id
stringclasses 100
values | input
stringclasses 100
values | response
stringlengths 35
718
| score
float64 1
5
| prompt
stringlengths 2.14k
5.24k
| cluster_assignment
stringclasses 4
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot just days before president obama visited utah earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ' secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites , according to police . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot just days before president obama visited utah earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ' secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites , according to police .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | an fbi agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window and tying a rope around the rifle case's handle . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
an fbi agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window and tying a rope around the rifle case's handle .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | An FBI agent's sniper rifle was stolen from his car during a hotel parking lot robbery in Salt Lake City, Utah The FBI did not immediately respond to requests for comment. | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
An FBI agent's sniper rifle was stolen from his car during a hotel parking lot robbery in Salt Lake City, Utah The FBI did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock . the rifle's serial number has been entered into the national crime information computer . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock . the rifle's serial number has been entered into the national crime information computer .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | an fbi agent 's sniper rifle -lrb- similar to the one pictured -rrb- was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot . an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot just days before president obama visited utah earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites , according to police . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
an fbi agent 's sniper rifle -lrb- similar to the one pictured -rrb- was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot . an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot just days before president obama visited utah earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites , according to police .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | an fbi agent 's sniper rifle -lrb- similar to the one pictured -rrb- was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot . an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot just days before president obama visited utah earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites , according to police . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
an fbi agent 's sniper rifle -lrb- similar to the one pictured -rrb- was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot . an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot just days before president obama visited utah earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites , according to police .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites . Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window , tying a rope around the rifle case 's handle or a cable lock , and using the momentum from another vehicle . The agent 's gear bag , backpack , and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites . Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window , tying a rope around the rifle case 's handle or a cable lock , and using the momentum from another vehicle . The agent 's gear bag , backpack , and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ' secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window , tying a rope around the rifle case 's handle or a cable lock , and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case 's handle free from the lock . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ' secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window , tying a rope around the rifle case 's handle or a cable lock , and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case 's handle free from the lock .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot just days before president obama visited utah earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window , tying a rope around the rifle case 's handle or a cable lock . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel parking lot just days before president obama visited utah earlier this month . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe with padlocks while the car was parked at the marriott springhill suites . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window , tying a rope around the rifle case 's handle or a cable lock .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | fbi agent 's sniper was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right window . an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel just days before president obama visited utah earlier the window frame of the agent 's car was pulled from the door . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
fbi agent 's sniper was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel . the gun was inside a hard rifle case and was ` secured properly ' to a truck safe . police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right window . an fbi agent 's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car 's window and stolen from a salt lake city hotel just days before president obama visited utah earlier the window frame of the agent 's car was pulled from the door .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-051db270afc32571a08c15124330efe89d80fea8 | An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office | The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites . Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock . The agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
An FBI agent's sniper rifle (similar to the one pictured) was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot An FBI agent's sniper rifle was ripped out of his car's window and stolen from a Salt Lake City hotel parking lot just days before President Obama visited Utah earlier this month. The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites, according to police. Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock. The window frame of the agent's car was pulled from the door, which police believe could indicate the large case was ripped through the shattered window. 'The rifle had been secured properly,' Salt Lake City Police Detective Dennis McGowan told Fox 13 Salt Lake City. 'There are all kinds of ways the weapon was secure. Yet someone was able to forcefully take the weapon.' The FBI agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft, which the police report states happened overnight. The theft happened just a week before Obama (pictured during his visit) made a scheduled trip to Utah earlier this month Officers found two skid marks and pieces of rope lying on the pavement near the car, as well as the broken-off handle of the rifle case. The agent's bags and some of his clothing were found at a Residence Inn across the street, but the sniper rifle has not been recovered. Marriott Springhill Suites, the agent's hotel, is next to the city's airport and just down the street from the state's FBI office. The hotel does not have surveillance cameras, according to the police report. Salt Lake City police said the rifle's serial number has been entered into the National Crime Information Computer. The Secret Service told Fox 13 Salt Lake City the agency was notified about the stolen rifle before President Obama's visit, but could not comment if the theft prompted an increase of security. Det. McGowan said police do not know if the thief specifically targeted the agent's car. The sniper rifle was stolen sometime overnight from the parking lot of Marriott Springhill Suites, where the agent was staying. The hotel is just across the street from the state's FBI office
### RESPONSE
The gun was inside a hard rifle case and was 'secured properly' to a truck safe with padlocks and chains while the car was parked at the Marriott Springhill Suites . Police believe the thief stole the rifle by breaking the rear right passenger-side window, tying a rope around the rifle case's handle or a cable lock, and using the momentum from another vehicle to then break the case's handle free from the lock . The agent also reported that his gear bag, backpack, and some clothing and tools were also stolen during the March 27 theft .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , is accused of biting his neighbour terrence freebody 's head , slitting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on july 2012 . he was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder . he allegedly killed his neighbour in 2012 , a jury has heard . the triple 0 calls it made ` almost certainly ' during the incident . | 4.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , is accused of biting his neighbour terrence freebody 's head , slitting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on july 2012 . he was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder . he allegedly killed his neighbour in 2012 , a jury has heard . the triple 0 calls it made ` almost certainly ' during the incident .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . the man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012 , a jury has heard . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event , the abc reported . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . the man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012 , a jury has heard . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event , the abc reported .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident . costa 's state of mind is critical to case , as . the jury can return a not guilty verdict if costa 's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident . costa 's state of mind is critical to case , as . the jury can return a not guilty verdict if costa 's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of killing his elderly neighbour terrence freebody in the dining room of his home on mugga way , red hill , canberra in july 2012 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of killing his elderly neighbour terrence freebody in the dining room of his home on mugga way , red hill , canberra in july 2012 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of killing his elderly neighbour terrence freebody in the dining room of his home on mugga way in july 2012 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of killing his elderly neighbour terrence freebody in the dining room of his home on mugga way in july 2012 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | the man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012 , a jury has heard . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
