id
stringclasses 100
values | input
stringclasses 100
values | response
stringlengths 35
718
| score
float64 1
5
| prompt
stringlengths 2.14k
5.24k
| cluster_assignment
stringclasses 4
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
dm-test-2cf8c2d1d2ceb1980249f77e703f9039e63799d0 | Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait | japanese photographer y ? ki aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers . in each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose . the images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as daughter and salary man . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait
### RESPONSE
japanese photographer y ? ki aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers . in each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose . the images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as daughter and salary man .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2cf8c2d1d2ceb1980249f77e703f9039e63799d0 | Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait | japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air . a series of images by photographer yûki aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters . the images are from the 37-year-old 's latest book which roughly translates into daughter and salary man . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait
### RESPONSE
japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air . a series of images by photographer yûki aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters . the images are from the 37-year-old 's latest book which roughly translates into daughter and salary man .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2cf8c2d1d2ceb1980249f77e703f9039e63799d0 | Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait | sick of awkward father-daughter portraits ? well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting . japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait
### RESPONSE
sick of awkward father-daughter portraits ? well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting . japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2cf8c2d1d2ceb1980249f77e703f9039e63799d0 | Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait | Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air . In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose . The images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salaryman . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait
### RESPONSE
Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air . In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose . The images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salaryman .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2cf8c2d1d2ceb1980249f77e703f9039e63799d0 | Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait | japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers . the images are from the 37-year-old 's latest book which roughly translates as daughter and salaryman . each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait
### RESPONSE
japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers . the images are from the 37-year-old 's latest book which roughly translates as daughter and salaryman . each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2cf8c2d1d2ceb1980249f77e703f9039e63799d0 | Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait | japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers next to their daughters . images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates into daughter and salary man . the 37-year-old 's images include . | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait
### RESPONSE
japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers next to their daughters . images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates into daughter and salary man . the 37-year-old 's images include .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2cf8c2d1d2ceb1980249f77e703f9039e63799d0 | Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait | japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers . images are from the 37-year-old 's latest book which translates into daughter and salary man . photographer yûki aoyama sees fathers leaping into air next to their daughters . in each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while father pulls a dramatic pose . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait
### RESPONSE
japanese photographer yûki aoyama 's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers . images are from the 37-year-old 's latest book which translates into daughter and salary man . photographer yûki aoyama sees fathers leaping into air next to their daughters . in each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while father pulls a dramatic pose .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-2cf8c2d1d2ceb1980249f77e703f9039e63799d0 | Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait | Japanese photographer Y ? ki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers next to their fathers leaping into the air . In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose . The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salary Man . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Sick of awkward father-daughter portraits? Well one photographer has found an effective - if a little odd - way of making them more interesting. Japanese photographer Yûki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers pictured next to their fathers leaping into the air. In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose. A series of images by photographer Yûki Aoyama sees fathers leaping into the air next to their daughters The images are from the 37-year-old's latest book which roughly translates into Daughter and Salary Man. According to the photographer's website the images allow the father who usually has to act serious to express his fun side by being 'a hero jumping the sky, enfold(ing) strong excitement and hope.' Salary man may refer to the choice of clothing in the shoot which sees each dad in a sharply dressed suit. The images see the fathers pull energetic poses despite their age with some of the expressions of the older fathers looking slightly pained. Very little else is known about the pictures or why they have come into existence but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online for their curious nature. The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salaryman Each image sees the daughter stood po-faced as their father makes an energetic leap Some of the older fathers adopt a pained expression as they make their jump Each photograph sees the daughter wearing casual clothing with her father in a sharp suit The pictures see the families pose in front of various Japanese landmarks Very little is known about the set of photos but they are already drumming up plenty of interest online Some of the jumps are more subtle than others with this father opting for a classic jump This young girl can't help but giggle at her dad's ambitious leap This dapper dad adds a peace gesture into his final pose This father can't help but jump for joy in his portrait
### RESPONSE
Japanese photographer Y ? ki Aoyama's latest series of images capture po-faced teenagers next to their fathers leaping into the air . In each picture the daughter looks directly into the camera smiling while her father pulls a dramatic pose . The 37-year-old's images are said to be part of a book which roughly translates as Daughter and Salary Man .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | paul downton host paul downton as england 's managing director . kevin pietersen joked with reporters at the kia oval for the photo . he posed for the surrey team photo shoot for surrey at the new campaign . pietersen joked that he joked with photographers at the end of the season . he is the to return to the international set-up after being axed by former director director in 2014 . | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
paul downton host paul downton as england 's managing director . kevin pietersen joked with reporters at the kia oval for the photo . he posed for the surrey team photo shoot for surrey at the new campaign . pietersen joked that he joked with photographers at the end of the season . he is the to return to the international set-up after being axed by former director director in 2014 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo . the batsman joked with photographers at the kia oval for the photo session , with surrey set to begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo . the batsman joked with photographers at the kia oval for the photo session , with surrey set to begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | the dismissal of paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . surrey play oxford mccu in a mcc university match on sunday . kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
