id
stringclasses 100
values | input
stringclasses 100
values | response
stringlengths 35
718
| score
float64 1
5
| prompt
stringlengths 2.14k
5.24k
| cluster_assignment
stringclasses 4
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack . arsenal are third in the premier league , level on points with manchester city but with a game in hand . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack . arsenal are third in the premier league , level on points with manchester city but with a game in hand .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . henry was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . henry was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . sky sports pundit thierry henry said : ' i think they need to buy four players - they need that spine . they need a goalkeeper , they still need a holding midfielder ' | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . sky sports pundit thierry henry said : ' i think they need to buy four players - they need that spine . they need a goalkeeper , they still need a holding midfielder '
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . henry , who was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea , also hit out at olivier giroud by claiming the gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club 's first choice striker . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . henry , who was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea , also hit out at olivier giroud by claiming the gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club 's first choice striker . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . henry , who was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea , also hit out at olivier giroud by claiming the gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club 's first choice striker . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . henry , who was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea , also hit out at olivier giroud by claiming the gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club 's first choice striker . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | arsenal drew 0-0 with chelsea at stamford bridge on saturday . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned arsenal's transfer business . henry said the gunners need to buy four players to win the league . he said they need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
arsenal drew 0-0 with chelsea at stamford bridge on saturday . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned arsenal's transfer business . henry said the gunners need to buy four players to win the league . he said they need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | Henry thinks Arsenal need four players in the summer 'I think he's in the best form of his career and he's scoring a lot of goals, but he's not leading the team to the title yet. 'He's not leading the team to the title yet. It's a question of him. | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
Henry thinks Arsenal need four players in the summer 'I think he's in the best form of his career and he's scoring a lot of goals, but he's not leading the team to the title yet. 'He's not leading the team to the title yet. It's a question of him.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | thierry henry has criticised arsenal's transfer dealings in the transfer window . the sky sports pundit says the gunners need four players to win the title . henry was speaking after arsenal's goalless draw with chelsea . arsenal are third in the premier league, level on points with manchester city . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
thierry henry has criticised arsenal's transfer dealings in the transfer window . the sky sports pundit says the gunners need four players to win the title . henry was speaking after arsenal's goalless draw with chelsea . arsenal are third in the premier league, level on points with manchester city .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack . sunderland -lrb- home -rrb- may 20 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack . sunderland -lrb- home -rrb- may 20 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . henry , who was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea , also hit out at olivier giroud by claiming the gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club 's first choice striker . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the barclays premier league title . henry , who was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea , also hit out at olivier giroud by claiming the gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club 's first choice striker .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | Thierry Henry believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker in the summer . The Frenchman also questioned whether Olivier Giroud can win the Premier League with the Gunners . Arsenal are currently third in the table , level on points with Manchester City . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
Thierry Henry believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker in the summer . The Frenchman also questioned whether Olivier Giroud can win the Premier League with the Gunners . Arsenal are currently third in the table , level on points with Manchester City .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window . the frenchman believes arsenal need to buy four players in the summer . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
thierry henry has criticised arsenal 's recent dealings in the transfer window . the frenchman believes arsenal need to buy four players in the summer . sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack . the frenchman believes the gunners need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to remain as the club 's first choice striker . henry has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer . | 4.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
sky sports pundit thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud in attack . the frenchman believes the gunners need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder and striker if they are to remain as the club 's first choice striker . henry has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | thierry henry has urged his former side to purchase four top players . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder . henry was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea . thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud . arsenal are third in premier league , level on points with manchester city . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