the man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012 , a jury has heard . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event . he told the court that the triple 0 calls which costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment' | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event . he told the court that the triple 0 calls which costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of murdering his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012. The accused is on trial for the murder of his neighbour. | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of murdering his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012. The accused is on trial for the murder of his neighbour.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour terrence freebody in the dining room of his home on mugga way, red hill, canberra in july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining . 'i believe that at the time of the killing mr costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour terrence freebody in the dining room of his home on mugga way, red hill, canberra in july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining . 'i believe that at the time of the killing mr costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | the man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012 , a jury has heard . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . costa 's state of mind is critical to case , as . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
the man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012 , a jury has heard . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . costa 's state of mind is critical to case , as .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | the man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012 , a jury has heard . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event , the abc reported . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
the man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012 , a jury has heard . luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra on july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event , the abc reported .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | Luigi Costa , 71 , is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way , Red Hill , Canberra in July 2012 . Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event . The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa 's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
Luigi Costa , 71 , is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way , Red Hill , Canberra in July 2012 . Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event . The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa 's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , is accused of killing his elderly neighbour terrence freebody in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra in july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event . professor mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which costa made ' almost certainly ' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from ' moment to moment ' . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , is accused of killing his elderly neighbour terrence freebody in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra in july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event . professor mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which costa made ' almost certainly ' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from ' moment to moment ' .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra in july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind abuse at the time of the attack . costa feigned his failing memory . | 2.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour terrence freebody 's head , cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on mugga way in red hill , canberra in july 2012 . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen believes there was evidence of the accused 's state of mind abuse at the time of the attack . costa feigned his failing memory .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour 's head . luigi costa , 71 , was accused of killing his neighbour terrence freebody . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident . professor mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls costa made ` almost certainly ' the man was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
luigi costa , 71 , is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour 's head . luigi costa , 71 , was accused of killing his neighbour terrence freebody . forensic psychiatrist professor paul mullen examined costa 's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident . professor mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls costa made ` almost certainly ' the man was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b1f6faac3f406edca1e0cad8cce1319c83e62605 | The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 . A psychiatrist told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment' He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state . The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The man who allegedly killed his neighbour was believed to be suffering from dementia and alcohol abuse at the time of the horrendous murder in 2012, a jury has heard. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of stomping on his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody's head, cutting his throat and stabbing him multiple times in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way in Red Hill, Canberra on July 2012. Forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen examined Costa after the attack and believes there was evidence of the accused's state of mind declining in the lead-up to the incident and also during the event, The ABC reported. Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in the dining room of his home on Mugga Way, Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 Professor Mullin told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment'. He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state. 'I believe that at the time of the killing Mr Costa's brain was compromised by dementia and when you add to this alcohol that led to a confused state,' he said. 'I do not think you would understand what you were doing in that state or understand the dreadful long-term consequences.' Prosecutor Shane Drumgold suggested that Costa feigned his failing memory while being interviewed by Professor Mullin - who denied these claims. 'My view is that it was more likely than possible that Mr Costa was suffering a demented illness in the weeks, months and possibly years in the lead up to this event,' he said. Costa's state of mind is critical to case, as The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
Luigi Costa, 71, is accused of killing his elderly neighbour Terrence Freebody in Red Hill, Canberra in July 2012 . A psychiatrist told the court that the triple 0 calls which Costa made 'almost certainly' during the incident proved that his mood fluctuated from 'moment to moment' He also said the trail of faeces from the crime scene to the toilet were police found Costa suggested his confused mental state . The jury can return a not guilty verdict if Costa's unstable mindset at time of the attack can be proven .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley . roberto martinez has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . the roberto martinez says barkley is in his rights to request penalty-taking . | 1 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley . roberto martinez has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . the roberto martinez says barkley is in his rights to request penalty-taking .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon -- rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . baines scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon -- rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . baines scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon -- rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . baines -lrb- left -rrb- has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon -- rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . baines -lrb- left -rrb- has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on saturday . baines has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on saturday . baines has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon -- rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon -- rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1 - 0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon – rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty - taking duties on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1 - 0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon – rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty - taking duties on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton beat burnley 1-0 at goodison park on saturday . ross barkley missed from the penalty spot in the 10th minute . kevin mirallas took a penalty from leighton baines in january . roberto martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to take it . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton beat burnley 1-0 at goodison park on saturday . ross barkley missed from the penalty spot in the 10th minute . kevin mirallas took a penalty from leighton baines in january . roberto martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to take it .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | Everton's Ross Barkley missed a penalty in the Premier League, but his replacement Leighton Baines had no problem taking the shot. Photo: PA | 2.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
Everton's Ross Barkley missed a penalty in the Premier League, but his replacement Leighton Baines had no problem taking the shot. Photo: PA
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton defeated burnley 1-0 in their premier league clash on saturday . ross barkley missed from the spot in the 10th minute at goodison park . the toffees boss roberto martinez was forced to defend his player . leighton baines has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the league . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton defeated burnley 1-0 in their premier league clash on saturday . ross barkley missed from the spot in the 10th minute at goodison park . the toffees boss roberto martinez was forced to defend his player . leighton baines has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the league .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . barkley 's effort is saved by burnley goalkeeper tom heaton at goodison park . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . barkley 's effort is saved by burnley goalkeeper tom heaton at goodison park . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon -- rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time , it brought back memories of everton 's match against west brom in january when kevin mirallas grabbed the ball from baines to take a penalty - and missed . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon -- rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time , it brought back memories of everton 's match against west brom in january when kevin mirallas grabbed the ball from baines to take a penalty - and missed .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | Ross Barkley missed from the spot in Everton 's 1-0 win against Burnley . The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon . Leighton Baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