the dismissal of paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . surrey play oxford mccu in a mcc university match on sunday . kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team photo before the start of the new county championship season . the batsman joked with photographers at the kia oval for the photo session , with surrey set to begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 . downton 's sacking on wednesday has paved the way for pietersen to return to the international set-up . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team photo before the start of the new county championship season . the batsman joked with photographers at the kia oval for the photo session , with surrey set to begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 . downton 's sacking on wednesday has paved the way for pietersen to return to the international set-up .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . the batsman joked with photographers at the kia oval for the photo session , with surrey set to begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 . downton 's sacking on wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . the batsman joked with photographers at the kia oval for the photo session , with surrey set to begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 . downton 's sacking on wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . however , you do n't have to go to far before talk returns to the england team again as kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . however , you do n't have to go to far before talk returns to the england team again as kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | the dismissal of paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . however , you do n't have to go to far before talk returns to the england team again as kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign . kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
the dismissal of paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . however , you do n't have to go to far before talk returns to the england team again as kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign . kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | kevin pietersen posed for the surrey team photo at the kia oval . the batsman looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end . surrey begin their county championship campaign on april 19 . paul downton's sacking has paved the way for pietersen's return . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
kevin pietersen posed for the surrey team photo at the kia oval . the batsman looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end . surrey begin their county championship campaign on april 19 . paul downton's sacking has paved the way for pietersen's return .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | The England captain has been sacked from his role as managing director Pietersen has been in talks with Surrey for several weeks in an attempt to return to the national set-up The former England captain is currently in talks with Surrey to return to the England set-up Pietersen is currently on tour in Australia and is currently in talks with Surrey to return to the national set-up The former England captain is currently on tour in Australia and is currently in talks | 3 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
The England captain has been sacked from his role as managing director Pietersen has been in talks with Surrey for several weeks in an attempt to return to the national set-up The former England captain is currently in talks with Surrey to return to the England set-up Pietersen is currently on tour in Australia and is currently in talks with Surrey to return to the national set-up The former England captain is currently on tour in Australia and is currently in talks
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | kevin pietersen posed for the surrey team photo at the kia oval . the event comes before the start of the county championship season . surrey begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
kevin pietersen posed for the surrey team photo at the kia oval . the event comes before the start of the county championship season . surrey begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | the dismissal of paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . the event at the kia oval comes before the start of the county championship season . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
the dismissal of paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . the event at the kia oval comes before the start of the county championship season .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | the dismissal of paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . however , you do n't have to go to far before talk returns to the england team again as kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign . pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo , but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the england set-up took a step closer . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
the dismissal of paul downton as england 's managing director may be the big talking point in english cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season . however , you do n't have to go to far before talk returns to the england team again as kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign . pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo , but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the england set-up took a step closer .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | Kevin Pietersen took part in a Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval . The batsman was in a jovial mood ahead of the start of the county championship season . Surrey begin their campaign against Glamorgan on April 19 . CLICK HERE for all the latest cricket news . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
Kevin Pietersen took part in a Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval . The batsman was in a jovial mood ahead of the start of the county championship season . Surrey begin their campaign against Glamorgan on April 19 . CLICK HERE for all the latest cricket news .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . the batsman joked with photographers at the kia oval for the photo session , with surrey set to begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 . downton 's sacking on wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
kevin pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . the batsman joked with photographers at the kia oval for the photo session , with surrey set to begin their campaign at glamorgan on april 19 . downton 's sacking on wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | kevin pietersen set for the surrey team photo shoot for surrey on april 19 . the batsman has been axed as england 's managing director before the start of the county championship season . pietersen has been at the kia oval for the photo session on wednesday . | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
kevin pietersen set for the surrey team photo shoot for surrey on april 19 . the batsman has been axed as england 's managing director before the start of the county championship season . pietersen has been at the kia oval for the photo session on wednesday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team . downton 's sacking has been axed by former managing director in 2014 . pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of team photo . the event comes before the start of the county championship season . | 2.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for surrey . kevin pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the surrey team . downton 's sacking has been axed by former managing director in 2014 . pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of team photo . the event comes before the start of the county championship season .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5bc2ae78441e4ac08fb01823d5fc0f1627c3166 | The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey | Kevin Pietersen joined his Surrey team-mates for a team photo at the KIA Oval . The Surrey batsman looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the photo . The event comes before the start of the County Championship season . Pietersen is hoping to force his way back into the England set-up . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