thierry henry has urged his former side to purchase four top players . the frenchman believes arsenal need a goalkeeper , centre back , defensive midfielder . henry was speaking after arsenal 's goalless draw with chelsea . thierry henry questioned whether arsenal can win the title with olivier giroud . arsenal are third in premier league , level on points with manchester city .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-d83b82a9cd504218e604616be3f3c3928e3428b8 | Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season | Arsenal drew 0-0 with Chelsea at the Emirates on Sunday afternoon . Gunners are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City . Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry said Arsenal need to buy four players . He believes they need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker . Henry also questioned whether Olivier Giroud can win the title with Arsenal . | 4.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thierry Henry has criticised Arsenal's recent dealings in the transfer window and has urged his former side to purchase four top players in the summer. The Frenchman believes Arsenal need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker if they are to have any chance of winning the Barclays Premier League title. Henry, who was speaking after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea, also hit out at Olivier Giroud by claiming the Gunners will struggle to win the league if his fellow countryman is to remain as the club's first choice striker. Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry questioned whether Arsenal can win the title with Olivier Giroud in attack Henry (centre) said after Arsenal's goalless draw with Chelsea that Giroud (right) may need replacing Hull (away) - May 4 Swansea (home) - May 11 Man United (away) - May 17 Sunderland (home) May 20 West Brom (home) - May 24 Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, Henry said: 'I think they need to buy four players - they need that spine. They need a goalkeeper, they still need a centre back, they still need a holding midfielder and, I'm afraid, they need a top, top quality striker to win this league again. 'You had the best example with Chelsea here today. They were struggling last season to win the league. They went on to buy [Thibaut] Cortouis, [Nemanja] Matic, Cesc [Fabregas] and [Diego] Costa. 'For me, that speaks volumes and you saw it today - a team didn't and a team did, and they are about to win the league again. Arsenal are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City but with a game in hand 'He [Arsene Wenger] has to do it. You need to have this competitive thing within the group - to win the league, that has to happen.' And he added on Giroud's inability to lead Arsenal to the title despite scoring 14 league goals so far this season: 'I think Giroud is doing extremely well. But can you win the league with him? I wouldn't think so. 'He does a job, and he does it ever so well, but you can't win the league. 'Arsenal were at the top of the league last season, but everyone was saying they are not going win the league.' Arsenal need to sign players of a similar calibre to Thibaut Courtois, Nemanja Matic, Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, according to Henry Giroud, pictured during Arsenal's match against Chelsea, has scored 14 Premier League goals this season
### RESPONSE
Arsenal drew 0-0 with Chelsea at the Emirates on Sunday afternoon . Gunners are third in the Premier League, level on points with Manchester City . Sky Sports pundit Thierry Henry said Arsenal need to buy four players . He believes they need a goalkeeper, centre back, defensive midfielder and striker . Henry also questioned whether Olivier Giroud can win the title with Arsenal .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims said she is scared for her future relationships , and did n't understand why she had been targeted . the bega cheese boss said she was forced to break her silence . she was subjected to years of abuse by the bega boss . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded sentenced to 12 years in jail . she kept the van ryn did to her secret , but when she found out . | 4 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims said she is scared for her future relationships , and did n't understand why she had been targeted . the bega cheese boss said she was forced to break her silence . she was subjected to years of abuse by the bega boss . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded sentenced to 12 years in jail . she kept the van ryn did to her secret , but when she found out .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims told sydney 's district court that she is scared for her future relationships , and did n't understand why she had been targeted . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims told sydney 's district court that she is scared for her future relationships , and did n't understand why she had been targeted .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the young woman , who can not be named , said when he abused her as a child she did n't know it was wrong . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the young woman , who can not be named , said when he abused her as a child she did n't know it was wrong .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the young woman , who can not be named , said when he abused her as a child she did n't know it was wrong . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . the young woman , who can not be named , said when he abused her as a child she did n't know it was wrong .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences . | 2.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims told sydney 's district court on monday that she is scared for her future relationships , and did n't understand why she had been targeted . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims told sydney 's district court on monday that she is scared for her future relationships , and did n't understand why she had been targeted . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims told sydney's district court on monday that she is scared for her future relationships . the young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong . 'he has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time,' she said . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
maurice van ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims told sydney's district court on monday that she is scared for her future relationships . the young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong . 'he has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time,' she said .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I don't feel safe. I don't feel like I can trust anyone.' She added: 'I don't know what to do. | 1.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I don't feel safe. I don't feel like I can trust anyone.' She added: 'I don't know what to do.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | a young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by bega cheese boss maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
a young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by bega cheese boss maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | a young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by bega cheese boss maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
a young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by bega cheese boss maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | a young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by bega cheese boss maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
a young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by bega cheese boss maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . for years she kept what van ryn did to her a secret , but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | Maurice Van Ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including persistent sexual abuse of a child . One of his victims told Sydney 's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships . The young woman , who can not be named , said when he abused her as a child she did n't know it was wrong . She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
Maurice Van Ryn has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including persistent sexual abuse of a child . One of his victims told Sydney 's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships . The young woman , who can not be named , said when he abused her as a child she did n't know it was wrong . She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences . | 2.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
