024950440973043442, -0.05185827240347862, -0.01568247377872467, -0.04452311620116234, 0.009983663447201252, 0.031879838556051254, -0.02569323219358921, -0.06655804067850113, 0.022739022970199585, 0.02232309989631176, -0.01627517305314541, 0.03084659017622471, 0.0016108173877000809, -0.022525878623127937, -0.020262183621525764, -0.08235898613929749, 0.008507579565048218, -0.04020030051469803, 0.042017120867967606, -0.020106133073568344, 0.008907807990908623, -0.03618045151233673, -0.04006198048591614, 0.03307318687438965, 0.006476143840700388, 0.015314063988626003, 0.026610346511006355, 0.002101125894114375, 0.055180635303258896, -0.035378795117139816, -0.007108067627996206, 0.04827352985739708, 0.0017849436262622476, 0.01878282055258751, -0.019413359463214874, 0.031907860189676285, -0.047160547226667404, -0.009431269019842148, 0.05099644884467125, -0.017979422584176064, 0.033856019377708435, -0.05712119862437248, 0.00807730108499527, -0.0439872145652771, -0.07027333229780197, 0.041859935969114304, -0.0518733449280262, 0.03631797432899475, 0.027942750602960587, 0.014370206743478775, 0.03115798719227314, -0.0076843807473778725, -0.042860716581344604, 0.0058656781911849976, 0.006032521370798349, -0.03268018364906311, 0.0762215256690979, -0.013172457925975323, -0.015207362361252308, -0.029396871104836464, 0.009405815042555332, -0.06906618922948837, 0.05807184427976608, 0.034264642745256424, -0.04231831431388855, 0.02870027907192707, -0.05788777396082878, -8.529202091267507e-7, -0.0305778868496418, 0.031573329120874405, -0.046873871237039566, 0.04881345480680466, -0.03410998359322548, -0.017924025654792786, -0.01239507645368576, -0.02871434949338436, -0.023530226200819016, -0.03228098154067993, -0.04085255786776543, 0.018812542781233788, 0.054884690791368484, -0.025984331965446472, 0.04908791556954384, 0.031132575124502182, 0.05226704478263855, -0.011096040718257427, -0.01956690289080143, -0.012012060731649399, 0.025985071435570717, -0.07553023099899292, 0.03458641469478607, -0.003810224821791053, -0.037284865975379944, -0.01584506966173649, 0.005962410941720009, 0.03482244163751602, -0.06955362111330032, -0.0005461494438350201, 0.018235310912132263, 0.024690862745046616, -0.025781845673918724, -0.015929140150547028, -0.050273597240448, 0.02638634853065014, -0.006627472583204508, -0.016100572422146797, 0.006345962639898062, -0.01671241782605648, -0.03787807747721672 ]
We show that the dynamics of a quantum system can be represented by the dynamics of an underlying classical systems obeying the Hamilton equations of motion. This is achieved by transforming the phase space of dimension $2n$ into a Hilbert space of dimension $n$ which is obtained by a peculiar canonical transformation that changes a pair of real canonical variables into a pair of complex canonical variables which are complex conjugate of each other. The probabilistic character of quantum mechanics is devised by treating the wave function as a stochastic variable. The dynamics of the underlying system is chosen so as to preserve the norm of the state vector.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00151v1
[ -0.04130004718899727, -0.0491391122341156, 0.007357399445027113, 0.014824721030890942, 0.01974201761186123, -0.03456848859786987, -0.020815784111618996, -0.0165941771119833, -0.021693643182516098, -0.017120402306318283, -0.00027181286714039743, -0.028991222381591797, -0.054052338004112244, -0.02448975294828415, -0.06964822858572006, 0.032480016350746155, 0.058822087943553925, 0.01972009614109993, 0.012215926311910152, 0.06606151908636093, 0.02499309554696083, -0.031490299850702286, -0.022383378818631172, 0.062013257294893265, 0.008145519532263279, -0.04006079211831093, 0.019686654210090637, -0.032483793795108795, -0.030672358348965645, -0.028032518923282623, 0.05012768507003784, -0.04053279384970665, 0.05683957785367966, -0.002128585474565625, -0.03527597710490227, 0.0039497921243309975, -0.020131871104240417, 0.01574528031051159, 0.0361427366733551, -0.04057760164141655, 0.010932669043540955, 0.012819619849324226, -0.036527592688798904, -0.05085471272468567, -0.011531254276633263, -0.0023574819788336754, -0.0641801655292511, -0.028108179569244385, -0.0489012748003006, -0.0501413568854332, 0.025124860927462578, 0.008969379588961601, 0.018414415419101715, 0.04995488375425339, -0.05012514069676399, -0.007422717288136482, -0.005361513234674931, -0.039875417947769165, -0.06476335227489471, -0.035641688853502274, -0.011041440069675446, -0.027443373575806618, 0.04903489723801613, -0.06664466112852097, 0.00328126666136086, 0.013761227950453758, -0.030820975080132484, -0.056074339896440506, -0.018373673781752586, -0.028474394232034683, 0.013219647109508514, -0.054948341101408005, 0.039927542209625244, 0.0036060335114598274, -0.0632881298661232, 0.02305513061583042, -0.008533637970685959, -0.019909121096134186, -0.013231441378593445, 0.04446299374103546, 0.0014102525310590863, 0.002821841975674033, 0.0038137100636959076, -0.014335841871798038, 0.054698050022125244, -0.035281166434288025, 0.06439913809299469, -0.023670749738812447, -0.005905674304813147, -0.05185294151306152, 0.03461279720067978, -0.016369182616472244, -0.05909540504217148, -0.04467737674713135, 0.03595605492591858, -0.04924040660262108, 0.054297931492328644, 0.059290144592523575, -0.0018588608363643289, 0.019677655771374702, -0.008155644871294498, -0.03912879154086113, -0.021649925038218498, 0.025967150926589966, -0.0018635735614225268, -0.005441256333142519, -0.04525505751371384, 0.013111904263496399, -0.046961598098278046, 0.053260013461112976, 0.0047037252224981785, 0.026401188224554062, -0.01795702986419201, -0.020201846957206726, -0.03599521145224571, -0.051087331026792526, 0.0495745874941349, 0.013822684995830059, 0.021059323102235794, 0.023457787930965424, -0.02849678136408329, 0.004506940022110939, -0.0019525268580764532, 0.009483512490987778, -0.05474822595715523, -0.022741932421922684, 0.04773414134979248, 0.05669425427913666, 0.00795590877532959, 0.002583137946203351, -0.039145100861787796, 0.025589410215616226, 0.046292148530483246, -0.024185147136449814, 0.01273751724511385, 0.015078402124345303, 0.006246760953217745, -0.0557432547211647, 0.006953673902899027, 0.03477773070335388, -0.05003876984119415, -0.04757658392190933, 0.046261079609394073, 0.057455725967884064, 0.029316024854779243, 0.001937404158525169, -0.07683289796113968, 0.05639153718948364, 0.024054797366261482, -0.01795417070388794, -0.014203923754394054, 0.028866153210401535, 0.05261833965778351, -0.007527382578700781, 0.0073511539958417416, -0.009727705270051956, 0.06980917602777481, -0.03268587216734886, -0.06234339252114296, -0.002917956095188856, -0.012473714537918568, -0.027789652347564697, -0.01740645058453083, 0.012570134364068508, 0.026811396703124046, 0.003846984589472413, 0.02972557581961155, -0.014086962677538395, -0.038655251264572144, -0.030042726546525955, -0.014467542991042137, -0.034613337367773056, 0.06225842982530594, -0.05618246644735336, -0.005529644433408976, -0.05834750086069107, -0.03545915707945824, -0.044251855462789536, 0.019157977774739265, 0.001366174896247685, -0.036009397357702255, -0.013813798315823078, -0.02303667552769184, 0.010122454725205898, -0.06537889689207077, -0.014273076318204403, -0.06777722388505936, 0.012556792236864567, 0.04211454093456268, 0.01459872629493475, -0.03893991559743881, -0.042676765471696854, 0.03392850607633591, -0.04755406081676483, -0.06564772874116898, -0.03275694325566292, 0.005558946169912815, -0.06540326774120331, -0.005811147857457399, 0.041591089218854904, -0.03671203553676605, -0.04660625383257866, -0.038530364632606506, 0.004412782844156027, 0.007059190422296524, -0.06554894149303436, 0.05022042244672775, 0.03759691119194031, -0.03347087651491165, -0.0527467243373394, 0.07055802643299103, -0.02547576278448105, 0.04566604271531105, -0.05200035870075226, 0.005313074681907892, -0.029948918148875237, -0.08960789442062378, 0.023453988134860992, -0.005793924909085035, 0.004774920642375946, 0.002210010774433613, 0.0015362580306828022, 0.01027787383645773, -0.03481978178024292, -0.011562895029783249, 0.019668838009238243, 0.06668105721473694, 0.00043122973875142634, -0.015470149926841259, -0.04931572079658508, -0.04556688293814659, -0.053587257862091064, -0.0635552927851677, -0.06143172085285187, -0.039634257555007935, 0.008115416392683983, 0.005857443902641535, 0.01783568039536476, -0.04288966581225395, -0.0325741246342659, -0.06172575801610947, -0.03991382196545601, 0.03828159719705582, -0.05136467143893242, -0.020711932331323624, -0.0370042510330677, 0.017740126699209213, 0.036487746983766556, -0.018877463415265083, -0.03895470127463341, -0.01299026794731617, -0.06842435896396637, -0.0288188848644495, -0.06162470579147339, -0.011782240122556686, 0.04111254960298538, -0.026778612285852432, 0.05606137588620186, 0.005167572293430567, 0.052800338715314865, 0.00966015737503767, 0.033762842416763306, -0.05235642194747925, -0.017401840537786484, 0.022026600316166878, 0.019459368661046028, -0.06933946162462234, -0.030905915424227715, -0.03210730478167534, -0.011339887976646423, -0.006081870757043362, 0.014670666307210922, 0.05908966064453125, 0.0026601706631481647, 0.005629270803183317, 0.04792693629860878, -0.008486038073897362, -0.029099617153406143, 0.035138264298439026, 0.0010981683153659105, 0.0467660091817379, 0.014958508312702179, -0.007940102368593216, -0.06224779412150383, -0.019554274156689644, 0.010231029242277145, -0.02838759869337082, -0.06328564137220383, -0.061614733189344406, -0.0405096560716629, -0.05404557287693024, 0.020745066925883293, -0.055398326367139816, -0.004079884849488735, -0.05366123467683792, -0.03838803246617317, -0.010110387578606606, -0.03542358800768852, 0.01207185909152031, -0.07710271328687668, -0.0656772255897522, 0.03658701106905937, 0.013595160096883774, 0.03563893958926201, -0.03483519330620766, -0.07040375471115112, 0.011030025780200958, 0.00907241553068161, -0.03556538373231888, 0.028651924803853035, -0.0436042845249176, -0.01730016991496086, -0.021878184750676155, -0.005688325501978397, 0.01162122655659914, 0.0010442690690979362, 0.034734852612018585, -0.03317922726273537, 0.03227398544549942, -0.010004407726228237, -0.0011070057516917586, 0.0038110080640763044, 0.01687636226415634, -0.01644052378833294, -0.0042301686480641365, -0.03766673430800438, 0.0476982556283474, 0.02533200941979885, -0.045185040682554245, -0.02200300619006157, -0.02965874969959259, -0.056904613971710205, 0.001609339495189488, 0.007381589151918888, 0.06175849214196205, 0.04812861233949661, 0.006367675494402647, -0.019560199230909348, -0.05902516096830368, 0.012491777539253235, 0.015834122896194458, 0.03489358350634575, 0.05282149836421013, 0.0021510545630007982, -0.02440521866083145, -0.06829999387264252, 0.035666365176439285, 0.03778959810733795, 0.033681150525808334, -0.04553874954581261, -0.009766743518412113, -0.0007554591866210103, -0.04268288612365723, 0.005037814844399691, 0.015382828190922737, -0.014130448922514915, 0.033865977078676224, 0.029590753838419914, -0.055135007947683334, -0.020423732697963715, -0.05245101451873779, -0.05610669404268265, -0.05175764486193657, -0.001999234315007925, 0.0317339189350605, 0.05326659604907036, 0.01874908059835434, -0.04601764306426048, 0.03272605314850807, -0.07323666661977768, 0.04528552666306496, 0.02266480214893818, -0.0282601248472929, 0.006964343134313822, -0.01078615803271532, -0.02643456868827343, -0.02030271850526333, 0.022481637075543404, -0.031150519847869873, -0.0008153318194672465, 0.0017316715093329549, -0.041859500110149384, 0.008967481553554535, 0.0029177824035286903, -0.025769047439098358, -0.006512969266623259, -0.004956766963005066, -0.014448611065745354, 0.03926722705364227, -0.061022013425827026, 0.00413153599947691, -0.01734231971204281, -0.0340736024081707, 0.038597557693719864, 0.001881591510027647, -0.043079935014247894, 0.009707387536764145, 0.03648003935813904, -0.02037106454372406, -0.04410850629210472, 0.05584470182657242, -0.008053292520344257, -0.034417539834976196, -0.07211455702781677, -0.032056014984846115, -0.07917172461748123, -0.017930777743458748, 0.034731872379779816, -0.0733279436826706, 0.07046940922737122, 0.039890069514513016, -0.03961287811398506, -0.04041172191500664, -0.06121493875980377, 0.01166624017059803, -0.033668484538793564, 0.0104356799274683, -0.05889563634991646, 0.01854034513235092, -0.06212532892823219, -0.017589189112186432, -0.04872893914580345, 0.0314096063375473, -0.05171366408467293, -0.006360637955367565, -0.03901711851358414, 0.03882460296154022, -0.0028558634221553802, 0.03738231211900711, 0.024217654019594193, 0.013103488832712173, -0.015642380341887474, -0.005510873626917601, -0.023749906569719315, -0.0154489204287529, -0.028951043263077736, 0.020805910229682922, -0.052994806319475174, -0.05211129039525986, 0.009690224193036556, -0.00115531450137496, 0.039906445890665054, -0.03384988754987717, -0.037911124527454376, -0.013255304656922817, 0.045376893132925034, -0.008446692489087582, -0.03203923627734184, -0.02675583027303219, -0.039080943912267685, -0.026432210579514503, 0.002030454110354185, -0.03667312115430832, 0.0037390165962278843, 0.0036879675462841988, 0.032270073890686035, -0.000027781126846093684, -0.0131808677688241, -0.049849286675453186, 0.0087044108659029, 0.0016052054706960917, 0.039564430713653564, -0.05456608906388283, -0.006177283823490143, -0.03235262632369995, 0.026737142354249954, -0.004046231042593718, -0.025629859417676926, -0.005441213026642799, 0.0514521449804306, -0.013013377785682678, 0.03549906983971596, -0.0767548531293869, 0.04613465443253517, 0.03460553660988808, 0.011080371215939522, -0.04180474206805229, 0.054245803505182266, -0.062308818101882935, -0.011473171412944794, 0.00957114901393652, 0.031002972275018692, -0.026421144604682922, 0.010221523232758045, -0.01519608311355114, 0.0035212435759603977, -0.03817259892821312, 0.04119420051574707, 0.0505010262131691, -0.03120027855038643, -0.03567740321159363, -0.011771269142627716, -0.05161616951227188, -0.02037680335342884, -0.06332962214946747, 0.03513498604297638, 0.006035781931132078, -0.06462252140045166, -0.062672920525074, 0.03525680676102638, -0.00895744003355503, 0.019479159265756607, 0.03438302502036095, -0.0466318354010582, 0.061320677399635315, 0.05146080628037453, -0.028702497482299805, -0.025017905980348587, 0.037874601781368256, -0.01841645874083042, -0.02432388998568058, 0.051304470747709274, 0.02737252227962017, -0.04235682636499405, -0.025157762691378593, -0.034201983362436295, 0.021583188325166702, -0.03346068784594536, 0.042768772691488266, 0.04198037460446358, 0.023533396422863007, 0.03672388568520546, -0.012775016017258167, 0.018115991726517677, 0.015007910318672657, 0.02024739608168602, 0.018266189843416214, -0.001837340765632689, -0.04990151524543762, 0.04983421042561531, 0.01069207675755024, -0.022060133516788483, 0.05180635303258896, -0.01793861761689186, -0.02223660796880722, -0.03691311180591583, 0.02435733750462532, -0.020614130422472954, -0.061841994524002075, -0.009442362003028393, 0.04885056987404823, -0.04654351621866226, 0.022974571213126183, 0.017430853098630905, -0.004701479338109493, 0.004168862942606211, -0.029437288641929626, 0.02403903566300869, -0.025958824902772903, -0.06336484849452972, 0.08420105278491974, -0.03871539235115051, 0.015721533447504044, -0.07576559484004974, -0.011623173952102661, -0.03880743682384491, -0.05067224055528641, 0.00030831689946353436, 0.019810235127806664, -0.03847527876496315, -0.020061129704117775, 0.04490195959806442, 0.029072413221001625, -0.07744603604078293, -0.04171783849596977, 0.04853813722729683, -0.058046504855155945, 0.019249502569437027, -0.012181070633232594, -0.04170391336083412, -0.04631578177213669, 0.04218128323554993, -0.05844538286328316, -0.016669463366270065, -0.049656450748443604, 0.05877349153161049, 0.041548676788806915, -0.03400591388344765, 0.046540532261133194, 0.04710398241877556, -0.009943446144461632, 0.020131254568696022, -0.06931395083665848, -0.020052986219525337, -0.03198009356856346, -0.007861175574362278, -0.030003586784005165, -0.028052043169736862, -0.011883193626999855, 0.04614608362317085, -0.03925739973783493, -0.00686640152707696, 0.028757601976394653, 0.02887868322432041, 0.005833923816680908, -0.04452585428953171, -0.022928928956389427, -0.013247904367744923, 0.016727875918149948, -0.022431878373026848, -0.013036581687629223, -0.005801151506602764, -0.02638613060116768, -0.0038436551112681627, -0.031115444377064705, 0.004833026323467493, -0.004331149160861969, 0.04708936810493469, -0.02901269495487213, 0.019072039052844048, -0.05400891974568367, -0.01709439978003502, -0.00003772255513467826, 0.05178116634488106, 0.025683632120490074, 0.0064034974202513695, -0.010600333102047443, 0.013514725491404533, -0.02184617891907692, -0.0034613136667758226, -0.007683997508138418, -0.02243080735206604, -0.012947901152074337, 0.02267516776919365, 0.05867725983262062, -0.04657471552491188, 0.04864181578159332, -0.03525140881538391, -0.06693591922521591, 0.012580055743455887, 0.00524270161986351, -0.03525509685277939, -0.028273887932300568, 0.03322472795844078, -0.010877406224608421, -0.019694209098815918, 0.017101792618632317, -0.03246970847249031, -0.01816224679350853, 0.009340154007077217, -0.014083839021623135, 0.02758772298693657, -0.02405298687517643, -0.011261841282248497, -0.012693587690591812, 0.03805100917816162, 0.06234263628721237, 0.02209899015724659, 0.03501499071717262, -0.013022554107010365, -0.04243754968047142, -0.047242071479558945, 0.00988163985311985, 0.00393993454053998, -0.02601371705532074, -0.011679560877382755, -0.05323128402233124, -0.07142343372106552, 0.02670755423605442, -0.02620834857225418, -0.01641484536230564, 0.0251446682959795, -0.06531703472137451, 0.03985156863927841, -0.01829817332327366, -0.015059871599078178, -0.08315567672252655, 0.018333006650209427, 0.006883404683321714, 0.012141900137066841, 0.01178514864295721, -0.002021082676947117, -0.05588267743587494, 0.01659616082906723, -0.07791425287723541, 0.0014536845264956355, -0.03010094352066517, 0.0507861003279686, 0.005499819293618202, -0.024819405749440193, 0.009177062660455704, -0.03821723163127899, 0.03729229420423508, 0.010983254760503769, -0.03190436586737633, 0.032392676919698715, 0.037635352462530136, 0.03233092278242111, -0.059867944568395615, -0.03410138562321663, 0.05138332396745682, -0.04783863574266434, -0.0025714586954563856, 0.07377307862043381, 0.05792514607310295, -0.028371065855026245, -0.009927229024469852, 0.04506783187389374, 0.011379767209291458, 0.0602576807141304, -0.02419356256723404, -0.04265044257044792, -0.029641786590218544, -0.06808043271303177, -0.027808452025055885, -0.06862904876470566, 0.027825362980365753, -0.023486824706196785, -0.03317566588521004, -0.030062202364206314, -0.04678380489349365, -0.05802502483129501, -0.025902360677719116, 0.018329421058297157, -0.019863711670041084, 0.06002318486571312, -0.056963954120874405, 0.03841400146484375, 0.030576322227716446, 0.0012479276629164815, -0.030119217932224274, -0.0006155887967906892, 0.02406887337565422, -0.03963050991296768, 0.05595872178673744, -0.06584297120571136, 0.04504460096359253, -0.030134117230772972, 0.03862259164452553, 0.02484290860593319, 0.028287749737501144, -0.0029104938730597496, -0.0020094315987080336, -0.046091414988040924, -0.0025580504443496466, 0.031132757663726807, -0.041544344276189804, -0.014631981961429119, 0.023652218282222748, 0.006801897659897804, 0.04176732525229454, 0.056818101555109024, -0.0012635793536901474, 0.06545797735452652, 0.029661843553185463, 0.011383186094462872, 0.007722130976617336, -0.011985795572400093, -0.0403837114572525, -0.009470554068684578, 0.0013873104471713305, -0.016006985679268837, -0.02756228670477867, 0.0015095649287104607, -0.009388145990669727, 0.010124447755515575, -0.029683969914913177, 0.00798647478222847, 0.0566607303917408, -0.06789877265691757, -0.034133926033973694, 0.015320364385843277, -0.05317306891083717, -0.04385298490524292, 0.05731307342648506, 0.027209464460611343, 0.02252577617764473, -0.026597486808896065 ]
The Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) will be the next-generation observatory in the field of very-high-energy (20 GeV to 300 TeV) gamma-ray astroparticle physics. The traditional approach to data analysis in this field is to apply quality cuts, optimized using Monte Carlo simulations, on the data acquired to maximize sensitivity. Subsequent steps of the analysis typically use the surviving events to calculate one set of instrument response functions (IRFs) to physically interpret the results. However, an alternative approach is the use of event types, as implemented in experiments such as the Fermi-LAT. This approach divides events into sub-samples based on their reconstruction quality, and a set of IRFs is calculated for each sub-sample. The sub-samples are then combined in a joint analysis, treating them as independent observations. In previous works we demonstrated that event types, classified using Machine Learning methods according to their expected angular reconstruction quality, have the potential to significantly improve the CTA angular and energy resolution of a point-like source analysis. Now, we validated the production of event-type wise full-enclosure IRFs, ready to be used with science tools (such as Gammapy and ctools). We will report on the impact of using such an event-type classification on CTA high-level performance, compared to the traditional procedure.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11375v1
[ 0.02819369174540043, -0.064097099006176, 0.02169036865234375, 0.042848240584135056, -0.017782019451260567, -0.046192798763513565, 0.045666225254535675, 0.023376522585749626, -0.03946230188012123, -0.009756437502801418, -0.050836920738220215, 0.011725667864084244, -0.06839653849601746, -0.021397458389401436, -0.06336004287004471, 0.06228729709982872, 0.05694427713751793, 0.01010653842240572, -0.01975671388208866, 0.09072252362966537, 0.0489572174847126, 0.016624974086880684, -0.042454417794942856, 0.05240711197257042, 0.03834286332130432, 0.0050475457683205605, 0.029089204967021942, -0.0020026681013405323, -0.01573662832379341, -0.006204917095601559, 0.07333005219697952, -0.019456900656223297, -0.005755893420428038, -0.03181389346718788, 0.004987828899174929, -0.03171658515930176, 0.009416574612259865, 0.031571872532367706, 0.03692084923386574, -0.020382100716233253, 0.019717399030923843, -0.06243548169732094, -0.054910410195589066, -0.03364141657948494, -0.01042784471064806, -0.0227496437728405, -0.05834643170237541, 0.005152347031980753, -0.07682570070028305, -0.056268103420734406, 0.035552769899368286, 0.009305538609623909, -0.038363199681043625, 0.05396192520856857, -0.037182826548814774, 0.03351512551307678, -0.01816556230187416, -0.008735046721994877, -0.06085533648729324, 0.024579329416155815, 0.021518906578421593, -0.04439092054963112, 0.0010316325351595879, 0.0021494757384061813, 0.0076882257126271725, 0.047735124826431274, -0.041978709399700165, -0.030101951211690903, -0.04059860110282898, -0.05260328948497772, 0.0364479161798954, -0.07088402658700943, 0.020440012216567993, -0.0024650341365486383, -0.06418082863092422, -0.041169412434101105, 0.024637635797262192, -0.018238721415400505, 0.005436589475721121, -0.011139982379972935, -0.05235634371638298, 0.02595747448503971, 0.03865862265229225, 0.04640192538499832, -0.01967998594045639, -0.041571903973817825, 0.06914341449737549, -0.0305598434060812, 0.00018679650384001434, -0.022021878510713577, 0.047632377594709396, -0.030520210042595863, -0.058668144047260284, 0.008195006288588047, 0.03199594095349312, -0.012987068854272366, 0.06767556816339493, -0.007626149337738752, -0.0024275362957268953, -0.006733669899404049, 0.023965196684002876, -0.007951471954584122, 0.015571140684187412, 0.06524249911308289, 0.044294100254774094, -0.029178209602832794, 0.006462615914642811, -0.01312430389225483, -0.04492170363664627, -0.0077334376983344555, -0.001406311639584601, -0.033886656165122986, 0.020688358694314957, -0.05446173623204231, -0.007030056323856115, -0.06536230444908142, 0.03734220564365387, -0.012623371556401253, 0.002992956666275859, 0.0200907364487648, -0.014947076328098774, 0.017061196267604828, 0.04519395902752876, -0.019498050212860107, -0.0677553042769432, -0.021802427247166634, 0.03357413411140442, 0.011243666522204876, -0.0002891690528485924, -0.0245729498565197, -0.009605281054973602, 0.04757936671376228, -0.029674505814909935, -0.028584808111190796, 0.02690901793539524, -0.019195526838302612, -0.04979880899190903, -0.05889935418963432, 0.006932837422937155, -0.036605022847652435, -0.057731159031391144, -0.0336834192276001, 0.030614783987402916, 0.009208768606185913, 0.00408977922052145, 0.040775589644908905, -0.055432435125112534, -0.03315199539065361, 0.022882545366883278, 0.02696100063621998, -0.012950999662280083, -0.0048247831873595715, -0.017581956461071968, 0.0006064628250896931, 0.026955151930451393, -0.017216237261891365, 0.040276043117046356, -0.036912597715854645, 0.0050932420417666435, -0.001254446804523468, -0.009395771659910679, -0.01928083784878254, -0.00026230522780679166, -0.009331309236586094, 0.02278480865061283, -0.03867688030004501, 0.013709020800888538, -0.025691518560051918, -0.016422033309936523, 0.0047257146798074245, 0.0030712231528013945, -0.015321397222578526, -0.022916654124855995, -0.04324446618556976, -0.042855679988861084, -0.04319562762975693, -0.0014582426520064473, -0.05768227577209473, -0.05456090718507767, 0.01729627698659897, -0.030513279139995575, -0.01459119375795126, 0.010731271468102932, 0.010125413537025452, -0.05808105319738388, -0.018625343218445778, -0.07888561487197876, -0.013789665885269642, -0.008663353510200977, -0.005214313045144081, -0.04353206604719162, -0.025587528944015503, 0.03350735083222389, 0.007891368120908737, -0.043508801609277725, -0.009999601170420647, 0.011833537369966507, -0.04595706984400749, 0.004318270832300186, -0.02036474272608757, -0.08273874223232269, -0.04694955050945282, -0.050234533846378326, 0.007180048152804375, -0.0024790377356112003, -0.06044701859354973, 0.004174627363681793, 0.006566628813743591, -0.005413508042693138, 0.007509474642574787, 0.046562910079956055, 0.036544788628816605, 0.05473434552550316, 0.018025675788521767, 0.03801659494638443, -0.023164009675383568, -0.10274604707956314, 0.06694663316011429, 0.010114164091646671, -0.01921653375029564, 0.0344427116215229, 0.0004506728146225214, -0.012307857163250446, -0.03394760563969612, 0.037945423275232315, 0.04646547883749008, 0.03229835629463196, -0.041936732828617096, -0.010200676508247852, -0.04884093999862671, -0.0014224033802747726, -0.04266049340367317, -0.05417792499065399, -0.08578571677207947, -0.01918881945312023, 0.003763448679819703, 0.014768109656870365, 0.051687732338905334, -0.02148149535059929, -0.06907631456851959, -0.038933128118515015, 0.013572311028838158, 0.03365134447813034, -0.04793718084692955, -0.04432935640215874, -0.03549034148454666, -0.04395474120974541, 0.030068492516875267, -0.04659351333975792, -0.012934411875903606, -0.0016372828977182508, -0.0477076880633831, -0.01038266345858574, -0.01033621747046709, 0.01003942172974348, 0.014756085351109505, -0.03904343768954277, 0.03206982836127281, -0.02206786349415779, 0.06748215854167938, 0.006098106969147921, 0.04872250556945801, -0.03350994735956192, 0.005477998871356249, 0.00997145101428032, 0.005754576530307531, -0.030182329937815666, -0.03646508976817131, 0.00044392136624082923, -0.03040408156812191, -0.01717868074774742, 0.0410521924495697, 0.042513228952884674, 0.007666801568120718, -0.04260401055216789, -0.021313026547431946, -0.030491536483168602, -0.05775947868824005, 0.04488326981663704, 0.02568487636744976, 0.035260461270809174, -0.0035452928859740496, 0.023998990654945374, -0.05856506898999214, -0.010783113539218903, -0.03207738697528839, -0.006658719852566719, -0.06459635496139526, -0.06366469711065292, 0.0028407343197613955, -0.07305526733398438, -0.01426053885370493, -0.03258449584245682, -0.06225993484258652, 0.004117107484489679, -0.03823738917708397, -0.007816017605364323, -0.016807619482278824, 0.008926384150981903, 0.005984691437333822, -0.05756359547376633, 0.02634546346962452, 0.0422465018928051, 0.012500308454036713, -0.03251240402460098, -0.021377988159656525, -0.054418131709098816, 0.009369510225951672, 0.0584537610411644, 0.012040076777338982, -0.0635838508605957, 0.006731330417096615, -0.05428013205528259, 0.024109192192554474, -0.0036399250384420156, -0.02640986070036888, 0.03085000440478325, 0.021954292431473732, 0.006552789825946093, -0.05476447567343712, 0.02387898787856102, -0.01809667982161045, 0.039414726197719574, -0.026583539322018623, -0.029392385855317116, -0.03535197675228119, 0.043017659336328506, 0.01250513270497322, -0.06042533740401268, -0.013253533281385899, -0.01899075135588646, 0.01760312169790268, 0.008710939437150955, 0.033236343413591385, 0.044756293296813965, 0.04742884635925293, -0.04444175586104393, 0.009823586791753769, -0.03929899260401726, 0.005551665555685759, 0.0019699803087860346, 0.017815211787819862, -0.04254995658993721, 0.00043589522829279304, 0.025741392746567726, -0.09295336902141571, 0.052392181009054184, 0.012953469529747963, 0.06609920412302017, -0.012215686030685902, 0.005182300694286823, 0.025500042364001274, 0.017154015600681305, 0.008621416054666042, -0.011464127339422703, 0.006618117447942495, 0.028943169862031937, 0.046822480857372284, -0.03840474784374237, -0.030822088941931725, -0.014440847560763359, -0.05904078856110573, -0.050372496247291565, -0.03449522703886032, 0.05993512272834778, 0.059667788445949554, 0.020941300317645073, -0.05934542790055275, 0.050208620727062225, -0.021539947018027306, 0.03259845823049545, 0.017672186717391014, -0.03493628278374672, 0.04476480185985565, -0.043151386082172394, 0.02784138359129429, 0.028054457157850266, -0.02716430276632309, -0.031447943300008774, -0.07328325510025024, 0.02105725184082985, -0.04791514575481415, 0.03666462004184723, 0.044655974954366684, 0.028651028871536255, 0.016939545050263405, 0.024433959275484085, -0.008470704779028893, 0.047055684030056, 0.0019542891532182693, -0.017242351546883583, -0.03235447034239769, 0.009377625770866871, 0.03288584202528, 0.0037704387214034796, -0.0632844865322113, -0.005775132682174444, 0.006322574336081743, 0.0008091640775091946, -0.048609644174575806, 0.0009974909480661154, -0.0074158539064228535, -0.04276761785149574, -0.07299783080816269, -0.024096233770251274, -0.04022413119673729, 0.010430109687149525, -0.034503351897001266, -0.0214042067527771, 0.0605602003633976, -0.06167307123541832, 0.030944837257266045, -0.054214105010032654, 0.00751391751691699, -0.052654802799224854, -0.031400974839925766, -0.004286943003535271, -0.0889488235116005, 0.0009341377881355584, -0.052444007247686386, 0.06222383677959442, -0.025453563779592514, -0.0007967767887748778, -0.06382036954164505, -0.031579289585351944, 0.009749162942171097, 0.013113857246935368, 0.03732047602534294, 0.015401789918541908, -0.002101265825331211, 0.035232774913311005, -0.017599809914827347, 0.00807755347341299, 0.005397563334554434, 0.016488535329699516, -0.010287197306752205, 0.03262519836425781, 0.007986195385456085, -0.010478861629962921, -0.04992584511637688, -0.003896279726177454, 0.03827917203307152, -0.04783981293439865, -0.005068894010037184, 0.02597908116877079, 0.03850894421339035, -0.03265604376792908, -0.07464014738798141, -0.04058026149868965, -0.019159669056534767, -0.04144361987709999, -0.005386125296354294, 0.03062976710498333, 0.011383861303329468, 0.020831948146224022, 0.020185915753245354, 0.0408160537481308, 0.02976236119866371, -0.027132874354720116, 0.033523108810186386, -0.023512670770287514, 0.04047727212309837, -0.028867684304714203, -0.03977445885539055, -0.047661192715168, 0.013751854188740253, -0.019374515861272812, -0.00796157494187355, 0.030565012246370316, 0.027968816459178925, 0.02772532030940056, 0.06248190999031067, -0.089173324406147, 0.03340883180499077, 0.008378587663173676, 0.00400622608140111, -0.012930521741509438, 0.05426093935966492, 0.016703171655535698, 0.049155157059431076, -0.016597691923379898, -0.035164762288331985, 0.024854207411408424, -0.047551196068525314, 0.03205668553709984, 0.01497719157487154, -0.02232990972697735, 0.018965156748890877, 0.042466338723897934, 0.00235552410595119, -0.054841749370098114, 0.014087316580116749, 0.02491922490298748, 0.004182085860520601, -0.038089361041784286, 0.0271861981600523, 0.04703090712428093, 0.005686013028025627, -0.015409235842525959, 0.012885943986475468, -0.021772556006908417, 0.024235470220446587, 0.05334661155939102, -0.031878769397735596, -0.015934713184833527, 0.02798144333064556, 0.026188498362898827, -0.011069774627685547, -0.013500592671334743, -0.026728210970759392, 0.027684522792696953, 0.019681138917803764, 0.023433169350028038, -0.06354653835296631, -0.06717560440301895, -0.051128894090652466, 0.023375414311885834, 0.030588719993829727, 0.0676577091217041, 0.03007197007536888, 0.05721415579319, 0.022084271535277367, -0.038315799087285995, -0.02167886309325695, -0.021822983399033546, 0.05934172123670578, -0.008105332963168621, 0.03748530149459839, 0.005830487702041864, 0.056708335876464844, -0.002759621711447835, 0.04910977557301521, 0.055120162665843964, 0.009026135317981243, -0.03199455142021179, 0.0000475547494716011, 0.016407964751124382, 0.0448014959692955, -0.03193267062306404, -0.008534754626452923, 0.028710076585412025, -0.0036120072472840548, 0.054147299379110336, 0.0737515315413475, -0.021707499399781227, -0.005297930911183357, -0.024584470316767693, -0.03763314336538315, -0.06694894284009933, 0.017051726579666138, 0.08113669604063034, -0.05496048927307129, -0.014882872812449932, -0.04836564138531685, -0.01566409319639206, 0.036218270659446716, -0.04099827632308006, -0.012981792911887169, -0.015422689728438854, -0.01671001873910427, -0.0739889070391655, 0.03969668969511986, 0.0007633714703842998, -0.07199086248874664, -0.008239754475653172, 0.012569861486554146, -0.08146023005247116, -0.020536722615361214, 0.04197641834616661, -0.012734831310808659, -0.002301060128957033, 0.05317263305187225, -0.057068970054388046, 0.009005441330373287, -0.019068852066993713, 0.06975427269935608, 0.07798831909894943, -0.007869090884923935, 0.03853697329759598, 0.03510959818959236, 0.01595836505293846, -0.024086084216833115, -0.020424673333764076, -0.009251346811652184, -0.018895378336310387, 0.05209159851074219, 0.035981304943561554, -0.05564013868570328, -0.029741089791059494, 0.044012364000082016, -0.029193619266152382, 0.03701858967542648, 0.01321491040289402, -0.007099770475178957, 0.024175768718123436, -0.03554827719926834, -0.05855144187808037, 0.010385725647211075, -0.023119736462831497, -0.040014881640672684, 0.0037033187691122293, -0.03889479860663414, 0.010720769874751568, 0.036297593265771866, 0.014695527963340282, -0.05643521621823311, -0.0010600785026326776, 0.010586695745587349, -0.034782834351062775, 0.04453541710972786, -0.07504963874816895, 0.010912517085671425, 0.025319093838334084, 0.05254725366830826, 0.04655760899186134, 0.05346611142158508, -0.06268367916345596, 0.005932447966188192, 0.048984676599502563, 0.021496595814824104, 0.046098992228507996, 0.016279196366667747, 0.05620727315545082, -0.05824478715658188, 0.012554279528558254, -0.026138247922062874, -0.023110536858439445, -0.023630430921912193, -0.03607362508773804, -0.048879802227020264, 0.023775257170200348, -0.0058167544193565845, -0.05553818866610527, 0.032946377992630005, 0.003146994858980179, -0.005266537889838219, 0.02082478255033493, 0.01605769619345665, -0.0495012067258358, 0.020254844799637794, -0.0045037418603897095, -0.00009581294580129907, 0.0240370761603117, 0.033417053520679474, 0.03870296850800514, 0.012522310949862003, 0.03448403626680374, 0.0034309683833271265, 0.00960622914135456, 0.0043514184653759, -0.013659771531820297, -0.012586716562509537, 0.028413614258170128, 0.0445893220603466, -0.05955169349908829, 0.012461687438189983, 0.006943130865693092, -0.08487866818904877, 0.002488198922947049, 0.02688015066087246, -0.019250353798270226, -0.006423600483685732, -0.06728247553110123, -0.01490726973861456, 0.029202263802289963, -0.06104710325598717, -0.0745052844285965, -0.044370464980602264, -0.01093821506947279, -0.03746507689356804, -0.010169890709221363, -0.04330136626958847, -0.0640765056014061, -0.006880429107695818, -0.09814825654029846, -0.017641598358750343, -0.027591461315751076, 0.05032069608569145, -0.0375814326107502, -0.03647404536604881, 0.032195083796978, 0.0126039432361722, 0.0032786570955067873, 0.01368007343262434, 0.030353637412190437, 0.04098045453429222, -0.009955496527254581, -0.016678951680660248, -0.038092389702796936, -0.017156044021248817, 0.02087642066180706, 0.010634452104568481, -0.0071900999173521996, -0.010117261670529842, 0.024984167888760567, -0.0014613957609981298, -0.0035339791793376207, 0.07249648869037628, 0.039547961205244064, 0.011239055544137955, -0.011822264641523361, -0.022229664027690887, -0.017526375129818916, -0.07048576325178146, 0.02015027590095997, -0.0413016751408577, 0.017550310119986534, 0.04083477333188057, 0.003345959819853306, -0.0174641702324152, -0.01336462888866663, -0.02103922888636589, 0.02803906612098217, 0.008594180457293987, -0.014141196385025978, 0.029227914288640022, -0.07863647490739822, 0.06036102771759033, 0.008460262790322304, 0.0022617385257035494, -0.03094623237848282, -0.025490652769804, 0.05341702699661255, -0.05708574503660202, 0.0041705830954015255, -0.03316736966371536, 0.026808664202690125, -0.007988396100699902, 0.023875268176198006, -0.05499224364757538, 0.06689997762441635, 0.0030117949936538935, -0.031784046441316605, -0.06085582822561264, -0.012105277739465237, -0.005951655097305775, -0.04907301813364029, -0.01906610280275345, -0.008492945693433285, 0.032279327511787415, -0.04035443440079689, -0.010843263939023018, -0.00653933035209775, 0.059770405292510986, 0.010257807560265064, 0.00018385153089184314, 0.023518258705735207, 0.014042431488633156, -0.03378241881728172, 0.07661613821983337, 0.011832690797746181, 0.015295254997909069, -0.036592550575733185, 0.049613941460847855, -0.012295744381844997, -0.020128963515162468, 0.025990650057792664, 0.030886642634868622, -0.03199760243296623, -0.027603257447481155, -0.03675435110926628, -0.007193667348474264, -0.05538860335946083, -0.03794972971081734, -0.023973697796463966, 0.057917047291994095, -0.018271807581186295, -0.03443717211484909 ]
Many magnetic materials are predicted to exhibit bosonic topological edge modes in their excitation spectra, because of the nontrivial topology of their magnon, triplon or other quasi-particle band structures. However, there is a discrepancy between theory prediction and experimental observation, which suggests some underlying mechanism that intrinsically suppresses the expected experimental signatures, like the thermal Hall current. Many-body interactions that are not accounted for in the non-interacting quasi-particle picture are most often identified as the reason for the absence of the topological edge modes. Here we report stable bosonic edge modes at the boundaries of a ladder quantum paramagnet with gapped triplon excitations in the presence of the full many-body interaction. For the first time, we use tensor network methods to resolve topological edge modes in the time-dependent spin-spin correlations and the dynamical structure factor, which is directly accessible experimentally. We further show that these edge modes have anomalously long time coherence, discuss the topological phase diagram of the model, demonstrate the fractionalization of its low-lying excitations, and propose potential material candidates.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15113v1
[ -0.01513072568923235, -0.04523563012480736, 0.02656061202287674, 0.0006722678081132472, 0.02557963691651821, -0.02705005556344986, 0.00938887894153595, 0.03728238120675087, -0.00853528082370758, 0.02155599184334278, -0.0001207972745760344, -0.06020323187112808, -0.05174887552857399, -0.05671430006623268, -0.0422900952398777, -0.008004849776625633, 0.08006919175386429, 0.027290981262922287, -0.04947188124060631, 0.06582164019346237, 0.00002091008900606539, 0.0017524039139971137, 0.012084603309631348, 0.0429348386824131, -0.017603520303964615, -0.01689234748482704, -0.028764143586158752, 0.021954156458377838, -0.044498298317193985, -0.012684841640293598, 0.0673518255352974, -0.05319754034280777, -0.0007530751172453165, -0.005335699301213026, -0.013288985006511211, -0.008263392373919487, 0.023721877485513687, 0.035011015832424164, 0.07042086124420166, -0.01659148558974266, -0.008019284345209599, -0.04517247900366783, -0.05522412806749344, 0.014558467082679272, -0.026184270158410072, 0.0004778637085109949, -0.02729020081460476, 0.0024804454296827316, -0.037592094391584396, -0.06978996098041534, 0.030319740995764732, 0.02342241443693638, 0.045887552201747894, 0.03964894264936447, -0.07018457353115082, 0.0005120980204083025, 0.007253006566315889, 0.012034588493406773, -0.05472316965460777, 0.010892145335674286, -0.031075920909643173, -0.0292405616492033, 0.028478646650910378, 0.0012383878929540515, -0.035394731909036636, 0.02426346391439438, -0.01491674967110157, -0.06824915111064911, -0.031411848962306976, -0.07216566056013107, 0.030838513746857643, -0.06877510249614716, 0.007944347336888313, 0.005682563409209251, -0.06780410557985306, 0.011515995487570763, -0.01563096232712269, -0.0004467071557883173, -0.03111385554075241, 0.030909046530723572, -0.032713476568460464, -0.013720334507524967, 0.03459598124027252, -0.023243514820933342, 0.0052239298820495605, 0.04722179099917412, 0.036018047481775284, -0.0041901720687747, 0.031180353835225105, -0.05776520445942879, 0.05163578316569328, -0.02517147921025753, -0.05907547101378441, -0.03200530633330345, 0.0718391165137291, -0.0449172779917717, 0.06812162697315216, 0.02915171906352043, 0.04344739019870758, -0.009585740976035595, 0.008632472716271877, -0.018689213320612907, -0.04368828609585762, 0.025918038561940193, -0.015277065336704254, -0.04418894648551941, 0.024577321484684944, -0.025434866547584534, -0.03761442005634308, 0.006226646713912487, -0.01937231421470642, -0.03369428589940071, 0.030156884342432022, -0.02637912519276142, -0.022061731666326523, -0.04056143760681152, 0.05349121242761612, -0.015579363331198692, 0.055313773453235626, 0.03312533348798752, -0.015289138071238995, 0.055463358759880066, -0.007446221075952053, 0.017245328053832054, -0.05326826125383377, 0.01184165384620428, 0.07010422646999359, 0.013047249987721443, -0.030267376452684402, -0.0512993298470974, -0.06008617952466011, -0.006460847333073616, 0.016563523560762405, -0.044366247951984406, 0.04890478402376175, 0.0062490603886544704, -0.004115513525903225, -0.005351330153644085, -0.014633753336966038, 0.005670322570949793, -0.021586736664175987, -0.05106965824961662, -0.024183528497815132, 0.007118173409253359, 0.01649678312242031, 0.02042992040514946, -0.08297493308782578, -0.0004433283756952733, 0.03380298987030983, 0.017733268439769745, 0.017194394022226334, 0.0034644377883523703, 0.007789462339133024, 0.03691732883453369, 0.04183776676654816, -0.05965721979737282, 0.0150596359744668, 0.028412627056241035, -0.05369130149483681, 0.004995549563318491, 0.016652069985866547, -0.03857307508587837, 0.0230104997754097, 0.005624605808407068, -0.007566789165139198, 0.01773417741060257, 0.0196304339915514, -0.050653014332056046, -0.023316441103816032, -0.019935524091124535, -0.012677481397986412, 0.018678050488233566, -0.005493411794304848, -0.06040472909808159, -0.029399896040558815, -0.037173014134168625, -0.017909986898303032, -0.06947370618581772, -0.02774595282971859, 0.011541761457920074, 0.029992956668138504, 0.013564691878855228, -0.046847715973854065, -0.032856862992048264, -0.017060358077287674, 0.024734189733862877, -0.08312595635652542, -0.02408190816640854, 0.030775098130106926, -0.022630997002124786, -0.04548351466655731, -0.03418200463056564, 0.019711000844836235, 0.007879539392888546, -0.020682476460933685, -0.016424890607595444, 0.00517680961638689, -0.028737323358654976, -0.031795866787433624, 0.013292822055518627, -0.07445327192544937, 0.015067671425640583, -0.025779251009225845, -0.02708246558904648, -0.03322579339146614, -0.05550235137343407, -0.0002551301149651408, 0.023556401953101158, -0.04962241277098656, -0.028907200321555138, 0.043915484100580215, 0.041114889085292816, 0.042423080652952194, 0.002620830899104476, 0.012616588734090328, 0.032064419239759445, -0.09253985434770584, 0.053840965032577515, 0.017868202179670334, -0.002273454098030925, 0.018478773534297943, -0.0006466065533459187, 0.022958846762776375, -0.05622172728180885, -0.04173622280359268, 0.06416507810354233, 0.006270047277212143, 0.02883211523294449, -0.048367053270339966, -0.026269739493727684, -0.01997934840619564, -0.06172868236899376, -0.03494300693273544, -0.05816679075360298, -0.01522024068981409, 0.014298193156719208, -0.07310360670089722, 0.0391426607966423, -0.021299991756677628, -0.02689424902200699, -0.04852112755179405, -0.023545971140265465, 0.036475639790296555, -0.03583665192127228, -0.03184325248003006, -0.042386967688798904, -0.05894571170210838, 0.0434098020195961, -0.04710932821035385, -0.008413820527493954, -0.024790294468402863, -0.06266439706087112, -0.036903031170368195, -0.0011335073504596949, 0.030976872891187668, 0.0680156871676445, -0.05219332501292229, -0.01933707669377327, -0.00868224911391735, 0.03279707208275795, 0.022568056359887123, 0.02511579729616642, -0.02778736874461174, 0.028704950585961342, 0.04766923561692238, 0.025382034480571747, -0.041584741324186325, 0.012235203757882118, 0.004843865055590868, -0.0455746054649353, 0.028279246762394905, 0.01727250963449478, 0.049443673342466354, -0.008070949465036392, 0.014038599096238613, -0.04449145123362541, -0.03738365322351456, -0.04189730063080788, 0.008999505080282688, 0.03953436017036438, 0.07246118783950806, -0.0028066623490303755, -0.052391305565834045, -0.07740604132413864, -0.018932567909359932, -0.02556089125573635, 0.00048478945973329246, -0.04863647744059563, -0.04289693385362625, -0.010216874070465565, -0.06940803676843643, 0.035498399287462234, -0.0578073151409626, 0.005285320803523064, -0.05328366905450821, -0.06391772627830505, -0.035651519894599915, -0.014110717922449112, 0.02920648269355297, -0.05047210678458214, -0.061534345149993896, -0.018830377608537674, 0.021825965493917465, 0.02395608462393284, -0.013225809670984745, -0.03359106928110123, -0.03999371454119682, 0.018563099205493927, 0.0012526476057246327, -0.031032780185341835, -0.06589233130216599, 0.02678558975458145, -0.06731821596622467, -0.00839907769113779, 0.004914840217679739, 0.04069047048687935, 0.01640641689300537, -0.03376598656177521, 0.0057113575749099255, -0.010946877300739288, -0.004137950483709574, 0.015664277598261833, 0.0007791669922880828, -0.003339118789881468, -0.07376917451620102, -0.023197870701551437, 0.054433517158031464, 0.06392721831798553, -0.015649426728487015, -0.03532210364937782, -0.007832377217710018, -0.02853051945567131, 0.037279605865478516, 0.026634477078914642, 0.06712643802165985, 0.04223661869764328, -0.04713740199804306, -0.0009015577961690724, -0.03765034303069115, 0.02468816749751568, -0.028035692870616913, 0.02925381436944008, -0.01361884269863367, -0.022588931024074554, -0.00975335668772459, -0.04882408306002617, 0.01093066856265068, 0.023432113230228424, 0.03750823438167572, 0.0005595982656814158, -0.004511653911322355, 0.009789085946977139, 0.02607622742652893, 0.015741100534796715, -0.00632448447868228, 0.01482187770307064, -0.0018399904947727919, 0.06771326810121536, -0.0373702310025692, -0.06018584221601486, 0.011050453409552574, -0.07148361206054688, -0.057084228843450546, 0.036951761692762375, 0.008743642829358578, 0.018011918291449547, 0.02022821456193924, -0.015942657366394997, 0.039582058787345886, -0.05585063248872757, 0.03285463899374008, -0.039235811680555344, -0.0068223970010876656, 0.008978950791060925, -0.010954625904560089, -0.02799229323863983, -0.01676025427877903, 0.0017879450460895896, -0.05216418579220772, -0.05738399177789688, -0.012369170784950256, -0.06263374537229538, 0.021958336234092712, 0.05025211349129677, 0.05314898118376732, 0.018098294734954834, 0.02445712685585022, -0.023986805230379105, 0.048082977533340454, 0.020332397893071175, 0.029321972280740738, -0.024071697145700455, 0.006560380570590496, 0.026776112616062164, -0.023693125694990158, -0.03707277402281761, -0.007075707893818617, 0.0010076442267745733, -0.04074621945619583, 0.0041734641417860985, -0.008065467700362206, 0.004171699285507202, -0.03430970013141632, -0.08514329046010971, -0.01900359056890011, -0.03518472984433174, 0.011988954618573189, -0.028228797018527985, -0.04571644961833954, 0.07573788613080978, -0.026273369789123535, 0.011323136277496815, -0.005253075156360865, -0.04647776111960411, -0.05840149521827698, 0.03417455777525902, -0.02695334143936634, -0.027692019939422607, 0.038561031222343445, -0.035236600786447525, -0.0031040532048791647, -0.01985303871333599, 0.03283544257283211, -0.06924355030059814, 0.04861202463507652, 0.042623527348041534, 0.055261049419641495, 0.04891445115208626, 0.015364556573331356, 0.023369140923023224, -0.012186145409941673, 0.0004697169060818851, -0.019794907420873642, 0.009492572396993637, 0.0003009620413649827, -0.03558851778507233, 0.013529078103601933, -0.06280893832445145, -0.016889099031686783, -0.04841766506433487, 0.005769683513790369, 0.06650812178850174, -0.03444574028253555, -0.029802504926919937, 0.012840161100029945, 0.03709295392036438, -0.014464146457612514, -0.0713191106915474, -0.02336002141237259, -0.035159144550561905, -0.07800199836492538, 0.002916412428021431, -0.001712438534013927, 0.01352914422750473, -0.00863237027078867, 0.041023656725883484, -0.041809141635894775, 0.021056873723864555, -0.027362417429685593, 0.012026605196297169, 0.03227050229907036, 0.012559464201331139, 0.04189213737845421, -0.03580252826213837, -0.06251464784145355, -0.0102338632568717, 0.01643010415136814, -0.01683005318045616, -0.006220171693712473, 0.024159735068678856, -0.02694043703377247, 0.038329754024744034, -0.07426692545413971, 0.04054511338472366, 0.05496591702103615, -0.051479775458574295, -0.025005662813782692, 0.021110665053129196, -0.030249599367380142, 0.002930314978584647, -0.03547114133834839, 0.01402978878468275, -0.022392302751541138, -0.02114267461001873, 0.017394790425896645, 0.014425469562411308, -0.029178429394960403, -0.012142430059611797, 0.02386455237865448, 0.005472686607390642, -0.0652085542678833, 0.037940531969070435, 0.029165752232074738, -0.0300820954144001, -0.0508529357612133, 0.02744404226541519, 0.03385039418935776, -0.014829539693892002, -0.01750192418694496, -0.010129152797162533, 0.005039817187935114, 0.01339723914861679, 0.023042339831590652, -0.08044232428073883, -0.009539974853396416, 0.009562259539961815, 0.02557504177093506, 0.037301383912563324, 0.0060846335254609585, -0.018764058127999306, -0.0012016254477202892, 0.022885041311383247, -0.010097585618495941, -0.05562252551317215, 0.034535087645053864, -0.05868314951658249, 0.04064095765352249, 0.043168846517801285, 0.03283826261758804, 0.00035718176513910294, 0.06959577649831772, -0.0039465660229325294, -0.04450201243162155, -0.039082638919353485, -0.011785238981246948, 0.05635104700922966, -0.04130125045776367, 0.030813243240118027, 0.026757309213280678, 0.0315667949616909, -0.007582301273941994, 0.014259040355682373, -0.04431707412004471, -0.048545677214860916, -0.057602450251579285, 0.0060536726377904415, -0.036714792251586914, -0.0008782804943621159, -0.06203843653202057, 0.029108980670571327, 0.05303743854165077, 0.0007672844803892076, 0.028572402894496918, 0.01859922520816326, 0.04830114543437958, 0.0018133395351469517, 0.02026512660086155, 0.046018823981285095, -0.06201484054327011, -0.025695284828543663, 0.08236166834831238, -0.0792054608464241, -0.024363992735743523, -0.017230195924639702, -0.043477531522512436, -0.030642522498965263, -0.03717966377735138, -0.0069482941180467606, 0.04149101674556732, -0.009199617430567741, -0.07197409123182297, 0.009061266668140888, 0.0180719755589962, -0.05643784627318382, -0.012866312637925148, -0.024302242323756218, -0.07618935406208038, 0.004868118558079004, -0.023140812292695045, -0.02192467451095581, -0.02114454284310341, 0.03226771205663681, -0.044521111994981766, -0.05615942180156708, -0.01669343188405037, 0.05270860344171524, 0.0636167898774147, -0.03263918310403824, 0.022072643041610718, 0.013011110946536064, -0.009589492343366146, -0.0036481653805822134, -0.04711870104074478, -0.003450558055192232, 0.036457642912864685, 0.04159370809793472, -0.016242219135165215, -0.027087058871984482, -0.01939697563648224, 0.022592846304178238, -0.023529106751084328, -0.04650255665183067, -0.000156810216140002, 0.010402267798781395, 0.03916222229599953, -0.0548270121216774, -0.03410302475094795, -0.0034092068672180176, 0.037269700318574905, -0.0027980285231024027, -0.046545084565877914, 0.013609390705823898, -0.01468972023576498, 0.03725339472293854, 0.0002114115923177451, -0.012107953429222107, -0.02244996652007103, -0.04397447779774666, -0.07620447874069214, -0.01712716929614544, -0.011021086014807224, 0.004665132146328688, -0.005280892830342054, 0.04100703075528145, 0.015848660841584206, 0.049209874123334885, -0.033094726502895355, 0.02215343713760376, 0.0028133986052125692, -0.0050797369331121445, 0.00982578657567501, 0.014052128419280052, 0.005750702228397131, -0.013878720812499523, 0.03361015021800995, -0.014820726588368416, 0.003740179818123579, -0.057194244116544724, -0.07170518487691879, 0.03739815577864647, -0.036973144859075546, -0.03341270983219147, 0.017998578026890755, -0.012444132938981056, -0.04708905145525932, -0.012467369437217712, 0.026785176247358322, 0.00899104867130518, -0.06996803730726242, 0.01271010097116232, 0.0006611431017518044, 0.00527635682374239, -0.008112777024507523, 0.03166763111948967, 0.024024125188589096, -0.006453694775700569, 0.06461437046527863, 0.06495426595211029, 0.032552797347307205, 0.0012901186710223556, -0.055100150406360626, 0.02104433998465538, 0.043347958475351334, 0.025604212656617165, -0.03926580026745796, 0.01567726768553257, -0.031312741339206696, -0.08007676154375076, 0.01570631004869938, -0.004864368587732315, -0.04779588058590889, -0.01563047245144844, -0.05055026710033417, 0.023813683539628983, 0.037578754127025604, -0.03658502176403999, -0.07752257585525513, -0.0035883462987840176, 0.019716797396540642, -0.009675140492618084, -0.030074337497353554, -0.02277214452624321, -0.0713111013174057, -0.018567170947790146, -0.07934257388114929, 0.00220917584374547, -0.030552897602319717, 0.06564553081989288, 0.036687444895505905, 0.0057967668399214745, -0.044125933200120926, -0.018771905452013016, 0.02861807309091091, 0.020937327295541763, -0.002035051817074418, 0.05137331783771515, -0.02138320729136467, 0.03395577892661095, -0.027651064097881317, -0.005912791471928358, 0.01983758807182312, -0.032547637820243835, -0.0175115168094635, 0.00934373028576374, 0.045276276767253876, -0.01731768064200878, 0.015766466036438942, 0.0023630941286683083, -0.04974580183625221, 0.014099596999585629, -0.0436449758708477, 0.027697598561644554, -0.05841083452105522, -0.06489019095897675, 0.047944143414497375, -0.028146572411060333, -0.0009899918222799897, -0.0004189771134406328, 0.0007053500157780945, -0.029605330899357796, -0.033451713621616364, -0.04507482424378395, 0.06088567525148392, 0.04713604599237442, -0.02164425700902939, 0.06691860407590866, -0.04681083932518959, -0.009025833569467068, -0.03407111391425133, 0.005227626301348209, -0.019874727353453636, 0.045345768332481384, 0.027482738718390465, -0.057394083589315414, 0.038452066481113434, -0.08341069519519806, 0.05456983298063278, -0.01156077440828085, 0.0222900602966547, -0.01092230249196291, 0.06466023623943329, -0.06248674541711807, 0.001294490066356957, -0.05062529072165489, -0.031966108828783035, -0.04781379923224449, -0.04959544539451599, -0.011914364993572235, 0.033633604645729065, 0.009166172705590725, 0.013810601085424423, 0.043413471430540085, 0.010216912254691124, 0.05604234337806702, 0.02412799745798111, 0.022639790549874306, -0.038365233689546585, -0.010279075242578983, -0.04484812170267105, 0.04595581069588661, -0.00007932363223517314, -0.04354417696595192, -0.05642160400748253, -0.007239359896630049, 0.010624190792441368, -0.02458157017827034, 0.013033551163971424, 0.02637273259460926, -0.037585318088531494, -0.05285714939236641, -0.045117542147636414, 0.04174197092652321, 0.002495477208867669, 0.0019283818546682596, 0.03563064709305763, 0.022696983069181442, -0.02100110426545143, -0.060837212949991226 ]
This paper presents a state-of-the-art solution to the LongEval CLEF 2023 Lab Task 2: LongEval-Classification. The goal of this task is to improve and preserve the performance of sentiment analysis models across shorter and longer time periods. Our framework feeds date-prefixed textual inputs to a pre-trained language model, where the timestamp is included in the text. We show date-prefixed samples better conditions model outputs on the temporal context of the respective texts. Moreover, we further boost performance by performing self-labeling on unlabeled data to train a student model. We augment the self-labeling process using a novel augmentation strategy leveraging the date-prefixed formatting of our samples. We demonstrate concrete performance gains on the LongEval-Classification evaluation set over non-augmented self-labeling. Our framework achieves a 2nd place ranking with an overall score of 0.6923 and reports the best Relative Performance Drop (RPD) of -0.0656 over the short evaluation set.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13562v1
[ -0.010404071770608425, -0.03419090062379837, 0.03733069822192192, 0.03371068090200424, -0.03542306274175644, 0.002974958159029484, -0.03744698315858841, -0.010816292837262154, 0.042136285454034805, -0.009897896088659763, -0.03371594473719597, 0.02905081771314144, -0.0511254221200943, -0.01870962418615818, 0.013296378776431084, 0.01901056058704853, 0.04058616980910301, 0.01860182173550129, -0.02392839454114437, 0.059554263949394226, -0.0031609698198735714, -0.015122922137379646, -0.06029731407761574, 0.0346599705517292, 0.01728876680135727, -0.0020224072504788637, -0.04629899933934212, -0.014381836168467999, -0.014917667023837566, -0.02551441453397274, 0.07498369365930557, -0.013532815501093864, -0.01313875149935484, -0.03923455998301506, -0.026808016002178192, -0.05230901390314102, 0.0365053191781044, -0.009980759583413601, 0.001631107646971941, -0.03386840224266052, 0.042354684323072433, -0.07622849196195602, -0.06027337163686752, 0.0005118696135468781, -0.013195746578276157, 0.02243269607424736, -0.03570667281746864, 0.06364467740058899, -0.08649793267250061, -0.05786895379424095, 0.04165839031338692, -0.01344839297235012, -0.03286366164684296, 0.028814762830734253, -0.052507031708955765, 0.013187059201300144, 0.019816359505057335, 0.003923302050679922, -0.05519934743642807, -0.03364235535264015, 0.03858964517712593, -0.014107590541243553, -0.03488170728087425, 0.026970436796545982, 0.009203465655446053, 0.016510779038071632, 0.011643148958683014, -0.0689794048666954, -0.04430576413869858, -0.0690867155790329, 0.04295264557003975, -0.05121159180998802, -0.031316112726926804, -0.007307191379368305, -0.02777082286775112, -0.021674133837223053, -0.05215933918952942, -0.01755201630294323, 0.0021083378233015537, -0.008058147504925728, -0.009362156502902508, 0.05446281284093857, 0.04803016036748886, 0.02876228466629982, -0.0282637570053339, -0.06359623372554779, 0.01687067747116089, 0.03774841129779816, -0.012657957151532173, 0.00043939505121670663, 0.03656423091888428, -0.026132410392165184, -0.06128688529133797, 0.05642079561948776, 0.029187804087996483, 0.00019738545233849436, 0.05829188600182533, 0.025862814858555794, 0.019480623304843903, -0.007711352780461311, -0.0016703341389074922, 0.009224777109920979, -0.011233281344175339, 0.06261272728443146, 0.030078202486038208, -0.02408602274954319, 0.021736187860369682, 0.03551194816827774, -0.04148012772202492, 0.020490581169724464, -0.039288923144340515, -0.013843731954693794, 0.02944963425397873, -0.04705032706260681, -0.0560888797044754, -0.04962892457842827, 0.0185445174574852, -0.015100165270268917, 0.03782699257135391, -0.004709384869784117, -0.004335533827543259, 0.06837331503629684, 0.028312550857663155, -0.02162349596619606, -0.023172862827777863, -0.03770631179213524, -0.008678256534039974, 0.03062359243631363, -0.059358496218919754, -0.006374558433890343, -0.006962754763662815, -0.0024456975515931845, -0.012090642005205154, -0.05859686806797981, 0.021474778652191162, 0.008335268124938011, -0.017301464453339577, -0.03979006037116051, 0.016612576320767403, -0.04985269904136658, -0.05341656506061554, -0.06372557580471039, 0.02183939702808857, -0.04152705892920494, -0.029016995802521706, 0.05418857932090759, -0.00845522340387106, -0.03741440549492836, 0.027400732040405273, -0.009753314778208733, 0.04452291876077652, -0.04200250655412674, 0.022279758006334305, 0.009827842004597187, 0.004571390803903341, -0.010160633362829685, -0.0015305276028811932, -0.020908843725919724, -0.059271082282066345, 0.03054228611290455, 0.005299037322402, -0.025691021233797073, 0.04812011495232582, -0.06653018295764923, 0.05383291468024254, -0.017094286158680916, 0.0493670329451561, -0.013492903672158718, -0.01876554824411869, 0.03316239267587662, -0.00792066939175129, -0.00794197991490364, -0.020029859617352486, -0.01681816764175892, -0.04316495358943939, -0.032296668738126755, -0.002945441287010908, -0.0177754033356905, -0.08497972041368484, -0.05144244804978371, -0.025061247870326042, 0.012737508863210678, -0.0036459662951529026, -0.032045748084783554, -0.04951133579015732, -0.01778925210237503, -0.07153286784887314, -0.02006974071264267, 0.04939384013414383, 0.008682784624397755, -0.027807097882032394, -0.0008234836277551949, 0.005414806772023439, 0.05057275667786598, -0.037237342447042465, -0.06899633258581161, 0.040631458163261414, -0.016377391293644905, 0.0012287357822060585, 0.009915800765156746, -0.08959745615720749, -0.06462595611810684, -0.051095303148031235, 0.011396024376153946, -0.025238368660211563, -0.038532428443431854, -0.01144036091864109, 0.058543186634778976, -0.059333328157663345, 0.014188678003847599, -0.0036469390615820885, 0.059039801359176636, 0.06972350925207138, 0.03298947587609291, 0.06302301585674286, -0.01635514758527279, -0.09673913568258286, 0.05964614823460579, -0.010634713806211948, 0.03228006511926651, 0.025552069768309593, 0.039189305156469345, 0.00008280124893644825, -0.02735850214958191, -0.014014466665685177, 0.05494694039225578, 0.02677007019519806, -0.03263929486274719, -0.04529586806893349, -0.038641609251499176, 0.002440204843878746, -0.053724255412817, -0.04027803614735603, -0.07713481038808823, -0.005255051888525486, 0.013697908259928226, -0.009579392150044441, 0.028002044185996056, -0.018723051995038986, -0.04126394912600517, -0.04392194375395775, -0.046486157923936844, 0.024518869817256927, -0.019628044217824936, -0.014229880645871162, -0.058925144374370575, -0.02586550824344158, 0.03260509669780731, -0.03703204169869423, -0.021978134289383888, -0.00040077243465930223, -0.018316173925995827, -0.021024189889431, -0.03453920781612396, 0.03614221140742302, 0.027360666543245316, -0.026362210512161255, 0.005603871773928404, -0.019383341073989868, 0.03372940793633461, 0.010790645144879818, 0.06342308968305588, -0.0369684062898159, -0.004233557730913162, 0.031853485852479935, -0.03876657411456108, 0.013348279520869255, -0.04768109321594238, -0.047019630670547485, 0.012168623507022858, 0.048891134560108185, 0.04632663354277611, 0.036806195974349976, -0.013652496039867401, -0.012313483282923698, -0.03949448838829994, 0.013871720992028713, -0.03879157453775406, 0.010428127832710743, 0.05316583812236786, 0.03530683368444443, 0.0542985163629055, 0.013075013644993305, -0.067701056599617, -0.002008056500926614, -0.04561040550470352, -0.0571807324886322, -0.05893755704164505, -0.060414865612983704, 0.018454011529684067, -0.06340374052524567, 0.005845325067639351, -0.028213275596499443, -0.004670191090553999, 0.005468261428177357, -0.020933356136083603, -0.06583701074123383, 0.0056310854852199554, 0.03370662033557892, -0.0002164202305721119, -0.016226092353463173, -0.04216938093304634, 0.026635579764842987, -0.012824039906263351, 0.030026253312826157, -0.0431007519364357, -0.03558627516031265, -0.014543545432388783, 0.037930697202682495, 0.03129371628165245, -0.03009353019297123, 0.029854441061615944, 0.025335757061839104, 0.027015605941414833, -0.00713659031316638, 0.05762394890189171, -0.012811393477022648, 0.034537941217422485, 0.003434605197981, -0.038221802562475204, 0.016119016334414482, 0.01375480554997921, -0.03688627853989601, 0.005306176841259003, -0.04928475245833397, -0.045225996524095535, 0.03790679946541786, -0.0032040041405707598, -0.05630306154489517, 0.004764794372022152, -0.034027617424726486, 0.03908122330904007, 0.028000814840197563, -0.02147090435028076, 0.05951598659157753, 0.023424938321113586, -0.03180544823408127, -0.007429539225995541, -0.012465937063097954, -0.051148153841495514, -0.0315142460167408, 0.02043183147907257, -0.04686640202999115, 0.015426469035446644, 0.05256509408354759, -0.08923503756523132, 0.012320472858846188, 0.021550782024860382, 0.07222853600978851, -0.036873959004879, -0.01603255607187748, -0.03827306628227234, 0.03014715388417244, -0.009710242971777916, 0.0005250740796327591, 0.051431383937597275, 0.04332641512155533, 0.04783710837364197, -0.00505110016092658, -0.035070016980171204, 0.04003743827342987, -0.05403459072113037, -0.04634103178977966, -0.02965010516345501, 0.010791662149131298, -0.01234518364071846, 0.005839439108967781, -0.07109082490205765, 0.015590599738061428, -0.0015632138820365071, 0.02508484572172165, -0.005813377909362316, -0.0661131739616394, 0.018191024661064148, -0.04766801744699478, 0.01810600608587265, 0.03945565223693848, -0.0008482097182422876, 0.0076619344763457775, -0.0360075980424881, 0.025152672082185745, -0.04037721827626228, 0.050158534198999405, 0.035145070403814316, -0.019718678668141365, 0.04463335499167442, 0.062183625996112823, 0.022001612931489944, 0.005156254395842552, -0.0455760657787323, -0.025599263608455658, -0.02214997261762619, -0.013486973941326141, -0.03309550881385803, -0.0009320029057562351, -0.046107202768325806, -0.00830011535435915, -0.01337295863777399, 0.0018705512629821897, -0.05426352843642235, 0.023751966655254364, -0.017826376482844353, 0.004743065685033798, -0.0465274378657341, -0.02325659990310669, -0.0590662807226181, 0.03438200801610947, -0.03308824077248573, -0.07285882532596588, 0.05531369149684906, -0.05808379501104355, 0.02130909450352192, -0.03267214074730873, -0.022512774914503098, -0.012048118747770786, -0.04620775580406189, -0.03889904543757439, -0.04771674424409866, 0.031536832451820374, -0.05699305981397629, 0.01035402063280344, -0.04628179594874382, 0.0044680191203951836, -0.06082373112440109, -0.018885960802435875, 0.0005745538510382175, 0.0357610285282135, 0.057768065482378006, 0.015702124685049057, -0.02769884653389454, -0.007038511335849762, -0.020971879363059998, 0.001112372730858624, -0.021014872938394547, -0.03982517123222351, -0.0318235382437706, 0.04153262451291084, -0.01459778007119894, -0.02106749825179577, 0.0071570961736142635, 0.014625404961407185, 0.06685756891965866, -0.03870640695095062, -0.03837287425994873, -0.032651353627443314, 0.04614787548780441, -0.02838406153023243, -0.04862268269062042, -0.015522890724241734, -0.02280271053314209, -0.024380549788475037, -0.024159317836165428, 0.04701317101716995, 0.02310466207563877, -0.04017242416739464, 0.012362825684249401, 0.039299216121435165, -0.010828779079020023, 0.008584477007389069, 0.024418743327260017, 0.027255281805992126, 0.01465812511742115, -0.006048738956451416, 0.003447177354246378, -0.08508215844631195, -0.040090955793857574, -0.04702700674533844, 0.005532267037779093, -0.04592006281018257, 0.008637489750981331, -0.0065826717764139175, 0.045782625675201416, -0.07372210919857025, -0.019442280754446983, 0.018335016444325447, 0.004578392952680588, 0.0122129637748003, 0.033291373401880264, -0.0008207614882849157, 0.014978958293795586, -0.02568836137652397, -0.004670978989452124, 0.004309381358325481, -0.03352063521742821, -0.014694438315927982, -0.011664321646094322, 0.00689864344894886, -0.030687497928738594, 0.06904737651348114, 0.021661095321178436, -0.019671494141221046, -0.038168612867593765, 0.008105813525617123, 0.047789834439754486, -0.00958747137337923, 0.045562777668237686, 0.07747212052345276, -0.03299497067928314, 0.018183350563049316, -0.013839099556207657, -0.027861757203936577, 0.017773160710930824, 0.0045569296926259995, -0.032301463186740875, 0.01075686514377594, 0.038428910076618195, 0.024563634768128395, -0.02877742052078247, 0.06039823964238167, 0.01050032302737236, 0.013584698550403118, -0.026972495019435883, 0.011510465294122696, -0.043835561722517014, -0.0006184025551192462, -0.0452672615647316, 0.0033270621206611395, 0.022020719945430756, 0.035089172422885895, 0.01753215305507183, 0.02641826681792736, 0.0070286160334944725, 0.02185208350419998, -0.05031164735555649, -0.048814963549375534, 0.0470920167863369, 0.0026234257966279984, -0.0357932411134243, 0.005349121522158384, 0.04703327268362045, 0.0002731552522163838, 0.04306281730532646, 0.044526826590299606, 0.03626277670264244, -0.03149830549955368, 0.01215070579200983, 0.043626006692647934, -0.06775843352079391, -0.016402924433350563, 0.01328529603779316, 0.01950237527489662, -0.03836853802204132, -0.004429779946804047, 0.044212229549884796, 0.003880900563672185, -0.01207293663173914, -0.014716845005750656, -0.007535467389971018, -0.05220260098576546, -0.009676630608737469, 0.06005079671740532, -0.016836734488606453, -0.038103021681308746, -0.0333104282617569, -0.02231205254793167, 0.0030562374740839005, -0.0679125264286995, 0.030914872884750366, 0.03233909606933594, 0.017427945509552956, -0.056614868342876434, 0.07629474997520447, -0.01880117692053318, -0.07275567948818207, 0.019996630027890205, 0.024383224546909332, -0.07192288339138031, -0.027360983192920685, 0.0021992370020598173, -0.01436313334852457, -0.0009725057170726359, 0.022347649559378624, 0.016415515914559364, 0.02259233221411705, 0.03138713538646698, 0.05824244022369385, 0.08685452491044998, -0.01482552383095026, -0.002019930863752961, 0.025850119069218636, -0.0846560001373291, -0.029753917828202248, -0.005504213273525238, 0.0015144945355132222, 0.01619541272521019, 0.03254663199186325, 0.06216788664460182, -0.037487588822841644, -0.02115914411842823, 0.039379529654979706, -0.06946150213479996, -0.01661679521203041, -0.00935377273708582, -0.003971408121287823, 0.05184245854616165, -0.030434558168053627, 0.003179430728778243, -0.005713054444640875, -0.016749050468206406, -0.006843362934887409, -0.05365986377000809, 0.0062411753460764885, -0.008304297924041748, -0.005973209626972675, 0.01597728207707405, -0.088556669652462, -0.024100301787257195, -0.01316575612872839, -0.06917749345302582, 0.020008737221360207, -0.06480122357606888, 0.029379982501268387, -0.04476343095302582, 0.03123265691101551, -0.019881101325154305, 0.06566068530082703, -0.04582131654024124, -0.04386768490076065, -0.0017067440785467625, -0.0005416265339590609, -0.017189104110002518, 0.005604909732937813, 0.030318662524223328, -0.022099152207374573, 0.04194308817386627, -0.04830890893936157, 0.02497035078704357, -0.03510762006044388, -0.0707685723900795, 0.012360267341136932, 0.005755998194217682, 0.008371956646442413, -0.06826314330101013, 0.046387750655412674, -0.06644129008054733, -0.015765590593218803, 0.003292142879217863, -0.06712990999221802, -0.06650353968143463, -0.02646380104124546, 0.00889290776103735, -0.026189493015408516, 0.047121308743953705, 0.02318669855594635, -0.00617970572784543, -0.03514821082353592, -0.011953967623412609, 0.014480569399893284, -0.007940535433590412, 0.023886093869805336, -0.022855514660477638, -0.045789290219545364, -0.007288833614438772, -0.016802774742245674, -0.039741043001413345, 0.010577986016869545, 0.012440855614840984, -0.05119958147406578, -0.015277476981282234, 0.07533885538578033, 0.03289780020713806, -0.041872791945934296, -0.06668377667665482, 0.026097821071743965, 0.0009192617726512253, -0.07871432602405548, -0.011733483523130417, 0.04000279679894447, -0.0005825591506436467, -0.05792630463838577, -0.03166937828063965, 0.009774664416909218, -0.04318220540881157, -0.03700084984302521, -0.09265028685331345, 0.022849030792713165, 0.000701726065017283, -0.016737978905439377, 0.025568798184394836, -0.012789251282811165, -0.015140882693231106, -0.03350219130516052, 0.04737366363406181, 0.005101545248180628, -0.006053077522665262, -0.0021505781915038824, 0.04129653796553612, -0.009792214259505272, -0.07099804282188416, -0.04014347121119499, 0.062385816127061844, 0.026052528992295265, -0.045206453651189804, 0.031242700293660164, 0.010707789100706577, 0.04357946291565895, -0.009335380978882313, 0.06260011345148087, 0.03148899972438812, 0.038054175674915314, -0.05886193364858627, -0.000051139362767571583, -0.020859429612755775, -0.01657094806432724, 0.01972070336341858, -0.046169839799404144, 0.04138133302330971, 0.03606846556067467, -0.037853047251701355, -0.004757879301905632, -0.0318022184073925, -0.03960498794913292, 0.02061575837433338, -0.05086224898695946, -0.05525955185294151, 0.02909586951136589, -0.0533510260283947, 0.043522052466869354, -0.002369444817304611, -0.008221459574997425, -0.036128778010606766, -0.0067703076638281345, 0.032286785542964935, -0.001204906147904694, -0.011098534800112247, -0.05826214328408241, 0.006526018958538771, 0.001155897043645382, 0.010363020934164524, -0.037953656166791916, 0.08343570679426193, 0.013749443925917149, -0.02049965411424637, -0.03128265589475632, -0.03280114009976387, -0.029864704236388206, -0.06139712408185005, -0.05611317977309227, -0.04169830307364464, 0.03397238254547119, -0.03361035883426666, 0.004638334736227989, -0.027241356670856476, 0.022785700857639313, 0.020918894559144974, 0.009902406483888626, 0.0005132781225256622, -0.0009993704734370112, -0.03545244783163071, 0.07462137192487717, 0.0022329792845994234, -0.004159376956522465, -0.02533937618136406, 0.029970310628414154, 0.02115679159760475, 0.0013772748643532395, -0.011099369265139103, -0.012441523373126984, 0.02085118740797043, -0.0308857224881649, -0.008161027915775776, -0.002781035378575325, 0.03209494426846504, -0.06972982734441757, -0.009585906751453876, -0.022134440019726753, -0.06149350106716156, -0.002558867447078228 ]
The intricacies of black hole ringdown analysis are amplified by the absence of a complete set of orthogonal basis functions for quasinormal modes. Although damped sinusoids effectively fit the ringdown signals from binary black hole mergers, the risk of overfitting remains, due to initial transients and nonlinear effects. In light of this challenge, we introduce two methods for extracting quasinormal modes in numerical simulations and qualitatively study how the transient might affect quasinormal mode fitting. In one method, we accurately fit quasinormal modes by using their spatial functional form at constant time hypersurfaces, while in the other method, we exploit both spatial and temporal aspects of the quasinormal modes. Both fitting methods leverage the spatial behavior of quasinormal eigenfunctions to enhance accuracy, outperforming conventional time-only fitting techniques at null infinity. We also show that we can construct an inner product for which the quasinormal eigenfunctions form an orthonormal (but not complete) set. We then conduct numerical experiments involving linearly perturbed Kerr black holes in horizon penetrating, hyperboloidally compactified coordinates, as this setup enables a more precise isolation and examination of the ringdown phenomenon. From solutions to the Teukolsky equation, describing scattering of an ingoing gravitational wave pulse, we find that the contributions from early-time transients can lead to large uncertainties in the fit to the amplitudes of higher overtones ($n\geq 3$). While the methods we discuss here cannot be applied directly to data from merger observations, our findings underscore the persistence of ambiguities in interpreting ringdown signals, even with access to both temporal and spatial information.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13204v3
[ -0.052262529730796814, -0.03291494771838188, 0.04397675767540932, 0.023402251303195953, 0.04267236217856407, -0.010095474310219288, 0.017314305528998375, 0.046936459839344025, 0.017460471019148827, 0.004545368254184723, -0.041550152003765106, -0.03706902265548706, -0.05052602291107178, -0.04329150542616844, -0.01642536371946335, 0.003882658900693059, 0.06626737862825394, -0.016249381005764008, -0.05084992200136185, 0.07502693682909012, 0.020809654146432877, -0.056181058287620544, -0.01783609203994274, 0.013606052845716476, -0.011118381284177303, -0.006651837378740311, -0.03469688072800636, -0.016006845980882645, -0.04240119457244873, -0.026743069291114807, 0.05674055591225624, -0.021455632522702217, 0.005562634207308292, -0.0328056737780571, -0.04220780357718468, -0.016997214406728745, -0.003669265192002058, 0.022608261555433273, 0.051450785249471664, -0.015553073957562447, 0.02450077421963215, -0.05462118983268738, -0.04324245825409889, 0.025829454883933067, -0.05439385771751404, -0.03673408553004265, -0.0006136748124845326, -0.03349459916353226, -0.03065580315887928, -0.05932708457112312, 0.04341994598507881, 0.017287109047174454, -0.0044750333763659, 0.03153211623430252, -0.039176054298877716, 0.00455594714730978, -0.007308193016797304, 0.010385354049503803, -0.0659375712275505, 0.014050059020519257, -0.022009408101439476, -0.03658776730298996, 0.013867590576410294, 0.013812859542667866, 0.02105223946273327, 0.0421312041580677, -0.02780170924961567, -0.05227534472942352, -0.04296881705522537, -0.05313750356435776, 0.03720495104789734, -0.06024627014994621, -0.013803905807435513, -0.009640596807003021, -0.0578249953687191, 0.026010973379015923, -0.046382829546928406, -0.014666873961687088, -0.016927728429436684, 0.0216111671179533, -0.04064593464136124, 0.042739566415548325, 0.008658629842102528, 0.028293287381529808, 0.02782590687274933, 0.01734590344130993, 0.041365765035152435, 0.02819846197962761, -0.009833910502493382, -0.058262113481760025, 0.0020774975419044495, -0.027063613757491112, -0.04867427423596382, -0.00020928839512635022, 0.049565400928258896, -0.02651076763868332, 0.05737380310893059, 0.06079477444291115, 0.023449957370758057, 0.02315308153629303, 0.0067801084369421005, -0.024242332205176353, -0.052118800580501556, 0.05957058072090149, -0.009687441401183605, -0.04054775461554527, -0.015150240622460842, -0.019334377720952034, -0.029490016400814056, -0.00672717671841383, -0.036941662430763245, -0.023428864777088165, 0.00952298566699028, -0.06098201498389244, -0.02848798595368862, -0.065561942756176, 0.07122448831796646, 0.023660017177462578, 0.0330355279147625, -0.004275128711014986, -0.010250064544379711, 0.01509766560047865, 0.005377269349992275, 0.015236386097967625, -0.024660632014274597, -0.02467896044254303, 0.069944366812706, 0.043580856174230576, -0.03045361116528511, -0.0018316253554075956, -0.015648091211915016, 0.015308734960854053, 0.022001903504133224, -0.00849552359431982, 0.05541874095797539, 0.0149846775457263, -0.01165139488875866, -0.018501881510019302, -0.011873114854097366, -0.006650705821812153, -0.046792831271886826, -0.05836481973528862, 0.023281266912817955, -0.003549128072336316, 0.014223461970686913, 0.046907633543014526, -0.07690376788377762, -0.021252969279885292, 0.037615519016981125, 0.05079096928238869, -0.00046847554040141404, -0.024003637954592705, 0.04001501947641373, 0.04544787108898163, 0.028433827683329582, -0.00632016034796834, 0.0525011382997036, 0.006055759731680155, -0.031193247064948082, -0.0029210136272013187, 0.020505741238594055, -0.033797942101955414, 0.06560332328081131, 0.037164315581321716, 0.040589116513729095, 0.03218948841094971, 0.04632459580898285, -0.016974743455648422, -0.03715256601572037, 0.002092149341478944, -0.05122285336256027, -0.008057092316448689, 0.012095640413463116, -0.028142858296632767, -0.03259614109992981, -0.037908025085926056, -0.009616428054869175, -0.0359136201441288, -0.036881376057863235, 0.020294977352023125, -0.017956556752324104, 0.016237840056419373, -0.01883181370794773, 0.022365877404808998, -0.03123999945819378, 0.0027050424832850695, -0.08981845527887344, 0.009723341092467308, 0.051395200192928314, 0.03607986122369766, -0.033683642745018005, -0.04154784604907036, 0.02277555875480175, 0.040645211935043335, -0.07744063436985016, -0.052096836268901825, 0.0033632651902735233, -0.02352612093091011, 0.002454554196447134, 0.03961741924285889, -0.08186263591051102, -0.03500441834330559, -0.0333956815302372, -0.0006286121206358075, -0.023856831714510918, -0.055717699229717255, 0.006519411224871874, 0.02523326873779297, -0.04125993326306343, 0.018791839480400085, 0.05701335147023201, 0.015939489006996155, 0.043906375765800476, 0.01081878412514925, 0.01827964559197426, -0.006194091401994228, -0.09702768921852112, 0.03589121997356415, 0.009761083871126175, -0.018436940386891365, 0.020958920940756798, -0.008995790034532547, -0.013522259891033173, -0.056706734001636505, -0.026419317349791527, 0.07063164561986923, 0.06667915731668472, -0.028219398111104965, -0.06376586109399796, -0.0559338703751564, -0.03698965907096863, -0.042426496744155884, -0.036943741142749786, -0.05197199434041977, -0.0164188239723444, -0.009733428247272968, -0.03757331147789955, 0.06369631737470627, 0.015276278369128704, -0.019700398668646812, -0.0771784856915474, 0.02806372009217739, 0.055458128452301025, -0.03955519199371338, -0.04672820121049881, -0.028971519321203232, -0.025197908282279968, 0.03808740898966789, -0.02926633320748806, 0.0025897459127008915, -0.004528257064521313, -0.05542173236608505, -0.016587523743510246, -0.0011824675602838397, 0.02444380149245262, 0.06421791017055511, -0.03647748380899429, 0.007028317078948021, 0.008090847171843052, 0.07006654143333435, 0.023607414215803146, 0.01714436151087284, -0.06676999479532242, -0.0024555649142712355, 0.05109194293618202, 0.026157397776842117, -0.05347288027405739, -0.018249589949846268, -0.005434622522443533, -0.051430843770504, 0.02819744125008583, -0.0037200197111815214, 0.06030368059873581, -0.002976774936541915, -0.003656474407762289, -0.019805749878287315, -0.007514553144574165, -0.01379750482738018, 0.04272385686635971, 0.04983844235539436, 0.04316328838467598, 0.02796703577041626, -0.0054135750979185104, -0.07432485371828079, 0.02008693665266037, -0.02980087511241436, -0.0006550602265633643, -0.04776136949658394, -0.060684315860271454, -0.049475688487291336, -0.0708615854382515, -0.020353980362415314, -0.044477351009845734, -0.027711650356650352, -0.017242977395653725, -0.03410414606332779, -0.03572332113981247, -0.0010553681058809161, 0.03139335662126541, -0.021187061443924904, -0.04084477201104164, -0.01965857669711113, 0.04166088253259659, 0.01927196979522705, 0.027912911027669907, -0.015461721457540989, -0.07377397269010544, -0.01780519261956215, 0.028456497937440872, 0.006831346545368433, -0.0011581310536712408, 0.0035858326591551304, -0.02887827716767788, 0.013031727634370327, 0.03253569081425667, 0.0495082288980484, -0.004878931678831577, -0.013337209820747375, -0.00018024721066467464, -0.03062162548303604, -0.004866435658186674, 0.0037577429320663214, 0.007960913702845573, 0.0025974400341510773, -0.056031420826911926, 0.03569206967949867, 0.06987827271223068, 0.04708690196275711, -0.04391811043024063, 0.002333669224753976, 0.005297769792377949, -0.02706844173371792, 0.01088664960116148, -0.06026957556605339, 0.04595101252198219, 0.0291970856487751, -0.04959310591220856, -0.027737801894545555, -0.02811046503484249, 0.015454561449587345, 0.006677029188722372, 0.027568109333515167, -0.017827391624450684, -0.026945166289806366, 0.02379331924021244, -0.08253354579210281, 0.04521210119128227, 0.038862377405166626, 0.05720474198460579, -0.023501841351389885, -0.004985983949154615, -0.013628000393509865, 0.03689926862716675, 0.001016161753796041, 0.016252879053354263, 0.014262895099818707, 0.02086644247174263, 0.0535820871591568, 0.02058194763958454, -0.05981360748410225, 0.004328479524701834, -0.0747806653380394, -0.06228793039917946, 0.024124659597873688, 0.04958375170826912, 0.027012662962079048, 0.027836773544549942, -0.05344738811254501, 0.01704438589513302, -0.04859812930226326, 0.03649430721998215, 0.01052823569625616, -0.04555265232920647, 0.03939599171280861, -0.03756967931985855, 0.014920668676495552, -0.0035564573481678963, 0.01066200714558363, 0.02671101689338684, -0.07703877240419388, -0.006582306697964668, -0.07317064702510834, 0.03320693597197533, -0.026381000876426697, -0.03241267427802086, 0.04953240603208542, 0.03944322094321251, -0.022653991356492043, 0.03360787779092789, 0.008939705789089203, 0.01982096955180168, 0.01885892078280449, -0.027649495750665665, 0.013744658790528774, -0.00043625381658785045, -0.04814870283007622, 0.00005844085171702318, -0.009913958609104156, -0.023754509165883064, 0.021408386528491974, -0.016081860288977623, -0.02359231933951378, -0.00501315388828516, -0.07102180272340775, -0.043190356343984604, -0.03977951779961586, 0.023342914879322052, -0.010799300856888294, -0.04409230872988701, 0.06090458109974861, -0.011992675252258778, 0.009787364862859249, -0.04363209381699562, -0.021213578060269356, -0.05341684818267822, -0.04110661894083023, -0.03842046856880188, -0.06791558861732483, 0.015846112743020058, -0.06328748911619186, 0.03439547121524811, -0.019267160445451736, 0.00017819505592342466, -0.04467647895216942, 0.019193733111023903, -0.01378975436091423, 0.06018996611237526, 0.017170308157801628, 0.004782482981681824, 0.03605429083108902, 0.004235361237078905, -0.019329698756337166, 0.0250945333391428, -0.05746055021882057, 0.012211461551487446, -0.053236257284879684, 0.04528028890490532, -0.04992416128516197, -0.02870069071650505, -0.043169453740119934, -0.006188537459820509, 0.061598680913448334, -0.0240772757679224, -0.033114366233348846, 0.014978950843214989, 0.0403701551258564, -0.0406152717769146, -0.04804261773824692, -0.037756405770778656, 0.001861114869825542, -0.06634354591369629, -0.010302073322236538, 0.03522830083966255, 0.034064315259456635, -0.010425309650599957, 0.03698411211371422, 0.007437190972268581, 0.016661087051033974, -0.029434645548462868, -0.007303797174245119, 0.012858426198363304, 0.039306752383708954, 0.01905563473701477, -0.05232491344213486, -0.07218136638402939, -0.0012280925875529647, -0.010708590038120747, 0.022901657968759537, -0.046182695776224136, 0.04158928245306015, -0.021020540967583656, 0.05772740766406059, -0.07883825898170471, -0.020341835916042328, 0.06895091384649277, -0.06101265177130699, -0.030076196417212486, 0.04406605288386345, -0.002947573782876134, 0.025567958131432533, -0.033999864012002945, 0.027402983978390694, 0.02011575736105442, -0.045484866946935654, -0.015671977773308754, 0.0251629501581192, -0.0270893145352602, -0.023881539702415466, 0.0241133701056242, 0.018450895324349403, -0.056750889867544174, 0.005337256472557783, 0.008049169555306435, 0.008657477796077728, -0.05039234459400177, 0.052393000572919846, 0.027349140495061874, -0.03411364555358887, -0.03346960246562958, 0.007142889313399792, 0.018032729625701904, 0.025371108204126358, 0.029972486197948456, -0.05382537096738815, -0.021561631932854652, 0.040280696004629135, 0.010444071143865585, 0.0022476038429886103, 0.06284607946872711, -0.0020716721192002296, -0.036199163645505905, -0.013704502023756504, -0.013446557335555553, -0.05149170756340027, -0.019769759848713875, -0.022658420726656914, 0.04843886196613312, 0.04347112029790878, 0.030018692836165428, 0.028864294290542603, -0.010197288356721401, -0.043782882392406464, -0.010757786221802235, -0.04747337847948074, -0.010798410512506962, 0.036953847855329514, -0.033316925168037415, 0.05665305256843567, 0.0029236022382974625, 0.05207311362028122, 0.002985627856105566, 0.0011282173218205571, -0.008703017607331276, -0.00030731072183698416, -0.03270789980888367, -0.01963683031499386, 0.035905495285987854, -0.002861058572307229, -0.033023327589035034, -0.01684308983385563, 0.03967561572790146, -0.037884652614593506, 0.011587101966142654, 0.07149770110845566, -0.010499685071408749, 0.020690564066171646, -0.027546048164367676, -0.020766766741871834, -0.05551532655954361, 0.009084505960345268, 0.07327120006084442, -0.0707630068063736, -0.0020349363330751657, -0.008966526947915554, -0.02888118475675583, 0.020679933950304985, -0.05461243912577629, 0.019085705280303955, 0.03736574947834015, 0.028048306703567505, -0.05413467809557915, 0.03156429901719093, 0.026789776980876923, -0.07290671020746231, -0.020104140043258667, 0.02786152809858322, -0.06613195687532425, -0.012012672610580921, -0.01573057658970356, -0.03170401230454445, -0.0217679962515831, 0.0025149155408143997, -0.010799365118145943, -0.0569843053817749, -0.04181260988116264, 0.04886222630739212, 0.06963566690683365, -0.03667755797505379, 0.02013733796775341, 0.05051141977310181, -0.0011162954615429044, 0.020869391039013863, -0.033618297427892685, 0.026029840111732483, -0.00012812219210900366, 0.034119825810194016, 0.03352869674563408, -0.051925454288721085, -0.019113196060061455, 0.06492402404546738, -0.05146961659193039, -0.000343667168635875, 0.028908684849739075, 0.04124828055500984, 0.0472533255815506, -0.00699694873765111, -0.0204938817769289, 0.027296844869852066, 0.020412323996424675, -0.025324393063783646, -0.03713831305503845, 0.016132334247231483, -0.01718997210264206, 0.031641729176044464, -0.01606977917253971, -0.041307661682367325, -0.01777740940451622, -0.0016179376980289817, -0.05044163763523102, 0.002325761830434203, -0.059395380318164825, 0.0003303014091216028, -0.012754806317389011, 0.0030841901898384094, 0.02553723193705082, 0.03557632863521576, -0.04691728577017784, 0.004999952856451273, -0.011973519809544086, 0.049467336386442184, -0.010165140964090824, 0.017501700669527054, 0.005734100937843323, -0.013745386153459549, 0.04310978576540947, -0.01680070348083973, 0.025199241936206818, -0.027489444240927696, -0.05036965385079384, 0.02857920154929161, -0.030473098158836365, -0.033667705953121185, -0.0422096773982048, 0.020802568644285202, -0.05551926791667938, -0.0033839945681393147, 0.027097685262560844, -0.04602330923080444, -0.08528385311365128, 0.009871264919638634, -0.006644252687692642, -0.01321311667561531, 0.009997183457016945, 0.026775192469358444, 0.029487960040569305, -0.03006031922996044, 0.03611625358462334, 0.05546128749847412, 0.006106493528932333, 0.029130006209015846, -0.0304531529545784, -0.05345296859741211, 0.025620531290769577, 0.00003583209036150947, -0.035802148282527924, -0.016140108928084373, -0.02664683386683464, -0.06884842365980148, 0.03191807121038437, 0.053502894937992096, -0.01213165931403637, 0.02975860983133316, -0.04531845450401306, 0.04544892534613609, 0.004281377419829369, -0.05743885040283203, -0.0727366954088211, -0.017810022458434105, -0.005903786979615688, 0.0018187075620517135, -0.042541440576314926, -0.03715454787015915, -0.059385497123003006, -0.00008988338231574744, -0.0859026238322258, 0.0007781580206938088, 0.010409600101411343, 0.056313540786504745, -0.024842651560902596, -0.04102080687880516, -0.01306217536330223, -0.033939260989427567, -0.018911417573690414, 0.024303236976265907, 0.0016467937966808677, 0.006778908893465996, 0.051208898425102234, 0.03721792623400688, -0.05800250917673111, -0.04851025715470314, 0.03826844319701195, -0.011516358703374863, 0.009160173125565052, 0.03793632611632347, 0.035514745861291885, -0.02842225879430771, 0.024026626721024513, 0.06925749033689499, 0.002067702589556575, 0.03305427357554436, -0.06319566071033478, -0.0017783388029783964, -0.041423194110393524, -0.07098449021577835, 0.020733436569571495, -0.0070473370142281055, 0.018379388377070427, -0.022153165191411972, -0.029102826490998268, -0.016877084970474243, -0.06325291842222214, -0.04245304688811302, 0.0188043974339962, -0.005645386874675751, -0.04356943815946579, 0.04947634041309357, -0.06205048784613609, 0.008367548696696758, -0.010281008668243885, 0.035681746900081635, -0.04167431220412254, 0.04487170651555061, 0.026785748079419136, -0.03150394186377525, 0.015469223260879517, -0.07556270807981491, 0.021326713263988495, -0.029713794589042664, -0.05560511723160744, -0.02733350358903408, 0.0638761818408966, -0.027913162484765053, -0.0011355569586157799, -0.03384164348244667, -0.010990787297487259, -0.02549818716943264, -0.05947792902588844, -0.03970567509531975, -0.007221978157758713, 0.029764559119939804, 0.01075971219688654, 0.030334459617733955, 0.014066710136830807, 0.06194121018052101, 0.03413242846727371, 0.009872821159660816, -0.007883789017796516, 0.0035307356156408787, -0.025742335245013237, 0.03712395951151848, -0.01801902800798416, -0.03108745999634266, -0.07169530540704727, 0.006933055352419615, 0.003707877593114972, 0.0007536293705925345, -0.010311263613402843, 0.007775832433253527, -0.03420059382915497, -0.05425216257572174, 0.00014721594925504178, 0.022698285058140755, -0.010686436668038368, -0.05053747817873955, 0.04520687088370323, -0.0023778406903147697, -0.05521352216601372, -0.06380830705165863 ]
Software frameworks for behaviour are critical in robotics as they enable the correct and efficient execution of functions. While modern behaviour systems have improved their composability, they do not focus on smooth transitions and often lack functionality. In this work, we present the Director, a novel behaviour framework that addresses these problems. It has functionality for soft transitions, multiple implementations of the same action chosen based on conditionals, and strict resource control. The system was successfully used in the 2022/2023 Virtual Season and RoboCup 2023 Bordeaux, in the Humanoid Kid Size League. It is implemented at https://github.com/NUbots/DirectorSoccer, which also contains over thirty automated tests and technical documentation on its implementation in NUClear.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09248v2
[ 0.0017080545658245683, -0.06339007616043091, 0.040174830704927444, 0.02504395693540573, -0.030780451372265816, -0.05052295699715614, 0.006538054905831814, -0.03760180622339249, 0.06686744093894958, -0.05975818634033203, -0.0022656514775007963, 0.025540918111801147, -0.04821140319108963, -0.03483874723315239, -0.040726497769355774, 0.018791863694787025, 0.06558584421873093, 0.01780635677278042, -0.04145582765340805, 0.07228761911392212, -0.044849053025245667, -0.08161486685276031, -0.056952524930238724, 0.014293141663074493, 0.013741333968937397, 0.02667897380888462, -0.004515346139669418, 0.022990038618445396, 0.022758137434720993, 0.03406970575451851, 0.0681113749742508, -0.02029137872159481, 0.01060524582862854, -0.04502150043845177, -0.039983149617910385, 0.005856286268681288, -0.04005914926528931, 0.03660343587398529, 0.06592632830142975, -0.011973387561738491, 0.03580047935247421, -0.04578198492527008, -0.07601958513259888, -0.018703749403357506, -0.020825650542974472, -0.03401315584778786, -0.03862113505601883, -0.0069126891903579235, -0.04142959788441658, -0.040954604744911194, -0.011494126170873642, -0.016010668128728867, 0.017665939405560493, 0.04171879217028618, -0.04497269168496132, 0.006376512348651886, -0.0206462312489748, -0.0037801761645823717, -0.01739572361111641, -0.0062502664513885975, -0.014286442659795284, 0.005647411569952965, 0.038630466908216476, -0.008528045378625393, 0.027705805376172066, 0.04117191582918167, -0.009182194247841835, -0.015801530331373215, -0.011734475381672382, -0.023598795756697655, 0.02067895047366619, -0.06333291530609131, 0.032480984926223755, 0.02696300484240055, -0.003025283105671406, -0.025148995220661163, -0.012945888563990593, -0.003308414714410901, 0.03692078962922096, 0.023475728929042816, 0.0331602618098259, -0.0036143832840025425, 0.0493633896112442, -0.012152571231126785, -0.0007724874885752797, -0.05633443593978882, -0.010236484929919243, -0.023263897746801376, 0.0217032041400671, -0.020352521911263466, 0.046149007976055145, 0.015034274198114872, -0.08504486829042435, 0.04022252932190895, 0.03611031547188759, -0.007046131882816553, 0.05324367806315422, 0.045880235731601715, 0.007421667221933603, -0.03721773996949196, -0.027186468243598938, 0.02362608164548874, -0.02985059842467308, 0.003560134908184409, 0.005316769704222679, -0.004230141174048185, 0.026790296658873558, 0.0028706821613013744, -0.0075563788414001465, -0.04532412067055702, 0.007989390753209591, 0.010418452322483063, 0.0005856094649061561, -0.09454799443483353, -0.028992580249905586, -0.01602085307240486, 0.002992922207340598, 0.01181100308895111, 0.026095572859048843, 0.03353428840637207, -0.02659524232149124, 0.0525444895029068, 0.035157784819602966, -0.02402789704501629, -0.044139258563518524, -0.06991544365882874, 0.0024255956523120403, -0.028945529833436012, -0.00916254986077547, 0.025036776438355446, -0.040070053189992905, 0.004992036148905754, -0.007224471773952246, -0.08716388046741486, 0.06249329447746277, 0.002848519943654537, 0.02721063792705536, -0.05334587022662163, 0.03859952837228775, -0.07407712936401367, -0.026484904810786247, -0.06110396981239319, 0.030989956110715866, 0.004694453906267881, 0.0650414377450943, 0.05260084196925163, 0.0195403303951025, -0.0037243745755404234, -0.02847333997488022, 0.05974430963397026, 0.0025557163171470165, 0.015276622958481312, 0.03316856175661087, 0.03167475014925003, -0.014765197411179543, -0.03937790170311928, 0.015625089406967163, -0.014666533097624779, -0.07625114917755127, -0.044575512409210205, -0.005578286480158567, -0.0410524420440197, -0.013262630440294743, -0.043318793177604675, -0.010111454874277115, 0.041980352252721786, 0.059582266956567764, -0.004932180978357792, -0.0015369437169283628, 0.012332437559962273, -0.014013919979333878, -0.04522617161273956, 0.005919360555708408, -0.009707699529826641, -0.0467948317527771, -0.01425821054726839, 0.00931535940617323, -0.047534115612506866, -0.06627970188856125, 0.037230461835861206, -0.026990564540028572, 0.029535258188843727, -0.02700127474963665, 0.008236921392381191, -0.04615314304828644, 0.00042498987750150263, -0.05278065800666809, -0.043797317892313004, 0.06275991350412369, 0.005893623922020197, -0.03603730350732803, -0.054393917322158813, -0.003704724134877324, 0.0277246180921793, -0.08427315950393677, -0.033612221479415894, 0.012473945505917072, -0.03287023305892944, 0.02134876511991024, -0.02788674645125866, -0.08693743497133255, 0.008487001061439514, -0.06509426981210709, 0.0015391571214422584, -0.00600586598739028, -0.036776892840862274, 0.041745517402887344, 0.06863633543252945, -0.03695496916770935, -0.03250548988580704, 0.017472729086875916, 0.002592186676338315, 0.057587649673223495, -0.012361599132418633, 0.04488701745867729, 0.003785107284784317, -0.1139557808637619, 0.0513559952378273, 0.03861955925822258, 0.059769466519355774, -0.008808286860585213, 0.01631050743162632, 0.0052831522189080715, -0.05290794372558594, -0.006011646706610918, 0.02772856317460537, 0.02172904647886753, -0.01033156830817461, -0.06685556471347809, -0.005102730356156826, -0.015212301164865494, -0.04848393797874451, 0.035191141068935394, -0.04316528141498566, -0.03896396607160568, -0.038678087294101715, -0.042735349386930466, 0.05186108127236366, 0.00589840579777956, -0.020262183621525764, -0.03585429489612579, -0.05859031528234482, 0.048985470086336136, -0.039335135370492935, -0.04326242581009865, -0.04644807055592537, -0.008372423239052296, -0.006012327503412962, -0.029692310839891434, 0.017191803082823753, -0.00992031954228878, -0.006019819527864456, -0.01185403298586607, -0.020344069227576256, 0.03083423525094986, 0.06736695021390915, -0.051254529505968094, 0.002982822712510824, -0.021499376744031906, 0.019701290875673294, 0.006008766125887632, -0.01679258607327938, -0.021455001085996628, 0.009920342825353146, 0.017404891550540924, 0.014766468666493893, 0.03670103847980499, -0.02658070996403694, 0.004404944833368063, -0.04769468680024147, -0.012591628357768059, -0.010815822519361973, 0.029447896406054497, -0.04339729622006416, 0.01573372073471546, -0.010506788268685341, 0.018552783876657486, -0.01976799964904785, 0.027925467118620872, 0.058402493596076965, 0.011045328341424465, -0.04629990831017494, 0.028051111847162247, -0.0656556487083435, -0.02133675292134285, 0.02198856882750988, -0.010249939747154713, -0.039240557700395584, -0.015268614515662193, -0.0448274202644825, -0.015016265213489532, -0.060297951102256775, -0.0028160247020423412, -0.040867287665605545, 0.03142021596431732, -0.013643762096762657, -0.030364425852894783, 0.022522810846567154, 0.035845931619405746, 0.010352658107876778, -0.027316110208630562, -0.04800903797149658, 0.012064932845532894, 0.0322071835398674, 0.02280369959771633, -0.06198689714074135, -0.015946535393595695, -0.0200338214635849, -0.042086854577064514, 0.000935925345402211, 0.003600877244025469, 0.00697379931807518, -0.013614872470498085, 0.009743903763592243, 0.0167548730969429, -0.02604345977306366, 0.023816324770450592, 0.08408622443675995, -0.028883539140224457, 0.005685161799192429, -0.022989707067608833, 0.024760596454143524, 0.023133039474487305, -0.014960534870624542, -0.02821948379278183, -0.023252949118614197, 0.026773782446980476, -0.04149927943944931, -0.037960030138492584, -0.02172274701297283, 0.05242013931274414, 0.060986071825027466, -0.002676517702639103, -0.05309561640024185, 0.03330637514591217, 0.03885916247963905, 0.013745388016104698, -0.009128516539931297, 0.027230458334088326, 0.006521434523165226, 0.024199489504098892, 0.001960820285603404, -0.02390773594379425, -0.02960994653403759, 0.08080676943063736, -0.08804034441709518, -0.02814333140850067, 0.041641321033239365, 0.042638443410396576, -0.049532387405633926, 0.028835326433181763, -0.02089226245880127, -0.016637828201055527, 0.048065897077322006, 0.008970280177891254, 0.008559474721550941, 0.04113476350903511, 0.04210468754172325, -0.009648139588534832, -0.05063040554523468, 0.020288918167352676, -0.05961534008383751, -0.031240900978446007, -0.009637118317186832, 0.03297784924507141, 0.024659933522343636, -0.004713806323707104, -0.08971214294433594, -0.05445631965994835, -0.003279289463534951, 0.022813884541392326, 0.019524499773979187, -0.039687976241111755, 0.01738317310810089, -0.03781731054186821, 0.003195348661392927, -0.04193076863884926, 0.023778215050697327, 0.0022258576937019825, -0.03467493876814842, 0.007086839992552996, -0.06681966781616211, 0.03705264627933502, -0.04326155036687851, -0.010782130993902683, 0.02337292768061161, 0.0011723830830305815, 0.020761417225003242, 0.055861447006464005, -0.058656997978687286, 0.000797887914814055, 0.04490291327238083, -0.02900567092001438, -0.00878562219440937, -0.04387957230210304, -0.03954099118709564, -0.03274320065975189, 0.005307913292199373, -0.01915515586733818, -0.03588933125138283, 0.007803686894476414, -0.012012391351163387, -0.021468056365847588, -0.08157344162464142, 0.017318695783615112, -0.05130162462592125, 0.0351557731628418, 0.007466432172805071, -0.008273298852145672, 0.07005839049816132, -0.02036866918206215, -0.014073583297431469, 0.0039796410128474236, -0.01656397432088852, 0.005308065563440323, -0.0492204912006855, -0.007595440372824669, -0.0893426388502121, 0.026813527569174767, 0.017346708104014397, 0.047533102333545685, -0.031659189611673355, 0.054618533700704575, -0.010041922330856323, -0.018741922453045845, 0.007271796930581331, 0.0506734624505043, 0.06819043308496475, 0.020108556374907494, 0.04875830560922623, -0.05638657510280609, 0.041276734322309494, 0.0205543115735054, -0.00587435532361269, -0.004569722339510918, -0.01430094800889492, 0.03977087885141373, -0.012915202416479588, -0.0014436827041208744, -0.02437632530927658, 0.03631525859236717, 0.03198911249637604, 0.04462622106075287, -0.05645551532506943, -0.028908981010317802, 0.05395623669028282, -0.004308854695409536, -0.029894230887293816, -0.04906804487109184, -0.039464566856622696, -0.026892587542533875, -0.0453665517270565, 0.004035503603518009, 0.03834694251418114, -0.027119942009449005, 0.0136212557554245, 0.03128799423575401, 0.01593650132417679, -0.02446550875902176, 0.0015651991125196218, 0.040376510471105576, -0.00915931910276413, 0.008269654586911201, -0.0032477660570293665, -0.05187391862273216, 0.04504784941673279, -0.051826681941747665, 0.023559555411338806, -0.04296547919511795, 0.04251151904463768, 0.009045928716659546, 0.002303138142451644, -0.09500777721405029, 0.02200969308614731, 0.05345916002988815, 0.012307152152061462, 0.001848105457611382, 0.016841908916831017, -0.028469519689679146, -0.026236115023493767, -0.05366148427128792, 0.010488413274288177, 0.08515651524066925, 0.03848027437925339, -0.040561698377132416, -0.004685861524194479, -0.012980282306671143, -0.020387684926390648, 0.03638903796672821, -0.0016376464627683163, -0.022993242368102074, -0.01927889697253704, 0.011621924117207527, 0.032914403825998306, -0.01834922470152378, 0.05821431800723076, 0.01769944280385971, 0.00401131110265851, 0.04370291158556938, -0.009003806859254837, 0.027638962492346764, -0.0387340672314167, 0.012109932489693165, 0.01850738190114498, -0.014563629403710365, 0.01784973032772541, -0.031233061105012894, -0.0002039795508608222, 0.048475589603185654, 0.0114206587895751, 0.023855479434132576, -0.016157714650034904, -0.06212342903017998, -0.038075510412454605, -0.005750227253884077, 0.02448372356593609, 0.00617612199857831, 0.05552627518773079, 0.027837255969643593, -0.009641868062317371, -0.019868049770593643, 0.006046775262802839, -0.012193433940410614, 0.005552053451538086, -0.0236072801053524, 0.02509257383644581, 0.0046943239867687225, 0.022095054388046265, -0.015551417134702206, 0.0015622884966433048, 0.0029864946845918894, 0.031980548053979874, -0.021655209362506866, -0.02001071721315384, -0.030954228714108467, -0.04000893235206604, 0.008932852186262608, -0.07475581020116806, -0.003783510299399495, 0.041549112647771835, 0.008302176371216774, -0.02859438955783844, -0.0442638136446476, 0.057047367095947266, -0.010891901329159737, 0.03374594822525978, 0.044663023203611374, 0.020325256511569023, -0.023356538265943527, 0.015164686366915703, 0.06446201354265213, -0.012932928279042244, -0.04207082837820053, -0.05496305972337723, -0.0037910903338342905, -0.014577740803360939, -0.04831146076321602, 0.03591205179691315, -0.029078667983412743, -0.030912676826119423, -0.029583020135760307, 0.023641332983970642, -0.03581952676177025, -0.04591164365410805, -0.011243912391364574, 0.02871113270521164, -0.05809294059872627, -0.019564619287848473, -0.0047302888706326485, -0.03038150630891323, -0.03963610529899597, 0.08171949535608292, 0.06110402196645737, -0.000423998135374859, -0.014294284395873547, 0.040708694607019424, 0.07074540108442307, 0.02092701569199562, 0.006289719603955746, -0.023597249761223793, -0.05481310188770294, 0.024747230112552643, -0.02281547337770462, -0.02407243847846985, 0.038420431315898895, -0.03432167321443558, 0.03695408254861832, -0.04158458486199379, -0.02588612027466297, 0.07792577147483826, 0.010216383263468742, -0.016886312514543533, 0.01984550803899765, -0.02484983764588833, 0.007910545915365219, 0.027319548651576042, -0.03291274607181549, 0.021464718505740166, 0.02440084144473076, -0.0508553571999073, -0.029963409528136253, -0.015979241579771042, -0.005632602144032717, -0.020187709480524063, -0.019453726708889008, -0.080616295337677, -0.012112928554415703, -0.02335275523364544, -0.0889820009469986, 0.00849007535725832, -0.001127492287196219, 0.001973799429833889, 0.009876912459731102, -0.0576520636677742, 0.034429389983415604, 0.01243978925049305, -0.01035263855010271, -0.04170924797654152, 0.0352742038667202, -0.04457102715969086, 0.026632582768797874, -0.0008909518946893513, -0.0046013048849999905, 0.030514685437083244, 0.035875752568244934, 0.005938713438808918, -0.04214642569422722, -0.04183785989880562, -0.07205645740032196, 0.014187927357852459, 0.04013843461871147, -0.02742314711213112, 0.009471835568547249, -0.06134214997291565, 0.04988577216863632, -0.03028055466711521, 0.005869805347174406, -0.06466446816921234, -0.026700997725129128, 0.023637665435671806, 0.03583063557744026, 0.03405734896659851, -0.03418775647878647, 0.03134411945939064, 0.00856372993439436, -0.028065351769328117, 0.060788702219724655, 0.014107909984886646, -0.005784135777503252, 0.004627651069313288, -0.04486048221588135, -0.053929559886455536, -0.006051080301403999, 0.01599947363138199, -0.039989765733480453, -0.06289707869291306, 0.03866260498762131, -0.04036325961351395, 0.026571299880743027, 0.03770394250750542, -0.01921781152486801, -0.0301473718136549, -0.09024884551763535, 0.050725307315588, -0.009709559381008148, -0.03895088657736778, -0.0018001837888732553, -0.011788712814450264, 0.02183283120393753, -0.060514289885759354, 0.03422800824046135, 0.0293368361890316, -0.03152353689074516, 0.036248862743377686, -0.08003199100494385, 0.026345159858465195, 0.023692794144153595, 0.020819049328565598, 0.009218516759574413, -0.009851790964603424, -0.0392565056681633, -0.029717450961470604, -0.01855296827852726, 0.006321956403553486, 0.015167396515607834, -0.009052340872585773, 0.05000855028629303, 0.0326787531375885, -0.07546185702085495, -0.0321769081056118, 0.05170745030045509, -0.004249013960361481, 0.01887175254523754, -0.0007858859025873244, 0.04147850722074509, 0.07149761915206909, -0.0069237262941896915, -0.013750806450843811, -0.059577200561761856, 0.03247295692563057, -0.04954091086983681, 0.03515717387199402, -0.035340603440999985, -0.052439164370298386, -0.0018433798104524612, 0.008679049089550972, 0.022966258227825165, 0.021070022135972977, 0.03902093693614006, 0.060144294053316116, -0.032862454652786255, -0.033629707992076874, 0.07006710022687912, -0.05368751287460327, -0.029717333614826202, 0.045157093554735184, -0.0229628998786211, 0.018404489383101463, -0.04783225059509277, -0.010083651170134544, -0.02036183886229992, 0.06855590641498566, 0.015356524847447872, -0.01254021842032671, 0.03214099258184433, -0.05352718383073807, -0.006796597503125668, 0.03474211320281029, -0.01015701238065958, -0.045435816049575806, 0.08404286205768585, 0.003806655528023839, -0.03358443081378937, 0.009452387690544128, -0.033697884529829025, -0.0424012690782547, -0.05333034694194794, -0.029202494770288467, -0.026189561933279037, 0.03383638709783554, -0.02702793851494789, -0.014421015977859497, 0.0474390834569931, 0.0005977937835268676, -0.005004233680665493, 0.08327063173055649, 0.013714782893657684, 0.030479606240987778, -0.05464116483926773, 0.06315021961927414, 0.014949209056794643, -0.024587856605648994, -0.03246508166193962, 0.026133127510547638, -0.0096910884603858, -0.022087203338742256, -0.0033843654673546553, -0.04767404869198799, 0.027529293671250343, 0.03927076235413551, -0.044274378567934036, 0.02098904550075531, 0.029574565589427948, -0.06677588075399399, 0.023142103105783463, -0.03903393819928169, -0.052924226969480515, -0.039344631135463715 ]
Radiofrequency capacitively coupled plasma is studied theoretically using a Particle-in-Cell code. For He discharge, the time-averaged sheaths are in the range of few centimeters. The sheath potential, ion, and electron energy and angular distributions, discharge current, and dissipated power depend on the driven potentials and frequencies. Increasing the amplitude of the high radio frequencies increases the bulk density and the sheath potential and, consequently, increases the plasma processing rate. Increasing the intermediate radio frequency amplitude allows a wider sheath with a broad ion energy distribution and a narrower ion angular distribution. Changing the amplitude and the phase shift between driven frequencies provide different energies and angular distribution allowing performing various processes. The interplay between the sheath and bulk dynamics in the intermediate radiofrequency regime and the high-frequency regime may excite harmonics in the discharge current.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16368v1
[ -0.05639055743813515, -0.00661071203649044, -0.022244689986109734, 0.014141182415187359, -0.032604724168777466, -0.03192552179098129, -0.05084796994924545, 0.0011915020877495408, -0.021675365045666695, 0.016975557431578636, -0.006435977295041084, -0.060931507498025894, -0.049364641308784485, -0.06623011827468872, -0.01876174658536911, -0.008994626812636852, 0.06000036746263504, 0.07253079116344452, -0.06860534101724625, 0.07141856849193573, 0.004210904706269503, 0.006967159919440746, 0.012264084070920944, 0.033023178577423096, 0.03127386420965195, -0.03146999701857567, -0.03828124701976776, 0.026817867532372475, -0.02039237692952156, 0.0033821293618530035, 0.02519385889172554, -0.03889138251543045, -0.014036913402378559, -0.009756224229931831, -0.031831514090299606, 0.009472324512898922, -0.04492659121751785, 0.028655733913183212, 0.05598671734333038, -0.028058188036084175, -0.009698367677628994, -0.06103460118174553, -0.05357746779918671, 0.003390594618394971, -0.03060164302587509, -0.042390838265419006, -0.057588350027799606, 0.02968760021030903, -0.05036385729908943, -0.05478359013795853, -0.03647145256400108, 0.021093396469950676, 0.010995512828230858, 0.07286689430475235, -0.05164287984371185, 0.013810042291879654, 0.01143417228013277, -0.02647877298295498, -0.05261373892426491, -0.03784887492656708, -0.006940467283129692, 0.015576439909636974, 0.03350402042269707, 0.008258672431111336, -0.04903250187635422, 0.01872578263282776, -0.01196140144020319, -0.054026324301958084, -0.013097657822072506, -0.051134705543518066, 0.034669894725084305, -0.06979186832904816, 0.01721697486937046, 0.03859290853142738, -0.0666964128613472, 0.0008223060867749155, 0.04382762685418129, -0.023017996922135353, 0.014855198562145233, -0.0035117552615702152, -0.022799117490649223, 0.0249167587608099, -0.03613267093896866, 0.037705451250076294, -0.004634285811334848, 0.033471737056970596, 0.04671146720647812, -0.059375863522291183, -0.03843458741903305, -0.06397988647222519, 0.03930683061480522, 0.025880059227347374, -0.03336017206311226, 0.01656215451657772, 0.052634481340646744, -0.0012860684655606747, 0.07095411419868469, 0.014164851978421211, -0.002502797869965434, -0.06423117965459824, 0.029916219413280487, -0.05066662281751633, 0.014542614109814167, 0.02200224995613098, 0.008717148564755917, -0.04127999767661095, -0.011913614347577095, -0.043575964868068695, -0.022736892104148865, 0.04170091822743416, -0.005715075880289078, 0.014925675466656685, -0.0075887893326580524, -0.011813943274319172, -0.06129522621631622, -0.020905468612909317, 0.04957062005996704, 0.017755629494786263, -0.03592965379357338, -0.011759710498154163, -0.05114324763417244, 0.03288847580552101, -0.05459032952785492, 0.04067147523164749, -0.051653143018484116, 0.05005601793527603, 0.07924739271402359, 0.0002716951130423695, -0.04174553602933884, -0.054323285818099976, -0.034440699964761734, -0.010316411033272743, 0.031202875077724457, -0.03734278306365013, 0.005389468278735876, -0.005374372471123934, -0.015939772129058838, 0.0050674378871917725, 0.01096591167151928, 0.015004935674369335, -0.009781604632735252, -0.04146596044301987, 0.008852140046656132, 0.00451999343931675, 0.0349416546523571, -0.0032011703588068485, -0.07342755049467087, -0.018551496788859367, 0.06463395804166794, 0.001841211342252791, 0.014086992479860783, 0.004815281368792057, -0.02297419309616089, -0.06737977266311646, -0.00044074811739847064, 0.026850761845707893, 0.05822377651929855, 0.008909662254154682, 0.015379621647298336, -0.009066079743206501, 0.01874079927802086, -0.04639603942632675, -0.04228430613875389, 0.02483244240283966, -0.02051319181919098, -0.04095284640789032, 0.06314513832330704, -0.0009288989240303636, -0.01882057823240757, 0.025286374613642693, -0.06281314790248871, 0.043395742774009705, 0.050623830407857895, -0.05708761140704155, -0.05008573830127716, -0.0315144844353199, -0.024849029257893562, 0.019733566790819168, 0.011078199371695518, -0.0025658037047833204, 0.03603930398821831, -0.031405024230480194, -0.04840230941772461, -0.007223382592201233, -0.06465984880924225, -0.029289832338690758, -0.07661353796720505, 0.05249692127108574, 0.04981845244765282, -0.03391852229833603, -0.026942815631628036, -0.01850457862019539, 0.028381681069731712, -0.005373101215809584, 0.002053403528407216, -0.00013415819557849318, -0.004551265854388475, -0.05320592597126961, 0.002178108785301447, 0.030295617878437042, -0.04600506275892258, -0.03950251638889313, -0.04227854311466217, 0.006472346372902393, 0.03821685537695885, -0.06112159043550491, 0.007299086079001427, -0.0006171406712383032, -0.04826106131076813, 0.0003016793925780803, 0.03353829309344292, 0.050591062754392624, 0.015114396810531616, -0.015165984630584717, -0.009812355041503906, -0.004098750185221434, -0.08658948540687561, 0.014828097075223923, -0.006029526703059673, -0.005354125052690506, 0.03374694660305977, 0.028534958139061928, 0.009961334057152271, -0.000527426425833255, 0.004737642128020525, 0.008603890426456928, 0.020704466849565506, -0.04793768748641014, -0.06012291833758354, 0.01237547304481268, -0.053727827966213226, -0.05726459622383118, -0.050583358854055405, -0.053230829536914825, -0.02824280597269535, -0.002010681899264455, -0.016918065026402473, -0.013873666524887085, -0.008311426267027855, -0.02690955437719822, -0.047486502677202225, -0.040583156049251556, 0.04525698721408844, 0.024939345195889473, -0.05011143162846565, -0.058561280369758606, -0.0607047937810421, 0.03381284698843956, -0.03100019134581089, -0.01116106379777193, -0.0023880216758698225, -0.02302047237753868, -0.014499446377158165, 0.015422618947923183, 0.002828710712492466, 0.025635158643126488, -0.05611453577876091, 0.0014735521981492639, -0.001953744562342763, 0.010269749909639359, -0.02235059067606926, 0.02894430235028267, -0.057802628725767136, 0.05156806856393814, -0.026262300089001656, 0.012812234461307526, -0.05314697325229645, 0.015502474270761013, 0.03603624552488327, -0.015529516153037548, -0.017617447301745415, 0.054887399077415466, 0.036418698728084564, 0.0014969374751672149, 0.02268246002495289, -0.013528547249734402, -0.0401865690946579, 0.01784922182559967, -0.0006551746046170592, -0.004094354342669249, 0.05223134905099869, 0.032025404274463654, 0.04367342218756676, -0.040612004697322845, -0.010345358401536942, -0.02384701929986477, 0.006640564184635878, -0.049048714339733124, -0.03971654921770096, -0.02322513982653618, -0.05611281841993332, -0.021474206820130348, -0.00623363209888339, 0.008367265574634075, -0.016290852800011635, -0.013873367570340633, 0.034003764390945435, -0.045833561569452286, 0.03248567879199982, -0.06717099249362946, -0.07113155722618103, 0.003597353817895055, 0.042949844151735306, 0.000278299005003646, -0.06837927550077438, -0.03737939894199371, 0.001849013497121632, 0.01583295501768589, -0.009237078949809074, -0.023913776502013206, -0.051070887595415115, -0.04212971031665802, -0.07985615730285645, -0.03914393484592438, -0.03263099491596222, 0.015100383199751377, 0.04895199462771416, -0.052995484322309494, -0.04912898316979408, -0.008967193774878979, -0.01239332091063261, -0.031021276488900185, 0.04634781926870346, 0.0227897297590971, -0.012671670876443386, -0.058566417545080185, 0.0229587871581316, 0.04646074399352074, 0.014784789644181728, -0.05048488453030586, -0.04054894670844078, 0.016953274607658386, 0.021936733275651932, 0.03413594514131546, 0.05041557922959328, 0.05076873302459717, -0.052766088396310806, -0.009656454436480999, -0.06500785797834396, 0.054347120225429535, -0.03086724877357483, 0.037285216152668, 0.04430143162608147, 0.02521989308297634, 0.017286334186792374, -0.03767111897468567, 0.027700716629624367, 0.022711964324116707, 0.04898092895746231, -0.0460132472217083, -0.02183830924332142, 0.03094414249062538, -0.02534668520092964, 0.024912727996706963, -0.010812749154865742, 0.040363334119319916, 0.037524450570344925, 0.030992891639471054, -0.05020995810627937, -0.008418688550591469, -0.04293248429894447, -0.07540585845708847, -0.04769790172576904, -0.039229486137628555, -0.015057866461575031, -0.0035968716256320477, 0.026579592376947403, 0.009006522595882416, -0.001856692018918693, -0.03797067329287529, 0.04799884930253029, 0.01664123870432377, -0.027873879298567772, 0.031059827655553818, -0.011449024081230164, 0.022691870108246803, -0.016820883378386497, -0.014879855327308178, -0.03751048445701599, -0.01845998503267765, 0.06690581142902374, -0.022234199568629265, 0.00211352133192122, 0.00956941582262516, -0.008715282194316387, 0.003944299649447203, 0.014171660877764225, 0.002472557360306382, 0.029459184035658836, 0.014470992609858513, -0.027797002345323563, -0.06293400377035141, -0.03136860206723213, -0.03329573944211006, 0.01212848536670208, -0.03957165777683258, -0.015522213652729988, -0.0018633127911016345, -0.030320899561047554, 0.03362515941262245, 0.004885070491582155, -0.003434505546465516, -0.03865465149283409, -0.07272523641586304, -0.012209692038595676, -0.04322264343500137, 0.053287215530872345, 0.02458738535642624, -0.021068934351205826, 0.052366770803928375, 0.010247561149299145, -0.008446847088634968, -0.030529264360666275, 0.007212988566607237, -0.004990747198462486, -0.034537285566329956, 0.04094759747385979, -0.017444634810090065, 0.05101969465613365, -0.033758971840143204, 0.03507894650101662, 0.01880796067416668, 0.0255638025701046, -0.06573153287172318, 0.028285901993513107, -0.04770635813474655, -0.012685798108577728, 0.056764066219329834, 0.029151590541005135, -0.01703495904803276, -0.03349912539124489, -0.038116972893476486, 0.05765672028064728, 0.030999580398201942, 0.03811919316649437, -0.03229247406125069, 0.033204395323991776, -0.05159619823098183, -0.05317044258117676, -0.014318367466330528, -0.008257299661636353, 0.018273212015628815, -0.069951131939888, -0.05130697041749954, 0.0018883775919675827, 0.027944551780819893, -0.03711032122373581, -0.022995032370090485, -0.06429722905158997, -0.030573062598705292, -0.07407339662313461, -0.04595264419913292, 0.017696281895041466, -0.04013795778155327, 0.02115660533308983, 0.04763486608862877, 0.05325345695018768, 0.025664372369647026, -0.034164320677518845, 0.05936839431524277, 0.010900145396590233, 0.003718035761266947, -0.031992107629776, -0.0428207665681839, -0.03507833182811737, 0.032143786549568176, 0.03671347722411156, -0.034770186990499496, -0.007623953279107809, -0.02686733938753605, -0.020919721573591232, -0.013551480136811733, -0.07576031982898712, 0.04698409140110016, 0.017004046589136124, -0.03428515046834946, 0.05379864200949669, -0.013438187539577484, -0.014399394392967224, 0.04868997260928154, -0.020915580913424492, 0.007678271736949682, -0.02980799600481987, -0.02227841317653656, 0.002827366814017296, 0.0016409038798883557, -0.0532899834215641, 0.04661101475358009, 0.00022036413429304957, -0.03578244894742966, -0.042219776660203934, 0.0325375534594059, 0.03489213064312935, -0.025655174627900124, -0.011898091994225979, 0.023871036246418953, 0.05920273810625076, -0.025598783046007156, -0.06844352185726166, 0.0004880026972386986, -0.01593291200697422, -0.022239508107304573, 0.055675189942121506, -0.020576270297169685, -0.0016627745935693383, -0.03236710652709007, 0.026047272607684135, 0.018679192289710045, 0.044289976358413696, 0.031028643250465393, -0.008358286693692207, -0.004628110211342573, -0.0231857281178236, -0.047794874757528305, -0.023924285545945168, -0.05365518480539322, -0.02675853855907917, -0.061693549156188965, -0.015845755115151405, 0.06544546037912369, 0.034858595579862595, 0.027423856779932976, -0.07516422867774963, -0.012384566478431225, 0.0008102795109152794, 0.038157932460308075, -0.03709251433610916, -0.03724858537316322, -0.009593668393790722, 0.05221271887421608, 0.020361565053462982, 0.0022035185247659683, 0.006617134902626276, -0.02740684524178505, -0.040582820773124695, -0.01366895716637373, 0.03111676685512066, 0.019568346440792084, -0.05782666429877281, -0.018587276339530945, 0.055278584361076355, -0.030201561748981476, 0.07417154312133789, 0.007254605647176504, -0.007510259747505188, 0.04403405264019966, -0.032882243394851685, -0.023066457360982895, -0.010096713900566101, 0.04444735124707222, 0.05431552976369858, -0.06361711025238037, -0.006323994603008032, -0.022857455536723137, 0.0015124810161069036, -0.01653251238167286, -0.021116020157933235, -0.05383013188838959, -0.00820072740316391, -0.01216369029134512, -0.05015993490815163, 0.059105753898620605, 0.03509143367409706, -0.06738368421792984, 0.020016415044665337, 0.02707299403846264, -0.05026701092720032, -0.03949965909123421, 0.04263532906770706, -0.02741003967821598, -0.05230258032679558, 0.016640430316329002, -0.043836936354637146, -0.030879054218530655, -0.05367763340473175, 0.04197453707456589, 0.008144071325659752, -0.04581207409501076, -0.04887039214372635, -0.025730421766638756, 0.010197934694588184, -0.03889872133731842, -0.007955266162753105, -0.05222548171877861, -0.021928152069449425, 0.015094977803528309, 0.0025831288658082485, -0.03689396381378174, -0.020012546330690384, 0.029875274747610092, -0.036138202995061874, -0.00597326410934329, -0.02699233405292034, -0.014729434624314308, 0.040491994470357895, -0.05683666095137596, -0.05004080757498741, 0.030178027227520943, -0.07117146998643875, 0.017166830599308014, 0.0037543068174272776, 0.017423871904611588, 0.01728762499988079, 0.06818799674510956, 0.03563258424401283, -0.05424971878528595, 0.017053423449397087, -0.019303131848573685, -0.0316496342420578, 0.020454252138733864, -0.045437779277563095, -0.0054528494365513325, 0.04886610060930252, 0.03656042739748955, -0.026022473350167274, 0.044168826192617416, -0.031202193349599838, -0.006958169862627983, -0.02341519668698311, 0.03132719546556473, 0.04675287753343582, -0.023862691596150398, 0.0034672501496970654, -0.06288240849971771, 0.026298025622963905, -0.05934260040521622, -0.03023238480091095, 0.017512256279587746, -0.028742773458361626, 0.03329993784427643, 0.03197145089507103, -0.01873381808400154, -0.03327011689543724, -0.005446580238640308, -0.05619250237941742, -0.015986183658242226, 0.024290544912219048, -0.03775884211063385, -0.013302677311003208, 0.010411370545625687, -0.02565058507025242, -0.01842302642762661, 0.03831111639738083, -0.007749893236905336, 0.025109639391303062, -0.012554451823234558, 0.0424758717417717, 0.05670783668756485, 0.02323283441364765, -0.012034635990858078, -0.051795441657304764, -0.018969494849443436, 0.04947063326835632, -0.02014492079615593, -0.05435536056756973, -0.05202300846576691, -0.04203471541404724, -0.07091722637414932, -0.050735753029584885, -0.010992128401994705, -0.047342948615550995, -0.02593308687210083, -0.015438050031661987, 0.05336751416325569, 0.040890879929065704, -0.01914430595934391, -0.07642779499292374, 0.02281908690929413, 0.005737049505114555, -0.03681078925728798, 0.02786867506802082, -0.031033897772431374, -0.054570309817790985, -0.004959775134921074, -0.07599195092916489, 0.001266599865630269, -0.062107574194669724, 0.050905801355838776, -0.014541945420205593, 0.014156456105411053, -0.028559153899550438, -0.029587317258119583, 0.030063195154070854, -0.02588786743581295, 0.007101390510797501, 0.014297468587756157, 0.024683421477675438, -0.005551829002797604, -0.04648086428642273, -0.000531636003870517, 0.05057285726070404, -0.018201423808932304, -0.01695534773170948, 0.006888972595334053, 0.034319911152124405, -0.029522277414798737, 0.006581832189112902, 0.025964953005313873, -0.0010001062182709575, 0.016997480764985085, -0.007561823818832636, -0.014071518555283546, -0.03256186842918396, -0.0366600900888443, 0.0590410940349102, -0.03501850366592407, -0.0019576905760914087, -0.0005084802396595478, -0.03846707195043564, 0.008212566375732422, 0.014973219484090805, -0.03060532920062542, 0.03291027992963791, 0.012217308394610882, -0.02527337707579136, 0.07442494481801987, -0.031092064455151558, 0.02914639748632908, 0.040906358510255814, 0.029705747961997986, -0.06972110271453857, 0.050936561077833176, 0.026867175474762917, -0.05516476184129715, 0.025889523327350616, -0.0019229939207434654, 0.0395522303879261, -0.025329826399683952, -0.02356182225048542, -0.0031638683285564184, 0.021428324282169342, -0.0473189502954483, -0.0412934385240078, -0.0019162265816703439, -0.0669710785150528, 0.011195354163646698, -0.06219363957643509, 0.014196342788636684, -0.037068430334329605, 0.06002714857459068, -0.01552045438438654, 0.03289639577269554, -0.01833442971110344, 0.03416910022497177, 0.03683771565556526, -0.01661659963428974, -0.06356869637966156, -0.01142978947609663, -0.035265736281871796, -0.0020008843857795, 0.04172280430793762, 0.014726771041750908, -0.06323544681072235, 0.013464623130857944, 0.002347668632864952, 0.05271722003817558, 0.01443815790116787, -0.004281994886696339, -0.05202200263738632, -0.06183687970042229, -0.055106859654188156, 0.0009127482189796865, 0.04605519399046898, -0.03754020482301712, 0.01722586527466774, -0.013437841087579727, 0.01386144571006298, -0.07304971665143967 ]
Optical nanofiber cavity research has mainly focused on the fundamental mode. Here, a Fabry-P\'erot fiber cavity with an optical nanofiber supporting the higher-order modes, TE01, TM01, HE21o, and HE21e, is demonstrated. Using cavity spectroscopy, with mode imaging and analysis, we observe cavity resonances that exhibit complex, inhomogeneous states of polarization with topological features containing Stokes singularities such as C-points, Poincar\'e vortices, and L-lines. In situ tuning of the intracavity birefringence enables the desired profile and polarization of the cavity mode to be obtained. These findings open new research possibilities for cold atom manipulation and multimode cavity quantum electrodynamics using the evanescent fields of higher-order mode optical nanofibers.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13432v1
[ -0.05004989728331566, -0.03353418409824371, -0.013472250662744045, -0.009203963913023472, -0.012103023938834667, -0.07181935012340546, 0.027388637885451317, -0.007957829162478447, -0.02274913527071476, 0.030936116352677345, -0.020739756524562836, -0.01659812219440937, -0.07895578444004059, -0.05054977536201477, -0.05930718407034874, 0.03207949176430702, 0.03094072826206684, -0.014319928362965584, -0.016987834125757217, 0.06643570959568024, 0.0006747771985828876, -0.03921829164028168, 0.02412426471710205, 0.02103390358388424, 0.028635907918214798, -0.009320547804236412, -0.031103836372494698, 0.0158168263733387, -0.010208955965936184, -0.04151037335395813, 0.0631202682852745, 0.017734460532665253, -0.05052262544631958, -0.007868839427828789, 0.022097431123256683, -0.009108347818255424, -0.03647006303071976, 0.06026337668299675, 0.04686226695775986, -0.014339815825223923, 0.005779113620519638, -0.019049426540732384, -0.06282113492488861, -0.02633931115269661, -0.018095750361680984, -0.04203261435031891, -0.06068097800016403, -0.003670475212857127, -0.07393354922533035, -0.056817300617694855, -0.010423915460705757, 0.029784439131617546, -0.029537992551922798, 0.035986337810754776, -0.03790266439318657, -0.00027626584051176906, -0.0047640264965593815, -0.016538023948669434, -0.0529867447912693, 0.03774873912334442, 0.03457287698984146, -0.01767701655626297, 0.027488162741065025, -0.016591930761933327, -0.04482624679803848, -0.0010645759757608175, -0.04198364168405533, -0.06117399036884308, -0.04536563903093338, -0.04200588911771774, -0.021735727787017822, -0.043122343719005585, -0.014803007245063782, 0.012865290977060795, -0.040219374001026154, -0.003193839453160763, -0.010313871316611767, 0.007458622567355633, -0.014774833805859089, 0.013979804702103138, -0.043208133429288864, 0.001974863698706031, 0.03409678116440773, 0.03068959154188633, 0.01321925688534975, 0.003953608218580484, -0.004193137865513563, -0.04298108071088791, -0.01393855269998312, -0.049136120826005936, 0.0633559599518776, 0.01457795687019825, -0.04013428837060928, 0.04697732254862785, 0.07157544791698456, -0.03882116824388504, 0.06314028054475784, -0.002123515587300062, -0.0071773165836930275, 0.023964380845427513, 0.03169546276330948, -0.032395388931035995, -0.00750398775562644, 0.039608538150787354, -0.01824948750436306, -0.013106795959174633, -0.015339663252234459, -0.026134133338928223, -0.008386462926864624, -0.001461318344809115, 0.004688054323196411, 0.028917361050844193, 0.030461935326457024, 0.019132519140839577, 0.019048908725380898, -0.06227264180779457, 0.061536021530628204, 0.0034038510639220476, -0.022841058671474457, -0.028153594583272934, -0.01141026709228754, 0.07390522211790085, 0.03654133155941963, -0.03394680842757225, -0.07014638185501099, -0.023443171754479408, 0.08028019964694977, 0.012892570346593857, -0.008091882802546024, -0.0711250975728035, 0.04071059450507164, 0.01639886014163494, 0.005682193674147129, -0.04085063561797142, 0.04319281876087189, -0.04591840133070946, -0.02005046419799328, -0.009115939028561115, -0.02537325769662857, -0.010869677178561687, -0.042543984949588776, -0.04230979084968567, -0.006241956260055304, -0.05032755061984062, 0.030549829825758934, 0.0346306636929512, -0.07439171522855759, -0.0014881219249218702, 0.03956814110279083, 0.029508700594305992, 0.02893928252160549, -0.016049109399318695, -0.006099694408476353, 0.001652362523600459, 0.0028035605791956186, -0.020491868257522583, 0.048858847469091415, -0.0020878082141280174, -0.0284446831792593, 0.043428290635347366, -0.013797340914607048, -0.022159608080983162, 0.04506152868270874, -0.023352930322289467, -0.05487925186753273, -0.030497537925839424, -0.01656646467745304, -0.026720356196165085, -0.02955872379243374, 0.00800887681543827, -0.06839258223772049, 0.0072873495519161224, 0.007110636681318283, -0.017879847437143326, -0.06143940985202789, -0.020984956994652748, 0.006549102254211903, -0.02861783839762211, 0.005475451238453388, -0.013475560583174229, -0.02135162241756916, 0.01628446765244007, -0.00007700724381720647, -0.022576522082090378, -0.05679834261536598, -0.00682661822065711, -0.08977861702442169, 0.026850728318095207, 0.04250628128647804, -0.03958558291196823, -0.006165085826069117, -0.03367597237229347, 0.01321925688534975, 0.015489545650780201, -0.061165377497673035, -0.038838744163513184, -0.0222620889544487, -0.017168458551168442, 0.02367245778441429, 0.00940481573343277, -0.07160820066928864, -0.03100183606147766, -0.029751259833574295, 0.010746958665549755, 0.01939578913152218, -0.060654230415821075, 0.023267360404133797, 0.06124066561460495, -0.026503514498472214, 0.004701836965978146, 0.026345165446400642, 0.034655287861824036, 0.058680035173892975, -0.020484687760472298, -0.015784967690706253, -0.007410087622702122, -0.09974199533462524, 0.04297370836138725, 0.011644632555544376, 0.00695671234279871, 0.011195534840226173, 0.0003661344526335597, -0.0103052519261837, -0.0365239717066288, -0.050321195274591446, 0.05974365398287773, 0.05340232327580452, -0.016849929466843605, 0.014877894893288612, 0.031377505511045456, 0.027522731572389603, -0.07232099026441574, -0.05797044560313225, -0.032751474529504776, -0.06401481479406357, -0.002695404691621661, -0.06578972190618515, 0.05134730786085129, -0.030752044171094894, -0.061877716332674026, -0.05792246758937836, 0.004238021560013294, 0.06881633400917053, -0.015717877075076103, -0.01961115561425686, 0.0092471269890666, -0.053947772830724716, 0.02234179899096489, -0.053344596177339554, 0.012436035089194775, 0.0070181116461753845, -0.05748384818434715, -0.0060131424106657505, -0.03854086250066757, -0.010377442464232445, 0.03269851580262184, -0.01823483407497406, 0.007160492707043886, -0.02623642422258854, 0.05994948372244835, 0.03292268514633179, 0.03395964205265045, -0.032159991562366486, -0.00011901080142706633, 0.030157674103975296, 0.016339434310793877, -0.03130577132105827, -0.03788546100258827, -0.00213658157736063, -0.025602251291275024, -0.000003229192998333019, 0.024929065257310867, 0.013309158384799957, 0.04232017323374748, -0.028935007750988007, -0.022406678646802902, -0.033988844603300095, -0.03439508005976677, 0.01886989176273346, 0.0491182915866375, 0.06671037524938583, 0.04109799489378929, -0.03260969743132591, -0.04870636388659477, 0.018074415624141693, -0.045045405626297, 0.000711096974555403, -0.0751207247376442, -0.03168569132685661, -0.0025381664745509624, -0.06809568405151367, -0.004229322075843811, -0.005956596694886684, -0.057099200785160065, -0.04056514799594879, -0.05448976531624794, -0.025658955797553062, -0.0015052317176014185, 0.04823454096913338, -0.06462091952562332, -0.052419427782297134, 0.03476506471633911, -0.015826096758246422, 0.030736153945326805, -0.05500795692205429, -0.044634342193603516, -0.029651153832674026, 0.058518365025520325, -0.0239034965634346, -0.02623455598950386, -0.02452801540493965, 0.0062997182831168175, -0.08295083045959473, 0.01979851722717285, 0.02059982530772686, 0.061352141201496124, -0.00012031283404212445, -0.0021666984539479017, 0.0004949893918819726, -0.00976920872926712, -0.03014509193599224, 0.006751824636012316, 0.01246225368231535, 0.02499653771519661, -0.03285248950123787, 0.021513141691684723, 0.06738758832216263, 0.015561689622700214, -0.040714364498853683, 0.004704108461737633, -0.011217025108635426, 0.0065630660392344, 0.03210245445370674, 0.011324607767164707, 0.049119193106889725, -0.009501139633357525, -0.02714168094098568, -0.01635030284523964, -0.0659387931227684, -0.004164906218647957, 0.02442367933690548, -0.012529254890978336, 0.040152281522750854, 0.013584273867309093, -0.04342444986104965, -0.08159947395324707, 0.016721175983548164, 0.03314312547445297, 0.058355316519737244, -0.03993099182844162, -0.03242529183626175, -0.01928859017789364, 0.02325928397476673, 0.0032862741500139236, -0.007586364168673754, -0.01943524181842804, 0.04875289648771286, 0.03518568351864815, -0.06713006645441055, -0.04625376686453819, -0.06821031868457794, -0.0715348869562149, -0.06615862250328064, -0.019262073561549187, 0.054923560470342636, 0.017505528405308723, 0.03682980313897133, -0.0438840277493, 0.0022220052778720856, -0.06088698282837868, 0.04383150115609169, 0.012901506386697292, -0.022630151361227036, -0.013182154856622219, -0.006653830874711275, 0.0030440196860581636, -0.006936189718544483, -0.04281207546591759, -0.033159784972667694, -0.037175554782152176, 0.03221048414707184, -0.05296779423952103, 0.011196882463991642, -0.007592662237584591, 0.06359374523162842, 0.00938250683248043, 0.008942634798586369, 0.0509970560669899, 0.020908880978822708, -0.0385417677462101, 0.05817553773522377, 0.0375351756811142, 0.0379972904920578, 0.00090657954569906, -0.03174641355872154, -0.005660193972289562, -0.020234376192092896, -0.004587600473314524, -0.062442004680633545, 0.030582580715417862, 0.0036655087023973465, 0.02843131683766842, -0.04688747599720955, -0.08639468252658844, -0.010972455143928528, -0.040261268615722656, 0.026947198435664177, -0.009971021674573421, -0.021662238985300064, 0.05943723022937775, -0.027650728821754456, 0.006053462624549866, -0.0034705866128206253, -0.041541315615177155, -0.019836319610476494, -0.038907699286937714, -0.00886625424027443, -0.07260319590568542, 0.04374511167407036, -0.028634976595640182, 0.012691320851445198, -0.0013584478292614222, -0.0023202993907034397, -0.07049387693405151, 0.040500350296497345, -0.006181658711284399, -0.006092844996601343, 0.049187980592250824, -0.022655479609966278, 0.05514223128557205, 0.03936820104718208, 0.031665608286857605, 0.07078322768211365, 0.011131636798381805, 0.05617262050509453, -0.011149134486913681, 0.06535633653402328, -0.01595224440097809, 0.004296503495424986, -0.007251292001456022, -0.019979700446128845, 0.052762940526008606, -0.02481313981115818, -0.014330776408314705, 0.026735585182905197, 0.035607531666755676, -0.015434601344168186, -0.07003176957368851, 0.0032595426309853792, 0.00993987638503313, -0.04613226279616356, 0.0001964713301276788, 0.03978747874498367, -0.014395073987543583, 0.01272855419665575, -0.0076447236351668835, -0.00412870803847909, 0.017903117462992668, -0.0667436346411705, -0.00010248058242723346, 0.05248824134469032, 0.02494070678949356, 0.003192346077412367, -0.05207947641611099, -0.06268758326768875, 0.007808579597622156, -0.020584020763635635, 0.0062364572659134865, 0.043251506984233856, 0.04408701881766319, -0.03645266592502594, 0.02814529277384281, -0.09102367609739304, 0.039332788437604904, 0.058727044612169266, -0.052847206592559814, -0.025626186281442642, 0.013776649720966816, 0.023476460948586464, 0.01533039752393961, 0.025142183527350426, -0.01290182862430811, -0.028113413602113724, -0.061411019414663315, -0.0009593627764843404, 0.022907080128788948, -0.011541127227246761, 0.06314759701490402, -0.006122529041022062, 0.03831488639116287, -0.0572357140481472, -0.0005712146521545947, 0.03708380088210106, -0.010793169029057026, -0.03601403906941414, 0.016836822032928467, 0.013822672888636589, -0.029100123792886734, -0.052047278732061386, 0.02584136463701725, -0.05009503662586212, 0.03692921996116638, -0.013539806008338928, -0.049821678549051285, -0.00969412736594677, -0.008984662592411041, -0.00024757281062193215, 0.036558087915182114, 0.006535811349749565, -0.043632909655570984, -0.0027484826277941465, 0.04163188859820366, -0.05852968245744705, -0.03989081829786301, -0.006870873738080263, -0.040643151849508286, -0.024703944101929665, 0.036938246339559555, -0.002461305120959878, 0.05465710908174515, 0.041734691709280014, 0.017432305961847305, -0.019367001950740814, 0.0035976890940219164, -0.04834279417991638, 0.06259749084711075, -0.032077837735414505, -0.03616601228713989, -0.0005367156118154526, 0.05934232473373413, -0.004961463622748852, 0.03845587372779846, 0.03326723352074623, 0.010355889797210693, -0.03698315843939781, 0.0116447564214468, -0.01177532970905304, 0.028051717206835747, -0.028126787394285202, -0.0020710595417767763, 0.033999908715486526, -0.037256788462400436, 0.045677270740270615, 0.031086649745702744, 0.001219364465214312, 0.04221780598163605, 0.0006914908881299198, 0.023847725242376328, -0.04349645972251892, -0.027555003762245178, 0.05557316541671753, -0.08215393871068954, -0.027863482013344765, -0.0043199933134019375, -0.06408790498971939, 0.00657846312969923, -0.05351544916629791, -0.00434120511636138, 0.03479605168104172, -0.015438622795045376, -0.07210492342710495, 0.02224436216056347, -0.011169609613716602, -0.04249459132552147, 0.02076662704348564, -0.01403802540153265, -0.0670175552368164, -0.04170609265565872, 0.01784277893602848, -0.032274261116981506, 0.02673736959695816, 0.02297019399702549, -0.038848720490932465, -0.05579427629709244, -0.01638026349246502, 0.0011254086857661605, 0.040737830102443695, 0.006348461844027042, 0.019366908818483353, -0.026033062487840652, 0.03419370576739311, -0.032645657658576965, -0.03648797795176506, -0.020586945116519928, -0.033016327768564224, 0.01311621256172657, 0.018918998539447784, -0.03882022574543953, 0.002189527964219451, 0.020265568047761917, -0.03352517634630203, -0.013858257792890072, -0.024076296016573906, 0.0059822616167366505, 0.05709529668092728, -0.03514537960290909, -0.05557404085993767, 0.03960304334759712, -0.0009018350392580032, -0.03530941158533096, -0.0576549768447876, 0.00726017402485013, -0.050906430929899216, 0.00782686471939087, 0.029405903071165085, -0.014793039299547672, -0.043656498193740845, -0.04468342661857605, -0.07919812947511673, -0.024836044758558273, -0.07979506254196167, -0.05201432853937149, 0.02621454745531082, 0.04159872606396675, 0.024061892181634903, 0.026640737429261208, -0.019024433568120003, -0.013612167909741402, -0.009157468564808369, 0.00016524204693268985, 0.04443572461605072, 0.03542635589838028, 0.021828874945640564, -0.04116986691951752, 0.020278261974453926, -0.04848179221153259, 0.038362957537174225, -0.008309339173138142, -0.04405473172664642, -0.005747006740421057, -0.00599361676722765, -0.04730995371937752, -0.02820303849875927, -0.012128956615924835, 0.00588598195463419, -0.01654067263007164, 0.0006443840102292597, -0.015316544100642204, -0.061682239174842834, 0.029337072744965553, -0.017325354740023613, 0.017320500686764717, 0.003933488857001066, 0.027389731258153915, 0.013687880709767342, -0.025618091225624084, 0.024814153090119362, 0.04324867203831673, 0.008784734643995762, -0.014116299338638783, -0.03206631541252136, 0.009707302786409855, 0.034083981066942215, 0.061581939458847046, -0.07247575372457504, -0.027003049850463867, -0.060099322348833084, -0.08529549837112427, 0.0038058410864323378, -0.031646691262722015, -0.016059409826993942, -0.02230694331228733, -0.05902004614472389, 0.02048862725496292, 0.03593479096889496, 0.010274844244122505, -0.07508940249681473, -0.02572482079267502, 0.05271939933300018, 0.008054069243371487, 0.01411821972578764, -0.0233144573867321, -0.04068223014473915, -0.025835281237959862, -0.06679844856262207, -0.011824779212474823, -0.02045910432934761, 0.050874173641204834, 0.013388829305768013, -0.03918307647109032, 0.0016904657240957022, -0.04522259160876274, -0.052781566977500916, 0.011756747961044312, -0.022873224690556526, -0.00048314587911590934, -0.024856794625520706, -0.009677276946604252, -0.0350528284907341, -0.003920694347470999, 0.017745167016983032, -0.0236379224807024, -0.01988614909350872, -0.017858309671282768, 0.052508287131786346, -0.026184316724538803, 0.02545417658984661, 0.050416190177202225, 0.013487719930708408, 0.06614819169044495, -0.03248937055468559, 0.004649254493415356, -0.02662118524312973, -0.07267788052558899, 0.053432781249284744, -0.06389739364385605, -0.02422601357102394, 0.028701195493340492, -0.028315210714936256, -0.0028393976390361786, 0.00776059040799737, -0.05692138522863388, 0.022585319355130196, -0.000846491486299783, -0.012941597029566765, 0.04616085812449455, -0.07339917868375778, 0.00255188113078475, -0.016446474939584732, 0.01342130359262228, -0.036732230335474014, 0.025392092764377594, 0.028864501044154167, -0.049291469156742096, 0.02070619910955429, -0.06551861763000488, 0.03868675231933594, -0.02232893370091915, -0.0007167811854742467, 0.015148176811635494, 0.05215737223625183, -0.036431729793548584, 0.022011352702975273, -0.06722503155469894, -0.056134309619665146, 0.038147833198308945, -0.04101197049021721, -0.0009638890041969717, 0.0006660337094217539, 0.04174471274018288, 0.024147765710949898, 0.008445698767900467, -0.026272770017385483, 0.06708987802267075, 0.027287160977721214, -0.012294323183596134, -0.0375770665705204, 0.01697194017469883, 0.018625779077410698, 0.06015518307685852, 0.014519781805574894, -0.012858357280492783, -0.045134857296943665, 0.01684015430510044, -0.018272951245307922, -0.01396793220192194, -0.03116925247013569, 0.02097509242594242, -0.039523884654045105, 0.0148643609136343, 0.008096638135612011, -0.018283821642398834, -0.03001517616212368, -0.032822385430336, 0.005197871942073107, 0.01025654748082161, -0.04716050624847412, -0.0631835088133812 ]
In recent years, excitation of surface phonon polaritons (SPhPs) in van der Waals materials received wide attention from the nanophotonics community. Alpha-phase Molybdenum trioxide ($\alpha$-MoO3), a naturally occurring biaxial hyperbolic crystal, emerged as a promising polaritonic material due to its ability to support SPhPs for three orthogonal directions at different wavelength bands (range 10-20 $\mu$m). Here, we report on the fabrication and IR characterization of large-area (over 1 cm$^2$ size) $\alpha$-MoO3 polycrystalline films deposited on fused silica substrates by pulsed laser deposition. Single alpha-phase MoO3 films exhibiting a polarization-dependent reflection peak at 1006 cm$^{-1}$ with a resonance Q-factor as high as 53 were achieved. Reflection can be tuned via changing incident polarization with a dynamic range of $\Delta$R=0.3 at 45 deg. incidence angle. We also report a polarization-independent almost perfect absorption condition (R<0.01) at 972 cm$^{-1}$ which is preserved for a broad angle of incidence. The development of a low-cost polaritonic platform with high-Q resonances in the mid-infrared (mid-IR) range is crucial for a wide number of functionalities including sensors, filters, thermal emitters, and label-free biochemical sensing devices. In this framework our findings appear extremely promising for the further development of lithography-free, scalable films, for efficient and large-scale devices operating in the free space, using far-field detection setups.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13210v1
[ -0.04235636815428734, 0.010488645173609257, 0.031129024922847748, -0.02622796595096588, -0.027925819158554077, -0.05807073786854744, 0.026438310742378235, -0.018122168257832527, -0.04886828735470772, -0.004094344563782215, -0.02932099625468254, -0.04080455005168915, -0.010492472909390926, -0.03764842450618744, -0.04685908555984497, 0.02540244348347187, 0.006325458642095327, 0.021383162587881088, -0.07425671815872192, 0.07298213988542557, 0.044593967497348785, -0.021534902974963188, -0.022902224212884903, 0.04640621691942215, 0.026490194723010063, -0.01082609687000513, -0.014752074144780636, 0.037604838609695435, 0.00292036822065711, -0.07036607712507248, 0.051950279623270035, 0.027097679674625397, -0.06946056336164474, -0.010986370965838432, 0.014279686845839024, 0.008407440036535263, -0.007726222742348909, 0.06450055539608002, -0.03441152721643448, -0.013496248051524162, 0.028465839102864265, -0.04479700326919556, -0.02192200906574726, -0.02811567857861519, -0.021176232025027275, -0.02365415170788765, -0.042716238647699356, 0.008925617672502995, -0.04774404317140579, -0.038005586713552475, 0.049351513385772705, 0.031229861080646515, 0.005906049627810717, 0.05634867399930954, -0.02444583736360073, -0.009004632011055946, 0.005403462797403336, 0.008653356693685055, 0.021709103137254715, 0.017364943400025368, 0.03621453419327736, -0.04897373169660568, 0.029836516827344894, -0.0074166059494018555, -0.06560039520263672, 0.012695369310677052, -0.06995558738708496, -0.02435850352048874, 0.028672456741333008, -0.07802648842334747, -0.008103628642857075, -0.04889820143580437, 0.014153527095913887, 0.03825788199901581, -0.07408144325017929, -0.009055155329406261, -0.052007682621479034, -0.0047875065356493, -0.008295316249132156, 0.020670292899012566, -0.020939340814948082, -0.02420777454972267, 0.006134622730314732, 0.06047133728861809, -0.00022803650062996894, -0.01827879436314106, -0.000657196098472923, -0.06230461597442627, 0.014606845565140247, 0.004996081348508596, 0.04035266116261482, -0.013099961914122105, -0.01747332699596882, 0.021847903728485107, 0.07263412326574326, -0.03053146041929722, 0.06670793890953064, 0.024454809725284576, 0.04507286846637726, -0.014192400500178337, 0.0010893128346651793, 0.012836855836212635, 0.01252226997166872, -0.0005648941150866449, 0.02676153928041458, -0.017408134415745735, 0.01643271930515766, 0.025486456230282784, -0.018691763281822205, 0.009510998614132404, -0.015646765008568764, -0.008533946238458157, 0.007571430876851082, -0.00988495722413063, -0.03691895306110382, -0.07688616961240768, 0.054814763367176056, -0.013218991458415985, -0.039010439068078995, 0.011267107911407948, -0.06044109910726547, 0.056168656796216965, 0.058412715792655945, -0.02186228521168232, -0.005471734795719385, -0.0032495358027517796, 0.07416479289531708, -0.05932415649294853, 0.0005367250414565206, -0.028027107939124107, -0.001330164959654212, 0.012120326980948448, 0.03683490306138992, -0.040989939123392105, 0.020511994138360023, -0.028173668310046196, 0.008892683312296867, -0.010682329535484314, -0.03792816773056984, -0.015922334045171738, 0.014860700815916061, -0.018676800653338432, -0.001571738044731319, -0.03687754645943642, 0.006205902900546789, -0.028231147676706314, -0.07928512245416641, 0.0005329634877853096, 0.035641271620988846, 0.05190318822860718, -0.04430490732192993, 0.008107892237603664, -0.03031417727470398, 0.0349699929356575, -0.01110139675438404, -0.0031030382961034775, 0.037865445017814636, 0.010682611726224422, -0.04043637961149216, 0.03102455846965313, -0.03652583435177803, -0.00986469816416502, 0.050078436732292175, -0.027148937806487083, 0.00944937951862812, -0.007396652828902006, 0.034820765256881714, -0.03505789488554001, 0.014216004870831966, 0.025089768692851067, -0.01906551606953144, -0.03061452880501747, -0.0366455540060997, 0.002490498125553131, -0.07112444937229156, -0.0009883021702989936, -0.009092133492231369, -0.019374573603272438, -0.05504164099693298, 0.020521825179457664, 0.022928334772586823, -0.05530506744980812, 0.022602630779147148, -0.05403776839375496, -0.049972180277109146, 0.014607548713684082, -0.0778377503156662, -0.005438205786049366, 0.03145168349146843, -0.04969251528382301, -0.057134561240673065, -0.04229113832116127, 0.0034352215006947517, 0.03292911872267723, -0.019040675833821297, 0.05078662931919098, -0.039314985275268555, -0.040326494723558426, -0.009782444685697556, 0.003912030253559351, -0.06489534676074982, -0.05551200360059738, -0.07125379145145416, -0.02333167754113674, 0.051388006657361984, -0.07999275624752045, -0.014516506344079971, 0.043553996831178665, -0.05220195651054382, -0.012189536355435848, 0.03959203138947487, 0.02105894312262535, 0.032553210854530334, 0.0012194575974717736, -0.01364143006503582, -0.026394516229629517, -0.09396407753229141, 0.029352175071835518, 0.027041509747505188, -0.03341478109359741, 0.03720467910170555, 0.00846040714532137, 0.017323888838291168, -0.026455333456397057, -0.03824771195650101, 0.06440980732440948, 0.0606575682759285, -0.04084249958395958, -0.04668492078781128, 0.02133224718272686, 0.04494618996977806, -0.06873565912246704, -0.05551831051707268, -0.07700052857398987, -0.03553016856312752, 0.014125770889222622, -0.06200651824474335, 0.028118330985307693, -0.05168991908431053, -0.029719026759266853, -0.02105266973376274, -0.008281252346932888, 0.037171151489019394, 0.01685839518904686, -0.06516271829605103, -0.05070990324020386, -0.05593869835138321, -0.0034542223438620567, -0.06440652906894684, -0.05663415044546127, -0.001050644787028432, -0.059123676270246506, -0.0022491980344057083, 0.011456990614533424, 0.053022682666778564, 0.004516150336712599, 0.027533330023288727, 0.03418653830885887, -0.052215177565813065, 0.03137708827853203, -0.013498003594577312, 0.03361878916621208, -0.04642857238650322, 0.01637975685298443, -0.01789010688662529, -0.007227347232401371, -0.07534761726856232, 0.008533542975783348, -0.012535280548036098, -0.012447042390704155, -0.03929457068443298, 0.062418267130851746, -0.009335089474916458, 0.03338957205414772, 0.020879648625850677, -0.04431271180510521, -0.011468346230685711, -0.02793356589972973, 0.04130520671606064, -0.015735849738121033, 0.06882372498512268, 0.0148831931874156, 0.02043253183364868, -0.059544697403907776, -0.020492011681199074, -0.055699001997709274, -0.020502351224422455, -0.041024185717105865, -0.05879117175936699, -0.032395437359809875, -0.03189186379313469, -0.021066172048449516, -0.02089412324130535, 0.0008495998336002231, 0.02324989251792431, -0.04547031968832016, -0.03029737062752247, 0.01158376969397068, 0.02680227719247341, -0.03826392441987991, -0.011485300958156586, 0.01777515932917595, -0.010904436931014061, 0.006265892647206783, -0.061325784772634506, 0.029994172975420952, -0.03603287786245346, 0.048997774720191956, -0.012038055807352066, -0.0004037024627905339, -0.04542233422398567, 0.05563334748148918, -0.04990951344370842, 0.030689947307109833, 0.008878907188773155, 0.05300319567322731, 0.03759137541055679, -0.009207099676132202, 0.01214034017175436, -0.038571178913116455, -0.012379039078950882, -0.01862785778939724, 0.0012624496594071388, 0.025156954303383827, -0.039423394948244095, -0.03250717744231224, 0.05120881646871567, 0.07233791053295135, 0.038475215435028076, -0.06742503494024277, -0.05457773059606552, 0.020538104698061943, -0.005899311043322086, -0.017369788140058517, 0.06487306207418442, 0.009225633926689625, -0.041018612682819366, 0.03326144069433212, -0.026866717264056206, -0.021480504423379898, -0.023815657943487167, -0.010149741545319557, 0.01579890586435795, -0.028598062694072723, 0.002702412661164999, -0.0840001031756401, 0.047805264592170715, 0.04498190060257912, 0.03190167620778084, 0.026445934548974037, -0.01840757392346859, 0.0011438444489613175, -0.026580942794680595, 0.03000563569366932, -0.03994164615869522, 0.03471333160996437, 0.0040170177817344666, 0.04903898760676384, -0.045285459607839584, -0.03206368535757065, -0.003304803278297186, -0.051964372396469116, -0.0461999885737896, -0.039281610399484634, -0.023962026461958885, 0.039604682475328445, 0.03576042503118515, -0.05071017146110535, 0.029321013018488884, -0.0499243326485157, 0.02311563491821289, -0.029812438413500786, -0.05424888804554939, 0.031233930960297585, 0.0058942195028066635, -0.01758064143359661, 0.01816275343298912, -0.018010403960943222, -0.031857457011938095, -0.05523451417684555, 0.0035994048230350018, -0.014957153238356113, 0.0014916426734998822, 0.020360097289085388, 0.059785693883895874, 0.0009048390202224255, 0.022196048870682716, 0.061349935829639435, 0.0024017696268856525, 0.022459059953689575, 0.009900121949613094, -0.006375246215611696, -0.009180650115013123, 0.022124074399471283, -0.029679903760552406, -0.03912162408232689, -0.04206085577607155, -0.030209781602025032, -0.02419181913137436, 0.0007736554834991693, 0.04787815362215042, -0.033814914524555206, -0.006700117606669664, -0.08488969504833221, -0.0042411708272993565, -0.05628589913249016, 0.004760004114359617, -0.017292076721787453, -0.02459774538874626, 0.05882500857114792, -0.049939848482608795, 0.011235487647354603, 0.028969423845410347, 0.019680963829159737, -0.008808499202132225, -0.03616560995578766, -0.023939620703458786, -0.05457932502031326, -0.03550548478960991, -0.05154839903116226, 0.04931874945759773, -0.04397046938538551, -0.006549797486513853, -0.05330339074134827, 0.018522175028920174, -0.0350499153137207, -0.003273745533078909, 0.05150131508708, -0.01176917739212513, 0.010103859007358551, -0.00505532743409276, 0.00959116779267788, 0.030056577175855637, 0.010682080872356892, 0.05865839868783951, -0.06117783859372139, 0.011321229860186577, -0.0057813860476017, -0.026393521577119827, 0.017332084476947784, 0.016328150406479836, 0.008270487189292908, -0.05193687602877617, -0.048514652997255325, 0.007644503377377987, 0.019623158499598503, 0.029830437153577805, -0.033030394464731216, -0.045800041407346725, -0.010186504572629929, -0.07342541962862015, -0.006644441746175289, 0.04657202959060669, -0.043911632150411606, 0.013267730362713337, 0.005706938449293375, 0.019239459186792374, -0.02234618179500103, -0.015719980001449585, 0.026605771854519844, 0.048662301152944565, 0.030567539855837822, -0.032775942236185074, -0.04163694009184837, -0.06170213595032692, -0.002772306790575385, 0.01864732801914215, -0.03345855697989464, -0.01945740543305874, -0.02747930772602558, 0.007734648417681456, 0.00372799183242023, -0.0819592997431755, 0.04960742965340614, 0.019090915098786354, -0.04383762553334236, -0.022759437561035156, 0.02821485884487629, 0.031021658331155777, 0.03365350887179375, 0.030582426115870476, 0.04878243803977966, -0.016175104305148125, -0.03815853223204613, -0.02980729751288891, -0.022154293954372406, -0.042034633457660675, -0.021421171724796295, -0.0012733177281916142, 0.030948108062148094, -0.05947677418589592, 0.005172490142285824, -0.009861630387604237, -0.022735722362995148, 0.013581102713942528, 0.013348998501896858, 0.045123398303985596, -0.0266009159386158, -0.05651059001684189, -0.00287889433093369, -0.020110268145799637, 0.010281281545758247, 0.05522574111819267, -0.04315218701958656, -0.016922514885663986, -0.008278366178274155, 0.0247095488011837, 0.056145813316106796, -0.012109655886888504, 0.04370560497045517, -0.04526717960834503, 0.03415849059820175, -0.06325087696313858, -0.050525419414043427, -0.025064872577786446, -0.06863483786582947, 0.01603984646499157, 0.007002008147537708, 0.028182346373796463, 0.07904767990112305, 0.06432708352804184, 0.043708350509405136, -0.01727703958749771, -0.011534685268998146, -0.06106610968708992, 0.060466933995485306, 0.010900966823101044, 0.0005361784133128822, -0.0006122140912339091, 0.03136834129691124, 0.01238998956978321, -0.006897862534970045, -0.0005405204719863832, 0.014966398477554321, -0.03796205669641495, -0.014200842007994652, 0.03166252747178078, 0.023257501423358917, -0.05265447869896889, -0.0030715279281139374, 0.043650612235069275, -0.07186014205217361, 0.04519626498222351, 0.00004234153311699629, 0.0035570410545915365, 0.03092212975025177, 0.04051552340388298, 0.03321542963385582, -0.06686162948608398, 0.0023264822084456682, 0.07318117469549179, -0.068056121468544, -0.03506612777709961, -0.04434486851096153, -0.06852523982524872, -0.023274188861250877, -0.06104114651679993, -0.02087414264678955, 0.01532489899545908, -0.025023464113473892, -0.029048791155219078, 0.05064626410603523, -0.017765499651432037, -0.05556034669280052, 0.02682339772582054, 0.027537913993000984, -0.0677683874964714, -0.04407709464430809, 0.010100300423800945, -0.038615234196186066, 0.00036941104917787015, -0.019081957638263702, -0.05166911333799362, -0.02031155675649643, 0.012309655547142029, 0.015386633574962616, 0.011166405864059925, -0.006187265273183584, -0.028612298890948296, 0.014148102141916752, 0.038078855723142624, -0.005817795637995005, -0.026792030781507492, -0.025708632543683052, -0.013283215463161469, 0.05004272982478142, 0.03105018101632595, -0.0500650517642498, -0.01007318776100874, 0.005737186409533024, -0.029750339686870575, 0.03243262693285942, 0.01018165796995163, 0.009706459008157253, 0.05823152884840965, -0.05183052271604538, -0.007379720453172922, 0.0410439632833004, -0.06083965301513672, -0.011412717401981354, -0.020901301875710487, -0.004754811059683561, -0.0036031180061399937, 0.04223272204399109, 0.056058403104543686, -0.04366770386695862, -0.028827471658587456, -0.0686807855963707, -0.01775740645825863, -0.010406342335045338, -0.05991540476679802, -0.015584646724164486, 0.009150778874754906, 0.048042722046375275, 0.06765269488096237, 0.01125083863735199, -0.05524349957704544, -0.030362827703356743, -0.05673430487513542, -0.028083981946110725, -0.011686314828693867, -0.0026266237255185843, 0.054176799952983856, -0.06478390842676163, 0.016432523727416992, -0.015706339851021767, 0.0426463708281517, -0.008493642322719097, -0.05796442925930023, 0.0038045470137149096, 0.01517221238464117, -0.05447069928050041, -0.03161388635635376, -0.04111919179558754, -0.036233268678188324, -0.003001757897436619, 0.017012501135468483, -0.04581829160451889, -0.05676882714033127, -0.02284969761967659, -0.028846243396401405, -0.00003562944402801804, 0.013362613506615162, 0.017253370955586433, 0.050844721496105194, -0.035468850284814835, 0.04691014066338539, 0.016376785933971405, 0.03146173804998398, 0.016847878694534302, -0.023111771792173386, 0.013549203053116798, 0.06026835739612579, -0.0034151345025748014, -0.03590700775384903, -0.018970482051372528, -0.045250389724969864, -0.06918948888778687, -0.0023709204979240894, -0.04417373612523079, 0.029446227476000786, -0.032237328588962555, -0.05033813789486885, 0.03435622528195381, 0.03070409782230854, 0.025066297501325607, -0.08060862123966217, 0.003945763222873211, 0.018544932827353477, -0.033925216645002365, 0.0006765924044884741, 0.0014709769748151302, -0.047996703535318375, 0.014017886482179165, -0.07655517011880875, -0.014725537970662117, -0.024269144982099533, 0.06479885429143906, -0.02063632570207119, -0.026535406708717346, -0.030817566439509392, 0.0071198660880327225, -0.007947142235934734, 0.044371217489242554, -0.0034599918872117996, 0.020696187391877174, -0.01883440464735031, -0.020810775458812714, -0.0007240114500746131, -0.02231820486485958, 0.018667709082365036, -0.006525400094687939, 0.0020396208856254816, 0.0027126253116875887, 0.022853387519717216, -0.05151045694947243, -0.02019292674958706, 0.04799884930253029, -0.024373799562454224, -0.004034413490444422, -0.028789781033992767, -0.025143081322312355, 0.000691329303663224, -0.045246753841638565, 0.010544167831540108, -0.06330214440822601, -0.010496099479496479, 0.007410848047584295, 0.02433415874838829, 0.007198298815637827, -0.05133257433772087, -0.029683293774724007, -0.011286115273833275, 0.021805379539728165, -0.00013403085176832974, 0.07468722015619278, -0.0764593631029129, -0.011958668008446693, -0.004597169812768698, -0.018481193110346794, -0.04318425431847572, 0.04210274666547775, 0.05825847014784813, -0.019830530509352684, 0.004196158144623041, -0.06501573324203491, 0.012881963513791561, -0.01630702242255211, -0.0023479461669921875, 0.012753847986459732, 0.06520894169807434, -0.06415916234254837, -0.011826889589428902, -0.04772435873746872, -0.035747021436691284, 0.031097810715436935, -0.0014418275095522404, 0.038460131734609604, 0.015556068159639835, 0.006078731268644333, 0.018047358840703964, -0.01987859234213829, -0.034462377429008484, 0.0427958145737648, 0.020432278513908386, 0.006106805056333542, 0.017061099410057068, -0.012948725372552872, 0.0006615824531763792, 0.044594816863536835, -0.01203060895204544, -0.01189009565860033, -0.06306014955043793, 0.005792298354208469, 0.018720446154475212, -0.014749755151569843, -0.012071998789906502, 0.029057106003165245, -0.02092975750565529, -0.020611755549907684, -0.027074752375483513, 0.01396670751273632, 0.03973263129591942, -0.07161761820316315, -0.018963994458317757, 0.021518981084227562, -0.029525959864258766, -0.07952643930912018 ]
Visualization of dynamic processes in scientific high-performance computing is an immensely data intensive endeavor. Application codes have recently demonstrated scaling to full-size Exascale machines, and generating high-quality data for visualization is consequently on the machine-scale, easily spanning 100s of TBytes of input to generate a single video frame. In situ visualization, the technique to consume the many-node decomposed data in-memory, as exposed by applications, is the dominant workflow. Although in situ visualization has achieved tremendous progress in the last decade, scaling to system-size together with the application codes that produce its data, there is one important question that we cannot skip: is what we produce insightful and inspiring?