The dismissal of Paul Downton as England's managing director may be the big talking point in English cricket but focus has already shifted to the start of the county championship season. However, you don't have to go to far before talk returns to the England team again as Kevin Pietersen cut a range of emotions as he posed for the Surrey team photo before the start of the new campaign. Pietersen looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the team photo, but was otherwise in a jovial mood as a potentially sensational return to the England set-up took a step closer. Kevin Pietersen takes a moment to reflect ahead of a team photo shoot for Surrey The event at the KIA Oval comes before the start of the County Championship season As team-mates turn their attention to other matters, Pietersen looks ahead in deep thought The batsman joked with photographers at the KIA Oval for the photo session, with Surrey set to begin their campaign at Glamorgan on April 19. Downton's sacking on Wednesday has paved the way for the 34-year-old to return to the international set-up having been controversially axed by the former managing director in 2014. It was during the last Ashes tour for England in Australia last year when Pietersen last featured at international level, in a disastrous trip which saw his side suffer a whitewash series defeat. With England hoping to regain the urn this summer on home soil, Pietersen has rejoined Surrey in an attempt to force his way back into the Test set-up. Surrey play Oxford MCCU in a MCC University match on Sunday. Kevin Pietersen took his place on the right of the front row for the Surrey team photo shoot at the KIA Oval Using his camera, Pietersen turned the tables to take pictures of photographers Team-mate Chris Tremlett flashes a smile as he and Pietersen share a joke during the event Photographers gather round Pietersen to get close-up pictures of the batsman Pietersen flashes a cheeky grin to the camera as he sat at the end of the front row for the team photo Pietersen was all smiles as he joked with team-mates ahead of the new county championship season Pietersen smiles as he sits alongside Chris Tremlett (second right), Stuart Meaker (centre), Jason Roy (second left) and Jade Dernbach Pietersen walks out to the KIA Oval pitch with a tracksuit top on, closely followed by his Surrey team-mates Pietersen jokes with a photographer during the Surrey CCC photocall at The Kia Oval Pietersen looks on from inside the KIA Oval as he hopes to work his way back into the England set-up with Surrey
### RESPONSE
Kevin Pietersen joined his Surrey team-mates for a team photo at the KIA Oval . The Surrey batsman looked in deep thought as he sat right at the end of the photo . The event comes before the start of the County Championship season . Pietersen is hoping to force his way back into the England set-up .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | brazilian coach ze maria was fired on wednesday after poor run . the romanian club have been sacked by ze maria for the second time . neamt neamt have been beaten by mid-table fc botosani on saturday . the former inter milan and parma right back in the bottom of the season . ze maria replaced the florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach . | 2.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
brazilian coach ze maria was fired on wednesday after poor run . the romanian club have been sacked by ze maria for the second time . neamt neamt have been beaten by mid-table fc botosani on saturday . the former inter milan and parma right back in the bottom of the season . ze maria replaced the florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | ze relegation-threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day . flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance ' . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
ze relegation-threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day . flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance ' .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | relegation-threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance . ' but the 41-year-old former inter milan and parma right back , capped 25 times by brazil , angered massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
relegation-threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance . ' but the 41-year-old former inter milan and parma right back , capped 25 times by brazil , angered massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run . former brazil defender ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach this season . | 4.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run . former brazil defender ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach this season .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | ceahlaul maria represented brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years . ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach this season . ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach this season . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
ceahlaul maria represented brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years . ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach this season . ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach this season .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance ' | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance '
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | relegation - threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ' give the coaching staff another chance . ' but the 41 - year - old former inter milan and parma right back , capped 25 times by brazil , angered massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2 - 0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
relegation - threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ' give the coaching staff another chance . ' but the 41 - year - old former inter milan and parma right back , capped 25 times by brazil , angered massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2 - 0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day . the 41-year-old angered owner angelo massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day . the 41-year-old angered owner angelo massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | Ze Maria was sacked for the second time in a week. The club are currently in the relegation zone and are currently without a win in 12 games. The club's new owner, Massone, made the appointment after a failed attempt to buy the club from former owner Antonio Caicedo in January. | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
Ze Maria was sacked for the second time in a week. The club are currently in the relegation zone and are currently without a win in 12 games. The club's new owner, Massone, made the appointment after a failed attempt to buy the club from former owner Antonio Caicedo in January.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run . the 41-year-old was reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance' but the 41-year-old angered massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run . the 41-year-old was reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance' but the 41-year-old angered massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | relegation-threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance . he will be replaced by serbian vanya radinovic . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
relegation-threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance . he will be replaced by serbian vanya radinovic .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | relegation-threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance . ' but the 41-year-old former inter milan and parma right back , capped 25 times by brazil , angered massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
relegation-threatened romanian club ceahlaul piatra neamt have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time in a week . former brazil defender ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner angelo massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance . ' but the 41-year-old former inter milan and parma right back , capped 25 times by brazil , angered massone again after ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table fc botosani on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt sacked Ze Maria for the second time in a week . Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after owner Angelo Massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance ' The 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back was capped 25 times by Brazil . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt sacked Ze Maria for the second time in a week . Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day after owner Angelo Massone decided to ` give the coaching staff another chance ' The 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back was capped 25 times by Brazil .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | romanian coach ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day . former inter defender ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach this season . he will be replaced by serbian vanya radinovic . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