maurice van ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life . but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims told sydney 's district court on monday she is scared for her future relationships , and did n't understand why she had been targeted . the young woman said when he abused her as a child she did n't know it was wrong . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . one of his victims told sydney 's district court on monday she is scared for her future relationships , and did n't understand why she had been targeted . the young woman said when he abused her as a child she did n't know it was wrong .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | a young woman was subjected to abuse by bega cheese boss maurice van ryn . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences . he pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including most serious charge of a child . one of his victims told sydney 's district court that she is scared for her future relationships . for years she kept what van ryn did to break her silence . a young woman was subjected to years of abuse by bega cheese . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
a young woman was subjected to abuse by bega cheese boss maurice van ryn . the wealthy nsw businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences . he pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences , including most serious charge of a child . one of his victims told sydney 's district court that she is scared for her future relationships . for years she kept what van ryn did to break her silence . a young woman was subjected to years of abuse by bega cheese .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-0cd10ad50ceef529d96a255ed12ac9cd001ba9db | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article. | A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the impact it had on her life . For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life. For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence. The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child. One of his victims told Sydney's District Court on Monday that she is scared for her future relationships, and didn't understand why she had been targeted. Scroll down for video A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn (pictured) has told a court of the severe impact it had on her life The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child 'I am scared for my future relationships,' the young woman said, according to News Corp. 'He has stolen my right to share my body with someone for the first time.' Van Ryn sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong. 'I didn't understand why he would do something like this. Does this happen to every kid? Do friends do this to other friends?' she said. 'I didn't know it was against the law.' Van Ryn (left) sat calmly in the dock and did not look at the young woman as she told Sydney's District Court on Monday about the impact his abuse has had on her. The young woman, who cannot be named, said when he abused her as a child she didn't know it was wrong She said she hadn't spoken up about the abuse until the day she heard he had been caught, and since then had attempted to take her own life. 'I knew I had to say something.' Since then, however, she says she has been scared people will find out. 'I didn't want people to know what happened to me. I don't want people asking questions. She says she wonders when Van Ryn, who is now in custody will be out in the community again, and she worries what he did to her will forever affect how she relates to men. She said she has suffered depression since she was 14 and had been hospitalised for self harm and attempted suicide. The hearing continues. Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14. Sorry we are not currently accepting comments on this article.
### RESPONSE
A young woman who was subjected to years of abuse by Bega Cheese boss Maurice Van Ryn has told a court of the impact it had on her life . For years she kept what Van Ryn did to her a secret, but when she found out he had been caught she knew she had to break her silence . The wealthy NSW businessman has pleaded guilty to 12 sex offences, including the most serious charge of persistent sexual abuse of a child .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time . the arsenal youngster has not featured for arsenal since march last year . the 19-year-old has not played since the champions league last season . he has been sidelined with serious knee injury . the germany international played for bayern munich in march 2014 . | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time . the arsenal youngster has not featured for arsenal since march last year . the 19-year-old has not played since the champions league last season . he has been sidelined with serious knee injury . the germany international played for bayern munich in march 2014 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march last year . serge gnabry played for arsenal 's development squad as they lost 1-0 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march last year . serge gnabry played for arsenal 's development squad as they lost 1-0 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading on monday . the 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march last year after suffering serious knee injury . the 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the gunners last season , but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading on monday . the 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march last year after suffering serious knee injury . the 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the gunners last season , but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the 19-year-old has not featured since march last year after suffering serious knee injury . gnabry played for arsenal 's development squad as they lost 1-0 to reading on monday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the 19-year-old has not featured since march last year after suffering serious knee injury . gnabry played for arsenal 's development squad as they lost 1-0 to reading on monday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time as the arsenal teenager impressed for the gunners last season . the 19-year-old has not featured since the champions league last-16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 . the germany under-21 international is at last closing in on a return . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time as the arsenal teenager impressed for the gunners last season . the 19-year-old has not featured since the champions league last-16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 . the germany under-21 international is at last closing in on a return .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time as the arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out . gnabry , as a result , has not featured since the champions league last-16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time as the arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out . gnabry , as a result , has not featured since the champions league last-16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | the 19 - year - old midfielder impressed for the gunners last season , but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury . gnabry , as a result , has not featured since the champions league last - 16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 , although he is at last closing in on a return . serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading on monday | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
the 19 - year - old midfielder impressed for the gunners last season , but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury . gnabry , as a result , has not featured since the champions league last - 16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 , although he is at last closing in on a return . serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading on monday