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00469v1
[ 0.04221832752227783, -0.035410117357969284, 0.037397462874650955, 0.002088149543851614, -0.04866975545883179, -0.034854184836149216, 0.01069396361708641, -0.046448931097984314, 0.028413651511073112, -0.05124359950423241, -0.025271834805607796, 0.03172287344932556, 0.012520305812358856, -0.03203091397881508, -0.0600152313709259, -2.1194109578459575e-8, 0.06643097847700119, -0.012016751803457737, -0.056609876453876495, 0.0658210813999176, 0.004216925706714392, 0.018331250175833702, 0.015043364837765694, -0.02724207006394863, 0.02326572872698307, -0.02549591474235058, -0.03290407359600067, 0.052374325692653656, -0.027891306206583977, -0.0016599174123257399, 0.050932012498378754, -0.04136611893773079, -0.037493012845516205, -0.034796956926584244, -0.021298836916685104, 0.0007123652612790465, -0.04547834023833275, 0.0219565536826849, -0.06087012588977814, -0.028190147131681442, 0.07699283957481384, -0.03755195811390877, -0.04146503657102585, 0.0066809686832129955, -0.018303563818335533, -0.0069158622063696384, -0.04150178283452988, 0.02956724725663662, -0.08434442430734634, 0.031750354915857315, 0.021621428430080414, -0.01812613196671009, 0.005945401731878519, 0.06283541768789291, 0.03580858185887337, -0.0396585538983345, -0.019708827137947083, -0.0005340493516996503, -0.012299943715333939, -0.017035070806741714, 0.015385757200419903, -0.029135094955563545, -0.016151389107108116, -0.037492137402296066, -0.024700144305825233, 0.060693204402923584, 0.015492482110857964, -0.06690184026956558, -0.047036197036504745, -0.062287963926792145, 0.015137091279029846, -0.06970123201608658, -0.016716724261641502, 0.014437224715948105, -0.07371396571397781, -0.010493174195289612, -0.0018411423079669476, -0.02328440733253956, -0.016121210530400276, 0.041289664804935455, -0.045613452792167664, 0.03313257545232773, 0.028630699962377548, 0.02729536034166813, -0.006327367387712002, 0.012608912773430347, 0.07045866549015045, -0.0119512639939785, 0.020174356177449226, -0.025110609829425812, 0.055614884942770004, -0.050585318356752396, -0.06900964677333832, 0.0038496435154229403, 0.07052703946828842, 0.007718478329479694, 0.0738384798169136, 0.012181369587779045, -0.015438592061400414, 0.013841829262673855, -0.0585593655705452, -0.025278765708208084, -0.01940212771296501, 0.0032961484976112843, -0.011212955228984356, -0.04917024448513985, -0.014144501648843288, -0.010798031464219093, -0.02532840147614479, 0.022535856813192368, 0.019766490906476974, -0.009248968213796616, -0.03406143933534622, -0.07783310115337372, -0.008151227608323097, -0.04466024786233902, 0.04554970934987068, 0.0057512265630066395, -0.005181971937417984, -0.019218526780605316, 0.026635853573679924, 0.03958800435066223, 0.04379669204354286, -0.043784040957689285, -0.030004791915416718, -0.01594468392431736, 0.01782820001244545, -0.035406388342380524, 0.04484475776553154, -0.00462231645360589, -0.053328774869441986, 0.004135397728532553, 0.02539387159049511, -0.008051687851548195, 0.044494885951280594, 0.030386295169591904, 0.004153205081820488, -0.048395492136478424, 0.044845107942819595, 0.031067196279764175, -0.045715704560279846, -0.04343568533658981, 0.04644535854458809, -0.03521322086453438, -0.003622769145295024, 0.007424356881529093, 0.00044399360194802284, -0.04616258665919304, 0.01127275638282299, 0.02563369646668434, -0.018629902973771095, -0.004904365632683039, 0.013363111764192581, -0.037365566939115524, -0.007436669431626797, 0.01720862090587616, 0.016764361411333084, -0.05518364906311035, -0.04704910144209862, -0.02607000060379505, 0.0031181073281913996, -0.03164026886224747, -0.0383552610874176, -0.05833534896373749, 0.05168870836496353, -0.037297822535037994, 0.03501961752772331, -0.03763855993747711, -0.02747361734509468, 0.05345461145043373, -0.0025146249681711197, -0.05564720556139946, -0.023400507867336273, -0.026215508580207825, -0.004839171189814806, -0.0019058426842093468, 0.010692315176129341, -0.05377309024333954, -0.03856487199664116, -0.036748480051755905, -0.03419645503163338, -0.02272486872971058, -0.022236807271838188, -0.04316309839487076, -0.03420596569776535, -0.04367836192250252, -0.06625035405158997, 0.009387575089931488, 0.02132352627813816, -0.02308306097984314, -0.018758287653326988, -0.0057621365413069725, -0.002205776982009411, 0.031276386231184006, 0.003659205511212349, 0.002237125998362899, 0.0061532072722911835, -0.06807222962379456, 0.01989586651325226, -0.012169578112661839, -0.0867200493812561, -0.05669553950428963, -0.03553922101855278, -0.049411483108997345, 0.015662532299757004, -0.06473002582788467, 0.021108506247401237, -0.0027144711930304766, -0.06789437681436539, 0.01497808936983347, 0.06507314741611481, 0.049437083303928375, 0.06544126570224762, 0.014117562212049961, 0.03720363602042198, -0.05666257068514824, -0.09601417183876038, 0.004309659358114004, 0.012584622018039227, -0.016475513577461243, -0.03359900414943695, 0.02826540358364582, -0.052353065460920334, -0.06354974210262299, -0.023781780153512955, 0.06822603940963745, 0.06880534440279007, 0.0263049453496933, -0.06746106594800949, 0.022311823442578316, -0.04158821702003479, -0.059742022305727005, -0.022132214158773422, -0.0765848383307457, -0.06468848139047623, -0.002367528388276696, -0.008236528374254704, 0.0423891544342041, -0.020701460540294647, -0.03871014341711998, -0.021000675857067108, -0.05732343718409538, 0.02817303128540516, -0.01625758595764637, -0.02537710778415203, -0.015351896174252033, -0.0357661247253418, 0.050783511251211166, -0.018442364409565926, -0.009900500997900963, -0.04519922658801079, -0.0418965183198452, 0.014509370550513268, -0.003574120346456766, 0.01762298122048378, 0.017750879749655724, -0.011790602467954159, 0.06000012159347534, 0.020080139860510826, 0.002477445872500539, -0.01636597327888012, -0.005300689022988081, -0.01739363558590412, 0.013686868362128735, 0.00306489784270525, -0.011701918207108974, -0.017718352377414703, 0.01252396684139967, -0.009186231531202793, -0.04515569657087326, -0.019958633929491043, 0.04205865040421486, 0.0356791727244854, 0.015239857137203217, 0.021609505638480186, -0.07306230813264847, -0.0008404846303164959, -0.01395485084503889, 0.02759629487991333, 0.05608575418591499, 0.0031745675951242447, -0.027892205864191055, -0.0035091438330709934, -0.04354235157370567, 0.008183165453374386, -0.03749409317970276, -0.03132844343781471, -0.07771553099155426, -0.05953012406826019, -0.0008972808136604726, -0.06317571550607681, -0.05215916410088539, -0.02696368098258972, -0.057836487889289856, 0.02454642951488495, -0.05889398232102394, 0.017940083518624306, -0.026020316407084465, 0.054812245070934296, 0.04721613973379135, -0.004871841985732317, -0.02472607232630253, 0.05262192711234093, 0.02759118378162384, -0.022345036268234253, -0.05234389379620552, -0.02433953806757927, -0.016204843297600746, -0.01595689170062542, -0.03917323425412178, 0.027063267305493355, 0.03619755059480667, -0.034971415996551514, 0.04142910614609718, -0.015232045203447342, -0.0010247031459584832, -0.00678795063868165, 0.03798368573188782, -0.03430917114019394, -0.0036303463857620955, -0.004435229580849409, -0.05175332725048065, -0.0026653888635337353, -0.0225748922675848, -0.004786841571331024, -0.037105411291122437, 0.015538942068815231, -0.047848958522081375, -0.07060635089874268, -0.05094937980175018, 0.003028324106708169, 0.03426596149802208, 0.0025123562663793564, 0.02814825251698494, 0.026870563626289368, 0.014499500393867493, -0.005147657822817564, -0.03246185928583145, -0.051314134150743484, 0.024007035419344902, 0.012342473492026329, 0.02410949021577835, -0.07181952893733978, -0.044079482555389404, 0.07097679376602173, -0.08691412955522537, -0.005252681206911802, 0.06682746112346649, 0.053772807121276855, -0.008325058966875076, 0.028698308393359184, 0.01358629297465086, -0.017522066831588745, -0.005787812639027834, -0.0004935501492582262, -0.054977692663669586, 0.05008718743920326, 0.06820248812437057, -0.05767971649765968, -0.01894625835120678, 0.008094210177659988, -0.07626475393772125, 0.0005976887769065797, -0.01529426034539938, 0.01581326685845852, 0.04122589901089668, 0.02303360588848591, -0.05517289415001869, -0.042792849242687225, -0.02333628199994564, 0.04989065229892731, 0.0268237441778183, -0.04920536279678345, 0.027692489326000214, -0.06718632578849792, 0.03412850573658943, 0.024884698912501335, -0.014250313863158226, 0.015228468924760818, -0.005350903142243624, 0.03364581614732742, -0.06227743625640869, 0.051158029586076736, 0.006756434217095375, -0.027808139100670815, 0.00523754395544529, 0.027694934979081154, 0.015989340841770172, 0.04051317647099495, 0.014525379985570908, -0.03416459634900093, -0.013516574166715145, 0.016437267884612083, -0.0139930360019207, 0.02962389588356018, -0.004718070849776268, 0.025237565860152245, 0.019117102026939392, -0.03271240368485451, -0.02712216228246689, -0.002372769871726632, -0.004587685689330101, -0.0003803915169555694, -0.05605136975646019, 0.012078404426574707, -0.0384744368493557, 0.042830176651477814, -0.023119894787669182, -0.0061948904767632484, 0.01926462911069393, -0.01562387216836214, 0.006738284602761269, -0.03081543557345867, -0.0015493963146582246, 0.02104506641626358, -0.01728660985827446, 0.021293267607688904, -0.07117800414562225, 0.027917100116610527, -0.019762245938181877, 0.060177214443683624, -0.00985782127827406, 0.06580926477909088, -0.01620149053633213, -0.049241770058870316, -0.026072407141327858, -0.010794819332659245, 0.05309513956308365, 0.009347198531031609, -0.08330972492694855, -0.025265872478485107, 0.027422871440649033, -0.021234732121229172, 0.002593918005004525, 0.02294745109975338, -0.01635001413524151, 0.0054933554492890835, 0.00021701044170185924, -0.042875736951828, 0.0023696538992226124, -0.036601472645998, 0.043852727860212326, -0.061160728335380554, -0.01773434691131115, 0.02754731848835945, -0.008047717623412609, -0.047847796231508255, -0.023419851437211037, -0.04976070672273636, -0.07985413819551468, -0.058943234384059906, -0.014971315860748291, 0.005273113958537579, 0.00677610095590353, 0.022465502843260765, 0.04312123358249664, 0.027891213074326515, -0.011951739899814129, 0.004346986301243305, 0.025587694719433784, 0.022305013611912727, -0.039672933518886566, -0.02754312939941883, -0.02865472622215748, -0.049353089183568954, 0.031004831194877625, 0.022389397025108337, -0.047027576714754105, 0.0203211922198534, -0.01711827889084816, 0.008423981256783009, 0.040129147469997406, -0.07675773650407791, 0.06559133529663086, 0.02461746707558632, -0.009666730649769306, 0.01999799907207489, 0.04378284513950348, 0.023619068786501884, 0.015586254186928272, -0.04363616183400154, -0.007356378715485334, -0.010107872076332569, -0.004084289073944092, -0.018895583227276802, -0.0012628596741706133, -0.03650974482297897, -0.028309596702456474, 0.036068860441446304, -0.03797753527760506, -0.03566698729991913, 0.0021857440005987883, 0.015090019442141056, 0.01635972410440445, 0.02057546377182007, 0.034583840519189835, 0.003311782144010067, -0.0006115944706834853, -0.034612804651260376, -0.020395958796143532, -0.030477432534098625, -0.052538301795721054, 0.04758639261126518, 0.012919513508677483, -0.02384660206735134, 0.032343436032533646, -0.02321968972682953, 0.022394074127078056, -0.017737368121743202, 0.03532819449901581, -0.02765742503106594, -0.0008932733908295631, -0.04849632829427719, -0.03257589414715767, -0.047141000628471375, 0.013870739378035069, -0.014664201997220516, 0.0017112981295213103, 0.00680043688043952, -0.016296565532684326, 0.020314056426286697, -0.0029982728883624077, -0.035720184445381165, 0.008160781115293503, 0.0012048626085743308, -0.01020924374461174, -0.04647645354270935, 0.05341789126396179, 0.015202837064862251, -0.012648525647819042, -0.028124677017331123, 0.03009384498000145, -0.0026691481471061707, 0.02095603384077549, -0.022021643817424774, 0.0038386941887438297, 0.028332367539405823, -0.07436374574899673, -0.035899948328733444, 0.03931871056556702, 0.020140495151281357, 0.009093196131289005, 0.043259695172309875, 0.07394354045391083, -0.04904002323746681, 0.01680615358054638, -0.019187530502676964, -0.032459329813718796, -0.03139328584074974, 0.03395545855164528, 0.01583465188741684, -0.01629420556128025, -0.01676337979733944, -0.05011942237615585, -0.02904530242085457, 0.019434882327914238, -0.022946376353502274, -0.0055635711178183556, -0.003789101494476199, -0.018255308270454407, -0.017116812989115715, 0.06770803034305573, -0.04122605174779892, -0.08196452260017395, 0.03496435657143593, 0.06039382889866829, -0.042931023985147476, -0.04250621050596237, 0.0056075649335980415, 0.042199525982141495, -0.042945746332407, 0.01582125946879387, 0.025489365682005882, -0.020749442279338837, -0.04399266839027405, 0.04273875057697296, 0.077508844435215, 0.03058609738945961, -0.021982284262776375, -0.00988589134067297, -0.061698850244283676, -0.008548114448785782, 0.0032382782083004713, 0.03402319923043251, -0.01606944017112255, 0.012383522465825081, -0.038261063396930695, -0.06092614307999611, -0.03661789000034332, 0.0578979030251503, -0.036379266530275345, -0.030675770714879036, 0.017864704132080078, 0.006309164222329855, -0.00745196221396327, -0.04210902005434036, -0.058921556919813156, 0.018860911950469017, -0.01514246966689825, -0.020628495141863823, -0.06389210373163223, 0.004549176897853613, -0.040767014026641846, -0.012927338480949402, 0.0033845435827970505, -0.07346507906913757, 0.01023508794605732, -0.009143966250121593, -0.05326341092586517, 0.036841217428445816, -0.06364824622869492, -0.03047110326588154, -0.011906431056559086, 0.018144745379686356, 0.036976657807826996, 0.06240198016166687, -0.05689653009176254, -0.037384189665317535, 0.008100667037069798, -0.01948823221027851, 0.0018307830905541778, -0.05061725527048111, 0.01670175790786743, -0.06865930557250977, 0.04983506724238396, -0.018521877005696297, -0.03771665692329407, 0.029357073828577995, -0.0040781148709356785, 0.01620723307132721, -0.0037878684233874083, -0.05447367578744888, -0.0330108106136322, -0.02809835970401764, -0.032471902668476105, -0.00287810736335814, 0.03734419867396355, -0.04859337955713272, -0.06068534031510353, -0.001490338589064777, -0.012752359732985497, -0.006883991416543722, 0.0026117214001715183, 0.03888403996825218, 0.055716924369335175, -0.06652228534221649, 0.009027517400681973, -0.008803910575807095, -0.011845013126730919, -0.013353017158806324, -0.03977474197745323, -0.04456415772438049, 0.0029768601525574923, -0.033238109201192856, -0.05311191827058792, -0.0757506787776947, -0.0008453850168734789, -0.02657506801187992, -0.02170065976679325, 0.058928847312927246, 0.044839512556791306, -0.020497437566518784, -0.04907078668475151, 0.01912052184343338, -0.009505326859652996, -0.025726361200213432, -0.07036004960536957, 0.050986431539058685, -0.01830139383673668, -0.018032658845186234, 0.06324537843465805, 0.04257220774888992, 0.015304096974432468, 0.016784820705652237, -0.07484367489814758, -0.009853514842689037, -0.01284361444413662, 0.03301452472805977, -0.00601431168615818, -0.011781463399529457, 0.01820298656821251, -0.012420179322361946, 0.0077171907760202885, 0.0438971072435379, -0.0007078273920342326, 0.017990928143262863, 0.015198562294244766, -0.060214851051568985, -0.058762501925230026, -0.009493841789662838, -0.015408624894917011, -0.030762625858187675, -0.000609840324614197, 0.028003061190247536, 0.0025292313657701015, 0.018714118748903275, -0.0011975322850048542, 0.05339917540550232, 0.005707352887839079, 0.06031538546085358, -0.04424102231860161, 0.03463536873459816, -0.02332311123609543, -0.02932005189359188, 0.04001208394765854, -0.04506096988916397, -0.008996444754302502, 0.020885109901428223, -0.029864279553294182, 0.06911583244800568, -0.015786968171596527, -0.05408589914441109, 0.002655813004821539, -0.03632825240492821, 0.024331124499440193, 0.05191587656736374, -0.047297634184360504, 0.00388603238388896, -0.04430243745446205, -0.03400039300322533, -0.046796832233667374, 0.029617341235280037, 0.05703017860651016, -0.01296620536595583, -0.013370566070079803, -0.062252629548311234, -0.023195255547761917, -0.0275052972137928, -0.012621046975255013, -0.041957467794418335, 0.04279610887169838, 0.005774079356342554, -0.014568294398486614, -0.05994032323360443, -0.024937160313129425, 0.0008041769615374506, -0.045400358736515045, -0.00020636478438973427, -0.042724497616291046, 0.050959471613168716, -0.03690086305141449, -0.018301958218216896, -0.007057050708681345, 0.022745011374354362, -0.007676979992538691, 0.012921289540827274, 0.010329987853765488, 0.02100890502333641, -0.06035596504807472, 0.06148003786802292, 0.0113129997625947, 0.05483762547373772, -0.014816726557910442, 0.023197801783680916, 0.010448514483869076, -0.06559089571237564, 0.014873676002025604, -0.03189072757959366, 0.03237612918019295, -0.07387344539165497, -0.004043715540319681, -0.030357077717781067, 0.014741526916623116, -0.04724925383925438, -0.06744115799665451, -0.004911326337605715, -0.04255406931042671, -0.06472563743591309 ]
Self-supervised learning (SSL) is at the origin of unprecedented improvements in many different domains including computer vision and natural language processing. Speech processing drastically benefitted from SSL as most of the current domain-related tasks are now being approached with pre-trained models. This work introduces LeBenchmark 2.0 an open-source framework for assessing and building SSL-equipped French speech technologies. It includes documented, large-scale and heterogeneous corpora with up to 14,000 hours of heterogeneous speech, ten pre-trained SSL wav2vec 2.0 models containing from 26 million to one billion learnable parameters shared with the community, and an evaluation protocol made of six downstream tasks to complement existing benchmarks. LeBenchmark 2.0 also presents unique perspectives on pre-trained SSL models for speech with the investigation of frozen versus fine-tuned downstream models, task-agnostic versus task-specific pre-trained models as well as a discussion on the carbon footprint of large-scale model training. Overall, the newly introduced models trained on 14,000 hours of French speech outperform multilingual and previous LeBenchmark SSL models across the benchmark but also required up to four times more energy for pre-training.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05472v2
[ -0.020708676427602768, -0.0030253627337515354, 0.0587649792432785, 0.01471587736159563, -0.016960181295871735, -0.041900116950273514, -0.04066642373800278, -0.03877084329724312, -0.00934478361159563, -0.011832434684038162, -0.035367224365472794, 0.031904932111501694, -0.03669637441635132, 0.04128372669219971, -0.07094883918762207, 0.03393141180276871, -0.00308463373221457, 0.05110938474535942, -0.04816773533821106, 0.02928621880710125, -0.006915234494954348, 0.01614871621131897, -0.01750710979104042, 0.010465661995112896, -0.0003782969724852592, -0.005950423888862133, -0.03536700829863548, 0.03113434463739395, -0.005522940773516893, -0.02601606957614422, 0.047141097486019135, -0.008210045285522938, 0.02787555381655693, -0.044698573648929596, -0.05266670882701874, -0.028806006535887718, -0.04719200357794762, 0.028183531016111374, 0.014715190976858139, -0.049792010337114334, 0.010630358010530472, -0.049430835992097855, -0.07473976165056229, 0.020356332883238792, -0.024770792573690414, 0.018658984452486038, -0.006971766706556082, 0.020031966269016266, -0.07374436408281326, -0.05149378627538681, 0.01541571319103241, 0.030843231827020645, -0.03238190710544586, 0.048139289021492004, 0.0042458707466721535, -0.03708724305033684, -0.01065303385257721, -0.005942351650446653, -0.0680159479379654, -0.021460112184286118, -0.014210209250450134, -0.04299982264637947, -0.02615155279636383, 0.011861393228173256, -0.019412841647863388, 0.07233470678329468, -0.019842129200696945, -0.020031070336699486, -0.01599961891770363, -0.05615722015500069, 0.056504249572753906, -0.04998721182346344, -0.05319412425160408, 0.03831097111105919, 0.02720167115330696, -0.038843341171741486, -0.0024729054421186447, -0.06009124964475632, -0.01965809054672718, -0.0011674066772684455, -0.01358464639633894, 0.01694651134312153, 0.003856734372675419, 0.028917375952005386, -0.020351015031337738, -0.04542452096939087, 0.013948173262178898, -0.009127822704613209, -0.00695589417591691, -0.0022917899768799543, 0.015821166336536407, -0.02006208524107933, -0.08347711712121964, 0.06554078310728073, 0.06869387626647949, 0.005690797232091427, 0.048830706626176834, 0.008857978507876396, 0.0013961830409243703, -0.014666762202978134, -0.01970815472304821, 0.04831135645508766, -0.0038625155575573444, 0.05325943976640701, 0.028430325910449028, -0.014942022040486336, 0.03760576248168945, -0.015197070315480232, -0.04551452770829201, 0.02223063074052334, -0.022326914593577385, 0.006000928580760956, 0.02449769340455532, -0.04329973831772804, -0.011890568770468235, -0.06626109033823013, 0.03471347317099571, -0.008666683919727802, 0.012941817753016949, 0.009167182259261608, -0.02078838273882866, 0.060180630534887314, 0.0671512708067894, -0.012783706188201904, 0.00005503951615537517, 0.03199663385748863, 0.05518345907330513, -0.024892471730709076, -0.04357532784342766, 0.006765132304280996, 0.0049024005420506, 0.012253755703568459, -0.0052977376617491245, -0.038993071764707565, 0.006757492199540138, 0.005896785296499729, -0.021186133846640587, -0.027480347082018852, -0.027181565761566162, -0.05767246335744858, -0.028261948376893997, -0.08062618970870972, -0.00548190763220191, -0.03541015088558197, 0.03564026579260826, 0.037526194006204605, -0.05765513703227043, -0.030345803126692772, -0.012722685001790524, -0.013191573321819305, -0.006062997505068779, 0.030119754374027252, 0.012088445015251637, -0.006212457083165646, -0.0027679800987243652, -0.034823883324861526, 0.0326894074678421, -0.0229983851313591, -0.050361331552267075, 0.04013380408287048, -0.024126682430505753, -0.04941107705235481, -0.012821225449442863, -0.05563989654183388, 0.046841997653245926, 0.010758218355476856, 0.027225647121667862, -0.00497798016294837, -0.00463132606819272, 0.016871504485607147, -0.06241545081138611, -0.006226023659110069, -0.01261881273239851, 0.020998185500502586, -0.06224235147237778, -0.01849525235593319, 0.05744972079992294, -0.029384983703494072, -0.040102485567331314, -0.03781173378229141, -0.012625417672097683, 0.06477311253547668, -0.0036210091784596443, -0.03229830041527748, -0.0794701874256134, 0.013056263327598572, -0.05479338392615318, 0.03305146470665932, 0.04071233421564102, 0.002013320801779628, -0.043482664972543716, -0.0008498489041812718, -0.031565748155117035, -0.0008913864730857313, -0.024242382496595383, -0.03922911360859871, -0.019735919311642647, -0.05880076065659523, -0.05354820191860199, 0.039915431290864944, -0.08530431985855103, -0.022055650129914284, -0.07017561793327332, -0.04022235423326492, 0.039303943514823914, -0.06573958694934845, 0.005922721698880196, 0.06482389569282532, -0.02293848618865013, 0.007740403059870005, 0.0232100673019886, 0.04890410974621773, 0.07491723448038101, 0.03267386183142662, 0.025878682732582092, 0.014559028670191765, -0.10186411440372467, 0.07051235437393188, 0.002188735641539097, 0.008063528686761856, 0.04255044087767601, 0.05747256800532341, -0.030752671882510185, 0.007184007670730352, -0.030478021129965782, 0.024567602202296257, 0.03878258541226387, -0.041503239423036575, -0.057605043053627014, -0.026291845366358757, 0.010734869167208672, -0.03920406475663185, -0.012073598802089691, -0.06804288923740387, -0.03068949468433857, 0.0009896314004436135, -0.022990118712186813, 0.011293693445622921, -0.028965367004275322, -0.011665891855955124, -0.03170427307486534, -0.028381450101733208, 0.02807031013071537, -0.02254517376422882, -0.06309930235147476, -0.021688928827643394, -0.008554859086871147, 0.02133774757385254, -0.011487668380141258, -0.04733970761299133, -0.039626963436603546, -0.0038679479621350765, -0.04098418354988098, 0.003981930203735828, -0.02136179246008396, 0.04090665653347969, -0.0272466242313385, 0.03964812308549881, 0.02230355702340603, 0.004293867386877537, 0.03712688386440277, 0.05913807451725006, -0.050592921674251556, 0.01045770850032568, 0.03598763793706894, -0.01864437572658062, -0.01800917461514473, -0.007292743772268295, -0.04546442627906799, 0.00004761335003422573, -0.036997564136981964, 0.06885043531656265, 0.06857554614543915, -0.011928016319870949, -0.046630967408418655, -0.036234159022569656, 0.01882180944085121, 0.019154956564307213, 0.019586218520998955, 0.055681806057691574, 0.0032315589487552643, 0.027185576036572456, 0.03280864283442497, -0.04379584640264511, -0.000264612928731367, -0.04100412130355835, -0.06626507639884949, -0.05620555952191353, -0.03449953719973564, -0.056017935276031494, -0.05937797203660011, -0.018023045733571053, 0.01670192927122116, -0.002030872041359544, -0.00026361728669144213, -0.05600232630968094, 0.0084190983325243, -0.0431697852909565, 0.026464633643627167, -0.036937493830919266, -0.0332765206694603, -0.01802753657102585, 0.0088777095079422, 0.04895099997520447, -0.013749566860496998, -0.03194567188620567, -0.025915028527379036, -0.02721673995256424, 0.010714130476117134, 0.01921292394399643, -0.035849492996931076, 0.03216461092233658, -0.006646515801548958, 0.03908787667751312, 0.04181797802448273, 0.039973434060811996, 0.005703249480575323, 0.03346728906035423, -0.019668277353048325, -0.03164590895175934, -0.007350872736424208, -0.01852559857070446, -0.03966900333762169, -0.04395589604973793, -0.019603019580245018, -0.06116054207086563, 0.04678874835371971, 0.0007858559256419539, -0.011981556192040443, -0.026054231449961662, -0.019141526892781258, 0.03389072045683861, -0.014056715182960033, 0.014033148996531963, 0.04535088688135147, 0.019671233370900154, 0.015356030315160751, -0.0039244722574949265, -0.01547445822507143, -0.05972181633114815, -0.045295074582099915, -0.041900839656591415, -0.025402503088116646, -0.04339483380317688, 0.05235879495739937, -0.07917004823684692, 0.028239188715815544, 0.061041209846735, 0.06262291967868805, -0.06422346085309982, -0.026675859466195107, -0.0011082601267844439, 0.02137596160173416, 0.0072900643572211266, -0.02016816847026348, 0.04315018281340599, 0.05926167964935303, 0.0494292750954628, -0.034611523151397705, 0.01216362789273262, 0.05546163395047188, -0.06911533325910568, -0.07099206745624542, -0.01515468955039978, 0.020427001640200615, 0.026450663805007935, 0.00675239646807313, -0.03523356840014458, -0.014298412017524242, 0.0017784155206754804, 0.04382787644863129, -0.02588719315826893, -0.07748495787382126, -0.011880804784595966, -0.05751650407910347, 0.01918110065162182, 0.036783598363399506, -0.033787403255701065, 0.011223881505429745, -0.009295297786593437, 0.025310859084129333, -0.06425915658473969, 0.027509871870279312, 0.004185208585113287, 0.005394269246608019, -0.0027480153366923332, 0.04830459877848625, 0.013978810980916023, 0.025992972776293755, -0.01876373030245304, -0.0317404568195343, 0.00926752295345068, -0.025865325704216957, -0.036775730550289154, -0.030855003744363785, -0.012755973264575005, -0.01443553902208805, 0.04209383577108383, -0.0005598702118732035, -0.034883059561252594, 0.05915145203471184, -0.00027288906858302653, 0.031067974865436554, -0.07756847143173218, -0.04141325131058693, -0.04054723680019379, 0.0312974639236927, -0.02197042852640152, -0.06173362582921982, 0.06944046914577484, -0.043195806443691254, -0.015351112931966782, 0.029058992862701416, -0.007532395422458649, -0.05349544808268547, -0.0656108409166336, 0.02026410587131977, -0.06090737134218216, 0.06424028426408768, -0.07158587127923965, 0.07029324024915695, -0.03894297033548355, -0.007051366381347179, -0.016550038009881973, -0.042821887880563736, -0.017987534403800964, 0.0287705659866333, 0.04810306057333946, 0.061674587428569794, -0.024733254685997963, -0.01646830327808857, 0.041478224098682404, 0.019017936661839485, -0.025284234434366226, 0.028798822313547134, 0.007384081836789846, 0.021382566541433334, 0.018730483949184418, 0.0031643365509808064, 0.014257499016821384, 0.02271503396332264, -0.006354316137731075, -0.04427609220147133, -0.00028515252051874995, 0.02658957615494728, 0.039096761494874954, 0.00759799312800169, -0.0624464713037014, -0.027466872707009315, -0.030858268961310387, -0.012939870357513428, -0.009381599724292755, 0.03605504706501961, 0.007500327657908201, 0.0018424531444907188, 0.03367350623011589, 0.04938981682062149, -0.0000903113468666561, 0.002721393946558237, 0.04079398512840271, 0.009302607737481594, -0.0365096814930439, -0.008316591382026672, -0.032093729823827744, -0.05498812720179558, 0.02548559382557869, -0.015014694072306156, -0.03277815505862236, -0.04639928415417671, 0.0319635234773159, 0.012437948025763035, 0.04757005348801613, -0.08463995158672333, -0.009145459160208702, 0.03894396871328354, -0.04761780425906181, -0.02016664855182171, 0.045181747525930405, 0.023055819794535637, 0.0318647138774395, -0.038569413125514984, 0.024573996663093567, -0.008917760103940964, 0.008517907932400703, -0.003569323569536209, 0.029780661687254906, -0.03772490471601486, -0.003825737629085779, 0.028192291036248207, -0.0017570477211847901, 0.02191801369190216, 0.019957788288593292, 0.06735673546791077, -0.009819213300943375, -0.026216547936201096, 0.04062487185001373, 0.07014255970716476, -0.014341515488922596, 0.0031733852811157703, -0.046646200120449066, 0.04522276669740677, 0.00048005933058448136, 0.04357885196805, -0.01934444159269333, -0.03685788810253143, 0.007495997007936239, -0.02851051092147827, 0.01694628968834877, 0.0539950430393219, 0.013894918374717236, 0.005248120985925198, -0.004664101172238588, -0.03683782368898392, -0.03538910672068596, -0.024088509380817413, -0.056219179183244705, 0.00871734693646431, 0.028602145612239838, 0.02129465527832508, 0.0377778634428978, -0.019092127680778503, 0.012955001555383205, -0.021265875548124313, -0.004705657716840506, -0.06753642112016678, 0.0527074970304966, -0.029321899637579918, -0.005612883251160383, -0.033134981989860535, 0.024982701987028122, -0.003778610145673156, 0.08063936978578568, -0.00045585943735204637, 0.014956707134842873, -0.014514612033963203, -0.00000958097825787263, 0.012025228701531887, -0.08347398787736893, 0.01637747325003147, -0.014550470747053623, 0.03817930445075035, -0.03321780264377594, 0.043019022792577744, -0.0010640547843649983, 0.03760208189487457, 0.05196480080485344, 0.06422527879476547, -0.027975285425782204, -0.0259413905441761, -0.02541879378259182, 0.057318635284900665, -0.03151039779186249, 0.03556966781616211, -0.055156100541353226, -0.023102782666683197, -0.0035865348763763905, -0.030086230486631393, 0.02363215759396553, 0.03200601041316986, -0.022989099845290184, -0.013327754102647305, 0.07753314077854156, -0.01656738668680191, -0.06987833231687546, 0.03525860235095024, 0.01861504651606083, -0.02978714369237423, 0.006244091782718897, -0.004576372914016247, -0.009231645613908768, -0.011874985881149769, 0.03738626092672348, 0.037046197801828384, 0.027314135804772377, -0.03176482021808624, 0.06923245638608932, 0.05278496444225311, -0.010035176761448383, -0.038484785705804825, 0.0068307919427752495, -0.03671780228614807, -0.007642705459147692, -0.03531214967370033, -0.07072949409484863, 0.04204774647951126, 0.008342568762600422, 0.03673708438873291, -0.048666637390851974, 0.006009125150740147, 0.03432105854153633, -0.013204926624894142, 0.033861998468637466, -0.00878933072090149, -0.004854262340813875, 0.038622621446847916, -0.039076752960681915, -0.02026747353374958, 0.007372086402028799, -0.05533348023891449, 0.03656855225563049, -0.01043759472668171, -0.014980614185333252, -0.011437226086854935, 0.021350597962737083, 0.00019190891180187464, -0.07771645486354828, 0.032292287796735764, -0.036000147461891174, -0.08196105808019638, 0.014336684718728065, -0.020825069397687912, -0.021462680771946907, -0.04406417906284332, -0.004560848698019981, -0.013155653141438961, 0.027068203315138817, -0.04275919124484062, -0.06666123867034912, -0.022741135209798813, 0.009351499378681183, -0.01878024823963642, -0.037660837173461914, -0.02219993807375431, -0.07205308973789215, 0.01077942457050085, -0.024532487615942955, -0.007370606530457735, 0.029201457276940346, -0.0821428969502449, -0.003271147608757019, 0.04931773617863655, -0.047062139958143234, -0.027567869052290916, 0.0061531043611466885, -0.02050662413239479, 0.019431106746196747, 0.0461895689368248, -0.03984600678086281, -0.027990797534585, -0.01191730983555317, 0.03631136566400528, -0.0010965762194246054, 0.010805089958012104, 0.03800046071410179, 0.008547700010240078, -0.04135870561003685, -0.016699111089110374, -0.04383969306945801, -0.00788719579577446, 0.04352174699306488, -0.06376919895410538, -0.01760317012667656, 0.007629406172782183, -0.04852653294801712, -0.03514180704951286, -0.02146177366375923, 0.042945172637701035, -0.037349410355091095, -0.00969882495701313, 0.0605577751994133, 0.016186514869332314, -0.009173956699669361, -0.04995381087064743, 0.0014579041162505746, 0.0003088200755883008, -0.019003843888640404, -0.04393121600151062, 0.012677011080086231, -0.0411253497004509, -0.05458657443523407, -0.029725024476647377, -0.0027154453564435244, -0.02308998443186283, 0.0025260450784116983, -0.08278724551200867, -0.036588478833436966, -0.022891145199537277, 0.020064443349838257, 0.021472038701176643, -0.02610713243484497, 0.0043699853122234344, -0.05235134810209274, -0.003506858367472887, 0.007087433245033026, -0.04183822125196457, -0.03281506896018982, -0.013876549899578094, 0.029437009245157242, -0.05607158690690994, 0.00019502840586937964, 0.054759398102760315, -0.014210764318704605, -0.06239957734942436, 0.023481035605072975, 0.008264413103461266, -0.02173728682100773, -0.007810752838850021, 0.0454707108438015, -0.045901812613010406, 0.02619556151330471, -0.051568806171417236, -0.049059316515922546, -0.06147881597280502, -0.043024856597185135, -0.0020515858195722103, -0.05339673161506653, 0.0320347435772419, 0.01832362450659275, -0.05260798707604408, 0.021396564319729805, -0.05126871168613434, -0.04626500606536865, -0.026079516857862473, -0.05179070308804512, -0.005228412803262472, 0.06011117622256279, -0.03131600469350815, -0.0171122495085001, -0.004718546289950609, 0.003683579619973898, -0.05119618400931358, 0.05965667590498924, 0.07724512368440628, -0.045009348541498184, -0.00031320255948230624, -0.04152311012148857, -0.006349412724375725, -0.03457142412662506, 0.039691973477602005, -0.006026054732501507, 0.06983654201030731, 0.01323570404201746, 0.008577561937272549, -0.048421476036310196, -0.041078194975852966, -0.010251197963953018, -0.07121644169092178, -0.0271611288189888, -0.04445075988769531, 0.031852900981903076, -0.034761086106300354, -0.014020919799804688, -0.0006788308965042233, 0.034499041736125946, 0.009111047722399235, -0.005064484663307667, 0.015753403306007385, 0.0444628931581974, -0.023930206894874573, 0.05964027717709541, 0.0009367178427055478, -0.010711651295423508, -0.031912222504615784, 0.05624539032578468, 0.02113725058734417, 0.0059053609147667885, -0.039313822984695435, -0.00824731308966875, 0.06380109488964081, -0.030527900904417038, -0.01372034102678299, -0.00020605781173799187, -0.0061029731296002865, -0.045523639768362045, -0.05006013810634613, 0.02910875529050827, -0.01899966411292553, -0.031144391745328903 ]
In this paper we consider stationary states of the SSH model for infinite polyacetylene chains that are homoclinic or heteroclinic connections between two-periodic dimerized states. We prove that such connections converge exponentially fast to the corresponding asymptotic periodic states.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00145v1
[ -0.0585002638399601, 0.008237699046730995, 0.050221677869558334, -0.02378574013710022, 0.031472884118556976, -0.018092213198542595, 0.0017334350850433111, 0.006643406581133604, -0.01755012385547161, 0.0016350520309060812, 0.02686852216720581, -0.0024060788564383984, -0.018628627061843872, -0.054406408220529556, 0.01362644974142313, 0.0014595771208405495, 0.022717924788594246, 0.044155996292829514, -0.017197810113430023, 0.01593681424856186, -0.0667317658662796, -0.023373104631900787, -0.034302957355976105, -0.011737512424588203, -0.0678950622677803, -0.06336051225662231, -0.05190528929233551, 0.007565611507743597, -0.05904606357216835, 0.013997763395309448, -0.01876520738005638, -0.013832868076860905, -0.02221415750682354, -0.05131079629063606, 0.007975631393492222, -0.020812682807445526, 0.04062790423631668, 0.024334382265806198, 0.04789295792579651, 0.0032368379179388285, -0.03737489506602287, -0.06922559440135956, -0.052720874547958374, 0.0022281662095338106, 0.03449729457497597, 0.030720775946974754, -0.04211955890059471, -0.023149807006120682, -0.02982279285788536, -0.05425544083118439, 0.02048935554921627, -0.0071076019667088985, 0.002028466435149312, -0.00839162152260542, -0.055941805243492126, -0.04288684204220772, 0.01646781899034977, 0.04699757695198059, -0.05740814283490181, -0.019688069820404053, -0.06182162091135979, -0.039730317890644073, 0.015084569342434406, -0.011444651521742344, 0.01161146629601717, 0.03177328407764435, 0.00788616482168436, -0.059001050889492035, -0.008107938803732395, -0.039495084434747696, 0.038785114884376526, 0.031610824167728424, -0.012496355921030045, -0.04002514109015465, -0.05833201855421066, 0.03930997475981712, 0.003966795280575752, 0.011734693311154842, 0.015113073401153088, 0.020389309152960777, -0.01739269495010376, 0.06003453582525253, -0.028778817504644394, -0.011499564163386822, 0.02567525953054428, 0.0064698634669184685, 0.0038272819947451353, -0.005831767339259386, -0.051845353096723557, -0.03788237273693085, -0.05670666694641113, 0.025573883205652237, -0.04370283707976341, -0.011702231131494045, 0.043801046907901764, -0.04635388031601906, 0.04837251827120781, 0.04626386612653732, 0.010886704549193382, 0.026152903214097023, -0.032531097531318665, -0.042446114122867584, -0.05262210965156555, 0.023751040920615196, -0.012135705910623074, 0.01888132281601429, -0.015633277595043182, 0.0174655020236969, -0.05074640363454819, -0.00027704148669727147, -0.049002449959516525, -0.003901237389072776, 0.0008714311406947672, -0.05430165305733681, -0.04307492822408676, -0.05609912425279617, -0.022434769198298454, -0.027133041992783546, 0.023038694635033607, 0.02202448435127735, -0.004158403258770704, 0.049005959182977676, -0.02640639804303646, -0.010332750156521797, -0.03749040514230728, -0.03627927228808403, 0.02202380634844303, 0.039047785103321075, -0.06080527976155281, -0.02528241276741028, -0.02050897665321827, -0.004999777302145958, 0.040345825254917145, -0.0010645920410752296, 0.037260230630636215, -0.05358779430389404, 0.055261969566345215, 0.014432656578719616, -0.04865702614188194, -0.0021860115230083466, -0.048251789063215256, -0.05483090877532959, -0.04731963574886322, 0.025275707244873047, 0.010806362144649029, 0.006916081067174673, -0.06190819293260574, 0.005033979192376137, 0.052098557353019714, 0.013889324851334095, 0.01238291710615158, 0.03201723098754883, 0.03896041214466095, -0.01756446249783039, 0.015881309285759926, -0.04863801226019859, 0.030397558584809303, -0.0058372667990624905, -0.06907333433628082, -0.0037950787227600813, -0.01798425242304802, -0.0047617037780582905, -0.0038122530095279217, 0.0029579109977930784, 0.01375351008027792, -0.004322563763707876, -0.03219697251915932, -0.04109509289264679, -0.03685770928859711, -0.05652089789509773, 0.020830335095524788, 0.019586751237511635, 0.030415695160627365, -0.03698442876338959, -0.03934694454073906, -0.03736216947436333, -0.02530410885810852, -0.060393620282411575, -0.05849393084645271, -0.0254497192800045, 0.02679240144789219, 0.015532409772276878, -0.03603626787662506, -0.058835819363594055, -0.0445856973528862, 0.02184346318244934, -0.06201903522014618, 0.0027320522349327803, 0.04155055806040764, -0.04356918856501579, 0.007730722427368164, -0.04133281484246254, -0.024506201967597008, 0.008348211646080017, -0.04804922267794609, -0.06673641502857208, 0.03513704612851143, -0.04532064497470856, -0.06253287941217422, 0.048392198979854584, -0.05902530997991562, 0.02210959605872631, 0.032372862100601196, -0.018946606665849686, -0.015080579556524754, -0.0012679101200774312, 0.03441577032208443, 0.023797981441020966, -0.06243050843477249, -0.02233114279806614, 0.01702165976166725, 0.03744702413678169, 0.006574433296918869, -0.0019306275062263012, -0.004728005267679691, 0.035007577389478683, -0.07482952624559402, 0.029416190460324287, -0.04922354593873024, 0.013372259214520454, 0.015321667306125164, 0.007304694969207048, -0.009418042376637459, 0.0346042662858963, -0.050916846841573715, 0.0414314791560173, 0.05551430583000183, 0.04881255701184273, -0.0166966263204813, -0.0025304125156253576, -0.054185785353183746, -0.06026703119277954, -0.029117602854967117, -0.06031319871544838, -0.01293148472905159, -0.04635365679860115, -0.06588137149810791, 0.029336784034967422, -0.04133683070540428, -0.02429167926311493, -0.013336611911654472, -0.043005041778087616, 0.017730986699461937, -0.06763029098510742, -0.036917418241500854, -0.02912016771733761, -0.04791569337248802, 0.048203181475400925, 0.0504148006439209, -0.04732213169336319, 0.042906831949949265, -0.06774351745843887, -0.054815199226140976, -0.022468145936727524, 0.027911795303225517, 0.04833607003092766, -0.03761667013168335, 0.021939052268862724, -0.050939228385686874, 0.014145578257739544, 0.0006728341104462743, -0.011571817100048065, -0.05446101725101471, -0.041744913905858994, -0.033453814685344696, 0.0019185488345101476, -0.04198305308818817, -0.03700273856520653, -0.058568719774484634, -0.04719748720526695, 0.044827546924352646, 0.01934169977903366, 0.03756553679704666, -0.0031611286103725433, 0.0294939111918211, 0.0037263906560838223, 0.027545694261789322, -0.030454862862825394, 0.02724628895521164, -0.018250489607453346, 0.048954077064991, 0.0009806131711229682, -0.05502014979720116, -0.043654073029756546, 0.005130101460963488, -0.019106505438685417, -0.025325139984488487, 0.027192475274205208, -0.010492938570678234, -0.03424892574548721, -0.06614092737436295, 0.002961203921586275, 0.007388178259134293, 0.036737795919179916, -0.04288752004504204, -0.048546601086854935, -0.028545590117573738, -0.0029553344938904047, -0.019958442077040672, -0.040763307362794876, -0.04357893764972687, -0.06927330791950226, 0.019909365102648735, 0.017579277977347374, -0.009583496488630772, -0.06097559258341789, -0.04075658321380615, -0.06604430079460144, -0.027560142800211906, -0.06365429610013962, -0.035341519862413406, -0.052565157413482666, -0.048515766859054565, -0.034474655985832214, -0.05454302206635475, 0.04910820722579956, 0.019210416823625565, -0.03512946143746376, 0.00452902028337121, 0.023279080167412758, 0.032142508774995804, -0.03339971601963043, -0.05321121960878372, -0.03173668682575226, -0.04713300243020058, -0.021913301199674606, 0.05586942285299301, 0.04546188935637474, -0.037126071751117706, 0.029182791709899902, 0.022047411650419235, -0.06892424821853638, -0.0009191842982545495, -0.0018667472759261727, 0.059079788625240326, -0.03469711169600487, -0.010243145748972893, 0.060415174812078476, -0.02376599796116352, 0.05244218930602074, -0.030520766973495483, 0.03438962250947952, 0.024234242737293243, -0.03640153259038925, -0.05458051711320877, -0.04310052841901779, -0.027149148285388947, -0.002675105584785342, 0.005828486289829016, -0.02825319580733776, -0.06778288632631302, 0.011600805446505547, -0.0038333807606250048, -0.004512145183980465, -0.004882208537310362, 0.0072646960616111755, -0.032637592405080795, 0.014308790676295757, -0.04200124368071556, 0.033238817006349564, 0.012843594886362553, -0.037940435111522675, -0.059121280908584595, -0.002792093437165022, -0.043915972113609314, -0.022835932672023773, -0.051333237439394, -0.010160267353057861, 0.0021163607016205788, -0.03739069402217865, 0.06421907991170883, -0.013443073257803917, 0.011060916818678379, -0.0256766676902771, -0.04358970746397972, -0.046520549803972244, 0.013273021206259727, 0.037716977298259735, -0.027722641825675964, -0.05401105806231499, 0.019928839057683945, -0.05254777520895004, -0.031629446893930435, 0.0419808030128479, -0.011446279473602772, 0.019799603149294853, 0.014006770215928555, 0.0021673408336937428, -0.036905303597450256, -0.04334792122244835, 0.028245020657777786, -0.05974764749407768, -0.05115137994289398, 0.0036640940234065056, -0.0365973599255085, -0.05269630625844002, -0.008630357682704926, -0.0593545101583004, -0.0016380073502659798, 0.005762514658272266, 0.03875618427991867, -0.05986664071679115, -0.003588421968743205, -0.07135380804538727, -0.058146268129348755, 0.005384508520364761, 0.013448099605739117, 0.030269866809248924, -0.047168560326099396, 0.0438573993742466, 0.019363924860954285, -0.00037531295674853027, -0.03929224610328674, -0.026972979307174683, -0.03945997357368469, -0.016393838450312614, -0.027172299101948738, -0.006242835894227028, 0.028745058923959732, -0.057258326560258865, -0.05655037611722946, -0.02888464741408825, -0.011485160328447819, -0.04251379519701004, 0.006373536307364702, 0.04992833733558655, -0.01384907029569149, 0.03928997740149498, -0.02542298287153244, -0.01973658800125122, -0.03722962364554405, -0.0010905881645157933, -0.019677061587572098, -0.028687644749879837, -0.0010517367627471685, -0.04521677643060684, 0.03128083050251007, -0.040085840970277786, -0.06501015275716782, -0.0027039300184696913, 0.020543428137898445, 0.034596122801303864, -0.03130859136581421, -0.02442351169884205, -0.006625060923397541, 0.06305482238531113, -0.022371992468833923, -0.047962091863155365, 0.04596438631415367, -0.04185943678021431, -0.06328665465116501, -0.0072289640083909035, 0.033689264208078384, -0.0005826796987093985, -0.056798506528139114, -0.03624974563717842, -0.042708877474069595, -0.011970684863626957, -0.03342115879058838, 0.04042714089155197, -0.03348264470696449, 0.012418542988598347, -0.022559156641364098, -0.0015150952385738492, -0.024912286549806595, -0.06570315361022949, -0.005875305738300085, 0.013089058920741081, -0.05076592415571213, 0.03243621811270714, -0.03771191090345383, -0.027689162641763687, -0.06832192838191986, 0.02928098477423191, -0.02822255529463291, -0.0066887871362268925, -0.02681860886514187, -0.015905307605862617, -0.027077363803982735, 0.0255423616617918, -0.039857130497694016, -0.021163973957300186, -0.032028138637542725, -0.02682401053607464, -0.00923194456845522, 0.02749103307723999, -0.0240249615162611, -0.013472309336066246, -0.04249957203865051, -0.040854886174201965, -0.027981873601675034, -0.043990038335323334, -0.03480062633752823, 0.013811725191771984, -0.035166800022125244, -0.04861955717206001, 0.0193177480250597, -0.04206382855772972, -0.010211522690951824, -0.012009039521217346, 0.018084360286593437, 0.035469941794872284, -0.008877800777554512, -0.05407389998435974, -0.002979862969368696, 0.06421846151351929, -0.03529791161417961, -0.00604973966255784, 0.05187859386205673, 0.00830214936286211, -0.023287471383810043, -0.0463409386575222, -0.0005366833065636456, -0.03535955399274826, 0.032263170927762985, -0.06416802853345871, -0.029185444116592407, -0.06275607645511627, -0.04568694159388542, -0.0032378053292632103, 0.007231516297906637, 0.010032867081463337, -0.06181033328175545, -0.026337265968322754, -0.018728896975517273, -0.05761731043457985, -0.004259850829839706, -0.04658554494380951, 0.0159904882311821, 0.05076449364423752, -0.012951468117535114, -0.00920748058706522, 0.021827561780810356, -0.027915965765714645, -0.04948781058192253, 0.0017179956194013357, -0.02824442647397518, -0.04668999835848808, -0.06593727320432663, -0.030167169868946075, 0.030766382813453674, -0.01904927007853985, 0.03588760644197464, -0.00113305461127311, 0.03463556244969368, 0.009506477043032646, -0.03100220300257206, -0.006578751839697361, -0.03988097608089447, -0.025078529492020607, 0.06554476171731949, -0.060240164399147034, 0.04927695542573929, -0.05401262268424034, -0.005487347021698952, 0.01740766502916813, -0.023748278617858887, -0.006121136713773012, 0.06285775452852249, -0.026573913171887398, -0.04112650081515312, -0.028959080576896667, 0.0060701132752001286, -0.045261092483997345, -0.06476987898349762, 0.003053252585232258, 0.015632571652531624, -0.02799060195684433, -0.024237891659140587, -0.030975379049777985, -0.01924309693276882, -0.003526936052367091, 0.01606939546763897, 0.0002470414328854531, 0.0036006569862365723, 0.029127493500709534, -0.03202836588025093, -0.01867547072470188, -0.05240669474005699, -0.03365517035126686, -0.032080184668302536, -0.051213983446359634, -0.05772244557738304, -0.047350216656923294, 0.05796528980135918, 0.030972249805927277, -0.0656924843788147, -0.03207850828766823, -0.011960216797888279, 0.02842474728822708, -0.07143153995275497, -0.01776331104338169, -0.018536381423473358, 0.003166785929352045, 0.02929522842168808, -0.02620677277445793, 0.03751087933778763, -0.015089022926986217, 0.036746710538864136, -0.038746096193790436, -0.034762851893901825, 0.02425069734454155, -0.04399029165506363, -0.014964058995246887, 0.00982341356575489, 0.03428981453180313, -0.04156229645013809, 0.017345238476991653, -0.05174301192164421, 0.005437039770185947, 0.02046479657292366, -0.04904179275035858, -0.057155679911375046, 0.00242498517036438, -0.031824126839637756, 0.01576446183025837, -0.01797541417181492, 0.004973352421075106, -0.032838836312294006, 0.007303612772375345, -0.047971904277801514, 0.04023345932364464, -0.007855268195271492, -0.0011635221308097243, 0.056532375514507294, -0.05895625054836273, 0.015640923753380775, -0.04513150081038475, -0.06988026946783066, 0.0320102833211422, -0.014687033370137215, -0.045814916491508484, -0.02519882470369339, 0.008475425653159618, -0.06424402445554733, -0.008357659913599491, -0.024884101003408432, -0.04860707372426987, -0.060982268303632736, -0.02761251851916313, -0.02801198698580265, -0.050902705639600754, 0.032778434455394745, -0.06490567326545715, -0.05436912924051285, -0.016845354810357094, -0.008940481580793858, 0.05362208932638168, 0.015518655069172382, -0.035969823598861694, -0.01572963036596775, -0.041782576590776443, 0.05380371958017349, 0.03255131468176842, -0.015334785915911198, -0.04245317727327347, -0.04992865025997162, -0.054100509732961655, 0.02301749214529991, 0.0273070577532053, -0.0337512381374836, -0.04154536500573158, -0.02649952471256256, -0.015960892662405968, 0.004516568034887314, -0.05393550172448158, -0.06407514959573746, -0.022937661036849022, 0.03650713339447975, -0.010064907371997833, -0.05864334478974342, 0.05008775368332863, -0.04882071912288666, -0.05026634410023689, -0.052783191204071045, -0.038474325090646744, -0.047356706112623215, 0.0290977843105793, 0.060159627348184586, 0.01440273504704237, -0.030222218483686447, -0.014024357311427593, 0.019118107855319977, -0.018200678750872612, -0.01951720379292965, -0.010680703446269035, 0.029928352683782578, -0.015884442254900932, -0.0455390140414238, -0.06725205481052399, 0.03261955454945564, -0.011651672422885895, -0.041283100843429565, 0.061316851526498795, 0.030398448929190636, -0.039816856384277344, -0.0027959230355918407, -0.018726224079728127, -0.007249829359352589, -0.017853662371635437, 0.0025272234342992306, 0.006550093647092581, -0.0601038821041584, -0.05102171748876572, 0.03490555286407471, -0.06680892407894135, 0.047536928206682205, -0.01564602740108967, -0.004443954676389694, -0.03289365768432617, -0.008476546965539455, -0.02787473052740097, -0.03756444528698921, 0.021113399416208267, 0.03294089064002037, -0.02010674588382244, -0.06047552824020386, 0.01768495701253414, 0.046669572591781616, 0.020738370716571808, -0.048734311014413834, 0.026647647842764854, 0.021899046376347542, 0.036760881543159485, -0.0014338205801323056, -0.04896818473935127, 0.024126846343278885, -0.017330266535282135, 0.012031957507133484, 0.02033921144902706, 0.018445909023284912, -0.05582530051469803, 0.0054658446460962296, -0.023531530052423477, -0.032880764454603195, -0.041318487375974655, -0.05862094834446907, -0.0021533994004130363, 0.021441426128149033, -0.01534235943108797, 0.022491784766316414, 0.04312118515372276, -0.016841478645801544, 0.0216568224132061, -0.0030324119143188, 0.02348024770617485, -0.0019043982028961182, -0.0604267343878746, -0.0630030706524849, -0.01275069359689951, 0.02230023965239525, 0.022709999233484268, -0.050330884754657745, 0.033949535340070724, -0.01645345613360405, -0.05088459327816963, -0.0605512335896492, -0.0117057329043746, -0.053036753088235855, -0.046881306916475296, -0.02855750173330307, 0.011314286850392818, 0.022701911628246307, -0.045368440449237823, 0.02950749546289444, -0.03924247995018959, -0.02202223427593708, -0.0416422002017498 ]
This paper proposes a multi-spectral random forest classifier with suitable feature selection and masking for tree cover estimation in urban areas. The key feature of the proposed classifier is filtering out the built-up region using spectral indices followed by random forest classification on the remaining mask with carefully selected features. Using Sentinel-2 satellite imagery, we evaluate the performance of the proposed technique on a specified area (approximately 82 acres) of Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) and demonstrate that our method outperforms a conventional random forest classifier as well as state-of-the-art methods such as European Space Agency (ESA) WorldCover 10m 2020 product as well as a DeepLabv3 deep learning architecture.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06073v1
[ -0.0020241569727659225, -0.026722501963377, 0.039672158658504486, 0.042120713740587234, -0.028519470244646072, -0.01835542544722557, -0.03248501569032669, -0.021225906908512115, 0.016919119283556938, -0.011533302254974842, -0.023223236203193665, 0.008653045631945133, -0.039952393621206284, 0.004414968658238649, -0.06274278461933136, 0.047447919845581055, 0.012891998514533043, -0.027731355279684067, -0.030401678755879402, 0.07774874567985535, 0.049068644642829895, 0.021835807710886, -0.02278926409780979, 0.00141411111690104, 0.036850400269031525, -0.008989466354250908, -0.045154303312301636, 0.002010686555877328, -0.006365050561726093, -0.002883560722693801, 0.058439724147319794, -0.0015912556555122137, -0.04928368330001831, -0.013118797913193703, -0.013693397864699364, 0.01196062657982111, 0.00839777197688818, 0.014974752441048622, 0.013322047889232635, -0.033274099230766296, 0.011840925551950932, 0.017490683123469353, -0.04651647433638573, -0.0030239562038332224, -0.02882373332977295, 0.02260930836200714, -0.05937981233000755, 0.012350368313491344, -0.061023954302072525, -0.06339739263057709, 0.028450611978769302, -0.039630189538002014, -0.027549568563699722, 0.04067616164684296, 0.0046903640031814575, 0.0020237865392118692, -0.012442761100828648, -0.03424425423145294, -0.041566092520952225, 0.05233234167098999, 0.04779062420129776, -0.059689342975616455, -0.03386273235082626, 0.010482385754585266, 0.022154539823532104, 0.06503105163574219, -0.0019431083928793669, -0.08275176584720612, -0.014542114920914173, -0.019495336338877678, 0.0518365353345871, -0.03561517223715782, -0.00029567978344857693, 0.018787255510687828, -0.05461879074573517, -0.04242568835616112, 0.01927526853978634, 0.016548098996281624, -0.005780806299299002, -0.05668048933148384, -0.02523161843419075, 0.008378063328564167, 0.06995578110218048, 0.09150330722332001, 0.005944950971752405, -0.055161017924547195, 0.04846001788973808, 0.005220829043537378, 0.03933950141072273, -0.0009028025669977069, 0.02235373668372631, -0.03668895363807678, -0.030119704082608223, 0.028672808781266212, 0.053816523402929306, -0.022699419409036636, 0.07449844479560852, 0.03342081978917122, 0.065907321870327, -0.01456417329609394, -0.048049766570329666, -0.018087826669216156, 0.05068402364850044, 0.03465751186013222, -0.009648707695305347, 0.01957455836236477, 0.013990448787808418, 0.030717892572283745, -0.006436873693019152, 0.01214829832315445, -0.07178722321987152, 0.03958485275506973, 0.023684943094849586, -0.054060082882642746, -0.053910624235868454, -0.0575222410261631, 0.046858303248882294, -0.025618741288781166, -0.0036345855332911015, -0.0024490670766681433, -0.015764467418193817, 0.024449249729514122, 0.046234577894210815, -0.020012782886624336, -0.03868282213807106, -0.009710735641419888, 0.050860874354839325, 0.014042303897440434, -0.012283510528504848, -0.008731682784855366, 0.06898842006921768, 0.03798758238554001, 0.00516706146299839, -0.05198565497994423, 0.035110607743263245, -0.04713710770010948, 0.029834553599357605, -0.05387742072343826, 0.007272382266819477, -0.03354688361287117, -0.06223759427666664, -0.051552433520555496, 0.03753960132598877, -0.025646425783634186, -0.018753478303551674, 0.03766055777668953, -0.055024392902851105, -0.05678997561335564, -0.007900957949459553, -0.007621580734848976, 0.019036924466490746, -0.016447963193058968, 0.01449272409081459, 0.006215047091245651, -0.007907732389867306, -0.03615940734744072, 0.04861340671777725, -0.06549756973981857, -0.017293157055974007, 0.023755593225359917, 0.0036932139191776514, -0.00035499644582159817, -0.002869205316528678, -0.023021377623081207, 0.0031270773615688086, -0.061918869614601135, 0.03685943782329559, -0.017462845891714096, 0.014313983730971813, 0.01389338169246912, 0.018988749012351036, -0.01596871390938759, -0.057853661477565765, -0.03576076030731201, -0.03249035403132439, -0.037290945649147034, 0.008961179293692112, -0.029817085713148117, -0.030074279755353928, -0.004730237647891045, 0.0009178759064525366, 0.0008713380666449666, -0.008899884298443794, -0.006583495531231165, -0.07170578092336655, -0.01839265041053295, -0.05267751216888428, -0.019463500007987022, -0.011157660745084286, 0.01916559785604477, -0.022906165570020676, -0.024955561384558678, 0.029844656586647034, 0.016691144555807114, -0.06084586679935455, -0.06007572263479233, 0.016741976141929626, -0.006327388342469931, 0.056696631014347076, -0.011872982606291771, -0.07373794913291931, -0.039301060140132904, -0.060710180550813675, 0.02015375718474388, -0.008650427684187889, -0.05063135549426079, -0.006025232840329409, 0.06946812570095062, -0.04645967110991478, 0.01672104373574257, 0.05546141043305397, 0.06378613412380219, 0.07896280288696289, -0.00850794930011034, -0.03341391682624817, -0.012052327394485474, -0.10974209755659103, -0.01445308979600668, -0.010049990378320217, 0.0028381531592458487, 0.04171799495816231, 0.03755873441696167, 0.007570329587906599, -0.013809514231979847, 0.007386603858321905, 0.0414956659078598, 0.062151674181222916, -0.03178592026233673, -0.06937383115291595, -0.023153288289904594, -0.04616691917181015, -0.057750340551137924, -0.018200775608420372, -0.05025847628712654, -0.07301296293735504, 0.0313558354973793, -0.001699161482974887, 0.027013828977942467, -0.01600775308907032, -0.04077545553445816, -0.00965170655399561, 0.019092977046966553, 0.05779000744223595, -0.056352682411670685, -0.042087212204933167, -0.023300649598240852, -0.03740813210606575, 0.07032740861177444, -0.015235092490911484, -0.061234936118125916, -0.04565113037824631, -0.032234158366918564, 0.019108032807707787, -0.030897356569767, 0.03185896575450897, 0.014016467146575451, 0.01428172830492258, 0.0006020948640070856, -0.05429322272539139, 0.07063829898834229, 0.03759634867310524, 0.03663809970021248, -0.068728007376194, 0.001707454794086516, 0.03248707577586174, 0.020622095093131065, 0.014515885151922703, -0.03928838670253754, -0.01140036154538393, -0.020315488800406456, -0.007353539578616619, -0.0005038735689595342, 0.038168735802173615, 0.02083207666873932, -0.0294035654515028, -0.003325122408568859, -0.04304185137152672, -0.031104007735848427, 0.04217507690191269, 0.038807306438684464, 0.03890933468937874, 0.057027239352464676, 0.003196681383997202, -0.05379099398851395, -0.030615951865911484, -0.060376930981874466, -0.027433259412646294, -0.08658519387245178, -0.0746501088142395, -0.014492809772491455, -0.04096478223800659, 0.009555598720908165, -0.04894370213150978, -0.029307952150702477, -0.023144187405705452, -0.04560639336705208, -0.05113866180181503, -0.007061211857944727, 0.0016561431111767888, 0.005962565541267395, -0.009065317921340466, -0.0273128654807806, 0.04892852157354355, 0.03599488362669945, -0.04061184450984001, -0.04826425015926361, -0.06333623081445694, 0.0027744676917791367, 0.04326339438557625, 0.008522736839950085, -0.034161992371082306, 0.03150129318237305, 0.010816650465130806, 0.05651826038956642, 0.036876171827316284, 0.05300324782729149, 0.0004976294585503638, 0.01150903757661581, 0.0063092890195548534, 0.010576295666396618, 0.03893369063735008, 0.04077918082475662, 0.04261716455221176, -0.029575912281870842, -0.005009554326534271, -0.018577512353658676, 0.0111435791477561, 0.022444533184170723, -0.04834074154496193, -0.030193598940968513, 0.025848276913166046, 0.05151203274726868, 0.00930037908256054, -0.002351342234760523, 0.047832343727350235, 0.00011305380030535161, -0.014077591709792614, 0.00023209673236124218, -0.025785008445382118, -0.0002630768867675215, -0.00934143178164959, 0.003354086773470044, -0.03380400314927101, 0.016523543745279312, 0.014425644651055336, -0.09119341522455215, 0.04891420528292656, 0.05125952512025833, 0.0801168754696846, 0.006350316107273102, 0.02653557062149048, -0.018380863592028618, 0.048402272164821625, 0.007465403527021408, -0.009308476001024246, 0.033068180084228516, 0.030140861868858337, 0.020822538062930107, -0.037252262234687805, -0.06684840470552444, -0.02155468240380287, -0.06989988684654236, -0.055417075753211975, 0.004502002149820328, 0.017915723845362663, 0.015143508091568947, 0.025977669283747673, -0.0523311048746109, 0.021276183426380157, 0.008436269126832485, 0.0025944786611944437, 0.01114663202315569, -0.0693771094083786, 0.02036365121603012, -0.03923410177230835, 0.005979364272207022, 0.008757752366364002, -0.05752807483077049, -0.014921316877007484, -0.047248851507902145, 0.012960034422576427, -0.019392753019928932, 0.018880696967244148, 0.0005264279898256063, 0.023917023092508316, 0.01585550792515278, 0.02563047781586647, 0.024387763813138008, -0.005830108188092709, -0.0033740680664777756, -0.0327569954097271, -0.004788499791175127, 0.030044017359614372, 0.026335034519433975, 0.007513405289500952, -0.00038912156014703214, -0.019710691645741463, -0.010776967741549015, -0.0283748060464859, -0.03990356996655464, 0.024201489984989166, -0.005135058891028166, 0.012259968556463718, -0.0729077085852623, 0.02239139936864376, -0.02916095219552517, -0.005255423951894045, 0.006156761199235916, -0.054936472326517105, 0.03568460792303085, -0.07718382775783539, -0.035501815378665924, -0.043279509991407394, 0.011650477536022663, -0.01532771810889244, -0.08030596375465393, -0.026751305907964706, -0.07616294175386429, 0.0005110784550197423, -0.06735944002866745, 0.05021730810403824, -0.03981919586658478, 0.010311809368431568, -0.031087635084986687, -0.019718412309885025, -0.024094553664326668, -0.007632787339389324, 0.010425674729049206, 0.0360211580991745, 0.029053330421447754, 0.04599379003047943, -0.011191059835255146, 0.0022779281716793776, 0.026463577523827553, -0.003205777145922184, 0.0026324577629566193, 0.047168415039777756, -0.0469537153840065, -0.029653560370206833, -0.011732651852071285, -0.049525290727615356, 0.02514253742992878, -0.04442775622010231, -0.01962774619460106, 0.021756885573267937, 0.023447692394256592, -0.03731662034988403, -0.040621064603328705, -0.056195806711912155, -0.04293612390756607, -0.03400697931647301, -0.024517321959137917, 0.038302525877952576, 0.022392859682440758, -0.02298370935022831, 0.0008863933617249131, 0.038425326347351074, 0.017133478075265884, -0.03921327367424965, 0.02594136632978916, 0.00760828610509634, 0.025251151993870735, -0.012000036425888538, -0.06237537041306496, -0.09420625865459442, 0.025240452960133553, 0.010812191292643547, 0.0028286606539040804, 0.0029029331635683775, -0.018717527389526367, 0.026343658566474915, 0.03251504898071289, -0.08066078275442123, 0.025515209883451462, 0.04933086037635803, 0.01630478911101818, -0.027442695572972298, 0.043186962604522705, 0.057703692466020584, 0.04572214558720589, 0.009548747912049294, -0.01743587851524353, -0.004237226210534573, -0.045491792261600494, 0.0015906757907941937, -0.003257647855207324, -0.023889165371656418, 0.016811495646834373, 0.023584729060530663, -0.03795512393116951, -0.06971899420022964, -0.042839765548706055, 0.02263176441192627, -0.007993726059794426, -0.05500514432787895, 0.036125656217336655, 0.06648935377597809, -0.005433409009128809, -0.022616909816861153, 0.020730046555399895, -0.003476198995485902, -0.01346884947270155, 0.008931456133723259, -0.02186625823378563, 0.005856275092810392, 0.021544286981225014, -0.04422488808631897, -0.014931255020201206, 0.03953367471694946, -0.044832441955804825, -0.0009135212749242783, 0.02348967455327511, 0.010254507884383202, -0.052970126271247864, -0.06272297352552414, -0.021611925214529037, 0.005114705301821232, 0.03555060550570488, 0.0606001615524292, 0.02351248264312744, 0.032162632793188095, 0.02051662653684616, 0.030602475628256798, 0.021343322470784187, -0.02429865300655365, 0.008657549507915974, -0.008806654252111912, 0.018508505076169968, 0.02891882322728634, 0.044814400374889374, 0.016104016453027725, 0.015027972869575024, 0.06890711933374405, 0.013472054153680801, -0.042055461555719376, -0.01741248369216919, 0.04164780676364899, 0.004223993048071861, -0.04096751660108566, -0.000357133976649493, 0.008382678031921387, -0.052717044949531555, 0.034151263535022736, 0.03904411196708679, 0.019490303471684456, 0.06808348000049591, -0.02761097438633442, 0.010470789857208729, -0.05705709755420685, -0.028910275548696518, 0.05894668027758598, 0.007195619400590658, -0.011660992167890072, -0.004174019675701857, -0.042109571397304535, 0.016352608799934387, -0.07549243420362473, 0.04777112975716591, 0.03797798231244087, -0.01166213396936655, -0.028116801753640175, 0.03836407512426376, -0.004399157594889402, -0.05823700875043869, 0.028489558026194572, 0.009218563325703144, -0.09074166417121887, -0.021581223234534264, -0.03938746824860573, -0.03634053096175194, 0.005574921611696482, 0.07642174512147903, -0.05447058007121086, 0.027504118159413338, -0.021851355209946632, 0.018324514850974083, 0.05784409120678902, 0.01066729798913002, -0.0112101249396801, 0.03231002017855644, -0.030592389404773712, 0.025545602664351463, -0.014532465487718582, -0.011647648178040981, -0.01751435548067093, 0.017803894355893135, 0.050750091671943665, -0.04451880231499672, -0.011261433362960815, 0.0357598178088665, 0.002515624975785613, 0.014118471182882786, -0.004954181145876646, -0.015805598348379135, 0.03718624636530876, -0.06081001088023186, -0.06131916865706444, 0.03000677190721035, -0.020930465310811996, -0.013137844391167164, -0.03927331045269966, -0.02426491305232048, 0.003150281263515353, 0.011904253624379635, 0.02874988131225109, -0.06241362914443016, 0.01621781289577484, -0.03219282999634743, -0.027802305296063423, 0.042114660143852234, -0.09442860633134842, 0.006727044936269522, -0.05545917898416519, 0.07803429663181305, 0.02260289341211319, 0.022616591304540634, -0.05275663733482361, -0.02717333659529686, -0.015988968312740326, 0.020175468176603317, -0.0030999190639704466, -0.03648805618286133, 0.00743863545358181, -0.0023018328938633204, 0.04373590275645256, -0.0030844754073768854, 0.024969570338726044, -0.014605630189180374, -0.010993663221597672, -0.03991374373435974, -0.04267285391688347, -0.03279858082532883, -0.028674453496932983, 0.0395774319767952, -0.015887312591075897, -0.019078800454735756, -0.002051297575235367, -0.07311291992664337, -0.042555585503578186, -0.021835574880242348, -0.008863391354680061, 0.005128033459186554, 0.027392907068133354, 0.032310616225004196, 0.037983234971761703, -0.02190658450126648, -0.02255435474216938, 0.01728237234055996, -0.033248309046030045, -0.015416119247674942, -0.018270298838615417, -0.01816137321293354, -0.01394721120595932, 0.039007436484098434, -0.059624768793582916, 0.02726123481988907, -0.04375487193465233, -0.07894276082515717, 0.039277222007513046, 0.025080181658267975, 0.03022661991417408, -0.011825934052467346, -0.02365150861442089, -0.013628115877509117, -0.0012217700714245439, -0.02359277568757534, -0.07548457384109497, -0.02645700052380562, -0.038170650601387024, -0.03564963862299919, 0.008712411858141422, -0.03748494014143944, -0.0205721165984869, 0.01738346740603447, -0.09119924157857895, 0.0005820102524012327, 0.02012336254119873, 0.02708679623901844, 0.0553412102162838, -0.03368610888719559, 0.03041898086667061, -0.03783807530999184, -0.07815231382846832, -0.006331636570394039, -0.008210752159357071, -0.001803141669370234, 0.029618827626109123, 0.0002014830824919045, -0.056192878633737564, -0.037830453366041183, -0.0009778287494555116, -0.003057424444705248, -0.04135269671678543, -0.0010339963482692838, 0.002198450267314911, 0.03791335970163345, 0.005526399705559015, 0.0848059430718422, 0.006126648746430874, 0.03496655821800232, -0.040997326374053955, 0.02293272688984871, -0.021201644092798233, -0.025172511115670204, -0.03192352503538132, -0.04947902634739876, 0.04911678284406662, 0.028501547873020172, -0.02000533789396286, 0.0035441911313682795, -0.030291708186268806, -0.06451020389795303, 0.0012910468503832817, 0.002430056920275092, -0.009758176282048225, 0.02027222327888012, -0.06457415223121643, 0.047427304089069366, 0.018404722213745117, -0.04466694965958595, -0.023346690461039543, -0.0031388746574521065, 0.00928555242717266, -0.02313663624227047, -0.0001594544155523181, -0.06660940498113632, -0.029168913140892982, -0.012856106273829937, 0.01899704895913601, -0.008952939882874489, 0.03658818453550339, 0.015810860320925713, -0.021615812554955482, -0.06967031955718994, -0.0587163120508194, 0.030382081866264343, -0.021012304350733757, -0.057177864015102386, -0.0495431087911129, 0.021797943860292435, -0.006952071096748114, -0.006655840668827295, -0.026720533147454262, 0.0625704899430275, 0.027978848665952682, -0.02569107711315155, 0.014972741715610027, 0.027674710378050804, -0.006588956341147423, 0.08410521596670151, 0.0006708619766868651, -0.000567878014408052, 0.002939582569524646, -0.030629616230726242, -0.04184809699654579, -0.04839916154742241, -0.041578345000743866, -0.0018263793317601085, 0.01742900162935257, -0.05961187183856964, 0.0019276889506727457, -0.045060306787490845, -0.013327698223292828, -0.04744814336299896, -0.0290245208889246, 0.017771542072296143, -0.008436438627541065, -0.010134932585060596 ]
With most modern visualization tools, authors need to transform their data into tidy formats to create visualizations they want. Because this requires experience with programming or separate data processing tools, data transformation remains a barrier in visualization authoring. To address this challenge, we present a new visualization paradigm, concept binding, that separates high-level visualization intents and low-level data transformation steps, leveraging an AI agent. We realize this paradigm in Data Formulator, an interactive visualization authoring tool. With Data Formulator, authors first define data concepts they plan to visualize using natural languages or examples, and then bind them to visual channels. Data Formulator then dispatches its AI-agent to automatically transform the input data to surface these concepts and generate desired visualizations. When presenting the results (transformed table and output visualizations) from the AI agent, Data Formulator provides feedback to help authors inspect and understand them. A user study with 10 participants shows that participants could learn and use Data Formulator to create visualizations that involve challenging data transformations, and presents interesting future research directions.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10094v2
[ -0.016546543687582016, -0.05924329161643982, 0.05139046907424927, 0.013239697553217411, -0.04592844843864441, -0.036552585661411285, 0.008148260414600372, -0.016604270786046982, -0.03635993227362633, -0.017825733870267868, -0.06949260085821152, 0.033707231283187866, -0.025063084438443184, -0.04698007181286812, -0.05564713850617409, -0.0115743363276124, 0.0730619803071022, 0.007818548940122128, -0.03437690809369087, 0.043540388345718384, -0.00593018252402544, 0.04182958975434303, -0.03220493346452713, 0.04855892434716225, 0.017697924748063087, -0.02047261781990528, -0.02250303328037262, 0.04519113525748253, -0.018648212775588036, 0.006331683602184057, 0.06604056060314178, -0.03893366828560829, -0.02429765835404396, -0.06020025908946991, -0.053478535264730453, 0.006193119566887617, -0.00191714137326926, 0.006730126682668924, -0.030133984982967377, -0.051226906478405, 0.061786387115716934, -0.03647748380899429, -0.0565434992313385, -0.035827696323394775, -0.042793918401002884, 0.013557801954448223, -0.06720278412103653, 0.005849538370966911, -0.07129545509815216, -0.03549988567829132, -0.006032356061041355, 0.00804125890135765, -0.03090907633304596, 0.05058223009109497, -0.0021720384247601032, 0.01435393188148737, 0.004612613003700972, 0.03417925164103508, -0.05489413067698479, 0.003723683999851346, 0.013934828341007233, -0.016829470172524452, -0.004558653570711613, 0.009071815758943558, -0.02564168907701969, 0.04671981930732727, -0.04599890857934952, -0.05080453306436539, -0.042123276740312576, -0.04502688720822334, 0.03491438925266266, -0.06434459984302521, -0.019314097240567207, 0.01572440192103386, -0.04857901483774185, 0.005039417650550604, -0.017985958606004715, -0.036111414432525635, 0.01975303702056408, -0.005826277192682028, -0.020806970074772835, -0.0001396625448251143, 0.03608677536249161, 0.05840317904949188, -0.01441936381161213, -0.027141962200403214, 0.023294424638152122, 0.01360172126442194, 0.02781549282371998, -0.05523701012134552, 0.050424281507730484, -0.029508432373404503, -0.07346048206090927, -0.004793917760252953, 0.04306294769048691, -0.035918474197387695, 0.030894581228494644, 0.015813272446393967, -0.011905678547918797, -0.00001342380801361287, -0.05745919048786163, -0.009789053350687027, -0.013586094602942467, 0.001375208841636777, 0.03893808647990227, -0.06218930333852768, 0.0074033187702298164, -0.04124787449836731, -0.04775727540254593, -0.04441399127244949, -0.010777740739285946, 0.011309700086712837, 0.03448725491762161, -0.07150831818580627, -0.02500316873192787, -0.059701208025217056, 0.002707242965698242, -0.020519142970442772, 0.021443042904138565, 0.013103864155709743, -0.023159397765994072, 0.032461971044540405, 0.04931817203760147, -0.05118222162127495, -0.061244525015354156, -0.04520187899470329, 0.059898413717746735, -0.022078176960349083, -0.013111051172018051, -0.03545794636011124, -0.05776998773217201, 0.054520610719919205, -0.0402071438729763, -0.0569775216281414, 0.06054515764117241, -0.009206412360072136, -0.025761159136891365, -0.06472039967775345, 0.005311720073223114, -0.01809726282954216, -0.040592826902866364, -0.04603768512606621, 0.02107487991452217, -0.018988467752933502, -0.00758701516315341, 0.042143162339925766, 0.025194572284817696, -0.022114301100373268, -0.02393297106027603, -0.021521931514143944, 0.038267239928245544, -0.010460187681019306, 0.05741143971681595, 0.018508460372686386, 0.007569586392492056, -0.05231299251317978, 0.01304090116173029, -0.025271447375416756, -0.05594480782747269, 0.029236488044261932, -0.020119380205869675, -0.02452712506055832, 0.01379221212118864, -0.04452798143029213, -0.0012747113360092044, -0.009027132764458656, 0.04032905399799347, -0.03471488133072853, -0.02404862269759178, 0.0020806461106985807, -0.040437500923871994, -0.0373997837305069, -0.01896609552204609, -0.030092356726527214, -0.029918791726231575, 0.028244709596037865, -0.03481697291135788, -0.06371212750673294, -0.057369232177734375, 0.0035643193405121565, -0.04909093677997589, -0.01562611572444439, -0.033493202179670334, -0.04390849173069, -0.03692794591188431, -0.0024137254804372787, -0.06845024228096008, -0.0608842708170414, 0.010280952788889408, 0.023357734084129333, -0.0660758689045906, -0.04100891947746277, -0.007151610683649778, -0.017454516142606735, -0.026198389008641243, 0.015898551791906357, 0.024879589676856995, -0.029981961473822594, -0.03253021463751793, 0.03886966034770012, -0.06809978932142258, -0.034321919083595276, -0.05941566452383995, 0.01647367887198925, -0.023935426026582718, -0.07072991132736206, -0.02591482177376747, 0.0270391833037138, -0.03884762525558472, 0.0047512361779809, 0.018637415021657944, 0.02154211886227131, 0.067251056432724, 0.03454040363430977, 0.05491521209478378, 0.01575368084013462, -0.07911825180053711, 0.048751555383205414, 0.017309701070189476, 0.013295145705342293, -0.013577220030128956, 0.02440374158322811, 0.03393334522843361, -0.03429136425256729, -0.007080607116222382, 0.03963460400700569, 0.02653457038104534, 0.003267798339948058, -0.06525008380413055, -0.04705661162734032, -0.02151045948266983, -0.052852462977170944, 0.010800532065331936, -0.07263708114624023, -0.0005716352607123554, -0.0012051188386976719, -0.015882911160588264, 0.012492885813117027, -0.031154898926615715, -0.03773123025894165, -0.024763435125350952, -0.0649198666214943, 0.05770540609955788, 0.010403807274997234, -0.03295740857720375, 0.0005936569068580866, -0.021220510825514793, 0.0034230879973620176, -0.04113831743597984, 0.016483766958117485, -0.050531789660453796, -0.06449828296899796, -0.0007828233065083623, -0.019605468958616257, 0.055945392698049545, -0.025997789576649666, -0.02732725627720356, 0.028369152918457985, -0.02317904680967331, 0.04952388256788254, -0.011124690063297749, 0.03995013236999512, -0.050321727991104126, 0.050260625779628754, 0.04254918545484543, -0.030434422194957733, 0.009222994558513165, -0.05805230885744095, 0.034892767667770386, -0.04680219665169716, -0.008172505535185337, 0.027320895344018936, 0.004311105702072382, 0.011187183670699596, -0.03829573839902878, 0.009958654642105103, -0.03287640959024429, -0.038537923246622086, 0.04298430308699608, 0.06617862731218338, -0.0038289795629680157, 0.005565293598920107, -0.04118739068508148, -0.06375626474618912, 0.004975087009370327, -0.057310041040182114, -0.024230754002928734, -0.07011973857879639, -0.061152711510658264, -0.0357678048312664, -0.07354024797677994, -0.04164145886898041, -0.06045719236135483, -0.05513646826148033, -0.00038311892421916127, -0.044628262519836426, 0.005619802977889776, -0.037365857511758804, 0.06060568615794182, 0.029298225417733192, -0.05836135894060135, -0.047851067036390305, -0.00007568520959466696, -0.007125843781977892, -0.003046398749575019, -0.0659932941198349, -0.05481504648923874, 0.0002733957953751087, 0.015118986368179321, -0.03160456195473671, -0.006898535881191492, 0.04353407770395279, -0.047929394990205765, -0.019088495522737503, 0.026818184182047844, -0.03993222862482071, -0.013163400813937187, 0.017660344019532204, -0.021720919758081436, -0.010498604737222195, 0.013464936055243015, -0.010862359777092934, 0.03319890424609184, -0.03377667814493179, -0.02478780969977379, -0.06442905962467194, 0.005432960111647844, -0.02894008718430996, -0.03864656388759613, -0.05074392631649971, -0.006852929946035147, -0.0072061787359416485, 0.01813138648867607, 0.008132105693221092, -0.0000054674696912115905, 0.046680204570293427, 0.008786295540630817, -0.06299575418233871, -0.028646904975175858, -0.02559061348438263, -0.0021890669595450163, 0.03430251032114029, -0.04681028053164482, -0.011278166435658932, 0.04761262238025665, -0.08043204993009567, -0.008674710988998413, 0.02920241467654705, 0.05910667032003403, -0.02484956756234169, 0.0059580933302640915, -0.028455397114157677, -0.04181499406695366, 0.02412967011332512, -0.0230381041765213, 0.031708501279354095, 0.03291720896959305, 0.05153660476207733, -0.06682546436786652, -0.07241292297840118, -0.021974891424179077, -0.07082098722457886, -0.03548673540353775, 0.017310690134763718, 0.033091865479946136, 0.04551994428038597, 0.031216610223054886, -0.030537497252225876, -0.012544408440589905, -0.0418381541967392, 0.05475227162241936, 0.048918843269348145, 0.01041334681212902, 0.02644839882850647, -0.06532515585422516, 0.04632328078150749, 0.023773619905114174, 0.007525356952100992, -0.009970985352993011, 0.017257891595363617, 0.039105214178562164, -0.05928926542401314, 0.05445823445916176, 0.03186895325779915, -0.020318664610385895, 0.018775176256895065, 0.03977757319808006, -0.03240656480193138, 0.04956540837883949, -0.030872952193021774, -0.010085667483508587, 0.02787650376558304, 0.031410444527864456, -0.06186727061867714, 0.0014157514087855816, -0.05727936699986458, -0.013781385496258736, 0.011233859695494175, 0.007458347361534834, -0.031985122710466385, 0.0010631340555846691, -0.022829808294773102, -0.00615473510697484, -0.06256964802742004, 0.022746186703443527, -0.06070706620812416, 0.03536893427371979, 0.02018021047115326, -0.029984846711158752, 0.03895964100956917, -0.05227478966116905, -0.008433259092271328, -0.021574556827545166, -0.02198037877678871, -0.01425393857061863, -0.04128061234951019, 0.051758017390966415, -0.07405031472444534, -0.011420682072639465, -0.049786631017923355, 0.02733604796230793, 0.03304729983210564, 0.028041187673807144, -0.00355414766818285, -0.028022877871990204, -0.015552425757050514, -0.007065088953822851, 0.0758894607424736, 0.018495241180062294, -0.0140003627166152, -0.013479472137987614, 0.03178820386528969, -0.0383121483027935, 0.04620774835348129, -0.022248955443501472, -0.03294755518436432, 0.003247602377086878, 0.015374054200947285, 0.04122375696897507, -0.004589437507092953, -0.05371267721056938, 0.019068283960223198, -0.047488730400800705, -0.02364593744277954, -0.023327389732003212, 0.01987176574766636, -0.04717693850398064, -0.060888729989528656, -0.054795268923044205, -0.023583488538861275, -0.061812445521354675, -0.009958924725651741, -0.00851479358971119, 0.002746345940977335, 0.014774822629988194, -0.0019382279133424163, 0.043856993317604065, 0.018971160054206848, -0.014468429610133171, -0.015178797766566277, -0.005791094619780779, -0.02544262446463108, -0.03504418954253197, -0.004774469882249832, -0.06894636154174805, 0.0204134713858366, -0.06610316038131714, -0.01922101341187954, -0.0039372858591377735, 0.03039437159895897, 0.042553529143333435, 0.07411795854568481, -0.07264217734336853, 0.0317612923681736, 0.030436474829912186, -0.005769061390310526, 0.00282594608142972, 0.05596478655934334, 0.015782678499817848, 0.020416738465428352, -0.01843295618891716, 0.03668183088302612, -0.004051171708852053, -0.04149278998374939, 0.007917209528386593, 0.0022750033531337976, 0.006612879224121571, -0.009685114957392216, 0.04789336770772934, -0.04273991659283638, -0.014849060215055943, 0.01006944477558136, 0.026384662836790085, 0.03636212274432182, -0.024909811094403267, 0.0051722037605941296, -0.005521910265088081, -0.03788669779896736, -0.02850412204861641, -0.012958250008523464, -0.052662648260593414, -0.046430014073848724, 0.02182137966156006, 0.0065122633241117, 0.02979089878499508, 0.0494019091129303, 0.0064195292070508, -0.016000714153051376, -0.039116475731134415, 0.022904306650161743, 0.015633931383490562, -0.04975461587309837, 0.021836353465914726, -0.03644312918186188, -0.032717265188694, -0.0476856529712677, 0.030947372317314148, 0.05295458063483238, 0.050150878727436066, 0.0067137484438717365, 0.005610261578112841, -0.032876547425985336, -0.024250289425253868, 0.017831915989518166, -0.02573067881166935, -0.016758952289819717, -0.038008060306310654, 0.03220861405134201, -0.021149631589651108, 0.015482129529118538, 0.01615952141582966, 0.05975399911403656, 0.03899650275707245, -0.0013035621959716082, -0.015520981512963772, -0.035536035895347595, 0.02893313579261303, -0.04773738980293274, -0.04066691920161247, 0.028274135664105415, 0.038558606058359146, -0.004641492385417223, 0.03257419168949127, 0.026133647188544273, -0.04266967251896858, -0.011741801165044308, -0.01603568345308304, -0.007758148945868015, -0.0414990596473217, 0.04002351686358452, 0.04316967353224754, -0.050594761967659, 0.025423232465982437, -0.012399766594171524, -0.058076612651348114, 0.010669556446373463, -0.005609537940472364, 0.0420081801712513, -0.0033357059583067894, -0.03988710045814514, -0.04598241671919823, 0.05149831622838974, -0.01924438588321209, -0.06651519984006882, 0.029102591797709465, -0.006427012849599123, -0.0662996843457222, -0.00827559269964695, -0.00064643140649423, 0.05748694762587547, -0.028848422691226006, 0.049615658819675446, 0.02876412868499756, -0.01668049581348896, -0.05746613070368767, 0.07327506691217422, 0.07011466473340988, -0.019425198435783386, 0.011564436368644238, 0.02325831539928913, -0.0703040212392807, 0.010229021310806274, 0.00696251355111599, 0.046103738248348236, -0.0033444995060563087, -0.010078717023134232, 0.012954718433320522, -0.048892341554164886, -0.04391181468963623, 0.036946944892406464, -0.020365744829177856, -0.00007246479799505323, -0.019512062892317772, -0.029104923829436302, 0.03223826363682747, -0.028877997770905495, -0.06893908232450485, -0.002248016418889165, -0.04361565783619881, 0.008737577125430107, -0.06320473551750183, -0.01423467043787241, 0.002281089313328266, -0.018789170309901237, -0.0010948547860607505, -0.060195550322532654, 0.007789306342601776, -0.035257238894701004, -0.06667813658714294, 0.04340748116374016, -0.06857409328222275, -0.0026617131661623716, 0.02131478302180767, 0.015886040404438972, 0.04156559333205223, 0.05157561972737312, -0.036554377526044846, 0.006417074706405401, 0.04547939449548721, -0.009199685417115688, 0.02218022011220455, -0.023866131901741028, 0.02966609038412571, -0.021621113643050194, 0.020917726680636406, -0.04039008542895317, -0.03249295800924301, -0.0020267069339752197, -0.014948038384318352, 0.025755541399121284, -0.017660321667790413, -0.03455382585525513, -0.0539872869849205, 0.002106372034177184, -0.010656931437551975, -0.010752949863672256, 0.014128626324236393, -0.03681877255439758, -0.06629298627376556, -0.025837279856204987, -0.04513473063707352, 0.030472969636321068, 0.025797290727496147, 0.057026371359825134, 0.06332866847515106, -0.034028153866529465, 0.031922806054353714, 0.007684285286813974, -0.016262797638773918, 0.028130603954195976, -0.05734006315469742, -0.024914834648370743, -0.039121113717556, -0.05494548752903938, -0.04486991465091705, -0.017414763569831848, 0.03478386998176575, -0.060437772423028946, 0.03209906816482544, 0.049845535308122635, 0.0037552793510258198, -0.01279381848871708, -0.05875050276517868, -0.028550338000059128, -0.022332273423671722, -0.034543123096227646, -0.051319390535354614, 0.016166863963007927, 0.021314572542905807, -0.032435864210128784, 0.032652948051691055, 0.0016192409675568342, -0.02058148942887783, -0.012587100267410278, -0.071570985019207, 0.014285855926573277, 0.0021423441357910633, 0.038298349827528, -0.019551564007997513, -0.04309766739606857, 0.012529647909104824, -0.014152872376143932, -0.0074332342483103275, -0.03232628479599953, -0.0032734873238950968, -0.011378432624042034, 0.0019839173182845116, -0.03434381261467934, -0.058349911123514175, 0.015443296171724796, 0.027910325676202774, -0.010399889200925827, 0.011018778197467327, -0.010969108901917934, 0.00664516631513834, 0.02310827374458313, -0.0523144006729126, 0.03318822383880615, -0.006031470373272896, 0.051057226955890656, -0.05332348495721817, 0.037977904081344604, 0.023914599791169167, -0.06638149172067642, 0.025624437257647514, -0.04677416384220123, -0.020567448809742928, 0.03816165030002594, -0.025411903858184814, 0.004325238522142172, 0.004843972623348236, -0.06263459473848343, 0.038099151104688644, -0.03262193128466606, -0.023192163556814194, 0.05041440948843956, -0.05553896352648735, 0.013106654398143291, -0.04000650346279144, -0.025589916855096817, -0.03249094635248184, 0.010490366257727146, 0.04124550148844719, -0.014900214970111847, 0.0039326706901192665, -0.05537889897823334, 0.008510926738381386, 0.011532314121723175, -0.00976173859089613, -0.005969682242721319, 0.07036559283733368, 0.01760105788707733, -0.04746086522936821, -0.013113941997289658, -0.03958359733223915, -0.014090318232774734, -0.06516489386558533, -0.0442567802965641, -0.04114823415875435, 0.01938333362340927, -0.024857666343450546, -0.032636597752571106, -0.005193064454942942, 0.04021906480193138, 0.03023877553641796, 0.020641984418034554, 0.02180345728993416, -0.027836952358484268, -0.04776318371295929, 0.036578282713890076, 0.0013297165278345346, 0.026557089760899544, -0.011950656771659851, -0.034013863652944565, -0.02811472676694393, -0.002602339256554842, -0.00006011626101098955, 0.0018383389106020331, 0.004667868837714195, -0.05896463245153427, -0.009760790504515171, 0.026036683470010757, -0.02270589768886566, -0.03446713462471962, -0.058954037725925446, 0.028578151017427444, -0.05791899561882019, -0.06767607480287552 ]
Mixed Reality (MR) allows users to interact with digital objects in a physical environment, but several limitations have hampered widespread adoption. Physiologically adaptive systems detecting user's states can drive interaction and address these limitations. Here, we highlight potential usability and interaction limitations in MR and how physiologically adaptive systems can benefit MR experiences and applications. We specifically address potential applications for human factors and operational settings such as healthcare, education, and entertainment. We further discuss benefits and applications in light of ethical and privacy concerns. The use of physiologically adaptive systems in MR has the potential to revolutionize human-computer interactions and provide users with a more personalized and engaging experience.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17978v1
[ -0.012857923284173012, -0.021827077493071556, 0.0577978678047657, -0.03420763090252876, 0.03200274333357811, 0.014872580766677856, 0.028015106916427612, -0.04143854230642319, -0.03852052614092827, -0.06079135835170746, -0.04019730165600777, -0.025594856590032578, -0.035184524953365326, -0.03481725975871086, -0.048120226711034775, 0.0471918061375618, 0.06401289254426956, 0.04035630822181702, -0.026417886838316917, 0.03054569475352764, -0.001025840057991445, -0.057886675000190735, -0.04454145208001137, 0.04215189069509506, -0.03471566364169121, 0.021727509796619415, 0.040620043873786926, -0.03381865471601486, 0.027517352253198624, -0.021204596385359764, 0.019131552428007126, -0.03070026822388172, 0.01674002967774868, -0.019916854798793793, -0.05471784994006157, -0.011642779223620892, -0.005185008514672518, 0.010778997093439102, -0.037459708750247955, -0.015827249735593796, 0.0425279438495636, 0.024707162752747536, -0.05556662753224373, -0.016366304829716682, -0.02025950513780117, -0.013765925541520119, -0.05522434040904045, -0.05072480067610741, -0.07308517396450043, -0.025526603683829308, 0.0028834943659603596, 0.052560221403837204, 0.03411079943180084, 0.06843740493059158, -0.021703539416193962, 0.03341202437877655, -0.02469582110643387, 0.00425745127722621, -0.03776954859495163, -0.014285304583609104, 0.010587996803224087, -0.035908475518226624, 0.04304742068052292, -0.0006874704267829657, -0.021595114842057228, 0.009002696722745895, -0.060810405761003494, -0.05137569457292557, 0.004679446574300528, -0.06247246637940407, 0.01890016347169876, -0.07042070478200912, -0.0022638316731899977, 0.004233331885188818, -0.03425336256623268, -0.036550380289554596, -0.02796381153166294, -0.012702282518148422, -0.03713656961917877, 0.0425180085003376, -0.01420615240931511, 0.056887418031692505, 0.02145441062748432, 0.008068823255598545, -0.01100397389382124, -0.038335591554641724, 0.024592459201812744, -0.05597485974431038, -0.0022413870319724083, -0.03553222864866257, 0.045763079077005386, -0.028698869049549103, -0.0653524398803711, 0.0310378298163414, 0.04711303114891052, -0.005981592461466789, -0.0013352129608392715, 0.03488839045166969, -0.024255601689219475, -0.0025250210892409086, -0.018143625929951668, 0.009529416449368, -0.013797520659863949, 0.06349152326583862, -0.028263123705983162, -0.06765837222337723, -0.0021636970341205597, -0.0005757134640589356, -0.025745131075382233, -0.06338277459144592, -0.025024961680173874, -0.052757371217012405, -0.027360515668988228, -0.08631951361894608, -0.03427564352750778, -0.0038504546973854303, -0.004637594800442457, -0.017927831038832664, -0.01721947081387043, 0.02615203894674778, -0.04647759348154068, 0.032837819308042526, -0.04653766006231308, -0.042485643178224564, -0.06362507492303848, -0.026573151350021362, 0.047733865678310394, -0.037071410566568375, -0.057087987661361694, -0.028632495552301407, -0.07121957093477249, -0.013174810446798801, -0.03036048263311386, -0.006831796374171972, 0.06525608897209167, -0.03250545263290405, 0.028830809518694878, 0.00016250743647105992, 0.04880179464817047, -0.020767977461218834, -0.040402937680482864, -0.03717154264450073, -0.03079591505229473, -0.07221440225839615, 0.013009230606257915, 0.02551797777414322, 0.018664253875613213, -0.0330987386405468, 0.01850190944969654, 0.016922136768698692, 0.043227653950452805, -0.019646361470222473, 0.017440978437662125, 0.03502141311764717, 0.02945718541741371, -0.0037066445220261812, 0.03895459696650505, -0.03702886402606964, -0.06479311734437943, -0.007948384620249271, 0.00007960201764944941, -0.012567790225148201, 0.007600830402225256, -0.05476592853665352, 0.0014772505965083838, 0.009767992421984673, 0.03749057278037071, -0.01933978870511055, 0.002184108830988407, -0.021129760891199112, -0.036957576870918274, -0.03029782883822918, 0.013914109207689762, 0.003410195931792259, -0.06639371812343597, 0.001526029547676444, 0.026533978059887886, -0.02409997396171093, -0.021918470039963722, 0.042513322085142136, -0.006946301553398371, 0.032496530562639236, -0.05284353345632553, 0.028734024614095688, -0.02542973682284355, 0.023011263459920883, -0.03963327407836914, -0.04594271257519722, 0.026564031839370728, -0.016566798090934753, -0.06573658436536789, -0.06645296514034271, 0.0044881971552968025, 0.012230576947331429, -0.06333008408546448, -0.002461569383740425, -0.009256466291844845, -0.06935568898916245, 0.02478201501071453, 0.02165491320192814, -0.08009396493434906, 0.02094029262661934, -0.03186281770467758, -0.052246443927288055, 0.0110844187438488, -0.06032092496752739, 0.03916914388537407, 0.023071041330695152, 0.0024843227583914995, -0.02939799800515175, 0.029039720073342323, -0.012099907733500004, 0.054587412625551224, -0.002376382937654853, 0.034599993377923965, 0.009505127556622028, -0.091626837849617, 0.055990785360336304, 0.019245410338044167, 0.0161026231944561, 0.04037632793188095, -0.014410873875021935, -0.04310747608542442, -0.01062406599521637, -0.002222812967374921, -0.02277480438351631, -0.014385552145540714, 0.04234558716416359, -0.038357220590114594, -0.028207512572407722, -0.014987817034125328, -0.07546918094158173, -0.0022777188569307327, -0.07784955948591232, -0.011518030427396297, -0.036716338247060776, -0.04842490330338478, 0.025736138224601746, -0.013557273894548416, -0.011696072295308113, -0.014277104288339615, -0.03136150911450386, 0.029038963839411736, 0.029977597296237946, -0.04313379526138306, -0.05059636011719704, -0.0012109202798455954, 0.03309530019760132, -0.06972608715295792, 0.03465747833251953, 0.01048004999756813, -0.06707192212343216, 0.006301613058894873, 0.004159505013376474, 0.04232092946767807, 0.008757348172366619, -0.05782270431518555, -0.0006524502532556653, 0.016918467357754707, 0.06700567156076431, 0.03926276043057442, 0.0030283168889582157, -0.07102988660335541, 0.03802499175071716, -0.007288398686796427, -0.003520043333992362, -0.0284343883395195, -0.03133602440357208, 0.0233103409409523, -0.03703117370605469, 0.06341539323329926, -0.0065651144832372665, 0.048079151660203934, -0.024834301322698593, 0.01530215609818697, -0.026583688333630562, 0.0337386280298233, -0.047917790710926056, -0.01129863690584898, 0.05683622509241104, 0.0581824891269207, -0.02152440883219242, 0.02512926235795021, -0.06242472678422928, -0.017190711572766304, -0.03253892809152603, -0.05409923568367958, -0.01633494719862938, -0.015881624072790146, -0.05145804584026337, -0.057051029056310654, -0.060411565005779266, 0.031994689255952835, -0.04607366770505905, 0.01975776068866253, -0.04922553896903992, -0.024623222649097443, -0.032758988440036774, 0.02958771027624607, -0.04476146399974823, -0.00405034888535738, -0.02479703351855278, 0.01721363700926304, 0.0332043319940567, -0.02577960677444935, -0.04770185425877571, -0.04671141132712364, -0.06119096651673317, -0.01116019207984209, -0.043708786368370056, 0.025003142654895782, 0.0522901713848114, -0.05330958589911461, -0.03538984805345535, -0.020376890897750854, -0.01818152144551277, 0.022875063121318817, -0.05716720595955849, -0.05078492686152458, -0.007874379865825176, 0.008883390575647354, -0.038771852850914, 0.03554636612534523, -0.006940026301890612, -0.05839233100414276, 0.01637120172381401, 0.04613802209496498, 0.05463903769850731, 0.024253886193037033, -0.008574570529162884, 0.003551492467522621, -0.004692739807069302, 0.013749106787145138, -0.018691590055823326, -0.014291317202150822, 0.013864579610526562, -0.004427868407219648, -0.0331115797162056, 0.023637911304831505, 0.05950850620865822, -0.03361396864056587, -0.001020861673168838, -0.05238739028573036, -0.05224284529685974, 0.01218764204531908, -0.07185322046279907, -0.002478512702509761, 0.007954747416079044, 0.06288081407546997, -0.04096909239888191, 0.003463772824034095, 0.03454582393169403, -0.027126727625727654, 0.028270820155739784, -0.02712046168744564, -0.03932158648967743, 0.0017217319691553712, 0.03484562784433365, -0.027206046506762505, -0.06243954226374626, 0.013960054144263268, -0.04289349913597107, -0.040401820093393326, 0.019909685477614403, 0.034451667219400406, 0.04084227979183197, 0.05907614901661873, -0.07313410937786102, 0.012225780636072159, -0.01981450244784355, 0.001274628797546029, 0.019762974232435226, -0.03473759815096855, 0.03876202553510666, -0.02752121351659298, -0.0027156793512403965, 0.009982781484723091, -0.010869222693145275, -0.06541657447814941, -0.0484505295753479, 0.008738239295780659, -0.05051500350236893, 0.015412951819598675, 0.03247835859656334, 0.0033684123773127794, 0.03204420581459999, 0.005462402477860451, 0.02823285385966301, 0.043970320373773575, -0.05546751245856285, -0.01599305309355259, -0.021304553374648094, -0.030929701402783394, -0.05788835138082504, -0.048863139003515244, -0.07369349151849747, -0.029078729450702667, -0.021087637171149254, -0.014972423203289509, -0.006350196432322264, 0.001457692007534206, -0.009710858575999737, 0.02119635045528412, -0.08162935823202133, -0.014718124642968178, -0.029321765527129173, 0.03677942603826523, 0.04743871092796326, 0.009800182655453682, 0.009067113511264324, -0.05926693603396416, 0.034828078001737595, -0.04287271574139595, 0.01235724426805973, -0.003713793819770217, 0.03276260197162628, 0.030262980610132217, -0.06998219341039658, -0.04848823323845863, -0.04891178756952286, 0.03868275135755539, 0.014927800744771957, 0.03624092787504196, -0.024612849578261375, -0.026732956990599632, -0.0010283285519108176, 0.059982266277074814, 0.041718218475580215, -0.03999913111329079, 0.015485638752579689, -0.04940083995461464, 0.04539738595485687, -0.004600302781909704, 0.03327968716621399, 0.05132942274212837, -0.0376141257584095, 0.01393161527812481, -0.05645372346043587, -0.008587120100855827, -0.039031293243169785, -0.015236090868711472, 0.050683729350566864, -0.003929249010980129, -0.010262896306812763, 0.03569876030087471, 0.02164730802178383, -0.02691633813083172, -0.027040675282478333, -0.059214428067207336, -0.035369016230106354, -0.04734627902507782, -0.027509234845638275, -0.005945512559264898, -0.03676436096429825, 0.026404226198792458, -0.0030879024416208267, 0.01956315152347088, 0.02591477893292904, -0.012519710697233677, 0.031529780477285385, 0.006857417523860931, -0.01492486521601677, -0.00041218078695237637, -0.03283720463514328, -0.030848076567053795, 0.044447578489780426, -0.020181827247142792, 0.01960364542901516, 0.00666308868676424, 0.03080878220498562, 0.0048206099309027195, -0.004806841257959604, -0.07409150153398514, 0.0545937605202198, 0.04537845402956009, 0.0034409663639962673, 0.03485789895057678, 0.03879496082663536, 0.030277151614427567, 0.015298866666853428, -0.04396240785717964, 0.04278779402375221, 0.02264147810637951, 0.0006241640076041222, -0.024181943386793137, -0.028683297336101532, -0.01459225732833147, -0.02490600384771824, 0.031147781759500504, -0.050778668373823166, -0.0677109882235527, -0.00654920469969511, 0.03832700476050377, 0.04110315442085266, -0.02086692862212658, 0.04434667155146599, 0.0031648213043808937, -0.004625045228749514, -0.037913862615823746, 0.01870114728808403, -0.029417933896183968, 0.02512437477707863, 0.05170024186372757, -0.07466081529855728, 0.01838778518140316, -0.028924284502863884, 0.004878986161202192, 0.007751344703137875, 0.0036197917070239782, 0.009395498782396317, -0.007561300881206989, -0.004101935774087906, -0.015280820429325104, -0.0330742672085762, -0.03553430363535881, -0.07520966976881027, 0.03430076315999031, 0.05319131538271904, 0.034710630774497986, 0.05057748034596443, 0.003445336828008294, -0.057843830436468124, -0.04521546885371208, -0.029183300212025642, -0.00794227235019207, -0.003030288266018033, -0.05606832355260849, 0.03850717097520828, 0.015550629235804081, -0.012335799634456635, 0.03876892477273941, -0.019558006897568703, 0.019324105232954025, -0.011589165776968002, -0.014509581960737705, -0.06111840531229973, 0.008347863331437111, -0.050826020538806915, -0.049824949353933334, 0.03124912455677986, 0.04006868600845337, -0.054595813155174255, 0.009628661908209324, 0.004582719877362251, -0.027237538248300552, 0.04661375284194946, 0.01599452644586563, -0.0005348238628357649, -0.05695395916700363, 0.06622125208377838, 0.059270184487104416, -0.03133493661880493, 0.0013723702868446708, -0.044722914695739746, -0.03844914212822914, -0.009016630239784718, -0.023113969713449478, -0.03627784177660942, -0.0023754138965159655, 0.010535886511206627, -0.031927503645420074, 0.023942910134792328, -0.032814834266901016, -0.07443200796842575, -0.02156062237918377, -0.04965750873088837, -0.06438897550106049, -0.01749192364513874, 0.03431788086891174, -0.010482910089194775, -0.0498608760535717, 0.050652917474508286, -0.0008128747576847672, -0.047712720930576324, -0.049501001834869385, 0.07491816580295563, 0.0670752078294754, 0.007996993139386177, 0.022604841738939285, -0.03847856819629669, -0.0716431736946106, -0.05394308269023895, 0.007841994054615498, 0.027514012530446053, 0.022009143605828285, 0.021966636180877686, 0.010708651505410671, -0.06703589856624603, -0.06742273271083832, 0.026896141469478607, 0.013423411175608635, -0.032731130719184875, 0.05117372050881386, 0.014794446527957916, 0.020243512466549873, 0.01555370632559061, -0.03042726032435894, -0.044145647436380386, -0.02388138882815838, -0.049707744270563126, 0.0025038381572812796, -0.003686274169012904, 0.025479529052972794, -0.012375127524137497, 0.009920590557157993, -0.012745734304189682, -0.05580359697341919, -0.032636858522892, -0.062203191220760345, 0.02699870802462101, -0.03651871904730797, -0.0040754820220172405, 0.0009260427905246615, -0.04224167391657829, 0.05411413311958313, -0.0023375190794467926, -0.013717032968997955, 0.0345601886510849, -0.010439107194542885, 0.007773208897560835, 0.009464741684496403, -0.009988590143620968, -0.021986156702041626, -0.024213429540395737, -0.01724880002439022, -0.0012130498653277755, -0.04150541499257088, 0.022432785481214523, -0.027642328292131424, -0.04169457033276558, 0.014311559498310089, -0.005516666453331709, -0.03241725265979767, -0.021190760657191277, -0.00661316467449069, 0.01695614494383335, 0.031017620116472244, -0.005202834960073233, -0.03648557513952255, 0.02378075011074543, -0.01688442938029766, 0.0031706239096820354, -0.03481041267514229, 0.04990343004465103, 0.02452426590025425, 0.006309127900749445, 0.053696248680353165, 0.015314415097236633, -0.014923904091119766, 0.0302360188215971, -0.08143527805805206, 0.003147900104522705, 0.0330049991607666, -0.04787658900022507, -0.04559988155961037, -0.0357586070895195, 0.03491530194878578, -0.05827173963189125, 0.009421886876225471, 0.004114450886845589, 0.003014971502125263, 0.00514162378385663, -0.03245934844017029, 0.028520939871668816, 0.0029797109309583902, -0.060029394924640656, -0.06550483405590057, 0.004692416172474623, -0.024981936439871788, -0.05333077907562256, 0.009407907724380493, -0.013306405395269394, -0.05232438072562218, 0.002947528613731265, -0.07138115912675858, 0.023738255724310875, 0.026796594262123108, 0.011321050114929676, -0.053855668753385544, -0.043065138161182404, 0.011729302816092968, -0.042974188923835754, 0.030282970517873764, 0.044899314641952515, 0.04594339802861214, 0.0299942959100008, 0.026051536202430725, 0.019018802791833878, -0.038825616240501404, -0.009762140922248363, -0.0034952559508383274, -0.07322685420513153, 0.008820582181215286, -0.0055673858150839806, -0.014749683439731598, 0.018621794879436493, -0.025443827733397484, -0.004270552657544613, -0.01576990820467472, 0.032250892370939255, -0.005332190077751875, 0.059263378381729126, -0.045612335205078125, -0.07802125066518784, 0.04739334434270859, -0.02907242253422737, 0.0036393471527844667, 0.05634618550539017, 0.007376877591013908, -0.004593576304614544, -0.026870839297771454, -0.04714483767747879, 0.057178664952516556, -0.030474787577986717, 0.002143062185496092, 0.050967320799827576, 0.011563636362552643, -0.030314087867736816, -0.0472886860370636, -0.046680811792612076, -0.02703215554356575, 0.029140913859009743, 0.030376872047781944, -0.008489473722875118, -0.0005236166762188077, -0.060442063957452774, 0.01041743066161871, -0.01508118212223053, -0.05139346048235893, -0.0722791850566864, 0.06964804977178574, 0.006176619790494442, -0.032998375594615936, 0.0025203602854162455, -0.04393230751156807, 0.004003622103482485, -0.06855864077806473, -0.007935457862913609, -0.04250233620405197, 0.025800125673413277, 0.023402715101838112, 0.033606886863708496, 0.016258204355835915, 0.025139998644590378, -0.011077722534537315, 0.06226973980665207, -0.02666798047721386, -0.008487137034535408, -0.00830178614705801, 0.05380671098828316, 0.010733667761087418, 0.06065943092107773, -0.05122578516602516, 0.004618020728230476, -0.04770719259977341, 0.02908819355070591, 0.06410162895917892, 0.017203314229846, -0.04976407811045647, -0.01636906899511814, 0.014075818471610546, 0.0021285624243319035, 0.01683752052485943, -0.025515008717775345, -0.004311660770326853, 0.045461948961019516, -0.002296298975124955, -0.05772024020552635 ]
By ultrafast x-ray diffraction we show that the laser-induced magnetostructural phase transition in FeRh nanoislands proceeds faster and more complete than in continuous films. We observe an intrinsic 8 ps timescale for nucleation of ferromagnetic (FM) domains in both types of samples. For the continuous film, the substrate-near regions, which are not directly exposed to light, are only slowly transformed to the FM state by domain wall motion following heat transport. In contrast, numerical modeling of the plasmonic absorption in the investigated nanostructure reveals a strong contribution near the FeRh/MgO interface. On average, the absorption is larger and more homogeneous in the nanoislands, enabling the phase transition throughout the entire volume at the intrinsic nucleation timescale.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12683v2
[ -0.04952884092926979, 0.02469676360487938, 0.024069881066679955, 0.0013544907560572028, -0.0467945896089077, -0.038160376250743866, 0.02735034003853798, 0.019591819494962692, -0.022187598049640656, -0.037894878536462784, 0.011518781073391438, -0.046524010598659515, -0.022473182529211044, -0.06373974680900574, -0.04976121336221695, 0.04465781897306442, 0.04354548454284668, 0.006813487969338894, 0.0028361077420413494, 0.05578794330358505, 0.011234339326620102, 0.019381560385227203, -0.04624505713582039, 0.011898310855031013, -0.03691064193844795, -0.044155724346637726, -0.026405388489365578, 0.05803631246089935, 0.014625216834247112, -0.03952719643712044, 0.06275162845849991, -0.04151064530014992, -0.007318580523133278, -0.00463262852281332, 0.007514622528105974, 0.03402039408683777, -0.04874538630247116, 0.030184930190443993, 0.002533596707507968, -0.01773570291697979, -0.0062633841298520565, -0.042246393859386444, -0.011015346273779869, -0.05749300867319107, -0.05468214303255081, -0.03750224784016609, -0.03548530489206314, 0.001312438165768981, -0.052347976714372635, -0.039789874106645584, 0.03649056702852249, -0.004721721634268761, 0.003865394974127412, 0.042578089982271194, 0.005790872033685446, -0.012418791651725769, -0.049778975546360016, 0.027641890570521355, -0.022250225767493248, 0.0005110889323987067, -0.0469757542014122, -0.058601170778274536, 0.03842049464583397, -0.05654739961028099, -0.02975146844983101, -0.009460377506911755, -0.023226860910654068, -0.058357954025268555, -0.045041777193546295, -0.07044349610805511, 0.037456247955560684, -0.05525169149041176, -0.04754076525568962, 0.05686698481440544, -0.06611071527004242, -0.016289295628666878, -0.014320578426122665, -0.00036074299714528024, 0.0015846977476030588, 0.00813644751906395, -0.03760889917612076, 0.017486419528722763, -0.005952358245849609, 0.04449212923645973, -0.007279573008418083, -0.005690345540642738, 0.028504058718681335, -0.057390615344047546, -0.03921101987361908, -0.006446876097470522, 0.06304217875003815, -0.061535969376564026, -0.020062750205397606, 0.023374689742922783, 0.07545426487922668, -0.038615815341472626, 0.06005721911787987, 0.011371026746928692, 0.04558444768190384, 0.01593899354338646, 0.008608286269009113, -0.06073879078030586, -0.058174218982458115, -0.008024612441658974, -0.004914501681923866, -0.0021658630575984716, 0.00810479000210762, -0.029393350705504417, -0.039447106420993805, 0.04795878380537033, -0.01570121757686138, -0.0012231555301696062, 0.03884756937623024, 0.002839860040694475, -0.051273416727781296, -0.04819880425930023, 0.04665682092308998, -0.04155059903860092, -0.04561350494623184, 0.019889051094651222, -0.024358173832297325, 0.04796633869409561, 0.04183367267251015, -0.014968952164053917, 0.018708568066358566, 0.021121885627508163, 0.07253338396549225, -0.01162516139447689, 0.015637218952178955, -0.05384862795472145, -0.00045193391270004213, 0.05081534385681152, 0.026954567059874535, -0.04296525940299034, 0.04519633948802948, 0.008345039561390877, 0.011973520740866661, 0.0013172398321330547, -0.02166714146733284, 0.035595960915088654, 0.023197470232844353, -0.00978921353816986, 0.029613923281431198, -0.004434601403772831, -0.01565513387322426, 0.0006851512007415295, -0.08118155598640442, 0.03338177874684334, 0.05085689201951027, 0.016482457518577576, 0.009032174944877625, -0.008034219965338707, 0.005545550025999546, 0.04285858944058418, -0.03776862844824791, -0.02952362224459648, 0.03814120218157768, 0.05256519839167595, -0.028034433722496033, 0.041203711181879044, -0.012120753526687622, -0.04398837685585022, 0.042505960911512375, -0.021695654839277267, -0.030900759622454643, -0.06905944645404816, -0.026117058470845222, -0.03210146352648735, -0.011666107922792435, -0.017872681841254234, -0.03953374922275543, 0.004810768645256758, -0.012782935053110123, -0.016743406653404236, -0.05975785106420517, -0.04632599279284477, 0.003863530931994319, -0.02650785632431507, -0.03280137851834297, -0.006751372013241053, 0.04728614166378975, -0.032770153135061264, -0.036070603877305984, -0.0318470261991024, -0.047924790531396866, -0.02363363653421402, -0.08417903631925583, 0.004816827829927206, 0.040591731667518616, -0.04031086340546608, -0.03137597069144249, -0.02702774666249752, 0.029975850135087967, -0.021891267970204353, -0.032869573682546616, 0.010901442728936672, -0.064440056681633, -0.05231061205267906, 0.01945127546787262, 0.019006378948688507, -0.062268029898405075, -0.06456878781318665, -0.007047478575259447, -0.023850610479712486, 0.027748219668865204, -0.03972965106368065, 0.005623144563287497, 0.021116450428962708, 0.0047805034555494785, 0.0403529591858387, 0.005939645692706108, 0.03566473722457886, 0.0008934923098422587, -0.018502365797758102, -0.019129019230604172, -0.03248345106840134, -0.08968833833932877, -0.0043175555765628815, -0.01955900713801384, 0.02148667722940445, 0.0214560404419899, 0.0038213259540498257, -0.024552928283810616, 0.0029536366928368807, -0.04368136450648308, 0.04870358109474182, 0.06198008731007576, -0.02945862151682377, -0.030628854408860207, 0.025752030313014984, 0.03158930316567421, -0.04052833095192909, -0.06975124031305313, -0.0451170988380909, -0.04991928115487099, 0.032259099185466766, -0.06409547477960587, 0.011431018821895123, -0.032997310161590576, -0.01625186949968338, -0.03305027261376381, -0.00522890267893672, 0.018452119082212448, 0.021773869171738625, -0.0306902714073658, -0.04352431371808052, -0.03792056441307068, 0.04820917546749115, -0.04497949033975601, -0.048587996512651443, -0.021690383553504944, -0.010651269927620888, 0.03074946254491806, -0.03153947740793228, 0.024913884699344635, 0.03378179669380188, -0.017641006037592888, -0.03375422954559326, -0.040941547602415085, 0.01941230148077011, -0.011305625550448895, 0.005231891293078661, -0.04088713228702545, 0.03254087269306183, -0.04912254586815834, -0.03329860419034958, -0.06128721684217453, -0.022328447550535202, 0.007270064204931259, -0.023251600563526154, -0.023659268394112587, 0.057917315512895584, 0.021214531734585762, 0.058068592101335526, -0.03711266815662384, -0.03515365347266197, -0.03790599852800369, -0.039718832820653915, -0.013597548007965088, 0.01745390146970749, 0.04765871539711952, -0.012598694302141666, 0.014060446992516518, -0.023088576272130013, -0.032905466854572296, -0.0663471668958664, -0.007630459498614073, -0.01201583445072174, -0.016036469489336014, -0.005075535736978054, -0.05894387513399124, -0.04217497631907463, -0.03816631808876991, -0.011663457378745079, 0.05568823218345642, -0.0062833814881742, -0.05036170780658722, -0.03514447063207626, -0.015323234722018242, -0.018459217622876167, -0.05040235072374344, -0.011454601772129536, 0.04190565645694733, 0.013241098262369633, -0.037546440958976746, -0.01321050338447094, 0.01369587704539299, 0.021816179156303406, 0.023159200325608253, 0.0034914070274680853, -0.06503806263208389, 0.02519485168159008, -0.07346631586551666, -0.017312919721007347, -0.011945008300244808, 0.05296880751848221, 0.04894496127963066, -0.05725260078907013, -0.00024123328330460936, 0.036081042140722275, -0.015511730685830116, -0.059674955904483795, -0.0094856983050704, 0.020942600443959236, -0.0203236136585474, -0.049067944288253784, 0.04749290272593498, 0.049571581184864044, 0.0009592946153134108, -0.032388146966695786, -0.03948764130473137, 0.009342405945062637, 0.009075699374079704, -0.009402959607541561, 0.04132514074444771, -0.023926464840769768, -0.05297324061393738, 0.014737340621650219, -0.03438115119934082, -0.024968571960926056, 0.02231762744486332, 0.024309048429131508, 0.004102092236280441, -0.009469036012887955, 0.05715031176805496, -0.062777578830719, -0.04674791917204857, 0.032472122460603714, 0.03913117200136185, -0.03388552740216255, 0.006628451868891716, 0.03480083495378494, 0.0038753177504986525, 0.03919733688235283, 0.0028606359846889973, 0.002785283839330077, -0.013245531357824802, 0.05809303745627403, -0.0370379239320755, -0.014690804295241833, -0.04646877944469452, -0.06493733078241348, -0.025183791294693947, -0.025175023823976517, -0.01477905921638012, 0.05108712613582611, -0.0010739810531958938, -0.03389890119433403, 0.012822157703340054, -0.049080658704042435, 0.06733042001724243, -0.0133074214681983, -0.048972178250551224, -0.03293626755475998, -0.019499007612466812, -0.045276980847120285, 0.040656037628650665, -0.0037443905603140593, -0.019717933610081673, -0.053219303488731384, -0.015336842276155949, -0.015805047005414963, -0.0067763058468699455, 0.02260114625096321, -0.004065338522195816, 0.03576786071062088, 0.042186956852674484, 0.0006485137273557484, 0.024092718958854675, -0.0264268945902586, -0.012339326553046703, -0.04306647926568985, -0.05242681875824928, 0.044593632221221924, 0.03954174742102623, -0.04200223460793495, 0.009370069950819016, 0.03566312417387962, -0.026229804381728172, 0.04005962610244751, -0.00551897007972002, -0.05022628977894783, -0.03814775496721268, -0.08275054395198822, 0.0023682876490056515, -0.060746658593416214, 0.06902576237916946, 0.004372825380414724, 0.016565389931201935, 0.052064768970012665, -0.02620466984808445, 0.023314904421567917, -0.028563180938363075, 0.0027350159361958504, -0.053697340190410614, -0.05040999501943588, 0.03966914117336273, -0.04026708006858826, 0.02602771855890751, -0.021207427605986595, 0.0315275639295578, -0.030825505033135414, 0.021690670400857925, -0.05355207249522209, -0.004782399162650108, -0.03982894867658615, 0.01639130525290966, -0.0039579495787620544, -0.0027764274273067713, -0.02719253860414028, -0.018075134605169296, -0.049853090196847916, 0.03240136429667473, 0.024411654099822044, 0.02565792202949524, -0.05922120437026024, 0.004785463679581881, -0.020824050530791283, -0.059004928916692734, -0.0018832262139767408, 0.04153000935912132, 0.039906300604343414, -0.0598018541932106, -0.037453532218933105, 0.03794793412089348, -0.004643614403903484, -0.015931157395243645, -0.044190846383571625, -0.04006677493453026, 0.0064801485277712345, -0.06385893374681473, -0.011503474786877632, -0.002838125452399254, -0.028760051354765892, 0.0285439882427454, -0.019974268972873688, -0.00012174771109130234, -0.021890396252274513, -0.026352565735578537, 0.045990366488695145, -0.04322132468223572, 0.01945977285504341, -0.030650852248072624, -0.06075209751725197, -0.02002694085240364, 0.0019472684944048524, -0.026889780536293983, -0.04639168456196785, 0.0031370671931654215, -0.004114684648811817, -0.03924674168229103, 0.031507283449172974, -0.06432946026325226, 0.036787815392017365, 0.021310193464159966, -0.07567260414361954, -0.001850173226557672, 0.03669024631381035, -0.013925825245678425, 0.024329546838998795, 0.01577536016702652, 0.0304811242967844, -0.01706012897193432, -0.047553081065416336, -0.0511506050825119, 0.02431051805615425, -0.04831388592720032, -0.004346028435975313, 0.005885347258299589, 0.03462022915482521, -0.05337926000356674, 0.04146965220570564, 0.033555664122104645, -0.02501109056174755, 0.03567337244749069, 0.013204636052250862, 0.04985203966498375, 0.0036667108070105314, -0.041437212377786636, -0.0015634279698133469, -0.0172499381005764, -0.015906712040305138, 0.03975594416260719, -0.05849025025963783, -0.039210494607686996, 0.03920726105570793, 0.019166626036167145, 0.025012614205479622, 0.004399491939693689, -0.04994857311248779, -0.026222584769129753, 0.03455527871847153, -0.028055721893906593, -0.07512665539979935, -0.013891486451029778, -0.07977888733148575, -0.024976883083581924, -0.025419438257813454, 0.030561666935682297, 0.04798093065619469, 0.07275383174419403, -0.0071438695304095745, -0.017896831035614014, -0.02274802140891552, -0.024208059534430504, 0.04393364116549492, -0.04697193577885628, -0.04515484347939491, 0.009687806479632854, 0.05955849215388298, -0.023558853194117546, 0.011301234364509583, 0.001043455209583044, 0.02613113261759281, -0.043379489332437515, -0.018192799761891365, 0.016072366386651993, 0.0025767995975911617, -0.063102126121521, -0.03889083489775658, 0.045482899993658066, -0.0645068883895874, 0.04096347093582153, 0.005983765237033367, -0.016327114775776863, -0.0007891995483078063, 0.014778896234929562, 0.005012070294469595, -0.04216127097606659, -0.01689029484987259, 0.07078060507774353, -0.07842318713665009, -0.033923257142305374, -0.03562479093670845, 0.0012373514473438263, -0.027170592918992043, -0.056869715452194214, -0.019098469987511635, 0.032620348036289215, -0.05446450412273407, -0.049381475895643234, 0.007836309261620045, -0.0047589195892214775, -0.06757298111915588, -0.054523322731256485, 0.04445513337850571, -0.06253921240568161, -0.050510287284851074, 0.05391967296600342, -0.015175898559391499, -0.05802593007683754, -0.027898326516151428, -0.046129368245601654, -0.05432181432843208, -0.01033099740743637, 0.0006508137448690832, 0.04861241951584816, -0.005895392969250679, -0.015352199785411358, -0.03081570938229561, 0.018083661794662476, 0.014366782270371914, -0.05058807507157326, -0.010006275959312916, -0.016154499724507332, 0.01335899531841278, -0.013507152907550335, -0.05825257673859596, 0.01984172686934471, 0.05348256230354309, -0.059896863996982574, -0.02414795570075512, 0.013070219196379185, 0.008643788285553455, 0.030137741938233376, -0.07334370911121368, -0.042428553104400635, 0.035828739404678345, -0.031460680067539215, 0.0072950818575918674, -0.03651963174343109, -0.02554829604923725, -0.028563860803842545, 0.016963589936494827, 0.0477006733417511, -0.053722843527793884, -0.0024780803360044956, -0.04944060742855072, -0.05380495637655258, 0.02373182773590088, -0.030076853930950165, -0.042461104691028595, 0.011134196072816849, 0.007626740261912346, 0.023939628154039383, 0.0031222584657371044, -0.0475829653441906, -0.0438486710190773, -0.06365450471639633, 0.010192539542913437, 0.002388634718954563, -0.04521249234676361, 0.0474364273250103, -0.015741851180791855, 0.007568388245999813, -0.05473523214459419, -0.05160641670227051, -0.028133073821663857, -0.06944762170314789, 0.010036746971309185, -0.002780524780973792, -0.016286393627524376, -0.01191590167582035, 0.01904224045574665, 0.02445649914443493, 0.00846804678440094, -0.0010668019531294703, -0.0021658586338162422, -0.03272291645407677, -0.013226744718849659, -0.024320734664797783, -0.0358673632144928, 0.04828261211514473, -0.017022518441081047, 0.009856835938990116, -0.04781211540102959, 0.03871193900704384, 0.017256570979952812, 0.00418756902217865, 0.017008444294333458, -0.04013241082429886, 0.002911707852035761, 0.05214235559105873, -0.029936641454696655, -0.04171714931726456, -0.036620132625103, -0.057464420795440674, -0.07002981752157211, -0.014772792346775532, 0.021892927587032318, 0.03836267068982124, -0.02167181670665741, -0.04629635810852051, 0.00041552152833901346, 0.04915454983711243, -0.014957892708480358, -0.08094645291566849, 0.027388079091906548, 0.03032602369785309, -0.028056425973773003, -0.012424235232174397, 0.012897786684334278, -0.03436722233891487, -0.058352429419755936, -0.07490251213312149, -0.023710574954748154, -0.04934704303741455, 0.07821327447891235, 0.02304663322865963, -0.03416619077324867, -0.03664868324995041, -0.05227482318878174, -0.0385272316634655, 0.0583844818174839, 0.029463347047567368, 0.018636183813214302, -0.013297200202941895, -0.01622563973069191, -0.05370175838470459, -0.0037696922663599253, 0.017570478841662407, -0.040135759860277176, -0.008277161046862602, -0.0005186417838558555, -0.021638182923197746, 0.007354986388236284, 0.012994338758289814, 0.05384959653019905, 0.01687929593026638, 0.008430296555161476, -0.014885533601045609, -0.059206705540418625, -0.031017456203699112, 0.003991234581917524, -0.01619793474674225, -0.058741290122270584, 0.023075206205248833, 0.03312898427248001, 0.011880679987370968, -0.015003564767539501, -0.032729845494031906, -0.06310376524925232, -0.0013917699689045548, 0.017207084223628044, 0.022510044276714325, 0.0507211796939373, -0.05471622198820114, -0.04240325093269348, 0.011337697505950928, -0.016443705186247826, -0.04600190743803978, 0.03432289510965347, 0.01877797581255436, -0.018387475982308388, 0.005762595217674971, -0.07355525344610214, 0.06289777159690857, -0.02370379865169525, -0.0005849432782270014, 0.0033841088879853487, 0.03156368434429169, -0.07611742615699768, 0.011806008405983448, -0.02520064078271389, -0.06447306275367737, 0.01390818040817976, -0.032236404716968536, 0.005619068164378405, 0.02433956228196621, 0.010934527032077312, -0.038096316158771515, 0.04142061620950699, -0.03483731299638748, 0.027317503467202187, 0.021348852664232254, 0.01354051474481821, -0.03837977722287178, -0.04740986227989197, -0.04398031905293465, 0.04452769458293915, 0.010517646558582783, 0.010126451961696148, -0.06369100511074066, 0.050348103046417236, -0.003879518248140812, 0.03529563546180725, 0.0016437179874628782, 0.013763557188212872, 0.04703238606452942, -0.05207636579871178, -0.057854656130075455, 0.017667507752776146, 0.016136249527335167, -0.02982708066701889, 0.0006347028538584709, -0.04587322846055031, -0.013156844303011894, -0.023283425718545914 ]
Co-salient Object Detection (CoSOD) endeavors to replicate the human visual system's capacity to recognize common and salient objects within a collection of images. Despite recent advancements in deep learning models, these models still rely on training with well-annotated CoSOD datasets. The exploration of training-free zero-shot CoSOD frameworks has been limited. In this paper, taking inspiration from the zero-shot transfer capabilities of foundational computer vision models, we introduce the first zero-shot CoSOD framework that harnesses these models without any training process. To achieve this, we introduce two novel components in our proposed framework: the group prompt generation (GPG) module and the co-saliency map generation (CMP) module. We evaluate the framework's performance on widely-used datasets and observe impressive results. Our approach surpasses existing unsupervised methods and even outperforms fully supervised methods developed before 2020, while remaining competitive with some fully supervised methods developed before 2022.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05499v3
[ -0.0000975581060629338, -0.026155518367886543, 0.02521906979382038, 0.0247206948697567, -0.0035403945948928595, -0.018935546278953552, 0.04040166363120079, 0.033966414630413055, 0.0057317339815199375, -0.02607407607138157, -0.015577241778373718, 0.03429381921887398, -0.04608866199851036, -0.04824388399720192, -0.03418799117207527, 0.026630757376551628, 0.07076602429151535, -0.007235495839267969, -0.05037249997258186, 0.07137700915336609, 0.017857979983091354, -0.027134239673614502, -0.040038079023361206, -0.007837992161512375, -0.024361856281757355, 0.007539344485849142, -0.03606652840971947, -0.001273543108254671, -0.030628260225057602, -0.03131706267595291, 0.05883985757827759, -0.01480594277381897, 0.007942693307995796, -0.05613604560494423, -0.03649764508008957, 0.007766198366880417, 0.0028809818904846907, 0.02222684770822525, 0.019081218168139458, -0.06925751268863678, 0.004746664315462112, -0.07403553277254105, -0.07740999013185501, 0.0012351471232250333, 0.0241247545927763, -0.036302272230386734, -0.04910716414451599, 0.020001210272312164, -0.05701224505901337, -0.05425676703453064, 0.017499050125479698, -0.014682003296911716, -0.005308372434228659, 0.03466389700770378, -0.024617008864879608, 0.006403819192200899, -0.016616009175777435, 0.06205110624432564, -0.04070226848125458, 0.016567813232541084, 0.0460660345852375, -0.0010652432683855295, -0.00749948900192976, -0.01518719457089901, 0.048268385231494904, 0.06309899687767029, 0.012445400469005108, -0.06842587143182755, -0.05666036531329155, -0.01760978065431118, 0.06484507024288177, -0.06073935702443123, 0.005293882451951504, 0.0072662802413105965, -0.04371650889515877, -0.03384004160761833, -0.06537553668022156, -0.04875766113400459, -0.0009383305441588163, -0.0010860491311177611, -0.006345250643789768, 0.02626325935125351, 0.05014597997069359, 0.01246145460754633, -0.03780399635434151, -0.0041411640122532845, -0.011106904596090317, -0.03097422420978546, -0.003019005060195923, -0.054597850888967514, 0.05104032903909683, -0.054900411516427994, -0.07981299608945847, 0.034247271716594696, 0.06026782467961311, -0.03565624728798866, 0.04027242958545685, 0.05720452964305878, 0.016513081267476082, 0.00800811406224966, -0.013169413432478905, 0.025559181347489357, -0.019931940361857414, -0.012727889232337475, 0.016584711149334908, 0.01750219240784645, 0.04352737218141556, -0.02438843809068203, -0.030253702774643898, 0.003891747910529375, 0.0015598840545862913, -0.007991082035005093, -0.03446478024125099, -0.07915007323026657, -0.04243510961532593, -0.037119876593351364, 0.024786990135908127, -0.02799396403133869, 0.009910864755511284, -0.006003342568874359, 0.020899983122944832, 0.026607699692249298, 0.04900525510311127, -0.022857289761304855, -0.024943124502897263, -0.04693938046693802, 0.027609826996922493, -0.03991270065307617, -0.01828661561012268, -0.02687809057533741, -0.015508715063333511, 0.03709761053323746, -0.023155556991696358, -0.029866572469472885, 0.06328408420085907, -0.018630413338541985, 0.014161610044538975, -0.05014735460281372, 0.03827457129955292, -0.030609294772148132, -0.05330325663089752, -0.061218176037073135, -0.008839767426252365, -0.040559519082307816, 0.024228397756814957, 0.07030808925628662, 0.01636102795600891, -0.011986702680587769, 0.03543497622013092, 0.045541562139987946, 0.0038888028357177973, 0.0012638968182727695, 0.019905399531126022, 0.04950294271111488, -0.0234675370156765, -0.02476992830634117, 0.035408396273851395, -0.017637815326452255, -0.06279221177101135, 0.013894337229430676, -0.012971237301826477, -0.0013256921665742993, 0.05356166511774063, -0.037552643567323685, 0.042638376355171204, 0.01256595179438591, 0.018913304433226585, -0.043283507227897644, -0.0007591622415930033, 0.03563953563570976, 0.015194070525467396, -0.05062679201364517, 0.022429155185818672, 0.0044030179269611835, -0.03294137865304947, 0.004869753494858742, -0.01472246553748846, -0.06904438883066177, -0.06809599697589874, 0.031302813440561295, -0.010659366846084595, 0.03867042437195778, -0.016679733991622925, -0.012666395865380764, -0.05253193527460098, -0.006999138277024031, -0.07500136643648148, -0.04866950586438179, 0.02864000014960766, 0.02486131712794304, -0.04741041362285614, -0.007957969792187214, 0.022921018302440643, 0.031220218166708946, -0.03657325357198715, -0.028518807142972946, 0.007437191437929869, -0.012776700779795647, 0.029276367276906967, 0.02230859361588955, -0.09530408680438995, -0.03976763039827347, -0.04908493906259537, -0.00738374562934041, -0.03938426822423935, -0.02981385588645935, -0.028251711279153824, 0.03198704496026039, -0.04848024994134903, 0.0004355479031801224, -0.007461036089807749, 0.03848990052938461, 0.07541712373495102, 0.004469443112611771, 0.044672269374132156, 0.030382530763745308, -0.10093196481466293, 0.05494820699095726, 0.02340357005596161, -0.0012580285547301173, 0.04834742099046707, 0.009250286035239697, -0.015944497659802437, -0.03484512120485306, -0.028614811599254608, 0.05398373678326607, 0.06117051839828491, 0.01952284201979637, -0.04235988110303879, -0.001280847704038024, -0.011492528952658176, -0.048426076769828796, 0.0010028115939348936, -0.0552627295255661, -0.05328071489930153, -0.01563062146306038, -0.05016801133751869, 0.05725264549255371, 0.015473374165594578, -0.06142465025186539, -0.021337954327464104, -0.0189026091247797, 0.05336553603410721, -0.06344179809093475, -0.03524015471339226, -0.020168429240584373, 0.0035280180163681507, 0.03510283678770065, -0.008963637985289097, -0.009716644883155823, -0.02819198928773403, -0.041005689650774, 0.024317143484950066, 0.011048530228435993, 0.061931781470775604, 0.03791418671607971, -0.04564007371664047, -0.007552380673587322, -0.03316129744052887, 0.024871522560715675, 0.03844023868441582, -0.004613819997757673, -0.021292520686984062, 0.016306409612298012, 0.05240246281027794, 0.02731500379741192, -0.021510815247893333, -0.0348985381424427, 0.015432476997375488, -0.04192374274134636, -0.00969424657523632, 0.04296256601810455, 0.04195351153612137, 0.024556957185268402, -0.008844132535159588, 0.0033297021873295307, -0.007898188196122646, -0.04035024344921112, 0.032812993973493576, 0.04940453916788101, 0.0015706875128671527, 0.01773332804441452, 0.003082532435655594, -0.07142821699380875, -0.033196281641721725, -0.03971611335873604, -0.03681687265634537, -0.03205017372965813, -0.06851547211408615, -0.024075794965028763, -0.07603172957897186, -0.041776638478040695, -0.01860692910850048, -0.03033917210996151, 0.004071625880897045, -0.025716746225953102, -0.026228036731481552, 0.03297591954469681, -0.012837987393140793, 0.025132324546575546, -0.019067350775003433, -0.038456957787275314, -0.013831861317157745, 0.012934979982674122, -0.004343037027865648, -0.07359123975038528, -0.05065097287297249, 0.016937434673309326, 0.005820741411298513, 0.005474992096424103, 0.002039166633039713, 0.04721686244010925, 0.01693972572684288, 0.009147260338068008, 0.0281564649194479, 0.04123575612902641, 0.0011586492182686925, 0.0652705729007721, 0.013419194146990776, -0.017044100910425186, -0.01250680536031723, 0.003132828278467059, -0.010691031813621521, -0.03629525378346443, -0.05385648459196091, -0.033549822866916656, 0.06028473749756813, 0.029777809977531433, -0.0677911639213562, -0.012566393241286278, 0.027396244928240776, -0.016520172357559204, 0.018726767972111702, -0.030217211693525314, 0.017073580995202065, 0.013506142422556877, -0.04369450360536575, -0.030824894085526466, 0.01141297072172165, 0.0009999893372878432, -0.004752947948873043, 0.007337937597185373, -0.06651036441326141, -0.04114941135048866, 0.08050084114074707, -0.09479814767837524, 0.016600849106907845, 0.03234896808862686, 0.06108277291059494, -0.0027534249238669872, -0.0007217379752546549, -0.00007235260272864252, 0.046053387224674225, 0.014977454207837582, 0.024260643869638443, 0.06107625737786293, -0.0203836802393198, 0.04733025282621384, -0.0007903478690423071, -0.05267980694770813, 0.026308737695217133, -0.046370964497327805, -0.06053426116704941, 0.026112593710422516, 0.03870977461338043, -0.027819329872727394, -0.001727152499370277, -0.06702146679162979, -0.019480543211102486, 0.0076453606598079205, 0.016089119017124176, -0.02533385530114174, -0.037427790462970734, 0.014730129390954971, -0.058561455458402634, 0.012965856119990349, -0.013095010071992874, -0.0034621974918991327, -0.01528509333729744, -0.06202103942632675, -0.008298909291625023, -0.05659119039773941, 0.06604620069265366, 0.019342394545674324, 0.018074767664074898, 0.024202581495046616, 0.06585749983787537, 0.007021437399089336, 0.0674777626991272, -0.038857053965330124, -0.024779360741376877, -0.0037424417678266764, 0.012679795734584332, -0.021079443395137787, -0.0421651266515255, -0.03723997622728348, -0.025004271417856216, -0.030887853354215622, -0.011870712973177433, -0.03295378014445305, -0.005353040061891079, -0.01637192629277706, -0.0290821623057127, -0.08145277947187424, -0.02754819206893444, -0.004962264560163021, 0.043447863310575485, 0.015524927526712418, -0.05063062906265259, 0.06417383253574371, -0.04022221639752388, 0.0005387737764976919, -0.025807559490203857, 0.016717705875635147, -0.03513091057538986, -0.0335904099047184, -0.024820446968078613, -0.08799593150615692, 0.01365977805107832, 0.011190772987902164, 0.0666428804397583, 0.019840296357870102, -0.010564472526311874, -0.04641292989253998, -0.050836436450481415, 0.0005716746090911329, -0.020292405039072037, 0.015723293647170067, -0.03104693815112114, -0.019005674868822098, -0.04445648938417435, 0.014167298562824726, -0.001849520136602223, -0.0295170359313488, 0.044270485639572144, -0.052307482808828354, 0.06563159823417664, -0.018023686483502388, -0.04663156718015671, -0.042279526591300964, -0.027293695136904716, 0.030256491154432297, -0.01309980545192957, -0.06001937761902809, -0.07369126379489899, 0.017186598852276802, -0.0026657318230718374, -0.02232455275952816, -0.039752453565597534, -0.022411759942770004, -0.04262729734182358, 0.004490312188863754, -0.01262897439301014, 0.019168155267834663, 0.01181437261402607, -0.036966681480407715, 0.01523812860250473, 0.004142590798437595, 0.0030087896157056093, 0.01625593565404415, 0.02808888629078865, -0.027253665030002594, -0.005104361101984978, -0.041085224598646164, -0.07215714454650879, 0.0003820226702373475, -0.05618031695485115, -0.013686257414519787, 0.002448481507599354, 0.019783632829785347, 0.022151866927742958, 0.06571543216705322, -0.09354472160339355, 0.01531403511762619, 0.015638675540685654, -0.010638928040862083, 0.03473331034183502, 0.05891003832221031, 0.003733271500095725, 0.019006675109267235, -0.01003189291805029, -0.004968881607055664, 0.04729609191417694, -0.007752770557999611, -0.035672876983881, 0.020685499534010887, -0.03544607013463974, -0.04891127347946167, 0.034495409578084946, -0.001910206861793995, -0.06752777844667435, 0.03262409567832947, 0.018857937306165695, -0.014829011633992195, -0.0395980030298233, 0.03455464541912079, 0.036604490131139755, -0.019228115677833557, -0.03827354684472084, 0.01379548478871584, -0.010502341203391552, -0.018740497529506683, 0.020747600123286247, -0.007706725969910622, 0.004787954967468977, 0.06168735772371292, -0.0036836948711425066, -0.01176370494067669, 0.014295080676674843, 0.036857932806015015, 0.05507763475179672, -0.027037670835852623, 0.01845930702984333, -0.03384067863225937, -0.012374679557979107, -0.031748466193675995, 0.023465994745492935, 0.01892348937690258, 0.02722126990556717, -0.005617189686745405, 0.01710326410830021, 0.012768404558300972, 0.009050320833921432, -0.0017850390868261456, -0.0301392562687397, 0.010110707022249699, -0.041674088686704636, 0.0441078320145607, 0.016252154484391212, -0.017709551379084587, -0.02872229740023613, 0.03515741229057312, 0.005355164408683777, 0.027528995648026466, -0.030132601037621498, -0.017452837899327278, 0.013068554922938347, -0.06761389225721359, -0.03874631226062775, 0.04160691797733307, -0.010438989847898483, -0.03556410223245621, -0.017446579411625862, 0.07087680697441101, -0.017889413982629776, 0.04217696189880371, -0.0057692923583090305, -0.0027511995285749435, -0.06615634262561798, 0.0062154559418559074, 0.062018606811761856, -0.06311146169900894, -0.012175142765045166, -0.04197302088141441, -0.03194389119744301, 0.010086122900247574, -0.034216128289699554, 0.021828733384609222, 0.038472071290016174, -0.0038672471418976784, -0.04952363669872284, 0.04848785325884819, -0.0041860053315758705, -0.06171901151537895, 0.013720164075493813, 0.004316354636102915, -0.07811684906482697, -0.05359407141804695, -0.03698189929127693, 0.009156369604170322, -0.013984116725623608, 0.03778247907757759, 0.029574517160654068, 0.019559679552912712, -0.028267033398151398, 0.07604049891233444, 0.0860985741019249, -0.002412134548649192, -0.004153873771429062, 0.002739593153819442, -0.06795705854892731, 0.02241448126733303, -0.05701465532183647, 0.014620010741055012, 0.039691176265478134, 0.028631247580051422, 0.023483702912926674, -0.06636610627174377, -0.04599669948220253, 0.05130670964717865, -0.029654787853360176, 0.015910929068922997, 0.006047908682376146, -0.03073211759328842, 0.03517733886837959, -0.030841447412967682, -0.0267742108553648, 0.033123016357421875, -0.03346622735261917, -0.004223837051540613, -0.025943955406546593, 0.005868491251021624, -0.012494327500462532, 0.0014654748374596238, 0.029575053602457047, -0.060673490166664124, 0.0020481792744249105, -0.051272012293338776, -0.03566092252731323, -0.006273927632719278, -0.05662821978330612, 0.04628988355398178, -0.009651504456996918, 0.03248899430036545, 0.04378537833690643, 0.0777231752872467, -0.03096599690616131, -0.04404317960143089, 0.04453551396727562, -0.025325262919068336, 0.0029802846256643534, 0.01874081790447235, 0.06303299963474274, 0.015310916118323803, 0.025098692625761032, -0.02868993580341339, -0.021129418164491653, -0.015714459121227264, -0.07307375222444534, 0.039325322955846786, 0.009914160706102848, -0.02570653147995472, -0.014377128332853317, 0.0046404083259403706, -0.0450887493789196, 0.010456858202815056, 0.026562126353383064, -0.05674825981259346, -0.06260170042514801, -0.012510077096521854, -0.011707516387104988, 0.00829925574362278, 0.000303816661471501, 0.033608924597501755, 0.04739030823111534, -0.01059256587177515, 0.03679120913147926, 0.03464416414499283, 0.005221331957727671, -0.03315624222159386, -0.04236598685383797, -0.03786719962954521, -0.002424138132482767, 0.005752389319241047, -0.046128980815410614, -0.05480773746967316, -0.0030175659339874983, -0.06645316630601883, 0.021999554708600044, 0.05792141333222389, -0.00017561987624503672, -0.014733787626028061, -0.06593389064073563, 0.04201669245958328, 0.022084200754761696, -0.05873039364814758, -0.03189247474074364, 0.011566703207790852, -0.009232180193066597, -0.026757633313536644, 0.008689620532095432, -0.025304801762104034, -0.04231785237789154, 0.014984716661274433, -0.08335914462804794, 0.030285529792308807, 0.025799402967095375, 0.01829095371067524, 0.012286693789064884, -0.05172738805413246, 0.019413290545344353, -0.05515407398343086, -0.01930529624223709, 0.033793896436691284, -0.002770902356132865, -0.01662401109933853, -0.003368123434484005, 0.04206760600209236, -0.0702083483338356, -0.04127969592809677, 0.013331269845366478, -0.04340542107820511, -0.022925520315766335, 0.009537257254123688, 0.015667526051402092, 0.0589994341135025, 0.019082607701420784, 0.04987190291285515, -0.012415613979101181, 0.032177798449993134, -0.044079430401325226, 0.01816094107925892, -0.04967642202973366, -0.05000768601894379, 0.039057593792676926, -0.01119196880608797, 0.00024504540488123894, 0.03330899775028229, -0.008477071300148964, 0.030134601518511772, -0.04042638838291168, -0.024440990760922432, 0.04146765172481537, -0.03630875423550606, 0.00518779456615448, 0.04282839968800545, -0.06079809367656708, -0.021019574254751205, -0.025367790833115578, -0.026918532326817513, -0.019928954541683197, 0.015362960286438465, 0.055198948830366135, -0.024931589141488075, 0.028725797310471535, -0.05678081512451172, -0.03434936702251434, 0.019353194162249565, -0.003448410192504525, -0.024914827197790146, 0.06489203870296478, 0.010100221261382103, -0.04528484866023064, -0.013094592839479446, -0.015208314172923565, 0.007017430849373341, -0.02988061122596264, -0.03665982559323311, -0.04637743532657623, 0.028943350538611412, -0.019135354086756706, -0.02189629338681698, 0.02337566763162613, 0.026563331484794617, 0.044253405183553696, -0.012792272493243217, 0.029453840106725693, 0.0359562411904335, -0.05262470245361328, 0.06973405182361603, 0.01463327370584011, 0.015347261913120747, -0.02063324674963951, 0.06338328868150711, 0.02102476730942726, -0.027801908552646637, -0.006169318687170744, 0.015590707771480083, 0.02546853758394718, -0.06188319995999336, 0.0015497622080147266, 0.058560531586408615, -0.009531551040709019, -0.03893488645553589, -0.016975929960608482, -0.02184170112013817, -0.058308519423007965, -0.03787064924836159 ]
We obtain an analytical solution for the time-optimal control problem in the induction phase of anesthesia. Our solution is shown to align numerically with the results obtained from the conventional shooting method. The induction phase of anesthesia relies on a pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PK/PD) model proposed by Bailey and Haddad in 2005 to regulate the infusion of propofol. In order to evaluate our approach and compare it with existing results in the literature, we examine a minimum-time problem for anesthetizing a patient. By applying the Pontryagin minimum principle, we introduce the shooting method as a means to solve the problem at hand. Additionally, we conducted numerical simulations using the MATLAB computing environment. We solve the time-optimal control problem using our newly proposed analytical method and discover that the optimal continuous infusion rate of the anesthetic and the minimum required time for transition from the awake state to an anesthetized state exhibit similarity between the two methods. However, the advantage of our new analytic method lies in its independence from unknown initial conditions for the adjoint variables.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04787v1
[ 0.0006525339558720589, -0.000012670780051848851, 0.043063513934612274, -0.0014067469164729118, -0.007665254175662994, -0.01767347939312458, 0.013958989642560482, -0.01694636233150959, -0.019170209765434265, -0.004257495515048504, -0.05891460180282593, 0.003788636066019535, -0.03316544368863106, -0.07530670613050461, -0.0025573386810719967, 0.03543541207909584, 0.07829789817333221, 0.012643125839531422, -0.017467429861426353, 0.06242753565311432, -0.012993251904845238, -0.02693755179643631, -0.032278873026371, 0.037000786513090134, -0.01731679029762745, -0.013818370178341866, -0.012713136151432991, -0.019964024424552917, -0.06008703261613846, -0.0012589188991114497, 0.05103152617812157, -0.04838373512029648, -0.021777935326099396, -0.042188867926597595, -0.03936880826950073, -0.031426604837179184, 0.014787094667553902, -0.018718961626291275, 0.05033412203192711, -0.039196960628032684, 0.025357339531183243, -0.07387839257717133, -0.04432784020900726, 0.013956754468381405, 0.022457275539636612, 0.011525456793606281, -0.06505138427019119, 0.044779278337955475, -0.05555623397231102, -0.06088518351316452, 0.0102408267557621, 0.03640902787446976, -0.04722967743873596, 0.009380689822137356, -0.07546375691890717, -0.0053245145827531815, -0.019989458844065666, 0.026959462091326714, -0.0691952183842659, -0.03874323517084122, 0.028622668236494064, 0.010101821273565292, -0.021337220445275307, 0.003594066482037306, -0.0063957227393984795, 0.035206954926252365, -0.014372787438333035, -0.0639214813709259, -0.04628852754831314, -0.07561753690242767, 0.032002318650484085, -0.04642771929502487, -0.016421493142843246, 0.020676443353295326, 0.01813007891178131, -0.05614741891622543, -0.03778650239109993, 0.006804768927395344, 0.005457904655486345, 0.030334051698446274, -0.045837294310331345, 0.016462082043290138, -0.004199204035103321, 0.017922809347510338, 0.04771764203906059, -0.00931214913725853, 0.008660470135509968, -0.029145875945687294, -0.010325086303055286, -0.0350867435336113, 0.05670327693223953, -0.05765977129340172, -0.04958399385213852, 0.03508593887090683, 0.07014398276805878, -0.04713791608810425, 0.018217235803604126, 0.030276622623205185, 0.0349264070391655, 0.013242342509329319, 0.008588056080043316, 0.02193908393383026, -0.05244878679513931, 0.026828790083527565, 0.029829302802681923, -0.03975304961204529, 0.016414489597082138, -0.030714422464370728, -0.008656950667500496, -0.0422893650829792, -0.042329851537942886, -0.053408633917570114, -0.0103684701025486, -0.026125291362404823, -0.05217443406581879, -0.030570073053240776, 0.05241762846708298, -0.012057299725711346, 0.02973855473101139, -0.029257331043481827, -0.03723418340086937, 0.03911827504634857, 0.008576932363212109, 0.05196152999997139, -0.04301384836435318, 0.008522825315594673, 0.03544049710035324, 0.019459426403045654, -0.03716331347823143, -0.016655899584293365, -0.042453959584236145, 0.04008278250694275, -0.014004480093717575, -0.0029693737160414457, 0.01857941411435604, 0.04531792178750038, -0.03533468768000603, -0.03276714310050011, 0.061134882271289825, 0.04882701486349106, -0.04646232724189758, -0.028984270989894867, 0.0030694555025547743, -0.049582548439502716, -0.046725016087293625, 0.03957610949873924, -0.059524547308683395, 0.0030316219199448824, 0.04764396697282791, 0.024531515315175056, -0.002046697773039341, 0.018071334809064865, 0.015554637648165226, 0.045759525150060654, 0.003497801721096039, 0.015000424347817898, 0.04999151825904846, 0.001016570022329688, -0.039477232843637466, 0.03671170026063919, 0.03307061642408371, -0.005837755743414164, 0.038066014647483826, -0.015510987490415573, 0.005221015773713589, 0.01615135371685028, 0.020343376323580742, 0.0009144527139142156, -0.018870942294597626, -0.012176950462162495, -0.008428245782852173, -0.054701488465070724, 0.019103344529867172, -0.021001925691962242, -0.02365758828818798, -0.06697236001491547, 0.030597813427448273, -0.02665133960545063, -0.0720999464392662, -0.04839491844177246, 0.04598749056458473, -0.005195275414735079, -0.04955616965889931, 0.008077926002442837, -0.03249253332614899, 0.01304546743631363, -0.07908833771944046, -0.012886789627373219, 0.06693871319293976, 0.020199131220579147, -0.023601122200489044, -0.00544967083260417, 0.023637134581804276, 0.03187296539545059, -0.049015045166015625, -0.03408127650618553, -0.020037448033690453, 0.008027260191738605, 0.02326027862727642, 0.03956824541091919, -0.06812600791454315, -0.028147811070084572, -0.0719994381070137, 0.024836838245391846, -0.04349898919463158, -0.03408382460474968, 0.0018448194023221731, 0.052285123616456985, -0.04008995741605759, 0.014712159521877766, 0.011085470207035542, 0.03575299680233002, 0.04639754071831703, 0.012718075886368752, 0.040046993643045425, -0.006348967086523771, -0.09495439380407333, 0.06541892886161804, -0.028862863779067993, 0.01013814378529787, 0.012790897861123085, -0.00975691806524992, -0.010053333826363087, -0.03522596135735512, -0.04019922390580177, 0.06520587205886841, 0.02970896102488041, 0.02062949351966381, -0.0504005141556263, -0.03686342388391495, 0.02084931917488575, -0.054508987814188004, -0.04117199406027794, -0.03471957519650459, -0.03384833782911301, 0.033091455698013306, -0.014235660433769226, 0.03856229409575462, 0.011167234741151333, -0.026791945099830627, -0.05728910118341446, -0.02067384123802185, 0.054348789155483246, -0.025784336030483246, -0.019639695063233376, -0.007401066832244396, -0.020911626517772675, 0.04194829985499382, -0.019744303077459335, -0.008403349667787552, 0.007018547039479017, -0.0350775383412838, -0.015748141333460808, -0.02500329352915287, -0.0017841662047430873, 0.03704836592078209, -0.0094916932284832, 0.012763986364006996, 0.005099763162434101, 0.042303334921598434, 0.021685417741537094, 0.06255754083395004, -0.02898402325809002, -0.009014463052153587, 0.01676703616976738, 0.04338672384619713, -0.008239688351750374, 0.02556913159787655, 0.007069744635373354, -0.02933495305478573, 0.020641040056943893, -0.0025405080523341894, -0.018334316089749336, 0.053430669009685516, 0.0013119408395141363, -0.015580371022224426, -0.01696018874645233, -0.035542115569114685, 0.05226582661271095, 0.0396355539560318, 0.0404454730451107, -0.009925754740834236, 0.02849084697663784, -0.07615713030099869, -0.025758398696780205, -0.052271340042352676, 0.00468008266761899, -0.0452284999191761, -0.04732994735240936, -0.00240388629026711, -0.08132791519165039, -0.007867526262998581, 0.005750264972448349, -0.03189805895090103, -0.028432821854948997, -0.04771893471479416, -0.0481531135737896, -0.016386203467845917, 0.06052205339074135, -0.026417752727866173, -0.08303181827068329, -0.02877742610871792, -0.007338235154747963, 0.00958105269819498, 0.04655127599835396, 0.0030202141497284174, -0.02808842435479164, -0.012442653998732567, 0.03515057638287544, 0.06580813229084015, -0.00920411478728056, 0.03478946164250374, -0.006256855558604002, 0.012339324690401554, -0.015442793257534504, 0.012034185230731964, 0.027974938973784447, 0.022556520998477936, -0.005751721560955048, -0.037641800940036774, -0.00808718241751194, 0.007335000205785036, -0.015028554014861584, 0.003973326645791531, -0.05808454379439354, -0.02939257025718689, 0.0485956147313118, 0.043655794113874435, 0.015413880348205566, -0.02836652845144272, -0.03414471819996834, -0.045132603496313095, 0.0383518747985363, 0.00009707577555673197, 0.06827160716056824, 0.0035843350924551487, -0.034947335720062256, -0.06295282393693924, -0.03159897029399872, -0.02725086733698845, -0.010169913992285728, 0.031047793105244637, -0.019197652116417885, 0.017490414902567863, 0.032098084688186646, -0.08405502140522003, -0.013862541876733303, 0.025426097214221954, 0.011386904865503311, -0.006886306218802929, 0.005027341656386852, -0.033880166709423065, 0.011248769238591194, -0.04406394809484482, 0.02094435691833496, 0.01357174851000309, 0.02071520686149597, 0.022176317870616913, -0.0019643642008304596, -0.03383710980415344, 0.027003230527043343, -0.06088017299771309, -0.060158487409353256, 0.01664927788078785, 0.0180277768522501, -0.010713311843574047, 0.00340666645206511, -0.04409145563840866, 0.004111545160412788, -0.04183855280280113, 0.0334000289440155, -0.014733943156898022, -0.04734056070446968, 0.0037669490557163954, -0.04385099932551384, 0.01343914307653904, 0.05726654827594757, 0.0053119114600121975, -0.01020611822605133, -0.060271214693784714, 0.038358841091394424, -0.06073342636227608, 0.04103422164916992, 0.04749840870499611, 0.01071386318653822, 0.008158262819051743, 0.05071819946169853, -0.017731597647070885, 0.014081408269703388, -0.015208211727440357, -0.04825742915272713, -0.04089679196476936, 0.04030022770166397, -0.03598611801862717, 0.013394292443990707, -0.05752933397889137, 0.013067022897303104, 0.021621571853756905, 0.0178506001830101, -0.0041101365350186825, -0.0259195938706398, -0.03286420926451683, 0.004520229529589415, -0.08160071820020676, -0.04336059093475342, -0.04666455462574959, 0.05010353401303291, 0.007351865526288748, -0.07005374133586884, 0.04886950924992561, -0.022593330591917038, -0.014905763790011406, -0.05356055498123169, -0.06815794855356216, -0.012298192828893661, -0.03145191818475723, -0.01439857017248869, -0.06429603695869446, 0.04170657694339752, -0.031548015773296356, 0.024174315854907036, 0.009327459149062634, -0.038602691143751144, -0.06228052079677582, -0.02202809602022171, -0.019207781180739403, 0.03052540309727192, 0.07270344346761703, -0.021535200998187065, 0.010380111634731293, 0.008197825402021408, -0.02103167586028576, 0.005446589086204767, 0.003119145054370165, -0.02399345487356186, -0.06186673790216446, 0.011264867149293423, -0.023969588801264763, -0.04496403783559799, -0.016263781115412712, 0.021599799394607544, 0.08340644091367722, 0.0012953652767464519, -0.01967971958220005, -0.011352752335369587, 0.0017909278394654393, -0.07575920969247818, -0.06048179045319557, 0.021725893020629883, -0.034962378442287445, -0.020810894668102264, -0.02564120478928089, 0.0009579714969731867, 0.029248446226119995, 0.02441263385117054, 0.039771534502506256, 0.01355076301842928, 0.010465498082339764, -0.058061424642801285, 0.010374144650995731, 0.026018323376774788, 0.03918259218335152, -0.027204737067222595, 0.02952919527888298, -0.08224733918905258, -0.0200992152094841, -0.043840229511260986, -0.005635648965835571, 0.0007069879793561995, 0.07437408715486526, 0.03858167678117752, 0.04070504382252693, -0.08038932085037231, -0.001165521563962102, 0.005001000128686428, -0.047954801470041275, 0.024107778444886208, 0.04118622839450836, -0.024118250235915184, -0.019089413806796074, -0.017206784337759018, -0.014623535796999931, 0.01653718203306198, -0.03813973441720009, -0.03310016915202141, -0.014849954284727573, 0.0009666557889431715, -0.030863944441080093, 0.06293811649084091, 0.007428684271872044, -0.07769443094730377, 0.0007593153859488666, -0.03654550015926361, 0.0056584239937365055, -0.05126093327999115, 0.02322247065603733, 0.021152369678020477, -0.04740497097373009, -0.025342769920825958, -0.0343262180685997, -0.02603410929441452, -0.002374021802097559, -0.007364640012383461, -0.044969480484724045, -0.003420037915930152, 0.04626508057117462, 0.056887414306402206, 0.013842744752764702, 0.03818526864051819, -0.016208184882998466, 0.034255251288414, -0.028463542461395264, 0.047546759247779846, -0.06781802326440811, 0.005094625521451235, -0.05757969990372658, 0.049621984362602234, 0.03768692910671234, 0.00865046214312315, -0.005408138502389193, 0.022013146430253983, -0.0006458183634094894, -0.023322485387325287, -0.01632329635322094, 0.005890701897442341, -0.007581998128443956, -0.004290527664124966, -0.03239414095878601, 0.03285455331206322, 0.04417847469449043, 0.006550468970090151, 0.03141394257545471, 0.056719306856393814, -0.009751889854669571, 0.01082043070346117, 0.008235910907387733, -0.0037233892362564802, -0.07371991872787476, -0.061683934181928635, 0.025423232465982437, 0.03738545626401901, -0.009688169695436954, 0.030516574159264565, 0.002540396526455879, -0.0046431683003902435, 0.012917312793433666, -0.034280456602573395, -0.032428037375211716, -0.04686947539448738, 0.041805729269981384, 0.07462213933467865, -0.04769522696733475, 0.0004599513194989413, -0.04391646012663841, -0.028500888496637344, -0.03091183304786682, -0.01819406822323799, 0.0044349548406898975, 0.02496103011071682, 0.024871734902262688, -0.06675306707620621, 0.06797413527965546, 0.026516875252127647, -0.06592655926942825, -0.036601874977350235, 0.04083263874053955, -0.07328753918409348, -0.030118077993392944, 0.061092767864465714, -0.0033389467280358076, -0.002406533109024167, 0.01788327470421791, 0.04870523512363434, -0.037736278027296066, -0.051809050142765045, 0.05015992373228073, 0.07500040531158447, -0.008859018795192242, 0.05866231396794319, -0.03429222106933594, -0.05217989906668663, -0.016023339703679085, -0.05243586003780365, -0.0168810673058033, 0.0064292182214558125, -0.006949825212359428, -0.014426150359213352, 0.0011331788264214993, -0.047987718135118484, 0.04596957564353943, -0.062091849744319916, 0.02213842049241066, -0.006095751188695431, 0.04390132799744606, 0.05024653300642967, -0.04577846825122833, -0.05709271878004074, -0.011551986448466778, -0.005408531986176968, -0.04262927174568176, -0.056933335959911346, -0.035207826644182205, -0.02331797406077385, 0.0345364548265934, -0.02317604422569275, -0.046486273407936096, -0.025290200486779213, -0.012551355175673962, -0.03982573747634888, 0.037871383130550385, -0.0525658018887043, 0.014027530327439308, -0.02269648015499115, -0.06116099655628204, -0.02693563513457775, 0.06776736676692963, -0.01346307061612606, 0.03180237114429474, -0.0034310994669795036, 0.005574862007051706, -0.01377788558602333, 0.03530590236186981, 0.010382958687841892, -0.012929920107126236, 0.03799285367131233, -0.033223893493413925, 0.018138857558369637, -0.04871036857366562, -0.0442667156457901, 0.025983257219195366, 0.006165674887597561, -0.026926130056381226, -0.0688173770904541, 0.0476558618247509, -0.026932736858725548, -0.0210422370582819, 0.00219334801658988, -0.058883801102638245, -0.06503421813249588, 0.033585768193006516, -0.04281463846564293, 0.032918862998485565, -0.01493952888995409, 0.01692529395222664, -0.005290421191602945, 0.02396969310939312, 0.03476354479789734, 0.0030206379014998674, 0.010280337184667587, 0.016289537772536278, -0.08085448294878006, -0.02989760786294937, 0.0019907262176275253, -0.002967528300359845, -0.06187663972377777, -0.036019712686538696, -0.01194600760936737, -0.05877816677093506, -0.015142706222832203, 0.04090125113725662, 0.033711787313222885, 0.02052873559296131, -0.06038488447666168, 0.019706623628735542, 0.03256421163678169, -0.02735663577914238, -0.03758236765861511, -0.009901958517730236, -0.009601393714547157, 0.01063646748661995, 0.023336775600910187, -0.02419879101216793, -0.017642809078097343, -0.021918579936027527, -0.08471591025590897, -0.004470233339816332, -0.05393292382359505, 0.05115114152431488, 0.003281791927292943, -0.0015561723848804832, 0.016463153064250946, -0.04095084220170975, 0.017340252175927162, 0.008727303706109524, 0.004574817139655352, 0.006632787641137838, 0.07038330286741257, 0.01358290296047926, -0.07358735054731369, -0.030891837552189827, 0.03777698799967766, 0.024784889072179794, 0.016330385580658913, 0.03811120614409447, 0.04474825784564018, -0.019039887934923172, -0.023155322298407555, 0.04759390279650688, 0.030919771641492844, 0.027741659432649612, -0.0309859998524189, -0.027839427813887596, -0.03800246864557266, -0.06335631012916565, 0.04337933659553528, -0.03457346186041832, 0.04576277732849121, -0.002980238990858197, -0.002409005770459771, -0.037776973098516464, -0.008592662401497364, -0.016376905143260956, 0.03357093781232834, -0.004215451423078775, -0.012269263155758381, 0.06278932839632034, -0.009531116113066673, -0.0185752771794796, -0.01990656740963459, 0.01587631180882454, -0.06656046956777573, 0.0030733367893844843, -0.007204368244856596, -0.013802037574350834, 0.03627469763159752, -0.08271320164203644, 0.023642493411898613, -0.018498815596103668, 0.004429154563695192, -0.0570179708302021, 0.044396597892045975, 0.01622735522687435, -0.019395936280488968, -0.017436176538467407, -0.038860537111759186, -0.004495381377637386, -0.06717634946107864, -0.04059280455112457, 0.023503940552473068, 0.02143334038555622, -0.02877430059015751, 0.07326605170965195, 0.011238799430429935, 0.06538621336221695, 0.030411118641495705, 0.03036332316696644, -0.03518633544445038, 0.02193433977663517, -0.05627398565411568, 0.06025564670562744, 0.018872637301683426, -0.040928915143013, -0.05688943341374397, 0.014352189376950264, 0.02482074312865734, 0.0017956659430637956, 0.028243238106369972, 0.009234351105988026, -0.0045154280960559845, -0.041053034365177155, -0.015309780836105347, -0.01925363391637802, 0.023167837411165237, -0.017594626173377037, 0.022602945566177368, -0.006509437225759029, -0.05060781538486481, -0.04217401519417763 ]
Reinforcement learning (RL) for bipedal locomotion has recently demonstrated robust gaits over moderate terrains using only proprioceptive sensing. However, such blind controllers will fail in environments where robots must anticipate and adapt to local terrain, which requires visual perception. In this paper, we propose a fully-learned system that allows bipedal robots to react to local terrain while maintaining commanded travel speed and direction. Our approach first trains a controller in simulation using a heightmap expressed in the robot's local frame. Next, data is collected in simulation to train a heightmap predictor, whose input is the history of depth images and robot states. We demonstrate that with appropriate domain randomization, this approach allows for successful sim-to-real transfer with no explicit pose estimation and no fine-tuning using real-world data. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first example of sim-to-real learning for vision-based bipedal locomotion over challenging terrains.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14594v2