romanian coach ze maria was fired on wednesday after a poor run , only to be reinstated the next day . former inter defender ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become ceahlaul 's third coach this season . he will be replaced by serbian vanya radinovic .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | ze maria represented brazil on 25 occasions during international career . ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become third coach . brazilian coach ze maria fired on wednesday after poor run . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
ze maria represented brazil on 25 occasions during international career . ze maria replaced florin marin in january to become third coach . brazilian coach ze maria fired on wednesday after poor run .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | relegation-threatened piatra have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time . former brazil defender was fired on wednesday after a poor run . maria represented brazil on 25 occasions during an international career . ceahlaul 16th in the standings , six points adrift of safety . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
relegation-threatened piatra have sacked brazilian coach ze maria for the second time . former brazil defender was fired on wednesday after a poor run . maria represented brazil on 25 occasions during an international career . ceahlaul 16th in the standings , six points adrift of safety .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-130ff8f2dfb6ab67861d5924b0ff5acd63c7d8ce | Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic. | Brazilian Ze Maria was sacked by Romanian side Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt . The 41-year-old was reinstated by owner Angelo Massone the next day . But Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday . The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety . Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Relegation-threatened Romanian club Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt have sacked Brazilian coach Ze Maria for the second time in a week. Former Brazil defender Ze Maria was fired on Wednesday after a poor run, only to be reinstated the next day after flamboyant owner Angelo Massone decided to 'give the coaching staff another chance.' But the 41-year-old former Inter Milan and Parma right back, capped 25 times by Brazil, angered Massone again after Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday. Ze Maria represented Brazil on 25 occasions during an international career spanning five years The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety. Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season. He will be replaced by Serbian Vanya Radinovic.
### RESPONSE
Brazilian Ze Maria was sacked by Romanian side Ceahlaul Piatra Neamt . The 41-year-old was reinstated by owner Angelo Massone the next day . But Ceahlaul were beaten 2-0 by mid-table FC Botosani on Saturday . The result left Ceahlaul 16th in the standings, six points adrift of safety . Ze Maria replaced Florin Marin in January to become Ceahlaul's third coach this season .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united during his season-long loan . louis van gaal 's side have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent . the atletico madrid striker has scored four goals in louis van . falcao is not happy in france but thinks he would have been better off . | 3.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united during his season-long loan . louis van gaal 's side have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent . the atletico madrid striker has scored four goals in louis van . falcao is not happy in france but thinks he would have been better off .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united during his season-long loan . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united during his season-long loan .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao has scored four goals all season louis van gaal 's side . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent . united are unlikely to take up that option . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao has scored four goals all season louis van gaal 's side . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent . united are unlikely to take up that option .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united during his season-long loan . nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united during his season-long loan . nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate believes colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate believes colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao 's former monaco team - mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season - long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . united will have to pay £ 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season louis van gaal 's side are unlikely to take up that option . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao 's former monaco team - mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season - long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . united will have to pay £ 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season louis van gaal 's side are unlikely to take up that option .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao moved to manchester united on a season-long loan . the colombian striker has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . falcao's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao moved to manchester united on a season-long loan . the colombian striker has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . falcao's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | Nabil Dirar believes Falcao would have been better off staying at Monaco 'The Premier League is not the best for Falcao. Falcao has to work harder. He's a player who needs to be more consistent. | 2.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
Nabil Dirar believes Falcao would have been better off staying at Monaco 'The Premier League is not the best for Falcao. Falcao has to work harder. He's a player who needs to be more consistent.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao joined manchester united on a season-long loan last summer . the colombian has struggled to hit the heights he achieved at old trafford . united will have to pay £46million to make falcao's transfer permanent . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao joined manchester united on a season-long loan last summer . the colombian has struggled to hit the heights he achieved at old trafford . united will have to pay £46million to make falcao's transfer permanent .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united during his season-long loan . falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united during his season-long loan . falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season louis van gaal 's side are unlikely to take up that option . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season louis van gaal 's side are unlikely to take up that option .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | Radamel Falcao joined Manchester United on a season-long loan last summer . The Colombian striker has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . United will have to pay £ 46million to make the loan permanent . Louis van Gaal 's side are unlikely to take up that option . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
Radamel Falcao joined Manchester United on a season-long loan last summer . The Colombian striker has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . United will have to pay £ 46million to make the loan permanent . Louis van Gaal 's side are unlikely to take up that option .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer . falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao 's former monaco team-mate nabil dirar believes the colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to manchester united even though he was not happy in france . the former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer . falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer . former atletico madrid striker was not happy in france . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao moved to old trafford on a season-long loan last summer . former atletico madrid striker was not happy in france . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united . former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan . nabil dirar believes colombian must be regretting his failed loan move . falcao struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