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry has not played for arsenal since march 2014 . the 19-year-old suffered a serious knee injury against bayern munich . gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the midfielder says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry has not played for arsenal since march 2014 . the 19-year-old suffered a serious knee injury against bayern munich . gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the midfielder says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | Gnabry has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
Gnabry has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march 2014 . gnabry has been hampered by a serious knee injury . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march 2014 . gnabry has been hampered by a serious knee injury .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time as the arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out . serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading on monday . the 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march last year after suffering serious knee injury . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time as the arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out . serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading on monday . the 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march last year after suffering serious knee injury .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time as the arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out . the 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the gunners last season , but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury . gnabry , as a result , has not featured since the champions league last-16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 , although he is at last closing in on a return . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry says he is feeling ` better and better ' all the time as the arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out . the 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the gunners last season , but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury . gnabry , as a result , has not featured since the champions league last-16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 , although he is at last closing in on a return .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading . The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year . The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal 's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading . The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year . The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal 's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry says he is feeling ' better and better ' all the time . the 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the gunners last season . but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry says he is feeling ' better and better ' all the time . the 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the gunners last season . but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading on monday . the 19-year-old impressed for the gunners last season . gnabry has not featured since the champions league second leg . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading on monday . the 19-year-old impressed for the gunners last season . gnabry has not featured since the champions league second leg .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the 19-year-old midfielder has been stunted by a knee injury . 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march last year . gnabry has not featured since champions league last-16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 . | 4.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
serge gnabry played 90 minutes for arsenal under 21s against reading . the 19-year-old midfielder has been stunted by a knee injury . 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since march last year . gnabry has not featured since champions league last-16 second leg against bayern munich in march 2014 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-632cfdb03aacd90a34a470f6a70b47eee62ec5f0 | Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.' | Serge Gnabry has not featured for Arsenal's first team since March 2014 . The 19-year-old suffered a serious knee injury against Bayern Munich . He played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday . The midfielder says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Serge Gnabry says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time as the Arsenal teenager prepares to return after more than a year out. The 19-year-old midfielder impressed for the Gunners last season, but his progress has been stunted by a serious knee injury. Gnabry, as a result, has not featured since the Champions League last-16 second leg against Bayern Munich in March 2014, although he is at last closing in on a return. Serge Gnabry played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday The 19-year-old has not featured for the first team since March last year after suffering serious knee injury Gnabry impressed for the Gunners last season before his progress was curtailed due to injury The Germany Under-21 international played for Arsenal's development squad as they lost 1-0 to Reading on Monday and is now over his injury worries. 'I am feeling good, I'm feeling better and better,' Gnabry told Arsenal Media. 'It is my second 90 minutes [in the space of a week], I am playing and over my injury so it is all good and I am looking forward to the next game.'
### RESPONSE
Serge Gnabry has not featured for Arsenal's first team since March 2014 . The 19-year-old suffered a serious knee injury against Bayern Munich . He played 90 minutes for Arsenal Under 21s against Reading on Monday . The midfielder says he is feeling 'better and better' all the time .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused promenade , south wales . he had been out drinking in december but did n't have enough cash to pay for it . inquest heard he ran from a taxi to avoid paying fare fare . the trio got out of the taxi to ` use an atm ' before making a run . mr phillips had been drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi with friends in december . he was found guilty of accidental death but did not have enough money for the taxi . | 3.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused promenade , south wales . he had been out drinking in december but did n't have enough cash to pay for it . inquest heard he ran from a taxi to avoid paying fare fare . the trio got out of the taxi to ` use an atm ' before making a run . mr phillips had been drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi with friends in december . he was found guilty of accidental death but did not have enough money for the taxi .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . graduate jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff . cabbie dave sidaway told the inquest : ` i had no idea how much danger he was in ' . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . graduate jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff . cabbie dave sidaway told the inquest : ` i had no idea how much danger he was in ' .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff . cardiff coroner 's court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ` use an atm ' before making a run for it . the university graduate had been out drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi with friends padraig crowley and rory robinson . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff . cardiff coroner 's court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ` use an atm ' before making a run for it . the university graduate had been out drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi with friends padraig crowley and rory robinson .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade . he ran from the driver , who gave chase at the seaside town of penarth . an inquest heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ` use an atm ' . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade . he ran from the driver , who gave chase at the seaside town of penarth . an inquest heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ` use an atm ' .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab after a night out with friends in december . but did n't have enough cash to pay for it . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab after a night out with friends in december . but did n't have enough cash to pay for it .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december . inquest heard he ran from the driver , who gave chase at the seaside town of penarth . the university graduate had been out drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi with friends padraig crowley and rory robinson . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december . inquest heard he ran from the driver , who gave chase at the seaside town of penarth . the university graduate had been out drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi with friends padraig crowley and rory robinson .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | a young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare . graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december – but did n’t have enough cash to pay for it . an inquest heard he ran from the driver , who gave chase at the seaside town of penarth , south wales . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
a young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare . graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december – but did n’t have enough cash to pay for it . an inquest heard he ran from the driver , who gave chase at the seaside town of penarth , south wales .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff . taxi driver dave sidaway said he would not have left him if he knew where they were . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff . taxi driver dave sidaway said he would not have left him if he knew where they were .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | Jacob Phillips fell down a 70ft cliff to his death in Cardiff. | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
Jacob Phillips fell down a 70ft cliff to his death in Cardiff.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips, 23, fell down the cliff at the end of the disused northern promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff . he had been out drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi with friends padraig crowley and rory robinson . mr phillips, of reading, berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker . for confidential support call the samaritans in the uk on 08457 90 90 90, visit a local samaritans branch or click here for details . | 2 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips, 23, fell down the cliff at the end of the disused northern promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff . he had been out drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi with friends padraig crowley and rory robinson . mr phillips, of reading, berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker . for confidential support call the samaritans in the uk on 08457 90 90 90, visit a local samaritans branch or click here for details .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december -- but did n't have enough cash to pay for it . ' jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december -- but did n't have enough cash to pay for it . ' jacob phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | a young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare . graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december -- but did n't have enough cash to pay for it . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
a young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare . graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december -- but did n't have enough cash to pay for it .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | Jacob Phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff . The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson . The trio got out of the taxi to ` use an ATM ' before making a run for it . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
Jacob Phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff . The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson . The trio got out of the taxi to ` use an ATM ' before making a run for it .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
graduate jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips , 23 , was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade , a rocky area at the base of the cliff .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december . he did n't have enough cash to pay for it . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence . mr phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december . he did n't have enough cash to pay for it .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december . jacob phillips was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade . the university graduate had been out drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi . trio got out of taxi to ` use an atm ' before making a run for it . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
jacob phillips , 23 , plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark . mr phillips caught the cab home after a night out with friends in december . jacob phillips was found dead at the end of the disused northern promenade . the university graduate had been out drinking in cardiff before catching a taxi . trio got out of taxi to ` use an atm ' before making a run for it .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-c50d33e9749e7bb484d9b69c4f5fca35a3a50cb5 | A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered | Jacob Phillips, 23, fell down the cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade . He had caught a taxi home from a night out in Penarth, South Wales . The driver gave chase and Mr Phillips ran off into the 'pitch black' He was discovered the next day by a dog walker at the bottom of the cliff . The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A young accountant fell down a 70ft cliff to his death when he ran from a taxi to avoid paying the fare. Graduate Jacob Phillips, 23, plunged down the cliff when he leapt over a fence in the dark. Mr Phillips had caught the cab home after a night out with friends in December – but didn’t have enough cash to pay for it. An inquest heard he ran from the driver, who gave chase at the seaside town of Penarth, South Wales. Cabbie Dave Sidaway told the inquest: ‘I stopped because I couldn’t see where I was going. I had no idea how much danger he was in.’ Jacob Phillips, 23, was found dead at the end of the disused Northern Promenade, a rocky area at the base of the cliff The university graduate had been out drinking in Cardiff before catching a taxi with friends Padraig Crowley and Rory Robinson. Cardiff Coroner’s Court heard how the trio got out of the taxi to ‘use an ATM’ before making a run for it. ‘The plan was to go to Penarth but we did not have enough money for the taxi – I ran off in one direction, Jacob went in another direction,’ Mr Robinson told the inquest. ‘Running away from the taxi was a stupid thing to do.’ Mr Phillips, of Reading, Berks, was discovered the next day on the rocky beach by a dog walker. Paramedics arrived at the scene after his body was discovered in the morning by a dog walker A long way down: Mr Phillips fell down this cliff after a night out. Tthe taxi driver said he would not have left him if he knew where they were Recording a verdict of accidental death, coroner Andrew Barkley said: ‘It is likely that he became disorientated and there is no evidence that he knew where he was at the time. ‘There is no way he could have known the danger that lay in front of him. The following day with the benefit of light it was clear the danger he faced by the sheer drop off the cliff just yards beyond the fence.’ Mr Phillips worked for Pretty Green, the clothing label run by Oasis star Liam Gallagher. He had grown up in Barry, South Wales, before studying accountancy at the University of Birmingham. The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area. Mr Phillips had planned to stay at a friend’s house but he and his friends didn’t have enough money to complete the journey, so decided to trick the driver by ‘dodging’ the fare. Mr Phillips ran off into the ‘pitch black’ and fell down a cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade – also called The Dardanelles. Police search the scene at the bottom of the cliff where his body was discovered
### RESPONSE
Jacob Phillips, 23, fell down the cliff at the end of the disused Northern Promenade . He had caught a taxi home from a night out in Penarth, South Wales . The driver gave chase and Mr Phillips ran off into the 'pitch black' He was discovered the next day by a dog walker at the bottom of the cliff . The inquest heard that he had returned to Wales for Christmas and had been staying with his mother in the upmarket Cowbridge area .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Business and Finance |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | managers at the passport agency made # 42 million profit in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents . ministers said it could not say how many claims were rejected , partly because of ` system failure of our customer complaint system ' . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
managers at the passport agency made # 42 million profit in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents . ministers said it could not say how many claims were rejected , partly because of ` system failure of our customer complaint system ' .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer 's passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation . at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer 's passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation . at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . the boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . the boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | boxes of passport applications piled up at peak of backlog last summer . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . in total just half a million passports stuck in the system . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
boxes of passport applications piled up at peak of backlog last summer . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . in total just half a million passports stuck in the system .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer 's passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation . at the same time , managers at the passport agency made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer 's passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation . at the same time , managers at the passport agency made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a £ 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to £ 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . the problems began a year ago as hm passport office struggled to cope with 3.6 million britons applying for documents . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a £ 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to £ 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . the problems began a year ago as hm passport office struggled to cope with 3.6 million britons applying for documents .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between april last year and january this year . the total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68 . ministers rejected a demand by the home affairs select committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between april last year and january this year . the total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68 . ministers rejected a demand by the home affairs select committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | The problem started a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents The Mail on Sunday has learned that £1.5 million of the £2.5 million the Passport Office has received in compensation has been paid out. The Mail on Sunday has also seen records showing that the Passport Office has been paid more than £2.5 million since the chaos began. The Mail on Sunday obtained figures showing that the Passport Office | 2 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
The problem started a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents The Mail on Sunday has learned that £1.5 million of the £2.5 million the Passport Office has received in compensation has been paid out. The Mail on Sunday has also seen records showing that the Passport Office has been paid more than £2.5 million since the chaos began. The Mail on Sunday obtained figures showing that the Passport Office
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between april last year and january this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year . the total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68 . home affairs committee chairman keith vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between april last year and january this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year . the total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68 . home affairs committee chairman keith vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . the boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . the boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer 's passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation . at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer 's passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation . at the same time , managers at the passport agency , which made a # 42 million profit during the chaos , received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some who missed out on trips .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | Ministers refused blanket refund to families who had to pay extra to get documents . Just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year , scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year . Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
Ministers refused blanket refund to families who had to pay extra to get documents . Just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year , scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year . Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | managers at the passport agency , which made a £42 million profit during the chaos , received up to £3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some missed out on trips . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
managers at the passport agency , which made a £42 million profit during the chaos , received up to £3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through , and even to some missed out on trips .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | boxes of passport applications received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give blanket refund to desperate families who had to pay extra to get travel documents rushed through . passport passport office struggled to cope with 3.6 million britons . | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