[ -0.0330328568816185, -0.03223177790641785, 0.0438312403857708, 0.03272746875882149, -0.012668079696595669, -0.012367842718958855, 0.022201599553227425, 0.0010943596716970205, -0.006667876150459051, -0.05869794636964798, -0.05070412904024124, 0.006893745623528957, -0.05798486992716789, -0.045174576342105865, -0.022472143173217773, 0.035331275314092636, 0.07498310506343842, -0.05895190313458443, -0.06689094007015228, 0.046045657247304916, 0.026976941153407097, 0.03516048192977905, -0.030483990907669067, -0.013505439274013042, -0.0005375523469410837, -0.03980662673711777, -0.028769757598638535, 0.051222436130046844, -0.04447595402598381, -0.016772275790572166, 0.06583187729120255, -0.040942974388599396, -0.014409945346415043, -0.016848137602210045, -0.044492289423942566, 0.008490216918289661, -0.006682096514850855, 0.01635877415537834, 0.0309770330786705, -0.027316411957144737, 0.02559717744588852, -0.01948198676109314, -0.0319787971675396, -0.019703060388565063, -0.053020477294921875, -0.03215619549155235, -0.045921504497528076, 0.04040477052330971, -0.051937978714704514, -0.06341549754142761, -0.0037895487621426582, -0.012191648595035076, 0.024692116305232048, 0.038886211812496185, -0.021458039060235023, 0.0035901754163205624, 0.0381733737885952, 0.02864079922437668, -0.044062886387109756, -0.003784304717555642, -0.01808531954884529, -0.052048057317733765, 0.0369560681283474, -0.006060822866857052, 0.05144147947430611, 0.053801797330379486, -0.04864468052983284, -0.04140106961131096, -0.05024769902229309, -0.040391985327005386, 0.06380170583724976, -0.06652235984802246, -0.012721661478281021, 0.024516254663467407, -0.03946371749043465, -0.023135356605052948, -0.024404224008321762, -0.0213557668030262, 0.01376622635871172, 0.0015511808451265097, -0.032072845846414566, 0.03878282010555267, 0.06509333103895187, 0.06428719311952591, 0.020261505618691444, 0.003102672751992941, 0.04764735326170921, -0.020886147394776344, 0.028527967631816864, -0.0358896367251873, 0.055464521050453186, -0.034339237958192825, -0.024042606353759766, 0.01659717597067356, 0.07207220047712326, -0.03273667395114899, 0.06818241626024246, 0.005916680209338665, 0.011218643747270107, 0.019489198923110962, -0.04432021453976631, 0.015956498682498932, -0.030105657875537872, 0.04594451189041138, 0.0215124674141407, -0.06420859694480896, 0.012437235563993454, -0.007957729510962963, -0.012693440541625023, 0.010994075797498226, -0.060822539031505585, -0.027527160942554474, 0.022267881780862808, -0.05236019566655159, -0.03401225432753563, -0.02580384910106659, 0.05537768453359604, -0.005952584557235241, 0.02974238246679306, -0.013733753934502602, -0.03851890191435814, 0.04921325296163559, 0.038289304822683334, -0.03201960399746895, 0.009606550447642803, -0.03506692498922348, 0.07582917809486389, 0.011234469711780548, -0.0263527762144804, -0.012442809529602528, 0.006588501390069723, 0.04536646977066994, -0.02120102196931839, -0.0614996999502182, 0.05060999095439911, -0.00562854390591383, -0.002164139412343502, -0.02636069618165493, -0.0036221961490809917, 0.0016177044017240405, -0.007737497333437204, -0.05033760517835617, 0.028616536408662796, -0.0036339142825454473, -0.028288057073950768, 0.03461901471018791, -0.05460049584507942, -0.041677121073007584, -0.019670024514198303, 0.02127811685204506, 0.037719301879405975, 0.005861547775566578, 0.03395475819706917, 0.04642852768301964, 0.020127087831497192, -0.04484749957919121, 0.0619194358587265, 0.01677865907549858, -0.06800954788923264, -0.00672660768032074, 0.03876248002052307, -0.002963474951684475, 0.03825778886675835, -0.018879178911447525, 0.03305288776755333, 0.025886276736855507, 0.04674404114484787, -0.016973452642560005, -0.018254738301038742, 0.01440216600894928, -0.02344372309744358, -0.020194480195641518, -0.009736836887896061, -0.002151352120563388, -0.05159755423665047, -0.039143145084381104, 0.00029066571732982993, -0.03856346756219864, -0.010223343037068844, 0.0048034233041107655, -0.01055258046835661, 0.03630688041448593, -0.029881319031119347, 0.004218775313347578, -0.06652652472257614, -0.03683299943804741, -0.08541248738765717, -0.06977453082799911, 0.019230272620916367, 0.01992386393249035, -0.03753727674484253, -0.03915088623762131, -0.008715640753507614, -0.017041465267539024, -0.06474032998085022, -0.038752131164073944, -0.0219205804169178, -0.004127910826355219, 0.026111450046300888, 0.010059184394776821, -0.09017198532819748, -0.0019813559483736753, -0.03461866453289986, -0.015951653942465782, -0.010202734731137753, -0.06848850846290588, 0.00857018493115902, 0.04770663380622864, -0.019178973510861397, 0.050124406814575195, -0.007155085913836956, 0.03948330506682396, 0.07742013037204742, -0.022409994155168533, 0.03486727923154831, 0.012387068010866642, -0.10024263709783554, 0.030033620074391365, 0.007282021921128035, -0.0009430252248421311, 0.0197895560413599, 0.023812025785446167, 0.005201128777116537, -0.026099475100636482, -0.044062357395887375, 0.041393108665943146, 0.07412020862102509, 0.0050605288706719875, -0.053927384316921234, -0.05306890234351158, -0.04392741248011589, -0.07070261240005493, -0.04862189665436745, -0.07130841910839081, -0.07348138093948364, -0.0009739100350998342, -0.01920802891254425, 0.03879361227154732, 0.009399031288921833, -0.0052888719365000725, -0.060131289064884186, -0.00017319108883384615, 0.03099737875163555, -0.053743548691272736, -0.04841950535774231, -0.045072536915540695, -0.03774990513920784, 0.01605045422911644, 0.02588069625198841, -0.01220429316163063, -0.04823470860719681, -0.04526830464601517, 0.044080790132284164, -0.03788844868540764, 0.054743148386478424, 0.060117706656455994, -0.02019658498466015, 0.01801775023341179, -0.0606929287314415, 0.05060463398694992, 0.01976602151989937, -0.016377434134483337, -0.07668615877628326, -0.021325524896383286, 0.01596144586801529, -0.009757079184055328, -0.003717944258823991, -0.052889928221702576, -0.009304754436016083, -0.01928138919174671, -0.005677788984030485, 0.016653025522828102, 0.022162752225995064, -0.017804864794015884, -0.035872094333171844, -0.04768308624625206, -0.035482872277498245, 0.020809641107916832, 0.019660649821162224, 0.04178130254149437, 0.05274270102381706, 0.018950171768665314, 0.02287733182311058, -0.02587311901152134, -0.008022760041058064, -0.063574880361557, -0.02452884614467621, -0.07161188870668411, -0.06468348205089569, 0.011280731298029423, -0.06394173204898834, -0.0017310739494860172, -0.042775627225637436, -0.055205896496772766, 0.016995660960674286, -0.012720723636448383, -0.03960650786757469, 0.04871360585093498, -0.0034965130034834146, -0.03396743908524513, -0.028967738151550293, -0.02077091485261917, 0.009774209931492805, 0.04166127368807793, -0.006908633280545473, -0.03691712021827698, -0.05864420905709267, -0.031995318830013275, 0.03627835959196091, 0.00412112707272172, -0.039923783391714096, 0.059207286685705185, -0.01347434613853693, 0.03494413197040558, 0.02182938903570175, 0.01593843474984169, 0.0021734186448156834, 0.03276846557855606, -0.03576279431581497, 0.002686044666916132, 0.00808565504848957, -0.02881496399641037, 0.02218625880777836, -0.01324531715363264, -0.048965420573949814, -0.007361462339758873, 0.04309363290667534, 0.036951784044504166, 0.004162200260907412, -0.024634983390569687, 0.03287232667207718, -0.0010674376972019672, 0.010370049625635147, 0.00414910027757287, 0.050746332854032516, 0.007548677735030651, -0.007881343364715576, -0.0063851866871118546, -0.030914442613720894, 0.010854502208530903, 0.004951750859618187, 0.04061323404312134, -0.06627402454614639, -0.014517443254590034, 0.03183821961283684, -0.08948624134063721, 0.016623711213469505, 0.02715323120355606, 0.04869554191827774, 0.007398101966828108, 0.039040397852659225, 0.015280831605196, 0.042487483471632004, 0.02012290246784687, 0.016439594328403473, 0.016199452802538872, 0.01527302898466587, 0.060794729739427567, -0.01284391526132822, -0.027470974251627922, -0.04164228215813637, -0.07991351932287216, -0.048293180763721466, -0.005310584791004658, 0.03198430314660072, -0.004563032649457455, 0.05356328934431076, -0.058574382215738297, -0.0038253695238381624, 0.008410164155066013, 0.026903847232460976, -0.004987584892660379, -0.031159013509750366, 0.046644262969493866, -0.02863994427025318, 0.020440345630049706, -0.004017514176666737, 0.013536104001104832, 0.001475403318181634, -0.0528632290661335, 0.007749362848699093, -0.07045695930719376, 0.02876814641058445, -0.01910499669611454, -0.036642394959926605, 0.0421401783823967, 0.03526489436626434, -0.0011803915258497, 0.046189066022634506, -0.023922430351376534, -0.0026688366197049618, 0.019400713965296745, -0.021486321464180946, -0.01884884014725685, 0.021926097571849823, -0.023192672058939934, 0.031152555719017982, 0.003086332930251956, -0.008335134014487267, 0.028057187795639038, -0.018128253519535065, -0.01850019209086895, -0.04652491211891174, -0.08640789240598679, -0.015631550922989845, -0.027133135125041008, 0.031759150326251984, -0.011983397416770458, -0.01450200192630291, 0.07011323422193527, -0.0370628759264946, -0.01208860706537962, -0.014776463620364666, -0.014301365241408348, -0.025647040456533432, -0.027299335226416588, -0.02747941203415394, -0.07710468769073486, 0.029549121856689453, -0.05959443747997284, 0.044892214238643646, -0.03820694983005524, 0.02782939001917839, -0.04499306529760361, -0.02369273640215397, -0.01426462922245264, 0.056166525930166245, 0.005943928845226765, 0.006469483021646738, -0.008483326062560081, 0.015664642676711082, -0.008219699375331402, 0.012811142951250076, 0.026465635746717453, -0.027163727208971977, -0.018504910171031952, 0.033669378608465195, -0.04792340472340584, 0.004477331880480051, -0.003855630289763212, 0.028030676767230034, 0.05611447989940643, -0.012162331491708755, -0.00554591603577137, -0.01356172002851963, 0.0700666606426239, -0.02939615026116371, -0.05343889445066452, -0.047293201088905334, -0.027441928163170815, -0.060798726975917816, 0.014950287528336048, 0.022720426321029663, -0.0016907801618799567, -0.0012906722258776426, 0.009189906530082226, 0.01573200151324272, 0.047151580452919006, -0.0335143581032753, -0.00007593107147840783, 0.010808647610247135, 0.006980055943131447, 0.011831413954496384, -0.05256272479891777, -0.07909221202135086, 0.05426996946334839, 0.011921647936105728, -0.02780723385512829, -0.028429202735424042, 0.020417243242263794, 0.004031246528029442, 0.04015371948480606, -0.08386336266994476, 0.006871714722365141, 0.057971637696027756, -0.03706267848610878, 0.03736354038119316, 0.05150768533349037, -0.044618070125579834, 0.03098403662443161, -0.01435149647295475, 0.015317150391638279, 0.016913961619138718, -0.03587334603071213, -0.028519155457615852, -0.0005118369008414447, -0.0054432726465165615, 0.006189269479364157, 0.029254768043756485, -0.032753314822912216, -0.03983479365706444, 0.011452208273112774, -0.02285272814333439, 0.02093888446688652, -0.05116884410381317, 0.0028662646654993296, 0.03782329335808754, -0.0533122755587101, -0.032410286366939545, 0.024544812738895416, 0.0019812637474387884, -0.009724583476781845, 0.007529453840106726, -0.04628700390458107, 0.030221909284591675, 0.03952976316213608, -0.03734177350997925, 0.00990681629627943, 0.00004900316343992017, -0.0018530292436480522, 0.030114904046058655, 0.03139333799481392, -0.014570898376405239, -0.06545630097389221, -0.015124822966754436, -0.027716685086488724, 0.04537183791399002, 0.008544840849936008, 0.0404551737010479, 0.0030603075865656137, 0.0492141954600811, -0.01880958490073681, -0.0007650119950994849, -0.001508884015493095, -0.006526534911245108, 0.04110056534409523, -0.061808180063962936, 0.0390218086540699, 0.018994314596056938, 0.021427281200885773, 0.005328338127583265, 0.05062595382332802, 0.02223736047744751, -0.015088478103280067, -0.040957894176244736, -0.03643343970179558, 0.009129250422120094, -0.06901637464761734, -0.06296058744192123, 0.03077036701142788, -0.001329116872511804, -0.02300090529024601, 0.01481681503355503, 0.022437190636992455, 0.0232134610414505, 0.043407149612903595, -0.00545953493565321, 0.031978458166122437, -0.03250804916024208, 0.0012839460978284478, 0.08094082027673721, -0.022889787331223488, -0.011894379742443562, -0.0013206000439822674, -0.061538197100162506, -0.0006045291665941477, -0.04028793051838875, 0.024646831676363945, -0.010764346458017826, 0.030350934714078903, -0.05870264768600464, -0.019643345847725868, 0.01231338270008564, -0.06000525876879692, -0.0009962135227397084, 0.020501218736171722, -0.07812856137752533, -0.03135361149907112, 0.00038855583989061415, -0.04522557929158211, -0.04787744581699371, 0.05503310635685921, 0.022424353286623955, 0.03483720123767853, -0.0059038917534053326, 0.054409194737672806, 0.07790642976760864, 0.027815785259008408, 0.005774374585598707, 0.009935444220900536, -0.013827408663928509, -0.003487997455522418, -0.036372825503349304, 0.025410573929548264, 0.035008810460567474, 0.03146316111087799, 0.027810124680399895, -0.050788164138793945, -0.01999090611934662, 0.05058612301945686, -0.04607241228222847, -0.021506473422050476, -0.012266667559742928, 0.01645836979150772, 0.07646690309047699, -0.020626993849873543, -0.07400789856910706, 0.012603926472365856, -0.024406641721725464, -0.020892325788736343, -0.04696525260806084, -0.015388019382953644, 0.019487541168928146, 0.03526850417256355, -0.014166503213346004, -0.050308357924222946, -0.024288250133395195, -0.0347069688141346, -0.04005182534456253, 0.016294552013278008, -0.04437605291604996, -0.04410713538527489, -0.03687388077378273, -0.019032694399356842, 0.03782660886645317, 0.027302304282784462, -0.06220955774188042, -0.0395532064139843, -0.016436778008937836, 0.020865892991423607, -0.029337773099541664, -0.02910326048731804, 0.04573812708258629, 0.011639448814094067, 0.01644832454621792, -0.015151754021644592, -0.019905630499124527, 0.005005799233913422, -0.04402928799390793, 0.00993119366466999, -0.012029931880533695, -0.03198908641934395, -0.02602514810860157, 0.023204993456602097, -0.01653410866856575, 0.016492294147610664, 0.003928164020180702, -0.008350959047675133, -0.051856204867362976, 0.02731422334909439, 0.003488316433504224, 0.027137624099850655, -0.046696003526449203, 0.0038659635465592146, 0.03592006489634514, -0.02376951277256012, 0.018091481178998947, 0.028392571955919266, -0.03285909816622734, 0.0047493563033640385, -0.06582095474004745, -0.04250156134366989, 0.02094028890132904, -0.003974719904363155, -0.07053142040967941, -0.012986326590180397, -0.04471052438020706, -0.06372497230768204, 0.015865305438637733, 0.026198307052254677, -0.024737641215324402, 0.029816053807735443, -0.07265980541706085, 0.021426435559988022, -0.018584443256258965, -0.03425785154104233, -0.05125272274017334, -0.03319684788584709, 0.0037788059562444687, -0.0380028560757637, -0.016693715006113052, -0.011093704029917717, -0.05093458667397499, 0.009577996097505093, -0.08167175948619843, 0.004443282727152109, 0.01837797835469246, 0.02341081015765667, 0.03265417367219925, -0.04902522265911102, -0.01721649244427681, -0.007630460429936647, -0.02654366008937359, 0.02803177200257778, 0.005536525975912809, 0.009023143909871578, 0.06787752360105515, -0.006130869500339031, -0.05071286857128143, -0.058131374418735504, 0.017490196973085403, -0.019205652177333832, -0.01981748826801777, 0.05303714796900749, 0.0436127595603466, 0.051553722470998764, -0.03228777274489403, 0.06436342746019363, -0.016360532492399216, 0.044842686504125595, -0.04469229280948639, 0.048763468861579895, -0.04174860566854477, -0.03965241461992264, 0.03285890072584152, -0.04215719550848007, 0.015805445611476898, 0.02277063950896263, -0.020609047263860703, 0.0330958366394043, -0.06871578097343445, -0.05906853452324867, 0.06455864757299423, -0.015604047104716301, 0.003048747545108199, 0.05420960858464241, -0.041893258690834045, 0.01342481467872858, 0.004588073585182428, -0.03356745094060898, -0.0037057276349514723, 0.009012986905872822, 0.020544180646538734, 0.014848149381577969, 0.01453110110014677, -0.08429379016160965, -0.016052281484007835, -0.019182398915290833, 0.0075134695507586, -0.036987606436014175, 0.07664159685373306, 0.00916067510843277, -0.0504014827311039, -0.060421526432037354, -0.05491647869348526, -0.016593482345342636, -0.031047867611050606, -0.0004699110286310315, -0.010550717823207378, 0.03830794245004654, -0.0017046041321009398, 0.023783959448337555, 0.027130646631121635, 0.04128298908472061, 0.044424284249544144, 0.029072413221001625, -0.025150224566459656, -0.014456333592534065, -0.05612020567059517, 0.07999803870916367, -0.03118050843477249, 0.014464186504483223, -0.043131906539201736, -0.011908491142094135, 0.01670338585972786, -0.023540135473012924, -0.060952913016080856, 0.0001281715085497126, 0.017612066119909286, -0.05283746123313904, -0.005085871554911137, 0.04411185532808304, -0.03961089253425598, -0.032633475959300995, -0.024386202916502953, 0.012090891599655151, -0.029830699786543846, -0.06379275023937225 ]
In recent years new deep learning approaches to solve combinatorial optimization problems, in particular NP-hard Vehicle Routing Problems (VRP), have been proposed. The most impactful of these methods are sequential neural construction approaches which are usually trained via reinforcement learning. Due to the high training costs of these models, they usually are trained on limited instance sizes (e.g. serving 100 customers) and later applied to vastly larger instance size (e.g. 2000 customers). By means of a systematic scale-up study we show that even state-of-the-art neural construction methods are outperformed by simple heuristics, failing to generalize to larger problem instances. We propose to use the ruin recreate principle that alternates between completely destroying a localized part of the solution and then recreating an improved variant. In this way, neural construction methods like POMO are never applied to the global problem but just in the reconstruction step, which only involves partial problems much closer in size to their original training instances. In thorough experiments on four datasets of varying distributions and modalities we show that our neural ruin recreate approach outperforms alternative forms of improving construction methods such as sampling and beam search and in several experiments also advanced local search approaches.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17089v1
[ -0.04303750395774841, -0.007243644446134567, 0.03098614513874054, 0.03797848895192146, -0.038077499717473984, -0.026553163304924965, 0.03198767080903053, -0.03365445137023926, -0.006307673174887896, -0.03962035849690437, -0.0012689696159213781, 0.0005954314838163555, -0.03619531914591789, -0.010820039547979832, -0.047919534146785736, 0.03326636180281639, 0.0525432787835598, 0.01934848353266716, -0.052404895424842834, 0.056048862636089325, 0.037922900170087814, -0.028720026835799217, -0.039315275847911835, 0.04130706191062927, -0.0020248962100595236, 0.0045691439881920815, -0.034069813787937164, 0.028935082256793976, -0.016845831647515297, -0.0378810316324234, 0.08018767088651657, -0.010539157316088676, -0.03853663057088852, -0.05592229962348938, -0.018338732421398163, -0.048685990273952484, -0.01933290623128414, 0.032663922756910324, 0.0529179573059082, -0.047362592071294785, 0.042273733764886856, -0.05361030250787735, -0.06881460547447205, -0.01789780892431736, -0.00640743738040328, -0.017951013520359993, -0.02925889380276203, -0.00548631651327014, -0.0735694169998169, -0.06684473156929016, 0.02221749722957611, 0.012283531948924065, 0.015392106957733631, 0.00891026295721531, -0.04342605173587799, -0.023654595017433167, -0.037717122584581375, 0.034553151577711105, -0.06750869750976562, -0.030337193980813026, -0.004404537845402956, -0.001623881165869534, -0.009594721719622612, -0.04071826860308647, 0.01737036183476448, 0.07156762480735779, -0.04027313366532326, -0.0811588317155838, -0.042047444730997086, -0.016082577407360077, 0.054610177874565125, -0.05771619826555252, 0.04334879666566849, 0.02605808526277542, -0.03783697634935379, -0.03597872331738472, -0.027085887268185616, -0.03138178586959839, 0.023431042209267616, 0.007491293828934431, -0.050788749009370804, 0.04400787875056267, 0.006520534865558147, -0.03955771401524544, -0.03512297198176384, -0.046178318560123444, 0.002273597288876772, -0.014907690696418285, 0.024800477549433708, -0.06211697682738304, 0.045522626489400864, -0.015503914095461369, -0.06522326916456223, 0.03852496296167374, 0.0695599913597107, -0.007258309982717037, 0.03868170455098152, 0.05944029614329338, 0.008871405385434628, -0.002625534776598215, -0.0025305424351245165, -0.053174443542957306, -0.05363156273961067, 0.035343244671821594, 0.012160273268818855, -0.012696669436991215, -0.02583969011902809, 0.012811188586056232, -0.07069634646177292, 0.02333553321659565, -0.0041445777751505375, -0.029299767687916756, 0.012366189621388912, -0.06382180750370026, 0.006812933832406998, -0.052062854170799255, 0.06898639351129532, 0.023100167512893677, -0.0033729050774127245, -0.03861109912395477, -0.05304032936692238, 0.0324210561811924, 0.06578761339187622, -0.010215330868959427, 0.01986744813621044, -0.02271253615617752, 0.05520707368850708, 0.0075738755986094475, -0.03476174175739288, -0.009269775822758675, -0.00039707141695544124, 0.01805584318935871, -0.020963935181498528, 0.012151422910392284, 0.06024489179253578, -0.009676116518676281, -0.004625804256647825, -0.06065854802727699, 0.0418550930917263, -0.01863802783191204, -0.030752750113606453, -0.08531869947910309, 0.035993725061416626, -0.032929643988609314, 0.011122381314635277, 0.05855465307831764, -0.0723089724779129, -0.005019393749535084, 0.0028815404511988163, 0.06203306466341019, 0.0022097507026046515, 0.008544355630874634, -0.012655617669224739, 0.02153678797185421, 0.010280794464051723, 0.005540335550904274, 0.04002637416124344, -0.0028738295659422874, -0.03327608108520508, -0.009091335348784924, -0.012388964183628559, -0.0467887781560421, 0.013716323301196098, -0.010923152789473534, 0.017717652022838593, -0.00259876879863441, 0.027509786188602448, -0.016144592314958572, 0.01817632094025612, 0.016860883682966232, -0.033363912254571915, -0.039021167904138565, 0.020817941054701805, 0.007610445376485586, -0.05277009680867195, -0.023205779492855072, 0.023021377623081207, -0.009728705510497093, -0.06091058626770973, -0.0020038906950503588, 0.03531135246157646, 0.034025564789772034, -0.03575124219059944, 0.03476310148835182, -0.039441414177417755, -0.001868533669039607, -0.08755247294902802, 0.04169052466750145, 0.04359317943453789, -0.00008620959852123633, -0.052424442023038864, -0.032589275389909744, 0.04207105562090874, 0.011287719011306763, -0.02791321650147438, -0.03462304174900055, -0.03807830065488815, -0.03701847791671753, 0.03393831476569176, 0.06240362301468849, -0.09478212147951126, 0.030820192769169807, -0.046523839235305786, -0.008638803847134113, 0.03771544620394707, -0.05854042246937752, 0.024426523596048355, 0.0655185878276825, -0.030097398906946182, -0.03973778337240219, 0.029969051480293274, 0.011581327766180038, 0.04028753563761711, 0.03393327072262764, 0.035400066524744034, -0.022466158494353294, -0.10459645092487335, 0.06281515210866928, 0.0020021290984004736, 0.0031173399183899164, 0.02128549851477146, -0.009354706853628159, -0.020816978067159653, -0.01645357720553875, -0.020782139152288437, 0.007974212989211082, 0.027185775339603424, -0.015917908400297165, -0.03408009558916092, 0.020362727344036102, 0.02344648726284504, -0.048597585409879684, -0.030382966622710228, -0.08323395252227783, -0.04332717880606651, 0.01942652277648449, -0.04017523676156998, 0.08098357915878296, 0.02635522373020649, -0.03911574184894562, -0.0450437068939209, 0.01699894107878208, 0.02316029742360115, -0.01678374595940113, -0.04613040015101433, -0.04197334870696068, -0.011777123436331749, -0.011633212678134441, -0.024059157818555832, -0.030450763180851936, -0.03785772621631622, -0.0077069951221346855, -0.004037552513182163, -0.012999781407415867, 0.02136455662548542, 0.009677346795797348, -0.005465313326567411, 0.029825514182448387, -0.011591071262955666, 0.01901296339929104, 0.04614384099841118, 0.03453170135617256, -0.04488396272063255, -0.007385363336652517, 0.021657729521393776, 0.009976140223443508, -0.05809345096349716, -0.0054085575975477695, 0.03744461014866829, -0.03603589907288551, -0.020452944561839104, 0.05294516310095787, 0.04311426356434822, 0.02833477593958378, -0.0059544965624809265, -0.06474923342466354, -0.013681987300515175, -0.057118479162454605, 0.03176473081111908, 0.036880046129226685, 0.027101727202534676, -0.002667241031304002, 0.006246407516300678, -0.07861576974391937, -0.025511359795928, -0.06148914247751236, -0.027662837877869606, -0.04450006037950516, -0.05638453736901283, -0.032760098576545715, -0.08675169199705124, -0.04550105333328247, 0.0021551665849983692, -0.06962672621011734, 0.023881563916802406, -0.05123148113489151, -0.031488027423620224, 0.00727258063852787, 0.0013638364616781473, -0.0243378933519125, -0.0457296147942543, -0.034000884741544724, -0.0027445987798273563, 0.03164602443575859, 0.02835847996175289, -0.054773297160863876, -0.033684682101011276, -0.0022594102192670107, 0.002216949826106429, 0.02690623700618744, -0.013617362827062607, 0.03349146619439125, 0.005526822526007891, 0.03546033427119255, 0.0012158346362411976, 0.022604910656809807, -0.004948573652654886, 0.06660231947898865, -0.009281971491873264, -0.059268735349178314, 0.00395482312887907, -0.025174174457788467, -0.023355435580015182, -0.044209592044353485, -0.025856435298919678, 0.009473557583987713, 0.0660349577665329, 0.024428142234683037, -0.04216676205396652, -0.01881968416273594, -0.0007593656191602349, -0.007945336401462555, 0.030343182384967804, -0.03174202889204025, 0.040207359939813614, 0.0479537695646286, -0.032632675021886826, -0.012735933996737003, -0.02626568078994751, 0.010623461566865444, -0.006976844277232885, 0.0022108894772827625, -0.038380201905965805, 0.004417479038238525, 0.06470106542110443, -0.09743927419185638, 0.0346798337996006, 0.04014412686228752, 0.0694039985537529, -0.02958998829126358, 0.022875625640153885, 0.020807724446058273, 0.008542414754629135, -0.008551442064344883, -0.004119282588362694, 0.009961695410311222, 0.0314042866230011, 0.07058241218328476, -0.0225230660289526, -0.0248631089925766, 0.0034195331390947104, -0.06792827695608139, -0.03559030964970589, 0.019561490043997765, 0.03554186597466469, 0.045867111533880234, 0.024476001039147377, -0.06183650344610214, -0.004740417934954166, -0.027988897636532784, 0.010236194357275963, -0.04013684391975403, -0.07221246510744095, 0.026205122470855713, -0.0065221888944506645, 0.020757582038640976, -0.013454724103212357, -0.012366029433906078, 0.004366667941212654, -0.0372144877910614, 0.0008872058242559433, -0.05145798623561859, 0.06020258367061615, 0.007857437245547771, -0.023261267691850662, 0.025485632941126823, 0.0471019372344017, -0.03195377066731453, 0.05657728761434555, 0.006651405245065689, 0.020721865817904472, -0.028996916487812996, 0.012820919044315815, -0.01910693757236004, 0.0075478279031813145, -0.04850969463586807, 0.0037368994671851397, 0.028071684762835503, -0.009775131940841675, -0.0364883616566658, 0.0015237793559208512, 0.007443465292453766, -0.017492277547717094, -0.09167926758527756, 0.0074306451715528965, -0.037694551050662994, 0.04294533655047417, -0.029722874984145164, -0.017721613869071007, 0.060466840863227844, -0.04260919615626335, 0.049655813723802567, -0.015052379108965397, -0.04448849707841873, -0.0398971363902092, 0.025474397465586662, -0.0417553074657917, -0.08850623667240143, 0.04338829219341278, -0.02815602533519268, 0.05101192370057106, 0.020556403324007988, 0.0006686695851385593, -0.04114712402224541, -0.058477431535720825, 0.0081286346539855, 0.0627470314502716, 0.023147230967879295, 0.008941245265305042, -0.03592447564005852, -0.02116371877491474, 0.008054898120462894, -0.011634736321866512, 0.01363096758723259, 0.013399794697761536, -0.049604352563619614, 0.02949971705675125, 0.013863357715308666, -0.05028858408331871, -0.028186652809381485, 0.00598321994766593, 0.05883444473147392, -0.017973152920603752, -0.02623448334634304, -0.021031050011515617, 0.034457188099622726, -0.03611809387803078, -0.0764552503824234, -0.02242659032344818, -0.04826045781373978, -0.056366417557001114, -0.03482089564204216, 0.02164148911833763, 0.040768831968307495, 0.0009920235024765134, -0.03496704623103142, 0.0009406858589500189, 0.014684313908219337, 0.013444531708955765, 0.005640951916575432, 0.01970750279724598, -0.006809566169977188, -0.008485129103064537, -0.029536521062254906, -0.07929405570030212, 0.0075669316574931145, -0.02143513597548008, 0.011710595339536667, 0.001769207650795579, 0.05481301248073578, -0.01154581643640995, 0.03677587956190109, -0.09577460587024689, 0.04300572723150253, 0.045590367168188095, -0.025079112499952316, -0.012321509420871735, 0.07445039600133896, -0.017159858718514442, 0.030488867312669754, -0.009849099442362785, 0.018903952091932297, 0.028149962425231934, -0.045788999646902084, 0.006459683645516634, -0.027485491707921028, -0.02519366703927517, 0.041894178837537766, 0.07371637970209122, 0.028193442150950432, -0.02468814328312874, 0.021563608199357986, 0.03152459114789963, 0.007954055443406105, -0.026513351127505302, 0.05824926123023033, -0.014996045269072056, -0.006200185511261225, -0.03790886327624321, -0.041586898267269135, 0.011384552344679832, -0.024397913366556168, -0.01564597524702549, -0.027854211628437042, -0.04823645204305649, 0.05352354422211647, 0.03973020240664482, -0.0028050930704921484, -0.01868451200425625, -0.0031410683877766132, -0.0000979324322543107, -0.028136542066931725, -0.044060517102479935, -0.05436418205499649, 0.005160185974091291, -0.02600841037929058, 0.024293769150972366, -0.01627354323863983, 0.021365253254771233, 0.014866366051137447, 0.037827298045158386, -0.03842261806130409, -0.00012588656682055444, 0.02701595239341259, 0.009514475241303444, 0.038097817450761795, -0.009379236027598381, 0.04519522935152054, 0.02291812375187874, 0.023701658472418785, 0.02134069614112377, 0.004238432738929987, 0.009390057064592838, -0.00904819741845131, 0.01884901151061058, -0.016719872131943703, 0.013811555691063404, -0.07445026189088821, -0.003743584966287017, -0.006706987041980028, -0.017880892381072044, -0.024491067975759506, 0.036785297095775604, 0.06280486285686493, 0.0035944718401879072, 0.04488847777247429, 0.0037740960251539946, -0.0016856261063367128, -0.04342342168092728, 0.03202198073267937, 0.06974316388368607, -0.078865647315979, 0.010363343171775341, -0.0481962114572525, -0.00031147291883826256, 0.05712282657623291, -0.021785316988825798, -0.0016796179115772247, 0.004764975514262915, 0.003710207063704729, -0.05460808798670769, 0.07662995159626007, 0.020313240587711334, -0.08017075061798096, 0.002428001258522272, 0.0415584072470665, -0.09239832311868668, -0.0291511919349432, 0.055841390043497086, -0.01668524369597435, -0.04271354898810387, 0.028282973915338516, 0.0040960186161100864, -0.02455868571996689, -0.030117642134428024, 0.07432090491056442, 0.08561643958091736, -0.004768503829836845, 0.033534906804561615, -0.025144658982753754, -0.030913373455405235, -0.0026976787485182285, -0.008134453557431698, -0.024660803377628326, 0.00840306282043457, 0.01991667039692402, -0.04627566412091255, -0.034243907779455185, -0.020491186529397964, 0.0694296583533287, -0.0412277914583683, -0.01540448609739542, 0.01985757052898407, -0.020792072638869286, 0.03299039229750633, -0.027791088446974754, -0.013657246716320515, -0.008929464966058731, 0.013510312885046005, -0.01824933849275112, -0.05015302821993828, -0.01983708329498768, -0.014538032002747059, 0.012638294138014317, -0.0238625667989254, -0.06286723166704178, -0.04751172661781311, -0.023205386474728584, -0.0640900731086731, 0.04060635343194008, -0.02206435613334179, -0.01876445673406124, -0.0000698584335623309, -0.00227639963850379, 0.018785668537020683, 0.05672106519341469, -0.020469991490244865, -0.014076936058700085, -0.00028811884112656116, 0.03278104588389397, -0.0004964016261510551, -0.03183574602007866, 0.0018755588680505753, -0.042958617210388184, 0.026775579899549484, -0.0149629982188344, -0.029000956565141678, -0.047853708267211914, -0.031304456293582916, 0.008462976664304733, 0.018032046034932137, -0.026035785675048828, -0.03864249214529991, 0.00009043089812621474, -0.000312487332848832, 0.018022049218416214, 0.011494031175971031, -0.013211818411946297, -0.07172343134880066, 0.01930425502359867, -0.007814774289727211, -0.019444625824689865, 0.032904695719480515, 0.0005271757254377007, -0.007567348424345255, -0.00394536042585969, 0.03531012311577797, 0.024761509150266647, 0.024897562339901924, -0.002021316671743989, -0.058142974972724915, -0.015958372503519058, 0.0012600604677572846, -0.024665672332048416, -0.05493837967514992, -0.04068910703063011, -0.0019475577864795923, -0.07879182696342468, 0.0036229556426405907, 0.027791740372776985, 0.008798923343420029, 0.03159382939338684, -0.08018525689840317, 0.04603703320026398, 0.033069126307964325, -0.03195738419890404, -0.014607079327106476, -0.017590951174497604, 0.04719537869095802, -0.04223066568374634, 0.0019469930557534099, -0.009628661908209324, -0.05645115673542023, -0.01860222779214382, -0.08488410711288452, -0.03388824313879013, 0.03365199267864227, 0.031129805371165276, -0.007230421062558889, -0.028137976303696632, -0.04168650507926941, -0.02702132612466812, 0.002897985279560089, -0.009435223415493965, 0.002333987271413207, 0.016966255381703377, 0.030488457530736923, 0.021910805255174637, -0.05958997830748558, -0.04037894308567047, 0.04492649808526039, -0.04329409450292587, 0.006295316852629185, 0.035728733986616135, 0.02865397185087204, 0.014366314746439457, 0.037444181740283966, 0.05270174518227577, -0.006402625236660242, 0.0322624072432518, -0.022588830441236496, -0.03633639216423035, -0.05639982968568802, -0.044594887644052505, 0.043234921991825104, -0.022165223956108093, -0.032232653349637985, 0.029969660565257072, 0.025446072220802307, -0.0034049111418426037, 0.02551846019923687, -0.009591902606189251, 0.055428821593523026, -0.01146870106458664, 0.028055207803845406, 0.027515439316630363, -0.044726256281137466, -0.015644369646906853, -0.039137762039899826, -0.021332018077373505, -0.017379729077219963, 0.030551396310329437, 0.03813902288675308, -0.049454450607299805, -0.019944550469517708, -0.05029686540365219, -0.03732721880078316, -0.009656257927417755, 0.014546236954629421, 0.008953084237873554, 0.07402439415454865, 0.0006236158660613, -0.018920166417956352, -0.007897983305156231, -0.031871337443590164, -0.019682107493281364, -0.06611986458301544, 0.00245659239590168, -0.010747595690190792, 0.02508540265262127, -0.04125119000673294, -0.004045750480145216, 0.01683899015188217, 0.06416355818510056, 0.020023135468363762, -0.011947223916649818, -0.022012919187545776, 0.02727016620337963, -0.0625602975487709, 0.0849633440375328, -0.025099992752075195, -0.03043900430202484, -0.02061040885746479, 0.03462350368499756, 0.013125449419021606, -0.016143111512064934, -0.008653520606458187, -0.05016333982348442, -0.0023472702596336603, -0.023715078830718994, -0.03393075242638588, 0.011940645053982735, -0.004901810083538294, -0.047737427055835724, 0.022350093349814415, -0.037052590399980545, -0.03079133853316307, -0.03607649356126785 ]
Xenes, two-dimensional (2D) monolayers composed of a single element, with graphene as a typical representative, have attracted widespread attention. Most of the previous Xenes, X from group-IIIA to group-VIA elements have bonding characteristics of covalent bonds. In this work, we for the first time unveil the pivotal role of a halogen bond, which is a distinctive type of bonding with interaction strength between that of a covalent bond and a van der Waals interaction, in 2D group-VIIA monolayers. Combing the ingenious non-edge-to-edge tiling theory and state-of-art ab initio method with refined local density functional M06-L, we provide a precise and effective bottom-up construction of 2D iodine monolayer sheets, iodinenes, primarily governed by halogen bonds, and successfully design a category of stable iodinenes, encompassing herringbone, Pythagorean, gyrated truncated hexagonal, i.e. diatomic-kagome, and gyrated hexagonal tiling pattern. These iodinene structures exhibit a wealth of properties, such as flat bands, nontrivial topology, and fascinating optical characteristics, offering valuable insights and guidance for future experimental investigations. Our work not only unveils the unexplored halogen bonding mechanism in 2D materials but also opens a new avenue for designing other non-covalent bonding 2D materials.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06184v2
[ -0.0283049326390028, 0.005291299428790808, 0.051429327577352524, -0.005069782957434654, 0.0290524922311306, -0.050423480570316315, -0.02242976240813732, -0.02180633135139942, -0.004148976877331734, -0.00984776858240366, -0.00723543856292963, -0.06667935848236084, -0.060043253004550934, -0.020809024572372437, -0.01767846569418907, 0.011238607577979565, 0.06699678301811218, 0.027520855888724327, -0.0613543801009655, 0.061437930911779404, -0.024458780884742737, -0.03278656303882599, 0.04007614031434059, 0.002807651413604617, 0.013482872396707535, -0.01415656041353941, -0.038224466145038605, 0.00320351030677557, 0.010067025199532509, -0.001854090136475861, 0.07132813334465027, -0.007458908017724752, -0.004202347248792648, -0.025602346286177635, -0.011284725740551949, -0.018446829169988632, -0.043203916400671005, 0.04049268737435341, 0.0408325120806694, -0.047545287758111954, -0.03199562430381775, -0.05228882655501366, -0.04279765859246254, -0.01813395693898201, -0.028714805841445923, -0.028245728462934494, -0.03764672204852104, 0.03374771028757095, -0.07451345026493073, -0.0441163033246994, 0.03238062188029289, -0.01683199033141136, 0.005717622581869364, 0.04715888574719429, 0.018776709213852882, 0.003595801768824458, 0.00325252884067595, -0.005594994407147169, -0.03345135599374771, 0.06338237971067429, -0.02809102274477482, -0.04174605384469032, 0.05119132250547409, -0.015141329728066921, -0.05200301855802536, 0.030161742120981216, -0.05498227849602699, -0.056361209601163864, -0.008110028691589832, -0.026036718860268593, 0.05113973096013069, -0.06185048446059227, -0.015915213152766228, -0.03279366344213486, -0.05586698278784752, 0.01805214025080204, -0.048868756741285324, -0.05353909358382225, -0.010063857771456242, 0.006598754320293665, -0.004477278329432011, 0.014046942815184593, 0.06133868917822838, 0.03651106730103493, 0.00424484396353364, 0.03244500607252121, 0.04055528715252876, -0.027617551386356354, -0.01236669160425663, -0.04087972640991211, 0.007630800362676382, -0.010290337726473808, -0.05332024022936821, 0.035438794642686844, 0.041276901960372925, 0.02207893878221512, 0.055162351578474045, 0.03329721465706825, 0.007399196270853281, -0.03925007954239845, -0.008883961476385593, -0.038108814507722855, 0.001622052164748311, 0.006123258266597986, 0.011564543470740318, -0.007626362144947052, 0.0007620523101650178, -0.033620189875364304, 0.02685166336596012, 0.0038187841419130564, 0.04431680962443352, 0.015237880870699883, 0.004777953028678894, -0.019387032836675644, -0.04317967966198921, -0.05929197371006012, 0.03935927152633667, 0.021558081731200218, 0.006125771440565586, 0.0070484597235918045, 0.01200907677412033, 0.03537264093756676, 0.008026964031159878, -0.023240387439727783, -0.060196276754140854, -0.011012567207217216, 0.0727032870054245, 0.004561504814773798, 0.013961464166641235, -0.04819219559431076, -0.0017254388658329844, -0.013633056543767452, 0.06016525998711586, -0.039910245686769485, 0.04745865240693092, -0.05538647249341011, 0.008037369698286057, -0.021912647411227226, 0.013821936212480068, 0.028326956555247307, -0.052461788058280945, -0.04751651734113693, 0.015839511528611183, -0.04903288558125496, 0.047998614609241486, 0.07657640427350998, -0.06233177334070206, 0.02350720576941967, 0.03620503097772598, 0.03234481438994408, -0.007266769651323557, -0.0021210452541708946, 0.013262593187391758, 0.014521714299917221, -0.028217025101184845, -0.06912471354007721, 0.03533206135034561, 0.011788000352680683, -0.052136462181806564, 0.03126191720366478, 0.026363680139183998, -0.013584723696112633, 0.012269311584532261, 0.02757718227803707, -0.03582489490509033, -0.02025218866765499, 0.006720078643411398, -0.06192072480916977, -0.01712789013981819, 0.005223665852099657, -0.050836231559515, 0.016713932156562805, -0.03517471253871918, -0.031926680356264114, -0.041610702872276306, -0.01463840901851654, -0.009733101353049278, -0.05456002429127693, -0.02895239181816578, -0.0019479523180052638, 0.0036661396734416485, -0.008585288189351559, 0.018616434186697006, 0.018887342885136604, -0.009386501275002956, -0.017896264791488647, -0.08938586711883545, -0.013806154951453209, 0.03152468055486679, -0.047302164137363434, -0.025689033791422844, -0.05208444595336914, -0.00562535272911191, 0.04490823671221733, -0.04865345358848572, -0.05807727575302124, 0.015791427344083786, -0.020825322717428207, -0.0017934662755578756, -0.029646869748830795, -0.06788230687379837, -0.03908544033765793, 0.0028278441168367863, 0.006497504655271769, 0.0011916786897927523, -0.08354613184928894, -0.02047041803598404, -0.013044395484030247, -0.03176327049732208, -0.023352239280939102, 0.03821779787540436, 0.061025477945804596, 0.06534598767757416, -0.06288979202508926, -0.009859967976808548, -0.04985225573182106, -0.10511626303195953, 0.0030251743737608194, 0.02780822291970253, -0.022864792495965958, 0.05038745701313019, 0.021985743194818497, 0.028829321265220642, -0.02644585445523262, -0.025938767939805984, 0.05692831799387932, 0.05909602344036102, -0.009311949834227562, -0.03177798166871071, 0.0306467916816473, -0.00963143352419138, -0.04919973015785217, -0.037642136216163635, -0.03250274062156677, -0.01600649766623974, 0.005066865123808384, -0.07984164357185364, 0.04677288606762886, -0.04078712686896324, -0.0840611681342125, -0.035632602870464325, -0.04008115828037262, 0.046441152691841125, 0.007984211668372154, -0.05762390047311783, -0.012586677446961403, -0.06108779087662697, -0.018492335453629494, 0.02974070981144905, -0.010173781774938107, 0.01968512497842312, -0.08728061616420746, -0.03146664425730705, -0.012024070136249065, 0.014735480770468712, 0.045539867132902145, -0.006275958847254515, 0.033464137464761734, -0.014523590914905071, 0.03412451595067978, 0.01756955124437809, 0.045993465930223465, -0.02836802788078785, -0.007596543058753014, 0.029827140271663666, 0.015713321045041084, -0.02839224599301815, -0.05481062829494476, 0.027745414525270462, -0.007728909607976675, 0.00766600901260972, 0.020514320582151413, 0.04775594547390938, -0.022564943879842758, -0.011493262834846973, -0.011926504783332348, 0.02387981303036213, -0.014520935714244843, -0.0006847030599601567, 0.007328446488827467, 0.03516421094536781, 0.033277880400419235, -0.030100328847765923, -0.07166346907615662, -0.04165758565068245, -0.012033740989863873, -0.0326005220413208, -0.07957743108272552, -0.06402018666267395, 0.005291566718369722, -0.034290678799152374, 0.013517419807612896, -0.009717710316181183, -0.0436909981071949, -0.049367330968379974, -0.042875852435827255, 0.04316344112157822, 0.03874959424138069, 0.016071660444140434, -0.004054633900523186, -0.0495518259704113, 0.0316181406378746, 0.017341654747724533, 0.02261817269027233, -0.04372534900903702, -0.0396246537566185, -0.009564103558659554, 0.04210471734404564, -0.025415126234292984, -0.06922989338636398, -0.002142643555998802, 0.01730290614068508, -0.045239996165037155, -0.02897288091480732, 0.01250249333679676, 0.07915220409631729, 0.03547777235507965, 0.006464848760515451, -0.007963059470057487, -0.008011472411453724, -0.05478963255882263, -0.000497588946018368, -0.04097071662545204, -0.029244501143693924, -0.06419762969017029, -0.015772197395563126, 0.04560277983546257, 0.055994339287281036, 0.0012952208053320646, -0.00027643906651064754, -0.04150635004043579, -0.05002535134553909, 0.011251586489379406, -0.01809827983379364, 0.027872037142515182, 0.0000806984244263731, -0.018655404448509216, -0.014917569234967232, -0.04456586763262749, -0.01142732985317707, -0.018527718260884285, 0.013256383128464222, 0.02881508506834507, -0.05794841796159744, 0.030305705964565277, -0.06823277473449707, 0.02953885681927204, 0.014049993827939034, 0.06922491639852524, -0.022376418113708496, 0.02396196499466896, 0.016860995441675186, -0.015419078059494495, 0.00836324691772461, -0.04284906014800072, 0.039109449833631516, 0.007668936625123024, 0.04530797526240349, -0.04134508594870567, 0.0059869056567549706, -0.05966000631451607, -0.07431624084711075, -0.054369572550058365, -0.021293018013238907, 0.037548284977674484, 0.026146432384848595, -0.007953994907438755, -0.03827013075351715, 0.02507866360247135, -0.042815037071704865, 0.036937858909368515, 0.0035455417819321156, -0.031248942017555237, -0.034204501658678055, 0.005022396799176931, 0.0049730888567864895, 0.0012642784276977181, 0.033606115728616714, -0.003780362894758582, -0.024594297632575035, -0.0026181030552834272, -0.05429358780384064, 0.019597148522734642, -0.0037958426401019096, 0.012812898494303226, 0.03172532096505165, 0.013838237151503563, -0.02635343000292778, 0.0033123381435871124, -0.003860467579215765, 0.04339073225855827, 0.016282184049487114, 0.02002725377678871, 0.003534789429977536, -0.025580212473869324, -0.03626815974712372, 0.003246199106797576, -0.02988443709909916, -0.045097317546606064, -0.008122765459120274, -0.027048833668231964, 0.007844228297472, -0.030362499877810478, -0.07161711156368256, -0.056192245334386826, 0.005744630005210638, -0.0203951895236969, -0.015396973118185997, -0.07852420210838318, 0.08493373543024063, -0.0069594127126038074, -0.00203093234449625, 0.0026047679129987955, 0.01903693750500679, -0.0065283202566206455, -0.03448204696178436, -0.03624655678868294, -0.012307824566960335, -0.012819225899875164, -0.004023558925837278, -0.0256334375590086, -0.04846395552158356, -0.0024927484337240458, -0.05430104210972786, 0.04230538010597229, -0.03417119011282921, 0.03171738237142563, 0.06385122984647751, 0.02960360050201416, 0.04110347107052803, -0.018038969486951828, 0.05884655937552452, 0.038069434463977814, -0.04220373556017876, 0.06165584549307823, -0.010491392575204372, 0.00713948393240571, -0.040896520018577576, -0.03397208824753761, 0.0059753479436039925, -0.0706171989440918, 0.0633971244096756, -0.033147577196359634, -0.05257922038435936, 0.0018670513527467847, -0.008044595830142498, -0.021417899057269096, -0.03853084519505501, 0.032627567648887634, -0.004354288335889578, -0.03602856025099754, -0.02113238163292408, -0.014787743799388409, -0.0023536477237939835, -0.023097794502973557, 0.03317198529839516, 0.02822873555123806, -0.04615379124879837, -0.0029673560056835413, 0.0028067058883607388, 0.04954557120800018, 0.029260478913784027, 0.0074295648373663425, -0.023450227454304695, -0.0691085085272789, 0.007966370321810246, -0.03052069991827011, 0.00864039920270443, -0.028404224663972855, 0.004324338864535093, -0.028404347598552704, 0.04654349759221077, -0.09411658346652985, 0.032243601977825165, 0.0306987427175045, 0.013539574109017849, -0.02778402343392372, 0.005616486072540283, 0.027495991438627243, -0.001348844962194562, 0.035302046686410904, -0.009865880943834782, -0.002549639903008938, -0.019030602648854256, -0.02240980975329876, 0.0136412363499403, -0.033735550940036774, 0.03519420698285103, 0.02766606956720352, -0.01091520581394434, -0.03553356975317001, 0.0347856841981411, -0.012706306762993336, 0.024655625224113464, -0.0088512497022748, 0.028684688732028008, 0.030361358076334, -0.012731656432151794, -0.006838942877948284, 0.0027816693764179945, -0.02557101845741272, 0.02738938480615616, 0.014576800167560577, -0.027506781741976738, 0.009854529052972794, 0.04486554116010666, -0.03547711670398712, 0.06256933510303497, 0.040484990924596786, -0.03016643598675728, -0.028741637244820595, 0.008578193373978138, -0.06318828463554382, -0.06192004308104515, -0.031083829700946808, -0.04393200948834419, 0.017465919256210327, 0.03664472699165344, -0.005641927942633629, 0.06824170053005219, 0.04996274784207344, 0.030439801514148712, -0.025082314386963844, 0.016650820150971413, -0.005424611270427704, 0.018341848626732826, -0.06278665363788605, 0.05487023666501045, -0.033810097724199295, 0.01954144425690174, 0.008359183557331562, 0.029773566871881485, -0.008961773477494717, 0.03512902185320854, -0.07166348397731781, -0.005276739131659269, -0.003912368323653936, 0.009581227786839008, -0.07494247704744339, 0.027832364663481712, 0.03344578668475151, -0.044268786907196045, 0.0585293211042881, 0.012139616534113884, 0.02428608201444149, 0.026080789044499397, 0.015031243674457073, 0.03146154060959816, -0.029934953898191452, -0.08244141936302185, 0.07703320682048798, -0.08527907729148865, -0.01674487255513668, 0.00923556461930275, -0.07763785123825073, -0.04393169283866882, -0.059128619730472565, 0.0021723995450884104, 0.056085437536239624, -0.028597792610526085, -0.05426419898867607, 0.029720572754740715, 0.005154563579708338, -0.06460647284984589, 0.009564080275595188, 0.027513526380062103, -0.044407572597265244, 0.002606502966955304, -0.06214011460542679, 0.009024636819958687, -0.026790743693709373, -0.01375247910618782, -0.014635510742664337, -0.03651091828942299, -0.020129788666963577, -0.005160299129784107, 0.01327420398592949, -0.008756871335208416, -0.023097524419426918, 0.012953974306583405, -0.010331752710044384, -0.03893672302365303, -0.04539595544338226, -0.011341461911797523, 0.01520821638405323, 0.025529585778713226, -0.0034360443241894245, -0.003155580721795559, 0.03269540145993233, 0.026746131479740143, -0.05615927278995514, 0.011697378940880299, 0.02253909595310688, -0.027728011831641197, -0.01074681431055069, -0.02513412944972515, -0.004926230292767286, 0.03673915937542915, -0.03915230557322502, 0.03611686825752258, -0.034159425646066666, 0.014678310602903366, -0.02027658000588417, 0.000041764560592127964, 0.013325025327503681, 0.010378081351518631, -0.03149660676717758, -0.050601549446582794, -0.021519791334867477, -0.0065668192692101, -0.04812054708600044, 0.007264458574354649, 0.02061307802796364, 0.07243793457746506, -0.011483118869364262, -0.01976042240858078, -0.040116701275110245, -0.01445432472974062, -0.017737822607159615, -0.04768159240484238, -0.014852143824100494, 0.029831472784280777, 0.012047656811773777, -0.006778069771826267, 0.02444184012711048, -0.04943016171455383, 0.059956371784210205, -0.018877888098359108, -0.0571008175611496, 0.03375804051756859, -0.03259623050689697, -0.0419953353703022, -0.021160783246159554, -0.01649221032857895, -0.03316535800695419, 0.025969428941607475, 0.011043800041079521, -0.05588342621922493, -0.060341883450746536, -0.023148711770772934, -0.029555855318903923, -0.03140131011605263, 0.06463144719600677, -0.028957951813936234, 0.012361454777419567, 0.00801305752247572, 0.05672125890851021, 0.059192754328250885, -0.016455084085464478, -0.03331417217850685, -0.02219718135893345, -0.01824483647942543, 0.02905314229428768, -0.030035316944122314, -0.04441293701529503, -0.0008918753010220826, -0.03673467040061951, -0.08228692412376404, 0.011628690175712109, -0.008173245936632156, -0.013414931483566761, -0.056225087493658066, -0.01646612398326397, 0.06801432371139526, 0.011480948887765408, 0.006835318636149168, -0.06747854501008987, 0.03415390104055405, 0.034065086394548416, 0.00018685073882807046, -0.042391203343868256, -0.001353100291453302, -0.04379827156662941, 0.004329563118517399, -0.08754502236843109, 0.01324626337736845, -0.021364469081163406, 0.06965107470750809, 0.026911811903119087, -0.021772198379039764, 0.03355545550584793, -0.06108684092760086, -0.04997006431221962, -0.005839664954692125, 0.042257532477378845, -0.0004206077428534627, -0.03973402827978134, 0.06703019887208939, -0.036180123686790466, 0.04674680903553963, 0.015195527113974094, -0.04941849038004875, 0.01968231424689293, 0.016078395769000053, 0.03629307821393013, -0.025747183710336685, 0.04060715436935425, 0.038832519203424454, -0.026031076908111572, 0.052525248378515244, -0.01596730202436447, 0.02826625481247902, -0.022693078964948654, -0.0708276778459549, -0.02972513623535633, -0.05211617797613144, -0.024606840685009956, -0.0281610619276762, -0.02585223875939846, -0.041073158383369446, -0.0010956964688375592, -0.035621944814920425, -0.020687052980065346, -0.0003994081635028124, -0.052074532955884933, 0.058102142065763474, -0.05274984985589981, -0.049994077533483505, -0.02545066922903061, -0.010969792492687702, -0.04175075888633728, 0.040591634809970856, 0.07197512686252594, -0.07493078708648682, 0.06568756699562073, -0.06935596466064453, 0.029143627732992172, -0.012630907818675041, 0.007427731528878212, -0.01138048991560936, 0.04403167590498924, -0.0518249049782753, -0.00020872754976153374, -0.03303023800253868, -0.026885533705353737, 0.00904806051403284, -0.05553094670176506, -0.023662636056542397, -0.022438159212470055, 0.05000615119934082, 0.030307870358228683, -0.026397578418254852, -0.03474082052707672, 0.08655846863985062, 0.013724010437726974, -0.013426870107650757, 0.0017027255380526185, -0.0008323055226355791, 0.020180480554699898, 0.02327343448996544, 0.020343026146292686, -0.0304351095110178, -0.038170937448740005, -0.009554881602525711, 0.027672985568642616, -0.005395198706537485, -0.02548651210963726, 0.04037075862288475, 0.0013959830394014716, -0.036409467458724976, -0.005804109387099743, 0.04254330322146416, 0.03262273222208023, -0.005848597269505262, 0.0009395320666953921, 0.04573522135615349, -0.011063657701015472, -0.07118158042430878 ]
Offline Reinforcement Learning (RL) enables policy learning without active interactions, making it especially appealing for self-driving tasks. Recent successes of Transformers inspire casting offline RL as sequence modeling, which, however, fails in stochastic environments with incorrect assumptions that identical actions can consistently achieve the same goal. In this paper, we introduce an UNcertainty-awaRE deciSion Transformer (UNREST) for planning in stochastic driving environments without introducing additional transition or complex generative models. Specifically, UNREST estimates uncertainties by conditional mutual information between transitions and returns. Discovering 'uncertainty accumulation' and 'temporal locality' properties of driving environments, we replace the global returns in decision transformers with truncated returns less affected by environments to learn from actual outcomes of actions rather than environment transitions. We also dynamically evaluate uncertainty at inference for cautious planning. Extensive experiments demonstrate UNREST's superior performance in various driving scenarios and the power of our uncertainty estimation strategy.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16397v3
[ -0.05605122074484825, -0.034472692757844925, 0.025939906015992165, 0.021372653543949127, -0.01590082049369812, 0.017279837280511856, 0.02653319761157036, 0.023365218192338943, 0.023714013397693634, -0.031116187572479248, -0.03637067601084709, -0.029598871245980263, -0.028970234096050262, -0.030753031373023987, -0.027294369414448738, -0.009721090085804462, 0.061716992408037186, 0.007794244680553675, -0.04481596499681473, 0.020992962643504143, 0.021564556285738945, -0.014781794510781765, -0.0652957484126091, 0.024463670328259468, -0.0010489328997209668, -0.04187783971428871, 0.004871914628893137, 0.010557238943874836, -0.020117271691560745, 0.018722740933299065, 0.0722988024353981, -0.01417204737663269, 0.002888816175982356, -0.03815016895532608, -0.018125368282198906, -0.04574451223015785, 0.02296888642013073, 0.03186549246311188, 0.01652858406305313, -0.011172018013894558, 0.037579867988824844, -0.028832243755459785, -0.054674841463565826, -0.019139951094985008, -0.04625147953629494, -0.008249957114458084, -0.0249725803732872, -0.0016570227453485131, -0.06502915918827057, -0.03597027063369751, 0.051566094160079956, -0.001123367459513247, 0.01595637947320938, 0.01490661408752203, -0.06306913495063782, 0.029546596109867096, 0.010970248840749264, 0.022571511566638947, -0.058825887739658356, -0.04560251161456108, 0.0018912912346422672, -0.028817756101489067, 0.01990772783756256, 0.02843880094587803, 0.01122330129146576, 0.05527326837182045, -0.01830252632498741, -0.03508346527814865, -0.03751986846327782, -0.054002415388822556, 0.022686684504151344, -0.04821576550602913, -0.022186726331710815, -0.002084719715639949, -0.03952823206782341, -0.009044960141181946, -0.030749598518013954, -0.025062449276447296, 0.042762137949466705, -0.0056274752132594585, 0.00041883677477017045, 0.01370881125330925, 0.0237713735550642, 0.02909170649945736, 0.021107759326696396, -0.011363303288817406, 0.056938331574201584, 0.026987915858626366, 0.015728246420621872, 0.0032816759776324034, 0.032903656363487244, -0.03986044228076935, -0.025771811604499817, -0.002800363814458251, 0.03250203654170036, -0.04001437872648239, 0.061422958970069885, 0.01564781740307808, 0.019094839692115784, 0.002473795088008046, -0.06014905497431755, -0.008931021206080914, -0.023695185780525208, 0.06145089119672775, 0.059332869946956635, -0.03259631246328354, -0.020687362179160118, 0.028344279155135155, -0.04056643694639206, 0.020781569182872772, -0.03967719152569771, -0.020825285464525223, 0.016007045283913612, -0.06886771321296692, -0.03278348967432976, -0.052331067621707916, 0.05267474427819252, -0.00504672946408391, 0.034065477550029755, 0.019281107932329178, -0.06585538387298584, 0.04526171833276749, 0.029628606513142586, -0.025751369073987007, -0.02149232290685177, -0.03146636486053467, 0.08418717980384827, 0.017138099297881126, 0.02445359341800213, 0.05782856419682503, -0.015604933723807335, 0.04219033941626549, 0.012355780228972435, -0.05386459827423096, 0.06225396320223808, 0.020163755863904953, -0.001833070651628077, -0.0498349629342556, 0.008369204588234425, -0.030064906924962997, -0.03446619212627411, -0.06964939832687378, 0.016638679429888725, -0.011568667367100716, 0.0003237401833757758, 0.03196749463677406, -0.06252014636993408, -0.047433800995349884, -0.008957109414041042, 0.013871087692677975, 0.016492441296577454, -0.008035087026655674, 0.04743422195315361, 0.03866851329803467, 0.05120505765080452, -0.0036838455125689507, 0.055379197001457214, -0.02312738262116909, -0.06668712198734283, 0.015376674942672253, 0.04157017543911934, -0.041953980922698975, 0.03627309575676918, -0.034076888114213943, 0.039270710200071335, -0.01684972085058689, 0.05242400988936424, -0.018624255433678627, -0.025400148704648018, -0.013550140894949436, -0.024550143629312515, 0.059644147753715515, 0.01997510716319084, -0.0049736169166862965, -0.06589242070913315, -0.05615488067269325, 0.01454608328640461, -0.033132053911685944, -0.006768534891307354, 0.02187112346291542, -0.01685790903866291, 0.02623957209289074, -0.01907900534570217, -0.0077438075095415115, -0.04151943325996399, 0.019804108887910843, -0.08212990313768387, -0.0242018923163414, 0.015173814259469509, 0.009580283425748348, -0.04513978958129883, -0.04085245728492737, 0.015030136331915855, 0.016086170449852943, -0.06502097100019455, -0.04112619906663895, -0.009183960035443306, -0.018508652225136757, 0.019377676770091057, 0.03919558972120285, -0.0898439884185791, -0.010715960524976254, -0.04624098911881447, 0.00933835469186306, -0.016138140112161636, -0.05648994818329811, 0.0016907521057873964, 0.041313931345939636, -0.01400363352149725, -0.012367862276732922, -0.006773839239031076, 0.03875206783413887, 0.02620577998459339, 0.04446582868695259, 0.029392993077635765, -0.008366554975509644, -0.10697130113840103, 0.04905248433351517, -0.00347788049839437, 0.002249248092994094, 0.02451452612876892, 0.011473015882074833, 0.013544917106628418, -0.016972161829471588, 0.024787642061710358, 0.040327709168195724, 0.06491823494434357, -0.04060524329543114, -0.0554690957069397, -0.06703618168830872, -0.024567393586039543, -0.05178581550717354, -0.04320919141173363, -0.0864599272608757, -0.03820900619029999, 0.006232668180018663, -0.036736201494932175, 0.05992770940065384, -0.025731710717082024, 0.006203531287610531, -0.06322436779737473, -0.009755889885127544, 0.030992543324828148, -0.02384037710726261, -0.054540108889341354, -0.06342040002346039, -0.019521959125995636, -0.0017049004090949893, -0.010845541022717953, -0.01087723858654499, -0.015768539160490036, -0.043326761573553085, 0.009850614704191685, -0.06639549136161804, 0.02623906172811985, 0.06521299481391907, -0.03615514189004898, 0.0487770177423954, -0.03476691618561745, 0.027527227997779846, -0.010656477883458138, 0.02626901865005493, -0.059660404920578, -0.002861614339053631, 0.007532126735895872, 0.006406673230230808, 0.010308470577001572, -0.039350830018520355, -0.002136790193617344, -0.06756910681724548, 0.018212271854281425, 0.015597918070852757, 0.03726930543780327, 0.007293275091797113, -0.019236139953136444, -0.019051458686590195, 0.008368988521397114, -0.0036952595692127943, 0.01925775222480297, 0.015193788334727287, 0.038190167397260666, 0.01808333769440651, 0.034038327634334564, -0.05018727481365204, 0.006798152811825275, -0.028376834467053413, -0.0018632137216627598, -0.04502851888537407, -0.04543446749448776, -0.053958710283041, -0.078900046646595, -0.021618815138936043, -0.02374889701604843, -0.03525121510028839, -0.00791856274008751, -0.020543690770864487, -0.02515922300517559, 0.0038764248602092266, 0.02839709259569645, -0.051741454750299454, -0.019902290776371956, -0.02165820822119713, 0.0037333997897803783, 0.002605447778478265, -0.01882936991751194, -0.06654129922389984, -0.06289216876029968, -0.0752323716878891, 0.002065765205770731, 0.0029376656748354435, -0.01008701603859663, 0.004121007397770882, -0.026458874344825745, 0.0469522662460804, -0.010601093992590904, 0.0215595792979002, -0.015508228912949562, 0.007623249664902687, -0.029862644150853157, -0.047725219279527664, 0.028448421508073807, 0.022936394438147545, -0.001449128845706582, -0.0019915117882192135, -0.054806239902973175, 0.011862285435199738, 0.07878559082746506, -0.003198962425813079, -0.01426531933248043, -0.039357177913188934, 0.008807213976979256, 0.029400022700428963, -0.012266245670616627, -0.015717780217528343, 0.06382602453231812, 0.04760874807834625, -0.0292971208691597, -0.02429250441491604, -0.012155150063335896, -0.007794598583132029, -0.01411436591297388, 0.03503702953457832, -0.06194337457418442, 0.013744101859629154, 0.0564802885055542, -0.08513034880161285, 0.019902629777789116, 0.033441029489040375, 0.05489194765686989, -0.010646972805261612, 0.003236297983676195, 0.004083958920091391, 0.02046249248087406, 0.038672953844070435, 0.0360974557697773, 0.006870312616229057, 0.052797604352235794, 0.06091826781630516, -0.03701641783118248, -0.0039878105744719505, -0.03682250902056694, -0.08548778295516968, -0.04288467764854431, -0.009606444276869297, 0.05543741583824158, 0.014784632250666618, 0.028490450233221054, -0.05701809749007225, 0.04292035847902298, 0.005736560560762882, 0.055474281311035156, 0.04836238920688629, -0.025141863152384758, 0.03223934397101402, -0.040787458419799805, -0.020196840167045593, -0.018046004697680473, 0.04726042225956917, 0.03171311318874359, -0.027357973158359528, 0.0012390721822157502, -0.036517489701509476, 0.01222500391304493, -0.01144056674093008, -0.038158781826496124, 0.042015690356492996, 0.04740959405899048, -0.03220212832093239, 0.06050071865320206, -0.017582615837454796, 0.007889613509178162, 0.021857520565390587, -0.010547995567321777, 0.011199340224266052, -0.01598585583269596, -0.06643649935722351, -0.0342419296503067, 0.023687250912189484, -0.016561638563871384, 0.001826865249313414, -0.006541535258293152, 0.0061446367762982845, -0.03425958380103111, -0.08452364057302475, 0.02715931460261345, -0.050432536751031876, 0.036593254655599594, -0.002261695684865117, 0.0064432802610099316, 0.0788036361336708, -0.020030183717608452, 0.02559714950621128, -0.0378967709839344, -0.021932892501354218, -0.03787548467516899, -0.044100210070610046, -0.014643605798482895, -0.06660609692335129, 0.03737480938434601, -0.06984391063451767, 0.03434174880385399, -0.042373936623334885, 0.03617638722062111, -0.03813401237130165, -0.009583873674273491, 0.013440937735140324, 0.0651838555932045, 0.045279428362846375, 0.06690149009227753, -0.004497966729104519, 0.0016694603255018592, -0.00943464320152998, -0.011652837507426739, 0.03592810407280922, -0.040265943855047226, -0.0187748484313488, 0.0281711183488369, -0.057877905666828156, -0.013150678016245365, -0.03373881056904793, 0.020573638379573822, 0.040439423173666, -0.033210963010787964, -0.02960880473256111, 0.00997977890074253, 0.06250908970832825, -0.05485306307673454, -0.06524670869112015, -0.031206998974084854, -0.03219350799918175, -0.0610772930085659, 0.014539748430252075, 0.031808119267225266, 0.00706907594576478, -0.03534165397286415, -0.01863166317343712, 0.04029056057333946, 0.026466405019164085, 0.03378796949982643, 0.03619314357638359, 0.009662861935794353, 0.008928806520998478, 0.020281650125980377, -0.035098858177661896, -0.08207709342241287, -0.00330903846770525, -0.02724512293934822, -0.004893934354186058, -0.03191504254937172, 0.0416736826300621, 0.015405382961034775, 0.05290648341178894, -0.08511312305927277, 0.027158865705132484, 0.04087071493268013, -0.005427244585007429, 0.007847674190998077, 0.05530437082052231, -0.025707505643367767, 0.0323457345366478, -0.03997766599059105, -0.006484661251306534, 0.05033758655190468, -0.057788245379924774, 0.011906941421329975, -0.037281669676303864, -0.008506154641509056, -0.0029876127373427153, 0.04692946746945381, 0.007424551993608475, -0.053509797900915146, 0.003572010202333331, -0.010904609225690365, 0.03769300505518913, -0.058186329901218414, 0.035577137023210526, 0.04486038163304329, -0.034703001379966736, -0.028998898342251778, -0.025655515491962433, -0.010589894838631153, 0.010006267577409744, 0.04724026471376419, -0.04770112782716751, -0.01552218571305275, 0.022515909746289253, 0.006888017989695072, -0.017944857478141785, 0.011541985906660557, 0.020665565505623817, -0.006529081612825394, -0.0016239219112321734, 0.0017311180708929896, -0.07567914575338364, -0.007423064671456814, -0.044802162796258926, 0.044009141623973846, -0.0018511064117774367, 0.015867961570620537, 0.01922968402504921, 0.015226220712065697, -0.0610906258225441, -0.04413493350148201, 0.03333496302366257, -0.025492655113339424, 0.02522062137722969, -0.04880135506391525, 0.03293982520699501, 0.01616516336798668, 0.035041771829128265, -0.041088420897722244, -0.00025380461011081934, 0.018026908859610558, -0.040640607476234436, -0.030449217185378075, -0.022693665698170662, 0.04567782208323479, -0.041491925716400146, -0.017514638602733612, -0.003579168813303113, 0.01823125220835209, -0.0011717743473127484, 0.030697589740157127, 0.015829011797904968, -0.007452797144651413, 0.01061435230076313, 0.0008412810857407749, 0.035776685923337936, -0.008517962880432606, 0.04588175565004349, 0.09047669172286987, -0.06100280210375786, -0.0029748810920864344, -0.04170088469982147, -0.04474790766835213, 0.013208186253905296, -0.04257301986217499, 0.004742247052490711, -0.001999638509005308, -0.007770263124257326, -0.05775193125009537, 0.004543689079582691, -0.02951965108513832, -0.0761035680770874, -0.04156509041786194, 0.03432697057723999, -0.06939200311899185, 0.01271750871092081, 0.04117526113986969, -0.03807244077324867, -0.04188036918640137, 0.07888221740722656, 0.014989074319601059, -0.015054922550916672, -0.03189784288406372, 0.0641946941614151, 0.08803094178438187, -0.014789149165153503, -0.004038896411657333, 0.012322570197284222, -0.001066841883584857, 0.036696288734674454, -0.026486966758966446, 0.0044473204761743546, 0.032788876444101334, 0.03361179307103157, 0.022355150431394577, -0.010136577300727367, 0.002702397760003805, 0.06250882148742676, -0.017197048291563988, -0.015702540054917336, 0.0034560777712613344, -0.0036757751367986202, 0.036677706986665726, -0.012918236665427685, -0.04376215487718582, -0.009387867525219917, -0.000028673222914221697, -0.041724320501089096, -0.05352751165628433, -0.03671172261238098, 0.02294253744184971, -0.017132041975855827, 0.030602050945162773, -0.06557225435972214, 0.0072388178668916225, -0.02382519841194153, -0.07248847186565399, 0.053531523793935776, -0.04528196156024933, 0.013677775859832764, -0.03283192217350006, -0.0333651602268219, 0.002675473690032959, 0.026705091819167137, -0.06593060493469238, -0.012933173216879368, -0.024509137496352196, 0.052350401878356934, -0.002281550318002701, 0.01181872095912695, 0.010662536136806011, 0.0019428279483690858, 0.05650182440876961, -0.010340862907469273, -0.01741131767630577, -0.0005921475822106004, -0.06065019220113754, 0.034278497099876404, -0.01943196915090084, -0.039996981620788574, -0.06581590324640274, 0.03213253244757652, -0.030855607241392136, -0.002837446751073003, 0.006991473957896233, -0.019900308921933174, -0.07464483380317688, 0.02558080479502678, 0.019402652978897095, 0.005594535730779171, 0.001562532503157854, 0.02533005364239216, 0.01709681935608387, -0.005733164958655834, 0.025205282494425774, 0.02173922397196293, 0.00022812691167928278, 0.04711596295237541, -0.009479531086981297, -0.04602483659982681, 0.02752869389951229, -0.0322805717587471, -0.019677206873893738, -0.0205228291451931, -0.04546093940734863, -0.06900501251220703, 0.02332303114235401, 0.0588843896985054, 0.01677105762064457, 0.010314985178411007, -0.08660628646612167, 0.023061081767082214, 0.012850483879446983, -0.03546274080872536, -0.03687320649623871, -0.011272273026406765, 0.0048482720740139484, -0.004302230663597584, 0.00124608282931149, -0.03252500295639038, -0.07103320211172104, 0.0020066292490810156, -0.08700274676084518, -0.017802145332098007, 0.0191231407225132, 0.05149185284972191, -0.01318669505417347, -0.003973090555518866, 0.0012804374564439058, 0.006959917955100536, 0.026638291776180267, -0.001470496179535985, 0.0002722824865486473, 0.03222108259797096, 0.07305335253477097, 0.005402970127761364, -0.06594517081975937, -0.06355106085538864, 0.053718384355306625, 0.0005118202534504235, -0.017095929011702538, 0.04254959523677826, 0.0401763878762722, 0.056184254586696625, -0.015936346724629402, 0.05389057844877243, 0.01539615262299776, 0.039633430540561676, -0.02716751955449581, 0.034363556653261185, -0.02362746372818947, -0.06159587204456329, 0.014318159781396389, -0.040677234530448914, 0.021514244377613068, 0.027092797681689262, -0.003251156769692898, -0.011290829628705978, -0.04959748312830925, -0.04957706853747368, 0.0472625307738781, -0.010060169734060764, -0.015402502380311489, 0.05215313285589218, -0.04390837624669075, 0.0325784832239151, 0.004550692159682512, -0.02627752721309662, 0.002046050038188696, 0.041742872446775436, 0.030328419059515, -0.0065131885930895805, -0.036077830940485, -0.0653110221028328, 0.014274440705776215, 0.02200131304562092, 0.02987881749868393, -0.051613979041576385, 0.0758170560002327, -0.0032158554531633854, -0.06655817478895187, -0.0011763625079765916, -0.006871099583804607, -0.0416068360209465, -0.06561223417520523, 0.005044981371611357, -0.021115103736519814, 0.037398871034383774, 0.0025374731048941612, 0.0095434058457613, 0.029120931401848793, 0.05006348714232445, 0.03969566151499748, 0.03605298325419426, -0.00937983300536871, 0.011206516996026039, -0.048505667597055435, 0.07586250454187393, -0.010515747591853142, 0.00926127564162016, -0.016626257449388504, 0.014301645569503307, -0.0037431721575558186, 0.00481609208509326, -0.01712075062096119, 0.02005276270210743, 0.0026514374185353518, -0.01424518320709467, -0.03465734422206879, 0.017584720626473427, -0.026160571724176407, -0.060914743691682816, 0.004931419622153044, 0.019096819683909416, -0.039296187460422516, -0.0608823224902153 ]
We introduce the Sparsity Roofline, a visual performance model for evaluating sparsity in neural networks. The Sparsity Roofline jointly models network accuracy, sparsity, and theoretical inference speedup. Our approach does not require implementing and benchmarking optimized kernels, and the theoretical speedup becomes equal to the actual speedup when the corresponding dense and sparse kernels are well-optimized. We achieve this through a novel analytical model for predicting sparse network performance, and validate the predicted speedup using several real-world computer vision architectures pruned across a range of sparsity patterns and degrees. We demonstrate the utility and ease-of-use of our model through two case studies: (1) we show how machine learning researchers can predict the performance of unimplemented or unoptimized block-structured sparsity patterns, and (2) we show how hardware designers can predict the performance implications of new sparsity patterns and sparse data formats in hardware. In both scenarios, the Sparsity Roofline helps performance experts identify sparsity regimes with the highest performance potential.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00496v2
[ -0.030899466946721077, -0.01562560722231865, 0.05670420452952385, 0.03148157522082329, 0.0269473884254694, -0.04592357203364372, -0.019820690155029297, 0.004207681864500046, 0.02525503560900688, -0.04435135796666145, -0.03423444181680679, 0.03520890697836876, -0.05273832008242607, -0.06069149449467659, -0.0006968114757910371, 0.0021452715154737234, 0.06701809167861938, 0.042445436120033264, -0.04615332931280136, 0.07807104289531708, -0.005078024696558714, -0.043860454112291336, -0.028140773996710777, 0.025885529816150665, -0.03524203598499298, -0.03787527233362198, -0.049357008188962936, 0.014232931658625603, -0.03253839910030365, -0.01475861482322216, 0.03431525453925133, -0.018386906012892723, -0.03004644066095352, -0.042190611362457275, -0.04357919842004776, -0.00459651555866003, -0.024059055373072624, 0.04478749632835388, 0.05519149452447891, -0.04242799058556557, 0.02941618673503399, -0.029422637075185776, -0.02877872623503208, -0.022471889853477478, 0.005860151257365942, 0.007361427880823612, -0.033322110772132874, -0.009485270828008652, -0.04909973591566086, -0.030721385031938553, 0.020863885059952736, -0.029977859929203987, 0.018211137503385544, 0.032592616975307465, -0.04036753624677658, -0.013873780146241188, -0.01899402216076851, 0.025193260982632637, -0.04812771826982498, -0.01840302161872387, 0.01508816797286272, -0.025168048217892647, -0.03166680783033371, 0.003692205995321274, 0.030429251492023468, 0.04308697208762169, -0.026221880689263344, -0.06048263609409332, -0.009417145512998104, -0.0047593736089766026, 0.06144114211201668, -0.055684976279735565, 0.03798776865005493, -0.008170552551746368, -0.04806142300367355, -0.013239816762506962, -0.0027583385817706585, -0.010702535510063171, 0.04547177255153656, 0.02198183722794056, -0.05752042308449745, 0.02501455508172512, 0.04454144462943077, 0.05213535577058792, -0.04279928281903267, -0.014056302607059479, 0.04180688410997391, 0.0473504513502121, 0.02219558134675026, -0.021066896617412567, 0.03240519389510155, -0.015123020857572556, -0.07477480918169022, 0.03302852064371109, 0.0463511198759079, -0.005477424710988998, 0.03458075225353241, 0.03271910920739174, 0.00434526102617383, -0.03743242099881172, -0.05290408805012703, -0.029372982680797577, -0.041881393641233444, 0.031031768769025803, 0.051994286477565765, -0.033478014171123505, -0.022385763004422188, 0.020845655351877213, -0.04354768991470337, -0.00444918405264616, -0.0349925234913826, -0.0018969817319884896, 0.0230046808719635, -0.061806995421648026, -0.007067661266773939, -0.05760568007826805, 0.04919537156820297, 0.06099372357130051, 0.008688672445714474, 0.03390681371092796, -0.033642031252384186, 0.02294399030506611, 0.010633565485477448, -0.03865932673215866, -0.01835622824728489, -0.035370923578739166, 0.049612704664468765, -0.03174184635281563, -0.001668017590418458, 0.004534331150352955, -0.011454468593001366, 0.05739914998412132, -0.009466600604355335, -0.04602332040667534, 0.07485604286193848, -0.06733313947916031, 0.024214042350649834, -0.03222895413637161, 0.003536855336278677, -0.03167107328772545, -0.0676112249493599, -0.07108380645513535, 0.01601238362491131, -0.003488504095003009, 0.022190576419234276, 0.06133270263671875, -0.03723066672682762, -0.024565530940890312, 0.003810418304055929, 0.033899638801813126, 0.05844000726938248, -0.022811200469732285, 0.005052061751484871, -0.011414751410484314, 0.0055301194079220295, -0.005251994822174311, 0.03677748143672943, -0.03498794883489609, -0.021280240267515182, -0.006664920598268509, 0.03568580374121666, -0.005350097548216581, 0.013758157379925251, -0.04624165594577789, 0.003586717415601015, -0.0058820671401917934, 0.01767776533961296, -0.00630907854065299, -0.005465393420308828, 0.027912862598896027, -0.028175758197903633, -0.0042464639991521835, 0.005857012700289488, -0.036707986146211624, -0.05989475175738335, -0.04896116256713867, -0.005480277352035046, -0.03761395066976547, -0.03306521102786064, -0.015456282533705235, 0.006127890199422836, 0.012918929569423199, -0.026600755751132965, 0.016756514087319374, -0.04174567386507988, -0.03417188674211502, -0.07959581911563873, -0.0026776879094541073, -0.005881941877305508, 0.025675995275378227, -0.007647205144166946, -0.048728469759225845, 0.04446268826723099, -0.015550331212580204, -0.014769324101507664, -0.028086449950933456, 0.021974662318825722, 0.007881459780037403, -0.027571216225624084, 0.05876275151968002, -0.07130927592515945, 0.001413883175700903, -0.03149765357375145, -0.022052321583032608, -0.018671058118343353, -0.05980478599667549, 0.04395059868693352, 0.023838961496949196, -0.05812438949942589, -0.025859937071800232, 0.041519053280353546, 0.04782900959253311, 0.05371004343032837, 0.025151411071419716, 0.001984398579224944, -0.02097982168197632, -0.0901535227894783, 0.0009290185407735407, -0.004280790686607361, 0.002088849898427725, 0.03555050492286682, 0.0423177033662796, -0.03846123814582825, -0.0225476436316967, -0.012909077107906342, 0.052873071283102036, 0.06508631259202957, -0.019841402769088745, -0.06159324198961258, 0.01826907880604267, -0.038622524589300156, -0.051111530512571335, -0.04009389504790306, -0.06568455696105957, -0.01907193288207054, -0.016124693676829338, -0.020482055842876434, 0.04839431867003441, 0.030627280473709106, -0.032318364828825, -0.015014366246759892, -0.06821652501821518, 0.021818241104483604, -0.023190390318632126, -0.03340046480298042, -0.033596768975257874, -0.04728643223643303, 0.03979448601603508, -0.01910329982638359, 0.03319164738059044, -0.031191416084766388, -0.05193139985203743, -0.015031106770038605, -0.016509490087628365, 0.050712041556835175, 0.006794473621994257, 0.0009587911772541702, 0.019373534247279167, -0.03507016599178314, 0.06380452960729599, 0.0021201996132731438, 0.02381804771721363, -0.04752909392118454, -0.007043985649943352, 0.04115047678351402, 0.027758801355957985, -0.02867351844906807, -0.01099230907857418, 0.025264663621783257, -0.05888160690665245, -0.00464387284591794, 0.013431486673653126, 0.03145721182227135, -0.021770423278212547, -0.004513806197792292, -0.0093670804053545, -0.04375668242573738, -0.05489397421479225, 0.041952356696128845, 0.06322062015533447, 0.028300482779741287, 0.02681063301861286, 0.05107647553086281, -0.0637032762169838, 0.00758986035361886, -0.017918767407536507, -0.009461949579417706, -0.06464166194200516, -0.03437380492687225, -0.06038589030504227, -0.0753742977976799, -0.04254522547125816, -0.009726433083415031, -0.037094004452228546, -0.020046291872859, -0.0474274680018425, -0.0019388808868825436, -0.006562359165400267, 0.024597367271780968, -0.036576006561517715, -0.057083744555711746, -0.05715595930814743, 0.020455794408917427, 0.04403601586818695, 0.015854602679610252, -0.08121205866336823, -0.043983880430459976, -0.029224872589111328, 0.02781866304576397, -0.02231656387448311, -0.021373126655817032, 0.011632774956524372, -0.0006849690689705312, 0.03337493911385536, -0.004743014927953482, -0.008088767528533936, 0.017262503504753113, -0.0008298422326333821, 0.004429889377206564, -0.014303607866168022, 0.03877854347229004, 0.027247166261076927, 0.03324437886476517, -0.060017671436071396, -0.02297782339155674, -0.05335819348692894, 0.06159289926290512, -0.022001413628458977, -0.0687696561217308, 0.0003245290135964751, 0.019578078761696815, 0.007824821397662163, 0.008875553496181965, -0.007996266707777977, 0.03702111542224884, 0.026195475831627846, -0.016606271266937256, 0.03088308870792389, -0.03482746705412865, 0.02055566944181919, -0.01045486144721508, 0.04659402370452881, -0.03438319265842438, -0.020113755017518997, 0.010495448485016823, -0.08703835308551788, 0.004254891071468592, 0.04704046621918678, 0.05962907522916794, -0.057745881378650665, 0.017082752659916878, 0.02632254734635353, 0.030594762414693832, 0.01983397640287876, -0.0010389788076281548, 0.013141468167304993, 0.06069531664252281, 0.04781830310821533, -0.034930478781461716, -0.05331283435225487, 0.04201003536581993, -0.051158566027879715, -0.058051612228155136, 0.04451486095786095, 0.0025748375337570906, 0.029051437973976135, 0.040577907115221024, -0.04286906123161316, 0.021736491471529007, 0.009293670766055584, 0.041273776441812515, 0.008137470111250877, -0.026348786428570747, 0.02081749215722084, -0.07807526737451553, 0.07356516271829605, 0.011379304341971874, -0.018994854763150215, 0.01841289922595024, -0.060254957526922226, -0.021372370421886444, -0.07197976857423782, 0.005362528841942549, -0.009157801978290081, -0.04126414656639099, 0.016445161774754524, 0.04944764822721481, -0.025695400312542915, 0.07452616095542908, 0.023924898356199265, -0.029050234705209732, 0.005006651394069195, 0.013019373640418053, 0.0017114001093432307, 0.01252436451613903, -0.05355612188577652, -0.00984626542776823, 0.0021489481441676617, -0.0028761273715645075, -0.014211858622729778, 0.027313943952322006, -0.049212198704481125, 0.028533564880490303, -0.07672429829835892, 0.02047031559050083, -0.020924149081110954, 0.060817208141088486, -0.03858703002333641, -0.033897656947374344, 0.06216229870915413, -0.044211193919181824, -0.010207820683717728, -0.04077485576272011, -0.03792081028223038, -0.04812533035874367, -0.030023053288459778, -0.02877410314977169, -0.07138355076313019, 0.017315462231636047, -0.05828368663787842, 0.0032803108915686607, -0.023733407258987427, 0.020297938957810402, -0.01531083881855011, -0.011179395951330662, 0.0356258898973465, 0.044847387820482254, 0.04779395833611488, 0.012544529512524605, -0.010171161964535713, -0.026165831834077835, -0.02146594226360321, 0.009125146083533764, -0.03212627395987511, -0.012894951738417149, -0.0053914738819003105, 0.05671323090791702, -0.03488308563828468, -0.04236527904868126, -0.010464487597346306, 0.0010419725440442562, 0.034698985517024994, -0.03058723546564579, -0.04749177768826485, -0.03258879482746124, 0.04788757860660553, -0.060405805706977844, -0.059700824320316315, 0.009879178367555141, -0.0559476874768734, -0.06425897777080536, -0.05108293518424034, 0.04626055806875229, 0.02089877799153328, -0.04370946064591408, 0.03487902879714966, 0.03149549290537834, 0.03980960696935654, -0.006930954288691282, 0.02414270117878914, 0.01972520723938942, 0.00785909779369831, -0.01673988811671734, -0.010256764478981495, -0.05707426741719246, -0.017040720209479332, -0.008095567114651203, 0.04375572130084038, -0.008116474375128746, 0.019825151190161705, -0.009927711449563503, 0.02462098002433777, -0.07898467779159546, 0.014681724831461906, 0.03302989900112152, -0.026342151686549187, 0.024093661457300186, -0.001486040884628892, -0.011372181586921215, 0.024509739130735397, -0.05118785426020622, -0.006114567164331675, 0.050470396876335144, -0.009076596237719059, 0.020122436806559563, 0.04688647389411926, -0.03104751743376255, -0.0369342565536499, 0.05273362249135971, 0.02703407034277916, -0.03156018257141113, -0.00030270995921455324, 0.06140301749110222, 0.04991645738482475, 0.010969985276460648, 0.014319580048322678, 0.04314468801021576, -0.025124922394752502, -0.019895324483513832, -0.02316410094499588, 0.027531804516911507, -0.0252167247235775, 0.008736499585211277, -0.010760542936623096, -0.0016117279883474112, 0.021963847801089287, 0.019434507936239243, -0.0016169367590919137, -0.009524475783109665, 0.015256943181157112, -0.0010067340917885303, -0.028686122968792915, 0.01712765358388424, -0.03554108366370201, 0.010892187245190144, 0.031056636944413185, -0.0007550862501375377, 0.008526495657861233, 0.049537718296051025, -0.00610759761184454, -0.0005905476864427328, -0.028569836169481277, -0.06376834213733673, -0.012666125781834126, -0.0327109694480896, 0.03334007412195206, -0.024847734719514847, 0.019702838733792305, 0.0062614865601062775, 0.0607881061732769, -0.014365840703248978, -0.010114261880517006, 0.018868109211325645, -0.033829543739557266, -0.017344094812870026, -0.02623704820871353, 0.038340721279382706, -0.038375332951545715, -0.03341878578066826, 0.0026915408670902252, 0.03258349001407623, -0.01563289947807789, 0.05219888314604759, 0.0690741017460823, -0.010250391438603401, 0.031660616397857666, 0.00025889414246194065, 0.006713226903229952, -0.06394907832145691, 0.03631627559661865, 0.054521478712558746, -0.04122468829154968, 0.008238689042627811, -0.048684027045965195, -0.05842527002096176, 0.018188927322626114, -0.004131702706217766, 0.039187487214803696, 0.011379268020391464, 0.0012691197916865349, -0.06183924898505211, 0.038196712732315063, -0.024457601830363274, -0.07044660300016403, 0.029492784291505814, -0.010785791091620922, -0.06282873451709747, 0.03344838693737984, 0.04864899441599846, -0.025176536291837692, -0.023329751566052437, 0.026352141052484512, -0.004282394424080849, -0.009951007552444935, -0.05630078539252281, 0.05456352233886719, 0.08274608850479126, -0.030340464785695076, -0.0038054094184190035, 0.01414825301617384, -0.03779861330986023, 0.011897094547748566, 0.009680834598839283, -0.0019729784689843655, -0.04538799822330475, -0.009953283704817295, 0.013647367246448994, -0.06278972327709198, -0.04000689089298248, 0.08077841997146606, -0.009143219329416752, -0.04303300008177757, -0.00295639899559319, 0.0028454873245209455, 0.04153518006205559, -0.06702564656734467, -0.03602202236652374, -0.02613578923046589, -0.02696928381919861, -0.048017509281635284, -0.05942259356379509, 0.048651501536369324, -0.024821389466524124, -0.008051109500229359, -0.009693332947790623, -0.048073843121528625, 0.02268926613032818, 0.010884094052016735, -0.04390355572104454, 0.020355137065052986, -0.06495922803878784, 0.008734905160963535, -0.003769693663343787, 0.0494045689702034, 0.032047636806964874, 0.07517624646425247, -0.05457059666514397, -0.04411062225699425, -0.016407771036028862, 0.011050325818359852, 0.0064242868684232235, -0.038438599556684494, -0.019766777753829956, -0.021013962104916573, 0.0443773977458477, -0.03686295822262764, -0.005773754324764013, -0.03715251013636589, -0.023514695465564728, -0.023172052577137947, -0.006433964241296053, -0.0032455273903906345, -0.048951223492622375, -0.017439397051930428, -0.05151989683508873, -0.01960710436105728, 0.04186967760324478, -0.03399587422609329, -0.07021179795265198, 0.024809658527374268, -0.016819050535559654, -0.036866262555122375, 0.020579665899276733, -0.015364433638751507, 0.010588238015770912, -0.037189941853284836, 0.04640461504459381, 0.04415086284279823, -0.02568865567445755, 0.016052845865488052, -0.06119868531823158, -0.04857964068651199, 0.014605678617954254, 0.030201822519302368, -0.060030851513147354, -0.05681580305099487, -0.018299605697393417, -0.08045260608196259, -0.012070192955434322, 0.04161709174513817, -0.011247795075178146, -0.02236079052090645, -0.06976669281721115, -0.005113183055073023, -0.006574559025466442, -0.06203296408057213, -0.048566706478595734, 0.023457547649741173, 0.014581847004592419, -0.03722023963928223, 0.013032305985689163, 0.04773182049393654, -0.05702386796474457, 0.020199520513415337, -0.08673317730426788, -0.05440281704068184, 0.019620053470134735, 0.03130676969885826, 0.024623755365610123, -0.023331407457590103, -0.053948741406202316, -0.0460464246571064, 0.0005723540671169758, 0.003928249701857567, 0.002320799045264721, -0.025080841034650803, 0.028329459950327873, -0.01802637055516243, -0.03736496716737747, -0.05411549657583237, 0.06879156082868576, -0.0004522804811131209, -0.03414096683263779, 0.03239442780613899, 0.02807273156940937, 0.060852907598018646, 0.005008390173316002, 0.0573333315551281, -0.003092205850407481, 0.030566850677132607, -0.014446732588112354, 0.05629100650548935, -0.03928900137543678, -0.0486781932413578, 0.06261704117059708, -0.05045601725578308, -0.026809746399521828, -0.011260545812547207, -0.02680780179798603, -0.00717643229290843, -0.02072971872985363, -0.04963570088148117, 0.021492205560207367, 0.008830764330923557, 0.03538688272237778, 0.01975240185856819, -0.04627636447548866, 0.04697759076952934, -0.01361189316958189, 0.016301607713103294, -0.04468522220849991, 0.03748311474919319, 0.020603781566023827, -0.04974532499909401, 0.0015466625336557627, -0.044707607477903366, 0.014276599511504173, -0.014428826980292797, -0.019461246207356453, -0.013999095186591148, 0.07453276216983795, 0.0005906423320993781, -0.01692882552742958, -0.007609920110553503, 0.01538777444511652, -0.03403836488723755, -0.07350179553031921, -0.03188811615109444, -0.030505036935210228, 0.048077020794153214, 0.01411448884755373, 0.03294225409626961, 0.005309270229190588, 0.05732739344239235, 0.024392327293753624, 0.000678222335409373, 0.01490858942270279, 0.005597489420324564, -0.04230978712439537, 0.07298054546117783, 0.022940078750252724, 0.017889205366373062, -0.035478319972753525, 0.03907427564263344, -0.033640164881944656, -0.023485274985432625, -0.0008152410155162215, -0.04615382105112076, -0.06007896363735199, -0.04037027806043625, -0.0031542254146188498, 0.009223319590091705, -0.01825811341404915, -0.04060044512152672, 0.002967331325635314, -0.01195157878100872, 0.005551562178879976, -0.03510501608252525 ]
In this paper we present the first investigation into the effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) for Failure Mode Classification (FMC). FMC, the task of automatically labelling an observation with a corresponding failure mode code, is a critical task in the maintenance domain as it reduces the need for reliability engineers to spend their time manually analysing work orders. We detail our approach to prompt engineering to enable an LLM to predict the failure mode of a given observation using a restricted code list. We demonstrate that the performance of a GPT-3.5 model (F1=0.80) fine-tuned on annotated data is a significant improvement over a currently available text classification model (F1=0.60) trained on the same annotated data set. The fine-tuned model also outperforms the out-of-the box GPT-3.5 (F1=0.46). This investigation reinforces the need for high quality fine-tuning data sets for domain-specific tasks using LLMs.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08181v1
[ -0.01254783570766449, -0.039020128548145294, 0.037120021879673004, 0.019938534125685692, -0.02833249419927597, -0.004727060440927744, -0.012035004794597626, 0.004743148107081652, 0.011862545274198055, 0.00996438693255186, -0.04202117770910263, 0.041772883385419846, -0.06726270169019699, -0.02319219335913658, -0.06449776142835617, 0.006472705863416195, 0.06186393275856972, -0.0272066630423069, -0.0019733619410544634, 0.06778864562511444, 0.023791590705513954, 0.01520333532243967, -0.08251617103815079, 0.025830544531345367, 0.046367187052965164, -0.011663385666906834, -0.038426175713539124, -0.028212856501340866, 0.024221105501055717, -0.0010020846966654062, 0.06238330528140068, -0.01424598228186369, -0.03715546056628227, -0.019627170637249947, -0.004071473143994808, -0.03889327868819237, 0.005090663675218821, 0.0379209890961647, 0.025510717183351517, -0.00872955471277237, 0.028827758505940437, -0.005730793811380863, -0.04055245965719223, -0.04446783661842346, -0.021572105586528778, 0.024622827768325806, -0.03403887525200844, 0.007154406979680061, -0.04117055609822273, -0.048707325011491776, 0.06821975111961365, -0.03550132364034653, -0.041977427899837494, 0.04722470045089722, -0.02546730637550354, -0.031642697751522064, -0.0015992256812751293, -0.010945090092718601, -0.052361782640218735, -0.012332023121416569, 0.04569290578365326, -0.025539513677358627, -0.03034992516040802, -0.0036777269560843706, 0.013722051866352558, 0.023683013394474983, 0.01762714423239231, -0.06251108646392822, -0.034304022789001465, -0.035164542496204376, 0.04617719724774361, -0.031354859471321106, -0.03934222459793091, 0.0005160854780115187, -0.005506803281605244, -0.04620068520307541, -0.046058062463998795, -0.018760373815894127, -0.04179985076189041, -0.015582175925374031, -0.03643118590116501, 0.0373687706887722, 0.02894027903676033, 0.005179563537240028, 0.037046920508146286, -0.06946389377117157, 0.04612299054861069, -0.00463106157258153, -0.01596188358962536, -0.029371580109000206, 0.037586040794849396, -0.04056771472096443, -0.08167405426502228, -0.017758402973413467, 0.04776247218251228, -0.009242663159966469, 0.06676337122917175, -0.005525080021470785, -0.022230038419365883, -0.0028888785745948553, -0.0587758868932724, -0.02324003353714943, -0.03657768294215202, 0.06665747612714767, 0.053456105291843414, -0.0039242105558514595, 0.020081421360373497, 0.027407368645071983, -0.03137185424566269, -0.006614724174141884, -0.043117959052324295, -0.060277633368968964, -0.007791728246957064, -0.06118916720151901, -0.0695526972413063, 0.001210812944918871, 0.016518957912921906, 0.015711769461631775, -0.017165977507829666, 0.013828646391630173, -0.02322298288345337, 0.03725690394639969, 0.07074928283691406, -0.022324398159980774, -0.037389058619737625, -0.04241000860929489, 0.0654640793800354, -0.0027764865662902594, -0.005065398756414652, -0.06046910211443901, -0.05155833438038826, 0.008604229427874088, 0.0005304545047692955, -0.030056379735469818, 0.05036013200879097, -0.00019106370746158063, -0.03505992889404297, -0.04194772616028786, 0.05616692081093788, -0.03297396004199982, -0.018937669694423676, -0.08428308367729187, 0.05448770895600319, -0.04350122809410095, 0.014395736157894135, 0.05620615929365158, -0.022018563002347946, -0.017823247238993645, 0.06311315298080444, -0.01248898170888424, -0.017643606290221214, -0.007916310802102089, -0.02987859584391117, 0.04708990827202797, 0.05348177254199982, 0.022075800225138664, 0.053881943225860596, -0.035206109285354614, -0.060436323285102844, 0.030543509870767593, -0.0013506270479410887, -0.006777499802410603, -0.0009085274650715292, -0.0023162325378507376, 0.01725049503147602, -0.03366298973560333, 0.020660793408751488, -0.014139450155198574, -0.0022974410094320774, 0.023126812651753426, -0.02019190788269043, -0.031307876110076904, 0.011931190267205238, -0.04689190536737442, -0.04073797166347504, -0.02756475657224655, 0.01412578858435154, -0.03532528132200241, -0.01866399310529232, -0.03160605579614639, 0.00762309180572629, 0.03066357783973217, -0.04872322082519531, -0.020526304841041565, -0.05997821316123009, -0.025268329307436943, -0.08615381270647049, -0.024778008460998535, 0.008070573210716248, 0.010089661926031113, -0.03472341224551201, 0.0006600833730772138, 0.017848270013928413, 0.004342005122452974, 0.01404730323702097, -0.016155235469341278, 0.03774772211909294, 0.016070440411567688, 0.018689051270484924, 0.02734502963721752, -0.090296171605587, -0.06437962502241135, -0.03335113823413849, 0.024711769074201584, -0.02777603641152382, -0.04988476261496544, -0.00645911181345582, 0.04455355554819107, -0.03134310245513916, 0.05141130089759827, 0.0642542839050293, 0.05275755003094673, 0.07275203615427017, -0.005803230218589306, 0.04352337494492531, 0.01718754880130291, -0.09750605374574661, 0.05151063948869705, -0.024729186668992043, -0.004421439487487078, 0.043677981942892075, 0.03106692247092724, -0.027424339205026627, -0.025539511814713478, 0.011083105579018593, 0.05418838560581207, 0.043485529720783234, -0.03295291215181351, -0.00018252052541356534, -0.025104081258177757, -0.025389721617102623, -0.03161129727959633, -0.056530967354774475, -0.06889650970697403, -0.028521835803985596, 0.016999492421746254, -0.028398413211107254, 0.015539256855845451, -0.0335155688226223, -0.040881842374801636, -0.035306770354509354, -0.0243215374648571, 0.03362570330500603, -0.012374235317111015, -0.032332416623830795, -0.05048510059714317, -0.046971648931503296, 0.03311840072274208, -0.017311910167336464, 0.016980526968836784, -0.04643558710813522, -0.04364031180739403, 0.011376883834600449, -0.041941333562135696, 0.02376209944486618, 0.02795860543847084, 0.023207753896713257, 0.02143007330596447, -0.018402112647891045, 0.03388842195272446, 0.0037744715809822083, 0.03496113419532776, -0.0585688054561615, 0.01449594832956791, 0.0009251177543774247, -0.037166204303503036, -0.02446838468313217, 0.007897179573774338, -0.044504377990961075, -0.0017169172642752528, 0.005885687191039324, 0.057771023362874985, 0.047663334757089615, -0.03273173049092293, -0.03676367551088333, -0.004217319656163454, 0.03321749344468117, -0.0246582068502903, -0.006061329040676355, 0.0287679024040699, 0.020047426223754883, 0.009135964326560497, -0.018147818744182587, -0.0544341579079628, -0.00885146576911211, -0.05120847746729851, -0.013978569768369198, -0.0743650570511818, -0.016418810933828354, -0.04228804633021355, -0.059502966701984406, -0.0029636945109814405, -0.007953786291182041, -0.039695531129837036, -0.019587133079767227, -0.05116807669401169, -0.04605434462428093, 0.01038429420441389, 0.02450340986251831, -0.025428511202335358, -0.05738871544599533, -0.06088079884648323, 0.03754301741719246, -0.019785257056355476, 0.0483991764485836, -0.06151162087917328, -0.0360543467104435, -0.0032357852905988693, 0.03334730491042137, 0.0070742168463766575, -0.030919775366783142, 0.025253821164369583, 0.0011037851218134165, 0.024221086874604225, -0.010762038640677929, 0.0751747265458107, 0.0005947282770648599, 0.023173309862613678, 0.006737313698977232, 0.006618354469537735, 0.02974849008023739, 0.0238360483199358, -0.00021606315567623824, -0.0462142713367939, -0.031164366751909256, -0.03358105942606926, 0.05454213172197342, -0.029616056010127068, -0.02126208320260048, -0.007791496347635984, -0.025908512994647026, 0.0350547693669796, 0.013848898001015186, 0.003978588152676821, 0.015276908874511719, 0.04783874377608299, -0.01845257543027401, -0.008614348247647285, -0.023017527535557747, -0.020573880523443222, -0.0010527516715228558, 0.027767913416028023, -0.020833663642406464, 0.005038911011070013, 0.03830656409263611, -0.09187086671590805, -0.003508136374875903, 0.0410001315176487, 0.055211544036865234, -0.005158150568604469, 0.002642149105668068, -0.04142339155077934, 0.011049716733396053, 0.004640328697860241, -0.012101954780519009, 0.03702292591333389, 0.052926551550626755, 0.038634445518255234, 0.033177122473716736, -0.06726983934640884, 0.01915336586534977, -0.04375603795051575, 0.003139576641842723, -0.03964611515402794, -0.013564101420342922, -0.02589404210448265, -0.01112255360931158, -0.06670547276735306, 0.04142685607075691, 0.000767864054068923, 0.044487155973911285, 0.04043998196721077, -0.024960817769169807, 0.04441402107477188, -0.04085972160100937, -0.008345188573002815, 0.026707520708441734, -0.006480368319898844, 0.03137015551328659, -0.05189698189496994, 0.03264973312616348, -0.05769917368888855, 0.019241563975811005, 0.05795598775148392, -0.006835347041487694, 0.05066874250769615, 0.05128544196486473, 0.017531730234622955, 0.028443584218621254, -0.048867594450712204, -0.033225465565919876, 0.0016798728611320257, -0.0033471405040472746, 0.00893192645162344, 0.009421804919838905, -0.05438375473022461, 0.007764087058603764, 0.033568374812603, -0.03038833476603031, -0.015203077346086502, 0.028901774436235428, 0.006681772880256176, -0.016048632562160492, -0.08059753477573395, 0.018444282934069633, -0.06504669785499573, 0.05045513063669205, -0.05388493835926056, -0.03674327954649925, 0.03440222889184952, -0.04559657722711563, -0.05026569217443466, -0.03395386412739754, -0.03490906581282616, 0.02881193719804287, -0.0545218288898468, -0.04053638502955437, -0.05753529444336891, -0.02288421429693699, -0.06841281056404114, 0.05791196972131729, -0.020364169031381607, -0.024915646761655807, -0.02106091007590294, -0.04804356396198273, -0.013189462013542652, 0.011865115724503994, 0.05279393121600151, -0.0009391374187543988, -0.026811791583895683, -0.020131565630435944, -0.03297444060444832, -0.006369838956743479, -0.0014710419345647097, -0.01454149279743433, -0.038871023803949356, -0.0062393187545239925, 0.0028819891158491373, 0.015251543372869492, -0.01483625452965498, 0.05335498973727226, 0.06207515671849251, -0.009023643098771572, -0.026289016008377075, 0.0025357496924698353, 0.06263964623212814, -0.05457235872745514, -0.06589996069669724, 0.02183784358203411, -0.037806637585163116, -0.05825667455792427, -0.0554700642824173, 0.022630855441093445, 0.020383942872285843, -0.05526185780763626, -0.002336801728233695, 0.05358649790287018, 0.0038240638095885515, -0.019888995215296745, -0.021986782550811768, 0.0637236163020134, -0.015446944162249565, -0.018379157409071922, -0.010940909385681152, -0.07335715740919113, -0.04101983830332756, -0.026120448485016823, -0.004312332719564438, -0.030418584123253822, 0.036543089896440506, 0.04396611824631691, 0.05623236671090126, -0.0663408413529396, 0.04260140284895897, 0.0028138519264757633, -0.028467068448662758, 0.019279740750789642, 0.05740004777908325, -0.013509515672922134, 0.04754669591784477, -0.043910618871450424, 0.010446765460073948, 0.027431724593043327, -0.04925915226340294, 0.011020144447684288, 0.026858514174818993, -0.05349767208099365, -0.011242263950407505, 0.024344246834516525, 0.02441609464585781, -0.060531020164489746, 0.016926610842347145, 0.010687918402254581, 0.03764422982931137, -0.05622364953160286, 0.018878739327192307, 0.0653148666024208, 0.006233599036931992, -0.04134802147746086, 0.0246605072170496, 0.0015707460697740316, -0.0007810955285094678, -0.03136484697461128, -0.06746406108140945, -0.01015511155128479, 0.03750132769346237, -0.019822146743535995, -0.004085072316229343, 0.04471595585346222, 0.02544054016470909, -0.039688609540462494, -0.025450894609093666, 0.011251289397478104, -0.03694329038262367, -0.04056599363684654, -0.024944137781858444, 0.027304645627737045, 0.05757209658622742, 0.00952243059873581, 0.027388565242290497, 0.023300841450691223, -0.006178629584610462, -0.0034035788848996162, 0.0017548301257193089, -0.0162236075848341, 0.03902275860309601, -0.013276214711368084, 0.00016956290346570313, -0.0148025406524539, 0.05949913710355759, 0.049241259694099426, 0.04016050696372986, 0.005816262681037188, 0.007879739627242088, -0.042880043387413025, -0.008460759185254574, 0.022704273462295532, -0.05453639104962349, -0.041391532868146896, 0.027957646176218987, 0.0176122784614563, -0.03297502174973488, -0.03272128850221634, 0.0014708202797919512, -0.004939940292388201, 0.03487246856093407, -0.000653164170216769, -0.07391117513179779, -0.04400215297937393, -0.0006883745663799345, 0.06712153553962708, -0.03134393319487572, 0.03898875415325165, 0.012855740264058113, -0.045177116990089417, 0.03517903760075569, -0.021581128239631653, 0.04889263957738876, 0.035349730402231216, 0.004259573295712471, -0.04256841912865639, 0.05811629071831703, 0.012225261889398098, -0.0632825717329979, 0.023347582668066025, 0.021388450637459755, -0.07930498570203781, 0.010295405052602291, 0.01579313352704048, -0.02241753786802292, -0.04296529293060303, 0.07128563523292542, 0.02279820293188095, -0.012295825406908989, 0.007015995215624571, -0.00024596165167167783, 0.087288998067379, -0.017753561958670616, 0.030550936236977577, 0.04347169026732445, -0.0674418956041336, 0.001178212114609778, 0.014826344326138496, 0.017596282064914703, 0.011254945769906044, 0.012399163097143173, -0.0023254118859767914, -0.004939067177474499, 0.0015709174331277609, 0.06275984644889832, -0.05633164942264557, -0.008995754644274712, 0.02728934772312641, 0.0064335716888308525, 0.0342135950922966, -0.03847130015492439, -0.018447071313858032, 0.026312844827771187, -0.019248122349381447, 0.007699688896536827, -0.07780039310455322, 0.0041030170395970345, -0.012179277837276459, 0.00292637525126338, -0.027716873213648796, -0.07539734989404678, 0.008383727632462978, -0.03428054600954056, -0.06928438693284988, -0.009602462872862816, -0.052458375692367554, -0.006734133698046207, -0.0057894447818398476, -0.006246779579669237, 0.005886202212423086, 0.07017182558774948, -0.05808395892381668, -0.06863689422607422, 0.02194831520318985, -0.0021453499794006348, -0.0245549064129591, -0.04354380443692207, 0.01839047111570835, -0.013461810536682606, 0.05974164232611656, -0.02936866134405136, -0.00965929590165615, -0.019554516300559044, -0.048751458525657654, 0.026074538007378578, 0.0026143165305256844, -0.0025979429483413696, -0.04005506634712219, 0.030269047245383263, -0.030670680105686188, -0.00879670213907957, -0.03130713850259781, -0.0775417611002922, -0.05962562933564186, -0.03835676982998848, 0.01648571901023388, -0.00644870288670063, 0.011676478199660778, 0.052181486040353775, 0.049662552773952484, -0.018920699134469032, -0.010360597632825375, -0.017773935571312904, 0.045711345970630646, 0.0068450989201664925, -0.03226383775472641, -0.00037491865805350244, 0.011773955076932907, -0.026222070679068565, -0.011683009564876556, 0.01437376905232668, 0.0028276066295802593, -0.05033716559410095, 0.0022712654899805784, 0.050731539726257324, 0.03156489506363869, -0.025707755237817764, -0.07031241804361343, 0.015641754493117332, 0.02197670191526413, -0.06380446255207062, -0.06884123384952545, -0.004441835917532444, 0.019337931647896767, -0.06270507723093033, -0.008262349292635918, -0.020133476704359055, -0.024874761700630188, -0.0028461231850087643, -0.08350112289190292, 0.01740976795554161, 0.009994749911129475, 0.035300515592098236, 0.05163031816482544, -0.047409821301698685, 0.011545383371412754, -0.02024569734930992, 0.020412731915712357, 0.015422875061631203, -0.0030268386472016573, 0.027019310742616653, 0.014551202766597271, 0.0033030787017196417, -0.05660131573677063, -0.0045793852768838406, 0.062205180525779724, -0.019010402262210846, 0.019482431933283806, 0.03055761568248272, 0.006329155992716551, 0.03946365788578987, -0.0018936741398647428, 0.06628834456205368, -0.02976103127002716, 0.02969825267791748, -0.042114246636629105, 0.008635095320641994, 0.005763012915849686, -0.05893644690513611, 0.0012218051124364138, -0.06911623477935791, 0.014855758287012577, 0.03848407417535782, -0.011810571886599064, -0.004197539296001196, -0.011876256205141544, -0.04452873393893242, 0.012387415394186974, 0.00018619142065290362, -0.039951588958501816, 0.03579767048358917, 0.014715902507305145, 0.006382466293871403, -0.012488821521401405, -0.04341540485620499, -0.046207454055547714, 0.018231460824608803, 0.017221009358763695, -0.0278960969299078, 0.014969410374760628, -0.07668343186378479, 0.03392540290951729, 0.003738763276487589, 0.04112784564495087, -0.02241656184196472, 0.08306165784597397, 0.0140288220718503, -0.05163537710905075, -0.030242344364523888, -0.044436849653720856, -0.042577240616083145, -0.05617278814315796, -0.059816692024469376, -0.019391359761357307, -0.0032901610247790813, -0.029227564111351967, -0.015266471542418003, -0.029525848105549812, 0.05950995907187462, 0.0052680401131510735, 0.014019460417330265, 0.01635671779513359, -0.01597176492214203, -0.05371696874499321, 0.08756925165653229, 0.007621374446898699, 0.016530770808458328, -0.025290068238973618, 0.015924742445349693, 0.003653895342722535, -0.01461005862802267, -0.010508903302252293, 0.022435838356614113, 0.05845615267753601, -0.03540821373462677, 0.012653771787881851, -0.013702898286283016, -0.02676745317876339, -0.02852022647857666, -0.007265194784849882, -0.023580672219395638, -0.01389442291110754, -0.045895323157310486 ]
The Weyl-Wigner representation of quantum mechanics allows one to map the density operator in a function in phase space - the Wigner function - which acts like a probability distribution. In the context of statistical mechanics, this mapping makes the transition from the classical to the quantum regimes very clear, because the thermal Wigner function tends to the Boltzmann distribution in the high temperature limit. We approximate this quantum phase space representation of the canonical density operator for general temperatures in terms of classical trajectories, which are obtained through a Wick rotation of the semiclassical approximation for the Weyl propagator. A numerical scheme which allows us to apply the approximation for a broad class of systems is also developed. The approximation is assessed by testing it against systems with one and two degrees of freedom, which shows that, for a considerable range of parameters, the thermodynamic averages are well reproduced.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16613v2
[ 0.003049911232665181, -0.05619349330663681, -0.013874441385269165, 0.020506782457232475, 0.0070801787078380585, -0.020391449332237244, 0.03652574494481087, 0.0018198499456048012, -0.005119957961142063, 0.021355541422963142, -0.05605247616767883, -0.0410330630838871, -0.029096828773617744, -0.06386497616767883, -0.06266949325799942, 0.0123240165412426, 0.06809920072555542, 0.024895597249269485, -0.06426014751195908, 0.06629019230604172, 0.012919238768517971, -0.008685820735991001, -0.007213810458779335, 0.07099059969186783, -0.025073491036891937, 0.0349293127655983, -0.030124394223093987, -0.03388438746333122, -0.05316736921668053, -0.04095391556620598, 0.027955329045653343, -0.03441397473216057, 0.03466220200061798, -0.01269025169312954, 0.0007547690765932202, 0.0034086364321410656, -0.042859990149736404, 0.023541098460555077, 0.04718288779258728, -0.005921489559113979, 0.011049522086977959, -0.0400579459965229, -0.03066442720592022, -0.010673831216990948, -0.008786334656178951, 0.006092216353863478, -0.0463840626180172, -0.0009934831177815795, -0.04054391011595726, -0.048660825937986374, 0.020944682881236076, 0.026939908042550087, 0.02340332418680191, 0.059097036719322205, -0.043758828192949295, -0.012374598532915115, -0.02422725036740303, -0.0013159197987988591, -0.05670277029275894, -0.02395046502351761, -0.03111019730567932, -0.01815365068614483, 0.0415622852742672, -0.04048953205347061, -0.04751415550708771, 0.06010786443948746, -0.04538298025727272, -0.06473235040903091, -0.00886466633528471, -0.07674431055784225, 0.007938317023217678, -0.05943373218178749, -0.003940628841519356, 0.034637369215488434, -0.06584803760051727, -0.02745332568883896, -0.00818846095353365, -0.03425415977835655, 0.012738408520817757, 0.055570874363183975, -0.00047110734158195555, 0.018654940649867058, 0.034276388585567474, 0.019130399450659752, 0.05118667334318161, -0.014539718627929688, 0.04443684592843056, 0.003305895021185279, 0.007664280012249947, -0.032141879200935364, 0.024171791970729828, 0.006534069310873747, -0.05156373977661133, -0.004435141105204821, 0.06797201931476593, -0.04601884260773659, 0.0685897022485733, 0.04898780584335327, 0.0027349633164703846, -0.009202525019645691, 0.0047308593057096004, -0.0501532144844532, -0.012168562039732933, 0.058137569576501846, 0.017890501767396927, -0.023014115169644356, 0.001545208622701466, -0.006668050307780504, 0.0048420000821352005, 0.0011778651969507337, -0.0020306759979575872, 0.016582468524575233, 0.019007639959454536, -0.024119233712553978, -0.01690351590514183, -0.033574122935533524, 0.06045345962047577, 0.01801224611699581, 0.05787817761301994, -0.058796558529138565, -0.04303987696766853, 0.04277004674077034, 0.019975176081061363, 0.008852598257362843, -0.02270893193781376, 0.009042126126587391, 0.06243402883410454, 0.002645201748237014, -0.010594015009701252, -0.022510435432195663, -0.04069269448518753, -0.008063092827796936, 0.022313766181468964, 0.024256015196442604, 0.019866587594151497, 0.01023197267204523, -0.024764547124505043, 0.014202567748725414, -0.029809141531586647, 0.02797575853765011, -0.01363400649279356, -0.061020344495773315, 0.006095796823501587, -0.011742755770683289, 0.019137892872095108, -0.002858454827219248, -0.060238201171159744, 0.022600842639803886, 0.007516674697399139, 0.023880168795585632, 0.017425810918211937, -0.0028466859366744757, 0.010954576544463634, 0.01449308730661869, 0.002305647125467658, -0.004749874118715525, 0.06892042607069016, -0.010437562130391598, -0.046572212129831314, 0.019232414662837982, 0.007318838965147734, -0.00039131459197960794, -0.057355497032403946, -0.032222770154476166, -0.014184738509356976, -0.016005219891667366, 0.053560733795166016, -0.035671964287757874, -0.015673696994781494, -0.04265909641981125, -0.05591137707233429, 0.034090060740709305, 0.048974260687828064, -0.0397597998380661, -0.040495794266462326, -0.05233320593833923, -0.04154099524021149, -0.05542168766260147, -0.013683776371181011, 0.036143604665994644, 0.005962987896054983, -0.0261506550014019, -0.016141630709171295, -0.011555495671927929, -0.0606011226773262, -0.010328047908842564, -0.07663670182228088, 0.00850722473114729, 0.029522540047764778, -0.04064677655696869, 0.0014060026733204722, -0.020017484202980995, 0.013443428091704845, 0.03655785322189331, -0.04417220130562782, -0.03879952430725098, 0.025095047429203987, -0.04792530834674835, -0.051155973225831985, 0.017224473878741264, -0.056621283292770386, -0.030623922124505043, -0.01173042505979538, -0.03054077737033367, -0.01685585454106331, -0.050024569034576416, 0.026107115671038628, 0.01281458418816328, -0.03299238905310631, -0.019634179770946503, 0.050419826060533524, 0.02664414793252945, 0.049546126276254654, -0.04374849423766136, 0.0014027191791683435, 0.01319601945579052, -0.08794157952070236, -0.0036947692278772593, -0.009366926737129688, 0.0330621600151062, -0.006733465474098921, 0.036594558507204056, -0.015680886805057526, -0.05837520211935043, -0.009379664435982704, 0.07120619714260101, 0.059809695929288864, 0.04492081701755524, -0.06676039844751358, -0.014073974452912807, -0.01906237006187439, -0.014740134589374065, -0.040569599717855453, -0.07453674077987671, -0.04554889723658562, 0.01585725136101246, 0.0010590937454253435, 0.028406379744410515, -0.009000572375953197, -0.05698667839169502, -0.051945433020591736, -0.013002250343561172, 0.018902193754911423, -0.03913099318742752, 0.01894177310168743, -0.04870632663369179, -0.03852715715765953, 0.022081386297941208, 0.018562547862529755, -0.04000939056277275, -0.02241448499262333, -0.05945785716176033, -0.00707598589360714, -0.05634871870279312, 0.015764055773615837, 0.030089905485510826, 0.00289433472789824, 0.05327102541923523, 0.0054740821942687035, 0.04578228294849396, 0.056949976831674576, 0.026633180677890778, -0.05282573774456978, 0.023059170693159103, -0.016668686643242836, 0.004776285029947758, -0.0678490549325943, -0.017891941592097282, 0.011869369074702263, -0.0402618944644928, 0.026236722245812416, -0.022540803998708725, 0.07182660698890686, 0.0026151586789637804, 0.0560733824968338, -0.0062327515333890915, -0.055186741054058075, -0.05231824889779091, 0.0296748336404562, 0.058073826134204865, 0.04756089299917221, 0.00674830935895443, -0.021317191421985626, -0.07086304575204849, -0.01091843843460083, 0.0015082224272191525, 0.006777270697057247, -0.0733816996216774, -0.04427117109298706, -0.03401251509785652, -0.04865759611129761, -0.02667759172618389, -0.056032415479421616, 0.008355297148227692, -0.0367354117333889, -0.06699953228235245, -0.012576188892126083, -0.010483945719897747, 0.011402913369238377, -0.06347065418958664, -0.058655329048633575, 0.0010376437567174435, 0.0573476143181324, 0.05515342578291893, -0.0624319389462471, -0.05559706687927246, 0.00946736615151167, 0.01685759797692299, -0.01569545641541481, 0.02777213416993618, -0.0223148912191391, -0.003776120487600565, -0.01322076003998518, -0.0003146690141875297, 0.00452838372439146, -0.04508819058537483, 0.0373157262802124, -0.04349149018526077, 0.02039836160838604, -0.051839813590049744, -0.00729580270126462, -0.013759886845946312, 0.013560155406594276, 0.04135000705718994, -0.059206798672676086, -0.04698272421956062, 0.02263733185827732, 0.03880752995610237, -0.02151932194828987, -0.012886607088148594, -0.053435489535331726, 0.011102071963250637, 0.021790791302919388, -0.00517931068316102, 0.07601305097341537, 0.05592537671327591, -0.044027093797922134, 0.006624944508075714, -0.047681596130132675, -0.0038362364284694195, -0.00339856231585145, 0.039491575211286545, -0.014203800819814205, 0.022607211023569107, 0.017836635932326317, -0.07712724059820175, 0.044101737439632416, 0.05491312965750694, 0.02720545046031475, -0.028054306283593178, -0.05386478453874588, -0.034063562750816345, -0.04499081149697304, -0.0069462088868021965, 0.00820071343332529, 0.010501326993107796, 0.017287878319621086, 0.041687775403261185, -0.06856470555067062, -0.009471634402871132, -0.033713825047016144, -0.05373680964112282, -0.05310153216123581, -0.01878584921360016, 0.04174388200044632, 0.042781442403793335, -0.013113140128552914, -0.01017010398209095, 0.018963731825351715, -0.05847528576850891, 0.06302179396152496, 0.03297607600688934, -0.030998865142464638, 0.01937350071966648, -0.017659135162830353, -0.01285336073487997, 0.04068952798843384, -0.011419320479035378, -0.03781174495816231, -0.04265636205673218, 0.04042370244860649, -0.047505978494882584, -0.01051246002316475, -0.034200914204120636, -0.0367511510848999, 0.007686540950089693, -0.015619323588907719, 0.024177417159080505, 0.0021348383743315935, 0.012408583424985409, 0.013634518720209599, -0.000797431799583137, -0.031632181257009506, 0.029431212693452835, 0.01945783756673336, -0.020423904061317444, 0.009666458703577518, -0.02503523975610733, -0.059716854244470596, -0.0017638866556808352, -0.007569947279989719, -0.008383691310882568, 0.004701036028563976, -0.06019260361790657, -0.009404560551047325, -0.042154550552368164, 0.02951188199222088, -0.00694384565576911, -0.04929972067475319, 0.060056451708078384, 0.008344091475009918, -0.019005289301276207, -0.024442022666335106, -0.027638422325253487, -0.0317193940281868, -0.03456764668226242, -0.0009213269222527742, -0.060747433453798294, 0.027743307873606682, -0.056452564895153046, 0.03318639472126961, -0.030559826642274857, 0.02602083422243595, -0.04932188615202904, -0.034660812467336655, -0.061946433037519455, 0.007307967636734247, 0.037888966500759125, 0.04332922399044037, 0.04162226617336273, 0.009939407929778099, -0.030195971950888634, 0.05064282938838005, -0.006396578159183264, -0.044387273490428925, -0.027765249833464622, -0.02452787570655346, -0.04325806349515915, -0.05807105451822281, -0.020750882104039192, 0.0074944812804460526, 0.03996385261416435, -0.07241123169660568, -0.050074268132448196, 0.00961837638169527, 0.06021195277571678, -0.050480131059885025, -0.0517607219517231, -0.04173620417714119, -0.0037735584191977978, -0.055500756949186325, -0.011100977659225464, -0.010068348608911037, 0.01056112814694643, -0.045893844217061996, 0.03787665069103241, 0.0029843866359442472, 0.019918588921427727, -0.03518873080611229, 0.04742395132780075, 0.04460135102272034, -0.006075932644307613, -0.04248876869678497, -0.06188705191016197, -0.04018522799015045, 0.018786288797855377, -0.008367200382053852, -0.010131173767149448, -0.037317197769880295, 0.040234703570604324, -0.03376608341932297, 0.04055803641676903, -0.07366633415222168, 0.03816455602645874, 0.029450565576553345, -0.03318412974476814, -0.01549770962446928, -0.003899511182680726, -0.027623731642961502, -0.02703574299812317, 0.013639595359563828, -0.01345409732311964, -0.005059537012130022, -0.02934919483959675, 0.005843714345246553, -0.01047693844884634, -0.005302755162119865, -0.0029174124356359243, 0.02849017269909382, -0.008030635304749012, -0.04627946391701698, 0.0145927295088768, 0.006884761620312929, -0.03565399721264839, -0.03173305466771126, 0.022297652438282967, 0.03953878581523895, -0.04184341058135033, -0.05703595280647278, -0.00196036696434021, -0.012541769072413445, -0.01876172237098217, 0.035028126090765, -0.04759858921170235, 0.03916400671005249, 0.009784550406038761, -0.016751714050769806, 0.00440666638314724, 0.022296659648418427, -0.022079963237047195, -0.01098907645791769, 0.031175605952739716, -0.010560493916273117, -0.04152687266469002, -0.006877498235553503, -0.017976433038711548, 0.04472937807440758, -0.018768396228551865, 0.07095382362604141, 0.05348939821124077, 0.058838944882154465, -0.0072104353457689285, -0.06594394892454147, 0.03233557939529419, -0.009283175691962242, 0.058311063796281815, -0.04703943431377411, -0.014672760851681232, -0.029968537390232086, 0.06591686606407166, 0.006386559456586838, -0.01213141530752182, -0.01643051952123642, -0.02314361371099949, -0.060333315283060074, -0.032139863818883896, 0.009012212045490742, -0.022265804931521416, -0.05606634542346001, -0.01531131099909544, 0.05516104772686958, -0.04190393537282944, 0.05373040586709976, -0.004891572054475546, 0.03225370869040489, 0.022216130048036575, -0.02977883629500866, 0.012249269522726536, -0.0035262678284198046, -0.04234375059604645, 0.07947825640439987, -0.04073657467961311, -0.03651208430528641, -0.03616344556212425, -0.06348293274641037, -0.041106972843408585, -0.07151675969362259, 0.030673006549477577, -0.014346436597406864, -0.025290507823228836, -0.050676506012678146, 0.026927907019853592, 0.01036064699292183, -0.07892332971096039, 0.01955289952456951, 0.03858242928981781, -0.07061675935983658, -0.016648901626467705, 0.0020021365489810705, -0.052268072962760925, -0.02472558058798313, 0.03996598348021507, -0.003547386499121785, -0.042352087795734406, -0.04842158406972885, 0.021555619314312935, 0.05698296055197716, -0.004241975490003824, 0.03441932797431946, 0.04432027041912079, -0.03413291275501251, 0.010874095372855663, -0.057873647660017014, -0.019627735018730164, -0.012854923494160175, 0.00674306508153677, -0.034914467483758926, -0.009608997032046318, 0.009687799960374832, 0.04731828346848488, -0.05563189461827278, -0.030649716034531593, -0.02006600797176361, 0.007038077339529991, 0.020034309476614, -0.055213190615177155, -0.05460437014698982, 0.015828484669327736, -0.002697837073355913, -0.007889319211244583, -0.029685474932193756, 0.02318328060209751, 0.018900861963629723, 0.060442060232162476, -0.025964727625250816, -0.031039493158459663, -0.005025348626077175, -0.005118089262396097, -0.014980350621044636, 0.02001195214688778, -0.06489308923482895, -0.007169095799326897, 0.028780780732631683, 0.0352783240377903, 0.016841785982251167, -0.003376008477061987, -0.02049248293042183, 0.025416463613510132, -0.02151988260447979, -0.02682003378868103, -0.0020855951588600874, 0.012583881616592407, -0.017437616363167763, -0.008774962276220322, 0.027068231254816055, -0.05192046985030174, 0.037430256605148315, -0.0040538557805120945, -0.05997118726372719, 0.006309616379439831, 0.0033897049725055695, -0.06439042836427689, -0.04973366856575012, -0.0029610737692564726, -0.04555097594857216, -0.021946780383586884, 0.00843754317611456, 0.0002113727096002549, -0.057944852858781815, 0.008799196220934391, 0.03221164271235466, -0.00918872281908989, -0.025649085640907288, -0.019277583807706833, 0.03422568738460541, -0.03542095795273781, 0.054980918765068054, 0.06244327872991562, -0.009825918823480606, 0.03333180397748947, -0.062185611575841904, -0.0552409328520298, 0.04488033428788185, -0.030355747789144516, -0.04469052702188492, -0.045603446662425995, -0.025960559025406837, -0.058025769889354706, 0.00788275059312582, -0.0018123355694115162, -0.022833529859781265, 0.017244024202227592, -0.06407713890075684, 0.008191684260964394, 0.04509962722659111, -0.04389464855194092, -0.08291798084974289, -0.01919049769639969, -0.0120459059253335, 0.01067500188946724, -0.0004916483303532004, -0.009131131693720818, -0.06802435964345932, 0.00810486450791359, -0.07917005568742752, -0.02247719280421734, -0.016336187720298767, 0.06288515776395798, -0.004507331643253565, -0.03128025680780411, -0.005618612747639418, -0.04155632108449936, 0.04122620448470116, -0.031709227710962296, -0.033137839287519455, 0.012781238183379173, 0.0428883358836174, 0.011751865036785603, -0.06750048696994781, -0.014333781786262989, 0.06010724976658821, -0.055727142840623856, -0.01237119734287262, 0.02024519257247448, -0.010261855088174343, -0.027798904106020927, -0.009941516444087029, 0.06616931408643723, 0.02872084639966488, 0.06273401528596878, -0.04017343372106552, 0.0020130674820393324, -0.05952773988246918, -0.07441013306379318, 0.0047652823850512505, -0.04882308840751648, 0.02645209990441799, -0.013552239164710045, -0.02006886526942253, -0.0006238161586225033, -0.05593661963939667, -0.019392749294638634, 0.04344429448246956, 0.01996946707367897, -0.04489558935165405, 0.0680004209280014, -0.027487581595778465, -0.0013928365660831332, 0.020818501710891724, 0.04023988917469978, -0.0464584082365036, 0.012366116978228092, -0.01766924187541008, -0.0421166867017746, 0.04653560742735863, -0.052713893353939056, 0.012897881679236889, -0.019805410876870155, -0.023793578147888184, -0.006065170746296644, 0.05349501222372055, -0.006710132583975792, -0.014059251174330711, -0.04871305450797081, -0.03411456197500229, 0.007231306284666061, -0.07085633277893066, -0.05596291273832321, -0.0011228244984522462, -0.001224342966452241, 0.020582405850291252, 0.047055091708898544, -0.02751910500228405, 0.040086813271045685, 0.015132363885641098, -0.02028202824294567, -0.05603085830807686, 0.019810626283288002, -0.0605100579559803, 0.00649648904800415, -0.022111589089035988, -0.018499106168746948, -0.03166589513421059, -0.024379631504416466, 0.0267474427819252, -0.0006913106772117317, 0.023230858147144318, 0.011883869767189026, 0.03946630656719208, -0.04966917261481285, 0.00786886177957058, 0.016897138208150864, -0.008072588592767715, -0.012119044549763203, 0.027795158326625824, 0.002457184251397848, -0.041350532323122025, -0.06557688117027283 ]
The $2$-packing number $\rho_2(G)$ of a graph $G$ is the cardinality of a largest $2$-packing of $G$ and the open packing number $\rho^{\rm o}(G)$ is the cardinality of a largest open packing of $G$, where an open packing (resp. $2$-packing) is a set of vertices in $G$ no two (closed) neighborhoods of which intersect. It is proved that if $G$ is bipartite, then $\rho^{\rm o}(G\Box K_2) = 2\rho_2(G)$. For hypercubes, the lower bounds $\rho_2(Q_n) \ge 2^{n - \lfloor \log n\rfloor -1}$ and $\rho^{\rm o}(Q_n) \ge 2^{n - \lfloor \log (n-1)\rfloor -1}$ are established. These findings are applied to injective colorings of hypercubes. In particular, it is demonstrated that $Q_9$ is the smallest hypercube which is not perfect injectively colorable. It is also proved that $\gamma_t(Q_{2^k}\times H) = 2^{2^k-k}\gamma_t(H)$, where $H$ is an arbitrary graph with no isolated vertices.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04963v1
[ -0.05263587459921837, -0.0433662086725235, 0.05046270787715912, 0.0022755584213882685, -0.012513265013694763, -0.02729634754359722, -0.058003999292850494, 0.002450348110869527, -0.059436261653900146, -0.010256434790790081, -0.01829398237168789, -0.03172312676906586, 0.014325140975415707, -0.047854624688625336, -0.03723085671663284, 0.04687909781932831, 0.028893020004034042, 0.050019145011901855, 0.0005157131818123162, 0.06318933516740799, -0.014256185851991177, -0.053970884531736374, -0.020317111164331436, 0.0471578910946846, -0.017745494842529297, 0.01549597829580307, -0.03197937086224556, -0.012447409331798553, -0.03936783969402313, -0.038600701838731766, 0.060614392161369324, -0.03446535766124725, 0.03774527832865715, -0.04258500784635544, 0.03282667696475983, 0.03587108105421066, -0.027826547622680664, 0.04409146308898926, 0.021221429109573364, -0.05915107950568199, -0.018337629735469818, -0.05424150452017784, -0.018330320715904236, -0.06635160744190216, -0.036395926028490067, -0.035642821341753006, -0.027953706681728363, -0.012314220890402794, 0.021107593551278114, -0.04229716584086418, 0.0281834714114666, -0.022494427859783173, -0.006550709716975689, 0.018418803811073303, 0.025003360584378242, -0.035163599997758865, -0.009394959546625614, -0.007955559529364109, -0.022368552163243294, -0.008741673082113266, -0.009339774027466774, -0.014148283749818802, -0.027772875502705574, -0.030312826856970787, -0.058139946311712265, 0.017064467072486877, -0.04184114933013916, -0.028220975771546364, 0.0017598794074729085, -0.03355691581964493, 0.02802024595439434, -0.03925401344895363, 0.0024391082115471363, 0.010692267678678036, -0.06240818649530411, 0.02061145007610321, -0.033671606332063675, 0.03386572748422623, -0.06164867803454399, -0.008711603470146656, -0.010692250914871693, 0.000616595905739814, -0.0269900131970644, -0.030830906704068184, -0.003044215962290764, 0.013108324259519577, -0.024536894634366035, -0.04918370023369789, 0.004436310846358538, -0.047805383801460266, -0.02722017467021942, -0.032640159130096436, -0.04032221809029579, 0.006621476728469133, 0.033890292048454285, -0.06181004270911217, 0.0417029932141304, 0.038688357919454575, 0.03824520856142044, -0.022631628438830376, -0.027770260348916054, -0.05802839994430542, -0.05565263703465462, -0.04025976359844208, 0.013040317222476006, 0.033858928829431534, 0.024479273706674576, -0.035972632467746735, -0.05156389996409416, 0.06856857985258102, 0.03325358405709267, 0.013145259581506252, -0.016503650695085526, -0.053882867097854614, -0.024670792743563652, -0.05683906748890877, 0.06653283536434174, 0.014574342407286167, 0.06131315603852272, -0.0016010593390092254, -0.00038413083530031145, 0.013591877184808254, 0.04205777123570442, 0.011546796187758446, -0.021323680877685547, -0.012571203522384167, 0.024062685668468475, 0.0028721473645418882, 0.04104214161634445, 0.0068038469180464745, 0.05670314282178879, -0.019297173246741295, 0.034838996827602386, -0.013689168728888035, 0.0037275224458426237, -0.003560961689800024, 0.04171701520681381, -0.02803310938179493, 0.0048883953131735325, 0.0022827815264463425, -0.03813112899661064, -0.07349599897861481, 0.06138011813163757, 0.00033528730273246765, 0.022687623277306557, 0.05981765687465668, -0.04786037653684616, 0.038809068500995636, -0.00887796375900507, 0.014879944734275341, -0.025476140901446342, 0.008858486078679562, -0.037533607333898544, -0.0035067733842879534, -0.05836066976189613, 0.044387008994817734, 0.048515740782022476, -0.008466016501188278, -0.00971585139632225, -0.014068079181015491, 0.020976202562451363, 0.0409582145512104, -0.018137594684958458, 0.02894328162074089, 0.016903188079595566, 0.023332513868808746, 0.028070906177163124, -0.05141724646091461, 0.04760049283504486, 0.042885612696409225, -0.0037365946918725967, -0.036667704582214355, -0.021313611418008804, -0.0614025816321373, -0.058606382459402084, -0.020997602492570877, -0.05184328928589821, -0.054356832057237625, -0.0615931861102581, -0.05115209147334099, 0.0024984225165098906, -0.017590872943401337, -0.02859026938676834, -0.0034549992997199297, -0.06537295132875443, 0.006863658782094717, -0.06858844310045242, 0.05852304771542549, 0.007605910766869783, 0.03875195235013962, 0.046645354479551315, -0.03822983428835869, -0.0036177553702145815, -0.029879562556743622, -0.02661464549601078, -0.034354858100414276, 0.007793516386300325, -0.03435366600751877, -0.059470586478710175, -0.010484962724149227, -0.056972820311784744, -0.048274844884872437, -0.0327858030796051, 0.058381788432598114, 0.023024188354611397, -0.0721355602145195, -0.04251965880393982, 0.051639117300510406, 0.0013968069106340408, -0.05938612297177315, 0.05037515610456467, -0.016406267881393433, 0.014750201255083084, -0.04351900517940521, -0.06869541853666306, -0.05042865872383118, -0.07886172086000443, 0.031689487397670746, 0.022244708612561226, -0.018553946167230606, 0.03807254880666733, -0.03065689094364643, -0.026099754497408867, -0.03471653163433075, -0.020165372639894485, 0.04625905305147171, 0.016524814069271088, -0.0366024412214756, -0.030719682574272156, -0.03910450637340546, 0.016747165471315384, -0.06555484980344772, 0.01610870659351349, -0.004482337739318609, -0.027285130694508553, -0.040407635271549225, -0.016709866002202034, 0.05641287565231323, -0.006416780408471823, -0.034547239542007446, -0.05020742490887642, 0.028757769614458084, 0.030265910550951958, 0.01873595081269741, -0.0210691187530756, -0.059347495436668396, -0.04917111247777939, -0.01470564678311348, 0.034739863127470016, -0.025502849370241165, 0.03339899331331253, -0.012272967025637627, -0.046720393002033234, -0.025379857048392296, 0.04100216552615166, 0.007085268385708332, -0.03387582302093506, -0.004554587882012129, -0.019119255244731903, 0.011663504876196384, 0.04052599519491196, -0.049662455916404724, 0.006183784455060959, -0.04938969388604164, -0.004731189925223589, 0.018597785383462906, -0.06563390046358109, -0.034614160656929016, -0.010552122257649899, 0.016091087833046913, -0.0038394415751099586, -0.013821402564644814, 0.043182145804166794, -0.05655843764543533, -0.04325438290834427, 0.010073737241327763, -0.051118988543748856, -0.01129891723394394, 0.029545016586780548, -0.021849261596798897, 0.026576129719614983, 0.05828924477100372, -0.013864634558558464, -0.0648423433303833, -0.036262091249227524, -0.0068528978154063225, -0.026400838047266006, -0.05395154654979706, -0.039169322699308395, -0.03295298293232918, -0.06105616316199303, 0.006104616913944483, -0.04502491652965546, -0.042157936841249466, -0.05765770003199577, -0.05181868001818657, -0.02008131705224514, 0.023791691288352013, -0.04046998545527458, -0.07023453712463379, -0.022179996594786644, 0.03238007053732872, 0.053857967257499695, 0.04021071270108223, -0.012175848707556725, -0.010455470532178879, -0.022413205355405807, -0.026352019980549812, 0.03118433989584446, 0.004403695464134216, 0.017321350052952766, -0.035632044076919556, -0.0537274144589901, -0.010056989267468452, -0.007998079061508179, 0.0432446263730526, 0.03656372055411339, -0.004266191273927689, 0.006179481279104948, 0.016315868124365807, -0.05914541333913803, -0.061021674424409866, 0.022201336920261383, -0.040458615869283676, -0.031447883695364, -0.008910862728953362, -0.004922318272292614, 0.051950786262750626, -0.012154599651694298, -0.04087543860077858, -0.054757244884967804, -0.0057932534255087376, 0.026421228423714638, -0.05483584478497505, 0.012518380768597126, -0.0078105921857059, -0.022425934672355652, -0.03128857910633087, -0.05441635847091675, 0.03851212561130524, 0.014648531563580036, 0.008284018374979496, 0.04506310820579529, -0.027944151312112808, 0.024229934439063072, -0.07341277599334717, 0.043043509125709534, 0.038153763860464096, 0.047271981835365295, -0.046870458871126175, -0.023388195782899857, 0.0018634343286976218, -0.026411045342683792, 0.0025009249802678823, -0.016568822786211967, 0.034855570644140244, 0.05338887870311737, 0.007964760065078735, -0.015225260518491268, -0.030034415423870087, -0.006084219552576542, -0.008016033098101616, -0.0036465206649154425, 0.04365687817335129, -0.010186425410211086, 0.04351850971579552, -0.020607199519872665, -0.024303661659359932, 0.009761270135641098, 0.013117783702909946, -0.01244090124964714, -0.025487791746854782, -0.028767425566911697, -0.04819256067276001, -0.038642868399620056, 0.022269897162914276, 0.030992252752184868, -0.027586087584495544, -0.013048061169683933, -0.060058657079935074, -0.015538128092885017, -0.03135154768824577, 0.01600867137312889, 0.029448704794049263, -0.027630994096398354, -0.02153025008738041, -0.05137372761964798, 0.015463663265109062, 0.020463446155190468, -0.044760562479496, 0.013606086373329163, -0.015626108273863792, -0.005432668142020702, 0.018618376925587654, 0.006565519608557224, 0.020977526903152466, 0.03258798271417618, 0.022426048293709755, -0.076289601624012, -0.03374071419239044, -0.0035049617290496826, -0.026210663840174675, -0.02289646305143833, -0.044104404747486115, -0.05474485084414482, -0.02215593494474888, 0.013242368586361408, -0.041696224361658096, -0.04643931984901428, 0.06373385339975357, 0.025565030053257942, -0.018864018842577934, -0.03219328820705414, -0.012477690353989601, -0.020937630906701088, -0.05707024410367012, -0.057947661727666855, 0.01837584376335144, 0.013563121668994427, 0.015323270112276077, 0.031742196530103683, 0.02978302352130413, -0.07127212733030319, -0.014326242730021477, -0.03608624264597893, 0.006622247863560915, 0.009992972947657108, -0.01161122228950262, 0.021129367873072624, -0.019822871312499046, 0.009671686217188835, -0.033947352319955826, -0.029437916353344917, -0.07140933722257614, 0.005243724677711725, -0.06833153963088989, 0.043075405061244965, -0.004583188332617283, -0.05992208793759346, -0.023722819983959198, -0.05528569594025612, 0.02180446870625019, -0.03407683223485947, -0.04177182912826538, -0.04731311276555061, 0.0070108515210449696, -0.060235969722270966, -0.0577857680618763, -0.007171657867729664, -0.016368864104151726, -0.0637453943490982, 0.014485298655927181, -0.03434860333800316, -0.024110376834869385, 0.027566730976104736, -0.01774021051824093, -0.012834778055548668, -0.009441787376999855, -0.04344229772686958, -0.00395192950963974, 0.022364798933267593, 0.0074425945058465, -0.04826023429632187, 0.010451260022819042, -0.07040303945541382, 0.007031845394521952, -0.046218860894441605, -0.012965920381247997, 0.0537618063390255, 0.023397741839289665, -0.01943071000277996, 0.06098909303545952, -0.05626126751303673, 0.012867599725723267, 0.058384835720062256, -0.027563486248254776, -0.01017691008746624, 0.031976211816072464, -0.018153762444853783, 0.004973201081156731, 0.015211244113743305, 0.043930746614933014, 0.016474854201078415, -0.004340382758527994, -0.03633818030357361, -0.02894294075667858, -0.0692739486694336, -0.040971431881189346, 0.01082703098654747, -0.0010257159592583776, -0.0072496915236115456, -0.00039138045394793153, -0.0034021171741187572, -0.032110292464494705, -0.009039676748216152, 0.058487020432949066, 0.032114673405885696, -0.0587117075920105, -0.05687890946865082, -0.031865064054727554, 0.009380900301039219, 0.01880924589931965, 0.028623929247260094, -0.027452578768134117, -0.00596061535179615, 0.03686562925577164, -0.008479916490614414, -0.0175155159085989, 0.02512611262500286, -0.00641249492764473, -0.04663635417819023, -0.02809988148510456, -0.06641588360071182, -0.052753996104002, -0.022084694355726242, -0.05129489675164223, 0.005915116518735886, 0.04494102671742439, 0.005446320399641991, 0.015435723587870598, -0.035893578082323074, -0.04595779627561569, -0.04078689217567444, -0.04339691624045372, -0.01807585544884205, -0.006135039031505585, -0.04502943158149719, 0.006937086582183838, -0.04450929909944534, -0.0003481732273939997, -0.03365778177976608, -0.04270699992775917, 0.0010822450276464224, 0.030716169625520706, -0.060993343591690063, 0.004007718991488218, 0.028614860028028488, 0.01924293115735054, 0.003314490895718336, 0.004933352116495371, 0.049897436052560806, -0.0735059455037117, 0.034990016371011734, 0.03244988992810249, 0.015205287374556065, -0.029644425958395004, 0.021311458200216293, 0.04210822656750679, -0.047410231083631516, -0.05674850940704346, 0.0011995374225080013, -0.046520721167325974, 0.020340729504823685, -0.018118012696504593, -0.020197540521621704, 0.042391713708639145, -0.06277913600206375, 0.032238204032182693, -0.010310979560017586, -0.005801997147500515, 0.0033415760844945908, 0.025690564885735512, 0.023788653314113617, -0.051397763192653656, 0.02982436679303646, -0.00006117867451393977, -0.05676306039094925, -0.00046872321399860084, -0.04130366072058678, 0.008491515181958675, -0.029710011556744576, 0.006564045790582895, -0.0694161131978035, -0.05838317424058914, -0.03291529789566994, 0.041849132627248764, -0.0037988759577274323, -0.07255548983812332, 0.009575588628649712, 0.05907198786735535, -0.029213886708021164, 0.013516213744878769, -0.06810028851032257, -0.04283842444419861, 0.004057611338794231, 0.05381516367197037, -0.004674004390835762, -0.020986929535865784, -0.009611375629901886, 0.03925298899412155, -0.012931966222822666, -0.010084393434226513, 0.06236319988965988, 0.025440439581871033, 0.01949382945895195, 0.029562722891569138, 0.021740693598985672, -0.003925241529941559, -0.040192678570747375, -0.003752029500901699, 0.0007785959169268608, 0.049156688153743744, -0.06569498032331467, -0.04123103618621826, 0.0082805585116148, -0.042528752237558365, -0.029664985835552216, -0.04323286563158035, -0.042493801563978195, -0.007617088966071606, -0.03521869704127312, 0.02837044931948185, 0.02164098620414734, 0.06462280452251434, 0.018013080582022667, -0.024219470098614693, -0.057704489678144455, -0.030852826312184334, -0.04264961555600166, -0.056722357869148254, -0.021445294842123985, 0.034769125282764435, 0.05272552743554115, -0.002977078314870596, 0.058818068355321884, -0.01696842350065708, 0.039558034390211105, -0.014740725047886372, -0.048076797276735306, 0.011724756099283695, 0.022995807230472565, -0.053124669939279556, -0.008846801705658436, 0.00809861533343792, -0.055202875286340714, 0.04297557845711708, 0.015554241836071014, -0.006158443633466959, -0.039523448795080185, -0.03004467487335205, -0.058950528502464294, -0.05131889134645462, 0.05295576527714729, -0.05494009330868721, 0.02285606786608696, 0.03300841897726059, 0.015140741132199764, 0.04070693999528885, 0.03749037906527519, -0.019150646403431892, -0.02386046200990677, -0.01569773443043232, -0.04850958287715912, -0.03126343712210655, -0.003303097328171134, -0.03496997430920601, -0.07126568257808685, -0.025873500853776932, 0.032652534544467926, 0.010547199286520481, 0.006022168789058924, -0.032681725919246674, 0.0009988745441660285, 0.00658697634935379, 0.02195340022444725, 0.0028609437867999077, -0.06580711901187897, -0.04992007836699486, -0.033237095922231674, -0.011643117293715477, -0.04629974812269211, -0.042781274765729904, -0.05942351371049881, 0.010182718746364117, -0.07604978233575821, -0.042940404266119, 0.04668916016817093, 0.012007836252450943, 0.024135803803801537, -0.0596034862101078, -0.040070079267024994, -0.055495426058769226, -0.042454496026039124, 0.021646786481142044, -0.01901010237634182, -0.0037486362271010876, -0.009982963092625141, 0.004935485776513815, -0.027206022292375565, -0.021484985947608948, 0.006023943889886141, 0.02773863635957241, -0.06194467097520828, -0.029505183920264244, 0.021926971152424812, -0.061405327171087265, 0.03889233618974686, 0.05597279593348503, -0.0046950289979577065, 0.018358629196882248, 0.013856292702257633, -0.05267345532774925, -0.0505760982632637, -0.04745874181389809, -0.014929366298019886, -0.04665296897292137, -0.009270749054849148, -0.023172428831458092, -0.03629377856850624, -0.06336373090744019, -0.04899898171424866, -0.06576541811227798, -0.03000364825129509, 0.0009299379889853299, -0.03046317957341671, -0.0002108680346282199, -0.031175410374999046, -0.025495605543255806, -0.020093461498618126, 0.0007948941783979535, -0.03424811363220215, -0.060817014425992966, 0.03296207636594772, -0.045260969549417496, -0.0021985340863466263, -0.05685507506132126, -0.02251545339822769, -0.05489809438586235, -0.01792367920279503, 0.06502772122621536, 0.03821993246674538, -0.04571182653307915, 0.05338154733181, -0.026557207107543945, -0.0114835100248456, 0.037063419818878174, -0.04997365176677704, -0.039639342576265335, -0.03387697413563728, 0.00866109412163496, 0.04342718794941902, -0.003656241577118635, -0.0551040954887867, -0.008577672764658928, -0.015884609892964363, -0.056549374014139175, -0.018268175423145294, -0.0014763878425583243, 0.02867167443037033, -0.02158515900373459, 0.01835021749138832, -0.07024592161178589, -0.011797656305134296, 0.02754020504653454, 0.011984727345407009, -0.03481898829340935, -0.050467174500226974, -0.006006026174873114, 0.016261592507362366, -0.05471111834049225, -0.024694081395864487, 0.07284635305404663, 0.03687520697712898, -0.048753537237644196, 0.05696963146328926, 0.0011616504052653909, -0.05362526327371597, -0.05286699905991554 ]
Although syntactic information is beneficial for many NLP tasks, combining it with contextual information between words to solve the coreference resolution problem needs to be further explored. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end parser that combines pre-trained BERT with a Syntactic Relation Graph Attention Network (RGAT) to take a deeper look into the role of syntactic dependency information for the coreference resolution task. In particular, the RGAT model is first proposed, then used to understand the syntactic dependency graph and learn better task-specific syntactic embeddings. An integrated architecture incorporating BERT embeddings and syntactic embeddings is constructed to generate blending representations for the downstream task. Our experiments on a public Gendered Ambiguous Pronouns (GAP) dataset show that with the supervision learning of the syntactic dependency graph and without fine-tuning the entire BERT, we increased the F1-score of the previous best model (RGCN-with-BERT) from 80.3% to 82.5%, compared to the F1-score by single BERT embeddings from 78.5% to 82.5%. Experimental results on another public dataset - OntoNotes 5.0 demonstrate that the performance of the model is also improved by incorporating syntactic dependency information learned from RGAT.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04977v1
[ -0.0054632737301290035, -0.030492335557937622, 0.05654734745621681, 0.03223045542836189, -0.019029654562473297, -0.0028080958873033524, -0.007637069094926119, -0.008350279182195663, -0.016947411000728607, -0.0610673651099205, -0.06947402656078339, 0.014565974473953247, -0.06207968294620514, -0.038780998438596725, -0.029654713347554207, -0.011861082166433334, 0.05912100896239281, 0.0144670894369483, 0.001426523900590837, 0.07298768311738968, -0.00018141137843485922, 0.00394328823313117, -0.06459145992994308, 0.055233635008335114, 0.01879245787858963, -0.009668558835983276, 0.006528784520924091, -0.03319598734378815, -0.0026659725699573755, -0.001465971814468503, 0.057040609419345856, -0.005985095631331205, -0.008026854135096073, -0.0285039059817791, -0.03341512009501457, 0.0014972509816288948, -0.008953912183642387, 0.028880849480628967, 0.05929078534245491, -0.04820435494184494, -0.012606173753738403, -0.037927158176898956, -0.06637625396251678, -0.03197276592254639, -0.010634840466082096, 0.04592588171362877, -0.03686961531639099, 0.021822284907102585, -0.0466851182281971, -0.06355106085538864, 0.04765384644269943, 0.03295064717531204, -0.027397293597459793, -0.005938519258052111, -0.05185822769999504, 0.007508924696594477, -0.008598657324910164, 0.041713226586580276, -0.06481388956308365, -0.012616222724318504, -0.01333698257803917, -0.05162351205945015, -0.017598148435354233, -0.01626194640994072, -0.04569926857948303, 0.042216043919324875, -0.010831765830516815, -0.07292257249355316, -0.002258367370814085, -0.03575380519032478, 0.02455727756023407, -0.05081503465771675, -0.04102827236056328, -0.002810829319059849, 0.005373161751776934, -0.011906822212040424, -0.05195676162838936, -0.018938587978482246, 0.007337165530771017, -0.031486786901950836, -0.019322939217090607, 0.01870550401508808, 0.022930344566702843, 0.013749404810369015, -0.01967492513358593, -0.0370829813182354, 0.048846323043107986, -0.0018680226057767868, -0.01186881959438324, -0.03899180889129639, 0.03390233963727951, -0.03351801633834839, -0.06863618642091751, 0.031875401735305786, 0.05543000251054764, 0.007813865318894386, 0.023189304396510124, -0.018122058361768723, -0.001592464977875352, -0.02082488127052784, -0.059950388967990875, -0.0010955992620438337, -0.0009744276758283377, 0.059927817434072495, 0.031130848452448845, 0.016105083748698235, 0.0014205528423190117, 0.00035443101660348475, -0.05226774141192436, -0.0034286812879145145, -0.039906345307826996, -0.04012656211853027, 0.004233544692397118, -0.05967492610216141, -0.056468091905117035, -0.055752430111169815, 0.049757219851017, 0.03134116530418396, 0.018434951081871986, 0.01141249481588602, -0.03095131553709507, 0.047127921134233475, 0.05189426615834236, -0.025877423584461212, -0.0810457319021225, -0.04748337343335152, 0.03936990723013878, 0.03363053873181343, -0.017574749886989594, -0.03100905567407608, -0.04288849979639053, 0.022514397278428078, -0.016878513619303703, -0.01665773056447506, 0.0733846053481102, -0.025065042078495026, 0.006852494552731514, -0.0454910583794117, 0.037043314427137375, 0.018066370859742165, -0.047276128083467484, -0.07511511445045471, 0.02541307546198368, -0.03913459926843643, 0.027828041464090347, 0.0689513087272644, -0.021470455452799797, -0.04570998623967171, -0.010408568195998669, 0.015439508482813835, -0.03986986353993416, -0.019235605373978615, 0.04698377847671509, 0.06142950430512428, 0.030225345864892006, -0.0047867135144770145, 0.05558203533291817, -0.008107546716928482, -0.05118537321686745, 0.024744246155023575, 0.03091748245060444, -0.015968186780810356, 0.016034318134188652, -0.02139090746641159, 0.018570519983768463, 0.0019166525453329086, -0.009776638820767403, -0.03300699219107628, -0.00582759128883481, 0.009012583643198013, -0.022559331730008125, -0.017772119492292404, 0.024673860520124435, 0.0017986833117902279, -0.07265467196702957, -0.009176813997328281, 0.02200479805469513, -0.04981786012649536, -0.05465495213866234, -0.007876280695199966, 0.014938226900994778, 0.0631806030869484, -0.01052250899374485, 0.004895604681223631, -0.04213479906320572, -0.00484131183475256, -0.08154293894767761, -0.06186400726437569, 0.03290657326579094, 0.011365456506609917, -0.015328695066273212, -0.04450908675789833, 0.02429300732910633, 0.011930887587368488, -0.0473673976957798, -0.04004574567079544, 0.03317337483167648, -0.03534660488367081, -0.04672888293862343, 0.03330332040786743, -0.08387694507837296, -0.040934007614851, -0.06394438445568085, 0.012286418117582798, 0.0032261130400002003, -0.0640588030219078, -0.017083851620554924, 0.03631972149014473, -0.009712524712085724, 0.022578826174139977, 0.03357855975627899, 0.05249771475791931, 0.05567428469657898, 0.022001249715685844, 0.02406720444560051, -0.002962178084999323, -0.09171038120985031, 0.06677789986133575, 0.01925906538963318, 0.012037691660225391, 0.022384604439139366, 0.01689726673066616, 0.01465350016951561, -0.02327609993517399, 0.012170198373496532, 0.04319756478071213, 0.035133130848407745, 0.030900616198778152, -0.043726980686187744, -0.010274508036673069, 0.006174653768539429, -0.052483465522527695, 0.005204734392464161, -0.06947214901447296, -0.032186541706323624, 0.017636887729167938, -0.05471773445606232, 0.04851026460528374, -0.007594986818730831, -0.043547194451093674, -0.04171720892190933, -0.01097917091101408, 0.043783556669950485, 0.02176094427704811, -0.05390040948987007, -0.017804790288209915, -0.012375258840620518, -0.00031962626962922513, 0.011640181764960289, -0.012213525362312794, -0.025494901463389397, -0.05886757746338844, -0.025482269003987312, -0.014964913949370384, 0.0454256571829319, 0.04659434035420418, -0.029356354847550392, 0.021950986236333847, -0.022783953696489334, 0.03662465885281563, 0.039477571845054626, 0.02139138989150524, -0.06225012615323067, 0.026301341131329536, -0.0017521639820188284, -0.01902727410197258, -0.015431667678058147, -0.03138656169176102, 0.035832855850458145, -0.018536295741796494, 0.035276733338832855, 0.067120261490345, 0.042057838290929794, -0.027729840949177742, -0.06506607681512833, 0.0008878138614818454, 0.03701944649219513, 0.011788565665483475, 0.03722301125526428, 0.04763772338628769, 0.038036905229091644, 0.04657749831676483, 0.006336592137813568, -0.08345041424036026, -0.010220416821539402, -0.004093569237738848, -0.032314471900463104, -0.05723053961992264, -0.05498458817601204, -0.02330074831843376, -0.07345464080572128, -0.020519984886050224, -0.05789041891694069, -0.051892027258872986, -0.020444758236408234, -0.04515760764479637, -0.030975650995969772, -0.01263002585619688, -0.007199819665402174, -0.0223231203854084, -0.03440150246024132, -0.014895351603627205, 0.03467021510004997, -0.03155340999364853, 0.019036442041397095, -0.058884188532829285, -0.0398932546377182, -0.009216303937137127, 0.021398385986685753, 0.036015670746564865, -0.014617991633713245, 0.0037722548004239798, 0.006966759450733662, 0.030722130089998245, -0.03803678974509239, 0.04944344609975815, 0.011978911235928535, 0.05895443260669708, -0.028089091181755066, -0.04556255042552948, 0.007678167428821325, -0.01249691005796194, -0.019854633137583733, -0.04444790631532669, -0.06091846153140068, 0.016292724758386612, 0.0464073084294796, 0.04477962478995323, 0.005427416879683733, -0.030481712892651558, -0.0104071581736207, 0.030444562435150146, 0.008383233100175858, 0.022251907736063004, -0.02251598797738552, 0.06417053937911987, 0.02625986374914646, -0.055177103728055954, 0.02475057914853096, -0.0008226809441111982, 0.034017935395240784, -0.005628033075481653, -0.04386115446686745, -0.026954343542456627, 0.04959729686379433, -0.08462308347225189, 0.023835530504584312, -0.003247769782319665, 0.05650096386671066, -0.024093180894851685, -0.015028241090476513, 0.04113677889108658, 0.036084335297346115, 0.032926201820373535, -0.017812475562095642, 0.018227465450763702, 0.0251251719892025, 0.04933125525712967, -0.009971370920538902, -0.0023244398180395365, -0.042337916791439056, -0.0561385378241539, -0.011090004816651344, -0.01508233044296503, 0.005776570178568363, 0.043428923934698105, 0.014316686429083347, -0.06340938806533813, 0.0030264107044786215, 0.01224060170352459, 0.025604890659451485, 0.028117923066020012, -0.01357901468873024, -0.007465672213584185, -0.05056506022810936, 0.017219938337802887, 0.018059048801660538, 0.00048820089432410896, 0.02101663500070572, -0.04187396541237831, 0.03652498871088028, -0.051497481763362885, 0.05296960473060608, 0.04889122024178505, -0.011403564363718033, 0.051661692559719086, 0.04072519391775131, -0.040394753217697144, 0.06383704394102097, -0.03557026758790016, -0.010056385770440102, 0.007501842919737101, 0.022971367463469505, -0.054358962923288345, -0.0038496290799230337, -0.05485618859529495, 0.01547203678637743, 0.04184519499540329, -0.03227679431438446, 0.01056684460490942, -0.033154428005218506, 0.049305811524391174, -0.02754353918135166, -0.0867789089679718, -0.015516131184995174, -0.0040608798153698444, 0.014089314267039299, -0.01718306355178356, -0.035510335117578506, 0.06545747816562653, -0.0015643094666302204, -0.01974703185260296, 0.005703741684556007, -0.025629190728068352, -0.05197402089834213, -0.01455012895166874, -0.003976236097514629, -0.039378292858600616, 0.007717737928032875, -0.06367956101894379, 0.030500411987304688, 0.0024036746472120285, -0.0030041818972676992, -0.052266400307416916, -0.05263800173997879, 0.029314134269952774, 0.04356040433049202, 0.07458139955997467, 0.02937972918152809, 0.019057396799325943, 0.005203723441809416, 0.0071691847406327724, -0.010592173784971237, 0.03226218372583389, 0.014652674086391926, -0.018632635474205017, 0.025151917710900307, -0.02083822339773178, -0.0033648330718278885, -0.006718531716614962, -0.02115427888929844, 0.03877055644989014, -0.034005098044872284, 0.03388243913650513, 0.001358561683446169, 0.02963121235370636, -0.029588643461465836, -0.05893290415406227, -0.021106764674186707, -0.02149157039821148, -0.05242735892534256, -0.01950773037970066, 0.038131825625896454, 0.006290982011705637, 0.020634936168789864, -0.012148818001151085, -0.019246140494942665, 0.009258388541638851, -0.05105901136994362, -0.01265732292085886, 0.006446842569857836, -0.03320404514670372, 0.020461253821849823, -0.03359631821513176, -0.07595416158437729, 0.010773323476314545, -0.053050123155117035, -0.048402685672044754, 0.019770419225096703, 0.016377076506614685, 0.02811381220817566, 0.07343433052301407, -0.07736148685216904, 0.02980676293373108, 0.043346066027879715, -0.011385777965188026, 0.003118524793535471, 0.06894984841346741, -0.04256950691342354, 0.03325806185603142, -0.027926024049520493, -0.03584113344550133, 0.002494996879249811, -0.04775447025895119, -0.006578925531357527, -0.0258493535220623, -0.016260938718914986, 0.01370311714708805, 0.012678151950240135, 0.008309248834848404, -0.04196504130959511, 0.03325735405087471, -0.016276080161333084, 0.02814098820090294, -0.05087082087993622, 0.020748907700181007, 0.041140396147966385, -0.010179256089031696, -0.023755474016070366, -0.0395975261926651, -0.022632401436567307, 0.0007071241270750761, 0.018559856340289116, -0.04344715550541878, 0.009629957377910614, 0.053650856018066406, 0.015450275503098965, -0.004806825891137123, 0.014173521660268307, 0.0113536911085248, 0.010353945195674896, 0.0015266451518982649, 0.035554103553295135, -0.05787552520632744, -0.01974787935614586, -0.052167195826768875, 0.05801906809210777, 0.06830724328756332, 0.03070220910012722, -0.02067289501428604, 0.03932967409491539, -0.022458314895629883, -0.02137777954339981, -0.020716335624456406, -0.04107455164194107, 0.01649804785847664, -0.06885313242673874, 0.043813906610012054, -0.039343059062957764, 0.03931776434183121, 0.03556247428059578, 0.0632857233285904, 0.01677180454134941, 0.04728781804442406, -0.025923987850546837, 0.006747220177203417, -0.0032583640422672033, -0.03256558999419212, 0.00034009924274869263, 0.010615721344947815, 0.010453914292156696, -0.017518147826194763, 0.007498996797949076, -0.0015463782474398613, 0.005512927658855915, 0.04389706254005432, 0.05127492547035217, -0.047795604914426804, -0.049661822617053986, -0.02546783722937107, 0.07733740657567978, -0.055960386991500854, -0.0294492170214653, -0.019672758877277374, -0.04361792281270027, 0.022287344560027122, -0.025366222485899925, -0.014763697050511837, 0.03514377027750015, -0.022529348731040955, -0.05599994212388992, 0.05546485632658005, -0.003322955686599016, -0.05741283670067787, -0.0019055132288485765, 0.006990440189838409, -0.08667602390050888, 0.03083435259759426, 0.0371699184179306, 0.01675727218389511, -0.04958817735314369, 0.06440392136573792, 0.017102554440498352, -0.020854581147432327, -0.03824258968234062, 0.05454263463616371, 0.08227942138910294, -0.05967492610216141, 0.0004855357692576945, 0.05539402365684509, -0.05217212066054344, -0.022141674533486366, -0.039935823529958725, -0.0133294016122818, 0.023469625040888786, 0.026606902480125427, 0.01020053867250681, -0.04145865887403488, 0.022211650386452675, 0.0672842413187027, -0.032697152346372604, 0.014594445005059242, 0.006829028017818928, -0.0012512452667579055, 0.03238678351044655, -0.024665428325533867, -0.05379800871014595, 0.008431034162640572, -0.02806946635246277, -0.03701481595635414, -0.04232189804315567, -0.014739560894668102, -0.01699603535234928, 0.04330708831548691, 0.0020148041658103466, -0.07539717108011246, -0.041526876389980316, -0.04028851166367531, -0.06844539940357208, 0.023511463776230812, -0.0451369509100914, 0.042338285595178604, -0.018538853153586388, -0.027763962745666504, -0.0065307593904435635, 0.05101904645562172, -0.051555801182985306, -0.05039997398853302, -0.004569177981466055, 0.03350076451897621, 0.03340364620089531, 0.007393246982246637, 0.019943300634622574, -0.06014349311590195, 0.03981804847717285, -0.06193516030907631, -0.029373683035373688, -0.0021653962321579456, -0.06806572526693344, -0.023280339315533638, 0.048458125442266464, -0.01694467104971409, -0.04427110776305199, 0.01870591938495636, -0.013920656405389309, 0.03317810595035553, -0.005781157407909632, -0.029427755624055862, -0.08011975139379501, 0.013889240100979805, 0.00561025645583868, -0.014011558145284653, 0.0069326721131801605, 0.01696522906422615, 0.03550323098897934, 0.002830711891874671, -0.0037638137582689524, -0.0264519602060318, 0.0060158357955515385, 0.05316154286265373, -0.07486710697412491, 0.024657851085066795, 0.01631326973438263, -0.04397798702120781, -0.017388295382261276, 0.0192441176623106, 0.002726644044741988, -0.065290167927742, -0.03265441954135895, 0.03122594766318798, -0.004009103402495384, 0.01988932490348816, -0.08129199594259262, 0.007530895993113518, 0.024661734700202942, -0.05490441992878914, -0.016606343910098076, -0.013388019055128098, 0.0019951232243329287, -0.06228481978178024, -0.022840920835733414, -0.05601419508457184, -0.052867528051137924, -0.007118078414350748, -0.07978707551956177, -0.010000661946833134, 0.001712121069431305, 0.03721945732831955, 0.008859502151608467, 0.012681080959737301, -0.0068721892312169075, -0.017489492893218994, 0.0023587604518979788, -0.04135711118578911, 0.035534679889678955, 0.03650251775979996, 0.037373993545770645, 0.026176748797297478, -0.04713229089975357, -0.024931030347943306, 0.026829294860363007, -0.03447788581252098, 0.0106166061013937, 0.00033643320784904063, 0.034998975694179535, 0.0433405302464962, -0.013697569258511066, 0.06338085234165192, -0.02550925686955452, 0.025391079485416412, -0.012725436128675938, -0.015159417875111103, -0.0516328364610672, -0.050708141177892685, 0.010715225711464882, -0.028992366045713425, 0.000850585347507149, 0.04074408859014511, -0.004627162590622902, -0.023636627942323685, -0.049325551837682724, -0.04561175778508186, 0.040360111743211746, -0.01646273396909237, -0.03175250440835953, 0.03423197194933891, 0.005924925673753023, -0.04598304629325867, 0.010261128656566143, 0.005011782981455326, 0.01278701238334179, -0.020613158121705055, 0.04239285737276077, -0.01742187887430191, -0.015156046487390995, -0.07453794777393341, 0.03570346534252167, 0.02417820319533348, 0.023505166172981262, 0.02282583899796009, 0.06395517289638519, -0.005339385010302067, 0.01276740524917841, 0.008350257761776447, -0.018296018242836, -0.030218027532100677, -0.0755709856748581, -0.024529242888092995, -0.025466475635766983, 0.026146607473492622, 0.0057889423333108425, 0.024593446403741837, -0.02458619326353073, 0.03353925049304962, -0.0367770791053772, 0.010615035891532898, 0.02199970744550228, 0.025822969153523445, -0.016644367948174477, 0.07296939194202423, -0.01644834876060486, -0.009078321047127247, -0.02065163478255272, 0.018855106085538864, -0.009669851511716843, -0.000770026701502502, 0.05587003752589226, 0.030993852764368057, 0.021151123568415642, -0.04815436899662018, -0.024339715018868446, 0.03865024447441101, 0.0014690146781504154, -0.061117518693208694, -0.023964442312717438, 0.04428400099277496, -0.005434757564216852, -0.06552036851644516 ]
The sharing-economy-based business model has recently seen success in the transportation and accommodation sectors with companies like Uber and Airbnb. There is growing interest in applying this model to energy systems, with modalities like peer-to-peer (P2P) Energy Trading, Electric Vehicles (EV)-based Vehicle-to-Grid (V2G), Vehicle-to-Home (V2H), Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V), and Battery Swapping Technology (BST). In this work, we exploit the increasing diffusion of EVs to realize a crowdsourcing platform called e-Uber that jointly enables ride-sharing and energy-sharing through V2G and BST. e-Uber exploits spatial crowdsourcing, reinforcement learning, and reverse auction theory. Specifically, the platform uses reinforcement learning to understand the drivers' preferences towards different ride-sharing and energy-sharing tasks. Based on these preferences, a personalized list is recommended to each driver through CMAB-based Algorithm for task Recommendation System (CARS). Drivers bid on their preferred tasks in their list in a reverse auction fashion. Then e-Uber solves the task assignment optimization problem that minimizes cost and guarantees V2G energy requirement. We prove that this problem is NP-hard and introduce a bipartite matching-inspired heuristic, Bipartite Matching-based Winner selection (BMW), that has polynomial time complexity. Results from experiments using real data from NYC taxi trips and energy consumption show that e-Uber performs close to the optimum and finds better solutions compared to a state-of-the-art approach
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.04753v1