Ross Barkley missed from the spot in Everton 's 1-0 win against Burnley . The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick -- awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon . Leighton Baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon – rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . barkley 's effort is saved by burnley goalkeeper tom heaton at goodison park . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after ross barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against burnley at goodison park . the untried barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon – rather than leighton baines , who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . barkley 's effort is saved by burnley goalkeeper tom heaton at goodison park .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | ross barkley has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty at the club . the untried barkley took the 10th minute kick for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon . | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
ross barkley has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty at the club . the untried barkley took the 10th minute kick for a foul by david jones on aaron lennon .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco . leighton baines scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . ross barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
everton manager roberto martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco . leighton baines scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the premier league . ross barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty . martinez insisted barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-c6667409fcdea2c89ba9f0d3a72c50e3967b4b1b | Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley | Everton beat Burnley 1-0 in their Premier League clash on Saturday . Ross Barkley missed from the spot in the 10th minute at Goodison Park . Roberto Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday . Leighton Baines has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the league . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Everton manager Roberto Martinez was forced to defend another penalty fiasco at the club after Ross Barkley missed from the spot in their 1-0 win against Burnley at Goodison Park. The untried Barkley inexplicably took the 10th minute kick – awarded for a foul by David Jones on Aaron Lennon – rather than Leighton Baines, who has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League. Although there was no dispute between the team-mates this time, it brought back memories of Everton's match against West Brom in January when Kevin Mirallas grabbed the ball from Baines to take a penalty - and missed. Ross Barkley steps up to take a 10th minute penalty despite the presence of Leighton Baines on the pitch Barkley's effort is saved by Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton at Goodison Park Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday. 'If Romelu Lukaku had been on the pitch, he would have taken it. Otherwise, I am happy to have three or four players who can take penalties and let it depend on how they feel at that moment,' argued the Everton manager. Baines (left) has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the Premier League 'Ross showed incredible responsibility to take it. I love seeing players take control of the big moments and Leighton was happy to given him that responsibility.' Barkley's penalty was well-struck but wasn't put in the corner and Burnley goalkeeper Tom Heaton dived to his right to save. Fortunately for the young England player, it didn't prove costly as Mirallas went on to score the only goal of the game after 29 minutes. Everton boss Roberto Martinez issues instructions to his players during a break in play against Burnley
### RESPONSE
Everton beat Burnley 1-0 in their Premier League clash on Saturday . Ross Barkley missed from the spot in the 10th minute at Goodison Park . Roberto Martinez insisted Barkley was within his rights to request penalty-taking duties on Saturday . Leighton Baines has scored 15 penalties from 16 attempts in the league .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | two guests found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico . the cruise line said two guests were found dead in a murder-suicide . holland america line says two passengers found dead at their stateroom on thursday . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
two guests found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico . the cruise line said two guests were found dead in a murder-suicide . holland america line says two passengers found dead at their stateroom on thursday . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | -lrb- cnn -rrb- two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide , the cruise line said . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
-lrb- cnn -rrb- two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide , the cruise line said . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide . the ship left tampa , florida , on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide . the ship left tampa , florida , on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | two passengers were found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
two passengers were found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide . holland america line said two guests were found inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . `` the cabin was immediately secured , and the authorities were notified , including the fbi , '' holland said . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide . holland america line said two guests were found inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . `` the cabin was immediately secured , and the authorities were notified , including the fbi , '' holland said .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | ( cnn ) two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder - suicide , the cruise line said . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14 - day southern caribbean cruise . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
( cnn ) two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder - suicide , the cruise line said . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14 - day southern caribbean cruise .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | two passengers were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam . the ship left tampa, florida, on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
two passengers were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam . the ship left tampa, florida, on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. UPDATE: Holland America said the two passengers were found dead in their stateroom, but did not provide details. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. UPDATE: Holland America said the two passengers were found dead in their stateroom, but did not provide details. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | fbi spokesman says authorities are on scene investigating . two passengers were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam . the ship left tampa, florida, on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
fbi spokesman says authorities are on scene investigating . two passengers were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam . the ship left tampa, florida, on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | -lrb- cnn -rrb- two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide , the cruise line said . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
-lrb- cnn -rrb- two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide , the cruise line said . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | -lrb- cnn -rrb- two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide , the cruise line said . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . `` the cabin was immediately secured , and the authorities were notified , including the fbi , '' holland america said . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
-lrb- cnn -rrb- two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide , the cruise line said . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms ryndam at 11:30 a.m. thursday . `` the cabin was immediately secured , and the authorities were notified , including the fbi , '' holland america said .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | Holland America Line says two guests were found dead inside their stateroom . The ship left Tampa , Florida , on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise . Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago says cleaning staff discovered the deceased passengers . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
Holland America Line says two guests were found dead inside their stateroom . The ship left Tampa , Florida , on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise . Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago says cleaning staff discovered the deceased passengers .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ship . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ship . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 on a 14-day southern caribbean cruise . it 's currently in san juan , puerto rico .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | holland left tampa , florida , on march 29 . two passengers found dead inside their stateroom on the ship . it 's in san juan , puerto rico . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
holland left tampa , florida , on march 29 . two passengers found dead inside their stateroom on the ship . it 's in san juan , puerto rico .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 . fbi spokesman says authorities were on scene investigating . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in puerto rico . holland america line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom . the ship left tampa , florida , on march 29 . fbi spokesman says authorities were on scene investigating .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
cnn-test-bcdb32ae644040a721da880fff9c1d502048cd8b | (CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door. | "The authorities will make the official determination on what occurred," Holland America says . The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
(CNN)Two passengers found dead on a cruise ship in Puerto Rico appear to have died in a murder-suicide, the cruise line said. Holland America Line said two guests were found dead inside their stateroom on the ms Ryndam at 11:30 a.m. Thursday. "The cabin was immediately secured, and the authorities were notified, including the FBI," Holland America said. "We are cooperating fully with the investigation, and the authorities will make the official determination on what occurred." FBI spokesman Moises Quiñones said authorities were on scene investigating. The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise. It's currently in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Port Authority spokesman Efraín Santiago told El Nuevo Dia newspaper that the cleaning staff on the ship had discovered the deceased passengers after knocking on the cabin's door.