boxes of passport applications received up to # 3,500 in bonuses . ministers refused to give blanket refund to desperate families who had to pay extra to get travel documents rushed through . passport passport office struggled to cope with 3.6 million britons .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | managers at the passport agency received # 42 million profit during the chaos . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who missed out on trips . the boxes of passport applications piled up at the peak of the backlog last summer . problems began a year ago as hm passport office struggled to cope . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
managers at the passport agency received # 42 million profit during the chaos . ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who missed out on trips . the boxes of passport applications piled up at the peak of the backlog last summer . problems began a year ago as hm passport office struggled to cope .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2377095dda83df778e34304b7a09813808105d3b | Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500. | Passport agency made a £42 million profit during the chaos last summer . Just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April and January . Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz 'astonished' only one got money back . | 4.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Thousands of holidaymakers caught up in last summer’s passport delay fiasco have not received any compensation. At the same time, managers at the passport agency, which made a £42 million profit during the chaos, received up to £3,500 in bonuses. Ministers refused to give a blanket refund to the desperate families who had to pay extra to get their travel documents rushed through, and even to some who missed out on trips. Scroll down for video The boxes of passport applications piled up at in office in Liverpool at the peak of the backlog last summer Keith Vaz, who as chairman of the Home Affairs Committee led the calls for compensation, said last night: ‘I am astonished so few people have been given compensation for what was a fiasco presided over by the management of the passport office, especially as they made a profit last year that ran into millions of pounds.’ The problems began a year ago as HM Passport Office struggled to cope with 3.6 million Britons applying for documents. By mid-June there were more than half a million passports stuck in the system. Ministers agreed to give urgent cases a free upgrade to the fast-track service, but thousands had already paid the extra £30 per passport for this. Many still missed trips because their passports did not arrive in time. Details obtained by The Mail on Sunday show scarcely any of the thousands of holidaymakers caught up in the chaos ever got anything back from the Passport Office. In total just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April last year and January this year, scarcely changed from 2,077 for the previous year. The total paid out was £203,066, giving an average sum of £92.68. The biggest single payout was £5,463; the lowest £1. The Passport Office said it could not say how many claims were rejected, partly because of ‘the system failure of our customer complaint database’. It can be revealed however that Ministers rejected a demand by the Home Affairs Select Committee for all those left out of pocket to be compensated, saying: ‘It would create a precedent.’ Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz led the calls for compensation and was 'astonished' to learn just 2,191 compensation applications were approved This newspaper contacted more than a dozen holidaymakers who had either missed trips or had to pay extra to get passports in time. Only one had got money back. Among those refused were Mathew Bean and Hayley Kirkham. They lost close to £1,500 on a trip to Morocco, where he had planned to propose, because their passports did not arrive in time – even though they had applied ten weeks before they were due to travel and paid for upgrades. HM Passport Office made a surplus of £42.3 million between April and October last year. In 2013-14, the most recent figures available, managers were handed a total of £1.8 million in bonuses, with the average reward £499 and the highest £3,500.
### RESPONSE
Passport agency made a £42 million profit during the chaos last summer . Just 2,191 compensation applications were approved between April and January . Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz 'astonished' only one got money back .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . the 1930s is up for sale with original features including a windows and kitchen . the house has been a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . the # 250,000 house will be auctioned on april 30 at the county ground in bristol . it has been the original bathroom and kitchen and a ` guide ' for the . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . the 1930s is up for sale with original features including a windows and kitchen . the house has been a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . the # 250,000 house will be auctioned on april 30 at the county ground in bristol . it has been the original bathroom and kitchen and a ` guide ' for the .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and retro jars of popular food . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and retro jars of popular food .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . the historic house will be auctioned on april 30 at the county ground in bristol . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . the historic house will be auctioned on april 30 at the county ground in bristol .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | hoe house 's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows , depicting ships in full sail , while the living room 's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass . the historic house will be auctioned on april 30 at the county ground in bristol . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
hoe house 's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows , depicting ships in full sail , while the living room 's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass . the historic house will be auctioned on april 30 at the county ground in bristol .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . original features including stained-glass windows , oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . original features including stained-glass windows , oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | a timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained - glass windows , oil - fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . the collector ’s paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood - panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old - fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £ 200,000 and £ 250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
a timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained - glass windows , oil - fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . the collector ’s paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood - panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old - fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £ 200,000 and £ 250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the collector’s paradise in horfield, bristol, has gone untouched for more than 80 years . it comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the collector’s paradise in horfield, bristol, has gone untouched for more than 80 years . it comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | The house is up for sale complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and oil-fired central heating. The property is in Horfield, Bristol, which has been untouched since the 1930s | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