[ 0.007875272072851658, -0.049940694123506546, 0.020870795473456383, 0.04929700121283531, 0.015308569185435772, 0.002799122128635645, 0.041807375848293304, 0.049339115619659424, -0.02247537672519684, -0.057577505707740784, -0.053902141749858856, 0.0282610971480608, -0.04587438702583313, -0.022185198962688446, -0.039322540163993835, 0.06315021961927414, 0.06216227635741234, -0.0052542113699018955, -0.037528470158576965, -0.03688016161322594, 0.020068593323230743, 0.052289899438619614, -0.03454173728823662, 0.053595319390296936, -0.02362171933054924, 0.016003906726837158, -0.030029481276869774, -0.057848259806632996, -0.037723395973443985, -0.03422430157661438, 0.055301517248153687, 0.036436453461647034, -0.0002083806466544047, -0.023046934977173805, -0.02749032899737358, -0.03438885137438774, 0.013184329494833946, -0.019914017990231514, -0.006702232174575329, -0.027806971222162247, 0.025116929784417152, -0.04638044163584709, -0.05361393094062805, -0.058744754642248154, -0.007558201439678669, -0.006627575494349003, -0.07127746194601059, 0.043792467564344406, -0.07879246771335602, -0.0433102548122406, -0.022699100896716118, 0.03949388861656189, 0.023706384003162384, 0.04825177043676376, -0.03169068321585655, 0.025337470695376396, -0.01582086831331253, 0.0043608625419437885, -0.03816387429833412, -0.05061821639537811, -0.005039097275584936, -0.024737507104873657, 0.005783017259091139, 0.012498755939304829, -0.014319206587970257, 0.04999394342303276, -0.042475778609514236, -0.025887509807944298, -0.025055265054106712, -0.04346393421292305, 0.04147767648100853, -0.02135491743683815, 0.02051490731537342, 0.01840093918144703, -0.03966537490487099, -0.06147408112883568, -0.020997190847992897, -0.032070647925138474, 0.0264396071434021, -0.06420393288135529, -0.01501786895096302, -0.028319839388132095, 0.030545447021722794, 0.034762248396873474, -0.0085596377030015, -0.04154948145151138, 0.031975891441106796, 0.01627489924430847, 0.04199042171239853, -0.025579968467354774, 0.054768141359090805, -0.01770729199051857, -0.0702885165810585, 0.009311923757195473, 0.018188821151852608, 0.011462732218205929, -0.0009746519499458373, 0.021145470440387726, 0.02341829240322113, -0.04530871659517288, -0.021918604150414467, -0.020826449617743492, -0.056091368198394775, 0.03488031402230263, 0.026769272983074188, -0.04976477101445198, 0.01580200530588627, 0.013730030506849289, -0.036189135164022446, 0.026334498077630997, -0.0319555439054966, 0.013415667228400707, 0.007120819296687841, -0.06422605365514755, -0.03325388580560684, 0.014302448369562626, 0.03125755116343498, 0.00811085570603609, 0.05338779464364052, -0.011752900667488575, -0.003083094721660018, 0.04520571976900101, 0.054375819861888885, -0.018057310953736305, -0.03045632317662239, 0.015175255946815014, 0.0413752906024456, 0.01779957115650177, -0.013250055722892284, 0.004994857124984264, 0.008895235136151314, 0.054629743099212646, -0.02945338562130928, -0.066625215113163, 0.053278904408216476, 0.012049580924212933, -0.04551064223051071, 0.003067955607548356, -0.005885062273591757, -0.056761011481285095, -0.060868918895721436, -0.046545401215553284, 0.034604523330926895, -0.014708127826452255, 0.021393610164523125, 0.0698503628373146, 0.02673467993736267, -0.0007257804973050952, -0.05686262249946594, 0.017986716702580452, 0.05237807705998421, 0.03917175903916359, 0.004885995760560036, 0.0004999350057914853, 0.03596310690045357, -0.031762704253196716, 0.05112164840102196, -0.06388728320598602, -0.04314645752310753, 0.06072606146335602, -0.04803275689482689, 0.012883701361715794, -0.00999424047768116, -0.034429553896188736, -0.015813400968909264, -0.01063445769250393, 0.007486750837415457, 0.040687840431928635, -0.012366345152258873, -0.017686335369944572, -0.05843342840671539, 0.04644114524126053, 0.016662904992699623, -0.033425867557525635, -0.061677463352680206, -0.009579445235431194, -0.013572248630225658, -0.06409288942813873, -0.03799963369965553, -0.03113533742725849, -0.0018723756074905396, 0.04847170040011406, -0.03295883163809776, 0.050613585859537125, -0.0768795982003212, 0.018524406477808952, -0.07664018124341965, -0.012822109274566174, -0.033883869647979736, -0.014151114039123058, -0.007289677858352661, -0.044475436210632324, -0.00115874782204628, -0.003851445624604821, -0.053715258836746216, -0.04481852427124977, 0.018358083441853523, -0.011201858520507812, -0.0030522863380610943, 0.014765381813049316, -0.05237984657287598, 0.005608137231320143, -0.05513783544301987, -0.014020215719938278, -0.023258689790964127, -0.07466782629489899, -0.0028393007814884186, 0.03815939277410507, -0.02678873762488365, 0.011906037107110023, -0.003163618966937065, 0.023288391530513763, 0.01760668121278286, -0.04304543510079384, 0.05069015920162201, -0.019144851714372635, -0.09761139005422592, 0.039746154099702835, 0.005404293537139893, -0.007809035945683718, 0.01616594009101391, 0.024351775646209717, -0.02205776236951351, 0.010136354714632034, 0.011937524192035198, -0.030887095257639885, 0.016725657507777214, -0.022836659103631973, -0.020913418382406235, 0.0218492541462183, -0.03396635875105858, -0.027274586260318756, -0.05283847451210022, -0.071894071996212, -0.00557224964722991, 0.006075306795537472, -0.02477194182574749, 0.031334344297647476, -0.002401552861556411, -0.06214308366179466, -0.00887377094477415, -0.04493105411529541, 0.06204786151647568, -0.008942593820393085, -0.005907235201448202, -0.023500610142946243, -0.05083673074841499, -0.011796660721302032, -0.03290833532810211, 0.005521778017282486, 0.008290205150842667, 0.013203735463321209, -0.026121089234948158, -0.04927058145403862, 0.05492846295237541, -0.029067909345030785, -0.019786592572927475, 0.04669880494475365, -0.03127845376729965, 0.013834276236593723, -0.022596586495637894, 0.03287035599350929, -0.04565883427858353, -0.009324681013822556, 0.035757895559072495, -0.02433832921087742, 0.02932688035070896, -0.07582195848226547, 0.04307803511619568, -0.04426324740052223, -0.01008483488112688, 0.007870454341173172, 0.02807476744055748, -0.02917608991265297, 0.04422936961054802, 0.005555195268243551, -0.06061131879687309, -0.009744220413267612, -0.012763327918946743, 0.05533318966627121, 0.04383113980293274, 0.027781885117292404, 0.015008628368377686, -0.031697917729616165, -0.017896227538585663, -0.012312707491219044, -0.026566967368125916, -0.05922318249940872, -0.04394099861383438, -0.04556712880730629, -0.05188257247209549, -0.021845046430826187, -0.04094930738210678, -0.036634936928749084, -0.049576807767152786, -0.03037170134484768, 0.009078382514417171, -0.0027905928436666727, 0.0034785063471645117, -0.03849519416689873, -0.02828693576157093, 0.025321127846837044, 0.011866829358041286, 0.001057595363818109, -0.041777849197387695, -0.016697010025382042, -0.025917936116456985, -0.05610363557934761, -0.014851990155875683, -0.006236694287508726, -0.005530999507755041, 0.004676243755966425, -0.039144955575466156, 0.030343255028128624, -0.015359550714492798, -0.01716860942542553, 0.008416222408413887, 0.06336601823568344, -0.006973893381655216, -0.04865293949842453, -0.0019511112477630377, 0.02252330258488655, 0.022511258721351624, -0.04307900369167328, -0.07283376902341843, -0.04365098103880882, 0.033066656440496445, 0.0443088598549366, -0.009331938810646534, 0.010822482407093048, 0.0034780194982886314, 0.004272137768566608, 0.04191865399479866, 0.021964220330119133, 0.030141456052660942, 0.02535870298743248, -0.007377561181783676, -0.031837139278650284, -0.01010777335613966, -0.05380736291408539, -0.05881163477897644, 0.01816551201045513, -0.02610476128757, 0.017400192096829414, 0.05831366032361984, -0.06865545362234116, 0.051984529942274094, 0.0232269074767828, 0.07054039090871811, -0.011181849986314774, 0.001279220450669527, 0.02274276316165924, -0.01603294536471367, 0.050933413207530975, 0.01187488716095686, 0.05007978901267052, 0.049473684281110764, 0.05201699212193489, -0.05996190011501312, -0.024183381348848343, -0.05931072682142258, -0.0458374097943306, -0.05697927251458168, 0.016939226537942886, 0.04998910427093506, 0.029058679938316345, 0.04659144952893257, -0.01698066107928753, 0.03852950409054756, 0.02206725813448429, 0.019550060853362083, 0.002215537941083312, -0.07401521503925323, 0.01327901054173708, 0.001675601932220161, 0.013508979231119156, 0.03611034154891968, -0.030941493809223175, -0.009307748638093472, -0.021779049187898636, 0.007588415872305632, -0.05616812780499458, 0.029119065031409264, -0.01989760994911194, -0.017604434862732887, -0.04207737743854523, 0.02854163758456707, 0.03888538107275963, 0.05395807325839996, -0.036983851343393326, 0.003048214828595519, -0.043092794716358185, -0.009396257810294628, -0.06404922157526016, -0.008081353269517422, -0.058743759989738464, 0.04793616756796837, 0.04192817583680153, -0.03011963702738285, -0.010203970596194267, 0.024740952998399734, 0.02746046520769596, -0.028089623898267746, -0.08429010212421417, -0.002063789637759328, -0.023757081478834152, 0.0200872290879488, 0.03210654482245445, -0.013025669381022453, 0.07625199854373932, -0.023338235914707184, 0.02779611200094223, -0.06029136851429939, -0.017251450568437576, -0.021126531064510345, -0.0591614693403244, -0.03720785304903984, -0.058621250092983246, 0.04156415909528732, -0.04673076793551445, 0.026806248351931572, 0.0019016729202121496, 0.02052466943860054, -0.07163992524147034, -0.06741119921207428, -0.017826739698648453, 0.026881976053118706, 0.049163226038217545, 0.042295124381780624, -0.0034893860574811697, -0.016011172905564308, 0.014236915856599808, 0.023988664150238037, 0.0005863758851774037, -0.04252789914608002, -0.0071438695304095745, 0.012279557064175606, 0.01770002953708172, 0.02470012940466404, 0.02343355491757393, -0.008975069038569927, 0.05802562087774277, -0.05631266161799431, 0.014949611388146877, -0.05486636236310005, 0.0485512800514698, -0.030012788251042366, -0.054033443331718445, -0.03174632787704468, -0.04254600405693054, -0.03273753449320793, -0.011316604912281036, 0.03943163529038429, -0.07014993578195572, 0.014543253928422928, -0.0010261990828439593, 0.040465690195560455, 0.009966990910470486, -0.0005341926007531583, 0.008576740510761738, -0.01195252314209938, -0.012259689159691334, -0.05258728936314583, -0.005331508349627256, -0.06975988298654556, 0.02591816335916519, -0.03259773924946785, 0.029370112344622612, -0.0532454177737236, 0.03271133452653885, 0.024623000994324684, 0.01885467767715454, -0.07892027497291565, 0.014610733836889267, 0.05986316129565239, 0.014963123947381973, 0.03282788768410683, -0.01429842785000801, -0.03918174281716347, 0.027376167476177216, -0.02833910658955574, 0.018275011330842972, 0.03181929141283035, -0.03712141513824463, 0.002014047699049115, -0.02156832627952099, -0.004793129395693541, 0.05566024407744408, 0.052165694534778595, -0.028806576505303383, -0.032089367508888245, 0.011179125867784023, 0.04474933445453644, -0.011633679270744324, -0.02243097685277462, 0.028785454109311104, 0.030276872217655182, -0.058430351316928864, 0.009773163124918938, -0.019910065457224846, 0.032533079385757446, -0.05751712992787361, 0.023733913898468018, -0.03765122592449188, 0.019113624468445778, 0.017174802720546722, -0.010803085751831532, -0.003265918930992484, 0.00429125502705574, 0.009922502562403679, 0.04728015512228012, 0.010415077209472656, -0.014291878789663315, -0.06457038968801498, 0.006985502317547798, -0.03644935414195061, -0.008580499328672886, -0.028201846405863762, 0.07317144423723221, 0.0373094268143177, 0.0009103610645979643, -0.0599069707095623, -0.056990355253219604, 0.032443299889564514, -0.02819276787340641, 0.03680022433400154, -0.07037896662950516, 0.022198041900992393, 0.0020492635667324066, -0.0069633591920137405, 0.03667860105633736, -0.04868540167808533, 0.03812065348029137, -0.04429410398006439, -0.044552698731422424, -0.0425124391913414, 0.019312158226966858, -0.04701002314686775, -0.021529607474803925, -0.01709270104765892, 0.046459048986434937, -0.0568869449198246, 0.05991846323013306, 0.005761956330388784, 0.026375113055109978, 0.05103243514895439, 0.016553690657019615, 0.015578057616949081, 0.03674263507127762, 0.027349842712283134, 0.057440511882305145, -0.07067713141441345, -0.018865182995796204, -0.025038588792085648, -0.07162532955408096, -0.0022755456157028675, -0.02305576764047146, -0.020123111084103584, -0.022702578455209732, -0.02205333113670349, -0.07155711203813553, 0.03135407716035843, -0.043583519756793976, -0.07298892736434937, 0.028730398043990135, -0.015305878594517708, -0.07734473049640656, 0.0013983127428218722, 0.05544497072696686, -0.0273036677390337, -0.060219764709472656, 0.0398315005004406, 0.011601822450757027, 0.01868548057973385, -0.060338493436574936, 0.05849509686231613, 0.023512262850999832, 0.02519744075834751, 0.01235935278236866, 0.024855002760887146, -0.0724160298705101, 0.02911088801920414, -0.025297390297055244, -0.018323572352528572, 0.03952827304601669, 0.057581596076488495, 0.05115310102701187, -0.050184328109025955, -0.04037099704146385, 0.029763557016849518, -0.020229995250701904, -0.034773699939250946, 0.006164361257106066, -0.050592973828315735, 0.031449463218450546, -0.01917499676346779, -0.05314626917243004, -0.00042002281406894326, -0.04925689473748207, 0.008605221286416054, 0.04436279088258743, 0.007714394945651293, 0.007787419017404318, -0.008032593876123428, 0.009022154845297337, -0.03731795400381088, 0.02501695230603218, 0.004569527693092823, -0.06271731853485107, 0.05209645628929138, -0.042123109102249146, -0.010265596210956573, 0.03623060882091522, 0.0076567018404603004, 0.0006414299714379013, 0.0355885811150074, -0.013637149706482887, 0.017674995586276054, 0.045012835413217545, -0.03337966278195381, 0.010062050074338913, 0.01569790206849575, 0.037783432751894, 0.026725471019744873, 0.05290992930531502, 0.023477423936128616, -0.029175421223044395, -0.016522176563739777, -0.011214194819331169, -0.05082900822162628, 0.0302264466881752, -0.004154969472438097, -0.0466826930642128, 0.033845916390419006, 0.025139855220913887, -0.014557180926203728, 0.01081303134560585, -0.02543492801487446, -0.04202962666749954, -0.020265543833374977, -0.01963028870522976, 0.019240697845816612, -0.017435939982533455, -0.01857980340719223, 0.04215719923377037, -0.021059900522232056, -0.029182812198996544, -0.03541824594140053, 0.0063035921193659306, -0.037071872502565384, -0.05861591920256615, -0.05506748706102371, -0.02295016683638096, -0.036340177059173584, -0.06189030408859253, -0.04909071326255798, 0.014326993376016617, -0.05323633924126625, -0.026215316727757454, 0.023764457553625107, -0.02834794856607914, -0.0023817194160073996, -0.07743373513221741, 0.00585883017629385, -0.008221936412155628, -0.03495276719331741, -0.041601184755563736, -0.025713765993714333, 0.006112535484135151, -0.05360613018274307, -0.022116463631391525, -0.026978593319654465, -0.04131452739238739, -0.004323678091168404, -0.07068740576505661, -0.0388406403362751, 0.03835635259747505, 0.02418486587703228, -0.01459911186248064, -0.03788626566529274, 0.024763433262705803, -0.06524819880723953, 0.010026264004409313, -0.011500244960188866, -0.05087515711784363, -0.020863886922597885, 0.03167504817247391, 0.03380525857210159, -0.0405922569334507, -0.010099186562001705, -0.006372677627950907, -0.01793018914759159, -0.03315260261297226, 0.011304202489554882, 0.003737230785191059, 0.014595109038054943, -0.04407274350523949, 0.040650736540555954, -0.020964806899428368, 0.06348743289709091, -0.01736791618168354, 0.035775862634181976, -0.030901916325092316, -0.061673566699028015, 0.023274047300219536, -0.03801063448190689, 0.002088045235723257, 0.041530150920152664, -0.027972804382443428, -0.016118444502353668, -0.03209710121154785, -0.04491744562983513, 0.042523737996816635, -0.009950190782546997, -0.022177312523126602, 0.0037423018366098404, -0.03381342440843582, -0.038564156740903854, -0.0024596801958978176, 0.02709963172674179, 0.04703777655959129, 0.011454113759100437, 0.0017059985548257828, -0.07231571525335312, 0.032394152134656906, 0.004734179936349392, -0.002402946352958679, -0.023071996867656708, 0.018674734979867935, -0.0028192088939249516, 0.03338673338294029, 0.04106137156486511, -0.05356336385011673, -0.04534127563238144, -0.011159516870975494, -0.07355813682079315, -0.0614938847720623, -0.01559119950979948, -0.013774042017757893, 0.04728709161281586, 0.04062468558549881, -0.020358653739094734, -0.04170644283294678, 0.011636380106210709, -0.01289491169154644, -0.005550018511712551, -0.02511465921998024, -0.004673503804951906, -0.023172937333583832, 0.06895796954631805, -0.037559304386377335, -0.0251663476228714, -0.006764840334653854, 0.05120876431465149, 0.003946036100387573, 0.07358057051897049, -0.0009059507865458727, -0.020756863057613373, -0.005399147514253855, 0.018180688843131065, -0.0008879064116626978, 0.04458828270435333, -0.03731754794716835, -0.017598513513803482, -0.048707474023103714, 0.06205228716135025, -0.007604774087667465, -0.040852323174476624 ]
We formulate monocular depth estimation using denoising diffusion models, inspired by their recent successes in high fidelity image generation. To that end, we introduce innovations to address problems arising due to noisy, incomplete depth maps in training data, including step-unrolled denoising diffusion, an $L_1$ loss, and depth infilling during training. To cope with the limited availability of data for supervised training, we leverage pre-training on self-supervised image-to-image translation tasks. Despite the simplicity of the approach, with a generic loss and architecture, our DepthGen model achieves SOTA performance on the indoor NYU dataset, and near SOTA results on the outdoor KITTI dataset. Further, with a multimodal posterior, DepthGen naturally represents depth ambiguity (e.g., from transparent surfaces), and its zero-shot performance combined with depth imputation, enable a simple but effective text-to-3D pipeline. Project page: https://depth-gen.github.io
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14816v1
[ -0.05910593643784523, -0.03241671249270439, 0.05652320384979248, 0.003481782739982009, -0.006149924360215664, 0.022848278284072876, 0.011188303120434284, 0.007086573168635368, 0.01685946062207222, -0.02512362040579319, -0.022077292203903198, -0.028092674911022186, -0.05270526930689812, -0.045254744589328766, 0.013981998898088932, -0.015762699767947197, 0.06879185885190964, -0.047350771725177765, -0.05226382613182068, 0.0747518539428711, 0.025013107806444168, -0.018677720800042152, -0.031983792781829834, 0.016014905646443367, -0.03135094791650772, -0.030708175152540207, -0.07113740593194962, 0.042180344462394714, 0.012373528443276882, -0.01933595910668373, 0.07240807265043259, -0.033528149127960205, -0.047430891543626785, -0.04375649243593216, 0.003799322061240673, 0.027798833325505257, -0.058122649788856506, 0.04938648268580437, 0.049165308475494385, -0.0645192489027977, 0.02931845746934414, -0.06421338766813278, -0.0663059651851654, -0.033980146050453186, -0.05998541787266731, 0.03941638022661209, 0.02502688579261303, 0.007122358772903681, -0.06163424998521805, -0.049452461302280426, 0.03135092183947563, -0.004101060796529055, -0.045021042227745056, 0.02521289885044098, -0.004169532563537359, 0.003968691453337669, 0.019025320187211037, 0.011165790259838104, -0.05034647509455681, 0.011653358116745949, 0.05121363699436188, -0.02796747535467148, 0.012935935519635677, -0.05027825012803078, -0.02442062459886074, 0.03492362052202225, -0.004652386996895075, -0.05590399354696274, -0.031174976378679276, -0.06306811422109604, 0.017708418890833855, -0.05061238259077072, -0.034532129764556885, 0.01280273962765932, -0.019201291725039482, 0.00007269069465110078, -0.016108140349388123, 0.018344325944781303, -0.015282335691154003, -0.005145118106156588, -0.034452587366104126, 0.033560335636138916, 0.006025900132954121, 0.06301184743642807, 0.015532851219177246, -0.02261163294315338, 0.011624082922935486, -0.027514535933732986, 0.014348464086651802, -0.03700263053178787, 0.003735227044671774, -0.02694888599216938, -0.06221454218029976, 0.00806246418505907, 0.07381779700517654, -0.03645128384232521, 0.05597574636340141, 0.01835225336253643, 0.019431831315159798, -0.021430013701319695, -0.040452804416418076, -0.06906706094741821, -0.04976274445652962, 0.01337956078350544, 0.0188407264649868, 0.013401247560977936, -0.017925187945365906, 0.0005736810271628201, -0.0483224093914032, 0.04207463935017586, -0.028086548671126366, -0.0008572480292059481, 0.012541930191218853, -0.02706194296479225, -0.043561141937971115, -0.0410318598151207, 0.07071708142757416, 0.010341710411012173, -0.004304612521082163, -0.01908308081328869, -0.006726144813001156, -0.006179528310894966, 0.02795259840786457, -0.05164420232176781, -0.003870214568451047, -0.03712635114789009, 0.04987459257245064, -0.025381365790963173, -0.010860743932425976, -0.02811366505920887, -0.01971576362848282, 0.003386391093954444, -0.003934402484446764, -0.04900924116373062, 0.054381899535655975, -0.016621669754385948, 0.0015204447554424405, -0.054870396852493286, 0.019544808194041252, 0.03668121621012688, -0.05571180209517479, -0.052008599042892456, 0.014916002750396729, 0.023538077250123024, -0.00864486489444971, 0.04130646958947182, -0.04929288476705551, -0.039294175803661346, 0.0144718112424016, 0.0515601709485054, 0.032164476811885834, -0.013007386587560177, 0.02359488233923912, 0.049074284732341766, -0.006429845932871103, -0.029041828587651253, 0.0534585565328598, 0.028069639578461647, -0.030526818707585335, 0.043249987065792084, 0.021446287631988525, -0.05062144249677658, 0.043069399893283844, -0.02588110975921154, 0.038790829479694366, 0.01378337200731039, 0.03302277997136116, -0.03285495564341545, -0.004229763522744179, 0.013781697489321232, -0.04599497467279434, -0.0289908479899168, -0.009462912566959858, 0.017819760367274284, -0.053694263100624084, -0.0070527708157896996, 0.004471861757338047, -0.048556845635175705, -0.05932498350739479, 0.006697803735733032, -0.021196888759732246, 0.022533942013978958, -0.03366962447762489, -0.03442526236176491, -0.04459114000201225, -0.028580645099282265, -0.08660542219877243, -0.020229967311024666, 0.013086112216114998, 0.007825004868209362, -0.0578782819211483, -0.019029125571250916, 0.005222718231379986, 0.003622813383117318, -0.03866734728217125, -0.024464450776576996, -0.0039052926003932953, 0.023969491943717003, -0.003371207043528557, 0.053509023040533066, -0.09446220099925995, -0.04204344004392624, -0.03359445556998253, 0.039514798671007156, -0.005189688876271248, -0.024944067001342773, -0.04038674756884575, 0.06079341098666191, -0.024249708279967308, 0.005947427824139595, 0.04932387173175812, 0.04375133663415909, 0.07271774113178253, -0.026213647797703743, 0.0322222076356411, -0.00459261192008853, -0.10050737857818604, 0.027912301942706108, 0.0020993161015212536, -0.0014635897241532803, 0.015917614102363586, 0.013736282475292683, -0.004653043579310179, -0.06851139664649963, -0.020529191941022873, 0.0643453374505043, 0.055640388280153275, -0.02335226535797119, -0.05257421359419823, -0.007281657308340073, 0.03357311710715294, -0.06402530521154404, -0.018581705167889595, -0.06820608675479889, -0.062149908393621445, 0.0008012691978365183, -0.020998669788241386, 0.06715188920497894, -0.01432148925960064, 0.0033289892598986626, -0.03143101930618286, -0.0035169150214642286, 0.06624025106430054, 0.021545285359025, -0.041600048542022705, -0.005311471410095692, 0.0014103964203968644, 0.008790629915893078, -0.04037940874695778, -0.01243013795465231, -0.064319908618927, -0.04709316045045853, -0.026665205135941505, -0.001531403511762619, 0.04869798570871353, 0.04891933500766754, 0.00268358807079494, 0.004955373238772154, 0.009436378255486488, 0.06975466758012772, 0.013552315533161163, -0.008214895613491535, -0.059769079089164734, -0.0055941264145076275, 0.012991747818887234, -0.009202349931001663, -0.013594837859272957, -0.01687869243323803, 0.011177904903888702, -0.04230203852057457, 0.01927310787141323, 0.036906369030475616, 0.04412567615509033, 0.021936403587460518, -0.034349698573350906, -0.018601790070533752, -0.011086001992225647, -0.026728346943855286, 0.01622983254492283, 0.04003482311964035, 0.04845806583762169, 0.02639728970825672, -0.02694631926715374, -0.05810160934925079, -0.006749684456735849, -0.06610118597745895, -0.039215948432683945, -0.07739754766225815, -0.06531862914562225, 0.0103334691375494, -0.08535709232091904, -0.04833297058939934, -0.04316197335720062, -0.061374083161354065, -0.036817099899053574, -0.0172464270144701, -0.07645245641469955, -0.01206212118268013, 0.05851622298359871, 0.003697756677865982, -0.03091464191675186, -0.039005573838949203, -0.013986920937895775, 0.03927748650312424, 0.02781648002564907, -0.03928935155272484, -0.05523337423801422, 0.0186525397002697, 0.023265041410923004, -0.028730306774377823, -0.016843562945723534, 0.02358020283281803, -0.02325747348368168, 0.01844080723822117, 0.03846880421042442, 0.06596460193395615, -0.015182350762188435, 0.012496452778577805, -0.0014667300274595618, -0.048474084585905075, 0.01095216441899538, -0.054026518017053604, -0.017286410555243492, -0.05948241055011749, -0.024762511253356934, -0.03893285617232323, 0.017352525144815445, -0.015971774235367775, -0.025549523532390594, -0.05722636356949806, -0.03220617398619652, 0.03279644995927811, -0.002961775055155158, -0.034174494445323944, 0.04962778463959694, 0.0397658571600914, -0.03724396228790283, -0.04592667892575264, -0.01003129780292511, 0.03927838057279587, 0.022064408287405968, -0.014824205078184605, -0.03859210014343262, 0.03553059697151184, 0.058602578938007355, -0.09537889808416367, 0.009147364646196365, 0.08297653496265411, 0.05952819436788559, 0.002567221177741885, -0.005373538471758366, -0.029135365039110184, 0.001510581816546619, 0.05322101339697838, 0.01464707963168621, -0.016900580376386642, 0.030931591987609863, 0.0404428169131279, -0.01177649199962616, -0.04957069084048271, 0.01469319686293602, -0.06917973607778549, -0.014655029401183128, -0.0017941811820492148, 0.021509289741516113, 0.0276353657245636, 0.05301942303776741, -0.054016292095184326, 0.01371249184012413, 0.017320744693279266, 0.03329052776098251, -0.030146751552820206, -0.0011513326317071915, 0.019572312012314796, -0.041851527988910675, 0.012099271640181541, -0.00333785661496222, -0.01932496577501297, 0.006157523486763239, -0.03679864853620529, 0.025336459279060364, -0.0513639822602272, 0.0721743032336235, 0.0038773638661950827, 0.006297383923083544, 0.05360739305615425, 0.04985534027218819, -0.024070365354418755, 0.006562997121363878, -0.020292198285460472, -0.023436270654201508, 0.004341773223131895, 0.024412475526332855, -0.03613431006669998, 0.016110779717564583, -0.035098012536764145, -0.004422454163432121, 0.027890069410204887, -0.01564094051718712, 0.001537082134746015, -0.01898033730685711, 0.0020137743558734655, -0.020188987255096436, -0.06395974010229111, -0.004892717581242323, -0.022231610491871834, 0.030755924060940742, -0.036409568041563034, 0.013312341645359993, 0.058827079832553864, -0.00045612198300659657, -0.004782974254339933, 0.01122110616415739, -0.010377115570008755, -0.028310881927609444, -0.04999712109565735, 0.0037491461262106895, -0.05586330592632294, 0.01599281094968319, -0.02140405774116516, 0.03525613248348236, 0.03705974668264389, 0.00005832843453390524, -0.04421978071331978, -0.017931584268808365, -0.04001467302441597, -0.007255591452121735, 0.04995962232351303, 0.004603745881468058, -0.001354171079583466, 0.030326053500175476, 0.009807754307985306, -0.025466950610280037, 0.0007769908406771719, 0.02005603536963463, -0.03339321166276932, 0.00787729024887085, -0.0272020623087883, -0.031191423535346985, -0.036913637071847916, -0.014197132550179958, 0.025902122259140015, -0.02821594476699829, -0.011995991691946983, 0.00014082103734835982, -0.0027631644625216722, -0.05539967864751816, -0.060130197554826736, -0.010389041155576706, -0.044158078730106354, -0.040009621530771255, -0.023562977090477943, 0.033120594918727875, 0.047617413103580475, 0.003961616195738316, -0.022032128646969795, 0.008042819797992706, -0.005510598421096802, -0.012595088221132755, -0.04116175323724747, 0.0288616381585598, -0.0210367850959301, -0.042428601533174515, -0.06468337774276733, -0.08000552654266357, -0.004561386536806822, -0.0588473342359066, 0.002090539550408721, 0.015262330882251263, 0.0324869267642498, -0.025875158607959747, 0.039036016911268234, -0.08877323567867279, -0.03094685636460781, 0.0704534724354744, -0.02495640516281128, 0.034076862037181854, 0.0408625565469265, -0.010195057839155197, 0.026514718309044838, -0.02609260380268097, 0.012406077235937119, 0.024110496044158936, -0.04655400663614273, -0.021405881270766258, 0.007466407492756844, -0.028496796265244484, -0.04766825959086418, 0.04161946475505829, 0.03679604083299637, -0.025075793266296387, 0.031787022948265076, 0.021090354770421982, -0.00260112970136106, -0.05753600597381592, 0.00316848186776042, 0.049111805856227875, -0.011044135317206383, -0.043683115392923355, -0.0007296843687072396, -0.037230756133794785, 0.02069614641368389, 0.011947582475841045, -0.04287879168987274, -0.04164590686559677, 0.029781505465507507, -0.04598424583673477, 0.01639033481478691, 0.05437087640166283, 0.003252271329984069, 0.016609899699687958, -0.030671896412968636, -0.02317165583372116, -0.0395038016140461, -0.03560475632548332, 0.002131811808794737, -0.009368008933961391, 0.04949395731091499, 0.01940065622329712, -0.011292822659015656, 0.03890290856361389, -0.03549688309431076, 0.04198881611227989, 0.016797805204987526, -0.04793355613946915, 0.025987893342971802, -0.01694396138191223, 0.03302904963493347, 0.006649881601333618, 0.002884157933294773, -0.01984475739300251, 0.0542193204164505, -0.0049077835865318775, -0.011994541622698307, -0.0004401171754579991, -0.017045730724930763, 0.06391081213951111, -0.04516921564936638, -0.01833551935851574, 0.00047875678865239024, 0.001276702038012445, -0.0377134345471859, 0.019335437566041946, 0.02700583077967167, 0.009612503461539745, 0.04625485837459564, -0.02830773964524269, 0.006042799912393093, -0.0628979504108429, -0.028182629495859146, 0.04855157434940338, -0.03632323071360588, 0.0034825922921299934, -0.014026887714862823, -0.03433746099472046, 0.010112211108207703, -0.05908644571900368, 0.027697548270225525, 0.024696173146367073, 0.007892112247645855, -0.033624134957790375, 0.07216096669435501, -0.030628317967057228, -0.08102915436029434, 0.027040772140026093, 0.0015408361796289682, -0.09046466648578644, 0.007683777250349522, -0.007332394830882549, -0.037465307861566544, -0.049277011305093765, 0.019373053684830666, 0.02952808327972889, 0.02066214196383953, -0.06570567935705185, 0.06870190054178238, 0.0839853584766388, -0.007522390224039555, 0.00752450292930007, 0.0006652972660958767, -0.05253267288208008, 0.036529041826725006, -0.05176207050681114, 0.042440131306648254, -0.005801612511277199, 0.011476819403469563, -0.012503678910434246, -0.046628888696432114, -0.02174549549818039, 0.05170194432139397, -0.05188167095184326, -0.0034336771350353956, 0.0069900876842439175, 0.017358286306262016, 0.05847873538732529, 0.012180513702332973, -0.016833722591400146, 0.02435312420129776, 0.022605691105127335, -0.01866467297077179, -0.05303420126438141, 0.03205094486474991, 0.004606727510690689, 0.0000856409315019846, 0.007210947573184967, -0.08126840740442276, 0.02921161614358425, -0.048330675810575485, -0.07857436686754227, 0.0425424687564373, -0.0777469053864479, -0.00019142249948345125, -0.04126610606908798, 0.022535456344485283, 0.04420631751418114, 0.03274054452776909, -0.05589659512042999, -0.04684455692768097, -0.010862728580832481, 0.03675197809934616, 0.012805950827896595, -0.023406775668263435, 0.01323020737618208, -0.05987948924303055, 0.026641355827450752, -0.04385783150792122, 0.0012124864151701331, -0.025905974209308624, -0.013536762446165085, 0.05515630543231964, -0.01604892499744892, -0.04581417888402939, 0.012345648370683193, 0.005847267806529999, -0.04039664939045906, 0.0251592006534338, 0.008599217981100082, -0.05396074801683426, -0.07853687554597855, 0.008110139518976212, -0.0033432296477258205, -0.009617906995117664, 0.005607785191386938, 0.038587234914302826, 0.0027259730268269777, -0.03314327076077461, 0.030183618888258934, 0.03190366178750992, -0.040397122502326965, 0.005918428767472506, -0.07330624014139175, -0.02551076002418995, 0.017742639407515526, -0.030387600883841515, -0.03634309023618698, -0.03462798893451691, -0.019274823367595673, -0.06508046388626099, -0.016839195042848587, 0.0394662469625473, 0.05163373798131943, -0.05731019377708435, -0.05655141547322273, 0.02003191038966179, -0.015059920959174633, -0.009635106660425663, 0.002286018803715706, -0.010962915606796741, 0.02462773397564888, -0.013681711629033089, -0.01722625643014908, 0.0023426690604537725, -0.050857044756412506, 0.018774230033159256, -0.08334419131278992, 0.016529850661754608, 0.024605676531791687, -0.009541480801999569, -0.00940006971359253, -0.020612221211194992, -0.037424810230731964, -0.014115546829998493, -0.03448925539851189, 0.012108437716960907, 0.039296381175518036, -0.0025451434776186943, 0.045645348727703094, -0.038807258009910583, -0.043795570731163025, -0.028668811544775963, 0.04130228981375694, -0.01899334229528904, -0.03639686107635498, 0.02359062246978283, 0.015929771587252617, 0.017583798617124557, 0.00396409397944808, 0.04913332313299179, -0.002822177018970251, 0.031918976455926895, -0.05867878720164299, 0.028300566598773003, -0.029772674664855003, -0.026602977886795998, 0.044504426419734955, -0.01989557221531868, -0.009082182310521603, -0.008908591233193874, -0.010971189476549625, -0.010248901322484016, -0.020670438185334206, -0.04459279775619507, 0.007354930508881807, -0.03787859156727791, 0.01925784721970558, 0.03249433636665344, -0.053206078708171844, 0.004739957395941019, -0.03824184089899063, 0.014284035190939903, -0.042543601244688034, 0.005788782611489296, 0.03154946491122246, -0.02504967898130417, 0.0030611746478825808, -0.04976093769073486, -0.019565362483263016, -0.04008178412914276, -0.02349170856177807, -0.034704677760601044, 0.08302632719278336, -0.022229988127946854, 0.012207215651869774, -0.019151771441102028, -0.035445913672447205, 0.042570747435092926, -0.04188882187008858, -0.012259505689144135, -0.03161783143877983, 0.037327058613300323, -0.05262311175465584, -0.010183295235037804, 0.007136180065572262, 0.039752308279275894, 0.011021227575838566, 0.03085084818303585, 0.0024396616499871016, 0.03549124673008919, -0.03946777805685997, 0.0718347504734993, 0.007461568806320429, 0.003300220239907503, -0.034040894359350204, 0.0193188339471817, 0.015082791447639465, -0.06633496284484863, -0.0009021262521855533, -0.04308485984802246, 0.060899265110492706, -0.06702376157045364, 0.007339559495449066, 0.009503265842795372, -0.008004504255950451, -0.05123712122440338, 0.0031471671536564827, -0.020801309496164322, -0.04018980637192726, -0.07202064245939255 ]
Deploying service robots in our daily life, whether in restaurants, warehouses or hospitals, calls for the need to reason on the interactions happening in dense and dynamic scenes. In this paper, we present and benchmark three new approaches to model and predict multi-agent interactions in dense scenes, including the use of an intuitive qualitative representation. The proposed solutions take into account static and dynamic context to predict individual interactions. They exploit an input- and a temporal-attention mechanism, and are tested on medium and long-term time horizons. The first two approaches integrate different relations from the so-called Qualitative Trajectory Calculus (QTC) within a state-of-the-art deep neural network to create a symbol-driven neural architecture for predicting spatial interactions. The third approach implements a purely data-driven network for motion prediction, the output of which is post-processed to predict QTC spatial interactions. Experimental results on a popular robot dataset of challenging crowded scenarios show that the purely data-driven prediction approach generally outperforms the other two. The three approaches were further evaluated on a different but related human scenarios to assess their generalisation capability.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.00065v1
[ -0.019250137731432915, -0.05298082157969475, 0.0689338743686676, 0.030866164714097977, -0.0023938026279211044, -0.036363210529088974, 0.03299509361386299, 0.009537342004477978, -0.012701114639639854, -0.04464179277420044, -0.03150203451514244, 0.015322409570217133, 0.0062770964577794075, -0.028972802683711052, -0.008952369913458824, 0.02646445482969284, 0.06611612439155579, 0.018696988001465797, -0.036250531673431396, 0.06518996506929398, 0.007785028778016567, -0.05210576206445694, -0.017541034147143364, 0.023561052978038788, -0.0068614911288022995, 0.003647120902314782, -0.025329580530524254, 0.015578195452690125, -0.03814171999692917, -0.014621405862271786, 0.06460517644882202, -0.04686355218291283, -0.026117313653230667, -0.052779655903577805, -0.03259117528796196, -0.014506024308502674, 0.029690369963645935, 0.03499310836195946, 0.018638363108038902, -0.043704189360141754, 0.004973418079316616, -0.059506937861442566, -0.07501664757728577, 0.013308260589838028, -0.03132675215601921, 0.017707224935293198, -0.02411733567714691, -0.004716909024864435, -0.06840581446886063, -0.040011219680309296, 0.018781112506985664, -0.0018912238301709294, 0.0027685852255672216, 0.042147889733314514, -0.04936930537223816, 0.0077069164253771305, -0.016502518206834793, 0.040195442736148834, -0.0479862205684185, -0.007533208467066288, -0.012388557195663452, -0.027021588757634163, 0.012747191824018955, 0.011605123989284039, 0.0267852284014225, 0.05855947732925415, -0.05192525312304497, -0.06996232271194458, -0.010832608677446842, -0.05350300669670105, 0.050541505217552185, -0.0670681968331337, 0.020547308027744293, -0.03045698255300522, -0.017299432307481766, -0.020903032273054123, -0.019345445558428764, -0.009971080347895622, 0.013965606689453125, 0.0012995880097150803, -0.01022811233997345, 0.04542042315006256, 0.03634512424468994, 0.025789950042963028, -0.010054638609290123, -0.04589320346713066, 0.06357742846012115, -0.007194525096565485, 0.02288082242012024, -0.05228535085916519, 0.041436146944761276, -0.04282455891370773, -0.04166887328028679, -0.01716911792755127, 0.051052846014499664, -0.028335778042674065, 0.04042012616991997, 0.039662912487983704, 0.017569594085216522, -0.024037884548306465, -0.0072236028499901295, 0.001635711989365518, -0.03748514875769615, 0.06135460361838341, 0.05217772349715233, -0.03985299915075302, 0.02630537748336792, 0.006285926327109337, -0.03621985390782356, -0.022823570296168327, -0.051082175225019455, -0.04634622484445572, 0.01939668506383896, -0.0668783038854599, -0.052113473415374756, -0.04957050457596779, 0.04800073429942131, 0.02392915077507496, 0.04803021624684334, 0.008015445433557034, -0.05379148945212364, 0.04190864786505699, 0.00922850426286459, -0.018870536237955093, -0.04589620977640152, -0.020917007699608803, 0.060163307934999466, 0.034913964569568634, -0.016800593584775925, -0.02342359721660614, -0.04597194865345955, 0.016375383362174034, -0.041686058044433594, -0.04130452871322632, 0.05058204382658005, -0.00020503593259491026, -0.019194267690181732, -0.06146683543920517, 0.00766888028010726, -0.000548212556168437, -0.06282597780227661, -0.07183489203453064, -0.01669980213046074, -0.02173078991472721, -0.029251107946038246, 0.048402052372694016, -0.05605560913681984, -0.05262114852666855, 0.007916655391454697, 0.027258940041065216, 0.02792695350944996, -0.016779020428657532, 0.012500005774199963, 0.03910168632864952, 0.03934835270047188, -0.023288000375032425, 0.045835644006729126, -0.04319940134882927, -0.052403971552848816, 0.010155978612601757, 0.046449460089206696, -0.05735548585653305, 0.025008514523506165, -0.014409375376999378, -0.036272287368774414, 0.019645297899842262, 0.050365254282951355, -0.021983088925480843, -0.007208243943750858, -0.018274780362844467, 0.032920047640800476, -0.04215829819440842, 0.008221341297030449, -0.018852271139621735, -0.03984448313713074, -0.0483824722468853, 0.009984157048165798, -0.052741941064596176, -0.06883012503385544, -0.017322640866041183, -0.008724252693355083, 0.015285556204617023, -0.03324310854077339, -0.012142461724579334, -0.060582906007766724, 0.024701332673430443, -0.08014072477817535, -0.05721062421798706, 0.042047373950481415, 0.0022215815261006355, -0.02999293990433216, -0.04038021340966225, 0.004654987249523401, 0.02177075669169426, -0.054211925715208054, -0.060880787670612335, 0.01569359190762043, -0.056957390159368515, 0.0011179051361978054, 0.010280188173055649, -0.08512596040964127, -0.027011794969439507, -0.0425138883292675, -0.03429850935935974, 0.01675855927169323, -0.06802242249250412, 0.05133971571922302, 0.03576119989156723, -0.04912780970335007, -0.023202264681458473, 0.023379836231470108, 0.02875565178692341, 0.029768481850624084, -0.007608509622514248, 0.01763950102031231, 0.021628467366099358, -0.09808201342821121, 0.0350094735622406, 0.04873247444629669, 0.03504716977477074, 0.04229946434497833, 0.021985167637467384, 0.03823823481798172, -0.0165585745126009, -0.02495677024126053, 0.06342799216508865, 0.04914137348532677, 0.00512391421943903, -0.05410762131214142, -0.0241104569286108, -0.05147307366132736, -0.08557784557342529, -0.007488246075809002, -0.06992459297180176, -0.01290202233940363, -0.05184716731309891, -0.06562858819961548, 0.06950870901346207, -0.00041683114250190556, -0.030905162915587425, -0.030908960849046707, -0.03473561629652977, 0.02846786007285118, -0.05331196263432503, -0.06053061783313751, -0.01913963258266449, -0.03623475134372711, 0.031654104590415955, 0.00142357696313411, -0.025457866489887238, -0.019390756264328957, -0.06138233095407486, -0.030160576105117798, -0.017810199409723282, 0.0369781032204628, 0.05228569358587265, -0.03118429332971573, 0.02859441190958023, -0.018558280542492867, 0.06565949320793152, -0.011055748909711838, 0.038572389632463455, -0.03935450688004494, 0.0530625656247139, 0.04333994910120964, -0.013338886201381683, -0.013003131374716759, -0.0336260162293911, 0.0027228884864598513, -0.046459000557661057, 0.000870663148816675, 0.012131156399846077, 0.02291378751397133, 0.0002320396015420556, 0.012114444747567177, -0.02919582650065422, 0.007311288733035326, -0.03173001483082771, 0.03967310115695, 0.056813884526491165, 0.037471648305654526, 0.002243038499727845, 0.014044372364878654, -0.056025221943855286, 0.020294874906539917, -0.014604163356125355, -0.007388043683022261, -0.06057829409837723, -0.00925822276622057, -0.008433647453784943, -0.055471837520599365, -0.011678063310682774, -0.043616726994514465, -0.04542531073093414, -0.004413270857185125, -0.06656159460544586, -0.014258012175559998, -0.035623468458652496, 0.013837154023349285, -0.02552567981183529, -0.026422057300806046, -0.040515460073947906, 0.03434330224990845, 0.04029146209359169, 0.03228950873017311, -0.034625399857759476, -0.04628422111272812, -0.03467411547899246, -0.0006351398187689483, -0.011833601631224155, -0.03193018585443497, 0.021076031029224396, -0.04278111830353737, 0.04351050406694412, -0.005300742108374834, 0.0010344063630327582, -0.019748972728848457, 0.009633745066821575, -0.0046050166711211205, -0.0020101701375097036, 0.02118626981973648, -0.007591885980218649, 0.04202137142419815, -0.04030482470989227, -0.05319707468152046, -0.023726077750325203, 0.06176241859793663, 0.03267284110188484, -0.02354585751891136, -0.033071063458919525, 0.05505134165287018, 0.003384502837434411, 0.038300301879644394, 0.008879067376255989, 0.04691004380583763, 0.006095167249441147, -0.01802721433341503, -0.007023452315479517, 0.005016418173909187, 0.02656332030892372, -0.033753614872694016, -0.022435689345002174, -0.034175533801317215, -0.013300655409693718, 0.008323650807142258, -0.08165749907493591, -0.005629831925034523, 0.04988504573702812, 0.07432320713996887, -0.011799473315477371, 0.014686615206301212, 0.007375394459813833, 0.029354996979236603, -0.020812533795833588, 0.012333500199019909, 0.02024475485086441, 0.011999981477856636, 0.06900916993618011, -0.022760359570384026, -0.03995414078235626, -0.0000541186636837665, -0.07614109665155411, -0.06240867078304291, 0.014061837457120419, 0.008109906688332558, 0.027535896748304367, 0.042968664318323135, -0.06327936053276062, 0.040763672441244125, -0.04285368323326111, 0.03632890060544014, 0.0037501859478652477, -0.021500419825315475, 0.02941429801285267, -0.056173067539930344, 0.01604541391134262, 0.027304397895932198, 0.01755424030125141, -0.022539762780070305, -0.06322377920150757, 0.001784982974641025, -0.07560627162456512, 0.051426127552986145, -0.00284236716106534, 0.000056630826293257996, 0.03239043802022934, 0.03490239009261131, -0.00709339277818799, 0.034347593784332275, -0.00042512541403993964, 0.008948344737291336, -0.03185097873210907, -0.013729266822338104, -0.015214608050882816, -0.0012392452917993069, -0.04044065624475479, -0.007004483137279749, -0.009261174127459526, -0.011613509617745876, -0.025641227141022682, -0.004904371686279774, -0.018044956028461456, -0.004688178654760122, -0.08611559122800827, -0.014536630362272263, 0.013615287840366364, 0.021052401512861252, -0.009456018917262554, -0.021907493472099304, 0.061398617923259735, -0.0017567337490618229, 0.019283633679151535, -0.049300290644168854, -0.0015269729774445295, -0.047633808106184006, -0.021546630188822746, 0.013276619836688042, -0.05837225914001465, 0.036607276648283005, -0.05513462796807289, -0.009314280934631824, 0.006854931358247995, 0.04324866086244583, -0.03701458498835564, -0.02699005790054798, 0.025727516040205956, 0.050155047327280045, 0.0395161509513855, 0.011637626215815544, -0.019334038719534874, -0.02452327311038971, 0.053604934364557266, -0.03396433964371681, -0.00943664088845253, -0.021354608237743378, -0.006591130513697863, 0.06007712334394455, -0.01955386810004711, -0.005430391989648342, -0.0031763524748384953, -0.00329409702681005, 0.04982978105545044, -0.006455264985561371, -0.00829662661999464, 0.020954888314008713, 0.070131316781044, -0.0565020814538002, -0.04711998254060745, -0.05867224931716919, -0.05617904290556908, -0.06451686471700668, -0.02407984994351864, 0.028731340542435646, 0.052161239087581635, 0.010845649987459183, 0.009418098255991936, 0.036904942244291306, 0.03766101598739624, 0.0020202407613396645, 0.054771993309259415, -0.011167362332344055, 0.037429049611091614, -0.007239961996674538, 0.01692560501396656, -0.04319063574075699, 0.0016534472815692425, 0.014358995482325554, 0.007046540733426809, -0.03464600071310997, 0.0521882027387619, 0.04580466449260712, 0.035886287689208984, -0.08456733077764511, 0.05185379460453987, 0.02566397190093994, -0.026080287992954254, 0.018344316631555557, 0.04145875945687294, -0.016402773559093475, 0.006728837266564369, -0.03109552338719368, 0.010825823061168194, 0.03437303379178047, -0.03216293081641197, -0.014293406158685684, -0.01976628787815571, -0.0007307571941055357, 0.02309500239789486, 0.060032475739717484, -0.03330361098051071, -0.05677466839551926, 0.0018008565530180931, 0.0116176912561059, 0.026122163981199265, -0.04382801428437233, 0.02908531203866005, 0.03746052458882332, -0.057280246168375015, 0.011992407031357288, 0.005547794513404369, 0.0015590550610795617, 0.04210546240210533, 0.026654142886400223, -0.03544081002473831, 0.007495413068681955, 0.03232088312506676, 0.026215391233563423, 0.008505442179739475, 0.03561004251241684, -0.003746746340766549, -0.0324767529964447, 0.015088330022990704, -0.003991845529526472, -0.06008026376366615, -0.015257059596478939, -0.03171778470277786, 0.04412119835615158, 0.04534922540187836, 0.04215335100889206, 0.009483694098889828, 0.03304697200655937, -0.046269651502370834, -0.05473124235868454, -0.03218169882893562, -0.010720859281718731, 0.017805350944399834, -0.05582733824849129, 0.05361926183104515, -0.009071597829461098, 0.04316556826233864, 0.017988597974181175, 0.02627585455775261, 0.03373893350362778, -0.02522790990769863, -0.044486865401268005, -0.04767564311623573, -0.0024416318628937006, -0.023715652525424957, -0.06629666686058044, 0.04550320282578468, 0.05886928737163544, -0.022183896973729134, 0.023447701707482338, 0.03992031514644623, -0.040050044655799866, 0.003797964658588171, 0.0055786008015275, 0.02256973274052143, -0.06545210629701614, 0.014196743257343769, 0.08288630843162537, -0.03302410989999771, -0.02941090613603592, -0.0128981564193964, -0.03327849879860878, -0.002352733863517642, -0.02905510738492012, 0.0015880543505772948, 0.008784299716353416, 0.007632406894117594, -0.0643780305981636, 0.029178576543927193, -0.014637145213782787, -0.07884442806243896, -0.012260341085493565, -0.021171042695641518, -0.0684233084321022, 0.003272305941209197, 0.032935529947280884, 0.011497840285301208, -0.059804774820804596, 0.040612708777189255, -0.006334538105875254, 0.007743973284959793, -0.032980069518089294, 0.05181357264518738, 0.08040796965360641, 0.012370864860713482, 0.001124091329984367, 0.012807877734303474, -0.044581338763237, 0.018580550327897072, -0.04045013338327408, 0.017711758613586426, 0.035911157727241516, 0.02805563062429428, 0.027477316558361053, -0.03179808706045151, -0.0359063483774662, 0.07644149661064148, -0.03270566463470459, -0.013448867946863174, -0.02559925615787506, -0.0038331139367073774, 0.04875325784087181, 0.024424640461802483, -0.02409452758729458, 0.023457271978259087, -0.016068212687969208, -0.03373575955629349, -0.03415929153561592, 0.010232043452560902, -0.009339703246951103, 0.006835679989308119, -0.007477509323507547, -0.03573334962129593, -0.012104353867471218, -0.02335399016737938, -0.056843679398298264, 0.043730948120355606, -0.030945241451263428, -0.004838890396058559, -0.027979550883173943, -0.0006040610023774207, 0.038834840059280396, 0.00878425408154726, -0.0729658231139183, 0.009597950614988804, -0.015337883494794369, 0.020535046234726906, -0.01277512963861227, 0.017586415633559227, 0.02039284072816372, -0.011614669114351273, 0.02910500019788742, -0.02625505067408085, 0.00698643596842885, -0.04758933559060097, -0.046377506107091904, 0.03184379264712334, -0.007516179233789444, -0.009131485596299171, -0.06440246850252151, 0.0006372247007675469, 0.004496715031564236, 0.01572325825691223, 0.0578649528324604, -0.031057456508278847, -0.07202056050300598, 0.03973217308521271, -0.03393497318029404, -0.006529250647872686, -0.01697107031941414, 0.009341602213680744, 0.02340778335928917, 0.007005027029663324, 0.022697435691952705, 0.03615739569067955, -0.003057061228901148, -0.005609334912151098, -0.06911861151456833, -0.006491561885923147, 0.056590497493743896, 0.0034002719912678003, -0.03430898115038872, -0.036933958530426025, -0.004064504988491535, -0.07486899197101593, 0.0004892302094958723, 0.04788513481616974, -0.03349573537707329, -0.002801094902679324, -0.05076975002884865, -0.018228895962238312, 0.0070416065864264965, -0.06560825556516647, -0.0624995157122612, -0.0007964008837006986, -0.0366629920899868, -0.025531137362122536, -0.023057283833622932, -0.012389345094561577, -0.061263684183359146, -0.007564843632280827, -0.08734168112277985, -0.017520887777209282, -0.027417276054620743, 0.03255695104598999, -0.005449006799608469, -0.022170918062329292, -0.01721307821571827, -0.021610314026474953, 0.01540968008339405, 0.009950174018740654, 0.024927083402872086, -0.012834141962230206, 0.03959102928638458, 0.037149835377931595, -0.05105659365653992, -0.022789480164647102, 0.03809697926044464, -0.010238966904580593, 0.007242782507091761, -0.008430874906480312, 0.0641731396317482, -0.01306050457060337, -0.029791871085762978, 0.01885429210960865, 0.010270074009895325, 0.04116615280508995, -0.03713884577155113, 0.019346753135323524, -0.035480987280607224, -0.06283487379550934, 0.03195192292332649, -0.019386012107133865, 0.0404650941491127, 0.01224780734628439, -0.003623928874731064, 0.005452820565551519, -0.04526858404278755, -0.04145388305187225, 0.06339837610721588, 0.0023966259323060513, -0.012899641878902912, 0.05695958435535431, -0.027988163754343987, 0.011738763190805912, -0.03515645116567612, -0.012715387158095837, -0.04358324408531189, 0.030625082552433014, 0.04391578584909439, -0.04105689004063606, 0.03184472396969795, -0.059638313949108124, 0.040487032383680344, 0.036549162119627, -0.061648912727832794, -0.06511536240577698, 0.07560624927282333, 0.02167687751352787, -0.040595244616270065, 0.0036605317145586014, -0.02677929401397705, -0.032908979803323746, -0.06337326765060425, -0.023726193234324455, -0.015514466911554337, 0.03200162947177887, -0.014380981214344501, 0.04149661958217621, 0.03355082497000694, 0.06511148065328598, -0.0005009153392165899, 0.05067060887813568, 0.006619737483561039, -0.0009914424736052752, -0.00047186794108711183, 0.07494352757930756, -0.008674219250679016, 0.010829775594174862, -0.0398336797952652, -0.010575533844530582, -0.022554898634552956, -0.027105679735541344, 0.033661093562841415, 0.0033335068728774786, -0.030868085101246834, -0.053027406334877014, -0.036798685789108276, 0.05456643924117088, -0.02508976310491562, -0.037940770387649536, -0.006247414741665125, 0.0219414159655571, -0.010955466888844967, -0.05775824934244156 ]
OpenID Connect (OIDC) is a widely used authentication standard for the Web. In this work, we define a new Identity Certification Token (ICT) for OIDC. An ICT can be thought of as a JSON-based, short-lived user certificate for end-to-end user authentication without the need for cumbersome key management. A user can request an ICT from his OpenID Provider (OP) and use it to prove his identity to other users or services that trust the OP. We call this approach $OIDC^2$ and compare it to other well-known end-to-end authentication methods. Unlike certificates, $OIDC^2$ does not require installation and can be easily used on multiple devices, making it more user-friendly. We outline protocols for implementing $OIDC^2$ based on existing standards. We discuss the trust relationship between entities involved in $OIDC^2$, propose a classification of OPs' trust level, and propose authentication with multiple ICTs from different OPs. We explain how different applications such as videoconferencing, instant messaging, and email can benefit from ICTs for end-to-end authentication and recommend validity periods for ICTs. To test $OIDC^2$, we provide a simple extension to existing OIDC server software and evaluate its performance.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16607v2
[ -0.015180010348558426, -0.05930972471833229, 0.05289037898182869, -0.016357682645320892, 0.01248076744377613, -0.014912493526935577, -0.03692147508263588, 0.0069069028832018375, -0.017285000532865524, -0.05212699994444847, -0.019497130066156387, 0.018514597788453102, -0.0494951531291008, -0.04975033551454544, 0.047546565532684326, 0.01530445646494627, 0.08331543207168579, 0.049563080072402954, -0.05569182336330414, 0.012034881860017776, -0.041476521641016006, -0.05219908803701401, -0.030345935374498367, 0.02122977375984192, -0.03309205546975136, -0.03003421425819397, -0.017116200178861618, 0.0010351964738219976, -0.022505002096295357, -0.042462825775146484, 0.07247117161750793, -0.03991106152534485, -0.001315198140218854, -0.00017976817616727203, -0.03760785609483719, -0.032174766063690186, 0.037751954048871994, 0.01502472348511219, -0.04849573224782944, -0.05417066812515259, 0.007684967014938593, -0.07191925495862961, -0.04500100761651993, -0.03720607981085777, 0.005231592338532209, -0.0357176773250103, -0.04015251249074936, -0.009412433952093124, -0.05975722521543503, -0.010841414332389832, 0.02226117253303528, 0.035907622426748276, -0.03967830911278725, 0.03144674375653267, 0.0060562132857739925, -0.016126437112689018, 0.02009051851928234, 0.03534067049622536, -0.04185250774025917, -0.0035695694386959076, -0.009594381786882877, -0.012029665522277355, -0.04678097739815712, -0.013414346612989902, -0.03253063187003136, 0.05683036521077156, -0.009574594907462597, -0.05906878039240837, -0.006001182831823826, -0.033395227044820786, 0.06725933402776718, -0.0536123588681221, 0.0015264705289155245, -0.044993866235017776, -0.023549586534500122, -0.02373514138162136, -0.04337167739868164, -0.03256426379084587, -0.003509816247969866, -0.015436221845448017, -0.014243821613490582, 0.023019058629870415, 0.01880442537367344, 0.02497883513569832, -0.0487273745238781, 0.00803857110440731, 0.009272327646613121, 0.02084781788289547, 0.02478126622736454, -0.06891410052776337, -0.008167920634150505, -0.033945199102163315, -0.07478564232587814, 0.04567740485072136, 0.038280460983514786, -0.034837815910577774, 0.022719357162714005, 0.022637879475951195, -0.033135827630758286, -0.026051167398691177, -0.015149150043725967, -0.01130631472915411, -0.03412221372127533, 0.026298852637410164, 0.031166985630989075, 0.01912437379360199, 0.037783339619636536, 0.016394976526498795, -0.06850577890872955, -0.0038344638887792826, -0.021886460483074188, -0.061314113438129425, 0.0035764859057962894, -0.07855170965194702, -0.03250905126333237, -0.029916631057858467, -0.000828971213195473, -0.013787304982542992, 0.05084282159805298, -0.00837814062833786, -0.00036084663588553667, 0.018832948058843613, 0.05247229337692261, -0.012874061241745949, -0.04745721071958542, 0.0008850875892676413, 0.01754927821457386, -0.009158307686448097, 0.0005988255143165588, -0.010201144963502884, -0.003692332189530134, 0.04228445515036583, 0.0069643184542655945, -0.019011087715625763, 0.05350669473409653, -0.004500259179621935, 0.006180241238325834, 0.00751408189535141, 0.0008883384289219975, -0.023439573124051094, -0.0534568689763546, -0.06448864191770554, -0.06260007619857788, -0.05083738639950752, 0.01881524547934532, 0.03577718511223793, 0.03217526152729988, -0.008540748618543148, 0.035111840814352036, 0.033144738525152206, -0.03927610069513321, 0.00045951566426083446, 0.03258449211716652, 0.011981080286204815, -0.036171697080135345, -0.05058152228593826, 0.023155780509114265, -0.028239741921424866, -0.053708452731370926, 0.03355563059449196, 0.02556869573891163, 0.016669979318976402, 0.0040184264071285725, -0.050001367926597595, 0.0012590833939611912, 0.03857337310910225, 0.025805771350860596, -0.011111102066934109, 0.022999754175543785, 0.048810143023729324, -0.04140622541308403, -0.055212970823049545, 0.03367578238248825, -0.03687184676527977, -0.04922100901603699, -0.01097945123910904, 0.04981740191578865, -0.01105515193194151, -0.06093517318367958, -0.01744021661579609, -0.008726699277758598, 0.04308769479393959, 0.03807523846626282, 0.005480008665472269, -0.05918246507644653, 0.009336037561297417, -0.04024543985724449, -0.020465083420276642, -0.020559992641210556, -0.020092884078621864, -0.018624184653162956, -0.0497342012822628, -0.03281266242265701, -0.026085177436470985, 0.007877699099481106, -0.01978578232228756, -0.01475458312779665, -0.03469868376851082, 0.005770331714302301, 0.03251837193965912, -0.06383305788040161, 0.008313381113111973, -0.008470147848129272, -0.002602809574455023, -0.04642939940094948, -0.04156021773815155, -0.046763770282268524, 0.047709085047245026, -0.06844712048768997, -0.010376309975981712, 0.006970969028770924, 0.00820831023156643, 0.05267507582902908, 0.02839294821023941, 0.06553255021572113, 0.024839729070663452, -0.08693971484899521, 0.04054853692650795, 0.04945235699415207, 0.0350109338760376, 0.0285031758248806, -0.002544269198551774, -0.012445086613297462, -0.004562619142234325, -0.011146260425448418, 0.04158186540007591, -0.0018007667968049645, 0.03272406384348869, -0.056351058185100555, -0.019399084150791168, -0.021863874047994614, -0.03312642499804497, 0.021436627954244614, -0.05006197839975357, 0.02790907956659794, -0.0497809462249279, -0.05836111679673195, 0.00655954098328948, -0.03355054929852486, -0.055048052221536636, -0.012387100607156754, -0.0720217302441597, 0.04205545037984848, 0.020275110378861427, -0.03446939215064049, -0.03413083776831627, -0.020895279943943024, 0.018706966191530228, 0.011259878054261208, -0.0014413963072001934, 0.026413634419441223, -0.061842940747737885, 0.019903266802430153, -0.007889584638178349, 0.05337149277329445, 0.054606981575489044, 0.012312986887991428, 0.01665821298956871, 0.010920216329395771, -0.006734647788107395, 0.014274357818067074, 0.039542924612760544, -0.05915852263569832, 0.03158970922231674, 0.020750867202878, -0.01621527411043644, -0.006187173537909985, -0.03343156725168228, 0.015240774489939213, -0.004165213089436293, 0.010830286890268326, 0.03732914850115776, 0.046119507402181625, -0.049853190779685974, 0.021660124883055687, 0.009028509259223938, 0.03871171548962593, 0.004751873202621937, 0.0490945465862751, 0.01181851141154766, -0.036189403384923935, 0.018521904945373535, 0.03755852207541466, -0.07375652343034744, -0.017768191173672676, -0.031730275601148605, -0.02374032326042652, -0.025861840695142746, -0.01582949236035347, -0.051615819334983826, -0.028786789625883102, 0.020873406901955605, 0.04363545402884483, 0.021598925814032555, -0.04487932473421097, -0.033107925206422806, -0.05418550968170166, -0.036176372319459915, 0.051389843225479126, 0.028281576931476593, -0.056155625730752945, -0.07276127487421036, 0.030176755040884018, 0.007915446534752846, 0.02383449673652649, -0.035967398434877396, -0.043533921241760254, -0.03396539017558098, 0.014907998032867908, -0.011049141176044941, 0.04180586338043213, 0.03670134395360947, -0.01893739029765129, -0.025405053049325943, 0.0393812321126461, -0.032973676919937134, -0.01801363006234169, 0.0326349101960659, -0.008359966799616814, -0.020237531512975693, 0.031168073415756226, -0.041132181882858276, 0.00805723201483488, 0.010779795236885548, -0.057723697274923325, -0.03073245659470558, 0.05021438002586365, 0.03332784026861191, -0.003260534256696701, 0.0009262509411200881, -0.006943447515368462, -0.04291779175400734, 0.0335596427321434, -0.05052667856216431, -0.03710661455988884, -0.020452020689845085, -0.006348419468849897, -0.01731741614639759, 0.020312508568167686, -0.008086273446679115, -0.03400801494717598, -0.026259245350956917, -0.025520797818899155, -0.03960851579904556, 0.03083079122006893, -0.07785071432590485, 0.04182450845837593, 0.05769600719213486, 0.07739358395338058, 0.00841999426484108, -0.007600392214953899, 0.01375407911837101, -0.02025648020207882, 0.039884261786937714, 0.022860385477542877, 0.04910776764154434, -0.0010951650328934193, 0.03709028661251068, -0.033092234283685684, -0.03030441142618656, 0.03500910475850105, -0.01842312328517437, -0.0215951856225729, -0.008652148768305779, -0.04583583027124405, 0.006128544453531504, -0.005908553954213858, -0.026914367452263832, 0.036969639360904694, -0.028034672141075134, 0.05561169981956482, 0.05460067093372345, -0.027041945606470108, -0.025307711213827133, -0.03974439948797226, 0.03791544958949089, 0.027331868186593056, 0.0658896267414093, -0.04205334186553955, -0.03830042481422424, 0.04102225601673126, -0.0685795471072197, 0.03180316835641861, 0.055549848824739456, -0.03543069213628769, 0.007807683665305376, 0.04135223105549812, 0.010077632032334805, 0.05013331025838852, -0.031068306416273117, -0.01121731661260128, -0.042734649032354355, 0.020640943199396133, -0.04727557301521301, -0.01399686373770237, -0.03303436562418938, -0.047071464359760284, 0.014429371803998947, -0.05539276823401451, 0.025718530640006065, 0.020960452035069466, -0.024267494678497314, 0.06968659907579422, -0.07810487598180771, -0.030686885118484497, -0.033280886709690094, 0.014464490115642548, -0.021081149578094482, -0.055125124752521515, 0.05321381241083145, -0.04341820254921913, 0.06855575740337372, -0.05044737458229065, -0.01207867730408907, -0.020435478538274765, -0.028452999889850616, 0.0030015138909220695, -0.03852789103984833, -0.06255289912223816, -0.034200627356767654, -0.006066471803933382, 0.03240422531962395, 0.008143499493598938, -0.056263428181409836, 0.015640810132026672, -0.009838778525590897, -0.03174491599202156, 0.0488356351852417, 0.0259509589523077, 0.02906692400574684, -0.059522468596696854, 0.0027567415963858366, 0.023138126358389854, -0.02233557030558586, 0.022623486816883087, -0.031375400722026825, 0.04725873842835426, -0.00009024955943459645, 0.003258251817896962, 0.023638160899281502, -0.0533905103802681, 0.02724144607782364, -0.009906835854053497, -0.050107259303331375, -0.050574254244565964, -0.03343585133552551, -0.053014546632766724, -0.01361860241740942, -0.03251595050096512, -0.025079617276787758, -0.05908716097474098, -0.03918824717402458, 0.021763557568192482, 0.026707645505666733, -0.023868922144174576, -0.02027920074760914, 0.0649266466498375, 0.055087532848119736, 0.05444679409265518, 0.011136041022837162, -0.010981922969222069, -0.023215023800730705, -0.060504041612148285, 0.04957984760403633, -0.0334564633667469, -0.023880109190940857, -0.020394455641508102, 0.043353043496608734, -0.02663513273000717, 0.0013446874218061566, 0.0030995828565210104, 0.03262465447187424, -0.07762658596038818, 0.038986686617136, -0.008157791569828987, -0.030745331197977066, 0.05255885422229767, 0.007208527531474829, 0.044145841151475906, -0.009585550986230373, 0.0051200613379478455, 0.01824953965842724, 0.05011690780520439, -0.020153500139713287, -0.012838620692491531, -0.04815416410565376, -0.027350954711437225, -0.03269777074456215, 0.03029823862016201, -0.04939247667789459, -0.03666343539953232, -0.005941529292613268, 0.05813034623861313, -0.020388677716255188, 0.00003220023063477129, -0.005550085101276636, 0.0007292965310625732, -0.05254626274108887, 0.0021997601725161076, 0.03127432242035866, 0.04495704919099808, -0.006173133850097656, -0.009495946578681469, 0.0003840207355096936, 0.03129515424370766, 0.054361116141080856, -0.03427964076399803, -0.03591045364737511, 0.037736326456069946, 0.030747713521122932, -0.008569029159843922, -0.036627668887376785, 0.01750427670776844, -0.0024180158507078886, 0.01226029172539711, -0.03498809039592743, -0.013381307013332844, 0.04108540713787079, 0.040666285902261734, 0.04593784362077713, -0.003933947067707777, 0.000007069258572300896, -0.06092344596982002, -0.05337176099419594, -0.04942327365279198, -0.02582952380180359, -0.026975389569997787, -0.0029749537352472544, -0.06549493968486786, 0.0015704380348324776, 0.002856932347640395, -0.024590928107500076, -0.019198957830667496, 0.0426822304725647, -0.03466176241636276, -0.003941026981920004, -0.001988190459087491, -0.06442050635814667, -0.0652177631855011, 0.03574158251285553, 0.030190853402018547, -0.05181329324841499, 0.0018248397391289473, 0.0027887250762432814, -0.04063860699534416, 0.015089579857885838, -0.024126579985022545, 0.015388591215014458, -0.035002730786800385, 0.019645119085907936, 0.05494089052081108, -0.0540657714009285, 0.03390888124704361, -0.02028532512485981, -0.007145009469240904, 0.02373269759118557, 0.0044679963029921055, -0.042414434254169464, 0.05817040428519249, -0.007031375076621771, -0.05959451198577881, 0.052547112107276917, -0.04678691178560257, -0.08303800225257874, -0.014766179956495762, -0.024142837151885033, -0.047045301645994186, 0.024592531844973564, 0.014918806962668896, 0.0015358839882537723, -0.011174500919878483, 0.030790993943810463, 0.01562558300793171, 0.021093418821692467, -0.01118507981300354, 0.0445447638630867, 0.03499588742852211, -0.01693483628332615, -0.028582869097590446, -0.029723219573497772, -0.07215270400047302, -0.03596150502562523, -0.06211455166339874, 0.03744310140609741, 0.05045405030250549, 0.034792907536029816, 0.044957391917705536, -0.020367339253425598, -0.022113002836704254, 0.056181054562330246, -0.05428624153137207, 0.015767155215144157, -0.011719471774995327, -0.061009857803583145, 0.039754316210746765, -0.030263513326644897, -0.021934648975729942, -0.01689799502491951, -0.06751931458711624, -0.0021714475005865097, 0.0024611481931060553, 0.03911426290869713, 0.025647085160017014, 0.0002772144216578454, 0.051843829452991486, -0.028207499533891678, -0.03332255035638809, 0.01331331953406334, -0.06424474716186523, -0.00791040901094675, -0.05345214530825615, 0.019717855378985405, 0.04090487211942673, 0.019804667681455612, 0.020106632262468338, 0.05969829112291336, -0.03774348273873329, -0.03306689113378525, 0.016376057639718056, -0.04640036076307297, -0.04514497518539429, 0.03886890038847923, -0.04442289471626282, -0.0014056937070563436, 0.04321504011750221, -0.015405301004648209, -0.05411974713206291, 0.013010546565055847, -0.036992765963077545, 0.03698432072997093, -0.06209937855601311, -0.018730852752923965, -0.059429433196783066, -0.012658609077334404, -0.06481269001960754, -0.005009246990084648, 0.0105289863422513, -0.07262110710144043, -0.060774266719818115, -0.037760697305202484, -0.06800948828458786, -0.013052270747721195, 0.02721712365746498, -0.019290180876851082, 0.044400013983249664, 0.03570981323719025, 0.07475777715444565, -0.028918908908963203, 0.010224204510450363, -0.018166974186897278, -0.05784584954380989, -0.027240455150604248, 0.021348237991333008, -0.030247798189520836, -0.022718725726008415, -0.014211157336831093, -0.017573360353708267, -0.025120986625552177, -0.010064485482871532, -0.009698940441012383, -0.021243814378976822, -0.029904883354902267, -0.03938503935933113, 0.047816675156354904, -0.014967064373195171, -0.043094635009765625, -0.05385344475507736, 0.005280669312924147, 0.0033399073872715235, -0.04504935070872307, -0.03307431563735008, -0.034329935908317566, -0.05249893292784691, 0.02488549053668976, -0.0749817043542862, -0.022860882803797722, 0.040974169969558716, -0.03817883878946304, 0.02806570939719677, -0.028179451823234558, 0.06459662318229675, -0.035245221108198166, -0.00644906610250473, 0.02499902993440628, 0.017900817096233368, -0.046105992048978806, 0.011136490851640701, 0.030335215851664543, -0.030164729803800583, -0.016504427418112755, 0.01329648308455944, -0.050842300057411194, -0.02237863652408123, 0.03952958434820175, 0.01699097640812397, -0.0005057080998085439, 0.011288299225270748, 0.018347570672631264, -0.036436304450035095, 0.02927272766828537, -0.04986642301082611, 0.05935683846473694, -0.055314235389232635, -0.07523057609796524, -0.023645855486392975, -0.051954057067632675, -0.00796026922762394, -0.008239630609750748, -0.06092209368944168, 0.013477880507707596, -0.05957448482513428, -0.006912406533956528, 0.001874681212939322, -0.03281493857502937, -0.04003198817372322, 0.04970509558916092, -0.0021311314776539803, -0.036707114428281784, -0.014692016877233982, -0.011672941967844963, -0.0172592606395483, 0.016603419557213783, 0.04967069625854492, -0.0406179316341877, -0.016026806086301804, 0.017863621935248375, 0.0039343577809631824, 0.01586626097559929, -0.007422024384140968, -0.02454262599349022, 0.06635136902332306, 0.053047627210617065, -0.013364255428314209, -0.03544212877750397, -0.04597103223204613, -0.022098753601312637, -0.06393158435821533, -0.020358186215162277, -0.049675073474645615, -0.008543943054974079, -0.004367384593933821, 0.0011252968106418848, 0.004989239852875471, -0.003827265463769436, 0.02670818381011486, 0.04074523597955704, 0.050622232258319855, 0.0341964066028595, -0.02487819455564022, 0.033489424735307693, 0.02333093248307705, 0.025171438232064247, -0.07296042144298553, 0.047937389463186264, -0.06208117678761482, 0.042552921921014786, 0.03420804440975189, -0.029827576130628586, -0.008921518921852112, -0.0540972463786602, -0.018073812127113342, 0.061658140271902084, -0.0003504077612888068, -0.02196059376001358, -0.054223451763391495, 0.02739744819700718, -0.06489596515893936, -0.05599386990070343 ]
As consumer adoption of immersive technologies grows, virtual avatars will play a prominent role in the future of social computing. However, as people begin to interact more frequently through virtual avatars, it is important to ensure that the research community has validated tools to evaluate the effects and consequences of such technologies. We present the first iteration of a new, freely available 3D avatar library called the Virtual Avatar Library for Inclusion and Diversity (VALID), which includes 210 fully rigged avatars with a focus on advancing racial diversity and inclusion. We present a detailed process for creating, iterating, and validating avatars of diversity. Through a large online study (n=132) with participants from 33 countries, we provide statistically validated labels for each avatar's perceived race and gender. Through our validation study, we also advance knowledge pertaining to the perception of an avatar's race. In particular, we found that avatars of some races were more accurately identified by participants of the same race.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10902v2
[ 0.011356937699019909, -0.03817438706755638, 0.06929556280374527, 0.012957276776432991, 0.013751020655035973, 0.009361776523292065, 0.03796185180544853, 0.018738938495516777, -0.05291011929512024, -0.05815231800079346, -0.04527343809604645, 0.026048673316836357, -0.002760041505098343, -0.04458269849419594, -0.0366201251745224, 0.020091857761144638, 0.04674283042550087, 0.018492702394723892, -0.062256839126348495, 0.03667765483260155, 0.02733597718179226, 0.014861413277685642, -0.01010280940681696, 0.06925981491804123, 0.008069257251918316, -0.006982936058193445, -0.0028466316871345043, -0.008051303215324879, -0.010100388899445534, -0.03080136328935623, 0.06595689803361893, -0.05991053208708763, 0.015364181250333786, -0.0503462553024292, -0.07188311964273453, -0.00027704020612873137, -0.0438736155629158, 0.030636746436357498, -0.06206696107983589, -0.06937336176633835, 0.01192419696599245, -0.06108202785253525, -0.06695189327001572, -0.014064745977520943, -0.07260026037693024, -0.010970724746584892, -0.03547750040888786, -0.0180075503885746, -0.09298337996006012, -0.02217087894678116, -0.006448009982705116, 0.012695894576609135, 0.0016220618272200227, 0.033087652176618576, 0.05848761647939682, -0.012145789340138435, -0.011472299695014954, 0.06198608875274658, -0.05009045824408531, 0.024133358150720596, -0.03123771771788597, -0.008019611239433289, 0.024102961644530296, 0.01787365972995758, -0.03712575510144234, 0.050346024334430695, -0.027766790241003036, -0.035362374037504196, -0.00816003791987896, -0.06504198908805847, 0.07532017678022385, -0.05973844975233078, 0.01301305741071701, 0.0033192720729857683, -0.06389789283275604, 0.007493188139051199, -0.03476867452263832, -0.011388850398361683, 0.0255964994430542, 0.0350845605134964, -0.02270675264298916, 0.014736475422978401, -0.0005834565381519496, 0.02481061965227127, -0.04041763022542, -0.02470388263463974, 0.012838136404752731, 0.005474023055285215, 0.03174005448818207, -0.035948287695646286, 0.02679966762661934, -0.002513629850000143, -0.07882531732320786, -0.019408728927373886, 0.06955324858427048, 0.015509087592363358, 0.001943244249559939, 0.058805398643016815, -0.01972508430480957, 0.013734068721532822, -0.02626679092645645, 0.009427502751350403, 0.02333911508321762, 0.03460603579878807, 0.04206020385026932, -0.02586398273706436, 0.01577185094356537, -0.028783975169062614, -0.034205012023448944, 0.025931328535079956, 0.00046563593787141144, 0.003535296767950058, 0.009246272034943104, -0.06111523136496544, -0.06733818352222443, -0.0067798360250890255, 0.05322684720158577, -0.018316159024834633, 0.026225382462143898, -0.007983002811670303, -0.00810985080897808, 0.04412701353430748, 0.0517512746155262, -0.008584581315517426, -0.03526321053504944, 0.017022177577018738, 0.016140373423695564, 0.0059317173436284065, -0.03767794743180275, 0.014470932073891163, 0.01699853129684925, -0.004886103328317404, -0.032767247408628464, -0.01790846511721611, 0.05887122079730034, -0.030097389593720436, -0.011564730666577816, -0.0614137202501297, -0.026244111359119415, -0.0329507477581501, -0.02877202443778515, -0.03586724400520325, -0.010922146029770374, -0.02228480391204357, -0.013408947736024857, 0.04178127273917198, 0.022583158686757088, 0.008439800702035427, 0.006388426758348942, 0.019994603469967842, 0.03660190850496292, 0.007693303748965263, 0.029210872948169708, 0.05226759985089302, -0.00046244400436989963, -0.07539293169975281, 0.07231111079454422, -0.02094792202115059, -0.0691378265619278, 0.007120461203157902, -0.044738106429576874, -0.013553600758314133, -0.01214709784835577, -0.05915343761444092, 0.00378188188187778, -0.03655623272061348, 0.03590124845504761, -0.011707310564815998, -0.02013809233903885, -0.04019654169678688, -0.021647606045007706, 0.019111625850200653, -0.008929469622671604, 0.01881447061896324, -0.058743201196193695, 0.011112820357084274, -0.0032076193019747734, -0.05115937814116478, -0.027290377765893936, -0.002081404672935605, 0.002708820626139641, 0.003381007816642523, 0.000028858848963864148, 0.023328512907028198, -0.0062180920504033566, 0.0555080771446228, -0.0621713288128376, -0.036710456013679504, 0.0712219849228859, -0.022998647764325142, -0.04175613448023796, -0.046788137406110764, -0.01645360328257084, 0.00816312711685896, 0.0042003910057246685, -0.01679743267595768, -0.04722316190600395, -0.048337794840335846, 0.03077704645693302, -0.008195849135518074, -0.07595635950565338, -0.01884915679693222, -0.06215765327215195, -0.035138390958309174, -0.0032575444784015417, -0.05455334484577179, 0.0008312014979310334, -0.013437849469482899, -0.03245050832629204, -0.03328558802604675, 0.04335430637001991, 0.036354128271341324, 0.05855366960167885, -0.012505748309195042, 0.039669349789619446, 0.01948404684662819, -0.10583020746707916, 0.03665349259972572, 0.033323727548122406, 0.013866831548511982, 0.0370812863111496, 0.018223701044917107, -0.00682290643453598, 0.004028798080980778, 0.00045654477435164154, 0.040651869028806686, 0.022950420156121254, 0.01812121458351612, -0.06598860770463943, -0.02523290365934372, 0.010135381482541561, -0.05942775309085846, 0.011752680875360966, -0.0710906907916069, 0.02177150920033455, -0.021654866635799408, -0.027127312496304512, 0.04575018584728241, 0.017828278243541718, -0.04139776900410652, -0.006695249583572149, -0.04078952223062515, 0.012428044341504574, 0.006041152402758598, -0.04317115247249603, -0.011120043694972992, 0.019687198102474213, 0.007543519139289856, -0.02547452412545681, 0.002454734407365322, 0.017664378508925438, -0.04608069732785225, -0.013030427508056164, -0.01586519367992878, 0.025305118411779404, 0.01267020683735609, -0.02605993114411831, 0.03762630373239517, -0.007695473730564117, 0.04715782403945923, 0.028743283823132515, 0.045806482434272766, -0.05794228985905647, -0.00884461123496294, 0.06200289726257324, -0.030428174883127213, -0.07120145857334137, -0.03446124494075775, 0.04586324840784073, -0.040586814284324646, 0.0190783329308033, 0.028215868398547173, 0.05222826451063156, -0.020115802064538002, -0.03494719788432121, -0.04127238318324089, 0.004107925575226545, -0.03423124924302101, 0.04244491457939148, 0.05176807940006256, 0.0013469653204083443, 0.03818363696336746, 0.013541263528168201, -0.07499522715806961, 0.0016592293977737427, 0.003400782123208046, -0.02608337812125683, -0.054998837411403656, -0.039749130606651306, -0.018923893570899963, -0.06295137852430344, -0.04948839917778969, -0.04265108332037926, -0.054590847343206406, 0.004496438894420862, -0.07120005041360855, -0.016289668157696724, -0.041314251720905304, 0.052936721593141556, 0.02128024585545063, -0.009827041998505592, -0.05071141570806503, 0.00801762379705906, 0.03499261662364006, -0.017860589548945427, -0.06943336129188538, 0.003023577155545354, -0.052570268511772156, -0.011124754324555397, -0.028769075870513916, 0.01837444119155407, 0.05167616531252861, -0.031970132142305374, 0.005023997277021408, -0.0016775410622358322, -0.00768023869022727, -0.022774571552872658, 0.0011348545085638762, -0.004392020404338837, -0.03272340074181557, 0.023755371570587158, -0.02146662399172783, 0.02972755953669548, -0.0065499660558998585, -0.0736369788646698, 0.006856656167656183, 0.044024549424648285, 0.04565460607409477, -0.0012119845487177372, -0.03845308721065521, -0.013829185627400875, 0.006523452699184418, -0.005257818847894669, -0.02036846987903118, 0.001433845143765211, 0.03631756827235222, -0.007017132360488176, -0.04033496975898743, 0.02233400009572506, 0.00937952846288681, -0.009604187682271004, 0.021976910531520844, -0.06588052213191986, -0.04256291687488556, 0.03623824194073677, -0.0916711837053299, 0.033358532935380936, 0.01906667649745941, 0.0842178538441658, 0.006383540574461222, 0.017956756055355072, 0.031085386872291565, -0.03184670954942703, 0.038094062358140945, 0.007745583541691303, 0.04943622648715973, 0.03800225630402565, 0.045825716108083725, -0.03804042935371399, -0.0427209734916687, 0.002837445819750428, -0.05529782548546791, -0.05687674134969711, 0.008075319230556488, 0.0668250024318695, 0.07325096428394318, 0.046582188457250595, -0.04567433148622513, 0.006734042428433895, -0.022796276956796646, 0.059322942048311234, 0.0008708051755093038, -0.02685108780860901, 0.011686907149851322, -0.04855700954794884, 0.05663589760661125, 0.0467708483338356, 0.0262585636228323, -0.010227088816463947, -0.03634066879749298, -0.00528663769364357, -0.05334220081567764, 0.030182035639882088, 0.02127291075885296, -0.017933811992406845, 0.0171506367623806, 0.020102379843592644, 0.038197074085474014, 0.03080897033214569, -0.026323651894927025, -0.018423428758978844, 0.005512986797839403, -0.01408323273062706, -0.02281184121966362, -0.024531599134206772, -0.041236087679862976, 0.0162612646818161, 0.010523902252316475, -0.049171850085258484, 0.01912393793463707, -0.025652259588241577, -0.004188512451946735, -0.006775210611522198, -0.07343760132789612, 0.019356876611709595, -0.0024404311552643776, 0.03949345275759697, 0.0027929386124014854, -0.03908487781882286, 0.036468755453825, -0.0413193516433239, 0.01777942292392254, -0.005277776625007391, 0.017178429290652275, -0.0203141737729311, -0.014792807400226593, 0.06108705699443817, -0.06152145192027092, -0.015656977891921997, -0.03775728493928909, 0.049762677401304245, 0.025765402242541313, 0.03146236017346382, -0.05027734860777855, -0.03571449965238571, -0.0383366160094738, 0.019178641960024834, 0.052097201347351074, 0.05875459685921669, -0.006652796175330877, -0.04424264281988144, 0.0632803738117218, 0.022651948034763336, 0.03313709422945976, 0.016064541414380074, -0.020329998806118965, 0.04369020089507103, -0.014741102233529091, -0.013338941149413586, -0.019598068669438362, -0.04706789180636406, 0.027101974934339523, -0.029380975291132927, -0.05021153762936592, 0.003039711620658636, 0.023385368287563324, -0.03157918155193329, -0.06130366772413254, -0.04417355731129646, -0.028560349717736244, -0.032011136412620544, 0.000610848655924201, -0.003669114550575614, 0.04599401354789734, -0.03118542581796646, -0.020409096032381058, 0.03787951171398163, 0.03191840648651123, -0.009957737289369106, 0.03514247015118599, 0.020792871713638306, -0.05024661868810654, -0.01851818338036537, -0.03459591045975685, -0.05453532189130783, 0.0007937383488751948, -0.0015936099225655198, 0.019410962238907814, -0.004634111188352108, 0.04619336873292923, -0.0010311141377314925, 0.05272650718688965, -0.08920097351074219, 0.04112140089273453, 0.09229692071676254, 0.009715219028294086, 0.028542768210172653, 0.049768559634685516, -0.004857588559389114, 0.010190845467150211, -0.05832412466406822, 0.03600476309657097, 0.018745239824056625, -0.03290573135018349, -0.027619974687695503, 0.014522000215947628, -0.012106148526072502, -0.007350597996264696, 0.03420640528202057, -0.015736041590571404, -0.07868745923042297, -0.008050785399973392, 0.05949867144227028, -0.008417423814535141, -0.019381191581487656, 0.004706889390945435, 0.010696850717067719, -0.014210243709385395, 0.017863908782601357, 0.011587216518819332, -0.02793820947408676, -0.029403263702988625, 0.0367637500166893, 0.005194471683353186, -0.006159951910376549, 0.059793226420879364, -0.055081501603126526, -0.013449376448988914, -0.012048340402543545, -0.012051587924361229, 0.02518410235643387, -0.0037266567815095186, -0.023634959012269974, 0.001065660617314279, -0.040343835949897766, -0.04667406529188156, 0.06838184595108032, 0.06017725169658661, 0.04384159669280052, 0.049029313027858734, 0.028544044122099876, -0.026725320145487785, -0.0482659712433815, -0.003442567540332675, -0.011215976439416409, 0.007613287772983313, -0.03385569900274277, 0.07427684962749481, -0.051102690398693085, 0.014099723659455776, -0.01612287387251854, 0.038791973143815994, -0.00036181570612825453, 0.04929709434509277, -0.02754596434533596, -0.011098826304078102, -0.002997597446665168, 0.007344619836658239, -0.02929006889462471, -0.016938693821430206, 0.05065057799220085, -0.028148408979177475, 0.00878691766411066, 0.015907449647784233, -0.013526366092264652, -0.015479999594390392, 0.02591998316347599, 0.01080105360597372, -0.059163544327020645, -0.025810806080698967, 0.054459892213344574, -0.0389118529856205, 0.0356111042201519, 0.011981436982750893, -0.015009859576821327, 0.008965559303760529, -0.0390777550637722, -0.014176365919411182, 0.04765119403600693, 0.012336960062384605, -0.04272563010454178, 0.04741552844643593, -0.018193954601883888, -0.056033894419670105, 0.05331186577677727, -0.04943963885307312, -0.0874548852443695, 0.03003208339214325, -0.01413524616509676, 0.04499053582549095, -0.027707943692803383, 0.04928432032465935, -0.02456461824476719, 0.002546458039432764, -0.04794938489794731, 0.07831276208162308, 0.086147241294384, -0.04337448626756668, -0.02896185964345932, 0.03493707627058029, -0.07018127292394638, -0.013999618589878082, -0.012013062834739685, 0.023384181782603264, 0.02409576252102852, 0.037197086960077286, 0.016517670825123787, -0.03667362779378891, -0.01044262945652008, 0.06398674845695496, -0.04473447799682617, 0.010129696689546108, 0.02793007902801037, -0.06328815966844559, 0.05088455229997635, 0.000957525975536555, -0.05357061326503754, 0.04284588247537613, -0.03385999798774719, 0.02580150030553341, -0.05241899937391281, -0.0038382799830287695, -0.015276063233613968, 0.029231317341327667, 0.011438429355621338, -0.05464678630232811, -0.020796259865164757, -0.04552005976438522, -0.06982137262821198, 0.04825376719236374, -0.06056893616914749, 0.01880934275686741, -0.0012915941188111901, 0.019023306667804718, 0.057628825306892395, 0.04118833318352699, -0.03753313422203064, 0.000855179678183049, 0.034022603183984756, -0.04159111902117729, 0.03370479494333267, 0.018174340948462486, -0.0034802190493792295, -0.0022749342024326324, -0.007718298584222794, -0.032692961394786835, -0.03234279155731201, -0.00975117925554514, -0.01990717649459839, 0.0223478265106678, -0.02534816414117813, -0.031885016709566116, -0.07594304531812668, 0.02459677681326866, 0.004145794548094273, 0.0018910671351477504, 0.036914367228746414, -0.018257534131407738, -0.05709870904684067, -0.03877473622560501, -0.03184658661484718, -0.0033927198965102434, -0.007313441019505262, 0.04318588227033615, 0.06562662869691849, 0.023649754002690315, 0.049679335206747055, 0.007770761847496033, -0.022564083337783813, 0.013202005997300148, -0.06358358263969421, 0.0015334251802414656, 0.0008678284357301891, -0.052811041474342346, -0.035344187170267105, 0.011015867814421654, 0.004719199612736702, -0.06656727939844131, 0.0030969695653766394, 0.015873000025749207, -0.03175067901611328, -0.03268830478191376, -0.04335206747055054, -0.0038320927415043116, 0.018500063568353653, -0.035454850643873215, -0.05827218294143677, 0.016131684184074402, 0.005328252445906401, -0.052578166127204895, -0.019780617207288742, -0.007480568252503872, -0.05137135088443756, 0.014636590145528316, -0.08942166715860367, 0.0066398861818015575, 0.0328986756503582, 0.008596887812018394, -0.05159759894013405, -0.06685137003660202, -0.0017355079762637615, -0.05463870242238045, 0.04379890859127045, -0.0058506811037659645, 0.011611190624535084, 0.004832488019019365, 0.03837519511580467, 0.024810606613755226, -0.03970364108681679, -0.009097320958971977, -0.004607419017702341, -0.05461018159985542, 0.0006337317754514515, -0.007855046540498734, 0.029625650495290756, -0.013258709572255611, -0.0030414953362196684, 0.044725436717271805, -0.03294280916452408, 0.026501521468162537, -0.06542253494262695, 0.03691983222961426, -0.039100438356399536, -0.01739891991019249, 0.03893580660223961, -0.0029845633544027805, -0.02609727531671524, 0.025501854717731476, -0.03871409595012665, -0.027348307892680168, -0.01701074279844761, -0.02023792639374733, 0.02026018500328064, -0.0315333753824234, 0.02136256918311119, 0.053002603352069855, -0.026456350460648537, -0.030132770538330078, -0.029270339757204056, -0.02485845796763897, -0.03622771054506302, 0.0071099624037742615, 0.04436516389250755, -0.038652148097753525, -0.003741178195923567, -0.03901541605591774, -0.043990910053253174, -0.017977481707930565, -0.0044185565784573555, -0.003079210175201297, 0.07232183963060379, 0.00841321237385273, -0.03363543748855591, -0.03486195206642151, -0.02823680266737938, 0.01577639766037464, -0.04300572723150253, -0.04536959156394005, 0.009859762154519558, 0.015104137361049652, -0.022623520344495773, -0.012516814284026623, 0.01801915653049946, 0.025123389437794685, -0.021018167957663536, 0.021765856072306633, 0.03931500017642975, 0.038143590092659, -0.02598331682384014, 0.04374169185757637, -0.018394654616713524, 0.03796067088842392, -0.014151076786220074, 0.024929193779826164, 0.011953495442867279, -0.010062026791274548, 0.0435279943048954, -0.001572498818859458, -0.013386023230850697, -0.08094878494739532, 0.004767865873873234, 0.03969346359372139, -0.004772589076310396, -0.05759591981768608, -0.030861888080835342, 0.02602921612560749, -0.06100276857614517, -0.06419817358255386 ]
We propose a Dynamical System (DS) approach to learn complex, possibly periodic motion plans from kinesthetic demonstrations using Neural Ordinary Differential Equations (NODE). To ensure reactivity and robustness to disturbances, we propose a novel approach that selects a target point at each time step for the robot to follow, by combining tools from control theory and the target trajectory generated by the learned NODE. A correction term to the NODE model is computed online by solving a quadratic program that guarantees stability and safety using control Lyapunov functions and control barrier functions, respectively. Our approach outperforms baseline DS learning techniques on the LASA handwriting dataset and complex periodic trajectories. It is also validated on the Franka Emika robot arm to produce stable motions for wiping and stirring tasks that do not have a single attractor, while being robust to perturbations and safe around humans and obstacles.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00186v3
[ -0.031017137691378593, -0.01081752497702837, 0.057004187256097794, 0.02676386944949627, 0.010331761091947556, -0.010353639721870422, 0.020160527899861336, 0.012080131098628044, 0.001093351049348712, -0.02251536399126053, -0.04900820553302765, -0.028848586603999138, -0.07118956744670868, -0.061650726944208145, -0.03369574993848801, 0.023875979706645012, 0.05762043595314026, -0.014740404672920704, -0.040101826190948486, 0.03273969143629074, 0.00380971422418952, -0.04273466020822525, -0.017393125221133232, 0.02384287305176258, -0.012282966636121273, -0.050145119428634644, 0.006240240763872862, 0.04055510461330414, -0.04790663719177246, -0.01652158983051777, 0.07712886482477188, -0.003402408678084612, 0.009189646691083908, -0.04782623052597046, -0.03842021897435188, -0.024227745831012726, -0.024693278595805168, 0.03526626154780388, 0.05467413365840912, 0.0013842781772837043, 0.02630213089287281, -0.03736516088247299, -0.06620335578918457, 0.01114871259778738, -0.010192924179136753, -0.006914481520652771, -0.0177913811057806, 0.01302189938724041, -0.04289133846759796, -0.06261257082223892, 0.002756955334916711, -0.012226361781358719, 0.03980519622564316, 0.04936878755688667, -0.04848584160208702, 0.04867151007056236, 0.007116539869457483, 0.04136921092867851, -0.04549262300133705, -0.029580937698483467, 0.0351933017373085, -0.012718811631202698, 0.005449136719107628, 0.02056983672082424, 0.04078569635748863, 0.05482296273112297, 0.013311628252267838, -0.04182510823011398, -0.05484727397561073, -0.03890817612409592, 0.017641399055719376, -0.06667044013738632, 0.026410218328237534, -0.0024143222253769636, -0.022384649142622948, -0.0385110080242157, -0.028639130294322968, -0.03074265643954277, 0.018339866772294044, -0.010067026130855083, -0.008120864629745483, -0.016178404912352562, 0.05295783281326294, 0.05913150683045387, 0.034485239535570145, -0.03472023829817772, 0.03213762119412422, -0.03234129026532173, 0.04555153474211693, -0.0414092130959034, 0.030292673036456108, -0.03805912286043167, -0.07810015976428986, -0.025655491277575493, 0.05720018595457077, -0.021416308358311653, 0.0653565302491188, 0.05043065547943115, 0.0133775370195508, -0.046586330980062485, -0.04419989511370659, -0.007752411067485809, -0.014858169481158257, 0.03997798636555672, 0.045891836285591125, -0.029429567977786064, -0.0072753895074129105, -0.028967930004000664, -0.054884687066078186, 0.009683460928499699, -0.002623039297759533, -0.026608578860759735, 0.009801547974348068, -0.029038896784186363, -0.03804602473974228, -0.02904236689209938, 0.029201768338680267, -0.031038980931043625, 0.026856932789087296, 0.00776580348610878, -0.06185556575655937, 0.03630737215280533, -0.005244760308414698, 0.017259668558835983, -0.0006409302004612982, -0.018549880012869835, 0.0880439281463623, -0.0010777765419334173, -0.014700713567435741, -0.009295464493334293, 0.02880880795419216, 0.034503694623708725, -0.011611146852374077, -0.0675174742937088, 0.03674165531992912, -0.027940884232521057, -0.03499922528862953, -0.07199375331401825, 0.0422949492931366, 0.01231278944760561, -0.053418077528476715, -0.015830151736736298, 0.027850989252328873, -0.008330125361680984, -0.0246711615473032, 0.05139109492301941, -0.0658421665430069, 0.01043615397065878, 0.03979745879769325, 0.052278053015470505, 0.02154725417494774, -0.012813367880880833, 0.015230901539325714, 0.04151391610503197, 0.02122526988387108, -0.03279680386185646, 0.027299532666802406, -0.027014819905161858, -0.07258368283510208, 0.008098206482827663, 0.05223032832145691, -0.03642607480287552, 0.04428401589393616, -0.029415855184197426, 0.015112693421542645, 0.05438365414738655, 0.046980369836091995, -0.017630059272050858, 0.0032219691202044487, 0.0005771038704551756, -0.03519246354699135, -0.017422443255782127, -0.01155785284936428, -0.02549033798277378, -0.07256704568862915, -0.03835592418909073, -0.00505521334707737, -0.057845037430524826, -0.03998177498579025, 0.01464233547449112, 0.002719171578064561, 0.01600274257361889, 0.015958374366164207, 0.06096791476011276, -0.05288795381784439, 0.0008409805595874786, -0.07950644940137863, -0.027497705072164536, 0.03360455855727196, 0.04319876804947853, -0.048120155930519104, -0.05610770732164383, 0.01609753631055355, 0.02650313824415207, -0.040769897401332855, -0.02708488330245018, -0.06236870214343071, -0.028763657435774803, 0.02819463051855564, 0.021009938791394234, -0.07834216207265854, 0.005659580230712891, -0.05930504947900772, 0.013948566280305386, -0.013026086613535881, -0.049002692103385925, 0.0021243866067379713, 0.04791337996721268, -0.05585288256406784, 0.024443170055747032, 0.020903203636407852, 0.03203129768371582, 0.05855921283364296, 0.024411289021372795, 0.05408404394984245, 0.015139728784561157, -0.1047494113445282, 0.04782785847783089, 0.04161882773041725, 0.018824517726898193, 0.051183655858039856, -0.035912834107875824, 0.013376540504395962, -0.029870785772800446, -0.05193415656685829, 0.02943386137485504, 0.033737704157829285, -0.03657769411802292, -0.061279021203517914, -0.029686961323022842, -0.0019620521925389767, -0.07862106710672379, -0.03460961952805519, -0.06728407740592957, -0.04057156667113304, -0.022088315337896347, -0.03882671520113945, 0.03012869693338871, -0.017605721950531006, -0.0313146747648716, -0.009648994542658329, -0.0480317696928978, 0.045172736048698425, -0.06275889277458191, -0.038950104266405106, -0.024795057252049446, -0.04521036520600319, 0.017040157690644264, -0.03942270204424858, 0.0032792999409139156, -0.008496791124343872, -0.021483469754457474, -0.0005007212166674435, -0.041289541870355606, 0.017196174710989, 0.0745861679315567, -0.023123005405068398, 0.01909908466041088, -0.010287441313266754, 0.053899094462394714, 0.02425951138138771, 0.03901732340455055, -0.05881914123892784, -0.00855643767863512, -0.009566131047904491, 0.031093895435333252, 0.011630993336439133, -0.0383494608104229, -0.010453931987285614, -0.04356857389211655, 0.002495005028322339, -0.027051061391830444, 0.03977910429239273, 0.004241582937538624, -0.022226104512810707, 0.030966952443122864, 0.0029939922969788313, -0.024637993425130844, 0.024716274812817574, 0.024206172674894333, -0.004491201136261225, 0.019463330507278442, 0.02356971614062786, -0.062215108424425125, -0.053371258080005646, -0.04030260071158409, -0.006915273144841194, -0.07068108767271042, -0.039474084973335266, -0.030405940487980843, -0.06929053366184235, -0.012363019399344921, -0.04335711896419525, -0.013794698752462864, -0.04562665522098541, -0.04384252429008484, -0.036067817360162735, 0.02943098358809948, 0.004098040517419577, -0.030727175995707512, -0.06687094271183014, -0.015428470447659492, 0.002413602080196142, 0.02856118232011795, -0.03560514375567436, -0.06787914782762527, -0.01819567382335663, -0.004919337574392557, -0.00019007436640094966, 0.028254298493266106, -0.020634109154343605, 0.05004672333598137, -0.004844282288104296, 0.022087857127189636, 0.020075667649507523, 0.030643925070762634, -0.0018633767031133175, 0.01774386502802372, -0.019273601472377777, -0.00839217845350504, 0.027881760150194168, -0.001422438770532608, 0.019630426540970802, 0.010678712278604507, -0.06661290675401688, -0.028878740966320038, 0.06280026584863663, 0.03997844457626343, 0.007701503578573465, -0.02036857046186924, 0.015296059660613537, -0.017840730026364326, 0.010196593590080738, -0.02288985066115856, 0.06818409264087677, -0.021510139107704163, 0.011097398586571217, -0.0041212965734303, -0.031166430562734604, 0.012759161181747913, -0.061507392674684525, 0.029981300234794617, -0.004570340272039175, -0.0037096587475389242, 0.03132056072354317, -0.0790180042386055, 0.034876443445682526, 0.018409505486488342, 0.030824752524495125, -0.001844514161348343, 0.062398627400398254, 0.01605277881026268, 0.05637023597955704, 0.019774049520492554, -0.00004656917735701427, 0.03984382748603821, 0.05763521417975426, 0.06311986595392227, -0.015425180085003376, -0.015971502289175987, 0.03175528347492218, -0.08612004667520523, -0.019474629312753677, -0.015010536648333073, 0.02170856110751629, -0.00067580008180812, 0.02509286440908909, -0.08049251139163971, 0.020926760509610176, -0.01709636300802231, 0.030399248003959656, 0.026093263179063797, 0.004371588584035635, 0.04696481674909592, -0.008634732104837894, -0.012020517140626907, -0.021921532228589058, 0.053837668150663376, 0.0008618237334303558, -0.02917124517261982, 0.031013572588562965, -0.03126535564661026, 0.021784337237477303, -0.0278552807867527, -0.014665418304502964, 0.0030830595642328262, 0.040267325937747955, -0.052647169679403305, 0.042572177946567535, -0.009321789257228374, -0.007682126481086016, 0.015975499525666237, -0.0028696812223643064, -0.05947642773389816, -0.02819928713142872, -0.06030910089612007, -0.0029310088139027357, -0.009294352494180202, -0.022328833118081093, 0.00040290411561727524, 0.003157255006954074, 0.006422659382224083, -0.021611029282212257, -0.08552306145429611, 0.005378787871450186, -0.033667948096990585, -0.0042581213638186455, -0.04966522753238678, -0.03364301472902298, 0.0677085667848587, -0.02372928149998188, -0.008478563278913498, -0.017607226967811584, -0.03511577472090721, 0.00319068250246346, -0.038366470485925674, -0.025839241221547127, -0.0742303878068924, 0.007518394384533167, -0.010055734775960445, 0.06526705622673035, -0.028668444603681564, 0.042709410190582275, -0.06295602768659592, 0.018372386693954468, -0.016613705083727837, 0.0392836332321167, 0.06430161744356155, 0.04597419872879982, 0.04863107576966286, -0.011772088706493378, 0.010434863157570362, 0.032684583216905594, 0.01052858680486679, -0.0001776652061380446, 0.000697570969350636, 0.03223887458443642, -0.03832171857357025, -0.028369029983878136, 0.0018506033811718225, -0.000186278106411919, 0.06730915606021881, 0.016098525375127792, -0.02825266681611538, -0.0033730994910001755, 0.03137446939945221, -0.047983359545469284, -0.06684796512126923, -0.01057844702154398, -0.06078583747148514, -0.05124718323349953, 0.009482677094638348, 0.015114862471818924, 0.04493561387062073, -0.0010190248722210526, 0.04402772709727287, 0.016651269048452377, 0.0022015536669641733, -0.02261136844754219, 0.000690885994117707, 0.03476441279053688, 0.02401532232761383, 0.004006309900432825, 0.027926597744226456, -0.09543130546808243, 0.010128173045814037, -0.045120514929294586, 0.0016491225687786937, -0.017834626138210297, 0.07041165232658386, 0.020101476460695267, 0.06607231497764587, -0.09000608325004578, 0.014020162634551525, 0.007662568707019091, -0.043564315885305405, 0.018963191658258438, 0.0373159684240818, -0.01987585984170437, 0.02644389308989048, -0.04625924304127693, -0.034009743481874466, 0.04134535789489746, -0.05258215218782425, -0.004114137496799231, 0.027797531336545944, -0.03300737217068672, -0.005114963743835688, 0.047343384474515915, -0.0027876771055161953, -0.03654616326093674, -0.02761971391737461, -0.0015589536633342505, 0.015445990487933159, -0.060361165553331375, 0.035525131970644, 0.056075770407915115, -0.023334117606282234, -0.014739773236215115, 0.005040089134126902, 0.00955747626721859, -0.011468909680843353, 0.00011481913679745048, -0.02488924190402031, 0.01850472204387188, 0.0323028527200222, -0.022590259090065956, -0.015282406471669674, 0.01268748752772808, 0.02226179651916027, 0.02648613043129444, -0.02788817323744297, 0.028824718669056892, -0.07046952843666077, -0.049731723964214325, -0.01614510640501976, 0.01056814193725586, 0.035810697823762894, 0.03253532573580742, 0.040591124445199966, 0.022095290943980217, 0.015080957673490047, -0.010087138041853905, 0.022703206166625023, -0.04977046325802803, 0.03998144343495369, -0.04702942445874214, 0.012563865631818771, 0.009549637325108051, 0.027094503864645958, -0.03841746225953102, 0.004869505763053894, 0.02777528204023838, -0.03785862401127815, -0.03133636340498924, -0.040467485785484314, 0.028117163106799126, -0.05627952516078949, -0.06668912619352341, 0.015630271285772324, 0.0139771094545722, -0.0015541849425062537, 0.03756394237279892, 0.013764186762273312, 0.017623253166675568, 0.04586739465594292, 0.0063933138735592365, 0.006360645405948162, -0.026384778320789337, 0.024539558216929436, 0.07885134965181351, -0.04128105565905571, -0.01881958730518818, 0.003058452857658267, -0.033479925245046616, -0.038372110575437546, -0.03468179702758789, 0.006133888848125935, -0.013205260969698429, -0.006612665951251984, -0.07104498893022537, 0.059346918016672134, -0.008379354141652584, -0.057982731610536575, -0.009165304712951183, 0.02106414921581745, -0.07494156062602997, 0.014699568971991539, 0.000940502155572176, -0.020408304408192635, -0.05168486014008522, 0.05787460505962372, 0.033575259149074554, -0.0022605732083320618, -0.001676643849350512, 0.05529563128948212, 0.07444716989994049, 0.03361832723021507, -0.007844573818147182, -0.014533719047904015, -0.04315859079360962, 0.06082310155034065, -0.06252863258123398, 0.017728878185153008, -0.0005668795784004033, 0.045167554169893265, -0.0009508417570032179, -0.03692598268389702, -0.044539906084537506, 0.05493775010108948, -0.058768514543771744, -0.04060085117816925, 0.020906459540128708, -0.02932334691286087, 0.0646810233592987, -0.008763293735682964, -0.03150184452533722, 0.0006230564904399216, -0.027944495901465416, 0.008203862234950066, -0.016942299902439117, -0.003380862297490239, 0.00901124905794859, -0.04462281987071037, 0.02216673083603382, -0.04025859385728836, 0.01670370250940323, -0.0366477370262146, -0.06939326971769333, 0.006913715973496437, -0.07103724777698517, -0.0016701992135494947, -0.012561817653477192, -0.01541894767433405, 0.03915588557720184, 0.021521292626857758, -0.035840362310409546, 0.036929886788129807, -0.011412994004786015, 0.022461870685219765, 0.0307519119232893, 0.029953395947813988, 0.0027713351882994175, 0.01949102245271206, 0.0597737580537796, -0.025116490200161934, 0.017338218167424202, -0.0356968455016613, -0.04345139488577843, 0.01144410576671362, -0.023537226021289825, -0.02883913181722164, -0.007002843543887138, -0.021845171228051186, -0.01849030703306198, 0.0250861756503582, 0.005354141816496849, -0.07315617799758911, -0.027328532189130783, 0.03596760705113411, 0.015673168003559113, 0.018019450828433037, -0.0355973057448864, -0.0033463253639638424, -0.010823726654052734, 0.009929072111845016, 0.03817855566740036, 0.05004061013460159, 0.01037573255598545, -0.019333042204380035, -0.07161252945661545, -0.02244831807911396, -0.0007728663622401655, 0.004145913291722536, -0.044365040957927704, -0.013104964978992939, -0.0161245446652174, -0.08367396146059036, 0.00418091518804431, 0.04063475504517555, 0.014502784237265587, -0.031861480325460434, -0.08275668323040009, 0.056595560163259506, -0.031055185943841934, -0.017983391880989075, -0.010386420413851738, 0.015922201797366142, 0.020238788798451424, -0.03734534978866577, 0.012276260182261467, -0.000868038390763104, -0.060779374092817307, 0.001617269474081695, -0.08334021270275116, -0.0033050398342311382, -0.005201361607760191, 0.026829084381461143, 0.03299715369939804, -0.01396074891090393, 0.028700634837150574, -0.07202719151973724, -0.021763069555163383, 0.030790889635682106, 0.03518298268318176, 0.0029611943755298853, 0.04929622262716293, 0.012222900986671448, -0.06292305141687393, -0.04908299446105957, 0.043682731688022614, 0.030982762575149536, -0.012181984260678291, 0.06922533363103867, 0.03632950410246849, 0.011321534402668476, -0.018946008756756783, -0.010453629307448864, -0.024107551202178, 0.01871286891400814, -0.039733730256557465, 0.04321739077568054, -0.026307998225092888, -0.06485942751169205, -0.009084704332053661, -0.03094777837395668, 0.007108701858669519, -0.020983371883630753, -0.01393836922943592, 0.00454282620921731, -0.02460343763232231, -0.04938823729753494, 0.04396314546465874, -0.01258790772408247, 0.03217680752277374, 0.0591302216053009, -0.054689183831214905, 0.005714308004826307, -0.014309993013739586, -0.027877138927578926, -0.03961322829127312, 0.018667541444301605, 0.04000624269247055, -0.015653321519494057, -0.0180780328810215, -0.05505074933171272, 0.014521399512887001, 0.005817288998514414, 0.008701961487531662, -0.06841637939214706, 0.0676826760172844, -0.008673198521137238, -0.03516702353954315, -0.030225152149796486, -0.03554356098175049, -0.055394209921360016, -0.0017599776620045304, 0.0008155694231390953, -0.06146867200732231, 0.02523977868258953, -0.024837853386998177, 0.043599002063274384, 0.0423208549618721, 0.0781697928905487, 0.05327155068516731, 0.03319738805294037, -0.0038124409038573503, 0.02170233242213726, -0.023142443969845772, 0.03272002935409546, 0.012259246781468391, -0.014684891328215599, -0.05836925283074379, -0.0012162253260612488, 0.0008910907199606299, 0.026630282402038574, -0.025901643559336662, -0.008530587889254093, -0.016634764149785042, -0.041167110204696655, -0.00859714113175869, -0.013235901482403278, 0.015355643816292286, -0.04321170225739479, 0.0032604066655039787, 0.002892435295507312, -0.00971167627722025, -0.04908650368452072 ]
Forecasting motion and spatial positions of objects is of fundamental importance, especially in safety-critical settings such as autonomous driving. In this work, we address the issue by forecasting two different modalities that carry complementary information, namely optical flow and depth. To this end we propose FLODCAST a flow and depth forecasting model that leverages a multitask recurrent architecture, trained to jointly forecast both modalities at once. We stress the importance of training using flows and depth maps together, demonstrating that both tasks improve when the model is informed of the other modality. We train the proposed model to also perform predictions for several timesteps in the future. This provides better supervision and leads to more precise predictions, retaining the capability of the model to yield outputs autoregressively for any future time horizon. We test our model on the challenging Cityscapes dataset, obtaining state of the art results for both flow and depth forecasting. Thanks to the high quality of the generated flows, we also report benefits on the downstream task of segmentation forecasting, injecting our predictions in a flow-based mask-warping framework.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20593v1
[ -0.035635530948638916, -0.030922887846827507, 0.021305492147803307, 0.011059035547077656, 0.0032290273811668158, 0.043713945895433426, -0.004040718078613281, 0.001971480203792453, 0.03409338742494583, -0.012888272292912006, -0.05809802561998367, 0.019463615491986275, -0.022831633687019348, -0.06396803259849548, -0.007362444885075092, 0.006399714387953281, 0.07164029777050018, -0.030365444719791412, -0.04892133176326752, 0.06467834115028381, 0.004423873033374548, -0.004080403130501509, -0.035767436027526855, 0.029012924060225487, 0.001258142408914864, -0.012592542916536331, -0.04122432693839073, -0.005372737068682909, -0.061054982244968414, 0.0020339598413556814, 0.067704938352108, -0.013907046057283878, -0.05061106011271477, -0.05359034240245819, -0.01612236723303795, -0.0026836118195205927, -0.029894595965743065, 0.05392371118068695, 0.038805726915597916, -0.02644001692533493, 0.06429513543844223, -0.06936477869749069, -0.046968769282102585, 0.001954954583197832, -0.040367450565099716, 0.008827105164527893, -0.017782585695385933, 0.041150860488414764, -0.07720023393630981, -0.010636262595653534, 0.02520051784813404, 0.0016516497125849128, -0.004950719885528088, 0.04805361106991768, -0.01215450931340456, -0.016970695927739143, 0.0039051210042089224, 0.018822675570845604, -0.035220734775066376, 0.030702657997608185, 0.029140181839466095, -0.008942640386521816, -0.017673229798674583, -0.009980309754610062, 0.04619771987199783, 0.06736071407794952, 0.0035993156488984823, -0.046884048730134964, -0.02559882029891014, -0.04832359775900841, 0.030237285420298576, -0.06130761653184891, -0.015256636776030064, 0.021803444251418114, -0.039831385016441345, 0.018315935507416725, -0.017164792865514755, 0.004632130730897188, -0.016770320013165474, 0.008943762630224228, -0.010920468717813492, -0.019471189007163048, 0.03528773412108421, 0.07272244989871979, -0.002383207669481635, -0.007259969599545002, 0.023987744003534317, 0.018740113824605942, 0.03365200012922287, -0.036998994648456573, 0.02063719369471073, -0.056644123047590256, -0.07902570813894272, 0.007165738381445408, 0.04104465991258621, -0.0263727605342865, 0.07000843435525894, 0.026384558528661728, 0.03124031238257885, -0.0380217619240284, -0.06726769357919693, 0.0009983681375160813, -0.022886883467435837, 0.035578060895204544, 0.0534813329577446, -0.0523003451526165, 0.0410875529050827, 0.021087048575282097, -0.004230014979839325, -0.0269717238843441, -0.02742665261030197, -0.018981901928782463, 0.006168473046272993, -0.03439312055706978, -0.039482101798057556, -0.03355798497796059, 0.037874314934015274, 0.0010754406685009599, 0.04760923981666565, 0.03533245250582695, -0.0291450098156929, 0.011095918715000153, 0.05783596262335777, -0.025242244824767113, -0.009863351471722126, -0.01814226619899273, 0.05925705283880234, 0.031435687094926834, 0.030730748549103737, -0.013138072565197945, -0.0027227296959608793, 0.006096854340285063, -0.0318739153444767, -0.04120102524757385, 0.06655322015285492, -0.009392807260155678, 0.026981284841895103, -0.036186762154102325, 0.003829838940873742, 0.010396060533821583, -0.03300369530916214, -0.0807923674583435, 0.015221284702420235, 0.0054393308237195015, 0.004460579250007868, 0.042741987854242325, -0.030138935893774033, 0.00234943232499063, 0.018146665766835213, 0.035075027495622635, 0.02044769562780857, -0.026193179190158844, 0.04687796160578728, 0.038903746753931046, 0.012550967745482922, -0.03445924445986748, 0.05458872765302658, -0.04422103613615036, -0.05817773938179016, 0.03147558495402336, 0.012983966618776321, -0.03518776223063469, 0.03255407512187958, -0.011328132823109627, 0.019041724503040314, 0.011039385572075844, 0.039147794246673584, -0.0054821232333779335, -0.0216778963804245, 0.011226712726056576, 0.0015421630814671516, -0.002474711276590824, -0.03547503054141998, -0.019308455288410187, -0.06411413103342056, -0.0163042601197958, -0.003034499939531088, -0.054969221353530884, -0.046657364815473557, -0.027298390865325928, -0.0009105892386287451, -0.017329875379800797, -0.049646951258182526, 0.019878370687365532, -0.02357250638306141, 0.019278207793831825, -0.08364537358283997, -0.022687243297696114, -0.0037606193218380213, 0.016658039763569832, -0.045809634029865265, -0.03531103581190109, -0.009898962453007698, 0.016738221049308777, -0.05841582641005516, -0.03244662284851074, 0.0008073628996498883, -0.025798212736845016, 0.01718856394290924, 0.01900574378669262, -0.07811126857995987, -0.02671394683420658, -0.061391718685626984, 0.00912107340991497, 0.00782222580164671, -0.06346627324819565, -0.025084692984819412, 0.032407812774181366, -0.06777407974004745, 0.0036069038324058056, 0.03990156576037407, 0.026925330981612206, 0.06124533340334892, 0.017522789537906647, -0.011716443113982677, 0.007016055751591921, -0.10139446705579758, 0.01969441957771778, 0.0012299709487706423, 0.021547121927142143, 0.03952383995056152, 0.0418250672519207, -0.014828034676611423, -0.04272628203034401, -0.010884545743465424, 0.059012964367866516, 0.07734286040067673, -0.02572968602180481, -0.07517433911561966, -0.012051830068230629, -0.05073060840368271, -0.06727273017168045, -0.016456443816423416, -0.05118091031908989, -0.06440508365631104, -0.02888782136142254, -0.02891538292169571, 0.05376727133989334, 0.004435416776686907, -0.0006602805224247277, 0.004762482363730669, -0.03251174837350845, 0.054457761347293854, -0.030432622879743576, -0.032794591039419174, 0.01280641183257103, -0.024462368339300156, 0.028691837564110756, 0.008462103083729744, -0.0321609303355217, -0.03312399238348007, -0.04371488839387894, -0.04263146221637726, -0.008277744986116886, 0.012120927684009075, 0.06317971646785736, -0.029532119631767273, 0.01719105802476406, -0.02756975032389164, 0.05336933210492134, -0.027596410363912582, 0.01086333580315113, -0.05689699575304985, 0.05021955817937851, 0.02304045855998993, 0.01816854439675808, -0.012090909294784069, -0.04451770335435867, 0.008161621168255806, -0.03317913040518761, 0.013186650350689888, -0.008909415453672409, 0.05745674669742584, 0.007907947525382042, 0.016713280230760574, -0.014539734460413456, -0.026106096804142, -0.012338654138147831, 0.024524936452507973, 0.0462920255959034, 0.044338714331388474, 0.00413872953504324, -0.005768674425780773, -0.04005409777164459, 0.030427947640419006, -0.044396139681339264, -0.00009845518798101693, -0.059585247188806534, -0.02306513674557209, -0.04661145806312561, -0.0696559026837349, -0.01412537507712841, 0.006760620512068272, -0.051629457622766495, -0.02086086943745613, -0.06780043244361877, -0.0022175961639732122, -0.001860935939475894, 0.050097376108169556, 0.030840743333101273, -0.03853735700249672, -0.01455423329025507, 0.042538516223430634, 0.04599205031991005, -0.000048310859710909426, -0.05866587907075882, -0.07231353223323822, -0.027785036712884903, 0.0036623405758291483, -0.05791480094194412, -0.05052659660577774, 0.0369853600859642, 0.020305223762989044, 0.0415155254304409, 0.021510381251573563, 0.035538818687200546, -0.005393083207309246, 0.009296000003814697, -0.031554512679576874, -0.017472771927714348, 0.04439800605177879, 0.01717256009578705, 0.024394793435931206, -0.008028942160308361, -0.06773916631937027, -0.03837607800960541, 0.03576809540390968, 0.0029416661709547043, -0.015161341056227684, -0.04598397761583328, -0.005587381310760975, 0.00853611622005701, 0.007662671618163586, 0.02907533198595047, 0.04289587587118149, 0.01992112770676613, -0.020684104412794113, -0.06496603786945343, -0.01775597780942917, -0.0049950662069022655, 0.002087116939947009, 0.00649683503434062, -0.05671798065304756, 0.0021555975545197725, 0.03576100990176201, -0.0918276384472847, 0.025899089872837067, 0.06171826273202896, 0.07115506380796432, 0.03244008496403694, 0.04374224320054054, -0.03538410738110542, 0.032738763839006424, 0.0010310175130143762, 0.04068973660469055, 0.014998644590377808, 0.0397709384560585, 0.04042385146021843, -0.023061303421854973, -0.056693773716688156, -0.012886150740087032, -0.07534162700176239, -0.04684416577219963, 0.013877207413315773, 0.027012668550014496, 0.0026444271206855774, 0.059347447007894516, -0.0656062662601471, 0.008061212487518787, -0.012843189761042595, 0.04798407107591629, 0.0056592500768601894, -0.014136641286313534, 0.03093978762626648, -0.07441536337137222, 0.016268234699964523, 0.029495468363165855, -0.0016711109783500433, 0.032723575830459595, -0.053071748465299606, -0.005189455579966307, -0.035080913454294205, 0.05731762945652008, -0.004302192945033312, 0.018059827387332916, 0.023060379549860954, 0.05677718296647072, 0.008237858302891254, 0.0418020635843277, -0.029403751716017723, -0.05133870616555214, 0.004818595014512539, 0.023521555587649345, -0.009708372876048088, 0.005798427853733301, -0.039596378803253174, -0.036854811012744904, 0.006490359082818031, -0.027723275125026703, -0.012858167290687561, -0.030677758157253265, -0.01475598942488432, -0.009513205848634243, -0.07794172316789627, 0.019797945395112038, -0.024900101125240326, 0.03477640450000763, 0.00005540244092117064, -0.009956109337508678, 0.07212511450052261, -0.033913809806108475, -0.012800745666027069, -0.01560119166970253, -0.02858046069741249, -0.022332262247800827, -0.04867764189839363, -0.02861727587878704, -0.059291522949934006, 0.0561600923538208, -0.0632215142250061, 0.04846282675862312, 0.014129365794360638, 0.041578881442546844, 0.00203657615929842, -0.04593556746840477, -0.012010937556624413, 0.0401141531765461, 0.04865991324186325, -0.017755018547177315, -0.040637437254190445, 0.023282146081328392, -0.02195923961699009, 0.03953247144818306, 0.025969315320253372, -0.008980046957731247, -0.027282021939754486, 0.05121016502380371, -0.03366997092962265, 0.016687089577317238, 0.018546076491475105, -0.00854781549423933, 0.051853857934474945, -0.02206709235906601, -0.05112273991107941, -0.013272002339363098, 0.0340668186545372, -0.05829233303666115, -0.04724971577525139, -0.014309937134385109, -0.03909233585000038, -0.02465846762061119, -0.0035820279736071825, 0.055254340171813965, 0.017937486991286278, -0.02351054735481739, 0.0026653835084289312, 0.0031299125403165817, 0.021682286635041237, -0.027759822085499763, 0.0058092339895665646, 0.028220199048519135, 0.0023448332212865353, -0.02847890742123127, -0.044360142201185226, -0.07406394183635712, -0.007046753540635109, -0.00915520079433918, -0.0356619693338871, -0.0379079133272171, 0.04042516648769379, 0.04474056884646416, 0.06420591473579407, -0.0896545872092247, 0.02111569046974182, 0.03391924872994423, -0.03636014834046364, 0.020962923765182495, 0.04146912321448326, -0.0074471295811235905, 0.04170198366045952, -0.01642586477100849, -0.0075479657389223576, 0.047156356275081635, -0.0512554831802845, -0.021374916657805443, 0.04288201034069061, 0.008018529042601585, -0.0068366434425115585, 0.04488584026694298, -0.00879002921283245, -0.055867839604616165, 0.0028840729501098394, -0.007167153526097536, 0.018869929015636444, -0.055115748196840286, 0.005266943480819464, 0.026037249714136124, -0.027335332706570625, -0.01678754948079586, -0.001349416677840054, 0.005640738643705845, -0.02120484970510006, 0.01779310591518879, -0.03284792974591255, 0.006001509726047516, 0.046442992985248566, -0.02949998527765274, 0.01004539243876934, 0.03287385404109955, 0.018257692456245422, -0.04029611498117447, 0.004060237668454647, 0.041746824979782104, -0.05878150090575218, -0.034864842891693115, 0.003139259060844779, 0.005426280666142702, 0.0697793960571289, 0.06107591837644577, 0.032212838530540466, 0.02382882870733738, -0.016411928460001945, 0.005080371163785458, 0.025570139288902283, 0.017574656754732132, 0.025016045197844505, -0.06933954358100891, 0.005101422313600779, 0.0224342942237854, 0.026933539658784866, -0.015428232029080391, 0.04676875099539757, 0.035222891718149185, -0.03158232197165489, -0.014239120297133923, -0.04295598715543747, 0.01425450574606657, -0.03972313925623894, -0.05139337107539177, 0.0225853119045496, 0.052235979586839676, -0.030421311035752296, 0.024171220138669014, -0.005621661897748709, -0.03314360976219177, 0.03781457245349884, -0.044051703065633774, 0.010357142426073551, -0.04469696804881096, -0.030967004597187042, 0.07871118932962418, -0.05599978566169739, 0.020556561648845673, 0.018036559224128723, -0.027666060253977776, -0.027696160599589348, -0.038190413266420364, 0.03630884364247322, 0.0256852637976408, -0.00019076777971349657, -0.06148846074938774, 0.057539306581020355, -0.014354569837450981, -0.06368640810251236, 0.02102397009730339, 0.017751596868038177, -0.046727586537599564, -0.003668638877570629, 0.033980708569288254, 0.0034659362863749266, -0.026905016973614693, 0.049417607486248016, 0.02260729856789112, 0.0012906354386359453, -0.05839007720351219, 0.04406898468732834, 0.07926248759031296, 0.004493508487939835, -0.014952405355870724, -0.0206169243901968, -0.045184239745140076, 0.06768941134214401, -0.03237893432378769, 0.015416034497320652, 0.009804879315197468, 0.028578748926520348, 0.03067087195813656, -0.01940792240202427, 0.012533745728433132, 0.07745232433080673, -0.055534880608320236, -0.017490489408373833, 0.020981160923838615, 0.005223922897130251, 0.06324660032987595, -0.005645819939672947, -0.03336931765079498, -0.01004016026854515, -0.004030361771583557, 0.00011047397856600583, -0.05002269893884659, -0.003139037173241377, 0.009077832102775574, -0.01656048558652401, 0.03275616466999054, -0.06265740841627121, 0.044960908591747284, -0.05749204754829407, -0.0704844668507576, 0.03186197578907013, -0.07625441253185272, 0.006753144785761833, -0.018134908750653267, 0.01939520426094532, 0.05177074670791626, 0.03475843742489815, -0.0796251967549324, -0.05056118965148926, 0.006681852508336306, 0.01089114136993885, 0.004819572437554598, 0.02091965265572071, 0.03359750285744667, -0.007286679930984974, 0.04756765440106392, -0.043890465050935745, -0.003170526120811701, -0.03190105780959129, -0.01792931742966175, 0.023815637454390526, 0.006944500841200352, -0.07570779323577881, -0.0030822972767055035, -0.0028157634660601616, -0.047463804483413696, 0.003476616693660617, 0.02001091279089451, -0.07288122922182083, -0.0707973912358284, 0.012708129361271858, -0.015606924891471863, 0.02280344069004059, -0.012076680548489094, 0.02694970928132534, 0.05513112619519234, -0.04755097255110741, 0.017208276316523552, 0.0435042530298233, -0.03894055634737015, 0.0025033531710505486, -0.04796074330806732, -0.02577485516667366, -0.007842902094125748, 0.013552902266383171, -0.04308522492647171, -0.02904617413878441, -0.04031471535563469, -0.06547842919826508, 0.01368095725774765, 0.05385672301054001, -0.01542449276894331, -0.01759158819913864, -0.07013880461454391, -0.01972447894513607, -0.011363978497684002, -0.04735054820775986, -0.05291595682501793, 0.029232380911707878, 0.02866232767701149, -0.006347588263452053, -0.019628049805760384, 0.01560450904071331, -0.04839421436190605, -0.015718974173069, -0.0787748396396637, -0.008383115753531456, 0.010611328296363354, 0.017124556005001068, 0.026703910902142525, -0.041438259184360504, 0.018094900995492935, -0.05548129230737686, -0.036575205624103546, 0.013765308074653149, 0.019978776574134827, -0.019042393192648888, 0.04497646912932396, 0.010274910368025303, -0.06576076149940491, -0.04359909147024155, 0.04886355623602867, 0.031289033591747284, -0.008267506957054138, 0.045176513493061066, 0.02188202179968357, 0.01488189771771431, -0.001923264004290104, 0.045101433992385864, -0.01611527055501938, 0.0033717388287186623, -0.0522729754447937, 0.06295544654130936, -0.0033992272801697254, -0.047768641263246536, 0.009280798025429249, -0.01815909519791603, 0.021564777940511703, -0.026868373155593872, 0.006105986889451742, 0.006371695082634687, -0.0370771624147892, -0.05742122232913971, 0.015356316231191158, -0.030865740031003952, 0.01500620786100626, 0.0626278817653656, -0.049630749970674515, 0.028848377987742424, 0.0095346225425601, -0.0014906086726114154, -0.042625684291124344, 0.03050578199326992, 0.023881617933511734, -0.04565952345728874, -0.02065853215754032, -0.0713622197508812, 0.0012365905568003654, -0.015001149848103523, -0.02977697178721428, -0.059752121567726135, 0.06766070425510406, -0.004678699187934399, -0.021144350990653038, -0.00839651096612215, 0.02084522880613804, -0.03613196313381195, -0.05489083379507065, -0.0493270568549633, -0.014814388006925583, 0.044336047023534775, -0.02356535941362381, 0.0023918021470308304, 0.011315974406898022, 0.037471648305654526, 0.021594466641545296, 0.03313127160072327, -0.00816431362181902, 0.01151279080659151, -0.0454866848886013, 0.04851289466023445, -0.013081485405564308, -0.028485141694545746, -0.003929257858544588, 0.007716022897511721, -0.017084142193198204, -0.04810509830713272, -0.03792324662208557, -0.0065103499218821526, 0.007283114828169346, -0.06873609125614166, 0.016608569771051407, 0.03864792361855507, -0.014646699652075768, -0.05478362366557121, -0.017253775149583817, 0.02030661702156067, -0.0468006506562233, -0.04581434279680252 ]
Many real-time applications (e.g., Augmented/Virtual Reality, cognitive assistance) rely on Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) to process inference tasks. Edge computing is considered a key infrastructure to deploy such applications, as moving computation close to the data sources enables us to meet stringent latency and throughput requirements. However, the constrained nature of edge networks poses several additional challenges to the management of inference workloads: edge clusters can not provide unlimited processing power to DNN models, and often a trade-off between network and processing time should be considered when it comes to end-to-end delay requirements. In this paper, we focus on the problem of scheduling inference queries on DNN models in edge networks at short timescales (i.e., few milliseconds). By means of simulations, we analyze several policies in the realistic network settings and workloads of a large ISP, highlighting the need for a dynamic scheduling policy that can adapt to network conditions and workloads. We therefore design ASET, a Reinforcement Learning based scheduling algorithm able to adapt its decisions according to the system conditions. Our results show that ASET effectively provides the best performance compared to static policies when scheduling over a distributed pool of edge resources.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13618v1
[ -0.030449362471699715, -0.037770938128232956, 0.07475510239601135, 0.02501390315592289, -0.041964080184698105, -0.018789909780025482, 0.022305216640233994, -0.01393802184611559, 0.0013395455898717046, -0.05563139542937279, -0.017238663509488106, -0.007371111772954464, -0.03612080588936806, -0.03082238882780075, -0.03265731409192085, -0.0010471796849742532, 0.06588844954967499, 0.006192210596054792, -0.04181291535496712, 0.04415901377797127, -0.00459251319989562, -0.016700342297554016, -0.03824034333229065, 0.007188616320490837, 0.013351982459425926, -0.026095552369952202, -0.033271364867687225, 0.0240533035248518, -0.028136154636740685, -0.008773435838520527, 0.04601043462753296, -0.026007337495684624, -0.0383647195994854, -0.016191240400075912, -0.03434038907289505, -0.042185310274362564, -0.027724985033273697, 0.045030929148197174, 0.030260413885116577, -0.024416595697402954, 0.040183670818805695, -0.02953680045902729, -0.05535942688584328, -0.04548919200897217, -0.029874863103032112, 0.012976441532373428, -0.018831707537174225, 0.015032939612865448, -0.045402731746435165, -0.015401039272546768, 0.059198327362537384, -0.0014339868212118745, 0.014559580944478512, 0.021653298288583755, -0.03614640608429909, 0.027465274557471275, -0.03937651216983795, 0.0006384249427355826, -0.05167558044195175, -0.052607204765081406, -0.0014640181325376034, -0.040294285863637924, 0.01242877822369337, -0.03511440008878708, -0.0036652637645602226, 0.06784992665052414, 0.002328848000615835, -0.064411960542202, -0.022608842700719833, -0.031018147245049477, 0.04080352559685707, -0.03103976882994175, 0.010888504795730114, -0.03334210440516472, -0.035036228597164154, 0.00872120913118124, -0.014635995961725712, -0.00926271453499794, 0.028325753286480904, 0.02048397623002529, -0.0247319545596838, -0.008616938255727291, 0.040693484246730804, 0.050089843571186066, -0.013365601189434528, -0.04458608478307724, 0.05230684205889702, 0.03895438089966774, 0.024374837055802345, -0.03543302044272423, 0.03863804042339325, -0.05809345841407776, -0.06793290376663208, -0.0007778314175084233, 0.059387482702732086, -0.018885381519794464, 0.01747088134288788, 0.039970435202121735, -0.014275389723479748, -0.027842141687870026, -0.052950527518987656, -0.01228679995983839, -0.04136138781905174, 0.06146898865699768, 0.022625243291258812, -0.026677126064896584, -0.01476494874805212, -0.005377048626542091, -0.06033797562122345, -0.006442741956561804, -0.023845715448260307, -0.04948262497782707, 0.0009600314660929143, -0.07391953468322754, -0.034100793302059174, -0.016599517315626144, 0.06101148575544357, 0.020433146506547928, 0.009003364481031895, -0.008964034728705883, -0.04771140590310097, 0.025888454169034958, 0.028227973729372025, -0.03717392310500145, -0.04635787755250931, -0.011324111372232437, 0.07612841576337814, 0.010835563763976097, 0.03147343918681145, -0.01076418161392212, -0.0546007864177227, 0.044922489672899246, -0.0072570135816931725, -0.030030017718672752, 0.0731402337551117, -0.011011585593223572, -0.027879338711500168, -0.052148908376693726, 0.010081425309181213, -0.0010125843109562993, -0.05013301223516464, -0.052289992570877075, -0.018745314329862595, -0.03539678826928139, 0.03085504099726677, 0.04861705005168915, -0.026575826108455658, -0.04660450294613838, 0.018959738314151764, 0.03493058308959007, -0.010535037145018578, -0.0012991107068955898, 0.028828511014580727, -0.0039046916645020247, 0.033925291150808334, -0.006891732104122639, 0.04774516075849533, -0.04812086001038551, -0.059776026755571365, -0.0066865975968539715, 0.055714815855026245, -0.05175201594829559, -0.043322376906871796, -0.04995753616094589, -0.016037380322813988, 0.02513517439365387, 0.013966220431029797, -0.03068087436258793, 0.022230787202715874, 0.025599638000130653, -0.016540855169296265, -0.03252271190285683, 0.04021196812391281, -0.02958296611905098, -0.05436763912439346, -0.047174714505672455, 0.029795560985803604, -0.03535884618759155, -0.03207690268754959, -0.017063040286302567, -0.0018322552787140012, 0.05076685920357704, -0.05239947885274887, 0.023959796875715256, -0.04695284366607666, -0.017024438828229904, -0.07714216411113739, 0.006052006036043167, 0.01602708362042904, 0.00653779087588191, -0.030343858525156975, -0.0487329326570034, 0.02094503492116928, 0.035178042948246, -0.025225043296813965, -0.04070153832435608, 0.010710707865655422, -0.009293637238442898, -0.011530467309057713, 0.02171243168413639, -0.07819382101297379, -0.012670831754803658, -0.035378310829401016, -0.003013037610799074, -0.04346981272101402, -0.0536324605345726, 0.03084188513457775, 0.01943705417215824, -0.014568837359547615, 0.002478687558323145, 0.03975605219602585, 0.04151665419340134, 0.055208802223205566, 0.04487663879990578, 0.046208299696445465, 0.017795268446207047, -0.09252174198627472, 0.03156204894185066, 0.03275744244456291, -0.005234583280980587, -0.006595499813556671, -0.015127797611057758, -0.021874377503991127, -0.0058985608629882336, 0.036919254809617996, 0.050726860761642456, 0.020763326436281204, 0.004523564130067825, -0.07169471681118011, 0.009349474683403969, -0.03464004024863243, -0.06054389476776123, -0.024002984166145325, -0.0792769119143486, -0.017385415732860565, 0.02038385719060898, -0.058465734124183655, 0.03867163881659508, -0.049144819378852844, -0.0074807871133089066, -0.019436975941061974, -0.04492538794875145, 0.021627172827720642, -0.014173505827784538, -0.05918819084763527, -0.038255076855421066, -0.015205682255327702, 0.0027473175432533026, 0.0007271140348166227, -0.04155159741640091, -0.056623317301273346, -0.03720877319574356, -0.04796325042843819, -0.001842103898525238, 0.03490457683801651, 0.04009801894426346, -0.020965898409485817, 0.037336528301239014, 0.006049538962543011, 0.05567969009280205, 0.029759051278233528, 0.029261332005262375, -0.05286827310919762, 0.026210453361272812, 0.025472750887274742, -0.006379286292940378, -0.013155894353985786, 0.010911357589066029, 0.016433829441666603, -0.06467462331056595, 0.01618584804236889, 0.03163442760705948, 0.008532687090337276, 0.002569010015577078, 0.016178105026483536, -0.042666684836149216, 0.00916993711143732, -0.01235946360975504, 0.008823386393487453, 0.06574138253927231, 0.021358834579586983, 0.017723726108670235, 0.03161267936229706, -0.06730680167675018, -0.008794068358838558, -0.06510167568922043, 0.01644285023212433, -0.05552158132195473, -0.03880658745765686, -0.07148629426956177, -0.06943655759096146, -0.023210709914565086, -0.0029812222346663475, -0.05356838181614876, -0.004671176429837942, -0.008184144273400307, -0.0040459297597408295, -0.025564957410097122, 0.022338107228279114, -0.023810777813196182, -0.024495156481862068, -0.05140433833003044, 0.04446009173989296, 0.04441370815038681, 0.03785796836018562, -0.061700522899627686, -0.014345638453960419, 0.007584400940686464, 0.021379519253969193, 0.04336641728878021, -0.014101584441959858, 0.0012798099778592587, -0.038862429559230804, 0.02999117597937584, 0.012547723017632961, 0.04574112594127655, -0.02298925444483757, 0.016118457540869713, -0.03941035270690918, -0.0118489945307374, 0.015528913587331772, 0.010486256331205368, 0.020554743707180023, -0.046752288937568665, -0.060964133590459824, -0.03639310225844383, 0.059155017137527466, -0.010905705392360687, -0.016981162130832672, -0.015363497659564018, 0.04726690798997879, 0.0407903753221035, -0.009057769551873207, 0.037074267864227295, 0.046950485557317734, 0.05118480324745178, -0.020212730392813683, 0.015304245054721832, 0.017320463433861732, 0.0295870304107666, -0.021857213228940964, -0.009393862448632717, -0.049614641815423965, -0.010197166353464127, 0.05757375434041023, -0.0846751257777214, 0.005730230361223221, 0.024811837822198868, 0.05788556486368179, -0.03922787681221962, 0.005405588541179895, 0.009412136860191822, 0.010780042968690395, 0.029317688196897507, -0.00823428388684988, -0.020402422174811363, 0.04306509345769882, 0.06273381412029266, -0.02823224663734436, -0.018875012174248695, -0.009278172627091408, -0.06311925500631332, -0.019932933151721954, 0.02906705066561699, -0.007922428660094738, 0.032587211579084396, -0.005165050271898508, -0.05157884955406189, 0.019985873252153397, -0.03361649438738823, 0.06509262323379517, 0.020452003926038742, -0.012019434943795204, 0.04043761268258095, -0.05964761599898338, -0.0127789918333292, -0.006913086865097284, 0.02674824185669422, 0.0357544869184494, -0.030208805575966835, 0.03936563804745674, -0.07385009527206421, 0.02285485714673996, -0.02998202294111252, -0.04295463487505913, 0.0007190959877334535, 0.02488168515264988, -0.03418835997581482, 0.05428322032094002, -0.02245323732495308, -0.003970262128859758, -0.003998782951384783, 0.011238861829042435, -0.018164608627557755, 0.020033102482557297, -0.07401105761528015, 0.0029503058176487684, 0.037246085703372955, -0.011907456442713737, 0.023350216448307037, 0.029418647289276123, -0.020532049238681793, 0.005942928604781628, -0.07694413512945175, 0.02303294464945793, -0.042971864342689514, 0.038817502558231354, -0.03131544217467308, 0.006189520470798016, 0.06989902257919312, -0.011531268246471882, -0.006587418727576733, -0.0449250154197216, -0.03382600098848343, 0.004756579175591469, -0.011689504608511925, -0.0019164023688063025, -0.046136125922203064, 0.012313762679696083, -0.04133441299200058, 0.046709951013326645, 0.019243119284510612, 0.039917923510074615, -0.05799402669072151, -0.05145680904388428, 0.011522763408720493, 0.037531424313783646, 0.06137744337320328, 0.023197278380393982, -0.036471039056777954, 0.012241498567163944, 0.019551226869225502, -0.012566747143864632, 0.030541706830263138, -0.0022261885460466146, -0.016648726537823677, 0.011926570907235146, -0.029983343556523323, -0.03898795321583748, 0.005851175170391798, -0.0027352571487426758, 0.0646108090877533, -0.025947799906134605, -0.010223022662103176, 0.009167284704744816, 0.04217085242271423, -0.05061342194676399, -0.06224031373858452, -0.021849490702152252, -0.05570101737976074, -0.07221713662147522, -0.06832850724458694, 0.03101244755089283, 0.01601342111825943, -0.0008741762139834464, 0.01924477145075798, 0.021158741787075996, 0.04392325133085251, 0.011122344061732292, 0.023671938106417656, -0.006136517506092787, -0.026660200208425522, 0.0008778757182881236, 0.02265014499425888, -0.07336808741092682, -0.002533086109906435, 0.0008967725443653762, -0.024593224748969078, -0.03664267063140869, 0.015632497146725655, 0.006026326213032007, 0.04257940873503685, -0.0726919174194336, 0.039436981081962585, 0.03403331711888313, 0.0010425446089357138, 0.04480569809675217, 0.013455411419272423, -0.006313030142337084, 0.01952912099659443, -0.04831349104642868, 0.011455236934125423, 0.04895450919866562, -0.06433109939098358, 0.03022092953324318, 0.02985372208058834, -0.04741973802447319, 0.020280126482248306, 0.047369688749313354, -0.007368171121925116, -0.04882185906171799, 0.03403045982122421, 0.03397762030363083, 0.026924695819616318, -0.024258367717266083, 0.005870359018445015, 0.01300510298460722, -0.012672586366534233, -0.009347283281385899, -0.03383157402276993, 0.03886794298887253, -0.012863676995038986, -0.01592397317290306, -0.022660600021481514, -0.0526515357196331, 0.0396442748606205, -0.002903539454564452, 0.03432886675000191, -0.004030356649309397, 0.04446164518594742, -0.017605267465114594, -0.0341264083981514, -0.010813145898282528, -0.05933739244937897, 0.004619672428816557, -0.02835245057940483, 0.009371211752295494, 0.01876215822994709, 0.034183111041784286, -0.02511533722281456, 0.023444101214408875, -0.04956834390759468, -0.050300221890211105, -0.024317629635334015, -0.030388113111257553, 0.02339893765747547, -0.03903590887784958, 0.05482625961303711, -0.02167888917028904, 0.055709484964609146, 0.024403175339102745, 0.011042971163988113, 0.012485436163842678, -0.027635913342237473, 0.010011734440922737, -0.030301934108138084, 0.034718144685029984, -0.0614221952855587, -0.0553627572953701, 0.027136046439409256, 0.042183104902505875, -0.04717661440372467, 0.06980161368846893, 0.021504923701286316, 0.0026570709887892008, 0.047439660876989365, -0.02376873977482319, -0.048829786479473114, -0.02794034592807293, 0.06821688264608383, 0.06762023270130157, -0.06158136576414108, 0.00952216237783432, -0.028886185958981514, -0.016482317820191383, 0.04600803181529045, 0.0028212578035891056, -0.012545126490294933, -0.0076812575571238995, -0.02143840491771698, -0.05108284205198288, 0.05977736786007881, -0.04062866047024727, -0.08141089975833893, -0.006087081041187048, 0.02491673454642296, -0.0766325443983078, 0.05629922077059746, 0.03489241376519203, 0.01606886088848114, -0.06874660402536392, 0.05205072462558746, 0.017665604129433632, 0.012135111726820469, -0.046997640281915665, 0.05478349328041077, 0.07240927219390869, 0.00024500806466676295, -0.0039437622763216496, -0.005921295378357172, -0.04871729761362076, 0.02541751228272915, -0.02146892622113228, 0.014302309602499008, -0.0039192186668515205, 0.027118684723973274, -0.04749712720513344, -0.03789613023400307, -0.035434380173683167, 0.059761445969343185, -0.03367544338107109, -0.04552503675222397, 0.009836060926318169, -0.01680825464427471, 0.028113722801208496, -0.0359296053647995, -0.05175801366567612, 0.0029516853392124176, -0.020864052698016167, -0.028644319623708725, -0.031816430389881134, 0.029606306925415993, -0.017674645408988, -0.005265721119940281, -0.016748245805501938, -0.05447261780500412, 0.029415249824523926, -0.039346788078546524, -0.06425794214010239, 0.04578004777431488, -0.06437969952821732, -0.061677299439907074, -0.020792217925190926, -0.025975409895181656, 0.011100739240646362, 0.04880484938621521, -0.06465297937393188, -0.01028207503259182, -0.01622861810028553, 0.009447593241930008, -0.006330979522317648, -0.044383298605680466, -0.004192512948065996, -0.0499996617436409, 0.03132247552275658, -0.03993569314479828, -0.06256181746721268, -0.03667575120925903, -0.010131391696631908, -0.004349591676145792, 0.006014394108206034, -0.01204344816505909, -0.038901232182979584, -0.003504346590489149, -0.024462541565299034, 0.008364608511328697, 0.034380871802568436, -0.06022043898701668, -0.08300449699163437, -0.002116393530741334, -0.021419404074549675, 0.0050516859628260136, 0.011453024111688137, 0.035511843860149384, 0.004865696188062429, -0.04851309210062027, 0.005533269140869379, 0.007223920430988073, 0.02662688121199608, 0.015852726995944977, -0.04791751876473427, -0.02198287844657898, 0.012386560440063477, -0.02700827084481716, -0.050719551742076874, -0.0466911755502224, 0.035844914615154266, -0.0681399405002594, -0.04420916736125946, 0.06893961876630783, 0.0027306380216032267, -0.03741418570280075, -0.07047883421182632, -0.01024741493165493, -0.037025243043899536, -0.03760366514325142, -0.041190147399902344, -0.005575783085078001, 0.020186197012662888, -0.025205638259649277, 0.0239810012280941, -0.0018370768520981073, -0.02583560161292553, 0.006739223841577768, -0.08005072921514511, -0.04171529412269592, -0.018069854006171227, 0.06324556469917297, 0.02129841037094593, 0.013499167747795582, -0.03165702894330025, -0.03602159023284912, 0.006723690312355757, 0.00681442953646183, 0.029445292428135872, 0.007377388421446085, 0.06141054257750511, 0.0066286842338740826, -0.052954401820898056, -0.04302201420068741, 0.027709558606147766, -0.021483825519680977, 0.011443075723946095, 0.051133379340171814, 0.03738468885421753, 0.04872287064790726, 0.001657809829339385, 0.055015675723552704, -0.03962885960936546, 0.040697816759347916, -0.039121050387620926, 0.018780380487442017, -0.03939429298043251, -0.05744795501232147, 0.027772219851613045, -0.05948732793331146, -0.006410753354430199, 0.002543260110542178, 0.008784552104771137, -0.001675575622357428, -0.0191218052059412, -0.06144839897751808, 0.024356383830308914, 0.016885027289390564, -0.0009790422627702355, 0.044608939439058304, -0.0065232920460402966, -0.0012594670988619328, -0.03245043382048607, -0.030347874388098717, -0.0361795611679554, 0.040961213409900665, 0.05594891309738159, -0.044909365475177765, -0.021767809987068176, -0.039929889142513275, 0.05695253238081932, -0.008342644199728966, -0.023400718346238136, -0.06253274530172348, 0.0749158188700676, 0.0019912959542125463, -0.004895157180726528, -0.001534592011012137, -0.024417050182819366, -0.06233102083206177, -0.07722216844558716, -0.013161181472241879, -0.05289458483457565, 0.028697876259684563, -0.026866484433412552, 0.017668746411800385, 0.0017583156004548073, 0.061553534120321274, 0.017809731885790825, 0.010349519550800323, 0.014287891797721386, 0.016618045046925545, -0.04410615190863609, 0.07898121327161789, 0.017301270738244057, 0.01756913587450981, -0.047407977283000946, -0.010199482552707195, -0.036418020725250244, 0.005092604085803032, 0.006941293366253376, -0.002440574113279581, 0.014744401909410954, -0.05569468066096306, -0.0015005224850028753, -0.0208362378180027, 0.007944243960082531, -0.05263018235564232, -0.015790365636348724, -0.01536770910024643, -0.015780813992023468, -0.06773686408996582 ]
The $\mathbb{R}$-motivic cohomology of an $\mathbb{R}$-motivic spectrum is a module over the $\mathbb{R}$-motivic Steenrod algebra $\mathcal{A}^{\mathbb{R}}$. In this paper, we describe how to recover the $\mathbb{R}$-motivic cohomology of the Spanier-Whitehead dual $\mathrm{DX}$ of an $\mathbb{R}$-motivic finite complex $\mathrm{X}$, as an $\mathcal{A}^{\mathbb{R}}$-module, given the $\mathcal{A}^{\mathbb{R}}$-module structure on the cohomology of $\mathrm{X}$. As an application, we show that 16 out of 128 different $\mathcal{A}^{\mathbb{R}}$-module structures on $\mathcal{A}^{\mathbb{R}}(1):= \langle \mathrm{Sq}^1, \mathrm{Sq}^2 \rangle$ are self-dual.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16142v2
[ -0.046935874968767166, -0.0654437467455864, 0.04118169844150543, -0.03387196734547615, -0.001912406412884593, -0.05084118992090225, -0.04808675870299339, -0.034064751118421555, -0.06103096902370453, -0.031313858926296234, 0.014791762456297874, -0.03234804794192314, -0.011503826826810837, 0.04423766955733299, -0.05090658739209175, 0.01289204228669405, 0.05200918763875961, 0.04333356022834778, -0.01161347609013319, 0.043247438967227936, -0.032774295657873154, -0.015862753614783287, -0.06255084276199341, 0.07226113975048065, 0.01720539480447769, -0.046255648136138916, -0.04246719554066658, -0.04877123236656189, -0.05830582603812218, -0.03319443389773369, 0.06618619710206985, -0.02342532016336918, 0.03578031435608864, -0.01354204211384058, -0.03037117049098015, 0.03185546025633812, 0.008983198553323746, 0.00479021854698658, 0.040548212826251984, -0.01927727460861206, -0.015468502417206764, -0.05158533900976181, -0.06467235833406448, -0.04521792754530907, 0.04616814851760864, -0.03987696394324303, -0.02598775364458561, -0.03169294446706772, -0.04432639852166176, -0.0639357641339302, 0.009483532048761845, 0.01703539676964283, 0.016974830999970436, 0.0267636738717556, -0.04276803508400917, -0.002222692593932152, 0.0034362783189862967, -0.03524557128548622, -0.040266480296850204, -0.016634579747915268, 0.013798956759274006, -0.02296121045947075, -0.027131015434861183, -0.0249236561357975, -0.002965527353808284, 0.025761231780052185, -0.05202776938676834, -0.040939681231975555, 0.0034466031938791275, 0.0019158077193424106, -0.0012012777151539922, -0.04345432296395302, 0.0635291263461113, -0.00769375916570425, -0.07439717650413513, 0.011703578755259514, -0.010527625679969788, -0.06036045029759407, 0.002819431945681572, 0.023056073114275932, -0.040296852588653564, -0.031207453459501266, -0.015001021325588226, -0.022913170978426933, 0.057700496166944504, -0.029819777235388756, 0.038600124418735504, -0.006485484074801207, 0.032790567725896835, -0.04915173724293709, -0.0015806988812983036, -0.016387514770030975, -0.05633411556482315, 0.009861982427537441, 0.02745429053902626, -0.05959774926304817, 0.01815536431968212, 0.010396505706012249, 0.03787574917078018, -0.013095485977828503, 0.016964709386229515, -0.03314363211393356, -0.002657529665157199, -0.00947410985827446, 0.030385591089725494, -0.03359856829047203, -0.020541341975331306, 0.024851016700267792, -0.06677167862653732, 0.02960531786084175, 0.016361534595489502, 0.029032748192548752, -0.02839554473757744, -0.025397049263119698, -0.005481136497110128, -0.06890583783388138, 0.05798961594700813, 0.03193351998925209, 0.0446765311062336, -0.009665518999099731, -0.0010404940694570541, 0.02038884535431862, 0.023119524121284485, -0.028335142880678177, -0.017790043726563454, -0.06589571386575699, 0.00911013688892126, 0.017392612993717194, -0.028459811583161354, -0.02961772121489048, -0.02976219169795513, -0.02261386625468731, 0.047063205391168594, -0.03473725914955139, 0.036336399614810944, -0.0671604797244072, -0.03629427030682564, -0.054958831518888474, 0.013853617943823338, 0.011763901449739933, -0.030138064175844193, -0.08451259136199951, 0.016272475942969322, -0.011387365870177746, 0.01392076164484024, 0.04799269139766693, -0.05371040478348732, 0.039717115461826324, -0.011749787256121635, 0.0481756292283535, -0.02087698131799698, 0.028348283842206, 0.02167648635804653, -0.014529220759868622, -0.019505735486745834, -0.021181998774409294, 0.04086551070213318, -0.011930479668080807, -0.05626034736633301, 0.011964640580117702, -0.013240234926342964, -0.02113477885723114, 0.012527993880212307, -0.005924942437559366, 0.010888483375310898, -0.013650918379426003, 0.011044378392398357, 0.0007266402244567871, -0.013221281580626965, -0.0009075388661585748, -0.02088838629424572, -0.0067301359958946705, 0.052930038422346115, -0.055069610476493835, -0.06869551539421082, -0.03520895913243294, -0.05336173623800278, -0.03427466005086899, -0.04583987221121788, -0.00029137410456314683, 0.019287290051579475, -0.03719161078333855, -0.027217000722885132, 0.012110475450754166, -0.06771473586559296, 0.0487600639462471, -0.06009745970368385, 0.018148811534047127, 0.01755984127521515, 0.0429065115749836, 0.02163480967283249, -0.04915772005915642, 0.040998637676239014, -0.029803162440657616, -0.055144067853689194, -0.014415130019187927, 0.027651967480778694, -0.04579974710941315, 0.00014648071373812854, 0.04139956086874008, -0.05973755568265915, 0.006014527752995491, -0.05717482417821884, -0.013450647704303265, 0.023234648630023003, -0.07625237107276917, -0.0041503747925162315, 0.03584377095103264, -0.013980130665004253, -0.05682925879955292, 0.05356138199567795, -0.017657963559031487, 0.001024542492814362, -0.02454925701022148, 0.013034343719482422, -0.026956668123602867, -0.08804181963205338, 0.07213078439235687, -0.007678390946239233, -0.04051566123962402, -0.008386672474443913, 0.02610180526971817, 0.012671809643507004, -0.029467571526765823, -0.05510851368308067, 0.034009866416454315, 0.01050886046141386, 0.019275935366749763, -0.0293491892516613, 0.03815649822354317, -0.00031294222571887076, -0.05318544805049896, -0.007954808883368969, -0.07577880471944809, -0.021444587036967278, 0.01625535823404789, 0.03103731758892536, 0.05251691862940788, 0.005614609457552433, -0.018566962331533432, -0.04330294579267502, -0.018997065722942352, 0.03042973019182682, -0.005469686817377806, -0.05671454966068268, -0.06283214688301086, -0.0688195452094078, 0.0012086144415661693, -0.0035282562021166086, 0.00811444129794836, 0.007854972034692764, -0.012270410545170307, -0.05056590586900711, -0.010484100319445133, 0.02241406962275505, -0.008043630979955196, -0.0028783075977116823, 0.056783754378557205, -0.058083292096853256, 0.021008754149079323, 0.0322260744869709, 0.047495659440755844, -0.0401887521147728, -0.03239819407463074, -0.046352237462997437, 0.005066019482910633, -0.06340041011571884, -0.06366700679063797, -0.03264188766479492, -0.04011068865656853, 0.03569604456424713, -0.013746082782745361, 0.02262704260647297, -0.04364063963294029, 0.016768360510468483, -0.02654273994266987, -0.012512721121311188, -0.022776171565055847, 0.026122085750102997, 0.023548243567347527, 0.004693902563303709, 0.0022790844086557627, -0.039713580161333084, -0.08326774090528488, -0.02856094390153885, -0.00354550639167428, -0.04834818094968796, -0.03352108225226402, -0.06720961630344391, 0.004646676126867533, -0.04803776368498802, 0.00564225809648633, -0.04758710414171219, -0.028961731120944023, -0.06471728533506393, -0.07367154955863953, -0.01261039450764656, 0.008943446911871433, -0.048905860632658005, -0.0787598192691803, -0.06339292228221893, 0.015508734621107578, -0.05646812543272972, 0.01501170452684164, -0.0498075857758522, -0.012877791188657284, -0.052338361740112305, 0.04002080112695694, -0.04975125938653946, 0.022896286100149155, -0.052625734359025955, 0.012738630175590515, -0.031856469810009, 0.008134214207530022, 0.0055200750939548016, 0.02095557004213333, 0.00944478902965784, 0.029658596962690353, 0.023012617602944374, 0.018705084919929504, -0.030382230877876282, -0.012950086034834385, 0.040824029594659805, -0.03852739557623863, -0.03188643231987953, -0.03155481442809105, 0.045088984072208405, 0.06389807909727097, -0.056248076260089874, -0.03475549817085266, -0.07483793050050735, -0.04673721268773079, 0.021766502410173416, 0.02510164864361286, 0.03893286734819412, 0.027603041380643845, 0.0237362552434206, 0.004342057276517153, -0.05970796197652817, -0.00832912977784872, -0.057471927255392075, 0.028452260419726372, 0.017037438228726387, -0.006135676521807909, -0.02735580876469612, -0.08345572650432587, 0.07433465868234634, 0.011980866082012653, 0.027908451855182648, -0.009486284106969833, -0.029170220717787743, 0.03789636865258217, -0.012490308843553066, -0.011137094348669052, -0.0250333733856678, 0.013918100856244564, 0.021853918209671974, -0.00596280861645937, -0.04707197844982147, -0.007798653095960617, -0.016350697726011276, -0.05013103038072586, -0.03524770215153694, 0.04126545414328575, 0.007482037413865328, 0.03204194828867912, 0.0029079781379550695, -0.03785090893507004, 0.029710862785577774, -0.008395127020776272, -0.004470349755138159, -0.03321859613060951, -0.024585921317338943, -0.012885266914963722, -0.03259173035621643, 0.01428352389484644, -0.0006611756980419159, -0.01984982006251812, -0.05855980142951012, -0.023883899673819542, 0.018214233219623566, -0.021853748708963394, 0.028948836028575897, 0.01259327121078968, -0.016751540824770927, -0.025855422019958496, -0.05032290145754814, 0.005474007688462734, 0.04367103800177574, -0.04845314100384712, 0.028072642162442207, -0.038350075483322144, -0.01704440452158451, 0.02394070476293564, -0.05026928707957268, -0.046137720346450806, 0.01641576923429966, -0.014484258368611336, -0.025296490639448166, -0.06220798194408417, 0.002976725809276104, -0.023136621341109276, -0.029072528705000877, -0.08035537600517273, -0.042470961809158325, -0.050945207476615906, -0.008894376456737518, -0.008493886329233646, -0.07445833086967468, 0.07029604911804199, -0.006560450419783592, -0.05446762964129448, 0.00681852363049984, -0.02844846621155739, -0.0474369078874588, -0.01928369514644146, -0.07106586545705795, -0.01903359778225422, 0.02370850183069706, -0.06210378184914589, 0.01877586916089058, -0.02913038432598114, -0.03201122581958771, -0.0501534566283226, 0.04129619151353836, -0.02068028599023819, 0.012330802157521248, 0.011424936354160309, 0.04282922297716141, 0.05201314017176628, 0.004289199132472277, 0.0034063677303493023, -0.007208466529846191, -0.015461503528058529, 0.0009281562524847686, -0.05395445600152016, 0.04590390622615814, -0.04958706721663475, -0.04941422864794731, 0.01820502057671547, -0.014228163287043571, 0.02486634999513626, -0.03423217311501503, 0.018841629847884178, -0.03381691128015518, 0.029114387929439545, -0.05910564213991165, -0.06248268857598305, -0.01712510734796524, -0.03717811405658722, -0.022049058228731155, 0.02251690998673439, 0.049761008471250534, -0.00892261229455471, -0.03565452992916107, 0.0364086739718914, -0.03651226684451103, 0.022565128281712532, -0.05109170824289322, 0.03615585342049599, -0.004480266943573952, -0.028017988428473473, 0.0004394379793666303, 0.02236195281147957, -0.075221486389637, 0.025425657629966736, -0.04021648317575455, -0.006956505123525858, 0.04355300962924957, 0.0560445636510849, 0.028201686218380928, 0.036360058933496475, -0.08085313439369202, 0.029342763125896454, 0.02348686195909977, 0.004730788059532642, -0.001081335125491023, 0.01939835026860237, -0.0351845882833004, -0.020897947251796722, -0.0007357050199061632, -0.02256597764790058, -0.04230242967605591, 0.02493441477417946, -0.03333810344338417, -0.02705809473991394, -0.01876956783235073, 0.0060006738640367985, 0.017112985253334045, -0.023404661566019058, -0.013766026124358177, 0.010156909935176373, 0.004302703309804201, -0.018125753849744797, 0.0029382938519120216, 0.07339184731245041, -0.0061419131234288216, -0.06482934206724167, -0.04563277214765549, -0.05027775838971138, 0.003999946638941765, -0.031493231654167175, 0.007210847456008196, 0.0040313792414963245, 0.03588881343603134, 0.04677433893084526, -0.023960208520293236, 0.0070412494242191315, 0.0000455323897767812, 0.01330354530364275, -0.017493974417448044, 0.024135660380125046, -0.0007811777177266777, -0.03275972977280617, 0.020544370636343956, -0.060290172696113586, 0.042236655950546265, 0.0017279358580708504, -0.004434114322066307, 0.046171076595783234, 0.036550045013427734, 0.04284527897834778, -0.02014065533876419, 0.018054360523819923, 0.015045960433781147, 0.03225512057542801, 0.010788614861667156, -0.03306160494685173, -0.016415858641266823, 0.008281748741865158, -0.019328953698277473, -0.06992559880018234, 0.033653732389211655, -0.03814484924077988, -0.028562704101204872, 0.02390415221452713, 0.017534295096993446, -0.008200203999876976, -0.060964278876781464, -0.05152428150177002, 0.02510412223637104, -0.0062410603277385235, 0.0682745948433876, 0.027354439720511436, 0.0616924948990345, 0.007066104095429182, 0.04311356693506241, 0.024546463042497635, -0.059155408293008804, -0.03057197481393814, 0.03566189110279083, -0.031668417155742645, 0.015220966190099716, -0.06402295082807541, -0.04644360765814781, 0.019747406244277954, -0.044964637607336044, -0.035669270902872086, -0.00285448064096272, -0.014075307175517082, -0.026821281760931015, 0.051224496215581894, 0.00011873464245582, -0.027262156829237938, 0.009352387860417366, 0.05826353654265404, -0.0723051205277443, -0.0376058891415596, -0.022354336455464363, -0.013824943453073502, -0.01001247763633728, 0.047726262360811234, -0.06354722380638123, -0.04834337159991264, -0.04458444565534592, 0.062354061752557755, 0.05774971470236778, -0.042452212423086166, 0.046946559101343155, 0.031402841210365295, -0.04156789556145668, -0.0021588802337646484, -0.06953214854001999, -0.06812269240617752, -0.02890944294631481, 0.05927349999547005, -0.025984618812799454, -0.032560400664806366, -0.00016646702715661377, 0.014941560104489326, 0.008851151913404465, -0.04464424401521683, 0.0536830797791481, -0.03803537040948868, 0.01418090146034956, -0.010644816793501377, -0.0013386727077886462, -0.03751280531287193, -0.006975657306611538, -0.03244641050696373, -0.031652435660362244, 0.02336970716714859, 0.003694327548146248, 0.03007185272872448, -0.005999486893415451, -0.01310289092361927, -0.02499043568968773, 0.014428682625293732, -0.07018133997917175, 0.0025317564141005278, -0.0640353187918663, 0.03514229506254196, 0.011398383416235447, 0.04545816779136658, -0.019379213452339172, 0.038747165352106094, 0.015083319507539272, 0.018153049051761627, -0.03280089050531387, -0.004800906404852867, -0.0042705293744802475, -0.002715147566050291, -0.01589418202638626, -0.03536362573504448, 0.07566944509744644, -0.06487872451543808, 0.008250468410551548, -0.03619901463389397, -0.04328015074133873, -0.024357415735721588, 0.05817309767007828, -0.03558946028351784, 0.0014024297706782818, -0.04293221980333328, -0.03383481875061989, 0.005014523863792419, 0.016735583543777466, -0.03395754471421242, -0.04081561416387558, -0.0069503942504525185, 0.030814146623015404, -0.0224636010825634, -0.0075803897343575954, -0.031143398955464363, 0.03815450519323349, 0.051413048058748245, 0.0011939846444875002, -0.028106775134801865, 0.04254346713423729, -0.0061047011986374855, -0.06917420774698257, -0.006094844080507755, -0.036414630711078644, -0.03253946080803871, -0.03906330466270447, -0.036399029195308685, -0.05639895424246788, -0.06533090770244598, 0.0029362186323851347, 0.00029773524147458375, 0.02049293741583824, 0.02491920255124569, -0.044439081102609634, 0.03332489728927612, 0.0409587137401104, 0.011558353900909424, -0.08130539953708649, -0.03835032135248184, 0.031523916870355606, -0.03723951056599617, -0.021990636363625526, -0.03943758085370064, -0.03690483793616295, 0.005028507672250271, -0.08061149716377258, -0.04212126135826111, 0.004646931309252977, 0.03966408595442772, 0.010741817764937878, 0.011657231487333775, -0.03205261379480362, -0.06030506268143654, 0.005906692240387201, -0.04742111638188362, 0.03601621463894844, 0.04678666964173317, -0.027630740776658058, 0.003982168156653643, -0.0015396478120237589, 0.02993141859769821, 0.05145254731178284, -0.012705456465482712, -0.01719990000128746, 0.06284629553556442, 0.029034646227955818, -0.06274652481079102, 0.0032055911142379045, 0.04157506301999092, -0.02999507449567318, 0.0028542988002300262, 0.026225274428725243, -0.04663990065455437, -0.05355395749211311, -0.0315537191927433, 0.048542264848947525, -0.050847578793764114, -0.01312822662293911, 0.011199729517102242, 0.001401083660311997, -0.05289042741060257, 0.021917305886745453, -0.043416719883680344, -0.019656838849186897, 0.05356549471616745, 0.02864905819296837, -0.01857597380876541, -0.033618636429309845, -0.0022637576330453157, 0.01973729394376278, 0.0072083002887666225, 0.05209922417998314, -0.007879647426307201, 0.03525060415267944, -0.03740588575601578, 0.009705058299005032, -0.03426344692707062, 0.00423308415338397, -0.03989503160119057, 0.015286264941096306, 0.017765825614333153, 0.0568184070289135, 0.015944430604577065, -0.012712637893855572, -0.04305380955338478, 0.00833179336041212, -0.0030348794534802437, -0.07393328845500946, -0.00677039660513401, -0.005264427047222853, 0.00702044228091836, 0.0447332039475441, 0.03261086344718933, -0.038798440247774124, 0.029811009764671326, -0.012831714004278183, -0.009868201799690723, 0.055304501205682755, 0.046399861574172974, -0.024211617186665535, 0.014457234181463718, 0.03247072547674179, -0.057970255613327026, -0.053031545132398605, 0.04140765219926834, 0.02140611596405506, -0.01819007284939289, -0.029079074040055275, -0.01752041094005108, -0.011335614137351513, -0.04162092134356499, -0.031549692153930664, 0.02907422184944153, 0.03385192155838013, -0.025288915261626244, 0.03676974028348923, -0.009499589912593365, 0.02002716064453125, -0.00618528900668025 ]
High-order structures have been recognised as suitable models for systems going beyond the binary relationships for which graph models are appropriate. Despite their importance and surge in research on these structures, their random cases have been only recently become subjects of interest. One of these high-order structures is the oriented hypergraph, which relates couples of subsets of an arbitrary number of vertices. Here we develop the Erd\H{o}s-R\'enyi model for oriented hypergraphs, which corresponds to the random realisation of oriented hyperedges of the complete oriented hypergraph. A particular feature of random oriented hypergraphs is that the ratio between their expected number of oriented hyperedges and their expected degree or size is 3/2 for large number of vertices. We highlight the suitability of oriented hypergraphs for modelling large collections of chemical reactions and the importance of random oriented hypergraphs to analyse the unfolding of chemistry.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06351v1