### RESPONSE
"The authorities will make the official determination on what occurred," Holland America says . The ship left Tampa, Florida, on March 29 on a 14-day Southern Caribbean cruise .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | patrick kluivert has been winning start in world cup qualifiers . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf . patrick kluivert 's team won 4-3 on aggregate at montserrat to win . the holland face 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat . | 2 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
patrick kluivert has been winning start in world cup qualifiers . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf . patrick kluivert 's team won 4-3 on aggregate at montserrat to win . the holland face 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . kluivert 's team won 2-1 on saturday in willemstad . patrick kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 world cup qualification . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . kluivert 's team won 2-1 on saturday in willemstad . patrick kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 world cup qualification . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 world cup qualification . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 world cup qualification .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . patrick kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage . kluivert 's mother is from curacao , was a world cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . patrick kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage . kluivert 's mother is from curacao , was a world cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . patrick kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 world cup qualification . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . patrick kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 world cup qualification .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | former holland forward and assistant coach patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2 - 2 in a second - leg match at montserrat to win 4 - 3 on aggregate . kluivert 's team won 2 - 1 on saturday in willemstad . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
former holland forward and assistant coach patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2 - 2 in a second - leg match at montserrat to win 4 - 3 on aggregate . kluivert 's team won 2 - 1 on saturday in willemstad .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | patrick kluivert's curacao beat montserrat 4-3 on aggregate . curacao face cuba in the next round of 2018 world cup qualification . kluivert was assistant to louis van gaal at the 2014 world cup . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
patrick kluivert's curacao beat montserrat 4-3 on aggregate . curacao face cuba in the next round of 2018 world cup qualification . kluivert was assistant to louis van gaal at the 2014 world cup .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | Kluivert's side won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
Kluivert's side won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | curacao have qualified for the second qualifying round of the 2018 world cup . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . patrick kluivert worked with louis van gaal at the 2014 world cup . curacao face cuba in the next round on june 8 and 16 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
curacao have qualified for the second qualifying round of the 2018 world cup . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . patrick kluivert worked with louis van gaal at the 2014 world cup . curacao face cuba in the next round on june 8 and 16 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | former holland forward and assistant coach patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . kluivert 's team won 2-1 on saturday in willemstad . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
former holland forward and assistant coach patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . kluivert 's team won 2-1 on saturday in willemstad .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | former holland forward and assistant coach patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
former holland forward and assistant coach patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | Curacao beat Montserrat 4-3 on aggregate to progress to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 World Cup . Patrick Kluivert 's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad . The former Holland forward worked with Louis van Gaal last year . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
Curacao beat Montserrat 4-3 on aggregate to progress to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 World Cup . Patrick Kluivert 's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad . The former Holland forward worked with Louis van Gaal last year .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf . patrick kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 world cup qualification . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying as coach of curacao . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf . patrick kluivert has helped curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 world cup qualification .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2-2 in a match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . louis van gaal scored in the 87th minute five minutes after a substitute . | 1 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in concacaf for the 2018 tournament late tuesday . curacao drew 2-2 in a match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . louis van gaal scored in the 87th minute five minutes after a substitute .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | former holland forward patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . the first-round encounter was headed to extra time on tuesday . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
former holland forward patrick kluivert has made a winning start in world cup qualifying . the caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round . curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate . the first-round encounter was headed to extra time on tuesday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-46609841ffd23e9c22d1507edf7b176ecc4d834f | Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal. | Patrick Kluivert was assistant to Louis van Gaal at the 2014 World Cup . C Curacao drew 2-2 at Montserrat but won 4-3 on aggregate . C Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Former Holland forward and assistant coach Patrick Kluivert has made a winning start in World Cup qualifying as coach of Curacao. The Caribbean island team advanced to the second qualifying round in CONCACAF for the 2018 tournament late Tuesday. Curacao drew 2-2 in a second-leg match at Montserrat to win 4-3 on aggregate. Kluivert's team won 2-1 on Saturday in Willemstad. Patrick Kluivert has helped Curacao progress to the next stage of 2018 World Cup qualification Former Holland assistant Kluivert (far right) worked with Louis van Gaal (centre) at the 2014 World Cup The first-round encounter was headed to extra time on Tuesday until former Holland Under 21 international Charlton Vicento scored in the 87th minute, five minutes after coming on as a substitute. Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16. Kluivert, whose mother is from Curacao, was a World Cup losing semi-finalist in 1998 as a player, and last year as assistant to coach Louis van Gaal.