radamel falcao has struggled for manchester united . former atletico madrid striker moved to old trafford on a season-long loan . nabil dirar believes colombian must be regretting his failed loan move . falcao struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury . united will have to pay # 46million to make falcao 's transfer permanent .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-4001b252a072ac149c70840b22299cc6cfab3bae | Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.' | Radamel Falcao joined Manchester United on a season-long loan last summer . But the Colombian has struggled to reach the heights he achieved . Falcao was not happy in France, according to his former Monaco team-mate . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Radamel Falcao's former Monaco team-mate Nabil Dirar believes the Colombian must be regretting his failed loan move to Manchester United even though he was not happy in France. The former Atletico Madrid striker moved to Old Trafford on a season-long loan last summer but has struggled to hit the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury. United will have to pay £46million to make Falcao's transfer permanent but having only scored four goals all season Louis van Gaal's side are unlikely to take up that option. Radamel Falcao has struggled for Manchester United during his season-long loan Falcao has struggled to reach the heights he achieved before suffering a serious knee injury And Dirar has revealed that Falcao was not happy in France but thinks he would have been better off staying at Monaco. 'I think Falcao must be biting his fingers [ruing the fact] he's gone,' he told Le Parisien. 'Here, he would have played and participated in the Champions League. But he may need more atmosphere. 'In Monaco, he was not feeling well.'
### RESPONSE
Radamel Falcao joined Manchester United on a season-long loan last summer . But the Colombian has struggled to reach the heights he achieved . Falcao was not happy in France, according to his former Monaco team-mate .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed christchurch dairy . the fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask is described as being ` tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash . the man in a fluoro mask demanded cash from owner 's daughter . police are asking anyone with information that may help identify this person to call crimestoppers on 0800 555 or to call police online . | 4.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed christchurch dairy . the fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask is described as being ` tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash . the man in a fluoro mask demanded cash from owner 's daughter . police are asking anyone with information that may help identify this person to call crimestoppers on 0800 555 or to call police online .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday . police say there were no signs of any weapons used but the robber remained at large . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday . police say there were no signs of any weapons used but the robber remained at large .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday , stuff.co.nz reports . the masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $ 1,500 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday , stuff.co.nz reports . the masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $ 1,500 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday . police were reportedly called to the union st dairy , in east christchurch at about 12.30 pm . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday . police were reportedly called to the union st dairy , in east christchurch at about 12.30 pm .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday . police are appealing to the public to identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday . police are appealing to the public to identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask . the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask . the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall '
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ' distinctive ' cartoon mask . the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ' very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday , stuff.co.nz reports . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ' distinctive ' cartoon mask . the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ' very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday , stuff.co.nz reports .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | a man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask robbed a christchurch dairy on saturday . he made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash . police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
a man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask robbed a christchurch dairy on saturday . he made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash . police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask . the offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall' he made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask . the offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall' he made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday , stuff.co.nz reports . a man in a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner 's daughter on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday , stuff.co.nz reports . a man in a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner 's daughter on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask . the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday , stuff.co.nz reports . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask . the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ` very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday , stuff.co.nz reports .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | A man in a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask robbed a Christchurch dairy . He made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on Saturday . The offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as ` very tall ' | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
A man in a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask robbed a Christchurch dairy . He made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on Saturday . The offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as ` very tall '
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ' distinctive ' cartoon mask . the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ' very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy wearing a ' distinctive ' cartoon mask . the offender , snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask , is described as being ' very tall ' . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash on saturday .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | a man in a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner 's daughter on saturday . he threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $ 1,500 . police were reportedly called to the union st dairy . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
a man in a ` distinctive ' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner 's daughter on saturday . he threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $ 1,500 . police were reportedly called to the union st dairy .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash . man in ` distinctive ' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner 's daughter . police were reportedly called to the union st dairy , in east christchurch . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
new zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a christchurch dairy . he made off with the dairy 's till and about $ 1500 in cash . man in ` distinctive ' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner 's daughter . police were reportedly called to the union st dairy , in east christchurch .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-cf4ba8f94f2dd5604eb8f8a4e655c10cf0996365 | New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online. | A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday . The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall' He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash . Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
New Zealand police are appealing to the public to help identify a man who robbed a Christchurch dairy wearing a 'distinctive' cartoon mask. The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall'. He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash on Saturday, Stuff.co.nz reports. A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday Police were reportedly called to the Union St dairy, in east Christchurch at about 12.30pm, after receiving reports of a masked man demanding cash from the dairy owner's daughter. Christina Chen told reporters her 30-year-old daughter ran out of the shop screaming 'robber!'. The masked man threw the cash register to the ground and took off with the till drawer and up to $1,500. 'Normally they just rob cigarettes and some more things, it's not a big issue,' Chen told Stuff.co.nz. 'But this time they were scary because they wore a mask, and we don't know who it is.' Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large. They are asking anyone with information that may help to identify this person to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or to message police online.