[ -0.010649725794792175, -0.007162477821111679, 0.033744506537914276, 0.018138432875275612, 0.022654930129647255, -0.035825055092573166, -0.041663702577352524, -0.03013245202600956, -0.008046746253967285, -0.042037613689899445, -0.01785893179476261, -0.040345847606658936, -0.023543674498796463, -0.03178010880947113, -0.0516761839389801, 0.03079298883676529, 0.057256292551755905, 0.07149685174226761, -0.051359325647354126, 0.07256249338388443, -0.041960131376981735, 0.0017025202978402376, -0.028959833085536957, 0.049782898277044296, -0.016353294253349304, -0.00046570354606956244, -0.008554883301258087, 0.016206856817007065, -0.023493215441703796, 0.009877199307084084, 0.035755936056375504, -0.018811676651239395, -0.00037849086220376194, -0.05632641538977623, -0.003855910385027528, 0.014913663268089294, -0.012917541898787022, 0.03996829688549042, 0.05195551738142967, -0.04255454242229462, -0.013858582824468613, -0.023889807984232903, -0.04913315549492836, -0.022082224488258362, 0.0031622922979295254, 0.0028154347091913223, -0.05780847370624542, 0.011719813570380211, -0.03269178420305252, -0.05710722133517265, 0.0249954741448164, -0.02499181404709816, 0.0122396070510149, 0.06369809806346893, -0.030948372557759285, -0.04314392805099487, 0.008196434006094933, 0.0042592124082148075, -0.05917080491781235, 0.03714337199926376, -0.06266763061285019, -0.03463295102119446, 0.021579449996352196, -0.013351778499782085, -0.011839447543025017, 0.024026136845350266, -0.06272008270025253, -0.06734400242567062, -0.001712950412184, -0.05374417454004288, 0.0610051304101944, -0.06441561132669449, 0.04096566513180733, 0.04147715866565704, -0.06176936998963356, 0.027686426416039467, -0.021162385120987892, -0.007549594156444073, -0.001815974828787148, 0.03372856602072716, -0.03344965726137161, 0.00506672402843833, 0.0011868466390296817, 0.02100851573050022, 0.0020084301941096783, 0.026791250333189964, 0.05566812679171562, -0.009341314435005188, -0.031023433431982994, -0.040297891944646835, 0.026321856305003166, -0.002045207191258669, -0.07153139263391495, 0.03477749228477478, 0.035392533987760544, -0.0031058688182383776, 0.06946650892496109, 0.07246344536542892, 0.0464530847966671, 0.0005253444542177022, -0.02366487681865692, -0.031154997646808624, 0.01018376462161541, 0.025863412767648697, 0.030238114297389984, -0.031274229288101196, -0.01157947164028883, 0.01513378694653511, -0.041548289358615875, -0.025359904393553734, -0.03746791183948517, -0.037892553955316544, 0.03574671596288681, -0.06125225871801376, -0.05499670282006264, -0.034469593316316605, 0.06413573771715164, 0.013256891630589962, 0.03457839787006378, 0.053158149123191833, -0.034588150680065155, 0.015760716050863266, 0.03996339440345764, -0.02100277505815029, -0.06742726266384125, -0.030100762844085693, 0.03127167001366615, 0.029366035014390945, 0.003975433297455311, -0.038538236171007156, -0.009937255643308163, 0.02905953861773014, 0.010101375170052052, -0.02113936096429825, 0.04609864950180054, -0.034571439027786255, 0.05334203317761421, -0.043269816786050797, 0.0342194139957428, 0.025157639756798744, -0.014215229079127312, -0.08717027306556702, 0.03734435513615608, 0.009827813133597374, 0.025399114936590195, 0.0622987374663353, -0.05044512823224068, -0.011028701439499855, 0.045785628259181976, 0.04240681603550911, -0.026070285588502884, 0.0026417977642267942, 0.039641786366701126, 0.02502276375889778, 0.012154554948210716, -0.04068313166499138, 0.04823553189635277, -0.014199822209775448, -0.0568421296775341, -0.03256259486079216, -0.0009575072908774018, 0.005227381829172373, -0.012242492288351059, 0.01053475309163332, -0.01547486986964941, 0.011111940257251263, 0.00626796530559659, -0.024528302252292633, -0.03474260866641998, 0.0031872133258730173, -0.025373557582497597, -0.0015387129969894886, 0.03821844235062599, -0.03822331130504608, -0.07660825550556183, 0.011387434788048267, -0.029981380328536034, -0.06181657686829567, -0.05755172669887543, -0.01852145977318287, -0.008300564251840115, 0.034460511058568954, 0.019673312082886696, 0.03188983350992203, 0.0016988934949040413, 0.015674684196710587, -0.07987894862890244, 0.010522342287003994, 0.0392804816365242, 0.017128145322203636, 0.0038525525014847517, -0.052363842725753784, 0.011312638409435749, 0.002700997516512871, -0.03511476144194603, -0.041198816150426865, 0.025745311751961708, -0.07529262453317642, -0.036202993243932724, 0.038078904151916504, -0.07743272930383682, 0.028174586594104767, -0.02670871652662754, -0.0030010368209332228, 0.019947543740272522, -0.08044293522834778, 0.019833019003272057, 0.03823778033256531, -0.037924811244010925, -0.040546394884586334, 0.05564643815159798, 0.036348607391119, 0.039867013692855835, 0.009240296669304371, -0.024321818724274635, -0.020300576463341713, -0.09522007405757904, 0.04899519309401512, -0.002323383232578635, -0.0059239305555820465, 0.02838888391852379, 0.04964260011911392, 0.0122517179697752, -0.025665437802672386, 0.022761544212698936, 0.07265935838222504, 0.07264042645692825, 0.021419797092676163, -0.04143514484167099, -0.014231211505830288, -0.0002679812314454466, -0.06763287633657455, -0.025768639519810677, -0.0553431361913681, -0.020412398502230644, -0.023856177926063538, -0.03598695248365402, 0.057033538818359375, -0.018049485981464386, -0.02079569175839424, -0.042922355234622955, 0.0066131302155554295, 0.051313381642103195, 0.010080081410706043, -0.05240761488676071, -0.07024436444044113, -0.04971033334732056, 0.0069796061143279076, -0.005008432548493147, -0.01720586232841015, 0.010587815195322037, -0.06944333016872406, -0.05026482790708542, 0.011895259842276573, 0.009638057090342045, 0.04608549922704697, 0.006128513254225254, 0.03601180762052536, -0.04686986654996872, -0.006307088304311037, 0.03986925631761551, -0.02064279466867447, -0.006466356106102467, -0.008151644840836525, -0.007936399430036545, 0.013932243920862675, -0.05989900603890419, 0.0066041420213878155, 0.02588394470512867, -0.03410629555583, 0.03609186038374901, 0.026318026706576347, 0.020393555983901024, -0.009966330602765083, 0.010485603474080563, -0.01294297631829977, -0.007582948077470064, -0.008756183087825775, 0.056866299360990524, -0.010162338614463806, 0.0511518232524395, 0.053692109882831573, -0.04783245921134949, -0.07553018629550934, -0.030989596620202065, 0.009363779798150063, -0.04146560654044151, -0.044380154460668564, -0.05009801313281059, -0.04947240650653839, -0.07057849317789078, -0.032485563308000565, 0.009892549365758896, -0.04626041650772095, -0.01808531954884529, -0.067628875374794, -0.022232865914702415, 0.033298324793577194, -0.0032648269552737474, -0.03393206000328064, -0.06624514609575272, 0.029553517699241638, 0.07284033298492432, 0.003908537793904543, -0.050955578684806824, -0.05252419039607048, -0.04630032926797867, -0.002601456828415394, 0.03204696625471115, -0.05547753721475601, -0.01949845254421234, -0.001942759845405817, -0.028552602976560593, 0.025690538808703423, -0.02462601475417614, 0.05118840932846069, 0.05856804922223091, -0.012441650032997131, 0.025090377777814865, 0.024611860513687134, -0.04258955270051956, -0.04127633944153786, -0.004725172184407711, -0.02037370763719082, -0.07720727473497391, 0.017992643639445305, 0.026468388736248016, 0.04503621160984039, -0.003384385025128722, 0.00497609144076705, -0.004793053958564997, -0.004636120051145554, -0.014265917241573334, -0.006150451488792896, 0.025988493114709854, 0.027470093220472336, 0.002918865531682968, -0.0304986871778965, -0.013824369758367538, 0.045951660722494125, 0.026933837682008743, 0.005986938718706369, 0.00965906772762537, -0.043819114565849304, 0.027842387557029724, -0.08542526513338089, 0.03352832421660423, 0.0192145723849535, 0.056554023176431656, 0.0011214428814128041, -0.02924550510942936, 0.044352948665618896, -0.029722746461629868, 0.018978266045451164, -0.023207245394587517, 0.034635722637176514, -0.021109266206622124, 0.06093448027968407, -0.024707265198230743, 0.002368466230109334, -0.062705397605896, -0.06206058710813522, -0.03653357923030853, 0.00713368970900774, 0.002804392948746681, 0.05119580775499344, 0.012443565763533115, -0.006467065308243036, -0.018951674923300743, 0.0010730365756899118, 0.05276324972510338, 0.012654096819460392, -0.031978167593479156, -0.014612216502428055, -0.05519464612007141, 0.00604983838275075, 0.03012959472835064, 0.013626592233777046, 0.0016366259660571814, -0.06435246020555496, -0.012009542435407639, -0.06148425117135048, 0.05041880160570145, 0.036123719066381454, -0.012843798846006393, 0.059590984135866165, -0.016122503206133842, 0.021031973883509636, 0.045638829469680786, 0.0013206248404458165, 0.03634116053581238, -0.045495498925447464, 0.013732889667153358, -0.007911862805485725, -0.00003991373159806244, -0.014247535727918148, -0.012190484441816807, 0.012957986444234848, -0.04665670916438103, 0.014595502987504005, 0.004482508171349764, -0.026872757822275162, -0.061938706785440445, -0.08159314841032028, 0.0172397643327713, -0.010914190672338009, 0.005219959653913975, 0.01647510565817356, -0.07272746413946152, 0.06848489493131638, 0.014273744076490402, 0.02135756053030491, -0.06005389988422394, -0.02278304658830166, -0.05063671991229057, -0.02976386807858944, -0.06036890298128128, -0.05997897684574127, 0.036608096212148666, -0.029827388003468513, 0.009759851731359959, -0.026167048141360283, -0.030514152720570564, -0.04354650527238846, -0.03114050067961216, 0.005282322410494089, 0.04619366303086281, 0.04085017368197441, -0.03526574745774269, -0.01969473622739315, -0.01609894074499607, 0.02937418408691883, -0.00637419568374753, -0.011542024090886116, 0.034123849123716354, -0.051273781806230545, 0.016089480370283127, -0.014384216628968716, -0.04143199697136879, -0.00513817835599184, -0.007660943083465099, 0.04575362429022789, -0.044896386563777924, -0.009386382065713406, -0.034967388957738876, 0.058901071548461914, -0.051920004189014435, -0.06637753546237946, 0.02733423002064228, -0.04919498786330223, -0.06834405660629272, 0.028162799775600433, 0.03926530107855797, -0.058109063655138016, -0.034013986587524414, -0.010993451811373234, 0.0031199774239212275, -0.007710597477853298, -0.048256948590278625, 0.03568032756447792, 0.004282014444470406, -0.006108068395406008, -0.05764809623360634, -0.023029595613479614, -0.06565558910369873, 0.0013178056105971336, -0.033015210181474686, -0.0036266017705202103, -0.013855183497071266, 0.03756459429860115, 0.013433891348540783, 0.023498646914958954, -0.08763189613819122, 0.035344578325748444, 0.05248585343360901, 0.016522042453289032, -0.02853199653327465, 0.06642143428325653, -0.021507833153009415, 0.024868778884410858, -0.007374914828687906, 0.025488434359431267, 0.0007029167609289289, -0.041911955922842026, -0.026308240368962288, -0.009635455906391144, 0.00783956702798605, 0.04978048801422119, 0.036240849643945694, -0.03723658248782158, -0.04784102737903595, -0.004058255814015865, -0.020780734717845917, 0.010834687389433384, -0.019012419506907463, 0.06282027065753937, 0.00828248169273138, -0.025292454287409782, -0.030183220282197, -0.04718277230858803, 0.01644301414489746, 0.020846890285611153, 0.02931101992726326, -0.04330587014555931, -0.009939009323716164, 0.047403644770383835, 0.01504933089017868, 0.011167533695697784, 0.018334930762648582, -0.02916186861693859, -0.005216196179389954, 0.015275518409907818, -0.021264808252453804, -0.07035041600465775, 0.011381995864212513, -0.024873627349734306, 0.026746276766061783, 0.014195461757481098, 0.003211790230125189, 0.044404760003089905, 0.02303253300487995, -0.00819331407546997, -0.03117368184030056, -0.0364595502614975, 0.03492072969675064, 0.03980650007724762, -0.05323466658592224, 0.004020758904516697, 0.025837820023298264, 0.01139915268868208, 0.0004182686097919941, -0.03358744457364082, 0.00911222118884325, -0.015651321038603783, -0.044967588037252426, -0.04691338166594505, -0.0013570452574640512, -0.015711894258856773, -0.051696110516786575, 0.008079908788204193, 0.05509980767965317, -0.054004568606615067, 0.05422608181834221, 0.030903704464435577, 0.0484963022172451, 0.005966867320239544, 0.020852738991379738, 0.05343729630112648, -0.0031333118677139282, -0.03218552842736244, 0.0825241431593895, -0.05452045798301697, -0.020381160080432892, -0.04325712472200394, -0.0225746538490057, 0.04301441088318825, -0.05774350464344025, 0.03824227303266525, 0.00965069979429245, -0.04098717123270035, -0.02635740488767624, 0.011432920582592487, 0.01220577210187912, -0.05759052932262421, 0.015851467847824097, 0.021419145166873932, -0.017282944172620773, -0.011751245707273483, 0.02141449600458145, 0.010000232607126236, -0.019555453211069107, 0.042860276997089386, -0.0471305288374424, -0.056438472121953964, -0.03348209336400032, 0.03925437852740288, 0.044540636241436005, -0.036470841616392136, -0.016732558608055115, 0.01480262540280819, -0.019477542489767075, 0.0009120929171331227, -0.018726583570241928, -0.0461965836584568, 0.013801341876387596, 0.01436289120465517, -0.024209482595324516, -0.033266086131334305, -0.0033209193497896194, 0.055680159479379654, -0.04910826310515404, 0.0009460162837058306, 0.04136963561177254, -0.019249746575951576, 0.00906386598944664, -0.02356194145977497, -0.017094437032938004, -0.012506579048931599, 0.03199167177081108, -0.01007241290062666, -0.0028370912186801434, -0.01022305991500616, -0.038724999874830246, 0.014859282411634922, -0.01650434359908104, -0.0473899208009243, -0.06202885881066322, -0.008922559209167957, -0.04067906364798546, 0.017284447327256203, -0.04892541468143463, 0.013144198805093765, -0.013862527906894684, 0.0561203733086586, 0.022660082206130028, 0.036914486438035965, 0.012528656050562859, -0.020551737397909164, 0.003534081857651472, -0.017047790810465813, 0.031293854117393494, 0.0367262028157711, 0.06368304789066315, 0.0013081267243251204, 0.054637372493743896, -0.05511295422911644, -0.014620708301663399, -0.02341257594525814, -0.03893587738275528, -0.026768242940306664, 0.012075738050043583, -0.04422672465443611, -0.014561546966433525, -0.011648276820778847, -0.026171289384365082, 0.03830434009432793, 0.048300307244062424, -0.021117985248565674, -0.06440391391515732, -0.03150744363665581, -0.006325450725853443, -0.026481103152036667, 0.03687639161944389, 0.008385155349969864, 0.026530908420681953, -0.02030724287033081, 0.0404529832303524, 0.024889269843697548, 0.029021136462688446, 0.014843271113932133, -0.02523154392838478, -0.03832877054810524, 0.024795813485980034, 0.013785380870103836, -0.006864224560558796, -0.013279628939926624, -0.050913531333208084, -0.07052430510520935, 0.016221502795815468, 0.029274296015501022, -0.013868631795048714, 0.00901567842811346, -0.041176218539476395, 0.014238902367651463, 0.004311972763389349, -0.013263426721096039, -0.08554089814424515, -0.04252905026078224, 0.041334934532642365, -0.017770269885659218, -0.04728812724351883, 0.030905693769454956, -0.057663433253765106, 0.038546811789274216, -0.08397632837295532, 0.007040923926979303, -0.011444291099905968, 0.06166050210595131, 0.0019739626441150904, -0.04761732369661331, -0.046933118253946304, -0.022709572687745094, -0.002800283022224903, 0.017171230167150497, -0.008229986764490604, 0.05411636829376221, 0.013723372481763363, 0.04358328506350517, -0.04668126627802849, -0.021186217665672302, 0.040563199669122696, -0.051852401345968246, 0.032128337770700455, 0.017361769452691078, 0.02773410454392433, -0.028906594961881638, 0.022802673280239105, 0.048519864678382874, -0.015043194405734539, 0.011117536574602127, 0.004384945146739483, -0.0009954051347449422, -0.07097911834716797, -0.05578305199742317, 0.037763189524412155, -0.038702890276908875, -0.012110509909689426, -0.021270569413900375, 0.024521831423044205, -0.009793180972337723, 0.006600193679332733, -0.0483199805021286, 0.03828618302941322, -0.014566393569111824, 0.02346542477607727, 0.04847409948706627, -0.06417832523584366, 0.005490433890372515, 0.014174802228808403, -0.02389581687748432, -0.013225136324763298, 0.026668202131986618, 0.03309369459748268, -0.05754805728793144, 0.02429800294339657, -0.06832192838191986, -0.0170718003064394, -0.029828239232301712, -0.007813094183802605, 0.034940626472234726, 0.06947880238294601, -0.07338640838861465, 0.009359817951917648, -0.012975328601896763, -0.04339604079723358, 0.005828348454087973, -0.0697261244058609, -0.010108045302331448, -0.012982245534658432, 0.01865839585661888, 0.00755872018635273, 0.011864247731864452, -0.03167516738176346, 0.04933294281363487, 0.01629490777850151, -0.004196316935122013, 0.029699955135583878, 0.0016335872933268547, -0.029105767607688904, 0.029088644310832024, 0.010165110230445862, -0.030370401218533516, -0.014442474581301212, 0.04292811453342438, 0.034978292882442474, -0.04944852367043495, -0.049439363181591034, 0.012678825296461582, -0.025266794487833977, -0.02913491800427437, -0.03666432574391365, 0.06315076351165771, 0.037675268948078156, -0.0630616620182991, 0.026631740853190422, 0.012098434381186962, -0.04208957776427269, -0.06384055316448212 ]
Interfacial instabilities are common phenomena observed during adhesion measurements involving viscoelastic polymers or fluids. Typical probe-tack adhesion measurements with soft adhesives are conducted with rigid probes. However, in many settings, such as for medical applications, adhesives make and break contact from soft surfaces such as skin. Here we study how detachment from soft probes alters the debonding mechanism of a model viscoelastic polymer film. We demonstrate that detachment from a soft probe suppresses Saffman-Taylor instabilities commonly encountered in adhesion. We suggest the mechanism for interface stabilization is elastohydrodynamic deformation of the probe and propose a scaling for the onset of stabilization.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09704v1
[ -0.05568034201860428, 0.008031545206904411, 0.043679025024175644, -0.04030461236834526, -0.0029988724272698164, -0.013699717819690704, 0.03523949906229973, 0.003769485978409648, -0.05092060938477516, 0.014577866531908512, 0.017853084951639175, -0.02790323831140995, -0.015825534239411354, -0.07817677408456802, 0.005260935518890619, 0.004099579062312841, 0.06115192919969559, -0.020726624876260757, -0.05354076623916626, 0.05105762928724289, 0.0023295085411518812, -0.010671189054846764, -0.03580816835165024, 0.06377266347408295, -0.029975371435284615, -0.0409148707985878, -0.035210344940423965, 0.059256672859191895, -0.01077992282807827, -0.04936595633625984, 0.048509351909160614, 0.00928746908903122, -0.0219411663711071, 0.0005231613758951426, -0.008888598531484604, 0.03194226697087288, -0.0014560418203473091, -0.043887920677661896, 0.006897485349327326, -0.02058815024793148, -0.014437281526625156, 0.017875973135232925, -0.02093266323208809, -0.01711280457675457, -0.04798572510480881, 0.011889715678989887, 0.024103771895170212, 0.04120303690433502, -0.013236260041594505, -0.03567903861403465, 0.04971430450677872, 0.02955026738345623, -0.01998569630086422, 0.05252743139863014, -0.04642095789313316, 0.03282619267702103, 0.001122601330280304, 0.016398290172219276, -0.055637482553720474, -0.05449914559721947, -0.03392539173364639, 0.007742754183709621, 0.024470509961247444, -0.026405788958072662, -0.04588554799556732, 0.009762775152921677, -0.017970699816942215, -0.06733737885951996, 0.0012369968462735415, -0.05825098976492882, 0.013060622848570347, -0.02418074943125248, 0.04144009202718735, 0.03952160105109215, -0.026110785081982613, 0.00965303834527731, -0.04988836497068405, 0.03057987056672573, 0.05528096482157707, 0.047900281846523285, -0.014582017436623573, 0.0029319978784769773, 0.03450499475002289, 0.013598580844700336, 0.041202764958143234, -0.012380578555166721, 0.0363846980035305, -0.019313372671604156, 0.04461037740111351, -0.009129862301051617, 0.034628819674253464, -0.03966957703232765, -0.020262276753783226, -0.02978966012597084, 0.0886785015463829, -0.09025479108095169, 0.04690510779619217, 0.03151758015155792, 0.05468921363353729, -0.035551317036151886, 0.0015560360625386238, -0.02855696715414524, -0.03632810339331627, 0.009696101769804955, 0.025227515026926994, -0.04710879921913147, 0.005591859575361013, 0.01544912625104189, -0.007689492776989937, -0.04349326714873314, -0.04854827746748924, 0.015288756228983402, 0.057144150137901306, -0.06316416710615158, -0.027760613709688187, -0.023818662390112877, 0.05301857739686966, -0.05762132629752159, -0.0018412654753774405, 0.0013154851039871573, -0.0658171996474266, 0.07159829884767532, -0.005353986285626888, 0.0013319747522473335, -0.03236958011984825, 0.0014788691187277436, 0.051116686314344406, 0.029009951278567314, -0.03833627328276634, -0.015133388340473175, -0.04763546586036682, -0.027557680383324623, 0.03949151933193207, 0.01447529997676611, 0.07822737842798233, -0.016685251146554947, 0.006372409872710705, 0.02584247477352619, -0.05522943660616875, 0.03979746997356415, -0.017420800402760506, -0.014326387085020542, -0.01208089105784893, -0.015169368125498295, -0.01059089694172144, 0.008874040096998215, -0.06123967468738556, 0.016710110008716583, 0.01967497169971466, 0.03495350852608681, 0.03820553794503212, -0.023204276338219643, 0.0416819304227829, 0.06928202509880066, 0.04981376603245735, -0.03050905466079712, 0.01399873849004507, -0.010305075906217098, -0.026674117892980576, 0.025746861472725868, 0.028853438794612885, 0.008967088535428047, 0.03751962259411812, -0.04815297573804855, 0.03165562078356743, -0.013910376466810703, 0.004364499822258949, 0.006961072329431772, -0.02070092409849167, -0.013314373791217804, 0.014165544882416725, 0.00983905978500843, -0.028680313378572464, -0.05728456377983093, -0.07661078125238419, 0.0035311684478074312, 0.0038019304629415274, -0.048122603446245193, -0.04047231376171112, 0.00615247106179595, 0.03989320620894432, -0.025198176503181458, 0.009144178591668606, -0.03895961493253708, 0.01896663010120392, -0.02799338661134243, -0.08804184943437576, -0.01648307964205742, 0.0025740526616573334, 0.011594354175031185, -0.04041966423392296, -0.05482697859406471, 0.030493533238768578, 0.037817832082509995, -0.005493909120559692, -0.006628745701164007, 0.03767237812280655, -0.023170163854956627, 0.017634866759181023, 0.04220608249306679, -0.0704089105129242, 0.031672053039073944, -0.050893791019916534, -0.03073989227414131, -0.03761850297451019, -0.043803390115499496, -0.009997570887207985, 0.047154687345027924, -0.027503017336130142, -0.007419154979288578, 0.03836013004183769, 0.04828497767448425, 0.026388036087155342, 0.03951899707317352, 0.026401402428746223, 0.03173181414604187, -0.11833833903074265, -0.02551886811852455, 0.041234374046325684, 0.03246492147445679, 0.003738661762326956, 0.019279776141047478, 0.009414599277079105, 0.00891440361738205, -0.06499557942152023, 0.0428147055208683, 0.05608078092336655, 0.010241743177175522, -0.04250312224030495, 0.029938777908682823, 0.017652764916419983, -0.012972292490303516, -0.03826563432812691, -0.06464146822690964, -0.0035900978837162256, 0.019918356090784073, -0.08626580238342285, 0.022141380235552788, -0.0045324363745749, -0.009890454821288586, 0.006761739030480385, -0.05521376058459282, 0.04735802486538887, -0.014003436081111431, -0.06031316891312599, -0.04385703429579735, -0.0615081787109375, 0.001222109654918313, -0.014765911735594273, -0.010922149755060673, -0.04283259063959122, -0.05384824797511101, 0.019532496109604836, -0.0236086156219244, 0.04727740213274956, 0.05824871361255646, -0.022133680060505867, 0.02388596720993519, 0.028224265202879906, 0.032396260648965836, 0.039871275424957275, 0.05639272928237915, -0.02990248240530491, 0.03262396529316902, 0.015909379348158836, 0.031251776963472366, -0.025294601917266846, -0.028197597712278366, -0.01984192430973053, -0.04688047245144844, 0.03653012588620186, 0.05901794508099556, 0.029564209282398224, 0.062301237136125565, 0.0263579860329628, -0.02467033825814724, -0.030117372050881386, -0.05576225370168686, 0.018361417576670647, 0.05177201330661774, 0.061683427542448044, -0.017930015921592712, 0.007852421142160892, -0.0464770570397377, 0.0008567232871428132, -0.033866629004478455, -0.019857337698340416, -0.08043620735406876, -0.03932533413171768, 0.030629877001047134, -0.06870797276496887, -0.011824928224086761, 0.025500521063804626, 0.05692952126264572, -0.020567115396261215, -0.046898022294044495, -0.012079905718564987, 0.017242304980754852, 0.04664360359311104, -0.013786065392196178, -0.04232660308480263, 0.014950186014175415, -0.00041518689249642193, 0.02893884666264057, 0.004825661890208721, -0.04019545391201973, -0.02743302471935749, 0.025752441957592964, 0.037524186074733734, -0.028009632602334023, -0.026375681161880493, 0.017868604511022568, -0.044058751314878464, -0.02097715623676777, -0.01278613694012165, -0.011055432260036469, 0.024892743676900864, -0.020779570564627647, 0.025003090500831604, -0.0032987119629979134, 0.01437566801905632, -0.014805207028985023, 0.021410265937447548, 0.043718695640563965, -0.005606965161859989, 0.01844361238181591, 0.07377640902996063, 0.03319619968533516, -0.016302473843097687, 0.006213477812707424, -0.018194928765296936, 0.0061115724965929985, 0.009043503552675247, -0.01196043286472559, 0.012749128974974155, 0.026519877836108208, -0.03260419890284538, 0.017240554094314575, -0.016471052542328835, 0.002707282779738307, -0.0129157779738307, 0.014331278391182423, -0.018991371616721153, -0.021677380427718163, 0.015999268740415573, -0.07215970009565353, -0.013392933644354343, 0.041371285915374756, 0.013174649327993393, -0.03660057485103607, -0.016000522300601006, 0.018004778772592545, 0.00482291541993618, 0.036469969898462296, -0.0006113027920946479, 0.04176045209169388, -0.005504582542926073, 0.04509889334440231, -0.05185222625732422, -0.025709910318255424, 0.013283150270581245, -0.030568398535251617, -0.06804569065570831, 0.021831903606653214, -0.03259344771504402, -0.01247509103268385, -0.005845654755830765, -0.040398698300123215, 0.06747934967279434, -0.04084676504135132, 0.05913325771689415, -0.04630400612950325, -0.004406238440424204, 0.007941446267068386, -0.014534146524965763, 0.030794376507401466, 0.00888033676892519, 0.024990836158394814, -0.06265074014663696, -0.04345889762043953, 0.05532172694802284, -0.007550775073468685, -0.015439227223396301, 0.0460759699344635, 0.03572706878185272, 0.051910728216171265, 0.05593787506222725, -0.007747702766209841, 0.03851182386279106, -0.0013914791634306312, 0.013626272790133953, 0.008575321175158024, -0.021607449278235435, 0.00423978129401803, -0.04703214019536972, -0.03851885721087456, -0.016207313165068626, 0.005458396393805742, -0.04584577679634094, 0.04879433289170265, 0.024687020108103752, -0.0015607444802299142, -0.01385577768087387, -0.09222744405269623, 0.0001685733877820894, -0.04849814996123314, 0.03156575188040733, 0.04405395686626434, -0.037884775549173355, 0.0637093111872673, -0.026071948930621147, 0.01570059172809124, 0.00445518596097827, 0.023746134713292122, -0.0434248261153698, -0.0036157462745904922, -0.0012704962864518166, -0.04165331646800041, -0.011439969763159752, -0.08356310427188873, -0.017939670011401176, 0.01476832665503025, 0.020788181573152542, -0.054680321365594864, 0.04170001298189163, -0.027813781052827835, 0.04438247159123421, 0.060959164053201675, -0.042074527591466904, 0.026885919272899628, -0.020691003650426865, 0.039268530905246735, 0.004625943023711443, 0.021322298794984818, 0.005756162106990814, -0.012002441100776196, -0.006148421671241522, -0.0394415408372879, -0.07300738990306854, -0.011768782511353493, -0.0014769801637157798, 0.023548442870378494, -0.03521024435758591, -0.001685414812527597, -0.002985095139592886, 0.033733684569597244, -0.0545218326151371, -0.08125894516706467, -0.04928603023290634, 0.0329987071454525, -0.040832992643117905, 0.014649173244833946, -0.0014840211952105165, 0.028731008991599083, -0.015912920236587524, -0.022236820310354233, -0.022088751196861267, -0.0034972417633980513, 0.0470232330262661, 0.02016155794262886, 0.03342333063483238, 0.05152418836951256, -0.006960634142160416, -0.01723259873688221, -0.038239240646362305, 0.023263180628418922, 0.00467306561768055, 0.008552131243050098, -0.035196322947740555, 0.07836353033781052, -0.027731571346521378, 0.008634072728455067, -0.0821366012096405, 0.05431344732642174, 0.0050663729198277, -0.022646689787507057, -0.019772710278630257, -0.02912592515349388, -0.0051601966843008995, 0.03108139894902706, -0.03342253714799881, 0.04229755327105522, -0.05300232395529747, -0.02894304320216179, -0.0588156022131443, -0.015395657159388065, 0.016873115673661232, -0.03130731359124184, 0.032240308821201324, 0.0008245142525993288, -0.05200942978262901, 0.0037741917185485363, 0.0239262618124485, -0.024861600250005722, -0.02689243108034134, -0.013371329754590988, 0.02217395231127739, -0.04865102097392082, -0.030365921556949615, -0.010457033291459084, -0.00584063958376646, 0.03951100632548332, 0.04162877798080444, -0.06415493786334991, -0.007250227965414524, -0.008115047588944435, 0.0001604210992809385, 0.012477416545152664, -0.027699867263436317, -0.007330192252993584, -0.025810766965150833, -0.028200358152389526, -0.022467972710728645, -0.07687675207853317, -0.01385120302438736, -0.08142837882041931, 0.008684457279741764, -0.013590842485427856, 0.05231121554970741, 0.039221957325935364, 0.03257443383336067, -0.03347120061516762, -0.03380299359560013, -0.03500692918896675, -0.04524737223982811, -0.008301472291350365, 0.0021066260524094105, 0.015879929065704346, 0.016233965754508972, 0.06020047143101692, 0.038154520094394684, -0.039140403270721436, -0.054686564952135086, 0.007955196313560009, -0.01240819413214922, 0.0010929270647466183, 0.07310621440410614, -0.02672538161277771, -0.051833659410476685, 0.018454208970069885, 0.04968780651688576, -0.058345310389995575, 0.0538189671933651, 0.0012708503054454923, -0.020388728007674217, 0.023807812482118607, 0.04758291319012642, -0.011665470898151398, -0.06608270108699799, -0.0034976471215486526, 0.0896369218826294, -0.08064192533493042, -0.025073444470763206, -0.006087060552090406, -0.06496657431125641, -0.02714674547314644, -0.0011515477672219276, -0.0030490888748317957, 0.06777841597795486, -0.017579389736056328, -0.08005977421998978, 0.0036034698132425547, -0.014511782675981522, -0.02910458855330944, -0.03295901045203209, -0.015137272886931896, -0.05653456971049309, 0.04163280129432678, 0.04366155341267586, 0.003584827994927764, 0.016591627150774002, 0.010665500536561012, -0.001628200407139957, -0.006413731258362532, 0.022291086614131927, 0.05460627004504204, 0.03819917514920235, 0.02008669264614582, -0.01346717681735754, -0.06111190468072891, -0.01691596210002899, -0.012162546627223492, -0.033044468611478806, -0.019892731681466103, -0.026508355513215065, -0.03602471947669983, -0.025387955829501152, -0.016754137352108955, -0.012920691631734371, 0.03342016041278839, -0.009418623521924019, -0.03428106755018234, 0.01794993132352829, -0.0015954496338963509, 0.05277325585484505, 0.0031563686206936836, -0.008390300907194614, 0.0314193069934845, 0.006104642990976572, -0.041208796203136444, -0.06914275139570236, 0.06448090821504593, 0.01403693575412035, 0.03150797635316849, 0.05014603212475777, -0.02754606120288372, 0.003345021279528737, -0.007004877552390099, -0.028299715369939804, -0.006232260726392269, -0.006996132433414459, 0.01665390096604824, -0.0003330558829475194, 0.05341249331831932, 0.03330766037106514, 0.03157509118318558, -0.017798127606511116, 0.05207123979926109, -0.009648140519857407, 0.0076553127728402615, -0.010840065777301788, 0.040177956223487854, -0.012767032720148563, 0.010908800177276134, -0.015243832021951675, -0.020149270072579384, 0.0008541946881450713, -0.034106671810150146, -0.025658810511231422, 0.04461987316608429, -0.022751018404960632, -0.03982909396290779, -0.05363825336098671, 0.012743765488266945, -0.04172728583216667, 0.04120899364352226, -0.023571370169520378, -0.01881270483136177, -0.06909042596817017, 0.01731683872640133, -0.011149507015943527, -0.012123825959861279, 0.04932251200079918, 0.03505147621035576, -0.009522558189928532, 0.009713289327919483, 0.03453988581895828, 0.04838768020272255, 0.011262650601565838, 0.029045647010207176, -0.057043902575969696, -0.006915840320289135, 0.05258987098932266, 0.017166130244731903, -0.02470601350069046, 0.012803548015654087, -0.03875312581658363, -0.05402909219264984, 0.0029705080669373274, -0.004741659387946129, -0.017750084400177002, -0.01962408423423767, 0.009319749660789967, 0.041734542697668076, -0.0025527768302708864, 0.013222355395555496, -0.04686133190989494, 0.01822941191494465, 0.04755294322967529, -0.011786813847720623, 0.008060814812779427, -0.029865147545933723, -0.07197263091802597, -0.07395347952842712, -0.094825379550457, 0.006944125983864069, -0.026108533143997192, 0.07966159284114838, 0.006194992922246456, -0.02765030413866043, -0.009783503599464893, -0.02821538969874382, 0.05918916314840317, 0.0074349441565573215, -0.0015669465065002441, 0.02541925385594368, -0.02687845565378666, -0.011866004206240177, -0.0558386966586113, -0.03859192132949829, 0.06987123191356659, -0.032274436205625534, -0.03490171954035759, 0.007891697809100151, 0.05511321499943733, -0.04521666467189789, -0.015116714872419834, -0.004116039723157883, 0.010785897262394428, 0.05191142484545708, -0.022179190069437027, 0.026066742837429047, -0.05295410007238388, -0.031891118735075, 0.04388226196169853, -0.0697249174118042, -0.018662359565496445, -0.00003861896402668208, 0.0519157275557518, -0.021231744438409805, -0.03701388090848923, -0.04208429530262947, 0.0004657912359107286, 0.020082121714949608, -0.029651260003447533, 0.058871131390333176, -0.045385442674160004, -0.005454066209495068, 0.0041167899034917355, -0.010995851829648018, -0.044092144817113876, 0.03931383043527603, 0.024116400629281998, 0.018156088888645172, 0.019481714814901352, -0.10011663287878036, 0.06797446310520172, 0.001108441036194563, 0.05133892595767975, 0.014632457867264748, 0.0364181324839592, -0.04594232141971588, 0.012854977510869503, -0.050471339374780655, -0.06190715730190277, 0.020628616213798523, -0.06670740991830826, -0.030027462169528008, 0.03743388131260872, -0.015218912623822689, 0.03860611468553543, 0.045636046677827835, -0.039891839027404785, 0.06153223291039467, -0.00578957749530673, 0.04643736407160759, -0.017369061708450317, -0.010170228779315948, -0.02666052244603634, 0.040450528264045715, 0.032670725136995316, 0.011287358589470387, -0.06642176955938339, -0.019377660006284714, -0.045081205666065216, -0.007033806759864092, 0.005563861690461636, -0.01351584866642952, -0.028891347348690033, -0.031451113522052765, -0.014344937168061733, 0.02647750824689865, 0.045868758112192154, 0.030600987374782562, 0.02280162088572979, 0.05222591757774353, -0.021674832329154015, -0.04805579036474228 ]
The disordered ferromagnet is a disordered version of the ferromagnetic Ising model in which the coupling constants are non-negative quenched random. A ground configuration is an infinite-volume configuration whose energy cannot be reduced by finite modifications. It is a long-standing challenge to ascertain whether the disordered ferromagnet on the $\mathbb{Z}^D$ lattice admits non-constant ground configurations. We answer this affirmatively in dimensions $D\ge 4$, when the coupling constants are sampled independently from a sufficiently concentrated distribution. The obtained ground configurations are further shown to be translation-covariant with respect to $\mathbb{Z}^{D-1}$ translations of the disorder. Our result is proved by showing that the finite-volume interface formed by Dobrushin boundary conditions is localized, and converges to an infinite-volume interface. This may be expressed in purely combinatorial terms, as a result on the fluctuations of certain minimal cutsets in the lattice $\mathbb{Z}^D$ endowed with independent edge capacities.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06437v2
[ -0.05407368764281273, -0.020205164328217506, 0.021962465718388557, -0.011920745484530926, 0.002124412916600704, 0.026768317446112633, -0.009280608966946602, 0.006339640822261572, -0.04357849434018135, -0.02409127913415432, 0.0254869032651186, -0.06567501276731491, -0.0549192801117897, -0.027608459815382957, -0.06782465428113937, -0.011553260497748852, 0.05382645130157471, 0.03584209457039833, -0.026025384664535522, 0.0026400103233754635, -0.022174470126628876, 0.006230912636965513, -0.026445291936397552, 0.060748208314180374, 0.009718441404402256, -0.011471038684248924, -0.03759044408798218, 0.042975254356861115, 0.024678992107510567, -0.030846836045384407, 0.06063951179385185, -0.03550703451037407, 0.012206032872200012, 0.026509618386626244, -0.057658467441797256, -0.00009593617869541049, -0.025798821821808815, 0.006606339942663908, 0.032947100698947906, -0.06136399507522583, 0.0010600303066894412, 0.007532475516200066, -0.038617175072431564, -0.025312216952443123, -0.02564099058508873, -0.03784238547086716, -0.028668735176324844, 0.0064072804525494576, 0.02493858151137829, -0.07022543996572495, 0.06411541253328323, 0.0024382120463997126, -0.003066467121243477, 0.04182010143995285, -0.04360271245241165, 0.002804849296808243, -0.0011013807961717248, -0.0524221770465374, -0.030065378174185753, -0.028886500746011734, -0.014393026940524578, -0.03670718893408775, 0.010653355158865452, -0.009278317913413048, -0.06816115975379944, -0.022702332586050034, -0.04235334321856499, -0.060320690274238586, -0.04730598255991936, -0.05955317243933678, 0.0038565904833376408, -0.07394753396511078, -0.006087482441216707, 0.003820201149210334, -0.07090751826763153, 0.024717822670936584, -0.0243152417242527, 0.006809277925640345, -0.056486401706933975, -0.016648437827825546, -0.004654397256672382, -0.02437090501189232, -0.028025055304169655, -0.0063762660138309, 0.024048373103141785, 0.04718415439128876, 0.05391344428062439, -0.0020295947324484587, -0.0069889831356704235, -0.03173438087105751, 0.0391077846288681, -0.032926347106695175, -0.06673159450292587, -0.051003020256757736, 0.058896370232105255, -0.0305763129144907, 0.025929728522896767, 0.026939360424876213, 0.015759963542222977, -0.037106845527887344, -0.02258874475955963, -0.046842291951179504, -0.05941098555922508, -0.011143691837787628, -0.03237441927194595, -0.01971844583749771, -0.008803731761872768, -0.01168089546263218, -0.03929685056209564, 0.05763276293873787, -0.016527943313121796, 0.01894155517220497, -0.027871277183294296, -0.04028798267245293, -0.027374694123864174, -0.036406707018613815, 0.04650525003671646, 0.008876324631273746, 0.01335972547531128, 0.010552392341196537, -0.018775517120957375, -0.027201984077692032, 0.04009057953953743, -0.02092200703918934, -0.008717356249690056, 0.003852994181215763, 0.07482152432203293, -0.008138192817568779, 0.04105844348669052, -0.020735319703817368, -0.06525073200464249, -0.0000752730411477387, 0.057995401322841644, -0.039441224187612534, 0.06274046748876572, 0.026631973683834076, 0.02457580529153347, -0.030654320493340492, 0.0017614959506317973, 0.028363555669784546, -0.04080814868211746, -0.06779661029577255, 0.002606663154438138, 0.0373116098344326, -0.013569582253694534, 0.04847080633044243, -0.06906601786613464, -0.011367305181920528, 0.032092735171318054, -0.014499509707093239, -0.03228521719574928, 0.021335935220122337, 0.019945820793509483, 0.011249279603362083, -0.014099315740168095, 0.011129268445074558, 0.017702512443065643, 0.0513918399810791, -0.058876942843198776, 0.04418008029460907, 0.019484175369143486, -0.02248569205403328, -0.009367372840642929, -0.0026772122364491224, -0.0033496671821922064, 0.030202193185687065, 0.02693493664264679, -0.04970763996243477, -0.04021073505282402, 0.031040124595165253, -0.05185195803642273, -0.0051591782830655575, -0.005232856143265963, -0.049085833132267, -0.04068443924188614, -0.054974205791950226, -0.025321774184703827, -0.053260184824466705, -0.01389381755143404, 0.04730687662959099, -0.006139432080090046, 0.007119071204215288, -0.014422820881009102, -0.02639014832675457, -0.03783521056175232, -0.026816364377737045, -0.07915923744440079, 0.02763224020600319, 0.0015545968199148774, 0.020733345299959183, -0.03230985254049301, -0.03207102790474892, 0.008368328213691711, -0.0046873618848621845, -0.04619910567998886, 0.012416744604706764, 0.025892188772559166, -0.047063469886779785, -0.03611224889755249, 0.029214050620794296, -0.07068786025047302, -0.050821125507354736, -0.033750928938388824, 0.018692104145884514, -0.027803191915154457, -0.06792936474084854, -0.033471547067165375, 0.06570734828710556, -0.04144296422600746, -0.012449595145881176, 0.07157213985919952, 0.012812654487788677, 0.06540127843618393, -0.015956711024045944, 0.019582532346248627, -0.00933920219540596, -0.08724531531333923, 0.06006831303238869, 0.012333735823631287, -0.023789789527654648, 0.03182414174079895, 0.019316643476486206, 0.0007018480682745576, -0.03900045156478882, -0.02762698009610176, 0.07549624145030975, 0.06832282990217209, 0.025941887870430946, -0.02338217943906784, -0.0665462538599968, 0.01051772478967905, -0.051824137568473816, -0.04902365803718567, -0.058420754969120026, -0.04225168377161026, -0.017514897510409355, -0.04347489774227142, 0.031385637819767, -0.02574414573609829, -0.04360148310661316, -0.06463126093149185, 0.0001665070012677461, 0.06666772067546844, 0.008586886338889599, -0.04885515570640564, -0.05612334609031677, -0.05555681511759758, 0.007986047305166721, -0.06800533086061478, -0.029410643503069878, 0.017204614356160164, -0.07344513386487961, -0.0050236196257174015, -0.05876527354121208, 0.006873318459838629, 0.05613913759589195, -0.05791819468140602, 0.008575811982154846, 0.04222233220934868, 0.03346708416938782, 0.0206195879727602, 0.011487292125821114, -0.03375997766852379, -0.004508429206907749, 0.050924427807331085, 0.008571264334022999, -0.055649738758802414, -0.013401268981397152, -0.017848670482635498, -0.027164161205291748, 0.03985145315527916, 0.027969587594270706, 0.007013986818492413, 0.01463903859257698, -0.012762138620018959, -0.018629251047968864, -0.015808161348104477, -0.014943755231797695, -0.0019691642373800278, -0.007887360639870167, 0.03992852568626404, 0.03326956555247307, -0.015440247021615505, -0.07390513271093369, 0.01876581273972988, -0.022289931774139404, -0.020870395004749298, -0.04126885533332825, -0.057284675538539886, -0.05150659754872322, -0.0695573166012764, -0.04207603633403778, -0.0361814945936203, -0.03519576042890549, -0.023414531722664833, -0.027102967724204063, -0.020066292956471443, -0.02242918312549591, -0.027759574353694916, -0.06653760373592377, -0.045680124312639236, 0.01736416295170784, 0.002246677642688155, -0.010706629604101181, 0.0007170345052145422, -0.04492447152733803, -0.038189370185136795, 0.020577432587742805, 0.010759602300822735, -0.020684298127889633, -0.031506847590208054, 0.004700222983956337, -0.04778661951422691, 0.009462574496865273, 0.04537489265203476, 0.03144451230764389, 0.009641831740736961, -0.027858493849635124, 0.04319286346435547, 0.025423936545848846, -0.027273500338196754, -0.013273956254124641, -0.0010595202911645174, -0.013512582518160343, -0.04172762483358383, -0.03356558829545975, 0.05417156592011452, 0.05226767435669899, -0.0070553128607571125, -0.007874769158661366, -0.05167752876877785, 0.006219686008989811, 0.02024136483669281, -0.04912329837679863, 0.058591436594724655, 0.06318194419145584, -0.0303510669618845, -0.0032143837306648493, -0.0071570309810340405, 0.011593933217227459, -0.01854601316154003, 0.010872418992221355, -0.011761736124753952, -0.0036816736683249474, 0.039388369768857956, -0.060227829962968826, 0.021349726244807243, 0.03871934860944748, 0.03195395693182945, -0.024412987753748894, -0.030500859022140503, 0.013048582710325718, 0.018747573718428612, 0.03485319763422012, 0.002140508498996496, 0.002155163325369358, 0.034691404551267624, 0.06882362812757492, -0.005488727707415819, -0.04337941110134125, -0.04748420789837837, -0.07516172528266907, -0.01659020036458969, 0.032730456441640854, 0.06502041965723038, 0.046567223966121674, 0.016252610832452774, 0.0101908128708601, 0.04882240667939186, -0.015288311056792736, 0.06893762946128845, -0.024598898366093636, -0.020199546590447426, 0.01388646475970745, 0.008343825116753578, -0.030351167544722557, 0.013608397915959358, 0.030077839270234108, -0.028118304908275604, -0.037474941462278366, 0.04261050373315811, -0.06102621555328369, 0.03023642860352993, 0.014596188440918922, 0.02133380062878132, 0.056547049432992935, 0.02359813079237938, 0.006782731506973505, 0.03920597583055496, -0.036983609199523926, 0.02679496258497238, 0.0040835426189005375, -0.013976511545479298, 0.020455030724406242, -0.024725202471017838, -0.057800162583589554, 0.01606793887913227, 0.03502668812870979, -0.051213860511779785, -0.02378109097480774, 0.052411679178476334, 0.020365683361887932, -0.0556253045797348, -0.07162615656852722, 0.010629642754793167, -0.04005666449666023, 0.013621085323393345, -0.013701875694096088, -0.06495165079832077, 0.06430068612098694, 0.043090514838695526, -0.001765460823662579, -0.02500142529606819, -0.050441838800907135, -0.026908742263913155, -0.039171092212200165, -0.036190517246723175, -0.03270591422915459, 0.004155884031206369, -0.0572553351521492, 0.04730184003710747, -0.03160868585109711, -0.03670340031385422, -0.07022494077682495, 0.05625654011964798, -0.00735661294311285, 0.01947755552828312, 0.0380709245800972, 0.026530442759394646, 0.002387224230915308, 0.01326734945178032, -0.022874927148222923, -0.038787778466939926, -0.011275806464254856, -0.005302674137055874, -0.03156587481498718, -0.044974979013204575, -0.06991543620824814, -0.04296577349305153, -0.04946840554475784, -0.002342297462746501, 0.033889248967170715, -0.0397697277367115, -0.017613176256418228, 0.0040639303624629974, 0.01631665602326393, -0.05119972676038742, -0.04458944499492645, -0.006964624393731356, -0.03121064603328705, -0.07662612199783325, 0.016450120136141777, -0.017062660306692123, -0.01346852257847786, 0.0005047845770604908, 0.05243614315986633, 0.006324986927211285, -0.010437235236167908, -0.01772797293961048, -0.0037667949218302965, 0.03978900611400604, 0.0380188524723053, -0.03492116928100586, -0.026234768331050873, -0.03640143945813179, 0.028543224558234215, -0.009649974294006824, 0.002446476835757494, 0.02250813879072666, 0.040720682591199875, -0.0005202758475206792, 0.03513118624687195, -0.05649986490607262, 0.03216820955276489, 0.07350502163171768, -0.05773899704217911, -0.04005705565214157, 0.03352116420865059, -0.04108608514070511, 0.021783074364066124, -0.043764106929302216, 0.04173768684267998, 0.002369104651734233, 0.008695960976183414, 0.0010127485729753971, -0.0007296985131688416, -0.05032310262322426, -0.022005613893270493, 0.04300727695226669, 0.006169124040752649, -0.06432392448186874, 0.002240460831671953, 0.0017446536803618073, -0.002088276669383049, -0.05359414219856262, 0.02237492799758911, 0.017472829669713974, -0.05577302724123001, -0.04777640104293823, 0.02811204083263874, 0.012339199893176556, 0.022342856973409653, 0.03358231857419014, -0.06389287114143372, -0.017084641382098198, 0.04159129410982132, -0.025738557800650597, 0.035524241626262665, 0.03616055101156235, 0.008728181943297386, -0.003235143842175603, 0.008788001723587513, -0.04811742529273033, -0.06524956226348877, 0.0352570004761219, -0.015129921026527882, 0.027557875961065292, 0.003589111613109708, -0.00892325397580862, 0.03534824401140213, 0.03309859707951546, -0.016687562689185143, -0.04214131087064743, 0.015086142346262932, -0.03755592182278633, 0.06425239145755768, -0.018600115552544594, 0.005696621257811785, 0.014506540261209011, 0.015998288989067078, -0.00660389568656683, -0.024411430582404137, -0.03285239636898041, -0.01729368232190609, -0.005616238806396723, -0.025296054780483246, 0.022391149774193764, 0.000985141727142036, -0.02413179539144039, -0.023072823882102966, 0.04071751609444618, -0.041974026709795, 0.043282877653837204, 0.01748868264257908, 0.025213776156306267, 0.007997525855898857, 0.017895294353365898, 0.05317959561944008, -0.03483261540532112, -0.02053009904921055, 0.06447065621614456, -0.06573955714702606, 0.02567468024790287, -0.035573747009038925, -0.05593980476260185, -0.005241622216999531, -0.0539218969643116, 0.004229106940329075, 0.017734266817569733, -0.015434380620718002, 0.011394631117582321, 0.01937289908528328, 0.02462603524327278, -0.07182396948337555, 0.0019854644779115915, 0.05998094379901886, -0.06807716935873032, 0.02738935686647892, -0.01993684284389019, -0.037208009511232376, -0.05016480013728142, 0.03488646447658539, -0.0541379377245903, -0.018122537061572075, -0.044776588678359985, 0.06770472973585129, 0.055418260395526886, -0.05184270069003105, 0.011330385692417622, 0.01033701840788126, -0.010811001062393188, 0.0019591590389609337, -0.04452410340309143, -0.004491778090596199, -0.03946305066347122, 0.008774262852966785, -0.018331794068217278, -0.03278011083602905, 0.025177983567118645, 0.029230872169137, 0.0006546734366565943, 0.004412177484482527, 0.06271824240684509, 0.023664679378271103, 0.004627453628927469, -0.03394629433751106, -0.02753794752061367, 0.036104075610637665, -0.014813682995736599, 0.039764404296875, -0.04002726450562477, 0.02209182269871235, -0.04831915721297264, 0.027272343635559082, -0.0013137029018253088, -0.012316561304032803, 0.01409953273832798, 0.011020627804100513, -0.05870634689927101, 0.007651337888091803, -0.03114073909819126, 0.0010135768679901958, -0.03334185108542442, 0.041683707386255264, 0.011807801201939583, 0.03607696294784546, -0.022975357249379158, 0.00560112064704299, 0.010265890508890152, 0.011157795786857605, -0.01707647368311882, -0.0058824471198022366, 0.007392225321382284, -0.05609217286109924, 0.07722517848014832, -0.0659734234213829, 0.035588450729846954, -0.027934584766626358, -0.0461970791220665, 0.03827287629246712, -0.035129614174366, -0.04088382050395012, 0.03105367347598076, 0.0031366890762001276, -0.04873985797166824, -0.01798994652926922, 0.013457865454256535, -0.022812949493527412, -0.07926823943853378, 0.013620725832879543, -0.010129706934094429, -0.0002367218694416806, 0.056928254663944244, 0.01892193779349327, -0.006946615409106016, 0.018778260797262192, 0.06412438303232193, 0.032731182873249054, 0.03885665535926819, 0.04297909140586853, -0.02216828055679798, 0.04593630135059357, -0.03894073888659477, -0.008862442336976528, -0.024569809436798096, -0.021333154290914536, -0.016915302723646164, -0.041410893201828, 0.04060341790318489, -0.02538483217358589, 0.04174197465181351, -0.04042956233024597, -0.023731645196676254, 0.0681837871670723, 0.015012512914836407, 0.009205411188304424, -0.07910401374101639, -0.008399796672165394, 0.018386851996183395, 0.009336261078715324, -0.026457734405994415, -0.011463677510619164, -0.041649140417575836, -0.01753769814968109, -0.07764250785112381, -0.03976219519972801, 0.010278601199388504, 0.0535806305706501, 0.010624668560922146, -0.03623715043067932, -0.01582626812160015, -0.014373116195201874, 0.002241382608190179, 0.0012980292085558176, 0.02898927964270115, 0.024024290964007378, 0.018069561570882797, 0.011224312707781792, -0.04474377632141113, 0.023454980924725533, 0.04132949188351631, -0.022537633776664734, -0.017175624147057533, 0.016071978956460953, 0.008046054281294346, -0.006300447974354029, 0.02786560356616974, 0.006209660321474075, -0.050470106303691864, 0.0391029492020607, -0.06160958483815193, -0.019406849518418312, -0.03293946385383606, -0.08022355288267136, 0.06378395855426788, -0.04331280291080475, 0.011012976989150047, -0.011566286906599998, -0.03850594907999039, -0.06220176815986633, -0.04829614609479904, -0.07377425581216812, 0.0388936810195446, 0.03298353776335716, -0.047521356493234634, 0.055519722402095795, -0.050993893295526505, -0.029978884384036064, 0.00989833939820528, -0.03172536566853523, -0.02732202410697937, 0.018411921337246895, 0.036379434168338776, -0.032957691699266434, 0.014897601678967476, -0.02948347106575966, 0.04077054560184479, -0.026340093463659286, 0.04901988431811333, 0.028844140470027924, 0.05251400172710419, -0.059873126447200775, -0.0036095203831791878, -0.06749702990055084, -0.049873728305101395, 0.052078746259212494, -0.06300156563520432, 0.025128807872533798, -0.015158666297793388, 0.011828034184873104, 0.0020202575251460075, 0.04300567880272865, -0.004776853136718273, 0.04333113133907318, 0.018059615045785904, -0.0049187056720256805, 0.033665068447589874, -0.0023940843529999256, -0.020516367629170418, 0.04182147607207298, 0.02093612775206566, -0.04523785784840584, -0.061564184725284576, 0.02234034612774849, -0.003692114260047674, -0.004484185017645359, -0.009785836562514305, 0.03890591859817505, 0.04284590110182762, -0.01660136692225933, -0.029149191454052925, 0.05393518880009651, -0.0107071902602911, -0.041999440640211105, 0.04260729253292084, -0.011610619723796844, 0.00905565731227398, -0.06138909235596657 ]
We construct a nontrivial generalization of the paradigmatic Kuramoto model by using an additional coupling term that explicitly breaks its rotational symmetry resulting in a variant of the Winfree Model. Consequently, we observe the characteristic features of the phase diagrams of both the Kuramoto model and the Winfree model depending on the degree of the symmetry breaking coupling strength for unimodal frequency distribution. The phase diagrams of both the Kuramoto and the Winfree models resemble each other for symmetric bimodal frequency distribution for a range of the symmetry breaking coupling strength except for region shift and difference in the degree of spread of the macroscopic dynamical states and bistable regions. The dynamical transitions in the bistable states are characterized by an abrupt (first-order) transition in both the forward and reverse traces. For asymmetric bimodal frequency distribution, the onset of bistable regions depends on the degree of the asymmetry. Large degree of the symmetry breaking coupling strength promotes the synchronized stationary state, while a large degree of heterogeneity, proportional to the separation between the two central frequencies, facilitates the spread of the incoherent and standing wave states in the phase diagram for a low strength of the symmetry breaking coupling. We deduce the low-dimensional equations of motion for the complex order parameters using the Ott-Antonsen ansatz for both unimodal and bimodal frequency distributions. We also deduce the Hopf, pitchfork, and saddle-node bifurcation curves from the evolution equations for the complex order parameters mediating the dynamical transitions. Simulation results of the original discrete set of equations of the generalized Kuramoto model agree well with the analytical bifurcation curves.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14341v1
[ 0.01216502021998167, -0.0017151815118268132, 0.03141728788614273, 0.03688501566648483, 0.016329560428857803, -0.021605292335152626, 0.010962157510221004, 0.06628629565238953, 0.023172469809651375, 0.02308419905602932, -0.05445736646652222, -0.03716045245528221, -0.0652211531996727, -0.06122253090143204, -0.06340353935956955, 0.002531441394239664, 0.06230651214718819, 0.02904641628265381, -0.07676524668931961, 0.06970963627099991, 0.03377484530210495, -0.01250653900206089, -0.04736601188778877, 0.062457770109176636, -0.0457853265106678, -0.0430268868803978, -0.04697837680578232, 0.005944511387497187, -0.02438129484653473, -0.015073324553668499, 0.057576362043619156, 0.01288452185690403, -0.009849412366747856, -0.022021621465682983, -0.03477843478322029, -0.012606622651219368, 0.006212024018168449, 0.027271578088402748, 0.042791713029146194, -0.019963346421718597, -0.01678156852722168, -0.04998628795146942, 0.011528188362717628, 0.01487419381737709, -0.031662195920944214, 0.024851888418197632, -0.018882468342781067, -0.023051699623465538, -0.012636001221835613, -0.03087562508881092, 0.03712531179189682, 0.02055315487086773, 0.023496145382523537, 0.06749621778726578, -0.038997359573841095, -0.016195643693208694, 0.0035978760570287704, 0.009819080121815205, -0.043518513441085815, -0.01647811383008957, 0.0015397625975310802, 0.01945439539849758, 0.047855496406555176, -0.02876073494553566, -0.03011428751051426, 0.03866175562143326, -0.03873838484287262, -0.06121232360601425, 0.0014600574504584074, -0.0377291701734066, 0.047747593373060226, -0.052989158779382706, 0.026507414877414703, 0.03232946991920471, -0.07535035908222198, 0.011639195494353771, -0.011641338467597961, -0.00863347016274929, 0.03439411520957947, -0.006301225163042545, 0.03274010494351387, 0.025554940104484558, 0.009704386815428734, 0.04825684055685997, 0.03449500724673271, 0.030366569757461548, 0.042367398738861084, 0.010034220293164253, -0.027734892442822456, -0.045242562890052795, 0.0056518311612308025, -0.0257897786796093, -0.06762708723545074, -0.04081890359520912, 0.04460084065794945, -0.01760164089500904, 0.06138908118009567, -0.002013933379203081, 0.010127549059689045, -0.009984425269067287, -0.032523948699235916, -0.05271688103675842, -0.035971205681562424, 0.043018463999032974, 0.030016714707016945, -0.05041763186454773, -0.002580029657110572, 0.03495250642299652, -0.02911018580198288, 0.012502753175795078, -0.021140342578291893, 0.003960483707487583, 0.02782288007438183, -0.03610267862677574, -0.0034717426169663668, -0.04998281970620155, 0.05556409806013107, 0.021503303200006485, 0.03409155458211899, -0.033138208091259, -0.05229445919394493, 0.03690067678689957, -0.011106837540864944, 0.03364185616374016, -0.008890212513506413, 0.0237177312374115, 0.05730564519762993, 0.022196175530552864, 0.008798118680715561, -0.040012191981077194, -0.0020673840772360563, -0.008546896278858185, 0.013775265775620937, -0.01455788966268301, 0.03772226348519325, -0.004569477401673794, 0.060728054493665695, -0.011134935542941093, 0.01676146499812603, 0.02308700419962406, -0.004579748958349228, -0.047763559967279434, 0.0030044910963624716, 0.024683037772774696, 0.02726198546588421, 0.005383927375078201, -0.07595614343881607, -0.006832705345004797, 0.03740599378943443, 0.010598802007734776, 0.01652601733803749, -0.029907524585723877, 0.04690259322524071, 0.048162560909986496, 0.017430000007152557, -0.037068191915750504, 0.07468405365943909, 0.005632112268358469, -0.03282085061073303, 0.042497728019952774, 0.016689660027623177, 0.004619079641997814, 0.03766457736492157, 0.015108268707990646, 0.018502939492464066, -0.02969820238649845, 0.0627913624048233, 0.0007294015376828611, -0.02133987657725811, -0.0121422428637743, -0.02867763303220272, 0.07379589974880219, 0.0607222244143486, -0.03946734964847565, -0.046233583241701126, -0.021404091268777847, -0.02922644093632698, -0.03791862726211548, 0.007340423762798309, -0.0022266607265919447, 0.026440344750881195, 0.008798438124358654, -0.04429382085800171, -0.01411335077136755, -0.042791254818439484, -0.02561955526471138, -0.08552989363670349, 0.031988877803087234, 0.05623321607708931, -0.028576938435435295, -0.019986549392342567, -0.06769614666700363, 0.016655029729008675, 0.017425455152988434, -0.030631255358457565, -0.04624900594353676, -0.013134026899933815, -0.03196600452065468, -0.01379746850579977, 0.04598945379257202, -0.06591392308473587, -0.0038966373540461063, -0.015761977061629295, -0.0032113571651279926, 0.03814312815666199, -0.013913332484662533, 0.008052116259932518, 0.024528013542294502, -0.07811065763235092, 0.004289743024855852, 0.0375882126390934, 0.02454911358654499, 0.05084482952952385, -0.032695136964321136, -0.012918954715132713, -0.029396532103419304, -0.09358566254377365, -0.017864596098661423, -0.017285587266087532, 0.002772629028186202, 0.011364427395164967, 0.03945736214518547, -0.02577097713947296, -0.028885578736662865, -0.01290229894220829, 0.048598576337099075, 0.08052517473697662, -0.020262474194169044, -0.04401581734418869, -0.04659125581383705, -0.027628900483250618, -0.027695605531334877, -0.057402584701776505, -0.04449068009853363, -0.03918501362204552, 0.009350643493235111, -0.055277492851018906, 0.02532241865992546, 0.0075112502090632915, -0.06820710003376007, -0.054989855736494064, -0.039029765874147415, 0.03174913674592972, -0.03746839985251427, 0.024587688967585564, -0.009558404795825481, -0.05855335295200348, 0.03914877772331238, -0.035019200295209885, -0.010909167118370533, 0.018276246264576912, -0.062046464532613754, -0.0036566981580108404, -0.02202102541923523, 0.02148273214697838, 0.06922891736030579, -0.05400137975811958, 0.014328583143651485, 0.0096012894064188, 0.024300467222929, -0.02070675604045391, -0.0041850535199046135, -0.07867566496133804, 0.05592775344848633, -0.04436061158776283, 0.0068154726177453995, -0.0627313107252121, -0.01452990435063839, 0.010118522681295872, -0.07011988759040833, -0.038767457008361816, -0.024268120527267456, 0.05766032636165619, -0.03322642669081688, 0.03701082989573479, 0.04271959885954857, -0.03783609718084335, -0.03088369406759739, 0.016748875379562378, 0.031038347631692886, 0.06800013780593872, 0.00017629725334700197, -0.04823973774909973, -0.035107411444187164, -0.01611942984163761, -0.029691413044929504, 0.005309474188834429, -0.05615655332803726, -0.04897239804267883, -0.06237122789025307, -0.07716907560825348, -0.0355837345123291, -0.043838828802108765, 0.015158573165535927, -0.01223148126155138, -0.0480625294148922, -0.015638843178749084, 0.011292512528598309, -0.01584431901574135, -0.04883286729454994, -0.05718750134110451, -0.011030320078134537, 0.035320110619068146, 0.0020453771576285362, -0.052599065005779266, -0.04101019352674484, -0.001688749180175364, -0.0011462861439213157, 0.03250927850604057, -0.021407637745141983, -0.016998544335365295, -0.022128092125058174, -0.029114799574017525, 0.01074503269046545, -0.00885570328682661, 0.02953997068107128, 0.053926292806863785, -0.0037983465008437634, 0.023469537496566772, -0.05458357185125351, 0.005989406257867813, 0.009721317328512669, -0.0008818891947157681, 0.02109416201710701, -0.05424553155899048, -0.03238658234477043, 0.062016818672418594, 0.06582003831863403, 0.00036136299604550004, -0.010657204315066338, -0.025814499706029892, -0.031934719532728195, -0.021538693457841873, -0.024158025160431862, 0.06883265823125839, 0.05920395255088806, -0.011459406465291977, -0.021503105759620667, -0.03455108031630516, 0.008043055422604084, -0.020051034167408943, 0.04186434671282768, 0.01781885139644146, 0.02813809923827648, 0.03678656369447708, -0.07760651409626007, 0.005900457967072725, 0.044572215527296066, 0.025708436965942383, -0.03088747337460518, -0.004898747429251671, -0.0475742369890213, 0.025435909628868103, 0.01884531043469906, 0.03951530531048775, 0.004672905430197716, 0.04506327584385872, 0.07216070592403412, 0.0032395287416875362, -0.054869018495082855, -0.030328715220093727, -0.07335655391216278, -0.018358102068305016, 0.0075094131752848625, 0.011530093848705292, 0.011061202734708786, 0.04385485127568245, 0.023658012971282005, 0.03469081223011017, -0.032979726791381836, 0.058888111263513565, -0.0026231042575091124, -0.05466142296791077, 0.018729139119386673, 0.0015294061740860343, -0.007754277903586626, -0.02727564238011837, -0.018932532519102097, 0.022595981135964394, -0.06239667907357216, 0.03145682439208031, -0.02422516979277134, -0.0032734128180891275, 0.006431215908378363, 0.019536135718226433, 0.044338226318359375, 0.03819175809621811, 0.010283280164003372, 0.05216813459992409, 0.03711091727018356, 0.015085138380527496, -0.01733127050101757, 0.01504190731793642, 0.0002748813130892813, 0.010987534187734127, -0.06496381759643555, 0.009044124744832516, 0.0018695131875574589, -0.01907808892428875, -0.004559025634080172, 0.03067348338663578, 0.014699749648571014, -0.006318244151771069, -0.07793968915939331, 0.027857515960931778, -0.0533519983291626, 0.03905323147773743, -0.0077832769602537155, -0.055643487721681595, 0.062493931502103806, 0.012832589447498322, 0.002347493078559637, -0.002017914317548275, -0.027303798124194145, -0.059081122279167175, -0.021141696721315384, -0.023582175374031067, -0.02922578901052475, 0.055490344762802124, -0.05399644374847412, 0.02159094251692295, -0.021468905732035637, 0.02423294633626938, -0.01383737102150917, -0.004464458208531141, -0.02758641727268696, 0.03183790296316147, 0.01976913958787918, 0.031229417771100998, 0.012520302087068558, -0.015742482617497444, -0.05956830829381943, 0.03525041416287422, 0.03772396966814995, -0.012121878564357758, -0.038174983114004135, 0.005699828267097473, -0.0340866856276989, -0.013458963483572006, -0.020914677530527115, 0.0275957640260458, 0.03347394987940788, -0.07869307696819305, -0.06743783503770828, -0.007407987955957651, 0.03660060092806816, -0.03363732621073723, -0.04634780436754227, -0.04525039345026016, -0.01951872929930687, -0.04746290668845177, -0.0041932049207389355, -0.05224495381116867, -0.004810838028788567, -0.007294680457562208, 0.029884986579418182, 0.04845550283789635, -0.002194415545091033, 0.0004643114225473255, 0.03503112494945526, 0.04243697226047516, 0.05129559338092804, -0.0004914475721307099, -0.04750862717628479, -0.03295425325632095, -0.014409942552447319, -0.006619643419981003, -0.0057494984939694405, -0.03624292463064194, 0.02317904308438301, -0.00710621802136302, 0.02066793479025364, -0.07843998074531555, 0.0349760577082634, 0.028546882793307304, -0.03914589062333107, -0.01283723022788763, 0.042689867317676544, -0.05255862697958946, 0.03513939306139946, -0.002306555397808552, 0.02664654329419136, -0.003760900814086199, -0.018618127331137657, -0.019333509728312492, 0.03248277306556702, -0.04246930405497551, 0.007947996258735657, 0.04500267282128334, 0.004278935492038727, -0.053697846829891205, 0.007688183803111315, -0.033948756754398346, -0.0356774777173996, -0.06769658625125885, 0.019933192059397697, 0.05184674263000488, -0.017165565863251686, -0.05008997023105621, 0.04395533725619316, -0.017186779528856277, -0.023144548758864403, 0.03960387781262398, -0.03645569086074829, 0.002429737476631999, 0.06135350093245506, -0.002966906875371933, -0.012122451327741146, 0.014285449869930744, 0.02066846750676632, -0.028735337778925896, 0.01531949546188116, -0.003183103399351239, -0.0469643697142601, -0.033799879252910614, -0.02155662514269352, 0.022973092272877693, -0.03877900168299675, 0.03557403013110161, 0.055585891008377075, 0.019765103235840797, -0.029543327167630196, -0.0437224805355072, -0.021777909249067307, 0.00798715278506279, 0.04321557283401489, -0.06831589341163635, 0.02958107739686966, 0.009193500503897667, 0.06448569148778915, 0.001009774161502719, -0.01926460675895214, -0.026437796652317047, -0.05515854060649872, -0.050249822437763214, -0.025059286504983902, 0.018803728744387627, 0.020442405715584755, -0.02399967797100544, -0.013268493115901947, 0.036304060369729996, -0.05388692766427994, 0.015131202526390553, -0.0008211075328290462, -0.0206863135099411, 0.0038429806008934975, -0.03416912630200386, 0.014995823614299297, -0.030247274786233902, 0.005273353308439255, 0.06433681398630142, -0.07294056564569473, 0.04494110867381096, 0.028759952634572983, -0.05136537551879883, -0.053019680082798004, -0.02538737654685974, 0.0196994561702013, 0.03193629905581474, -0.0441238097846508, -0.04612264409661293, 0.055246010422706604, -0.01654854044318199, -0.05663470923900604, -0.03540973737835884, 0.04228775203227997, -0.0670941174030304, -0.03256053104996681, 0.026430966332554817, -0.06411083787679672, -0.00935136154294014, -0.019994137808680534, -0.0021677555050700903, -0.06179390102624893, -0.062462225556373596, 0.025501439347863197, 0.05024511367082596, -0.029742633923888206, 0.01805727556347847, 0.016763849183917046, -0.02102983556687832, -0.004588189069181681, -0.053657416254282, -0.0077394056133925915, -0.003998525440692902, 0.007460651453584433, -0.026234228163957596, -0.013904671184718609, 0.0008890086319297552, 0.07231716066598892, -0.03830995038151741, -0.01917712576687336, 0.02693568356335163, 0.003383534261956811, 0.05379938334226608, -0.06137706711888313, -0.046456724405288696, -0.00856038648635149, -0.022504614666104317, 0.032014794647693634, -0.04913289472460747, 0.008183023892343044, 0.01182809378951788, 0.06223873421549797, 0.012119975872337818, -0.019042732194066048, 0.0019190605962648988, -0.0003295339993201196, 0.0030672838911414146, -0.00986434891819954, -0.05964658036828041, 0.04059344902634621, 0.02970716543495655, 0.03174450621008873, -0.01782512106001377, 0.06168793514370918, -0.04420223832130432, -0.019208792597055435, -0.009818990714848042, 0.06578196585178375, 0.01032743975520134, -0.0026594968512654305, 0.023221531882882118, 0.04246889054775238, 0.04173845797777176, -0.038647983223199844, 0.0002482803538441658, 0.006011896766722202, -0.067392997443676, 0.03265250101685524, -0.04710448160767555, -0.04742873087525368, -0.02267915941774845, 0.023916013538837433, -0.05709652602672577, 0.009047244675457478, 0.03116660937666893, -0.0473884642124176, -0.06787854433059692, -0.002288509625941515, -0.002121178200468421, 0.005124871619045734, 0.041638247668743134, -0.022286806255578995, 0.015567618422210217, -0.043597616255283356, 0.06880464404821396, 0.06465259194374084, -0.016237054020166397, -0.0005351891741156578, -0.07515033334493637, -0.034292202442884445, -0.013052977621555328, -0.018230320885777473, -0.022431517019867897, -0.005825852509588003, -0.04712869971990585, -0.05901084095239639, 0.015405166894197464, -0.004675966687500477, -0.011171911843121052, -0.048177093267440796, -0.06478407233953476, 0.017855685204267502, 0.023591818287968636, -0.02897506020963192, -0.08251111209392548, 0.01788061484694481, 0.0035923952236771584, -0.008082195185124874, -0.04206415265798569, -0.0036012649070471525, -0.07453116774559021, 0.030961714684963226, -0.06283615529537201, -0.008685287088155746, 0.017967650666832924, 0.07256315648555756, 0.01625758223235607, 0.0035101028624922037, 0.01053574774414301, -0.03277501463890076, 0.0085722291842103, 0.006849822122603655, -0.030474893748760223, 0.020463373512029648, 0.029072431847453117, 0.0020343135111033916, -0.06546726077795029, -0.04757227748632431, 0.07006580382585526, -0.027584301307797432, -0.032550472766160965, 0.02373131364583969, 0.02265838347375393, -0.016801360994577408, 0.02790858782827854, 0.00586449820548296, 0.04145274683833122, 0.02066658064723015, -0.038466885685920715, -0.022854553535580635, -0.027820907533168793, -0.03162116929888725, -0.007938084192574024, -0.030200166627764702, 0.03867927938699722, -0.02380896359682083, -0.03543369099497795, -0.03501597046852112, -0.037447258830070496, -0.050989262759685516, 0.06994980573654175, -0.003397604450583458, 0.0016536660259589553, 0.061223022639751434, -0.029602067545056343, 0.0033810343593358994, 0.009456930682063103, 0.01773809641599655, -0.03915281593799591, 0.01683186925947666, -0.043356046080589294, -0.050109509378671646, 0.02871328964829445, -0.035304389894008636, -0.002249025506898761, -0.05150347948074341, -0.009991235099732876, 0.020891115069389343, 0.04110695794224739, -0.03814580664038658, -0.021593667566776276, -0.05624961853027344, -0.0525689572095871, -0.000511322810780257, -0.05576464161276817, 0.006103176157921553, -0.012728641740977764, 0.03735935688018799, 0.002650281647220254, 0.0496252104640007, -0.00047584527055732906, 0.06326057761907578, 0.02955535426735878, 0.059812068939208984, -0.044119954109191895, -0.017509985715150833, -0.03483836352825165, 0.01970501057803631, -0.02925015427172184, -0.02621903270483017, -0.017098305746912956, 0.017645452171564102, 0.0010613788617774844, 0.014780785888433456, 0.009630179964005947, 0.000608209113124758, -0.00480969762429595, -0.05570537969470024, -0.023189298808574677, 0.0408184714615345, -0.028951628133654594, -0.06356773525476456, 0.0380290187895298, -0.017255110666155815, -0.028417464345693588, -0.04642513021826744 ]
Radio Relics are typically found to be arc-like regions of synchrotron emission in the outskirts of merging galaxy clusters, bowing out from the cluster center. In most cases they show synchrotron spectra that steepen towards the cluster center, indicating that they are caused by relativistic electrons being accelerated at outwards traveling merger shocks. A number of radio relics break with this ideal picture and show morphologies that are bent the opposite way and show spectral index distributions which do not follow expectations from the ideal picture. We propose that these `Wrong Way' Relics can form when an outwards travelling shock wave is bent inwards by an in-falling galaxy cluster or group. We test this in an ultra-high resolution zoom-in simulation of a massive galaxy cluster with an on-the-fly spectral Cosmic Ray model. This allows us to study not only the synchrotron emission at colliding shocks, but also their synchrotron spectra to adress the open question of relics with strongly varying spectral indices over the relic surface.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.00046v2
[ -0.033944759517908096, -0.0007377485162578523, -0.015749800950288773, 0.004231221973896027, 0.03336416557431221, -0.007341477554291487, -0.024470632895827293, 0.04010816290974617, -0.04429393261671066, -0.00638701394200325, 0.029725149273872375, -0.064777672290802, -0.03309323638677597, -0.07622602581977844, -0.007717434782534838, 0.025347616523504257, 0.0746077373623848, 0.038567762821912766, -0.05863769352436066, 0.04605739936232567, 0.03441555052995682, 0.052191752940416336, 0.0015746286371722817, 0.023818759247660637, 0.014079606160521507, -0.012988538481295109, 0.000729861727450043, 0.034596845507621765, -0.038807500153779984, 0.003264825092628598, 0.07063848525285721, 0.0015513505786657333, -0.0010775504633784294, -0.005043092183768749, 0.005147202406078577, 0.02775305137038231, 0.0522598959505558, 0.04133288562297821, 0.04194062575697899, -0.011038560420274734, -0.0405832976102829, -0.04914384335279465, -0.030083073303103447, 0.004393722862005234, -0.06192238628864288, -0.055002450942993164, -0.027591029182076454, 0.026593150570988655, -0.022710124030709267, -0.05518396943807602, -0.011001880280673504, -0.006542476359754801, 0.04528438672423363, 0.06520666927099228, -0.030476095154881477, -0.03029685653746128, 0.038279563188552856, 0.006193756125867367, -0.028850780799984932, 0.015308208763599396, -0.06023141369223595, -0.044050950556993484, 0.00029242978780530393, -0.028235819190740585, -0.020196517929434776, 0.023692544549703598, -0.039616286754608154, -0.06421422958374023, -0.0013951462460681796, -0.014587314799427986, 0.024909494444727898, -0.06720384210348129, -0.017886800691485405, 0.03792145103216171, -0.06690656393766403, 0.023706085979938507, -0.029452931135892868, -0.0343063659965992, 0.0420202761888504, 0.015706174075603485, -0.02917982079088688, -0.017849057912826538, 0.037434980273246765, 0.041369449347257614, 0.012452499009668827, 0.05513463541865349, 0.0575590506196022, 0.02855108678340912, -0.011636150069534779, -0.04657527431845665, 0.03155655041337013, 0.0003835310344584286, -0.05694922059774399, -0.031163452193140984, 0.06410355865955353, -0.02536672353744507, 0.07417960464954376, 0.02599557489156723, 0.037265241146087646, -0.0007892485009506345, -0.00572997098788619, -0.06255995482206345, -0.010227440856397152, 0.025985991582274437, 0.011651449836790562, -0.033320728689432144, -0.0063250563107430935, -0.017729396000504494, -0.03298492357134819, 0.05548595264554024, -0.026213837787508965, -0.008262937888503075, 0.05593450739979744, -0.054454121738672256, -0.028048500418663025, -0.039671916514635086, 0.03637225925922394, -0.011128051206469536, 0.009067128412425518, 0.027196524664759636, -0.05217321589589119, 0.04442765936255455, -0.010013938881456852, -0.019806601107120514, -0.003523851977661252, -0.005170741584151983, 0.06401357054710388, 0.039845023304224014, -0.005230064503848553, -0.035446781665086746, -0.04008321091532707, 0.014793897047638893, -0.009402435272932053, -0.026325708255171776, 0.006938200909644365, -0.008737553842365742, 0.05860515311360359, 0.04147622361779213, 0.009678889997303486, -0.016596736386418343, 0.046336282044649124, -0.04804458096623421, 0.06054045259952545, 0.015864992514252663, -0.03451696038246155, 0.029026221483945847, -0.06741916388273239, -0.01398411113768816, 0.050475794821977615, 0.03991870954632759, -0.03388029336929321, -0.019578084349632263, 0.028359441086649895, 0.02213561348617077, 0.009107118472456932, -0.02946208044886589, 0.04816482588648796, 0.019335828721523285, -0.01601814292371273, -0.011158929206430912, -0.028833923861384392, -0.011950293555855751, 0.009099800139665604, 0.05177474394440651, -0.0038554861675947905, 0.009249553084373474, 0.029170013964176178, -0.020178038626909256, -0.028821390122175217, 0.017061935737729073, -0.0508861318230629, 0.06246145814657211, 0.011569641530513763, -0.010005302727222443, -0.02890729159116745, 0.0169915072619915, -0.058844443410634995, -0.03410732373595238, 0.003476416924968362, 0.03568652272224426, 0.03734949231147766, 0.01913372054696083, -0.04092904180288315, 0.014099531807005405, -0.004037259612232447, -0.0229472815990448, -0.08146212995052338, -0.021779585629701614, 0.021522855386137962, 0.0008548051700927317, -0.029576916247606277, -0.04545331001281738, 0.0446615144610405, 0.019795909523963928, -0.0037455547135323286, 0.004647937137633562, 0.015508144162595272, -0.02862057462334633, -0.015265017747879028, 0.030036896467208862, -0.0711241066455841, 0.025046156719326973, -0.016115522012114525, -0.003443594789132476, 0.005709848832339048, -0.07497311383485794, 0.0013350609224289656, -0.004205884877592325, -0.05183990299701691, -0.00029392793658189476, -0.001687467098236084, 0.035727035254240036, 0.021179351955652237, 0.030933864414691925, -0.017162585631012917, 0.028356846421957016, -0.09857314825057983, 0.023020213469862938, -0.01615329273045063, -0.03495186194777489, 0.02124714106321335, -0.005707665346562862, 0.013061120174825191, -0.03815063089132309, -0.026717547327280045, 0.042707864195108414, 0.05257483571767807, -0.028622359037399292, -0.06203479692339897, -0.047396425157785416, -0.059456273913383484, -0.058213118463754654, -0.060852840542793274, -0.06669686734676361, -0.02120548114180565, 0.01840832084417343, -0.04414839670062065, 0.02926076017320156, 0.0022779679857194424, 0.008438941091299057, -0.043094657361507416, 0.0015250416472554207, -0.002419721568003297, -0.008771576918661594, -0.03370498865842819, -0.06009002774953842, -0.037764713168144226, 0.0174940824508667, -0.04845435172319412, 0.009960087947547436, -0.007691926788538694, -0.04714518412947655, -0.003113283310085535, 0.02888152003288269, 0.02879868634045124, 0.05525313317775726, -0.029127417132258415, 0.0004229379410389811, -0.016572047024965286, 0.049906473606824875, 0.006267585791647434, -0.03316115215420723, -0.06758853793144226, 0.003112523118034005, -0.002370230620726943, 0.0062254793010652065, -0.04242270439863205, 0.000319874583510682, 0.005417511332780123, -0.042853180319070816, 0.01610131561756134, 0.021519584581255913, 0.03129284828901291, 0.00017852697055786848, 0.005919366143643856, -0.04590815305709839, -0.03857557848095894, -0.0225435309112072, 0.011623110622167587, 0.01784081570804119, 0.07203199714422226, 0.0033747570123523474, -0.039479371160268784, -0.05455829203128815, -0.008318406529724598, -0.0538824163377285, 0.010904327966272831, -0.035894982516765594, -0.013924671337008476, 0.006173976231366396, -0.08383233100175858, 0.013087155297398567, -0.018981551751494408, 0.027957577258348465, -0.03505793958902359, -0.007313152309507132, 0.009078551083803177, 0.035172007977962494, 0.017474595457315445, -0.03084138035774231, -0.03736580163240433, 0.019566334784030914, 0.04041553661227226, -0.020005522295832634, -0.07392853498458862, -0.029705554246902466, -0.0439637117087841, 0.03950082138180733, -0.01074428390711546, -0.014318764209747314, -0.056857526302337646, 0.03236906975507736, -0.05987311154603958, 0.021914616227149963, -0.03482881560921669, 0.055947672575712204, 0.012772001326084137, -0.04889478161931038, 0.009955140762031078, -0.03438052535057068, -0.02606171928346157, -0.014730756171047688, 0.025039171800017357, 0.0016112282173708081, -0.05924311652779579, -0.03439296782016754, 0.05044332891702652, 0.06952136754989624, -0.021268615499138832, -0.06529565155506134, -0.02356850914657116, -0.0008756439201533794, 0.03736965358257294, -0.009845983237028122, 0.012136798352003098, 0.0659043937921524, -0.03720235452055931, 0.005450800992548466, -0.06070982664823532, 0.030733149498701096, -0.010439806617796421, 0.028300872072577477, -0.03340670093894005, 0.040954768657684326, 0.0183198694139719, -0.06545888632535934, -0.011039169505238533, 0.004694019444286823, 0.047291647642850876, 0.011287934146821499, 0.016208577901124954, 0.03655962273478508, 0.024582311511039734, 0.04662524536252022, 0.00008514885848853737, 0.013548956252634525, -0.01397791225463152, 0.07246798276901245, -0.06046919524669647, -0.018548084422945976, -0.047873467206954956, -0.0701313242316246, -0.01671788841485977, 0.023446857929229736, 0.005151612218469381, 0.025988642126321793, 0.05662935599684715, 0.007972972467541695, 0.0113672511652112, 0.002084889682009816, 0.04256396368145943, -0.0337853878736496, -0.04388878494501114, 0.018422678112983704, -0.020825279876589775, 0.013300887309014797, -0.03954567387700081, 0.025110339745879173, -0.006388453301042318, -0.021656889468431473, -0.00020657361892517656, -0.04963013529777527, 0.023863360285758972, 0.00014416774502024055, 0.023557908833026886, 0.051202915608882904, 0.003227506997063756, 0.017017487436532974, 0.028401155024766922, 0.03897562250494957, 0.025170153006911278, -0.03964757174253464, 0.014986257068812847, -0.0014107327442616224, 0.013237501494586468, 0.030558831989765167, -0.015836436301469803, 0.003391253761947155, -0.06917460262775421, 0.037026070058345795, -0.0186518132686615, 0.009271121583878994, -0.03672771900892258, -0.08796227723360062, 0.005013091955333948, -0.02274222858250141, 0.05476420372724533, 0.007352286018431187, -0.0072457618080079556, 0.06372787058353424, -0.0170726515352726, 0.019755132496356964, -0.026900090277194977, -0.011182986199855804, -0.06001068279147148, -0.05111362040042877, -0.038507476449012756, -0.03946956247091293, 0.05365525558590889, -0.0516994409263134, 0.02053936943411827, 0.010296960361301899, 0.036137938499450684, -0.03847534954547882, 0.024458030238747597, 0.00554237375035882, 0.014655675739049911, 0.0072307405062019825, 0.014639172703027725, 0.027606233954429626, -0.0034876272547990084, -0.022800235077738762, -0.02038557641208172, 0.052825383841991425, -0.033489733934402466, -0.04318365827202797, 0.052268970757722855, -0.03061298467218876, -0.04943305626511574, -0.03543650358915329, 0.006297033745795488, 0.0047064065001904964, -0.07594623416662216, -0.046924348920583725, 0.011559613980352879, 0.01772487908601761, -0.03412074223160744, -0.055346958339214325, -0.06552102416753769, -0.03345094621181488, -0.09078431874513626, 0.03729475289583206, -0.002825048053637147, -0.05667754262685776, -0.030891353264451027, 0.011516258120536804, 0.0014107857132330537, 0.007048309780657291, -0.03347243368625641, 0.042239174246788025, 0.026380443945527077, 0.013659990392625332, 0.0003102044283878058, -0.07921300083398819, -0.06467420607805252, 0.011098499409854412, 0.008954808115959167, -0.036739274859428406, -0.0413828082382679, -0.011375966481864452, -0.03620218113064766, 0.051994867622852325, -0.08092724531888962, 0.03746216744184494, 0.05171890929341316, -0.046334851533174515, 0.009665383026003838, 0.05192112550139427, -0.027291588485240936, 0.027208825573325157, 0.0017629644135013223, 0.020363105461001396, -0.012502382509410381, -0.02182009071111679, 0.029823139309883118, 0.010923881083726883, -0.03256125748157501, 0.0030581997707486153, 0.03671704977750778, -0.028919124975800514, -0.05980994179844856, -0.014966115355491638, 0.03121456503868103, -0.04343053698539734, -0.030123887583613396, 0.036503106355667114, 0.04662691801786423, -0.0010905195958912373, -0.05959724634885788, 0.006003227550536394, -0.007185580208897591, 0.0007541693048551679, 0.06376896053552628, -0.04870471730828285, -0.02931624837219715, 0.0016126915579661727, 0.0020758556202054024, -0.018544936552643776, 0.0370166078209877, 0.018682120367884636, -0.016314387321472168, 0.022324683144688606, -0.007859078235924244, -0.07145081460475922, -0.0027434315998107195, -0.0583333894610405, 0.05668790265917778, -0.01164934691041708, 0.0632183626294136, 0.05874795839190483, 0.0027932431548833847, -0.021969027817249298, -0.061349790543317795, -0.007918651215732098, 0.037098366767168045, 0.020291000604629517, -0.038294050842523575, 0.03221431374549866, 0.028490673750638962, 0.014012442901730537, -0.022004421800374985, -0.018646791577339172, 0.0019802742172032595, -0.0155916977673769, -0.05602201819419861, -0.005565941799432039, -0.006586989387869835, 0.03778945654630661, -0.056028418242931366, 0.03094831295311451, 0.02364189364016056, -0.012049280107021332, 0.06674651056528091, 0.06305322051048279, 0.02089076302945614, 0.016432879492640495, -0.022672241553664207, 0.023888088762760162, -0.019025176763534546, 0.0023193650413304567, 0.06081168353557587, -0.07680734246969223, -0.003559139557182789, -0.028577469289302826, -0.02527651935815811, 0.04607585445046425, -0.026941202580928802, 0.028508445248007774, 0.03973978012800217, 0.011968819424510002, -0.039388179779052734, -0.0016303809825330973, -0.017179371789097786, -0.03063347190618515, -0.033475495874881744, 0.03545110672712326, -0.07775943726301193, -0.06164461001753807, 0.03132817894220352, -0.0025567130651324987, -0.06455113738775253, 0.013932070694863796, -0.05054812133312225, -0.045919012278318405, -0.027642657980322838, 0.060991112142801285, 0.06605164706707001, -0.04159622639417648, -0.01838352158665657, 0.018944423645734787, 0.005698821973055601, 0.01836254447698593, 0.009290321730077267, -0.00507253035902977, -0.004949191119521856, 0.05969192832708359, 0.008409629575908184, -0.03129357844591141, 0.01066530216485262, 0.02503480389714241, -0.05537800490856171, -0.0292141642421484, -0.014550919644534588, -0.009505795314908028, 0.051316309720277786, -0.045111943036317825, -0.024285178631544113, -0.011876869015395641, 0.02233714796602726, 0.03946027532219887, -0.03163228556513786, -0.03108261525630951, 0.018763944506645203, 0.03062008135020733, 0.01700866036117077, -0.049752376973629, -0.0011827513808384538, -0.00845469068735838, -0.04914851859211922, 0.05624736100435257, -0.0477198101580143, 0.03373372554779053, 0.006947733927518129, 0.050316907465457916, 0.03962136059999466, 0.05940765514969826, -0.006202101241797209, -0.032937005162239075, -0.008927961811423302, 0.013482990674674511, 0.026929054409265518, 0.013735557906329632, 0.055218808352947235, 0.023424023762345314, 0.046187806874513626, -0.0400385856628418, -0.029563870280981064, -0.010536123998463154, -0.03160533308982849, 0.03647499531507492, -0.033035505563020706, -0.05513410642743111, 0.0011315594892948866, 0.036314889788627625, -0.05023174360394478, -0.009113118052482605, 0.037506066262722015, 0.013813240453600883, -0.06536602973937988, -0.012001984752714634, 0.00300510972738266, -0.052459705621004105, -0.0008722391212359071, 0.024777619168162346, 0.04088074341416359, -0.05486645549535751, 0.04649948701262474, 0.05715727061033249, 0.0319591648876667, -0.027084510773420334, -0.019222218543291092, -0.04145735874772072, 0.03304300084710121, -0.012754390016198158, -0.0483044758439064, 0.005921009462326765, -0.08097291737794876, -0.054708294570446014, 0.03607713431119919, 0.021036066114902496, 0.006674414500594139, -0.015087658539414406, -0.0368129163980484, 0.04687923938035965, 0.052238937467336655, -0.017056521028280258, -0.08432292938232422, -0.003188811242580414, 0.007297079544514418, -0.017597975209355354, -0.01944081112742424, -0.00463103735819459, -0.05462316796183586, 0.01758093386888504, -0.07319019734859467, 0.025997960940003395, -0.038130082190036774, 0.07116420567035675, -0.029873469844460487, -0.026069190353155136, -0.04285155236721039, -0.02742055058479309, 0.0231929961591959, 0.014944920316338539, -0.023753974586725235, 0.0697820708155632, 0.027707958593964577, -0.01052548922598362, -0.06285756826400757, -0.005751298274844885, 0.004795190412551165, -0.03982144966721535, -0.015284658409655094, -0.00856174435466528, 0.023253602907061577, 0.012271087616682053, 0.0070276721380651, 0.02466905117034912, -0.03243397921323776, -0.012127014808356762, -0.042100582271814346, 0.04135802015662193, -0.05640328302979469, -0.019253814592957497, 0.04501871392130852, 0.009493089281022549, -0.005086552817374468, 0.047186944633722305, -0.0027006762102246284, -0.0245237834751606, -0.0476505383849144, -0.04668246954679489, 0.050128865987062454, 0.01682354509830475, 0.014341660775244236, 0.07055202126502991, -0.0662165954709053, 0.004020418040454388, -0.03201352432370186, 0.012578528374433517, -0.02433563582599163, 0.06642451137304306, -0.04951534420251846, -0.07021710276603699, -0.02586912177503109, -0.08191206306219101, 0.007531088776886463, -0.04255622997879982, -0.022831212729215622, 0.04500280320644379, -0.005404660012573004, -0.059625715017318726, -0.01190964225679636, -0.01853024959564209, -0.02301405929028988, -0.008872363716363907, -0.019814448431134224, 0.011471659876406193, -0.0002806572592817247, 0.04185450077056885, 0.015577618964016438, 0.024663301184773445, 0.012157924473285675, 0.034541238099336624, 0.02504550851881504, 0.027451250702142715, -0.027382196858525276, -0.01250214409083128, -0.0413106344640255, 0.02663910575211048, -0.010657521896064281, -0.01957949437201023, -0.05060999467968941, 0.012168915010988712, 0.016484417021274567, 0.024942675605416298, -0.04111384227871895, 0.0181793961673975, -0.03789994865655899, -0.05671761557459831, -0.0683673620223999, 0.02607472985982895, 0.012730224058032036, -0.022441158071160316, 0.05959061160683632, 0.01680920459330082, -0.0017620897851884365, -0.06614124774932861 ]
In everyday life collaboration tasks between human operators and robots, the former necessitate simple ways for programming new skills, the latter have to show adaptive capabilities to cope with environmental changes. The joint use of visual servoing and imitation learning allows us to pursue the objective of realizing friendly robotic interfaces that (i) are able to adapt to the environment thanks to the use of visual perception and (ii) avoid explicit programming thanks to the emulation of previous demonstrations. This work aims to exploit imitation learning for the visual servoing paradigm to address the specific problem of tracking moving objects. In particular, we show that it is possible to infer from data the compensation term required for realizing the tracking controller, avoiding the explicit implementation of estimators or observers. The effectiveness of the proposed method has been validated through simulations with a robotic manipulator.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07729v1
[ -0.032218530774116516, -0.057394642382860184, 0.05643416568636894, -0.007741892710328102, 0.005288878455758095, -0.010516755282878876, 0.0052201817743480206, 0.012399989180266857, -0.010532722808420658, -0.05114521086215973, -0.04514046013355255, 0.0346861369907856, -0.05008154362440109, -0.037790216505527496, -0.023909760639071465, 0.025411037728190422, 0.07132693380117416, -0.012292301282286644, -0.03171451389789581, 0.05726899206638336, 0.02745859883725643, 0.004903121385723352, -0.03909171000123024, 0.002549343276768923, -0.036454878747463226, -0.025882266461849213, 0.02048332244157791, 0.043232232332229614, -0.033378470689058304, -0.028563426807522774, 0.04970904067158699, 0.007895879447460175, 0.005021190736442804, -0.053291551768779755, -0.05378686264157295, -0.019479569047689438, -0.04409639164805412, 0.02312052622437477, 0.028487076982855797, -0.047554343938827515, 0.02096562832593918, -0.015203696675598621, -0.05883902311325073, -0.020532861351966858, -0.031801845878362656, -0.0332297645509243, -0.04141843691468239, -0.013463001698255539, -0.060020141303539276, -0.05224937945604324, 0.010276488959789276, 0.00896958727389574, 0.010727392509579659, 0.03663362190127373, -0.022968916222453117, 0.028874821960926056, -0.011895976960659027, 0.03608843684196472, -0.055678840726614, -0.009058390744030476, 0.015034154057502747, -0.028430428355932236, 0.01928580552339554, 0.013019257225096226, 0.032980840653181076, 0.04002273827791214, -0.049208175390958786, -0.052853845059871674, -0.043328456580638885, -0.021161861717700958, 0.054016657173633575, -0.06896217167377472, -0.03622487187385559, 0.00595793966203928, -0.03421174734830856, -0.033899594098329544, -0.054171644151210785, -0.04432276636362076, 0.01831956021487713, -0.018247582018375397, -0.04994149133563042, 0.024950096383690834, 0.06524301320314407, 0.04988805204629898, -0.0020053077023476362, -0.007129356265068054, -0.013897347263991833, 0.003354343120008707, 0.025224579498171806, -0.030208971351385117, 0.06584439426660538, -0.03901800140738487, -0.07343384623527527, 0.012066897936165333, 0.042368315160274506, -0.027091385796666145, 0.02160542458295822, -0.005678136367350817, -0.0005704350187443197, -0.04065018519759178, -0.026721758767962456, 0.010964722372591496, -0.05383927747607231, 0.05081372708082199, 0.0497698150575161, -0.07135298103094101, 0.02197255752980709, 0.006463196594268084, -0.025710681453347206, -0.03254440426826477, -0.030114976689219475, -0.010638879612088203, 0.027513962239027023, -0.07766290754079819, -0.03856148570775986, -0.0652412548661232, 0.020249545574188232, -0.040512315928936005, 0.04208921641111374, 0.021927956491708755, -0.04936002194881439, 0.05897439271211624, 0.028047841042280197, -0.014666596427559853, 0.007391112856566906, 0.004160614218562841, 0.07254306226968765, -0.008846956305205822, -0.02149605192244053, -0.04134005680680275, -0.03484984114766121, 0.06061432883143425, -0.06169385462999344, -0.07529386132955551, 0.03990725427865982, -0.0068390630185604095, -0.010964347049593925, -0.0241220835596323, 0.03543055057525635, -0.05300862714648247, -0.040087226778268814, -0.03876598924398422, 0.017345627769827843, -0.004875536076724529, 0.0100338039919734, 0.03863058611750603, -0.04511939734220505, -0.04777560383081436, -0.017989506945014, 0.014195645228028297, 0.04734621196985245, 0.004636100493371487, 0.04405466094613075, 0.03766702115535736, 0.039515141397714615, -0.062374286353588104, 0.05513434484601021, -0.015738852322101593, -0.0724794864654541, -0.03598398715257645, -0.003182076383382082, -0.0004925763932988048, 0.0191191416233778, -0.03229457512497902, 0.003897335147485137, 0.016254708170890808, 0.02609933167695999, -0.025811035186052322, -0.012724445201456547, 0.018202846869826317, -0.02123047038912773, -0.03184545412659645, 0.0016778407152742147, 0.003355189226567745, -0.029701385647058487, -0.0242347102612257, -0.000995793379843235, -0.04861367866396904, -0.03990861400961876, 0.029255622997879982, -0.027368808165192604, 0.015443661250174046, -0.023997845128178596, -0.008880307897925377, -0.0658731460571289, 0.0033776741474866867, -0.079969123005867, -0.07294066995382309, 0.011122366413474083, 0.04197850450873375, -0.06475196033716202, -0.05727420374751091, 0.02505979873239994, 0.0024119834415614605, -0.05856671556830406, -0.04088510200381279, -0.025173023343086243, -0.016749385744333267, 0.020369000732898712, 0.050167229026556015, -0.08657277375459671, 0.008649618364870548, -0.04498386010527611, -0.012621026486158371, -0.01355285570025444, -0.07230232656002045, 0.0054136305116117, 0.04656944423913956, -0.03356410562992096, 0.015004892833530903, 0.013119662180542946, 0.003392330138012767, 0.06493278592824936, 0.00235385587438941, 0.04597097635269165, 0.011154158040881157, -0.0939326211810112, 0.028409941121935844, 0.027473928406834602, 0.019080525264143944, 0.018831122666597366, 0.0038013476878404617, 0.0007385630160570145, -0.04486478865146637, -0.0071726636961102486, 0.06476736068725586, 0.03281977027654648, -0.055045224726200104, -0.042214732617139816, -0.049445200711488724, -0.0059638735838234425, -0.05167714133858681, -0.04236837849020958, -0.06640052795410156, -0.039662547409534454, -0.015576975420117378, -0.031125156208872795, 0.037902966141700745, -0.035110827535390854, -0.030305979773402214, -0.04244903102517128, -0.06563326716423035, 0.06231416389346123, -0.018623625859618187, -0.020736856386065483, -0.03838018700480461, -0.005022547207772732, 0.017299044877290726, -0.037768084555864334, 0.041570160537958145, -0.043972447514534, -0.042645785957574844, 0.02550364099442959, -0.030848920345306396, 0.05111827328801155, 0.03565029799938202, -0.04821508005261421, -0.017514539882540703, -0.03486226499080658, 0.029559897258877754, 0.006550362799316645, -0.027410272508859634, -0.05836460366845131, -0.014510071836411953, 0.04506582394242287, -0.02571568265557289, 0.004414573311805725, -0.05011485889554024, -0.00000921200989978388, -0.036855269223451614, 0.006533601321280003, -0.005804055370390415, 0.016734598204493523, -0.006840051617473364, -0.0195915624499321, -0.01643008179962635, -0.013821768574416637, -0.02438896894454956, 0.005025629419833422, 0.029760049656033516, 0.020515091717243195, 0.0061895460821688175, 0.008494569920003414, -0.056833092123270035, -0.043361250311136246, -0.02518671378493309, -0.007211861200630665, -0.07136614620685577, -0.07916364818811417, -0.010770549066364765, -0.0551290437579155, -0.003114536637440324, -0.04230635240674019, -0.03318352624773979, -0.022333160042762756, -0.04719112440943718, -0.04851001128554344, 0.03303317353129387, 0.022420795634388924, -0.025596775114536285, -0.03308846428990364, -0.029608236625790596, -0.01639360561966896, 0.008814116939902306, -0.008320912718772888, -0.06056797876954079, -0.058044444769620895, -0.014808389358222485, 0.0006746051367372274, -0.014866008423268795, -0.03492003306746483, 0.05366577208042145, -0.015226854011416435, 0.02326633594930172, -0.0010968234855681658, -0.019012318924069405, 0.007113268133252859, 0.028486214578151703, -0.02073153667151928, -0.02655932307243347, 0.01315638143569231, 0.023853274062275887, 0.055406201630830765, -0.013728922232985497, -0.04754698649048805, -0.02835967391729355, 0.05283366143703461, 0.02088232897222042, -0.015029201284050941, -0.06197095662355423, -0.0034537033643573523, -0.005573763977736235, 0.031170740723609924, 0.018527517095208168, -0.013695395551621914, -0.005734530743211508, -0.0033955825492739677, -0.02606778033077717, -0.023206744343042374, -0.007007907144725323, -0.030794300138950348, -0.013491515070199966, -0.05010448023676872, -0.03778865188360214, 0.035859934985637665, -0.09064522385597229, -0.030347496271133423, 0.023081311956048012, 0.07300779968500137, 0.004621350206434727, 0.04559904709458351, -0.02448381669819355, 0.000662546546664089, 0.010886900126934052, 0.01072161365300417, 0.057187698781490326, 0.035320669412612915, 0.045040689408779144, 0.0038411724381148815, -0.05877963826060295, 0.022842587903141975, -0.0784667581319809, -0.058607783168554306, 0.023813283070921898, 0.015003430657088757, 0.026811782270669937, 0.05013357102870941, -0.07281176000833511, 0.0020978462416678667, -0.03140190988779068, -0.006479422561824322, 0.04759421944618225, -0.03692060708999634, 0.0012626689858734608, -0.04317528009414673, 0.018416134640574455, 0.0009087931830435991, 0.033272720873355865, -0.039041973650455475, -0.017828140407800674, 0.004539018496870995, -0.06873394548892975, 0.03899551182985306, 0.0042053028009831905, -0.019626660272479057, 0.04904244467616081, 0.05543391406536102, 0.024978499859571457, 0.0612756684422493, -0.019246267154812813, -0.0031147408299148083, 0.006312697660177946, -0.01682218909263611, -0.045108843594789505, -0.027505671605467796, -0.04982656612992287, 0.023145481944084167, 0.025790348649024963, 0.0014901973772794008, -0.0033528273925185204, 0.00843733362853527, 0.006774622015655041, -0.0020902298856526613, -0.08580180257558823, 0.005569476168602705, -0.051369402557611465, 0.03963841497898102, -0.0029215477406978607, -0.008729809895157814, 0.06933490931987762, -0.05668601766228676, -0.0046519129537045956, -0.049228884279727936, -0.015022777952253819, -0.0010912129655480385, -0.059213507920503616, -0.0489768348634243, -0.07783045619726181, -0.012876441702246666, -0.03661232814192772, 0.020996104925870895, -0.017777202650904655, 0.023996232077479362, -0.04463033750653267, -0.0400698222219944, 0.002379193902015686, 0.033323049545288086, 0.026393957436084747, 0.009275982156395912, 0.014542688615620136, -0.019185716286301613, 0.02297663874924183, -0.010244520381093025, -0.01192537508904934, 0.00653877854347229, -0.004196885507553816, 0.048474304378032684, -0.018824463710188866, 0.04311100393533707, 0.0220619086176157, -0.010646224021911621, 0.05239478871226311, 0.009105757810175419, -0.009992050006985664, -0.029666434973478317, 0.055971406400203705, -0.02188597060739994, -0.06338079273700714, -0.054669953882694244, -0.010356724262237549, -0.05862746387720108, -0.005001433193683624, -0.028735052794218063, 0.017908252775669098, 0.01633058674633503, 0.00812483113259077, 0.05785661190748215, 0.007933836430311203, -0.009036519564688206, 0.0035745224449783564, 0.02900531515479088, 0.02092937007546425, 0.024853918701410294, -0.03389152139425278, -0.08264128118753433, 0.059085819870233536, -0.04133103787899017, -0.002890047151595354, -0.03506221994757652, 0.015123650431632996, 0.04661247506737709, 0.020477069541811943, -0.0896640419960022, 0.025257984176278114, 0.040796127170324326, -0.02726539969444275, 0.019113048911094666, 0.03225300461053848, -0.01687788963317871, 0.04402146115899086, -0.004815118387341499, 0.013581572100520134, 0.005304660182446241, -0.03036339208483696, -0.03735071420669556, -0.020397545769810677, -0.037215154618024826, -0.024301225319504738, 0.057200539857149124, -0.017967544496059418, -0.043937236070632935, -0.003368118079379201, -0.0007081879302859306, 0.01882426254451275, -0.0259467251598835, 0.02111198566854, 0.03869940713047981, -0.05671722814440727, -0.0303154606372118, -0.0021558308508247137, -0.006265103351324797, -0.002780112437903881, 0.029849011451005936, -0.02467445284128189, 0.021974988281726837, 0.01669083535671234, 0.022745415568351746, -0.011269229464232922, 0.014629864133894444, -0.01035525556653738, 0.008692087605595589, -0.011784222908318043, 0.005532142706215382, -0.05565502867102623, -0.020783452317118645, -0.016870465129613876, 0.044876474887132645, 0.03550511226058006, 0.04147155582904816, 0.02031341940164566, 0.03913085535168648, -0.023683980107307434, -0.0034445980563759804, -0.006661542225629091, -0.024859288707375526, 0.024152865633368492, -0.046483736485242844, 0.049293920397758484, -0.015381596982479095, -0.005294990260154009, -0.029921405017375946, 0.03785992041230202, 0.012040650472044945, -0.023604055866599083, -0.02436812035739422, -0.03995673358440399, 0.0001725057081785053, -0.07440140843391418, -0.03453248739242554, 0.04146334528923035, 0.02044060453772545, -0.02996288612484932, 0.033594075590372086, 0.035112518817186356, -0.0003634715103544295, 0.009243291802704334, -0.013874467462301254, 0.010179870761930943, -0.054768163710832596, 0.030274637043476105, 0.0670306608080864, -0.045269012451171875, -0.0017933538183569908, -0.029056981205940247, -0.04983967915177345, 0.003618428250774741, -0.024054795503616333, -0.0054543777368962765, -0.018928054720163345, 0.002350948750972748, -0.06816458702087402, 0.01738843508064747, -0.022517254576086998, -0.07887784391641617, -0.015365281142294407, -0.00737461494281888, -0.06431795656681061, -0.018827559426426888, 0.021126041188836098, -0.0308902096003294, -0.041191618889570236, 0.059278976172208786, 0.05038734897971153, -0.0011973470682278275, -0.04429352283477783, 0.06316515058279037, 0.06439115107059479, -0.00862650666385889, 0.002692539244890213, 0.00039559858851134777, -0.035684216767549515, -0.001710262498818338, -0.01298669632524252, 0.014671637676656246, 0.026444103568792343, 0.017037099227309227, 0.05698602646589279, -0.06041570380330086, -0.044388458132743835, 0.058026496320962906, -0.026435378938913345, 0.007644135504961014, -0.02795734815299511, -0.002488145139068365, 0.07007104158401489, -0.011649920605123043, -0.042924828827381134, -0.009787614457309246, -0.022869238629937172, -0.03073250874876976, -0.03346506133675575, -0.023326409980654716, 0.004665600601583719, 0.011189783923327923, 0.008006563410162926, -0.03878732770681381, 0.0031559839844703674, -0.03295839577913284, -0.043819934129714966, 0.015457188710570335, -0.04802555590867996, 0.002103530103340745, 0.030685339123010635, -0.028300538659095764, 0.03240940347313881, 0.06121727451682091, -0.026854507625102997, -0.01365293376147747, 0.004257797263562679, 0.008502468466758728, 0.017595531418919563, -0.029137223958969116, 0.03361906856298447, 0.02206362597644329, 0.010757455602288246, 0.01376853883266449, -0.0013323859311640263, -0.01569783315062523, -0.029015609994530678, 0.042160533368587494, -0.0072442409582436085, -0.006814230233430862, -0.03897145763039589, 0.02443051151931286, 0.0065303342416882515, -0.003275909461081028, 0.005380701273679733, -0.013235995545983315, -0.0487256720662117, 0.018044954165816307, -0.03186018392443657, 0.005763881839811802, -0.03978026285767555, 0.0355098657310009, 0.04971495643258095, -0.01417723298072815, 0.036942560225725174, 0.01633770763874054, -0.04361003637313843, 0.012347989715635777, -0.07689119130373001, -0.04361431300640106, 0.050333645194768906, -0.010558423586189747, -0.06601075828075409, 0.010623428039252758, -0.000859929365105927, -0.04743756353855133, 0.0332801453769207, 0.01998552680015564, 0.042071107774972916, 0.011191213503479958, -0.058236122131347656, 0.024871760979294777, -0.029389237985014915, -0.06339755654335022, -0.05180073529481888, -0.005231128074228764, -0.015400349162518978, -0.04483059421181679, 0.020757678896188736, -0.004227174445986748, -0.06685962527990341, -0.023862309753894806, -0.08705368638038635, 0.004700331017374992, 0.019799495115876198, 0.03717845678329468, -0.014148632064461708, -0.044016033411026, 0.010675376281142235, -0.05551018938422203, 0.01523908693343401, 0.053226813673973083, 0.004591674078255892, 0.0006265242700465024, 0.04774969443678856, 0.004482344724237919, -0.04268186539411545, -0.04945803061127663, 0.06561654806137085, 0.000635171658359468, 0.004163062199950218, 0.026229357346892357, 0.028890972957015038, 0.03736306354403496, -0.05000285804271698, 0.04963096231222153, -0.010703113861382008, 0.05439312756061554, -0.055964820086956024, 0.034842438995838165, -0.03554564341902733, -0.0707223117351532, -0.04364682734012604, -0.007859699428081512, 0.048878494650125504, 0.014126118272542953, -0.03124883584678173, -0.008576085790991783, -0.045656923204660416, -0.016613030806183815, 0.06967669725418091, -0.03221346437931061, -0.025735381990671158, 0.05944730341434479, -0.0406477265059948, -0.012058811262249947, -0.03396688401699066, -0.008014077320694923, -0.043099384754896164, 0.019928814843297005, 0.05734905228018761, -0.0026958936359733343, 0.027345694601535797, -0.06637775897979736, 0.04082570970058441, 0.03599521890282631, -0.04392654821276665, -0.01948329247534275, 0.07231786102056503, 0.04231211543083191, -0.07135481387376785, -0.03764710947871208, -0.035691842436790466, -0.04399695619940758, -0.05704564228653908, 0.0034327791072428226, -0.029010208323597908, -0.013180812820792198, 0.006458380725234747, 0.018172524869441986, 0.0033027795143425465, 0.04604062810540199, 0.026744676753878593, 0.06314321607351303, -0.010254648514091969, -0.010870388709008694, -0.004819159395992756, 0.07492229342460632, 0.01978791505098343, -0.01872069761157036, -0.04950128123164177, 0.03277080878615379, -0.01993497461080551, -0.00888071022927761, -0.020602453500032425, -0.02227463759481907, -0.006956986151635647, -0.010348936542868614, -0.03100697137415409, 0.05621841549873352, 0.0011344164377078414, -0.04284082353115082, -0.038527242839336395, 0.05348263680934906, -0.028975529596209526, -0.07245729863643646 ]
Results of astrometric very long baseline interferometry (VLBI) observations towards an extreme OH/IR star candidate NSV17351 are presented. We used the VERA (VLBI Exploration of Radio Astrometry) VLBI array to observe 22\,GHz H$_2$O masers of NSV17351. We derived an annual parallax of 0.247$\pm$0.035 mas which corresponds to a distance of 4.05$\pm$0.59 kpc. By averaging the proper motions of 15 maser spots, we obtained the systemic proper motion of NSV17351 to be ($\mu_{\alpha}\cos{\delta}, \mu_{\delta}$)$^{\mathrm{avg}}$ $=$ ($-$1.19 $\pm$ 0.11, 1.30 $\pm$ 0.19) mas\,yr$^{-1}$. The maser spots spread out over a region of 20 mas $\times$ 30 mas, which can be converted to a spatial distribution of $\sim$80 au $\times$ $\sim$120 au at the source distance. Internal motions of the maser spots suggest an outward moving maser region with respect to the estimated position of the central star. From single dish monitoring of the H$_2$O maser emission, we estimate the pulsation period of NSV17351 to be 1122$\pm$24 days. This is the first report of the periodic activity of NSV17351, indicating that NSV17351 could have a mass of $\sim$4\,M$_{\odot}$. We confirmed that the time variation of H$_2$O masers can be used as a period estimator of variable OH/IR stars. Furthermore, by inspecting dozens of double-peaked H$_2$O maser spectra from the last 40 years, we detected a long-term acceleration in the radial velocity of the circumstellar matter to be $0.17\pm0.03$ km\,s$^{-1}$\,yr$^{-1}$ Finally, we determined the position and kinematics of NSV17351 in the Milky Way Galaxy and found that NSV17351 is located in an interarm region between the Outer and Perseus arms. We note that astrometric VLBI observations towards extreme OH/IR stars are useful samples for studies of the Galactic dynamics.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04234v1
[ -0.04387842118740082, 0.0036277510225772858, 0.043936170637607574, 0.02486836537718773, -0.031123755499720573, 0.0022519887425005436, 0.011983327567577362, 0.018705444410443306, -0.004067593719810247, -0.023265251889824867, -0.04207763820886612, -0.0560666061937809, 0.0015551612013950944, -0.04868995025753975, -0.0782710611820221, 0.058205947279930115, 0.012086746282875538, 0.017862964421510696, -0.03671389818191528, 0.042364489287137985, 0.019033458083868027, -0.0036987115163356066, -0.03067660704255104, 0.022215306758880615, 0.007933536544442177, -0.036157116293907166, 0.02386586181819439, 0.005994036328047514, -0.06785917282104492, -0.030924327671527863, 0.02835450880229473, 0.0457572340965271, 0.0021400474943220615, -0.001293283887207508, 0.017569098621606827, 0.03403882682323456, -0.0021236566826701164, 0.0592307411134243, -0.03168739378452301, -0.004136297386139631, -0.00005009603046346456, -0.05311541259288788, -0.011958378367125988, -0.058461666107177734, -0.05008019879460335, -0.024548599496483803, -0.011272327974438667, -0.04588901624083519, -0.03856457397341728, -0.0670124962925911, 0.008666537702083588, -0.007713711354881525, 0.010740628466010094, 0.05521034821867943, 0.0011033753398805857, 0.013387421146035194, 0.024392256513237953, 0.04607946053147316, -0.002754567889496684, -0.0017787128454074264, 0.02473360300064087, -0.03823930397629738, 0.014532215893268585, 0.0088726244866848, -0.05193532258272171, 0.030789298936724663, -0.06542228907346725, -0.043840307742357254, 0.027286728844046593, -0.06144986301660538, -0.013657879084348679, -0.030051644891500473, -0.020759008824825287, 0.026557281613349915, -0.08050956577062607, -0.009858749806880951, -0.04770077392458916, -0.023780176416039467, 0.01686679758131504, -0.02466939017176628, -0.012124377302825451, 0.004107520449906588, 0.0388774536550045, 0.039366234093904495, 0.039438944309949875, 0.00660472409799695, 0.01766698807477951, -0.04345889016985893, 0.038307271897792816, -0.041066836565732956, 0.002848573261871934, -0.03751474991440773, -0.02674870938062668, -0.016620522364974022, 0.06952527165412903, -0.046481356024742126, 0.06514982879161835, 0.015634937211871147, 0.04733632132411003, 0.004468183498829603, -0.01155956368893385, -0.0042921132408082485, -0.014743414707481861, 0.047741398215293884, 0.007766908034682274, -0.010573314502835274, 0.0034932054113596678, 0.006854911334812641, -0.02585117146372795, 0.02681923285126686, -0.0006301872781477869, 0.03309217467904091, -0.0010852360865101218, -0.013063154183328152, -0.028440821915864944, -0.0806509256362915, 0.05078206956386566, -0.01423503365367651, 0.02949320152401924, 0.009086508303880692, -0.03997862711548805, 0.03626677021384239, 0.04596390575170517, -0.040856748819351196, 0.021641777828335762, 0.024962952360510826, 0.06027231365442276, -0.02987576648592949, 0.013274150900542736, 0.00965078454464674, 0.005165767390280962, 0.010803472250699997, 0.012964935973286629, -0.03352481499314308, -0.04506722465157509, -0.0029060717206448317, -0.00007049324631225318, -0.024819765239953995, -0.016644781455397606, -0.01727859489619732, 0.011132813058793545, -0.015549381263554096, 0.01736251823604107, 0.0071416208520531654, 0.02292092889547348, 0.015666615217924118, -0.08434685319662094, -0.0017880464438349009, 0.02299405075609684, 0.05164874345064163, 0.0017380985664203763, 0.033281534910202026, -0.015101715922355652, -0.004249109886586666, 0.006134386174380779, -0.030986864119768143, 0.04756549745798111, -0.006249840836971998, -0.04602279141545296, -0.005982404109090567, 0.006000586785376072, -0.0508413091301918, -0.0004613068012986332, 0.0075610666535794735, -0.014912847429513931, -0.01924658939242363, 0.04804259538650513, -0.029801828786730766, -0.004079093225300312, 0.0076421401463449, -0.05208377540111542, -0.019861234351992607, -0.0033106559421867132, 0.017383992671966553, -0.027642453089356422, -0.06043575331568718, 0.002611002651974559, -0.034648437052965164, -0.03559767082333565, 0.012879433110356331, 0.00671500014141202, 0.008960266597568989, 0.0016136654885485768, -0.01861056312918663, -0.07974818348884583, -0.030198754742741585, -0.06794237345457077, -0.005091420840471983, 0.04957431182265282, 0.02383613772690296, -0.011634753085672855, -0.052003610879182816, 0.03126746788620949, 0.03593960404396057, -0.05978958681225777, -0.0410810150206089, 0.01415568869560957, -0.031383659690618515, -0.041049543768167496, -0.042712386697530746, -0.057138703763484955, -0.026224937289953232, -0.06174290552735329, 0.022542914375662804, -0.006457351613789797, -0.07121685147285461, 0.03015468642115593, 0.029213018715381622, -0.014766586013138294, -0.0322381854057312, 0.009705835022032261, -0.009091547690331936, -0.011021459475159645, 0.014536933042109013, -0.03362463414669037, -0.008344119414687157, -0.09245175123214722, 0.04773576185107231, 0.02901051566004753, -0.023422280326485634, 0.026139745488762856, -0.024886976927518845, -0.010925658978521824, -0.03743341937661171, -0.0026010500732809305, 0.04454786702990532, 0.03516304865479469, -0.047799717634916306, -0.06779944151639938, -0.028904657810926437, -0.012125707231462002, -0.06384405493736267, -0.050610192120075226, -0.06277897208929062, -0.005546829663217068, 0.03664634749293327, -0.05358538031578064, 0.04560510814189911, 0.008657198399305344, -0.030705932527780533, -0.04264413192868233, 0.04879935458302498, 0.03560030460357666, -0.06627476215362549, -0.026456594467163086, -0.016096938401460648, -0.047993723303079605, 0.017273815348744392, -0.04862833395600319, -0.03304576501250267, 0.006141135469079018, -0.01069541834294796, -0.0024656974710524082, -0.004442169331014156, 0.04770410433411598, -0.006356165744364262, -0.017165377736091614, 0.016287105157971382, -0.052767012268304825, 0.04995199665427208, 0.02996695041656494, -0.030801566317677498, -0.07113465666770935, 0.0051447488367557526, -0.04158533364534378, 0.041077110916376114, -0.0675094947218895, -0.022018320858478546, 0.010906008072197437, 0.009946146979928017, 0.015796955674886703, -0.05164271593093872, 0.045344818383455276, 0.011889487504959106, -0.02863449603319168, 0.013184450566768646, -0.03290610387921333, -0.014491901732981205, 0.012597545050084591, -0.005450026132166386, 0.05860966816544533, 0.03210701048374176, 0.02050773985683918, -0.06120320037007332, -0.04194819554686546, -0.04592801630496979, -0.0010522993979975581, -0.05201610550284386, -0.0777987465262413, -0.049369607120752335, -0.029841257259249687, -0.02495359256863594, -0.03565135970711708, -0.014372661709785461, -0.014401682652533054, -0.021458160132169724, -0.011415588669478893, 0.016153693199157715, 0.02686472237110138, -0.07580357789993286, 0.016280658543109894, -0.036751098930835724, 0.018299443647265434, 0.005014433525502682, -0.05439034104347229, 0.029767503961920738, -0.0088619040325284, 0.026517104357481003, -0.01629219762980938, 0.039737407118082047, 0.0026354938745498657, 0.00498165562748909, -0.06998728215694427, -0.007785785477608442, 0.0036901100538671017, 0.03392574563622475, 0.017229599878191948, -0.050159089267253876, -0.008353433571755886, -0.01731187477707863, -0.017409855499863625, -0.009789480827748775, 0.030227890238165855, 0.025965623557567596, -0.039937540888786316, -0.024243352934718132, 0.03830578178167343, 0.07795581221580505, 0.0189390629529953, -0.057508595287799835, -0.01106405258178711, -0.02773546241223812, 0.022715343162417412, 0.0035533744376152754, 0.06229029968380928, 0.040061526000499725, -0.072336845099926, 0.05046840384602547, -0.027171285822987556, -0.0003692500467877835, -0.02119261398911476, -0.014756415970623493, -0.025186756625771523, -0.006901316344738007, 0.02846585214138031, -0.0860663503408432, 0.04280436784029007, 0.022016916424036026, 0.07201053202152252, -0.015024235472083092, -0.007737266831099987, -0.018535112962126732, 0.004498525522649288, 0.02959549054503441, -0.040492910891771317, 0.029107671231031418, -0.013504872098565102, 0.05589720979332924, -0.06598981469869614, 0.0009618346812203526, -0.005914929788559675, -0.06445720046758652, -0.019922491163015366, -0.012671812437474728, -0.02499045990407467, 0.06307949125766754, 0.05180494859814644, -0.026733221486210823, 0.022587886080145836, -0.016501329839229584, 0.023851215839385986, 0.028588946908712387, -0.0475514717400074, -0.005210221279412508, 0.05361432954668999, -0.06155979633331299, 0.004131857305765152, 0.004888040013611317, 0.008093769662082195, -0.020217979326844215, 0.04281459376215935, -0.06656277924776077, 0.011925873346626759, -0.02018348127603531, -0.007226055022329092, 0.013619550503790379, -0.07430055737495422, 0.019309883937239647, 0.025430621579289436, 0.024417990818619728, -0.056181084364652634, -0.030940253287553787, -0.024996446445584297, -0.0018703601090237498, -0.021606095135211945, -0.0014044655254110694, 0.03988351672887802, 0.005207589361816645, -0.03668969124555588, -0.007249452639371157, 0.05185841768980026, -0.018784787505865097, -0.0018441419815644622, -0.0645393654704094, -0.019099121913313866, -0.053313110023736954, -0.004372099414467812, 0.008708998560905457, 0.032501623034477234, 0.06315264105796814, -0.010973955504596233, 0.0010025969240814447, -0.014951564371585846, -0.013896089978516102, -0.02956278622150421, -0.057404275983572006, -0.033961664885282516, -0.03070298582315445, 0.001414067461155355, -0.028186963871121407, 0.045324232429265976, -0.008614634163677692, -0.00869685411453247, -0.07527050375938416, -0.012556948699057102, 0.0010636691004037857, -0.0059354607947170734, -0.0004378519079182297, 0.04185537248849869, 0.06637405604124069, 0.02791161835193634, -0.022188358008861542, -0.027221444994211197, -0.028282204642891884, -0.008412376046180725, -0.028634455054998398, 0.011086075566709042, -0.0062140231020748615, -0.03690539300441742, -0.017853623256087303, -0.018593696877360344, 0.005100236739963293, -0.04680919274687767, 0.0077348072081804276, 0.06595876812934875, 0.04989849030971527, -0.052505820989608765, -0.033753592520952225, -0.07093451917171478, -0.026069235056638718, -0.07911954820156097, -0.03717651590704918, 0.001623230637051165, 0.02328702062368393, -0.018809016793966293, 0.04301135614514351, -0.0001396693114656955, 0.011406969279050827, -0.06354695558547974, 0.013628858141601086, -0.005688853096216917, 0.02951383776962757, 0.0375513918697834, -0.03695156052708626, -0.07759909331798553, -0.042470335960388184, -0.03060070239007473, -0.021384000778198242, -0.01768774352967739, 0.01949312910437584, 0.00654409546405077, 0.0009439946734346449, -0.07900193333625793, 0.06224982067942619, 0.030226245522499084, -0.049920495599508286, -0.039538171142339706, 0.06440963596105576, 0.009795788675546646, 0.014322000555694103, -0.0031922035850584507, 0.03618984296917915, -0.02214164473116398, -0.04322589188814163, -0.03407081216573715, -0.05043423920869827, -0.05439373850822449, 0.006305336952209473, 0.011023573577404022, -0.01952045038342476, -0.025847604498267174, 0.01305230613797903, -0.02239825576543808, -0.03638122230768204, 0.008494055829942226, 0.060160670429468155, 0.06727220118045807, -0.03474041447043419, -0.06932194530963898, -0.02629641443490982, 0.015156474895775318, 0.0009624740341678262, 0.06034749373793602, -0.012067182920873165, 0.015000265091657639, 0.040139198303222656, -0.022521916776895523, 0.046906717121601105, 0.017753466963768005, 0.017882859334349632, 0.04017122834920883, 0.0022086435928940773, 0.007554405368864536, -0.020893670618534088, -0.07037118822336197, -0.037457168102264404, -0.00864382740110159, -0.03563858941197395, 0.05516047403216362, 0.021720152348279953, 0.03572501987218857, -0.0022956253960728645, -0.044553156942129135, -0.04641677439212799, -0.03708086535334587, 0.05722271651029587, -0.0204115379601717, 0.0318804532289505, -0.01795012690126896, 0.060670703649520874, -0.03418412804603577, -0.02469993382692337, 0.015067984350025654, -0.058430757373571396, -0.04104752466082573, -0.01475047878921032, 0.03153584897518158, 0.013645349070429802, -0.06266868114471436, -0.0386071652173996, 0.026426246389746666, -0.05028979480266571, 0.05987635254859924, 0.046581074595451355, 0.04233933240175247, 0.037088457494974136, 0.019551431760191917, 0.027175597846508026, -0.03704946115612984, 0.023524923250079155, 0.035114143043756485, -0.005453168414533138, -0.01468029897660017, -0.03978702425956726, -0.020024152472615242, -0.02935955673456192, -0.05829744040966034, -0.0260065458714962, -0.01833144947886467, -0.04012099653482437, -0.02963261678814888, 0.054632268846035004, -0.015696845948696136, -0.05171237885951996, -0.029025547206401825, 0.008289715275168419, -0.08230382949113846, -0.029764343053102493, -0.016362562775611877, -0.04176595062017441, -0.03450601175427437, -0.009084103628993034, -0.061957817524671555, -0.01010950654745102, -0.05020065978169441, 0.018664011731743813, -0.01525403093546629, -0.014518670737743378, 0.04475397616624832, 0.019046733155846596, 0.022818351164460182, -0.029972456395626068, -0.02065672166645527, 0.013018491677939892, -0.012889349833130836, 0.06112838536500931, 0.005861620418727398, -0.0359906442463398, -0.0046206205151975155, 0.011992587707936764, -0.070654958486557, -0.009591164067387581, -0.0145104443654418, 0.021776121109724045, 0.07485712319612503, 0.024783004075288773, -0.033090878278017044, -0.047932956367731094, -0.06575870513916016, -0.03427489101886749, 0.01129645574837923, 0.008397998288273811, 0.013482256792485714, 0.03215731680393219, 0.00502809789031744, -0.0105670765042305, -0.005170601885765791, -0.010849006474018097, 0.03494912385940552, 0.03554690629243851, -0.0559699684381485, -0.013089940883219242, -0.034789230674505234, 0.0371427945792675, -0.002846485236659646, -0.0182417631149292, -0.060820721089839935, -0.05553550645709038, -0.0647360160946846, 0.020562613382935524, -0.011170292273163795, -0.013899472542107105, 0.037894584238529205, -0.01946328766644001, 0.06351619213819504, -0.01266187522560358, 0.014431311748921871, -0.03818622976541519, -0.06489139795303345, 0.011929966509342194, -0.03753342851996422, -0.054447807371616364, -0.0708269253373146, 0.014352025464177132, 0.004475743044167757, -0.023993777111172676, 0.03150073066353798, -0.030802400782704353, -0.059112660586833954, 0.035872384905815125, -0.016980718821287155, -0.06129176542162895, 0.013222531415522099, -0.036923959851264954, 0.03412037342786789, -0.006178759504109621, -0.04397803544998169, -0.012416116893291473, -0.01766882836818695, 0.002097467426210642, -0.015435120090842247, -0.04782799258828163, 0.04820561781525612, 0.058306481689214706, -0.03563990816473961, -0.024701878428459167, -0.04076974466443062, -0.038391124457120895, 0.012587600387632847, 0.023615378886461258, 0.019289862364530563, 0.025169793516397476, -0.0584883838891983, 0.020671114325523376, 0.03135603293776512, -0.025461018085479736, -0.08667443692684174, -0.0679193064570427, 0.008141436614096165, -0.0022609459701925516, 0.00217682053335011, 0.01293820422142744, -0.056593071669340134, 0.03465605899691582, -0.07296916097402573, -0.043021488934755325, -0.03756455332040787, 0.0156816728413105, -0.002280029933899641, 0.0196582842618227, -0.04146517813205719, -0.02050686441361904, -0.02925959788262844, 0.035108763724565506, -0.0477982796728611, 0.03737309202551842, 0.05981075018644333, -0.05133971571922302, -0.04185137897729874, -0.01233435608446598, 0.001553415204398334, -0.006660865154117346, -0.01058428268879652, 0.035023607313632965, -0.011111702769994736, -0.062105558812618256, -0.057028815150260925, 0.07850952446460724, 0.005236616358160973, 0.02349521778523922, 0.0013357619754970074, -0.07321920245885849, -0.05628311261534691, -0.04119425266981125, -0.047209978103637695, -0.054591018706560135, 0.061917200684547424, 0.018214261159300804, -0.022820258513092995, -0.015684783458709717, -0.052069373428821564, -0.044265955686569214, -0.012387757189571857, 0.054892364889383316, -0.006892672739923, 0.01709875464439392, -0.06802039593458176, -0.025977594777941704, -0.01758739911019802, 0.042327769100666046, -0.05405580997467041, -0.04701262712478638, 0.012454998679459095, -0.03895127400755882, 0.0006917598657310009, -0.04244497790932655, 0.04128233343362808, -0.042953651398420334, 0.010494645684957504, 0.03636861965060234, 0.029553938657045364, -0.006514949724078178, 0.015903424471616745, -0.04213070869445801, -0.03326338902115822, -0.021421415731310844, -0.019685544073581696, -0.017021115869283676, 0.005110497586429119, 0.017569344490766525, -0.026308907195925713, 0.04025258496403694, -0.04293163865804672, 0.020339790731668472, 0.009508227929472923, -0.00039603558252565563, 0.004712144378572702, -0.031613148748874664, 0.037561386823654175, 0.05490465834736824, -0.02862335927784443, -0.05444703996181488, -0.05744694173336029, 0.013995693996548653, 0.04489311948418617, 0.041526876389980316, -0.04519068822264671, 0.04193346947431564, -0.0025670130271464586, -0.055412765592336655, -0.047991152852773666, 0.012560366652905941, 0.015164489857852459, -0.04556791111826897, -0.007833637297153473, 0.004574684891849756, -0.05554996058344841, -0.07007908821105957 ]
Figurative language is commonplace in natural language, and while making communication memorable and creative, can be difficult to understand. In this work, we investigate the robustness of Question Answering (QA) models on figurative text. Yes/no questions, in particular, are a useful probe of figurative language understanding capabilities of large language models. We propose FigurativeQA, a set of 1000 yes/no questions with figurative and non-figurative contexts, extracted from the domains of restaurant and product reviews. We show that state-of-the-art BERT-based QA models exhibit an average performance drop of up to 15\% points when answering questions from figurative contexts, as compared to non-figurative ones. While models like GPT-3 and ChatGPT are better at handling figurative texts, we show that further performance gains can be achieved by automatically simplifying the figurative contexts into their non-figurative (literal) counterparts. We find that the best overall model is ChatGPT with chain-of-thought prompting to generate non-figurative contexts. Our work provides a promising direction for building more robust QA models with figurative language understanding capabilities.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13748v1
[ -0.001329093356616795, -0.007073775865137577, 0.042107269167900085, 0.009478956460952759, 0.012416924349963665, -0.024114834144711494, 0.012536251917481422, 0.015891410410404205, -0.0782259851694107, -0.043378397822380066, -0.04962622746825218, 0.017950227484107018, -0.050791095942258835, -0.03560794144868851, -0.022850029170513153, -0.018113987520337105, 0.053732387721538544, -0.0022356973495334387, -0.017711561173200607, 0.007627620827406645, 0.007727919612079859, 0.014821192249655724, -0.05548727884888649, 0.03447940573096275, 0.024825729429721832, 0.006790486164391041, -0.023136025294661522, -0.018750259652733803, -0.005836904048919678, -0.036523256450891495, 0.07327104359865189, 0.028772233054041862, -0.015357844531536102, -0.053743187338113785, -0.031073948368430138, -0.011517836712300777, -0.0247883889824152, 0.015102419070899487, 0.04614134877920151, -0.055547960102558136, 0.03856567665934563, -0.06445221602916718, -0.0704166442155838, -0.03828468918800354, -0.037231069058179855, 0.011787202209234238, -0.014290151186287403, 0.04608197137713432, -0.058428000658750534, -0.04375747963786125, 0.052183233201503754, -0.017792565748095512, -0.01392425037920475, 0.0006132537964731455, -0.04720373451709747, -0.002230903832241893, -0.02353392168879509, 0.024829421192407608, -0.05386649817228317, -0.0546761155128479, 0.0128701813519001, 0.0022812450770288706, -0.0055364035069942474, 0.02397867664694786, -0.019862068817019463, -0.006900150794535875, -0.029503297060728073, -0.003171565243974328, -0.004614737816154957, -0.04264400154352188, 0.03092198260128498, -0.05028114095330238, -0.022782664746046066, -0.008037022314965725, 0.03274945169687271, -0.03299020603299141, -0.039181873202323914, -0.023955630138516426, 0.036264173686504364, -0.0099147018045187, -0.0018891914514824748, 0.032477229833602905, 0.041387565433979034, -0.02002217061817646, -0.027498818933963776, -0.059544049203395844, 0.01657850481569767, 0.005423563066869974, -0.03389500081539154, -0.04068607836961746, 0.056033022701740265, -0.023239264264702797, -0.0722869411110878, 0.0021269540302455425, 0.07073622941970825, 0.003148891730234027, 0.022108344361186028, 0.00847461074590683, -0.008643373847007751, -0.024334628134965897, -0.00040757833630777895, -0.03430173546075821, -0.06042243167757988, 0.051497720181941986, 0.0023791715502738953, -0.015139458701014519, -0.002087407512590289, -0.02398115210235119, -0.07197362184524536, 0.005886477418243885, -0.044935181736946106, -0.03995658829808235, 0.018630921840667725, -0.0637766495347023, -0.04705148562788963, -0.06869102269411087, 0.05120151489973068, -0.0178393367677927, 0.016906915232539177, -0.01743350736796856, -0.013932214118540287, 0.0644005611538887, 0.05447610840201378, -0.04797392711043358, -0.052847232669591904, -0.047117363661527634, 0.030249519273638725, 0.003779669990763068, 0.01724276691675186, -0.010425939224660397, -0.02214592695236206, 0.02025645039975643, 0.0017746892990544438, -0.02819773368537426, 0.0748000368475914, 0.0027887567412108183, -0.026076678186655045, -0.0577240027487278, 0.017089752480387688, -0.03577406704425812, -0.0527343787252903, -0.0723181739449501, 0.018691429868340492, -0.026647914201021194, 0.01305973157286644, 0.07213564217090607, -0.009564297273755074, -0.04512478783726692, 0.026030175387859344, 0.031116945669054985, 0.003819913137704134, -0.021115247160196304, 0.005704726092517376, 0.06501296162605286, 0.025946984067559242, -0.0069920578971505165, 0.057256851345300674, 0.009734305553138256, -0.04024405777454376, 0.006306430324912071, -0.01660304144024849, -0.015419703908264637, 0.04447478428483009, -0.018692655488848686, 0.030285736545920372, 0.010948612354695797, 0.017810724675655365, -0.013231958262622356, -0.022744854912161827, -0.013718726113438606, -0.0017031198367476463, -0.003807326080277562, 0.00024161965120583773, -0.013345199637115002, -0.06867864727973938, 0.0015443844022229314, 0.03912436217069626, -0.03844418376684189, -0.032568786293268204, 0.0013348334468901157, -0.011777585372328758, 0.04162735491991043, -0.027809148654341698, -0.003993191756308079, -0.041465237736701965, 0.016285166144371033, -0.07256373763084412, -0.046885862946510315, 0.051080893725156784, 0.006459417752921581, -0.0254571083933115, -0.020107459276914597, -0.02198771759867668, 0.027831818908452988, -0.005773529410362244, 0.0036891200579702854, -0.015450973063707352, -0.03081751987338066, -0.04844963178038597, 0.04606817662715912, -0.08724536001682281, -0.006891136523336172, -0.04609469696879387, 0.00992991030216217, 0.02657516673207283, -0.05990147218108177, -0.028668072074651718, 0.05972100794315338, -0.022310705855488777, 0.02510315552353859, 0.036700453609228134, 0.04314756020903587, 0.06384002417325974, 0.05062323063611984, 0.015375694260001183, 0.006353052798658609, -0.09813642501831055, 0.057054392993450165, -0.005142210051417351, 0.02295803092420101, 0.0315735898911953, 0.026365961879491806, 0.04525309056043625, 0.042649198323488235, 0.0053447820246219635, -0.0034724015276879072, 0.06698788702487946, -0.023021169006824493, 0.0030117062851786613, -0.0371694341301918, -0.007890531793236732, -0.05114340782165527, -0.017566317692399025, -0.05807122588157654, 0.0016258549876511097, -0.028430640697479248, -0.037911221385002136, 0.067351333796978, -0.03639788180589676, -0.010751007124781609, -0.03718903288245201, -0.04196903109550476, 0.02646789513528347, 0.004132249392569065, -0.049035701900720596, 0.008657364174723625, 0.024368861690163612, 0.012420281767845154, -0.002214808249846101, -0.023773878812789917, -0.024592174217104912, -0.06873816251754761, -0.04482107236981392, -0.008077334612607956, 0.019302992150187492, 0.04151919484138489, -0.0535438098013401, 0.030377954244613647, 0.024281585589051247, 0.057814620435237885, 0.03026014380156994, 0.03410216420888901, -0.018173156306147575, -0.010558906011283398, 0.0484800823032856, -0.04873216524720192, -0.03369295597076416, -0.014342986978590488, -0.004365908447653055, -0.026591824367642403, 0.019778123125433922, 0.0708974227309227, 0.0476178377866745, -0.0042352392338216305, -0.05550488457083702, -0.001931685023009777, 0.015480470843613148, -0.004749375861138105, 0.03892698511481285, 0.04534602910280228, 0.037706270813941956, -0.010010010562837124, 0.011224080808460712, -0.06666399538516998, 0.0026998003013432026, 0.013705061748623848, -0.03821195662021637, -0.061816565692424774, -0.03281988948583603, -0.0365617610514164, -0.0787525624036789, -0.0443505197763443, -0.032084882259368896, -0.020618027076125145, 0.011494532227516174, -0.022034790366888046, -0.03953700512647629, -0.02755015902221203, 0.027871306985616684, -0.03275600075721741, -0.02973535843193531, -0.02141769789159298, 0.025033168494701385, 0.003384252078831196, 0.02645109035074711, -0.036859024316072464, -0.03138286620378494, -0.05064469203352928, 0.009665017016232014, 0.028416546061635017, 0.011907918378710747, 0.0051620472222566605, -0.0036537691485136747, 0.046358782798051834, -0.022248616442084312, 0.03433040529489517, 0.0292787104845047, 0.05986630544066429, -0.0017439709044992924, -0.026396699249744415, -0.04606155678629875, -0.017433127388358116, -0.04099785163998604, -0.0623791329562664, -0.055039312690496445, -0.025252437219023705, 0.059983279556035995, -0.03114631026983261, 0.004154699854552746, 0.0025212292093783617, -0.027626872062683105, 0.04392627999186516, -0.0035811152774840593, 0.029986608773469925, -0.0007864786894060671, 0.04916275665163994, -0.008593210950493813, -0.016422808170318604, 0.003524991450831294, -0.017735904082655907, 0.014242121949791908, -0.0029584832955151796, -0.023773472756147385, 0.01224006712436676, 0.05581718310713768, -0.09557424485683441, 0.027885526418685913, 0.05673743784427643, 0.05637030676007271, -0.045207429677248, -0.032324567437171936, 0.003647447098046541, 0.024395689368247986, 0.010468563996255398, -0.028499661013484, 0.030757850036025047, 0.045205067843198776, 0.04702040180563927, -0.03767602518200874, -0.0319894477725029, -0.0011104450095444918, -0.06479958444833755, -0.005342402495443821, 0.007201052270829678, 0.013398845680058002, 0.01703108474612236, -0.0027862004935741425, -0.0667104721069336, 0.013738524168729782, 0.016918258741497993, 0.05234955623745918, 0.006035148166120052, -0.039477359503507614, 0.029054341837763786, -0.0672416016459465, 0.03334636613726616, 0.03647790104150772, 0.031439170241355896, -0.005053537432104349, -0.029203511774539948, -0.006557249464094639, -0.028157973662018776, 0.014131905511021614, -0.0013344165636226535, -0.0364944152534008, 0.027370505034923553, 0.02737698145210743, -0.04534029960632324, 0.05268270522356033, -0.02590104378759861, -0.026866361498832703, 0.026163138449192047, -0.0010235999943688512, -0.03561706095933914, 0.005971770733594894, -0.07342586666345596, 0.0017441060626879334, 0.042291123420000076, -0.036904577165842056, -0.007721929810941219, 0.007299913093447685, -0.018752850592136383, -0.027635840699076653, -0.0811370462179184, -0.009427791461348534, -0.02864464744925499, 0.046042367815971375, 0.007315225899219513, -0.055477697402238846, 0.04760697856545448, 0.004626241512596607, -0.006013166159391403, -0.016222206875681877, -0.007706468924880028, -0.056074775755405426, -0.03792516514658928, -0.006425698287785053, -0.06242882087826729, 0.0065798950381577015, -0.05171017721295357, -0.0004931061994284391, 0.010302416048943996, -0.000020406590920174494, -0.010110901668667793, -0.0602945014834404, 0.014645516872406006, 0.018304698169231415, 0.05888577178120613, 0.03258712217211723, -0.01722625456750393, -0.01071831863373518, 0.022136900573968887, -0.05551045015454292, -0.03813996538519859, -0.05185466632246971, -0.031015202403068542, 0.047439273446798325, 0.0008616005652584136, 0.009428631514310837, -0.011678093113005161, 0.0005356678739190102, 0.041843194514513016, -0.06542191654443741, -0.015956338495016098, -0.002189439255744219, 0.06643739342689514, -0.035399410873651505, -0.0879775807261467, 0.007767900358885527, -0.03676585480570793, -0.07794187217950821, 0.013503598049283028, 0.0458175353705883, 0.03715751692652702, -0.027773074805736542, -0.02051592618227005, 0.008576523512601852, -0.029622530564665794, -0.00018219185585621744, 0.0026146096643060446, 0.03903288021683693, -0.029681427404284477, -0.0112893246114254, -0.007139233872294426, -0.05607651174068451, 0.00011230054951738566, -0.06162424013018608, -0.014278540387749672, -0.0413631908595562, 0.02171441540122032, -0.004054176155477762, 0.07008150219917297, -0.08785222470760345, -0.006693097297102213, 0.025341534987092018, -0.0004422181809786707, -0.028357062488794327, 0.05304349586367607, -0.020006313920021057, 0.03569883108139038, 0.0038989658933132887, 0.04275639355182648, -0.03203161433339119, -0.04313584789633751, 0.0029496517963707447, 0.011029240675270557, -0.04248194396495819, -0.014698740094900131, 0.04238143190741539, 0.020297927781939507, -0.059991199523210526, 0.02125084213912487, 0.03860211372375488, 0.028354531154036522, -0.05054856091737747, 0.024978676810860634, 0.0582682304084301, -0.03389222174882889, -0.036273665726184845, -0.028984757140278816, -0.03195183351635933, 0.01331427413970232, 0.03336425870656967, -0.04164902865886688, -0.00903967022895813, 0.02808947116136551, 0.003393034217879176, 0.00836445763707161, -0.008734616450965405, 0.021370654925704002, 0.00871030893176794, -0.022223331034183502, 0.03534902632236481, -0.0447554774582386, 0.01081459503620863, -0.06008375436067581, 0.06991796940565109, 0.062372446060180664, 0.043480150401592255, 0.015099391341209412, -0.029373127967119217, -0.03934592008590698, -0.027537688612937927, -0.015322191640734673, -0.040163304656744, 0.01171566080302, -0.02717619389295578, 0.0343371219933033, -0.019410908222198486, 0.03122079186141491, 0.014013580977916718, 0.040598127990961075, -0.008497407659888268, 0.03368213400244713, -0.02926272712647915, -0.025621073320508003, -0.030058445408940315, -0.036106012761592865, -0.014532440342009068, 0.04654988646507263, 0.024638457223773003, -0.016055652871727943, 0.01694229617714882, 0.021149052307009697, -0.019316958263516426, 0.04521961137652397, -0.0015555729623883963, -0.028749899938702583, -0.03717897832393646, -0.015760889276862144, 0.0401952750980854, -0.051300983875989914, 0.024150511249899864, -0.0036841598339378834, -0.04401090368628502, 0.01858532801270485, -0.057871926575899124, 0.04214721545577049, 0.028026623651385307, 0.02649325504899025, -0.027139684185385704, 0.024752460420131683, -0.046868644654750824, -0.07631087303161621, 0.012325841933488846, 0.02400895580649376, -0.079804927110672, 0.016829531639814377, 0.012086293660104275, 0.02407078817486763, -0.052427325397729874, 0.04310387372970581, 0.021596377715468407, -0.03808454051613808, -0.03682452440261841, 0.08374577015638351, 0.07874516397714615, -0.06207231059670448, 0.03362610191106796, 0.05279126018285751, -0.047389548271894455, 0.016590651124715805, -0.04125985875725746, -0.03437497466802597, 0.043069664388895035, 0.028606323525309563, 0.00019741992582567036, -0.04298782721161842, 0.018703510984778404, 0.05713393911719322, -0.05046527460217476, 0.024339161813259125, 0.04875233769416809, -0.0063423882238566875, 0.04796908423304558, -0.047573305666446686, 0.011666694656014442, -0.003895086469128728, -0.02540443278849125, -0.024397362023591995, -0.0312294140458107, -0.024456776678562164, -0.023865917697548866, 0.023233087733387947, -0.00918068177998066, -0.08155816048383713, -0.011021488346159458, -0.01796683669090271, -0.08217504620552063, -0.014298581518232822, -0.0218247938901186, 0.04143773391842842, 0.005804415792226791, 0.02627474069595337, 0.032464805990457535, 0.02800476923584938, -0.056342024356126785, -0.058606892824172974, 0.019934384152293205, 0.0007105801487341523, 0.00422700634226203, 0.003822679165750742, 0.027946462854743004, -0.04746626317501068, 0.053850576281547546, -0.024665076285600662, -0.014978347346186638, -0.03734233230352402, -0.053623493760824203, 0.003426009090617299, 0.04462732747197151, -0.0025710202753543854, -0.058081865310668945, 0.04797602817416191, 0.001685541938059032, 0.04602092131972313, -0.028082692995667458, -0.02525712177157402, -0.08096963167190552, -0.002831622725352645, 0.0440971702337265, -0.011992535553872585, 0.03245031461119652, -0.0018989747622981668, 0.011895201168954372, -0.049326058477163315, 0.04603925719857216, -0.023254964500665665, 0.01307922974228859, 0.048767756670713425, -0.053925056010484695, -0.009391711093485355, 0.024944547563791275, -0.06489250808954239, -0.01643083058297634, 0.035470642149448395, 0.01392009761184454, -0.06753280013799667, -0.018220754340291023, 0.039260104298591614, 0.018832705914974213, -0.04954356327652931, -0.06467418372631073, 0.031041570007801056, 0.014933998696506023, -0.05295587703585625, -0.037752240896224976, 0.013034172356128693, -0.03276451677083969, -0.05057040601968765, -0.041310831904411316, -0.007855670526623726, -0.051166217774152756, 0.019553186371922493, -0.08977340906858444, 0.018095998093485832, 0.007739057764410973, 0.04446903243660927, -0.022850841283798218, -0.0299876369535923, -0.02072186768054962, -0.05584890395402908, 0.030003434047102928, -0.0165915098041296, -0.03233308345079422, 0.0272356029599905, 0.05695532262325287, 0.048840079456567764, -0.03957197815179825, -0.012516108341515064, 0.03724947199225426, -0.019879793748259544, -0.04020806401968002, -0.012260333634912968, -0.0005557250115089118, 0.04837208241224289, 0.011152242310345173, 0.03921336308121681, -0.0206731129437685, 0.05547812208533287, 0.0009775512153282762, 0.000946187530644238, -0.04795262962579727, -0.04728533700108528, 0.014070278033614159, -0.036775168031454086, -0.009927709586918354, 0.05007235333323479, 0.008811015635728836, -0.006885445211082697, -0.017995700240135193, -0.047331731766462326, 0.05547178164124489, -0.01439570914953947, -0.03160858526825905, 0.02877042628824711, -0.021382387727499008, -0.026080111041665077, -0.025117088109254837, -0.011214888654649258, -0.021085109561681747, 0.03557218983769417, 0.03660706803202629, -0.026120822876691818, -0.02706805057823658, -0.027247492223978043, 0.0014419695362448692, -0.0004760822339449078, 0.006621695589274168, 0.04878688603639603, 0.07976898550987244, 0.031670231372117996, 0.03093559294939041, -0.021069375798106194, -0.050601959228515625, -0.044793501496315, -0.08000289648771286, -0.02940594218671322, -0.009289177134633064, 0.0389658622443676, 0.04207503795623779, -0.009063254110515118, -0.03036191500723362, 0.056447409093379974, -0.0006940364255569875, 0.047216616570949554, 0.06160823628306389, 0.0017166152829304338, -0.026270292699337006, 0.06075992062687874, 0.026547828689217567, -0.012438032776117325, -0.029094748198986053, 0.012808109633624554, -0.007915702648460865, -0.005915504414588213, 0.05126525089144707, -0.0029198394622653723, 0.03671615943312645, -0.030597209930419922, -0.029361313208937645, 0.007389937527477741, -0.023561980575323105, -0.05545247718691826, -0.024952489882707596, 0.0008618112187832594, 0.009338722564280033, -0.03000936470925808 ]
We introduce a dynamic event-triggering mechanism for regulating the axonal growth of a neuron. We apply boundary actuation at the soma (the part of a neuron that contains the nucleus) and regulate the dynamics of tubulin concentration and axon length. The control law is formulated by applying a Zero-Order Hold (ZOH) to a continuous-time controller which guides the axon to reach the desired length. The proposed dynamic event-triggering mechanism determines the specific time instants at which control inputs are sampled from the continuous-time control law. We establish the existence of a minimum dwell-time between two triggering times that ensures avoidance of Zeno behavior. Through employing the Lyapunov analysis with PDE backstepping, we prove the local stability of the closed-loop system in $L_2$-norm, initially for the target system, and subsequently for the original system. The effectiveness of the proposed method is showcased through numerical simulations.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00131v2
[ -0.01985536329448223, -0.039891067892313004, 0.07585818320512772, 0.01925998367369175, 0.03933646157383919, -0.038520243018865585, 0.002680279314517975, -0.01578560844063759, 0.011544955894351006, -0.0048339650966227055, -0.03981063887476921, -0.020990362390875816, -0.02786523476243019, -0.06526467204093933, -0.0426868312060833, 0.030817613005638123, 0.0737234503030777, 0.03727564215660095, -0.046919770538806915, 0.057201869785785675, 0.005240153055638075, -0.06118316948413849, -0.006616740487515926, -0.00007153573096729815, -0.01456692535430193, -0.05881885066628456, -0.010584378615021706, 0.028105273842811584, -0.07549143582582474, -0.03142339363694191, 0.060641393065452576, -0.0459074042737484, 0.022229434922337532, 0.023831550031900406, -0.03120226413011551, -0.045374345034360886, -0.009534425102174282, 0.004357575438916683, 0.04975299909710884, 0.018045935779809952, 0.00757165951654315, -0.047679487615823746, -0.04155472293496132, 0.039318159222602844, 0.012805735692381859, -0.009678796865046024, -0.044643331319093704, 0.021924426779150963, -0.022351600229740143, -0.0682947039604187, 0.012352798134088516, 0.011469149962067604, 0.01898111402988434, 0.04180467128753662, -0.050710875540971756, 0.03905695676803589, -0.008759045042097569, 0.022289691492915154, -0.06096682325005531, -0.04092758893966675, 0.014815282076597214, -0.0516032911837101, -0.005773000884801149, -0.005888371262699366, 0.03394465148448944, 0.05083739385008812, 0.023607129231095314, -0.05738354101777077, -0.04580084607005119, -0.04055830091238022, 0.046998199075460434, -0.05878670513629913, 0.017490165308117867, -0.012844272889196873, -0.040161289274692535, -0.04227624088525772, -0.007406512275338173, -0.0237672608345747, -0.010075096040964127, 0.03117760643362999, -0.016360463574528694, 0.0164932981133461, 0.04021156206727028, 0.05729330703616142, 0.028280772268772125, 0.011194121092557907, 0.0381072461605072, -0.03900871053338051, 0.026122529059648514, -0.061399515718221664, 0.03391174226999283, -0.03136347234249115, -0.057579316198825836, 0.03179815411567688, 0.04892634227871895, -0.05735444277524948, 0.053472764790058136, 0.04530053585767746, 0.014396538026630878, -0.014861353673040867, -0.02102726511657238, 0.01958378404378891, -0.014706875197589397, 0.03185424581170082, 0.028341729193925858, -0.03331737220287323, 0.016098028048872948, -0.02243981696665287, -0.03856629133224487, 0.04105529934167862, -0.018054962158203125, -0.060161933302879333, -0.015596989542245865, -0.07008735835552216, -0.046045225113630295, -0.012949300929903984, 0.06765944510698318, -0.025599263608455658, 0.04386667162179947, -0.010009901598095894, -0.043584659695625305, 0.06541410833597183, -0.03429553657770157, 0.051805976778268814, -0.0237803403288126, 0.01907436177134514, 0.05881806090474129, 0.050537168979644775, -0.05807638168334961, -0.015497351065278053, 0.035922203212976456, 0.03927074000239372, -0.019234992563724518, -0.055906206369400024, -0.0030550153460353613, -0.013363303616642952, 0.015533200465142727, -0.06787292659282684, -0.009909274987876415, 0.005120543297380209, -0.035365406423807144, 0.036094781011343, 0.01430967915803194, -0.02948261797428131, 0.016192596405744553, -0.005753658711910248, -0.06028025969862938, 0.0013288655318319798, 0.05282139405608177, 0.01508457399904728, 0.00037942558992654085, 0.013364691287279129, 0.013255451805889606, -0.02292240597307682, -0.017274662852287292, -0.02493966370820999, 0.03326636925339699, 0.0029071427416056395, -0.0553630031645298, -0.010966136120259762, 0.0673159584403038, -0.05253426730632782, 0.020677588880062103, -0.025185195729136467, -0.0030466378666460514, 0.03674614429473877, 0.03497299179434776, -0.020260890945792198, 0.005724240094423294, 0.006719091907143593, 0.005535770673304796, -0.023367660120129585, 0.0035790400579571724, -0.027708737179636955, -0.030437329784035683, -0.06473978608846664, 0.017308305948972702, -0.07011439651250839, -0.05763736367225647, -0.02302679233253002, 0.02042536251246929, 0.04052178934216499, -0.03550275042653084, 0.03328586369752884, -0.032006703317165375, -0.006970371585339308, -0.07708743959665298, 0.007096664980053902, 0.06465613842010498, 0.04629118740558624, -0.02572246640920639, -0.058313675224781036, 0.014540725387632847, 0.02889923006296158, -0.03776504471898079, -0.04270089790225029, -0.017203710973262787, -0.004645708482712507, 0.0011503985151648521, 0.007016264833509922, -0.055036067962646484, -0.007805950939655304, -0.053394608199596405, 0.002538955071941018, -0.03913372382521629, -0.034076027572155, 0.03740112856030464, 0.03892267867922783, -0.06884455680847168, -0.003194835502654314, 0.008754312060773373, 0.008231465704739094, 0.04891454428434372, -0.035822052508592606, 0.027546478435397148, -0.024664606899023056, -0.09747012704610825, 0.0415860190987587, 0.0548701174557209, -0.015076049603521824, 0.031080074608325958, -0.041258569806814194, -0.037466101348400116, -0.02005855180323124, -0.052908964455127716, 0.050907257944345474, 0.002959665609523654, -0.029385626316070557, -0.05467008799314499, -0.017555108293890953, -0.003935019485652447, -0.07337021082639694, -0.03748338297009468, -0.049083199352025986, -0.02238503098487854, 0.00925600714981556, -0.030845096334815025, 0.018726473674178123, 0.01779038831591606, -0.03610294684767723, -0.0588172972202301, -0.012913278304040432, 0.05187804251909256, -0.0656159445643425, -0.032403841614723206, -0.04932568222284317, -0.059436965733766556, 0.023976080119609833, -0.017451249063014984, -0.039862871170043945, 0.030284199863672256, -0.015189019031822681, -0.03870999813079834, -0.03870277479290962, 0.010088297538459301, 0.06923146545886993, -0.009948662482202053, 0.018288103863596916, -0.015161505900323391, 0.03851136565208435, 0.04519004002213478, 0.02938988246023655, -0.034327615052461624, 0.0034992373548448086, -0.024772314354777336, -0.00809322390705347, -0.04162120446562767, 0.006604078225791454, 0.005333352833986282, -0.020300228148698807, 0.02349545992910862, -0.02844637632369995, 0.024230513721704483, 0.015161973424255848, 0.007874573580920696, -0.0020030569285154343, -0.02555699273943901, -0.02852727845311165, 0.055037714540958405, 0.01775354892015457, 0.04310903698205948, 0.028041653335094452, 0.031506653875112534, -0.08170612901449203, -0.025375261902809143, -0.05609099194407463, 0.017970552667975426, -0.07304614037275314, -0.061314940452575684, -0.02407982386648655, -0.05724245682358742, 0.05154990777373314, -0.025537794455885887, -0.004360462538897991, -0.06910328567028046, -0.043944429606199265, -0.04939943552017212, 0.01448946725577116, 0.00140685576479882, -0.06848783046007156, -0.04639951139688492, -0.020353661850094795, 0.028460374101996422, 0.009211632423102856, 0.034284673631191254, -0.02672893926501274, 0.016096055507659912, -0.04956263676285744, 0.03877465799450874, 0.050906259566545486, -0.01909797452390194, 0.030736787244677544, -0.00938445795327425, -0.02203552983701229, 0.0001962658134289086, 0.03134582191705704, 0.024282798171043396, 0.0002400915400357917, -0.006093150936067104, -0.020820511505007744, -0.012684350833296776, -0.031880151480436325, 0.008415951393544674, -0.0017930122558027506, -0.056097351014614105, -0.051144447177648544, 0.04046854376792908, 0.043941739946603775, -0.029512356966733932, -0.059856727719306946, -0.005364864598959684, -0.025072427466511726, -0.0053198570385575294, -0.017818447202444077, 0.07325238734483719, -0.008829768747091293, -0.044056184589862823, 0.00007822603220120072, -0.040209852159023285, 0.023629730567336082, -0.038018327206373215, 0.023467039689421654, 0.009179891087114811, 0.0036838473752141, 0.019237373024225235, -0.05330730974674225, 0.024124523624777794, 0.022396178916096687, 0.022986678406596184, -0.030140914022922516, 0.04985653609037399, -0.006904867943376303, 0.022542035207152367, 0.017847588285803795, 0.022516664117574692, 0.03977470472455025, 0.051231980323791504, 0.040174905210733414, 0.020684638991951942, -0.019109351560473442, 0.03355836495757103, -0.07890929281711578, -0.04411540552973747, -0.03019055165350437, 0.009485638700425625, 0.023844346404075623, -0.01266500260680914, -0.04707479104399681, 0.03261222690343857, -0.04935530945658684, 0.05715396627783775, -0.013683260418474674, -0.033512093126773834, 0.000536613049916923, -0.04215491935610771, -0.025361593812704086, 0.03181903809309006, 0.028210556134581566, -0.026551848277449608, -0.04147215560078621, 0.009567750617861748, -0.06202026456594467, 0.02071840688586235, -0.02911076508462429, -0.03047334775328636, -0.008274552412331104, 0.01746353693306446, -0.054533906280994415, 0.025769077241420746, -0.0288749560713768, -0.014367396011948586, -0.043926529586315155, -0.043675996363162994, 0.011425734497606754, 0.007734664250165224, -0.032019492238759995, 0.024946659803390503, -0.023262012749910355, -0.022182293236255646, -0.03526965156197548, 0.02917693741619587, -0.03494968265295029, -0.008916136808693409, -0.05565574765205383, -0.007139588240534067, -0.04521910473704338, 0.011180197820067406, -0.0340564139187336, -0.0514141209423542, 0.05464671924710274, -0.01706230640411377, 0.0019935767631977797, -0.06138934567570686, -0.017315803095698357, 0.004983228165656328, -0.020424026995897293, -0.047248341143131256, -0.03070555254817009, 0.031931545585393906, 0.009553789161145687, 0.04453184828162193, -0.028626320883631706, 0.012977727688848972, -0.06171092391014099, -0.00852388795465231, -0.022881492972373962, 0.049058739095926285, 0.04861482232809067, 0.024334369227290154, 0.006872578989714384, 0.021889569237828255, -0.023969322443008423, 0.031246397644281387, -0.01789306290447712, 0.00974564254283905, -0.051977481693029404, 0.028086090460419655, -0.06483897566795349, -0.035454679280519485, 0.013566708192229271, 0.037369560450315475, 0.08228720724582672, 0.020741388201713562, -0.04970194771885872, -0.01875142939388752, 0.04707440361380577, -0.06128815561532974, -0.03956425562500954, -0.013907631859183311, -0.05500982701778412, -0.055923473089933395, -0.02704816684126854, -0.007508276496082544, 0.018205735832452774, 0.04917788505554199, 0.06376542150974274, 0.019528698176145554, 0.04953538998961449, -0.017745541408658028, -0.004975814372301102, 0.006826434750109911, 0.05034197121858597, 0.014353718608617783, 0.051547642797231674, -0.07899904996156693, 0.002715572714805603, -0.013518295250833035, -0.014287116937339306, -0.014196045696735382, 0.07085403800010681, 0.001988042378798127, 0.018677491694688797, -0.07870248705148697, -0.015385981649160385, -0.00712160300463438, -0.010669934563338757, 0.050025347620248795, -0.0036358374636620283, -0.013369155116379261, 0.009344261139631271, -0.04204349219799042, 0.008444641716778278, 0.028096944093704224, 0.015597399324178696, -0.006494784727692604, 0.05030959099531174, -0.029567362740635872, -0.01662050187587738, 0.04935593903064728, 0.005684283562004566, -0.05092688277363777, 0.015630554407835007, -0.0063035329803824425, 0.022860197350382805, -0.02418731525540352, 0.01207686960697174, 0.049827948212623596, -0.02539973147213459, 0.009789903648197651, 0.02371811307966709, 0.029645519331097603, 0.007241507526487112, 0.021169964224100113, -0.03742257505655289, -0.0006326816510409117, 0.029862310737371445, 0.03257051482796669, 0.02701040543615818, 0.04827382043004036, 0.026575040072202682, 0.024022208526730537, -0.004453892819583416, 0.023208510130643845, -0.051194384694099426, 0.02564452961087227, -0.007794705219566822, -0.004858872853219509, 0.0003522006736602634, 0.005786205176264048, 0.002214705338701606, 0.03624922037124634, 0.01659412682056427, -0.02809467725455761, -0.06612696498632431, -0.03364591673016548, 0.03636753931641579, -0.025249142199754715, -0.007636329624801874, 0.016443926841020584, 0.05948268249630928, -0.027265507727861404, 0.025715872645378113, 0.018317291513085365, -0.0072576082311570644, 0.01265210285782814, -0.021134154871106148, 0.05248617008328438, -0.062345340847969055, -0.04620884358882904, 0.024314936250448227, 0.024007858708500862, -0.06110083684325218, 0.022686762735247612, 0.04902692139148712, 0.011106588877737522, -0.00472338916733861, -0.014865322038531303, -0.003806803608313203, -0.07090207934379578, 0.01060038898140192, 0.08519814908504486, -0.030948737636208534, -0.02038954757153988, -0.030526023358106613, -0.014760015532374382, -0.013954823836684227, -0.05362134426832199, -0.04852999374270439, 0.003043767996132374, -0.0009708453435450792, -0.06366193294525146, 0.05886845663189888, 0.011808090843260288, -0.07169870287179947, -0.016251852735877037, 0.05714048817753792, -0.06743838638067245, 0.03717434033751488, 0.006387201137840748, -0.02328287437558174, -0.041788846254348755, -0.008564661256968975, -0.02538898028433323, -0.022953640669584274, 0.001719739055261016, 0.045084431767463684, 0.04639860615134239, 0.023782698437571526, -0.0019188930746167898, -0.01000269129872322, -0.04291512444615364, 0.016337184235453606, -0.05940423533320427, -0.008008546195924282, -0.02157372608780861, 0.05468037724494934, 0.03137466311454773, -0.03437774255871773, -0.017854217439889908, 0.04703475534915924, -0.04122081398963928, -0.026717768982052803, -0.03094320185482502, 0.01791081763803959, 0.03454188257455826, -0.031963005661964417, -0.03804975003004074, -0.033061739057302475, -0.00459838192909956, -0.017697935923933983, -0.036441534757614136, 0.024844449013471603, -0.03923796862363815, -0.007410195656120777, 0.012471621856093407, -0.036345258355140686, -0.02770189568400383, -0.031053267419338226, -0.0025401220191270113, 0.019209029152989388, -0.06590476632118225, -0.055758193135261536, 0.0014730275142937899, 0.010761317797005177, 0.022063426673412323, 0.04392646253108978, -0.048016469925642014, 0.037165261805057526, -0.030568422749638557, -0.0014324686489999294, 0.0058791241608560085, -0.0017908929148688912, -0.02071342244744301, 0.000668972497805953, 0.03484892472624779, -0.02236551232635975, 0.03753848373889923, -0.042385876178741455, -0.05937238037586212, 0.030668674036860466, -0.027381518855690956, 0.005316753406077623, -0.05813295766711235, -0.0022227023728191853, -0.06779450923204422, 0.0036133145913481712, 0.03259715437889099, -0.05856502801179886, -0.0283871591091156, 0.033227384090423584, -0.032215286046266556, -0.0021079692523926497, 0.005682796705514193, 0.007394351065158844, -0.037185732275247574, 0.03076869435608387, 0.013827658258378506, 0.07262087613344193, 0.02779802866280079, -0.0357866995036602, -0.030272264033555984, -0.04419904574751854, 0.04043072089552879, 0.03309145197272301, -0.03917920961976051, -0.03854113444685936, -0.017698220908641815, -0.05876922979950905, -0.022422989830374718, 0.06807763129472733, -0.03267447277903557, -0.013573743402957916, -0.07113668322563171, 0.03784077242016792, -0.03175369277596474, -0.04558295011520386, -0.0689842626452446, -0.010647707618772984, 0.006391404662281275, -0.011588336899876595, 0.018351562321186066, -0.011913701891899109, -0.030036360025405884, -0.03793690726161003, -0.08579143136739731, -0.0018081535818055272, -0.026959549635648727, 0.04193238914012909, 0.03281315416097641, 0.013252350501716137, -0.03850167989730835, -0.04042297229170799, 0.010699925944209099, 0.05243278294801712, 0.044912803918123245, 0.0027538982685655355, 0.04787188023328781, 0.0025082677602767944, -0.04927397519350052, -0.028211936354637146, 0.046967651695013046, -0.012150115333497524, -0.012103475630283356, 0.08290700614452362, 0.02773270383477211, -0.012470225803554058, -0.021989045664668083, -0.013572460040450096, 0.029766179621219635, 0.021315930411219597, -0.023616725578904152, -0.04991547018289566, -0.04247644916176796, -0.04191827401518822, 0.04810992255806923, -0.043583765625953674, 0.012042264454066753, -0.04395641013979912, -0.006432130467146635, 0.023712914437055588, -0.009863662533462048, -0.018444668501615524, 0.054369375109672546, -0.005087841767817736, -0.005325731821358204, 0.05197380855679512, -0.058072056621313095, -0.0025444997008889914, -0.021530497819185257, -0.00849280133843422, -0.06827437877655029, 0.003327034180983901, 0.03388218954205513, -0.00851020310074091, 0.04363730549812317, -0.060820069164037704, 0.030139798298478127, -0.041790831834077835, 0.019148584455251694, -0.0666150376200676, 0.04584961384534836, -0.027103038504719734, 0.02789740264415741, -0.048120684921741486, -0.04427483305335045, -0.03444337844848633, -0.03638666868209839, 0.007370115257799625, -0.02227090485394001, 0.016361545771360397, -0.04584761708974838, 0.0449950210750103, 0.000754951557610184, 0.056252654641866684, 0.03604070469737053, 0.016120975837111473, -0.04280652850866318, -0.011742068454623222, -0.03286706656217575, 0.03398703411221504, 0.030785996466875076, -0.021985333412885666, -0.06526169925928116, 0.014659399166703224, 0.030915556475520134, 0.028637275099754333, -0.024878527969121933, -0.004145478829741478, 0.010345863178372383, -0.06064935773611069, -0.01850801892578602, 0.04231206327676773, 0.004986712243407965, -0.055019643157720566, 0.049381062388420105, 0.02014929987490177, -0.026061346754431725, -0.028970345854759216 ]
The classification of phases and the detection of phase transitions are central and challenging tasks in diverse fields. Within physics, it relies on the identification of order parameters and the analysis of singularities in the free energy and its derivatives. Here, we propose an alternative framework to identify quantum phase transitions. Using the axial next-nearest neighbor Ising (ANNNI) model as a benchmark, we show how machine learning can detect three phases (ferromagnetic, paramagnetic, and a cluster of the antiphase with the floating phase). Employing supervised learning, we demonstrate the feasibility of transfer learning. Specifically, a machine trained only with nearest-neighbor interactions can learn to identify a new type of phase occurring when next-nearest-neighbor interactions are introduced. We also compare the performance of common classical machine learning methods with a version of the quantum nearest neighbors (QNN) algorithm.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15339v1