### RESPONSE
Patrick Kluivert was assistant to Louis van Gaal at the 2014 World Cup . C Curacao drew 2-2 at Montserrat but won 4-3 on aggregate . C Curacao face Cuba in the next round, on June 8 and 16 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the premier league . esteban cambiasso says the foxes will be up there with the best . the foxes are also seven points behind leicester city . the argentinian midfielder has won a cup in european competitions . | 1.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the premier league . esteban cambiasso says the foxes will be up there with the best . the foxes are also seven points behind leicester city . the argentinian midfielder has won a cup in european competitions .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester city in the premier league would be up there with the best . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester city in the premier league would be up there with the best . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester city in the premier league would be up there with the best . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining , knowing that time is running out to save themselves . esteban cambiasso says that helping keep leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester city in the premier league would be up there with the best . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining , knowing that time is running out to save themselves . esteban cambiasso says that helping keep leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | leicester city are seven points adrift at the bottom of the table . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table . esteban cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
leicester city are seven points adrift at the bottom of the table . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table . esteban cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester city in the premier league would be up there with the best . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining . cambiasso says that helping keep leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester city in the premier league would be up there with the best . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining . cambiasso says that helping keep leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining , knowing that time is running out to save themselves . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . esteban cambiasso says that helping keep leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining , knowing that time is running out to save themselves . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . esteban cambiasso says that helping keep leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso says keeping leicester in the premier league would be up there with the best achievements of his career . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining . leicester face west ham united at upton park on saturday . | 3 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso says keeping leicester in the premier league would be up there with the best achievements of his career . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining . leicester face west ham united at upton park on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | Esteban Cambiasso is confident Leicester can win the Premier League and keep themselves in the top flight. | 2 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
Esteban Cambiasso is confident Leicester can win the Premier League and keep themselves in the top flight.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso says keeping leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy . leicester are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table . nigel pearson's side face west ham united on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso says keeping leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy . leicester are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table . nigel pearson's side face west ham united on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso says that helping keep leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy . ' the argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 fifa club world cup . argentine primera division . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso says that helping keep leicester in the premier league will feel like winning a trophy . ' the argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 fifa club world cup . argentine primera division .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester city in the premier league would be up there with the best . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining , knowing that time is running out to save themselves . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping leicester city in the premier league would be up there with the best . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining , knowing that time is running out to save themselves . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | Esteban Cambiasso says keeping Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy . The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining . The Argentinian midfielder signed for the Foxes in the summer , leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
Esteban Cambiasso says keeping Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy . The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table , with only eight games remaining . The Argentinian midfielder signed for the Foxes in the summer , leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the premier league . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester city up will feel like winning a trophy . cambiasso had an illustrious career at inter milan . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso has won all the major european competitions a player can during his illustrious career . the foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the premier league . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester city up will feel like winning a trophy . cambiasso had an illustrious career at inter milan .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | leicester city are seven points adrift at the bottom of the premier league . esteban cambiasso signed for the foxes in the summer . the former inter milan star has won all the major european competitions . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
leicester city are seven points adrift at the bottom of the premier league . esteban cambiasso signed for the foxes in the summer . the former inter milan star has won all the major european competitions .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | esteban cambiasso has won the major european competitions . esteban cambiasso believes helping keep leicester in the premier league . foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table . click here for all the latest chelsea news . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