The house is up for sale complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and oil-fired central heating. The property is in Horfield, Bristol, which has been untouched since the 1930s
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the collector’s paradise in horfield, bristol, has gone untouched for more than 80 years . it boasts the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating . the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the collector’s paradise in horfield, bristol, has gone untouched for more than 80 years . it boasts the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating . the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | a timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows , oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
a timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows , oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | a timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows , oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
a timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows , oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . with features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned , the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | The collector 's paradise in Horfield , Bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . It comes complete with the original bathroom , kitchen , stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating . The semi-detached property has a guide price of between £ 200,000 and £ 250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
The collector 's paradise in Horfield , Bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . It comes complete with the original bathroom , kitchen , stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating . The semi-detached property has a guide price of between £ 200,000 and £ 250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the collector’s paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years , comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , kitchen , stained-glass windows and even the vintage cupboards . it 's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it 's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the collector’s paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years , comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen , kitchen , stained-glass windows and even the vintage cupboards . it 's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it 's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , will be auctioned on april 30 . original features include stained-glass windows , oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . the house has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the collector 's paradise in horfield , bristol , will be auctioned on april 30 . original features include stained-glass windows , oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food . the house has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | the timewarp home has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale . the paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . the collector 's paradise has gone untouched for more than 80 years . the house even boasts the original bathroom which was built in a fetching mint green and black colour . the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
the timewarp home has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale . the paradise in horfield , bristol , has gone untouched for more than 80 years . the collector 's paradise has gone untouched for more than 80 years . the house even boasts the original bathroom which was built in a fetching mint green and black colour . the semi-detached property has a guide price of between # 200,000 and # 250,000 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-e880fda4c25289f8325574246f0f8ed4ff5eb26b | A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off | The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, has gone untouched for more than 80 years . Boasts the original bathroom, kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . Three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A timewarp home which has remained unchanged since the 1930s is up for sale complete with original features including stained-glass windows, oil-fired central heating and retro jars of popular food. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years comes complete with the original bathroom and kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards. With features that were once commonplace but are now considered decidedly old-fashioned, the semi-detached property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000. The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, which has gone untouched for more than 80 years, comes complete with the original bathroom, kitchen, stained-glass windows and even oil-fired central heating - making it a collector's or antique love's paradise It's a nondescript semi-detached home from the outside but inside it's a treasure trove with features including beautiful stained glass windows The house even boasts the original bathroom which was installed when it was built - in a fetching mint green and black colour scheme The most eye-catching room is the dated bathroom - with its mint and black colour scheme - which comes complete with original tiles, wooden floor, yellow wallpaper and green sink. hoe house's wood-panelled hall is lit by quirky stained-glass windows, depicting ships in full sail, while the living room's windows are patterned with coats of arms on the glass. The three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink. A high shelf in the hallway holds original tins of produce from yesteryear, including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard. While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - David Beddoe, director of Auction Houses Bristol and Somerset North, believes the potential cost of renovations could put developers off. He believes the house could make a perfect family home for those with a passion for antiques. The historic house will be auctioned on April 30 at the County Ground in Bristol. A hallway shelf holds original tins of produce from the past including Cadbury’s Marvel dried milk, Tate and Lyle sugar and Colman’s Mustard The original kitchen appears dated but still has some unusual original features including the cupboards and the glass-panelled door The three-bedroom home also comes with all the original cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and a rather dated kitchen sink While the wood-panelled hall is lit by stained-glass windows depicting ships the living room comes with various coats of arms in the glass With once commonplace features (pictured) now considered old-fashioned the property has a guide price of between £200,000 and £250,000 The property is unimposing from the outside - but inside boasts a number of quirky and unusual original features like these bedroom windows While some features have been upgraded - the house is double glazed - auctioneers worry the cost of renovations could put developers off
### RESPONSE
The collector’s paradise in Horfield, Bristol, has gone untouched for more than 80 years . Boasts the original bathroom, kitchen, wood-panelled hallway and even the vintage cupboards . Three-bedroom home also comes with all of the original 1930s cupboards in the kitchen, a brick open-face fire and dated kitchen sink .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.