[ -0.026270490139722824, -0.0051419236697256565, 0.0120689757168293, 0.021082798019051552, -0.0026649131905287504, -0.04252439737319946, 0.07019425183534622, 0.05604799836874008, -0.0021209849510341883, -0.02594054862856865, -0.029480112716555595, -0.046243634074926376, -0.03672023490071297, -0.06410154700279236, -0.047340277582407, 0.004568374250084162, 0.061396703124046326, -0.0035114982165396214, -0.04191045090556145, 0.04128915071487427, 0.03996540978550911, -0.009621571749448776, -0.015031948685646057, 0.05499149113893509, -0.03223533555865288, -0.029979128390550613, -0.02777758613228798, -0.02485852874815464, -0.026054395362734795, -0.02665422111749649, 0.05566250905394554, -0.03702439367771149, 0.00918425153940916, -0.02445823885500431, -0.030263736844062805, -0.04036708548665047, 0.008177016861736774, 0.04686824977397919, 0.03196064382791519, -0.029149921610951424, -0.018802599981427193, -0.04787469282746315, -0.05235246941447258, -0.006784576456993818, -0.03598111867904663, -0.020120128989219666, -0.03907265514135361, -0.025983473286032677, -0.04768410325050354, -0.039138540625572205, 0.008363759145140648, -0.025772396475076675, -0.014936601743102074, 0.04494357481598854, -0.039632633328437805, -0.013067658990621567, -0.018732745200395584, 0.01729021966457367, -0.041124068200588226, -0.011279679834842682, 0.0037752294447273016, -0.0414128378033638, 0.018203316256403923, 0.0024162461049854755, -0.01261050533503294, 0.03774585947394371, -0.031819574534893036, -0.06843279302120209, -0.02224878780543804, -0.06845918297767639, 0.03662613034248352, -0.05188191309571266, -0.012946467846632004, 0.016659293323755264, -0.058839939534664154, -0.05786832422018051, -0.01193699985742569, -0.02121601440012455, 0.0053968271240592, -0.010570839047431946, -0.004778983537107706, 0.02471841126680374, 0.043671682476997375, 0.05215592309832573, 0.002605535788461566, -0.012973354198038578, 0.028454555198550224, -0.002647607820108533, -0.006551994942128658, -0.05836116522550583, 0.030925333499908447, -0.02410729229450226, -0.030677001923322678, -0.041885845363140106, 0.055564604699611664, 0.006441236007958651, 0.02334303967654705, 0.04085277393460274, -0.0186635572463274, -0.011765013448894024, -0.027156269177794456, -0.0429258830845356, -0.0374814011156559, 0.07434459030628204, 0.015128754079341888, -0.023657556623220444, -0.01710338518023491, 0.0005995519459247589, -0.045800741761922836, 0.04391412064433098, 0.019404172897338867, 0.014924056828022003, 0.015103583224117756, -0.0562809519469738, -0.046852100640535355, -0.024797076359391212, -0.001457800273783505, 0.03786114230751991, 0.036759380251169205, -0.01773839071393013, -0.0419340506196022, -0.006157411262392998, 0.029467863962054253, -0.03175291046500206, -0.057899754494428635, 0.029243793338537216, 0.07417413592338562, -0.002590588293969631, 0.013284790329635143, -0.03276604413986206, -0.0031490414403378963, 0.02897801622748375, 0.029713492840528488, -0.04810185357928276, 0.06834224611520767, -0.023491138592362404, -0.037448637187480927, -0.05024724453687668, -0.016970239579677582, 0.011924326419830322, -0.06508596241474152, -0.05206169933080673, -0.001563031692057848, -0.01568758115172386, 0.0035221802536398172, 0.03251824155449867, -0.08078475296497345, -0.0050628515891730785, -0.00043528832611627877, 0.02154618129134178, 0.028037570416927338, -0.005332369357347488, 0.02530040591955185, -0.017194999381899834, 0.032954007387161255, -0.0419020876288414, 0.05312230810523033, -0.03769189864397049, -0.05260149762034416, 0.020833659917116165, 0.02709154412150383, -0.018212543800473213, -0.03616045415401459, -0.009307893924415112, -0.009274768643081188, 0.0032816012389957905, 0.01578986458480358, -0.036107249557971954, -0.0008289085235446692, -0.028509866446256638, -0.054749052971601486, 0.0037721788976341486, 0.021611288189888, -0.0421936959028244, -0.0431290827691555, -0.052562251687049866, -0.030761417001485825, -0.06246097385883331, 0.019240852445364, -0.0014373795129358768, 0.036123331636190414, -0.028828924521803856, -0.028953932225704193, 0.029924383386969566, -0.06105976551771164, 0.05660108104348183, -0.08425098657608032, -0.001686621573753655, 0.028199447318911552, 0.00706408079713583, -0.004659002646803856, -0.027091778814792633, 0.05073545128107071, -0.0011051757028326392, -0.048309776932001114, -0.008369160816073418, -0.03060835786163807, -0.020918091759085655, -0.012050531804561615, 0.050428394228219986, -0.0755988359451294, -0.006921978201717138, -0.0184775497764349, -0.018275141716003418, -0.0378725491464138, -0.06500244140625, 0.047410327941179276, 0.005518155172467232, -0.010023387148976326, -0.027401059865951538, 0.0310206301510334, 0.06626001000404358, 0.05593588203191757, 0.0036367233842611313, -0.013170384801924229, -0.006378138437867165, -0.09307143092155457, 0.017940005287528038, -0.02594105154275894, 0.009334755130112171, 0.041577987372875214, 0.002635281067341566, 0.005118928384035826, -0.009809350594878197, -0.004588581621646881, 0.04687003418803215, 0.02503698505461216, 0.0015556510770693421, -0.03797050938010216, -0.056443214416503906, -0.009183722548186779, -0.060379475355148315, -0.06296578794717789, -0.051953092217445374, -0.048202838748693466, 0.014958814717829227, -0.0501091405749321, 0.0309512410312891, -0.008746315725147724, -0.07126937061548233, -0.03201627731323242, -0.00786973349750042, 0.06252238899469376, -0.03701020032167435, -0.04461655765771866, -0.023608243092894554, -0.023930376395583153, 0.045496322214603424, -0.006090377923101187, -0.06343692541122437, -0.0011367487022653222, -0.0694660171866417, -0.006400026381015778, -0.04614698886871338, -0.011036191135644913, -0.01664319820702076, -0.029704725369811058, 0.012932241894304752, -0.01290514413267374, 0.056858889758586884, 0.01634090766310692, 0.02131069265305996, -0.046411361545324326, 0.002607710426673293, 0.02197292447090149, 0.013001101091504097, -0.024255570024251938, -0.012813263572752476, 0.000849270261824131, -0.03534837067127228, -0.03538556396961212, 0.023434605449438095, 0.036872293800115585, 0.016116555780172348, -0.05754823982715607, -0.00362818012945354, -0.0379471555352211, -0.07169897854328156, 0.019703349098563194, 0.013842269778251648, 0.05105878412723541, 0.01310627069324255, -0.01029143389314413, -0.037420984357595444, -0.004851440899074078, -0.04157771170139313, -0.014496628195047379, 0.016004059463739395, -0.038452230393886566, -0.03947887197136879, -0.07124544680118561, 0.01046797540038824, -0.06710899621248245, -0.06114347651600838, -0.02508576214313507, -0.05334813520312309, 0.003932354971766472, -0.041290365159511566, 0.021815704181790352, -0.022128354758024216, -0.06367840617895126, -0.02484949305653572, 0.030861198902130127, 0.03377338871359825, -0.0019961476791650057, -0.07015153020620346, -0.02223704382777214, 0.013246065936982632, 0.016727445647120476, 0.005565599538385868, -0.04674369469285011, 0.01824330911040306, -0.055368490517139435, 0.029598252847790718, 0.031629011034965515, 0.018550090491771698, 0.022345883771777153, -0.01774226687848568, 0.0036290520802140236, -0.03037828952074051, 0.022714998573064804, 0.0186715479940176, 0.04180936515331268, 0.003970134537667036, -0.059855956584215164, -0.03879442438483238, 0.06151745840907097, 0.00596131756901741, -0.020534664392471313, -0.023373838514089584, -0.006712873466312885, 0.009435140527784824, 0.06315410882234573, -0.006008009891957045, 0.05352938175201416, 0.030288545414805412, 0.008240894414484501, -0.02620028145611286, -0.04951227828860283, 0.02079877071082592, 0.01132022961974144, 0.03983873873949051, 0.015200797468423843, 0.005877394694834948, -0.0017699133604764938, -0.08208182454109192, 0.0325872004032135, 0.013371087610721588, 0.05693788081407547, -0.04074074700474739, -0.018442798405885696, 0.04510332643985748, 0.014221496880054474, 0.02061154693365097, -0.0027332347817718983, 0.05211763456463814, 0.023679645732045174, 0.050015680491924286, -0.003564484417438507, -0.02020588330924511, -0.0531640350818634, -0.06876134872436523, -0.06293781101703644, 0.011124406941235065, 0.048849694430828094, 0.04722943529486656, 0.000379001721739769, -0.05632438138127327, 0.021084889769554138, -0.007918565534055233, 0.07417362183332443, 0.01701458729803562, -0.029972398653626442, 0.022023934870958328, 0.015429372899234295, -0.03819309175014496, 0.022279653698205948, -0.00811583548784256, -0.05589590221643448, -0.07460831105709076, -0.005578156560659409, -0.04834001138806343, 0.033303823322057724, 0.047046925872564316, 0.0074580637738108635, 0.024174373596906662, 0.011900296434760094, -0.040168143808841705, 0.01920720376074314, 0.010154051706194878, -0.0022657010704278946, -0.026183772832155228, -0.009119628928601742, -0.005962209310382605, 0.007551887072622776, -0.06628011167049408, 0.022574270144104958, 0.026285815984010696, -0.01862352527678013, -0.02179965190589428, 0.01640775240957737, 0.009611831046640873, 0.010438152588903904, -0.0841589868068695, -0.020502567291259766, -0.05773603916168213, 0.0106642572209239, -0.0368545837700367, -0.022713951766490936, 0.07800361514091492, -0.027798708528280258, 0.03666193038225174, -0.040901944041252136, -0.01751001551747322, -0.03058793768286705, -0.0399191789329052, 0.00016898738977033645, -0.08051873743534088, -0.006135033909231424, -0.04817026108503342, 0.03907746449112892, 0.000511327525600791, -0.01043314766138792, -0.07622186839580536, -0.028343964368104935, 0.003333193715661764, 0.0014620221918448806, 0.039053257554769516, 0.05667811632156372, 0.03505478426814079, -0.0019185948185622692, 0.006010172422975302, 0.036625225096940994, 0.019239861518144608, 0.0032115625217556953, -0.02400164306163788, 0.022970793768763542, -0.021260574460029602, -0.024011481553316116, -0.03573645278811455, -0.0004345203342381865, 0.06591898947954178, -0.04550454765558243, -0.050962988287210464, 0.04895816370844841, 0.005570914130657911, -0.04861130192875862, -0.05801142007112503, -0.051625315099954605, 0.015022484585642815, -0.07002582401037216, -0.030288180336356163, 0.0028569521382451057, 0.008516871370375156, -0.013852559961378574, -0.0502827987074852, 0.022924145683646202, 0.05171508714556694, -0.020819352939724922, 0.022792549803853035, -0.01261912565678358, 0.018828406929969788, -0.04169931635260582, -0.016101747751235962, -0.049722716212272644, -0.014017279259860516, -0.010251535102725029, -0.013452601619064808, -0.008959071710705757, 0.04157011955976486, -0.0001694647507974878, 0.05843978002667427, -0.08454081416130066, 0.05091748759150505, 0.0446767583489418, -0.006763329263776541, -0.026597952470183372, 0.010830010287463665, -0.03179040551185608, 0.023271594196558, -0.043420951813459396, 0.0022023520432412624, 0.02815714105963707, -0.021592505276203156, 0.034072138369083405, -0.012458855286240578, -0.042621832340955734, 0.022253192961215973, 0.042068399488925934, -0.01858130656182766, -0.03454200178384781, 0.005252487491816282, 0.02230753004550934, 0.007234983146190643, -0.06265027076005936, 0.03473677858710289, 0.04069830849766731, -0.021755101159214973, -0.02348705753684044, 0.008363962173461914, -0.007181352004408836, -0.024257227778434753, 0.02077685482800007, -0.004556676372885704, -0.04799477010965347, 0.038491640239953995, 0.02654474787414074, 0.0030933169182389975, -0.0022862055338919163, 0.007445651106536388, 0.029342930763959885, -0.0030363372061401606, 0.019435543566942215, -0.06064766272902489, -0.022574497386813164, -0.03801271319389343, 0.012194818817079067, -0.030123069882392883, 0.05059097334742546, 0.04235445708036423, 0.055098287761211395, -0.02950138971209526, -0.0625113844871521, 0.03984759375452995, -0.05531984940171242, 0.0496884323656559, -0.04345092549920082, 0.031658828258514404, -0.008344839327037334, 0.05445466935634613, -0.01350037194788456, 0.047553423792123795, 0.044584691524505615, -0.03901945799589157, -0.032491181045770645, -0.030996568500995636, 0.009753190912306309, 0.004542021080851555, -0.03430035710334778, -0.05082974582910538, 0.007559488527476788, 0.012516552582383156, 0.01219972688704729, -0.0057248505763709545, 0.012749118730425835, 0.03572183847427368, 0.0029598481487482786, 0.013050563633441925, -0.043696604669094086, 0.014311526902019978, 0.08612232655286789, -0.07224395126104355, 0.011050927452743053, -0.03490164130926132, -0.03405510634183884, 0.019212430343031883, -0.023179367184638977, 0.021445931866765022, 0.020810963585972786, -0.03480285778641701, -0.08631230145692825, 0.037536077201366425, -0.007259595673531294, -0.06060510873794556, -0.05506515130400658, -0.01544979028403759, -0.07038068026304245, 0.008247772231698036, 0.03944263234734535, -0.007660730741918087, -0.029790563508868217, 0.04713720083236694, -0.013901269063353539, -0.025382747873663902, -0.04557541012763977, 0.033599719405174255, 0.07401634752750397, -0.06000809744000435, 0.029443558305501938, 0.052577219903469086, 0.03038705885410309, 0.03314724192023277, -0.047415390610694885, 0.02479538321495056, 0.024413233622908592, 0.05295048654079437, 0.007151593454182148, -0.01607670821249485, 0.015657374635338783, 0.03584004193544388, -0.04195091873407364, -0.009476518258452415, -0.03799128159880638, -0.014253237284719944, 0.03971453383564949, -0.06056135147809982, -0.06224220618605614, -0.00043504807399585843, -0.01992407813668251, -0.009976486675441265, -0.01353383157402277, -0.025220174342393875, -0.05132722482085228, 0.023888124153017998, -0.013521992601454258, -0.04421038553118706, 0.04448879137635231, -0.043980807065963745, -0.06389821320772171, 0.02784395031630993, -0.059751659631729126, -0.052818942815065384, 0.008979735895991325, 0.027874000370502472, 0.047733042389154434, 0.024172550067305565, -0.03457285836338997, -0.02579948678612709, -0.019721776247024536, 0.03662654757499695, -0.0026795133017003536, 0.021570932120084763, -0.0019411350367590785, -0.002486385637894273, 0.03358788788318634, -0.013692599721252918, -0.009231152944266796, -0.02911132015287876, -0.04558320343494415, 0.02445404790341854, -0.004753417335450649, -0.02882327511906624, -0.03613674268126488, 0.019001591950654984, 0.012319983914494514, -0.0009911099914461374, 0.030357971787452698, -0.03247452899813652, -0.04428567364811897, 0.02426004968583584, -0.023384157568216324, 0.022810187190771103, 0.012793037109076977, -0.00017244619084522128, 0.022788386791944504, 0.012169856578111649, 0.06256978213787079, 0.045263685286045074, 0.029702015221118927, 0.012605974450707436, -0.04306435212492943, -0.03047129139304161, 0.026544293388724327, 0.0068875811994075775, -0.050081949681043625, -0.022109655663371086, -0.04428965970873833, -0.07087040692567825, -0.025788215920329094, -0.008025120943784714, -0.03284413367509842, -0.013357042334973812, -0.07289928942918777, 0.02480968087911606, 0.010290112346410751, -0.06430497765541077, -0.06893282383680344, 0.010060850530862808, -0.005211312789469957, -0.006409083493053913, 0.025939373299479485, 0.0075583611615002155, -0.060802049934864044, 0.004890674725174904, -0.08484994620084763, -0.018948348239064217, -0.03455681353807449, 0.0526697114109993, -0.004697328433394432, 0.0282836202532053, -0.010920998640358448, -0.037629928439855576, 0.028350213542580605, 0.03043307550251484, 0.04600729048252106, 0.05016188323497772, 0.004788212478160858, 0.041360802948474884, -0.02749255672097206, -0.05201573669910431, 0.061290960758924484, -0.029068080708384514, -0.0021479863207787275, 0.026908908039331436, 0.03908848762512207, 0.04580247402191162, 0.024453766644001007, 0.059073787182569504, 0.027567626908421516, 0.035656802356243134, -0.04529528692364693, -0.0061049251817166805, -0.028959155082702637, -0.07791957259178162, 0.014003219082951546, -0.05409013107419014, 0.039517808705568314, 0.036600835621356964, -0.0444219633936882, -0.05302825942635536, 0.011879589408636093, -0.016347398981451988, 0.009994354099035263, 0.002756692236289382, -0.013258468359708786, 0.07058615982532501, -0.0637068971991539, 0.003928001504391432, 0.0315685011446476, -0.019009381532669067, -0.05001615732908249, 0.028644615784287453, 0.03384866937994957, -0.0702635869383812, 0.02005237340927124, -0.06177237629890442, 0.060053031891584396, -0.035219624638557434, 0.0071848551742732525, 0.014066100120544434, 0.03958513215184212, -0.011332551948726177, -0.04904216527938843, -0.012417125515639782, -0.02840350568294525, -0.04269794002175331, -0.06482681632041931, 0.0037656533531844616, -0.01825203187763691, 0.022785581648349762, -0.016909515485167503, 0.044217031449079514, 0.027874311432242393, 0.07419916987419128, 0.05166660249233246, -0.018450627103447914, -0.0107493344694376, 0.009473997168242931, -0.04654855653643608, 0.06159624084830284, 0.007266576401889324, 0.021440548822283745, -0.03586307168006897, 0.029261957854032516, -0.03861507400870323, 0.03050798736512661, 0.028532901778817177, 0.03560088202357292, -0.03189430013298988, -0.028368260711431503, -0.015610167756676674, -0.0011155606480315328, -0.03742405027151108, -0.001967791933566332, 0.02553691528737545, -0.0004587693838402629, 0.004094537813216448, -0.05664679408073425 ]
The problem of optimal recovering high-order mixed derivatives of bivariate functions with finite smoothness is studied. On the basis of the truncation method, an algorithm for numerical differentiation is constructed, which is order-optimal both in the sense of accuracy and in terms of the amount of involved Galerkin information.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09710v1
[ -0.022186279296875, -0.030512778088450432, 0.055656883865594864, 0.03412164747714996, -0.010125684551894665, -0.013058298267424107, -0.0226863045245409, -0.02727661095559597, -0.0006744292331859469, -0.03488998860120773, -0.04802990332245827, -0.003075429704040289, -0.06133532524108887, -0.0001989626616705209, -0.0684996247291565, 0.02342367172241211, 0.048307083547115326, 0.0357167087495327, -0.0404067263007164, 0.07990344613790512, -0.03616764768958092, 0.026103490963578224, -0.016924651339650154, 0.05926554650068283, 0.023059042170643806, 0.00943155586719513, -0.057691171765327454, 0.010378201492130756, -0.022399023175239563, -0.018721651285886765, 0.038343705236911774, -0.010808845050632954, 0.008003816939890385, -0.050554171204566956, -0.013642407022416592, 0.013828849419951439, -0.014507049694657326, 0.004878079053014517, 0.06329954415559769, -0.010314048267900944, -0.0408637560904026, -0.03470060974359512, -0.0736059695482254, -0.005571112502366304, 0.027291228994727135, 0.05058080330491066, -0.04493875801563263, -0.02546102926135063, -0.03843372315168381, -0.04546209052205086, 0.010710122063755989, -0.0445026233792305, -0.0007515717297792435, 0.02889435552060604, -0.042424555867910385, -0.029502516612410545, -0.003676250111311674, 0.01919310912489891, -0.042447373270988464, 0.008702309802174568, -0.024553798139095306, -0.018747592344880104, -0.03084622509777546, -0.021360088139772415, -0.06600777059793472, 0.05513377487659454, -0.01754288747906685, -0.042083337903022766, 0.02218855917453766, -0.027899034321308136, 0.03635090962052345, -0.0200901348143816, 0.038006581366062164, 0.01977243833243847, -0.03770831972360611, -0.05435587465763092, -0.012610577046871185, -0.011038663797080517, -0.011873423121869564, -0.020654136314988136, -0.02062450721859932, 0.06101222336292267, 0.017629224807024002, 0.025487137958407402, -0.00021953626128379256, -0.019835351034998894, 0.07342515885829926, -0.010132679715752602, 0.015007401816546917, -0.038555808365345, 0.008168978616595268, 0.02819633111357689, -0.07954190671443939, -0.022145546972751617, 0.030837129801511765, -0.0001100257140933536, 0.061912890523672104, 0.06697990000247955, 0.003453867742791772, 0.027248382568359375, -0.05112142488360405, -0.0504591204226017, -0.04114751145243645, 0.02947242744266987, 0.0032339130993932486, 0.05387899652123451, -0.036442529410123825, 0.00921314861625433, 0.030853722244501114, -0.013614687137305737, 0.004800333175808191, 0.007179672829806805, -0.02151292935013771, -0.016815269365906715, -0.052545346319675446, -0.022029737010598183, 0.04600244760513306, 0.06255738437175751, 0.001692254445515573, -0.03109484352171421, 0.020292891189455986, -0.013467444106936455, -0.023340225219726562, -0.021278442814946175, -0.07915494590997696, -0.05999365076422691, -0.0008299489272758365, 0.027777403593063354, -0.014235454611480236, -0.03037036582827568, -0.02257106453180313, -0.037462808191776276, 0.04968437924981117, -0.02750464528799057, 0.024510938674211502, -0.010004480369389057, -0.007888099178671837, -0.06990531831979752, 0.02941386215388775, 0.007013942115008831, -0.061034783720970154, -0.0783427506685257, 0.0615498349070549, -0.03691801428794861, -0.0004942889790982008, 0.04793795198202133, -0.03278594836592674, -0.011316510848701, 0.03950217738747597, 0.06434940546751022, -0.03589304909110069, 0.020271239802241325, -0.010432776063680649, -0.009087284095585346, -0.028945358470082283, 0.06483113765716553, 0.05851924046874046, -0.03221834823489189, -0.020288705825805664, 0.030111337080597878, 0.002199616516008973, 0.011684664525091648, -0.02687915973365307, 0.004680037032812834, -0.004205409903079271, -0.014721968211233616, 0.01677723601460457, -0.02549329586327076, -0.03370063006877899, -0.041641801595687866, -0.0461529865860939, -0.005705992691218853, 0.0470413975417614, -0.060969892889261246, -0.024658910930156708, -0.04825908690690994, -0.05419004708528519, -0.06737914681434631, -0.045986104756593704, -0.030874133110046387, 0.02379951812326908, 0.03173567354679108, 0.02646615542471409, -0.0006604683585464954, -0.017748508602380753, 0.015091471374034882, -0.06351576745510101, 0.01796508952975273, 0.05217338725924492, 0.020807065069675446, 0.04468170925974846, -0.04628244787454605, 0.00860211905092001, 0.018740752711892128, -0.04254372790455818, -0.05209266021847725, 0.030332989990711212, -0.03827085345983505, -0.05498750880360603, 0.0354156456887722, -0.07803452759981155, -0.06373506784439087, -0.031195351853966713, 0.021503355354070663, 0.0028481341432780027, -0.029883332550525665, 0.016278889030218124, 0.016419218853116035, -0.0378093421459198, -0.003741063177585602, 0.08544030040502548, 0.07365711778402328, 0.066381074488163, 0.004165195859968662, -0.017366718500852585, -0.0017215569969266653, -0.09260297566652298, 0.029016686603426933, -0.006718519609421492, -0.0054328106343746185, -0.005052641499787569, 0.031954843550920486, -0.033141691237688065, -0.05875324457883835, 0.008476790972054005, 0.07736674696207047, 0.020493945106863976, 0.02775118127465248, -0.004421822726726532, -0.016918683424592018, 0.03858392685651779, -0.045816488564014435, 0.006269889418035746, -0.07076266407966614, -0.023938780650496483, 0.02164897508919239, -0.0009774654172360897, 0.06560098379850388, -0.01642332598567009, -0.06780970096588135, -0.0663282722234726, 0.0147945461794734, 0.06263904273509979, 0.003048216924071312, -0.021946536377072334, -0.02307320199906826, 0.0027725643012672663, -0.029140161350369453, -0.018034661188721657, 0.012511497363448143, 0.02486756071448326, -0.07300176471471786, -0.041902534663677216, 0.00894000194966793, 0.0071492427960038185, 0.018007254227995872, 0.017326025292277336, 0.051286883652210236, 0.017119109630584717, 0.0505625382065773, 0.05753937363624573, -0.004191203974187374, -0.048998139798641205, -0.03715721517801285, -0.017948627471923828, 0.03003060072660446, 0.010469541884958744, 0.01982031762599945, -0.031954895704984665, -0.0546669140458107, 0.015225337818264961, 0.0013206744333729148, -0.004700124263763428, -0.011346463114023209, -0.010026013478636742, 0.0027756537310779095, -0.014329418540000916, -0.03310977295041084, 0.031604085117578506, -0.01388619001954794, 0.0018574523273855448, 0.01633939892053604, 0.02308077923953533, -0.061367955058813095, 0.06132734566926956, 0.03096049278974533, -0.022861793637275696, -0.07564681768417358, -0.028710346668958664, 0.0013401205651462078, -0.07312483340501785, -0.03887399286031723, -0.036624688655138016, -0.08089741319417953, -0.033592842519283295, -0.06130851060152054, -0.008937173523008823, -0.00916278176009655, -0.0058613368310034275, -0.0228737723082304, -0.06960786134004593, -0.044308919459581375, 0.05609964579343796, -0.033036645501852036, -0.02609904855489731, -0.023050371557474136, -0.05444405972957611, 0.017422284930944443, 0.0249894168227911, -0.006452993024140596, 0.01909458078444004, -0.03751743212342262, 0.017485907301306725, 0.041048429906368256, -0.007248482666909695, 0.0297574233263731, 0.041233278810977936, 0.02222388982772827, 0.010192891582846642, 0.0552946962416172, 0.003910762257874012, 0.024842524901032448, -0.013179817236959934, -0.04850975051522255, -0.034291524440050125, 0.0009542807820253074, -0.0013080363860353827, -0.03754681721329689, -0.01373126171529293, 0.004656879231333733, -0.031736914068460464, -0.0111997090280056, -0.0020445426926016808, -0.050065938383340836, 0.02990363910794258, 0.04240339249372482, 0.014906077645719051, -0.059007368981838226, -0.039500217884778976, 0.02921644225716591, 0.010400805622339249, 0.04570199176669121, 0.0552373044192791, -0.043569762259721756, -0.02271549217402935, -0.07891764491796494, 0.03235292062163353, -0.010088418610394001, 0.020561058074235916, -0.042566876858472824, -0.03878989443182945, -0.0013782178284600377, -0.048262353986501694, -0.015263868495821953, -0.02541401982307434, -0.025068799033761024, -0.016844486817717552, 0.05028912425041199, 0.01815497688949108, 0.019294576719403267, -0.005110708065330982, -0.05233699828386307, 0.018522974103689194, -0.0610969215631485, 0.038029786199331284, 0.07107129693031311, -0.042408108711242676, -0.029694655910134315, -0.0038689232897013426, -0.019251110032200813, -0.002800545422360301, 0.05338865891098976, -0.03749268874526024, 0.04544029012322426, -0.0009877997217699885, 0.0037792709190398455, 0.014059176668524742, -0.03357263281941414, 0.06648790836334229, -0.053323809057474136, 0.027982810512185097, -0.062297191470861435, 0.04581611603498459, -0.004787685349583626, -0.016393965110182762, 0.048235706984996796, -0.013520817272365093, -0.010644073598086834, 0.020652269944548607, 0.011352759785950184, -0.008810863830149174, -0.007174565922468901, 0.04117332026362419, -0.032997407019138336, 0.029560957103967667, -0.061920542269945145, 0.0468059740960598, 0.013537898659706116, 0.0019434733549132943, -0.012715079821646214, 0.022136228159070015, 0.02865511178970337, -0.04907742515206337, -0.07000523805618286, 0.0033378559164702892, -0.0015426049940288067, 0.040218207985162735, -0.029341494664549828, -0.0806373730301857, 0.03515716269612312, -0.025468330830335617, -0.03040047362446785, -0.02604675106704235, -0.025233443826436996, 0.015475894324481487, -0.06672610342502594, -0.024637646973133087, -0.06398886442184448, 0.016677580773830414, -0.038860272616147995, 0.04105501249432564, 0.025737076997756958, -0.04449747875332832, -0.020565669983625412, -0.05048843100667, 0.04680917412042618, -0.00310665019787848, 0.07895765453577042, -0.01825490966439247, 0.02577565237879753, -0.018533267080783844, 0.03276258334517479, -0.024932462722063065, -0.04038837552070618, 0.02470371127128601, -0.014737820252776146, 0.0000840615393826738, -0.032504789531230927, -0.024868780747056007, -0.03309367597103119, -0.009881111793220043, 0.04618488997220993, -0.05079001933336258, -0.006862442009150982, 0.0030353893525898457, 0.0017443278338760138, -0.04494854807853699, -0.043158095329999924, 0.014802657067775726, 0.0073989699594676495, 0.01263415813446045, -0.051817551255226135, 0.03273565322160721, 0.025638539344072342, 0.02990984544157982, -0.004502024967223406, -0.03169523552060127, -0.05882727727293968, -0.06829188764095306, -0.034421324729919434, 0.026654021814465523, 0.01577633060514927, -0.07931071519851685, -0.050259437412023544, -0.07626628875732422, -0.03770138695836067, -0.009232614189386368, 0.040714848786592484, 0.014462331309914589, 0.03796955570578575, 0.04000503942370415, 0.0186085794121027, -0.07204566150903702, -0.025457721203565598, 0.06206884980201721, -0.011874253861606121, -0.030995938926935196, 0.03340451419353485, 0.0017399071948602796, 0.04576645791530609, -0.05441218242049217, -0.061511896550655365, 0.004205601755529642, -0.03710145130753517, -0.0450114831328392, 0.03227310627698898, -0.01835636794567108, 0.00670700753107667, 0.026355065405368805, -0.00143950036726892, -0.034502409398555756, -0.050406958907842636, -0.022845610976219177, -0.0026824597734957933, -0.022429393604397774, 0.021709319204092026, 0.03130287677049637, 0.018404154106974602, -0.06451946496963501, -0.03509518504142761, -0.005295321345329285, 0.023258548229932785, 0.01175063755363226, -0.013467878103256226, 0.011597884818911552, 0.019064821302890778, -0.01706470176577568, 0.014871573075652122, 0.03378631919622421, -0.010550811886787415, -0.021521596238017082, -0.05638229101896286, -0.0375560000538826, -0.05124560743570328, -0.04099055752158165, 0.0035748828668147326, 0.02032838575541973, 0.010587448254227638, -0.034873124212026596, -0.023418037220835686, -0.006636219564825296, 0.024978158995509148, -0.03225192055106163, 0.015471048653125763, -0.013472765684127808, 0.019794665277004242, -0.011157644912600517, 0.05114441737532616, -0.03828209638595581, 0.04428882151842117, 0.04243967682123184, -0.02176543138921261, 0.004389666020870209, 0.0034009343944489956, -0.028009427711367607, 0.012311911210417747, -0.002692447043955326, -0.0028050404507666826, 0.004493736196309328, 0.0008737265015952289, 0.05753626674413681, -0.001684131333604455, 0.040979109704494476, -0.03500732034444809, -0.014753526076674461, 0.005460410378873348, 0.02451261319220066, -0.06382623314857483, -0.02368786185979843, 0.032736942172050476, 0.08018253743648529, -0.009106209501624107, -0.040324337780475616, -0.04506896063685417, -0.053568433970212936, -0.013261934742331505, -0.06812196969985962, 0.03170496225357056, 0.00989437848329544, 0.006422203499823809, -0.02710450254380703, 0.059645019471645355, -0.010972561314702034, -0.0013150376034900546, 0.028040969744324684, 0.046805690973997116, -0.06550655514001846, -0.024045554921030998, -0.03540901094675064, -0.029944825917482376, -0.04804239422082901, 0.035445380955934525, -0.002748713828623295, -0.031242087483406067, -0.07244391739368439, 0.03618786484003067, 0.050412070006132126, -0.059571366757154465, -0.00037378561682999134, 0.04534466937184334, -0.038795921951532364, -0.021101148799061775, -0.01698288321495056, -0.047692082822322845, -0.03181196004152298, 0.0251923780888319, -0.028562486171722412, -0.07734758406877518, -0.03776989504694939, 0.04202652350068092, -0.03672769293189049, -0.00270031183026731, 0.042722318321466446, 0.017366891726851463, 0.005701195914298296, -0.017853135243058205, 0.02463165670633316, 0.0004332130483817309, 0.027392251417040825, -0.014509372413158417, 0.015492795035243034, 0.01554570347070694, -0.03867575526237488, 0.05888904258608818, -0.06259092688560486, -0.019307095557451248, -0.03650136664509773, 0.03843381255865097, -0.03406181186437607, -0.017558077350258827, -0.08068741858005524, 0.022788235917687416, -0.04189858213067055, 0.02669154852628708, -0.006223950535058975, -0.01685997284948826, 0.030669355764985085, 0.008641558699309826, 0.04441339150071144, 0.030966030433773994, 0.007936472073197365, 0.005459062289446592, -0.019908005371689796, -0.06697462499141693, 0.056305404752492905, -0.025885792449116707, 0.04885558784008026, -0.03059973567724228, -0.05875900015234947, -0.013255724683403969, 0.07450958341360092, -0.028628433123230934, -0.023871487006545067, -0.04805131256580353, 0.0016371210804209113, -0.04150508716702461, 0.012997891753911972, -0.007776009850203991, -0.05405015870928764, 0.0014208946377038956, 0.03376273438334465, -0.0361906997859478, -0.02474289759993553, 0.004092053510248661, -0.011768328957259655, -0.004738226532936096, 0.0031167466659098864, -0.017108453437685966, 0.04700995981693268, 0.012159601785242558, -0.04292500019073486, -0.06399202346801758, 0.002053826581686735, -0.051876798272132874, -0.003999704960733652, -0.009070321917533875, 0.03126276284456253, -0.06382890790700912, -0.009766921401023865, -0.011014550924301147, 0.016110427677631378, -0.0012109887320548296, -0.03786049783229828, 0.010218759067356586, -0.006160072982311249, -0.028904877603054047, -0.07372820377349854, 0.01172546111047268, -0.00845447275787592, -0.0003326968871988356, -0.027537919580936432, 0.025408577173948288, 0.00079523422755301, 0.020167697221040726, -0.05721978470683098, 0.005492314696311951, 0.011445716954767704, 0.04640667140483856, -0.025379013270139694, -0.022306017577648163, 0.03248023986816406, -0.01632673293352127, 0.006751439068466425, -0.01976180262863636, 0.05517789348959923, 0.047593001276254654, 0.03206423297524452, -0.013979501090943813, -0.05126471444964409, -0.0446951799094677, 0.030336325988173485, -0.02634408511221409, 0.039396267384290695, -0.043800584971904755, 0.06871763616800308, -0.00021517563436646014, -0.010693790391087532, 0.0700189620256424, -0.014823189936578274, -0.007687517441809177, -0.012629033997654915, -0.032184161245822906, -0.04218342900276184, -0.055726565420627594, 0.03622351959347725, -0.06294085085391998, -0.013762536458671093, 0.0012960659805685282, -0.006010490003973246, -0.013735742308199406, 0.023581236600875854, -0.04340679943561554, -0.041069187223911285, -0.02008359506726265, -0.017408622428774834, -0.0050870878621935844, -0.0026126510929316282, 0.001749676652252674, -0.010575325228273869, 0.0441773422062397, -0.03592081367969513, -0.008196442387998104, 0.024397552013397217, -0.02028336375951767, 0.028803406283259392, -0.054014671593904495, 0.007456211838871241, -0.03885555639863014, 0.017646532505750656, 0.022293617948889732, 0.023355143144726753, -0.0532732792198658, -0.012354222126305103, -0.04882350191473961, -0.026920249685645103, 0.0018846839666366577, -0.060491904616355896, -0.01068340614438057, -0.0561724454164505, 0.03387581557035446, 0.02287396974861622, 0.03559093177318573, -0.04148602485656738, 0.061153750866651535, -0.005760005675256252, 0.026459405198693275, 0.009441899135708809, 0.012610005214810371, -0.07724787294864655, 0.06485876441001892, -0.022999867796897888, -0.03835917264223099, -0.02178376354277134, -0.026895469054579735, 0.036253586411476135, -0.048298683017492294, 0.009818841703236103, 0.01416531577706337, -0.013238821178674698, -0.03325069695711136, 0.015589944086968899, -0.03887386992573738, 0.03903159499168396, -0.06220993772149086, 0.013539760373532772, -0.02111085131764412, 0.03412718325853348, -0.05107234790921211 ]
Here, we develop a framework for the prediction and screening of native defects and functional impurities in a chemical space of Group IV, III-V, and II-VI zinc blende (ZB) semiconductors, powered by crystal Graph-based Neural Networks (GNNs) trained on high-throughput density functional theory (DFT) data. Using an innovative approach of sampling partially optimized defect configurations from DFT calculations, we generate one of the largest computational defect datasets to date, containing many types of vacancies, self-interstitials, anti-site substitutions, impurity interstitials and substitutions, as well as some defect complexes. We applied three types of established GNN techniques, namely Crystal Graph Convolutional Neural Network (CGCNN), Materials Graph Network (MEGNET), and Atomistic Line Graph Neural Network (ALIGNN), to rigorously train models for predicting defect formation energy (DFE) in multiple charge states and chemical potential conditions. We find that ALIGNN yields the best DFE predictions with root mean square errors around 0.3 eV, which represents a prediction accuracy of 98 % given the range of values within the dataset, improving significantly on the state-of-the-art. Models are tested for different defect types as well as for defect charge transition levels. We further show that GNN-based defective structure optimization can take us close to DFT-optimized geometries at a fraction of the cost of full DFT. DFT-GNN models enable prediction and screening across thousands of hypothetical defects based on both unoptimized and partially-optimized defective structures, helping identify electronically active defects in technologically-important semiconductors.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06423v2
[ -0.012755434028804302, -0.033850476145744324, 0.041887376457452774, 0.04420927166938782, -0.02812296338379383, -0.025147050619125366, 0.015632880851626396, 0.035594262182712555, -0.018345952033996582, -0.01910046488046646, -0.03452899307012558, -0.009773628786206245, -0.05226735398173332, -0.028658732771873474, -0.052282802760601044, 0.016201606020331383, 0.0683712363243103, 0.028349531814455986, -0.018327249214053154, 0.06571163982152939, 0.029347142204642296, -0.03472183644771576, -0.010010698810219765, 0.06257425993680954, 0.027878398075699806, 0.048043813556432724, -0.0413489006459713, -0.01890777237713337, 0.02095881663262844, -0.014576676301658154, 0.06130160763859749, -0.01910361833870411, 0.000612703908700496, -0.03414273262023926, 0.02166072465479374, -0.04053939878940582, -0.03047136776149273, 0.043829090893268585, 0.026129264384508133, -0.05879054218530655, -0.03556668013334274, -0.02128133550286293, -0.0658513605594635, -0.04600856825709343, -0.030687324702739716, 0.03853664547204971, -0.025288060307502747, -0.014165992848575115, -0.04884111508727074, -0.05838996171951294, 0.050520144402980804, -0.031210336834192276, -0.011353128589689732, 0.059583332389593124, -0.018476175144314766, 0.0063463738188147545, -0.05321716517210007, -0.00048474493087269366, -0.052163247019052505, 0.0023025365080684423, 0.04181166738271713, -0.04090200737118721, -0.03722703456878662, -0.03820192813873291, -0.040224213153123856, 0.047312188893556595, -0.015247350558638573, -0.05197177454829216, -0.016793090850114822, -0.04103398695588112, 0.00879814475774765, -0.05054875835776329, 0.022287825122475624, -0.044844143092632294, -0.019028935581445694, -0.051953624933958054, -0.03509135916829109, 0.02124834805727005, 0.015143807046115398, -0.008976701647043228, -0.00272883428260684, 0.0216048713773489, 0.037494562566280365, 0.05105748772621155, -0.019996555522084236, -0.03345302492380142, 0.04741211235523224, -0.04037093371152878, -0.01813376322388649, -0.019506389275193214, 0.03023175150156021, -0.035533081740140915, -0.06754463911056519, 0.013642264530062675, 0.039815861731767654, 0.00416185799986124, 0.026844464242458344, 0.007545123808085918, -0.011736336164176464, -0.003398885950446129, -0.05663035809993744, -0.049338582903146744, 0.0016211973270401359, 0.04944897070527077, 0.017714262008666992, 0.014587161131203175, -0.023003006353974342, -0.04174729809165001, -0.039600688964128494, 0.01568331941962242, 0.005462374538183212, -0.029257064685225487, 0.004263304173946381, -0.03880073502659798, -0.07386087626218796, -0.042952485382556915, 0.05558242276310921, 0.03229226917028427, 0.03371782973408699, 0.0014228264335542917, -0.02429424412548542, 0.015905769541859627, 0.03601111099123955, -0.014419237151741982, -0.03920309618115425, 0.014837091788649559, 0.05723312497138977, -0.006335181184113026, 0.006062208209186792, -0.01614215224981308, -0.05060933530330658, 0.016498204320669174, 0.005163968075066805, -0.04234502464532852, 0.05029583349823952, -0.054097630083560944, -0.0032689457293599844, -0.04898767173290253, 0.024043966084718704, 0.044892583042383194, -0.052236657589673996, -0.054240088909864426, 0.020392531529068947, -0.0026456830091774464, -0.023609453812241554, 0.07812988013029099, -0.06833824515342712, -0.03647257387638092, 0.03622766584157944, 0.020737038925290108, 0.017964115366339684, -0.008105509914457798, -0.03757688030600548, -0.03739655390381813, -0.0024769254960119724, -0.0069569251500070095, 0.05185706540942192, -0.00812495406717062, -0.03187406808137894, 0.0458134226500988, -0.010960601270198822, -0.06891696900129318, -0.01079389825463295, 0.009087643586099148, -0.038939885795116425, 0.0047486815601587296, -0.018517276272177696, -0.03609476238489151, 0.03716088831424713, -0.008802797645330429, -0.05008377134799957, -0.01745162159204483, 0.010223438031971455, -0.044208139181137085, -0.00515012489631772, -0.04222436994314194, -0.0030628982931375504, -0.06691713631153107, -0.04062606394290924, -0.03103075735270977, 0.019578207284212112, 0.044439882040023804, -0.011428702622652054, 0.00992671586573124, -0.03521690145134926, -0.041199106723070145, -0.08124571293592453, -0.017839014530181885, 0.017426544800400734, -0.02728877402842045, -0.006558096501976252, -0.0403943806886673, -0.0004469783743843436, 0.011572031304240227, -0.021960392594337463, -0.07105135917663574, 0.035437460988759995, -0.004472376313060522, -0.0210429597645998, 0.007243523374199867, -0.07743146270513535, -0.02328246831893921, -0.029329197481274605, 0.03514126315712929, 0.010794962756335735, -0.05592753365635872, -0.020573629066348076, 0.022454528138041496, -0.03787514194846153, -0.0036304329987615347, 0.05962846055626869, 0.03414131700992584, 0.05844377726316452, -0.002127810614183545, -0.029321040958166122, 0.001270046690478921, -0.08975143730640411, 0.052099790424108505, -0.010884029790759087, 0.004271906800568104, 0.039951689541339874, 0.011144272051751614, 0.04577060788869858, -0.036219388246536255, -0.005998453591018915, 0.036680761724710464, 0.055969640612602234, -0.011942683719098568, 0.02488056570291519, -0.01663486286997795, -0.03421900048851967, -0.054366063326597214, -0.06378646939992905, -0.06512008607387543, -0.008056135848164558, 0.002009099116548896, -0.041358307003974915, 0.059673894196748734, -0.03755272552371025, -0.07367219775915146, -0.03786992281675339, -0.0060075134970247746, 0.03290539234876633, -0.010637329891324043, -0.04584674909710884, -0.0001738159917294979, -0.03990625962615013, 0.03399454802274704, -0.01144531648606062, -0.023923786357045174, 0.012456276454031467, -0.0596785806119442, -0.020475756376981735, -0.017594560980796814, 0.0013171480968594551, 0.04073368012905121, -0.01567445509135723, 0.027583763003349304, -0.008312943391501904, 0.0740031898021698, 0.032266765832901, 0.026800978928804398, -0.003628647653385997, 0.011607683263719082, 0.04254351928830147, 0.012500254437327385, -0.02637939155101776, -0.010982765816152096, 0.0335230752825737, -0.039873018860816956, -0.014786827377974987, 0.0065627084113657475, 0.05846703425049782, -0.0025866448413580656, -0.05432015657424927, 0.01821538805961609, -0.01021863054484129, -0.03658133000135422, 0.001934237778186798, 0.013413568027317524, 0.054552942514419556, 0.01221927348524332, 0.01796119287610054, -0.061135511845350266, -0.006967594381421804, -0.048595692962408066, 0.03987664729356766, -0.05467198044061661, -0.025801250711083412, -0.01715494692325592, -0.06313607096672058, -0.03846515342593193, -0.05404786020517349, -0.04854799807071686, -0.02838272601366043, -0.05447499826550484, -0.03321206569671631, -0.04330119118094444, 0.004319269210100174, -0.05274998024106026, -0.05133702605962753, -0.045917659997940063, 0.025338150560855865, 0.057972393929958344, 0.015347152017056942, -0.0594046451151371, -0.04095634073019028, 0.008817587979137897, 0.04007149115204811, 0.017591772601008415, -0.041523609310388565, 0.01137999165803194, -0.0491228923201561, 0.03167128935456276, 0.007456320337951183, 0.03456515818834305, 0.019397351890802383, -0.01243932917714119, 0.04867035895586014, -0.01657114177942276, 0.001728909439407289, 0.007960540242493153, 0.018155435100197792, -0.03552496060729027, -0.04840109497308731, -0.048597000539302826, 0.046630192548036575, 0.017631299793720245, -0.01858861744403839, 0.014798182062804699, -0.0264810249209404, -0.0005571602378040552, 0.015046692453324795, -0.006196126341819763, 0.05655748397111893, 0.06102157384157181, -0.040559615939855576, -0.001376663101837039, -0.0239684097468853, -0.015177005901932716, -0.0020812067668884993, 0.018311403691768646, 0.003548710374161601, 0.03622274473309517, 0.011589761823415756, -0.07367951422929764, 0.010660102590918541, 0.01644337736070156, 0.06390772014856339, -0.005735411308705807, -0.010258194990456104, 0.014353929087519646, 0.03806987777352333, 0.02542370744049549, 0.016667312011122704, 0.06066451966762543, 0.018212851136922836, 0.07503025233745575, -0.004822260700166225, -0.04836530238389969, -0.010324706323444843, -0.05272441357374191, -0.048987068235874176, 0.019289962947368622, 0.05490223690867424, 0.04448578134179115, 0.008183232508599758, -0.038170699030160904, 0.06213342025876045, 0.017537208274006844, 0.046365391463041306, 0.015691950917243958, -0.0198785699903965, 0.038576360791921616, -0.022139770910143852, 0.0031151508446782827, 0.016220225021243095, -0.026942390948534012, 0.0071039143949747086, -0.07324261963367462, 0.0305707436054945, -0.06988266855478287, 0.0024242980871349573, 0.04316147044301033, 0.0030033907387405634, 0.030874717980623245, 0.039096660912036896, -0.02708624117076397, 0.052621230483055115, -0.009601183235645294, 0.003777502104640007, 0.0025748375337570906, 0.04746635630726814, 0.0008133212686516345, 0.016107609495520592, -0.05523142218589783, -0.004621168132871389, 0.03680652752518654, -0.05603618919849396, -0.04001617804169655, 0.0099571468308568, 0.044177617877721786, 0.0018658071057870984, -0.05424937978386879, -0.022334301844239235, -0.02426624670624733, 0.005199419800192118, -0.04975135624408722, -0.020622359588742256, 0.05030045658349991, -0.015342092141509056, -0.007486315909773111, -0.021043330430984497, -0.018293138593435287, -0.030242720618844032, -0.024404270574450493, 0.014913363382220268, -0.06673496961593628, 0.02309824898838997, -0.03862328082323074, 0.03352546691894531, -0.010884168557822704, -0.006536932196468115, -0.0743010938167572, 0.0022282416466623545, -0.015204337425529957, -0.018620016053318977, 0.058549728244543076, 0.04082028940320015, 0.03955548629164696, 0.009625771082937717, 0.033351145684719086, -0.019481131806969643, -0.04779297113418579, 0.027255313470959663, -0.02719562128186226, 0.01832594722509384, 0.01048301998525858, -0.048337455838918686, -0.03647913038730621, -0.006896969396620989, 0.05099591240286827, -0.047733381390571594, -0.03010338544845581, 0.033543650060892105, 0.02022082544863224, -0.05678267031908035, -0.05207768827676773, -0.03319587558507919, -0.049851637333631516, -0.04258181154727936, -0.03599637746810913, 0.018713487312197685, 0.010249634273350239, 0.014220059849321842, 0.02083849534392357, 0.03373090177774429, -0.0014016535133123398, -0.00780482916161418, 0.03457053005695343, 0.04917837306857109, 0.0550604946911335, 0.017968596890568733, -0.030572708696126938, -0.066621795296669, -0.04314013198018074, -0.024539586156606674, -0.001641959766857326, -0.009044221602380276, 0.056329093873500824, 0.01994827203452587, 0.034013278782367706, -0.0669487714767456, 0.017116112634539604, 0.045565761625766754, 0.04740074276924133, -0.034053340554237366, 0.019552409648895264, 0.02003050409257412, 0.01152145303785801, -0.05224529653787613, -0.0067908866330981255, 0.026925139129161835, 0.011366636492311954, 0.04993370547890663, 0.022928135469555855, -0.05730463191866875, 0.030813278630375862, 0.06638738512992859, 0.03158801794052124, -0.04116929695010185, 0.024695932865142822, 0.00704340822994709, 0.0016070632264018059, -0.044018931686878204, -0.013711627572774887, 0.060733094811439514, -0.01613367348909378, -0.02748812735080719, -0.017869476228952408, 0.016328953206539154, 0.008965084329247475, -0.01969337835907936, -0.07153880596160889, -0.012416467070579529, 0.033677857369184494, 0.01075668167322874, 0.03857351467013359, 0.014432297088205814, 0.014717203564941883, 0.041807692497968674, -0.03393946588039398, -0.012640196830034256, -0.06553357094526291, -0.030966222286224365, -0.003034498542547226, 0.056932102888822556, 0.06471860408782959, 0.032634954899549484, -0.01363036036491394, 0.05837894603610039, -0.04958822950720787, -0.03466755896806717, 0.00685577979311347, -0.02696359157562256, 0.04365930333733559, -0.058193907141685486, 0.05329670384526253, -0.011300355195999146, 0.04700914025306702, 0.02779989130795002, 0.019345348700881004, -0.03846384212374687, -0.006000049877911806, -0.06019992381334305, -0.04474262520670891, 0.019224265590310097, 0.002044808119535446, -0.046942420303821564, -0.0005864863633178174, 0.04650245979428291, -0.03794708847999573, 0.03620203956961632, 0.00894309114664793, -0.012787391431629658, 0.01645456999540329, -0.0011691275285556912, -0.040533799678087234, -0.06491132080554962, -0.017519636079669, 0.06720104068517685, -0.06906545162200928, -0.01028460543602705, -0.015750251710414886, -0.0471130907535553, 0.01485513336956501, -0.05794810503721237, 0.04418601468205452, 0.024765504524111748, -0.02551773004233837, -0.051549382507801056, 0.010973561555147171, 0.011963823810219765, -0.071657195687294, -0.004570991266518831, -0.017696108669042587, -0.07678520679473877, 0.04760764539241791, 0.00024952253443188965, -0.0361061654984951, -0.07009465992450714, 0.027075299993157387, -0.017440997064113617, 0.00297832814976573, -0.0722450464963913, 0.05745783448219299, 0.06999900937080383, -0.013247487135231495, 0.05297797918319702, 0.05469132959842682, 0.01911229081451893, 0.0026557198725640774, -0.04892345517873764, -0.056708287447690964, -0.01468726247549057, 0.02321246825158596, 0.005185350310057402, -0.027504172176122665, -0.03175030276179314, 0.05888792872428894, 0.005499765742570162, -0.014760996215045452, 0.006455595139414072, -0.022126557305455208, 0.01143304631114006, -0.023055974394083023, -0.02183571644127369, 0.005906152073293924, -0.0575430803000927, -0.02853902243077755, -0.03879718855023384, 0.03404815122485161, -0.04993654787540436, 0.02387148141860962, -0.016795072704553604, -0.03347185254096985, -0.007571425288915634, -0.002512893173843622, -0.033834055066108704, 0.030978813767433167, -0.05578184127807617, 0.014975144527852535, -0.007649528328329325, 0.037444692105054855, -0.0019469655817374587, -0.004207544960081577, -0.023313501849770546, -0.044111140072345734, 0.0027470269706100225, 0.010627602227032185, -0.03693557158112526, -0.006252022925764322, -0.012244464829564095, -0.05059656873345375, 0.04682539403438568, -0.018035629764199257, 0.019607391208410263, -0.03253073990345001, -0.04555308818817139, -0.01646997220814228, -0.012638201005756855, -0.04720781743526459, -0.02635018713772297, 0.0361822247505188, -0.01176535990089178, 0.024951541796326637, 0.05821312218904495, -0.04644874855875969, -0.06474138796329498, 0.04936613515019417, -0.039434630423784256, -0.003629011334851384, 0.0332329235970974, 0.020382871851325035, 0.04141717404127121, 0.011965458281338215, 0.04798654839396477, 0.048881154507398605, -0.027303308248519897, 0.003698631189763546, -0.05106858164072037, 0.003273092908784747, 0.030146701261401176, 0.022449811920523643, -0.0404445044696331, -0.05483211949467659, -0.001476333593018353, -0.07995980232954025, -0.020875878632068634, -0.00234614172950387, -0.033907096832990646, -0.0422077476978302, -0.07414989173412323, 0.0221859160810709, 0.029760893434286118, -0.04582076519727707, -0.06954780220985413, -0.008133124560117722, -0.046560727059841156, 0.01001380942761898, -0.014916734769940376, 0.00751976715400815, -0.010600583627820015, 0.028765683993697166, -0.07939065247774124, -0.05314117670059204, 0.011702364310622215, 0.07589723914861679, 0.03508300334215164, -0.020243613049387932, -0.05984702333807945, -0.03548487648367882, -0.04338282346725464, -0.025670884177088737, 0.015099306590855122, 0.013891845941543579, 0.02664646878838539, 0.033317916095256805, -0.05030123516917229, -0.042806874960660934, 0.016747409477829933, -0.02977936342358589, -0.019085174426436424, 0.00187637226190418, 0.0305962935090065, 0.032912444323301315, 0.0370132252573967, 0.05955955386161804, -0.03180577978491783, 0.013916275463998318, -0.041630204766988754, -0.006227428093552589, -0.03757600858807564, -0.06581497192382812, 0.05588813126087189, -0.05770889297127724, -0.019253337755799294, -0.03477972373366356, -0.015991801396012306, -0.04952497035264969, -0.001310632680542767, -0.04939965903759003, -0.0014458977384492755, 0.04843525215983391, -0.01636328734457493, 0.04639903083443642, -0.04507635533809662, 0.03762490302324295, -0.03627873212099075, 0.019829291850328445, -0.06364406645298004, -0.008556537330150604, 0.01093005109578371, -0.04917741194367409, 0.018563998863101006, -0.035733725875616074, 0.03612187132239342, 0.005326292011886835, 0.01797322742640972, 0.019458724185824394, 0.07407765090465546, -0.0028427194338291883, -0.003318436909466982, -0.018171582370996475, -0.011993635445833206, -0.00559809897094965, -0.03957599774003029, -0.005197121296077967, 0.012609180994331837, 0.05879288166761398, 0.028011219576001167, -0.0037640875671058893, -0.007720818277448416, 0.07990032434463501, -0.006073299795389175, -0.0010270121274515986, 0.014050770550966263, 0.014148016460239887, -0.012739378027617931, 0.07187735289335251, 0.016303203999996185, -0.0015245865797623992, -0.019349148496985435, -0.0042917001992464066, -0.02312578447163105, 0.016535667702555656, 0.030010253190994263, 0.03156747296452522, 0.0009578394237905741, -0.0378623902797699, -0.01039387658238411, 0.007682425435632467, -0.030645228922367096, -0.03271768242120743, 0.04841696470975876, 0.029834238812327385, 0.009498282335698605, -0.0428968220949173 ]
Multi-objective learning (MOL) problems often arise in emerging machine learning problems when there are multiple learning criteria, data modalities, or learning tasks. Different from single-objective learning, one of the critical challenges in MOL is the potential conflict among different objectives during the iterative optimization process. Recent works have developed various dynamic weighting algorithms for MOL such as MGDA and its variants, where the central idea is to find an update direction that avoids conflicts among objectives. Albeit its appealing intuition, empirical studies show that dynamic weighting methods may not always outperform static ones. To understand this theory-practical gap, we focus on a new stochastic variant of MGDA - the Multi-objective gradient with Double sampling (MoDo) algorithm, and study the generalization performance of the dynamic weighting-based MoDo and its interplay with optimization through the lens of algorithm stability. Perhaps surprisingly, we find that the key rationale behind MGDA -- updating along conflict-avoidant direction - may hinder dynamic weighting algorithms from achieving the optimal ${\cal O}(1/\sqrt{n})$ population risk, where $n$ is the number of training samples. We further demonstrate the impact of the variability of dynamic weights on the three-way trade-off among optimization, generalization, and conflict avoidance that is unique in MOL. We showcase the generality of our theoretical framework by analyzing other existing stochastic MOL algorithms under the framework. Experiments on various multi-task learning benchmarks are performed to demonstrate the practical applicability. Code is available at https://github.com/heshandevaka/Trade-Off-MOL.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.20057v3
[ -0.019415060058236122, -0.019529784098267555, 0.04626333341002464, -0.02009139209985733, -0.038274575024843216, 0.03488539531826973, 0.02727505937218666, 0.015453279949724674, -0.03426961228251457, 0.009281467646360397, -0.03367435559630394, -0.03130440041422844, -0.03738733008503914, -0.03851236030459404, -0.04635349288582802, -0.001715726568363607, 0.07358954846858978, 0.0018299848306924105, -0.045935314148664474, 0.05296547710895538, -0.012117112055420876, 0.016475070267915726, -0.05078577250242233, 0.0597233921289444, 0.01868405193090439, -0.00498490035533905, -0.02906029485166073, -0.00039706972893327475, 0.012943516485393047, -0.020740924403071404, 0.06335140019655228, -0.015420839190483093, -0.037758421152830124, -0.07115335762500763, -0.0007899063639342785, -0.034111522138118744, -0.010837966576218605, 0.04939240217208862, 0.04232725873589516, -0.03864092379808426, 0.01644866168498993, -0.035788461565971375, -0.07135409116744995, 0.012328504584729671, -0.03423839434981346, 0.036187805235385895, 0.005181633867323399, -0.03229749947786331, -0.0358697772026062, -0.05273454636335373, 0.0476912260055542, 0.009250160306692123, 0.0423566959798336, 0.04710594192147255, -0.02578692138195038, 0.03809802606701851, -0.019560134038329124, 0.01779209077358246, -0.07312911748886108, -0.04836888238787651, 0.05880724638700485, 0.007100208196789026, -0.0013190066674724221, 0.01102394051849842, -0.03841081261634827, 0.017301391810178757, -0.0005539094563573599, -0.06988741457462311, -0.051324523985385895, -0.05246031656861305, 0.06216428428888321, -0.06342282891273499, 0.022486677393317223, 0.03983473405241966, -0.062271472066640854, -0.022885426878929138, -0.04621639475226402, -0.022471070289611816, -0.021745629608631134, 0.00039353183819912374, 0.009977174922823906, -0.001401020330376923, -0.04857988655567169, -0.015034998767077923, 0.0036929540801793337, -0.028525352478027344, -0.0055188024416565895, -0.02742934413254261, 0.025509679690003395, -0.06108066067099571, 0.03673955798149109, -0.05380402132868767, -0.07671233266592026, -0.03314246982336044, 0.0525888092815876, -0.05796258524060249, 0.04242629185318947, 0.04969904571771622, 0.02048945054411888, -0.016088908538222313, -0.024385415017604828, -0.05501526966691017, -0.03820465877652168, 0.014772813767194748, 0.04506627097725868, -0.03290483355522156, 0.019633185118436813, -0.0018906370969489217, -0.05041637271642685, 0.03293244540691376, 0.02028648555278778, -0.0077382344752550125, -0.013183633796870708, -0.055346306413412094, -0.0618027001619339, -0.030996916815638542, 0.030527561902999878, 0.02780362404882908, 0.017560681328177452, -0.004828691016882658, -0.049220312386751175, 0.0481146015226841, 0.012611225247383118, -0.011082256212830544, -0.01982060819864273, -0.036942195147275925, 0.04536406695842743, -0.03395075350999832, -0.027713211253285408, -0.014402570202946663, -0.06090790405869484, -0.01766955293715, 0.027119727805256844, -0.03211692348122597, 0.06068103760480881, 0.006772625260055065, -0.03987112268805504, -0.05207611247897148, 0.061533793807029724, 0.008919821120798588, -0.0069328551180660725, -0.08649694919586182, 0.04089544340968132, -0.03940628096461296, 0.03334074094891548, 0.03566398844122887, -0.06303391605615616, 0.006298144813627005, 0.0350235179066658, 0.04405361786484718, 0.009246368892490864, 0.035448383539915085, 0.005271245259791613, 0.03939932584762573, 0.027322806417942047, 0.008668778464198112, 0.03008817508816719, -0.024690745398402214, -0.0821496844291687, 0.0066809882409870625, -0.003978443797677755, 0.005564042367041111, 0.040533021092414856, -0.04900135099887848, 0.04501546546816826, 0.00611891457810998, 0.046102721244096756, -0.01134439930319786, 0.021070754155516624, -0.004521266557276249, 0.01732548512518406, -0.009585351683199406, 0.03522787615656853, -0.005319463089108467, -0.05542278289794922, -0.014076788909733295, -0.012154498137533665, -0.05452216416597366, -0.0521000474691391, 0.012907246127724648, 0.04014432057738304, 0.02614160254597664, -0.05848196521401405, 0.018364567309617996, -0.02315904013812542, 0.042683325707912445, -0.08077715337276459, 0.019900592043995857, 0.031052416190505028, 0.038689445704221725, -0.05796915665268898, -0.029941996559500694, 0.03083210065960884, 0.01987588033080101, -0.0036549109499901533, -0.04018222540616989, 0.009425560012459755, -0.0011999846901744604, 0.022906532511115074, 0.05975895747542381, -0.08869647234678268, 0.007382689975202084, -0.05836805701255798, 0.004606359172612429, -0.04086313396692276, -0.05136711522936821, -0.016925882548093796, 0.057439401745796204, -0.02845693565905094, -0.03533244505524635, 0.0551636628806591, 0.048387911170721054, 0.03861100971698761, 0.03285686671733856, 0.04356473311781883, 0.0054626185446977615, -0.09659230709075928, 0.0709325522184372, 0.01309704128652811, 0.01656711846590042, 0.04423811286687851, -0.03505569323897362, -0.0029783458448946476, -0.01410120539367199, 0.009005695581436157, 0.0450347475707531, 0.016032487154006958, 0.01730372942984104, -0.041398897767066956, -0.024061599746346474, 0.011517212726175785, -0.0792369619011879, 0.0014302083291113377, -0.07391750067472458, -0.009205140173435211, 0.00748702697455883, -0.058100685477256775, 0.0588359534740448, -0.013733938336372375, -0.03922634571790695, -0.01472528651356697, -0.01683189533650875, 0.04502679780125618, 0.005757198669016361, -0.044806525111198425, -0.036411598324775696, 0.02585233375430107, 0.02299518696963787, -0.03161441162228584, -0.02163366973400116, -0.040728941559791565, -0.05592966824769974, -0.02850658819079399, -0.01627247780561447, 0.0495431125164032, 0.034814149141311646, -0.04711071774363518, -0.009792516939342022, -0.0273129865527153, 0.04149341583251953, 0.03556893393397331, 0.03594641014933586, -0.022794324904680252, 0.0420645996928215, 0.022834384813904762, -0.002041578060016036, -0.05582060664892197, 0.009392340667545795, 0.007413857150822878, -0.05211765319108963, 0.01681005209684372, 0.022152192890644073, 0.054750945419073105, 0.04236888885498047, 0.013474772684276104, -0.03391154482960701, -0.030424408614635468, -0.05051779747009277, -0.0002822844253387302, 0.031943678855895996, 0.02198687754571438, -0.009706559590995312, -0.030075693503022194, -0.06491553783416748, -0.03684338182210922, -0.05635957419872284, -0.05743679776787758, -0.032275814563035965, -0.060540203005075455, -0.044302865862846375, -0.0797647088766098, -0.050192780792713165, -0.028225526213645935, -0.03152927756309509, -0.027082787826657295, -0.06808128952980042, -0.03436031937599182, -0.00594334164634347, 0.005307197570800781, -0.032435446977615356, -0.03899732977151871, -0.009256360121071339, -0.014650948345661163, 0.005588907282799482, -0.04438956081867218, -0.06208141893148422, -0.018803687766194344, -0.024593304842710495, 0.021274756640195847, 0.0019271440105512738, -0.010156605392694473, 0.03513050079345703, -0.03323167935013771, 0.021004104986786842, -0.011011340655386448, 0.04113006219267845, 0.00822390429675579, -0.00842217169702053, -0.02579733170568943, -0.006225459277629852, 0.013147661462426186, -0.013168826699256897, -0.010505707003176212, -0.035840924829244614, -0.051790911704301834, -0.01048328261822462, 0.07570598274469376, 0.016174742951989174, -0.015932930633425713, -0.04519875347614288, -0.014535831287503242, -0.02418975718319416, 0.009846420958638191, -0.019402241334319115, 0.04266919195652008, 0.03290281817317009, -0.05272624269127846, -0.0339362658560276, -0.04213915020227432, -0.006688710767775774, -0.028338611125946045, 0.022828761488199234, -0.024092091247439384, 0.0062425327487289906, 0.04799530655145645, -0.08871810138225555, 0.009988442994654179, 0.03681600093841553, 0.01788479834794998, -0.009577539749443531, 0.03306546062231064, -0.024621153250336647, -0.024939991533756256, 0.015123396180570126, 0.012170924805104733, 0.045194707810878754, 0.031355369836091995, 0.029591569676995277, -0.009543837048113346, -0.04854979366064072, 0.027686122804880142, -0.06885980069637299, -0.052842043340206146, 0.019836677238345146, 0.02010612189769745, -0.004865247290581465, 0.01569771021604538, -0.07277996093034744, 0.0008428099099546671, -0.018014198169112206, -0.00041016851901076734, -0.012856598943471909, -0.028810804709792137, 0.03047751635313034, -0.024559007957577705, -0.018953124061226845, 0.014601137489080429, 0.01595841906964779, -0.016625111922621727, -0.047224801033735275, 0.030612200498580933, -0.0329766646027565, 0.04188832640647888, 0.02603965811431408, 0.015037315897643566, 0.023742003366351128, 0.061494823545217514, -0.029322944581508636, 0.03718968853354454, -0.02479585073888302, -0.012404306791722775, -0.04070514068007469, 0.009276945143938065, -0.03688646852970123, -0.014313161373138428, -0.08090474456548691, -0.03243406489491463, 0.028811654075980186, -0.024331511929631233, -0.020986398681998253, 0.017320189625024796, 0.013616183772683144, 0.00048106067697517574, -0.08363377302885056, 0.027490852400660515, -0.06692853569984436, 0.042632825672626495, -0.00624213507398963, -0.03471360728144646, 0.08497866243124008, -0.024502858519554138, -0.014119402505457401, -0.03436145931482315, -0.02069036103785038, 0.007142242044210434, -0.026842139661312103, -0.035141296684741974, -0.060384850949048996, -0.008311226963996887, -0.02134864777326584, 0.04437517374753952, 0.014069696888327599, -0.006467440631240606, -0.05470139905810356, -0.06201024726033211, 0.005420100409537554, 0.049256373196840286, 0.07162819802761078, -0.0012871820945292711, -0.03492005914449692, -0.002653018804267049, 0.02037162519991398, -0.044343337416648865, 0.008245712146162987, 0.019910380244255066, -0.03172072395682335, -0.004146997816860676, -0.012339566834270954, -0.029642466455698013, -0.037321627140045166, -0.024452343583106995, 0.07076284289360046, -0.006755146663635969, -0.04562452435493469, -0.031010381877422333, 0.03762803599238396, -0.06043598800897598, -0.07528603076934814, -0.00811284501105547, -0.029687363654375076, -0.021890345960855484, 0.02602078951895237, 0.01543455757200718, 0.03770039230585098, -0.004610082134604454, -0.03696824237704277, -0.002475341549143195, 0.010873965919017792, -0.006384889595210552, 0.023721477016806602, 0.036244455724954605, 0.008358868770301342, 0.021947968751192093, -0.021293016150593758, -0.0895191952586174, -0.016248447820544243, -0.021209092810750008, 0.025870436802506447, 0.0306584183126688, 0.05079652741551399, 0.02070014737546444, 0.0658639520406723, -0.08422857522964478, 0.03598891571164131, 0.03280824422836304, 0.0019723866134881973, 0.01790337823331356, 0.061935022473335266, -0.03411301225423813, 0.01910829171538353, 0.006353366654366255, 0.030278630554676056, -0.0039632003754377365, -0.04674256592988968, 0.01314561814069748, -0.011726811528205872, -0.03965803235769272, -0.04613518714904785, 0.052674438804388046, -0.006385278422385454, -0.06437322497367859, 0.03024006262421608, 0.002534647239372134, -0.006111680064350367, -0.04843392223119736, 0.05910613015294075, 0.011485254392027855, -0.023273054510354996, -0.06397619843482971, -0.03642904758453369, 0.01685875840485096, -0.017775392159819603, -0.007188023068010807, -0.05961807444691658, 0.001553826965391636, 0.027205554768443108, 0.020656786859035492, 0.011375903151929379, 0.009460276924073696, 0.03373141214251518, 0.0125058488920331, -0.041166435927152634, 0.005045229569077492, -0.0513644739985466, -0.010162610560655594, -0.03427181392908096, 0.028470354154706, 0.030255509540438652, 0.014440331608057022, 0.02302849106490612, 0.01844305545091629, -0.01189469825476408, -0.01860344596207142, 0.024178901687264442, -0.003216799348592758, 0.012925248593091965, -0.004831322468817234, 0.0430227555334568, -0.01588483899831772, -0.029050109907984734, 0.004522985778748989, 0.00402379035949707, -0.03874557837843895, -0.05324174091219902, -0.013014129363000393, 0.008655932731926441, 0.0065382784232497215, -0.047356076538562775, -0.045982468873262405, 0.03864561393857002, 0.03578707203269005, -0.0075134402140975, 0.023549145087599754, -0.02506162039935589, -0.016766587272286415, 0.013069231063127518, 0.016833243891596794, -0.0269638579338789, -0.03300171718001366, 0.05240827426314354, 0.07085712999105453, -0.07010983675718307, 0.028449177742004395, -0.01797850802540779, -0.04566994309425354, 0.016652777791023254, -0.03698958829045296, -0.01562877744436264, 0.02685524709522724, -0.006949110422283411, -0.03870275989174843, 0.05429629236459732, -0.019186345860362053, -0.0746464803814888, -0.002520679496228695, 0.005121357273310423, -0.07853344082832336, -0.04174991697072983, -0.00832272507250309, -0.023162508383393288, -0.047793686389923096, 0.04104876145720482, 0.000014867533536744304, -0.023307103663682938, -0.03785531595349312, 0.06145016476511955, 0.06098898872733116, -0.03719537332653999, 0.014226924628019333, 0.00045357210910879076, -0.06310734152793884, 0.025245796889066696, -0.036838918924331665, 0.0346408449113369, 0.029588928446173668, 0.05894438922405243, 0.007257107645273209, -0.04107073321938515, -0.014039765112102032, 0.06349264830350876, -0.05401710793375969, -0.02848074771463871, 0.04519091174006462, -0.010085416957736015, 0.04617774859070778, 0.010574468411505222, -0.013748402707278728, -0.01153801940381527, 0.02163879945874214, -0.024294480681419373, -0.044904716312885284, 0.004799587652087212, -0.02033483050763607, -0.021943332627415657, -0.04389627277851105, -0.06651406735181808, 0.023182734847068787, -0.03220248967409134, -0.07924137264490128, 0.030591851100325584, -0.04019780457019806, 0.041163891553878784, 0.009197727777063847, 0.0212864950299263, 0.028969449922442436, 0.05316367372870445, -0.04571615159511566, 0.009974981658160686, -0.012188180349767208, -0.016641853377223015, 0.018742412328720093, 0.023343555629253387, 0.016069384291768074, -0.007988394238054752, 0.027937518432736397, -0.015025746077299118, 0.007573546841740608, -0.01576940342783928, -0.03255361318588257, 0.05852259695529938, 0.03202800452709198, -0.027810921892523766, -0.02655000425875187, -0.011483282782137394, -0.025809168815612793, 0.02999000810086727, -0.017123311758041382, -0.03599715232849121, -0.06136343255639076, -0.050408799201250076, 0.032108522951602936, 0.02115514688193798, 0.025235770270228386, 0.02204894833266735, 0.03344601392745972, 0.011092448607087135, 0.04105319082736969, 0.033928774297237396, -0.014436782337725163, 0.010086886584758759, -0.06339140236377716, -0.003309137187898159, -0.004091558046638966, -0.037692297250032425, 0.0067727090790867805, -0.040113694965839386, -0.007159050088375807, -0.05701455473899841, 0.003547252854332328, 0.0417628288269043, 0.01700505055487156, 0.02111399546265602, -0.07124332338571548, 0.02401730790734291, 0.0312051959335804, 0.0110857505351305, -0.03921733796596527, 0.0034294244833290577, 0.03891972079873085, -0.029237335547804832, 0.018097078427672386, -0.005210371688008308, -0.055425167083740234, 0.004083297681063414, -0.07845376431941986, -0.011847691610455513, -0.01728346198797226, 0.04279569163918495, 0.024016378447413445, -0.03066015988588333, 0.0064521790482103825, -0.0482378713786602, 0.04917376488447189, 0.0019753980450332165, 0.01912781409919262, 0.04957249388098717, 0.01033008098602295, 0.023122183978557587, -0.03264873847365379, -0.008319121785461903, 0.043429598212242126, -0.023794205859303474, -0.027276501059532166, 0.03134936839342117, -0.0021580299362540245, 0.030515026301145554, 0.033017806708812714, 0.03272607922554016, -0.05241689831018448, 0.010558254085481167, -0.02564260922372341, 0.005705973133444786, -0.03644489869475365, -0.06533320248126984, 0.034242257475852966, -0.02027939073741436, -0.0137547068297863, 0.0020249823573976755, 0.01607096567749977, -0.010432781651616096, -0.03379558399319649, -0.036539461463689804, 0.022554593160748482, -0.021686963737010956, -0.03112180158495903, 0.06061660870909691, -0.018428903073072433, -0.024804793298244476, -0.04000470042228699, -0.04340973496437073, -0.014453382231295109, 0.016255958005785942, 0.05075211822986603, -0.04542316123843193, -0.011039330624043941, -0.08122417330741882, 0.031561996787786484, -0.03593016043305397, -0.004085076507180929, -0.038755398243665695, 0.06901941448450089, 0.018230106681585312, -0.03135359287261963, 0.02205757051706314, -0.007237664423882961, -0.03803033009171486, -0.07196705043315887, -0.005990068428218365, -0.04201170429587364, 0.002951605012640357, -0.0046682218089699745, 0.022735219448804855, 0.021692849695682526, 0.051846444606781006, 0.034771427512168884, 0.016663329675793648, -0.006800072733312845, 0.029575077816843987, -0.034012485295534134, 0.07557420432567596, 0.02995113842189312, -0.015238061547279358, -0.04393693432211876, 0.027283770963549614, 0.04919103533029556, -0.04568616673350334, 0.013879413716495037, 0.013253878802061081, -0.008086081594228745, -0.05430607870221138, 0.004803113639354706, 0.029828112572431564, 0.01364222913980484, -0.042045481503009796, 0.029152706265449524, -0.003278673393651843, -0.04218009114265442, -0.0638606920838356 ]
The logical analysis of data, LAD, is a technique that yields two-class classifiers based on Boolean functions having disjunctive normal form (DNF) representation. Although LAD algorithms employ optimization techniques, the resulting binary classifiers or binary rules do not lead to overfitting. We propose a theoretical justification for the absence of overfitting by estimating the Vapnik-Chervonenkis dimension (VC dimension) for LAD models where hypothesis sets consist of DNFs with a small number of cubic monomials. We illustrate and confirm our observations empirically.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16630v1
[ -0.039083871990442276, -0.02328745648264885, 0.027847208082675934, 0.038416411727666855, 0.00839308649301529, -0.061851415783166885, -0.0186149999499321, -0.0053620305843651295, -0.011893516406416893, -0.0023107663728296757, -0.06356649845838547, -0.032908618450164795, -0.03007812239229679, -0.031656067818403244, -0.03388076275587082, -0.009521017782390118, 0.04208667203783989, 0.01726575382053852, -0.039625197649002075, 0.06539390236139297, -0.014804687350988388, -0.0030493945814669132, -0.0297849103808403, 0.06418313086032867, 0.031248042359948158, 0.036950577050447464, -0.014421853236854076, -0.034050870686769485, -0.018890822306275368, -0.02142300270497799, 0.0656360387802124, -0.03217855468392372, 0.03320177271962166, -0.06404904276132584, -0.03488495200872421, -0.02171154133975506, 0.00616426719352603, 0.020803134888410568, 0.022336190566420555, -0.03773433342576027, 0.018058381974697113, -0.030604584142565727, -0.06763262301683426, 0.013192245736718178, -0.0454927422106266, -0.004778008442372084, -0.025481194257736206, 0.0006272344617173076, -0.029558103531599045, -0.06769495457410812, 0.04498326778411865, -0.0054788002744317055, 0.013064839877188206, 0.02007024735212326, -0.05641525983810425, 0.06253805011510849, -0.015167387202382088, -0.030098389834165573, -0.06649589538574219, 0.0011688830563798547, 0.03222666308283806, -0.03822606801986694, -0.002935906173661351, -0.020043782889842987, -0.014674998819828033, 0.03103123977780342, -0.019540168344974518, -0.05681043863296509, 0.004767313599586487, -0.054259561002254486, 0.049865782260894775, -0.057253576815128326, 0.029892295598983765, 0.006859879940748215, -0.039071712642908096, -0.02411235310137272, -0.021079253405332565, -0.02104845456779003, 0.03543507680296898, 0.050681132823228836, -0.038479097187519073, -0.009890958666801453, -0.0017063417471945286, -0.015331074595451355, -0.0014730793191120028, -0.04066873714327812, 0.06415887176990509, -0.04439932480454445, 0.023633303120732307, -0.05027211084961891, 0.042847178876399994, -0.05260087549686432, -0.038067787885665894, -0.027992291375994682, 0.018653985112905502, -0.057557620108127594, 0.06683055311441422, 0.05941278859972954, -0.0419914573431015, 0.014523196965456009, -0.009003953076899052, -0.04834947735071182, -0.002924994332715869, -0.007695009931921959, -0.0004534834297373891, 0.007264320272952318, -0.019444843754172325, -0.02637227438390255, -0.04237787425518036, -0.002465885365381837, -0.006428700406104326, 0.018901802599430084, -0.06832592189311981, -0.04081232473254204, -0.023980392143130302, 0.003696058876812458, 0.06504680216312408, 0.01665576919913292, 0.027743373066186905, 0.008480783551931381, -0.020133692771196365, -0.0003763185231946409, -0.02515891194343567, 0.003880365053191781, -0.03797449171543121, -0.01753828302025795, 0.060766931623220444, 0.03414440155029297, -0.00596252828836441, -0.00648697093129158, -0.052490606904029846, -0.0018965770723298192, 0.06126807630062103, -0.01175558753311634, 0.024940883740782738, -0.02163233421742916, -0.03633018210530281, -0.0800045058131218, 0.010917690582573414, 0.023511771112680435, -0.04225549101829529, -0.08331096917390823, 0.05217580869793892, -0.0207312423735857, 0.002256083767861128, 0.06524661928415298, -0.06908123195171356, 0.048480596393346786, 0.00044555289787240326, 0.04833326116204262, -0.01203299593180418, 0.036293867975473404, 0.0068534547463059425, -0.01615051180124283, -0.030680565163493156, -0.016939960420131683, 0.004713192116469145, -0.0070576779544353485, -0.009314761497080326, 0.011948738247156143, 0.024407925084233284, -0.045013055205345154, -0.04259628430008888, 0.002369901165366173, 0.045406877994537354, 0.000553969934117049, 0.012214365415275097, -0.03064041957259178, 0.026988515630364418, -0.017272770404815674, -0.061230115592479706, -0.05790359899401665, -0.01836531050503254, -0.03515278175473213, -0.010288909077644348, -0.0005257297889329493, -0.0224225502461195, -0.0684756338596344, -0.003982934169471264, 0.006859572604298592, -0.0112041300162673, 0.003197399200871587, 0.023311054334044456, 0.030986471101641655, -0.03451298922300339, -0.02784580923616886, -0.05145052820444107, 0.01611385866999626, -0.010166934691369534, 0.04689103364944458, 0.018106618896126747, 0.021577296778559685, 0.018954753875732422, 0.04473351314663887, -0.06911388784646988, -0.035190436989068985, 0.02485099993646145, -0.03834202513098717, 0.0013084819074720144, 0.015408170409500599, -0.081393763422966, -0.04266940802335739, -0.03380417078733444, 0.006942864041775465, -0.06311535090208054, -0.013479560613632202, -0.02620673179626465, 0.04293447732925415, -0.044362444430589676, -0.024792367592453957, 0.05873465538024902, 0.06636391580104828, 0.06791985034942627, -0.020368166267871857, 0.019770268350839615, 0.022991415113210678, -0.0896938145160675, 0.03474399819970131, 0.009175359271466732, -0.01999390684068203, 0.024475982412695885, 0.003111733589321375, -0.024077000096440315, -0.04714841768145561, -0.044265538454055786, 0.04940090328454971, 0.04576301947236061, 0.05146452412009239, -0.05992792919278145, -0.014905889518558979, 0.02186506614089012, -0.03173011168837547, -0.014542418532073498, -0.07314405590295792, -0.06054651364684105, -0.008678851649165154, -0.0008197766728699207, 0.0609070360660553, 0.014813526533544064, -0.06640295684337616, -0.05013116076588631, 0.03214207664132118, 0.03169011324644089, -0.044414982199668884, -0.015382692217826843, -0.029928212985396385, 0.005125570576637983, 0.025463255122303963, -0.0037540143821388483, 0.027519311755895615, -0.014474255032837391, -0.07919924706220627, -0.0137012405321002, -0.031216278672218323, -0.0048401737585663795, 0.03651464357972145, -0.01156688667833805, 0.04029149189591408, -0.0022277701646089554, 0.051668740808963776, 0.05707494542002678, 0.05889728292822838, 0.013932312838733196, -0.01649298332631588, 0.026235707104206085, -0.0067205363884568214, -0.007529538590461016, 0.02010190114378929, -0.02686348184943199, -0.041242003440856934, -0.00857551395893097, 0.013566115871071815, 0.04227453097701073, 0.02580968663096428, -0.020761219784617424, 0.05398248881101608, -0.049766506999731064, -0.025519970804452896, 0.06057027354836464, 0.031749971210956573, 0.00018968373478855938, 0.029160374775528908, 0.0277236495167017, -0.07024696469306946, -0.02533312700688839, -0.026212051510810852, -0.048984020948410034, -0.0746309906244278, -0.0548800453543663, -0.05861516296863556, -0.07921631634235382, -0.04387963190674782, -0.028494685888290405, -0.005508413538336754, -0.0405479297041893, -0.04766538739204407, -0.017960194498300552, -0.04189980775117874, 0.03011309541761875, -0.0382256917655468, -0.05519719421863556, -0.01652013137936592, 0.027883367612957954, 0.029806841164827347, -0.01313587836921215, -0.07156125456094742, -0.06362047791481018, 0.002486548386514187, 0.030557310208678246, 0.0024096218403428793, 0.01851898431777954, 0.022986622527241707, -0.001469078822992742, 0.029978729784488678, 0.01563757099211216, 0.02394188567996025, 0.02318974770605564, -0.023990947753190994, 0.023208854719996452, -0.019170597195625305, -0.00615707878023386, 0.013700134120881557, -0.017887279391288757, -0.030329888686537743, -0.028462139889597893, -0.055738210678100586, 0.058586299419403076, 0.03794098645448685, -0.045197438448667526, 0.019388383254408836, -0.04421425983309746, -0.0005517224781215191, 0.0401211641728878, -0.03938360512256622, 0.06330972909927368, 0.04199899733066559, -0.014885218814015388, -0.043581556528806686, -0.04960456117987633, -0.012232834473252296, -0.024823075160384178, 0.03477351367473602, -0.04622074216604233, -0.0034415055997669697, 0.028003305196762085, -0.07289095222949982, 0.06672700494527817, 0.033278826624155045, 0.03467939794063568, -0.05208232253789902, -0.021255649626255035, 0.02311539649963379, 0.018112899735569954, 0.00697984267026186, -0.009495802223682404, 0.02134684845805168, 0.0062798261642456055, 0.03524896502494812, -0.03936978802084923, -0.030342688784003258, 0.03009003773331642, -0.046412285417318344, -0.05566922947764397, 0.01329697947949171, 0.015853559598326683, -0.004434919450432062, -0.056400083005428314, -0.05038895830512047, 0.05934556946158409, -0.045218490064144135, 0.04926055297255516, 0.020848818123340607, -0.05250467732548714, 0.04847367852926254, -0.03961450606584549, 0.0009853688534349203, 0.03727834299206734, -0.001448998344130814, 0.020157208666205406, -0.03336202725768089, -0.02973800152540207, -0.0718579813838005, 0.03144163265824318, -0.037045545876026154, -0.01846395619213581, 0.022533101961016655, 0.03383766859769821, -0.018772397190332413, 0.044018667191267014, -0.01007173117250204, 0.02082778699696064, 0.035335034132003784, 0.02655821107327938, 0.008577126078307629, 0.016634685918688774, -0.050303347408771515, -0.0034065903164446354, -0.012447992339730263, -0.045286960899829865, -0.04784300550818443, 0.034947872161865234, -0.02219398133456707, -0.041021108627319336, -0.0665874034166336, -0.012106060981750488, -0.0535249337553978, -0.024631084874272346, -0.054272424429655075, -0.07764685153961182, 0.04444103688001633, 0.005895355250686407, -0.006724356673657894, 0.01519158948212862, -0.03179573640227318, -0.030859656631946564, -0.03226893022656441, 0.025208257138729095, -0.0821184441447258, 0.00724451057612896, -0.01853015646338463, 0.051020361483097076, -0.0342758372426033, -0.023567507043480873, -0.05213651433587074, -0.0004452432331163436, -0.017934754490852356, 0.030098823830485344, 0.07381436973810196, 0.05412127077579498, 0.02043462172150612, 0.016576489433646202, 0.023611795157194138, 0.0039557116106152534, -0.02924235723912716, -0.02695169858634472, -0.055404648184776306, -0.03321539983153343, -0.04707672819495201, -0.05748763680458069, -0.04418102279305458, 0.008890997618436813, 0.011042846366763115, -0.018375739455223083, -0.050005264580249786, -0.01720397360622883, 0.039351001381874084, -0.02494453266263008, -0.05497680604457855, -0.001283102435991168, 0.024854790419340134, -0.04500772804021835, -0.013545278459787369, 0.029673060402274132, 0.02795717492699623, -0.021208373829722404, 0.03458194434642792, -0.004743449855595827, 0.020185818895697594, -0.030399763956665993, -0.009598275646567345, 0.05021219328045845, 0.008068138733506203, -0.05009060725569725, 0.013060661032795906, -0.07931408286094666, -0.014717621728777885, -0.0581522174179554, -0.000191006125533022, 0.003016180358827114, 0.03884939104318619, 0.004717190284281969, 0.062897227704525, -0.06740792095661163, 0.022722050547599792, 0.018872801214456558, -0.0013448239769786596, 0.0006370253395289183, 0.0555959977209568, -0.023308631032705307, 0.0005417711799964309, 0.010715832933783531, 0.0035907230339944363, 0.002006284659728408, -0.02112416736781597, 0.013266436755657196, -0.020779380574822426, 0.02395842969417572, -0.053656842559576035, 0.0503167100250721, 0.013967527076601982, -0.005417958367615938, -0.02091224677860737, 0.03472793474793434, -0.008014866150915623, -0.032422665506601334, 0.022688137367367744, 0.03135761246085167, -0.03899092227220535, -0.01442932803183794, -0.008883019909262657, 0.020830616354942322, 0.022113870829343796, 0.018429797142744064, -0.032090019434690475, -0.01598181203007698, -0.0017573325894773006, -0.06006564199924469, 0.00027679087361320853, -0.021146738901734352, -0.01682741940021515, -0.002228441182523966, -0.02787799760699272, -0.01994394324719906, -0.012871821410953999, 0.0008624541223980486, -0.014024939388036728, 0.03284355252981186, 0.033730361610651016, 0.017172491177916527, -0.02137872576713562, 0.017603987827897072, 0.0316748283803463, 0.005787850823253393, 0.03183270990848541, -0.04964607208967209, 0.059947457164525986, -0.008607672527432442, 0.012527679093182087, -0.05385882034897804, 0.04286899045109749, 0.007904292084276676, 0.039870645850896835, 0.004563270602375269, 0.020232725888490677, -0.01782255992293358, 0.01112420205026865, 0.016406917944550514, -0.04097199812531471, -0.055595479905605316, -0.020464802160859108, 0.052108023315668106, -0.022963400930166245, 0.03683619201183319, -0.022916851565241814, 0.02256510592997074, -0.0008928634342737496, 0.02861044928431511, 0.003747115842998028, -0.021076112985610962, 0.008017383515834808, 0.07520429790019989, -0.030597791075706482, -0.041909027844667435, -0.02264721319079399, -0.06538980454206467, -0.001225378131493926, -0.029353752732276917, 0.03628626465797424, -0.004927019588649273, -0.0047365217469632626, 0.001212908187881112, 0.030010860413312912, 0.04393353313207626, -0.07770909368991852, -0.020423712208867073, 0.04836127161979675, -0.055281348526477814, 0.0036083131562918425, -0.02472880855202675, -0.04126786068081856, -0.049262773245573044, 0.03092031553387642, -0.008119121193885803, 0.004039074759930372, -0.04624539613723755, 0.06085672229528427, 0.051708824932575226, -0.037894878536462784, -0.02393718808889389, 0.02622625231742859, -0.026896309107542038, 0.04905557632446289, -0.060620274394750595, -0.04348153620958328, -0.027164652943611145, -0.007213047239929438, 0.01581479050219059, -0.027072323486208916, -0.06423930823802948, 0.008013182319700718, 0.011946403421461582, -0.0028818119317293167, 0.04769771918654442, -0.00611256854608655, -0.01731182262301445, -0.04167076200246811, -0.03716130182147026, 0.016950441524386406, -0.04155806824564934, -0.032467927783727646, -0.013340963050723076, 0.01347290351986885, 0.002876788843423128, -0.05970603972673416, -0.004645107313990593, -0.06755698472261429, -0.016782259568572044, -0.0027707424014806747, -0.03786701336503029, -0.034644607454538345, -0.07107976078987122, -0.02389867976307869, 0.042149338871240616, 0.061369214206933975, -0.024724984541535378, 0.023577980697155, -0.039423324167728424, 0.033323030918836594, 0.031193925067782402, 0.00456174835562706, -0.054897040128707886, -0.009729627519845963, -0.00892702303826809, -0.04724077135324478, 0.02579246647655964, -0.04070685803890228, 0.06460562348365784, -0.001757521415129304, -0.03579944372177124, -0.03966641426086426, 0.027941595762968063, -0.06261052936315536, -0.07464538514614105, 0.04135975241661072, -0.04893992096185684, -0.031726494431495667, -0.0022631462197750807, -0.05959452688694, -0.059515513479709625, 0.02636227197945118, -0.011493375524878502, -0.014418888837099075, -0.017094263806939125, 0.016883015632629395, 0.04404590278863907, -0.003168514696881175, -0.00550299184396863, 0.02036397159099579, 0.052397314459085464, 0.02776002325117588, -0.04913340136408806, -0.05471748113632202, 0.007093586027622223, -0.007127534132450819, -0.029637856408953667, 0.015852877870202065, 0.007038854993879795, -0.07084903866052628, 0.005874696187674999, 0.027019476518034935, -0.016757085919380188, -0.011118295602500439, -0.06267262250185013, 0.018270324915647507, -0.02422662079334259, -0.06322523951530457, -0.06793474406003952, 0.01679106056690216, -0.0005576172261498868, 0.013389202766120434, 0.017221147194504738, -0.04861906170845032, -0.04216248169541359, -0.021811621263623238, -0.08701115846633911, -0.060833778232336044, -0.02587367407977581, 0.050088200718164444, 0.05293721333146095, -0.0393226332962513, 0.014954950660467148, -0.039110857993364334, 0.01969960145652294, 0.010977503843605518, -0.0037565857637673616, 0.010923771187663078, 0.02211492508649826, 0.015967948362231255, -0.06700079888105392, -0.019881505519151688, 0.04071403667330742, -0.01578507386147976, -0.0235011987388134, 0.03213313966989517, 0.006912148557603359, -0.021313510835170746, 0.04189915582537651, 0.06947647780179977, -0.014386017806828022, -0.004638562444597483, -0.030840275809168816, 0.034225255250930786, -0.03681653365492821, -0.042847465723752975, 0.02722623571753502, -0.07754463702440262, 0.01158016175031662, -0.04493848979473114, -0.017092492431402206, -0.05720631405711174, -0.055374760180711746, -0.04199221357703209, -0.034987673163414, -0.003100322326645255, -0.01642017252743244, 0.013478572480380535, -0.02829248271882534, 0.004568173084408045, 0.05403460934758186, 0.0202238280326128, -0.0488455630838871, 0.016026083379983902, 0.040134258568286896, -0.04216345399618149, 0.02479705959558487, -0.07618502527475357, 0.022637465968728065, -0.0487273633480072, -0.013815776444971561, -0.014013553038239479, 0.0581585057079792, -0.0012140212347730994, -0.03138576075434685, 0.0004014262813143432, -0.01088352408260107, -0.017690062522888184, -0.04861122742295265, -0.0026304766070097685, -0.04810308292508125, -0.004928696434944868, -0.0279447790235281, 0.054983895272016525, -0.01365329697728157, 0.07043421268463135, 0.01534216571599245, -0.040601812303066254, 0.025195864960551262, 0.025110939517617226, -0.03219711408019066, 0.017380181699991226, -0.007102566305547953, -0.0010332285892218351, -0.03180587664246559, -0.04223338142037392, 0.014327519573271275, -0.0025783635210245848, 0.018767613917589188, -0.011407116428017616, 0.01656964235007763, -0.07610880583524704, 0.01837945729494095, -0.03897927701473236, 0.008346525952219963, -0.021794268861413002, 0.012001789174973965, -0.023645421490073204, -0.0194508396089077, -0.05322717875242233 ]
Steinerberger proposed a notion of curvature on graphs (J. Graph Theory, 2023). We show that nonnegative curvature is almost preserved under three graph operations. We characterize the distance matrix and its null space after adding an edge between two graphs. Let $D$ be the graph distance matrix and $\mathbf{1}$ be the all-one vector. We provide a way to construct graphs so that the linear system $Dx = \mathbf{1}$ does not have a solution. Let $\eta$ be the Perron eigenvector of $D.$ We provide a lower bound to $\langle\eta,\mathbf{1}\rangle$ when the graph is a tree.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16156v2
[ -0.01856212317943573, -0.05465910583734512, 0.009991077706217766, 0.009011294692754745, -0.014632949605584145, 0.01740795373916626, -0.028112296015024185, 0.006118481513112783, -0.023269305005669594, -0.008953123353421688, -0.0355638824403286, -0.05093052238225937, 0.03164266049861908, 0.019956618547439575, -0.05869659408926964, -0.004337226506322622, 0.04714171215891838, 0.00967995822429657, -0.045682333409786224, 0.05802299454808235, -0.023715807124972343, -0.00324571062810719, 0.009487410075962543, 0.061968740075826645, -0.043548692017793655, -0.00979927834123373, -0.021866273134946823, 0.0056723798625171185, -0.062232065945863724, -0.015895996242761612, 0.07348466664552689, -0.052706215530633926, 0.020994732156395912, -0.00329905585385859, 0.01630210503935814, 0.05480843409895897, -0.0038009926211088896, 0.005829238798469305, 0.02999960258603096, -0.05892782285809517, 0.04560866579413414, -0.0326065868139267, -0.042564284056425095, -0.04344155639410019, -0.032292600721120834, -0.02861318178474903, -0.008997966535389423, -0.01608206145465374, -0.020490961149334908, -0.017191670835018158, 0.03818356245756149, -0.004080210812389851, 0.03813665360212326, 0.040078699588775635, -0.03200361505150795, -0.006759383715689182, -0.001512383809313178, -0.010447395034134388, -0.025167016312479973, -0.021160302683711052, -0.013338454067707062, -0.039797473698854446, -0.0016859497409313917, -0.03952299803495407, -0.05748840421438217, 0.018593519926071167, -0.033978722989559174, -0.07235396653413773, -0.024294639006257057, -0.021707817912101746, 0.004790871869772673, -0.05930763855576515, 0.049348823726177216, 0.011083594523370266, -0.07696744799613953, 0.04722167178988457, 0.0023405137471854687, -0.0048520527780056, -0.04009929671883583, 0.009449037723243237, 0.007812591269612312, -0.032906338572502136, 0.027036791667342186, 0.020344916731119156, 0.0336591936647892, -0.008700554259121418, 0.039544686675071716, 0.0038950543384999037, 0.040057793259620667, -0.044904012233018875, -0.008059142157435417, -0.04838993027806282, -0.06074700132012367, -0.03871121257543564, 0.012566725723445415, -0.047710519284009933, 0.04983264580368996, 0.06069984287023544, 0.0228415597230196, -0.04362465813755989, -0.03298166021704674, -0.06343995034694672, 0.0013321145670488477, -0.02336646430194378, -0.010063881054520607, -0.03414338082075119, -0.011776714585721493, -0.03242285177111626, -0.036632683128118515, 0.057031143456697464, 0.007999095134437084, 0.04071887210011482, 0.012068311683833599, -0.025915183126926422, 0.010759820230305195, -0.06268403679132462, 0.057262763381004333, -0.004092357587069273, 0.07006015628576279, -0.00729270139709115, 0.010098912753164768, 0.01483126636594534, 0.01514572836458683, -0.02624737285077572, -0.022833559662103653, -0.02345522865653038, 0.042116928845644, 0.0001492700248491019, 0.03737384080886841, 0.04904790595173836, 0.004869410302489996, 0.005348570644855499, 0.00823340006172657, -0.05357176810503006, 0.021208150312304497, -0.0030252656433731318, -0.011416052468121052, -0.052213799208402634, -0.018808066844940186, 0.0518840067088604, -0.015098463743925095, -0.03513709455728531, 0.012872440740466118, 0.04977620393037796, -0.023577503859996796, 0.03076632134616375, -0.0686507597565651, 0.024092387408018112, 0.01889198087155819, 0.045042745769023895, 0.026969267055392265, -0.04563324153423309, 0.009770529344677925, 0.009209114126861095, -0.007961319759488106, -0.01732848398387432, 0.03170720860362053, 0.0011147722834721208, -0.04712998494505882, 0.023343568667769432, 0.02010449208319187, -0.04489462822675705, -0.01997785083949566, -0.008141021244227886, -0.005575099959969521, 0.01383837778121233, 0.0016953442245721817, -0.047605663537979126, 0.02661670185625553, 0.008194414898753166, -0.047406189143657684, -0.022036908194422722, -0.016667675226926804, -0.05114692822098732, -0.055721309036016464, -0.0006457607378251851, -0.04205384850502014, -0.0716303288936615, -0.01938907988369465, 0.018276939168572426, -0.018506867811083794, -0.023365402594208717, 0.010542021133005619, -0.03424690291285515, -0.05743182823061943, 0.016671134158968925, -0.07612909376621246, 0.006456916686147451, 0.04116157814860344, 0.030812891200184822, -0.02880071848630905, -0.05321456491947174, 0.038518164306879044, 0.0020183816086500883, -0.027307000011205673, -0.04339976981282234, 0.0031726437155157328, -0.04951760172843933, -0.06367897242307663, 0.015655454248189926, -0.05623563751578331, -0.04403034970164299, -0.039907537400722504, 0.003922006115317345, -0.0019455970032140613, -0.06525120139122009, -0.010019179433584213, 0.010828029364347458, 0.02313058450818062, -0.035429947078228, 0.06547918170690536, -0.023516705259680748, 0.04917996749281883, -0.026890994980931282, -0.019839448854327202, -0.00151353410910815, -0.0871635228395462, 0.04930400848388672, -0.003463847329840064, 0.012764018028974533, -0.03416132554411888, -0.012184245511889458, 0.018928255885839462, -0.07228676974773407, -0.02291295863687992, 0.05277176946401596, 0.04089684784412384, 0.03701983764767647, -0.03992617502808571, -0.005414165556430817, 0.016353921964764595, -0.07300650328397751, -0.0461566299200058, -0.0033279929775744677, -0.03397872671484947, 0.01430937834084034, -0.04992881789803505, 0.036472074687480927, -0.01867288537323475, -0.018235385417938232, -0.042903900146484375, 0.00652169156819582, 0.057840488851070404, 0.03050852194428444, -0.035042159259319305, -0.009536349214613438, -0.05369255691766739, -0.01722221076488495, -0.05247953161597252, 0.003658221336081624, 0.005269824527204037, -0.03643600642681122, -0.02435789629817009, -0.03713519126176834, 0.03836970031261444, 0.014223010279238224, -0.03013395331799984, 0.0034346571192145348, -0.0099264495074749, 0.04628054052591324, 0.01978447288274765, 0.01303160097450018, 0.023174747824668884, -0.05206388235092163, -0.025251826271414757, -0.005240951664745808, -0.05199767276644707, -0.02481638640165329, 0.04932272434234619, -0.045198552310466766, 0.019253505393862724, -0.008586476556956768, 0.025569576770067215, 0.012992334552109241, -0.04273587092757225, 0.0007616289658471942, -0.06982241570949554, -0.057202793657779694, 0.036070045083761215, 0.012026645243167877, 0.0365312434732914, 0.03224784508347511, -0.05738307163119316, -0.07477208971977234, -0.0417884923517704, 0.02772359549999237, -0.006952345371246338, -0.05695772171020508, -0.06802144646644592, -0.025955472141504288, -0.07048651576042175, 0.010503675788640976, -0.07376258075237274, -0.03103010170161724, -0.04823170229792595, -0.06634790450334549, -0.05701060965657234, -0.01954967901110649, -0.015194347128272057, -0.06929709017276764, -0.03142377361655235, 0.007205009926110506, 0.03047669678926468, 0.04726548120379448, -0.005202608648687601, -0.06559598445892334, -0.04737551510334015, 0.015405521728098392, -0.012714807875454426, 0.006546077784150839, -0.02888469770550728, 0.03161425143480301, -0.05152709782123566, -0.021071525290608406, 0.033886510878801346, -0.004066293127834797, 0.006223287899047136, -0.0522247776389122, 0.04538743197917938, -0.00788878370076418, -0.008301103487610817, 0.020020203664898872, 0.03487701714038849, -0.02796483412384987, -0.06476017832756042, -0.029976869001984596, 0.001988339703530073, -0.0053548626601696014, -0.05610961839556694, -0.023113738745450974, -0.012413594871759415, 0.024263447150588036, -0.002878335537388921, -0.05136469006538391, -0.005016467534005642, 0.013253068551421165, 0.01943596452474594, -0.00943139847368002, -0.03286582604050636, 0.01454832497984171, -0.00785090308636427, 0.013813932426273823, -0.012398168444633484, 0.002693632384762168, -0.0004092906601727009, -0.08192799985408783, 0.05289185792207718, 0.053736086934804916, 0.04159661382436752, -0.029031112790107727, -0.009575136005878448, 0.049359604716300964, -0.03118264116346836, 0.003050731960684061, -0.051043782383203506, -0.019602106884121895, 0.004739471711218357, 0.06680547446012497, -0.04512355476617813, -0.035757262259721756, -0.002554762875661254, -0.07245226204395294, 0.03200768306851387, 0.06586728990077972, 0.026092369109392166, 0.035717349499464035, 0.029568498954176903, -0.05990263447165489, 0.01232249103486538, -0.022106152027845383, 0.05133504793047905, 0.001802298822440207, -0.013057359494268894, 0.02470162883400917, -0.021072350442409515, -0.01203474123030901, 0.0005866948631592095, 0.01647978462278843, 0.02754794992506504, -0.041960351169109344, 0.013970892876386642, -0.04752454534173012, 0.029639683663845062, 0.015693623572587967, -0.014973810873925686, -0.02122143656015396, -0.037955883890390396, -0.0352400578558445, 0.03753185644745827, -0.05578870698809624, 0.011897476390004158, 0.028381504118442535, -0.0019353671232238412, 0.030508488416671753, -0.010347089730203152, -0.04491911828517914, 0.011652530170977116, 0.003646432887762785, -0.05745886266231537, -0.06791647523641586, 0.0532197505235672, 0.009562840685248375, -0.01448087953031063, -0.04224805906414986, -0.029429543763399124, -0.025388754904270172, -0.026937371119856834, -0.022154079750180244, -0.058018751442432404, 0.0619048997759819, -0.014308520592749119, -0.03825059160590172, -0.03895740956068039, -0.024403562769293785, -0.03300906717777252, 0.000289056304609403, -0.04638245329260826, -0.0591910183429718, -0.004155255854129791, -0.04561098664999008, 0.03767376393079758, -0.006738707423210144, 0.017054539173841476, -0.036723438650369644, 0.00990927405655384, -0.02848433144390583, 0.025600608438253403, 0.03957930952310562, 0.051475975662469864, 0.036534957587718964, 0.013659151270985603, -0.0473872534930706, -0.019878484308719635, -0.06718841195106506, -0.04217297583818436, -0.0201566182076931, 0.010661629028618336, -0.03795585408806801, -0.04699139669537544, -0.013545980677008629, -0.01542120985686779, 0.04987039789557457, -0.04962463304400444, -0.018964579328894615, 0.012687016278505325, 0.017946964129805565, -0.0682431012392044, -0.05526310205459595, -0.02643025666475296, -0.027704983949661255, -0.062308505177497864, 0.038314808160066605, -0.018227441236376762, 0.00019019618048332632, 0.0000529896242369432, 0.023521026596426964, -0.034242305904626846, 0.02215578407049179, -0.051276206970214844, 0.02659361995756626, 0.032749127596616745, 0.01878323405981064, -0.010045097209513187, -0.03461761400103569, -0.06663911044597626, 0.005548081826418638, -0.07086911797523499, 0.015188302844762802, 0.041228558868169785, 0.009175614453852177, -0.011691641993820667, 0.06111004948616028, -0.06325171887874603, 0.0403282456099987, 0.036108627915382385, -0.014699564315378666, -0.026851259171962738, 0.04750542715191841, -0.03389716148376465, -0.006340983789414167, -0.006704685743898153, 0.017567943781614304, -0.01069547701627016, -0.0011678654700517654, -0.0035076735075563192, -0.022870581597089767, 0.001184365595690906, -0.026045970618724823, 0.06780138611793518, 0.015288139693439007, 0.0024230116978287697, -0.007569615263491869, -0.0068941740319132805, 0.018694423139095306, -0.044452689588069916, 0.051317114382982254, 0.03245045244693756, -0.055450793355703354, -0.03456580266356468, -0.005096683278679848, -0.02700573392212391, 0.028273604810237885, 0.04700146242976189, -0.0014796345494687557, 0.0015459407586604357, 0.03246011957526207, -0.04855302348732948, 0.008997662924230099, 0.04641449451446533, -0.010180087760090828, -0.009130426682531834, -0.014561381191015244, -0.0022125006653368473, -0.03634447604417801, 0.005427825730293989, -0.005142866633832455, 0.0079854317009449, 0.03498676046729088, -0.011901185847818851, -0.02991701103746891, 0.038337573409080505, -0.028309592977166176, -0.00428416021168232, -0.01847917027771473, -0.032618552446365356, 0.07349301129579544, -0.042628951370716095, 0.00923566147685051, 0.01602567732334137, 0.029331175610423088, -0.036676932126283646, -0.021810315549373627, -0.02099275030195713, -0.04373246431350708, -0.02163536287844181, -0.000744612596463412, 0.042002543807029724, 0.017100460827350616, -0.03397301211953163, -0.05418182164430618, 0.028208650648593903, -0.025642435997724533, 0.03790963068604469, 0.033084120601415634, 0.05774308741092682, 0.00880458578467369, 0.03551965579390526, 0.07706111669540405, -0.05081577226519585, -0.04562653601169586, 0.052161041647195816, -0.03114810585975647, -0.028355982154607773, -0.024704674258828163, -0.048060327768325806, -0.03896511346101761, -0.06434131413698196, 0.034580834209918976, -0.008382385596632957, -0.030405784025788307, -0.05114853009581566, 0.03339557722210884, 0.005181938409805298, -0.05644753947854042, -0.008161133155226707, 0.013641956262290478, -0.05592110753059387, 0.03148549050092697, -0.03845133259892464, -0.002322391839697957, 0.006107944529503584, 0.028974179178476334, -0.07920201867818832, -0.07904410362243652, -0.06791897863149643, 0.057603154331445694, 0.06369706988334656, -0.06569239497184753, 0.06309087574481964, 0.059938013553619385, -0.03516106680035591, 0.04357736557722092, -0.04906132444739342, -0.026263413950800896, -0.05772692337632179, -0.01360105536878109, 0.010758377611637115, -0.027093438431620598, -0.03890782967209816, 0.0020083237905055285, -0.04285110905766487, -0.06494951248168945, 0.03098888322710991, 0.01916387304663658, 0.008709624409675598, 0.005278125870972872, -0.04762279987335205, 0.013966324739158154, 0.035434555262327194, -0.020471537485718727, -0.03630809858441353, 0.04821651801466942, -0.011661013588309288, -0.016747597604990005, -0.015753723680973053, -0.056846149265766144, 0.006474949419498444, -0.015571318566799164, -0.02863261103630066, -0.037239495664834976, -0.07350931316614151, 0.00920732133090496, -0.04859915003180504, 0.05296003445982933, 0.03990092873573303, 0.009245346300303936, 0.0072004590183496475, 0.024429339915513992, -0.03888324275612831, 0.013569705188274384, 0.0013044832739979029, 0.004441762343049049, 0.02463163249194622, -0.03513704612851143, 0.07092182338237762, -0.05516408383846283, 0.03147318586707115, -0.05341702327132225, -0.03174949437379837, -0.00021891800861340016, -0.015086431056261063, -0.02376759611070156, 0.013821011409163475, -0.00537265557795763, -0.06413772702217102, -0.005499056074768305, 0.008936148136854172, -0.018255578354001045, -0.0758945494890213, -0.0028485844377428293, -0.02711782418191433, 0.003982470370829105, 0.009336249902844429, -0.018122922629117966, 0.013063113205134869, -0.008814394474029541, 0.022814195603132248, 0.02767820470035076, 0.00949045829474926, -0.00041969079757109284, -0.036322761327028275, 0.011673800647258759, -0.026620538905262947, -0.03913281857967377, -0.01721334457397461, -0.007931054569780827, -0.044113293290138245, -0.07186514139175415, 0.023137517273426056, 0.03151785582304001, 0.005997380707412958, -0.053678374737501144, -0.060209471732378006, 0.0062885284423828125, 0.014712505973875523, 0.04846351966261864, -0.07148861885070801, -0.01567767560482025, 0.0003705289273057133, -0.018556982278823853, -0.03958570957183838, 0.016877315938472748, -0.061767954379320145, 0.01069729309529066, -0.07797528058290482, -0.026207666844129562, 0.040531400591135025, 0.06679447740316391, -0.005150086712092161, 0.017671046778559685, -0.06904236227273941, -0.05379543453454971, -0.010691002942621708, -0.013604136183857918, 0.004979260265827179, 0.026161914691329002, 0.05980899930000305, -0.04749613627791405, 0.009668373502790928, -0.0030586395878344774, 0.028614703565835953, 0.035779837518930435, 0.006263003684580326, 0.04065678268671036, 0.02156032994389534, -0.01463078148663044, 0.012359601445496082, 0.045575469732284546, 0.014224580489099026, 0.0562438890337944, -0.027025651186704636, -0.03812048211693764, -0.04357687756419182, -0.05979740992188454, 0.0038290987722575665, -0.04031863808631897, -0.046114999800920486, -0.03960542380809784, -0.04133230075240135, -0.05727526172995567, -0.026482364162802696, -0.06192407384514809, 0.028446517884731293, 0.045338526368141174, -0.027913589030504227, -0.050429049879312515, -0.06509140878915787, -0.023220190778374672, 0.01291349995881319, 0.010872812010347843, -0.045186202973127365, -0.03872286528348923, 0.016232604160904884, 0.01828470639884472, 0.01715390756726265, -0.05380750074982643, 0.035658180713653564, -0.038004301488399506, -0.03253208100795746, 0.07158137112855911, 0.011819247156381607, -0.01663190685212612, 0.05091092735528946, -0.04135233908891678, -0.03210444003343582, 0.024668296799063683, -0.0525696724653244, 0.01827227510511875, -0.041225552558898926, 0.033529072999954224, 0.036680277436971664, 0.03282325714826584, -0.04478883743286133, 0.04036561772227287, 0.03397249057888985, -0.03155291825532913, 0.030410783365368843, 0.009305309504270554, -0.010089149698615074, 0.027876224368810654, 0.01621237024664879, -0.0584619864821434, -0.044869836419820786, 0.02274143323302269, -0.051334887742996216, -0.029560668393969536, 0.01859784685075283, -0.006186997052282095, 0.03959021717309952, -0.033955737948417664, 0.015587668865919113, 0.02064024843275547, 0.027615468949079514, -0.05864359065890312, 0.04992218688130379, -0.013479506596922874, -0.020403653383255005, -0.028317760676145554 ]
In this research, we aim to compare the performance of different classical machine learning models and neural networks in identifying the frequency of occurrence of each digit in a given number. It has various applications in machine learning and computer vision, e.g. for obtaining the frequency of a target object in a visual scene. We considered this problem as a hybrid of classification and regression tasks. We carefully create our own datasets to observe systematic differences between different methods. We evaluate each of the methods using different metrics across multiple datasets.The metrics of performance used were the root mean squared error and mean absolute error for regression evaluation, and accuracy for classification performance evaluation. We observe that decision trees and random forests overfit to the dataset, due to their inherent bias, and are not able to generalize well. We also observe that the neural networks significantly outperform the classical machine learning models in terms of both the regression and classification metrics for both the 6-digit and 10-digit number datasets. Dataset and code are available on github.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.04431v1
[ -0.023925404995679855, -0.04595234990119934, 0.0196470245718956, -0.03803588077425957, 0.0007572948816232383, -0.007678576745092869, -0.02606550231575966, 0.0033239314798265696, 0.000346897984854877, -0.02926497720181942, -0.05209363251924515, 0.0025029946118593216, -0.06707905232906342, -0.05306941643357277, -0.056038979440927505, 0.001089880126528442, 0.08038389682769775, 0.03223729506134987, -0.05869421362876892, 0.08065911382436752, 0.03145338594913483, -0.02708911895751953, -0.0302871186286211, 0.02905391901731491, -0.0035552741028368473, -0.015784751623868942, -0.014757756143808365, 0.028986621648073196, -0.0014277069130912423, 0.02356572076678276, 0.057327140122652054, -0.021976785734295845, -0.013522285036742687, -0.06500653922557831, 0.0048726447857916355, -0.002405277220532298, 0.014223985373973846, 0.030202006921172142, 0.055887915194034576, -0.057457685470581055, 0.01586776040494442, -0.06287511438131332, -0.07736320793628693, -0.0060514844954013824, -0.014610246755182743, 0.01582612656056881, -0.02958531305193901, -0.006478457245975733, -0.052709855139255524, -0.03820555657148361, -0.007564090192317963, -0.03664275258779526, 0.025948259979486465, 0.03999029099941254, -0.0324559360742569, -0.01010847557336092, -0.04669604450464249, 0.026246780529618263, -0.039779793471097946, 0.0011231191456317902, 0.02828364633023739, -0.02974206767976284, -0.010819847695529461, -0.0015124153578653932, 0.04955101013183594, 0.045451756566762924, -0.029188204556703568, -0.07870031893253326, -0.06039959564805031, 0.0003508270310703665, 0.05456889793276787, -0.06598734110593796, 0.04366549104452133, -0.005949325859546661, -0.05239903926849365, -0.008019333705306053, -0.004501767456531525, -0.029055273160338402, 0.02684260718524456, 0.012151078321039677, -0.03126330301165581, 0.026287715882062912, -0.027103088796138763, 0.0408267080783844, -0.024638762697577477, -0.050931282341480255, 0.05576563626527786, -0.0022499386686831713, -0.005220259074121714, -0.043313026428222656, -0.003624052507802844, -0.04192480817437172, -0.07802341878414154, -0.015666089951992035, 0.0651460513472557, -0.028978442773222923, 0.042255062609910965, 0.04830305278301239, 0.04321833699941635, -0.016621796414256096, 0.00023537898960057646, -0.05972710996866226, 0.01810768060386181, 0.05518122389912605, 0.030380943790078163, -0.03146937116980553, -0.022988807410001755, -0.0038307583890855312, -0.06985286623239517, 0.021652545779943466, -0.011083004996180534, -0.009450478479266167, -0.013495012186467648, -0.0725238174200058, -0.07243509590625763, -0.050924915820360184, 0.0233567263931036, 0.02949756383895874, 0.009769581258296967, -0.016479220241308212, -0.022634146735072136, 0.02470887266099453, -0.0008935719379223883, -0.02532755769789219, -0.04293470457196236, -0.03743377700448036, 0.036091215908527374, 0.00519812386482954, -0.012642612680792809, -0.03209865093231201, -0.05816206708550453, -0.002722752746194601, -0.01798059418797493, 0.00004746279228129424, 0.06457739323377609, -0.026369290426373482, -0.004882696084678173, -0.04930095002055168, 0.027901118621230125, 0.03425955772399902, -0.052722152322530746, -0.06572716683149338, 0.015288697555661201, -0.0106591135263443, 0.036222103983163834, 0.05912594497203827, -0.055530935525894165, -0.011300915852189064, 0.053143251687288284, 0.046002842485904694, 0.030406923964619637, -0.0015601067570969462, 0.02293855883181095, 0.021577373147010803, 0.02947000041604042, 0.0010939103085547686, 0.03539727255702019, -0.04161348193883896, -0.038827892392873764, -0.011117319576442242, 0.025179291144013405, -0.012999951839447021, 0.019294651225209236, -0.03313154727220535, -0.003082014387473464, -0.0014173160307109356, 0.053253479301929474, 0.007894087582826614, -0.013843808323144913, 0.021546900272369385, 0.006912895478308201, -0.008465517312288284, 0.04866866394877434, -0.02903134748339653, -0.06560388207435608, 0.0008455907227471471, -0.0038029144052416086, -0.06897227466106415, -0.06190994381904602, 0.010871629230678082, 0.02107190154492855, 0.025482505559921265, -0.04867428168654442, 0.02311878837645054, -0.02256808988749981, 0.006214341148734093, -0.07863851636648178, 0.033998314291238785, 0.027243228629231453, 0.020378373563289642, 0.012870557606220245, -0.05079931393265724, 0.012510146014392376, -0.005486665293574333, -0.008932843804359436, -0.03873561695218086, 0.024305526167154312, -0.0007770121446810663, 0.018857192248106003, 0.04182424023747444, -0.08487574756145477, -0.022514227777719498, -0.0413452610373497, -0.018102599307894707, -0.03873221203684807, -0.06786243617534637, 0.026951473206281662, 0.04234415665268898, -0.018885446712374687, -0.004243749193847179, 0.0749090388417244, 0.037521831691265106, 0.05765960365533829, 0.0074907876551151276, -0.013822799548506737, 0.03651736304163933, -0.090597003698349, 0.048026882112026215, -0.02640574797987938, 0.04651963338255882, 0.01126290112733841, 0.004412176553159952, -0.04595033824443817, -0.036108408123254776, -0.0022236849181354046, 0.02881637029349804, 0.05202372372150421, 0.008158784359693527, -0.04473787918686867, -0.04412250593304634, -0.05627609044313431, -0.06102190911769867, -0.023404834792017937, -0.07164419442415237, 0.003648660611361265, -0.017784086987376213, -0.020884955301880836, 0.05104690045118332, -0.04794379323720932, -0.04047207906842232, -0.0350831113755703, -0.021612174808979034, 0.02400730364024639, -0.03513593599200249, -0.04198219254612923, -0.031846143305301666, -0.027188699692487717, 0.05981728807091713, -0.014999637380242348, -0.006406353786587715, -0.05467568337917328, -0.04563082754611969, -0.03096599690616131, -0.035213373601436615, 0.025561489164829254, 0.022005949169397354, -0.014452393166720867, 0.04361865669488907, -0.004708038177341223, 0.06539390981197357, 0.037086475640535355, 0.03127366676926613, -0.0750603899359703, 0.039232589304447174, 0.03945090249180794, 0.0044610886834561825, -0.030637621879577637, -0.01765592023730278, 0.05158286541700363, -0.0544305257499218, -0.010757476091384888, 0.003832237096503377, 0.05466485396027565, -0.01696751080453396, -0.0196919534355402, -0.009414302185177803, -0.004583260510116816, -0.04787049442529678, 0.0382881797850132, 0.044062431901693344, 0.023075848817825317, 0.03845373913645744, -0.006456019356846809, -0.07151012122631073, -0.008885527960956097, -0.051290515810251236, -0.004390461836010218, -0.04341168329119682, -0.041232865303754807, -0.043633777648210526, -0.08603888750076294, -0.038625992834568024, -0.04147785156965256, -0.04128475859761238, -0.03607717528939247, -0.07720596343278885, -0.02470836043357849, 0.0055804792791605, -0.003841857425868511, -0.00033257840550504625, -0.033871788531541824, -0.04108353331685066, 0.017445072531700134, -0.0064554898999631405, -0.0036882173735648394, -0.06380544602870941, -0.02476556785404682, -0.01163195725530386, 0.03357245773077011, 0.01136772707104683, -0.0030210448894649744, -0.00030046794563531876, -0.05872927978634834, 0.03779866173863411, -0.014722389169037342, -0.008123465813696384, -0.03304705768823624, 0.015943264588713646, 0.006626805290579796, -0.0040358672849833965, 0.020754577592015266, -0.014169256202876568, -0.00015703789540566504, -0.050953544676303864, -0.04810752347111702, -0.03755701333284378, 0.03892376646399498, 0.008194878697395325, -0.062100961804389954, -0.033461008220911026, 0.011854490265250206, 0.0001818612654460594, 0.012464887462556362, -0.006442362908273935, -0.0011339508928358555, 0.024113602936267853, -0.01707853563129902, -0.03232660889625549, -0.03422816842794418, 0.04186698794364929, 0.019143391400575638, 0.027052804827690125, -0.038406893610954285, 0.027541840448975563, 0.05298292264342308, -0.08313217759132385, 0.021191425621509552, 0.049568407237529755, 0.048981551080942154, -0.04201420396566391, 0.007292053196579218, 0.010915305465459824, 0.011479330249130726, 0.008294247090816498, 0.018219396471977234, 0.03400823101401329, 0.04392741620540619, 0.06991680711507797, -0.04248155653476715, -0.04706637188792229, -0.01775791309773922, -0.061702728271484375, -0.026592932641506195, 0.007052066270262003, 0.011671573854982853, 0.018452879041433334, 0.010712926276028156, -0.049947477877140045, -0.033969517797231674, 0.013557630591094494, 0.018611250445246696, -0.017126619815826416, -0.006489405408501625, 0.03556809946894646, -0.053712062537670135, 0.05996784195303917, -0.02238074131309986, -0.0078054023906588554, -0.005810415372252464, -0.05172106251120567, 0.018753821030259132, -0.0629952996969223, 0.03632621839642525, 0.010630445554852486, -0.029426416382193565, 0.03170403838157654, 0.0408405140042305, -0.045288242399692535, 0.05009236931800842, -0.013819016516208649, -0.011904945597052574, -0.005345124751329422, 0.01176562998443842, -0.04139735922217369, -0.00761522026732564, -0.04914276301860809, -0.01868360862135887, 0.016568437218666077, -0.012289098463952541, -0.016148574650287628, -0.003714662743732333, -0.017285790294408798, -0.01920737512409687, -0.08522340655326843, -0.0018138475716114044, -0.02698693238198757, 0.02027796395123005, 0.0028558566700667143, -0.04577234387397766, 0.04614836350083351, -0.028793135657906532, -0.025618620216846466, -0.047353651374578476, 0.011299852281808853, -0.02667977847158909, -0.022271376103162766, -0.03505760431289673, -0.06455622613430023, 0.033130042254924774, -0.03969196602702141, 0.05378863215446472, 0.015676598995923996, 0.0350254662334919, -0.018123794347047806, -0.04614479839801788, -0.011977886781096458, 0.018639057874679565, 0.060352783650159836, 0.024425823241472244, -0.007869221270084381, -0.011618298478424549, 0.005735907703638077, -0.02904840186238289, -0.004535841289907694, 0.026449503377079964, -0.0009168699034489691, 0.06399330496788025, 0.005847926717251539, -0.005645244847983122, -0.04032847285270691, -0.026854872703552246, 0.031171342357993126, -0.03473366051912308, -0.048022180795669556, -0.023825356736779213, 0.04098820686340332, -0.05554484575986862, -0.06942439079284668, -0.061440762132406235, -0.047600921243429184, -0.04943050816655159, -0.02384730987250805, 0.026394277811050415, 0.03168083354830742, -0.03158476948738098, 0.01776602678000927, 0.0019052454736083746, 0.03416617214679718, -0.004253496415913105, 0.05121181160211563, 0.013670835644006729, 0.0410061776638031, -0.003802667371928692, -0.040655240416526794, -0.07275402545928955, 0.0009496696875430644, -0.03818192705512047, 0.009838005527853966, 0.005190713796764612, 0.0319577194750309, 0.047646913677453995, 0.06103293225169182, -0.08346801996231079, 0.01917865313589573, 0.03305140882730484, 0.005481884814798832, 0.02384227141737938, 0.05404311418533325, -0.02556481584906578, 0.0193569827824831, -0.034344762563705444, -0.04083416983485222, 0.039121225476264954, -0.02385525405406952, -0.010606937110424042, -0.0026987867895513773, -0.03559654578566551, -0.002077787881717086, 0.06107589602470398, -0.017911897972226143, -0.06100774556398392, -0.024252813309431076, 0.03355716913938522, 0.0471937470138073, -0.019185293465852737, 0.04106124863028526, 0.03582778573036194, -0.03903540223836899, -0.05910370871424675, -0.03851516172289848, -0.015140078030526638, -0.01457895152270794, -0.004423885140568018, -0.029834629967808723, 0.03021589107811451, 0.0297293271869421, 0.005824385676532984, -0.04149879887700081, 0.021707875654101372, 0.04398489370942116, 0.00026109491591341794, -0.04619709774851799, 0.01994003914296627, -0.06435544788837433, -0.013152624480426311, -0.0172561127692461, 0.045541852712631226, 0.05659148469567299, 0.031738001853227615, 0.013125283643603325, -0.00567963533103466, -0.03302289545536041, -0.0408749021589756, -0.0094950245693326, 0.009988510981202126, 0.02631598524749279, -0.03630475327372551, 0.041313014924526215, 0.02166179195046425, 0.04732672497630119, -0.013207557611167431, -0.014579988084733486, 0.013436620123684406, -0.01516762562096119, -0.010048630647361279, 0.001406178344041109, 0.034264277666807175, -0.02098020724952221, -0.01894807256758213, 0.04374252259731293, -0.01235666312277317, 0.005698929075151682, 0.05136130377650261, 0.05242711678147316, -0.004386053886264563, 0.03139442950487137, 0.005164334084838629, -0.016815192997455597, -0.025222307071089745, 0.05442064255475998, 0.05649702250957489, -0.04637831822037697, 0.007880399003624916, -0.03955930098891258, -0.041616570204496384, 0.021722961217164993, -0.03299001604318619, 0.0021893298253417015, 0.023846397176384926, 0.007086196914315224, -0.05596807599067688, 0.05120784416794777, -0.027281073853373528, -0.07396835088729858, 0.0007953884196467698, 0.007310645654797554, -0.07508060336112976, -0.008619129657745361, 0.0017111680936068296, 0.007305679842829704, -0.039277710020542145, 0.027441713958978653, -0.0017220739973708987, -0.018734339624643326, -0.053592171519994736, 0.06634996831417084, 0.08477126061916351, -0.024691510945558548, 0.005847294349223375, 0.017040228471159935, -0.06117357313632965, -0.003325709607452154, -0.008522482588887215, 0.0043392060324549675, -0.012055767700076103, 0.021777627989649773, -0.020313074812293053, -0.05465291813015938, -0.029270701110363007, 0.0788654014468193, -0.048488810658454895, -0.003449778538197279, 0.01502372045069933, 0.01112310029566288, 0.044812172651290894, -0.015257636085152626, -0.04440005123615265, 0.003257173579186201, -0.008379588834941387, -0.023038474842905998, -0.05633892863988876, -0.0017464823322370648, -0.004253036342561245, 0.03292343020439148, -0.03787587583065033, -0.0658341646194458, -0.007974963635206223, 0.02530878596007824, -0.06418085843324661, 0.020590990781784058, -0.07127999514341354, 0.026694852858781815, -0.019832013174891472, 0.012089279480278492, -0.0072248405776917934, 0.04365819692611694, -0.04614334553480148, -0.0022257633972913027, 0.022348884493112564, 0.03335793688893318, 0.018852591514587402, -0.002082376042380929, 0.02382741868495941, -0.017231281846761703, 0.04428491368889809, -0.01632622443139553, -0.014920131303369999, -0.03725434094667435, -0.036266718059778214, 0.0466495044529438, -0.004784077871590853, 0.007607758976519108, -0.03129707649350166, 0.01250266283750534, -0.01864016056060791, 0.010737123899161816, 0.03249654546380043, -0.0501091331243515, -0.04214239493012428, 0.025440245866775513, 0.027940217405557632, -0.031054558232426643, -0.013585111126303673, 0.005045060999691486, 0.0449465848505497, 0.014039658010005951, 0.04427503049373627, 0.03543154150247574, -0.026228727772831917, -0.02623259276151657, -0.07915656268596649, -0.042380329221487045, 0.006395813077688217, -0.028930284082889557, -0.028530392795801163, -0.056951798498630524, -0.0015380745753645897, -0.07428959757089615, 0.023224517703056335, 0.04332469403743744, -0.016400093212723732, -0.0008708468521945179, -0.06846586614847183, 0.02055775374174118, 0.02815220318734646, -0.03069864958524704, -0.04469591751694679, -0.013158624991774559, -0.010094499215483665, -0.03870067372918129, 0.009510048665106297, 0.005914419423788786, -0.02977079153060913, 0.05719494819641113, -0.08662401139736176, -0.018636098131537437, 0.023885689675807953, 0.04819073528051376, 0.025448374450206757, -0.029231127351522446, -0.014115331694483757, -0.05345536768436432, -0.011986318975687027, -0.009501555934548378, -0.0074220746755599976, 0.02871989831328392, 0.04379284009337425, 0.027729809284210205, -0.03783262148499489, -0.0517839677631855, 0.0526474304497242, -0.026277223601937294, -0.020697683095932007, -0.0016515902243554592, 0.03628699481487274, 0.021561291068792343, 0.003117405576631427, 0.027902528643608093, -0.03343425691127777, 0.05655727535486221, -0.05223001539707184, 0.0020044809207320213, -0.05767010152339935, -0.05365697667002678, 0.05385194718837738, -0.026528075337409973, -0.043156784027814865, 0.013476724736392498, -0.036928046494722366, 0.0032305223867297173, -0.04151342809200287, -0.03269321843981743, 0.04838911443948746, 0.0013057499891147017, -0.0048908572643995285, 0.04338058829307556, -0.0296523068100214, 0.009442747570574284, -0.04816237464547157, -0.03200007975101471, -0.048479728400707245, 0.01983705163002014, 0.007445935625582933, -0.06141197308897972, 0.0024599230382591486, -0.038746077567338943, 0.0051833996549248695, 0.041258662939071655, -0.020285269245505333, 0.002919810824096203, 0.0696374773979187, -0.0023086669389158487, 0.002967655658721924, -0.0028425806667655706, -0.04047692194581032, 0.005508715286850929, -0.07132478803396225, -0.04352518543601036, -0.05778205767273903, 0.028451111167669296, 0.021065181121230125, 0.030300699174404144, 0.021168489009141922, 0.07189105451107025, 0.016893062740564346, 0.031995709985494614, 0.03280428424477577, 0.023999618366360664, -0.010876715183258057, 0.06758075207471848, 0.016958296298980713, 0.03313999995589256, -0.01045723631978035, 0.05717412382364273, 0.01336198765784502, -0.03466976806521416, 0.02074933983385563, -0.02046279050409794, -0.014721445739269257, -0.06594560295343399, 0.014644579030573368, 0.021828506141901016, 0.005939756985753775, -0.04240284115076065, 0.021249206736683846, -0.02359018102288246, -0.060030531138181686, -0.03018777444958687 ]
Ultrafast electron-phonon relaxation dynamics in graphene hides many distinct phenomena, such as hot phonon generation, dynamical Kohn anomalies, and phonon decoupling, yet still remains largely unexplored. Here, we unravel intricate mechanisms governing the vibrational relaxation and phonon dressing in graphene at a highly non-equilibrium state by means of first-principles techniques. We calculate dynamical phonon spectral functions and momentum-resolved linewidths for various stages of electron relaxation and find photo-induced phonon hardening, overall increase of relaxation rate and nonadiabaticity as well as phonon gain. Namely, the initial stage of photo-excitation is found to be governed by strong phonon anomalies of finite-momentum optical modes along with incoherent phonon production. Population inversion state, on the other hand, allows production of coherent and strongly-coupled phonon modes. Our research provides vital insights into the electron-phonon coupling phenomena in graphene, and serves as a foundation for exploring non-equilibrium phonon dressing in materials where ordered states and phase transitions can be induced by photo-excitation.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09076v1
[ -0.01816129870712757, -0.0008147024200297892, -0.02320762537419796, 0.004128917120397091, 0.022887980565428734, -0.04516955092549324, 0.022714385762810707, 0.048899970948696136, -0.03816908225417137, 0.008702490478754044, -0.04499322548508644, -0.06295279413461685, -0.0665433406829834, -0.043142810463905334, -0.021123774349689484, 0.013804396614432335, 0.09032919257879257, 0.01863773912191391, -0.035599756985902786, 0.0565737709403038, 0.0213753804564476, 0.018325908109545708, 0.017888404428958893, 0.03943368420004845, 0.005138223059475422, -0.035808783024549484, -0.037558458745479584, 0.051728684455156326, -0.0164791326969862, -0.03374356031417847, 0.06772461533546448, -0.04563966393470764, 0.010316074825823307, 0.04088246449828148, -0.010233423672616482, -0.03098258748650551, -0.008160743862390518, 0.04537748917937279, 0.04224640876054764, -0.03332648426294327, -0.020958539098501205, -0.03491106256842613, -0.03132401779294014, 0.04175814241170883, -0.025556132197380066, -0.045517727732658386, -0.026239363476634026, 0.05829935893416405, -0.06933186948299408, -0.0539676807820797, 0.003445764072239399, 0.030933277681469917, 0.0011946375016123056, 0.05009901151061058, -0.05592988431453705, -0.010798919014632702, 0.0011907529551535845, -0.02131248451769352, -0.05467711389064789, -0.00021814045612700284, 0.0037051131948828697, -0.0338367223739624, 0.023084547370672226, -0.03543804958462715, -0.029795194044709206, 0.013003339059650898, -0.01253830548375845, -0.040052395313978195, -0.035677455365657806, -0.06843812763690948, 0.001118648680858314, -0.030357401818037033, 0.028872089460492134, 0.018878107890486717, -0.014810946770012379, -0.013043239712715149, 0.012539488263428211, 0.005289571825414896, -0.025063853710889816, 0.06283573061227798, -0.04564783722162247, 0.016016468405723572, 0.008493365719914436, 0.04838809370994568, 0.006923488341271877, 0.0374472439289093, 0.035068754106760025, -0.017563723027706146, -0.04106675460934639, -0.04299301281571388, 0.07256144285202026, -0.05479774251580238, -0.019222695380449295, -0.0033431423362344503, 0.03740914911031723, -0.04085307940840721, 0.07936937361955643, 0.020133716985583305, -0.023673050105571747, 0.010890963487327099, 0.0017420492367818952, -0.017518945038318634, -0.02691110037267208, 0.019809069111943245, 0.0027173073031008244, -0.03857237100601196, -0.02523120306432247, -0.048219386488199234, -0.0352453738451004, 0.020993536338210106, 0.01144717913120985, -0.020275412127375603, -0.0011596857802942395, -0.04565153643488884, -0.03760317713022232, 0.016161957755684853, 0.047646414488554, 0.004428389947861433, -0.03356776013970375, -0.01330828107893467, -0.025648726150393486, 0.06869055330753326, -0.039093807339668274, 0.012004153802990913, -0.05769705772399902, 0.023220818489789963, 0.08240009099245071, 0.02465442381799221, 0.021984977647662163, -0.050407156348228455, -0.027633637189865112, 0.018088163807988167, 0.036822155117988586, -0.040752798318862915, 0.05244004353880882, -0.028049122542142868, 0.01635648123919964, 0.012261171825230122, -0.00022698852990288287, 0.029325833544135094, -0.053346674889326096, -0.0011647309875115752, 0.03529680147767067, -0.04373803734779358, 0.023791026324033737, 0.027481770142912865, -0.06210913881659508, 0.02964998409152031, 0.07106860727071762, 0.04301038011908531, 0.040739718824625015, 0.0076301549561321735, 0.011472728103399277, 0.02357451245188713, 0.016769899055361748, 0.01653192937374115, 0.05924498662352562, 0.030019620433449745, -0.0009470807854086161, 0.028085941448807716, -0.0014569596387445927, -0.0516962967813015, 0.04473736509680748, -0.0071921623311936855, -0.004099381621927023, -0.03112659603357315, 0.049221575260162354, -0.03435526415705681, -0.03130193054676056, 0.02465212717652321, -0.04321479797363281, 0.05528473109006882, 0.050316277891397476, -0.03980607911944389, -0.05869109928607941, -0.028933146968483925, -0.01042358111590147, -0.03204760327935219, 0.016611114144325256, -0.007823732681572437, 0.0034311350900679827, 0.0219869501888752, -0.0331580713391304, -0.03878291696310043, 0.003964487463235855, -0.022426554933190346, -0.0941830426454544, 0.025819798931479454, 0.05450230464339256, -0.02591685764491558, -0.007487173657864332, -0.04884600266814232, 0.016345221549272537, -0.02773025631904602, -0.01808398775756359, -0.0028616911731660366, 0.007933104410767555, -0.020845679566264153, 0.020042715594172478, 0.0435379259288311, -0.0841398537158966, -0.020487796515226364, -0.022815879434347153, -0.02082146890461445, -0.009302501566708088, -0.0425039678812027, 0.01579991541802883, 0.011905173771083355, -0.04777153953909874, 0.03711460530757904, 0.051091715693473816, 0.06411045044660568, 0.0487382709980011, -0.009700805880129337, 0.019260277971625328, -0.008723968639969826, -0.11013419926166534, 0.012014701962471008, 0.00058855174575001, -0.028305739164352417, 0.009452263824641705, 0.00111862039193511, -0.039783548563718796, -0.020778808742761612, -0.04044663533568382, 0.04049958288669586, 0.04032513499259949, -0.023054683580994606, -0.03657474368810654, -0.019685037434101105, -0.014892945997416973, -0.03270743787288666, -0.06812388449907303, -0.056442566215991974, -0.05118919163942337, 0.040284644812345505, -0.023748314008116722, -0.01075365487486124, -0.05177632346749306, -0.024243289604783058, -0.03703683987259865, -0.01580636203289032, 0.041905827820301056, 0.010844587348401546, -0.030636854469776154, -0.04689324274659157, -0.035820599645376205, 0.04642424359917641, -0.03566772863268852, 0.0066323489882051945, -0.0031553448643535376, -0.07500344514846802, -0.007046878337860107, 0.0013698803959414363, -0.0033151309471577406, 0.05870624631643295, -0.026893092319369316, 0.022354118525981903, 0.003859856864437461, 0.032628804445266724, 0.0035096730571240187, 0.027044033631682396, -0.02745281532406807, 0.021066399291157722, 0.0455223023891449, 0.029693283140659332, -0.015026171691715717, 0.007912644185125828, 0.018816905096173286, -0.04374026134610176, -0.03227251395583153, 0.06030413880944252, 0.018202008679509163, 0.01737528294324875, 0.006421677302569151, -0.04416026175022125, -0.0019054955337196589, -0.02440447360277176, 0.028247734531760216, 0.036332834511995316, 0.037472549825906754, 0.03920689597725868, 0.005618304014205933, -0.059199173003435135, -0.015042571350932121, -0.04724247381091118, -0.008709093555808067, -0.024919182062149048, -0.029191583395004272, -0.005224202293902636, -0.07293567806482315, 0.01582447811961174, -0.027067605406045914, -0.04054681956768036, -0.06023783981800079, -0.036275893449783325, -0.036986541002988815, -0.023013001307845116, 0.04842771589756012, -0.04571857675909996, -0.08038200438022614, 0.02408369816839695, 0.030728543177247047, -0.009964332915842533, -0.04938197135925293, -0.03230368345975876, -0.024359246715903282, 0.008302795700728893, -0.013981256633996964, -0.024777863174676895, -0.01697091944515705, -0.004181500058621168, -0.08682160824537277, 0.028371816501021385, -0.015660565346479416, 0.04539311304688454, 0.06327643245458603, -0.05221329256892204, -0.02183232456445694, -0.017561214044690132, -0.028135402128100395, -0.03476293757557869, 0.005040041171014309, 0.009983648546040058, -0.0235273540019989, -0.03644486889243126, 0.06845340132713318, 0.020092103630304337, -0.00748484255746007, -0.028951680287718773, -0.06844496726989746, -0.03715560585260391, 0.04146046191453934, -0.0036297915503382683, 0.05267760902643204, -0.00046949824900366366, -0.03374340757727623, -0.0346737802028656, -0.05504981428384781, 0.041613440960645676, 0.0284282099455595, 0.009460827335715294, 0.011490261182188988, 0.043629713356494904, -0.009946142323315144, -0.02762291207909584, 0.03843894600868225, 0.04115549102425575, 0.04933618754148483, -0.0365389883518219, 0.00526366475969553, 0.02442614547908306, -0.0037317906972020864, 0.04662797227501869, 0.02847512997686863, -0.008317527361214161, 0.016053879633545876, 0.06755779683589935, -0.01167326420545578, -0.020667236298322678, -0.02651059627532959, -0.05602484941482544, -0.06382527202367783, -0.021605702117085457, 0.05123598873615265, 0.028421351686120033, 0.0062191844917833805, -0.006786542013287544, -0.003737173043191433, -0.04210812970995903, 0.07039576768875122, -0.015961045399308205, -0.01688002608716488, 0.010049322620034218, 0.005506841000169516, 0.024749532341957092, -0.023752471432089806, 0.0029046242125332355, -0.03291049972176552, -0.03746609389781952, -0.008388890884816647, -0.045421432703733444, 0.0454438291490078, 0.049085576087236404, 0.023154648020863533, 0.019719861447811127, 0.0431208461523056, 0.017621731385588646, 0.06800361722707748, -0.007947966456413269, 0.0347406305372715, -0.009080187417566776, -0.005629364401102066, 0.012661175802350044, -0.00289940950460732, -0.040983691811561584, -0.006881267298012972, 0.024342549964785576, -0.04651005566120148, 0.03271332383155823, 0.015309209004044533, 0.006000305991619825, -0.05635305866599083, -0.09695567190647125, -0.04871607571840286, -0.03554929047822952, 0.05160878971219063, -0.010845942422747612, -0.01404108852148056, 0.08013220876455307, -0.025408849120140076, -0.01660490594804287, -0.02201050892472267, -0.021986927837133408, -0.03881172835826874, -0.03436236456036568, 0.01597900502383709, -0.061968084424734116, 0.036080166697502136, 0.0031978636980056763, 0.028344718739390373, 0.00930098071694374, 0.027691109105944633, -0.05376798287034035, 0.04434230551123619, -0.018040992319583893, 0.01049670297652483, 0.06167450174689293, -0.008116928860545158, -0.001869412837550044, -0.015240776352584362, -0.020453516393899918, 0.057166215032339096, 0.023082951083779335, 0.04523180052638054, -0.04667913168668747, 0.05252697691321373, -0.03943799436092377, 0.010968798771500587, -0.02749025635421276, 0.01752753183245659, 0.06985538452863693, -0.07297424972057343, -0.0683039203286171, -0.003931673243641853, 0.036146629601716995, 0.017645902931690216, -0.03575005754828453, 0.007494060322642326, -0.024454830214381218, -0.044832564890384674, -0.023228183388710022, 0.01741604320704937, -0.03973253816366196, 0.03132157400250435, 0.0174780935049057, 0.0014665407361462712, 0.02846839278936386, -0.005750493612140417, 0.016941653564572334, 0.05591579154133797, 0.023794149979948997, -0.02615571953356266, -0.03732383996248245, -0.03747926279902458, 0.04115741699934006, 0.011809472925961018, -0.036050282418727875, 0.019093669950962067, 0.018721723929047585, -0.0007332161767408252, 0.048851702362298965, -0.08727788925170898, -0.019190680235624313, 0.04578199237585068, -0.02503567561507225, 0.016678540036082268, 0.025443745777010918, -0.019422022625803947, 0.042123135179281235, -0.046944040805101395, -0.010005841962993145, -0.015695827081799507, -0.0009257287019863725, 0.007987448945641518, -0.010110716335475445, -0.04644434154033661, 0.010799900628626347, 0.02212514542043209, -0.009749251417815685, -0.07765522599220276, 0.030406247824430466, 0.0409080907702446, -0.0034079975448548794, -0.027623025700449944, 0.022438019514083862, 0.06516449898481369, -0.02277468517422676, -0.0593363419175148, 0.014634131453931332, -0.0001841128250816837, -0.0006106756045483053, 0.05132164806127548, -0.07511728256940842, -0.03123871609568596, -0.013768580742180347, 0.020251698791980743, 0.022043058648705482, 0.011833143420517445, 0.012580256909132004, -0.00576357264071703, -0.00087886699475348, -0.023333171382546425, -0.06533928960561752, 0.03190555050969124, -0.0729605033993721, 0.009720103815197945, 0.0015749583253636956, -0.02032451331615448, 0.03441561013460159, 0.05747845396399498, 0.017352072522044182, -0.03955438733100891, -0.009224836714565754, -0.008250253275036812, 0.033568404614925385, -0.03314956650137901, -0.006175860296934843, 0.0182390995323658, 0.06655189394950867, -0.028408674523234367, 0.018433937802910805, -0.016644421964883804, -0.024719685316085815, -0.049921657890081406, 0.02509476989507675, 0.0287444107234478, 0.0094488225877285, -0.036213379353284836, 0.00978036317974329, 0.023619169369339943, -0.03081625886261463, 0.02948417142033577, 0.01470860280096531, 0.00023380188213195652, 0.012302583083510399, 0.03027993254363537, -0.023594502359628677, -0.02737155742943287, 0.035186439752578735, 0.09744850546121597, -0.09540057927370071, 0.006137263961136341, -0.019872140139341354, -0.040192101150751114, -0.015155897475779057, -0.03940671682357788, -0.011054917238652706, 0.009168763644993305, -0.015716880559921265, -0.08348799496889114, 0.01984240487217903, -0.012428727932274342, -0.05556207150220871, -0.004125760868191719, -0.001874937443062663, -0.030010340735316277, 0.016417108476161957, -0.005135994404554367, 0.008337038569152355, -0.035498008131980896, 0.0063750552944839, 0.00353595451451838, -0.06442038714885712, -0.03871947154402733, 0.0726751759648323, 0.07793992012739182, -0.04469217360019684, -0.010046443901956081, 0.0016957729822024703, 0.002934441901743412, 0.017232930287718773, -0.03702549636363983, -0.019731633365154266, -0.032675210386514664, 0.03109038434922695, -0.0006049389485269785, -0.043713655322790146, -0.031366605311632156, 0.038423534482717514, -0.03776104748249054, -0.0009762619156390429, -0.013401968404650688, 0.0006917815189808607, 0.03039083071053028, -0.06803559511899948, -0.05696486309170723, 0.040677446871995926, 0.00026347278617322445, -0.01222261693328619, -0.035520125180482864, -0.026371249929070473, -0.03129417449235916, 0.028223557397723198, 0.03602822124958038, -0.024239633232355118, -0.007601981982588768, -0.016867831349372864, -0.06758664548397064, -0.020571839064359665, -0.05242264270782471, -0.030393842607736588, 0.036612316966056824, 0.0004977316129952669, 0.02205244079232216, 0.021230479702353477, -0.0013101081131026149, -0.006002124864608049, 0.030089592561125755, -0.043912794440984726, 0.031352099031209946, 0.022943997755646706, -0.01324866060167551, -0.027858247980475426, 0.018768826499581337, -0.03440909832715988, -0.0024270331487059593, -0.009368272498250008, -0.0644577145576477, -0.002737965201959014, 0.013621756806969643, -0.0021809162572026253, -0.007054227404296398, 0.01445501483976841, -0.05732468515634537, -0.031784236431121826, 0.03635123744606972, -0.014278464950621128, -0.020545221865177155, 0.028781600296497345, -0.0066544427536427975, 0.027678463608026505, -0.00962788425385952, 0.020534370094537735, 0.044925134629011154, -0.027468472719192505, 0.0652809590101242, 0.06066861003637314, 0.04454587772488594, -0.004427584819495678, -0.022129589691758156, -0.013023789040744305, 0.05173736438155174, -0.008429787121713161, -0.04924476519227028, 0.008457113988697529, -0.0411190502345562, -0.0856279656291008, -0.002102854195982218, -0.029565753415226936, -0.03579888865351677, -0.014879588969051838, -0.058016661554574966, 0.07018732279539108, 0.030547291040420532, -0.031370148062705994, -0.08864739537239075, 0.04738428443670273, 0.02252095378935337, -0.012052389793097973, -0.023366408422589302, -0.039839744567871094, -0.03764767572283745, 0.005813902243971825, -0.07868104428052902, 0.003729822114109993, -0.011466000229120255, 0.07350806146860123, 0.007840984500944614, -0.021783022210001945, 0.04059852659702301, -0.02534898929297924, 0.028539491817355156, 0.06086621433496475, 0.014940370805561543, 0.04692327231168747, -0.015074088238179684, 0.03221776708960533, -0.013977598398923874, -0.009777236729860306, 0.023770228028297424, -0.024518869817256927, -0.0031380350701510906, 0.01205711904913187, 0.05748750641942024, 0.0018907699268311262, 0.05204025283455849, 0.044554125517606735, -0.04221901297569275, 0.006650126539170742, -0.0343686006963253, 0.04760807380080223, -0.0018244420643895864, -0.05859139934182167, 0.05842984840273857, -0.031823866069316864, -0.01511889323592186, 0.017701828852295876, -0.01396972220391035, -0.01752052828669548, 0.001260851975530386, -0.04011904448270798, -0.003452316392213106, -0.030043037608265877, 0.023321818560361862, 0.07514838874340057, -0.039171237498521805, 0.011087690480053425, 0.03542493283748627, -0.008289972320199013, -0.055516213178634644, 0.041414473205804825, -0.0001771995157469064, -0.056495144963264465, 0.0281898882240057, -0.09371503442525864, 0.05980309471487999, -0.0431939959526062, 0.036149248480796814, -0.013932740315794945, 0.02294374816119671, -0.061427533626556396, 0.0034709067549556494, -0.05508032813668251, 0.008447627536952496, 0.002931926166638732, -0.04912199452519417, 0.015736812725663185, -0.000703171594068408, 0.04407951608300209, 0.03518541902303696, 0.02091856487095356, 0.0031371391378343105, 0.05712047591805458, 0.03426746651530266, -0.0006905498448759317, -0.06738714128732681, -0.03661106154322624, -0.008503000251948833, 0.03724285215139389, 0.033741142600774765, 0.03757670894265175, -0.08276432752609253, 0.03977295011281967, 0.003009186591953039, 0.0193043015897274, 0.03905842453241348, 0.003977480810135603, -0.04202410578727722, -0.03181332349777222, -0.0053619020618498325, 0.028557073324918747, -0.015087469480931759, -0.03265947476029396, 0.0045710098929703236, 0.009821084327995777, -0.004219754133373499, -0.06519438326358795 ]
We study states arising from fluctuations in the disorder potential in systems with long-range hopping. Here, contrary to systems with short-range hopping, the optimal fluctuations of disorder responsible for the formation of the states in the gap, are not rendered shallow and long-range when $E$ approaches the band edge ($E\to 0$). Instead, they remain deep and short-range. The corresponding electronic wave functions also remain short-range-localized for all $E<0$. This behavior has striking implications for the structure of the wave functions slightly above $E=0$. By a study of finite systems, we demonstrate that the wave functions $\Psi_E$ transform from a localized to a quasi-localized type upon crossing the $E=0$ level, forming resonances embedded in the $E>0$ continuum. The quasi-localized $\Psi_{E>0}$ consists of a short-range core that is essentially the same as $\Psi_{E=0}$ and a delocalized tail extending to the boundaries of the system. The amplitude of the tail is small, but it decreases with $r$ slowly. Its contribution to the norm of the wave function dominates for sufficiently large system sizes, $L\gg L_c(E)$; such states behave as delocalized ones. In contrast, in small systems, $L\ll L_c(E)$, quasi-localized states are overwhelmingly dominated by the localized cores and are effectively localized.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06345v3
[ -0.0699513778090477, -0.03198918327689171, 0.03416005149483681, 0.0013773033861070871, 0.009402532130479813, -0.020910676568746567, -0.057284969836473465, 0.03691801801323891, -0.023958394303917885, -0.024606626480817795, 0.05935979634523392, -0.07171711325645447, -0.0316285565495491, -0.036958079785108566, -0.05182814598083496, 0.02117362804710865, 0.0601440966129303, 0.06380955129861832, -0.006346423644572496, 0.05216871201992035, -0.045002344995737076, -0.021841540932655334, 0.019463811069726944, 0.0207130815833807, 0.009419023059308529, -0.051361553370952606, -0.0516381599009037, 0.051808033138513565, -0.02947004698216915, 0.015939559787511826, 0.06845764070749283, -0.03835888206958771, -0.017170846462249756, 0.018877318128943443, -0.03754643723368645, 0.012884712778031826, -0.018800953403115273, 0.066387839615345, -0.0018104108748957515, -0.0056395744904875755, 0.027724450454115868, -0.05537845194339752, -0.0341460220515728, -0.04642777517437935, -0.021736154332756996, -0.053467635065317154, -0.03949480876326561, 0.019867422059178352, -0.03749613091349602, -0.06785790622234344, 0.00024460299755446613, 0.0074771372601389885, -0.011042596772313118, 0.06729841977357864, -0.008660674095153809, -0.041452474892139435, -0.023941975086927414, -0.02347506582736969, -0.01820278912782669, -0.019157661125063896, -0.05338907241821289, -0.043550044298172, -0.04201922193169594, -0.018401026725769043, -0.004986476618796587, 0.029886124655604362, -0.03720856457948685, -0.06156391277909279, -0.010426714085042477, -0.030099747702479362, 0.01413196511566639, -0.07038131356239319, -0.021165236830711365, 0.004360365681350231, -0.0603293739259243, 0.0065332637168467045, 0.025737594813108444, -0.027351798489689827, 0.006910067982971668, -0.006154043134301901, -0.009074882604181767, 0.018928490579128265, 0.03744165971875191, 0.010526844300329685, 0.04451282322406769, 0.020155515521764755, 0.055009521543979645, -0.059378307312726974, -0.012654077261686325, -0.04982587322592735, 0.01259955670684576, -0.03885073959827423, -0.07093600928783417, 0.012159356847405434, 0.04034613445401192, -0.041869841516017914, 0.06344926357269287, 0.056772612035274506, 0.04700847342610359, -0.007322563324123621, 0.016038518399000168, -0.06570525467395782, -0.01054655946791172, 0.022122632712125778, -0.019108077511191368, -0.061954718083143234, -0.003977825865149498, -0.0292681697756052, -0.059533651918172836, 0.051890429109334946, -0.0034042377956211567, -0.02139732614159584, -0.03798370435833931, -0.07072991132736206, -0.05314468964934349, -0.035056862980127335, 0.06790875643491745, -0.001399486674927175, -0.021902885288000107, -0.015887919813394547, -0.014325662516057491, 0.0449841134250164, 0.03097252920269966, -0.004884710069745779, 0.02026110701262951, 0.027148190885782242, 0.05174107477068901, -0.014881943352520466, 0.017817115411162376, 0.01928868517279625, 0.011851243674755096, 0.046957168728113174, 0.05088932812213898, -0.03245029225945473, 0.010766686871647835, -0.00931705255061388, 0.05526746064424515, 0.02256791479885578, 0.00995670910924673, -0.00839985255151987, 0.034466493874788284, -0.014489250257611275, -0.0021438198164105415, 0.05697508528828621, 0.015961406752467155, 0.011439569294452667, -0.0521915964782238, -0.011335254646837711, 0.0647025778889656, 0.029914503917098045, 0.012032323516905308, 0.004938302095979452, 0.035924047231674194, -0.0426921509206295, -0.028131205588579178, -0.010579865425825119, 0.04052869975566864, 0.0606851801276207, -0.036525409668684006, 0.014316767454147339, 0.015936922281980515, -0.01298636943101883, -0.028278851881623268, 0.014651292003691196, 0.008479972369968891, 0.030900001525878906, 0.03525770083069801, -0.013377636671066284, 0.02754373289644718, 0.0444352887570858, -0.06055659428238869, 0.05201658234000206, -0.022036656737327576, -0.05598558858036995, -0.02857912704348564, -0.004041640087962151, 0.025141222402453423, -0.03330980986356735, -0.022568393498659134, 0.049631524831056595, 0.052248239517211914, 0.03809972479939461, -0.026178453117609024, -0.018182333558797836, -0.06963000446557999, -0.025588661432266235, -0.07099930942058563, 0.025041114538908005, 0.06658042967319489, 0.041922446340322495, -0.03735755756497383, -0.0442548505961895, 0.02899576909840107, -0.02930302917957306, -0.007879954762756824, -0.02130219340324402, 0.021330032497644424, -0.06216893345117569, -0.007721578702330589, 0.03382760286331177, -0.06490926444530487, 0.003859391203150153, -0.020377054810523987, 0.011690503917634487, 0.011966702528297901, -0.05472686141729355, 0.035308945924043655, 0.03385617211461067, 0.010624631308019161, -0.0188886858522892, 0.03784561529755592, 0.021814724430441856, 0.04972602799534798, 0.020893646404147148, -0.03257710114121437, -0.055689044296741486, -0.0843438133597374, 0.06217052787542343, 0.037528663873672485, -0.04527771845459938, 0.05003964528441429, 0.03494991362094879, -0.03401609882712364, -0.02319800667464733, -0.055375684052705765, 0.030304523184895515, 0.03232802078127861, -0.015233667567372322, -0.04077840968966484, 0.003080890281125903, 0.0014543975703418255, -0.06944599747657776, -0.035392191261053085, -0.06244347244501114, -0.004106448031961918, -0.010651706717908382, -0.027990100905299187, 0.021543698385357857, -0.009561778046190739, -0.023408077657222748, -0.0713898316025734, 0.005083902273327112, 0.023225514218211174, 0.05518677458167076, -0.059410348534584045, -0.04123727232217789, -0.06782836467027664, -0.011012453585863113, -0.03126237913966179, -0.029495222494006157, 0.004908781498670578, -0.034535977989435196, -0.033196501433849335, -0.021602360531687737, 0.01643483154475689, 0.04631531611084938, -0.014076675288379192, 0.009981898590922356, -0.019282624125480652, 0.022368011996150017, -0.021284010261297226, -0.018890906125307083, -0.03975039720535278, -0.01764822192490101, -0.02506495639681816, 0.030592437833547592, -0.03637634962797165, 0.006463299039751291, -0.017147105187177658, -0.011596332304179668, 0.032187823206186295, 0.0066538164392113686, 0.026457494124770164, -0.036896105855703354, 0.017509644851088524, -0.06290455907583237, -0.05716118589043617, 0.022296419367194176, -0.0041692228987813, -0.013913594186306, 0.05854443460702896, -0.011633976362645626, -0.020162397995591164, -0.0690588727593422, -0.05341247096657753, -0.029042594134807587, -0.02200459875166416, -0.07162231206893921, -0.043751850724220276, -0.03242051228880882, -0.04860663041472435, 0.03843053802847862, -0.01711534708738327, -0.04187760502099991, -0.047783467918634415, -0.021283814683556557, -0.04816541075706482, -0.026690050959587097, 0.04249696433544159, -0.0711793377995491, -0.026170674711465836, -0.019917776808142662, 0.051881153136491776, 0.02920333854854107, -0.03798413276672363, -0.0029894565232098103, 0.009520180523395538, -0.048739492893218994, 0.011870477348566055, -0.028073225170373917, -0.027908196672797203, -0.028001751750707626, -0.04547109827399254, -0.006683084648102522, 0.004531034734100103, 0.03900745138525963, 0.03901791572570801, -0.053903743624687195, -0.03473208472132683, 0.003397261491045356, -0.04792949557304382, -0.06710577756166458, 0.027894482016563416, -0.023881228640675545, -0.018001873046159744, -0.040692564100027084, 0.05961112305521965, 0.04681244492530823, 0.006240153219550848, -0.07078820466995239, -0.05951404944062233, 0.012736898846924305, -0.010699287988245487, -0.027509743347764015, 0.006659777835011482, 0.05579361319541931, -0.029380537569522858, 0.03432402014732361, -0.031081996858119965, 0.022501064464449883, -0.0025775444228202105, -0.00574386864900589, 0.0012767884181812406, 0.018824607133865356, 0.019309841096401215, -0.05688901245594025, -0.0020342508796602488, 0.06054568290710449, 0.062221694737672806, -0.05521435663104057, -0.00575820729136467, 0.02303069457411766, -0.01250894833356142, 0.06345667690038681, -0.028979599475860596, 0.027335120365023613, 0.0065148985013365746, 0.05851810798048973, -0.013619794510304928, -0.0007710942882113159, -0.008900628425180912, -0.06995328515768051, -0.014730015769600868, -0.011111380532383919, -0.011106859892606735, 0.020739326253533363, 0.008345389738678932, 0.007514346390962601, 0.02273928001523018, -0.027456965297460556, 0.0672493726015091, -0.020628657191991806, -0.05816590413451195, 0.004769564606249332, -0.0024658406618982553, -0.0416484996676445, 0.012997562065720558, 0.0035485411062836647, -0.029774900525808334, -0.0407857708632946, 0.0077162692323327065, -0.07248343527317047, -0.002487422898411751, -0.014650115743279457, -0.02852136641740799, 0.02756642922759056, -0.008252558298408985, -0.02850707806646824, 0.0569312646985054, -0.028999174013733864, 0.021069709211587906, -0.01746789924800396, -0.04970798268914223, 0.0471147783100605, -0.0024023179430514574, 0.04319518059492111, -0.034013353288173676, 0.03543942794203758, -0.05987461283802986, 0.020356882363557816, 0.040642205625772476, 0.0089091332629323, 0.0027180975303053856, -0.080050989985466, 0.01071331650018692, -0.055189840495586395, 0.018074747174978256, 0.007300897501409054, -0.03248675912618637, 0.0541454516351223, -0.02945859357714653, 0.0032869253773242235, -0.05727716535329819, 0.019600575789809227, -0.006995716597884893, -0.0558612123131752, -0.03490563482046127, -0.018080029636621475, 0.04535622522234917, -0.04469521716237068, 0.018941419199109077, -0.02725698985159397, 0.0012868194608017802, -0.06978724896907806, 0.05895717814564705, -0.039065275341272354, 0.018647147342562675, -0.001494848751462996, 0.02661479450762272, 0.03059639036655426, -0.008732209913432598, -0.05787501484155655, -0.015445166267454624, -0.03500654175877571, 0.04222668707370758, -0.04625573009252548, 0.020003607496619225, -0.06348743289709091, -0.042706042528152466, -0.04665819928050041, 0.016473304480314255, 0.017850195989012718, -0.04062466323375702, -0.03372301533818245, 0.0029508713632822037, -0.019737467169761658, -0.06001640483736992, -0.030280249193310738, -0.048753686249256134, -0.060477279126644135, -0.06980165839195251, -0.001356011489406228, -0.020248938351869583, -0.04165223240852356, -0.0351310633122921, 0.06989280134439468, 0.03350831940770149, 0.04950592294335365, -0.02699287235736847, 0.02911956235766411, 0.005711857229471207, 0.01600981131196022, -0.023408493027091026, -0.036135461181402206, -0.03374239802360535, 0.04396224766969681, -0.04472614452242851, -0.028176914900541306, -0.038304176181554794, 0.0424489825963974, -0.03232386335730553, -0.015490650199353695, -0.08185672760009766, 0.00608999514952302, -0.0003084849158767611, -0.019958222284913063, 0.024383578449487686, 0.029129507020115852, -0.059500552713871, 0.019025733694434166, -0.032336026430130005, 0.02407987043261528, 0.004642893560230732, 0.03481592983007431, -0.023255979642271996, 0.0029021494556218386, -0.053221993148326874, 0.00010046006354968995, 0.0183892622590065, -0.020965291187167168, -0.05253920331597328, 0.0034412529785186052, 0.040679771453142166, -0.0008243271731771529, -0.03574962168931961, 0.03386760130524635, 0.03491330146789551, -0.048763491213321686, -0.07124987989664078, 0.007228466682136059, 0.01599711738526821, 0.007042937446385622, 0.07379519939422607, -0.04163758084177971, -0.012454153038561344, -0.0032389527186751366, -0.020159868523478508, 0.03353101387619972, 0.04707755148410797, 0.0007487763650715351, -0.014538721181452274, 0.00898026954382658, -0.025857744738459587, -0.07254936546087265, -0.01587880402803421, -0.05281754583120346, 0.010863385163247585, -0.043867092579603195, -0.04437071457505226, 0.0037653809413313866, -0.0010140737285837531, -0.014485824853181839, -0.05619889125227928, -0.047870706766843796, -0.022542310878634453, 0.03714655339717865, -0.01050402782857418, -0.03468654304742813, 0.017282521352171898, 0.044693175703287125, 0.010166045278310776, -0.020181095227599144, -0.05786309018731117, -0.005855615716427565, -0.014426302164793015, 0.03582385927438736, 0.008140034042298794, -0.03390815854072571, -0.027108358219265938, -0.0037297673989087343, 0.006435373332351446, -0.056251246482133865, 0.0670233964920044, 0.0119654331356287, 0.031448543071746826, 0.03231067582964897, -0.02445930987596512, 0.051107604056596756, -0.06249025836586952, -0.009336255490779877, 0.06624292582273483, -0.047669488936662674, 0.03805717080831528, -0.06455589830875397, 0.006557968910783529, -0.0020453566685318947, -0.05146799609065056, -0.0005080022965557873, 0.03628024086356163, -0.023847442120313644, -0.02114024944603443, 0.0322774201631546, 0.0076682413928210735, -0.06872720271348953, 0.0025799120776355267, 0.04641387611627579, -0.06839700788259506, 0.008488630875945091, -0.000565668276976794, -0.013181719928979874, -0.05074777826666832, 0.02097810059785843, -0.03047763556241989, -0.06360539048910141, -0.004892940632998943, 0.041703078895807266, 0.051607050001621246, -0.03149985894560814, -0.014604825526475906, -0.013665193691849709, 0.01187402568757534, -0.018732506781816483, -0.014553474262356758, -0.03162413835525513, -0.018593454733490944, -0.003999006003141403, 0.0009246182162314653, 0.003088198136538267, 0.0024779653176665306, 0.006762805860489607, -0.054370056837797165, 0.0045173089019954205, -0.01896938867866993, -0.024369999766349792, 0.0395304411649704, -0.015356614254415035, -0.03547629341483116, 0.03149852156639099, -0.0368865467607975, 0.027490735054016113, -0.020663663744926453, -0.011201431043446064, 0.034699782729148865, 0.008087851107120514, 0.05266576632857323, -0.02829822711646557, -0.003814483294263482, 0.01905784197151661, -0.04988306015729904, 0.03886955976486206, -0.04735993966460228, -0.02472868002951145, 0.017501888796687126, 0.0068279411643743515, -0.007288582157343626, 0.025721408426761627, -0.024242855608463287, -0.025035440921783447, 0.006202027667313814, 0.00720908073708415, 0.0029508378356695175, -0.03073659911751747, -0.027708875015378, -0.03379976004362106, 0.05714752525091171, -0.032427381724119186, -0.03028714843094349, 0.013865168206393719, -0.046497296541929245, 0.03868646174669266, -0.03038749285042286, -0.037286076694726944, -0.011019697412848473, -0.000545269635040313, -0.05381127446889877, 0.010019335895776749, -0.002231330843642354, -0.023609701544046402, -0.02684001438319683, -0.021931732073426247, 0.01822127215564251, 0.003447656286880374, 0.04238056764006615, -0.012926124967634678, 0.02292623557150364, -0.015906766057014465, 0.03644261509180069, 0.022323638200759888, 0.04388916492462158, -0.016197947785258293, -0.024780476465821266, 0.003071025013923645, 0.02952955849468708, -0.019332483410835266, -0.02701616659760475, 0.018263885751366615, -0.05373149365186691, -0.056935809552669525, -0.010888182558119297, 0.011314453557133675, 0.03217405080795288, -0.034334562718868256, -0.04710083827376366, 0.06784526258707047, -0.015986410900950432, 0.0030179237946867943, -0.08013784885406494, -0.03623509034514427, 0.04539480060338974, 0.0059434799477458, -0.010804381221532822, -0.01994767226278782, -0.06452611833810806, -0.0017383222002536058, -0.073966845870018, -0.006288602482527494, -0.046711113303899765, 0.05485020950436592, -0.002877881983295083, 0.017834030091762543, -0.06312974542379379, -0.01110045611858368, 0.004530690144747496, 0.01681404374539852, -0.01829654350876808, 0.024126937612891197, 0.055073585361242294, -0.023403791710734367, -0.02638479694724083, 0.03751714900135994, 0.05841780826449394, -0.060410089790821075, 0.0230712890625, 0.03828080743551254, -0.04270869120955467, -0.019011348485946655, 0.03206847608089447, -0.008280225098133087, -0.014710266143083572, 0.039788417518138885, 0.001617605215869844, -0.04303863272070885, -0.049009039998054504, -0.04669637605547905, 0.014380642212927341, -0.07549398392438889, 0.02071397937834263, 0.03604237362742424, -0.022166330367326736, -0.058559007942676544, -0.02090711146593094, -0.05483909696340561, 0.035608649253845215, -0.01616465486586094, 0.010120715945959091, 0.03619251400232315, -0.06864973157644272, 0.010043643414974213, -0.0051470608450472355, -0.014660950750112534, -0.020468831062316895, 0.06462383270263672, 0.025209343060851097, -0.050541505217552185, -0.02319684438407421, -0.024087287485599518, -0.005471046548336744, 0.011990444734692574, 0.04167349264025688, 0.02654186077415943, 0.03586648404598236, -0.06215672194957733, 0.00203792005777359, -0.0549808144569397, -0.05847877636551857, 0.02576245367527008, -0.059576697647571564, 0.012521233409643173, -0.02679857239127159, 0.0033033699728548527, 0.005388043355196714, 0.013392476364970207, -0.030367089435458183, 0.010187431238591671, 0.06167130172252655, 0.014349564909934998, 0.0031512726563960314, -0.034041665494441986, -0.054790329188108444, 0.020903954282402992, -0.004487005528062582, -0.02112247236073017, -0.07382931560277939, 0.015974218025803566, -0.024482619017362595, 0.0384540893137455, -0.04109320789575577, -0.039722006767988205, -0.005361451767385006, -0.0571870319545269, -0.04140017554163933, 0.026267321780323982, 0.027084462344646454, -0.037467967718839645, 0.03389117866754532, 0.010005878284573555, -0.029521649703383446, -0.007802594918757677 ]
Power systems Unit Commitment (UC) problem determines the generator commitment schedule and dispatch decisions for power networks based on forecasted electricity demand. However, with the increasing penetration of renewables and stochastic demand behaviors, it becomes challenging to solve the large-scale, multi-interval UC problem in an efficient manner. The main objective of this paper is to propose a fast and reliable scheme to eliminate a set of redundant or inactive physical constraints in the high-dimensional, multi-interval, mixed-integer UC problem, while the reduced problem is equivalent to the original full problem in terms of commitment decisions. Our key insights lie on pre-screening the constraints based on the load distribution and considering the physical feasibility regions of multi-interval UC problem. For the multistep UC formulation, we overcome screening conservativeness by utilizing the multi-step ramping relationships, and can reliably screen out more constraints compared to current practice. Extensive simulations on both specific load samples and load regions validate the proposed technique can screen out more than 80% constraints while preserving the feasibility of multi-interval UC problem.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05894v1