esteban cambiasso has won the major european competitions . esteban cambiasso believes helping keep leicester in the premier league . foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table . click here for all the latest chelsea news . cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping leicester up will feel like winning a trophy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2a48112ddee712f2364f128076cb2db555a043b1 | Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal | Leicester City are currently bottom of the Premier League . Only eight games remain for Nigel Pearson's side . Esteban Cambiasso says keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Esteban Cambiasso has won all the major European competitions a player can during his illustrious career but revealed that keeping Leicester City in the Premier League would be up there with the best. The Foxes are currently seven points adrift at the bottom of the table, with only eight games remaining, knowing that time is running out to save themselves. Cambiasso refuses to give up and admits that keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy. Esteban Cambiasso says that helping keep Leicester in the Premier League will feel like winning a trophy 'For me, it's like another cup,' he told BBC East Midlands Today. 'When you start another season you have an objective, and this is the objective for us. 'For me, winning a cup or winning the league with another team is the same now as having the possibility to save Leicester in the Premier League.' The Argentinian midfielder poses with the trophy after his team won the 2010 FIFA Club World Cup Cambiasso had an illustrious career at Inter Milan, winning an impressive 15 trophies during his stint River Plate (2001-2002) Argentine Primera Division Real Madrid (2002-2004) La Liga Super Cup Supercopa de Espana Inter Milan (2004-2014) Champions League Serie A (5) Coppa Italia (4) Supercoppa (4) FIFA Club World Cup Having not won a game since January, Nigel Pearson's men face West Ham United on Saturday and Cambiasso is still convinced they can avoid the drop. 'I understood when I signed for Leicester it's not an easy job to stay in the Premier League,' he said. 'It's a difficult situation but I think we have our chances to win matches. There's a quarter of the Premier League left to finish. 'I think some people think for Leicester all is finished. But I'm sure, because I watch my team-mates every day, we can save Leicester and stay in the Premier League.' The former Inter Milan star signed for the Foxes in the summer, leaving Italy after ten years and embarking on a new challenge in England. After agreeing to a one-year-deal, Cambiasso has quickly established himself as a key player but it remains to be seen if he'll still be in the East Midlands at the start of next season. The former Real Madrid man was also successful during his short spell in Spain for Real Madrid Cambiasso played during Real's 'Galatico' era, with Luis Figo, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldo and David Beckham 'Leicester always wanted me,' he added. 'After these nine months or eight months, I'm very happy because my family is OK, and I'm good. 'I want a few more points, but all the rest is perfect.' Cambiasso is happy in the East Midlands and could stay beyond his current one-year-deal
### RESPONSE
Leicester City are currently bottom of the Premier League . Only eight games remain for Nigel Pearson's side . Esteban Cambiasso says keeping Leicester up will feel like winning a trophy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-fadabe346fe95d33eee71299e6596754768f5246 | A 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying. The woman, named only as Gemma, has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother Debbie when they were four months old. Now Debbie is threatening to ban Gemma from seeing the children at all, after discovering her daughter's penchant for legal high, MKat, and because she suspects her of stealing. Scroll down for video Feckless: 23-year-old Gemma faces being prevented from seeing her children by her own mother 'I love them,' says Debbie of the two children. 'She [Gemma] isn't fit enough to have them. She doesn't care.' Debbie, who stepped in to care for the children after social services threatened to take them away, says her daughter's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand. She also claims that Gemma, who is unemployed, stole an iPad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle. Although Gemma says she did not steal the device, she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past. 'From around the age of 13, she went off the rails,' says Debbie. 'She was drinking beer and having underage sex. Upset: Debbie reacts after hearing the results of Gemma's lie detector test - which revealed she did steal Furious: Debbie, who has looked after Gemma's children all their lives, says she will ban her from the house 'With the children, she was excited about being pregnant but gave up about four months after having them and then dumped the babies on me.' As a result, Debbie, who appeared alongside her daughter on The Jeremy Kyle Show, has been left to bring both children up alone. Now at the end of her tether, Debbie says she is preparing to ban Gemma from her home and from seeing the children - because she can't trust her not pinch their possessions. Upset: According to her mother, Gemma prefers drinking and parties to work and motherhood 'I don't know how you could do that to your own kid,' adds Debbie, who also revealed that Gemma's children call her mum and not grandma. 'She doesn't care. She doesn't care at all and I feel awful about it because at the end of the day, they're my grandchildren and I love them. 'She's missed out from day one. She doesn't put them first. She knows she needs to grow up and stop drinking and taking drugs and partying.' | woman named only as gemma , has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother debbie . debbie is threatening to ban her from seeing children at all ages . she says her daughter 's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand . she also claims her daughter , who is unemployed , stole an ipad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle . she said her daughter is n't ` fit enough to have them ' . she has been banned from . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying. The woman, named only as Gemma, has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother Debbie when they were four months old. Now Debbie is threatening to ban Gemma from seeing the children at all, after discovering her daughter's penchant for legal high, MKat, and because she suspects her of stealing. Scroll down for video Feckless: 23-year-old Gemma faces being prevented from seeing her children by her own mother 'I love them,' says Debbie of the two children. 'She [Gemma] isn't fit enough to have them. She doesn't care.' Debbie, who stepped in to care for the children after social services threatened to take them away, says her daughter's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand. She also claims that Gemma, who is unemployed, stole an iPad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle. Although Gemma says she did not steal the device, she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past. 'From around the age of 13, she went off the rails,' says Debbie. 'She was drinking beer and having underage sex. Upset: Debbie reacts after hearing the results of Gemma's lie detector test - which revealed she did steal Furious: Debbie, who has looked after Gemma's children all their lives, says she will ban her from the house 'With the children, she was excited about being pregnant but gave up about four months after having them and then dumped the babies on me.' As a result, Debbie, who appeared alongside her daughter on The Jeremy Kyle Show, has been left to bring both children up alone. Now at the end of her tether, Debbie says she is preparing to ban Gemma from her home and from seeing the children - because she can't trust her not pinch their possessions. Upset: According to her mother, Gemma prefers drinking and parties to work and motherhood 'I don't know how you could do that to your own kid,' adds Debbie, who also revealed that Gemma's children call her mum and not grandma. 'She doesn't care. She doesn't care at all and I feel awful about it because at the end of the day, they're my grandchildren and I love them. 'She's missed out from day one. She doesn't put them first. She knows she needs to grow up and stop drinking and taking drugs and partying.'