### RESPONSE
A man in a 'distinctive' cartoon mask demanded cash from owner's daughter on Saturday . The offender, snapped on security footage in a fluoro orange sweatshirt and oversized mask, is described as being 'very tall' He made off with the dairy's till and about $1500 in cash . Police say there were no signs of any weapons used but that the robber remained at large .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Legal and Court Cases |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with pupil . she had sex with an underage pupil from a texas high school . she has been accused of having sex with a 15-year-old student . she was arrested for letting another teen touch her breasts in april last year . the abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship with the 15-year-old . the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on march 24 . | 2 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with pupil . she had sex with an underage pupil from a texas high school . she has been accused of having sex with a 15-year-old student . she was arrested for letting another teen touch her breasts in april last year . the abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship with the 15-year-old . the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on march 24 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , accused of having sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . she was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , accused of having sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . she was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january . granado was arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy , also 15 , and lettin him touch her breasts . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january . granado was arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy , also 15 , and lettin him touch her breasts .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . a texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a texas high school a month . kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . a texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a texas high school a month . kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15 - year - old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15 - year - old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado, 24, is a maths teacher at macarthur high school in irving, texas . she was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old pupil, and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in january . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado, 24, is a maths teacher at macarthur high school in irving, texas . she was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old pupil, and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in january .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | Teacher Kaitlyn Granado was arrested on Monday after having sex with a 15 year old pupil from a Texas high school, and was released on bail 'We are committed to providing a safe, supportive and welcoming learning environment where all students feel comfortable and supported.' The school district said Granado was placed on administrative leave on March 26. A spokesman for the Texas Department of Public Safety said: 'The DPS takes all allegations of sexual assault seriously. | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
Teacher Kaitlyn Granado was arrested on Monday after having sex with a 15 year old pupil from a Texas high school, and was released on bail 'We are committed to providing a safe, supportive and welcoming learning environment where all students feel comfortable and supported.' The school district said Granado was placed on administrative leave on March 26. A spokesman for the Texas Department of Public Safety said: 'The DPS takes all allegations of sexual assault seriously.