[ 0.01369773130863905, -0.02939755655825138, 0.022535599768161774, 0.023912739008665085, -0.03361732140183449, -0.0319230854511261, 0.029129860922694206, 0.028373761102557182, -0.022717658430337906, -0.018434718251228333, -0.01730996184051037, -0.009344769641757011, -0.029220573604106903, -0.03806062415242195, -0.03423472121357918, 0.0027444097213447094, 0.06540808081626892, 0.006572183687239885, -0.047293439507484436, 0.016911853104829788, 0.01657869480550289, 0.026153763756155968, -0.026085201650857925, 0.013187079690396786, 0.024171631783246994, 0.00422808900475502, -0.04144395515322685, -0.024673033505678177, -0.05167375132441521, -0.0169014111161232, 0.04578244313597679, -0.0027775452472269535, -0.02940221130847931, -0.03576856106519699, -0.015850583091378212, -0.05401183292269707, 0.0052990601398050785, 0.024300621822476387, 0.039538610726594925, -0.02440507523715496, 0.025665339082479477, -0.06159793958067894, -0.039741210639476776, -0.009187481366097927, -0.008003483526408672, -0.008057118393480778, 0.0075676399283111095, 0.027113469317555428, -0.06346249580383301, -0.034764986485242844, 0.031148798763751984, -0.006993675604462624, -0.022213054820895195, 0.026593487709760666, -0.042914558202028275, -0.016935020685195923, -0.02792132832109928, 0.025003379210829735, -0.03526408597826958, -0.04761407524347305, 0.0013504946837201715, -0.0034576577600091696, -0.016236962750554085, 0.01002588216215372, -0.007263700943440199, 0.06105426326394081, 0.002984982216730714, -0.07290976494550705, 0.021260136738419533, -0.039225608110427856, 0.037455059587955475, -0.023765020072460175, 0.031422510743141174, 0.025639493018388748, -0.03667224198579788, -0.002304308582097292, -0.02152726799249649, -0.03178099915385246, 0.006212971173226833, -0.017413459718227386, -0.013495324179530144, -0.016444535925984383, 0.028608102351427078, 0.006865439936518669, -0.00764483492821455, -0.023104332387447357, 0.0531219020485878, 0.034989483654499054, -0.01276283897459507, -0.04567144066095352, 0.057670943439006805, -0.020888442173600197, -0.052895914763212204, 0.00012632054858841002, 0.05189042538404465, -0.04527497664093971, 0.04833614453673363, 0.055034711956977844, 0.029177701100707054, -0.06593361496925354, -0.0325288400053978, -0.03999864310026169, -0.06119060143828392, 0.05825868993997574, 0.03250671178102493, 0.008844861760735512, 0.047105636447668076, 0.005235779564827681, -0.06671490520238876, 0.01704348437488079, -0.029387079179286957, -0.005578338634222746, 0.015196052379906178, -0.06817999482154846, -0.03928562253713608, -0.0465247817337513, 0.0558147169649601, 0.04210108146071434, 0.02823716029524803, -0.047720447182655334, -0.03582468256354332, 0.029009923338890076, 0.028003068640828133, 0.025396421551704407, -0.046874240040779114, -0.01941431500017643, 0.06228932738304138, -0.028056152164936066, 0.03619718924164772, -0.02493664063513279, -0.030782975256443024, 0.010718309320509434, -0.006448020227253437, -0.015825731679797173, 0.07198760658502579, 0.02573746256530285, 0.008347990922629833, -0.025047361850738525, 0.037270598113536835, 0.010176140815019608, -0.050597451627254486, -0.07181503623723984, -0.009024316444993019, -0.047416944056749344, 0.0007179487147368491, 0.07249167561531067, -0.033606141805648804, -0.0631294995546341, 0.024143463000655174, 0.01405006181448698, -0.01653655245900154, 0.012230142951011658, -0.017797095701098442, -0.0009811085183173418, 0.03660808131098747, 0.02145838364958763, 0.05705059692263603, 0.008828419260680676, -0.025388682261109352, 0.004513927735388279, 0.02000112645328045, -0.04151085019111633, -0.01963737979531288, -0.0033676628954708576, 0.0059958333149552345, 0.02647845819592476, 0.02410212717950344, 0.008575177751481533, 0.01121201366186142, 0.005645246710628271, -0.024754231795668602, 0.011082394048571587, 0.036107830703258514, -0.05656960606575012, -0.0537816621363163, -0.04004603251814842, 0.05183207988739014, -0.027540305629372597, -0.03818072751164436, 0.0020775117445737123, 0.010945423506200314, 0.01827322691679001, -0.04626394435763359, 0.0030946056358516216, -0.07418347895145416, -0.002401116769760847, -0.07882712036371231, 0.05674540996551514, 0.0009959752205759287, -0.04512592777609825, -0.018029548227787018, -0.031562689691782, 0.026436222717165947, 0.026295339688658714, -0.015009962022304535, -0.05032392591238022, 0.02022530883550644, -0.012393711134791374, -0.011086861602962017, 0.02214159443974495, -0.07045747339725494, 0.03985618054866791, -0.04010789096355438, 0.016075490042567253, 0.0022475654259324074, -0.059657804667949677, 0.014674147590994835, 0.025511490181088448, -0.04885389655828476, -0.0018923213938251138, 0.07730572670698166, 0.042071279138326645, 0.03391527011990547, 0.025182276964187622, 0.026908105239272118, -0.0018986966460943222, -0.10387858003377914, 0.005351225845515728, -0.024818599224090576, 0.002738307463005185, 0.04679463803768158, 0.01215664017945528, -0.04223112389445305, 0.008590396493673325, -0.00231494870968163, 0.061431340873241425, 0.028792211785912514, -0.014735087752342224, -0.045695267617702484, -0.008625632151961327, -0.04075298830866814, -0.06989534944295883, -0.028716489672660828, -0.07669717073440552, -0.03120533935725689, -0.00608481839299202, -0.010712685063481331, 0.06932028383016586, 0.0005848786677233875, -0.05216895043849945, -0.04995642974972725, -0.0459468811750412, 0.04781295731663704, -0.015706682577729225, -0.04065734148025513, -0.023599816486239433, -0.0408584289252758, 0.026749594137072563, 0.011877289973199368, -0.025118444114923477, -0.0006865417235530913, -0.030101565644145012, -0.016374489292502403, -0.016903463751077652, 0.005929627921432257, 0.0583961196243763, -0.035561155527830124, -0.01684955321252346, -0.023443907499313354, 0.03556983545422554, 0.007835298776626587, 0.022626657038927078, -0.053687456995248795, 0.0314360186457634, 0.037755999714136124, 0.014137398451566696, 0.005317493807524443, 0.022646969184279442, 0.022580396384000778, -0.05607390031218529, -0.009172623045742512, 0.014272525906562805, 0.03382909297943115, 0.03518066555261612, 0.0573321171104908, -0.04399428516626358, -0.02713707834482193, -0.026104766875505447, 0.013847730122506618, 0.04269414022564888, 0.030102670192718506, -0.0008407655404880643, -0.02018781192600727, -0.06172248348593712, -0.009164728224277496, -0.03440309688448906, 0.019479144364595413, -0.04365178570151329, -0.06763487309217453, -0.03366437554359436, -0.08526666462421417, -0.040995772927999496, 0.019406698644161224, -0.045761577785015106, -0.029164399951696396, -0.03592180460691452, -0.023476965725421906, -0.008410206995904446, 0.02763158082962036, -0.04642893373966217, -0.0554451085627079, -0.055135007947683334, 0.048375263810157776, 0.03649153560400009, -0.032279904931783676, -0.04822740703821182, -0.04529349505901337, 0.0056939939968287945, -0.0039055924862623215, -0.01669001393020153, -0.027614478021860123, -0.033187899738550186, -0.024135753512382507, 0.06113541126251221, 0.007671110797673464, 0.023582229390740395, 0.018798593431711197, 0.018762951716780663, -0.010823321528732777, 0.01785329543054104, 0.010852931998670101, -0.01679433509707451, 0.013727334327995777, -0.044169552624225616, -0.06026500090956688, -0.038847509771585464, 0.06273084878921509, 0.05534985661506653, -0.01214427687227726, -0.013833556324243546, -0.02321825921535492, 0.03888591378927231, 0.03181242197751999, 0.017567932605743408, 0.06663968414068222, 0.05861015245318413, -0.0535762719810009, 0.029412902891635895, -0.011848379857838154, 0.04351750761270523, -0.03319280222058296, 0.00020764427608810365, -0.02411503903567791, 0.04078059270977974, 0.042734768241643906, -0.08297599852085114, 0.059434037655591965, 0.03833902254700661, 0.07971715182065964, 0.018851658329367638, 0.028368258848786354, 0.018697941675782204, 0.009243808686733246, 0.018183965235948563, -0.009989775717258453, 0.001711664954200387, 0.05395587906241417, 0.047899022698402405, -0.009444243274629116, -0.06863664835691452, 0.013240069150924683, -0.07326783239841461, -0.04945510998368263, -0.006793939042836428, 0.02443738281726837, 0.01727650873363018, 0.03211754932999611, -0.03717849403619766, 0.02982231043279171, 0.017748704180121422, 0.06542001664638519, 0.0012708643916994333, -0.046106189489364624, 0.037800468504428864, -0.04574481025338173, -0.024508433416485786, 0.012025031261146069, -0.029497429728507996, 0.0028810850344598293, -0.044379737228155136, 0.01724233105778694, -0.06242571771144867, -0.002197891939431429, 0.0002227509394288063, 0.031043795868754387, 0.04273157939314842, 0.05848592519760132, -0.005586005747318268, 0.03837406635284424, 0.013336431235074997, -0.025431107729673386, -0.05356640741229057, 0.021212885156273842, -0.01470161508768797, -0.00032330024987459183, -0.053385477513074875, -0.001060300157405436, 0.0076943072490394115, -0.04514529928565025, -0.05340055003762245, 0.0017258368898183107, -0.006795921362936497, 0.018762929365038872, -0.09399938583374023, 0.013877994380891323, -0.01621108688414097, 0.05431326478719711, 0.0068308948539197445, 0.02272932603955269, 0.06408808380365372, -0.01427838671952486, 0.024237433448433876, -0.06300250440835953, -0.027360165491700172, 0.01377312932163477, -0.040975432842969894, -0.029855510219931602, -0.05365827679634094, 0.044395506381988525, -0.01127892080694437, 0.058424632996320724, 0.0572233609855175, 0.017674217000603676, -0.06454304605722427, -0.032773684710264206, 0.03375813737511635, -0.0015031007351353765, 0.03767192363739014, 0.014443588443100452, -0.022247549146413803, -0.02477150782942772, 0.0003671497106552124, -0.02256886102259159, 0.007314618211239576, -0.012619704008102417, -0.019882628694176674, 0.04231768101453781, -0.041455212980508804, -0.031873781234025955, -0.0025069275870919228, 0.025247827172279358, 0.06965707987546921, -0.07867026329040527, -0.02160366252064705, 0.008124464191496372, 0.04386800527572632, -0.05612322315573692, -0.04461578279733658, -0.0054794177412986755, -0.05743978172540665, -0.061418384313583374, -0.04240822792053223, 0.02780788205564022, -0.00006836211832705885, 0.015485498122870922, 0.020109063014388084, -0.0028412677347660065, 0.039284370839595795, -0.011646020226180553, 0.06250521540641785, 0.029221126809716225, -0.002097793621942401, 0.0048034945502877235, -0.022353241220116615, -0.08340524882078171, -0.01240454614162445, 0.016242945566773415, 0.001810345915146172, -0.036097168922424316, 0.02369292639195919, 0.0028896203730255365, -0.01244911178946495, -0.08270497620105743, 0.06631406396627426, 0.02322998456656933, -0.02187691070139408, 0.039579614996910095, -0.0021661431528627872, 0.005917582660913467, 0.05131762847304344, -0.0659404918551445, -0.014806819148361683, 0.00913334172219038, -0.04948386549949646, 0.02733222395181656, 0.0069680605083703995, -0.05139172077178955, 0.0033695846796035767, 0.054412443190813065, -0.006238570436835289, -0.08412860333919525, -0.010022509843111038, 0.0018579534953460097, -0.0008346700924448669, -0.036974817514419556, 0.02554706484079361, 0.02124015800654888, -0.027729615569114685, -0.03261339291930199, -0.010436703450977802, 0.029405051842331886, -0.0023978776298463345, 0.03939319774508476, -0.023211201652884483, -0.025962337851524353, 0.03717394918203354, 0.01784147322177887, -0.02992342598736286, 0.0025419120211154222, 0.033511366695165634, -0.012392653152346611, -0.011571541428565979, 0.01129311602562666, -0.06834151595830917, 0.02390649914741516, -0.019771317020058632, -0.001299418625421822, 0.017577940598130226, 0.025341618806123734, 0.02645457349717617, 0.011374004185199738, -0.025650041177868843, -0.07135335355997086, 0.024522066116333008, 0.003560995450243354, 0.05334168300032616, -0.05351670831441879, 0.04143287241458893, 0.00791119784116745, 0.023394053801894188, 0.03615448623895645, -0.020049884915351868, 0.001401101122610271, -0.013556929305195808, -0.004847078118473291, -0.02008814550936222, -0.01606193371117115, -0.02794608473777771, -0.03954773768782616, 0.02199864201247692, 0.04369789734482765, -0.03553203493356705, 0.05058937147259712, 0.0256415456533432, -0.030205868184566498, 0.04827757179737091, -0.035911813378334045, -0.01747111789882183, -0.009112810716032982, 0.04896712303161621, 0.06340790539979935, -0.07156871259212494, 0.014484993182122707, -0.02962631545960903, -0.02802692912518978, 0.024372519925236702, -0.04363733157515526, -0.007575108669698238, -0.021927934139966965, 0.014503461308777332, -0.04499278590083122, 0.058706749230623245, -0.029397811740636826, -0.07826738059520721, 0.030379878357052803, 0.009640255011618137, -0.07530397176742554, 0.002195586683228612, 0.04194408655166626, 0.0075303553603589535, -0.059669069945812225, 0.046819012612104416, -0.015584166161715984, -0.04089425504207611, -0.053966913372278214, 0.06861033290624619, 0.07701749354600906, -0.010846556164324284, -0.008440209552645683, -0.028770748525857925, -0.016648389399051666, 0.033428288996219635, -0.05097617954015732, 0.005935841239988804, 0.000555587699636817, 0.05153791978955269, -0.03261809051036835, -0.031165942549705505, -0.051977504044771194, 0.05770187824964523, -0.002565511269494891, -0.006526994053274393, 0.02463529258966446, -0.04522164538502693, 0.03938010334968567, -0.0375392884016037, -0.07034248858690262, -0.0036664020735770464, -0.03979024291038513, 0.0021345496643334627, -0.007192404940724373, 0.0046053677797317505, -0.024846140295267105, 0.0569477379322052, -0.028494583442807198, -0.04681497439742088, 0.037568382918834686, -0.006298738997429609, -0.0438416488468647, 0.03365099057555199, -0.04721939191222191, 0.002080978825688362, 0.011947683058679104, 0.00794999860227108, -0.005666244309395552, 0.06224694103002548, -0.055430565029382706, -0.0036199346650391817, -0.006054767873138189, 0.035701002925634384, -0.01268843188881874, 0.005015012342482805, -0.032621026039123535, -0.027119077742099762, 0.06704788655042648, -0.04679093509912491, -0.02115030027925968, -0.012508356012403965, -0.034487053751945496, 0.02155882492661476, 0.01983470469713211, -0.04436979815363884, -0.030130304396152496, -0.003022831864655018, -0.02685403823852539, 0.03660207614302635, 0.02250453643500805, -0.04149355739355087, -0.08910290896892548, -0.019803624600172043, -0.008302140049636364, -0.013169761747121811, 0.0553385391831398, -0.00483664171770215, 0.029655538499355316, -0.040266308933496475, 0.03157733380794525, 0.0484258271753788, 0.009376714937388897, -0.0011734695872291923, -0.06574832648038864, 0.0011011511087417603, 0.02831271104514599, -0.016836067661643028, -0.03515242785215378, -0.049344658851623535, 0.014128648675978184, -0.04479079321026802, 0.00024430049234069884, 0.04040798172354698, 0.030598441138863564, -0.05115558207035065, -0.04770117625594139, 0.027015306055545807, 0.04206250607967377, -0.033569030463695526, -0.06016043201088905, 0.00743443937972188, 0.01334938034415245, 0.0011601087171584368, -0.0218430794775486, -0.026796407997608185, -0.07096245884895325, 0.0038960366509854794, -0.07427390664815903, -0.036230724304914474, -0.01763264089822769, 0.037827037274837494, -0.0034762925934046507, 0.031092695891857147, 0.017829492688179016, -0.037628721445798874, 0.030578557401895523, -0.01862264983355999, 0.00270893145352602, -0.0040242173708975315, 0.037628479301929474, 0.0025297526735812426, -0.052787479013204575, -0.0031384211033582687, 0.023468907922506332, -0.026792174205183983, 0.014453823678195477, 0.022495778277516365, 0.04621519520878792, -0.029245812445878983, 0.041526418179273605, 0.042325250804424286, -0.038990318775177, 0.061115067452192307, -0.040449950844049454, 0.05218867212533951, -0.04499965161085129, -0.07610898464918137, 0.05192769318819046, -0.019866537302732468, 0.028636470437049866, 0.017736762762069702, 0.016214430332183838, -0.007016841787844896, 0.00031515202135778964, -0.04290132224559784, 0.06541135907173157, -0.00700796116143465, 0.004103317856788635, 0.04969869554042816, -0.02232399582862854, 0.005437539890408516, -0.03458692505955696, -0.0022832925897091627, -0.008177694864571095, 0.06378122419118881, 0.017551742494106293, -0.055909231305122375, -0.031876031309366226, -0.025269150733947754, -0.021473225206136703, 0.008984130807220936, -0.0094221206381917, -0.03787492215633392, 0.05790103226900101, 0.023985611274838448, -0.04214470088481903, -0.022008655592799187, -0.03525213524699211, -0.05854547396302223, -0.06565393507480621, -0.029001351445913315, -0.03762930631637573, 0.019668983295559883, 0.0024826847948133945, 0.04748804494738579, -0.005087628029286861, 0.0417424701154232, 0.0007978107896633446, 0.006516018882393837, -0.027461916208267212, 0.034128133207559586, -0.061295900493860245, 0.0701821893453598, 0.03943729028105736, -0.0277270320802927, -0.03353964164853096, 0.005217628553509712, -0.022045794874429703, -0.01345088891685009, 0.026585044339299202, -0.027195727452635765, -0.006244052667170763, -0.06838627904653549, -0.034326814115047455, -0.011669793166220188, 0.00072575913509354, 0.010627040639519691, -0.009032969363033772, 0.01251653116196394, -0.02050381526350975, -0.04428820312023163 ]
In the field of speaker verification, session or channel variability poses a significant challenge. While many contemporary methods aim to disentangle session information from speaker embeddings, we introduce a novel approach using an additional embedding to represent the session information. This is achieved by training an auxiliary network appended to the speaker embedding extractor which remains fixed in this training process. This results in two similarity scores: one for the speakers information and one for the session information. The latter score acts as a compensator for the former that might be skewed due to session variations. Our extensive experiments demonstrate that session information can be effectively compensated without retraining of the embedding extractor.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14741v1
[ -0.01550766546279192, -0.004200355615466833, 0.016121141612529755, -0.02144506759941578, 0.00010225222649751231, 0.002109549241140485, -0.013349703513085842, 0.013311315327882767, -0.0012905787443742156, -0.021063867956399918, -0.00675218878313899, 0.011684550903737545, -0.05286119878292084, -0.07703150808811188, -0.02617388404905796, 0.020456133410334587, 0.0830196812748909, 0.008033809252083302, -0.03415632247924805, 0.01375884935259819, -0.04451781138777733, 0.020213497802615166, 0.003385798307135701, 0.03165276721119881, -0.005793548189103603, -0.044866155833005905, -0.02920498140156269, 0.019237888976931572, -0.037227410823106766, -0.007049095816910267, 0.05116146057844162, -0.04151197522878647, -0.049882158637046814, 0.022449340671300888, -0.043375466018915176, -0.02764933742582798, -0.010632858611643314, 0.03493938222527504, -0.006595435552299023, -0.028807152062654495, 0.019184228032827377, -0.07163166254758835, -0.06302142888307571, 0.008624030277132988, -0.026994958519935608, -0.026265230029821396, 0.035301025956869125, -0.012131430208683014, -0.07344451546669006, 0.004767902661114931, 0.023141639307141304, 0.01394057460129261, -0.025342093780636787, -0.002781808376312256, 0.005804874002933502, -0.02862321212887764, 0.006388747598975897, 0.008265616372227669, -0.08079035580158234, -0.03931497409939766, 0.02027115784585476, -0.038241349160671234, -0.012492080219089985, 0.0002988227643072605, -0.027894292026758194, 0.04198576137423515, -0.0060259620659053326, -0.08126268535852432, -0.04298356547951698, -0.022985385730862617, 0.03682766854763031, -0.06953912228345871, 0.015819020569324493, 0.03201182186603546, -0.037971608340740204, 0.002492038533091545, -0.007213229313492775, -0.05277983471751213, -0.006089428905397654, 0.022326184436678886, -0.03924557939171791, 0.03348041698336601, 0.006990639492869377, 0.02960517629981041, -0.01328432559967041, -0.00020244055485818535, 0.03786975517868996, 0.005358867812901735, 0.03796500340104103, -0.04357641562819481, 0.006275840103626251, -0.05186767503619194, -0.08767902851104736, -0.020034929737448692, 0.07333287596702576, -0.042387768626213074, 0.030103445053100586, 0.0008707822998985648, -0.02172224037349224, 0.03458758071064949, 0.015349453315138817, -0.0027011537458747625, -0.017465122044086456, 0.031144285574555397, 0.0066511789336800575, -0.04984929785132408, 0.012552923522889614, -0.013222763314843178, -0.05473136156797409, 0.06847576051950455, -0.007482931017875671, 0.013794253580272198, 0.02367353066802025, -0.08405168354511261, 0.0018561757169663906, -0.0048976438120007515, 0.025465890765190125, 0.02000495418906212, 0.024451348930597305, -0.051328834146261215, -0.005822926294058561, 0.05449923127889633, 0.045890334993600845, -0.012407295405864716, -0.039258599281311035, -0.02350219339132309, 0.03349193558096886, 0.02785027213394642, -0.006013530306518078, -0.020187251269817352, -0.04152500256896019, 0.03924357891082764, -0.017749404534697533, -0.0001489275455242023, 0.05644358694553375, 0.01955648884177208, 0.012539754621684551, -0.04785715043544769, 0.0002812572638504207, 0.011240191757678986, -0.01590784266591072, -0.0881851390004158, 0.02740752510726452, -0.02699960023164749, 0.043303146958351135, 0.017326978966593742, -0.06542902439832687, -0.006404043175280094, -0.0026629006024450064, 0.022919366136193275, 0.0010645703878253698, 0.02314595691859722, 0.05880966782569885, 0.010063464753329754, -0.022165942937135696, -0.02670860104262829, 0.05902579426765442, -0.006769335363060236, -0.06451650708913803, 0.040723446756601334, 0.0018510371446609497, 0.02663656324148178, -0.020880237221717834, -0.03946053609251976, 0.030049152672290802, -0.019350608810782433, 0.02689618058502674, 0.022077782079577446, -0.010911175981163979, 0.019794659689068794, -0.03944443166255951, 0.036673303693532944, -0.01308633852750063, -0.0011651624226942658, -0.014779835008084774, -0.003560706740245223, 0.011908355168998241, -0.008102201856672764, -0.024350279942154884, 0.019573304802179337, -0.032487813383340836, 0.040042441338300705, -0.03237314894795418, -0.03246929496526718, -0.04297764599323273, 0.0014515790389850736, -0.09079011529684067, 0.008714980445802212, 0.05067974701523781, 0.004903205204755068, -0.03690560162067413, -0.03152468055486679, -0.01280145812779665, 0.024443399161100388, -0.0031199986115098, -0.012888406403362751, 0.01058561448007822, -0.0007172899204306304, 0.019383007660508156, 0.07398874312639236, -0.0853893980383873, -0.028083791956305504, -0.07904745638370514, 0.009367197751998901, -0.027399679645895958, -0.05287545546889305, -0.024181194603443146, 0.01873445138335228, -0.05244721844792366, 0.003967662341892719, 0.051984988152980804, 0.062452733516693115, 0.030305057764053345, 0.00589391216635704, 0.02297351323068142, 0.0006899806903675199, -0.1138174831867218, 0.03531938046216965, 0.0004099875222891569, 0.010122534818947315, 0.0008206737693399191, 0.049769043922424316, -0.010499777272343636, -0.017384598031640053, -0.005959009751677513, 0.04184770956635475, 0.02215719036757946, -0.010400762781500816, -0.06509841233491898, -0.026233907788991928, -0.01933917962014675, -0.031722985208034515, -0.020640717819333076, -0.07845362275838852, -0.02469337359070778, -0.005386571865528822, -0.015665283426642418, -0.009430425241589546, 0.03456142917275429, -0.02647046558558941, -0.06155798211693764, -0.04885543882846832, 0.0618603378534317, -0.00790223479270935, -0.03780597448348999, -0.04577990621328354, 0.004891912918537855, 0.05014049634337425, 0.015933936461806297, -0.003971380647271872, 0.006733336951583624, -0.07393563538789749, -0.007691018749028444, -0.0010397633304819465, 0.025389716029167175, 0.028673561289906502, -0.05233696475625038, 0.0064828707836568356, 0.008391326293349266, 0.04604487493634224, -0.00921743456274271, 0.029229186475276947, -0.05702929571270943, 0.022866809740662575, 0.04644520580768585, -0.03555522859096527, 0.0009179346961900592, -0.022921660915017128, 0.0101520586758852, -0.02555657923221588, -0.028468893840909004, 0.05152156576514244, 0.036572981625795364, 0.002214627806097269, 0.014610841870307922, -0.07731223851442337, 0.03763426095247269, -0.009732161648571491, 0.0191060658544302, 0.05234600231051445, 0.020138168707489967, 0.03582156449556351, 0.03084149956703186, -0.06612487882375717, 0.034357693046331406, -0.06864854693412781, -0.025730665773153305, -0.05705789849162102, -0.06301730126142502, -0.025490347295999527, -0.07007870823144913, -0.012181236408650875, -0.03287164494395256, 0.00026016091578640044, -0.03372729942202568, -0.04130001366138458, -0.011654484085738659, -0.005357508081942797, 0.057601261883974075, 0.00900382548570633, -0.04571019485592842, -0.0207192525267601, 0.028228947892785072, -0.00439296942204237, -0.0004613083438016474, -0.04984109103679657, -0.03354039788246155, -0.010283933021128178, 0.032436519861221313, 0.010024482384324074, 0.004277792293578386, 0.01018612366169691, -0.033351391553878784, 0.01589837297797203, -0.00033906204043887556, 0.001569315791130066, -0.021973371505737305, 0.019287483766674995, -0.005974230822175741, -0.05546494573354721, 0.051257915794849396, 0.007775294594466686, -0.04130058363080025, -0.011552046984434128, -0.06066059321165085, -0.009321494027972221, 0.060653265565633774, -0.015044060535728931, -0.060804590582847595, -0.029902158305048943, -0.0009659005445428193, 0.011157259345054626, 0.02355704829096794, -0.05232306569814682, 0.0012134973658248782, 0.06333838403224945, 0.004839939996600151, -0.04280495643615723, -0.020965643227100372, -0.018556857481598854, -0.029817789793014526, 0.03928390145301819, -0.04775259643793106, 0.030382318422198296, 0.008326170034706593, -0.09767443686723709, -0.018057212233543396, 0.04650648683309555, 0.07957793772220612, 0.00041005993261933327, -0.008789065293967724, 0.023099392652511597, -0.014452378265559673, 0.015344593673944473, 0.041428904980421066, -0.03247632458806038, 0.025795280933380127, 0.030459482222795486, -0.05340619385242462, -0.04038318991661072, -0.012205134145915508, -0.04933429881930351, -0.06592129915952682, 0.016325728967785835, 0.020881690084934235, 0.021645640954375267, 0.03642798587679863, -0.04249022156000137, 0.011102085933089256, -0.03844093903899193, 0.056571606546640396, 0.029168030247092247, -0.01666070520877838, 0.017949465662240982, -0.02014574036002159, 0.04566679522395134, -0.0077830166555941105, -0.0031724032014608383, -0.0190306194126606, -0.032803911715745926, 0.05354711040854454, -0.06963944435119629, 0.058184221386909485, 0.020210690796375275, -0.022616319358348846, 0.0057858796790242195, 0.04896589741110802, -0.01214479561895132, 0.032236866652965546, -0.010984516702592373, 0.015629542991518974, 0.014613119885325432, -0.009414752945303917, -0.04619775712490082, -0.028950713574886322, -0.06351792812347412, 0.0028377349954098463, 0.017581211403012276, 0.0032625270541757345, -0.01521600503474474, -0.010709344409406185, -0.003090162994340062, 0.007365802302956581, -0.08897632360458374, 0.009502586908638477, -0.016671888530254364, 0.0751388818025589, 0.013562723062932491, -0.06126086413860321, 0.08889871090650558, -0.013368957675993443, -0.02193824201822281, -0.04707854986190796, 0.01862856186926365, -0.06061355397105217, -0.067904531955719, 0.032537512481212616, -0.06709864735603333, 0.032679516822099686, -0.04454750567674637, 0.04771193489432335, 0.04388346150517464, -0.006312489043921232, -0.04338860139250755, -0.044708214700222015, -0.045679353177547455, 0.043641071766614914, 0.07117006182670593, 0.06077640503644943, -0.017136698588728905, 0.01366035919636488, 0.01965630240738392, 0.004687156993895769, 0.029718317091464996, 0.00005606110789813101, -0.02118293009698391, 0.0243863333016634, -0.00015213909500744194, -0.020559607073664665, 0.007168132346123457, -0.029594717547297478, 0.034297872334718704, -0.049247827380895615, -0.03878157213330269, 0.009678059257566929, 0.006103217136114836, -0.04857799410820007, -0.040635764598846436, -0.0412028543651104, 0.011099092662334442, -0.04260993003845215, -0.024651244282722473, 0.023628385737538338, 0.057729579508304596, -0.000424184458097443, 0.01935505121946335, 0.04787183925509453, 0.051670141518116, -0.012691977433860302, 0.04319331422448158, 0.043352898210287094, 0.00952173862606287, -0.015453504398465157, -0.04573784023523331, -0.06275822967290878, 0.025304336100816727, 0.009783454239368439, 0.002037521917372942, 0.012464763596653938, -0.0067651839926838875, -0.0026172897778451443, 0.03661508485674858, -0.07610709220170975, 0.021515777334570885, 0.08220469951629639, -0.039124745875597, 0.06685252487659454, 0.08526360243558884, 0.006891636643558741, 0.05451016500592232, -0.02355893701314926, -0.002182950731366873, 0.009738356806337833, -0.03060648962855339, 0.02029402367770672, 0.0029579047113656998, -0.03259781002998352, -0.018818657845258713, 0.043253976851701736, 0.026488792151212692, -0.02234848402440548, 0.027272891253232956, 0.06593816727399826, 0.029177550226449966, 0.01162088941782713, 0.013070597313344479, 0.010372244752943516, -0.06153819337487221, -0.027192693203687668, 0.012566659599542618, -0.036461241543293, 0.017933381721377373, 0.03844321519136429, -0.007743183057755232, -0.028034048154950142, 0.030284062027931213, -0.010363667272031307, 0.02328827604651451, 0.05972013995051384, -0.005725208669900894, -0.021685777232050896, -0.026056956499814987, -0.0067749046720564365, -0.0029556595254689455, 0.02270377427339554, -0.010412064380943775, 0.05764031782746315, 0.017155978828668594, 0.025835737586021423, 0.024519409984350204, 0.014290353283286095, -0.04256187751889229, -0.04470261186361313, 0.003031882457435131, -0.02227982133626938, 0.036024510860443115, 0.013499584048986435, 0.0477030947804451, -0.036712344735860825, 0.006423824466764927, 0.024247480556368828, 0.04074066877365112, -0.05022597312927246, 0.05764253810048103, -0.01068166084587574, 0.04177375137805939, 0.05930544063448906, 0.015137569978833199, -0.0465310700237751, -0.003938276786357164, 0.004805529024451971, -0.030228806659579277, 0.040360815823078156, 0.039864588528871536, -0.017438750714063644, -0.01671006716787815, -0.009233017452061176, -0.032594215124845505, -0.021150413900613785, 0.03860494866967201, 0.06916909664869308, -0.05264531821012497, 0.010224828496575356, -0.021219981834292412, -0.0015059863217175007, 0.053500983864068985, -0.009490689262747765, -0.02294657938182354, 0.032068416476249695, -0.03099994733929634, -0.03314252197742462, 0.06594224274158478, -0.014673889614641666, -0.07339698076248169, -0.020518653094768524, -0.028347082436084747, -0.0869341790676117, -0.034754008054733276, 0.009735374711453915, 0.02225089631974697, -0.01412192452698946, 0.03449980169534683, 0.011015611700713634, 0.0015838217223063111, -0.060465771704912186, 0.06468735635280609, 0.06918830424547195, -0.0430537611246109, -0.0529431477189064, -0.004163057077676058, -0.04312891140580177, -0.007276598364114761, -0.017085518687963486, 0.02877054177224636, 0.0027024392038583755, 0.04286341741681099, 0.010308902710676193, -0.06751532852649689, -0.008572014980018139, 0.08597908914089203, -0.043455686420202255, 0.01340768113732338, -0.01244315691292286, -0.004814429674297571, 0.04036205634474754, -0.019422193989157677, -0.05990995466709137, 0.005397853907197714, 0.019332656636834145, 0.024903902783989906, 0.0011060660472139716, -0.015862874686717987, -0.017153123393654823, 0.0438605360686779, 0.006814162712544203, -0.060746174305677414, 0.045294713228940964, 0.02234751731157303, -0.07604964822530746, 0.014696555212140083, -0.07806385308504105, 0.018884701654314995, -0.008084049448370934, 0.022754088044166565, 0.03374607488512993, 0.06909027695655823, -0.009330954402685165, 0.015848271548748016, 0.033701010048389435, 0.012559053488075733, 0.024732809513807297, 0.019684407860040665, -0.022601351141929626, -0.06298405677080154, 0.02918093279004097, -0.032475702464580536, -0.03456671163439751, 0.020110484212636948, -0.05257072672247887, 0.05283670127391815, 0.023429211229085922, -0.014657227322459221, -0.050451815128326416, 0.014700526371598244, -0.02291286550462246, -0.028288213536143303, 0.05475447326898575, -0.04605311155319214, -0.07034722715616226, -0.02509819157421589, -0.0025322381407022476, -0.015045295469462872, 0.03832414746284485, 0.004796893801540136, 0.032309796661138535, -0.005318202544003725, 0.04888176918029785, 0.019768068566918373, -0.017967496067285538, 0.04042085260152817, -0.06634992361068726, -0.017785513773560524, -0.005356638226658106, -0.030440188944339752, -0.0421728678047657, -0.018410345539450645, 0.00927728321403265, -0.026919854804873466, 0.02222876064479351, 0.05633671581745148, -0.008583937771618366, -0.020883966237306595, -0.06177567318081856, 0.04204929247498512, 0.032431259751319885, -0.04634449630975723, -0.025702375918626785, 0.015324024483561516, 0.005297044757753611, -0.0025672016199678183, -0.035190556198358536, -0.007929813116788864, -0.029153378680348396, -0.050995681434869766, -0.07995922863483429, -0.012239882722496986, 0.008050584234297276, 0.02514568530023098, -0.03715746849775314, 0.021237336099147797, 0.02098815143108368, -0.025560444220900536, 0.030138729140162468, -0.04544747248291969, 0.02575000561773777, 0.004201532807201147, 0.03091609664261341, -0.009897829964756966, -0.06349962204694748, -0.02828993834555149, 0.03615042567253113, -0.010207969695329666, -0.01684359647333622, 0.013314733281731606, 0.066759392619133, 0.0017278239829465747, 0.005705767311155796, 0.04236259311437607, -0.0015816662926226854, 0.060219090431928635, -0.077909454703331, 0.019244873896241188, 0.003975467756390572, -0.045463450253009796, 0.035748645663261414, -0.02381639927625656, -0.03607192635536194, 0.05660397186875343, -0.04965835437178612, -0.027968576177954674, -0.05376739799976349, -0.015392797067761421, -0.005713851656764746, -0.030491486191749573, -0.040237318724393845, 0.029528670012950897, 0.0191730335354805, -0.04770682007074356, -0.02755746990442276, 0.023887431249022484, -0.045310650020837784, 0.04005369171500206, 0.024722013622522354, -0.023692823946475983, -0.005212096497416496, -0.04941699653863907, 0.019297000020742416, -0.026077963411808014, -0.0028447892982512712, -0.010724006220698357, 0.042736079543828964, 0.003494909731671214, -0.03652290254831314, -0.015667492523789406, -0.004585596267133951, -0.006960959639400244, -0.09909111261367798, -0.0368860587477684, -0.022823208943009377, 0.009200728498399258, 0.01661243662238121, 0.019662946462631226, 0.01380909699946642, 0.0191340371966362, 0.0013974043540656567, 0.019504766911268234, 0.0037632386665791273, 0.039333853870630264, -0.05448416247963905, 0.06864845752716064, 0.0036907722242176533, 0.01881762221455574, -0.04709835723042488, 0.042680419981479645, -0.01598287932574749, -0.0074137006886303425, 0.010764945298433304, -0.003068581223487854, 0.020959533751010895, -0.0766228511929512, 0.0006379270926117897, 0.06734415888786316, -0.010273615829646587, -0.031408537179231644, -0.028307750821113586, 0.018574435263872147, -0.053283315151929855, -0.011418313719332218 ]
We propose an unsupervised deep learning algorithm for the motion-compensated reconstruction of 5D cardiac MRI data from 3D radial acquisitions. Ungated free-breathing 5D MRI simplifies the scan planning, improves patient comfort, and offers several clinical benefits over breath-held 2D exams, including isotropic spatial resolution and the ability to reslice the data to arbitrary views. However, the current reconstruction algorithms for 5D MRI take very long computational time, and their outcome is greatly dependent on the uniformity of the binning of the acquired data into different physiological phases. The proposed algorithm is a more data-efficient alternative to current motion-resolved reconstructions. This motion-compensated approach models the data in each cardiac/respiratory bin as Fourier samples of the deformed version of a 3D image template. The deformation maps are modeled by a convolutional neural network driven by the physiological phase information. The deformation maps and the template are then jointly estimated from the measured data. The cardiac and respiratory phases are estimated from 1D navigators using an auto-encoder. The proposed algorithm is validated on 5D bSSFP datasets acquired from two subjects.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04552v1
[ -0.02664787322282791, 0.0006503580952994525, 0.03702537715435028, 0.04260231554508209, -0.05167791247367859, -0.020339475944638252, 0.03684496134519577, 0.012908762320876122, -0.022728562355041504, -0.04008493945002556, -0.05331811681389809, 0.009499824605882168, -0.023440925404429436, -0.00687154708430171, -0.032489463686943054, 0.051569726318120956, 0.05983877182006836, 0.012796731665730476, -0.04328911751508713, 0.06083768606185913, 0.05477902665734291, 0.014037858694791794, -0.024645879864692688, 0.0385843850672245, 0.01254948042333126, -0.032018475234508514, -0.027871588245034218, 0.019191961735486984, -0.06436557322740555, -0.032219383865594864, 0.0659901574254036, -0.06493066996335983, 0.01510070264339447, -0.04810032248497009, -0.05452709645032883, 0.004269147291779518, -0.01983002759516239, 0.04066942632198334, -0.006214742548763752, -0.048686668276786804, 0.04263613000512123, -0.05663176625967026, -0.06085444614291191, -0.021268950775265694, -0.020092608407139778, 0.010669729672372341, -0.06878865510225296, -0.005272772628813982, -0.05338003858923912, -0.01727992482483387, 0.035220012068748474, -0.023714931681752205, 0.02956381067633629, 0.04381342977285385, -0.06308364868164062, 0.014637444168329239, -0.03939472511410713, 0.03616689145565033, -0.060750074684619904, -0.01067969761788845, 0.04368659108877182, 0.006117089185863733, 0.0029634665697813034, -0.031026078388094902, 0.0058036306872963905, 0.06735825538635254, -0.03162192180752754, -0.06797527521848679, -0.044599421322345734, -0.058353178203105927, 0.051588159054517746, -0.06294575333595276, 0.0346420593559742, 0.03882789611816406, -0.04660092294216156, -0.020290983840823174, -0.00270089041441679, 0.0013266424648463726, -0.0020306755322963, -0.009006086736917496, -0.029703862965106964, 0.014561761170625687, -0.00775673845782876, 0.05759583041071892, 0.010410170070827007, -0.03364872932434082, 0.059270162135362625, -0.024864375591278076, 0.027985762804746628, -0.04234602674841881, 0.028126558288931847, -0.06254667788743973, -0.032465074211359024, 0.027905691415071487, 0.03936676308512688, -0.046870309859514236, 0.032786931842565536, 0.036464840173721313, 0.03055410645902157, 0.011373554356396198, -0.0009028465137816966, 0.041697438806295395, 0.007937907241284847, 0.054017968475818634, 0.024537183344364166, -0.033030916005373, -0.013079370371997356, -0.017755938693881035, -0.05943438410758972, 0.0010050662094727159, -0.02751283533871174, -0.043862223625183105, 0.007566092535853386, 0.0001786319335224107, -0.03503203019499779, -0.03762202709913254, 0.04919803515076637, -0.02033497393131256, 0.04916735738515854, 0.034693408757448196, -0.039066512137651443, 0.0007421697373501956, 0.010854545049369335, -0.006326278671622276, 0.008343650959432125, 0.011802426539361477, 0.07704957574605942, 0.004377696663141251, -0.047785066068172455, -0.05821642652153969, -0.012120547704398632, 0.036332059651613235, -0.04137830436229706, -0.01614869013428688, 0.02651226334273815, 0.021065237000584602, -0.03610697016119957, -0.058698032051324844, 0.01204641629010439, 0.015284541994333267, -0.024360835552215576, -0.0760122612118721, -0.012976492755115032, -0.032014571130275726, -0.035273756831884384, 0.0403742790222168, -0.07088349014520645, 0.0029990016482770443, 0.04553432762622833, -0.012726872228085995, -0.027017487213015556, 0.003362938528880477, 0.03366537764668465, 0.037044163793325424, -0.015927240252494812, -0.0008849273435771465, 0.06978939473628998, -0.02077619358897209, -0.036420755088329315, 0.0036093827802687883, 0.03413493186235428, -0.051706284284591675, 0.037689562886953354, -0.02450612373650074, 0.019517943263053894, -0.014231972396373749, 0.05235881358385086, 0.009308187291026115, -0.020037317648530006, -0.002502413932234049, -0.048223771154880524, -0.054584842175245285, 0.011936255730688572, -0.01512825582176447, -0.04351097717881203, -0.031879764050245285, 0.030223490670323372, -0.04630951210856438, -0.06084837019443512, -0.017728416249155998, -0.022652991116046906, 0.04110521078109741, -0.0011208625510334969, -0.0013065565144643188, -0.06849714368581772, -0.033237751573324203, -0.08139270544052124, -0.02668757736682892, 0.031777285039424896, 0.023411313071846962, -0.05719265341758728, -0.037469420582056046, -0.0048238858580589294, 0.011016001924872398, -0.04816180840134621, -0.021840237081050873, -0.03431778773665428, -0.0386870838701725, -0.020304959267377853, 0.03684854507446289, -0.07713633030653, -0.058269862085580826, -0.05876543000340462, -0.010187451727688313, 0.013703757897019386, -0.05791632458567619, -0.013807432726025581, 0.019493643194437027, -0.033598799258470535, 0.0022113958839327097, 0.04061681777238846, 0.03263556584715843, 0.05308794230222702, -0.003907579928636551, 0.04357461631298065, 0.00946386530995369, -0.08701791614294052, 0.06706468760967255, -0.060168344527482986, 0.01403945591300726, 0.03632894903421402, 0.03219811990857124, -0.01059904508292675, -0.026030661538243294, -0.030011802911758423, 0.03407914191484451, 0.049642398953437805, -0.006422128994017839, -0.06675923615694046, -0.051388468593358994, -0.011721121147274971, -0.068649061024189, -0.04702719300985336, -0.06939223408699036, -0.032597724348306656, 0.027012959122657776, -0.013893106020987034, 0.018380746245384216, 0.02058088779449463, -0.02008155547082424, -0.029280101880431175, -0.005952577572315931, 0.040367159992456436, -0.02316436730325222, -0.04239752143621445, -0.01962491311132908, -0.022769249975681305, 0.04139232262969017, -0.007298297714442015, -0.030683979392051697, -0.022946195676922798, -0.05286381021142006, -0.021972665563225746, -0.015468303114175797, 0.04156910255551338, 0.04225046560168266, -0.0245676226913929, 0.011403480544686317, -0.05164604261517525, 0.035919249057769775, -0.007928892970085144, 0.046300262212753296, -0.07744547724723816, 0.024173559620976448, 0.012969800271093845, 0.0028932506684213877, -0.0101327421143651, -0.01466415822505951, 0.04470803216099739, -0.011744922026991844, -0.013490583747625351, 0.024399006739258766, 0.015390652231872082, -0.04890207201242447, 0.010625869035720825, 0.012186376377940178, 0.004059917759150267, -0.05747159197926521, 0.030104469507932663, 0.022058075293898582, 0.012615516781806946, 0.0284317284822464, 0.03592674434185028, -0.06872402876615524, -0.007418136112391949, -0.07677547633647919, 0.024244677275419235, -0.03824182227253914, -0.05962415039539337, -0.021691689267754555, -0.07336845248937607, -0.032023608684539795, -0.04496493563055992, -0.014271847903728485, 0.0014383792877197266, -0.044355154037475586, -0.04296397045254707, -0.035925932228565216, 0.04310787469148636, 0.02690463699400425, -0.06086048483848572, -0.02891155332326889, 0.016865350306034088, 0.02763322927057743, -0.020080681890249252, -0.04323563352227211, -0.05057157203555107, 0.036459121853113174, -0.0031921856570988894, 0.024390894919633865, -0.01786789670586586, 0.05786200612783432, -0.037559740245342255, -0.02552567981183529, 0.04369282349944115, 0.026263199746608734, 0.018118707463145256, -0.006685307715088129, -0.008335311897099018, 0.00008589976641815156, 0.04121457785367966, -0.01256551779806614, 0.019270943477749825, -0.026524217799305916, -0.06583888083696365, -0.02306331694126129, 0.01176782138645649, 0.05408801510930061, -0.027654526755213737, 0.005942650604993105, -0.014476137235760689, -0.034590717405080795, -0.0071652913466095924, -0.005281016696244478, 0.06274799257516861, -0.01161415595561266, 0.02150893770158291, -0.022084001451730728, -0.02738574519753456, 0.003312478307634592, -0.03524874523282051, 0.01960802637040615, -0.03883516788482666, -0.0006500373710878193, 0.03929045423865318, -0.07204610854387283, -0.011354571208357811, -0.011331195943057537, 0.0584903247654438, -0.00008751490531722084, -0.0033019615802913904, -0.010605190880596638, 0.006692060735076666, 0.01424561720341444, -0.013761120848357677, 0.010232551954686642, -0.009152733720839024, 0.05280610918998718, -0.03457312658429146, -0.06733350455760956, -0.01233666855841875, -0.06835101544857025, -0.06342438608407974, 0.025664404034614563, 0.05010587349534035, 0.005395572166889906, 0.04702422767877579, -0.05209120362997055, 0.027164114639163017, -0.05704902112483978, 0.02149868570268154, 0.00819290243089199, -0.006718447431921959, 0.03783354163169861, -0.03507844731211662, 0.010671955533325672, 0.022745225578546524, -0.011374499648809433, -0.00488161901012063, -0.034229204058647156, 0.048726823180913925, -0.046074267476797104, 0.0376431979238987, 0.009057815186679363, -0.014311978593468666, 0.0314696729183197, 0.035929325968027115, -0.022194987162947655, 0.02626815438270569, -0.017218198627233505, -0.011425085365772247, -0.050185173749923706, -0.026741066947579384, -0.038990568369627, -0.010898998938500881, -0.0722503513097763, 0.013395724818110466, 0.0006759990938007832, 0.02481524832546711, -0.03333093225955963, -0.03607321158051491, -0.02741040289402008, -0.03670346364378929, -0.07555718719959259, -0.0051654307171702385, -0.038783472031354904, 0.03322237730026245, -0.015267398208379745, -0.059864796698093414, 0.06409177929162979, -0.003007161431014538, 0.0031977270264178514, -0.019186867401003838, -0.044765930622816086, -0.044943761080503464, -0.018558382987976074, 0.036037810146808624, -0.0770614817738533, 0.023297343403100967, -0.049757469445466995, 0.04472102224826813, -0.004117886535823345, -0.017009364441037178, -0.06379380077123642, -0.05240746587514877, -0.04107034578919411, 0.00816122256219387, 0.037407372146844864, -0.02264564484357834, -0.022225094959139824, 0.017143044620752335, -0.02797047235071659, -0.0001277192641282454, 0.0062413341365754604, 0.026258613914251328, -0.04771764948964119, 0.02193346433341503, -0.0192779079079628, -0.043313171714544296, -0.026538869366049767, -0.010633918456733227, 0.05697149410843849, -0.01519853062927723, -0.003542040940374136, -0.034632790833711624, -0.012439100071787834, -0.032415036112070084, -0.03351987525820732, -0.043842218816280365, -0.05395500734448433, -0.04507942870259285, -0.003330439329147339, -0.004307368770241737, 0.004490434657782316, 0.029087170958518982, 0.031048577278852463, 0.03491951525211334, -0.014453878626227379, -0.04805026575922966, 0.03750893846154213, 0.010151328518986702, 0.01372545212507248, -0.028260281309485435, -0.033863235265016556, -0.07278399914503098, -0.02510553039610386, -0.047178369015455246, -0.025665855035185814, -0.005717102903872728, 0.02595466747879982, 0.05648524686694145, 0.038347575813531876, -0.06601542979478836, 0.06542383134365082, 0.03897786885499954, -0.025869257748126984, 0.021009743213653564, 0.06440961360931396, 0.001043864176608622, 0.05067789927124977, -0.014336861670017242, 0.035744521766901016, 0.0076958611607551575, -0.053985852748155594, -0.03222188726067543, -0.014855554327368736, 0.020680900663137436, 0.0025700940750539303, 0.05922120809555054, -0.029882363975048065, -0.04439255967736244, -0.00947814341634512, 0.0018824124708771706, -0.015863852575421333, -0.030416544526815414, 0.02855583094060421, 0.01093082595616579, -0.020517513155937195, -0.03803108260035515, -0.004751917440444231, -0.017136625945568085, -0.017420083284378052, 0.028075706213712692, -0.024863189086318016, 0.03039989434182644, 0.05846835672855377, -0.018420834094285965, -0.008846445940434933, 0.032806407660245895, -0.001229150453582406, 0.006689917761832476, 0.022149989381432533, 0.02824610285460949, -0.03230558708310127, -0.04597736522555351, -0.04353921115398407, 0.020710980519652367, 0.04199069365859032, 0.0571708008646965, 0.01825081743299961, 0.01149166189134121, -0.03349091112613678, 0.0037134122103452682, 0.012332943268120289, 0.023693956434726715, 0.04493642598390579, -0.05113182216882706, 0.02622280642390251, -0.002383610000833869, 0.04199235886335373, 0.007974919863045216, 0.019898442551493645, 0.07208791375160217, -0.03889111056923866, -0.013161169365048409, -0.053022775799036026, 0.02401309460401535, -0.047377921640872955, -0.07420388609170914, 0.0021548978984355927, 0.04323246330022812, -0.02942485548555851, 0.011226074770092964, 0.027932947501540184, -0.006433133501559496, 0.0032890071161091328, -0.020445913076400757, -0.009698121808469296, -0.029379798099398613, 0.027158010751008987, 0.06527328491210938, -0.041468918323516846, -0.005661300383508205, -0.00036332174204289913, -0.017500992864370346, -0.047547757625579834, -0.0375322587788105, 0.06486950814723969, 0.009888733737170696, -0.038591623306274414, -0.06251754611730576, 0.05709398165345192, 0.03132392093539238, -0.061792485415935516, 0.031279124319553375, 0.01143849641084671, -0.06225388124585152, 0.006500567775219679, 0.021529216319322586, 0.0014185080071911216, -0.06227264553308487, 0.03616207838058472, -0.017814425751566887, -0.023017052561044693, -0.06739328056573868, 0.0616111122071743, 0.06017247214913368, 0.003634811844676733, -0.0013522085500881076, 0.012146460823714733, -0.045515164732933044, 0.03904154896736145, -0.05910682678222656, 0.009820051491260529, -0.013948152773082256, 0.007803389802575111, -0.006700802594423294, -0.05093365162611008, -0.05725695565342903, 0.05912820249795914, -0.035672884434461594, -0.00812049675732851, 0.04945526272058487, -0.011030576191842556, 0.01961725391447544, -0.06642330437898636, -0.02737410180270672, -0.0019137513590976596, -0.03900282829999924, 0.012897120788693428, 0.006749286316335201, -0.0004986466374248266, -0.00003901983654941432, 0.0361001119017601, 0.015140379779040813, -0.01057539414614439, -0.024011334404349327, -0.03495530039072037, -0.04939526319503784, 0.04496750608086586, -0.0680398941040039, 0.004878329578787088, -0.046014878898859024, -0.0030572465620934963, 0.033396005630493164, 0.0537554956972599, -0.06055930629372597, -0.0039017314556986094, 0.0119657963514328, 0.0381048358976841, -0.03679519519209862, -0.03875887021422386, 0.029646459966897964, -0.04287274554371834, 0.05626227706670761, 0.004800315946340561, -0.030811576172709465, -0.007826215587556362, -0.05307016894221306, -0.016164345666766167, 0.007690761238336563, -0.05147049203515053, -0.042138904333114624, -0.00744866905733943, -0.036515217274427414, -0.010245941579341888, 0.04461287707090378, -0.0730757936835289, -0.045319970697164536, -0.003971134312450886, -0.06029703468084335, -0.00466126250103116, 0.017109151929616928, 0.009713703766465187, 0.022943688556551933, -0.023898934945464134, -0.0049704499542713165, -0.0044148750603199005, -0.030829597264528275, -0.00010661395936040208, -0.07705386728048325, -0.04156353324651718, -0.021945850923657417, 0.013805853202939034, -0.036924879997968674, -0.03751147910952568, -0.006159118376672268, -0.06295695900917053, 0.06014365330338478, 0.038328867405653, 0.017940284684300423, 0.022829115390777588, -0.06424778699874878, -0.01760714501142502, 0.001642889343202114, 0.01519766729325056, -0.06338034570217133, -0.02240832895040512, -0.004230149555951357, -0.016977393999695778, -0.015282992273569107, 0.021264666691422462, -0.018519548699259758, 0.008711819536983967, -0.08000992238521576, -0.01485805120319128, 0.0008879865636117756, 0.06348108500242233, -0.03046474978327751, -0.06378031522035599, 0.026639454066753387, -0.06157946586608887, -0.050373055040836334, -0.00004846822776016779, 0.020147264003753662, -0.04026804119348526, 0.05041264742612839, 0.005596861708909273, -0.08075419813394547, -0.03244134783744812, 0.011168520897626877, -0.008343498222529888, 0.009432896971702576, 0.02282799407839775, 0.03525174781680107, 0.011892536655068398, -0.016476154327392578, 0.03213624283671379, 0.015770940110087395, 0.006629944313317537, -0.021826252341270447, 0.000500258756801486, -0.015416628681123257, -0.05278560146689415, -0.0171651691198349, -0.04762226715683937, -0.027829153463244438, -0.0030816385988146067, 0.0043368348851799965, -0.021053263917565346, -0.041248951107263565, -0.06410636007785797, 0.030223287642002106, 0.004722648300230503, 0.027940936386585236, 0.04581586644053459, -0.029091551899909973, -0.032621245831251144, -0.019615713506937027, -0.021493395790457726, -0.03592030704021454, -0.038610659539699554, -0.0013459918554872274, -0.05291673168540001, 0.021721763536334038, -0.04149095341563225, -0.000562448927666992, -0.006985053885728121, -0.01639571413397789, -0.0508129820227623, 0.07106731086969376, -0.008383868262171745, -0.03046758845448494, -0.03517614305019379, -0.036250289529561996, 0.011401786468923092, -0.034508369863033295, -0.03506863862276077, -0.026052437722682953, 0.021892940625548363, -0.06137470155954361, 0.04412223771214485, 0.010684370063245296, 0.05206763744354248, 0.040496498346328735, 0.00983204785734415, -0.026118865236639977, -0.03714729845523834, -0.030826833099126816, 0.031435731798410416, -0.0375446155667305, -0.02790355682373047, -0.038241494446992874, -0.011860852129757404, -0.033703241497278214, 0.029009811580181122, 0.006800523493438959, 0.021609608083963394, 0.004216789733618498, -0.07634143531322479, -0.008185669779777527, 0.004951551556587219, -0.0224232729524374, -0.02030411921441555, -0.039760831743478775, -0.03833834081888199, -0.013567342422902584, -0.05842342600226402 ]
The influence of the gravitational fields of pulsars and magnetars on the arion emission during the propagation of magnetodipole waves in a constant magnetic field has been evaluated. The solution of the equation was obtained and the flux of arions emitted by magnetodipole waves during their propagation in a constant magnetic field was found. It is shown that the amplitude of the born arion wave at a distance from the source of magnetodipole radiation of a pulsar or magnetar $(r\to\infty)$ in the considered case tends to a constant value. The intensity of the arion emission in the solid angle element and the amount of arion energy $\overline{I}$, emitted in all directions per unit time grow quadratically with increasing distance, traveled by the magnetodipole radiation of a pulsar or magnetar in a constant magnetic field. Such growth of the energy of the born arion wave is due to the fact that in the considered problem constant magnetic field is defined in the whole space. In reality, the galactic and intergalactic magnetic fields can be represented in this form only in regions of space of finite dimensions, outside of which the force lines of their induction vector are curved. Therefore, it is possible to apply these results only in a region of space for which $r\leq L_{coh}<\infty$, where $L_{coh}$ is the coherence length, the distance at which the force lines of the induction vector can be considered as straight lines. An estimate for the value of the coupling constant of photons with arions is obtained.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07073v1
[ -0.027634695172309875, -0.03046152926981449, 0.008623153902590275, -0.003274782793596387, -0.028695156797766685, 0.039489470422267914, -0.01592913083732128, 0.022702369838953018, -0.07649246603250504, 0.029062191024422646, -0.016395464539527893, -0.05702874809503555, -0.004509306978434324, -0.060874637216329575, -0.02681598626077175, -0.020380912348628044, 0.06564325839281082, 0.020519711077213287, -0.06305402517318726, 0.03692037612199783, -0.013891402631998062, -0.014234085567295551, -0.002407512627542019, 0.05364292114973068, 0.01811748370528221, -0.04448468238115311, -0.008400501683354378, 0.01642606034874916, -0.05944815278053284, -0.01435218844562769, 0.058233510702848434, -0.032519228756427765, 0.013421036303043365, 0.007889370433986187, -0.019845766946673393, 0.013965857215225697, -0.002463990356773138, 0.033543121069669724, 0.027025900781154633, -0.0025735143572092056, -0.01902785897254944, -0.06535522639751434, -0.019791200757026672, -0.00943151954561472, -0.060355450958013535, -0.06502784043550491, -0.03693605959415436, 0.006387086119502783, -0.05814450606703758, -0.06708288192749023, 0.004849617835134268, 0.021051086485385895, 0.04280588775873184, 0.05781713128089905, -0.008011828176677227, -0.0012597094755619764, 0.03491197153925896, -0.03745371103286743, -0.011139252223074436, -0.0003809023182839155, -0.03728368878364563, -0.04165844991803169, -0.010165863670408726, 0.0047315750271081924, -0.05266496166586876, 0.02964078262448311, -0.058417998254299164, -0.0428498201072216, 0.004286559764295816, -0.05152418464422226, 0.013758780434727669, -0.06751702725887299, 0.003813273971900344, 0.024783562868833542, -0.07245146483182907, 0.04496843367815018, 0.005568434949964285, 0.004910748917609453, -0.0243015605956316, 0.002070399932563305, -0.001460877712816, -0.030873214825987816, -0.027116606011986732, 0.039104875177145004, 0.02251623198390007, 0.005767435301095247, 0.03284630924463272, -0.011281449347734451, -0.013484152965247631, -0.06390158087015152, 0.03003820963203907, -0.017124373465776443, -0.04523549601435661, -0.028591757640242577, 0.06286081671714783, -0.027740485966205597, 0.05673707649111748, 0.02065204828977585, -0.0007366871577687562, -0.04741298034787178, 0.013925067149102688, -0.04527891054749489, -0.06218995153903961, -0.01360372919589281, -0.03126242756843567, -0.0581379197537899, -0.002602827502414584, -0.025795886293053627, -0.058705199509859085, 0.03754936531186104, 0.015467165969312191, 0.0014555170200765133, -0.040743421763181686, -0.04575469344854355, -0.011899431236088276, -0.0477178581058979, 0.05109898000955582, 0.00336723355576396, 0.018526051193475723, 0.004939025267958641, -0.06539804488420486, 0.025906547904014587, 0.014654883183538914, -0.013772496022284031, -0.017574088647961617, 0.022070644423365593, 0.06609069555997849, 0.002744070254266262, 0.02382379025220871, -0.008572515100240707, -0.014196177944540977, 0.023196766152977943, 0.05504655838012695, -0.029044777154922485, 0.0014497743686661124, 0.04242762178182602, 0.021325718611478806, 0.02426365204155445, 0.009804293513298035, -0.008760051801800728, 0.02608119137585163, -0.014999772422015667, 0.021587181836366653, 0.03262829780578613, -0.023450570181012154, -0.011266641318798065, -0.07280207425355911, -0.01698598638176918, 0.05461277440190315, 0.02616935409605503, -0.007432293612509966, 0.01961171254515648, -0.008866588585078716, -0.023750271648168564, -0.03902646154165268, -0.014982912689447403, 0.06412674486637115, 0.060956425964832306, -0.008608442731201649, -0.019017599523067474, 0.024206532165408134, -0.004595723934471607, -0.03771835193037987, 0.039379268884658813, 0.007873986847698689, 0.02192138507962227, 0.07327111810445786, -0.03893236443400383, -0.005593293812125921, 0.04963509365916252, -0.0548117533326149, 0.05603734776377678, 0.019503677263855934, -0.04749707877635956, -0.03903063014149666, -0.04645007476210594, -0.014937923289835453, -0.018289443105459213, 0.012807224877178669, 0.018621647730469704, 0.0511256642639637, -0.029437227174639702, -0.05862779542803764, 0.008655337616801262, -0.04627152532339096, 0.02666139043867588, -0.06981094181537628, 0.00010058609041152522, 0.037174370139837265, 0.005530416965484619, -0.022711824625730515, -0.06871988624334335, -0.003268925240263343, -0.01637611724436283, 0.007635895628482103, 0.0015434845117852092, -0.030443688854575157, -0.05848110839724541, 0.0031606091652065516, 0.025944426655769348, -0.006436842959374189, -0.037504494190216064, -0.06644903123378754, -0.004872865043580532, 0.02266019769012928, -0.07590354979038239, -0.007217042148113251, -0.010893766768276691, -0.04852452874183655, -0.026829969137907028, 0.040239401161670685, 0.030324406921863556, -0.0083772549405694, 0.008286825381219387, 0.006550717167556286, 0.01003425195813179, -0.08034945279359818, 0.04298695921897888, -0.01314796693623066, -0.015742328017950058, 0.0434412956237793, -0.04161361977458, 0.025888318195939064, 0.013647647574543953, -0.014863120391964912, 0.01605634205043316, 0.03725070878863335, -0.039446890354156494, -0.07520101219415665, -0.03877990320324898, -0.060805510729551315, -0.06928165256977081, -0.059201035648584366, -0.0478181391954422, -0.03168997913599014, -0.018160993233323097, -0.03515556827187538, 0.05154282599687576, -0.03247924521565437, 0.011825294233858585, -0.015766920521855354, 0.03073371760547161, 0.029366500675678253, 0.03172707557678223, -0.04612636938691139, -0.03239421918988228, -0.05574183166027069, 0.025346586480736732, -0.051921628415584564, -0.023547999560832977, -0.00217013549990952, -0.04353073611855507, -0.036657560616731644, 0.03306465968489647, 0.004286215640604496, -0.0018710929434746504, -0.06523440778255463, 0.013075076043605804, 0.0028244496788829565, 0.02536022663116455, 0.014381997287273407, 0.003606625832617283, -0.06509692966938019, 0.014822352677583694, 0.016445735469460487, 0.008441160432994366, -0.07218391448259354, 0.002674420364201069, 0.014401649124920368, -0.02477230131626129, 0.009148582816123962, -0.026096805930137634, 0.0029459460638463497, -0.011883113533258438, 0.008971340022981167, -0.016484001651406288, -0.02773582562804222, 0.016971928998827934, 0.011103655211627483, -0.018099859356880188, 0.04911118745803833, -0.010197898373007774, -0.017862770706415176, -0.06128944829106331, -0.011767398566007614, -0.052549511194229126, -0.021549569442868233, -0.031764738261699677, -0.051355741918087006, -0.03719574213027954, -0.059863388538360596, 0.0032615317031741142, -0.044634927064180374, -0.053606923669576645, -0.01605842635035515, -0.02668972872197628, 0.003248583059757948, -0.002625077962875366, 0.03457317873835564, -0.07254109531641006, -0.04906708374619484, 0.019415080547332764, 0.032972756773233414, -0.023109786212444305, -0.05996372550725937, -0.02377769909799099, -0.040080223232507706, 0.007542043458670378, -0.02383699268102646, 0.0028122125659137964, -0.04213571548461914, 0.010555488057434559, -0.07204461097717285, -0.014320380054414272, -0.014585256576538086, 0.0037481070030480623, 0.04916286841034889, -0.07361073046922684, -0.00947993341833353, -0.03369319066405296, -0.061923883855342865, -0.05396781861782074, 0.039044637233018875, 0.0015882181469351053, -0.052230142056941986, -0.06253112107515335, 0.01065199077129364, 0.07178326696157455, 0.03697538375854492, -0.06254877150058746, -0.06624255329370499, -0.032670531421899796, 0.01222241297364235, 0.03933972865343094, 0.06115994602441788, 0.017086360603570938, -0.0636533573269844, 0.030178532004356384, -0.05640234425663948, 0.02686203643679619, 0.020028522238135338, -0.010195257142186165, -0.004943022038787603, -0.012006641365587711, -0.0024216254241764545, -0.054138172417879105, 0.011092497035861015, 0.014417781494557858, 0.0483025386929512, -0.016330057755112648, -0.004669503308832645, 0.018565593287348747, -0.011542550288140774, 0.03404891490936279, -0.02356141246855259, 0.03743819519877434, -0.002880598185583949, 0.03191106393933296, -0.007890740409493446, -0.05125748738646507, -0.03952114284038544, -0.0640120878815651, -0.029240043833851814, -0.0064124492928385735, 0.0475732795894146, 0.049140628427267075, 0.06619468331336975, 0.035588834434747696, -0.017619114369153976, -0.033761609345674515, 0.04487930238246918, -0.03195808082818985, -0.025048110634088516, 0.025903930887579918, 0.002769122365862131, -0.041027139872312546, -0.0019438619492575526, 0.019931640475988388, -0.028933634981513023, -0.053287994116544724, 0.04483514651656151, -0.0003982158668804914, -0.0025125411339104176, 0.0012799169635400176, 0.017681224271655083, 0.002230247715488076, -0.030661195516586304, -0.00378492777235806, 0.03903273120522499, 0.039235156029462814, -0.021064456552267075, -0.046333588659763336, -0.03653812035918236, 0.0024986397475004196, -0.0014713105047121644, -0.025146739557385445, 0.04129621013998985, 0.02246362902224064, -0.01270485669374466, 0.01662263832986355, 0.03426477685570717, -0.023454593494534492, -0.015180541202425957, -0.07043654471635818, -0.02418595179915428, -0.05949835851788521, 0.05011545494198799, -0.02194111794233322, -0.0011673551052808762, 0.05772015079855919, -0.01699327491223812, -0.002300633117556572, -0.04482265189290047, -0.016863400116562843, -0.022246036678552628, -0.023488372564315796, -0.022610850632190704, -0.03721286728978157, 0.04780920222401619, -0.026672227308154106, 0.057678963989019394, 0.030447404831647873, 0.031672921031713486, -0.050538673996925354, -0.01587674766778946, -0.024372495710849762, 0.030891750007867813, 0.052633482962846756, 0.0579422190785408, 0.025404341518878937, 0.004582646768540144, -0.056089792400598526, 0.003360358066856861, 0.04534568637609482, -0.0012309509329497814, -0.04640538990497589, 0.045971062034368515, -0.05632372573018074, -0.04103309288620949, -0.05453715845942497, -0.0036226226948201656, 0.048144012689590454, -0.06408798694610596, -0.056262534111738205, 0.02997659705579281, 0.010568895377218723, -0.059703584760427475, -0.06867419928312302, -0.0631733238697052, -0.04695259407162666, -0.06841889768838882, 0.043347302824258804, -0.006111349444836378, -0.027295390143990517, 0.013542575761675835, 0.05490080639719963, 0.01472360547631979, 0.060004252940416336, -0.047339264303445816, 0.01619262807071209, 0.012957497499883175, 0.05068136751651764, 0.011285820975899696, -0.0557757206261158, -0.05283036828041077, 0.02457519806921482, 0.00981620978564024, -0.04511215165257454, 0.023014269769191742, 0.016166692599654198, 0.0035174472723156214, 0.015839988365769386, -0.07003668695688248, 0.023023955523967743, 0.029177039861679077, -0.03603237867355347, -0.006862286478281021, 0.011403396725654602, -0.026756642386317253, 0.039271630346775055, -0.002358462894335389, 0.051803458482027054, -0.02855359949171543, -0.018503686413168907, 0.0008542637806385756, -0.008645760826766491, -0.05080719664692879, 0.001524976221844554, 0.022435083985328674, -0.05269579961895943, -0.07354157418012619, 0.008065590634942055, -0.026899736374616623, -0.05587617680430412, -0.028542065992951393, 0.03060247004032135, 0.054025620222091675, -0.0022084610536694527, -0.04062824323773384, -0.0035948168952018023, -0.012860341928899288, -0.01609288714826107, 0.05756426602602005, -0.03344095125794411, -0.01746905967593193, -0.010184341110289097, 0.004506432916969061, -0.0017935804789885879, 0.0037322500720620155, 0.05368919298052788, 0.001597303431481123, -0.018584271892905235, -0.010820280760526657, -0.06108751893043518, 0.008850525133311749, -0.05927247926592827, 0.04205906391143799, 0.004939359612762928, -0.003266663756221533, 0.063372902572155, 0.015101955272257328, -0.008201696909964085, -0.05997367575764656, -0.014498633332550526, 0.018384357914328575, 0.01843447797000408, -0.043439339846372604, 0.02757752127945423, 0.008893422782421112, 0.04052386060357094, -0.023770401254296303, -0.013481098227202892, 0.006089515518397093, -0.04147633910179138, -0.040688831359148026, -0.02328544110059738, -0.013167149387300014, 0.0347871407866478, -0.05305683612823486, -0.01639903336763382, 0.03947586566209793, -0.04521787911653519, 0.0661744475364685, 0.02085592970252037, 0.003567625069990754, 0.04796208068728447, -0.02310057543218136, 0.04793360456824303, -0.056709252297878265, 0.020578796043992043, 0.06403299421072006, -0.049152225255966187, 0.03967658430337906, -0.005272011272609234, -0.04804705083370209, -0.016993403434753418, -0.03835238516330719, -0.026547955349087715, 0.019237257540225983, 0.020339012145996094, -0.006046204827725887, 0.028227753937244415, 0.016873959451913834, -0.0473831407725811, 0.012551303021609783, 0.06009043753147125, -0.059046536684036255, -0.04100188612937927, -0.017653176560997963, -0.04212163761258125, -0.04152241721749306, 0.024729210883378983, -0.0683174654841423, -0.06101050600409508, -0.06924259662628174, 0.05551169067621231, 0.019976843148469925, -0.06204695627093315, 0.033386196941137314, 0.04004907235503197, 0.015043575316667557, 0.0035719473380595446, 0.003779464168474078, 0.0018821441335603595, -0.02463332749903202, 0.02801031619310379, 0.015642719343304634, -0.01132267527282238, 0.014782605692744255, 0.021164199337363243, -0.04657416790723801, -0.02419772744178772, -0.004104752093553543, -0.02919771336019039, 0.05475502461194992, -0.06195315718650818, -0.05937761440873146, 0.00169764191377908, -0.03123665228486061, 0.032029323279857635, -0.002763265511021018, -0.026928622275590897, 0.015370017848908901, 0.050476718693971634, 0.017045484855771065, -0.03213619440793991, 0.00840920303016901, -0.012183326296508312, -0.04460101202130318, 0.02626713551580906, -0.042371075600385666, 0.010760007426142693, 0.010371005162596703, 0.02305961772799492, 0.0027304787654429674, 0.019293155521154404, -0.06558403372764587, -0.03158525377511978, -0.06031002104282379, -0.004777285736054182, 0.03493243455886841, -0.02603290230035782, 0.040473371744155884, -0.006341651547700167, 0.053681906312704086, -0.049969639629125595, -0.0010485752718523145, -0.03508231043815613, -0.016033383086323738, 0.03367947041988373, -0.027478940784931183, -0.054666779935359955, 0.0023322971537709236, -0.004834779072552919, -0.04967089742422104, 0.0329175665974617, 0.03469889238476753, 0.03545597568154335, -0.07014499604701996, -0.018681418150663376, -0.01884373277425766, -0.032314710319042206, 0.03487229719758034, -0.01655023917555809, 0.035748451948165894, -0.006380666978657246, 0.040695495903491974, 0.05698247253894806, 0.008386112749576569, -0.030168285593390465, -0.03532722219824791, 0.01101716235280037, -0.002024314599111676, -0.04573008045554161, 0.0004649418406188488, -0.022681575268507004, -0.06835797429084778, -0.06241946294903755, 0.018202057108283043, 0.004232652019709349, 0.0009941402822732925, -0.008725631982088089, -0.031408607959747314, 0.03370850160717964, 0.0521753765642643, 0.0399186946451664, -0.07816813141107559, -0.053596120327711105, -0.018738364800810814, -0.03846143186092377, 0.023529646918177605, 0.013303615152835846, -0.06404311954975128, 0.024476518854498863, -0.07270745187997818, -0.026553457602858543, -0.040002528578042984, 0.04861386492848396, -0.04419679194688797, 0.017259595915675163, -0.04229212924838066, -0.015643304213881493, 0.007943655364215374, 0.001388941309414804, -0.023101745173335075, 0.054987989366054535, 0.0481511615216732, -0.0345507375895977, -0.0105981370434165, 0.007904867641627789, 0.018506772816181183, -0.017602041363716125, -0.025542106479406357, 0.019389862194657326, 0.0019334421958774328, -0.043818894773721695, 0.03175029903650284, 0.041628893464803696, -0.040373314172029495, -0.011638499796390533, 0.00942644290626049, -0.05389377102255821, -0.03376774117350578, -0.056661415845155716, 0.04356769099831581, -0.03231384605169296, 0.013216733932495117, 0.028418436646461487, -0.03855226933956146, -0.02771344780921936, -0.03509830683469772, -0.040477100759744644, 0.04030287265777588, 0.00951544288545847, -0.046313900500535965, 0.06856707483530045, -0.0554695725440979, -0.030888615176081657, 0.009718774817883968, 0.011714124120771885, -0.04732237383723259, -0.020886287093162537, -0.010985571891069412, -0.06763603538274765, 0.027994304895401, -0.030243121087551117, 0.027243757620453835, -0.06825356185436249, -0.0036143609322607517, 0.03581489250063896, 0.009993663989007473, -0.03626098856329918, -0.025926604866981506, -0.05826412886381149, -0.04219887778162956, 0.028251290321350098, -0.05960770696401596, 0.018041234463453293, 0.00010411812399979681, 0.04374386742711067, -0.016954701393842697, 0.018048318102955818, 0.001681751455180347, 0.024288557469844818, 0.009303588420152664, -0.03469093516469002, -0.01568182185292244, -0.03450494632124901, -0.005656503606587648, 0.0043483516201376915, -0.020616475492715836, -0.05573861300945282, -0.060278959572315216, 0.02378561720252037, 0.012381291016936302, 0.02958318032324314, 0.018578631803393364, 0.05053156986832619, -0.04921719431877136, -0.05297880992293358, -0.033460214734077454, -0.008259914815425873, 0.0019138314528390765, -0.038985077291727066, 0.0347091369330883, -0.009600549004971981, -0.003024444915354252, -0.07257290929555893 ]
In recent years, cloud and edge architectures have gained tremendous focus for offloading computationally heavy applications. From machine learning and Internet of Thing (IOT) to industrial procedures and robotics, cloud computing have been used extensively for data processing and storage purposes, thanks to its "infinite" resources. On the other hand, cloud computing is characterized by long time delays due to the long distance between the cloud servers and the machine requesting the resources. In contrast, edge computing provides almost real-time services since edge servers are located significantly closer to the source of data. This capability sets edge computing as an ideal option for real-time applications, like high level control, for resource-constrained platforms. In order to utilize the edge resources, several technologies, with basic ones as containers and orchestrators like Kubernetes, have been developed to provide an environment with many features, based on each application's requirements. In this context, this works presents the implementation and evaluation of a novel edge architecture based on Kubernetes orchestration for controlling the trajectory of a resource-constrained Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) by enabling Model Predictive Control (MPC).
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13624v1
[ 0.0072699179872870445, -0.07625138759613037, 0.05270112678408623, -0.012263708747923374, -0.045483820140361786, -0.027235306799411774, -0.0267505906522274, -0.03687195107340813, 0.04315859079360962, -0.035147830843925476, -0.0246336180716753, 0.06631714105606079, -0.034170523285865784, -0.046844739466905594, -0.06511035561561584, 0.011539053171873093, 0.07466299831867218, 0.0474315769970417, -0.058771178126335144, 0.05883307382464409, 0.0065802899189293385, -0.03576655685901642, -0.026333782821893692, -0.001452127005904913, 0.012581583112478256, -0.0033324144314974546, -0.012894906103610992, 0.03021160326898098, -0.03392409160733223, 0.022017424926161766, 0.06402503699064255, -0.012568092904984951, -0.042208872735500336, 0.0026606828905642033, -0.042203374207019806, 0.0017864903202280402, -0.0035713943652808666, 0.02127622812986374, 0.0011149690253660083, -0.028576981276273727, 0.043244875967502594, -0.04698546603322029, -0.04197574779391289, -0.0711384266614914, 0.018409283831715584, -0.04463977366685867, -0.06866239756345749, 0.002955458126962185, -0.06701736152172089, -0.003410073695704341, 0.03822801262140274, 0.028908168897032738, 0.01357718650251627, 0.048530593514442444, -0.015239274129271507, -0.0012301072711125016, 0.00031908912933431566, 0.021578462794423103, -0.029346304014325142, -0.02234989032149315, -0.020288823172450066, -0.03466927632689476, 0.005157487466931343, -0.020542943850159645, 0.0022134636528789997, 0.07969651371240616, -0.03225519880652428, -0.037275280803442, -0.015099456533789635, -0.02958790957927704, 0.039522890001535416, -0.06977827101945877, 0.017308680340647697, -0.02649124339222908, -0.029408801347017288, -0.004789893515408039, -0.012783625163137913, -0.02861854061484337, 0.01939394883811474, -0.018869804218411446, 0.0037639050278812647, 0.01733555644750595, 0.024148454889655113, 0.03546915948390961, -0.01344728097319603, -0.04703725501894951, 0.031783703714609146, -0.0002710535190999508, 0.01862100325524807, -0.031952153891325, 0.06924202293157578, -0.04668612778186798, -0.08771573752164841, 0.044315092265605927, 0.04267802834510803, 0.0027610971592366695, 0.019647836685180664, 0.04326888546347618, -0.00552072050049901, -0.024879643693566322, -0.03550978749990463, -0.024076180532574654, -0.06723568588495255, 0.04761902987957001, -0.006442428100854158, -0.048638153821229935, 0.03978081792593002, -0.00029379018815234303, -0.026480648666620255, -0.00463512260466814, -0.017732271924614906, -0.021418077871203423, -0.005201397463679314, -0.06682208925485611, -0.017620354890823364, -0.06244290620088577, 0.06753067672252655, -0.008835666812956333, 0.026140019297599792, -0.009944552555680275, 0.008070076815783978, 0.013759522698819637, 0.046582482755184174, -0.006614556070417166, -0.03315737098455429, -0.04305904358625412, 0.009182551875710487, -0.008419713005423546, 0.04805430397391319, -0.025306668132543564, -0.05562721937894821, 0.06550473719835281, -0.04084194824099541, -0.027506843209266663, 0.038869522511959076, 0.0026834725867956877, -0.007583846803754568, -0.04850934445858002, 0.05018635466694832, -0.013511193916201591, -0.06255050003528595, -0.0531238429248333, -0.010544147342443466, -0.0046411436051130295, 0.009206993505358696, 0.016389265656471252, -0.004470605403184891, -0.05965041369199753, -0.009439953602850437, 0.03616808354854584, 0.020459149032831192, 0.024600466713309288, 0.036648109555244446, -0.03317120671272278, 0.02913638949394226, -0.026273416355252266, -0.004829926881939173, -0.06802324950695038, -0.07581421732902527, 0.008841471746563911, 0.024283668026328087, -0.001247856649570167, -0.03047141060233116, -0.0644698515534401, -0.031391691416502, 0.006778827868402004, 0.0032429408747702837, -0.0161235723644495, 0.006663124077022076, 0.05728915333747864, -0.014941416680812836, -0.03683291748166084, 0.009500931017100811, -0.040354274213314056, -0.043289266526699066, -0.033983346074819565, 0.002441626274958253, -0.04017714783549309, -0.028610097244381905, -0.030744047835469246, -0.04237477853894234, 0.030696574598550797, -0.025356363505125046, -0.017120297998189926, -0.023094773292541504, 0.022872185334563255, -0.058966364711523056, -0.017898134887218475, -0.006695155054330826, 0.0038944019470363855, -0.006940511055290699, -0.03712081164121628, -0.006118117831647396, -0.010229077190160751, -0.03727196529507637, -0.0586530938744545, -0.0006016555125825107, -0.02927282638847828, 0.028971942141652107, 0.027773121371865273, -0.07017147541046143, -0.013817152939736843, -0.03027527406811714, -0.014719294384121895, -0.005303376354277134, -0.07274498045444489, 0.04170119762420654, 0.05184436962008476, -0.04440561681985855, 0.009359343908727169, 0.04259006679058075, 0.013760345056653023, 0.03848375380039215, 0.018039532005786896, 0.0528174564242363, 0.02577141486108303, -0.0999210774898529, 0.03890502452850342, 0.01107819750905037, 0.02425687573850155, 0.007423551753163338, 0.0235279593616724, -0.03201957419514656, -0.01241091825067997, 0.030002858489751816, 0.06721247732639313, 0.019389692693948746, -0.02120467647910118, -0.05292883142828941, -0.019245570525527, -0.06268270313739777, -0.04880490526556969, -0.015630396082997322, -0.03019198216497898, -0.04526407644152641, -0.03206166625022888, -0.05644465982913971, 0.0680278018116951, -0.0360407680273056, -0.03715820983052254, -0.04599858447909355, -0.02735130302608013, 0.04801538214087486, -0.020751524716615677, -0.07932189851999283, -0.04888683557510376, -0.02116161584854126, -0.009535781107842922, -0.00892721489071846, -0.031826432794332504, -0.012666814029216766, -0.020302701741456985, 0.006465385667979717, -0.029552478343248367, 0.04878445714712143, 0.03922276571393013, -0.05338390916585922, 0.028202518820762634, -0.03356815502047539, 0.02283814363181591, -0.016124235466122627, 0.02147374302148819, -0.05015944316983223, 0.01819920912384987, 0.026897335425019264, -0.0030787999276071787, 0.03438659757375717, -0.024370592087507248, -0.011152993887662888, -0.05777930095791817, 0.0059270309284329414, -0.017624158412218094, 0.0010335828410461545, -0.014223054051399231, 0.004408909473568201, -0.029636388644576073, -0.00059399293968454, 0.02422771230340004, -0.01642288826406002, 0.05334368348121643, 0.04594231769442558, 0.007498487830162048, 0.04275691136717796, -0.07112441211938858, -0.004278355278074741, -0.0386849008500576, -0.010132275521755219, -0.011259897612035275, -0.021129857748746872, -0.06148091331124306, -0.017057202756404877, -0.017541492357850075, -0.003240008605644107, -0.05248848721385002, -0.0327930673956871, -0.02420640178024769, 0.002905446570366621, -0.02689799852669239, 0.03175865858793259, -0.006775899324566126, 0.010480529628694057, -0.04810322821140289, 0.030861735343933105, 0.02343817800283432, 0.02415573224425316, -0.05160022899508476, -0.02697405219078064, -0.02180197648704052, 0.032384783029556274, 0.035960402339696884, -0.008076357655227184, 0.02489122375845909, -0.03596700727939606, 0.004038043320178986, 0.04532230645418167, 0.016553211957216263, -0.0016822799807414412, 0.003716995706781745, 0.0005025980062782764, 0.0036603768821805716, -0.040335893630981445, -0.0018214212032034993, 0.04407009482383728, -0.05140142887830734, -0.06481187790632248, -0.054931897670030594, 0.006832532584667206, 0.002075697761029005, -0.008888882584869862, 0.001016536494717002, 0.06444264203310013, 0.03972664475440979, -0.005717567168176174, 0.02657272107899189, 0.012043951079249382, 0.04090188071131706, -0.03337655961513519, -0.011584393680095673, -0.036927394568920135, 0.046433862298727036, 0.007980518974363804, -0.019092364236712456, -0.023412887006998062, -0.03406105563044548, 0.023237887769937515, -0.09044060111045837, 0.007954615168273449, 0.04018737003207207, 0.06733893603086472, 0.004053635522723198, 0.02416817471385002, 0.03053727000951767, 0.02094883657991886, 0.04133114591240883, 0.0025635831989347935, -0.04427190124988556, 0.03796163573861122, 0.057010527700185776, -0.04096830636262894, -0.022594057023525238, -0.013632222078740597, -0.06398311257362366, -0.03701239079236984, 0.024115856736898422, 0.03740282356739044, 0.04177995026111603, 0.041603270918130875, -0.061757348477840424, -0.005638234317302704, -0.01808016188442707, 0.04723178967833519, -0.014064946211874485, -0.0596340112388134, 0.01230273861438036, -0.0664834976196289, -0.00669507822021842, -0.04226892068982124, -0.029939422383904457, 0.016392750665545464, -0.03380073979496956, 0.015068958513438702, -0.08295907080173492, 0.025000978261232376, -0.04259081557393074, 0.026877738535404205, -0.015094374306499958, 0.03522224724292755, -0.0009683816460892558, 0.06193842738866806, 0.013316858559846878, -0.037601128220558167, -0.02963159792125225, 0.028349226340651512, -0.00714105973020196, 0.005008024163544178, -0.034297022968530655, 0.0074439141899347305, 0.020175671204924583, -0.021670380607247353, -0.043917980045080185, 0.0020332548301666975, -0.0025637620128691196, -0.0013647476444020867, -0.06506722420454025, 0.009170367382466793, -0.05449517443776131, 0.05336936563253403, -0.028961218893527985, -0.006008731201291084, 0.07600638270378113, -0.05564499646425247, 0.00811814609915018, -0.06488846242427826, 0.023968731984496117, -0.009532990865409374, -0.04163536801934242, 0.001870783045887947, -0.05822664871811867, 0.029756460338830948, -0.02602406218647957, 0.062292058020830154, 0.007123596966266632, 0.05826147273182869, -0.05594957619905472, -0.011867317371070385, 0.007950848899781704, 0.015067516826093197, 0.029178043827414513, -0.0031881690956652164, -0.012161842547357082, -0.029894260689616203, 0.001055675558745861, 0.0184576865285635, 0.014855584129691124, -0.012044859118759632, -0.02841208130121231, 0.03428473323583603, -0.0031610121950507164, 0.010084738954901695, 0.021907582879066467, -0.016363268718123436, 0.04816535860300064, -0.023471752181649208, 0.013013361021876335, 0.0070929196663200855, 0.027434445917606354, -0.011997309513390064, -0.05747527256608009, -0.03598328307271004, -0.06056239455938339, -0.027324505150318146, -0.04502938687801361, 0.045835964381694794, 0.026639066636562347, 0.012758424505591393, 0.03834092989563942, 0.04550829157233238, 0.056467168033123016, -0.013806096278131008, 0.014074991457164288, -0.022937214002013206, -0.026825953274965286, -0.011758367531001568, 0.0509815439581871, -0.060811545699834824, -0.0020040220115333796, 0.02405478060245514, -0.0007443573558703065, -0.017053529620170593, -0.018666548654437065, 0.045067016035318375, -0.022633381187915802, -0.070595383644104, 0.03796007111668587, 0.046362075954675674, -0.0031199478544294834, 0.04235474020242691, 0.011159722693264484, 0.0009181194473057985, 0.029000455513596535, -0.025625314563512802, -0.009617675095796585, 0.06988446414470673, -0.0045432280749082565, -0.017324412241578102, 0.04616129398345947, -0.04214546084403992, 0.05597608536481857, 0.030736064538359642, -0.0365125946700573, -0.06825190037488937, 0.03318649157881737, 0.029756955802440643, -0.01301014143973589, -0.00946708582341671, 0.012729327194392681, 0.026413334533572197, -0.0253047663718462, -0.009072859771549702, -0.015637457370758057, 0.040965721011161804, -0.0272394847124815, -0.019033731892704964, -0.02587474323809147, -0.0178599264472723, 0.04292604699730873, -0.0010497273178771138, 0.027061978355050087, 0.0069133262149989605, 0.021716076880693436, -0.01291703712195158, -0.02085554599761963, -0.04142073169350624, -0.05287059023976326, -0.021826623007655144, 0.025158852338790894, -0.008988907560706139, 0.04133171960711479, 0.038721419870853424, 0.0025961650535464287, 0.026606932282447815, -0.047591451555490494, -0.05327635630965233, -0.026391640305519104, -0.018888400867581367, 0.017283620312809944, -0.05255487561225891, 0.004530138801783323, -0.020544391125440598, -0.02761189267039299, 0.023287920281291008, 0.016158152371644974, 0.010127895511686802, -0.00010771209053928033, -0.019684694707393646, -0.01392461359500885, -0.012654675170779228, -0.08337155729532242, -0.03418344631791115, 0.02271975576877594, 0.07548737525939941, -0.040678173303604126, 0.06281009316444397, 0.007415953557938337, -0.02439066767692566, 0.06133832037448883, 0.0005143531016074121, -0.01641560159623623, -0.036078426986932755, -0.01443462073802948, 0.04485109820961952, -0.051444992423057556, -0.023767929524183273, -0.01707863062620163, -0.05652303621172905, 0.037434227764606476, -0.03053710050880909, -0.01328833494335413, 0.022296611219644547, 0.0006376331439241767, -0.045523881912231445, 0.05237818509340286, -0.04397270455956459, -0.08495045453310013, -0.0016216818476095796, 0.014679349958896637, -0.06488308310508728, 0.0010146253043785691, 0.014070525765419006, -0.0027432076167315245, -0.05424576997756958, 0.07210960984230042, 0.027748461812734604, -0.0008587843622080982, -0.06210869550704956, 0.030021177604794502, 0.05421893671154976, 0.007483546156436205, 0.007453459315001965, -0.012412531301379204, -0.05077975615859032, -0.0069428784772753716, -0.015341631136834621, 0.001741925603710115, 0.027712998911738396, 0.022574996575713158, -0.010914193466305733, -0.0571921169757843, -0.02012295462191105, 0.05593271926045418, -0.017333021387457848, -0.04801488667726517, -0.0030994354747235775, 0.024608375504612923, 0.06093888729810715, -0.005786732770502567, -0.0627850592136383, -0.013128173537552357, -0.023405620828270912, -0.0016843138728290796, -0.004382003098726273, 0.02077917754650116, -0.03412115201354027, 0.07373511791229248, -0.003599027870222926, -0.04203233867883682, 0.04257412627339363, -0.0035049491561949253, -0.07645842432975769, 0.052492156624794006, -0.07502438127994537, -0.033876605331897736, -0.023690884932875633, -0.024500856176018715, 0.002023062901571393, 0.041904266923666, -0.018977288156747818, -0.0587155744433403, 0.014603753574192524, -0.02913481369614601, 0.03516778349876404, -0.01338539645075798, 0.06439150124788284, 0.03563722223043442, 0.05449821054935455, -0.008770124986767769, -0.06714025139808655, 0.0175823625177145, -0.02066522091627121, -0.0028497257735580206, -0.042069368064403534, -0.010613450780510902, 0.005065528675913811, -0.040099482983350754, 0.027866045013070107, -0.01790984719991684, 0.05086027458310127, -0.041306447237730026, -0.05710728093981743, -0.027555866166949272, 0.010474408976733685, 0.019907807931303978, -0.04763113707304001, 0.01455814577639103, 0.006413099821656942, -0.020573820918798447, 0.01056399755179882, -0.017054207623004913, 0.013434831984341145, -0.03199272230267525, -0.045580048114061356, -0.07041262835264206, -0.014250323176383972, 0.0027043912559747696, -0.04347171634435654, -0.046601105481386185, 0.02843751572072506, -0.0749812051653862, -0.013905324041843414, 0.05595959722995758, -0.010950759053230286, -0.03648350015282631, -0.06385809928178787, -0.012830321677029133, -0.04758414998650551, -0.05536368489265442, -0.05168520659208298, -0.04728495702147484, -0.04830990359187126, -0.012853124178946018, 0.022391797974705696, -0.00798589363694191, -0.008622482419013977, 0.02169056050479412, -0.0805177167057991, -0.0186228659003973, 0.006634972523897886, 0.02578887529671192, -0.009525560773909092, -0.009955771267414093, -0.008688417263329029, -0.01059197448194027, -0.012205971404910088, 0.0004895419115200639, 0.0353814996778965, 0.003009169828146696, 0.035568300634622574, 0.031684987246990204, -0.03142445906996727, -0.029366813600063324, -0.04511198401451111, -0.022068381309509277, 0.0341079980134964, 0.034508489072322845, 0.034041158854961395, 0.03103419952094555, -0.041389092803001404, 0.028277188539505005, -0.05828525498509407, 0.05474189296364784, -0.04341920092701912, -0.024649417027831078, -0.02869068644940853, -0.05303819477558136, 0.0050801802426576614, -0.04852403327822685, 0.030609607696533203, 0.007239534519612789, -0.020979363471269608, 0.036423832178115845, -0.04355772212147713, -0.06283757835626602, 0.03892211243510246, 0.026855234056711197, -0.02773904614150524, 0.05927496775984764, -0.06227961927652359, 0.011452853679656982, -0.027363965287804604, -0.007126512937247753, -0.017017219215631485, 0.035886477679014206, 0.056975625455379486, -0.0403294563293457, 0.009182914160192013, -0.009526288136839867, 0.033250633627176285, -0.017455551773309708, -0.001636661123484373, -0.06521060317754745, 0.08145257085561752, 0.024795344099402428, -0.011912359856069088, -0.07292933762073517, -0.05656413361430168, -0.039007071405649185, -0.05311090126633644, -0.007972823455929756, -0.06352515518665314, 0.048803821206092834, -0.001716231694445014, 0.011363922618329525, 0.03730791434645653, 0.041262101382017136, 0.023586232215166092, 0.021635863929986954, 0.017624542117118835, 0.04052985832095146, -0.048313744366168976, 0.08527205139398575, 0.020258955657482147, 0.00015355904179159552, -0.020076671615242958, 0.02171509899199009, -0.026027340441942215, -0.029232202097773552, -0.00985125545412302, -0.010685713961720467, 0.04525149613618851, -0.03831532970070839, -0.02167516015470028, 0.011511881835758686, 0.0007918123155832291, -0.05524136498570442, -0.06783390790224075, 0.05589555203914642, -0.03008531965315342, -0.05147052928805351 ]
Formalized $1$-category theory forms a core component of various libraries of mathematical proofs. However, more sophisticated results in fields from algebraic topology to theoretical physics, where objects have "higher structure," rely on infinite-dimensional categories in place of $1$-dimensional categories, and $\infty$-category theory has thusfar proved unamenable to computer formalization. Using a new proof assistant called Rzk, which is designed to support Riehl-Shulman's simplicial extension of homotopy type theory for synthetic $\infty$-category theory, we provide the first formalizations of results from $\infty$-category theory. This includes in particular a formalization of the Yoneda lemma, often regarded as the fundamental theorem of category theory, a theorem which roughly states that an object of a given category is determined by its relationship to all of the other objects of the category. A key feature of our framework is that, thanks to the synthetic theory, many constructions are automatically natural or functorial. We plan to use Rzk to formalize further results from $\infty$-category theory, such as the theory of limits and colimits and adjunctions.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08340v3
[ -0.012418367899954319, -0.05109383910894394, 0.026866525411605835, -0.03354688361287117, 0.032985247671604156, -0.03729667887091637, -0.0721965804696083, 0.004172538407146931, -0.019802715629339218, -0.012351619079709053, -0.010480562224984169, -0.03169093653559685, -0.059115808457136154, -0.032222405076026917, -0.046569809317588806, 0.004290447104722261, 0.08369103819131851, 0.04673586040735245, -0.040462855249643326, 0.07438905537128448, 0.0053398218005895615, -0.023914694786071777, -0.03631597384810448, 0.058753516525030136, -0.005303334444761276, -0.026587001979351044, -0.006848861463367939, -0.028952213004231453, -0.020372940227389336, -0.012425433844327927, 0.07708980143070221, -0.04862199351191521, -0.0009769084863364697, -0.03794048726558685, -0.026242980733513832, 0.008206839673221111, 0.010375702753663063, 0.01589098945260048, 0.03023393452167511, -0.01967056654393673, 0.00984370056539774, -0.026195509359240532, -0.05940541997551918, -0.02866198681294918, -0.04658976197242737, -0.017792310565710068, -0.05255630984902382, 0.014512402005493641, -0.06646419316530228, -0.06342169642448425, 0.056904442608356476, 0.023403925821185112, 0.014927171170711517, 0.05348408594727516, -0.017619311809539795, -0.023366449400782585, 0.050881754606962204, 0.008526885882019997, -0.058799825608730316, -0.007434793747961521, -0.0018344396958127618, -0.02636660821735859, 0.011746589094400406, -0.03787129744887352, 0.005200554616749287, 0.02361835539340973, -0.024619614705443382, -0.07843373715877533, -0.00638548843562603, -0.013124427758157253, 0.0036529572680592537, -0.06523309648036957, 0.025474073365330696, 0.010625997558236122, -0.06894347071647644, 0.0034822640009224415, -0.016769712790846825, -0.016322778537869453, 0.011910120956599712, 0.042633481323719025, -0.0015698842471465468, 0.008664766326546669, -0.007206817623227835, -0.028033573180437088, 0.002147344872355461, -0.03565581142902374, 0.06346611678600311, -0.0286189503967762, 0.015542778186500072, -0.049002621322870255, 0.02766299434006214, -0.009846792556345463, -0.07920095324516296, 0.014310731552541256, 0.052691441029310226, -0.06312432140111923, 0.023371044546365738, 0.05437623709440231, 0.03433271497488022, -0.034719228744506836, 0.00038544973358511925, -0.05977762117981911, 0.002945926273241639, 0.0023874540347605944, 0.0222004521638155, -0.012944746762514114, -0.004041527863591909, 0.012772353366017342, -0.057373903691768646, 0.026715461164712906, -0.027363816276192665, 0.020795613527297974, 0.0206060241907835, -0.02874244563281536, -0.04502016305923462, -0.05516691133379936, 0.04405221343040466, 0.031433168798685074, 0.019022373482584953, 0.03354194387793541, -0.019997427240014076, -0.00359592423774302, 0.017669467255473137, -0.035697560757398605, -0.07829367369413376, -0.0657116025686264, 0.022972889244556427, 0.03404378145933151, -0.008435307070612907, 0.008802513591945171, -0.031384654343128204, -0.014207147993147373, 0.04069139435887337, -0.009641674347221851, 0.04353363811969757, -0.010763967409729958, -0.016765229403972626, -0.07829923927783966, 0.04847709462046623, 0.04690958186984062, -0.021473681554198265, -0.07151935994625092, 0.007155397906899452, -0.017033632844686508, 0.009403377771377563, 0.06566494703292847, -0.04574963450431824, -0.033611517399549484, 0.01984938606619835, 0.02487359568476677, -0.028197189792990685, 0.009171458892524242, -0.0026003867387771606, 0.00024363478587474674, 0.031538207083940506, -0.004919859580695629, 0.022488698363304138, -0.05135303735733032, -0.03634278103709221, 0.000836470106150955, 0.03421834111213684, -0.0017874723998829722, -0.045910149812698364, -0.000535324274096638, 0.004854942671954632, 0.03464769572019577, 0.04591336473822594, -0.0429808683693409, -0.003092429367825389, 0.014632581733167171, -0.021810192614793777, -0.010641197673976421, -0.0005860180826857686, -0.051593758165836334, -0.052302900701761246, 0.003609752282500267, -0.029181428253650665, -0.05468933656811714, -0.028989916667342186, 0.028850292786955833, -0.036939866840839386, -0.06050650030374527, -0.021009525284171104, 0.01888507604598999, -0.03292655944824219, 0.021436244249343872, -0.05469810590147972, -0.0016104340320453048, -0.008528563193976879, 0.031153546646237373, -0.030951770022511482, -0.047220755368471146, 0.03904281556606293, -0.022791162133216858, -0.02558656968176365, 0.027243608608841896, 0.003477379446849227, -0.0682358592748642, -0.03046712465584278, 0.022433597594499588, -0.06895733624696732, -0.03979092463850975, -0.03926458582282066, -0.007897590287029743, 0.006790412589907646, -0.056379638612270355, 0.024506237357854843, 0.060787685215473175, 0.0027204377111047506, -0.01258569210767746, 0.07707935571670532, 0.0028226159047335386, 0.07419222593307495, -0.020205490291118622, 0.03905580937862396, -0.010691671632230282, -0.0938451886177063, 0.051709819585084915, -0.010719029232859612, -0.014691992662847042, -0.005544682499021292, 0.04206482321023941, -0.029012303799390793, -0.0556827187538147, -0.016434848308563232, 0.043949101120233536, 0.017006412148475647, 0.020880667492747307, -0.05890817567706108, 0.0010758106363937259, -0.028852742165327072, -0.059286125004291534, -0.03447598218917847, -0.06920509040355682, -0.041908107697963715, -0.014116397127509117, 0.010187464766204357, 0.056020140647888184, -0.03340199217200279, -0.04011892154812813, -0.06525610387325287, 0.007386320736259222, 0.05840187892317772, 0.015685560181736946, -0.04714833199977875, -0.04671700298786163, -0.03195644170045853, -0.027337823063135147, -0.029589634388685226, -0.02329612523317337, 0.003008931176736951, -0.052256740629673004, -0.034811172634363174, -0.004628336988389492, -0.012410838156938553, 0.04162124544382095, -0.02081654593348503, 0.04391895607113838, -0.002019632374867797, 0.027692576870322227, 0.02746494673192501, 0.04901377111673355, -0.03630414605140686, -0.02832418493926525, 0.014122485183179379, -0.0030603082850575447, -0.05267355591058731, -0.007649409119039774, 0.00446090754121542, 0.00731639051809907, 0.0027687805704772472, 0.0439378097653389, 0.05299893394112587, -0.01336455624550581, -0.003629198530688882, -0.015570112504065037, 0.003844579216092825, -0.0008213251712732017, 0.045362189412117004, 0.010885617695748806, 0.05476315692067146, -0.00003144305446767248, -0.047551076859235764, -0.08214102685451508, -0.042921263724565506, 0.03543722257018089, -0.053695518523454666, -0.05153902247548103, -0.04943952336907387, 0.0058858939446508884, -0.05520554259419441, 0.020116258412599564, 0.007025826256722212, -0.07120370864868164, -0.06053302809596062, -0.07250436395406723, -0.01963180862367153, -0.021848425269126892, 0.005789967719465494, -0.04627988487482071, -0.06271692365407944, 0.0038886978290975094, 0.046056464314460754, 0.015422260388731956, -0.04179540276527405, -0.061789896339178085, -0.03805294260382652, 0.009394713677465916, -0.010438093915581703, -0.04326215386390686, -0.04515694081783295, 0.00010714169911807403, 0.02819625474512577, 0.01876244693994522, 0.0435870885848999, -0.008130169473588467, 0.0566423237323761, -0.006261107046157122, 0.03868847340345383, -0.009623817168176174, -0.03032684698700905, -0.06190380081534386, 0.03389487415552139, -0.05326443165540695, -0.05305933579802513, -0.03413654863834381, 0.0006882949382998049, 0.021154310554265976, -0.04908115416765213, -0.03942607343196869, -0.03750685229897499, -0.02961798384785652, 0.03781156614422798, 0.013767154887318611, 0.012603825889527798, 0.012810800224542618, -0.004707958083599806, -0.06931613385677338, -0.03390524163842201, 0.022492779418826103, 0.04157978296279907, 0.025609120726585388, -0.010577837005257607, -0.04149002954363823, 0.0634072870016098, -0.08082488179206848, 0.05874859169125557, 0.03158201649785042, 0.06612180173397064, -0.0496719591319561, 0.021272040903568268, 0.026868455111980438, -0.03650064393877983, 0.00907569658011198, -0.03276335820555687, 0.01709100417792797, 0.0465102344751358, 0.03211260959506035, -0.037365708500146866, -0.04277150705456734, -0.026862094178795815, -0.0426066592335701, 0.00839703157544136, -0.01543243508785963, 0.03559638559818268, 0.013483584858477116, 0.02593342401087284, -0.0017569857882335782, -0.03084847703576088, -0.03468002378940582, 0.048214610666036606, -0.01384422741830349, 0.001644872478209436, 0.019489120692014694, -0.037394776940345764, -0.0029857666231691837, 0.01408940739929676, -0.006201029755175114, -0.005852594505995512, -0.020549166947603226, -0.03266560658812523, -0.03389386460185051, 0.03929101303219795, 0.03717959299683571, -0.003803350031375885, -0.011936478316783905, 0.01872187852859497, -0.015371972694993019, 0.05355832725763321, -0.007376485969871283, -0.011524961329996586, -0.04147275537252426, 0.02827984280884266, -0.003234192030504346, -0.004136939067393541, -0.03568866848945618, -0.013133471831679344, 0.022319544106721878, -0.03669370710849762, -0.037415437400341034, -0.01282744761556387, -0.018394216895103455, -0.034433845430612564, -0.07123946398496628, 0.00276198354549706, -0.04683637619018555, -0.011851917952299118, 0.012670475989580154, -0.07165523618459702, 0.0636453703045845, -0.028458036482334137, -0.010626970790326595, -0.004893367178738117, -0.002194902626797557, 0.007665742188692093, 0.01712675951421261, -0.02160179242491722, -0.04568369314074516, -0.0060575553216040134, -0.06649529188871384, -0.002106411848217249, 0.0015401962446048856, -0.0006255207117646933, -0.04697537049651146, 0.034703467041254044, -0.04480461776256561, 0.023298559710383415, 0.008289835415780544, 0.053964097052812576, 0.019191918894648552, -0.03352878615260124, 0.009664899669587612, 0.0017170751234516501, 0.012535386718809605, 0.005388288758695126, -0.03456159681081772, 0.013424322940409184, -0.03413209319114685, -0.034076027572155, -0.05827806890010834, -0.04957391694188118, 0.019648436456918716, -0.059312108904123306, 0.008762192912399769, -0.0402400903403759, 0.04861227050423622, -0.06182960793375969, -0.0755477324128151, -0.0020109289325773716, -0.02350495755672455, -0.04450353607535362, 0.027867957949638367, 0.049696024507284164, 0.008635248988866806, -0.012927001342177391, 0.03872050344944, -0.02611231431365013, -0.002634731587022543, -0.020177291706204414, -0.010171067900955677, 0.042389970272779465, -0.03224222734570503, -0.05644541233778, 0.03085554949939251, -0.0553303062915802, 0.0019235283834859729, -0.03122754767537117, -0.022423183545470238, 0.03564543277025223, 0.046885743737220764, -0.006403448060154915, 0.05678039789199829, -0.08950268477201462, 0.011002318002283573, 0.02762988954782486, -0.012706983834505081, 0.01273498684167862, 0.04012136533856392, -0.035264309495687485, -0.00720171956345439, -0.01090605091303587, -0.00004024014197057113, 0.023278340697288513, 0.01998983696103096, -0.01906222105026245, -0.01313374750316143, -0.016119664534926414, -0.03881143778562546, 0.05326548218727112, -0.054951976984739304, -0.04386179521679878, 0.03480331972241402, -0.004410192370414734, -0.019470321014523506, -0.05566644296050072, 0.06648664176464081, 0.021182890981435776, -0.028468836098909378, -0.04107766970992088, -0.03053552843630314, -0.022613495588302612, 0.011064753867685795, 0.013371356762945652, -0.017102550715208054, 0.014258557930588722, 0.03863360360264778, -0.04773526266217232, 0.0017988180043175817, -0.00992842111736536, -0.02816835790872574, -0.0053285569883883, 0.024267133325338364, 0.00048379451618529856, -0.05282969772815704, -0.016284910961985588, -0.0472077950835228, 0.033435191959142685, 0.04765720292925835, -0.0043605417013168335, 0.04594014585018158, 0.03688720613718033, -0.0077776722609996796, 0.008117878809571266, -0.01954863965511322, -0.025506475940346718, 0.050036247819662094, -0.05705602094531059, 0.0016745899338275194, -0.037226393818855286, 0.016757652163505554, 0.0076819974929094315, -0.001615838729776442, 0.018297240138053894, -0.035913825035095215, -0.034061018377542496, 0.029823774471879005, 0.03753945976495743, -0.033362455666065216, -0.03650584816932678, -0.010259546339511871, 0.04594932496547699, -0.03910582512617111, 0.054994095116853714, 0.013072127476334572, 0.03991943225264549, 0.021925197914242744, -0.002030923729762435, 0.03956829383969307, -0.0444888174533844, -0.06757781654596329, 0.07224401086568832, -0.06606072187423706, 0.012312439270317554, -0.0547989085316658, -0.01190478727221489, -0.031413864344358444, -0.0575716570019722, 0.02607877179980278, 0.00955983903259039, -0.008070223964750767, -0.05638442188501358, 0.0686158686876297, 0.028248414397239685, -0.06044347956776619, 0.010107926093041897, 0.040159229189157486, -0.0586714968085289, 0.02036324329674244, -0.00734688388183713, 0.0195914339274168, -0.022268757224082947, 0.06831125915050507, -0.02780493162572384, -0.043329302221536636, -0.02832038328051567, 0.06344879418611526, 0.08100438117980957, -0.03929993510246277, 0.06083079054951668, 0.010223486460745335, 0.011616300791501999, 0.03852253779768944, -0.05749616026878357, 0.0000422706434619613, -0.03543882444500923, 0.030942706391215324, -0.03252599760890007, -0.03920753300189972, -0.009456990286707878, 0.033674657344818115, -0.040435392409563065, -0.029736045747995377, 0.031598880887031555, -0.03626968711614609, 0.007707233540713787, -0.03235037997364998, -0.04370756819844246, -0.03639912232756615, 0.007644524797797203, -0.026133490726351738, -0.005810157395899296, -0.0016301112482324243, -0.0418640561401844, 0.015044121071696281, -0.029925284907221794, -0.04910483583807945, 0.006167927291244268, -0.005911733955144882, -0.0807172954082489, -0.01545435655862093, -0.03714916482567787, 0.015443562529981136, -0.012452300637960434, 0.058791469782590866, 0.02518950030207634, 0.01068005058914423, 0.008519531227648258, -0.0256218072026968, 0.013041106052696705, -0.03425167128443718, -0.0009578039753250778, 0.005190212745219469, -0.004556236322969198, -0.04103023186326027, 0.05847670137882233, -0.05003413185477257, -0.008984691463410854, -0.02151215448975563, -0.037348613142967224, 0.02163519524037838, -0.009702370502054691, -0.06558653712272644, 0.002457984955981374, -0.0086183687672019, -0.03672109171748161, 0.02600996010005474, 0.02510799467563629, -0.017499055713415146, -0.04822093993425369, 0.0026376540772616863, 0.03291277214884758, 0.028499817475676537, -0.020269423723220825, 0.036402586847543716, 0.041078753769397736, 0.0244334414601326, 0.051080990582704544, 0.01995222456753254, 0.06078873947262764, 0.013869435526430607, -0.07144695520401001, 0.005556791555136442, -0.01043086126446724, -0.052658241242170334, -0.017635812982916832, -0.041103512048721313, -0.049407243728637695, -0.055928245186805725, 0.02308541163802147, -0.022689318284392357, 0.006569216027855873, -0.03182044252753258, -0.06703682988882065, 0.058583781123161316, 0.02322516217827797, -0.010411723516881466, -0.07582283020019531, 0.009359406307339668, 0.012535656802356243, -0.010653587058186531, -0.000755631597712636, -0.055474504828453064, -0.052099525928497314, 0.012976343743503094, -0.08751647919416428, 0.006846992764621973, -0.00378865422680974, 0.05962434411048889, 0.008373228833079338, 0.007952059619128704, -0.04491579160094261, -0.02681291289627552, -0.009641006588935852, -0.01759164407849312, 0.022657575085759163, 0.0337788350880146, -0.02560424618422985, 0.02874019555747509, -0.004795551300048828, 0.0271687600761652, 0.0665024071931839, -0.04624337702989578, 0.004944903310388327, 0.025725817307829857, 0.02321549318730831, -0.005223228130489588, 0.03728943690657616, 0.03662952035665512, -0.0210049320012331, 0.04967263340950012, 0.007586732506752014, 0.0013499633641913533, -0.045891810208559036, -0.05655692517757416, 0.027406204491853714, -0.0656796395778656, -0.018178917467594147, 0.007876506075263023, -0.012559349648654461, -0.045135512948036194, 0.0004865467199124396, -0.05175565183162689, 0.03477014973759651, -0.033140864223241806, -0.012224001809954643, 0.05181945860385895, -0.04523486644029617, 0.027333270758390427, 0.004953489638864994, -0.0403793565928936, -0.025349607691168785, -0.032917920500040054, 0.04549993947148323, -0.05669514834880829, 0.026964595541357994, -0.05782775953412056, -0.005920784547924995, -0.04183230549097061, 0.04317763075232506, 0.008295198902487755, 0.03570583090186119, 0.0008327952236868441, -0.0021945752669125795, -0.036199748516082764, -0.012485968880355358, 0.00825478881597519, -0.08140833675861359, -0.009295780211687088, -0.023279016837477684, 0.04281789809465408, 0.018812747672200203, 0.02728922851383686, 0.00016092231089714915, 0.05518215149641037, 0.0353647843003273, 0.004213993437588215, 0.03531866520643234, 0.05974767357110977, -0.04546137899160385, 0.022671714425086975, 0.025891896337270737, -0.03685295209288597, -0.03804008662700653, 0.013906710781157017, -0.0238981731235981, -0.025905640795826912, 0.0023981581907719374, -0.01963506080210209, 0.052240509539842606, -0.06385412067174911, -0.027023455128073692, 0.01609065756201744, -0.0006935024284757674, -0.04925684258341789, 0.03370923548936844, 0.03375755995512009, 0.01332054752856493, -0.043906036764383316 ]
Recent results suggest that splitting topological navigation into robot-independent and robot-specific components improves navigation performance by enabling the robot-independent part to be trained with data collected by robots of different types. However, the navigation methods' performance is still limited by the scarcity of suitable training data and they suffer from poor computational scaling. In this work, we present PlaceNav, subdividing the robot-independent part into navigation-specific and generic computer vision components. We utilize visual place recognition for the subgoal selection of the topological navigation pipeline. This makes subgoal selection more efficient and enables leveraging large-scale datasets from non-robotics sources, increasing training data availability. Bayesian filtering, enabled by place recognition, further improves navigation performance by increasing the temporal consistency of subgoals. Our experimental results verify the design and the new method obtains a 76% higher success rate in indoor and 23% higher in outdoor navigation tasks with higher computational efficiency.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17260v4
[ -0.06076895445585251, -0.02391805872321129, 0.023177262395620346, 0.018604779615998268, -0.03169834986329079, 0.02381526678800583, 0.002943991683423519, 0.012562465853989124, 0.04506916552782059, -0.04642367362976074, -0.0439513623714447, 0.02205188199877739, -0.05662903934717178, -0.05839800834655762, -0.002283738926053047, -0.002399889985099435, 0.062435563653707504, -0.030171167105436325, -0.059231385588645935, 0.05113605037331581, 0.050215501338243484, -0.010579303838312626, -0.013468627817928791, 0.014995577745139599, 0.03261511027812958, -0.02684186026453972, -0.028204556554555893, 0.024909643456339836, -0.011002853512763977, 0.00977738294750452, 0.06141486018896103, -0.03667457029223442, -0.02411702089011669, -0.058696433901786804, -0.03950711339712143, 0.000546822149772197, -0.02552349492907524, 0.017723901197314262, 0.016279736533761024, -0.02107740007340908, 0.04687655717134476, -0.07239899784326553, -0.0163424089550972, -0.0523027628660202, -0.06699370592832565, -0.02932296320796013, -0.010072292760014534, -0.0026763714849948883, -0.05845404043793678, -0.04755580425262451, 0.028250493109226227, -0.031015323475003242, 0.03823697939515114, 0.008705532178282738, -0.015517356805503368, 0.00916613545268774, -0.00333416648209095, 0.03142305091023445, -0.04073699191212654, -0.019410833716392517, 0.01713494025170803, -0.00996282696723938, 0.021284064278006554, 0.02920784428715706, 0.049238067120313644, 0.029238414019346237, -0.037027135491371155, -0.07335039228200912, -0.059688664972782135, -0.02768809348344803, 0.03956286609172821, -0.058899689465761185, -0.028310824185609818, 0.017475176602602005, -0.03708989918231964, -0.017061982303857803, -0.012501157820224762, -0.02281523495912552, 0.04838893935084343, -0.03798417001962662, 0.00011711049592122436, 0.031444866210222244, 0.04032702371478081, 0.004434369504451752, -0.020949294790625572, -0.018412552773952484, 0.05631891265511513, -0.0009072116808965802, 0.030327437445521355, -0.02346799522638321, 0.03712219372391701, -0.018306633457541466, -0.052562225610017776, 0.0049032107926905155, 0.0738394558429718, -0.018519753590226173, 0.06022527441382408, 0.023617275059223175, 0.004314105492085218, -0.024530768394470215, -0.04012572765350342, -0.01807395927608013, -0.051777180284261703, 0.040975939482450485, 0.018443318083882332, -0.017750639468431473, -0.016650449484586716, -0.010567471385002136, -0.016585860401391983, 0.03434580937027931, -0.027538087218999863, 0.025219647213816643, -0.02369750291109085, -0.03631686046719551, -0.06648238748311996, -0.033326584845781326, 0.06495653092861176, -0.0025670956820249557, 0.01783624477684498, -0.03541712835431099, -0.0005824497784487903, 0.031161002814769745, 0.038221683353185654, 0.008759967051446438, -0.020842676982283592, -0.027773942798376083, 0.054543718695640564, 0.03226408362388611, -0.02355378493666649, -0.03077602945268154, 0.014418400824069977, 0.028008846566081047, -0.017870230600237846, -0.04332447052001953, 0.06653781235218048, 0.02477734535932541, -0.020791448652744293, -0.04934210330247879, 0.050118621438741684, -0.021229760721325874, -0.02274986356496811, -0.05808110162615776, 0.011336848139762878, -0.026737770065665245, 0.021686919033527374, 0.053044822067022324, -0.05401461943984032, -0.04770832881331444, 0.017083175480365753, 0.031531527638435364, 0.01246853731572628, 0.03750946372747421, 0.025534259155392647, 0.02819869853556156, 0.01696251519024372, 0.0007474432932212949, 0.045176807790994644, -0.017003189772367477, -0.0577232725918293, -0.005461155902594328, -0.014306087046861649, -0.005326118320226669, 0.0090870950371027, -0.04134824872016907, 0.011962922289967537, -0.014645172283053398, 0.05286335572600365, 0.00977935642004013, 0.011210807599127293, 0.022220995277166367, -0.045893602073192596, 0.004353444557636976, -0.0499272383749485, -0.04929516091942787, -0.03528352454304695, -0.018164025619626045, 0.007164694368839264, -0.03752677142620087, -0.015044048428535461, -0.016487980261445045, -0.020372161641716957, 0.018394140526652336, -0.006820368114858866, -0.0013773207319900393, -0.03575363755226135, -0.00837701465934515, -0.06951946020126343, -0.005816019605845213, 0.002797940047457814, 0.046505093574523926, 0.0018588907551020384, -0.0535462386906147, 0.029308656230568886, 0.024689793586730957, -0.04066157341003418, -0.04436488449573517, -0.05544302985072136, -0.042550988495349884, 0.03835582733154297, -0.014072592370212078, -0.08229132741689682, -0.05984041094779968, -0.061923034489154816, 0.03700945898890495, -0.004415064584463835, -0.0748700276017189, 0.03442498296499252, 0.03646933659911156, -0.02745932899415493, 0.037443146109580994, 0.04073089361190796, 0.04292158782482147, 0.059350501745939255, -0.015666579827666283, 0.02442539855837822, 0.006870165467262268, -0.09177122265100479, 0.018737168982625008, -0.028900109231472015, 0.044247981160879135, 0.049804653972387314, 0.0059007275849580765, -0.03086687996983528, -0.05672642961144447, -0.03364776819944382, 0.023993534967303276, 0.05914667621254921, -0.04364519193768501, -0.05995533987879753, -0.0448109470307827, -0.025974705815315247, -0.04496590420603752, -0.05331093445420265, -0.060567259788513184, -0.033024828881025314, -0.009255602024495602, -0.03413300961256027, 0.06722313165664673, 0.03411303833127022, -0.015139908529818058, -0.061030566692352295, -0.018390247598290443, 0.04641945660114288, -0.0119303148239851, -0.007755531929433346, -0.004239729139953852, -0.0001462709333281964, 0.005369465798139572, -0.0000015258245866789366, 0.0021025037858635187, -0.05027196556329727, -0.03645140677690506, -0.010163325816392899, -0.03218884766101837, 0.05334979668259621, 0.034046292304992676, -0.009071806445717812, 0.024644682183861732, -0.0616963729262352, 0.02728564850986004, -0.007256840355694294, -0.022059349343180656, -0.07812399417161942, -0.01872827112674713, 0.0173603817820549, 0.0043976400047540665, 0.03038054332137108, -0.059617459774017334, 0.029411884024739265, -0.012137998826801777, 0.011580399237573147, -0.008672161027789116, 0.04882173612713814, -0.03657505661249161, -0.0049974629655480385, -0.01913319155573845, 0.0013474677689373493, 0.01906958594918251, 0.020329197868704796, 0.03946639969944954, 0.056499116122722626, 0.06877759099006653, 0.06285574287176132, -0.05323484167456627, -0.00764616159722209, -0.04112085700035095, -0.0022570891305804253, -0.07508263736963272, -0.06555010378360748, -0.02615964412689209, -0.05227389559149742, -0.04160424694418907, -0.041213538497686386, -0.03707249090075493, -0.04432518780231476, -0.03564481437206268, -0.04528641328215599, 0.01767507568001747, 0.046775445342063904, -0.0005149521748535335, 0.019105274230241776, -0.062322407960891724, 0.03341865539550781, 0.014135497622191906, -0.01842041313648224, -0.07415571063756943, -0.017943261191248894, -0.01926524192094803, 0.022182947024703026, 0.02744213119149208, -0.003349181730300188, 0.012986879795789719, -0.018669093027710915, 0.0350109338760376, -0.031131625175476074, 0.024350903928279877, -0.021265575662255287, 0.017434492707252502, -0.01911611668765545, -0.026038600131869316, 0.030311817303299904, 0.031518977135419846, -0.01447704154998064, -0.02159743383526802, -0.05099509656429291, -0.0019432342378422618, 0.041806384921073914, 0.029636269435286522, -0.02451242133975029, -0.035777654498815536, -0.021751917898654938, 0.018074726685881615, 0.04153416305780411, -0.02666187472641468, 0.015474667772650719, 0.04705793410539627, -0.02549205720424652, -0.05245177820324898, -0.03380318358540535, 0.004828219767659903, -0.005827872548252344, 0.03584678843617439, -0.06173265352845192, -0.0076131634414196014, 0.03623603284358978, -0.07411812245845795, -0.00396061921492219, 0.02980628050863743, 0.05432383343577385, -0.016605660319328308, 0.04729476943612099, -0.0030222772620618343, 0.020507359877228737, 0.02972404472529888, 0.0036293058656156063, 0.032772213220596313, 0.011435886844992638, 0.04517742991447449, -0.05832070857286453, -0.056605901569128036, -0.005645321682095528, -0.07045932859182358, -0.045521002262830734, 0.0036934828385710716, 0.02517613209784031, 0.011168221943080425, 0.04682162031531334, -0.06982629001140594, -0.028890294954180717, 0.000297906924970448, 0.023470589891076088, -0.00619894964620471, -0.041810423135757446, 0.020546387881040573, -0.00887448713183403, 0.01560586504638195, 0.0029728312510997057, -0.017299233004450798, 0.03745482861995697, 0.0027426593005657196, 0.032163478434085846, -0.05576823279261589, 0.018049459904432297, -0.011562736704945564, -0.013979543931782246, 0.039904359728097916, 0.06327512860298157, -0.04253458231687546, 0.05752120167016983, 0.030646177008748055, -0.04884686693549156, 0.02341768704354763, -0.01616111770272255, -0.06284774839878082, -0.02256125770509243, -0.025401810184121132, 0.031170153990387917, -0.003915625158697367, -0.013830456882715225, -0.011555524542927742, -0.01852867752313614, -0.04123767092823982, -0.02219286374747753, -0.08219417929649353, 0.044609639793634415, -0.03276481851935387, 0.04856337234377861, -0.0268547423183918, -0.014597640372812748, 0.04842812567949295, -0.025019243359565735, 0.01408404391258955, -0.02694515883922577, -0.010844800621271133, -0.0074296495877206326, -0.04037666320800781, -0.01506012212485075, -0.05456811189651489, 0.029444513842463493, -0.005021682940423489, 0.04249998554587364, 0.02197485975921154, 0.041866522282361984, -0.06762334704399109, -0.022477982565760612, -0.012603585608303547, 0.027585163712501526, 0.02602563425898552, 0.03427086025476456, 0.028950495645403862, 0.0032063541002571583, -0.009037299081683159, 0.010149713605642319, -0.00408179871737957, -0.028059037402272224, -0.038245171308517456, 0.046514593064785004, -0.06322414427995682, -0.035529725253582, -0.026274491101503372, -0.01190513651818037, 0.06540226191282272, -0.028349732980132103, -0.010827912949025631, -0.028191376477479935, 0.05917828902602196, -0.05008004605770111, -0.04493893310427666, -0.06416352838277817, -0.05115878954529762, -0.061837758868932724, -0.01894882693886757, 0.018919553607702255, 0.04601645842194557, -0.03517964109778404, 0.024890542030334473, 0.032963912934064865, 0.024033496156334877, -0.05249890685081482, -0.0051601119339466095, 0.050561290234327316, 0.0277275200933218, 0.028817960992455482, -0.05240044370293617, -0.08346457779407501, 0.03564013913273811, -0.014569627121090889, 0.012781648896634579, -0.01831376738846302, -0.011827356182038784, 0.026179391890764236, 0.02084532380104065, -0.07701881974935532, 0.04049927741289139, 0.07493247091770172, -0.035760074853897095, 0.05634955316781998, 0.06849291920661926, -0.02844042330980301, 0.04093773663043976, -0.01759232021868229, -0.01853973977267742, 0.04763839393854141, -0.036401960998773575, -0.03539186716079712, -0.051261045038700104, -0.011064248159527779, -0.006157617084681988, 0.04264109954237938, -0.011960478499531746, -0.04114410653710365, -0.006095230579376221, 0.027699574828147888, 0.03306758031249046, -0.016659971326589584, 0.05506599694490433, 0.044478707015514374, -0.016299521550536156, -0.03915109112858772, -0.03722134232521057, -0.03599622845649719, -0.04204396903514862, 0.01972714252769947, -0.04341224208474159, 0.009917192161083221, 0.06083465367555618, -0.00904618576169014, -0.012851565144956112, -0.008900782093405724, 0.009630567394196987, 0.0037348323967307806, -0.024987252429127693, -0.02947634644806385, -0.025913149118423462, -0.030269557610154152, 0.004269422963261604, 0.014823918230831623, 0.022780796512961388, 0.03936585411429405, 0.00044711396913044155, 0.04736803472042084, -0.04386255890130997, -0.018538368865847588, 0.017813079059123993, -0.044573575258255005, 0.041958894580602646, -0.026591045781970024, 0.058284860104322433, -0.0024941428564488888, 0.018038088455796242, -0.0085401376709342, 0.04613632336258888, -0.013868167996406555, -0.006158841773867607, -0.054317690432071686, 0.007441231515258551, 0.006203047931194305, -0.032883498817682266, -0.034153133630752563, 0.03539867326617241, 0.017714757472276688, -0.010824711062014103, -0.0034009043592959642, -0.010095196776092052, 0.016651339828968048, 0.014063781127333641, 0.02457399107515812, 0.033331289887428284, -0.012419849634170532, 0.02201485075056553, 0.06875724345445633, -0.03701392561197281, -0.052687130868434906, -0.0053190505132079124, -0.039569247514009476, -0.0020277148578315973, -0.012371248565614223, 0.022430257871747017, 0.022790346294641495, 0.028698140755295753, -0.05911685898900032, 0.028974980115890503, -0.01551233883947134, -0.06811439245939255, 0.05211165174841881, 0.02400464192032814, -0.08583389222621918, -0.023988904431462288, -0.01310094352811575, -0.03617311269044876, -0.060989461839199066, 0.04104987904429436, 0.024073470383882523, 0.01303798332810402, -0.04035910591483116, 0.020571259781718254, 0.06823704391717911, 0.003473945427685976, -0.033477600663900375, 0.000319127575494349, -0.04218578711152077, 0.004910316318273544, -0.020958829671144485, 0.020999133586883545, -0.005231576040387154, 0.033102087676525116, 0.032763492316007614, -0.03953210636973381, -0.052487246692180634, 0.05811607465147972, -0.06502486765384674, -0.015490658581256866, 0.02356416918337345, 0.01830640248954296, 0.043170250952243805, 0.009592762216925621, -0.04970906302332878, 0.01145506277680397, -0.043737880885601044, 0.011651315726339817, -0.0483667254447937, -0.011546316556632519, -0.006939508020877838, 0.05627784505486488, -0.004773485939949751, -0.06849616020917892, -0.030310960486531258, -0.04991835355758667, -0.06346229463815689, 0.04300440847873688, -0.06757745146751404, 0.0220349058508873, -0.018155552446842194, 0.00474674953147769, -0.022931762039661407, 0.04845848307013512, -0.04140105098485947, -0.03438296169042587, 0.01615726202726364, 0.030223960056900978, -0.0007977725472301245, 0.004310367163270712, 0.02486003376543522, -0.001248144544661045, 0.06800102442502975, -0.0023361588828265667, 0.013234172016382217, -0.03611702471971512, -0.036138374358415604, 0.04789089411497116, -0.04567820206284523, -0.01825183816254139, -0.06314146518707275, 0.04924336448311806, -0.00903194211423397, -0.02040986903011799, -0.007517777383327484, -0.051237501204013824, -0.06153562292456627, 0.012970850802958012, 0.0018845869926735759, -0.03963986784219742, -0.02312929928302765, 0.03165934607386589, 0.03210168331861496, -0.024523017928004265, -0.0330781489610672, 0.03842571750283241, -0.02745431289076805, -0.02986166998744011, -0.04140262305736542, -0.06904251873493195, 0.02161153219640255, 0.01347319781780243, -0.06783652305603027, 0.006226944737136364, -0.002010698663070798, -0.056498024612665176, 0.010556778870522976, 0.028935298323631287, -0.01380536612123251, -0.007073508109897375, -0.06653192639350891, 0.019075961783528328, -0.05196252837777138, -0.054948143661022186, -0.04071854427456856, -0.029532475396990776, -0.000863978813868016, -0.02381075732409954, 0.00840798206627369, 0.005011904053390026, -0.0471925288438797, 0.0012487065978348255, -0.07049840688705444, 0.004332246724516153, 0.03755372017621994, -0.018623335286974907, 0.00897856056690216, -0.025083504617214203, -0.02712841145694256, 0.004403326194733381, 0.010837598703801632, -0.042999014258384705, 0.006995005998760462, -0.035207346081733704, 0.06239162012934685, -0.01455916091799736, -0.06371302902698517, -0.02711222507059574, 0.02232409454882145, -0.02091534435749054, -0.007493988145142794, 0.02249504067003727, 0.05294211581349373, 0.045368652790784836, -0.0522785522043705, 0.06858361512422562, -0.017103184014558792, 0.0656818151473999, -0.06242557242512703, 0.033098526298999786, -0.013478538952767849, -0.02404511347413063, 0.011047725565731525, -0.05337844043970108, -0.016526900231838226, 0.050617363303899765, -0.046676356345415115, 0.0012931604869663715, -0.05810507759451866, -0.03761035576462746, 0.044484980404376984, -0.004299921449273825, -0.04298305884003639, 0.05274449661374092, -0.04141603037714958, -0.024167712777853012, -0.00907490961253643, -0.005705616436898708, -0.0023426776751875877, -0.020664526149630547, 0.031647179275751114, -0.018312158063054085, -0.0023655290715396404, -0.05866657942533493, -0.025379860773682594, 0.025386039167642593, 0.01163591630756855, -0.034071870148181915, 0.07225637882947922, 0.03002893179655075, -0.006399031728506088, -0.03634339198470116, -0.027600083500146866, -0.03655887022614479, -0.05558427423238754, -0.03123427927494049, 0.010779531672596931, 0.027122491970658302, -0.018272247165441513, 0.022071536630392075, 0.0011943726567551494, 0.022517414763569832, -0.004777088295668364, 0.022478030994534492, -0.010434219613671303, 0.025830110535025597, -0.005345422774553299, 0.07157301157712936, -0.048449281603097916, 0.016718342900276184, -0.009543812833726406, 0.03269162029027939, 0.024945080280303955, 0.001420707325451076, -0.009692161343991756, -0.004032249562442303, -0.01937185786664486, -0.07237675040960312, 0.005741852335631847, 0.053778279572725296, 0.012522849254310131, -0.05677090212702751, -0.04314059391617775, -0.016115259379148483, -0.056732892990112305, -0.054749131202697754 ]
With the proliferation of hate speech on social networks under different formats, such as abusive language, cyberbullying, and violence, etc., people have experienced a significant increase in violence, putting them in uncomfortable situations and threats. Plenty of efforts have been dedicated in the last few years to overcome this phenomenon to detect hate speech in different structured languages like English, French, Arabic, and others. However, a reduced number of works deal with Arabic dialects like Tunisian, Egyptian, and Gulf, mainly the Algerian ones. To fill in the gap, we propose in this work a complete approach for detecting hate speech on online Algerian messages. Many deep learning architectures have been evaluated on the corpus we created from some Algerian social networks (Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter). This corpus contains more than 13.5K documents in Algerian dialect written in Arabic, labeled as hateful or non-hateful. Promising results are obtained, which show the efficiency of our approach.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11611v1
[ 0.019200118258595467, -0.03226519003510475, 0.006129489745944738, -0.06584351509809494, 0.02798113040626049, 0.014258905313909054, -0.016789287328720093, 0.016340719535946846, -0.06168324872851372, -0.03321777284145355, -0.04139620438218117, -0.024980325251817703, -0.010958528146147728, 0.011252532713115215, -0.0057754903100430965, 0.025761181488633156, 0.07225416600704193, -0.02459804341197014, -0.06039026007056236, 0.048863258212804794, -0.008330834098160267, -0.0012674105819314718, -0.0324077308177948, 0.05782405287027359, 0.03348308429121971, -0.009802578017115593, -0.039170991629362106, -0.0303416159003973, -0.004192791413515806, -0.020770905539393425, 0.07302190363407135, 0.0017939636018127203, -0.005809652153402567, -0.04229377582669258, -0.0389368012547493, 0.026750070974230766, -0.0262160487473011, 0.03332553058862686, 0.008757883682847023, -0.040410540997982025, 0.044609904289245605, -0.08272135257720947, -0.055517420172691345, -0.001884695142507553, -0.05970999225974083, 0.020227981731295586, 0.02650587446987629, 0.05115358531475067, -0.06945724040269852, -0.0253631379455328, 0.040794264525175095, 0.031833942979574203, -0.03492952510714531, 0.028753217309713364, -0.03913342207670212, -0.023592982441186905, -0.02476980909705162, -0.043876033276319504, -0.015208170749247074, -0.029931217432022095, 0.025156812742352486, 0.031681276857852936, -0.024981556460261345, -0.010180018842220306, -0.02271847426891327, -0.014173607341945171, -0.024196285754442215, -0.01420540176331997, -0.0177791565656662, -0.07501006871461868, 0.01665521040558815, -0.057094506919384, -0.017511868849396706, 0.009495383128523827, 0.0031250333413481712, -0.024279043078422546, -0.0015445551835000515, 0.007781460415571928, 0.019832201302051544, -0.005631521809846163, -0.03178567439317703, -0.0034200698137283325, 0.006060933228582144, -0.02990473248064518, -0.01522876974195242, -0.04983166605234146, 0.01681061089038849, -0.01642267405986786, 0.00879694614559412, 0.015759870409965515, 0.024034496396780014, -0.03436073660850525, -0.038431670516729355, -0.007683152332901955, 0.07400618493556976, 0.000025012939659063704, -0.007890427485108376, 0.01270801480859518, 0.0123545927926898, -0.054311323910951614, 0.010751988738775253, -0.004243506118655205, -0.0006403865409083664, 0.03480709716677666, 0.02858506329357624, -0.04680929705500603, -0.03331497684121132, 0.01257170457392931, -0.03111080266535282, 0.047033894807100296, -0.009496384300291538, -0.01288437657058239, -0.00675997557118535, -0.04678581655025482, -0.04746353253722191, -0.04253655672073364, 0.01532981637865305, -0.03289521113038063, -0.0005993193481117487, 0.023391857743263245, -0.020986605435609818, 0.05139991268515587, -0.010938715189695358, -0.029139336198568344, -0.03183368220925331, -0.01854107342660427, 0.05252945423126221, -0.011015670374035835, 0.021314451470971107, 0.022310810163617134, -0.019658632576465607, -0.006434868089854717, 0.008551320992410183, -0.030212126672267914, 0.05891535431146622, -0.022584067657589912, -0.016473783180117607, -0.005582687444984913, -0.03746350482106209, 0.03865744173526764, 0.0285617895424366, -0.02609845995903015, 0.012680452316999435, -0.04927587881684303, -0.003694881685078144, 0.04427114501595497, -0.027517350390553474, -0.012496422044932842, -0.03113654814660549, 0.016850054264068604, 0.04767977446317673, 0.05098358169198036, -0.006988270673900843, 0.03405371308326721, -0.020925171673297882, -0.010061034932732582, 0.021966882050037384, 0.03537166491150856, -0.040730658918619156, 0.03250856325030327, -0.016026604920625687, -0.056929655373096466, 0.05052925646305084, 0.01238781213760376, -0.02453652210533619, 0.030302274972200394, 0.05845223739743233, -0.01773822121322155, -0.024233117699623108, 0.012827683240175247, -0.06249912828207016, 0.05405011028051376, -0.019286135211586952, 0.029355792328715324, -0.05925643816590309, 0.0014645351329818368, 0.03305990993976593, -0.05349696800112724, -0.0476820208132267, 0.010925058275461197, 0.00395538005977869, 0.04561488702893257, -0.025204060599207878, -0.03151947632431984, -0.0002199142036261037, 0.045468464493751526, -0.06636207550764084, -0.0418633371591568, 0.02880491130053997, -0.006626596674323082, -0.009899749420583248, -0.03105241432785988, -0.013495001941919327, 0.013270358555018902, 0.011451813392341137, 0.008931877091526985, 0.017632504925131798, -0.06681355834007263, 0.0006582275964319706, 0.028815384954214096, -0.07310352474451065, -0.028034688904881477, -0.06685248017311096, -0.017950892448425293, 0.0353013277053833, -0.08555544167757034, -0.0071584745310246944, 0.021965865045785904, 0.01594795472919941, 0.015430469065904617, -0.0054326471872627735, 0.03532072901725769, 0.062376637011766434, -0.003076941007748246, -0.02094879560172558, 0.02403983473777771, -0.10067500174045563, 0.06106450408697128, 0.06240655854344368, -0.03605332598090172, 0.004093584604561329, 0.030049916356801987, -0.02298387512564659, -0.027746470645070076, -0.03697085380554199, -0.04208549112081528, 0.02931578829884529, -0.07162841409444809, -0.03709905222058296, -0.04538795351982117, -0.04323757067322731, -0.003800124628469348, -0.0051948996260762215, -0.04780585318803787, 0.03327469527721405, -0.05923769250512123, -0.026639485731720924, -0.02715497650206089, -0.05066147446632385, -0.0403825119137764, -0.006188603583723307, 0.01676386035978794, 0.041130367666482925, 0.04944375157356262, -0.01896827295422554, 0.04995528236031532, -0.030551716685295105, 0.033397745341062546, -0.016051333397626877, 0.0407487116754055, 0.03293630853295326, 0.005975393112748861, -0.018592944368720055, -0.007524522952735424, 0.027865683659911156, 0.011970588937401772, -0.014962452463805676, 0.04860152676701546, 0.022816533222794533, 0.06098050996661186, 0.0349014550447464, 0.03402559459209442, -0.03974156454205513, -0.045376766473054886, 0.012854269705712795, -0.02156972512602806, -0.014675320126116276, -0.03865912929177284, 0.04778217151761055, 0.01699948124587536, 0.0255794208496809, 0.05866723880171776, 0.025444090366363525, -0.017458252608776093, -0.026186157017946243, -0.04399827867746353, 0.060001593083143234, 0.0069503472186625, 0.02874896302819252, 0.027971243485808372, -0.03174373134970665, -0.027518322691321373, -0.006235368084162474, -0.07520532608032227, -0.020004088059067726, 0.01517857238650322, -0.043492890894412994, -0.03748598322272301, 0.037682775408029556, -0.024840980768203735, -0.057834550738334656, -0.028398392722010612, -0.0057976506650447845, -0.06629888713359833, -0.030730225145816803, -0.06679888069629669, -0.03738439455628395, -0.05643938109278679, 0.013553173281252384, 0.022140583023428917, 0.0022468799725174904, 0.003803796600550413, 0.035183385014534, -0.03242385387420654, 0.021650562062859535, 0.04390322044491768, -0.0024532624520361423, -0.05034768208861351, -0.008697031997144222, -0.039248108863830566, -0.004457960370928049, 0.024489041417837143, -0.07616168260574341, 0.02846084162592888, 0.034458234906196594, 0.028318779543042183, 0.003371761878952384, 0.013980822637677193, 0.009380274452269077, -0.033999551087617874, -0.005201756022870541, -0.045130934566259384, 0.0037434690166264772, -0.05498180165886879, -0.056869104504585266, -0.029986077919602394, 0.0062577431090176105, -0.023190714418888092, 0.010710600763559341, -0.023550281301140785, -0.0006408197223208845, 0.050118204206228256, -0.003010435961186886, 0.0037475465796887875, -0.03292325511574745, 0.062352921813726425, -0.04838588461279869, 0.0020799615886062384, 0.030055660754442215, -0.012232535518705845, 0.029182681813836098, -0.04544135183095932, -0.030721575021743774, 0.021551020443439484, 0.05826491117477417, -0.08517296612262726, 0.027863629162311554, 0.02872507832944393, 0.07146213948726654, -0.014367767609655857, 0.0016696392558515072, 0.00638611800968647, 0.01534865889698267, 0.018526636064052582, -0.018275314942002296, 0.027945859357714653, 0.03379431366920471, 0.086702361702919, -0.037781067192554474, -0.015371907502412796, 0.04581828415393829, -0.04145209491252899, 0.000007963229109009262, -0.03577161952853203, 0.02004205994307995, 0.055643774569034576, -0.0059815580025315285, -0.023651769384741783, -0.0425182580947876, 0.009946230798959732, 0.0502672977745533, -0.007597404066473246, -0.053975678980350494, 0.01845240406692028, -0.011083509773015976, 0.0647844672203064, 0.06112121045589447, -0.026320835575461388, -0.008200481534004211, -0.06791388988494873, 0.023112764582037926, -0.026372110471129417, 0.07089164853096008, 0.019987812265753746, 0.0063409931026399136, -0.0017783018993213773, 0.010852024890482426, 0.002726796083152294, 0.016439832746982574, 0.028367895632982254, -0.021514784544706345, -0.036670781672000885, 0.0015575395664200187, -0.02128715254366398, -0.05609918013215065, -0.04956173896789551, -0.01611127145588398, 0.06507138907909393, -0.044677115976810455, 0.007740993518382311, 0.034853171557188034, 0.014604893513023853, 0.005930841434746981, -0.0802469253540039, -0.005050612613558769, -0.014168334193527699, 0.002559301443397999, -0.03888890892267227, -0.005285982042551041, 0.04975299909710884, -0.051932718604803085, -0.021569333970546722, -0.03229553997516632, 0.05618421360850334, -0.045445237308740616, 0.025559326633810997, 0.024526312947273254, -0.05504811182618141, 0.026502065360546112, -0.05773663893342018, 0.05914498120546341, 0.007960918359458447, -0.016511011868715286, -0.009688065387308598, 0.028590025380253792, -0.070755735039711, -0.007998522371053696, 0.08204513788223267, 0.03442349657416344, 0.0077844345942139626, -0.02420131117105484, 0.025551211088895798, 0.03168884292244911, -0.03955857828259468, 0.0182124525308609, -0.0005115332314744592, 0.03399091958999634, 0.01959756575524807, 0.022167908027768135, -0.02702006697654724, -0.002319334540516138, -0.017010243609547615, -0.0735655203461647, -0.041386935859918594, 0.010424601845443249, 0.03261232748627663, -0.05489363148808479, -0.07870244234800339, 0.024982500821352005, -0.03311193734407425, -0.03755660355091095, -0.0017529773758724332, 0.050124067813158035, 0.0315302275121212, -0.00872836820781231, 0.021252010017633438, 0.01688537374138832, -0.025702668353915215, 0.009342487901449203, -0.009420319460332394, -0.0044680130667984486, 0.02954719215631485, 0.00041765376226976514, -0.022214733064174652, -0.007998093031346798, 0.03274707868695259, -0.01975901611149311, 0.008152608759701252, -0.06286383420228958, 0.05585705116391182, 0.01641799323260784, 0.07112959772348404, -0.06719744205474854, -0.03715948015451431, 0.07412710785865784, 0.012827344238758087, 0.04306149110198021, 0.00938660092651844, 0.014909419231116772, 0.0609297975897789, -0.028397802263498306, 0.017704008147120476, 0.008251477964222431, -0.016671419143676758, 0.032110411673784256, 0.04236482456326485, -0.029955187812447548, -0.05120391398668289, 0.01358619425445795, 0.008535617031157017, -0.02432362362742424, -0.013472959399223328, 0.06037763133645058, -0.012826086953282356, 0.008792060427367687, 0.05597471818327904, 0.04241456463932991, -0.021045316010713577, 0.04230190068483353, -0.055228471755981445, 0.012928076088428497, -0.029543159529566765, 0.045343607664108276, -0.020260857418179512, -0.02399599365890026, 0.0285247303545475, -0.013423155061900616, 0.03422227501869202, 0.011485409922897816, 0.06782171875238419, 0.0029175186064094305, -0.024793749675154686, -0.05289061740040779, -0.04974231868982315, -0.016058558598160744, -0.04769560322165489, 0.07245143502950668, 0.07638713717460632, 0.036548882722854614, 0.061760902404785156, -0.0023432159796357155, -0.03693992644548416, -0.029029134660959244, -0.005825465079396963, -0.05330199748277664, 0.010767241939902306, -0.030380185693502426, 0.03612930700182915, -0.02371682971715927, -0.0069517348892986774, 0.030881162732839584, -0.005016447976231575, -0.07058604806661606, -0.023699050769209862, -0.012272858060896397, -0.012705671600997448, -0.016556348651647568, 0.03245500847697258, -0.013725082390010357, 0.02639997936785221, 0.015214810147881508, -0.034846432507038116, 0.03473760932683945, -0.009504219517111778, -0.03562852740287781, 0.014888090081512928, 0.031640857458114624, -0.03704225644469261, 0.01719438098371029, 0.014144622720777988, 0.019155850633978844, -0.061688702553510666, 0.024776175618171692, 0.020749997347593307, -0.014157908037304878, -0.013363774865865707, 0.018768049776554108, -0.0505133680999279, 0.010191083885729313, -0.003272604662925005, -0.06214761734008789, 0.039469245821237564, -0.052256930619478226, -0.043804802000522614, 0.03273843228816986, -0.05234365165233612, -0.0653330460190773, 0.04521658271551132, 0.009844625368714333, 0.038875989615917206, -0.02844175137579441, 0.008761606179177761, -0.015783272683620453, 0.005405595060437918, -0.015437583439052105, 0.057252053171396255, 0.07352344691753387, -0.035589784383773804, 0.019674642011523247, 0.03133668005466461, -0.03411995247006416, 0.019246913492679596, -0.003971123602241278, -0.005488929804414511, 0.030180208384990692, 0.043244343250989914, -0.008586063049733639, -0.05517387017607689, -0.006059976294636726, 0.029640106484293938, -0.06084321066737175, 0.038690485060214996, 0.0055845994502305984, -0.03681042790412903, 0.05986470729112625, -0.01510981097817421, 0.006562376860529184, 0.016462191939353943, 0.015422044321894646, 0.011652096174657345, 0.00157831737305969, -0.031861938536167145, -0.02176595851778984, 0.005484506953507662, 0.040106676518917084, -0.08231478929519653, 0.01538785919547081, -0.002251110738143325, -0.09079154580831528, 0.0294625423848629, 0.0029289124067872763, 0.006094292271882296, -0.029535485431551933, -0.008714024908840656, -0.003066025674343109, -0.018766215071082115, -0.06003937870264053, -0.041153863072395325, 0.018459053710103035, -0.05163648724555969, 0.029836801812052727, -0.013032695278525352, 0.04675624519586563, -0.06070588901638985, 0.030412979423999786, -0.03507579118013382, -0.03611117601394653, -0.046387456357479095, 0.030916651710867882, 0.017245721071958542, 0.011053265072405338, -0.003353681182488799, -0.050053492188453674, 0.004164926242083311, 0.007316752802580595, 0.035694245249032974, 0.06861414760351181, -0.017349550500512123, -0.057626888155937195, 0.029767436906695366, 0.03972623869776726, -0.04156634584069252, -0.015551572665572166, 0.034423310309648514, -0.009338391944766045, -0.033905841410160065, 0.034528277814388275, -0.03304622694849968, -0.01312900148332119, 0.03386945277452469, -0.0392434298992157, -0.013134347274899483, -0.005320813041180372, -0.06966108828783035, -0.014402942731976509, 0.005546265747398138, -0.023133540526032448, -0.015718968585133553, -0.01962733082473278, 0.02385578118264675, -0.0056842779740691185, -0.0438849963247776, -0.04358149319887161, 0.019226202741265297, 0.020431987941265106, -0.011431490071117878, -0.05485320836305618, -0.028719821944832802, -0.05471392720937729, -0.08379916101694107, -0.027486715465784073, -0.019258668646216393, -0.027202220633625984, 0.01312639657407999, -0.08095678687095642, -0.00517591368407011, -0.017222879454493523, 0.04078299552202225, -0.05200920253992081, -0.04566657915711403, -0.06128866225481033, -0.06912471354007721, -0.011057247407734394, -0.0014242499601095915, -0.008909611031413078, 0.04013925790786743, 0.07436241209506989, 0.03069375641644001, 0.04843908175826073, -0.0021073983516544104, 0.009482134133577347, -0.002064619679003954, -0.049428243190050125, -0.01790434867143631, -0.004671564791351557, -0.02359340712428093, 0.03738052770495415, 0.021873723715543747, -0.020925484597682953, 0.012135227210819721, -0.05423254519701004, -0.025450004264712334, -0.029615407809615135, -0.03404378518462181, 0.043098386377096176, -0.029037440195679665, -0.04476138949394226, 0.056082867085933685, 0.0009457100532017648, -0.030444355681538582, -0.01171779166907072, -0.054886095225811005, 0.011358627118170261, -0.012245692312717438, -0.03278062492609024, 0.04846581444144249, -0.03135281801223755, -0.04719046503305435, -0.07352849096059799, -0.004343422595411539, -0.029655450955033302, 0.03755439072847366, 0.03783970698714256, -0.07234017550945282, 0.00936922151595354, -0.009995236992835999, 0.0027590831741690636, -0.03608008101582527, 0.048297010362148285, -0.00764604564756155, 0.04402488097548485, -0.01285248901695013, 0.07089515030384064, -0.05751480162143707, -0.03413878753781319, 0.0017654243856668472, -0.07209723442792892, 0.0033271857537329197, -0.0133490189909935, 0.04696187376976013, 0.04308418929576874, -0.018953055143356323, -0.007258561905473471, 0.057458505034446716, -0.02310270443558693, 0.047485947608947754, 0.030078886076807976, 0.015340843237936497, 0.043161045759916306, 0.0697687417268753, 0.06721405684947968, -0.020640462636947632, -0.060986317694187164, 0.04961550608277321, 0.0001861520140664652, 0.042900409549474716, 0.05889379233121872, -0.03344619646668434, -0.021237345412373543, -0.00047191776684485376, 0.02532169781625271, 0.018468204885721207, -0.0030867697205394506, -0.07725128531455994, -0.0468883216381073, 0.007295234128832817, 0.0012741226237267256, -0.04432482272386551 ]
The study of improper phases in the context of multiferroic materials has a long history, but superconductivity has yet to be connected to the network of ferroic orders. In this work, we highlight an overlooked mechanism that couples superconducting order parameters to odd-parity orders in the charge or spin sectors such that the latter emerge as improper orders. For that, we explore a novel perspective of nonsymmorphic symmetries based on extended symmetry groups in real space. We highlight how nonsymmorphic symmetries can generate rather nonintuitive couplings between order parameters. In particular, we find that a bilinear in the superconducting order parameter can couple linearly to odd-parity orders in centrosymmetric systems. Our findings can account for the unusual phenomenology of CeRh$_2$As$_2$, a recently discovered heavy fermion superconductor, and open the door for exploring nonsymmorphic symmetries in the broader context of improper orders with potential applications to functional materials.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05664v1
[ -0.03987940028309822, -0.0005425821873359382, 0.043171267956495285, 0.028789157047867775, 0.018820572644472122, -0.04329898953437805, -0.04618310183286667, 0.022276729345321655, 0.02227584458887577, -0.0037321518175303936, -0.0012936401180922985, -0.04475117474794388, -0.059995394200086594, -0.058699723333120346, -0.04499541223049164, -0.011127372272312641, 0.07862682640552521, 0.07359243184328079, -0.02153831161558628, 0.06765363365411758, -0.030873360112309456, -0.0368228442966938, -0.026346728205680847, 0.040426936000585556, 0.006379681173712015, -0.04453762620687485, -0.011500908993184566, 0.004960330668836832, -0.014750499278306961, -0.007018397096544504, 0.031079579144716263, -0.035024549812078476, 0.019686292856931686, 0.011515291407704353, -0.012630516663193703, 0.006397005170583725, 0.009411673992872238, 0.006981900427490473, 0.03711339086294174, -0.023908721283078194, -0.024852583184838295, 0.00100929313339293, -0.03778185695409775, -0.012843409553170204, -0.014132924377918243, -0.03366853669285774, -0.02373678982257843, -0.02674681879580021, -0.018305158242583275, -0.04243066534399986, 0.02722211740911007, 0.042631227523088455, 0.047334883362054825, 0.03478545695543289, -0.04875752702355385, -0.03416598588228226, 0.0038455300964415073, 0.04829353094100952, -0.05789950489997864, 0.0045977383852005005, -0.05654135346412659, -0.0225453432649374, 0.03682219237089157, -0.012447268702089787, -0.014283058233559132, 0.03444213420152664, -0.04191555827856064, -0.06511462479829788, -0.04313712194561958, -0.051549799740314484, 0.027325542643666267, -0.06567459553480148, 0.0061722188256680965, 0.010075763799250126, -0.07278717309236526, 0.02453181892633438, -0.04618106037378311, 0.004781499970704317, -0.015427380800247192, 0.021646691486239433, 0.014598189853131771, 0.016917917877435684, -0.003369739977642894, -0.0193625595420599, 0.013846366666257381, 0.014434312470257282, 0.05331473425030708, 0.004899119958281517, -0.010341683402657509, -0.04794345051050186, 0.03006185218691826, -0.01791837438941002, -0.055198416113853455, 0.012822323478758335, 0.05172091722488403, -0.00907691940665245, 0.04158870875835419, 0.07453851401805878, 0.04713086411356926, 0.02060561813414097, 0.012324094772338867, -0.037244610488414764, -0.04049758240580559, 0.015471147373318672, -0.005210369359701872, -0.02824186161160469, 0.0011814013123512268, 0.03941704332828522, -0.04148959740996361, 0.01021870132535696, -0.015801526606082916, 0.006324306130409241, -0.004683756269514561, -0.06962686032056808, -0.04957686737179756, -0.05524487793445587, 0.059506069868803024, 0.03071451745927334, 0.023550748825073242, 0.013671435415744781, -0.008093692362308502, 0.035993386059999466, -0.005413487087935209, -0.013305537402629852, -0.05444760248064995, -0.01887054741382599, 0.053231529891490936, 0.03839994594454765, -0.014363370835781097, -0.014369781129062176, -0.056179482489824295, 0.01201070100069046, 0.03446872532367706, 0.001082958304323256, 0.06880879402160645, -0.017535341903567314, 0.03317445144057274, 0.005241271108388901, 0.019335580989718437, 0.01011328399181366, -0.02354465425014496, -0.047210849821567535, 0.05638441815972328, -0.009359265677630901, 0.027498293668031693, 0.041718024760484695, -0.07256452739238739, -0.011314918287098408, 0.026384085416793823, 0.039438240230083466, -0.0006959522725082934, -0.001212223549373448, 0.023627303540706635, -0.0070218718610703945, 0.02009187452495098, -0.005836666561663151, 0.0436537079513073, -0.01463349536061287, -0.035957273095846176, 0.01299056876450777, 0.027503635734319687, 0.00034412232344038785, 0.036838844418525696, -0.0046761310659348965, 0.02599729411303997, 0.005704852752387524, 0.024825742468237877, 0.0012758461525663733, -0.028041385114192963, 0.02415688894689083, -0.030247874557971954, 0.03191832825541496, 0.051595538854599, -0.066248320043087, -0.05897265672683716, -0.0025168838910758495, -0.047670576721429825, -0.06146414950489998, -0.008647100068628788, 0.015484764240682125, -0.001250955043360591, 0.007605291903018951, -0.028254777193069458, -0.01090320199728012, -0.03358384594321251, -0.016925601288676262, -0.09310606867074966, 0.016151925548911095, 0.051397304981946945, 0.014564483426511288, -0.023288091644644737, -0.05701886862516403, 0.05093531683087349, 0.015851451084017754, -0.002526454161852598, -0.041711580008268356, 0.025167636573314667, -0.01584434136748314, -0.029914183542132378, 0.06926795095205307, -0.08199208229780197, 0.011088532395660877, -0.020903803408145905, -0.03054947592318058, -0.0019157937495037913, -0.054339729249477386, 0.025113526731729507, 0.00715827289968729, -0.04902513697743416, -0.025896387174725533, 0.0501067116856575, 0.032927971333265305, 0.04666784778237343, 0.03982200473546982, 0.009555959142744541, -0.012915834784507751, -0.1114528477191925, 0.03510812669992447, 0.014103882014751434, 0.0045602284371852875, 0.04028494283556938, 0.04352666065096855, -0.02895914763212204, -0.02808488719165325, -0.029508015140891075, 0.06441152095794678, 0.020822880789637566, 0.02891002595424652, -0.0038199471309781075, 0.01919717527925968, -0.030995400622487068, -0.02986811101436615, -0.03152003511786461, -0.06630325317382812, -0.011210989207029343, -0.036248743534088135, -0.05266619101166725, 0.04013121500611305, -0.005289390683174133, -0.0570857897400856, -0.08015209436416626, -0.018361521884799004, 0.061743706464767456, -0.0034771431237459183, -0.04286456108093262, -0.053113605827093124, -0.03939877077937126, 0.009273935109376907, -0.028589634224772453, -0.0019525312818586826, 0.03128594160079956, -0.04510447382926941, -0.013509778305888176, -0.03750842064619064, 0.023517997935414314, 0.06143767759203911, -0.02617056854069233, 0.018840521574020386, -0.02393146976828575, 0.037685245275497437, 0.020208658650517464, 0.03544773906469345, -0.009828467853367329, 0.000890196010004729, 0.04077160358428955, 0.0029958542436361313, -0.008345559239387512, -0.0067288693971931934, -0.004142759833484888, -0.0311697069555521, 0.03829403221607208, 0.051911111921072006, 0.04602726921439171, -0.031165054067969322, 0.0011646905913949013, -0.02070198766887188, -0.020522724837064743, 0.0026491854805499315, 0.0127932820469141, 0.04207470640540123, 0.0624849833548069, 0.039879634976387024, 0.009133031591773033, -0.0781378448009491, -0.013599656522274017, -0.024154746904969215, 0.004670273512601852, -0.03137711435556412, -0.006306360941380262, -0.05590519681572914, -0.04788905754685402, 0.027802633121609688, -0.023830562829971313, -0.02070966735482216, -0.030266784131526947, -0.03144415095448494, -0.010263346135616302, 0.030483247712254524, 0.013313590548932552, -0.0659012496471405, -0.05235787481069565, -0.025058139115571976, 0.025873536244034767, -0.0039020883850753307, -0.013455506414175034, -0.0709666833281517, -0.031792815774679184, 0.004547170363366604, 0.010691283270716667, -0.02431981824338436, -0.027233067899942398, 0.006250092759728432, -0.046281810849905014, -0.011655569076538086, -0.017084823921322823, 0.024716097861528397, 0.06017034128308296, -0.039536308497190475, 0.03963308781385422, -0.0008432645699940622, -0.014282445423305035, -0.018526330590248108, 0.006600795313715935, 0.013197283260524273, -0.07061859220266342, -0.01079244539141655, 0.0713883712887764, 0.04065604507923126, -0.052302438765764236, 0.004666274879127741, 0.018535654991865158, -0.03918277844786644, 0.026506640017032623, -0.02940061129629612, 0.04576212540268898, 0.036506231874227524, -0.021474672481417656, -0.02330145053565502, -0.02363143116235733, 0.0358431413769722, -0.0026737768203020096, 0.04643065109848976, 0.0006704397383145988, -0.039910849183797836, 0.012140337377786636, -0.06570720672607422, 0.005061200819909573, 0.03952513262629509, 0.05714314058423042, -0.02711506187915802, -0.025066690519452095, 0.030767716467380524, -0.0028003628831356764, 0.04309364780783653, -0.009926242753863335, 0.0221535824239254, -0.004438906908035278, 0.057972587645053864, -0.04161512851715088, -0.04259459301829338, -0.021157721057534218, -0.0641915425658226, -0.06164925545454025, 0.009398533962666988, 0.04211565479636192, 0.027445102110505104, 0.003915808163583279, -0.012754805386066437, -0.002117058727890253, -0.04230481758713722, 0.08288201689720154, 0.008595695719122887, -0.05168093740940094, 0.011057437397539616, -0.011285513639450073, -0.014459325931966305, -0.009382504969835281, -0.01496394444257021, -0.024305399507284164, -0.05462093651294708, -0.008272266015410423, -0.07494515925645828, 0.0255105160176754, 0.033836912363767624, -0.001428790856152773, 0.04210604727268219, 0.04334479570388794, 0.010418449528515339, 0.04819810017943382, 0.005554238799959421, 0.057268176227808, -0.015656733885407448, -0.0011252545518800616, 0.018156249076128006, 0.000987198087386787, -0.04822744429111481, -0.0005234652780927718, -0.017325501888990402, -0.019791562110185623, 0.02492677792906761, 0.02205333486199379, -0.006237484049052, -0.039512068033218384, -0.09652342647314072, 0.0024466468021273613, -0.03813078999519348, 0.05170173570513725, 0.03280704468488693, -0.05460359901189804, 0.0765678733587265, -0.04655337706208229, 0.013532869517803192, -0.031768616288900375, -0.02442285232245922, -0.02556721866130829, -0.052546966820955276, -0.052212055772542953, -0.051658257842063904, 0.03988546133041382, -0.057724855840206146, 0.002935540396720171, -0.01700184866786003, -0.012381997890770435, -0.06345529854297638, 0.036644306033849716, 0.03247687593102455, 0.0467260405421257, 0.03612830117344856, 0.021019695326685905, 0.009980564936995506, -0.048954639583826065, 0.0015186832752078772, -0.002505433978512883, 0.0005231899558566511, 0.017030829563736916, -0.04051107540726662, 0.025943167507648468, -0.05807480216026306, -0.019149569794535637, -0.03567836433649063, -0.009204141795635223, 0.04593227058649063, -0.04611056670546532, -0.0038042496889829636, -0.029377920553088188, 0.03741249442100525, -0.011488464660942554, -0.04389997199177742, -0.01944146119058132, -0.033727701753377914, -0.05900881811976433, 0.007315369322896004, 0.034450992941856384, -0.011201825924217701, -0.012830782681703568, 0.03588021546602249, -0.010502979159355164, 0.04534042999148369, -0.009001931175589561, 0.03340841084718704, 0.04365035519003868, -0.03608996421098709, -0.010964121669530869, -0.011634615249931812, -0.04499075934290886, -0.026377957314252853, 0.006371403578668833, -0.008270944468677044, -0.034614939242601395, 0.018916502594947815, -0.008810547180473804, 0.033266834914684296, -0.08803372085094452, 0.012007194571197033, 0.06508653610944748, -0.036938752979040146, -0.0264115110039711, -0.0003856042749248445, -0.002786665689200163, 0.006847497075796127, -0.044597335159778595, 0.01677088253200054, 0.004884281195700169, 0.026346005499362946, 0.010243907570838928, 0.010212947614490986, -0.016813015565276146, 0.01615014486014843, 0.034967925399541855, 0.0013760683359578252, -0.0677826851606369, -0.004666097462177277, 0.025734251365065575, 0.006411396898329258, -0.014426135458052158, 0.03268361836671829, 0.04218119755387306, -0.021365702152252197, -0.0444805882871151, -0.04532578960061073, 0.026813292875885963, 0.03172663226723671, 0.049339182674884796, -0.03813061863183975, 0.008855986408889294, 0.04209001734852791, -0.0018251350848004222, 0.014316683635115623, 0.05303957313299179, 0.0027947707567363977, -0.015145172365009785, -0.017857806757092476, -0.05216294899582863, -0.06876584142446518, 0.01410872396081686, -0.06363622099161148, 0.004848793148994446, -0.00954897329211235, -0.0029299913439899683, 0.05870133265852928, 0.006022516638040543, -0.022720687091350555, -0.0630614385008812, -0.03617358207702637, -0.026722269132733345, 0.0493653230369091, -0.04413926601409912, 0.0006194624584168196, 0.0011112077627331018, 0.04951172322034836, 0.040160395205020905, -0.026013866066932678, -0.06730900704860687, -0.006631819996982813, -0.050951238721609116, -0.01510460115969181, 0.03549892455339432, -0.05898319184780121, -0.043692365288734436, 0.012777846306562424, 0.04012695699930191, -0.04144083708524704, 0.049315109848976135, 0.0511149987578392, 0.00053452851716429, 0.012182914651930332, 0.027708280831575394, 0.027429644018411636, -0.016262367367744446, 0.0018821345875039697, 0.09551455825567245, -0.08918900787830353, -0.01749974489212036, -0.05223781615495682, -0.03784511983394623, 0.005920384544879198, -0.05474873259663582, 0.02494737319648266, 0.043803561478853226, 0.006670995615422726, -0.06007000058889389, 0.012908081524074078, 0.03553914651274681, -0.0632963702082634, -0.03628186881542206, 0.0223463736474514, -0.03938589617609978, -0.01401666458696127, 0.01210041157901287, 0.010860097594559193, -0.02978602610528469, 0.01598995551466942, 0.03832218423485756, -0.0524551160633564, -0.028952261433005333, 0.041211094707250595, 0.06937544047832489, -0.04235851764678955, 0.006324133835732937, 0.04734554886817932, 0.014079634100198746, -0.006831533275544643, -0.051713909953832626, 0.0005100884009152651, 0.0043199979700148106, 0.04403667524456978, -0.02179226651787758, -0.036993980407714844, -0.00867801159620285, 0.07291936129331589, 0.0018165446817874908, -0.03325992077589035, 0.01526967715471983, 0.03729413449764252, 0.0214484091848135, -0.01695268601179123, -0.02741270884871483, 0.01756725087761879, -0.001329495687969029, -0.015733344480395317, -0.009989014826714993, 0.050155043601989746, -0.043507661670446396, 0.051794808357954025, 0.0014435730408877134, -0.006317353807389736, -0.004211364313960075, 0.022385137155652046, -0.08352997153997421, -0.004043406806886196, 0.00264261057600379, -0.021139154210686684, -0.010679610073566437, 0.04641767963767052, 0.011072592809796333, 0.02178633213043213, -0.008112632669508457, 0.004275199491530657, -0.01835109107196331, -0.012129263021051884, 0.0050508719868958, 0.01459522731602192, 0.007681953255087137, -0.002663141582161188, 0.051779501140117645, -0.03707217425107956, -0.008410094305872917, 0.01728225313127041, -0.08360284566879272, 0.04082462936639786, -0.01117625366896391, -0.05350057780742645, 0.024111809208989143, -0.032943014055490494, -0.05410316586494446, -0.0004062266380060464, 0.04299640655517578, 0.005983131006360054, -0.08039417862892151, 0.017508460208773613, 0.020386716350913048, -0.00330625893548131, 0.04434620216488838, 0.0036185882054269314, 0.027959579601883888, -0.031292885541915894, 0.03686082363128662, 0.06835868209600449, 0.0298937801271677, 0.02154596336185932, -0.05174089968204498, -0.0416925847530365, 0.041227076202631, -0.003126211930066347, -0.004132258705794811, -0.020697133615612984, -0.025920117273926735, -0.06446737051010132, 0.00602691899985075, 0.00785683374851942, 0.0035613393411040306, -0.014113026671111584, -0.051627032458782196, 0.06557553261518478, 0.025216320529580116, -0.029095865786075592, -0.08245792239904404, 0.021148797124624252, 0.007753393612802029, -0.029947830364108086, -0.017588278278708458, -0.008621198125183582, -0.07464849948883057, -0.020353375002741814, -0.09201453626155853, 0.0006064223125576973, -0.015863804146647453, 0.07783588021993637, -0.011283110827207565, -0.011504314839839935, -0.03663114830851555, -0.03588537499308586, 0.019585613161325455, -0.0054465695284307, 0.017808232456445694, 0.03986299782991409, -0.01375412568449974, 0.03119676001369953, -0.035168085247278214, -0.027907608076930046, 0.0282874908298254, -0.045090191066265106, 0.0142119275406003, 0.04409337043762207, 0.061136841773986816, -0.01100854855030775, 0.030154163017868996, 0.02958601340651512, -0.031164580956101418, 0.0485968180000782, -0.03585758060216904, -0.023026637732982635, -0.054577067494392395, -0.07072722911834717, 0.04605748876929283, -0.06596047431230545, -0.011946693062782288, 0.012098882347345352, -0.02298933081328869, -0.00916934572160244, -0.030204709619283676, -0.05033380165696144, 0.04785149171948433, -0.00796480756253004, -0.006934820674359798, 0.04630148783326149, -0.06262893229722977, 0.0230544563382864, 0.010827037505805492, -0.019433550536632538, -0.007087917998433113, 0.053908854722976685, 0.053552888333797455, -0.06207108125090599, 0.011540547013282776, -0.08860569447278976, 0.06167634576559067, -0.018340665847063065, 0.006879598833620548, 0.005993329454213381, 0.059852052479982376, -0.05308208987116814, 0.005662246141582727, -0.02452870085835457, -0.007751580327749252, 0.01204768754541874, -0.07623070478439331, -0.019884252920746803, 0.005892052780836821, 0.005954681430011988, 0.046599943190813065, 0.05498119443655014, 0.044588785618543625, 0.05932722985744476, 0.048205357044935226, -0.017990125343203545, -0.009372678585350513, 0.016676824539899826, -0.06968146562576294, 0.04639394208788872, 0.019244424998760223, 0.023979555815458298, -0.06452861428260803, 0.00938865914940834, -0.02992061711847782, 0.04073821008205414, 0.008961435407400131, -0.0075739421881735325, 0.008389822207391262, -0.016822634264826775, -0.00984594039618969, 0.06202077120542526, 0.027604632079601288, -0.028391029685735703, 0.013443011790513992, 0.009382412768900394, -0.02999449521303177, -0.029873549938201904 ]
We present an apparatus that applies Ramsey's method of separated oscillatory fields to proton spins in water molecules. The setup consists of a water circuit, a spin polarizer, a magnetically shielded interaction region with various radio frequency elements, and a nuclear magnetic resonance system to measure the spin polarization. We show that this apparatus can be used for Rabi resonance measurements and to investigate magnetic and pseudomagnetic field effects in Ramsey-type precision measurements with a sensitivity below 100 pT.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18108v2