### RESPONSE
woman named only as gemma , has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother debbie . debbie is threatening to ban her from seeing children at all ages . she says her daughter 's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand . she also claims her daughter , who is unemployed , stole an ipad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle . she said her daughter is n't ` fit enough to have them ' . she has been banned from .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-fadabe346fe95d33eee71299e6596754768f5246 | A 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying. The woman, named only as Gemma, has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother Debbie when they were four months old. Now Debbie is threatening to ban Gemma from seeing the children at all, after discovering her daughter's penchant for legal high, MKat, and because she suspects her of stealing. Scroll down for video Feckless: 23-year-old Gemma faces being prevented from seeing her children by her own mother 'I love them,' says Debbie of the two children. 'She [Gemma] isn't fit enough to have them. She doesn't care.' Debbie, who stepped in to care for the children after social services threatened to take them away, says her daughter's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand. She also claims that Gemma, who is unemployed, stole an iPad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle. Although Gemma says she did not steal the device, she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past. 'From around the age of 13, she went off the rails,' says Debbie. 'She was drinking beer and having underage sex. Upset: Debbie reacts after hearing the results of Gemma's lie detector test - which revealed she did steal Furious: Debbie, who has looked after Gemma's children all their lives, says she will ban her from the house 'With the children, she was excited about being pregnant but gave up about four months after having them and then dumped the babies on me.' As a result, Debbie, who appeared alongside her daughter on The Jeremy Kyle Show, has been left to bring both children up alone. Now at the end of her tether, Debbie says she is preparing to ban Gemma from her home and from seeing the children - because she can't trust her not pinch their possessions. Upset: According to her mother, Gemma prefers drinking and parties to work and motherhood 'I don't know how you could do that to your own kid,' adds Debbie, who also revealed that Gemma's children call her mum and not grandma. 'She doesn't care. She doesn't care at all and I feel awful about it because at the end of the day, they're my grandchildren and I love them. 'She's missed out from day one. She doesn't put them first. She knows she needs to grow up and stop drinking and taking drugs and partying.' | gemma , 13 , has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother debbie when they were four months old . debbie is threatening to ban gemma from seeing the children at all , after discovering her daughter 's penchant for legal high , mkat , and because she refuses to stop drinking and partying . debbie says she is preparing to ban gemma from her home and from seeing the children . | 2 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying. The woman, named only as Gemma, has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother Debbie when they were four months old. Now Debbie is threatening to ban Gemma from seeing the children at all, after discovering her daughter's penchant for legal high, MKat, and because she suspects her of stealing. Scroll down for video Feckless: 23-year-old Gemma faces being prevented from seeing her children by her own mother 'I love them,' says Debbie of the two children. 'She [Gemma] isn't fit enough to have them. She doesn't care.' Debbie, who stepped in to care for the children after social services threatened to take them away, says her daughter's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand. She also claims that Gemma, who is unemployed, stole an iPad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle. Although Gemma says she did not steal the device, she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past. 'From around the age of 13, she went off the rails,' says Debbie. 'She was drinking beer and having underage sex. Upset: Debbie reacts after hearing the results of Gemma's lie detector test - which revealed she did steal Furious: Debbie, who has looked after Gemma's children all their lives, says she will ban her from the house 'With the children, she was excited about being pregnant but gave up about four months after having them and then dumped the babies on me.' As a result, Debbie, who appeared alongside her daughter on The Jeremy Kyle Show, has been left to bring both children up alone. Now at the end of her tether, Debbie says she is preparing to ban Gemma from her home and from seeing the children - because she can't trust her not pinch their possessions. Upset: According to her mother, Gemma prefers drinking and parties to work and motherhood 'I don't know how you could do that to your own kid,' adds Debbie, who also revealed that Gemma's children call her mum and not grandma. 'She doesn't care. She doesn't care at all and I feel awful about it because at the end of the day, they're my grandchildren and I love them. 'She's missed out from day one. She doesn't put them first. She knows she needs to grow up and stop drinking and taking drugs and partying.'
### RESPONSE
gemma , 13 , has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother debbie when they were four months old . debbie is threatening to ban gemma from seeing the children at all , after discovering her daughter 's penchant for legal high , mkat , and because she refuses to stop drinking and partying . debbie says she is preparing to ban gemma from her home and from seeing the children .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-fadabe346fe95d33eee71299e6596754768f5246 | A 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying. The woman, named only as Gemma, has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother Debbie when they were four months old. Now Debbie is threatening to ban Gemma from seeing the children at all, after discovering her daughter's penchant for legal high, MKat, and because she suspects her of stealing. Scroll down for video Feckless: 23-year-old Gemma faces being prevented from seeing her children by her own mother 'I love them,' says Debbie of the two children. 'She [Gemma] isn't fit enough to have them. She doesn't care.' Debbie, who stepped in to care for the children after social services threatened to take them away, says her daughter's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand. She also claims that Gemma, who is unemployed, stole an iPad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle. Although Gemma says she did not steal the device, she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past. 'From around the age of 13, she went off the rails,' says Debbie. 'She was drinking beer and having underage sex. Upset: Debbie reacts after hearing the results of Gemma's lie detector test - which revealed she did steal Furious: Debbie, who has looked after Gemma's children all their lives, says she will ban her from the house 'With the children, she was excited about being pregnant but gave up about four months after having them and then dumped the babies on me.' As a result, Debbie, who appeared alongside her daughter on The Jeremy Kyle Show, has been left to bring both children up alone. Now at the end of her tether, Debbie says she is preparing to ban Gemma from her home and from seeing the children - because she can't trust her not pinch their possessions. Upset: According to her mother, Gemma prefers drinking and parties to work and motherhood 'I don't know how you could do that to your own kid,' adds Debbie, who also revealed that Gemma's children call her mum and not grandma. 'She doesn't care. She doesn't care at all and I feel awful about it because at the end of the day, they're my grandchildren and I love them. 'She's missed out from day one. She doesn't put them first. She knows she needs to grow up and stop drinking and taking drugs and partying.' | the woman , named only as gemma , has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother debbie when they were four months old . a 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying . now debbie is threatening to ban gemma from seeing the children at all , after discovering her daughter 's penchant for legal high , mkat , and because she suspects her of stealing . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying. The woman, named only as Gemma, has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother Debbie when they were four months old. Now Debbie is threatening to ban Gemma from seeing the children at all, after discovering her daughter's penchant for legal high, MKat, and because she suspects her of stealing. Scroll down for video Feckless: 23-year-old Gemma faces being prevented from seeing her children by her own mother 'I love them,' says Debbie of the two children. 'She [Gemma] isn't fit enough to have them. She doesn't care.' Debbie, who stepped in to care for the children after social services threatened to take them away, says her daughter's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand. She also claims that Gemma, who is unemployed, stole an iPad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle. Although Gemma says she did not steal the device, she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past. 'From around the age of 13, she went off the rails,' says Debbie. 'She was drinking beer and having underage sex. Upset: Debbie reacts after hearing the results of Gemma's lie detector test - which revealed she did steal Furious: Debbie, who has looked after Gemma's children all their lives, says she will ban her from the house 'With the children, she was excited about being pregnant but gave up about four months after having them and then dumped the babies on me.' As a result, Debbie, who appeared alongside her daughter on The Jeremy Kyle Show, has been left to bring both children up alone. Now at the end of her tether, Debbie says she is preparing to ban Gemma from her home and from seeing the children - because she can't trust her not pinch their possessions. Upset: According to her mother, Gemma prefers drinking and parties to work and motherhood 'I don't know how you could do that to your own kid,' adds Debbie, who also revealed that Gemma's children call her mum and not grandma. 'She doesn't care. She doesn't care at all and I feel awful about it because at the end of the day, they're my grandchildren and I love them. 'She's missed out from day one. She doesn't put them first. She knows she needs to grow up and stop drinking and taking drugs and partying.'