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado, 24, is a maths teacher at macarthur high school in irving . she was first arrested on march 19 for having inappropriate relationship . in police interview she admitted kissing 15-year-old and letting him touch breasts . she was suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school . on monday she was arrested again for having sex with another pupil . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado, 24, is a maths teacher at macarthur high school in irving . she was first arrested on march 19 for having inappropriate relationship . in police interview she admitted kissing 15-year-old and letting him touch breasts . she was suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school . on monday she was arrested again for having sex with another pupil .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . a texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts . kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . | 4.333333 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . a texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts . kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | Kaitlyn Granado , 24 , was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in January . She was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . Now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused Granado of having sex with him . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
Kaitlyn Granado , 24 , was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in January . She was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . Now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also aged 15 , also accused Granado of having sex with him .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on january 18 and 19 across the road from another school in dallas . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on january 18 and 19 across the road from another school in dallas . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , texas , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on january 18 and 19 . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado , 24 , a teacher at macarthur high school in irving , texas , was first arrested on march 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student , and was released on bail . now she has been arrested again after another pupil , also accused granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in january this year . the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on january 18 and 19 .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | kaitlyn granado was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . she also accused granado of having sex with him on two nights . kaitlyn granado , 24 , was first arrested on march 19 for having inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student . she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts . the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on january 18 and 19 across the road from another school in dallas . | 4 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
kaitlyn granado was arrested on monday amid claims she had sex with pupil , 15 , in her car on consecutive nights in january . she also accused granado of having sex with him on two nights . kaitlyn granado , 24 , was first arrested on march 19 for having inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student . she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts . the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on january 18 and 19 across the road from another school in dallas .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-8e6c8aec6808f66ed0342e128a4e146f3ecd627d | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.' | Kaitlyn Granado, 24, arrested on March 19 for having sex with 15-year-old . Teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas, released on $50,000 bail . On Monday she was arrested again amid claims she had sex with pupil . Affidavit says relationship took place in her car on two nights in January . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, was arrested on Monday amid claims she had sex with pupil, 15, in her car on consecutive nights in January A Texas math teacher has been accused of having sex with an underage pupil from a Texas high school a month after she was arrested for letting another teenage touch her breasts. Kaitlyn Granado, 24, a teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, was first arrested on March 19 for having an inappropriate relationship with a 15-year-old student, and was released on bail. Now she has been arrested again after another pupil, also aged 15, also accused Granado of having sex with him on two consecutive nights in January this year. According to the affidavit, seen by the Star-Telegram, the teen claims the sexual relationship took place in her car late at night on January 18 and 19 across the road from another school in Dallas. The abuse came to light after a school police officer learned of a possible relationship between Granado and one of the boys last month. She was arrested on March 19, and in a police interview she admitted kissing the pupil and allowing him to touch her breasts in April the previous year, according to the Dallas Morning News. She was subsequently suspended from teaching and put on administrative leave by school officials. At the time, detectives said they didn't think she had been in a relationship with any other pupils, but just days later, on March 24, officers quizzed a second boy about a possible relationship with her. A spokesman for the police department said: 'There was some discussion, some rumoring, there may have been a second person involved. 'That information came from within the school, and it turned out to be true.' Granado, who is a maths teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas (pictured), was also arrested last month when she admitted kissing another boy, also 15, and lettin him touch her breasts Granado was booked into Irving County Jail for the second time on Monday, and released after posting a $50,000 bail. It is not known how Granado intends to plead to the second set of charges against her. A spokesman for Irving school district said: 'While privacy laws prevent us from sharing specific details, we can reassure our families that we took immediate and appropriate action. 'Being on administrative leave prevents her from working with students and being present on any Irving ISD property.'
### RESPONSE
Kaitlyn Granado, 24, arrested on March 19 for having sex with 15-year-old . Teacher at MacArthur High School in Irving, Texas, released on $50,000 bail . On Monday she was arrested again amid claims she had sex with pupil . Affidavit says relationship took place in her car on two nights in January .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5925c1a02fa9a8f6b1d5ad764c19a732deac0df | A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now' | new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife . a black dog wearing a red collar in new zealander 's mouth . the clip shows a large animal of a crocodile swimming through a public marina . the the animal was taken by the owner of puerto vallarta in mexico . the dog was the attack happened and described how the animal kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' . | 1.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'
### RESPONSE
new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife . a black dog wearing a red collar in new zealander 's mouth . the clip shows a large animal of a crocodile swimming through a public marina . the the animal was taken by the owner of puerto vallarta in mexico . the dog was the attack happened and described how the animal kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5925c1a02fa9a8f6b1d5ad764c19a732deac0df | A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now' | tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when attack happened . new zealander tim weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws . one woman called the video ` horrible ' and another said ' i hate crocodiles now ' . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'
### RESPONSE
tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when attack happened . new zealander tim weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws . one woman called the video ` horrible ' and another said ' i hate crocodiles now ' .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5925c1a02fa9a8f6b1d5ad764c19a732deac0df | A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now' | new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how ` the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' . the clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of puerto vallarta , in mexico , with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth . a video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner 's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times . | 4.666667 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'
### RESPONSE
new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how ` the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' . the clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of puerto vallarta , in mexico , with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth . a video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner 's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5925c1a02fa9a8f6b1d5ad764c19a732deac0df | A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now' | new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how ` the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' he told daily mail australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop 's owner . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring that the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing any false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'
### RESPONSE
new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how ` the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' he told daily mail australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop 's owner .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misalignments with the original article, often introducing false information.
2: The summary has several factual inaccuracies and misalignments, with some instances of false information introduced.
3: The summary is mostly aligned with the original article but contains minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. There may be minor instances of false information.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns well with the original article, with only a few minor factual inaccuracies or misalignments. No false information is introduced.