[ -0.06816516071557999, -0.014380953274667263, 0.006508622318506241, 0.007903947494924068, -0.012437833473086357, -0.03418002277612686, -0.03410618379712105, -0.0004034829034935683, 0.020550915971398354, -0.007525608409196138, -0.0441465824842453, -0.04988749697804451, -0.05096597969532013, -0.0671292245388031, -0.027725666761398315, 0.04652733355760574, 0.021633749827742577, 0.03726912662386894, -0.015088513493537903, 0.030588649213314056, 0.020799970254302025, -0.05514178425073624, -0.03373311087489128, 0.04385984688997269, 0.019801422953605652, -0.03685479983687401, -0.051568396389484406, 0.035401150584220886, -0.05067017674446106, -0.019358349964022636, 0.03869841247797012, -0.06149628013372421, -0.030603865161538124, 0.030707012861967087, -0.04417471960186958, 0.012883072718977928, -0.01946857199072838, 0.04396244138479233, 0.06360802054405212, -0.0084550054743886, 0.004253633785992861, 0.018009666353464127, -0.0711582601070404, -0.05052810534834862, -0.009463357739150524, -0.06899663060903549, -0.048614002764225006, 0.005704355426132679, -0.00510393688455224, -0.049542397260665894, -0.05312485992908478, -0.0012190622510388494, 0.007477372884750366, 0.041624777019023895, -0.05694504454731941, -0.020253105089068413, 0.009914243593811989, -0.024570684880018234, -0.0012222861405462027, 0.038241319358348846, 0.006391812115907669, -0.012477800250053406, 0.0037872951943427324, 0.019013434648513794, -0.0037467058282345533, -0.010037407279014587, -0.06394137442111969, -0.041001517325639725, -0.016593992710113525, -0.03064984641969204, 0.003413819009438157, -0.051704041659832, 0.02826204150915146, 0.005357817281037569, -0.023091649636626244, -0.036115922033786774, -0.004017856903374195, -0.009448444470763206, 0.009500503540039062, 0.05329231172800064, -0.06536293029785156, -0.025513075292110443, 0.026978330686688423, 0.06392156332731247, 0.039659008383750916, 0.022068237885832787, 0.011494732461869717, -0.041597481817007065, 0.03100305050611496, 0.012985184788703918, 0.020189790055155754, 0.005263612139970064, -0.0587318018078804, -0.013574809767305851, 0.07131440192461014, -0.04718352109193802, 0.020282424986362457, 0.03933479264378548, 0.03989843279123306, -0.04173243045806885, 0.023705212399363518, -0.002991435816511512, 0.01605621539056301, 0.028626486659049988, -0.010649754665791988, -0.03715837746858597, -0.016763819381594658, -0.004840388428419828, 0.02834337390959263, -0.02378077432513237, -0.06039128825068474, -0.009723791852593422, 0.0005268788081593812, -0.04383503645658493, -0.045724622905254364, -0.025052204728126526, 0.0015518078580498695, 0.014423107728362083, -0.04754135385155678, 0.0406184121966362, -0.07632866501808167, 0.008590267971158028, -0.0019121754448860884, -0.009436102584004402, -0.06441713869571686, 0.015338346362113953, 0.08195428550243378, -0.02774023450911045, -0.02302243374288082, -0.07479532808065414, -0.0405949167907238, 0.04543634131550789, 0.019229955971240997, -0.036832962185144424, 0.05162345618009567, -0.043754059821367264, 0.022518111392855644, -0.019787980243563652, -0.0359293594956398, -0.018428217619657516, 0.03078058734536171, -0.007361557800322771, 0.04265826195478439, 0.009239839389920235, 0.0286453515291214, -0.018219679594039917, -0.05405233055353165, -0.001068140147253871, 0.014506236650049686, -0.010978980921208858, -0.020360948517918587, -0.03661692142486572, -0.009346770122647285, 0.022477207705378532, 0.04312990978360176, 0.0036281270440667868, 0.04505539312958717, 0.00111539161298424, -0.03365703299641609, -0.024457605555653572, 0.05492901802062988, -0.02615267038345337, -0.009481963701546192, 0.043722596019506454, -0.04320182278752327, 0.006542997434735298, 0.030490465462207794, 0.00012022167356917635, -0.003828240092843771, -0.023814896121621132, -0.060795899480581284, -0.026881903409957886, -0.018380537629127502, -0.03187777101993561, -0.04187023267149925, -0.04223860427737236, -0.06167275458574295, -0.02106906846165657, -0.016409356147050858, 0.05161404609680176, 0.045015182346105576, -0.04847712442278862, -0.033945247530937195, 0.010404172353446484, -0.06721758842468262, 0.007797011639922857, -0.051298338919878006, -0.040486305952072144, 0.023506471887230873, -0.0147150419652462, -0.03443056344985962, -0.02172754518687725, 0.0088590607047081, -0.026722420006990433, -0.06397988647222519, 0.052175603806972504, -0.027525274083018303, -0.013573935255408287, 0.007892441935837269, -0.025813942775130272, -0.03509724140167236, -0.01008703000843525, -0.03937734290957451, -0.012698061764240265, -0.0006868837517686188, -0.06924732774496078, 0.043190062046051025, 0.020020170137286186, 0.037261638790369034, -0.03211690112948418, 0.037215881049633026, -0.0018443232402205467, 0.04155253618955612, 0.020603692159056664, -0.0715034157037735, 0.024351974949240685, -0.08926557004451752, 0.0038947616703808308, 0.05668880417943001, -0.009553991258144379, 0.001018908922560513, 0.03970583155751228, 0.009162981994450092, -0.04822918772697449, -0.014772946946322918, 0.03150898590683937, 0.04886242002248764, -0.015201328322291374, -0.06698854267597198, 0.00018407218158245087, -0.014174490235745907, -0.04783399775624275, -0.06770256906747818, -0.06478388607501984, -0.04572588950395584, 0.006201470736414194, -0.013255123980343342, -0.01711730659008026, -0.029128361493349075, -0.024364644661545753, -0.013363013043999672, -0.025210285559296608, 0.05939145386219025, -0.02672892063856125, -0.030350036919116974, -0.051668960601091385, -0.06189001351594925, 0.047840774059295654, -0.047915611416101456, -0.009980390779674053, -0.03287864103913307, -0.027042079716920853, -0.04039057344198227, -0.028480928391218185, -0.02288375236093998, 0.03526890650391579, -0.04102163389325142, 0.01669701375067234, -0.01913517713546753, 0.05479727312922478, 0.03202322497963905, -0.010373461991548538, -0.07804901152849197, 0.004399536177515984, -0.05314032360911369, 0.025701792910695076, -0.05389681085944176, -0.019859177991747856, -0.012762201949954033, -0.03146030381321907, 0.02134396880865097, 0.006328909192234278, 0.026638038456439972, -0.033467844128608704, -0.048654358834028244, 0.0014326694654300809, -0.039596691727638245, -0.0014940508408471942, 0.044408153742551804, 0.01825343258678913, 0.0714169293642044, -0.027492189779877663, 0.03004239872097969, -0.06080097705125809, -0.005525362677872181, -0.01991519145667553, 0.05516060069203377, -0.05117586627602577, -0.03401787206530571, -0.008838188834488392, -0.0783805176615715, 0.03809788078069687, -0.02928960882127285, -0.017019305378198624, 0.013048862107098103, -0.032501835376024246, 0.015131216496229172, -0.008054024539887905, 0.03135000914335251, -0.06814594566822052, -0.06740517914295197, -0.024173831567168236, -0.0024600783362984657, 0.05947863683104515, -0.05723375454545021, 0.004544619936496019, -0.0005550414207391441, 0.03831763565540314, 0.012181793339550495, 0.023660046979784966, -0.06381385773420334, -0.005190238356590271, -0.04626091197133064, 0.002947085304185748, -0.04166651517152786, 0.03434421494603157, 0.01056109368801117, -0.03415856882929802, -0.027953214943408966, 0.013151641935110092, 0.03523362800478935, -0.0069390940479934216, 0.05279114469885826, 0.016039952635765076, -0.02794635109603405, -0.021640554070472717, 0.029569903388619423, 0.07212645560503006, -0.010261928662657738, -0.03764038532972336, -0.03215514123439789, 0.01921210251748562, 0.039572011679410934, 0.02081545628607273, 0.027746401727199554, 0.019426673650741577, 0.03563910722732544, -0.001154978876002133, -0.05056481435894966, 0.0034304463770240545, -0.02275044657289982, 0.03566615656018257, 0.029319539666175842, 0.013549239374697208, -0.037971049547195435, -0.06789962947368622, 0.014714826829731464, 0.020434940233826637, 0.02784506417810917, -0.021436043083667755, -0.0014537278329953551, 0.016460875049233437, 0.03263545408844948, 0.022295571863651276, 0.017571790143847466, 0.042768921703100204, 0.0036954365205019712, 0.009569919668138027, -0.053902510553598404, 0.0035073512699455023, -0.027976782992482185, -0.06435741484165192, -0.03463912010192871, -0.009306339547038078, -0.014870543964207172, -0.02780790999531746, 0.06504194438457489, -0.01751968264579773, 0.004407651722431183, -0.01732035167515278, -0.006803970318287611, 0.06029698997735977, -0.027106039226055145, 0.0582372210919857, -0.03487095609307289, 0.026939701288938522, -0.004359902814030647, -0.035523153841495514, -0.0683758407831192, -0.05201477184891701, 0.04585454612970352, -0.012233509682118893, 0.01051576342433691, 0.023876704275608063, -0.017259890213608742, 0.003497751895338297, -0.026484277099370956, -0.0006334204226732254, -0.009308746084570885, 0.010030599310994148, 0.010622660629451275, 0.017025968059897423, 0.022527048364281654, -0.00332631915807724, 0.01589469611644745, -0.017702048644423485, -0.015989646315574646, -0.029723091050982475, -0.03200917690992355, 0.024702712893486023, -0.011729191057384014, -0.009011231362819672, -0.04594215005636215, -0.0768122598528862, 0.011198563501238823, -0.061077337712049484, 0.040303222835063934, 0.03898268938064575, -0.009579443372786045, 0.04534367471933365, -0.033144742250442505, 0.019973130896687508, -0.007156098261475563, 0.04873218387365341, -0.009805792942643166, -0.059773389250040054, -0.028597082942724228, -0.03641458600759506, 0.04455338045954704, -0.035734623670578, 0.05184216424822807, -0.040057528764009476, 0.034596074372529984, -0.0767659991979599, 0.04067901521921158, -0.06880363821983337, -0.03436354175209999, 0.025734977796673775, 0.04280293360352516, 0.06363461166620255, -0.0192409735172987, -0.022495491430163383, 0.026357993483543396, 0.04055865481495857, 0.04308860003948212, -0.0023603506851941347, 0.06992579996585846, -0.0716131255030632, -0.006355594377964735, -0.038222651928663254, 0.0006312407203949988, 0.011262170039117336, -0.0432710163295269, -0.02898971363902092, 0.020539309829473495, 0.05016086995601654, -0.009225254878401756, -0.04871943220496178, -0.08008573949337006, 0.0007594396010972559, -0.08430169522762299, -0.026419339701533318, 0.03263981640338898, -0.06162609905004501, -0.03706413879990578, 0.012896070256829262, 0.02919791080057621, 0.040443748235702515, -0.047979701310396194, 0.0147709921002388, 0.04973220452666283, 0.030341122299432755, -0.047505300492048264, -0.016199801117181778, -0.015912480652332306, 0.026203861460089684, 0.011317497119307518, -0.02526196278631687, -0.003211241913959384, 0.00992390513420105, 0.02225288562476635, 0.0008375896140933037, -0.07087977975606918, 0.019876325502991676, 0.005732784979045391, -0.05729150027036667, 0.005222541280090809, 0.002508565317839384, -0.0081850690767169, 0.048212677240371704, -0.027380451560020447, 0.005839165300130844, 0.04297133907675743, -0.035149335861206055, -0.010708852671086788, 0.006760349031537771, -0.0324387289583683, 0.0037218299694359303, -0.020313864573836327, -0.0058776312507689, -0.029303988441824913, -0.011692618951201439, 0.03624532371759415, 0.027687737718224525, -0.013531504198908806, -0.0008161392761394382, 0.06587977707386017, -0.018223222345113754, -0.06724517792463303, 0.007839947938919067, -0.0070645809173583984, -0.010587564669549465, -0.006254132837057114, -0.04497123137116432, 0.013769139535725117, -0.04193198308348656, 0.013672230765223503, 0.006219354458153248, 0.03470778837800026, -0.02166781574487686, 0.0252095777541399, 0.033953066915273666, -0.027490263804793358, -0.058604273945093155, -0.03980634734034538, -0.0594848208129406, 0.05827206000685692, -0.011670948006212711, 0.059383176267147064, 0.06975308060646057, 0.04938405379652977, 0.030032631009817123, -0.05920197069644928, -0.02556147798895836, -0.05682617425918579, 0.031572531908750534, -0.0004119794175494462, -0.0026169808115810156, -0.0045462679117918015, 0.0630892887711525, 0.023863855749368668, -0.025366082787513733, 0.0031254279892891645, -0.009191627614200115, -0.01712953671813011, -0.04261454567313194, 0.005879561882466078, 0.04415428638458252, -0.040247805416584015, -0.0016531224828213453, 0.033380478620529175, -0.0649474710226059, 0.07075115293264389, -0.00901230238378048, 0.013807818293571472, 0.03688888996839523, -0.008600665256381035, -0.0017445924459025264, -0.07079711556434631, 0.015459714457392693, 0.05353982746601105, -0.06252332031726837, -0.029494505375623703, -0.04671589285135269, -0.01718265190720558, -0.01768818311393261, -0.05627023056149483, -0.01703062653541565, -0.03951803967356682, -0.031440794467926025, -0.06020208075642586, -0.0012795208021998405, 0.01186517532914877, -0.03680121526122093, 0.0186946839094162, 0.0062764850445091724, -0.07114486396312714, -0.007278164383023977, 0.034086987376213074, -0.02445097640156746, -0.03366852551698685, 0.05080205574631691, -0.03663010895252228, -0.04016504064202309, 0.004205499775707722, 0.022614555433392525, 0.05180968716740608, 0.0009436074760742486, 0.006269650533795357, -0.038029994815588, 0.000961239798925817, -0.026273855939507484, -0.014866912737488747, -0.05551312491297722, -0.04073898121714592, 0.02214428223669529, 0.009498802945017815, -0.04354099929332733, -0.034462958574295044, -0.016685400158166885, 0.026342391967773438, -0.006160266697406769, -0.038057535886764526, 0.016326410695910454, 0.0513063445687294, -0.03576541692018509, -0.05285311117768288, -0.006507975049316883, -0.06516767293214798, 0.01783510483801365, -0.0016215910436585546, -0.012407313100993633, 0.05202809348702431, 0.04710587486624718, 0.008017003536224365, 0.023630905896425247, -0.04950810968875885, -0.061360038816928864, -0.02259804680943489, -0.00351318228058517, -0.05203919857740402, -0.04519500955939293, 0.015006312169134617, 0.01097581721842289, 0.04934801906347275, 0.017914488911628723, 0.006712520029395819, -0.00635284511372447, -0.013095011934638023, 0.047990087419748306, -0.0008814881439320743, -0.03717268258333206, -0.003891523228958249, -0.06156943738460541, 0.030695315450429916, -0.02566641941666603, -0.015237835235893726, -0.02391081489622593, -0.04406263306736946, 0.007757012266665697, 0.0013709956547245383, -0.001026701065711677, -0.02455384097993374, -0.02875959873199463, -0.015302861109375954, -0.03623872995376587, -0.00952238216996193, -0.043044015765190125, 0.012015053071081638, 0.0450589656829834, -0.015564247965812683, 0.02187528647482395, -0.06122557073831558, -0.05280308052897453, 0.005887091625481844, 0.007175650913268328, 0.04721910506486893, 0.046607669442892075, 0.0430699959397316, -0.00102840771432966, -0.06512634456157684, -0.010457337833940983, 0.060162924230098724, 0.007569938898086548, -0.07059359550476074, -0.03706326708197594, -0.044783998280763626, -0.059023577719926834, -0.023436754941940308, -0.042965371161699295, -0.056981950998306274, -0.018342552706599236, -0.020577695220708847, 0.046634964644908905, 0.053678564727306366, -0.05092400684952736, -0.07731710374355316, -0.03099379502236843, -0.0013752736849710345, -0.04881330206990242, 0.014263913966715336, -0.04778502136468887, -0.05307222902774811, 0.013208610005676746, -0.07678217440843582, -0.024822944775223732, -0.038140974938869476, 0.062133632600307465, 0.0005850906600244343, -0.02792658843100071, -0.06817327439785004, -0.020050842314958572, -0.018959352746605873, 0.035276543349027634, 0.025366341695189476, 0.019466910511255264, 0.030667252838611603, 0.024999981746077538, -0.03180382028222084, -0.02799087017774582, 0.04185802862048149, -0.010676037520170212, -0.0031955738086253405, 0.014684858731925488, 0.04365599527955055, -0.0064052981324493885, -0.030474305152893066, -0.0016666912706568837, -0.009793849661946297, -0.005574605893343687, 0.0019093644805252552, 0.037013839930295944, -0.0573134645819664, -0.06176053360104561, 0.05021052807569504, -0.05237022787332535, 0.022352293133735657, 0.0016728573245927691, 0.014472817070782185, -0.02941460907459259, -0.0037068102974444628, -0.06596705317497253, 0.04066285863518715, 0.047422729432582855, -0.008570553734898567, 0.07459200173616409, -0.047325652092695236, 0.034605007618665695, 0.0029743993654847145, 0.0019170577870681882, -0.0667712464928627, 0.05639466270804405, -0.009336097165942192, -0.04418667033314705, -0.017768412828445435, -0.019336603581905365, 0.024516480043530464, 0.036106448620557785, -0.01681676134467125, -0.015489470213651657, 0.05053531378507614, -0.06886336952447891, -0.060004156082868576, -0.029777728021144867, -0.01788179762661457, -0.0035561153199523687, 0.018496371805667877, 0.0015915075782686472, -0.008075051940977573, -0.0024757934734225273, -0.0029662989545613527, 0.055274344980716705, 0.01694808341562748, 0.02600124292075634, 0.024866769090294838, 0.015002453699707985, 0.011032205075025558, 0.009993393905460835, -0.022559169679880142, 0.04361853376030922, -0.001312202075496316, -0.014785923063755035, -0.0670495256781578, -0.043150003999471664, -0.06149543821811676, 0.041351087391376495, -0.015463427640497684, -0.003658702364191413, -0.05794641375541687, -0.025539694353938103, -0.04586202651262283, 0.0039787800051271915, -0.009949824772775173, 0.0048339469358325005, 0.0245417021214962, 0.03075420670211315, 0.03247435390949249, -0.05506269261240959 ]
By studying the distribution of calcium-aluminium-rich inclusions (CAIs) that are embedded within meteorites, we can learn about the dynamical history of the protoplanetary disk from which our Solar System formed. A long-standing problem concerning CAIs is the CAI storage problem. CAIs are thought to have formed at high temperatures near the Sun, but they are primarily found in carbonaceous chondrites, which formed much further out, beyond the orbit of Jupiter. Additionally, radial drift of CAI particles should have removed them from the solar protoplanetary disk several million years before the parent bodies of meteorites in which they are encountered would have accreted. We revisit a previously suggested solution to the CAI storage problem by Desch, Kalyaan, and Alexander which proposed that CAIs were mixed radially outward through the disk and subsequently got trapped in a pressure maximum created by Jupiter's growing core opening a planet gap. Our aim is to investigate whether their solution still works when we take into account the infall phase during which the disk builds up from the collapse of a molecular cloud core. We build a 1D numerical code in Python using the DISKLAB package to simulate the evolution of the solar protoplanetary disk, starting with a collapsing molecular cloud. We find that outward transport of CAIs during the infall phase is very efficient, possibly mixing them all the way into the far outer disk. Subsequent inward radial drift collects CAIs in the pressure maximum beyond Jupiter's orbit while draining the inner disk, roughly reproducing parts of the result by Desch et al. By introducing CAI formation so early, abundances out to 100 AU remain significant, possibly not consistent with some meteoritic data. It is possible to create a disk that does not expand as far out and also does not push CAIs as far out by using a very slowly rotating cloud.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13760v1
[ -0.03183259814977646, -0.04165806248784065, 0.032077446579933167, -0.030228229239583015, 0.019857944920659065, -0.00971981231123209, -0.001355716958642006, 0.0023425740655511618, -0.0171711016446352, 0.017158405855298042, 0.03967833146452904, -0.050215523689985275, 0.015180297195911407, -0.06969185918569565, 0.014201641082763672, 0.04132887348532677, 0.06460446864366531, -0.00003319922325317748, -0.045720379799604416, 0.08083030581474304, 0.0496574230492115, 0.03993111103773117, 0.018359491601586342, -0.020843399688601494, 0.046928130090236664, -0.015282017178833485, 0.0026008798740804195, 0.04509388282895088, -0.06566228717565536, -0.04408686235547066, 0.08541268110275269, -0.046460721641778946, -0.005724846851080656, -0.03631468862295151, -0.02505544014275074, -0.02858760394155979, 0.00941384769976139, 0.02780928835272789, 0.0033233780413866043, -0.022903604432940483, -0.029903659597039223, -0.07052287459373474, -0.02799033932387829, 0.004802601411938667, -0.06173531338572502, -0.044502727687358856, -0.003894718596711755, 0.019443798810243607, -0.0543011799454689, -0.0544816330075264, -0.000399901153286919, -0.0019315719837322831, 0.0026465989649295807, 0.027665534988045692, -0.021990887820720673, -0.014722202904522419, 0.01690923050045967, 0.01825794018805027, 0.0035789685789495707, -0.004260518122464418, -0.04905617982149124, -0.03391176089644432, 0.024521026760339737, -0.05145774036645889, -0.0062943389639258385, 0.06452188640832901, -0.041020818054676056, -0.02768685109913349, -0.017289336770772934, -0.03891192749142647, 0.04766189679503441, -0.0802336037158966, -0.01962697133421898, 0.028276480734348297, -0.055062081664800644, 0.057467371225357056, -0.03459412232041359, -0.03899877145886421, 0.024183519184589386, 0.033158011734485626, -0.03878162056207657, -0.006163892801851034, 0.042166296392679214, 0.02390412427484989, 0.012595041655004025, -0.00877296831458807, 0.0376250296831131, 0.006619559600949287, 0.026756176725029945, -0.027322668582201004, 0.021290015429258347, 0.001941384864039719, -0.02079138718545437, -0.04535709694027901, 0.07186371833086014, -0.023474695160984993, 0.055810920894145966, 0.07614336907863617, 0.0022333853412419558, -0.013123933225870132, 0.006369813811033964, -0.048918627202510834, -0.042589686810970306, 0.02151666395366192, 0.002930412767454982, -0.029412155970931053, -0.0028930341359227896, 0.0057114469818770885, -0.04548874869942665, 0.0464174747467041, 0.04795488715171814, 0.02000989392399788, 0.012966197915375233, -0.04820144176483154, -0.03348616510629654, -0.07625440508127213, 0.04856368899345398, -0.017696641385555267, 0.06787646561861038, 0.02030307613313198, -0.03930847346782684, 0.029366154223680496, 0.008590134792029858, -0.0065412623807787895, 0.013312626630067825, -0.013994692824780941, 0.04600083827972412, 0.014690502546727657, 0.000795582658611238, -0.0038773438427597284, -0.057921405881643295, 0.004045090172439814, 0.03233494982123375, -0.05143949016928673, 0.010277212597429752, 0.009791645221412182, -0.012640993110835552, 0.02288680523633957, 0.001466785790398717, 0.03816777840256691, -0.020436596125364304, -0.028746357187628746, 0.04123368114233017, 0.01666879653930664, -0.05203812196850777, -0.005932136904448271, -0.031086234375834465, -0.006753738038241863, 0.05736160650849342, 0.06515026837587357, 0.0057756430469453335, 0.04224289581179619, 0.012650256976485252, 0.0022636442445218563, -0.011617384850978851, -0.027753954753279686, 0.01890713721513748, -0.011833971366286278, -0.03350374102592468, 0.013513986021280289, -0.0022117833141237497, -0.03334808722138405, 0.0025953820440918207, 0.03310267999768257, 0.03197205066680908, 0.040879663079977036, 0.014336870051920414, -0.03677510842680931, -0.005349591840058565, 0.02360563538968563, -0.040938641875982285, -0.014558822847902775, -0.03413046523928642, -0.003219855483621359, -0.0036574937403202057, -0.013690585270524025, -0.02981569431722164, -0.02435818873345852, 0.008866347372531891, 0.016745105385780334, 0.03682011365890503, -0.010754384100437164, -0.046999819576740265, -0.008691866882145405, -0.026383105665445328, -0.026300830766558647, -0.07747168838977814, 0.0031181294471025467, -0.011752399615943432, 0.0027731438167393208, -0.029717957600951195, -0.015875976532697678, -0.009463026188313961, 0.0019198566442355514, 0.02589302323758602, 0.004947907291352749, 0.0475672148168087, -0.010248723439872265, -0.007587765343487263, 0.018080614507198334, -0.04102189466357231, -0.008099404163658619, -0.007549270987510681, -0.03100723773241043, 0.013224681839346886, -0.09048376232385635, -0.012000965885818005, -0.014364423230290413, -0.04126483201980591, -0.024906625971198082, 0.028812844306230545, 0.008698354475200176, 0.03449065610766411, 0.011997571215033531, 0.030677858740091324, 0.029032787308096886, -0.11145619302988052, 0.01136933546513319, 0.011534463614225388, 0.003027848433703184, -0.004869826138019562, 0.003856180002912879, 0.0013398169539868832, -0.04442712664604187, -0.032810311764478683, 0.04829417169094086, 0.007570063229650259, -0.012842903845012188, -0.06687811017036438, -0.027593117207288742, -0.038639917969703674, -0.054669421166181564, -0.06630785763263702, -0.022910278290510178, -0.02244611084461212, 0.04450945556163788, -0.053616225719451904, 0.06494837999343872, -0.026931580156087875, -0.009019428864121437, -0.047458600252866745, -0.01985481195151806, -0.009538698941469193, -0.04756257310509682, -0.06404881924390793, -0.009811017662286758, -0.044076625257730484, 0.03671151027083397, 0.007647091988474131, -0.011545746587216854, -0.02233058214187622, -0.04350772127509117, 0.023648764938116074, 0.0048827738501131535, 0.013425351120531559, 0.056623831391334534, -0.012525766156613827, 0.010331549681723118, 0.029550358653068542, 0.06007802113890648, -0.007531499490141869, 0.05434953793883324, -0.02110755816102028, -0.02106047235429287, 0.03006105124950409, 0.016272054985165596, -0.024819396436214447, -0.004606789909303188, -0.02917185239493847, 0.017339590936899185, 0.014768790453672409, 0.031461745500564575, 0.029296521097421646, 0.024713734164834023, 0.0016673081554472446, -0.04904009401798248, 0.0010312091326341033, -0.05149707943201065, -0.034477993845939636, 0.0001529374421807006, 0.019853144884109497, 0.04679587855935097, 0.004060567356646061, -0.07195654511451721, -0.03664341941475868, -0.03453749790787697, -0.021295666694641113, -0.003687084186822176, -0.04579676687717438, 0.04690255969762802, -0.06213223561644554, 0.03569330275058746, 0.0070679085329174995, 0.0010354180121794343, -0.0065450663678348064, 0.02865169756114483, 0.016282280907034874, -0.011068375781178474, 0.051951825618743896, -0.0034567725379019976, -0.049242302775382996, 0.0018015782115980983, 0.044499896466732025, 0.03235255181789398, -0.02586269937455654, 0.022797681391239166, -0.06010150909423828, 0.05061306059360504, -0.019177868962287903, 0.033223364502191544, -0.040094226598739624, 0.04969286173582077, -0.04165741801261902, -0.024808023124933243, 0.019044596701860428, 0.07980230450630188, 0.005721728783100843, -0.036760542541742325, -0.042164601385593414, -0.04900136590003967, -0.03709119185805321, -0.009447538293898106, 0.02619868330657482, -0.0003508599766064435, -0.08134137094020844, -0.04060923680663109, -0.0014580265851691365, 0.06329391151666641, 0.03388204053044319, -0.046331290155649185, -0.058029983192682266, 0.0038785261567682028, -0.02337074466049671, 0.012830274179577827, 0.045459721237421036, 0.047621533274650574, -0.04097525402903557, 0.0034659465309232473, -0.04296829551458359, 0.025371143594384193, 0.0030409982427954674, 0.01868954859673977, -0.00785187166184187, -0.03314170241355896, -0.005231580697000027, -0.0370701439678669, 0.027421951293945312, 0.04942971467971802, 0.032572150230407715, -0.01024068333208561, 0.04935458302497864, 0.03429771214723587, 0.014947501942515373, -0.006563347764313221, -0.044932786375284195, -0.0005326198879629374, 0.03608384355902672, 0.053518958389759064, -0.03689049184322357, -0.006531894207000732, -0.001663619070313871, -0.05948726087808609, -0.015876872465014458, 0.04622473195195198, 0.037629034370183945, 0.03734249994158745, 0.02044299803674221, -0.03026699461042881, -0.01161718275398016, -0.02066187560558319, 0.020492197945713997, -0.0652555450797081, -0.03612683713436127, 0.034152496606111526, -0.056671254336833954, 0.012794681824743748, -0.06786039471626282, 0.011519595049321651, -0.007356198038905859, -0.06800083070993423, 0.006099236663430929, -0.05348961427807808, 0.0084998095408082, -0.00048822059761732817, 0.04832832142710686, 0.02228621207177639, 0.0010269401827827096, 0.01853102073073387, 0.005378208123147488, 0.027546407654881477, -0.01381118968129158, -0.03964656591415405, 0.024943683296442032, 0.038150280714035034, -0.00015570074901916087, -0.0020523983985185623, 0.007861563004553318, 0.0020293015986680984, -0.01803702861070633, 0.006795444991439581, -0.05086223781108856, -0.008062191307544708, -0.00937158614397049, -0.07727095484733582, -0.04746350646018982, -0.034713439643383026, 0.024219803512096405, -0.02995615266263485, -0.03430251404643059, 0.057873085141181946, -0.04133089631795883, -0.011562108062207699, -0.011675775051116943, -0.04071350768208504, -0.025870533660054207, 0.027665359899401665, 0.017846351489424706, -0.02862486056983471, 0.028437575325369835, -0.0465024970471859, 0.013922054320573807, -0.012341768480837345, 0.04220344126224518, -0.05371455103158951, 0.04396677389740944, -0.029423698782920837, 0.0017564519075676799, 0.04868055135011673, -0.0030366447754204273, -0.0024296510964632034, -0.03310021385550499, 0.033444177359342575, -0.017386475577950478, 0.015675578266382217, 0.04547266662120819, -0.07128782570362091, 0.0342501625418663, -0.009496447630226612, -0.07171078026294708, 0.02003183402121067, -0.04820861294865608, 0.05903778597712517, -0.054783545434474945, -0.044263631105422974, 0.022501900792121887, -0.005430037155747414, -0.03288198262453079, -0.058496057987213135, -0.02194828912615776, -0.028811221942305565, -0.05264415219426155, 0.029201816767454147, -0.033616915345191956, 0.003626217134296894, -0.0014320991467684507, 0.04234227165579796, -0.02150195837020874, -0.01661517284810543, -0.014814415946602821, 0.040226537734270096, 0.005497504025697708, 0.03244967758655548, -0.03537731617689133, -0.016550233587622643, -0.0839015543460846, 0.033878836780786514, 0.012571918778121471, -0.06223806366324425, -0.041444331407547, 0.003715894417837262, -0.030777769163250923, 0.06288750469684601, -0.08619645237922668, 0.024702979251742363, 0.06141715496778488, -0.025163734331727028, 0.000985428923740983, -0.015217764303088188, 0.04437297210097313, -0.025848034769296646, -0.020231589674949646, 0.023449746891856194, -0.019332874566316605, 0.013309053145349026, 0.04798782244324684, 0.07433058321475983, -0.06336025893688202, -0.01059079822152853, 0.05980125442147255, -0.02064494416117668, -0.02408304437994957, -0.008122535422444344, 0.018631678074598312, -0.019616637378931046, -0.05467883497476578, 0.004220358561724424, 0.02547500468790531, -0.02379738911986351, -0.05547933280467987, -0.010648549534380436, -0.02171419933438301, -0.005487718153744936, 0.042781177908182144, -0.029526829719543457, 0.00729496031999588, -0.017275653779506683, -0.011502648703753948, 0.03190924972295761, 0.04780833423137665, 0.03719056770205498, 0.0009786655427888036, -0.03198814019560814, -0.008700964972376823, -0.06733572483062744, -0.003318984294310212, -0.06702423095703125, 0.05113006383180618, 0.028880232945084572, 0.050308238714933395, 0.020364226773381233, 0.0281686969101429, 0.017458321526646614, -0.039431843906641006, -0.021632643416523933, 0.04164375737309456, 0.021695174276828766, -0.039607685059309006, 0.022868361324071884, 0.004699544049799442, 0.0108976224437356, 0.004348824266344309, -0.010018182918429375, 0.02570204995572567, 0.010564952157437801, -0.034457989037036896, 0.01225811243057251, -0.025938017293810844, -0.046878959983587265, -0.05754133313894272, 0.00015844684094190598, 0.02480465918779373, -0.010975917801260948, 0.04760187119245529, 0.06229006499052048, -0.022354837507009506, 0.06025053933262825, -0.0673440620303154, -0.028789639472961426, -0.02150934375822544, -0.04402511939406395, 0.05404120311141014, -0.07060281187295914, 0.016460256651043892, -0.006561097223311663, -0.026737794280052185, 0.04166359081864357, -0.020972054451704025, 0.013505545444786549, 0.03378865122795105, 0.0005106902099214494, -0.03719162940979004, 0.039487484842538834, -0.0026449302677065134, -0.032944463193416595, -0.0020415354520082474, 0.01795329339802265, -0.0628749206662178, -0.02734152227640152, -0.04564367234706879, 0.047146935015916824, -0.04681886360049248, 0.041461024433374405, -0.03844572976231575, -0.051981065422296524, -0.05298910662531853, 0.05876035988330841, 0.07116492092609406, -0.04583154618740082, 0.023818328976631165, 0.018108323216438293, -0.045261383056640625, -0.0021699094213545322, -0.04028945416212082, 0.01644086465239525, -0.030115818604826927, 0.06948927789926529, 0.011251669377088547, -0.004328501410782337, -0.019009290263056755, -0.007391621824353933, -0.05325893685221672, -0.001352150458842516, 0.014186829328536987, 0.01755361258983612, 0.041006382554769516, -0.03640319034457207, -0.06945997476577759, 0.0012111510150134563, 0.019619407132267952, 0.026873890310525894, 0.006318356841802597, -0.003381777089089155, -0.020140014588832855, 0.044475991278886795, 0.012721540406346321, -0.06226198747754097, 0.022746102884411812, -0.01787431910634041, -0.05348537117242813, 0.04637227952480316, -0.039713431149721146, 0.002984989434480667, -0.038725849241018295, 0.034042734652757645, -0.00384558760561049, 0.04974597692489624, -0.048954881727695465, 0.031021295115351677, -0.028325917199254036, -0.04859501123428345, 0.008488520048558712, 0.00572461262345314, 0.018638109788298607, 0.028411883860826492, 0.027865011245012283, 0.04791081324219704, 0.005352615378797054, -0.039898574352264404, 0.012474232353270054, 0.0287119559943676, -0.0017935283249244094, -0.06961159408092499, -0.006795802619308233, 0.03594590350985527, -0.04484889283776283, 0.0002570161013863981, 0.05779079347848892, -0.04901932552456856, -0.05304735153913498, -0.025992443785071373, -0.03596102073788643, 0.006597909610718489, -0.030400780960917473, 0.0026934973429888487, 0.05930406227707863, -0.026424335315823555, 0.047267183661460876, 0.03569858521223068, 0.02437773160636425, -0.07882804423570633, -0.05732749402523041, -0.07043761759996414, 0.023536955937743187, 0.010706831701099873, -0.04272061213850975, -0.0364798940718174, -0.05283397063612938, -0.06763377785682678, 0.0026321369223296642, 0.03805920109152794, 0.042339589446783066, -0.04057172313332558, -0.04501713812351227, 0.05833548679947853, 0.022603122517466545, -0.027269059792160988, -0.02541402354836464, 0.036696504801511765, -0.03210725262761116, -0.01611058972775936, 0.05378080904483795, 0.013575614430010319, -0.013405545614659786, 0.029711604118347168, -0.0868147611618042, 0.05067247524857521, -0.06635148078203201, 0.051952656358480453, -0.021316060796380043, 0.027983063831925392, -0.008480840362608433, -0.07065928727388382, 0.03538134694099426, 0.030801553279161453, 0.01581675000488758, 0.042855024337768555, 0.029447514563798904, 0.04296986013650894, -0.01944098062813282, -0.04416188225150108, -0.02724001556634903, -0.028019441291689873, -0.014545806683599949, 0.05038071796298027, 0.028987564146518707, -0.031888291239738464, 0.0355372354388237, 0.031124357134103775, -0.01780129037797451, -0.015298085287213326, -0.025879397988319397, 0.020990040153265, -0.019157499074935913, -0.030537456274032593, 0.024570778012275696, -0.0051495288498699665, 0.006212154868990183, 0.04897517338395119, 0.005916541907936335, -0.005828869994729757, -0.03232376277446747, -0.0002020094689214602, -0.0033274537418037653, 0.020921409130096436, 0.009234934113919735, 0.08506666868925095, -0.08395841717720032, 0.015581438317894936, -0.0312536284327507, -0.01635066047310829, -0.05405280366539955, 0.03844258189201355, 0.04041321575641632, -0.07316979020833969, -0.003827250562608242, -0.06684838980436325, 0.008621103130280972, -0.07246968150138855, -0.006949080619961023, 0.0026614079251885414, -0.0019328156486153603, -0.025304606184363365, -0.0038628356996923685, -0.06635185331106186, -0.02583814039826393, 0.0074110073037445545, -0.02364174835383892, -0.023221321403980255, -0.027816932648420334, 0.05995567515492439, 0.019033381715416908, 0.02570997178554535, 0.05626719444990158, 0.06032157689332962, 0.06014256924390793, -0.04169274494051933, 0.02389851026237011, 0.011144852265715599, -0.07470100373029709, 0.029610300436615944, 0.0049396781250834465, -0.038341253995895386, -0.031632889062166214, 0.021799100562930107, 0.020688889548182487, 0.0375644713640213, -0.0013819850282743573, 0.011486600153148174, -0.015302635729312897, -0.0705336332321167, -0.044693395495414734, 0.0052109165117144585, 0.034293852746486664, 0.04059573635458946, 0.039703045040369034, 0.02872685343027115, -0.0037803647574037313, -0.070243701338768 ]
In this work we pretrain a CLIP/ViT based model using three different modalities of satellite imagery across five AOIs covering over ~10\% of Earth's total landmass, namely Sentinel 2 RGB optical imagery, Sentinel 1 SAR radar amplitude and interferometric coherence. This model uses $\sim 250$ M parameters. Then, we use the embeddings produced for each modality with a classical machine learning method to attempt different downstream tasks for earth observation related to vegetation, built up surface, croplands and permanent water. We consistently show how we reduce the need for labeled data by 99\%, so that with ~200-500 randomly selected labeled examples (around 4K-10K km$^2$) we reach performance levels analogous to those achieved with the full labeled datasets (about 150K image chips or 3M km$^2$ in each area of interest - AOI) on all modalities, AOIs and downstream tasks. This leads us to think that the model has captured significant earth features useful in a wide variety of scenarios. To enhance our model's usability in practice, its architecture allows inference in contexts with missing modalities and even missing channels within each modality. Additionally, we visually show that this embedding space, obtained with no labels, is sensible to the different earth features represented by the labelled datasets we selected.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.00119v2
[ -0.047928616404533386, -0.04605378955602646, 0.05884596332907677, 0.019213778898119926, 0.02485811710357666, -0.01790410280227661, -0.014364729635417461, 0.0065951962023973465, 0.027562320232391357, -0.03156837448477745, -0.02873930335044861, 0.024031607434153557, -0.04674177244305611, -0.01108479406684637, -0.05015607923269272, 0.055905453860759735, 0.06005074828863144, -0.023376112803816795, -0.038674481213092804, 0.0714258924126625, 0.054387059062719345, -0.040758807212114334, -0.04731304943561554, 0.016770513728260994, -0.024336552247405052, -0.016115790233016014, -0.01610596850514412, 0.017746958881616592, -0.023951157927513123, -0.03447979688644409, 0.032260581851005554, 0.027169151231646538, -0.012922341004014015, -0.019085533916950226, 0.012000729329884052, 0.000997218769043684, -0.025175098329782486, 0.05586935579776764, 0.04134521633386612, -0.0004783809999935329, 0.051195863634347916, -0.05249931290745735, -0.05396071448922157, -0.020821096375584602, -0.026497958227992058, -0.028415558859705925, -0.01879853382706642, -0.021318159997463226, -0.07184277474880219, -0.06278495490550995, 0.03536256030201912, 0.03367726132273674, 0.0015756525099277496, 0.026352079585194588, -0.0060097770765423775, 0.00477552879601717, -0.0009914383990690112, 0.019805733114480972, -0.056495726108551025, 0.022314850240945816, 0.03781326115131378, -0.06409043073654175, -0.02198275737464428, -0.023922685533761978, 0.0009861178696155548, 0.07194097340106964, -0.024511557072401047, -0.06103556975722313, -0.03192485123872757, -0.02212524227797985, 0.018175821751356125, -0.06438221782445908, -0.034039486199617386, 0.023993665352463722, -0.03920811042189598, -0.041569024324417114, -0.030454589053988457, -0.018035247921943665, 0.0011418976355344057, 0.009762476198375225, -0.038461487740278244, -0.027012379840016365, 0.048622168600559235, 0.06377112120389938, 0.009088553488254547, 0.0014756966847926378, 0.03604436293244362, 0.005090746097266674, -0.0010144272819161415, -0.02585405856370926, -0.003933772910386324, -0.043038055300712585, -0.054753128439188004, 0.04853492230176926, 0.06514588743448257, -0.03198522701859474, 0.028241995722055435, 0.00020674691768363118, 0.02151632122695446, 0.012315316125750542, -0.018011240288615227, 0.008607606403529644, -0.013996917754411697, 0.04295721277594566, 0.04322117567062378, -0.030119800940155983, 0.0013289226917549968, -0.008434433490037918, -0.04134832322597504, -0.004497668240219355, -0.04146899655461311, -0.009003992192447186, 0.0023114841897040606, -0.03846123069524765, -0.02277792990207672, -0.07869496941566467, 0.05729982629418373, -0.02391238696873188, 0.032028086483478546, 0.013570883311331272, 0.015993785113096237, 0.01897183060646057, 0.05534940958023071, -0.023220138624310493, -0.00890879426151514, 0.014465104788541794, 0.0643593817949295, -0.04158155992627144, 0.030095184221863747, -0.00755722913891077, 0.024050399661064148, 0.008186368271708488, -0.00979840662330389, -0.03499681502580643, 0.0497988797724247, -0.023974480107426643, 0.0029696919955313206, -0.012026842683553696, 0.012061773799359798, -0.025274071842432022, -0.0001780932943802327, -0.04095086082816124, 0.02156653441488743, 0.0017582091968506575, 0.03432874754071236, 0.023746389895677567, -0.0724198967218399, -0.0573442280292511, 0.022167880088090897, 0.033918604254722595, 0.0017431891756132245, 0.0031814947724342346, -0.016580304130911827, 0.05244781821966171, 0.003741055028513074, -0.03403367102146149, 0.050818607211112976, -0.02739429473876953, -0.007257064804434776, -0.000457879708847031, -0.015310592949390411, -0.04073816165328026, 0.02407943643629551, -0.0069321077316999435, -0.0100447628647089, 0.005287329666316509, -0.0040299175307154655, -0.023514214903116226, 0.029094120487570763, -0.037170201539993286, 0.000009736789252201561, -0.03476247191429138, -0.023462502285838127, -0.00706688966602087, -0.023198366165161133, -0.03465224429965019, 0.004466401878744364, -0.043875399976968765, -0.04763343185186386, 0.024239880964159966, 0.03439157083630562, 0.019762052223086357, -0.03283439204096794, -0.015559653751552105, -0.0717640370130539, 0.02410590648651123, -0.07455168664455414, -0.03323288634419441, 0.011870436370372772, 0.0016937803011387587, -0.045004162937402725, -0.04629318043589592, 0.030751895159482956, -0.016051989048719406, -0.07005218416452408, -0.03569096699357033, -0.005585874896496534, -0.04170111566781998, -0.0063544209115207195, -0.005756809841841459, -0.07721486687660217, 0.026243621483445168, -0.05356169119477272, 0.0045190900564193726, 0.034933388233184814, -0.07717272639274597, 0.010642935521900654, 0.04336374253034592, -0.031876787543296814, 0.026472369208931923, 0.04054449126124382, 0.0008465040009468794, 0.052869439125061035, -0.0012421364663168788, -0.03885272890329361, -0.015087726525962353, -0.09171205013990402, 0.053143713623285294, 0.041762374341487885, -0.017744416370987892, 0.02379169873893261, 0.001816627336665988, -0.0041535720229148865, -0.05960497260093689, 0.001885998877696693, 0.017852017655968666, 0.07057511061429977, -0.030418463051319122, -0.060163818299770355, 0.017021356150507927, -0.04166960343718529, -0.06175241619348526, -0.030212199315428734, -0.07702700793743134, -0.03524020314216614, -0.01612788997590542, -0.0049279737286269665, 0.038905829191207886, -0.024420902132987976, -0.005323128774762154, -0.019918452948331833, -0.002322874031960964, 0.0510253831744194, -0.058244653046131134, -0.05944365635514259, 0.01063191331923008, -0.06639548391103745, 0.05438755452632904, 0.0032369873952120543, -0.0317038856446743, -0.07037689536809921, -0.05056309327483177, -0.05505157634615898, -0.0034408802166581154, 0.011809556744992733, 0.06174365431070328, -0.014594719745218754, 0.03994178771972656, -0.04392736032605171, 0.07058700174093246, 0.031809817999601364, 0.03054976649582386, -0.07251586019992828, 0.026039650663733482, -0.005291828885674477, 0.036687057465314865, -0.05637111887335777, -0.04321737214922905, -0.0009274333715438843, -0.024755557999014854, -0.025769885629415512, -0.0029073157347738743, 0.06566942483186722, 0.023648405447602272, -0.0155204301699996, 0.009164820425212383, -0.047338418662548065, -0.023651419207453728, 0.014201050624251366, 0.04998748004436493, 0.03403029963374138, 0.021521857008337975, -0.021526403725147247, -0.07100428640842438, -0.04805011674761772, -0.06744161248207092, 0.03280431032180786, -0.07275892794132233, -0.06967014074325562, -0.04259822890162468, -0.054629016667604446, -0.03010689467191696, -0.032402604818344116, -0.05029068887233734, -0.008694860152900219, -0.0779838114976883, -0.03036670573055744, -0.03305651620030403, 0.004990359768271446, -0.023525962606072426, -0.017763111740350723, -0.046486832201480865, 0.021545197814702988, 0.0546477735042572, -0.005491700954735279, 0.00008142198930727318, -0.06471265107393265, -0.020501695573329926, 0.017997385933995247, -0.04796493798494339, -0.011175781488418579, 0.011237839236855507, -0.029117360711097717, 0.053346749395132065, 0.003935625310987234, 0.03302663937211037, 0.005211568437516689, 0.002218420384451747, -0.020410316064953804, -0.021144172176718712, 0.0009668476996012032, -0.007465295027941465, 0.040263451635837555, -0.036314237862825394, -0.04237273707985878, -0.04614705964922905, 0.03678175061941147, 0.06121225655078888, -0.03060414269566536, -0.006106538698077202, -0.045694734901189804, -0.004069540183991194, 0.00691795302554965, 0.0457502044737339, 0.038619715720415115, -0.006528857629746199, -0.03157775476574898, 0.025196341797709465, -0.003476561978459358, 0.006848213728517294, 0.023963062092661858, -0.04854336380958557, -0.03028835542500019, -0.004394084215164185, 0.03926294669508934, -0.08624371141195297, 0.056378401815891266, 0.0699731707572937, 0.08395800739526749, 0.028431637212634087, 0.013395321555435658, -0.007595366332679987, 0.048793766647577286, 0.014704279601573944, -0.03516097739338875, 0.014395931735634804, 0.030435994267463684, 0.04683949053287506, -0.055849380791187286, -0.056350063532590866, 0.018474746495485306, -0.08120232820510864, -0.025829149410128593, 0.02888723835349083, -0.004268490243703127, 0.04222489148378372, 0.054296113550662994, -0.04191168025135994, 0.027504773810505867, 0.014616778120398521, 0.029528947547078133, 0.022729692980647087, -0.05771864950656891, 0.011746400035917759, -0.06457214057445526, 0.027224762365221977, -0.012567502446472645, -0.027879657223820686, -0.026900367811322212, -0.03869010508060455, 0.013805724680423737, -0.05245545133948326, 0.04044967517256737, 0.009917117655277252, -0.029935073107481003, 0.05006639286875725, 0.01848071627318859, -0.002542356960475445, 0.029743552207946777, 0.0004502471419982612, -0.024823663756251335, -0.00831071101129055, 0.013167288154363632, 0.0014062196714803576, 0.015852998942136765, -0.005010724533349276, 0.0004895556485280395, 0.021029116585850716, -0.007109982892870903, -0.026007359847426414, 0.016383199021220207, 0.022648347541689873, 0.0018039635615423322, -0.07658813148736954, -0.01888943277299404, -0.04051496833562851, 0.005091394763439894, 0.0326957106590271, -0.01436428539454937, 0.05777433142066002, -0.0461680106818676, 0.00011684492346830666, -0.01689434051513672, 0.009729606099426746, -0.04199429973959923, -0.045917171984910965, -0.0342821404337883, -0.06255251169204712, 0.027940556406974792, -0.04456944391131401, 0.07612541317939758, -0.02127070724964142, 0.03531261160969734, -0.05005859211087227, -0.016194304451346397, 0.00043396849650889635, -0.011990935541689396, -0.036169614642858505, 0.025053981691598892, 0.005534103140234947, 0.03894279897212982, -0.0018763694679364562, -0.02832927368581295, -0.014575331471860409, 0.022698253393173218, -0.041042279452085495, 0.061783887445926666, -0.02339387871325016, 0.0058449250645935535, -0.0050803194753825665, -0.015825437381863594, 0.017442792654037476, -0.05512337386608124, 0.010706090368330479, 0.010228375904262066, 0.06986965239048004, -0.04056829959154129, -0.06456038355827332, -0.04203294217586517, -0.05132957547903061, -0.05585378408432007, -0.021074119955301285, 0.030461246147751808, 0.03284585848450661, 0.023984383791685104, 0.03272533789277077, 0.009638314135372639, -0.006254741456359625, -0.04740714654326439, 0.027647007256746292, -0.010608300566673279, 0.0022274088114500046, -0.027195416390895844, -0.05930837616324425, -0.08211109042167664, 0.04286859929561615, 0.009984169155359268, -0.02103959396481514, -0.007282115984708071, 0.017542390152812004, 0.033826690167188644, -0.005427955184131861, -0.08536369353532791, -0.03174721822142601, 0.006762496195733547, -0.01806880533695221, -0.00997552927583456, 0.024051588028669357, 0.03140368312597275, 0.06481242924928665, -0.03318149596452713, 0.023981109261512756, -0.006461685057729483, -0.044993821531534195, 0.009161513298749924, 0.0035996667575091124, -0.0661541074514389, -0.004734286107122898, 0.02810291387140751, 0.0004501219664234668, -0.03187243267893791, 0.013164165429770947, -0.0069792186841368675, -0.007248197682201862, -0.03115663304924965, 0.02602078765630722, 0.05749889463186264, -0.03025972843170166, -0.046409398317337036, 0.012881403788924217, 0.014718037098646164, 0.00018281710799783468, 0.004552812315523624, -0.04021412134170532, -0.003393928287550807, 0.056615427136421204, -0.03681488707661629, 0.022887874394655228, 0.03748927637934685, -0.00499613955616951, -0.006060441490262747, -0.010127192363142967, 0.0045384899713099, -0.05780941620469093, -0.03737020865082741, -0.036888908594846725, 0.040942344814538956, 0.052022650837898254, 0.058087125420570374, 0.02119200862944126, 0.025706304237246513, 0.000095568218966946, 0.020603271201252937, -0.0038174926303327084, -0.00978841818869114, 0.03600408136844635, -0.045142218470573425, 0.042568255215883255, 0.0032678127754479647, 0.007541229482740164, -0.014710835181176662, 0.04166308790445328, 0.011198787949979305, 0.006431079003959894, -0.046520356088876724, -0.041091438382864, 0.015091684646904469, -0.007572703994810581, -0.04281597211956978, -0.003930015489459038, 0.04341024160385132, -0.03965660184621811, 0.03724624216556549, 0.025030842050909996, 0.012237581424415112, 0.07004782557487488, -0.04151798412203789, -0.01832151785492897, -0.06985414773225784, -0.004217721056193113, 0.02386525645852089, -0.058126743882894516, 0.03783635050058365, -0.05373450741171837, -0.04234079644083977, 0.02821984514594078, -0.045301176607608795, -0.0044349683448672295, 0.006571278907358646, -0.003581475233659148, -0.014173430390655994, 0.0011363241355866194, -0.04852867126464844, -0.05419199913740158, 0.03607145696878433, 0.005549986381083727, -0.06167540326714516, -0.004447347018867731, -0.04731941223144531, -0.014578810892999172, -0.009801235049962997, 0.029974231496453285, -0.040493253618478775, 0.014179609715938568, -0.0419863685965538, 0.06025473773479462, 0.06699430197477341, 0.0331265963613987, 0.04886661842465401, 0.008713962510228157, -0.001337837427854538, -0.030673788860440254, -0.04688138887286186, -0.03796510398387909, 0.005638123024255037, 0.04010661318898201, 0.004269045311957598, -0.051212333142757416, -0.029314011335372925, 0.036915045231580734, -0.03442583233118057, 0.0014990310883149505, 0.04557618871331215, 0.029395265504717827, 0.04973595589399338, -0.020968051627278328, -0.027422817423939705, -0.015325171872973442, -0.03298851102590561, -0.031223857775330544, -0.033813972026109695, -0.017706645652651787, 0.023584218695759773, 0.040271710604429245, 0.0047280145809054375, -0.046142976731061935, -0.00014833465684205294, -0.05121047794818878, -0.049543596804142, -0.011540011502802372, -0.06489791721105576, -0.026023678481578827, -0.012180493213236332, 0.050076309591531754, 0.03018486499786377, 0.03215780854225159, -0.06132984906435013, -0.05297727510333061, -0.010034671984612942, 0.023236418142914772, -0.021042486652731895, -0.04198779910802841, 0.0121097881346941, -0.046073343604803085, 0.035533443093299866, -0.007413651794195175, 0.01299712248146534, -0.018435757607221603, -0.015381934121251106, -0.018267745152115822, -0.02127823792397976, -0.06367418169975281, -0.051101136952638626, 0.01751912385225296, -0.02821243740618229, 0.050618719309568405, -0.008374281227588654, -0.045490723103284836, -0.06757836043834686, -0.025700312107801437, -0.02400127798318863, -0.0257735475897789, 0.001192057621665299, -0.02159818820655346, 0.0487801767885685, -0.013068980537354946, 0.013252905569970608, 0.029142573475837708, -0.01872461661696434, -0.015387817285954952, -0.06445591896772385, -0.025244910269975662, 0.059680432081222534, 0.019987601786851883, -0.06877156347036362, -0.027778344228863716, 0.013041852973401546, -0.06852956861257553, 0.00226574600674212, -0.0022809416987001896, 0.0034164434764534235, -0.007681612391024828, -0.05994142219424248, 0.01663353107869625, -0.0017960004042834044, -0.025190046057105064, -0.08169805258512497, -0.027234122157096863, -0.032329220324754715, -0.03791707754135132, -0.038808129727840424, -0.037659306079149246, -0.06563206017017365, 0.03121970221400261, -0.08093903213739395, -0.007214195095002651, 0.02284853719174862, 0.03301483392715454, 0.022290309891104698, -0.04870966076850891, -0.025165174156427383, -0.04136038199067116, -0.04487617686390877, 0.0429496243596077, 0.01990381069481373, -0.03306490182876587, 0.02879718691110611, -0.003614072920754552, -0.03184313327074051, -0.05991101264953613, 0.022289389744400978, -0.03141509369015694, -0.023293334990739822, 0.04306856170296669, 0.029687264934182167, 0.004060288891196251, -0.016457023099064827, 0.0788034126162529, -0.010088680312037468, 0.05194425582885742, -0.03016316145658493, 0.006946686189621687, -0.0577804371714592, -0.042696088552474976, -0.021642912179231644, -0.011975809000432491, 0.05221852287650108, -0.023148493841290474, 0.01101908553391695, -0.009916169568896294, -0.034929316490888596, -0.038646288216114044, 0.013406825251877308, 0.019943444058299065, -0.014091197401285172, 0.04293161258101463, -0.06293968856334686, 0.004410797730088234, -0.01118575967848301, -0.014290750958025455, -0.05205696448683739, 0.003538055345416069, 0.04696446284651756, 0.015246544033288956, -0.016858138144016266, -0.03594245761632919, 0.0015275048790499568, -0.02396506629884243, -0.013144847936928272, -0.02287508361041546, 0.05648353323340416, 0.036803074181079865, -0.0030124762561172247, -0.05278440937399864, 0.011818892322480679, -0.02440490759909153, -0.04460238665342331, -0.03463585674762726, -0.02341865375638008, 0.025543756783008575, -0.017017967998981476, 0.003359129885211587, -0.041066888719797134, 0.051628049463033676, 0.02884102426469326, 0.05385622754693031, -0.007226171437650919, 0.012643439695239067, 0.017936864867806435, 0.08041439950466156, -0.011950282379984856, -0.006435634568333626, -0.05158234387636185, 0.03048863261938095, -0.03622082620859146, -0.029987405985593796, -0.042865507304668427, -0.02795078605413437, -0.02105368673801422, -0.05047013983130455, -0.02436741814017296, 0.027502622455358505, -0.032252561300992966, -0.034324947744607925, -0.029343774542212486, 0.06029311940073967, -0.013589235953986645, -0.058296091854572296 ]
We discuss our recent study of local quantum mechanical uncertainty relations in quantum many body systems. These lead to fundamental bounds for quantities such as the speed, acceleration, relaxation times, spatial gradients and the Lyapunov exponents. We additionally obtain bounds on various transport coefficients like the viscosity, the diffusion constant, and the thermal conductivity. Some of these bounds are related to earlier conjectures, such as the bound on chaos by Maldacena, Shenker and Stanford while others are new. Our approach is a direct way of obtaining exact bounds in fairly general settings. We employ uncertainty relations for local quantities from which we strip off irrelevant terms as much as possible, thereby removing non-local terms. To gauge the utility of our bounds, we briefly compare their numerical values with typical values available from experimental data. In various cases, approximate simplified variants of the bounds that we obtain can become fairly tight, i.e., comparable to experimental values. These considerations lead to a minimal time for thermal equilibrium to be achieved. Building on a conjectured relation between quantum measurements and equilibration, our bounds, far more speculatively, suggest a minimal time scale for measurements to stabilize to equilibrium values.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.00021v1
[ -0.009574801661074162, -0.02836189791560173, 0.014938268810510635, -0.006132643669843674, -0.00834039505571127, -0.026303065940737724, 0.008407819084823132, 0.017801234498620033, -0.028063978999853134, -0.006938472390174866, -0.025615476071834564, -0.05637681856751442, -0.055340155959129333, -0.06202168017625809, -0.05368565395474434, 0.024072198197245598, 0.07311946153640747, 0.03678625822067261, -0.0498727522790432, 0.06077245995402336, -0.0034898875746876, -0.035553380846977234, -0.007983601652085781, 0.052514173090457916, 0.010995733551681042, -0.0029918241780251265, 0.005081349052488804, 0.03792679309844971, -0.004828787874430418, -0.007923648692667484, 0.029546566307544708, -0.025640130043029785, -0.01409206073731184, -0.04028872027993202, -0.016295846551656723, -0.02572108991444111, 0.012568013742566109, 0.005642531905323267, 0.050455912947654724, -0.0333951897919178, -0.031019341200590134, -0.06689480692148209, -0.04209483042359352, 0.009241219609975815, -0.03747383505105972, 0.009128266014158726, 0.006981789134442806, 0.020465180277824402, -0.02163504995405674, -0.06403975933790207, 0.04368732124567032, 0.030624669045209885, -0.028625359758734703, 0.05052671581506729, -0.026814080774784088, 0.013408624567091465, -0.033332329243421555, -0.01628400944173336, -0.050189755856990814, -0.04447649046778679, -0.014682287350296974, -0.02452128194272518, 0.029556885361671448, -0.01116685476154089, 0.016237715259194374, 0.03527338057756424, -0.019718380644917488, -0.0812542662024498, -0.02678089402616024, -0.07433432340621948, -0.016069289296865463, -0.05644439533352852, 0.02107653208076954, 0.009207963943481445, -0.06536466628313065, -0.0072902715764939785, -0.02163541689515114, 0.008748485706746578, -0.0030447759199887514, 0.04585373029112816, -0.012601285241544247, 0.0007779566221870482, 0.024926116690039635, 0.03431379422545433, 0.0197848379611969, -0.0041860793717205524, 0.04605047032237053, -0.007455021142959595, 0.00412216130644083, -0.03409424051642418, 0.025617940351366997, -0.05265242978930473, -0.06206408515572548, -0.03084299899637699, 0.07501190900802612, -0.028946643695235252, 0.03995898365974426, 0.05639713257551193, 0.021505825221538544, -0.03817188739776611, 0.014034049585461617, -0.03729371726512909, -0.04082028195261955, 0.04847382754087448, 0.022113537415862083, -0.03235217183828354, -0.014388198032975197, -0.0009829072514548898, -0.05695309117436409, 0.004212809726595879, -0.03244100138545036, -0.0005436599021777511, -0.002146872691810131, -0.0327749140560627, -0.05059698224067688, -0.05224695801734924, 0.060247886925935745, -0.002209422877058387, 0.052282948046922684, -0.01818661205470562, -0.047454770654439926, 0.019632311537861824, -0.01603761874139309, 0.02884969301521778, -0.011003227904438972, 0.041296422481536865, 0.06254947930574417, 0.0054270732216537, 0.003663550363853574, 0.021505920216441154, -0.06634995341300964, -0.0043557374738156796, 0.005301217548549175, -0.0022990498691797256, 0.04094121605157852, 0.032190952450037, -0.030501624569296837, -0.012642288580536842, 0.014309478923678398, 0.0608988031744957, -0.05514151230454445, -0.053389471024274826, -0.026175158098340034, 0.006396672688424587, -0.01277545653283596, 0.012315383180975914, -0.07856524735689163, -0.004766690079122782, 0.05792269855737686, 0.03860078379511833, 0.014826602302491665, 0.020479287952184677, 0.028571894392371178, 0.03869898244738579, 0.04242061451077461, -0.017310313880443573, 0.02328849583864212, -0.01866539753973484, -0.05469125881791115, 0.03683917596936226, 0.06828349083662033, -0.03737914189696312, -0.010881992988288403, -0.03548761457204819, 0.028693290427327156, 0.022404927760362625, 0.03062388300895691, -0.012887352146208286, 0.01150136161595583, 0.016892703250050545, -0.02004074677824974, 0.007872669026255608, 0.03185218200087547, -0.04075958579778671, -0.056535135954618454, -0.05164939537644386, 0.007835923694074154, -0.021144624799489975, -0.04264339059591293, 0.013246585614979267, 0.007350499741733074, -0.015535455197095871, -0.038433462381362915, 0.005415637511759996, -0.014631753787398338, 0.024533849209547043, -0.08387130498886108, 0.031088126823306084, 0.029949447140097618, 0.02453017234802246, -0.03078211098909378, -0.026747172698378563, 0.02776150219142437, -0.005686628166586161, -0.015338207595050335, -0.017845509573817253, 0.02952777035534382, -0.01029356662184, -0.021561527624726295, 0.01844601146876812, -0.08364357054233551, -0.030626507475972176, -0.03579511120915413, -0.01548066083341837, -0.05035717412829399, -0.02273680828511715, 0.04018360748887062, 0.03787285462021828, -0.011507847346365452, -0.001678659114986658, 0.064215287566185, 0.007969492115080357, 0.036707453429698944, 0.007411727216094732, 0.016081076115369797, -0.0027077144477516413, -0.09744410216808319, 0.04516352340579033, -0.01358475536108017, -0.0020393761806190014, -0.0036800813395529985, 0.03744475170969963, -0.04618522524833679, -0.0269031822681427, -0.04167209193110466, 0.0779281035065651, 0.019039329141378403, 0.04497790336608887, -0.06469147652387619, -0.0203242227435112, -0.007143726106733084, -0.0471985787153244, -0.04282413423061371, -0.06811904162168503, -0.023650769144296646, -0.01011723279953003, -0.04984230548143387, 0.004766038618981838, -0.030196696519851685, -0.01454631332308054, -0.05081573873758316, -0.008263664320111275, 0.0512193888425827, -0.04723795875906944, -0.04141043499112129, -0.0596487894654274, -0.020202936604619026, 0.02200745791196823, -0.03879735246300697, -0.014126736670732498, -0.01197167206555605, -0.06236087903380394, -0.017464814707636833, -0.030963517725467682, -0.0007036553579382598, 0.06489191949367523, -0.0455794595181942, 0.05096884071826935, 0.03596512973308563, 0.06310693919658661, 0.02274451218545437, 0.033183783292770386, -0.020399801433086395, -0.0026607040781527758, 0.02487276680767536, 0.049297068268060684, -0.037539977580308914, -0.008259603753685951, -0.009568915702402592, -0.01350664533674717, 0.023499934002757072, 0.025534234941005707, 0.06670121848583221, 0.029622521251440048, 0.010800828225910664, -0.022112324833869934, -0.028292132541537285, -0.04702311009168625, 0.044048622250556946, 0.06592667102813721, 0.05534941703081131, 0.011638020165264606, 0.013396608643233776, -0.07105662673711777, -0.0202648788690567, -0.030936697497963905, -0.026294352486729622, -0.044938985258340836, -0.04990768805146217, 0.005105928517878056, -0.047927673906087875, 0.011653183959424496, 0.01958121359348297, -0.032489877194166183, -0.023348601534962654, -0.06810348480939865, -0.024537060409784317, -0.007001041900366545, 0.038122158497571945, -0.04308770224452019, -0.0453605093061924, -0.0028973626904189587, 0.029547927901148796, 0.002257466549053788, -0.02411310002207756, -0.043099284172058105, -0.007629001513123512, 0.016605276614427567, 0.04378974810242653, 0.003682520240545273, -0.038701094686985016, -0.012582509778439999, -0.03233436867594719, -0.013601461425423622, -0.0068319630809128284, 0.003200978273525834, 0.025705110281705856, -0.0005833996110595763, 0.021967725828289986, -0.027927611023187637, 0.003943496849387884, -0.03258543834090233, 0.040736474096775055, -0.007848714478313923, -0.0453602559864521, -0.06532963365316391, 0.06285951286554337, 0.04186677187681198, 0.01202396024018526, -0.03889032080769539, 0.015855634585022926, -0.014212217181921005, -0.016257021576166153, 0.03942300006747246, 0.055422451347112656, 0.06288688629865646, -0.04205052927136421, -0.0003369905170984566, -0.009695922955870628, 0.028033556416630745, -0.027995366603136063, 0.021882472559809685, -0.020992914214730263, 0.007238437421619892, 0.03911109268665314, -0.08046211302280426, 0.005051430780440569, 0.06807278096675873, 0.05105798318982124, -0.043654464185237885, -0.0015305392444133759, 0.011982778087258339, 0.019951123744249344, -0.002801236929371953, 0.005385991185903549, 0.0301276333630085, 0.04009328410029411, 0.05730705335736275, -0.0314721018075943, -0.03203094005584717, 0.013402569107711315, -0.05993213504552841, -0.06543097645044327, 0.01697930507361889, -0.00179342704359442, 0.03192877769470215, 0.03311329707503319, -0.046900562942028046, 0.03448689728975296, -0.04157133027911186, 0.05445040389895439, -0.05495082587003708, -0.04773010313510895, 0.004274860490113497, -0.03011692687869072, -0.016244925558567047, -0.0014693703269585967, 0.021273169666528702, -0.010592743754386902, -0.05905338004231453, 0.011780042201280594, -0.06610151380300522, 0.028079163283109665, 0.023488005623221397, 0.025146786123514175, 0.022699197754263878, 0.028876880183815956, -0.03332432731986046, 0.04598559811711311, -0.029638802632689476, 0.014731613919138908, -0.002845142735168338, 0.02017286792397499, -0.0017768002580851316, -0.005198668222874403, -0.05261046066880226, -0.005840223282575607, 0.03285140171647072, -0.023065488785505295, -0.01686231419444084, 0.03253290802240372, -0.025742685422301292, -0.0013658342650160193, -0.08756595849990845, -0.022100066766142845, -0.05912592634558678, 0.05585269629955292, -0.05443713068962097, -0.04716653376817703, 0.07890306413173676, -0.044941749423742294, 0.026645606383681297, -0.035877883434295654, -0.027351554483175278, -0.024621987715363503, 0.004756185691803694, -0.024599969387054443, -0.04653570055961609, 0.053601980209350586, -0.06485273689031601, 0.026410812512040138, 0.03741458058357239, -0.015530352480709553, -0.05480389669537544, 0.004581005312502384, -0.03166303411126137, 0.0517875999212265, 0.01008487306535244, 0.014181908220052719, 0.01899660751223564, -0.02504817768931389, 0.003301116870716214, 0.04259282723069191, 0.0010358919389545918, -0.02887202613055706, -0.010776836425065994, -0.004603871144354343, -0.04557042196393013, -0.04498565196990967, -0.037848327308893204, 0.005405348725616932, 0.04866979643702507, -0.033747002482414246, -0.015476980246603489, 0.02574845962226391, 0.04511604830622673, -0.0553457997739315, -0.07276593148708344, 0.005673933774232864, 0.015470948070287704, -0.06285551190376282, -0.00849183090031147, 0.01681729033589363, 0.02587079256772995, -0.02019289880990982, 0.022537490352988243, 0.010097228921949863, 0.03651824966073036, -0.0018411044729873538, 0.02880619652569294, -0.006830444093793631, 0.006131978705525398, -0.024497367441654205, 0.007706555537879467, -0.058464501053094864, -0.025508027523756027, -0.0033945690374821424, -0.05040065199136734, -0.012942463159561157, 0.06320944428443909, -0.013671442866325378, 0.031002311035990715, -0.0796528160572052, 0.03626396134495735, 0.0505049005150795, -0.05892404541373253, -0.0004900644416920841, 0.012286518700420856, -0.03900453448295593, -0.01872202754020691, -0.014145066030323505, 0.015815626829862595, -0.003014481393620372, 0.007835892029106617, 0.007680028211325407, -0.001478174002841115, -0.036240946501493454, -0.027432842180132866, 0.041626252233982086, -0.009671291336417198, -0.06714075803756714, 0.01393690425902605, 0.01333416998386383, -0.022349629551172256, -0.050725024193525314, 0.02645973674952984, 0.055109623819589615, -0.03981450945138931, -0.07165177911520004, 0.0003322326811030507, 0.006631606724113226, 0.022635335102677345, 0.039818864315748215, -0.07388385385274887, -0.008785117417573929, 0.011383714154362679, 0.03842770680785179, 0.0005164391477592289, 0.02190883830189705, -0.02906874381005764, 0.002216241555288434, 0.023345453664660454, -0.0403461828827858, -0.066953644156456, 0.007255449891090393, -0.029358888044953346, -0.00002897331432905048, -0.009781970642507076, 0.050750043243169785, 0.03668401762843132, 0.042645636945962906, 0.000787207914981991, -0.05879107862710953, -0.01566452533006668, -0.02471165731549263, 0.02403702214360237, -0.0544387549161911, 0.008708818815648556, 0.00977768562734127, 0.07297179102897644, 0.03412875533103943, 0.008432366885244846, 0.013999969698488712, -0.035356443375349045, -0.0144644221290946, 0.026272356510162354, 0.006469511426985264, -0.037575870752334595, -0.04727483168244362, 0.00871528685092926, 0.06126044690608978, -0.018115172162652016, 0.06909022480249405, -0.00790711771696806, 0.02300425060093403, 0.010285144671797752, 0.0058950018137693405, -0.010888226330280304, -0.03976866975426674, 0.006861347239464521, 0.08431391417980194, -0.05511385202407837, 0.004767835605889559, -0.04510665684938431, -0.013165709562599659, -0.03872993588447571, -0.021823693066835403, 0.011979020200669765, -0.012782730162143707, 0.0077264574356377125, -0.0851876437664032, 0.05579380318522453, 0.002601733896881342, -0.0821031704545021, -0.01821565069258213, -0.021130679175257683, -0.07713045924901962, -0.0005858084186911583, 0.04545464739203453, -0.03974626213312149, 0.0222125556319952, 0.03255879133939743, -0.006262589246034622, -0.03407597914338112, -0.033746637403964996, 0.06191886216402054, 0.07500565052032471, 0.0012469111243262887, 0.04381786659359932, -0.05191832780838013, -0.03327468782663345, -0.01104192715138197, -0.04337527975440025, 0.0010449928231537342, -0.025887487456202507, 0.03254033997654915, -0.027123555541038513, -0.01055651530623436, -0.0131442341953516, 0.045108385384082794, -0.04633563011884689, -0.0064504812471568584, -0.027613939717411995, 0.033801618963479996, 0.04909888282418251, -0.041220370680093765, -0.03390442207455635, 0.0103293526917696, 0.011909225024282932, -0.02962537482380867, 0.009619790129363537, 0.03228147327899933, -0.02666405402123928, 0.06126881390810013, 0.0034798341803252697, -0.021727077662944794, 0.043627239763736725, -0.015305867418646812, -0.04423277825117111, 0.03827765956521034, -0.05500881373882294, -0.01772295869886875, -0.006760588847100735, 0.023624513298273087, 0.0043491218239068985, 0.04284054785966873, -0.03439437597990036, 0.0362505204975605, -0.026182472705841064, -0.03424941375851631, 0.04179918393492699, 0.02935020811855793, 0.015028498135507107, -0.004501714371144772, 0.01248976681381464, -0.05649268999695778, -0.03496723622083664, -0.01778825931251049, -0.03439350053668022, 0.027319081127643585, -0.003615374444052577, -0.04006223753094673, -0.03006463125348091, 0.012557048350572586, -0.06784849613904953, 0.0030760979279875755, 0.060958366841077805, -0.028189685195684433, -0.06882178783416748, 0.011400793679058552, -0.001999267376959324, -0.03188825771212578, -0.026687657460570335, 0.05138217285275459, 0.0028839537408202887, -0.0010788216022774577, 0.04368835687637329, 0.05337989330291748, -0.019369332119822502, -0.0045104254968464375, -0.06036300212144852, -0.00776800187304616, 0.04420733451843262, 0.0009690651786513627, 0.0015916816191747785, -0.02486257255077362, 0.007540170568972826, -0.06782645732164383, -0.010970862582325935, 0.003536612493917346, 0.047265853732824326, -0.013287875801324844, -0.030224021524190903, 0.046608150005340576, -0.01092586200684309, -0.03973255306482315, -0.0679524689912796, -0.004981445148587227, -0.006385307293385267, 0.006435930263251066, 0.009920582175254822, -0.03371629863977432, -0.06417027860879898, 0.00037993729347363114, -0.08771117031574249, -0.018729373812675476, -0.04059433192014694, 0.04396083950996399, 0.023406237363815308, 0.01394867803901434, -0.008051766082644463, -0.042135510593652725, 0.03186562657356262, -0.00932328775525093, 0.01066564116626978, 0.03838743269443512, 0.03206703066825867, 0.025920230895280838, -0.04650769382715225, -0.03112504631280899, 0.06590496003627777, -0.03917934373021126, 0.006128265056759119, 0.03537674993276596, 0.03093516267836094, -0.03776593133807182, 0.02566390112042427, 0.05284880846738815, 0.005554273724555969, 0.041631992906332016, -0.04844915121793747, 0.01251960825175047, -0.042979806661605835, -0.07160542160272598, 0.02318647690117359, -0.02238931879401207, 0.01397766824811697, -0.011219312436878681, -0.02008877694606781, -0.058809053152799606, -0.04016173630952835, -0.03789912164211273, 0.03370106592774391, 0.03414688631892204, -0.022960415109992027, 0.07196573168039322, -0.031026119366288185, -0.0013514156453311443, 0.009580397047102451, -0.028854694217443466, -0.055585283786058426, 0.024257348850369453, 0.04112501069903374, -0.06052001193165779, 0.0005783701781183481, -0.06900813430547714, 0.05580243095755577, -0.04655279964208603, 0.012412344105541706, -0.02758142538368702, 0.053761012852191925, -0.02412339672446251, 0.02423601597547531, -0.046554069966077805, -0.0359240286052227, -0.03222058340907097, -0.07020755112171173, -0.006486549042165279, -0.018231946974992752, 0.012245964258909225, 0.016081903129816055, 0.06687823683023453, 0.014429350383579731, 0.06343451887369156, 0.016511468216776848, 0.01070457510650158, -0.028391318395733833, 0.03606110066175461, -0.057042669504880905, 0.06691575795412064, 0.03926527127623558, 0.005008684005588293, -0.06119830161333084, 0.033720001578330994, 0.022463973611593246, -0.013343515805900097, 0.03279813751578331, 0.006011745892465115, -0.015738122165203094, -0.0438692532479763, -0.022625824436545372, 0.029961086809635162, 0.017525427043437958, -0.039046525955200195, 0.025737619027495384, 0.007573616690933704, -0.0329718217253685, -0.06807150691747665 ]
This article provides a curated review of selected papers published in prominent economics journals that use machine learning (ML) tools for research and policy analysis. The review focuses on three key questions: (1) when ML is used in economics, (2) what ML models are commonly preferred, and (3) how they are used for economic applications. The review highlights that ML is particularly used to process nontraditional and unstructured data, capture strong nonlinearity, and improve prediction accuracy. Deep learning models are suitable for nontraditional data, whereas ensemble learning models are preferred for traditional datasets. While traditional econometric models may suffice for analyzing low-complexity data, the increasing complexity of economic data due to rapid digitalization and the growing literature suggests that ML is becoming an essential addition to the econometrician's toolbox.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00086v2
[ -0.018368350341916084, -0.049007635563611984, 0.04310388118028641, -0.011406844481825829, -0.0631827563047409, 0.01580965518951416, -0.016888771206140518, 0.007197866681963205, -0.007164614740759134, -0.04789832606911659, -0.027666959911584854, 0.0013870312832295895, -0.0173066183924675, 0.06121186912059784, -0.04877403751015663, 0.040145184844732285, 0.06529048830270767, 0.06176304072141647, -0.045260246843099594, 0.032006293535232544, 0.027364959940314293, 0.014806958846747875, -0.058890629559755325, 0.03482920676469803, 0.029805734753608704, 0.008046243339776993, -0.06846021860837936, -0.022031504660844803, -0.01642669178545475, -0.011715690605342388, 0.016287319362163544, -0.06696581095457077, -0.03695158287882805, -0.07491718232631683, 0.001264854334294796, -0.028788898140192032, 0.0329245999455452, -0.015134232118725777, -0.04579436779022217, -0.02369150146842003, 0.042333923280239105, -0.02836022526025772, -0.06208140775561333, -0.04563041776418686, -0.021333225071430206, 0.021352525800466537, -0.07655718177556992, -0.027565082535147667, -0.07160475850105286, -0.0320669487118721, 0.044842690229415894, 0.007036453112959862, 0.033780429512262344, 0.06616690009832382, -0.025686321780085564, -0.006591798737645149, 0.028995830565690994, -0.046392772346735, -0.06478878855705261, -0.01514680776745081, 0.022345317527651787, 0.02719808928668499, -0.006652527954429388, -0.004591119475662708, -0.02139800600707531, 0.018567772582173347, 0.025003738701343536, -0.06752019375562668, -0.0500468872487545, -0.05435920134186745, 0.06156265363097191, -0.06409071385860443, 0.03609270974993706, -0.026453016325831413, -0.038619264960289, -0.007267678156495094, -0.0008894026977941394, -0.02148246020078659, -0.009826434776186943, 0.018835989758372307, -0.04971196502447128, 0.052666954696178436, -0.026023367419838905, -0.03606759011745453, -0.003548522712662816, -0.0656028538942337, -0.010232940316200256, -0.029771987348794937, -0.010648378171026707, -0.033220767974853516, 0.02252523973584175, -0.00591014139354229, -0.05496908351778984, 0.0025214822962880135, 0.014126626774668694, -0.02863982878625393, 0.033794667571783066, 0.03616219013929367, 0.01309104822576046, 0.022966966032981873, -0.01484878733754158, -0.04456181824207306, -0.0335664227604866, 0.06978137046098709, 0.03641572967171669, -0.0613192655146122, -0.039905134588479996, -0.011513523757457733, -0.048788394778966904, -0.022366169840097427, -0.011398667469620705, -0.01620430499315262, -0.027864249423146248, -0.050168704241514206, -0.014815106987953186, -0.009092333726584911, 0.04328133910894394, 0.03422970324754715, 0.006569137796759605, -0.0076652271673083305, -0.056145016103982925, 0.03533407673239708, 0.02717043273150921, -0.02218066155910492, -0.03806575387716293, -0.038031041622161865, 0.05209508538246155, -0.01680675335228443, -0.05206232890486717, -0.0025335855316370726, -0.06803691387176514, -0.03054429218173027, -0.0009937803260982037, -0.007521804887801409, 0.048740554600954056, -0.02284534089267254, -0.03475702553987503, -0.07651998102664948, 0.037340741604566574, -0.03679191321134567, -0.05836085230112076, -0.07968700677156448, 0.031766414642333984, -0.0663674995303154, 0.0066138929687440395, 0.03885357081890106, -0.016424724832177162, -0.018245233222842216, -0.02402649261057377, -0.003284633858129382, 0.046082157641649246, -0.002520068781450391, 0.0192586500197649, 0.01358015276491642, 0.0342312753200531, 0.006659536622464657, -0.020014626905322075, -0.025539087131619453, -0.04061799496412277, -0.013998662121593952, 0.05447663366794586, -0.04580513387918472, -0.0019024068024009466, -0.06070662662386894, -0.03453344106674194, -0.00436217337846756, 0.04374733567237854, -0.0364864282310009, -0.00004526232442003675, -0.01025557890534401, -0.026334602385759354, 0.007736884988844395, 0.050828032195568085, -0.019270209595561028, -0.04040760174393654, 0.021017109975218773, 0.013499454595148563, -0.06984947621822357, -0.03641156479716301, -0.01298780832439661, 0.02511540800333023, 0.056393712759017944, -0.05412084236741066, -0.026594191789627075, -0.0017649257788434625, 0.046261321753263474, -0.06370057910680771, 0.020536279305815697, 0.013471833430230618, 0.01920354925096035, -0.022116191685199738, 0.02868650108575821, 0.014708759263157845, -0.031433094292879105, -0.010893876664340496, -0.06709392368793488, 0.04666638746857643, -0.02476835995912552, 0.00832412764430046, 0.04652436822652817, -0.07897558808326721, -0.035883985459804535, -0.010916933417320251, -0.024093709886074066, -0.03930371254682541, -0.044094957411289215, 0.0163323525339365, 0.044507090002298355, -0.026562407612800598, -0.008382732979953289, 0.011660236865282059, 0.059792324900627136, 0.017487695440649986, 0.04032864421606064, 0.05439614877104759, -0.01842697709798813, -0.08043083548545837, 0.04918203875422478, -0.037935253232717514, 0.00011109652405139059, 0.035256631672382355, 0.02138962410390377, -0.007518440019339323, 0.00998652633279562, 0.0026579906698316336, 0.040829844772815704, 0.04950133338570595, 0.023403258994221687, -0.025894546881318092, -0.02583014778792858, -0.032037101686000824, -0.06021103262901306, -0.060493480414152145, -0.06047496944665909, -0.0076142968609929085, -0.019711699336767197, -0.045940034091472626, 0.049368251115083694, -0.020733799785375595, -0.0380280576646328, 0.0002555385872256011, -0.006378507707268, -0.02217247523367405, 0.0355992428958416, -0.05315753072500229, -0.0493968203663826, -0.01714739389717579, 0.03491486608982086, -0.0143822580575943, 0.02177693136036396, -0.03862851858139038, -0.06310723721981049, -0.009987175464630127, -0.025830231606960297, 0.061033591628074646, 0.024176493287086487, -0.03212537616491318, 0.009959466755390167, 0.004104137886315584, -0.019064193591475487, 0.046621572226285934, 0.036358051002025604, -0.05977453663945198, 0.03749591484665871, 0.041898272931575775, -0.046111300587654114, -0.006578204687684774, 0.001857294701039791, 0.007160868030041456, -0.041952166706323624, 0.03650156781077385, 0.0444229356944561, 0.04612475261092186, -0.02432149276137352, -0.06022120639681816, -0.039389390498399734, 0.0038732385728508234, -0.06012018397450447, 0.002740620169788599, 0.028519179672002792, 0.03652719408273697, 0.05856647342443466, -0.0292196124792099, -0.05811849981546402, -0.055687204003334045, -0.05059022828936577, -0.06244785338640213, -0.061845142394304276, -0.06972575932741165, -0.027756627649068832, -0.07705338299274445, -0.040254879742860794, -0.022308237850666046, -0.05051390826702118, -0.046011656522750854, -0.07575786858797073, -0.05605216696858406, 0.008056213147938251, 0.011764902621507645, 0.0035249923821538687, -0.02370777353644371, -0.027167459949851036, -0.00905497744679451, 0.02638961374759674, 0.012566710822284222, -0.04985204339027405, -0.06407663971185684, -0.04069153964519501, 0.03591165319085121, -0.023709045723080635, 0.03429322689771652, 0.024993091821670532, -0.0269797183573246, 0.0024820398539304733, -0.01730741746723652, 0.05096559599041939, 0.013150193728506565, 0.010235034860670567, -0.03168272227048874, -0.02597724087536335, -0.0011810135329142213, -0.008364039473235607, -0.03478580713272095, -0.006558252964168787, -0.010067769326269627, -0.017664462327957153, 0.06027885526418686, -0.05235087126493454, -0.058537039905786514, -0.023798372596502304, -0.020114365965127945, 0.01260648388415575, 0.02974601276218891, 0.01691155880689621, 0.00018856112728826702, 0.018507443368434906, -0.008740904740989208, -0.01763288676738739, 0.004256142769008875, 0.002346609253436327, -0.027586733922362328, 0.02358175627887249, -0.03829990699887276, 0.014909963123500347, 0.01765514351427555, -0.0720394104719162, 0.04397771507501602, 0.013117194175720215, 0.0590943843126297, -0.015788396820425987, 0.007374551147222519, 0.0310991071164608, 0.004927069880068302, 0.02847294695675373, -0.006248655263334513, 0.04045366123318672, 0.053731776773929596, 0.04710825905203819, -0.055963966995477676, -0.042081568390131, 0.026388952508568764, -0.051912132650613785, 0.005108287557959557, 0.0002385614498052746, -0.0014956751838326454, -0.009288843721151352, 0.0021510832011699677, -0.04577064886689186, -0.007500501815229654, -0.015871796756982803, 0.02386220544576645, 0.008179466240108013, -0.04566517844796181, 0.034738339483737946, -0.04075833037495613, 0.010329661890864372, 0.016684511676430702, -0.04318539798259735, 0.04536060616374016, -0.03250154107809067, 0.013003873638808727, -0.060355402529239655, 0.015692194923758507, 0.05556271970272064, 0.0034585727844387293, 0.0006824214942753315, 0.03751645237207413, 0.003909190651029348, 0.04902641102671623, -0.034047238528728485, -0.045705024152994156, -0.03882221132516861, -0.02016749605536461, -0.037113696336746216, -0.007481385488063097, -0.051220089197158813, 0.01210812944918871, 0.06588058918714523, 0.009054291062057018, -0.035597093403339386, 0.007281039841473103, 0.01531789731234312, 0.00504783121868968, -0.07542067021131516, 0.029159944504499435, -0.05282532051205635, 0.015570147894322872, -0.002403771970421076, -0.04513230919837952, 0.05076749995350838, -0.0418851263821125, -0.042559072375297546, -0.023890823125839233, -0.0022764781024307013, -0.037583015859127045, -0.057143133133649826, -0.019440077245235443, -0.07631327211856842, 0.02257664129137993, -0.06122928857803345, 0.02663353458046913, -0.04659369960427284, -0.014174536801874638, -0.05527679994702339, -0.04373281076550484, 0.004377812147140503, -0.02404358610510826, 0.06335171312093735, 0.03509433940052986, -0.03542472794651985, -0.03226248174905777, 0.006333508528769016, -0.02873929776251316, -0.04836191609501839, -0.021286500617861748, -0.010148536413908005, -0.002097615972161293, 0.020313140004873276, -0.03172167018055916, -0.022589966654777527, -0.003715391969308257, 0.06506691128015518, -0.011228990741074085, 0.009302167221903801, -0.02053428441286087, 0.06062236428260803, -0.0679154247045517, -0.07798982411623001, -0.0259023979306221, -0.0422854945063591, -0.037246618419885635, -0.040067654103040695, 0.04871033877134323, 0.017792832106351852, 0.0008152108057402074, -0.019371235743165016, -0.0014921084512025118, 0.02008005417883396, 0.01288678776472807, -0.001610246836207807, -0.013579335063695908, -0.046498045325279236, -0.03279520571231842, 0.002699100412428379, -0.07092223316431046, -0.06430352479219437, -0.007867175154387951, 0.016156334429979324, 0.03468511253595352, 0.039711978286504745, 0.018660474568605423, 0.059887442737817764, -0.0730196163058281, 0.0016149500152096152, -0.019108403474092484, 0.03974379971623421, 0.03621635586023331, 0.06622288376092911, -0.013982634991407394, 0.029816241934895515, -0.04565722867846489, 0.03833319619297981, -0.011325908824801445, -0.032357726246118546, 0.01869032345712185, -0.04347828030586243, 0.018170243129134178, -0.007419985719025135, 0.03899097070097923, -0.04897133260965347, -0.055466149002313614, -0.0026314673013985157, 0.009133393876254559, -0.03588152304291725, -0.028733080253005028, 0.04326147586107254, 0.0003485420602373779, -0.04070980101823807, -0.045444075018167496, -0.06111203879117966, 0.022961968556046486, -0.023758206516504288, -0.031225167214870453, -0.02625863626599312, -0.01757805049419403, 0.01143724750727415, -0.03470541909337044, 0.0313076414167881, 0.013362940400838852, 0.024151818826794624, -0.015956714749336243, -0.016799461096525192, 0.017489805817604065, -0.05165053531527519, 0.01160807441920042, -0.05486126244068146, 0.03373342752456665, 0.028715819120407104, 0.007151318714022636, -0.013317228294909, 0.001627785386517644, -0.03191765397787094, 0.028191713616251945, 0.015000822953879833, -0.0017231095116585493, 0.008602743968367577, -0.017624346539378166, -0.001915246481075883, -0.02779664285480976, 0.03520485758781433, 0.056543152779340744, -0.01697184517979622, 0.04602409154176712, -0.04090023785829544, -0.036878280341625214, 0.02582428604364395, 0.005402558017522097, -0.03903265297412872, -0.033107172697782516, 0.047650277614593506, 0.016611775383353233, -0.03395921736955643, 0.014708624221384525, -0.004908144474029541, 0.023382142186164856, 0.023218439891934395, -0.01665577106177807, -0.04306903854012489, -0.03481663763523102, 0.034513991326093674, 0.019801007583737373, -0.0027052194345742464, 0.018712136894464493, -0.030250195413827896, -0.01006308663636446, -0.0009193384321406484, -0.027678772807121277, 0.05470951274037361, 0.04354323446750641, -0.0006646836409345269, -0.050012726336717606, 0.04688505083322525, 0.0036242243368178606, -0.06826551258563995, 0.01957760937511921, -0.012302815914154053, -0.04223073273897171, 0.020761236548423767, 0.042993709444999695, 0.03964552283287048, -0.052067238837480545, 0.04146381840109825, -0.04589483141899109, -0.0012012934312224388, -0.03990429267287254, 0.06404895335435867, 0.07814010232686996, -0.01907123066484928, 0.025801338255405426, -0.002562884008511901, -0.06347473710775375, 0.005623630713671446, -0.014883841387927532, 0.01051886286586523, 0.0013764087343588471, 0.01818663440644741, -0.004734085872769356, -0.03479360416531563, -0.0644347295165062, 0.053286362439394, -0.018235834315419197, -0.05641632899641991, 0.03990257903933525, -0.019645454362034798, 0.04524747282266617, -0.046973053365945816, -0.02895212173461914, -0.014223282225430012, -0.012643224559724331, -0.05023207888007164, -0.05102507397532463, -0.017365779727697372, 0.007662918884307146, -0.03569477051496506, -0.024048466235399246, -0.07053906470537186, 0.028939899057149887, -0.016602899879217148, -0.06438621133565903, -0.01597548834979534, -0.015869665890932083, -0.03926657512784004, 0.014709282666444778, 0.038565266877412796, -0.0380055196583271, 0.06817789375782013, -0.03320480138063431, -0.0127739692106843, -0.02051459811627865, -0.023210052400827408, -0.03400206193327904, -0.023130547255277634, 0.022883418947458267, 0.014652477577328682, 0.02143523469567299, -0.03294488787651062, -0.02935720421373844, -0.021061480045318604, -0.002710375702008605, -0.030774161219596863, -0.005965616088360548, -0.026882914826273918, -0.03841781243681908, 0.0030789803713560104, -0.010812676511704922, 0.016592631116509438, -0.011416479013860226, -0.04338093474507332, -0.05049724131822586, -0.050201669335365295, 0.01555909588932991, -0.003633328014984727, 0.0049543785862624645, 0.03365477919578552, 0.06327036768198013, -0.022099515423178673, -0.04531743749976158, -0.039518196135759354, 0.04954547807574272, 0.05642006918787956, -0.037776753306388855, -0.03742089495062828, 0.01933828741312027, -0.05833084136247635, -0.025006456300616264, -0.03726404532790184, -0.004631440620869398, -0.05283762514591217, -0.005711982026696205, 0.06833497434854507, -0.038009144365787506, 0.01810343749821186, -0.07145339250564575, -0.01073347870260477, -0.0069509935565292835, -0.03122902289032936, -0.06002553924918175, 0.016862312331795692, 0.010387138463556767, -0.052700892090797424, 0.024443522095680237, -0.021649470552802086, 0.0027829878963530064, 0.04608992114663124, -0.07680993527173996, -0.0018922805320471525, -0.009610403329133987, -0.0020989496260881424, 0.01863769441843033, -0.02777990885078907, -0.016190748661756516, -0.04371131584048271, 0.020850684493780136, 0.023052169010043144, -0.0008775287424214184, 0.037980854511260986, -0.011055625975131989, 0.017568981274962425, -0.0499081052839756, -0.029989076778292656, 0.02781837247312069, -0.016045792028307915, -0.018739715218544006, 0.03767198696732521, -0.011499098502099514, 0.02453319914638996, 0.0330204963684082, 0.05692071095108986, -0.037974342703819275, 0.023185288533568382, -0.002826458541676402, 0.00022617097420152277, -0.03712848946452141, -0.055556926876306534, 0.045835692435503006, -0.0012123745400458574, -0.01500660926103592, 0.01875615119934082, -0.012933594174683094, -0.005154493730515242, -0.02732624113559723, -0.05035348981618881, 0.019852787256240845, -0.035144589841365814, -0.006427348125725985, 0.025868985801935196, 0.03172667697072029, -0.007275692652910948, -0.04573038965463638, -0.035410426557064056, -0.02861117012798786, -0.031765107065439224, 0.009151170961558819, -0.017934191972017288, -0.008198540657758713, -0.06735491007566452, 0.004914626479148865, -0.04725908115506172, 0.010840478353202343, -0.04190599545836449, 0.07338963449001312, -0.02919756807386875, -0.013586554676294327, -0.0012695916229858994, -0.019070807844400406, -0.04983016848564148, -0.05592356249690056, -0.05212806165218353, -0.07069764286279678, 0.04679364338517189, 0.028365882113575935, -0.0045053549110889435, 0.03473753109574318, 0.05129975825548172, 0.040947455912828445, -0.01386190764605999, 0.037282224744558334, -0.05337411165237427, -0.029526356607675552, 0.05184338986873627, 0.01865139603614807, 0.04743795841932297, -0.036789510399103165, 0.02003411389887333, 0.01014561578631401, -0.044258370995521545, -0.030061133205890656, -0.0030210528057068586, -0.0012765403371304274, -0.04570288211107254, 0.005433863494545221, -0.03430699557065964, 0.015370432287454605, -0.04488837346434593, -0.027389949187636375, 0.012462781742215157, -0.0508623830974102, -0.034766074270009995 ]
Testing with randomly generated inputs (fuzzing) has gained significant traction due to its capacity to expose program vulnerabilities automatically. Fuzz testing campaigns generate large amounts of data, making them ideal for the application of machine learning (ML). Neural program smoothing (NPS), a specific family of ML-guided fuzzers, aims to use a neural network as a smooth approximation of the program target for new test case generation. In this paper, we conduct the most extensive evaluation of NPS fuzzers against standard gray-box fuzzers (>11 CPU years and >5.5 GPU years), and make the following contributions: (1) We find that the original performance claims for NPS fuzzers do not hold; a gap we relate to fundamental, implementation, and experimental limitations of prior works. (2) We contribute the first in-depth analysis of the contribution of machine learning and gradient-based mutations in NPS. (3) We implement Neuzz++, which shows that addressing the practical limitations of NPS fuzzers improves performance, but that standard gray-box fuzzers almost always surpass NPS-based fuzzers. (4) As a consequence, we propose new guidelines targeted at benchmarking fuzzing based on machine learning, and present MLFuzz, a platform with GPU access for easy and reproducible evaluation of ML-based fuzzers. Neuzz++, MLFuzz, and all our data are public.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16618v1
[ -0.03840808570384979, -0.00579180009663105, 0.038154784590005875, 0.025153959169983864, -0.03850216418504715, 0.02300173230469227, 0.01304247509688139, 0.00675243092700839, -0.004521636757999659, -0.033618517220020294, -0.06599515676498413, 0.03377451375126839, -0.026613881811499596, -0.04417344927787781, -0.058572620153427124, -0.003973606042563915, 0.045449137687683105, 0.034566909074783325, -0.02648409642279148, 0.05280110239982605, 0.014410079456865788, -0.05361803621053696, -0.08218206465244293, 0.026517461985349655, 0.013127636164426804, 0.010112917982041836, -0.013374503701925278, -0.0072184535674750805, -0.017268333584070206, -0.01208474300801754, 0.05370430275797844, -0.02649572305381298, -0.04318420961499214, -0.045863665640354156, -0.022760281339287758, -0.02845923602581024, -0.04425442963838577, 0.019889837130904198, 0.01276245154440403, -0.02805395796895027, 0.03041493520140648, -0.03501822426915169, -0.049348924309015274, -0.039227649569511414, -0.017691265791654587, -0.01282407809048891, -0.03955677151679993, 0.012861845083534718, -0.035852428525686264, -0.05418344959616661, 0.03992823511362076, -0.03648395091295242, -0.021317189559340477, 0.021303027868270874, -0.04711121693253517, -0.02090328000485897, -0.041606977581977844, 0.021852795034646988, -0.029471563175320625, 0.0007202083361335099, 0.038584738969802856, 0.02501068077981472, -0.02398870885372162, 0.002924252301454544, 0.008256979286670685, 0.03949357196688652, 0.005792322102934122, -0.0615854412317276, -0.047659244388341904, -0.027692707255482674, 0.018664134666323662, -0.050880931317806244, -0.03587668389081955, -0.004216296132653952, -0.030415572226047516, 0.005872079636901617, -0.05414324998855591, -0.011814919300377369, -0.005156155209988356, 0.014066296629607677, -0.03646840527653694, 0.021285949274897575, 0.011915498413145542, -0.01548024918884039, -0.034375954419374466, -0.0701509565114975, 0.0054773748852312565, -0.04368888586759567, 0.015041308477520943, -0.03523893654346466, 0.03412054479122162, -0.02582809329032898, -0.06350459158420563, 0.04239482060074806, 0.07040567696094513, -0.015314891003072262, 0.03347241133451462, 0.026761494576931, 0.0037221829406917095, -0.0205997321754694, -0.037712834775447845, -0.02023368328809738, -0.045273300260305405, 0.055702488869428635, 0.05028045177459717, 0.012185226194560528, -0.005867033265531063, 0.0024945279583334923, -0.05271812155842781, 0.0001741968881106004, -0.02324308641254902, -0.021453099325299263, -0.02301381342113018, -0.06975299119949341, -0.041031040251255035, -0.03157586231827736, 0.03504519909620285, 0.0034157042391598225, -0.00007779135194141418, 0.018187833949923515, -0.05165017396211624, 0.03697294741868973, 0.06483957171440125, -0.047720007598400116, -0.028064440935850143, -0.020184002816677094, 0.05877374857664108, -0.04711462929844856, -0.03805531933903694, 0.015511085279285908, -0.038092371076345444, 0.0279765073210001, -0.0005976730608381331, -0.009197618812322617, 0.07243435084819794, -0.016751529648900032, 0.015430547297000885, -0.04840712994337082, 0.044417478144168854, -0.02717544697225094, -0.04362015053629875, -0.01998729445040226, 0.034158654510974884, -0.033002618700265884, 0.049553871154785156, 0.06670593470335007, -0.04433758929371834, -0.013179360888898373, 0.03317395970225334, -0.003031256375834346, 0.003961966838687658, 0.003359581110998988, -0.03474445641040802, 0.03744185343384743, 0.033611029386520386, 0.0293007493019104, 0.04751560837030411, 0.02299215830862522, -0.025841666385531425, 0.0008885996066965163, 0.022851455956697464, -0.05882161110639572, -0.0011675218120217323, -0.01544489897787571, -0.0012355756480246782, -0.011781108565628529, 0.028832338750362396, -0.02722771465778351, 0.036241259425878525, 0.029571978375315666, -0.04172920435667038, -0.024607423692941666, -0.031143853440880775, -0.015466433018445969, -0.06794524192810059, -0.0018246687250211835, 0.03567151352763176, -0.05861977860331535, -0.057100117206573486, -0.007235487457364798, 0.012400513514876366, 0.026902854442596436, -0.051415640860795975, 0.031806863844394684, -0.039122696965932846, -0.010929403826594353, -0.08686938136816025, -0.0027445557061582804, 0.015428605489432812, 0.014221190474927425, -0.027577796950936317, -0.05358346924185753, 0.034384340047836304, 0.046628326177597046, -0.019466105848550797, -0.025776246562600136, -0.0200651865452528, 0.041599661111831665, -0.012990150600671768, 0.013925522565841675, -0.09246300905942917, -0.04284108057618141, -0.06555050611495972, 0.016662590205669403, -0.05471368134021759, -0.03423565998673439, 0.02473241649568081, 0.028466850519180298, -0.019074559211730957, -0.02445646934211254, 0.020582539960741997, 0.03026542067527771, 0.05677327141165733, 0.039091259241104126, 0.033981163054704666, 0.007927617989480495, -0.0995078980922699, 0.07165047526359558, 0.0010060083586722612, -0.0099983811378479, 0.01187608577311039, -0.04323511943221092, -0.039129044860601425, 0.010687514208257198, -0.011020299978554249, 0.03123348206281662, 0.029186485335230827, -0.04868919029831886, -0.027439279481768608, 0.008667073212563992, -0.005131025332957506, -0.02979104593396187, -0.05710075795650482, -0.05547381564974785, -0.00814824178814888, 0.027144894003868103, 0.009767873212695122, 0.0528668649494648, 0.05552963539958, -0.01629127375781536, -0.017356419935822487, 0.0014296169392764568, 0.04240989685058594, 0.005363148637115955, -0.043252360075712204, -0.03356626629829407, -0.02972320094704628, 0.03649016097187996, -0.03760429471731186, 0.009665083140134811, -0.05340934544801712, -0.010483307763934135, 0.0064199380576610565, -0.03758642077445984, -0.018156979233026505, 0.022898996248841286, 0.022915489971637726, -0.004574418067932129, -0.0008692117989994586, 0.0469200536608696, -0.03294563665986061, 0.026607295498251915, -0.06806885451078415, 0.04577876999974251, 0.02469562366604805, -0.003795177675783634, -0.02767259255051613, 0.004163229838013649, 0.04789069667458534, -0.03284833952784538, 0.00887121632695198, 0.043861377984285355, 0.0416099950671196, -0.011262201704084873, -0.049774833023548126, -0.019135724753141403, 0.018164196982979774, -0.03151635825634003, -0.0008314413717016578, 0.028881091624498367, 0.05606820061802864, 0.03295482322573662, 0.04001312330365181, -0.07314614951610565, -0.01840290054678917, -0.054985303431749344, -0.015004370361566544, -0.05756466090679169, -0.05773783475160599, -0.06438657641410828, -0.081026591360569, -0.026622945442795753, 0.008326198905706406, -0.029732344672083855, 0.010418727993965149, -0.04791523888707161, -0.04718831554055214, -0.017131824046373367, -0.0072377645410597324, 0.007732812315225601, -0.03808947652578354, -0.06856762617826462, 0.003413812257349491, 0.02987509034574032, 0.05323982238769531, -0.08046817779541016, -0.00578466709703207, -0.01906999945640564, 0.028512677177786827, 0.053376875817775726, -0.028519954532384872, 0.051871251314878464, -0.04024722799658775, 0.027764782309532166, 0.003525343956425786, 0.057872503995895386, -0.024997156113386154, 0.026765121147036552, -0.0036106982734054327, -0.03875771537423134, 0.00029672717209905386, -0.023491686210036278, -0.0215570367872715, -0.02047025039792061, -0.06978778541088104, -0.0319582000374794, 0.04851352423429489, 0.001127630122937262, -0.011078170500695705, -0.03669310733675957, -0.0016439525643363595, 0.031954847276210785, 0.035831280052661896, -0.008966902270913124, 0.01399252936244011, 0.04059712588787079, -0.050194501876831055, -0.020577093586325645, 0.017321478575468063, -0.009043007157742977, 0.004711965564638376, 0.01214649435132742, -0.017822789028286934, -0.016694450750947, 0.0775035098195076, -0.08905191719532013, 0.029257135465741158, 0.06372171640396118, 0.04646987468004227, -0.050060972571372986, 0.017544854432344437, 0.016905449330806732, 0.023116879165172577, 0.023159610107541084, -0.007141077425330877, 0.05067526921629906, 0.05294604226946831, 0.04036704823374748, -0.02710566855967045, -0.06036326661705971, 0.048529356718063354, -0.054626625031232834, -0.00121707608923316, -0.014622372575104237, 0.004048994742333889, 0.026291241869330406, 0.019824374467134476, -0.035728130489587784, 0.0000581615386181511, -0.0109019223600626, 0.05237772315740585, 0.008164111524820328, -0.03664793074131012, 0.006567532196640968, -0.02111406810581684, 0.0033633089624345303, 0.028628487139940262, 0.017112603411078453, -0.010257294401526451, -0.04188443720340729, 0.026569170877337456, -0.04800892621278763, 0.0127902552485466, 0.022430649027228355, -0.01339162141084671, 0.0242853295058012, 0.043370772153139114, -0.0412815622985363, 0.057343143969774246, -0.022628339007496834, -0.05060367286205292, 0.01395451370626688, -0.0012963571352884173, -0.019003866240382195, 0.013270866125822067, -0.054342832416296005, 0.0023358601611107588, 0.032031603157520294, -0.023406237363815308, -0.02622639574110508, 0.025683239102363586, -0.029627742245793343, -0.032759059220552444, -0.08314520865678787, -0.016712913289666176, -0.0579879991710186, 0.034050073474645615, -0.015183026902377605, 0.026062287390232086, 0.04003536328673363, -0.01433060597628355, -0.0031802456360310316, -0.002803840208798647, 0.001538726151920855, -0.012466694228351116, -0.04177682101726532, -0.03216371685266495, -0.07882379740476608, -0.013982187025249004, 0.015176702290773392, 0.06449402123689651, 0.011798926629126072, -0.004529088735580444, -0.05247180163860321, -0.06234898045659065, -0.011913700960576534, 0.014132387936115265, 0.07657056301832199, 0.017722705379128456, -0.0013876990415155888, -0.03148931264877319, -0.05597054585814476, 0.01504432037472725, -0.027515804395079613, 0.006074453238397837, -0.03464152663946152, 0.05408570542931557, 0.012910127639770508, -0.04016739875078201, -0.037456754595041275, 0.039025381207466125, 0.06535911560058594, -0.006530651357024908, -0.041468892246484756, -0.010395564138889313, 0.03537723422050476, -0.07309237122535706, -0.06114707514643669, -0.02073441818356514, -0.04979432374238968, -0.06490560621023178, -0.05485779419541359, 0.010765159502625465, 0.03201613947749138, -0.0053591737523674965, -0.027427809312939644, -0.014976161532104015, 0.048983894288539886, -0.00982998963445425, -0.006133556831628084, 0.05052660405635834, -0.011911957524716854, 0.03347352519631386, -0.02104877308011055, -0.06797195971012115, -0.03884689137339592, -0.07256298512220383, -0.030650218948721886, -0.015844475477933884, 0.029255211353302002, 0.0071452888660132885, 0.05372399464249611, -0.08564525097608566, -0.0016475992742925882, 0.01673016883432865, -0.0391317754983902, 0.03486914932727814, 0.0648350939154625, -0.032202884554862976, -0.004802900366485119, -0.058873992413282394, 0.008225363679230213, 0.03828095272183418, -0.015764553099870682, 0.005867241881787777, -0.018124934285879135, -0.027707979083061218, -0.008837374858558178, 0.03551298752427101, 0.013017917051911354, -0.01637892797589302, 0.03308983892202377, 0.03784669190645218, 0.04213300719857216, 0.00022541111684404314, 0.0469236820936203, 0.050986919552087784, 0.010716749355196953, -0.024820435792207718, -0.03984791785478592, -0.013482194393873215, -0.02352062053978443, 0.0074885087087750435, -0.0466257743537426, -0.035728272050619125, 0.04532478004693985, -0.01783571019768715, -0.0016844355268403888, 0.018238259479403496, 0.050761573016643524, 0.015201721340417862, -0.05268663540482521, 0.012338296510279179, -0.05611640214920044, -0.008129204623401165, -0.008609806187450886, 0.011493222787976265, 0.049711938947439194, 0.031143147498369217, -0.00476423092186451, 0.032558172941207886, -0.026002049446105957, 0.0038133931811898947, 0.013572278432548046, -0.03779155761003494, 0.056104108691215515, 0.01498331781476736, -0.0020682953763753176, 0.0019031271804124117, 0.0577528178691864, 0.040713343769311905, 0.025199005380272865, 0.0008477790979668498, -0.0035377866588532925, -0.030800865963101387, 0.0027771254535764456, 0.03624430298805237, -0.04886195808649063, 0.04280635714530945, -0.028326591476798058, -0.0001737491984385997, -0.056956946849823, 0.0029019310604780912, 0.04404769092798233, 0.018514862284064293, 0.005347917787730694, 0.022324426099658012, -0.042850349098443985, -0.07143044471740723, 0.02818486839532852, 0.05213791877031326, -0.05083880573511124, -0.01218830794095993, -0.056166503578424454, 0.0015553435077890754, -0.0008035408100113273, 0.0010237451642751694, 0.02140275575220585, 0.03721087425947189, -0.007461404427886009, -0.05743087828159332, 0.06016995385289192, 0.015607854351401329, -0.08028579503297806, 0.0031325044110417366, 0.03720025718212128, -0.08425271511077881, 0.002403861377388239, 0.06040342152118683, -0.005419967230409384, -0.06121229752898216, -0.008867845870554447, 0.038425594568252563, -0.03193618729710579, -0.033845845609903336, 0.024774761870503426, 0.0872562825679779, -0.01655680499970913, 0.05600259453058243, 0.011556955985724926, -0.050452880561351776, 0.02082916907966137, -0.025085093453526497, 0.021732551977038383, -0.04307542368769646, 0.01688850298523903, -0.023651696741580963, -0.0170174278318882, -0.002878808882087469, 0.07038039714097977, -0.009634331800043583, 0.0022000963799655437, 0.022343209013342857, 0.026237765327095985, 0.017652524635195732, -0.04862966388463974, -0.044925495982170105, -0.027094105258584023, -0.02530672401189804, -0.02217351272702217, -0.06690561771392822, -0.004181938711553812, -0.019896021112799644, -0.011073091998696327, -0.026635456830263138, -0.08651480823755264, -0.005927867256104946, -0.058691609650850296, -0.05726004019379616, 0.038051143288612366, -0.018781747668981552, 0.007347740698605776, -0.012641552835702896, -0.027709102258086205, -0.020924128592014313, 0.05094129592180252, -0.07529468089342117, -0.04271857067942619, -0.03758833557367325, -0.0049268510192632675, -0.019797395914793015, -0.03587109223008156, 0.046419959515333176, -0.007371631450951099, 0.04505942016839981, -0.04082118719816208, -0.02771575003862381, -0.04719104990363121, -0.040884196758270264, 0.020184332504868507, -0.008026880212128162, -0.00042610435048118234, -0.04568875581026077, 0.00014674491831101477, -0.018831299617886543, 0.0023844854440540075, 0.011936099268496037, -0.05324086919426918, -0.07129328697919846, 0.011759630404412746, 0.003621409647166729, -0.03768238052725792, 0.03251447156071663, 0.041276346892118454, 0.026293622329831123, -0.006851764861494303, 0.0028364299796521664, 0.025207465514540672, 0.006581212393939495, 0.0004751344968099147, -0.046364303678274155, -0.02657179720699787, 0.03567538410425186, -0.007724170573055744, -0.028702545911073685, -0.053711794316768646, -0.009028191678225994, -0.0491618849337101, -0.006972051691263914, 0.05697190761566162, -0.013153014704585075, -0.02546663209795952, -0.07104849070310593, 0.02331683225929737, 0.031652528792619705, -0.0658755898475647, -0.03845483064651489, 0.007908295840024948, -0.016665920615196228, -0.049010567367076874, 0.04499993100762367, 0.019610166549682617, -0.02213628776371479, 0.011407832615077496, -0.09113048017024994, -0.03752679377794266, 0.018328199163079262, 0.028140807524323463, 0.011413289234042168, -0.01685335300862789, -0.0649350956082344, -0.015903031453490257, -0.03601041063666344, 0.022217169404029846, 0.01015071664005518, -0.021964821964502335, 0.04285002872347832, -0.005076616536825895, -0.05231476202607155, -0.03368346765637398, 0.07138339430093765, -0.01046244241297245, 0.008877201937139034, 0.0446133054792881, -0.03126881644129753, 0.028873838484287262, -0.01625111699104309, 0.07063192129135132, 0.00019109527056571096, -0.028387414291501045, -0.05285542085766792, -0.04822114109992981, -0.026237918063998222, -0.024147266522049904, 0.047783177345991135, -0.042237985879182816, -0.01623375713825226, 0.03153471276164055, 0.006608336698263884, -0.015740973874926567, -0.0024007486645132303, -0.024263478815555573, 0.03308058902621269, 0.02300466038286686, -0.008848288096487522, 0.0349101722240448, -0.05874108523130417, -0.004328514449298382, -0.0013377637369558215, -0.02688208408653736, -0.0651332288980484, 0.02806134521961212, 0.03525713458657265, -0.042998772114515305, -0.02323359251022339, -0.06668118387460709, 0.011335146613419056, 0.02969643846154213, 0.019603658467531204, -0.006277024280279875, 0.06629786640405655, -0.023193014785647392, 0.022371960803866386, 0.018390443176031113, -0.024991044774651527, -0.040605638176202774, -0.06703539192676544, -0.0439714640378952, -0.008646358735859394, 0.005359537433832884, -0.041689593344926834, 0.0013024103827774525, -0.015498373657464981, 0.02865191549062729, -0.013207491487264633, -0.03890359401702881, 0.04375464469194412, 0.03153282031416893, -0.015341383405029774, 0.08853333443403244, 0.016053972765803337, 0.004122517071664333, -0.03881208598613739, 0.03282878175377846, -0.009250221773982048, -0.01674644649028778, -0.01627824828028679, -0.027127213776111603, 0.01884039118885994, -0.020339518785476685, 0.009886533953249454, 0.029137413948774338, -0.006589855067431927, -0.04001469910144806, -0.023064013570547104, 0.013725542463362217, -0.05423879250884056, -0.03263412043452263 ]
The density functional plus dynamical mean-field theory is used to study the spin excitation spectra of SrRu$_2$O$_6$. A good quantitative agreement with experimental spin excitation spectra is found. Depending on the size of the Hund's coupling $J_H$ the systems chooses either Mott insulator or covalent insulator state when magnetic ordering is not allowed. We find that the nature of the paramagnetic state has negligible influence on the charge and spin excitation spectra. We find that antiferromagnetic correlations hide the covalent insulator state for realistic choices of the interaction parameters.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.19826v2
[ -0.0481451041996479, -0.009458346292376518, 0.022080807015299797, 0.007665918208658695, 0.02458004653453827, -0.008024806156754494, -0.002447357401251793, 0.025887515395879745, -0.028469976037740707, -0.001066879602149129, 0.00784646812826395, -0.06452222168445587, -0.038189373910427094, -0.04575546458363533, -0.062171533703804016, 0.0431269146502018, 0.07110174745321274, 0.06272614747285843, 0.009960919618606567, 0.05723794177174568, -0.012119999155402184, -0.039329420775175095, -0.020374637097120285, -0.007518400903791189, -0.032969880849123, -0.013697630725800991, -0.0071715605445206165, 0.009993785060942173, -0.022304220125079155, 0.013665100559592247, 0.03519609570503235, -0.003336999798193574, -0.001478850026614964, -0.03458510711789131, 0.024775221943855286, -0.00979755911976099, -0.004149080254137516, 0.031390637159347534, 0.06116968393325806, -0.036288585513830185, -0.028272151947021484, 0.009904097765684128, -0.05480773374438286, 0.021876122802495956, -0.008501947857439518, 0.01232243049889803, -0.009837337769567966, 0.0017125527374446392, -0.02407192438840866, -0.0601365752518177, 0.03955945372581482, -0.0029579377733170986, 0.048423148691654205, 0.041488900780677795, -0.047532081604003906, 0.03594932705163956, -0.011658690869808197, -0.02266528084874153, -0.05819263309240341, -0.009945432655513287, -0.00993485376238823, -0.038219038397073746, 0.032886870205402374, 0.0204051211476326, 0.0038972743786871433, 0.021488627418875694, -0.028938891366124153, -0.028718912973999977, 0.011710401624441147, -0.03252070024609566, 0.028766240924596786, -0.04874705895781517, 0.052849266678094864, 0.00809619389474392, -0.03817947208881378, 0.0332934744656086, -0.040463559329509735, 0.023443765938282013, -0.00006277563807088882, 0.009125798009335995, 0.020848045125603676, -0.012525925412774086, 0.009357004426419735, 0.04717450961470604, 0.03715316951274872, 0.0012361101107671857, 0.037700358778238297, -0.009073368273675442, -0.01558220386505127, -0.039387546479701996, 0.04847719520330429, -0.03791695088148117, -0.0409771166741848, 0.010070557706058025, 0.04518449679017067, -0.07237381488084793, 0.07559975236654282, 0.03471635282039642, 0.05222434550523758, 0.016070332378149033, 0.0025038968306034803, -0.03496013209223747, -0.017266040667891502, -0.0019230914767831564, 0.023878952488303185, -0.01067050639539957, 0.01109103299677372, -0.023298684507608414, -0.0403858944773674, 0.03225674107670784, -0.02798226848244667, -0.0023693153634667397, 0.0009778122184798121, -0.054422527551651, -0.05310623347759247, -0.048967886716127396, 0.07378342747688293, 0.06580416858196259, -0.01377877313643694, 0.013734904117882252, -0.03723246604204178, 0.07295837253332138, -0.05473377928137779, 0.008758592419326305, -0.024388426914811134, -0.027541784569621086, 0.06394500285387039, 0.011171407997608185, 0.0025856459978967905, -0.024229535833001137, -0.03836575895547867, 0.02826356329023838, 0.017814960330724716, -0.05253104865550995, 0.05958786979317665, -0.020626073703169823, 0.027187515050172806, -0.016147388145327568, 0.009915400296449661, 0.011492766439914703, -0.05032174289226532, -0.05024196580052376, -0.0004417347954586148, 0.01628679223358631, 0.04316822066903114, 0.0249258391559124, -0.07053828984498978, 0.0037159989587962627, 0.031107239425182343, 0.01871541328728199, -0.005896194837987423, -0.02154463902115822, 0.019255952909588814, 0.026862051337957382, 0.022307535633444786, -0.009053788147866726, 0.02900850400328636, -0.002841346198692918, -0.0053497543558478355, 0.022654272615909576, 0.03982327878475189, 0.02275250107049942, 0.008048771880567074, 0.0030686359386891127, -0.008017439395189285, 0.002476953435689211, 0.009537454694509506, -0.015652816742658615, -0.010133267380297184, -0.03127838298678398, 0.009236002340912819, 0.0025397888384759426, 0.028957366943359375, -0.06465073674917221, -0.06781100481748581, -0.035758860409259796, -0.014255664311349392, -0.046838950365781784, -0.00026896095369011164, 0.043752122670412064, -0.007210419047623873, 0.001120157539844513, -0.027912648394703865, -0.008474716916680336, -0.01883326657116413, 0.007846948690712452, -0.07551885396242142, 0.004480630159378052, 0.02996371127665043, -0.0077250320464372635, -0.03878546133637428, -0.01409109402447939, 0.05730697512626648, 0.0002927245222963393, -0.05158871039748192, -0.007340258918702602, -0.01373342052102089, 0.02312542125582695, 0.006506921723484993, 0.039129588752985, -0.07587102055549622, -0.006901700049638748, -0.03274165838956833, -0.03274517506361008, -0.034884244203567505, -0.0607195608317852, 0.008880366571247578, 0.0500556118786335, -0.0343456007540226, -0.037866439670324326, 0.04672262817621231, -0.014076854102313519, 0.01982295885682106, 0.008868317119777203, -0.028980284929275513, -0.004725577775388956, -0.10799567401409149, 0.034713830798864365, 0.03395550698041916, -0.02318955399096012, -0.0009242265368811786, 0.014514571987092495, 0.007814847864210606, 0.011335723102092743, -0.02148274891078472, 0.03903192654252052, 0.05575745180249214, 0.001930577796883881, -0.034524962306022644, 0.016264446079730988, -0.011371462605893612, -0.052433814853429794, -0.03651830926537514, -0.05887501686811447, -0.04126447066664696, 0.005303076934069395, -0.013530902564525604, 0.06718706339597702, -0.0373268686234951, -0.025178369134664536, -0.05884092301130295, -0.0015851976349949837, -0.00746100302785635, -0.019747378304600716, -0.04570341855287552, -0.06083124876022339, -0.01071501336991787, 0.015098469331860542, -0.027412276715040207, -0.024310771375894547, 0.014487537555396557, -0.05337167903780937, -0.04209094122052193, 0.02487892471253872, 0.04602910578250885, 0.017200009897351265, -0.05002041533589363, 0.019965576007962227, -0.0005789072602055967, 0.03651658445596695, 0.023242902010679245, 0.015978500247001648, -0.018278686329722404, 0.014624794013798237, 0.0034934787545353174, 0.01729990728199482, -0.02147400937974453, -0.018411386758089066, -0.010250285267829895, -0.0731765553355217, 0.009948081336915493, -0.005433234851807356, 0.03451436012983322, 0.0061879269778728485, 0.00742495059967041, -0.0023664904292672873, -0.0507107637822628, -0.0051521919667720795, 0.03476206213235855, 0.028466328978538513, 0.0724199116230011, 0.04516206681728363, 0.01614784635603428, -0.05166666954755783, -0.019608721137046814, -0.0434887520968914, 0.022776231169700623, -0.07827220857143402, -0.06619440019130707, 0.008899301290512085, -0.07361115515232086, 0.0026510097086429596, -0.012784423306584358, 0.0008892323821783066, -0.05907301977276802, -0.05933501943945885, -0.019721057265996933, 0.038205042481422424, 0.012782987207174301, -0.09345363080501556, -0.04907172545790672, 0.03022151067852974, 0.020502006635069847, 0.028194477781653404, -0.06186288967728615, -0.0292077474296093, -0.03423088788986206, -0.011447055265307426, 0.02710741199553013, -0.01147926039993763, -0.0247341338545084, -0.02942308783531189, -0.06331346184015274, -0.016347719356417656, -0.044966522604227066, 0.03222745656967163, 0.044905055314302444, -0.05200155824422836, 0.017751701176166534, 0.005981894675642252, -0.0061052097007632256, -0.022578028962016106, 0.008485670201480389, -0.033241238445043564, -0.025577690452337265, 0.0033994598779827356, 0.07165183126926422, 0.06525014340877533, -0.03720669448375702, -0.012904651463031769, -0.04746200889348984, -0.00692433025687933, -0.033767737448215485, -0.0033813694026321173, 0.05471444129943848, 0.013882370665669441, -0.037749506533145905, -0.010262656956911087, -0.007184776943176985, 0.06439141184091568, -0.0510905459523201, 0.03999602422118187, -0.010342443361878395, -0.018846524879336357, 0.0190853551030159, -0.06741340458393097, 0.012131384573876858, 0.053658682852983475, 0.040695108473300934, -0.03728310763835907, 0.007627035956829786, 0.021045763045549393, 0.008670452982187271, 0.033870868384838104, 0.02292710728943348, -0.0017950846813619137, 0.009621498174965382, 0.014180924743413925, -0.028447505086660385, -0.03198263421654701, -0.02119656465947628, -0.06256823986768723, -0.04903795197606087, 0.011523908004164696, 0.016346745193004608, 0.02257457934319973, 0.025864476338028908, -0.029689360409975052, 0.06841015815734863, 0.0023722073528915644, 0.02758806198835373, 0.00879599153995514, -0.01705499179661274, 0.004643663298338652, -0.03343049809336662, 0.008635464124381542, -0.0072081382386386395, 0.011442674323916435, -0.021342528983950615, -0.06100161373615265, 0.010603769682347775, -0.03206602856516838, -0.03264238312840462, 0.0406632162630558, -0.004857533145695925, 0.04598690941929817, 0.018029695376753807, -0.01284327358007431, 0.06678217649459839, -0.034393150359392166, 0.026699086651206017, -0.02779863029718399, 0.004019871819764376, -0.00686762947589159, 0.011250446550548077, -0.052187491208314896, 0.004172428511083126, -0.014969083480536938, -0.061098307371139526, 0.03807733207941055, 0.030905116349458694, -0.0053460849449038506, -0.04352008178830147, -0.09191927313804626, -0.03711586445569992, -0.05869564786553383, 0.053107850253582, 0.05514107644557953, -0.053086571395397186, 0.06135106459259987, -0.01777288317680359, -0.025029223412275314, -0.053328484296798706, 0.015177805908024311, -0.04007646441459656, -0.07635049521923065, -0.04667853191494942, -0.015730006620287895, 0.035504650324583054, -0.01324436254799366, -0.01987440511584282, -0.030179008841514587, 0.02522973157465458, -0.05769042670726776, 0.03917597234249115, 0.02172367461025715, 0.04904196038842201, 0.006865064147859812, 0.015414677560329437, 0.04275058954954147, 0.006357928272336721, 0.014346080832183361, -0.014449612237513065, 0.01794012077152729, 0.03864247724413872, -0.05903320014476776, 0.04718280956149101, -0.08764570951461792, -0.054624199867248535, -0.05249747633934021, 0.021715182811021805, 0.05477375537157059, -0.023809311911463737, -0.021876035258173943, 0.000390286702895537, 0.05216628313064575, -0.04045872390270233, -0.03471599891781807, -0.04869617149233818, -0.030010534450411797, -0.06380164623260498, -0.025334227830171585, -0.0066445982083678246, -0.0377236045897007, -0.01624969020485878, 0.005554548930376768, 0.029304496943950653, 0.03742377460002899, -0.023510843515396118, 0.039810195565223694, 0.046696677803993225, 0.02843106910586357, -0.007872678339481354, -0.027044298127293587, -0.06623226404190063, 0.011043665930628777, -0.028461076319217682, 0.009669719263911247, 0.026609215885400772, 0.02892267145216465, -0.007306552492082119, -0.004464515019208193, -0.08609779924154282, 0.048677824437618256, 0.03153689578175545, -0.023620247840881348, 0.002624364336952567, 0.034522708505392075, -0.031778112053871155, 0.02191942185163498, -0.029209479689598083, -0.013603772968053818, -0.025650406256318092, -0.01921665295958519, -0.023362915962934494, -0.007518858183175325, -0.05785396695137024, -0.010107909329235554, 0.0035952702164649963, -0.009032897651195526, -0.06572709232568741, 0.049559611827135086, 0.0036719958297908306, 0.008046749047935009, -0.06275880336761475, 0.06181035190820694, 0.06610744446516037, -0.049954771995544434, -0.057421643286943436, -0.024211471900343895, -0.010639715008437634, 0.045931849628686905, 0.05620882660150528, -0.07452899217605591, 0.04186844825744629, -0.05110446736216545, 0.05694558471441269, -0.028929341584444046, 0.018176022917032242, -0.02903648093342781, 0.0028616159688681364, 0.016178684309124947, -0.005505096632987261, -0.07167971134185791, 0.01369408331811428, -0.04492306709289551, 0.03953087329864502, -0.03887586668133736, -0.027665309607982635, 0.057036418467760086, 0.027230901643633842, 0.016729049384593964, -0.056809987872838974, -0.06811493635177612, -0.011275253258645535, 0.01673038676381111, -0.012109759263694286, -0.012074928730726242, 0.006743758451193571, 0.025878682732582092, 0.025197232142090797, -0.0353250652551651, -0.018689196556806564, -0.019020654261112213, -0.03667255863547325, 0.0015654315939173102, 0.05717294290661812, 0.04480328410863876, -0.05866992101073265, -0.022540545091032982, 0.037944965064525604, -0.05066702887415886, 0.05293568968772888, 0.008474764414131641, 0.023945966735482216, 0.011417826637625694, 0.020953457802534103, 0.07687452435493469, -0.08136050403118134, -0.005839877296239138, 0.0916353240609169, -0.052109211683273315, 0.0008940823026932776, -0.06531652063131332, -0.06459861993789673, -0.024818474426865578, -0.057771243155002594, -0.020934054628014565, -0.014303131029009819, 0.01596973091363907, -0.0035935367923229933, -0.017461363226175308, -0.006493283435702324, -0.0829305648803711, 0.0031704611610621214, 0.025526879355311394, -0.0564633384346962, 0.005108373239636421, 0.0005120892310515046, -0.054047953337430954, -0.01098630204796791, 0.041957221925258636, -0.07814951986074448, -0.059722162783145905, -0.024108391255140305, 0.03462248295545578, 0.0550508052110672, -0.05124383419752121, -0.0010053332662209868, -0.010630447417497635, -0.017317049205303192, -0.031214257702231407, -0.05225939676165581, -0.0508260577917099, 0.00045182122266851366, 0.03414994105696678, 0.009934988804161549, -0.02997264266014099, -0.009168551303446293, 0.017859341576695442, 0.00903245061635971, -0.004425373859703541, 0.013331280089914799, 0.029899656772613525, 0.01752813346683979, -0.03027634508907795, -0.059145454317331314, 0.012222817167639732, 0.003418789943680167, -0.026149434968829155, -0.00017745840887073427, 0.0017068821471184492, 0.04802529513835907, 0.03544066473841667, -0.01560112927109003, -0.010607446543872356, -0.025229431688785553, -0.019399259239435196, 0.011361147277057171, -0.025679098442196846, -0.04276926815509796, 0.023374278098344803, -0.01982790231704712, 0.05843179300427437, 0.024819523096084595, 0.020134730264544487, -0.02815788798034191, 0.011058066971600056, -0.04324736073613167, 0.05910991504788399, -0.001976476749405265, 0.032873183488845825, 0.0052301413379609585, 0.0012624874943867326, 0.03750215470790863, -0.06277663260698318, 0.015064743347465992, -0.02746701054275036, -0.08664458990097046, 0.03957566246390343, -0.01060379296541214, 0.010746951214969158, -0.045270632952451706, -0.012727160006761551, -0.058782149106264114, 0.01866675540804863, -0.00019757695554289967, -0.01683211699128151, -0.07884009182453156, -0.019183211028575897, -0.0040659611113369465, -0.00809017475694418, 0.03604681417346001, 0.0002062556886812672, 0.04214426875114441, 0.012839444912970066, 0.024693863466382027, 0.047770630568265915, 0.03178803622722626, 0.015129359439015388, -0.03792637214064598, -0.02716083638370037, 0.06269191205501556, -0.017217649146914482, 0.03339282423257828, -0.02804986760020256, -0.02706999145448208, -0.08276105672121048, 0.0042041875422000885, 0.012628269381821156, -0.006899653933942318, 0.005514470860362053, -0.02678922936320305, 0.06332194805145264, 0.007115707732737064, 0.004214735701680183, -0.08657030761241913, -0.038951974362134933, -0.0027926398906856775, -0.010813586413860321, 0.007061561103910208, -0.028286699205636978, -0.07886743545532227, 0.019820716232061386, -0.09101278334856033, -0.024721799418330193, -0.008008751086890697, 0.06535062938928604, 0.034439388662576675, 0.005754890386015177, -0.006457324139773846, -0.009928593412041664, 0.019810153171420097, 0.03870227187871933, 0.03228507190942764, 0.0351223461329937, 0.0013656486989930272, 0.026247896254062653, -0.022695466876029968, -0.030333204194903374, 0.06669454276561737, -0.02527680993080139, -0.01321886945515871, 0.01534148771315813, 0.029721898958086967, -0.03962736576795578, -0.018128376454114914, 0.02844785526394844, 0.019782552495598793, 0.019227271899580956, 0.0036089601926505566, -0.001648730249144137, -0.04563506692647934, -0.06096574291586876, 0.059607669711112976, -0.06533041596412659, 0.013007237575948238, -0.027440017089247704, 0.019968900829553604, -0.013345406390726566, -0.03272754326462746, -0.05120668560266495, 0.03548761084675789, 0.052485886961221695, -0.02340877614915371, 0.008217262104153633, -0.03334216773509979, 0.027324020862579346, 0.028008174151182175, -0.0078119682148098946, -0.05370344594120979, 0.025185000151395798, 0.039988238364458084, -0.03371506184339523, 0.020225849002599716, -0.08169614523649216, 0.030781250447034836, 0.0024574280250817537, -0.026989629492163658, -0.01628575474023819, 0.03286690637469292, -0.047114644199609756, -0.022735148668289185, -0.010406735353171825, -0.06391042470932007, 0.0030399297829717398, -0.06174248829483986, -0.01067356113344431, -0.007389425300061703, -0.0322766974568367, 0.02571703866124153, 0.01864634081721306, -0.04193675145506859, 0.06214165687561035, 0.016946295276284218, 0.03524539992213249, -0.017555618658661842, -0.0021691289730370045, -0.048021573573350906, 0.024184977635741234, 0.020291082561016083, -0.007953121326863766, -0.040232736617326736, 0.01678197830915451, 0.012329165823757648, -0.029550472274422646, -0.017267189919948578, 0.04261801019310951, -0.012609001249074936, -0.0461992584168911, -0.030747300013899803, 0.04886161535978317, 0.030356980860233307, -0.04082193225622177, 0.055073339492082596, 0.05298396944999695, 0.006962205283343792, -0.044164955615997314 ]
In psychiatric diagnosis, a contemporary data-driven, manual-based method for mental disorders classification is the most popular technique; however, it has several inevitable flaws. Using the three-way decision as a framework, we propose a unified model that stands for clinicians' subjective approach (CSA) analysis consisting of three parts: quantitative analysis, quantitative analysis, and evaluation-based analysis. A ranking list and a set of numerical weights based on illness magnitude levels according to the clinician's greatest degree of assumptions are the findings of the qualitative and quantitative investigation. We further create a comparative classification of illnesses into three groups with varying important levels; a three-way evaluation-based model is utilized in this study for the aim of understanding and portraying these results in a more clear way. This proposed method might be integrated with the manual-based process as a complementary tool to improve precision while diagnosing mental disorders
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.03351v4
[ 0.018829526379704475, -0.01452314667403698, -0.012442813254892826, -0.01158972829580307, -0.04096740856766701, -0.03856205940246582, 0.027630362659692764, -0.015407000668346882, -0.046088967472314835, -0.011030682362616062, -0.05611955374479294, -0.022382153198122978, 0.018762752413749695, -0.018748799338936806, -0.04119383543729782, 0.023594820871949196, 0.06256388872861862, 0.00727659510448575, -0.0708039328455925, 0.06267241388559341, 0.014612684026360512, -0.023699913173913956, -0.020062362775206566, 0.049746640026569366, 0.03325580433011055, 0.020899293944239616, -0.05599341168999672, -0.06096690893173218, -0.0325336679816246, 0.006812848150730133, 0.06323622912168503, -0.047242671251297, -0.05394067242741585, -0.056334029883146286, -0.012974563986063004, -0.03771880269050598, 0.04833962023258209, -0.021185629069805145, 0.0010739434510469437, -0.06398088485002518, 0.032020505517721176, -0.06933365017175674, -0.07071466743946075, 0.00685911113396287, -0.010792073793709278, 0.011642731726169586, -0.054594311863183975, 0.03054121881723404, -0.07084090262651443, -0.00205254927277565, 0.04732762649655342, -0.04204798489809036, -0.008504140190780163, 0.07013040781021118, -0.04612581804394722, -0.00046925354399718344, -0.010005481541156769, 0.014264289289712906, -0.03663480654358864, -0.010214893147349358, 0.058645330369472504, 0.008616596460342407, 0.0005668436642736197, 0.009998157620429993, 0.02220895327627659, 0.02838343009352684, -0.02189439907670021, -0.0769866332411766, -0.041787974536418915, -0.0608365498483181, 0.053601887077093124, -0.07194274663925171, 0.0686904639005661, 0.01757005602121353, -0.047715362161397934, -0.05141797661781311, 0.021398907527327538, -0.048501156270504, -0.019441301003098488, 0.031089819967746735, 0.0005967537290416658, 0.05892657861113548, 0.004011024255305529, -0.01574631966650486, -0.0204623993486166, -0.0715918242931366, 0.0554862879216671, -0.04818624258041382, -0.007531087379902601, -0.06008626148104668, -0.017346074804663658, -0.04145902395248413, -0.05075729265809059, -0.03655119985342026, 0.036447688937187195, -0.010377796366810799, 0.028800874948501587, 0.03367898240685463, 0.02566452883183956, -0.04686766490340233, -0.006966977845877409, -0.008833945728838444, -0.035067833960056305, 0.04303831607103348, 0.04270080476999283, -0.050294071435928345, 0.0016608430305495858, -0.018511855974793434, -0.035047706216573715, -0.044572439044713974, -0.056680966168642044, -0.00838460586965084, -0.03462095931172371, -0.07179659605026245, -0.028814885765314102, -0.0012550611281767488, 0.050290029495954514, 0.03626745566725731, 0.01176106370985508, -0.043332021683454514, -0.07001995295286179, 0.023783937096595764, -0.00434052525088191, -0.029395222663879395, -0.058619193732738495, -0.01624804548919201, 0.03539078310132027, -0.023434843868017197, -0.02338353544473648, -0.017287397757172585, -0.059360601007938385, -0.011812140233814716, -0.010301577858626842, 0.031363748013973236, 0.04373617842793465, 0.0031564407981932163, -0.03156614303588867, -0.0701269656419754, 0.020429043099284172, 0.039438750594854355, -0.023023143410682678, -0.0761142149567604, 0.02060920000076294, -0.05866849794983864, -0.03050820343196392, 0.06400235742330551, -0.04662830010056496, 0.0008997020195238292, 0.027177337557077408, 0.05603189766407013, 0.014377784915268421, -0.027768829837441444, 0.01513738464564085, 0.0065697855316102505, 0.04212838411331177, 0.0064629786647856236, 0.037314366549253464, -0.04020320996642113, -0.054235078394412994, 0.03718483820557594, 0.010092013515532017, -0.030373554676771164, -0.023040706291794777, -0.03232181444764137, -0.005773294251412153, -0.0086843715980649, 0.06126080080866814, -0.003346794517710805, 0.010993273928761482, -0.01828666217625141, -0.015452660620212555, -0.011751691810786724, -0.0206309761852026, -0.04334845393896103, -0.040432434529066086, 0.01619492471218109, 0.007488364353775978, -0.06740152835845947, -0.06948345899581909, -0.0012206167448312044, 0.020006844773888588, -0.033288102596998215, -0.022967321798205376, 0.014148644171655178, -0.026663897559046745, 0.017433883622288704, -0.0684402585029602, -0.03574976697564125, 0.041064679622650146, 0.02207745425403118, -0.031607385724782944, 0.021502958610653877, 0.04707542061805725, 0.022494236007332802, -0.07000324875116348, -0.0239994078874588, 0.043946802616119385, -0.04230091720819473, 0.016195429489016533, 0.007987424731254578, -0.08230678737163544, -0.026302890852093697, -0.06011562421917915, 0.005778896156698465, -0.028914308175444603, -0.06265207380056381, -0.0013802133034914732, 0.012136464938521385, -0.03533809259533882, -0.022337622940540314, 0.045567721128463745, 0.058243609964847565, 0.061631131917238235, -0.004713960457593203, 0.00900441873818636, 0.028269752860069275, -0.08390563726425171, 0.06061302125453949, -0.012959906831383705, -0.014882026240229607, 0.03923194110393524, 0.011299321427941322, 0.05343049392104149, -0.00484404107555747, -0.030198795720934868, 0.050145525485277176, 0.028170159086585045, 0.02477012760937214, -0.010421281680464745, -0.036222733557224274, -0.02132526971399784, -0.07585224509239197, -0.013103801757097244, -0.07093315571546555, 0.014519833959639072, -0.024945463985204697, 0.008718040771782398, 0.0366029255092144, 0.01607084646821022, -0.06647051870822906, -0.05734150484204292, 0.003474692115560174, 0.038879673928022385, -0.029413701966404915, -0.014886578544974327, 0.0009381456184200943, -0.05038083344697952, 0.020401859655976295, -0.003500793594866991, -0.029352840036153793, -0.0015120183816179633, -0.062013447284698486, -0.0013841299805790186, -0.028542248532176018, 0.022237852215766907, 0.0022659313399344683, -0.037009939551353455, 0.018712731078267097, -0.0174675602465868, 0.0521160364151001, 0.048949066549539566, 0.04547945782542229, -0.04324167221784592, 0.04852999746799469, 0.010737703181803226, -0.020434565842151642, 0.01905471459031105, 0.01749652624130249, 0.027195189148187637, -0.03820904716849327, 0.0068807462230324745, -0.0024324306286871433, -0.0017376132309436798, -0.007477370090782642, -0.0040828208439052105, -0.0332178957760334, 0.009636645205318928, -0.057355478405952454, 0.05717848986387253, 0.04290517792105675, 0.03201423957943916, -0.03482787311077118, -0.03626401722431183, -0.06747842580080032, -0.015175141394138336, -0.04457695782184601, -0.02900209277868271, -0.048212677240371704, -0.058286260813474655, 0.01773958094418049, -0.06537789106369019, -0.044784288853406906, -0.0322997160255909, -0.027126414701342583, 0.00787942111492157, -0.07575967907905579, -0.043367765843868256, -0.050212640315294266, 0.013749872334301472, 0.04656227305531502, -0.03399544209241867, -0.05956956744194031, 0.018307501450181007, 0.027820106595754623, 0.015074262395501137, -0.046637602150440216, -0.01961452141404152, -0.026687344536185265, 0.02923576906323433, -0.029173415154218674, 0.0011934646172448993, 0.02093813754618168, 0.007617591414600611, 0.01963578723371029, -0.030870765447616577, -0.03188874199986458, -0.03401203081011772, 0.03410719335079193, -0.008919576182961464, 0.042639315128326416, 0.04196422919631004, -0.01550188660621643, -0.012751061469316483, -0.03279298543930054, 0.004035148769617081, -0.0358782596886158, 0.06806426495313644, -0.030688682571053505, -0.02582237869501114, -0.05201299861073494, 0.014135714620351791, -0.005459453910589218, 0.03814354166388512, -0.027410028502345085, 0.015601073391735554, 0.025207137688994408, -0.03508105129003525, -0.041185591369867325, -0.044942717999219894, -0.004441377706825733, -0.044327571988105774, 0.01840330846607685, -0.03082216903567314, 0.03806008771061897, -0.00317315268330276, -0.0778757631778717, 0.049410056322813034, 0.03391089662909508, 0.07390822470188141, 0.03071678802371025, 0.004664101637899876, 0.022396022453904152, -0.006414436269551516, -0.03602636978030205, -0.03011639043688774, 0.026584744453430176, -0.019750915467739105, 0.0502404049038887, -0.049227673560380936, -0.002989801811054349, 0.043577950447797775, -0.045956578105688095, -0.03391348198056221, 0.0015592867275699973, 0.03165362402796745, -0.03157810494303703, 0.0004903694498352706, -0.06389116495847702, -0.020082693547010422, 0.0043719857931137085, 0.039450909942388535, -0.0060429321601986885, 0.00022202354739420116, 0.06746816635131836, -0.02181394025683403, 0.032232966274023056, 0.05057590827345848, -0.014617941342294216, -0.008037948980927467, -0.05391223356127739, 0.016406962648034096, -0.026133378967642784, 0.04367693141102791, 0.027969058603048325, 0.012788056395947933, 0.025008581578731537, 0.0030231093987822533, -0.036923639476299286, 0.0011837729252874851, 0.005414352752268314, -0.011639978736639023, -0.0403006412088871, -0.009228043258190155, -0.044584620743989944, 0.007107637356966734, -0.07425442337989807, -0.024828583002090454, -0.0358828641474247, -0.02662770263850689, -0.07251480221748352, -0.039387792348861694, -0.018644900992512703, -0.012242619879543781, -0.07242535054683685, -0.026746200397610664, 0.008690745569765568, -0.031199073418974876, -0.031416989862918854, -0.0688154324889183, 0.031212756410241127, -0.013086272403597832, 0.02932950295507908, -0.05705530196428299, 0.03145180270075798, -0.039945680648088455, 0.003978446591645479, 0.00814169179648161, -0.07876916229724884, -0.02512552961707115, -0.05711816996335983, 0.02829727716743946, 0.01615743897855282, -0.025420881807804108, -0.03942836448550224, -0.039302218705415726, 0.0013166861608624458, -0.020286131650209427, 0.05816756933927536, 0.01019895076751709, -0.007510013412684202, -0.031034570187330246, 0.026350973173975945, -0.019697628915309906, -0.002400617115199566, -0.024103675037622452, 0.008122414350509644, 0.023830624297261238, -0.013456573709845543, -0.03305651247501373, -0.04852677509188652, -0.03172704577445984, 0.06970136612653732, -0.018268022686243057, -0.03613448143005371, -0.002040666528046131, 0.01168136764317751, -0.03792465478181839, -0.02889254130423069, -0.043036192655563354, -0.030055424198508263, -0.06135926395654678, -0.029438775032758713, 0.051532045006752014, 0.029423609375953674, -0.023547589778900146, -0.012230097316205502, -0.00137827277649194, -0.02788228914141655, 0.0025816785637289286, 0.015732796862721443, 0.02048121578991413, 0.03189794346690178, -0.04537538066506386, 0.003456883132457733, -0.06808444857597351, -0.022684331983327866, -0.02543630078434944, 0.006586608476936817, -0.014318102970719337, 0.04307185858488083, 0.01633905991911888, 0.05608857050538063, -0.066649429500103, 0.06413538753986359, -0.020642438903450966, -0.004571401048451662, 0.023609235882759094, 0.07693524658679962, 0.0029680130537599325, 0.034369491040706635, -0.04700491949915886, -0.013001332990825176, 0.023657960817217827, -0.04884772002696991, 0.008057952858507633, -0.0561845600605011, 0.04869704693555832, -0.024823399260640144, 0.06845825165510178, -0.06073600426316261, -0.038675565272569656, -0.005494983401149511, 0.02758767455816269, 0.012969722971320152, -0.028996925801038742, 0.046226851642131805, -0.006813274696469307, -0.012080342508852482, -0.05579637363553047, 0.015985658392310143, -0.05675695836544037, -0.023136502131819725, 0.03193897008895874, -0.04026750475168228, -0.008431033231317997, 0.05795259773731232, -0.001502334256656468, -0.0008445958374068141, 0.012842738069593906, 0.0021024306770414114, 0.0035117119550704956, 0.02023353986442089, 0.04821627959609032, -0.02865317091345787, -0.030523739755153656, -0.0391402393579483, 0.0522218756377697, 0.028833214193582535, 0.0054473583586514, -0.014116616919636726, -0.019229110330343246, -0.041500698775053024, -0.007419069297611713, 0.030017288401722908, 0.0006142091006040573, 0.018336616456508636, -0.012974013574421406, 0.04645008593797684, 0.019296595826745033, 0.052945274859666824, 0.07001832127571106, 0.005447713192552328, 0.04776238277554512, -0.010280176065862179, -0.032394889742136, 0.02204374596476555, 0.014891590923070908, 0.020024273544549942, -0.06637979298830032, 0.05081116780638695, -0.00246741296723485, -0.008009977638721466, 0.030338291078805923, -0.01640918105840683, -0.01755760796368122, -0.032333165407180786, -0.01492406241595745, -0.03448100388050079, -0.050506871193647385, 0.0434771291911602, 0.054895177483558655, -0.04171418026089668, -0.019059186801314354, -0.03163359314203262, 0.005905084311962128, -0.0021390963811427355, -0.062385573983192444, 0.06132799759507179, 0.0009624690283089876, 0.0074975211173295975, -0.05621686577796936, 0.019343342632055283, 0.0031728637404739857, -0.061171822249889374, -0.03487902507185936, -0.01739017479121685, -0.059881001710891724, -0.014247365295886993, 0.017294039949774742, 0.023331452161073685, -0.023413633927702904, 0.04582464322447777, -0.01851484552025795, -0.007239757105708122, -0.014991718344390392, 0.06733952462673187, 0.07843217253684998, 0.014232024550437927, 0.019735053181648254, -0.01637173257768154, -0.05177374184131622, 0.005271063651889563, -0.017345678061246872, 0.003502414096146822, -0.004805158358067274, 0.012527585960924625, -0.011771155521273613, -0.017729612067341805, -0.0656798854470253, 0.06606849282979965, -0.0393402986228466, -0.03185386210680008, 0.057001616805791855, -0.037101443856954575, 0.012689162977039814, -0.022978147491812706, -0.03265539929270744, -0.04012631997466087, -0.015494327992200851, -0.00951422844082117, -0.02995118498802185, -0.003103326540440321, -0.03604684770107269, 0.027588466182351112, -0.038339097052812576, -0.04386080801486969, 0.015260177664458752, -0.025890348479151726, -0.011829848401248455, 0.01706664450466633, -0.0713493824005127, -0.011060526594519615, 0.0038063041865825653, 0.027797944843769073, 0.026269249618053436, 0.051224298775196075, -0.026214370504021645, 0.02629522606730461, 0.033431656658649445, 0.015268038958311081, 0.005296815186738968, 0.026082197204232216, 0.026171697303652763, 0.008467081002891064, -0.002744984580203891, -0.0613071508705616, -0.028389090672135353, -0.04765456169843674, 0.010733703151345253, 0.03415412828326225, 0.006866041105240583, -0.02266920916736126, -0.06647004187107086, 0.007654986809939146, -0.022009853273630142, 0.0018154745921492577, 0.007833496667444706, -0.03404876962304115, -0.06506526470184326, 0.016093920916318893, -0.011606849730014801, -0.007883304730057716, -0.009704476222395897, 0.04738438501954079, 0.01756865717470646, 0.024398239329457283, -0.01784425787627697, 0.03857429325580597, 0.022207867354154587, 0.033440593630075455, -0.05437291041016579, -0.017075544223189354, 0.0019906004890799522, -0.039084479212760925, -0.010848783887922764, -0.018152376636862755, 0.014088031835854053, -0.06694719195365906, -0.029391612857580185, 0.048917658627033234, -0.03275575861334801, 0.011548795737326145, -0.057412039488554, -0.013857806101441383, 0.011732913553714752, -0.0571080818772316, -0.02836916595697403, -0.009831591509282589, -0.00958314910531044, -0.01754469983279705, -0.027056541293859482, -0.022770842537283897, -0.03264503553509712, 0.03671247884631157, -0.06772681325674057, -0.0012854264350607991, 0.022941432893276215, 0.05060984939336777, -0.005713062360882759, -0.005300553981214762, 0.01258811540901661, -0.014305348508059978, 0.020828574895858765, -0.05949464812874794, 0.014835759997367859, -0.005222712643444538, 0.03601571545004845, 0.03695258870720863, -0.05765262246131897, -0.03186602517962456, 0.02338481694459915, -0.025987405329942703, 0.014924120157957077, 0.020375248044729233, 0.004611647222191095, -0.02313871495425701, 0.02710898593068123, 0.013744599185883999, 0.009566453285515308, 0.028952263295650482, -0.07200810313224792, 0.025005962699651718, -0.048045769333839417, -0.06469309329986572, 0.05499334633350372, -0.02040098048746586, -0.01234086137264967, 0.010649474337697029, -0.004073193296790123, -0.000890514173079282, -0.0018447183538228273, -0.0676964670419693, 0.044270601123571396, -0.03294367343187332, -0.02905573695898056, 0.04125915840268135, -0.0002072061615763232, 0.0047428491525352, -0.04270420968532562, 0.030288953334093094, -0.028996136039495468, 0.01209759246557951, 0.02133040875196457, -0.05285825952887535, -0.029650749638676643, -0.060071367770433426, -0.037795454263687134, -0.0027919039130210876, -0.03931388631463051, -0.056344594806432724, 0.04931522533297539, 0.01639033667743206, -0.03198771923780441, 0.006797388661652803, -0.03270374611020088, -0.011703510768711567, -0.05989072471857071, -0.058790672570466995, -0.021546630188822746, 0.038376450538635254, 0.0008940225816331804, 0.026304008439183235, 0.043812356889247894, 0.05845491215586662, 0.02064848691225052, 0.03711410239338875, 0.0029358449392020702, -0.020497964695096016, -0.03793686628341675, 0.056640565395355225, 0.03222901001572609, 0.039673250168561935, -0.030684493482112885, -0.04328017681837082, -0.027324305847287178, -0.025690199807286263, 0.054112646728754044, 0.006276079453527927, -0.009369862265884876, -0.067662812769413, 0.027547400444746017, -0.02922900766134262, -0.049963995814323425, -0.030801981687545776, -0.021986672654747963, 0.02172013744711876, -0.007552918512374163, -0.02230955846607685 ]
The recent synthesis of MoSi2N4 material, along with theoretical predictions encompassing the entire family of chemical analogs, has opened up a new array of low-dimensional materials for a diverse range of optoelectronics and photovoltaics applications. In this study, we conducted state-of-the-art many-body first-principles calculations to analyze the quasi-particle electronic structure of the material class MSi2Z4 (where M = Mo, W, and Z = N, P, As, Sb). All monolayers display a direct band gap at the K point, with the exception of MoSi2N4. In tungsten-based compounds, the fundamental-gap can be adjusted over a significantly broader energy range compared to their molybdenum-based counterparts. Additionally, increasing atomic weight of the Z, both the band gap and exciton binding energies decrease. A noteworthy feature is the absence of a lateral valley ({\Lambda} or Q) near the conduction band minimum, indicating potential higher photoluminescence efficiencies compared to conventional transition-metal dichalcogenide monolayers. The optical spectra of these materials are predominantly characterized by tightly bound excitons, leading to an absorption onset in the visible range (for N-based) and in the infrared region (for others). This diversity offers promising opportunities to incorporate these materials and their heterostructures into optoelectronic devices, with tandem solar cells being particularly promising.
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11163v1
[ -0.06066368892788887, -0.045033976435661316, 0.03671823814511299, -0.00007521705992985517, -0.014945652335882187, -0.01834341324865818, -0.02092265896499157, 0.015195576474070549, -0.0302480086684227, -0.011641289107501507, 0.048504285514354706, -0.053221214562654495, -0.043575532734394073, -0.056633420288562775, -0.0308269951492548, 0.04279087111353874, 0.04395875707268715, 0.05045812577009201, -0.029652617871761322, 0.04185149818658829, 0.027220193296670914, -0.0415617898106575, -0.01197064109146595, 0.031222444027662277, 0.006549239158630371, 0.028245771303772926, -0.034928884357213974, -0.025746185332536697, 0.01281643845140934, -0.02491680160164833, 0.023339668288826942, -0.034814026206731796, -0.04198988899588585, -0.04166765511035919, 0.03845418244600296, -0.010315967723727226, -0.031456612050533295, 0.012548367492854595, -0.0029689837247133255, -0.048296649008989334, -0.018740054219961166, -0.04729113727807999, -0.03936759755015373, -0.00416764197871089, 0.016543112695217133, -0.0471680723130703, -0.05162965506315231, -0.016234414651989937, -0.0727178230881691, -0.060356415808200836, 0.04858537018299103, -0.0002143908350262791, 0.03183537349104881, 0.062428608536720276, -0.003222630824893713, 0.023822031915187836, -0.01116364449262619, -0.04518039897084236, -0.01099404226988554, 0.02484188601374626, 0.03854075074195862, -0.007272196933627129, -0.012885112315416336, -0.043113935738801956, -0.06933559477329254, 0.02600529044866562, -0.023786302655935287, -0.07564589381217957, -0.04089963063597679, -0.07313767820596695, 0.0044209822081029415, -0.07791874557733536, -0.021087368950247765, -0.035103801637887955, -0.07360903173685074, -0.018152806907892227, -0.05830232799053192, -0.016799457371234894, -0.015241227112710476, -0.005684366449713707, -0.0022153621539473534, 0.005057580303400755, 0.007514149881899357, -0.015765659511089325, -0.02161301113665104, 0.007221725303679705, -0.008232890628278255, -0.05759513005614281, -0.008281939662992954, -0.01766163855791092, 0.03194337710738182, -0.04720799997448921, -0.059057243168354034, 0.03817843645811081, 0.07580745965242386, -0.0031466304790228605, 0.018619300797581673, 0.049550846219062805, 0.031451232731342316, -0.014272957108914852, -0.0015775803476572037, -0.05601104348897934, -0.057153090834617615, 0.018692662939429283, -0.023711973801255226, -0.03853136673569679, 0.03762402385473251, -0.03043096512556076, -0.011461127549409866, 0.01695248857140541, 0.04587705060839653, -0.0024246566463261843, -0.010312437079846859, 0.006849618628621101, -0.06095061078667641, -0.0574517585337162, 0.05809082090854645, 0.019668223336338997, 0.011536586098372936, 0.008490856736898422, -0.02062295749783516, 0.027545904740691185, 0.038458678871393204, 0.008037043735384941, -0.015508906915783882, 0.02795090340077877, 0.055383410304784775, -0.01617620326578617, 0.015725882723927498, -0.0351833812892437, -0.0443778894841671, 0.0375625304877758, 0.036507993936538696, -0.005367101635783911, 0.02385496348142624, 0.01889861561357975, -0.012729775160551071, -0.01666645146906376, 0.038233283907175064, 0.01479188259691, -0.035611290484666824, -0.014723652973771095, 0.0163764338940382, -0.013926275074481964, 0.0036428901366889477, 0.02525950036942959, -0.06380289047956467, -0.0036267030518501997, 0.03443392366170883, 0.01793813332915306, -0.016792867332696915, 0.013764875009655952, -0.01674676686525345, -0.022530965507030487, -0.008772343397140503, 0.012102669104933739, 0.006799194496124983, 0.03594561666250229, -0.041555095463991165, 0.04115604981780052, 0.029313066974282265, 0.01598268561065197, 0.006193418055772781, -0.02817760594189167, -0.03239260986447334, 0.0005483530112542212, 0.0005286607192829251, -0.048620548099279404, 0.03036716766655445, 0.039948124438524246, -0.02818046510219574, 0.011529028415679932, -0.027277840301394463, -0.06493917852640152, -0.034536249935626984, 0.0004682978324126452, 0.01096423715353012, -0.056224096566438675, -0.03250504285097122, -0.0012543905759230256, 0.024853818118572235, -0.03173675388097763, -0.026394275948405266, -0.04822106286883354, -0.02331392653286457, 0.03153957799077034, -0.07272026687860489, 0.0331241711974144, 0.02611570619046688, 0.009469202719628811, -0.027696741744875908, 0.001187880290672183, 0.0401221327483654, 0.018754765391349792, -0.024373752996325493, 0.0033626030199229717, -0.012744292616844177, -0.010439887642860413, 0.02175087295472622, 0.027117451652884483, -0.07155559957027435, -0.028237104415893555, -0.0031914860010147095, -0.03645229712128639, -0.005330602638423443, -0.07557380199432373, 0.023647846654057503, 0.03757033497095108, -0.02939520590007305, -0.034132011234760284, 0.05543730407953262, 0.051259685307741165, 0.04168640449643135, 0.007171138655394316, 0.0014164835447445512, -0.0404830202460289, -0.09161965548992157, 0.03347572684288025, -0.002025049179792404, -0.007018741685897112, 0.05615534260869026, -0.009359828196465969, -0.00024335156194865704, -0.009788158349692822, -0.0350332111120224, 0.06338538229465485, 0.00888204574584961, -0.012347372248768806, -0.02304169535636902, 0.03603345528244972, 0.03775002807378769, -0.0660448670387268, -0.07846641540527344, -0.04588788375258446, 0.0280657596886158, 0.007725998759269714, -0.052843086421489716, 0.04536387324333191, -0.03695378080010414, -0.06877308338880539, -0.02296631410717964, -0.00015007441106718034, 0.029059119522571564, 0.00020695454441010952, -0.0418672040104866, -0.045913342386484146, -0.033572420477867126, 0.008005497977137566, -0.07171077281236649, -0.004331983160227537, 0.0376567617058754, -0.05586467683315277, -0.04721716418862343, -0.008953140117228031, 0.010759561322629452, 0.037776485085487366, -0.02723122015595436, -0.01618959940969944, 0.02082064375281334, 0.02800751104950905, -0.022411704063415527, 0.04317101463675499, -0.02687840722501278, -0.004681213293224573, 0.027480559423565865, 0.024489637464284897, -0.06859055161476135, -0.01726699061691761, -0.02384832687675953, -0.0005632844404317439, 0.03745386376976967, 0.005086949095129967, 0.029355771839618683, 0.03477954864501953, -0.03859558328986168, -0.027689719572663307, -0.017397576943039894, -0.03775273263454437, -0.027872810140252113, 0.04721513390541077, 0.07262089103460312, 0.031618632376194, 0.014532278291881084, -0.055633172392845154, -0.0574336051940918, -0.031386833637952805, -0.020432211458683014, -0.04597780480980873, -0.056542422622442245, -0.03787638619542122, -0.031962692737579346, 0.0023387593682855368, -0.029383987188339233, -0.014821133576333523, -0.0006796372472308576, -0.06907321512699127, -0.02590155601501465, -0.004749429412186146, -0.010433885268867016, -0.037330031394958496, -0.04599931091070175, 0.03964591771364212, -0.019551986828446388, 0.02290811948478222, -0.05247517302632332, -0.05771391838788986, -0.019920378923416138, 0.05995035171508789, 0.010342027992010117, -0.01269512064754963, -0.03668098524212837, 0.03343657776713371, -0.042380575090646744, -0.011744280345737934, -0.015131565742194653, 0.061662282794713974, 0.05240795761346817, -0.04083101451396942, 0.00925640668720007, 0.005009165499359369, -0.030784213915467262, -0.010163307189941406, -0.002539834240451455, -0.00914185494184494, -0.05079702287912369, -0.05303312465548515, 0.061937350779771805, 0.0808747261762619, 0.0042698439210653305, -0.057600345462560654, -0.05424985662102699, 0.016784753650426865, 0.001711660181172192, 0.006969986483454704, 0.0633205696940422, 0.010767696425318718, -0.059559550136327744, -0.012288887053728104, -0.025414153933525085, -0.011048677377402782, -0.034635383635759354, 0.006119442638009787, 0.011324993334710598, -0.03974977135658264, 0.027880944311618805, -0.06624864786863327, -0.011352616362273693, 0.04704500362277031, 0.07069342583417892, -0.003265979466959834, 0.0075471787713468075, 0.0032064327970147133, 0.047237299382686615, 0.04747834429144859, -0.020832106471061707, 0.056997496634721756, 0.004568526521325111, 0.04912464693188667, -0.030550485476851463, -0.02684829756617546, 0.028417028486728668, -0.04627782851457596, -0.045320481061935425, 0.02421601116657257, -0.013550725765526295, 0.016668692231178284, 0.03942864015698433, -0.020277297124266624, 0.016133464872837067, -0.01963619515299797, 0.04012884199619293, -0.035369712859392166, -0.06890105456113815, -0.03985784202814102, 0.004801645874977112, -0.056687306612730026, 0.009467077441513538, -0.010477299802005291, -0.02939806878566742, -0.04358992725610733, 0.006284387782216072, -0.05835229158401489, 0.027991995215415955, 0.03528590872883797, 0.044970717281103134, 0.021467629820108414, 0.04732624441385269, 0.030281782150268555, 0.03198728337883949, -0.03188445419073105, 0.0029212634544819593, -0.04120219498872757, -0.00543083855882287, 0.024650216102600098, -0.006018947809934616, -0.029981138184666634, -0.020035741850733757, 0.024933287873864174, -0.033990539610385895, -0.021697578951716423, 0.059640590101480484, 0.01908249780535698, 0.01562073640525341, -0.08038907498121262, -0.010231771506369114, -0.061755042523145676, 0.04536256566643715, -0.015997128561139107, -0.0464959442615509, 0.05787697806954384, -0.027006328105926514, 0.015109756961464882, -0.037438713014125824, -0.008170844055712223, -0.014742651022970676, -0.05504441633820534, -0.01615832932293415, -0.05001898854970932, -0.00039061473216861486, 0.009165332652628422, 0.028091922402381897, -0.028673015534877777, -0.0055427998304367065, -0.07980143278837204, 0.015823757275938988, 0.015115422196686268, 0.02279536798596382, 0.0017685280181467533, -0.003945168573409319, 0.02039085142314434, -0.002046040492132306, -0.007138693705201149, -0.025094110518693924, -0.004573159851133823, 0.04642881453037262, -0.06605641543865204, 0.045565731823444366, -0.06611069291830063, -0.057891666889190674, -0.009278934448957443, -0.007149836979806423, 0.06667114794254303, -0.013383612968027592, -0.029941720888018608, -0.013792901299893856, -0.03698622062802315, -0.04439572989940643, -0.03367697820067406, -0.033815376460552216, -0.046824414283037186, -0.0626431331038475, 0.04201314225792885, -0.005328555591404438, -0.027560047805309296, -0.008706706576049328, 0.008519329130649567, 0.060202762484550476, -0.0033553678076714277, -0.008384177461266518, 0.011801546439528465, 0.03557289391756058, 0.0012946338392794132, -0.009312641806900501, -0.013801646418869495, -0.0752217173576355, -0.023714223876595497, 0.0015619812766090035, -0.036024607717990875, 0.012505151331424713, 0.013481790199875832, -0.03524700179696083, 0.018289715051651, -0.08067624270915985, 0.011433020234107971, 0.056902576237916946, -0.04119940474629402, -0.009936613030731678, 0.011161506175994873, -0.00770182441920042, 0.018882732838392258, 0.025921158492565155, 0.0038245946634560823, -0.011268038302659988, -0.026565365493297577, -0.004008494783192873, -0.006170520558953285, -0.05961170420050621, -0.006091517861932516, 0.05047719180583954, 0.02456766366958618, -0.06402447074651718, 0.03804325684905052, 0.017708802595734596, -0.02295236475765705, -0.0001004422374535352, 0.006914525292813778, 0.06412361562252045, -0.046288058161735535, -0.06637122482061386, 0.004235763102769852, -0.017943089827895164, 0.018782347440719604, 0.044480033218860626, -0.05701936036348343, -0.023914922028779984, 0.024062899872660637, 0.02858089469373226, 0.04367596283555031, 0.0003408061165828258, -0.006896249484270811, -0.02252117730677128, -0.018511641770601273, -0.05911445990204811, -0.05932214483618736, -0.013713669031858444, -0.04573967680335045, -0.04557975009083748, 0.005295648239552975, 0.013253279030323029, 0.06608867645263672, 0.06390345096588135, 0.03269830718636513, -0.020352696999907494, -0.014833543449640274, -0.05724969133734703, 0.05525607243180275, -0.039737217128276825, 0.007708646822720766, -0.007186321076005697, -0.017440808936953545, 0.03782910853624344, -0.022771373391151428, -0.028844129294157028, 0.018716389313340187, -0.05650704354047775, 0.013978919945657253, -0.0365816205739975, -0.02761627919971943, -0.04653460904955864, 0.017822086811065674, 0.04326673969626427, -0.04954567924141884, 0.06388577818870544, -0.009294480085372925, 0.0015901225851848722, 0.0018321227980777621, 0.030545728281140327, 0.031814996153116226, -0.06838210672140121, -0.027424000203609467, 0.0682048425078392, -0.06813313812017441, -0.034917235374450684, -0.06827102601528168, -0.037998609244823456, -0.03519219532608986, -0.033419229090213776, -0.00894629955291748, 0.022243216633796692, -0.014879639260470867, -0.012507912702858448, 0.031183699145913124, 0.043723948299884796, -0.08302561193704605, 0.025377970188856125, 0.00630265474319458, -0.06884875893592834, -0.05467405170202255, 0.03881556913256645, -0.045165449380874634, -0.019803758710622787, -0.04899505525827408, -0.016590477898716927, -0.036832306534051895, -0.013633843511343002, -0.000596005585975945, 0.042442016303539276, -0.042799074202775955, 0.05564023181796074, 0.0037148494739085436, -0.018662801012396812, -0.019829202443361282, -0.03886254131793976, -0.03083018586039543, -0.03434300050139427, 0.06124141439795494, -0.03141328692436218, -0.011936359107494354, -0.03042994998395443, 0.02469790168106556, -0.01702079176902771, -0.023507434874773026, 0.026160407811403275, 0.02974952571094036, 0.035915620625019073, -0.032920245081186295, -0.012459046207368374, 0.00680010300129652, -0.054466377943754196, 0.030883947387337685, 0.0017936060903593898, 0.04100514203310013, -0.020290309563279152, 0.015986887738108635, 0.014441345818340778, -0.050771888345479965, 0.025739779695868492, -0.0461028553545475, -0.06144078075885773, -0.010437557473778725, -0.019727477803826332, -0.026869136840105057, 0.06117621064186096, 0.04797991365194321, 0.011083635501563549, 0.03849733620882034, 0.0003855694376397878, -0.023641161620616913, -0.04603400453925133, -0.04077758267521858, -0.010377527214586735, 0.012664439156651497, 0.029466642066836357, 0.005662001669406891, 0.06021307408809662, -0.05004747584462166, 0.023691993206739426, -0.020395586267113686, -0.050442472100257874, 0.0030568947549909353, -0.02603720687329769, -0.026508662849664688, 0.02253090590238571, -0.01733442209661007, -0.03218210116028786, 0.013896913267672062, 0.0268931295722723, -0.00010889286204474047, -0.07496702671051025, -0.0539209321141243, -0.030750049278140068, -0.04634322598576546, 0.033649150282144547, -0.006161462981253862, 0.05077168717980385, 0.024923641234636307, 0.04890257120132446, 0.03410995006561279, 0.01928129978477955, -0.017377661541104317, -0.035421352833509445, 0.0014573135413229465, 0.05266688019037247, 0.01263788715004921, -0.047276921570301056, -0.042079225182533264, 0.0291863102465868, -0.07034265249967575, -0.03093361295759678, -0.01985657401382923, 0.05167459696531296, -0.033760566264390945, -0.008430044166743755, 0.04508379101753235, 0.027409318834543228, -0.028219113126397133, -0.07696302980184555, 0.02813752368092537, -0.008854729123413563, 0.01305324211716652, 0.029675360769033432, 0.012140988372266293, -0.0680622085928917, -0.0034418017603456974, -0.06091678515076637, -0.03402741998434067, -0.026461739093065262, 0.04901944473385811, 0.03228750452399254, 0.004517650697380304, -0.016026636585593224, -0.041609205305576324, -0.01264194119721651, 0.04553484544157982, 0.026868855580687523, 0.03521469980478287, -0.055330369621515274, -0.024126259610056877, -0.022537577897310257, 0.003586173988878727, 0.051090970635414124, -0.06278026103973389, -0.04457014799118042, -0.021125564351677895, 0.011743376031517982, -0.04235959053039551, 0.011089446023106575, 0.0481942743062973, -0.024815723299980164, 0.026569783687591553, -0.056554436683654785, -0.02281970903277397, -0.02963414043188095, -0.0543053038418293, -0.0031823532190173864, -0.058464858680963516, 0.023493414744734764, -0.015324469655752182, -0.0525597408413887, -0.05113895982503891, -0.02814542129635811, -0.05783400684595108, -0.01248004287481308, 0.036416273564100266, -0.05297538638114929, 0.07394400984048843, -0.04526100307703018, -0.030281277373433113, -0.020693348720669746, -0.04687884449958801, -0.06179976090788841, 0.03654700890183449, 0.061161108314991, -0.0532861202955246, -0.0006856899126432836, -0.06901653856039047, 0.038828302174806595, -0.05911315605044365, -0.019940081983804703, 0.01882428303360939, 0.03581010922789574, -0.06520179659128189, 0.024444835260510445, -0.008341249078512192, -0.0200045108795166, -0.0016180288512259722, -0.04839443042874336, 0.0004755503323394805, -0.02263953536748886, -0.018208753317594528, -0.001490689581260085, 0.00798456184566021, 0.016510402783751488, 0.060881804674863815, 0.001419496489688754, -0.05059260129928589, 0.011892466805875301, 0.03144148737192154, -0.0030366985592991114, 0.015617999248206615, 0.008386432193219662, -0.0368354432284832, -0.01427018828690052, 0.03169435262680054, 0.01807577908039093, -0.002728446153923869, -0.00839734636247158, 0.03589587286114693, 0.02211051620543003, -0.012734039686620235, -0.041247520595788956, 0.05174708366394043, 0.03709980845451355, -0.03734361380338669, -0.003760047722607851, 0.018051572144031525, -0.034850433468818665, -0.043830178678035736 ]