### RESPONSE
the woman , named only as gemma , has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother debbie when they were four months old . a 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying . now debbie is threatening to ban gemma from seeing the children at all , after discovering her daughter 's penchant for legal high , mkat , and because she suspects her of stealing .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-fadabe346fe95d33eee71299e6596754768f5246 | A 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying. The woman, named only as Gemma, has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother Debbie when they were four months old. Now Debbie is threatening to ban Gemma from seeing the children at all, after discovering her daughter's penchant for legal high, MKat, and because she suspects her of stealing. Scroll down for video Feckless: 23-year-old Gemma faces being prevented from seeing her children by her own mother 'I love them,' says Debbie of the two children. 'She [Gemma] isn't fit enough to have them. She doesn't care.' Debbie, who stepped in to care for the children after social services threatened to take them away, says her daughter's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand. She also claims that Gemma, who is unemployed, stole an iPad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle. Although Gemma says she did not steal the device, she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past. 'From around the age of 13, she went off the rails,' says Debbie. 'She was drinking beer and having underage sex. Upset: Debbie reacts after hearing the results of Gemma's lie detector test - which revealed she did steal Furious: Debbie, who has looked after Gemma's children all their lives, says she will ban her from the house 'With the children, she was excited about being pregnant but gave up about four months after having them and then dumped the babies on me.' As a result, Debbie, who appeared alongside her daughter on The Jeremy Kyle Show, has been left to bring both children up alone. Now at the end of her tether, Debbie says she is preparing to ban Gemma from her home and from seeing the children - because she can't trust her not pinch their possessions. Upset: According to her mother, Gemma prefers drinking and parties to work and motherhood 'I don't know how you could do that to your own kid,' adds Debbie, who also revealed that Gemma's children call her mum and not grandma. 'She doesn't care. She doesn't care at all and I feel awful about it because at the end of the day, they're my grandchildren and I love them. 'She's missed out from day one. She doesn't put them first. She knows she needs to grow up and stop drinking and taking drugs and partying.' | the woman , named only as gemma , has two children under five by two fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother debbie when they were four months old . now debbie is threatening to ban gemma from seeing the children at all , after discovering her daughter 's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand . she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A 23-year-old mother-of-two is at risk of being banned from seeing her own children - because she refuses to stop drinking and partying. The woman, named only as Gemma, has two children under five by two different fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother Debbie when they were four months old. Now Debbie is threatening to ban Gemma from seeing the children at all, after discovering her daughter's penchant for legal high, MKat, and because she suspects her of stealing. Scroll down for video Feckless: 23-year-old Gemma faces being prevented from seeing her children by her own mother 'I love them,' says Debbie of the two children. 'She [Gemma] isn't fit enough to have them. She doesn't care.' Debbie, who stepped in to care for the children after social services threatened to take them away, says her daughter's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand. She also claims that Gemma, who is unemployed, stole an iPad from one of the children and sold it to fund her party lifestyle. Although Gemma says she did not steal the device, she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past. 'From around the age of 13, she went off the rails,' says Debbie. 'She was drinking beer and having underage sex. Upset: Debbie reacts after hearing the results of Gemma's lie detector test - which revealed she did steal Furious: Debbie, who has looked after Gemma's children all their lives, says she will ban her from the house 'With the children, she was excited about being pregnant but gave up about four months after having them and then dumped the babies on me.' As a result, Debbie, who appeared alongside her daughter on The Jeremy Kyle Show, has been left to bring both children up alone. Now at the end of her tether, Debbie says she is preparing to ban Gemma from her home and from seeing the children - because she can't trust her not pinch their possessions. Upset: According to her mother, Gemma prefers drinking and parties to work and motherhood 'I don't know how you could do that to your own kid,' adds Debbie, who also revealed that Gemma's children call her mum and not grandma. 'She doesn't care. She doesn't care at all and I feel awful about it because at the end of the day, they're my grandchildren and I love them. 'She's missed out from day one. She doesn't put them first. She knows she needs to grow up and stop drinking and taking drugs and partying.'
### RESPONSE
the woman , named only as gemma , has two children under five by two fathers and handed both infants over to her 52-year-old mother debbie when they were four months old . now debbie is threatening to ban gemma from seeing the children at all , after discovering her daughter 's constant drinking and partying is getting out of hand . she admits to stealing money and other items from her mother in the past .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.