5: The summary is completely accurate and aligns perfectly with the original article, with no factual inaccuracies or introduced false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5925c1a02fa9a8f6b1d5ad764c19a732deac0df | A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now' | the clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of puerto vallarta , in mexico . new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened . mr weston told daily mail australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop 's owner . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'
### RESPONSE
the clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of puerto vallarta , in mexico . new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened . mr weston told daily mail australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop 's owner .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5925c1a02fa9a8f6b1d5ad764c19a732deac0df | A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now' | clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of puerto vallarta , in mexico , with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth . new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how ` the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article, ensuring the summary accurately represents all facts without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'
### RESPONSE
clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of puerto vallarta , in mexico , with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth . new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how ` the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all '
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains significant inaccuracies or fabrications, failing to represent the facts from the original article.
2: The summary includes some facts from the original article but also introduces notable inaccuracies or false information.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the key facts from the original article, with some minor inaccuracies or omissions.
4: The summary is largely accurate and aligns with the original article, including nearly all factual elements with only minor discrepancies.
5: The summary is completely accurate, thoroughly representing all facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
dm-test-b5925c1a02fa9a8f6b1d5ad764c19a732deac0df | A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now' | a video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online . the clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of puerto vallarta , in mexico , with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth . new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how ' the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' . mr weston told daily mail australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop 's owner . | 5 | Evaluate the response based on the given task, input, response, and evaluation rubric.
Provide a fair and detailed assessment following the rubric.
### TASK
Evaluate whether the facts in the summary align with those in the original article. This rubric assesses the accuracy and completeness of the summary in representing the original content without introducing false information. Rate the summary on a scale of 1 to 5.
### INPUT
A video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online. The clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of Puerto Vallarta, in Mexico, with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how 'the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages, not moving at all'. Mr Weston told Daily Mail Australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop's owner. Scroll down for video The large croc proudly held on to its catch for hours as it lurked around the Puerto Vallarta marina, in Mexico 'There's a sanctuary for these crocodiles up the river (200m away) which runs out to the sea and the marina,' Mr Weston explained. 'The dog went to the water's edge to see the crocodile (being curious I guess) but things didn't go according to plan obviously. 'It was certainly a shock to the system. Guess that's nature though,' he said. In the video the beast glides through the water, with rocks on one side and a footpath on the other, as crowds gasp in amazement. New Zealander Tim Weston was on holiday in Puerto Vallarta with his wife when he saw the alarming sight Tourist Tim Weston took a photo of the crocodile with the dog between its jaws A video of the crocodile swimming through the marina with the bike shop owner's dog has been viewed more than 500,000 times Mr Weston said: 'A couple of hours later we walked back past and there was still a crowd... But we didn't want to look at it again as we had just eaten. Yesterday morning there was no sign of either.' Social media users have reacted in horror to the video that was posted on the Bogged Facebook page. One woman called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'. But crocodiles are a common site in Puerto Vallarta as the Mexican beach resort is built amongst the mangroves that the creatures have called home for centuries. As well as living in the nearby sanctuary, crocs are regularly spotted on the resort's golf course. In Mexico the 'American Crocodiles' can reach lengths of 6 meters and as a result of urbanisation are living closer to humans than ever before. One social media user called the video 'horrible' and another said 'I hate crocodiles now'
### RESPONSE
a video of a menacing crocodile swimming through a public marina with a dead pet dog locked in between its jaws has been viewed more than half a million times online . the clip shows a large croc calmly moving through the marina in the tourist hotspot of puerto vallarta , in mexico , with a black dog wearing a red collar lifeless in its mouth . new zealander tim weston was on holiday in puerto vallarta with his wife when the attack happened and described how ' the crocodile kept the dog in its mouth for ages , not moving at all ' . mr weston told daily mail australia the dog belonged to the local bike shop 's owner .
### EVALUATION RUBRIC
1: The summary contains numerous factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations of the original article. Key facts are missing, and the summary may introduce false information.
2: The summary captures some facts from the original article but includes several inaccuracies or misrepresentations. Some key facts are missing or incorrectly represented.
3: The summary is mostly accurate, capturing the majority of key facts from the original article. However, there are minor inaccuracies or omissions in representing the facts.
4: The summary is largely accurate and comprehensive, correctly representing nearly all key facts from the original article with only a few minor inaccuracies or omissions.
5: The summary is completely accurate and comprehensive, accurately representing all key facts from the original article without introducing any false information.
### OUTPUT FORMAT
Return a JSON response in the following format:
{
"explanation": "Explanation of why the response received a particular score",
"score": "Score assigned to the response based on the rubric between 1 to 5"
}
### EVALUATION | Sports News |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.